a game of who said what, when, and where
e h t s
h
d
a s
o
p
w
h
y e
r
e
110
f e ar
h
o t
e at v ri
p
m
a
r
t
k
e
t
178 136
lies and the
sound of flutes and horns MIT
Department
of
Architecture
102
20
The narrative of failed romance cannot rely on specious evidence alone. at
an
h o u r
illici t
f o r
a c ti v i ty a n d
bound
12
a
b y
b o r e
work we e k
the highest price ever paid Media
n o t
t h e
“M
178
o f
t h o s e
on
for
and
110
w a no s th t e o e n as pi ly si the gn t ed
st
ro
si
ty
�
from relative obscurity to monumental status
Historiography
120
2
12
46
m a y display s o m e c o r porate unease Faith
and
56
Why would I want that to be a Jewish space,
or a Catholic space, or a
34
Muslim space?
Religion
“
i
m
a
a
82
g
e
n
p
r
o
d p
s
T h i s i s t h i s t o d a y, and it will be something else
34
t o m o r r o w.
200
Speculations,
s
Activism
�
For although you reek, I enjoy listening to you.
Possible
They
figured it would be
impossible to fight
city hall.
and
90
102
76 Futures
128
a f part of a t o r a p world ld ry r o i m a gw i n a r iyn a g a im
Speculations, and Possible
Activism Futures
Thresholds 43 Scandalous Edited by Nathan Friedman and Ann Lui
Editorial Policy Thresholds, the journal of the MIT Department of Architecture, is an annual peer-reviewed publication produced by student editors at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Opinions in Thresholds are those of the contributors and do not necessarily reflect those of the editors, the Department of Architecture, or MIT. Correspondence Thresholds — MIT Architecture 77 Massachusetts Ave, Room 7– 337 Cambridge, MA 02139 thresholds@mit.edu http://thresholdsjournal.com Publisher SA+P Press MIT School of Architecture + Planning 77 Massachusetts Ave, Room 9 –224 Cambridge, MA 02139 Copyright Copyright © 2015 Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Individual contributions are copyright their respective authors. Figures and images are copyright their respective creators, as individually noted. Every effort has been made to identify owners and gain permission for images. Errors or omissions will be corrected in subsequent editions. ISBN 978 – 0 – 9961166 – 0 – 2
a search for , 3 4 e u s is n o While working e MIT Institute th to s u t h g u bro local scandal gue Against a e L s n e iz it C “ e Archives and th Contained in nineteen m.” ers were the the Sonic Boo ld fo 7 8 5 e m o and s records boxes ism movement v ti c a p to k s e d hremnants of a lopment of hig ve e d l ia rc e m m against the co 967 by W. 1 in d e d n u o F l. speed air trave rise of supere th h it w ll a s d .E mShurcliff and J aggressively ca e u g a e L e th t, sonic shocksonic fligh ” g n ri e tt a h s “ st the f transport. o paigned again rm fo w e n e d by th s waves produce New York Time e th in t n e m e A June advertis s time a single te u in m ve fi t u o warned, “In ab ng Island— o L n o e n o ry ve me , all schools, SST could boo ls a im n a ll a , le peop s all 5,0 0 0,0 0 0 affected region e -b o -t n o o S .” aps—one for m all hospitals d n a s m ra g in dia were visualized —depicting the s te ta S d e it n U y ight each of the fift ing moiré of fl s s ro c s s ri c a “boom zone” in d over the nation. pose ic paths superim gainst the Son A e u g a e L s n e Citiz licy through o p c li b u p e g n “ ch a Boom sought to he archive’s collection of .” T ct public outrage graphs, and fa to o h p , s g in p p li letters, news c om which the fr l a n e rs a e th e t sheets compris tical tactic. Ye li o p s a l a d n a d sc group deploye adlines, the e h in e ik p s l pora ibeyond the tem f murmurs: ind o y c a g le a to ign archive spoke eague’s campa L e th to s e s n viduals’ respo of the cultural ry to is h r e d a attest to the bro al correspondences paint a on movement. Pers rly seventies: the role of e ea ing power of backdrop of th w ro g e th , ts is lobby hagencies and nce to new tec ta is s re , e c n ie civic disobed
iii
aw a collective s e w rs e p a p e g, nology. In thes just as revealin s a w t a th l a d n a response to sc sue at stake. is l a tr n e c e th as if not more so, content for this d te c le e s e th You’ll find ly and comp to d e d n te in olds is than approissue of Thresh r e th ra t n ve e ptive plicate the disru ntributors sort o c r u O . e lu va k nd priate its shoc itecture, art, a h rc a f o th a rm e through the aft onsideration c g in k vo ro p , als cultural scand utrageous one o — s e n li d a e h s hy ut also our b not just of spla — xt e n e th e n en go moment and th s and their implications. tion ove collective reac ewspaper, “ab n t n ri p e n o g y In the b be seen on ld u o c t a h w to ed the fold” referr adlines, catchy e h t: e e h s d a ro ab ed the top half of We’ve introduc . s e g a im y e k ation: texts iz hooks, and n a rg o s l’ a rn ur jou rst half and fi this model in o e th in d e w re previe e and projects a d half. We hop n o c e s e th in en then conclude cencies betwe ja d a d te c e xp e n to this provokes u paying tribute o ls a e il h w s n In addition to contributio . id lo b ta s u lo anda the the original sc nts located in te n o c f o le b ta the journal p a traditional ra w s e g a p n stinatio front matter, de of navigation s n a e m te a rn e lt d and offer an a ages group an p n o ti a n ti s e D e. based on them n d H is to ri o g a ia d e M “ : to n t in p e c u la ti o n s , re gro u p c o n te S “ ,” n io g li e R and ra p hy,” “ Fa ith re s ,” “ Id e n ti ty tu u F le ib s s o P nd A c ti v is m a n d G ove rn m e n t a r, e w o P “ d n a a n d th e C it y,” e Surveillance.” Citizens Leagu e th to r e tt le In a 1967 ean Martinon, J , m o o b ic n o of s phony Orcheson the effects m y S o g a ic h C f the st to then director o nkind find a re a m l il w re e h tra, asked: “W
iv
agitation?” g in v o m r te s d ever fa s its constant an in other nation rs e e p s it d n a e u le in While the Leag sful, responsib s e c c u s ly te a mercial superwere ultim m o c t s in a g a d asse stern Europe, part for bans p e W d n a S U e l in th sonic air trave to speak also to s m e e s n o ti s e the literal to g Martinon’s qu in rr fe re e h rn. Was a larger conce for ever-faster e ir s e d e th — n o ti cact of accelera gue’s use of ta a e L e th to d a ste l transport? Or in raging of socia ve le e th : ” n o ti tical “agita tion in the age p ru is d ve ti a rform friction and pe e issue of sonic th s p a rh e P ? ts of civic protes s c in a ti o n o f fa e th d te n e s icp o ll u ti o n re p re ewness, and fr n l, a d n a c s h it w av e humanity itself g u e ’s ta c ti c s h a e L e th s a y, ing headlines k ti o n . To d a c o h s d n a e c onpla n become comm on’s persuasio in rt a M f o e s o e proliferate, th tion against th a z ti e th s e a n -a tive wonder: is self on? If a collec ti lu o s ly n o e th outside world d reflects the n a s e p a h s l a d an sue 43 also response to sc is s ld o h s re h T ent, -sensitization e historical mom d g in w ro g r u hat o . hopes to ask w rrent condition u c r u o t u o b a s ay s Ann — Nathan and
v
Contents Introduction iii — v Sebastiano Fabbrini Scanda(Loos): Theatrics and Print Media in the Controversy of the Michaelerplatz Building 2 — 11 372 — 379 AnnMarie Perl Succès de “scandale” and Biblical scandal: Yves Klein’s debut performance of the Anthropometries in 1960 12 — 19 362 — 371 No ra We n d l Uncompromising Reasons for Going West: A Story of Sex and Real Estate, Reconsidered 20 — 33 346 — 361 Austin+Mergold Of the Sacred & the Divine: Subway Sukkah 34 — 45
vi
Kristen Gaylord The controversy of Peace on Earth : Immaculate Heart College and IBM in 1965 46 — 55 336 — 345 Beatriz Colomina A Slight Nausea: Carlo Mollino 56 — 65 326 — 335 Jackson Davidow Reading The Bostonians in Boston 66 — 75 316 — 325 Doris Sommer Press Here: Cultural Acupuncture and Civic Stimulation 76 — 81 310 — 315 Urbonas Studio Lietuva Cinema I: Pro-Test Lab 82 — 89 NADA A A with Cristina Parreño Architecture and Urbonas Studio Lietuva Cinema II: Modernaus Meno Centras 90 — 101
Mark Jarzombek Leon Battista Alberti and His Somniatic Troubles 102 — 109 300 — 309 Ang Li Raised by Association: Robin Hood Gardens and Its Interpretations 110 — 119 292 — 299 Andrés Jaque Mies in the Basement: The Ordinary Confronts the Exceptional in the Barcelona Pavilions 120 — 127 276 — 278 Didier Faustino Love Songs for Riots 128 — 135 268 — 275 Peter Galison & John May The Revelation of Secrets: Peter Galison and John May on Artifacts of Surveillance, Part I and II 136 — 159 254 — 267 Ruvimbo Moyo Nkandlagate: Only Partial Evidence of Urban African Inequality 160 — 171 244 — 253
Hans van Houwelingen Monument in Commemoration of Prof. Dr. A. de Froe, 1907–1992 172 — 177 236 — 243 Nisa Ari The Purchase on Modernity: The Turkish National Narrative and Osman Hamdi Bey’s The Tortoise Trainer 178 — 187 226 — 235 Jordan Carver On Art Storage and Tax Evasion 188 — 199 210 — 225 fala atelier Revised Pantheon 200 — 209 Andrés Jaque / Of fice for Political Innovation PHANTOM: Mies as Rendered Society 279 — 291 Contributors 381 — 384 Image Credits 385 — 387
vii