The Print Volume 3, Issue 11

Page 1

THE

PRINT

The official publication of Maynooth Students’ Union

Tuesday 3rd April 2012 - Volume 3, Issue 11

Editor@ThePrint.ie

USI Debate Funding Preferendum, Croke Park Agreement Renegociation SHANE McNALLY @thobiasinkblot

USI Congress this year has seen some very interesting turns of events, from a defeat of the proposed preferendum on fees to USI deciding to scrap the Croke Park Agreement. In a sense it has been division that has been the common denominator of the entire congress with some progressive motions being passed that were at the very least a reflection of how far Ireland has progressed as a society. First off were policies in which there were no major issues. The conference then moved onto the preferendum. Each of the options were to be debated then voted on were proposed and debated by various delegates. The most interesting events being the passionate and well crafted speeches for and against the ‘exchequer funded’ option, the student loan and the graduate tax. Gary Redmond, current USI president spoke on behalf of a graduate tax as something he ‘believes in’. Needless to say this caused a bit of a stir. Many also spoke in favour of voting for ‘none of the above’ in protest over the manner in which the preferendum was carried out. A 9D was then proposed from the floor (9D: sending it back to special congress to be reshaped into something that may be in fact viable)in an effort to delay the motion on the preferedum due to a number of objections that delegates had. This motion came about as a result of a closed meeting of presidents earlier this year. At this meeting the preferendum was proposed and then rolled out with little or no consultation to other sabbatical officers. What resulted then was rushed preferendums in various colleges. Trinity, a college of over 17,000 students got a turnout of 442 students in favour of a student loan scheme. The college then deemed the vote to be a mandate: a vote of under three percent. Maynooth Student Union ran one during Sabbat

elections, but decided that there had not been enough consultation with students on the options that they were voting on so deemed the ballot null and void. Maynooth Students’ Union was the major proponent of the 9D along with GMIT and various other colleges. After much debate the 9D was just about carried with an almost evenly split room, of 92 votes to 84 to an uproarious response from those opposing the motion. Day two was also full of major debate with several significant motions being passed. The first such motion was the decision of USI to reaffirm its stance on equal rights for all, specifically for marriage and adoption. This debate saw some of the best speeches of the day in favour of LGBT rights with Maynooth’s Keith Broni being very impressive in his maiden speech. The motion was passed unanimously, a clear indication of a progressive Union. The cohesion that characterised the former debate was not present in a later debate on the Croke Park agreement, that turned out to be a left right divide, the former arguing against a renegotiation. Maynooth again had some very impressive speakers in Séamus Reynolds and Ruaidhrí Boland. Aengus Ó Maoláin former president of Maynooth and now education officer of USI also spoke against the motion of a renegotiation of the Agreement. Speakers for the motion included the current president of UCD Pat de Brun. The motion then went to the floor and was carried meaning USI will now lobby for a renegotiation of the deal as it believes that it is affecting the student body negatively. A clear theme of the day was division, but this was characterised by a very well informed and excellent standard of debate on some of the most major issues currently affecting Ireland. There is certainly much more to come from this conference.

Irish Colleges Fall In Times University Ranks CONOR O’BRIEN News Co-Editor @ConorWOBrien

Ireland’s higher education system took another body blow to its international reputation last month with the publication of the latest Times University Rankings, with none of the country’s eight universities managing to make the prestigious Top 100. This completes a drastic decline in the standards of Irish university education in recent years, with both TCD and UCD, regular features in the Top 100 until this point, absent from the elite list all together. Instead, universities from Asia (China in particular) appear to be on the rise, rubbing shoulders with familiar giants such as Harvard (top of the pile), Cambridge (3rd) and Stanford (4th). In total, 19 countries were represented in the Top 100, but worryingly for a certain Ruairi Quinn, Ireland was not among them.

Facebook.com/ThePrintMSU

The alarming decline in standards is directly linked to the funding shortage afflicting Irish universities at the present time, availing of only a fraction of the budget enjoyed by their counterparts in the UK. This is likely to bring the contentious issue of college fees to the fore once more, with speculation abound within the higher education sector that registration charges could rise to €3,000 over the coming years. However, even this sharp rise (an increase of over €1,000 in less than a decade) may not be enough to finance the already overstretched sector, with numbers expected to rise substantially over the coming decades. Despite this bleak outlook, the Department of Education remains convinced of the continued standard of Irish universities. When contacted by the Print, a department spokesperson claimed that the overall performance of the underfunded Irish system was highly ranked; 17th overall and 6th relative to our GDP. The department also warned that rankings such

as these – being subjective – need to be interpreted with caution, noting how Cambridge came 3rd on the Times table and 1st on the QS list. “Notwithstanding these reservations, it is recognised that league tables are referenced by international investors, employers and students as a marker of quality across systems and as such they cannot be ignored” said the spokesperson. “Delivering high quality higher education for a growing proportion of our population will mean that we need to maintain a clear focus on system performance overall rather than a narrower focus on individual institutional performance. In this regard, the National Strategy for Higher Education and recent proposals issued by the Higher Education Authority make a range of recommendations, currently being implemented, which seek to enhance the quality and efficiency of the Irish system.”

Twitter.com/ThePrintMSU

Printed in Enniscorthy, Co. Wexford via Datascope and Impression LTD.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.