R E POR T
The
Challenge
Current and future CEOs voice optimism despite underlying concerns.
B
usinesses are growing. So say hundreds of CEOs from our community of leaders who participated in our seventh annual NYSE Euronext CEO Report. In addition to CEOs of NYSE Euronext companies, this year’s survey for the first time polls more than 100 CEOs from “emerging companies” (up-and-coming firms, most backed by private equity or venture capital) who are stimulating change in business and society. We also surveyed aspiring corporate leaders — some 200 MBA students and recent MBA grads. Together, they comment on the pressing topics of the economy and growth, the
workforce and job creation, innovation, social media, and brand and reputation management. The groups agree on their concerns regarding protectionism and trade issues, as well as financial and political stability. Regulation and taxes draw their fire, and many worry about our global education systems. Yet their perspectives diverge when it comes to doing business in the future, particularly on the topics of social media and innovation. The bottom-line finding is this: Our three generations of leaders and aspiring leaders are getting to growth and overcoming economic setbacks while maneuvering around the global political and regulatory obstacles.
Charts by Tommy McCall s u r v e y c o n d u c t e d b y o r c i n t e r n a t i o n a l o n b e h a l f o f NYSE EURONE X T
N YS
CEO
M AG A
on
iPad
NE
NYSE EURONEXT
E
ZI
Find more results from the 2011 survey on the NYSE magazine app.
Financial & political
instability
Crowdsourcing sparks
keep US up at night
innovation
The U.S. must get a handle on
taxes
We want better ROI from our
Brands
Regulation is a major concern
Social Media will rule
Vision
IS The No. 1 quality a CEO needs
Growth PROJECtions
we are
hiring!
(though The economy is still hurting)
Education needs improvement
Reputation is everything
T H E E C O N O M Y & G R O W T H 1 8 | W O R K F O R C E & J O B C R E AT I O N 2 0 | I N N O VAT I O N 2 2 S ocia l me d ia & d igita l strategy 2 4 | R E P U TAT I O N & B R A N D M A N A G E M E N T 2 6
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
PERCENTage WHO THINK THE FOLLOWING COULD IMPACT GROWTH
GROWTH INHIBITORS
Beyond the economy
CEOs worry that regulation, inflation and rising costs are among conditions that could hinder growth. Strong Some impact impact Listed-company CEOs Emerging-company CEOs
GROWTH TRAPS
U.S. eco nom y
CEOs and future leaders diverge on many issues yet share these mutual concerns. David Johnson, CEO of seven-year-old Achates Power Inc., expects that a world looking to conserve energy will embrace his San Diego-based company’s efficient engine design. But he admits that “economic uncertainty may cause our customers and prospects to be more cautious, to preserve their capital and to move slower. This, in turn, would make it more difficult for us to secure new business and cause us to adjust our growth plans.” Johnson is hardly alone in his concern about the future. Even as most companies prepare for growth, CEOs express worry over not just the economy but also protectionism and trade restrictions, financial and political instability, regulation and taxes. In fact, six out of 10 listed-company CEOs who participated in the 2011 NYSE Euronext CEO Report expect the U.S. to have an unfavorable corporate tax environment during the next three years. Current and future business leaders also fret about how well educational systems are preparing the next generation of workers, especially in the U.S.: Nearly twice as many CEOs based in the U.S. as those headquartered elsewhere view their country’s education system as fair or poor. MBA students offer solutions. “The global landscape has changed quickly, yet schools still focus on standardized testing and a curriculum that does not keep up with the times,” says Sean Donnelly, a Fordham University MBA student with a concentration in international finance. Vlad Karas, who is studying innovation and technology management at the Polytechnic Institute of New York University, hopes schools will do more to stimulate creativity: “Kids should not be afraid to take chances and play with new ideas, new concepts and creative thinking — this is what will drive innovation for the next generation.”
� For more thoughts from emerging leaders, and to see how your opinions stack up against our respondents’, get the Q4 issue on iPad. To see how our research was conducted, visit nysemagazine.com/methodology.
*Some items may not add up due to rounding
PERCENTAGE OF CEOs WHO have concerns regarding THE FOLLOWING COUNTRIES
34/33 30/28
80/73
19 /16 43/34
Canada
65/65
REGIONAL CONCERNS
Protectionism, political stability and financial stability
44/49
give respondents concern regarding specific regions — particularly in the U.S. and in Europe.
74/65
33/47
United States
48/62
45/47 27/41
Mexico
58/65 40/62
61/54 Brazil
South America (except Brazil) Source: ORC International for NYSE Euronext
16
n y s e m ag a z i ne.com
sur vey S IN
46/48
Western Europe
TAX ENVIRONMENT
U.S. corporations face an unfavorable tax outlook
during the next three years, according to 60% of listed-company CEOs and 59% of emerging-company CEOs. The nearest rival? Western Europe, cited by 46% and 48%, respectively.
Japan
34 / 15
South America
32/35
(except Brazil)
26/21
Brazil
21/41
Mexico
21/26
India
20/22
China
19/16
Canada
18/22
Eastern Europe
17/5
Australia & New Zealand
9/18
Southeast Asia
6/21
Middle East
77/68
EDUCATION SYSTEMs
About half of all respondents
82/74
48/40
42/60
28/32 42/35 29/30
54/50 81/82
25/64
49
32/45
34/27
Eastern Europe
52/46
PERCENTage WHO SAY their country’s EDUCATION SYSTEM IS FAIR or POOR %
63/52
33/51
34/39
Western Europe
indicate that their country’s education system does only a fair or poor job of providing students with the skills to succeed in the workforce.
66/79
39/57
China
10
Poor LISTED CEOs
Japan
42/47 34/35
55%
36/41
43
Middle East KEY Listed-company CEOs Emerging-company CEOs Protectionism or trade restrictions Financial stability Political stability
39
Fair
Fair
India
Southeast Asia
37/23 23/19
16/10
Australia and New Zealand
12
Poor EMERGING CEOs
46% 35
Fair
11
Poor MBAs nyse m ag a z i n e .c oM
17
S
60/59
United States
HT IG
PERCENTAGE OF CEOs who have concerns about the tax environment in the following countries
with
peter voser
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
SHE L L
Royal Dutch Shell’s CEO hopes to lead in an industry that is undergoing seismic change.
W
JUST THE FACTS Headquarters The Hague, the Netherlands
Revenue
$368.1 billion (fiscal 2010)
Market cap* $228 billion
Employees 93,000
Listed since July 20, 2005
*As of 10/17/2011
18
hen Peter Voser, 53, took over from the retiring CEO of Royal Dutch Shell PLC (NYSE: RDS.A, RDS.B; NYSE Euronext: RDSA, RDSB) in 2009, he set a goal to make Shell “the most competitive and innovative energy company in the world.” But before the former CFO could turn his full attention to reshaping the company for a world where energy demand would inevitably increase, supply would shrink and tighter environmental regulations would come into play, he had to scale a stone wall. “Shell and its competitors faced the unprecedented challenge of building a more sustainable energy system while responding to the worst economic downturn since the 1930s,” observes Voser. Even as he made bold bets on the future, Voser began reducing expenses through a combination of flatter structures in Shell’s senior management team, faster decision-making and simpler ways of working. The company also sold noncore assets, including some European and African downstream operations, using much of the proceeds to shore up higher-margin businesses and maintain R&D levels through the worst of the downturn. “Current economic challenges aside, energy remains a long-term business,” says the CEO, who points to estimates that fuel needs are poised to soar. The International Energy Agency expects China, India and Brazil to
n y s e m ag a z i ne.com
double their energy consumption during the next 40 years, meaning that these three economies alone could account for a third of global energy consumption — on top of continued existing demand. Voser estimates that Shell will invest more than $100 billion globally between 2011 and 2014, with a target of raising its production by 12 percent from 2010 levels to 3.7 million barrels of oil equivalent a day, one of the fastest growth rates in the industry. “Whereas much of the world is still drawing up plans, we are doing what we can today to make a difference,” says Voser. “That means producing more natural gas, focusing on biofuels, helping to develop carbon capture and storage technology, and trying to improve energy efficiency in our operations.” When it comes to renewables, Shell has shifted most of its attention to biofuels, especially through Raizen, a joint venture with Cosan Ltd. (NYSE: CZZ), a processor of Brazilian sugarcane. The venture is developing what Voser says is the lowestcarbon biofuel commercially available: ethanol that can reduce CO2 emissions by around 70 percent compared with standard petroleum. Raizen’s blueprint calls for more than doubling annual production to 5 billion liters of sugarcane ethanol in the next five years from about 2.2 billion liters in 2010.
The End of an Era But Shell isn’t putting aside its focus on its traditional hydrocarbon products, although Voser warns that “the era of so-called easy and cheap oil and gas is over.” With that in mind, Shell expects to increasingly explore challenging environments, such as the Arctic. Nearly 200 miles off the coast of Brazil, the company is drilling in pre-salt areas — so named because the reserves are trapped beneath a geological cap of impermeable salt that restricts the oil from pushing up.
COURTESY ROYAL DUTCH SHELL
A New Energy Blueprint
S IG HT IN S vey sur
Whereas much of the world is still drawing up plans, we are doing what we can today to make a difference.” Peter Voser CEO, Shell
Part of Shell’s R&D budget is used to develop sophisticated computer systems that help geologists identify hidden reservoirs more accurately and thus place drilling rigs more precisely. Technology also has enabled Shell’s shift from oil to natural gas, which by next year will represent more than half of its production, says the company. Noting that natural gas plants emit up to 70 percent less CO2 than old coal-fired plants, Voser says: “North America now has enough gas reserves to last for the next 100 years, thanks to discoveries of gas trapped in dense rock — tight gas — and new production techniques.” With tight gas and shale gas potential elsewhere, he cites the International Energy Agency in noting that “the world has enough gas for 250 years at the current level of production.” Shell is also developing procedures aimed at cleaner energy. For example, the company has filed more than 3,500 patents that apply to the Pearl Gasto-Liquids (GTL) project, which opened in June in Qatar. This plant, explains Voser, refines natural gas, turning it into diesel fuel for vehicles, kerosene for aircraft and other products for the chemical sector. Pearl GTL’s water processing plant, the company claims, recovers, treats and reuses every drop of the industrial process’s water. With a capacity to treat 280,000 barrels of water a day, Pearl GTL’s water treatment plant is the world’s largest, comparable to that for a city of 140,000, according to the company. While mapping out a new energy blueprint for Shell, Voser is counting on something that might be the biggest challenge of all: collaboration. To meet growing energy needs, “we need to bring together scientists, urban planners, businesses, governments and society to develop policies and solutions,” he says. Voser is optimistic. “The human race has faced many challenges in the past and surmounted them with ingenuity and creativity.” — Susan Caminiti
GREAT EXPECTATIONS Compared with last year, we’ve made progress: Fewer listed-company CEOs (85 percent) rate the global economy as fair or poor, compared with 96 percent in 2010 and 99 percent in 2009. And more are planning for growth, despite significant concerns about protectionism (particularly in China) and financial and political stability in many regions — including the U.S. and Europe. CEOs of listed companies are budgeting larger increases for capital expenditures, energy and regulatory compliance, while emerging-company CEOs — those who head businesses backed by venture capital or private equity — are spending more for R&D, technology, marketing and PR.
Although they still consider the global economy fair at best… Percentage who think the economy is fair or poor
85%
96% 4% Good
15% Good 61% Fair
75% Excellent
19%
6% 24%
56%
Poor
Fair
LISTED CEOs
40%
Good
48%
Poor
27%
Fair
EMERGING CEOs
Poor
MBAs
…most CEOs are planning for growth. Two-thirds of listed-company CEOs and more than four in five emergingcompany CEOs expect growth in their own companies. Percentage OF CEOs who expect growth
76% 18% No change
30%
Significant growth
84% 6%
Decline
46%
Modest growth
LISTED CEOs
12% No change 45%
Significant growth
5%
Decline
39%
Modest growth
EMERGING CEOs
� To see where executives are allocating the largest budget increases, check out nysemagazine.com/chartindex or visit the NYSE magazine app.
nyse m ag a z i n e .c oM
19
with
PETER LÖSCHER
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
SIE M ENS
Staffing Up Siemens identifies two growth drivers: globalization and demand for modern solutions to infrastructure, health care and energy needs.
20
n y s e m ag a z i ne.com
JUST THE FACTS Headquarters Munich, Germany
Revenue
$103.4 billion (fiscal 2010)
Market cap* $87.9 billion
Employees 421,000
Listed since March 12, 2001
*As of 10/17/2011
Löscher believes that adding diversity to Siemens’ workforce is crucial to its ability to grow in new geographic and sector markets. “We need to create great, diverse teams made up of people who believe in the company’s totality and have the right passion,” he explains. “At the end of the day, there must be chemistry.”
A U.S. Push Siemens is particularly interested in growth in the U.S., where it already employs more than 60,000 in some 100 manufacturing facilities. The company reports “significant orders,” such as a contract to supply Amtrak with 70 energy-efficient electric locomotives, which will create 250 green manufacturing jobs at three plants. Siemens also is expanding an Illinois facility that makes wind turbines and an Iowa wind blade manufacturing plant, together generating some 1,100 jobs. In explaining why Siemens is spending nearly $200 million to build a gas turbine factory in Charlotte, N.C., Löscher notes: “By manufacturing here, we get proximity to our largest market, highly skilled workers educated at some of the world’s best universities — with access to the best research facilities — and cutting-edge innovation that we can link directly to our manufacturing sites.” That plant, which expects to employ 1,000 people and spur 2,000 indirect jobs, is slated to export gas turbines to markets across the world. Siemens added around 1,000 new U.S. jobs last fiscal year, taking advantage of a small resurgence in manufacturing and tax incentives. For example, the company, which is investing $2.9 million to expand a smart-grid project in Wendell, N.C., is set
COURTESY SIEMENS
E
lectronics and engineering conglomerate Siemens AG (NYSE: SI) already has 421,000 employees in 1,640 locations around the globe. Yet with a new worldwide focus on infrastructure, health care and energy solutions such as wind power, the company is creating more jobs. President and CEO Peter Löscher says it’s a case of identifying opportunities — even in tough economic times for some of Siemens’ key markets — and directing the company’s resources accordingly. “We laid the foundation for economic growth quite a while ago by addressing the megatrends of demographic change, urbanization, climate change and globalization,” says Löscher, 54. “The current economic crisis didn’t catch us unawares. We never let up during the recession, which has helped us come out of it relatively unscathed.” As a result, Löscher says, today the company is a “pioneer in energy efficiency, industrial productivity, affordable and personalized health care, and intelligent infrastructure solutions.” Being a leader in those fields, he says, contributes to a reputation that draws a dedicated workforce from around the world. In fact, Siemens created more than 16,000 jobs worldwide in the first nine months of fiscal 2011 as Löscher pushed the company in new directions and into new markets. A native of Austria and a former pharmaceutical industry executive whom Siemens recruited in 2007 as the first outsider to head the company in its 164-year history, he has taken a far more global perspective than some of his predecessors, perhaps owing to stints in locales as diverse as Japan, Spain and the U.S. (He also studied at The Chinese University of Hong Kong.)
S IG HT IN S vey Peter Löscher CEO, SIEMENS
sur
We need to create great, diverse teams. At the end of the day, there must be chemistry.”
Employment roll CALL Despite fears of a sluggish economy, 17 percent more listed-company CEOs than last year expect to add to their payrolls — 62 percent versus 45 percent in 2010. Emerging CEOs were even more optimistic, with seven out of 10 adding jobs. Average increases are healthy: Heads of listed companies hope to boost their workforces by 18 percent and entrepreneurs may up theirs by 34 percent. Look for most jobs to be in their home countries, especially in the U.S., Europe and China.
Despite economic challenges, CEOs expect to add to their workforces through 2012… Changes CEOs Expect to make to their workforce
to receive up to $2.6 million in state tax incentives if it meets its goals of creating 139 new jobs. Yet Siemens frequently finds itself unable to hire enough qualified workers — despite U.S. unemployment rates topping 9 percent. Currently the company is looking to fill more than 12,000 positions worldwide, including more than 3,000 in the U.S. Many of these jobs are for workers that vocational schools used to train when manufacturing employed a higher percentage of the U.S. workforce. To help qualify would-be employees, Siemens launched an apprenticeship program modeled on its long-standing practice in Germany. The company pays high school seniors an hourly wage to learn a skill, then puts them through a two-year community college. When finished, they have an inside track to be hired by Siemens. Currently the company provides this training to nearly 10,000 young people in Germany, Saudi Arabia, Russia and the U.S.
Listed-company CEOs
Emerging-company CEOs
71% 62%
Adding to it
22%
Keeping it the same
28%
8%
Reducing it
3% …with many new jobs slated for sales and IT. Emerging CEOs are even more likely to add jobs in sales and marketing. 67
Percentage of CEOs WHO EXPECT TO ADD JOBS IN THE FOLLOWING CATEGORIES
Listed-company CEOs
Emerging-company CEOs 50
A Powerful Advantage Beyond the U.S., Siemens has doubled its emergingmarkets revenues since 2005, Löscher says, and continues to expand aggressively in markets such as China — although he admits that market is becoming more challenging as local engineering firms mature. “For many years, we had no serious trouble finding talent,” the CEO says, “but now we compete with Chinese companies seeking graduates as well.” Yet he says Siemens’ reputation as a global powerhouse gives it an edge when it comes to hiring. “We build the world’s biggest gas turbine, the fastest CAT scan and some of the fastest passenger trains,” remarks Löscher. “That’s how the hearts of young engineers get opened.” — Sheridan Prasso
37 33 29 26 23 13 9
Engineering HR
Marketing
Manu- Finance General facturing management
IT
Sales
� See the NYSE magazine app for a map showing new job distribution.
nyse m ag a z i n e .c oM
21
with
DAVID A. FLYNN
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
The Soul of Innovation
David A. Flynn, Fusion-io’s CEO and founder, adds new efficiency to digital memory.
ENTER WOZNIAK JUST THE FACTS Headquarters Salt Lake City
Revenue
$197.2 million (fiscal 2011)
Market cap* $2.2 billion
Employees 430
Listed since June 9, 2011
*AS OF 10/17/2011
That mindset led to a more straightforward memory design using solid-state drives, which helped the startup land $115.5 million in venture capital and prompted Apple Inc. co-founder Steve Wozniak to call Fusion-io’s approach “revolutionary.” In fact, the usually reticent Wozniak was so impressed that he agreed to become the company’s chief scientist in 2008. “The technology marketplace has not seen such capacity for innovation and radical transformation since the mainframe computer was replaced by the home computer,” Wozniak enthused when he announced that he would join the company. Previously, solid-state drives had been treated like mechanical hard drives, which failed to take advantage of the memory chips’ speed. “It was like trying to suck an elephant through a straw,” says Flynn. So rather than simply replacing hard drives with solidstate memory, Fusion-io’s design treats solid-state drives as if they were part of direct memory. The approach means eliminating bottlenecks in the servers and allowing the chips to operate at full speed. “We’re getting rid of the middleman here,” Flynn explains, boosting the performance of data centers by as much as 10 times without having to add more servers, according to Fusion-io and some independent tests.
By starting with a clean slate, we freed researchers to ignore the traditional design of computer systems and start afresh.” David A. Flynn
CEO, FUSION-IO
COURTESY FUSION-IO (2)
W
e’re moving from the information age to the media age,” states David A. Flynn, chairman, president and CEO of six-year-old Fusion-io Inc. (NYSE: FIO). He points to connected devices like smartphones and tablet computers, which have shifted the focus from building faster devices to building faster networks. “For example, consider what it takes for a program on your phone to recognize a song and tell you the title, or to do live facerecognition searches on a crowd of people in a security video over a network,” Flynn suggests.
When co-founding Fusion-io, Flynn observed that data centers delivering information to these connected devices needed to run more efficiently to meet future demand. So, armed with a BS in computer science from Brigham Young University and experience in software research and development, Flynn, 42, realized that researchers needed to rethink the basic design of current computers. “We had to eliminate complexity,” says Flynn. “By starting with a clean slate, we freed researchers to ignore the traditional design of computer systems and start afresh.”
S IG HT IN S vey sur As more people use more portable devices needing even faster access to information, demand from corporate enterprise customers is growing. “We now have over 2,000 clients,” says Flynn, “from Facebook to Wall Street.” Fusion-io reported fourth-quarter 2011 revenues of $71.7 million, up from just $10.9 million for the same period the previous year, and a net income of $5.8 million, compared with a net loss of $11.9 million in the same quarter in 2010.
Memory for All Flynn credits an important decision made early on with putting Fusion-io on the fast track: The company would work with all current systems on the market. Because it is agnostic when it comes to different operating systems, says Flynn, Fusion-io’s products have been widely adopted by hardware makers such as IBM Corp. (NYSE: IBM) and Hewlett-Packard Co. (NYSE: HPQ). “This is why we have some of the leading operating systems experts on staff,” says the CEO, explaining that the company’s 430 employees include experts in Linux, Oracle Solaris, Windows and Apple’s OS X. Flynn says two competing trends will keep Fusion-io humming. In addition to the major shift to cloud computing and the accompanying vast memory storage that requires, he explains, a number of Steve Wozniak customers are taking back their own comChief Scientist puter storage. They can do this, he says, because Fusion-io’s memory systems require fewer servers and thus less overhead. “Essentially,” he observes, “they are creating their own private clouds.” The company continues to look for ways to squeeze even more performance out of its technology, partly through acquisitions. Using part of the $222.7 million it raised through its June IPO, Fusion-io recently purchased IO Turbine Inc., a software company specializing in using flash memory in virtual memory designs. Flynn expects Fusion-io’s breakthrough to catalyze innovation as improved data-center performance allows customers to create new services. And he expresses no doubt that other aspects of existing networks need improvement. “Now,” says Flynn, “with processors running at full speed without the memory drag, the speed of Internet connections becomes a bottleneck again.” — John R. Quain
Catalysts for ideas R&D departments are busy: CEOs of listed corporations are generally satisfied with their company’s level of innovation, and emerging-company CEOs are really happy. Nearly one out of three entrepreneurs and 10 percent of listed-company CEOs plan to up their R&D budgets through 2012. Both groups feel that communicating stories of success spurs innovation, but MBAs also embrace nontraditional catalysts such as hiring a global workforce and crowdsourcing. Non-U.S. CEOs are four times as likely to credit social media as a source of ideas, while U.S. CEOs are more apt to embrace acquisitions.
Most are satisfied with their company’s level of innovation… Twice as many emerging-company CEOs are “very satisfied.”
Very satisfied
22%
Somewhat satisfied
65%
Not satisfied (NET)
44% 43%
13%
13%
LISTED CEOs
EMERGING CEOs
87
87%
%
VERY/SOMEWHAT SATISFIED (NET
…but the groups express differing views on how best to spur innovation. Listed-company CEOs Emerging-company CEOs MBA students
Most effective ways TO SPUR INNOVATION...
0%
10%
20%3 %30%
40%
50%
60%
Communicating stories of innovation success within the organization New employees Acquisitions Employing a diverse global workforce Providing employees with time to focus on furthering innovative ideas Use of external consultants Generating ideas through crowdsourcing or other social media Providing employees with sabbaticals to explore new ideas
nysem ag a z i n e .c oM
23
with
TOM EVANS
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
B AN K RAT E
Digital Change Agent High-profile media veteran Tom Evans remakes Bankrate for a connected world.
Y
Headquarters North Palm Beach, Fla.
Revenue
$300 million (2010 pro forma)
Market cap* $1.7 billion
Employees 360
Listed since June 17, 2011
*As of 10/17/2011
24
n y s e m ag a z i ne.com
I found the new online business environment more similar than different from the print business.” Tom Evans CEO, BANKRATE and mortgage information from 4,800 financial institutions in 575 markets in 50 states. Furthermore, Bankrate has added information on CD rates, savings accounts, credit cards, insurance, car loans and many other financial topics through a network of sites. To this raw data, the advertising-supported Bankrate adds tools such as glossaries and calculators for refinancing. “We cover 300 different
MEREDITH JENKS
JUST THE FACTS
ou can’t fight change,” says Thomas R. Evans, CEO of Bankrate Inc. (NYSE: RATE). “You’ve got to find a way to embrace it.” For Evans, 56, those words are something of a mantra. In 1998, after 20 years in print publishing that included serving as president and publisher of U.S. News & World Report, Fast Company and The Atlantic, he became CEO of GeoCities, a pioneer in popularizing personal Websites. (Evans eventually brought the company public in 1998, and a year later Yahoo! Inc. purchased it.) Evans was surprised by how much he could apply the fundamentals of print journalism to the Web. He says the skills needed to create content, present it to an audience and match it to an advertiser are just as relevant online as they are in the print world — despite what he calls a bias in digital circles against traditional media veterans: “The attitude in the online world is ‘Don’t let any of the old guys in because they’ll ruin it.’” Instead, “I found the new business environment more similar than different — the basics still apply,” he says. When Evans joined Bankrate in 2004, the brand had roots going back 35 years. The company had built a reputation for delivering reliable, objective mortgage and lending rates through national weekly newsletters and licensing of its content to outside users, such as broadcast and print news outlets. In a shrinking print publishing market with ever-increasing paper costs and declining ad revenues, Evans recognized that the company could reach a much bigger market online. Another advantage? “The delivery cost is almost zero.” But to really make the push into the online world, Evans believed, Bankrate needed to become more consumer focused — without abandoning its core competency. Today, Bankrate’s roughly 360 employees reach 150 million unique visitors per year by amalgamating up-to-the-minute lending
S IG HT IN S vey sur products in 600 different markets and offer 125 different calculators,” Evans says. The diversification has apparently worked, according to the company’s 2011 Q2 SEC filing: The $197.5 million total revenues that the company reported for the six months ended June 30 is 172 percent higher than its total during the same period last year. Bankrate’s June IPO raised $300 million. To further Bankrate’s online expansion, Evans says, he deploys these tactics: • Diversify through acquisitions. Bankrate reports recent strategic purchases of $145 million for CreditCards.com Inc., which lets consumers shop for, compare and apply for credit cards online, and $205 million for NetQuote Inc., which provides information on insurance. The company also bought Nationwide Card Services Inc., which helps financial services firms market credit cards online to consumers and small businesses. • Don’t just aggregate information — verify and customize it. “Information has to be credible,” Evans stresses. Bankrate independently vets the interest rates and other pricing data that banks and other financial institutions advertise to confirm the rates’ availability. Today’s well-informed consumer would quickly become disillusioned if Bankrate’s information proved faulty, Evans says. The ability to customize information to suit a particular visitor’s needs is a big advantage offered by the digital realm, he adds, noting that “everything is inherently local.” A consumer needs to see the best 30-year fixed rates in his area from local lenders. • Follow digital trends selectively. Bankrate offers smartphone and tablet applications but has kept them simple for now, says Evans, knowing how and where consumers tend to access certain information and recognizing their privacy concerns. “If you’re getting a mortgage, you probably don’t want to do that walking down the street,” Evans explains. And while the company notifies consumers about new interest rates via its Facebook page, it has not invested in functionality that would, for instance, allow users to share their progress in meeting personal goals, the way a fitness site might. “People are relatively private about their finances,” he says. — John R. Quain
staying connected CEOs are becoming increasingly comfortable with the digital realm. Eight in 10 listed-company CEOs single out Websites as their most common source of business information — 89 percent of emerging-company CEOs and 83 percent of MBAs agree. Most executives supplement digital fact-finding with peer conversations and reading print publications, while emerging-company CEOs and MBA students are more likely to access business blogs, Twitter streams and TV. Hefty majorities of all groups say social media will affect the way companies do business in the future and also will play a major role in customerrelationship management, but few have digital strategies.
All three groups expect social media to significantly affect the way they will do business in the future… Emerging CEOs and MBAs are particularly sold on social media.
PERCENTage WHO AGREE THAT SOCIAL MEDIA WILL HAVE A MAJOR IMPACT ON HOW COMPANIES DO BUSINESS IN THE FUTURE
79%
91%
91%
Strongly agree 31%
Strongly agree
38%
Strongly agree 43%
Somewhat agree 53%
Somewhat agree 48%
Somewhat agree 48% Disagree
Disagree
LISTED CEOs
Disagree
EMERGING CEOs
MBAs
…yet few CEOs have developed a social media strategy. Listed-company CEOs
PERCENTage WHO...
Emerging-company CEOs
13% 29%
18% 26%
actively use social media and have a strategy in place
actively use social media but are still developing a strategy
26% 16% are not using or exploring social media but may do so in the future
34% 27%
9%
are committed to social media use but have yet to implement a strategy
have no interest in social media today or in the future
2%
nyse m ag a z i n e .c oM
25
with
DAVID LIU & CARLEY RONEY
NYSE EURONEXT
CEO R E POR T
X O GRO U P
Why Branding Matters
E
JUST THE FACTS Headquarters New York City
Revenue
$112.9 million (2010)
Market cap* $259.1 million
Employees 605
Listed since June 28, 2011
*As of 10/17/2011
ven before Carley Roney and David Liu launched Web portal The Knot in 1996, the wife-and-husband team believed that the brand must be the message. “Without a brand, people can take your business model and beat you on every level,” says Roney, chief content officer at parent company XO Group Inc. (NYSE: XOXO). “But a brand that rings true is a huge advantage in keeping consumers loyal.” Indeed, The Knot Wedding Network, which includes the Websites TheKnot.com and WeddingChannel.com, has attracted nearly 2 million members. Along the way, XO Group has developed The Nest for newlyweds and The Bump for first-time parents. National and local publications, books, social and mobile applications, and television programs deliver the brands by whatever medium brides, new homeowners or expectant parents choose. To better reflect the expanded role that its brands occupy in customers’ lives, The Knot changed its corporate name to XO Group in June when it transferred its stock listing to the NYSE. This new corporate umbrella, though not its own brand, says CEO Liu, makes it easier to expand with a name that is still unmistakably linked to the happy events of life.
Beyond Technology Liu and Roney, who met as film students at New York University, credit their nontech backgrounds as the driving force throughout the company’s 15year history. “At a lot of online businesses, the technology is the most important thing and the brand is often the afterthought,” explains Liu. To stand out in an already crowded field, Roney and Liu vowed to keep their site cool by addressing real-life issues. “We wanted to provide wedding advice your best friend would give you as opposed to your mom or the prim etiquette lady,” says Roney. 26
n y s e m ag a z i ne.com
In planning their own wedding in 1993, the pair had experienced dilemmas that come with a cross-cultural marriage, and they knew that other couples were grappling with similar issues and more. “Traditional wedding sites just weren’t addressing second marriages, divorced parents and kids from previous relationships, yet that stuff was happening in the real world,” Roney says. The partners drew up a list of about 250 names. “The first one we came up with was The Knot,” recalls Roney. “We kept returning to it because it was edgy and memorable — you know, tying the knot.” Liu and Roney completely overhauled the concept of wedding publications with The Knot magazine. Rather than randomly placing ads of wedding gowns throughout the magazine, The Knot runs ads alphabetically, with each designer listing the gowns’ price range. “Brides typically buy wedding magazines for the gown ads, so why not make it as easy as possible for them?” Roney asks. “Listing prices meant that they weren’t going to fall in love with dresses they couldn’t afford.” Although she says advertisers were skeptical, “once brides began coming to their showrooms with pages ripped from our magazine, they knew it was working.” “Consistency in message and execution is so important when building a brand,” adds Liu. For example, the partners vetoed a weight-loss product advertising deal. “Our Website and magazines have always been accepting of women’s different body types,” says Roney. “An ad like that is simply not consistent with what our customers expect.” Still, a little flexibility in the business model doesn’t hurt. “Our original plan called for launching a new brand every six months,” says Liu, who credits the 10 years it took to build The Knot for the success-
JOÃO CANZIANI
The founders of The Knot wedding site say creating a presence that consumers identify with is key to continued success.
S IG HT IN S vey sur
LIVING UP TO YOUR NAME Nearly all CEOs surveyed view reputation management as part of their overall enterprise risk-management program. That said, most respondents from emerging companies, and more than a third of listed-company CEOs and MBA students, say trust in public businesses is declining. Respondents are split on whether CEOs do enough to protect their companies’ reputations, with six in 10 MBA students saying they don’t. CEOs aren’t overly satisfied with the returns on their brand investments, with just 26 percent of listed-company CEOs and 23 percent of emerging-company CEOs saying the brand’s ROI has met expectations.
The three groups think trust in publicly traded companies is decreasing… Emerging-company CEOs are the most negative. Percentage WHO SAY TRUST IS...
At a lot of online businesses, the technology is the most important thing and the brand is often the afterthought.”
Increasing
8%
Decreasing
35%
David Liu CEO, XO Group with Carley Roney chief content officer ful launch of The Nest in 2005 and The Bump two years later. He says online forum comments on The Knot showed how intensely users wanted information about the next logical life stages: setting up a home and becoming parents. The branding of these offshoots had to clear the same hurdles as The Knot: to be edgy and slightly off-center. “People have an ‘aha’ moment when they hear The Knot, The Nest and The Bump,” says Roney. “They take a second to get, but you never forget them.” The company recently launched Ijie.com (which translates to “love knot”) to provide Western inspiration and local advice for weddings, relationships and pregnancy for the Chinese consumer. “A generation in China is seeking inspiration from Western brands and wants to reaffirm these very important events in their lives,” Liu says. The pair have also had discussions with investors in India, Europe and South America. After all, adds Roney, “falling in love, getting married and starting a family cuts through all cultures.” — Susan Caminiti
20%
32%
35% 56%
LISTED CEOs
EMERGING CEOs
MBAs
…yet most listed-company respondents think CEOs do enough to protect their companies’ reputations. Emerging-company CEOs and MBAs don’t agree. PERCENTage WHO THINK THAT...
Yes, CEOs do enough
No, CEOs don’t do enough
63%
43%
39%
37%
57%
61%
LISTED CEOs
EMERGING CEOs
MBAs
nyse m ag a z i n e .c oM NYSE MAGAZINE IS PUBLISHED BY THE NYSE GROUP, INC. IN CONJUNCTION WITH TIME INC. CONTENT SOLUTIONS © 2011 NYSE GROUP, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
27