ประวัติศาสตร์เศรษฐกิจโซเวียต

Page 1






“43 43 43 44 45 47 43 50 53 57 58 58 59

61 63 64 67 70

71 73 74 74 77 30

81 83 85


87

80 80

00 01 02 04

00 102 103 104 105 107 108 111 111 114 118 120

121 121 122 126

127 128 120 131 132 134



187 187 188 189 192 193 195 198 199 200 200 202 204 205 2c5 209 212 214 216 217 218 220 227 231 232 237 237 238 238 241 243 244


246 252 254 265 268 260 268 268 264 266 268 269 282 284 286 285 287 289 2 293 299 299 801 806 809 314 816 818

9

0


321 324 331 332 332 332 334 335 337 338 340 343 343 344 345 348 354 355 357 361 369 385


,

/


EC 394

3




EC 394


EC 394



EC 334

9


110

EC 394






Mediterranean PERSIA

EC 394


EC 394

17


3. wanma4os 4. wanmawai

1. 8

EC 394


EC 3 9 4

19


20

EC 394



,

22

EC 394


E C 394

23


2 4

EC 394


EC 3 9 4

2 5


26

EC 394


EC 394

‘27


2 8

EC 394


Etc 3 9 4

20


30

EC 394


EC 394


32

EC

394


EC 394

33


,

34

EC 394


EC 394


36

I

EC 394



.

38

EC 394


.

EC

334

39


.

4

0

EC 394


4

EC

394

41


: d

i


44


EC 394

45


46.

EC 394


E C 3 9 4

4 7


48

EC! 394


EC

394



-, i


52

EC, 394


EC 394

53






5 8

EC 394


EC 394

5 9


6 0

.EC 3 9 4


EC

394

ti 1


6 2

EC 394


EC 3 9 4



EC

394

6 5


6 6

EC 394



6 8

EC 394


EC 394

A !)



EC 394

71


7 2

EC 394


EC 394

7 .3


7

4

EC 394



76

EC 394


E C 3 9 4

7 7




80

EC

394


EC

394

81


82

EC 394



8’4

EC 394


EC 394

x i,



.

EC 394

8 7


t-.

EC 394

-

1


90

EC 394



92

EC

394


EC 394

9 3



! : .5


96

EC :94



98

EC 394



100

EC 394 ~



102

EC 394


EC 3 9 4



EC

394

105


106

EC 394


Ezc 394

1 0 7


108

Rc 394




112

EC

394


EC 3534

1 1 3


114

EC 394























EC 394

1 3 7


EC 394


EC

394

139


140

w 394


0 EC

394


142

,

EC 394


EC 394

143


144

Ed 394



1 4 6

EC 394


EC

394


4 A


150

EC 394

.


EC 394

151


152

EC 394


EC 394


154

EC 394


committee)

EC 394

155


156

EC 394


: EC 394

\


158

EC 394


EC 394

159


160

EC

394


EC 394

161


,’

162

EC 394


EC 394

163


.

164

2c 3 9 4


EC 394


‘\

166

EC 3%


EC 394

1 6 7


168

EC 394



1 170

8’

EC 394


EC 394

171


~ial9~bn~s~aPrb~njsuQ~nl~~l~l~~~ (46 uososbhh~

7)

5

LQflTm

Q

mm&

1925 - 26

27.1

31.6

41.3

1926 - 27

18.5

30.9

50.6

1927 - 20

15.6

29.2

55.0



174

EC 394


EC 394

175


176

EC 394


EC 394

977


178

EC 3%


EC 394

179


980

EC 394



1 8 2

1913

100.

100

100

1920

20

64

22

1928

102,

118

106

EC 394


EC

394.

1 8 3


1922

184

I

1923

I

1924

EC 394


EC 394

1 8 5


186

EC 394


(iM3. 1928L1933j

EC 394

'

J

187


EC

394


E C 394


190

EC 394


1932

3

1932

(Law)

(859

49.7

45.5

43.2

43.3

18.1

23.1

25.1

20.2

25.8

16.6

22.0

13.4

75

64.3

22

21.4

19

i2.1

10

6.2

10.4

5.9

4688

7362

3.4

0.61

270

93.3

15.8

22.8

191


1 9 2

EC 394


EC 394

193


194

EC 394


EC 394

195


1 9 8

EC 394



198

EC 394


EC

394

199


2 0 0

EC 394


EC 394

1930

1931

1932

1933

1934

1935

1936

23.6

52.7

61.5

64.4

71.4

83.2

89.6

33.6

67.0

77.6

83.1

87.4

94.1

-

201


202

EC 394


EC 394

203


EC 394


1 ”

(Rfl. 1933 - 1937) “ /


206

EC 394


EC 394

2 0 7


208

EC 394


EC 394

209


210

EC 394


1'332 (69)

(uwsa)

(63)

100,200

96,300

43,303

92,112

95,500

23.1""

45,526

55,2"0

20,200

47,184

40,300

13.4

38.0

36.2

64.3

152.5

128.”

22.3

46.8

28.5

6.2

16.0

14.5

5.9

17.0

17.7

15.0

40.0

45.5

3.5

7.5

5.5

2,720

5,100

3,448

94.6

226.6

106.3

18”

183

828

2,500

2,421

51.6

166.7

66.5

0.9

9.0

3.2

3 3,070

38,160

20,123

59.9

104.8

96.0

22.94

28.91

26.99

7.97

lO.2”

10.11

1,427

1,755

3,047

103

65

160

1""

394

,937

45.500

82

E C

1937

250.7

150


2'1 2

b

EC 394


EC 394

2 1 3


214

EC 394


. EC 394

2 1 5


..

. 216

EC 394


EC 394

2 1 7


1932

218

2,350

EC 394


EC 394

219


220

EC

394


EC 394

221


222

EC 394


EC 394

223


5iuni5

2 2 4

1937

1938

1939

%

%

15.0

14.3

16.0

4.0

2.0

4.0

33.0

37.0

5.1

4.0

18.6

18.2

13.6

13.9

0.8

0.8

2.0

2.7

35.0

35.6

26.9

23.9

100.0

100.0

EC 394


EC 394

2 2 5


226

EC 394


EC 394

2 2 7


1932

1933

1934

1935

1937

(glkid) 1427

2 2 8

1556

1858

2269

.

3047

EC,

394


EC

394

2 2 9


230

EC 394


EC 394

231


232

EC 394


EC

394

233


2 3 4

EC 394


EC 394

2 3 5


1928

-

n.u.

1934

1933

-

1937

1933

3

1939

1938

1942

1938

-

1941

4

1946

1946

1950

1946

-

1950

5

1952

1951

1955

1951

-

1955

6

1956

1956

1960

1

6'pamlu 1927

2

EC

394

n.er.

-

1933

1928

1956

-

B.?l.

1932

1937

mGnlu?J

1958 2 3 7


EC 394


EC

394

239


2 4 0

EC 394


EC 394

241


242

EC 394


EC 394

2 4 3


1938

67.2

85.9

1939

56.4

61.6

1940

419.1

736.5

(LLMdS%Jl : Alec Nove, An Economic History of USSR, p. 260.

244

EC 394


EC 394

2 4 5


24fi

EC 394


EC

394

2 4 7


-248

EC 394


EC 394

2 4 9


250

EC 394


EC 394

2 5 1


252

EC 394


EC 394

2 5 3


rc 3 9 4


EC 394

255


256

EC 394


EC

394

2 5 7


2 5 8

EC 394


1941

1942

1943

1944

1945

(Gu:lM;LcEJ)

E C

394

3lUfU

177.0

165.0

204.4

268.7

302.0

51&1u

191.4

182.8

210.0

264.0

298.6

2 5 9


EC 394


EC 394

.mm

261



EC 394

263


264

EC 394


1940

EC

394

1945

1950

1950

2 6 5


266

EC

394


EC 394

2 6 7


2 6 8

EC 394


EC 394

269


2 7 0

E C 394


EC 394

271


2 7 2

EC 394



2 7 4

EC 394


EC 394


2 7 6

EC 394


EC

394

2 7 7


2 7 8

EC 394


1945 1946 1947 1948 1949

EC 394

270




filanl~7Plnl~t~odt~aods�paalAu

2 8 2

1947 (The 1947 Monetary Reform)

EC 394


EC

39”

% 8 3


4lUG

1947

194%

1949

1950

1951 '

1952

(&U~llu~~fiS) 386.2

410.5

437.0

422.8

470.3

499.9

239.9

247.3

245.5

236.1

247.8

246.9

n1izfh1s

22.6

27.2

42.2

40.4

48.0

58.5

JlldYl1Bl-7.l

28.0

33.1

33.7

35.8

42.9

47.4

mEmina3uff

25.7

23.9

27.6

31.0

34.5

35.7

YhaJvl

'

: mGn7mJ&do

284

EC 394



2 8 6

EC 394



1950

(LawPa)

(959)

160

171

100

170

185

100

780

191

100

165

1 .76

373.4

389.9

37.9

70.9

70.8

91.2

164.2

170.2

1-9.2

33.8

33.3

27.3

44.2

45.3

292.9

314.0

10.3

9.7

22.4

22.5

246.1 5.5 10.2

2 8 8

1955

100

261.1

/

1955

161.0

251.2

212.1

3899

6277

5905

155.2

239.0

252.3

203

315

271

2523

4491

3419

1755

2773

2737

40.4

46.5

50.3

72.4

105

112.9

100

170

189

EC 39i



2 9 0

EC 394


1952

1955

1955

(a?~)

(amwnm4)

(9%)

5,:;44

6,267

5,905

150.5

271

252.3

224.6

573

525.8

Glixit6 (h6Lam'a)

256.5

406

305.5

~wi7uluMLw~xa~

234.9

382

346.5

63.5

88

584 9

777

cJo7t%u .

(hwm,~

hJU+l'i &7qwJ

(khALWl3)

(hmJw3)

p&.buan’Lwx4au qa&

RC

jij‘lUf1~

394

.

(bbwebau) (hmdaw)

85.1 772.2

2 9 1


1952 (GJ)

(ammnod)

1955 (959)

237.7

318

804.5

2,615

1,610.g

3,445

2,883.a

104.4

225

244.5

10,486

22,000

19,705

4,527

4,024.fi

330

151.4

6,958

4,911

1,650.4

1,331.g

2,883

292

1955

274.3

EC

394

I


1954 739 165 626 369 99 ,?a9 102


. 294

I

EC 394


EC 394

2 9 5





EC

394



nl%~nMl2-

1953-8

._ i 93

1354

1955

1956

1951

1958

1953

134.7

31.1

56.9

I

958

(h.46~) 82.5

85.6

103.7

125.0

102.6

26.9

37.2

27.7

63.3

38.1

58.4

10.8

32.8

72.6

75.0

71.8

96.0

87.8

86.5

5.4

7.0

2.6

1.9

3.0

3.9

2.8

4.6

1.8

2.6

0.15

0.22

0.38

0.52

0.44

0.44

0.15

0.39

3.9

4.2

3.9

4.3

4.2

4.4

3.9

4.4

5.8

5.3

6.3

6.6

7.4

7.7

3.6

5.7

36.5

38.1

43.1

49.1

54.8

58.9

10.6

22.1

24.3

25.2

26.4

21.1

29.0

31.4

i9. 5

33.3

30.9

34.0

40.8

44.3

9q.3

99.8

99.0

103.3

08.2

120.2

105

117

132

136

151

I uo

I

-

-

-




E C ?94


306

EC 394


EC 394

307


308

EC 394


EC 394

3 0 9


310

EC 394


EC 394

311


3 1 2

1955

25.0

8.4

1956

29.5

11.5

1957

38.'i

13.5

1958

45.7

24.5

1959

53.5

27.2

F:c

394


EC

39.1

37

3


314

EC 394


EC 394

3 1 5


3 1 6

EC 394


E C

3 9 4

317


318

E C

394


1958

100 100

1965

1965

LLWU

G.1

162-165 180

184

100

185-188

196

100

762-165

1 60

88.8\

150-160

153.4

38.6

65-70

66.2

54.9

86-91

91 .o

493

600-612

578

113

230-240

242.9

29.9 235

1 50 500-520

129.3 507

1%

35

166

666

407

138

190-200

185

220 251 33.3 5.79 303

31.6

355 275-280 75-81 7.7-8.0

273 72.4 7.08

1,485

365

356.4

515

486

134.7

164-180

3.37

EC 394

158

6.13

121.1 5.25

56.0

66.5

76.9

71.2

650-660

79.2

3 1 9


3 2 0

E C

794


EC 394

321


,a 2 2

EC 394


EC 394

3 2 3


3 2 4

EC 394


EC 394

3 2 5


3 2 6

EC 394


EC 394

3 2 7


3 2 8

E C

394


E C

394

329


EC 394

331


332

EC

394


EC 394

333


3 3 4

EC 394


EC 394

335


3 3 6

EC 3 9 4


EC 394

3 3 7


3 3 8

EC 394


EC 394

339


340

EC 394


EC 394

341


342

EC 394


EC 394

343


344

EC 394


EC 394

3 4 5


346

EC 394


EC 394

347


3 4 8

EC 394


EC

394

349


350

EC 394


EC 394

351


352

EC 394


E C

394


3 5 4

EC 394


EC 394

355


3 5 6

EC 394


EC 394

3 5 7


n33at-fSvMi

(%u$iuiibaTmg-%.u.)

&ah (th4&&) aark

(+Gdhb

si1wRu

(h&)

avik?maau aesBnn& ~-An%

3 5 8

au.81.)

(~GIA) (h.4&)

(&w$

1965

1970

507

840-850

243

345-355

129

225-240

578

665-675

66

94-97

91

124-129

71

95-99

EC 394


1965 9 31.3 821

1970 '

14-15 62-65 2100-2300

407

780-830

616

1360-1510

380

600-650

201

700-800

355

600-625

1446

2500

337

350-365

3.2

8.4-9

3.23

5-5.3

72.4

100-105

7.5

9.5-9.8

486

610-630

4.8

5.9-6.2

5.8

8.5-9

8.9

9.8-10

5.2

7.5-8

3‘7

7.5-7.7

1.7

5.3-5.6


360

EC 394


GLOSSARY

EC 394

361


362

EC 394


EC 394

3 6 3


3 6 4

EC 394


EC 394

365


3 6 6

E C 3 9 4



Tsentrosoyuz : tWi?l~&~!.J’E1S~~Fl~~IAll31~

3 6 8

(central - consumer cooperative)


‘Roger Munting, The Economic Development of the USSR (New York : St. Martin’s Press, 1982), p. 168.

‘Sidney Harcave, Russia : .4 History (New York : J.B. Lippincott Company, 1968). p. 17. 2D.M. Sturley, A Short History of Russia (New York : Harper & Row, Publishers, 1967), p. 15. ,

“Michael T. Florinsky, Russia : A Short History (New York : The Macmillan Company, 1964), p. 15-18. 5tpJ~~6i yv%iq, XJWlp6FlS

d3~~1aian~qaaBtt

: Y%h’la~~‘ihl~~~~ %ui

h%l,

bnuanitpw, aio.Giu,

: qmhwm.6t1u&

m.fl.

1 9 1 7 (n~mw

2525), I& 2 2 . wCi1 4 6 .

‘Sturley, op.cit., p.20. *&UI bmsmnpu,

aisGiu,

wG1 4 1 .

Qa%Gieran’es, Gil 8 6 .

“Harcave,-op.cit.,

pp. 35-48 *

“Ibid., pp. 51-53. EC 394

3 6 9


‘*Ibid., p. 71. 131bid., pp. 71-72. ‘%ar Spector, An Introduction to Russian History and Culture’5th. ed. (New York: D. Van Nostrand Company, 1969), p. 33. “Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974), p.

78.

’ ‘%pector,

op.cit., p. 44.

“Basil Dmytryshyn, A History of Russia (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey : PrenticeHall, Inc., 1977), p. 225. “Ibid. lgHarcave, op.cit., p. 73. “Ibid., pp. 73-74. 2’Dukes,

opcit., p. 59.

“Ibid., p. 80.

‘Michael T. Florinsky, Russia : A Short History (New York : The Macmillan Company, 1964), p. 181. 2Basil Dmytryshyn, A History of Russia (Englewood Cliffs, New Jersay : PrenticeHall, Inc., 1977), p. 258. 3Paul Dukes,

A History of Russia (New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974),

p. 98. 4Sidney Harcave, Russia : A History (New York : J.B. Lippincott Company, 1968). p. 109. ‘Florinsky, op.cit., p. 1,82. ‘Ibid., p. 183. ‘D.M. Sturley, A Short History of Russia (New York : Harper & Row, Publishers, 1967), p. 87. ‘Harcave, op.cit., p. 106. ‘Florinsky, op.cit., p. 180.

370

EC 394


“Harcave, “Florinsky,

op.&., p. 107. op.&.

“Sturley, op.cit., p. 74. ‘3Florinsky,op.cit.,

p. 180.

“‘Sturley, op.cit., p.> 89. “Florinsky,

op.cit., p. 203.

16&jbu~ finajan7yW, nl~~~fliarni~~"n%a%:~~~~6~~

(n~9bwwmmwn

: Fpk4

ihMii9, 2526), ?& 182. 17Dmytryshyn, op.cit., pp. 291-292. “Ibid., p. 293. lgHarcave, op.cit., p. 167. 201bid., pp. 167-168. “Ibid., p. 169. “Dmytryshyn,

op.cit., p. 291.

23Florinsky, op.cit., p. 229. “Harcave,

op.cit., p. 173.

25Dukes, op.cit., p. 117. 26Dmytryshyn, op.cit., p. 315. “Ibid. “Florinsky,

op.cit., p. 231.

‘Qlvar Spector, An lntroduiction

to Russian History and Culture, 5th.ed. (New York:

D. Van Nostrand Company, 1969), p. 82. 301bid. 3’Dukes, op.cit., pp. 136-137. 32Florinsky, op.cit., 263 and 279 331bid., p. 281. 34Spector, op.cit., p. 116. 35Dukes,

op.cit., p. 140.

36Dmytryshyn, op.cit., p. 348. 37Sturley, op.cit., p. 133.

EC 394

371


‘Angus Maddison, Economic Growth in Japan and the USSR (London : Allen I% Unwin Ltd., 1969), p. 84. ‘Ivar Spector, An Introduction to Russian History and Culture, Sth.ed. (New York: D.Van Nostrand Company, 1969), p. 128. 3Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974), p. 161. 4D.M. Sturley, A Short History of Russia (New York : Harper & Row, Publishers, 1967), p;. 166-167. ‘Ibid., p. 167. ‘jIbid. 7Dukes, op.cit., p. 162. ‘Joel Carmichael, A Short History of The Russian Revolution (3rd.ed.;

New York:

Basic Books, Inc., 1964), p. 5. ‘Dukes, op.cit., pp. 162-163. ‘%I.

pld mt

a .

u1p~op”1, nl~~:a~flian~solni~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,

A Short History of The USSR, ‘6@1e, q O?i?Wd 2525),

(n~9~mwHlUfl4

: Whskp

aadmn “@laqf&“,

‘dl 1 1 .

“Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart, Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York : Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974), p. 26. lgSturIey,

3 7 2

op.cit., p. 171.

EC 3 9 4 ’


“Maddison,

op.cit., p. 90.

“Sturley, op.cit., p. 187. “Spector, lot. cit. 23Michael

T. iorinsky, Russia : A Short History (New York : The Macmillan Company,

1964), p. 318. *%El97~ u@iBm, tk&i%mm%"%aaGa 9 9 P UMll.4Fl~ : lJ‘%~+hl%%Jw" i'likl, 2525),

25Sergei

: ~nlumm&h ma. 1917 (rqam?& 363.

Pushkarev, The Emergence of Modern Russia 1801-1917 (New York : Holt,

Rinehart and Winston, Inc., 1963), p. 227. 26Jesse D. Clarkson, A History of Russia 2nd.ed. (new York : Random House, 1969), p. 358. 27Pushkarev, loc.cit. “Clarkson,

loc.cit.

‘gSpector, op.cit., p. 162. 30Florinsky, op.cit., p. 319. 3’Spector, op.cit., p. 161. 32Pushkarev, op.cit., p. 224. %urley,

op.cit., p. 187.

34Spector, op.cit., p. 162. 35Florinsky, op.cit., p. 320. ¶JpIi 5

‘Alec Nave, An Economic Hlistory of USSR (London : The Penguin Press, 1976), p. 13. ‘Ivar Spector, An Introduction to Russian History and Culture, 5th.ed. (New York: D.Van Nostrand Company, 1969), p. 158. 3Michael

T. Florinsky, Russia : A Short History (New York : The Macmillan Company,

1969), p. 348.

%pector, opxit., pp. 277.278. ‘Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart, Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York: Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974), p. 23.

EC 394

373


‘Angus Maddison, Economic Growth in Japan and the USSR (London : AIlen & Unwin Ltd., 1969), p. 92. kfpv4 UAf wpJovl, nl%=a~alscil;aPlrnw~~t~~~~~~~~t~~,

A Short History of The USSR, b$lfJbk &%I~ (fl~SbWWBJHlU+l7 : %%‘swy@l

aanJw91n

“GWnJ&", 2525),

HGI 18.

8Maddison,

op.cit., p. 90.

‘Nave, op.cit., p. 18: “Maddison, op.cit., p. 91. “Sergei Pushkarev, The Emergence of Modern Russia 1801-1917 (New York : Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc:, 1963), p. 228. \ “Florinsky, op.cit., p. 351. 13~U~ Fl.B(.

1877

~Ia~lbaeiwr~soPln~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~l~

+l.fl. 1905 Ibds3-ns~El~a"a8~~P~~~~l~

27

34

KJWl~a"

ad

EILFBI;

14Spector, op.cit., p. 279. “Florinsky, op.cit., p. 352. “Nave, opcit., p. 23. “Spector, op.cit., pp. 280-281. ‘8Florinsky, op.cit., pp. 354-355. lgIbid.,‘p. 355. “‘Nave. op.cit., p. 25. “Ibid. “Florinsky, opcit., p. 349. “3Pushkarev,

op.cit., 279.

“4+l.QlTl~ LLRt

WQXJD'i,

&d%J,

61

18.

’ “Pushkarev, Ioc.cit. 26Maddison, op.cit., p. 93. I-l7lflJ$;!u?l +l.f?.

1913, 17.5% YCl~WRW~~V~~~3~~lU

ari8inr~baau~~~ar~~~~~~~~~~

EC 394


‘Harry Schwartz, Russia’s Soviet Economy (2nd ed.; New Jersey : Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1958), p. 69. ‘Ibid., p. 70. “Ibid. 41bid., pp. 86-87. ¶Jwi

7 ‘Marie Lavigne, The Socialist Economies of the Soviet Union nd Europe (London:

The Pitman Press, Bath; 1974), p. 1. %.pww

bba: a.t.qpovl, nl~=a~fli-an%“awni~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,

sadawn ,4

Short History of The USSR, h,er by &%d, (nqwW.JWlubnT : rn~hp “twaqfld”, 2525), WY1

74.

-

3Roger

Munting, The Economic Development of the USSR (New York : St. Martin’s

Press, 1982), p. 42. 4Lavigne, op.cit., p. 2. 5n.ym4 LLat a.qud, aTosa881, %+o.Gwaih,

&i 7 6 .

~9th 7 5 .

‘Munting, loc.cit. ‘Alec Nove, An Economic History of USSR (London : The Penguin Press, 1976), p.50. ‘Maurice Dobb, Soviet Ecamomic Development Since 1917 (8th.ed.; London: Routledge & Kegan

Paul, 1978), pp. 84-85. “Ibid., pp. 85-86. “Nave, op.cit., p. 53. ‘*Lavigne, op.cit., p. 3. 13Dobb,

op.cit., p. 86.

“‘Ibid., p. 87.

e

“Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart, Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York : Harper and Row, Pubhshers, 1974). p. 45.

EC 394

375


16David MacKenzie, and Michael W. Omen, A History of Russia and the Soviet Union (Homewood, Illinois : The Dorsey Press, 1982), p. 488. “Gregory and Stuart, op.cit., p. 44. 181bid. lgDobb, op.cit., p. 117. z”Munting, op.cit., p. 44. “Cheka &lB~~nl~~7saP&iPra~nn”?

~&.&&Ba”na~ 7 l%a?@a.t

n.a. 1917

2zLavigne, op.cit., p. 3. 23Michaei

T. Florinsky, Russia : A Short History (New York : The Macmillan Company,

1964), p. 470.

“Nave,

opcit., p. 62.

*sMacKenzie

and Curren, op.cit., p. 488.

zgPaul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974), p. 240.

31Dobb,

opcit., p. 112.

3’Dukes, op.cit., p. 240. 332!W Z-h h.JLwTl-2 Lb% 39i0~b~eJ-dK~,

LTKUlW6, - 9

L$osLhJ,

H&

61.

W~lL~er7~U.

35D .M. Sturley, A Short History of Russia (New York : Harper & Kow, Publishers, (1967), p. 255. 36Dukes, 37Sturley,

loc.cit. ioc.cit.

3sMacKenzie and Curren, loc.cit. 3gGregory and Stuart, op.cit., p. 51.

3 7 6

EC 394


40Sturley, op.cit., p. 263. 4'a19

m ~Ymhw~Irb

bm: u.=qiyG, a%osah,

esC7 62.

@Nave, op.cit., p. 84. 43Sturley,

locxit., The land code of 1922 e~na~n~~lavosaon~~~~~~~

U&lklU~?&~l

oejl,,,~~l~~~~~‘l~eanlsawl~~lgn 44Munting, op.cit., p. 4 9 45Gregory and Stuart, op.cit., p. 53. 46a%r4

m dou~wiis ax u.=mu~uw&

“Nave,

a&GieJaik

v&&afb

op.cit., p. 104.

5’Lavigne, op.cit.. p. 7. 531bid. 54Lavigne, loc.cit. %regory 5bMunting,

and Stuart, op.cit., p. 54. loc.cit.

“Gregory and Stuart, op.cit., p. 55. S8Nove, 5givlunting,

op.cit., p. 90. op.cit., p. 54.

60a!,A bib fi%x~awiI7 LLR:

u."az~ppia?,

a+kIl,sa&J,

MCI

62.

“Now, op.cit., p. 92.

65MacKenzie and Curren, op.cit., p. 489. EC 394

3 7 7


‘Harry Schwartz, Russia’s Soviet Economy (2nd ed.; New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1958), p. 113. “Ibid., pp. 297-298. 3Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart, Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York: Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974), p. 235. 4Fedor Belov, The History of a Soviet Collective Farm (New York : Frederick A. Praeger, Publishers, 1955), p. 33. ‘Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974)

p. 262. 6alfl m douawm XJMlWl5 : blLl%lPalWl%,

7Schwartz,

LLR: pa.m~iy&

awniwbw%w

dma~adayh

(nqmwi-

2516), Vii1 65.

op.cit., p. 114.

sRobert William Davies, The Industrialisation

of Soviet Russia Vol. 1 (London:Mac-

millan, 1980), p. 203. 9aVb~ N ~YOSJW~

bb~t

~.m-ppY,

~%3sGf~aih esi%eJan”Pd.

“Alec Nove, An Economic History of USSR (London : The Penguin Press, 1976), p. 183.

‘*Schwartz, op.cit., p. 115. 13Dukes, loc.cit. 14Schwartz,

. .. .

loc.cit.

I

“Dukes, op.cit., p. 263. ¶.wi

9

‘U-ii% bFl=Wj~tl-~,

hQWt’&%t&

(n~SLWHl'lWI3

:

LM%lUl,

2515),

M?il

117.

‘Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart. Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York : Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974), p. 119.

.378

EC 3 9 4


2525), I& 139.

4Alec Nove, An Economic .History of IJSSR (Londcn : The Penguin Press, 1976),p.225. ‘Ibid,, p. 232. ‘Ibid. ‘Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw--Hill Book Company, 1974), p. 265. ‘Nave, op.cit., p. 236. gIbid., p. 238. “Ibid., p. 239. “k&~r %lOV, The History Iof a Soviet Collective Farm (New York : Frederick A. praeger, Publishers, 1955), p. 3X. “Ibid., p. 88. “Nave. op.cit., p. 242. ‘“Ibid , p. 253. ’ ‘ibid. ‘“FLpm

LiaE mmpwJ,

s%.Ga.J,

VI'il

153.

!‘a!3 m dmuwm bix ra.myiyd, 3waiwWk1~1 BIWIWIS : "IYl~J~FAledlVi-i~~, 2514,

&haa:1P”97~~tia

jnTam+

MCI d5-ST.

“D.M. Sturley, A Short Historv

of Russia :New York Harper & Sow PubliTher<,

19671, p. 274.

‘Alec Nnve, An Economic HListory of I;YSR (London The Pengum Press, !976), p. 257. ‘loid,, p. 270. ‘ibid.

,p 271.

41bid. ‘Ibid., p. 272.

E C 394

379


61bid., p. 273. ‘Ibid., p. 274. ‘Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974), p. 278. ‘Ibid. “Nave, opsit., p. 279. “Ibid., p. 283. ¶Jw; 1 1

‘Paul Dukes, A History of Russia (New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974), p. 279. *Alec Nove, An Economic History of USSR (London : The Penguin Press, 1976), p. 288. 3Harry

Schwartz, Russia’s Soviet Economy (2nd ed.; New Jersey : Prentice-Hill Inc.,

1958), p. 600. 4David MacKenzie, and Michael W. Curren, A History of Russia and the Soviet Union (Homewood, Illinois : The Dorsey Press, 1982), p. 582. ‘Nave, op.cit., p. 291. %~a~4

bm:

-J.uI~J~,

nl%=a~flia~%‘~~lnl~~~l~~~~~~~~t~~,

A Short History of the USSR, ‘bfl)Ub!$ BJ%%&

(n~9l?I’I%JVIl~fl~

: Fr&tXl+a

mhain

“@llaqn6",

2525), H;l 1 8 3 .

7MacKenzie

and Curren, op.cit., pp. 582-583.

*Nave, op.cit., p. 300. ‘Ibid., p. 301. “Ibid., p. 302. “Ibid., p. 306. “Ibid., p. 307. 13Schwartz, op.cit., pp. 479-486. 14Dukes, op.cit., p. 280. “Nave, op.cit., p. 311. “Ibid., p. 340.

3 8 0

EC 394


171bid., p. 325. ‘?bid., p. 328. lgNicolas Spulber, The Soviet Economy . Structure, Principles and Problems (New York : W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1969), p. 89. wld 1 2 lal~

bib &~uaw~s LLR: w,.q~iymT, anniwhifm

85MlW15 : ~WU%JUlWl%, 25i6),

an"naaa:~a~Gu (n;ww-

%?;I 69.

zRoger Muting, The Econlomic Development of the USSR (New York : St. Martin’s Press, 1982). p. 132. 3J.N. Westwood, Endurance and Endeavour : Russian History 1812 : 1980 2nd.ed. (New York : Oxford University Press, 1981). p. 396. 4Alec Nove, An Economic History of USSR (London : The Penguin Press, 1976), p. 340. ‘David MacKenzie, and Michael W. Curren A History of Russia and the Soviet Union (Homewood, Illinois : The Dorsey Press, 1982), p. 595. 6MichaeI

T. Florinsky, Russia : A Short History(New York : The Macmillan Company,

1964), p. 588. 7u=EB W%WUl,

2519),

ans~~yn, !-?;I

%&N&JTik,

nis1:~89rnlnln~s89~~~~~~t~~~~t~~

(n~9~wwp97uns:

124-125. Vi;1 125-126.

‘Westwood, loc.cit. “Florinsky,

op.cit., p. 594.

“Nave, op.cit., p. 346. “Ibid., p. 347. 13u.~~~egmG, Lb'&%lUl,

2516),

rn~a~esaa~~:msnln~a~~~~~~w~lw~~t~~~

(nq9~mwmum :

-it& 249.

14Mackenzie atid Curren, op.cit., p. 597. i5Nove, op.cit., p. 350. 161bid., p. 353.

EC 394

381


“Munting, op.cit., p. 135 ‘*Ibid., p. 147. “R.W. Davies, “Economic Planning in the USSR”, The Soviet Fxonomy : Continuity and Change (Boulder, Colorado : Westview

Press Inc., 1982), p. 30.

*‘Paul R. Gregory, and Robert C. Stuart: Soviet Economic Structure and Performance (New York : Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974), pp. 243.245. “Florinsky,

op.cit., p. 599.

“MacKenzie and Curren, op.cit., p. 643. wl; 1 3

*Marie Lavigne, The Socialipt Economies of the Soviet Union and Europe (London: The Pitman Press, Bath, 1974), pp. 115-117. 31bid.,pp.

117-118. .

41bid., p. 118. ‘Douglas B. Diamond, and Constance B. Krueger, “Recent Developments in Soviet Agriculture”, The Soviet Economy : A Book of Reading (4th ed.; lllinois: Richard D. Irwin, Inc.. 1974). p. 226. ‘Lavigne, op.cit., pp. 118-119. 71bid., p. 120. *Alec Nave, “Soviet Agriculture under Brezhnev”, The Soviet Economy : A Book of Reading (4th ed.; Illinois: Richard D. Irwin, Inc., 1974), pp. 203-204. gLavigne, op.cit., p. 113. ‘OIbid., p. 114. “Ibid.,pp.

114-115.

“Ibid., p. 113.

3 8 2

EC 394


15E.G.

Liberman, “The Economic Reform in the USSR”, The Soviet Economy : A

Hook of Reading (4th ed.; Illinois: Richard D. Irwin, Inc., 1974), p. 467. ‘“USTG aFm~lpl%,

aioGaJ,

Gil

130-131.

“R.W. Davies, “Economic Planning in the USSR”, The Soviet Economy : Continuity and Change (Boulder, Colorado : Westview

Press Inc., 1982). p. 30

“Roger Muting, The Economic Development of the USSR (New York : St.Martin’s Press, 1982), p.153. lgDavie?, op.cit., p. 31. “Liberman,

op.cit., pp. 474.475.

“Ibid., p. 475. ‘“Ibid. 231bid., p. 476. 24Lavigne, op.cit., p. 51. “Munting, loc.cit. 26Davies,

op.cit., p. 33.

“J.P. Cole, and F.C. German, A Geography of the USSR (London : Butterworth and Co (Publishers) Ltd., 1970), p. 72. *‘Ibid., pp. 72-73. “Ibid., pp. 152-153. 301bid., p. 193.

EC 394

383


Jw~l~.aflsnqB

/’

Belov, Fedor. The History of a Sovie CoMcctive Farm. New York : Frederick A. Praeger, Publishers, 1955. Bornstein, Morris (cd.) The Soviet Economy : Continuity and Change. Boulder, Colorado: West-view Press Inc., 1982. Bornstein, Morris, and Fusfeld,

Daniel R. (ed.) The Soviet Economy: A Rook of Reading. 4th

ed. Illinois: Richard D. Irwin,

Inc.,

1974.

Carmichael, Joel. A Short History of the Russian Revolution. New York: Basic Books,

Inc.,

Clarkson, Jesse D. A History of E&a. 2nd ed. New York: Random House, 1969.

1964.


Cole, J.P., and German, F.C. A Geography

of the USSR. 2nd ed. London: Butterworth and Co

(Publishers) Ltd., 1970. Davies, Robert William. The Industriolfsation Dmytryshyn,

of Sovtef Russia. Vol. 1 London : Macmillan, 1980.

Basil. A Witory of R&a. Et&wood Cliffs, New Jersey : Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1 9 7 7 .

Dobb, Maurice. Soviet Economic Development Since 1917. London : Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1978. Dukes, Paul. A History of Russia. New York : McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1974. Florinsky, Michael T. Russia : A History

and Atilnterpretation. 2 vols. New York : The Macmillan

Company, 1953. Florinsky, Michael T. Russia : A Shortkistory. New York : The Macmillan Company, 1964. Gregory, Paul’R.,

and Stuart, Robert C. Soviet Economic Structure and Performance. New York:

Harper and Row, Publishers, 1974. Harcave, Sidney, Russia : A History. New York : J.B. Lippincott Company, 1968. Lavigne, Marie, The Socialist Economies of the Soviet Union and Europe. London : The Pitman Press, Bath, 1974. MacKew.ie,

David and Curren,

Michael W. A History of Russia and the Soviet Union. Homewood,

Illinois : The Dorsey Press, 1982. Maddison, Angus. Economic Growth in Japan and the USSR. London : Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1%9. Munting, Roger. The Economic Development of the USSR. New York : St. Martin’s Press, 1982. Nove, Alec. An Ekonomic

History of USSR. London : The Penguin Press, 1976.

Nove, Alec. The Soviet Economic System. London : Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1977. Pushkarev. Sergei. The Emergence of Modern Russia 1801-1917. New York : Holt, Rinehart and Winstou, Inc.. 1963. Schwartz, Harry. Russia’s Soviet Ecooomy. 2nd ed. New Jersey : Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1958. Spector, Ivar. An Introduction to R&an History and Culture. 5th ed. New York : D.Van Nostrand Company 1969. Spulber, Nicolas. The Soviet fkonomy : Structure, Principles and Problems. New York :,W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1969,

386

EC 394


Sturley. D.M. A Short History of Russia. New York: Harper and Row, Publishers. 1967. Westwood, J.N. Endurance and Endeavonr

: Russian History 1812 - 1980.2nd ed. New York :

Oxford University Press, 1981.

EC 394 I


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.