Graphic Organizer: Forming Opinions
Lesson Plan
What is treasure?
Section 1: My initial opinion
Fluent Plus reading stage
What is treasure? A chest full of coins? Rare and expensive jewels?
Level N (30)
Section 2: Gathering information: What I have learned
Section 3: My informed opinion
PERSPECTIVES
Contents • Treasure from the past • Speak out! • King Midas and the golden touch • National treasure
Paired connected texts
Famous Finds recounts the incredible stories of Mary Anning’s fossil discoveries and Howard Carter’s discovery of Tutankhamen’s Tomb.
William decides to help his uncle discover Egyptian treasure. But things go wrong, and William gets trapped inside a tomb!
Content vocabulary coins diamonds expensive gems gold jewels museum national treasure past precious reward rich statues treasure value/able
Correlations with Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills Flying Start to Literacy Lesson Plan Perspectives What is Treasure? What Do You Value? © 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd. © 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd. This work is protected by copyright law, and under international copyright conventions, applicable in the jurisdictions in which it is published. The trademark “Flying Start to Literacy” and Star device is a registered trademark of EC Licensing Pty Ltd in the US. In addition to certain rights under applicable copyright law to copy parts of this work, the purchaser may make copies of those sections of this work displaying the footnote: “© 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd”, provided that: (a) the number of copies made does not exceed the number reasonably required by the purchaser for its teaching purposes; (b) those copies are only made by means of photocopying and are not further copied or stored or transmitted by any means; (c) those copies are not sold, hired, lent or offered for sale, hire or loan; and (d) every copy made clearly shows the footnote copyright notice. All other rights reserved.
Developed by Eleanor Curtain Publishing
okapi educational publishing
Text: Kerrie Shanahan Consultant: Linda Hoyt Designed by Derek Schneider Printed in China through Colorcraft Ltd, Hong Kong Distributed in the USA by Okapi Educational Publishing Inc. Phone: 866-652-7436 Fax: 800-481-5499 Email: info@myokapi.com www.myokapi.com www.flying-start-to-literacy.com
Reading 3(6) (H) Synthesize information to create new understanding. 3(7) (A) Describe personal connections to a variety of sources, including self-selected texts. 3(9) (E) Recognize characteristics and structures of argumentative text. 3(10) (A) Explain the author’s purpose and message within a text.
Writing 3(12) (C) Compose argumentative texts, including opinion essays, using genre characteristics and craft. Speaking and Listening 3(10) (B) Explain how the use of text structure contributes to the author’s purpose.
PERSPECTIVES What is Treasure? What Do You Value? Key concepts • T reasure can be many things including rare and precious objects, artifacts from the past, national treasures, and personal precious items. • T reasure can mean different things to different people.
Initiate ideas
Explore further
Introduce the book
Read the text
Ask: What do you think treasure is? Have students talk with a partner about this. Introduce the Graphic Organizer: Forming Opinions. Say: Work with your partner to fill in the first section of your Forming Opinions charts. Collect students’ graphic organizers to revisit later. Show the students the front cover of PERSPECTIVES: What is Treasure? What Do You Value? Say: This book is about treasure. It has several texts that discuss different points of view about what treasure is. Read the title and ask: What types of treasure might we find in this book? Have students discuss their ideas.
Have students turn to the “Speak out!” section on pages 8 and 9 and read the introduction. Invite a student to read aloud one of the “speak outs” to the group. Ask: What is your view on this opinion? Discuss. Continue reading and discussing each “speak out” opinion in a similar manner. Have students turn to “King Midas and the golden touch” on pages 10–13. Say: This story is a traditional tale from ancient Greece. It was first told long, long ago. It’s a story that has a message – something for people to learn a lesson from. After you read the story independently, talk to your partner about what you learned from it. Ask: How did King Midas’ view on treasure change? Why did it change? What message do you get from this story? Do you agree with this message? Discuss as a group. Use students’ ideas to create a group statement about the moral or lesson they got from the story.
Read the text Give each student a copy of PERSPECTIVES: What is Treasure? What Do You Value? Have them browse through the book. Have students turn to page 4, and read the introduction aloud to them. Ask: What do you think about these questions? Have students share their ideas with the group. Have students turn to “Treasure from the past” on pages 6 and 7. Read the introduction aloud to the students. Have students view the images. Ask: Do you think these things are treasure? If so, what makes them treasure? Have students talk with a partner and then share ideas as a group.
Respond to the text Say: We have started to gather new information about what treasure is. What different perspectives have you discovered? Use students’ ideas to create a concept map about treasure on a large chart. Have pairs of students revisit their graphic organizers. Say: Think about what you have read. Use this information to add to section two of your Forming Opinions charts. Collect students’ graphic organizers to revisit later.
Draw conclusions
Express opinions
Read the text
Setting the task
Ask: Can a treasure be a place? Have students talk with a partner about this. Have students turn to “National treasure” on pages 14 and 15. Say: Read and view this text with your partner. Ask: Does it make sense to you that the Grand Canyon is a treasure? Why? What other places could be called a treasure? Provide time for students to share their opinions. Ask: What new perspective does this text give you about what a treasure can be? Discuss, and use students’ ideas to add to the group concept map.
Students can choose one or both of the following options as a way to show their thinking or express their opinion.
Respond to the text Read out the following statements one at a time. Ask students to move to one side of the room if they agree with the statement and to the other side if they disagree. Discuss students’ choices and invite individual students to share the reasons for their opinion. Treasure is something expensive. / Treasure does not have to be an object. / Something that is a treasure to me, might be worth nothing to my friend. Have pairs of students revisit their graphic organizers. Say: Think about everything you now know about treasure and complete section three of your Forming Opinions charts.
Bring it all together Have students meet with their completed graphic organizers. Invite pairs of students to share their Forming Opinions charts at a group discussion. Discuss the various points of view and opinions that arise. During the discussion, encourage students to draw on information in the texts to back up their opinions.
Writing Have students respond by writing about their opinion. Say: Think about what you have learned about treasure and how you feel about this information. Present the Graphic Organizer: How to write about your opinion (see PERSPECTIVES: What is Treasure? What Do You Value?, page 16). Support students by guiding them through the steps involved. 1. Have students revisit the questions posed in the introduction on page 4. Ask: What is your opinion now about treasure? What is valuable to you? Have students discuss with a partner. 2. Model how to find further information about the topic, or, if appropriate, students could do independent research. 3. Say: Now that you have the information you need, you can write a plan. Use the graphic organizer to help you. 4. Have students publish their writing. Say: Think about the graphics or images you can include to support your written opinion.
Drawing Have students draw a picture of their treasure. Before deciding what to draw, have them talk with a partner about what they most value and what is precious to them. Have students in small groups take turns talking about their drawing. Encourage them to explain why their drawing represents their treasure.
Respond to the text Have students revisit their graphic organizers. Say: Think about what you have read. Use this information to add points to section two of your Forming Opinions charts. Collect students’ graphic organizers to revisit later.
Think tank If students are passionate about the issue, they may like to think about it further and take action. Have small groups of students reflect on what they have learned about treasure. Have each group create a poster that shows the different things that treasure can be.
Have the groups display their posters around the school to share their understandings with the school community.
Graphic Organizer: Forming Opinions
Lesson Plan
What is treasure?
Section 1: My initial opinion
Fluent Plus reading stage
What is treasure? A chest full of coins? Rare and expensive jewels?
Level N (30)
Section 2: Gathering information: What I have learned
Section 3: My informed opinion
PERSPECTIVES
Contents • Treasure from the past • Speak out! • King Midas and the golden touch • National treasure
Paired connected texts
Famous Finds recounts the incredible stories of Mary Anning’s fossil discoveries and Howard Carter’s discovery of Tutankhamen’s Tomb.
William decides to help his uncle discover Egyptian treasure. But things go wrong, and William gets trapped inside a tomb!
Content vocabulary coins diamonds expensive gems gold jewels museum national treasure past precious reward rich statues treasure value/able
Correlations with Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills Flying Start to Literacy Lesson Plan Perspectives What is Treasure? What Do You Value? © 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd. © 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd. This work is protected by copyright law, and under international copyright conventions, applicable in the jurisdictions in which it is published. The trademark “Flying Start to Literacy” and Star device is a registered trademark of EC Licensing Pty Ltd in the US. In addition to certain rights under applicable copyright law to copy parts of this work, the purchaser may make copies of those sections of this work displaying the footnote: “© 2020 EC Licensing Pty Ltd”, provided that: (a) the number of copies made does not exceed the number reasonably required by the purchaser for its teaching purposes; (b) those copies are only made by means of photocopying and are not further copied or stored or transmitted by any means; (c) those copies are not sold, hired, lent or offered for sale, hire or loan; and (d) every copy made clearly shows the footnote copyright notice. All other rights reserved.
Developed by Eleanor Curtain Publishing
okapi educational publishing
Text: Kerrie Shanahan Consultant: Linda Hoyt Designed by Derek Schneider Printed in China through Colorcraft Ltd, Hong Kong Distributed in the USA by Okapi Educational Publishing Inc. Phone: 866-652-7436 Fax: 800-481-5499 Email: info@myokapi.com www.myokapi.com www.flying-start-to-literacy.com
Reading 3(6) (H) Synthesize information to create new understanding. 3(7) (A) Describe personal connections to a variety of sources, including self-selected texts. 3(9) (E) Recognize characteristics and structures of argumentative text. 3(10) (A) Explain the author’s purpose and message within a text.
Writing 3(12) (C) Compose argumentative texts, including opinion essays, using genre characteristics and craft. Speaking and Listening 3(10) (B) Explain how the use of text structure contributes to the author’s purpose.