AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh | 15110016
PEOPLE LIVING IN URBAN AREAS
WORLD
< 30 %
1950
53.9 %
62%
2015 2035
DELHI
<4%
25.9 %
43.3 %
Source : https://population.un.org/wup/Publications/Files/WUP2018-Report.pdf
1950
2015 2035
TRADITIONAL VS VERTICAL
Why do we need vertical farming?
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
DELHI'S GROWTH LAND USE + OCCUPATION PATTERNS
Over the past several decades, the city has seen an immense loss in vegetation in conjunction with the growth of urban areas and agriculture. The latter of these two are very detrimental for pollution as they both are emission sources for gaseous and solid waste, as well as the fact that they both present an issue of chemical runoff which during the monsoon season can be very harmful to the Yamuna region. The raw data gathered alone spells a dangerous future for Delhi. If the process of urbanization continues the pattern of the last 25 years, The National Capital Territory will lose all the agricultural and forest areas by 2028. These dramatic changes, on such a small timescale of 25 years and the immediate projections, illustrate just how vital it is that this problem be addressed holistically by the correct authorities.
Delhi Rural populaƟon (Lacs) 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 2001
2011
Farmland under culƟvaƟon (hectares)
No. Of Delhi villages
60000
300
50000
250
40000
200
30000
150
20000
100
10000
50
0
0 2000
2016
1961
2011
Source : http://www.yamunariverproject.org/
Vertical farming
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
PROTOTYPE FOR INDOOR FARMING
AGRICULTURE: URBAN WHOLESALE MARKETS
Okla Mandi is th one of the biggest vegetable wholesale markets in Delhi. It was developed by DDA (Delhi Development Authority) and is called the "fruits and vegetable market sub yard•Okhla''. Farmers from all adjacent villages come here to sell their produce to the retailers and also to consumers. All the areas around Delhi get their supply of vegetables and fruits from Okhla Mandi, especially South Delhi, Ghasiabad, Noida and Gurgaon.
58% of Delhi’s waste directly dumped into river Source : Food Systems (Re-Centering Delhi Research Catalog) - The Yamuna River Project elhi R ese
Site and its neighbourhood
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
PERCEIVED BENEFITS OF VERTICAL FARMING S.No. Name
Locati Hei on ght
Type of Building
Products
Area
Technology
year Website
1.
The Plant Vertical Farm
Chicago, IL
Existing building in 19 century
Wide variety of edible crops includes an artisanal brewery, kombucha brewery, mushroom farm, and bakery, Tilapia
100,000 sq.ft
-Aquaponics systems and fish breeding areas - Hydroponic -Recycling waste to energy - Using biogas from an anaerobic digester -Natural sun energy
2013
www.plantchicag o.com
2.
Sky Greens Farms
Singapor 9 m e
New
leafy green vegetables
600 m
-Aeroponuic system -Low carbon hydraulic waterdriven -Natural sun energy
2009
www.skygreens.a ppsfly.com
3.
VertiCrop TM
Vancouv er, Canada
Rooftop of existing building
Leafy greens, micro greens, and strawberries
50*75 Sq.ft, 120 racks with 24 growing trays on each rack = 16-acre farm.
-Fully automated system - Closed loop conveyor hydroponic -Room temperature, lighting, fertilization, irrigation and recapturing of the water being used - Natural and artificial light
2009
www.verticrop.co m
4.
Republic of South Korea VF
South Korea
3 story
New
leafy green vegetables ,almost wheat, and corn
450 m²
-Renewable resources like geothermal and solar -Automated rack system - LED
2011
www.cityfarmer.in fo/
5.
Nuvege plant factory
Japan (Kyoto)
4 story
Leafy green vegetables
30,000 -Automated rack system horizontal sq.ft -LED grow lights 57,000 sq.ft of -Hydroponics vertical growing space
6.
Plantlab VF
Den Bosch, Holland
3 Existing story building under groun d
every imaginable crop, including beans, corn, cucumbers, tomatoes, and strawberries
7.
Vertical Harvest plans2
Jackson Wyomin g, USA
3 story
New
tomatoes, strawberries, lettuce, and micro greens
8.
Planned Vertical Farm
Linkopin g, Sweden
17 story
New
Asian leafy green vegetables
9.
Green Sense Farms
-First farm in : Portage, Indiana Shenzhe n, china
New
-Micro Greens -Baby Greens -Herbs -Lettuces
20,000 sq./ft
-Using stacking vertical towers 2014 http://www.gree -Using automated computer -2016 nsensefarms.com 2012 controls, which provide the precise amount of light, nutrients, water, temperature, and humidity - Minimize waste, and recycle water technique
10.
AeroFarms
Newark, New Jersey
New
250 different types of herbs and greens grow like kale, arugula, and mizuna.
20,000-sq/ft with 35 rows and 12 levels of vertically grown
-Without any soil, pesticides, or sunlight. - Crops sit on stacked trays outfitted - LED lights -Using Sensors that track the growing process. - Recycle water technique
3stor y
9m
4500 sq.ft. footprint into 18,000 sq.ft., or four times the growing area
www.nuvege.com
-Without the use of daylight - Advanced LED -Aeroponic and hydroponic
2011
www.plantlab.nl/
-Recirculating hydroponic methods - LED
2012
www.verticalharv estjackson.com/
-Aeroponic -Hydroponic -Using waste products in the process - Natural lighting
2012
www.plantagon.c om
http://aerofarms. com/
Source : Thesis Book - The Seed -Urban Vertical Farming
PERCEIVED BENEFITS OF VERTICAL FARMING #
Benefits
Environmental
Reduce food-miles (travel distances)
Social Improve air quality, health
Economical Reduce energy, packaging, fuel use
Reduce air pollution
1 Reduce water consumption for food production
Reduce surface water run-off
2
3
Recycle organic waste
4
Create local jobs
Reduce needed land fills
Reduce commuting time
Reduce fertilizers, herbicides and pesticides
5
Improve the environmental well- being
Make portable water available to more people
Reduce costs
Improve food quality, purify grey water to drinking water
Turn waste into asset
Create a local community of workers and social network with farmers
Benefit local people economically
More control of food safety Reduce costs
Reduce redundant, repetitive work
6
Improve productivity
7
Avoid crop losses due to floods, droughts, hurricane, over exposure to sun, and seasonal changes
Needs less space
Offer greater yields
Improve food security
8
Control product / produce regardless to seasons
Avoid economics losses
Reduce environmental damage
Increase accessibility year- round
Stimulate economic activities year-round
Year-round production
Reduce fossil fuel use
9
10
11
Use renewable energy
Improve air quality
Increase bio- diversity Bring nature closer to city
Promote high-tech and green industry
Improve health, reduce stress and improve welfare
Improve environments Encourage higher education and generated skills
Reduce costs
Create jobs in the city
Provide new jobs in engineering, biochemistry, biotechnology, construction and maintenance, R&D
12
13
Reduce the activities of traditional farming
Repurpose dilapidated buildings
Vertical farming
Preserve and restore natural ecosystem
Improve health
Enhance the environment
Create opportunities for social interaction
Save money required to correct environmental damage
Revive economy
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
CULTURE ROOM
The following steps are taken by workers entering the culture room: (1) enter the changing/locker room in the operation room, (2) take off all clothing, (3) take a hot water shower or air shower for the whole body including hair/head washing, (4) put on clean underwear, overalls, cap, mask, and gloves, (5) wash the hands while wearing the gloves using a disinfectant for sterilization, (6) put on clean boots and sterilize the boot soles, (7) take an air shower again, and (8) enter the culture room.
“CLOSED-LOOP
Seeding for germination
Trimming damaged leaves
weighing and packaging
Shipping
Growing germinated seedings in light
Harvesting/removing roots
Labeling backs
cooling
AGRICULTURAL”
“Closed-loop agricultural” ecosystems intend to mimic natural ecosystems that treat waste as a resource. Similar to aquaponics, the waste of one part of the system becomes the nutrients for the other. The closed-loop system recycles and reuses nearly every element of the farming process—dirty water, sewage, and nutrients. Food waste can also be converted to compost. In a closed-loop system, everything remains in the system, leading to a zero-waste outcome. ANAEROBIC
1st transplanting
2nd transplanting
Packaging
Labeling boxes
A typical flow of operations in the plant production process focusing on the movements of plants. COMPONENTS OF A VERTICAL FARM
Vertical Farms can be very diverse, both structurally and technologically. Some farms rely solely on artificial lighting for plant growth, whereas others grow plants vertically, still utilizing some of the sun’s light. Also, plants can either be grown in soil (potted) or using hydroponic methods, which are much more common. Usually, a commercial Vertical Farm relies on an artificial, warehouse-like structure, thermally insulated, in which ventilation is kept at a minimum, and artificial light is used as the sole light source for plant growth [9]. In such Vertical Farms, the environment for plant growth can be controlled as precisely as desired, regardless of the outside weather. In addition to the recirculating nutrient solution in a hydroponic or aeroponic system, the water transpired by plants can be condensed and collected at the cooling panel of the air conditioners and then recycled for irrigation.
DIGESTER
“Closed-loop agricultural” ecosystems intend to mimic natural ecosystems that treat waste as a resource. Similar to aquaponics, the waste of one part of the system becomes the nutrients for the other. The closed-loop system recycles and reuses nearly every element of the farming process—dirty water, sewage, and nutrients. Food waste can also be converted to compost. In a closed-loop system, everything remains in the system, leading to a zero-waste outcome.
structure and growing system
NUTRIENT FILM TECHNIQUE (NFT)
DEEP FLOW TECHNIQUE (DFT)
In the Nutrient Film Technique (NFT), a thin film of water continuously flows through the pipe/gutter, so it is always in contact with the roots. This ensures constant availability of nutrients to the plants. NFT also supplies ample oxygen to the plants, since the roots are exposed above the thin film. This system requires the nutrient solution to be continuously in circulation, which results in no stagnant water in any point of the system.
Deep Flow Technique (or Deep Water Culture), as opposed to NFT, always has some amount of nutrient solution at some depth. More nutrient is periodically pumped in and through the overflow pipe and the excess nutrient solution goes back to the reservoir and is recycled. Even when there is a power outage, or other problem preventing the pump operating properly, there is always some water to keep the plants alive. This system allows more control over water temperature when compared to N F T .
ECOSYSTEMS
Environmental control units
Air conditioning
Vertical farm components
Nutrient supply & control
CO2 supply unit
Lighting
VERTICAL FARMING SPATIAL DESIGN
Schematic diagrams of DFT (left) and NFT (right) hydroponic systems
Source : GROWING POWER VERTICAL FARM - Building Systems Integration Structural Systems
Components of vertical farming
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
PLANTS SUITED AND UNSUITED TO PFALS
Plants suited to PFALs for commercial production have the following characteristics: (1) short in height (about 30 cm or less) to be adapted to multiple cultivation racks with a vertical distance between the culture beds of 40–50 cm; (2) fast growing (harvestable 10–30 days after transplanting); (3) growing well under low light intensity and at high planting density; (4) high-value product if fresh, clean, tasty, nutritious, and pesticide-free; (5) the product value can be effectively improved by environmental control; (6) about 85% in fresh weight of the plant can be sold as produce (e.g., root weight ratio of leaf lettuce should be lower than 10–15%) (7) any kind of transplant Plants suited to greenhouses using sunlight rather than PFALs for improved quality and yield include: (1) fruit-vegetables such as tomatoes, green peppers, and cucumbers that contain large amounts of functional components;(2) berries such as strawberries and blueberries; (3) high-end flowers such as Phalaenopsis, dwarf loquats; (4) mangoes and grapes, etc. for growing in containers with trickle irrigation; and (5) nonwoody or annual medicinal plants such as Angelica, medicinal dwarf Dendrobium, Plants that are not suitable to PFAL production are staple crops used primarily as a source of calories (carbohydrates, protein, and fats) for people and livestock, such as rice, wheat, corn, and potatoes, plants such as sugarcane and rapeseed used primarily as a fuel (energy) source, larger fruit trees, and trees used for timber such as cedar and pine, and others including daikon, burdock, and lotus. These plants require large areas for growth and have a harvest cycle of several months to ten or more years, but they have a low ratio of value (price) to mass.
Lolla Rosa lettuce
Broccoli Crop
Bell pepper
Oregano
Capsicum
Strawberry
Romaine lettuce
Spinach
Shoot zone height (m)
Root zone height (m)
Fresh edible biomass Fresh inedible biomass (g/sqm-day) (g/sqm-day)
Lettuce
0.25
0.15
131.25
7.30
Cabbage
0.35
0.15
75.78
6.74
Spinach
0.25
0.15
72.97
7.30
Carrots
0.25
0.30
74.83
59.87
Radish
0.20
0.30
91.67
55.00
Tomatoes
0.40
0.20
173.76
127.43
Peppers
0.40
0.20
148.94
127.43
Potatoes
0.65
0.40
105.30
90.25
Peas
0.50
0.20
12.20
161.00
Strawberry
0.25
0.15
77.88
144.46
Plants suitable for vertical farming
Iceberg lettuce
Arungla
Basil
Coriander
Cucumber
Mint
Tomatoes
Crop
Soil system (lb)
Hydroponics system (lb)
Potatoes
16,000
1,40,000
Lettuce
9,000
21,000
Comparative yields per acre crop
Tomatoes
10,000-20,000
1,20,000-6,00,000
Cucumbers
7,000
28,000
2-4 HOURS lettuce spinach radish carrots
4-6 HOURS
broccoli cabbage cauliower kale brussel sprouts basil mint
6 + HOURS eggplant corn tomato beans peas squash melon potatoes cucumbers herbs chives bell pepper
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
TYPICAL PRODUCTION ROOM
ANAEROBIC DIGESTER
An anaerobic digester is a biogas recovery system that converts food waste into biogas to produce power and heat.At the heart of the system is an anaerobic digester that turns organic materials into biogas, which is piped into turbine generator to make electricity for plant grow light. Waste from the fish feeds the plants and the plants clean the water for the fish. Sludge from the digester that becomes algae duckweed also feeds the fish. Along electricity, the turbine makes steam which is piped to the commercial kitchen and the entire building for heating and cooling.
Waste products
Biomass gasifier
food waste
Production of ‘producer’s gas’
possible output
H2 High pressure steam
Steam turbine CO CH4
combustible waste
Tri generation plant office waste
Biogas cogeneration plant
HEAT agricultural waste
By products of combustion
WATER PURIFICATION
waste ash to be reused as farm fertiliser
LIGHT SOURCE AND LIGHTING SYSTEM DESIGN
Only 37 % of the energy in sunlight is within the wave length (colour) useful for photosynthesis, while 62 % is infrared (Thermal energy) and the remaining 0.6 % is ultraviolet. Photosynthesis in the plan t leaf is powered by 1% of the sunlight that falls on the plant, 10 % of the sunlight is elected and 10 % passes through the leaf. The leaf will retain 80% which is used for transportation. Some of the light is re-radiated, while the fraction that remains is used for building food from the, minerals and water. • WHITE COLOUR It is actually a combination of all colours of light Red + Green +Blue (and all colours in between) • BLUE LIGHT Photosynthesis occurs, tips grow toward light, hormones trigger growth, and dormancy is inhibited. Metal Halide lamps are high in blue light making them good for leafy plants. • GREEN LIGHT Most of this colour light is reflected, that is why plants appear green, and however some green light is required for growth. Most HID lamps do not emit much green light. • RED LIGHT Photosynthesis occurs, seed germination aided, pigments formed, flowering aided, dormancy included. High pressure sodium bulbs emit red light and are generally better for flowering and fruiting plants. • FAR-RED LIGHT Speed up some full sun plants, reverses some red light effects. HID lighting usually doesn't emit far-red except in the case of some High and low pressure sodium bulbs, more so in the form of heart rather than photosynthetic light.
FOUR CHLOROPHYLL ABSORPTION PEAKS
There are four chlorophyll absorption peaks and led grow lights use four different types of LEDs to hit all four peaks (two red and two blue). Early LED grow lamps used hundreds of 1 or 2 watt and were not effective replacements for hid lamps. Newer advanced LED grow lamps use automotive grade 6 watt LEDs and have
LIGHT SYSTEM NATURAL LIGHTING SYSTEM A network of reflectors on every floor to utilize maximum sunlight during day time and also can be used for light during night by using led. Network of side reflector consist of reflecting panels placed around periphery ofthe building. At the ceiling of each floor a network of concave shaped reflectors are arranged so as to reflect the rays received by the side reflectors to the plants.
ARTIFICIAL LIGHTING SYSTEM
Incandascent grow lights Incandescent grow lights have a red-yellowish tone and low color temperature (approx. 2700 k). They are used to highlight indoor plant groupings and not as a true plant growing' light. Incandescent growing lamps have an average life span of 750 hours.
Fluorescent tube lghts These are available in either cool white colours (producing light in the blue range) or warm white colours (producing more light in the red range). Ideally, use one "cool" bulb and one "warm' bulb to provide the most natural spectrum of light. The fluorescent tubes are usually rated to last up to 4 years but lose 85% of their intensity before they bum out. For plants that require a maximum amount of light intensity, replace bulbs about 70 percent of the way through their rated life.
LED Fixture LED light has been used as the source of artificial light, originally modified to emit light with a wavelength that are suitable for plant. LEDs also provide the opportunity to adjust the ratio of red (R) and far-red (FR) light for desired plant responses, which can promote stem elongation in many plant species. Blue LED light can help to shorten the plant height, which can facilitate transport when needed. LEDs are low in radiant heat and can therefore be placed near the growing plant, thus more suitable for vertical farms with narrow height shelves.
Source : Kozai, Toyoki_ Niu, Genhua_ Takagaki, Michiko - Plant factory _ an indoor vertical farming system for efficient quality food production (2016, Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier) Mechanical systems in vertical farming
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
Aeroponics Aeroponics The principle of aeroponics is to grow plants suspended in a closed or semi-closed environment by spraying the plant's dangling roots and lower stem with an atomized or sprayed, nutrient-rich water solution. The leaves and crown, extend above. The roots of the plant are separated by the plant sup-port structure. Often, closed-cell foam is compressed around the lower stem and inserted into an opening in the aeroponic chamber, which decreases labor and expense; for lamer plants, trel-lisinc is used to suspend the weight of vegetation and fruit.
Trellis The A-frame 'trellis" design was the 11 rst commercially successful hy-droponic system to exhibit a vertical orientation. Varieties of this design consist of pipes configured either vertically or horizontally to form a triangular extrusion of its footprint, thus Increasing the available growing surface without meaningfully reducing sunlight access. 1 he primary advantage of the A-frame design is its simplicity, as it achieves a high degree of space effi dewy while utilizing technology that has been standard In the hydroponic industry for decades.
Cocoponics Dry coconut strands are very rich in nutrients. Cocoponics is a simple methodology of growing plants in coir. The plant seeds are embedded into the a pot of full of coir and is water everyday for its growth,
IKEA Innovation spherical garden Developed by the IKEA innovation lab Space10 along-side architects sine lindholm and mads-ulrik husum, the spherical "Growroom" is a DIY garden structure intended to help people "grow their own food much more locally in a beautiful and sustainable way." Designed for communities to affordably start their own urban gardens, the Growroom takes up only 2.8 x 2.5 meters of space, using a spherical shape that allows plants to receive ample light within a vertical setup. It is designed to support our everyday sense of well being in the cities by creating a small oasis or 'pause'-architecture in
Anaerobic Digestor Anaerobic digestion is a collection of processes by which microorgan-isms break down biodegradable material in the absence of oxygen.The process is used for industrial or domestic purposes to manage waste or to produce power. Its a closed loop system in terms of vertical farming. (as shown in the diagram) Incorporating modern waste management strategies into the vertical farm model works without the need for new technologies to come to the rescue. It must be emphasised that urbansustainability will be only realised through the valuing of waste as a commodity.
Aquaponics Aquaponics Aquaponics refers to any system that combines conventional aquaculture (raising aquatic animals such as snails, fish, crayfish or prawns in tanks) with hydroponics (cultivating plants in water) in a symbiotic environment. In an aquaponic system, water from an aquaculture system is fed to a hydroponic system where the by-products are broken down by nitrifying bacteria initially into nitrites and subsequent-ly into nitrates, which are utilized by the plants as nutrients, and the water is then recirculated back to the aquaculture system.
Hydroponics Hydroponics Hydroponics is a subset of hydro culture, the method of grow-ing plants without soil, using mineral nutrient solutions in a water solvent. Terrestrial plants may be grown with only their roots exposed to the mineral solution, or the roots may be supported by an inert medium, such as perlite or gravel. The nutrients in hydroponics can be from fish waste, duck manure, or normal nutrie n t s .
Stacked beds The design is merely a stacking of the standard in-line pipe beds that continue to be the system of choice for commercial hydroponic farms. Much like the ramification of stratifying floors in a vertical farm, the de-sign's stacked configuration doesn't allow sunlight to penetrate each layer, making artificial lighting a necessity. The best commercial example of the stacked bed approach is the de-sign used by TerraSphere Systems, which has implemented systems with five tiers of growing surface within a 3 metre fl oor to ceiling height.
Stacked drums Though it is the least common commercial hydroponic system listed here, the drum design likely offers the most promise for the future of indoor agriculture. It consists of growing plants within the interior of a drum structure positioned around a central artificial light source, resulting in extraordinarily low space and energy use per unit of production. Today the most popular variant is produced by Omega Garden'" of Victoria, B.C., which features a mechanism that rotates the drum through a tray containing the nutrient solution.
Water system 1. rain water collection 2. cistern 3. purification filter 4. potable water 5. grey / black water 6. on site wastewater treatment 7. output water to wetland system 8. rain water for urban farm 9. on-site infiltration 10. nutrient supply for growing systems 11. hydroponic, aeroponic growing facility
References : A Review of Vertical Farming Technology: A Guide for Implementation of Building Integrated Agriculture in Cities
Source : https://issuu.com/kallolshah/docs/kallol_shah_vertigrow
UP,Techniques UP ofAND AWAY! THE ECONOMICS OF VERTICAL FARMING Vertical farming AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
EV panels for solar energy collection
Vertical convenyance for crops
geothermal heat pumps infrastructure mechanical lab
seed storage
electric generator
temp
Growing floors
light
Nursery for selection and germination of seeds
nutrient solutions
climate control monitoring center
air lock
dehumidificahumidity tion
quality control lab
restaurant
lobby
Production spaces
rainwater collection
locker rooms
break rooms
loading area for receiving and distribution
cafe
bathrooms
offices for management
harvesting
waste water treatment
anaerobic digesters for organic matter
Food / Farmer’s market
Distribution spaces/ retail
Eco education/exhibition center
Community garden for traditional crops
Education/ System exhibition monitoring center
Workforce/- Infrastruccontrol ture/technolrooms ogy Integration
5 PRINCIPLES TO CONSIDER IN A VERTICAL FARM
PLACEMENT Choice of placement determines the level of proximity to plants. SIZE The maximum height of the plant will affect the size of the planter. SCALE Intensity of production will likely determine how extensive the planting provision will be. SPECIES Type of plant may require more environmental control and affect how much exposure it will receive.
Design Program
PURPOSE Production purpose will determine the auxiliary needs. STAKEHOLDERS Customers. Suppliers. Beneficiaries. Staff. Competitors. SERVICES Delivery routes and subsidiary services provided or supplied need to be considered SUPPLIES Necessary stock and equipment for purpose of production
INTEGRATION Level of Integration will determined the flexibility and robustness of the system. MODULAR Suitable for retrofitting and upgrading but limited by module and connection. INTEGRATED Robust and durable system but likely to require costly upgrades and inflexible. HYBRID Benefits of both systems but may not be as flexible and require custom maintenance.
MEDIUM Soil based, water based. air based. SOIL Soil control measures required Prone to bacterial infection. SLURRY Water tight features and water management on top of normal irrigation. SUSPENDED Hanging infrastructure required with custom irrigation.
SCALE Business development and growth needs to be factored in. PHYSICAL New facilities are necessary to manage. handle and certify the food produced. FINANCING New opportunities for business investors will kick-start the urban agribusiness.. CONSULTANTS Intermediary consultants can bring the different parties together.
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
Babool Kalkaji Metro Station
Okhla Railway Station
Pipal
Kaner
Eucalyptus
Neem
Banyan
Okhla Railway Station
N
N
Vehicular Pedestrian
Pedestrian and Vehicular flow
There has been a total of 4 Entrance/Exit gates on the site. 1 is officially used for Entry and there is APMC office where they check everything. The exit is from other 3 sites out of that only 2 are majorly used. There aren’t any parking facility within the site.
N
Site has more concrete character than natural. There isn’t much vegetation on site and most of the site is paved with concrete road.
N
Sunpath and wind direction
In summer there is sunlight on the site from 7 Am untill 7 PM and in winters from 9 AM to 5.30 PM. Though the site gets wind from all 4 sides but major part of wind is coming from west side.
N
Footfall on the site
It is one of the most crowded mandi in Delhi. Thousands of customers used to come here to buy fresh vegetables. Okhla mandi works throughout the day from auctions starting around 2am everyday to selling vegetables until night. Lot of muslim population come to okhla mandi for non-veg consumption.
N
Drainage and Electric lines
Natural slope on the site is towards North-East having a level drop of around 1 m. However due to poor infrastructure there is blockage of water on the site resulting in filthy smell. Electric lines runs along North-East part of the site.
Site Analysis
Vegetation on the site
Site for the project
There are some existing buildings on the site but they are not suited to current requirements . I will be retaining APMC office, Existing toilets, Substation.
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
Site connectivity 1. Lotus Temple 2. NSIC Okhla 3. Kalkaji Metro Station 4. Nehru Place Metro station 5. Sukhdev Vihar Metro Station 6. Kasturba Balika Vidyalaya 7. NSIC Estate 8. Okhla Industrial Area 9. Sarai Jullena Village 10. ISKCON Temple Delhi 11. Amrit Puri 12. East of Kailash 13. Sri Niwaspuri 14. Sri Niwaspuri Extension 15. Friends colony
13 15
12
14 6
5
S W O T
11
10
9
2
1
8
4 7
3
Site and its neighbourhood
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
Accessible from the main road Prime location and urban level connect Catering to large number of poulation(Economic viability) Deals with very soul of Indian economy
High traffic density Improper drainage Improper ventillation Roadside encroachments No parking facility Poor waste management/too much trash on the site Existing built structures does not evolve with new requirements
Great project to serve local residents Farming within the city City needs a revolution in farming A step towards saving water Creating strong ecological environment(reducing urban heat island) Food can be seen as a tourism element Integration of Food+culture+society
Lack of awareness about vertical farming within the Indian population Dealing with the unskilled labour Government policies
Okhla Mandi work flow analysis The vehicles enter the mandis with the permission of the APMC and weight of each vehicle is checked Once the vehicles are checked, the vehicles then go their respective commission agents Now the commission agents come together for the auction process at 2AM in the morning. Here each product is auctioned depending on the quality of the product . There are two ways in which a product is brought inside the Mandi 1) Jute bags 2) Karats The commission agent just acts as a mediator between the farmers and the retailers, once the retailer buys the product he/she has to pay a commission of 6% to the commission agents. Agents in turn pay 1% to APMC.
Site and its neighbourhood
Persisting Problems Unhygienic conditions Waste from rotten vegetables has not been cleared up regularly Traffic Congestion and Parking lots issues. Disability Infrastructure No Provisions of Vehicular and Pedestrian Traffic – Secondary Roads in Okhla mandi are chaotic and congested at peak hours due to the departure time of SMV’s for supplying of goods as there are no segregated lanes for pedestrian/SMV’s, cyclist. Encroachment- Due to unsignalized junction for SMV’s and the row is mostly encroached upon by on-street parking and encroachments by shops. Absence of hawker zone or street vendors place will lead to massive congestion in the Mandis at peak hours
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
I call it intelligent living tower where the core of building is vertical farm resembles the function of brain in human body. It is connected using conveyer belts whose wheels represent shops which drives the economy of the farm and the spine of the brain is connected to the city where it is delivering the healthy vegetable in every corner. This way we are rethinking by integrating food + culture + economy. We are minimazing the food travel distance saving energy cost.
The design of the proposed building aims to provide the platform for research, education and implementation that is essential for the development of resilient urban agriculture. Reintroduction of urban food networks offer unique spatial, social and environmental opportunities for architects. These opportunities will be explored throughout the dissertation to inform a design intervention capable of evolving with the state-of-the-art of agritecture.
FORM MIMICS NATURE Form follows function, and building function can be derived from natural processes. Industrial ecology mimics natural processes within the food production system. For the purpose of this dissertation, it can be derived that form should follow the food production system. People, food and architecture can coexist as a living machine. It should be noted that pure scientific application of natural principles will not spontaneously result in good architecture. Other design principles, as explored through this thesis, will also be incorporated to produce a balanced design outcome.
Design concept
• A building should be integrated with its site. • A building should reflect natural simplicity and unity through form and composition that result from a holistic integration of material, structure, and purpose. • Materials should be selected according to and reflect structural and aesthetic function.
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
EV panels for solar energy collection
Vertical convenyance for crops
geothermal heat pumps infrastructure mechanical lab
seed storage
electric generator
temp
Growing floors
light
Nursery for selection and germination of seeds
nutrient solutions
climate control monitoring center
air lock
dehumidificahumidity tion
quality control lab offices for management
rainwater collection
locker rooms
break rooms
loading area for receiving and distribution
restaurant
Eco education/exhibition center
lobby
Production spaces
waste water treatment
bathrooms
harvesting
cafe
anaerobic digesters for organic matter
Food / Farmer’s market
Community garden for traditional crops
Distribution spaces/ retail
Education/ System exhibition monitoring center
Workforce/- Infrastructure/techcontrol nology Integration rooms Public toilets
Reception office
Shops(open) Waiting Hall
Reception Entrance lobby
Security
Entrance
Entrance
Toilets
Private Offices
Service entrance
Accounts section
Administration
Managers room Service core
Storage
Auction halls
Core
Cafes Rear Entrance
Shop owner’s toilet
Shops (built)
Office
Loading/unloading
Cold storage
Receiving Area
Godown Vendor’s offices
Restaurants
Pantry
Core
Loading/ Unloading
Maintain ence room Service core
Packaging
Conference room
Recycling room
Operation Core
Locker rooms Service core
Shipping products room
Air management/thermal Changing storage room Hot NDS Room air/water shower
Office
Production room
Storage
Meeting room
Airlock Seed germination room
Cultivation rooms
Workshop Exhibition
Seminar room
Core
Training centre
Core Nursery
Library
Spatial Proximity
Open terraces
Service Core
Quality control labs
Guest rooms Core
Lab of residue Vegetation management
Terrace farming
Hydroponic research labs
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016
Service corridor for disposal of garbage & movement of goods, facility core for parking & shops for
Segregation of different activities
Physical planning Closed loop water management system and solar power standby system
Visual connectivity to public realm
Not to disturb regional traffic system, separate roads for heavy and light vehicles Waste management system
Create healthy living public spaces
Storage & auction halls
Water collection / solar panels
Production areas
Production areas
Private
Production areas
Offices/conferences/labs
Terrace farming
Terrace farming
Vendor’s offices
Sabji mandi
Sabji mandi/ground farming
Semi public
Exhibitions/Nursery/workshop
Restaurants/cafes
Public
Administration
Shops
Sabji mandi
Civic Plaza
Parking
Site Zoning
AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT IN URBAN METROPOLIS OF DELHI
B.Arch Thesis 2019-20 Nirbhay Singh 15110016