Inside: the annual Perdeby Gaming Supplement
Perdeby
Tuks se amptelike studentekoerant / Official Tuks student newspaper / Kuranta ya baithuti ya semmušo ya Tuks
19 October 2015
year77issue18
IMB highlights discrepancies in 2015 SRC election CHAD JOHNSTON AND MARKO SVICEVIC On 2 October the Independent Monitoring Body (IMB) declared that the recent Student Representative Council (SRC) elections were “substantially free and fair” and that all irregularities on voting procedures and the counting of votes were resolved. However, they ruled that a re-election must be held for the portfolio of president and deputy president. The IMB met over a period of just over one month to consider and address all processes, complaints and irregularities regarding the
DATE 15/10/2015
2015 SRC elections and highlighted several discrepancies which occurred throughout the election period in a report that was published. Hate speech allegations The IMB addressed hate speech allegations brought forward by Daso and Afriforum. The complainants alleged that certain SRC candidates had uttered statements such as “whites have no rights in Africa” and “Afrikaans students must leave” during an SRC circus session and a Black Thursday society event, respectively. The IMB stated that “the words [that were] complained of probably constitute hate speech in terms of section 10 of the Promotion
ELECTION SCHEDULE Announcement at the Piazza Opening of Nominations
BY IEFSA
Closing of Nominations 19/10/2015
20/10/2015 20/10/2015
Verification of submitted nominations Indaba on candidates Publication of Provisional Candidate list
TIME 13h00 12h00
IEFSA
IEFSA
13h0017h00 09h00 12h00
Opening of Objections to candidate list
IEFSA
12h00
Closing of Objections to candidate list
12h00
Compulsory Stakeholder Meeting
IEFSA / IMB
21/10/2015
Publication of the final candidates \ nomination list
IEFSA /IMB
13h00
21/10/2015
Official Campaigning period starts
IEFSA
14h00
22/10/2015
Training of Electoral Staff
DSA/ IEFSA
27/10/2015
End of Official Campaign period
DSA / IEFSA
12h00 midnight
28/10/2015
Election day
IEFSA
07am07pm
29/10/2015
Publication of Provisional election results
IEFSA/ IMB
09h00
29/10/2015
Opening of Objections to provisional results
IEFSA/ IMB
12h00
30/10/2015
Closing of Objections to provisional results
IEFSA/ IMB
12h00
30/10/2015
IMB Meeting to declare elections
IEFSA/ IMB
13h00
30/10/2015
Publication of Final election results
IEFSA/ IMB
15h00
21/10/2015
13h00
of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000” and that it would “arguably be hurtful to most reasonable members of the white and Afrikaans-speaking community”, respectively. Citing a lack of evidence to suggest that the words complained of were in fact uttered by SRC candidates for the election, the IMB dismissed both complaints. Election regulation violations The IMB noted with some concern several election regulation transgressions, including poster regulation violations, society activities relating to promoting candidates, and the distribution of “freebies” by political parties. The IMB dismissed most of these complaints but noted that, in future, the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC) and Department of Student Affairs (DSA) “should regulate society activity more rigorously during the campaigning period”. Vote count irregularities and KPMG audit With regard to complaints by Sasco and the EFFSC-UP that the vote count and voters’ roll did not correspond (particularly at the IT voting station), the IMB ruled that the number of votes cast and number of people per voter roll are not compared to determine if reconciliation is possible. Instead, the number of clean ballot papers were counted before voting took place and were then compared to the number of total used and unused ballot papers after voting at each particular voting station. The IMB further added that students who were not listed in the voters roll were allowed to vote, provided they had a dated proof of registration with identification. They noted, however, that because the students’ details were not recorded, a comparison between the number of votes and the voters’ roll could not be done. Unsealed ballot-boxes On the matter of unsealed ballotboxes, the IMB stated that all votes contained in the ballot boxes had already been counted and the result slips were signed off by all party agents. Lack of stickers from Tuks Toonbank for posters A member of Sasco lodged a complaint that Tuks Toonbank had an insufficient number of stickers in stock that needed to be stuck onto approved election posters. In response, the DSA stated that they did
not make provision for societies that printed their own posters. As a result, the DSA only provided for 40 posters and poster stickers per candidate, as required by the Constitution for Student Governance (CSG).
“The IMB ruled that a re-election must be held for the portfolio of president and deputy president.” After poster approvals, Afriforum had brought 400 pre-printed posters to Toonbank. According to the DSA, they did not want to prevent Afriforum from putting up their posters, and so alternative plans were made. The IMB noted its displeasure at the lack of “appropriate planning of the DSA and IEC in that insufficient stickers for election posters were available”. KPMG audit report The KPMG audit report, among other things, highlighted the differences in vote counts by the IEC and KPMG. The following differences in the vote count were found with regard to each SRC portfolio. • President and deputy-president: 68 vote difference. • Secretary and deputy-secretary: 32 vote difference. • Treasurer: 111 vote difference. • Facilities, safety and security: 139 votes difference. • Marketing, media and communications: 132 vote difference. • Study finance: 72 vote difference. • Postgraduate and international students: 98 vote difference. • Societies: 47 vote difference. • Transformation and student success: 49 vote difference. • Day and external students: 12 vote difference. The highest difference in the vote counts occurred with the Treasurer portfolio for Nomtha Gobe (96 votes), the facilities, safety and security portfolio for Brian Nkala (95 vote difference), and the postgraduate and international students portfolio for Benjamin Ho (91 vote difference). The IMB declared that, despite several small differences in the vote counts, the results of the SRC 2015 election remained unchanged. Continued on page 3...
cutting edge student living
A look at UP’s Swaziland international students Benele Dlamini - pg. 7
Zambia Mumbi Muk
Second-year BA Law student originally from Swaziland.
Second-year BCom Marketi from Zambia.
“Swaziland is known for being the last absolute monarchy in the world. I miss the love of culture that the Swazi people show with pride, along with an appreciation of their roots and identity.”
He says that the biggest ste faces is that he was from Ni He added that his favourite meal is “Kapenta”, which is a sardine eaten with Nshima
Mozambique Nico Niehaus
Namibia Logino Giovan
Second year BEng Mechanical Engineering student from Mozambique. His favourite Mozambiquan phrase is “maningue nice”. He explained it as what Mozambiquans say to describe something pleasant. Where some South Africans may say “lekker”, Mozambiquans say “maningue nice”.
First-year LLB student from He shared some interesting home country.
“Namibia is the second leas populated country on Earth Mongolia, and is roughly ha Alaska.”
Greece Thalia Avvakoumides
France Alexandre Larr
Sport supports Cansa Second-year BA Political Sciences Second-year BA Internationa 13 from France. He says student from Greece. She describes - pg.student some of the things students can do in Greece.
favourite [French] food is fon means melted.
“Every student will love island hopping, beach parties and even skinny dipping!”
“It is a traditional dish made cheese from Savoie, an Alpin France, and reminds me of w mountains and skiing holida
South Korea
Leanne Jeon
First-year BCom Accounting Sciences student from South Korea.
“In South Korea, fast and free Wi-Fi is available everywhere, and all
Bittereinder discuss their new album - pg. 10
EU migrant crisis explained
- pg. 6
0861 MIDCITY www.midcity.co.za