Wp u 20111001

Page 1

34567 5 ) ) 6>55

˛ ˚ ˚

) ˝ % ˚ ˝˙˚ • ˚

34567

S`*3 V*3/\-\ ,m]daV*B 86 5:6 >>> 5<< )˛%

OCTOBER 1, 2011

˚ & ˝ w b\`\31,*q +*jZqx a\ab\Sb , ]`\aW*,W1ZSS 1-\,m \-* P 1`f\,Z\-\ `*,Sb1Wq a1O W1ZZ\yD /`1,ZS1 ,`1Y1Z* ab\`\31,m1 +*jZS ]\4,\WqWS Wp/qY Z*+Wp/*bn 4* ]`\Saf\/qkSYD \/\+ZmY \+`*4\Y ob\b 3d`Z*W ]\V*4m,*1bE V*V\1 4Z*h1ZS1 YS`\,m1 a\+mbSq SY1pb , a,1b1 +S+W1yaVSf ]`\`\h1ab,D Z db1j*1b Wp/1y +W*-\y ,1abnp \ b\YE hb\ *`ab,\ \-* P `1*WnZ\1 ]`*,Sb1Wnab,\ Z* Z1+1 P ,aV\`1 ]\V\ZhSb a\ 4W\Y S ,aq 41YWq ab*Z1b `*1YD 'b\b 3d`Z*W dV`1]Wq1b ,1`d , Sada* `Sab*E V\b\`my dY1`E hb\O +m Ym Y\-WS \+`1abS ,1hZdp 3S4ZnE S V\b\`my a1yh*a ]`*,Sb V*V *`n \3n1-\ *`ab,*D ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m S4/*pb ob\b 3d`Z*W Z1]`1`m,Z\ a 5<;= -\/*D Z ]\WSbSh1aVS Z1yb`*W1Z S ]\WZ\abnp \aZ\,*Z Z* S+WSSD

1a]W*bZ\D 4/*ZS1 w b\`\31,\y +*jZSx P h*abn ,a1YS`Z\y +S+W1yaV\y ]`\a,1bSb1WnZ\y /1qb1WnZ\abSE V\b\`*q ]\//1`3S,*1baq /\+`\,\WnZmYS ]\31`b,\,*O ZSqYSD ˚aWS Z1 dV*4*Z\ SZ*h1E +S+W1yaVS1 gSb*bm ,4qbm S4 w ,qk1ZZ\-\ Sa*ZSq P 1`1,\/* Z\,\-\ YS`*xD

˚ ˚

7 *Y V\-/*OZS+d/n W-*WSH 8 \- Z1]\abS3SYD `*,/* WS ob\H

; \- Z1a]`*,1/WS,D `*,/* WS ob\H

9 \- +14`*4WSh1Z V Wp/qYD `*,/* WS ob\H

< \- ]`SZSY*1b ,a1fE Vb\ SaV`1ZZ1 ,1`SbD `*,/* WS ob\H

: \- V*`*1b Wp/1yD `*,/* WS ob\H

= abSZ* Y\31b S4Y1ZSbn ,*jd 3S4Zn

) %˚

&

5>

˛Z*1b1 WS ,mH

55

Sb*b1WS SZb1`1adpbaq

56

S+WSq Y1Zq1b 3S4Zn

59

`S+WS3*yb1an V \-dD

m Y\31b1 Z*ybS w4Z*ZS1 \ \-1x

5:

4dh*yb1 W\,\ \-*D *V a/1W*bn a1Ynp ah*abWS,\yH

5<

\/`*3*yb1 Sf ,1`1D Z* ,abd]SW*an 4* \3Sy Z*`\/

68

+dh*yb1 a,\Sf /1b1yD \-/* Ym /\W3Zm +\/`ab,\,*bn

˝˚ ˚ ˚ 58 w 1]\,SZ\,1ZS1E V\b\`\1 ,m4m,*1b d,*31ZS1x

&

6:

\-/* +mW `*4`dj1Z /`1,ZSy 1`da*WSYH *V\1 ob\ SY11b 4Z*h1ZS1D h1Y -\,\`qb e*Vbm

˙ O ˙&

W-*WSH hb\ `*ZSb b*V 31 +\WnZ\E V*V W\3n b\-\E V\Yd ,m /\,1`qWSD ˚aWS ,*Y a\W-*WSE ,mE ,\4Y\3Z\E ]\hd,ab,\,*WSE hb\ ,*a dZS4SWS S ]`1/*WSE S ob\ ,m4,*W\ d ,*a -Z1,D ˙*E W\3n `*4Wdh*1b /`d41yE `*4`dj*1b a1YnS S ]`ShSZq1b d+mbVS , YSWWS\Zm /\WO W*`\,D b\ +m ,m ]\hd,ab,\,*WSE d4Z*,E hb\ ,*Y -\,\`SWS W\3n \ \-1H ˚aWS ,m -Wd+\V\ ,1O `dpkSy h1W\,1VE b\E aV\`11 ,a1-\E ob\ ,m4,*O W\ +m d ,*a b*VS1 31 aSWnZm1 hd,ab,*E V*V d ˙S*ZZ S dSa*D

˘

w Y1Zq +mW\ hd,ab,\E aW\,Z\ g1`V\,n Y1Zq ]`1/*W*x L˙ MD ˘ w) +mW 4\WD ) ]\ZqWE hb\ Y1Zq \+Y*Zm,*WS S hb\ ,a1 Y\S Z*/13/m S ab`1YW1ZSq \V*4*WSan bk1bZmYSx L MD \31b +mbnE ,m Z1 /\]daV*1b1 S YmaWS \ b\YE hb\ ,*Y -\,\`SWS W\3n \ \-1D 1/n ,m ]\WdhSWS 4Z*ZSq \ \-1 \b b1fE V\Yd ,m /\O ,1`q1b1 S Vb\ ZSV\-/* Z*Y1`1ZZ\ Z1 ]`ShSO ZSW +m ,*Y ,`1/*EP \b `\/Sb1W1yE a,qO k1ZZSV*E ]*ab\`* SWS +WS4V\-\ /`d-*D 1 SaVWph1Z\E hb\ ,m ]`S/1`3S,*1b1an Z1V\b\O `mf dh1ZSy ,ap a,\p 3S4ZnD /Z*V\ /*31 \h1Zn `*a]`\ab`*Z1ZZ*q S/1q Y\31b +mbn W\3npE Z1 b*V WSH \E V*V aV*4*W +m,jSy ]`14S/1Zb " `*ZVWSZ d4,1WnbE w]\O ,b\`1ZS1 Z1 ]`1,`*k*1b W\3n , SabSZdxD *V d4Z*bnE Z1 \+Y*Zdbm WS ,mH /Z*3/m Sada `Sab\a aV*4*W , Y\WSb,1 \-dB w ,\1 aW\,\ 1abn SabSZ*x L \*ZZ* 5;B5;MD ˙*E a ]\O Y\knp \3n1-\ W\,*E S+WSSE Y\3Z\ \bO WShSbn ]`*,/d \b W3SD \ob\Yd /*,*yb1 `*aaY\b`SY ]qbn W\3O Zmf db,1`3/1ZSy \ \-1 , a,1b1 S+WSSD m d,S/Sb1E V*V 4Z*ZS1 SabSZm Y\31b S4Y1O ZSbn ,*jd 3S4Zn V Wdhj1YdD ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

3

1

\- Z1]\abS3SY

Ë™ ' H

\4Y\3Z\E ,m aWmj*WSB w dbS \a]\/ZS

Z1Sa]\,1/SYmxD w b1g Z1]\abS3SYE mZ Z1]\abS3SYE S

,qb\y ˙df Z1]\abS3SYxEP -\,\`Sbaq , e*Z*an1,aV\Y aSY,\W1 ,1`m \ `\Sg1E /\-O Y*b1E V\b\`\Yd dh*b YZ\-S1 f`SabS*ZaVS1 g1`V,SD

ËšaWS \- P ob\ Z1]\abS3SY*q `\Sg*E b\ V*V Ym Y\31Y d4Z*bn 1-\H

1Yd dhSb S+WSqD Sada aV*4*WE hb\ 1aO

1Y ]\W14Z\ 4Z*ZS1 SabSZmD ËšaWS \- P

Z1]\abS3SY*q b*yZ*E b\-/* 4*h1Y ]mb*bnO aq d4Z*bn 1-\H /Z*V\ \- ]\4,\Wq1b Z*Y Z1 b\WnV\ d4Z*bn 1-\E Z\ S `*4,Sbn a ZSY /`d3+dD *]`SY1`E \Z Z*4,*W a,\SY /`dO -\Y ,`**Y*D g*`n /`1,Z1-\ 4`*SWq ˙*O ,S/ Z*]Sa*WB w˙\,1`Sb1WnZm1 \bZ\j1ZSq a 1-\,\y P d +\qkSfaq 1-\x L a*W\Y 69B58C a*Sq 85B<MD *31baq WS ,*YE hb\ SY1bn +WS4VS1 \bZ\O j1ZSq a \-\Y Z1,\4Y\3Z\H \-/* \+`*bSb1 ,ZSY*ZS1 Z* aW\,* S4 VZS-S ˙1qZSq 5;B6;B

34567 ËšaWS ,m 31W*1b1 ]\WdhSbn +\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS SWS f\bSb1E hb\+m a ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\an +1a]W*bZ\1 /\O Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 S+WSSE ]\3*Wdyab*E ]SjSb1 ,S/1O b1WqY 1-\,m ]\ \/Z\Yd S4 ZS31dV*4*ZZmf */`1a\,D \WZmy a]Sa\V */`1a\, eSWS*W\, Y\3Z\ Z*ybS Z*

www.watchtower.org/address.

4

w \- Z1 /*W1V\ \b V*3/\-\ S4 Z*axD V*V\Y aYmaW1H 1`14 S+WSp \- ]`1/\ab*,Wq1b ,a1 Z1\+f\/SY\1E hb\+m Ym Y\-WS d4Z*bn 1-\1D \- \bV`mW Z*Y a,\1 SYqE 1-\,* L a*Sq 86B<MD Z b*V31 ]\4*+\bSWaqE hb\+m , S+O WSS +mW\ Z*]Sa*Z\ \ b\YE V*V \Z \+`*k*Waq a Wp/nYS , ]`\jW\YD W*-\/*`q ob\Yd Ym Y\31Y d4Z*bnE V*V\y WShZ\abnp \Z q,Wq1bO aqD `\Y1 b\-\E \- `*aaV*4*W Z*Y \ a,\Sf V*h1ab,*fD S+WSS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ \Z wYSO W\a1`/Zmy S ,1WSV\/djZmyE Y1/W1ZZmy Z* -Z1, S Sa]\WZ1ZZmy Wp+qk1y /\+`\bm S SabSZmx L af\/ 78B:MD *jS ]\abd]VS Y\-db 4*b`*-S,*bn 1-\ hd,ab,*D *VE /`1,ZS1 S4`*O SWnbqZ1E ,\aab*,*q ]`\bS, \-*E w\-\`h*WS 1-\xD b1E Vb\ aWdj*pbaq 1-\E ]`SZ\aqb 1Yd `*/\abn L a*W\Y ;<B8>C `SbhS 6;B55MD

The Trinity c.1500, Flemish School, (16th century) / H. Shickman Gallery, New York, USA / The Bridgeman Art Library International

WS h1W\,1V +d/1b w]`S\+`1b*bn 4Z*ZSq \DDD 1/SZab,1ZZ\Y SabSZZ\Y \-1xE b\ \Z Y\O 31b ]\WdhSbn ,1hZm1 +W*-\aW\,1ZSq L \*ZO Z* 5;B7MD \ V*V Y\3Z\ ]`S\+`1b*bn 4Z*ZSq \ \-1E 1aWS \Z Z1]\abS3SYH \- Z1 aV`m,*1b a1+q \b Wp/1yE Z*\+\`\bE \Z f\h1bE hb\+m 1-\ 4Z*W V*3/my h1W\,1V L 1`1YSq 75B78MD \Z1hZ\E Ym ZSV\-/* Z1 d4Z*1Y \ \-1 ,a1O -\D ob\ Z1d/S,Sb1WnZ\E ,1/n 1-\ YmaWS S ]dbS ,mj1 Z*jSf L'VVW14S*ab 7B55C a*Sq 99B<E =MD

1 \Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS \ b\YE hb\ , S+WSS -\,\`Sbaq \ \-1E Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , 5Oy -W*,1 VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD 4/*Z* ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,mD

`Y1ZSqB >>5>E Ëš`1,*ZE *Nq ;9D 1W*`danB 1WS-S\4Z\1 \+l1O /SZ1ZS1 ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , 1a]d+WSV1 1W*`danE 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZSqB The Ridgeway, London NW7 1RN. 1`Y*ZSqB 65617 Selters. `d4SqB >5>6E +SWSaSO6E *Nq 67;D 4`*SWnB PO Box 29345, 61293 Tel Aviv. *4*fab*ZB >9>>>>E WY*bmE *Nq 5=<D m`-m4ab*ZB ;6>><>E SjV1VE *Nq <>D *b,SqB A.k. 15, Rıga, LV-1001. Sb,*B Pd 2632, LT-48022 Kaunas. ‘ \W/\,*B PO Box 472E MD-2005 Chi Ÿsinau. \aaSqB ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,mE *Nq 5<6E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E 5=>>>>D " B 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*SZ*B ;=8=5E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE */a =99D SZWqZ/SqB PO Box 68, FI-01301 Vantaa. 'ab\ZSqB PO Box 1075, 10302 Tallinn.

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) is published semimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; M. H. Larson, President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. 5 2011 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of PennsylvaniaD 4/*b1Wnab,\B Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V., Selters/ Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. a1 ]`*,* a\f`*ZqpbaqD Printed in Germany.

Vol. 132, No. 19

Semimonthly

RUSSIAN

2

\- +14`*4WSh1Z V Wp/qY

Ë™ ' H

\4Y\3Z\E ,m aWmj*WSB wËšaWS +m \- Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 4*+\bSWaq \ Wp/qfE \Z dab`*O ZSW +m 4W\ S ab`*/*ZSqD /*31 1aWS \Z 4*+\bSbaq \ Wp/qf , g1W\YE 1Yd +14`*4WShO Z\E hb\ ]`\Saf\/Sb a\ YZ\yxD 1Yd dhSb S+WSqD 1-\,* \- Z1 ]`ShSZqO 1b 4W* L *V\,* 5B57MD \bq \Z Y\31b ]\V\ZO hSbn a ZSY , Wp+\y Y\Y1ZbE \Z /\]daV*1b adk1ab,\,*ZS1 `*4,`*k1ZZ\-\ \+k1ab,*E hb\+m `*4`1jSbn ,*3Zm1 a]\`Zm1 ,\]`\O amE ]\/Zqbm1 Z* 4*`1 h1W\,1h1aV\y Sab\O `SSD \ ,aV\`1 \Z Z*hZ1b /1yab,\,*bn Z* +W*-\ Wp/1y S dab`*ZSb ,1an ,`1/E ]`ShSO Z1ZZmy b1YSE Vb\ \b,1`-*1b 1-\ ]`*,W1ZS1 L mbS1 7B5P:C a*Sq :9B5;M1D /Z*V\ \-* ,\WZd1b +W*-\]\WdhS1 Z1 1 \Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS \ b\YE ]\h1Yd \- /\]daV*1b ab`*O /*ZSqE ,m Y\31b1 Z*ybS , 55Oy -W*,1 VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD

ËšaWS Ym +14`*4WShZm

\-dE ]\h1Yd \Z ]`S4m,*1b Z*a Y\WSbnaq 1YdH

˛˙ ˚ ) 5<< )˛% B *41`+*y/3*ZaVSyE *41`O +*y/3*ZaVSy LVS`SWWSg*ME *yY*`*E *W+*ZaVSyE *Yf*`O aVSyE *Z-WSyaVSy67 Lb*V31 j`Seb `*yWqME *`*+aVSyE *`O YqZaVSyE *`YqZaVSy L4*]*/ZmyME *e`SV**ZaE *h\WSE +*dO W1E +1Z-*WnaVSyE +SV\WnaVSyE +SaW*Y*E +\W-*`aVSyE ,*WqyO b*E ,*`*yO,*`*yE ,1Z-1`aVSy67E ,1Z/*E ,\ab\hZmy d,1*E ,n1bZ*YaVSyE -*E -*SbqZaVSy V`1\WnaVSyE -*ZE -`1ZW*Z/O aVSyE -`1h1aVSyE -`d4SZaVSyE -d*`*ZS687E -d/3*`*bSE /*bO aVSy7E 4*Z/1E 4dWdE S,`SbE S-+\E SW\V*ZaVSyE SZ/\Z14SyO aVSyE SaW*Z/aVSyE Sa\V\E Sa]*ZaVSy67E Sb*WnqZaVSy67E y\`dO +*E V*4*faVSyE V*ZZ*/*E V*\Z/1E V,*Z-*WSE V1hd* L ZO V*jME V1hd* L qVdh\ME V1hd* L \WS,SqME V1hd* L daV\ME V1hd* L'V,*/\`ME VSV\Z-\E VSVdypE VSWd+*E VSY+dZ/dE VSO Znq`d*Z/*E VS`-S4aVSyE VS`S+*bSE VS`dZ/SE VSb*yaVSy Lb`*O

b\WnV\ h1W\,1h1ab,* , g1W\YE Z\ S \b/1WnO Zmf Wp/1yD 4 *be1q 5>B6=P75 ,S/Z\E hb\ \Z 4Z*1b \ Z*a b\E h1-\ Z1 4Z*1Y /*31 Ym a*YSB w *4,1 Z1 ]`\/*pb /,df ,\`\+n1, 4* \/Zd Y1WVdp Y\Z1bVdH ,a1 31 ZS \/SZ S4 ZSf Z1 d]*/1b Z* 41YWp +14 ,1/\Y* ,*O j1-\ bg*D d ,*a /*31 ,\W\am Z* -\W\O ,1 P S b1 ,a1 a\ahSb*ZmD \ob\Yd Z1 +\yO b1anB ,m g1ZZ11 YZ\31ab,* ,\`\+n1,xD 1Y ]\W14Z\ 4Z*ZS1 SabSZmD *V ]`*,SO W\E Ym ab\`\ZSYaq -`d+mf S `*,Z\/djZmf Wp/1yD \ob\Yd Z1d/S,Sb1WnZ\E hb\ S4O4* W\3Z\-\ db,1`3/1ZSqE +d/b\ \- `*,Z\/dO j1ZE YZ\-S1 Wp/S Z1 31W*pb d4Z*,*bn \ Z1Y SWS \+`*k*pbaq V Z1Yd WSjn , +14,mO f\/Z\y aSbd*gSSD \E ]\ZSY*qE hb\ 1-\,* 4*+\bSbaq \ Z*aE Ym +d/1Y \f\bZ\ d4Z*,*bn \ Z1Y S `*4,S,*bn a ZSY /`d3+dD *]`SY1`E ,mE ,\4Y\3Z\E Y\WSWSan \-d S Z1 +mWS d,1`1ZmE aWmjSb WS \Z ,*a S \bO ,1bSb WS Z* ,*jd Y\WSb,dD \ S+WSq 4*O ,1`q1bE hb\ w Wdj*b1Wn Y\WSb,x a -\b\,Z\O abnp ,maWdjS,*1b V*3/\-\E Vb\ SaV`1ZZ1 \+`*k*1baq V Z1Yd L a*W\Y :9B6MD S+WSq ]\+d3/*1b Z*aB w a1 a,\S +1a]\O V\yab,* ,\4W\3Sb1 Z*DDD \-* E ]\b\Yd hb\ \Z 4*+\bSbaq \ ,*ax L5 1b`* 9B;MD m Y\31Y ]\W*-*bnaq Z* \-* /*31 , a*Ymf b`d/Zmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*fE ,1/n , 1-\ W\,1 -\,\`SbaqB w 1-\,* +WS4\V V d/`dh1ZZmY a1`/g1YE S a\V`dj1ZZmf /df\Y \Z a]*a*1bx L a*W\Y 78B5<MD

/SgS\ZZmyM7 L*d/S\4*]SaS b\WnV\ Z* ]dbdZfd*ME VSb*yaVSy Ld]`\k1ZZmyME V\Z-\E V\`1yaVSy67E V\a*E Vd*ZnqY*E VfY1`O aVSyE W*bmjaVSyE WSZ-*W*E WSb\,aVSyE W\4SE Wd,*W1E Wd-*ZO /*E WdZ/*E Wd\E Y*,`SVSyaVSy V`1\WnaVSyE Y*yqE Y*V1/\ZO aVSyE Y*W*-*aSyaVSyE Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbSyaVSyE Y*`*bfSE Y*`j*WWnaVSyE YS4\E YSf1E Y\`1E YnqZY*ZaVSyE Z/1+1O W1E Z/\Z-*E Z1Y1gVSy67E Z1\a\W\Y\ZSVE Z1]*WnaVSyE Z4SO Y*E ZS/1`W*Z/aVSy67E ZSdoE Z\`,13aVSy67E ZnqZ1V*E \`\Y\E \a1bSZaVSyE \b1b1W*E ]*W*dE ]*Z-*aSZ*ZaVSyE ]*Z/3*+SE ]*O ]nqY1Zb\ L p`*a*\ME ]1`aS/aVSyE ]\WnaVSy67E ]\Z*]1E ]\`O bd-*WnaVSy687E `*`\b\Z-*E `dYmZaVSyE `daaVSy67E a*Y\*ZO aVSyE a*Z-\E a*]\b1V LSabYdaME a,*bSE a1+d*ZaVSyE a1yj1WnO aVSy V`1\WnaVSyE a1]1/SE a1`+aVSyE a1`+aVSy LW*bSZSg*ME a1a\b\E aSZ-*WnaVSyE aW\,*gVSyE aW\,1ZaVSyE a`*Z*ZOb\Z-\E

ad*fSWSE b*-*WnaVSy7E b*SbSE b*yaVSyE b*YSWnaVSyE b*b*`O aVSyE b,SE b1Wd-dE b1bdYE bS,E bS-`*yE b\VO]SaSZE b\Z-*E b\b\O Z*VE b`dVE ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd,*WdE bdY+dV*E bd`1gVSyE dV`*O SZaVSyE dY+dZ/dE d`/dE d`ddZ/E eS/3SE eSZaVSy7E e`*Zgd4O aVSy687E f*da*E fSWS-*yZ\ZE fSZ/SE fS`SOY\bdE f\`,*baVSyE g\gSWnE h1jaVSy7E hS+1Y+*E hSWd+*E hSb\Z-*E hSh1,*E j,1/O aVSy7E jSba,*E j\Z*E o,1E oab\ZaVSyE oeSVE q]E q]\ZaVSy67D 6 *V31 Z* CD. 8 *V31 , e\`Y*b1 MP7 (CD-ROM). 7 *V31 *d/S\4*]SaS Z* www.jw.org.

3

\- V*`*1b Wp/1y

˙ ' H

\4Y\3Z\E ,m aWmj*WSB w \- ,1/1b ah1b

-`1f*Y h1W\,1V* S ]\b\Y V*`*1b 1-\ ,1hZmO YS Ydh1ZSqYS , */dxD w \- Z*V*4m,*1b -`1jZSV\,E ]\amW*q abSfSyZm1 +1/ab,SqxEP db,1`3/*pb Z1V\O b\`m1D

1Y ]\W14Z\ 4Z*ZS1 SabSZmD ˚aWS Ym ]\O ZSY*1YE hb\ \- w-\b\, ]`\k*bnx S Z1 a]1O jSb \ad3/*bnE ob\ ]\Y\-*1b Z*Y ]`S+WSO 3*bnaq V Z1Yd L a*W\Y <:B9MD m aWd3SY \-d Z1 S4 hd,ab,* ,SZm SWS +\W14Z1ZZ\-\ ab`*f* ]1`1/ Z*V*4*ZS1YE * S4 Wp+,S V Z1O YdD p+\,n ]`\+d3/*1b , Z*a 31W*ZS1 /1O W*bn ,a1 ,\4Y\3Z\1E hb\+m d-\3/*bn 1Yd L *be1q 66B7:P7<C 5 \*ZZ* 9B7MD \bq \- 31W*1bE hb\+m ,a1 Wp/S \+`*O bSWSan \b 4Wmf /1WE \Z 4Z*1bE hb\ YZ\-S1 Z1 a/1W*pb ob\-\D ˚aWS +m \Z ZSV\-/* Z1 6

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

˝1W*1b WS \-E hb\+m Ym ]\VW\ZqWSan 1Yd S4 ab`*f* ]1`1/ Z*V*4*ZS1YH ]`1/]`SZSY*W /1yab,Sy ]`\bS, b1fE Vb\ d]`qY\ b,\`Sb 4Wm1 /1W*E \Z +mW +m ]\O f\3 Z* ]`*,Sb1WqE V\b\`my dab*Z*,WS,*1b 4*V\ZmE Z\ Z1 \+1a]1hS,*1b Sf a\+Wp/1ZSqE b1Y a*YmY ]\4,\Wqq `*a]`\ab`*Zqbnaq Z1O a]`*,1/WS,\abS S ab`*/*ZSqY L'VVW14S*ab <B55MD ˛Z*ZS1 b\-\E hb\ \- Z1 +d/1b b1`]1bn Z1h1abS1 +1aV\Z1hZ\E ]\Y\-*1b Z*Y aY\bO `1bn , +d/dk11 a Z*/13/\yD 1-\,* \+1O k*1b dab`*ZSbn b1fE Vb\ 4*V\aZ1W , -`1f*fE hb\+m V`\bVS1 Wp/S Y\-WS Z*aW*3/*bnaq ,1hZ\y 3S4Znp Z* 41YW1E V*V \Z S4Z*h*WnO Z\ S 4*YmaWSW L a*W\Y 7;B5>E 55E 6=M1D 1 b\+m d4Z*bn +\Wnj1 \ b\YE V*V \- ]`1,`*bSb 41YWp , `*yE aY\b`Sb1 7Op S <Op -W*,m VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD

´ Engravings by Dore

1Yd dhSb S+WSqD \ 6 1b`* 7B= -\,\`SbO aqE hb\ 1-\,* wZ1 f\h1bE hb\+m Vb\OWS+\ ]\-S+E Z\ f\h1bE hb\+m ,a1 ]`SjWS V `*aV*O qZSpxD Z a\a`1/\b\hS,*1baq Z1 Z* Z*jSf \jS+V*fE * Z* Z*jSf /\+`mf /1W*fD w W*4* 1-\,m \aY*b`S,*pb ,ap 41YWpE hb\+m \Z Y\- ]`\q,Sbn a,\p aSWd Z* +W*-\ b1fE hn1 a1`/g1 ]\WZ\abnp a ZSYx L6 1b\]San 5:B=MD h1ZS1 \+ */1 Z1 \aZ\,*Z\ Z* S+WSSD ˙*31 YmaWn \ b\YE hb\+m ,1hZ\ YdhSbn WpO /1yE \b,`*bSb1WnZ* \-dD *Y\1 ab`\-\1 Z*O V*4*ZS1E ]`1/daY\b`1ZZ\1 \-\YEP WSO jSbn Z1h1abS,\-\ h1W\,1V* /*`* 3S4ZS L 1`1YSq ;B75C SYWqZ*Y :B;MD bSfSyZm1 +1/ab,SqE ,\ ,`1Yq V\b\`mf -S+Zdb V*V ]W\fS1E b*V S f\`\jS1E ]`\Saf\/qb Z1 ]\ ,SZ1 \-*D ZS Y\-db ]`ShSZSbn ab`*/*O ZSq Wp+\YdE Vb\ \V*4*Waq , Z1]\/f\/qk11 ,`1Yq , Z1]\/f\/qk1Y Y1ab1 L'VVW14S*ab =B55MD

4

\- Z1a]`*,1/WS,

Ë™ ' H

\4Y\3Z\E ,m aWmj*WSB w S`\Y ]`*,Sb

˘ Sven Torfinn/Panos Pictures

\-E S ,a1E hb\ , Z1Y ]`\Saf\/SbE ]`\Saf\O /Sb ]\ ,\W1 \-*D \ob\Yd \Z \b,1bab,1Z 4* b\E hb\ YS` ]\W\Z Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abSE 31ab\O V\abS S ]`Sb1aZ1ZSyxD 1Yd dhSb S+WSqD 1a]`*,1/WS,\abnE g*O `qk*q , ob\Y YS`1E Z1 Saf\/Sb \b \-*D + 1-\,1 , S+WSS aV*4*Z\B w˚-\ /1W* a\,1`O j1ZZmE S ,a1 1-\ ]dbS a]`*,1/WS,mx L b\`\O 4*V\ZS1 76B8MD \- ]`\q,Wq1b k1/`\abn V\ ,a1Y WpO /qYE /*31 V b1YE Vb\E V*V V*31baqE ob\-\ Z1 4*aWd3S,*1bD *]`SY1`E w\Z ]\,1W1,*1b a\WZgd ,\af\/Sbn Z*/ 4WmYS S /\+`mYS S ]\amW*1b /\3/n Z* ]`*,1/Zmf S Z1]`*,1/O Zmfx L *be1q 9B89MD Z ]\abd]*1b a]`*,1/O WS,\ a Wp/nYS ,a1f Z*gSy S VdWnbd`E V*V \+ ob\Y aV*4*Z\ , ˙1qZSqf 5>B78E 79B w \Z1WSg1]`Sqb1ZE Z\ ,\ ,aqV\Y Z*`\/1 +\qO kSyaq 1-\ S ]\abd]*pkSy ]`*,1/Z\ d-\O /1Z 1YdxD \-/* ]\h1Yd , YS`1 ab\WnV\ Z1a]`*O ,1/WS,\abSH Z\-S1 Wp/S Z1 aW1/dpb \O 3n1Yd ]`SY1`d S Z*Y1`1ZZ\ ]\abd]*pb Z1a]`*,1/WS,\ L b\`\4*V\ZS1 76B9MD `\Y1 b\-\E , S+WSS aV*4*Z\E hb\ \- /\]daV*O 1bE hb\+m YS`\Y ]`*,SW 1-\ ,`*-E ˙nq,\W L5 \*ZZ* 9B5=M1D /Z*V\ ,aV\`1 \- ]\W\O 3Sb V\Z1g 1-\ Z1a]`*,1/WS,\Yd ]`*,W1O 1 b\+m d4Z*bn \ b\YE V*V ]\q,SWaq ˙nq,\WE aY\b`Sb1 7Op -W*,d VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD

ZSpD 1-\,* d31 ]`1/]`SZqW Y1`mE hb\+m w`*4`djSbn /1W* ˙nq,\W*x L5 \*ZZ* 7B<MD 1Y ]\W14Z\ 4Z*ZS1 SabSZmD \4Y\3Z\E ,*a

]\`\y ]`S,\/Sb , 4*Y1j*b1Wnab,\ Z1aV\ZO h*1Ymy ]\b\V a\\+k1ZSy \ V\``d]gSSE Z*aSWSS S Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abSD \E 4Z*q ]`SO hSZm ]`\+W1Y h1W\,1h1ab,*E ,m +d/1b1 ]\O ZSY*bnE ]\h1Yd ,a1 ]\]mbVS Wp/1y a/1W*bn YS` Wdhj1 b1`]qb V`*f S aSbd*gSq , YS`1 ab*Z\,Sbaq b\WnV\ fd31 L a*W\Y 58:B7MD m Z1 ab*Z1b1 b`*bSbn ,`1Yq S aSWm Z* b\E hb\+m /\+Sbnaq ]`1\+`*4\,*ZSyE V\b\`m1 , Wdhj1Y aWdh*1 ]`SZ1adb WSjn ,`1Y1ZZdp ]\Wn4dE ,1/n ,*j* Z*/13/* Z* +d/dk11 +dO /1b a,q4*Z* a ,1`\y , \3nS \+1k*ZSq L bO V`\,1ZS1 65B7E 8MD ˛Z*bn ]`*,/d \ b\YE ]\h1Yd , YS`1 ab\WnO V\ Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abSE \a\+1ZZ\ ,*3Z\E V\-O /* +1/* ]`Sf\/Sb , Z*j /\YD ˚aWS a Z*O YS \+\jWSan Z1a]`*,1/WS,\E YmE `*4/1Wqq hd,ab,* \3n1-\ aWd3Sb1Wq ,,*VdY*E Y\O 31Y a\V`dj*bnaqB w \b1`qW aSWd 4*V\Z S a]`*,1/WS,\abn ZSV\-/* Z1 \/1`3S,*1b ]\O +1/dx L ,,*VdY 5B8MD 1-\,* Z1 \ad/SW ]`\`\O V* 4* obS aW\,*D Z 4*,1`SW ,,*VdY*E hb\ dab*Z\,SW ,`1YqE V\-/* ]\W\3Sb 4Wd V\Z1gE S ]\Y\- 1Yd \+`1abS `*/\abnE Z1aY\b`q Z* b`d/Z\abS L ,,*VdY 6B6P8C 7B5;E 5<MD ˚aWS ,m +d/1b1 /\,1`qbn \3n1Yd \+1k*ZSp dab`*O ZSbn Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abnE ,m b\31 +d/1b1 SaO ]mbm,*bn YS` S /dj1,Zmy ]\V\y /*31 , ob\Y Sa]\WZ1ZZ\Y 4W* YS`1D

b,1bab,1Z WS \4* Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abn S ab`*/*ZSqH

5

\- ]`SZSY*1b ,a1fE Vb\ SaV`1ZZ1 ,1`Sb

˙ ' H

\4Y\3Z\E ,m aWmj*WSB w *V 31 V*V V \/O

Z\Yd S b\Yd 31 Y1abd ,1/1b YZ\-\ `*4O Zmf /\`\-E V \-d ,1/1b YZ\-\ `*4Zmf ]db1yD V*3/\-\ a,\y ]dbn V \-dxD 1Yd dhSb S+WSqD m /\W3Zm ]\VW\O Zqbnaq \-d SaV`1ZZ1E S4+1-*q ]`Sb,\`ab,* S WSg1Y1`SqD `*4-\,\`1 a `1WS-S\4ZmYS `dV\,\/Sb1WqYS a,\1-\ ,`1Y1ZS Sada \+lO qaZSWE ]\h1Yd \- \b,1`- SfB w 1`Z\ ]`\`\O h1ab,\,*W \ ,*a a*SqE V*V Z*]Sa*Z\B t'b\b Z*`\/ hbSb Y1Zq -d+*YSE Z\ Sf a1`/g* d/*O W1Zm \b Y1Zqrx L *`V* ;B:MD 1Y Z1 Y1Z11 \/O Z\y WSjn SaV`1ZZ\abS Z1/\ab*b\hZ\E hb\+m Z*j1 ]\VW\Z1ZS1 +mW\ d-\/Z\ \-dD Sada qaZ\ ]\V*4*W ob\E \+`*bS, ,ZSO Y*ZS1 Z* -W*,Zdp \jS+Vd b1f `1WS-S\4Zmf `dV\,\/Sb1W1y S Sf dh1ZSV\,D Z ]`SY1ZSW V ZSY aW\,* \-*B w *]`*aZ\ \ZS ]\VW\ZqO pbaq YZ1E ]\b\Yd hb\ Sf dh1ZSq ,a1-\ WSjn h1W\,1h1aVS1 4*]\,1/Sx L *`V* ;B;MD f ]\O VW\Z1ZS1 +mW\ Z*]`*aZmYE SWS +1a]\W14O ZmYE ]\b\Yd hb\ `1WS-S\4Zm1 b`*/SgSS +mO WS /Wq ZSf ,*3Z11E h1Y b`1+\,*ZSq \-*D S+WSq Z1 dhSbE hb\ V \-d Y\3Z\ ]`SO +WS4Sbnaq `*4ZmYS ]dbqYSD Z1y -\,\`SbO aqE hb\ V \-d ,1/1b b\WnV\ \/SZ ]dbnD *be1q ;B57E 58 aV*4*Z\B w f\/Sb1 h1`14 d4VS1 ,\`\b*E ]\b\Yd hb\ jS`\V* S ]`\ab\`O Z* /\`\-*E ,1/dk*q V -S+1WSE S YZ\-S1 S/db 1pE b\-/* V*V d4VS ,\`\b* S b1aZ* /\`\-*E ,1O /dk*q V 3S4ZSE S Z1YZ\-S1 Z*f\/qb 11xD 1Y ]\W14Z\ 4Z*ZS1 SabSZmD `1/ab*,nb1E

hb\ ,m Z1aV\WnV\ Y1aqg1, -\b\,SWSan V a\O `1,Z\,*ZSqY ]\ Y*`*e\ZaV\Yd +1-dE ]`\+1O 3*WS /Sab*ZgSp S ]`SjWS V eSZSjd ]1`O ,mYE Z\ +mWS /SaV,*WSeSgS`\,*Zm 4* Z*`dj1ZS1 ]`*,SW*E \ V\b\`\Y ,m Z1 4Z*WSD b\ +m ,m ]\hd,ab,\,*WSH V\`11 ,a1-\E ,m Sa]mb*WS +m `*4\h*`\,*ZS1E \bb\-\ hb\ ,a1 8

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

a1 WS `1WS-SS ,1/db V \-dH

,*jS ab*`*ZSq \V*4*WSan Z*]`*aZmYSD \O 31b WS Z1hb\ ]\/\+Z\1 aWdhSbnaq a ]\VW\O Z1ZS1Y \-dH

`*,ZS,*q Z*j1 aWd31ZS1 \-d a\ a]\`O bS,ZmYS a\abq4*ZSqYSE *]\ab\W *,1W Z*]Sa*WB w˚aWS Vb\ dh*ab,d1b , a\`1,Z\,*O ZSqfE b\ \Z Z1 ]\Wdh*1b ,1ZV*E 1aWS a\O `1,Zd1baq Z1 ]\ ]`*,SW*Yx L6 SY\e1p 6B9MD m 4*aWd3SY \3n1 \/\+`1ZS1E 1aWS +dO /1Y ]\VW\Zqbnaq 1Yd w]\ ]`*,SW*YxE b\ 1abn b*VE V*V 1Yd d-\/Z\D m Z1 Y\31Y ,m+S`*bn a,\y a\+ab,1ZZmy ]dbn V \-dE ]\/\+Z\ b\O Yd V*V Y*`*e\Z1g Z1 Y\31b +13*bn b*YE -/1 1Yd 4*+W*-\`*aad/SbaqE S ]`S ob\Y \3SO /*bnE hb\ 1-\ \+lq,qb ]\+1/Sb1W1Y 4*+1-*D b\+m Z*j1 ]\VW\Z1ZS1 +mW\ d-\/Z\ \O -dE \Z\ Z1 /\W3Z\ SY1bn ZSh1-\ \+k1-\ a W\O 3np \ 1YD Sada aV*4*WB w abSZZm1 ]\O VW\ZZSVS +d/db ]\VW\Zqbnaq bgd , /df1 S SabSZ1x L \*ZZ* 8B67MD m Y\31Y Z*ybS ]dbnE ,1/dkSy V \-dE a ]\Y\knp 1-\ W\,*E S+WSS L \*ZZ* 5;B5;M1D 1 \Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS \ b\YE V*V\1 ]\VW\Z1ZS1 d-\/Z\ \-dE Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , 59Oy -W*,1 VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD

abSZ*

˝˚ ˛ ˚ & " ˝ ˛ &

˚ ) E ,m aWmj*WS \/Z\ S4 W\3O Zmf db,1`3/1ZSy \ \-1E V\b\`m1 `*O 4\+W*h*WSan , ob\y a1`SS ab*b1yD a1 31 ,*Y Y\31b +mbn b`d/Z\ \bV*4*bnaq \b a,\O Sf d+13/1ZSyE \a\+1ZZ\ 1aWS ,m ]`S/1`O 3S,*1b1an Sf /\W-\1 ,`1YqD *a Y\3Z\ ]\ZqbnD Z1V\b\`mf g1`V,qf Z1 \/\+`qpb b1fE Vb\ a`*,ZS,*1b Sf dh1O ZSq a b1YE hb\ -\,\`Sbaq , S+WSSD /`dO -Sf g1`V,qf \bab*S,*pb W\3nE db,1`3/*qE hb\ S+WSq aWSjV\Y aW\3Z* S Z1/\abd]O Z* ]\ZSY*ZSp V*3/\-\D /Z*V\ +\WnjSZO ab,\ dh1ZSV\, Sada*E f\bq S Z1 +mWS ,ma\V\\+`*4\,*ZZmYS Wp/nYSE +14 b`d/* ]\ZSY*WS 1-\ dh1ZSq L˙1qZSq 8B57MD \4Y\3Z\E ,m Z1 `1j*1b1an ]`\,1`Sbn a,\S d+13/1ZSqE \]*a*qanE hb\ b*V ,m ,mO V*31b1 Z1/\ab*b\V ,1`mD \ `*4dYZ\ WS /dO Y*bnE hb\ \- +d/1b Z1/\,\W1Z b1YE hb\ ,m S4dh*1b1 S+WSpE 1-\ ]SanY\ Wp/qYE ab`1O Yqan ]\ZqbnE h1-\ \Z \b ,*a \3S/*1bH \O Z1hZ\ Z1bI W\,\ \-* ]`S4m,*1b Z*a wd/\ab\,1`qbnaqE , h1Y a\ab\Sb /\+`*qE 31O W*ZZ*q S a\,1`j1ZZ*q ,\Wq \-*xD m Y\O 31Y /1W*bn ob\E SaaW1/dq ,qk1ZZ\1 SO a*ZS1 L SYWqZ*Y 56B6MD abSZ* \ \-1 P ob\ Z1 ]`\ab\ 4Z*ZSqE \Z* Y\31b S4Y1ZSbn ,*jd 3S4Zn V Wdhj1O

Yd L \*ZZ* <B76MD ˙S*ZZE \ V\b\`\y -\O ,\`SW\an , ]1`,\y ab*bn1E \+`1W* b,1`/dp ,1`dE \aZ\,*ZZdp Z* W\,1 \-*D Z* `*aO aV*4m,*1bB w) S Z1 /dY*W*E hb\ S+WSp W1-V\ ]\ZqbnE ]\V* Z1 Z*h*W* S4dh*bn 11D 1]1`n 1-\,* /Wq Y1Zq Z1 +14WSVSy \-E * Wp+qkSy Z1+1aZmy b1gD ) \+`1W* Z*O ab\qkSy aYmaW 3S4ZSxD \31b +mbnE ,m S4dh*WS S+WSpE Z\ Z1 ,S/1WS , ob\Y ]\Wn4mD b*V\Y aWdh*1 Z1 \]daV*yb1 `dVSD ˚aWS ,*a dhSWS W3S \ \O -1E b\ ,*jS ]\]mbVS ]\Zqbn S+WSp ]\O /\+Zm ]\]mbV*Y aW\3Sbn Y\4*SVdE ,4q, , V*h1ab,1 \+`*4g* Z1]`*,SWnZdp V*`bSO ZdD m Y\31b1 aW\3Sbn ,Y1ab1 Z1V\b\`m1 11 h*abSE Z\ ,mE aV\`11 ,a1-\E a/*/Sb1anE V\-/* d,S/Sb1E hb\ obS h*abS Z1 a\\bO ,1bab,dpb Saf\/Z\y V*`bSZ1D /Z*V\E 1aO WS ,m Z*hZ1b1 4*Z\,\E -Wq/q Z* ]`*O ,SWnZmy \+`*41gE ,a1 /1b*WS aW\3*baq ,\1/SZ\D \b1WS +m ,m d4Z*bn SabSZd \ \-1H \-/* \+`*bSb1an V ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m , ,*j1y Y1abZ\abS SWS Z*]SjSb1 S4/*b1O WqY ob\y ]d+WSV*gSS ]\ \/Z\Yd S4 */O `1a\,E dV*4*ZZmf Z* ab`*ZSg1 8E S ]\]`\O aSb1 \ +1a]W*bZ\Y /\Y*jZ1Y S4dh1ZSS S+WSSD

/\ab\,1`qyb1anE w, h1Y a\ab\Sb /\+`*qE 31W*ZZ*q S a\,1`j1ZZ*q ,\Wq \-*x L ) 56B6MD

9

˛ ˚ ˚ %H

\h1Yd , 1`da*WSYaV\Y f`*Y1 Z*f\/SWSan Y1Z\,kSVS /1Z1-H ˇ 14*/\W-\ /\ a,\1y aY1`bS Sada ,\WnZm1 ]`SZ\j1ZSqE SY Zd3Zm +mWS d,S/1W , f`*Y1 ,\]Spkdp Z1a]`*O ,1/WS,\abnD S+WSS a\\+k*1baqE ‹ hb\ \Z b\-/* a/1W*WB w Sada ,m-Z*W \bbd/* ,a1fE Vb\ b*Y ]`\/*,*W S ]\VdO ]*WD Z ]1`1,1`ZdW ab\Wm b1fE Vb\ \+O Y1ZS,*W /1Zn-SE S aV*YnS b1fE Vb\ ]`\/*,*W -\Wd+1yE S aV*4*W SYB t *O ]Sa*Z\B t \y /\Y +d/db Z*4m,*bn /\O Y\Y Y\WSb,mrE * ,m ]`1,`*k*1b1 1-\ , ]`Sab*ZSk1 `*4+\yZSV\,rx L *be1q 65B56E 57MD

]1`,\Y ,1V1 /Wq ]\VW\Z1ZSq \O -d , 1`da*WSY ab1V*WSan Sd/1S S ]`\41WSbm S4 `*4Zmf -\`\/\, S ab`*ZD b\+m d]W*bSbn 131-\/Zmy Z*W\- Z* f`*YE * b*V31 Vd]Sbn 31`b,1ZZ\1 3SO ,\bZ\1 SWS ]`SZ1abS /`d-S1 /\+`\O

Y\Z1bmE V\b\`m1 SY1WS f\3/1ZS1 , d/11D \ob\Yd \ZS jWS V Wp/qYE V\O b\`m1 4* ]W*bd \+Y1ZS,*WS /1Zn-SD \-/* ]`S+WS3*WSan Sd/1yaVS1 ]`*4O /ZSVSE Y1Z\,kSVS /1Z1- ab*,SWS a,\S ab\Wm , f`*Y1E ,\ /,\`1 Z11,`11,D V*4*,E hb\ Y1Z\,kSVS /1Z1- ]`1O ,`*k*WS f`*Y , w]`Sab*ZSk1 `*4+\yO ZSV\,xE SadaE \h1,S/Z\E SY1W , ,SO /dE hb\ 4* a,\S daWd-S \ZS +`*WS Z1]\O Y1`Zdp ]W*bdD

\h1Yd , +S+W1yaVS1 ,`1Y1Z* Y*aWSZm ,ma\V\ g1ZSWSanH ˇ \- \+1k*W S4`*SWnbqZ*YE hb\ 1aO W*an /Wq ]`S-\b\,W1ZSq +W*-\,\ZSyD WS \ZS +d/db f`*ZSbn 1Yd ,1`Z\abnE b\ \ZE a`1/S ]`\h1-\E /*ab SY ,SZ\-`*/O ZSVS S Y*aWSZm L b\`\4*V\ZS1 :B5>E 55MD *aWSZm ,ma\V\ g1Zqbaq S a1-\/O ZqD ZS Y\-db /*,*bn +\-*bmy d`\3*y Z* ]`\bq31ZSS a\b1Z W1b S ]`S ob\Y Z1 b`1+dpb \a\+\-\ df\/*D dWnbd`Z*q Y*aWSZ* Y\31b `*abS /*31 , V*Y1ZSO ab\y ]\h,1 S ]1`1Z\aSbn h*abm1 4*adO fSD \`Z1,Sk1 a`d+W1ZZ\-\ SWS d]*,O j1-\ /1`1,* \+mhZ\ /*1b Z1aV\WnV\ ]\+1-\,E V\b\`m1 ,]\aW1/ab,SS Y\-db ab*bn Z\,mYS ab,\W*YSD

+S+W1yaVS1 ,`1Y1Z* V\`* S WSO abnq Y*aWSZm g1ZSWSan 4* a,\S 3*`\O ]\ZS3*pkS1 a,\yab,*D +W*/*pk*q ,*ZSWnZmY *`\Y*b\Y aY\W*E V\b\`*q a\hSbaq S4 ab*`mf ,1b,1yE Sa]\Wn4\,*O 10

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

\ -W*,ZmY \+`*4\Y obS /1`1,nq g1O ZSWSan 4* a,\S ]W\/m S 4* Y*aW\E V\O b\`\1 S4 ZSf ]\Wdh*WSD 4,1abZ\E hb\ YqV\bn a]1W\y \WS,VS Z*]\W\,SZd a\O ab\Sb S4 Y*aW*D 4 ]W\/\, \/Z\-\ /1`1,* Y\3Z\ ]\WdhSbn /\ 9; WSb`\, Y*aW* , -\/D WS,V\,\1 Y*aW\ d]\b`1+WqWS , ]SkdE SY 4*]`*,WqWS a,1bSWnZSVSE \Z\ SaO ]\Wn4\,*W\an , g1`1Y\ZS*WnZmf S `1O WS-S\4Zmf g1WqfE V*V V\aY1bSh1aV\1 a`1/ab,\ /Wq b1W* S ,\W\a S V*V W1O V*`ab,1ZZ\1 a`1/ab,\ /Wq 4*3S,W1O ZSq `*Z S djS+\, L af\/ 6;B6>C 1,Sb 6B5P;C <B5P56C den 7B7C dVS 5>B77E 78MD

˚ ˚ ˚ ( )

W1/d1b WS V`1abSbn YW*/1Zg1,H ˇ w) +\qW*anE hb\ Y\y YW*/jSy +`*bE ˙3\ZE ]\O ]*W , WSY+xEP ]\/1WSW*an SVb\`SqD \h1Yd \Z* ob\-\ +\qW*anH Z* \+lqaZSW*B w˙3\Z dY1` Z1V`1k1ZmYE S V*b\WSh1aVSy a,qk1ZZSV aV*4*WE hb\ ]\ob\Yd Y\y +`*b \ab*Z1baq , WSY+1 Z*,1hZ\xD 'b\ dh1ZS1 /1yab,Sb1WnZ\ ]d-*1b WpO /1yE Z\ \aZ\,*Z\ WS \Z\ Z* S+WSSH hSb WS W\,\ \-* b\YdE hb\ /1bSE V\b\`m1 dY1`WS Z1O V`1k1ZmYSE \+`1h1Zm Z* ab`*/*ZSqH

S+WSS Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 -\,\`SbaqE hb\ f`SO abS*Z*Y Zd3Z\ V`1abSbnaqD Sada ]\`dhSW a,\SY ]\aW1/\,*b1WqYB w \ ,a1f Z*`\/*f ]\/-\b*,O WS,*yb1 dh1ZSV\,E V`1abq Sf ,\ SYq bg*E mZ* S a,qb\-\ /df* S dh* Sf a\+Wp/*bn ,a1E hb\ q ,*Y ]\,1W1Wx L *be1q 6<B5=E 6>MD +`*bSb1 ,ZSY*O ZS1E hb\ b\bE Vb\ ]`SZSY*1b V`1k1ZS1E /\W31Z +mbn dh1ZSV\Y Sada*D 'b\ \4Z*h*1bE hb\ b*V\y h1W\,1V ]\WdhSW 4Z*ZSq \+ Sada1 S `1jSW aW1O /\,*bn 4* ZSYE * YW*/1Z1gE 1ab1ab,1ZZ\E Z1 Y\O 31b a/1W*bn ob\D 1Y Z1 Y1Z11 YZ\-S1 db,1`3/*pbE hb\ ]\O ,1W1ZS1 Sada* \bZ\aSbaq S V Y*W1ZnVSY /1bqYD w `1abSbn aW1/d1b ,a1fE , b\Y hSaW1 YW*/1ZO g1,xEP aV*4*W Wpb1`*ZaVSy ]*ab\` Sf*`/ dO f1`D ˛*b1Y \Z /\+*,SWB w /1`3S,*bn Sf \b V`1O k1ZSq P ,a1 `*,Z\ hb\ Z1 /*,*bn SY ]\WdhSbn

\3n1 ]`\k1ZS1 S ]\/,1`-*bn Sf ]`\VWqbSpxD /Z*V\ b*VS1 db,1`3/1ZSq ]`\bS,\`1h*b dh1O ZSqY Sada* ]\ Y1Znj1y Y1`1 , b`1f \bZ\j1O ZSqfD

\O]1`,mfE Sada Z1 dhSWE hb\ YW*/1Zg1, aW1/d1b V`1abSbnD 1Y ]`SY1h*b1W1Z ob\b e*VbH Sada d/1WqW +\Wnj\1 ,ZSY*ZS1 b\YdE hb\+m 1-\ dh1ZSVS da,\SWS \3nS b`1+\,*ZSqD 1V\O b\`m1 ,*3Zm1 dh1ZSq \Z ]\,b\`qW Z1\/Z\V`*bO Z\D ˛*h1YH b\+m d+1/Sbnaq , b\YE hb\ 1-\ dh1O ZSVS ]\ZqWS Sf adbn L *be1q 68B86C 69B57C *`O V* =B78P7;C 5>B79P89MD /Z*V\ Sada ZS `*4d Z1 d]\YqZdWE hb\ Zd3Z\ V`1abSbn YW*/1ZO g1,D \31bE \Z ]`\ab\ 4*+mW a/1W*bn ob\H \O Z1hZ\ Z1bI ˚aWS +m YW*/1Zg1, Zd3Z\ +mW\ V`1O abSbnE \Z Z1]`1Y1ZZ\ aV*4*W +m \+ ob\YD

\O,b\`mfE Sada Z1 dhSWE hb\ ]\aW1 aY1`bS Vb\Ob\ Sa]mbm,*1b ab`*/*ZSqD Z ,a1g1W\ /\O ,1`qW b\YdE hb\ -\,\`Sbaq , ,qk1ZZ\Y Sa*O ZSSB w˝S,m1 4Z*pbE hb\ \ZS dY`dbE * Y1`b,m1 ZSh1-\ Z1 4Z*pbx L'VVW14S*ab =B9MD Sada 4Z*WE hb\ ]\aW1 aY1`bS Wp/S Z1 ]\]*/*pb ZS , hSabSWSk1E ZS , WSY+E ZS , */E ZS Vd/* +m b\ ZS +mW\ 1k1D Z dhSWE hb\ Y1`b,m1 Z*f\/qbO aq , +1aa\4Z*b1WnZ\Y a\ab\qZSSE a`*,ZSY\Y a\ aZ\Y L \*ZZ* 55B5P58MD

Ob`1bnSfE Sada dhSWE hb\ w,a1 Z*f\/qkS1O aq , ]*YqbZmf aVW1]*fx +d/db ,\aV`1j1Zm L \*ZZ* 9B6<E 6=MD 1a\YZ1ZZ\E a`1/S ZSf +dO /db YSWWS\Zm b1fE Vb\ Z1 +mW V`1k1ZD \-/* \ZS ,\aV`1aZdbE SY +d/1b /*Z* ,\4Y\3Z\abn d4Z*bn \3nS b`1+\,*ZSq S 3Sbn ,1hZ\ , *p Z* 41YW1 L a*W\Y 7;B6=M1D b*VE a\,1`j1ZZ\ qaZ\B S+WSq Z1 dhSb b\O YdE hb\ YW*/1Zg1, Zd3Z\ V`1abSbnD 1 \Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS \ -`q/dk1Y *1 S Z*/13/1 Z* ,\aV`1O a1ZS1 ,m Y\31b1 Z*ybS , 7Oy S ;Oy -W*,*f VZS-S w 1Yd Z* a*O Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHxD 4/*Z* ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,mD ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

11

) ˚ )˚ ˝ ˛ & ]\+d/SW\ /1,djVd ,Z\,n Z*h*bn 3Sbn ]\ +S+W1yaVSY ]`SZgS]*YE V\b\`m1 1y ]`S,S,*WS 11 f`SabS*ZaVS1 `\/Sb1WSH \b hb\ \Z* \ a1+1 `*aaV*4m,*1bD

w 1]1`n Y\q 3S4Zn ]\WZ* aYmaW*x L ˛ ˙ ˚MD

\ Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 b*V*q 3S4Zn Z1 ]`SZ\aSW* YZ1 ah*O abnqD \S /`d4nq +mWS W1-V\O YmaW1ZZmYS Wp/nYS S ZS V h1Yd Z1 \bZ\aSWSan a1`n14Z\D 1Zq 31 +1a]\V\SW\ YZ\-\1E Z*]`SY1` ]\,a1Y1abZ*q Z1O a]`*,1/WS,\abnD "W\ ,`1YqE S q hd,ab,\,*W* a1+q ,a1 +\O W11 S +\W11 ]\/*,W1ZZ\yD

˙ ˝˙˚ )B 5=<: B ( ˚

" B ˚" ˚ ˝ & ˚•

)D ) ,m`\aW* ,

hSab\YE a]\V\yZ\Y S ]`\g,1b*pO k1Y -\`\/V1 1`b`*Z3E Z1]\/*O W1Vd \b -\`\/* pVa1Y+d`-*D \S `\/Sb1WSE ,S/1b1WS 1-\O ,mE ]`SW*-*WS YZ\-\ daSWSyE hb\+m ]`SO ,Sbn YZ1 S Y\SY h1b,1`mY ab*`jSY +`*bnqY S a1ab`*Y f`SabS*ZaVS1 g1ZZ\abSD ]\/`\abV\,m1 -\/m d Y1Zq ab*WS ]\O q,Wqbnaq a1`n14Zm1 a\YZ1ZSq , \bZ\j1ZSS dh1ZSy ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mD ) Z1 ]`S/*,*W* ob\Yd 4Z*h1ZSqE S a\ ,`1Y1Z1Y Y\q ,1`* \aW*O +1W*D \/Sb1WS /1W*WS ,a1E hb\+m ]\Y\hn YZ1E Z\ q \b,1`-*W* Sf ]\Y\knD 14 Sf ,1/\O Y* q ab*W* \+k*bnaq a Y\W\/13npE V\b\`*q \bWSh*W*an +dZb*`aVSY Z*ab`\1YD ) b\31 f\O b1W* \+`1abS a,\+\/dE V\b\`*qE V*4*W\anE +mO W* d ZSfD m ]\ab\qZZ\ ,1a1WSWSan Z* ,1h1O `SZV*fE ,1WS +1a]\`q/\hZdp ]\W\,dp 3S4ZnE ]`SZSY*WS Z*`V\bSVS S Z*]S,*WSanD 1`,\1 ,`1Yq YZ1 Z`*,SW\an +mbn , V\Y]*ZSS WpO /1yE V\b\`m1 +`*WS \b 3S4ZS ,a1D 12

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

) ˛ ˚ ( ˝ ˛ &D /Z*3/mE V\-/* YZ1

+mW\ 5; W1bE q hd,ab,\,*W* a1+q \a\+1ZZ\ ]W\f\D ,SO /1,E , V*V\Y q a\ab\qZSSE Y*O Y* ]\]`\aSW* Y1Zq /*bn S+WSS 1k1 \/SZ j*ZaD Z* ]`1/W\3SW* YZ1 SaaW1O /\,*bn +S+W1yaVS1 dh1ZSq S 4*b1Y `1jSbnE f\hd q 3Sbn , a\-W*aSS a ZSYS SWS Z1bD \b a1`/1hZmy `*4-\,\` ab*W ]\,\`\bZmY ]dZVb\Y , Y\1y 3S4ZSD ) a\-W*aSW*an S4dO h*bn S+WSp a Y\1y ab*`j1y a1ab`\y *`\O WSZ\y S 11 Yd31YE VSe\YD Z Z1 ,\a]SbmO ,*Waq , a1Yn1 ,S/1b1W1yE * ab*W \/ZSY S4 ZSfE +d/dhS ,4`\aWmYD ˛Z*q \ ]`\jO W\Y VSe*E q hd,ab,\,*W*E hb\ Y\-d +mbn a ZSY \bV`\,1ZZ\yD ˙Wq Y1Zq ob\ +mW\ \h1Zn ,*3Z\D

w m ]\ab\qZZ\ ,1a1WSWSan Z* ,1h1`SZV*fE ,1WS +1a]\`q/\hZdp ]\W\,dp 3S4ZnE ]`SZSY*WS Z*`V\bSVS S Z*]S,*WSanx

w) ]\YZp \ a,\Sf \jS+V*fE Z\ ab*`*pan Z1 a\a`1/\b\hS,*bnaq Z* ZSfx

) 4Z*W*E hb\ Y\y \+`*4 3S4ZS Z1]`SO 1YW1Y /Wq ,S/1b1W1yE Z\ ]\Z*h*Wd ahSb*O W*E hb\ b\E V*V q 3S,dEP ob\ Y\1 WShZ\1 /1O W\D /Z*V\E S4dh*q S+WSpE q \a\4Z*W*E hb\ Y\1 ]\,1/1ZS1 4*b`*-S,*1b hd,ab,* 1-\,m L a*W\Y ;<B8>E 85C `SbhS 6;B55MD b\Yd 31 q ]\ZqW*E hb\ \Z\ ,WSq1b S Z* /`d-Sf Wp/1yD \ Y1`1 b\-\ V*V q S4dh*W* S+WSpE q Z*O f\/SW* YZ\-\ W\-ShZmf S d+1/Sb1WnZmf /\V*4*b1Wnab, b\-\E hb\ \Z* W\,\ \-*D *O ]`SY1`E q d4Z*W* \ YZ\-Sf +S+W1yaVSf ]`\O `\h1ab,*fE V\b\`m1 Sa]\WZSWSan ,]W\bn /\ Y1Wnh*yjSf ]\/`\+Z\ab1yD 'bS 4Z*ZSq ]\Y\-WS YZ1 `*4,1qbn Y\S +mWm1 a\YZ1O ZSqD

]dabq ]`SY1`Z\ -\/ ]\aW1 b\-\E V*V q Z*h*W* S4dh*bn S+O WSpE Ym a `\/Sb1WqYS ]\a1O bSWS Y\1-\ ab*`j1-\ +`*b*E V\O b\`my aWd3SW /\+`\,\Wng1Y , eSWS*W1 ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , 1`Y*ZSSD 1Zq -Wd+\V\ b`\ZdO W\ b\E V*V ah*abWS, +mW Y\y +`*bD Y1ZZ\ b*V\-\ ah*abnq q SaV*W*I * Y1Zq b*V31 ]`\S4,1O WS ,]1h*bW1ZS1 /`d-S1 ,S/1O b1WSE V\b\`m1 b*Y b`d/SWSanD *V 31 \ZS \bWSh*WSan \b Y\Sf ]`13ZSf Z1h1abZmf 4Z*V\YmfE V\b\`mf Z1 SZb1`1a\,*W\ ZSh1O -\E V`\Y1 \ab`mf \kdk1ZSyI aV\`1 ]\aW1 ob\-\ q \+`*bSO W*an , a1`/1hZ\y Y\WSb,1 V 1O -\,1 S ]\\+1k*W* aWd3Sbn 1Yd ,ap Y\p 3S4ZnD 5= W1b q aSYO ,\WS4S`\,*W* a,\1 ]\a,qk1ZS1 1-\,1 V`1k1ZS1YD

" & ) ˝ ˛ &D 1]1`n Y\q

3S4Zn ]\WZ* aYmaW*D ) Sa]mbm,*p `*/\abnE \bb\-\ hb\ \+dh*p Wp/1y +S+W1yaV\y SabSO Z1 S ]\Y\-*p SY d4Z*bn \+ 1-\,1 S \ 1-\ \+1k*ZSqfD WdhjSW*an 3S4Zn S Y\Sf /\O Y*jZSf P q +\Wnj1 Z1 /\ab*,Wqp SY +1a]\O V\yab,D ) ]\YZp \ a,\Sf \jS+V*fE Z\ ab*`*pan Z1 a\a`1/\b\hS,*bnaq Z* ZSfD *]`\bS,E q `*4O YmjWqp \ \3n1Y ]`\k1ZSS S 4*+\b1D ) ]\WZ\abnp a\-W*aZ* a\ aW\,*YSE 4*]Sa*ZO ZmYS , `Sbh*f 5>B66B w W*-\aW\,1ZS1 1O -\,m P \Z\ \+\-*k*1bE S \Z Z1 /\+*,Wq1b V Z1Yd +\WSxD

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

13

w 1]\,SZ\,1ZS1E V\b\`\1 ,m4m,*1b d,*31ZS1x ˚ ) a,\1-\ ]`*,W1ZSq 1`Y*ZS1y /\Wne SbW1` ]\WdhSW /1aqbVS bmaqh ]SO ˛ a1YD \aW1 b\-\ V*V , 5=89 -\/d a\,1baVS1 ,\yaV* 4*f,*bSWS 1`WSZE YZ\-S1 S4 obSf ]SO a1Y ]\]*WS , \aV,dE -/1 /\W-S1 -\/m f`*ZSO WSan , *`fS,*fD ab\`SV 1Z`SV '+1`W1 S4dO hSW bmaqhS S4 ZSfE hb\+m d4Z*bnE Vb\ S ]\h1Yd ]Sa*W SbW1`dD ,\S 4*VWph1ZSq '+1`W1 \]d+WSV\,*W , VZS-1 w SanY* SbW1`dx LBriefe an HitlerMD w SbW1`d ]Sa*WS dhSb1Wq S dh1ZSVSE Y\Z*O fSZS S a,qk1ZZSVSE +14`*+\bZm1 S da]1jZm1 ]`1/]`SZSY*b1WSE */YS`*Wm S \+mhZm1 jbd`Y\,SVSxEP -\,\`Sb '+1`W1D ˙*W11 \Z \bY1h*1bB w /ZS ahSb*WS 1-\ ,Z\,n `\3/1ZO ZmY 1aaS1yE /`d-S1 P ,\]W\k1ZS1Y 4W*xD

mWS WS a`1/S ]Sa1YE , V\b\`mf ,m`*3*W\an Z1/\,\Wnab,\ ]`\S4,\W\Y Z*gSab\,E ]SanY* \b `1WS-S\4Zmf `dV\,\/Sb1W1yH mWSE Z\ \ZS ,ab`1h*WSan \h1Zn `1/V\D /Z*V\ , Y\aV\,aVSf *`fS,*f '+1`W1 Z*O j1W ]SanY* SbW1`dE , V\b\`mf ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m S4 `*4Zmf h*ab1y 1`Y*ZSS ,m`*3*WS Z1/\,\Wnab,\ /1yab,SqYS Z*gSab\,D \+k1y aW\3Z\abS ,S/1b1WS S4 ]\hbS 9> ab`*Z Z*O ]`*,SWS , */`1a SbW1`* ]`SY1`Z\ 6> >>> ]Sa1Y S b1W1-`*YYE , V\b\`mf \ad3/*W\an 31ab\V\1 \+`*k1ZS1 a\ ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\O ,mD maqhS ,S/1b1W1y +mWS *`1ab\,*ZmE S Z1aV\WnV\ a\b1Z +mWS V*4Z1Zm SWS dY1`WS \b `dV Z*gSab\,D '+1`W1 ]\/mb\3S,*1bB w a`*,Z1ZSS a YSWWS\Z*YS 31`b, Z*gSabO aV\-\ `13SY* ob\ hSaW\ ]\ab`*/*,jSf ,SO /1b1W1y V*31baq Z1+\WnjSYD \ ,a1 31 \Z\ a,S/1b1Wnab,d1b \ V\WW1VbS,Z\Y S +1aV\Y]`\YSaaZ\Y Z1]\,SZ\,1ZSSE V\b\`\1 ,m4m,*1b d,*31ZS1xD

14

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

˝ • ˚ &

m Y\31b1 Z*ybS w4Z*ZS1 \ \-1x ˚ \ab*,SW Wp/qY +1ag1ZZ\1 a\V`\,Sk1E S \Z -\`qh\ 31W*1bE hb\O +m Ym Z*jWS 1-\D 'b\ a\V`\,Sk1 Z1 a/1O W*1b Z*a +\-*bmYS Y*b1`S*WnZ\E Z\ +W*-\O /*`q 1Yd Y\3Z\ \+`1abS b\E hb\ Z1 VdO ]Sbn ZS 4* V*VS1 /1Zn-SEP /dj1,Zmy ]\V\yE /\,\Wnab,\ S ah*abWS,dp 3S4ZnD b\ ob\ 4* a\V`\,Sk1H b,1b Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , aW\O ,*f g*`q \W\Y\Z*E 4*]Sa*ZZmf , `Sbh*f 6B5P:D \W\Y\Z -\,\`SbE hb\ ob\ a\V`\,Sk1 P w4Z*ZS1 \ \-1xE b\ 1abn SabSZ* \ \-1 S 1-\ 4*YmaW*fE a\/1`3*k*qaq , S+WSS LabSf 9MD ˙*,*yb1 `*aaY\b`SYE hb\ \Z\ , a1+q ,VWpO h*1bD ˛Z*ZS1 SabSZmD S+WSq \b,1h*1b Z* YZ\-S1 ,\]`\amE Z*]`SY1`B V*V\1 SYq d

\-*H L a*W\Y <7B5<MD b\ ]`\Saf\/Sb ]`S aY1`bSH L a*W\Y 58:B7E 8MD ˙Wq h1-\ Ym 4/1anH L mbS1 5B6:P6<C a*W\Y 559B5:MD V\WnV\ +m ,m 4*]W*bSWSE hb\+m ]\WdhSbn \b,1bm Z* obS ,\]`\amH d/`\1 `dV\,\/ab,\D S+WSq ]\Y\-*O 1b Z*Y Z*ybS a*Ymy WdhjSy 3S4Z1ZZmy ]dbnD *V dV`1]Sbn +`*VH L'e1aqZ*Y 9B6<E 6=E 77MD *V ,\a]Sb*bn /1b1y \b,1bab,1ZZmO YS Wp/nYSH L b\`\4*V\ZS1 :B9P;C 'e1O aqZ*Y :B8MD *V \+`1abS ah*abn1H L *be1q 9B7C dVS 55B6<MD V\WnV\E ]\O,*j1YdE ab\qb Z*/13Zm1 a\,1bm ]\ obSY ,\]`\a*YH ˛Z*ZSq \ b\YE V*V\y \- S V*VS1 d Z1O -\ V*h1ab,*D S+WSq P \aZ\,Z\y Sab\hZSV b\hZmf 4Z*ZSy \ \-1D *V\y \ZH L \*ZZ* 5B5<C 8B68MD ˛*+\bSbaq WS \Z \ Z*aH L5 1b`* 9B:E ;MD *V\,m Z1V\b\`m1 S4 1-\ V*h1ab,H L af\/ 78B:E ;C 5 \*ZZ* 8B<MD \ aV\WnO V\ +m ,m \g1ZSWS b\hZm1 4Z*ZSq \ Z*j1Y ,\`g1H

\SabSZ1E w4Z*ZS1 \ \-1x P ob\ /df\,O Z\1 a\V`\,Sk1I *V 1-\ Z*ybSH \/aV*4V* Z*f\/Sbaq , 8OY abSf1 6Oy -W*,m `SbhE , V\b\`\Y \W\Y\Z a`*,ZS,*1b ob\ 4Z*ZS1 a\ wa]`qb*ZZmY a\V`\,Sk1YxD ]`qb*ZZ\1 a\O V`\,Sk1 a*Y\ ]\ a1+1 Z1 ]\]*/1b , W1ZSO ,m1 `dVSD b\+m \bmaV*bn 1-\E Zd3Z\ ]`SO W\3Sbn Z1Y*W\ aSWD \ 31 Y\3Z\ aV*4*bn S \ 4Z*ZSS \ \-1D b\+m Z*ybS ob\ a\V`\,SO k1E a]`qb*ZZ\1 , S+WSSE Z1\+f\/SYm daSO WSqD \W\Y\Z \+lqaZq1bE V*V Z*ybS w4Z*ZS1 \

\-1xD m`*31ZSq w]`SY1jn Y\S aW\,*x S w`*a]\W\3Sjn a,\1 a1`/g1x dV*4m,*pb Z* b\E hb\ Z*j1 a1`/g1 /\W3Z\ +mbn ,\aO ]`SSYhS,mY LabSfS 5E 6MD aW\,* w,4m,*bnxE wSaV*bnx S w`*4maVS,*bnx ]\/`*4dY1,*pb *VbS,Zm1 /1yab,Sq S da1`/S1 LabSfS 7E 8MD W1/\,*b1WnZ\E hb\+m \bmaV*bn ob\ a\V`\O ,Sk1E Ym /\W3Zm ab*`*b1WnZ\ S4dh*bn S+O WSp S /1W*bn ob\ S4 ]`*,SWnZmf ]\+d3/1ZSy L dVS <B59MD ˚aWS Ym b*V ]\abd]*1YE 1-\,* ]\Y\31b Z*Y Z*ybS ob\ a\V`\,Sk1D :OY abSf1 -\,\O `SbaqB w 1-\,* /*1b Yd/`\abnxD \Zqbn +S+O W1yaVS1 SabSZm Y\3Z\ b\WnV\ a ]\Y\knp

\-* L \*ZZ* :B88C ˙1qZSq 5:B58MD d/nb1 d,1`1ZmB 1aWS ,m da1`/Z\ SaaW1/d1b1 W\O ,\ \-*E ,m \bmk1b1 w4Z*ZS1 \ \-1x P ,1O WSh*yj11 a\V`\,Sk1 L `SbhS 6B5>P65M1D 1 ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m ]\ ,a1Yd YS`d ]`1/W*-*pb +1aO ]W*bZ\1 /\Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 S+WSS Wp/qYE V\b\`m1 f\bqb , Z1y `*4\+`*bnaqD +`*bSb1an V ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m , ,*O j1y Y1abZ\abS SWS Z*]SjSb1 ]\ \/Z\Yd S4 */`1a\,E ]`S,1O /1ZZmf Z* ab`*ZSg1 8D

˚ ˚ ˙ ˚ ˚ ˚ ˚

) ˚B

˛ `SbhS 5P65

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

15

˛ • ˚

ob\y ab*bn1 ]\/ZSY*pbaq ,\]`\amE V\b\`m1E ,\4Y\3Z\E d ,*a ,\4ZSV*WSE S \+lqaZq1baqE -/1 , a,\1y S+WSS ,m Y\31b1 Z*ybS Z* ZSf \b,1bmD *V31 ,m Y\31b1 \+ad/Sbn Sf a\ ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,mD

*V a/1W*bn a1Ynp ah*abWS,\yH 5D \h1Yd Z1\+f\/SY\ 4*`1-Sab`S`\,*bn +`*VE hb\+m a1Ynq +mW* ah*abWS,\yH

`*V \aZ\,*W 1-\,*E ah*abWS,my \-D \WnV\ , +`*V1 d Yd3hSZm S 31ZkSZm Y\-db +mbn /\,1`SO b1WnZm1 \bZ\j1ZSqE * Sf /1bS Y\-db `*abS , +W*-\O ]\WdhZ\y \+ab*Z\,V1D *V\y d \-* ,4-Wq/ Z* +`*VH Z f\h1bE hb\+m ob\ +mW /\W-\,1hZmy 4*V\ZZmy a\O p4 Yd3hSZm S 31ZkSZm L dVS 6B5P9MD \- \3S/*O 1bE hb\ Yd3 S 31Z* +d/db ,1`Zm /`d- /`d-d LËš,`1O qY 57B8MD b\hVS 4`1ZSq 1-\,mE f`SabS*ZSZ SY11b ]`*,\ `*4,1abSan S ,abd]Sbn , Z\,my +`*V b\WnV\ , aWdh*1 S4Y1Zm ad]`d-* SWS ad]`d-SD L `\hSb*yb1 *be1q 5=B7P:E =DM

6D *V Yd3 S 31Z* /\W3Zm \+`*k*bnaq /`d- a /`d-\YH 1-\,* a\4/*W Yd3hSZd S 31ZkSZd b*VE hb\+m \ZS /\]\WZqWS /`d- /`d-* L mbS1 6B5<MD d3d \b,1/1Z* `\Wn -W*,m a1YnSD Z /\W31Z \+1a]1hS,*bn a1Ynp Y*O b1`S*WnZ\ S ]\Y\-*bn 31Z1 S /1bqY ]`S\+`1b*bn 4Z*ZSq \ \-1D d3 /\W31Z +mbn -\b\, S/bS `*/S 31Zm Z* 31`O b,mD d]`d-S /\W3Zm Wp+Sbn S d,*3*bn /`d- /`d-*D \O aV\WnVd ,a1 Ym Z1a\,1`j1ZZmE dY1ZS1 ]`\k*bn , 4Z*O hSb1WnZ\y ab1]1ZS a\/1yab,d1b ah*abnp , +`*V1D L `\O hSb*yb1 'e1aqZ*Y 8B75E 76C 9B66P69E 77C 5 1b`* 7B;DM

7D *V +mbnE 1aWS +`*V Z1 ]`SZ\aSb ah*abnqH ËšaWS \bZ\j1ZSq Y13/d ad]`d-*YS Z1 W*O /qbaqE b\ SY \+\SY Zd3Z\ ab`1YSbnaq V b\O YdE hb\+m \+`*k*bnaq /`d- a /`d-\Y a Wp+\,np L5 \`SZeqZ*Y 57B8E 9MD S+WSq Z1 ]\\k`q1b `1j*bn ]`\+W1Ym , +`*V1 a

]\Y\knp `*4/1WnZ\-\ 3Sb1Wnab,*D /Z*O V\ , SaVWphSb1WnZmf aSbd*gSqf \/SZ S4 adO ]`d-\, Y\31b `1jSbnE hb\ 1Yd SWS 1y WdhO j1 3Sbn \b/1WnZ\D L `\hSb*yb1 5 \`SZeqO Z*Y ;B5>P57DM

8D ˙1bSE h1-\ ,*Y 31W*1b \-H 1-\,* f\h1bE hb\+m ,m +mWS ah*abWS,mD Z /*1b Z*SWdhjS1 a\,1bmE +W*-\/*`q V\b\`mY pZm1 -\/m +d/db ]`SZ\aSbn ,*Y `*/\abnD *V31 \Z f\h1bE hb\+m ,m \+`*k*WSan 4* a\,1b\Y V a,\SY `\/Sb1WqYE ]\O aV\WnVd d ZSf +\Wnj1 3S4Z1ZZ\-\ \]mb* L \W\aaqO Z*Y 7B6>MD 1-\,* g1ZSb b\E hb\ ,m aWdj*1b1an `\O /Sb1W1yE ,1/n b*V ,m ]`\aW*,Wq1b1 1-\D L `\hSO b*yb1 'VVW14S*ab 55B=P56B5C *be1q 5=B57P59C 65B59E 5:DM

9D \/Sb1WSE V*V ,m Y\31b1 a/1W*bn a,\Sf /1b1y ah*abWS,mYSH * ,*a W13Sb \+q4*ZZ\abn 4*+\bSbnaq \ b\YE hb\O +m d /1b1y +mW* ]Sk*E \/13/* S V`\, L5 SY\O e1p 9B<MD \ hb\+m ,*jS /1bS +mWS ah*abWS,mE ,*Y b*V31 Zd3Z\ dhSbn Sf Wp+Sbn \-* S aWdj*bnaq 1-\ L'e1aqZ*Y :B8MD \-/* /1bS ,S/qb ,*jd Wp+\,n V \-dE ob\ 4*b`*-S,*1b Sf a1`/g1D ËšaWS ,*jS Z*O ab*,W1ZSq \aZ\,*Zm Z* S+WSSE b\ \ZS ]\Y\-db /1O bqY `*4,S,*bn ]`*,SWnZ\1 YmjW1ZS1D L `\hSb*yb1

b\`\4*V\ZS1 :B8P;C `SbhS 66B:DM ˙1bS Zd3/*pbaq , ]\f,*W1 S /\+`mf aW\,*fD \ ]\`\y Sf Zd3Z\ Sa]`*,Wqbn S Z*ab*,WqbnD *O V\1 d`*,Z\,1j1ZZ\1 ,\a]Sb*ZS1 d+1`131b Sf \b ]\O ,1/1ZSqE V\b\`\1 ,]\aW1/ab,SS Y\-W\ +m a/1W*bn Sf Z1ah*abZmYS L `SbhS 66B59MD /Z*V\ Z*V*4*ZS1 ZSV\-/* Z1 /\W3Z\ +mbn ad`\,mY SWS 31ab\VSYD L `\hSb*yb1 \W\aaqZ*Y 7B65DM ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m S4/*WS Z1aV\WnV\ \aZ\,*ZZmf Z* S+WSS VZS-E V\b\`m1 ]`1/Z*4Z*h1Zm /Wq b\-\E hb\+m ]\Y\-*bn `\/Sb1WqY S /1bqYD L `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 5=B;E 55 5<B<E 56E SZ\/*WnZmy ]1`1,\/ DM

\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , 58Oy -W*,1 ob\y VZS-SE S4/*ZZ\y ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,mD

Ëš Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 )H

17

˙ ˝ • ˚ ˚ ˚

Z* ,abd]SW*an 4* \3Sy Z*`\/ ˚ ˙ ˚ 'aeS`S \bh*qZZ\ V\W\bSW\an , -`d/SE V\-/* \Z* ]\/f\/SW* V ,Zdb`1ZZ1Yd /,\`d ,1WSh1ab,1ZZ\-\ /,\`g* , d4*fD ,1bZm1 +*`1Wn1em ,\SZ\,E Wn,\, S V`mW*bmf +mV\, Z* -W*4d`\,*ZZ\Y VS`]Sh1E \-`\YZm1 V*Y1ZZm1 V\W\ZZm S ab*bdSE * b*V31 a*Y /,\`1gE `*a]\W\31ZZmy Z* Y*aaS,Z\y ]W*be\`Y1 +WS4 4*aZ131ZZmf -\` ˛*-`\aE Z* +1`1-d V`Sab*WnZ\ hSab\y `1VS \*a]EP ,a1 ob\ -\,\`SW\ \ Z1+m,*W\Y Y\-dk1ab,1 h1W\,1V*E ]1`1/ V\b\`mY a\+S`*W*an ]`1/ab*bn 'aeS`nE h1W\,1V*E V\b\`my Z*4m,*W a1+q w,1WSVSY g*`1YxD 'b\ +mW 11 Yd3D d3I f*j,1`\j1 +mW a\,a1Y Z1 b*VSY Yd31YE V*V\-\ Y\-W* 31W*bn a1+1 +\-\+\q4O Z1ZZ*q Sd/1yaV*q /1,djV*D Z Z1 ahSb*W Zd3ZmY `*,Zqbnaq Z* V\-\OWS+\E Z*]`SO Y1` Z* ,`**Y*E V\b\`my aYS`1ZZ\ ,ZqW \3n1Yd ]\,1W1ZSp S ]\aWdj*Waq a,\1y 31ZmE *``m L mbS1 65B56MD *`n Z1 4Z*W ZSh1-\ SWS ]\hbS ZSh1-\ \+ 1-\,1E \-1 'aeS`SE S \ 1-\ ˛*V\Z1D ˛*b\ \Z 4Z*W 4*O V\Z ]1`a\,E 4*]`1k*,jSy b\E hb\ a\+S`*O W*an a/1W*bn 'aeS`nD b\ SY1ZZ\H ˛*V\Z -W*aSWE hb\ Wp+\YdE Vb\ ]`1/ab*Z1b ]1`1/ ]1`aS/aVSY Y\Z*`f\Y Z14,*ZmYE -`\4Sb aY1`bZ*q V*4ZnD *`n Z1 4,*W 'aeS`nE Z\ \Z* ,a1 `*,Z\ V Z1Yd jW*D 1Y +WS31 \Z* ]\/f\/SW* V ,Zdb`1ZZ1Yd /,\`dE -/1 11 Y\d,S/1bn g*`nE b1Y \ab`11E /\W3Z\ +mbnE d Z11 ab*Z\,SW\an hd,ab,\E hb\ \Z* S/1b Z* ,1`Zdp aY1`bn L'aeS`n 8B55C 9B5MD ˛*h1Y 'aeS`n b*V `SaV\,*W*H 1Yd ,1O `* ob\y d/S,Sb1WnZ\y 31ZkSZm Y\31b Z*O dhSbn Z*aH `13/1 h1Y \b,1bSbn Z* obS ,\O ]`\amE /*,*yb1 d4Z*1YE V*V \Z* ab*W* g*O `Sg1y 1`aSSD 1 `SZqb\ ahSb*bnE hb\ f*j,1`\j P ob\ a1`Va IE V\b\O `my ]`*,SW 1`aS/aV\y SY]1`S1y , Z*h*W1 V ,1V* /\ ZD oD

18

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

˙1,djV* `1/V\y V`*a\bm

'aeS`n +mW* aS`\b\yD *Y ZSh1-\ Z1 S4,1abZ\ \ 11 `\/Sb1WqfE V\b\`m1 /*WS 1y SYq */*aa*E hb\ , ]1`1,\/1 a 1,`1yaV\O -\ q4mV* \4Z*h*1b wYS`bx P Vdab*`ZSV a Z13ZmYS +1WmYS g,1bV*YSD \-/* `\/SO b1WS 'aeS`S dY1`WSE \ Z1y ab*W 4*+\O bSbnaq 11 /,\p`\/Zmy +`*b *`/\f1yE V\O b\`my +mW Z*YZ\-\ ab*`j1 11D Z 4*+`*W 11 V a1+1 S \bZ\aSWaq V Z1y V*V V `\/Z\y /\h1`S L'aeS`n 6B9P;E 59MD *`/\f1y S 'aeS`n +mWS Sd/1yaVSYS ]1`1a1W1Zg*YSD ˛/1anE , ab\WSg1 1`O aS/aV\y SY]1`SSE V ZSYE ,\4Y\3Z\E \bZ\O aSWSan a ]`14`1ZS1Y S4O4* Sf ,1`m S ˛*O V\Z*E V\b\`my \ZS a\+Wp/*WSD *`/\f1y `*aaV*4m,*W 'aeS`S \ YSW\a1`/Z\Y \O -1E 1-\,1E V\b\`my Z1\/Z\V`*bZ\ a]*a*W a,\y Z*`\/ , ]`\jW\Y S \+1k*W /1W*bn ob\ , +d/dk1Y L 1,Sb 6:B88E 89MD 1a\YO Z1ZZ\E ob\ 1k1 +\Wnj1 a+WS3*W\ Sf /`da /`d-\YD h1,S/Z\E *`/\f1y +mW hSZ\,ZSV\Y , /,\`g1 , d4*f S aS/1W d 1-\ ,\`\b ,Y1ab1 a /`d-SYS aWd-*YS g*`q L'aeS`n 6B5=E 65C 7B7MD m Z1 4Z*1YE h1Y 4*ZSY*W*an 'aeS`n

, pZ\abSE Z\ Y\3Z\ ]`1/]\W\3SbnE hb\ \Z* a Wp+\,np 4*+\bSW*an \ a,\1Y /,\pO `\/Z\Y +`*b1 S 1-\ /\Y1E V\b\`myE ,1`\qbO Z\E +mW ]\ /`d-dp ab\`\Zd `1VS \b g*`O aV\-\ /,\`g*E , b\y h*abS -\`\/*E -/1 3SO WS +1/Zm1 Wp/SD \4Y\3Z\E \Z* f\/SW* 4* ]\Vd]V*YS Z* -\`\/aV\y `mZ\V S Z1 \bO V*4m,*W* a1+1 , d/\,\Wnab,SS ]\aY\b`1bn Z* b\,*`mE V\b\`m1 ]`1/W*-*WS 4\W\bmf S a1`1+`qZmf /1W Y*ab1`* S Vd]gmD 'aeS`n Z1 Y\-W* S ]\/dY*bnE hb\ b*VS1 /`*-\g1ZO Z\abS ab*Zdb /Wq Z11 \+mhZmY /1W\YD Z* /*31 Z1 ]`1/ab*,WqW*E hb\ \3S/*1b 11 , +d/dk1YD *`Sg* WSj1Z* a,\1-\ 4,*ZSq

/Z*3/m d4m ,ab`1,\3SW aWdf \ b\YE hb\ , g*`aV\y a1Yn1 b,\`Sbaq hb\Ob\ Z1O W*/Z\1D f*j,1`\j dab`\SW /Wq a,\Sf a*Z\,ZSV\, +\Wnj\y ]S`E Z* V\b\`\Y ]\O *`/\f1q +mWS ,a1 \aZ\,*ZSq -\`/Sbnaq a,\1y ]`S1YZ\y /\h1`np

/*,*WS S4maV*ZZm1 +Wp/* S ,SZ*D Z ]\4,*W a,\p 31ZdE V`*aS,dp g*`Sgd *jO bSE V\b\`*q dab`\SW* ]S` /Wq 31ZkSZD \ \Z* Z1 4*f\b1W* ]`SybSD aV\`+W1ZZmy g*`n , -Z1,1 a]`\aSW d a,\Sf a\,1bZSV\,E V*V aW1/d1b 11 Z*V*4*bnD *V\y a\,1b \ZS 1Yd /*WSH SjSbn 11 g*`aV\-\ 4,*ZSqI \-/* g*`n ,1W1W a,\SY aWd-*Y `*4maV*bn ,\ ,a1y SY]1`SS V`*aS,mf /1,dj1VE hb\O +m \Z ,m+`*W S4 Sf hSaW* Z\,dp g*`Sgd L'aeS`n 5B5P6B8MD \3Z\ ]`1/ab*,Sbn a1+1E V*V *`/\O f1y a Wp+\,np aY\b`1W Z* 'aeS`n S SaO ]mbm,*W -\`/\abn S b`1,\-dE 4*Y1h*qE hb\ \Z* ,m`\aW* S ab*W* Z1\+mVZ\,1ZZ\ V`*O aS,\yD 'aeS`n 6B; -\,\`SbaqB w'b* Y\O W\/*q 31ZkSZ* +mW* ab`\yZ* S V`*aS,*xD 1a\YZ1ZZ\E V`*a\b* P ob\ /\ab\SZab,\E Z\ \Z* /\W3Z* a\h1b*bnaq a Yd/`\abnp S aV`\YZ\abnpD Z*h1 S4O4* Z11 , a1`/g1 Y\O -db `*4,Sbnaq -\`/\abnE bk1aW*,S1 S /`dO -S1 \bb*WVS,*pkS1 V*h1ab,* L `SbhS 55B66MD ˙\,\/SW\an WS ,*Y Z*+Wp/*bn ]\O /\+Z\1H 1 Sa]\`bSb WS V`*a\b* 'aeS`nH `1Yq ]\V*31bD

Wd-S g*`q d,S/1WS 'aeS`nD ZS 4*O +`*WS 11 \b *`/\f1q S ]`S,1WS , `\O aV\jZmy /,\`1g Z* /`d-\Y +1`1-d `1VS L'aeS`n 6B<MD *aab*,*bnaqE Z*,1`Z\1E +mO W\ \h1Zn bq31W\E ,1/n *`/\f1y S 'aeS`n +mWS +WS4VSE aW\,Z\ \b1g S /\hnD *`O /\f1y Z1 31W*WE hb\+m 1-\ ]`S1YZ*q /\hn ,mjW* 4*Yd3 4* Z1Sd/1qE ]dabn /*31 4* g*`qE Z\ , ob\y aSbd*gSS \Z +mW +1aaSW1ZD 'aeS`nE /\W3Z\ +mbnE \h1Zn ,ZSY*b1WnZ\ aWdj*W* 1-\ Z*]dbab,SqE ]`13/1 h1Y 11 d,1WSD \ /\`\-1 ,\ /,\`1g \Z* ,a1 aZ\,* S aZ\,* a]`*jS,*W* a1+qE hb\ 3/1b 11 ,]1O `1/SH Z* \+`1W* w+W*-\aVW\ZZ\abn , -W*4*f ,a1fE Vb\ 11 ,S/1Wx

'aeS`n ]\]*W* , a\,a1Y /`d-\yE hd3/my 1y YS`D Z* \V*4*W*an a`1/S wYZ\-Sf Y\O W\/mf 31ZkSZxE V\b\`mf ]`S,1WS a\ ,a1f V`*1, 1`aS/aV\y SY]1`SSD 1`\qbZ\E \ZS ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

19

'aeS`n ]\ZSY*W*E hb\ aV`\YZ\abn S Yd/`\abn Z*YZ\-\ ,*3Z11 V`*a\bm

-\,\`SWS Z* `*4Zmf q4mV*f S ]`S/1`3S,*O WSan `*4Zmf \+mh*1, S ,4-Wq/\,D ˙1,dj1V \b/*WS Z* ]\]1h1ZS1 ]`S/,\`Z\-\ 1-*qE S \ZS g1Wmy -\/ ]`\f\/SWS V\aY1bSh1aVS1 ]`\g1/d`mE V\b\`m1 ,VWph*WS Y*aa*3 a +W*-\,\ZZmYS Y*aW*YS L'aeS`n 6B<E 56MD b*V\y \+ab*Z\,V1 d /1,dj1V W1-V\ Y\-O WS ]\q,Sbnaq \/1`3SY\abn a,\1y ,Z1jZ\O abnpE bk1aW*,S1 S /df a\]1`ZSh1ab,*D \O ,WSqW\ WS ob\ Z* 'aeS`nH S \/SZ h1W\,1V Z1 ]1`13S,*W 4* 'aO eS`n b*V aSWnZ\E V*V *`/\f1yD S+WSS a\\+k*1baqE hb\ \Z V*3/my /1Zn ]`Sf\O /SW V /,\`d /\Y* /Wq 31ZkSZ S ]mb*Waq d4Z*bnE ,a1 WS f\`\j\ d 'aeS`S L'aeS`n 6B55MD \ Z1YZ\-\1E hb\ \Z d4Z*,*W \ Z1y h1O `14 aWd-E Z1a\YZ1ZZ\E Z*]\WZqW\ 1-\ a1`/O g1 \bg\,aV\y -\`/\abnpD \h1YdH 'aeS`n \h1Zn ]\Z`*,SW*an 1-*pE S \Z ab*W \bZ\aSbnaq V Z1y a \a\+\y /\+`\b\yD Z /*W 1y a1Yn /1,dj1V , aWd3*ZVS S ]1O `1,1W 11 , Wdhjdp h*abn /\Y* /Wq 31ZO kSZD ]\,1ab,\,*ZSS -\,\`SbaqB w'aO eS`nDDD \+`1b*W* +W*-\aVW\ZZ\abn , -W*O 4*f ,a1fE Vb\ 11 ,S/1Wx L'aeS`n 6B=E 59MD \ b\WnV\ WS a,\1y V`*a\b\y 'aeS`n 4*,\1,mO 20

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

,*W* `*a]\W\31ZS1 Wp/1yH 1bE , Z1y +mO W\ hb\Ob\ 1k1D *]`SY1`E , S+WSS -\,\`SbaqB w'aeS`n ZSV\Yd Z1 `*aaV*4*W* ZS \ a,\1Y Z*`\O /1E ZS \ a,\Sf `\/ab,1ZZSV*fE ]\b\Yd hb\ *`/\f1y ,1W1W 1yE hb\+m \Z* Z1 `*aaV*4mO ,*W*x L'aeS`n 6B5>MD *`/\f1y aV*4*W 'aO eS`S Z1 -\,\`Sbn \ a,\1Y ]`\Saf\3/1ZSSB \Z ,S/1WE hb\ YZ\-S1 ]`S /,\`1 \bZ\aqbaq V Sd/1qY a ]`1/d+13/1ZS1YD *V 31 ]`SqbO Z\ 1Yd +mW\ d4Z*bnE hb\ 'aeS`nE f\bq S Z1 Z*f\/Sbaq `q/\Y a ZSYE ]\O]`13Z1Yd ]`\O q,Wq1b Yd/`\abn S ]\aWdj*ZS1I \/\+ZmY \+`*4\Y a1-\/Zq pZ\jS S /1O ,djVS Y\-db `*/\,*bn a,\Sf `\/Sb1W1y S \]1VdZ\,D \-/* b1f Z1b `q/\YE \ZS P /*31 , \V`d31ZSS W1-V\YmaW1ZZmf S +14O Z`*,ab,1ZZmf Wp/1y P Y\-db ]`\bS,\ab\O qbn ]W\f\Yd ,WSqZSp S b,1`/\ /1`3*bnaq b\-\E hb\ ]`*,SWnZ\D \abd]*q b*VE Y\O W\/m1 Wp/SE ]\/\+Z\ 'aeS`SE +d/db `*/\O ,*bn a1`/g1 a,\1-\ Z1+1aZ\-\ bg* L `SbO hS 6;B55MD \-/* Z*abd]SW h1`1/ 'aeS`S ]`1/O ab*bn ]1`1/ g*`1YE 1y ]\4,\WSWS ,m+`*bn ,a1E hb\ \Z* ]\31W*1bE hb\+m ,m-Wq/1bn

1k1 +\W11 ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\D /Z*V\ \Z*E ]`\q,S, aV`\YZ\abnE Z1 ab*W* ]`\aSbn ZSO h1-\E V`\Y1 b\-\E hb\ ]\a\,1b\,*W 1y 1-*y L'aeS`n 6B59MD V\`11 ,a1-\E \Z* ]\ZSY*W*E hb\ \/Z\y WSjn V`*a\b\y g*`q Z1 d/S,SbnE * ,\b aYS`1ZS1 S aV`\YZ\abnE V\b\`m1 +mO WS ,1anY* `1/VS ]`S /,\`1E Z*,1`ZqV*E ]\O V\`qb 1-\ a1`/g1D V*4*W*an WS \Z* ]`*,*H S+WSS -\,\`SbaqB w *`n ]\Wp+SW 'aO eS`n +\Wnj1 ,a1f /`d-Sf 31ZkSZ S \bZ\O aSWaq V Z1y a +\Wnj1y +W*-\aVW\ZZ\abnp S Wp+qk1y /\+`\b\yE h1Y V\ ,a1Y /`d-SY /1,ab,1ZZSg*YD Z ,\4W\3SW 1y Z* -\W\,d g*`aVSy -\W\,Z\y d+\` S a/1W*W 11 g*`SO g1y ,Y1ab\ *jbSx L'aeS`n 6B5;MD V`\YO Z\y Sd/1yaV\y /1,djV1E Z*,1`Z\1E +mW\ Z1O ]`\ab\ ]`S,mVZdbn V a,\1y Z\,\y `\WS P g*`Sgm S 31Zm a*Y\-\ Y\-dk1ab,1ZZ\-\ Y\Z*`f* b\-\ ,`1Y1ZSI aV`d3SW\ WS ob\ 1y -\W\,dH \4-\`/SW*an WS \Z*E ab*, g*O `Sg1yH

\,a1Y Z1bD 'aeS`n \ab*W*an ]\aWdjO Z\y a,\1Yd ]`S1YZ\Yd \bgdE *`/\f1pD Z* ]\O]`13Z1Yd /1`3*W* , b*yZ1E hb\ +mW* Sd/1yV\yD `\Y1 b\-\E V\-/* *`O /\f1y d4Z*W \ 4*-\,\`1 ]`\bS, f*j,1`\O j*E 'aeS`n ]\aWdjZ\ ]1`1/*W* 1-\ aW\O ,* g*`pE S 4*-\,\`kSV\, Z*V*4*WS L'aO eS`n 6B6>P67MD ˚1 ,1`* , \-* ,m`*3*O W*an , aV`\YZ\abS S ]\aWdj*ZSSD 1-\/Zq ]\aWdj*ZS1 Z1 , ]\h1b1E * Z1]\V\`Z\abn S +dZb*`ab,\ ab*WS Z\`Y\yD \ b1E Vb\ SaO V`1ZZ1 ,1`Sb , \-*E ]\/\+Z\ 'aeS`SE ]`\O q,Wqpb ob\ g1ZZ\1 V*h1ab,\D 1`* 'aeS`S Sa]mbm,*1baq

1Y ,`1Y1Z1Y ]`S /,\`1 f*j,1`\j* ,a1 +\W11 ,WSqb1WnZmY ab*Z\,SWaq h1W\O ,1V ]\ SY1ZS Y*ZD *`n Z*4Z*hSW 1-\ -W*,ZmY a*Z\,ZSV\Y S a,\SY a\,1bZSO V\YD *V Y*Z ab*W ,b\`mY WSg\Y , g*`O ab,1D *`n /*31 S4/*W dV*4E hb\+m ,a1E Vb\ ,S/Sb Y*Z*E VW*ZqWSan 1Yd L'aeS`n 7B5P8MD 'b\b dV*4 a\4/*W b`d/Z\abS *`O /\f1pD Z ]\ZSY*WE hb\ /\W31Z ]\,SZ\O

,*bnaq g*`pE Z\ Z1 b\-/*E V\-/* obSY Y\3Z\ \aV\`+Sbn \-*D ˙1W\ , b\YE hb\ Y*Z +mW *-*-SbqZSZ\YD \ ,a1y ,S/SY\abSE \Z +mW ]\b\YV\Y -*-*E g*`q *Y*WSVSbqZE V\b\`\O -\ d+SW \3Sy ]`\`\V *YdSW L5 *YdSW* 59B77MD Y*WSVSbqZ1 +mWS ,`*-*YS 1-\,m S 4`*SWqD 'b\b Z1h1abS,my Z*`\/ 4*O aWd3SW \ad3/1ZSq 1-\,m L b\`\4*V\ZS1 69B5=M1D *V Y\- ,1`Zmy \-d Sd/1y ]\VW\O ZSbnaq *Y*WSVSbqZSZdH *`/\f1y b,1`/\ `1jSW Z1 /1W*bn ob\-\D \ a1y /1Zn +\-\O +\q4Z1ZZm1 Yd3hSZm S 31ZkSZm /*31 ]1O `1/ WSg\Y aY1`bS ]`S/1`3S,*pbaq ]`SZO gS]*B w m /\W3Zm ]\/hSZqbnaq \-d V*V ]`*,Sb1WpE * Z1 Wp/qYx L˙1qZSq 9B6=MD 'b\ ]`S,1W\ Y*Z* , q`\abnI ˚Yd ]\V*O 4*W\an Y*W\ d+Sbn \/Z\-\ *`/\f1qD Z 4*O f\b1W Sab`1+Sbn ,1an 1-\ Z*`\/I `*4-\,\O `1 a g*`1Y \Z \h1`ZSW Sd/11,D 1 \+lqaZqq V\ZV`1bZ\E \ V\Y \Z -\,\`SbE Y*Z aV*4*WE hb\ Sd/1S P Z14Z*hSb1WnZmy Z*`\/E w`*aO a1qZZmy a`1/S Z*`\/\, S 3S,dkSy \+\a\+O W1ZZ\xD Z ]\j1W 1k1 /*Wnj1 S aV*4*WE hb\ \ZS Z1 ]\,SZdpbaq 4*V\Z*Y g*`q S ]\oO b\Yd ]`1/ab*,Wqpb d-`\4d SY]1`SSD Y*Z ]`1/W\3SW ,Z1abS , g*`aVdp V*4Zd \-`\YO Zdp adYYd /1Z1-E hb\+m ]\V`mbn `*af\/mE a,q4*ZZm1 a Sab`1+W1ZS1Y Sd/11,2D \-/* f*j,1`\j /*W Y*Zd g*`aVSy ]1`ab1Zn a ]1h*bnpE V\b\`mY \Z Y\- 4*,1`Sbn Wp+\y dV*4 L'aeS`n 7B9P5>MD aV\`1 ,\ ,a1 V\Zgm \-`\YZ\y SY]1`SS ]\Yh*WSan -\ZgmE Z1aq ,1abn \ aY1`bZ\Y ]`S-\,\`1 Sd/1yaV\Yd Z*`\/dD `1/ab*,nO b1E V*V\,\ +mW\ aWmj*bn ob\b dV*4 SdO /1qY , /*W1V\Y 1`da*WSY1E V\b\`m1E ,1`O Zd,jSan bd/* S4 ,*,SW\ZaV\-\ ]W1Z*E ]mO b*WSan \bab`\Sbn -\`\/E /\ aSf ]\` Z1 1 \ ,a1y ,S/SY\abSE Y*Z +mW \/ZSY S4 ]\aW1/ZSf *Y*O WSVSbqZE ]\aV\WnVd Sf w\ab*b\Vx +mW Sab`1+W1Z ,\ /ZS g*`q ˚41VSS L5 1b\]San 8B87MD 2 Y*Z ]`1/W\3SW 5> >>> a1`1+`qZmf b*W*Zb\, P a\bZS YSWWS\Z\, /\WW*`\, ]\ ZmZ1jZSY Y1`V*YD ˚aWS f*j,1O `\j P ob\ a1`Va IE b\ d]\YSZ*ZS1 \ /1Zn-*f Y\-W\ +mbn /Wq Z1-\ ,1a\YmY *`-dY1Zb\YE ]\aV\WnVd ,\yZ* a -`1V*YSE V\b\O `*q ]`\S4\jW*E ,1`\qbZ\E 1k1 /\ 1-\ +`*V* a 'aeS`npE \]dO ab\jSW* 1-\ V*4ZdD ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

21

SaVdq 3S4ZnpE 'aeS`n ,abd]SW*an 4* Z*`\/ \-*

SY1,jSy 4*kSbZ\y ab1ZmI 1`\qbZ\E daO Wmj*, obd d3*aZdp ,1abnE *`/\f1y ]\O /dY*W \ ZSfE * b*V31 \ a,\Sf /`d4nqf S `\/ab,1ZZSV*f , d4*fD Z1 a1+q \b -\`qE \Z `*4\`,*W Z* a1+1 \/13/dE Z*/1W Y1jV\O ,SZdE ]\am]*W a1+q ]1]W\Y SE ,my/q Z* a1O `1/SZd -\`\/*E ab*W -`\YV\ ]W*V*bnD Y*Z 31 a1W ]Sbn a g*`1YD ˚-\ ZSaV\WnV\ Z1 ,\WO Z\,*W\ b\E , V*V\1 \bh*qZS1 \Z ]\,1`YZ\-Sf Sd/11, S Sf /`d41y , d4*f L'aeS`n 7B56P8B5MD *`/\f1y 4Z*WE hb\ Z*/\ /1yab,\,*bnD \ hb\ \Z Y\- a/1W*bnH aWmj*, \ 1-\ ab`*/*ZSqfE 'aeS`n ]\aW*W* 1Yd \/13O /dE Z\ \Z Z1 f\b1W ]`SZqbn db1j1ZS1D \O 31b +mbnE \Z d31 /\W-\1 ,`1Yq Z1/\dY1O ,*WE ]\h1Yd 1-\,* /\]dabSWE hb\+m 1-\ Wp+SYdp 'aeS`n 4*+`*WS S a/1W*WS 31O Z\y q4mh1aV\-\ g*`qD 1]1`nE V*31baqE 22

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

,a1 ]`\qaZSW\anD *`/\f1y ]\aW*W a\\+O k1ZS1 g*`Sg1E dY\Wqq 11 ]\-\,\`Sbn a g*O `1Y S ,abd]Sbnaq w4* a,\y Z*`\/x L'aeS`n 8B8P<MD \-/* 'aeS`S ]1`1/*WS 1-\ ]`\an+dE 11E Z*,1`Z\1E \f,*bSW ab`*fD 'b\ +mW\ a*O YmY +\WnjSY Sa]mb*ZS1Y 11 ,1`mD Z* +\O qW*an S h1abZ\ aV*4*W* \+ ob\Y *`/\f1pD 'aeS`n Z*]\YZSW* 1Yd \ 4*V\Z1E V\b\`my ]\/ ab`*f\Y aY1`bS 4*]`1k*W ]`Sf\/Sbn V g*`p Z14,*ZmYD \WnV\ 1aWS g*`n ]`\bqO Z1b a,\y 4\W\b\y aVS]1b`E ]`Sj1/j1Yd +dO /1b a\f`*Z1Z* 3S4ZnD \-W* WS 'aeS`n `*aahSbm,*bn Z* aZSaf\3/1ZS1 g*`qE \a\O +1ZZ\ ]`SZSY*q ,\ ,ZSY*ZS1 dh*abnE ]\O abS-jdp *jbSE V\b\`*q \bV*4*W*an ]`1/O ab*bn ]1`1/ ZSYH 'aeS`n aV*4*W* *`/\O f1pE hb\ g*`n Z1 4,*W 11 d31 7> /Z1yI 'b\ /*,*W\ 1y ,a1 \aZ\,*ZSq /dY*bnE hb\ \Z*

67B58MD *`/\f1y aV*4*W 'aeS`SB w b\ 4Z*O 1bE Z1 /Wq b*V\-\ WS ,`1Y1ZS bm S /\abS-O W* g*`aV\-\ ]\W\31ZSqHx L'aeS`n 8B56P58MD *`/\f1y ,a1g1W\ ]\W*-*Waq Z* a,\1-\ \O -*E 1-\,dD \3Z\ WS b\ 31 aV*4*bn S \ Z*aH L `SbhS 7B9E :MD 1`* aSWnZ11 ab`*f* ]1`1/ aY1`bnp

db`*bSW* +W*-\aVW\ZZ\abn Z1]\ab\qZZ\-\ Y\Z*`f* L'aeS`n 8B=P55M1D ,1`/my \b,1b *`/\f1q dV`1]SW ,1`d 'aO eS`SD Z aV*4*W 1yE hb\ 1aWS \Z* Z1 +d/1b /1yab,\,*bnE b\ S4+*,W1ZS1 /Wq Sd/11, ]`SO /1b a /`d-\y ab\`\ZmD \ Y\31b WS \Z* Z*/1qbnaq Z* a]*a1ZS1E 1aWS ]`1aW1/\,*ZSq Z*+1`db aSWdH *V ]`\q,SW*an V`1]V*q ,1`* *`/\f1q , 1-\,dE V\b\`my ZSV\-/* Z1 /\O ]dabSbE hb\+m 1-\ Z*`\/ +mW Sab`1+W1ZE * \+1k*ZSq Z1 Sa]\WZSWSan L Sada *,SZ 1 a1`Va I +mW S4,1ab1Z a,\SY Z1]\ab\qZab,\Y S 31ab\V\O abnpD `1h1aVSy Sab\`SV 1`\/\b 4*]Sa*W Z1aV\WnV\ aWdh*O 1,E ]`\S4\j1/jSf ,\ ,`1Yq ,\yZm a1`Va* a -`1V*YSD /O Z*3/m g*`n `*a]\`q/SWaqE hb\+m h1`14 ]`\WS, 1WW1a]\Zb +mW ]\ab`\1Z ,`1Y1ZZmy Y\ab S4 V\`*+W1yD \-/* jb\`Y `*4O `djSW Y\abE a1`Va ]`SV*4*W \+14-W*,Sbn 4\/hSfE * 1WW1aO ]\Zb wZ*V*4*bnxE +Shdq 1-\ ,\/m S ]`\S4Z\aq ]`S ob\Y \aV\`O +Sb1WnZm1 aW\,*D V\-/* , b\y 31 ,\1ZZ\y V*Y]*ZSS \/SZ +\-*bmy h1W\,1V ab*W ]`\aSbn g*`q \a,\+\/Sbn amZ* \b dh*O abSq , ]\f\/1E a1`Va ]`SV*4*W `*4`d+Sbn 1-\ amZ* ]\]\W*Y S ]\W\3Sbn 1-\ b1W\ Z* ,S/d d \ab*WnZmf /Wq dab`*j1ZSqD

˙Wq 'aeS`S Z*abd]SW `1j*pkSy Y\O Y1ZbD Z* ]\]`\aSW* *`/\f1qE hb\+m ,a1 Sd/1S , d4*f b`S /Zq ]\abSWSan ,Y1ab1 a Z1yD ˛*b1Y \Z* ]`\S4Z1aW* aW\,*E V\b\`m1 a]dabq YZ\-S1 ,1V* ]\O]`13Z1Yd a,S/1b1WnO ab,dpb \ 11 Yd31ab,1 S V`1]V\y ,1`1B w˚aO WS YZ1 ]`S/1baq ]\-S+ZdbnE b\ ]\-S+Zdx L'aO eS`n 8B59P5;MD *,1`Z\1E obS b`S /Zq \Z* Y\WSW*an b*V -\`qh\E V*V ZSV\-/* ]`13O /1D \ ,\b Z*abd]SW\ ,`1Yq /1yab,\,*bnD 'aO eS`n \/1W*an , Wdhjdp g*`aVdp \/13/d S a/1W*W* ,a1E hb\ Y\-W*E hb\+m g*`n ,ab`1bSW 11 a +W*-\aVW\ZZ\abnpD ˛*b1Y \Z* ]\jW* V g*`pD *V \]Sam,*W\an , Z*h*W1 ab*bnSE 'aeS`n jW* ,\ ,Zdb`1ZZSy /,\` g*`aV\-\ /,\`g*D \3Z\ ]`1/ab*,SbnE V*V aSWnZ\ \Z* b\-/* ]1`13S,*W* S V*V -\`qh\ Y\WSW*anD 'aeS`n ,\jW* ,\ ,Zdb`1ZZSy /,\`E \bVd/* \Z* Y\-O W* ,S/1bn f*j,1`\j*E aS/qk1-\ Z* b`\Z1D

V\`11 ,a1-\E \Z*E ]mb*qan ]\ZqbnE , V*V\Y \Z Z*ab`\1ZSSE a +1a]\V\yab,\Y ,-Wq/m,*O W*an , 1-\ WSg\E \+`*YW1ZZ\1 *VVd`*bZ\ 4*O ,SbmYSE aSYY1b`ShZmYS Vd/`qYS S ]`qY\O d-\WnZ\y +\`\/\yD ˚aWS 1y ]`SjW\an 3/*bnE b\ ob\ ,`1Yq bqZdW\an /Wq Z11 YdhSb1WnZ\ /\W-\D ,\b Yd3 d,S/1W 11D ZE Z1a\YZ1ZO Z\E \h1Zn d/S,SWaqE Z\ 1-\ WSg\ aYq-hSW\anD Z ]`\bqZdW 1y 4\W\b\y aVS]1b`I L'aeS`n 9B5E 6MD *`n ]`SZqW S ,maWdj*W 'aeS`nD /1W*, b\E hb\ d-\/Z\ \-dE S ,abd]S,jSan 4* a,\y Z*`\/E \Z* ]\/*W* ,a1Y aWd3Sb1WqY \-* 4*O Y1h*b1WnZmy ]`SY1` ,1`mD \ a*Y\1 b`d/Z\1 \3S/*W\ 11 ,]1`1/SD *V 1y d+1/Sbn g*`q , b\YE hb\ Y*ZE 1-\ ]`S+WS31ZZmy a*Z\,ZSV S a\,1bZSVE Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 4W\+Zmy SZb`SO -*ZH *V 1y a]*abS a,\y Z*`\/H b,1bm Z* obS ,\]`\am +d/db \+ad3/*bnaq ]\4/Z11D ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

23

• ˚ ˙˚ ˚•

\-/* Ym /\W3Zm +\/`ab,\,*bn

˚ E bm a\-W*aSjnaqE hb\ , ˚˚ jV\W1 \h1Zn ,*3Z\ +\/`ab,\,*bnD Z\O -S1 VWppb Z\a\Y ,\ ,`1Yq d`\V\,E Z\E hb\+m f\`\j\ dhSbnaqE b1+1 Zd3Z\ +\/`ab,\,*bnD

\4Y\3Z\E bm f\/Sjn Z* ,ab`1hSE Z* V\b\`mf S4dh*1jn S+WSpEP Z* ZSf b\31 Z1Wn4q a]*bnD *V bm /dY*1jnE hb\ ]\Y\31b b1+1 +\/O `ab,\,*bnH 1 /SZ f\`\jSy a\,1b P ,\O ,`1Yq W\3Sbnaq a]*bnD `\Y1 b\-\E ]\Y\-*1b V\`\bVSy a\Z /Z1YD ˙*,*y ]\aY\b`SYE h1Yd Z*a Y\31b Z*dhSbn `*aaV*4 \ Y\W\/\Y h1W\O ,1V1E V\b\`my 4*aZdW ,\ ,`1Yq `1hS *]\ab\O W* *,W*D bV`\1Y , S+WSS ˙1qZSqE 6>Op -W*,dE abSfS a ;O-\ ]\ 56OyE S d4Z*1YE hb\ b\-O /* ]`\S4\jW\D *,1W ]\a1k*W a\+`*ZS1 , ]\`b\,\Y -\O `\/1 `\*/*D S+WSS aV*4*Z\E hb\ wZ* aW1O /dpkSy /1Znx \Z a\+S`*Waq \b]`*,Sbnaq , ]dbn Z* V\`*+W1D \ob\Yd *,1W w]`\/\W3*W a,\p `1hn /\ ]\WdZ\hSxD ˙*W11 Ym hSb*1YB w /SZ Y\W\/\y h1W\,1VE ]\ SY1ZS ˚,bSfE aSO /1,jSy Z* \VZ1E -Wd+\V\ 4*aZdWxD b\ aWdhSO W\an 4*b1YH ˚,bSf ,m]*W S4 \VZ* b`1bn1-\ ob*3*D *,1W S /`d-S1 ]\+13*WS V Z1YdD ˚,bSf Z1O ]\/,S3Z\ W13*W Z* 41YW1D Z +mW Y1`b,I \31jn WS bm ]`1/ab*,SbnE V*V\1 -\`1 ,a1f \f,*bSW\H S+WSS aV*4*Z\E hb\ *O ,1W ]`S]*W V pZ\j1 S \+ZqW 1-\D aV\`1 *O ,1W a `*/\abnp V`SVZdW /`d-SYE hb\+m \ZS Z1 ]1h*WSWSanEP \- ,1`ZdW ˚,bSf* V 3S4ZSI 1 ˚aWS ,m hSb*1b1 ,Y1ab1 a `1+1ZV\YE 4Z*V bSWn/* L M Z*O ]\YSZ*1b \ b\YE hb\ Y\3Z\ a/1W*bn ]*d4d S ]\+d/Sbn 1-\ ,mO aV*4*bn a,\1 YZ1ZS1D

24

b\ Ym Y\31Y d4Z*bn \ \-1 S4 `*aO aV*4* \ ˚,bSf1H m d4Z*1YE hb\ 1-\,*E Z*j Z1+1aZmy b1gE Y\31b ,1`Zdbn V 3S4ZS Y1`b,mfE , b\Y hSaW1 S /1b1yD `\Y1 b\-\E 1-\,* ]\ZSY*1b S Wp+Sb b1+q /*31 +\Wnj1E h1Y b,\S `\/Sb1WSD \-/* Sada +mW Z* 41YO W1E \Z +`*W Y*W1ZnVSf /1b1y Z* `dVS S +W*-\O aW\,WqW SfE b*V \Z ]\V*4*WE V*VSY \-\Y q,O Wq1baq 1-\,*D Z /*31 ,\aV`1j*W pZmfE Z*]`SY1` 56OW1bZpp /1,\hVdD b\ bm hd,ab,d1jnE 4Z*qE hb\ b,\y Z1O +1aZmy b1g Wp+Sb b1+qH ˙*E ob\ ]\+d3O /*1b Z*a Wp+Sbn 1-\,d , \b,1b S aWdj*bnaq 1-\D ˛Z*1jnE V*V Ym Y\31Y ]\V*4*bnE hb\ Wp+SY 1-\H /SZ a]\a\+ P ob\ -\,\`Sbn \ a,\1y Wp+,SD Sada aV*4*WB w) Wp+Wp bg*xD \ \Z Z1 b\WnV\ -\,\`SWE hb\ Wp+Sb \-*D Z ]\V*4m,*W ob\ a,\SYS /1W*YSD Sada +mW ]\aWdj1Z \-dD w) ,a1-/* /1O W*p b\E hb\ 1Yd d-\/Z\xEP aV*4*W \ZD b\+m d-\3/*bn 1-\,1 S 1-\ mZdE SadadE Ym /\W3Zm S4\ ,a1f aSW ab*`*bnaq +\/`ab,\O ,*bnE V\-/* ob\ Zd3Z\D

• ˚ ˚•

˙1qZSq 6>B;P56 dVS <B8=P9: \*ZZ* <B6=C 58B75

'b\ ]1`,*q S4 /,df ab*b1yE , V\b\`mf \+ad3/*pbaq Z*dhZm1 ,\]`\amE a,q4*ZZm1 a /*b\y `*4`dj1ZSq /`1,Z1-\ 1`da*WSY*D obSf ab*bnqf ]`S,\/qbaq bk*b1WnZ\ ]`\O ,1`1ZZm1 /*ZZm1E * b*V31 \aZ\,*ZZm1 Z* S+WSS \b,1bm Z* ,\]`\amE V\b\`m1 +1a]\V\qb Z1V\b\`mf hSb*b1W1yD

\-/* +mW `*4`dj1Z /`1,ZSy 1`da*WSYH & 5 ˚ ' ˚˚ ˛ ˚ ˚

˚ ) %

w Z\-S1 Sab\`SVS S *`f1\W\-S af\/qbaq ,\ YZ1ZSSE hb\ 1`da*WSY +mW `*4`dj1Z , 9<: SWS 9<; -\/d /\ ZD oD1 \h1Yd b\-/* ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m -\,\`qbE hb\ ob\ ]`\S4\jW\ , :>; -\/d /\ ZD oDH * h1Y \aZ\,*Z\ ob\ YZ1ZS1Hx • ,\]`\a 4*/*W \/SZ Z*j hSb*b1WnD /Z*V\ ]\h1Yd Zd3Z\ SZb1`1a\,*bnaq b\hZ\y /*b\yE V\-/* ,*,SW\ZaVSy g*`n *O ,df\/\Z\a\` II \]dab\jSW 1`da*WSYH \O ]1`,mfE ]\b\YdE hb\ ob\ a\+mbS1 ab*W\ ]\O ,\`\bZmY ]dZVb\Y , Sab\`SS Z*`\/* \-*D \ aW\,*Y \/Z\-\ Sab\`SV*E \Z\ ]`S,1W\ V wV*b*ab`\e1E ab`*jZ\y V*b*ab`\e1xD \-O /* ,*,SW\ZqZ1 `*4`djSWS f`*YE V\b\`my +mW g1Zb`\Y ]\VW\Z1ZSq a1Y\-dk1Yd \O -d +\W11 8>> W1bD a*WY\]1,1g a\V`dj*WaqB w \31I q4mhZSVSDDD \aV,1`ZSWS a,qb\y f`*Y ,\yE 1`da*WSY ]`1,`*bSWS , `*4,*WSZmx L a*W\Y ;<B5E SZ\/*WnZmy ]1`1,\/E /*W11

;=B5E 1`1,\/ Z\,\-\ YS`* M2D \O,b\`mfE ]\b\YdE hb\E 4Z*qE V\-/* SY1ZO Z\ Z*h*W*an wab`*jZ*q V*b*ab`\e*xE S ]\ZSO Y*qE V*V ,\aab*Z\,W1ZS1 SabSZZ\-\ ]\VW\Z1O ZSq , 1`da*WSY1 a,q4*Z\ a Sa]\WZ1ZS1Y

1 a,1baVSf Sab\hZSV*f ,ab`1h*pbaq \+1 /*bmD ˙Wq ]`\O ab\bm Ym +d/1Y -\,\`Sbn \ 9<; -\/1 /\ ZD oD 2 4/*b1WS ob\y ]d+WSV*gSSE ,S/1b1WS 1-\,mE ,m]daV*O pb b\hZmy ]1`1,\/ S+WSSE V\b\`my Z*4m,*1baq w ,qk1ZZ\1 Sa*ZS1 P 1`1,\/ Z\,\-\ YS`*xD ˚aWS ,m Z1 ,S/1b1Wn 1O -\,mE ,mE ,\4Y\3Z\E ]`1/]\hSb*1b1 ]\Wn4\,*bnaq /`d-SY ]1O `1,\/\Y ]`S `*aaY\b`1ZSS +S+W1yaVSf ,\]`\a\,D \ob\Yd , ob\y ab*bn1 ]`S,\/qbaq gSb*bm S4 Z*S+\W11 `*a]`\ab`*Z1ZO Zmf ]1`1,\/\, S+WSSD

26

˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

b\hZ\-\ +S+W1yaV\-\ ]`\`\h1ab,*E Ym dV`1O ]SY a,\1 /\,1`S1 V \3n1Yd W\,dD b*VE ]\O h1Yd ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m dV*4m,*pb Z* /*O bdE V\b\`*q \bWSh*1baq \b \+k1]`SZqb\y Z* 6> W1bH ˚aWS \b,1bSbn V\`\bV\E ]\b\Yd hb\ \+ ob\Y a,S/1b1Wnab,d1b a*Y* S+WSqD w 1Yn/1aqb W1bx P /Wq V\-\H

˛*/\W-\ /\ `*4`dj1ZSq 1`da*WSY* SdO /1yaVSy ]`\`\V 1`1YSq ]`\S4Z1a aW\,*E V\O b\`m1 ]\Y\-*pb \]`1/1WSbn VWph1,m1 /*O bm +S+W1yaV\y f`\Z\W\-SSD Z ]`1/d]`1O /SW w,a1f 3Sb1W1y 1`da*WSY*xB w aq 41YWq ob* +d/1b ]dabmZ1p S d3*a\YC S Z*`\/m aSS +d/db aWd3Sbn g*`p *,SW\ZaV\Yd a1Yn/1O aqb W1bx L 1`1YSq 69B5E 6E 55E MD \4/Z11 ]`\`\V aV*4*WB w *V -\,\`Sb 1-\,*B t \-/* ,m ]`\,1/1b1 , *,SW\Z1 a1Yn/1aqb W1bE q \+`*kd Z* ,*a ,ZSY*ZS1 S Sa]\WZp /\+`\1 aW\,\E V\b\`\1 aV*4*W \ ,*aEP q ,1`Zd ,*a Z* ob\ Y1ab\rx L 1`1YSq 6=B5>MD V*VSf a1YS/1O aqbS -\/*f S/1b `1hnH V*V ob\b ]1`S\/ ]\O Y\-*1b Z*Y dab*Z\,Sbn /*bd `*4`dj1ZSq 1O `da*WSY*H \ YZ\-Sf ]1`1,\/*f S+WSS Z*]Sa*Z\ Z1 wV\-/* ,m ]`\,1/1b1 , *,SW\Z1 a1Yn/1aqb

W1bxE * wV\-/* Sa]\WZSbaq *,SW\Zd a1Yn/1O aqb W1bx L]1`1,\/ *`fSY*Z/`Sb* *V*`SqMD \ob\Yd Z1V\b\`m1 Sab\`SVS db,1`3/*pbE hb\ ;>OW1bZSy ]1`S\/ \bZ\aSbaq V *,SW\ZO aV\y SY]1`SSD \-W*aZ\ a,1baV\y f`\Z\W\O -SSE ,*,SW\ZqZ1 -\a]\/ab,\,*WS Z*/ /`1,O ZSY d/\y S 1`da*WSY\Y ;> W1bE ]`SY1`Z\ a :>= ]\ 97= -\/ /\ ZD oDP -\/E V\-/* +mW 4*O f,*h1Z -\`\/ *,SW\ZD /Z*V\ S4 S+WSS ,S/Z\E hb\ ;> W1b P ob\ ]1`S\/ ab`\-\-\ Z*V*4*ZSqE V\b\`mY \- ]\V*`*W SY1ZZ\ 3Sb1W1y d/m S 1`dO a*WSY*E a\ab\q,jSf a ZSY , a\-W*j1ZSS S ]\b\Yd \+q4*ZZmf ]\,SZ\,*bnaq 1Yd L aO f\/ 5=B7P:MD \-/* \ZS Z1 4*f\b1WS \ab*O ,Sbn a,\S 4Wm1 ]dbSE \- aV*4*WB w) ]`SO 4\,dDDD *,df\/\Z\a\`*E g*`q *,SW\Z*DDD Z* obd ab`*Zd S ,a1f 11 \+Sb*b1W1yE S Z* ,a1 \V`1abZm1 Z*`\/mx L 1`1YSq 69B8E 9E <E =E YmaW\,\y ]1`1,\/MD \bq a\a1/O ZSY Z*`\/*Y b\31 ]`1/ab\qW\ ab`*/*bn ]\/ -Z1b\Y *,SW\Z*E `*4`dj1ZS1 1`da*WSY* S ]\aW1/dpk11 ;>OW1bZ11 S4-Z*ZS1 +mWSE ]\ aW\,*Y 1`1YSSE wZ*V*4*ZS1Y Z1h1abSq /k1`S Z*`\/* Y\1-\xE ]\b\Yd hb\ wbq3V\ a\-`1jSW 1`da*WSYx L W*h 1`1YSS 5B<C 7B86C 8B:E MD b*VE a\-W*aZ\ S+WSSE ;> W1b +mWS ,`1O Y1Z1Y ad`\,\-\ Z*V*4*ZSq /Wq d/mE * ,*,SO W\ZqZ1 +mWS SZab`dY1Zb\Y , `dV*f \-*D /Z*V\ \- ]\\+1k*W Sd/1qYB w \-/* Sa]\WO ZSbaq ,*Y , *,SW\Z1 a1Yn/1aqb W1bE b\-/* ) ]\a1kd ,*aDDD hb\+m ,\4,`*bSbn ,*a Z* Y1O ab\ aS1 , 41YWp d/m S , 1`da*WSY x L 1O `1YSq 6=B5>E MD \-/* Z*h*WSan wa1Yn/1aqb W1bxH

ab\`SV ˚4/`*E V\b\`my 3SW ]\aW1 ;>OW1bZ1-\ ]1`S\/*E ]`1/aV*4*ZZ\-\ 1`1O YS1yE Z*]Sa*W ]\/ ,/\fZ\,1ZS1Y \-* \ g*`1 *,df\/\Z\a\`1B w 1`1a1WSW \Z \ab*,jSfaq \b Y1h* , *,SW\ZE S +mWS \ZS `*+*YS 1-\ S amZ\,1y 1-\E /\ ,\g*`1ZSq g*`q 1`aS/aV\O -\E /\V\W1E ,\ Sa]\WZ1ZS1 aW\,* \a]\/ZqE aV*4*ZZ\-\ dab*YS 1`1YSSE 41YWq Z1 \bO ]`*4/Z\,*W* ad++\b a,\SfD \ ,a1 /ZS 4*]dO ab1ZSq \Z* ad++\bab,\,*W* /\ Sa]\WZ1ZSq

a1YS/1aqbS W1bx L6 *`*WS]\Y1Z\Z 6 1b\O ]San 7:B6>E 65E MD

W1/\,*b1WnZ\E ;> W1b /\W3Zm +mWS ab*bn ]1`S\/\YE , V\b\`my 41YWq d/m S 1`da*O WSY \b]`*4/Zdpb a,\S ad++\bmD 'b\ \4Z*h*O W\E hb\ 41YWp Z1 +d/db ,\4/1Wm,*bnB ZS a1O qbn a1Y1Z*E ZS \+`14*bn ,SZ\-`*/Zm1 W\4m L 1,Sb 69B5P9MD ˛* a,\1 Z1]\aWdj*ZS1E V\O b\`\1E ]\YSY\ ]`\h1-\E Y\-W\ ]`\q,Wqbnaq , Z1a\+Wp/1ZSS 4*V\Z* \ ad++\bZSf -\/*fE \3Sy Z*`\/ /\W31Z +mW ]\/,1`-Zdbnaq Z*O V*4*ZSpB 1-\ 41YWq /\W3Z* +mW* \ab*,*bnaq Z1,\4/1W*ZZ\y S 4*+`\j1ZZ\y ;> W1b L 1O ,Sb 6:B6;E 76P79E 86E 87MD \-/* 41YWq d/m ab*W* 4*+`\j1ZZ\y S Z1,\4/1W*ZZ\yH *,SW\ZaVS1 ,\yaV* ,\ -W*O ,1 a *,df\/\Z\a\`\Y Z*]*/*WS Z* 1`da*O WSY /,*3/mE a `*4ZSg1y , Z1aV\WnV\ W1bD \-/* 31 Z*h*Waq ;>OW1bZSy ]1`S\/H ]`1O /1W1ZZ\ Z1 ,\ ,`1Yq ]1`,\y \a*/m 1`da*O WSY*D \h1YdH \bq , b\ ,`1Yq *,df\/\Z\O ‹ a\` d,1W , *,SW\Z YZ\-\ ]W1ZZSV\,E +\WnO jdp h*abn Z*`\/* \Z \ab*,SW 3Sbn , d/1D `\Y1 b\-\E 1`da*WSY Z1 +mW `*4`dj1ZD \/m a]dabq ]\aW1 ob\-\ ]1`1a1W1ZSq b1E Vb\ \ab*WSan b*YE w+1/Zmy Z*`\/ 41YWSxE ]`\/\W3*WS ,\4/1Wm,*bn 41YWp L8 *`ab, 6 *`1y 68B<P5;E MD /Z*V\ 4*b1Y ,a1 S4O Y1ZSW\anD \aV\WnVd Sd/1S ]\/ZqWS Yqb13E ,*,SW\O ZqZ1 ,1`ZdWSan , 1`da*WSY L6 *`1y 68B6>C 69B<P5>MD ob\b `*4 \ZS `*4`djSWS f`*Y S -\`\/ S d,1WS YZ\-Sf 1-\ 3Sb1W1y , ]W1Z , *,SW\ZD 1`14 /,* Y1aqg* w,ab*W ,1an Z*O `\/ \ab*,jSyaq , d/1 E \b Y*W\-\ /\ +\WnO j\-\E S ,\1Z*h*WnZSVSE S ]\jWS , ˚-SO ]1bE ]\b\Yd hb\ +\qWSan *W/11,x L8 *`ab, 6 *`1y 69B69E 6:E MD \WnV\ b\-/*E , Y1aqO g1 bSj`S La1Zbq+`nQ\Vbq+`nME a1/nY\Y Y1aqO g1 ]\ Sd/1yaV\Yd V*W1Z/*`pE \ 41YW1E b1O ]1`n Z1,\4/1W*ZZ\y S 4*+`\j1ZZ\yE Y\3Z\ +mW\ aV*4*bnE hb\ \Z* Z*h*W* ]`*4/Z\,*bn a,\S ad++\bmD 1`14 1`1YSp 1-\,* aV*4*W Sd/1qYE +13*,jSY , ˚-S]1bB w m ,S/1WS ,a1 +1/ab,S1E V*V\1 ) Z*,1W Z* 1`da*WSY S Z* ,a1 -\`\/* d/1yaVS1C ,\bE \ZS b1]1`n ]dabmE S ZSVb\ Z1 3S,1b , ZSfx L 1`1YSq 88B5E 6E ˝˚ ) " ) ˙ 5 ) ) 6>55

27

MD h1,S/Z\E b\-/* Z*h*Waq ;>OW1bZSy ]1O `S\/D \ V*V\y ob\ +mW -\/H b\+m Z*ybS \bO ,1bE Zd3Z\ d4Z*bnE V\-/* ob\b ]1`S\/ 4*V\ZO hSWaqD

Tablet: ˘ The Trustees of the British Museum

\-/* 4*V\ZhSWSan wa1Yn/1aqb W1bxH

`\`\V ˙*ZSSWE V\b\`my 3SW , *,SW\O Z1E V\-/* ,\g*`SWaq wg*`n 1`aS/aVSyxE ,mO hSaWSW ,`1Yq 4*,1`j1ZSq ;>OW1bZ1-\ ]1`SO \/*D Z Z*]Sa*WB w)E ˙*ZSSWE a\\+`*4SW ]\ VZS-*Y hSaW\ W1bE \ V\b\`\Y +mW\ aW\,\ \aO ]\/Z1 V 1`1YSS ]`\`\VdE hb\ a1Yn/1aqb W1b Sa]\WZqbaq Z*/ \]dab\j1ZS1Y 1`da*WSY*x L˙*ZSSW =B5E 6E MD ˚4/`*E `*4YmjWqq \ ]`\`\h1ab,*f 1O `1YSSE a,q4*W \V\Zh*ZS1 ;>OW1bZ1-\ ]1`SO \/* a\ ,`1Y1Z1YE V\-/* w \a]\/n ]\+d/SW S`* ]1`aS/aV\-\ g*`q a/1W*bn a]1gS*WnO Z\1 \+lq,W1ZS1x L6 *`*WS]\Y1Z\Z 6 1b\O

]San 7:B65E 66E \,`1Y1ZZmy ]1`1,\/MD V\-O /* +mWS \a,\+\3/1Zm Sd/1SH V*4 \+ \V\Zh*ZSS ]W1Z* +mW S4/*Z w, ]1`,\Y -\O /d g*`ab,\,*ZSq ]1`aS/aV\-\ g*`q S`*xD L Y\b`Sb1 `*YVd w *3Z*q Sab\`Sh1aV*q /*O b*xDM \a1Znp 97; -\/* /\ ZD oD Sd/1S ,1`ZdO WSan , 1`da*WSYE hb\+m ,\aab*Z\,Sbn SaO bSZZ\1 ]\VW\Z1ZS1 L˚4/`* 5B5P9C 6B5C 7B5P9MD *VSY \+`*4\YE a\-W*aZ\ +S+W1yaV\y f`\O Z\W\-SSE ;> W1b +mWS +dV,*WnZmY ]1`S\/\Y ,`1Y1ZSE 4*,1`jS,jSYaq , 97; -\/d /\ ZD oD bahSb*, Z*4*/ ;> W1bE Ym ]`S/1Y V :>; -\/d /\ ZD oD \ 1aWS ,qk1ZZ\1 Sa*ZS1 qaZ\ dV*4mO ,*1bE hb\ 1`da*WSY +mW `*4`dj1Z , :>; -\O /d /\ ZD oDE ]\h1Yd YZ\-S1 dh1Zm1 ahSb*pbE hb\ ob\ ]`\S4\jW\ , 9<; -\/d /\ ZD oDH ZS \aZ\,m,*pbaq Z* b`d/*f VW*aaSh1aVSf Sab\O

˝ ) ˚ ) ˙

97= -\/d /\ ZD oDE , V\b\`my S` II 4*f,*bSW *,SW\ZE Y\3Z\ ]`SybSE \]S`*qan Z*B

ˇ `d/m /`1,ZSf Sab\`SV\, S SZe\`Y*gSp S4 VWSZ\]SaZmf b*+WSh1VD ˙S\/\` SgSWSyaVSy L\VD <>P6> /\ ZD oDM Z*]Sa*WE hb\ S` ab*W g*`1Y 1`aSS , w]1`,my -\/ ]qbn/1aqb ]qb\y \WSY]S*O /mx LHistorical LibraryD Book IXD 65MD 'b\ +mW 9:> -\/ /\ ZD oD `1h1O aVSy Sab\`SV 1`\/\b L\VD 8<9 P \VD 869 /\ ZD oDM Z*]Sa*WE hb\ S` V\ ,`1Y1ZS a,\1y aY1`bS wg*`ab,\,*WDDD ]\WZmf 6= W1bx L 1`\/\bD ab\`SqD ZS-* ID 658MD W1/\,*b1WnZ\E \Z dY1` , 7>Oy -\/ a,\1-\ ]`*,W1ZSqE b\ 1abn , 97> -\/d /\ ZD oD 4 VWSZ\]SaZmf b*+WSh1V ,S/Z\E hb\ /\ a,\1y aY1`bS S` ]`*,SW *,SW\Z\Y = W1bD bahSO b*, Z*4*/ \b 97> -\/* /\ ZD oD = W1bE Ym ]`S/1Y V 97= -\/d /\ ZD oDP -\/dE , V\b\`my S` 4*f,*bSW *,SW\ZD

28

' ,1/1ZSq S4 VWSZ\]SaZmf b*+WSh1VD *,SW\ZaV*q *ab`\Z\O YSh1aV*q -WSZqZ*q b*+WShV* LBM 77>::M ]\/b,1`3/*1bE hb\ S` dY1` , 97> -\/d /\ ZD oD \bq , ob\y b*+WShV1 /\]dk1Zm Z1V\b\O `m1 \jS+VS \bZ\aSb1WnZ\ ]\W\31ZSq Z1+1aZmf b1WE , Z1y a\/1`O 3Sbaq b\hZ*q SZe\`Y*gSq \ /,df WdZZmf 4*bY1ZSqfE V\b\`m1E V*V , Z1y aV*4*Z\E ]`\S4\jWS , a1/nY\y -\/ ]`*,W1ZSq *Y+Sa* IIE amZ* S ]`11YZSV* S`*D 'b\ +mWS WdZZm1 4*bY1ZSqE Z*+Wp/*,O jS1aq , *,SW\Z1 5: SpWq 967 -\/* /\ ZD oD S 5> qZ,*`q 966 -\/* /\ ZD oD *VSY \+`*4\YE Z*h*W\ a1/nY\-\ -\/* ]`*,W1ZSq *Y+SO a* ]`Sf\/Sbaq Z* ,1aZd 967 -\/* /\ ZD oD W1/\,*b1WnZ\E ]1`,mY -\/\Y 1-\ ]`*,W1ZSq +mW 96= -\/ /\ ZD oD ˛Z*hSbE ]\aW1/ZSY -\O /\Y ]`*,W1ZSq S`* +mW 97> -\/ /\ ZD oDE * , 97= -\/d /\ ZD oD \Z Z*h*W ]`*,Sbn *,SW\Z\YD

`SV\, S Z* V*Z\Z1 b\W1Y1qD Ë›*aWd3S,*pb WS obS Sab\hZSVS +\Wnj1-\ /\,1`SqE h1Y S+WSqH Ë™*,*yb1 ]\aY\b`SYD

Photograph taken by courtesy of the British Museum

*aV\WnV\ b\hZm b`d/m VW*aaSh1aVSf Sab\`SV\,H

ab\`SVSE V\b\`m1 3SWS a]dabq Z1aV\WnO V\ ,1V\, ]\aW1 `*4`dj1ZSq 1`da*WSY*E ]`1/\ab*,Wqpb ]`\bS,\`1hS,dp SZe\`Y*O gSp \ Z\,\,*,SW\ZaVSf g*`qf1D L Y\b`Sb1 `*YVd w \,\,*,SW\ZaVS1 g*`SxDM `\Z\W\O -SqE V\b\`*q \aZ\,*Z* Z* Sf b`d/*fE `*af\O /Sbaq a +S+W1yaV\yD \ Z*aV\WnV\ b\hZm Sf b`d/mH /ZSY S4 b*VSf Sab\`SV\, +mW 1`\aE ,*O ,SW\ZaVSy 3`1g +\-* 1W*D Ëš-\ b`d/ w ab\O `Sq *,SW\ZSSxE Z*]Sa*ZZmy ]`SY1`Z\ , 6<5 -\/d /\ ZD oDE Z1 a\f`*ZSWaqE S /\ Z*jSf /Z1y /\jWS WSjn e`*-Y1Zbm ob\-\ b`d/* , a\hSZ1ZSqf /`d-Sf Sab\`SV\,D 1`\a db,1`O 3/*WE hb\ \Z Sa]\Wn4\,*W VZS-SE V\b\`m1 wa +\Wnj\y 4*+\b\y f`*Zqbaq , *,SW\Z1x5D *aV\WnV\ bk*b1WnZ\ \Z aW1/SW 4* b\hZ\O abnp SZe\`Y*gSSE V\b\`dp ]`1/\ab*,WqWH

*aaY\b`SY \/SZ ]`SY1`D 1`\a Z*]Sa*WE hb\ *aaS`SyaVSy g*`n SO Z*f1`S+ L 1ZZ*fS`SYM ]`*,SW ]\aW1 a,\1O -\ +`*b*E w]\aW1 Z1-\ 1-\ amZ a*`f*//\Z L a*`/*ZM ]`*,SW < W1bE * ]\aW1 ob\-\ *YO Yd- "*Y*jOjdYOdVSZ ]`*,SW 65 -\/x L aO b\`Sq *,SW\ZSSD ZS-* IIID 6D5E 8MD /Z*V\E 1 1`,mY g*`1Y \,\,*,SW\ZaV\-\ g*`ab,* +mW *+\]*W*O a*`E \b1g *,df\/\Z\a\`*E * ]\aW1/ZSY P *+\ZS/D `1Yq ]`*,W1ZSq Z\,\,*,SW\ZaVSf g*`1y ]`1/ab*,Wq1b /Wq dh1Zmf ‹ SZb1`1aE ]\aV\WnVd \Z\ \f,*bm,*1b +\Wnjdp h*abn ;>OW1bZ1-\ ]1`S\/* 4*]dab1ZSq d/mD

a\-W*aZ\ ,*,SW\ZaVSY Sab\`Sh1aVSY /\VdO Y1Zb*YE a\ab*,W1ZZmY 4*/\W-\ /\ 1`\a*E

SZ*f1`S+ aY1ZSW Z* ]`1ab\W1 Z1 +`*b*E * a,\1-\ \bg*E *`-\Z* IIE a*`f*//\Z ]`*,SW Z1 <E * 56 W1bE * "*Y*jOjdYOdVSZ P Z1 65 -\/E * 6> W1bD ab\`SV *Z /1` ]1VE \bY1O bS,E hb\ 1`\a \+`*k*Waq V ,*,SW\ZaVSY f`\ZSV*YE Z*]Sa*WB w 1Y Z1 Y1Z11 \Z ]\4,\O WqW a1+1 /\+*,W1ZSq S a\+ab,1ZZm1 b\WV\O ,*ZSqx6D V*V /`d-S1 dh1Zm1 `*aaY*b`S,*pb b`dO /m 1`\a*H w *Znj1 1`\a*E V*V ]`*,SW\E ahSb*WS Sab\`SV\YxEP -\,\`Sb b1ZWS 1`O ab*yZE V\b\`my ]`\,1W bk*b1WnZ\1 SaaW1/\O ,*ZS1 b`d/\, 1`\a*D \ ,\b V V*V\Yd ,m,\O /d \Z ]`Sj1WB w */\ ]`S4Z*bnE hb\ 1-\ ]\/O f\/ V `*+\b1 Z1 ]\/\+*1b Sab\`SVdD ˙*31 , b1f e`*-Y1Zb*f t ab\`SS *,SW\ZSSrE V\O b\`m1 /\abd]Zm Z*Y a1-\/ZqE a\/1`3Sbaq YZ\31ab,\ Z1\3S/*ZZmf Z1b\hZ\ab1y , ]`\O abmf ,1k*fDDD DDD ˙Wq Sab\`SV* b*VS1 \jS+O VS +mWS +m Z1]`\abSb1WnZmE Z\ 1`\a Z1 +mW Sab\`SV\Yx7D *4,*WS +m ,m ,,S/d ,mj1aV*4*ZZ\-\ ,mO hSaW1ZSq 1`\a* b\hZmYSH hb\ Y\3Z\ aV*O 4*bn \ /`d-Sf VW*aaSh1aVSf Sab\`SV*fE V\b\O `m1 \aZ\,m,*WS a,\p f`\Z\W\-Sp +\Wnj1y h*abnp Z* a\hSZ1ZSqf 1`\a*H ˛*aWd3S,*O pb WS Sf ,m,\/m /\,1`SqH *Z\Z b\W1Y1q

]\//1`3Vd 9<; -\/* /\ ZD oD V*V /*O bm `*4`dj1ZSq 1`da*WSY* b*V31 ]`S,\/qb w *Z\Z g*`1yx *ab`\Z\Y* W*,/Sq b\W1O Y1qE 3S,j1-\ ,\ II ,1V1 ZD oD ]Sa\V g*`1yE

Ëš ËšaWS a,1/1ZSq obSf Sab\`SV\, b\hZmE ]\h1Yd \ZS ]`\bS,\`1h*b /`d- /`d-dH *`S

Ëš \VD 79>P6;> /\ ZD oD

5>9PH /\ ZD oD

• ˚ ˚• 7;P5>> LHM ZD oD \VD 5>> P \VD 5;> ZD oD

*+\]*W*a*`

65

6>

P

65

*,df\/\Z\a\` II

87

87

87

87

Y1WnO *`/dV

6

56

5<

6

1`S-WSaa*`

8

8

8>

8

*+*jSO *`/dV *+\ZS/

= Y1aqg1, 5;

P 5;

= Y1aqg1, 5;

P 5;

`1Yq ]`*,W1ZSq g*`1y L, -\/*fM a\-W*aZ\ VW*aaSh1aVSY Sab\`SV*Y

Photograph taken by courtesy of the British Museum

a\ab*,W1ZZmy b\W1Y11YE ahSb*1baq \aZ\O ,\y f`\Z\W\-SS /`1,Z1y Sab\`SSE ,VWph*q Z\,\,*,SW\ZaVSy ]1`S\/D b\W1Y1y a\ab*,SW ob\b a]Sa\V a]dabq +\O W11 :>> W1b ]\aW1 Z\,\,*,SW\ZaV\-\ ]1`S\O /*D *V \Z \]`1/1WSW /*bdE V\-/* Z*h*W g*`O ab,\,*bn ]1`,my g*`nE d]\YqZdbmy , 1-\ a]SaV1H b\W1Y1y \+lqaZSWE hb\ a ]\Y\knp *ab`\Z\YSh1aVSf `*ah1b\,E \aZ\,*ZZmfE a`1O /S ]`\h1-\E Z* Z*+Wp/1ZSS 4*bY1ZSyE \Z ,mO hSaWSW /*bm ]`*,W1ZSq g*`1y w,]W\bn /\ Z*h*W* g*`ab,\,*ZSq *+\Z*aa*`*xE ]1`,\-\ g*`q , 1-\ a]SaV18D `Sab\e1` \V1`E a\O b`d/ZSV `Sb*ZaV\-\ Yd41qE -\,\`SbB w *O Z\Z b\W1Y1q +mW SaVdaab,1ZZ\y aSab1Y\yE a\4/*ZZ\y a g1Wnp ]`1/\ab*,Sbn *ab`\Z\O Y*Y b\hZdp f`\Z\W\-SpDDD * Z1 a g1Wnp ]`1O /\ab*,Sbn Sab\`SV*Y b\hZdp SZe\`Y*gSp \ ,`1Y1ZS ,\aj1ab,Sq Z* ]`1ab\W S aY1`bS g*`1yx9D w /*,ZSf ]\` S4,1abZ\E hb\ V*Z\Z b\W1O Y1q b\h1Z a b\hVS 4`1ZSq *ab`\Z\YSSxEP ]Sj1b 1\ ˙1]*dbE V\b\`my \aZ\,*b1WnZ\ S4dhSW b`d/m b\W1Y1qD Z ]`\/\W3*1bB w \ ob\ Z1 4Z*hSbE hb\ \Z b\h1Z a b\hVS 4`1O

ZSq Sab\`SSxD `\Y1 b\-\E ]`\e1aa\` ˙1]*O db \bY1h*1bB w b\ V*a*1baq `*ZZSf g*`1y ,VWph*q Z\,\,*,SW\ZaVSf E b\E hb\+m \]`1O /1WSbn ,`1Yq ]`*,W1ZSq V*3/\-\ S4 ZSfE V*Z\Z aW1/d1b a,1`qbn a VWSZ\]SaZmYS /\O VdY1Zb*YSx:D b\ ob\ 4* wVWSZ\]SaZm1 /\VdY1ZbmxE +W*-\/*`q V\b\`mY Y\3Z\ ]`\,1`Sbn Sab\O `ShZ\abn V*Z\Z* b\W1Y1qH `1/S ZSf ,*O ,SW\ZaVS1 f`\ZSVSE a]SaVS g*`1y S /1W\,m1 /\VdY1ZbmE a\ab*,W1ZZm1 ]Sag*YS , Z\,\O ,*,SW\ZaVSy ]1`S\/ SWS ,aV\`1 ]\aW1 Z1-\;D b\ ]\V*4m,*1b a`*,Z1ZS1 a]SaV* b\W1O Y1q a VWSZ\]SaZmYS /\VdY1Zb*YSH `*YV1 w \-W*ad1baq WS V*Z\Z b\W1Y1q a VWSZ\O ]SaZmYS b*+WShV*YSHx L,ZS4dM a`*,ZS,*1bO aq h*abn w *Z\Z* g*`1yx a /`1,ZSY VWSO Z\]SaZmY /\VdY1Zb\YD +`*bSb1 ,ZSY*ZS1E hb\ b\W1Y1y ]1`1hSaWq1b b\WnV\ h1bmO `1f g*`1y Y13/d ,*,SW\ZaVSYS ]`*,Sb1WqO YS *Z/*W*Zd S *+\ZS/\YD b\ ,`1Yq V*VE a\-W*aZ\ d`dVaV\Yd a]SaVd g*`1yE Y13/d ZSO YS ]`*,SWS a1Yn g*`1yD \31b +mbnE ,`1Yq ]`*,W1ZSq Z1d]\YqZdbmf b\W1Y11Y g*`1y +mW\ aWSjV\Y Z1/\W-SYH \-W*aZ\ VWSZ\O

Ëš )

Ëš Ëš) % H b\W1Y1y Z1 ,Z1a , a]Sa\V Z1V\b\`mf g*`1yD \h1YdH

Ëš Ëš)

*,SW\ZaVS1 f`\ZSVS P h*abn VWSZ\]SaZmf /\VdY1Zb\,E V\b\`m1 ]\4,\Wqpb ]`\,1`Sbn b\hZ\abn V*Z\Z* b\W1Y1q

*+\Z*aa*` *+dOZ*/SZO41`S VSZO41` S dWd WdW*y L *WY*Z*a*` VM wg*`n aaS`SSx *`/dVO*]W*OS//SZ `V1*Z L *`-\Z IIM wg*`n aaS`SSx ]1`,\1 Y13/dg*`ab,S1

1WOS+ZS jjd`OZ*/SZOjdYS 1`-*WOdj14S+ 1j14S+O *`/dV ,b\`\1 Y13/dg*`ab,S1 a*`f*//\Z wg*`n aaS`SSx "*Y*jOjdYOdVSZ *Z/*W*Zd

*+\]*W*a*` *,df\/\Z\a\` II

Y1WnO *`/dV 1`S-WSaa*`

30 *+\ZS/ S` *Y+Sa

• ˚• %

*Z/*W*Zd SZOjdYdOWSjS` SZOj*`OSjVdZ *+\]*W*a*` *,df\/\Z\a\` II

Y1WnO *`/dV 1`S-WSaa*` *+*jSO *`/dV *+\ZS/

*V\y Y\3Z\ a/1W*bn ,m,\/H

Ë™*,*yb1 ]\/,1/1Y Sb\-D S+WSS qaZ\ -\,\`SbaqE hb\ 4*]dab1ZS1 d/m /WSW\an ;> W1bD d/1S ,1`ZdWSan Z* `\/SZd , 97; -\O /d /\ ZD oDE b\Yd 1abn d+1/Sb1WnZm1 /\V*4*O b1Wnab,*E S a obSY a\-W*aZ\ +\WnjSZab,\ dh1ZmfD \]\ab*,W1ZS1 obSf /,df e*Vb\, ]`S,\/Sb Z*a V ,m,\/dE hb\ 1`da*WSY +mW `*4`dj1Z , :>; -\/d /\ ZD oD `d/m VW*aaSh1O aVSf Sab\`SV\, S V*Z\Z b\W1Y1q Z1 ]\/O b,1`3/*pb obd /*bdE Z\ , \bZ\j1ZSS b\hZ\O abS a\/1`3*k1yaq , ZSf SZe\`Y*gSS ,\4O

`SY1h*ZSq 5D ab\`Sq *,SW\ZSS LChaldaeorum HistoriaeMD ZD ID 5D5D 6D Studies in Ancient Near Eastern World View and Society. P. 295. 7D The Babyloniaca of Berossus. P. 8. 8D WnY*-1abD 1`1,\/ a /`1,Z1-`1h1aO V\-\ D D 1a1W\,aV\-\D D 5==<D ZD IIID ;D D =<D b\W1Y1y 4Z*WE hb\ ,*,SW\ZaVS1 *ab`\Z\Ym dY1WS ,mhSaWqbn ,`1Yq ]`\jO Wmf S +d/dkSf 4*bY1ZSyE ]\b\Yd hb\ \+Z*O `d3SWS 4*V\Z\Y1`Z\abnB \/SZ*V\,m1 4*bO Y1ZSq ]\,b\`qpbaq V*3/m1 5< W1b L WnY*-1abD ZD IVD 6MD 9D Mesopotamia and Iran in the Persian Period. Pp. 17-18. :D Journal of Cuneiform Studies. Vol. 47, 1995, pp. 106-107.

ZSV*pb a1`n14Zm1 ,\]`\amD ˙1yab,Sb1WnZ\E \ZS Z1 ]`1/\ab*,Wqpb /\ab*b\hZ\ /\V*O 4*b1Wnab,E hb\+m \]`\,1`-Zdbn +S+W1yaVdp f`\Z\W\-SpD a1 31 \ab*1baq Z1aV\WnV\ ,\]`\a\,D 1O d31WS Z1b ZSV*VSf Sab\`Sh1aVSf /\V*4*O b1Wnab, \aZ\,*ZZ\Yd Z* S+WSS ,m,\/dE hb\ 1`da*WSY +mW `*4`dj1Z , :>; -\/d /\ ZD oDH h1Y a,S/1b1Wnab,dpb /*bS`\,*ZZm1 VWSO Z\]SaZm1 /\VdY1ZbmE YZ\-S1 S4 V\b\`mf +mO WS Z*]Sa*Zm Wp/nYSE 3S,jSYS , b\ ,`1YqH 'bS ,\]`\am +d/db `*aaY\b`1Zm , aW1/dpO k1Y ,m]daV1D

Photograph taken by courtesy of the British Museum

]SaZmY /1W\,mY /\VdY1Zb*YE \/SZ S4 ZSf ]`*,SW a1Yn W1b <D b\Yd 31 VWSZ\]SaZm1 /\VdY1Zbm a\/1`O 3*b ,1aV\1 /\V*4*b1Wnab,\ b\-\E hb\ /\ *O +\]*W*a*`* L]1`,\-\ g*`q Z\,\,*,SW\ZaV\-\ ]1`S\/*M , *,SW\ZSS h1bm`1 -\/* ]`*,SW /`d-\y g*`n L jjd`Oob1WnOSW*ZSMD `\Y1 b\-\E +\W11 \/Z\-\ -\/* , ab`*Z1 ,\\+k1 Z1 +mW\ g*`q=D \ ZS \/SZ S4 obSf e*Vb\, Z1 \b`*31Z , V*Z\Z1 b\W1Y1qD \h1Yd b\W1Y1y Z1 ,Z1a , a]Sa\V Z1V\b\O `mf g*`1yH h1,S/Z\E \Z Z1 ahSb*W Sf 4*O V\ZZmYS ]`*,Sb1WqYS *,SW\Z*5>D *]`SO Y1`E \Z Z1 d]\YqZdW Z\,\,*,SW\ZaV\-\ g*`q *+*jSO *`/dV*D \E a\-W*aZ\ VWSZ\]SaO ZmY /\VdY1Zb*YE g*`SE V\b\`mf b\W1Y1y Z1 ,VWphSW , V*Z\ZE Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 ]`*,SWS *,SW\ZS1yD g1W\Y V*Z\Z b\W1Y1q ahSb*1baq /\ab*O b\hZ\ b\hZmYD /Z*V\E ,,S/d ,mj1aV*4*ZO Z\-\E Y\3Z\ WS db,1`3/*bnE hb\ ]`S,1/1ZO Zm1 , Z1Y /*ZZm1 +14\jS+\hZmH

%Ëš Ë?Ëš )

ˇ Z\-S1 Sab\`SVS db,1`3/*pbE hb\ 1`da*WSY +mW `*4`dj1Z , 9<; -\/d /\ ZD oD ˇ S+W1yaV*q f`\Z\W\-Sq qaZ\ ]\V*O 4m,*1bE hb\ ob\ ]`\S4\jW\ , :>; -\/d /\ ZD oD ˇ ab\`SVSE V*V ]`*,SW\E \aZ\,m,*pb a,\S 4*VWph1ZSq Z* b`d/*f VW*aaSh1O aVSf Sab\`SV\, S Z* V*Z\Z1 b\W1Y1qD ˇ a\hSZ1ZSqf VW*aaSh1aVSf Sab\`SO V\, /\]dk1Zm adk1ab,1ZZm1 \jS+VSE V`\Y1 b\-\E ]`S,1/1ZZm1 , ZSf a,1/1O ZSq Z1 ,a1-/* a\,]*/*pb a\ a,1/1ZSO qYSE a\/1`3*kSYSaq , -WSZqZmf b*+O WShV*fD

;D WSZ\]San P ob\ a]\a\+ ]SanY*E 4*O VWph*pkSyaq , Z*Z1a1ZSS Z* -WSZqZm1 b*+WShVS SWS Z* V*Y1Zn VWSZ\,S/Zmf h1`O b\h1VD <D SZOj*`OSjVdZ ]`*,SW a1Yn W1bD mO W\ Z*y/1Z\ 9; VWSZ\]SaZmf /1W\,mf /\O VdY1Zb\, ob\-\ g*`qE V\b\`m1 /*bS`dpbO aq ,`1Y1Z1Y \b 1-\ ,\aj1ab,Sq Z* ]`1ab\W /\ a1/nY\-\ -\/* 1-\ ]`*,W1ZSq LJournal of Cuneiform StudiesD Vol. 35, 1983, pp. 54-59MD =D *+WShV* /1W\,\-\ a\/1`3*ZSq LC.B.M. 2152M /*bS`d1baq h1b,1`bmY -\/\Y ]`*,O W1ZSq jjd`Oob1WnOSW*ZS LClay A.T. Legal and Commercial Transactions Dated in the Assyrian, Neo-Babylonian and Persian Periods—Chiefly From Nippur. 1908, p. 74MD *V31 , f*``*ZaVSf Z*/]Saqf *+\ZS/* LH1BME , ab\W+g1 IE ab`\V1 7>E \Z d]\YSZ*O

1baq ]1`1/ *+\]*W*a*`\Y LAnatolian Studies. Vol. VIII, 1958, pp. 35, 47MD ]1`S\/1 Y13/dg*`ab,Sq Z*]Sa*Z\ ,\ 6Oy `\ZSV1E ab`\V1 58 LAssyrian and Babylonian Chronicles. Pp. 87-88MD 5>D 1V\b\`m1 dh1Zm1 db,1`3/*pbE hb\ b\W1Y1yE V\b\`myE V*V ahSb*1baqE ]1`1O hSaWSW b\WnV\ ,*,SW\ZaVSf g*`1yE Z1 ,VWphSW , a]Sa\V Z1aV\WnVSf g*`1yE ]\O b\Yd hb\ \ZS +mWS Z*4,*Zm wg*`qYS aaS`SSxD /Z*V\E V*V ,m Y\31b1 ,SO /1bn , `*YV1 Z* ab`*ZSg1 7>E Z1V\b\O `m1 g*`SE d]\YqZdbm1 , V*Z\Z1 b\W1Y1qE b\31 +mWS Z*4,*Zm wg*`qYS aaS`SSxD WSZ\]SaZm1 /1W\,m1 /\VdY1Zbm S ]SanO Y*E * b*V31 Z*/]SaS qaZ\ ]\V*4m,*pbE hb\ g*`S jjd`Oob1WnOSW*ZSE SZOjdYdO WSjS` S SZOj*`OSjVdZ ]`*,SWS *,SW\O ZS1yD

The Trinity c.1500, Flemish School, (16th century) / H. Shickman Gallery, New York, USA / The Bridgeman Art Library International

*VS1 ]qbn Z1,1`Zmf ]`1/ab*,W1ZSy \ \-1 `*a]`\ab`*Z1Zm , Z*jS /ZSH Ëš % 8P <D

*V 4Z*ZS1 SabSZm \ \-1 Y\31b S4Y1ZSbn ,*jd 3S4ZnH Ëš =D

W1/d1b WS V`1abSbn YW*/1Zg1,H

*V /\abShn ah*abnq , a1Yn1H

Ëš 55D

Ëš % 5:P5;D

1Yd Z*a dhSb ]`SY1` aY1W\y S ,1`Z\y \-d 31ZkSZm ]\ SY1ZS 'aeS`nH Ëš 5<D

\b1WS +m ,mE hb\+m ,*a ]\a1bSWSH Ë™*31 , ob\Y +1a]\V\yZ\Y YS`1 Y\3Z\ /\abShn ah*abnq +W*-\/*`q b\hZ\Yd 4Z*ZSp +S+W1yaV\y SabSZm \ \-1E 1-\ *`ab,1 S 1-\ 4*Y1h*b1WnZ\Y Z*Y1`1ZSS \bZ\aSb1WnZ\ h1W\,1h1ab,*D ËšaWS ,m 31W*1b1 ]\WdhSbn +\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS SWS f\bSb1E hb\+m a ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\an +1a]W*bZ\1 /\Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 S+WSSE ]\3*Wdyab*E ]SjSb1 ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m ]\ \/Z\Yd S4 */`1a\,E dV*4*ZZmf Z* ab`*ZSg1 8D www.watchtower.org

wp11 10/01-U

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.