Beaver
Issue 836 | 13.10.15
the
Newspaper of the LSE Students’ Union
Comment:
HeForShe Talk Was Tiring, Insulting and Disappointing Purvaja Kavattur Social Policy and Economics Student
UN HeForShe Campaign Receives Critical Reception On Campus Ellen Wilkie Executive Editor
THIS WEEK UN WOMEN’S HeForShe campaign’s #getfree Tour arrived at the London School of Economics campus to widespread criticism. This criticism came as a result of an allegedly racist remark made by panellist Charles Stephens and the implication in the name ‘HeForShe’ that there are only two genders. HeForShe is a solidarity campaign rallying men to become advocates of gender equality and encouraging action against inequalities towards women. LSE played host to alumna Elizabeth Nyamayaro, Executive Director of UN Women and Founder of HeForShe. The panel also included Lena Schofield, Hilary Stauffer, Douglas Booth and Charles Stephens, Head of Global Gender Agenda and Head of Diversity and Inclusion Head Office Functions at Barclays Plc. The comment made by Charles Stephens that came under criticism
recounted an incident where ‘I was recently…(in) a small grocery grab and go...in the centre of London... There was a veiled woman working behind the counter and this guy came in and grabbed her breast. And I’m like, I said something not very polite in very loud terms out of a reaction. I’m blown away, like, I’m in the centre of London and this is happening. This isn’t a rural village in Africa or the rural United States’. Whilst making this statement Stephens gestured towards Elizabeth Nyamayaro, the only BME panellist. Lena Schofield, LSESU Women’s Officer and panellist at the event commented ‘Regarding the UN Women event, I would describe it as a really uncomfortable thing to be a part of. I had reservations about taking part, but had hoped it would be an opportunity to challenge the school on real issues. Unfortunately HeForShe and LSE were more interested in cross promotion for its own sake rather than engaging with the concerns of students. The high point of the
event was certainly contributions from students in the audience who challenged HeForShe on their poor record on recognising non-binary gender identities and raised serious concerns about safety on London transport. It was a shame to see the panelists fail to engage fully with these questions, or attempt to mansplain women’s experiences to us. Most concerning were the xenophobic comments made by a panelist, which the Chair failed to challenge. HeForShe has repeatedly shown itself to be more interested in press and centering the voices of men than intersectional feminist issues.’ Schofield’s full statement can be read on page 3. Mahatir Pasha, LSESU BME Officer said, regarding Stephens’ comment, that ‘I find it extremely shocking that someone who is Head of Diversity and Inclusion at a company as large as Barclays can so casually exert what come across as racist remarks. From what I have heard, not only does the statement suggest that sexism is in some way more understandable in rural parts
The City Sport
of Africa or the United States, but it also posits that it is more prevalent in these regions. Evidence actually suggests that islamophobia, especially that against women, is just as much of a problem in London than it is anywhere else. This can be seen through the Met Police recently releasing that hate crimes against Muslims in London have risen by 70% in the past year, with Tell MAMA, an organisation that monitors Islamophobic attacks, saying that 60% of Islamaphobia victims were women. To suggest that some hate crimes are more understandable in Africa and the US than in London is not only lacking in evidence, but may also reinforce lazy, often orientalist, stereotypes. These kinds of remarks lack foundation, cause offence and are wholly unacceptable. They should not be welcome at the LSE.’ The HeForShe Campaign was contacted for comment, but at time of print The Beaver had not received a statement. Read the full report on Page 3
An Interview with AU Welcome Party, James Meadway Reviewed!
Page 24 Page 32
THE HEFORSHE EVENT ON Wednesday has left me feeling tired, insulted, and disappointed. There were just too many comments made at the event which left me despairing over the future of gender equality, and consequently, the future of feminism. An event supposedly aimed at reaching a state where gender discrimination is a distant memory, in turn went on to reinforce the barriers that many people face in getting involved in the discussion of gender equality, as well as reinforced the very structures of kyriarchy that the event supposedly opposed. Now HeForShe, instead of addressing the history of discrimination in the struggle for gender equality, went on to make uneasy lesbophobic and xenophobic comments. Actor Douglas Booth referred to the hypothetical sporty girl who prefers hockey over ‘hanging out with her mates’. He expressed distress when he imagined people calling her a lesbian. Yet he failed to qualify this. Now I’m going to give Booth the benefit of the doubt and assume the distress he felt was over how people can so shockingly assume someone’s sexuality is determined by the sport they play. However the fact Booth didn’t qualify his disgust gave off the impression that he thought being called a lesbian is an insult. As a person in the media he surely must understand the impact and gravity of word choice, and even more so when he is given a powerful platform on which to speak. Continued on Page 9