Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
V
SOMMARIO GENERALE SALUTI
XVII
RELAZIONI INTRODUTTIVE
ALBANO BIONDI - Tempi e memorie della città GIOVANNI SANTINI - Lo Stato Estense nel quadro degli ordinamenti italiani preunitari GIORGIO BOCCOLARI - Gli Estensi di Modena MARCO CATTINI - Per un profilo dell’economia modenese nei secoli XVII e XVIII ODOARDO ROMBALDI - Dalla Repubblica Cispadana alla Repubblica Cisalpina Giovanni Paradisi e Iacopo Lamberti
3 11 23 45 69
LA CAPITALE
ANNA MARIA MATTEUCCI ARMANDI - Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena e i disegni di Angelo Venturoli GIORDANO BERTUZZI - Rinnovamento edilizio di una capitale ORIANNA BARACCHI - Vie, piazze, canali di Modena capitale ELENA CORRADINI - La zecca ducale di Modena: 1598-1796 ERNESTO MILANO - Vicissitudini della Biblioteca Estense alla Corte di Modena JADRANKA BENTINI - Collezionismo di corte: una sintesi e alcune riflessioni PERICLE DI PIETRO - Rapporti degli Estensi con l’Università di Modena
85 93 105 125 151 181 187
ARTE E CULTURA MATERIALE
ANGELO MAZZA - Pittura “estense” a Modena nei secoli XVII-XVIII. I maestri dell’Accademia di pittura GRAZIELLA MARTINELLI BRAGLIA - La pittura nel Ducato austro-estense MARINELLA PIGOZZI - L’architettura del Pubblico a Modena e a Reggio Emilia al tempo di Francesco III e di Ercole III VINCENZO VANDELLI - “...Pour la beauté de ses bâtiments”: Modena e l’architettura aristocratica LIDIA RIGHI GUERZONI - La scultura a Modena nel Seicento: collezionismo e commissioni ducali UMBERTO NOBILI - Sculture in stucco nel territorio reggiano tra Sei e Settecento MARIA CANOVA - La tradizione artigiana nella Modena ducale PATRIZIA CURTI - Note sull’arredo ducale tra il XVII e il XIX secolo
193 225 255 305 327 345 351 369
VI
Sommario generale
FRANCESCO LIVERANI - La ceramica nello Stato di Modena MASSIMO MUSSINI - La comunicazione grafica negli Stati estensi ELENA CORRADINI – PIER LUIGI CAVANI - “La preziosa Galleria delle Medaglie, e ricco Museo” degli Estensi nel palazzo ducale di Modena CARLO GIOVANNINI - La diffusione dell’arte organaria negli Stati estensi fra Seicento e Ottocento
379 385 413 431
STATI DI CASA D’ESTE
LAURA FEDERZONI - Gli Stati di Casa d’Este nella cartografia GRAZIA BIONDI - Comunità e corte a Modena nel periodo di formazione della Capitale ARMENO FONTANA - Il Frignano nello Stato di Modena GINO BADINI - La città e il Ducato di Reggio nello Stato di Modena (1598-1859) GIULIVO RICCI - La Lunigiana interna e gli Estensi PIER LUIGI RAGGI - La Garfagnana negli Stati estensi GILBERTO ZACCHÈ - La città e il principato di Carpi nello Stato di Modena TULLIO SORRENTINO - La nascita e il perdurare del “mito” dello Stato di Sassuolo ALBERTO GHIDINI - La città e il Principato di Correggio nello Stato di Modena BRUNO ANDREOLLI - Mirandola e i Pico di fronte a Modena e agli Estensi GABRIELE FABBRICI - Riflessioni sulla genesi della Contea gonzaghesca di Novellara OLGA RAFFO - Il Ducato di Massa ed il principato di Carrara nello Stato austro-estense (1829-1859)
451 481 495 513 541 551 571 587 601 617 635 651
II SOCIETÀ
GUIDO GUERZONI - Le corti estensi nella devoluzione del 1598 ALBERTO MENZIANI - L’esercito estense ed austro-estense (1598-1859) GIANCARLO MONTANARI - Il Vescovato poi Arcivescovato di Modena (1598-1859) GIUSEPPE ORLANDI - I religiosi dello Stato di Modena nel Settecento tra riforme e rivoluzione ANDREA ZANARDO - Gli ebrei negli Stati estensi LAURA TURCHI - Matrimoni e memoria genealogica fra tardo medioevo ed età moderna MARIO PECORARO - Massoneria, società segrete e “congiura estense” DANIELA GRANA - Le istituzioni di assistenza e beneficenza di Modena Capitale ANNA GIANNETTI - Viaggiatori stranieri a Modena: alla scoperta di una città CESARE MALAGOLI - Comunità, nobiltà e borghesia nel periodo austroestense
669 699 719 743 783 801 833 847 855 867
Sommario generale
VII
IL DIRITTO E L’ECONOMIA
MARCO CAVINA - Per una storia della cultura giuridica negli Stati estensi: fonti e problemi CARMELO ELIO TAVILLA - La giustizia suprema negli Stati estensi (secc. XV-XIX) GIUSEPPE BEDONI - Il diritto civile negli Stati estensi: dal codice del 1771 al codice del 1851 ANGELO SPAGGIARI - Gli archivi negli Stati estensi LUIGI PUCCI - “Il capitale di traffico”: aspetti e problemi dell’economia modenese del Settecento ALBERTO RINALDI - Il possesso fondiario modenese dal sec. XVIII al 1859 GIORGIO BOCCOLARI - L’economia modenese nel periodo austro-estense
887 905 919 933 951 967 981
LA CULTURA
GIORGIO MONTECCHI - Stampatori e librai nella Modena capitale degli Estensi FABIO MARRI - Muratori, lo Stato di Modena e le relazioni col mondo tedesco ANNA ROSA VENTURI - Girolamo Tiraboschi e le figure dei bibliotecari estensi nella Modena Capitale ALESSANDRA CHIARELLI - La civiltà musicale modenese nel periodo estense (secc. XVII-XIX) MARINA CALORE VECCHI - La vita teatrale a Modena dal Seicento all’Ottocento PAOLA DI PIETRO LOMBARDI - Modena nella storiografia post-unitaria: il contributo dei principali istituti culturali modenesi MARTINO CAPUCCI - Letteratura di una Capitale RENATO BERTACCHINI - Avvenimenti e personaggi politici modenesi nella civiltà letteraria dell’Ottocento
995 1029 1047 1061 1077 1097 1115 1133
MODENA E GLI STATI EUROPEI
HUBERT GASSER - Lo Stato di Modena e l’Impero LUIGI LONDEI – MARINA MORENA - Lo Stato di Modena e la Santa Sede ANNA BELLINAZZI – FRANCESCO MARTELLI - Le relazioni del Granducato di Toscana con lo Stato di Modena nei carteggi politici del principato mediceo MARINA BROGI - Lo Stato di Modena e la Repubblica di Lucca RITA SEVERI - Rapporti tra il ducato di Modena e l’Inghilterra nel ’600. Il sogno di Maria di Modena regina d’Inghilterra UGO COVA - Austria e Modena: archivi, rapporti dinastici, politica commerciale MARIA PARENTE - Lo Stato di Modena e lo Stato di Parma e Piacenza
1151 1159
Bibliografia
1277
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1321
Indice degli autori
1367
1179 1211 1227 1241 1257
62&,(7-
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
99<
*8,'2 *8(5=21,
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
3UHPHVVD 4XHVWR HODERUDWR q LO ULVXOWDWR/ DQFRUFKp SDU]LDOH/ GL XQ HVSHULPHQWR1 1RQ VL WUDWWD GL XQD PRQRJUDILD VXOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD/ GL XQ VDJJLR GL PH0 WRGRORJLD GHOOD ULFHUFD RSSXUH GL XQD SURYD GL VWRULD HFRQRPLFR0VRFLDOH R SROLWLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ PD GHOOD WDSSD GL XQ SHUFRUVR GL LQGDJLQH TXDVL GHFHQ0 QDOH/ YROWR DG DSSURIRQGLUH OD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOOH FRUWL HVWHQVL LQ HWi PRGHUQD1 ,O PHWRGR H OH IRQWL 7DOH RELHWWLYR q VWDWR SHUVHJXLWR DGRWWDQGR GXH DSSURFFL FRPSOHPHQWDUL H ILQDOL]]DWL D XQD UHFLSURFD LQWHJUD]LRQH/ FRPSXOVDQGR OH IRQWL WUDGL]LRQDO0 PHQWH LQWHUURJDWH QHOOH ULFHUFKH GL VWRULD SROLWLFD/ LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ JLXULGLFD/ VR0 FLDOH HG HFRQRPLFD H FRVWUXHQGR LQ SDUDOOHOR XQ·µDQDJUDIH HVWHQVHµ LQIRUPD0 WL]]DWD/ XQ pWDW FLYLO/ UHVLGHQWH LQ XQ GDWD0EDVH UHOD]LRQDOH PXOWLOLYHOOR RYH VR0 QR FRQIOXLWL L GDWL4 ULJXDUGDQWL L VDODULDWL GL EROOHWWD +FKH UDSSUHVHQWDQR OD VHPL WRWDOLWi GHL FRUWLJLDQL/ HFFH]LRQ IDWWD SHU JOL VWDOOLHUL H L PXODWWLHUL H SHU L PHPEUL GHOOD JXDUGLD GXFDOH, GL GLYHUVL SULQFLSL H SULQFLSHVVH GHO VDQJXH1 ,QIDWWL/ SHU VWXGLDUH OD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHOOH FRUWL GL $OIRQVR ,, H GL &HVDUH/ KR ULFRVWUXLWR L WHPSL GL SHUPDQHQ]D D FRUWH/ L EDFLQL H OH SURFHGXUH GL FR0 RSWD]LRQH/ OH GLQDPLFKH GHOOH FDUULHUH LQWHUQH GHL PHPEUL GHOOH FRUWL GL= ²²²²²²²² 4 4XDQGR q VWDWR SRVVLELOH KR ULSRUWDWR SHU FLDVFXQ LQGLYLGXR O·DQQR GL LQL]LR H GL ILQH VHUYL]LR/ OD GXUDWD GHOOD FDUULHUD/ LO WLWROR/ LO QRPH/ LO FRJQRPH2SDWURQLPLFR2WRSRQLPR/ JOL HYHQWXDOL VRSUDQQRPL/ OD SURYHQLHQ]D JHRJUDILFD/ JOL HYHQWXDOL UDSSRUWL SDUHQWDOL/ OH FDULFKH ULFRSHUWH/ JOL XIILFL GL DSSDUWHQHQ]D/ OD FDUULHUD FRPSOHVVLYD/ L VDODUL PHQVLOL1
9:3
4,
5,
6,
7, 8,
9,
:,
;,
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
$OIRQVR , H FRQVRUWL/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR 41793 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 47<7 H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 4866/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 47<7/ 47<</ 4833/ 4835/ 4837/ 4839/ 483;/ 483</ 4843/ 4844/ 4845/ 4846/ 4848/ 484;/ 4854/ 4856/ 4858/ 4859/ 485;/ 4863/ 4864/ 4865/ 48661 (UFROH ,,/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR <69 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 4863 H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 488;/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 4863/ 4864/ 4865/ 4866/ 4867/ 4868/ 4869/ 486:/ 486</ 4875/ 4876/ 4877/ 487:/ 4883/ 4886/ 4888/ 488;/ 488<1 5HQDWD GL 9DORLV/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR 57: LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 4864 H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 4893/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 486404865/ 4867/ 486809/ 4873/ 4875/ 4877/ 487;/ 487</ 4883/ 4884/ 4886/ 4887/ 4888/ 4889/ 488;/ 488</ 48931 /DXUD (XVWRFKLD 'LDQWL/ OLPLWDWDPHQWH DL 5: FRUWLJLDQL FKH OD VHUYLURQR QHO SHULRGR 489<0:61 $OIRQVR ,,/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR 41968 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 4888 H DV0 VXQWL VLQR DO 48<:/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJL0 VWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 488809/ 488;0</ 4893/ 4895/ 4896/ 4897/ 4898/ 489:/ 489;/ 489</ 48:7/ 48:9/ 48:;/ 48;5/ 48;6/ 48;8/ 48;;/ 48;</ 48<3/ 48<5/ 48<7 +6SHQGHULD 6<: H 6SLVDQWL :;,/ 48<9 +6SHQGHULD 74: H 6SLVDQWL ;3,/ 48<: +$QWROLQL,1 &HVDUH H 9LUJLQLD GH· 0HGLFL/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR <9< LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 48;4 H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 495:/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 48;4048;7/ 48;9048;:/ 48;;/ 48;<0<3/ 48<6/ 48<7/ 48<8/ 48<9/ 48<:/ 48<;/ 48<</ 4933/ 4936/ 4937/ 4939/ 493:/ 493</ 4943/ 4944/ 4945/ 4946/ 4947/ 4948/ 4949/ 494:/ 494;/ 494</ 4953/ 4954/ 4955/ 4956/ 4957/ 4958/ 4959/ 495:1 $OIRQVR ,,,/ )UDQFHVFR ,/ $OIRQVR ,9 H /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ UHODWLYDPHQWH DL VROL 84 FRUWLJLDQL GL &HVDUH/ DVVXQWL VLQR DO 495:/ FKH GDO 4977 DO 49:5 ULPDVHUR DO VHUYL]LR GHL GXFKL H GHOOH GXFKHVVH GL &DVD G·(VWH +VRQR SXU0 WURSSR VFRPSDUVH OH EROOHWWH GHL VDODULDWL UHODWLYH DJOL DQQL 495;04976,1 GRQ $OIRQVR/ PDUFKHVH GL 0RQWHFFKLR/ SDGUH GL &HVDUH/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR 6<8 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 4873 H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 48;4/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 487304874/ 487504878/ 48790487;/ 4887/ 489404897/ 48980489:/ 48;4 +L UHJLVWUL VL0 QR DO 4878 LQFOXGRQR DQFKH L VDODULDWL GL GRQ $OIRQVLQR,1
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9:4
<,
GHO FDUGLQDOH ,SSROLWR ,,/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR 978 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 485; H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 48:5/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 485;/ 485</ 4873/ 4874/ 4884/ 4885/ 4889/ 4898/ 489:/ 489;/ 489</ 48:3/ 48:4/ 48:51 43, GHO FDUGLQDOH /XLJL/ LQ FXL VHUYLURQR :34 LQGLYLGXL/ JLi SUHVHQWL QHO 488; H DVVXQWL VLQR DO 48;9/ L FXL GDWL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOO·HODERUD]LRQH GHL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL QHJOL DQQL 488;0488</ 488<04893/ 4899/ 489;/ 48:9/ 48::/ 48:;/ 48:</ 48;3/ 48;4/ 48;5/ 48;6/ 48;7/ 48;91 44, $OHVVDQGUR/ OLPLWDWDPHQWH DL 96 FRUWLJLDQL FKH OR VHUYLURQR QHO SHULRGR 48<30<5 +VL WUDWWD SXUWURSSR GHOO·XQLFD EROOHWWD VRSUDYYLVVXWD, 45, /XFUH]LD G·(VWH/ GXFKHVVD G·8UELQR/ OLPLWDWDPHQWH DL 9< FRUWLJLDQL PHQ0 ]LRQDWL QHO VXR WHVWDPHQWR GHO 48<;1 /D VFHOWD GL FRQFHQWUDUPL VXL VROL VDODULDWL GL EROOHWWD q GHULYDWD GDO IDWWR FKH VROR FRVWRUR HUDQR FRQVLGHUDWL D WXWWL JOL HIIHWWL FRUWLJLDQL/ SRLFKp VHUYLYDQR VWDELOPHQWH LO GXFD/ OD GXFKHVVD H L YDUL SULQFLSL H SULQFLSHVVH GL &DVD G·(VWH DOO·LQWHUQR GHJOL VSD]L SULYDWL H GRPHVWLFL= OD FRQWLQXLWj GHOOD UHOD]LRQH WUD SULQ0 FLSH H FRUWLJLDQR H OD SURVVLPLWj ILVLFD H UHVLGHQ]LDOH/ LQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDO0 OH UDJLRQL GHO VHUYL]LR/ FRVWLWXLYDQR L SULPL SDUDPHWUL GL VHOH]LRQH1 4XHVWH HOHPHQWDUL GLVWLQ]LRQL FRQVHQWLYDQR GL FODVVLILFDUH OH YDULH FDWHJR0 ULH GL LQGLYLGXL FKH LQWUDWWHQHYDQR UDSSRUWL ODYRUDWLYL FRQ LO PLOLHX FXUWHQVH= PHQWUH LO UHTXLVLWR GHOOD FRQWLQXLWj HVFOXGHYD L QXPHURVLVVLPL IRUQLWRUL GL EHQL H VHUYL]L/5 OD FR0UHVLGHQ]D HG LO SULYDWR VHUYLUH GLVFULPLQDYDQR JOL LQGLYLGXL ²²²²²²²² 5
6L LQWHQGRQR SHU IRUQLWRUL GL EHQL H VHUYL]L VLD L FRPPHUFLDQWL FKH ULIRUQLYDQR OD FRUWH GXFDOH GL PDQXIDWWL H GHUUDWH/ FKH L WHFQLFL/ JOL DUWLJLDQL H OH PDHVWUDQ]H FRLQYROWL QHOO·HVHFX]LRQH GL SURJHWWL GL GLYHUVD VSHFLH1 4XHVWL XOWLPL VL GLYLGHYDQR WUD ODYRUDWRUL VDO0 WXDUL H VWDJLRQDOL/ QRWL FRPH VWUDRUGLQDUL +IDFFKLQL/ WUDVSRUWDWRUL/ DTXDUROL/ RSHUDL LPSHJQDWL LQ ODYRUL GL PDQXWHQ]LRQH H ULSDUD]LRQH GL WLSR VSHFLDOLVWLFR/ EDUFDLROL/ ELURFFLDL/ PXODWWLHUL H FDUUHWWLHUL,/ H TXHOOL FKH/ SXU RSHUDQGR WXWWR O·DQQR JUD]LH DOOH FRPPHVVH GL FRUWH/ QRQ YH0 QLYDQR DVVXQWL PD SDJDWL D JLRUQDWD/ D RSHUD/ FRQ FRQWUDWWL D EUHYH WHUPLQH ULQQRYDELOL1 8QD SULPD VWLPD/ ULIHUHQWHVL DOO·LQGRWWR GHOOD VROD FRUWH GXFDOH/ QH VWLPD LO QXPHUR LQ FLUFD 4933/ GLPRVWUDQGR TXDQWR IRVVH SURSXOVLYD OD SUHVHQ]D GHOOH FRUWL QHOO·DPELWR GHOOH HFRQRPLH XU0 EDQH1 7UD L IRUQLWRUL GL EHQL GREELDPR DQQRYHUDUH/ ROWUH DL ULYHQGLWRUL GL GHUUDWH DOLPHQWDUL FKH RSHUDYDQR VXO PHUFDWR GH SLD]]D IHUUDUHVH +GL FXL q LPSRVVLELOH YDOXWDUH O·HVDWWD FRQVLVWHQ]D QXPHULFD,/ XQD PHGLD GL FLUFD 533 LQGLYLGXL/ GLVWLQWL SHU FDWHJRULH PHUFHRORJLFKH +JUDQDJOLH H OHJXPL/ YLQL/ IUXWWD H RUWDJJL/ ODWWLFLQL/ VDOXPL H JUDVVL DQLPDOL/ ROLR/ VSH]LH/ OHJQD GD IXRFR H GD RSHUD/ DUWLFROL GL IHUUDPHQWD/ FRUGDPL/ ERWWL H PDVWHOOL/ VHUYL]L GD FXFLQD LQ UDPH/ YHWUR H FHUDPLFD/ VDSRQL/ FDQGHOH H WRUFH/ WHVVXWL/ FDSL G·DEELJOLDPHQWR/ FDO]DWXUH/ FXRL/ DUPL/ DUJLOOD H VDEELD/ FDUERQH GL OHJQD HFFHWHUD,> WDOH FLIUD VRWWRVWLPD LO QXPHUR HIIHWWLYR/ SRLFKp HVLVWH0 YDQR DPSLH UHWL GL VXEIRUQLWXUD JHVWLWH GD XQ DJHQWH0IRUQLWRUH SULQFLSDOH= DG HVHPSLR OD FRU0
9:5
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
FKH/ SXU HVVHQGR UHJRODUPHQWH VWLSHQGLDWL GDO GXFD/ QRQ ILJXUDYDQR WUD L FRUWL0 JLDQL LPPHGLDWH VDODULDWL/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH ODYRUDYDQR ORQWDQR GDOOD VXD &DVD H GLVWDQWL GDOOD VXD SHUVRQD1 7UD TXHVWL WURYLDPR JOL XIILFLDOL +SRGHVWj/ QRWDL/ JRYHUQDWRUL/ FRPPLVVDUL/ FDSLWDQL/ HWF1, RSHUDQWL VXO WHUULWRULR GHO GXFDWR/ L PHPEUL GHOOH PDJLVWUDWXUH ILQDQ]LDULH IHUUDUHVL H SHULIHULFKH/ L PHPEUL GHOOH PLOL]LH SHUPDQHQWL H GHOOD IORWWD GXFDOH/ L SURIHVVRUL GHOOR 6WXGLR IHUUDUHVH/6 OH ROWUH 51333 SHUVRQH LPSHJQDWH QHOOH DWWLYLWj DJULFROH H ]RRWHFQLFKH/7 OH 51833 LPSLHJDWH QHOOH PDQLIDWWXUH GXFDOL +$UWH GHOOD ODQD H GHOOD VHWD/ IRUQDFL GHO YH0 WUR/ IDEEULFD GL VDSRQH/ ]HFFD/ IRQGHULH/ IRUQDFL SHU OD SURGX]LRQH GL PDWHULD0 OL HGLOL,/8 OH :330;33 DWWLYH QHOOH VDOLQH GL /RQJDVWULQR/ QHOOH YDOOL GL &RPDF0 ²²²²²²²² WH GXFDOH DFTXLVWDYD LO SHVFH SHU OH VXH PHQVH GDO VXSHULRUH GHO GDWLR GHOOD SHVFDULD/ FKH D VXD YRO0 WD OR FRPSUDYD GD SL• GL GXHFHQWR WUD VSURFDQL H SHVFDGXUL/ H OR VWHVVR DFFDGHYD SHU O·RIILFLDOH DO SROODUR R SHU LO EHFFDUR GL FRUWH/ FKH ´ILOWUDYDQRµ OH UHOD]LRQL FRQ L SLFFROL ULYHQGLWRUL> LQ TXHVWR PRGR/ LQYHFH GL HIIHWWXDUH H UHJLVWUDUH PLJOLDLD GL WUDQVD]LRQL HFRQRPLFKH GL VFDUVR ULOLHYR +GXH SROOL/ WUH FDSSRQL/ FLQTXDQWD XRYD/ HWF1, H GL LQWDVDUH L UHJLVWUL FRQWDELOL FRQ OD WUDVFUL]LR0 QH GL FHQWLQDLD H FHQWLQDLD GL FRQWL GL LPSRUWL ULVLELOL/ JOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL GXFDOL IURQWHJJLDYDQR XQ VROR UHIHUHQWH/ FXL HUD GHOHJDWR O·RQHUH GHOOD JHVWLRQH DPPLQLVWUDWLYD H FRQWDELOH GHOOD UHWH GHL VXE0IRUQLWRUL1 8Q SUXGHQWH FDOFROR FRPSOHVVLYR GHL IRUQLWRUL GL EHQL SHUPHWWH IDFLOPHQWH GL LGHQWLILFDUH ;330<33 LQGLYLGXL1 7DOH YDORUH q SUHVVRFKp LGHQWLFR D TXHOOR GHL IRUQLWRUL GL VHUYL]L= WHFQLFL/ DUWLJLDQL H PDH0 VWUDQ]H FRVWDQWHPHQWH LPSHJQDWL QHOO·HVHFX]LRQH GHOOH FRPPHVVH GXFDOL> D WLWROR GL HVHPSLR QHL VHWWRUL LQJHQLHULVWLFR0LGUDXOLFR H DUFKLWHWWRQLFR0HGLOL]LR +LQJHJQHUL/ DJULPHQVRUL/ VRSUD0 VWDQWL DOOH IDEEULFKH H DOOH ERQLILFKH/ DUFKLWHWWL/ SLWWRUL/ VFXOWRUL/ LQWDJOLDWRUL/ ODSLFLGL/ WRUQLWRUL/ PDHVWUL GD PXUR/ YHWUDL/ IDOHJQDPL/ IDEEUL/ IRUQDFLDUL, RSHUDYDQR LQ PHGLD 783 LQGLYLGXL/ PHQWUH SL• GL 533 +VDUWL H VDUWH/ WLUDRUR/ ULFDPDWRUL H ULFDPDWULFL/ SHQQDFFKLHUL/ FDO]RODL/ FLD0 EDWWLQL, HUDQR FRLQYROWL QHOOD FRQIH]LRQH GL FDO]DWXUH H FDSL G·DEELJOLDPHQWR FRPPLVVLRQDWL GDOOD *XDUGDURED GXFDOH1 $QFKH TXHVWL LQGLYLGXL/ QRQRVWDQWH WUDHVVHUR OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL SURSUL UHGGLWL GD FRPPHVVH GXFDOL/ HUDQR SDJDWL D JLRUQDWD R D ODYRUR/ QRQ ILJXUDQGR TXLQGL WUD JOL VWLSHQGLDWL ILVVL1 6 $OPHQR VLQR DO 47:4 JOL VWLSHQGL GHL SURIHVVRUL H GHL OHWWRUL GHOOD FHOHEUH 8QLYHUVLWj IHUUDUHVH IXURQR SDJDWL GDL GXFKL/ L TXDOL LQ VHJXLWR/ GRSR DYHU DFFROODWR WDOH RQHUH DOOH FDVVH FRPXQDOL/ VL ULVHUYDURQR LO FRQWUROOR GHOO·RUJDQR FROOHJLDOH FKH SURYYHGHYD DOOD QRPLQD GHL GRFHQWL H DOOD GHILQL]LRQH GHJOL LQGLUL]]L GL VWXGLR1 7 6L QRWL EHQH FKH TXHVWR YDORUH VL ULIHULVFH HVFOXVLYDPHQWH DJOL LQGLYLGXL FKH ODYRUDYDQR QHOOH SURSULHWj IRQGLDULH FKH LO GXFD IDFHYD FRQGXUUH GLUHWWDPHQWH> ULVXOWDQR GXQTXH HVFOXVL GDO FRPSXWR FRORUR FKH VYROJHYDQR IXQ]LRQL DQDORJKH SHU FRQWR GHJOL DOWUL PHPEUL GL FDVD G·(VWH/ OD FXL VRPPD FRPSOHVVLYD VXSHUDYD GL JUDQ OXQJD TXHOOD GHL GLSHQGHQWL GXFDOL1 8 9DOH DQFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR OD SUHFLVD]LRQH GHOOD QRWD SUHFHGHQWH= LO &DUGLQDOH ,SSROLWR , FRQGXFHYD DWWUDYHUVR SURSUL IXQ]LRQDUL OH VXH PDQLIDWWXUH GL SDQQL ODQD H WHVVXWL VHULFL/ PHQWUH 6LJLVPRQGR G·(VWH/ IUDWHOOR GHO GXFD (UFROH ,/ GHWHQHYD +H GRSR GL OXL L VXRL HUHGL, LO
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9:6
FKLR/ QHOOH PLQLHUH H QHL IRUQL VLWXDWL VXOOH SHQGLFL DSSHQQLQLFKH1 7XWWL TXHVWL LQGLYLGXL GLSHQGHYDQR GDO GXFD/ PD QRQ HUDQR FRQVLGHUDWL PHPEUL GHOOD VXD FRUWH H OR VWHVVR DFFDGHYD SXUH DL PHPEUL GHOOH FRUWL GHOOD GXFKHVVD H GHJOL DOWUL SULQFLSL H SULQFLSHVVH GHO VDQJXH/ FRUWL FKH SXU QRQ UDJJLXQJHQGR OH GLPHQVLRQL GL TXHOOD GXFDOH/ Qp SRVVHGHQGRQH O·LQGXEELD FHQWUDOLWj SROLWLFD H VRFLDOH/ QH UHSOLFDYDQR LQ VFDOD ULGRWWD LO PHGHVLPR VFKHPD RUJDQL]]DWLYR/ HFRQRPLFR H UHOD]LRQDOH/ DVVLFXUDQGR DL SURSUL HVSR0 QHQWL LO JRGLPHQWR GHO PHGHVLPR UHJLPH HFRQRPLFR H ILVFDOH JRGXWR GDL FRUWLJLDQL GHO GXFD1 7XWWDYLD/ SXU DYHQGR GHOLPLWDWR L SHULPHWUL LQFOXVLYL GHOOD FRUWH GXFDOH H GL TXHOOH SDUWLFRODUL/ q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·RUGLQDULR,/ FRUULVSRVWR RJQL PHVH LQ PRQHWH DUJHQWHH: H2R GL OHJKH EURQ]HH/; H XQD GL ²²²²²²²² PRQRSROLR VXOOD SURGX]LRQH GL FDUWD/ VXOOH DWWLYLWj GL VWDPSD/ VXO FRPPHUFLR OLEUDULR1 9 $ SDUWLUH GDO UHJQR GL $OIRQVR ,/ RJQL SULQFLSH H SULQFLSHVVD GHO VDQJXH PDQWHQQH XQD SURSULD H LQGLSHQGHQWH EROOHWWD GHL VDODULDWL1 : )DFHYDQR HFFH]LRQH L PHPEUL GHOO·DOWD FRUWH +VLJQRUL H JHQWLOXRPLQL/ FDPHULHUL/ VFXGLHUL/ PDJJLRUGRPL H VLQLVFDOFKL/ RUDWRUL/ IDWWRUL JHQHUDOL/ FRQVLJOLHUL GL JLXVWL]LD,/ FKH/ D SDUWLUH GDOOD PHWi GHJOL DQQL FLQTXDQWD GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ YHQQHUR SDJDWL LQ EDQFR LQ VFXGL G·RUR1 ; )DWWD HFFH]LRQH SHU XQD R GXH PHQVLOLWj FKH YHQLYDQR UHJRODUPHQWH WUDWWHQXWH RJQL DQ0 QR= OD ´SDJD PRUWD GHOOH PXUDµ H OD ´SDJD PRUWD GH FRUWHµ1 9LJHYD LQIDWWL XQ VLVWHPD GL ULWH0 QXWH DOOD IRQWH/ WUDGL]LRQDOPHQWH QRWH FRPH SDJKH PRUWH/ FKH ULGXFHYD D 43 R D 44 LO QXPHUR GL VWLSHQGL PHQVLOL LQFDVVDWL1 6L WUDWWDYD GL XQD IRUPD GL SUHOLHYR ILVFDOH JLj GLIIXVD D PHWj 4XDWWURFHQWR/ GHVWLQDWD DOOD FRSHUWXUD GL SDUWLFRODUL YRFL GL VSHVD GHL ELODQFL VWDWDOL/ FKH ULSD0 JDYD SDU]LDOPHQWH LO GXFD GHOOH DPSLH HVHQ]LRQL FRQFHVVH D VYDULDWH FDWHJRULH GL FRUWLJLDQL/ LPPXQLWj FKH VL WUDGXFHYDQR LQ FRQVLVWHQWL FRQWUD]LRQL GHO JHWWLWR GL GHWHUPLQDWH LPSRVWH1 )LQR DL SULPL GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ WDOH ULWHQXWD IX OLPLWDWD DG XQD VROD PHQVLOLWj= VROR D SDUWLUH GDL SULPL DQQL ¶43 QH IX LQWURGRWWD XQD VHFRQGD/ GHQRPLQDWD SDJKD PRUWD GHOOH PXUD/ ULVHUYDWD HVSOLFLWDPHQWH DJOL RQHUL GL PDQXWHQ]LRQH H UDIIRU]DPHQWR GHOOD FLQWD PXUDULD H GHOO·LPSLDQWR GLIHQVLYR GHOOD FDSLWDOH GHO GXFDWR1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR/ PHQWUH TXDVL WXWWL L VLJQRUL/ JHQWLOXRPLQL/ FDPHULHUL/ VFXGLHUL/ IDWWRUL/ VHJUHWDUL H FRQVLJOLHUL GL JLXVWL]LD LQFDVVD0 YDQR GRGLFL VWLSHQGL/ L ULPDQHQWL PHPEUL GL FRUWH HUDQR JUDYDWL GDOOD VRWWUD]LRQH GL GXH
9:7
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
VWLSHQGLR VWUDRUGLQDULR +O·H[WUDRUGLQDULR,1 7DOH GLVWLQ]LRQH VFDWXULYD GDOOH QH0 JR]LD]LRQL FKH SUHFHGHYDQR O·DVVXQ]LRQH QHL UDQJKL GL FRUWH/ LQ FXL YHQLYD VWDELOLWD LQ DQWLFLSR OD TXRWD GL WHPSR ODYRUDWLYR H2R OD WLSRORJLD GHO ODYRUR FKH VDUHEEH VWDWD UHPXQHUDWD PHQVLOPHQWH QHOO·RUGLQDULR< H TXHOOD FKH LQYHFH VDUHEEH VWDWD SDJDWD D SDUWH QHOO·H[WUDRUGLQDULR SHU L ODYRUL FKH HFFHGHYDQR L OLPLWL SUHILVVDWL +HVSUHVVL LQ QXPHUR GL SH]]L SURGRWWL/ RUH R JLRUQDWH ODYRUDWL0 YH,1 $QFRUD SL• LPSRUWDQWH HUD SRL LO VDODULR LQ QDWXUD/43 R SURYLVLRQH/ FDOFRODWR VXOOD EDVH GHOOD SRVL]LRQH JHUDUFKLFD GHO ULFHYHQWH/ 44 HTXLYDOHQWH DO GRSSLR R ²²²²²²²² PHQVLOLWj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j GD 43 OLUH QH ULVFXRWHYD 453/ XQ FDQFHOOLHUH FRQ 43 OLUH DO PHVH/ PD JUDYDWR GL GXH SDJKH PRUWH/ QH LQFDVVDYD VROR 433/ SDUL D ;/9/; OLUH PHQVLOL1 < ,Q PHGLD HTXLYDOHQWH DO VDODULR SHUFHSLWR LQ 53 JLRUQDWH GD XQ DUWLJLDQR VSHFLDOL]]DWR1 43 9D SHUDOWUR UDPPHQWDWR/ D VFDQVR GL HTXLYRFL/ FKH WXWWL L SHUFHWWRUL GHOOH UD]LRQL DOL0 PHQWDUL HUDQR FKLDPDWL VSLVDQWL/ WXWWDYLD DOFXQL ULVFXRWHYDQR LO ´SDQLHUHµ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·DPPRQWDUH ILQDOH1 7DOH SUDVVL/ SRFR GLIIXVD DOO·LQL]LR GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ IX PDVVLFFLDPHQWH VHJXLWD QHO FRUVR GHO FLQ0 TXDQWHQQLR VXFFHVVLYR/ SHU PRWLYL SUHVXPLELOPHQWH LJLHQLFL H VLFXUDPHQWH ORJLVWLFR0 DPPLQLVWUDWLYL/ VROOHYDQGR JOL XIILFL GL FRUWH GD RQHURVL FDULFKL JHVWLRQDOL1 44 1RQ YL HUD RJJHWWR R JHVWR FKH QRQ IRVVH PLVXUDELOH H PLVXUDWR/ YDOXWDELOH H YDOXWDWR/ SRLFKp RJQL EHQH/ DQFKH LO SL• EDQDOH/ PLVXUDYD H ULIOHWWHYD OD SRVL]LRQH RFFXSDWD QHOO·RUGUH VRFLDO= OH TXDOLWj GHOOH FRVH H GHJOL XRPLQL HUDQR LQVHSDUDELOL JHPHOOH/ OD SURYD LQFRQWURYHUWLEL0 OH GHO UHFLSURFR YDORUH1 2FFRUUHYD JDUDQWLUH XQD SHUIHWWD H LQVLQGDFDELOH FRUULVSRQGHQ]D ELXQLYRFD WUD LO UDQJR GHJOL XRPLQL H TXHOOR GHL EHQL H GHL VHUYL]L GL ORUR VSHWWDQ]D= FLEL H LQ0 GXPHQWL/ DUPL H JLRLHOOL/ FDYDOFDWXUH H GRQL/ RVSLWDOLWj H VYDJKL GRYHYDQR HVVHUH HVDWWDPHQWH FRPPLVXUDWL DOOH SL• VIXPDWH SRVL]LRQL JHUDUFKLFKH/ DVVLFXUDQGR O·HTXLWj GL XQ PHFFDQLVPR FKH WURYDYD OD SURSULD UDJLRQ G·HVVHUH QHOO·DVLPPHWULFD GLVWULEX]LRQH GL EHQL H VHUYL]L GL TXD0 OLWj LQHJXDOH1 &RVu JOL RUGLQDUL GHO YLQR ULSRUWDYDQR L QRPLQDWLYL GL FRORUR FKH SRWHYDQR ULFHYH0 UH OH UD]LRQL GL TXDWWUR GLYHUVH TXDOLWi GL YLQR +GD VLJQRUH/ GD WLQHOOR/ GD IDPLJOLD IUHVFR H EXLGR,/ JOL RUGLQDUL GHO SDQH UHJRODYDQR O·DVVHJQD]LRQH GL RWWR WLSL GL SDQH +SDQH LQWLHUR GD VLJQRUH GL SULPR H VHFRQGR ILRUH/ SDQ WDLD/ URVHIIR/ IUHVFKR/ GD IDPLJOLD/ GD FDQL/ ELVFRWWR,/ JOL RUGLQDUL GHO SHVFH VWDELOLYDQR FKL SRWHYD PDQJLDUQH OH VSHFLH SL• ´RUGLQDULHµ H TXHOOH SL• SUHJLDWH +SHVFH H IUXWWL GL PDUH/ VWR0
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9:8
DO WULSOR GHO YDORUH GHO VDODULR LQ PRQHWD/ GLIIHUHQ]LDWR VLD LQ WHUPLQL TXDQWLWD0 WLYL FKH TXDOLWDWLYL H FRQVLVWHQWH LQ UHJRODUL DVVHJQD]LRQL GL DOLPHQWL45 H EHQL GL XVR GRPHVWLFR/46 WHVVXWL/ FDO]DWXUH H FDSL GL DEELJOLDPHQWR JLj FRQIH]LRQD0 WL/ VHQ]D GLPHQWLFDUH OD FRQFHVVLRQH JUDWXWLWD GHOOH DELWD]LRQL/47 O·DVVHJQD]LRQH GL FDYDOFDWXUH PDQWHQXWH QHOOH VWDOOH GXFDOL/ OH FXUH DVVLFXUDWH GDL PHGLFL GL FRUWH/ L GRQL ULWXDOL FKH VHJXLYDQR HYHQWL SDUWLFRODUL +QDVFLWH H PDWULPRQL,/ DUULYDQGR ILQR DOOD WRWDOH FRSHUWXUD GHOOH VSHVH GHL IXQHUDOL1 2UD/ O·RSHUD]LRQH GL FRVWUX]LRQH GHOO·DQDJUDIH SURVRSRJUDILFD q SDVVDWD DWWUDYHUVR WUH GLVWLQWH IDVL1 1HOOD SULPD KR WUDVFULWWR LQ GLVWLQWL IRJOL GL ODYRUR GL VLQJROL ILOHV GL ([FHO 813 IRU :LQGRZV +L ILOHV VRQR VWDWL LQWHVWDWL DL GLYHUVL SDWHU2PDWHU IDPLOLDH, L GDWL GL 48; EROOHWWH GHL VDODULDWL +FRQVHUYDWH QHL IRQGL 6DODULDWL GHOOD &DPHUD 'XFDOH H $PPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL 3ULQFLSL GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD,/ GL 5 UHJLVWUL GHO IRQGR 6SHQGHULD H 5 UHJLVWUL GHO IRQGR 6SLVDQWL FRQVHUYDWL QHO PHGHVLPR DU0 FKLYLR/ GHOOD OLVWD GHL VDODULDWL GL $OIRQVR ,, GHO 48<: SXEEOLFDWD LQ DSSHQGLFH GD $QWROLQL/ GHOOD OLVWD DOOHJDWD DO WHVWDPHQWR GL /XFUH]LD G·(VWH/ GHOOH 4: ERO0 OHWWH GHL VDODULDWL GL 5HQDWD GL )UDQFLD GHSRVLWDWH SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 7RULQR/ VH]LRQL ULXQLWH1 $ TXHVWR SXQWR/ L GDWL GHL IRJOL GL ODYRUR GHL VLQJROL ILOHV VRQR FRQIOXLWL LQ XQ SULPR GDWD0EDVH +UHDOL]]DWR LQ ([FHO SHU :LQGRZV <;,/ FKH KR XWLOL]]DWR SHU OD FRGLILFD H OD VWDQGDUGL]]D]LRQH GHL GDWL RULJLQDOL1 7DOL RSHUD]LRQL KDQQR ²²²²²²²² ULRQL/ WURWH/ OXFFL H JDPEHUL,/ JOL RUGLQDUL GL JXDUGDURED H GL GUDSSHULD UHJRODYDQR O·DVVHJQD]LRQH GL FDO]DWXUH/ FDSL GL YHVWLDULR/ OHQ]XROD H FXVFLQL/ FRSHUWH H PDWHUDVVL GL YDULH TXDOLWj H VWDELOL0 YDQR TXDOL TXDGUL/ DUD]]L/ EDFLOL H EURQ]HWWL GRYHVVHUR RUQDUH OH VWDQ]H GHL YDUL RVSLWL1 45 (FFH]LRQ IDWWD SHU L PHPEUL GHOOH IDPLOLH/ XVXDOPHQWH FRVWLWXLWH GDL PHPEUL GHOO·DOWD FRUWH H GD DOFXQL GHL SL~ LQWLPL VHUYLWRUL +VLJQRUL/ JHQWLOXRPLQL/ FDPHULHUL/ VFXGLHUL/ SDJJL/ VFDOFKL H XIILFLDOL LQ WLQHOOR/ DOFXQL VWDIILHUL H XIILFLDOL LQ JXDUGDURED,/ FKH SUDQ]DYDQR H FHQD0 YDQR DOOD WDYROD GHO GXFD H QHL GXH WLQHOOL1 46 , VDODULDWL GL EROOHWWD DYHYDQR GLULWWR DOOD UHJRODUH FRUUHVSRQVLRQH GL XQD R SL• UD]LRQL D0 OLPHQWDUL JLRUQDOLHUH +D VHFRQGD GHO QXPHUR GHOOH ERFFKH D FDULFR, H FRVWLWXLWH GD FDUQH R SH0 VFH +4 OLEEUD H 426 DO JLRUQR/ RVVLD 783 JUDPPL/ FRQ FLQTXH JLRUQL GD FDUQH +GD GRPHQLFD D JLRYHGu, H GXH JLRUQL GD SHVFH +YHQHUGu0VDEDWR, DOOD VHWWLPDQD/ YLQR +5 ER]]H R ERFFDOL DO JLRU0 QR/ HTXLYDOHQWL D 5/; OLWUL, H SDQH +LQ PHGLD WUHQWD RQFH/ SDUL D ;33 JUDPPL,/ LQWHJUDWH GD SH0 ULRGLFKH GLVWULEX]LRQL GL ROLR/ VDOH/ FDUQH VDODWD/ ODUGR H IRUPDJJLR/ FDQGHOH H OHJQD GD DUGHUH H GDOOH OLPRVLQH QDWDOL]LH H SDVTXDOL +XRYD H FDSSRQL/ SDQL GROFL H IUXWWL/ IRUPDJJL H VSH]LH,1 47 1RUPDOPHQWH LO GXFD ULFRUUHYD D WUH VROX]LRQL= DG DOFXQL SDJDYD O·DIILWWR GL FDVH GL SURSULHWj DOWUXL/ DG DOWUL FRQFHGHYD JUDWXLWDPHQWH O·XVR GL LPPRELOL GL VXD SURSULHWj/ ULFRU0 UHQGR WDOYROWD D FXULRVH IRUPH FRQWUDWWXDOL +YL VRQR LQIHXGD]LRQL R LQYHVWLWXUH LQ IRUPD GL OLYHOOR GL QXPHURVL LPPRELOL XUEDQL,/ DG DOWUL DQFRUD UHJDODYD XQD R SL• DELWD]LRQL1
9:9
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
FRQVHQWLWR GL RUGLQDUH DOIDEHWLFDPHQWH L GDWL/ LQ PRGR GD RWWHQHUH UHFRUGV RPRJHQHL= ROWUH 781333/ UHODWLYL DL :1538 FRUWLJLDQL FKH VHUYLURQR QHOOH GRGLFL FRUWL VRSUD PHQ]LRQDWH1 6L SUHVHQWDYDQR WXWWDYLD GXH SUREOHPL/ LO SULPR UDS0 SUHVHQWDWR GDOOD GLIILFLOH JRYHUQDELOLWi GL XQD VLPLOH PDVVD GRFXPHQWDULD/ LO VHFRQGR/ EHQ SL~ VSLQRVR/ GDO IDWWR FKH PROWL GL TXHVWL :1538 FRUWLJLDQL VHUYL0 URQR LQ SL~ FRUWL= O·HIIHWWLYR QXPHUR GL LQGLYLGXL HUD SHUWDQWR SL~ EDVVR H EL0 VRJQDYD HYLWDUH LQJLXVWLILFDWH GXSOLFD]LRQL/ WULSOLFD]LRQL/ TXDGULSOLFD]LRQL1 +R FRVt GHFLVR GL FRVWUXLUH XQD VHFRQGD DQDJUDIH GL VLQWHVL/ UHVLGHQWH LQ XQ DOWUR GDWD EDVH +TXHVWD YROWD FRVWUXLWR LQ $FFHVV SHU :LQGRZV <;,/ FKH KD SRUWDWR DOOD GHILQL]LRQH ILQDOH GL 5186; UHFRUGV/ FRUULVSRQGHQWL DL 5186; FRUWL0 JLDQL GL $OIRQVR ,, H &HVDUH= 4189< VHUYLURQR VROR $OIRQVR +SXU SUHVWDQGR VHUYL]LR DQFKH LQ DQFKH FRUWL/ HVFOXVD TXHOOD GL &HVDUH H 9LUJLQLD GH· 0HGLFL,/ <36 VROR &HVDUH H 9LUJLQLD +SXU SUHVWDQGR VHUYL]LR DQFKH LQ DQFKH FRUWL/ H0 VFOXVD TXHOOD GL $OIRQVR,/ 99 LQ HQWUDPEH1 , ULVXOWDWL SL~ LQWHUHVVDQWL= OD FRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,, /D FRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,,/ GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD DPPLQLVWUDWLYR/ VL IRUPz WUD LO 4887 H LO 4888/ DOORUTXDQGR LO VHFRQGRJHQLWR GL (UFROH ,,/ SURVVLPR DO YHQ0 WXQHVLPR DQQR GL HWj/ YHQQH PXQLWR GDO SDGUH GL XQ VHJXLWR GL WXWWR ULVSHWWR= L VDODULDWL HUDQR 447 QHO 4888 H 449 QHO 4889/ PHQWUH LO FRPSXWR GHOOH ERFFKH VWD]LRQDYD DWWRUQR DOOH 4;3 XQLWj1 7XWWDYLD/ GL Oj GDOOD FRQVLVWHQ]D/ q LQWHUHVVDQWH RVVHUYDUH FKH D GLIIHUHQ]D GL TXDQWR HUD DFFDGXWR LQ SDVVDWR O·HQWRXUDJH DOIRQVLQR QRQ YHQQH DO PRQGR GDOOH WUDGL]LRQDOL ´FRVWROHµ SDWHUQH1 6L WUDWWDYD GL XQD FRUWH WRWDOPHQWH QXR0 YD1 ,O <8( GHL VXRL PHPEUL QRQ YDQWDYD FDUULHUH HVWHQVL SUHJUHVVH H/ IDWWR DQFRU SL•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´VSLXPzµ JOL RUJDQLFL GHOOD VXD FRUWH DOORQWDQDQGR JUXSSL LQWHUL GL XIILFLDOL SDWHUQL/ FRPH VL SXz DUJXLUH GDOOD OHWWXUD GHOOD VHJXHQWH WDEHOOD=
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9::
7DEHOOD 4= L WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU GHOOD FRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,,1 $QQR 1XPHUR 1XRYL (1XRYL $EEDQGRQL ( $EEDQGRQL &RUWLJLDQL LQJUHVVL LQJUHVVL 4888 447 447 433/33( ; :/35( 4889 449 43 ;/95( 76 6:/3:( 488; ;; 48 4:/38( 6; 76/4;( 4893 6<; 67; ;:/77( 46: 67/75( 4895 75; 49: 6</35( 59 9/3:( 4896 748 46 6/46( 63 :/56( 489: 7;4 495 66/9;( 6: :/9<( 489; 783 9 4/66( ;9 4</44( 489< 799 435 54/;<( 49: 68/;7( 48:7 69< :3 4;/<:( 84 46/;5( 48:9 6;6 98 49/<:( 87 47/43( 48:; 675 46 6/;3( :; 55/;4( 48;5 74; 487 69/;7( 48 6/8<( 48;6 76: 67 :/:;( :8 4:/49( 48;8 73; 79 44/5:( :4 4:/73( 48;; 738 9; 49/:<( 5< :/49( 48;< 737 5; 9/<6( 76 43/97( 48<3 6<; 6: </63( 97 49/3;( 48<5 6<< 98 49/5<( 495 73/93( 48<: 6:9 46< 69/<:( 66: ;</95( )RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= QHOOD FRORQQD UHFDQWH OD GLFLWXUD ¶QXPHUR FRUWLJLDQL· q UL0 SRUWDWR LO QXPHUR WRWDOH GL VDODULDWL LQ VHUYL]LR QHOO·DQQR FRUULVSRQGHQWH/ LQ TXHOOD ¶QXRYL LQJUHV0 VL· LO QXPHUR GL FRUWLJLDQL FKH LQL]LDURQR D VHUYLUH QHOO·DQQR/ LQ TXHOOD ¶DEEDQGRQL· LO QXPHUR GL FRUWLJLDQL FKH VHUYu SHU O·XOWLPD YROWD QHOO·DQQR1
3URFHGHQGR DG XQ·DWWHQWD DQDOLVL GHL GDWL/ VRQR GXH OH FLIUH FKH FL LQGXFR0 QR D ULIOHWWHUH1 ,QQDQ]LWXWWR O·DOWR QXPHUR GL DEEDQGRQL GHO 488;/ FKH QRQ VL SXz VSLHJDUH ULFRUUHQGR VROR DO OLFHQ]LDPHQWR GL SDUWH GHO VHJXLWR UDFFROWR SHU LO VRJJLRUQR LQ WHUUD GL )UDQFLD> q XWLOH QRWDUH FRPH/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GL TXDQ0 WR IHFH LO IUDWHOOR /XLJL/ $OIRQVR QRQ VL DWWRUQLz GL QXPHURVL HOHPHQWL ORFDOL= LO <3( GHOOD VXD FRUWH WUDQVDOSLQD/ LQIDWWL/ HUD IRUPDWD GD LWDOLDQL/ LQ ODUJD PL0 VXUD IHUUDUHVL1 6L KD FRVu OD QHWWD LPSUHVVLRQH FKH FRQ TXHVWH HVSXOVLRQL HJOL DEELD LQWHVR WDJOLDUH L SRQWL FRO SDVVDWR/ ULQQHJDQGR LO WRUPHQWDWR SHULRGR GL
9:;
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
VXERUGLQD]LRQH GLQDVWLFD OLEHUDQGRVL GL FRORUR FKH LQ TXDOFKH PRGR SRWHYD0 QR UDPPHQWDUJOL JOL DQQL GHOOD GLSHQGHQ]D GDO SDGUH1 'LYHUVR q LQYHFH LO VL0 JQLILFDWR GHOO·HOHYDWR QXPHUR GL DEEDQGRQL GHO 4893/ DVFULYLELOH DOOD VFUHPD0 WXUD GHL UDQJKL GHOOD FRUWH GHOOD FRQVRUWH H DO GHOLEHUDWR DOORQWDQDPHQWR GL QXPHURVL FRUWLJLDQL GHO SDGUH1 ,QIDWWL/ VH GLDPR XQ YROWR DL IUHGGL QXPHUL/ VFRSULDPR FKH D IURQWH GL FLUFD 683 QXRYL DUULYL +FKH QXOO·DOWUR VRQR VH QRQ L 63< VDODULDWL GL (UFROH ,, GHO 488< SL• OD TXDUDQWLQD GL IDPLOLDUL GL /XFUH]LD GH· 0HGLFL,/ DOOD ILQH GHOO·DQQR EHQ 46: SHUVRQH YHQQHUR GHILQLWLYDPHQWH ´FDVVD0 WHµ/ VHQ]D SHUDOWUR WURYDUH VXFFHVVLYH VLVWHPD]LRQL LQ DOWUH FRUWL HVWHQVL= VROR PHVVHU 7DUDELQR GD 0RGHQD/ JLj FDYDOFDWRUH VRWWR $OIRQVR , H (UFROH ,, H OL0 FHQ]LDWR GD $OIRQVR ,, QHO 4898 WURYz SRVWR/ FRQ OD PHGHVLPD TXDOLILFD/ QHO0 OD FRUWH GL /XLJL/ LQ FRPSDJQLD GL TXHO PHVVHU 1LFROD %HFFDUL FKH/ ODVFLDWL QHO 4893 L UDQJKL DOIRQVLQL FRQ OD FDULFD GL XIILFLDOH GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH/ ULXVFu D ULHQ0 WUDUH QHO 4899 LQ TXHOOL GL /XLJL QHOOH YHVWL GL FRPSXWLVWD/ YHVWL FKH PDQWHQQH VLQR DO 48::1 6HJXLURQR FRVu DOFXQL DQQL GL UHODWLYD FDOPD/ VHJQDWL GDOOD FRVWDQWH FUHVFLWD GLPHQVLRQDOH GHOOD FRUWH DOIRQVLQD/ FKH GDL 6<; VDODULDWL GHO 4893 DVFHVH DL 7;4 GHO 489: +DQQR LQ FXL ULVXOWDYDQR JLj DJJUHJDWL L FRUWLJLDQL GL %DUEDUD G·$XVWULD/ VSRVDWD QHO 4898 LQ VHFRQGH QR]]H,1 6H FRQVLGHULDPR FKH GD WDOH FRPSXWR VRQR VWDWL HVFOXVL L GLSHQGHQWL GHOOD VWDOOD GXFDOH +FKH GDL UHODWLYL UH0 JLVWUL ULVXOWDQR HVVHUH VWDWL/ QHL PHGHVLPL DQQL/ QRQ PHQR GL 4330453,/ OH JXDUGLH VXL]HUH H WRGHVFKH +ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH 83 H 83, H TXHOOH GH FDVWHOOR +43048 DUPDWL,/ L SDJJL +53058 XQLWj,/ L JDU]RQL H JDU]RQFHOOL GHOOD &DQFHOOHULD H GHOOD &DPHUD 'XFDOH +DOWUL 63073 UDJD]]L, H OH QXPHURVLVVLPH ERFFKH +GL VROLWR XQD RJQL GXH VDODULDWL,/ SRVVLDPR DIIHUPDUH FKH DOOD ILQH GHJOL DQQL ¶93 OD FRUWH GL $OIRQVR H %DUEDUD HUD FRVWLWXLWD GD ROWUH <33 SHUVRQH/ FLIUD GL QRWHYROH HQWL0 Wj/ PD LQ OLQHD FRQ OH FRQVXHWXGLQL HVWHQVL H OH DPEL]LRQL GHO GXFD1 ,Q WDO VHQVR/ ULWRUQDQGR DOO·DQDOLVL GHL WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU/ O·DOWR QXPHUR GL DEEDQGRQL GHO 489< +EHQ 49: FRUWLJLDQL, q VROR GD DWWULEXLUVL DOOD ODFXQRVLWj GHOOH IRQWL/ FKH VDOWDQR LO 48:3/ DQQR LQ FXL %DUEDUD VSLUz= JUDQ SDUWH GHO VXR VHJXLWR YHQQH OLFHQ]LDWR H VROR GRSR LO WHU]R PDWULPRQLR/ FHOHEUDWR QHO 48:; FRQ 0DUJKHULWD *RQ]DJD/ OD FRQVLVWHQ]D GHJOL RUJDQLFL ULSUHVH YLJRUH/ FRQ XQD QHWWD SURJUHVVLRQH GDL 675 VDODULDWL GHO 48:; DL 76: GHO 48;61 7XWWDYLD/ LO GDWR SL• VRUSUHQGHQWH HPHUJH GDOO·DQDOLVL GHOOD GLQDPLFD/ LQYH0 UR DQRPDOD/ GHL WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU GHJOL DQQL ¶<3= GHL 6:9 VDODULDWL GL FRUWH FKH VHUYLYDQR LO GXFD QHO 48<:/ EHQ 4;< HUDQR HQWUDWL LQ UXROR VROR QHJOL XOWLPL ; DQQL H GXH VX FLQTXH GRSR LO 48<51
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9:<
6L WUDWWDYD GXQTXH GL XQD FRUWH JLRYDQLVVLPD/ DOOHJUD/ SLHQD GL YLWD/ ULIRQ0 GDWD H[0QRYR QHO PRPHQWR LQ FXL $OIRQVR UHDOL]]DYD GHILQLWLYDPHQWH OD VXD LPSRWHQWLD JHQHUDQGL H VHQWLYD DYYLFLQDUVL O·RUD GHOOD ILQH= VLDPR EHQ ORQWDQL GDOO·LPPDJLQH VWHUHRWLSDWD GL XQD FHUFKLD GHFUHSLWD/ HVDXVWD H GHFDGHQWH/ LP0 SHJQDWD DG DVVHFRQGDUH L PHVWL VSDVVL GL FKL/ FRQVDSHYROH VLQ GDO 48<4 %FKH SHU OD FRQWLQXDWLRQH GHO 'RPLQLR GL )HUUDUD/ QHOOD VXD )DPLJOLD/ KDYHYD IDWWR TXDQWR KDYHD SRWXWR/ FRQRVFHQGR/ FKH OL ULPDQHYD SRFR SL• GL YLWD/ YROOH TXHVWR ULPDQHQWH SDVVDUH FRQ RJQL VRUWD GL VRGLVIDWLRQH UDJLRQHYROH/ HW FRQ0 YHQLHQWH DG XQ JUDQ 3ULQFLSH/ HW YHUDPHQWH &KULVWLDQR%148 (SSXUH/ GL Oj GDO FRPSUHQVLELOH GHVLGHULR GL VXJJHUH LO QHWWDUH GHOOD JLR0 YHQW• PHQWUH OH IRU]H YHQLYDQR PHQR/ FLUFRQGDQGRVL GL MXQLRUHV VXUURJDQWL O·DIIHWWXRVD SUHVHQ]D GHL ILJOL PDL DYXWL/ ULWHQJR FKH LO YDPSLUHVFR $OIRQVR DEELD YROXWR FRQ TXHVWD WUDVIXVLRQH GL JLRYDQH SODVPD IHUUDUHVH ILDFFDUH ID0 WDOPHQWH OH VSHUDQ]H GL &HVDUH/ FKH YHQQH SULYDWR/ QHO PRPHQWR GHFLVLYR/ GHOOD SRVVLELOLWj GL DWWUDUUH D Vp IRU]H IUHVFKH H YHUGL VSHUDQ]H1 ,QIDWWL/ SURSULR WUD LO 48;; H LO 48<6 &HVDUH VL JLRFz OH XOWLPH FKDQFHV GL SODVPDUH XQD FRUWH DOO·DOWH]]D GHJOL DUGLPHQWRVL FRPSLWL FKH OD DWWHQGHYDQR= VROR 5: GHL 49: FRUWLJLDQL FKH LQL]LDURQR D VHUYLUOR WUD LO 48;4 H LO 48;7 ULVXO0 WDYDQR DQFRUD DO VXR VHUYL]LR QHO 48<6/ D GLPRVWUD]LRQH GHO IDWWR FKH IXURQR JOL VWHVVL VRGDOL GHO VHFRQGRJHQLWR GL GRQ $OIRQVR D ILXWDUH/ TXDWWUR DQQL SULPD GHOOD 'HYROX]LRQH/ TXDOH VDUHEEH VWDWR LO SUREDELOH HSLORJR GHOOD LQIH0 OLFH YLFHQGD VXFFHVVRULD1 'LHWUR XQD PDVFKHUD GL LQDSSXQWDELOH FRUWHVLD/ $OIRQVR ERLFRWWz OD VXF0 FHVVLRQH GHO FXJLQR/ LPSHGHQGRJOL GL LQWHVVHUH OHJDPL JHQHUD]LRQDOL FRL FRH0 WDQHL IHUUDUHVL1 &RVWRUR YHQQHUR YROXWDPHQWH PDOH HGXFDWL GDO GXFD FKH OL D0 ELWXz D OLYHOOL GL VIDU]R FKH QHVVXQ VXFFHVVRUH DYUHEEH PDL SRWXWR JDUDQWLUH H FUHDQGR DVSHWWDWLYH FKH TXHO ¶SRYHUDFFLR· GL &HVDUH QRQ DYUHEEH PDL SRWXWR VRGGLVIDUH1 ,Q WDO VHQVR/ QRQ FUHGR FKH OH pOLWHV IHUUDUHVL/ ´PDOFRQWHQWH/ LQGH0 ELWDWH/ GLVXVDWH DOOD JXHUUDµ/49 DEELDQR YROWDWR OH VSDOOH D &HVDUH SHUFKp GHOX0 VH GD $OIRQVR/ UHR GL DYHUOH FRQGRWWH VXO EDUDWUR GHOOD EDQFDURWWD1 9DOH VHPPDL LO GLVFRUVR LQYHUVR/ FKH L IHUUDUHVL QRQ DEELDQR YROXWR ULQXQFLDUH DO FRQVXHWR VWLOH GL YLWD OLEHUDOH H JDXGHQWH/ FRPH VDUHEEHUR VWDWL FRVWUHWWL D IDUH ²²²²²²²² 48
*1 6$5',/ /LEUR GHOOH KLVWRULH IHUUDUHVL GHO VLJ1 *DVSDUR 6DUGL1 &RQ XQD QXRYD DJJLXQWD GHO PHGH0 VLPR DXWRUH1 $JJLXQWLYL GL SL• TXDWWUR OLEUL GHO VLJ1 GRWWRUH )DXVWLQL VLQR DOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO GXFDWR GL )HU0 UDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH/ )HUUDUD/ *LXVHSSH *LURQL/ 4979/ S1 ;;1 49 $1 *$63$5,1,/ &HVDUH G·(VWH H &OHPHQWH 9,,,/ 0RGHQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD (GLWULFH 0RGHQHVH/ 4<8</ S145:1
9;3
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
TXDORUD DYHVVHUR DEEUDFFLDWR OD SRYHUD FDXVD GL &HVDUH/ VLFXUL FKH O·$OGREUDQGLQL DYUHEEH SUROXQJDWR OD URWWD IHVWRVD WUDFFLDWD GD $OIRQVR1 4XHVWH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL FKLDULVFRQR LO VLJQLILFDWR GHOOH LPSUHVVLRQDQWL FLIUH GHOO·XOWLPD ULJD GHOOD WDEHOOD 4= YLVWL L FKLDUL GL OXQD/ QRQ GREELDPR VWXSLUFL VH 66; GHL 6:9 VDODULDWL GL $OIRQVR ,, QRQ VHJXLURQR &HVDUH D 0RGHQD= XQD YHUD GHEDFOH/ LQ ODUJD PLVXUD DVFULYLELOH DOOH PRVVH GHOO·XOWLPR GXFD GL )HUUDUD1 /D FRUWH GL &HVDUH /D FRUWH GL &HVDUH VL IRUPz WUD LO 48;4 H LO 48;5/ TXDQGR LO VHFRQGRJHQLWR GL GRQ $OIRQVR PDUFKHVH GL 0RQWHFFKLR H GL GRQQD *LXOLD GHOOD 5RYHUH HUD SURVVLPR DL YHQW·DQQL +HUD QDWR LO 4 RWWREUH 4895, H LQ SUHGLFDWR GL SUHQGHUH PRJOLH/ HVVHQGR VWDWH DYYLDWH OH WUDWWDWLYH SHU SURFXUDUJOL OD PDQR GL PDGD0 PLJHOOD GL 9DXGHPRQW/ VRUHOOD GL /XLJLD UHJLQD GL )UDQFLD1 *OL HVRUGL IXURQR VFLQWLOODQWL/ TXDVL UHJDOL= &HVDUH PDQWHQHYD FLUFD 443 VD0 ODULDWL H ROWUH 493 ERFFKH/ FLIUH FKH VDOLURQR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH DL 483 H DOOH 543 GHO 48;7/ DQQR LQ FXL/ WUDPRQWDWH OH VSHUDQ]H GHO FRQQXELR FRQ OD SULQFLSHV0 VD WUDQVDOSLQD/ GRQ $OIRQVR VLJOz LO FRQWUDWWR PDWULPRQLDOH FKH LPSHJQDYD LO ILJOLROR D PDULWDUH 9LUJLQLD GH· 0HGLFL/ ILJOLD QDWXUDOH GHO JUDQGXFD &RVLPR H GL &DPLOOD 0DUWHOOL/ H IRUQLWD/ D SDU]LDOH LQGHQQL]]R GHOO·LPSXULWi GHO VDQJXH/ GL XQD VRQDQWH GRWH GL 4331333 VFXGL G·RUR/ PHUFH UDUD LQ TXHL WHPSL GL PD0 JUD1 7XWWDYLD/ VH LQ WHUPLQL QXPHULFL OH FRUWL GL $OIRQVR H &HVDUH SUHVHQWDYDQR DO PRPHQWR GHOOD ORUR FRVWLWX]LRQH SDUHFFKL HOHPHQWL GL VLPLOLWXGLQH/ GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD GHOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH HUDQR TXDVL DJOL DQWLSRGL= PHQWUH OD FRUWH DOIRQVLQD HUD UDGLFDOPHQWH QXRYD/ TXHOOD GL &HVDUH ULVXOWDYD TXDVL LQWHJUDO0 PHQWH FRVWLWXLWD GD IHGHOLVVLPL GHO SDGUH/ LO TXDOH/ DSSURVVLPDQGRVL OD ILQH GHOOH IDWLFKH WHUUHQH/ DVVHJQz DO ILJOLR/ GL DQQR LQ DQQR/ XQ QXPHUR FUHVFHQWH GL YHFFKL XIILFLDOL1 ,QIDWWL/ GHOOH 49: SHUVRQH HQWUDWH DO VHUYL]LR GL &HVDUH WUD LO 48;4 H LO 48;7/ EHQ 9: HUDQR VWDWL LVFULWWL QHOOD EROOHWWD GHL VDODULDWL GL GRQ $OIRQVR GHO 48;304 H WUD FRVWRUR/ JXDUGD FDVR/ VL WURYDYDQR L WLWRODUL GHOOH FDULFKH GL PDJJLRU SUH0 VWLJLR H UHVSRQVDELOLWj= L PDJQLILFL PHVVHUL 7XUFKHWWR &DQGLRWWR/ $QGUHD 0D]]DUHOOL/ 0RQWLQR 0RQWLQL H $XUHOLR 5RLWR/ HQWUDWL DO VHUYL]LR GHO SDGUH QHO 4887/ ILJXUDYDQR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH FRPH FDVWHOODQR GHOO·,VROD/ PDJJLRUGR0 PR/ PDHVWUR GL VWDOOD H QRWDLR/ LO PDJQLILFR PHVVHU *HURODPR *DOHD]]L/ JLj
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9;4
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z D QR]]H FRQ 0DUILVD G·(VWH/ ILJOLD GL GRQ )UDQFHVFR PDU0 FKHVH GL 0DVVDORPEDUGD/ QHO TXDGUR GL XQ GLVHJQR GLQDVWLFR FKH DYUHEEH SRWXWR FUHDUH XQ QXRYR UDPR GHOO·DUERUH HVWHQVH/ VROLGR/ ULFFR H GL JUDQGH SUH0 VWLJLR> LO IDWR YROOH FKH LO JLRYDQH $OIRQVLQR/ VHFRQGR L PDOLJQL VSRVVDWR GDOOH PDUDWRQH VHVVXDOL LQJDJJLDWH FROO·LQVD]LDELOH 0DUILVD/ VFKLDWWDVVH JLRYDQLVVL0 PR/ QHSSXUH TXDWWUR PHVL GRSR OD FHOHEUD]LRQH GHO PDWULPRQLR1 &HVDUH VL ULWURYz FRVt HUHGH GHOOH DPEL]LRQL SDWHUQH/ PD OD FRQIXVLVVLPD H TXDVL LQWHUPLQDELOH SUDWLFD VXFFHVVRULD QRQ GLHGH SHU OXQJR WHPSR DGLWR DG DOFXQD VSHUDQ]D FKH JLXVWLILFDVVH OD IRUPD]LRQH GL XQD FRUWH GHJQD GL XQ IX0 WXUR GXFD= VH QHO 48;4 $OIRQVR ,, DYHYD LQXWLOPHQWH FHUFDWR GL RWWHQHUH GDO SDSD OD GLVSHQVD SHU VFLRJOLHUH GDL YRWL LO IUDWHOOR /XLJL/ RUPDL LQ VDFULV/ DIILQ0 FKp SRWHVVH XQLUVL LQ PDWULPRQLR H GDUH TXHOO·HUHGH OHJLWWLPR LQGLVSHQGDELOH DOOH FDXVH HVWHQVL/ VL GRYHWWH DWWHQGHUH LO OXJOLR GHO 48<8 SHUFKp OD FDQGLGDWXUD GL &HVDUH YHQLVVH GHILQLWLYDPHQWH XIILFLDOL]]DWD1 ,Q PH]]R/ LQ TXHO WRUPHQWD0 WR TXLQGLFHQQLR/ VL VXVVHJXt/ LQ XQD ULGGD GL YRFL LQFRQWUROODELOL/ XQD JLUDQGR0 OD GL FDQGLGDWXUH/ EUXFLDWH GDO PHGHVLPR GXFD R GDL YHWL SDSDOL H FDUGLQDOL]L= SULPD VL LSRWL]]y O·LQYHVWLWXUD GHO SDGUH GL &HVDUH/ GRQ $OIRQVR/ XRPR QRQ SL~ JLRYDQLVVLPR PD DQFRUD SUHVWDQWH +HUD QDWR QHO 485:,/ SRL GL &HVDUH 7URWWL/ VHFRQGR DOFXQL ILJOLR DGXOWHULQR GL (UFROH ,, H GL 'LDQD PRJOLH GL *LDFRPR 7URWWL/ VSDOOHJJLDWR QHOOH VXH SUHWHQVLRQL GD /XFUH]LD GL (VWH/ LQIL0 QH/ QHO 48<30<4/ IX OD YROWD GL )LOLSSR G·(VWH/ GHO UDPR VLJQLVPRQGLDQR GHL PDUFKHVL GL 6DQ 0DUWLQR LQ 5LR 0 XRPR EHQ LQWURGRWWR QHOOD FRUWH VDEDXGD
9;5
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
PD VRSUDWWXWWR FRJQDWR GHO EDURQH 3DROR 6IRQGUDWL/ IUDWHOOR GL SDSD *UHJR0 ULR ;,9 0 FKH ULPDVH LQ RWWLPD SRVL]LRQH VLQR DOOD ILQH GHOO·HVWDWH GHO 48<4/ SHU SRL ULQXQFLDUH/ GHOXVR GDO FRPSRUWDPHQWR GL $OIRQVR ,,/ H PRULUH O·DQQR VXFFHVVLYR1 4XHVWH LQFHUWH]]H VL ULIOHWWRQR QHOO·DQDOLVL GHL WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU GHOOD FRUWH GL &HVDUH SULPD GHOOD 'HYROX]LRQH/ 7DEHOOD 5= L WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU GHOOD FRUWH GL &HVDUH/ 48;4048<: $QQR 1XPHUR 1XRYL ( 1XRYL $EEDQGRQL ( $EEDQGRQL FRUWLJLDQL LQJUHVVL LQJUHVVL 48;407 479 479 433/33( 434 9</4;( 48;90: 47; 436 9</8<( 6< 59/68( 48;; 474 65 55/:3( 69 58/86( 48;<0<3 476 6; 59/8:( 7; 66/8:( 48<6 459 64 57/93( 47 44/44( 48<7 457 45 </9;( 47 44/5<( 48<8 44< < :/89( 8 7/53( 48<9 459 45 </85( 47 44/44( 48<: 456 44 ;/<7( 8: 79/67( )RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= QHOOD FRORQQD UHFDQWH OD GLFLWXUD QXPHUR FRUWLJLDQL q ULSRUWDWR LO QXPHUR WRWDOH GL VDODULDWL LQ VHUYL]LR QHOO·DQQR FRUULVSRQGHQWH/ LQ TXHOOD QXRYL LQJUHVVL LO QXPHUR GL FRUWLJLDQL FKH LQL]LDURQR D VHUYLUH QHOO·DQQR/ LQ TXHOOD DEEDQGRQL LO QXPHUR GL FRUWLJLDQL FKH VHUYu SHU O·XOWLPD YROWD QHOO·DQQR1
3RVVLDPR LQIDWWL FRQVWDWDUH FKH WUD LO 48;7 H LO 48;: OD FRUWH GL &HVDUH YHQQH ULIRQGDWD/ FRQ XQ ULFDPELR TXDVL FRPSOHWR GHO SHUVRQDOH LQ VHUYL]LR/ SURYRFDWR GDOO·D]LRQH GL GXH IDWWRUL FRQFRPLWDQWL= O·DJJUHJD]LRQH GHL IDPLOLDUL GHOOD FRQVRUWH 9LUJLQLD/ JLXQWD D )HUUDUD QHO 48;9 H O·HVSXOVLRQH GHL FRUWLJLDQL HUHGLWDWL GDO SDGUH/ VFRPSDUVR QHO 48;:1 7XWWDYLD/ TXHVWL DYYHQLPHQWL/ FRQ VL VXVVHJXHQWL QXRYL DUULYL/ QRQ PLJOLRUDURQR OD TXDOLWj GHOOD FHUFKLD FHVDULDQD/ L FXL YHUWLFL FRQWLQXDURQR DG DQQRYHUDUH OD SUHVHQ]D/ WXWW·DOWUR FKH TXDOLILFDQ0 WH/ GL WDQWL SHUVRQDJJL GL VHFRQGR H WHU]R SLDQR/ VFRQRVFLXWL DL SL•= VH HVFOX0 GLDPR L FDPHULHUL )HUUDQWH 0RUL/ $OIRQVR %HOODLD H $OIRQVR 9LQFHQ]L/ LO PDJJLRUGRPR *LXOLR 0RUL/ OR VFDOFR *LXOLR 3HURQGROL/ LO PDHVWUR GL VWDOOD $OIRQVR 0RO]D H SRFKH GDPH TXDOL %HDWULFH 6LJQD R )ORULQGD 5LPLQDOGL/ TXHOOD GL &HVDUH ULPDQHYD XQD FRUWH PLQRUH QHO VHQVR OHWWHUDOH GHO WHUPLQH/ SULYD GL UHOD]LRQL FRQ OH pOLWHV GHO GXFDWR/ VHQ]D SHUVRQDOLWj H/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ YHUJRJQRVDPHQWH SRYHUD GL XRPLQL H GHQDUL1
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9;6
$ WDOXQL SRWUHEEH LQIDWWL DSSDULUH SDUDGRVVDOH LO IDWWR FKH &HVDUH/ GRSR DYHU HUHGLWDWR WUD LO 48;9 H LO 48;: OH IRUWXQH GHO SDGUH H GHOOR ]LR /XLJL/ VL VLD YLVWR FRVWUHWWR D ULGXUUH FRVWDQWHPHQWH JOL RUJDQLFL GHOOD VXD FRUWH/ FKH LQYH0 FH GL FUHVFHUH FRQWLQXDURQR SHQRVDPHQWH D FRQWUDUVL/ VLQR DL 456 VDODULDWL GHO 48<:/ XQD FLIUD ORQWDQD DQQL OXFH GDJOL DVWURQRPLFL YDORUL IRUQLWL GDOOR 6SDF0 FLQL/ VHFRQGR LO TXDOH YHQHUGt 59 GLFHPEUH 48<: ´LO VLJQRU GRQ &HVDUH KD DF0 FDODWR 833 ERFFKH LQXWLOH DOOD VXD FRUWHµ14: 0D OD SRVVLELOLWj GL DOODUJDUH OD FHUFKLD GHL SURWHWWL H GL HVWHQGHUH OD UHWH GHOOD SURSULD LQIOXQ]D HUD FRQGL]LR0 QDWD GDOOH GLVSRQLELOLWj HFRQRPLFKH H L ODVFLWL SLRPEDWL WUD FDSR H FROOR QHO ELHQQLR 48;0: SRUWDURQR VROR JXDL= ´JUDQ TXDQWLWi >GL GHELWL@ PH QH ODVFLy LO &DUGLQDO /XLJL H LO VLJQRUH GRQ $OIRQVR PLR SDGUH/ GH TXDOL QH SDJR PROWL JUDYL LQWHUHVVLµ14; &HVDUH QRQ PHQWLYD= LO SDGUH JOL ODVFLy GHELWL SHU TXDVL 5331333 OLUH/ LO FXJLQR /XLJL SHU 4;81333 OLUH D 5RPD H 7831333 OLUH D )HUUDUD/ FLWWi LQ FXL LO SRUSRUDWR GRYHYD FLIUH DVWURQRPLFKH D QXPHURVL IHXGDWDUL H0 VWHQVL= %HYLODTXD/ 3LR/ 2EL]]L/ 7DVVRQL/ 3XWWL/ *DWWL/ $ULRVWL H &\ER 0DODVSL0 QD1 4< &LRQRQRVWDQWH/ OD FRUWH GL &HVDUH/ D GLVSHWWR GHOOH FURQLFKH GHILFLHQ]H IL0 QDQ]LDULH/ QRQ ULQXQFLy D UDFFRJOLHUH IUDPPHQWL GL DOWUH FRUWL IHUUDUHVL H UR0 PDQH/ GLYHQHQGR O·XOWLPD VSLDJJLD SHU TXDQWL/ UHVSLQWL IRUVH GD $OIRQVR/ QRQ ULXVFLURQR D WURYDUH GLJQLWRVH DOWHUQDWLYH1 8Q RDVL UDFFRJOLWLFFLD/ L FXL SH]]L SUHJLDWL HUDQR VRYHQWH VFKHJJH GL IDPLOLH HVWHQVL DEEDQGRQDWH GD SDWHU R PDWHU SDVVDWL D PLJOLRU YLWD= ROWUH DOOD VHWWDQWLQD GL H[ FRUWLJLDQL GHO SDGUH/ GDOO·HQWRXUDJH GL /DXUD (XVWRFKLD 'LDQWL DUULYy LO VHVFDOFR &DUOR GDOO·2FD> GD TXHOOR GL ,SSROLWR JLXQVHUR LO PDJQLILFR UHYHUHQGR GRQ $QQLEDOH &DSHOOL GD 5RPD/ JLi FDXGDWDULR GHO FDUGLQDOH/ LO UHYHUHQGR PHVVHU 6HEDVWLDQR %ULFL/ PDHVWUR GHL SDJJL H GL FDSSHOOD/ H LO FHOHEUH VHPSOLFLVWD (YDQJHOLVWD GD *XE0 ELR> GD TXHOOR GL /XLJL IXURQR DFFROWL LO PDJQLILFR (UFROH 3HUL/ JRYHUQDWRUH GL &RQVDQGROL/ O·LOOXVWUH VLJQRUH )UDQFHVFR *XDUHVFKL/ JHQWLOXRPR GL $OIRQVR ,, ²²²²²²²² 4: ,Q *1%1 63$&&,1,/ &URQDFD GL 0RGHQD/ DQQL 48;;04935/ D FXUD GL $1 %,21',051 %866, H *1 *,29$11,1,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<<6/ S1:<1 4; ,Q $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', ),5(1=(/ $UFKLYLR 0HGLFHR GHO 3ULQFLSDWR/ Q1 5<48/ %0RGHQD/ OHWWHUH GL GXFKL H GL SULQFLSL HVWHQVL/ 48<:0493<%/ /HWWHUD GL &HVDUH DO *UDQGXFD GHO 47 PDU0 ]R 4936%1 4< ,Q $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', ),5(1=(/ 0LVFHOODQHD 0HGLFHD/ I1 45/ LQVHUWR 6/%'HELWL FKH V·KDQQR LQ 5RPD SHU FRQWR GHOO·KHUHGLWi GHO 6LJQRUH &DUGLQDOH GD (VWH%/ FF16:U0Y> %&UHGLWRUL GHOOD IHOLFH PHPRULD GHO 6LJQRUH &DUGLQDOH G·(VWH SHU GDQDUL FKH VH QH SDJD LQWHUHVVH YLGHOL0 FHW LQ )HUUDUD/% FF16;U06<Y1
9;7
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
H GL /XLJL/ PHVVHU *LRYDQQL 3DQHUYHUFR/ XQ SRODFFR FUHVFLXWR QHOOD SDJJHULD GL 7LYROL H LO PDJQLILFR $OEHUWR GD &RPR/ FKH GRSR DYHU VHUYLWR FRPH PDH0 VWUR GHL FRQWL GHOO·HUHGLWi GL /XLJL/ QHO 48<6 YHQQH SURPRVVR SURYYHGLWRUH GL FRUWH> LQILQH/ GDOOD FHUFKLD DOIRQVLQD/ SULPD GHO 48<:/ JLXQVHUR LQ WXWWR VHL VROL LQGLYLGXL1 6H HVFOXGLDPR LO PDJQLILFR &DPLOOR 0RQWLQL +FKH IX VFDOFR GL &H0 VDUH GDO 48;4 DO 48;7/ GRSR DYHU VHUYLWR FRQ OD PHGHVLPD TXDOLILFD $OIRQVR ,, GDO 4893 DO 48:9,/ JOL DOWUL FLQTXH HUDQR SHUVRQDJJL TXDVL LQVLJQLILFDQWL= O·RUWRODQR %DWWLVWD GHL 5RVVL/ XQ *LDFRPR 7UHYLVDQR IDFFKLQR/ LO IDWWRUH FD0 YDOFDQWH /XGRYLFR GD %RUJR/ LO FRPSXWLVWD PHVVHU )UDQFHVFR )ORULR/ OR VSHQGLWRUH 3DROR GDOO·2UWR1 1HVVXQR GL ORUR/ FRPXQTXH/ VHJXt &HVDUH D 0RGHQD1 7XWWDYLD/ FL VL SRWUHEEH DVSHWWDUH FKH OD ILDFFKH]]D/ OD SRFKH]]D GHOOD FRU0 WH GL &HVDUH IRVVH GHVWLQDWD D VFRPSDULUH QHO PRPHQWR LQ FXL OD VXD FDQGLGD0 WXUD DOOD VXFFHVVLRQH YHQQH XIILFLDOL]]DWD/ YDOH D GLUH WUD LO 48<7 H LO 48<8/ H QHL GXH DQQL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH VXFFHVVLYL1 &Ly/ SXUWURSSR/ QRQ DYYHQQH= QHO FRUVR GHJOL DQQL ¶<3 QRQ VL YHULILFy XQ VROR WUDVIHULPHQWR GDOOH ILOD DOIRQVLQH H DQFKH L QXRYL DUULYDWL QRQ HUDQR FKH SHUVRQDOH GL WHU]·RUGLQH/ VJXDWWHUL/ IDFFKLQL/ VWDIILHUL/ XIILFLDOL GL FDVD1 1HVVXQ IHUUDUHVH ULPDVH LPSURYYLVDPHQWH IROJRUDWR GDOOD EHOOH]]D GHOO·DVWUR QDVFHQWH/ FKH VL WURYy VWUHWWR LQ XQD IHUUHD PRUVD> GD XQD SDUWH $O0 IRQVR ,, VL DGRSHUy WHPSHVWLYDPHQWH SHU VSHJQHUH VXO QDVFHUH L WLPLGL IRFKH0 UHOOL GL SDVVLRQH SHU OD FDXVD GHO EXRQ &HVDUH/ GDOO·DOWUD O·LQYHVWLWXUD JLXQVH WURSSR WDUGL +RVHUHL GLUH VXIILFLHQWHPHQWH WDUGL, H QRQ GLHGH LO WHPSR GL VWUDSSDUH L IHUUDUHVL DQFRUD LQGHFLVL VXO SDUWLWR GD SUHQGHUVL DOOH OXVLQJKH GH0 JOL DJHQWL SRQWLILFL/ FKH/ ]LWWL ]LWWL/ FRQWLQXDURQR LO ORUR LPSODFDELOH ODYRULR DL ILDQFKL/ JUD]LH DO TXDOH 6DQWD 5RPDQD &KLHVD VL DVVLFXUy L IHGHOL VHUYLJL GHO PDUFKHVH %RQLIDFLR %HYLODTXD/ GL )UDQFHVFR 6DFUDWL/ GL 2WWDYLR HG (UFROH 7DVVRQL/ GHO FRQWH $OIRQVR *LJOLROL H GHO FRQWH (UFROH %HYLODTXD/ XRPLQL GHOOH SULQFLSDOL IDPLJOLH IHUUDUHVL/ FDSDFL DOO·RFFDVLRQH GL IDU YDOHUH WXWWR LO OR0 UR SHVR SROLWLFR1 4XHVWD VLWXD]LRQH FKLDULVFH OH UDJLRQL GHOO·HOHYDWD PRELOLWi GHJOL RUJDQLFL FHVDULDQL QHO SHULRGR 48;4048<:> O·LQFHUWH]]D GHO TXDGUR SROLWLFR/ OH ULVWUHW0 WH]]H ILQDQ]LDULH/ OH YHODWH PLQDFFH GXFDOL UHQGHYDQR LQVWDELOH LO UDSSRUWR GL VHUYL]LR/ FKH SUHVHQWD WDVVL PHGL GL DEEDQGRQL GHFLVDPHQWH SL~ HOHYDWL GL TXHOOL GL $OIRQVR ,,/ SURYRFDQGR OD GHSUHVVLRQH GHO SHULRGR PHGLR GL SHU0 PDQHQ]D QHL UDQJKL GL FRUWH1 ,QIDWWL VH DQDOL]]LDPR L GDWL GHOOD WDEHOOD VRWWR0 VWDQWH=
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9;8
7DEHOOD 6= $QQL GL VHUYL]LR DOOD FRUWH GL &HVDUH $QQL GL 1XPHUR GL ( VXO $QQL GL 1XPHUR GL FRU0 ( VXO VHUYL]LR FRUWLJLDQL WRWDOH VHUYL]LR WLJLDQL WRWDOH 4 ;7 ;/9:( 5< : 3/:5( 5 :: :/<8( 63 43 4/36( 6 97 9/93( 64 4: 4/:8( 7 474 47/88( 65 5 3/54( 8 8: 8/;;( 66 9 3/95( 9 83 8/49( 67 4 3/43( : 69 6/:5( 68 8 3/85( ; 68 6/94( 69 6 3/64( < 77 7/87( 6: 6 3/64( 43 58 5/8;( 6; 4 3/43( 44 4; 4/;9( 6< 4 3/43( 45 59 5/9;( 73 6 3/64( 46 46 4/67( 74 3 3/33( 47 54 5/4:( 75 9 3/95( 48 53 5/39( 76 4 3/43( 49 43 4/36( 77 5 3/54( 4: 4< 4/<9( 78 7 3/74( 4; 4: 4/:8( 79 6 3/64( 4< 65 6/63( 7: 7 3/74( 53 44 4/47( 7; 6 3/64( 54 45 4/57( 7< 3 3/33( 55 48 4/88( 83 4 3/43( 56 44 4/47( 84 4 3/43( 57 44 4/47( 85 6 3/64( 58 43 4/36( 86 4 3/43( 59 9 3/95( 8: 4 3/43( 5: : 3/:5( 5; ; 3/;6( 0HGLD 44/56 7RWDOH <9< 433( )RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= QHOOD SULPD H QHOOD WHU]D FRORQQD VRQR VWDWL HOHQFDWL JOL DQQL GL VHUYL]LR/ GD XQ PLQLPR GL 4 D XQ PDVVLPR GL 8:/ QHOOD VHFRQGD H QHOOD TXDUWD LO QX0 PHUR GL LQGLYLGXL FKH VHUYu SHU LO FRUULVSRQGHQWH ODVVR GL WHPSR/ QHOOD WHU]D H QHOOD VHVWD LO YDORUH SHUFHQWXDOH VXO WRWDOH GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH GHL FRUWLJLDQL/ QRQ SRVVLDPR RVVHUYDUH OD GL0 YHUVLWi GHOOH SHUPDQHQ]H PHGLH GHL GXH SHULRGL 48;4048<: H 48<;0495:= D IURQWH GL XQD FDU0 ULHUD PHGLD GL 44/56 DQQL/ FRORUR FKH HQWUDURQR DO VHULYL]LR GL &HVDUH WUD LO 48;4 H LO 48<: UL0 PDVHUR LQ PHGLD DOOH VXH GLSHQGHQ]H SHU :/4; DQQL/ TXHOOL HQWUDWL GRSR LO 48<; SHU 43/;; DQ0 QL/ D GLVSHWWR GHOOH PLQRUH HVWHQVLRQH FRPSXWD]LRQDOH GHO SHULRGR FURQRORJLFR1 1RQ VDUHEEH SRWXWR HVVHUH DOWULPHQWL/ YLVWL JOL DEEDQGRQL GHO 48<:1
9;9
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
/D 'HYROX]LRQH
6LDPR JLXQWL DO PRPHQWR WRSLFR GHOOD QRVWUD VWRULD/ DOOD 'HYROX]LRQH1 %L0 VRJQDYD VFHJOLHUH GD FKH SDUWH VWDUH= R GL TXD/ VRWWR OH FKLDYL SDSDOLQH/ R GL Oi/ VRWWR O·DTXLOD HVWHQVH/ VHQ]D SRVVLELOLWi GL ULWRUQDUH VXOOH SURSULH GHFLVLRQL= D VFDQVR GL HTXLYRFL/ VROR 6; GHL 6:9 VDODULDWL GL $OIRQVR ,, GHFLVHUR GL VHJXL0 UH &HVDUH QHO VXR HVLOLR PRGHQHVH1 0D GL FKL VL WUDWWDYD" 7DEHOOD 7= L 6; IHGHOL GHOOD SULPD RUD/ YDOH D GLUH L VDODULDWL GL $OIRQVR ,, FKH QHO 48<; VHJXL0 URQR &HVDUH D 0RGHQD1 $5 48;60<: &( 48<;0495: $5 48<30: &( 48<;0939 $5 48:90<: &( 48<;04937
0DHVWUR
9LQFHQ]R
0HVVHU 6LJQRU
*LDFRPR G·$GDPR 0DULD $OHVVDQGUR $ULRVWR
$5 48;80<7 &( 48<;04955 $5 48<: &( 48<;04945
0HVVHU
/XLJL
$YLFK
*LDFRPR
%HOOLQR
*LXOLR
%LJQR]L
$5 48;50<: 0HVVHU &( 48<;04933 $5 48<: &RQWH &( 48<;04933 $5 48<90: &( 48<;049372494509
$EEDWL
*XLGREDOGR %RQDUHOOL *LDFRPR
%UDQGL
/8 488;0< ,3 4898 $5 48;50<: &( 48<; $5 48<50: &( 48<;04945
5HYHUHQ0 6HEDVWLDQR GR PHVVHU
,OOXVWUH VLJQRU
3DROR (PLOLR
&DVDWL
$5 48<: &( 48<;04946 $5 48;<0<: &( 48<;0495:
0HVVHU
%DWWLVWD
&DWWHQDUL
6LJQRU
(UFROH
&RFFDSDQL
%ULFL
&XRFR VLQR DO 4939/ PDHVWUR GL FXFLQD GDO 493: 8IILFLDOH GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH VLQR DO 48<:/ GDO 48<; XIILFLDOH GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH DOOD OLEUHULD H IXULHUH &DPHULHUH VLQR DO 48;8/ FDPHULHUH QHOOD IDPLJOLD GHOOD GXFKHVVD GDO 48;; DO 48<3/ GDO 48<5 IXULHUH PDJJLRUH/ VFDOFR QHO 48<;/ JHQWLOXRPR GL 6$ QHO 4937 8IILFLDOH GL JXDUGDURED GDO 48;80<7/ GDO 48<; XIILFLDOH GL VSHQGHULD 6WDIILHUH QHO 48<: FRQ $OIRQVR ,,/ VWDIILHUH GDO 48<; DO 4936/ GHFDQR GHJOL VWDIILHUL GL 6$ GDO 4937 DO 4939/ YDOOHWWR GHO SULQFLSH GDO 493< 8IILFLDOH GL VWDOOD *HQWLOXRPR GL $OIRQVR ,,/ PDHVWUR GL FDPHUD GL 6$ GDO 48<; )DFFKLQR DOOD FUHQGHQ]D QHO 48<90:/ DO WLQHOOR GHJOL VWDIILHUL GDO 48<; DO 4933/ IDFFKLQR QHO 493607/ DVVHQWH GDO 4938 DO 4944/ QHO 4945 ULDSSDUH IDFFKLQR DOOD FUH0 GHQ]D GHO SULQFLSH $OIRQVR/ FDULFD FKH PDQWLHQH VLQR DO 4956/ TXDQGR GLYHQWD IDFFKLQR DOOH FDPHUH GHO SULQFLSH $OIRQVR &DSSHOODQR H PDHVWUR GHL SDJJL GL /XLJL/ 0DHVWUR GHL SDJJL GL &HVDUH
7UD FRQVLJOLHUL H GRWWRUL QHO 48<5/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL VH0 JQDWXUD QHO 48<:/ QHO 48<<0933 VLJQRUH GHO FRQVLJOLR VHJQDWXUD H FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD/ QHO 4936 FRQVL0 JOLHUH GL VWDWR/ GDO 4937 DO 493: FRQVLJOLHUH H VLJQRUH GL VHJQDWXUD/ GDO 493< UXEULFDWR FRPH FRQVLJOLHUH 6HUYLWRUH GHL SDJJL &DPHULHUH GL 6$ VLQR DO 48<:/ GDO 48<; JXDUGDURELHUH/ GDO 4936 JXDUGDURELHUH GL 6$
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9;:
/8 48:90;9 $5 48;;0<: &( 48<;04943
0HVVHU
/HRQDUGR
$5 48<50: &( 48<;04955 $5 489:0<: &( 48<;04947 $5 48;60<: &( 48<;04933 $5 48;80<: &( 48<;0493< $5 48<30: &( 48<;04958 $5 48;;0<: &( 48<;0495: $6 495; )4 495<077 $5 48<7 &( 48<;04958 $5 48<30: &( 48<;04937 $5 48<: &( 48<;04958
0DHVWUR
$OIRQVR
*DU]RQH VSH]LDOH QHO 48:9/ VSH]LDOH GDO 48:: DO 48;7/ YDOOHWWR QHO 48;9/ YDOOHWWR GL 6$ GDO 48;; DO 4937/ YDO0 OHWWR H VSH]LDOH GDO 4939 DO 493;/ YDOOHWWR GDO 493< DO 4943 &UHPRQLQR &XRFR/ GDO 494: FXRFR GHO SULQFLSH $OIRQVR
*LXOLR
'LFHPEUL
8IILFLDOH GL JXDUGDURED
7DGGHR
)HUUDULQL
)DFFKLQR LQ GLVSHQVD
0HVVHU
(UFROH
)LRUQRYHOOL
&DQFHOOLHUH
0HVVHU
6FLSLRQH
)LRUQRYHOOL
&RQWH
$OIRQVR
)RQWDQHOOL
8IILFLDOH LQ GLVSHQVD VLQR DO 4936/ GDO 4937 GLVSHQVLH0 UH 7UD L VLJQRUL H JHQWLOXRPLQL GL $OIRQVR VLQR DO 48<:/ PDHVWUR GL FDPHUD GL &HVDUH
0HVVHU
)HGHULFR
*DJOLDUGL
$5 48<70: &( 48<;04937 $5 48<: &( 48<;04948
0HVVHU
)UDQFHVFR
&DQFHOOLHUH/ FDQFHOOLHUH GL 6$ QHO 48<</ GDO 4933 FDQ0 FHOOLHUH *LRYDQQHWWL )DFFKLQR QHOOD IDPLJOLD GL PDGDPD QHO 48<:/ IDFFKLQR DOOH OHJQDLH VLQR DO 4947/ QHO 4948 DOOH FDPHUH GL PD0 GDPD/ GDO 4949 DOOH FDPHUH GHOOD SULQFLSHVVD *LXOLD *UD]LDQL 6WDIILHUH QHO 48<7/ GDO 48<: XVFLHUH GL 6$
6LJQRU
)UDQFHVFR
*XDUHVFKL
$5 48<80<: &( 48<;04944 $5 48:90<: &( 48<;0494;
PR/ PV ,SSROLWR GDO 8<; ,OOXVWUL0 *LRYDQQL VPR %DWWLVWD VLJQRU $QQD
/DGHUFKL
*HQWLOXRPR GL $OIRQVR ,,/ PDHVWUR GL VWDOOD VLQR DO 4944/ QHO 494506 PDHVWUR GL VWDOOD H FDPHULHUH GL 6$/ QHO 494708 PDHVWUR GL VWDOOD H FDPHULHUH VHJUHWR GL 6$ 6DUWR LQ JXDUGDURED FRQ $OIRQVR ,, VLQR DO 48<:/ YDO0 OHWWR GL 6$ VLQR DO 493</ GDO 4943 VDUWR H YDOOHWWR 6HJUHWDULR H FRQVLJOLHUH GL 6WDWR
0DODJROD
%XJDGDUD GL FRUWH
0HVVHU
6DQWR
3DOODYLFLQL
(UFROH
3DVTXDOHWWL
0DHVWUR
$QWRQLR
5RPHL
&DYDOFDWRUH VLQR DO 4933/ GDO 4936 DO 4946 FDYDOOHUL]0 ]R/ GDO 4947 FDYDOOHUL]]R GL 6$ 9DOOHWWR VLQR DO 48<:/ GDO 4933 FDSR GHOOD SRUWD GL VDQW·$JRVWLQR $UPDLROR
0HVVHU
*HURODPR
6FDSSL
6LJQRU
2UD]LR
6HJKL]]L
$5 48<: &( 48<; $5 48;50<: &( 48<;0495: $5 48:;0<: &( 48<;04933 $5 48<30: &( 48<;04933 $5 489:0<: &( 48<;0494: $5 48<: &( 48<;04943
0DJQLILFR &HVDUH PHVVHU 'RPHQLFR
&RLDQD
)DOFRQLHUH
*DYDVVLQL
*XDVFRQL
6RSUDFXRFR/ GDO 48;5 QHOOD IDPLJOLD GHOOD GXFKHVVD/ VRSUDFXRFR GL &HVDUH *RYHUQDWRUH GHL SDJJL
9;;
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
$5 48<: &( 48<;0495: $5 48<: &( 48<;0< $5 48:90;6 &( 48<;04939 $5 48<5 &( 48<;0495:
0DHVWUR
$5 48<: &( 48<;04943 /8 48::0;9 $5 48<30: &( 48<;04936
%HUQDUGR
6SLQHWWD
$UPDLROR FKH ID JOL DUFKLEXJL
*UHJRULR
7DVVL
8IILFLDOH DO WLQHOOR
&RQWH
*LXOLR
7DVVRQL
0HVVHU
*LXOLR
7HVWL
0HVVHU
&ULVWRIRUR
8JROLQL
0HVVHU
)LOLSSR
'HOOD 9HGRYD
&DPHULHUH GL $OIRQVR ,,/ PDJJLRUGRPR H IDWWRUH JH0 QHUDOH GDO 48<< 8IILFLDOH GL FDPHUD QHO 48<5/ PDVVDUR GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH VLQR DO 4936/ GDO 4937 PDHVWUR GL FRQWR H PDV0 VDUR GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH 8IILFLDOH GL FDVD GL $OIRQVR ,,/ VSHQGLWRUH VLQR DO 4936/ GDO 4937 IDWWRUH GXFDOH LQ FDUSLJLDQD %RWWLJOLHUH/ QHO 4936 ERWWLJOLHUH GL 6$
)RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= $5 VWD SHU $OIRQVR ,,/ &( SHU &HVDUH/ /8 SHU /XLJL> LO SULPR DQQR q TXHOOR GL LQL]LR VHUYL]LR/ LO VHFRQGR TXHOOD GHOOD ILQH1
6L WUDWWDYD VRSUDWWXWWR/ q TXHVWD O·DPDUD UHDOWi/ GL GLVJUD]LDWL VHQ]D DUWH Qp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i= VH JLi OD PDWWLQD GL GRPHQLFD 4 JHQ0 QDLR 48<;/ TXDWWUR JLRUQL GRSR OD PHVWD SDUWHQ]D GL &HVDUH SHU 0RGHQD/ LO FDUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQL ´UHVWz D GLVQDUH FRQ WXWWL TXHL 3UHODWL/ 3ULQFLSL HW 6L0 JQRUL/ VHUYLWL GD JOL VFDOFKL/ HW PLQLVWUL GHO 'XFD $OIRQVR GL ERQD PHPRULDµ/53 QRQ DSSHQD LQ DSULOH DUULYy &OHPHQWH 9,,, %L &DUGLQDOL FKH HUDQR JLXQWL SULPD i )HUUDUD/ JOL $PEDVFLDWRUL GL )UDQFLD/ ) 9HQHWLD/ PROWL 9HVFRYL/ ) DOWUL/ 3UHODWL/ DOFXQL %DURQL 5RPDQL/ WXWWL L 1RELOL/ ) PROWL DOWUL IHUUDUHVL/ DQGRUQR LQ GLYHUVH WUXSSH i ULQFRQWUDUH 11 6LJ1 >LO SDSD@µ/ 54 H OD PHGHVLPD VFHQD VL ULSHWp LO
²²²²²²²² 53
,Q 1DUUDWLRQH GHOOD SDUWHQ]D GHO 6HUHQLVV1 6LJ1 '1 &HVDUH GD (VWH/ 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ HUW GL 5HJJLR/ ) &1 FRQ OH IHVWH HW WULRQIL IDWWH QHOO·,QWUDWD GHOO·,OOXVWULVV1 (W 5HYHUHQGLVV1 &DUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQR /HJDWR1 1HOOD FLWWi GL )HUUDUD/ LO Gt 5< GL *HQDUR/ 01'1;&9,,,/ 3DYLD/ $QGUHD 9LDQL/ 48<;/ F16Y/ ULSUR0 GRWWR WUD L IDFVLPLOHV GHO WHVWR GL %1 0,7&+(/// 48<; $ \HDU RI 3DJHDQWU\ LQ /DWH 0HGLHYDO )HUUDUD/ %LQJKDPSWRQ01HZ <RUN/ 0HGLHYDO DQG 5HQDLVVDQFH WH[WV DQG 6WXGLHV/ 4<<31 54 ,Q )HOLFLVVLPD HQWUDWD GL 1161331 &OHPHQWH 9,,, QHOO·,QFOLWD &LWWi GL )HUUDUD1 &RQ JOL $SSDUDWL
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9;<
63 PDJJLR GHOOR VWHVVR DQQR/ TXDQGR DG DFFRJOLHUH JOL DPEDVFLDWRUL GHOOD 6HUHQLVVLPD 6LJQR0 ULD GL 9HQHWLD ´YL IXURQR PROWL *HQWLOO·KXRPLQL )HUUDUHVL i &RUWHJJLDUOL/ ) LQILQLWR 3RSROR%55
6H HVFOXGLDPR GXQTXH LO VLJQRU $OHVVDQGUR $ULRVWR/ LO FRQWH *XLGREDOGR %RQDUHOOL/ O·LOOXVWUH VLJQRU 3DROR (PLOLR &DVDWL/ LO VLJQRU (UFROH &RFFDSDQL/ LO PDUFKHVH *LXOLR 7KLHQL/ LO FRQWH $OIRQVR )RQWDQHOOL H LO EXRQ /DGHUFKL/ L YHUWLFL GHOOD FRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,, GLVHUWDURQR LQ PDVVD OD FDXVD GHO VXR VXFFHV0 VRUH1 1p PDQFDURQR/ IDWWR DQFRU SL~ JUDYH/ OH GHIH]LRQL WUD JOL VWHVVL FRUWLJLDQL GL &HVDUH/ VH q YHUR FKH TXDVL OD PHWi GL TXDQWL OR VHUYLURQR D )HUUDUD QHO 48<: +8: VX 456, GHFLVH GL DEEDQGRQDUOR DO VXR GHVWLQR GL SURIXJR GL OXVVR/ FRPH IHFHUR DG HVHPSLR LO VLJQRU /XGRYLFR %HIIL/ PRQVLJQRU 6DQWR 3DVWL R LO PDJQLILFR $OHVVDQGUR *XDULQL1 3HU LURQLD GHOOD VRUWH/ OD JUDQ SDUWH GHL UHVLGXL VHVVDQWDVHL IHGHOLVVLPL HUD FRVWLWXLWD GDL IDPLOLDUL GHOOD PRJOLH 9LUJLQLD/ XQD 0HGLFL/ SHU GL SL~ EDVWDUGD1 8QD GHEDFOH/ XQ YHUR GLVDVWUR/ OD FXL DPDUH]]D YHQQH SDU]LDOPHQWH PLWLJDWD GDOOD OHDOWi GHL FRPDQGDQWL GHOOH PLOL]LH H GHL SULQFLSDOL UHWWRUL GHJOL VWDWL H0 VWHQVL= ULPDVHUR LQIDWWL IHGHOL D &HVDUH LO ORFRWHQHQWH ,SSROLWR %HQWLYRJOLR +LO YH0 UR DOWHU0HJR GL &HVDUH QHL SULPL DQQL GHO WRUPHQWDWR VRJJLRUQR PRGHQHVH, H LO GL OXL IUDWHOOR (Q]R/ *DOHD]]R 7DVVRQL (VWHQVH/ FDSLWDQR GHOOD FDYDOOHULD/ LO FRQWH (QHD 0RQWHFXFFROL/ FDSLWDQR GHOOD JXDUGLD GXFDOH QRPLQDWR QHO 48<< JRYHUQDWRUH GL &DUSL/ LO FDSLWDQR GHOOH ODQFLH GL /XJR (UQHVWR %HYLODFTXD/ L FRORQQHOOL 5REHUWR 2EL]]L/ &DPLOOR 0DUWLQHQJR H 3DROR %UXVDQWLQL/ LO JRYHU0 QDWRUH GL 0RGHQD )HUUDQWH 7DVVRQL (VWHQVH H VXR ILJOLR (UFROH/56 TXHOOR GL 5HJJLR/ FRQWH (UFROH 5RQGLQHOOL +VRVWLWXLWR GDO IHEEUDLR DO VHWWHPEUH 48<< GD &DPLOOR 5RQGLQHOOL, H TXHOOR GL *DUIDJQDQD/ 2UD]LR 6DFUDWL/ FXL DO PRPHQWR GHOOD SDUWHQ]D VL XQLURQR SRFKL DOWUL QRELOL IHUUDUHVL/ WUD FXL OD PDUFKHVD 7DV0 ²²²²²²²² 3XEEOLFL IDWWL QHOOH &LWWi/ 7HUUH/ &DVWHOOL/ H /XRJKL/ GRYH 616DQWLWi q SDVVDWD/ GRSR OD VXD SDUWLWD GL 5RPD/ )HUUDUD/ 9LWWRULR %DOGLQL/ 48<;/ F16U/ ULSURGRWWR WUD L IDFVLPLOHV GHO WHVWR GL %1 0,7&+(/// 48<; $ \HDU RI 3DJHDQWU\ LQ /DWH 0HGLHYDO )HUUDUD«FLW1 55 ,Q 1DUUDWLRQH GHOOD VROHQLVVLPD HQWUDWD LQ )HUUDUD GHO 6HUHQLVVLPR GXFD GL 0DQWRD HW GHOO·,OOXVWULVVLPL $PEDVFLDWRUL GL 9HQHWLD FRQ LO UHFLYHPHQWR IDWWROL GD 11 6LJ1 3DSD &OHPHQWH 9,,,1 5DF0 FROWR SHU *LHURQLQR $PDURWWL/ 5RPD/ %DUWRORPHR %RQIDGLQR/ 48<;/ F15U/ ULSURGRWWR WUD L IDFVLPLOHV GHO WHVWR GL %1 0,7&+(/// 48<; $ \HDU RI 3DJHDQWU\ LQ /DWH 0HGLHYDO )HUUDUD«FLW1 56 6L YHGDQR D WDO SURSRVLWR OH LQWHUHVVDQWL RVVHUYD]LRQL GL 11 7$6621, (67(16(/ /D FULVL H O·HYROX]LRQH GHOO·DULVWRFUD]LD HVWHQVH GRSR OD 'HYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 616HGH/ DWWUDYHUVR OH YLFHQGH GHOOD IDPLJOLD 7DVVRQL/ LQ %$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQ0 FLH 0RGHQHVL%/ V1 ;,/ ;; +4<<;,/ SS1 438044;/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH SS1 44504461
9<3
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
VRQL/ L FRQWL *XLGREDOGR 5RYHUHOOD/ 7LEHULR 5LFFL/ 8JR 5DQJRQL/ *LRYDQQL 0RO]D/ L JHQWLOXRPLQL &DUOR )RUQL H *HPLQLDQR 5RQFi/ LO FRORQQHOOR 0RO0 OD157 &HVDUH HVSLDYD GXQTXH OD VXD PDOD HGXFD]LRQH DO SRWHUH/ VFRQWDYD O·LPSRVVLELOLWi GL SURPHWWHUH/ QHOOH FRQGL]LRQL LQ FXL VL WURYDYD/ RQRUL/ FDUL0 FKH H ULFFKH]]H/ SDJDYD OD VFDUVD IRU]D GHOOH VXH UHOD]LRQL FRQ OH IDPLJOLH GRPLQDQWL/ FKH YDQWDYDQR LQYHFH VROLGL OHJDPL FRQ OD ID]LRQH ILORSRQWLILFLD> DQFRU SULPD GHOOD SDUWHQ]D )HUUDUD QRQ JOL DSSDUWHYD SL~/ IRUVH QRQ JOL HUD PDL GDYYHUR DSSDUWHQXWD= LO 5; JHQQDLR 48<;/ VRWWR XQD PDOLQFRQLFD SLRJJH0 UHOOLQD LQYHUQDOH/ LO EXRQ &HVDUH %SUHFHGXWR GDOOD PRJOLH H GDL ILJOLROL H GDOOD FRUWH LQ QXPHURVH FDUUR]]H/ HJOL VROR LQ XQ·DOWUD/ VFRUWDWR GD 933 FDYDOOHJJH0 UL/ 533 DUFKLEXJHUL D FDYDOOR/ H 633 VROGDWL GL IDQWHULD/ VHQ]D OHYDU PDL JOL X0 PLGL RFFKL GD XQD OHWWHUD FKH OHJJHYD/ DWWUDYHUVDQGR LO JLDUGLQR GHO 3DGLJOLR0 QH >«@ VL DYYLy YHUVR OD SRUWD GHJOL $QJHOLµ H/ GRSR DYHU IDWWR OLEHUDUH L FDUFH0 UDWL/ ´GDWR TXHVWR XOWLPR FRPDQGR >« @ XVFt GDOOD FLWWi >«@ H V·LQFDPPLQy DO VXR 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD%158 /D FRUWH GL &HVDUH GRSR OD GHYROX]LRQH /D QDUUD]LRQH GHOOD SDUWHQ]D GL &HVDUH ULSRUWDWD QHOOD FKLXVXUD GHO SUHFH0 GHQWH FDSLWROR QRQ q VWDWD VFHOWD D FDVR1 (VVD GLPRVWUD FRPH LO VHJXLWR GHO QRYHOOR GXFD GL 0RGHQD VL VLD VLOHQ]LRVDPHQWH PD LQVWDQFDELOPHQWH LQJURV0 VDWR QHO FRUVR GHO WHPSR/ JUD]LH DL ULWRFFKL GL TXDQWL YROOHUR DWWULEXLUH PDJ0 JLRU VSHVVRUH ´XPDQRµ D TXHOOR FKH IX XQ GUDPPD TXDVL SULYDWR1 ,Q WDO VHQ0 VR/ LO )UL]]L/ DXWRUH GHO SDVVR VRSUD FLWDWR/ QRQ IHFH FKH DOLPHQWDUH XQD OHJ0 JHQGD VWRULRJUDILFD FKH JHQHUD]LRQL H JHQHUD]LRQL GL VWXGLRVL DYHYDQR JLi JH0 QHURVDPHQWH QXWULWR1 3URYLDPR LQIDWWL D SDUDJRQDUH OH GLYHUVH QDUUD]LRQL GL TXHOO·LQIDXVWR HYHQ0 WR/ LQL]LDQGR GDOOD FRHYD 1DUUDWLRQH GHOOD SDUWHQ]D GHO 6HUHQLVV1 6LJ1 '1 &HVDUH GD (VWH/ SXEEOLFDWD D 3DYLD QHO 48<;1 ,Q WDOH WHVWR O·DQRQLPR DXWRUH GHVFULVVH LQ TXHVWL WHUPLQL OD FRPLWLYD GHL SDUWHQWL %PHUFRUGL D 48 KRUH/ FKH IX OL 5; *HQDUR VL SDUWt LO GXFD GD TXHVWD &LWWi FRQ TXHVWR RU0 GLQH >111@ YHQLYD OD 'XFKHVVD FRQ OD ILJOLROD GHQWUR XQD OHWWLFD DPPDODWD/ HW PDOHQFRQLFD/ FKH
²²²²²²²² 57 7DOL QRPLQDWLYL VRQR VWDWL GHVXQWL GDOOD OLVWD GL /1 &+,$33,1,/ 48<;= GLDULR GL XQD VYROWD LQ )HUUDUD/ :1 4<<:/ S1 541 58 $1 )5,==,/ 0HPRULH SHU OD VWRULD GL )HUUDUD/ )HUUDUD/ )UDQFHVFR 3RPDWHOOL/ 4:<404:<9/ OL0 EUR 9/ S1 491
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9<4
KDYHYD TXDVL GLVSHUVR OD QRWWH DYDQWL/ HW GLHWUR LQ XQ·DOWUD OHWWLFD YHQLYDQR JOL ILJOLXROLQL1 3RL LQ WUH FDUUR]]H i VHL FDYDOOL YHQLYDQR OH VXH GDPLJHOOH/ HW VXRL JHQWLO·KXRPLQL SDUWLFRODUL1 6H0 JXLYD SXU LQ FDUUR]]D LO 'XFD FRQ TXDWWUR JHQWLO·KXRPLQL/ HW EHQ IX GL PDFLJQLR HW GL GLD0 PDQWH FKL WHQQH O·RFFKLR DVFLXWWR D TXHO IXQHEUH HW FRPSDVVLRQHYROH VSHWWDFROR%59
'XH OHWWLJKH H TXDWWUR FDUUR]]H/ XQ VHJXLWR GL SURSRU]LRQL WXWW·DOWUR FKH ELEOLFKH/ GHVWLQDWR D LQJURVVDUVL D GLVPLVXUD/ TXDVL FKH QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL OH GXH OHWWLJKH H OH TXDWWUR FDUUR]]H GHO 48<; DYHVVHUR LPEDUFDWR/ DQQR GRSR DQQR H PLJOLR GRSR PLJOLR/ QXRYL SDVVHJJHUL/ VLQR D UDJJLXQJHUH FLIUH VXUUHD0 OL/ IRUWXQDWDPHQWH VPDVFKHUDWH GDO &KLDSSLQL/ LO TXDOH KD UHFHQWHPHQWH RV0 VHUYDWR FKH &HVDUH IX VHJXLWR D 0RGHQD ´GD QRQ SRFKL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOD QRELOWi IHUUDUHVH/ FLUFD XQ PLJOLDLRµ PD ´QRQ YHQWLPLOD/ FRPH TXDOFXQR KD GHWWR/ FLIUD DVVXUGD/ VH VL FRQVLGHUD FKH OD SRSROD]LRQH FLWWDGLQD DPPRQWDYD D FLUFD WUHQWDTXDWWURPLOD XQLWiµ15: ,Q UHDOWi/ L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOD QRELOWi IHUUDUHVH IXURQR PROWL GL PHQR/ SUREDELOPHQWH QRQ SL~ GL GXHFHQWR WUD FRUWLJLDQL/ FRPDQGDQWL GHOOH PLOL]LH/ UHWWRUL GHOOR VWDWR/ ULVSHWWLYH FRQVRUWL H UHODWLYL SDUHQWL1 6RPPDQGR ORUR LO FHQWLQDLR GL VDODULDWL GL FRUWH/ OH 4830533 ERFFKH D FDULFR +ILJOL/ PRJOL H SDUHQWL YDUL,/ XQD FLQTXDQWLQD WUD VWDOOLHUL H PXODWWLHUL/ OH FHQWR JXDUGLH VYL]]HUH H WH0 GHVFKH H OH QXWULWH VHUYLW~ GHL FODQ DULVWRFUDWLFL DUULYLDPR D XQ PLJOLDLR GL SHUVRQH/ XQD FLIUD GL WXWWR ULVSHWWR/ FRPXQTXH LQ JUDGR GL IDU VDOWDUH L GHOLFDWL HTXLOLEUL GHPRJUDILFL HG HFRQRPLFL GHOOD SLFFROD FLWWi SUHDSSHQQLQLFD1 7XWWD0 YLD/ PL VHQWR GL DJJLXQJHUH FKH WUD L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOD QRELOWi QRQ Y·HUD JUDQ FRSLD GL DULVWRFUDWLFL IHUUDUHVL/ L TXDOL/ LQ YHULWi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i IHUUDUHVH HUDQR LQ EHQ DOWUH IDFFHQGH DIID0 FHQGDWL/ WXWWL SUHVL DG RFFXSDUH L YHQWLVHWWH VFUDQQL ULVHUYDWL DOOD FODVVH GHL QRELOL ²²²²²²²² 59 ,Q 1DUUDWLRQH GHOOD SDUWHQ]D GHO 6HUHQLVV1 6LJ1'1&HVDUH GD (VWH/ 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ HW GL 5HJJLR/ ) &1 FRQ OH IHVWH HW WULRQIL IDWWH QHOO·,QWUDWD GHOO·,OOXVWULVV1 (W 5HYHUHQGLVV1 &DUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQR /HJDWR1 1HOOD FLWWi GL )HUUDUD/ LO Gt 5< GL *HQDUR/ 01'1;&9,,,«FLW1 5: /1 &+,$33,1,/ 48<;= GLDULR GL XQD VYROWD FLW1/ SS1 4:05:> OD FLWD]LRQH q WUDWWD GD S1541
9<5
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
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p OD FRUWH GL &HVDUH ULXVFLVVH OHQWDPHQWH D ULSUHQGHUH YLJRUH/ FRPH VL SXy HYLQFHUH GDOOD OHWWXUD GHOOD VHJXHQWH WDEHOOD= 7DEHOOD 8= L WDVVL GL WXUQ0RYHU GHOOD FRUWH GL &HVDUH/ 48<;0495: $QQR 1XPHUR 1XRYL ( 1XRYL $EEDQGRQL ( $EEDQGRQL FRUWLJLDQL LQJUHVVL LQJUHVVL 48<; 49: 434 93/7;( : 7/4<( 48<< 4:6 46 :/84( 44 9/69( 4933 4:7 45 9/<3( 69 53/9<( 4936 49: 5< 4:/6:( 45 :/4<( 4937 495 : 7/65( 43 9/4:( 4939 49: 48 ;/<;( < 8/6<( 493: 49: < 8/6<( : 7/4<( 493< 578 ;8 67/9<( 4: 9/<7( 4943 57: 4< :/9<( 48 9/3:( 4944 57< 4: 9/;6( 48 9/35( 4945 586 4< :/84( 49 9/65( 4946 57< 45 7/;5( 43 7/35( 4947 584 45 7/:;( 64 45/68( 4948 55< < 6/<6( 44 7/;3( 4949 56< 54 ;/:<( 65 46/6<( 494: 54< 45 8/7;( 7 4/;6( 494; 567 4< ;/45( ; 6/75( 494< 57< 56 </57( 47 8/95( 4953 597 5< 43/<;( ; 6/36( 4954 599 43 6/:9( 45 7/84( 4955 5:: 56 ;/63( 4: 9/47( 4956 5;: 5: </74( 48 8/56( 4957 5<: 58 ;/75( 4< 9/73( 4958 637 59 ;/88( 5: ;/;;( 4959 5;; 44 6/;5( 69 45/83( 495: 5:7 55 ;/36( 4977 64< 59; ;7/34( )RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= QHOOD FRORQQD UHFDQWH OD GLFLWXUD QXPHUR FRUWLJLDQL q ULSRUWDWR LO QXPHUR WRWDOH GL VDODULDWL LQ VHUYL]LR QHOO·DQQR FRUULVSRQGHQWH/ LQ TXHOOD QXRYL LQJUHVVL LO QX0 PHUR GL FRUWLJLDQL FKH LQL]LDURQR D VHUYLUH QHOO·DQQR/ LQ TXHOOD DEEDQGRQL LO QXPHUR GL FRUWL0 JLDQL FKH VHUYu SHU O·XOWLPD YROWD QHOO·DQQR1
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9<6
(UD GXQTXH XQD FRUWH PLQXVFROD/ OH FXL GLPHQVLRQL QRQ UDJJLXQVHUR QHS0 SXUH QHO 4958/ DOO·DSLFH GHOOD VXD IORULGH]]D/ LO OLYHOOR PLQLPR WRFFDWR GD TXHOOD DOIRQVLQD QHO VHFROR SUHFHGHQWH> Qp VL SHQVL FKH LO EDO]R WUD LO 493: H LO 493< VLD GD DWWULEXLUVL D FDXVH SDUWLFRODUL= O·RWWDQWLQD GL VDODULDWL FKH LQ TXHVWR ODVVR GL WHPSR VL DJJLXQVHUR DOOR VPXQWR UXROR GL &HVDUH HUDQR LQ SUHSRQGH0 UDQ]D IDPLOLDUL GL ,VDEHOOD GL 6DYRLD/ VSRVDWD QHO 493; GDO SULPRJHQLWR $OIRQ0 VR1 , QXPHUL QRQ GHYRQR SHUy WUDUUH LQ LQJDQQR= &HVDUH SHUVHJXt XQ SROLWLFD GL FKLDPDWH D FRUWH HVWUHPDPHQWH DFFRUWD/ SRWHQGR SHVFDUH LQ XQ GRSSLR EDFLQR1 ,O SULPR/ VLFXUDPHQWH LO SL~ DIIDVFLQDQWH/ HUD FRVWLWXLWR GDO IURQWH GHL IHU0 UDUHVL ´SHQWLWLµ1 /·LQIDWXD]LRQH SHU OD FDXVD SRQWLILFLD GXUy EHQ SRFR/ VYD0 QHQGR QRQ DSSHQD VL UHDOL]]y FKH O·$OGREUDQGLQL QRQ DYUHEEH PDQWHQXWR OH SURPHVVH IDWWH QHJOL XOWLPL GXH PHVL GHO 48<:/ TXDQGR SUDWLFDYD ´PROWH IDPLJOLH GL TXHVWD FLWWi SULQFLSDOL SHU HFFLWDUOH FRQWUR LO 'XFD/ PDVVLPDPHQWH GL TXHOOH/ R F·KDQR EHQL VRWWR OD FKLHVD/ R F·KDQR SUHWL LQ FDVD VXD/ SURPHWWHQGR ORUR KRQRUL/ FDUGLQDODWL/ FDULFKH LQ JXHUUD/ IHXGL/ HW LQILQLWL FRPPRGLµ5;
9L IXURQR/ ELVRJQD DPPHWWHUOR/ GHOOH SURPR]LRQL +LO FRQWH 2WWDYLR (0 VWHQVH 7DVVRQL H LO FRQWH $OIRQVR *LJOLROL YHQQHUR QRPLQDWL FDPHULHUL VHJUHWL GHO SDSD/ LO FRQWH )UDQFHVFR 6DFUDWL GLYHQQH DXGLWRUH GL 5RWD H LQ VHJXLWR FDU0 GLQDOH/ PRQVLJQRU &DUOR 7URWWL RWWHQQH LO YHVFRYDWR GL %DJQDUHD/ LO IUDWH 0R0 GHVWR *DYD]]L HEEH LO YHVFRYDWR GL $OLVVH/ 2UD]LR *LUDOGL/ JLi YHVFRYR GL &RPDFFKLR/ YHQQH HOHWWR JRYHUQDWRUH GL $QFRQD H LO FRQWH %RQLIDFLR %HYL0 ODTXD/ FK·HUD VWDWR UHIHUHQGDULR/ JRYHUQDWRUH GL &DPHULQR H LQILQH SDWULDUFD GL &RVWDQWLQRSROL FRQVHJXt O·DJRJQDWD SRUSRUD FDUGLQDOL]LD,/ PD LO IHUUDUHVH *L0 VPRQGR )ORULR QRQ GRYHYD HVVHUH GHO WXWWR LQVLQFHUR TXDQGR/ HVRUWDQGR &H0 VDUH L ULSUHQGHUVL OD FDSLWDOH DYLWD/ ODPHQWDYD FKH %L PLQLVWUL HFFOHVLDVWLFL >111@ FRPH QXRYL OLVWULJRQL/ DQWURSRIDJL/ JLULRQL/ SROLIHPL HG DUSLH GL SUHVHQWH WLUDQQHJJLDQGROD >)HUUDUD@ KDQQR LQ TXHOOD VRYHUWLWR RJQL EXRQ FRVWXPH/ LQWUR0 GRWWR TXDOXQTXH YLWLR/ LVEDQGLWD OD YLUWX/ GLWUXWWH OH SL~ EHOOH IDEULFKH/ GLVVLSDWL OL PLJOLRUL FLW0 WDGLQL/ SHUPHVVH O·LQRQGDWLRQL GHOO·DFTXH H SHU FRQFKLXGHUOD ULGGRWWD OD PLVHUD FLWWi FKH LQ ²²²²²²²² 5; ,Q $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 0$1729$/ $UFKLYLR *RQ]DJD/ $PEDVFLDWRUL )HUUDUD/ Q1 4593/ /HWWHUD GL /HOLR $UULYDEHQH DG $QQLEDOH &KLHSSR/ GD )HUUDUD/ GHO 4< GLFHPEUH 48<:%1
9<7
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
TXHOOD GD HVVL QRQ VL VWLPD OD QRELOWi Qp VL DWWHQGH DOOD SRYHUWi/ PD VROR DG DFFXPXODUH RUR HW DUJHQWR SHU YLH LQGLUHWWH KRU XQD IDPLJOLD HW KRU XQ·DOWUD%5<
'RSR OD VERUQLD GHO 48<;/ VYDQLWH OH LOOXVLRQL LQL]LDOL/ OD FRUWH HVWHQVH/ SHU TXDQWR ORQWDQD/ WRUQy D HVHUFLWDUH XQ LQQHJDELOH IDVFLQR/ H QRQ VROR VXJOL DUL0 VWRFUDWLFL GL RULJLQH PRGHQHVH/ UHJJLDQD H JDUIDJQLQD1 $OFXQL ULXVFLURQR D ULHQWUDUH SL~ R PHQR UDSLGDPHQWH QHL UDQJKL PRGHQHVL= QHO 48<< WRUQDURQR DOO·RYLOH LO VLJQRU FDYDOLHU *HURODPR 0DOYH]]L/ VRWWRVFDOFR GL $OIRQVR ,, UL0 DPPHVVR FRQ OD PHGHVLPD FDULFD H PHVVHU 'DQLHOH 0LFKHOHWWL/ O·RURORJLDLR DOIRQVLQR FKH DQFKH D 0RGHQD FRQWLQXy D VYROJHUH OD PHGHVLPD PDQVLRQH/ QHO 4933 IX OD YROWD GHJOL LOOXVWUL PDUFKHVL $OIRQVR H &RUQHOLR 0DODVSLQD/ VL0 QR DO 48<: JHQWLOXRPLQL GL $OIRQVR H UHLQWHJUDWL FRQ OD VWHVVD TXDOLILFD/ QHO 4936 L PHVVHUL 6FLSLRQH *DJOLDUGL/ IDOFRQLHUH/ H )UDQFHVFR *LJOLROL/ XIILFLDOH LQ WLQHOOR VRWWR $OIRQVR ,, H DO VHUYL]LR GHL SDJJL GL &HVDUH/ QHO 493: )UDQFH0 VFR 0DULD %DWWDJOLD/ JLi VWDIILHUH GL &HVDUH QHO 48<: H ULSUHVR FRQ LGHQWLFD PDQVLRQH/ H O·LOOXVWULVVLPR VLJQRU FRQWH /XLJL 0RQWHFFXFROL/ VLQR DO 48<7 FDPHULHUH GL $OIRQVR H GDO 493: FDPHULHUH VHJUHWR GL &HVDUH/ QHO 493< PHV0 VHU *LRYDQQL %DUELHUL/ VWDIILHUH GL $OIRQVR ,, ULHQWUDWR QHL UDQJKL FHVDULDQL FRPH XVFLHUH GL 6XD $OWH]]D/ QHO 4943 O·LOOXVWULVVLPR VLJQRU FRQWH (UFROH 7URWWL/ JHQWLOXRPR GL $OIRQVR DFFROWR TXDOH FDPHULHUH VHJUHWR GL $OIRQVR/ QHO 4957 O·LOOXVWULVVLPR FRQWH 0DVVLPLOLDQR 0RQWHFXFFROL/ VLQR DO 48<: FDPH0 ULHUH GL $OIRQVR H ULDSSDUVR QHO 4957 FRPH PDJJLRUGRPR GL &HVDUH1 7XWWDYLD/ EHQFKp QRQ VL SRVVD WDFHUH O·DOWLVRQDQ]D GHL QRPL GL FRORUR FKH ULDEEUDFFLDURQR OD FDXVD HVWHQVH/ VRQR DQFRU SL~ LQWHUHVVDQWL L FDVL GL FKL/ SXU SURYDQGRFL/ QRQ RWWHQQH LO EHQHSODFLWR OHJDWL]LR> LQIDWWL/ D ULSURYD GHO SUR0 JUHVVLYR VFDGLPHQWR GHL UDSSRUWL FRL QXRYL SDGURQL GHOOD FLWWi/ VL PROWLSOLFD0 URQR OH ULFKLHVWH GL SHUGRQR +FKH QRQ VHPSUH VL WUDGXVVHUR LQ OLFHQ]H GL H0 VSDWULR, PHQWUH FRQ VRVSHWWD DVVLGXLWi PROWL IHUUDUHVL VL SUHVHQWDYDQR D 0R0 GHQD SHU ULYHULUH LO QRYHOOR GXFD1 ,Q YHULWi/ L SULPL VHJQDOL GL LQVRIIHUHQ]D VL HUDQR PDQLIHVWDWL QHSSXUH XQ PHVH GDOOD SDUWHQ]D GL &HVDUH= JLi LO 5 PDU]R GHO 48<; O·DPEDVFLDWRUH GL FRPSOL0 FHPHQWR PHGLFHR/ LO FDYDOLHU &XU]LR 3LFFKHQD/ LQIRUPDYD LO JUDQGXFD FKH ´LO &DUGLQDOH >$OGREUDQGLQL@ RJQL JLRUQR SLX VL LQJHJQD GL GDU VRGLVIDWWLRQH D WXWWD TXHVWD QRELOWi IHUUDUHVH/ PD L FLWWDGLQL/ DL TXDOL SDUH FKH GL ORUR QRQ VLD ²²²²²²²² 5< (1 &$//(*$5,/ /D 'HYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH +48<;, GD GRFXPHQWL LQHGLWL GDJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H 9HQH]LD/ LQ ©5LYLVWD 6WRULFD ,WDOLDQDª/ ;,,/ ,/ 4;<8/ SS1 408:> OD FLWD0 ]LRQH q WUDWWD GD S1 881
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9<8
WHQXWR TXHO FRQWR FKH HVVL YRUUHEERQR/ UHVWDQR VLQR D KRUD XQ SRFR GLVJX0 VWDWL ´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
(UD HYLGHQWH FKH O·DSSDUHQWH FRQFRUGLD WUD OH SULQFLSDOL FDVH IHUUDUHVL VL UHJJHYD VROR VXOO·DHUHR IRQGDPHQWR GHOOH SURPHVVH SRQWLILFH/ SDUHQGR GHVWL0 QDWD D LQIUDQJHUVL GD XQ PRPHQWR DOO·DOWUR/ YLVWL JOL LQVDQDELOL FRQWUDVWL H OH DFFHVH ULYDOLWi HVLVWHQWL LQ VHQR DOO·LUUHTXLHWR IURQWH GHL WUDGLWRUL1 ,O )HGHOH/ OD FHOHEUH VSLD IHUUDUHVH GL &HVDUH/ VFULYHQGR D ILQH PDJJLR D SURSRVLWR GHL JHQ0 WLOXRPLQL GHO FRVWLWXHQGR FRQVLJOLR FHQWXPYLUDOH/ FRQIHVVDYD FKH %QRQ Vy FRPH JRYHUQDUDQ EHQH/ PDQJLDQGRVL LO FXRUH WUD GL ORUR TXHVWL LQIHGHOL1 &RQWH 7XUFKL/ FDYDOLHU *XDOHQJXR/ *LOLXROL %HYLODFTXL IDQQR XQD OHJD1 7DVVRQL/ )LDVFKL/ 6FDQGLDQR SHU DLXWR XQ·DOWUD1 &DOFDJQLQL GL SHU VH FRPH OL 0RVWL/ OL TXDOL VWDQQR ULWLUDWL HW TXHO PDWWR VSD]]DWR GHO FRQWH (UFROH VL GD DO GLDYROR GHOOD VXD EDOORQGHULD GLFHQGR= QRQ YLp SL~ OXRJR D ULPHGLDU D FRVD DOFXQD >«@ GLHWUR OH VXH SHGDWH FL YDQQR PROWL DOWUL/ PD QRQ VH QH ODVFLDQ LQ0 WHQGHUH/ FRQRVFHQGR O·HUURU ORUR/ PD WDUGL/ VJUDWLDWL FKH VRQR/ SRLFKH TXDQGR SDUODQR QHOO·LQWULQVHFR/ VL ODPHQWDQR VHJUDWDPHQWH/ HW OR Vy LR EHQLVVLPR/ SHUFKH TXDQGR EHQ·DQFR LO 3DSD DYHVVHD EHQHILFLDU OD &LWWi/ HW OR IDFHVVH LQ HIHWWR/ VDQQR FHUWR TXHVWR/ FKH OD FDUQH GD *HQWLOKXRPR YHUUi D GXH TXDWWULQL OD OLUD/ WDQWR SRFR VDUDQ SUH]]DWL%165
/H SUHYLVLRQL GHO )HGHOH VL ULYHODURQR SUHVWR HVDWWH H QHSSXUH XQ DQQR GRSR LO FROOHJDWR SRQWLILFLR VL YLGH FRVWUHWWR D SUHQGHUH XUJHQWL SURYYHGLPHQWL/ SHU WDPSRQDUH XQ IOXVVR HPRUUDJLFR FKH SDUHYD GHVWLQDWR DG DXPHQWDUH GL JLRUQR LQ JLRUQR «
²²²²²²²² 63
,Q $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', ),5(1=(/ $UFKLYLR 0HGLFHR GHO 3ULQFLSDWR/ Q15<44/ %/HWWHUH GHO &DYDOLHU &XU]LR 3LFFKHQD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH GL FRPSOLPHQWR/ 48 IHEEUDLR 48<: 0 DSULOH 48<;/ OHW0 WHUD GHO 5 PDU]R 48<;1% 64 ,Q *1%1 63$&&,1,/ &URQDFD GL 0RGHQD/ DQQL 48;;04935 FLW1/ SS1 44404451 65 ,Q $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ $PEDVFLDWRUL 5RPD/ Q1496/ %/HW0 WHUD GHO )HGHOH GHO 63 PDJJLR 48<;%1
9<9
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
%,O VLJQRU 'XFD/ D SHUVXDVLRQH GHO VLJQRU &DUGLQDOH HW 0DUFKHVH GL 6FDQGLDQR SHU TXHO FKH PL q VWDWWR UHIIHUWR KDYHYD GL QXRYR DFHWWDWR DO VHUYL]LR LO &RQWH +HUFXOOH GH 0RVWL/ SHU FRQVLJOLHU GL VWDWWR/ VWDQ]H LQ FRUWH HW VSHVD SHU ERFFKH VHL/ FRQ 633 VFXGL GL SURYLVLRQH/ HW TXDQGR HVVR FRQWH/ FRQ VXH OHWWHUH KD FKLHVWR OLFHQ]D DO 6LJQRUH &DUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQR/ OL q VWDWWR ULVSRVWR FKH VH QH YDGD GD 0RQVLJQRUH ,OOXVWULVVLPR &DUGLQDO &ROHJDWWR/ GDO TXDOH KD0 YHUi OD UHVVROXWLRQH/ HW SDUH FKH HVVHQGRVL VWDWWR KDEEL UHWUDWWR FKH SHU GHJQL UHVSHWWL QRQ SXRO KDYHU OLFHQ]D/ HW RJJLGt LQ )HUUDUD D WXWWL VLD IHUUDUHVL FRPH IRUHVWLHUL DOOH SRUWH VL IDQQR GDUH OHWWHUH/ HW OH PDQGDQR DO &DUGLQDOH/ HW TXHVWR WUDWWR OR IHFHUR XOWLPDPHQWH D XQ ILJOLROR GHO &RQWH +HUFKXOOH %HYLODTXD%166 /·LGLOOLR HUD GXQTXH ILQLWR H SHUVLQR XQ %HYLODFTXD/ IDPLJOLD UHSXWDWD WUD OH SULQFLSDOL DUWHILFL GHO WUDGLPHQWR GHOOD FDXVD GL &HVDUH ©(W WUD OD QRELOWD VRQR SULQFLSDOPHQWH DFFDUH]]DWL HW IDYRULWL TXHOOL FKH KDQQR KDYXWR OD PDQR QHO QHJRWLR GHOO·DFFRPRGDPHQWR/ R FKH DOPHQR VL GLPRVWUDURQR VXELWR SDUWLDOL SHU OD &KLHVD/ FRPH GLUH LO &DYDOLHU *XDOHQJR/ LO FRQWH *XLGR &DOFDJQLQL/ L VLJQRUL %HYLODTXD/ L FRQWL *LJOLROL/ HW DOWUL/ PHWWHQGRVL DQFKH WUD TXHVWR QX0 PHUR LO VLJQRU &HVDUH 7URWWL/ IUDWHOOR SXWDWLYR GHO GXFD $OIRQVR67ª/ WHQWDYD GL ULDFTXLVWDUH LO IDYRUH GHO GXFD H ULWRUQDUH QHOO·RUELWD GHO SRWHUH HVWHQVH/ VHJXL0 WR D UXRWD GD XQ DOWUR WUDGLWRUH/ TXHO *DOHD]]R *XDOHQJR FKH QHOO·DJRVWR GHO 4935 LO FDUGLQDO $OHVVDQGUR UDFFRPDQGDYD DO IUDWHOOR SRLFKp %KD PRVWUR GH0 VLGHULR GL WUDVIHULUVL D 0RGHQD SHU IDU ULYHUHQ]D D 9RVWUD $OWH]]D HW FRQWLQXD0 UH O·DQWLFD VXD GLYRW1QH%168 &HVDUH/ RYYLDPHQWH/ QRQ SRWp DFFRJOLHUH WXWWH TXHVWH LVWDQ]H/ YXRL SHU FDOFROL GL QDWXUD SROLWLFD/ YXRL SHU OH DVVLOODQWL SUHRFFXSD]LRQH GL FDUDWWHUH HFRQRPLFR1 (JOL GRYHYD LQIDWWL ULFRVWUXLUH OD SURSULD FRUWH WHQHQGR FRQWR GHOOH QXRYH EDVL WHUULWRULDOL/ FKH OR REEOLJDYDQR D LQWHVVHUH GHOLFDWL UDSSRUWL FROOD ILHUD H WDOYROWD LQVRIIHUHQWH IHXGDOLWi ORFDOH/ FKH VHFROL H VHFROL GL ORQWD0 QDQ]D GDOOD FDSLWDOH DYHYDQR TXDVL LQVHOYDWLFKLWR/ VHQ]D SHUDOWUR LQLPLFDUVL OH RUJRJOLRVH ERUJKHVLH PXQLFLSDOL/ JHORVH GHOOD SURSULD YHWXVWD LQGLSHQGHQ]D PD QHO FRQWHPSR GHVLGHURVH GL DFTXLVLUH XQ WRQR FDSDFH GL QRQ IDUOH VILJX0 ²²²²²²²²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
/H FRUWL HVWHQVL QHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHO 48<;
9<:
UDUH QHO FRQIURQWR FRQ JOL D]]LPDWL SURIXJKL IHUUDUHVL1 ,O SURJHWWR GL UHVWDXUR GL TXHVWH IUDJLOL WUDPH SROLWLFKH H VRFLDOL/ FRQGRWWR FRQ OD WHQDFLD H OD SD]LHQ]D FKH VHPSUH FRQWUDGGLVWLQVHUR O·RSHUDWR GL &HVD0 UH/ DQGy IHOLFHPHQWH LQ SRUWR/ GRSR WUH GHFHQQL GL VLOHQWH ODYRULR GLSORPDWL0 FR1 2VVHUYLDPR LQIDWWL OD VHJXHQWH WDEHOOD= 7DEHOOD 9= )DPLJOLH DYHQWL DOPHQR GXH PHPEUL LQ VHUYL]LR WUD LO 47:4 H LO 495: QHO JUXSSR GHL VLJQRUL/ JHQWLOXRPLQL/ FDPHULHUL/ VFDOFKL/ VFXGLHUL/ PHGLFL/ VHJUHWDUL/ PDHVWUL GL JXDUGDURED/ VWDOOD H FDFFH/ RUDWRUL/ FRQVLJOLHUL/ IDWWRUL JHQHUDOL1 )DPLJOLD
47:408< $5
&( )DPLJOLD
47:408< $5
&( )DPLJOLD
47:408< $5
&(
$OYDURWWL
5
5
3
'DOOD 9HOD
5
3
3
0RUL
4
7
6
$QWRQHOOL
3
3
5
'DOO·$VVDVVLQR
5
4
3
0RVWL
7
5
3
$ULRVWL
<
6
6
'XUDQWL
3
3
5
1DVHOOL
5
5
3
%DUR]]L
3
3
5
)DUROILQL
7
3
3
3DQ]D
4
5
3
%HOHQFLQL
3
5
5
)HUUDUL
4
3
6
3DULVDQL
4
5
3
%HOODLD
6
4
4
)HUUL
3
3
5
3HURQGROL
5
3
5
%HQGHGHL
7
4
3
)LDVFKL
7
7
3
3LJQD
4
4
6
%HQWLYRJOLR
6
:
3
)RJOLDQL
4
5
3
3LR
6
4
3
%HUQLHUL
5
4
3
)RQWDQD
3
6
4
3LVWRJOLD
3
5
3
%HYLODFTXD
5
7
5
)RUQL
6
4
5
3UHWWL
3
5
3
%RLDUGL
5
4
4
)RVFDUGL
6
3
3
3URVSHUL
5
4
3
%RQDFFLROL
7
4
3
*DWWL
5
6
3
4XDJOLD
5
4
3
%RQOHL
7
4
3
*LDQHOOD
3
7
3
5DQJRQL
6
;
5
%RVFKHWWL
8
4
5
*LJOLROL
5
8
3
5LFFL
4
4
6
%UDVDYROD
5
7
4
*LUDOGL
3
5
3
5RPHL
7
3
3
%UXJLD
6
3
3
*LURQGL
5
3
3
5RVVHWWL
4
5
3
&DOFDJQLQL
5
4
4
*RQ]DJD
8
7
3
5XJJHUL
4
6
5
&DORUL
3
4
5
*UHFR
3
5
4
6DJUDWL
44
5
4
&DQRVVD
3
5
3
*ULOOHQ]RQL
3
3
5
6DQVHYHULQL
6
4
3
&DQWHOPL
5
3
3
*XDOHQJKL
5
5
3
6DUWRUL
4
5
5
&DVWHOOL
3
4
5
*XDULQL
4
6
3
6DVVL
3
3
5
&DVWHOYHWUR
3
3
5
*XDUQLHUL
6
5
3
6FRWWL
5
3
4
&DWWDQL
3
4
5
/DFLRVL
5
3
3
6HJKL]]L
3
4
6
&DYD]]D
3
3
6
/DGHUFKL
3
4
5
6RJDUL
3
5
3
&DYHGRQL
5
3
3
/DUGL
5
3
3
6RPHQ]D
3
4
5
&HVLV
3
3
5
/DYH]]ROL
4
5
3
6RVHQD
3
5
3
9<;
*XLGR *XHU]RQL
&HVWDUHOOL
6
3
3
/HYL]]DQL
3
3
6
6WUR]]L
8
3
3
&RFFDSDQL
3
5
6
0DFFKLDYHOOL
5
4
3
7DVVRQL
;
<
8
&RGHEXH
3
3
7
0DJQDQLPL
5
4
3
7KLHQH
8
6
5
&RQHJUDQL
4
5
3
0DODVSLQD
3
7
;
7RPEHVL
5
5
3
&RUWHVL
5
3
3
0DODWHVWD
4
6
3
7RUUL
3
3
5
&RUWLOL
5
4
3
0DQGLQL
3
3
5
7RUULFHOOL
3
3
5
&RVWDELOL
<
3
3
0DQIUHGL
5
5
7
7URWWL
49
;
4
'D &DVWHOOR
6
3
3
0DUHVFRWWL
3
5
3
7XUFKL
8
7
3
'D &RUUHJJLR
6
3
3
0DVHWWL
3
4
5
9DOHQWLQL
5
3
3
'D &UHPD
5
3
3
0LURJOLR
3
7
3
9DUDQR
6
3
3
'DL %DQFKL
5
3
3
0RO]D
3
5
;
9H]]DOL
3
3
5
'DL &DUUL
5
3
3
0RQWHFDWLQL
4
6
3
9LVGRPLQL
4
5
3
'DO 3R]]R
5
3
3
0RQWHFXFFROL
6
7
7
=REHOL
5
4
3
'DO 6DOH
6
3
3
0RQWLQL
4
7
5
)RQWH= GDWD0VHW *XHU]RQL1 /HJHQGD= QHOOD FRORQQD 47:408< q LQGLFDWD OD VRPPD GL TXDQWL VHUYL0 URQR QHO JUXSSR GHL VLJQRUL/ JHQWLOXRPLQL/ FDPHULHUL/ VFDOFKL/ VFXGLHUL/ PHGLFL/ VHJUHWDUL/ PDH0 VWUL GL JXDUGDURED/ VWDOOD H FDFFH/ RUDWRUL/ FRQVLJOLHUL H IDWWRUL JHQHUDOL VRWWR L GXFKL (UFROH ,/ $OIRQVR , HG (UFROH ,,/ LQ TXHOOD $5 TXHOOL FKH VHUYLURQR VRWWR $OIRQVR ,,/ LQ TXHOOD &( TXHO0 OL FKH VHUYLURQR VRWWR &HVDUH1
5LVXOWD HYLGHQWH LO ULSRVL]LRQDPHQWR LQ VHQVR ILORWHUULWRULDOH GHOOH pOLWHV GL FRUWH/ FKH GD XQD SDUWH DFFROVHUR QHOOH ORUR ILOD DOFXQL IHGHOL VHUYLWRUL IHUUDUH0 VL H YDUL FLWWDGLQL PRGHQHVL UHJJLDQL/ FDUSLJLDQL H JDUIDJQLQL GL IUHVFD QRELOLWD0 ]LRQH +%DUR]]L/ &DWWDQL/ &DYD]]D/ &RGHEXH/ 'XUDQWL/ 6DUWRUL/ 6DVVL/ 6HJKL]]L 7RUUL/ 7RUULFHOOL R 9H]]DOL,/ GDOO·DOWUD UHJLVWUDURQR LO OHQWR PD FRVWDQWH ULDYYL0 FLQDPHQWR GHL SULQFLSDOL IHXGDWDUL GHO GXFDWR/ FRPH VL SXy HYLQFHUH GDL FDVL GHL /HYL]]DQL/ GHL 0DODVSLQD R GHL 0RO]D/ PHQWUH VFRPSDUYHUR SHU VHPSUH L QRPL GL WDQWH LOOXVWUL FDVDWH IHUUDUHVL/ JLi PHVVH D GXUD SURYD GDL YROHUL DOIRQ0 VLQL1
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
9<<
$/%(572 0(1=,$1,
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
1HO JHQQDLR GHO 48<; OH &RQYHQ]LRQL IDHQWLQH GHILQLURQR/ D WXWWR VYDQ0 WDJJLR GHO GXFD &HVDUH/ LO FRQWHQ]LRVR LQVRUWR IUD OD &KLHVD H O·(VWHQVH SHU OD VXFFHVVLRQH QHO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD/ SRQHQGR FRVu OH FRQGL]LRQL SHU LO WUDVIHUL0 PHQWR GHOOD &DSLWDOH D 0RGHQD1 )UD L GLYHUVL SXQWL GHOO·DFFRUGR/ XQR ULJXDU0 GDYD VSHFLILFDPHQWH O·DPELWR PLOLWDUH/ H SL• SUHFLVDPHQWH OD VRUWH GHOOH DUWL0 JOLHULH XVFLWH GDOOH FHOHEUL RIILFLQH GL $OIRQVR ,/ (UFROH ,, H $OIRQVR ,,= D &H0 VDUH HUD GDWD IDFROWj GL SRUWDUQH XQD PHWj IXRUL GD )HUUDUD H GDJOL DOWUL OXRJKL GD DEEDQGRQDUH/ PHQWUH O·DOWUD PHWj GRYHYD HVVHUH FRQVHJQDWD DL GHOHJDWL SDSDOL1 1RQRVWDQWH OH 79 ERFFKH GD IXRFR SHUGXWH QHOO·RFFDVLRQH4/ DJOL LQL]L GHO SHULRGR PRGHQHVH GL FDVD G·(VWH O·DUWLJOLHULD GXFDOH FRQWDYD FLUFD FHQWRFLQ0 TXDQWD SH]]L GL GLYHUVR FDOLEUR IUD FDQQRQL/ PH]]L FDQQRQL/ FROXEULQH/ IDOFR0 QL/ IDOFRQHWWL/ VDJUL/ JLULIDOFKL HFF1/ GLVWULEXLWL QHOOH YDULH ORFDOLWj GHOOR 6WDWR51 1HO 4936 DOFXQL GL WDOL SH]]L IXURQR LPSLHJDWL FRQ VXFFHVVR FRQWUR LO IRUWLOL0 ]LR OXFFKHVH GL &DVWLJOLRQH GL *DUIDJQDQD DSUHQGR FRO ORUR IXRFR XQD YDVWD EUHFFLD QHOOH PXUD/ HG DOWUD EUHFFLD IX DSHUWD GDL FDQQRQL HVWHQVL QHO VXFFHV0 VLYR DVVHGLR GHO 4946/ DQFKH VH LQ HQWUDPEL L FDVL O·LQWHUYHQWR GHOOD GLSORPD0 ]LD VSDJQROD LPSHGu FKH &DVWLJOLRQH FDGHVVH LQ PDQR DL PRGHQHVL1 6XO ILQLUH GHO VHF1 ;9,,/ OH ERFFKH GD IXRFR VHUYLELOL SUHVHQWL ©QHOOH SLD]]H GHO 6WDWR GL 61$161ª6 HUDQR FRPSOHVVLYDPHQWH 494/ FRPSUHVL 8 PRUWDL H ; SH0 ²²²²²²²² 4
&IU1 &1 0217Õ/ 6WRULD GHOO*DUWLJOLHULD LWDOLDQD/ ,/ 5RPD/ 5LYLVWD G*$UWLJOLHULD H *HQLR/ 4<67/ S1:8:1 5 &IU1 LO GRF1 GHO 4935 ULSRUWDWR/ LELG1/ SS1:8:0:8<1 6 %49<4 $UWLJOLHULD FKH VL ULWURYD QHOOH SLD]]H GHO 6WDWR GL 61$161 FRQ OR DFFRPSDJQDPHQWR GHOOH VXH SDOOH D OXRFR SHU OXRFR%/ LQ $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ +G*RUD LQ SRL $602,/ 0LOLWDUH H0 VWHQVH/ E14751
:33
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
WULHUH FKH WLUDYDQR SDOOH LQ PDFLJQR1 3HU IDUH XQ UDIIURQWR/ VL VWLPD FKH OD PDJJLRUH SRWHQ]D GHOO·HSRFD/ FLRH· OD )UDQFLD GL /XLJL ;,9/ GLVSRQHVVH FRP0 SOHVVLYDPHQWH QHO SHULRGR GL FLUFD 461333 SH]]L7/ DQFKH VH RFFRUUH WHQHUH FRQWR GHO IDWWR FKH LQ TXHJOL DQQL WXWWH OH ULVRUVH GHO UHJQR HUDQR PRELOLWDWH D FDXVD GHOOD JXHUUD GHOOD /HJD GL $XJXVWD +49;;049<:,1 ,O SDUFR G·DUWLJOLHULD GHO 'XFDWR VL HUD SHUDOWUR EHQ SRFR ULQQRYDWR QHO WHPSR/ FRPH WHVWLPRQLD O·©,QYHQWDULR *HQHUDOH +111, GH· 3H]]L +111, FKH VRQR QH· 0DJD]HQL H VRYUD LO 5DPSDUR GHOOD &LWWj/ H &LWWDGHOOD GL 0RGHQDª FRPSL0 ODWR LO 8 DJR1 4:67 0 YDOH D GLUH XQD TXLQGLFLQD GL JLRUQL GRSR O·RFFXSD]LRQH GHOOD &DSLWDOH GD SDUWH GHL JDOOR0VDUGL QHO FRUVR GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH SRODFFD0/ DOOD SUHVHQ]D GHO &RPPLVVDULR /D %LQRQ/ GHO &RUSV 5R\DO G·$UWLOOHULH/ GL 'RPHQLFR &RUUDGL/ &RPPLVVDULR JHQHUDOH GHOO·DUWLJOLHULD HVWHQVH/ H GHO PXQL]LRQLHUH )UDQFHVFR 0DLQDUGL81 )UD OH 7: ERFFKH GD IXRFR LQ EURQ]R JLXGLFDWH XWLOL]]DELOL GL FXL LO GRFXPHQWR IRUQLVFH HOHPHQWL LGRQHL DG LQGLYL0 GXDUH O·HSRFD GL IDEEULFD]LRQH/ EHQ 54 +FLRH· TXDVL OD PHWj, ULVXOWDQR LQIDWWL GHO ¶833/ 4; GHO ¶933 H VROR ; GHO ¶:33> OH SL• DQWLFKH +WUH/ GD XQD OLEEUD H PH]]R, ULVDOJRQR DO 4873/ PHQWUH LO SH]]R SL• UHFHQWH H· GHO 4:4;91 1RQ H· SHUDOWUR GD ULWHQHUH FKH LO PDQWHQLPHQWR LQ VHUYL]LR GL DUWLJOLHULH YHFFKLH DQ0 FKH GL VHFROL IRVVH XQD SHFXOLDULWj GHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD= DOOD FDGXWD GHO JR0 YHUQR IDUQHVLDQR/ DG HVHPSLR/ L FDQQRQL FKH VL WURYDYDQR QHOOD FLWWDGHOOD GL 3DUPD HUDQR GL HWj FRPSUHVD IUD LO 4838 HG LO SULPR 6HWWHFHQWR/ PHQWUH O·HSRFD GL IDEEULFD]LRQH GL TXHOOL GHOOD FLWWDGHOOD GL 3LDFHQ]D DQGDYD GDO 4854 DO 4:36:1 8QR GHL SH]]L SUHVL GD *XJOLHOPR ,,, G·2UDQJH D 1DPXU/ WROWD DL IUDQFHVL QHO 49<8/ UHFDYD GHO UHVWR LO PRQRJUDPPD GL (QULFR ,9 GL %RUERQH +48<704943,;1 3HU DOFXQH GHOOH ERFFKH GD IXRFR HOHQFDWH O·LQYHQWDULR GHO 4:67 ULSRUWD LO QRPH GHO IRQGLWRUH/ DSSRVWR VXOOD IDVFLD GHOOD FXODWWD1 , SH]]L FLQTXHFHQWH0 ²²²²²²²² 7
&IU1 '1 &+$1'/(5/ 7KH $UW RI :DUIDUH LQ WKH $JH RI 0DUOERURXJK/ 6WDSOHKXUVW/ 6SHO0 OPRXQW/ 4<<7/ ,,/ S147;1 8 /*LQYHQWDULR/ UHGDWWR LQ IUDQFHVH H LQ LWDOLDQR/ q FRQVHUYDWR LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E14751 9 /*LQYHQWDULR HOHQFD DOWUL 46 SH]]L VHUYLELOL LQ EURQ]R GL HWj LPSUHFLVDWD/ 5 SH]]L LQ EURQ0 ]R LQXWLOL SHUFKq FUHSDWL H 6 FDQQRQL GL IHUUR ODYRUDWR1 3HU LQGLFDUH LO FDOLEUR GHOOH ERFFKH GD IXRFR VL IDFHYD RUGLQDULDPHQWH ULIHULPHQWR DO SHVR GHOOD SDOOD1 : &IU1 01 =$1121,/ /*HVHUFLWR IDUQHVLDQR GDO 49<7 DO 4:64/ 3DUPD/ 3DODWLQD (GLWULFH/ 4<;4/ SS1 44504461 &RPH QRWR/ O*XOWLPR GXFD GL 3DUPD GL FDVD )DUQHVH/ $QWRQLR/ PRUu QHO JHQQDLR GHO 4:641 ; &IU1 '1 &+$1'/(5/ 7KH $UW 111 FLW1/ S14::1
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:34
VFKL ´ILUPDWLµ ULVXOWDQR WXWWL RSHUD GHO SL• IDPRVR DUWHILFH GHOOH RIILFLQH IHU0 UDUHVL/ LO WUHQWLQR $QQLEDOH %RUJRJQRQL/ PHQR XQR GHO 48;3/ JHWWDWR GDOOR VYL]]HUR *LRYDQQL /DPSUHFKW/ FKH LO /RFDWHOOL ULWLHQH HVVHUH VXFFHGXWR DO %RUJRJQRQL QHOOD GLUH]LRQH GHOOD IDEEULFD GXFDOH GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH<1 , QRPL GL $QFKLVH ´GH &HQVRULEXVµ H GL (UFROH &DOHIIL GD &DUSL FRPSDLRQR LQYHFH VX DOFXQL SH]]L ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH GHOO·HSRFD GL )UDQFHVFR , H GHJOL XOWLPL DQQL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ PHQWUH TXHOOL GHO PRGHQHVH 3HGUHWWL H GL ´-RDQQHV GH 0D]]DUROLVµ ILJXUDQR VX FDQQRQL H PRUWDL GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR1 /H GHVFUL]LRQL GHOO·LQYHQWDULR GDQQR DOWUHVu FRQWR GHOOH ILJXUH H GHL PRWWL FKH WDORUD DGRUQDYDQR OH DUWLJOLHULH= SHU TXHOOH IXVH VRWWR 5LQDOGR/ DG HVHP0 SLR/ VL WUDWWD WDOYROWD GL XQD )DPD DFFRPSDJQDWD GDOO·LVFUL]LRQH ©1HF IDFHUH QHF SDWL LQMXULDVª/ WDODOWUD GL XQ·DTXLOD FRQ IXOPLQL WUD JOL DUWLJOL H OD VFULWWD ©+LV MXUD WXHQWXUª/ HFF1 8Q QRWHYROH DPPRGHUQDPHQWR GHO PDWHULDOH G·DUWLJOLHULD VL HEEH D PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ D VHJXLWR GHOOD IXVLRQH GL PROWL QXRYL SH]]L H GHOOD VWDQGDU0 GL]]D]LRQH GHL FDOLEUL GHULYDQWH GDOO·DGR]LRQH GHO VLVWHPD 9DOOLqUH1 ,QWURGRWWR LQ )UDQFLD GDOO·2UGRQQDQFH GHO : RWW1 4:65/ LO VLVWHPD LGHDWR GD -HDQ0)ORUHQW GH 9DOOLqUH +499:04:8<, SUHYHGHYD FRPH QRWR FLQTXH VROL FDOLEUL/ GD 7/ ;/ 45/ 49 H 57 OLEEUH1 7UD LO 4:84 H LO 4:86 IXURQR LQ HIIHWWL IDWWL IRQGHUH GD )UDQFHVFR ,,, 53 SH]]L GD 57 +FLDVFXQR GHL TXDOL ULFHYHWWH LO QRPH GL XQ SHUVRQDJJLR GL FDVD G·(VWH,/ 4< SH]]L GD 49 +FKLDPDWL FRQ QRPL GL LPSHUDWRUL URPDQL,/ ; SH]]L GD 45 +GLVWLQWL FRO QRPH GL VDQWL,/ : SH]]L GD ; +FXL IXURQR GDWL QRPL GL FLWWj,/ 4; SH]]L GD 7 +GHQRPLQDWL /D 3DQWHUD/ ,O )DOFR/ /·8QLFRUQR/ ,O /HRQH HFF1,/ H FRVu LQ WRWDOH :5 SH]]L431 )LQ TXDVL DOOD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR DO VHUYL]LR GHOOH ERFFKH GD IXRFR GXFDOL SURYYHGHYDQR L %RPEDUGLHUL1 'L HVVL VROR SRFKL HUDQR D VROGR= DL SULPL GHO 4:6;/ DG HVHPSLR/ L ERPEDUGLHUL VWLSHQGLDWL HUDQR LQ WXWWR DSSHQD 43/ GLVWUL0 EXLWL IUD OD FLWWDGHOOD GL 0RGHQD/ %UHVFHOOR/ 6HVWROD H OD IRUWH]]D JDUIDJQLQD GL 0RQWH $OIRQVR441 ,O ULPDQHQWH HUD FRVWLWXLWR GD YRORQWDUL/ FLRH· GD LQGLYLGXL FKH HVHUFLWDYDQR DOWUH SURIHVVLRQL +GL IDOHJQDPH/ IDEEUR/ PXUDWRUH/ WDJOLDSLH0 ²²²²²²²² <
&IU1 )1 /2&$7(//,/ /D IDEEULFD GXFDOH HVWHQVH GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH/ %RORJQD/ &DSSHOOL/ 4<;8/ SS1:4 H VHJXHQWL1 43 &IU1 &1 0217Õ/ 6WRULD GHOO*DUWLJOLHULD111 FLW1/ ,,/ 4<68/ SS14468044691 44 &IU1 XQD UHOD]LRQH QRQ ILUPDWD LQGLUL]]DWD DO GXFD LO 7 JHQ1 4:6; LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH H0 VWHQVH/ E1<;1 ,O GRFXPHQWR q TXDVL LQWHJUDOPHQWH ULSURGRWWR LQ &1 0217Õ/ 6WRULD GHOO*DUWLJOLH0 ULD111 FLW1/ ,,/ SS1445<044651
:35
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
WUD H VLPLOL/ VHFRQGR L &DSLWROL GHL %RPEDUGLHUL GHO 4993,/ L TXDOL VL IDFHYDQR UHJLVWUDUH QHL UXROL SHU VHUYLUH TXDQGR YH QH IRVVH ELVRJQR/ DOOHWWDWL GD GH0 WHUPLQDWL SULYLOHJL1 , &DSLWROL GHO 4993 VWDELOLYDQR DG HVHPSLR DO ULJXDUGR FKH OD FRJQL]LRQH GHOOH FDXVH FLYLOL GL FXL IRVVHUR SDUWH L ERPEDUGLHUL/ FRPH DQ0 FKH GL TXHOOH FULPLQDOL SHU IDWWL FRPPHVVL LQ VHUYL]LR/ VSHWWDVVH DO *HQHUDOH GHOO·DUWLJOLHULD> DWWULEXLYDQR D FDSLERPEDUGLHUL H ERPEDUGLHUL OD SRVVLELOLWj GL SRUWDUH %111SHU WXWWR JOL 6WDWL GL 61$161 PHGLDWL H LPPHGLDWL LQ &DPSDJQD O·$UFKLEXJLR OXQJR/ H FRUWR GL PLVXUD/ H QHOOH &LWWj/ 7HUUH/ )RUWH]]H/ H OXRJKL PXUDWL ILQR DOO·DOORJJLR/ VHQ]D IHUPDU0 VL/ H WLUDUH FRQ TXHOOL QHOOH &DPSDJQH QRQ ULVHUXDWH DG XFFHOOL QRQ SURLELWL 111%451
4XDQWR DO QXPHUR GHL ERPEDUGLHUL/ QHO 498: LQ WXWWR OR 6WDWR VH QH FRQ0 WDYDQR 58< HVFOXVL JOL XIILFLDOL/ SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOH FRPSD0 JQLH GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ %UHVFHOOR H &DUSL/ PD SUHVHQWL DQFKH D &RUUHJJLR/ 5XELHUD/ 0RQWH $OIRQVR/ 6HVWROD H DOOH 9HUUXFROH461 3RFKL DQQL GRSR/ VRWWR $OIRQVR ,9/ L ERPEDUGLHUL HUDQR 864/ VXGGLYLVL WUD OH PHGHVLPH ORFDOLWj1 6XF0 FHVVLYDPHQWH OH FRPSDJQLH GHL %RPEDUGLHUL IXURQR SHU TXDOFKH WHPSR DER0 OLWH/ PD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD ©YHQXWD GHOOL $OHPDQL D TXDUW1H LQ T1WL 6WDWLª/ GX0 UDQWH OD JXHUUD GHOOD /HJD GL $XJXVWD/ LO &RPPLVVDULR GHO FDQQRQH %HUQDUGL0 QR &RUUDGL ULFHYHWWH LQFDULFR GD )UDQFHVFR ,, GL ULFRVWLWXLUOH ©HW GL SULQFLSLDUH D GDUOL VFXRODª1 $O 64 DJR1 49<9 OD FRPSDJQLD GL 0RGHQD FRPSUHQGHYD FRVu 483 ERPEDUGLHUL QRQFKH· XQD VTXDGUD GL 64 JUDQDWLHUL/ ©TXDOL VHUYRQR DOOR VEDUR DQFRUD GH 0RUWDULª/ H LQROWUH 7 IXFLOLHUL1 'D 45< H 43; ERPEDUGLHUL H0 UDQR SRL ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH FRVWLWXLWH OH FRPSDJQLH GL 5HJJLR H GL &DUSL/ GHVWL0 QDWH DQFKH D IRUQLUH SHUVRQDOH SHU LO VHUYL]LR GHL SH]]L GL %UHVFHOOR/ OD FXL FRPSDJQLD DYHYD XQ RUJDQLFR GL FLQTXDQWD XRPLQL1 &RQ TXHOOL GL 5XELHUD/ &RUUHJJLR/ 6HVWROD/ 0RQWH $OIRQVR H 9HUUXFROH Y·HUDQR DOO·HSRFD FRPSOHVVL0 YDPHQWH ROWUH 883 ERPEDUGLHUL471 $L SULPL GHO 4:6;48 VL FRQWDYDQR LQYHFH 77: WUD ERPEDUGLHUL H FDSRUDOL/ GL FXL XQD WUHQWLQD DOOD 0LUDQGROD +GD TXDOFKH ²²²²²²²² 45
&DSLWROL GHL %RPEDUGLHUL GHO 57 IHE1 4993/ FRPH WUDVFULWWL LQ &1 0217Õ/ 6WRULD GHOO*DUWL0 JOLHULD111 FLW1/ ,/ SS1:9;0::41 46 &IU1 ,ELG1/ ,/ SS1:990:9:1 47 &IU1 SHU WDOL GDWL/ H SHU TXHOOL UHODWLYL DL ERPEDUGLHUL DOO*HSRFD GL $OIRQVR ,9/ TXDQWR DO0 OHJDWR DG XQD OHWWHUD GL %HUQDUGLQR &RUUDGL DO GXFD GHO 64 DJR1 49<9 +$602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1475,/ GDOOD TXDOH VRQR SXUH WUDWWH OH FLWD]LRQL QHO WHVWR1 48 &IU1 OD UHOD]LRQH FLW1 DOOD QRWD 441
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:36
WHPSR DJJUHJDWD DJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL,/ PHQWUH D %UHVFHOOR QRQ Y·HUDQR FKH 5 VROL ERPEDUGLHUL/ HVVHQGR VWDWD TXHOOD IRUWH]]D GHPROLWD QHO FRUVR GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD1 3RFKL DQQL GRSR/ H SL• SUHFLVDPHQWH DOO·LQL]LR GHO 4:75/ LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,, ©IRUPR· XQ &RUSR GL &DQQRQLHUL FRPSRVWR GL 453 XRPLQL FRPSUHVRYL OL 8IILFLDOLª491 *OL DVVHGL GHOOD FLWWDGHOOD GL 0RGHQD H GL 0LUDQGROD/ DUUHVHVL DJOL DXVWUR0VDUGL ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH LO 5< JLXJQR H LO 55 OXJOLR GHO 4:75 GRSR XQ·RQRUHYROH UHVLVWHQ]D GXUDWD SL• JLRUQL/ YLGHUR L FDQQRQLHUL LQ SULPD OLQHD QHO VHUYL]LR GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH FKH GLIHQGHYDQR OH GXH SLD]]H1 8QR ©6WDWR GHJOL 8IIL]LDOL GL 61$1 6HU1PD +111, VRUWLWL GDOOH &LWWDGHOOH GL 0RGHQD/ H GHOOD 0LUDQ0 GRODª4: FRPSUHQGH LQ HIIHWWL DQFKH JOL ; XIILFLDOL H LO FDQFHOOLHUH GHO UHJJLPHQ0 WR G·$UWLJOLHULD/ GHO TXDOH HUD FRPDQGDQWH 'RPHQLFR &RUUDGL FRO JUDGR GL FRORQQHOOR1 ,QWRUQR DOOD PHWj GHO 4:9; LO UHJJLPHQWR/ DOO·HSRFD VRWWR JOL RUGL0 QL GHO FRO1 /XLJL 5HPDLOOH 'H &RORQJH/ DYHYD XQ RUJDQLFR GL 43; WHVWH/ FRQ XQR 6WDWR PDJJLRUH GL 7 XIILFLDOL H GXH FRPSDJQLH GL 85 XRPLQL O·XQD/ DIILGD0 WH DL FDSLWDQL 3RUWRFDUUHUR H 6FDUDEHOOL1 $OOD ULYLVWD SDVVDWD LO 57 PDJJLR GL TXHOO·DQQR/ LO JHQ1 LVSHWWRUH PDUFKHVH &RYDUUXYLDV WURYz LO UHSDUWR FRQ XQD IRU]D HIIHWWLYD GL 435 LQGLYLGXL H ©LQ XQR 6WDWR SDVVDELOHª ´ULJXDUGR DOOD TXDOL0 Wj GHJO·8RPLQLµ 4;1 $OPHQR ILQR DO 4::3 WURYLDPR DFFDQWR DJOL DUWLJOLHUL DQFRUD L %RPEDUGLH0 UL= LO 55 PDU]R GL TXHOO·DQQR/ DG HVHPSLR/ LO VHJUHWDULR )DEUL]L DXWRUL]]DYD/ SHU OD *LXQWD PLOLWDUH/ O·DFFHWWD]LRQH GL XQ LQGLYLGXR WUD L ERPEDUGLHUL GL 0RQWH $OIRQVR DO SRVWR GL DOWUR GHIXQWR/ EHQLQWHVR ©7URYDQGRVL LGRQHR/ H FDSDFH LO SURSRVWR VRVWLWXWRª4<1 ²²²²²²²²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j H FLWWDGHOOD GL 0RGHQD= WHQ1 FRO1 FRQWH 6FDUDEHOOL 3HGRFFD> DL GLSDUWLPHQWL GHO )ULJQDQR/ *DUIDJQDQD H 0DVVD ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH L FDSLWDQL )DEEUL/ &RVWD H 'HO 0HGLFR1 4< /D GHWHUPLQD]LRQH GHO )DEUL]L H* LQ FDOFH D XQ UDSSRUWR DOOD *LXQWD PLOLWDUH GHO &RP0 PLVVDULR JHQHUDOH GL JXHUUD FRQWH %RORJQHVL SXUH GHO 55 PDU1 4::3 +$602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E144;,1
:37
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
,O WXUELQH QDSROHRQLFR FKH WUDYROVH QHO 4:<9 OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH VSD]]R· YLD DQFKH OH VXH LVWLWX]LRQL DUWLJOLHUHVFKH H PLOLWDUL1 , QXRYL SDGURQL QRQ HVLWDUR0 QR QHSSXUH D GLVIDUVL GL TXHOOD FKH VHFRQGR LO /RFDWHOOL HUD VWDWD ©/D SL• FH0 OHEUH ERFFD GD IXRFR LWDOLDQD GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWRª53/ H FLRH· OD FROXEULQD ´5HJL0 QDµ/ FDSRODYRUR GL $QQLEDOH %RUJRJQRQL UHDOL]]DWR QHO 48891 1HOO·RWWREUH GHO 4:<: OD ´5HJLQDµ IX LQIDWWL YHQGXWD GD XQ FRPPLVVDULR IUDQFHVH D WDOL IUD0 WHOOL %RQWHPSHOOL GL 5RPD DO SUH]]R GL ©ILOLSSL QRYH RJQL FHQWR OLEEUHª541 5HVWDXUDWR QHO 4;47 LO JRYHUQR GXFDOH/ YHQQH SXUH ULFRVWLWXLWR LO &RUSR G·$UWLJOLHULD/ FKH HEEH SHUz SHU GLYHUVL DQQL GLPHQVLRQL HVLJXH= LO 5 IHE1 4;64/ DOOD YLJLOLD GHOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH GHO 0HQRWWL/ HVVR FRQWDYD LQ WXWWR DSSHQD 5 XIIL0 FLDOL H 55 WUD VRWWXIILFLDOL H VROGDWL551 'RSR OD ULYROX]LRQH OH IRU]H DUPDWH H0 VWHQVL YHQQHUR SHUDOWUR SURJUHVVLYDPHQWH SRWHQ]LDWH/ VLFFKH· DOOD ILQH GHO 4;74 LO &RUSR G·$UWLJOLHULD HUD RUPDL XQ RUJDQLVPR EHQ VYLOXSSDWR1 3RVWR VRWWR LO FRPDQGR GHO PDJJLRUH )UDQFHVFR %HFNHUKLQ/ HVVR HUD DUWLFRODWR LQ GXH FRPSDJQLH GL ;3 XRPLQL O·XQD1 'L TXHVWL 493 DUWLJOLHUL XQ FHQWLQDLR HUD0 QR GLVORFDWL D 0RGHQD/ RYH SURYYHGHYDQR DO VHUYL]LR GL XQD EDWWHULD GD FDP0 SDJQD HVHUFLWDQGRVL LQ DXWXQQR QHO WLUR DO EHUVDJOLR DOOD &DVLJOLD SUHVVR 6DV0 VXROR/ PHQWUH L UHVWDQWL HUDQR GL JXDUQLJLRQH D 0DVVD1 3HU LO WUDLQR GHL SH]]L GHOOD EDWWHULD GL 0RGHQD HVLVWHYD SRL XQ PH]]R VTXDGURQH FRVLGGHWWR ´GHO 7UHQRµ/ FRPDQGDWR GD XQ FDSLWDQR H IRUWH GL 59 XRPLQL FRQ 79 FDYDOOL> HVVR VL RFFXSDYD DQFKH GHO WUDVSRUWR GL SROYHUH/ PXQL]LRQL/ OHJQDPL HFF1 1HO 4;78 LO 7UHQR YHQQH DJJUHJDWR DOO·$UWLJOLHULD/ SXU FRQWLQXDQGR D ULPDQHUH XQ·HQWLWj GLVWLQWD GD TXHVW·XOWLPD1 6HPSUH D ILQH ¶74 LO FRPSLWR GL VHUYLUH L SH]]L FKH JXDUQLYDQR OD ULFRVWUXL0 WD SLD]]DIRUWH GL %UHVFHOOR HUD DIILGDWR DG XQD VSHFLDOH FRPSDJQLD ´GHOOH 7RU0 ULµ/ FKLDPDWD DQFKH FRPSDJQLD 3LRQLHUL 0LOLWL +434 LQGLYLGXL FRPSUHVR LO FD0 SLWDQR,1 2OWUH DG RFFXSDUVL GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH/ JOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD FRPSDJQLD VYROJHYDQR DQFKH ODYRUL GL IDOHJQDPHULD/ PXUDWXUD HFF1/ FKH FRVWLWXLYDQR DW0 WLYLWj SURSULH GHO &RUSR 3LRQLHUL/ HG HUDQR DOWUHVu DGGHVWUDWL D JHWWDUH VXO 3R LO SRQWH GL EDUFKH ´DOOD %LUDJRµ/ L FXL PDWHULDOL VL FXVWRGLYDQR DSSXQWR D %UH0 ²²²²²²²² 53
)1 /2&$7(//,/ /D IDEEULFD111 FLW1/ S1::1 0RGHQD QDSROHRQLFD QHOOD &URQDFD GL $QWRQLR 5RYDWWL1 /*$OEHUR GHOOD /LEHUWj 4:<904:<:/ D FX0 UD GL *131 %5,==,/ 0RGHQD/ )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<9/ S154;1 55 &IU1 OR ©6WDWR GLPRVWUDQWH OD IRU]D ILVVDWD GHL &RUSL DOO*HSRFD GHO 5 )HEEUDMR 4;64111ª1 ,O GRFXPHQWR/ GDWDWR 0RGHQD 9 IHE1 4;65/ WURYDVL LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ %ULJDWD HVWHQ0 VH/ ILO]D :71 54
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:38
VFHOOR561 1HO 4;75 OD FRPSDJQLD GHOOH 7RUUL IX SRL DQFK·HVVD SRVWD VRWWR LO FRPDQGR GHO %HFNHUKLQ/ DQFKH VH LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9 GLVSRVH FKH OD PHGH0 VLPD FRQWLQXDVVH D ULPDQHUH ©DIIDWWR VHSDUDWD GDOOH GXH G·$UWLJOLHULD FKH VRQR D 0RGHQD H D 0DVVDª/ SURLEHQGR GL FRQVHJXHQ]D ©©RJQL SDVVDJJLR GDOOH &RPSDJQLH VXGGHWWH D TXHOOD GL %UHVFHOOR/ H YLFHYHUVDª571 1HO PDU]R 4;7</ HOLPLQDWL 7UHQR H FRPSDJQLD GHOOH 7RUUL/ O·$UWLJOLHULD GXFDOH/ RUD VRWWR LO FRPDQGR GHO FRQWH *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *XHUUD/ YHQQH UL0 RUJDQL]]DWD VX WUH FRPSDJQLH/ GL FXL OD SULPD PRQWDWD H OH DOWUH D SLHGL1 1HO 4;84 O·RUJDQLFR GHO &RUSR FRPSUHQGHYD 684 XRPLQL/ GLYLVL WUD 6WDWR PDJ0 JLRUH/ 6WDWR PLQRUH/ , FRPSDJQLD +D 0RGHQD,/ ,, FRPSDJQLD +D %UHVFHOOR,/ ,,, FRPSDJQLD +D 0DVVD, H GHSRVLWR1 7DOH DVVHWWR ULPDVH LQ VHJXLWR LQYDULDWR/ QH· YL DSSRUWz PXWDPHQWR OD ULXQLRQH GL $UWLJOLHULD H 3LRQLHUL VRWWR XQ PHGHVL0 PR FRPDQGR +4;88,/ JLDFFKH· L GXH &RUSL ULPDVHUR GLVWLQWL/ PDQWHQHQGR FLD0 VFXQR OD SURSULD VWUXWWXUD1 4XDQWR DL PDWHULDOL/ QHJOL DQQL ¶83 O·DUWLJOLHULD HVWHQVH GD FDPSR FRP0 SUHQGHYD JOL ; SH]]L GHOOD ´EDWWHULD GL FDYDOOHULDµ GL 0RGHQD +7 FDQQRQL LQ EURQ]R H DOWUHWWDQWL RELFL FRUWL SXUH LQ EURQ]R/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH GD 9 H : OLE0 EUH DXVWULDFKH,/ 5 SLFFROL FDQQRQL GD PRQWDJQD LQ EURQ]R GD 7 OLEEUH IUDQFH0 VL GLVORFDWL D 0DVVD/ H DOFXQL DOWUL FDQQRQL/ RELFL H VSLQJDUGRQL1 1HL GLYHUVL IRUWL GHO 'XFDWR HUDQR SRL FXVWRGLWL XQ·RWWDQWLQD GL SH]]L ©GD 3LD]]D R GD 0DULQDª1 )UD OH SLD]]HIRUWL GHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH PHULWD GL HVVHUH ULFRUGDWD SHU SULPD TXHOOD GL %UHVFHOOR/ GRYH VLQ GDOOD PHWj GHO ¶833 O·LQJHJQHUH GXFDOH 7HU]R 7HU]L DYHYD HUHWWR XQD FLQWD EDVWLRQDWD SHQWDJRQDOH/ JXDUQLWD QHO 4935 GD 58 SH]]L G·DUWLJOLHULD1 1HJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHO VHFROR &ODXGLR 5LFFL VHJQDODYD SHUDO0 WUR D 5LQDOGR ,/ GLYHQXWR GXFD GD SRFKL PHVL/ FKH OD SLD]]DIRUWH HUD ©PROWR PDO DSSDUHFKLDWD SHU OD GLIHVDª/ GHQXQFLDQGR OH SHVVLPH FRQGL]LRQL LQ FXL YHUVDYDQR VLD LO SUHVLGLR FKH OH DUWLJOLHULH EUHVFHOOHVL1 ©111OL VROGDWLª VFULYHYD LO 5LFFL ©VWDQQR PDOLVVLPR GL 3DOOLRQL/ H FRSHUWH D VHJQR WDOH FKH VWDQQR PHJOLR LQ VHQWLQHOOD FKH D GRUPLUH/ GHOOL &DSRWWL SHU OL 6ROGDWL FKH YDQR LQ VHQWLQHOOD/ H GL 5RQGD/ H &RQWUD 5RQGD QRQ VH QH WURYD ²²²²²²²² 56
3HU TXDQWR HVSRVWR FLUFD $UWLJOLHULD/ 7UHQR H FRPSDJQLD GHOOH 7RUUL YHGDVL )UDQFHVFR G*$XVWULD0(VWH/ 2UJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOH WUXSSH HVWHQVL/ PDQRVFULWWR DXWRJUDIR GDWDWR 0RGHQD 45 JHQ1 4;75 LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH GL 9LHQQD/ SDUWH 9,/ ILO]D 451 57 'HFUHWR VRYUDQR GHOO*44 PDJ1 4;75 WUDVFULWWR LQ XQD OHWWHUD LQGLUL]]DWD LO 45 GDO 6XSUH0 PR FRPDQGR JHQHUDOH/ G*RUD LQ SRL 61F1J1 DOO*(FRQRPDWR PLOLWDUH1 $602/ 0LOLWDUH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ 5DJLRQHULD GHOO*$]LHQGD PLOLWDUH/ ILO]D 441
:39
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
XQRª581 4XDQWR DL SH]]L/ GHL GLFLRWWR WUD FDQQRQL/ IDOFRQL/ IDOFRQHWWL/ DVSLGL H VDJUL FKH VL WURYDYDQR VXL FLQTXH EDOXDUGL GL 61 )UDQFHVFR/ 61 5RFFR/ 61 *HQHVLR/ 61 0DULD H GHOOD 5RFFD/ VROR GXH HUDQR LQ RUGLQH/ PHQWUH WXWWL JOL DOWUL DYHYD0 QR JOL DIIXVWL URWWL/ JLDFHYDQR D WHUUD/ HFF1591 ,O GXFD SUHVH HYLGHQWHPHQWH JOL RSSRUWXQL SURYYHGLPHQWL/ SHUFKH· DO GL0 YDPSDUH LQ ,WDOLD GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD OD IRUWH]]D GL %UHVFHOOR HUD ©EHQ SUHVLGLDWD H PXQLWDª/ LO FKH QRQ HYLWz SHUDOWUR D 5LQDOGR GL GRYHUOD FHGHUH DJOL LPSHULDOL LO 8 JHQ1 4:351 $L FHVDUHL OD WROVHUR SRL L IUDQFR0VSDJQROL QHO OXJOLR GHO 4:36/ GRSR XQ DVVHGLR GXUDWR XQGLFL PHVL1 ,Q VHJXLWR /XLJL ;,9 RUGLQz OD GLVWUX]LRQH GHOOH IRUWLILFD]LRQL/ FKH YHQQH PDWHULDOPHQWH HVH0 JXLWD QHO 4:37 GD JXDVWDWRUL PHVVL D GLVSRVL]LRQH GDO GXFD GL 3DUPD/ SURQWR DG DSSURILWWDUH GHOO·RFFDVLRQH FKH JOL VL SUHVHQWDYD SHU HOLPLQDUH TXHOOD FKH SHU L )DUQHVH HUD VHPSUH VWDWD ©XQD SXQJHQWLVVLPD VSLQDª1 $QFKH GRSR OR VPDQWHOODPHQWR GHOOD SLD]]DIRUWH/ %UHVFHOOR FRQWLQXz WXW0 WDYLD D ULYHVWLUH XQD FHUWD LPSRUWDQ]D GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD PLOLWDUH/ HVVHQGR LYL SRVWD OD EDVH GHO QDYLJOLR FKH LO GXFD WHQHYD VXO 3R ©D ILQH GL ULVFXRWHUH L VXRL 'D]M VX TXHO )LXPHª5:1 6L WUDWWDYD/ QHO JHQQDLR GHO 49<85;/ GL XQ ©%HUJDQWLQR QXRYRª PXQLWR GL XQ FDQQRQH GD 9/ H GL XQD IHOXFD/ SXUH QXRYD1 3HU LO VHUYL0 ]LR GHOO·DUWLJOLHULD GHO ´%UHJDQWLQRµ Y·HUDQR DOO·LQL]LR GHO 4:6; D %UHVFHOOR 5 ERPEDUGLHUL VWLSHQGLDWL/ PHQWUH QHO 4:75 ULVXOWDQR DSSDUWHQHUH DOOR 6WDWR PDJJLRUH GHOOD SLD]]D 9 PDULQDL/ SL• DOWUL 9 DJJLXQWLYL LQ DSULOH5<1 8QD JDOHRWWD HUD LQILQH DJOL RUGLQL GHO FDS1 $XJLHU QHJOL DQQL ¶:3 GHO VHF1 ;9,,,1 1HO 4;68269 %UHVFHOOR YHQQH QXRYDPHQWH IRUWLILFDWD SHU RUGLQH GL )UDQ0 FHVFR ,91 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH/ IXURQR UHDOL]]DWH TXDWWUR WRUUL PDVVLPLOLDQH63/ GL0 ²²²²²²²² 58
/D OHWWHUD/ GDWDWD %UHVFHOOR 58 JHQ1 49<8/ H* FRQVHUYDWD LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E14751 &IU1 O*HOHQFR GHJOL ©DWWUHFFL PLOLWDULª SUHVHQWL QHOOD ©'XFDO 0XQLWLRQHª GL %UHVFHOOR/ LQ GDWD 55 JHQ1 49<8 HG D ILUPD *LXOLR )UDQF1 %DFFKL/ DOOHJDWR DOOD OHWWHUD FLWDWD DOOD QRWD SUHFH0 GHQWH1 'D WDOH HOHQFR ULVXOWD FKH QHOOD IRUWH]]D VL WURYDYDQR XQD TXDUDQWLQD G*DOWUL SH]]L/ DO0 FXQL GHL TXDOL FROORFDWL ©VRSUD OD 0XUDJOLDª/ 73 VSLQJDUGH H XQD QRWHYROH TXDQWLWj GL PR0 VFKHWWL/ SLFFKH/ SDUWLJLDQH/ EUDQGLVWRFFKL/ DUPDWXUH/ ERPEH/ SDOOH GD FDQQRQH/ HFF1 9*HUDQR LQROWUH 5;<9 ©*UDQDWH GL WHUUD FRWWDª GD ODQFLDUH D PDQR1 5: /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOH DQWLFKLWj HVWHQVL/ ,,/ LQ 0RGHQD/ QHOOD VWDPSHULD GXFDOH/ 4:73/ S18<31 5; &IU1 O*HOHQFR GHO 55 JHQ1 49<8 GL FXL DOOD QRWD 591 5< &IU1 OD ©&RSLD GDO 3LDQR *HQHUDOH GHO 0LOLWDUH 4:75ª/ LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1;<1 63 /H WRUUL PDVVLPLOLDQH GHULYDYDQR LO ORUR QRPH GDOO*DUFLGXFD 0DVVLPLOLDQR G*$XVWULD0 59
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:3:
VSRVWH LQWRUQR DOOD FLWWDGLQD HG LQWLWRODWH DL VDQWL )UDQFHVFR/ )HUGLQDQGR/ 0DVVLPLOLDQR H &DUOR1 &LDVFXQD WRUUH HUD DUPDWD GL FLQTXH JURVVL FDQQRQL LQ IHUUR GD 4; OLEEUH DXVWULDFKH H GL DOWUHWWDQWL RELFL GD : OLEEUH1 $ FRPSOHWDPHQWR GHOOH GLIHVH GHOOD SLD]]DIRUWH QHO 4;74 YHQQHUR FRVWUXLWH GXH EDWWHULH G·DUJLQH/ FLDVFXQD PXQLWD GL GXH FDQQRQL1 ,Q WHPSR GL JXHUUD IUD OH YDULH RSHUH IRUWLILFDWH YHQL0 YD VWHVD XQD OLQHD GL SDOL]]DWH1 3URSULR D %UHVFHOOR VL DVVHUDJOLDURQR QHO PDU0 ]R GHO 4;7< LO GXFD H O·HVHUFLWR GRSR OD GHQXQFLD GHOO·DUPLVWL]LR 6DODVFR GD SDUWH GHO 3LHPRQWH/ HG DOWUHWWDQWR DYUHEEH LQWHVR IDUH )UDQFHVFR 9 GLHFL DQQL GRSR VH LO SUHFLSLWDUH GHJOL DYYHQLPHQWL QRQ JOLHOR DYHVVH LPSHGLWR1 $OWUD LPSRUWDQWH SLD]]D GD JXHUUD HUD 0RGHQD/ RYH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR H QHOO·2WWRFHQWR HUD DFTXDUWLHUDWD OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHOO·HVHUFLWR GXFDOH1 2OWUH FKH GDOOH PXUD/ OD &DSLWDOH HUD GLIHVD GD XQD IRUWH FLWWDGHOOD SHQWDJRQDOH/ H0 UHWWD QHO 4968 VX SURJHWWR GL &DUOR &DVWHOODPRQWH1 1HOO·DSULOH GHO 4:35 OD JXDUQLYDQR 4< SH]]L GL JURVVR FDOLEUR/ 46 GL SLFFROR FDOLEUR H XQ PRUWDLR LQ EURQ]R GD 473/ PHQWUH QHOO·DUVHQDOH H IRQGHULD GHOOD FLWWD· VL WURYDYDQR DOWUH 64 ERFFKH GD IXRFR641 6RWWR (UFROH ,,, XQR GHL EDVWLRQL GHOOD FLWWDGHOOD/ H SLX· SUHFLVDPHQWH TXHOOR SURVSLFLHQWH OD FLWWj/ YHQQH GHPROLWR> DO VXR SRVWR QHO 4;65 LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9 IHFH LQQDO]DUH XQD WRUUH IRUWLILFDWD R ´GRQ0 JLRQHµ/ DQFK·HVVD SHUz DEEDWWXWD QHO 4;7; GDO JRYHUQR ULYROX]LRQDULR1 )UDQ0 FHVFR 9 WHQHYD VXL EDVWLRQL ULPDVWL WUH FDQQRQL GD SLD]]D LQ IHUUR GD 451 $QFKH 5HJJLR HUD IRUWLILFDWD H VHGH GL JXDUQLJLRQH> QHO 4:75 OR 6WDWR PDJJLRUH GHOOD SLD]]D FRPSUHQGHYD/ ROWUH DO *RYHUQDWRUH GHOO·DUPL FRQWH $UFKLQWR/ XQ DLXWDQWH/ ©45 $UFLHUL SHO *RYHUQRª H TXDWWUR FDSLWDQL FXVWRGL GHOOH SRUWH GHOOD FLWWj651 /D FLWWDGHOOD/ RYH QHOOD SULPDYHUD GHO 4:35 VL WURYD0 YDQR 57 SH]]L G·DUWLJOLHULD VHUYLELOL/ IX SUHVVRFKp FRPSOHWDPHQWH VPDQWHOODWD QHO 4;7;1 1H SUHVH LO SRVWR LO IRUWH )HUGLQDQGR 9LWWRULR/ HUHWWR QHO 4;83 VXO EDOXDUGR GL 61 0DUFR H FRVu FKLDPDWR LQ PHPRULD GHO GHIXQWR IUDWHOOR GL )UDQFHVFR 9> LO VXR DUPDPHQWR HUD FRVWLWXLWR GD XQ PRUWDLR H TXDWWUR RELFL1 2OWUH FKH VXOOH SLD]]HIRUWL GL %UHVFHOOR/ 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ QHL VHFF1 ;9,, H ;9,,, LO 'XFDWR SRWHYD FRQWDUH SHU OD SURSULD GLIHVD DQFKH VXO ´VDVVRµ GL ²²²²²²²² (VWH/ IUDWHOOR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 HG LGHDWRUH GL TXHVWR WLSR GL IRUWLILFD]LRQL/ XWLOL]]DWR SHU OD SULPD YROWD D /LQ] QHO 4;641 64 &IU1 XQD OLVWD GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH HVLVWHQWL QHOOH GLYHUVH ORFDOLWj GHOOR 6WDWR LQ GDWD 4 DSU1 4:35 +$602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1475,/ GDOOD TXDOH VRQR WUDWWL DQFKH L GDWL SL• ROWUH ULSRUWDWL FRQFHUQHQWL OD FLWWDGHOOD GL 5HJJLR1 65 &IU1 LO GRF1 FLW1 DOOD QRWD 5<1
:3;
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
5XELHUD H VXL IRUWL GL PRQWDJQD GL 6HVWROD/ 9HUUXFROH H 0RQWH $OIRQVR/ SUHV0 VR &DVWHOQXRYR GL *DUIDJQDQD1 %RFFKH GD IXRFR VL WHQQHUR LQROWUH D OXQJR SXUH D &RUUHJJLR H D &DUSL/ ORFDOLWj FKH SHUVHUR SHUDOWUR FRO WHPSR 0DO SDUL GL 0LUDQGROD/ JLj FHOHEUH SHU OH VXH IRUWLILFD]LRQL0 RJQL LPSRUWDQ]D PLOLWDUH/ VHEEHQH DQFRUD D PHWj GHOO·2WWRFHQWR HVVH IRVVHUR VHGH GL FRPDQGL GL SLD]0 ]D1 $ VHJXLWR GHO PDWULPRQLR WUD LO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 0RGHQD (UFROH 5L0 QDOGR H 0DULD 7HUHVD &\ER GXFKHVVD GL 0DVVD +4:74,/ OH WUXSSH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, IXURQR FKLDPDWH D JXDUQLUH DQFKH OH IRUWH]]H GHO 0DVVHVH1 ,O FRO1 &HVDUH GHOOD 3DOXGH/ LQFDULFDWR GL SUHQGHUQH SRVVHVVR/ WURYz LQ TXHOOD GL $YHQ]D 0 GHVFULWWD SHU OD YHULWj FRPH ©XQ 7RUULRQH $QWLFR FKH QRQ SXz VHUYLUH DG DO0 WUR FKH SHU VFRSULUH GD ORQWDQR L %DVWLPHQWL/ R TXDOFKH WUXSSD FKH VFRUUHVVH OH YLFLQH FDPSDJQHª 0 66 FDQQRQL VPRQWDWL/ ©YDULH VSLQJDUGH SDULPHQWL VPRQWDWH/ HG XQD TXDQWLWj GL 0RVFKHWWL QRQ VHUYLELOLª/ PHQWUH QHO FDVWHOOR GL 0DVVD/ ©FDGHQWH GD WXWWH OH SDUWL HG LQ VWDWR GL SRFD GLIHVDª/ QRQ Y·HUDQR FKH TXDOFKH FDQQRQH GL IHUUR H SRFKH SDOOH661 &RPXQTXH/ DQFRUD VRWWR )UDQFH0 VFR 9 LO IRUWH GL 0DVVD HUD XWLOL]]DWR D VFRSL PLOLWDUL H PXQLWR GL DOFXQL SH]]L GL DUWLJOLHULD/ PHQWUH DG $YHQ]D Y·HUD XQD EDWWHULD FRVWLHUD1 2OWUH FKH GD TXHVW·XOWLPD/ LQ HSRFD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH OD GLIHVD GHO OLWRUDOH WLU0 UHQLFR HUD DVVLFXUDWD GD XQD VHFRQGD EDWWHULD SUHVVR OR VFDOR GL 6DQ *LXVHSSH H GDL IRUWLQL GHQRPLQDWL 0DULD %HDWULFH/ 61 )UDQFHVFR H 6SHUDQ]D/ IDWWL FR0 VWUXLUH GD )UDQFHVFR ,9> QHO 4;7: SDVVz LQROWUH VRWWR LO FRQWUROOR PRGHQHVH DQFKH LO IRUWH JLj WRVFDQR GHO &LQTXDOH1 /D FRVWD HUD DOWUHVu YLJLODWD/ DOPHQR QHJOL DQQL ¶63 H ¶73 GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ GD GXH ODQFH/ FLDVFXQD DUPDWD FRQ XQ SLFFROR FDQQRQH LQ IHUUR GD 5671 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD IDQWHULD H FDYDOOHULD/ QHO 6HLFHQWR L GXFKL DYHYDQR D GLVSRVL]LRQH DQ]LWXWWR XQD PDVVD GL PLOL]LRWWL D SLHGL H D FDYDOOR UHFOXWDWL HG RUJDQL]]DWL VX EDVH WHUULWRULDOH/ L TXDOL SHUDOWUR/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWL 0SHU XVDUH OD WHUPLQRORJLD GHOO·HSRFD0 ´GHVFULWWLµ QHL UXROL/ UHVWDYDQR DOOH ORUR FDVH SUH0 VWDQGR VHUYL]LR VROR TXDQGR QHFHVVDULR/ FRQ O·REEOLJR WXWWDYLD GL SUHVHQWDUVL ²²²²²²²² 66
/D UHOD]LRQH GHO FRO1 GHOOD 3DOXGH D )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ GDWDWD 0DVVD 4; DSU1 4:74/ H* FRQ0 VHUYDWD LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1<;1 67 $OWUH RSHUH IRUWLILFDWH UHDOL]]DWH QHOO*2WWRFHQWR IXURQR LO IRUWLQR GHOOD 6SDUDYDOOH/ D FRQWUROOR GHOOD VWUDGD PLOLWDUH GHO &HUUHWR/ H TXHOOL GHO %HUQLQR H GHOOD &KLXVD/ D VEDUUDPHQWR GHOOD VWUDGD GHOOH /DPH LQ YDO GL 0DJUD1
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:3<
SHULRGLFDPHQWH DOOH UDVVHJQH H DOO·DGGHVWUDPHQWR1 , &DSLWROL/ ) 2UGLQL GHO GXFD $OIRQVR ,, 6RSUD OD 0LOL]LD/ ) 2UGLQDQ]D GHOOR 6WDWR VXR/ HPDQDWL D )HUUD0 UD LO 59 JHQ1 48<9/ VWDELOLYDQR LQ SDUWLFRODUH FKH SHU OH FRPSDJQLH D SLHGL YL IRVVH XQD ´0RVWUDµ JHQHUDOH XQD YROWD DOO·DQQR WHQXWD GDO FRORQQHOOR/ H WUH XOWHULRUL PRVWUH ´3DUWLFRODULµ1 5LJXDUGR DOO·DGGHVWUDPHQWR/ L SUHGHWWL &DSLWROL LPSRQHYDQR DL FDSRUDOL GL ©IDU WLUDU G·$UFKLEXJLR L 6ROGDWL XQD YROWD LO 0HVH/ LQ OXRJR FRPRGR SHU HVHUFLWDUJOL/ Vu FRPH DQFKH GL PRVWUDU ORUR FRPH VL WHQJD/ H SRUWL OD 3LFFDª1 $L VHQVL GHL PHGHVLPL &DSLWROL/ LQROWUH/ FRVWLWXLYD SUHFLVR REEOLJR GHL PLOL]LRWWL LO ©WHQHU OH ORU·$UPL QHWWH/ IRUELWH/ H EHQH DOO·RUGLQH/ ) DYHU SDOOH/ IRUPH/ FRUGD/ IXFLOH/ H SROYHUH DOPHQ GXH OLEUHª1 $ IURQWH GHJOL REEOLJKL ORUR LPSRVWL/ JOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD 0LOL]LD D SLHGL JRGH0 YDQR GL YDUL SULYLOHJL/ IUD L TXDOL LO SRUWR G·DUPL H O·HVHQ]LRQH ©GD WXWWH OH ID0 ]LRQL/ H JUDYH]]H SHUVRQDOL/ RUGLQDULH/ H VWUDRUGLQDULH/ FKH QH· ORU &RPXQL RF0 FRUUDQRª/ FRQ SRVVLELOLWj SHU XIILFLDOL/ VRWWXIILFLDOL/ H VROGDWL FKH DYHVVHUR ©R 0RVFKHWWRQL/ R &RUVDOHWWLª/ GL HVWHQGHUH WDOH HVHQ]LRQH DQFKH DG DOWUL LQGLYL0 GXL1 , &DSLWROL/ H 3ULYLOHJL 'HOOD 0LOL]LD D &DYDOOR GHO 6HUHQLVVLPR 6LJQRU 'XFD &HVDUH G·(VWH/ GHO 4944/ VWDELOLYDQR GDO FDQWR ORUR FKH SRWHVVHUR HVVHUH ´GHVFULWWLµ LQ WDOH 0LOL]LD/ DOOD TXDOH HUDQR HVWHVL ©WXWWL L SULYLOHJL/ ) LPPXQLWj/ FKH JRGRQR L 6ROGDWL/ ) 8IIL]LDOL GHOOD 0LOL]LD D SLHGLª/ FRORUR FKH DYHYDQR ©IDFXOWj R SURSULH/ R FRPPXQL FRQ JOL DELWDQWL LQVLHPH LQ XQD VWHVVD IDPLJOLD/ VXIILFLHQWL D VRVWHQHU WDO FDULFDª1 (QWUR WUH PHVL GDOO·LVFUL]LRQH QHL UXROL FRVWRUR GRYH0 YDQR SURYYHGHUVL %111GL EXRQL &DYDOOL/ GL &DVDFFD FRQIRUPH D TXHOOH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD +111, ) LQ ROWUH G·$UPL/ GL PRQL]LRQL/ GL SDQQL/ H G·DEELJOLDPHQWL FRQYHQLHQWL +111,/ WHQHQGR EHQH DOO·RUGLQH GHWWH FRVH/ SHU VHUYLUVHQH SURQWDPHQWH QH· VHUYL]M GL 6XD $OWH]]D111%1
2JQL SULPD GRPHQLFD GHO PHVH/ RYYHUR XQD YROWD RJQL GXH PHVL ©QHO WHPSR GHO PLHWHUH/ H GL EDWWHUH/ H GHO VHPLQDUH/ H QHO ULJRUH GHOO·,QYHUQRª/ HUD SUHVFULWWR FKH L OXRJRWHQHQWL WHQHVVHUR PRVWUD/ LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD TXDOH GR0 YHYD HVVHUH LQVHJQDWR DL PLOL]LRWWL ©LO PRGR GL IDU FDUDFROOL/ H GL FRPEDWWHUH LQ RJQL PRGR FRQYHQLHQWH DOOD TXDOLWj GHOOD 0LOL]LD ORURª1 2OWUH D FLz/ L OXRJRWH0 QHQWL HUDQR WHQXWL DG LVSH]LRQDUH VSHVVR L ORUR XRPLQL ©D VTXDGUD SHU VTXD0 GUD/ HVHUFLWDQGRJOL/ H PRVWUDQGRJOL DOOL VXRL &DSRUDOLª1 (VLVWHYDQR SXUH PLOL]LH XUEDQH= LQ EDVH DJOL VSHFLILFL &DSLWROL SXEEOLFDWL QHOOD &DSLWDOH O·44 H LO 45 JLXJQR 4958/ DG HVHPSLR/ QHL UXROL GHOOH FHQWXULH GHL &DSRULRQL GL 0RGHQD GRYHYDQR HVVHUH LQVHULWL DSSXQWR XQLFDPHQWH VRJ0
:43
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
JHWWL DELWDQWL LQ FLWWj/ FRQ HVFOXVLRQH SHUDOWUR GHJOL DSSDUWHQHQWL D GHWHUPLQD0 WH FDWHJRULH/ TXDOL L VHUYLWRUL/ JOL DUUXRODWL GDL &DSLWDQL GHOOH SRUWH/ JOL DVFULWWL DL %RPEDUGLHUL/ HFF168,1 ,Q FDVR GL JXHUUD/ LO QHUER GHOOD IDQWHULD H GHOOD FDYDOOHULD YHQLYD SHUDOWUR DG HVVHUH FRVWLWXLWR GD FRPSDJQLH H UHJJLPHQWL DVVROGDWL/ DUUXRODWL 0VHFRQGR OD SUDVVL GHOO·HSRFD0 GD TXHVWR R TXHOO·XIILFLDOH LQ HVHFX]LRQH GL VSHFLILFL DF0 FRUGL LQWHUYHQXWL FRQ JOL DJHQWL GXFDOL1 1HOO·DPELWR GHJOL DUPDPHQWL IDWWL GD )UDQFHVFR , DO WHPSR GHOOD SULPD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR/ DG HVHPSLR/ QHO OXJOLR GHO 4975 IX VWLSXODWD XQD FRQYHQ]LRQH SHU LO UHFOXWDPHQWR GD SDUWH GHOO·DOILHUH DOEDQHVH &DVD *LRQLPD GL XQD FRPSDJQLD GL 433 IDQWL GL TXHOOD QD]LRQH/ FRQ DUPDPHQWR SURFXUDWR GDO GXFD H SDJD GL 5; OLUH DO PHVH LQ PRQHWD GL 0RGH0 QD SHU RJQL VROGDWR/ ROWUH DG XQ SDLR GL VFDUSH RJQL GXH PHVL1 &RQ LO WHQHQWH ,SSROLWR 3HJRORWWL LO 56 OXJ1 4975 YHQQH SRL FRQFOXVR XQ DFFRUGR SHU O·DUUXRODPHQWR GL XQD FRPSDJQLD GL FDYDOOHULD GL 83 FRUD]]H/ GD DUPDUVL D FX0 UD GHOOR VWHVVR 3HJRORWWL H GD UHFOXWDUVL IXRUL GHO 'XFDWR/ VDOYD FRPXQTXH OD SRVVLELOLWj GL DUUXRODUH DQFKH ©VROGDWL YRORQWDUL VXGGLWL GL 61$1 +111, SXU FKH QRQ VLDQR REOLJDWL DG DOWUR VHUY1R GL 61$1ª691 8Q FDVR GL FRQWUDWWR SHU OD OHYD GL XQ LQWHUR UHJJLPHQWR H· LQYHFH TXHOOR GHO 5: OXJ1 4975/ TXDQGR LO PDUFKH0 VH *XLGR 5DQJRQL VL LPSHJQz DG DUUXRODUH/ ©FRQ RJQL PDJJLRU VROOHFLWXGL0 QHª/ GLHFL FRPSDJQLH GL 433 IDQWL O·XQD/ FRPSRVWH GD JHQWH ©,WDOLDQD IRUHVWLH0 UD/ FKH QRQ VLD GL 6WDWL VRVSHWWL D 61$1ª/ FRQ GLULWWR SHU LO 5DQJRQL GL QRPLQD0 UH LO WHQHQWH FRORQQHOOR/ LO VHUJHQWH PDJJLRUH H L FDSLWDQL1 &RQYHQ]LRQL FRPH TXHOOH VWLSXODWH QHO GLFHPEUH 4975 FRO FDS1 &ULVWRIRUR 6LOYD GL 0LODQR/ QHO 4976 FRO VHUJHQWH PDJJLRUH )UDQFHVFR 0D]]D GHWWR ´)RUPLFDµ R QHOO·RWWREUH 4979 FRO FDS1 JHQRYHVH &HVDUH 0DQGULVL/ QHOOH TXDOL HUD VSHFLILFDPHQWH SUHYLVWR FKH OH IDQWHULH GD DUUXRODUH IRVVHUR DUPDWH SHU GXH WHU]L GL PRVFKHWWL H SHU XQ WHU]R GL SLFFKH/ HYLGHQ]LDQR FRPH DQFKH 0RGHQD VL DGHJXDVVH DJOL VWDQGDUG HXURSHL GHO WHPSR/ FKH YROHYDQR DSSXQWR XQ SLFFKLHUH RJQL GXH PRVFKHWWLHUL VRWWR OH DUPL1 ,Q FDVR GL FRQIOLWWR YHQLYDQR FRPXQTXH PRELOLWDWL DQFKH QRWHYROL FRQ0 WLQJHQWL GL PLOL]LD= QHO 4935/ DG HV1/ LO PDUFKHVH ,SSROLWR %HQWLYRJOLR FRQGXV0 ²²²²²²²² 68
, &DSLWROL GHO 48<9/ TXHOOL GHOOD 0LOL]LD D FDYDOOR/ H JOL 2UGLQL/ H 3ULYLOHJL111 6RSUD L &DSRULR0 QL111/ VRQR ULSURGRWWL LQ &DSLWROL/ 2UGLQL/ ( 3ULYLOHJL &RQFHVVL 'D* 6HUHQLVVLPL $QWHFHVVRUL $ EHQHIL]LR GHOOD VXD GLOHWWD/ H IHGHO 0LOL]LD/ DSSURYDWL/ H FRQILUPDWL 'DOO*$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD GL 5LQDOGR ,111/ ULVWDP0 SDWL LQ 0RGRQD/ 3HU %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL 6WDPSDWRUH 'XFDOH/ 4:3:1 69 ,O FRQWUDWWR FRO 3HJRORWWL/ DO SDUL GHJOL DOWUL PHQ]LRQDWL QHO WHVWR/ H* FRQVHUYDWR LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1 5541
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:44
VH FRQWUR L /XFFKHVL LQ *DUIDJQDQD GLYHUVH PLJOLDLD GL ©)DQWL VFLHOWL GHOOH 0L0 OL]LH GHO 5HJJLDQR/ H GHO PRGRQHVHª6:/ PHQWUH LO 56 DJR1 4976/ GXUDQWH OD SULPD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR/ HUDQR GL SUHVLGLR QHOOD &DSLWDOH 4:5; PLOL]LRWWL SLX· L ORUR XIILFLDOL/ FKH VL DJJLXQJHYDQR D 595 XRPLQL GHO FLWDWR UHJJLPHQWR 5DQ0 JRQL6;1 /D PLOL]LD ODVFLDYD SHUDOWUR VSHVVR D GHVLGHUDUH/ VLD VXO SLDQR GHOO·DIILGDELOLWj +QHO 4976/ DG HVHPSLR/ FRQWUR L 3DSDOLQL FKH DVVDOLURQR 6SL0 ODPEHUWR/ 9LJQROD H *XLJOLD HVVD QRQ IHFH ©TXHOOD UHVLVWHQ]D/ FK·HUD VXSSR0 VWDª,/ VLD DQFKH VRWWR DOWUL SURILOL1 $L PLOL]LRWWL VL ULPSURYHUDYDQR LQ HIIHWWL ©SRFD EXRQD GLVFLSOLQDª H ©WURSSR DSHUWD GLVREHGLHQ]Dª6</ H QRQ LQIUHTXHQWL HUDQR SXUH JOL DEXVL FRPPHVVL GDJOL XIILFLDOL1 *Lj DL WHPSL GHO GXFD &HVDUH DFFDGHYD DG HVHPSLR FKH FDSLWDQL GHOOH &RUD]]H H GHJOL $UFKLEXJLHUL PRQWDWL WROOHUDVVHUR VROGDWL ©VHQ]·DUPL/ H VHQ]D FDYDOOL SHU OH ULFRJQLWLRQL/ FKH QH KD0 YHDQRª73/ FRPH DQFKH VL YHULILFDYD 0DOORUD FRPH LQ VHJXLWR0 FKH ©R· SHU DPLFL0 WLD/ R· SHU DOWUR ILQHª ©OL EHQ VWDQWL/ H SL• FRPPRGLª IRVVHUR HVHQWDWL ©GDOOH )DWLRQLª/ FRQ FRQVHJXHQWH DJJUDYLR GHL ©3RYHUL/ H 0LVHUDELOLª/ FKH SRL ILQLYD0 QR QRQ GL UDGR SHU DEEDQGRQDUH LO VHUYL]LR R DGGLULWWXUD/ DO VXR WHUPLQH/ LO SDHVH ©SHU QRQ HVVHU GL QXRXR VIRU]DWL D IDUH/ ROWUH OH SDUWL ORUR/ TXHOOH DQFRU GHJO·DOWULª741 ©(W SHUz YROHQGR +111, SURYHGHUH D TXHVWL DEEXVL/ H GLVRUGLQL/ ) DYHU VHP0 SUH OH VXH 3LD]]H IRUQLWH GL EXRQD JHQWH +111,/ ) EHQ GLVFLSOLQDWDª/ QHO JLXJQR GHO 498< LO GXFD $OIRQVR ,9 HVHQWz OD 0LOL]LD GDO JUDYRVR REEOLJR GL IRUQLUH LO SHUVRQDOH QHFHVVDULR DOOD FXVWRGLD RUGLQDULD GHOOH SLD]]H D IURQWH SHUDOWUR GHO SDJDPHQWR GL XQD VRPPD DQQXDOH GD SDUWH GHL PLOL]LRWWL/ ©SHU SRWHUVL +111, FRQ WDO PH]R PDQWHQHUH OH *XDUGLH/ H 3UHVVLGLM GHOOH 3LD]]H FRQ JHQWH YRORQ0 WDULD/ H GL )RUWXQD/ LQ ORFR ORURª751 1HO 49;8 WURYLDPR FRVL· GL SUHVLGLR D %UH0 VFHOOR/ DG HVHPSLR/ DSSXQWR XQD FRPSDJQLD GL IRUWXQD/ FLRH· GL WUXSSD DVVRO0 GDWD/ FRPDQGDWD GDO FDS1 $QWRQLR 0DULD 6XVDUL1 $ VROGR HUD DQFKH OD *XDU0 ²²²²²²²² 6: 'HVFUL]LRQH G*$OFXQH *XHUUH WUD LO 'XFD GL 0RGRQD/ H /XFKHVL/ LQ $QQDOL HW YDULH LVWRULH/ H DFFL0 GHQWL RFFRUVL LQ 5HJJLR GL /RPEDUGLD HW DOWUL OXRJKL/ %(02/ 0VV1 &DPSRUL 559 +,,1 6; &IU1 OD ©1RWD GH 6ROGDWL HIIHWWLYL FRPSUHVL JOL 8II1OL FKH VRQR LQ 0RG1D GHO 5HJJLP1WR 5DQJRQLª/ GDWDWD DSSXQWR 56 DJR1 4976 H FRQVHUYDWD LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1 5481 6< *ULGD D VWDPSD 6RSUD OD OLEHUDWLRQH GH* 6ROGDWL GHOOH 0HOLWLH GDOOH JXDUGLH GL 0RGRQD/ 5HJJLR/ &DUSL/ &RUHJJLR/ %HUVHOOR/ ) DOWUL OXRJKL D ILUPD GL *LRYDQQL 7RUUL/ SXEEOLFDWD D 0RGHQD LO 5; H LO 5< JLXJQR 498< +,ELG1/ E1 554,1 73 /HWWHUD GL $QGUHD &RGHEz V1G1 H GLUHWWD D QRPLQDWLYR QRQ SUHFLVDWR +,ELG1/ E1 554,1 74 ,ELGHP/ DOOD QRWD 6<1 75 ,ELGHP/ DOOD QRWD 6<1
:45
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
GLD VYL]]HUD/ FKH JOL (VWHQVL WHQHYDQR DO ORUR VHUYL]LR VLQ GDO SHULRGR IHUUDUH0 VH H FKH DOO·HSRFD GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,, FRQWDYD XQ FHQWLQDLR GL XRPLQL76/ LQTXDGUDWL 0DOPHQR QHJOL DQQL ¶;3 H ¶<3 GHO VHF1 ;9,,0 LQ XQD FRPSDJQLD GL $ODEDUGLHUL1 $OOD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR HG DL SULPL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR LO UXROR GHOOD 0LOL]LD/ UL0 SDUWLWD LQ XQLWD· H FLUFRVFUL]LRQL TXDOL LO UHJJLPHQWR GHO 3LDQR GL 0RGHQD/ LO UHJJLPHQWR GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ L FRORQQHOODWL GL 5HJJLR/ GL &RUUHJJLR/ GL 61 )H0 OLFH HFF1/ FRQWLQXDYD SHUDOWUR DG HVVHUH FHQWUDOH1 'LYHUVH PLJOLDLD IXURQR LQ HIIHWWL L PLOL]LRWWL PRELOLWDWL QHO FRUVR GHL FRQIOLWWL LQ FXL LO 'XFDWR VL WURYz FRLQYROWR DOO·HSRFD GL 5LQDOGR ,1 ,Q RFFDVLRQH GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD/ DG HVHPSLR/ ROWUH 5833 VROGDWL GL 0LOL]LD YHQQHUR FKLDPDWL D JXDU0 QLUH 5HJJLR QHO OXJOLR GHO 4:35/ PHQWUH SHU OD GLIHVD GHOOD &DSLWDOH HUDQR VWDWL FRPDQGDWL 6333 ©IDQWL 3DHVDQLª H PLOL]LRWWL D FDYDOOR1 /D SURYD GDWD GD TXH0 VWH WUXSSH QRQ IX SHUDOWUR GHOOH PLJOLRUL= EDVWL SHQVDUH FKH/ FDGXWD 5HJJLR QHOOH PDQL GHL IUDQFHVL/ SHU ULXVFLUH D PDQGDUH ©XQ 'LVWDFFDPHQWR GL &DYDO0 OHULD GHO 3DHVHª LQ ULFRJQL]LRQH IXRUL GD 0RGHQD LO 63 OXJOLR IX QHFHVVDULR PLQDFFLDUH ©GL IDUOL PRVFKHWWDUH GDL VROGDWL GL IRUWXQD +111, GL *XDUGLD DOOH 3RUWH GHOOD &LWWjª771 6HFRQGR XQ UHFHQWH VWXGLR VXOOH DUPDWH LWDOLDQH QHOOH JXHUUH GHO SULPR 6HWWHFHQWR/ QHOOR VWHVVR DQQR 4:35 L &RUSL VWLSHQGLDWL DO VHUYL]LR GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR FRQWDYDQR <83 HIIHWWLYL/ FRPSUHVL 93 XRPLQL GHOOD *XDUGLD GHO FRU0 SR H 55 GHOOD *XDUGLD VYL]]HUD781 6RWWR )UDQFHVFR ,,, +4:6:04:;3, O·DSSDUDWR PLOLWDUH HVWHQVH YHQQH UDSL0 GDPHQWH DPPRGHUQDWR H SRWHQ]LDWR1 *LD· DOO·LQL]LR GHJOL DQQL ¶73 WURYLDPR LQ HIIHWWL DO VROGR GHO GXFD XQ UHJJLPHQWR VYL]]HUR/ DJOL RUGLQL GHO FRO1 GH *URRVV H IRUWH DO 7 JLXJQR 4:75 GL 45<9 XRPLQL/ QRQFKH· LO UHJJLPHQWR 3D0 OXGH/ FRVL· GHQRPLQDWR GDO FRQWH &HVDUH GHOOD 3DOXGH VXR FRPDQGDQWH/ FKH DO : PDJJLR VHPSUH GHO 4:75 FRQWDYD 4573 WUD VROGDWL HG XIILFLDOL D IURQWH GL XQ RUJDQLFR ILVVDWR LQ 4633 WHVWH791 1HO 4:73274 IXURQR LQROWUH FRVWLWXLWL FLQTXH ²²²²²²²² 76 &IU1 *1 &$0325,/ 'HOOD LVWLWX]LRQH GHOOH *XDUGLH VYL]]HUH LQ ,WDOLD H SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LQ 0RGHQD/ HVWUDWWR GD ©/*,QGLFDWRUH 0RGHQHVHª/ 4;85/ 53054/ S1 :1 6HFRQGR LO &DPSRUL/ OD *XDUGLD VYL]]HUD YHQQH OLFHQ]LDWD QHL SULPL WHPSL GHO JRYHUQR GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,,1 77 *1 )5$1&+,1,/ &URQDFD111 FLW1/ ,/ F17491 78 &IU1 91 ,/$5,0*1 %2(5,0&1 3$2/(77,/ 7UD L %RUERQL H JOL $VEXUJR1 /H DUPDWH WHUUHVWUL H QD0 YDOL LWDOLDQH QHOOH JXHUUH GHO SULPR 6HWWHFHQWR +4:3404:65,/ $QFRQD/ 1XRYH 5LFHUFKH/ 4<<9/ S1 4:61 79 3HU OD IRU]D GHL GXH UHJJLPHQWL FIU1 OD ©7DEHOOH GH 5HYXH GX 5pJLP1W DX[ *DUGHV 6XLV0 VHV GH 61$1 6HU1PH j 0RGHQH OH 7PH -XLQ 4:75µ D ILUPD GHO PDJJ1 &RUQDEH*/ H OD ´7DEHOOD
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:46
UHJJLPHQWL GL IDQWHULD ´1D]LRQDOHµ= LO ´5HJJLRµ/ LO ´0RGHQDµ/ LO ´0LUDQGRODµ/ LO ´)ULJQDQRµ H LO ´*DUIDJQDQDµ/ FLDVFXQR VX TXDWWUR FRPSDJQLH GL 483 XR0 PLQL SUHVL GDOOH ORFDOL PLOL]LH1 1HOOR VWHVVR SHULRGR OD FDYDOOHULD GXFDOH FRPSUHQGHYD XQD FRPSDJQLD GL *XDUGLD GHO FRUSR H GXH PLQXVFROL UHJJLPHQWL/ XQR GL FRUD]]LHUL FRPDQGDWR GDO FRO1 $QWRQLR 0RQWHFXFFROL H XQR GL GUDJRQL VRWWR LO PDUFKHVH %RQLID]LR 5DQJRQL1 $ ILQH RWWREUH 4:74 OD IRU]D GL WDOL UHJJLPHQWL HUD GL FLUFD 483 XR0 PLQL O·XQR/ VXGGLYLVL LQ TXDWWUR FRPSDJQLH +FRORQQHOOD/ WHQ1 FRORQQHOOD/ PDJ0 JLRUD H FDSLWDQD,7:1 4XDQGR SHUDOWUR OD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH DXVWULDFD LQYHVWu LO 'XFDWR SUHV0 VRFKH· WXWWH TXHVWH WUXSSH YHQQHUR SRVWH TXDVL VXELWR IXRUL FRPEDWWLPHQWR/ SRLFKH· JOL DXVWUR0VDUGL OH EORFFDURQR QHOOH FLWWDGHOOH GL 0RGHQD H 0LUDQGROD FRVWULQJHQGROH DOOD UHVD QHO JLXJQR2OXJOLR 4:751 /·4 DJR1 4:75 DVVXQVH DOORUD O·LPSHJQR GL OHYDUH SHU LO VRYUDQR HVWHQVH XQ QXRYR UHJJLPHQWR GL VYL]]HUL LO FRO1 %DYRLV/ HG XQ DOWUR IX DXWRUL]]DWR DG DUUXRODUQH QHO 4:78 LO FRO1 0RWWHW1 $O 63 DJR1 4:7: TXHVW·XOWLPD XQLWj/ DOORUD DFFDVHUPDWD D 1DUERQD/ FRQWDYD SLX· GL 983 WUD XIILFLDOL/ VRWWXIILFLDOL H VROGDWL> DOOD ILQH GL IHEEUDLR GHOOR VWHVVR DQQR LO %DYRLV/ GLVORFDWR D 7RORQH/ HUD IRUWH GDO FDQWR VXR GL 966 LQGLYLGXL1 'RSR OD SDFH GL $TXLVJUDQD IX VWDELOLWR FKH L GXH UHSDUWL VL IRQGHVVHUR LQ XQR VROR/ H FRQ SDWHQWH GXFDOH GHO 46 IHE1 4:7< D FDSR GHO QXRYR UHJJLPHQ0 WR ULVXOWDQWH GDOO·DFFRUSDPHQWR IX SRVWR -HDQ )UDQoRLV %UHVVHQFRXU/ EDURQH GL 0DQGUH> QHO JLUR GL XQ DQQR/ SHUDOWUR/ SL• GHOOD PHWj GHL 4733 XRPLQL FKH FRPSRQHYDQR LQL]LDOPHQWH LO UHSDUWR IX FRQJHGDWD7;1 'RSR FKH )UDQFHVFR ,,, GLYHQQH JRYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR +4:87,/ SDUWH GHO0 OH WUXSSH HVWHQVL SDVVR· SHU DOFXQL DQQL GL JXDUQLJLRQH QHOOD /RPEDUGLD DX0 VWULDFD1 1HOO·DSULOH 4:8< VL WURYDYDQR FROj SL• GL 5:33 VROGDWL GXFDOL/ H FLRH· GXH VTXDGURQL GL GUDJRQL/ LO ´*DUIDJQDQDµ/ GLVORFDWR D 3DYLD +FRQ GLVWDFFD0 PHQWL D IRUWH )XHQWHV/ D /HFFR HG LQ DOWUH ORFDOLWj,/ LO ´)ULJQDQRµ/ DFTXDUWLHUD0 ²²²²²²²² 'HOO*,QFOLWR 5HJJLPHQWR G*,QIDQWHULD GHOOD 3DOXGH 'L 61$16HU PD ,O 6LJU 'XFD GL 0RGRQD OL : 0DJJLR 4:75ª D ILUPD GHO FRO1 0DGHUQL/ HQWUDPEH LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E158:1 7: &IU1 OH ©7DEHOOH GH 5HJJLP1WL GL &DYDOOHULD 6WDWD GL 6HUYLJLR QH JLRUQL GHOOL 5:= 5;> H 5<1 ;EUH 4:74ª +LELGHP,1 7; 3HU OH YLFHQGH GHL UHJJLPHQWL %DYRLV/ 0RWWHW H 0DQGUH FIU1 *1 25/$1',/ 3HU OD VWRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD QHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD GDOOH RULJLQL DO 4:88/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;4/ SS1<704331
:47
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
WR D 0DQWRYD/ HG LO ´3DOXGHµ/ GL SUHVLGLR D /RGL H 3L]]LJKHWWRQH7<1 4XHVW·XOWLPR UHSDUWR/ GHQRPLQDWR DQFKH ´5HJJLPHQWR *XDUGLH D 3LHGLµ/ YDUFz LO 3R SHU WRUQDUH D 0RGHQD LO 45 JLX1 4:96/ SDVVDQGR SRL QHO JLUR GL VHL PHVL/ SHU HIIHWWR VRSUDWWXWWR GL FHQWLQDLD GL FRQJHGDPHQWL/ GD 4548 D VROL ;79 XRPLQL1 7UD FRVWRUR L PRGHQHVL QRQ HUDQR SL• GL 486/ D IURQWH GL 49: ©7R0 GHVFKLª/ ;9 ©)UDQFHVLª H 773 LWDOLDQL GL DOWUL 6WDWL831 1HO JLXJQR GHO 4:98 DOOH *XDUGLH HUD DQFRUD DVVHJQDWR XQ RUJDQLFR GL ;79 XRPLQL/ PHQWUH OD FDYDOOH0 ULD DQQRYHUDYD 495 JXDUGLH GHO FRUSR/ VXGGLYLVH WUD 0LODQR +RYH LO GXFD FRQ0 WLQXDYD D ULVLHGHUH,/ 0RGHQD H OD YLOOHJJLDWXUD GL 6DVVXROR/ QRQFKH· 479 XR0 PLQL GHO UHJJLPHQWR 'UDJRQL/ DOORUD FRPDQGDWR GDO FRO1 0HQDIRJOLR841 1HOOR VWHVVR SHULRGR L FLQTXH UHJJLPHQWL GL IDQWHULD QD]LRQDOH FRQWDYDQR FRPSOHV0 VLYDPHQWH 4<:8 WUD XIILFLDOL H VROGDWL D IURQWH GL XQ HIIHWWLYR ILVVDWR LQ 5448 WHVWH1 'DOOR ©6WDWR +111, 'HJO·,QFOLWL 5HJJLPHQWL ,QIDQWHULD 1D]LRQDOL GL 61$161 +111, DOOD 5LYLVWD *HQHUDOH GDWWD GDO &RPPHVVDULR *HQHUDOH GL *XHUUD 0DU0 FKHVH )RQWDQHOOL QHO 0HVH GL *LXJQR 4:98ª85 ULVXOWD LQROWUH FKH DOO·HSRFD WUD LO SHUVRQDOH Y·HUDQR QRQ VROR ´VXGGLWLµ/ PD DQFKH ´IRUHVWLHULµ1 3L• SUHFLVD0 PHQWH TXHVWL XOWLPL HUDQR 5:</ FRQ XQD SHUFHQWXDOH GHO 47(/ FKH VDOH DO 7<( VH VL SUHQGRQR LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH L VROL XIILFLDOL +433 LQ WRWDOH,1 7UD L 49<9 XRPLQL FRQWHJJLDWL FRPH VXGGLWL LO GRFXPHQWR FRPSUHQGH SHUDOWUR DQFKH 75 PDVVHVL H 5;8 ´/RPEDUGLµ1 1HO 4:9< L UHJJLPHQWL GL IDQWHULD QD]LRQDOH YHQQHUR VRSSUHVVL H DO ORUR SRVWR ©QH IRUPDURQR XQ DOWUR GHWWR LO 5HJJLPHQWR 6WDWR FRQ XQLIRUPH ELDQ0 FR/ H PRVWUD WXUFKLQD/ H YL ULPDVHUR LO 5HJJLPHQWR *XDUGLH D 3LHGLª +FXL YHQQH DWWULEXLWD XQ·XQLIRUPH GDL FRORUL URYHVFLDWL/ FLRH· EOHX FRQ PRVWUH ELDQFKH,/ ©OL 'UDJRQL/ H OL &DQQRQLHULª86/ ROWUH DOOD *XDUGLD GHO FRUSR1 ,O UHJ0 JLPHQWR GL 6WDWR/ LQ FXL SRWHYDQR HVVHUH SHUDOWUR DUUXRODWL DQFKH IRUHVWLHUL ²²²²²²²² 7<
&IU1 XQD ©7DEHOOH 'HV 7URXSSHV GH 61$161 OH 'XF GH 0RGHQH DX 6HUYLFH GH 6101 /*,PS1FH 5HLQH GH JDUQLVRQ GDQV OD /RPEDUGLH DXWULFKLHQQHª D ILUPD GHO FRQWH GHOOD 3DOXGH/ LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1 ;<1 83 &IU1 XQD ©7DEHOOD GL 9DULD]LRQHª GHO UHJJLPHQWR *XDUGLH D SLHGL GDO 45 JLXJQR/ ©*LRU0 QR GHOOD 9DUFD]LRQH GHO 3R*/ VLQR /*8OWLPR GLFHPEUH 4:96ª/ D ILUPD GHO FRO1 6DQGR] GH 1RL0 UDLJXH +,ELGHP,1 84 &IU1 XQD ©7DEHOOD 0RVWUDOH GHOOD IRU]D GL FXL VL WURYDQR D WXWWR JLXJQR 4:98 DOOH 5HYLVWH SDVVDWH GDO &RPPHVVDULR *HQHUDOH 0DUFKHVH )RQWDQHOOL /L &RUSL GL &DYDOOHULD DO VHUYLJJLR GL 61$1 6HUHQLVVLPDª/ D ILUPD GHO PDUFKHVH $OIRQVR )RQWDQHOOL +LELGHP,1 85 ,Q $602/ 0LOLWDUH HVWHQVH/ E1 5561 86 *1 )5$1&+,1,/ &URQDFD111 FLW1/ ,/ F1 9351
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:48
©TXDORUD VL WUDWWL GL EXRQD H EHOOD JHQWHª87/ QHOO·DJRVWR GHO 4::3 HUD FRPDQGD0 WR GDO FRO1 %RVFKHWWL HG HUD DUWLFRODWR VX GXH EDWWDJOLRQL/ GL FXL XQR/ DJOL RU0 GLQL GHO WHQ1 FRO1 :LVDUG/ GL SUHVLGLR QHO 0DVVHVH1 $QFKH OH *XDUGLH D SLHGL FRPSUHQGHYDQR GXH EDWWDJOLRQL/ XQR GHL TXDOL QHO PDU]R 4::3 HUD GL JXDUQL0 JLRQH D 0RGHQD PHQWUH O·DOWUR HUD VXGGLYLVR WUD 5HJJLR H 0LUDQGROD1 4XDQWR DOOD 0LOL]LD/ OH RUGLQDQ]H VXOOH PLOL]LH IRUHQVL HPDQDWH LO 9 OXJ1 4:73 SHU RUGLQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, OLPLWDYDQR ©/H ID]LRQL +111, H VHUYLJJLª FXL HUDQR WHQXWH OH PLOL]LH VWHVVH DO ©JXDUGDU L &RQILQL/ OL 3DVVL/ OL $UJLQL GH· ILX0 PL/ QH· FDVL GL ELVRJQR/ OH )LHUH/ HG DOWUH SXEEOLFKH )XQ]LRQL/ FKH VL IDFHVVHUR QH· ORUR ULVSHWWLYL 7HUULWRUMª/ QRQFKH· DOO·DUUHVWDUH GLVHUWRUL H PDOYLYHQWL HFF1/ ©FRVH WXWWH FKH ULJXDUGDQR LO TXLHWR YLYHUH/ H LO EXRQ JRYHUQR SDUWLFRODUH/ FXL FLDVFXQR H· WHQXWR QHOOD VXD 3DWULDª881 ,Q WDOXQH RFFDVLRQL WXWWDYLD OD 0LOL]LD YHQQH LPSLHJDWD LQ FRPSLWL SL• LPSHJQDWLYL= QHOOD SULPDYHUD GHO 4::5 DG H0 VHPSLR WURYLDPR XQ GLVWDFFDPHQWR GL PLOL]LRWWL GL SUHVLGLR QHO IRUWH GL 6H0 VWROD1 ,O UHJJLPHQWR *XDUGLH D SLHGL IX FRQVHUYDWR DQFKH GD (UFROH ,,,/ GXFD GDO 4:;3/ GHOOH FXL WUXSSH YHQQH D FRVWLWXLUH LO QHUER1 $ TXDQWR ULIHULVFH LO *RUD0 QL QHL VXRL 0pPRLUHV/ LO UHJJLPHQWR FRQWDYD DOORUD XQ PLJOLDLR GL XRPLQL HG HUD ©EHQ WHQXWRª/ FRQ VROGDWL ©EHQ YHVWLWL H EHQH DUPDWLª FKH HUDQR LQ JUDGR GL ©FRPSHWHUH FRQ OH WUXSSH DXVWULDFKH/ VHQ]D WHPHUH LO FRQIURQWRª891 'RSR OD SDUHQWHVL QDSROHRQLFD +4:<904;47, OH IRU]H DUPDWH GXFDOL YHQQH0 UR ULFRVWLWXLWH VX QXRYH EDVL1 3ULPD DUPD GHOO·HVHUFLWR GLYHQQHUR L 'UDJRQL/ TXDOLILFDWL GDO 5HJRODPHQWR 'L 6HUYLJLR/ 'LVFLSOLQD/ H 3ROL]LD +111, SHU LO 5HDO &RUSR GHL 'UDJRQL (VWHQVL GHO 4;4; FRPH ©XQD )RU]D LVWLWXLWD SHU DVVLFXUDUH LO PDQWHQL0 PHQWR GHOO·RUGLQH/ H O·HVHFX]LRQH GHOOH /HJJL QHOO·LQWHUQR GHOOR 6WDWRª +DUW14,/ H IRUPDWL VXO PRGHOOR GHOOD *HQGDUPHULD IUDQFHVH/ FXL SXUH VL LVSLUDYDQR &RUSL DQDORJKL GL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL FRPH DG HV1 L &DUDELQLHUL SLHPRQWHVL1 6XO ILQLUH GHO 4;74 LO &RUSR 'UDJRQL FRQWDYD 5;; XRPLQL/ VXGGLYLVL LQ XQR VTXD0 GURQH GL FDYDOOHULD H GXH FRPSDJQLH D SLHGL1 /D IRU]D GHOOR VTXDGURQH/ GLVOR0 ²²²²²²²²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pPRLUHV VHFUHWV HW FULWLTXHV GHV FRXUV/ GHV JRXYHUQHPHQV HW GHV PRHXUV GHV SULQFLSDX[ qWDWV GH O*,WDOLH XVFLWL D 3DULJL QHO 4:<6
:49
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
FDWR SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH D 0RGHQD/ HUD GL ;8 LQGLYLGXL/ FRPSUHVL DOFXQL JDU0 ]RQL GHVWLQDWL D SXOLUH LO TXDUWLHUH H OH VWDOOH/ D VWULJOLDUH L FDYDOOL/ HFF1 /H FRP0 SDJQLH GL IDQWHULD HUDQR LQYHFH ULSDUWLWH LQ ROWUH 63 EULJDWH/ SRVWH QHOOH SULQ0 FLSDOL ORFDOLWj GHOOR 6WDWR H VXL SXQWL GL FRQILQH1 1HL ©3DHVL PRQWXRVL GHO )ULJQDQR H 5HJJLDQR/ *DUIDJQDQD /XQLJLDQDª OH LQFRPEHQ]H GHL 'UDJRQL IXURQR SHUDOWUR VYROWH SHU GLYHUVL DQQL GDL &DFFLD0 WRUL GHO )ULJQDQR/ LVWLWXLWL QHO 4;641 6HPSUH D ILQH ¶74 LO &RUSR/ DO TXDOH SR0 WHYDQR DFFHGHUH VRODPHQWH L SURYHQLHQWL GDO )ULJQDQR/ GDOO·DSSHQQLQR UHJ0 JLDQR/ GDOOD *DUIDJQDQD H GDOOD /XQLJLDQD/ FRPSUHQGHYD VHL FRPSDJQLH GL ;3 XRPLQL O·XQD/ GHOOH TXDOL GXH HUDQR GL SUHVLGLR D 0DVVD H &DUUDUD/ PHQWUH OH DOWUH HUDQR DQFK·HVVH VXGGLYLVH LQ EULJDWH/ VSDUVH SHU OD PRQWDJQD8:1 3HUDOWUR ©QHOOD VWDJLRQH LQYHUQDOHª ©QRQ SRFKH GL TXHOOH %ULJDWH GL 0RQWDJQDª UHVWD0 YDQR ©WRWDOPHQWH LQRSHURVHª ©SHUFKH· OD VWDJLRQH VWHVVD +111, UHQGH LPSRVVLELOL L JLUL GHL FRQWUDEDQGLHUL H PDOYLYHQWLª8;1 , &DFFLDWRUL GHO )ULJQDQR IXURQR VRSSUHVVL GDO JRYHUQR ULYROX]LRQDULR GHO 4;7;1 1HO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH LO QHUER GHOO·HVHUFLWR GXFDOH HUD FRPXQTXH FRVWLWXLWR GDOOD IDQWHULD GL /LQHD1 $OOD ILQH GHO 4;66 LO %DWWDJOLRQH GL /LQHD/ FRPDQGDWR GDO WHQ1 FRO1 9LQFHQ]R =XFFKL/ DYHYD XQ RUJDQLFR GL <;9 WHVWH H FRPSUHQGHYD/ ROWUH DOOR 6WDWR PDJJLRUH/ DOOR 6WDWR PLQRUH H DOOD EDQGD/ GXH FRPSDJQLH GL JUDQDWLHUL/ HQWUDPEH GL JXDUQLJLRQH QHOOD &DSLWDOH/ H VHL FRP0 SDJQLH GL IXFLOLHUL/ ULSDUWLWH WUD 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR H 0DVVD8<1 1HO OXJOLR GHO 4;67 LO %DWWDJOLRQH DFTXLVu XQD VHWWLPD FRPSDJQLD/ D VHJXLWR GHOO·DJJUHJD]LRQH DO PHGHVLPR GHOOD FRVLGGHWWD &RPSDJQLD 0LVWD/ LVWLWXLWD QHO 4;64 SHU FRQFHQWUDUYL L VROGDWL GL WXWWL L &RUSL FKH DYHYDQR VHUYLWR L ULEHO0 OL GXUDQWH OD ULYROX]LRQH GL TXHOO·DQQR1 1HJOL DQQL ¶83 OD IDQWHULD GL /LQHD FR0 VWLWXLYD RUPDL XQ UHJJLPHQWR/ FRQ XQ HIIHWWLYR GL FLUFD 5633 XRPLQL ULSDUWLWL LQ WUH EDWWDJOLRQL +GXH GL JUDQDWLHUL H IXFLOLHUL HG XQR GL FDFFLDWRUL,/ SL• XQ TXDUWR EDWWDJOLRQH GHVWLQDWR DG LQTXDGUDUH LQ FDVR GL ULFKLDPR ROWUH :33 UL0 VHUYLVWL H FKH SHUWDQWR QRQ FRQWDYD RUGLQDULDPHQWH LQ VHUYL]LR FKH XQ SXJQR GL XIILFLDOL H VRWWXIILFLDOL1 ²²²²²²²² 8:
3HU TXDQWR HVSRVWR FLUFD 'UDJRQL H &DFFLDWRUL GHO )ULJQDQR FIU1 LO GRF1 FLWDWR DOOD QRWD
561 8;
5HOD]LRQH DO GXFD LQ GDWD 46 QRY1 4;79 GHO FRPDQGDQWH GHOOH WUXSSH $JRVWLQR 6DFFR]0 ]L +$602/ 0LOLWDUH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ $WWL ULVHUYDWL GHO 61F1J1 4;7927<,1 8< &IU1 OR ©6WDWR 0LOLWDUH (VWHQVH DOOD ILQH GHO 4;66ª FRQVHUYDWR QHOO*DUPDGLR GHOOD GLUH]LRQH GHOO* $6021
/·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +48<;04;8<,
:4:
/·DXPHQWR GHOOD IRU]D IX UHVR SRVVLELOH GDOOD FRVFUL]LRQH REEOLJDWRULD/ LQ0 WURGRWWD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL FRQ GHFUHWR VRYUDQR GHO 8 DSU1 4;7<1 2OWUH D FRQ0 VHQWLUH LO SRWHQ]LDPHQWR GHOO·HVHUFLWR/ OD FRVFUL]LRQH YDOVH DQFKH D PLJOLRUDUH OD TXDOLWj GHO SHUVRQDOH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD ILVLFR/ UHFDQGR VRWWR TXHVWR SURIL0 OR/ D GHWWD GHO FRPDQGDQWH GHOOH WUXSSH JHQ1 6DFFR]]L/ ©VRPPR YDQWDJJLRª1 1HO 4;89 O·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·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ DL FRPDQGL GL SLD]]D HFF1/ QRQFKp OD *XDUGLD QRELOH G·RQRUH/ FKH SURYYHGHYD DOOD VFRUWD GHO VRYUDQR H GHOOD IDPLJOLD UHDOH ©QHOOH JUDQGL RFFDVLRQL GL &RUWH/ R GL IXQ]LRQLª H YLJLODYD VXOOD 5HDOH $QWLFDPHUD DIILQFKp YL VL PDQWHQHVVHUR O·RUGLQH H OH FRQYHQLHQ]H H QHVVXQ LQGLYLGXR VL LQWURGXFHVVH VHQ]D DXWRUL]]D]LRQH QHOOH VWDQ]H GXFDOL1 $QFKH OD 0LOL]LD YRORQWDULD/ H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH OD 0LOL]LD GL ULVHUYD/ VYRO0 VHUR XQ UXROR QRQ WUDVFXUDELOH LQ HSRFD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH1 /D 0LOL]LD YRORQWDULD HUD IRUPDWD GD FRQWDGLQL/ FKH YHQLYDQR ULXQLWL GL TXDQGR LQ TXDQGR OD GRPHQLFD SHU IDUH DGGHVWUDPHQWR1 6XR SULQFLSDOH FRP0 SLWR HUD TXHOOR GL DVVLFXUDUH OD WUDQTXLOOLWj H OD VLFXUH]]D GHOOH FDPSDJQH> YL SURYYHGHYD DWWUDYHUVR SDWWXJOLDPHQWL QRWWXUQL H PDQWHQHQGR O·RUGLQH DOOH VDJUH H ILHUH FDPSHVWUL1 &RQWLQJHQWL GL PLOLWL YHQQHUR FRPXQTXH WDORUD DQFKH PRELOLWDWL SHU SUHVWDUH VHUYL]LR GL SLD]]D1 $ ILQH ¶74 OD 0LOL]LD YRORQWDULD FRQ0 WDYD FLUFD 9333 DUPDWL H FRPSUHQGHYD LO UHJJLPHQWR GHOOD SURYLQFLD GL 0R0 GHQD VX WUH EDWWDJOLRQL/ GXH EDWWDJOLRQL GHOOD SURYLQFLD GL 5HJJLR/ XQ EDWWD0 JOLRQH GL FDFFLDWRUL PLOLWL GHO 3LDQR PRGHQHVH/ XQ DOWUR GHOOD PRQWDJQD UHJ0 JLDQD HG XQ WHU]R DJJUHJDWR DL &DFFLDWRUL GHO )ULJQDQR/ SL• XQ EDWWDJOLRQH PLOLWL G·2OWUDSSHQQLQR VX VHL FRPSDJQLH/ GL FXL GXH GL EHUVDJOLHUL JXDUGDFR0 VWH H GXH GL FDFFLDWRUL PLOLWL1 %HUVDJOLHUL H FDFFLDWRUL PLOLWL HUDQR GRWDWL GL FD0 UDELQH/ PHQWUH JOL DOWUL DYHYDQR IXFLOL1 7DOH DUPDPHQWR HUD FXVWRGLWR GDL VLQ0 ²²²²²²²² 93 &IU1 OD ©6LWXD]LRQH QXPHULFD GHOOD )RU]D GHL &RUSL 0LOLWDUL $WWLYL GDO JLRUQR 5; )HEEUDMR DO 9 0DU]R 4;89ª/ LQ $602/ 51 6HJUHWHULD GL JDELQHWWR/ ILO]D 98: +4<255,1
:4;
$OEHUWR 0HQ]LDQL
JROL PLOLWL LQVLHPH DOOH EXIIHWWHULH H DO FRSULFDSR PLOLWDUH> OH XQLIRUPL HUDQR LQYHFH LQ FRQVHJQD DL FDSLWDQL941 /H YLFHQGH GHO 4;7; SRUWDURQR DOOD GLVSHU0 VLRQH GHOOD PDJJLRU SDUWH GL TXHVWR PDWHULDOH= GHL :34 DELWL H SDLD GL SDQWDOR0 QL LQ GRWD]LRQH DO 54 PDU]R GL TXHOO·DQQR DO , EDWWDJOLRQH GHOOD SURYLQFLD GL 5HJJLR/ DG HVHPSLR/ QH HUDQR ULPDVWL D VHWWHPEUH SRFR SL• GL 483951 $PPDHVWUDWR GD WDOH HVSHULHQ]D/ )UDQFHVFR 9 QRQ YROOH GDUH XQLIRUPL DO0 OD 0LOL]LD GL ULVHUYD/ FKH QHO 4;7< UDFFROVH O·HUHGLWj GHOOD 9RORQWDULD/ ULWHQHQ0 GR VXIILFLHQWH/ DOPHQR SHU L VRWWXIILFLDOL H OD WUXSSD/ XQ VHPSOLFH EHUUHWWR PL0 OLWDUH1 $UWLFRODWD VX WUH UHJJLPHQWL/ OD 0LOL]LD GL ULVHUYD FRQWDYD QHO 4;8; FLUFD :833 DUPDWL1 ,Q WDOXQH FLUFRVWDQ]H HVVD IX FKLDPDWD D FRDGLXYDUH O·HVHUFLWR QHO IURQWHJJLDUH HPHUJHQ]H GL FDUDWWHUH PLOLWDUH/ FRPH DFFDGGH DG HV1 QHO 4;89 LQ RFFDVLRQH GL XQ·LQFXUVLRQH GL EDQGH ULYROX]LRQDULH QHO &DUUDUHVH> GL PDVVLPD WXWWDYLD O·LPSLHJR GHOOD 0LOL]LD LQ SULPD OLQHD HUD HVFOXVR/ QHOOD FRQ0 VLGHUD]LRQH FKH DYUHEEH SRUWDWR ©SL• FRQIXVLRQH FKH YDQWDJJLRª1 &RPH QRWR/ OD FDGXWD GHO 'XFDWR QHO 4;8< QRQ VHJQz OD ILQH GHOO·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH/ FKH YHQQH GLVFLROWR VROR QHO VHWWHPEUH GHO 4;96/ GRSR HVVHUH ULPD0 VWR SHU ROWUH TXDWWUR DQQL LQ HVLOLR DFFDQWR DO SURSULR VRYUDQR LQ DWWHVD GL XQD ULVFRVVD FKH OD VRUWH QRQ YROOH FRQVHQWLUH1
²²²²²²²² 94
3HU TXDQWR HVSRVWR FLUFD OD 0LOL]LD YRORQWDULD FIU1 LO GRF1 FLWDWR DOOD QRWD 561 &IU1 XQD OHWWHUD GHOO*H[ FRPDQGDQWH GHO EDWWDJOLRQH DOOD GLUH]LRQH GHOO*(FRQRPDWR PLOL0 WDUH LQ GDWD 57 VHW1 4;7;/ FRQVHUYDWD LQ $602/ 0LOLWDUH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ (FRQRPDWR PLOLWDUH/ ILO]D 53<25 GHO 4;7;1 95
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:4<
*,$1 &$5/2 0217$1$5,
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
3UHPHVVD 4XDQGR LO 63 JHQQDLR 48<; LO GXFD &HVDUH G·(VWH/ LQWLPDPHQWH WUDYDJOLD0 WR/ SUHVH SRVVHVVR GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD FKH GLYHQWDYD FRVu &DSLWDOH GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL/ VL WURYz GL IURQWH DG DFFRJOLHUOR XQ QRQ SL• JLRYDQH YHVFRYR/ *DVSDUH 6LOLQJDUGL +48<6 ² 493:,4 LO TXDOH JRYHUQDYD XQD FKLHVD ORFDOH FKH GD SRFR SL• GL VHGLFL DQQL +FLRq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u LO FULVWLDQHVLPR H LQL]Lz D YLYHUOR DWWUDYHUVR XQD VWUXWWXUD HFFOHVLDVWLFD FKH/ QDWXUDOPHQWH/ ULFDOFDYD O·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH URPDQD1 0RGHQD DYUj VLFXUD0 ²²²²²²²² 4
4XHVWR YHVFRYR/ FKH JXLGz OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH GLYLGHQGR LO VXR PDQGDWR HVDWWDPHQWH WUD VHWWH DQQL GHO &LQTXHFHQWR H VHWWH GHO 6HLFHQWR/ UHGDVVH XQ SUH]LRVR &DWDORJR GL WXWWL L YHVFR0 YL GL 0RGHQD/ IRQWH GHOOD VWRULD UHOLJLRVD ORFDOH H ULSXEEOLFDWR GD GRQ *LRUJLR /HQ]LQL +&URQR0 WDVVL GHL 9HVFRYL GL 0RGHQD/ 3DYXOOR GL 0RGHQD/ 7LSROLWR %HQHGHWWL/ 4<<8, FKH q ULPDVWR XQD GHOOH SRFKH D FXL DWWLQJHUH ILQR DO UHFHQWH 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD01RQDQWROD +0RGHQD/ 7LS1 3DOWULQLHUL/ 4<<:/ LQ GXH YROXPL D FXUD GL $1 /(21(//,0*1&1 0217$1$5, H $1 %$5%,(5,,1 5 %ROOD GL SDSD *UHJRULR ;,,, LQ GDWD VXGGHWWD FKH IDFHYD GL %RORJQD XQD FKLHVD DUFLYH0 VFRYLOH PHWURSROLWDQD1 6 3L• FHUWDPHQWH FKH DOPHQR/ FRPH VL DFFHQQHUj1 7 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD01RQDQWROD 111FLW1/ ,/ FDS1 51
:53
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
PHQWH XQ YHVFRYR OHJDWR D 0LODQR8 LQ $QWRQLQR/ WHU]R GHOOD VHULH VHFRQGR OD FURQRWDVVL XIILFLDOH/ PD SULPR YHVFRYR FHUWR GHOOD FLWWj/ D FXL VXFFHGHUj *H0 PLQLDQR ,/ LO VDQWR SDWURQR1 3URSULR QHOO·DQQR LQ FXL TXHVWL PRULUj/ DQFKH TXHOOR PLODQHVH/ $PEURJLR/ LO 7 DSULOH GHO 6<: VFRPSDULUj DQFRU UHODWLYDPHQ0 WH JLRYDQH H TXDQGR QHO 735 L 9LVLJRWL RFFXSDQR 5DYHQQD/ HFFR FKH O·LPSHUDWRUH URPDQR G·2FFLGHQWH 2QRULR WUDVIHULUj FROj +GD 0LODQR FKH HUD, OD FDSLWDOH LPSHULDOH1 &RVu/ QHO 7639 0RGHQD H OH DOWUH GLRFHVL HPLOLDQH VDUDQQR VRJJHWWH DOOD JLXULVGL]LRQH DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GL 5DYHQQD H TXHVWR SHU TXDVL VHWWHFHQWR DQQL/ FKp VL GHYH JLXQJHUH DO &RQFLOLR GL *XDVWDOOD GHO 55 RWWREUH 4439 SHUFKp LO YHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD: VLD VRWWUDWWR DOOD JLXULVGL]LRQH PHWURSROLWDQD UDYHQQD0 WH/ SHU TXDQWR JLj QHO 444; SDSD *HODVLR ,,/ VXFFHGXWR D SDSD 3DVTXDOH ,,; DYHVVH UHYRFDWR TXHOOD GHOLEHUD]LRQH1 (UDQR SXUH JOL DQQL FKH YLGHUR RSSRUVL 0RGHQD DOOR VWUDSRWHUH GHOO·DEED]LD GL 1RQDQWROD> JOL DQQL SXUH GHOOD *UDQ &RQWHVVD 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD1 3RL F·q DQFRUD XQD OXQJD YLFHQGD FKH VXSHUD LO %DVVR 0HGLRHYR H VIRUD O·(Wj 0RGHUQD/ VLQR DO 43 GLFHPEUH 48;5 FKH/ FRPH ULIHULWR/ q OD GDWD GL HUH0 ]LRQH GL %RORJQD D FKLHVD DUFLYHVFRYLOH PHWURSROLWDQD VRWWR OD TXDOH 0RGH0 QD SDVVz1 (UD YHVFRYR/ GDO 48:4</ 6LVWR 9LVGRPLQL/ GRPHQLFDQR FKH DYUHEEH DYXWR FRPH LPPHGLDWR VXFFHVVRUH/ PD SHU SRFR/ *LXOLR &DQDQL/ IHUUDUHVH +48<4048<5,/ LO TXDOH PRUu LO 5: QRYHPEUH 48<5 H DYUHEEH DYXWR FRPH VXF0 FHVVRUH LO YHVFRYR *DVSDUH 6LOLQJDUGL FKH DFFROVH LO QHR GXFD &HVDUH G·(VWH FRVWUHWWR D YHQLUH LQ 0RGHQD FKH GLYHQWDYD &DSLWDOH1 &KLHVD PRGHQHVH H SRWHUH HVWHQVH GDO 48<; DO 4:6: (· QDWXUDOH HG RYYLR FKH QRQ VL SRVVRQR GLVJLXQJHUH OH YLFHQGH GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH GL 0RGHQD GDO SRWHUH GHJOL (VWH/ QHO OXQJR DUFR GL ROWUH 594 ²²²²²²²² 8 8QLFD 0HWURSROL HFFOHVLDVWLFD GHOO·,WDOLD 6HWWHQWULRQDOH/ VFULYH PRQV1 $1721,12 /(21(//, LQ 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL 111FLW1 9 1HO 74;/ VHFRQGR LO 9HGULDQL1 : $VVLHPH D TXHOOL GL %RORJQD/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D1 ; 3DVTXDOH ,, IX SDSD GDO 43<< DO 444; H *HODVLR GDO 444; DO 444<1 1HOOD &URQRWDVVL FXUDWD GDO YHVFRYR 6LOLQJDUGL VL OHJJH FKH OH &KLHVH GHOO·(PLOLD/ QHOO·DQQR 444;/ IXURQR SRL UHVWLWXLWH D 9DO0 WHUUR/ $UFLYHVFRYR GL 5DYHQQD/ ULWRUQDWR DOO·REEHGLHQ]D GHOOD &KLHVD GL 5RPD1 < 6DUHEEH PRUWR LO 5: VHWWHPEUH 48<31
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:54
DQQL FKH YDQQR GD TXHO 63 JHQQDLR 48<; FKH YLGH YHQLUH LQ FLWWj &HVDUH G·(VWH/ DOO· 44 JLXJQR 4;8</ GDWD GHOOD SDUWHQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR 9 G·$XVWULD0 (VWH1 6RQR ROWUH GXH VHFROL H PH]]R GL VWRULD FRQWUDVVHJQDWD GD OXQJKL PR0 PHQWL GL DFFRUGL +WDFLWL R VFULWWL,/ PD DQFKH GD WHQVLRQL QRQ SLFFROH/ FKp OD SROLWLFD GHL GXFKL H SRL GHJOL DUFLGXFKL IX YDULD D VHFRQGD GHOOH SHUVRQDOLWj FKH OD LVSLUDYDQR H DQFKH JOL VWHVVL YHVFRYL PRGHQHVL HEEHUR ORUR LGHH H PR0 GL GL FRQGX]LRQH/ D YROWH LQ DFFRUGR/ DOWUH LQ FRQWUDSSRVL]LRQH FRQ OD SROLWLFD GXFDOH1 $G HVHPSLR/ DQFRU SULPD GHOO·DUULYR LQ FLWWj GL &HVDUH/ QHO FRUVR GHO &LQ0 TXHFHQWR/ 0RGHQD/ DQFKH D VHJXLWR GHOO·DWWXD]LRQH GD QRL GHOOD 5LIRUPD 7UL0 GHQWLQD/ HEEH/ FRL VXRL YHVFRYL H SHU LPSXOVR GXFDOH/ DG LQL]LDUH XQD YHUD H SURSULD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH1 8Q FDPELDPHQWR LQ PHJOLR DQFKH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD HGLOL]LR FKH SUHOXGHYD D TXDQWR VDUHEEH DYYHQXWR QHO 6HLFHQWR1 8Q ULQQRYD0 PHQWR FKH FRLQYROVH LO VDFUR1 *Lj QHO ;9, VHFROR/ GD (UFROH ,,/ O·HGLOL]LD VWDYD PRGLILFDQGR OD FLWWj H D ILQH VHFROR VH QRQ VL SRWHYD SDUODUH GL ULYROX]LRQH HGLOL]LD SRFR FL PDQFDYD1 /R VWHVVR 'XFD &HVDUH/ XRPR UHOLJLRVR DQFKH VH HEEH D ULFHYHUH XPLOLD]LRQL SURSULR GDOOD &KLHVD/ QHO VXR WUHQWHQQDOH JRYHUQR GL 0RGHQD43 IX SURSXOVLYR YHUVR O·HGLOL]LD VDFUD1 0ROWR OHJDWR DL &DSSXFFLQL FRQ O·LQWHUD FRUWH/ IHFH DOWUHVu FRVWUXLUH OD FKLHVD GL 6DQ 9LQFHQ]R SHU L SDGUL 7HDWLQL H TXHOOD GL 6DQ %DUWRORPHR SHU L *HVXLWL441 'XUDQWH LO VXR UHJQR IXURQR YHVFRYL/ ROWUH DO 6LOLQJDUGL/ /D]]DUR 3HOOLFFLDUL 2131/ 3HOOHJULQR %HUWDFFKL HG $OHVVDQGUR 5DQJRQL45> YHVFRYL FKH WXWWL GLHGHUR LPSXOVR/ LQ DFFRUGR FRQ LO 'XFD/ D YDULH LVWLWX]LRQL UHOLJLRVH1 6L SHQVL FKH IX IRQGDWD QHO 4939 OD &RPSDJQLD GHOOH 6WLPPDWH46> IX IRQGDWR LO FRQYHQWR GHOOH PRQDFKH GHWWH GHOOD 0DGRQQD +HUD JLj YHVFRYR PRQV1 %HU0 WDFFKL,/ H SXUH LO PRQDVWHUR GL VDQW·2UVROD H OD &RQJUHJD]LRQH GL 6DQ &DUOR471 ²²²²²²²² 43 &HVDUH IX GXFD GL 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH GDO 63 JHQQDLR 48<; DOOD PRUWH DYYHQXWD O·44 GL0 FHPEUH 495;1 44 6L YHGD DG HVHPSLR TXDQWR DIIHUPD /1 &+,$33,1, QHO VXR *OL (VWHQVL/ 0LODQR/ 'DOO·2JOLR/ 4<9:1 45 ,O 3HOOLFFLDUL GDO 493: DO 4943> LO %HUWDFFKL ILQR DO 495:> LO 5DQJRQH GLYHQQH YHVFRYR O·DQQR LQ FXL LO GXFD &HVDUH PRUu H VDUj WDOH ILQR DO 49731 46 ,O FXL FRPSLWR HUD GL DOEHUJDUH H PDQWHQHUH L SHOOHJULQL GL SDVVDJJLR LQ FLWWj1 47 1HO QRYHPEUH 4943 IX FDQRQL]]DWR SURSULR VDQ &DUOR %RUURPHR FKH HUD VWDWR DEDWH FRPPHQGDWDULR GL 1RQDQWROD GDO 4893 DO 48991 /D FKLHVD GL 6DQ &DUOR VDUj LQL]LDWD SRL QHO 49971 ,QWDQWR LO FXOWR GHO VDQWR VL IDFHYD VROLGR LQ WXWWR LO WHUULWRULR PRGHQHVH/ FRPH GLPR0 VWUD O·DUWH VDFUD GHO WHPSR1 3HU DOFXQL UDJLRQDPHQWL VL YHGD DG HVHPSLR LO WHVWR 5RFFD 0DODWLQD +*1&1 0217$1$5,/ 0RGHQD/ (GL]LRQL ,O )LRULQR/ 4<<9,1
:55
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
,QVRPPD/ D YHGHUH OH FRVH VROR LQ VXSHUILFLH/ VL SRWUHEEH FRQFOXGHUH FKH SRWHUH SROLWLFR H VSLULWXDOH LQ 0RGHQD D FDYDOOR IUD &LQTXH H 6HLFHQWR DJLYD0 QR DOO·XQLVRQR1 1RQ IX HVDWWDPHQWH VHPSUH FRVu/ VH VL SHQVD FKH/ FRQ LO &RQ0 FLOLR GL 7UHQWR +487804896,/ OD &KLHVD YHQQH DG HVHPSLR HVWURPHVVD GDOOD JH0 VWLRQH GHJOL RVSHGDOL FLWWDGLQL/ VX FXL FRQWLQXz D ULVHUYDUVL XQD VRUWD GL FRQ0 WUROOR LVSHWWLYR DWWUDYHUVR L VXRL YHVFRYL481 $ 0RGHQD JLj GDO 4874 JOL DQWLFKL LVWLWXWL RVSHGDOLHUL YHQQHUR DJJUHJDWL VRWWR OD GHQRPLQD]LRQH GL 6DQWD 8QLR0 QH> XQ LVWLWXWR FKH GHFDGGH SUHVWR H JLj QHO 4936 IXURQR HPDQDWH UHJROH SHU JOL DIILWWL GHL EHQL VWDELOL H VL SURLELURQR L VXEDIILWWL1 )X SUHVVDSSRFR LQ TXHO SHULRGR FKH &DSSXFFLQL H *HVXLWL SUHVHUR OH UHGL0 QL GHOOD VLWXD]LRQH +YLVWD OD FDWWLYD JHVWLRQH FRPXQDOH, H VL GHGLFDURQR DOOH RSHUH SLH/ IDFHQGR QDVFHUH RSHUH DVVLVWHQ]LDOL TXDOL O·2SHUD GHL 0HQGLFDQWL491 ,QVRPPD/ FKHFFKp VH QH GLFD/ VL HUD DYYLDWR XQ SURFHVVR GL ODLFL]]D]LRQH GHOO·DVVLVWHQ]D H L YHVFRYL GRYHWWHUR VH QRQ DVVLVWHUH SDVVLYL/ DOPHQR FRQWURO0 ODUH D GLVWDQ]D/ DJHQGR DWWUDYHUVR JOL RUGLQL UHOLJLRVL VXGGHWWL1 0ROWR DLXWDUR0 QR OD FKLHVD ORFDOH YDUL SHUVRQDJJL GL QRELOH VFKLDWWD/ FRPH DG HVHPSLR LO &RQWH 3DROR %RVFKHWWL/ GL DQWLFD IDPLJOLD JXHOID FKH QHO 4945 GLHGH YLWD DOOD &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHL 3UHWL 6HFRODUL GHWWL GHOOD %HDWD 9HUJLQH H GL 6DQ &DUOR/ H FRPH OD FHOHEUH SRHWHVVD 7DUTXLQLD 0RO]D FKH ODVFLz LQ HUHGLWj L SURSUL EHQL DOO·2VSLWDOH GHOOD &DGq4:1 6L SXz DOWUHVu VHJQDODUH QHO 4959 O·LVWLWX]LRQH LQ 61 *LRYDQQL GHO &DQWRQH GHO FRVLGGHWWR &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL FKH QHO 4997 VL WUDVIHULUj SUHVVR OD FKLHVD GL 6DQ &DUOR DVVXPHQGRQH LO QRPH1 1HOO·LQWUHFFLR PRGHQHVH GL VWRULD GHOOD &KLHVD H VWRULD SROLWLFD/ F·q OD YLFHQGD GHO GXFD FDSSXFFLQR/ FLRq GHOO·LPSURYYLVD DEGLFD]LRQH GHO GXFD $OIRQVR ,,, +VDOLWR DO SRWHUH GRSR OD PRUWH GHO SDGUH &HVDUH,/ FKH JLj LO 5: OXJOLR 495</ FLRq GRSR FLUFD VHWWH PHVL GL WURQR/ DEGLFD0 YD LQ IDYRUH GHO ILJOLR )UDQFHVFR SHU HQWUDUH QHOO·2UGLQH &DSSXFFLQR1 6HJXu D EUHYH +4963, OD SHVWH H GRSR GL HVVD YHQQH O·LPSHULRVR LPSXOVR FRVWUXWWLYR FKH SRUWz D HGLILFDUH OD &KLHVD GHO 9RWR/ PD SXUH D WUDVIRUPDUH LQ 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH OD GLPRUD GHJOL (VWH H D FRVWUXLUH OD VHGH VSOHQGLGD GL 6DVVXROR/ PHQ0 ²²²²²²²² 48
'HOLEHUD]LRQL GHO &RQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR/ VHVVLRQH 9,,/ FDSS1 9, H 9,, +487:, H VHVVLRQH ;;,,,/ FDS1 9,,, +4895,1 49 1HO 48<: HUD QDWR LQ FLWWj XQ UHFOXVRULR0RVSL]LR SHU LO PDQWHQLPHQWR H O·HGXFD]LRQH FULVWLDQD GHL PHQGLFDQWL FKH VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH GLYHQQH XQ RUIDQRWURILR1 4: /D &DGq R &DVD GL 'LR/ ULVDOLYD FRPH IRQGD]LRQH DO ODLFR *XJOLHOPR GHOOD &HOOD YLVVXWR QHO ;,,, VHFROR1
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:56
WUH D )LRUDQR QDVFHYD LO IXWXUR VDQWXDULR 0DULDQR +RUD %DVLOLFD 0LQRUH, GHOOD %191 GHO &DVWHOOR/ FLRq LO SL• LPSRUWDQWH VDQWXDULR PDULDQR GHO PRGHQHVH1 1RQRVWDQWH FHUWH UHDOL]]D]LRQL GHO SHULRGR/ VHFRQGR LO 5RPEDOGL4; L UDS0 SRUWL WUD 6DQWD 6HGH H SRWHUH GXFDOH/ DOPHQR DL SULPRUGL GHO UHJQR GL )UDQFH0 VFR ,/ IXURQR SHVVLPL1 1HO GLFHPEUH GHO 4966 LO SRHWD )XOYLR 7HVWL DJLYD SHU IDU DYHUH LO FDSSHOOR FDUGLQDOL]LR DO 3ULQFLSH 2EL]]R G·(VWH/ PD LO 3DSD 8UED0 QR 9,,, +XQ %DUEHULQL FKH UHJQz SHU TXDVL YHQW·DQQL, QRQ HUD IDYRUHYROH DL VLJQRUL PRGHQHVL1 $QFRUD QHO 496< VRQR ULDYYLDWH WUDWWDWLYH SHU OD QRPLQD D FDUGLQDOH GL 2EL]]R H TXDWWUR DQQL SULPD LO 3DSD DYHYD DPPRQLWR LO JLRYDQH 'XFD )UDQFHVFR , D ULVSHWWDUH L GLULWWL GHOOD 6DQWD 6HGH QHL IHXGL GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D1 ,O 57 VHWWHPEUH 4968 FL VDUj XQ PRQLWR SDSDOH FKH LQWLPDYD DO GXFD GL 0RGHQD GL ULWLUDUH OH VXH WUXSSH GDO 0LODQHVH1 (UD XQ YHUR H SURSULR EUDFFLR GL IHUUR H L %DUEHULQL/ VFULYH 5RPEDOGL/ H0 UDQR GHFLVL D GLVWUXJJHUH L GXFDWL HPLOLDQL SHU FRQJLXQJHUH %RORJQD H )HUUDUD FRQ 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D1 1HO 4974/ PHQWUH D 0RGHQD q YHVFRYR GHOO·DQQR SUHFHGHQWH 2EL]0 ]R G·(VWH/ LO 3DSD ID HQWUDUH OH VXH WUXSSH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL1 ,O 4; JHQQDLR 4975/ SHU JOL VWUDQL HTXLOLEUL GL SRWHUH GHO WHPSR/ q FRPXQTXH HOHWWR FDUGLQDOH XQ DOWUR (VWH/ 5LQDOGR H OD SDFH VL DYUj GRSR OD *XHUUD GL &DVWUR GHO 49761 6R0 OR DOOD ILQH GHO VHJXHQWH 4977 LO 'XFD WUDWWHUj FRQ LO 3RQWHILFH H LO 48 OXJOLR 4978 LO FDUGLQDOH 0D]]DULQR DFFRUGHUj D 5LQDOGR OD VXD SURWH]LRQH1 6L DYUj SRL OD FDPSDJQD IUDQFR0PRGHQHVH FRQWUR OR 6WDWR VSDJQROR GL 0LODQR H JOL DFFRUGL VHJXLUDQQR LO 5: IHEEUDLR 497<1 ,QWDQWR/ JLj LO 57 RWWREUH 497;/ FRQ OD 3DFH GL 9HVWIDOLD/ HUD WHUPLQDWD OD *XHUUD GHL 7UHQW·DQQL1 1HO 4983 FL IX LO 47ƒ *LXELOHR/ FRQ SDVVDJJLR SHU 0RGHQD GL XQ EXRQ IOXVVR GL SHOOHJULQL H FLz IDYRUu OD SLHWj SRSRODUH H O·D]LRQH LQ IDYRUH GHOOH FR0 VH VSLULWXDOL1 'RQQD 0DWLOGH %HQWLYRJOLR/ PRJOLH GL XQ 5DQJRQL/ ID FRVWUXLUH OD FKLHVD H LO FRQYHQWR GHOOH PRQDFKH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H +4984,4<1 $ VHJXLUH/ WUDPRQWHUj O·DVWUR SHU OR SL• JXHUULHUR GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ GD VHPSUH LPSHJQDWR LQ IDWLFRVH FDPSDJQH PLOLWDUL= LO 'XFD PRULUj LO 47 RWWREUH 498; D 6DQWKLj/ YLFLQR D 9HUFHOOL1 $YHYD IDWWR LQ WHPSR D VSRVDUVL WUH YROWH/ LO EHOOLFRVR 'XFD/ H O·XOWLPD FRQ /XFUH]LD %DUEHULQL QHO 4987/ VLFFKp LO 58 DSULOH 4988 HUD QDWR 5LQDOGR/ IXWXUR FDUGLQDOH H DQFKH IXWXUR GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ PHUFp OD ULQXQFLD D VXR WHPSR GHO FDSSHOOR FDUGLQDOL]LR/ FRPH VL GLUj1 (/ VHPSUH QHO 4988/ ²²²²²²²² 4;
21 520%$/',/ ,O GXFD )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH +495<0498;,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/
4<<51 4< 5LPDUUDQQR SHU FLUFD WUH VHFROL H SRL VL WUDVIHULUDQQR D 61 0LFKHOH GHL 0XFFKLHWWL QHO UHJJLDQR1
:57
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
F·HUDQR VWDWH OH QR]]H WUD LO ILJOLR GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ $OIRQVR/ H OD VHGLFHQQH /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ QLSRWH GHO FDUG1 *LXOLR 0D]]DULQR531 (UD YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD54 GD FLUFD XQ DQQR H OR VDUHEEH VWDWR SHU XQ TXDUWR GL VHFROR LO FRQWH (WWRUH , 0RO]D +4988049:<,/ VXFFHGXWR D PRQV1 5REHUWR )RQWDQD +497804987, FKH DYHYD FHOHEUDWR XQ VLQRGR GLRFHVDQR QHO 497: H SURPRVVR OD WUDVOD]LRQH GHOO·LPPDJLQH GHOOD %191 $XVLOLDWULFH GHO 3R0 SROR 0RGHQHVH LQ 61 *LRUJLR1 ,O 0RO]D FKH JOL VXFFHVVH DYUHEEH DYXWR OD IRU0 WXQD GL JRYHUQDUH OD FKLHVD ORFDOH QRQ VROR D OXQJR/ PD LQ XQ SHULRGR GL UH0 VSLUR/ ULVSHWWR DO SRWHUH GHJOL (VWH/ GRSR L WUDYDJOL GHL VXRL LPPHGLDWL SUHGH0 FHVVRUL1 ,O 0RO]D/ FRPH YHVFRYR WUDWWz FRQ WUH GXFKL= )UDQFHVFR ,/ VXR ILJOLR $OIRQVR ,9/ VSRVR GHOOD 0DUWLQR]]L PD FKH PRUu YHQWRWWHQQH QHO QRYHPEUH GHO 4993 GRSR DSSHQD GXH DQQL GL UHJQR/ H TXLQGL/ GDO 49:7/ FRQ )UDQFHVFR ,,/ ILJOLR GL $OIRQVR1 1HOO·LQWHUYDOOR GL WHPSR 4993049:7 HEEH OD YHQWXUD GL DYHU D FKH IDUH FRQ OD 5HJJHQWH/ PDGUH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ H FLRq /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ UHOLJLRVLVVLPD/ FKH VL DYYDOVH GL GXH EXRQL PLQLVWUL +LO FRQWH *LURODPR *UD]LDQL H LO JLXULVWD %DUWRORPHR *DWWL,/ QRQFKp GL XQ FRQIHVVRUH/ SDGUH $QGUHD *DULPEHUWL/ JH0 VXLWD FKH/ VH IHFH SDUODUH GL FOHULFDOL]]D]LRQH GHOOD FRUWH/ SXUH IX LQIOXHQWH LQ PRGR SRVLWLYR VX GL OHL1 )DFLOL DQQL SHU L UDSSRUWL FKLHVD ORFDOH0SRWHUH SROLWL0 FR/ TXHL FLUFD TXLQGLFL GXUDQWH L TXDOL IX HUHWWR LO FRQYHQWR GHOOH PRQDFKH GHOO·2UGLQH GHOOD 9LVLWD]LRQH H LQ FXL LO JUDQGH DYYHQLPHQWR +FKH GRYHYD UL0 VXOWDUH IDWDOH SHU OD EUDYD 5HJJHQWH,55 IX UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDO PDWULPRQLR GHOOD ILJOLD 0DULD %HDWULFH FRO 'XFD GL <RUN/ FLRq *LDFRPR 6WXDUW/ TXDUDQWHQQH HUHGH DO WURQR G·,QJKLOWHUUD561 /D PDGUH DFFRPSDJQz FRQ XQ SLFFROR VHJXLWR OD ILJOLD QHOOD WHUUD G·$OELRQH/ PD DO ULWRUQR LQ 0RGHQD LO 48 PDU]R 48:7 VL DFFRUVH FKH LO ILJOLR )UDQFHVFR ,, FKH DYHYD DSSHQD FRPSLXWR L 47 DQQL/ O·DYHYD HVDXWRUDWD1 *OL XOWLPL FLQTXH DQQL TXLQGL LQ FXL IX LQ FDULFD LO YHFFKLR YHVFRYR (WWRUH , 0RO0 ²²²²²²²² 53
/H QR]]H IXURQR FHOHEUDWH LO 63 PDJJLR 49881 6LFFRPH FRQ L YHVFRYL HUDYDPR JLXQWL D FLWDUH 2EL]]R G·(VWH/ ILJOLR GL $OIRQVR ,,, H IUDWHOOR GL )UDQFHVFR , H GHO FDUGLQDOH 5LQDOGR , +LO FDUGLQDOH 5LQDOGR ,, VDUj SRL GXFD FRQ LO QRPH GL 5LQDOGR,/ HFFR FKH QRPLQLDPR LO VXR VXFFHVVRUH/ PRQV1 5REHUWR )RQWDQD +49780 4987, FKH IX GDSSULPD VHJUHWDULR GHO FDUG1 $OHVVDQGUR G*(VWH1 55 ,O JRYHUQR GHOOD 0DUWLQR]]L IX WDOH FKH TXDOFXQR VFULVVH HVVHUH VWDWD OHL LO PLJOLRU GXFD GL 0RGHQD$ 56 /XL/ OR 6WXDUW/ HUD YHGRYR H FRQ GXH ILJOLH YLYHQWL> OHL/ 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH/ IXWXUD +H VIRUWXQDWD, UHJLQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD/ DYHYD 49 DQQL/ HVVHQGR QDWD QHO 498;1 54
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:58
]D/ LO SRWHUH SROLWLFR HUD LQ PDQR GL XQ UDJD]]R FKH VL DYYDOHYD GHL FRQVLJOL GHO FXJLQR &HVDUH ,JQD]LR/ DOWUR JLRYDQH DPEL]LRVR +H/ RYYLR/ LQ RPEUD/ DP0 EL]LRVL PLQLVWUL,1 6DOWz FRVu LO FRQVLJOLHUH0FRQIHVVRUH SDGUH *DULPEHUWL/ LQL]Lz XQ JRYHUQR OD FXL SULPD IDVH GXUz FLUFD 44 DQQL/ ILQR DO 49;857/ TXDQGR &H0 VDUH ,JQD]LR/ LO 56 JLXJQR/ IX DOORQWDQDWR H FHVVz GL LQIOXLUH VXOO·DOORUD YHQWLFLQTXHQQH )UDQFHVFR ,,1 ,Q TXHO WHPSR/ QDWXUDOPHQWH/ H FRQ YHVFRYR &DUOR 0RO]D +49:<049<3,/ L UDSSRUWL FRUWH0YHVFRYDWR HUDQR PXWDWL1 &L IX SRL XQ DOWUR FDPELR DOOD JXLGD GHOOD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH FKH HEEH FRPH SDVWRUH +OR VDUHEEH VWDWR SHU EHQ 58 DQQL, LO FRQWH PRQV1 /RGRYLFR 0DVGRQL1 /·DQFRU JLRYDQH GXFD GL 0RGHQD HUD SHUz DPPDODWR H PRUu D 6DVVXROR LO 9 VHWWHPEUH 49<7 ODVFLDQGR DSHUWR/ SRLFKp VHQ]D HUHGL/ LO SUREOHPD GHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH58/ SXUH VH GXH DQQL SULPD DYHYD VSRVDWR 0DUJKHULWD )DUQHVH1 $QFRUD XQD YROWD OH FLUFRVWDQ]H IDYRULURQR JOL LQWHUHVVL GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH1 9HQQH GHVLJQDWR FRPH VXFFHVVRUH GHO UDPR FROODWHUDOH OR ]LR GHO GHIXQWR VRYUDQR/ FLRq LO FDUGLQDOH 5LQDOGR/ DOORUD WUHQWDQRYHQQH/ FKH ULQXQFLz SURQ0 WDPHQWH +SHU FRQFHVVLRQH SDSDOH, DOOD SRUSRUD H IX GXFD591 8Q GXFD FKH111 %FRQVHUYz VHPSUH O·DXVWHULWj H OD JUDYLWj GHJOL RWWR DQQL LQ FXL HUD VWDWR FDU0 GLQDOH1 $PDYD PROWLVVLPR OD SDFH/ HG HEEH LQYHFH LO GRORUH GL YHGHUH VFRQ0 WUDUVL QHOOH SURSULH WHUUH JOL HVHUFLWL GHOOD )UDQFLD H GHOO·$XVWULD1 3HU EHQ GXH YROWH/ DQ]L/ GRYHWWH IXJJLUH FRQ OD IDPLJOLD D %RORJQD 0 WHUULWRULR SRQWLILFLR 0 PHQWUH D 0RGHQD HQWUDYDQR WUXSSH VWUDQLHUH%/ KD VFULWWR FRQ SDUWHFLSD]LRQH LO /HRQHOOL +LQ 0RGHQD/ SDVVDWR UHPRWR/ SDVVDWR SURVVLPR/ &DSULFRUQR/ 4<:6,1 8Q GXFD/ 5LQDOGR/ FKH DJu VXELWR EHQH H WUD L FXL PHULWL PHWWLDPR SXUH TXHOOR GL DYHUH FKLDPDWR D 0RGHQD XQ JLRYDQH SUHWH YLJQROHVH FKH DOORUD ODYRUDYD DOOD %LEOLRWHFD $PEURVLDQD GL 0LODQR/ FLRq /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL +QHO 4:33,1 0D LQWDQWR GLFLDPR GL FRPH IX FDULFD GL SHQVLHUL SHU LO YHVFRYR 0DVGRQL OD VXD PLVVLRQH FRQGRWWD IUD FDPEL GL DOOHDQ]H SROLWLFKH QHO PRGHQHVH H DE0 EDQGRQL GHOO·DXWRULWj SROLWLFD1 5LQDOGR FRO VXR PDWULPRQLR ULSRUWz O·DVVH GHOO·DOOHDQ]D GHJOL (VWH GDOOD )UDQFLD YHUVR O·$XVWULD H QHJOL DQQL GDO 4:35 DO ²²²²²²²² 57
,Q TXHOO·DQQR/ LO 56 DSULOH/ 0DULD %HDWULFH IX UHJLQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD1 &KH/ VL VD/ SHU JOL (VWH DYYHQLYD VROR SHU OLQHD PDVFKLOH1 59 (FFR DOFXQH LQIRUPD]LRQL SHU LQTXDGUDUH 5LQDOGR G·(VWH +49<704:6:,1 1DWR LO 58 DSUL0 OH 4988/ IX FDUGLQDOH GDO 5 VHWWHPEUH 49;9/ H GXFD GRSR OD ULQXQFLD GHOOD SRUSRUD LO 54 PDU]R 49<81 6L VSRVz FRQ &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD %UXQVZLFN0/XQHEXUJ FKH LO 5 OXJOLR 49<; GDYD DOOD OXFH LO IXWXUR )UDQFHVFR ,,,1 58
:59
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
4:3: F·HUD VWDWD O·RFFXSD]LRQH GHL WHUULWRUL GD OXL JRYHUQDWL GD SDUWH GHOOH WUXSSH IUDQFR0VSDJQROH1 ,O ULYROJLPHQWR/ LQ XQ GXFDWR HQGHPLFDPHQWH DIIOLW0 WR GD SRYHUWj H FDUHVWLH +O·XOWLPD JUDYLVVLPD HUD VWDWD QHJOL DQQL 49:90:</ PD QRQ HUD FKH VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH SHU L SRYHUL LO WHQRUH GL YLWD IRVVH PROWR FDP0 ELDWR, DYUHEEH GDWR DO FOHUR QHOOD SULPD SDUWH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR VSD]LR SHU DJLUH/ PD VL WUDWWDYD GL XQ LQVLHPH DQFRUFKp QXPHURVR/ VSHVVR LPSUHSDUDWR5:1 $O0 EHUWR %DUELHUL DIIHUPD5; FKH VX 6331333 DELWDQWL QHOO·LQWHUR GXFDWR/ YL HUDQR :333 HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ FLRq WURSSL +XQ VDFHUGRWH RJQL 73 IHGHOL, H LO YHVFRYR )R0 JOLDQL DYUHEEH SRL DQQRWDWR FKH LQYHFH GL HGLILFDUH GLVWUXJJRQR O·HFFOHVLDVWLFD GLVFLSOL0 QD$ &HUWR/ TXDVL WXWWL DVVLVWHYDQR DOOD PHVVD GRPHQLFDOH H WXWWL D 3DVTXD VL FRPXQLFDYDQR/ PD LO 0XUDWRUL/ LQ GXH SUHFLVL VFULWWL/ LO 'H VXSHUVWLWLRQH YLWDQGD H LO 'HOOD UHJRODWD GHYR]LRQH/ DYUHEEH VSHVR PROWR LQFKLRVWUR D IDUH GLVWLQ]LRQL RQHVWH H SUH]LRVH1 1HO 4:54 LO 0XUDWRUL DYHYD LVWLWXLWR O·2SHUD GHOOD &DULWj/ RWWR DQQL SULPD DYHYD LQFRUDJJLDWR LO SDGUH 3DROR 6HJQHUL MXQLRUH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV• D SUHGLFDUH QHO GXFDWR/ PD O·LJQRUDQ]D VLD GHL IHGHOL FKH GL FKL GRYHYD LVWUXLUOL HUD DOWLVVLPD1 ( D SUHRFFXSDUH LO VDQW·XRPR H L YHVFRYL 0DVGRQL SULPD H )R0 JOLDQL SRL/ F·HUD SXUH O·DWHLVPR FKH LQL]LDYD D IDU SURVHOLWL/ DVVLHPH D YDULH IRUPH +TXLHWLVPR H DOWUR, GL GHYLD]LRQL GDOOD IHGH FDWWROLFD1 6HPSUH LO %DUELH0 UL/ VFULYH FKH SRFR GRSR LO 4:63 D 0RGHQD VL LQL]Lz D SDUODUH GL 0DVVRQHULD FRQ DGHUHQWL GL IDPLJOLH QRELOL H GL LQWHOOHWWXDOL1 (UD LO VHFROR GHL OXPL FKH DYDQ]DYD/ LQVRPPD H OD UHD]LRQH GHOOD &KLHVD OR0 FDOH IX JXDUGLQJD/ WDQWRFKp *LXVHSSH 2UODQGL5< DIIHUPD FKH O·,QTXLVL]LRQH SRL VL DVWHQQH GD TXDOVLDVL VHULD LQGDJLQH VXL PDVVRQL1 6L JLXQVH TXLQGL DOOD ILQH GHO OXQJR UHJQR GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR63 FRQ XQD VLWXD]LRQH FKH LQ PRGR VRWWHUUDQHR PXWDYD LQ IUHWWD1 ,O 'XFD PRULYD QHO 4:6:/ FLQTXH DQQL SULPD GHO YHVFRYR 6WHIDQR )RJOLDQL FKH DYUHEEH LQL]LDWR D FRQIURQWDUVL FRO ILJOLR/ O·HUHGH DO GX0 FDWR GL 0RGHQD )UDQFHVFR ,,,1
²²²²²²²² 5:
6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL 111FLW1/ ,1 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL 111FLW1/ ,,1 5< *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL IUD 5LYROX]LRQH H 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/4:<304;48/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9:1 63 &KH HEEH D VXELUH XQ·DOWUD RFFXSD]LRQH GHL VXRL WHUULWRUL QHJOL DQQL 4:670691 5;
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:5:
6RFLHWj H &KLHVD PRGHQHVH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR 7RUQDQGR SHU XQ DWWLPR DOO·LQL]LR GHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ FKLDULDPR FKH LO UDS0 SRUWR &KLHVD0(VWH IX PROWR SDUWLFRODUH QHO SULPR TXDUDQWHQQLR/ H WRUPHQWD0 WR/ QRQRVWDQWH L WUDVFRUVL GHO GXFD H[ FDUGLQDOH1 (UD XQ XRPR GHILQLWR DXVWHUR/ 5LQDOGR H SLR H DXWRFUDWH/ FKH VH GD XQ ODWR DJLYD FRQ OH LGHH FKLDUH LQ WHPD GL UHOLJLRQH/ GDOO·DOWUR FRPELQz YDUL SDVWLFFL/ PHWWHQGRVL LQ FRQWUDVWR FRQ OD 6DQWD 6HGH641 1RQ IHFH FLRq HFFH]LRQH DO GHWWR FKH OH YLH GHOO·LQIHUQR VRQR ODVWUL0 FDWH GL EXRQH LQWHQ]LRQL= OXL/ GXFD GL IHUUR/ DYUHEEH YROXWR FRQLXJDUH O·LPSRVVLELOH H FLRq JOL LQWHUHVVL GHO VXR 6WDWR FRQ TXHOOL GHOOD &KLHVD1 8QR 6WDWR LO VXR/ G·DOWURQGH/ RYH F·HUD H FUHVFHYD XQ SUREOHPD GHIODJUDQ0 WH TXDOH LO SDXSHULVPR/ XQD SRYHUWj HQGHPLFD/ DVVROXWD/ DJJUDYDWD GDL GD]L/ GDO0 OH WDVVH H GDOOH EDUULHUH GRJDQDOL1 8QD SDWDWD EROOHQWH FKH SRL DYUHEEH HUHGL0 WDWR VXR ILJOLR/ LO WHU]R )UDQFHVFR H FKH/ FRQ OD GLIIXVLRQH GL QXRYH LGHH DQ0 FKH RVWLOL DOOD &KLHVD H DOOD UHOLJLRQH LQ JHQHUDOH/ VDUHEEH GLYHQXWD LO FUXFFLR GHO VXR UHJQDUH GLVWDQWH +DQFKH ILVLFDPHQWH, H IRQWH GL VFRQWUL FRQ LO WUDGL0 ]LRQDOH SRWHUH VSLULWXDOH651 )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ GXFD DOOD PRUWH GHO SDGUH/ SHU FLUFD XQ TXLQGLFHQQLR/ DQFKH SHUFKp RFFXSDWR VX YDUL YHUVDQWL/ QRQ WRFFz L UDS0 SRUWL FRQ OD &KLHVD ORFDOH1 $ PRQV1 6WHIDQR )RJOLDQL VXFFHVVH TXLQGL PRQV1 *LXOLDQR 6DEEDWLQL QHO 4:78 H D TXHVWR VFRORSLR H FHOHEUH RUDWRUH DPLFR GL SDSD %HQHGHWWR ;,9 +4:7304:8;, LO GXFD/ SXUH DPLFR GHO SDSD/ QRQ GHWWH GDSSULPD SHQVLHUL1 0D GDOOD VFRPSDUVD GL TXHO SRQWHILFH OH FRVH OHQWDPHQWH PXWDURQR1 *Lj QHO 4:84 VL LQL]Lz D SDUODUH GL IDU SDJDUH OH WDVVH D QRELOL H FOHUR H )UDQFHVFR ,,, ULXVFu DG RWWHQHUH LO EHQHSODFLWR SRQWLILFLR SHU REEOLJDUH LO FOH0 UR D GHQXQFLDUH O·HVDWWD FRQVLVWHQ]D GHL SURSUL EHQL Vu GD IDU SDJDUH VX GL HVVL O·LPSRVWD SUHGLDOH FKH IX ILVVDWD LQ ó +PHWj, GL TXHOOD SDJDWD GDL VHFRODUL1 &·HUD WXWWD XQD FRUUHQWH GHILQLELOH JLDQVHQLVWD ORFDOH FKH VRVWHQHYD D VSDGD WUDWWD OH SUHURJDWLYH GHO VRYUDQR H QHO 4:8:/ SURSULR O·DQQR LQ FXL VFRPSDUYH LO YHVFRYR 6DEEDWLQL D FXL VXFFHVVH PRQV1 *LXVHSSH 01 )RJOLDQL +4:8;04:;8,/ LQL]Lz XQ GXHOOR IUD L GXH SRWHUL IDWWR GL FDYLOOHVFKH RSSRVL]LRQL D 5RPD661 ²²²²²²²² 64
/1 6,0(21,/ /·DVVRUELPHQWR DXVWULDFR GHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH H OD SROLWLFD GHL GXFKL 5LQDOGR H )UDQFH0 VFR ,,,/ 0RGHQD/ &RRS1 7LSRJUDIL/ 4<4<1 65 &LUFD OD SRYHUWj/ VL SHQVL FKH OH JULGH GXFDOL FRQWUR L PHQGLFDQWL IXURQR XQD FRVWDQWH LQXWLOH SHU XQ SUREOHPD FKH QRQ SRWHYD FHVVDUH FRQ JOL VFULWWL GL SURLEL]LRQH1 $ XQ FHUWR PRPHQWR IXURQR FHQVLWL 54;:3 DELWDQWL LQ FLWWj GL FXL 9;64 SRYHUL H 435; TXHVWXDQWL$ 66 6L QRWL FKH OD VFRPSDUVD GL SDSD %HQHGHWWR ;,9 O·DQQR VHJXHQWH/ FLRq QHO 4:8;/ VSLD0
:5;
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
&RQWUR OH LVWLWX]LRQL H LQ JHQHUH OH FRVH OHJDWH DO VDFUR FL IXURQR RUGLQDQ0 ]H GXFDOL H )UDQFHVFR VL VFDJOLz +LQ OLQHD FRQ PROWL VXRL DQWHQDWL/ FRPH VRWWR0 OLQHz LO &DVROL, FRQWUR L *HVXLWL671 5LFRUGLDPR FKH QHO 4:95 HUD WHUPLQDWR LO *UDQGH 2VSHGDOH GHJOL ,QIHUPL YROXWR GDO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ OD FXL JHVWLRQH IX GL XQD FRQJUHJD]LRQH JHQHUDOH IDFHQWH FDSR DO PLQLVWUR GL %XRQ *RYHUQR1 3RL LO GXFD DYUHEEH VRSSUHVVR OD 6DQWD 8QLRQH SHU LVWLWXLUH O·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL LQ FXL FRQIOXLURQR WXWWL JOL LVWLWXWL H OH RSHUH SLH FLWWDGLQH1 1HO 4:97 YHQQHUR IXVH LQVLHPH WXWWH OH RSHUH SLH ORFDOL H QH QDFTXH O·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL L FXL SRVVHVVL VRQR VWDWL YDOXWDWL LQ 429 GHO FRQWDGR PRGHQHVH1 1HO 4:8: HUD VWDWR LVWLWXLWR LO FRVLGGHWWR 0DJLVWUDWR VRSUD OD *LXULVGL]LRQH FRQ WUH PHPEUL FKH HUDQR XQ FKLHULFR H GXH VHFRODUL/ SL• XQ VHJUHWDULR HFFOHVLD0 VWLFR681 ,O 46 PDJJLR GHO·8: LO 0DJLVWUDWR SURLEu OD SXEEOLFD H SULYDWD LQWURGX0 ]LRQH GL OLEUL/ OHWWHUH/ RSXVFROL H DOWUL VWDPSDWL VHQ]D OD VXD OLFHQ]D1 &LUFD XQ DQQR GRSR69 FL IX OD QRWLILFD SHU O·HVDPH GD SDUWH GHOOR VWHVVR 0DJLVWUDWR LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD FRVWLWX]LRQH GL SDWULPRQL D SURPXRYHQGL 2UGLQL1 7XWWR TXHVWR WRXUELOORQ GL GLVSRVL]LRQL DOODUPz OD 6DQWD 6HGH/ FKH HUD UHJRODUPHQWH LQIRUPDWD/ H SDSD &OHPHQWH ;,,, YROOH VDSHUH GDO YHVFRYR )RJOLDQL +VL HUD QHO 4:8<, TXHO FKH O·RUJDQR GXFDOH VXGGHWWR SURPXRYHYD FKH IRVVH FRQWUDULR DO0 OD LPPXQLWj HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 &LQTXH DQQL SL• DYDQWL QHO 4:97 YL IX XQD SURWHVWD XIILFLDOH URPDQD FRQ OR VFULWWR 5LVSRVWD DOOD 0HPRULD GHOOD &RUWH GL 5RPD GHO 4< JLXJQR 4:97 ULJXDUGDQWH LO PDJLVWUDWR VRSUD OD *LXULVGL]LRQH/ PD HUD RUPDL HYLGHQWH FKH LO GLVHJQR GXFDOH HUD TXHOOR GL VYLQFRODUH LO UHJQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, GDL YHFFKL OHJDPL GL IHXGDOLWj SDSDOH 1 $QFRUD WUH DQQL H IX HUHWWR LQ 0RGHQD LO –––––––– Qz/ SHU FRVu GLUH/ OD VWUDGD GHOOD FRQWHVWD]LRQH D )UDQFHVFR ,,, H DL VXRL PLQLVWUL1 67 31%1 &$62/,/ /D &KLHVD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL H LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL/ /D 6FXROD &DWWROLFD/ 4<351 68 3HU FDSLUH FRPH LO WHPSR DPDVVH L FRQWUDVWL/ ULFRUGLDPR FKH D FDSR GHO 0DJLVWUDWR VRSUD OH *LXULVGL]LRQL IX SRVWR O·DEDWH )HOLFH $QWRQLR %LDQFKL JHQRYHVH G·RULJLQH/ VHJUHWDULR GL JDEL0 QHWWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, H QHO 4:86/ FDSR GHOO·,QWHQGHQ]D *HQHUDOH VX WXWWD OD FRPXQLWj GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL1 4XHVWL/ VHJUHWDULR LQWLPR GHO GXFD/ HUD GL LGHH JLDQVHQLVWH/ D GHWWD GHO &DVROL/ H FHU0 FDYD FRQ VXFFHVVR GL PHWWHUH LQ PDOD OXFH L *HVXLWL1 1HO 4:66 HUD DUFLSUHWH D &DUSL H SRL SL• WDUGL VDUj YHVFRYR LQ SDUWLEXV GL 3HUJDPR H FRQVDFUDWR GDO YHVFRYR *LXVHSSH )RJOLDQL LQ 6DQW·$JRVWLQR1 0RULUj LO < DJRVWR 4::; QHOOD VXD YLOOD GL 6ROLHUD1 &HUWR IX LVSLUDWRUH GHOOD SR0 OLWLFD GXFDOH YHUVR OD FKLHVD ORFDOH FKH SRUWz +48 DJRVWR 4::7, DOOD QRWLILFD]LRQH SHU OD ULGX0 ]LRQH GD 4: D 8 GHOOH SDUURFFKLH XUEDQH GL 0RGHQD D FXL L SDUURFL VL DGHJXDURQR FRQ LO 4 JHQQDLR 4::81 69 4; OXJOLR 4:8;1
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:5<
'LFDVWHUR VXOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH H OD GLUH]LRQH GHL 0RQDVWHUL= LQVRPPD/ TXHVWR FRVWL0 WXHQGR 'LFDVWHUR HUD FUHDWR SHU YLJLODUH VX &RQIUDWHUQLWH HG 2VSHGDOL6:1 ,Q TXHO 4:9:/ LO 47 PDJJLR/ YL IX XQ HGLWWR VXOOH PDQLPRUWH= YLHWDYD OD FRVWLWX0 ]LRQH GL XOWHULRUL SDWULPRQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL$ ,O FDPELDPHQWR/ O·DPPRGHUQDPHQWR GHOOR 6WDWR FKH VSHVVR QRQ WHQHYD FRQWR GHOOH HVLJHQ]H GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH/ VL SURGXFHYD FRVu D JUDQGL SDVVL QHO WHUULWRULR HVWHQVH H QHO 4::4 YHQQH SURPXOJDWR LO &RGLFH (VWHQVH FKH SUHYHGH0 YD WUD O·DOWUR O·DEROL]LRQH GL JUDQ SDUWH GHL SULYLOHJL GHO )RUR (FFOHVLDVWLFR/ OD ILQH GHO GLULWWR GL DVLOR LQ FKLHVH H FRQYHQWL SHU L GHOLQTXHQWL FKH DYHVVHUR FRPPHVVR JUDYL UHDWL/ O·LPPLVVLRQH LQ FRPPHUFLR GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL FKH QRQ IRVVHUR VHUYLWL DOOD VRVWHQWD]LRQH GHO FOHUR H FRVu YLD1 $SSHQD OH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLDVWLFKH ORFDOL QHOOD SHUVRQD GHO YHVFRYR )RJOLDQL LQIRUPDURQR 5RPD/ YL IX XQD YLEUDWD SURWHVWD GHO SDSD «RYYLDPHQWH VHQ]D ULVXOWDWL1 /D PDFFKLQD VWDWDOH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, SURFHGHYD H LO 63 RWWREUH 4::5 LO 'LFDVWHUR GLYHQQH *LXQWD GL *LXULVGL]LRQH FKH VRUYHJOLDYD OH UHQGLWH GHL /XRJKL SLL ODLFDOL H DQFR0 UD QHO 4::6 SUHVH GHFLVLRQL FKH RYYLDPHQWH VFRQFHUWDURQR OD FXULD PRGHQH0 VH/ SHUFKp VL ULGXVVHUR H ILQDQFKH VRSSUHVVHUR L &RQYHQWL PDQFDQWL GHO QX0 PHUR FDQRQLFR H VL SUHVFULVVH O·REEOLJR GL XQD VXD OLFHQ]D D GDUH«OLFHQ]D GL SRUWDUH O·DELWR FOHULFDOH H D FRVWLWXLUH SDWULPRQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL H ILQDQFKH D LP0 PHWWHUH LQGLYLGXL QHL YDUL RUGLQL6;1 (YLGHQWHPHQWH LO FRQWUROOR GXFDOH HUD GLIILGHQWH YHUVR O·DXWRULWj HFFOHVLD0 VWLFD ORFDOH/ VH LO 54 IHEEUDLR GHO 4::7 OH &DQFHOOHULH YHVFRYLOL IXURQR LQYLWDWH D FRPXQLFDUH DQQXDOPHQWH OD QRWD GHL WRQVXUDWL H GHL SURPRVVL DO VXGGLDFRQD0 WR1 3ULPD GHOOD ILQH GHO UHJQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, VL HEEHUR DGGLULWWXUD QRUPH SHU O·DSHUWXUD H OH IXQ]LRQL VHUDOL QHOOH FKLHVH6<1 1HO 4::8 YLHQH SUHVHQWDWR LO 3LDQR GL UHJRODPHQWR SHU O·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL H LQWDQWR QHOOR VWHVVR DQQR D &OHPHQWH ;,9 HUD VXFFHVVR SDSD *LRYDQQDQJHOR %UDVFKL/ FLRq OR VIRUWXQD0 WR 3LR 9,73/ FKH JLj QHO 4::: ULQQRYz OD ULFKLHVWD IDWWD GDO VXR SUHGHFHVVRUH GL JLXQJHUH D XQ &RQFRUGDWR FRQ JOL (VWH> ULFKLHVWD FLUFD OD TXDOH LO GXFD QLF0 FKLDYD1 ²²²²²²²² 6: 6;
'DWD GL FRVWLWX]LRQH GHO 'LFDVWHUR 4 JLXJQR 4:9:1 6L QRWL SHU LQFLVR FKH LO 4::6 q O·DQQR LQ FXL YHQQH VFLROWD D 0RGHQD OD &RPSDJQLD GL
*HV•1 6<
,Q GDWD 4; PDU]R 4:::1 /H FXL GXUH YLFHQGH GL ILQH SRQWLILFDWR VRQR GD PH VWDWH ULFRVWUXLWH= ,Q 0RGHQD 4:<<= XQ SDSD YHUVR O·HVLOLR/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQ0 FLH PRGHQHVLª V1 ;,/ ;9,,+4<<8,1 73
:63
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
4XDQGR 3LR 9, UHLWHUz OD ULFKLHVWD/ HVVD QRQ SURFHGHWWH SHU OD PRUWH VR0 SUDYYHQXWD D 9DUHVH LO 55 IHEEUDLR 4:;3 GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,1 $ OXL VXFFHGHYD LPPHGLDWDPHQWH LO ILJOLR (UFROH +(UFROH ,,,/ SHU OD VWRULD,74 FKH RYYLDPHQWH DYUHEEH SURVHJXLWR OD SROLWLFD SDWHUQD FLUFRQGDQGRVL GL HVSHUWL FROODERUDWRUL TXDOL O·HFRQRPLVWD /RGRYLFR 5LFFL/ LO FRQWH *KHUDUGR 5DQJRQL H LO FRQWH *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 0XQDULQL FKH VDUj LO VXR DXWHQWLFR EUDFFLR GHVWUR1 6L GHYH LQQDQ]LWXWWR ULOHYDUH FKH OH LGHH GL (UFROH ,,, HUDQR TXHOOH GL XQ VRYUDQR LO0 OXPLQDWR H ULIRUPLVWD FKH LQ JLRYHQW• HUD VWDWR DOOLHYR GL /1$1 0XUDWRUL/ LO TXDOH DGGLULWWXUD JOL GHGLFz XQ·RSHUD/ FRP·HUD XVR D TXHL WHPSL H FLRq 5XGL0 PHQWL GL ILORVRILD PRUDOH SHU LO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR1 ( F·q GD DJJLXQJHUH FKH TXDQGR HUHGLWz DSSXQWR LO GXFDWR/ JOL DSSRJJL GL 5LFFL H 0XQDULQL JOL IXURQR SUH]LRVL1 /·XOWLPR JRYHUQz OD FLWWj GDO 4:;9 DO 4:<9 HG q UHVSRQVDELOH GHOOD SROLWLFD GL ULGX]LRQH +SHUDOWUR VHFRQGR XQD FHUWD RWWLFD QRQ GHO WXWWR HUUDWD, GHL UHOLJLRVL> LO 5LFFL +4:7504:<<,/ JUDQGH WHRULFR/ q FROXL FKH LQ SUDWLFD PHWWH VRWWR DFFXVD LO SUHFHGHQWH VSLULWR ILODQWURSLFR/ LQVHUHQGR QHOOH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH GHOOR 6WDWR PRGHUQR OD FDSDFLWj GL RYYLDUH DO SDXSHULVPR DVVLVWHQ]LDOLVWLFR1 (UD XQ ODXUHDWR LQ OHJJH FKH QHO 4:;9 HEEH O·LQFDULFR GDSSULPD GL VLVWHPDUH O·DUFKLYLR VHJUHWR GHO &RPXQH H SRL/ GDOO·DQQR VHJXHQWH/ IX PLQLVWUR GL (UFROH ,,,1 6FULVVH GXH RSHUH FKH LQWHUHV0 VDQR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LO UDSSRUWR FKLHVD PRGHQHVH0SRWHUH SROLWLFR H FLRq XQ 3LDQR GL ULIRUPD GL WXWWH OH RSHUH SLH H XQ 3LDQR GL ULIRUPD GHOO·HVWLPR GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQ0 VL1 'RSR OD IXJD GHO GXFD (UFROH/ DYUj LQFDULFKL SXUH QHOOH 5HSXEEOLFKH &L0 VSDGDQD H &LVDOSLQD H PRULUj/ DQFRU UHODWLYDPHQWH JLRYDQH/ QHO 4:<</ D 0R0 GHQD1 5HVWDQGR DL UDSSRUWL FRQ OD FKLHVD ORFDOH/ GD VXELWR VL HEEH OD PLVXUD GHOOD FRQWLQXLWj FRQ OD SROLWLFD SUHFHGHQWH= LO 45 PDU]R 4:;5 YHQQH HPDQDWD OD GL0 VSRVL]LRQH VHFRQGR OD TXDOH HUD SURLELWD O·HUH]LRQH GL QXRYL RUDWRUL SXEEOLFL H GL LQWHUYHQLUH VX TXHOOL LQ URYLQD VHQ]D LO SHUPHVVR GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH H D PDJJLR IX SURLELWD O·DFFHWWD]LRQH QHJOL LVWLWXWL 5HOLJLRVL GL SHUVRQH VHQ]D SUH0 YLD OLFHQ]D751 ,O FDPELDPHQWR HUD FRPXQTXH GHVWLQDWR D SURGXUUH HIIHWWL DOO·DOWH]]D GHL WHPSL/ FRPH TXDQGR LO 9 VHWWHPEUH 4:;8 IX VRSSUHVVR LO 7UL0 EXQDOH GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH OD FXL IDFROWj HUD ULVHUYDWD DL 9HVFRYL1 &Lz GHWWR/ DI0 IHUPDUH FKH FRPXQTXH OD FKLHVD QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH HUD VRJJHWWD DJOL DUELWULL GHO SRWHUH FLYLOH QRQ q SRL D]]DUGDWR H OD IDWLFD GL DUJLQDUH TXHVWR VWUDSRWHUH SDVVz ²²²²²²²² 74 75
(UFROH ,,, HUD QDWR QHO 4:5:1 *OL DFFHWWDWL GRYHYDQR DYHUH DOPHQR 53 DQQL FRPSLXWL1
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:64
QHO 4:;8 GDO YHVFRYR )RJOLDQL DO 0DUFKHVH PRQV1 7LEXU]LR &RUWHVH76 FKH FRO VXR OXQJR JRYHUQR VSLULWXDOH DYUHEEH WUDJKHWWDWR OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH LQ SLH0 QR VHFROR ;,; +PRULUj QHO 4;56,1 7UD L GLVSLDFHUL FKH LO SHU DOWUL YHUVL ´EXRQµ (UFROH ,,, GLHGH DO YHVFRYR &RUWHVH/ GREELDPR DQQRYHUDUH OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOH PHQVH YHVFRYLOH H FRPXQH/ LO &DSLWROR GHL FDQRQLFL GL 6DQ *LURODPR/ OD FRPPHQGD GL 6DQ *LRYDQQL771 ( FRQ OH VRSSUHVVLRQL GL HQWL/ DQFKH TXHOOH GL YDULH FKLHVH TXDOL 6DQ /R0 UHQ]R/ 6DQ 0DUFR/ 6DQ 5RFFR/ 6DQ 6DOYDWRUH/ 6DQW·$QWRQLR DEDWH/ 6DQ &DUOL0 QR 5RWRQGR/ 6DQWD 0DULD GHOOD 1HYH H GL FRQYHQWL TXDOL 6DQ 3LHWUR/ 6DQW·(XIHPLD/ 6DQW·$JRVWLQR/ 6DQW·2UVROD/ 6DQ )UDQFHVFR GL 3DROD/ 6DQWD 0DULD 0DGGDOHQD/ LO &RUSXV 'RPLQL/ OH 6DOHVLDQH/ OH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H/ QRQFKp O·DOORQWDQDPHQWR GD 0RGHQD GL 7HDWLQL/ 6HUYLWL/ $JRVWLQLDQL/ IUDWL GHO 7HU]R 2UGLQH )UDQFHVFDQR VHFRODUL]]DWR/ HG LQILQH O·DEROL]LRQH GL QXPHURVH FRQIUDWHUQLWH781 6H VL DJJLXQJH OD ULGX]LRQH GHOO·DVVH HFFOHVLDVWLFR SHU FXL IX0 URQR LQFDPHUDWH 991887 ELROFKH79/ VL FDSLUj FRVD GRYHWWH SURYDUH LO YHVFRYR &RUWHVH1 0D LO SHJJLR GRYHYD DQFRUD DUULYDUH H LO YHQWR GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH GHO 4:;< OR SUHDQQXQFLz7:1 &RPH QRQ EDVWDVVH/ LO QXRYR IX SUHFHGXWR GD TXDOFRVD GL WUHPHQGDPHQWH FLFOLFR= XQ 4:<8 GL IDPH H IUHGGR FKH PLVH LQ JL0 ²²²²²²²² 76 0RQV1 7LEXU]LR &RUWHVH FRQ LO VXR OXQJR JRYHUQR GHOOD GLRFHVL JHPLQLDQD FDYDOFz OD VWRULD GHOOD 5LYROX]LRQH H GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH1 77 'D 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL 111FLW1/ ,,1 78 'D 6WRULD GHOO·$UFLGLRFHVL 111FLW1/ ,1 79 *1 25/$1',/ , UHOLJLRVL QHOOD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD WUD ¶:33 H ¶;33 +, 3DUWH,1 *OL XOWLPL GHFHQQL GHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ 5RPD/ 4<<61 7: 3HU GDUH XQ SL• DPSLR UHVSLUR GL FRQRVFHQ]D GHO WHPSR GL (UFROH ,,,/ GLDPR DOFXQH LQIRUPD]LRQL SUHVH GDOOH QRWH GL *LXVHSSH *RUDQL/ YLVVXWR WUD LO 4:73 H LO 4;4<1 4XHVWR YLDJ0 JLDWRUH FXULRVR VFULVVH DSSXQWL SRL VWDPSDWL D 3DULJL QHO 4:<6 H ULVWDPSDWL GD QRL QHO 4<;: +*1 *25$1,/ 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;:,/ D FXUD GL *1 &$&,$*/,1 *RUDQL IX GD QRL QHOO·DOORUD GXFDWR QHO 4:;4 H SDUOD GL QXPHURVL FRQYHQWL HOL0 PLQDWL GD )UDQFHVFR H GDO ILJOLR (UFROH1 $IIHUPD FKH HVLVWHYDQR 65 SDUURFFKLH +VLDPR D ILQH 6HWWHFHQWR, H FKH 43 VDUHEEHUR VXIILFLHQWL H QH KD VRSSUHVVH 53 +HUDQR 84/ R 85 11,1 (FFR DOWUH LQIRUPD]LRQL GDO *RUDQL FKH FL SDUH LQWHUHVVDQWH ULSUHQGHUH= OD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD KD XQD UHQGLWD GL 6833 VFXGL URPDQL> OD GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR KD XQD UHQGLWD GL 7333 VFXGL URPDQL> OD GLRFHVL GL &DUSL YDOH 933 VFXGL> LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD q VXI0 IUDJDQHR GHOO·DUFLYHVFRYR GL %RORJQD> OD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD FRQWD 4;6 SDUURFFKLH +65 FLWWj,> OD GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR FRQWD 553 SDUURFFKLH> OD GLRFHVL GL &DUSL FRQWD 49 SDUURFFKLH1 7DQWR SHU FDSLUH TXHVWL GDWL/ VL SHQVL FKH OD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD01RQDQWROD QHO 4<84 FRPSUHQGHYD 558 SDUURFFKLH1
:65
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
QRFFKLR OH QRVWUH FDPSDJQH1 9HQQH OD SULPDYHUD H SRL/ FRQ O·DYYLFLQDUVL GL 1DSROHRQH/ OD ILQH GL XQ·HSRFD1 (UFROH ,,, GHFLVH GL ODVFLDUH 0RGHQD GRSR O·DUPLVWL]LR GL &KHUDVFR FKH UHQGHYD OLEHUL L IUDQFHVL GL SXQWDUH FRQWUR 0LOD0 QR1 6HWWH JLRUQL SULPD GL TXHVWD RFFXSD]LRQH +D 0LODQR 1DSROHRQH HQWUz LO 47 PDJJLR 4:<9,/ LO GXFD (UFROH ,,, G·(VWH/ ODVFLDQGR LQ 0RGHQD XQ &RQVL0 JOLR GL *RYHUQR/ VH QH DQGz YHUVR %RORJQD H SRL 9HQH]LD1 /·DQWLFR UHJLPH WHUPLQDYD1 ,O GXFD QRQ VDUHEEH SL• WRUQDWR7;1 9HQWL GL ULYROX]LRQH H FKLHVD PRGHQHVH +4:<904;48, /D YHQWLQD VFDUVD GL DQQL FKH YD GD 0RGHQD UHSXEEOLFDQD DOOD 5HVWDXUD0 ]LRQH GHILQLWD GDO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD/ SHU OD FKLHVD GL 0RGHQD IX FDULFD GL SHQH H VRYHQWH GL XPLOLD]LRQL1 %DVWL SHU WXWWL SHQVDUH DOO·DUULYR LQ FLWWj +63 PDU]R 4:<<, GHO YHFFKLR SDSD 3LR 9, FKH VDUj ULFHYXWR FRQ WLPRUH GD FOHUR H FDWWROLFL VLQFHUL/ GDWD O·DWPRVIHUD FKH OD SRSROD]LRQH UHVSLUDYD/ SHU FRVu GLUH1 ,Q YHULWj/ VH OH FURQDFKH RQHVWH GL TXHO SHULRGR FL VRQR UHVH FRQ GRYL]LD/ H VL ULFRUGL VROR OD SRWHQ]D GHJOL VFULWWL GHO VDFHUGRWH GRQ $QWRQLR 5RYDWWL7</ QRQ VL SXz HYLWDUH XQ VHQVR GL SHQD QHO SHQVDUH FRQ DQLPR UHOLJLRVR D TXHL PR0 PHQWL1 $G HVHPSLR/ GRSR OD IXJD GHO GXFD/ TXDQGR LO 53 DJRVWR 4:<9 VL VHSSH FKH D 5HJJLR (PLOLD HUD VWDWD SURFODPDWD OD UHSXEEOLFD/ XQD IROOD GL LQYDVDWL VL SUHFLSLWz QHL FRQYHQWL GL 6DQ 3LHWUR H GL 6DQ 'RPHQLFR/ PLQDFFLDQGR L PRQDFL H GHYDVWDQGR LQWRUQR1 3L• FKH QRWD H FLWDWD q OD VXFFHVVLYD VFHQD GHO SLDQWDPHQWR GL XQ DOEHUR GHOOD OLEHUWj LQ 3LD]]D *UDQGH H GHO FDRV FKH SURGXV0 VH SXUH GXH PRUWL +WUD FXL XQD SRYHUD GRQQD,1 /D FKLHVD FHUFz XQ DFFRUGR FRQ 1DSROHRQH FKH SURPLVH H QRQ PDQWHQQH= OH FKLHVH IXURQR FKLXVH HG RF0 FXSDWH SHU IDUQH GHSRVLWL PLOLWDUL83> L UHOLJLRVL GRYHWWHUR VYHVWLUVL> OH FRPSD0 JQLH H FRQIUDWHUQLWH IXURQR VFLROWH1 7XWWR O·LPSLDQWR UHOLJLRVR SURGRWWR GD VHFROL GL WUDGL]LRQL ORFDOL VDOWz/ LQVRPPD/ H L SL• LQYDVDWL GLFKLDUDYDQR +q VWR0 ULD YHFFKLD, FKH 'LR q 0RUWR$ )X SURSULR LO YHVFRYR &RUWHVH D PDQWHQHUH WUD L VXRL XQD FHUWD FDOPD LQ TXHOOD WUHPHQGD SURYD H FRQIXVLRQH H DQFKH VH QHO 4:<; YHQQH RUGLQDWR FKH RJQL VHJQR GL FXOWR VSDULVVH GDOOH SXEEOLFKH YLH H SLD]]H/ QRQ HUD FRQ GHFUHWL ²²²²²²²² 7;
0RULUj D 7UHYLVR QHO 4;361 2UD SXEEOLFDWH SHU FRQWR GHOOD )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD1 83 )X LO FDVR GL 6DQ )UDQFHVFR H 6DQ *LRUJLR1 7<
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:66
HG RUGLQL VFRQVLGHUDWL FKH VL SRWHYD XFFLGHUH OD UHOLJLRVLWj841 /·44 JLXJQR 4:<</ GRSR FKH QHO PRGHQHVH VL HUDQR ULYLVWH OH WUXSSH LPSHULDOL/ OD FLWWj IX RFFXSDWD GD FLUFD 531333 VROGDWL QDSROHRQLFL JXLGDWL GDO JHQHUDOH 0DF 'R0 QDOG FKH VH QH DQGDURQR SULPD FKH TXHOO·DQQR ILQLVVH1 4XHOOD FKH UHVWDYD H DXPHQWDYD HUD OD SRYHUWj/ PHQWUH/ SHU FRQWUR FRQ OH FRQILVFKH GHL EHQL UHOL0 JLRVL XQD SLFFROD VFKLHUD GL ERUJKHVL VL DUULFFKLYD LPSURYYLVDPHQWH H VPRGD0 WDPHQWH1 (· OD FRQVXHWD OH]LRQH GHOOH ULYROX]LRQL/ LQVRPPD/ FKH FDQFHOODQR LO YHF0 FKLR +R FRVu YRUUHEEHUR IDUH,/ PD QRQ IDQQR VRUJHUH XQ QXRYR YHUDPHQWH PLJOLRUH/ VH QRQ D SUH]]R GXUR SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHO SRSROR1 6HPSUH FLU0 FD OD VLWXD]LRQH GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH/ VL HUD SDVVDWL GDOO·DVVRJJHWWDPHQWR D XQ YHFFKLR SRWHUH FKH DYHYD DYXWR O·DPEL]LRQH GL GLYHQWDUH DVVROXWDPHQWH VWD0 WDULR +TXHOOR GHL GXFKL FRPH )UDQFHVFR ,,, H (UFROH ,,,/ SHU LQWHQGHUFL,/ DG XQR QRPLQDOPHQWH DVVROXWDPHQWH SRSRODUH FRQ LO TXDOH QRQ VL SRWHYD IDUH DOWUR +VL GLFH GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH, FKH HVVHUH PRUELGL H VSHUDUH LQ FDPELDPHQWL FKH HUDQR SRL FRQWLQXL URYHVFLDPHQWL1 6·q GHWWR GHL IUDQFHVL FKH YHQQHUR/ GHJOL LPSHULDOL FKH WRUQDURQR QHO 4:<< H SRL GHO ULDFFDVDPHQWR GD QRL GHL IUDQFHVL1 6L GHYH ULEDGLUH FKH OH WUXSSH GL 0DF 'RQDOG VH QH DQGDURQR YHUVR ILQH ¶<< SHU FXL VL ULSDUOz GL 5HJJHQ]D H ULWRUQR DOO·DQWLFR/ PD JLj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j QHO PDJJLR 4;36 DYHYD RWWHQXWR ULVXOWDWL ULDSUHQGR FRQYHQWL H FRO0 OHJL851 1HJOL DQQL VHJXHQWL IX XQ FRQWLQXR DUUDEDWWDUVL SHU DYHUH XQ RUGLQH GL ²²²²²²²² 84 ,O 'LUHWWRULR GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVDOSLQD GLHGH O·RUGLQH GL FDQFHOODUH RJQL VHJQR SXEEOL0 FR GL FXOWR LO 4: GL 0HVVLGRUR/ FLRq LO 8 OXJOLR 4:<;1 4XL QRQ q LO FDVR GL GLUH GHOOR VFRQFHUWR GL WDQWL VHPSOLFL FLWWDGLQL H DELWDQWL GHO FRQWDGR1 85 5DPPHQWLDPR FKH SULPD OH VLQJROH OHJLVOD]LRQL ORFDOL HG L UDSSRUWL WUD &KLHVD H 6WDWR VL EDVDYDQR VX XQ &RQFRUGDWR GHO 48 OXJOLR 4;34 WUD 3LR 9, H 1DSROHRQH LQ TXDOLWj GL 3ULPR &RQVROH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD )UDQFHVH1 0D HUD XQ &RQFRUGDWR QRQ ULFRQRVFLXWR GDO SRQWHILFH LQ TXDQWR 1DSROHRQH/ FRQ XQR GHL VXRL IUHTXHQWL JHVWL XQLODWHUDOL/ OR DYHYD QRWLILFDWR FRQ O·DJJLXQWD DUELWUDULD GHJOL ´$UWLFROL 2UJDQLFLµ GHOO·; DSULOH 4;351
:67
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
D]LRQH SDVWRUDOH H VL JLXQVH DO 4;43/ TXDQGR XQ GHFUHWR LPSHULDOH86 VRSSUHV0 VH WXWWH OH FRQJUHJD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH/ HVFOXGHQGR TXHOOH LPSHJQDWH QHJOL RVSH0 GDOL/ QHOOH IRUPH FDULWDWLYH H QHOO·HGXFD]LRQH1 /·LGHD/ LQ IRQGR QRQ QHJDWLYD/ HUD FKH OD YLWD UHOLJLRVD VL GRYHVVH RUJDQL]]DUH DWWRUQR DOOD SDUURFFKLD/ FRVD FKH DO YHVFRYR &RUWHVH IDFHYD SLDFHUH FRPH SDVWRUH PRGHQHVH871 ,QWDQWR OD VWRULD DQGDYD YHUVR O·LQHOXWWDELOH SUHVHQWD]LRQH GL FRQWL DQFKH SHU LO %RQDSDUWH1 &L IX OD &DPSDJQD GL 5XVVLD H LQL]Lz LO WUDPRQWR LQDUUHVWD0 ELOH GHOO·DVWUR PLOLWDUH0SROLWLFR IUDQFHVH1 1HO 4;46 VHPEUDYD HVVHUVL ULDJJLX0 VWDWR LO UDSSRUWR WUD &KLHVD H ,PSHUDWRUH FRQ LO &RQFRUGDWR GL )RQWDLQEOHDX +58 JHQQDLR,/ PD JLj LO 57 PDJJLR VXFFHVVLYR/ FRQ XQD OHWWHUD D 1DSROHRQH/ SDSD 3LR 9,, ULWUDWWz JOL DFFRUGL ULWHQXWL LQJLXVWL1 ,Q SUDWLFD/ O·,PSHUDWRUH IUDQFHVH VL DPPRUELGLYD/ PDQ PDQR FKH OD VXD IRUWXQD YHQLYD D PDQFDUH/ H LQILQH VL HEEH OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH PRGHQHVH FRQ O·DUULYR GL XQ GXFD/ )UDQFHVFR ,9 G·$XVWULD0(VWH/ FKH HUD QLSRWH GHO GHIXQWR (UFROH ,,,88 H FKH JLXQVH LQ FLWWj LO 48 OXJOLR 4;4789/ LVWLWXHQGR XQ SODWRQLFR &RQVLJOLR GL 6WDWR GHVWLQDWR D QRQ PDL ULXQLUVL1 (UD OD ILQH GL XQ SHULRGR H LO UL0 WRUQR GHOO·DQFLHQ UpJLPH= LO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD8: DYUHEEH D EUHYH ILVVDWR LO QXRYR FRUVR FKH SHU OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH VLJQLILFz GDYYHUR XQD OHQWD ULQDVFL0 WD H ULRUJDQL]]D]LRQH1 'DOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH D )UDQFHVFR 9= FRQFRUGDWL H FDPELDPHQWL 1RQ q SRVVLELOH/ QHO FRQWLQXDUH LO GLVFRUVR VXL UDSSRUWL IUD FKLHVD PRGH0 QHVH H SRWHUH SROLWLFR/ LJQRUDUH FKH/ QHO SUHQGHUH SRVVHVVR GHO VXR GXFDWR/ )UDQFHVFR ,9 GLFKLDUz SXEEOLFDPHQWH GL YROHU GLIHQGHUH LO EHQH GDOOD 6DQWD 5HOLJLRQH &DWWROLFD1 4XHVWR q LPSRUWDQWH/ LQ TXDQWR/ FRQ LO SHQXOWLPR GXFD GL ²²²²²²²² 86
1DSROHRQH %RQDSDUWH HUD VWDWR SURFODPDWR LPSHUDWRUH QHO 4;37/ LO 4; PDJJLR1 &Lz JOL SHUPHWWHYD GL FRQWUROODUH LO FOHUR VHFRODUH H JOL HYLWDYD PROWH JUDQH FRQ TXHOOR UHOLJLRVR1 88 (UFROH ,,, HUD PRUWR D 7UHYLVR LO 47 RWWREUH 4;36 H VXD ILJOLD 0DULD %HDWULFH 5LFFLDUGD DYHYD VSRVDWR )HUGLQDQGR G·$VEXUJR0/RUHQD/ XQR GHL ILJOL GL 0DULD 7HUHVD G·$XVWULD1 (FFR TXLQGL LO QXRYR UDPR $XVWUR0(VWHQVH1 89 )UDQFHVFR ,9 HUD QDWR LO 9 RWWREUH 4::< HG HUD VSRVDWR GDO 4;451 3ULPD GL YHQLUH D SUHQGHUH SRVVHVVR FRPH DUFLGXFD GHO UHJQR FKH HUD VWDWR GHO QRQQR PDWHUQR (UFROH ,,,/ D 0RGHQD GDO < IHEEUDLR 4;47 YL HUD VWDWD XQD 5HJJHQ]D FKH DYHYD SURYYHGXWR DG LQYLDUH D 9LHQQD XQD GHSXWD]LRQH ORFDOH SHU RPDJJLDUH LO QRYHOOR VRYUDQR1 8: /·DWWR ILQDOH GHO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD VL HEEH LO < JLXJQR 4;481 87
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:68
0RGHQD VLDPR GDYDQWL D XQ XRPR OD FXL SHUVRQDOLWj SXz VFRQFHUWDUH/ PD FKH DYHYD XQ VXR ULJLGR FRGLFH GL FRPSRUWDPHQWR H SHQVDYD DO SHUVRQDOH SRWHUH LQ SDUDOOHOR D TXHOOR VSLULWXDOH QHO TXDOH VLQFHUDPHQWH FUHGHYD1 ( VH WDOXQL VXRL JHVWL GL VRYUDQR VRQR VWDWL VHYHUL/ TXDVL LQFRQFLOLDELOL FRQ OD VXD GLFKLDUDWD IHGH/ SXUH VWD QHOO·HWLFD FRPSOHVVLYD/ QHO VXR EDJDJOLR FXOWX0 UDOH/ OD VSLHJD]LRQH +H QRQ VHPSUH OD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH, GHO VXR DJLUH QHO SL• FKH WUHQWHQQDOH JRYHUQR GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL1 *LXQWR D 0RGHQD DOOD PHWj GL OXJOLR GHO 4;47/ LQYLWDWR GD XQD GHSXWD]LRQH FKH HUD DQGDWD ILQR D 9LHQQD DG R0 PDJJLDUOR/ )UDQFHVFR ,9/ FRQ XQ 'HFUHWR GHO 5; DJRVWR/ LVWLWXu XQD ,QWHQGHQ]D JHQHUDOH GHL EHQL FDPHUDOL/ DOORGLDOL HG (FFOHVLDVWLFL H YL PLVH D FDSR LO FRQWH /XLJL *XLFFLDUGL8;1 3HU TXHO FKH ULJXDUGD L UDSSRUWL FRQ OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH/ L EHQL DQQRYHUDWL HUDQR TXHOOL FKH IXURQR LQFDPHUDWL GDO SUHFHGHQWH *RYHUQR SR0 VWHULRUPHQWH DO &RQFRUGDWR IDWWR LO Gu 49 VHWWHPEUH4;36 FRQ OD 6DQWD 6HGH H FKH QRQ VRQR DQFRUD DOLHQDWL H YRJOLDPR GHVWLQDUH L ORUR UHGGLWL HVFOXVLYD0 PHQWH DG RJJHWWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 ,O ULWRUQR GL XQ GXFD DO SRWHUH D 0RGHQD FRLQFLVH FRQ XQ PRPHQWR GL WXUEDPHQWR +YHUDPHQWH HUD GDO 4:<9 FKH OD VLWXD]LRQH HUD LQJDUEXJOLDWD H D TXDOFKH GHFHQQLR SULPD ULVDOLYDQR JOL LQIOXVVL TXLHWLVWL H JLDQVHQLVWL « , GHO FDW0 WROLFHVLPR QRVWUDQR FKH SXz HVVHUH FRPSUHVR VH VL SHQVD DOOH YLFHQGH FKH FRLQYROVHUR DGGLULWWXUD XQ VDFHUGRWH FKH SRL VDUHEEH GLYHQWDWR YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD VWHVVD1 ( GLFLDPR GL PRQV1 /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL H GHO JUXSSR GL UHOLJLRVL H ODLFL FDWWROLFL D OXL YLFLQL FKH SURSULR QHO SHULRGR 4;47049/ PHQWUH LO 5HJ0 JLDQLQL HUD FRQIHVVRUH LQ VHPLQDULR/ VRVSHWWz GL SRVL]LRQL HUUDWH GXH GRFHQWL FKH IXURQR ULPRVVL +XQR SRL IX UHLQWHJUDWR,8<1 ²²²²²²²² 8; $YUHEEH ULFRSHUWR OD FDULFD ILQR DO 4;63/ VRVWLWXLWR SRL ILQR DO 64 GLFHPEUH GHO 4;64 GD *LURODPR 5LFFLQL H SRL DQFRUD/ VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH H ILQR DO 4;79/ GDWD GHOOD VFRPSDUVD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ GDO FRQWH *LRYDQQL 6DOLV 6RJOLR1 8< /D YLFHQGD q ULFRVWUXLWD VLD QHO WHVWR GL SDGUH 67$1,6/$2 '$ &$03$*12/$/ &DWWROLFL LQWUDQVLJHQWL D 0RGHQD DJOL LQL]L GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/4<;7/ FKH SHUz q GLVFXWLELOH QHOO·LQGLFD]LRQH +OD ILJXUD GHO YHVFRYR 5HJJLDQLQL q YLVWD FRPH HQLJPD H FLz q VLQFHUDPHQWH WURSSR,/ VLD QHO WHVWR GL *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD FDWWROLFD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD +4;4804;94,/ 0RGHQD/ 6171(101 0XFFKL/ 4<9; FKH XQD YROWD WDQWR/ GD ODLFR/ EDWWH LO UHOLJLRVR SHU RELHWWLYLWj1 ,QROWUH/ OD ILJXUD GHO YHVFRYR /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL DLXWD D LQTXDGUDUOD SXUH OR VWX0 GLR GL 31%1 &$62/,/ /D &KLHVD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL H LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL/ HVWUDWWR GD ©/D 6FXROD &DWWROLFDª/ 0LODQR/ 4<351 6HJQDOLDPR SXUH/ SHU FRPSOHWH]]D/ FKH LO 'D &DPSD0 JQROD ULSRUWD XQ·DSSHQGLFH FKLDPDWD 3URVSHWWR GHOOD &KLHVD GL 0RGHQD/ WUDWWD GDOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR 9DWLFDQR= &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHL 5HOLJLRVL/ 0RGHQD 4;77/ FKH QRQ GHSRQH D IDYRUH GHO 5HJ0 JLDQLQL1
:69
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
/D SDWDWD EROOHQWH GRYHWWH JHVWLUOD RYYLDPHQWH XQ QRQ SL• JLRYDQH H TXLQGL RUPDL LQFHUWR/ YHVFRYR TXDOH LO &RUWHVH H D XQ FHUWR PRPHQWR PRQV1 5HJJLDQLQL IX HVSXOVR OXL VWHVVR GDO VHPLQDULR/ DQGDQGR FRQ L VXRL ILGL VDFHU0 GRWL +WUD FXL GXH SHUVRQDOLWj VSLFFDWH TXDOL GRQ *LXVHSSH %DUDOGL H GRQ 6HYH0 ULQR )DEULDQL, D YLYHUH QHOOR 6WDELOLPHQWR GHOOH )LJOLH GL *HV• DSHUWR SUHVVR OD FKLHVD GHO 3DUDGLVR1 $ SDUWH TXHVWD YLFHQGD LQJDUEXJOLDWD/ LO YHVFRYR &RU0 WHVH VXELWR IX G·DFFRUGR FRQ LO GXFD QHO GDUH LO YLD D XQ SURJUDPPD FKH FKLD0 ULVVH DVSHWWL YLWDOL SHU LO EXRQ JRYHUQR GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH1 )XURQR FHQVLWL L UH0 OLJLRVL UHJRODUL/ DSHUWL DOFXQL FRQYHQWL SULPD VRSSUHVVL93/ PHQWUH L EHQL HFFOH0 VLDVWLFL SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH LQFDPHUDWL H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH DOLHQDWL D IDYRUH GL GLYHUVL ´IRQGL VSHFLDOLµ FKH DYHYDQR SURYYHGXWR DO PDQWHQLPHQWR GL FKLHVH H FOHUR IXURQR UHVWLWXLWL DOOD FKLHVD GL 0RGHQD FRQ XQD GHFLQD GL DWWL XQLODWHUDOL GHO GXFD1 6LJQLILFDWLYR LO IDWWR FKH DFFDQWR DO VHPLQDULR PHWURSROLWDQR VL DYYLL O·DSHUWXUD GL GXH VHPLQDUL PLQRUL D )LXPDOER H D )LQDOH (PLOLD941 ,O 56 JHQQDLR 4;54 VL DYUj XQ EUHYH SRQWLILFLR FRQ LO TXDOH VL GLFKLDUD FKH OD &RPPHQGD GL 1RQDQWROD/ ULSULVWLQDQGR O·LQVLJQH VXD $EED]LD YLHQH DIILGD0 WD LQ SHUSHWXR DO YHVFRYR SUR WHPSRUH GL 0RGHQD +WDQWR FKp IRVVH DYYHQXWD OD PDQ0 FDQ]D GHO YHVFRYR GL 5HJJLR/ DPPLQLVWUDWRUH DSRVWROLFR GL GHWWD &RPPHQGD,951 ,O SRVVHV0 VR UHDOH GD SDUWH GL PRQV1 7LEXU]LR &RUWHVH DYYHQQH LO 54 JHQQDLR 4;55 H FHVVDYD FRVu OD SUHVWD]LRQH GD SDUWH GHOOD &DVVD GHOOR 6WDWR (VWHQVH GL /1 765;/69 DOOD 0HQVD YHVFRYLOH GL 0RGHQD961 0D/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ TXHVWD OD QRYLWj ²²²²²²²² 93
,O 43 PDJJLR 4;49 IXURQR ULSULVWLQDWL LO FRQYHQWR GHL IUDQFHVFDQL 0LQRUL GL 61 &DWDOGR H TXHOOR GL 0LUDQGROD1 1HO 4;4; VDUj ULDSHUWR LO PRQDVWHUR GL 61 3LHWUR D 0RGHQD> QHO 4;54 IX ULDSHUWR LO FROOHJLR GHL *HVXLWL/ VHPSUH LQ FLWWj> QHO 4;58 WRUQDURQR +D 0RGHQD H 9LJQROD, L &DSSXFFLQL1 3HU OH GRQQH IXURQR ULFRQRVFLXWL LO PRQDVWHUR GHOOD 9LVLWD]LRQH H TXHOOR GHOOH $JRVWLQLDQH GHWWR &RUSXV 'RPLQL/ GHOOH FDSSXFFLQH GL 6SLODPEHUWR +FKH SHUz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·(VWH FKH PRUu QHO 4;551 96 6L QRWL FKH VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH/ QHO 4;6</ LO YHVFRYR PRQV1 /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL/ GRSR SD0 ]LHQWL H RVWLQDWH ULFKLHVWH/ ULRWWHQQH GL QXRYR TXHOOD UHQGLWD FKH VFDQGDOL]]HUj L IXWXUL DQDOLVWL GHO UHJQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ TXDQGR LO GLWWDWRUH /XLJL )DULQL IDUj UDFFRJOLHUH GRFXPHQWD]LRQH VXO JRYHUQR GHL GXH XOWLPL DUFLGXFKL PRGHQHVL +VL YHGD 'RFXPHQWL ULJXDUGDQWL LO *RYHUQR GHJOL $XVWUR (VWHQVL LQ 0RGHQD GDO 4;47 DO 4;8</ 5 YROO1/ 0RGHQD/ =DQLFKHOOL/ 4;8<04;931
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:6:
GD ULPDUFDUH/ LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD DVVXPHYD LO WLWROR GL $EDWH GL 1RQDQWROD1 $FFHQQLDPR VRODPHQWH DO IDWWR FKH JOL DQQL WUD LO 4;54 H LO 4;55 SHU 0RGHQD IXURQR SROLWLFDPHQWH FULWLFL H FKH )UDQFHVFR ,9 DYHYD HPDQDWR GDO ¶53 O·HGLWWR SHU GLFKLDUDUH FROSHYROL GL OHVD PDHVWj97 FRORUR FKH IRVVHUR DIILOLDWL DOOD &DUERQHULD R DG DOWUH VHWWH SROLWLFKH1 ,O 48 PDJJLR 4;54 IX XFFLVR D SXJQDODWH O·DYYRFDWR *LXOLR %HVLQL GHOOD SROL]LD HVWHQVH H VFDWWz OD UHSUHVVLRQH FKH D0 YUHEEH SRUWDWR DOOD FRQGDQQD D PRUWH/ SHU PH]]R GHO WULEXQDOH VWDWDULR98/ GL GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL GD 6DQ 3RVVLGRQLR991 &RPH VL SXz QRWDUH/ SXU VH L UDSSRUWL FRQ OD FKLHVD HUDQR EXRQL/ TXDQGR VL WUDWWDYD GL GHFLVLRQL SROLWLFKH/ )UDQFHVFR ,9 QRQ JXDUGDYD LQ IDFFLD QHVVX0 QR/ FRPH SRL FRQIHUPDURQR L PRWL GHO ¶64 FRQ OH FRQGDQQH HVHJXLWH GL &LUR 0HQRWWL H 9LQFHQ]R %RUUHOOL1 (UD XQ GXFD SLR/ PD FRQ OH VXH LGHH/ TXHOOR/ H FKH DYHYD DQFRUD LO SRWHUH GL FRQWDUH VXOOD QRPLQD GHO YHVFRYR FLWWDGLQR/ FKH TXHVWD YROWD SURSULR OXL LQGLFz/ DOOD PRUWH GHO YHFFKLR PRQV1 $GHRGDWR &D0 OHIIL LQ /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL9:1 3ULPD DYHYD DYXWR D FKH IDUH FRQ GXH YHVFRYL GRSR LO &RUWHVH H FLRq PRQV1 *LXVHSSH 6RPPDULYD+4;5704;5<, H PRQV1 $GHRGDWR &DOHIIL+4;630 4;6:, H GXUDQWH LO JRYHUQR GHO SULPR LO PLQLVWUR GXFDOH 5LFFLQL DYHYD FKLHVWR H RWWHQXWR +4;5;, OD QRPLQD VRYUDQD SHU L FDQRQLFDWL VHPSOLFL GHOOD FDWWHGUDOH PRGHQHVH1 ,O EHQHGHWWLQR &DOHIIL HUD VWDWR SULPD YHVFRYR GL &DUSL9; H GLYHQ0 QH YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD FKH DYHYD :3 DQQL1 )DFLOH/ LQ DSSDUHQ]D/ O·LQGLFD]LRQH GXFDOH GHO VXR FRQIHVVRUH 5HJJLDQLQL FKH SHUz VXELWR PRVWUz GL QRQ DYHUH FRPSOHVVL H SLDJJHULH H FL IX XQD VRUWD GL EUDFFLR GL IHUUR SHUFKp LO PRQVL0 JQRUH SUHWHVH LO ULSULVWLQR GL OLEHUWj HFFOHVLDVWLFKH FKH LO GXFD QRQ YROHYD FRQFHGHUH H LQIDWWL OD &DPHUD GXFDOH SRL FRQWLQXz DG DUURJDUVL OD SDUWHFLSD0 ]LRQH H YLJLODQ]D QHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ VSHFLH QHO FDVR GL YDFDQ]D GHL EHQHIL]L1 ²²²²²²²² 97
/D /HVD PDHVWj FRQWHPSODYD OD FRQGDQQD D PRUWH H OD FRQILVFD GHL EHQL GHO FRQGDQQD0
WR1 98
,VWLWXLWR GRSR L PRWL SLHPRQWHVL1 ,O VXGGHWWR WULEXQDOH VWDWDULR JLXGLFz 79 LPSXWDWL/ GHFUHWDQGR QRYH FRQGDQQH D PRUWH GL FXL VHWWH LQ FRQWXPDFLD1 3RL/ JUD]LDQGR )UDQFHVFR &RQWL/ IX JLXVWL]LDWR LO VROR *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL LO 4: RWWREUH 4;551 4XHO FKH )UDQFHVFR ,9 QRQ VHSSH SHUGRQDUH QHJDQGRJOL OD JUD0 ]LD/ HUD FKH VL WUDWWDYD GL XQ FRUUXWWRUH GL JLRYHQW•1 9: ,O &DOHIIL HUD VXFFHGXWR QHO 4;63 D PRQV1 *LXVHSSH 6RPPDULYD FKH D VXD YROWD HUD VXFFHGXWR GRSR LO OXQJR SHULRGR GL HSLVFRSDWR D PRQV1 7LEXU]LR &RUWHVH1 &DOHIIL JRYHUQz OD FKLHVD GL 0RGHQD ILQR DO 8 DJRVWR GHO 4;6: TXDQGR PRUu1 9; &DUSL HUD GLRFHVL D Vp GDO 4::<1 99
:6;
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
*Lj QHO 4;6< FL IX XQD SUHFLVD ULFKLHVWD GD SDUWH GHOOD 6DQWD 6HGH SHU UL0 IRUPDUH OD OHJLVOD]LRQH HVWHQVH QHOOH SDUWL ULWHQXWH OHVLYH GHL GLULWWL GHOOD &KLH0 VD/ PD VROR QHO 4;74 YL VDUDQQR SUHFLVL DFFRGL &RQFRUGDWDUL WUD )UDQFHVFR ,9 H 5RPD H LO GXFD HPDQz XQ VXR HGLWWR LQ FXL ULFRQRVFHYD WDOXQL GLULWWL GHOOD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH HVDXWRUDWD QHO 4::4 GDO &RGLFH (VWHQVH9< H FKH HUDQR FLWDWL QHO %UHYH GL SDSD *UHJRULR ;9, GHO 63 DSULOH 4;741 /·HGLWWR GXFDOH q GHOO·; PDJJLR VHJXHQWH:3 H ULFRQRVFHYD VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH L VHJXHQWL SXQWL= 41 &DXVH FLYLOL WUD (FFOHVLDVWLFL H /DLFL R IUD GXH HFFOHVLDVWLFL= VDUDQQR GHFLVH GDL WULEXQDOL VHFRODUL1 51 &RVu DQFKH SHU L GHOLWWL GL OHVD PDHVWj/ VHGL]LRQH/ FRQWUDEEDQGR/ LQVRPPD FDXVH FULPLQDOL D FDULFR GL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 61 3HU OH UHQGLWH GHL EHQHILFL YDFDQWL HUD LVWLWXLWD XQD &RPPLVVLRQH FRPSR0 VWD GL GXH &DQRQLFL GHOOD FDWWHGUDOH H GL XQ 3URFXUDWRUH R 0LQLVWUR GXFDOH1 )UDQFHVFR ,9 RUGLQDYD SRL FKH FHVVDVVH RJQL LQJHUHQ]D QHOOH RUGLQD]LRQL GHL FKLHULFL/ QHOOH SURIHVVLRQL UHOLJLRVH/ QHOOH HVHFX]LRQL GHOOD FROOD]LRQH GHL EHQHIL]L HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ QHOO·$PPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL ORUR IRQGL/ QHOOH FDXVH PD0 WULPRQLDOL1 9HQQH DEROLWD OD OHJJH GHWWD GHOOH PDQL PRUWH/ RQGH QRQ UHVWD+YD, SL• LPSHGLWR DG DOFXQR GL GRQDUH R ODVFLDUH SHU DWWR GL XOWLPD YRORQWj DOOD FKLHVD R D FDXVH SLH1 &Lz GHWWR/ UHVWD GD FKLDULUH EHQH FKH TXHOOR FKH q FKLDPDWR &RQFRUGDWR GHO 4;74 q LO SULPR GL GXH DWWL ELODWHUDOPHQWH ULFRQRVFLXWL GDOOD 6DQWD 6HGH +LQ ID0 YRUH GHOOD FKLHVD GL 0RGHQD, GD XQD SDUWH H GDJOL DUFLGXFKL PRGHQHVL +SHU0 FKp LO SULPR IX UDWLILFDWR GD )UDQFHVFR ,9 H LO VHFRQGR GDO ILJOLR )UDQFHVFR 9, GDOO·DOWUD:41 6L GRYUj LQIDWWL JLXQJHUH DO 4;84 SHU DYHUH XQ VHFRQGR &RQFRUGDWR ORFDOH1 (/ VHPSUH ORFDOPHQWH SHU JOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ QRQ SRVVLDPR QRQ FLWDUH XQ 3UR0 VSHWWR GLPRVWUDWLYR DOOHJDWR DO JLj FLWDWR VWXGLR FRPPLVVLRQDWR GDO )DULQL:5/ ²²²²²²²² 9<
&KH LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9 ULPLVH LQ XVR QHO 4;471 3HU FRPSOHWH]]D GL LQIRUPD]LRQL/ UDPPHQWLDPR FKH LO 53 JLXJQR 4;74 YHQQH VRSSUHV0 VR/ D FDXVD GL XQ LQFLGHQWH GLSORPDWLFR FRQ JOL LQJOHVL/ LO JLRUQDOH /D 9RFH GHOOD 9HULWj FKH SHU GLHFL DQQL HUD VWDWR YROXWR GD )UDQFHVFR ,9 HG HUD LVSLUDWR DL SULQFLSL GHOO·DVVROXWLVPR SL• LQWUDQVLJHQWH1 :4 3HU O·,WDOLD L UDSSRUWL FRQ OH FKLHVH HUDQR LQ SUHFHGHQ]D UHJRODWL GDO &RQFRUGDWR GHO 46 VHWWHPEUH 4;36 FRQ OD 5HSXEEOLFD ,WDOLDQD/ PHQWUH OH VLQJROH OHJLVOD]LRQL ORFDOL VL HUDQR EDVD0 WH VXO &RQFRUGDWR GHO 48 OXJOLR 4;35 WUD SDSD 3LR 9,, H 1DSROHRQH LQ TXDOLWj GL 3ULPR &RQ0 VROH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD )UDQFHVH1 :5 'RFXPHQWL ULJXDUGDQWL LO *RYHUQR GHJOL $XVWUR (VWHQVL LQ 0RGHQD GDO 4;47 DO 4;8<= :3
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:6<
UHODWLYR DOOH VRVWDQ]H GL SURYHQLHQ]D HFFOHVLDVWLFD DPPLQLVWUDWH GDO 4;47 DO 4;85 GDOOD *HQHUDOH ,QWHQGHQ]D &DPHUDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL 'RPLQL= GRFXPHQWR FKH UL0 SRUWD FKH OH VSHVH VRVWHQXWH GDOOH GLYHUVH $PPLQLVWUD]LRQL /DLFDOL GHOOR 6WDWR D IDYRUH GHOOD &KLHVD H &DXVH 3LH HUDQR VWDWH SHU XQ WRWDOH GL /1 44/ :66/ 6661896 H FLRq SL• GL TXDQWR G·RULJLQH (FFOHVLDVWLFD RWWHQQH GDOOH &RQYHQ]LRQL 'LSOR0 PDWLFKH« 3ULPD GHO QXRYR &RQFRUGDWR GHO 4;84/ QHOO·DQQR VWHVVR GHOOD PRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9:6/ IXURQR SURGRWWL GHL GRFXPHQWL LQWHJUDWLYL> LQ VRVWDQ]D XQ (GLWWR GL LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH FLUFD OH FRPPLVVLRQL GLRFHVDQH VXOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 0D HUD JLj ILQLWR LO UHJQR GHO SUL0 PR DUFLGXFD H DO SRWHUH HUD VDOLWR TXHOOR FKH VDUHEEH VWDWR O·XOWLPR GL FDVD G·(VWH +LQ YHULWj $XVWUR0(VWHQVH,/ FLRq )UDQFHVFR 91 *OL XOWLPL DQQL GHO SRWHUH GXFDOH H OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH &RQ OD PRUWH GHO SDGUH DOO·LQL]LR GHO 4;79/ HSRFD GL IXJDFL VSHUDQ]H H GL UDSLGL FDPELDPHQWL:7/ PHQWUH HUD DQFRUD YHVFRYR PRQV1 /XLJL 5HJJLDQLQL:8/ DUFLGXFD GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL GLYHQQH +H OR IX SHU 46 DQQL H PH]]R, )UDQFHVFR 9:9/ XRPR GDL SULQFuSL GHO SDGUH/ PD FRQ XQ FDUDWWHUH FHUWDPHQWH GLYHUVR H VLFXUDPHQWH QRQ LQFOLQH D VROX]LRQL UHSUHVVLYH::1 ,O WXUELQH GHO ¶7; IX SHU OXL SUHVDJLR GL XQ GHVWLQR FKH GRYHYD VFKLDFFLDUOR SHUFKp OH FRQWUDSSRVL]LRQL WUD LO OLEHULVPR PRQWDQWH H JRYHUQR GXFDOH/ WUD +VL GHYH GLUOR, FOHULFDOL H ODLFL/ H0 UDQR XQD FRVWDQWH FKH DYUHEEH SRUWDWR OD YHFFKLD ,WDOLD GLYLVD LQ URYLQD1 ( QRQ q FKH )UDQFHVFR 9 QRQ OR DYHVVH SUHYLVWR/ FKH HEEH SURJHWWL GL &RQIHGHUD]LRQH ,WDOLDQD GL 6WDWL +TXHOOL/ SHU FRVu GLUH/ SL• UHD]LRQDUL/ WUD FXL LO VXR,:;/ PD QRQ FL IX QXOOD GD IDUH SHU WURSSH PLRSLH HVWHUQH DO VXR UHJQR H SHU LO SLFFROR FDERWDJJLR GHOOH SROLWLFKH GHJOL DOWUL VRYUDQL D OXL YLFLQL H FKH –––––––– LQ TXHVWR FDVR/ OD 3DUWH 7HU]D/ D SDJ1 6:9/ GDWDWD 6 PDJJLR 4;881 :6 'RSR GL HVVD/ DYYHQXWD LO 54 JHQQDLR 4;791 :7 1HO 4;7; FL VDUHEEHUR VWDWH OH YDULH ULYROWH SRL VPRU]DWH +LO 4XDUDQWRWWR/ GLYHQXWR SUR0 YHUELDOH,1 :8 &KH VDUHEEH PRUWR QHO 4;7; H D FXL VDUHEEH VXFFHGXWR PRQV1 /XLJL )HUUDUL1 :9 1DWR LO 4ƒ JLXJQR 4;4</ QRQ DYHYD 5: DQQL TXDQGR DVVXQVH LO SRWHUH FKH ODVFLz O·44 JLXJQR 4;8< GHWHUPLQDQGR OD ILQH GL 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH1 :: &HOHEUH OD VXD IUDVH= ,R QRQ IDUz PDL PDOH DG DOFXQR1 :; 6L YHGD DO SURSRVLWR OR VWXGLR GL *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR $X0 VWUR (VWHQVH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<::1
:73
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
GRYHYDQR FRPH OXL HVVHUH WUDYROWL GDOOD VWRULD1 &L IXURQR OH ULYROWH GDOOD 6LFL0 OLD DOOD )UDQFLD/ GDOOD *HUPDQLD DOO·$XVWULD/ GD 9HQH]LD D 0LODQR1 ( OH FLQTXH VWRULFKH *LRUQDWH GL 0LODQR FKH IHFHUR VFDWWDUH OD FRVLGGHWWD PDQLIHVWD]LRQH GHOOH *LXQFKLJOLH D 0RGHQD H LO VHJXLWR GL GLVRUGLQL FKH SRUWDURQR DO JRYHUQR GL *LXVHSSH 0DOPXVL FRQ O·DEEDQGRQR GHOOD FDSLWDOH GD SDUWH GXFDOH1 5LWRUQz/ SHU TXHOOD YROWD/ )UDQFHVFR 9/ JLj LO 43 DJRVWR GHO 4;7; +GRSR O·DUPLVWL]LR 6DODVFR H OD VFRQILWWD GL &XVWR]D, H DO 4ƒ VHWWHPEUH VL HEEH LO 0L0 QLVWHUR SHU JOL DIIDUL GL *LXVWL]LD/ GL *UD]LD HG (FFOHVLDVWLFL/ DIILGDWR DO SURIHVVRUH GL 'LULWWR (FFOHVLDVWLFR 5LQDOGR 6FR]LD1 ,Q XQ FKLURJUDIR GHO 8 QRYHPEUH VH0 JXHQWH/ LO GXFD SUHFLVz FKH ULVLHGH QHO GHWWR 0LQLVWHUR O·DOWD WXWHOD GHOOH SHUVRQH GHO FOHUR H GHL %HQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL +DUW1 ,, H DQFKH FKH GD HVVR GLSHQGRQR L 5HJL 'HOHJDWL SUHV0 VR OH &RPPLVVLRQL HFFOHVLDVWLFKH1 ,QVRPPD/ SHU XQD SDFH VRFLDOH FKH IRVVH DQFKH UHOLJLRVD/ )UDQFHVFR 9 VL LPSHJQz VLQFHUDPHQWH H WDQWR GD ULFKLDPDUH D 0R0 GHQD L *HVXLWL QHO 4;83:< H SRL GD VLJODUH LO &RQFRUGDWR D FXL V·q JLj DFFHQQD0 WR FRQ OD 6DQWD 6HGH QHO 4;841 &RVu/ FDULFR GL VRGGLVID]LRQL SDVWRUDOL IX LO JRYHUQR VROR WULHQQDOH +4;7; ² 4;84, GHO YHVFRYR PRQV1 /XLJL )HUUDUL FKH IX LQGLFDWR FRPH QRPLQDWLYR D 5RPD SURSULR VRWWR LO JRYHUQR 0DOPXVL;31 8RPR GL FXOWXUD +HUD GRFHQWH GL 7HRORJLD 0RUDOH DOO·8QLYHUVLWj H DXWRUH GL YDULH SXEEOLFD]LRQL,/ VXELWR LO )HU0 UDUL DYHYD FROWR LO GHVWUR SHU DOOLQHDUVL DO SDSD 3LR ,; H TXLQGL IX SHUGRQDWR GDOO·DUFLGXFD WRUQDWR DO SRWHUH +R PHJOLR= )UDQFHVFR 9 LJQRUz OH VXH SRVL]LR0 QL SUHFHGHQWL,1 0D OD VXD PRUWH GRSR WUH DQQL GL JXLGD SDVWRUDOH SRVH GL QXRYR D EUHYH LO SUREOHPD GL XQ YHVFRYR FKH VWDYROWD/ YLVWH OH UHFHQWL DFTXL0 VL]LRQL WHUULWRULDOL GHOO·DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ VDUHEEH VWDWR ILQDOPHQWH YHVFR0 YR GL XQD SURYLQFLD HFFOHVLDVWLFD FKH FRLQFLGHYD FRQ L FRQILQL GHO 'XFDWR (0 VWHQVH;41 4XHVWR QXRYR YHVFRYR FRQVDFUDWR D 5RPD LO 5; PDU]R 4;85/ IX PRQV1 )UDQFHVFR (PLOLR &XJLQL/ UHJJLDQR;5/ GHVWLQDWR D GLYHQWDUH LO SULPR DUFLYH0 VFRYR GL 0RGHQD1 'DSSULPD/ QHO VXR JRYHUQR LQL]LDOH/ HEEH DG DIIURQWDUH LO GLIILFLOH SHULRGR GHO FROHUD D FDYDOOR GHOO·DQQR 4;88/ FROHUD FKH GDO )ULJQDQR/ ²²²²²²²² :<
, *HVXLWL ULDSULURQR OD ORUR VFXROD1 0RQV1 /XLJL )HUUDUL HUD VWDWR YLFDULR FDSLWRODUH/ FLRq HOHWWR D UDSSUHVHQWDUH LO GHIXQWR YH0 VFRYR 5HJJLDQLQL QHO SHULRGR GL YDFDQ]D GL JRYHUQR GHOOD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH1 ;4 2OWUH D 0RGHQD/ LO GXFDWR DYHYD OH GLRFHVL VXIIUDJDQHH GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ &DUSL/ *XDVWDO0 OD1 ;5 1DWR LO 54 RWWREUH 4;38/ GL QRELOH IDPLJOLD/ VDUj YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD GDO 4;85 DO 4;:51 9LGH FLRq SUHVWR LO SDVVDJJLR DO QXRYR JRYHUQR LWDOLDQR XQLWDULR1 ;3
,O 9HVFRYDWR SRL $UFLYHVFRYDWR GL 0RGHQD +48<;04;8<,
:74
RYH VFRSSLz LQ SULPDYHUD/ VL HVWHVH D WXWWR LO GXFDWR1 )X XQ SHULRGR HSLFR/ GXUDQWH TXHOO·DQQR/ FRQ L FDSSXFFLQL LQ SULPD OLQHD/ PD FRQ WXWWD OD FKLHVD ORFDOH LPSHJQDWD1 6L FRQWDURQR 9:55 YLWWLPH GHO PRUER VX XQ QXPHUR TXDVL GRSSLR GL FRQWDJLDWL;61 0D LO 4;88 UHVWD PHPRUDELOH SHU OD %ROOD 3RQWLILFLD GHO 55 DJRVWR FKH DVVRJJHWWz DOOD QXRYD FKLHVD PHWURSROLWDQD GL 0RGHQD OH GLRFHVL VXIIUDJDQHH GL &DUSL/ *XDVWDOOD/ 0DVVD/ &DUUDUD H 5HJJLR (PLOLD1 0RGHQD HUD $UFKLGLRFHVL H PRQV1 &XJLQL SULPR $UFLYHVFRYR 0HWURSROLWD GHOOD FLWWj;71 6HJXu/ D PHQR GL GXH DQQL GD TXHOO·DYYHQLPHQWR/ OD YLVLWD D 0R0 GHQD GHOO·DOORUD VHVVDQWDFLQTXHQQH H DQFRUD HQHUJLFR SRQWHILFH 0DVWDL )HU0 UHWWL= JLXQVH QHO SRPHULJJLR GHO 5 OXJOLR 4;8:/ DFFROWR GD DXWRULWj UHOLJLRVH H FLYLOL H GDOOD IHVWRVD JLRLD GL WXWWL L PRGHQHVL1 5LSDUWu SHU %RORJQD LO 7 OXJOLR;81 0D OD VWRULD JDORSSDYD1 7UD TXHOO·DQQR H LO VXFFHVVLYR 4;8;/ D &DUUDUD YL IX FRQIXVLRQH D VHJXLWR GHJOL RUPDL GHFLVLYL LQIOXVVL PD]]LQLDQL H ILOR0 SLHPRQWHVL1 (UDQR L SURGURPL GHO FDPELDPHQWR YLFLQR1 $QFRUD O·DQQR VH0 JXHQWH/ D SULPDYHUD/ OD 6HFRQGD *XHUUD G·,QGLSHQGHQ]D H JLj LO 63 DSULOH )UDQFHVFR 9 IHFH DOORQWDQDUH GD 0RGHQD OD PRJOLH $GHOJRQGD1 3RL YHQQHUR 0RQWHEHOOR/ 3DOHVWUR H 0DJHQWD H LO 43 JLXJQR 4;8< HFFR JLXQJHUH LQ FLWWj OD QRWL]LD GHO ULWLUR DXVWULDFR VXO 0LQFLR H LO JLRUQR VHJXHQWH OD UHVD GXFDOH= )UDQFHVFR 9 ODVFHUj OD FDSLWDOH1 3HU VHPSUH;91 &RQFOXVLRQL /·DEEDQGRQR GHOO·DUFLGXFD H LO VHJXLWR D WDPEXU EDWWHQWH GL DYYHQLPHQWL FKH SRUWDURQR GDO JRYHUQR =LQL H D TXHOOL GL /XLJL &DUOR )DULQL FKH GLFKLDUz LQ SHUSHWXR GHFDGXWD OD GLQDVWLD GHJOL (VWH/ IXURQR YLVVXWL GDL PRGHQHVL GL IHGH ²²²²²²²² ;6
5HVWD/ TXHO SHULRGR/ DQQRWDWR QHOOH WDQWH SLDVWUHOOH UHWWDQJRODUL PXUDWH VXJOL HGLILFL FRQ LO 4;88 H LO WULJUDPPD GL *HV•1 ;7 ,O 6DFUR 3DOOLR/ FKH GLVWLQJXHYD TXHOOD GLJQLWj/ IX LPSRVWR LO 9 JHQQDLR 4;89 GDO FDUGL0 QDOH *DHWDQR %DUXIIL/ YHVFRYR GL ,PROD H /HJDWR 3DSDOH FKH YHQQH D 0RGHQD FRQ OD %ROOD GL SDSD 3LR ,;1 ;8 6DUj O·XOWLPD YLVLWD PRGHQHVH GL XQ SRQWHILFH ILQR D TXHOOD GHO 4<;; GL SDSD *LRYDQQL 3DROR ,,1 ;9 6L YHGD *1&1 0217$1$5,/ , IHGHOLVVLPL GHO 'XFD 0RGHQD/ (GL]LRQL ,O )LRULQR/ 4<<9= FRQ XQ GRFXPHQWR GHL SDGUL 0HFKLWDULVWL RUPDL SUHVVRFKp LQWURYDELOH WUDGRWWR GDO IUDQFHVH/ TXL VL ULIj FHUFDQGR O·RELHWWLYLWj/ OD VWRULD GHOOH XOWLPH YLFHQGH GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9 H GHL VROGDWL FKH SHU ROWUH TXDWWUR DQQL ULPDVHUR D OXL IHGHOL/ FLRq OD FRVLGGHWWD %ULJDWD (VWHQVH1
:75
*LDQ &DUOR 0RQWDQDUL
FDWWROLFD D VHFRQGD GHOOH ORUR LQWLPH FRQYLQ]LRQL SROLWLFKH/ PD FHUWDPHQWH VHPSUH FRQ ODFHUD]LRQL DQJRVFLRVH1 &HUWR/ PROWL HUDQR H UHVWDURQR GXFKLVWL/ DQFKH FRQ VSOHQGLGL HVHPSL GL FRHUHQ]D QHO WHPSR;:/ SRL YHQQH LO SOHELVFLWR GHOO·44 PDU]R 4;93 H PHQR GL 4333 IXURQR L 12/ FRQ JUDQGH VRGGLVID]LRQH GL 5H 9LWWRULR (PDQXHOH ,, H GL FKL DYHYD RSHUDWR SHU LO FDPELDPHQWR;;1 3HU TXHO FKH ULJXDUGD OD FKLHVD PRGHQHVH/ VL SXz SDUODUH GL ULJXUJLWL GL DQ0 WLFOHULFDOLVPR QHL VXRL FRQIURQWL/ FRQ PDQLIHVWD]LRQL LQ FXL VL JULGDYD FRQWUR 3LR ,; H FKH O·DUFLYHVFRYR &XJLQL VRSSRUWz FRQ FULVWLDQD ILORVRILD1 6DUHEEH QDWD WXWWD XQD VWDPSD RVWLOH DL FDWWROLFL/ PD DQFKH TXHVWL QRQ UL0 PDVHUR LQDWWLYL;<1 ( FL IXURQR IHURFL SROHPLFKH FKH VHJQDURQR LO VHFRQGR 2WWRFHQWR1 (UD GDYYHUR LQL]LDWD XQD QXRYD HUD FKH YLGH SHUz L FULVWLDQL +H TXHOOL PRGHQHVL SHU TXHO FKH ULJXDUGD LO SUHVHQWH ODYRUR GL ULFHUFD, SLXWWRVWR DUURFFDWL LQ GLIHVD1 0RQV1 &XJLQL YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD ILQR DOOD PRUWH/ H FKH WUD O·DOWUR DYHYD SDUWHFLSDWR DO &RQFLOLR (FXPHQLFR 9DWLFDQR ,<3/ UHVWz D FRPSLHUH LO VXR GRYHUH GL SDVWRUH ILQR LQ IRQGR> ILQR DOOD PRUWH LO 54 JHQ0 QDLR 4;:51 0D SHU ILQLUH TXHVWD ULYLVLWD]LRQH GL 594 DQQL GL VWRULD GHOOD FKLHVD ORFDOH H GHL VXRL UDSSRUWL FRQ LO SRWHUH FLYLOH/ DEELDPR GD IRUPXODUH XQ DX0 VSLFLR= FKH VL SRVVD ULOHJJHUH DWWHQWDPHQWH LO SHULRGR SRVW04;8< VHQ]D SUH0 JLXGL]L VRYHUFKL FRQWUR L FDWWROLFL1 3HUFKp PROWH VRQR DQFRUD OH FRVH GD VFR0 SULUH H GD UDFFRQWDUH1 0ROWL L GRFXPHQWL H OH VWRULH GD LQWHUSUHWDUH= GD TXHOOH GL FKL IX DOOD JXLGD GHOOD FKLHVD/ DOOH YLFHQGH GHOOD JHQWH FRPXQH1 &RVu FRPH/ LQILQH/ FL DXJXULD0 PR FKH GD TXHOOH TXL UDFFRQWDWH VFDWXULVFDQR/ GD SDUWH GL FKL OHJJH/ ULIOHVVLR0 QL= FKH VLD FKL q UHOLJLRVR FKH FKL VL VHQWH ODLFR SXz IDUH1
²²²²²²²² ;: 6RQR QRPL GL FLWWDGLQL LOOXVWUL H TXL FL SHUPHWWLDPR/ LQ XQ VROR ORWWR/ SXUWURSSR QRQ SDVVLELOH GL YDULH GLVWLQ]LRQL/ GL IDUH L QRPL GL 3LHU %LDJLR &DVROL/ 7HRGRUR %D\DUG GH 9ROR/ 0DUF·$QWRQLR 3DUHQWL/ *LXVHSSH %LDQFKL/ %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL« ;; )XURQR HVDWWDPHQWH 75:1845 YRWDQWL FRQ VROR :89 ´12µ1 ;< 'DO 4;93 DO 4;9: XVFu/ SUR FDWWROLFHVLPR/ ©,O 'LIHQVRUHª 'DO 4;9: ©,O 'LULWWR &DWWROL0 FRª1 <3 6L WHQQH GDOO·; GLFHPEUH 4;9< DO 53 GLFHPEUH 4;:31 0RQV1 &XJLQL IX PHPEUR GHOOD &RQJUHJD]LRQH 'H )LGH1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:76
*,86(33( 25/$1',
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
,O 43 GLFHPEUH 4:64 LO S1 &DVVLRGRUR 0RQWDJLROL/ GD 0RQWHFDVVLQR/ PDQL0 IHVWDYD D /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL O·LQWHQ]LRQH GL SDVVDUH GD TXHOOR EHQH0 GHWWLQR DG XQ 2UGLQH SL• DXVWHUR/ ©SHU ILQLUYL L PLHL JLRUQL DOPHQR FRQ OD FRQVROD]LRQH G·LQFRPLQFLDUH DG HVVHU 0RQDFRª1 (G DJJLXQJHYD= ©,O SHQVLHUR GL WDO SDVVDJJLR/ RYH YLJHVVH OR VSLULWR YHUR GHOOD YLWD PRQDVWLFD/ QRQ q GL SR0 FKH VHWWLPDQH/ PD SHU PROWL DQQL PHGLWDWR GD PH/ FKH DOWUR QRQ FXUR/ Qp EUDPR FKH XQ UL0 FRYHUR/ RYH SRWHU RSUDU O·HWHUQD PLD VDOYH]]D FRQIRUPH OD 5HJROD GD PH SURIHVVDWD/ H SL• GL TXHVWR LR QRQ FHUFR1 ,O QRQ DYHUOR VLQ RUD WURYDWR LQ ,WDOLD/ LQ FXL LO 0RQDFKHVLPR q QHOOR VWD0 WR/ LQ FXL (OOD/ TXDQWR PH/ OR YHGH/ PL KD ILQ RUD WUDWWHQXWR FRQ SHQD GL QRQ GDU LO FROSR1 9R0 OHUOR IDU IXRU G·,WDOLD QRQ PL VDUHEEH Vu IDFLOPHQWH SHUPHVVR/ HG LR Y·DYUHL DOWUH GLIILFROWjª41
/D ULVSRVWD GHO 0XUDWRUL QRQ HUD WDOH GD LQFRUDJJLDUH LO 0RQWDJLROL D UHD0 OL]]DUH LO VXR SURJHWWR= ©1RQ FRQRVFR LQ ,WDOLD/ VH QRQ L &HUWRVLQL H TXHL GHOOD 7UDSSD5/ FKH DEELDQR OH TXDOLWj FKH ULFHUFDª1 0D DQFKH TXHVWL ©QRQ VRQ ULWLUL GD FRQVLJOLDUH/ VH QRQ D FKL KD JUDQ YRJOLD GL SDVVDUH DO GHVHUWR/ H GL PRULUH G·LSRFRQGULD1 3HU DOWUR YHJJR LQ FKLRVWUL DIIDWWR ULODVVDWL SHUVRQH/ FKH WHQGR0 ²²²²²²²² 4 &IU %,%/,27(&$ (67(16(/ 0RGHQD +G·RUD LQ SRL= %(02,/ $UFKLYLR 0XUDWRULDQR/ ILO1 :5/ IDVF1 651 (YLGHQWHPHQWH/ VL HUD JLj DOTXDQWR UDIIUHGGDWR O·HQWXVLDVPR LQL]LDOH GL 0RQWDJLROL/ FKH LO 45 JLXJQR 4:63/ SRFR GRSR LO VXR DUULYR D 0RQWHFDVVLQR/ VFULYHYD D 0XUDWRUL/ ULOHYDQ0 GR ©VRSUDWXWWR XQ EXRQ FRVWXPH QH· PRQDFL/ PD LOOLEDWLVVLPR FHUWDPHQWH LQ DOFXQL/ FKH VRQR DQJHOL YHVWLWL G·XPDQD VSRJOLD1 6H D Gu QRVWUL SRWHVVH XVDUVL O·DQWLFD FRVWXPDQ]D GH· QRVWUL YHFFKL/ SRWUHEERQVL VHQ]D GLVSHQGLR GHOOD YHULWj GRSR OD ORU PRUWH DJJLXQJHUH D JOL DWWL GHO 31 0DELOORQH/ H SRWUHEERQVL GLUH PROWH FRVH1 +R VXJJHWWR GL PROWR FRQIRQGHUPL DO VROR PLUDU ORURª1 %(02/ $UFKLYLR 6ROL 0XUDWRUL/ ILO1 :5/ IDVF1 65 +0RQWDJLROL &DVVLRGRUR,/ I1 4:·1 5 1HO 4:38 HUD VWDWR IRQGDWR/ D %XRQVROOD]]R/ LO SULPR PRQDVWHUR WUDSSLVWD LWDOLDQR1&IU1 (1 %,1,/ ©,O SULPLHUR IHUYRU FLVWHUFLHQVHª1 /*LQWURGX]LRQH GHL 7UDSSLVWL LQ ,WDOLD/ 5RPD 4<<91
:77
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
QR DOOD VDQWLWj1 'DSSHUWXWWR/ HG DQFKH QHO VHFROR/ O·XRPR SXz GLYHQLU VDQWR/ VH GLFH GDYYHUR1 ( TXHVWD VROD FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GHH TXHWDUH L VXRL GHVLGHULª 61 ,O SXQWR GL YLVWD GHO 0XUDWRUL VXOOR VWDWR GHL UHOLJLRVL GHO WHPSR/ H VXL SURYYHGLPHQWL GD DGRWWDUH SHU UHQGHUQH SL• LQFLVLYD OD SUHVHQ]D QHOOD &KLHVD H QHOOD VRFLHWj/ q EHQ QRWR 71 /H VXH LGHH VXOOD QHFHVVLWj GL XQ PDJJLRUH LP0 SHJQR VRFLDOH GHL UHOLJLRVL HUDQR FRQGLYLVH DQFKH GD XQD SDUWH GHOOD FODVVH SROLWLFD LWDOLDQD/ FKH SRFR GRSR OD PRUWH GHO 9LJQROHVH FHUFz GL WUDGXUOH LQ SUDWLFD1 9HQQH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH SUHVD GL PLUD OD SURSULHWj GHL UHOLJLRVL/ QHOO·DPELWR GL XQD UHYLVLRQH JHQHUDOH GHL UDSSRUWL WUD 6WDWR H &KLHVD1 )X LQ 7RVFDQD/ GXUDQWH LO JRYHUQR GHO 5LFKHFRXUW/ FKH QHO PDU]R GHO 4:84 YHQQH VWHVR GD *LRYDQ 9LQFHQ]R $OEHUWL/ *LXOLR 5XFHOODL H )LOLSSR 5RWD XQ SURJHWWR GL OHJJH VXOOH PDQLPRUWH/ FRQVLGHUDWR DOORUD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH DUGL0 WR81 $QFKH D *HQRYD/ LQ TXHJOL DQQL/ HEEH LQL]LR OD GLVFXVVLRQH VXO UXROR GHL UHOLJLRVL QHOOD VRFLHWj/ H VXOOD IXQ]LRQH GHOOH ULFFKH]]H GD ORUR DFFXPXODWH QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL1 ,Q RFFDVLRQH GHOOD RFFXSD]LRQH GHOOD FDSLWDOH GHOOD 5HSXE0 EOLFD OLJXUH 0 GXUDQWH OD *XHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD 0 LO %DQFR GL 61 *LRU0 JLR HUD VWDWR FRVWUHWWR D FRSULUVL GL GHELWL1 )X FRVu FKH VL FRPLQFLz D ULIOHWWHUH VXOO·RSSRUWXQLWj FKH OD SURSULHWj HFFOHVLDVWLFD FRQWULEXLVVH LQ PLVXUD DGHJXDWD D IDU IURQWH DOOH SXEEOLFKH QHFHVVLWj 91 1H LPLWDURQR O·HVHPSLR DOWUL 6WDWL LWD0 OLDQL/ WUD FXL LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 , UHOLJLRVL , UHOLJLRVL GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL QHO 4::4 HUDQR ;:; +GL FXL 8<9 VDFHUGRWL, :1 ²²²²²²²² 6 0XUDWRUL D 0RQWDJLROL/ 0RGHQD 47 PDU]R 4:651 %(02/ $XWRJUDIRWHFD &DPSRUL/ IDVF1 ©0XUDWRUL /RGRYLFR $QWRQLRª/ I1 5571 ,O WHVWR/ FRQ YDULH PHQGH/ q VWDWR SXEEOLFDWR DQFKH LQ /1$1 085$725,/ (SLVWRODULR/ 9,, +4:5;04:66,/ D FXUD GL 01 &$0325,/ 0RGHQD 4<37/ SS1 636;/064:61 7$1 9(&&+,/ ,O OLEUR FKH LO 0XUDWRUL QRQ VFULVVH VXOOD ULIRUPD GHO &OHUR/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 9,,,/ 43+4<8;,/ SS1 60 4<1 8 )1 9(1785,/ 6HWWHFHQWR ULIRUPDWRUH/ ,, +/D &KLHVD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GHQWUR L ORUR OLPLWL/ 4:8;0 4::7,/ 7RULQR 4<:9/ S1 <71 9 ,ELG1/ S1 9:1 : *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL IUD 5LYROX]LRQH H 5HVWDXUD]LRQH +4:<304;48,/ 0RGHQD 4<9:/ S1 5331 3HU L FRQVXPL DQQXL GHL UHOLJLRVL H GHOOH UHOLJLRVH PRGHQHVL QHO 4:9;/ FIU LELG1/ SS1 8<0951 ,O 4ƒ PDU]R 4::< OD *LXULVGL]LRQH YDOXWDYD LO QXPHUR GHJOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL VHFRODUL
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:78
1RQ ULVXOWDYDQR GLVWULEXLWL XQLIRUPHPHQWH VXO WHUULWRULR/ GDWR FKH OH FLWWj GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR QH FRQWDYDQR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH 667 +GL FXL 55: VDFHUGRWL, H 63< +GL FXL 54; VDFHUGRWL, ;1 /H UHOLJLRVH GHO 'XFDWR QHO 4::4 HUDQR 41934/ GL FXL 7;3 QHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD +9;8 QHOO·LQWHUD GLRFHVL, H 878 QHOOD FLWWj GL 5HJJLR1 &RPSOHVVLYDPHQWH/ QHO 'XFDWR L UHOLJLRVL H OH UHOLJLRVH DPPRQWDYD0 QR D 517:< <1 &LIUD YHUDPHQWH QRWHYROH/ GDWR FKH UDSSRUWDWD DO WRWDOH GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH 0 FKH HUD GL FLUFD 6531333 XQLWj 43 0 GDYD XQ UHOLJLRVR R XQD UHOL0 JLRVD RJQL 454 DELWDQWL 441 $ 0RGHQD/ QHO 4::5 OH FDVH UHOLJLRVH PDVFKLOL +QRQ FRQVLGHUDQGR O·,QTXLVL]LRQH FRPH HQWLWj VHSDUDWD GDOO·DQQHVVR FRQYHQWR GRPHQLFDQR PR0 GHQHVH, HUDQR 48 +:8 (,/ H 8 QHO UHVWR GHOOD GLRFHVL1 1HOOD GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR/ YHUVR OD PHWj GHO VHFROR/ OH FDVH UHOLJLRVH PDVFKLOL HUDQR 58 451 ,Q DVVHQ]D GL LQGDJLQL DSSURIRQGLWH H JOREDOL VXO ORUR OLYHOOR GL IRUPD]LR0 QH VSLULWXDOH H FXOWXUDOH/ VXOOH DWWLYLWj VYROWH/ HFF1/ GXUDQWH TXHVWR SHULRGR 46 / ²²²²²²²² GHO 'XFDWR D 91733/ SDUL DO 5 ( GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH/ ULWHQXWD GL 6531333 DELWDQWL +FIU1 QRWD 43,1 , EHQHILFL FXUDWL HUDQR 88:/ H TXHOOL VHPSOLFL 419741 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$ +G·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©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 51 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH 3UR0 YLQFH 0RGHQHVLª/V1 ,9/ ,; +4;<<,/ S1 4 HUDQR 6531333/ H VHFRQGR 21 520%$/',/ &RQWULEXWR DOOD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOOD VWRULD HFRQRPLFD GHL GXFDWL HVWHQVL GDO 4::4 DOO*HWj QDSROHRQLFD/ 3DUPD 4<97/ S1 <, 63;19581 &IU1 QRWD 41 44 $L UHOLJLRVL DQGDYDQR DJJLXQWL L FLUFD :1333 VDFHUGRWL GHO 'XFDWR= XQR RJQL 76 DELWDQWL FLUFD1 *1 6$/9,2/,/ /D OHJLVOD]LRQH 111FLW1/ S1 61 45 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD WUD DQWLFKL H QXRYL UHJLPL/ ,/ +/·DJRQLD GHL SRWHUL WHPSRUDOL,/ %RORJQD 4<:</ S1 :51 46 3HU OR VWDWR GHJOL VWXGL VXOOD YLWD GHOOD &KLHVD LQ JHQHUDOH LQ TXHVW*DUHD/ VSHFLDOPHQWH DO0 OD ILQH GHOO*$QWLFR 5HJLPH/ FIU1 '1 0(12==,/ ,VWLWX]LRQL HFFOHVLDVWLFKH/ FXOWXUD FULVWLDQD H YLWD UHOL0 JLRVD QHOO*(PLOLD05RPDJQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 ,QWURGX]LRQH DL SULPL ULVXOWDWL GL XQD ULFHUFD/ LQ ©&ULVWLDQHVL0 PR QHOOD 6WRULDª/ 7 +4<;6,/SS1 6680674> *1 58**,(5,/ /D WHRORJLD ERORJQHVH DOOD ILQH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR=
:79
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
F·q GD ULWHQHUH FKH L UHOLJLRVL GHO 'XFDWR SUHVHQWDVVHUR OH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH GHL ORUR FRQIUDWHOOL GHO UHVWR G·,WDOLD1 6H TXDOFXQR KD QRWDWR FKH WUD L UHOLJLRVL H0 VWHQVL ©OH YLUW• DVFHWLFKH QRQ HUDQR GRYXQTXH FROWLYDWH FRQ LO PHGHVLPR ]H0 ORª/ q DQFKH YHUR FKH QRQ q PDQFDWR FKL VL q HVSUHVVR LQ WHUPLQL HORJLDWLYL QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL1 3HU HVHPSLR/ )UDQFHVFR 0DULD G·(VWH +4:7604;54,/ YH0 VFRYR GL 5HJJLR H DEDWH GL 1RQDQWROD 0 SHUDOWUR/ VHYHUR FHQVRUH GHL FRVWXPL GHJOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL 0 FKH ULWHQHYD L UHOLJLRVL GHOOD VXD GLRFHVL ©RPQL FRPPHQ0 GDWLRQH GLJQLª/ GDWR FKH/ ©SDXFLV H[FHSWLV/ SURFXUDQGDH DQLPDUXP VDOXWL SUR VXR RPQHV LQVWLWXWR DQLPXP YHKHPHQWHU DGMLFLXQW HW ERQXP ILGHOLEXV SUDH0 EHQW LQ YHUER/ LQ FRQYHUVDWLRQH/ LQ DOLLV YLUWXWLEXVª 471 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OD ORUR DWWLYLWj/ SRVVLDPR GLUH FKH SUDWLFDPHQWH WXWWL L UHOLJLRVL IRUQLYDQR DVVLVWHQ]D VSLULWXDOH DL IHGHOL FKH IUHTXHQWDYDQR OH ORUR FKLHVH +FKH WDORUD HUDQR DQFKH VHGL GL SDUURFFKLH,/ HG HYHQWXDOPHQWH DL PHPEUL GHL 7HU]L 2UGLQL 6HFRODUL H GHOOH FRQIUDWHUQLWH LQ HVVH HUHWWL1 6DSSLDPR/ LQROWUH/ FKH L &DSSXFFLQL 0 LPSHJQDWL QHOO·DVVLVWHQ]D DJOL LQIHU0 PL GHOO·2VSHGDOH GL 0RGHQD 48 H GL 5HJJLR 49 0 JRGHYDQR WUD LO SRSROR GL PH0 ULWDWD VWLPD H VL GHGLFDYDQR DQFKH DOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH QHOOH FDP0 SDJQH 4:> L &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L HUDQR LPSHJQDWL QHOOD GLUH]LRQH VSLULWXDOH/ H/ ²²²²²²²² OD ULIRUPD GHOOD &KLHVD/ LELG1/ SS1 76:07931 47 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD 111FLW1/ S1 :<1 48 /*DVVLVWHQ]D VSLULWXDOH GHJOL LQIHUPL GHOO*2VSHGDOH GL 0RGHQD QHO 4:75 YHQQH DIILGDWD DL &DSSXFFLQL/ FKH QHO 4:97 GRYHWWHUR FHGHUOD DJOL 6FRORSL1 $ TXHVWL QHO 4::7 VXEHQWUz XQ &RQVRU]LR GL 6DFHUGRWL/ FKH QHO 4;67 YHQQH D VXD YROWD VRVWLWXLWR GDL &DSSXFFLQL/ ULFKLDPDWL GD )UDQFHVFR ,91 &IU1 31', 3,(752/ /*2VSHGDOH GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<98/ SS145404551 49 ,Q VHJQR GL ULFRQRVFHQ]D SHU O·DVVLVWHQ]D SUHVWDWD DJOL DSSHVWDWL GXUDQWH OD WHUULELOH HSL0 GHPLD GHO 495<04964/ QHO 4:56 OD FLWWDGLQDQ]D DYHYD DIILGDWR DL &DSSXFLQL O·DVVLVWHQ]D VSLUL0 WXDOH GHOO·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·RUD LQ SRL= $&$02,/ 5HJ1 4;3404;35/ SS1 484/ 4981 $ VSLQJH0 UH L &DSSXFFLQL HPLOLDQL ©D PDJJLRUH ODERULRVLWj/ D UHQGHUVL XWLOL DOOD VRFLHWj/ D FROWLYDUH JOL VWXGL/ D WHQGHUH DG XQD SLHWj SL• LOOXPLQDWD/ D FRPEDWWHUH OD IDOVD PRUDOHª DYHYD FRQWULEXLWR/ GXUDQWH LO VXR SURYLQFLDODWR +4:9;04::4,/ S1 $GHRGDWR 7XUFKL/ FRQ OD VXD ©ORWWD VHQ]D TXDU0 WLHUH DL SUHJLXGL]L IUDWHVFKL/ DOOD R]LRVLWj/ DOOH VXSHUVWL]LRQL/ FKH WURYD>YD@ DQQLGDWH QHL FRQ0 YHQWLª1 67$1,6/$2 '$ &$03$*12/$/ $GHRGDWR 7XUFKL= XRPR0RUDWRUH0YHVFRYR +4:5;04;36,/ 5R0 PD 4<94/ 4331 &IU DQFKH SS1 43904451 &LUFD OD SURFHGXUD GD VHJXLUH SHU RWWHQHUH GDO SURYLQ0
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:7:
GRSR OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHL *HVXLWL/ DQFKH QHJOL HVHUFL]L VSLULWXDOL DJOL HFFOHVLD0 VWLFL> L %HQHGHWWLQL/ L &RQYHQWXDOL/ L 'RPHQLFDQL 4; / L 0LQLPL/ HFF1/ FXUDYDQR O·DWWLYLWj LQWHOOHWWXDOH1 &RPH L *HVXLWL 4</ FKH GLYLGHYDQR FRQ JOL 6FRORSL O·LQVHJQDPHQWR> H FRQ L 7HDWLQL OD FXUD VSLULWXDOH GHOOH FODVVL HOHYDWH1 0HQWUH JOL 2UDWRULDQL VL GHGLFDYDQR DOO·DVVLVWHQ]D GHOOD ERUJKHVLD531 , UHOLJLRVL SURY0 YHGHYDQR DQFKH DOO·DVVLVWHQ]D VSLULWXDOH DOOH WUXSSH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH GL TXHOOH VWUDQLHUH/ IRUQHQGR ORUR FDSSHOODQL PLOLWDUL H FRQIHVVRUL SROLJORWWL 541 1HO 6HW0 ²²²²²²²² FLDOH GHL &DSSXFFLQL O*DVVHJQD]LRQH GHO SUHGLFDWRUH TXDUHVLPDOH/ FIU OD OHWWHUD GL %1 %UDQGROL/ VHJUHWDULR GL &DVD 0RQWHFXFFROL/ D /1 3DUHQWL/ JRYHUQDWRUH GL 0RQWHFXFFROR/ GHO 49 QRYHP0 EUH 4:<51 %UDQGROL QRQ DYHYD JUDQGH VWLPD GL WDOL SUHGLFDWRUL/ ©JLDFFKp UDUL VRQR L &DSSXFFL0 QL FKH LQWHUHVVDQRª1 %(02/ )RQGR $1 6RUEHOOL/ ILO1 49/ Q1 891 &IU DQFKH LELG1/ Q1 831 8Q HVHP0 SLR GL FRPH IRVVH VXGGLYLVD WUD OH SDUURFFKLH GL XQ YLFDULDWR IRUDQHR O*RSHUD +H O*RQRUDULR, GHO SUHGLFDWRUH FLUFRODUH GHOOD TXDUHVLPD VL SXz OHJJHUH QHOOD OHWWHUD GHO 4; PDJJLR 4::;/ VFULWWD GD &DUSL GDO S1 %RQDYHQWXUD 0LODQWL DOO*LQTXLVLWRUH GL 0RGHQD1 $602/ ,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ILO]1 59:1 $ 0RGHQD/ LO VHJUHWDULR GHO YHVFRYR DYHYD ©LO UHJLVWUR H PDQHJJLR GL WXWWD OD SUHGL0 FD]LRQHª1 &IU %1 %UDQGROL D /1 3DUHQWL/ 0RGHQD 57 PDU]R 4:;61 %(02/ )RQGR $1 6RUEHOOL/ ILO1 462,,/ Q1 7<1 $ 0DVVD )LQDOHVH/ LQ PDQFDQ]D GL ©DVVHJQDPHQWR FHUWRª SHU LO SUHGLFDWRUH GHOOD TXDUHVLPD/ OH FRQIUDWHUQLWH ©PRWR SURSULR JOL SDVVDYDQR … 58 D WLWROR GL FLEDULDª1 3RFR SULPD GHO 4:93/ XQD IHGHOH REEOLJz O*HUHGH D YHUVDUH SHU WDOH VFRSR OLUH 83 DQQXH1 *101 58%%,$1,/ /LEUR GL PHPRULH VSHWWDQWL DOOD FKLHVD DUFLSUHWDOH GHOOD SLHYH GL 0DVVD GL 6DQ *HPLQLDQR/ FRPLQFLDWR GDOO*DUFLSUHWH *LRVHIIR 0DULD 5XEELDQL/ FLWWDGLQR PRGDQHVH/ O*DQQR 4:8; +PV LQ $5&+,9,2 3$552&&+,$/(/ 0DVVD )LQDOHVH,/ 440451 1HO 4:94 SUHGLFz OD TXDUHVLPD D 0DVVD )LQDOHVH LO S1 OHWWRUH 0DULQL/ ©EXRQR =RFFRODQWHª GHO )LQDOH> H QHO 4:94 LO S1 *LRVHIIR *REEL GD %UHVFHO0 OR/ &RQYHQWXDOH1 ,ELG1 6X 5XEELDQL +4:4904;35,/ DUFLSUHWH GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH +4:8;04;35,/ FIU (1 *5,0$/',/ 0DVVD )LQDOHVH H OD VXD DQWLFD SLHYH/ 6DQ )HOLFH VXO 3DQDUR 4<;8/ SS1;;0<8> *1 92/3,/ 1RWH DOOD ©6HULH FURQRORJLFD GHL SDUURFL GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVHª/ LQ 3HU XQD VWRULD GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH/ D FXUD GL &1 )5,621/ 0RGHQD 4<;8/ 46904741 6XOOH SURFHGXUH SHU O*DVVHJQD]LRQH GHL SXOSLWL D PHWj *933 +JOL DVSLUDQWL VL IDFHYDQR VSHVVR UDFFRPDQGDUH GD SULQFLSL HVWHUL,/ FIU $602/ *LX0 ULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO1 5;8/ IDVF1 ©3XOSLWL GHOOD 'LRFHVL GL 5HJJLR H SUHGLFKHª1 4; 3DUWLFRODUPHQWH QXPHURVL L SURIHVVRUL GRPHQLFDQL QHOOR 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 0RGHQD1 &IU1 31 ', 3,(752/ /R 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 61 &DUOR LQ 0RGHQD +49;504::5,1 1RYDQW*DQQL GL VWRULD GHOO*8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<:3/ &1*1 025031 ', 3,(752/ 6WRULD GHOO*8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGH0 QD/ ,/ )LUHQ]H 4<:81 4< &IU *1 25/$1',/ /D &RPSDJQLD GL *HV• D 0RGHQD/ DO WHPSR GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ LQ ©0RGHQD6WRULDª/ 6 +4<<8,/ SS1 6506:1 53 61635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD FLW1/ S1::1 54 1HO 4:9:/ LO S1 )UDQoRLV +1DFKWHO/ R 1DFKWHXO, GH /XFHUQH/ )UDWH 0LQRUH 2VVHUYDQWH GLPRUDQWH QHO FRQYHQWR PRGHQHVH GL 61 0DUJKHULWD/ HUD FDSSHOODQR GHO 5HJJLPHQWR *XDUGLH H GHOOD JXDUQLJLRQH GHOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH1 ,Q XQD OHWWHUD GHO : QRYHPEUH 4:9: GLUHWWD D XQ IXQ]LRQDULR GXFDOH VFULYHYD FKH LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO SUHFHWWR SDVTXDOH WURYDYD VFDUVD FROODERUD0 ]LRQH WUD LO FOHUR PRGHQHVH= ©SHUVRQQH VH SUrWH SRXU FRQIHVVHU OHV VROGDWV/ TXH PD UHOLJLRQ HW
:7;
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
WHFHQWR/ L UHOLJLRVL GHO 'XFDWR LQYLDURQR DQFKH SHUVRQDOH QHOOH PLVVLRQL HVWH0 UH 551 6XOO·DOWUR SLDWWR GHOOD ELODQFLD/ SHU XQ·RJJHWWLYD YDOXWD]LRQH GHO UXROR VYRO0 WR GDL UHOLJLRVL 0 PD OD FRVD YDOH QDWXUDOPHQWH DQFKH SHU OH UHOLJLRVH 0 DQ0 GUHEEHUR SRVWL JOL HYHQWXDOL DVSHWWL QHJDWLYL GHO ORUR FRPSRUWDPHQWR1 $ GLUH LO YHUR/ OH IRQWL SHUYHQXWHFL QRQ VHPEUDQR GHQXQFLDUH XQ SDUWLFRODUH PDOHV0 VHUH1 $QFKH VH QHO FRUVR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR QRQ PDQFDURQR QHOOH FLWWj H QHO FRQ0 WDGR FDVL FKH ULFKLHVHUR O·LQWHUYHQWR GHOOH DXWRULWj 56/ O·LPSUHVVLRQH FRPSOHV0 ²²²²²²²² OHV 3qUHV 7KpUpVLHQV &DUPpOLWDLQV GpFKDXVVpVª1 $602/ 5HJRODUL/ ILO]D 9;1 ,O 5; VHWWHPEUH 4:;;/ GRSR 6< DQQL GL VHUYL]LR/ FKLHVH FKH JOL IRVVH DIILDQFDWR ©XQ VHFRQGR FDSSHOODQR IRUH0 VWLHUH UHOLJLRVR GHO PHGHVLPR 2UGLQHª/ FKH VDSHVVH ©YDULH OLQJXHª1 6L LJQRUD VH OD VXD ULFKLHVWD YHQQH DFFROWD/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH O·XQLFR FDQGLGDWR QRQ HUD JUDGLWR DL VXSHULRUL/ SHUFKp ©GL SRFR EXRQ QRPH/ VFUHGLWDWR GD SHU WXWWR/ HG DQFKH HVLOLDWR GD DOFXQL 3DHVLª1 $602/ &DQFHOOH0 ULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO]D 7/ Q1 578/ ,9/ %/ 51 &IU QRWD 671 55 /D GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD/ SHU HVHPSLR/ IRUQu 59 PLVVLRQDUL +47 &DSSXFFLQL/ 7 &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L/ 5 &RQYHQWXDOL/ 8 )UDQFHVFDQL H 4 *HVXLWD,1 *1 3,6721,/ /*DWWLYLWj PLVVLRQDULD QHOOH 'LRFH0 VL GL 0RGHQD H 1RQDQWROD/ 0RGHQD 4<9:1 1HO FRPSXWR VRQR LQFOXVL DQFKH L PLVVLRQDUL SURYH0 QLHQWL GDOO·DEED]LD GL 1RQDQWROD/ FKH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR FRVWLWXLYD DQFRUD XQ·HQWLWj DXWRQRPD1 ,O *HVXLWD VXPPHQ]LRQDWR HUD S1 *DHWDQR &DWWDQHR +49<804:66,/ PLVVLRQDULR LQ 3DUDJXD\ +GDO 4:5<,/ OH FXL OHWWHUH DO IUDWHOOR *LXVHSSH RIIULURQR OR VSXQWR D /1$1 0XUDWRUL SHU VFULYHUH LO VXR &ULVWLDQHVLPR IHOLFH QHOOH 0LVVLRQL GHL 3DGUL GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV• QHO 3DUDJXD\/ 9HQH]LD 4:761 &IU1 *1 3,6721,/ /*DWWLYLWj PLVVLRQDULD«FLW1/ :80:91 $ IDUFL XQ*LGHD GHOOD VHQVLELOLWj GHL FULVWLDQL GHO WHPSR SHU OH PLVVLRQL HVWHUH FRQWULEXLVFH O·DUFLSUHWH GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH/ FKH GHVFULVVH OD YLVLWD GHOO*DEDWH PDURQLWD 7RPDVR $FKLP DOOD VXD SDUURFFKLD/ OD GRPHQLFD 5 RWWREUH 4:961 $OOD ILQH GHOOD PHVVD/ FHOHEUDWD GDOO*DEDWH QHO VXR ULWR/ LO SDUURFR LQYLWz L IHGHOL D VRFFRUUHUH L FULVWLDQL OLEDQHVL/ ©FKH ,GGLR SHUPHWWH GL ODVFLDU LQ PDQR GH* QHPLFL GHO QRPH FULVWLDQR1 /H SDUROH GHO 3DUURFR LQWHQHULURQR WDOPHQWH LO SRSROR/ FK*HJOL GDOO*DOWDUH QH ULPLUz YDULL D SLDQ0 JHUH/ H ULFDYz GD TXHVWL SRYHUL FRQWDGLQL LQ TXHO JLRUQR VROR … FHQWR YHQWLWUp1 3DUWu OD VHUD VWHVVD O*DEDWH FRQWHQWLVVLPRª1 *1 01 58%%,$1,/ /LEUR GL PHPRULH«FLW1/S1 4:1 &IU S1 <:1 56 &IU *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD FDWWROLFD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ 4;4804;94/ 0RGHQD 4<9;/ SS1 6706:1 6L KD O*LPSUHVVLRQH FKH WDORUD OH DXWRULWj GLSLQJHVVHUR OD VLWXD]LRQH D FRORUL SL• IRVFKL GHO GRYXWR/ PDJDUL SHU JLXVWLILFDUH OD ORUR SROLWLFD1 ,O 48 IHEEUDLR 4:9;/ DG HVHPSLR/ %LDQFKL VFULYHYD DO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD= ©(* JLXQWD D WDO VHJQR G*LUUHOLJLRVLWj/ GL SXEEOLFD LQGHFHQ]D H GL VFDQGDOR OD OLEHUD H IDPLJOLDUH PDQLHUD GL YLYHUH H GL FRPSDULUH SHU OD FLWWj GHOOD PDJJLRU SDUWH GH* UHJRODULª/ FKH LO GXFD/ ©LQ SHQGHQ]D GHOOH DOWUH SURYYLGHQ]H/ FKH EHQ D UDJLRQH VWD GLYLVDQGR VXO FRQWR GL WDOL IDPLJOLHª/ SHU VXR PH]]R VL ULYROJHYD DO YHVFRYR SHUFKp YL SRQHV0 VH ULSDUR1 (G HFFR OD FDXVD GL WDQWD LQGLJQD]LRQH= ©,Q PH]]R D XQD FLWWj FDSLWDOH/ H LQ IDFFLD DOOD VWHVVD &RUWH/ q LQWROOHUDELOH LO YHGHUH LQ WXWWH OH RUH GHOOD JLRUQDWD YDJDQWL SHU OH VWUDGH/ SHU OH FDVH H SHU OH ERWWHJKH GD FDIIq SHUVRQH UHOLJLRVH DIIDWWR VROH/ H LQ DELWL FRUWL/ FRPH VH IRVVHUR LQ PH]]R G*XQD YLOOD/ FRQ Vu SRFR ULJXDUGR DO SURSULR FDUDWWHUH/ H FRQ WDQWR PHQR ULVSHWWR DO SXEEOLFR PHGHVLPRª1 $O YHVFRYR/ SHUWDQWR/ VL RUGLQDYD GL FRQYRFDUH L VXSHULRUL GL
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:7<
VLYD FKH FL RIIURQR L GRFXPHQWL q SLXWWRVWR TXHOOD GL XQD ©DXUHD PHGLRFULWDVª 571 3HU HVHPSLR/ SXz GHVWDUH VWXSRUH/ SL• FKH VFDQGDOR/ FKH DOO·LQWHUQR GL 2UGLQL QRWL LQ SDVVDWR SHU LO ORUR IHUYRUH 0 FRPH L &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L 0 VL GL0 EDWWHVVHUR SUREOHPL FRPH OD OLFHLWj GHOOH YDFDQ]H HVWLYH GD WUDVFRUUHUH IXRUL FRQYHQWR +LQ IDPLJOLD R SUHVVR DPLFL,/ GHOOD ORUR GXUDWD/ HFF1 2 FKH VL HODER0 ²²²²²²²² GHWWL UHOLJLRVL H GL LQGXUOL D FRUUHJJHUH XQ GLVRUGLQH GDOOH LQILQLWH FRQVHJXHQ]H GDQQRVH1 $5&+,9,2 '(//$ 6(*5(7(5,$ $5&,9(6&29,/(/ 0RGHQD +G·RUD LQ SRL= $6$02,/ ILO1 4481 5HVWDYD/ FRPXQTXH/ VHPSUH YDOLGR FLz FKH LO 55 PDU]R 4::; VFULYHYD DOO*LQTXLVLWRUH GL 5HJ0 JLR LO S1 &DUOR $QWRQLR 3HUVRQDOL 0 D SURSRVLWR GL GLVRUGLQL PDQLIHVWDWLVL LQ XQ PRQDVWHUR IHPPLQLOH GL 0LUDQGROD 0 HVRUWDQGROR DG ©DQGDU VROHFLWDPHQWH DO WURSSR QHFHVVDULR ULSDUR SULPD FKH O*LQIH]LRQH V*LQROWUL/ EHQ VDSHQGR HOOD FKH DQFKH QH* FKLRVWUL YL VRQR DQLPH GHEROL/ H WDOYROWD LQFOLQDWH PDOH/ SL• IDFLOL SHUFLz DG HVVHU FRQWDPLQDWH GD HPSL SULQFLSL/ FKH ULODVFLD0 QR LO IUHQR D WXWWH OH XPDQH SDVVLRQL/ H LQROWUDWL FKH VLHQR H VSDUVL LQ XQ PRQDVWHUR/ D PHQR GL XQ SLHQR WULRQIR GHOOD GLYLQD JUD]LD/ QRQ ULHVFLUHEEH SRVVLELOH GL VUDGLFDUOLª1 $602/ ,QTXL0 VL]LRQH/ ILO]D 5:8/ %(GLWWL/ SXEEOLFD]LRQL/ HWF1/ 4:7304:;5%1 57 1RQ VHPEUD FKH OH FDUWH GHOO*,QTXLVL]LRQH/ FRQVHUYDWH QHOO*$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGH0 QD/ GHEEDQR LQGXUUH D PRGLILFDUH WDOH JLXGL]LR/ VH VL WLHQH FRQWR GHOOD JUDQGH TXDQWLWj GL UHOL0 JLRVL H UHOLJLRVH GLPRUDQWL QHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH1 &HUWDPHQWH TXHVWL YL ILJXUDYDQR FRPH LPSX0 WDWL/ PD LQ XQ QXPHUR GL FDVL SHUFHQWXDOPHQWH QRQ ULOHYDQWH1 ,O UHDWR SL• IUHTXHQWH HUD OD ©VROOHFLWDWLR DG WXUSLDª/ D SURSRVLWR GHOOD TXDOH q VWDWR VFULWWR= ©, UHL VRQR UHOLJLRVL GL YDULD QDWXUD H VWLOH= VL YD GDO SULRUH GL 61 'RPHQLFR FKH FRQIHVVD +4:37, XQD VXD UHOD]LRQH GHO WHPSR LQ FXL VL WURYDYD D &RUUHJJLR/ FRPH FRQIHVVRUH GHOOH PRQDFKH GRPHQLFDQH GL FODXVX0 UD >111@/ DO IUDWH IUDQFHVFDQR (XJHQLR GD $OHVVDQGULD FKH/ SHFFDQGR FRQ IDWWL H FRQ SDUROH/ VL ID FDFFLDUH +4:36, GD /HYL]]DQR GRYH VWD SUHGLFDQGR OD 4XDUHVLPD1 /D GLIIXVD LPPRUDOLWj GRFXPHQWDWD GD TXHVWL SURFHVVL FRVWLWXLVFH LO URYHVFLR GHOOD PHGDJOLD ULVSHWWR DOOD PDJJLRUH GLVFLSOLQD H GLVFUH]LRQH FKH LQGXEELDPHQWH FDUDWWHUL]]z OD FRQGRWWD GHO FOHUR GRSR LO &RQFL0 OLR GL 7UHQWRª1 $ TXDQWR SDUH/ OD VLWXD]LRQH PLJOLRUz QHL GHFHQQL VXFFHVVLYL1 &1 5,*+,/ /*,Q0 TXLVL]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFD D 0RGHQD QHO *:33/ LQ )RUPD]LRQH H FRQWUROOR GHOO*RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD D 0RGHQD QHO *:33/ D FXUD GL $1 %,21',/ 0RGHQD 4<;9/ S1 :81 3HU XQ FRQIURQWR FRQ L UHOLJLRVL GL DOWUH DUHH JHRJUDILFKH/ SHU HVHPSLR FRQ TXHOOL GHOOD 7RVFDQD H GHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL/ FIU1 %1 3(75$*/ 4XLHWLVPR H LQFUHGXOLWj QHO WDUGR 6HWWHFHQWR SUDWHVH/ LQ ©$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR 3UDWHVHª/ 97 +4<;;,/SS1 4:604;:> '1 $0%5$6,/ 5LIRUPDWRUL H ULEHOOL D 1DSROL QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 5LFHUFKH VXO JLDQVHQLVPR QDSROHWDQR/ 1DSROL 4<:</ SS1 6707;> 51 '( 0$,2/ 6RFLHWj H YLWD UHOLJLRVD D 1DSROL QHOO*H0 Wj PRGHUQD +498904:<<,/ 1DSROL 4<:4/ S1 4;61 $GGROFLPHQWL QHOOD SUDWLFD UHJRODUH VL HUDQR LQ0 VLQXDWL DQFKH QHJOL 2UGLQL SL• DXVWHUL1 ,O 46 GLFHPEUH 4:<5/ DG HVHPSLR/ LO S1 9ULHX FKLHGHYD O*DSSRJJLR GHO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD SHU SRWHU SDVVDUH GDOOD &HUWRVD GL %RORJQD/ GRYH YLJHYD OD SHUIHWWD RVVHUYDQ]D/ D TXHOOD GL )HUUDUD/ QHOOD TXDOH HUD VWDWD LQWURGRWWD TXDOFKH PLWLJD]LRQH1 ,O VXSSOLFDQWH/ GL QD]LRQDOLWj IUDQFHVH/ WURYDYD GLIILFLOH 1ULHQWUDUH QHL UDQJKL/ GRSR HVVHUH VWD0 WR D OXQJR VXSHULRUH1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6HJUHWHULD GL *DELQHWWR/ $IIDUL 'LYHUVL/ ILO]D 48 +4:<5,1
:83
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
UDVVHUR FRPSOLFDWH GLVTXLVL]LRQL VXOO·XVR GHOOD FLRFFRODWD/ HFF1581 &RPXQTXH/ VHPEUD GL SRWHU FRQGLYLGHUH FLz FKH VFULYH $OEHUWR 9HFFKL/ D SURSRVLWR GHO ULODVVDPHQWR GLIIXVR QHOOH FDVH UHOLJLRVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR= ©1XOOD GL WHQHEURVR/ GL YLROHQWR= VROWDQWR GL WURSSR QDWXUDOH DPRUH SHU OH PRUELGH]]H GL XQ TXLHWR YLYHUH >111@1 , ULJRURVL SDUODYDQR DEEDVWDQ]D YROHQWLHUL GL TXHVWR VWDWR GL ULODVVDWH]0 ]D/ G·LQILDFFKLPHQWR/ H QRQ VL SXz FRQWUROODUH VH FLz DYYHQLVVH LQ PLVXUD XQ WDQWLQR SL• ODUJD GHO QHFHVVDULR1 , WHPSL HUDQR SHUSHWXDPHQWH PRVVL GD LVWDQ]H SROHPLFKH FKH WHQGHYDQR D ULOHYDUH RYXQTXH PRWLYL GL ILHUD GUDPPDWLFLWjª 591
6ROR DOO·RFFKLR GHO SURIDQR OD IDODQJH GHL UHOLJLRVL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR SXz DS0 SDULUH XQLIRUPH H FRPSDWWD1 3HU FHUFDUH GL IDUH XQ SR· GL FKLDUH]]D 0 DQFKH LQ YLVWD GL TXDQWR DQGUHPR GLFHQGR LQ VHJXLWR 0 ELVRJQD RSHUDUH DOFXQH GL0 VWLQ]LRQL1 3HU HVHPSLR/ GDQGR SHU VFRQWDWD OD GLYLVLRQH GHJOL ,VWLWXWL PDVFKLOL ²²²²²²²² 58 7UDWWDWR VRSUD OH YDFDQ]H1 6H VLD OHFLWR DG XQ &DUPHOLWDQR 6FDO]R O·DQGDUYL1 6FULWWR D PDQLHUD GL OHWWHUD DG XQ DPLFR/ PV LQ %(02/ 5DFF1 &DPSRUL/ 4;5; +J1 21 81 67,/ V1G1/ PD SUREDELOPHQWH GHJOL DQQL 2WWDQWD GHO VHF1 ;9,,,1 3RWUHEEH HVVHUQH DXWRUH LO S1 9,7725,2/ 21&1'1 9L VL OHJ0 JH FKH PROWL UHOLJLRVL 0 SHU SURFXUDUVL OD FLRFFRODWD/ GL FXL HUDQR IRUWL FRQVXPDWRUL 0 ULFRUUH0 YDQR D ©ORQJKH GLPRUH IXRUL GHO FKLRVWUR SHU DSSURILWWDU GHOO·HOHPRVLQH GHOOH PHVVHª1 $YH0 YDQR PRWLYD]LRQL YHQDOL VLD ©O·HVSRUVL DO SXOSLWR FRQ SRFR FDSLWDOH GL VFLHQ]D/ H QHVVXQR GL YRFD]LRQH/ FRQ TXDWWUR VHUPRQL IDWWL D PRVDLFR/ H UHFLWDWL SHU LQWHUHVVH/ H QRQ SHU ]HOR GHOOD VDOXWH GHOOH DQLPHª/ VLD FHUWL ©WUDIILFL IDWWL FROOD VLFXUH]]D GHO JXDGDJQR H VLPLOLª +I1 476,1 7DQ0 WR FKH LO IDPRVR PRUDOLVWD 'DQLHOOR &RQFLQD DYHYD SRWXWR DIIHUPDUH FKH OD FLRFFRODWD HUD ©OD URYLQD GHOOD GLVFLSOLQD UHJRODUHª +I1 484,1 59 $1 9(&&+,/ ,O OLEUR FKH LO 0XUDWRUL QRQ VFULVVH VXOOD ULIRUPD GHO &OHUR/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHO0 OD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/V1 9,,,/ 43 +4<8;,/S1 <1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD 9HQH]LD QHO VHFROR SUHFHGHQWH/ LO SXQWR GL YLVWD GL 9HFFKL q VRVWDQ]LDO0 PHQWH FRQGLYLVR GD *1 63,1(//,/ , UHOLJLRVL H OH UHOLJLRVH/ LQ /D &KLHVD GL 9HQH]LD QHO 6HLFHQWR +&RQWULEXWL DOOD VWRULD GHOOD &KLHVD YHQH]LDQD/ 8,/ 9HQH]LD 4<<5/ S14<31 $ GHWWD GL 51 &$126$ +,O YHOR H LO FDSSXFFLR1 0RQDFD]LRQL IRU]DWH H VHVVXDOLWj QHL FRQYHQWL IHPPLQLOL LQ ,WDOLD WUD 4XDWWURFHQWR H 6HWWH0 FHQWR/ 5RPD 4<<4/ S1 559,/ ©QHO 6HL H 6HWWHFHQWR LQ JHQHUDOH +H VHQ]D QHJDUH OD HVLVWHQ]D GL IDWWL FKH/ LQ TXDOFKH PRGR QRQ HEEHUR QXOOD GD LQYLGLDUH D TXHOOL GHO %VHFROR G*RUR% GHOOD VHV0 VXDOLWj FRQYHQWXDOH, OH %WXUEROHQ]H% SHUVHUR GL TXDQWLWj H TXDOLWj1 4XDQWLWDWLYDPHQWH JOL %VFDQGDOL% IXURQR QRWHYROPHQWH PLQRUL GL TXHOOL TXDWWUR0FLQTXHFHQWHVFKL1 4XDOLWDWLYDPHQWH/ SL• FKH HVSUHVVLRQH GL VHVVXDOLWj/ DVVDL VSHVVR OR IXURQR GL %FRQYLYLDOLWj%/ OD UHSUHVVLRQH GHOOD SULPD FRQWULEXHQGR LQ TXDOFKH PRGR DOOD LQFOLQD]LRQH DOOD VHFRQGD1 /H IHVWH GL QRYL]LDWR/ TXHOOH GL FDUQHYDOH/ OH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL WHDWUDOL FKH GD WHPSR LPPHPRUDELOH VFDQGLYDQR OD YLWD FRQYHQWXDOH/ QRQ VROR QRQ YHQQHUR PHQR/ PD/ VXOO*RQGD GHOOD FXOWXUD GHO %DURFFR/ DVVDL EHQ GLVSRVWD QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL/ HEEHUR XQ SRVWR GL ULOLHYR FRPH WUDPLWH IUD LO FRQYHQWR HG LO PRQGRª1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:84
LQ &DQRQLFL 5HJRODUL/ 0RQDFL/ 0HQGLFDQWL/ &KLHULFL 5HJRODUL/ &RQJUHJD]LRQL 5HOLJLRVH H TXHOOH FKH RJJL VL FKLDPDQR 6RFLHWj GL 9LWD $SRVWROLFD/ HFF15:/ VD0 Uj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©3UHWL UHJRODULª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©0HQGLFDQWLª VROR L &DSSXFFLQL/ L &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L/ JOL 2VVHUYDQWL H L 5LIRUPDWL 641 8Q·DOWUD GLVWLQ]LRQH GD RSHUDUH q TXHOOD WUD UHOLJLRVL FKH SUDWLFDYDQR LO GL0 ULWWR GL DIILOLD]LRQH H TXHOOL FKH QRQ OR SUDWLFDYDQR1 /·DIILOLD]LRQH 0 GL FXL LO GH0 FUHWR GXFDOH GHO 7 JLXJQR 4:;5 VRVSHVH O·DSSOLFD]LRQH/ ILQR D QXRYR RUGLQH/ QHL FRQIURQWL GHL UHOLJLRVL HVWHUL 0 GHVLJQDYD O·DSSDUWHQHQ]D GL XQ UHOLJLRVR DG ²²²²²²²² 5:
3HU OD VXD SHFXOLDULWj/ WUDODVFLDPR GL WUDWWDUH GHOO*2UGLQH GL 0DOWD/ FKH D 0RGHQD DYHYD OD &RPPHQGD GL 61 *LRYDQQL GHO &DQWRQH/ VRSSUHVVD LO 4< IHEEUDLR 4:<;1 &IU *1 62/,/ &KLHVH GL 0RGHQD/ ,,/ 0RGHQD 4<:7/ S14;41 5; 6XO VLJQLILFDWR GHO WHUPLQH ©SRVVLGHQWLª/ FIU 01 0,(/(/ 5LFHUFKH VXOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHL UHOL0 JLRVL QHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL +4;3904;48,/ LQ ©&DPSDQLD 6DFUDª/ 7 +4<:6,/S1 841 5< /D &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHOOD %HDWD 9HUJLQH H GL 61 &DUOR HEEH OD GLUH]LRQH GHOOR 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR ILQR DO 4::5/ DQQR LQ FXL TXHVWR YHQQH WUDVIRUPDWR LQ 8QLYHUVLWj1 &IU $1 %,21',/ , VHFROL GHO 6DQ &DUOR/ LQ ,O &ROOHJLR H OD FKLHVD GL 6DQ &DUOR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<<4/ S17<1 &IU QRWD 4;1 63 ©0ROWH 5HOLJLRQL GL 3DGUL KDQQR DYXWD OD SROL]]D GDOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH GHOOR VWDWR VXR/ VH VRQR SRVVLGHQWL/ Vu R QRª1 $121,02/ &URQDFD GL 0RGHQD >GDO@ 4:8< LQ DYDQWL >4:<4@/ %(02/ D161:15 +,WDO14447,/ I1 5:7* +48 PDJJLR 4:;5,1 64 7DEHOOH GHJOL (FFOHVLDVWLFL 6HFRODUL H 5HJRODUL +4::304:<4,1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D ;1 7DOL WDEHOOH HUDQR UHGDWWH GDL VXSHULRUL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ LQ RWWHPSHUDQ]D DOOD QRWLILFD]LRQH FD0 PHUDOH GHO 5: DJRVWR 4:9;/ H WUDVPHVVH DOOD )HUPD *HQHUDOH1 ,O YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD HUD VROLWR GHVWLQDUH DOOH ©5HOLJLRQL 0HQGLFDQWLª GXH VDFFKL GL IUXPHQWR H FLQTXH VDFFKL GL IDULQD +SHU OD IHVWD GHL 0RUWL,/ YLQR/ IDJLROL/ HFF1/ LPSLHJDQGRYL OLUH PRGHQHVL 8331 $6$02/ 9LVLWH 3DVWRUDOL/ ILO]D % +HOHPRVLQH IDWWH QHO 4:;;,1
:85
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
XQ GHWHUPLQDWR PRQDVWHUR R FRQYHQWR/ LO FXL RUJDQLFR HUD ILVVDWR LQ EDVH DOOH GLVSRQLELOLWj HFRQRPLFKH GL HVVL1 ,O UHOLJLRVR HUD DIILOLDWR/ FLRq DJJUHJDWR DG XQD FDVD GHO VXR 2UGLQH LQ PDQLHUD SDUWLFRODUH/ WDQWR FKH L VXSHULRUL QRQ SR0 WHYDQR/ VHQ]D JLXVWR PRWLYR/ GHVWLQDUOR DG DOWUD UHVLGHQ]D 651 /·DIILOLD]LRQH GLIIHULYD GDOOD VWDELOLWj EHQHGHWWLQD/ LQ TXDQWR TXHVWD HUD DQ]LWXWWR XQ REEOLJR GHULYDQWH GD XQ YRWR 66/ FKH LO VXSHULRUH SRWHYD GLVSHQVDUH 0 SHU HVHPSLR/ GHVWLQDQGR XQ UHOLJLRVR DG XQD QXRYD IRQGD]LRQH 0 PHQWUH O·DIILOLD]LRQH HUD HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH XQ SULYLOHJLR/ FKH VL SRWHYD GLIHQGHUH DQFKH FRQWUR OD YRORQ0 Wj GHL VXSHULRUL1 ,O SUREOHPD DYHYD OD VXD LPSRUWDQ]D SUDWLFD/ DQFKH SHUFKp O·DIILOLD]LRQH HUD LO SUHVXSSRVWR SHU SRWHU GLYHQWDUH VXSHULRUH GL XQD FDVD UH0 OLJLRVD 67 1 1HO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ ILQR DO 4:<9 O·DIILOLD]LRQH HUD SUDWLFDWD GDL ²²²²²²²² 65
,O 5; VHWW1 4:;; OH DXWRULWj HVWHQVL HVDPLQDURQR OD ULFKLHVWD GHO S1 $QJHOR 7XUFL 216101 GL )LUHQ]H/ PDHVWUR GL UHWRULFD D 5HJJLR/ FKH ©LPSORUD>YD@ FRQ VXD VXSSOLFD GL HVVHUH QDWXUD0 OL]]DWR/ H IDWWR ILJOLR QHO FRQYHQWR GHO VXR RUGLQH LQ TXHOOD FLWWjª1 /D *LXULVGL]LRQH QRQ DYHYD QXOOD LQ FRQWUDULR/ WDQWR SL• FKH QHO FRQYHQWR GL 5HJJLR HUDQR YDFDQWL ©WUH ILJOLXRODQ]Hª1 $Q0 ]L/ ULWHQHYD FKH DFFRQWHQWDUOR SRWHYD VHUYLUH D LPSHJQDUOR VHPSUH SL• QHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR/ QHO TXDOH DYHYD ©ULVFRVVR VLQ·RUD O·DSSODXVR H VRGGLVID]LRQH GL TXHO SXEEOLFRª1 'L ODWR VL OHJJH= ©6L SHUPHWWDª1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO]D 8 + '/ 4:;<,/ Q1 578/ &/ 61 66 6XOOD VWDELOLWj/ FIU 'L]LRQDULR GHJOL ,VWLWXWL GL SHUIH]LRQH/ ,;/ 5RPD 4<<:/ 438044:1 67 'LFWLRQQDLUH GH 'URLW &DQRQLTXH/ ,,/ 5961 $OORUFKp QHO 4:;6 L &RQYHQWXDOL GL 0RGHQD YHQ0 QHUR VRSSUHVVL H GLVWULEXLWL QHL VXSHUVWLWL FRQYHQWL GHO 'XFDWR/ FKLHVHUR DO JRYHUQR GL JDUDQ0 WLUJOL ©FKH RYXQTXH VLDQR SHU HVVHUH ULFHYXWL/ SHU GLFKLDUD]LRQH VRYUDQD/ VLDQR DIILJOLDWL D TXHO FRQYHQWR FKH ORUR VDUj GHVWLQDWR/ JRGHQGR LQ TXHOOR GHO GLULWWR G*DQ]LDQLWj FKH ORUR DFFRUGD OD ULVSHWWLYD DIILJOLD]LRQHª1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ ILO]D 8: +59 JLXJQR 4:;6,1 /D ORUR HUD XQD SUHRFFXSD]LRQH JLXVWLILFDWD1 6DSSLDPR/ DG HVHPSLR/ FKH LO 54 DSULOH 4::6 OD *LXULVGL]LRQH +)1$1 %LDQFKL/ 71 &KLRGLQL H *1%1 $UDOGL, DYHYD HVDPLQDWR LO ULFRUVR GL XQ &RQYHQWXDOH FRQWUR OD GHFLVLRQH GHL FRQIUDWHOOL/ ©ILJOL GHO &RQYHQWR DG TXHPª/ FKH ULILX0 WDYDQR GL DFFRJOLHUOR/ GDWR FKH ©VHFRQGR OH &RVWLWX]LRQL GHOOD 5HOLJLRQH QRQ SXz DYHU OXRJR OD WUDVILJOLD]LRQH >111@ LQ TXHVWR &RQYHQWR/ SHU O*HVFOXVLRQH FKH QH j DYXWD OD GL OXL GRPDQGD FRQ GXH WHU]L GL YRWL FRQWUDULª1 /D *LXULVGL]LRQH VXJJHUu DO GXFD ©GL WRJOLHUH GL PH]]R FRQ XQ DVVROXWR FRPDQGR OH FDQRQLFKH GLIILFROWj FKH VL IUDSSRQJRQR/ ROWUH D JOL DOWUL ULOLHYL GHWDJOLDWL GD* 3DGUL FRQWUDGLFHQWL/ FRQIRUPHPHQWH DOOH PDVVLPH VLQ RUD SURYYLGDPHQWH DGRWWDWH GD 9RVWUD $OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD LQ RUGLQH DOO*LQWHUQD GLVFLSOLQD H JRYHUQR GH* FRUSL UHJRODULª1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D %/ 61 /*; GLFHPEUH 4:;9/ LO SDGUH FDUPHOLWDQR )UDQFHVFR $QWRQLR 0DMRFFKL RWWHQQH GDOOD 6DQWD 6HGH OD GLVSHQVD GHL YRWL1 1HOOD ULFKLHVWD/ GLFKLDUDYD GL ©ULWURYDUVL QHOOD FULWLFD FLUFRVWDQ]D G*HVVHUJOL PDQFDWR LO &RQYHQWR GL 0RGHQD/ GL FXL HUD IL0 JOLR/ HG DWWXDOPHQWH HVVHUH LPSLHJDWR DO VHUYLJLR GHO 6HUHQLVVLPR 'XFD/ LQ TXDOLWj GL &DSSHO0 ODQR DOOH *XDUGLH GHO &RUSRª1 2WWHQXWR O*H[HTXDWXU GXFDOH LO 6 JLXJQR 4:<6/ 0DMRFFKL YHQQH LQFDUGLQDWR QHOOD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD LO 4: JLXJQR1 $&$02/ 5HJLVWUL GL &DQFHOOHULD= 4:<604:<7/
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:86
UHOLJLRVL FKH ©YHVWLYDQR DELWR VRWWLOHª +$JRVWLQLDQL/ %HQHGHWWLQL/ &RQYHQWXDOL H 'RPHQLFDQL,/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GHL PHPEUL GL TXHJOL 2UGLQL PHQGLFDQWL FKH ©YHVWLYDQR GL ODQD JURVVDª +&DSSXFFLQL/ )UDQFHVFDQL/ HFF1, 681 *OL HUHPLWL 5LWHQLDPR RSSRUWXQR VHJQDODUH OD SUHVHQ]D QHO 'XFDWR GL DOFXQL HUHPLWL/ DQFKH VH VL WUDWWDYD GL XQ IHQRPHQR SUHVVRFKp LUULOHYDQWH1 3RFKL GRYHWWHUR HVVHUH LQIDWWL JOL LPLWDWRUL GL 3LHWUR *D]]HWWL/ QDWR QHO 494: D 3RJJLR GL 0RQ0 FHUUDWR +GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD, H PRUWR QHO 49:4 D 1RWR/ GRYH DYHYD FRQGRWWR YLWD HUHPLWLFD 691 /D VFDUVD VLPSDWLD GHOOD JHUDUFKLD HFFOHVLDVWLFD QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL HUHPLWL q WHVWLPRQLDWD GDOOH SUHVFUL]LRQL FKH L VLQRGL GLRFHVDQL 0 SDUWLFRODUPHQWH JOL XOWLPL FHOHEUDWL QHOOH GLRFHVL HVWHQVL GXUDQWH O·$QWLFR 5HJLPH 0 DYHYDQR H0 PDQDWR SHU UHJRODUQH OD YLWD1 3HU HVHPSLR/ TXHOOR GL 5HJJLR GHO 49<: +53055 PDJJLR,/ FKH QHOOD &RQVWLWXWLR ;/,, +'H (UHPLWLV,/ VWDELOLYD= ©1H VDHFXOL YLWLD/ HWLDP 5HOLJLRQLV KDELWX OLEHULXV H[FXUUDQW/ PRQDFKL/ DXW HUHPLWDH/ YH VLYH H[WHUL/ VLYH GLRHFHVDQL/ SHU FLYLWDWHP/ DXW GLRHFHVLP YDJDUL QRQ DXGHDQW/ RPQL VXEMHFWLR0 QLV MXJR VROXWL> VHFXV/ RSSRUWXQLV MXULV UHPHGLLV/ YHO LQ FRPPXQLEXV PRQDVWHULLV SURILWHUL FR0 JHQWXU/ YHO DG VROLWXGLQHP FRPSHOOHQWXU/ XW UH LSVD H[HUFHDQW/ TXRG QRPLQH/ HW KDELWX SUDH0 VHIHUXQWª 6:1
²²²²²²²² I1 5<<1 68 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH 111FLW1/ 4<91 69 )101 48$7752)5$7,/ 9LWD GHO 9HQHUDELOH 6HUYR GL 'LR )1 3LHWUR *D]]HWWL HUHPLWD PRGRQHVH/ 0RGHQD 49<41 7DOH RSHUD VL LQVHULYD QHO FRQWHVWR GL XQD YDORUL]]D]LRQH GHL ©VDQWL LQGLJHQLª/ SURPRVVD GDJOL (VWHQVL LQ TXHO SHULRGR1 &IU *1 25/$1',/ /LWXUJLD/ DJLRJUDILD H SROLWLFD QHO 'X0 FDWR GL 0RGHQD WUD 6HL H 6HWWHFHQWR/ LQ ©/DWHUDQXPª/ 7: +4<<4,/SS1 7:408461 6: 6\QRGXV GLRHFHVDQD 5HJLHQVLV111/ 3DUPDH 49<;/ 49;049</ Q1 41 /H SUHVFUL]LRQL GHOOD &RQVWLWX0 WLR ;/,, HUDQR SUHFHGXWH GDOOD VHJXHQWH LQWURGX]LRQH= ©1RQ RPQL VSLULWXL FUHGHQGXP HVW/ VHG SUREDQGL VSLULWXV/ VL H[ 'HR VLQW/ PRQHQWH $XJXVWLQR/ QRQ LQ VROR FRUSRUHDUXP UHUXP QLWRUH/ DWTXH SRPSD/ VHG HWLDP LQ LSVLV VRUGLEXV OXFWXRVLV HVVH SRVVH MDFWDQWLDP/ HW HR SHULFXORVLRUHP/ TXR VXE QRPLQH VHUYLWXWLV 'HL GHFLSLW1 4XRG PROLUL DOLTXDQGR VROHQW IDOVL TXLGDP DQDFKRUHWDH/ HW HUHPLWDH/ TXL SRHQLWHQWLDH YHODPLQH YLWLD REWHJHQWHV/ QRQ PRUXP/ VHG KDELWXV VHYHULWDWH/ HW LQXVLWDWR VTXDOOR0 UH/ DF VRUGLEXV/ LQWHQWRV LQ VH KRPLQXP RFXORV IDFLXQW/ XW/ GRORVD VDQFWLWDWLV LPDJLQH/ YHQHUDWLRQHP/ DWTXH XWLOLWDWHP DXFXSHQWXU> 2SHUDULL VXEGROL/ XWL YRFDW $SRVWROXV/ WUDVILJXUDQWHV VH LQ $SRVWRORV &KULVWL> HW QRQ HVW PLUXP> LSVH HQLP 6DWKDQDV WUDQVILJXUDW VH LQ DQJHOXP OXFLV1 1RQ HVW HUJR PDJQXP/ VL PLQLVWUL HLXV WUDQVILJXUHQWXU/ YHOXW PLQLVWUL MXVWLWLDH/ TXRUXP ILQLV HULW VHFXQGXP RSHUD LSVRUXPª1 ,ELG1
:87
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
3HU LQWUDSUHQGHUH GHOO·RUGLQDULR=
OD
YLWD
HUHPLWLFD
RFFRUUHYD
O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH
©$QDFKRUHWDUXP/ YHO (UHPLWDUXP QRPHQ/ HW KDELWXP GHIHUUH/ QHPLQL OLFHDW LQ QRVWUD GLRHFHVL/ QLVL LPSHWUDWD SULXV D QRELV/ LQ VFULSWLV/ RSSRUWXQD IDFXOWDWH1 (W/ TXL HDP REWLQXH0 ULQW/ WHQHDQWXU VH TXRWDQQLV/ LQWUD RFWDYDP 3DVFKDWLV/ QRELV/ YHO YLFDULR QRVWUR JHQHUDOL SUDH0 VHQWDUH> HW SDURFKL/ LQ FXMXV SDURFKLD KDELWDQW/ DWWHVWDWLRQHP H[KLEHUH GH HRUXP YLWD/ HW PR0 ULEXV/ DF VDFUDPHQWRUXP IUHTXHQWDWLRQH/ QH IRUWH/ XW DOLTXDQGR HYHQLW/ RYLQD SHOOH OXSL WH0 JDQWXU/ HW VXE VDQFWLWDWLV FRUWLFH LQLTXLWDWLV PHGXOOD IRYHDWXUª 6;1
, SDUURFL HUDQR WHQXWL D FRQWUROODUH VWUHWWDPHQWH JOL HUHPLWL= ©4XLD YHUR IDFLOH VHUSLW PDOXP/ TXRG VXE LPDJLQH ERQL IDOOLW/ DWWHQGDQW SDURFKL ORFRUXP/ LQ TXLEXV GHJXQW HUHPLWDH/ QH FRQYHQWLFXOD/ DXW FRQJUHJDWLXQFXODV/ VXE TXDYLV SLHWDWLV VSH0 FLH/ KDEHDQW> QH QRYD GRJPDWD UXGLRULEXV/ HW LQFDXWLV LQVLQXHQW/ QHF PLUDFXOD HYXOJHQW/ DXW LQGXOJHQWLDV/ DXW LQVXHWDV/ HW H[WUDRUGLQDULDV SURSRQDQW GHYRWLRQHV1 6DHSH HRUXP RUDWRULD/ GRPRV/ HW KDELWDWLRQHV YLVLWHQW/ HRUXPTXH YLYHQGL UDWLRQHP/ DSHUWR RFXOR/ REVHUYHQW> HW VL TXDV DQLPDGYHUWHULQW QRYLWDWHV/ DXW TXLGTXDP VXVSHFWXP/ 1RV LOOLFR FHUWLRUHV UHGGDQW/ XW D IDOVRUXP 3URSKHWDUXP IHUPHQWR JUHJHP QRVWUXP LQWDFWXP SUDHVHUYDUH YDOHDPXVª6<1
*OL HUHPLWL HUDQR DXWRUL]]DWL D TXHVWXDUH/ PD VROR SHU SURFXUDUVL OR VWUHWWR QHFHVVDULR DOOD YLWD= ©(W TXRQLDP DOLTXDQGR SLDH SDXSHUWDWLV WHJPLQH DXUL LPSURED FXSLGR SURWHJLWXU/ DWTXH HYDQJHOLFDH KXPLOLWDWLV QRPLQH YHQDOLV FLUFXPIHUWXU K\SRFULVLV/ RPQLQR HLV LQKLEHPXV HOHH0 PRVLQDV TXDHUHUH/ QLVL VXIILFLHQWHV/ HW QHFHVVDULDV DG TXRWLGLDQDP HRUXP VXVWHQWDWLRQHP/ HW TXLGHP QRQ ODXWDP/ VHG DXVWHUDH HRUXP SURIHVVLRQL UHVSRQGHQWHP/ VXE SRHQD DPLVVLRQLV HOHHPRVLQDUXP FRQJHVWDUXP/ QHF QRQ FDUFHULV/ DXW H[LOLLª 731
,O VLQRGR GL 1RQDQWROD/ FHOHEUDWR O·; VHWWHPEUH 49<;/ HUD PHQR SHUHQWR0 ULR QHO SURLELUH L FRQWDWWL GHJOL HUHPLWL FRQ L ODLFL= ©>111@ LQ VXLV KRVSLWLROLV PXOLHUHV LQJUHGL QXOOR PRGR SHUPLWWDQW VHG WDQWXP YLURV GH GLH +H[FHSWLV WDPHQ IDFLQRULV HW FULPLQRVDH YLWDH, VHFXODULXP FRQYHUVDWLRQHP SURXW VROLWDULRV
²²²²²²²² 6;
,ELG1/ Q1 51 ,ELG1/ Q1 71 73 ,ELG1/ Q1 61
6<
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:88
HUHPLTXH FXOWRUHV GHFHW/ SURSUVXV HIIXJLDQW/ PXOWRTXH PDJLV PXOLHUXP OXGLV/ FRQYLYLLV/ HW SURIDQLV TXLEXVYH VSHFWDFXOLV QXOOR SHQLWXV SDFWR LQWHUVLQWª 741
,O VLQRGR DIILGDYD DL YLFDUL IRUDQHL/ ROWUH FKH DL SDUURFL/ LO FRQWUROOR GHJOL HUHPLWL/ DL TXDOL HUD SURLELWR DOORQWDQDUVL SHU SL• GL WUH JLRUQL1 , VLQRGL FHOHEUDWL GRSR LO 4:58 QRQ SRWHYDQR SUHVFLQGHUH GDOOH VHJXHQWL QRUPH/ VWDELOLWH GDO &RQFLOLR 5RPDQR GL TXHOO·DQQR +WLW1 55= ©'H VWDWX 0RQD0 FKRUXP HW (UHPLWDUXPª,= ©41 $G DQWLTXXP/ TXRTXR PRGR SRVVLW UHSDUDQGXP IORULGXP (UHPLWDUXP VWDWXP/ H[DFWD TXRUXP YLYHQGL UDWLRQH VROLWXGR ROLP H[XOWDEDW HW IORUHEDW TXDVL OLOLXP/ VXDP TXDWHQXV SUR KLV FXUDP DOLTXDP LPSHQGDQW (SLVFRSL/ KRUXP VROOLFLWXGLQHV H[FLWDPXV1 1RVWULV LQWHUHD (UHPLWLV >«@ PDQGDPXV XW 5HJXODV 6\QRGDOHV DGLXQJHQGDV $SSHQGLFL >«@ KDEHDQW HW UHOL0 JLRVH REVHUYHQW >« @1 51 (DVGHP 1RV SURSWHUHD 5HJXODV (SLVFRSLV SUR 'LRHFHVDQLV VXLV (UHPLWLV GXFLPXV SURSRQHQGDV >«@1 61 'H FHWHUR QRQ LQFRQJUXXP/ LPPR SHUXWLOH LXGLFDPXV/ VL (UHPLFRODV RPQHV HW VLQJX0 ORV TXRWDQQLV FHUWD GLH DE (SLVFRSR SUDHILJHQGD H 'LRHFHVL LQ FLYLWDWHP FRQYHQLUH SUDHVFUL0 EDWXU> LEL FRUDP (SLVFRSR LSVR YHO HLXV 9LFDULR *HQHUDOL SHFXOLDUL VFUXWLQLR GH (FFOHVLLV HW (UHPLV/ TXDUXP VHUYLWLR HW FXVWRGLDH GHSXWDWL IXHULQW/ GH HOHPRV\QLV LQVXSHU HW LVWDUXP XVX GHTXH LOORUXP DFWLEXV HW LQ YLD VSLULWXDOL SURIHFWX UDWLRQHP UHGGLWXURVª751
1HJOL DWWL GL GHWWR &RQFLOLR +$SSHQGLFH/ Q1 54= ©5HJXODH REVHUYDQGDH TXRDG (UHPLWDVª, VL OHJJH DQFRUD= ©41 1XOOXV/ FXLXVFXPTXH GHPXP VWDWXV DXW FRQGLWLRQLV VLW/ YDOHDW SURSULR DUELWULR DVVX0 PHUH HW LQGXHUH KDELWXP HUHPLWLFXP DXW LQKDELWDUH (UHPLWRULD FXLXVFXPTXH GLRHFHVLV VLQH OLFHQWLD SURSULL (SLVFRSL HW 2UGLQDULL ORFL> VHG VL TXLV VLPLOHP YRFDWLRQHP VHQWLDW/ VLVWDW VH (SLVFRSR/ TXL/ DWWHQWR VSLULWX HW TXDOLWDWH SHUVRQDH/ FRQFHGHW KDELWXP/ DVVLJQDELW HUHPLWR0 ULXP HW HFFOHVLDP FXL GHEHDW VHUYLUH >« @1 ;1 2PQHV HUHPLWDH VLQJXOLV VDOWHP 'RPLQLFLV HW )HVWLV GH SUDHFHSWR FRQYHQLDQW/ TXLYLV LQ VXD SURSULD HFFOHVLD SDURFKLDOL/ LQ TXDUXP GLVWULFWX HUHPLWRULD IXHULQW/ XW VHPSHU PDJLV SURILFLDQW LQ GRFWULQD FKULVWLDQD1 <1 ,Q SURSULLV HFFOHVLLV SDURFKLDOLEXV VLQJXOLV VDOWHP PHQVLEXV/ SUDHWHU VROHPQLD IHVWD/ ²²²²²²²² 74
6\QRGXV GLRHFHVDQD DXJXVWDH DEEDWLDH 61 6LOYHVWUL GH 1RQDQWXOD111/ %RQRQLDH 49<4/ <71 &LW1 GD ,1 '( *8,%(57/ 'RFXPHQWD HFFOHVLDVWLFD FKULVWLDQDH SHUIHFWLRQLV VWXGLXP VSHFWDQWLD/ 5R0 PDH 4<64/ 67706781 75
:89
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
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
,O VLQRGR PRGHQHVH FHOHEUDWR LO 56 H LO 57 RWWREUH 4:6< GHGLFDYD DJOL HUH0 PLWL XQ SDUDJUDIR +QHO &DS1 9,= 'H UHJXODULEXV, FRQWHQHQWH OH QRUPH ©DG SUDH0 FOXGHQGDP YLDP YHUVXWLLV/ IUDXGLEXVTXH REHUUDQWLXP TXRUXQGDP KRPLQXP/ TXL HPHQWLWDP VXE HUHPLWLFR LQGXPHQWR SRHQLWHQWLDP SUDHVHIHUHQWHV ILGH0 OLXP SLHWDWL LOOXGHUH TXDQGRTXH TXDHUXQWª1 ,O YHVFRYR VL ULVHUYDYD GL HVHUFLWD0 UH XQ GLOLJHQWH ©VFUXWLQLXP GH YLWD/ PRULEXV HW YRFDWLRQH HUHPLWLFXP YLYHQGL JHQXV HOHFWXULª1 $ TXDQWR SDUH/ L FDQGLGDWL HUDQR GL GXH WLSL= TXHOOL FKH GHVL0 GHUDYDQR VHPSOLFHPHQWH ©HUHPLWLFXP KDELWXP JHVWDUH LQ GLRHFHVL QRVWUDª/ H TXHOOL FKH FKLHGHYDQR ©LQ PDQVLXQFXODV/ YHO RUDWRULROD VXE TXDYLV GHYRWLRQLV VSHFLH VH UHFLSHUHª771 $YUHEEH ULFHYXWD O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH YHVFRYLOH VROR FKL DFFHWWDYD ©LQ SUDHVWL0 WXWR VLEL ORFR PDQVLXQFXOD/ DXW RUDWRULROD LQKDELWDQGL/ HFFOHVLDVWLFD SUDHFHSWD DGLPSOHQGL/ SDURFKR VXR REVHFXQGDQGL/ VDFUDPHQWD SRHQLWHQWLDH HW HXFKDUL0 VWLDH IUHTXHQWDQGL/ HOHPRVLQDV H[ DOLHQD FKDULWDWH VSRQWDQHD SHUFLSLHQGL/ HDV YHUR QXQTXDP KLF HW LOOLF GLVFXUUHQGR SHUTXLUHQGL/ HW ERQRUXP RSHUXP LQ RPQLEXV H[HPSOD SXEOLFR LQWHULWX SHUKLEHQGLª1 3HVDQWL OH SHQH SUHYLVWH SHU L WUDVJUHVVRUL= ©$GYHUVXV SVHXGR0DQDFRUHWDV FDUFHUH/ YHO H[LOLR/ DOLLVTXH/ MX[WD WUDQVJUHVVLRQXP TXDOLWDWHV FDVWLJDWLRQLEXV LQVXUJHPXVª 781 ,Q SUDWLFD/ QRQ VHPEUD FKH Qp L YHVFRYL1 Qp L ORUR GHOHJDWL +YLFDUL IRUDQHL H SDUURFL, VL SUHRF0 FXSDVVHUR SL• GL WDQWR GHO FRQWUROOR GHJOL HUHPLWL1 /R SURYD LO IDWWR FKH/ QR0 QRVWDQWH OH ULFHUFKH IDWWH 0 SHU HVHPSLR/ QHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR 'LRFHVDQR GL 0RGHQD 0 QRQ VRQR VWDWL ILQRUD WURYDWL L UHJLVWUL GHOOH DXWRUL]]D]LRQL DG LQ0 ²²²²²²²² 76
,ELG1/ 6781 'HJOL HUHPLWL WUDWWDQR DQFKH JOL DWWL GHO FRQFLOLR SURYLQFLDOH GL )HUPR GHO 4:59 +WLW1 45= ©'H VWDWX 0RQDFKRUXP HW (UHPLWDUXP DF 0RQLDOLXPª,1 ,ELG1/ 67806791 77 6\QRGXV GLRHFHVDQD PXWLQHQVLV/ +4:6<,/ 47;1 *OL DWWL GL TXHVWR VLQRGR QRQ YHQQHUR PDL GDWL DOOH VWDPSH1 $EELDPR XWLOL]]DWR OD FRSLD PDQRVFULWWD ² UHDOL]]DWD GD *LRYDQQL )ODPLQLR 9H0 UDWWL QHO 4:;4 ² FRQVHUYDWD QHOO·$UFKLYLR &DSLWRODUH GL 0RGHQD +6LQRGL/ 436283,1 78 ,ELGHP1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:8:
GRVVDUH O·DELWR HUHPLWLFR 79 1 ,O FKH QRQ GHYH QHFHVVDULDPHQWH LQGXUUH DG H0 VFOXGH FKH OD SUHVHQ]D GL HUHPLWL QHO 'XFDWR IRVVH SUREDELOPHQWH PDJJLRUH GL TXHOOR FKH OD VFDUVLWj GHOOH IRQWL IDUHEEH VXSSRUUH1 7UDWWDQGRVL GL XQD IRUPD GL YLWD VFDUVDPHQWH LVWLWX]LRQDOL]]DWD 0 LO YLFDULR IRUDQHR GHO 61 2IILFLR GL 5XEELDQR/ SHU HVHPSLR/ QHO 4:88 QRQ VDSHYD SUHFLVDUH PHJOLR OR VWDWXV GL FHUWR %DUWRORPHR $QWLFKL/ VH QRQ GLFHQGROR ©H[HUFHQV DUWHP HUHPLWLFDPª 7: 0 O·HUHPLWLVPR LQGLYLGXDOH SDVVDYD LQRVVHUYDWR/ ILQR D TXDQGR LO FRPSRUWD0 PHQWR GL TXDOFKH VXR PHPEUR DWWLUDYD O·DWWHQ]LRQH GHOOH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLDVWL0 FKH/ H VSHFLDOPHQWH GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH 7;1 (UD LO FDVR GL TXHO *LXVHSSH *LDQ0 QHFFKLQL 0 FKH DOOD TXDOLILFD GL HUHPLWD XQLYD TXHOOH GL SURIHWD/ FKLUXUJR H GL FDYDGHQWL 0 DUUHVWDWR LO 58 VHWWHPEUH 4:7;/ SHUFKp LPSOLFDWR QHO SURFHVVR FRQWUR FHUWL ©WHVRUL]DQWL/ SUHWHVL VRUWLOHJKLª7<1 2 GL TXHOO·$QWRQLR 3XVFLQL 0 GHILQLWR QHO 4:8< GDO UHWWRUH GHOOD SDUURFFKLD QRQDQWRODQD GL 6HUUD]]RQH ©IDO0 ²²²²²²²² 79
3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD/ VL VD GL HUHPLWL FKH/ DG HVHPSLR/ FXVWRGLYD0 QR RUDWRUL D 6HUSLDQR H D 9LWULROD1 &IU *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH FLW1/ 54505461 7: &I LO YHUEDOH GHOO*HVFXVVLRQH GHOO*HUHPLWD TXDUDQWXQHQQH %DUWRORPHR $QWLFKL/ DG RSHUD GL G1 )UDQFHVFR 9HURQLFR 5XJJL/ 9LWULROD 63 OXJOLR 4:881 $602/ ,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ILO]D 5<< 0LVFHO0 ODQHD/ 4:3304:;9,1 /*$QWLFKL GRYHYD DYHUH TXDOFKH IRUPD]LRQH FXOWXUDOH/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH SUHVVR GL OXL +FKH FXVWRGLYD O*©RUDWRULR GHOOD 0DGRQQD GL &D* GH* =HUELQLª, VL GDYDQR WDORUD FRQYHJQR DOFXQL VDFHUGRWL1 (JOL HUD VWDWR LQWHUURJDWR QHOO*DPELWR GL XQ SURFHGLPHQWR FRQWUR *LXVHSSH 0DHVWUL/ GHQXQFLDWR O*; PDU]R 4:88 GD G1 /XGRYLFR 0DJQRQL1 ,ELG1/ ILO1 565 +3UR0 FHVVL/ 4:8604:88,1 7; 1RQ VHPSUH O*DXWRULWj LQTXLVLWRULDOH SHUVHJXLYD JOL HUHPLWL GHQXQFLDWL1 'D XQD OHWWHUD GHO 58 IHEEUDLR 4:87 GL G1 $JRVWLQR %LDQFKL/ YLFDULR IRUDQHR GHO 61 2IILFLR GL )UDVVLRQRUR/ VL DSSUHQGH FKH HJOL HUD VWDWR LQFDULFDWR GDOO*LQTXLVLWRUH GL UHFDUVL FRQ L SDWHQWDWL D &DVWHOQXRYR *DUIDJQDQD D ULOHYDUH XQ HUHPLWD LYL GHWHQXWR1 $OOD SUHVHQWD]LRQH GHOOD OLVWD GHOOH VSHVH GL YLDJJLR/ O*LQTXLVLWRUH JOL DYUHEEH GHWWR= ©0L JXDUGHUz LQ DYYHQLUH GL IDU FDUFHUDWL LQ FRWHVWH SDUWL/ SHUFKp FRVWDQR WURSSRª1 $602/ ,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ILO]D 598/ %/HWWHUH GL 9LFDUL%/ 49<;04:9;1 7< $602/ ,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ILO]D 559 %3URFHVVL%/ 4:7:,1 6L LJQRUD VH ULJXDUGDVVH LO *LDQQHFFKL0 QL OD GHQXQFLD GL )UDQFHVFR 5RVVL/ RVWH GL &DVWHOQXRYR *DUIDJQDQD/ FKH LO 43 PDJJLR 4:7: LQIRUPDYD O*,QTXLVL]LRQH FKH QHO PHVH SUHFHGHQWH HUD VWDWR VXR FOLHQWH 0 LQVLHPH D FHUWR 5DI0 IDHOH/ XQ UHJJLDQR PHUFDQWH GL FDSSHOOL/ FRO TXDOH HUD JLXQWR GD /LYRUQR 0 ©LO 5RPLWR GL 3UR0 IHWDª/ FKH GHVFULYHYD FRVu= ©>q@ XRPR SL• WRVWR JLRYDQH/ H YD YHVWLWR FRQ O*DELWR GD 5HIRUPDWR FRQ LO VXR FDSSXFFLRª1 6L GLFHYD FKH DYHVVH FDYDWR XQ WHVRUR 0 FRQVLVWHQWH LQ ©XQD FDPSDQD ULSLHQD GL PRQHWH G*RUR H G*DUJHQWR FRQ O*LPSURQWD HG HIILJLH GHOOD &RQWHVVD 0DWLOGHª 0 SUHV0 VR ©XQD FHUWD 0DGRQQD YHUVR OD /RPEDUGLDª/ LQVLHPH D GXH VDFHUGRWL GL /XQLJLDQD H GXH ODL0 FL1 /*HUHPLWD DYHYD GHWWR FKH ©DOOD JXDUGLD GL GHWWR WHVRUR >YL HUD@ XQ RPHWWR JREERª FKH QRQ YROHYD FHGHUOR/ ©VH QRQ JOL GDYDQR XQ*DQLPD EDWWH]]DWD/ GDO FKH DUJRPHQWDURQR HVVHUH LO GLD0 YRORª1 0D SRL LO JXDUGLDQR VL HUD DFFRQWHQWDWR GL XQ JDOOR EDWWH]]DWR1 $602/ ,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ILO]D 553/ %3URFHVVL%/ 4:7704:791
:8;
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
VR HUHPLWDª 0 LO TXDOH/ EHQFKp SULYDWR GHOOD ©SDWHQWH GL HUHPLWDª JLj GD 4; DQ0 QL/ DYHYD ©VHJXLWDWR OD YLWD H O·DELWR GD HUHPLWDª1 7UD JOL DGGHELWL PRVVLJOL YL HUD TXHOOR GL ©IDUH FHUWH EHQHGL]LRQL Vu D· FULVWLDQL/ FRPH D· EHVWLDPL LQIHUPL/ H ID TXHVWR QRQ VHQ]D SXEEOLFR VRVSHWWR GL VXSHUVWL]LRQL/ SHU OH TXDOL GXH YROWH >IX@ EDVWRQDWRª1 ,O UHWWRUH DJJLXQJHYD= ©6L GLFH DQFKH FRPPXQHPHQWH FKH H0 JOL VLD VWDWR SURPRWRUH D FDYDUH WHVRUL SL• YROWH1 >111@ 6R SDULPHQWH DYHU HJOL SURPHVVR GH· VHJUHWL DG XQD JLRYDQH SHU SURFXUDUH DERUWLR/ H DQFKH DSSUHVVR DO SXEEOLFR q PROWR VFDQGDORVR HG KD LO QRPH GL VXSHUVWL]LRVR H GL SRFR EXRQ FULVWLDQRª1 $ GLUH LO YHUR/ TXDOFKH IUDVH GHO UHWWRUH DXWRUL]]D LO VRVSHWWR FKH LO VXR JLXGL]LR VXO FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHOO·HUHPLWD QRQ IRVVH GHO WXWWR VHUH0 QR H GLVLQWHUHVVDWR= ©,Q WDQWL DQQL QRQ KD PDL UHFDWR QHVVXQ VHUYLJLR SHUVRQDOH/ Qp DOFXQD XWLOLWj FRQ TXHVWXH D TXHVWD FKLHVD >111@/ QRQ KD PDL YROXWR FKH LR JOL IDFFLD L FRQWL GHOOH TXHVWXH/ FRPH VDUHL REEOLJDWRª 831 6SHVVR OD GLIILGHQ]D GHOOH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLDVWLFKH 0 PD DQFKH GL TXHOOH FLYLOL 0 HUD PRWLYDWD GDO WLPRUH GHOO·LQIOXVVR LQFRQWUROODWR FKH JOL HUHPLWL HUDQR LQ JUDGR GL HVHUFLWDUH VXOOH SRSROD]LRQL UXUDOL 841 0LQRUL SUHYHQ]LRQL QXWULYDQR L YHVFRYL QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL HUHPLWL OHJDWL/ LQ TXDOFKH PRGR/ D XQ ,VWLWXWR UHOLJLRVR1 &RPH TXHOO·©REODWXV 6DQFWL )UDQFL0 VFL &DSSXFFLQRUXPª/ FKH QHO JLXJQR 4:;; FXVWRGLYD O·RUDWRULR GHOOD 0DGRQ0 QD GHOOD %UDVD GL &DVWHO G·$LDQR1 85 ²²²²²²²² 83 7DOL LQIRUPD]LRQL VRQR FRQWHQXWH QHOOD ©QRWL]LDª/ SUHVHQWDWD LO 9 PDJJLR 4:8< GD G1 &DUOR $QWRQLR 7RQLQL/ UHWWRUH GL 6HUUD]]RQH/ GLHWUR ULFKLHVWD GHL VXSHULRUL1 $602/ ,QTXLVL0 ]LRQH/ ILO]D 5<</ %0LVFHOODQHD% 4:3304:;91 84 $ TXDQWR SDUH/ OH SRSROD]LRQL QRQ IDFHYDQR PDQFDUH DJOL HUHPLWL LO QHFHVVDULR VRVWHQ0 WDPHQWR/ SURYYHGHQGR DQFKH DOOD PDQXWHQ]LRQH GHJOL VWDELOL H DOOH VSHVH GL FXOWR1 ,QIDWWL/ SHU TXHVWR SHULRGR QRQ VL FRQRVFRQR FDVL DQDORJKL D TXHOOR GHOO*©HUHPLWD GHOOD %191 GL &HUHVVHª/ FKH LQ GDWD LPSUHFLVDWD +PD YHUVR LO 49;6, FKLHVH D )UDQFHVFR ,, 0 SHU PH]]R GHO FRQIHVVRUH JHVXLWD 0 ROLR H FHUD SHU LO VXR RUDWRULR1 'LFHYD GL QRQ SRWHUYL SURYYHGHUH SHUVRQDOPHQWH/ D FDXVD GHOOD ©VFDUVH]]D GHOOH HOHPRVLQH FKH OH YHQJRQR VRPPLQLVWUDWHª1 $602/ 5HJRODUL/ ILO]D :4/ IDVF1 /1 0DQQL/ 61,1 85 $ELWDYD LQ GXH SLFFROH VWDQ]H/ DQQHVVH DOO*RUDWRULR1 ,O YHVFRYR JOL RUGLQz GL DQQRWDUH LQ XQ UHJLVWUR DSSRVLWR OH RIIHUWH FKH ULFHYHYD/ OH VSHVH/ OH IXQ]LRQL/ HFF1 $&$02/ 9LVLWD SDVWR0 UDOH1111 +4:;:,/ W1 4> *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH«FLW1/ 54505471 6XOO*DUJRPHQWR/ FIU DQFKH *1 )$%%5,/ /*HUHPLWLVPR LUUHJRODUH LQ *DUIDJQDQD QHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL 6WRULD GHOOD &KLHVD LQ ,WDOLDª/ 5< +4<:8,/SS1 4507</ SS1 736076:1 $QFKH LQ DOWUH SDUWL G*,WDOLD OD YLWD HUHPLWLFD LQ0 FRQWUz PROWH ULVHUYH1 61 $OIRQVR/ DG HVHPSLR/ OD ULWHQHYD LQFRQFLOLDELOH FRQ LO PRGHOOR DSR0 VWROLFR GHO VXR ,VWLWXWR1 7DQWR FKH L FDSLWROL JHQHUDOL GHL 5HGHQWRULVWL GHO 4:7: H GHO 4:97 H0 VFOXVHUR WDVVDWLYDPHQWH O*DFFHWWD]LRQH GL FDQGLGDWL ©FKH DYHVVHUR SULPD PHQDWD YLWD HUHPLWLFD R VROLWDULDª +&RGH[ 5HJXODUXP HW &RQVWLWXWLRQXP &166151/ 5RPDH 4;<9/ S1 55;/ Q1 7<<,1 ,Q UHDOWj/
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:8<
/H UHOLJLRVH 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OH GRQQH FRQVDFUDWH D 'LR LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR q QHFHV0 VDULR RSHUDUH XQD GLVWLQ]LRQH WUD TXHOOH FKH YLYHYDQR LQ IDPLJOLD H TXHOOH/ PROWR SL• QXPHURVH/ FKH HUDQR DVFULWWH DG XQ PRQDVWHUR R DG XQ FRQVHUYD0 WRULR 861 /H FDVH UHOLJLRVH IHPPLQLOL QHOOD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD/ QHO 4::5/ HUDQR 53/ GL FXL 46 D 0RGHQD +98 (,1 ,Q TXHOOD GL 5HJJLR/ YHUVR OD PHWj GHO VHFROR/ HUDQR 4: +SL• GHOOD PHWj GHOOH TXDOL GHQWUR OH PXUD FLWWDGLQH, 871 3UHVVR OH UHOLJLRVH QRQ HUD LQ XVR O·DIILOLD]LRQH/ SRLFKp OH QRYL]LH YHQLYDQR LVFULWWH QHO UXROR GHOOD FRPXQLWj LQ FXL DYUHEEHUR WUDVFRUVR LO UHVWR GHOOD YL0 WD881 6HPSUH SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OH UHOLJLRVH/ QHOOD QRUPDWLYD DOORUD LQ YLJRUH 0 DL ILQL GHO GLVFRUVR FKH VWLDPR IDFHQGR 0 YDQQR VRWWROLQHDWL WUH HOHPHQWL= OD FODXVXUD/ L YRWL VROHQQL H OD YLWD FRPXQH1 5HODWLYDPHQWH DL SULPL GXH/ OD PLVXUD SL• GUDVWLFD HUD VWDWD TXHOOD DGRWWDWD GD 3LR 9/ FKH/ HPDQDQGR OD &LUFD SDVWRUDOLV +5< PDJJLR 4899,/ DYHYD FHUFDWR GL HOLPLQDUH WXWWH OH FRPXQLWj IHPPLQLOL VHQ]D FODXVXUD H VHQ]D YRWL VROHQQL1 3L• GLIILFLOH/ H VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH LQVROXWR/ HUD ULPDVWR LO SUREOHPD GHOOD YLWD FRPXQH/ QRQRVWDQWH L ULSHWXWL LQWHUYHQWL GHOOD 6DQWD 6HGH 891 ²²²²²²²² QRQ PDQFDURQR GHURJKH D WDOL QRUPH/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH DOOH VSDOOH GL GXH GHOOH PDJJLRUL SHUVRQDOLWj GHOO·,VWLWXWR UHGHQWRULVWD 0 DFFHWWDWH PHQWUH LO )RQGDWRUH HUD DQFRUD LQ YLWD 0 WUR0 YLDPR GHOOH HVSHULHQ]H GL YLWD HUHPLWLFD1 %UHYH TXHOOD GL V1 *HUDUGR 0DLHOOD +4:5904:88,> PROWR SL• OXQJD H VLJQLILFDWLYD TXHOOD GL V1 &OHPHQWH 0DULD +RIEDXHU +4:8404;53,1 &IU )1 )(55(52/ 61 &OHPHQWH \ HO HUHPLWLVPR URPDQR GHO VLJOR ;9,,, \ ;,;/ LQ ©6SLFLOHJLXP +LVWRULFXP &RQJUHJDWLRQLV 661 5HGHPSWRULVª/ 4: +4<9<,/SS1 5580686> 4; +4<:3,/SS1 45<053</ 66306:3> ,'1/ (UHPLWLVPR LQGLYLGXDOH LQ 2FFLGHQWH/ LQ 'L]LRQDULR GHJOL ,VWLWXWL GL SHUIH]LRQH/ ,,,/ 5RPD 4<:9/ SS1 45790458;1 6XO UXROR GHOO*HUHPLWLVPR LQ V1 3DROR GHOOD &URFH H QHOO*,VWLWXWR SDVVLRQLVWD/ FIU1 )1 *,25*,1,/ /·HSRFD GHO )RQGDWRUH/ 4:5304::8 +6WRULD GHOOD &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHOOD 3DVVLRQH GL *HV• &UL0 VWR/ ,,/ 3HVFDUD 4<;4/ SS1 770791 86 ,O SXQWR GHOOD VLWXD]LRQH VXJOL VWXGL ULJXDUGDQWL OD VWRULD GHOOD YLWD UHOLJLRVD IHPPLQLOH YLHQH RIIHUWR GDOO·LPSRUWDQWH UDVVHJQD GL *1 =$55,0)1 0(',2/,0 31 9,60$5$ &+,$33$/ ©'H PRQLDOLEXVª +VHFROL ;9,0;9,,0;9,,,,/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL 6WRULD H /HWWHUDWXUD 5HOLJLRVDª/ 66 +4<<:,/SS1 9760:481 87 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD 111FLW1/ :51 6XO QXPHUR GHOOH UHOLJLRVH GHO 'XFD0 WR/ FIU QRWH <0431 88 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH111 FLW1/ S1 4<91 89 3HU LQTXDGUDUH O*DUJRPHQWR/ GL SDUWLFRODUH LPSRUWDQ]D q LO VDJJLR GL *1 =$55,/ 0RQD0 VWHUL IHPPLQLOL H FLWWj +VHFROL ;90;9,,,,/ LQ 6WRULD G*,WDOLD/ $QQDOL/ ,;/ 7RULQR 4<;9/ SS1 68<075<1
:93
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
'LYHUVD HUD OD QRUPDWLYD ULJXDUGDQWH L FRQVHUYDWRUL/ OH FDVH GL REODWH/ OH WHU]LDULH/ OH SLQ]RFKHUH/ HFF1 (UD VFRQWDWR FKH OH ORUR DVFULWWH QRQ GRYHVVHUR FRQVLGHUDUVL ©YHUHª UHOLJLRVH= LQIDWWL/ SRWHYDQR HPHWWHUH YRWL VROR WHPSRUDQHL/ FRQVHUYDQGR ©OD SURSULHWj GHL ORUR EHQL QHO TXDGUR LVWLWX]LRQDOH PRQDVWLFR GHOO·DXWRQRPLD GHOOH VLQJROH FDVHª 8:1 6FDUVLVVLPR HUD LO QXPHUR GHL YHUL FRQVHUYDWRUL1 $ TXDQWR SDUH/ QHOOD GLRFH0 VL GL 0RGHQD VH QH FRQWDYD XQR VROR 0 TXHOOR GHOOH %UDJOLH GL 0RQWHWRUWRUH 0 H VHPEUD FKH OH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLDVWLFKH QRQ QH DYHVVHUR SDUWLFRODUH VWLPD 8;1 3RFR LQIRUPDWL VLDPR VXO IHQRPHQR GHOOH FRVLGGHWWH ©PRQDFKH GL FDVDª8< 0 WDQWR ILRUHQWH LQ DOWUH SDUWL G·,WDOLD/ VSHFLDOPHQWH QHO 0H]]RJLRUQR 93 0 PD FKH/ D TXDQWR SDUH/ HEEH XQD OLPLWDWLVVLPD SUHVHQ]D QHO 'XFDWR1 6L ULIHULYDQR SUREDELOPHQWH DQFKH D ORUR OH VHJXHQWL QRUPH VWDELOLWH GDO VLQRGR PRGHQHVH GHO 4:6<= ©3UDHHXQWH VFLHQWLD/ SHUPLVVXTXH QRVWUR PXOLHULEXV H[WUD FODXVXUDP YLFWXULV UHJXODUHV YHVWHP 2UGLQLV VXL GHIHUHQGDP SRWHUXQW LQGXOJHUH/ GXPPRGR GH HDUXPGHP KRQHVWD QDWD0 OLXP FRQGLWLRQH/ GH ODXGDELOL YLYHQGL PHWKRGR/ GH DHWDWLV PDWXULWDWH HW FRPSHWHQWL DG YLF0 WXP/ YHVWLWXPTXH IDFXOWDWH SUREH QRELV FRQVWLWHULW1 ,Q 7HUWLDULDUXP / XW YRFDQW/ UHFHSWX TXR0 UXPYLV YLURUXP FRQWXEHUQLXP/ VHX GRPLFLOLXP SURUVXV YLWDUH WHQHELWXU/ VL FRQVDQJXLQHRV LQ SULPR JUDGX VLEL FRQMXQFWRV WDQWXPPRGR H[FLSLDV1 7HUWLDULD/ TXDH/ GXP YL[HULW/ LQGXPHQ0 WXP 2UGLQLV QRQ GHWXOHULW/ YHO YLUJLQLWDWLV/ DXW YLGXLWDWLV VHUYDQGDH YRWXP QRQ HPLVHULW/ TXXP GHFHVVHULW/ D 5HJXODULEXV VXSXOWXUD LQ HRUXP HFFOHVLLV QRQ HULW WUDGHQGD H[ 61 &RQJUH0 JDWLRQLV GHFUHWRª 941
1HO 'XFDWR/ OH GRQQH FRQVDFUDWH D 'LR H YLYHQWL LQ FRPXQH 0 GLYLVH QHOOH ²²²²²²²² &IU DQFKH 01 0$5&2&&+,/ /H RULJLQL GHO &ROOHJLR GHOOD %HDWD 9HUJLQH GL &UHPRQD/ LVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD 5LIRUPD &DWWROLFD +4943,/ &UHPRQD 4<:71 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OD VLWXD]LRQH QHOO*,WDOLD PHULGLR0 QDOH/ FIU1 2UGLQL UHOLJLRVL H VRFLHWj QHO 0H]]RJLRUQR PRGHUQR/ $WWL GHO VHPLQDULR GL VWXGLR/ /HFFH 5<064 JHQQDLR 4<;9/ D FXUD GL %1 3(//(*5,12 H )1 *$8',262/ 6 YROO1/ *DODWLQD 4<;:1 8: *1 52&&$/ /H QXRYH IRQGD]LRQL 111FLW1/S1 4791 8; *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH 111FLW1/ S1 53<1 8< &IU (1 6$675( 6$1726/ /D FRQGLFLyQ MXUtGLFD GH EHDWDV \ EHDWHULRV1 ,QWURGXFFLyQ \ WH[WRV/ 446<0 4<4:/ LQ ©$QWKRORJLFD $QQXDª/ 76 +4<<9,/ SS1 5;:08;91 93 *1 %2&&$'$02/ /H EL]]RFKH D 1DSROL WUD *933 H *:33/ LQ ©&DPSDQLD 6DFUDª/ 55 +4<<4,/SS1 68406<7> $1 '( 63,5,72/ 0DULD )UDQFHVFD *DOOR/ $OIRQVR GH /LJXRUL H LO ©JUDQ QXPHURª GL EL]]RFKH/ SS1 6<807731 94 6\QRGXV GLRHFHVDQD PXWLQHQVLV 111FLW1/ 47;047<1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:94
FODVVL GL FRULVWH H FRQYHUVH 95 LQ JUDQGH PDJJLRUDQ]D HUDQR PRQDFKH1 7DQWR FKH/ SDUODQGR GL UHOLJLRVH/ FL VL ULIHULYD DQ]LWXWWR D ORUR1 %HQFKp QRQ GRYHVVHUR PDQFDUH FDVL LQ FXL O·LQJUHVVR LQ PRQDVWHUR HUD GH0 WHUPLQDWR GDOOD OLEHUD VFHOWD GHOOH LQWHUHVVDWH 0 VSHFLDOPHQWH SHU TXDQWR UL0 JXDUGD JOL ,VWLWXWL SL• DXVWHUL/ FRPH TXHOOR GHOOH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H 96 0 VL KD O·LPSUHVVLRQH FKH VSHVVR VL WUDWWDVVH GL XQD GHFLVLRQH LPSRVWD GDOOD SUHRFFX0 SD]LRQH GHOOH IDPLJOLH GL GDUH XQD VLVWHPD]LRQH RQRUDWD/ ROWUH FKH SRFR RQH0 URVD/ DOOH ORUR JLRYDQL FRQJLXQWH QRQ GHVWLQDWH DO PDWULPRQLR1 /·DPPRQWDUH GHOOD GRWH QRQ HUD XJXDOH SHU RJQL PRQDVWHUR 971 /D OHJJH GHO 6 RWWREUH 4:;5 ²²²²²²²² 95 /D SHUFHQWXDOH GHOOH FRQYHUVH YDULDYD GD PRQDVWHUR D PRQDVWHUR1 ,Q TXHOOR GHOOH &DU0 PHOLWDQH 6FDO]H GL 0RGHQD/ DG HVHPSLR/ HUDQR WUH VX XQD WUHQWLQD GL PRQDFKH1 $602/ *LX0 ULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ 5HJ1 84/ SS1 660671 0HQWUH LQ TXHOOR GHOOH %HQHGHWWLQH PRGHQHVL +61 (X0 IHPLD, HUDQR 5< VX <3 PRQDFKH1 ,ELGHP1 96 /*DXVWHULWj GHOOD YLWD GHOOH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H GRYHYD FUHDUH TXDOFKH SUREOHPD GL UH0 FOXWDPHQWR1 ,QIDWWL/ QHO 4:;;/ VX 65 PRQDFKH EHQ 53 HUDQR QDWH IXRUL GHL FRQILQL GHO 'XFDWR +: HUDQR YHURQHVL/ 8 ERORJQHVL/ 7 SLDFHQWLQH/ 5 QRYDUHVL/ 4YLFHQWLQD H 4 IUDQFHVH,/ $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ 5HJ1 841/ SS1 650661 6RWWR LO 43 DJRVWR 4:;3/ O*$121,02 +&URQDFD 111FLW1/ I1 58;, DQQRWDYD OD YHVWL]LRQH 0 WUD OH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H GL 0RGHQD 0 GL VU 0DULD *LXVHSSD GHOO*,PPDFRODWD +DO VHFROR FRQWHVVD 11'1 0DULD $OHVVDQGUD *HVFRPHOOL $OEHULQL,/ GL DQQL 7</ FKH SHU PROWR WHPSR HUD VWDWD D GR]]LQD QHO PRQDVWHUR GL 61 &KLDUD/ H DQWHFHGHQWHPHQWH LQ DOWUL PRQDVWHUL IXRUL GL 0RGHQD1 'D JLRYDQH HUD IXJJLWD GL FDVD/ DQGDQGR ©DO VHUYLJLR GHO 5H GL 3UXVVLD/ YHVWLWD GD XRPR/ SHU WUH DQQL/ IDFHQGR LO VROGDWR1 )X VFRSHUWD GDO PDUHVFLDOOR/ PHGLDQWH XQD OHWWHUD SHUYHQXWDJOL GDOOD FDVD VXD/ FKH DQGDYD LQ WUDFFLD GL OHL SHU ULWURYDUOD> TXHVWL > LO UH GL 3UXVVLD@ OL UHJDOz XQ EDVWRQH FRQ LO SRPR SLHQR GL GLDPDQWL/ GHO YDORUH GL 733 ]HFFKLQL/ FKH WXWWDYLD FRQVHUYD HVVD DSSUHVVR GL Vpª1 /D *HVFRPHOOL $OEHULQL QRQ ULPDVH D OXQJR WUD OH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H1 ,QIDWWL/ HUD JLj XVFLWD GDO ORUR PRQDVWHUR LO 4ƒ OXJOLR 4:;7/ DOORUFKp RWWHQQH GL SDVVDUH WUD OH &ODULVVH GL )LQDOH1 &IU $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ 5HJ1 7;/ %5HJLVWUR GL 0RQDFD]LRQL HG (GXFDQGDWR% 4:::904:;:/ S1 5;<1 1HO 4:;8 D VU 0DULD *LUROD0 PD GHOOD 661 7ULQLWj +DO VHFROR FRQWHVVD 7HUHVD =DQDUGL, YHQQH FRQFHVVR GL ODVFLDUH SHU XQ ELHQQLR LO PRQDVWHUR GHOOH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H GL 0RGHQD/ H GL GLPRUDUH/ VHQ]D DELWR UHOLJLR0 VR/ SUHVVR OD IDPLJOLD GHO GRWWRUH ILVLFR *LXOLR 6DFUDWL GL 0HGROH1 0RWLYR= OD PRQDFD HUD ©UL0 GRWWD DOOR VWDWR GL PHUD SD]]LDª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
:95
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
VWDELOLYD LQ PHULWR XQ FRPSOLFDWR WDULIIDULR1 /D VRPPD YDULDYD VHFRQGR OH WUH FODVVL LQ FXL HUDQR GLYLVL L PRQDVWHUL1 /D SULPD FODVVH HUD FRVWLWXLWD GD TXHOOL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ SHU OD FXL DPPLVVLRQH HUD ULFKLHVWD XQD GRWH GL 933 IL0 OLSSL + OLUH PRGHQHVL <1333,> OD VHFRQGD GDL PRQDVWHUL GHOOH DOWUH FLWWj/ SHU OD FXL DPPLVVLRQH HUD ULFKLHVWD XQD GRWH GL 833 ILOLSSL> H OD WHU]D GDL PRQDVWHUL GL ©WHUUHª H ©FDVWHOOLª GHO 'XFDWR/ SHU OD FXL DPPLVVLRQH HUD ULFKLHVWD XQD GRWH GL 733 ILOLSSL981 /H FRULVWH HUDQR SURYYLVWH DQFKH GL XQ OLYHOOR/ SURSRU]LRQDWR DOOD FRQVLVWHQ]D SDWULPRQLDOH GHOOD IDPLJOLD 991 ,O FKH FL LQGXFH D ULFRUGDUH O·XVR GHO SHFXOLR SHUVRQDOH 9: 0 GHO UHVWR LQ YLJRUH DQFKH SUHVVR DOFXQL ,VWLWXWL PDVFKLOL 0 FKH UHQGHYD TXDVL LPSRVVLELOH OD SUDWLFD GHOOD SHUIHWWD YLWD FRPX0 ²²²²²²²² 98
$602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH (VWHQVH/ *ULGDULR/ *ULGD D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 44/ Q1 4641 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH 111FLW1/ 4<;1 /D OHJJH GHO 47 PDJJLR 4:9: ULFRQRVFHYD DL UHOL0 JLRVL H DOOH UHOLJLRVH LO GLULWWR GL ULVHUYDUVL XQ YLWDOL]LR/ R DQQXD SUHVWD]LRQH/ DO PRPHQWR GHO ORUR LQJUHVVR LQ PRQDVWHUR +DUW1 ,;,1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D 51 $ VU 6HUDILQD 7HUHVD /XLJLD &DYHGRQL/ HQWUDWD FRPH FRULVWD WUD OH 2UVROLQH GL 9LJQROD/ OD IDPLJOLD FRVWLWXu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©PD LO ELVRJQR FKH KDQQR GL YDOHUVL GH* VXRL OLYHOOL QHOOH SDUWL0 FRODUL ORUR LQGLJHQ]H/ DOOH TXDOL OL ULVSHWWLYL ORUR PXQLVWHUL QRQ VRQR WHQXWL GL VXSSOLUH/ LO FR0 VWULQJHª1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ 5HJ1 7</ %0RQDFKH/ 4:;:04:<5%/ S1 41 &DVR DQDORJR HUD TXHOOR GHO ©WHQXHª OLYHOOR GL OLUH :8 DQQXH/ FKH QHO 4:;; OD PRQDFD PLUDQGROHVH )UDQFHVFD 3DSD]]RQL QRQ ULXVFLYD D IDUVL FRUULVSRQGHUH1 ,ELG1/ 7<0831 9: 3HU SHFXOLR V*LQWHQGH XQD ©PRGHVWD GLVSRQLELOLWj GL EHQL PDWHULDOL/ YDOXWDELOL LQ GHQDUR/ FKH L UHOLJLRVL VL SURFXUDQR SHU SURYYHGHUH DOOH ORUR QHFHVVLWj/ DO GL Oj GHOOH QHFHVVLWj OHJDWH DOOD YLWD GL RJQL JLRUQR1 6L WUDWWD GHO SRVVHVVR GL EHQL DFTXLVLWL SUHFDULDPHQWH/ DPPLQLVWUDWL GDL VLQJROL UHOLJLRVL LQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDOO*DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FRPXQH H XWLOL]]DWL SHU SURYYH0 GHUH DOOH ORUR QHFHVVLWjª1 $1 %21,/ 3HFXOLR/ LQ 'L]LRQDULR GHJOL ,VWLWXWL GL SHUIH]LRQH/ 9,/ 46371 1HO PRQDVWHUR EHQHGHWWLQR GL 0RGHQD +61 (XIHPLD,/ QHO TXDOH HUDQR VWDWH WUDVIHULWH DQFKH OH FRQVRUHOOH GL 5HJJLR +61 7RPPDVR,/ YLJHYD SHU OH PRQDFKH ©O*LQJLXVWR REEOLJR GL ODYRUDUH D JXDGDJQR GHO PRQDVWHUR VWHVVR/ LQ WHPSR FKH L OLYHOOL SUHVVR FKH FRPXQL GHOOH SRYHUH UHOL0 JLRVH VRQR GL VROL YHQWL VFXGL GL TXHVWD PRQHWD/ H FKH GDO FRQYHQWR QRQ VRQR SURYHGXWH G*DO0 WUR/ FKH GL VROH GXH FDPLFLH GL FDQDSH EHQ JURVVR1 ,Q WHPSR >111@ FKH LO PRQDVWHUR q DVVDL VXI0 ILFLHQWHPHQWH SURYHGXWR GL UHGGLWL/ H FKH OH DJJLXQWH UHOLJLRVH GL 61 7RPPDVR GL 5HJJLR QRQ VRQR Qp YRJOLRQR FRQ WXWWD UDJLRQH HVVHUH DVWUHWWH D WDOH OHJJH/ GLDPHWUDOPHQWH RSSRVWD DOOR VSLULWR UHOLJLRVRª1 3URPHPRULD DO PLQLVWUR 9DOORWWD +DJRVWR 4:;7,/ LQ $6$02/ )RQGR &RUWHVH/ ILO]D 4481 99
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:96
QH 9;1 ,QIDWWL/ TXHVWD YLJHYD VROR LQ 6 GHL 53 PRQDVWHUL IHPPLQLOL GHOOD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD 9<1 , WHQWDWLYL GL PRQV1 &RUWHVH SHU LQWURGXUOD DQFKH QHJOL DOWUL H0 UDQR DQGDWL D YXRWR1 $OOD ILQH/ IX OD VWHVVD 61 &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHO &RQFLOLR D FRQVLJOLDUJOL GL GHVLVWHUH GDOO·LPSUHVD/ ©SHU QRQ SRUWDU LO GLVRUGLQH GRYH UHJQD OD SDFH H OD FDULWjª :31 6L SXz GXQTXH FRQFOXGHUH FKH0 D SUHVFLQGHUH GDOO·DSSRUWR H GDOO·DUULFFKLPHQWR FKH DOOD &KLHVD/ &RUSR PLVWLFR GL &ULVWR/ SURYHQLYD GDOOD SUHVHQ]D GL DQLPH FRQVDFUDWH H SDUWLFRODUPHQWH YRWDWH DG XQD YLWD GL PRUWL0 ILFD]LRQH H GL SUHJKLHUD 0/ VHPEUD FKH LO FRQWULEXWR GHOOH UHOLJLRVH DOOD YLWD GHOOD GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD IRVVH TXDQWR PDL PRGHVWR1 /H HGXFDQGH )DPD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH SRVLWLYD JRGHYDQR/ WUD OH UHOLJLRVH/ OH 9LVLWDQGLQH +R 6DOHVLDQH, GL 0RGHQD/ VSHFLDOPHQWH SHU LO FRQWULEXWR FKH GDYDQR DOO·HGXFD]LRQH IHPPLQLOH :41 ,O ORUR PRQDVWHUR HUD WUD TXHOOL GHO 'XFDWR FKH ²²²²²²²² 9; $ SURSRVLWR GHO PRQDVWHUR EHQHGHWWLQR GL 61 0LFKHOH GL 3HVFLD/ FKH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR DF0 FRJOLHYD OH ILJOLH GHOOD QRELOWj FLWWDGLQD/ q VWDWR VFULWWR= ©/H EDPELQH VLVWHPDWH LQ FRQYHQWR/ WDOYROWD DQFRU SULPD GHL GLHFL DQQL/ FRO SUHWHVWR GHOO*HGXFD]LRQH/ VSHVVR VRWWR OD SURWH]LRQH GL ]LH H VRUHOOH PDJJLRUL JLj PRQDFKH/ ILQLYDQR FRO UHVWDUYL WXWWD OD YLWD1 /H QRELOL H EHQHVWDQ0 WL DYHYDQR QHO PRQDVWHUR GL 61 0LFKHOH PROWL SULYLOHJL= GLVSRQHYDQR GHO GHQDUR ULFDYDWR GDOOH UHQGLWH GRWDOL/ QRQ GRUPLYDQR QHL GRUPLWRUL FRPXQL/ VHFRQGR O*XVR EHQHGHWWLQR/ PD DYHYD0 QR XQD FHOOD SHUVRQDOH FRQ DUPDGL HG DOWUL PRELOL/ VSHVVR DQFKH XQ RUWLFHOOR/ H WXWWR DOOD ORUR PRUWH ODVFLDYDQR LQ HUHGLWj D TXDOFKH FRQVRUHOOD/ TXDVL VHPSUH ORUR SDUHQWH/ SHUSHWXDQGR DEXVL H SULYLOHJL H LPSHGHQGR OD SHUIHWWD YLWD FRPXQH VHFRQGR O*DQWLFD UHJROD GHOO*2UGLQH1 ,Q PDQFDQ]D GL GLVSRVL]LRQL WHVWDPHQWDULH/ FHOOD/ RUWR HG DOWUL EHQL DQQHVVL/ YHQLYDQR YHQGXWL D TXHOOH PRQDFKH OH FXL IDPLJOLH SRWHYDQR SHUPHWWHUVL O*DFTXLVWR1 /H FRQYHUVH FKH DYHVVHUR SRUWDWR XQD EXRQD GRWH SRWHYDQR HVVHUH GLVSHQVDWH GDL ODYRUL SL• XPLOL1 7XWWH LQGLVWLQWD0 PHQWH/ FRUDOL H FRQYHUVH/ SRWHYDQR GLVSRUUH GHO GHQDUR ULFDYDWR GDO ORUR SHUVRQDOH ODYRUR +ULFDPL/ SDQQL GL ODQD H GL VHWD/ SDQH/ SDVWD H GROFL GL RJQL VSHFLH,ª1 01 67$1*+(//,1, %(51$5',1,/ /H RULJLQL GHO FRQVHUYDWRULR GL 61 0LFKHOH GL 3HVFLD +;9,,, VHF1,/ LQ ©'LPHQVLRQL H SUREOHPL GHOOD ULFHUFD VWRULFDª/ 5 +4<<4,/S1 591 9< $ TXDQWR SDUH/ XQR GL TXHVWL HUD LO PRQDVWHUR GHOOH &DUPHOLWDQH 6FDO]H1 &IU 3URPHPR0 ULD DO PLQLVWUR 9DOORWWD +DJRVWR 4:;7,/ LQ $602/ )RQGR &RUWHVH/ ILO]D 4481 :3 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH«FLW1/ S1 5431 1HO VHWWHPEUH GHO 4:<7 VL WHQWz GL LQWURGXUUH OD YLWD FRPXQH/ L YRWL VROHQQL H OD FODXVXUD DQFKH WUD OH &DSSXFFLQH GL 5HJJLR/ FKH HUDQR LQ FLW0 Wj GDO 496;1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G*$IIDUL/ ILO]D . +4:<7,/ ;:525:/ Q1 54;/ 4 +9 VHWWHPEUH 4:<7,1 'HOOH 2UVROLQH GL 9LJQROD q GHWWR FKH RVVHUYDYDQR OD ©SHUIHFWD FODXVXUDª +$&$02/ 9LVLWD 3DVWRUDOH= 9LJQROD/ 4< OXJOLR 4:;;,/ PD/ D TXDQWR SDUH/ QRQ OD YLWD FRPXQH1 *1 62/,/ 'HO SL• PRGHUQR VWDWR111 FLW1/ SS1 4<8053;1 :4 $ YROWH/ LO PRQDVWHUR GHOOD 9LVLWD]LRQH YHQLYD SUHIHULWR D TXHOOR LQ FXL OH PRQDFDQGH
:97
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
FRQWDYDQR XQ PDJJLRU QXPHUR GL HGXFDQGH :51 $QFKH OH 2UVROLQH PRGHQHVL H OH 7HU]LDULH &DSSXFFLQH GL 5HJJLR VL GHGLFDYDQR D WDOH DWWLYLWj/ VROR LQ SLF0 FROD SDUWH FRQGLYLVD GDOOH DOWUH UHOLJLRVH GHO 'XFDWR1 ,QIDWWL/ DQFKH VH TXDVL WXWWL L PRQDVWHUL DYHYDQR O·HGXFDQGDWR/ QHOOD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL FDVL VL OLPLWD0 YDQR DG DFFRJOLHUH XQ ULVWUHWWLVVLPR QXPHUR GL HGXFDQGH :61 3ROLWLFD GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, ULJXDUGDQWH L UHOLJLRVL 1HO 4::4 LO QXPHUR GHL UHOLJLRVL HUD JLj GLPLQXLWR/ SHU HIIHWWR GL DOFXQL SURYYHGLPHQWL D ORUR FDULFR/ DGRWWDWL GDO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH1 1RQ q TXL LO FDVR GL VWHQGHUQH O·HOHQFR/ GDWR FKH OD SROLWLFD HFFOHVLDVWLFD GHO 'XFDWR LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR q JLj VWDWD DPSLDPHQWH LOOXVWUDWD :7 1 &L OLPLWHUHPR D GLUH FKH L SULPL VLQWRPL GHO QXRYR DWWHJJLDPHQWR GHOOH DXWRULWj VWDWDOL QHL FRQIURQWL GHL UHOL0 JLRVL/ FRPH GHO UHVWR GHO FOHUR LQ JHQHUH/ VL HEEHUR QHJOL DQQL 4:8404:86/ DO0 ORUFKp L ORUR EHQL IXURQR VRWWRSRVWL D PHWj GHOO·LPSRVWD SUHGLDOH JUDYDQWH VX TXHOOL GHL ODLFL1 0D OD YHUD VYROWD SHU OD FRQGL]LRQH GHL UHOLJLRVL VL HEEH QHO 4:8:/ FRQ O·LVWLWX]LRQH GHO 0DJLVWUDWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH :81 ,Q XQ SULPR PR0 ²²²²²²²² HUDQR VWDWH HGXFDWH1 (UD LO FDVR GL (PLOLD 5DQJRQL/ FKH LO < JHQQDLR 4:<9 HQWUz IUD OH 9LVL0 WDQGLQH GL 0RGHQD1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G*$IIDUL/ ILO]D 0 +4:<9,/ ;:725:/ Q1 </ $1 &IU QRWD <31 :5 1HJOL DQQL 4::604::: LO QXPHUR GHOOH HGXFDQGH GHOOH 9LVLWDQGLQH YDULz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j1 /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL GDOOD ILQH GHO ¶:33 DOO·8QLWj QD]LRQDOH/ %RORJQD 4<<8/ SS1 640771 :8 ,Q XQ 3URPHPRULD VXOOD VWRULD H O*DWWLYLWj GL TXHVWR RUJDQLVPR +FKH QRL FLWHUHPR FRVu= 3URPHPRULD VXOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH,/ LQYLDWR DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH GDO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD PRQV1 /1 5HJ0 JLDQLQL +SUREDELOPHQWH LO 46 PDU]R 4;6<,/ VL OHJJH= ©1HOO*DQQR 4:8:/ HVVHQGRVL SHU O*DVVHQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, DFFUHVFLXWH OH RFFXSD]LRQL GHO 0DJLVWUDWR GH* WUH 6HJUHWDUL GL 6WDWR/ FKH GD OXQJR WHPSR HUD LQ YLJRUH QHJOL (VWHQVL 'RPLQL/ 61$161 JLXGLFz GL VJUDYDUOR GDOOD YLJLODQ]D VRSUD FLz FKH ULJXDUGDYD OD VXD JLXULVGL]LRQH/ H LVWLWXu TXLQGL XQ DSSRVLWR 0DJLVWUDWR VRSUD OD *LXULVGL]LRQH/ FKH GDSSULPD IX FRPSRVWR GL WUH ,QGLYLGXL/ XQR FKHULFR/ GXH VHFRODUL/ H GL XQ
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:98
PHQWR LO QXRYR RUJDQLVPR VL OLPLWz DG LQWHUYHQWL VX PDWHULH PDUJLQDOL/ PD YLD YLD OD VXD D]LRQH IX FRQGRWWD FRQ VHPSUH PDJJLRUH WHQDFLD H LQFLVLYLWj :91 8QD QRWLILFD]LRQH GHO 0DJLVWUDWR GHO 4; OXJOLR 4:8; SURYRFz OD UHD]LRQH GHO0 OH DXWRULWj URPDQH/ FKH YL UDYYLVDYDQR O·LQWHQ]LRQH GL LQWURGXUUH ©GLYHUVL UL0 OHYDQWL DEXVL LQ SUHJLXGL]LR GHOOD ,PPXQLWj H GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWL0 FDª1 ,QL]LDYD FRVu XQ SHULRGR GL WHQVLRQH WUD 5RPD H LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FKH/ VDOYR EUHYL VFKLDULWH/ GXUz ILQR DOOD YLJLOLD GHOOD 5LYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH :: 1 &RQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH/ OH DXWRULWj HVWHQVL VL HUDQR LPSHJQDWH LQ RSHUH GL QRWHYROH SRUWDWD VRFLDOH :;1 'RSR DYHU GHVWLQDWR QHO 4:89 OR 6SHGDOH GL 6DQ /D]]DUR/ SUHVVR 5HJJLR/ DL SD]]L GL WXWWR OR 6WDWR :</ H GRSR DYHU HUHWWR QHO 4:8: LO *UDQGH 2VSHGDOH GL 0RGHQD/ DYHYDQR GHFLVR GL FRVWUXLUH QHOOD FDSL0 WDOH XQ *UDQGH $OEHUJR/ GRYH SRWHVVHUR WURYDUH ULFHWWR L WDQWL PHQGLFDQWL GHO 'XFDWR1 3HU UHSHULUH O·DUHD QHFHVVDULD/ VL XWLOL]]z O·$UVHQDOH H O·DWWLJXR FRQ0 YHQWR GHJOL $JRVWLQLDQL;31 $OOR VFRSR GL FRQGXUUH D WHUPLQH O·RSHUD LQ FRUVR ²²²²²²²² 6HJUHWDULR HFFOHVLDVWLFRª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©0HPRULDOH VHJUHWR GHOOD 6RYUDQD *LXULVGL]LRQH GL 61$161%1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D 5/ ´&DUWHJJLRÅ1&IU1 DQFKH &1 )$17$33,(* 6RSSUHVVLRQH H ULSULVWLQR GHL PRQDVWHUL EHQHGHWWLQL LQ 7RVFDQD IUD 6HWWH H 2WWRFHQ0 WR/ LQ ,O PRQDFKHVLPR LWDOLDQR GDOOH ULIRUPH LOOXPLQLVWLFKH DOO*XQLWj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©5LYLVWD 6WRULFD ,WDOLDQDª/ 437 +4<<5,/SS1 <304871 :: *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH 111FLW1/ SS14<904<:1 :; 6XO SDXSHULVPR VHWWHFHQWHVFR QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FIU &1 %$5*(//,/ 3DXSHULVPR/ HFR0 QRPLD H VRFLHWj D 0RGHQD QHL VHFROL ;9,,0;9,,,/ 9HURQD 4<<;/ SS1 <6048:1 :< (1 &$9$==21,/ 3D]]L/ PHQWHFDWWL/ IXULRVL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL WUD HWj GHOOH 5LIRUPH HG HWj QDSROHRQL0 FD/ LQ 5HJJLR H L 7HUULWRUL (VWHQVL GDOO·$QWLFR 5HJLPH DOO·(Wj 1DSROHRQLFD/ D FXUD GL 01 %(5(1*2 H 61 520$*12/,/ ,/ 3DUPD 4<:</ SS1 5<8065;1 ;3 21 520%$/',/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR 0RGHQHVH/ 0RGHQD 4<;5/ SS1 43704381 ,O 59 PDU]R 4:96/ OD 61 &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHL 9HVFRYL H 5HJRODUL VDQDYD L SURYYHGLPHQWL GXFDOL/ GL FXL O*DYHYD LQIRUPDWD LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD1 $ GHWWD GL TXHVW*XOWLPR/ JOL $JRVWLQLDQL SHUGHYD0
:99
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
GL DWWXD]LRQH/ ROWUH FKH SHU DOOHYLDUH OH FRQGL]LRQL LQ FXL YHQQHUR D WURYDUVL JOL VWUDWL LQIHULRUL GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD FDUHVWLD GHO 4:97/ VL SURYYLGH D ULXQLUH LQ XQ·XQLFD 2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL L YDUL RUJDQL0 VPL SUHSRVWL DOOD SXEEOLFD DVVLVWHQ]D +63 PDU]R 4:97, ;41 0D TXDQGR/ GRSR XQ TXLQTXHQQLR +4:9604:9:,/ O·HGLILFLR IX WHUPLQDWR/ ULVXOWz LQVXIILFLHQWH DG DFFRJOLHUH OD JUDQ PDVVD GL SRYHUL GL WXWWR OR 6WDWR/ FRPH LQYHFH LO GXFD D0 YUHEEH SUHWHVR1 ,QDGHJXDWL VL ULYHODURQR DQFKH L PH]]L ILQDQ]LDUL RFFRUUHQWL SHU LO VXR IXQ]LRQDPHQWR1 )X FRVu FKH VL DGRWWDURQR DOWUL SURYYHGLPHQWL GL FDUDWWHUH ILQDQ]LDULR QHL FRQIURQWL GHL UHOLJLRVL/ FRQ O·LQWHQWR GL HTXLSDUDUOL DL ODLFL TXDQWR D WDVVH HG LPSRVWH1 ,QIDWWL/ OD OHJJH VXOOD PDQRPRUWD GHO 47 PDJJLR 4:9:/ FKH ULEDGLYD SUHFH0 GHQWL GLVSRVL]LRQL +HGLWWL GXFDOL GHO 45 VHWWHPEUH 4:96 H GHO 47 PDU]R 4:97,/ WRFFDYD DQFKH L UHOLJLRVL ;5 1 'D DOORUD VL QRWz XQD UHFUXGHVFHQ]D GHOOD SROLWL0 FD GXFDOH QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL/ LQ FRLQFLGHQ]D FRQ O·HOH]LRQH D PLQLVWUR GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH GHOO·DEDWH )HOLFH $QWRQLR %LDQFKL/ SURPRWRUH GHOOH ULIRUPH SL• UDGLFDOL LQ PDWHULD HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 ,O 4ž JLXJQR 4:9:/ LO 0DJLVWUDWR GL *LXULVGL0 ]LRQH IX WUDVIRUPDWR LQ 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD1 'D WULEXQDOH FROOHJLDOH/ GLYHQQH XQ SRWHQWH VWUXPHQWR LQ PDQR GHO %LDQFKL/ FKH QRQ HUD SL• YLQFRODWR QHOOH VXH GHFLVLRQL GDOOD GLVFRUGDQ]D GL SDUHUH GHJOL DOWUL PHP0 EUL1 '·RUD LQ SRL/ TXHVWL VDUHEEHUR VWDWL FRQYRFDWL VROR LQ YLD HFFH]LRQDOH1 ,O ²²²²²²²² QR SURSULHWj SHU OLUH PRGHQHVL ;41;53 +FRQYHQWR/ FRUWLOL/ RUWL/ HFF1,/ PD QH ULFHYHYDQR SHU OLUH PRGHQHVL ;51363> L &DQRQLFL 5HJRODUL /DWHUDQHQVL/ FKH YHQLYDQR SULYDWL GL TXHVWH XOWLPH/ ULFHYHYDQR LQ FDPELR FDSLWDOL SHU OLUH PRGHQHVL 8:1453 +&ROOHJLR GL 61 %HUQDUGLQR/ FRUWLOL/ FKLHVD/ DUUHGL/ HFF1,/ FRQ GDQQR GL OLUH PRGHQHVL 571<43/ FKH LO GXFD V*LPSHJQDYD SHUz D ULP0 ERUVDUJOL1 $&$02/ 0HPRULH YDULH1 'RSR DYHU RWWHQXWR O*DVVROX]LRQH H OD GLVSHQVD GDOO·LUUHJRODULWj FRQWUDWWD ©RE SHUPXWDWLRQHP PRQDVWHULL/ GHELWLV DEVTXH OLFHQWLLVª/ LO 5: DJR0 VWR 4:96 O*DEDWH H L &DQRQLFL 5HJRODUL /DWHUDQHQVL GL 0RGHQD FKLHVHUR DOOD 61 &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHO &RQFLOLR OD UHVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD ©DELOLWDWLR DG RIILFLD HW PXQLD UHOLJLRQLV/ WDP TXRDG SUDHVHQ0 WHV/ TXDP DEVHQWHV &DQRQLFRV D GLFWD &LYLWDWHª1 $5&+,9,2 '(//$ 61 &21*5(*$=,21( '(/ &21&,/,2 +G·RUD LQ SRL= $6&&,/ /LEHU 446 'HFUHWRUXP 6DFUDH &RQJUHJDWLRQLV &RQFLOLL DQQL 4:96/ II1 695*06961 /·DUFKLYLR GHL &DQRQLFL 5HJRODUL /DWHUDQHQVL +R 5RFFKHWWLQL, q FRQVHUYDWR LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR (1&1$1/ ILO]H 7:3/ 978098:1 ;4 &1 %$5*(//,/ 3DXSHULVPR«FLW1/ SS1 45604581 ;5 /D OHJJH VXOOD PDQRPRUWD GHO 47 PDJJLR 4:9: 0 ©LO GL FXL YRFDEROR VL GRYUj LQWHQGHUH QHOOD VXD PDJJLRUH DPSLH]]D HG HVWHQVLRQHª +DUW1 ;,,,, 0 DSSOLFDYD D WXWWL JOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL LO GHFUHWR GHO 4: DSULOH 4:44/ ULJXDUGDQWH OH SHUVRQH FKH HQWUDYDQR LQ PRQDVWHUR/ FKH YHQLYDQR GLFKLDUDWH LQFDSDFL GL VXFFHGHUH/ WDQWR DE LQWHVWDWR FKH H[ WHVWDPHQWR +DUW1 9,,,,1 $602/ *LXUL0 VGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO1 51 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH/ ©OH PDQRPRUWH QRQ SRWHYDQR DFFHGHUH DG HUHGLWj FKH VXSHUDVVHUR LO YDORUH GL 61333 OLUH PRGHQHVLª1 $1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGDQLD«FLW1/ 671
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:9:
%LDQFKL DYHYD TXLQGL PDQR OLEHUD/ VLFXUR LQROWUH GHO SDUWLFRODUH DSSRJJLR GHO VRYUDQR ;6 1 7DOH VLWXD]LRQH GXUz ILQR DO 63 RWWREUH 4::5/ DOORUFKp IX ULSULVWL0 QDWD OD FROOHJLDOLWj GHOOH GHFLVLRQL/ FRQ OD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR LQ *LXQWD GL *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD ;7 1 7UD L FRPSLWL DWWULEXLWLOH ILJXUDYD ©OD FX0 UD GL SURYYHGHUH DOOD SROL]LD HVWHUQD GHOO·XQR H GHOO·DOWUR &OHUR/ TXDORUD L ORUR WULEXQDOL OD WUDVFXUDVVHUR/ R QRQ IRVVHUR EDVWDQWL DOO·DGHPSLPHQWRª ;81 $O PRPHQWR GHOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV•/ LO %LDQFKL QRQ HUD SL• PLQLVWUR GHOOD *LXQWD GL *LXULVGL]LRQH/ HVVHQGR VWDWH DFFHWWDWH OH VXH GLPLVVLRQL LO 5: DSULOH 4::61 ,Q VHWWHPEUH/ IX QRPLQDWR DUFLSUHWH RUGLQDULR GL &DUSL1 ,O 48 DSULOH 4::9 JOL YHQQH FRQIHULWD O·RUGLQD]LRQH YHVFRYLOH/ FRQ LO WL0 WROR GL YHVFRYR GL 3HUJDPR L1S1L1 ;9 /D FRVD SRWUj VRUSUHQGHUH TXDQWL FRQR0 VFRQR OD GLVLQYROWXUD FRQ FXL HJOL DYHYD FRQGRWWR OD SROLWLFD HFFOHVLDVWLFD GHO ²²²²²²²² ;6
©1HO 4:9:/ LQ GDWD GHO 4ƒ JLXJQR/ LO PHGHVLPR 6RYUDQR )UDQFHVFR ,,, IRUPz GHO 0DJL0 VWUDWR VRSUD OD *LXULVGL]LRQH XQ 'LFDVWHUR/ RVVLD 'LSDUWLPHQWR SDUWLFRODUH/ DSSRJJLDQGROR DG XQR GH* 6HJUHWDUL GL 6WDWR> HG LQ WDOH RFFDVLRQH IX WROWD D* 9HVFRYL H ULPHVVD DG HVVR OD GLUH]LRQH GH* 0RQDVWHUL/ 2VSLWDOL/ &RQIUDWHUQLWH/ H GL WXWWH OH DOWUH SLH ,VWLWX]LRQL/ SHU TXHOOR FKH ULJXDUGD O*DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ HFRQRPLD HG LPSLHJR GHOOH UHQGLWHª1 3URPHPRULD VXOOD *LXUL0 VGL]LRQH«FLW1/ I1 781 ;7 ,O 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH DJLYD LQ EDVH DO UHJRODPHQWR GHO 8 JLXJQR 4:8; H VXFFHVVLYH LVWUX]LRQL1 /H VXH FRPSHWHQ]H ULJXDUGDYDQR OXRJKL/ RSHUH HG LVWLWX]LRQL SLH GL TXDOXQTXH QDWXUD/ FRQIUDWHUQLWH/ FRQVHUYDWRUL/ RVSL]L/ DOEHUJKL GHL SRYHUL/ RVSHGDOL/ PRQWL GL SLHWj/ FRQJUHJD]LRQL HFFOHVLDVWLFKH H UHJRODUL/ FRQYHQWL/ PRQDVWHUL H DOWUH FDVH UHOLJLRVH/ UHOD0 WLYDPHQWH DOO*DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ HFRQRPLD HG LPSLHJR GHOOH UHQGLWH/ FROOD]LRQH GHL EHQHILFL GL SDWURQDWR GXFDOH H QRPLQD DL SXOSLWL1 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH«FLW1/ 4<: H Q1 'DO 4:8: DO 4:9:/ VL FKLDPz ©0DJLVWUDWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQDª> GDO 4:9: DO 4::5/ ©'LSDUWLPHQWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQDª> H GDO 4::5 DO 4:<9/ ©*LXQWD +6XSUHPD, GL *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQDª1 $ GHWWD GHO 3URPHPRULD VXOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH FLW1 +I1 7:,/ GDO 4:;5 YHQQH DGRWWDWD OD GHQRPLQD]LRQH GL ©6XSUHPD *LXULVGL]LRQHª/ FRQ O*HVFOXVLRQH GL ©*LXQWDª1 ,O < IHEEUDLR 4:<:/ LO &RPLWDWR GL *RYHUQR PRGLILFz LO UHJRODPHQWR GHL WULEXQDOL GHJOL H[ 6WDWL HVWHQVL GHO < QRYHPEUH 4:<9/ DEROHQGR OD *LXULVGL]LRQH DQFKH SHU OH FDXVH FULPLQDOL1 *OL HFFOHVLDVWLFL YHQLYDQR VRWWRSRVWL DJOL VWHVVL WULEXQDOL FKH JLXGLFDYDQR TXDOVLDVL DOWUR FLWWDGLQR1 $&$02/ 5HOD]LRQL FRQ OD 5HSXEEOLFD H LO 5HJQR G*,WDOLD1 /D SURPXOJD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH (VWHQVH QHO 4::4 DYHYD JLj LQIHUWR XQ DOWUR JUDYH FROSR DL SULYLOHJL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD«FLW1/ S1 631 ;8 3URPHPRULD VXOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH«FLW1/ I1 78*1 ;9 1HO 4::9/ %LDQFKL HEEH DQFKH LO WLWROR/ SXUDPHQWH QRPLQDOH/ GL DXVLOLDUH GHO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD1 0RUu D 6ROLHUD LO < DJRVWR 4::;1 51 5,7=/(5/ 31 6()5,1/ +LHUDUFKLD FDWKROLFD FLW1/ 9,/ 666/ 7841 /*DUFLSUHWH GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH QH DQQRWz FRVu LO GHFHVVR= ©'RSR GL HVVHUH VWDWR WRU0 PHQWDWR GD VFKLIIRVD OHEEUD/ SDVVz >111@ DO 7ULEXQDOH GL 'LR FRQ GXH JUDQGL OLEUL D UHQGHU FRQ0 WR/ SHU XQD SDUWH GL TXHOOR FK*HJOL KD IDWWR/ H SHU O*DOWUD GL TXHOOR FKH KD GLVIDWWRª1 *1 01 58%%,$1,/ /LEUR GL PHPRULH FLW1/ 5781
:9;
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
'XFDWR1 1RQRVWDQWH FKH SRUWDVVH DYDQWL OD VXD EDWWDJOLD JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFD VHQ]D FXUDUVL PLQLPDPHQWH GHOOH SURWHVWH GL 5RPD 0 H DQFRU PHQR GHOOH FUL0 WLFKH GL TXDQWL/ SHU HVHPSLR/ GLVDSSURYDYDQR LO FDPELDPHQWR XQLODWHUDOH GHO0 OH YRORQWj GHL WHVWDWRUL ;: / HFF1 0 VL WHQGH RJJL D JLXGLFDUQH O·RSHUDWR FRQ PL0 QRUH VHYHULWj FKH LQ SDVVDWR ;;1 *OL YLHQH ULFRQRVFLXWR LO PHULWR GL DYHU FHUFD0 WR/ SHU HVHPSLR/ GL ©SURFHGHUH VHQ]D LQXWLOH RVWHQWD]LRQH R FRQ DWWL WURSSR GLFKLDUDWLª/ GDQGR O·LPSUHVVLRQH GL ©ULVSHWWDUH OD JLXULVGL]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFDª ;<1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGDYD LQ SDUWLFRODUH L UHOLJLRVL/ QRQ VHPEUDYD QXWULUH VHQ0 WLPHQWL RVWLOL QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL1 /R SURYD LO IDWWR FKH WUD L VXRL QLSRWL YL HUD0 QR GXH QRYL]L JHVXLWL H XQD 9LVLWDQGLQD <31 (JOL VL HUD SUHILVVR LO FRPSLWR GL FROSLUH L UHOLJLRVL ULWHQXWL LQIHGHOL DOOD ORUR YRFD]LRQH/ SULYDQGROL GL EHQL GD FRQYRJOLDUH YHUVR VFRSL VRFLDOL1 1RQ PHUDYLJOLD TXLQGL FKH/ D YROWH/ DQFKH WUD L UHOLJLRVL WURYDVVH FRQVHQVR/ FROODERUD]LRQH H VROLGDULHWj <41 ,O FKH QRQ LPSHGLVFH DJOL VWRULFL GL GDUH XQD YDOXWD]LRQH QHJDWLYD GL PROWH GHOOH ULIRUPH GD OXL DWWXDWH 0 FRQ LO FRQWULEXWR GL SRFKLVVLPH DOWUH SHUVRQH <5 ²²²²²²²² ;: ,O 57 OXJOLR 4:<; LO YHVFRYR GL &DUSL VFULYHYD D TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD= ©/H 6DFUH &RUSRUD0 ]LRQL TXL VRSSUHVVH HUDQR FDULFKH GL PROWL OHJDWL/ D VROOLHYR GHOOH DQLPH GHL WUDSDVVDWL H D VR0 VWHQWDPHQWR GHL PLQLVWUL GHO FXOWR1 3HU OH GLVSRVL]LRQL VLQ TXL WHQXWH/ q VRVSHVR DOOH XQH LO VXIIUDJLR/ DJOL DOWUL WROWD OD VXVVLVWHQ]Dª1 $6$02/ Qƒ :61 ;; *1 3,6721,/ 8Q PLQLVWUR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,= )HOLFH $QWRQLR %LDQFKL/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ 9,+4<;7, SS1 4880 4:91 ;< 21 520%$/',/ $VSHWWL 111FLW1/ S1 831 <3 *1 3,6721,/ 8Q PLQLVWUR FLW1/ S1 49<1 ,O 48 VHWWHPEUH 4::5/ %LDQFKL LQIRUPDYD LO YHVFR0 YR GL 0RGHQD GHO SURVVLPR LQJUHVVR GHL WUH JLRYDQL QHO QRYL]LDWR1 ( FRQFOXGHYD= ©6DUj SHU0 FLz FRQWHPSRUDQHD O*RIIHUWD FKH OR VFULYHQWH IDUj D 'LR GL WUH QLSRWLª1 $6$02/ ILO1 4481 <4 ,Q $121,02 +&URQDFD 111FLW1/ I1 <8,/ VRWWR LO 63 PDU]R 4:9< VL OHJJH= ©,O 6LJQRU 6HJUHWD0 ULR %LDQFKL KD SUHVR SHU VXR &RQIHVVRUH LO 31 &LULOOR >&DUPHOLWDQR@ 6FDO]R/ >H@ LO 31 3ULRUH >&DUPHOLWDQR@ 6FDO]R SHU VXR 7HRORJR/ H SHU TXHVWR OL PDQGz D FKLDPDUH/ DYHQGR OLFHQ]LDWR LO 6LJQRU '1 )RJOLDQL/ VXR &RQIHVVRUHª1 ,Q SUHSDUD]LRQH GHOO·RUGLQD]LRQH YHVFRYLOH/ LO %LDQFKL DYHYD IDWWR JOL HVHUFL]L VSLULWXDOL SUHVVR L &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L GL 0RGHQD1 ,ELG1/ I1 554 +56 JLX0 JQR 4::9,1 /H RSLQLRQL GL %LDQFKL VXL UDSSRUWL WUD 6WDWR H &KLHVD GRYHYDQR HVVHUH FRQGLYLVH 0 EHQFKp VROR LQ SDUWH H FRQ PRWLYD]LRQL GLYHUVH 0 DQFKH GD DOWUL UHOLJLRVL1 3HU HVHPSLR/ GDO0 O*DEDWH GHL %HQHGHWWLQL GL 0DQWRYD/ RVSLWH GHL FRQIUDWHOOL GL 0RGHQD GDO QRYHPEUH 4::<1 ,0 ELG1 +I1 57:*, VL OHJJH/ VRWWR LO 45 QRYHPEUH 4::</ FKH GHWWR DEDWH/ IUDWHOOR GL XQ DOWR IXQ]LRQD0 ULR GHOOD FRUWH GL 9LHQQD/ DYHYD ULILXWDWR GL YHUVDUH DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH 51333 ]HFFKLQL/ LQ DVVHQ]D GL XQ HVSOLFLWR RUGLQH GDOO*LPSHUDWULFH1 2OWUH DG HVVHUH ULFFR GL IDPLJOLD/ HJOL GLVSRQHYD GL 78 ]HFFKLQL DO PHVH1 0RUu QHO 4:;71 ,ELG1/ I1 6381 <5 21 520%$/',/ $VSHWWL 111FLW1/ :81 /*DQQR VXFFHVVLYR DOOH GLPLVVLRQL GL %LDQFKL/ DQFKH LO FRQVLJOLHUH WHRORJR GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH G1 *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD $UDOGL YHQQH ©OLFHQ]LDWR/ SHU
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:9<
0 QHO 'XFDWR1 1HO FDPSR DVVLVWHQ]LDOH/ SHU HVHPSLR/ HJOL ULWHQQH FRQ WURSSD EDOGDQ]D GL SRWHU VRSSLDQWDUH OD &KLHVD/ LQ XQ VHWWRUH FKH TXHVWD JHVWLYD GD VHFROL1 ©6H LO ULVXOWDWR IX GL WUDVIRUPDUH L SRYHUL GHOOD &KLHVD QHL SRYHUL GHOOR 6WDWR/ YD VXELWR GHWWR FKH TXHVWR VL FDULFz GL XQ FRPSLWR VXSHULRUH DOOH VXH IRU]H> LO SURSRUUH XQD VROX]LRQH UDGLFDOH H WRWDOH GHO SUREOHPD GHOOD PDODWWLD H GHOOD PHQGLFLWj IX QRQ VROR XQ HUURUH HFRQR0 PLFR PD DQFKH HWLFR0SROLWLFR/ FRPSUHQVLELOH QHO PRPHQWR FKH LO SUREOHPD YHQLYD SRVWR/ H GL FXL FL VL UHQGHUj FRQWR SL• WDUGL <6 > PD IX HUURUH H XWRSLD DWWULEXLUH DO SULQFLSH XQD IXQ0 ]LRQH HVFOXVLYD LQ PDWHULD/ VYDOXWDQGR TXDQWR OD &KLHVD DYHYD IDWWR GD VHFROL H SRWHYD DQFRUD IDUH/ GLPHQWLFDQGR LO FRQFRUVR GHL SULYDWL/ LQVRVWLWXLELOH <7 > IX XQ·LOOXVLRQH SDJDWD FDUD SL• FKH GDO %LDQFKL/ FRVWUHWWR D GLPHWWHUVL/ GDO SULQFLSDWR FKH/ GRSR LO ¶:6 H LQ PLVXUD UDGLFDOH GRSR O·;3/ FRQ (UFROH ,,, H FRQ /XGRYLFR 5LFFL/ DXWRUH GHOOD 5LIRUPD GHJOL LVWLWXWL SLL GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ IDUj LO ELODQFLR FULWLFR GHOO·DPEL]LRVR SURJHWWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,ª <81
,O IDOOLPHQWR GHOOD SROLWLFD DVVLVWHQ]LDOH GHO %LDQFKL YHQQH DFFRPSDJQDWR/ H LQ XQ FHUWR VHQVR FDXVDWR/ GDOOR VSHUSHUR GHOOH ULVRUVH DG HVVD GHVWLQDWH/ ²²²²²²²² DYHUH IDWWR LO 3LDQR GHOOH 3DUURFFKLH H GHOOH &RQIUDWHUQLWH >111@/ OHYDWR LO VWLSHQGLR GL 433 ]HF0 FKLQL/ WHQHQGR LO WLWROR GL 7HRORJR H &RQVLJOLHUHª1 $121,02/ &URQDFD111 FLW1/ I1 4<5* +44 H 45 OXJOLR 4::7,1 <6 8QD PHPRULD GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH +V1G1, WUDWWDYD GHOO*RSSRUWXQLWj GL WUDVIHULUH JOL 6FROR0 SL GD 0RGHQD D 0LUDQGROD/ DIILGDQGR ORUR LO FROOHJLR GHJOL H[0JHVXLWL1 7UD JOL DUJRPHQWL DG0 GRWWL/ ILJXUDYD OD FRQVWDWD]LRQH FKH 0LUDQGROD/ ©GRSR YDULH VRSSUHVVLRQL GL UHOLJLRQL/ H>UD@ ULPDVWD HVDXVWD GL WXWWL L VRFFRUVL/ Vu VSLULWXDOL FKH FDULWDWLYLª1 $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D 951 <7 3UREDELOPHQWH/ OD &RPSDJQLD GHOOD &DULWj/ SURPRVVD GD /1$1 0XUDWRUL QHO 4:53/ DYHYD OH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH SHU ©FRVWLWXLUH XQ SL• DWWXDOH PRGHOOR DVVLVWHQ]LDOH FKH LO GXFD DYUHEEH SR0 WXWR IDU VXR/ ODVFLDQGR DOOD FDULWj GHL SULYDWL/ GHL EXRQL FULVWLDQL LO FRPSLWR GL VRVWHQHUH O*DWWL0 YLWj DVVLVWHQ]LDOH GHOOR VWDWR FRQ O*HOHPRVLQD PDWHULDOH R VSLULWXDOH FKH IRVVHUR LQ JUDGR GL SURIRQGHUHª1 '1 *5$1$/ 3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD SXEEOLFD DVVLVWHQ]D D 0RGHQD1 0RGHOOL H VWUXWWXUH WUD *833 H *:33/ 0RGHQD 4<<4/S1:41 &IU )1 &$9$==21, 3('(5=,1,/ /D &RPSDJQLD GHOOD &DULWj GL /1 $1 0XUDWRUL/ LQ 2SXVFROL 5HOLJLRVL/ /HWWHUDUL H 0RUDOL/ 4+4;8:,/SS16;506<8> &1 %$5*(//,/ 3DXSH0 ULVPR111 FLW1/ SS1 44804581 <8 21 520%$/',/ $VSHWWL11 FLW1/ 4361 &IU1 &1 %$5*(//,/ 3DXSHULVPR«FLW1/ SS1 47804841 /D QHFHVVLWj GHOOD FROODERUD]LRQH GHL SULYDWL SHU DOOHYLDUH OD PLVHULD GLODJDQWH YHQQH DYYHUWLWD DQFKH GD *1%1 0XQDULQL/ FKH QHO 4:;7 WUDGXVVH GDO WHGHVFR LO UHJRODPHQWR GHOOD ©&RQIUDWHU0 QLWD GHOO*$PRU GHO SURVVLPRª 0 LVWLWXLWD LQ %RHPLD GDO FRQWH GL %RXTXRL 0 SUHVR D PRGHOOR GD *LXVHSSH ,, SHU OD VXD ©8QLRQH SHU O*$PRU GHO SURVVLPRª1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6HJUHWH0 ULD GL *DELQHWWR/ E1 5:/ %*LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD% 4:;804:<8/ IDVF1 4:<71
::3
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
FRPSUHVH TXHOOH GHULYDQWL GDOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOH FDVH UHOLJLRVH1 ,QIDWWL/ ©O·D]LRQH LQWUDSUHVD QHO 4:97 SHU ULVROYHUH LO SUREOHPD GHOOD PHQGLFLWj HEEH XQ HVLWR DVVDL GLYHUVR GD TXHOOR FKH HUD VWDWR SURFODPDWR <9 1 'RSR LO VDF0 FKHJJLR GHL EHQL GHOOD &KLHVD D YDQWDJJLR GHOO·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYH0 UL/ VL HEEH LO VDFFKHJJLR GHOOD VWHVVD 2SHUD 3LD D YDQWDJJLR GL ILWWDYROL DUULF0 FKLWL/ GL QRELOL LQWUDSUHQGHQWL/ GL FLWWDGLQL VSHFXODWRUL1 )UD L QRPL GHJOL DFTXL0 UHQWL H GHL OLYHOODUL WURYLDPR QRELOL FRPH %RQLIDFLR 5DQJRQL H OD FRQWHVVD 7HUHVD 0DJQDQL/ SURIHVVLRQLVWL FRPH L GRWWRUL )HUUDUHVL H &DYLFFKL/ DOFXQL PHUFDQWL LVUDHOLWL H SHUVLQR XQD VRFLHWj GL VSHFXODWRUL FKH SUHVH D OLYHOOR QHOO·DSULOH 4::4 XQ·HVWHQVLRQH GL WHUUD SDUL D 9;7/8< ELROFKHª <:1 , VXGGHWWL SURYYHGLPHQWL VL LQVHULYDQR LQ XQ FRQWHVWR YROWR D UD]LRQDOL]0 ]DUH O·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFD H OD SUDWLFD UHOLJLRVD1 $ WDOH VFRSR/ SHU H0 VHPSLR/ QHO 4:9; OH SDUURFFKLH GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD IXURQR ULGRWWH GD GL0 FLDVVHWWH D GLHFL <; / H QHO 4::7 D FLQTXH +ROWUH DOOD FDWWHGUDOH/ XQD SHU TXDUWLH0 ²²²²²²²² <9 8Q HVHPSLR GHL WHQWDWLYL RSHUDWL GDOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH GL DYYDOHUVL GHL EHQL/ VSHVVR GL SURYHQLHQ]D HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ FRQIOXLWL LQ RUJDQLVPL GHVWLQDWL D SURPXRYHUH O*LVWUX]LRQH H O*DVVL0 VWHQ]D SXEEOLFKH/ FL YLHQH RIIHUWD GDO VHJXHQWH GRFXPHQWR1 6L WUDWWD GL XQD OHWWHUD/ VFULWWD GD 0LODQR LO 5; RWWREUH 4::8 GD *LRYDQQL 3DROR 6SH]]DQL/ PHGLFR DOOD FRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, G*(VWH/ DO SURI1 /XLJL &HUHWWL/ GHOO*8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD1 ,Q HVVD VL OHJJH= ©0LQLVWUL GL SULPR UDQJR/ DOWUL GL VHFRQGR/ FDYDOLHUL/ HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ VLJQRUL/ HEUHL/ FULVWLDQL/ WXWWL VRQR JLj GD TXDO0 FKH WHPSR FRQFRUVL SHU RWWHQHUH D OLYHOOR EHQL/ H GHO SDWULPRQLR GHOO*8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL 6WXGL/ H >GHOOD &RQIUDWHUQLWD@ GHOOH 6WLJPDWH/ H GHOO·2131*111/ H WXWWL VXSSOLFDQR SHU OD GHURJD GHOOD SXEEOLFD DVWD1 8Q QXPHUR VLPLOH GL ULFRUUHQWL KD JLXVWDPHQWH DOODUPDWR LO 3DGURQ 6HUHQLVVL0 PR/ FKH D JUDQGH VWHQWR PL SHUVXDGR FKH HJOL VLD PDL SL• SHU HVDXGLUH XQ VROR >111@1 6H GL TXL VL YROHVVH GDU PDQR D VLPLOL FRQWUDWWL/ LR FHUWDPHQWH PL DGGRVVHUHL O*LPSHJQR GL IDUWL SUHIHUL0 UH D TXDOXQTXH DOWUR/ QRQ RVWDQWH OH YDOLGH UDFFRPDQGD]LRQL FKH YL VRQR SUHYHQWLYH D IDYRUH GHJOL DOWUL DVSLUDQWL >111@1 6DUz QRQ SHU TXHVWR SL• IRUWXQDWR QHOO*DIIDUH GHOOH WDVVH H QHJOL DUUH0 WUDWL " +R OXRJR GL OXVLQJDUPHQH/ H QH VRQR DQ]L TXDVL VLFXURª1 $602/ 3DUWLFRODUL/ ILO]D 695/ IDVF1 71 &HUHWWL HUD LQWHUHVVDWR DOOR VIUXWWDPHQWR GL EHQL/ SUREDELOPHQWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D HF0 FOHVLDVWLFD/ DQFKH VLWL IXRUL GHO 'XFDWR1 ,O 55 VHWWHPEUH 4:;7/ G1 &DUOR %1 %RUURQL OR LQIRU0 PDYD GD 0LODQR VXOOD FRQVLVWHQ]D GL XQ SRVVHGLPHQWR DJULFROR +©3RVVHVVLRQH &RUWH GL 0DQ0 WRYDª,/ GHOO*HVWHQVLRQH GL ELROFKH 41884 H WDYROH 871 'L TXHVWH/ ELROFKH ;< +H QRQ VROR ELROFKH 49 H WDYROH 6</ ©VHFRQGR OH GHQXQ]LH LQIHGHOL GDWH DO &HQVRª, HUDQR FROWLYDWH D ULVDLD1 6L WUDW0 WDYD GL XQD FRORQLD SDU]LDULD/ FKH UHQGHYD GL SRU]LRQH GRPLQLFDOH OLUH PDQWRYDQH 4;13331 ,ELG1/ ILO1 68</ IDVF1 8;1 <: &1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*DJULFROWXUD PRGHQHVH GDOO*HWj GHOOH ULIRUPH DOOD ILQH GHOOD UHVWDXUD0 ]LRQH/ LQ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<96/ S1 475> 21 520%$/',/ /·HFRQRPLD GHL WHUULWRUL GHL 'XFDWL HVWHQVL/ LQ 5HJJLR H L 7HUULWRUL (VWHQVL111 FLW1/ ,/ S1 891 <; 6X ULFKLHVWD GHO YHVFRYR/ LO 4; GLFHPEUH 4:9; OD 61 &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHO &RQFLOLR DSSUR0 YDYD OD ULGX]LRQH GHOOH SDUURFFKLH GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD1 $6&&/ /LEHU 65 /LWWHUDUXP 6DFUDH
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
::4
UH/ LQ FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GHOOH TXDWWUR SRUWH GHOOD FLWWj, <<1 $QFKH D 5HJJLR VFH0 VHUR GD 54 D 45/ H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH D 44 433 1 ,Q WDOH RFFDVLRQH/ DOOH HQWUDWH GHL EHQHILFL HFFOHVLDVWLFL LQFDPHUDWL IX VRVWLWXLWD XQD FRQJUXD SHU SDUURFL H FDS0 SHOODQL 4341 /·DWWHQ]LRQH GHOOH DXWRULWj SROLWLFKH SHU LO FOHUR LQ FXUD G·DQLPH H OH PL0 VXUH YROWH D UHQGHUQH SL• HIILFDFH O·D]LRQH GHULYDYDQR GDOOD FRQVDSHYROH]]D GHO SURIRQGR LQIOXVVR FKH HVVR HVHUFLWDYD VX WXWWL JOL DVSHWWL GHOOD YLWD/ UHOLJLR0 VD H FLYLOH 4351 'LYHUVR O·DWWHJJLDPHQWR YHUVR L UHOLJLRVL/ GL FXL VL GLIILGDYD= QRQ ©SRWHQGR QXWULUH DIIH]LRQH GL SDWULD H GL OXRJR GHO ORUR GRPLFLOLR/ Qp HV0 VHU IRUQLWL GH· QHFHVVDUL OXPL ORFDOLª/ VL ULWHQHYD FKH HVHUFLWDVVHUR XQD PLQRUH SUHVD VXOOD SRSROD]LRQH/ DOPHQR GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD SROLWLFR 4361 6H )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ VSHFLDOPHQWH LQ XQ SULPR WHPSR/ QRQ VL HUD GHWWR FRQ0 WUDULR D FHUFDUH XQ DFFRUGR FRQ 5RPD/ DQFKH PHGLDQWH OD VRWWRVFUL]LRQH GL XQ FRQFRUGDWR/ LO VXFFHVVRUH QRQ OR VHJXu VX TXHVWD VWUDGD 437 1 ²²²²²²²²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j GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD >4:;:@/ 46804691 /*HGLWWR GL HTXLSDUD]LRQH GHO 59 PDU]R 4:;7 0 FKH VRWWRSRQHYD ODLFL HG HFFOHVLDVWLFL DJOL VWHVVL FRQWUL0 EXWL FRPXQLWDWLYL/ WDVVH H FROOHWWH 0 SURPHWWHYD GL GDUH OD FRQJUXD DQFKH DL SDUURFL GHO UHVWR GHOOR 6WDWR1 $602/ *ULGDULR (VWHQVH/ 44/ Q1 4;91 9ROHQGR/ L SDUURFL SRWHYDQR FHGHUH DOOH FRPXQLWj L EHQL GHO EHQHILFLR SDUURFFKLDOH1 &IU &RQJUXH GH* 3DUURFL +4:<8 FLUFD,/ LQ $602/ *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D 951 435 $ SURSRVLWR GHL SDUURFL/ 5LFFL DIIHUPDYD FKH HVHUFLWDYDQR ©O*XIIL]LR SL• VDFUR H QHFHV0 VDULR QHOOD QRVWUD FRVWLWX]LRQHª/ WDQWR FKH ©IUD WXWWL L FHWL PRUDOPHQWH XWLOL QRQ Y*KD FKL OL SD0 UHJJLª1 /1 5,&&,/ 5LIRUPD111 FLW1/ 46804691 436 3URPHPRULD GL /1 5LFFL SHU JOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL VHFRODUL GD DPPHWWHUH QHOOH SXEEOLFKH UHJJHQ]H +4; DSULOH 4:<9,1 $602/ $UFKLYLR 5LFFL/ YRO1 ;62D/ 5HOD]LRQL/ ,/ I1 4581 437*1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD111 FLW1/ 640661 ,O 47 DSULOH 4:;9/ XQ PLQLVWUR HVWHQVH +SUREDELO0 PHQWH1 *1%1 0XQDULQL, VFULYHYD DO QHR HOHWWR YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD/ PRQV1 &RUWHVH/ ULQJUD0 ]LDQGROR GHO GHVLGHULR GL SDFH PDQLIHVWDWRJOL1 /R DVVLFXUDYD DQFKH FKH OR DYUHEEH FRQYLQWR ©FRJOL DWWL GHOOD IHUPD GLVSRVL]LRQH/ LQ FXL VRQR/ GL UHQGHUH DJHYROPHQWH FRQFLOLDELOH LO 6DFHU0 GR]LR H O*,PSHUR/ D VHFRQGD DSSXQWR GHOOH PDVVLPH VRYUDQH/ DOOH TXDOL WURYR Vu EHQH H FRQ WXWWD FRPSLDFHQ]D XQLIRUPL OH SUHPXUH GL 9RVWUD 6LJQRULD (FFHOOHQWLVVLPD H 5HYHUHQGLVVL0 PDª1 0LQXWD LQ $6021 *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD/ ILO]D 873;24361
::5
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
3ROLWLFD GL (UFROH ,,, ULJXDUGDQWH L UHOLJLRVL &RQ O·DVFHVD DO WURQR GL (UFROH ,,, +4:;3, L UDSSRUWL WUD &KLHVD H 6WDWR QRQ PLJOLRUDURQR1 ,QIDWWL/ VH LO JRYHUQR SUHVLHGXWR GDO PDUFKHVH *DXGHQ]LR 9DO0 ORWWD +4:;304:;8, q FRQVLGHUDWR PRGHUDWR VXO SLDQR HFRQRPLFR/ FLz QRQ VL0 JQLILFD FKH ULQXQFLDVVH DOOD SROLWLFD DQWLFXULDOH 438 1 1RQ PHUDYLJOLD TXLQGL FKH YHQLVVH VRSSUHVVD XQ·DOWUD VHULH GL FDVH UHOLJLRVH 4391 4XHVWL SURYYHGLPHQWL 0 FKH LQ TXDOFKH PLVXUD FRQWULEXLURQR DO SDUHJJLR GHO ELODQFLR SXEEOLFR/ UDJJLXQWR QHJOL DQQL 4:;804:;9 43: 0 ULYHODYDQR XQ QXRYR DWWHJJLDPHQWR/ SL• RVWLOH DOOR VWDWR UHOLJLRVR1 6H DL WHPSL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, VL HUDQR SUHVL GL PLUD VRSUDWWXWWR L ©FRQYHQWLQLª 0 FRO SUHWHVWR FKH LQ HVVL QRQ YLJHYD O·RVVHUYDQ]D UHJRODUH 0 H VH QH HUDQR GHVWLQDWL L EHQL DOOD SXEEOLFD DVVLVWHQ]D/ RUD VHPEUDYD PHVVR LQ GLVFXVVLRQH OR VWHVVR GLULWWR DOO·HVLVWHQ]D GHJOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL +GHILQHQGR ©TXDOVLYRJOLD PRQDVWHUR/ FRQYHQWR R FDVD UHOLJLRVDª LVWLWX]LRQL ©RYH O·XPDQD OLEHUWj UHVWD FRQ YRWL SHU VHPSUH OHJDWD/ DQ]L SUHVVRFKp DQQLHQWDWDª 43;,1 6SHVVR O·RSHUDWR GHOOH DXWRULWj HUD LUUD]LRQDOH1 &ROSLVFH OD IDFLORQHULD FRQ FXL IX FRQGRWWD OD SROLWLFD GXFDOH QHL FRQIURQWL GHL UHOLJLRVL/ DQFKH VRWWR (U0 FROH ,,,1 ,O 56 DJRVWR 4:;;/ LO PLQLVWUR 0XQDULQL IDFHYD QRWDUH DO VRYUDQR FKH O·DSSOLFD]LRQH LQWHJUDOH GHOOH QRUPH VXO UHFOXWDPHQWR GHL UHOLJLRVL/ VWDELOLWH QHO 4:;5/ DYUHEEH FRQGRWWR LQ EUHYH DOO·HVWLQ]LRQH GL WXWWL JOL ,VWLWXWL/ FRP0 SUHVL TXHOOL ULWHQXWL XWLOL/ FRPH OH 9LVLWDQGLQH1 1HO 'XFDWR/ DG LPLWD]LRQH GL TXDQWR VWDYD DYYHQHQGR D 9LHQQD/ QHO ©VXV0 VHJXLUVL GHOOH FRQWLQXH VFKHUPDJOLH/ D YROWH VX RJJHWWL GL DVVROXWD PHVFKLQLWj/ ²²²²²²²²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j/ OH 2SHUH 3LH/ H O*LQWURGX0 ]LRQH/ OD UHYLVLRQH H OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOH VWDPSH1 $&$02/ $IIDUL (FRQRPLFL H 3ROLWLFL/ 1ƒ 45:1 439 /1 38&&,/ /RGRYLFR 5LFFL FLW1/ SS1 <90<:1 $ VHWWH FRQYHQWL GL 5HJJLR/ GXUDQWH LO JRYHUQR GL (UFROH ,,,/ YHQQHUR VRWWUDWWH ELRFKH 914671 &IU1 21 520%$/',/ /·HFRQRPLD GHL WHUULWRUL«FLW1/ S1::1 1HO 4:;5 L PHPEUL GL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL PDVFKLOL QHO 'XFDWR HUDQR ;4;1 43: '1 *5$1$/ 3HU XQD VWRULD FLW1/ S1 4331 43; &IU1 LO FKLURJUDIR GXFDOH GHO 6 RWWREUH 4:;5/ LQ $602/ *ULGDULR (VWHQVH/ YRO1 44/ Q1 4641
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
::6
VL DUULYz SHUILQR D UHJRODUH LO VXRQR GHOOH FDPSDQH SHU OD TXLHWH GHL VXGGLWLª1 3UHVHUR DOORUD LO VRSUDYYHQWR OH FRUUHQWL LOOXPLQLVWLFKH H ILVLRFUDWLFKH/ YROWH D UHQGHUH GHILQLWLYD ©OD GHPDUFD]LRQH IUD ´YHULµ H ´IDOVLµ SRYHUL/ DVFULYHQGR TXHVWL XOWLPL QHOOD VIHUD GHOOD FULPLQDOLWjª 43<1 /D ©UDGLFDOH FULVL GHOO·LGHD GL FDULWjª q ©RUPDL SHUIHWWDPHQWH YLVLELOH QHOOD ULIRUPD GHJOL ,VWLWXWL 3LL GL 0RGHQD +4:;:, H GL 5HJJLR +4:;<,1 3HUVD O·DQWLFD LPPDJLQH GHOO·XPLOH SRYHUHOOR/ RFFDVLRQH GL EHQH H GL SLHWj/ LO PHQGLFR VL WURYD RUD SHUIHWWDPHQWH LPSDUHQWDWR FRQ O·R]LR H FRO YL]LR> ´YHJJLDPR 0 VFULYRQR L ULIRUPDWRUL PRGHQHVL 0 LO SL• GH· SRYHUL EHQ SDVFLXWL HVVHUH H]LDQ0 GLR GLVVROXWL/ WDYHUQLHUL/ JKLRWWRQL/ VRUGLGL/ EHVWHPPLDWRUL/ VHQ]D FRVWXPH/ H VHQ]D UHOLJLRQHµ/ ´PHQWUH QHOOH LPSXUH/ HG LQJRUGH ELVFD]]H 0 FRQIHUPDQR GD 5HJJLR 0 JR]]RYLJOLDQR SDUDVFLWL QRWWXUQL/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWL LPSRVWRUL GLXU0 QLµª 4431 ,O 47 OXJOLR 4:;</ XQD 1RWLILFD]LRQH ULQQRYDYD JOL RUGLQL GHOOH JULGH GHO 4< DSULOH 4:;7 +FRQWUR ©EDQGLWL/ IDFLQRURVL H PDOYLYHQWLª, H GHO 7 PDU]R 4:;8 +FRQWUR ©SHUVRQH PHQGLFDQWL/ R]LRVH H YDJDERQGH IRUHVWLHUH H VFRQRVFLXWHª,/ LQ EDVH DL TXDOL L PHQGLFDQWL IRUHVWLHUL/ FLRq GL DOWUL 6WDWL/ QRQ SRWHYDQR IHU0 PDUVL LQ FLWWj1 4XHOOL VXGGLWL HVWHQVL/ PD GL DOWUH FLWWj R WHUUH/ GRYHYDQR WRU0 QDUVHQH DOOH ORUR SDWULH1 , FRQWDGLQL QRQ SRWHYDQR WUDVIHULUVL LQ FLWWj1 2VWL/ ORFDQGLHUL H EHWWROLHUL QRQ SRWHYDQR DOORJJLDUH PHQGLFDQWL IRUHVWLHUL1 , PHQ0 GLFDQWL GHOOD FLWWj H GHO GLVWUHWWR GRYHYDQR PXQLUVL GL DSSRVLWL OLFHQ]D H FRQ0 WUDVVHJQR +©EROODª/ R ©PDUFKLRª/ R ©VHJQR YLVLELOHª GL FXRLR/ PDUFDWR ©$1$1ª/ FLRq ©$OEHUJR G·$UWLª,/ ULODVFLDWL GDJOL $PPLQLVWUDWRUL GHOO·$OEHUJR G·$UWL/ FKH DYHYDQR LO FRPSLWR GL VHSDUDUH L YHUL GDL IDOVL SRYHUL1 ,O WUDWWDPHQWR ULVHUYDWR D TXHVWL XOWLPL HUD LO VHJXHQWH= ©6L SUHVFULYRQR OH SHQH GL FDUFHUH/ HVLJOLR/ IUX0 VWD/ FRUGD/ R VWDILODWH/ VHFRQGR OD TXDOLWj GHOOH SHUVRQH/ H FLUFRVWDQ]Hª1 $QFKH D TXHOOL DSSURYDWL YHQLYD SURLELWR GL TXHVWXDUH QHOOH FKLHVH R VRWWR L SRUWLFL/ ©Qp JULGDU SHU OH FRQWUDGH VXRQDWD OD SULPD RUD GL QRWWHª4441 /D 1RWLILFD]LRQH GHO 47 JLXJQR 4:;< FRPPLQDYD OH SHQH D FDULFR GHL ©PHQGLFDQWL IRUHVWLHUL/ H YDJDERQGL GL DOWUL 6WDWLª= ©WUH WUDWWL GL FRUGD/ R GHOOD JDOHUD/ R GHOOD FDWHQD SHU OL SXEEOLFL ODYRUL DG DUELWULR GHOO·$161 VH VDUj XRPR/ H VH GRQQD GHOOD SHQD GHOOD IUXVWD R LQ DOWUH DUELWUDULHª4451 1DWXUDOPHQWH/ O·LUURJD]LRQH GHOOH SHQH ²²²²²²²² 43<
'1 *5$1$/ 3HU XQD VWRULD FLW1/ SS1 9<0:31 )1 &$9$==21,/ 3D]]L FLW1/ S1 6451 444 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO]D 8/ Q1 4;7/ %/ 5,1 445 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH (VWHQVH/ *ULGDUL/ *ULGH D VWDPSH LQ YROXPH/ YRO1 77 +4:;<0D:<4,/ Q1 7581 443
::7
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
QRQ GRYHYD WXUEDUH OD TXLHWH SXEEOLFD1 3HUFLz HUD VSHFLILFDWR= ©,O JDVWLJR GHO0 OH QHUEDWH H VWDIILODWH/ FKH VRQR PLQDFFLDWH D TXHOOL/ FKH PHQGLFDVVHUR VHQ]D OLFHQ]D/ VDUj GDWR QHO FRUWLOH SL• LQWHUQR GHOO·$OEHUJR >G·$UWL@/ SHUFKp QRQ VL IDFFLD VFKLDPD]]Rª4461 6WDQGR FRVu OH FRVH/ HUD SUHYHGLELOH FKH PROWL SRYHUL SUHIHULVVHUR GHILODUVL/ DOPHQR SHU LO PRPHQWR1 ,O FKH LQGXFHYD OH DXWRULWj FRPSHWHQWL D ULGLPHQ0 VLRQDUH LO SUREOHPD GHO SDXSHULVPR1 ,O 6 DJRVWR 4:;</ SHU HVHPSLR/ O·$PPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOO·$OEHUJR G·$UWL ULOHYDYD FKH LO QXPHUR GHL ©TXHVWXDQWL DPPHVVL FROOD EROOD DVFHQGH D WUHFHQWR VHVVDQWDGXH WHVWH/ VFDUVR QXPHUR/ H WHQXH VH YHQJD SDUDJRQDWR DOOD SXEEOLFD RSLQLRQH/ H DOOD UHOD]LRQL GH· SDUUR0 FKL/ GDOOH TXDOL VL IDFHDQR DVFHQGHUH DG DOFXQH PLJOLDLD> H QRQ RVWDQWH FKH HV0 VD DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH DEELD XVDWD OLEHUDOLWj/ H IDFLOLWj QHOOH FRQFHVVLRQL/ ULVHU0 YDQGRVL GL ULIRUPDUH LQ DSSUHVVR SL• RSSRUWXQDPHQWH LO FDWDORJRª447 1 &RQVXQWLYR GHOOD SROLWLFD GXFDOH ULJXDUGDQWH L UHOLJLRVL 8Q FRQVXQWLYR GHOOD SROLWLFD GXFDOH QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL GHYH SUHQGHUH LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH O·LQFDPHUDPHQWR GHL ORUR EHQL H O·LPSLHJR FKH QH YHQQH IDWWR1 $OPHQR LQ SDUWH/ TXHOO·LQJHQWH SDWULPRQLR YHQQH GHSUH0 GDWR GDOOD FODVVH GRPLQDQWH= OD QRELOWj H OD ERUJKHVLD HPHUJHQWH1 8Q FDSLWROR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH GRORURVR q FRVWLWXLWR DQFKH GDL GDQQL DO SD0 WULPRQLR DUWLVWLFR H DUFKLWHWWRQLFR 0 DQWLFLSD]LRQH GL TXHOOL FKH DYUHEEHUR FDXVDWR L PRWL ULYROX]LRQDUL GL ILQH VHFROR 448 0 SURFXUDWL GDO PRGR LQ FXL ²²²²²²²² 446 9D SHUz ULFRQRVFLXWR FKH/ D PRGHUDUH OD GLVFUH]LRQDOLWj GL FKL DSSOLFDYD OH SHQH/ LO GR0 FXPHQWR DJJLXQJHYD= ©4XDQGR VL WUDWWHUj GL IDU FDUFHUDUH R SXQLUH LQ DOWUR PRGR L FRQWUD0 YHQWRUL/ JOL $PPLQLVWUDWRUL DYUDQQR VHPSUH ULFRUVR DO &RQVLJOLHU *LXGLFHª1 $602/ &DQFHOOH0 ULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO]D 8/ Q14;7/ %/ 51 447 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO1 8/ Q1 534/ $/ 41 448 1HO 4:<;/ $ 5HJJLR/ SRFR PDQFz ©FKH SDVVDVVH O·LGHD GL GHPROLUH OD FKLHVD GL 61 *LRUJLR H GL VSRJOLDUH LO WHPSLR GHOOD *KLDUD SHU DGRUQDUH L VLJQDFROL GHOOD QXRYD UHOLJLRQH GHOOH WHRILODQWURSLD1 5DFFRQWD LO FURQLVWD FKH LQ XQD DVVHPEOHD SXEEOLFD/ SUHVHQWL ´SUHWL H VL0 JQRULµ/ VYROWDVL ´SHU IDUH PDQR EDVVD GHL SL• ULFFKL RUQDPHQWL GHOOH QRVWUH FKLHVH/ QLXQR DUGu SDUODUH LQ GLIHVD GL HVVH/ FKH VROR O·HEUHR %HQLDPLQR )Rj/ LO TXDOH/ DO]DWRVL/ GLVVH= FRV·q/ 6L0 JQRUL/ TXHVWD LGHD/ YRVWUD YDQGDOLFD " 6H QRQ YROHWH ULVSHWWDUH OD UHOLJLRQH LQ FXL VLHWH QDWL/ ULVSHWWDWH DOPHQR L FDSRODYRUL GHL YRVWUL DQWHQDWLª1 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD« FLW1/ 4;91 &IU1 *1 $*267,/ /*HVSXOVLRQH FLW111/ S1 61 3DUWH GHO PDWHULDOH FRQILVFDWR/ GL GLIILFLOH FROORFD]LRQH VXO PHUFDWR/ WRUQz DG HVVHUH XWLOL]]DWR LQ HGLILFL VDFUL1 1HO 4;3</ DG HVHPSLR/ O·RUJDQR GHOOD FKLHVD GHL &DUPHOLWDQL 6FDO]L GL 0RGHQD YHQQH DFTXLVWDWR GDO SDUURFR GL &RU0
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
::8
YHQQH DWWXDWD OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GL WDQWH FDVH UHOLJLRVH4491 $QFRUD XQD YROWD/ FROSLVFH O·LQFRPSHWHQ]D FRQ FXL IXURQR FRQGRWWH WDOL RSHUD]LRQL1 3HU HVHP0 SLR/ QHO PDU]R GHO 4:;< YHQQH GHFLVR OD GHVWLQD]LRQH GHJOL DUJHQWL FRQILVFDWL/ ©DVFHQGHQWL DO SHVR GL RQFLH Qƒ 518;9ª1 6L GRYHYDQR ©VTXDJOLDUH H ULGXUUH LQ YHUJKH JOL DUJHQWL ORJRUL/ H IDUQH PHUFDWR QHOOH ]HFFKH GL 9HQH]LD/ R GL )LUHQ0 ]Hª> FRPH VL GRYHYDQR ©DOLHQDUH L YDVL VDFUL GL ODYRUR PRGHUQR LQ 3DHVH/ PH0 GLDQWH SULYDWD FRQWUDWWD]LRQH/ JLDFFKp PROWL VRQR TXHOOL FKH QH jQQR ULFKLH0 VWR FRQ RIIHUWD GL SDJDUH SDUWH GHO SUH]]R GHO ODYRURª1 0RWLYR GHOOD GHFLVLR0 QH= ©SDUWH >GHJOL DUJHQWL@ VRQR ORJRUL H GL PRGD DQWLFD/ FRVLFFKp QRQ q D OX0 VLQJDUVL GL SRWHUQH ULWUDUUH ROWUH LO SUH]]R GL SXUR DUJHQWR> DOWUL VRQR FRQILWWL H UDFFRPDQGDWL VRSUD WDYROH GL OHJQDPH/ SHU FXL QRQ Y·q PDQLHUD GL VDSHUH OD SUHFLVD TXDQWLWj GHO ORUR SHVRª44:1 2JJL QHVVXQR FRQWHVWD SL• LO GLULWWR GHJOL 6WDWL GL UHJRODUH OD PDQRPRUWD/ H TXLQGL GL VRWWRSRUUH DQFKH L EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL D WULEXWR1 (· DQ]L LQFRPSUHQ0 VLELOH LO ULILXWR/ GD SDUWH GHJOL LQWHUHVVDWL/ GHOO·DGHPSLPHQWR GL TXHOOR FKH YLH0 QH FRQVLGHUDWR XQ HOHPHQWDUH GRYHUH FLYLFR1 6L SXz DQFKH GLUH FKH OD SHUGLWD GL FUHGLELOLWj QHO VRVWHQHUH GLULWWL RUPDL DQDFURQLVWLFL LPSHGu DOOD &KLHVD GL FRQGXUUH FRQ TXDOFKH SUREDELOLWj GL VXFFHVVR OD EDWWDJOLD FRQWUR O·DEROL]LRQH VWHVVD GL JUDQ QXPHUR GL FDVH UHOLJLRVH1 $O SDUL GL TXHOOD HFFOHVLDVWLFD LQ JHQH0 UDOH/ OD ORUR SURSULHWj 0 SHU OD VXD HVWHQVLRQH H OD VXD LQDOLHQDELOLWj 0 GRYHYD IDWDOPHQWH SURYRFDUH FRQWHVWD]LRQL H VXVFLWDUH FXSLGLJLH1 '·DOWUR FDQWR/ QRQ VL SXz QHPPHQR DSSURYDUH OD VXSHUILFLDOLWj H LO GLOHW0 WDQWLVPR FRQ FXL OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH UHDOL]]z OD VXD SROLWLFD HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 6HP0 EUD FKH DEELD VRSUDWWXWWR LPLWDWR O·RSHUDWR GHJOL DOWUL JRYHUQL/ DQ]LFKp HODER0 UDUH XQ SURJUDPPD DGHUHQWH DOOH UHDOL QHFHVVLWj GHO 3DHVH1 &L VL LPSRVVHVVz GHL EHQL GHJOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL 0 VSHVVR WUDVFXUDQGR GL LPSLHJDUOL LQ VFRSL GL ²²²²²²²² OR1 61 0217256,/ 0HPRULH DQWLFKH H QXRYH GHOOD FKLHVD GL &RUOR VFULWWH O·DQQR 4;44 +$5&+,9,2 3$552&&+,$/(/ &RUOR,/ I1 5·1 1HO 4;46/ LO FRUR GHOOH &ODULVVH GL &DUSL IX WUDVIHULWR QHO GXR0 PR GL 0RGHQD1 *1&1 62&,/ 0HPRULDH H[WUD RUGLQHP +%(02/ 0VV ,WDOLDQL1 1XRYH DFFHVVLRQL/ ,W1 5845 > ¢1 6914@,1 449 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLHVD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD FLW111/ SS1 :6/ :91 44: $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO1 82'/ Q1 :3/ &/ 6 +45 PDU]R 4:;<,1 'D XQ·DOWUD IRQWH +$121,02/ &URQDFD«FLW1/ 4<6, VL DSSUHQGH FKH LO 45 OXJOLR 4::7 VL VWDYD VJRPEUDQGR LO FROOHJLR GHL *HVXLWL GL 0RGHQD/ ©DYHQGR FRPSUDWD WXWWD OD URE0 ED LO 6LJQRU 3LHWUR /DQ]L >H@ LO 6LJQRU &KLRGHOOL/ VSH]LDOH GHOOR 2VSLWDOH/ GD YHQGHUHª1 0LJOLRUH VRUWH WRFFz DG DOWUL RJJHWWL FRQILVFDWL1 $ 5HJJLR/ SHU HVHPSLR/ XQ DOWDUH GL PDUPR QHUR GHOOD FKLHVD GL 61 6WHIDQR YHQQH WUDVIHULWR QHO GXRPR1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 6XSUHPR 0LQLVWUR/ (OHQFKL G·$IIDUL/ ILO]D 62&/ Q1 5<8/ &/ 6 +49 GLFHPEUH 4:;;,1
::9
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
YHUD XWLOLWj SXEEOLFD 0/ VHQ]D UHQGHUVL FRQWR GHL GDQQL FKH DOOD SRSROD]LRQH GHULYDYD GDOOD VFRPSDUVD GL FHQWUL D YROWH SOXULVHFRODUL/ DWWRUQR DL TXDOL URWH0 DYDQR WDQWH LQL]LDWLYH GL FDUDWWHUH UHOLJLRVR/ PD DQFKH FDULWDWLYH HG DVVLVWHQ0 ]LDOL 44;1 , SL• SHQDOL]]DWL IXURQR JOL DELWDQWL GHOOD FDPSDJQD H GHL FHQWUL PL0 QRUL/ FKH YHQQHUR SULYDWL GHOOD SUHVHQ]D GL YDULH FDVH UHOLJLRVH1 4XHVWH HUDQR SUREDELOPHQWH LQ JUDGR GL IRUQLUH XQ FRQWULEXWR SDVWRUDOH OLPLWDWR/ PD OD OR0 UR VFRPSDUVD WURYz VROR SDU]LDOL VXUURJDWL 44< 1 6H DOOD SROLWLFD GHJOL XOWLPL HVWHQVL YD ULFRQRVFLXWR LO PHULWR GL DYHU WHQWD0 WR/ VXOOH RUPH GL 0DULD 7HUHVD H VRSUDWWXWWR GL *LXVHSSH ,,/ GL IDUH GL XQ 3D0 HVH IHXGDOH H FOHULFDOH XQD PRQDUFKLD PRGHUQD/ FRQ XQ·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH VHP0 SOLFH H UD]LRQDOH/ VL GHYH DQFKH DJJLXQJHUH FKH VSHVVR 0 LVSLUDQGRVL DOO·LOOXPLQLVPR DXVWULDFR QHOOD VXD IDVH SL• UDGLFDOH +4:;304:<3, 453 0 ©IHFH GHO EHQH QHOOD PDQLHUD VEDJOLDWD/ SHUFKpÄ OR IHFH FRQ VFRQWURVLWj H IUHGGH]]D> SUDWLFz OD FDULWj VHQ]D VSLULWR GL FDULWj/ OD JHQHURVLWj VHQ]D VSLULWR GL JHQHURVL0 Wjª1 4541 &·q TXLQGL GD ULWHQHUH FKH DOO·XVFLWD GL VFHQD GHJOL (VWH L UHOLJLRVL GHO 'X0 FDWR QRQ DEELDQR SURYDWR HFFHVVLYL SDWHPL G·DQLPR1 $QFKH VH QRQ SRWHYDQR LPPDJLQDUH FLz FKH O·DYYHQLUH DYUHEEH ORUR ULVHUYDWR1 ,O 59 DJRVWR 4:<9 OH ²²²²²²²² 44;
/*DUFLSUHWH GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH FRPPHQWz FRVu OD PRUWH GHO SHQXOWLPR HVWHQVH= ©,Q 9D0 UHVH/ VXD VLJQRULD QHOOR 6WDWR GL 0LODQR/ FHVVz GL YLYHUH )UDQFHVFR ,,, QRVWUR 'XFD OL 55 IHE0 EUDLR >4:;3@/ LQ HWj G*DQQL ;5 H PHVL 7 FLUFD1 &RP*HJOL SRFR DPz VHPSUH L VXRL VXGGLWL/ FRVu SRFR YLVVH WUD HVVL/ H ORQWDQR GD HVVL YROOH PRULUH1 &Lz QRQ RVWDQWH O*DGXOD]LRQH WHQWHUj GL IDUOR SDVVDUH SHU XQ HURH/ ORGDQGRVL LQ OXL FLz FKH LO EXRQ FULWHULR UHQGHUj VHPSUH ELDVLPHYR0 OH1 )X SLHQR YHUDPHQWH G*LGHH PDJQLILFKH/ FKH YHQQHUR LQ OXL QXGULWH GD XQD PDVVD GL DGXOD0 WRUL/ FKH GL FRQWLQXR HEEH G*LQWRUQR1 0D QRQ VL DYYLGH PDL FKH WDOL LGHH QRQ GRYHDQR DYHU OXRJR LQ XQ 3ULQFLSH GL ILQDQ]H DVVDL OLPLWDWH1 >111@ $SUu XQ *UDQG*$OEHUJR SH* SRYHUL/ QRQ SHU TXHVWR UHVWz OD FLWWj QHWWDWD GDL TXHVWXDQWL/ PD OH FKLHVH VL WURYDQR WXWWDYLD ULSLHQH GL ELUEDQWL LPSRUWXQL/ QHPLFL GHO UDFFRJOLPHQWR/ FKH DFFRPSDJQDU GHH OD RUD]LRQHª1 *1 01 58%%,$1,/ /LEUR GL PHPRULH«FLW1/ SS1 57<05831 44< 1HO 4::4/ O*DUFLSUHWH GL 0DVVD )LQDOHVH DQQRWz QHOOD VXD FURQDFD= ©,Q TXHVW*DQQR LO FRQYHQWR GH* 0LQRUL 2VVHUYDQWL GHO )LQDOH UHVWz VRSSUHVVR D IURQWH DQFKH GHO EHQH FKH ID0 FHDQR TXH* EXRQL )UDWL/ PDVVLPH DL SRYHUL YLOODQL GHO 6HUUDJOLR H GHO &DPSR GHO 'RVVR/ HG L VRJJHWWL IXURQR GLVWULEXLWL QHJOL DOWUL FRQYHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ DL TXDOL IX SXUH FRQFHGXWR TXHO FKH DYHDQR GL PRELOL/ Vu GHO FRQYHQWR FRPH GHOOD FKLHVD/ GD GLVWULEXLUVL H ULSDUWLUH QH* VXGGHW0 WL FRQYHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ D FRJQL]LRQH GHO ORUR SURYLQFLDOH1 /D TXHVWXD FK*HVVL IDFHDQR QHO )L0 QDOHVH IX ULSDUWLWD D TXHL GHOOD 0LUDQGROD H GL 0RGDQDª1 *1 01 58%%,$1,/ /LEUR GL PHPRULH111 FLW1/ :80:91 453 &IU $1 $1121,/ *LXVHSSH ,,/ XQ $VEXUJR ULYROX]LRQDULR/ LQ ©$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR /RPEDUGRª/ 44: +4<<4,/ SS1 7;:0837> /1 %2',/ 6WXGL VXOO*LOOXPLQLVPR DXVWULDFR/ 4<:80<31 3UHPHVVH SHU XQD IXWX0 UD VLQWHVL/ LQ ©5LYLVWD 6WRULFD ,WDOLDQDª/ 436 +4<<4,/ SS1 :;;0;441 454 )1 )(-7g/ *LXVHSSH ,,/ XQ $VEXUJR ULYROX]LRQDULR/ *RUL]LD 4<<3/ S1 4;:/ S1 5561
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:::
WUXSSH IUDQFHVL HQWUDYDQR LQ 5HJJLR H LO 9 RWWREUH LQ 0RGHQD/ GD GRYH ILQ GDO : PDJJLR HUD IXJJLWR (UFROH ,,,1 ,O 'XFDWR YHQQH D IDU SDUWH GHOOD 5H0 SXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD +63 GLFHPEUH 4:<9, H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH GL TXHOOD &LVDOSL0 QD +JLXJQR 4:<:,1 3HU L UHOLJLRVL VWDYD SURILODQGRVL XQD QXRYD VWD]LRQH GHOOD ORUR YLD &UXFLV 4551 (SLORJR 1HJOL XOWLPL GHFHQQL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR 0 OR VL q YLVWR 0 LO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH/ FR0 PH DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ DYHYD FHUFDWR GL ULQQRYDUVL/ DWWXDQGR L FDQRQL GHO GL0 VSRWLVPR LOOXPLQDWR 4561 ,QIDWWL/ VL SXz YHUDPHQWH DIIHUPDUH FKH QHOOD VHFRQ0 GD PHWj GHO VHFROR DQFKH QHO QRVWUR 3DHVH LQL]LD OD ORWWD SROLWLFD PRGHUQD/ FRQ JOL VFKLHUDPHQWL FKH GLYHQWHUDQQR WLSLFL QHOO·2WWRFHQWR1 1HOO·,WDOLD 6HW0 WHQWULRQDOH/ OD GLIIXVLRQH GHOOD JUDQGH DIILWWDQ]D QHOOH FDPSDJQH PRGLILFD OH EDVL VWHVVH GHOOD VRFLHWj1 , FRQWDGLQL/ GHJUDGDWL GD PH]]DGUL D VDODULDWL H D EUDFFLDQWL/ VSHVVR FHUFDQR LQ FLWWj SURWH]LRQH H PLJOLRUL FRQGL]LRQL GL ODYR0 UR4571 7DOH DIIOXVVR GL PDQRGRSHUD VFDUGLQD D SRFR D SRFR L YLQFROL RUPDL DQDFURQLVWLFL H LO FKLXVR VLVWHPD GHOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL/ RVWDFROL ULOHYDQWL DO OLEHUR GLVSLHJDUVL GHOO·DWWLYLWj GL LQGLYLGXL FDSDFL H GHFLVL D IDUVL YDOHUH1 $QFKH D 0RGHQD OH FRUSRUD]LRQL YHQJRQR DEROLWH1 (· O·HSRFD GHOOD ERUJKHVLD H GHOO·LQL]LDWLYD SULYDWD/ IDYRULWD GDL VRYUDQL LOOXPLQDWL/ FKH D ORUR YROWD VRQR SUHVVDWL GD HVLJHQ]H ILQDQ]LDULH VHPSUH PDJJLRUL/ SHU IDU IURQWH DL QXRYL FRPSLWL ORUR DGGLWDWL GDL ILORVRIL1 3HU UHSHULUH L IRQGL QHFHVVDUL/ YHQJRQR LQGLYLGXDWL GXH VHWWRUL G·LQWHUYHQWR= VRWWRSRUUH D LPSRVWD L EHQL GHOOH FODVVL SULYLOHJLDWH +QRELOWj H FOHUR,/ H IDYRULUH OR VYLOXSSR HFRQRPLFR GHOOD ERUJKHVLD/ FKH LQ TXHVWD IDVH q DOOHDWD GHO SRWHUH FRVWLWXLWR1 6XO IURQWH RSSRVWR/ VL WURYDQR OD QRELOWj H LO FOHUR/ FKH SHUz QRQ VRQR DO0 OHDWL WUD GL ORUR/ QRQ VRQR XQLWL QHOOD GLIHVD GHL FRPXQL LQWHUHVVL1 /D SULPD YLHQH VRWWRSRVWD DO SDJDPHQWR GHOOH LPSRVWH/ PD VDOYD OD SURSULHWj1 &RVD FKH ²²²²²²²² 455
&IU 5LYROX]LRQH )UDQFHVH H VRFLHWj PRGHQHVH/ 0LUDQGROD 4<<3> 21 520%$/',/ /D 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD/ 0RGHQD 4<<:1 456 )1 &$7$/$12/ ,O PRYLPHQWR SROLWLFR H VRFLDOH= LO SHULRGR ULYROX]LRQDULR H QDSROHRQLFR/ 4:;<0 4;48/ LQ /*,WDOLD QHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR +6WRULD G*,WDOLD/ 9,,,,/ 0LODQR 4<97/ S1 81 457 /1 '$/ 3$1(/ ,QWURGX]LRQH DOOR VWXGLR GHOOD VWRULD GHOOH FDPSDJQH HPLOLDQH/ LQ /H FDPSDJQH H0 PLOLDQH QHOO·HSRFD PRGHUQD/ D FXUD GL 51 =$1*+(5,/ 0LODQR 4<8:/ 46059> $1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGD0 QLD«FLW1/ SS1 <80438/ 5761
::;
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
ULHVFH VROR LQ SDUWH DO FOHUR1 ,QIDWWL L EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL KDQQR XQD VRUWH SDU0 ]LDOPHQWH GLYHUVD D VHFRQGD FKH DSSDUWHQJDQR DO FOHUR VHFRODUH R DJOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL1 4XHVWL XOWLPL VRQR YLWWLPH GL JUDGXDOL FRQILVFKH/ FKH SHUPHWWRQR DOOR 6WDWR GL LPSDGURQLUVL GL XQD YDVWLVVLPD SURSULHWj LPPRELOLDUH1 (· OD ERU0 JKHVLD D WUDUUH LO PDJJLRUH YDQWDJJLR GD TXHVWD RSHUD]LRQH 0 DOOD TXDOH QRQ q SHUz HVWUDQHD DQFKH SDUWH GHOOD QRELOWj 458 0 FKH WURYD XQD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH L0 GHRORJLFD LQ FHUWL VHWWRUL GHOOR VWHVVR FOHUR +L JLDQVHQLVWL DXVSLFDQR LO ULWRUQR DOOD &KLHVD SULPLWLYD/ FKH QRQ FRQRVFHYD JOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL, 4591 ,O ULIRUPL0 VPR KD VDQ]LRQDWR OD URWWXUD FRQ LO SDVVDWR/ SURYRFDQGR XQ ULQQRYDPHQWR SURIRQGR GHO PRGR GL YLYHUH H GL SHQVDUH= OH OLPLWD]LRQL GHOO·DXWRULWj UHJLD/ FKH GRYHYD FRQIURQWDUVL FRQ L GLULWWL LQDOLHQDELOL GHOOD OHJJH GL QDWXUD H GHOOD UDJLRQH/ GLIIRQGRQR LO GHVLGHULR GL QXRYL H SL• UHVSRQVDELOL RUGLQDPHQWL1 0D q VRSUDWWXWWR OD ERUJKHVLD D UHQGHUVL FRQWR FKH OH FRQTXLVWH RWWHQXWH FRQ O·DLXWR GHL VRYUDQL QRQ VDUDQQR VLFXUH/ ILQ D TXDQGR QRQ VLDQR IRQGDWH VX JD0 UDQ]LH FRVWLWX]LRQDOL/ OLPLWDWULFL GHOO·HVHUFL]LR GHO SRWHUH DVVROXWR1 7DOH SUHVD GL FRVFLHQ]D SURYRFD XQD QXRYD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOH IRU]H= GD XQD SDUWH OD PRQDUFKLD/ L FHWL SULYLOHJLDWL +QRELOWj 45: H FOHUR45;, H OD ©SOHEHª 45< > GDOO·DOWUD ²²²²²²²² 458
&1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL FLW1/ S1 4731 21 520%$/', +/·HFRQRPLD GHL WHUULWRUL«FLW1, IRUQL0 VFH O·HOHQFR GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL FRQILVFDWL QHL 'LSDUWLPHQWL GHO 3DQDUR +SS1 ::0:;, H GHO &URVWROR +SS1 :;0;3,/ H L QRPLQDWLYL GHL ORUR DFTXLUHQWL +SS1 ;30<8,1 'HL ©EHQL QD]LRQDOLª D0 OLHQDWL QHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR/ LO 5:/4( ILQu QHOOH PDQL GL QRELOL/ FKH UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR LO 47/:( GHJOL DFTXLUHQWL1 $1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGDQLD111 FLW1/ 981 1HO FRPSOHVVR/ SHUz/ L SRVVHGL0 PHQWL QRELOLDUL QHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR GLPLQXLURQR/ DQFKH VH GL SRFR/ SDVVDQGR GDO 5;/9( DO 56/4(1 ,ELG1/ 5751 459 'D VRQGDJJL IDWWL/ ULVXOWD FKH QHO 0RGHQHVH GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR OH WHUUH DSSDUWHQHQWL D QRQ QRELOL SDVVDURQR GDO 86/9 DO 9</:(1 ,ELG1 45: 'D VRQGDJJL IDWWL/ ULVXOWD FKH QHO 0RGHQHVH GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR OH WHUUH DSSDUWHQHQWL D HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL SDVVDURQR GDO 46 DO 5/<(1 'XUDQWH OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ JOL HF0 FOHVLDVWLFL ©UHFXSHUDURQR VROR LQ PLQLPD SDUWH OH SRVL]LRQL SHUGXWH QHJOL DQQL IUDQFHVL/ SRU0 WDQGRVL DO 6/6( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH GHO FDPSLRQH/ JUD]LH DOOD UHVWLWX]LRQH GHL EHQL FRQILVFDWL GDO0 OH DXWRULWj QDSROHRQLFKH H ULPDVWL LQYHQGXWL H DG XQD GLVSRVL]LRQH GHO FRQFRUGDWR GHO 4;74 WUD LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGHª1 ,ELG1/ 5761 $QFKH D 5HJJLR/ OD VSHUDQ]D GHO YHVFR0 YR ©GL YHGHUVL UHVWLWXLWL PROWL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL DOLHQDWL DQGUj GHOXVDª1 61 635($),&2/ /D &KLH0 VD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD«FLW1/ 5;31 45; &IU $1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGDQLD«FLW1/ S1 5761 45< *1 5(=$6&2 +'L]LRQDULR GHO OLQJXDJJLR LWDOLDQR VWRULFR HG DPPLQLVWUDWLYR/ )LUHQ]H 4;;4/ ;3<, GHILQLVFH OD ©SOHEHª= ©/D SDUWH LQILPD GHO SRSROR/ D YROWH DQFKH SL• EDVVD GHO SRSROR PLQXWR/ TXDQGR SHU TXHVWR SRSROR V*LQWHVHUR OH DUWL PLQRUL> SRLFKp OD SOHEH R L PLQXWLVVLPL QRQ DYH0 YDQR &ROOHJL SURSUL G*DUWH/ PD VL ULGXFHYDQR VRWWR L FROOHJL GHOOH DUWL DIILQLª1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
::<
OD ERUJKHVLD +WHU]R VWDWR R ©SRSRORª 463,1 4XHVWD RWWLHQH OD VXD YLWWRULD FRQ OD 5LYROX]LRQH )UDQFHVH/ FKH QRQ D FDVR q VWDWD GHILQLWD XQD ULYROX]LRQH ERUJKHVH1 'HOOD ERUJKHVLD/ 1DSROHRQH LQWHU0 SUHWHUj LO GHVLGHULR GL VWDELOLWj H GL RUGLQH/ QHFHVVDUL D FRQVROLGDUH OH FRQTXL0 VWH RWWHQXWH1 /D UHOLJLRQH q FRQVLGHUDWD XQ SRWHQWH VRVWHJQR/ FKH YD ULPHVVR LQ FRQGL]LRQH GL HVVHUH XWLOL]]DWR GDO SRWHUH VWDWDOH/ PHGLDQWH OD SROLWLFD FRQ0 FRUGDWDULD1 6H JLj SULPD GHOOD ILQH GHOO·$QWLFR 5HJLPH H GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR IUDQFHVH LO FOHUR GLRFHVDQR GHO 'XFDWR/ GDWD OD VFDUVLWj GL UHOLJLRVL XWLOL]]DELOL/ HUD VWDWR LQGRWWR D GHGLFDUVL DOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH H DOOD FDWHFKHVL/ GXUDQWH OD 5HVWDXUD]LR0 QH YLHQH VSLQWR ©DG DVVXPHUVL SL• GLUHWWDPHQWH FRPSLWL D FXL VSHVVR LQ HSR0 FKH SUHFHGHQWL VL HUD VRWWUDWWR/ R FKH DYHYD GHPDQGDWR DL UHJRODUL/ VSHFLH QHO0 OH FDPSDJQH> DG DPSOLDUH FRQ XQ PDJJLRUH LPSHJQR QHOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH H QHOOD LVWUX]LRQH OH IXQ]LRQL VDFHUGRWDOL PLQLPH/ FHOHEUD]LRQH GHOOD PHVVD H DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL VDFUDPHQWL/ LQ XQR GHL TXDOL/ SHUDOWUR/ OD SHQLWHQ]D/ HUD VWDWR LQ SDVVDWR SXUH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH FRDGLXYDWR GDL UHJRODULª 4641 6L HUD LQ0 VRPPD URWWD OD GLFRWRPLD FKH DVVHJQDYD DO FOHUR GLRFHVDQR OD SDUWH VDFUD0 PHQWDOH GHOOD FXUD SDVWRUDOH H DO FOHUR UHJRODUH TXHOOD UHODWLYD DOO·DQQXQFLR GHOOD 3DUROD GL 'LR H DOOH GHYR]LRQL1 $ PHWWHUH LO FOHUR GLRFHVDQR LQ FRQGL0 ]LRQH GL IDU IURQWH DL VXRL REEOLJKL/ FRQWULEXLVFH OD ULDSHUWXUD GHL VHPLQDUL/ QHL TXDOL ILQDOPHQWH VL SXz HIIHWWXDUH OD IRUPD]LRQH GHOOH QXRYH OHYH VDFHU0 GRWDOL/ FKH LQ SUHFHGHQ]D DYYHQLYD QHOOH SDUURFFKLH 465 1 6H O·DFFHQWXD]LRQH GHO UXROR GHOOD SDUURFFKLD D VFDSLWR GHO UXROR GHL UHOLJLRVL UDSSUHVHQWDYD XQ HOHPHQWR GL UD]LRQDOL]]D]LRQH GHOOD VWUXWWXUD HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ OD VLWXD]LRQH YHQX0 WDVL D FUHDUH QRQ HUD LPPXQH GD DVSHWWL FKH KDQQR SHVDWR QHJDWLYDPHQWH VXO ²²²²²²²² 463 'D *1 5(=$6&2 +LELG1/ S1 657, LO ©SRSRORª q GHILQLWR= ©/*RUGLQH WUD OD SULPDULD QRELOWj H LO SRSROR PLQRUH R DUWHILFLª1 &IU1 01 5,&&,$5',/ /LQHH VWRULFKH VXO FRQFHWWR GL SRSROR/ LQ ©$QQDOL GHOO*,VWLWXWR 6WRULFR LWDOR0JHUPDQLFR LQ 7UHQWRª/ 49 +4<<3,/ SS1 636069<1 /D FLUFRODUH GHOOD &RPPLVVLRQH SHU OD 3URYYLVWD GHL *UDQL GHO GLSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR GHO 46 QRYHPEUH 4;33 HOHQFDYD= 3RVVLGHQWL/ 0HUFDQWL/ &DSLWDOLVWL/ $JULFROWRUL/ ,PSLHJDWL/ $UWLJLDQL1 $602/ )RQGR &RUWHVH/ ILO]D 465 +6WDPSH YHVFRYLOL,1 4641 9(58&&,/ &KLHVD H VRFLHWj111 FLW1/ S1 741 465 ,O FOHUR GLRFHVDQR FHUFDYD PRGHOOL GL VDQWLWj WUD OH VXH VWHVVH ILOH1 ,O 57 RWWREUH 4;4:/ D &DVXPDUR YHQQH HVXPDWD H FROORFDWD QHO FRUR GHOOD SDUURFFKLDOH OD VDOPD TXDVL LQFRUURWWD GL G1 *LXVHSSH &DUDVVLWL1 4XHVWL HUD PRUWR XQ YHQWHQQLR SULPD LQ FRQFHWWR GL VDQWLWj H GL ©XR0 PR GL VHPSUH SHUIHWWD RQHVWj H HVHPSODUH FRQGRWWD/ H GL SLHQD XPLOWj/ H SHUIH]LRQHª1 $&$02/ $IIDUL (FRQRPLFL H 3ROLWLFL/ 111 446/ 9381 1HO 4;75/ OD SDUURFFKLD GL &DVXPDUR SDVVz DOO·DUFKLGLRFHVL GL %RORJQD1 ,ELG1/ 1ƒ :981
:;3
*LXVHSSH 2UODQGL
IXWXUR GHOOD &KLHVD1 $QFKH SHUFKp DOFXQH VFHOWH IXURQR DGRWWDWH VHQ]D WHQHU FRQWR GHOOH HYHQWXDOL FRQVHJXHQ]H QHJDWLYH1 3HU HVHPSLR/ OD ULGX]LRQH GHO QXPHUR GHOOH SDUURFFKLH 0 YHULILFDWDVL D 0RGHQD H D 5HJJLR JLj QHJOL XOWLPL GHFHQQL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR 0 FRPSRUWz XQ PDJJLRU FDULFR SDVWRUDOH SHU L SDUURFL/ FKH SURSULR DOORUD YLGHUR VFHPDUH OD FROODERUD]LRQH TXDOLILFDWD GHL UHOLJLRVL/ ULGRWWL QXPHULFDPHQWH H D YROWH WRWDOPHQWH VFRPSDUVL1 8Q DOWUR OLPLWH HUD FRVWLWXLWR GDOOD UXUDOL]]D]LRQH GHOOD SDUURFFKLD GL FLWWj 466 / FKH HEEH XQ SDUWL0 FRODUH SHVR QHO PRPHQWR LQ FXL VL PDQLIHVWDYD XQD WHQGHQ]D DOO·XUEDQL]]D]LRQH/ XQD FUHVFLWD GHOOH FLWWj H XQD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GL ERUJKL D0 JULFROL LQ YHUH H SURSULH FLWWj/ SUHPHVVH GHOO·LQFLSLHQWH LQGXVWULDOL]]D]LRQH 4671 /D VFRPSDUVD GL WDQWH FDVH UHOLJLRVH/ YHULILFDWDVL JLj DOOD ILQH GHO 6HWWHFHQ0 WR/ DYHYD HOLPLQDWR XQD VRUJHQWH GL IUHTXHQWL FRQWUDVWL FRQ LO FOHUR GLRFHVD0 QR/ SULYDQGR SHUz FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH YDULH FDWHJRULH GL IHGHOL GL PH]]L GL FUHVFLWD VSLULWXDOH1 6L SHQVL DOOD UHWH GL FRQJUHJD]LRQL FKH URWHDYDQR DWWRUQR DL FROOHJL GHL *HVXLWL/ GL FXL 0 D SL• GL 53 DQQL GDOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOD &RPSD0 JQLD 0 LO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD DYYHUWLYD DQFRUD OD PDQFDQ]D 4681 6L SHQVL DO ²²²²²²²² 466
6XOO*DUJRPHQWR/ FIU -1 &20%/,1/ 7HRORJLD GHOOD FLWWj/ $VVLVL 4<:4/ S1 69;1 'HWWR DXWRUH ULWLHQH FKH OD &KLHVD GHOO*(XURSD RFFLGHQWDOH VLD UXUDOH LQ RJQL VXD VWUXWWXUD IRQGDPHQWDOH +GLRFHVL/ SDUURFFKLH/ SURYLQFLH/ HFF1,1 /H QXRYH VWUXWWXUH VL PRGHOODURQR VXOOD VLWXD]LRQH GHO PRQGR HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH UXUDOH GHOO*DOWR PHGLRHYR1 7DQWR FKH TXHOOH XUEDQH VRQR GD ULWHQHUVL SDUURFFKLH UXUDOL/ WUDVSRUWDWH LQ FLWWj1 /D ORUR VWUXWWXUD VL ULIj D QHFHVVLWj H D VLWXD]LRQL RUPDL VXSHUDWH/ GDWR FKH OD ©SDUURFFKLD VL q DGDWWDWD IHOLFHPHQWH DOOD VWUXWWXUD UXUDOH GHOO*(XURSD RFFLGHQWDOH FRPH VL q VYLOXSSDWD GRSR LO PHGLRHYRª1 ,ELG/ S1 6981 &IU1 9(58&&,/ &KLHVD H VRFLH0 Wj111 FLW1/ S1 8;1 )UD LO 4:;9 H LO 4;54/ OD GLRFHVL PRGHQHVH HEEH :;6 QXRYL VDFHUGRWL= LO 46 ( SURYHQLYD GDOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ LO 46 GDOOD SLDQXUD H LO :7 ( GDOOD FROOLQD0PRQWDJQD1 ,Q UDS0 SRUWR DO 4:<:/ D 0RGHQD L VDFHUGRWL HUDQR VFHVL GHO 66/8 ( QHO 4;48/ H GHO 76 ( QHO 4;65> LQ FDPSDJQD GHO 69 ( QHO 4;48/ H GHO 76 ( QHO 4;651 ,O FDULFR SDVWRUDOH SHU VDFHUGRWH/ FKH QHO 4:<: ULVXOWDYD GL 87 IHGHOL LQ FLWWj H GL 435 LQ FDPSDJQD/ QHO 4;48 HUD VDOLWR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH D :; H 4941 1HO 4;3</ OD SRSROD]LRQH GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR YLYHYD SHU LO :4 ( LQ SLDQXUD/ SHU O·44 ( LQ FROOLQD H SHU LO 4; ( LQ PRQWDJQD1 0RGHQD H JOL DOWUL FHQWUL GL FDQWRQH FRQWDYDQR XQ TXDUWR GHO WRWDOH GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR1 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH 111FLW1/ 7:/ 49;/ 64506461 467 9(58&&,/ &KLHVD H VRFLHWj111 FLW1/ SS1 8:08;1 468 'HOOH FRQJUHJD]LRQL FKH SULPD GHOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD L *HVXLWL GLULJH0 YDQR/ PRQV1 &RUWHVH QHO 4:<7 ULPSLDQJHYD VRSUDWWXWWR TXHOOH ©SHU OD SRYHUD JHQWHª= ©,Q VLPLOL XQLRQL VSLULWXDOL Y*q IUD PROWL DOWUL/ XQ YDQWDJJLR VSHFLDOLVVLPR/ FKH q TXHOOR FKH LO SL• VSHVVR L SDGUL YL FRQGXFRQR L ORUR ILJOLXROL> H GL TXL UHVWD SURYYHGXWR FRP*q FKLDUR LQ JUDQ SDUWH DOOD ORUR PRUDOH HGXFD]LRQHª1 *1 &257(6(/ 3URPHPRULD 111FLW1/ LQ *1 25/$1',/ /H FDP0 SDJQH 111FLW1/ SS1 6;:06;;1
, UHOLJLRVL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH
:;4
FRPSOHVVR GL SUDWLFKH/ GHYR]LRQL/ HFF1/ FKH JOL ,VWLWXWL UHOLJLRVL QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL DYHYDQR HVFRJLWDWR/ SDWURFLQDWR H GLIIXVR/ H FKH HUD JLj VWDWR LQ JUDQ SDUWH VSD]]DWR YLD GDOOR ]HOR GHL ULIRUPLVWL1 /·DOWUD IDFFLD GHOOD PHGDJOLD q UDSSUHVHQWDWD GDOOD SRVVLELOLWj FKH DOOD &KLH0 VD YLHQH RIIHUWD 0 DOPHQR LQ FHUWH DUHH 0 GL ULVWUXWWXUDUH VX EDVL WRWDOPHQWH QXRYH OD SUHVHQ]D H OD YLWD GHL UHOLJLRVL1 0ROWH GHOOH FDVH UHOLJLRVH FKH VL HUD LQYDQR WHQWDWR GL ULIRUPDUH/ SHU HVHPSLR/ FRQ O·LQWURGX]LRQH GHOOD YLWD FR0 PXQH/ VFRPSDUYHUR GHILQLWLYDPHQWH1 ,QVRPPD/ DQFKH SHU L UHOLJLRVL GHO 'X0 FDWR GL 0RGHQD SXz YDOHUH TXDQWR q VWDWR GHWWR GHL ORUR FRQIUDWHOOL GL DOWUH SDUWL G·,WDOLD= GRYH DYHYD IDOOLWR LO ©PHOHª GHOOD SHUVXDVLRQH/ OD VROX]LRQH HUD VWDWD WURYDWD GDO ©UDVRLRª GHOOD FRD]LRQH 4691
²²²²²²²² 469 &IU 01 0,(/(/ 5LFHUFKH VXOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHL UHOLJLRVL QHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL +4;3904;48,/ LQ ©&DPSDQLD 6DFUDª/ 7 +4<:6,/SS1 40477> *1 %5$1&$&&,2/ ,O WURQR/ OD IHGH H O*DOWDUH1 ,VWLWX]LRQL HF0 FOHVLDVWLFKH H YLWD UHOLJLRVD QHO PH]]RJLRUQR PRGHUQR/ 1DSROL 4<<9/ SS1 49;04:51
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:;6
$1'5($ =$1$5'2
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
1HO 4;<6 /XLJL )UDQFHVFR 9DOGULJKL FRPSOHWDYD L ´SULQFLSDOL SXQWL FURQR0 ORJLFL FKH QHL QRVWUL DQQDOL WRFFDQR TXHVWD QD]LRQHµ/ YDOH D GLUH JOL HEUHL/ DQ0 QRWDQGR FKH ´XQD FDUWD GHO YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD ,QJRQH +4358, ULFRUGD XQ $UGLQJR/ JLXGHR/ GHSRVLWDULR >L1H1 DSSDOWDWRUH@ G·XQD GHFLPD LQ 6DOLFHWRµ41 $O0 OR VWDWR DWWXDOH GHOOD ULFHUFD q TXHVWD OD SL• DQWLFD WUDFFLD GRFXPHQWDULD UL0 JXDUGDQWH OD SUHVHQ]D GL HEUHL QHO WHUULWRULR PRGHQHVH1 Ë EHQ QRWR FRPH OH IRQWL GHL VHFROL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH VXFFHVVLYL DOO·DQQR 0LOOH VLDQR SLXWWRVWR DYDUH GL LQGLFD]LRQL LQ PHULWR DOOD SUHVHQ]D HEUDLFD QHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUR0VHWWHQWULRQDOH1 0D WDOH OXRJR FRPXQH/ FDODWR QHOOD VLWXD]LR0 QH FRQFUHWD/ YDOH D GLUH QHOOD 0RGHQD GHL VHFROL ;,0;,9/ VL SUHVWD DG DOFXQH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL FULWLFKH1 6H q YHUR FKH q YDQD OD ULFHUFD GL QRUPH DG KRF QHJOL VWDWXWL FRPXQDOL GHO 465:/ FKH DQ]L GHGLFDQR DPSLR VSD]LR D SUHVWDWRUL FUL0 VWLDQL5/ YD ULFRUGDWR FKH QRQ VHPSUH DG XQD DVVHQ]D VXO SLDQR QRUPDWLYR FRUULVSRQGH XQD DVVHQ]D QHO PRQGR UHDOH1 7DOH LQGLFD]LRQH PHWRGRORJLFD DSSDUH SL• SUHJQDQWH FRQVLGHUDQGR OH UHFHQWL LQGDJLQL VYROWH VXO PDWHULDOH QRWDULOH61 ²²²²²²²² -&RUUH O·REEOLJR GL IDU ULIHULPHQWR DOOH UHOD]LRQL SUHVHQWDWH DO &RQYHJQR GL VWXGL /H &R0 PXQLWj HEUDLFKH GL 0RGHQD H &DUSL1'DO PHGLRHYR DOO·HWj FRQWHPSRUDQHD/ D FXUD GL )1%21,/$85, H 910$8*(5,/ )LUHQ]H 4<<< 4 &RPSOHVVD q OD YLFHQGD HGLWRULDOH GL /1 9$/'5,*+,/ 'L]LRQDULR VWRULFR0HWLPRORJLFR GHOOH FRQ0 WUDGH H VSD]LL SXEEOLFL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4;;31 6HPSUH LQ 0RGHQD/ QHO 4;;6/ IXURQR HGLWH OH $SSHQGLFL H QRWH H GLHFL DQQL SL• WDUGL OH $JJLXQWH DOOH $SSHQGLFL H QRWH/ GD FXL VL FLWD D S1 8:1 5 *1 6,/,1*$5', 0 $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL/ LQ (QFLFORSHGLD PRGHQHVH/ 9,, +9HURQD 4<<7,/ SS1 434043:1 6 $1 &$03$1,1,/ 7UDFFH GRFXPHQWDULH GHOOD SUHVHQ]D HEUDLFD D 0RGHQD QHO 0HGLRHYR/ UHOD]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH«FLW1
:;7
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
3UHVWDWRUL HEUHL VRQR SUHVHQWL D )HUUDUD QHO 45:8= q /XGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL DO GDUQH QRWL]LD/ PHQWUH ´LQWHQGH GL IDU YHGHUH FKH LQ TXHOOD FLWWj JRGHYDQR DVVDL IDYRUHµ7/ YDOH D GLUH TXDQGR Gj LO YLD DG XQD LPPDJLQH VWR0 ULRJUDILFD FKH DYUj JUDQGH IRUWXQD81 3HU VHFROL LO JLRFR GHOOD ILVFDOLWj HVWHQVH FRQFHVVH DJOL HEUHL XQD SHFXOLDUH QLFFKLD DOO·LQWHUQR GHO 'XFDWR> PD HYRFDUH LQ SURSRVLWR O·LGHD GL WROOHUDQ]D ULVFKLD GL DSSDULUH IXRUL OXRJR1 1RQ YDQQR LQ0 IDWWL GLPHQWLFDWH OH FRRUGLQDWH LGHRORJLFKH GHOO·HSRFD/ EHQ SUHVHQWL QHOOD PHQWH GHJOL (VWH/ FRPH q VWDWR JLXVWDPHQWH ULFRUGDWR LQ WHPSL UHFHQWL91 ( WDOL FRRUGLQDWH LGHRORJLFKH/ GHFLIUDELOL JUD]LH DOOD ULFHUFD VXOOD OHWWHUDWXUD JLX0 ULGLFD/ QRQ VROR SRQJRQR O·HEUHR DO GL IXRUL GHOOD VRFLHWj FULVWLDQD/ PD WUD ;,,, H ;9 VHFROR OR FROORFDQR DO FHQWUR GL XQD GLDOHWWLFD WUD WROHUDQWLDH FLYLOL0 VWLFKH H JUDYDPLQD GL RULJLQH FDQRQLVWLFD/ SXU VHPSUH ULFRQGXFLELOL DOO·DFFXVD GL GHLFLGLR:1 ,O 53 JHQQDLR GHO 46<6 $OEHUWR G·(VWH FRQFHGHYD D *XJOLHOPR GL 0XVHWR/ RULJLQDULR GL )HUPR QHOOH 0DUFKH PD UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD/ LO SHUPHVVR GL D0 SULUH XQ EDQFR IHQHUDWL]LR DVVLHPH DL VXRL VRFL> FRQFHVVLRQH GHOOD GXUDWD GL FLQTXH DQQL H/ DOOD VFDGHQ]D/ SXQWXDOPHQWH ULQQRYDWD1 *XJOLHOPR HUD VRFLR GL EDQFKLHUL ULPLQHVL/ ERORJQHVL H SHUXJLQL;1 $ 0RGHQD/ JLj QHO 46:6/ 9LWDO 0D0 QRHOOR GD )HUPR H %XRQDYHQWXUD &RQVLJOLR GD )RUOu DYHYDQR FRQFHVVR DG $PHGHR FRQWH GL 6DYRLD XQ SUHVWLWR GL RWWRPLOD GXFDWL G·RUR<1 1HOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO ;,9 VHFROR/ 0RGHQD q VHGH GL DWWLYLWj HFRQRPLFKH GHL SUHVWDWRUL RULJLQDUL GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH H/ QHO VHFROR VXFFHVVLYR/ JLXQJH DG RWWHQHUH XQD FROORFD]LRQH QHOOD JHRJUDILD GHOO·,WDOLD HEUDLFD> FKH q/ FRPH q EHQ QRWR/ JHR0 JUDILD SXQWLIRUPH/ FRPSRVWD GL PLFUR0LQVHGLDPHQWL GDOOH GLPHQVLRQL SRFR SL• FKH IDPLOLDUL431 ²²²²²²²² 7
$1 )5,==,/ 0HPRULH SHU OD VWRULD GL )HUUUDUD/ ,,,/ )HUUDUD 4;7;/ S1 5331 /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ ;9,,/ , 'XFDWL SDGDQL1 7UHQWR H 7ULHVWH/ 7RULQR 4<:</ S1 481 9 *1 )$%%5,&,/ $OFXQH RVVHUYD]LRQL VXO UDSSRUWR WUD (EUHL HG (VWHQVL WUD %DVVR 0HGLRHYR HG (Wj 0RGHUQD +VHFROR ;9 0 ;9,,,/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ ;;, +4<<<,/ SS1 47604941 : '1 48$*/,21,/ ©%RWK DV YLOODLQ DQG YLFWLPª1 /·HEUHR LQ JLXGL]LR1 &RQVLGHUD]LRQL LQWURGXWWLYH/ LQ ©4XDGHUQL 6WRULFLª/ <</ 4<<;/ SS1 84:08651 ; $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD 4<63 +ULVW1 DQDVW1 %RORJQD 4<9<,/ SS1 4904;1 < $1 0,/$12/ 6WRULD GHJOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<96/ SS1 44;045<1 43 51 %21),// *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD QHOO·HSRFD GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ )LUHQ]H 4<<4/ SS1 540881 8
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:;8
3RFR VDSSLDPR GHOOD ILVLRQRPLD GL TXHVWR SULPR JUXSSR GL HEUHL PRGH0 QHVL1 3RVVLDPR VXSSRUUH FKH/ DQDORJDPHQWH D TXDQWR DFFDGHYD LQ DOWUL FR0 PXQL GHOO·,WDOLD VHWWHQWULRQDOH/ DO JUXSSR GL SLRQLHUL VL DJJLXQJHVVHUR/ QHO FRU0 VR GHJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL/ DOWUL SUHVWDWRUL/ FRQ RJQL SUREDELOLWj DQFK·HVVL GL RUL0 JLQH LWDOLDQD/ SL• R PHQR OHJDWL DL SULPL GD DOOHDQ]H IDPLOLDUL R SURIHVVLRQDOL441 *OL LQGL]L QRQ PDQFDQR= EDVWL SHQVDUH DO ULIHULPHQWR D XQ ´GDFWDUR +HEUHRµ FKH SUHVWD GHQDUR DOOD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD QHO 4745 R DO VRQWXRVR $URQ KD0 NRGHVK +DUPDGLR VDFUR, ULVDOHQWH DO 47:5/ SURYHQLHQWH GD XQD VLQDJRJD PRGH0 QHVH HG DWWXDOPHQWH FXVWRGLWR DO 0XVHR GL &OXQ\451 &RPSXOVDQGR OH WHVWL0 PRQLDQ]H DUWLVWLFKH/ DUFKLWHWWRQLFKH HG DUFKLYLVWLFKH/ q IDFLOH GHGXUUH OH FD0 UDWWHULVWLFKH GL TXHVWR PRYLPHQWR PLJUDWRULR HEUDLFR FKH WUD ;,9 H ;9 VH0 FROR LQYHVWu/ ROWUH D 0RGHQD/ PROWR SUREDELOPHQWH/ DQFKH &RPXQL FLUFRVWDQ0 WL/ WUD FXL FHUWDPHQWH &DUSL461 4XHVWR PRYLPHQWR PLJUDWRULR HEUDLFR/ FKH ULJXDUGD WXWWD O·,WDOLD FHQWUR0 VHWWHQWULRQDOH/ ID L FRQWL FRQ OD YLUXOHQWD SUHGLFD]LRQH DQWLVHPLWD GHL IUDQFH0 VFDQL47 1 , WRQL GL TXHVWD SUHGLFD]LRQH/ FKH VSD]LDYD GDOOD GHQXQFLD GHOO·XVXUD/ OD TXDOH GLYHQLYD GHQXQFLD GHOOR VFDQGDOR GHOOD SUHVHQ]D HEUDLFD QHO FRUSR VRFLDOH FULVWLDQR/ SHU JLXQJHUH DOOD DFFXVD HVSOLFLWD GL RPLFLGLR ULWXDOH/ VRQR EHQ QRWL481 $QFKH 0RGHQD HG LO VXR WHUULWRULR YHQQHUR LQYHVWLWL GDOOD VHFRODUH SROH0 PLFD FKH/ ´WROOHUDQ]Dµ HVWHQVH R PHQR/ UDJJLXQVH LQ EUHYH WHPSR OLYHOOL GUDPPDWLFL1 1HO 4834 FRUUHYD YRFH FKH VL DJJLUDVVH SHU 0RGHQD TXDOFXQR GHJOL DVVDVVLQL GL 6LPRQLQR GD 7UHQWR491 /·LQGLFD]LRQH GHO FURQLVWD/ ROWUH D GLPRVWUDUH OD ULVRQDQ]D WUHQWHQQDOH GHOO·HYHQWR/ ULYHOD TXDQWR SURIRQGD IRV0 VH OD WUDFFLD ODVFLDWD GDOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH IUDQFHVFDQD4:1 0XRYH DG DQDORJKH ²²²²²²²² 44 01 /8==$7,/ %DQFKL H LQVHGLDPHQWL HEUDLFL QHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUR0VHWWHQWULRQDOH IUD 7DUGR 0HGLRHYR HG LQL]L GHOO·HWj PRGHUQD/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD1 $QQDOL ;,1 *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<<9/ W1 ,/ SS1 4;:0 56<1 45 &1 *+(/), 0 21 %$5$&&+,/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<<8/ SS1 470491 46 &XOWXUD HEUDLFD LQ (PLOLD05RPDJQD/ D FXUD GL 6101 %21'21, H *1 %86,/ 5LPLQL 4<;71 47 /1 32/,$.29/ /HV %DQFKLHUL -XLIV HW OH 6DLQW 6LqJH GL ;,,, DX ;9,, VLHFOH/ 3DULV 4<981 48 -1 &2+(1/ 7KH )ULDUV DQG WKH -HZV1 7KH HYROXWLRQ RI PHGLHYDO DQWL -XGDLVP/ /RQGRQ 4<;51 1RQ VL SXz QRQ ULOHYDUH LO VLOHQ]LR LQ SURSRVLWR GHOOD VWRULRJUDILD FDWWROLFD/ GD FXL SURYHQJR0 QR LQYHFH WHVL GLFKLDUDWDPHQWH DSRORJHWLFKH/ S1 HV1 91 0(1(*+,1/ %HUQDUGLQR GD )HOWUH H L 0RQWL GL 3LHWj/ 9LFHQ]D 4<:71 49 71 '(· %,$1&+, GHWWR GH· /DQFHOORWWL/ &URQDFD PRGHQHVH/ 3DUPD 4;99/ YRO1 ,,,/ S1 991 4: 6X 6LPRQLQR GD 7UHQWR/ VXSSRVWD YLWWLPD GHOOD SHUILGLD -XGHRUXP/ VXOOD ´YLWD VRWWHUUDQH0 Dµ GHOOD YLFHQGD +OH SHULRGLFKH ULHPHUVLRQL/ ILQR D TXHVWR VHFROR, YHGL '1 48$*/,21,/ ,O SUR0
:;9
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
FRQVLGHUD]LRQL OD SURVRSRSHD GHO JLXUHFRQVXOWR UHJJLDQR *KHUDUGR 0D]]ROL/ FKH QHO 4888 WHQWDYD GL SRUUH DUJLQH DOOD SUHVHQ]D HEUDLFD1 ´'D FRVWRUR/ FR0 PH QHPLFL GHOOD IHGH FULVWLDQD/ QRQ Y·q GD DVSHWWDUVL DOWUR FKH PDOH/ H TXDQWR SL• VDUDQQR/ WDQWR PDJJLRUH QH VDUj OD SHVWH LQ TXHVWD FLWWj/ SRLFKp TXDQGR PROWL LQIHWWL DFFRUURQR LQ XQ OXRJR/ YL VL ID GL JLRUQR LQ JLRUQR SL• VSHVVR LO FRQWDJLR1 0RUELGD IDFWD SHFXV WRWXP FRUUXPSLW RYLOH1 *OL (EUHL QRQ VL DIIDQQR PDL EHQH FRL &ULVWLDQL> DQ]L/ JUDQ SUHJLXGL]LR DUUHFD DOOD QRVWUD IHGH LO FRQYLYHU FRQ HVVLµ4;1 $QFKH QHL WHUULWRUL HVWHQVL KD GXQTXH FLWWDGLQDQ]D SHU VHFROL XQ GLVFRUVR FKH SRVVLDPR GHILQLUH DQWLVHPLWD DQFKH DOOD OXFH GL DXWRUHYROL SXQWXDOL]]D0 ]LRQL4<1 0D SHU QRQ SHFFDUH XOWHULRUPHQWH GL DVWUDWWH]]D RFFRUUH FROORFDUH TXHO GLVFRUVR/ TXHOOD FLUFROD]LRQH GL LGHH HVSUHVVH +FRPH VL q YLVWR, LQ IRUPD GL PHWDIRUH/ DOO·LQWHUQR GHO ORUR FRQWHVWR VWRULFR H VRFLDOH1 /H YLFHQGH GHOO·HFRQRPLD H OD VWRULD LVWLWX]LRQDOH GHO 'XFDWR/ FKH VRQR QRWH D JUDQGL OL0 QHH53 DQGUHEEHUR PHVVH LQ UHOD]LRQH FRQ L YDUL SURYYHGLPHQWL DQWL0HEUDLFL/ SHUORPHQR FRQ TXHOOL QRWL1 $QFKH D 0RGHQD/ QHO ;9 VHFROR/ FL VL SUHRFFXSz D SL• ULSUHVH GL GLVWLQJXHUH L FULVWLDQL GDJOL HEUHL/ LPSRQHQGR D TXHVWL XQ VH0 JQR GLVWLQWLYR54> DQFKH D 0RGHQD L IUDQFHVFDQL IRQGDURQR VROHQQHPHQWH XQ 0RQWH GL 3LHWj/ QHO 47<7/ SHU WRJOLHUH FOLHQWHOD DL EDQFKL HEUDLFL DOORUD SUH0 VHQWL LQ FLWWj +GXH,/ H ´SULPR HIIHWWR QH IX O·LQDVSULPHQWR GHOOR VWDWR GHJOL (EUHLµ SUHVWDWRUL/ SURFHVVDWL SHU FDYLOOL551 1HOOR VYROJHUVL GL TXHVWH YLFHQGH JOL (VWH SDLRQR LQWHQ]LRQDWL D ´IDYRULUHµ JOL HEUHL R VHPSOLFHPHQWH DOOR VWDWXV TXR/ YDOH D GLUH D PDQWHQHUH LQ IXQ]LRQH LO JLRFR GHOOD ILVFDOLWj " 6L WUDWWD GL QRGL VWRULRJUDILFL DQFRUD GD VFLRJOLHUH1 1RQ q IXRUL OXRJR VXSSRUUH FKH JLj DOOD ILQH GHO ;9 VHFROR/ VL VLD YHULILFD0 WD XQD LPPLJUD]LRQH GL SURIXJKL LEHULFL LQ VHJXLWR DOOH RIIHUWH GL DVLOR GL (U0 FROH ,= PD VRQR DQFRUD GD VWXGLDUH OH PRGDOLWj GL TXHVWD PLJUD]LRQH/ ROWUH FKH LO GHVWLQR GHOOH IDPLJOLH FRLQYROWH561 1RQ QH VRQR QRWL L SHUFRUVL/ QRQ ²²²²²²²² FHVVR GL 7UHQWR GHO 47:8/ LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH H JOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ D FXUD GL 01 /8==$77,/ 5RPD0%DUL 4<<7/ SS1 4<067/ FRQ DPSLD ELEOLRJUDILD1 4; $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL FLW1/ S1 48;1 4< /D YHWXVWD GLVWLQ]LRQH WUD DQWLJLXGDLVPR WHRORJLFR HG DQWLVHPLWLVPR UD]]LVWD q VWDWD PHVVD LQ TXHVWLRQH GD <1+1 <HUXVKDOPL/ $VVLPLODWLRQ DQG 5DFLDO DQWL06HPLWLVP= WKH ,EHULDQ DQG WKH *HU0 PDQ 0RGHOV/ 1HZ <RUN 4<;51 53 /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1 54 &1 *+(/), 0 21 %$5$&&+,/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD FLW1/ SS1 47 H 4;1 55 $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL FLW1/ SS1 930941 56 01*1 08==$5(//,/ )HUUDUD/ RYYHUR XQ SRUWR SODFLGR H VLFXUR WUD ;9 H ;9, VHFROR LQ 9LWD H
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:;:
VDSSLDPR VH HG LQ TXDOH PLVXUD TXHVWL FRPSUHQGHVVHUR DQFKH OD FLWWj GHOOD *KLUODQGLQD1 6L SXz TXL ULIHULUH XQD WUDGL]LRQH SRSRODUH LQ SURSRVLWR= PROWL HEUHL PRGHQHVL VDUHEEHUR RULJLQDUL GL 6LYLJOLD/ GRYH HVLVWH XQD WRUUH FDPSD0 QDULD GHWWD *LUDOGD> OD VRPLJOLDQ]D GL TXHVWD FRQ LO FDPSDQLOH PRGHQHVH D0 YUHEEH SRUWDWR DOOD FUHD]LRQH GHO WHUPLQH/ SHU PH]]R GHO GLPLQXWLYR *LUDOGL0 QD571 9DUUHEEH OD SHQD GL LQGDJDUH DWWRUQR D TXHVWD SOXUL0VWUDWLILFDWD H FRP0 SOHVVD ´LQYHQ]LRQH GHOOD WUDGL]LRQHµ/ GRYH VL IRQGRQR OD SHUFH]LRQH FULVWLDQD GHJOL HEUHL H OD SHUFH]LRQH HEUDLFD GHO FDPSDQLOH FULVWLDQR1 ,Q PDQLHUD SL• R PHQR FDUVLFD/ GXQTXH/ QHO ;9, VHFROR/ DQFKH 0RGHQD VL WURYD DG HVVHUH FRPSUHVD QHOOD PDSSD GHOOD 'LDVSRUD VHIDUGLWD1 OO PRGHOOR VSDJQROR/ TXHOOR GHOOD FDFFLDWD GHL ´SHUILGL ]XGpµ LQL]LD DG HVVHUH LQYRFDWR GDO SXOSLWR GHO 'XRPR QHO 483<58 H QH VHJXLUDQQR UHLWHUDWL WHQWDWLYL GL GL0 VWLQJXHUH JOL HEUHL GDL FULVWLDQL R GL JUDYDUQH OH DWWLYLWj HFRQRPLFKH GL TXHVWL1 7XWWR GD LQGDJDUH q VH TXHVWL SURYYHGLPHQWL YDGDQR SRVWL LQ UHOD]LRQH FRQ XQ DXPHQWR GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH HEUDLFD LQ FLWWj/ H VH WDOH DXPHQWR YDGD PHVVR R PHQR LQ UHOD]LRQH FRQ LO VXFFHVVR GL WDOH SUHGLFD]LRQH1 1RQ YHQJRQR GD 6LYLJOLD PD GDO 3RUWRJDOOR JOL HEUHL GL FXL VL SDUOD QHO 487;> WUD 4843 H 4864 OD FLWWj QRQ q LQ SRVVHVVR GHJOL (VWH H SURVHJXH OD SUHGLFD]LRQH FRQWUR L ´SHUIL0 GL ]XGpµ/ JOL XVXUDL591 ,O FKH SDUUHEEH LQGLFDUH FRPH O·LGHQWLWj SURIHVVLRQDOH GHL QXRYL LPPLJUDWL VHIDUGLWL/ D SURSRVLWR GHL TXDOL KD DQFRUD FRUVR XQD SHU0 FH]LRQH SL• OHWWHUDULD FKH VWRULFR0VRFLDOH/ QRQ HUD GLVWLQWD/ DOPHQR SHU TXDQ0 WR ULJXDUGD OH SULPH JHQHUD]LRQL/ GD TXHOOD GHJOL HEUHL ´LWDOLDQLµ1 4XDQGR/ QHO 4953/ O·LQVLHPH GHL SURYYHGLPHQWL JLj LQ YLJRUH QHOOR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD/ GDOOD SURLEL]LRQH GL DYHUH LQVHUYLHQWL FULVWLDQL D TXHOOD GL LQVH0 JQDUH ´DOFXQD VRUWD GL VFLHQ]Dµ/ YHQQHUR ULDVVXQWL H VLVWHPDWL]]DWL ´FRQ IRU]D GL OHJJH LQYLRODELOHµ5: / VL IDFHYD ULIHULPHQWR D SUHFHGHQWL GLVSRVL]LRQL GHO 48:3/ SRL FDGXWH LQ GLVXVR1 /H ULFHUFKH G·DUFKLYLR QRQ KDQQR DQFRUD SRUWDWR D VFRSULUH LO WHVWR GL TXHVWL SURYYHGLPHQWL1 4XHOOR FKH q FHUWR q FKH QHO 48:3 ²²²²²²²² FXOWXUD HEUDLFD QHOOR 6WDWR (VWHQVH1 $WWL GHO , FRQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL/ D FXUD GL (1 )5(*1, H 01 3(5$1,/ 1RQDQWROD +0RGHQD, 4<<6/ SS1 568058:1 57 *1 6,/,1*$5', 0 $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL/ LQ (QFLFORSHGLD PRGHQHVH/ 9,,/ FLW1/ S1 4361 58 1HO 4846 YHUUj SXEEOLFDWR LO /LEHOOXV DG /HRQHP 'HFHP GHL PRQDFL FDPDOGROHVL 4XHULQL H *LXVWLQLDQL/ OD SL• QRWD IRUPXOD]LRQH HVSOLFLWD GHOO·HVRUWD]LRQH DO 3RQWHILFH DIILQFKp PHWWD JOL HEUHL GL IURQWH DOO·DOWHUQDWLYD WUD EDWWHVLPR HG HVSXOVLRQH1 $1 )2$/ (EUHL LQ (XURSD1 'DOOD 3HVWH 1HUD DOO·(PDQFLSD]LRQH1 ;,90;9,,, VHFROR/ 5RPD0%DUL 4<<5/ S1 861 59 &1 *+(/),021 %$5$&&+,/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD FLW1/ SS1 4<0531 5: *ULGD 6RSUD JOL +HEUHL 3XEOLFDWD LQ 0RGRQD LO Gu 53 ) 54 'LFHPEUH 493 LQ 0RGHQD 3HU $QWR0 QLR1 ) )LOLSSR *DGDOGLQL 6WDPSDWRUL 'XFDOL 49531
:;;
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
QHOO·DUHD GHOO·DWWXDOH SLD]]DOH %RVFKHWWL/ HUD VLWXDWR LO FLPLWHUR HEUDLFR/ O·2UWDFFLR GL 6DQ 6LOYHVWUR> FKH QHOOD FRQWUDGD 6DQ *LRUJLR YL HUD XQD VLQDJR0 JD> FKH SRFR ORQWDQR YL HUD XQD FRQWUDGD GHWWD GHO =XGp5;1 1HOO·$QILSDUQDVR FRPHGLD KDUPRQLFD/ HGLWD DOOD ILQH GHO ;9, VHFROR/ LO PRGHQHVH 2UD]LR 9HFFKL VEHIIHJJLD OD SDUODWD FKH HUD SRVVLELOH DVFROWDUH LQ TXHOOH FKH HUDQR QRWH SR0 SRODUPHQWH FRPH ´VWUDGH GHJOL HEUHLµ +HEUHL ´$KL %DUXFKDL/ %DGDQDL 0HUGRFKDL/ $Q %LOXFKDQ *KHW 0LORWUDQ /D %DUXFKDEjµ >«@ )UDQFDWULSSD ´8 XKu/ R RKu 2 PHVVLU $URQµ +HEUHL ´&·KD SXOVqW D ¶VWz SRUWRQ "µ )UDQFDWULSSD ´6R Pu/ VR Pu/ 0HVVLU $URQµ +HEUHL ´&KH FKHXVD YROuW " &KH FKHXVD GLFuW "µ5< ,O EUDQR FLWDWR q VLQWRPR GHOOD SHUFH]LRQH GL XQD HVWUDQHLWj FXOWXUDOH/ PD DQFKH GL XQD VHULH GL UDSSRUWL SHUVRQDOL= )UDQFDWULSSD FRQRVFH LO QRPH GHOO·HEUHR/ L TXDOL ² VLD SXUH FRQ DFFHQWR FDUDWWHULVWLFR ² VRQR DQFKH FDSDFL GL HVSULPHUVL LQ OLQJXD LWDOLDQD631 2 ´OLQJXD LWDOLDQD FKULVWLDQDµ/ FRPH YHUUj GH0 ILQLWD GD XQ SHUVRQDJJLR DO FRQILQH WUD OH GXH FXOWXUH/ XQ QHRILWD VHFHQWHVFR/ FKH PHWWHUj LO SURSULR ´VYHJOLDWR LQJHJQRµ DO VHUYL]LR GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH/ ID0 ²²²²²²²² 5;
*1 6,/,1*$5',/ $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL FLW1/ S1 4361 /1 9$/'5,*+,/ $JJLXQWH DOOH $SSHQGLFL H QRWH DO 'L]LRQDULR VWRULFR0HWLPRORJLFR GHOOH FRQWUDGH H VSD]LL SXEEOLFL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4;<6/ SS1 4;:04;;1 63 6XO GLDOHWWR JLXGHR0PRGHQHVH= 01 0$<(5 0RGHQD/ /H SDUODWH JLXGHR LWDOLDQH LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD1 $QQDOL ;,1 *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<<:/ W1 ,,/ SS1 <8708;1 5<
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:;<
FHQGRVL FHQVRUH GL OLEUL HEUDLFL641 &RQ LO ;9,, VHFROR OD ULQQRYDWD ,QTXLVL]LRQH SUHVH D IXQ]LRQDUH DQFKH QHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH1 /D 5LIRUPD FDWWROLFD JLXQJHYD D IDU VHQWLUH LO SURSULR SHVR DQFKH VXJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL/ VXL TXDOL VL DJJUDYDYD OD SUHVVLRQH FRQYHU0 VLRQLVWLFD651 7UD 4933 H 4937 XQD VHULH GL SURFHVVL LQTXLVLWRULDOL FROSu JOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL= SHU GLVVXDVLRQH GDO EDWWHVLPR/ SHU GHWHQ]LRQH GL OLEUL YLHWDWL/ SHU FRQWDWWL LQGHELWL FRQ FULVWLDQL1 1H VHJXLURQR FRQGDQQH/ SURQWDPHQWH FRP0 PXWDWH LQ SHQH SHFXQLDULH661 (UD O·HVRUGLR GL XQD SUHFLVD VWUDWHJLD ILQDQ]LDULD= SDUWLWD VHQ]D PH]]L DGHJXDWL/ O·,QTXLVL]LRQH ORFDOH/ FKH QRQ SRWHYD VSHUDUH QHO VXSSRUWR GHL 'XFKL H PHQR DQFRUD LQ TXHOOR GHO YHVFRYR/ DYHYD WURYDWR LO PRGR SHU ILQDQ]LDUVL> H VDUHEEH LQWHUHVVDQWH DSSURIRQGLUH VH OD VWUDWHJLD YHQQH ULSUHVD DQFKH GD DOWUL WULEXQDOL LWDOLDQL GHO 6DQW·8IIL]LR1 /D DGRWWz LP0 PHGLDWDPHQWH OD 9LFDULD GL )LQDOH= VH QH DFFRUVH LO UDEELQR ,VDFFR 6DFHUGRWL/ LQGDJDWR QHO 4968 SHU DYHU ERUERWWDWR ´FRVWRUR YRJOLRQR GHOOL TXDWWULQLµ JXDUGDQGR XQ HGLWWR GHO 6DQW·8IIL]LR671 ,O 'XFDWR HUD RUPDL HQWUDWR QHO VHFROR GHOO·DYDQ]DQWH GHSUHVVLRQH= VX GL XQD HFRQRPLD SURYDWD GDOOH SHUGLWH WHUULWRULDOL H GDOOD FRQJLXQWXUD FRPSOHV0 VLYD +GDOO·RVVHUYDWRULR PRGHQHVH SXz HVVHUH RVVHUYDWR O·DYDQ]DUH GHOOD ´SLF0 FROD HWj JODFLDOHµ68 , FRQWLQXDYD DG HVHUFLWDUVL LO JLRFR GHOOD ILVFDOLWj1 'D )HU0 UDUD OD FRUWH VL HUD VSRVWDWD QHOOD QXRYD FDSLWDOH H/ DVVLHPH DG HVVD/ DQFKH TXDOFKH IDPLJOLD GL HEUHL/ FKH SRFR JUDGLYD L QXRYL SDGURQL GHOOD FLWWj URPD0 JQROD1 ,O WHUURUH GHOO·LQYDVLRQH HEUDLFD EHQ VL YHGH QHOOD &URQDFD GL *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 6SDFFLQL/ FKH VHJQDOD OD SUHVHQ]D GL FLQTXHPLOD HEUHL LQ FLWWj/ DFFDQWR DOOD UDVVLFXUDQWH FRQVWDWD]LRQH VHFRQGR OD TXDOH VDUDQQR SUHVWR FKLXVL LQ XQ VHUDLR H FRVWUHWWL ILQDOPHQWH D SRUWDUH LO VHJQR691 $ 0RGHQD VL HUD LQL]LDWR D SDUODUH HVSOLFLWDPHQWH GL JKHWWR> JOL HEUHL YL YHUUDQQR FRQGRWWL VROR QHO 496;1 ,O SHUFRUVR LVWLWX]LRQDOH FKH SRUWD DOOD FR0 VWUX]LRQH q ²DO VROLWR0 SXQWHJJLDWR GHJOL LQWHUYHQWL GHL SUHGLFDWRUL IUDQFHVFDQL ²²²²²²²² 64 0L VLD FRQFHVVR ULQYLDUH D $1 =$1$5'2/ ´/RU FROSD IX G·HVVHUH VHGRWWLµ1 8Q SURFHVVR GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH PRGHQHVH DG HEUHL H QHRILWL/ LQ ©1XRYD 5LYLVWD 6WRULFDª/ /;;;/4<<9/ SS1 85808<51 65 $1 )2$/ (EUHL LQ (XURSD1 'DOOD 3HVWH 1HUD DOO·(PDQFLSD]LRQH1 ;,90;9,,, VHFROR/ 5RPD0 %DUL 4<<5/ SS1 580931 66 $1 %,21',/ /XQJD GXUDWD H PLFURDUWLFROD]LRQH QHO WHUULWRULR GL XQ 8IILFLR GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH= LO ´6D0 FUR 7ULEXQDOHµ D 0RGHQD +45<504:;8, LQ ©$QQDOL GHOO·,VWLWXWR VWRULFR LWDOR0JHUPDQLFR LQ 7UHQ0 WRª/ 9,,,/ %RORJQD 4<;5/ SS1 :60<31 67 $1 0$6,1$/ /D &RPXQLWj HEUDLFD D )LQDOH QHO 6HLFHQWR/ 9HURQD 4<;;/ S1 45:1 68 '1 &$08))2/ &OLPD H VWRULD/ 0LODQR 4<;;1 69 *1 %1 63$&&,1,/ &URQDFD GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<<6/ S1 5;3 +55 IHEEUDLR 48<;,1
:<3
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
+FRPH S1 HV1 QHOO·DYYHQWR GHO 494:,/ FKH ULVFXRWRQR PROWR VXFFHVVR WUD OH $U0 WL/ L FXL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL VL UHFDQR D SL• ULSUHVH SUHVVR LO 'XFD/ SUHSDUDQGR YDUL SURJHWWL GL VHJUHJD]LRQH6:1 )RUQDL/ ´ODUGDUROLµ/ EHFFDL/ ´SHOOL]]DULµ VRQR SUH0 RFFXSDWL GHOOD FRQFRUUHQ]D HFRQRPLFD GHJOL HEUHL/ FKH S1 HV1 QHO 494< YHQ0 GRQR DL FULVWLDQL OH FDUQL LO FXL FRQVXPR q LPSHGLWR GDOOH UHJROH GHOOD NDVKH0 UXWK6;1 ´0HU]DULµ/ ´FDQHYDUROLµ +TXHOOL FKH HVHUFLWDQR O·DUWH GHOOD FDQDSD, H VHWDLROL YRJOLRQR VHQ]D GXEELR SRUUH XQ IUHQR D TXHJOL HEUHL FKH GD SL• GL XQ GHFHQQLR HVHUFLWDQR O·DUWH GHL SDQQL1 1RQ q GLIILFLOH ULQWUDFFLDUH VLPLOL PRWL0 YD]LRQL DQFKH GLHWUR L GLVRUGLQL WUD HEUHL H FULVWLDQL DYYHQXWL QHO 48<;/ TXDQ0 GR ²H QRQ VDUHEEH VWDWD OD SULPD RFFDVLRQH0 IDQFLXOOL FULVWLDQL DYHYDQR SL• YROWH JULGDWR ´IXRUL JOL (EUHLµ6<1 /H $UWL VDSHYDQR GL DYHUH DOOHDWL QHOOD QRELOWj H QHO YHVFRYR/ H VL SUHPXUD0 URQR GL IDUOR VDSHUH DO 'XFD731 (VSRQHQWH GHOOD SULPD SXz HVVHUH FRQVLGHUD0 WR TXHOO·$QGUHD &RGHEz FKH QHO 494; FKLHGHYD DO 'XFD GL PHWWHUH LQ DWWR OD UHFOXVLRQH741 4XDQWR DOO·DWWHJJLDPHQWR GHOOH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLDVWLFKH/ OD JLj FL0 WDWD JULGD GHO 4953 LQGLFD ILQR D TXDOH SXQWR VL ULXVFLVVH D FRQGL]LRQDUH L 'X0 FKL1 ,O GRPLQLR GHJOL (VWH q QRWR DOOD VWRULRJUDILD ILQ GDL WHPSL GL %XUFNKDUGW SHU HVVHUH ´LO SL• PLQDFFLDWR GL WXWWL JOL DOWUL JUDQGL H PHGLRFUL G·,WDOLDµ75/ SUL0 YR GL FRQILQL QDWXUDOL HG HFFOHVLDVWLFDPHQWH GLYLVR WUD TXDWWUR GLRFHVL/ QHVVX0 QD GHOOH TXDOL LQWHUDPHQWH DOO·LQWHUQR GHL FRQILQL SROLWLFL1 /D FRQGL]LRQH GHJOL HEUHL q/ LQ TXHVWR FRQWHVWR/ XQ EXRQ PRGR SHU PLVX0 UDUH O·µLQIUDPPHWWHQ]Dµ GHOOD &KLHVD/ DQFKH FRQVLGHUDQGR O·LQWHQVD SURSD0 JDQGD PLVVLRQDULD VYROWD GD $OIRQVR ,,, G·(VWH FKH/ GRSR DYHU DEGLFDWR QHO 495;/ QHOOD QXRYD TXDOLWj GL IUDWH FDSSXFFLQR/ VL LPSHJQz D OXQJR SHU OD FRQ0 YHUVLRQH GHJOL HEUHL/ ULGDQGR S1 HV1 YLJRUH DOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH FXL JOL HEUHL HUD0 QR REEOLJDWL DG DVVLVWHUH761 ²²²²²²²² 6:
'1 &$/$%,/ 'DOOH FRQWUDGH HEUDLFKH DL JKHWWL1 *OL HEUHL QHOOH FLWWj LWDOLDQH WUD ;9 H ;9,, VHFROR/ LQ /D FLWWj LWDOLDQD H L OXRJKL GHJOL VWUDQLHUL1 ;,90;9,,, VHFROR/ 5RPD0%DUL 4<<;/SS1469046;1 6; +1 5$%,12:,&=/ 6KHKLWWDK LQ (QFLFORSHGLD -XGDLFD/ -HUXVDOHP 4<:4/ YRO1 ;,9/ FRO1 446:0 46781 6< *1 %1 63$&&,1,/ &URQDFD GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<<6/ S1 <; +64 JHQQDLR 48<;,1 73 $1 %,21',/ *OL HEUHL H O·,QTXLVL]LRQH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH H JOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ D F1 GL 01 /8==$77,/ 5RPD0%DUL 4<<7/ SS1 59805;91 74 /1 9$/'5,*+,/ 'L]LRQDULR VWRULFR0HWLPRORJLFR GHOOH FRQWUDGH H VSD]L SXEEOLFL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4;;3/ S1 4341 75 -1 %85&.+$5'7/ /D FLYLOWj GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR LQ ,WDOLD/ )LUHQ]H 4<77/ S1 861 76 /1 &+,$33,1,/ *OL (VWHQVL/ 9DUHVH 4<9:/ SS1 6<406<;1
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:<4
,O JKHWWR IX HGLILFDWR QHO 496; LQ XQD FLWWj VHJQDWD GDOOH FRQVHJXHQ]H GHOOD SHVWH GHO 496377 H GDO WLPRUH GHOOD FRQWDPLQD]LRQH FKH SRWHYD SURYHQLUH GD0 JOL HEUHL/ GDOOH ORUR VWUHJRQHULH H GDJOL ´DPRUL FRQ OH FULVWLDQHµ78 1 4XDUDQWD0 FLQTXH IDPLJOLH HEUDLFKH YHQLYDQR D VRVWLWXLUH WUHQWDFLQTXH IDPLJOLH FULVWLDQH QHOOD ]RQD OLPLWDWD GDOOH DWWXDOL YLH (PLOLD/ 7DJOLR/ 7RUUH H 6TXDOORUH/ FRP0 SUHQGHQWL OH YLH %ODVLD H &ROWHOOLQL1 , 0DVVDUL GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL HEUHL VH0 JQDOHUDQQR OH SURSULH SUHRFFXSD]LRQL HEUDLFD SHU OD ´VWUHWWH]]Dµ GHO OXRJR/ FKLHGHQGR GL SRWHU UHDOL]]DUH ´XQ SXRFKR GH SLD]]RODµ/ HG RWWHUUDQQR LO SHUPHVVR GL WHQHUH ERWWHJKH IXRUL GDO UHFLQWR/ ILUPDWR GDO SRGHVWj $QGUHD &RGHEz791 /D IDPLJOLD GL TXHVWL HUD SURSULHWDULD GL JUDQ SDUWH GHOOH FDVH DOO·LQWHUQR GHO UHFLQWR7: H SRWHYD JLRYDUVL GHOO·HVLWR GHOOD YLFHQGD/ YLVWD OD SR0 VL]LRQH GL IRU]D QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL DIILWWXDUL1 /D VHJUHJD]LRQH GHJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL q DFFRPSDJQDWD GD LPPHULWDWD ID0 PD GL EODQGL]LH/ FKH SDUH WUDUUH JLXVWLILFD]LRQH GDO FRQIURQWR FRQ LO FDVR UR0 PDQR YHUVR LO TXDOH YLHQH IDWWR YDOHUH LO FLWDWR SHUPHVVR GL UHFDUVL IXRUL GDO UHFLQWR SHU UDJJLXQJHUH OH SURSULH ERWWHJKH7;1 ,Q UHDOWj HUD EHQ LQ YLJRUH O·LQVLHPH GHOOH GLVSRVL]LRQL YROWH DG RWWHQHUH OD FRQYHUVLRQH GHJOL HEUHL/ GDOO·REEOLJR GL SRUWDUH LO VHJQR DOOD GHJUDGD]LRQH GHOOH FRQGL]LRQL DELWDWLYH/ DJJUDYDWH GDO WHUUHPRWR GHO 499:7<1 'LVSRVL]LRQH FRPH TXHOOD ULFRUGDWD/ R OH ULSHWXWH HVRUWD]LRQL D QRQ RIIHQGHUH H VFKHUQLUH JOL HEUHL/ D FXL S1 HV1 SRWHYD FDSLWDUH/ LQ RFFDVLRQH GL XQ IXQHUDOH/ GL VHQWLUVL FKLHGHUH GL YHUVDUH LO GD]LR GHOOH FDUQL83/ DQGUHEEHUR SRVWH LQ UHOD]LRQH FRQ OH HVLJHQ]H ILQDQ]LDULH GHOOD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD FKH/ GRSR DYHU VHJUHJDWR JOL HEUHL/ SHU WXWWR LO ;9,, VHFROR VHJXLWz D FKLHGHUH SUHVWLWL DJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL841 0D/ D VFDQVR GL ULGX0 ]LRQLVPL HFRQRPLFLVWLFL/ RFFRUUH ULFRUGDUH LO TXDGUR LGHRORJLFR FRPSOHVVLYR/ ULFKLDPDWR GDL SXOSLWL S1 HV1 LQ RFFDVLRQL PLVVLRQDULH +R FRQYHUVLRQLVWLFKH,/ FKH WUDVIRUPDYD OD VROD SUHVHQ]D GHOO·HEUHR LQ IRQWH GL FRQWDPLQD]LRQH851 6H ²²²²²²²² 77
&1 *+(/), 0 21 %$5$&&+,/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD«FLW1/ S1 591 $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL «FLW1/ S1 49;1 79 '1 &$/$%,/ 'DO TXDUWLHUH HEUDLFR DOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHO JKHWWR LQ ,WDOLD= LO FDVR GL 0RGHQD/ UHOD]LR0 QH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH«FLW1 7: $5&+,9,2 6725,&2 '(//$ &2081,7- (%5$,&$ ', 02'(1$/ ILO]D 4<*/ ´*KHWWRµ1 7; $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL111 FLW1/ S1 4851 7< *1 6,/,1*$5', 0 $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL111 FLW1/ S1 4371 83 $ &RUUHJJLR/ QHO 49461 $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL 111FLW1/ S1 4341 84 *1 /1 %$6,1,/ 6XO PHUFDWR GL 0RGHQD WUD &LQTXH H 6HLFHQWR1 3UH]]L H VDODUL/ 0LODQR 4<:71 85 01 .5,(*(// 8Q WUDLW GH SV\FKRORJLH VRFLDOH GDQV OHV SD\V PpGLWHUUDQpHQV GX %DV 0R\HQ $JH= OH -XLI FRPPH LQWRXFKDEOH/ LQ ©$QQDOHV (6&ª/ 64 +4<:9,/ SS1 65906631 78
:<5
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
QHO ;,9 VHFROR/ D 3HUXJLD/ DG HEUHL H SURVWLWXWH HUD YLHWDWR WRFFDUH IUXWWD FKH QRQ DYHVVHUR LQ SUHFHGHQ]D DFTXLVWDWR86/ QHO 49:3 +TXDQGR O·DELWXGLQH GL LPSRUUH SUHVWLWL HUD EHQ UDGLFDWD, LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD HGLILFD]LRQH GHO JKHWWR GL 5HJJLR/ VL ULFRUGDYD DJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL FKH ´D QLXQR VDUj OHFLWR DYHUH LQ FDVD XVFLR/ ILQHVWUD R EXFR SHU GRYH VL SRVVD XVFLUH GDO JKHWWR >«@ OH ILQHVWUH FKH KDQQR LO SURVSHWWR IXRUL GDO JKHWWR GRYUDQQR DYHUH OH IHUUDWH QHO PH]]R GHOOD PXUDJOLDµ871 1RQ VL SXz QRQ ULFRUGDUH TXL FRPH OH JORULH FLYLOL H PLOLWDUL GHJOL (VWH JUDYDVVHUR VXOOH ILQDQ]H VLD GHOOH VLQJROH IDPLJOLH GL HEUHL/ VLD GL WXWWD O· 8QL0 YHUVLWDV KHEUHRUXP= RJQL SHUPHVVR/ GD TXHOOR GL ULVLHGHUH ´QHL IHOLFLVVLPL 6WDWL GL 6XD $OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPDµ/ DO GLULWWR GL PDFHOODUH OH FDUQL/ YHQLYD FRUULVSRVWR GLHWUR SDJDPHQWR GL VRPPH FKH QHO FRUVR GHJOL DQQL QRQ DFFHQQDURQR PDL D GLPLQXLUH> QHO 49:4 OD ULSDUWL]LRQH GHO FDULFR IX RJJHWWR GL XQD FRQWURYHUVLD WUD OH 8QLYHUVLWDWHV HEUDLFKH GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR1 $ TXHVWD WDVVD]LRQH VL DJ0 JLXQJHYDQR ´GRQDWLYLµ LQ RFFDVLRQH/ S1 HV1 GHO PDWULPRQLR GL $OIRQVR G·(VWH FRQ ,VDEHOOD GL 6DYRLD QHO 493;/ OH FXL VSHVH IXURQR VRVWHQXWH VROR GDJOL HEUHL UHJJLDQL/ YLVWD OD SRYHUWj GL TXHOOL PRGHQHVL1 1HO ;9,, VHFROR GLYHQQH XVXD0 OH OD WDVVD]LRQH SHU UDJLRQL GL JXHUUD> JOL HEUHL VL YLGHUR ULFKLHGHUH GRQDWLYL S1 HV1 SHU OD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOH IRUWH]]H QHO 4968 R GHO 1DYLJOLR GL 5HJJLR QHO 4:491 $L JUDYDPLQD HVWHQVL VL DJJLXQJHYDQR TXHOOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL= QHO ;9, VHFROR FRQVLVWHYDQR RUGLQDULDPHQWH QHOOD YHQWHVLPD SDUWH GHL EHQL HEUDLFL/ FXL YHQL0 YDQR DG DJJLXQJHUVL 43 VFXGL DOO·DQQR SHU RJQL VLQDJRJD/ ´IRVVH TXHOOD GL )HU0 UDUD R O·XOWLPD GL %UHVFHOORµ881 /·LPSUHVVLRQLVWLFR UHVRFRQWR GL $QGUHD %DOOHW0 WL/ GD FXL VL q DWWLQWR/ ULFRVWUXLVFH HIILFDFHPHQWH XQ TXDGUR LGHRORJLFR FXL HUD HVWUDQHD TXDOVLDVL LGHD GL WROOHUDQ]D1 5LFHUFKH VXFFHVVLYH SRWUDQQR IRUQLUH XO0 WHULRUL FRQWULEXWL/ LQGDJDQGR S1 HV1 VXOOD FRQWLQXLWj FRQ FXL O·,QTXLVL]LRQH OR0 FDOH SDVVz GDOOH PXOWH DL VLQJROL DL SUHVWLWL +LQ UHDOWj GRQDWLYL, LPSRVWL DOOD LQ0 WHUD 8QLYHUVLWDV/89 PRGHQHVH/ QHO FRUVR GL TXHOOR FKH OR VWHVVR %DOOHWWL GHILQL0 VFH ´LO PLWH H VFHWWLFR 6HWWHFHQWRµ8:1
²²²²²²²² 86
51 %21),// *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD QHOO·HSRFD GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ )LUHQ]H 4<<4/ S1 771 &1 *+(/), 0 21 %$5$&&+,/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD«FLW1/ S1 651 88 $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL/ 111FLW1/ SS1 44804551 89 &1 5,*+,/ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFD D 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ LQ )RUPD]LRQH H FRQWUROOR GHOO·RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD D 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ D FXUD GL $1 %,21',/ 0RGHQD 4<;9/ SS1 940961 8: $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL 111FLW1/ S1 4851 87
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:<6
$ GLVWDQ]D GL VHFROL VL SXz ULFRUGDUH FRPH OD JKHWWL]]D]LRQH PRGHQHVH QRQ VLD ULVXOWDWD GL DOFXQD XWLOLWj QHPPHQR SHU XQD VWRULD GHJOL HEUHL/ FKH QRQ DVVXPD FRPH FHQWUDOH LO UDSSRUWR FRQ OD PDJJLRUDQ]D FULVWLDQD1 &L VL UL0 IHULVFH DOO·RUGLQDPHQWR DUFKLYLVWLFR GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ FRUSRVD H JHQH0 UDOPHQWH EHQ RUGLQDWD DQFKH SHU L VHFROL FKH SUHFHGRQR OD UHFOXVLRQH8;1 6RQR VHULH GRFXPHQWDULH FKH FRQVHQWRQR XQR VWXGLR LQWHQVLYR/ YROWR D ULFRVWUXLUH/ DOPHQR SHU L VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,, OH GLQDPLFKH LQWHUQH GHOOD VRFLHWj HEUDLFD/ FKH GLD GHOOD YLWD LQWHUQD DL JKHWWL XQD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH PHQR OHWWHUDULD/ H FKH WHQJD LO GRYXWR FRQWR GHOOH VSHFLILFLWj ORFDOL8<1 *OL VSXQWL QRQ PDQFDQR= OR FRQIHUPDQR L VRQGDJJL ILQRUD HIIHWWXDWL QHO FDPSR GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD PH0 GLFLQD R QHOOD VWRULD GHOOH GRQQH1 1HOO·XQR H QHOO·DOWUR FDVR q VWDWR SRVVLELOH ULOHYDUH IRUPH GL VRFLDOLWj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q LQROWUH XQ DVSHWWR SHFXOLDUH QHOOD VWRULD GHOO·HEUDLVPR PRGHQHVH/ ULOH0 YDWR GD *HUVKRP 6FKROHP/ O·XOWLPR 0ILQRUD0 DG DYHU VWXGLDWR OH FDUWH GL $0 YUDP 5RYLJR/ LO GRWWR FKH IHFH GL 0RGHQD XQ FHQWUR LPSRUWDQWH SHU OD GLIIX0 VLRQH GHO VDEEDWLDQHVLPR/ WUD 49;3 H 4:33> XQ YHQWHQQLR FUXFLDOH/ QHO FRUVR GHO TXDOH LO GLVFRUVR DXWR0PHVVLDQLFR GL 6DEEDWDL YLHQH ULHODERUDWR GD 1DWDQ ²²²²²²²² 8; $1 63$**,$5,/ )RQGL DUFKLYLVWLFL H GRFXPHQWL ULJXDUGDQWL JOL HEUHL QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0R0 GHQD H *1 )$%%5,&,/ $OFXQH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL VXOOH IRQWL GRFXPHQWDULHH VXOOD VWRULD GHOOH &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH GL 0RGHQD H &DUSL +VHFROL ;,90;9,,,,/ UHOD]LRQL SUHVHQWDWH DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH« FLW1 8< &L VL ULIHULVFH D 61 6,(*081'/ /D YLWD QHL JKHWWL/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD1 $QQDOL ;,1 *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<<9/ W1 ,/ SS1 ;790;<5> HG DOOH RVVHUYD]LRQL FULWLFKH GL /1 $//(*5$/ 0RGHUQDULD0 WR R LQYHQ]LRQH GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH/ LQ ©4XDGHUQL VWRULFLª/ <;/ 4<<;/ SS1 76;078;1 93 $1 ', /(21( /(21,/ /D QD]LRQH HEUDLFD VSDJQROD H SRUWRJKHVH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL1 3HU VHUYLUH DG XQD VWRULD GHOO·HEUDLVPR VHIDUGLWD/ 5LPLQL 4<<51 94 61 $5,(7,/ $VVLVWHQ]D H VWUXWWXUH VDQLWDULH HEUDLFKH QHOOH &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH GL 0RGHQD H &DUSL WUD ;9,,, H ;; VHFROR/ UHOD]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH«FLW1 95 /1 02'(1$/ 1RWH D PDUJLQH GHOOD YLWD GHOOH GRQQH HEUHH PRGHQHVL QHOO·HSRFD GHO JKHWWR/ UHOD]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH 111FLW1
:<7
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
GL *D]D/ GRSR O·DSRVWDVLD GHO IRQGDWRUH/ DWWLQJHQGR D SLHQH PDQL DOOD .DEED0 ODK1 ,Q TXHVWL DQQL JOL DGHSWL GHO VDEEDWLDQHVLPR VFUXWDQR LO PRQGR DOOD ULFHU0 FD GL VHJQDOL FKH FRQIHUPLQR OD SURVVLPD PDQLIHVWD]LRQH LQ 3DOHVWLQD GL 6DE0 EDWDL =HYu +LQ TXDOLWj GL *RHO ,VUDHO/ ´VDOYDWRUH GL ,VUDHOHµ H/ LQ DOFXQH OHWWXUH/ 0HVVLD,/ GHO TXDOH SURSULR D 0RGHQD %DUXNK GL $UH]]R FRPSRVH DOOD ILQH GHO ;9,, VHFROR XQD DJLRJUDILD1 (· LQ TXHVWR FRQWHVWR FKH/ QHO 4:34/ VL WUDVIHUu D *HUXVDOHPPH OD FRQIUDWHUQLWD PRGHQHVH ´6KRPULP OD %RTHUµ +´FRORUR FKH D0 VSHWWDQR LO PDWWLQRµ/ QRPH VLJQLILFDWLYR,/ SRFKL DQQL GRSR OD ULYHOD]LRQH PHVVLDQLFD GHOOR =DGRN GL *URGQR/ L FXL PHVVDJJL YHQLYDQR SRUWDWL D 0RGH0 QD GD GRWWL DVKNHQD]LWL/ TXDOL %DHU 3HUOKHIWHU GL 3UDJD R +D\P 0DODNK GL &UDFRYLD961 , UDSSRUWL WUD OD FRPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD H OH FRPXQLWj EDOFDQLFKH/ GRFXPHQ0 WDWL QHOOH ILO]H /HWWHUH SUHVHQWL QHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR GHOOD &RPXQLWj (EUDLFD GL 0RGHQD LQWHUHVVDQR DQFKH JOL VWXGLRVL GL VWRULD UHOLJLRVD/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH SURSULR QHL %DOFDQL LO VDEEDWLDQHVLPR DVVXPH ILQ GDO ;9,, VHFROR/ FRQQRWDWL UDGLFDOL/ DQFKH TXHVWL ULFRUGDWL GD *HUVKRP 6FKROHP971 8QD WUDFFLD GL TXHVWR IHUYRUH PHVVLDQLFR q O·XQLFD FRSLD PDQRVFULWWD FRPSOHWD DWWXDOPHQWH HVLVWHQ0 WH GL XQ QRWR FRPPHQWDULR FDEDOLVWLFR/ GRQDWD GD /HRQH 5RYLJR D )UDQFHVFR ,,, QHO 4:9;/ OR 2U KD0<DNDU +´OD OXFH SUH]LRVDµ, GL 0RVKH &RUGRYHUR1 , 49 YROXPL VL WURYDQR RUD QHO IRQGR ´0DQRVFULWWL 2ULHQWDOLµ GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (0 VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD981 6X GL XQ SXQWR YL q RJJL JHQHUDOH DFFRUGR WUD JOL VWXGLRVL= OD GLIIXVLRQH GHOOH GRWWULQH PHVVLDQLFKH VDEDWLDQH DYYHQQH SULYLOHJLDQGR OH FRQIUDWHUQLWH DO FXOWR VLQDJRJDOH> VL WUDWWz GL XQD PRGDOLWj VSHFLILFDPHQWH HEUDLFD GL TXHO PR0 YLPHQWR PRGHUQR GHOOD GLPHQVLRQH UHOLJLRVD YHUVR O·LQWHULRUH KRPLQH991 $ TXH0 VWR SURSRVLWR YDQQR ULFRUGDWL JOL VWXGL GL /XFLDQR $OOHJUD/ QHL TXDOL ULVDOWD LO UXROR VRFLDOH GHOOH FRQIUDWHUQLWH/ OXRJR SULYLOHJLDWR GL ULGLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOH ULVRUVH/ VDOGDWXUD WUD KDVVLGLVPR GHL VLQJROL +FKH TXL SRVVLDPR EHQ WUDGXUUH FRQ ´SLHWLVPRµ, H FRQFH]LRQL ELEOLFKH GHOOD JLXVWL]LD GLVWULEXWLYD9:1 /H VHULH ²²²²²²²² 96
*1 6&+2/(0/ .DEEDODK/ 1HZ <RUN 4<:7/ +WUDG1 LW1 5RPD 4<;5,/ SS1 5:905;81 *1 6&+2/(0/ /H JUDQGL FRUUHQWL GHOOD PLVWLFD HEUDLFD/ 7RULQR 4<<5/ SS1 64406451 98 6XOOD FRQYHUVLRQH GL /HRQH 5RYLJR/ PL VLD SHUPHVVR ULQYLDUH DG $1 =$1$5'2/ &DWHFX0 PHQL H QHRILWL H D 0RGHQD DOOD ILQH GHOO·$QWLFR 5HJLPH/ UHOD]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQL0 Wj HEUDLFKH«FLW1 99 51 %21),// *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD QHOO·HSRFD GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ )LUHQ]H 4<<4/ SS1 4;805331 9: /1 $//(*5$/ ,GHQWLWj LQ ELOLFR/ ,O JKHWWR HEUDLFR GL 7RULQR QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ 7RULQR 4<<9> VXO UXR0 OR VRFLDOH GHOOH FRQIUDWHUQLWH= SS1 53<057;1 97
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:<8
DUFKLYLVWLFKH PRGHQHVL/ FURQRORJLFDPHQWH LQLQWHUURWWH +S1 HV1 QHO PDWHULDOH QRWDULOH,/ SHUPHWWRQR XOWHULRUL ULFHUFKH/ YROWH D ULFRVWUXLUH ´GDO EDVVRµ/ DGRW0 WDQGR LO SXQWR GL YLWD GHOOH ELRJUDILH GHL VLQJROL/ TXHVWR SHFXOLDUH SURFHVVR GL ´VHFRODUL]]D]LRQH HEUDLFDµ/ FKH VL VYROJH OXQJR XQ DUFR FURQRORJLFR FRPSUH0 VR WUD OH SULPH HGL]LRQL D VWDPSD GHOOR =RKDU H JOL DQQL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &L0 VDOSLQD/ DQQL GXUDQWH L TXDOL YHUUj HVSOLFLWDPHQWH IRUPXODWD LQ WHUPLQL JLXUL0 GLFL OD ´VILGD GHOO·HJXDJOLDQ]Dµ WUD HEUHL H FULVWLDQL/ SRQHQGR DQFKH OH SUHPHV0 VH SHU OD UL0VFULWWXUD GHOO·LGHQWLWj HEUDLFD9;1 , ULIHULPHQWL DFFHQQDWL VRSUD FRQVHQWRQR GL FROORFDUH TXHVWD LGHQWLWj/ FRPSOHVVD DQFKH QHO JLRFR GHOOH DSSDUWHQHQ]H +VHIDUGLWL9</ VDEEDWLDQL/ LWDOLD0 QL,/ LQ XQR VSD]LR DOWUR ULVSHWWR DOOH GLPHQVLRQL GHOOR 6WDWR UHJLRQDOH1 /·LVWLWX]LRQH FKH/ WUDVFHQGHQGR L OLPLWL GHOOR 6WDWR UHJLRQDOH/ SRVVLHGH OH UL0 VRUVH H QXWUH LQWHUHVVH D FRQWUROODUH JOL HEUHL/ PLQRUDQ]D FKH DIILGD DOOD GL0 VSHUVLRQH JHRJUDILFD OD UHVLVWHQ]D DO ULVFKLR GHOOD GLVSHUVLRQH FXOWXUDOH/ QRQ SXz FKH HVVHUH O·,QTXLVL]LRQH:3= H SURSULR QHJOL DUFKLYL GHO 6DQW·8IIL]LR VL WURYDQR OH IRQWL ILQRUD SULYLOHJLDWH GDOOD ULFHUFD VWRULFD1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD JOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL/ OD ULFHUFD VXL IRQGL GHO 6DQW·8IIL]LR YHQH]LDQR FRQIHUPD TXDQWR VL q HVSRVWR ILQRUD:41 , IRQGL GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH ORFDOH/ FKH DQFKH GDOOD DWWLYLWj GL VRUYHJOLDQ]D GHJOL HEUHL WUDHYD OH SURSULH ULVRUVH ILQDQ]LDULH/ SHUPHWWRQR XQ DOWUR RUGLQH GL FRQVLGHUD]LRQL1 6RWWR O·RFFKLR GHOO·LQTXLVLWRUH FDGHYDQR WXWWH OH LQQXPHUHYROL RFFDVLRQL GL FRQWDWWR WUD HEUHL H FDWWROLFL/ OH FXL LGHQWLWj GRYHYDQR HVVHUH PDQWHQXWH GDOO·LVWLWX]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ GLVWLQWH H VRSUDWWXWWR JHUDUFKLFDPHQ0 WH RUGLQDWH= XQ TXDGUR XWRSLFR PHVVR LQ FULVL GDOOD FRQFUHWD UHDOWj GHOOD YLWD TXRWLGLDQD1 1HOO·$UFKLYLR GHO 6DQW·8IIL]LR GL 0RGHQD/ OH FDVVH GHOOH &DXVDH KHEUHRUXP FRQWHQJRQR OD WUDFFLD GRFXPHQWDULD GHOO·DWWLYLWj PLVVLRQDULD +S1 HV1 OD SXQL]LRQH GL TXHL QHRILWL FKH WHQWDYDQR GL ULWRUQDUH DOO·HEUDLVPR H DL SUR0 SUL IDPLOLDUL, H GHOOH QXPHURVH RFFDVLRQL QHOOH TXDOL HEUHL H FDWWROLFL YHQLYDQR ²²²²²²²² 9; 31 %(51$5',1,/ /D VILGD GHOO·XJXDJOLDQ]D1 *OL HEUHL D 0DQWRYD QHOO·HWj GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH IUDQFH0 VH/ 5RPD 4<<91 9< &XL q VWDWR GHGLFDWR XQ DWWHQWR VWXGLR= $1 ', /(21( /(21,/ /D QD]LRQH HEUDLFD VSDJQROD H SRUWRJKHVH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL1 3HU VHUYLUH DG XQD VWRULD GHOO·HEUDLVPR VHIDUGLWD/ 5LPLQL 4<<51 :3 $1 35263(5,/ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH URPDQD H JOL HEUHL/ LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH H JOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 5RPD0 %DUL 4<<7/ D FXUD GL 01 /8==$77,/ SS1 9:04531 :4 9HGL S1 HV1 LO YLDJJLR D 6DUDMHYR GHO QHRILWD PRGHQHVH &DUOR )UDQFHVFR 5HQDWR DOLDV %XRQDLXWR 3DFLILFL/ D SURSRVLWR GHO TXDOH VRQR LQGDJDWL QHO 49;6 L PDQWRYDQL $EUDPR &DQ0 WRQL H 1DWDQDHO 1RUVD 3URFHVVL GHO 61 8IIL]LR GL 9HQH]LD FRQWUR HEUHL H JLXGDL]]DQWL/ D FXUD GL 31&1 ,2/< =25$77,1,/ ;,,/ 49;504:67/ )LUHQ]H 4<<7/ SS1 6:0:41
:<9
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
D FRQWDWWR/ SULPD H GRSR O·HUH]LRQH GHO JKHWWR1 &RQ XQD FHUWD YLYH]]D/ OH IRQWL DUFKLYLVWLFKH UHVWLWXLVFRQR O·LPPDJLQH GL HEUHL H FULVWLDQL XQLWL GDOOD SDV0 VLRQH SHU LO JLRFR R GL GRQQH FULVWLDQH FKH YDUFDQR L SRUWRQL GHO JKHWWR SHU ODYRUDUH RFFDVLRQDOPHQWH DOOH GLSHQGHQ]H GL HEUHL:51 7UD OH DWWLYLWj GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH FKH JUDYDYDQR OD YLWD GHJOL HEUHL QRQ SRWHYD PDQFDUH LO FRQWUROOR GHL OLEUL1 , QXPHURVL VHTXHVWUL/ PHVVL LQ DWWR QHL SULPL GHFHQQL GHO 6HLFHQWR/ GLHGH0 UR OXRJR DG XQ DPSLR UHLPSLHJR GL PDWHULDOH SDUJDPHQDFHR1 6X TXHVWL IUDPPHQWL 0DXUR 3HUDQL FRQGXFH GD DQQL XQD ULFHUFD SDOHRJUDILFD/ FKH KD JLj QRWHYROPHQWH DUULFFKLWR OH FRQRVFHQ]H VXOOD FXOWXUD GHJOL HEUHL LWDOLDQL H VXO ORUR OLYHOOR GL OLWHUDF\1 *OL DUFKLYL PRGHQHVL FXVWRGLVFRQR XQD TXDQWLWj LPSUHVVLRQDQWH GL WDOL IUDPPHQWL/ SDUL D FLUFD OD PHWj GL WXWWL TXHOOL FHQVLWL LQ ,WDOLD H DO GRSSLR GL TXHOOL ULQYHQXWL QHJOL DOWUL SDHVL HXURSHL:61 ,Q TXHVWD IUHTXHQ]D GL UDSSRUWL QHOOD VIHUD GHOOD TXRWLGLDQLWj q VWDWD YLVWD XQD GHOOH SHFXOLDULWj GHOO·HEUDLVPR LWDOLDQR q VWDWD YLVWD XQD GHOOH SHFXOLDULWj GHOO·HEUDLVPR LWDOLDQR/ H ² IRUVH ² XQR GHL VLQWRPL GHOOD VFRQILWWD GHO SURJHWWR FKH LVSLUDYD OD VHJUHJD]LRQH:71 0D q IRUVH GL VFDUVD XWLOLWj YHULILFDUH TXDQWR OD SHULIHULD VL DGHJXDVVH DOOH GLUHWWLYH SURYHQLHQWL GD XQ FHQWUR/ GRYH LQGXE0 ELDPHQWH TXHVWR SURJHWWR IX D OXQJR FROWLYDWR:81 $SSDUH SL• SURILFXR/ GRSR DYHU ULVWUHWWR OD VFDOD GHOO·DQDOLVL SHU LPSLHJDUH VWUXPHQWL DQWURSRORJLFDPHQWH SL• SURILFXL/ DGRWWDUH OD SURVSHWWLYD SURSULD GHJOL VWXGL GL FXOWXUDO KLVWRU\ SHU LQGLYLGXDUH OH PRGDOLWj FRQ OH TXDOL L JUXSSL HEUDLFL YLVVHUR OD SURSULD FRQGL0 ]LRQH GL LQIHULRULWj JLXULGLFD1 6HQ]D IDU WRUWR DOOH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H LQHUHQWL OD YL0 ²²²²²²²² :5 $1 %,21',/ *OL HEUHL H O·,QTXLVL]LRQH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH H JOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD« FLW1/ SS1 59805;91 :6 01 3(5$1,/ &RQILVFD H FHQVXUD GL OLEUL HEUDLFL D 0RGHQD WUD &LQTXH H 6HLFHQWR LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH H JOL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD 111FLW1/ SS1 5;:0653 H ,'1/ ,O UHLPSLHJR GHL PDQRVFULWWL HEUDLFL1, IUDPPHQWL HEUDLFL VFR0 SHUWL SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR &RPXQDOH GL 0RGHQD HG LO ORUR FRQWULEXWR DOOR VWXGLR GHO JLXGDLVPR/ UHOD0 ]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH«FLW1 :7 $1 /8==$772/ ,QWURGX]LRQH VWRULFD LQ /D WXWHOD GHL EHQL FXOWXUDOL HEUDLFL LQ ,WDOLD/ LQ DWWXD]LRQH GHOO·,QWHVD WUD OR 6WDWR LWDOLDQR H O·8QLRQH GHOOH &RPXQLWj (EUDLFKH/ $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR/ %RORJQD/ < PDU]R 4<<7/ D FXUD GL )1 %21,/$85, H 91 0$8*(5,/ %RORJQD 4<<9 :8 1RQ VL SXz QRQ SHQVDUH D PRQV1 -RKDQQHV 0DULD *IROOQHU FKH/ QHO 4<66/ DOO·LQGRPDQL GHOOD QRPLQD GL +LWOHU D FDQFHOOLHUH GHO 5HLFK/ SHU SUHQGHUH OH GLVWDQ]H GDOO·DQWLVHPLWLVPR QD]LVWD/ VFULYHYD= ´/·HWj PRGHUQD QRQ XVD FDFFLDUH JOL HEUHL GD XQ 3DHVH1 'RYUHEEH WXWWDYLD SUHGLVSRUUH/ DWWUDYHUVR OD OHJLVOD]LRQH H O·RSHUD GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ XQD VROLGD GLJDµ +*1 0,&&2/,/ 6DQWD 6HGH/ TXHVWLRQH HEUDLFD H DQWLVHPLWLVPR IUD 2WWR H 1RYHFHQWR/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD1 $QQDOL ;,1 *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<<9/ W1 ,,/ SS1 469<048:71 /D FLWD]LRQH q D S1 4889,1
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:<:
WD TXRWLGLDQD/ L FRQILQL GHOO·LGHQWLWj SRVVRQR HVVHUH ULQWUDFFLDWL SL• FKH QHOOH PXUD GHL JKHWWL/ DOOD YLWD IDPLOLDUH ULFRUGDWD GD %DOOHWWL= ´VL VWHQWHUHEEH D FUH0 GHUH FKH GXH SRSROL/ QDWL H YLYHQWL QHOOD VWHVVD WHUUD/ FKH GDOOR VWHVVR VXROR H GDOOH VWHVVH LQGXVWULH WUDHYDQR L PH]]L GL YLYHUH/ PDQJLDVVHUR LQ PRGR DIIDWWR GLYHUVRµ:91 7UD L GXH SRSROL/ ´YLYHQWL QHOOD VWHVVD WHUUDµ FRQWLQXDYDQR D VXVVL0 VWHUH OH EDUULHUH JLXULGLFKH VRUWH SHU DFFHOHUDUH OD FRQYHUVLRQH GHJOL HEUHL1 $ TXHVWR ILQH/ D 5RPD/ HUD VWDWR SHQVDWR LO JKHWWR> H SHU UDJJLXQJHUH D 0RGHQD LO PHGHVLPR ILQH QHO ;9,,, VHFROR YHQQH IRQGDWD O·2SHUD SLD GHL FDWHFXPH0 QL1 /XQJL GDOO·DSSDULUH ´PLWH H VFHWWLFRµ LO 6HWWHFHQWR H· LO VHFROR GXUDQWH LO TXDOH O·D]LRQH FRQYHUVLRQLVWLFD VL ID PLUDWD/ OD GHWHUPLQD]LRQH GHL PLVVLRQDUL D UHFLGHUH L OHJDPL IDPLOLDUL GHL FRQYHUWLWL SXz FRQWDUH DQFKH VX XQ QDWXUDOH VDSHUH JLXULGLFR::1 7DOH VDSHUH SRJJLDYD VXOOD DSSDUHQWHPHQWH DQRGLQD FRQ0 VWDWD]LRQH GL XQD HVWUDQHLWj HEUDLFD1 $O &RQJUHVVR &LVSDGDQR GHO 4:<:/ /R0 GRYLFR 5LFFL/ FKH DYHYD SRVWR O·2SHUD 3LD GHO &DWHFXPHQR WUD JOL ´LVWLWXWL GD PDQWHQHUH QHOOR VWDWR SUHVHQWH >SHUFKp@ q RSHUD XWLOH ULWUDUUH JOL XRPLQL GD XQD VRFLHWj FKH ID VWDWR FRQWUR OR 6WDWR/ GDOOD SURIHVVLRQH GL XQD PRUDOH VOHD0 OH DG XQD OHDOHµ:;/ SUHVHQWDYD XQD ´0R]LRQH VRSUD JOL (EUHLµ QHOOD TXDOH VR0 VWHQHYD ´QRQ q HUURU SRSRODUH LO FUHGHUH FKH LO 7DOPXGGR DEELD FRPDQGDWR GL LQJDQQDUH LO FULVWLDQRµ:<1 'DWR LO TXDGUR LGHRORJLFR/ QRQ DSSDUH RSSRUWXQR HQIDWL]]DUH OH QRYLWj LQWURGRWWH GDO &RGLFH SURPXOJDWR QHO 4::4;31 /H QRUPH FKH VL RFFXSDQR GHO0 OD ´TXLHWH H VLFXUH]]Dµ GHJOL HEUHL/ ´WROOHUDWLµ QHJOL 6WDWL SHU FRQFHVVLRQH VR0 YUDQD/ SRVVRQR HVVHUH SXQWR GL SDUWHQ]D SHU ULFHUFKH VXL SHUFRUVL GL HPDQFL0 SD]LRQH GHJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL/ LQ DVVHQ]D GHOOH TXDOL QRQ VL SXz FKH SURFHGH0 UH LQ PDQLHUD LPSUHVVLRQLVWLFD/ ULOHYDQGR DOO·LQWHUQR GHO &RGLFH OD FRQWUDGGLW0 WRULD SUHVHQ]D GL QRUPH FKH SHUPHWWRQR DJOL HEUHL GL IUHTXHQWDUH O·8QLYHUVLWj H GL DOWUH FKH SUHVFULYRQR OD SHUPDQHQ]D GHO JKHWWR ´RYH TXHVWR HVLVWHµ1 $OO·LQWHUQR GHO UHFLQWR PRGHQHVH YLYHYDQR LQ TXHJOL DQQL SL• GL PLOOHFLQTXH0 FHQWR SHUVRQH= QHO 4:;6 OD FRQFHQWUD]LRQH JLXQVH DG XQ SXQWR WDOH FKH (UFR0 ²²²²²²²² :9
$1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL«FLW1/ S1 46:1 0L VLD FRQVHQWLWR ULQYLDUH D $1 =$1$5'2/ 1HRILWL H FDWHFXPHQL D 0RGHQD DOOD ILQH GHOO·$QWLFR 5HJLPH/ UHOD]LRQH SUHVHQWDWD DO &RQYHJQR /H &RPXQLWj HEUDLFKH 111FLW1 :; /1 5,&&,/ 5LIRUPD GHJOL ,VWLWXWL 3LL GHOOD &LWWj GL 0RGHQD/ 0LODQR 4;38/ S1 4<:1 :< /1 5,&&,/ $EER]]R GL PR]LRQH VRSUD JOL (EUHL/ +$5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ $UFKLYLR )DPLJOLD 5LFFL/ E1 75/ YRO1 ,/ S1 434,1 ;3 &RGLFH GL OHJJL H FRVWLWX]LRQL SHU JOL VWDWL GL VXD $OWH]]D VHUHQLVVLPD/ 0RGHQD 4::4/ /1 ,,,/ W1 ,;1 'HJOL HEUHL1 ::
:<;
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
OH ,,, IX FRVWUHWWR DG RUGLQDUH O·DPSOLDPHQWR GHO JKHWWR/ ILQR DG LQFOXGHUYL OH FRQWUDGH OLPLWURIH/ LO FRVLGGHWWR ´PH]]R JKHWWRµ;41 ,Q XQD FRQYHUVD]LRQH FRQ LO JLDFRELQR *LXVHSSH *RUDQL/ (UFROH ,,, HVSULPHYD O·LQWHQ]LRQH GL OLEHUDUH JOL HEUHL GDOO· ´RGLRVD FRQVXHWXGLQHµ GL HVVHUH FRVWUHWWL D SRUWDUH ´XQ PDUFKLR GLVWLQWLYRµ1;5 5LPDVH XQD LQWHQ]LRQH= OD IROOD FKH DELWDYD LO JKHWWR VHJXLWz D SRUWDUH VXO FDSSHOOR XQ QDVWUR JLDOOR R DUDQFLR/ GD FXL DOFXQL IDQQR GLVFHQGH0 UH O·HVSUHVVLRQH VSUHJLDWLYD GLDOHWWDOH ´WHVWD UDQ]Dµ;61 $OOD VWRULRJUDILD VRQR QRWH ILJXUH FRPH 0RLVq )RUPLJJLQL= QHO 4:<9/ JUD0 ]LH DL EXRQL XIILFL GL TXHVWR EDQFKLHUH/ OD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD ULPDVH LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ LO 'XFD/ IXJJLWR D 9HQH]LD/ H ULXVFu D SDJDUH DL )UDQFHVL LO GHELWR GL JXHUUD;71 ,Q VHJXLWR/ FRPH q QRWR/ )RUPLJJLQL VDUHEEH VWDWR HOHWWR GHSXWD0 WR GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD DO &RQJUHVVR GL 5HJJLR;81 8Q JKHWWR DIIROODWR GL ULFFKL EDQFKLHUL/ FRUULVSRQGH DG XQD LQHVDWWH]]D/ QHOOD TXDOH LQGXOJH WURSSR VRYHQWH OD VWRULRJUDILD1 /D JUDQ SDUWH GHJOL HEUHL PRGHQHVL FRQGLYLGHYD LO SURSULR VSD]LR DELWDWLYR FRQ RJQL VRUWD GL SROODPH/ FRPH DWWHVWDQR OH FDUWH GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR GHOOD &RPXQLWj (EUDLFD;9 H GL0 YHUVH LQGLFD]LRQL WRSRJUDILFKH/ S1 HV1 UHODWLYH DG XQ OXRJR/ ´YXOJDULWHU GHQR0 PLQDWR 3LD]]HWWD GHOO·2FKH SHUFKp LYL JOL (EUHL QH IDFHYDQR PHUFDWRµ;:1 %HU0 QDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL/ GHGLFDQGR XQ FDSLWROR GHOOD VXD RSHUD DOOH ´PDODWWLH GH0 JOL (EUHLµ/ QH ULQWUDFFLDYD O·RULJLQH QHOOH SURIHVVLRQL FXL VL GHGLFDYDQR= UDP0 PHQGDWULFL OH GRQQH/ FKH ´FRQ O·DQGDUH GHO WHPSR VRIIURQR G·LQGHEROLPHQWR GHOOD YLVWDµ> JOL XRPLQL/ LQ SUHYDOHQ]D ´DOPHQR LQ ,WDOLDµ/ VWUDFFLYHQGROL H PD0 WHUDVVDL FKH/ QHO FRUVR GHO ORUR ODYRUR/ ´LQJRLDQR JUDQ TXDQWLWj GL SROYHUH FKH SURGXFH JUDYL GLVWXUEL1 $ FDXVD GL TXHVWR ODYRUR VL DPPDODQR GL DVPD/ QDX0 VHD H YHUWLJLQL >«@ 6L DJJLXQJD FKH JOL HEUHL VRQR UHOHJDWL LQ YLFROL VWUHWWL/ H PHQWUH ODYRUDQR VWDQQR FRQ OH ILQHVWUH DSHUWH SHU ULFHYHUH OD OXFH> GD FLz GH0 ²²²²²²²² ;4 ;5
*1 6,/,1*$5', 0 $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL 111FLW1/ S1 4381 *1 *25$1,/ /·,WDOLD QHO ;9,,, VHFROR/ 9,/ 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ 0RGHQD 4<;:/ S1
941 ;6
*1 6,/,1*$5',/ $1 %$5%,(5,/ (EUHL 111FLW1/ S1 4341 $1 %,21',/ &RPH XQD SUHID]LRQH= 0RGHQD QHO 4:<9/ LQ )RUPD]LRQH H FRQWUROOR GHOO·RSLQLRQH SXE0 EOLFD D 0RGHQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR D FXUD GL $1 %,21',/ 0RGHQD 4<;9/ SS1 <0551 ;8 &1 =$*+,/ /·,WDOLD GL 1DSROHRQH GDOOD &LVDOSLQD DO 5HJQR/ 7RULQR 4<;9 ;9 $5&+,9,2 6725,&2 '(//$ &2081,7- (%5$,&$ ', 02'(1$/ )LO]D 89/ 3ROL]]H HG RU0 GLQH GL GLYHUVL VRYUDQL1 ;: /1 9$/'5,*+,/ $SSHQGLFL H QRWH DO 'L]LRQDULR VWRULFR0HWLPRORJLFR GHOOH FRQWUDGH H VSD]LL SXEEOLFL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4;;6/ S1 4591 ;7
*OL HEUHL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
:<<
ULYDQR YDUL GLVWXUELµ;;1 3RFKL GHFHQQL GRSR O·XVDQ]D GL UHOHJDUH JOL HEUHL LQ YLFROL VWUHWWL ULFHYHWWH LO SODXVR GL 0XUDWRUL= ´+DQQR OH VDJJH &LWWj GD XVDUH XQD VWUDRUGLQDULD GLOLJHQ]D SHU JOL (EUHL/ 1D]LRQH G·RUGLQDULR DELWDQWH DVVDL VSRUFDPHQWHµ;<1 /D IUDVH GL 0XUDWRUL/ q VSLD GL XQD LQWHUD HYROX]LRQH/ DWWHVWD LO SDVVDJJLR GDOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH IUDQFHVFDQD DOOD VHJUHJD]LRQH= OH FRQGL]LRQL GL YLWD GHJOL HEUHL QRQ VRQR SL• HIIHWWR GHOOD ´VWUHWWH]]Dµ GHL YLFROL/ PD DELWXGLQH FRQQD0 WXUDWD1 ,Q TXHVWR FRDFHUYR GL SUHJLXGL]L H GLVFULPLQD]LRQL/ GL RULJLQH VFKLHW0 WDPHQWH HFFOHVLDVWLFD H YDULDPHQWH LPSLHJDWR SHU RWWHQHUH OD FRQYHUVLRQH GH0 JOL HEUHL/ WURYHUDQQR DSSRJJLR OH GRWWULQH UD]]LVWH1 1HOO·$SULOH GHO 4:<9 LO &RPLWDWR GL *RYHUQR SHUPHWWHYD DJOL HEUHL GL UHVWDUH IXRUL GDO UHFLQWR GX0 UDQWH OD 6HWWLPDQD 6DQWD> SHU DYHU GHWWR ´$EELDPR YLQWRµ/ XQ HEUHR YHQQH DJJUHGLWR GD DOFXQL ´IDFFKLQLµ1 , SRUWRQL GHO JKHWWR YHQQHUR WROWL LO 4; OXJOLR 4:<9<3= JOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL DYUHEEHUR YLVWR/ QHO 4;47/ XQD XOWHULRUH VHJUHJD0 ]LRQH DG RSHUD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9<4/ O·8QLWj G·,WDOLD FRQ LO GHILQLWLYR DIIUDQFD0 PHQWR/ O·DEEDWWLPHQWR GHO JKHWWR H OD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD VRQWXRVD VLQDJRJD<51 7DSSH GL XQD FURQRORJLD FKH QRQ SXz QRQ FRPSUHQGHUH DQFKH OH OHJJL UD]]L0 VWH GHO 4<6;/ FKH SURSULR D 0RGHQD HEEHUR XQD GHOOH YLWWLPH SL• QRWH/ $QJH0 OR )RUWXQDWR )RUPLJJLQL<61 8QD VFDQVLRQH QRWD/ FKH ULJXDUGD LQ JUDQ SDUWH XQ DUFR FURQRORJLFR OXQJR LO TXDOH 0RGHQD QRQ q SL• FDSLWDOH> QHOOH VXFFHV0 VLYH ULFHUFKH OD SRVL]LRQH SHULIHULFD SXz ULYHODUVL XQ SXQWR GL RVVHUYD]LRQH SULYLOHJLDWR SHU OR VWXGLR GL WXWWD XQD VHULH GL IHQRPHQL ILQRUD LQ RPEUD= GDO IHQRPHQR GHOOH FRQYHUVLRQL DOO·HEUDLVPR QHOO·,WDOLD GHO SULPR 1RYHFHQWR<7 DL SHUFRUVL GL SURPR]LRQH VRFLDOH/ QRWL ILQRUD VRSUDWWXWWR SHU LO WUDPLWH GL WH0 ²²²²²²²² ;;
%1 5$0$==,1,/ 'H PRUELV DUWLILFXP GLDWULED/ 3DGRYD 4:46> WUDG1 LW1 0LODQR 4<;5/ SS1 4850
4871 ;<
/1 $1 085$725,/ /L WUH JRYHUQL SROLWLFR/ PHGLFR/ HG HFFOHVLDVWLFR XWLOLVVLPL DQ]L QHFHVVDUM LQ WHPSR GL SHVWH +«,/ /XFFD 4:76/ S1 9:1 <3 0RGHQD QDSROHRQLFD QHOOD &URQDFD GL $QWRQLR 5RYDWWL/ D FXUD GL *131 %5,==,/ 0RGHQD/ 4<;< SS1 4:7 H 5341 <4 $1 %$//(77,/ *OL (EUHL H JOL (VWHQVL 111FLW1/ SS1 56405751 <5 *1 %(578==,/ 7UDVIRUPD]LRQL HGLOL]LH H XUEDQLVWLFKH D 0RGHQD WUD 2WWRFHQWR H 1RYHFHQWR/ 0R0 GHQD/ 4<:5/ S1 68 6V1 <6 $QJHOR )RUWXQDWR )RUPLJJLQL XQ HGLWRUH GHO 1RYHFHQWR/ D FXUD GL /1 %$/6$02 H 51 &5(0$17(/ %RORJQD 4<;51 <7 71 &$7$/$1/ /H FRPXQLWj HEUDLFKH GDOO·8QLWj DOOD SULPD JXHUUD PRQGLDOH/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD1 $QQDOL ;,1 *OL HEUHL LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<<9/ W1 ,,/ SS1 4576045<31 ,O IHQRPHQR q VHJQDODWR D S1 45;71
;33
$QGUHD =DQDUGR
VWLPRQLDQ]H DXWRELRJUDILFKH= ´1RQQR &HOHVWLQR QHOOD YLWD VL HUD IDWWR VWUDGD FRQ JUDQGH HQHUJLD1 &RPLQFLDQGR FRPH XQ RUIDQHOOR DLXWDWR GDOOD &RPXQLWj/ YHQGLWRUH DPEXODQWH FRQ XQD FDVVHWWLQD DSSHVD VXO SHWWR H ULWLUDQGRVL/ DQFRUD QRQ YHFFKLR/ FHGHQGR XQR GHL PLJOLRUL H SL• DYYLDWL QHJR]L GL DEELJOLDPHQWR PDVFKLOH GL 0RGHQD« µ<8
²²²²²²²² <8
)1 /(9,/ , JLRUQL GHOO·HUED DPDUD/ *HQRYD 4<<3/ S1 641
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;34
/$85$ 785&+,
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD +JHQHDORJLH HVWHQVL/ VHFF1 ;90;9,,,
´'DOOH SDUHWL SHQGHYDQR ULWUDWWL GHL VXRL DQWHQDWL H XQD SDUWH GHL PRELOL ULVDOLYD DQFRUD DO ORUR WHPSR= O·DELWDWRUH GHOOD VWDQ]D DYHYD IRUPDWR LO VXR XRYR QHO JXVFLR GHOOD ORUR YLWD111µ +51 086,// /·XRPR VHQ]D TXDOLWj,
5LIOHVVLRQL SUHOLPLQDUL 6ROR GL UHFHQWH OH JHQHDORJLH VRQR VWDWH ULSURSRVWH DOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GHJOL VWRULFL H/ FLz FKH SL• FRQWD/ SURSULR SHU LO ORUR FRQWHQXWR ¶LQFUHGLELOH·= YDOH D GLUH/ SHU TXHOO·LQDELVVDUVL LQ HSRFKH UHPRWH TXDQWR QHEXORVH/ DOOR VFRSR GL FHUWLILFDUH O·DQWLFKLWj H GXQTXH OD QRELOWj GHL FDVDWL1 /D SUHVXSSRVL]LRQH GL FRQWLQXLWj IUD SDVVDWR H SUHVHQWH H O·LGHQWLILFD]LRQH IUD PHPRULD JHQWLOL]LD H WUDGLWLR VWRULFD FKH L JHQHDORJLVWL HUHGLWDURQR GDOOD VWRULRJUDILD JUHFR0URPDQD QRQ VL OLPLWDURQR WXWWDYLD D UHQGHU SRVVLELOL WHPHUDUL YLDJJL D ULWURVR QHL VH0 FROL H QHL PLOOHQQL41 (VVH TXDOLILFDURQR DQFKH TXHVWR JHQHUH VWRULRJUDILFR FRPH XQ DIILODWR VWUXPHQWR GL OHJLWWLPD]LRQH SROLWLFD H UHOLJLRVD/ TXDQGR QRQ DGGLULWWXUD GL EDWWDJOLD JLXGL]LDULD/ LQ FRQWHVWL VRFLR0SROLWLFL SHUDOWUR DVVDL GLI0 ²²²²²²²² 5LQJUD]LR VLQFHUDPHQWH $UPDQGR 3HWUXFFL SHU O*DLXWR H OH LQGLFD]LRQL GL ODYRUR GDWLPL HG 2WWDYLD 1LFFROL SHU L FRQVLJOL GL ULFHUFD1 -DQH )DLU %HVWRU KD OHWWR XQD SULPD YHUVLRQH GL TXH0 VWR WHVWR HG KD IDWWR PROWH XWLOL RVVHUYD]LRQL H GDWR VXJJHULPHQWL1 6RQR JUDWD DQFKH DG $QQD0 OLVD %DWWLQL/ 0DULR %HUWRQL/ )UDQFD *DOOLQD/ 0LOHQD 5LFFL H 5LFFDUGR 9DFFDUL SHU DYHU PHVVR D PLD GLVSRVL]LRQH OH ORUR FRPSHWHQ]H1 4 6XOOH JHQHDORJLH H OH ORUR ILQDOLWj/ 51 %,==2&&+,/ )DPLOLDH URPDQDH DQWLFKH H PRGHUQH/ LQ ©5LYLVWD VWRULFD LWDOLDQDª/ &,,, +4<<4,/ ,,/ SS1 6880<:> ,'1/ /D FXOWXUH JpQpDORJLTXH GDQV O*,WDOLH GX VHL]LqPH VLqFOH/ LQ ©$QQDOHV (161&1ª/ 79 +4<<4,/ 7/ SS1 :;<0;38> ,'1/ *HQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL1 6FULWWL GL VWRULD QHOO*(XURSD PRGHUQD/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<<81
;35
/DXUD 7XUFKL
IHUHQ]LDWL51 /D FRQVWDWD]LRQH GHOOD YDULHWj GL VRJJHWWL SURGXWWRUL H GL VFRSL DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ JHQHUH VWRULRJUDILFR FKH KD WXWWDYLD FDUDWWHULVWLFKH HSLVWHPRORJLFKH EHQ SUHFLVH SHUPHWWH GL ULIOHWWHUH VX XQ·LSRWHVL IRUPXODWD FRPSLXWDPHQWH DOFXQL DQQL ID GD *LDQQD 3RPDWD/ RVVLD FKH SHU OD VWRULD SROLWLFD 0 RULJLQDULDPHQWH LQ EXRQD SDUWH VWRULD GLQDVWLFD 0 OH JHQHDORJLH DYUHEEHUR FRVWLWXLWR OD PHWDIR0 UD FHQWUDOH HG LO FULWHULR RUGLQDWRUH GHOOD QDUUD]LRQH1 $OOD EDVH GHOO·HVFOXVLRQH IHPPLQLOH GDOOD VFULWWXUD GL VWRULD G·LPSLHJR SL• LPPHGLDWDPHQWH SXEEOLFR VWDUHEEH FLRp XQ·XQLODWHUDOH FRUULVSRQGHQ]D IUD OLJQDJJL DJQDWL]L H JHQHDOR0 JLH/ DWWD D VSLHJDUH DQFKH OH HYHQWXDOL YDULD]LRQL D TXHVWR PRGHOOR FRPH UL0 IOHVVL GHOOD VWUXWWXUD SDUHQWDOH SL• R PHQR SDWULOLQHDUH R ELODWHUDOH GHL VRJJHW0 WL SURGXWWRUL61 /D PROWHSOLFLWj GL VRJJHWWL H FRQWHVWL GL XWLOL]]R GHOOH JHQHDOR0 JLH QRQ q LO VROR HOHPHQWR FKH LQGXFD D ULSHQVDUH OD WHVL GL 3RPDWD1 &UHGLD0 PR FKH XQD SLHQD FRPSUHQVLRQH GL WDOL VFULWWL VL VRVWDQ]L LQIDWWL QHOOD YHULILFD SHU LO PHGHVLPR VRJJHWWR SURGXWWRUH GHOOH UHFLSURFKH/ PXWHYROL LQIOXHQ]H IUD RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOD SDUHQWHOD/ PRGDOLWj VXFFHVVRULH HG HGLILFD]LRQH GHOOD PHPRULD1 1HO FRUVR GHOOH SDJLQH VXFFHVVLYH/ WHQWHUHPR DSSXQWR GL YHULILFDUH JOL LQWUHFFL IUD TXHVWH YDULDELOL LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOD WHPDWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH/ FRVu ULFFD G·LPSOLFD]LRQL SHU OD PHPRULD IHPPLQLOH/ VLD SHU PRVWUDUQH OD GXUDWXUD YLWDOLWj DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ FRUSXV JHQHDORJLFR DVVXQWR FRPH RJJHWWR GL VWXGLR/ VLD SHU LOOXPLQDUH XQ FDVR GL FRQVDSHYROH XWLOL]]R GL TXHVWR JHQHUH VWRULRJUD0 ILFR GD SDUWH GL XQD GXFKHVVD UHJJHQWH1 /D JHQHDORJLD FRPPLVVLRQDWD GD /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO ;9,, VHFROR FRVWLWXLVFH LQIDWWL LO SXQWR G·DUULYR G·XQD OXQJD H FRQWUDGGLWWRULD WUDGL]LRQH PDWULPRQLDOH QHOOH JHQHDORJLH HVWHQVL1 3HU GDUH FRUSR DOOD QRVWUD DQDOLVL/ GRYUHPR DOPHQR DF0 FHQQDUH DO UXROR FHQWUDOH PD DPELJXR ULYHVWLWR GDL PDWULPRQL QHOOH PRGDOLWj VXFFHVVRULH GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH/ QRQFKp DOOD ORUR RULJLQDULD XWLOLWj SHU OD FR0 VWUX]LRQH G·XQ GRPLQLR SROLWLFR1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OD YDULDELOH JHQHDORJL0 FD/ GXH VRQR HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH OH ILQDOLWj SURSULH GL TXHVWR JHQHUH GL VFULWWL LQ HWj WDUGRPHGLRHYDOH H PRGHUQD= PRVWUDUH FKH OD JHUDUFKLD VRFLR0SROLWLFD VL IRQGD VX EDVL ILVLRORJLFKH H FKH OD YLUW•/ FRPH JLj SHU JUHFL H SHU L URPDQL/ q ²²²²²²²² 5
$1 02/+2/ *HQHDORJLD H SDUHQWDGR1 0HPRULH GHO SRWHUH QHOOD )LUHQ]H WDUGR PHGLHYDOH1 ,O FDVR GL *LRYDQQL 5XFHOODL/ LQ ©4XDGHUQL VWRULFLª[G*RUD LQ SRL 46]/ ;;,; +4<<7,/ ;9/ SS1 6960736> &1 ./$3,6&+0=8%(5/ $OEHUR JHQHDORJLFR H FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD SDUHQWHOD QHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ LQ LELG1/ 738053> 01 %(//$%$5%$/ 5DFFRQWL IDPLOLDUL= 6FULWWL GL 7RPPDVR 7DEDUHOOL GH )DWLV H DOWUH VWRULH GL QRELOL FLQ0 TXHFHQWHVFKL/ 7UHQWR/ 6RFLHWj GL VWXGL WUHQWLQL GL VFLHQ]H VWRULFKH/ 4<<:1 6 *1 320$7$/ 6WRULD SDUWLFRODUH H VWRULD XQLYHUVDOH= LQ PDUJLQH DG DOFXQL PDQXDOL GL VWRULD GHOOH GRQ0 QH/ LQ 46/ ;;9 +4<<3,/ :7/ SS1 67406;8/ VSHFLH DOOH SS1 68<06951
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;36
XQ IDWWR HUHGLWDULR1 1H FRQVHJXH FKH LO VDQJXH PDWHUQR FRQFRUUH LQ FHUWD PL0 VXUD D TXDOLILFDUH O·HOHYDWH]]D PRUDOH HG LO UDQJR VRFLDOH GHL GLVFHQGHQWL= OR FRQIHUPDQR OH FRQWUDGGLWWRULH WHRULH SURFUHDWLYH PHGLRHYDOL/ SHU OH TXDOL OH GRQQH VYROJRQR XQ UXROR SDVVLYR QHOOD SURFUHD]LRQH/ PD WUDVPHWWRQR DO IL0 JOLR SDUWH GHL FDUDWWHUL HUHGLWDUL DWWUDYHUVR OD SURSULD PDWHULD VHPLQDOH G·RULJLQH VDQJXLJQD71 /D FUHGLELOLWj GL TXHVWL DVVXQWL VL UDGLFD LQ XQD SUDVVL VWRULRJUDILFD FKH LQVWDXUD XQ UDSSRUWR PLPHWLFR FRQ OH HSRFKH WUDVFRUVH H WUDVIRUPD LO OHWWRUH QHO WHVWLPRQH RFXODUH G·XQ SDVVDWR YLYLGR H SDUODQWH= FD0 UDWWHULVWLFKH FKH OD VWRULRJUDILD GHOO·HWj GL PH]]R HUHGLWz QHO VXR FRPSOHVVR GD TXHOOD DQWLFD/ PD FKH VL IHFHUR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH SUHVHQWL QHOOH JHQHDORJLH/ WRUQDWH LQ JUDQ YRJD QHO ;9 VHFROR/ TXDQGR L FODVVLFL DVVXUVHUR D PRGHOOR GL SHQVLHUR81 $ TXHVWR SURSRVLWR/ SURSULR OD JHQHDORJLD PDUWLQR]]LDQD SXz LQ0 GXUUH DG LSRWL]]DUH XQD GLVFUDVLD IUD LO ULGLPHQVLRQDPHQWR GHOO·XWLOLWj SROLWL0 FR0GLSORPDWLFD GHL PDWULPRQL SHU OD FDVDWD SULQFLSHVFD H OD ORUR UHYLYLVFHQ]D QHOOD PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD GXFDOH/ JUD]LH DOOH JLj FLWDWH SHFXOLDULWj GHO JHQHUH VWRULRJUDILFR1 /D FRLQFLGHQ]D WHPSRUDOH IUD OD ILQH GL XQD YHUD PHPRULD PD0 WULPRQLDOH QHJOL VFULWWL JHQHDORJLFL HVWHQVL H O·LUULPHGLDELOH GHFDGHQ]D GHOOH JHQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL FL SRUWHUj LQILQH D SURSRUUH XQD SRVVLELOH/ GLYHUVD FUR0 QRORJLD GHOOD VFRPSDUVD GHOOH GRQQH GDOOD VWRULD SROLWLFD1 *HQHDORJLH H PDWULPRQL HVWHQVL= SULPL FRQWUDVWL ,Q TXHVWR FRQWULEXWR FL RFFXSHUHPR GL GXH JHQHUL GL JHQHDORJLH VFULWWH IUD O·XOWLPR TXDUWR GHO ;9 VHFROR H OD ILQH GHO ;9,,/ RVVLD GHOOH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL JUDILFKH PXQLWH G·XQ FRPPHQWR QDUUDWLYR SL• R PHQR DPSLR H GHOOH JHQHD0 ORJLH LQ SURVD/ LQVHULWH LQ FURQDFKH RSSXUH DXWRQRPH1 1RQ DQDOL]]HUHPR LQ0 YHFH OH JHQHDORJLH LQVHULWH LQ RUD]LRQL IXQHEUL/ WRFFDQGR VROR GL VIXJJLWD LO UDSSRUWR IUD TXHVWL GXH JHQHUL OHWWHUDUL/ Qq FL VRIIHUPHUHPR VX TXHOOH LQVHULWH LQ RSHUH SRHWLFKH/ VH QRQ SHU PRVWUDUQH DOFXQL FROOHJDPHQWL UHODWLYL DO QRVWUR WHPD FRQ OH JHQHDORJLH DQDOL]]DWH1 /D UDJLRQH GL TXHVWD VFHOWD VWD LQ TXHO UDS0 SRUWR PLPHWLFR FRO SDVVDWR FKH F·LQWHUHVVD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH= O·HVHPSODULWj GHOOH VWRULH FKH OH JHQHDORJLH QDUUDQR VL WUDGXFH QDWXUDOPHQWH LQ LPPDJLQL ²²²²²²²² 7 -1 )1 %(6725/ 7HRULH SURFUHDWLYH H ORUR LQIOXHQ]D VXO FRQFHWWR GL SDUHQWHOD QHOO*$QWLFKLWj H QHO 0H0 GLRHYR/ LQ /D IDPLJOLD LQ ,WDOLD GDOO*DQWLFKLWj DO ;; VHFROR/ D FXUD GL '1 .(57=(505131 6$//(5/ )LUHQ]H/ /H /HWWHUH/ 4<<8/ SS1 49<04;;1 &IU1 QRWD +4,1 8 )1 0(1$17/ /*DOWUD VWRULRJUDILD/ LQ 46/ ;;;,,, +4<<;,/ <:/ SS1 54:05591
;37
/DXUD 7XUFKL
SHQVDWH SHU HVVHUH IUXLWH LQVLHPH DL WHVWL1 $OO·LQWHUQR G·XQD JDPPD GL IRQWL SDUWLFRODUPHQWH YDVWD LQGXJHUHPR SRL QRQ VROR VXOOH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL VWR0 ULRJUDILFKH GHOOD FRQQHVVLRQH IUD PDWULPRQL/ VXFFHVVLRQH H VWUXWWXUD SDUHQWD0 OH/ PD DQFKH VX DOFXQH GHOOH SL• OHJDWH DG XQD PHPRULD FODVVLILFDWD FRPH SD0 WULOLQHDUH1 &RPSOHVVLYDPHQWH/ OH JHQHDORJLH GHL VLJQRUL GL )HUUDUD PRVWUDQR FRQQR0 WDWL GLVWLQWLYL SHU SL• G·XQD UDJLRQH= VH WHVWLPRQLDQR HFOHWWLVPR FRQWHQXWLVWL0 FR H FRQVLGHUHYROH DGDWWDELOLWj ULVSHWWR DOOH HVLJHQ]H VXFFHVVRULH GHOOD IDPL0 JOLD/ q SXU YHUR FKH/ HVVHQGR OH ORUR YDOHQ]H SROLWLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOL SL• DPSLH H GLUHWWH GL TXHOOH YHULILFDELOL SHU OH JHQHDORJLH GHL SDWUL]LDWL FLWWDGLQL/ QRQ YL VL SXz ULWURYDUH TXHOO·´LQFHVVDQWH ULDGDWWDPHQWR SURVSHWWLFRµ D SDUWLUH GDOO·HJR GL FKL VFULYH9/ RVVHUYDWR DG HVHPSLR SHU JOL VFULWWL JHQHDORJLFL GHL PHUFDQWL ILRUHQWLQL1 /D FRVWDQWH LGHQWLILFD]LRQH FKH SURSRQJRQR IUD VWRULD GHOOD FDSLWD0 OH H VWRULD GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH ID LQWUDYYHGHUH TXDQWR OD JHQWLOL]LD ´SUHVXS0 SRVL]LRQH GL FRQWLQXLWjµ IUD IDPLJOLD/ FLWWj H WHUULWRULR: SRVVD SURYRFDUH HIIHW0 WL VSHFLILFL H GL YDVWD SRUWDWD SHU OD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH WHRULFD G·XQD SUDVVL GL JR0 YHUQR1 /HJLWWLPDQGR L FDPELDPHQWL DYYHQXWL QHL PRGXOL GL WUDVPLVVLRQH VXF0 FHVVRULD H ULFDPELR JHQHUD]LRQDOH GHOOD IDPLJOLD VLJQRULOH/ OD VFULWWXUD JHQHD0 ORJLFD HEEH LQIDWWL SDUWH QHOOD FUHD]LRQH GL XQ·LGHRORJLD SROLWLFD FRQ GHL FRQ0 QRWDWL SUHFLVL/ LO FKH q SDUWLFRODUPHQWH YHUR SHU OD WHPDWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH1 1DWXUDOPHQWH/ FLz QRQ VLJQLILFD FKH O·LPSRUWDQ]D DWWULEXLWD DOOH DOOHDQ]H QX0 ]LDOL QHOOD SUDVVL H QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD YDORUL]]L GL QHFHVVLWj OD PH0 PRULD GHOOH PRJOL1 9HGUHPR DQ]L FRPH SURSULR O·HQIDVL VWRULRJUDILFD VX DOFX0 QH QR]]H SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LOOXVWUL IRVVH SDUWH GL XQ SURFHVVR GL ULPRGHOODPHQ0 WR GHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH H GHOOD VWUXWWXUD GHOOD SDUHQWHOD QHO FDVDWR1 6LJQLILFD WXW0 WDYLD FKH OD FRVFLHQ]D GHOOD ORUR XWLOLWj ULPDVH IRUWH SHU XQ OXQJR SHULRGR/ FKH D GLVSHWWR GL IRUWL IUDWWXUH LSRWL]]LDPR HVWHQGHUVL IUD ;9 H ;9,, VHFROR1 $OOH RULJLQL GL TXHOO·XWLOLWj/ Y·q XQD FDUDWWHULVWLFD EDVLODUH GHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH HVWHQVH= SHU TXDVL FHQWRFLQTXDQW·DQQL D )HUUDUD OD WUDVPLVVLRQH GHO SDWULPR0 QLR H GHO WLWROR GL VLJQRUL DYYHQQH SULQFLSDOPHQWH IUD IUDWHOOL/ OHJLWWLPL R PH0 QR1 6ROR QHOO·HWj GL (UFROH , +47:404838, VL DIIHUPz GHILQLWLYDPHQWH LO SULQFL0 SLR FKH LO WLWROR GRYHVVH VSHWWDUH DO SULPRJHQLWR OHJLWWLPR/ WUDVIRUPDQGR OH GLVFHQGHQ]H GHL IUDWHOOL LQ OLQHH FDGHWWH D WXWWL JOL HIIHWWL/ VHQ]D SHUz DUULYDUH D GLYLGHUH LO GRPLQLR1 ,Q HQWUDPEL JOL HOHPHQWL TXDOLILFDQWL GL TXHVWD VFHOWD/ VL ULWURYD LO UXROR GHFLVLYR JLRFDWR GDO PDWULPRQLR GL (UFROH , FRQ XQD SULQFL0 ²²²²²²²² 9 :
$1 02/+2 / *HQHDORJLD H SDUHQWDGR111 FLW1/ S1 6;<1 51 %,==2&&+,/ *HQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL111 FLW1/ S1 54;1
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;38
SHVVD GL VDQJXH UHDOH= (OHRQRUD G·$UDJRQD +47:6,;1 $QFKH SULPD GHO 47:6/ SHUz/ OH DOOHDQ]H PDWULPRQLDOL DYHYDQR ULYHVWLWR XQ·LPSRUWDQ]D QRWHYROH QHO0 OD VWRULD GHOOD IDPLJOLD H GHO GRPLQLR1 /H QR]]H FRQ PRJOL LOOXVWUL FRVWLWXLURQR LQIDWWL O·XOWLPD YDULDQWH GL VWUDWHJLH PDWULPRQLDOL HVRJDPLFKH ILQDOL]]DWH DO SURFHVVR GL WHUULWRULDOL]]D]LRQH H GL DIIHUPD]LRQH GL XQ·DOWD VXSHULRULWj VXL SULQFLSDWL SDGDQL PLQRUL/ VRSUDWWXWWR GDOO·HSRFD GL 1LFFROz ,,, +46<604774,<1 /·XVR FKH FRPH WXWWL L VLJQRUL LWDOLDQL JOL (VWH IHFHUR GHOOH DOOHDQ]H PDWULPR0 QLDOL D GLIHVD GHOO·HTXLOLEULR VDQFLWR GDOOD SDFH GL /RGL GLPRVWUD LQILQH XQD YROWD GL SL• TXDQWR IRVVH VWDWD SURIRQGDPHQWH DVVRUELWD QHOO·,WDOLD GHO 4XDW0 WURFHQWR O·DQWLFD LGHD URPDQD GHO PDWULPRQLR FRPH VHPLQDULXP FLYLWDWLV431 1RQ VL SXz QHPPHQR GLPHQWLFDUH FKH SHU TXDVL XQ VHFROR 0 ILQR DOOH QR]]H GL $O0 IRQVR ,, FRQ %DUEDUD G·$VEXUJR QHO 4898 0 OH PRJOL GHL GXFKL G·(VWH DSSDU0 WHQQHUR LQ JUDQ SDUWH D OLJQDJJL SL• HOHYDWL GL TXHOOR GHL PDULWL1 ,Q TXHO VHFROR VL YHULILFDURQR WXWWDYLD HYHQWL TXDVL HVL]LDOL SHU OD VRSUDYYLYHQ]D VWHVVD GHO GRPLQLR= OH JXHUUH G·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´GH PDQ LQ PDQµ TXDQWR DYYHQLYD/ VHQ]D SRWHUQH SUHYHGHUH O·HVLWR441 /D GLVWUX]LRQH GHOO·HTXLOLEULR LWDOLDQR VL DVVRPPz SHUDOWUR DOOD SURIRQGD FULVL FKH QHJOL XOWLPL GHFHQQL GHO 4XDWWURFHQWR DYHYD FROSLWR DOFXQL GHL SL• LPSRUWDQWL SDUWQHUV PDWULPRQLDOL GHJOL (VWH H GHO ORUR VHJXLWR/ D SDUWLUH GDL SLFFROL VLJQRUL SDGDQL/ FKH QRQ DYHYDQR RSWDWR SHU OD SULPRJHQLWXUD Qp SHU ²²²²²²²² ;-1 )1 %(6725/ %DVWDUG\ DQG /HJLWLPDF\ LQ WKH )RUPDWLRQ RI D 5HJLRQDO 6WDWH LQ ,WDO\= WKH (VWHQVH 6XFFHVVLRQ/ LQ ©&RPSDUDWLYH 6WXGLHV LQ 6RFLHW\ DQG +LVWRU\ª/ 6; +4<<9,/ 6/ SS1 87<08;81 < 71 '($1/ 7HUUD H SRWHUH D )HUUDUD QHO WDUGR 0HGLRHYR1 ,O GRPLQLR HVWHQVH= 468304783/ 0RGHQD0 )HUUDUD/ 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFH PRGHQHVL/ 4<<3/ SS1 48:04:7/ /1 )$%%5,/ 'D )LUHQ]H D )HUUDUD= JOL 6WUR]]L WUD &DVD G*(VWH H DQWLFKL OHJDPL GL VDQJXH/ LQ $OOD FRUWH GHJOL (VWHQVL1 )LORVRILD/ DUWH H FXOWXUD D )HUUDUD QHL VHFROL ;9 H ;9,/ D FXUD GL 01 %(572==,/ )HUUD0 UD/ 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL VWXGL GL )HUUDUD/ 4<<7/ SS1 <4043;1 43 '1 2:(1 +8*+(6/ ,O PDWULPRQLR QHOO*,WDOLD PHGLHYDOH/ LQ 6WRULD GHO PDWULPRQLR/ D FXUD GL 01 '( *,25*,20&+1 ./$3,6&+0=8%(5/ 5RPD0%DUL/ /DWHU]D/ 4<<9/ SS1 80941 44 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$ +G*RUD LQ SRL $602,/ &DVD H 6WDWR/ *HQHDORJLH/ VWRULH H QRWL]LH JHQHUDOL G*RUD LQ SRL *61/ E1 93/ &URQDFD GHOOD FDVD G*(VWH 45340485;/ F1 488 H SHU HVHPSL DQDORJKL FF1 43<0443/ 464> FIU1 0HPRULH VWRULFKH H JHQHDORJLFKH GHJOL (VWHQVL GD $OEHUWR $]]R +43<8, DG (UFROH ,,1
;39
/DXUD 7XUFKL
OD OHJLWWLPLWj/ FRQGDQQDQGRVL D IDLGH LQWHUSDUHQWDOL451 /H WUH JHQHDORJLH FKH HVDPLQHUHPR RUD UDSSUHVHQWDQR DSSXQWR WUH GLVWLQWL PRPHQWL GHO UDSSRUWR IUD PDWULPRQL/ FRVWUX]LRQH G·XQ GRPLQLR SROLWLFR H UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH VWRULR0 JUDILFD= GDOOH QR]]H GL (OHRQRUD G·$UDJRQD DOOD FULVL GHO SDUWLFRODULVPR VLJQR0 ULOH SDGDQR/ VLQR DOOH JXHUUH G·,WDOLD1 7UH JHQHDORJLH/ GXH WUDGL]LRQL JHQHDORJLFKH/ XQ·XQLFD GLVFHQGHQ]D $OOD EDVH GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD FLQTXHFHQWHVFD GHJOL (VWH VL WURYD0 QR GXH JHQHDORJLH/ O·XQD GHO 47:7/ O·DOWUD GL YHQW·DQQL VXFFHVVLYD/ FKH HEEHUR HQWUDPEH GHJOL HSLJRQL H VL FRQIURQWDURQR FRO SUREOHPD GHL PDWULPRQL QHOOD FDVDWD1 5LVSHWWR DG HVVH/ OD JHQHDORJLD GL 0DULR (TXLFROD WHUPLQDWD QHO 4849 UDSSUHVHQWD LQYHFH XQ HOHPHQWR GL YROXWD URWWXUD/ GRYXWD DO WUDXPD GHOOH JXHUUH HG DOOD PXWDWD PHQWDOLWj LQ UHOD]LRQH DO WHPSR HG DOO·XWLOLWj GHL PDWUL0 PRQL1 $ GLIIHUHQ]D GHOOH SULPH GXH/ HVVD QRQ HEEH XQD WUDGL]LRQH SURSULD/ PD QRQRVWDQWH L WHQWDWLYL VXFFHVVLYL GL FDQFHOODUH RJQL PHPRULD GHOOD FULVL EHOOLFD/ FRVWLWXu XQ SULPR/ IRUWH VHJQDOH GHOOD VILGXFLD SROLWLFD QHOOH DOOHDQ]H PDWULPRQLDOL1 4XDVL FHUWDPHQWH SHU FHOHEUDUH OH QR]]H GL (UFROH ,/ QHO 47:7 YHQQH VWHVD XQD JHQHDORJLD D PHGDJOLH/ OD SULPD D ILJXUH GL FXL FL VLD ULPDVWD WHVWLPRQLDQ0 ]D/ JLDFFKp TXHOOD LQYHQWDULDWD QHO 4769 VL q SHUGXWD461 ,O VXR DUJRPHQWR VTXL0 VLWDPHQWH PDWULPRQLDOH q FRPSURYDWR VRSUDWWXWWR GD WUH HOHPHQWL VWUXWWXUDOL= OD GRSSLD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH G·RJQL VLJQRUH/ FRPH ILJOLR H FRPH JRYHUQDQWH LQ FDULFD/ OD FRQVXHWXGLQH G·LQDXJXUDUH OH FDUWH/ GRYH SRVVLELOH/ FRQ OD IDPLJOLD GL XQ PDUFKHVH R GXFD H OD FRQVHJXHQWH UDIILJXUD]LRQH D SDJLQD LQWHUD GL %RUVR/ O·XQLFR GL HVVL D QRQ DYHUH Qp PRJOLH Qp ILJOL1 ,QILQH L VLJQRUL H OH ORUR ²²²²²²²² 45$1
35$1',/ ,O SDWULPRQLR IRQGLDULR GHL 3LR QHOOR %VWDWR% GL &DUSL/ LQ 6RFLHWj/ SROLWLFD H FXOWXUD D &DUSL DL WHPSL GL $OEHUWR ,,, 3LR/ ,,/ 3DGRYD/ $QWHQRUH/ 4<;4/ SS1 7:30835> 01 )2/,1/ )HXGDWD0 UL/ FLWWDGLQL/ JHQWLOXRPLQL1 )RUPH GL QRELOWj QHJOL VWDWL HVWHQVL IUD 4XDWWUR H &LQTXHFHQWR/ LQ FRUVR GL VWDPSD1 46 *HQHDORJLD GHL SULQFLSL G*(VWH/ %,%/,27(&$ 1$=,21$/( &(175$/( ', 520$/ PV1 9LWW1 (P1 5<6/ %(02/ PV1 ,W1 :53 ¡1 /18149> *1 %(5721,0(131 9,&,1,/ ,O FDVWHOOR GL )HUUDUD DL WHPSL GL 1LFFROz ,,,/ %RORJQD/ 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH SURYLQFH GL 5RPDJQD/ 4<3</ S1 ;<> )1 721,2/2/ *HQHDORJLD GHL SULQFLSL G*(VWH/ LQ /H 0XVH H LO SULQFLSH1 $UWH GL FRUWH QHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR SDGDQR/ 0RGHQD0)HUUDUD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<<4/ 5 YROO1/ YRO1 ,/ SS1 7<08:> LO PDQRVFULWWR q RUD ULSURGRW0 WR SHU LQWHUR LQ IDFVLPLOH FRQ &RPPHQWDULR DO FRGLFH/ D FXUD GL (1 0,/$12 0)1 1,877$00101 %5(&&,$ )5$7$'2&&+ 001 %,1,/ 0RGHQD/ ,O %XOLQR/ 4<<91
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;3:
PRJOL VRQR RVSLWDWL GD PHGDJOLRQL D VIRQGR RUR1 ,Q VRVWDQ]D/ OD JHQHDORJLD UDSSUHVHQWD FRPSOHVVLYDPHQWH JOL (VWH FRPH XQ FRQVRU]LR IRUPDWR GD XQLWj IDPLOLDUL H FHOHEUD OD OHJLWWLPLWj GL QDVFLWD FRPH SUHVXSSRVWR SHU OD VXFFHV0 VLRQH/ UHWURGDWDQGROD IDOVDPHQWH DOOH RULJLQL GHO FDVDWR47 +ILJ1 4,1 &LUFD YHQW·DQQL GRSR OD JHQHDORJLD PDWULPRQLDOH GHO 47:7/ OR VWRULFR HG DUFKLYLVWD GL FRUWH 3HOOHJULQR 3ULVFLDQL QH LQVHUu XQD QXRYD QHO VHWWLPR OLEUR GHOOH VXH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH1 3XU PDQWHQHQGR L PHGDJOLRQL H OH VRWWRVWDQWL GL0 GDVFDOLH SHU RJQL VLQJROR SHUVRQDJJLR/ O·DXWRUH QRQ VROR DGRWWz SHU OD SULPD YROWD OD IRUPD GHOO·DOEHUR GL -HVVH/ LQ DSHUWR FRQWUDVWR FRO PHGDJOLHUH GHO 47:7/ PD VFLVVH DGGLULWWXUD LQ WUH DOEHUL GLVWLQWL OD VWRULD GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH= XQR SHU L GXFKL HG L ORUR ILJOL/ XQR SHU OH ILJOLH HG XQR SHU OH PRJOL/ TXHVW·XOWLPR FRQ PHGDJOLRQL VHQ]D ULWUDWWR H GDO WURQFR YXRWR FRPH LO VH0 FRQGR48 +ILJ1 5,1 , WUH DOEHUL VDQFLURQR VHQ]·RPEUD GL GXEELR OD VHSDUD]LRQH GHL UXROL QHOOD FDVDWD= OD VXFFHVVLRQH YLULOLQHDUH DVVLFXUDYD OD WUDVPLVVLRQH GHO WLWROR VLJQRULOH/ OH PRJOL H OH ILJOLH JDUDQWLYDQR DEERQGDQ]D GL GLVFHQGHQWL/ OXVWUR QRELOLDUH HG DOOHDQ]H SROLWLFKH YDQWDJJLRVH1 /·XVR VWHVVR GHOO·DOEHUR GL -HVVH LQGLFD O·LPSRUWDQ]D G·XQ PRWLYR QRQ DOWUHWWDQWR GHWHUPLQDQWH QHO PH0 GDJOLHUH QX]LDOH= O·DFFHQWR VX XQD GLVFHQGHQ]D GDO VDQJXH JLj SXUR H VXOO·LGHD GL WHPSR OLQHDUH H FURQRORJLFR1 6H q YHUR FKH VL WUDWWD G·XQD QHJD]LRQH GHO PRGHOOR PDWULPRQLDOH SUHFHGHQWH/ UHVD HYLGHQWHPHQWH SRVVLELOH GDO VXFFHVVR FKH HVVR DYHYD DYXWR49/ q SXU YHUR FKH O·HVLVWHQ]D GL GXH DOEHUL DSSRVLWL SHU OH FRPSRQHQWL IHPPLQLOL GHO FDVDWR/ LO ULXWLOL]]R GHL PHGDJOLRQL H VRSUDWWXWWR OD UHJRODUH PHQ]LRQH GHL PDULWL SHU OH PRJOL H OH ILJOLH LQVHULWH GLPRVWUDQR DQ0 FRUD XQD VRVWDQ]LDOH LQGHFLVLRQH QHO YDOXWDUH LO UXROR GHOOH GRQQH QHOOD IDPL0 JOLD/ DQFKH TXDQGR LO UXROR GL ¶PH]]DQL· PDWULPRQLDOL GHL VLJQRUL GL )HUUDUD H OH ORUR VWUDWHJLH SROLWLFKH VSRQVDOL FRPLQFLDYDQR D YDFLOODUH1 &Lz q LQGLUHWWDPHQWH FRQIHUPDWR GDOO*LQVHULPHQWR LQ IXQ]LRQH YLULOLQHDUH GL 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD QHOOD VWRULD GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH H GDOOD VXD SUHVHQ]D VXOO*DOEHUR JHQHDORJLFR GHOOH PRJOL1 /D FRQWHVVD ID LQIDWWL LO VXR LQJUHVVR QHOOD ²²²²²²²² 47
-1 )1 %(6725/ .LQVKLS DQG 0DUULDJH LQ WKH 3ROLWLFV RI DQ ,WDOLDQ 5XOLQJ +RXVH= WKH (VWH RI )HUUDUD LQ WKH 5HLJQ RI (UFROH , +47:404838,/ 3K1G1 WKHVLV/ &KLFDJR 8QLYHUVLW\/ 4<<5/ LQ FRUVR GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH/ SS1 6;;06<;1 48 31 35,6&,$1,/ +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ 9,,/ $602/ %LEOLRWHFD +G*RUD LQ SRL %,%,/ PV1 464/ FF1 5Y06U/ 57U/ 58Y SHU JOL DOEHUL/ F1 7U SHU LO ORUR VFKL]]R LQL]LDOH1 6XOO*XVR GHOO*DOEHUR GL -HVVH H GHL PHGDJOLRQL/ Y1 &+1 ./$3,6&+0=8%(5/ 7KH *HQHVLV RI WKH )DPLO\ WUHH/ LQ ©, 7DWWL 6WXGLHVª 7 +4<<4,/ SS1 438045<1 &IU1 QRWD +49,1 49 91 -1)1 %(6725/ .LQVKLS DQG 0DUULDJH111 FLW1/ SS1 743044 SHU JOL DOEHUL GL 3ULVFLDQL HG LO FRQIURQWR FRO PHGDJOLHUH1
;3;
/DXUD 7XUFKL
PHPRULD GHO FDVDWR SURSULR FRQ OH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ FLUFD QHJOL VWHVVL DQQL LQ FXL LO FDUPHOLWDQR IHUUDUHVH %DWWLVWD 3DQHWWL WUDVFULVVH O·+LVWRULD FRPLWLVVDH 0D0 WKLOGLV GL 'RQL]RQH HG LQGLYLGXz DQWHQDWL FRPXQL SHU OHL H SHU JOL (VWH QHL PDUFKHVL GL 6FRUVLD4:1 , PRWLYL GHOO·LQWURGX]LRQH GL 0DWLOGH QHOOD VWRULD GHJOL (VWH VRQR PROWL= OD FRQWHVVD/ SXU HVVHQGR VWDWD VSRVDWD GXH YROWH/ QRQ DYHYD DYXWR ILJOL> LQ FRPSHQVR/ JRGHYD GL XQ·DXWRQRPD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUDILFD/ JUD]LH DOOD 9LWD 0DWKLOGLV GL 'RQL]RQH4;/ DYHYD JRYHUQDWR XQ YDVWR GRPLQLR H VRSUDWWXWWR HUD VWDWD VLJQRUD GL )HUUDUD PROWR SULPD GHL GXFKL1 $EELDPR JLj ULOHYDWR FRPH XQD GHOOH FRVWDQWL GHOOH JHQHDORJLH HVWHQVL IRVVH LO QHVVR LGHQWL0 WDULR IUD OD IDPLJOLD H OD FDSLWDOH GHO GRPLQLR= GLFKLDUDUVL GLVFHQGHQWL GL 0D0 WLOGH VLJQLILFDYD UHWURGDWDUH TXHO QHVVR H OD PHPRULD VWRULFD GHJOL (VWH GL GXH VHFROL H PH]]R> DOOR VWHVVR PRGR/ OD VXD IDPD GL GHYRWD UHJJLWULFH G·XQR VWDWR H GL FDPSLRQHVVD GHOOD &KLHVD FRQIHULYD XQD SDWLQD QRELOLWDQWH DOO·HVHUFL]LR HVWHQVH GHO YLFDULDWR SRQWLILFLR VX )HUUDUD1 3L• WDUGL/ OD VXD PDQFDQ]D GL ILJOL/ XQLWD DOOH TXDOLWj JLj ULFRUGDWH/ DYUHEEH UHVR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH DSSHWLELOH OD SUHVXSSRVL]LRQH G·HVVHUQH L GLVFHQGHQWL1 &L RFFXSHUHPR WUD EUHYH GHO PRGR LQ FXL L JHQHDORJLVWL FLQTXHFHQWHVFKL ULVROVHUR OH DQWLQRPLH ODVFLDWH LQ HUHGLWj GD 3ULVFLDQL> SULPD/ SHUz/ q EHQH VRWWROLQHDUH FKH OD FRQWHVVD 0DWLOGH GHOOH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH q DQFRUD XQD PRJOLH/ VHEEHQH VWHULOH/ VSRVDWD LQ VHFRQGH QR]]H QLHQWHPHQR FKH DG $OEHUWR $]]R/ OR VWHVVR FXL OD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUD0 ILFD HVWHQVH ID SHU OR SL• ULVDOLUH OD SDUHQWHOD IUD (VWH H *XHOIL GL 6DVVRQLD1 6DUj FRPSLWR GHO VHFROR VXFFHVVLYR WUDVIRUPDUH 0DWLOGH LQ XQ·DJQDWD1 2FFXSLDPRFL LQWDQWR G·XQD FURQRORJLD TXDVL VLPXOWDQHD D TXHOOD GHOOH JH0 QHDORJLH/ RVVLD TXHOOD VRWWHVD DOOH YLWH GHOOH GRQQH LOOXVWUL/ XQ JHQHUH OHWWHUDULR IRUWHPHQWH OHJDWR DOOH FRUWL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH D TXHOOD IHUUDUHVH H PDQWRYDQD1 1HO JLUR G·XQ TXDUDQWHQQLR/ VL SDVVz GDOOD YDORUL]]D]LRQH GHO PDWULPRQLR QHOOH SROLWLFKH GLQDVWLFKH DQFRUD SUHVHQWH QHOO·RSHUD GL 6DEDGLQR GHJOL $ULHQ0 WL +47;<0<3, DOOR VFRUSRUR GHOOD YLWD IDPLOLDUH GDOO·LGHQWLWj GHOOD ´GRQQD GL SD0 OD]]Rµ/ DFFDVDWD SHU REEOLJR VRFLDOH QH ,O FRUWHJLDQR GL %DOGDVVDUUH &DVWLJOLRQH ²²²²²²²² 4: 31 35,6&,$1,/ +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ FLW1/ ,9/ $602/ %LEO/ PV1 463/ FF1 7:U/ 8<Y/ 9,,/ $602/ %LEO/ PV1 464/ F1 6Y/ %1 3$1(7,86/ +LVWRULD FRPLWLVVDH 0DWKLOGLV/ %(02/ PV1 /DW1 954 ¡191<1:/ FF1 8/ 458045:1 (* LQ UHDOWj XQD OLEHUD WUDVSRVL]LRQH LQ SURVD GHOOD 9LWD 0DWKLOGLV GL 'RQL]RQH1 6X 3DQHWWL/ 3ULVFLDQL H L ORUR UDSSRUWL/ *1 %(5721,/ 1RWL]LH VXJOL DPDQXHQVL GHJOL (VWHQVL QHO 4XDWWURFHQWR/ LQ ©$UFKLYXP 5RPDQLFXPª/ ,, +4<4;,/ SS1 8808:/ $1 52721'2*/ 3HO0 OHJULQR 3ULVFLDQL +4768 FD10484;,/ LQ ©5LQDVFLPHQWRª ;, +4<93,/ 4/ SS1 9<0443/ DOOH SS1 <60<8/ <<1 4; 3HU XQD FRSLD TXDWWURFHQWHVFD GL 'RQL]RQH/ +LVWRULD FRPLWLVVDH 0DWKLOGLV/ %(02/ PV1 /DW1 5; ¡1 )15171 6X 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD H L VXRL PDWULPRQL FIU $1 63$**,$5,0*1 75(17,/ 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD QHOOD SURVRSRJUDILD HVWHQVH/ LQ 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD QHOOH FXOWXUH HXURSHH GHO VHFRQGR PLO0 OHQQLR1 'DOOD VWRULD DO PLWR1 $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL1 %RORJQD 4<<</ SS1 ;40<6
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;3<
+485;,1 )UD TXHVWL GXH HVWUHPL FURQRORJLFL VWD LO 'H PXOLHULEXV GL 0DULR (TXL0 FROD/ SUHFHWWRUH H SRL VHJUHWDULR GHOOD PDUFKHVD GL 0DQWRYD ,VDEHOOD G·(VWH/ RSHUD QHOOD TXDOH LO PDWULPRQLR q VPDVFKHUDWR FRPH O·LVWLWX]LRQH SHU HFFHO0 OHQ]D GHO FRQWUROOR VRFLDOH VXOOH GRQQH4<1 1HO 4849/ RVVLD TXLQGLFL DQQL GRSR OD VFULWWXUD GHO 'H PXOLHULEXV/ (TXLFROD SRUWz D WHUPLQH XQD *HQHDORJLD GH OL VL0 JQRUL GD (VWH SULYD G·LPPDJLQL/ FKH LJQRUz HVSOLFLWDPHQWH LO WHPD QX]LDOH/ ´SHUFLz FKH/ LQ WDO FRVH/ FKL 0 SL• FKH·O ORFR QRQ FHUFD 0 VL H[WHQGH/ SDUH GD PDJJLRU ORGH VLD GHVWLWXLWR1µ /D VSLHJD]LRQH VTXLVLWDPHQWH JHQHDORJLFD IRUQL0 WD GD (TXLFROD SHU XQD FRVu VFDUVD SUHJQDQ]D VWRULFD q FKH L PDWULPRQL QRQ FRQWULEXLVFRQR DOOD QRELOWj HG DOO·DQWLFKLWj GHO SL• SUHVWLJLRVR FDVDWR IUD TXHO0 OL LWDOLDQL531 /·XQLFD PRJOLH JUDWLILFDWD GDOO·DXWRUH G·XQD WUDWWD]LRQH VSHFLILFD q 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD/ TXL WUDVIRUPDWD GHILQLWLYDPHQWH LQ DJQDWD/ DGGXFHQGR D SURYH OD GLVFHQGHQ]D VXD H GHO VHFRQGR PDULWR $]]R G·(VWH GD GXH IUDWHOOL/ ILJOL G·XQ DOWUR $]]R HVWHQVH/ TXLQGL OD VHSDUD]LRQH GDO FRQLXJH QHO 43:4 SHU FRQVDQJXLQHLWj H ULVFKLR G·LQFHVWR541 $ FRQIHUPD GHOOD QRVWUD FURQRORJLD/ SXz HVVHU XWLOH XQ EUHYH FRQIURQWR IUD L GLYHUVL WUDWWDPHQWL ULVHUYDWL DG (OHR0 QRUD H /XFUH]LD GDOOD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUDILFD FRHYD1 /H RUD]LRQL QX]LDOL H JOL HQFRPL SRHWLFL FKH OH FHOHEUDURQR PLVHUR PDJJLRUPHQWH O·DFFHQWR VXOOH GRWL GHOOD SULQFLSHVVD QDSROHWDQD LQ XQ FDVR/ VXOOD IDPLJOLD GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD ILJOLD GHO 3DSD QHOO·DOWUR55= VHJQR FKH OH PRJOL VL VWDYDQR WUDVIRUPDQGR LQ FRO0 OHWWRUL GL DOOHDQ]H GLSORPDWLFKH PXOWLSOH WUDPLWH OH SDUHQWHOH JXDGDJQDWH GDOOD SURSULD IDPLJOLD G·RULJLQH1 &RQWUDGGL]LRQL FLQTXHFHQWHVFKH ²²²²²²²² 4<
&1 )$+</ 7KUHH (DUO\ 5HQDLVVDQFH 7UHDWLVHV RQ :RPHQ/ LQ ©,WDOLDQ 6WXGLHVª/ ;, +4<89,/ SS1 63088> :1/1 *81'(56+(,0(5/ %DUWRORPPHR *RJJLR= D )HPLQLVW LQ 5HQDLVVDQFH )HUUDUD/ LQ ©5HQDLVVDQFH 4XDUWHUO\ª/ 66 +4<;3,/ SS1 4:80533> 61 .2/6.</ %HQGLQJ WKH 5XOHV= 0DUULDJH LQ 5HQDLVVDQFH &ROOHFWLRQV RI %LRJUDSKLHV RI )DPRXV :RPHQ/ LQ 0DUULDJH LQ ,WDO\/ 463304983/ HGLWHG E\ 71 '($10.1/2:(/ &DPEULGJH/ &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV/ 4<<;/ SS1 55:057;1 53 01 (48,&2/$/ *HQHDORJLD GH 6LJQRUL GD (VWH/ %(02/ PV1 ,W1 598 ¡1:1915;/ FF1 73Y074U1 54 ,ELG1/ FF1 7U0;Y1 $ SURSRVLWR GL (TXLFROD/ Y1 61 .2/6.</ *7KH *RRG 6HUYDQW*= 0DULR (TXLFR0 OD1 &RXUW DQG &RXUWLHU LQ (DUO\ 6L[WHHQWK &HQWXU\ ,WDO\/ LQ ©7KH ,WDOLDQLVWª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
;43
/DXUD 7XUFKL
(· O·LPSUHVVLRQH FKH VL ULFDYD GDL IXQHUDOL FRPPHPRUDWLYL FHOHEUDWL D )HU0 UDUD QHO FRUVR GHO &LQTXHFHQWR SHU SULQFLSL VWUDQLHUL LPSDUHQWDWL FRQ JOL (VWH WUDPLWH (OHRQRUD G·$UDJRQD/ 5HQDWD GL )UDQFLD H %DUEDUD G·$VEXUJR561 /H VWHVVH RUD]LRQL IXQHEUL VFULWWH SHU OH GXFKHVVH SURYDQR OD YLYD FRQVDSHYROH]0 ]D GL TXDQWR OH SDUHQWHOH SHU YLD PDWULPRQLDOH JDUDQWLVVHUR UDSSRUWL SULYLOH0 JLDWL FRQ O·XQR R O·DOWUR SURWDJRQLVWD GHOOD WXUEROHQWD YLWD SROLWLFD HXURSHD1 *OL H[FXUVXV JHQHDORJLFL FKH WURYLDPR LQ HVVH OHJLWWLPDQR LQROWUH VX XQD VFDOD SL• DPSLD TXHO FXOWR SHU OH JHQHUD]LRQL SDVVDWH FRVu UDGLFDWR QHOOH JHQHDOR0 JLH1 ,O IDWWR p FKH OH XQH H OH DOWUH FRQGLYLGRQR O·LGHD FKH IDUH VWRULD VLJQLILFKL HYRFDUH LO IXQHEUH FRUWHR GHJOL DQWHQDWL/ SHU HVRUWDUH JOL HUHGL DG LPLWDUQH OH HVHPSODUL YLUW•1 6RQR/ LQVRPPD/ LGHDOL +PD QRQ DVWUDWWL, OXRJKL G·LQFRQWUR IUD YLYL H PRUWL571 3HU TXHVWR/ TXDQGR QHJOL DQQL &LQTXDQWD GHO ;9, VHFROR LO IUDWH 3DROR GD /LJQDJR VFULVVH OH JHQHDORJLH LQWHUDPHQWH PDWULPRQLDOL GL $UDJRQD/ $VEXUJR/ 9DORLV/ %RUJRJQD HG (VWH FRPSu XQ·RSHUD]LRQH HFFH]LRQDOH PD QRQ LQFRQ0 JUXD/ ULVSHWWR DL FDQRQL ILVVDWL SHU LO JHQHUH GDOOD WUDGL]LRQH FRUWLJLDQD581 /·DFFXUDWD PHQ]LRQH GL QRPL H GDWH SHU PRJOL H ILJOLH/ FRQ UHODWLYL PDULWL H GLVFHQGHQWL/ QRQ q ILQDOL]]DWD D UDSSUHVHQWDUH LO UXROR GHJOL DIILQL LQ RJQL ID0 PLJOLD/ EHQVu O·DIILQLWj PDWULPRQLDOH GL RJQL FDVDWR FRQ JOL (VWH/ VSLQWD DOOH HVWUHPH FRQVHJXHQ]H1 /R GLPRVWUD OD GLYHUVD WUDWWD]LRQH ULVHUYDWD DOOD IDPL0 JOLD GXFDOH/ YHUVR FXL WXWWR FRQYHUJH= FRHUHQWHPHQWH FRQ OR VYLOXSSR GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD ORFDOH/ L PDWULPRQL GHOOH ILJOLH VRQR QRPLQDWL VROR D SDUWLUH GDOOD VLJQRULD GL 2EL]]R ,, VX )HUUDUD +4597,/ PHQWUH SULPD GHO ;,9 VHFROR OH PRJOL YHQJRQR FHQVLWH VROR VH DSSRUWDWULFL GL OXVWUR QRELOLDUH H JLX0 ULVGL]LRQL1 *UD]LH DG (OHRQRUD G·$UDJRQD/ JOL (VWH VRQR LQYHFH GLFKLDUDWL GL0 VFHQGHQWL GHJOL $UDJRQD GL 6SDJQD H VHPSUH SHU VXR WUDPLWH/ OH DUDJRQHVL VSDJQROH *LRYDQQD H &DWHULQD SURFXUDQR DL GXFKL SDUHQWHOH FRQ JOL $VEXUJR HG L 7XGRU1 , %RUJRJQD YHQJRQR LQYHFH ULFRUGDWL LQ EUHYH SHU L ORUR OHJDPL FRQ JOL $VEXUJR H FRQ L 9DORLV/ GD FXL GLVFHQGH 5HQDWD GL )UDQFLD1 6L WUDWWD LQ VRVWDQ]D G·XQD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH VXE VSHFLH FRQLXJLL GHOOH UHOD]LRQL LQWHUQD]LRQD0 OL LQ FXL VL WURYDYD LQVHULWR LO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD1 6RSUDWWXWWR/ DWWUDYHUVR ²²²²²²²² 56
*1 5,&&,/ ,O SULQFLSH H OD PRUWH/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<<;/ SS1 468/ 46<1 ,ELG1/ SDVVLP SHU OH UHIHUHQ]H ELEOLRJUDILFKH H SS1 84085/ 8< FRQ ELEOLRJUDILD VXO UDSSRUWR IUD JHQHDORJLH HG RUD]LRQL IXQHEUL1 58 3$2/2 '$ /,*1$*2/ &URQLFD/ $602/ %LEO/ PV1 9</ FF1 :380:43 SHU OD JHQHDORJLD DUD0 JRQHVH/ FF1 :440:49 SHU TXHOOD DVEXUJLFD/ FF1 :4:0:53 SHU OD JHQHDORJLD 9DORLV H FF1 :540:68 SHU TXHOOD HVWHQVH/ RYH 0DWLOGH KD VROR XQD PHQ]LRQH GL VIXJJLWD D F1 :551 57
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;44
O·DQDPQHVL PDWULPRQLDOH GL GXHFHQWR DQQL GL VWRULD HXURSHD +PD SHU $VEXUJR HG (VWH VL DUUHWUD ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH DO ;,,, HG DO ; VHFROR,/ O·DXWRUH LQWHVH UDPPHQWDUH DL SURSUL VLJQRUL L FUHGLWL GLSORPDWLFL FKH DYUHEEHUR SRWXWR GL YROWD LQ YROWD DYDQ]DUH QHL FRQIURQWL GHOO·XQD R GHOO·DOWUD GLQDVWLD DIILQH1 /·RSHUD GL 3DROR GD /LJQDJR HVDOWD SULQFLSDOPHQWH L UDSSRUWL GHJOL (VWH FRQ $VEXUJR H 9DORLV HG q GL SRFKL DQQL DQWHULRUH DOOD SDFH GL &DWHDX0 &DPEUpVLV1 'LPRVWUD TXLQGL OD FRQVDSHYROH]]D FKH LO PDWULPRQLR DYYHQXWR QHO 485; IUD 5HQDWD GL )UDQFLD HG (UFROH ,, QRQ EDVWDYD SL• D JDUDQWLUH OD VRSUDYYLYHQ]D GHO GXFDWR LQ XQ TXDGUR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GLYHQXWR RUPDL VIDYR0 UHYROH DOO·,WDOLD WXWWD1 1RQGLPHQR/ OD ILGXFLD FKH PRVWUD QHOO·XWLOLWj GHOOH DOOH0 DQ]H VSRQVDOL DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD GLSORPD]LD HXURSHD q DQFRUD JUDQGH H/ JHQHD0 ORJLFDPHQWH/ VL VHUYH GL GXFKHVVH YLYH H PRUWH1 6H TXHVWD WHVVLWXUD GL PDWUL0 PRQL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL QRQ LQDXJXUz XQD IRUWH WUDGL]LRQH/ FLz DYYHQQH SUHVX0 PLELOPHQWH SHUFKp DOWUL PRWLYL DYHYDQR QHO IUDWWHPSR LQGRWWR L JHQHDORJLVWL GL (UFROH ,, D UHFXSHUDUH LQ GXH GLVWLQWL ILORQL LO PHGDJOLHUH GHO 47:7 HG L WUH DOEHUL GL 3HOOHJULQR 3ULVFLDQL1 6HQ]D GXEELR OD TXHVWLRQH GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D FRQ L 0HGLFL LQL]LDWD QHO 4874 PLVH LQ IRUVH SHU SULPD O·LGHQWLWj JHQWLOL]LD GHL GXFKL59> QRQ ELVRJQD WXWWDYLD GLPHQWLFDUH FKH LO WHVWDPHQWR GL $OIRQVR , VWL0 ODWR QHO 4866 DYHYD LQVHULWR XQ FRUUHWWLYR QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH VXFFHVVRULD GL OH0 JLWWLPLWj H SULPRJHQLWXUD LQDXJXUDWD GDO SDGUH1 $OIRQVR , DYHYD ODVFLDWR LQ0 IDWWL HUHGH (UFROH ,,/ DVVHJQDQGR SHUz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·RSHUD GHO SL• UDSSUHVHQWDWLYR IUD L ORUR SUHGHFHVVRUL> ²²²²²²²² 59 91 6$17,/ /D SUHFHGHQ]D WUD JOL (VWHQVL H L 0HGLFL H O*+LVWRULD GH* SULQFLSL G*(VWH GL *1 %DWWLVWD 3LJQD/ )HUUDUD/ 'HSXWD]LRQH IHUUDUHVH GL VWRULD SDWULD/ 4;<:1 6XL IDOVL HSLJUDILFL GL )DOOHWWL/ *1/1 *5(*25,/ *HQHDORJLH HVWHQVL H IDOVLILFD]LRQH HSLJUDILFD/ 5RPD/ 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL VWXGL /D 6D0 SLHQ]D/ 4<<31 5: $602/ &DVD H 6WDWR/ 3ULQFLSL UHJQDQWL/ E1 658/ WHVWDPHQWR GHO 5; DJRVWR 48661 1HO 4834 (UFROH , DYHYD SHUz LQYHVWLWR LO IUDWHOOR 6LJLVPRQGR GHL FDVWHOOL GL 61 0DUWLQR LQ 5LR/ &DVWHOOD0 UDQR H &DPSRJDOOLDQR/ LO FKH VSLHJD OD VFHOWD GL 3DROR GD /LJQDJR1 91 VX TXHVWL WHPL 01 )2/,1/ )HXGDWDUL/ FLWWDGLQL111 FLWDWR1 5; 01 )2/,1/ /H FURQDFKH D )HUUDUD H QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +;90;9,,/ LQ YLD GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH QHO YRO1 9,, GHOOD 6WRULD GL )HUUDUD1
;45
/DXUD 7XUFKL
TXLQGL/ DQFKH FRQ OH FRQWUDGGL]LRQL FKH QHOOH VXH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH HJOL QRQ HUD ULXVFLWR D FRPSRUUH/ QHO YDOXWDUH UXROL PDVFKLOL H IHPPLQLOL SHU OD VWRULD GHL GXFKL1 /D ILOLHUD FKH GD 3ULVFLDQL FRQGXFH DOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD H0 VWHQVH SL• FRQRVFLXWD PRVWUD XQD SULPD WRUVLRQH GHO PRGHOOR JLj QHOO·2UODQGR IXULRVR5<= O·HYRFD]LRQH LQ GXH FDQWL VHSDUDWL GHL GLVFHQGHQWL HVWHQVL GL 5XJJLHUR H %UDGDPDQWH H GHOOH ORUR PRJOL H ILJOLH QRQ LPSHGLVFH FKH O·LQFDQWHVLPR GHOOD PDJD 0HOLVVD GXUL EHQ TXDUDQWDWUH RWWDYH SHU L SULQFLSL H VHGLFL VROWDQWR SHU FRQVRUWL H ILJOLH LQVLHPH/ ODGGRYH 3ULVFLDQL DYHYD SUHYLVWR WUH DOEHUL GL0 VWLQWL1 /·LGHD GHOO·DUFKLYLVWD GL FRUWH SRVWXODYD WXWWDYLD XQD GLYHUVD ILGXFLD QHO UDSSRUWR IUD PDWULPRQL H SDUHQWHOD> HUD SHUFLz LQDGDWWD D UDSSUHVHQWDUH OH OR0 JLFKH SDWULOLQHDUL FKH VDQJXH/ WLWROL H GRWL GHOOH PRJOL LOOXVWUL IDYRULYDQR QHO VHFROR VXFFHVVLYR1 ,O PLWR GHOOH RULJLQL URPDQH H O·HODERUD]LRQH GHL IDOVL HSL0 JUDILFL FKH SRUWz FRQ Vp QRQ VL OLPLWDURQR SHUFLz D VRVWHQHUH OH UDJLRQL HVWHQ0 VL QHOOD TXHVWLRQH GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D= HVVL WUDVIRUPDURQR FRQWHVWXDOPHQWH OH ILJOLH/ PD DVVDL SL• OH PRJOL LQ XQD ULFFKH]]D LPEDUD]]DQWH/ REOLWHUDQGR TXDQ0 WR SL• SRVVLELOH O·XWLOLWj GL TXHVWH XOWLPH QHOOD FUHD]LRQH GL GLVFHQGHQWL PD0 VFKL H OHJLWWLPL H QHOOD GLSORPD]LD LQWHUQD]LRQDOH1 3DROR GD /LJQDJR DYHYD SUREDELOPHQWH VRVWHQXWR O·RULJLQH IUDQFD GHJOL (VWH LQ RQRUH DOOD GXFKHVVD 5HQDWD/ PD IX O·XOWLPR D IDUOR1 /·DOEHUR JHQHDORJLFR FXL DSSURGDURQR OH YHQ0 WHQQDOL ULFHUFKH GL *LURODPR )DOOHWWL PXWXz LQYHFH GDOOD FXOWXUD JHQWLOL]LD URPDQD QRQ VROR OH LVFUL]LRQL LQ OHWWHUD TXDGUDWD/ PD DQFKH H VRSUDWWXWWR LO OLQJXDJJLR DJQDWLFR GHOOD SDUHQWHOD1 'L FRQVHJXHQ]D/ FRQFHVVH HSLJUDIL DXWR0 QRPH VROR DOOH ILJOLH HG LQVHUu OH PRJOL QHL ULTXDGUL GHGLFDWL DL PDULWL/ DG DF0 FUHGLWDUH O·LGHD G·XQ ULFDPELR JHQHUD]LRQDOH SHU YLD PDVFKLOH631 8Q VROR HOH0 PHQWR FRQWUDVWD FRQ TXHVWD QHWWD ORJLFD SDWULOLQHDUH1 6L WUDWWD GL WUH HOHQFKL DFFRUSDWL LQ XQ·XQLFD/ LPPDJLQDULD VWHOH VLWD DOOD EDVH GHOO·DOEHUR/ D GHVWUD1 ,Q HVVL/ VL Gj FRQWR GHOOH IDPLJOLH FKH VRQR GHULYDWH GDJOL (VWH SHU YLD GL DJQDWL R DJQDWH H SL• DQFRUD GHOOH QXPHURVLVVLPH VWLUSL ORUR XQLWH SHU YLD PDWULPR0 QLDOH= LO WHU]R WLWROR/ 4XDH IDPLOLDH FRQLXJLRUXP FRSXOD LQ KDQF WUDQVPLJUDUXQW/ q VH0 ²²²²²²²² 5< /1 $5,2672/ 2UODQGR IXULRVR/ D FXUD GL /1 &$5(77,/ 7RULQR/ (LQDXGL/ 4<99/ ,,,/ 4:093/ ;,,,/ 8:0:6> 3HU VWXGL VSHFLILFL/ FIU1 -1)1 %(6725/ .LQVKLS DQG 0DUULDJH111/ FLW1/ SS1 7440745 H +1 +211$&.(5/ /*RULJLQH GHOOD FDVD G*(VWH IRUQLWD QHOO*2UODQGR IXULRVR GL /XGRYLFR $ULRVWR QHOOH HGL0 ]LRQL GHO 4849 H GHO 4854= XQD JHQHDORJLD IUD OHJJHQGD H VWRULD/ LQ ©6FKLIDQRLDª/ 4:04; +4<<:,/ SS1 45804661 ,O IUDPPHQWR DQRQLPR LQ $602/ *61/ E1 8</ Q1 SURW1 493425: GHO SLHQR &LQTXH0 FHQWR PRVWUD LO WHQWDWLYR GL IRQGHUH JOL DOEHUL GL 3ULVFLDQL FRQ OH HSLJUDIL GL )DOHWWL1 63 $602/ *61/ E1 8<> *1 320$7$/ /HJDPL GL VDQJXH/ OHJDPL GL VHPH1 &RQVDQJXLQHLWj H DJQD0 ]LRQH QHO GLULWWR URPDQR/ LQ 46/ ;;,; +4<<7,/ ;9/ SS1 5<<06671
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;46
JXLWR GDL QRPL GL WXWWH OH PRJOL FRL ULVSHWWLYL SDWURQLPLFL +ILJ1 6,1 1RQ q GLIIL0 FLOH ULFRQRVFHUH LQ TXHVWD LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH UDGLFDOH LO ORJRULR GHOOD SURSRVWD GL 3ULVFLDQL/ DQFKH SHUFKq/ VH OD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUDILFD SL• FRQRVFLXWD DFFROVH QHOOH VXH OLQHH GL IRQGR OR VFKHPD JHQHDORJLFR GL )DOOHWWL/ YL VRQR WHVWLPR0 QLDQ]H FKH LO ODVFLWR TXDWWURFHQWHVFR HUD DQFRUD RSHUDQWH/ SHUVLQR IUD L VRVWH0 QLWRUL GHOOH JHQHDORJLH ULJLGDPHQWH DJQDWL]LH1 &HUWR/ O·+LVWRULD GH SULQFLSL GL (VWH SXEEOLFDWD GD *LDPEDWWLVWD 3LJQD QHO 48:3 VXOOD VFRUWD GHO ODYRUR FRPSLXWR GDO )DOOHWWL VHJXu ULJRURVDPHQWH JOL $QQDOHV PDQRVFULWWL GL TXHVW·XOWLPR/ DQFKH SHUFKq LO VHJUHWDULR GXFDOH DYHYD GRYXWR FRQWLQXDUH XQ·RSHUD LQWHUURWWD GDOOD PRUWH GHOO·DXWRUH H IDUQH SXEEOL0 FDUH DOPHQR O·DOEHUR QHO 48981 $OWUHWWDQWR q SRVVLELOH GLUH/ FRQ YDULH VIXPD0 WXUH/ GL WXWWL L JHQHDORJLVWL H GHJOL VWRULFL FRLQYROWL GDOOD TXHVWLRQH GHOOD SUH0 FHGHQ]D LQ XQ ODYRUR FROOHWWLYR= *DVSDUH 6DUGL/ LO ILJOLR $OHVVDQGUR 0 FKH SUR0 VHJXu ILQR DOO·DQQR 4838 OD VWRULD LQWHUURWWD GDO 3LJQD DO 47:9 0 /HOLR *UHJR0 ULR *LUDOGL H *LDPEDWWLVWD *LUDOGL &LQ]LR641 /D JHQHDORJLD GLSLQWD QHO 48:: GD /XGRYLFR 6HWWHYHFFKL QHO FRUWLOH GHO FDVWHOOR GL )HUUDUD/ IRUVH VX FDUWRQL GHOO·DQWLTXDULR 3LUUR /LJRULR/ DSSDUWHQQH DO PHGHVLPR ILORQH GL ULFRVWUX]LRQH SDWULOLQHDUH651 ,QXWLOH GLUH FKH TXHVWD VWHVVD WUDGL]LRQH SHUVLVWHYD QHOO·DVVHJQDUH DOOD FRQ0 WHVVD 0DWLOGH SL• PDULWL +H WLWROL, GHO GRYXWR HG D VSRVDUOD FRQ XQ (VWHQVH VXR FRQVDQJXLQHR D VFHOWD1 1HOOD *HUXVDOHPPH OLEHUDWD GL 7RUTXDWR 7DVVR/ VL WHQWz DQFKH GL WUDVIRUPDUH OD VLJQRUD GL )HUUDUD LQ VHPSOLFH JXHUULHUD GHOOD &KLHVD1 ,O FKH QRQ VWXSLVFH/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH D GLPRVWUDUH JOL DQWLFKL IDVWL GHL GXFKL F·HUDQR RUPDL L URPDQL $WLL/ VLJQRUL HSRQLPL GL (VWH661 (SSXUH/ OR VWHVVR *DVSDUH 6DUGL DXWRUH GHOOH +LVWRULH IHUUDUHVL WHVWLPRQLD ²²²²²²²² 64 *1 6$5',/ /LEUR GHOOH KLVWRULH IHUUDUHVL/ )HUUDUD/ )UDQFHVFR 5RVVL/ 4889> $1 6$5',/ /LEUL FLQTXH GHOO*KLVWRULD HVWHQVH/ %(02/ PV1 ,W1 496 ¡1.16154> /1 *5(*25,2 *,5$/',/ 'H )HUUDULDH HW $WHVWLQLV SULQFLSLEXV FRPPHQWDULROXP/ )HUUDULDH/ SHU )UDQFLVFXP 5XEHXP/ 4889> *1%1 *,5$/', &,1=,2/ &RPPHQWDULR GHOOH FRVH GL )HUUDUD HW GH* SULQFLSL GD (VWH/ )HUUDUD/ 4889> *1%1 3,*1$/ +L0 VWRULD GH* SULQFLSL GL (VWH/ )HUUDUD/ )UDQFHVFR 5RVVL/ 48:31 65 /1 /2',/ ,PPDJLQL GHOOD JHQHDORJLD HVWHQVH/ LQ /*LPSUHVD GL $OIRQVR ,,1 6DJJL H GRFXPHQWL VXOOD SURGX]LRQH DUWLVWLFD D )HUUDUD QHO VHFRQGR &LQTXHFHQWR/ %RORJQD/ 1XRYD $OID/ 4<;:/ SS1 4840495 H ELEOLRJUDILD LYL FLWDWD> )1 +$6.(/// /H LPPDJLQL GHOOD VWRULD1 /*DUWH H O*LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GHO SDVVDWR/ 7RULQR/ (LQDXGL/ 4<<:/ SS1 7:0831 66 +1 )$/(7,/ (VWHQVLXP JHQWLV DQQDOHV LQ OLEURV VH[ WULEXWL/ %(02/ PV1 /DW1 7:; ¡1)16147/ OL0 EHU ,,/ FF1 9:U/ 9;U/ :7Y/ ;:Y0<5U/ OLEHU ,,,/ FF1 <8U/ 433U> *1 6$5',/ 0LVFHOODQHD ODWLQD/ %(02/ PV1 /DW1 7:9 ¡1-161</ F1 63Y VX )HUUDUD FRPH QXRYD (VWH/ FF1 565U056;Y VX 0DWLOGH> 91 )80$*$//,/ 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD1 3RWHQ]D H VROLWXGLQH GL XQD GRQQD GHO 0HGLRHYR/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOL0 QR/ 4<<9/ SS1 840861
;47
/DXUD 7XUFKL
O·LQFHUWH]]D FRQ FXL DQFRUD D PHWj VHFROR VL JXDUGDYD DOOD VWRULD GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH> D OXL VL GHYH XQD ULFRSLDWXUD GHOOD JHQHDORJLD HVWHQVH GL 3DROR GD /L0 JQDJR LQ FXL/ ROWUH DG DJJLXQJHUH L QRPL GL PRJOL H ILJOLH PDQFDQWL/ DVVHJQD DG $OIRQVR , FRPH WHU]D PRJOLH OD FRQFXELQD /DXUD 'LDQWL/ VROR SHU SRWHU GLFKLDUDUH OHJLWWLPL $OIRQVR HG $OIRQVLQR/ QDWL GD TXHOO·XQLRQH671 ,O FDVR LQ FXL OH LQFHUWH]]H GL 6DUGL QHO ULFRVWUXLUH LO SDVVDWR IDPLOLDUH HVWHQVH VRQR SL• SDOHVL q WXWWDYLD XQD VHULH GL HOHQFKL JHQHDORJLFL FRQ LQIRUPD]LRQL DJJLRUQDWH DL WHPSL VXRL/ LQ FXL PHWWH DOOD SURYD OR VFKHPD WULSDUWLWR GL 3ULVFLDQL VHQ]D WXWWDYLD ULXWLOL]]DUQH OH LPPDJLQL= GD XQ ODWR VXGGLYLGH OH VRUWL GL PDULWL/ PR0 JOL H ILJOLH LQ XQ EUHYH FRPSHQGLR GHL SULQFLSL G·(VWH/ HG LQ GXH OLVWH IHPPL0 QLOL1 'DOO·DOWUR/ DVVHULVFH QHO WLWROR GL WUDVFULYHUH OD *HQHDORJLD (VWHQVLXP PDU0 FKLRQXP SHU 3HUHJULQXP 3ULVFLDQXP OLEUR VHSWLPR> LQYHFH/ ILQR DG $]]R 9, +44:30 4545, H GD (UFROH , LQ SRL ULXQLVFH LQ XQ XQLFR HOHQFR L PDUFKHVL/ OH ORUR PR0 JOL/ L ILJOL H SHUVLQR OH ILJOLH/ TXDQGR FDQRQL]]DWH GDOOD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUDIL0 FD1 'LVWUXJJH FLRq LO SULQFLSLR GHOOD VHSDUD]LRQH GHJOL DOEHUL/ VX FXL HUD EDVDWD OD JHQHDORJLD GL 3ULVFLDQL681 $QFKH L IDXWRUL GHOOD PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD DJQD0 WL]LD PRVWUDYDQR TXLQGL FRQVLVWHQWL UHQLWHQ]H DG DEEDQGRQDUH LO WHPD PDWUL0 PRQLDOH/ WDQWR ULFFR G·LPSOLFD]LRQL SROLWLFR0GLSORPDWLFKH1 &KH WDOH WHPD IRVVH OXQJL GDOO·HVVHUH HVDXULWR q SURYDWR DQFKH GDO UHFXSH0 UR GHO PHGDJOLHUH TXDWWURFHQWHVFR/ D SDUWLUH DOPHQR GDJOL XOWLPL DQQL GL (U0 FROH ,,1 /D VFHOWD GL ULFRUGDUH XQ UDPR FDGHWWR DFFRPXQD JLj OD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GL *DVSDUH 6DUGL D TXHOOD GL 3DROR GD /LJQDJR/ FKH VFHOVH SHUz OD SUROH +LOOH0 JLWWLPD, GL 6LJLVPRQGR/ OHJLWWLPR H IUDWHOOR GL (UFROH ,/ SHU QRQ GLVFRVWDUVL WURSSR GDOOD WUDGL]LRQH VWRULRJUDILFD HUFXOHD691 8QD VHULH GL WHVWLPRQL GHO VH0 FRQGR &LQTXHFHQWR/ GL FXL VROWDQWR DOFXQL VRQR VWDWL SHU RUD LGHQWLILFDWL/ DJ0 JLRUQD LQYHFH O·DQWLFD JHQHDORJLD PDWULPRQLDOH SHU DJJLXQJHUYL $OIRQVR , H OD VXD GLVFHQGHQ]D/ LQFOXVD TXHOOD DYXWD GD /DXUD 'LDQWL/ FODVVLILFDWD FRPH OHJLW0 WLPD1 )UD HVVL/ YD DQQRYHUDWD DQFKH OD WUDVFUL]LRQH LQ FRUVLYD XPDQLVWLFD GHOOD JHQHDORJLD GHO 47:7 LQVHULWD QHO VHWWLPR OLEUR GHOOH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ FKH SUREDELOPHQWH ULVDOH DJOL XOWLPL DQQL GL (UFROH ,,6:1 4XHVWD UDIILJXUD]LRQH HG ²²²²²²²² 67
*1 6$5',/ &RSLD JHQHDORJLDH (VWHQVLXP SULQFLSXP111/ %(02/ PV1 /DW1 743 ¡1 )16161/ FF1 4U0
;Y1 68
,ELG1/ FF1 45U046Y SHU OH JHQHDORJLH GL PRJOL H ILJOLH/ F1 44UY SHU LO FRPSHQGLR/ FF1 <U043U SHU OD JHQHDORJLD XQLILFDWD1 69 3$2/2 '$ /,*1$*2/ &URQLFD/11 1FLW1/ F1 :651 6: 31 35,6&,$1,/ +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ 9,,/ FLW1/ FF1 8U049U> ,FRQRJUDILD HVWHQVH/ %,%/,27(&$ &2081$/( $5,267($ ', )(55$5$/ PV1 $QWROLQL/ 476/ FKH q SRVWHULRUH DO PDWULPRQLR GL $O0 IRQVR ,, FRQ %DUEDUD G*$VEXUJR1
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;48
XQ·DOWUD SL• WDUGD FRQVHUYDQR OD GLVSRVL]LRQH GHOOH ILJXUH SHU XQLWj IDPLJOLDUL H TXDVL VHPSUH OD IRUPD GHL PHGDJOLRQL/ ULSURGXFHQGR DSSURVVLPDWLYDPHQWH JOL DELWL H OH DFFRQFLDWXUH RULJLQDOL1 ,QROWUH DSSRQJRQR QXRYH GLGDVFDOLH DL SHUVRQDJJL QRQ SUHVHQWL QHO PRGHOOR TXDWWURFHQWHVFR H FRUUHJJRQR OH DQQR0 WD]LRQL DQWLFKH VROR LQ FDVR GL HUURUL R LQFRPSOHWH]]H1 (QWUDPEH LQVHULVFRQR FRPH GLVFHQGHQWH OHJLWWLPR $OIRQVR/ LO SULPRJHQLWR GL $OIRQVR , H /DXUD 'LDQWL1 1HO FDVR SL• WDUGR/ LO ILJOLR GHOOD 'LDQWL q UDIILJXUDWR VLD FRPH HUHGH FKH FRPH SULQFLSH/ DO SDUL GL (UFROH ,, H FRPH WXWWL L VLJQRUL GL )HUUDUD SUH0 VHQWL QHOO·RULJLQDOH GHO ;9 VHFROR6;1 /·XOWLPD FDUWD GHOOD JHQHDORJLD LQVHULWD QHOOH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH ULFDOFD LQYHFH LO WHVWDPHQWR GL $OIRQVR ,/ GDO PRPHQ0 WR FKH ROWUH DG (UFROH ,, GHVLJQD HUHGL GL $OIRQVR , ,SSROLWR G·(VWH +VHQ]D ULWUDWWR QHO PHGDJOLRQH/ SHUFKq PHQ]LRQDWR FRPH FDUGLQDOH, H )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH +UDIILJXUDWR LQYHFH QHO WRQGR/ LQ TXDQWR HOHJJLELOH D VXFFHGHUH,6<1 , UDSSRUWL IUD TXHVWL PDQRVFULWWL GRYUDQQR HVVHUH DSSURIRQGLWL LQ IXWXUR> SHU LO PRPHQWR/ VH QH SXz GHGXUUH FKH DOPHQR GDJOL XOWLPL DQQL GL (UFROH ,, DY0 YHQQH XQD FRVFLHQWH ULSUHVD GHOO·DQWLFR PRGHOOR JHQHDORJLFR VSRQVDOH/ OD TXDOH LQ REEHGLHQ]D DO WHVWDPHQWR GL $OIRQVR , WHQWz GL TXDOLILFDUH XQ VXF0 FHVVRUH H WUH FDGHWWL/ SHU QRUPDOL]]DUH O·LPEDUD]]DQWH HVLVWHQ]D G·XQD FRQFX0 ELQD XIILFLDOH FRQ GXH ILJOL LQYHVWLWL GL IHXGL H ULRUGLQDUH OD JHUDUFKLD VXFFHV0 VRULD731 4XDQGR/ SULYR GL GLVFHQGHQWL QRQRVWDQWH L SULPL GXH PDWULPRQL/ $OIRQVR ,, IX FRVWUHWWR D VFHJOLHUVL XQ VXFFHVVRUH/ OD VFHOWD FDGGH SHU HVFOXVLRQH VX &HVDUH/ QLSRWH GL $OIRQVR , SHUFKp ILJOLR OHJLWWLPR GHO SULPRJHQLWR GL /DXUD 'LDQWL1 'HOOH WUH OLQHH FDGHWWH VDQFLWH QHO 4866/ QRQ ULPDQHYD LQIDWWL FKH TXHOOD GHULYDQWH GDOO·LOOHJLWWLPR $OIRQVR GL 0RQWHFFKLR= ,SSROLWR VLJQRUH GL %UHVFHOOR HUD GLYHQXWR FDUGLQDOH H )UDQFHVFR/ LQIHXGDWR GL 0DVVDORPEDUGD/ QRQ DYHYD ODVFLDWR FKH XQD ILJOLD QDWXUDOH1 $O FRQWUDULR $OIRQVR/ LO FXL IHXGR GL 0RQWHFFKLR HUD VWDWR HOHYDWR D PDUFKHVDWR QHO 4895/ DYHYD DYXWR &HVDUH GDOOD PRJOLH *LXOLD GHOOD 5RYHUH1 $QFKH VH LO PDWULPRQLR GL TXHVW·XOWLPR FRQ ²²²²²²²² 6;
,FRQRJUDILD HVWHQVH/ FLW1/ F1 43UY +OD QXPHUD]LRQH q PLD,1 31 35,6&,$1,/ +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH/ 9,,/ FLW1/ F1 49U1 73 (* SUREDELPHQWH SDUWH GHO JUXSSR )UDJPHQWD URPDQDUXP DQWLTXLWDWXP GLOLJHQWHU GH0 VFULSWD1 ,OOXVWULXP PDUFKLRQXP (VWHQVLXP RULJR HW JHQHDORJLD/ SURSULHWj SULYDWD/ FRQ XQ H0 [FXUVXV VWRULFR VXOOD IDPLJOLD WUDWWR GDOO*+LVWRULD FRPLWLVVDH 0DWKLOGLV GL 3DQHWWL1 1RQ PL q VWDWR SRVVLELOH FRQVXOWDUH O*RSHUD/ GHVFULWWD LQ (1 0,/$12/ *HQHDORJLD H JHQHDORJLH1 'RFXPHQWL SHU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FDVD G*(VWH/ LQ &RPPHQWDULR DO FRGLFH«FLW1/ S1 5< H 01 5,&&,/ ,O OLEUR H LO PRQXPHQWR= PLQLDWXUH HG LVFUL]LRQL SHU OD JORULD GHJOL (VWHQVL/ LQ *OL (VWHQVL1 /D FRUWH111 FLW1/ S1 59:1 0LOHQD 5LFFL PL KD FRQIHUPDWR FKH OD JHQHDORJLD ULVDOH DOO*HSRFD GL $OIRQVR ,,1 6<
;49
/DXUD 7XUFKL
XQD 0HGLFL VHJQz OD ILQH GHOOD TXHVWLRQH GL SUHFHGHQ]D/ L JUDQGXFKL IHFHUR FRPXQTXH SHVDUH OD YLWWRULD RWWHQXWD FRQWUR L ULYDOL HG LO VDQJXH QRQ GHO WXW0 WR SXUR GHOOR VSRVR/ FRQFHGHQGRJOL LQ PRJOLH VROR 9LUJLQLD/ ILJOLD QDWXUDOH GHO JUDQGXFD &RVLPR1 4XHVWD YROWD/ SHU WDPSRQDUH OD FULVL VXFFHVVRULD SUR0 YRFDWD GD XQ HUHGH GL RULJLQL LOOHJLWWLPH/ RFFRUUHYD PDQRPHWWHUH OD WUDGL]LR0 QH HUFXOHD LQ PDWHULD GL OHJLWWLPLWj H SULPRJHQLWXUD/ DFFUHGLWDQGR O·HVLVWHQ]D GL DOPHQR XQD OLQHD FDGHWWD LQ JUDGR GL VXEHQWUDUH D TXHOOD GL (UFROH ,,1 /D UHFHQWH WUDGL]LRQH DJQDWL]LD GL )DOOHWWL H 3LJQD HUD LQVHUYLELOH/ DQ]L/ FRQWUR0 SURGXFHQWH> 3ULVFLDQL DYHYD G·DOWUR FDQWR VFRUSRUDWR O·DVVH IHPPLQLOH GDOO·DOEHUR GHL VLJQRUL/ LJQRUDQGR GL SURSRVLWR OD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH SHU XQLWj IDPLOLDUL1 1RQ UHVWDYD TXLQGL FKH UHLQYHQWDUH LO SUHFHGHQWH GHO 47:7/ DOOR VFRSR GL FUHDUH FRO ILQWR ULFRUGR G·XQD PRJOLH LQHVLVWHQWH XQ QXRYR HUHGH= FDGHWWR VL/ PD OHJLWWLPR1 /D SROLWLFD SRQWLILFLD FRURQDWD GDOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD/ LO SURJUHVVLYR FRQWUROOR HFFOHVLDVWLFR VXO PDWULPRQLR GRSR LO FRQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR H OH ORJLFKH GL SDWULOLJQDJJLR UHVHUR LUUHDOL]]DELOH LO SURJHWWR GL $O0 IRQVR ,, VXO SLDQR GHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH1 /·DVVHQ]D GL ULWUDWWL GD TXDVL WXWWL L PH0 GDJOLRQL GL QXRYR FRQLR SURYD QRQGLPHQR LO GLVDJLR GL ULSRUWDUH LQ YLWD XQD PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD FKH SUHVXPHYD XQD GLYHUVD FRQFH]LRQH GHOOD SDUHQWHOD H GHO WHPSR/ XQD PLQRU LQVLVWHQ]D VXL GLVFHQGHQWL 0 FLRq SURSULR VXO SUREOH0 PD FKH V·LQWHQGHYD ULVROYHUH 0 HG XQD YDORUL]]D]LRQH HVFOXVLYD GHOOH PRJOL UHDOPHQWH HVLVWLWH1 'DWR OR VWUHWWR UDSSRUWR LQVWDXUDWRVL IUD PRJOL HG HUHGL VLD QHOOD SUDVVL VXFFHVVRULD FKH QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD/ OD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH WHRULFD GHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD 0 RVVLD O·DVVHQ]D GL HUHGL OHJLWWLPL 0 DYUHEEH GRYXWR DVVHVWDUH LO FROSR ILQDOH DOOD YHFFKLD PHPRULD PDWULPRQLDOH1 'L FHUWR LO FDP0 ELR GHOOD FDSLWDOH GHFDSLWz D OXQJR OD PHPRULD SULQFLSHVFD H FRVWLWXu XQ WUDXPD FXOWXUDOH SHU JOL VWHVVL IHUUDUHVL/ FRQVLGHUDWR LO UXROR GHOOD FLWWj QHOOD SUDVVL H QHOOD OHJLWWLPD]LRQH GHO JRYHUQR GXFDOH741 $ TXHVWR SXQWR/ ELVRJQD WXWWDYLD ULFRUGDUH FKH WUDQQH LO FDVR SHFXOLDUH GL 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD/ OH PRJOL/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GHL ORUR PDULWL/ QRQ SRWHYDQR HVVHU LGHQWLILFDWH Qp FRQ )HUUDUD Qp FRQ DOWUH FLWWj/ HVVHQGR FRVWLWXWLYDPHQWH LO WUDPLWH IUD GXH FDVDWH1 3HUFLz/ DVVRUELWR LO FROSR GHO 48<;/ L PDWULPRQL WRUQDURQR XQ·XOWLPD YROWD DOOD ULEDO0 WD1 &DFFLD DG XQ PDWULPRQLR LQHVLVWHQWH ²²²²²²²² 74 3HU XQ HVHPSLR/ 6XFFHVVL RFFRUVL QHOOD FLWWj GL )HUUDUD O*DQQR 48<: GDOOD PRUWH GHO VHUHQLVVLPR $OIRQVR G*(VWH%/ $602/ %LEO1/ PV1 91
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;4:
)HUUDUD ILQu SHU VRSUDYYLYHUH QHOOD PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD HVWHQVH FRPH XQ IRVVLOH/ SUHVWLJLRVR PD GHIXQWR1 3HU L SULPL GHFHQQL GHO 6HLFHQWR/ SHUz/ LO PL0 UDJJLR GHOOD VXD ULFRQTXLVWD IRPHQWz OD ULFHUFD GHOOH VHULH SHUGXWH GHOO·DUFKLYLR GXFDOH1 1HOOH FRQWLQXH ULVWUXWWXUD]LRQL VXELWH GDO FDVWHOOR VRWWR L SRQWHILFL/ IDVFL GL FDUWH FRQWLQXDYDQR D ULDSSDULUH GLHWUR GRSSL PXUL H SDYL0 PHQWL VIRQGDWL/ SURSULR FRPH GD ´VHSROWXUH GL PRUWLµ/ REEOLJDQGR L ILGXFLDUL GXFDOL D YLVLWH QRWWXUQH H D WUDWWDWLYH FODQGHVWLQH/ SXU GL UHFXSHUDUOL1 $QFRUD VRWWR $OIRQVR ,,, VL FRQWLQXDYD LQIDWWL D FHUFDUH O·DWWR GL PDWULPRQLR IUD /DX0 UD 'LDQWL HG LO GXFD $OIRQVR ,/ SHU SUHGLVSRUUH XQ GRVVLHU FKH GLPRVWUDVVH DOOH FRUWL G·(XURSD LO EXRQ GLULWWR GHJOL (VWH VX )HUUDUD751 ,QVLHPH DOOH JORULH GL 0DWLOGH GL &DQRVVD/ TXHVW·DIIDQQRVD/ LQXWLOH FDFFLD ID GD FRQWUDOWDUH DOO·HFOLVVL JHQHDORJLFD FDODWD VXOOH GXFKHVVH ILQWDQWRFKp OD SRVL]LRQH GHOOD IDPLJOLD QHO QXRYR VWDWR QRQ VL IX ULQVDOGDWD761 &HVDUH G·(VWH DYHYD IDWWR SRFKL/ FRQWUDG0 GLWWRUL WHQWDWLYL SHU FHUWLILFDUVL FRPH GLVFHQGHQWH GD $OIRQVR , LQ OLQHD GLUHWWD PDVFKLOH H YLFHYHUVD SHU VRVWHQHUH LPSOLFLWDPHQWH OD WHVL GHOOH QR]]H GHOOD 'LDQWL771 ,O IDOOLPHQWR GL HQWUDPEH TXHVWH VWUDWHJLH q SDOSDELOH QHOO·HOLPLQD]LRQH GL RJQL DFFHQQR DOOH PRJOL GDOO·DOEHUR GL $OIRQVR ,,, +495;0 495<,/ FKH FRQVHUYD SHUz LO ULFRUGR GHOOH ILJOLH/ SHU YLD GHL WLWROL JXDGDJQDWL GDO FDVDWR JUD]LH DOOH ORUR QR]]H781 3L• PRWLYL IDYRULURQR OD OHQWD ULFRPSDUVD GHL PDWULPRQL QHOOD WUDVPLVVLR0 QH GHOOD PHPRULD/ D FRPLQFLDUH GDJOL VSRQVDOL GHOOH DJQDWH1 /·LPSRUWDQ]D GHO0 OH GRWL q LO SL• RYYLR/ PD QRQ EDVWD1 'L IDWWR/ OH DOOHDQ]H QX]LDOL FRQWLQXDYDQR D VHUYLUH XQD PHQWDOLWj QRELOLDUH FKH DVVHJQDYD JUDQGH LPSRUWDQ]D DOOD SX0 UH]]D GHO VDQJXH H SHUVLVWHYD QHOO·XWLOL]]DUH L OHJDPL GL DIILQLWj 0 HG LQ JHQHUD0 OH GL SDUHQWHOD 0 SHU TXDOLILFDUH VX VFDOD HXURSHD XQ UXROR GL pOLWH1 ,Q VHGH ORFDOH/ O·LQWHQVD SROLWLFD GL SDWURQDJH DUWLVWLFR H FXOWXUDOH GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ PRUWR ²²²²²²²² 75
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
;4;
/DXUD 7XUFKL
FDOH/ O·LQWHQVD SROLWLFD GL SDWURQDJH DUWLVWLFR H FXOWXUDOH GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ PRUWR QHO 498;/ DYHYD LQROWUH ULQVDQJXDWR LO OXVWUR GHL GXFKL GL 0RGHQD791 3HU TXH0 VWR O·DOEHUR JHQHDORJLFR IDWWR SXEEOLFDUH QHO 4993 DOOR VWDPSDWRUH GXFDOH %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL ULVSHFFKLD OD SRVL]LRQH RUPDL VWDELOH GHL GXFKL QHO QXRYR SULQFLSDWR/ DFFRPSDJQDQGR DOFXQL VDOGL HOHPHQWL GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJL0 FD FLQTXHFHQWHVFD FRQ GLYHUVH QRYLWj7:1 , SULPL VRQR HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH UDSSUHVHQWDWL GDO UHFXSHUR GHL URPDQL $WLL FRPH SURJHQLWRUL H GDOO·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GL 0DWLOGH FRPH DJQDWD/ FRQVDQJXLQHD H PRJOLH G·XQ (VWH1 )UD OH UHODWLYH QRYLWj/ VL FRQWD O·DPSLR VSD]LR GHGLFDWR D WXWWH OH FRQVRUWL LQ XQLWj IDPLOLDUL JHUDUFKLFKH SRVWH VRWWR O·HJLGD GHL PDULWL/ D ULSURYD GHOO·LPSRUWDQ]D DQQHVVD DL PDWULPRQL GDOOD SHUFH]LRQH JHQWLOL]LD GHOO·LGHQWLWj1 1HOOR VWHVVR VHQVR YD OHWWD OD YDORUL]]D]LRQH GHOOD SULPD H GHOOD WHU]D PRJOLH GL $]]R ,9 +&XQHJRQGD GL %DYLHUD H O·LPPDJLQLILFD *LXGLWWD/ ILJOLD GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH &RUUDGR ,,, FRPH DQWHQDWH GHL *XHOIL EDYDUHVL H GHL ORUR FXJLQL/ L PDUFKHVL G·(VWH1 /·DOEHUR GHO 4993 q LQROWUH LO SULPR D IDU ODUJR XVR GHL VDQWL GL IDPLJOLD/ PD WUDVFXUD GL SURSRVLWR OH GXH EHDWH %HDWULFL/ SHU ULFLFODUH FRUDJJLRVDPHQWH 6DQ &RQWDUGR +FKH JLj %RUVR G·(VWH DYHYD LQYDQR WHQWDWR GL IDU FDQRQL]]DUH QHO VHFRQGR 4XDWWURFHQWR, HG DJJLXQJHUJOL/ IUHVFKL GL FRQLR/ L IUDWHOOL $OGURYDQGLQR 9 HG $]]R ;,,, +VLF,/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH YHVFRYR H PDUFKHVH GL )HUUDUD QHO ;,9 VHFROR1 5DPL UREXVWL SHU VFHWWUL UHJDOL 6H FL VLDPR VRIIHUPDWL D OXQJR VXOOD ULFRVWUX]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD GHO 4993/ q SHUFKq FRVWLWXLVFH LO ORJLFR SUHFHGHQWH G·XQD JHQHDORJLD ILQRUD WUD0 VFXUDWD/ FKH HQIDWL]]D LQ PRGR GHFLVDPHQWH LQQRYDWLYR L PRWLYL GHO OXVWUR PDWULPRQLDOH H GHOOD VDQWLWj GLQDVWLFD7; +ILJ1 7,1 /D FHUQLHUD IUD OH GXH RSHUH q ²²²²²²²² 79
-1 6287+251/ 3RZHU DQG 'LVSOD\ 111FLW1/ SS1 5;0:41 $602/ *61/ E1 8<1 &IU1 21 520%$/',/ ,O GXFD )UDQFHVFR , G*(VWH+495<0498;,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<5> ,'1/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GL XQ VHFROR GL JRYHUQR HVWHQVH D 0RGHQD H D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<81 7; /*$TXLOD JUDQGH/ SLHQD H YDULD GL SLXPH RYHUR GRYL]LD H YDULHWj GL DWWHJQHQ]H FKH OD VHUHQLVVLPD FDVD G*(VWH FRQJLXQJRQR DOOH PDJJLRUL FRUWL VDQWH G*(XURSD H G*$VLD111/ $602/ *61/ E1 94/ 4; FF1/ FRQ XQ PRQFRQH G*DOEHUR JHQHDORJLFR> QH HVLVWH XQ DOWUR IUDPPHQWR QHOOD E1 95/ IDVF1 %&DVD GXFDOH1 )DPLJOLD1 6WRULD%/ 7 FF1 Q1Q1 $OOD F1 7Y/ F*q XQD QRWD GL FDQFHOOHULD= %&RQ OD OHWWHUD GHO 4: DJR0 VWR GHO SDGUH *DPEHUWL%1 ,O WLWROR GHOO*RSHUD q ULIHULWR D (]HFKLHOH/ 4:/ 6043/ TXL FLWDWR FRPH VHYHUR PRQLWR FRQWUR FKL LQIUDQJH OH DOOHDQ]H FKH KD VWLSXODWR1 9D QRWDWR FKH DO FHQWUR GHOOD YLVLRQH GHO SURIHWD Y*q O*DOEHUR GL FHGUR GHOOD VWLUSH G*,VUDHOH/ IDFLOPHQWH DVVLPLODELOH DG XQ 7:
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;4<
VHQ]D GXEELR OD ULVWUXWWXUD]LRQH GHOOD FKLHVD GL 61 $JRVWLQR H VRSUDWWXWWR GHO0 OD VXD IDFFLDWD/ YROXWD GD /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L YHGRYD GL $OIRQVR ,9/ TXDQGR QHO 4995 GLYHQQH UHJJHQWH1 $XWRUH GHO SURJUDPPD GHFRUDWLYR IX LO JHVXLWD 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL/ FXL JLj $OIRQVR ,9 DYHYD FRPPLVVLRQDWR OD GLUH]LRQH GHOOH FHULPRQLH SHU OH HVHTXLH GHO SDGUH )UDQFHVFR , HG XQD ELRJUDILD HQFR0 PLDVWLFD/ FKH ULFDSLWRODVVH OH YLUW• GHO GHIXQWR GXFD/ ULFROOHJDQGROH D VXRL H0 SLVRGL ELRJUDILFL H DG DQWHQDWL VSHFLILFL7<1 $OOD PRUWH GHO PDULWR/ OD GXFKHVVD YHGRYD H WXWULFH GHO IXWXUR )UDQFHVFR ,, QRQ DYHYD VROR DIILGDWR D *DPEHUWL O·RUD]LRQH IXQHEUH83 H O·LGHD]LRQH GHOO·DSSDUDWR IXQHUDULR> WHUPLQDWH OH FHUL0 PRQLH/ DYHYD DQFKH GHFLVR GL WUDVIRUPDUH OD FKLHVD QHOOD WRPED GL IDPLJOLD/ FRQVHUYDQGR DOOD IDFFLDWD O·DVSHWWR GL XQ SDQWKHRQ GL VDQWL DQWHQDWL HVWHQVL841 /·RULJLQDULD LPSURQWD DJLRJUDILFD VL PDQWHQQH DQFKH QHOOD JHQHDORJLD/ FRQ0 JLXQWD SHUz LQWLPDPHQWH DO WHPD PDWULPRQLDOH/ YLVWR O·LQWHUHVVH VXVFLWDWR QHO0 OD UHJJHQWH GD XQD ELRJUDILD GHO *DPEHUWL VXOOD EHDWD 5LFKLOGD/ FRQWHVVD GL %DUFHOORQD H GLVFHQGHQWH SHU YLD PDWHUQD QLHQWHPHQR FKH GD &DUOR 0DJQR851 1p SRWHYD HVVHUH GLYHUVDPHQWH/ YLVWH OH RULJLQL GHOOD GXFKHVVD= VXD PDGUH 0DUJKHULWD HUD VRUHOOD GHO FDUGLQDOH *LXOLR 0D]]DULQR1 &RPH JLj SHU OD ELR0 JUDILD GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ OH ULFHUFKH GL *DPEHUWL GRYHWWHUR HVVHU IDFLOLWDWH GDO ODYRUR GHO ELEOLRWHFDULR GXFDOH /XGRYLFR 7DJOLDYLQL/ GD TXHOOR VWHVVR 4995 DGGHWWR DOO·DUFKLYLR VHJUHWR GXFDOH SHU RUGLQH GHOOD UHJJHQWH/ DIILQFKp FRP0 ²²²²²²²²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qTXH GH OD &RPSDJQLH GH -qVXV/ ,,,/ %UX[HO0 OHV03DULV/ 2VFDU 6FKHSHQV ² $OSKRQVH 3LFDUG/ 4;<6/ SS1 44860871 )UD OH RSHUH LQHGLWH q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
;53
/DXUD 7XUFKL
SOHWDVVH LO JUDQGH UHSHUWRULR DUFKLYLVWLFR DYYLDWR GD 1LFFROz 6XVDUL861 4XDQWR FL ULPDQH GHO ODYRUR YROXWR GD /DXUD FRPELQD O·HORJLR GHL PDWUL0 PRQL FRPH FRORQQD SRUWDQWH GHOOD JORULD IDPLOLDUH FRO ULFRQRVFLPHQWR DOOH GRQQH GHOOD FDVD 0 PRJOL H DJQDWH 0 G·HVVHUH LO FDUGLQH GL TXHOO·LGHQWLWj JHQWLOL0 ]LD FXL O·DULVWRFUD]LD HXURSHD WDQWR WHQHYD1 1HOO·LQWURGX]LRQH DL GXH WRPL SURJHWWDWL/ O·DXWRUH VRVWHQQH LQIDWWL FKH GHL WUH HOHPHQWL EDVH GHOOD QRELOWj 0 DQWLFKLWj/ DOOHDQ]H PDWULPRQLDOL/ JORULD GL JHVWD 0 L VHFRQGL FRQWDYDQR SL• GL WXWWR/ JLDFFKq O·HFR GHOOH LPSUHVH SXz VELDGLUH QHL VHFROL H TXDQWR DOO·DQWLFKLWj/ VL SXz GLPRVWUDUOD VROR FRQ ULSHWXWL PDWULPRQL FKH HOXGDQR LO URYLQRVR WUDVFRUUHUH GHO WHPSR871 $ PDJJLRU UDJLRQH/ ´6H LQVLJQL HG DSSUH]0 ]DWLVVLPH GD PRQDUFKL SL• JUDQGL ULHVFRQR TXHOOH FRPPHVVXUH JHQHDORJLFKH OH TXDOL SURYDQR DOOH ORUR VWLUSL O·HVVHUVL FRQJLXQWH FRQ OHJDPL VFDPELHYROL O·DOWUH WXWWH111µ/ QRQ Y·q GXEELR FKH DQFKH SL• JUDGLWR GHEED ULXVFLUH XQ ´OD0 YRULR D SDUDJRQH GHO VXGGHWWR 111 UDULVVLPRµ= TXHOOR/ FLRq/ FKH ´QHOOH PLVWH JHQHDORJLH 111 VL DGRSHUD D WHUPLQDUH LQ SULQFLSL H UHJQDQWL VDQWL/ GRSSLDPHQWH LPSRUSRUDWLµ/ SHU QDWXUD H SHU JUD]LD881 3RLFKp OD QRELOWj FHOHVWH q VXSHULRUH D TXHOOD WHUUHQD/ q FKLDUR FKH O·DQWHQDWR VDQWR SXULILFD DQFKH LO VDQJXH SL• SOHEHR> G·DOWUR FDQWR/ FRQQHWWHUH VDQWL H EHDWL DOOH IDPLJOLH GHL JRYHUQDQWL UL0 GRQGD DQWLFKLWj/ SRLFKp OD GHFDGHQ]D GHL WHPSL KD IDOFLGLDWR OH PLOL]LH GHOOD YHUD IHGH891 &XOWR JHQHDORJLFR GHJOL DQWHQDWL H IHGH FDWWROLFD VL ULXQLVFRQR FRVu LQ XQ·HVHUFLWR GL VDQWH +H VDQWL,/ FKH JUD]LH DOOH GHYRWH PRJOL HVWHQVL VD0 FUDOL]]DQR/ QRELOLWDQR H VSURIRQGDQR LQ XQ 0HGLRHYR FULVWLDQR0EDUEDULFR OH RULJLQL GHJOL (VWH1 ,Q OLQHD FRO JRWLFLVPR FDWWROLFR HG DULVWRFUDWLFR GHO VHFRQ0 GR 6HLFHQWR/ LO PRQFRQH ULPDVWRFL GHOO·DOEHUR JHQHDORJLFR SURFXUD TXLQGL DL GXFKL GL 0RGHQD DQWHQDWL JHUPDQLFL/ SDUWHQGR GD XQ SURJHQLWRUH D ORUR ID0 PLOLDUH VLQ GDOOH ULFHUFKH GL PHWj &LQTXHFHQWR SHU OD TXHVWLRQH GL SUHFHGHQ0 ]D= :LWLNLQGR/ FDSRVWLSLWH GHL VDVVRQL *XHOIL8: +ILJ1 8,1 4XHVWR LQHGLWR ULQQRYR GHOOD WHPDWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH QH VYHOD G·DOWURQGH ²²²²²²²² 86 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ $6(/ ,/ YRO1 : LQ GXH WRPL SHU LO UHSHUWRULR/ ,,/ E1 :/ OHWW1 OXJ1 498< GL /XGRYLFR 7DJOLDYLQL H OHWW1 4 DJ1 4995 FRQ FXL OD UHJJHQWH QRPLQD DUFKLYLVWD OR VWHV0 VR/ FKH YL ULPDVH FRQ VLFXUH]]D ILQR DOO*DJRVWR 49;3/ FIU1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ 3DUWLFRODUL/ E1 4686/ IDVF1 %7DJOLDYLQL H 7DOLDYLQL%1 87 /*$TXLOD JUDQGH111/ FF1 405 GHO IUDPPHQWR QHOOD E1 941 88 ,ELG1/ F1 :1 89 ,ELG1/ FF1 :0;1 8: *1 &267$/ /H DQWLFKLWj JHUPDQLFKH QHOOD FXOWXUD LWDOLDQD GD 0DFKLDYHOOL D 9LFR/ 1DSROL/ %L0 EOLRSROLV/ 4<::/ SS1 4<505641 6XL VDVVRQL/ Y1 DG HVHPSLR/ $1 6$5',/ /H VXFFHVVLRQL GHL SULQ0 FLSL G*(XURSD111/ %(02/ PV1 ,W1 759 ¡1*17153/ FF1 5;305<7/ 5<80634/ 75607731
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;54
O·LPSOLFLWD FRQWUDGGLWWRULHWj DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH JHQHDORJLH SULQFLSHVFKH1 (· YH0 UR/ OD OHJLWWLPD]LRQH VXO SLDQR GHOOD SDUHQWHOD FHOHVWH GHOOH DOOHDQ]H PDWULPR0 QLDOL WHUUHQH FRQVHQWLYD LO UHFXSHUR GL SDWULPRQL LGHDOL OHJDWL DL VDQWL G·DOWUH GLQDVWLH8;1 7XWWDYLD/ SURSULR SHUFKp L PDWULPRQL VRQR DOOD EDVH GHOO·LQWHUR H0 GLILFLR/ OD GLIILFROWj FRVWUXWWLYD q HYLGHQWH= QRQ VL WUDWWD SL• GL ULVFRSULUH OH R0 ULJLQL GL XQD IDPLJOLD VROD/ PD G·LPSDUHQWDUOD FRQ OH QRELOL VWLUSL GL WXWWD (X0 URSD/ SULPD WUDPLWH OH PRJOL GHJOL (VWH/ SRL DWWUDYHUVR OH SULQFLSHVVH H OH UH0 JLQH/ EHDWH R DQFRU PHJOLR VDQWH/ PD SHU OR SL• VSRVDWH1 /·DQWLFD LGHD GHO PDWULPRQLR FRPH IRQWH GL SUHVWLJLR H UHOD]LRQL GLSORPD0 WLFKH VX VFDOD HXURSHD/ FRVu IRUWH QHOO·RSHUD GL 3DROR GD /LJQDJR PD JLj LP0 SOLFLWD QHJOL DOEHUL GL 3ULVFLDQL H SRL FRPSUHVVD QHOOD VWHOH WUDFFLDWD GD )DOOHWWL/ VL ULWURYD TXL HVWUHPL]]DWD/ D FRVWLWXLUH O·DVVH SRUWDQWH GL WXWWR LO ODYRUR1 /D GLYHUVLWj FRQ OD JHQHDORJLD GHO 4993 QRQ SRWUHEEH HVVHUH PDJJLRUH/ GDO PR0 PHQWR FKH LQ HVVD OH VROH IDPLJOLH DFFHWWDWH FRPH FRQJLXQWH VRQR JOL HVWLQWL/ IDYRORVL UH IUDQFHVL GHOO·$TXLOD ELDQFD/ LPSDUHQWDWL HVFOXVLYDPHQWH SHU YLD PDVFKLOH HG L %UXQVZLFN0/XHQHEXUJ GLVFHQGHQWL GDL *XHOIL WUDPLWH *XHOIR/ ILJOLR GL $]]R ,9 G·(VWH H GHOOD VXD SULPD PRJOLH= &XQHJRQGD GHL *XHOIL GL %DYLHUD1 *DPEHUWL q EHQ FRQVDSHYROH GHOOD GLIILFROWj QHO PHWWHUH OH DOOHDQ]H QX]LDOL DOOD EDVH GL WXWWR= ´XQ WUDYDJOLR VWHQWDWLVVLPR 111 VXOOH OLQHH WRUWXRVH GL DVVDLVVLPH GLVFHQGHQ]Hµ/ YLVWR FKH REEOLJD D WHQHU GLHWUR DJOL LPSUHYHGLELOL SHUFRUVL GHO VDQJXH IHPPLQLOH1 6D FKH ULVFKLD GL IRU]DUH ROWUH LO OLPLWH OD IRUPD0DOEHUR SHU GDU YLWD DG XQ ERVFR/ IRUVH DG XQD VHOYD LQHVWULFDWD8<1 ,PSRVVLELOH DG HVHPSLR HYLWDUH VTXLOL0 EUL QHJOL DOEHUL GHOOH SULQFLSHVVH HG LQ TXHOOR JHQHUDOH GHL VDQWL= OH GRQQH QRQ KDQQR WXWWH OD VWHVVD IHUWLOLWj1 6L DFFLQJH SHUFLz DG HYLWDUH LO SHULFROR/ DUWLFR0 ODQGR LO ODYRUR LQ XQD VHULH GL TXDUDQWD ELRJUDILH GL PRJOL H ILJOLH HVWHQVL PH0 ULWHYROL G·DYHU LPSDUHQWDWR OD IDPLJOLD GHL PDULWL FRQ VHLFHQWRFLQTXDQWD VDQ0 WL2H1 $OOH ELRJUDILH DYUHEEHUR IDWWR VHJXLWR DOWUHWWDQWL DOEHUL PLVWL/ LQ FXL HYL0 GHQ]LDUH OH VDQWH SDUHQWHOH DSSRUWDWH GDOOH SULQFLSHVVH R GDL ORUR GLVFHQGHQWL1 (UDQR LQILQH SUHYLVWL DSSRVLWL FDSLWROL VX WXWWL L VDQWL FHQVLWL/ XQ ORUR DOEHUR FRPSOHVVLYR H WDYROH ULDVVXQWLYH SHU VSLHJDUQH L UDSSRUWL QX]LDOL FRQ JOL (VWH/ LQ PRGR FKH GL WDOH SRGHURVD ULFRVWUX]LRQH VL SRWHVVH GLUH FLz FKH (]HFKLHOH DYHYD GHWWR GHO SRSROR G·,VUDHOH DL VXRL WHPSL IHOLFL= ´HEEH UDPL UREXVWL/ ²²²²²²²² 8; 61 &$%,%%2/ /D VDQWLWj IHPPLQLOH GLQDVWLFD/ LQ 'RQQH H IHGH/ D FXUD GL /1 6&$5$)),$0*1 =$55,/ 5RPD0%DUL/ /DWHU]D/ 4<<7/ SS1 6<<074; H ELEOLRJUDILD LYL FRQWHQXWD1 8< /*$TXLOD JUDQGH111/ FF1 :/ <043 GHO IUDPPHQWR QHOOD E1 941
;55
/DXUD 7XUFKL
EXRQL SHU VFHWWUL UHJDOLµ931 &·q XQD GLIILFROWj FURQRORJLFD1 /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ FKH QHO 4995 DYHYD RW0 WHQXWR GDOO·LPSHUDWRUH /HRSROGR , LO GLULWWR D QRPLQDUH DOWUL WXWRUL GHO ILJOLR IUD L SULQFLSL HVWHQVL/ IX FRVWUHWWD D GHSRUUH OD UHJJHQ]D QHO 49:7/ QRQ DSSHQD )UDQFHVFR ,, UDJJLXQVH L TXDWWRUGLFL DQQL FKH GHFUHWDYDQR OD ILQH GHOOD WXWHOD PDWHUQD1 (OHPHQWL LQWHUQL DOO·RSHUD GHO *DPEHUWL FRVu FRPH FL q JLXQWD LQGX0 FRQR D VSRVWDUOD DL VHFRQGL DQQL RWWDQWD= IUD HVVL/ OD PHQ]LRQH GHO FDUGLQDODWR SHU LO IXWXUR 5LQDOGR , +IUDWHOOR GL $OIRQVR ,9,/ RWWHQXWR QHO 49;9941 ,QROWUH OD VFHOWD GHO FDSRVWLSLWH HXURSHR GL VDQWL H SULQFLSL HUD DOOD ILQH FDGXWD VX :LWL0 NLQGR H QRQ VX &DUORPDJQR/ FRPH VDUHEEH VWDWR ORJLFR VXSSRUUH/ YLVWH OH R0 ULJLQL GL /DXUD HG LO VXR RULJLQDULR LQWHUHVVH SHU OD ELRJUDILD GL 5LFKLOGD1 ,Q UHDOWj/ OD JHQHDORJLD DYYLDWD QHO 4995 VL DUHQz FLQTXH DQQL GRSR SHU OH SUHVVLRQL GHOOD GXFKHVVD/ DQVLRVD GL YHGHU ILQLWD OD SDUWH UHODWLYD DOOH ELRJUDILH GHOOH SULQFLSHVVH FRQVRUWL HG DL ORUR PDWULPRQL951 , GXH UHYLVRUL QRPLQDWL SHU FRUUHJJHUH LO ODYRUR GL *DPEHUWL VRWWR OD JXLGD GHO JHVXLWD $QGUHD *DULPEHU0 WL/ FRQIHVVRUH GHOOD UHJJHQWH/ VL ULILXWDURQR GL FRQWLQXDUH QHOO·RSHUD GL HPHQ0 GDPHQWR961 &RVu/ QHO 49:3 O·DXWRUH VH QH DQGz GD 0RGHQD/ SRUWDQGR FRQ Vp OR VFULWWR LQFRPSLXWR1 /·DYUHEEH ULSUHVHQWDWR GLFLDVVHWWH DQQL GRSR/ TXDQGR JUD]LH DL EXRQL UDSSRUWL FRO FDUGLQDOH 5LQDOGR/ VL YLGH FRPPLVVLRQDUH GDO GX0 FD )UDQFHVFR ,, OD GLUH]LRQH GHOOH FHULPRQLH SHU LO IXQHUDOH GHOOD PDGUH971 ,Q HIIHWWL/ XQD VLIIDWWD ULFRJQL]LRQH VWRULFD VL DGDWWDYD EHQH DOO·LQGROH G·XQD GRQQD FKH/ QRQ DSSHQD FHUWD GHOO·HUHGLWj GHO FDUGLQDOH 0D]]DULQR/ DYHYD GH0 FLVR QHO 4994 GL FRPSUDUVL LO IHXGR GL *XDOWLHUL GDOOD &DPHUD GXFDOH/ FRQ ID0 FROWj GL VFHJOLHUVL LO VXFFHVVRUH LQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDO VHVVR H GDO YLQFROR GHOOD SULPRJHQLWXUD981 &RVWUHWWD DG DEEDQGRQDUH OD UHJJHQ]D/ OD GXFKHVVD D0 YHYD DQFKH WUDWWDWR D OXQJR FRO ILJOLR H FRO IXWXUR 5LQDOGR , SHU RWWHQHUH OD ²²²²²²²² 93 /*$TXLOD JUDQGH111/ FF1 4U07Y GHO IUDPPHQWR QHOOD E1 951 /D FLWD]LRQH GL (]HFKLHOH/ 4</ 44 q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
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;56
UHVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD GRWH HG XQ WHQRUH GL YLWD FRQIRUPH DO VXR UDQJR1 &HUWR VD0 SHYD FKH DYDQ]DUH SUHFHGHQWL LPPHGLDWL SHU OH VXH ULYHQGLFD]LRQL OH VDUHEEH VHUYLWR D SRFR/ SRLFKp VHJXHQGR XQD FRQVXHWXGLQH LQYDOVD QHOOD IDPLJOLD GX0 FDOH/ HOOD VWHVVD DYHYD IDWWR OLTXLGDUH DOOD VXRFHUD /XFUH]LD %DUEHULQL L VROL IUXWWL GRWDOL1 $YHYD DOORUD WHQWDWR FRQ XQR DQWLFR= LO FRQWUDWWR GRWDOH GL 5HQD0 WD GL )UDQFLD/ FXL LO VXRFHUR $OIRQVR , DYHYD GRYXWR SURPHWWHUH XQD FRVSLFXD FRQWURGRWH1 /D VWL]]LWD UHSOLFD GHL )DWWRUL GXFDOL LOOXVWUD DGHJXDWDPHQWH O·HYROX]LRQH GHOOH SUDWLFKH PDWULPRQLDOL QHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH1 /H ULFKLHVWH GHOO·H[0UHJJHQWH HUDQR D ORUR SDUHUH LQJLXVWLILFDWH= QRQ F·HUD OD ´SURSRUWLRQHµ GHO PDWULPRQLR/ JLDFFKq /DXUD QRQ SRWHYD FHUWR SDUDJRQDUVL DG XQD ILJOLD GL UH/ Qq L GXFKL GL 0RGHQD SRWHYDQR FRQIURQWDUVL FRQ L ORUR ULFFKL DQWHQDWL IHU0 UDUHVL1 ,QROWUH/ TXHOOR IUD OHL HG LO PDULWR $OIRQVR ,9 HUD VWDWR XQ PDWULPRQLR IUD XJXDOL/ FRPH VH Q·HUDQR FRPELQDWL SHUVLQR VLQ GD SULPD GHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD= LO ULIHULPHQWR q D 0DUJKHULWD *RQ]DJD/ XOWLPD PRJOLH GL $OIRQVR ,,991 1HPPHQR TXHVWD VHFRQGD YROWD OD JHQHDORJLD YLGH OD OXFH1 1HO 49;;/ VXJOL DGGREEL IXQHEUL LGHDWL GD *DPEHUWL SHU OD FHULPRQLD FRPPHPRUDWLYD GHOOD GHIXQWD +VHSROWD FRPH HVXOH YRORQWDULD D 5RPD XQ DQQR SULPD,/ L VHJQL GHOO·DSSDUWHQHQ]D DOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH IXURQR TXDVL GHO WXWWR DVVHQWL/ QHJDQGR DOOD PRJOLH GL $OIRQVR ,9 FLz FKH SL• OH HUD VWDWR D FXRUH= XQ SRVWR QHOOD JDO0 OHULD VWRULFD GL IDPLJOLD9:1 (SLORJR $O FRQWUDULR GL TXDQWR VRVWHQHYDQR L )DWWRUL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ XQ PDWUL0 PRQLR G·DOWR UDQJR F·HUD VWDWR LQ IDPLJOLD/ VHEEHQH LO OXVWUR PDJJLRUH DSSDU0 WHQHVVH DOOR VSRVR1 1HO 49:6 0DULD %HDWULFH/ VRUHOOD PDJJLRUH GHO GXFD/ HUD DQGDWD VSRVD D *LDFRPR 6WXDUW GXFD GL <RUN/ JUD]LH DOOD QHJR]LD]LRQH GHOOD PDGUH /DXUD H VRSUDWWXWWR DO VRVWHJQR GLSORPDWLFR GHOOD FRUWH GL )UDQFLD1 , FDWWROLFL GXFKL GL <RUN HUDQR GLYHQXWL UH G·,QJKLOWHUUD GRGLFL DQQL GRSR/ SHU0 FLz QHO 49;: *DPEHUWL DYHYD XQ·RWWLPD UDJLRQH SHU ULVRWWRSRUUH DO GXFD GL ²²²²²²²²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
;57
/DXUD 7XUFKL
0RGHQD OD JHQHDORJLD DJLRJUDILFR0PDWULPRQLDOH/ FRJOLHQGR DO YROR OH HVHTXLH GHOO·RULJLQDULD FRPPLWWHQWH1 'LVJUD]LD YROOH FKH DOOD GDPQDWLR PHPRULDH YROXWD GDO GXFD SHU OD UHJJHQ]D GHOOD PDGUH VL DJJLXQJHVVH QHO 49;< O·HVLOLR GHOOD UH0 JLQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD H GHO PDULWR1 $G HVVR HG DOO·DOORQWDQDPHQWR GD FRUWH GL $QJHOD 0DULD &DWHULQD G·(VWH 0 VSRVDWD QHO 49;7 DG (PDQXHOH )LOLEHUWR GL &DULJQDQR FRQWUR LO SDUHUH GL /XL0 JL ;,9 0 VL GHYH LO IHUDOH HOHQFR LQWLWRODWR 1RWL]LH GL WXWWH OH GRQQH GL FDVD G·(VWH PDULWDWH LQ FDVH IRUDVWLHUH1 &RQ LQHFFHSLELOH FRQVHTXHQ]LDOLWj JHQHDORJLFD/ YL VL GDQQR UDJJXDJOL VX WUHQWDVHL PDWULPRQL IDOOLWL LQWUDSUHVL GDOOH DJQDWH HVWHQVL= GD TXHOOR GL 0DUWLD/ PRJOLH GL 2EHOHULR $QWHQRUHR QHO ,; VHFROR DYDQWL &UL0 VWR/ D TXHOOL GHOOD SULQFLSHVVD GL &DULJQDQR H GHOOD UHJLQD 0DULD %HDWULFH9;= PXRLRQR L PDULWL/ L ILJOL/ TXDQGR QRQ DGGLULWWXUD OH PRJOL/ FRPXQTXH LPSRV0 VLELOLWDWH D WUDVIHULUVL VWDELOPHQWH QHOOH WHUUH GHL PDULWL> GD QHVVXQD GL TXHVWH XQLRQL IDWDOL QDVFH XQ HUHGH FKH PHVFROL QHO SURSULR LO VDQJXH GHL FRQLXJL1 (· OD QHJD]LRQH GHO SULQFLSLR PDUWLQR]]LDQR GHOOH DIILQLWj IUD IDPLJOLH/ DSSOLFDWD SHU GL SL• DOOH GRQQH FKH GHOOD FDVDWD VRQR PHPEUL D WXWWL JOL HIIHWWL1 1HO 49<:/ RVVLD GXH DQQL GRSR OH QR]]H GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR , G·(VWH/ VXR DQWLFR SURWHWWRUH/ O·LPSHUWXUEDELOH *DPEHUWL ULSURSRVH DQFRUD OD SXEEOLFD0 ]LRQH GHL VXRL GXH WRPL> VL VSHQVH LQYHFH QHO 4:33/ VHQ]D YHGHUOL SXEEOLFDWL9<1 /H QR]]H GHOO·H[ FDUGLQDOH FRQ &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD GL %UXQVZLFN0/XHQHEXUJ D0 YHYDQR DSHUWR LQIDWWL OD VWDJLRQH GHOOH ULFHUFKH JHQHDORJLFKH GL /HLEQL] H 0X0 UDWRUL1 3HU SDUWH PXUDWRULDQD/ OD ULFHUFD FXOPLQz FRQ OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOH $QWLFKLWj HVWHQVL D SDUWLUH GDO 4:4: H VL FRQFOXVH QHO 4:57 FRQ O·HGL]LRQH GHOOD 9LWD 0DWKLOGLV QHL 5HUXP LWDOLFDUXP VFULSWRUHV/ VX LPLWD]LRQH GHOO·HGL]LRQH OHLEQL0 ]LDQD H GHJOL $QQDOHV EUXQVYLFHQVHV1 3URSULR QHOOH $QWLFKLWj HVWHQVL/ 0XUDWRUL FRQGXVVH XQ DIIRQGR PHWRGRORJLFR FRQWUR JOL LQFUHGLELOLD GHL VXRL SUHGHFHV0 VRUL/ D VXR GLUH LQWHUHVVDWL VROR D VHUYLUH ´OD JORULD H LO FUHGLWR GL TXDOFKH SHU0 VRQD/ FLWWj R IDPLJOLD:3´1 6H DQFRU RJJL TXHVW·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH OLTXLGDWRULD SXz GLUVL FRQGLYLVD/ FLz GLSHQGH GDO FRQWULEXWR GHOO·DQWLTXDULD DOOD ULIRUPD GHO ²²²²²²²² 9;
$602/ *61/ E1 931 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ 5HJRODUL/ E1 7</ IDVF1 %/HWWHUH GL 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL JHVXLWD%/ FDUWHJJLR IUD *DPEHUWL H 5LQDOGR ,1 &RQWLHQH DOWUR PDWHULDOH GHO *DPEHUWL SHU OH FRPPHPR0 UD]LRQL GHO 49;;1 :3 /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOH DQWLFKLWj HVWHQVL HG LWDOLDQH/ 0RGHQD/ 6WDPSHULD GXFDOH/ 4:4:04:73/ 5 YROO1/ YRO1 ,/ S1 ;,1 &IU1 61 %(57(//,/ (UXGL]LRQH H VWRULD LQ /XGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL/ 1DSROL/ ,VWLWXWR LWDOLDQR SHU JOL VWXGL VWRULFL/ 4<93/ SS1 4:7058; VX TXHVWD SDUWH GHOOH ULFHUFKH GL 0X0 UDWRUL H /HLEQL]1 9<
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;58
PHWRGR VWRULFR LQ WHPD GL FULWLFD GHOOH IRQWL:4= DOPHQR QHOOH LQWHQ]LRQL/ OH GLVVHUWD]LRQL VFLHQWLILFKH PXUDWRULDQH YHQQHUR FRVWUXLWH VX GRFXPHQWL SXE0 EOLFL/ LVFUL]LRQL H PRQHWH HVDPLQDWL GLUHWWDPHQWH/ EHQ GLYHUVL GDOOH WHVWLPR0 QLDQ]H OHWWHUDULH FKH DYHYDQR LQIDUFLWR OH SDVVDWH JHQHDORJLH1 (· JLj VWDWR VRVWHQXWR FKH VROR O·,OOXPLQLVPR UXSSH GHILQLWLYDPHQWH FRO SDVVDWR/ HVSHOOHQGR FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH LO SUHVHQWH GDOOD VFULWWXUD GL VWRULD/ FRQ XQD QXRYD H VDOGD FRVFLHQ]D GHO SURFHVVR GL FLYLOL]]D]LRQH:51 /R VFHWWLFL0 VPR GL 0XUDWRUL SHU OH IRQWL YLVLYH FH QH IRUQLVFH XQ·XOWHULRUH SURYD:6/ VR0 SUDWWXWWR VH SHQVLDPR DO SURIRQGR UDSSRUWR IUD VWRULD HG LPPDJLQL FKH OH JHQHDORJLH VRWWHQGRQR= JOL H[HPSOD YLUWXRVL GL FXL HVVH H OH RUD]LRQL IXQHEUL VRQR LQWHVVXWH V·HUDQR IDWWL UHDOWj QHOOH JHQHDORJLH GLSLQWH GHO FDVWHOOR GL )HU0 UDUD1 /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L HUD EHQ FRQVDSHYROH GHO ORUR YDORUH SHUIRUPDWLYR QHL FRQIURQWL GHO SUHVHQWH:7/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH DYHYD FRPPLVVLRQDWR GXH SDQW0 KHRQ GL DQWHQDWL2H/ O·XQR LQ SLHWUD O·DOWUR LQ FDUWD/ FRQ FRQQHVVLRQL VX VFDOD HXURSHD ULVDOHQWL DOO·DOWR 0HGLRHYR1 (UD EHQ FRQVFLD DQFKH GL XQ·DOWUD FRQYHQ]LRQH GL IRQGR GHO JHQHUH/ RVVLD FKH QRQ O·LQGLYLGXR/ EHQVu LO VXR FRQWULEXWR DOOD JORULD GHOOD FDVD q GHJQR GL PHPRULD= RUD/ SHU VHFROL LO FRQWULEXWR IHPPLQLOH HUD FRQVLVWLWR HVVHQ]LDOPHQ0 WH QHO IDUH XQ EXRQ PDWULPRQLR/ FRQ UHODWLYR DSSDQQDJJLR GL WLWROL/ SDUHQWHOH DOWRORFDWH H ULFFKH GRWL1 1p OD UHJJHQWH Qp LO VXR JHQHDORJLVWD SRWHYDQR SHUz LJQRUDUH TXDQWR OD VLWXD]LRQH SROLWLFD GHO SLFFROR VWDWR HVWHQVH H GHOO·,WDOLD WXWWD IRVVH FRQGL]LRQDWD GDL FRQWUDVWL IUD %RUERQH HG $VEXUJR G·$XVWULD= YL0 VWL L UDSSRUWL GL IRU]D/ L PDWULPRQL SRWHYDQR RUPDL VROR JLRYDUH DOOD VRSUDY0 YLYHQ]D GHO GXFDWR QHOOD JUDQGH SROLWLFD HXURSHD:81 ,QFRPSUHQVLELOH DO GL IXRUL G·XQD WUDGL]LRQH JHQHDORJLFD FRQWURYHUVD PD FRPXQTXH IRUWHPHQWH OH0 ²²²²²²²² :4
$1 020,*/,$12/ 6XL IRQGDPHQWL GHOOD VWRULD DQWLFD/ 7RULQR/ (LQDXGL/ 4<;7/ SS1 6078/ 5850
5:31 :5
51 .26(//(&./ )XWXUR SDVVDWR= SHU XQD VHPDQWLFD GHL WHPSL VWRULFL/ *HQRYD/ 0DULHWWL/ 4<;9/ SS1 63087> 51 %,==2&&+,/ *HQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL111 FLWDWD1 &IU1 TXDQWR VRVWHQXWR LQ TXHVWR DUWLFR0 OR FRQ O*DFFHQQR DOOD ILQH GHOOH RULJLQL URPDQH GHJOL (VWH/ LQ 51 %,==2&&+,/ /D QRELOWj LQ 'DQ0 WH/ OD QRELOWj GL 'DQWH1 &XOWXUD QRELOLDUH/ PHPRULD VWRULFD H JHQHDORJLD IUD 0HGLR (YR H 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ LQ ©, 7DWWL 6WXGLHVª/ 7 +4<<4,/ S1 5431 3HU XQ GLYHUVR SDUHUH/ *1 ,$1=,7,/ +XPDQLVP*V 1HZ 6FLHQFH= WKH +LVWRU\ RI WKH )XWXUH/ LQ ©, 7DWWL 6WXGLHVª/ 7 +4<<4,/ SS1 8<0;;1 :6 )1 +$6.(/// /H LPPDJLQL GHOOD VWRULD111/ FLW1/ S1 4831 :7 &IU1 *1 5,&&,/ ,O SULQFLSH H OD PRUWH/ FLW1/ S1 4;304;5 SHU O*XVR VHLFHQWHVFR GHOOH LPPDJLQL IXQHEUL/ RUPDL VROR FRPPHPRUDWLYR1 )XQ]LRQDOH SHUz/ VL GLUHEEH/ D PDQWHQHUH DQFRUD YLYR XQ FHUWR UDSSRUWR FRO SDVVDWR1 :8 /1 6,0(21,/ /*DVVRUELPHQWR DXVWULDFR GHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH H OD SROLWLFD GHL GXFKL 5LQDOGR H )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ 0RGHQD/ %ORQGL H 3DUPHJJLDQL/ 4<4< +ULVW1 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;9,1
;59
/DXUD 7XUFKL
JDWD DO PRWLYR QX]LDOH/ OD VYHQWXUDWD JHQHDORJLD GHO SDGUH *DPEHUWL VHJQD TXLQGL XQ SXQWR GL QRQ ULWRUQR QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH HVWHQVH/ HVVHQGR FRQWHPSR0 UDQHDPHQWH O·XOWLPR WHQWDWLYR GL HWHUQDUH OD PHPRULD IHPPLQLOH QHOOH DOOHDQ0 ]H QX]LDOL HG LO SULPR D VSRVWDUH VWUDWHJLFDPHQWH VXO SLDQR G·XQD VDQWLWj GLQD0 VWLFD PROWLSOLFDWD LO OXVWUR JHQWLOL]LR GHOOD IDPLJOLD H O·DSSRUWR IHPPLQLOH DG HVVR1 7UH FRQWLQJHQ]H HFFH]LRQDOL O·DYHYDQR UHVR SRVVLELOH= OD SUHVHQ]D G·XQ HUHGH PLQRUH SHU OD OLQHD SULPRJHQLWD H GL GXH GLVFHQGHQWL GL OLQHD FDGHWWD 0 L ILJOL GL %RUVR/ WHU]RJHQLWR GL &HVDUH , :90 OD FRQVHJXHQWH UHJJHQ]D G·XQD PD0 GUH H WXWULFH FKH VL ULWHQHYD GL UDQJR VXSHULRUH DO PDULWR GHIXQWR HG LO PDWUL0 PRQLR G·XQD ILJOLD FRQ XQ IXWXUR UH1 $ UHQGHUOR SODXVLELOH HUD VWDWR LQYHFH OR VWDWXWR HSLVWHPRORJLFR GHOOD JHQHDORJLD/ OD VXD LQVLVWHQ]D VXOO·LPSRUWDQ]D GHO VDQJXH GHJOL DYL H VXOOH ORUR YLUW•0PRGHOOR SHU IRQGDUH XQD SUHPLQHQ]D VR0 FLR0SROLWLFD1 ,Q WDO VHQVR/ OD JHQHDORJLD GL /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L SXz HVVHU LQWHVD FRPH XQ PRGR SHU QRUPDOL]]DUH +JORULILFDQGROD, OD FULVL VXFFHVVRULD H OD UHJ0 JHQ]D IHPPLQLOH FKH QH GHULYDYD= O·XOWLPR VHUYL]LR UHVR GD XQD PRJOLH DOOD VXFFHVVLRQH SULPRJHQLWD H OHJLWWLPD1 &RPH H SL• GHO WUDGL]LRQDOLVPR VWRULR0 JUDILFR HVWHQVH H GHOO·DVVHQ]D GL VWRULFL DOOD FRUWH GL 0RGHQD SHU WXWWR LO 6HL0 FHQWR/ OD ULVSRVWD DL TXHVLWL SRVWL GD TXHVWR GRFXPHQWR VL WURYD QHOOH JHQHD0 ORJLH VWHVVH H QHOOH UDJLRQL GHO ORUR XWLOL]]R1 1HO 49<8 OH QR]]H GL 5LQDOGR , DG XQ DQQR GDO VXR DFFHVVR DO GXFDWR UL0 VROVHUR GHILQLWLYDPHQWH OD FULVL GLQDVWLFD SURURJDWD GDOOR VWHULOH PDWULPRQLR GL )UDQFHVFR ,, FRQ 0DUJKHULWD )DUQHVH +49<5, H PDUFDURQR O·HQWUDWD GHILQL0 WLYD GHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH QHOO·RUELWD DXVWULDFD1 $OO·HSRFD/ HUD JLj LQ DWWR LO ULQ0 QRYDPHQWR DQWLTXDULR GHO PHWRGR VWRULFR/ FKH OD FRUWH GL 0RGHQD FRQREEH JUD]LH DO ODYRUR GL /XGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL1 (SSXUH/ SRLFKp QH DYHYD VX0 ELWR LO IDVFLQR LQ JLRYHQW•::/ LO JUDQGH GHWUDWWRUH GHOOH JHQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL/ QH FRQVHUYz XQ HOHPHQWR GLVWLQWLYR= OD FURQRORJLD GLQDVWLFD/ YHUD LPSDOFDWXUD GL IRQGR GHOOH $QWLFKLWj HVWHQVL1 6RPPDWD DG XQD VHOH]LRQH GHL GRFXPHQWL FKH QH SULYLOHJLDYD LO FRQWHQXWR JLXVSXEEOLFLVWLFR/ HVVD SXUH FRQGXVVH SHU DOWUR YHUVR DOO·HOLPLQD]LRQH GL PDWULPRQL +H PRJOL, GDOOD PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD H0 VWHQVH/ VDOYR XQ ORUR XVR VWUXPHQWDOH D ILQL JLXULVGL]LRQDOL1 ,QVLHPH/ UHVHUR VFLHQWLILFDPHQWH LQDFFHWWDELOH O·DWWDFFDPHQWR JHQHDORJLFR SHU LO SDVVDWR H OD PHUD LQVLVWHQ]D VXO VDQJXH H VXL WLWROL GHJOL DQWHQDWL/ LQFOXVL TXHOOL GHOOH FRQ0 ²²²²²²²² :9 6L WUDWWD GL )RUHVWR H &HVDUH ,JQD]LR/ GL SRFR SL• DQ]LDQL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ GLVFHQGHQWH GHOOD OLQHD SULPRJHQLWD DWWUDYHUVR $OIRQVR ,,, H )UDQFHVFR ,1 /RUR VRUHOOD HUD $QJHOD 0DULD &DWHULQD1 :: 51 %,==2&&+,/ *HQHDORJLH LQFUHGLELOL111 FLW1/ SS1 48504861
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
;5:
VRUWL/ DQFKH VH JXDGDJQDWL SUHVVR OD FRUWH FHOHVWH1 2OWUH D VDQFLUH OD ILQH GHO UDSSRUWR UHYHUHQ]LDOH FRO SDVVDWR/ O·,OOXPLQLVPR GL FXL 0XUDWRUL IX SUHFXUVR0 UH DYUHEEH YLVWR OD QDVFLWD GHO FLWWDGLQR OLEHUR HG LQGLYLGXR FRPH GLUHWWD FRQ0 WURSDUWH GHOOR VWDWR/ XQD ULGHILQL]LRQH GHL FRQILQL IUD SXEEOLFR H SULYDWR FKH HVSXQJHYD L FRUSL LQWHUPHGL GDOO·DUHQD SXEEOLFD H O·HPDQFLSD]LRQH GHOOH WHR0 ULH SURFUHDWLYH GDOO·HUHGLWj GL $ULVWRWHOH H *DOHQR1 (· GXQTXH SRVVLELOH FKH VROR DOORUD/ GHSXUDWD GDOOH IROOLH HVHJHWLFKH GHOOH JHQHDORJLH/ PD HUHGH GHOOD ORUR RVVDWXUD FURQRORJLFD/ OD VWRULD SROLWLFD DEELD FDQFHOODWR OD PHPRULD GHOOH GRQQH/ DOOH TXDOL GL Ou D SRFR LO SHQVLHUR SROLWLFR H JLXULGLFR SL• DJJLRUQDWR DYUHEEH QHJDWR O·LGHQWLWj GL FLWWDGLQH1
;5;
/DXUD 7XUFKL
)LJXUD 4
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
)LJXUD 5
;5<
;63
/DXUD 7XUFKL
)LJXUD 6
0DWULPRQL H PHPRULD JHQHDORJLFD IUD WDUGR PHGLRHYR HG HWj PRGHUQD
)LJXUD 7
;64
;65
/DXUD 7XUFKL
)LJXUD 8
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;66
0$5,2 3(&25$52
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H %FRQJLXUD HVWHQVH%
'RSR LO FUROOR GL 1DSROHRQH/ LQ (XURSD VL YXROH XQ YHUR H SURSULR ULWRU0 QR DO SDVVDWR1 &RQ OD UHVWDXUD]LRQH GHILQLWD DO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD/ LO GXFDWR GL 0RGH0 QD/ LQ YLUW• GHO SULQFLSLR GL OHJLWWLPLWj/ YLHQH UHVWLWXLWR DJOL (VWHQVL QHOOD SHU0 VRQD GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ SULPRJHQLWR GHOO·DUFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR GL /RUH0 QD/ JRYHUQDWRUH GHOOD /RPEDUGLD/ H GL 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH &\ER/ HUHGH GHO GXFDWR GL 0DVVD H &DUUDUD41 ,O QXRYR VRYUDQR/ DFFRPSDJQDWR GDOOD PRJOLH 0DULD %HDWULFH GL 6DYRLD H GDO IUDWHOOR 0DVVLPLOLDQR/ HQWUD VROHQQHPHQWH LQ 0RGHQD LO 48 OXJOLR 4;47 VDOXWDWR FRQ HVXOWDQ]D GDL QRELOL H GDO FOHUR/ ILGX0 FLRVL GL ULDFTXLVWDUH L SULYLOHJL SHUGXWL/ PD DQFKH GDO SRSROR FKH/ GRSR L VD0 FULILFL SURGRWWL GDOOH JXHUUH QDSROHRQLFKH/ QXWULYD VSHUDQ]H GL SDFH H SURVSH0 ULWj51 ,O GXFDWR HVWHQVH q XQR GHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH SROLWLFD0 PHQWH WUD L SL• DUUHWUDWL1 $GGLULWWXUD SL• DUUHWUDWR GHOOR 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR/ GRYH LO FDUGLQDOH (UFROH &RQVDOYL/ FROXL FKH VL HUD ULILXWDWR GL VRWWRVFULYHUH JOL $WWL GHO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD/ VL LVSLUD D XQ FDXWR ULIRUPLVPR DYYHUVDQGR VLD OH WHQGHQ]H GHL ULYROX]LRQDUL FKH TXHOOH UHD]LRQDULH61 (· TXHOOR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 XQ DVVROXWLVPR ULJLGDPHQWH LQWUDQVLJHQWH1 )L0 QDQFR LO 0HWWHUQLFK QRQ DSSURYDYD OD ULJLGH]]D GHO GXFD FKH DO &RQJUHVVR GL ²²²²²²²² 4
/1 &+,$33,1,/ *OL (VWHQVL/ 0LODQR 4<9:/ S1 7:< H /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH/ 0RGHQD 4<<:/ S1 49<1 6L SXz LQROWUH YHGHUH OD ELRJUDILD DJLRJUDILFD GL &1 *$/9$1,/ 0HPRULH VWRULFKH LQWRUQR OD YLWD GL 61$151 )UDQFHVFR ,9/ 0RGHQD 4;7904;881 5 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL/XQ XRPR FKH IHFH O·,WDOLD/ 0RGHQD 4<<9/ S1 8;1 6 $1 %(56(//,/ 0RYLPHQWL SROLWLFL H VRFLDOL D 0RGHQD GDO 4:<9 DO 4;8</ LQ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<96/ SS1 5905: H *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD FDWWROLFD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD +4;4804;94,/ 0RGHQD 4<9;/ S1 :41
;67
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
/XELDQD GHO 59 JHQQDLR 4;54 DYHYD SURSRVWR GL GHSRUWDUH LQ $PHULFD WXWWD OD JHQuD GHL ULYROX]LRQDUL1 $QFKH TXDWWRUGLFL DQQL GRSR/ QHO VHWWHPEUH 4;68 )UDQFHVFR ,9 q VXOOH VWHVVH SRVL]LRQL1 ,QIDWWL/ LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOO·LQFRQWUR GL 7HSOLW] IUD L WUH VRYUDQL GHOOD 6DQWD $OOHDQ]D/ VFULYH DOOR ]DU 1LFROD , +SURYR0 FDQGRQH O·LQGLJQDWD UHD]LRQH, SHU FKLHGHUJOL LO SODFHW DOOD GHSRUWD]LRQH LQ 6L0 EHULD GHL SULJLRQLHUL SROLWLFL GHO GXFDWR71 9ROHQGR HVVHUH R DSSDULUH LQ ,WDOLD FRPH LO FDPSLRQH GHO OHJLWWLPLVPR H GHOOD ORWWD FRQWUR LO OLEHUDOLVPR/ LO 54 VHWWHPEUH 4;53 LO GXFD SURPXOJD XQ GH0 FUHWR FRQ FXL GLFKLDUD FROSHYROL GL OHVD PDHVWj H SXQLELOL FRQ OD SHQD GL PRU0 WH H OD FRQILVFD GHL EHQL JOL DIILOLDWL DOOD &DUERQHULD R DG DOWUH VHWWH FKH VL SUR0 SRQJDQR ´OD VRYYHUVLRQH H GLVWUX]LRQH GHL JRYHUQLµ81 &RQ O·LVWLWX]LRQH LO 48 JLXJQR 4;55 GHO 7ULEXQDOH VWDWDULR GL 5XELHUD/ FKH IXQ]LRQD FRQ HVWUHPD GXUH]]D/ UHSULPH OH VHWWH9 H GXH DQQL GRSR/ LO 4ƒ PDU0 ]R/ HPDQD XQ HGLWWR FRQWUR OD 0DVVRQHULD:1 9D ULFRUGDWR FKH SULPD GHO 4;47 )UDQFHVFR ,9 HUD VWDWR D OXQJR LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ JOL HPLVVDUL LQJOHVL GL /RUG %HQWLQFN/ LO TXDOH LQWHQGHYD VIUXWWDUH OD 0DVVRQHULD LWDOLDQD LQ IXQ]LRQH DQWL0 QDSROHRQLFD1 ,O GXFD TXLQGL GRYHYD FRQRVFHUH DOFXQL VHJUHWL GHOO·RUJD0 QL]]D]LRQH PDVVRQLFD1 1RQ VROR1 ,Q XQ UDSSRUWR GHOO·DJRVWR 4;49 GL 3LHWUR 'ROFH/ XQ QRELOH YHQHWR/ H[ PDVVRQH/ LQIRUPDWRUH VXO OLEUR SDJD GHOOD SROL]LD DXVWULDFD/ VL OHJJH FKH/ ROWUH D &DUOR $OEHUWR SUHWHVR FDUERQDUR/ ´FL VRQR DOWUL 3ULQFLSL FKH SULPHJJLDQR IUD L FRQJUHJDWL/ PD LR QRQ DUGLVFR SURQXQ]LDUH LO ORUR ULVSHWWDELOLVVLPR QRPHµ1 $ GHWWD GL $OHVVDQGUR /X]LR/ VWXGLRVR GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD FKH SHUz WUDWWD VROR PDUJLQDOPHQWH OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ LO SULQFLSH GL FXL LO 'ROFH QRQ RVD SURQXQFLDUH LO QRPH q )UDQFHVFR ,9;1 &KH/ TXLQGL/ SHU UDJLRQL GL FRQYHQLHQ]D SROLWLFD H GL RSSRUWXQLVPR QHO 4;57 FRQGDQQD OD VHWWD GHL )UDQFKL 0DVVRQL R /LEHUL 0XUDWRUL/ JLXGLFDQGROD UHVSRQVDELOH GL ²²²²²²²² 7
(1 '(/ 9(&&+,2/ ,O FUHSXVFROR GHOOD SROLWLFD HVWHUD GHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ LQ )UDQFHVFR ,9 H )UDQFHVFR 9 GXFKL GL 0RGHQD/ $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR/ 0RGHQD 6 RWWREUH4<<5/ S1841 8 /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD 111FLW1/ S1 4:: H $1 %(56(//,/ 0RYLPHQWL SROLWLFL 111 FLW1/ S1 631 9 $1 3$1,==,/ 'RFXPHQWL ULJXDUGDQWL LO JRYHUQR GHJOL $XVWUR 0 (VWHQVL/ 0RGHQD/ 4;8<1 : *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD FDWWROLFD 111 FLW1/ S1 :81 ; (· SURYDWR FKH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD HUD LVFULWWR DOOD VHWWD UHD]LRQDULD GHL &RQFLVWRULDOL/ QD0 WD QHO 4;48 FRQ OR VFRSR GL ULFRVWLWXLUH LO JXHOILVPR H VFDO]DUH O·$XVWULD 1 $O 0HWWHUQLFK FKH OR DPPRQLYD/ )UDQFHVFR ,9 ULVSRVH FKH OD VXD DSSDUWHQHQ]D DOOD VHWWD DYHYD LO ILQH GL HVHUFL0 WDUYL XQD VRUYHJOLDQ]D SHU FRQWR GHOO·,PSHUDWRUH1 &IU1 21 ',72/ 0DVVRQHULD/ &DUERQHULD HG DOWUH VRFLHWj VHJUHWH QHOOD VWRULD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR LWDOLDQR/ 7RULQR/ 4<38 +ULVW1 DQDVW1/ %RORJQD/ )RUQL/ 4<:;,/ SS1 5;<05<31
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;68
WXWWR LO PRYLPHQWR VHWWDULR<1 /D VWHVVD WHVL GHO GXFD q VRVWHQXWD LQ XQ PDQR0 VFULWWR/ ODFXQRVR H QRQ VHPSUH DWWHQGLELOH/ GDO WLWROR 6WRULD GHOOH VHWWH H GHOOH FR0 VSLUD]LRQL VHWWDULH GDOO·DQQR 4;49 DO 4;551 /·DXWRUH q *LRYDQQL 0DQ]RWWL GL 6DQW·,ODULR/ XQ H[ PDVVRQH LQL]LDWR DSSHQD DO SULPR JUDGR H FRQ VFDUVD IUH0 TXHQWD]LRQH GHOOD ORJJLD/ XQ SHQWLWR/ SHU GLUOD FRQ SDUROH VXH/ ´GL DYHU DSSDU0 WHQXWR DG XQD GHOOH LQLTXH VHWWH FKH QHJOL XOWLPL WHPSL VFRVVHUR OH IRQGDPHQ0 WD GHOO·$OWDUH/ GHO 7URQR H GHOOD 6RFLHWjµ431 ,O SHQWLWR 0DQ]RWWL +LO SUHPLR SHU OD FROODERUD]LRQH RIIHUWD DO 7ULEXQDOH VWDWDULR GL 5XELHUD q LO SURVFLRJOLPHQWR GDO FDUFHUH, q VFDUVDPHQWH FUHGLELOH H SRFR LQIRUPDWR VH VL OLPLWD D VHJQDODUH L QRPL GL GLHFL PDVVRQL UHJJLDQL H/ TXDQWR DL PRGHQHVL/ D ULSHUFRUUHUH OH GH0 SRVL]LRQL SURFHVVXDOL GL 5XELHUD1 /D 0DVVRQHULD QRQ KD LO SURJHWWR 0 FRPH DIIHUPDYDQR LO GXFD QHOOD QRWL0 ILFD]LRQH GHO 4ƒ PDU]R 4;57 H LO 0DQ]RWWL QHO VXR PDQRVFULWWR GHO 4;64 0 GL URYHVFLDUH RJQL DXWRULWj UHOLJLRVD H VHFRODUH/ QRQ DJLVFH VXO SLDQR GHOOD ORWWD LQVXUUH]LRQDOH/ QRQ VL RFFXSD GL SROLWLFD/ SHUORPHQR D OLYHOOR VWDWXWDULR1 /D 0DVVRQHULD IDYRULVFH/ PHGLDQWH L VXRL PHPEUL/ O·DIILOLD]LRQH DOOH DOWUH VHWWH VHJUHWH441 &RPH VFULYH 0LFKHOH 5RVL QHOOD VXD ,WDOLD RGLHUQD/ GXUDQWH OD 5H0 VWDXUD]LRQH L PDVVRQL QRQ DJLVFRQR SL• FRPH WDOL> DOFXQL GL HVVL HQWUDQR LQ DOWUH RUJDQL]]D]LRQL VHWWDULH FKH GHULYDQR GDOOD 0DVVRQHULD1 1HO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD GRSR LO 4;48 HOHPHQWL GL DWWLYLWj PDVVRQLFD VL UL0 WURYDQR LQWUHFFLDWL FRQ O·DWWLYLWj GHOOH VRFLHWj VHJUHWH ULYROX]LRQDULH FKH PX0 WXDQR GDL /LEHUL 0XUDWRUL LO PRGHOOR RUJDQL]]DWLYR +ULWL LQL]LDWLFL/ VLPERORJLD/ RUJDQL]]D]LRQH JHUDUFKLFD,1 (· TXHVWR XQ WHUUHQR GHO WXWWR LQHVSORUDWR/ R TXDVL1 8QR VWXGLR DSSURIRQGLWR VX TXHVWR WHPD ULFKLHGH LQGDJLQL PROWR OD0 ²²²²²²²² <
$1 /8=,2/ /D 0DVVRQHULD H LO 5LVRUJLPHQWR LWDOLDQR/ %RORJQD/ 4<58/YRO1 ,/ S 14;71 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$ +G·RUD LQ SRL $602,/ $UFKLYLR $XVWUR 0 (VWHQVH/ $OWD 3ROL]LD/ $WWL YDUL/ E14+433,/ IDVF1 ,91 44 /1 5,*+,/ 1RWH VXOOD 0DVVRQHULD QHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH QHL SULPL DQQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ LQ , , SULPL DQQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 4<;4 > *1 %('21,/ ,O SLDQR PHQRW0 WLDQR GHO 4;63 +QRWD VWRULFR 0 JLXULGLFD,/ LQ © $WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH 3URYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ ,9+4<;5,/ S1 5;: 1 3HU OD VWRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD H GHO PRYLPHQWR VHWWDULR LQ JHQHUDOH/ ROWUH DL JLj FLWDWL YROXPL GHO 'LWR H GHO /X]LR/ VL SRVVRQR XWLOPHQWH YHGHUH= *1 /(7,/ &DUERQHULD H 0DVVRQHULD QHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR LWDOLDQR/ *HQRYD/4<58 +ULVW1 DQDVW1/ %RORJQD/ )RUQL/ 4<99,> 31 3,(5,/ /H VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H L PRWL GHJOL DQQL 4;53054/ 0LODQR/ 4<64> 51 625,*$/ /H VRFLHWj VHJUHWH/ O·HPLJUD]LRQH SROLWLFD H L SULPL PRWL SHU O·LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ 0RGHQD/ 4<75 > 51 (6326,72/ /D 0DVVRQHULD H O·,WDOLD GDO 4;33 DL QRVWUL JLRUQL/ 5RPD/ 4<9< > &1 )5$1&29,&+/ 6WRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD LQ ,WDOLD GDOOH RULJLQL DOOD ULYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH/ )LUHQ]H/ 4<:8 > $1 02/$/ 6WRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD LWDOLDQD GDOO·XQLWj DOOD 5HSXEEOLFD/ 0LODQR/ 4<:91 43
;69
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
ERULRVH/ VLVWHPDWLFKH/ SUXGHQWL H O·DFFHVVR DG DUFKLYL SULYDWL1 6L KDQQR VROR WUDFFH GL DWWLYLWj ODWRPLVWLFD QHOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH VLD SHU OD FDUHQ]D GHOOD GR0 FXPHQWD]LRQH FKH SHU OD VXD VHJUHWH]]D+OD 0DVVRQHULD IX PHVVD DO EDQGR GDO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD H FRVWUHWWD TXLQGL D XQ OXQJR SHULRGR GL FODQGHVWLQLWj,1 (· SURYDWD O·HVLVWHQ]D GL XQD ORJJLD PDVVRQLFD FKH QHO 4:<6 WHQHYD OH VXH VHGXWH QHOO·RVSHGDOH GL 0RGHQD/ DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD VSH]LHULD1 1H IDFHYDQR SDU0 WH QRELOL FRPH 3URVSHUR &DUDQGLQL H 'LRIHER &RUWHVH H LQWHOOHWWXDOL TXDOL &DUOR %RVHOOLQL H %DUWRORPHR &DYHGRQL451 1HO 4;4; q GRFXPHQWDWD D 0RGHQD O·DWWLYLWj GHOOD ORJJLD ´/D &RVWDQ]Dµ/ XELFDWD LQ 5XD *UDQGH +RGLHUQD YLD )DULQL,/ RUJDQL]]DWD GDO PLUDQGROHVH GRWW1 $QWRQLR 6DFFKL461 /H VXH ILQDOLWj/ FRPH VL HYLQFH GD XQ UDSSRUWR GHOOD SROL0 ]LD/ HUDQR ILODQWURSLFKH H QRQ SROLWLFKH1 9L DGHULYDQR XIILFLDOL GHOO·DUPDWD QD0 SROHRQLFD FRPH )UDQFHVFR 0DUDQHVL H *LRYDQQL $QGUHD 0DODJROL HG HEUHL FRPH ,VUDHOH /DWLV H %HQHGHWWR 6DQJXLQHWWL1 4XDQWR DOOH RUJDQL]]D]LRQL VHWWDULH GHULYDQWL GDOO·DOYHR PDVVRQLFR/ QHO 4;4; VL UHJLVWUD OD QDVFLWD GHOOD VHWWD GHL 6XEOLPL 0DHVWUL 3HUIHWWL+610131,/ LQ SDUWH FRQWUROODWD/ VRSUDWWXWWR ILQR DO 4;54/ GD )LOLSSR %XRQDUURWL1 ,O VXR VFR0 SR XOWLPR+QRWR VROR D SRFKL,HUD OD FUHD]LRQH GL XQD UHSXEEOLFD VRFLDOLVWD DW0 WUDYHUVR O·DEROL]LRQH GHOOD SURSULHWj SULYDWD471 4XDQGR 0LVOH\/ 0HQRWWL/ 0D]]LQL/ 3RHULR/ 6DOIL H DOWUL QH VFRSURQR L ILQL SL• UHFRQGLWL OL ULILXWDQR LQ PRGR UHFLVR481 1HO VHWWHPEUH GHO 4;53 q OD YROWD GHOOD &DUERQHULD/ FRQVLGH0 UDWD FRPH XQ·DSSHQGLFH GHOOD VHWWD GHL 61 0131 8QR GHL UDPL GHOO·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOD &DUERQHULD PRGHQHVH q XQ·DVVRFLD]LRQH VHJUHWD IUD JOL VWXGHQWL XQLYHUVLWDUL VRUWD DOO·LQL]LR GHO 4;541 $ TXHOO·HSRFD 0 VFULYH /XLJL *HQHUDOL 0 ´OD TXDVL WRWDOLWj GHJOL VWXGHQWL GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD HUD ULXQLWD LQ XQD DVVRFLD]LRQH VHJUHWD/ GLYLVD LQ ²²²²²²²² 45
*1 25/$1',/ 3HU OD VWRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD GDOOH RULJLQL DO 4:88/ 0R0 GHQD/ 4<;4/ S1441 46 $O 6DFFKL IX VHTXHVWUDWR GDO %HVLQL LO GLSORPD PDVVRQLFR GDWDWR 4;4; H FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR $602/ $UFKLYLR $XVWUR 0 (VWHQVH/ $OWD 3ROL]LD/ $WWL YDUL/ E14 +433 ,/ IDVF1 ,91 ,O GLSORPD q VRWWRVFULWWR GDO 9HQHUDELOH /LUHOOL/ GD 0DUDQHVL H /DWLV/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH 4ƒ H 5ƒ 6RUYHJOLDQWH H GDL ´IUDWHOOLµ 9LVPDUD/ 0DVFKHUSD/9HOOL/ %DUELHUL/ 5RVVL/ 7RUUHJJLDQL/ =XFFKL1 $O 6DFFKL H0 UDQR FRQIHULWL L JUDGL VLPEROLFL GL $SSUHQGLVWD/ &RPSDJQR H 0DHVWUR1 &IU1 /1 5,*+,/ 1RWH VXOOD 0DVVRQHULD 111/ FLW1/ S1 4541 47 $1 *$/$17( *$5521(/ )LOLSSR %XRQDUURWL H L ULYROX]LRQDUL GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ 7RULQR/ 4<84/ S1 49;1 48 &1 %$5,*$==,/ )LOLSSR %XRQDUURWL H L SDWULRWL UHJJLDQL +4:<904;64,/ LQ ©/·$OPDQDFFRª 590 5:/ 4<<80<9/ S1 651
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;6:
GUDSSHOOL GL TXDWWUR FRQ XQ FDSR GDO TXDOH HVVL GRYHYDQR GLSHQGHUH 1 1RQ HUD XQD VRFLHWj SURSULDPHQWH GHWWD/ SHUFKp QRQ GRYHYD XQLUVL FKH QHO FDVR SHU FXL HUD LVWLWXLWD H QRQ VL XQu PDL/ DQ]L RJQL LQGLYLGXR GL HVVD QRQ GRYHYD FRQRVFHUH FKH LO JUXSSR GL FLQTXH SHUVRQH DO TXDOH DSSDUWHQHYD 1 2JQL DG0 GHWWR QRQ JLXUDYD DOWUR FKH GL FRQVHUYDUH LO VHJUHWR H G·HVVHU SURQWR DG RJQL FKLDPDWD GL SUHQGHU LO IXFLOH SHU OD FDXVD GHOOD 3DWULD >111@1 7XWWD O·DVVRFLD]LRQH DYHYD XQD SDUROD G·RUGLQH/ FKH DG LQWHUYDOOL YHQLYD FDPELDWD 1 /·XOWLPD SDUROD GDWD IX ´2VVLSDQJDµ/ SDUROD JUHFD FKH FUHGR VLJQLILFKL OLEHUWj R TXDOFKH FRVD GL DQDORJRµ491 1HO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD O·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH FKH KD LO PDJJLRU VHJXLWR q OD &DUERQHULD/ FKH QDVFH FRPH VWUXPHQWR GL D]LRQH SROLWLFD EDWWHQGRVL SHU O·LQVWDXUD]LRQH GL XQ JRYHUQR FRVWLWX]LRQDOH 1 (VVD UDFFRJOLH WUD OH VXH ILOH/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD OD FXL FRPSRVL]LRQH VRFLDOH HUD VWDWD DULVWRFUDWLFD HG HOLWDULD/ FRPPHUFLDQWL H SURIHVVLRQLVWL 1 /·DWWLYLWj FRVSLUDWLYD/ DQFKH VH JLRFRIRU]D OLPLWDWD D FDXVD GHL GHFUHWL GXFDOL FKH FRQVLGHUDYDQR O·DSSDUWHQHQ]D DOOD VRFLHWj VHJUHWD GHOLWWR GL OHVD PDHVWj/ UDJJLXQJH LO VXR FXOPLQH WUD LO : H LO 53 IHEEUDLR 4;54 TXDQGR WUXSSH DXVWULDFKH FRQ QXFOHL GL VROGDWL XQJKHUHVL SDVVDQR GD 0RGHQD SHU UHFDUVL QHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL D UH0 SULPHUYL OD ULYROWD1 ,Q TXHOOD FLUFRVWDQ]D L FDUERQDUL PRGHQHVL GLIIRQGRQR FODQGHVWLQDPHQWH LO SURFODPD ODWLQR DJOL 8QJKHUHVL/ FKH YHQJRQR LQYLWDWL D QHJDUH LO ORUR DLXWR DJOL RSSUHVVRUL GHL SDWULRWL QDSROHWDQL 1 &RQWUR JOL DIILOLDWL DOOD &DUERQHULD H DOOH DOWUH VHWWH )UDQFHVFR ,9 VFDWHQD LO FDSR GHOOD SROL]LD/ O·RGLDWR *LXOLR %HVLQL/ H[ SROL]LRWWR GHL %RUERQL D 1DSROL/ PROWR DELOH QHO IDUOL FRQIHVVDUH GXUDQWH JOL LQWHUURJDWRUL SHUFKp VRPPLQLVWUD0 YD O·DWURSLQD GL EHOODGRQQD1 )RUVH DYHYD TXDOFKH LQILOWUDWR4: R IRUVH DYHYD PLOLWDWR QHOOD &DUERQHULD H SHUWDQWR QH FRQRVFHYD L VHJUHWL4;1 /D UHWDWD RUGLQDWD LQ TXHL IUDQJHQWL SRUWD D QXPHURVL DUUHVWL WUD FXL TXHOOL GHOO·LPSUHQGLWRUH &LUR 0HQRWWL/ GHO SRHWD 3LHWUR *LDQQRQH/ GHOO·DEDWH *LR0 YDQQL 0RUHDOL +QHOOH VFKLHUH FDUERQDUH OD SUHVHQ]D GL UHOLJLRVL q HOHYDWD , H GL DOWUL SDWULRWL 1 /D GXUD UHSUHVVLRQH +FXOPLQHUj FRQ OD FRQGDQQD D PRUWH GL GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL LVFULWWR DOOD &DUERQHULD QHO 4;53 QHOO·DELWD]LRQH UHJ0 JLDQD GHL IUDWHOOL &DUOR H *LXVHSSH )DWWRUL , QRQ VL VSLHJD VROR FRQ PRWLYL GL ²²²²²²²² 49
*1 &$1(9$==,/ 5LFRUGDQ]H GL /XLJL *HQHUDOL/ LQ ©$UFKLYLR (PLOLDQR GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR 1D]LRQDOHª/ ,/ 4<3:/ SS1 570581 4: $ WLWROR HVHPSOLILFDWLYR/ $QWRQLR 3DQL]]L ULWHQHYD LO PDVVRQH PLUDQGROHVH $QWRQLR 6DFFKL VSLD GL %HVLQL1 4; /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD 111 FLW1/ S14:;1
;6;
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
SROLWLFD LQWHUQD = O·HVFOXVLRQH GDO JRYHUQR GHOOD ERUJKHVLD +SURSULR GD TXHVWD FODVVH VIRFLD O·RSSRVL]LRQH SROLWLFD FKH VL PDQLIHVWD FRQ O·DGHVLRQH DO PRYL0 PHQWR VHWWDULR ,/ OD JKHWWL]]D]LRQH GHJOL (EUHL/ OD FRPSUHVVLRQH GHOOH LQGX0 VWULH H GHL FRPPHUFL/ OD QHJD]LRQH DL VXGGLWL GHJOL HVVHQ]LDOL GLULWWL FLYLOL H SR0 OLWLFL/ O·LVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD FHQVXUD 1 &L VRQR DQFKH UDJLRQL GL SROLWLFD HVWHUD 1 3HU FHUWL DVSHWWL LO GXFD q XQ SUHLOOXPLQLVWD FKH VRJQD DQFRUD OD SROLWLFD VHLFHQWH0 VFD GHL PRQDUFKL DVVROXWL/ OD SROLWLFD GL LQJUDQGLPHQWR LQ FRQWUDSSRVL]LRQH D TXHOOD GL QD]LRQDOLWj/ LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ OLEHUWj/ WLSLFD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR4<1 $O &RQ0 JUHVVR GHOOD 6DQWD $OOHDQ]D GHO 4;55 VL SUHVHQWD FRPH FDPSLRQH GHO OHJLWWL0 PLVPR H VRVWHQLWRUH GHOOD QHFHVVLWj GL VUDGLFDUH LO VHWWDULVPR OLEHUDOH531 $VWXWR/ DPEL]LRVR H DYLGR GL SRWHUH/ )UDQFHVFR ,9/ VRYUDQR GL XQ SLFFROR 6WDWR +´LO JXVFLR GL FDVWDJQDµ GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR VEHUWXFFLDWR GDO *LXVWL,/ YDJKHJJLD LQJUDQGLPHQWL WHUULWRULDOL H DVSLUD DO WURQR SLHPRQWHVH FRPH PDUL0 WR GHOOD ILJOLD GL 9LWWRULR (PDQXHOH ,/ 0DULD %HDWULFH 9LWWRULD 1 &·q XQ DFFHQ0 QR DO ULJXDUGR DQFKH QHOOD PLQXWD GL XQD OHWWHUD/GDWDWD 53 DJRVWR 4;5</ LQGL0 UL]]DWD GDO FRQWH 1LFFROz %D\DUG GH 9ROR/ GHOHJDWR JRYHUQDWLYR LQ /XQLJLD0 QD/ D )UDQFHVFR ,9 = ´6L GLFH GXQTXH/ FKH 91$151 FROO·2UJDQR 'LSORPDWLFR KD IDWWR VHQWLUH D WXWWH OH &RUWL G·(XURSD O·D]LRQH OHJLWWLPD FKH KD OD QRVWUD DGRUDELOH $UFLGXFKHVVD 3DGURQD GL VXFFHGHUH/ GRSR LO 5H DWWXDOH GL 6DUGH0 JQD/ DOOD &RURQD GL WXWWL L +VLF , 6WDWL GHO 3LHPRQWH/ H GL 6DUGHJQD FRPH 3ULPR *HQLWD GHOOD 5HDOH 6XD &DVDµ541 1RQ YD GLPHQWLFDWR SRL FKH LO GXFD QRQ DYHYD PDL VPHVVR GL WUDPDUH FRQWUR O·HUHGH GHVLJQDWR &DUOR $OEHUWR/ FKH VL HUD FRPSURPHVVR FRQ L OLEHUD0 OL QHO 4;54 DO SXQWR GD HVVHUH VILRUDWR QHL SURFHVVL SHU DOWR WUDGLPHQWR FHOH0 EUDWLVL D 0LODQR H D 9HQH]LD QHL FRQIURQWL GL &RQIDORQLHUL/ 3HOOLFR/ 0DURQFHO0 OL1 /D VXD DPEL]LRQH GXQTXH q LQVRGGLVIDWWD H WDOH IRUVH VDUHEEH ULPDVWD VH D XQ FHUWR PRPHQWR QRQ IRVVH LQWHUYHQXWR TXDOFXQR DG DOLPHQWDUOD 14XHVWR TXDOFXQR q LO OLEHUDOH (QULFR 0LVOH\1 &KH/ VROOHFLWDWR SURSULR GDOOH DPEL]LRQL GHO GXFD/ DFFDUH]]D O·LGHD GHOOD UHDOL]]D]LRQH GL XQ 5HJQR GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUR0 VHWWHQWULRQDOH VRWWR OD FRURQD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 H SURSRQH SURSULR D OXL GL FD0 SHJJLDUH XQ PRYLPHQWR OLEHUDOH 11DVFH FRVu TXHOO·LQWULJR/ ´ XQ LQWUHFFLR GH0 JQR GL XQ FDSRODYRUR GL 3LUDQGHOORµ FRPH VFULYH 6SDGROLQL55/ SDVVDWR DOOD VWRULD FRPH ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ/ L FXL SULQFLSDOL SURWDJRQLVWL VRQR (QULFR 0L0 ²²²²²²²² 4<
$1 %(56(//,/ 0RYLPHQWL SROLWLFL 111 FLW1/ SS1640651 *1 0$11,/ /D SROHPLFD FDWWROLFD 111 FLW1/ S1:51 54 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 5:1 55 *1 63$'2/,1,/ *OL XRPLQL FKH IHFHUR O·,WDOLD/ 0LODQR/ 4<<6/ S1 9<1 53
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;6<
VOH\ H &LUR 0HQRWWL1 ,O 0LVOH\ q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• FKH SHU O·DUWH RUDWRULD GHO 0LVOH\/FKH LQGXEELD0 PHQWH JOL HUD SURSULD FRPH SXUH O·LQJHJQR YLYDFH 1 (· SURSULR LQ TXHVWR SH0 ULRGR FKH O·LQWUDSUHQGHQWH DYYRFDWR GHFLGH GL ULQXQFLDUH DOO·DWWLYLWj IRUHQVH H GL LQWURGXUVL QHOOD FRUWH GHO VRYUDQR GL FXL GLYHQWD XRPR G·DIIDUL JUD]LH DL EXRQL XIILFL GHO VHJUHWDULR GXFDOH *DHWDQR *DPRUUD 1 &RQ L VROGL GL )UDQFH0 VFR ,9/ LQ /RPEDUGLD H LQ 7RVFDQD DFTXLVWD JUDQR FKH SRL LO GXFD ULYHQGH FRQ SURILWWR571 *Lj PDVVRQH +VL LSRWL]]D VLD VWDWR LVFULWWR DOOD 0DVVRQHULD GX0 UDQWH O·HWj QDSROHRQLFD GDO SDGUH58/ GRFHQWH XQLYHUVLWDULR H SURSULHWDULR GL EHQL SUHVVR 9LJQROD ,/ WUD LO 4;57 H LO 4;59 HQWUD QHOOD &DUERQHULD PRGHQHVH H QHO FRQWHPSR FHUFD GL JXDGDJQDUVL OD ILGXFLD GL )UDQFHVFR ,91 1H GLYLHQH XQD VRUWD GL FRQVLJOLHUH WDQWR GD SURSRUJOL LO SLDQR GL XQD PRQDUFKLD FRVWLWX0 ]LRQDOH VX XQ YDVWR WHUULWRULR/ FRPSUHQGHQWH DQFKH LO 5HJQR GL 6DUGHJQD/FRQ D FDSR )UDQFHVFR ,9 1 ,O TXDOH DFFHWWD R ILQJH GL DFFHWWDUH591 ,O SLDQR PLVOH\DQR DSSDUH VXELWR SRFR UHDOLVWLFR SHUFKp SRJJLD VX XQ SULQFLSH DFFHQWUDWRUH +GXUDQWH LO VXR JRYHUQR ODVFLD EHQ 451444 FKLURJUDIL5: H PR]LRQL G·RUGLQH DL YDUL GLFDVWHUL ,FKH VXROH ULSHWHUH ´&ULVWR LQ FLHOR/ LR TXDJJL•µ/ DQWLFRVWLWX]LRQDOH/ DQWLOLEHUDOH/ RGLDWR GDL VHWWDUL SHU DYHU YROXWR OD PRUWH GL GRQ $QGUHROL1 /XLJL *HQHUDOL/ FKH GHOOD YLWD PRGHQHVH GL TXHOO·HSRFD FL KD ODVFLDWR XQD OXFLGD H SUH]LRVD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D/ ULFRUGD= ´0LVOH\ PL GLFHYD VSHVVR = )UDQFH0 VFR ,9 SRWUHEEH HVVHUH H SHU OD VXD IHUPH]]D H SHU OD VXD ULFFKH]]D XQ EXRQ FDSR SHU OD QD]LRQH LWDOLDQD1 ,R/ FRQ WXWWH OH SUHYHQ]LRQL FKH PL VXJJHULYD LO UHJLPH GL TXHO SULQFLSH D 0RGHQD > 111 @ PL DGLUDYD PROWR H DQGDYR TXDVL LQ IXURUH1 ,O FKH IDFHYD ULGHUH VJDQJKHUDWDPHQWH 0LVOH\ FKH PL ULVSRQGHYD= ²²²²²²²² 56
&1 %$5,*$==,/ )LOLSSR %XRQDUURWL 111 FLW1/ S1 6<1 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 591 58 &1 63(//$1=21/ 6WRULD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR H GHOO·8QLWj G·,WDOLD/ 0LODQR/4<67/ ,,/ S1 5<51 59 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 591 5: &1 )$12/ )UDQFHVFR ,9 +'RFXPHQWL H DVSHWWL GL YLWD UHJJLDQD,/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD/4<65/ S1 6661 57
;73
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
´3RWUHVWL DQFKH YHGHUH TXHO FKH QRQ FUHGL/ QRQ KDL DEEDVWDQ]D HVSHULHQ]D GL TXHVWR PRQGR/ ELVRJQD DEEDQGRQDUH OH SUHYHQ]LRQLµ5;1 /·LGHD GL 0LVOH\ GL FRLQYROJHUH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ GHILQLWD GDO *HQHUDOL XQD ´EHVWLDOLWjµ/ q LQYHFH PHQR SHUHJULQD GL TXDQWR SRVVD DSSDULUH/ FRPH DQQRWD LQ XQD OHWWHUD DOO·DPLFR 3URVSHUR 3LURQGL O·HVXOH SDUPHQVH &ODXGLR /LQDWL/ FRVSLUDWRUH D ILDQFR GL 0LVOH\ H EXRQDUURWLDQR FRQYLQWR/ FKH SURVH0 JXH = ´,R SXUH/ EHQFKp UDEEULYLGLL DOOD SULPD SURSRVL]LRQH/ SXUH PL FL DVVXH0 IHFL > 111 @1 &RJOL HOHPHQWL GL QD]LRQDOLWj H OLEHUDOLVPR FKH HVLVWRQR LQ ,WDOLD VHPSUH VL IDUHEEH VHUYLUH DOOD OXQJD DOOD QRVWUD PLUD/ TXDQG·DQFKH VL WUDWWDVVH GL PHWWHUH LO 3DSD VXO WURQR G·,WDOLDµ5<1 ,O SLDQR GHO 0LVOH\ KD VH QRQ DOWUR LO PHULWR GL DIIURQWDUH LO SUREOHPD QD0 ]LRQDOH/VLD SXUH LQ PRGR SDU]LDOH/VXSHUDQGR LO PXQLFLSDOLVPR H LO UHJLRQDOL0 VPR FKH DYHYDQR FDUDWWHUL]]DWR L PRWL GHO 4;54 H OHJDQGROR D XQ·DPSLD D0 ]LRQH HXURSHD 1 /·DYYRFDWR PRGHQHVH GXQTXH FRPLQFLD D IDUH LO FRPPHVVR YLDJJLDWRUH GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH1 0XQLWR GL UHJRODUL SDVVDSRUWL63 YLVWDWL GDOOD SROL]LD HVWHQVH H GL PROWR GDQDUR/ GLPHQWLFR +QRQRVWDQWH OH QXPHURVH OHWWHUH WUDVXGLQR D0 PRUH H IHGHOWj , GHOOD PRJOLH 0DULD )UDQFHVFD 5XIILQL/ GD SRFR VSRVDWD H JLj LQFLQWD GL $QQD/ SHUFRUUH SHU TXDWWUR DQQL PH]]D (XURSD DO ILQH GL SUHQGHUH FRQWDWWL FRQ L OLEHUDOL IUDQFHVL H JOL HVXOL LWDOLDQL GHO 4;53054 H WHVVHUH FRVu OD WUDPD ULYROX]LRQDULD 1 $ %RORJQD H D 7RULQR ID JLUDUH OD YRFH GL XQ &DUOR $OEHUWR LOOLEHUDOH/ D 3DULJL HQWUD LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ LO FRVLGGHWWR &RPLWDWR FRVPRSROLWD GLUHWWR GD /DIDMHWWH/ D /RQGUD FRQ LO &RPLWDWR GHJOL HVXOL LWDOLDQL1 1HL VXRL OXQJKL YLDJJL +ID DQFKH WDSSD D 9LHQQD/ %XGDSHVW/ %XFDUHVW , KD LQFRQWUL FRQ DJHQWL VHJUHWL UXVVL QHOOD VSHUDQ]D 0 YDQD SHUz SHU LO FDPELDPHQWR GHOO·LQGLUL]]R SROLWLFR GHOOR ]DU 1LFROD , 0 GL DYHUH O·DSSRJJLR GHOOD 5XVVLD DOOD FRQJLXUD 1 3ULPD GL IDU ULWRUQR D 0RGHQD/ LQYLD D /RQGUD &DPLOOR /RGRYLFR 0DQ]L0 QL/ PRGHQHVH/ HVXOH D 3DULJL SHU OH FRQJLXUH GHO 4;54/ FKH ULHVFH D FRQYLQFHUH LO &RPLWDWR VXOOD QHFHVVLWj GHOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH1 ,Q DOFXQL YHUEDOL VL DWWHVWD FKH LO &RPLWDWR GL /RQGUD GHOLEHUD/ GRSR VFDPEL HSLVWRODUL FRO 0LVOH\/ GL LQIRUPDUH )UDQFHVFR ,9/ SHU LO WUDPLWH GHO 0DQ]LQL/ GL HVVHUH GLVSRVWR D ULFRQRVFHUOR ²²²²²²²² 5; 5<
*1 &$1(9$==,/ 5LFRUGDQ]H 111 FLW1/ S1 <71 *1 58)),1,/ /H FRVSLUD]LRQL GHO 4;64 QHOOH PHPRULH GL (QULFR 0LVOH\/ %RORJQD/ 4<64/ SS1 7:0
7;1 63 6RQR FRQVHUYDWL SUHVVR OD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH 3URYLQFLH PRGH0 QHVL QHO IRQGR 0LVOH\0 5XIILQL1
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;74
FRPH FDSR GHO PRWR LQVXUUH]LRQDOH1 1HOO·RWWREUH GHO 4;5< LQIDWWL LO 0DQ]LQL LQFRQWUD D 0RGHQD +VRUSUHQGH FKH O·HVXOH PRGHQHVH SRVVD UHVWDUH LQGLVWXU0 EDWR LQ FLWWj , LO GXFD 1 &KH PRVWUD/ DQFKH VH FRQ SUXGHQ]D/ GL DFFHWWDUH OH SURSRVWH GHL FRVSLUDWRUL1 ,O FROORTXLR GHO 0DQ]LQL FRQ LO VRYUDQR H OD OLEHUWj GHL VXRL PRYLPHQWL WH0 VWLPRQLDQR OD FRQQLYHQ]D 0 VLQFHUD R ILQWD 0 GHO GXFD FRQ L FRQJLXUDWL GL 3D0 ULJL H GL /RQGUD641 'XQTXH UHOD]LRQL GL FDUDWWHUH SROLWLFR WUD )UDQFHVFR ,9 H L OLEHUDOL LQWHU0 FRUVHUR UHDOPHQWH DQFKH VH WDOXQL VRVWHQJRQR FKH LO VRYUDQR VLPXODYD SHU WHQWDUH GL SURFXUDUVL QRWL]LH SUH]LRVH VXL ORUR PRYLPHQWL1 1RQ PDQFD SRL FKL QHJD DGGLULWWXUD O·HVLVWHQ]D GL UDSSRUWL WUD LO GXFD H LO 0LVOH\ H DIIHUPD FKH/ QHO FDVR LQ FXL VL IRVVHUR YHULILFDWL/ TXHVWL DYHYDQR ´ULJXDUGDWR LO PRQGR GHJOL DIIDUL H LQ PRGR SDUWLFRODUH LO FRPPHUFLRµ651 /·RSHUD GHO 0LVOH\ LQYHFH VL VYROJH FRQ LO ´SDWURFLQLRµ GHO GXFD H PHQWUH FRQWLQXD D UHJJHUH OH ILOD GHOOD FRQJLXUD/ QHOO·RWWREUH GHO 4;5< HQWUD LQ VFHQD O·LPSUHQGLWRUH FDUSLJLDQR &LUR 0HQRWWL/ XQ OLEHUDOH FDUERQDUR + FRQ WUDVFRUVL JLRYDQLOL GL IHGH HQWXVLDVWLFD QHO GXFD WDQWR GD PLOLWDUH QHOOD JXDUGLD XUEDQD HVWHQVH , DUUHVWDWR QHO 4;54 SHUFKp VRVSHWWDWR GL FRVSLUD]LRQH 1 $ VHJXLWR GL XQ LQFRQWUR FRQ LO 0DQ]LQL +DPLFR GHO IUDWHOOR &HOHVWH , FKH OR LQIRUPD GHOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH/ 0HQRWWL HQWUD LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ LO 0LVOH\ 1 ,O TXD0 OH/ DFFRUWRVL GRSR LO FROORTXLR GHO 4< VHWWHPEUH 4;63 DO &DWDLR +UHVLGHQ]D H0 VWLYD GHL VRYUDQL HVWHQVL , GHOO·DPELJXLWj GHO GXFD FKH QRQ LQWHQGH SL• IDYRUL0 UH LO PRWR OLEHUDOH/VL GHILOD ODVFLDQGR D 0HQRWWL OD SDUWH RSHUDWLYD GHOOD FRQ0 JLXUD1 ,O PXWDWR DWWHJJLDPHQWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 q GRYXWR DJOL DYYHQLPHQWL IUDQ0 FHVL1 /D ULYROX]LRQH GHO OXJOLR 4;63 SRUWD VXO WURQR /XLJL )LOLSSR FKH SUR0 FODPD/ LQ RSSRVL]LRQH DJOL LQWHUYHQWL UHD]LRQDUL GHOOD 6DQWD $OOHDQ]D/ LO IDPR0 VR SULQFLSLR GHO ´QRQ LQWHUYHQWRµ1 ,O GXFD/ OHJLWWLPLVWD FRQYLQWR/ QXWUH XQD SURIRQGD DYYHUVLRQH SHU LO ´UH GHOOH EDUULFDWHµ1 ,QROWUH/ R WHPH FKH /XLJL )LOLSSR/ LQ FDPELR GHO ULFRQRVFL0 PHQWR GD SDUWH GHOOH SRWHQ]H GHOOD 6DQWD $OOHDQ]D/ VYHOL OD WUDPD PRGHQHVH DOO·$XVWULD R q SUHRFFXSDWR SHU OH UHD]LRQL GHO 0HWWHUQLFK FKH/ GRSR DYHU UL0 FHYXWR DOOD ILQH GL DJRVWR D 9LHQQD LO SULQFLSH GL &DQRVD/ VD GHOOH VXH PDQR0 YUH 1 ,QILQH QRQ YD VRWWDFLXWR FKH RUD FRQVLJOLHUH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 q SURSULR LO &DQRVD/ H[ PLQLVWUR GL SROL]LD GHO 5HJQR GHOOH 'XH 6LFLOLH/ FDPSLRQH GHO ²²²²²²²² 64 65
01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ SS1 5:05;1 /1 &+,$33,1,/ *OL (VWHQVL 111 FLW1/ S1 7;71
;75
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
OHJLWWLPLVPR/ DFHUULPR QHPLFR GHL OLEHUDOL/ OD FXL YHQXWD D 0RGHQD q IRUWH0 PHQWH YROXWD GDO FRQWH *LURODPR 5LFFLQL/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL 6WDWR GL 61$151/ TXDQGR VL UHQGH FRQWR GL FKH VRUWD GL LPEURJOLR VWDQQR WUDPDQGR FRQ )UDQ0 FHVFR ,9 0LVOH\ H 0HQRWWL661 1HL SULPL JLRUQL GL GLFHPEUH GHO 4;63 GXQTXH LO 0LVOH\ VL WUDVIHULVFH D 3D0 ULJL +SHU WHQHUVL PHJOLR LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ O·DPELHQWH SROLWLFR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH R SHUFKp KD ILXWDWR O·DULD , ODVFLDQGR D 0HQRWWL LO FRPSLWR GL FRQWLQXDUH OD FR0 VSLUD]LRQH H GL WHQHUH L FRQWDWWL FRQ LO GXFD 1 1HL FXL FRQIURQWL LO FDUSLJLDQR KD XQ DWWHJJLDPHQWR GL GLIILGHQ]D 1 1H VRQR XQD ULSURYD DOFXQH OHWWHUH LQYLD0 WH GDO 0HQRWWL DO 0LVOH\ SULPD GHOOR VFRSSLR GHO PRWR1 ,Q GDWD 46 GLFHPEUH 4;63 VFULYH= ´,O QRVWUR VRYUDQR ID SD]]LH VRSUD SD]]LH1 ,Q YHULWj GLYHQWD PDW0 WRµ 1 ( LO : JHQQDLR 4;64 = ´,O QRVWUR VLJQRUH q XQ YHUR ELUEDQWH > 111@ (JOL KD IDWWR VSDUJHUH SHU PH]]R GHL 6DQIHGLVWL FKH LR H WH VLDPR VXRL DJHQWL VWLSHQ0 GLDWL SHU IRUPDUH GHL &HQWUL HSSRL VFRSULUOL 1 (UDVL FRVu EHQ FUHGXWD D %ROR0 JQD FKH PL VL YROHYD IDU OD SHOOHµ1 ( DQFRUD LO 45 JHQQDLR = ´61$151 VL ODVFLD LQIOXHQ]DUH GDO 3ULQFLSH GL &DQRVD H VL WHPH TXDOFKH LPSURYYLVD LQLTXLWj 1 1RL VWLDPR DOO·HUWD H QRQ FL ODVFHUHPR LPSRUUHµ1 ,QILQH LO 4<= ´,O QRVWUR VL0 JQRUH VWD TXLHWR DSSDUHQWHPHQWH 1 $UPD SHUz FRPH OR SXz IDUH H FROOD VXD WHVWD H FROOD JHQWH FKH OR DYYLFLQDµ671 ,O GXFD/ LQIDWWL/ GD XQ ODWR VL SUHSDUD DOOD GLIHVD UHFOXWDQGR FLUFD WUHFHQWR PRQWDQDUL GHO )ULJQDQR +IHGHOLVVLPL DOOD FDVD HVWHQVH , H FKLHGHQGR LQ SUHVWL0 WR FDQQRQL D &DUOR )HOLFH/ GDOO·DOWUR ODVFLD OLEHUWj GL PRYLPHQWR DO 0HQRWWL1 ,O FXL ODYRUR FRVSLUDWLYR VL LQWHQVLILFD QHO GLFHPEUH GHO 4;63 FRQ OD FRVWLWX]LR0 QH GL FRPLWDWL LQVXUUH]LRQDOL D %RORJQD/ LQ 5RPDJQD/ D )LUHQ]H/ 0DQWRYD H 3DUPD1 6HPSUH QHOOR VWHVVR PHVH/ LO JLRUQR 45/ LQYLD DO 0LVOH\ D 3DULJL/ SHU0 FKp YHQJD DSSURYDWR GDJOL HVXOL/ LO SURJUDPPD SROLWLFR/ VFULWWR FRQ LQFKLR0 VWUR VLPSDWLFR/ OH FXL SDUROH G·RUGLQH VRQR = XQLWj/ OLEHUWj/ LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ PRQDUFKLD FRVWLWX]LRQDOH/ FRQ D FDSR XQ VRYUDQR VFHOWR GD XQ·DVVHPEOHD QD0 ]LRQDOH/ 5RPD FDSLWDOH H EDQGLHUD WULFRORUH VRWWR LO VHJQR GHOOD FURFH 1 /·DWWLYLWj GHO 0HQRWWL VL ID VHPSUH SL• IUHQHWLFD 1 &RQWLQXD D YLDJJLDUH1 6L UHFD D )LUHQ]H GRYH LQYLWD/ JUD]LH DL EXRQL XIILFL GL 0DURQFHOOL/ L IUDWHOOL %R0 QDSDUWH/ /XLJL 1DSROHRQH H &DUOR /XLJL 1DSROHRQH/ DG HQWUDUH QHOOD FRVSLUD0 ]LRQH1 6FULYH FRQWLQXDPHQWH SHU UDIIRU]DUH L FROOHJDPHQWL IUD L FRPLWDWL LQ0 ²²²²²²²² 66 )1 )2&+(5,1,/ /D ILJXUD GHO SULQFLSH GL &DQRVVD H L VXRL UDSSRUWL FRQ LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ LQ /D FRQJLXUD HVWHQVH/ $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL 6WXGL /0RGHQD/ &DUSL/ 6SH]]DQR/ :0;0< PDJJLR 4<<;/ D FXUD GL :1 %21,001 3(&25$52/ S1 5:41 67 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 631
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;76
VXUUH]LRQDOL1 5DFFRJOLH GHQDUR SUHVVR JOL (EUHL/ IDXWRUL GL XQ QXRYR JRYHUQR FKH OL VRWWUDHVVH DOOD GXUD FRQGL]LRQH GL VHUYLW• QHOOD TXDOH OL DYHYD UHOHJDWL LO GXFD1 &KH DYHYD SURLELWR ORUR ILQDQFR OD JHQHUD]LRQH DIILQFKp 0 SHU GLUOD FRQ LO 7RPPDVHR 0 ´QRQ Q·HVFDQR ILJOL GDQQDWL H ULEHOOLµ1 1HOOD OHWWHUD DO 0LVOH\ GHO : JHQQDLR 4;64 0HQRWWL VFULYH= ´*OL (EUHL QRQ KDQQR RJJL IRQGL1 0H QH SURPHWWRQR SHU 0HUFROHGuµ1 ( DQFRUD LQ XQ·DOWUD PLVVLYD DOO·DPLFR= ´0L GXR0 OH DVVDL O·LQFRQYHQLHQWH GHL IRQGL GL 0DUVLJOLD1 0DOHGHWWL (EUHLµ 1 $QFKH QHL FRQIURQWL GHL IDFROWRVL ERUJKHVL OLEHUDOL/ UHVWLL D YHUVDUH FRQWULEXWL SHU OD FDX0 VD/ QRQ q WHQHUR = ´1HVVXQR GL TXHVWH FDQDJOLH GL 5LFFKL FKH OR GLYHQQHUR DOO·RPEUD GHOOD OLEHUWj FKH YRJOLD IDU VDFULIL]Lµ +QHOOD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH GXQTXH SUHQGRQR SDUWH VRSUDWWXWWR OLEHUDOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD PHGLD H SLFFROD ERUJKHVLD , 1 ,QWHQVD q SXUH O·DWWLYLWj QHOOD UDFFROWD GHOOH DUPL1 6HFRQGR OD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D VXFFHVVLYD GHO SDWULRWD /RWDULR %DFFLRODQL/ OD FDVD 0HQRWWL LQ &RUVR &DQDOJUDQGH ´SDUHD XQD ERUVD GL QHJR]LDQWL >111@ FKL DQGDYD/ FKL YHQLYD/ Vu GL JLRUQR FKH GL QRWWH> 111@ OD VFXGHULD VHPEUDYD XQR VWDOODWLFR/ SHUFKp JOL DPLFL FKH GL IXRUL YHQLYDQR SHU FRQFHUWDUH/ Oj PHWWHYD0 QR FDSR= WXWWH OH DUPL GD FDFFLD D GXH/ D TXDWWUR FROSL/ IXFLOL/ SLVWROH/ WURYDWH SUHVVR L PHUFDQWL GL 0RGHQD/ IXURQR FRPSUDWH LQ SRFKL JLRUQL GDO 0HQRWWL H GD· VXRL DJHQWL >111@1 ,O *RYHUQR/ LQ RJQL DOWUR > PRPHQWR@ FRVu VRVSHWWRVR/ HUD PXWRµ681 /H PDQRYUH GHO 0HQRWWL QRQ VIXJJRQR DO SULQFLSH FRVu FRPH TXHOOH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 QRQ VIXJJRQR DO VHPSUH SL• GLIILGHQWH 0HQRWWL 1 (· TXDVL XQD JDUD WUD L GXH D YLJLODUVL YLFHQGHYROPHQWH1 3DYHQWDQGR XQ·LPSURYYLVD UHSUHV0 VLRQH/ 0HQRWWL VL GHFLGH DG HQWUDUH LQ D]LRQH ILVVDQGR OD ULYROWD D 0RGHQD H QHO GXFDWR SHU LO 8 IHEEUDLR 4;64 H QH LQIRUPD LO 0LVOH\ LQ GDWD 5; JHQQDLR LQ TXHVWL WHUPLQL = ´,O PRYLPHQWR q LPPDQFDELOH H GLVSRVWR WXWWR EHQH FKH QRQ WHPR RUPDL SL• GHOO·HVLWR/ Qq TXL/ Qq LQ 5RPDJQD/ Qq LQ 7RVFDQD 0 3DU0 PD FL VHJXLUj LO JLRUQR GRSR 0 ,R QRQ GRUPR/ QRQ PDQJLR1 6RQR LQ FRQWLQXR PRWR 1 ,QVRPPD/ /XQHGu WXWWR VDUj SURQWR 111µ691 ,O GXFD QH YLHQH D FRQRVFHQ]D H OD PDWWLQD GHO JLRUQR 6 ID DUUHVWDUH DOFXQL FRVSLUDWRUL/ WUD FXL 1LFROD )DEUL]L/RUGLQD O·DOORQWDQDPHQWR GHL JHQHUDOL =XF0 FKL H )RQWDQHOOL H DO FRORQQHOOR 6WDQ]DQL GL WHQHU SURQWH OH WUXSSH1 ,O 0HQRWWL GHFLGH TXLQGL GL DQWLFLSDUH O·LQVXUUH]LRQH OD QRWWH VWHVVD1 6XO IDU GHOOD VHUD GHO 6 IHEEUDLR L FRVSLUDWRUL VL ULXQLVFRQR QHOOD FDVD GHO 0HQRWWL LQ FRUVR &DQDOJUDQGH GRYH LUURPSRQR OH PLOL]LH GXFDOL1 , SDWULRWL ²²²²²²²² 68 69
&1 63(//$1=21/ 6WRULD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR 111 FLW1/ S1 6951 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 651
;77
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
ULVSRQGRQR D IXFLODWH XFFLGHQGR GXH VROGDWL/ XQ GUDJRQH H XQ SLRQLHUH1 ,O GXFD RUGLQD GL FLUFRQGDUH OD FDVD H/ SRUWDWRVL VXO SRVWR/ LQWLPD SHUVRQDOPHQ0 WH OD UHVD1 0HQRWWL WHQWD OD IXJD GDO WHWWR/ PD YLHQH IHULWR OLHYHPHQWH D XQD VSDOOD H FDWWXUDWR GDO PDUHVFLDOOR GHL GUDJRQL 3LRSSL LQVLHPH FRQ JOL DOWUL SD0 WULRWL 1 *OL LQVRUWL FKH OD QRWWH JLXQJRQR D 0RGHQD GD &DUSL H GDL SDHVL GHOOD %DVVD/ FRP·HUD QHL SLDQL/ WURYDQR FKLXVH OH TXDWWUR SRUWH GHOOD FLWWj H VL ULWL0 UDQR 1 /D VWHVVD QRWWH LO GXFD UHGLJH XQ SURFODPD FRQ FXL LQIRUPD OD SRSROD0 ]LRQH GHOOD VYHQWDWD FRQJLXUD SODXGHQGR DOOD ´SHUIHWWLVVLPD FDOPD H WUDQTXLO0 OLWj GL TXHVWD QRVWUD FLWWjµ6:1 ´1HVVXQ PRGHQHVH FRPSDUYHµ 0 ULIHULVFRQR LQ0 IDWWL OH FURQDFKH GHOO·HSRFD 0 SHU VDOYDUH L FDUERQDUL 1 &RPH QRWR/ OD UHD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 q IHURFH1 9HQJRQR SURQXQFLDWH EHQ 545 FRQGDQQH LQ JUDQ SDUWH FRQWUR LPSXWDWL LQ FRQWXPDFLD 1 &LUR 0H0 QRWWL H 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL6; YHQJRQR LPSLFFDWL VXO EDVWLRQH GHOOD &LWWDGHOOD GL 0RGHQD 1 7XWWL JOL DOWUL FRQJLXUDWL VRQR FRQGDQQDWL SHVDQWHPHQWH/ WUDQQH 0LVOH\/ QRQRVWDQWH OH SUHVVLRQL VXO GXFD HVHUFLWDWH GDO FDSR GHOOD SROL]LD SHU0 FKp YHQJD DOPHQR SURFHVVDWR LQ FRQWXPDFLD1 ,O PRWR GXQTXH q IDOOLPHQWDUH H PHWWH D QXGR 0 FRPH VFULYH 6SDGROLQL 0 ´OH LOOXVRULH VSHUDQ]H GL TXDQWL VL DWWHQGHYDQR XQ·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH HVWHQVLYD GHO SULQFLSLR GHO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR/ FLRq LO VRJQR GL XQD )UDQFLD SURQWD DG DF0 FRUUHUH LQ GLIHVD GHL SRSROL FKH LQYRFDYDQR OD OLEHUWjµ6<1 ,QROWUH OD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH ULYHOD XQD FHUWD LQJHQXLWj / PDQ0 FDQ]D GL FRRUGLQDPHQWR/ HUURUL GL FRQFH]LRQH H DVVHQ]D GHOOH SL• HOHPHQWDUL PLVXUH SUHFDX]LRQDOL1 $ 0RGHQD WXWWL VDSHYDQR GHL SUHSDUDWLYL1 &DVD 0HQRWWL LQ FRUVR &DQDOJUDQGH/ DO FLYLFR 43<;/ D GXH SDVVL GDO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH/ UHJL0 VWUDYD XQ HFFH]LRQDOH DQGLULYLHQL/ GLXUQR H QRWWXUQR1 1XOOD VIXJJLYD DOOD SROL0 ]LD HVWHQVH/ VHPSUH YLJLOH H VRVSHWWRVD 1 ,O GXFD GL 0RGHQD LQIDWWL 0 FRPH ²²²²²²²² 6:
,ELG1/ S1 4741 ,O QRWDLR PRGHQHVH 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL IX FRPSDJQR GL SDWLEROR GHO 0HQRWWL QRQ Juj SHU DYHU URJDWR O·DWWR GL GHFDGHQ]D GHO GXFD/ FRPH PROWL VWRULFL KDQQR ULSHWXWR SHU ROWUH XQ VH0 FROR/ EHQVu SHU DYHU VRWWRVFULWWR OD PDWWLQD GHO < IHEEUDLR/ LQVLHPH FRQ DOWUL VHWWDQWXQR FLW0 WDGLQL PRGHQHVL/ OD ´'LFKLDUD]LRQHµ DQWLGXFDOH GHO GLWWDWRUH %LDJLR 1DUGL/ UHQGHQGRVL FRVu FROSHYROH GHO GHOLWWR GL OHVD PDHVWj DO SDUL GL WXWWL JOL DOWUL ILUPDWDUL1 /D URJD]LRQH QRWDULOH DW0 WULEXLWDJOL QRQ q FKH SXUD OHJJHQGD QDWD SHU VSLHJDUH OD SHQD VSURSRU]LRQDWD FXL IX FRQGDQ0 QDWR LO QRWDLR/ FKH QRQ DYHYD SUHVR SDUWH DOFXQD DOOD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHO PRWR PHQRWWLDQR1 6L YHGD DO ULJXDUGR O·HVDXVWLYR FRQWULEXWR GL *1 58)),1,/ ,O VDFULILFLR GL 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH 3URYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ 9, +4<87,/ SS1 44404941 6< *1 63$'2/,1,/ *OL XRPLQL 111 FLW1/ SS1 9:09;1 6;
0DVVRQHULD/ VRFLHWj VHJUHWH H ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ
;78
VFULYH LO &KLDSSLQL 0 ´ FUHGHYD IHUPDPHQWH QHOOD VXD FLWWj FRPH LQ XQD YHUD H SURSULD FHQWUDOH GL SROL]LD DGGHWWD DO FRQWUROOR GHJOL DYYHQLPHQWL LWDOLDQLµ731 3HU FRQFOXGHUH/ TXDO q VWDWR LO UXROR GL (QULFR 0LVOH\ H GL &LUR 0HQRWWL QHOOD ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ" ,O VHFRQGR q SDVVDWR DOOD VWRULD FRPH O·HURH H LO UH0 JLVWD/ LO SULPR QRQ KD DYXWR QHDQFKH PHQ]LRQH LQ PROWL PDQXDOL GL VWRULD 1 $ QRVWUR DYYLVR/ LQYHFH/ IX LO 0LVOH\ O·LGHDWRUH/ LO UHJLVWD/ O·LQGHIHVVR WHVVL0 WRUH +SHU EHQ TXDWWUR DQQL/GDO 4;59 DO ·5<, GHOOD WUDPD FRVSLUDWLYD1 /·LPSUHQGLWRUH FDUSLJLDQR IX O·HVHFXWRUH GHO SLDQR HODERUDWR GDO 0LVOH\/ IX O·RUJDQL]]DWRUH/ O·DWWRUH FKH/ SHUz/ HQWUD VXOOD VFHQD QHOOD SDUWH ILQDOH +RWWREUH GHO ·5< , 1 $ FRVH IDWWH R/ TXDQWRPHQR/ JLj DYYLDWH1 (· YHUR FKH LO 0HQRWWL DV0 VXQVH O·HIIHWWLYD GLUH]LRQH GHO PRWR/ q YHUR FKH QH GLYHQQH LO FDSR H SRL LO VLPEROR/ PD q DOWUHWWDQWR YHUR FKH D LPEDVWLUH OD FRQJLXUD PDQWHQHQGR L FRQWDWWL SHUVRQDOL FRQ LO GXFD/ D WLUDUH L ILOL GHO FRPSORWWR IX LO 0LVOH\1 $ VR0 VWHJQR GL TXHVWD WHVL VROR TXDOFKH HOHPHQWR1 &KH q LO IUXWWR GHOOR VFDYR IDW0 WXDOH H QRQ GL LQWHUSUHWD]LRQL 1 ,QQDQ]LWXWWR XQD OHWWHUD DXWRJUDID GL &LUR LQ0 GLUL]]DWD DO 0LVOH\ LQ GDWD 49 DSULOH 4;64 +0HQRWWL VL WURYDYD DOORUD ULQFKLXVR QHOOH FDUFHUL PLOLWDUL GL 6DQ 6HEDVWLDQR D 0DQWRYD,1 ,Q TXHOOD PLVVLYD LO 0H0 QRWWL ULYHODYD O·LOOXVLRQH FKH 0LVOH\ SRWHVVH VDOYDUOR DVVXPHQGRVL/ OXL VROR/ OD UHVSRQVDELOLWj GL WXWWR FLz FKH HUD VWDWR IDWWR GDL FRQJLXUDWL PRGHQHVL 1 ( JOL DVVLFXUDYD FKH LQ FDVR FRQWUDULR VL VDUHEEH GLIHVR GD Vp/ FRQ FRUDJJLR H VHQ]D VFDULFDUH FROSH VXOO·DPLFR FRQ TXHVWH QRELOL SDUROH = ´(Q WRXV FDV/ UHWLHQV/ PRQ FKHU/ TXH MH QH IHUDLV MDPDLV URXJLUµ +´,Q RJQL FDVR/ ULFRUGDWL/ PLR FDUR/ FKH QRQ WL IDUz PDL DUURVVLUHµ,741 ,Q XQ·DOWUD OHWWHUD GDO FDUFHUH/ GDWDWD 56 DSULOH 4;64 H GLUHWWD/ SHU TXDQWR VL FUHGH/ DOOD VRUHOOD 9LUJLQLD/ VFULYHYD= ´>111@ GRSR OD SDUWHQ]D GL 0LVOH\ SHU OD )UDQFLD/ RYH/ FRPH q JLj QRWR GRYHYD DQGDUH LR VWHVVR D IDU OH VXH YHFL QHO PHVH GL 1RYHPEUH/ PD FRO FRQVHQVR GL 61$151 UHVWDL DO SRVWR SL• SHULFRORVR/ TXHOOR FLRq GHOO·HVHFX]LRQH > GHO SLDQR@µ751 9LHQH D VXIIUDJDUH TXHVWD WHVL DQFKH OD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR 9 FKH D SDJLQD TXDWWUR GHO VXR PDQRVFULWWR 5LFRUGL VXJOL DYYHQLPHQWL GHO IHEEUDLR 4;64 GLFH = ´8Q FHUWR 0LVOH\ XRPR VFHOOHUDWR H ILQWR PD GL WDOHQWR VRWWR YDULL SUH0 WHVWL VSHFLRVL IDFHYD GD SL• PHVL IUHTXHQWL YLDJJL/ HG HUD UHFHQWHPHQWH YHQX0 WR GDOOD )UDQFLD1 &RVWXL VL SXz YHUDPHQWH GLUH FKH IRVVH LO &DSR GHOOD ULYROX0 ]LRQH GL 0RGHQD 1 &RUUXSSH FRVWXL LO IDEEULFDWRUH GL FDSSHOOL GL WUXFFLROR &L0 ²²²²²²²² 73
/1 &+,$33,1,/ *OL (VWHQVL 111FLW1/ S1 7;:1 01 3(&25$52/ &LUR 0HQRWWL 111 FLW1/ S1 6<1 75 ,ELG1/ S1 981
74
;79
0DULR 3HFRUDUR
UR 0HQRWWLµ761 ( DQFRUD 1 ,O SURJUDPPD ´,GHH SHU RUJDQL]]DUH GHOOH LQWHOOLJHQ]H IUD WXWWH OH FLWWj GHOO·,WDOLD SHU OD VXD ,QGLSHQGHQ]D/ 8QLRQH H /LEHUWjµ/ SUHSDUDWR GDO 0HQRWWL QHO GLFHPEUH GHO 4;63/ ULYHODYD SUHRFFXSD]LRQL GL FDUDWWHUH RSHUDWL0 YR/ HUD XQ SLDQR G·D]LRQH 1 0HQRWWL HUD SL• SRUWDWR DOO·D]LRQH +LQQDWR HUD LQ OXL LO ELVRJQR G·DJLUH , FKH DOO·HODERUD]LRQH H DOOD SURJHWWXDOLWj1 1RQ DYHYD XQD EDVH LGHRORJLFD 1 (UD SL• XQ RUJDQL]]DWRUH FKH XQ WHRULFR1 9D VRWWROLQHD0 WR SRL FKH TXHO SURJUDPPD q VWDWR Vu UHGDWWR GL SURSULR SXJQR GDO 0HQRWWL/ PD q VWDWR FRQFRUGDWR FRQ LO 0LVOH\ GXUDQWH JOL XOWLPL JLRUQL GL SHUPDQHQ]D D 0RGHQD GL TXHVW·XOWLPR1 8QD SURYD SXz HVVHUH FRVWLWXLWD GDOO·DQDOLVL ILOROR0 JLFD GHO GRFXPHQWR1 &KH q VXIILFLHQWHPHQWH FRUUHWWR/ QRQ SUHVHQWD WXWWH TXHOOH LPSURSULHWj GL IRUPD FKH HUDQR LQYHFH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH GHJOL VFULWWL PH0 QRWWLDQL/ WLSLFKH GHOOR VWLOH GHO 0HQRWWL/ TXDVL XQ DXWRGLGDWWD 1 /D ILJXUD GHO 0LVOH\/ ´DJHQWH SURYRFDWRUHµ VHFRQGR )LOLSSR %XRQDUURWL/ ´LPEURJOLRQHµ SHU 0D]]LQL77/ IRUVH SURSULR SHU TXHVWD QRQ EXRQD UHSXWD]LR0 QH +DQFKH VH LO SDWULRWD $QWRQLR 3DQL]]L OR JLXGLFz ´XQ JDODQWXRPR GHOXVRµ H DOFXQL VWRULFL OR ULWHQJRQR LQ EXRQD IHGH/ VHSSXU QRQ LPPXQH GD OHJJHUH]]H, q VFRPSDUVD GDOOD PHPRULD FROOHWWLYD1 &KH ULFRUGD VROR TXHOOD GHO 0HQRWWL SHUFKp QRELOLWDWD GDO ´PDUWLULRµ/ SHUFKp q HQWUDWD LQ TXHOOR FKH L VXRL FRQ0 WHPSRUDQHL FKLDPDURQR LO ´PDUWLURORJLRµ GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR WDQWR GD GLYHQL0 UH/ GRSR OD PRUWH/ LO VLPEROR GHOOD ORWWD SHU OD OLEHUWj1
²²²²²²²² 76
$602/ $UFKLYLR %D\DUG GH 9ROR/ PD]]R <9/ Q1 41 /·DYYHUVLRQH GHO 0D]]LQL QHL FRQIURQWL GHO 0LVOH\ IRUVH QRQ HUD GHO WXWWR GLVLQWHUHVVD0 WD1 1HO 4;64065 LQIDWWL O·DYYRFDWR PRGHQHVH DYHYD XQD SRVL]LRQH GL SUHPLQHQ]D D 3DULJL H D /RQGUD SUHVVR L FRPLWDWL SDWULRWWLFL H LO 0D]]LQL PDO VRSSRUWDYD GL GLYLGHUH FRQ DOWUL LO FR0 PDQGR GHOOH IRU]H QD]LRQDOL1 &IU1 $1 625%(//,/ 0LVOH\ LO PLVWHULRVR/ LQ © LO 5HVWR GHO &DUOLQRª GHO 4< PDJJLR 4<641 77
/H LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
;7:
'$1,(/$ *5$1$
/H LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
/D UHWH GHJOL LVWLWXWL DVVLVWHQ]LDOL PRGHQHVL GL RULJLQH PHGLHYDOH HUD VWDWD TXDVL LQWHUDPHQWH VPDQWHOODWD GDOOD ULIRUPD YROXWD QHO 4874 GDL &RQVHUYDWRUL GHOOD FLWWj/ FKH DYHYD SRUWDWR VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH DOOD DJJUHJD]LRQH GHOOH UHQGLWH GHJOL DQWLFKL LVWLWXWL PHGLHYDOL QHOO·XQLFR RUJDQLVPR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR GHOOD 6DQWD 8QLRQH/ H DOOD FRQFHQWUD]LRQH GHL GHJHQWL GL WXWWL JOL RVSHGDOL PRGHQHVL QHOOD &DGq/ GLYHQWDWD O·XQLFR RVSHGDOH FLWWDGLQR/ GHVWLQDWR D GDU ULFRYHUR VLD DJOL LQIHUPL FKH DOO·LQIDQ]LD DEEDQGRQDWD1 &RQ OD ULIRUPD HUDQR VWDWL HVFOXVL GD RJQL IRUPD GL DVVLVWHQ]D L SDXSHUHV FRPPXQHV/ FKH DYHYDQR SRWXWR FRQWDUH VLQR DG DOORUD VX XQD UHWH GL SLFFROL RVSHGDOL0RVSL]L/ FKH RIIULYDQR LQGLVFULPLQDWR ULFHWWR H XQD JHQHULFD DVVLVWHQ0 ]D D FKLXQTXH QH IDFHVVH ULFKLHVWD1 $ FDYDOOR WUD ;9, H ;9,, VHFROR WXWWDYLD LO VLVWHPD DVVLVWHQ]LDOH PRGHQH0 VH HUD FRVWLWXLWR/ ROWUH FKH GDOOD 6DQWD 8QLRQH/ GD WUH RUIDQRWURIL/ XQR PD0 VFKLOH H GXH IHPPLQLOL/ LVWLWXLWL QHO FRUVR GHO ¶833 D EHQHILFLR GL DGROHVFHQWL GL ´FLYLO FRQGL]LRQHµ/ H GDO 'HVFR GHL 3RYHUL 0 XQLFD IUD OH RSHUH SLH GL RULJLQH PHGLHYDOH FKH VHPEUD QRQ HVVHUH VWDWD DVVRUELWD GDOOD 6DQWD 8QLRQH 0/ GHVWL0 QDWD D GLVWULEXLUH VXVVLGL DL SRYHUL YHUJRJQRVL/ D TXHOOD FODVVH GL SRYHUL FLRq FKH SHU QDVFLWD H FRQGL]LRQH VRFLDOH QRQ SRWHYD DEEDVVDUVL DG HVHUFLWDUH DUWH DOFXQD H WDQWR PHQR D TXHVWXDUH1 7XWWL JOL LVWLWXWL FLWWDGLQL/ DG HFFH]LRQH GHOOD &DGq/ HUDQR GXQTXH ULYROWL DOO·DUHD GHOOD SRYHUWj YHUJRJQRVD1 $L SRYHUL PLVHUDELOL LQYHFH QRQ VROR QRQ HUD GHVWLQDWD DOFXQD IRUPD GL DVVLVWHQ]D/ PD O·DWWHJJLDPHQWR GHOOH DXWRULWj FL0 YLOL H UHOLJLRVH QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL FRPLQFLDYD DG DVVXPHUH XQ FDUDWWHUH GL VHPSUH PDJJLRUH FKLXVXUD H RVWLOLWj1 ,O GHFDGLPHQWR HFRQRPLFR FLWWDGLQR UHQGHYD GUDPPDWLFR LO VHPSUH SL• PDVVLFFLR LQXUEDPHQWR GHL FRQWDGLQL SHU O·DVVROXWD PDQFDQ]D GL ULFKLHVWD GL
;7;
'DQLHOD *UDQD
PDQRGRSHUD1 6L FHUFDYD GL IURQWHJJLDUH LO IHQRPHQR GHOOD PHQGLFLWj HPD0 QDQGR D ULWPR VHUUDWR EDQGL FRQWUR O·DFFDWWRQDJJLR/ FRQWUR O·LQXUEDPHQWR GL FRQWDGLQL H IRUHVWLHUL H UDIIRU]DQGR OD JXDUGLD DOOH SRUWH1 /H PXUD FLWWDGLQH VHPEUDYDQR HVVHU GLYHQWDWH XQ EDOXDUGR D GLIHVD GDOOH RUGH GL FRQWDGLQL H PHQGLFDQWL/ SL• FKH GD HVHUFLWL VWUDQLHUL1 &RPLQFLDYDQR D OHYDUVL SUHRFFXSDWH H LQVRIIHUHQWL OH SURWHVWH GHL FLWWDGLQL/ WLPRURVL GL YHGHUH OH VWUDGH LQIHVWDWH GD PDVVH GL PLVHUDELOL/ FKH FRVWLWXLYDQR XQ·LQGXEELD PLQDFFLD SHU O·RUGLQH SXEEOLFR/ SHU OD VLFXUH]]D SHUVRQDOH/ SHU OD VDOXWH SXEEOLFD1 (· LQ TXHVWR FRQWHVWR/ DOOD YLJLOLD GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH/ LQ XQ DQQR GL FDUH0 VWLD FKH VHJXLYD GL SRFR XQ·DOWUD JUDYLVVLPD FULVL SURWUDWWDVL GDO 48<3 DO 48<6/ FKH VL LQVHULVFH O·LVWLWX]LRQH GHOO·2SHUD GHL 0HQGLFDQWL GHO 48<:/ FRQFHSLWD QRQ WDQWR D ILQL FDULWDWLYL/ TXDQWR SLXWWRVWR SHU OD SUHRFFXSD]LRQH GL VDOYD0 JXDUGDUH O·RUGLQH SXEEOLFR H LO GHFRUR FLWWDGLQR H QH VRQR HORTXHQWH WHVWL0 PRQLDQ]D OH SUHPHVVH DL FDSLWROL= ´3RLFKp O·LQVROHQ]D/ JOL DEERPLQHYROL DWWL H UDJLRQDPHQWL FRQ OL TXDOL L SRYHUL PHQGLFD0 YDQR/ QRQ VRODPHQWH PROHVWDYD OH SHUVRQH GDOO·DVFROWDU GLYRWDPHQWH OL GLYLQL XIILFL/ PD DOFX0 QH YROWH O·LPSRUWXQLWj ORUR HUD FDJLRQH G·LUD H GL VGHJQL/ VFRUJHQGRVL EHQH H VSHVVR DOFXQL/ FKH V·KDYUHEERQR SRWXWR JXDGDJQDUH LO YLYHUH/ H DOOH YROWH IRUHVWLHUL H YDJDERQGL/ FKH SHU OD ORUR GDSRFDJLQH IDFHYDQR SURIHVVLRQH GL PHQGLFDUH/ FRO OHYDUH LO SDQH TXDVL GL ERFFD DOOL YHUL SRYHUL H LQKDELOL1 2OWUH TXHL JULGL H TXHUHOH/ FKH GL JLRUQR H GL QRWWH/ SHU JOL OXRJKL SXEEOLFL H SULYDWL VL VHQWLYDQR G·RJQL VHVVR H G·RJQL HWj1 (W QHOOH FKLHVH TXHOOL ORUGL VSHWWDFROL/ FKH FRQ WDQWD LQGHJQLWj GHO FXOWR GLYLQR VL YHGHYDQR1 ,O TXDOH GHVLGHULR GHOOD FLWWj H GLVRUGLQH GH· SR0 YHUL FRQVLGHUDWR SL• H SL• YROWH GD PROWL JHQWLOKXRPLQL GD EHQH SUXGHQWL IX FDJLRQH FKH VL ULFRUVH DOOL PROWR LOOXVWUL VLJQRUL FRQVHUYDWRUL GL TXH· WHPSL H FRO ORUR IDYRUH H DLXWR FL IX SURYHGXWR 111 H SULQFLSLDWD TXHVWD VDQWD 2SHUD GH· 0HQGLFDQWL 111µ 4
/·2SHUD DYUHEEH GRYXWR VYROJHUH LQ SULPR OXRJR OH IXQ]LRQL GL RVSL]LR GHVWLQDWR DL ´YHULµ SRYHUL/ D TXDQWL FLRq SHU O·HWj R SHU OH FRQGL]LRQL ILVLFKH QRQ HUDQR LQ JUDGR GL SURFXUDUVL GL FKH YLYHUH FRQ OH SURSULH IRU]H/ H FLRq DJOL LQDELOL H DJOL RUIDQL SULYL GL SDUHQWL FKH IRVVHUR LQ JUDGR GL PDQWHQHUOL1 0D DYUHEEH DQFKH GRYXWR VYROJHUH OH IXQ]LRQL GL XQD PDJLVWUDWXUD SUHSRVWD DOOD SRYHUWj/ FRQ LO FRPSLWR GL FHQVLUH SHULRGLFDPHQWH L SRYHUL/ ULODVFLDUH L SHUPHVVL GL TXHVWXD/ SUHGLVSRUUH OH VWUDRUGLQDULH GLVWULEX]LRQL GL HOHPRVLQH H WHQHUH ORQWDQL GDOOD FLWWj L PHQGLFDQWL DEXVLYL1 ²²²²²²²² 4 $602/ &KLURJUDIL GXFDOL/ JULGH H VWDWXWL/ *ULGH D VWDPSD/ YRO1 $/ &DSLWROL GHOO·2SHUD GHOOL 3RYHUL PHQGLFDQWL GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ 49371
/H LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
;7<
/·LVWLWXWR GLYHQQH GL IDWWR XQ XOWHULRUH RUIDQRWURILR/ FKH VL DIILDQFDYD DL WUH JLj HVLVWHQWL/ GHVWLQDWR WXWWDYLD DJOL VWUDWL SL• GLVHUHGDWL GHOOD SRSROD]LRQH1 0D DQFKH TXHVWR/ FRPH JOL DQDORJKL RVSL]L VRUWL DOO·LQFLUFD LQ TXHO SHULRGR LQ DOWUH FLWWj/ GLPRVWUz EHQ SUHVWR WXWWD OD VXD GLPHQVLRQH XWRSLVWLFD/ QRQ ULX0 VFHQGR QRQ VROR D ULVROYHUH/ PD QHSSXUH DG DUJLQDUH SDU]LDOPHQWH LO IHQR0 PHQR GHOOD PHQGLFLWj GLODJDQWH1 &RQWLQXDURQR FRVu D VXVVHJXLUVL EDQGL GHO GXFD H GHOOD &RPXQLWj FRQWUR TXHVWXDQWL/ IRUHVWLHUL/ YDJDERQGL H FLDVFXQ ´VWURSLDWR/ LPSLDJDWR/ YDJDERQGR/ FLQJDUR H ELUEDQWHµ1 7DQWR O·2SHUD QRQ ULXVFu D FRQWHQHUH Qp D UHJRODUH LO IHQRPHQR GHOOD PHQGLFLWj/ FKH TXDVL XQ VHFROR GRSR LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,, VHPEUDYD LJQRUDU0 QH O·HVLVWHQ]D1 &RVu/ LQ FRQFRPLWDQ]D FRQ OD FDUHVWLD GHO 49:;049:</ IX WHQWD0 WR GL ULSHWHUH O·HVSHULHQ]D GL XQ RVSL]LR0UHFOXVRULR/ ULIDFHQGRVL DOO·HVHPSLR WRULQHVH1 'HO SURJHWWR GXFDOH WXWWDYLD QRQ VL IHFH QXOOD/ SHUFKp *XDULQR *XDULQL/ DUFKLWHWWR PRGHQHVH DO VHUYL]LR GHOOD FRUWH VDEDXGD/ FXL LO GXFD VL HUD ULYROWR SHU DVVXPHUH RJQL LQIRUPD]LRQH VX TXHOO·LVWLWXWR/ JOL GLPRVWUz D FKLD0 UH OHWWHUH LO IDOOLPHQWR GHOO·LPSUHVD= ´3HU LO FKH YHGHQGR FKH O·KRVSLWDOH LQVWLWXLWR QRQ KD ULPHGLDWR DOOD SRYHUWj GH· FHUFDQWL/ DQ]L HVVHQGR OD FLWWj HYDFXDWD GD TXHOOL/ q VWDWR XQ ULFFKLDPR G·DOWUL/ FKH VRQR FRUVL GDOOH YLOOH D ULHPSLU LO ORU ORJR/ PL SDUH VXSHUIOXR LQYLDUH D 9161 ,OO1PD OH UHJXOH HW LQVWLWXWLRQL GHOO·LVWHVVR KRVSLWDOH1 6·HOOD SHUz FRPDQGD QRQ RVWDQWH FLz G·KDYHUOH/ EDVWHUj XQ VXR FHQQR1µ5
,O SURJHWWR DFFDUH]]DWR GD )UDQFHVFR ,, YHQQH UHDOL]]DWR TXDOFKH WHPSR GRSR GDO GXFD 5LQDOGR/ SHU LPSXOVR GHOOD PDGUH /XFUH]LD %DUEHULQL/ DOORUFKp OD FULVL HFRQRPLFD GHO GXFDWR HUD VWDWD DJJUDYDWD GDOOH ULSHWXWH RFFXSD]LRQL GD SDUWH GHOOH WUXSSH DOHPDQQH1 /D GXFKHVVD PDGUH HUD VWDWD FRQTXLVWDWD GDOOH WHRULH GHO SDGUH JHVXLWD *LRYDQQL 0DULD %DOGLJLDQL/ FKH SHUFRUUHYD O·,WDOLD SURSXJQDQGR XQ VLVWHPD DVVLVWHQ]LDOH JLj GD WHPSR VSHULPHQWDWR H GLIIXVR LQ )UDQFLD1 7DOH VLVWHPD/ GHWWR DQFKH ´PHWRGR DOOD FDSSXFFLQDµ/ FRQVLVWHYD QHOO·RUJDQL]]DUH PLVVLRQL GXUDQWH OH TXDOL L SUHGLFDWRUL VROOHFLWDYDQR HOHPRVLQH LQ GDQDUR H LQ QDWXUD D IDYRUH GHL SRYHUL1 ,O ULFDYDWR VHUYLYD D ILQDQ]LDUH O·LVWLWX]LRQH GL RVSL]L QHOOH JUDQGL FLWWj H XIILFL GL FDULWj SHU O·DVVLVWHQ]D GHL SRYHUL D GRPLFLOLR QHL SLFFROL FHQWUL1 0D OR VFRSR SULQFLSDOH GL WDOL PLVVLRQL QRQ HUD WDQWR TXHOOR GHOOD UDF0 ²²²²²²²² 5 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UFKLWHWWL/ E1<24/ %OHWWHUD GL *XDULQR *XDULQL D )UDQFHVFR %LDQFKL/% 4 DSULOH 49:<1
;83
'DQLHOD *UDQD
FROWD GHOOH HOHPRVLQH/ TXDQWR TXHOOR GL LQVWLOODUH QHO SRYHUR LO FRQFHWWR GL SRYHUWj UDVVHJQDWD/ DO ILQH GL GLVWRJOLHUOR GDOOD WHQWD]LRQH GL SUHQGHUH OD YLD GHOOD FLWWj1 7DOL PLVVLRQL GLHGHUR QHO GXFDWR ULVXOWDWL VRGGLVIDFHQWL/ WDQWR FKH /XFUH]LD %DUEHULQL GHVWLQDYD SHU WHVWDPHQWR XQ OHJDWR SHU ILQDQ]LDUOH/ PHQ0 WUH QHO 4:45/ QHO GXFDWR HVWHQXDWR GDOOH RFFXSD]LRQL VWUDQLHUH/ LO GXFD 5LQDO0 GR ULODQFLDYD TXHVWR JHQHUH GL LQL]LDWLYD SHU ULVWDELOLUH O·RUGLQH PRUDOH H VR0 FLDOH1 1HO 49<8/ JUD]LH DOOD FDULWj GHL FLWWDGLQL FKH ULVSRVHUR JHQHURVDPHQWH DOOD SUHGLFD]LRQH GHO SDGUH %DOGLJLDQL H JUD]LH DQFKH D XQ FRVSLFXR FRQWULEXWR GXFDOH/ IX LVWLWXLWR O·2VSL]LR GHL 3RYHUL/ FKH HEEH VHGH QHL ORFDOL FKH HUDQR VWDWL GHO ILODWRLR ´GHJOL VSHQVLµ/ DFFDQWR D 6DQ 3LHWUR1 , SRYHUL FRQFHQWUDWL QHOO·2VSL]LR IXURQR DOO·LQL]LR SL• GL 533/ TXDVL WXWWL UDJD]]L G·DPER L VHVVL H TXDOFKH YHFFKLD LQDELOH DO ODYRUR1 ,Q VHJXLWR LO ORUR QXPHUR VL VWDELOL]]z LQ0 WRUQR D XQD FLIUD GL SRFR VXSHULRUH DO FHQWLQDLR1 $QFKH TXHVWR ,VWLWXWR/ DO SDUL GHOO·2SHUD GHL 0HQGLFDQWL/ HUD ILQDOL]]DWR DO UHFXSHUR H DOOD ULHGXFD]LRQH/ H GHVWLQDWR GXQTXH TXDVL HVFOXVLYDPHQWH DL UD0 JD]]L1 1HOO·DPELWR GL XQD FRQFH]LRQH GHOOD FDULWj ILQDOL]]DWD DOOD FUHD]LRQH GL XQD FODVVH RSHUDLD HG DUWLJLDQD SURGXWWLYD/ L PDVFKL ULFRYHUDWL QHOO·2VSL]LR YHQLYDQR PDQGDWL QHOOH ERWWHJKH FLWWDGLQH +SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH QHL ILODWRL, DG LPSDUDUH XQ PHVWLHUH/ PHQWUH OH UDJD]]H LPSDUDYDQR D FXFLUH VRWWR OD JXL0 GD GL XQD PDHVWUD H FRQIH]LRQDYDQR LQGXPHQWL H ELDQFKHULD SHU XVR GHOO·LVWLWXWR R VX FRPPLVVLRQH1 /·2VSL]LR DVVXQVH LQROWUH OH IXQ]LRQL GL PDJLVWUDWXUD SUHSRVWD DOOD SRYHU0 Wj/ IXQ]LRQL FKH O·2SHUD GHL 0HQGLFDQWL RUPDL GD WHPSR DYHYD VPHVVR GL VYROJHUH1 &RQ LO EDQGR GHO 5;05< PDJJLR 49<8 IX LPSRVWR DL PHQGLFDQWL O·REEOLJR GL SUHVHQWDUVL DL SUHVLGHQWL GHOO·2VSL]LR SHU RWWHQHUH OD OLFHQ]D GL TXHVWXDUH H LO QHFHVVDULR GLVWLQWLYR/ XQ FDUWRQH FRQ O·HIILJLH GL 6DQ *HPLQLDQR/ GD SRUWDUH EHQ YLVLELOH DO FROOR1 /·DFFDWWRQDJJLR IX GLVFLSOLQDWR/ PD UHDOLVWLFDPHQWH QRQ OR VL YLHWz1 , SHUPHVVL GL TXHVWXD YHQLYDQR ULODVFLDWL GRSR DWWHQWR YDJOLR GHJOL DWWHVWDWL GL SRYHUWj D ORUR YROWD ULODVFLDWL GDL SDUURFL1 )X WDVVDWLYDPHQWH YLHWD0 WR DL PHQGLFDQWL GL VWD]LRQDUH VRWWR L SRUWLFL VFRFFDWD OD SULPD RUD GHOOD QRWWH H GL IDUH VFKLDPD]]L R GL TXHVWXDUH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH FKLHVH/ ULEDGHQGR DQDOR0 JR GLYLHWR LPSRVWR QHO 49;: GDO YHVFRYR &DUOR 0RO]D/ SUHRFFXSDWR SHU %+1 1 1, HVVHUH FUHVFLXWD WDQW·ROWUH O·LQVROHQ]D H VFHOHUDWH]]D GH· VXGGHWWL SRYHUL OLPRVLQDQ0 WL/ FKH + 1 1, FRQ WHPHUDULR DUGLUH VL IDQQR OHFLWR GL FRPPHWWHUYL QHIDQGL VDFULOHJL/ SRUWDUYL
/H LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
;84
DPEDVFLHULH DPRURVH H WUDWWDUYL QHJR]LL LQGHJQL/ IDFHQGR OD &DVD GL 'LR OXRJR DG OHQRFLQLD SHUWUDFWDQGD1% 6
&RQ O·DYYHQWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, VL DSULYD XQ·HSRFD GL ULIRUPH FKH DYUHE0 EHUR LQYHVWLWR LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGR LO VHWWRUH DVVLVWHQ]LDOH1 /·XWRSLVWLFR LQWHQWR GL EDQGLUH OD PHQGLFLWj GDOOD FDSLWDOH H GDJOL VWDWL GLYHQQH LQIDWWL XQR GHJOL RELHWWLYL SULPDUL GHOOD SROLWLFD GHO GXFD ILQ GDJOL LQL]L GHO VXR UHJQR1 )XURQR LO 0DJLVWUDWR GL *LXULVGL]LRQH/ LQVLHPH DO PLQLVWUR GL %XRQ *R0 YHUQR D SUHSDUDUH LO FDPSR DOOH ULIRUPH YROXWH H VHJXLWH SHUVRQDOPHQWH H SXQWXDOPHQWH GDO GXFD VWHVVR/ IUD JOL XOWLPL UHJQDQWL G·(XURSD D FUHDUH TXHL GXH ´JUDQGL PRQXPHQWL GHOO·RUGLQH PRQDUFKLFR H ERUJKHVHµ/ SHU ULSUHQGHUH XQ·HVSUHVVLRQH GL )RXFDXOW/ FKH IXURQR LO *UDQGH 2VSHGDOH GHJOL ,QIHUPL H LO *UDQGH $OEHUJR GHL 3RYHUL1 ,O SULPLWLYR DPEL]LRVR SURJHWWR FKH PLUDYD D FUHDUH RVSL]L0UHFOXVRUL H R0 VSHGDOL GL JUDQGH FDSLHQ]D QHOOH PDJJLRUL FLWWj GHO GXFDWR YHQQH WXWWDYLD EHQ SUHVWR IUXVWUDWR VLD SHU OH HQRUPL GLIILFROWj H VSHVH FKH TXHVWR DYHYD FRP0 SRUWDWR QHOOD FDSLWDOH/ VLD SHU LO VRVWDQ]LDOH TXDQWR UDSLGR IDOOLPHQWR GHOO·LPSUHVD1 3HU SRWHU SURFHGHUH DOOD ULIRUPD GHO VLVWHPD RVSHGDOLHUR H DVVL0 VWHQ]LDOH GHOOD FDSLWDOH VL HUD GRYXWR ULFRUUHUH DOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GL QXPHURVL PRQDVWHUL/ FRQIUDWHUQLWH H RSHUH SLH GHOO·LQWHUR GXFDWR/ SHU FRQYRJOLDUQH OH UHQGLWH D IDYRUH GHL QXRYL LVWLWXWL FUHDWL QHOOD FDSLWDOH1 7XWWL L ´OXRJKLµ GHOOR VWDWR IXURQR LQROWUH FRVWUHWWL LQ TXDOFKH PRGR D SD0 JDUH LO ORUR WULEXWR SHU FRQFRUUHUH DOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHL GXH JUDQGL HGLILFL H SHU DFFUHVFHUH OH UHQGLWH GHOO·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL/ LVWLWXLWD QHO 4:97 DOOR VFRSR GL DPPLQLVWUDUH L EHQL GHVWLQDWL DOO·DVVLVWHQ]D GHL SRYHUL GHOOD FDSLWDOH H GHO GLVWUHWWR H GL JHVWLUH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD HFRQRPLFR H DPPLQL0 VWUDWLYR L GXH QXRYL LVWLWXWL FLWWDGLQL1 /D ULIRUPD/ FKH DYHYD FRPSRUWDWR OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GL WDQWH RSHUH SLH R O·DOWHUD]LRQH GHOOH ORUR ILQDOLWj/ FKH DYHYD JUDYDWR PROWR VXOOD SHULIHULD D WXWWR YDQWDJJLR GHOOD FDSLWDOH/ ULYHOz LQ EUHYLVVLPR WHPSR WXWWD OD VXD GLPHQVLRQH XWRSLVWLFD1 6L GLPRVWUz LQIDWWL LPSRVVLELOH FRQWHQHUH H FLUFRVFULYHUH DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ RVSL]LR0UHFOXVRULR VLD SXU GL JUDQGL GLPHQVLRQL OD GLODJDQWH PHQGLFLWj1 ,QROWUH LO IHQRPHQR GHOO·LQWDFFR GHL FDSLWDOL GHVWLQDWL DOOD SXEEOLFD DVVL0 VWHQ]D/ FKH SHU WXWWD O·HWj PRGHUQD DYHYD IRUQLWR O·DOLEL SHU SURFHGHUH LQ ²²²²²²²² 6 $602/ &KLURJUDIL GXFDOL/ JULGH H VWDWXWL/ *ULGH D VWDPSD/ YRO1 */ %HGLWWR GHO 45 GLFHPEUH 49;:%/ FKH ULSUHQGH WXWWDYLD DQDORJR SUHFHGHQWH EDQGR1
;85
'DQLHOD *UDQD
WHPSL HG RFFDVLRQL GLYHUVH DG DJJUHJD]LRQL/ VRSSUHVVLRQL H ULIRUPH SL• R PHQR UDGLFDOL/ QRQ VROR HUD GHVWLQDWR D ULSHWHUVL/ PD VL PDQLIHVWz TXHVWD YRO0 WD FRQ VWUDRUGLQDULD UDSLGLWj1 6L GLODSLGz QHOO·DUFR GL VROL RWWR DQQL XQ HQRUPH SDWULPRQLR H QRQRVWDQWH FLz OD FDSLWDOH H L PDJJLRUL FHQWUL GHO GXFDWR FRQWLQXDURQR DG HVVHUH LQIHVWDWL GDL PHQGLFDQWL/ FKH FRVWLWXLURQR OD SHQRVD SHFXOLDULWj GHO SDHVDJJLR HVWHQVH GHOO·HSRFD1 1HO 4::5 LO GXFD GRYHWWH FRUUHUH DL ULSDUL/ DIILGDQGR DG XQD 'H0 SXWD]LRQH 6RSULQWHQGHQWH LO FRPSLWR GL ULVDQDUH L JXDVWL GHOO·2SHUD 3LD *H0 QHUDOH1 /D 'HSXWD]LRQH/ FXL OR VWHVVR GXFD GHWWDYD L FULWHUL GD VHJXLUH/ SRUWDYD D WHUPLQH OD VXD RSHUD WUH DQQL GRSR H TXHO FKH QH VHJXu IX XQD FRQWUD]LRQH GHOOH VSHVH SHU LO SHUVRQDOH/ QRQFKp OD VFHOWD GL SULYLOHJLDUH QHOO·DVVLVWHQ]D L SRYHUL GHOOH FODVVL VRFLDOL SL• HOHYDWH D VFDSLWR GHL SRYHUL PLVHUDELOL1 3UHVR LQROWUH DWWR GHOO·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL DVVRUELPHQWR GL PDQRGRSHUD GD SDUWH GHO VHWWRUH PDQLIDWWXULHUR/ VL GLURWWDURQR PROWL GHJOL DOEHUJDQWL LQ FDPSDJQD LQ DLXWR GL IDPLJOLH FRQWDGLQH ELVRJQRVH GL EUDFFLD1 1RQRVWDQWH FLz LO SUREOHPD GHOOD PHQGLFLWj ULPDQHYD SUHVVDQWH H LPPX0 WDWR QHOOH SURSRU]LRQL H QHOOH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL H LO VXFFHGHUVL D ULWPR VHUUDWR GL EDQGL FRQWUR O·LQXUEDPHQWR GHL FRQWDGLQL QRQ HUD FKH LO VLQWRPR PDQLIHVWR GHOO·HVSORVLYLWj GHO IHQRPHQR1 0D VH DQFRUD OH ULIRUPH DVVLVWHQ]LDOL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ PDOJUDGR LO WHQWDWL0 YR GL WRWDOH UHFOXVLRQH/ ULVHQWLYDQR GHOOR VSLULWR ILODQWURSLFR FKH IRUVH LO GXFD/ DOOLHYR LQ JLRYHQW• GHO 0XUDWRUL/ DYHYD DVVLPLODWR GDO VXR PDHVWUR/ OH ULIRUPH DWWXDWH VRWWR LO UHJQR GHOO·XOWLPR HVWHQVH GLPRVWUDURQR OD SL• VRUGD RVWLOLWj DL SUREOHPL GHL FRQWDGLQL H GHL SRYHUL1 &RQ O·DYYHQWR DO WURQR GL (UFROH ,,, SXz FRQVLGHUDUVL LQIDWWL GHILQLWLYD H LQVDQDELOH OD IUDWWXUD IUD LO SRSROR GHJOL LQGLJHQWL H GHJOL HPDUJLQDWL H OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH1 /LEHUDUH OH FLWWj GDOO·LPSRUWXQLWj GL XQD PDVVD GL DFFDWWRQL GLYHQ0 QH LQIDWWL LO QRGR IRQGDPHQWDOH GHOOD SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFD GHO JRYHUQR 0XQD0 ULQL1 /D ULIRUPD GHJOL LVWLWXWL SLL/ DWWXDWD WUD LO 4:;; H LO 4:<4/ PRVWUz WXWWR LO VXR FDUDWWHUH FODVVLVWD QHO OLPLWDUH DOO·LQGLVSHQVDELOH O·DVVLVWHQ]D ULYROWD DOOD FODVVH GHL PLVHUDELOL H QHOO·DPSOLDUOD YLFHYHUVD DL ELVRJQRVL GHOOH FODVVL SL• H0 OHYDWH1 6L VYXRWDURQR GHL SRYHUL JOL $OEHUJKL0UHFOXVRUL FKH YHQQHUR WUDVIRU0 PDWL LQ $OEHUJKL GHOOH $UWL/ SUHVVR L TXDOL/ FRQ FDSLWDOL SULYDWL PD FRQ LO SD0 WURFLQLR GHOOR 6WDWR/ VL WHQWz D IDWLFD GL LPSLDQWDUH QXRYH PDQLIDWWXUH1 ,O SUREOHPD GHL SRYHUL IX DIIURQWDWR ´VFLHQWLILFDPHQWHµ/ IDFHQGRQH FLWWj SHU FLWWj/ SDUURFFKLD SHU SDUURFFKLD LO FHQVLPHQWR1
/H LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
;86
$ 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ GRYH HUDQR VWDWL FUHDWL JOL $OEHUJKL GHOOH $UWL/ VL VFHO0 VHUR L SRYHUL GD REEOLJDUH DO ODYRUR SUHVVR OH QXRYH PDQLIDWWXUH1 )XURQR DX0 WRUL]]DWL DOOD TXHVWXD VROR JOL LQYDOLGL/ FXL YHQLYD ULODVFLDWR LO ´EROOHWWRQHµ/ XQ SHUPHVVR FLRq GD ULQQRYDUH RJQL GXH DQQL SUHYLR FRQWUROOR GHOOD YDOLGLWj GHL UHTXLVLWL1 7XWWL JOL DOWUL/ VH VFRSHUWL D PHQGLFDUH/ YHQLYDQR SHUVHJXLWL DOOD VWUH0 JXD GL PDOIDWWRUL1 6L SURPXRYHYD LQROWUH XQ PRGHOOR DVVLVWHQ]LDOH/ FKH VL LVSLUDYD DOOD PXUD0 WRULDQD 2SHUD GHOOD &DULWj/ GHVWLQDWR D FKL QRQ IRVVH LQ JUDGR SHU O·HWj R SHU OH FRQGL]LRQL ILVLFKH GL ODYRUDUH R SHU FRQGL]LRQH VRFLDOH GL TXHVWXDUH1 /·LQWHQWR HUD GL FRVWLWXLUH LQ WXWWL L FHQWUL XUEDQL XQD &RPSDJQLD GHOOD &D0 ULWj FRQ LO FRPSLWR GL UDFFRJOLHUH OH HOHPRVLQH SHU SRL UHGLVWULEXLUOH LQ SUR0 SRU]LRQH DL ELVRJQL H DOOR VWDWXV VRFLDOH DL YHUL SRYHUL/ D TXHOOL FLRq FKH HUDQR VWDWL VFKHGDWL FRPH WDOL LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO FHQVLPHQWR1 &RPSRVWD GL VROL ODLFL YRORQWDUL/ O·RSHUD GHOOD FDULWj DYHYD QHO SDUURFR LO SULQFLSDOH SXQWR GL ULIHUL0 PHQWR1 ,O SDUURFR GLYHQLYD LO SUHVLGHQWH GHOOD &RPSDJQLD QHOO·DPELWR WHUULWR0 ULDOH GL FRPSHWHQ]D GHOOD SDUURFFKLD1 &RDGLXYDWR GD GHSXWDWL H GD LQIHUPLHUL/ DYHYD LO FRPSLWR GL RUJDQL]]DUH LO VHUYL]LR DVVLVWHQ]LDOH SURYYHGHQGR DOOD UH0 JLVWUD]LRQH GHL SRYHUL UHVLGHQWL QHO TXDUWLHUH/ DOOD UDFFROWD GHOOH HOHPRVLQH/ H DOOD ORUR UHGLVWULEX]LRQH LQ EDVH DL ELVRJQL> D OXL VSHWWDYD DQFKH GL YLJLODUH VXOOD FRQGRWWD PRUDOH H FLYLOH GHJOL DVVLVWLWL1 1RQ WXWWL L SDUURFL WXWWDYLD DGHULURQR FRQ HJXDOH HQWXVLDVPR DOO·LQL]LDWLYD SHU JOL RQHUL FKH HVVD FRPSRUWDYD1 ( LQ YHUR DQFKH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD VWHVVD FRPSDJLQH PLQLVWHULDOH FKH DYHYD HPDQDWR OH GLUHWWLYH VL PDQLIHVWDYD XQ FHU0 WR GLVVHQVR/ FRPH VL HYLQFH GD XQD VHULH GL QRWH PDQRVFULWWH WURYDWH IUD OH FDUWH GHO FRQVLJOLHUH GL HFRQRPLD &DUOR 3HGUHWWL/ FKH SHU TXDOFKH WHPSR FRO0 ODERUz FRQ LO 5LFFL H LO 0XQDULQL DOOR VWXGLR GHOOD ULIRUPD GHJOL LVWLWXWL SLL1 )UD TXHVWH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LQWHUHVVDQWL VRQR OH JORVVH DL FDSLWROL GHOOD &RPSD0 JQLD GHOOD &DULWj/ GL PDQR/ VHPEUD/ GHOOR VWHVVR 3HGUHWWL1 (JOL/ FRQ HYLGHQWH ULIHULPHQWR DOO·RSHUD PXUDWRULDQD ,O FULVWLDQHVLPR IHOLFH QHOOH PLVVLRQL GH· SDGUL GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV• QHO 3DUDJXDL/ VL FKLHGH ´6LDPR QRL DO 3DUDJXDL " 1p OL SDUUR0 FL VRQR JHVXLWL/ Qp LQGLDQL TXHVWL DELWDQWLµ17 ,Q GHILQLWLYD LO JRYHUQR 0XQDULQL DYHYD DIIURQWDWR OD FRPSOHVVD TXHVWLRQH VRFLDOH ULXVFHQGR D SRUWDUH DO SDUHJJLR L ELODQFL GHOOH RSHUH SLH/ WUDVIRUPDQGR JOL DOEHUJKL GHL SRYHUL LQ FDVH GL ODYRUR/ LPSLHJDQGR FLUFD 61333 SHUVRQH IUD RSHUDL H DUWLJLDQL QHOOH JUDQGL RSHUH SXEEOLFKH1 0D OH DWWLYLWj LPSLDQWDWH ²²²²²²²² 7 $602/ $UFKLYLR 0RQWDJQDQL/ %RFFRODUL/ 3HGUHWWL/ &DUWH 3HGUHWWL/ &DSLWROL GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GHOOD &DULWj/ E1 83
;87
'DQLHOD *UDQD
QHOO·$OEHUJR $UWL GHFDGGHUR LQ EUHYLVVLPR WHPSR/ PHQWUH JOL DUWLJLDQL FRQWL0 QXDYDQR D ODPHQWDUVL SHUFKp L VDODUL FRQFHVVL GDOO·DOEHUJR HUDQR WURSSR DOWL H IDFHYDQR FRQFRUUHQ]D DL ORUR1 &LRQRQRVWDQWH QRQ VL YROOH FKLXGHUH OD FDVD GL ODYRUR/ H/ ULPDVWL LQVROXWL WXWWL L QRGL GL XQD SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFD FKH QRQ DYH0 YD DYXWR LO FRUDJJLR GL LQWDFFDUH OH DUHH GHO SULYLOHJLR H GL VSH]]DUH L PRQR0 SROL/ QRQ VL ULXVFu HJXDOPHQWH D FRQWHQHUH LO IHQRPHQR GHOOD GLVRFFXSD]LRQH/ GHO SDXSHULVPR/ GHOOD PHQGLFLWj1 3UREOHPD TXHVWR FKH O·LPPLQHQWH DUULYR GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH DYUHEEH ULVROWR SHUVHJXHQGR LO UHDWR GL DFFDWWRQDJJLR FRQ O·DUUHVWR R FRQ O·LQWHUQDPHQWR IRU]DWR QHL GHSRVLWL GL PHQGLFLWj1
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;88
$11$ *,$11(77,
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
$JOL RFFKL GHL YLDJJLDWRUL FKH VL PXRYRQR OXQJR JOL LWLQHUDUL RUPDL FRQVR0 OLGDWL GHO *UDQG 7RXU/ O·LPPDJLQH GL 0RGHQD IDWLFD D SUHQGHUH FRUSR/ RVFLO0 ODQGR D OXQJR WUD OD ´FLWWj IHWHQWHµ OHJDWD DOOH SDJLQH GL 7DVVRQL LQVLHPH DOOD IDPRVD 6HFFKLD H TXHOOD EHOOD/ SXOLWD H RUGLQDWD/ FKH GHOL]LD OD YLVLWD GHO PDU0 FKHVH GH 6DGH GXUDQWH LO VRJJLRUQR GHO OXJOLR 4::841 /·DQQR VXFFHVVLYR -HDQ0 0DULH 5RODQG GH OD 3ODWLpUH VL SHUGHYD QXRYDPHQWH QHOOD EUXWWH]]D H PDOLQ0 FRQLD GHO GXRPR/ FKH JOL DSSDULYD JRWLFR FRPH LO YHVVDWRULR SRWHUH GHO GXFD VHPSUH DVVHQWH1 1HVVXQD DWWUDWWLYD JOL ULXVFLYD GL VFRUJHUH QHOOD FLWWj/ SXU UL0 FRQRVFHQGR OD EHOOH]]D GHO SDOD]]R GXFDOH H OD SUHVHQ]D GL DOFXQH FKLHVH QR0 WHYROL51 'LHFL DQQL GRSR/ QHO 4:;9/ LO QDSROHWDQR *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD 0DODVSLQD/ PD GL RULJLQH SDUPHQVH/ ULWRUQDQGR GD 3DULJL GRYH DYHYD DFFRPSDJQDWR LO PDUFKHVH GHO 9DVWR DPEDVFLDWRUH LQ 3RUWRJDOOR/ ULEDOWD LO JLXGL]LR WUDGL]LRQD0 OH/ WURYDQGR WULVWH H PDOPHVVD 3DUPD/ GRYH HUD JLXQWR GD *HQRYD/ H VRU0 SUHQGHQGRVL QHO UHJLVWUDUH OD PHWDPRUIRVL GHOOD EUXWWD 0RGHQD LQ XQD GHOOH SL• EHOOH FLWWj GHOOD SHQLVROD61 'HJQR GL QRWD JOL DSSDUH DQFKH O·LPSRQHQWH PR0 QXPHQWR HTXHVWUH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ VFROSLWR QHO 4::7 GD *LRYDQQL $QWRQLR &\EHL H IDWWR HULJHUH GDOOD FRPXQLWj FLWWDGLQD LQ VHJQR GL JUDWLWXGLQH WUD LO ´JUDQGH 6SHFLDOHµ H LO ´JUDQGH $OEHUJR GHL 3RYHULµ/ FKH 5RODQG GH OD 3ODWLqUH LQYHFH DYHYD WURYDWR PHGLRFUH FRPH OD SLD]]D FKH OR RVSLWDYD1 3RVL]LRQL FRQWUDVWDQWL LQ FXL VL FRQGHQVDQR YHFFKL OXRJKL FRPXQL VXOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH H QRYLWj UHVH HYLGHQWL GDOOH UDSLGH RVFLOOD]LRQL GHO JXVWR/ QHO0 ²²²²²²²² 4
3HU XQD VLVWHPDWLFD H SXQWXDOH FDWDORJD]LRQH GHL WHVWL/ 9LDJJL H YLDJJLDWRUL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR LQ (PLOLD H LQ 5RPDJQD/ D FXUD GL *1 &86$7(//,/ %RORJQD 4<;9/ 5 YROO1 > &1 '( 6(7$/ /·,WDOLD QHOOR VSHFFKLR GHO ´*UDQG 7RXUµ/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<;5/ YRO1 91 SS1 45:05971 5 -101 52/$' '( /$ 3/$7,(5(/ /HWWUHV11 3DULJL 4:;</ YRO1 ,,/ S1 58 H 6V1 6 $1 '·$1&21$/ 9LDJJLDWRUL H DYYHQWXULHUL/ )LUHQ]H 4<:7/ S15;41
;89
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
OH TXDOL SUHJLXGL]LR HVWHWLFR H SROLWLFR VL FRUULVSRQGRQR SL• FKH PDL LQ WDOH VFRUFLR GL VHFROR = L SLFFROL VWDWL LWDOLDQL VRQR XQ·DQRPDOLD FKH LQIDVWLGLVFH L YLDJJLDWRUL G·ROWUDOSH/ QHO PHVFRODUVL GL QRELOL ULIOHVVLRQL H GL YLVFHUDOL LQVRIIH0 UHQ]H QHL FRQIURQWL GL UHDOWj FKH DSSDLRQR LQXWLOPHQWH VRSUDYYLVVXWH DO ORUR WHPSR FRPH LO PRQGR JRWLFR FKH VL LQWUDYHGH VRWWR OD OXPLQRVD VWUXWWXUD XU0 EDQD GHOOD 0RGHQD WDUGR VHWWHFHQWHVFD1 6H LQ XQD SURVSHWWLYD VHWWHQWULRQDOH/ LO PHULGLRQH/ FRPH GLUH]LRQH JHRJUDILFD/ VL VWD WUDVIRUPDQGR LQ GLUH]LRQH VLPEROLFD FXOWXUDOPHQWH UHJUHVVLYD/ DOLPHQWDQGR LO QDVFHQWH URPDQ]R JRWLFR/ LO JLXGL]LR WXWWR VRPPDWR SRVLWLYR FKH OH YLHQH ULVHUYDWR DSSDUH DQFRU SL• LQGLFDWLYR/ VH QRQ VRUSUHQGHQWH1 ,QIRQGR/ OD SUHVHQ]D GHOO·$SSHQQLQR SRWUHEEH HVVHUH VXIILFLHQWH D IDU UL0 VDOWDUH LO FXRUH PHGLHYDOH FKH OD FLWWj FRQVHUYD/ ULVXFFKLDQGROD QHO SURSULR FRQR G·RPEUD1 'RSR WXWWR (PLO\/ OD SURWDJRQLVWD GL TXHOOR FKH q LO PDJJLRU VXFFHVVR GHO URPDQ]R JRWLFR/ 7KH 0\VWHULHV RI 8GROSKR GL $QQ 5DGFOLIIH HGLWR QHO 4:<7/ GDO SDOD]]R VXO &DQDO *UDQGH SRVVHGXWR GD 0RQWRQL/ LO IRVFR LWD0 OLDQR/ VL PXRYH GLUHWWD DO ODELULQWLFR FDVWHOOR GL 8GROIR DWWUDYHUVR OH RVFXULWj WHUULILFDQWL GHOOH PRQWDJQH DSSHQQLQLFKH1 9HQH]LD/ DQFKH SHU OHL q OD SULPD WDSSD G·XQ YLDJJLR YHUVR 6XG H TXLQGL YHUVR XQ PRQGR DQWLFR H FRQVXQWR/ VSDYHQWRVR H LUUD]LRQDOH VHPSUH SURQWR D HPHUJHUH DO GLVRWWR GHJOL VSOHQGRUL H GHOOD FODVVLFD PLVXUD/ OR VWHVVR FKH D IDWLFD VL ULHVFH D PDQWHQHUH DL PDUJLQL GHOOD ´EHOODµ FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH1 $Q]L/ OD FLWWj VL PXRYH FRQWURFRUUHQWH ULVSHWWR DOOH VXH YLFLQH SL• EODVRQD0 WH/ FRVu GD SDVVDUH GDO JLXGL]LR IUHWWRORVR H JHQHULFR FKH/ DOO·LQGRPDQL GHO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH/ 6FKRWW/ QHOOD JXLGD SL• OHWWD H WUDGRWWD GL WXWWR LO 6HLFHQWR/ QRQ DYHYD SRWXWR QRQ ULVHUYDUOH/ GHVFULYHQGROD SLFFROD H GL IRUPD FLUFRODUH PHQR ULFFD H YLYDFH GL 5HJJLR7/ D TXHOOR HVSUHVVR GD *HRUJ $U0 QDOG -DFREL/ FKH YL JLXQJH LO 53 QRYHPEUH GHO 4:<4/ GHILQHQGROD OD SL• EHOOD FKH VL SRVVD LQFRQWUDUH YHQHQGR GD *HQRYD/ FXOWD H VRFLHYROH H DPPLUDQGRQH JOL HOHJDQWL HGLILFL H JOL DPSL SRUWLFL8/ FRVu GD WURYDUVL LQ SHUIHWWR DFFRUGR FRQ O·DXWRUH GL XQD JXLGD LQJOHVH/ -1 2ZHQ FKH QHOOR VWHVVR DQQR OD VFRSUH GHOL]LR0 VD PHQWUH YLVLWD OD FDWWHGUDOH H OD FDSSHOOD GL 6DQ *HPLQLDQR19 ²²²²²²²² 7
)1 6&+277/ ,WLQHUDULL ,WDOLDH UHUXPTXH URPDQRUXP OLEUL WUHV/ $QYHUVD 48<</ WUDG1 LW1 4944/ S14761 8 *1$1 -$&2%,/ %ULHIH DXV GHU 6FKZHL] XQG ,WDOLHQ/ /XEHFK XQG /HLS]LQJ 4:<9/ ,/ SS1 44:0 44;1 9 -1 2:(1/ 7UDYHOV LQWR 'LIIHUHQW 3DUWV RI (XURSH LQ WKH \HDUV 4:<4 DQG 4:<5/ /RQGRQ 4:<91
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;8:
/D FLWWj YROXWD GD )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ LQVRPPD/ ULEDOWD OD SURSULD LPPDJLQH/ VXUFODVVDQGR O·HWHUQD ULYDOH 5HJJLR/ ILQR DG DOORUD VHPSUH DSSDUVD SL• SXOLWD/ RUGLQDWD H PHJOLR HGLILFDWD/ PD DQFKH OD SL• WLWRODWD 3DUPD H VH FLz QH VDQFL0 YD OD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH LQ PRGHUQD H DFFRJOLHQWH FDSLWDOH/ q DQFKH YHUR FKH/ DO FRQWUDULR/ 3DUPD FRPH %RORJQD SRWHYDQR RUPDL YDQWDUH VROR XQ JORULRVR SDVVDWR1 /D JHRJUDILD GHO *UDQG 7RXU VL HUD PRGLILFDWD/ PD DQFKH OR VJXDUGR GHL YLDJJLDWRUL HUD SURIRQGDPHQWH PXWDWR1 8Q SLWWRUH GL SDHVDJJL FRPH 7KRPDV -RQHV/ SDUWLWR SHU O·,WDOLD QHO 4::9/ GRSR DYHU WURYDWR /LRQH PROWR SL• EHOOD GL 3DULJL H HVVHUVL HQWXVLDVPDWR SHU OH URFFH/ SUHFLSL]L H SLWWRUHVFKH PRQWDJQH GHOOH $OSL H TXLQGL GHOO·$SSHQQLQR/ DWWUD0 YHUVD FRQ LQGLIIHUHQ]D 0LODQR/ PD DQFKH 3LDFHQ]D H %RORJQD1 4XDQWR D 3DUPD QRQ JOL VHPEUD PHULWDUH SL• GHOOD VRVWD GL XQD QRWWH SHU YHGHUH &RU0 UHJJLR H VROR XQD YROWD JLXQWR D 0RGHQD/ XQ DQQR GRSR 5RODQG GH OD 3ODWLp0 UH/ LO VXR LQWHUHVVH VL ULVYHJOLD = OD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH JOL DSSDUH FRPH OD FLWWj SL• EHOOD FKH DYHVVL PDL YLVWR/ FRQ OH FDVH ELDQFKH H OH VWUDGH SRUWLFDWH:/ UHDOL]]D]LRQH HVHP0 SODUH GHOOR VWLOH SHUIHWWDPHQWH LWDOLDQR GL FXL HUD SDUWLWR DOOD ULFHUFD1 &RVu FKH QRQ VRUSUHQGH FKH QHL SULPL DQQL GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ 0RGHQD DSSDLD DGGLULWWXUD WURSSR VSOHQGLGD H WURSSR PDJQLILFD LQ UDSSRUWR DO SURSULR 'RPLQLR VHFRQGR LO JLXGL0 ]LR GHILQLWLYR GL TXHOOD VXPPD GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD SHULHJHWLFD FKH q OD JUDQGH ELEOLRWHFD GL %UX]HQ GH OD 0DUWLQLpUH1 3HU WXWWR LO 6HLFHQWR/ 0RGHQD HUD VWDWD SRFR SL• GL XQD WDSSD SHU UDJ0 JLXQJHUH DOWUH PHWH/ XQ OXRJR GL SDVVDJJLR/ SL• R PHQR/ REEOLJDWR/ H D IDWLFD VL HUD GLVWDFFDWD GDO PRVDLFR/ UHJRODUH ILQR DOOD PRQRWRQLD/ GHOOH WHUUH FKH FRPSRQHYDQR OD ´/RPEDUGLD GL TXD GDO 3Rµ/ R (PLOLD/ QRQRVWDQWH LO VXR SURILOR DSSDULVVH FRPH XQ VHJQR QHWWR QHOO·RUL]]RQWH VFRQILQDWR FKH *RHWKH DPPLUDYD LQ ORQWDQDQ]D/ GDOO·DOWR GHOOD WRUUH GL %RORJQD/ YHGHQGRYL HPHUJH0 UH VROWDQWR OH WRUUL GL 0RGHQD;1 '·DOWURQGH/ DOO·HSRFD LQ FXL 6FKRWW O·DYHYD LQVHULWD QHO VXR LWLQHUDULR VL HUD DSSHQD FRQVXPDWD OD ODJULPHYRO 7UDJHGLD FRPH GHILQLYD 0XUDWRUL O·DEEDQGRQR GL )HUUDUD</ YLVVXWR GDL VLJQRUL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR TXDOH LUULPHGLDELOH FDF0 FLDWD GD XQ GRPLQLR FKH OH DUWL H OH OHWWHUH DYHYDQR WUDVIRUPDWR LQ PRGHOOR SHU OH DOWUH FRUWL LWDOLDQH H VWUDQLHUH1 /D QXRYD VHGH VHPEUDYD UHQGHUH SL• FR0 FHQWH OD VFRQILWWD GHOOD FDVD G·(VWH/ FRO YHFFKLR FDVWHOOR PHGLHYDOH FKH TXHO ²²²²²²²² : &1 '( 6(7$/ 7KRPDV -RQHV H L VXRL ´0HPRLUVµ / LQ 9HGXWLVWL H YLDJJLDWRUL LQ ,WDOLD WUD 6HWWHFHQWR H 2WWRFHQWR/ 7RULQR 4<<</ S1 781 ; -1:1 *2(7+(/ 9LDJJLR LQ ,WDOLD 4:;904:;;/ HG1 LW1 )LUHQ]H 4<;3/ S14361 < /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOH $QWLFKLWj HVWHQVL1 &RQWLQXD]LRQH/ R VLD 3DUWH 6HFRQGD/ 0RGHQD 4:4:1
;8;
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
SRVVHGLPHQWR/ VLQR DG DOORUD FRQVLGHUDWR VHFRQGDULR/ DYHYD SRWXWR RIIULUH DO GXFD &HVDUH LO TXDOH ULVLHGHYD QHOOH &DPHUH WXWWH QHJUH GL FDOLJLQH/ H D )HUUDUD JOL DO0 WUL VWDQQR QHOOH FDPHUH WXWWH G·RUR/ FRPH DQQRWDYD OR 6SDFFLQL QHOOD &URQDFD 1 ,Q0 IRQGR/ HUD SRFR SL• GL XQD SLD]]DIRUWH VXO FRQILQH VHPSUH FDOGR FRQ OR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD H/ D SDUWH LO 'XRPR/ OD *KLUODQGLQD H LO &RPXQH/ DSSDULYD FRPH XQ DJJORPHUDWR GL FDVH GL PDWWRQL/ DIIDFFLDWH VX FDQDOL H VRYUDVWDWH GDOOH WRUUL GHOOH UHVLGHQ]H QRELOLDUL H GD TXDOFKH FKLHVD1 6ROR FRQ LO QLSRWH )UDQFHVFR ,/ FRVWDQWHPHQWH LPSHJQDWR QHL TXDVL WUHQWD DQQL GHO VXR UHJQR D IDUH GL 0R0 GHQD OD FDSLWDOH GL XQR VWDWR SLHQDPHQWH ULFRQRVFLXWR H ULVSHWWDWR/ GDQGROH IRUPD H YLVLELOLWj FRQ XQD VHULH GL LQWHUYHQWL FRPH OD FRVWUX]LRQH GHO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH H GHOOD VSOHQGLGD UHJJLD HVWLYD GL 6DVVXROR/ HUD XVFLWD GDOO·RPEUD GHL WHWWL D VSLRYHQWH GHOO·LPSLDQWR PHGLHYDOH H VRSUDWWXWWR LQ YLUW• GHO IRUPLGDEL0 OH VWUXPHQWR GHO FROOH]LRQLVPR DUWLVWLFR VL HUD LPSRVWD DOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GL TXHOOD QXRYD UD]]D GL YLDJJLDWRUL DWWUDWWL SL• GDOOD JUDQGH SLWWXUD PRGHUQD FKH GDOOH YHVWLJLD URPDQH431 *UD]LH DOOD *DOOHULD GHOOH 3LWWXUH H DOOD IDPD FKH DFFRPSDJQD L GLSLQWL FKH YL VRQR UDFFROWL H FKH QDWXUDOPHQWH FRLQFLGH FRQ LO IDVFLQR HVHUFLWDWR GHOOH RSHUH GHO &RUUHJJLR/ OD FLWWj HQWUD D SLHQR GLULWWR LQ WDOL LWLQHUDUL VSHFLDOLVWLFL/ QHL TXDOL/ SHUz/ SRFR SL• GL XQR VJXDUGR GLVWUDWWR q ULVHUYDWR DOOH UHDOWj FKH FLUFRQGDQR OH SUH]LRVH RSHUH G·DUWH1 &KDUOHV01LFRODV &RFKLQ/ SXEEOLFDQGR LO UHVRFRQWR GHO YLDJJLR FRPSLXWR FRQ LO JLRYDQH IUDWHOOR GL 0DGDPH GH 3RP0 SDGRXU/ LO IXWXUR PDUFKHVH GL 0DULJQ\/ H GHVWLQDWR D GLYHQLUH LO SXQWR GL ULIH0 ULPHQWR REEOLJDWR SHU RJQL YDOXWD]LRQH VXOOD SLWWXUD LWDOLDQD/ QRQ IRUPXOD DO0 FXQ JLXGL]LR VX 0RGHQD H VXL VXRL DELWDQWL/ FRPH/ G·DOWURQGH/ VXOOH DOWUH FLWWj LQ FXL OD FRPLWLYD VRJJLRUQD1 $OOR VWHVVR PRGR LQ FXL VL VRIIHUPD DG DQDOL]]D0 UH FRQ FXUD L TXDGUL GHOOD *DOOHULD/ ULIHUHQGR WUD PLOOH FDXWHOH DXWRUL H VRJJHWWL 44 / FRVu VWLOD XQ EHQ SL• UDSLGR HOHQFR GHOOH DUFKLWHWWXUH/ R PHJOLR GHOOH GHFR0 UD]LRQL FKH SUHVHQWDQR = LO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH q QRELOH H JUDQGH/ OD FDWWHGUDOH XQ HGL0 ILFLR JRWLFR DEEDVWDQ]D DQWLFR/ OD FKLHVD GHL &DUPHOLWDQL YLFLQR 3RUWD %RORJQD KD XQD FXSROD H XQD YROWD DIIUHVFDWD PROWR EHQ FRPSRVWD/ LO WHDWUR q EHQ GHFRUDWR1 6ROR OD GHOL]LD GL 6DVVXROR ULHVFH YHUDPHQWH DG HQWXVLDVPDUOR/ R SLXWWRVWR OH RSHUH GL %LEELHQD H GL %RXODQJHU451 ²²²²²²²² 43
-1 %(17,1,/ ´2WLXP 5HJLXPµ1 , SULYLOHJL GHO SULQFLSH FROOH]LRQLVWD/ RYYHUR OH TXDOLWj GHOOD *DOOHULD GHO 6HUHQLVVLPR 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ LQ 6RYUDQH 3DVVLRQL/ FDWDORJR PRVWUD 0RGHQD 4<<;/ 0LODQR 4<<;/ S1 571 44 &111 &2&+,1/ 9R\DJH G·,WDOLH RX 5HFXHLO GH 1RWHV/ 3DULV 4:8404:9</ ,/ S1::1 45 ,ELGHP/ S1;6
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;8<
1HO JUDQGH PXVHR ,WDOLD/ GXQTXH/ 0RGHQD WURYD XQD SURSULD GHJQD FROOR0 FD]LRQH/ FRVu FRPH FRQ PROWD PDJJLRU IDWLFD O·DYHYD WURYDWD QHOO·,WDOLD $QWL0 TXD1 /R VWHVVR VJXDUGR VHOHWWLYR H VSHFLDOLVWLFR GL &RFKLQ DYHYD JLj DGRSHUD0 WR/ DOOD ILQH GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ (QV/ O·DXWRUH GHOOH IDPRVH 'HOLFLDH ,WDOLDH/ OD0 VFLDQGR VFRPSDULUH L PRQXPHQWL FLWWDGLQL VRWWR XQD GLIIXVD SDWLQD DQWLTXD0 ULD1 8Q WUHQWHQQLR SL• WDUGL LO GRWWR &OXYHULR/ DOO·HOHQFR GHOOH VFDUVH YHVWLJLD URPDQH DJJLXQJHYD QRWD]LRQL VXOO·LQGROH EHOOLFRVD H IHGHOH DO ORUR VLJQRUH GHL PRGHQHVL H VXOOD SUXGHQ]D GL JLXGL]LR GHL UHJJLDQL46 H VL OLPLWDYD D SURFODPD0 UH OD FLWWj FDSLWDOH GHO GXFDWR/ VHJXLWR FRPH VHPSUH GD 0RUHO\ FKH WUDVIRU0 PDYD 5HJJLR QHOOD VHFRQGD FLWWj GHOOR 6WDWR/ JUDQGH H IRUWH/ GRPLQDWD GD 0RGHQD FKH VL VFRUJHYD GD ORQWDQR FRQ LO VXR &DPSDQLOH1 &RPH LQ XQ JLRFR SURVSHWWLFR/ JOL DOWL HOHPHQWL YHUWLFDOL GHOOD VWUXWWXUD SL• DQWLFD VHPEUDQR YLVLELOL VROR LQ ORQWDQDQ]D > XQD YROWD HQWUDWL/ R SLXWWRVWR XQD YROWD HQWUDWD 0RGHQD QHOOD JHRJUDILD GHO *UDQG 7RXU/ VFRPSDLRQR/ VHQ]D ULXVFLUH D WURYDUH SRVWR LQ QHVVXQR GHL FDWDORJKL FKH GHILQLVFRQR OH DWWUDWWLYH FLWWDGLQH1 6HJQR QHWWR GL XQ·DOWUD FLWWj/ SHU OD TXDOH QRQ F·q DQFRUD SRVWR QHO SDHVDJJLR GHO %HO 3DHVH/ Qp LQ TXHOOR GHOOD OXPLQRVD FDSLWDOH UDIILJXUDWD VXOOD ILQLUH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR QHOOD IDPRVD VHULH GL YHGXWH GHOO·LQFLVRUH SDUPHQVH *X0 JOLHOPR 6LOYHVWHU/ GRYH DWWRUQR DO WUDGL]LRQDOH IXOFUR YLVLYR GHOOD *KLUODQGLQD VL DUWLFROD XQD QLWLGD VWUXWWXUD XUEDQD/ IUXWWR GL TXHO GHFRUR FKH HVDOWDYD LO ´%XRQ *RYHUQRµ1 6H OD 7RUUH &LYLFD/ GD WHPSR 0R]]D/ HUD RUPDL VFRPSDU0 VD/ TXHOOD GHOO·2URORJLR QRQ HUD SHU TXHVWR SL• OHJJLELOH H SHUVLQR LO ELSRODUL0 VPR WUD OD HWHUQD *KLUODQGLQD H LO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH/ FKH SXUH GRPLQDYD OD YH0 GXWD SHU FXL SUHJDYD O·DQRQLPR 6DQ *HPLQLDQR GL TXDOFKH GHFHQQLR SUHFH0 GHQWH/ FRQVHUYDWD QHO 0XVHR &LYLFR/ DSSDULYD VWHPSHUDWR QHOOD FRPSOHVVLWj GHO SURILOR GHOOD FLWWj PRGHUQD/ DQ]L GXFDOH1 $OOR VWHVVR PRGR Qp GH 6DGH/ Qp 0DODVSLQD/ Qp WDQWR PHQR -RQHV ´YHGRQRµ LO 'XRPR/ DWWUDWWL SLXWWRVWR GDJOL VSD]L OXPLQRVL FKH GHPROL]LRQL H UHWWLILFD]LRQL DYHYDQR UHDOL]]DWR VXO WUDFFLD0 WR GHOOD 6WUDGD *UDQGH/ FRPH DJOL DFFHVVL GD 3RUWD %RORJQD H GD 3RUWD &D0 VWHOOR R DOOR VODUJR GL 3LD]]D 6DQW·$JRVWLQR/ FDQFHOODQGR OD WUDGL]LRQDOH LP0 PDJLQH EXLD H RVFXUD1 'D TXHOOD SDVVHJJLDWD VXOOH PXUD/ FKH SHUVLQR 0D[LPL0 OLHQ 0LVVRQ/ DYHYD WURYDWR JUDGHYROH H FKH (UFROH 5LQDOGR ,,, VWDYD WUDVIRU0 PDQGR LQ SDVVHJJLR SXEEOLFR VL DPPLUDYDQR FDPSDJQH GDOOD DSSDUHQ]D GL EHL VLVWHPDWL JLDUGLQL FKH D 0DODVSLQD ULFRUGDYDQR TXHOOH GHOL]LRVH IUDQFHVL 471 ²²²²²²²² 46 47
31 &/89(5,86/ ,WDOLD $QWLTXD/ /H\GH 4957 $1 '·$1&21$ 111FLW1/ S1 5;41
;93
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
$QFKH QHOOD UDIILQDWD H FHOHEUH UHOD]LRQH GL YLDJJLR GL )ULHGULFK /HRSROG ]X 6WROEHUJ 0 6WROEHUJ48 LQVLHPH DL SRUWLFL GLYHQXWL HOHJDQWL H FRPRGL/ OH FDVH EHOOH/ OH VWUDGH DPSLH H GULWWH/ O·DPPLUD]LRQH p ULYROWD DL FDPSL ERUGDWL GL JHOVL H GL ROPL FRQ OH YLWL PDULWDWH FKH ULWURYDQR OD ORUR FODVVLFD DVFHQGHQ]D1 /H VWHVVH FKH 0LVVRQ/ DWWUDYHUVDQGR OH WHUUH HVWHQVL QHO 49;;/ LQ TXDOLWj GL DF0 FRPSDJQDWRUH GHO JLRYDQH FRQWH G·$UUDQ/ DYHYD OLTXLGDWR FRPH VRVWHQXWH GD DOEHUL SLDQWDWL D VFDFFKLHUD49 DJJLXQJHQGR FKH VHSSXUH JUDGHYROH LQ Vp XQD WDOH GLVSRVL]LRQH GLYHQWDYD QRLRVD DJOL RFFKL GHL YLDJJLDWRUL/ LO FXL VJXDUGR HUD VHPSUH OLPLWDWR GDL ILODUL PHQWUH VL DPD FDPELDUH RJJHWWR4:1 /D PRQRWRQLD DYHYD/ SHUz/ UDSLGDPHQWH ODVFLDWR LO SRVWR DO SLDFHUH FKH SURFXUDYD O·RUGLQDWR GL0 VSRUVL GHOOH FXOWXUH/ PXWDQGRVL LQ TXHOOD EHOOH]]D GHO SDHVDJJLR JLj VHJQDODWD/ DG RQRU GHO YHUR/ SURSULR GD -RVHSK $GGLVRQ QHL VXRL 5HPDUNV GHO 4:381 ,O WUDYHO DFFRXQW SL• ULVWDPSDWR GHO VHFROR/ H QRQ VROR LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD/ OD DYHYD FRQVHJQDWD FRPH WUDWWR GLVWLQWLYR GHOOD FLWWj DL YLDJJLDWRUL GL OLQJXD LQJOHVH1 $GGLVRQ HUD VWDWR HVWUHPDPHQWH SXQWXDOH QHO GHILQLUQH OD TXDOLWj = WUD 0RGH0 QD H 3DUPD YL HUDQR WUHQWD PLJOLD EHOOH H IHUWLOL/ FRVu FRPH WUD 0RGHQD H 0L0 UDQGROD/ EXRQH TXHOOH WUD 0RGHQD H %RORJQD FRPH WUD 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR4;1 1RQ D FDVR OD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHOO·LPPDJLQH GHO SDHVDJJLR VL DFFRPSDJQD D TXHOOD GHOOD FLWWj/ D HQQHVLPD ULFRQIHUPD/ VHPPDL YH QH IRVVH ELVRJQR/ FKH LO ´%XRQ *RYHUQRµ SDVVD QHFHVVDULDPHQWH SHU LO FRQWUROOR GHOOR VSD]LR H0 VWHUQR= QHO 4:79 HUD VWDWD SXEEOLFDWD OD &DUWD *HQHUDOH GHJOL 6WDWL GHO 6HUHQLVVLPR VLJU1 'XFD GL 0RGHQD LQ ,WDOLD/ UHGDWWD GD 9DQGHOOL/ FKH ILQDOPHQWH DSSDULYDQR XQLILFDWL VRWWR LO SUHGRPLQLR GL 0RGHQD/ UDSSUHVHQWDWD LQ YHGXWD QHO FDUWL0 JOLR1 )LQLYD FRVu O·XQLYHUVR FRPSRVLWR GHOOH WHUUH HVWHQVL FRQ L GXH 'XFDWL/ GL 0RG1D H GL 5HJJLR/ LO 3ULQFLSDWR GL &DUSL/ H OD VLJQRULD GHOOD 3URYLQFLD GL *DUIDJQDQD H GHO )ULJQDQR/111 GLVJLXQWL HW JRYHUQDWL/ FRPH GLYLVL H·VHSDUDWL111 4< UDIILJXUDWR QHOOD FDUWD LQFOXVD QHOO·,WDOLD GL 0DJLQL/ XOWLPDWD SURSULR QHO 48<;/ H FKH DQFRUD /DODQGH QHO 4:9<53 UDFFRPDQGDYD FRPH ULIHULPHQWR H VLD &RURQHOOL QHO 49<3 FKH ²²²²²²²² 48 )1/1 =8 672/%(5* 0 672/%(5*/ 5HLVH LQ 'HXWVFKODQG/ GHU 6FKZHL]/ ,WDOLHQ XQG 6LFLOLHQ/ /HLS]LJ 4:<51 49 01 0,6621/ 9R\DJH G·,WDOLD11119H pGLWLRQ1111FRQWHQDQW OHV 5HPDUTXHV GH 01 $GGLVRQ/ 8WUHFKW 4:54/ ,,/ S1 6871 4: ,ELGHP 4; -1 $'',621/ 5HPDUNV RQ 6HYHUDO 3DUWV RI ,WDO\111/ /RQGRQ 4:38/ S1 7751 4< $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH 6WDWR (VWHQVH/ E14/ %DQRQLPR WUD LO 4949 H LO 4954/ S14% 53 -1-1 /()5$1d2,6 '( /$/$1'(/ 9R\DJH HQ ,WDOLH/ 3DULV 4:9<04:;9/ ,1
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;94
0DWWHR 6HXWHU QHO 4:63 FRQWLQXDYDQR D ULSURSRUUH541 8Q WHUULWRULR YLVLYDPHQWH GRPLQDWR GDOOD SUHVHQ]D LQJRPEUDQWH GHOO·$SSHQQLQR/ LO SH]]R PHUDYLJOLRVR GHO FUHDWR DPPLUDWR GD *RHWKH/ LO PRQGR DVSUR/ FRPH OR GHILQLYD DOOD PHWj GHO &LQTXHFHQWR XQ RVVHUYDWRUH DWWHQWR H GRFXPHQWDWR TXDOH /HDQGUR $OEHUWL/ FKH DQFRU SL• FRQWUDVWDYD FRQ OH DPSLH WHUUH SLDQHJJLDQWL GHO PRGHQHVH PROWR SURGXFHYROH GL IUXPHQWR/ IDYH H G·DOWUH ELDGH H GL EXRQL YLQL55 1 8Q WHUULWRULR WDQWR IHUWLOH TXDQWR LQTXLHWDQWH SHU L PLVWHUL FKH UDFFKLXGHYD QHO VRWWRVXROR H GRYH O·DFTXD HUD PROWR FDWWLYD D PHQR GL QRQ VSLQJHUVL DO GL VRWWR GHO OHWWR GL SLHWUD/ VHPSUH VHFRQGR 0LVVRQ/ IHGHOPHQWH ULSUHVR GD $GGLVRQ VX TXHVWR SXQWR1 ,O SUHVLGHQWH 'H %URVVH/ GRSR DYHU UL0 IHULWR FKH 0RGHQD HUD FRVWUXLWD VX GL XQ VXROR EDVVR/ SRFR FRQVLVWHQWH H SDOXGRVR VL HUD VSLQWR ROWUH ULFRUGDQGR FKH D JUDQGH SURIRQGLWj YL VL WURYDQR SLDQWH H IUDPPHQWL GL DOEHUL/ FKH GHYRQR JLDFHUH GD TXDOFKH PLJOLDLR GL VHFROL FRJOLHQGR LPPHGLDWDPHQWH LO %HOOR VSXQWR SHU ULIOHVVLRQL GL PRUDOH H GL ILVLFD561 /·$SSHQQLQR QHO IUDWWHPSR DYHYD OHQWDPHQWH ULWURYDWR OH DQWLFKH ULF0 FKH]]H HYRFDWH GDOO·$OEHUWL/ LO TXDOH ULFRUGDYD FRPH YLFLQR 6SH]]DQR VFDWXULVFH IXRUL GHO VDVVR XQ OLTXRUH FKH SDUH ROLR FRQ DFTXD H ID EHQH DOOH IHULWH57 H FRPH YL VLD OD 3RUFHOODQD/ FKH q XQ KHUED GL FRORUH URVVR1 $QFKH &OXYHULR DYHYD ULFRUGDWR $F0 TXDULD H L SRWHUL GHOOH DFTXH FKH VFDWXULYDQR QHO PRGHQHVH/ TXHOOH VWHVVH VRU0 JHQWL PLUDFRORVH H PHGLFDPHQWRVH LQGDJDWH GD 9DOOLVHQL/ QHOO·XQLFR YLDJJLR QHOOD ]RQD FLWDWR GDOOD PDJQLILFD ELEOLRWHFD XQLYHUVDOH GL %RXFKHU GH OD 5L0 FKDUGHULH1 0DJJLRU LQWHUHVVH VXVFLWDQR/ SHUz/ L IRVVLOL GL 6DVVXROR/ OH FRUQLROH/ OH DJDWH URVVH H L GLDVSUL GL 9LJQROD ULFRUGDWL GDO WHVWR SL• GLIIXVR GHOOD 5HLVHOL0 WHUDWXU/ OD JXLGD GL -RKDQQ 9RONPDQQ HGLWD QHO 4:::581 '·DOWURQGH/ DQFRUD SHU WXWWD OD SULPD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ D 0RGHQD VL SDVVD/ VL FDSLWD/ DO SL• FL VL IHUPD UDSLGDPHQWH SHU DPPLUDUH OD *DOOHULD GXFD0 OH1 6H QHO FRUVR GHO 6HLFHQWR LO FXRUH GHOOD UHWH SRVWDOH LQWHUQD]LRQDOH ULPDQH 0DQWRYD/ LO IOXVVR GHO *UDQG 7RXU VILRUD OD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH SL• SHU QHFHVVLWj FKH SHU SLDFHUH FRPH DFFDGH D 'H %URVVHV/ LO TXDOH GHFLGH GL ULWRUQDUH LQ )UDQFLD GD 5RPD SHU OD YLD DGULDWLFD GL /RUHWR SLXWWRVWR FKH ULSHUFRUUHUH TXHOOD LPSHUYLD H IDWLFRVLVVLPD FKH SDVVD SHU )LUHQ]H1 &HUWDPHQWH WXWWR PXWD ²²²²²²²² 54
51 $/0$*,-/ 0RQXPHQWD ,WDOLDH &DUWRJUDSKLFD/ )LUHQ]H 4<5</ SS1 45< H 4671 /1 $/%(57,/ 'HVFULWWLRQH GL WXWWD O·,WDOLD111/ %RORJQD 4883/ S168;1 56 &1 '( %5266(6/ /HWWUHV IDPLOLqUHV pFULWHV G·,WDOLH HQ 4:6< HW 4:73/ 3DULV 4:<</ HG1 LW1 %DUL 4<:6/ S1 9641 57 ,ELGHP/ S1 68;1 58 -1 -1 92(.0$11/ +LVWRULVFK 0 NULWLVFKH 1DFKULFKWHQ YRQ ,WDOLHQ/ /HLS]LJ 4:::/ , S1 7431 55
;95
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
FRQ O·DSHUWXUD GHOOD YLD GL 3LVWRLD/ OH FXL WUDYDJOLDWH YLFHQGH LQL]LDQR QHO 4:96 H VX FXL GDO 4:;4 VL VSRVWDQR OD VWDIIHWWD SHU OD *HUPDQLD H LO FRUULHUH GD 0L0 ODQR DOOD 7RVFDQD/ PD D WDOH GDWD OD FLWWj KD JLj PROWR GD RIIULUH1 &DPELD LO SDHVDJJLR H FDPELD O·LPPDJLQH GHOOD FLWWj ´SL• EUXWWDµ G·,WDOLD = ULIOHVVR GHOOD SURIRQGD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH DYYHQXWD/ H FKH WXWWDYLD QRQ FKLDULVFH FRPH H VRSUDWWXWWR SHUFKp 0RGHQD DYHVVH PHULWDWR WDOH HWLFKHWWD1 &HUWR ED0 VWD ULFRQVLGHUDUH LO QXFOHR PRQXPHQWDOH FRPSDWWR UDIILJXUDWR GD 1LFFROz GHOO·$EDWH QHO 4879 D IRQGDOH GHOO·,QFRQWUR GHL 7ULXPYLUL/ QHOOD 6DOD GHO )XRFR GHO 3DOD]]R &RPXQDOH/ FRQ OD *KLUODQGLQD/ LQ IRUPH URPDQH VHQ]D JXJOLD/ OD 7RUUH &LYLFD DOWLVVLPD/ SULPD GHOOD ULGX]LRQH VHLFHQWHVFD/ H ULSXOLWD GHOOH PHU0 ODWXUH LQVLHPH DOOD 7RUUH GHOO·2URORJLR/ FKH VYHWWDQR VXOOD PDVVD FRQIXVD H GLVRUGLQDWD GHJOL HGLILFL GDL WHWWL D VSLRYHQWH/ EHQ UDIILJXUDWD QHO JRQIDORQH GLSLQWR GD /XGRYLFR /DQD QHO 4966/ SHU DYHU DQFRUD XQD YROWD OD VHQVD]LRQH FKH GXH FLWWj FRQYLYDQR D IDWLFD H FKH QRQ VLD VXIILFLHQWH HOLPLQDUH OH JXJOLH SHU FDQFHOODUH O·DWPRVIHUD ´JRWLFDµ FKH VL UHVSLUD1 , FRPSRQHQWL O·DPEDVFLDWD ILRUHQWLQD GL /RUHQ]R &RUVL/ GHVFULWWD GDOO·DEDWH 5XFFHOODL/ WUDQVLWDQGRYL LQ LQFRJQLWR QHO 4976 GLUHWWL D 3DUPD/ YH0 GRQR XQ 'XRPR PDOLQFRQLFR H RVVHUYDQR FRQ FXULRVLWj /D %RQLVVLPD/ GD XQ ODWR GHOOD FKLHVD YLFLQR DO WHWWR/ XQLFL HOHPHQWL GHJQL GL QRWD LQ XQD FLWWj DVVDL VSRU0 FD H EXLD/ GRYH LO 'XFD )UDQFHVFR VL GLYHUWLYD JLUDQGR D SLHGL/ PDVFKHUDWR/ FRQ FRPLWLYD GL YHQWLFLQTXH R WUHQWD VXRL JHQWLOXRPLQL 591 6RQR DQFRUD L VLPEROL GHOOD IRU0 WH LGHQWLWj FRPXQDOH D GRPLQDUH OD VFHQD XUEDQD/ TXHOOL VWHVVL VXL TXDOL OR VJXDUGR GHL YLDJJLDWRUL VFLYROD YLD FRQ LQGLIIHUHQ]D H WDOYROWD FRQ IDVWLGLR/ PD q VRSUDWWXWWR OD TXDOLWj GHOOH DELWD]LRQL H GHOOD UHWH YLDULD> VRQR L FDQDOL H OD VFDUVD LJLHQH FKH RUPDL OL FRQWUDGGLVWLQJXH D PDUFDUH OD FLWWj PROWR SL• GHOOH LQL]LDWLYH GXFDOL1 (G/ LQIDWWL/ 5HJJLR DYHYD FROSLWR SRVLWLYDPHQWH &RUVL H L VXRL FRPSDJQL GL YLDJJLR SHU O·HVWUHPD SXOL]LD/ FRVu FKH VL SXz DJJLXQJHUH XQ·XOWHULRUH HOHPHQWR DO GXDOLVPR JLj HPHUVR QHOOD JXLGD GL 6FKRWW H FKH 0LVVRQ DPSOLILFD VXO ILQLUH GHO VHFROR = 0RGHQD/ SLFFLROD H GL IRUPD FLUFRODUH/ 5HJJLR/ QRELOH/ EHQH KDELWDWD H FRSLRVD GL SRSROR HW DEERQGDQWH GHOOH FRVH QHFHVVDULH DO YLYHUH KXPDQR5:1 4XDOL VLDQR WDOL FRVH H TXDOH VLD OD PDQLHUD PRGHUQD FKH PDQFD DOOD FLWWj/ FRPH VL OHJJH LQ XQD UHOD]LRQH GHOO·HSRFD 5;/ q 0LVVRQ D VSLHJDUOR LQ QHJDWLYR= OH VXH IRUWLILFD]LRQL FDGRQR LQ URYLQD/ OH VWUDGH VRQR DQJXVWH H VSRU0 FKH/ L SRUWLFL FKH UHJQDQR TXDVL RYXQTXH FRPH D %RORJQD VRQR EDVVL H VWUHWWL/ QRQ FL VRQR ²²²²²²²² 59
$1 '·$1&21$/ FLW1/ S1571 )1 6&+277/ FLW1/ S1 476 +HGL]LRQH 49<<, 1 5; $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ E14/ S1<
5:
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;96
FKLHVH GL XQ TXDOFKH LQWHUHVVH/ OH EHOOH FDVH VRQR UDUH H VH QRQ IRVVH SHU LO SDVVDWR JOR0 ULRVR H SHU OD SUHVHQ]D GHOOH FRUWH/ 0RGHQD VDUHEEH EHQ SRFR QRWD/ QRQRVWDQWH OH VFXGHULH GXFDOL/ LO &RUVR/ OD SDVVHJJLDWD VXL EDVWLRQL H LO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH FKH SHU RUD/ SHUz/ SURPHWWH VROWDQWR GL HVVHUH XQD EXRQD DUFKLWHWWXUD5</ LQYHFH 5HJJLR/ VHSSXU SULYD GL TXDOXQTXH HOHPHQWR GL SDUWLFRODUH LQWHUHVVH q LQ JHQH0 UDOH PHJOLR FRVWUXLWD H SL• JUDGHYROH GL 0RGHQDB1 ,QVRPPD/ OD FRUWH/ D SRFR SL• GL XQ VHFROR GDO VXR WUDVIHULPHQWR/ QRQ JOL VHPEUD HVVHUH VWDWD FDSDFH GL LQFLGH0 UH VXOOD IRUWH VWUXWWXUD SUHHVLVWHQWH/ H OD FLWWj/ GL FRQVHJXHQ]D/ D SDUWH L TXDGUL GL &RUUHJJLR/ QRQ JOL DSSDUH LQ JUDGR GL RIIULUH JUDQFKp1 9HUR q FKH 0LVVRQ KD XQR VJXDUGR HVWUHPDPHQWH VHOHWWLYR FKH VFLYROD LPSLHWRVR VX WXWWR TXDQ0 WR QRQ ULVSRQGH DL FDQRQL GHO ´PRGHUQRµ H L ´YHFFKLXPLµ VL FRQIRQGR SHU OXL QHOO·RVFXULWj GHOOH YLH1 %XLD H PDOLQFRQLFD VRQR JOL DJJHWWLYL SL• XVDWL SHU GHILQLUH OD SLFFROD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH/ VSHVVR LQVLHPH D VSRUFD/ FRVu FKH OD VXD TXDOLWj HVWHWLFD QHJDWLYD VL LQWRQD DOOH RPEUH FXSH GHO PRQGR PHGLHYDOH DQ0 FRUD WURSSR SUHVHQWH1 (SSXUH/ D 5REHUW GH &RWWH/ XQR GHJOL DUFKLWHWWL SUHIHULWL GD /XLJL ;,9/ FKH YL VRJJLRUQD VROR XQ DQQR GRSR 0LVVRQ/ DSSDUH EHOOD/ FRQ OH VWUDGH ODU0 JKH/ DOFXQL HGLILFL QRWHYROL SHU OH IDFFLDWH GLSLQWH/ WUD OH TXDOL XQD LQ SDUWLFR0 ODUH RSHUD GL 1LFROD GHOO·$EDWH1 $QFKH O·DO]DWR GHOOD FKLHVD GL 6DQ *LRUJLR GL 9LJDUDQL JOL VHPEUD LQWHUHVVDQWH H PROWR EHOOD QHO FRPSOHVVR OD FKLHVD GL 6DQ %DUWRORPHR GHL *HVXLWL1 ,O SHVVLPR VWDWR GHOOH IRUWLILFD]LRQL OR LQWHUHVVD EHQ SRFR/ PHQWUH VRWWROLQHD OD PDJQLILFHQ]D GHOOH VFXGHULH GXFDOL LQ FRVWUX]LRQH/ GHO 3DOD]]R/ GHJOL DSSDUWDPHQWL H/ QDWXUDOPHQWH/ GHL GLSLQWL GHOOD *DOOHULDB1 6H 'H &RWWH SXz VHPEUDUH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH EHQ GLVSRVWR H DWWHQWR D FRJOLHUH OH QRYLWj SRVLWLYH/ TXDQWR PHQR HFFHVVLYD q OD UHD]LRQH GHO ODQJUDYLR &DUO ]X +HVVHQ 0 &DVVHO GL SDVVDJJLR D 0RGHQD QHO FRUVR GHO VXR .DYDOLHUWRXU VXO ILQL0 UH GHO 49<< = GLVJXVWDWR GDOOD VSRUFL]LD GHOOH VWUDGH VWUHWWH H EXLH VL ULILXWD GL YLVLWDUH LO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH H LO 'XRPR/ QRQRVWDQWH L PLUDFROL GL 6DQ *LPLQLD0 QR/ IXJJHQGR DO SL• SUHVWR1 1HOOR VWHVVR DQQR/ YLHQH SXEEOLFDWD OD JXLGD GL XQ DOWUR IUDQFHVH/ )UDQo0 RLV 0 -DFTXHV 'HVHLQH/ FKH/ QRQRVWDQWH L SRUWLFL EXL H VSRUFKL/ GHILQLVFH JUDQGH H PDJQLILFR/ TXHOOR VWHVVR 3DOD]]R VRWWROLQHDQGR OD ULFFKH]]D GHL PRELOL H GHJOL DUUHGL GHJOL DSSDUWDPHQWL H QDWXUDOPHQWH O·HFFHOOHQWH TXDOLWj GHL GLSLQWL UDFFROWL QHOOD *DOOHULD/ VHQ]D GLPHQWLFDUH GL GHVFULYHUH OD &DWWHGUD0 ²²²²²²²² 5<
01 0,6621 111FLW1/ S16881 ,ELGHP/ YRO1 ,,,/ S1 6 64 /H YR\DJH HQ ,WDOLH GH 5REHUW GH &RWWH/ D FXUD GL %1 -(67$=/ 3DULV 4<99/ SS1 57705781
63
;97
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
OH H LO FDPSDQLOH LQ FXL VL FXVWRGLYD OD 6HFFKLDB1 6HPSUH QHO 49<< HVFH LO UH0 VRFRQWR GL YLDJJLR GL &KDUOHV %RXUGLQ/ FKH D 0RGHQD DYHYD VRJJLRUQDWR TXDWWUR DQQL SULPD = WUD OH EHOOH FKLHVH VHJQDOD OD &DWWHGUDOH H WUD L PDJQLILFL 3DOD]]L TXHOOR GHO %RVFKHWWRB1 /H UHD]LRQL FRQWUDVWDQWL VL VXVVHJXRQR/ DQFKH VH OR VJXDUGR GL FRQQDLV0 VHXUV H DPDWHXUV q VHPSUH LO SL• EHQHYROR/ DOO·HURLFD ULFHUFD GL EHOOH]]H H UDULWj DUWLVWLFKH ULHVFRQR D QRQ YHGHUH Qp JOL HGLILFL JRWLFL/ Qp OH VWUDGH VSRUFKH1 &D\OXV FKH YL VRJJLRUQD SHU SRFKL JLRUQL QHO 4:47 FRQFRUGD VXOOD SLFFROH]]D GHOOH VWUDGH/ ILDQFKHJJLDWH GD VJUDGHYROL SRUWLFL EDVVL/ H VXOOD LUUHJRODULWj GHO ORUR WUDFFLDWR/ PD ROWUH DO SDOD]]R GXFDOH H DOOD *DOOHULD YLVLWD LO WHDWUR GHOO·2SHUD H WURYD/ WXWWR VRPPDWR/ SLDFHYROH LO VRJJLRUQR H EHOOH OH GRQQH YHVWLWH DOOD IUDQFHVHB1 3LFFROD/ QRQ EHOOD H WULVWH DSSDUH/ LQYHFH/ QHO 4:5< D 0RQWHVTXLHX/ FKH QRQ SHUGH O·RFFDVLRQH SHU YHGHUYL XQ SRSROR RSSUHVVR GDOOH LPSRVWH GL XQ GXFD DYDUR H TXLQGL IXUER H LPEURJOLRQH1 ,O 3DOD]]R 'X0 FDOH/ VHSSXUH QRQ XOWLPDWR/ JOL VHPEUD QRWHYROH H OD *DOOHULD IUD OH SL• SUH0 ]LRVH G·,WDOLD1 $QFKH 'H %URVVH/ JLXQJHQGRYL LO PHUFROHGu GHOOH &HQHUL GHO 4:73/ OD WUR0 YD SLFFROD/ QRQ JUD]LRVD H VSRUFD FRPH GRYHYD HVVHUH DL WHPSL GHO 3RWWDB LO FKH QRQ JOL LPSHGLVFH GL DSSUH]]DUQH LO VRJJLRUQR H O·DOOHJUD YLWD PRQGDQD1 1RQ VL VRW0 WUDH DOOD YLVLWD GHOOD &DWWHGUDOH PD QRQ ULHVFH D ULFRUGDUH QLHQWH GL QRWHYROH DOO·LQWHUQR/ OD WRUUH/ LQYHFH/ q DOWD HG KD XQD EHOOD VFDOD GL PDUPR1 ,O 3DOD]]R 'X0 FDOH JOL DSSDUH LO VROR HGLILFLR LPSRUWDQWH GHOOD FLWWj/ VH IRVVH WHUPLQDWR/ VDUHEEH XQR GHJOL HGLILFL SL• EHOOL G·,WDOLD/ PD IRUVH VROR SHU OH GLPHQVLRQL YLVWR FKH /R VWLOH DUFKLWHWWRQLFR GHOOD IDFFLDWD HVWHUQD QRQ PL SLDFH DIIDWWR > KDQQR FRPLQFLDWR D FRVWUXL0 UH QHO PH]]R QRQ VR TXDOH WRUULRQH G·DOWH]]D VPLVXUDWD/ XQD VSHFLH GL WRUUH GL %DEHOH D TXDWWUR SLDQL111/ H SRLFKp LO /RXYUH GL 3HUUDXOW q LO PRGHOOR D FXL OD UDSSRUWD VL FDSLVFH EHQH TXDQWR SRFR JOL SRVVD SLDFHUH/ DO FRQWUDULR GHOO·LQWHUQR FKH JLX0 GLFD VWXSHQGR1 0D q VRSUDWWXWWR DG LQFDQWDUOR OD VFDOD DSHUWD FKH VDOH GDO EDVVR ILQR LQ FLPD/ L FXL SLDQHURWWROL VRQR VRUUHWWL GD ILOH GL FRORQQH DFFRSSLDWH1111H FKH JLXGLFD OD UHJLQD GHOOH VFDOHB 1 6H/ FRPH q QRWR/ OD 1RWWH GL &RUUHJJLR OR HQWXVLDVPD ROWUH ²²²²²²²² 65
)1-1 '(6(,1(/ 1RXYHDX 9R\DJH G·,WDOLH &RQWHQDQW 8QH 'HVFULSWLRQ ([DFWH GH 7RXWHV VHV 3URYLQ0 FHV/ 9LOOHV OLHX[ FRQVLGHUDEOHV/ GHV ,VOHV TXL HQ GpSHQGHQWV/ /\RQ/ 49<</ S1 :71 66 &1 %285',1/ 9R\DJH G·,WDOLH HW GH TXHOTXHV HQGURLWV G·$OOHPDJQH/ 49<8 HW 49<9/ 3DGHUERUQ/ &1 3HOHULQ/ 49<</ S1:51 67 $1&131 '( &$</86/ 9R\DJH G·,WDOLH 4:74 04:48/ 3DULV/ $PLOGD $1 3RQV/ 4<47/ SS17707<1 68 &1 '( %5266(6/ FLW1/ S1 9681 69 ,ELGHP1
9LDJJLDWRUL VWUDQLHUL D 0RGHQD= DOOD VFRSHUWD GL XQD FLWWj
;98
PLVXUD/ HPR]LRQDQGROR FRPH QHVVXQD GHOOH RSHUH GHO GLYLQR 5DIIDHOOR/ YDOXWD OD *DOOHULD 'XFDOH FHUWDPHQWH OD SL• EHOOD JDOOHULD FKH HVLVWD LQ ,WDOLD/ QRQ SHUFKp VLD OD SL• ULFFD/ PD q OD PHJOLR WHQXWD/ OD PHJOLR RUGLQDWD HG RUQDWDB1 *Lj QHOOH 'pOLFHV G·,WDOLH GL 'H 5RJLVVDUW/ OD FLWWj HUD GLYHQXWD EHOOD/ SRSR0 ORVD H IDPRVD SHU LO YLQR H OD &DWWHGUDOH DYHYD WURYDWR LO SURSULR VSD]LR DF0 FDQWR DO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH B/ PD VL WUDWWDYD GL XQ WHVWR PHUDPHQWH FRPSLODWLYR/ FRVu FRPH GL PDQLHUD HUD OD SLDQWD GHOOD FLWWj LQVHULWD GD 3LHUUH 0RUWLHU QHO 1RXYHDX 7KpjWUH G·,WDOLH HGLWR DG $PVWHUGDP QHO 4:37 H DOOHJDWD DOOD JXLGD1 ,Q RJQL FDVR/ OD LPPDJLQH GHOOD FLWWj VL DUULFFKLVFH H OH DWWUDWWLYH VL PROWL0 SOLFDQR1 ( VH OD IDPD GHOOD FROOH]LRQH GXFDOH VRSUDYYLYH DOOD VXD GLVSHUVLRQH/ DQ]L L FRQVLGHUHYROL FHQWRPLOD ]HFFKLQL SDJDWL ´IDQQR QRWL]LDµ SL• GHL &RU0 UHJJLR SHUGXWL/ PDQ PDQR FKH FL VL DYYLD DOOD ILQH GHO VHFROR H LO *UDQG 7RXU VHPEUD JLj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·DUFKLWHWWXUD QH FULWLFD VHQ]D PH]]L WHUPLQL OD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHL TXDWWUR SLDQL VRUUHWWL GD DOWUHWWDQWL RUGLQL GLYHUVL111VL q VRUSUHVL GL YHGHUQH GXH GL VWLOH FRULQ]LR XQLWL FRQ XQR GL VWLOH GRULFR H XQR GL VWLOH LRQLFR1 $ SDUHU PLR TXHVWL YDVWL SRUWLFL/ PROWR EHOOL SHU OD YHULWj/ FRQYHUUHEEHUR PROWR PHJOLR DG XQ HGLILFLR SDUHFFKLR SL• JUDQGHB 1 ,O ULJRUH q RUPDL G·REEOLJR/ PD QRQ q OD VROD FULWL0 FD FKH PXRYH DOOD UHVLGHQ]D HVWHQVH/ DQFKH OH VWDQ]H GHJOL DSSDUWDPHQWL JOL DSSDLRQR QXPHURVLVVLPH H DUUHGDWH FRQ PDJQLILFHQ]D/ PD GL XQ JXVWR XQ SR· DQWLTXD0 WRB1 %HQ SL• LQWHUHVVDQWH WURYD OD ELEOLRWHFD/ R SLXWWRVWR L YROXPL UDFFROWL QH0 JOL VFDIIDOL LQ TXDQWR WHVWLPRQLDQ]H GHOOH RSLQLRQL H GHL JXVWL GL FKL OL KD UDF0 FROWL H FKH FRQ VRUSUHVD JLXGLFD LPSURQWDWL DG XQD FHUWD OLEHUDOLWj/ H VRSUDW0 WXWWR FDWWXUD OD VXD DWWHQ]LRQH OD &ROOH]LRQH GHO 'XFD/ PROWR QRWD FRO QRPH GL 0XVHR (VWHQVH/ GL FXL DSSUH]]D SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LO PHGDJOLHUH/ PHQWUH OH FXULRVLWj QD0 WXUDOL FKH YL VRQR UDFFROWH OR ODVFLDQR LQGLIIHUHQWH1 0RGHQD QHO FRPSOHVVR JOL ²²²²²²²² 6:
,ELGHP/ S1 9651 '( 52*,66$57/ /H GpOLFHV G·,WDOLH111/ /HLGH 4:39 04:33/ YRO1 ,,,/ SS1969096;1 6< (1 *,%%21/ 9LDJJLR LQ ,WDOLD/ D FXUD GL *1$1 %RQQDUG/ 0LODQR 4<98/ S1 45<1 73 ,ELGHP/ S1 4641 74 ,ELGHP1
6;
;99
$QQD *LDQQHWWL
DSSDUH PROWR EHOOD1 /H FDVH/ SHU OR SL• VRQR LQWRQDFDWH GL JHVVR/ LO FKH Gj ORUR XQ DVSHWWR SXOLWR HG HVWUHPDPHQWH JDLR1 /D VWUDGD SL• EHOOD q TXHOOD FKH PHWWH FDSR DO JLDUGLQR GHO 'XFDB1 3L• GHJOL LQWHUYHQWL H GHOOH LPSRUWDQWL RSHUH SXEEOLFKH YROXWH GD )UDQFH0 VFR ,,, q/ TXLQGL/ OD WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHO WHVVXWR XUEDQR FRQ OD VFRPSDUVD GHL WHWWL D VSLRYHQWH H GHL FRORUL VFXUL/ D GHWHUPLQDUH OD QXRYD EHOOH]]D GHOOD FLWWj1 $ GHILQLUOD VRQR VXIILFLHQWL TXHL GXH DJJHWWLYL ´SXOLWRµ H ´JDLRµ FKH LQGLFDQR LO VXR DYYLFLQDUVL DOOH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH GL XQD PRGHUQD FDSLWDOH1 7RFFD D /DODQ0 GH/ FKH JLXQJH D 0RGHQD FLQTXH DQQL GRSR *LEERQ/ ULDVVXPHUH QHO VXR FRPPHQWR D 0LVVRQ TXDOL VLDQR JOL HOHPHQWL FKH FRQFRUURQR D IDUQH XQD FLW0 Wj JUDGHYROH/ EHQ FRVWUXLWD/ EHQ IRUWLILFDWD76 H FKH OD UHQGRQR LQVLHPH D 5HJJLR EHQ GHJQH G·HVVHUH YLVWH/ FRPH VFULYH QHOOD 3UHID]LRQH1 , SRUWLFL QRQ SL• EXL H VSRUFKL VRQR GLYHQWDWL XQ HOHPHQWR GL GHFRUR OXQJR OH VWUDGH H OD JUDQGH UXH/ OD 6WUDGD 0DHVWUD/ PHULWD VRSUDWWXWWR GL HVVHUH ULFRUGDWD SHU OD EHOOH]]D GHL VXRL HGLILFL77 H QRQ VROWDQWR SHU OH VXH GLPHQVLRQL1 ,O 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH FRQWLQXD D DSSDULUJOL PD0 JQLILFR 0 QLHQWH SRWUHEEH HVVHUJOL SL• HVWUDQHR GHOOH UDIILQDWH FULWLFKH GL *LE0 ERQ DOOR VFDUVR ULJRUH FRPSRVLWLYR 0 PHQWUH OD *DOOHULD 'XFDOH JOL DSSDUH ULHPSLWD VRSUDWWXWWR GDO YXRWR ODVFLDWR GDL TXDGUL YHQGXWL DO UH GL 3RORQLD1 &RQ OD SUHFLVLRQH FKH OR FRQWUDGGLVWLQJXH QRQ GLPHQWLFD Qp OD &DWWHGUDOH LQ VWLOH JRWLFR/ Qp OD *KLUODQGLQD/ Qp OH FKLHVH GL 6DQ %DUWRORPHR/ GL 6DQ *LRU0 JLR H OD &KLHVD 1RYD1 $QFKH OD 6HFFKLD YLHQH ULFRUGDWD H QRQ FHUWR QHL WHU0 PLQL GLVLQFDQWDWL FRQ FXL OR DYHYD IDWWR LO 3UHVLGHQWH 'H %URVVHV FKH QRQ D0 YHYD VWHQWDWR D ULFRQRVFHUH FRPH XQD YHFFKLD VHFFKLD GL OHJQR SXWULGR H YHUPLQRVR781 $ IDUOH GD FRQWUDOWDUH VRQR OH ELEOLRWHFKH/ L PDQRVFULWWL/ L JDELQHWWL VFLHQWL0 ILFL FKH/ DQFKH/ DOOR VJXDUGR FULWLFR GL 5RODQG GH OD 3ODWLpUH WHVWLPRQLDQR GHO0 OR VSOHQGRUH HVWHQVH1
²²²²²²²² 75
,ELGHP/ S1 4661 -1-1 /()5$1d2,6 '( /$/$1'(/ FLW1/ ,/ S1 ;;;1 77 ,ELGHP1 78 &1 '( %5266(6/ FLW1/ S1 9681
76
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;9:
&(6$5( 0$/$*2/,
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
/·,WDOLD HUD/ QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ XQ RJJHWWR SDVVLYR GHOOD GLSORPD]LD HXURSHD/ OD VXD LPSRUWDQ]D VWDYD QHOOH VXGGLYLVLRQL WHUULWRULDOL/ HVVHQ]LDOL DL ILQL GHOO·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·$XVWULD D &DPSRIRUPLR/ VL FRVWLWXu OD EDVH GHOOH QXRYH LQL]LDWLYH FKH SRUWDURQR QHO ELHQQLR 4:<; 0 4:<< DO FRQWUROOR IUDQFHVH VX WXWWD OD SHQLVROD1 9HQQH TXLQGL UHDOL]]DWD XQD SULPD HVSHULHQ]D GL RUJDQLVPL VWDWDOL GLSHQ0 GHQWL GDOOD SURWH]LRQH IUDQFHVH/ QHL TXDOL IXURQR HPDQDWH GHOOH FRVWLWX]LRQL/ VWDELOLWL RUGLQDPHQWL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL/ FKLDPDWL D UHVSRQVDELOLWj GL JRYHUQR H0 VSRQHQWL YHFFKL H QXRYL GHOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH ORFDOH= GRSR L SULPL PRPHQWL GL GLVRULHQWDPHQWR FDGGHUR PROWH LOOXVLRQL/ PD YHQQHUR DOORQWDQDWL DQFKH WDQWL WLPRUL VXOOD SRUWDWD GHOOH LQQRYD]LRQL ULYROX]LRQDULH1
;9;
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
&RQ LO 4;33 YHQQH FRVWLWXLWD XQD VHFRQGD 5HSXEOLFD &LVDOSLQD/ YLD YLD DPSOLDWD QHO WHPSR/ FKH LQ VHJXLWR DO &RQJUHVVR GL /LRQH GHO 4;35 GLYHQQH 5HSXEEOLFD ,WDOLDQD H QHO 4;38 VL WUDVIRUPz LQ 5HJQR G·,WDOLD41 $ WXWWH TXHVWH FRPSDJLQL VWDWDOL 0RGHQD GLHGH XQ FRQWULEXWR ULOHYDQWH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD DPPLQLVWUDWLYR H SHU OD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DWWLYD H FRPSHWHQWH FKH OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH ORFDOH DVVLFXUz FRQ GLYHUVL XRPLQL GL SULPR SLDQR1 'RSR OD GHILQLWLYD VFRQILWWD GL 1DSROHRQH JOL VWDWLVWL HXURSHL FKH VL ULXQL0 URQR D 9LHQQD VL DGRSHUDURQR SHU GHILQLUH OD QXRYD JHRJUDILD SROLWLFD GHOO·(XURSD RULHQWDOH H PHULGLRQDOH= LO GHVWLQR GHOO·,WDOLD IX OHJDWR LQGLVVROX0 ELOPHQWH DOO·RUELWD GL SRWHUH GHJOL $VEXUJR/ FRQ OD VROD HFFH]LRQH GHO 5HJQR GL 3LHPRQWH H 6DUGHJQD1 , SULQFuSL FKH UHVVHUR O·LPSHUR DXVWULDFR GLYHQQHUR L IRQGDPHQWL GHOO·D]LRQH GHJOL 6WDWL FKH HUDQR FDGXWL VRWWR LO FRQWUROOR DVEXUJLFR/ LQ SDUWL0 FRODUH TXHOOR GHOOD PRQDUFKLD DVVROXWD/ O·XQLFD VLFXUD JDUDQ]LD GL RUGLQH VR0 FLDOH H SROLWLFR/ LQ FXL LO SULQFLSH ULPDQHYD VRYUDQR LQGLVFXVVR LQYHVWLWR GL XQD PLVVLRQH GLYLQD1 ,O < JLXJQR 4;48 YHQQH ILUPDWR O·DWWR ILQDOH GHO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD/ PD O·DVVHWWR GHOO·,WDOLD HUD JLj VWDWR GHFLVR QHO FRUVR GHOO·DQQR SUHFHGHQWH/ DG H0 VHPSLR )UDQFHVFR ,9 HQWUz LQ FLWWj QHO OXJOLR 4;471 $O PRPHQWR GHOOD QRPLQD HJOL HUD XQ DWWLYR HVSRQHQWH GHOOD IUD]LRQH SL• ULJLGDPHQWH DQWLIUDQFHVH HG DQWLLOOXPLQLVWD GHOOD FRUWH DVEXUJLFD/ HG HIIHWWL0 YDPHQWH L SULPL DWWL GL JRYHUQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 VL FDUDWWHUL]]DURQR SHU XQ QHWWR WDJOLR FRQ LO SDVVDWR UHFHQWH/ DG HVHPSLR= LO ULSULVWLQR GHO &RGLFH (0 VWHQVH GHO 4::4 QHOOD VXD TXDVL WRWDOLWj/ OD ULHVXPD]LRQH GHL YHFFKL WLWROL IHX0 GDOL/ OD ULDWWLYD]LRQH GHOOH PDQLPRUWH/ H LO ULFRQRVFLPHQWR DL QRELOL H DJOL HF0 FOHVLDVWLFL GHO SULQFLSLR FKH DG HVVL HUD GRYXWR XQ·LQGHQQL]]R SHU L EHQL FRQ0 ILVFDWL QHO 4:<951 ²²²²²²²² 4
*1 &$1'(/252/ 6WRULD GHOO*,WDOLD PRGHUQD/ ,/ /H RULJLQL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR 4::304;48/ 0LODQR/ )HOWULQHOOL/ 4<:;1 5 6XOOD SROLWLFD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 HG LO UXROR GHO 'XFDWR PRGHQHVH QHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR LWDOLD0 QR HVLVWRQR YDOXWD]LRQL DQFRUD SLXWWRVWR GLVVRQDQWL/ SHU XQ VLQWHWLFR SDQRUDPD GHJOL VWXGL GL DPELWR QD]LRQDOH q SRVVLELOH FRQVXOWDUH= *1 &$1'(/252/ 6WRULD GHOO*,WDOLD PRGHUQD«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
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;9<
/·LPSDWWR IX SDUWLFRODUPHQWH IRUWH SHU LO QXRYR VRYUDQR FKH QRQ SRVVH0 GHYD DOFXQ OHJDPH RUJDQLFR FRQ OD WUDGL]LRQH GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH H VL WURYz DG RSHUDUH LQ XQD UHDOWj QXRYD IRUWHPHQWH FRLQYROWD QHOO·HVSHULHQ]D IUDQFH0 VH H QDSROHRQLFD1 /·DWWHJJLDPHQWR FKH )UDQFHVFR ,9 DVVXQVH D SURSRVLWR GHOOD JHVWLRQH GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH IX DOWDOHQDQWH IUD O·HVSOLFLWR GL0 VSUH]]R QHL FRQIURQWL GHOOH QRYLWj LQWURGRWWH HG LO WHQWDWLYR GL XQD ORUR DVVL0 PLOD]LRQH/ DVWUDHQGROH SHUz FRPSOHWDPHQWH GDOOH LGHDOLWj H GDOOH HVLJHQ]H SR0 OLWLFKH FKH OH DYHYDQR JLXVWLILFDWH1 7XWWDYLD RFFRUUH WHQHU SUHVHQWH FKH LO ULFRQRVFLPHQWR DQFKH SDU]LDOH GHOOH LQQRYD]LRQL LQWURGRWWH GDL IUDQFHVL DYUHEEH SRWXWR YHQLU ULDOODFFLDWR DOOH UL0 IRUPH DYYLDWH QHO FRUVR GHOO·XOWLPD SDUWH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ TXDQGR L VRYUDQL ´LO0 OXPLQDWLµ DYHYDQR FHUFDWR GL ULGXUUH L SULYLOHJL GL FHWR H OH WUDGL]LRQDOL OLEHUWj ORFDOL QHOOH QRPLQH H QHOOD JHVWLRQH GHL PXQLFLSL> LQROWUH SRWHYD DQFKH DSSD0 ULUH FRPH XQ SRUWDWR GHL WHPSL/ XQ DGHJXDPHQWR DOOD YLWD SROLWLFD G·(XURSD/ JLDFFKq WXWWL L JUDQGL 6WDWL DYHYDQR/ LQ XQ TXDOFKH PRGR/ WHQXWR FRQWR GHOO·HVSHULHQ]D QDSROHRQLFD1 $QFKH PROWL JRYHUQL LWDOLDQL UHVWDXUDWL VL ULDOODFFLDURQR DOOD SROLWLFD GL FRQ0 WUROOR LQDXJXUDWD SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH/ VHJXHQGR QHOOD VRVWDQ]D L FULWHUL LQWURGRWWL LQ HWj QDSROHRQLFD GL XQLIRUPLWj DPPLQLVWUDWLYD H GL GHOHJD DL FR0 PXQL GL IXQ]LRQL H VHUYL]L ULJLGDPHQWH ILVVDWL61 5LVSHWWR DJOL DVVHWWL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL SUH0 ULYROX]LRQDUL O·RSHUD ULIRUPDWULFH FRQGRWWD GDL ULYROX]LRQDUL IUDQFHVL H GD 1DSROHRQH SURGXVVH GHL FDPELD0 PHQWL GHVWLQDWL D ODVFLDUH XQ·LPSURQWD GL WXWWR ULOLHYR QHO SDQRUDPD HXURSHR> HFFR LQ HVWUHPD VLQWHVL L SXQWL TXDOLILFDQWL GL WDOL PXWDPHQWL1 1HO FRUVR GHO 4:;< O·$VVHPEOHD QD]LRQDOH FRVWLWXHQWH HODERUz XQ QXRYR VFKHPD GL GLVWULEX]LRQH GHL SRWHUL IUD FHQWUR H SHULIHULD/ DIIHUPDQGR FRQ GH0 FLVLRQH GXH FRQFHWWL JXLGD= O·XQLIRUPLVPR HG LO GHFHQWUDPHQWR1 6L DIIHUPz O·HVLVWHQ]D GL XQ SULPR OLYHOOR HOHPHQWDUH GL DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH/ L 0XQL0 FLSL/ UHWWL GD XQR VFKHPD XQLIRUPH GL UHJROH/ VLD SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD O·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH LQWHUQD FKH LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOH IXQ]LRQL DG HVVL DVVHJQDWH1 4XLQGL VL GLVHJQz SHU WXWWL L WHUULWRUL GHOOD QD]LRQH/ XQD QXRYD ULSDUWL]LRQH ²²²²²²²² OHPLFD FDWWROLFD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD +4;4804;94,/ 0RGHQD/ 67(0 0XFFKL/ 4<9;> /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9;> , SULPL DQQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;4> )UDQFHVFR ,9 H )UDQFHVFR 9 'XFKL GL 0RGHQD/ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR/ 0RGHQD/ 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH/ 6 RWW1 4<<5/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<<61 6 4XHVWL FRQFHWWL VRQR DPSLDPHQWH VYLOXSSDWL HG DUWLFRODWL LQ= $1 6&,52&&2/ /*,WDOLD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR 4;3304;:4 111FLW1/ SS1 6;0:31
;:3
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
DPPLQLVWUDWLYD DUWLFRODWD LQ 'LSDUWLPHQWL GDOOH GLPHQVLRQL VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH HTXLSDUDELOL> VL GRWDURQR WDQWR OH PXQLFLSDOLWj FKH L GLSDUWLPHQWL GL RUJDQL H0 OHWWLYL/ FUHDQGR XQD UHWH GL DVVHPEOHH EDVDWH VX FULWHUL WHUULWRULDOL FRQ HVFOX0 VLRQH GL RJQL GLVWLQ]LRQH SHU RUGLQH> LQROWUH YHQQHUR FRQIHULWH D PXQLFLSDOLWj H GLSDUWLPHQWL IXQ]LRQL ULOHYDQWL/ DVVHJQDQGR DOOH GLYHUVH FRPXQLWj/ ROWUH FKH DWWLYLWj GL ULOLHYR ORFDOH/ DQFKH FRPSLWL SURSUL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOR 6WD0 WR GD HVVR GHOHJDWL1 ,Q XQ FRQWHVWR SROLWLFR H VRFLDOH SURIRQGDPHQWH PXWDWR/ 1DSROHRQH DW0 WXz XQ IRUWH ULRUGLQDPHQWR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR/ SRFKL PHVL GRSR LO FROSR GL VWD0 WR GHOO·DQQR 9,,, +4;33,1 &RQ TXHVWL SURYYHGLPHQWL LO SULPR FRQVROH YROOH UDJJLXQJHUH XQ SLHQR H GLUHWWR FRQWUROOR GHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL ORFDOL JUD]LH DOOD FRQFHQWUD]LRQH GL WXWWR LO FRPSOHVVR GHOO·DWWLYLWD HVHFXWLYD LQ RUJDQL PRQR0 FUDWLFL/ HG DOO·LQVHULPHQWR GL WDOL RUJDQL LQ XQD ULJLGD VFDOD JHUDUFKLFD/ FRQWURO0 ODWD GLUHWWDPHQWH GDO PLQLVWHUR1 )XOFUR GL TXHVWR VLVWHPD HUD LO 3UHIHWWR/ LVWLWXLWR LQ RJQL GLSDUWLPHQWR FRQ OD OHJJH 5; SLRYRVR DQQR 9,,, +4: IHEEUDLR 4;33,1 /·LVWLWX]LRQH GL TXHVWD QXRYD ILJXUD YROXWD GD 1DSROHRQH V·LQVHUu SLHQD0 PHQWH QHOOD VFLD GHOOH UHDOL]]D]LRQL DQWHULRUL/ SRLFKq UDIIRU]DYD O·XQLIRUPD]LRQH GHOO·RUGLQDPHQWR ORFDOH/ FRQVHQWHQGR XQ·D]LRQH RPRJHQHD VXOOD UHDOWj SHULIHULFD JUD]LH DOOD GLYLVLRQH IUD GLSDUWLPHQWL H FRPXQL HG DOOD VXD FDSDFLWj G·LQWHUYHQWR GLUHWWR QHJOL DIIDUL ORFDOL1 , FRQVLJOL FRPXQDOL YHQQHUR D ORUR YROWD FRPSRVWL/ JUD]LH DOOD PHGHVLPD OHJJH/ GD PHPEUL QRPLQDWL GDO SULPR FRQVROH/ SHU OH FDULFKH GL PDJJLRU UL0 OLHYR VLQR D VLQGDFR HG DVVHVVRUL GL FRPXQL FRQ SL• GL 8333 DELWDQWL/ H GDL SUHIHWWL L FRQVLJOLHUL/ DVVHVVRUL H VLQGDFL GHL PXQLFLSL PLQRUL/ FRVu FKH QHO FRPSOHVVR LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR YHUUj ULFRUGDWR FRPH XQ SHULGR GL FUH0 VFHQWH DFFHQWUDPHQWR HG DXWRULWDULVPR FKH ODVFLz EHQ SRFKL VSD]L DL FULWHUL GHOO·HOHWWLYLWj H GHOOD FROOHJLDOLWj71 )UDQFHVFR ,9/ QHOO·DSULOH GHO 4;47/ HPDQz XQ SLDQR GL JRYHUQR ULJXDUGDQ0 WH O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FHQWUDOH H SHULIHULFD GHOOR 6WDWR PRGHQHVH LO FXL SXQWR GL ULIHULPHQWR HUD LO PRGHOOR QDSROHRQLFR ILOWUDWR DWWUDYHUVR XQ·RWWLFD GL JR0 YHUQR DQFRU SL• GHFLVDPHQWH DFFHQWUDWULFH81 ²²²²²²²² 7
3HU XQD FRPSOHWD H GRFXPHQWDWD DQDOLVL GHL JUDQGL PXWDPHQWL LQ HWj ULYROX]LRQDULD H QDSROHRQLFD VL ULPDQGD D = /1 9$1'(//,/ 3RWHUL /RFDOL1 /H RULJLQL QHOOD )UDQFLD ULYROX]LRQDULD1 /H SURVSHWWLYH QHOO*(XURSD GHOOH UHJLRQL/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<<31 8 8Q GHWWDJOLDWR SDQRUDPD LQ SURSRVLWR YLHQH IRUQLWR GD= *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DP0 PLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR $XVWUR0HVWHQVH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<::1
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;:4
(JOL PDQWHQQH VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH LQDOWHUDWD OD VWUXWWXUD GHO JRYHUQR ORFDOH EDVDWD VXOOD VRVWLWX]LRQH GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR FRQ OD 3URYLQFLD H VXO ELQRPLR *RYHUQDWRUH +OD FDULFD FKH VRVWLWXu TXHOOD SUHIHWWL]LD, H &RQVLJOL &RPXQDOL/ VQDWXUDQGR SURIRQGDPHQWH DOFXQL WUDWWL IRQGDPHQWDOL GL TXHVWL XOWLPL/ SXU ULVSHWWDQGR TXDOFKH FDUDWWHUH FKH O·HWj QDSROHRQLFD DYHYD ORUR LPSUHVVR1 ,QQDQ]LWXWWR OH PXQLFLSDOLWj YHQQHUR ULVWDELOLWH LQ FRUSL FROOHJLDOL SHU WUDW0 WDUH OH LQFRPEHQ]H FRPXQDOL HG HVHJXLUH JOL RUGLQL WUDVPHVVL GDO *RYHUQR/ OH PRGDOLWj GL QRPLQD GHL FRQVLJOLHUL ULPDVHUR TXHOOH QDSROHRQLFKH/ PD YHQQH0 UR HVWURPHVVL G·XIILFLR JOL HEUHL H SHU OD QRPLQD D &RQVHUYDWRUH GHOOH FRPX0 QLWj GL SULPD FODVVH YHQQH ULPHVVD LQ DXJH O·DQWLFD SUDWLFD GHOOD VFHOWD GXFDOH IUD L QRELOL GHOOD FLWWj91 &RQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH )UDQFHVFR ,9 RSHUz XQD GUDVWLFD ULGX]LRQH GHO QXPHUR GHL PXQLFLSL/ GHFLVLRQH HYLGHQWHPHQWH DGRWWDWD QHOOD FRQVDSHYROH]0 ]D GL FDQFHOODUH TXHOOL FKH/ FRPH KR JLj DYXWR RFFDVLRQH GL VRWWROLQHDUH/ HUD0 QR L FDUGLQL GHOOH ULIRUPH ULYROX]LRQDULH GHO 4:;< H FKH DYHYDQR JLXVWLILFDWR O·DFFHQWUDPHQWR HG LO FRQWUROOR GL PHULWR GD SDUWH GHL SUHIHWWL H GHL ORUR FRO0 ODERUDWRUL1 1HJOL DQQL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD ,WDOLDQD H GHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD LO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR HUD FRPSRVWR GD RWWR GLVWUHWWL/ VHWWH GHL TXDOL FRUULVSRQGHYDQR DO WHUULWRULR GHOOD QRVWUD SURYLQFLD/ PHQWUH O·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
²²²²²²²² 9 /H ULIOHVVLRQL HG L GDWL SUHVHQWDWL QHO FRUVR GHOO*LQWHUYHQWR VRQR LO ULVXOWDWR GHOOD FRQVXO0 WD]LRQH VLVWHPDWLFD GHOOD VHULH GHJOL $WWL GL DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH JHQHUDOH GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ GDO 4;36 DO 4;:9 FKH QHO SHULRGR VWXGLDWR SUHVHQWDQR GXH GHQRPLQD]LRQL GLYHUVH= 3URGRWWH GHJOL DWWL GHOOD 0XQLFLSDOLWj SHU JOL DQQL FRPSUHVL IUD LO 4;36 HG LO 4;47 H 3URGRWWH GHJOL DWWL GHOOD &RPX0 QLWj WUD LO 4;47 H LO 4;86> QDWXUDOPHQWH LO WXWWR q FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR O*$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD +G*RUD LQ SRL $6&02,1
;:5
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
/·DWWDFFR DL FULWHUL GL XQLIRUPLWj H GL GHFHQWUDPHQWR QRQ DYUHEEH SRWXWR HVVHUH SL• HVSOLFLWR HG HIILFDFH/ VH QRQ FRQ LO WRWDOH DQQXOODPHQWR GHOO·LVWDQ]D FRQVLJOLDUH1 3HU LO FDSLOODUH FRQWUROOR GHO WHUULWRULR GXFDOH YHQQHUR FUHDWH OH 3URYLQFLH GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD H GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ RJQXQD FRQ XQ SURSULR *R0 YHUQDWRUH= LO 0DUFKHVH /XLJL &RFFDSDQL SHU 0RGHQD/ LO &RQWH $QWRQLR 5H SHU 5HJJLR (PLOLD H LO &RQWH /XLJL %RVFKHWWL SHU OD *DUIDJQDQD1 &RQWHVWXDOPHQWH LO QXRYR 'XFD GL 0RGHQD GRYHWWH DIIURQWDUH LO SUREOH0 PD GL GHILQLUH L FULWHUL GL VHOH]LRQH GHOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH SHU LO QXRYR 6WDWR HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH SHU OD &RPXQLWj PRGHQHVH H IX FRQ TXHVWR HVSOLFLWR LQWHQ0 WR FKH VL LPSHJQz D ULFRVWLWXLUH XQ FHWR QRELOH GL VXR JUDGLPHQWR/ DWWUDYHUVR OD UHGD]LRQH GL XQ QXRYR /LEUR G·2UR GHOOD QRELOWj PRGHQHVH:1 /D QRELOWj DXVWURHVWHQVH ULVXOWz HVVHUH LQIHULRUH D TXHOOD GHO 4:<9 GL 85 LQGLYLGXL/ SRLFKq LO QXPHUR FRPSOHVVLYR VL HUD ULGRWWR GD 5;9 D 567 SHUVRQH/ LQROWUH LO QXPHUR GHJOL LQGLYLGXL SUHVHQWL LQ HQWUDPEH OH OLVWH DPPRQWDYD D 463/ TXLQGL OD QRELOWj GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 HUD SLXWWRVWR GLYHUVD GD TXHOOD HVWHQVH GHJOL XOWLPLVVLPL DQQL GL JRYHUQR1 ,QROWUH LO 'XFD GRYHWWH DFFHWWDUH LO GDWR GL IDWWR FKH QRQ WXWWD OD QRELOWj PRGHQHVH VL HUD PDQWHQXWD LQRVVLGDELOPHQWH IHGHOH DOOD FDVDWD G·(VWH LQ HVL0 OLR> IX TXLQGL LQGLVSHQVDELOH JLXQJHUH DG XQD VRUWD GL FRPSURPHVVR SROLWLFR FRQ OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH PRGHQHVH GL HWj UHSXEEOLFDQD H QDSROHRQLFD1 $OO·HVFOXVLRQH GDOO·qOLWH GLULJHQWH GHO 'XFDWR GHJOL XRPLQL FKH LQ PRGR SL• EULOODQWH H UHVSRQVDELOH FRRSHUDURQR DOOH VWUXWWXUH GHO JRYHUQR FHQWUDOH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD ,WDOLDQD H GHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD/ HG DOO·XWLOL]]D]LRQH GHL UDSSUH0 VHQWDQWL GL TXHOOH IDPLJOLH FKH DYHYDQR PDQWHQXWR IHGH DL ORUR REEOLJKL GL GHYR]LRQH QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL (VWHQVL/ JLXQJHQGR VLQR D VHJXLUOL QHOO·HVLOLR GDOOD FLWWj/ FRUULVSRVH LO SLHQR LPSLHJR GL PROWL HVSRQHQWL GHOOD QRELOWj H0 VWHQVH H GL QXRYL QRELOL FKH DYHYDQR VHUYLWR LO JRYHUQR QDSROHRQLFR QHOOH GL0 YHUVH LVWDQ]H GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH/ GDO &RQVLJOLR GL 'LSDUWLPHQWR VLQR DO VLQJROR &RQVLJOLR &RPXQDOH1 /D VFHOWD DSSHQD LOOXVWUDWD HUD RUPDL LQHOXWWDELOH/ JLDFFKq O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH HUD GHILQLWLYDPHQWH HQWUDWD D IDU SDUWH GHOOD PDFFKL0 QD VWDWDOH FRQ FRPSLWL EHQ GHILQLWL/ TXLQGL JOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL DYUHEEHUR GR0 ²²²²²²²² :
2OWUH DO FDUWHJJLR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR JLj FLWDWR/ D SURSRVLWR GHO FHWR QRELOH q SRVVLELOH FRQ0 VXOWDUH SUHVVR O*$6&02 XQD QXWULWD VHULH GL $OPDQDFFKL GL &RUWH/ FKH GRFXPHQWDQR FRQ FRQ0 WLQXLWj WXWWR LO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH HG LQ PRGR SL• HSLVRGLFR JOL DQQL SUHFHGHQWL DO 4:<;/ HG LO /LEUR G*RUR GHOOD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD/ 4;491
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;:6
YXWR TXDOLILFDUVL QRQ VROR FRPH SHUVRQH SROLWLFDPHQWH VLFXUH/ PD DQFKH FD0 SDFL GL DGHPSLHUH OH IXQ]LRQL GHOHJDWH DO &RPXQH GDOOR 6WDWR FKH VH QH ULVHU0 YDYD OD QRPLQD H QH FRQWUROODYD O·RSHUDWR> LQIDWWL VLQ GDJOL HVRUGL GHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD QDSROHRQLFR/ LQ FLWWj/ LQL]Lz D GHOLQHDUVL LO SURILOR/ DQFRUD LQFHUWR/ GL XQD EXURFUD]LD FRPXQDOH FRQ FRPSLWL SXUDPHQWH HVHFXWLYL/ QRPLQDWD GD SR0 GHVWj H GDL FRQVHUYDWRUL1 '·DOWURQGH OH UHVSRQVDELOLWj GL YDULR JHQHUH DGGRVVDWH DJOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL FRPXQDOL SUHVXSSRQHYDQR O·HVLVWHQ]D D OLYHOOR ORFDOH GL XQ JUXSSR FRQVLVWHQ0 WH GL SHUVRQH LQ JUDGR GL GLVWULFDUVL WUD OH FLUFRODUL PLQLVWHULDOL/ JOL DGHPSL0 PHQWL EXURFUDWLFL H ILQDQ]LDUL VLQR DOOD VRUYHJOLDQ]D GHOO·RUGLQH SXEEOLFR> RY0 YLDPHQWH ULVXOWDYD DJHYRODWR QHOO·LQFDULFR/ SHU FRPSHWHQ]D H VLFXUH]]D/ FKL DYHYD JLj RSHUDWR QHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH1 1RQ GHYH TXLQGL VWXSLUH FKH )UDQFHVFR ,9 DEELD GRYXWR ULFRUUHUH QHOO·DPSLD PDJJLRUDQ]D GHOOH FDULFKH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH PRGHQHVL D SHUVRQDOH FKH/ SXU LQ PLVXUD YDULDELOH/ DYHYD GDWR SURYD GL Vq GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR QDSR0 OHRQLFR1 )X TXHVWR LO FDVR GL GXH GHL WUH JRYHUQDWRUL +&RFFDSDQL H 5H,/ GL WXWWL L SRGHVWj VLQR DO 4;64 +LO &RQWH &ODXGLR %RVFKHWWL/ LO 0DUFKHVH ,SSROLWR /LYL]0 ]DQL/ LO 0DUFKHVH (QHD )UDQFHVFR 0RQWHFXFFROL HG LO 0DUFKHVH *LXVHSSH 5DQJRQL, H GL YHQWLFLQTXH FRQVHUYDWRUL VXL WUHQWDFLQTXH FRPSOHVVLYDPHQWH QRPLQDWL IUD LO 4;47 HG LO 4;641 $ SURSRVLWR GHOOD FDUULHUD GHJOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL FRPXQDOL RFFRUUH VRWWROL0 QHDUH FKH TXLQGLFL FRQVHUYDWRUL VX WUHQWDFLQTXH ULVXOWDYDQR JLj FRPSRQHQWL GHO /LEUR G·2UR QHO 4:<9 HG XQD SDUWH GL ORUR RFFXSDURQR FDULFKH PXQLFLSD0 OL DQFKH QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH/ LQROWUH VROR WUH GL HVVL QRQ UL0 VXOWDYDQR IUD L FRPSRQHQWL GHOOH IDPLJOLH GHO /LEUR G·2UR GHO 4;49/ WXWWDYLD LQ VHJXLWR QH YHQQHUR QRELOLWDWL GXH VX WUH1 3RLFKp L TXDWWUR SRGHVWj GHO &RPXQH PRGHQHVH HUDQR FRPXQTXH QRPL0 QDWL FRQVHUYDWRUL QHO SHULRGR LQ FXL QRQ ULFRSULURQR TXHO UXROR/ ULVXOWD HYL0 GHQWH FKH IXURQR LQ WXWWR XQD TXDUDQWLQD GL SHUVRQH TXHOOH FKH VL DOWHUQDUR0 QR QHOOH PDVVLPH FDULFKH FRPXQDOL QHOO·DUFR GHL GLFLDVVHWWH DQQL SUHVL LQ H0 VDPH FRQ XQD FRQWLQXLWj GL SUHVHQ]D HOHYDWLVVLPD/ FKH LQ GLYHUVL FDVL YHQQH LQWHUURWWD VRODPHQWH FRQ OD ORUR PRUWH;1 ²²²²²²²² ;
3HU TXHOOR FKH ULJXDUGD JOL VWXGL SXEEOLFDWL VXOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH LO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ VL ULPDQGD DOOD OHWWXUD GL= )1 %$/'(//,/ , &RQVHUYDWRUL GHOOD &LWWj GL 0RGHQD +4:33 0 4;33,/ LQ= )RUPD]LRQH H FRQWUROOR GHOO*RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD D 0RGHQD QHO *:33/ D FXUD GL $1 %,21',/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<;9> $1 %,21',/ 3HU XQD VWRULD GHOO*DWWLYLWj FRQVLOLDUH GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD GDO 0HGLRHYR
;:7
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
/H QRELOL IDPLJOLH 0RO]D/ %HOOLQFLQL/ /LYL]]DQL/ 9DOHQWLQL/ 5DQJRQL/ )RUQL/ 0RQWHFXFFROL H &RUWHVL PDQWHQQHUR TXLQGL OH ORUR SRVL]LRQL GL SUHPLQHQ]D QHOOD VRFLHWj PRGHQHVH/ XQD SRVL]LRQH FKH WUDGL]LRQDOPHQWH RFFXSDYDQR GD VHFROL/ D YROWH DQFRU SULPD GHOO·DUULYR GHJOL (VWHQVL LQ FLWWj1 , UDSSUHVHQWDQWL SL• LQIOXHQWL GL TXHVWH IDPLJOLH DVVXQVHUR OD JXLGD GHOOR 6WDWR DXVWURHVWHQVH/ FRQ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH/ LQ XQD SRVL]LRQH GL IRU]D ULVSHWWR DL ORUR DQWHQDWL GHO VHFROR VFRUVR/ SURSULR LQ IXQ]LRQH DOO·HVWUDQHLWj GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 SULPD H GHO ILJOLR SRL/ DO FRQWHVWR HFRQRPLFR H VRFLDOH PRGHQHVH1 0HQWUH SHU SRWHU DVSLUDUH DOOH FDULFKH GL *RYHUQDWRUH H GL &RDGLXWRUH/ FRPH SHU JOL LQFDULFKL GL 3RGHVWj H GL &RQVHUYDWRUH/ ULVXOWz DVVROXWDPHQWH LQGLVSHQVDELOH IDU SDUWH GHOOH IDPLJOLH DVFULWWH DO /LEUR G·RUR/ LQYHFH SHU OD QRPLQD D &RQVLJOLHUH GHO PXQLFLSLR PRGHQHVH ULPDVH G·REEOLJR ULIHULUVL DOOD QRUPD QDSROHRQLFD FKH SUHVFULYHYD OD VFHOWD GHL FRQVLJOLHUL GD XQ HOHQFR GL ´(VWLPDWLµ= OH SHUVRQH GDO UHGGLWR SL• FRQVLVWHQWH QHO FRPXQH1 )UDQFHVFR ,9 QRQ PXWz TXHVWD QRUPD ODVFLDQGR DSHUWR XQR VSLUDJOLR SHU JOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD FODVVH QRQ QRELOH/ PD GL PDJJLRU SHVR HFRQRPLFR GHOOD FLWWj/ DQFKH QHOOD SURVSHWWLYD GL XQD HYHQWXDOH LQWHJUD]LRQH IXWXUD QHO QRYHUR GHOOH IDPLJOLH QRELOL PRGHQHVL1 ,O FRQIURQWR IUD OD OLVWD GHL FHQWR HVWLPDWL SHU OD QRPLQD PXQLFLSDOH GHO 4;46/ TXLQGL GHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD/ H OD OLVWD GHL FHQWRYHQWL HVWLPDWL HVWHQVL GHO 4;49 VL ULOHYD XQD SHUPDQHQ]D GHJOL LQGLYLGXL HOHQFDWL GHO 9;( H GXH DQQL GRSR WDOH SHUFHQWXDOH ULVXOWDYD DQFRUD GHO 93(1 6L WUDWWD GL SHUFHQWXDOL IRU0 WHPHQWH VLJQLILFDWLYH QHO VHQVR GHOOD FRQWLQXLWj QHOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHO FHWR HFRQRPLFDPHQWH SULYLOHJLDWR GHOOD FLWWj/ D VRWWROLQHDUH FRPH LO QRYHUR GHJOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL QDSROHRQLFL DYHVVH JLj GHILQLWR XQD VFHOWD G·pOLWH IUD L FLWWDGLQL SL• ULFFKL HG LQIOXHQWL1 1HJOL DQQL GL JRYHUQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 JOL HOHQFKL DOIDEHWLFL GHL FHQWRYHQWL PDJJLRUL HVWLPDWL FLWWDGLQL SUHVHQWDURQR OD FDUDWWHULVWLFD GL ULSRUWDUH FLUFD LO 83( GHJOL LVFULWWL FKH QRQ ULVXOWDYDQR LQFOXVL IUD JO·LQGLYLGXL DVFULWWL DO /LEUR G·RUR QHO PHGHVLPR DQQR1
²²²²²²²² DOOD ILQH GHOO*$QWLFR 5HJLPH +4:<9,/ LQ , UHJLVWUL GHOOH 'HOLEHUD]LRQL FRQVLOLDUL GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD GDO ;,9 DO ;9,,, VHFROR/ D FXUD GL &1 /,277, H 31 520$*12/,/ 0RGHQD/ 4<;:> $O *RYHUQR GHO &RPXQH1 7UHPLODFLQTXHFHQWR PRGHQHVL SHU OD &RPXQLWj ORFDOH GDO ;9 VHFROR DG RJJL/ D FXUD GL 01 &$77,1,/ 0RGHQD 4<<91
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;:8
3HU JOL XRPLQL QRQ QRELOL GHOOD OLVWD GHJOL HVWLPDWL QRQ IX DIIDWWR VHPSOLFH HQWUDUH QHO QRYHUR GHL &RQVLJOLHUL FRPXQDOL/ DOPHQR VLQR DL SULPL DQQL ¶53 GHO VHFROR1 ,QIDWWL GDO 4;47 DO 4;53 LO SUHGRPLQLR GHL QRELOL DOO·LQWHUQR GHO FRQVHVVR FRPXQDOH IX VFKLDFFLDQWH/ SRLFKq RFFXSDURQR FLQTXDQWDGXH GHL VHWWDQWDGXH VHJJL GD FRQVLJOLHUH DVVHJQDWL1 ,QYHFH QHOOH VXFFHVVLYH VRVWLWX]LR0 QL DYYHQXWH IUD LO 4;54 HG LO 4;64 LO QXPHUR GHL QRELOL VFHOWL GDO 'XFD GLPL0 QXu/ VHSSXU UHODWLYDPHQWH/ SRLFKq VX FLQTXDQWDTXDWWUR LQFDULFKL DVVHJQDWL YHQWRWWR DQGDURQR DOOD QRELOWj H YHQWLVHL DJOL HVWLPDWL GL GLYHUVD HVWUD]LRQH VRFLDOH1 1RQRVWDQWH OD ULFHUFD VYROWD/ ULPDQH DQFRUD DSHUWR LO SUREOHPD GHOOD GHIL0 QL]LRQH VRFLR0FXOWXUDOH GL TXHVWD FODVVH/ GLIILFLOPHQWH LGHQWLILFDELOH FRQ XQD VRGGLVIDFHQWH SUHFLVLRQH/ FKH WXWWDYLD PDWHULDOL]]z LQ PRGR LQHTXLYRFDELOH TXDQWR HUD FDPELDWR QHOOD VRFLHWj PRGHQHVH GRSR LO 4;331 5LVXOWD HYLGHQWH FRPH )UDQFHVFR ,9 PLUDVVH DG XQD JUDGXDOH H FRQWUROODWD FRPPLVWLRQH GHOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH PXQLFLSDOH GL HVFOXVLYD LPSURQWD QRELOLD0 UH/ H TXLQGL GLIILFLOPHQWH FRQWUROODELOH/ FRQ LQGLYLGXL GL RULJLQH GLYHUVD/ GHL TXDOL LQWHVH VSHULPHQWDUH OD IHGHOWj H OH FDSDFLWj GL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL LQ FRQVL0 JOLR VHQ]D DSULUH ORUR OH SRUWH GHO FHWR FRQVHUYDWRUH HG DOOD FDULFD GL SRGHVWj1 &RQ LO SDVVDUH GHJOL DQQL LO 'XFD RSHUz SHU XQD OHQWD H SURJUHVVLYD DFTXL0 VL]LRQH GL XQ PDJJLRU FRQWUROOR VXOOH LVWDQ]H GHO SRWHUH ORFDOH DWWUDYHUVR OD FUHD]LRQH GL XQ UHJLPH QRELOLDUH GL QXRYD JHQHUD]LRQH/ DIILDQFDWR GD HVSR0 QHQWL VFHOWL GHOOD ERUJKHVLD LQ DVFHVD/ GD FRVWLWXLUH QHO FRUVR GHJOL DQQL GHO SURSULR UHJQR JUD]LH DG XQ FRQWUROOR IHUUHR VX WXWWR O·DSSDUDWR GHO JRYHUQR GXFDOH/ VXOOH DPPLQLVWUD]LRQL ORFDOL HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH VXO 0XQLFLSLR GHOOD FD0 SLWDOH1 7XWWDYLD LQ FLWWj FRQWLQXDYD DG HVLVWHUH XQD IRUWH RSSRVL]LRQH SROLWLFD DO SURJHWWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ XQ·RSSRVL]LRQH OHJDWD DL YDORUL GL OLEHUWj H LQGL0 SHQGHQ]D GDOOR VWUDQLHUR/ FRVWUHWWD DG RUJDQL]]DUVL FRQ L PHWRGL GHOOH VRFLHWj VHJUHWH/ PD QLHQWH DIIDWWR ULQXQFLDWDULD1 /R GLPRVWUz OD YLROHQ]D GHOOD UHSUHVVLRQH DWWXDWD QHJOL DQQL 4;54 0 4;551 &RPH q QRWR GDSSULPD IXURQR RSHUDWL QXPHURVL DUUHVWL SHU VFRSULUH JOL DXWRUL GL XQ SURFODPD LQ ODWLQR GLIIXVR/ QHO JHQQDLR GHO 4;54/ WUD OH WUXSSH XQJKHUHVL SDVVDWH DWWUDYHUVR LO WHUULWRULR SURYLQFLDOH SHU UHFDUVL D FRPEDWWHUH QHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL1
;:9
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
3RL DO SULQFLSLR GHO 4;55 YHQQHUR DUUHVWDWL SL• GL FLQTXDQWD FLWWDGLQL VR0 VSHWWDWL GL DSSDUWHQHUH DOOD FDUERQHULD> PHQWUH VL VYROJHYD O·LVWUXWWRULD/ LO GL0 UHWWRUH GL 3ROL]LD *LXOLR %HVLQL YHQQH DVVDVVLQDWR H LO FROSHYROH ULXVFu D IXJJL0 UH/ YHQQH LQYHFH DUUHVWDWR $QWRQLR 3RQ]RQL/ DFFXVDWR GDO %HVLQL VWHVVR LQ SXQWR GL PRUWH/ FKH VHEEHQH SURVFLROWR GDL JLXGLFL IX WHQXWR XJXDOPHQWH LQ FDUFHUH SHU QRYH DQQL1 ,O SURFHVVR VL FRQFOXVH FRQ QRYH FRQGDQQH D PRUWH/ XQD VROD GHOOH TXDOL YHQQH HVHJXLWD/ TXHOOD GL 'RQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL<1 /H WUDPH FDUERQDUH YHQQHUR VWURQFDWH VXO QDVFHUH/ TXLQGL QRQ q SRVVLELOH SDUODUH GHOO·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GL XQ PRWR ULYROX]LRQDULR/ Qq GL XQ SURJUDPPD SROLWLFR JHQHUDOH/ Qq GL XQ SURJUDPPD DPPLQLVWUDWLYR LQ SDUWLFRODUH1 0D TXDQGR/ QHO 4;64/ LO WHQWDWLYR LQVXUUH]LRQDOH WURYz O· RVVLJHQR QHFHV0 VDULR SHU VRSUDYYLYHUH HG XQ PLQLPR GL VSD]LR SROLWLFR SHU FRQFUHWL]]DUVL/ LO UXROR GHO 0XQLFLSLR GLYHQQH GL SULPR SLDQR1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR VHFRQGR FDVR QRQ q SRVVLELOH SDUODUH Qq GL XQ SLDQR VWUDWHJLFR SUHRUGLQDWR/ Qq GL XQD SDU0 WLFRODUH DWWHQ]LRQH WHRULFD R SROLWLFD QHL FRQIURQWL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FR0 PXQDOH WXWWDYLD/ GRSR OD IXJD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 LO 8 IHEEUDLR/ IX SURSULR QHOOD VHGH FRPXQDOH FKH VL FRQFUHWL]]DURQR OH VFHOWH SROLWLFKH IRQGDPHQWDOL GHJOL LQVRUWL1 1HOOD VDOD GHO &RQVLJOLR FRPXQDOH VL ULXQLURQR L GHOHJDWL GD )UDQFHVFR ,9 D FRPSRUUH OD 5HJJHQ]D SURYYLVRULD GHOOD FLWWj FRQ L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHL FLWWD0 GLQL PRGHQHVL IDXWRUL GHOOD ULYROWD/ SHU GHILQLUH XQ SULPR JRYHUQR FLWWDGLQR GL WUDQVL]LRQH H QRPLQDUH LO FRPDQGDQWH JHQHUDOH GHOOD *XDUGLD 1D]LRQDOH1 1HOOD PHGHVLPD VDOD VL FRQYRFDURQR VHWWDQWDGXH FLWWDGLQL PRGHQHVL SHU QRPLQDUH LO *RYHUQR 3URYYLVRULR GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD H OD VXD SURYLQFLD/ GHILQHQGR OH FDULFKH GHO QXRYR JRYHUQR H GLFKLDUDQGR GHILQLWLYDPHQWH GHFD0 GXWR LO SRWHUH GHJOL (VWHQVL1 1HO FRUVR GL TXHVWD DQLPDWD ULXQLRQH O·DYYRFDWR 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL/ VWLODQ0 GR O·DWWR GL GHFDGHQ]D GHO UHJLPH DXVWURHVWHQVH/ VL PDFFKLz GL XQ GHOLWWR WDOH GD FRVWDUJOL/ DO ULWRUQR GHO 'XFD/ OD FRQGDQQD DOOD SHQD GL PRUWH1 3HU L ULYROWRVL GHO IHEEUDLR 4;64 LO &RPXQH HUD/ HYLGHQWHPHQWH/ OD VHGH QDWXUDOH GHO JRYHUQR GHL FLWWDGLQL PRGHQHVL OLEHUDWL GDO JLRJR GXFDOH/ LO OXRJR GHOOD OLEHUWj H GHOOD GLVFXVVLRQH/ GHOOD SROLWLFD H GHOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHO QXRYR 6WDWR1 ²²²²²²²² < $ SURSRVLWR GHL PRWL GHO 4;5304;54 H GHOOD UHSUHVVLRQH SUHYHQWLYD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ VL YHGD= *1 &$1'(/252/ 6WRULD GHOO*,WDOLD PRGHUQD/ ,,/ 'DOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH DOOD ULYROX]LRQH QD]LRQDOH/ 4;48 04;79/ SS1 45<0463/ 0LODQR/ )HOWULQHOOL/ 4<:;1
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;::
,Q UHDOWj/ QRQRVWDQWH OD SROLWLFD GXFDOH/ LO FHWR QRELOH QRQ ULVXOWz GHO WXWWR HVWUDQHR DOOD ULYROWD/ DOFXQL HVSRQHQWL GHOOH QRELOL IDPLJOLH PRGHQHVL SDUWHFL0 SDURQR DOOH GLYHUVH LVWLWX]LRQL FUHDWH GDL ULYROWRVL/ HG LQ TXDOFKH FDVR SDJDUR0 QR OD ORUR VFHOWD FRQ OD UDGLD]LRQH GDO /LEUR G·2UR H FRQ PLWL FRQGDQQH +0DUFKHVH *LR1$QWRQLR 0RUDQR/ &RQWH $QJHOR *XLGHOOL/ 1181 5DQJRQL )UDQFHVFR/ &RQWH 6DOLPEHQL )LOSSR,1 3HU TXHOOR FKH ULJXDUGD OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH GHOOD &RPXQLWj PRGHQHVH/ O·DGHVLRQH DO PRWR ULJXDUGz LQ PRGR VLJQLILFDWLYR L ILJOL HG L QLSRWL SLXWWRVWR FKH L VLQJROL LQGLYLGXL QRPLQDWL QHOOH PDJLVWUDWXUH FLWWDGLQH1 ,QIDWWL DFFDGGH FRQ XQD FHUWD IUHTXHQ]D FKH L ILJOL GHL FRQVLJOLHUL GHOOD 0XQLFLSDOLWj PRGHQHVH QRPLQDWL GDO 'XFD SDUWHFLSDVVHUR DOOD ULYROWD LQ SUL0 PD SHUVRQD/ DG HVHPSLR= &DVWLJOLRQL 6LOYHVWUR/ &LDOGLQL )UDQFHVFR/ L IUDWHOOL 1LFROD/ &DUOR/ /XLJL H 3DROR )DEUL]L/ L IUDWHOOL $QWRQLR/ *DHWDQR H *LXOLR &H0 VDUH 7DPSHOOLQL1 /D SUHFLSLWRVD IXJD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 H OD ULFKLHVWD GL DLXWR DOO·$XVWULD DYH0 YDQR LQROWUH HYLGHQ]LDWR OD VWUDRUGLQDULD GHEROH]]D GHOOD FRPSDJLQH VWDWDOH DXVWURHVWHQVH LQFDSDFH GL DIIURQWDUH LQ PRGR FRVWUXWWLYR L SUREOHPL FKH WXWWL JOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH DQGDYDQR LQYHFH OHQWDPHQWH GHIL0 QHQGR431 )UDQFHVFR ,9 GRSR L PRWL DFFHQWXz JOL DVSHWWL UHWULYL/ JLj PROWR HYLGHQWL/ GHOOD VXD OLQHD SROLWLFD LQWHUQD/ FRVu DFFDQWR DOOD VHQWHQ]D GL PRUWH SHU &LUR 0HQRWWL H 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL SRVVLDPR ULFRUGDUH DQFKH OD FRQGDQQD DOOD GHIL0 QLWLYD VFRPSDUVD GDOOD VFHQD SROLWLFD FLWWDGLQD GHO &RQVLJOLR &RPXQDOH GHOOD FDSLWDOH/ O·XOWLPR RUJDQR GHO JRYHUQR FKH/ LQ TXDOFKH PLVXUD/ DYUHEEH SRWXWR UDSSUHVHQWDUH LO WHQWDWLYR GL DOODUJDUH OD EDVH GHO FRQVHQVR VRFLDOH GHO UHJLPH DXVWURHVWHQVH1 &DQFHOODQGR O·HVLVWHQ]D GHO &RQVLJOLR O·RSHUD UHVWDXUDWLYD LQ PDWHULD GL SR0 WHUH ORFDOH HUD VWDWD FRPSOHWDWD/ RUD FRQ OD VROD SUHVHQ]D GHO SRGHVWj H GHL FRQVHUYDWRUL/ WXWWL GL GLUHWWD QRPLQD GXFDOH H GL HVFOXVLYD HVWUD]LRQH QRELOLD0 UH/ O·DQWLFD VWUXWWXUD GHO JRYHUQR ORFDOH WDUGR VHWWHFHQWHVFR ULWRUQDYD FRP0 SLXWDPHQWH LQ YLWD UDIIRU]DWD GDJOL HVLWL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL GHOO·DFFHQWUDPHQWR SURGRWWR LQ HWj QDSROHRQLFD1 ,Q TXHVWR PRGR OD VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD/ FUHDWD QHO FRUVR GHO SHULRGR IUDQFHVH/ FDGGH QHOOH PDQL GHOOD ULVWUHWWD qOLWH FRVWLWXLWD GDOOH SL• DWWLYH IDPL0 JOLH GHOOD QRELOWj PRGHQHVH FKH/ XQLFKH GHSRVLWDULH GHOOD ILGXFLD GXFDOH/ IX0 ²²²²²²²² 43 , PRWL GHO 4;6304;64 VRQR VWDWL DPSLDPHQWH VWXGLDWL GDOOD VWRULRJUDILD QD]LRQDOH LQ WXW0 WH OH RSHUH JHQHUDOL UHODWLYH DO 5LVRUJLPHQWR JLj FLWDWH QHOOD QRWD 51
;:;
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
URQR LQ JUDGR GL JHVWLUH LO JRYHUQR ORFDOH LQ PRGR VHPSUH SL• DXWRQRPR PDQ PDQR FKH )UDQFHVFR ,9 VL RVWLQDYD QHOO·DWWXDUH OD VXD SROLWLFD UHSUHVVLYD HG RVFXUDQWLVWLFD1 /D GHILQLWLYD VFHOWD GHO 'XFD SHU OD UHVWDXUD]LRQH SL• UDGLFDOH GHO SDVVDWR QRQ VRUWu SHUz OR VSHUDWR HIIHWWR GL SDFLILFDUH GHILQLWLYDPHQWH JOL DQLPL/ EHQVu GHWHUPLQz XQR VWDWR HQGHPLFR GL ULYROWD/ HVDFHUEz L UDQFRUL/ DXPHQWz OD GLI0 ILGHQ]D IUD L FHWL VRFLDOL/ JHWWDQGR LO GLVFUHGLWR VXL JRYHUQDQWL1 /D VFHOWD GHOOD VWUDWHJLD UHSUHVVLYD LPSOLFz/ SHU )UDQFHVFR ,9/ O·LQJUHVVR LQ XQ YHUR H SURSULR YRUWLFH GL VRVSHWWL/ GL WUDPH RVFXUH/ GL FODPRURVL SURFHVVL H GL SHVDQWL FRQGDQQH FKH VL FRQFOXVH VROR FRQ OD ILQH GHJOL DQQL 7UHQWD1 $ TXHVWR FOLPD GL VRWWLOH YLROHQ]D H GL LPSHUDQWH GLIILGHQ]D QRQ VIXJJu QHVVXQR/ QHPPHQR L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOD QRELOWj PRGHQHVH/ FKH GRYHWWHUR VXELUH OH FRQVHJXHQ]H GHOO·DWPRVIHUD GL VRVSHWWR LPSHUDQWH QHOOD FRUWH GXFD0 OH1 &RVu/ QHO 4;65/ 0RGHQD GRYHWWH DVVLVWHUH DG XQ·DOWUD HVHFX]LRQH FDSLWDOH TXHOOD GL *LXVHSSH 5LFFL/ *XDUGLD 1RELOH G·RQRUH GL 6XD $OWH]]D 5HDOH )UDQFHVFR ,9/ ILJOLR GHO &DYDOLHU &DUOR 5LFFL QRELOH DVFULWWR DO /LEUR G·2UR FRQ XQ·LPSRUWDQWH FDUULHUD GL FRQVHUYDWRUH H GL FRQVLJOLHUH PXQLFLSDOH1 *LX0 VHSSH 5LFFL YHQQH DFFXVDWR H FRQGDQQDWR SHU DYHU RUGLWR XQD WUDPD ULYROX0 ]LRQDULD DL GDQQL GHOOR 6WDWR H O·RPLFLGLR GHO 'XFD1 )UD O·HVWDWH GHO 4;67 H OD SULPDYHUD GHOO·DQQR VHJXHQWH IX OD YROWD GHL GXH SURFHVVL 0DWWLROL %HUWDFFKLQL1 1HO SULPR VL GHFUHWz OD FROSHYROH]]D GHOO·DYYRFDWR *LDFRPR 0DWWLROL %HUWDFFKLQL/ OHJDOH/ SURIHVVRUH GL JLXULVSUXGHQ]D FULPLQDOH H GL GLULWWR FKH YHQQH DFFXVDWR GL DYHU RUGLWR XQD WUDPD ULYROX]LRQDULD DO VHUYL]LR GHO *UDQ &RQVLJOLR (OYHWLFR QHOOH SURYLQFLH GHOOD PRQWDJQD PRGHQHVH/ GHOOD *DUID0 JQDQD H GHOOD /XQLJLDQD/ DO ILQH GL GLVWUXJJHUH OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH1 1HO VHFRQGR SURFHVVR YHQQHUR JLXGLFDWL H FRQGDQQDWL WUH FRPSOLFL GHO 0DWWLROL/ QHOOR VYLOXSSR GL TXHVWR SURFHGLPHQWR/ SHU OD SULPD YROWD/ YHQQH IDWWR HVSOLFLWR ULIHULPHQWR DOO·DVVRFLD]LRQH ´*LRYDQH ,WDOLDµ/ FKH HYLGHQWH0 PHQWH DYHYD WURYDWR QHO PRGHQHVH XQ IHUWLOH WHUUHQR GL GLIIXVLRQH> LQIDWWL IX0 URQR EHQ SUHVWR DYYLDWL DOWUL SURFHGLPHQWL JLXGL]LDUL D FDULFR GHJOL DIILOLDWL DOO·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH PD]]LQLDQD OH FXL VHQWHQ]H YHQQHUR HPHVVH QHO PDJJLR H DJRVWR 4;68 H QHO JLXJQR 4;69 FRLQYROJHQGR XQ WRWDOH GL YHQWRWWR SHUVRQH1 ,QILQH QHO JLXJQR 4;6: JLXQVH D FRQFOXVLRQH LO SURFHVVR DJOL ROWUH FHQWR ODWLWDQWL LQTXLVLWL SHU LO PRWR GHO 4;64= IXURQR FRPPLQDWH YHQWLVHWWH FRQGDQ0 QH DOOD SHQD GHOOD IRUFD GD HVHJXLUVL LQ HIILJH/ YHQWLWUq FRQGDQQH DOOD JDOHUD D
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;:<
YLWD H PROWH DOWUH SHQH PLQRUL1 1HJOL DQQL IUD LO 4;64 HG LO 4;7; OD 0XQLFLSDOLWj PRGHQHVH YHQQH JRYHU0 QDWD GD WUH 3RGHVWj +0DUFKHVH *LXVHSSH 5DQJRQL/ 0DUFKHVH ,SSROLWR /LYL]0 ]DQL H 0DUFKHVH *LXVHSSH &DUDQGLQL, GXH GHL TXDOL DYHYDQR JLj JXLGDWR O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FRPXQDOH QHL TXLQGLFL DQQL SUHFHGHQWL1 1HOOD FDULFD GL FRQVHUYDWRUH VL DOWHUQDURQR XQ QXPHUR ULVWUHWWR GL LQGLYLGXL/ SRLFKq QHL GL0 FLDVVHWWH DQQL LQ HVDPH YL IXURQR VROR GRGLFL QXRYH QRPLQH/ QDWXUDOPHQWH WXWWL L QXRYL HQWUDWL HUDQR GL RULJLQH QRELOLDUH1 /D SROLWLFD UHSUHVVLYD XQLWD DO FRQWLQXR UHVWULQJHUVL GHOO·qOLWH GLULJHQWH OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH HG DOOD SDVVLYLWj GHOOD PDJJLRUDQ]D GHL VXGGLWL DL TXDOL HUD LP0 SHGLWD RJQL IRUPD GL SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DOOH LVWDQ]H SROLWLFKH FLWWDGLQH/ GHWHUPL0 QDURQR OD WRWDOH LPSRWHQ]D GHO QXRYR 'XFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ GD GXH DQQL FLUFD DO SRWHUH/ GL IURQWH DOOD ULYROX]LRQH GHO 4;7;1 3DUWLWR GDOOD )UDQFLD LO PRWR ULYROX]LRQDULR VL HVWHVH D %HUOLQR SHU JLXQJH0 UH LQ PDU]R D 9LHQQD/ GHWHUPLQDQGR OD FDGXWD GHO 3ULQFLSH GL 0HWWHUQLFK H OD IRUPD]LRQH GL XQ JRYHUQR OLEHUDOH FRQ ULSHUFXVVLRQL LPPHGLDWH VXOOD VLWXD0 ]LRQH LWDOLDQD1 1HOOD SHQLVROD/ PHVVD LQ IHUPHQWR GDOOH ULIRUPH GL 3LR ,;/ /H0 RSROGR ,, GL 7RVFDQD H &DUOR $OEHUWR/ GLODJz OD ULYROWD FKH JLXQVH LQ FLWWj QHOOD SULPDYHUD GHWHUPLQDQGR O·HQQHVLPD IXJD GHL JRYHUQDQWL YHUVR WHUULWRUL SL• VLFXUL VRWWR LO FRQWUROOR DXVWULDFR1 )UDQFHVFR 9 ODVFLz OD FDSLWDOH QHOOH PDQL GL XQD 5HJJHQ]D EHQ SUHVWR VR0 VWLWXLWD GD XQ *RYHUQR SURYYLVRULR FKH JXLGz OD FLWWj SHU FLUFD FLQTXH PHVL/ QHO FRUVR GHL TXDOL VL GLEDWWq DQFKH GHL SUREOHPL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FR0 PXQDOH1 , ULYROX]LRQDUL PRGHQHVL QRQ VL OLPLWDURQR D VRVWLWXLUH SDU]LDOPHQWH JOL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL ORFDOL HVWHQVL FRQ XRPLQL GL ORUR JUDGLPHQWR> L ORUR SURJHWWL DQGDYDQR/ SHU OD SULPD YROWD/ EHQ ROWUH SRLFKq JLj QHOO·DSULOH YHQQHUR QRPL0 QDWH GXH &RPPLVVLRQL GL ODYRUR= XQD SHU OD ULIRUPD GHOOD GLVWUHWWXD]LRQH FRPXQDOH/ O·DOWUD SHU O·HODERUD]LRQH GL XQ QXRYR VWDWXWR SHU LO PXQLFLSLR> L SUREOHPL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH ORFDOH H GHOOD UDSSUHVHQWDQ]D FLWWDGLQD LQ SDU0 WLFRODUH HUDQR VHQ]·DOWUR DOO·RUGLQH GHO JLRUQR QHL GLEDWWLWL GHJOL XRPLQL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR PRGHQHVH/ HG LO ULSULVWLQR GHOOD IXQ]LRQDOLWj GHO &RQVLJOLR HUD XQD GHOOH ULFKLHVWH SULRULWDULH LQ TXHVWR VHQVR1 (IIHWWLYDPHQWH IXURQR PROWL JOL XRPLQL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH HVWHQVH FKH ILQLURQR SHU FROODERUDUH/ VHSSXU LQ PLVXUD YDULDELOH/ FRQ L ULYROX]LRQDUL VLD QHJOL RUJDQL GHO JRYHUQR ORFDOH VLD QHOO·DSSDUDWR PLOLWDUH> FRVu FKH )UDQFHVFR 9 DO VXR ULWRUQR D 0RGHQD QRQ SHUVHJXLWz FKL DYHYD DGHULWR DO PRWR ULYROX0
;;3
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
]LRQDULR/ DQ]L SHUFRUVH OD VWUDGD GHOO·DPPRGHUQDPHQWR LVWLWX]LRQDOH HG DP0 PLQLVWUDWLYR FKH LO SDGUH DYHYD/ WDQWR SHUYLFDFHPHQWH/ ULILXWDWR GL SUHQGHUH LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH1 1HJOL DQQL FRPSUHVL IUD LO 4;7< HG LO 4;8</ LO QXRYR 'XFD LPSUHVVH LP0 SRUWDQWL FDPELDPHQWL DOO·DVVHWWR GL JRYHUQR GHO VXR 6WDWR/ SXU FRQWLQXDQGR D JHVWLUOR FRPH XQD VRUWD GL SDWULPRQLR SHUVRQDOH1 &RQ )UDQFHVFR 9 YHQQH LVWLWXLWR LO &RQVLJOLR GL 6WDWR HG LO 0LQLVWHUR GHOO·,QWHUQR/ VRSSULPHQGR L JRYHUQL SURYLQFLDOL H FUHDQGR GHOOH GHOHJD]LRQL SURYLQFLDOL GLUHWWDPHQWH FRQWUROODWH GDO PLQLVWHUR> YHQQH FUHDWR LO VHUYL]LR GL OHYD/ IX GL QXRYR SHUPHVVD OD SLHQD IUHTXHQ]D DOO·XQLYHUVLWj/ YHQQH LQWURGRW0 WR LO VLVWHPD PHWULFR GHFLPDOH/ IXURQR LVWLWXLWH OD &RUWH GHL &RQWL H OD &RUWH GL &DVVD]LRQH H IXURQR HPDQDWL XQ &RGLFH FLYLOH/ XQ &RGLFH SHQDOH HG L &R0 GLFL GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH H SHQDOH441 5LVSHWWR DOOD VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD SDWHUQD )UDQFHVFR 9 ULGLHGH LPPH0 GLDWDPHQWH QXRYD YLWD DO &RQVLJOLR &RPXQDOH/ FUHz OD 'LUH]LRQH GHOOH 3RVWH/ LQWURGXFHQGR QHO GXFDWR O·XVR GHL IUDQFREROOL/ OD &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR VRWWR OD JDUDQ]LD GHO SDWULPRQLR FRPXQDOH H OD GLUH]LRQH GHOOD &RPXQLWj H QHO 4;89 HPDQz XQ 5HJRODPHQWR SHU O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL FRPXQL1 1HOOD VFHOWD GHL 3RGHVWj GHOOD FDSLWDOH/ LO 'XFD ULFRQIHUPz O·HVFOXVLYD SUH0 IHUHQ]D QHL FRQIURQWL GL XRPLQL GHO FHWR QRELOH/ WXWWDYLD TXHVWD VFHOWD VL ULYH0 Oz PROWR SL• GLIILFLOH H SUHFDULD ULVSHWWR DO WHPSR GHO SDGUH/ LQIDWWL QHJOL XQ0 GLFL DQQL LQ TXHVWLRQH VL DOWHUQDURQR QHOOD FDULFD VHL LQGLYLGXL FRQ XQD SHU0 PDQHQ]D PHGLD LQIHULRUH DL GXH DQQL FLDVFXQR1 $QFKH QHOOD QRPLQD GHL &RQVHUYDWRUL )UDQFHVFR 9 HYLGHQ]Lz XQD FHUWD GLVSRQLELOLWj DOOD PHGLD]LRQH/ LQQDQ]LWXWWR PDQWHQHQGR QHOOH ORUR FDULFKH GL0 YHUVL HVSRQHQWL GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH GHO 4;7; SHU DOFXQL DQQL GRSR LO VXR ULHQWUR LQ FLWWj/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR LQDXJXUDQGR XQD QXRYD SUDVVL QHOOD VFHOWD GHOOH SHU0 VRQH DGDWWH DG DVVXPHUH O·LQFDULFR GL FRQVHUYDWRUH= LQIDWWL HJOL GHFLVH GL VFH0 JOLHUH JOL LQGLYLGXL QRPLQDELOL SHU PHWj GDO FHWR QRELOH H SHU PHWj GDO ´FHWR FLWWDGLQRµ +LQ DOWUH SDUROH GDOO·HOHQFR GHJOL HVWLPDWL,/ FDGHYD FRVu LO SULQFLSLR GHOO·HVFOXVLRQH GHL QRQ QRELOL SHU O·DPPLVVLRQH D TXHVWD LPSRUWDQWH FDULFD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD1 ²²²²²²²² 44
6XOOD ILJXUD H OD SROLWLFD GL )UDQFHVFR 9 q SRVVLELOH FRQVXOWDUH XWLOPHQWH= 71 %$<$5' '( 92/2/ 9LWD GL )UDQFHVFR 9/ 'XFD GL 0RGHQD +4;4<04;:8,/ 0RGHQD/ 4;:;> *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR $XVWUR0HVWHQVH«FLW1> /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH«FLW1> )UDQFHVFR ,9 H )UDQFHVFR 9 'XFKL GL 0RGHQD1 $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR«FLW1> &ULVL GHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD 4;8</ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR/ 0LUDQGROD/ 3DUFR GHOOD &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0LUDQGROD 63 JLXJQR 4<<8/ &DUSL 4<<91
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;;4
3HU OD QRPLQD GHL FRQVLJOLHUL VL UHVH QHFHVVDULR ULYHGHUH O·HOHQFR GHJOL H0 VWLPDWL GDO TXDOH HVWUDUUH OH WULSOH SHU OD GHFLVLRQH ILQDOH FKH VSHWWDYD DO 'XFD LQ SHUVRQD/ HEEHQH IUD L FHQWRYHQWL HVWLPDWL FRPSUHVL QHOO·HOHQFR GHO 4;7</ HUDQR VROR YHQWRWWR TXHOOL FKH JLj HUDQR FRPSUHVL QHO PHGHVLPR HOHQFR GHO 4;63/ TXLQGL OD YDULD]LRQH GHOOH SHUVRQH IX YHUDPHQWH ULOHYDQWH1 ,QROWUH QHO QXRYR HOHQFR GHJOL (VWLPDWL LO QXPHUR GHJOL LQGLYLGXL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOH IDPL0 JOLH GHO /LEUR G·2UR HUD GL WUHQWDFLQTXH VX FHQWRYHQWL/ TXLQGL LQIHULRUH DO 63(1 2YYLDPHQWH OH UDJLRQL GL TXHVWR LPSRUWDQWH PXWDPHQWR ULPDQJRQR WXWWH GD LQGDJDUH/ GL FHUWR TXHVWD GHFLVLRQH VL SUHVHQWD FRPH XQ SULPR VHJQDOH GL QRYLWj QHOOD VWUXWWXUD GHO SRWHUH SROLWLFR GHOOD FDSLWDOH/ FRQVHJXHQ]D GHO SXU OHQWR PXWDPHQWR GHOOD VRFLHWj PRGHQHVH DYYHQXWR LQ TXHJOL DQQL1 6X QRYDQWD FRQVLJOLHUL QRPLQDWL QHOO·XOWLPR SHULRGR GL JRYHUQR HVWHQVH JOL HVSRQHQWL OD QRELOWj RFFXSDURQR PHQR GL TXDUDQWD VHJJL/ GLPLQXHQGR LQ PRGR VHQVLELOH OD ORUR SUHVHQ]D1 ,O PXWDPHQWR GHJOL XRPLQL DOOD JXLGD GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD DYYHQQH WUDPLWH XQ ULFDPELR JHQHUD]LRQDOH FKH FRLQFLVH FRQ O·LQJUHVVR QHO QRYHUR GHL FRQVLJOLHUL GL XQ PDJJLRU QXPHUR GL LQGLYLGXL DOORUD GHILQLWL ´FLWWDGLQLµ/ L TXD0 OL GHWHUPLQDURQR XQR VSRVWDPHQWR GHOO·DVVH SROLWLFR YHUVR XQD SRVL]LRQH FRQVHUYDWULFH PRGHUDWD/ DWWHQWD DL PXWDPHQWL SROLWLFL H VRFLDOL LQ DWWR QHO FRQWLQHQWH/ QHOOD SHQLVROD HG LQ FLWWj1 *OL DYYHQLPHQWL GHO 4;8< QRQ WURYDURQR FHUWR LPSUHSDUDWL L JRYHUQDQWL GHO 'XFDWR FKH/ FRPH HUD DFFDGXWR DOWUH YROWH LQ SUHFHGHQ]D/ VL UDVVHJQDUR0 QR DG DEEDQGRQDUH OD FDSLWDOH QHOOD VSHUDQ]D GL ULWRUQDUYL TXDQWR SULPD DO VHJXLWR GHOOH WUXSSH DXVWULDFKH1 4XHVWH VSHUDQ]H GRYHWWHUR SHUz HVVHUH FRPSOHWDPHQWH DEEDQGRQDWH IUD LO 4;96 HG LO 4;98 H OD FODVVH GLULJHQWH ORFDOH/ FRVWDQWHPHQWH DOOD JXLGD GHOOD FLW0 Wj SHU GLYHUVL VHFROL/ GRYHWWH DFFHWWDUH OD SHUGLWD GHOOD FHQWUDOLWj SROLWLFD HG HFRQRPLFD GL 0RGHQD VXL WHUULWRUL H[ HVWHQVL H OD SHUGLWD GHO UXROR GL qOLWH GL0 ULJHQWH GL XQD/ SXU SLFFROD/ FDSLWDOH451 0ROWH IDPLJOLH GHOOD QRELOWj PRGHQHVH VHJXLURQR LO 'XFD QHOO·HVLOLR/ DOWUH SXU QRQ DEEDQGRQDQGR OD FLWWj ULPDVHUR IHGHOL DL YDORUL GHOOD PRQDUFKLD H GHOOD UHOLJLRQH DQFRUD D OXQJR/ EHQ ROWUH RJQL UDJLRQHYROH SUHYLVLRQH1 ²²²²²²²² 45 3HU O*DSSURIRQGLPHQWR GHOOH ULIOHVVLRQL UHODWLYH DO SHULRGR VXFFHVVLYR LO 4;8< KR XWLOL]0 ]DWR L ULVXOWDWL GHOOD ULFHUFD SXEEOLFDWL QHO VDJJLR= &1 0$/$*2/,/ &HWR GLULJHQWH PXQLFLSDOH H UDS0 SUHVHQWDQ]D SROLWLFD +4;8<04<<8,/ LQ $O *RYHUQR GHO &RPXQH 111FLW1/ SS144504561
;;5
&HVDUH 0DODJROL
$OFXQL HVSRQHQWL GHOOH IDPLJOLH ULPDVWH LQ FLWWj PDQWHQQHUR YLYL L YDORUL VRFLDOL H FXOWXUDOL GHJOL DXVWURHVWHQVL LQ PRGR FRUDJJLRVR H FRHUHQWH/ GHFL0 GHQGR GL DFFHWWDUH OD VILGD FKH OR VYLOXSSR GHJOL DYYHQLPHQWL LPSRVH ORUR/ IRUWL GHOOH GLIILFROWj FUHDWH DOOD VRFLHWj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j FROODERUDWR FRQ JOL HVSRQHQWL GHO FHWR FLWWDGLQR QHL FRQVLJOL H IUD L FRQVHUYDWRUL QRPLQDWL GD )UDQFHVFR 9 H FRQRVFHYDQR SHU0 IHWWDPHQWH L PHFFDQLVPL GHO JRYHUQR ORFDOH1 /·HTXLOLEULR SROLWLFR H VRFLDOH PDWXUDWR QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH HUD GH0 ILQLWLYDPHQWH WUDPRQWDWR/ PD O·DIIHUPD]LRQH GHO JUXSSR OLEHUDOH PRGHUDWR QRQ GHWHUPLQz O·HVFOXVLRQH D SULRUL GHL VRVWHQLWRUL GHJOL DXVWURHVWHQVL> LQ UHDO0 Wj L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOH QRELOL FDVDWH PRGHQHVL ULSUHVHUR D FRPSDULUH IUD L FRQVLJOLHUL FRPXQDOL FRQ VHPSUH PDJJLRU IUHTXHQ]D FRQ LO SDVVDUH GHJOL DQQL1 'L FHUWR JLj QHO 4;96 WUH UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOO·DOD FRQVHUYDWULFH DULVWRFUDWLFD VL FDQGLGDURQR DOOH HOH]LRQL FRPXQDOL/ IUD HVVL YHQQH HOHWWR LO &RQWH &ODXGLR %HQWLYRJOLR/ JLj PLQLVWUR GL )UDQFHVFR 9 H LO 0DUFKHVH /RGRYLFR &RFFDSDQL ,PSHULDOL ULVXOWz LO SULPR GHL QRQ HOHWWL/ SRFKL DQQL GRSR QHOOD WRUQDWD HOHWWR0 UDOH GHO 4;9; LO &RQWH 7HRGRUR %D\DUG 'H 9ROR ULVXOWz LO SULPR GHL QRQ HOHW0 WL/ YHUUj SRL HOHWWR QHO 4;:61 2FFRUUH DOWUHVu WHQHUH SUHVHQWH FKH DOFXQL QRELOL DYHYDQR SDUWHFLSDWR DL PRWL ULVRUJLPHQWDOL GHO ¶64 H GHO ¶7; = QRELOWj QRQ IX VLQRQLPR GL UHD]LRQH/ DQFKH DOO·LQWHUQR GHO FHWR DULVWRFUDWLFR HVLVWHYDQR GLYLVLRQL H FRQWUDVWL/ QRQ VWXSLVFH SHUFLz WURYDUH QHOO·HOHQFR GHL TXDUDQWD FRQVLJOLHUL FRPXQDOL HOHWWL QHO VHWWHPEUH GHO 4;8</ TXLQGL QHO PRPHQWR GL PDJJLRU WHQVLRQH SROLWLFD/ VHWWH LQGLYLGXL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHO FHWR VRFLDOH OHJDWR DO SDVVDWR UHJLPH HVWHQVH/ LQROWUH QRQ D FDVR LO SULPR 3RGHVWj GHO JRYHUQR )DULQL IX LO &RQWH 9DOHULR 6DOLPEHQL HG LO SULPR UDSSUHVHQWDQWH GL 0RGHQD FLWWj DO 3DUODPHQWR QD]LRQDOH IX LO 0DUFKHVH *LXVHSSH &DPSRUL1
&RPXQLWj/ QRELOWj H ERUJKHVLD QHO SHULRGR DXVWURHVWHQVH
;;6
/·DPDOJDPD PRGHUDWR SRVW0XQLWDULR DO JRYHUQR GHO SDHVH QRQ YROOH IDUH FRPSOHWDPHQWH D PHQR GL FKL/ WUDPLWH XQD OXQJD WUDGL]LRQH IDPLOLDUH/ DYHYD GD VHPSUH JHVWLWR LO SRWHUH SROLWLFR H FXOWXUDOH LQ FLWWj/ WXWWDYLD JOL VSD]L GL PHGLD]LRQH H GL FROODERUD]LRQH DOOD JHVWLRQH GHOOD FRVD SXEEOLFD/ VRSUDWWXWWR LQ VHJXLWR DOOD SUHVD GL 5RPD HG DOO·DYYHQWR DO SRWHUH GHOOD 6LQLVWUD SDUODPHQ0 WDUH/ ULFKLHVHUR LQHOXWWDELOPHQWH DOOD ID]LRQH QRELOLDUH LO VRVWDQ]LDOH ULFRQR0 VFLPHQWR GHOOR VWDWR QD]LRQDOH H O·DEEDQGRQR GHILQLWLYR GL RJQL QRVWDOJLD GHO SDVVDWR1
,/ ',5,772 ( /*(&2120,$
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;;:
0$5&2 &$9,1$
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
0DQFD/ D WXWW·RJJL/ O·XQLFR VROLGR IRQGDPHQWR SHU XQD VHULD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD SURGRWWD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 0DQFD/ FLRq/ XQD UL0 JRURVD UHSHUWRULD]LRQH GHOOH IRQWL H PDQFD XQD VXIILFLHQWH SURVRSRJUDILD= VHQ]D GL HVVH 0 D PLR PRGR GL YHGHUH 0 TXDOVLDVL SXU DFXWD LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH FRPSOHVVLYD VDUHEEH YL]LDWD QHOOH UDGLFL41 6H QRQ FL VL YRJOLD OLPLWDUH D FRPSRUUH LPSUREDELOL H VRJJHWWLYL IORULOHJL DJLRJUDILFL/ VL GRYUj SRUWDUH DYDQWL XQ·LQGDJLQH D WDSSHWR/ DQFKH LQ GLUH]LRQH GHL ULFFKLVVLPL IRQGL GL IDPLJOLD1 6SHFLH SHU LO ¶:33 H O·1¶;33 GL QXPHURVL JLXUL0 VSHULWL FL q ULPDVWR O·LQWHUR DUFKLYLR1 5LFRUGLDPR/ DG HVHPSLR/ OH FDUWH ULFFKLV0 VLPH GL %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL/ PD DQFKH TXHOOH GHL 9DOGULJKL/ GL 7HRGRUR %D0 \DUG GH 9ROR/ GL %LDJLR &DVROL/ GL *LXVHSSH &DVVLDQL ,QJRQL/ GL *LXVHSSH /XJOL/ GL 0DUF·$QWRQLR 3DUHQWL/ GL /XLJL 9LDQL151 0ROWL DOWUL IRQGL VL SRWUHEEH0 UR DQFRUD PHQ]LRQDUH/ PD q XQ TXDGUR FKH SRWUj ULVHUYDUH QXRYH VRUSUHVH1 6L SHQVL DOOD YLFHQGD GHOO·DUFKLYLR GHL *DODIDVL/ IDPLJOLD FKH DQQRYHUz GLYHUVL JLXULVWL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR HVWHQVH= XQR GL HVVL SUHVWz XQ FRQWULEXWR GHWHUPLQDQWH DOOD GHILQL]LRQH GHOOD SDUWH FULPLQDOLVWLFD GHOOD FRQVROLGD]LRQH GHO 4::461 ²²²²²²²² 4
3HU TXDQWR PL ULJXDUGD KR WHQWDWR GL LPSRVWDUH XQD SULPD ULFRJQL]LRQH GHOOD WUDWWDWLVWL0 FD JLXULGLFD/ HGLWD H LQHGLWD/ GHOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ PD SHU L GXH VHFROL SUH0 FHGHQWL WXWWR/ R TXDVL/ UHVWD DQFRUD GD IDUH1 &IU1 01 &$9,1$/ ,O SRWHUH GHO SDGUH1 ,,1 /D VFXROD JLXULGLFD HVWHQVH H OD SURPR]LRQH GHOOD SDWULD SRVWHVWj QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD +4;4704;8<,/ 0LODQR/ 4<<8/ SS1 936094;1 5 Ë VWUXPHQWR HVVHQ]LDOH/ DQFKH VH QRQ HVDXVWLYR/ LO UHSHUWRULR qGLWR GDOO·XIILFLR FHQWUDOH SHU L EHQL DUFKLYLVWLFL $UFKLYL GL IDPLJOLH H GL SHUVRQH1 0DWHULDOL SHU XQD JXLGD/ ,/ 5RPD/ 4<<4/ >(PL0 OLD05RPDJQD@ SS1 9;04591 6 /·DUFKLYLR *DODIDVL FRQIOXu LQ TXHOOR GHL 0DQXGRUL= QHL JLRUQL GHO FRQYHJQR VX ©0RGH0 QD FDSLWDOHª VL WURYDYD DQFRUD SUHVVR JOL XOWLPL GLVFHQGHQWL RJJL UHVLGHQWL D 9LDUHJJLR/ PD GRYUHEEH HVVHUH SUHVWR IUXLELOH QHOO·DUFKLYLR GL 0RGHQD R LQ TXHOOR GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD1
;;;
0DUFR &DYLQD
2FFRUUHUHEEH/ FLRq/ UHFXSHUDUH OD FRPSOHVVLWj GHOOH IRQWL0 HGLWH H LQHGLWH 0 QHOOD ORUR PROWHSOLFLWj H QHOOH ORUR UHFLSURFKH FRQIOXHQ]H HG LQIOXHQ]H1 6ROR LQ TXHVWR PRGR VL SRWUDQQR SRUUH OH EDVL SHU XQD VFLHQWLILFD LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GHOOD PRUIRORJLD H GHOO·LQWLPR VLJLOOR GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 'RSR VLIIDWR DXVSLFLR GH LXUH FRQGHQGR/ YHGLDPR LQ EUHYL WUDWWL FRVD RJJL VLDPR LQ JUDGR GL LQWUDYHGHUH VXOOH OLQHH HVVHQ]LDOL GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD H0 VWHQVH QHL GXHFHQWRFLQTXDQW·DQQL LQ FXL 0RGHQD IX FDSLWDOH GHO GXFDWR1 $Q]LWXWWR q OHFLWR GRPDQGDUVL VH HVLVWD XQD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD TXDOLILFDELOH FRPH ¶HVWHQVH·/ PXQLWD GL XQD VSHFLILFLWj WDOH FKH OD TXDOLILFKL QHO FRQWHVWR LWDOLDQR HG HXURSHR/ VLD SXUH DOO·LQWHUQR GL FRRUGLQDWH FKH FHUWR QRQ IXURQR GL FUHD]LRQH DXWRFWRQD1 3UHQGLDPR GXQTXH OH PRVVH GDO &LQTXHFHQWR1 ,O ;9, VHFROR GL )HUUDUD0FDSLWDOH IX SL• ULFFR GL LPSRUWDQWL JLXULVWL PRGH0 QHVL0UHJJLDQL FKH QRQ L GXH VHFROL VXFFHVVLYL1 6RQR PROWL L SHUVRQDJJL GL ULOLH0 YR/ VSHVVR LQ FRPSOHVVD GLDOHWWLFD FRQ JOL (VWHQVL H FRQ OR 6WXGLR GXFDOH71 6L SHQVL DOO·HVHPSODUH LWLQHUDULR FXOWXUDOH H SURIHVVLRQDOH GHO UHJJLDQR &DUOR 5XLQL/ XQR GHL SL• LPSRUWDQWL JLXULVWL GHO &LQTXHFHQWR= JOL VWXGL D )HUUDUD/ LO GRWWRUDWR D 3LVD/ XQD GRFHQ]D HUUDERQGD SHU WUHQW·DQQL IUD 3LVD/ )HUUDUD/ 3D0 YLD H 3DGRYD/ PD ILQDOPHQWH O·DSLFH DFFDGHPLFR GHOOD FDUULHUD FRQ O·DVVXQ]LRQH YHQWHQQDOH GHOOD SULPD FDWWHGUD ERORJQHVH GL GLULWWR/ FRQVHUYDWD VLQR DOOD PRUWH >4863@1 (· VLJQLILFDWLYR FKH LO 5XLQL ² D GLIIHUHQ]D FKH SHU OH YDULH VHGL SUHFHGHQWL 0 VL WUDVIHULVVH GHILQLWLYDPHQWH D %RORJQD LQVLHPH DOOD VXD IDPLJOLD/ FKH VL ¶ERORJQHVL]]HUj· H FKH QHO FRUVR GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ JUD]LH DOO·HQRUPH SDWULPRQLR DFFXPXODWR GDO JLXULVWD/ VL QRELOLWHUj HG HQWUHUj QHO QzYHUR GHO SDWUL]LDWR IHOVLQHR1 (G DQDORJDPHQWH DO 5XLQL PLUHUDQQR DOOD ER0 ORJQHVL]]D]LRQH L VXRL GXH DOOLHYL UHJJLDQL *LURODPR 3UHYLGHOOL H *LXOLR 6FDU0 ODWWLQL81 ²²²²²²²² 7
,Q JHQHUDOH FIU1 )1 %256(7786/ +LVWRULDH $OPL )HUUDULDH *\PQDVLL/ ,,/ )HUUDULDH/ 4:68> *1 6(&&2 68$5'2/ /R 6WXGLR GL )HUUDUD D WXWWR LO ;9 VHFROR1 ,QGDJLQL >«@ FRUUHGDWH GD GRFXPHQWL LQHGLWL/ LQ ©$WWL GHOOD GHSXWD]LRQH SURYLQFLDOH >IHUUDUHVH@ GL VWRULD SDWULDª V1 ,/ 9+4;<7,/ SS1 5805<7> *1 3$5',/ /R 6WXGLR GL )HUUDUD QHL VHFROL ;9 H ;9, FRQ GRFXPHQWL LQHGLWL/ )HUUDUD/ 4<36 +ULVW1 DQDVWDW1 %RORJQD/ 4<:5,> $1 9,6&217,/ /D VWRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL )HUUDUD/ %RORJQD/ 4<83> $1 )5$1&(6&+,1,/ 1XRYL GRFXPHQWL UHODWLYL DL GRFHQWL GHOOR 6WXGLR GL )HUUDUD QHO VHF1 ;9,/ )HUUDUD/ 4<:3> /1 3(3(/ /D FXOWXUD VFLHQWLILFD H O·8QLYHUVLWj/ LQ ©6WRULD LOOXVWUDWD GL )HUUDUDª/ ,,/ D FXUD GL )1 %2&&+,/ 0LODQR/ 4<;:/ SS1 93<0957> ©,Q VXSUHPH GLJQLWDWLVª1 3HU OD VWRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL )HUUDUD1 46<404<<4/ D FXUD GL 31 &$67(//,/ )LUHQ]H/ 4<<81 8 &IU1 01 &$9,1$/ &DUOR 5XLQL1 8QD ¶DXWRULWj· GHO GLULWWR FRPXQH IUD 5HJJLR (PLOLD H %RORJQD/ IUD ;9 H ;9, VHFROR/ 0LODQR/ 4<<;1
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;;<
1HO ¶833 ² TXDQWRPHQR SHU LO GLULWWR ² OD JHRJUDILD XQLYHUVLWDULD HPLOLDQD VL SUHVHQWD DUWLFRODWD/ PD WXWWD RUELWDQWH LQWRUQR DOO·DWHQHR ERORJQHVH/ FKH SXUH ² DOPHQR GRSR OD PHWj GHO VHFROR ² QRQ FRQREEH FHUWR XQR GHL VXRL SHULRGL PLJOLRUL91 3DUH/ WXWWDYLD/ GLIILFLOH ULFRQRVFHUH XQ TXLG HVWHQVH QHO FRQWHVWR GHOOD FXOWXUD GL LXV FRPPXQH/ GL FXL YHQQHUR ULVSHFFKLDWH OH YDULH DQLPH QHO PLFURFRVPR GXFDOH1 /LPLWLDPRFL D TXDOFKH HVHPSLR:1 5LQDOGR &RUVL; H *XLGR 3DQFLUROL< IXURQR GLVFHSROL GHOO·$OFLDWR H/ FRPH ²²²²²²²² 9
6XOOD ©JHRJUDILDª H VXOOD WLSRORJLD GHJOL 6WXGL HPLOLDQR0URPDJQROL IUD ¶733 H ¶833 FIU1 01 &$9,1$/ /H 8QLYHUVLWj H OD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD/ LQ /H VHGL GHOOD FXOWXUD LQ (PLOLD05RPDJQD1 /*HSRFD GHOOH 6LJQRULH1 /H FLWWj/ D FXUD GL *1 &+,772/,1,/ 0LODQR/ 4<;9/ SS1 6407:1 : 2OWUH DJOL DXWRUL VSHFLILFDPHQWH FLWDWL/ DQFRUD SHU LO ¶833 ULFRUGLDPR $1'5($ $/%,1(//, +QDWR D 0RGHQD/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ FXUz L FRQVLOLD GHO VXR 0DHVWUR $QWRQ *DOHD]0 ]R 0DOYDVLD >48;9@,/ 3,(5 *,29$11, $1&$5$1, +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ VWXGLz D )HUUDUD/ ULFRSUu FDULFKH JLXGL]LDULH QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH >«487<«@/ SXEEOLFz )DPLOLDULXP LXULV TXDHVWLR0 QXP«>4896/ 489</ 48;3/ 48;4@,/ %$/'$66$55( %(1('(//, +IULJQDQHVH/ SXEEOLFz XQ 7UDFWD0 WXV LXULV SURWRPLVHRV >48<4/ 4933@ H $QLPDGYHUVLRQHV LQ WUDFWDWXP GH LXUH SURWRPLVHRV 3URVSHUL 5HQGHOODH >4947@,/ %$572/20(2 %(57$==2/, +QDWR D )LQDOH (PLOLD/ VWXGLz D )HUUDUD/ ULFRSUu FDULFKH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH H JLXGL]LDULH QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH/ IX GRFHQWH D )HUUDUD/ PRUu QHO 48;;/ SXEEOL0 Fz &RQVLOLD LQ PDWHULD FLYLOH H FULPLQDOH >48;6048;8@ HG XQ 7UDFWDWXV FODXVXODUXP LQVWUXPHQWDOLXP >48<;@,/ *,$0%$77,67$ %29,2 +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ VWXGLz D 3DGRYD/ DYYRFDWR/ SXEEOLFz XQ 'H VWDWXWDULD XUELV SUDHVFULSWLRQH >4897/ 489<@,/ %$572/20(2 &$5$1',1, +QDWR D 0RGHQD/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ IX GRFHQWH D 0DFHUDWD HG D 3DYLD/ PRUu QHO 4945/ SXEEOLFz 4XDHVWLRQHV GH XWURTXH LXUH >48<3@ HG DOOHJD]LRQL,/ *+(5$5'2 0$==2/, '(· /($==$5, +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PL0 OLD/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ DOOLHYR GL &DUOR 5XLQL/ ULFRSUu FDULFKH HVWHQVL H JLXGL]LDULH QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH/ IX DXGLWRUH GL URWD D )LUHQ]H/ PRUu GRSR LO 48;7/ SXEEOLFz &RQVLOLD >4887/ 489;/ 48:9@ HG DOPHQR XQD VXD 'HFLVLR >4884@,/ $&+,//( 3(5621$/, +QDWR D 0LUDQGROD/ SXEEOLFz 7UDFWDWXV WUHV/ VFLOLFHW GH DGLSLVFHQGD SRVVHVVLRQH >48:5@ H &RURQD TXDHVWLRQXP FLYLOLXP HW FULPLQDOLXP >48<9@,/ )5$1&(6&2 3(5621$/, +QDWR D 0LUDQGROD/ DXGLWRUH H SRGHVWj SUHVVR L *RQ]DJD/ SXEEOLFz 4XDHVWLRQHV SUDFWLFDQWLEXV QHFHVVDULDH >48;8@/ 'H LXGLFLLV HW WRUWXUD HW TXDHVWLRQLEXV FXP WUDFW1 GH JDEHOOLV >48;8@ H &RQVLOLD FLYLOLD HW FULPLQDOLD >48<3@,/ *,$0%$77,67$ 3,*1$ +QDWR IRUVH D )D0 QDQR/ GRFHQWH D )HUUDUD/ ULFRSUu YDULH FDULFKH QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH/ SXEEOLFz WUDWWDWL VXO GXHOOR H VXOOH SDFL SULYDWH,/ %(51$5',12 6&2'2%,2 +QDWR D 0RGHQD/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ DOOLHYR GHOO·$OFLDWR/ SXEEOLFz ,Q $XWKHQWLFDP &1 QH ILOLXV SUR SDWUH >487;@,/ *,$0%$77,67$ 686,2 +QDWR D 0LUDQGROD/ VWXGLz PHGLFLQD/ SXEEOLFR 7UH OLEUL GHOO·LQJLXVWLWLD GHO GXHOOR H GL FRORUR FKH OR SHUPHWWR0 QR >4888@ H &RQVLOLD >4894@,1 6X TXHVWL DXWRUL VL YHGD DQ]LWXWWR *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD «FLW1/ 4/ SS1 <6/ <;0<</ 5460547/ 58<0594/ 6730674> 6/ SS1 4<604<8> 7/ SS1 <5/ 4650488> 8/ SS1 9<0 :3/ 47904881 ; 'L &RUUHJJLR/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ ULFRSUHQGR SRL YDULH FDULFKH/ FRUWLJLDQR/ PD DQFKH HF0 FOHVLDVWLFR/ PRUu LQWRUQR DO 48;51 6X GL OXL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 5/ SS1 4840 498> *1 520(,/ &RUVR +0DFRQH, 5LQDOGR/ LQ ©'L]LRQDULR ELRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQLª/ 5</ 5RPD/
;<3
0DUFR &DYLQD
OXL/ IDXWRUL GL XQ SL• VWUHWWR UDSSRUWR GHJOL VWXGL JLXULGLFL FRQ TXHOOL XPDQLVWL0 FL H ILORORJLFL1 ,Q &DUOR 5XLQL H QHL VXRL GXH SULQFLSDOL DOOLHYL *LURODPR 3UHYL0 GHOOL43 H *LXOLR 6FDUODWWLQL44/ LQ XQ )XOYLR 3DFFLDQL45 RG LQ XQ 8EHUWLQR =XF0 FDUGL46 q/ LQYHFH/ HYLGHQWH O·RS]LRQH SHU OD WUDGL]LRQDOH PHWRGRORJLD GHO PRV ²²²²²²²² 4<;6/ SS1 9;:09<31 )X DXWRUH GL DGGLWLRQHV DL FRQVLOLD GL 2OGUDGR GD 3RQWH H GL XQ LQWHUHVVDQWH H IRUWXQDWR WUDWWDWHOOR VXOOH ¶SULYDWH UDSSDFLILFD]LRQL·/ PD LO VXR VSLULWR XPDQLVWLFR VL DIIHUPD FRQ FKLDUH]]D LQ 5DLQDOGXV &RUVXV/ ,QGDJDWLRQXP LXULV OLEUL ,,,/ 9HQHWLLV/ 489;/ RYH ULFKLDPD D SL• ULSUHVH O·LQVHJQDPHQWR DOFLDWHR +FIU1 DG HVHPSLR SS1 45/ 56,1 < 6XOOD ILJXUD LPSRUWDQWH H QRWLVVLPD GL *XLGR 3DQFLUROL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD « FLW1/ 7/ SS1 70531 5LFRUGLDPR SHU LQFLGHQV FKH DQFKH LO SDGUH GL *XLGR/ $OEHUWR/ IX JLXULVWD GL TXDOFKH YDORUH +FIU1 LELGHP/ 7/ SS1 406,1 43 1RWR VRSUDWWXWWR SHU XQ WUDWWDWR VXL SUREOHPL JLXULGLFL VROOHYDWL GDOOD SHVWH/ IX GRFHQWH D %RORJQD H ILJXUD GL SULPR SLDQR QHOOD TXHVWLRQH GHO ¶GLYRU]LR· GL (QULFR 9,,, G·,QJKLOWHUUD1 0RUu WUDJLFDPHQWH QHO 48671 &IU1 *XLGR 3$1=,52/86/ 'H FODULV OHJXP LQWHUSUHWLEXV OLEUL TXDWXRU/ /LSVLDH/ 4:54 +ULVW1 DQDVWDW1 0HLVHQKHLP2*ODQ/ 4<9;,/ SS1 59:059;> *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWH0 FD«FLW1/ 7/ SS1 5650567> 31 )217$1(6,/ 6XSSOHPHQWR DOOD %LEOLRWHFD 0RGHQHVH GHO 7LUDERVFKL SHU FLz FKH ULJXDUGD JOL VFULWWRUL UHJJLDQL WUDWWR GDL PDQRVFULWWL GL 3URVSHUR )RQWDQHVL H GHO &RQWH $FKLOOH &UHVSL DJJLXQWRYL TXDOFKH DQQRWD]LRQH H FRUUH]LRQH GD *LXVHSSH 7XUUL/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 4;:6/ SS1 <60<7> 01 $6&+(5,/ , JLXULVWL H OH HSLGHPLH GL SHVWH +VHFROL ;,90;9,,/ 6LHQD/ 4<<:/ SS1 48:04;3/ PD SS1 4:60 4:9> 01 &$9,1$/ &DUOR 5XLQL«FLW1 44 )X WUD L SULPL FLQTXH XGLWRUL GHOOD URWD ERORJQHVH IRQGDWD GD 3DROR ,,, QHO 48681 $S0 SUH]]DWR UHGDWWRUH GL FRQVLOLD/ RSHUz QHOOD YLWD SXEEOLFD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ GRYH IX DJJUHJDWR DO &ROOHJLR GHL GRWWRUL/ JLXGLFL H DYYRFDWL GDOO·; IHEEUDLR 484:1 3DUH IRVVH GRFHQWH GL GLULWWR FD0 QRQLFR SHU XQ DQQR >4878@ D 3DGRYD/ PD GL VLFXUR ULHQWUz H VL VWDELOu GHILQLWLYDPHQWH D %ROR0 JQD/ DFTXLVHQGRQH OD FLWWDGLQDQ]D LO 48 OXJOLR 4878/ VSRVDQGRYL &RVWDQ]D ILJOLD GHO JLXULVWD -DFRSR )DVDQLQL HG LQILQH PRUHQGRYL LO 56 JLXJQR GHO 48:71 6XOOR 6FDUODWWLQL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 8/ SS1 9909;> *1 )$178==,/ 1RWL]LH GHJOL VFULWWRUL ERORJQHVL 9,,/ %R0 ORJQD/ 4:;</ SS1 6840688> 01 &$9,1$/ &DUOR 5XLQL«FLW1 45 6X GL OXL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 6/ SS1 73607461 0RGHQHVH ULFRSUu YDULH FDULFKH SUHVVR L *RQ]DJD GL 6DEELRQHWD/ IX GRFHQWH D )HUUDUD/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD HVWHQVH/ JRYHUQDWRUH GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ XGLWRUH URWDOH D *HQRYD/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL VHJQDWXUD HVWHQVH/ FD0 SLWDQR GL JLXVWL]LD D 6LHQD1 3XEEOLFz YDULH RSHUH/ IUD OH TXDOL OD SL• IDPRVD IX LQGXEELDPHQWH LO VXR 7UDFWDWXV GH SUREDWLRQLEXV/ PD ULFRUGLDPR DOPHQR XQ 7UDFWDWXV GH DSSHOODWLRQLEXV HG XQD UDFFROWD GL &RQVLOLD1 1HL 497 UHVSRQVL LYL SXEEOLFDWL O·LPSRUWDQ]D GHL FRPPLWWHQWL HYLGHQ]LD OD QRWHYROH IDPD GHO 3DFFLDQL +FIU1 )XOYLXV 3DFLDQXV/ &RQVLOLD/ UHVSRQVD/ UHODWLRQHV/ HW DOOHJDWLRQHV LX0 ULV= DGGLWLV SOHUXPTXH UHEXV LXGLFDWLV/ DXW WUDQVDFWLV/ $XJXVWDH/ 4938,1 46 (UD GL &RUUHJJLR/ FLWWDGLQD HVWHUQD/ LQ TXHO WHPSR/ DOOR VSD]LR JLXULGLFR HVWHQVH1 6WXGLz D %RORJQD/ VSHFLH FRQ *LRYDQQL &URWWR/ IX GRFHQWH D )HUUDUD H PRUu QHO 48741 'L OXL UHVWDQR= &RQVLOLD >48<8@/ 5HSHWLWLRQHV >4886@/ 7UDFWDWXV GH PLVVLRQH LQ SRVVHVVLRQHP >4866@/ $UGXD HW VXEWLOLD FRPPHQWDULD VXSHU O1 ILQ1 GH HGLFWR $GULDQL >486:/ 48;:@1 &IU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 8/ SS1 768076<1
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;<4
LWDOLFXV/ FROWD QHOOD VXD HYROX]LRQH SUDJPDWLFD FLQTXHFHQWHVFD1 3URSULR QHOOD ORUR DWWLYLVVLPD SUDVVL FRQVLOLDUH SUHQGH FRUSR D SL• ULSUHVH XQD GHWWDJOLDWD YLVXDOL]]D]LRQH GHOOD VRFLHWj GHO GXFDWR VXE VSHFLH LXULV1 6DUj TXHVW·XOWLPR ILORQH SUDWLFLVWD0JLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOH D FRVWLWXLUH OD FLIUD VWLOLVWLFD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD PRGHQHVH QHL VXFFHVVLYL FHQWRFLQTXDQW·DQQL1 1HL VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,, O·HVSHULHQ]D HVWHQVH VL FROORFD LQ XQ VLVWHPD GL LXV FRPPXQH JLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOL]]DWR/ FKH VL HYROYH FRUDOPHQWH VXOO·RQGD GHOOD SUDV0 VL FRQVLOLDUH H JLXGL]LDOH1 1RQ q TXHOOR LO WHPSR GHOOH JUDQGL LQGLYLGXDOLWj GL JLXULVWL/ PHQWUH LO VHQVR GHOOH SHFXOLDULWj ORFDOL SRWUj FRPSUHQGHUVL HVDWWD0 PHQWH VROR DO SUH]]R GL TXHOOR VFDYR SURVRSRJUDILFR GL FXL KR SULPD SDUODWR H FKH DQFRUD PDQFD1 8Q UDSLGR VSRJOLR GHL SULQFLSDOL UHSHUWRUL GHOO·HUXGL]LRQH ORFDOH SXz GDUFL XQD SULPD DSSURVVLPDWLYD LGHD GHOO·DQWURSRORJLD GHO JLXULVWD HVWHQVH GHO ¶9331 )XURQR XRPLQL FKH VRYHQWH QRQ HEEHUR LQ JUDQGH SUHJLR O·DWWLYLWj GRFHQ0 WH1 1H ULFRUGLDPR L UHLWHUDWL DEEDQGRQL GHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR XQLYHUVLWDULR SHU VHJXLUH OD FDUULHUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD/ DQFKH SRVWHULRUPHQWH DOOD ¶ULIRQGD]LRQH· GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj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²²²²²²²² 47 3HU WXWWL FIU1 %1 '21$7,/ /·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD QHO 6HLFHQWR DL WHPSL GHO 0XUDWRUL GLVFHSROR/ 0RGHQD/ 4<68 +VL YHGD LQ SDUWLFRODUH >S1 99@ LO ULILXWR GHOOD OHWWXUD GL ,QVWLWXWD GD SDUWH GL *LDPEDWWLVWD %RFFDEDGDWL SHU VHJXLUH OD FDUULHUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD,>&1*1 0250 31 ', 3,(752/ 6WRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD/ ,0,,/ )LUHQ]H/ 4<:81 48 'L &DVWHOQXRYR GL *DUIDJQDQD/ DYYRFDWR H FRQVLJOLHUH GXFDOH/ PRUu QHO 49:71 3XEEOLFz 5HVROXWLRQHV IRUHQVHV/ ULqGLWH SL• YROWH1 &IU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 4/ S1 4481 49 0RGHQHVH/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD H GLYHQQH VHJUHWDULR H FRQVLJOLHUH GL VWDWR/ PRUu QHO 49;81 3XEEOLFz &RQVXOWDWLRQHV IRUHQVHV1 &IU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 4/ S1 7581 4: &DUSLJLDQR/ VWXGLz D &DUSL/ IX JLXGLFH H SRL VHJXu VRSUDWWXWWR OD FDUULHUD HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ PRUu QHO 4983 +FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 5/ SS1 5:05;,1 2JQL SUREOHPD JLXULGLFR GLVFXVVR WUDH RULJLQDWR GD XQD YHUWHQ]D OHJDOH FKH YLGH O·DXWRUH/ D TXDOFKH WLWROR/ SURWDJRQL0 VWD= OR VWHVVR LQFLSLW OR LQGLFD VSHVVR FRQ FKLDUH]]D +,Q XQD >FDXVD@ &DUSHQVL >« @/ ,Q TXDGDP FDXVD 0DQWXDQD >«@/ ,Q XQD VD[ROHQVL >«@= FIU1 ,R1 %DSWLVWD &LDUOLQXV/ &RQWURYHUVLDUXP IRUHQVLXP LXGLFLR0
;<5
0DUFR &DYLQD
SDUHUL JLXULGLFL 0 EUHYH PD DVVDL LQWHUHVVDQWH 0 GL %DUWRORPHR *DWWL/ VHJUHWDULR GL VWDWR4;1 (· RSHUD QRWHYROH/ TXDQWRPHQR FRPH GRFXPHQWR GL XQ·HSRFD/ GL XQD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD IRUJLDWD HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH GD JLXULVWL0IXQ]LRQDUL4</ HG RO0 WUHWXWWR q TXDVL XQD UDFFROWD FROOHWWLYD/ VH VL FRQVLGHUL FKH VX 63 FRQVLOLD GXH VRQR GL *LDPEDWWLVWD /DGHUFKL53 H FLQTXH GL *LURODPR $XJXVWRQL54/ HQWUDPEL LPSRUWDQWL DPPLQLVWUDWRUL GXFDOL1 'LVGHJQDYDQR/ GXQTXH/ O·HODERUD]LRQH WHRULFD1 $ TXHVWR SURSRVLWR YDOX0 WLDPR TXDOFKH HOHPHQWR TXDQWLWDWLYR551 'HL JLXULVSHULWL DWWLYL QHO 'XFDWR GHO ²²²²²²²² UXP/ ,0,,/ 9HQHWLLV/ 496:0497:1 6HJQDOLDPR SHU LQFLGHQV +LELGHP/ ,/ >FDS1 63@ S1 4<4,= ©HW KDHF IXLW SULPD FDXVD LQ TXD SRVW ODXUHDP GRFWRUDWXV FRQVXOXL HW UHTXLVLWXV GX[Lª1 4; 'L &DVWHOODUDQR/ DYYRFDWR/ FRQVXOWRUH GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD/ FRQVLJOLHUH H VHJUHWDULR GL VWDWR/ PRUu QHO 49;41 3XEEOLFz VRSUDWWXWWR XQD UDFFROWD GL &RQVLOLD1 &IU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 5/ S1 6;41 /H UDFFROWH FRQVLOLDUL GL )LOLSSR &DVWDOGL H GL %DUWRORPHR *DWWL IXURQR qGLWH D FXUD GL *LRYDQQL *DOOLDQL >P1 4:44@/ DGGRWWRUDWR D 3DUPD/ FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD/ FRQVLJOLHUH H VHJUHWDULR GL VWDWR QHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH +FIU1 %1 '21$7,/ /·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD«FLW1/ SS1 ;70;8,1 4< %DUWKRORPDHXV *$7786/ &RQVLOLD/ 3DUPDH/ 49;;1 ,O VXR PHWRGR FRQVLOLDUH VL IRQGD VX GL XQ·DUWLFRODWD GLVFXVVLRQH GHOOH ¶DXWRULWj· GRWWULQDOL H JLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOL/ YDOXWDWH GHWWDJOLDWD0 PHQWH LQ DSSRVLWL ¶SDUDJUDIL·1 53 &IU1 %DUWKRORPDHXV *$7786/ &RQVLOLD«FLW1/ >FF1 4;04<@ SS1 6:;07981 ,O /DGHUFKL QDFTXH DG ,PROD/ PD VWXGLz H GLYHQQH GRFHQWH GL GLULWWR D )HUUDUD ² DXWRUH GL 5HVSRQVD LXULV SXEEOLFD0 WL QHOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH QHO 4933 0/ IX VHJUHWDULR GXFDOH H PRUu QHO 494;1 &IU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 6/ SS1 8;0981 54 &IU1 %DUWKRORPDHXV *$7786/ &RQVLOLD«FLW1/ >FF1 5705;@ SS1 8670935= L SULPL WUH SDUHUL ULJXDUGDQR OD WXWHOD GHL GLULWWL HVWHQVL VX &RPDFFKLR/ LO Q1 5: q GLUHWWR FRQWUR XQD VHQWHQ]D GHOOD URWD GL 0DFHUDWD/ LO Q1 5; FRQFHUQH OD QRELOWj GHOOD VXD VWHVVD IDPLJOLD H OD TXDOLILFD GL ¶FLWWj· SHU &RUUHJJLR1 'L TXHVW·XOWLPD O·$XJXVWRQL HUD QDWLYR/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ IX FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD HG DYYRFDWR JHQHUDOH/ PRUu QHO 496<1 6X GL OXL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 4/ SS1 45304541 55 /D IRQWH VRQR DQFRUD L SULQFLSDOL UHSHUWRUL ELRJUDILFL1 2OWUH DJOL DXWRUL VSHFLILFDPHQWH FLWDWL/ DQFRUD SHU LO ¶933 ULFRUGLDPR $/(66$1'52 %(//(17$1, +QDWR D &DUSL/ VWXGLz D %R0 ORJQD/ VHJXu OD FDUULHUD HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ IX YHVFRYR/ PRUu QHO 49;5/ SXEEOLFz 6\OYXOD LXULV >498;@,/ ,332/,72 &,$5/,1, +QDWR D &DUSL/ IX QRWDLR/ SXEEOLFz 'H FDOFXOR WHUPLQRUXP IRUHQVLXP >4948@,/ &$0,//2 &5,9(//, +QDWR D 6FDQGLDQR/ IX QRWDLR H FDQFHOOLHUH GXFDOH/ SXEEOLFz 3UD[LV QRWDULR0 UXP >49<7@,/ 35263(52 )(55(77, +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ SXEEOLFz (OHQFKXV DOSKDEHWLFXP UXEUL0 FDUXP/ DF QRWDELOLXP 6WDWXWL 5HJLHQVLV FRQIHFWXV FXP EUHYL TXRGDP LXULV FLYLOLV SUDFWLFDH PHWKRGR LXGLFLDULR >4997@,/ *8,'2 )2*/,$1, 0$/&+,$9(//, +QDWR D 0RGHQD/ DYYRFDWR/ SXEEOLFz 7UDFWDWXV GH VHTXHVWUR FXP TXRGDP FRQVLOLR FXLXVGDP VLQGDFDWXV >493<@,/ *,86(33( 0$57,1(//, +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ DYYRFDWR H GRFHQWH/ PRUu QHO 4:54/ SXEEOLFz ,QHXQGDH LQVWLWXWLRQXP FLYLOLXP FDWKHGUDH SUROXVLR KDELWD 4<1 .DO1 -DQXDU1 4:39 >4:39@,/ $XUHOLR $JRVWLQR 0LDUL +QDWR D )LQDOH (PLOLD/ GR0 FHQWH OHJLVWD H SRL FDQRQLVWD SUHVVR /D 6DSLHQ]D GL 5RPD/ PRUu QHO 4:4:/ SXEEOLFz DOFXQL
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;<6
¶933 FL ULPDQJRQR D VWDPSD DOPHQR 55 RSHUH= 43 WUDWWDWL WUDGL]LRQDOL G·DUJRPHQWR URPDQLVWLFR/ 7 SUDWLFKH QRWDULOL/ 6 UDFFROWH GL GHFLVLRQHV/ 6 UDFFRO0 WH GL FRQVLOLD·/ 5 PLVFHOODQHH HQFLFORSHGLFKH1 'L TXHVWR PDWHULDOH/ SHU TXHO FKH VH QH VD/ VROR OH UDFFROWH GL GHFLVLRQHV H FRQVLOLD HEEHUR XQD TXDOFKH GLIIXVLRQH DUJRPHQWDWLYD QHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD GHO WHPSR1 3UHVFLQGLDPR RYYLDPHQWH GDO QRWLVVLPR UHSHUWRULR GL 'RPHQLFR 7RVFKL GD &DVWHOODUDQR/ OH 3UDFWLFDH FRQ0 FOXVLRQHV LXULV LQ RWWR SRQGHURVL YROXPL/ HODERUDWL D FDYDOLHUH IUD ;9, H ;9,, VHFROR561 '·DOWURQGH VH OD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD GHO ¶933 HVWHQVH QRQ IX HGLWRULDOPHQWH PROWR SUROLILFD/ DQFRU PHQR FL UHVWD RJJL GL TXHOOD GHO ¶:331 2FFRUUH/ SHUz/ VXELWR DJJLXQJHUH FKH LQ TXHVWR FDPSR L PDWHULDOL LQHGLWL VRQR LQJHQWLVVLPL HG DQFRUD PLVWHULRVL= FRGLFL GL OH]LRQL H GL FRQVLOLD VHL0VHWWHFHQWHVFKL ULSRVDQR LQHGLWL HG LQWRQVL QHJOL DUFKLYL H QHOOH ELEOLRWHFKH GHOOR VSD]LR JLXULGLFR H0 VWHQVH/ LQ DWWHVD GL HVVHUH DGHJXDWDPHQWH FDWDORJDWL H VWXGLDWL571 /D FXOWXUD FDXWDPHQWH ULIRUPLVWD H FULSWRLOOXPLQLVWD GHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO ;9,,, VHFROR IDYRUu OD IDPD GL QXPHURVL H QRWLVVLPL SHUVRQDJJL GL VWDWXUD QD]LRQDOH H JLXULGLFDPHQWH EHQ SUHSDUDWL1 0D IX XQD IDPD GRYXWD QRQ WDQWR DO ORUR VSHFLILFR FRQWULEXWR DOOD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD/ TXDQWR DOOD ORUR D]LRQH LQ0 FLVLYD HG HIILFDFH VXO FDPSR GHOOD SROLWLFD GHO GLULWWR1 ,O ULIRUPLVPR LOOXPLQDWR YHQQH YLVVXWR GDL JLXULVSHULWL HVWHQVL QHO FRQWL0 QXR H UDVVLFXUDQWH ULFKLDPR DOO·HVSHULHQ]D/ FLRq DOOD WUDGL]LRQH/ FRQ TXHVW·XOWLPD SUDJPDWLFDPHQWH PHGLDQGR1 3L• FKH FRPH JUDQGL JLXULVWL VL ²²²²²²²² FRPPHQWDUL DOOH ,VWLWX]LRQL HG DOOH 3DQGHWWH >49;:/ 49<7/ 49<:/ 4:33@,/ 25$=,2 3266,'21,2 +QDWR D 0LUDQGROD/ SXEEOLFz 7UDFWDWXV GH HPSWLRQH HW YHQGLWLRQH/ GH ORFDWLRQH HW FRQGXF0 WR >498<@,/ $/)2162 6$&&+, +QDWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ VWXGLz D %RORJQD/ IX SDUURFR H GRFHQWH GL GLULWWR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ PRUu QHO 4976/ SXEEOLFz 6\QWDJPD FDHVDUHL LXULV LQVWLWXWLRQXP >4939@/ 'H VSRQVDOLEXV/ QXSWLLV HW PDWULPRQLR >493<@ H 'H YHQDWLRQH/ SLVFDWLRQH HW DXFXSLR >4958@,/ *,$0%$77,67$ 6&$1$52/, +QDWR D 0RGHQD/ VWXGLz D 0DFHUDWD/ VHJXu OD FDUULHUD HFFOHVLDVWL0 FD/ SXEEOLFz 'H YLVLWDWLRQH FDUFHUDWRUXP >4968@,/ '20(1,&2 0$5,$ 62/,$1, +QDWR D %UHVFHOOR/ SXEEOLFz 3UDWLFD PRGHUQD GHO QRWDULDWR R IRUPXODULR G·LQVWUXPHQWL >49::@,1 6X TXHVWL DXWRUL VL YHGD DQ]LWXWWR *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 4/ SS1 4<604<8> 5/ SS1 68 / 5;405;5/ 6380639> 6/ SS1 83084/ 49</ 53;> 7/ S1 55;> 8/ SS1 73/ 46704681 56 'L &DVWHOODUDQR/ LO 7RVFKL IX YHVFRYR H FDUGLQDOH/ PRUu QHO 4953 HG RJJL q ULFRUGDWR VRSUDWWXWWR SHU OD VXD PRQXPHQWDOH UDFFROWD HQFLFORSHGLFD 3UDFWLFDH FRQFOXVLRQHV LXULV/ ,09,,,/ 5RPDH/ 49380493;1 6X GL OXL FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 8/ S1 5::1 57 3HU IDUH XQ HVHPSLR ULFRUGLDPR LO YROXPLQRVLVVLPR &RQVLOLD OHJDOLD GLYHUVRUXP +SS1 40 469:,/ LQ $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ 0DQRVFULWWL GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD1 4861
;<7
0DUFR &DYLQD
TXDOLILFDURQR FRPH JUDQGL HG LOOXPLQDWL IXQ]LRQDUL1 1RQ D FDVR OD SXEEOLFL0 VWLFD JLXULGLFD SURGRWWD GDL SURWDJRQLVWL GHOOD WHPSHULH ULIRUPLVWLFD PRGHQHVH q VRUSUHQGHQWHPHQWH HVLJXD/ VSHFLH VH OD VL UDSSRUWL FRQ TXHOOD GHOOH FRHYH DUHH LWDOLDQH LOOXPLQDWH1 1HL UHSHUWRUL ELRJUDILFL GHOO·HUXGL]LRQH ORFDOH QRQ QH ULPDQH SUHVVRFKq PHPRULD/ VH VL SUHVFLQGD GDOOH VROLWH DOOHJD]LRQL JLXGL]LDOL/ GD TXDOFKH PRGHVWR SURQWXDULR QRWDULOH58 H GD RSHUH FKH ULHQWUDQR VROR OD0 WDPHQWH QHOO·RUEH JLXULGLFR/ FRPH/ DG HVHPSLR/ DOFXQL FHOHEUL VDJJL GHO 0XUD0 WRUL H GHO 5LFFL59/ RYYHUR LO PRQXPHQWDOH HG LQFRPSLXWR $WHQHR GHOO·XRPR QREL0 OH GL 7DGGHR $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL5:1 3L• QRWH VRQR OH SDJLQH GHO GL OXL GLVFHQ0 GHQWH $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL/ OD FXL RSHUD SL• VLJQLILFDWLYD SHU OD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD JLDFH DQFRUD SUHVVRFKq LQHGLWD/ VH VL SUHVFLQGH GDJOL DPSL VWUDOFL SXEEOLFDWL GDO 9HQWXUL5;1 ,O QRWHYROH LQWHUHVVH GHOOH VXH OH]LRQL GL HFRQRPLD FLYLOH ULVDOWD JLj GDOOD ORUR DUWLFROD]LRQH VHFRQGR O·LQGLFH GHO PDQRVFULWWR UHJJLDQR/ GL FXL RI0 IULDPR LQ QRWD OD WUDVFUL]LRQH5<1 ²²²²²²²² 58 6L SHQVL/ DG HVHPSLR/ DG $QWRQLXV 3,672186/ 'H RIILFLR QRWDULDWXV LQ WUHV SDUWHV GLYLVXV/ 0XWLQDH/ 4:93/ RSHUHWWD GHVWLQDWD HVSOLFLWDPHQWH DJOL DVSLUDQWL QRWDL +FIU1 SS1 809, H FKH DOWUR QRQ q FKH XQ PRGHVWR IRUPXODULR/ DFFRPSDJQDWR GD XQD VHULH GL GRPDQGH H ULVSRVWH VXL UXGLPHQWL GHO GLULWWR SHU IDFLOLWDUH O·DPPLVVLRQH DO FROOHJLR GHL QRWDL1 'HOO·DXWRUH/ PRGHQHVH/ QRQ VDSSLDPR TXDVL QXOOD/ FIU1 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ %LEOLRWHFD«FLW1/ 7/ S1 54<1 59 6X GL OXL DOPHQR FIU1 /1 38&&,/ /RGRYLFR 5LFFL1 'DOO·DUWH GHO EXRQ JRYHUQR DOOD ILQDQ]D PRGHU0 QD/ 0LODQR/ 4<:41 5: 6X GL OXL/ ILJXUD DQFRUD QRQ DGHJXDWDPHQWH VWXGLDWD/ FIU1 &1 '21$7,/ /·LGHD GL QRELOWj LQ ,WDOLD1 6HFROL ;,90;9,,,/ %DUL/ 4<<8/ SS1 6330636/ 6461 5; &IU1 ,OOXPLQLVWL LWDOLDQL 9,,/D FXUD GL *1 *,$55,==2/ *1 725&(//$1/ )1 9(1785,/ 0L0 ODQR01DSROL/ 4<98/ SS1 76607;3/ FRPSUHVD XQD EUHYH ELRJUDILD H ELEOLRJUDILD VXO 3DUDGLVL1 5< 7DYROD *HQHUDOH 'L 7XWWL , &DSLWROL &RQWHQXWL 1HL 7UH 7RPL 'HOOD (FRQRPLD &LYLOH 7RPR 3ULPR 2 FDSLWROR , = VWDWR FLYLOH> FDSLWROR LL= OLEHUWD· FLYLOH> FDSLWROR ,,, GHOOH GLYHUVH IRUPH GHOOR VWDWR FLYLOH/ RVVLD WUDWWDWR GHL JRYHUQR> FDSLWROR ,9 = JRYHUQR IHXGDOH> FDSLWROR 9 = VDJJLR SROLWLFR/ LQ OD RULJLQH/ H GHFDGHQ]D GHOOD OLEHUWD· G·LWDOLD 7RPR 6HFRQGR 2 3DUWH 3ULPD 2 FDSLWROR SULPR= FODVVL GHOOR VWDWR1 VLVWHPD HFRQRPLFR> FDSLWROR VHFRQGR= VLVWHPD PRUDOH> FDSLWROR WHU]R= GHOOD SURSULHWj> FDSLWROR TXDUWR= GH· IHGH0 FRPPHVVL> FDSLWROR TXLQWR= GHOOH PDQL PRUWH> FDSLWROR VHVWR= GHOO·LQGXVWULD1 DJULFROWXUD1 JUDQL> FDSLWROR VHWWLPR= DJULFROWXUD1 OD YLWH> FDSLWROR RWWDYR= GHOOD FROWLYD]LRQH GHL ERVFKL> FDSLWROR QRQR= DOWUH DUWL SURGXWWULFL1 OD FDFFLD> FDSLWROR GHFLPR= GHOOD SHVFD> FDSLWROR XQGLFHVLPR= IRV0 VLOL H PLQHUDOL> WUDWWDWR SULPR= VWRULD GHO FRPPHUFLR LQ JHQHUDOH 3DUWH 6HFRQGD 2 FDSLWROR SULPR= HOHPHQWL GL FRPPHUFLR1 RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DOOR VWDWR> FDSLWROR VHFRQGR= RUGLQH SHU UDSSRUWR DOOH SHUVRQH> FDSLWROR WHU]R= RUGLQH SHU UDSSRUWR DO YDORUH GHOOH FRVH> FDSLWROR TXDUWR= RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DO YDORUH GHOOH IDWLFKH> FDSLWROR TXLQWR= RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DL SURSLHWDUL> FDSLWROR VHVWR= ULVFKLR QHOO·RUGLQH GHOO·HFRQRPLD
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;<8
$QFKH SHU LO ¶:33 VDUj GXQTXH QHFHVVDULD XQ·LQGDJLQH DJJLRUQDWD VXOOH ELRJUDILH GHL SURWDJRQLVWL H VXOOH LQHGLWH UHOLTXLH GHL ORUR WUDWWDWL H FRUVL XQLYHUVLWDUL1 *OL DQQL QDSROHRQLFL H SRL O·DIIHUPD]LRQH GHL GXFKL ¶DXVWULDFL· VHPEUDQR DYHU VLJQLILFDWR PROWR QHOOD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD PRGHQHVH/ WURQFDQ0 GRQH EUXVFDPHQWH O·HYROX]LRQH ULIRUPLVWLFR0PRGHUDWD ¶DOOD WRVFDQD· H VH0 JQDQGRQH LQGHOHELOPHQWH OD PRUIRORJLD LQ VHQVR SROLWLFR631 1HOOD GRWWULQD PRGHQHVH WUDPRQWDQR SUHVWR JOL XPRUL UDGLFDOL GL XQR -D0 FRSR /DPEHUWL/ GL XQ /XLJL 9DOGULJKL R GL XQ &DUOR %RVHOOLQL/ FKH IX IRUVH LO SL• LQWHUHVVDQWH SURSDJDWRUH GHOO·LOOXPLQLVPR JLXULGLFR QHO 'XFDWR1 /D UHVWDXUD]LRQH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH FUHz OH FRQGL]LRQL SHU OR VYLOXSSR GL XQD VFXROD JLXULGLFD LVSLUDWD DOOD FRQWHPSRUDQHD FXOWXUD GHO WUDGL]LRQDOLVPR SROL0 WLFR H ILORVRILFR/ VFXROD FKH DQGz DG DVVXPHUH XQD SRVL]LRQH RULJLQDOH QHOOD JHRJUDILD GHOOH FXOWXUH JLXULGLFKH LWDOLDQH SUHXQLWDULH1 ,O GLFKLDUDWR DSSRJJLR GXFDOH HEEH LPSRUWDQ]D GHFLVLYD1 /·HPDUJLQD]LRQH GDOO·8QLYHUVLWj GHL JLXULVWL PHQR IXQ]LRQDOL DOOD SROLWLFD OHJLWWLPLVWD/ OD ULJLGD SLDQLILFD]LRQH G·XQ LQVHJQDPHQWR JLXULGLFR VWUHWWDPHQWH FRQIRUPLVWD/ LO SUR0 JUHVVLYR LQDVSULPHQWR GHOOD FHQVXUD= VRQR IHQRPHQL FRQFRPLWDQWL FKH VSLH0 JDQR FRPH DQFKH QHOOD VFLHQ]D JLXULGLFD 0RGHQD GLYHQLVVH XQ IDUR SHU LO WUD0 GL]LRQDOLVPR FDWWROLFR H OHJLWWLPLVWD1 6L SHQVL DO SURJUHVVLYR LQDVSULPHQWR ²²²²²²²² 7RPR 7HU]R 2 3DUWH 3ULPD 2 FDSLWROR VHWWLPR= HFRQRPLD SXEEOLFD GLSHQGHQWH GDL SUR0 SULHWDUL> FDSLWROR RWWDYR= RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DOOD SRSROD]LRQH> FDSLWROR QRQR= RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DO ODYRUR> FDSLWROR GHFLPR= RUGLQH HFRQRPLFR SHU UDSSRUWR DL PHWDOOL> 3DUWH 6HFRQGD 2 FDSLWROR SULPR= HOHPHQWL GL FRPPHUFLR> FDSLWROR VHFRQGR= GHOOD FLUFROD0 ]LRQH> FDSLWROR WHU]R= RUGLQH SUDWLFR GHOOD FLUFROD]LRQH> FDSLWROR TXDUWR= GHOOH PDQLHUH SHU OH TXDOL VL DXPHQWD LO GDQDUR QHOOD FLUFROD]LRQH> FDSLWROR TXLQWR= GHJOL LQWHUHVVL 3DUWH 7HU]D 2 FDSLWROR SULPR= GHO FRPPHUFLR HVWHUQR> FDSLWROR VHFRQGR= GHO FDPELR> FD0 SLWROR WHU]R= GHOOH PRQHWH> FDSLWROR TXDUWR= GHO ELODQFLR GHO FRPPHUFLR1 &IU1 %,%/,27(&$ 3$1,==, ', 5(**,2 (0,/,$/ PVV1 (1 46</ PD DQFKH LELGHP/ 7XUUL1 '1 63 H 7XUUL1 *1 431 63 3HU O·HWj QDSROHRQLFD H SHU OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH PL OLPLWR D VLQWHWL]]DUH DV0 VDL EUHYHPHQWH TXDQWR KR HVSRVWR LQ ,O SRWHUH GHO SDGUH«,,ƒ«FLW1> ,O FRGLFH GLPHQWLFDWR1 8Q PLVWH0 ULRVR FRGLFH GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH >4;63FD@ GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 G*$XVWULD0(VWH/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL VWRULD GHO GLULW0 WR LWDOLDQRª/ 9;+4<<8,/ SS1 5660578> (ORJLR GHO GLULWWR LPPRWR1 5DSSUHVHQWD]LRQL HVWHQVL/ LQ ©0DWHULDOL SHU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFDª/ 59+4<<9,/ SS1 4340453> ,WLQHUDUL GHOOD VFXROD JLXULGLFD DX0 VWUR0HVWHQVH +FRQ O·HGL]LRQH GL XQ GRFXPHQWR ¶ULYROX]LRQDULR· FRQWUR LO FRQVLOLXP VDSLHQWLV LXGLFLDOH/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOO·$FFDGHPLD 1D]LRQDOH GL 6FLHQ]H /HWWHUH H $UWL GL 0RGHQDª/ V1 9,,/ 45+4<<70 4<<8,/ SS1 4<405561 $ TXHVWL VDJJL ULQYLR SHU XQ SL• SUHFLVR LQTXDGUDPHQWR VWRULFR H FXOWX0 UDOH GHL SUREOHPL GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD HVWHQVH IUD OD 5LYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH H O·8QLWj G·,WDOLD1
;<9
0DUFR &DYLQD
GHOOH SUDWLFKH FHQVRULH/ FDOGHJJLDWR GDL JLXULVWL WUDGL]LRQDOLVWL1 'DOOD GRFX0 PHQWD]LRQH ULPDVWD VDSSLDPR FKH FRVWRUR RSHUDURQR DWWLYDPHQWH QHOOH FRPPLVVLRQL GL FHQVXUD/ RYH FDVVDURQR LQHVRUDELOPHQWH OD SXEEOLFLVWLFD JLX0 ULGLFD FKH D ORUR QRQ JDUEDYD= OD IDPLJHUDWD OHJJH VXOOD FHQVXUD GHO 4;5;/ LVSL0 UDWD GDL JLXULVWL WUDGL]LRQDOLVWL/ HUD/ LQYHFH/ GXUDPHQWH FULWLFDWD GD XQ JLXULVWD GLVVLGHQWH/ /XLJL 9LDQL/ QHOOD VXD DQFRU RJJL LQHGLWD &URQDFD GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD1 $ SHUPHWWHUH O·DIIHUPD]LRQH G·XQD VFXROD JLXULGLFD ULJRURVDPHQWH OHJLWWL0 PLVWD H WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD IX/ SRL/ OD OHJLVOD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 LQ WHPD GL SXEEOLFD LVWUX]LRQH HG 8QLYHUVLWj1 /·LQWHUD GLGDWWLFD GHO GLULWWR QH XVFu VWHUL0 OL]]DWD H ¶SUDWLFL]]DWD·1)UD O·DOWUR UHVWz HVFOXVR GDL SURJUDPPL O·LQVHJQDPHQWR VSHFLILFR GHO GLULWWR SXEEOLFR H GL TXHOOR QDWXUDOH/ SHU LO ORUR FDUDWWHUH WURSSR ¶SROLWLFR·/ WURSSR SHULFRORVDPHQWH VXJJHVWLYR SHU FKL DYHYD YLVVXWR FRQ PD0 ODQLPR JOL DQQL GHL GLULWWL GHOO·XRPR H GHOOH FRVWLWX]LRQL1 6H VL YRJOLD DQFRUD DYHUH XQ·LGHD GHOOH FRQFH]LRQL JLXVSXEEOLFLVWLFKH FLUFRODQWL QHJOL DPELHQWL HVWHQVL GHOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH/ RFFRUUHUj ULIDUVL DG RSHUH LQHGLWH1 1HOO·DUFKLYLR GL IDPLJOLD GHO IDPLJHUDWR PLQLVWUR 7HRGRUR %D\DUG 'H 9ROR DEELDPR ULQWUDF0 FLDWR JOL DSSXQWL GHOOH OH]LRQL GL JLXULVSUXGHQ]D/ YHURVLPLOPHQWH WUDVFULWWL GDO JLRYDQH 7HRGRUR GDOOD YLYD YRFH GL &DUOR )RQWDQD1 2UEHQH FRVWXL LQWHJUDYD OH OH]LRQL RUGLQDULH FRQ XQ·DPSLD SDQRUDPLFD VXOOH LVWLWX]LRQL JLXVSXEEOLFL0 VWLFKH1 (· XQD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GL JUDQGH LQWHUHVVH H GHOOD TXDOH DEELDPR UHDOL]0 ]DWR XQD SULPD WUDVFUL]LRQH1 1H SUHVHQWLDPR TXL O·LQGLFH VRPPDULR64= 3UHID]LRQH65 ²²²²²²²² 64
&IU1 &IU1 $602/ $UFKLYL SULYDWL %D\DUG 'H 9ROR1 ;:1 ©/R VWXGLR GHO TXDOH FL RFFXSDPPR QHOOH SDVVDWH OH]LRQL YHUVz LQWRUQR DOOH OHJJL FLYLOL GDOOH TXDOL SURFXUDL GL GHVXPHUH D SUHIHUHQ]D GL RJQL DOWUD FRVD/ H VRWWRSRUUH DOOD FRQVLGHUD0 ]LRQH YRVWUD/ R JLRYDQL SUHJLDWLVVLPL/ WXWWH TXHOOH QR]LRQL FKH GLYHQLU SRWHVVHUR QHFHVVDULH QHOOD UHWWD DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH SXEEOLFKH VRVWDQ]H/ TXDORUD IRVWH D TXHVWD FKLDPDWL/ H QHOOD SULYDWD GHO SDWULPRQLR YRVWUR1 2UD SHUz FKH VHFRQGR LO PHWRGR SUHILVVR VLQ GD SULQFLSLR VL q GDWR FRPSLPHQWR DO FRUVR GHOOH FLYLOL LVWLWX]LRQL/ FRPH LQ DSSHQGLFH DOOH YHGXWH FRVH GHO FL0 YLOH GLULWWR HG LQ FRQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OH]LRQL GL JLXULVSUXGHQ]D FL SURSRUUHPR DG RJJHWWR GHO0 OH YHQWXUH OH]LRQL OD VSLHJD]LRQH GL DOFXQH LQWHUHVVDQWL WHRULH VXOO*RULJLQH/ QDWXUD HG HVHUFL]LR GHOOD VRYUDQD DXWRULWj/ OH TXDOL FRPH DSSXQWR VLJQLILFD OD SDUROD VWHVVD WHRULD/ FLRq ULIOHVVLRQH VXOOD QDWXUD GHOOD FRVD/ VDUDQQR GLUHWWH D TXHVWR SULQFLSDOH VFRSR/ D FRQRVFHUH FLRq LO YHUR H OHJLWWLPR IRQWH GHO VRYUDQR SRWHUH H GHOOD JLXVWL]LD GHL GLULWWL DG HVVR LQHUHQWL1 &KH SRL LO WUDW0 WDUH OH HVSRVWH PDWHULH SRVVD FRQVLGHUDUVL FRPH DSSHQGLFH H FRQWLQXD]LRQH DOOD VFXROD GHO FLYLOH GLULWWR QRQ VHPEUHUj IXRU GL SURSRVLWR/ DOORUFKq VL FRQVLGHUL FKH OH OHJJL FLYLOL DOORUD DSSXQWR KDQQR LO YHUR FDUDWWHUH GL OHJJH/ FLRq OD IRU]D GL REEOLJDUH DOO*RVVHUYDQ]D GL FLz FKH FRPDQGDQR/ TXDQGR YHQJRQR HVVH HPDQDWH GD FKL QHOOD FLYLOH VRFLHWj q LQYHVWLWR GHOOD VRYUD0 QD DXWRULWj= TXLQGL LO FRQRVFHUH OD QDWXUD/ O*HVVHQ]D/ O*LQYLRODELOLWj GHO SRWHUH VRYUDQR/ L GLULWWL 65
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;<:
3URSRVL]LRQH ,1 /·XRPR q QDWR SHU YLYHUH LQ VRFLHWj1 ,,1 /R VWDWR GL VRFLHWj/ DO TXDOH q O·XRPR SHU QDWXUD QHFHVVDULDPHQWH GH0 VWLQDWR H QHO TXDOH WURYDU GHYH L PH]]L SHU OD VXD FRQVHUYD]LRQH H IH0 OLFLWj/ GLYHUHEEH DOO·XRPR LQQXWLOH H QRFLYR VHQ]D LO IUHQR GL XQD SXEEOLFD DXWRULWj/ FKH LQYLJLODVVH SHO PDQWHQLPHQWR GHOO·RUGLQH1 ,,,1 /D SXEEOLFD DXWRULWj R VRYUDQLWj/ QHFHVVDULD QHOOD VRFLHWj FLYLOH SHU OD FRQVHUYD]LRQH H IHOLFLWj GHJOL XRPLQL +3URS1 VHF1,/ q XQ GLULWWR SHU OHJJH GL QDWXUD LQHUHQWH DOOR VWDWR GL FLYLO VRFLHWj/ H QRQ q TXLQGL XQ·LVWLWX]LRQH DUELWUDULD1 ,91 /D VRYUDQLWj/ DGXQTXH IRQGDWD VXOOD OHJJH GL QDWXUD +31 ,,,,/ KD OD VXD RULJLQH GD 'LR H QRQ GDOOD FRPXQH GHJOL XRPLQL/ FRPH LQVHJQD OD GRWWULQD GHO SDWWR R FRQWUDWWR VRFLDOH GL 5RXVVHDX1 ²²²²²²²² DO PHGHVLPR VSHWWDQWL/ FRVu QHOO*RUGLQH QDWXUDOH GHOOH FRVH FRQYLHQH H VL DGGLFH DOOH PDWHULH GHO FLYLOH GLULWWR/ LQ TXHOOD VWHVVD JXLVD FKH SURSULR q O*LQGDJDUH OD YHUD FDXVD GL XQ HIIHWWR TXDOXQTXH GHO TXDOH VH QH VLD DFTXLVWDWD OD FRJQL]LRQH1 (VSRVWR FRVu O*RJJHWWR GHOOH YHQWXUH OH]LRQL/ LO PHWRGR FKH VL WHUUj VDUj LO VHJXHQWH= YHUUj OD PDWHULD GLYLVD LQ DOWUHWWDQWH SURSRVL0 ]LRQL D FLDVFXQD GHOOH TXDOL DQGHUj XQLWD OD ULVSHWWLYD GLPRVWUD]LRQH/ VDUj TXHVWD GHVXQWD SULQFLSDOPHQWH GDOOD UDJLRQH/ HG RYH RFFRUUD FRQIHUPDWD GDOOD VWRULD/ HVVHQGR TXHVWD DO GLU GL &LFHURQH/ WDQWR JUDQ ILORVRIR TXDQWR JUDQGH RUDWRUH/ OD PDHVWUD GHOOD YHULWj 1 0HPRUL SRL GHOOD JUDQ VHQWHQ]D GHO JUDQ %DFFRQH GD 9HQHODPLR/ DQQRYHUDWR IUD L ULVWDXUDWRUL GHOOD ILORVR0 ILD/ FKH OD YHUD ILORVRILD VLD FRQGXUUH D 'LR FRPH FDXVD XQLYHUVDOH GL WXWWR LO FUHDWR/ QHOOH VXGGHWWH GLPRVWUD]LRQL FKH YHUUDQQR IDWWH QRQ VL SHUGHUj PDL GL YLVWD TXHVWR JLXVWR H UDJLR0 QHYROH SULQFLSLR SURSULR GL XQ YHUR ILORVRIR/ FLRq O*HVLVWHQ]D GL XQD SURYYLGHQ]D GLYLQD FUHD0 WULFH EHQHILFD H FRQVHUYDWULFH SLHWRVD GHJOL XRPLQL/ FKH VRQR O*RSHUD SL• EHOOD XVFLWD GDOOH PDQL GHOO*DOWLVVLPR1 H TXLQGL DYUj WUD HVVL YROXWD XQD SXEEOLFD DXWRULWj FKH OL UHJRODVVH/ VHQ]D OD TXDOH QRQ FL SXz HVVHUH FHUWDPHQWH DOFXQ RUGLQH1 1RQ VDUDQQR LQROWUH RPPHVVL WXWWL TXHOOL DUJRPHQWL/ FKH DOO*RFFRUUHQ]D FL VRPPLQLVWUHUDQQR OH VDFUH FDUWH/ FRL TXDOL DFTXLVWHUHPR TXHO FRQYLQFLPHQWR FKH QDVFH GDO FRQVLGHUDUH FKH LQ HVVH VL FRQWLHQH OD SDUROD GLYLQD/ H FR0 QRVFHUHPR FKH OH YHUH EDVL GHOO*RUGLQH VRFLDOH FRQWHQXWH VRQR QHOOD GRWWULQD GDO FULVWLDQHVL0 PR LQVHJQDWD1 6H OD VHPSOLFH HVSRVL]LRQH GHOOH VXGGHWWH PDWHULH q DWWD SHU Vq VWHVVD D GLPR0 VWUDUQH O*LPSRUWDQ]D/ TXHVWD SL• PDQLIHVWD VL UHQGH TXDORUD VL FRQVLGHUL O*LQILQLWj GHJOL HUURUL FKH XQLYHUVDOPHQWH q VWDWD VSDUVD VRSUD WDOL DUJRPHQWL SHU O*RSHUD GL IDOVL ILORVRIL H SROLWLFL/ L TXDOL D YHUR SUHJLXGL]LR GHOO*XPDQ JHQHUH QRQ KDQQR RPPHVVR H QRQ RPPHWWRQR DQFKH DGHVVR GL VSDUJHUH GXEEL VRSUD YHULWj FKH VRQR FKLDULVVLPH H LQGXELWDWH/ GDQGR DJOL XRPLQL FRO SUHWHVWR GL LVWUXLUOL GHL GLULWWL FKH QRQ HEEHUR JLDPPDL/ HG XQD VRJQDWD OLEHUWj/ VLPLOL LQ FLz D TXH* SRHWL H D TXH* URPDQ]LVWL/ L TXDOL DEEHOOLURQR OH FDSDQQH GHL SDVWRUL GL FHUWH LQFDQ0 WHYROL GHOL]LH/ OH TXDOL QRQ HVLVWRQR FKH QHOOD ORUR LPPDJLQD]LRQHª1 &IU1 $602/ $UFKLYL SULYD0 WL/ %D\DUG 'H 9ROR1 ;: %/H]LRQL GL JLXULVSUXGHQ]D/% TXDGHUQR 9,,1
;<;
91
9,1 9,,1
9,,,1 ,;1 ;1 ;,1 ;,,1 ;,,,1 ;,91 ;91 ;9,1 ;9,,1 ;9,,,1
;,;1
0DUFR &DYLQD
,Q TXDO VHQVR GHEEDVL LQWHQGHUH LO SULQFLSLR FKH WXWWL JOL XRPLQL VRQR XJXDOL SHU QDWXUD= IDOVLWj HG LQHVLVWHQ]D GHOOD VSLHJD]LRQH GDWD DG XQ WDO SULQFLSLR GDL PRGHUQL ILORVRIL DOO·HSRFD GHOOD 5LYROX]LRQH IUDQFH0 VH1 'LPRVWUDVL LQ TXDO VHQVR VL GHEED LQWHQGHUH H VSLHJDUH LO GLULWWR GHOOD QDWXUDO OLEHUWj D FLDVFXQ XRPR VSHWWDQWH= FKH D TXHVWR GLULWWR QRQ VL RSSRQH LO GLSHQGHUH QHOOD VRFLHWj FLYLOH GD FKL OD FRPDQGD H OD UHJJH1 /D VRYUDQLWj FRPH XQ PH]]R QHFHVVDULR DOOD FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHOOD VR0 FLHWj FLYLOH q LQIDOOLELOPHQWH XQ GLULWWR LQHUHQWH DOOD VWHVVD FLYLO VRFLHWj H GHULYDQWH GDOOD OHJJH GL QDWXUD/ H SHU FLz GD 'LR DXWRUH GL TXHVWD VWHVVD OHJJH= LO VRJJHWWR DGXQTXH FKH QHOOD FLYLO VRFLHWj HVHUFLWDU GR0 YHVVH L GLULWWL GHOOD VRYUDQLWj GHYH FRQVLGHUDUVL GL LVWLWX]LRQH GLYLQD1 'HOOH YDULH IRUPH GL JRYHUQR1 ,O FDUDWWHUH GHO VRYUDQR q VXEOLPH1 'HYH SHUz HVVHUH VDFUR H ULVSHWWD0 WR1 ,O FDUDWWHUH GHO VRYUDQR q XQD SRWHQ]D EHQHILFD H JLXVWD H GHYH TXLQGL HVVHUH DPDWR1 /D VRYUDQLWj GHYH HVVHUH XQD H LQGLYLVLELOH/ QRQ ULVWUHWWD Qq OLPLWDWD TXL LQ WHUUD GD DOFXQ DOWUD DXWRULWj1 /D VRYUDQLWj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·DYYDQ]DPHQWR H GL FRQJHGR GHJOL LPSLHJDWL1 , GHPDQL GHO SULQFLSH VRQR XQ·DVVROXWD VXD SURSULHWj1 +D LO VRYUDQR XQ GLULWWR DVVROXWR/ LQGLSHQGHQWHPHQWH GDOO·DVVHQVR GH· SURSUL VXGGLWL/ GL PHWWHUH HG HVLJHUH LPSRVL]LRQL H WULEXWL1 +4, 'D]LR GHOOH PHUFL/ FKH HQWUDQR/ VRUWRQR H WUDQVLWDQR QHOOR 6WDWR> +5, &LUFR0 OD]LRQH HG DPPDVVR GHOOH PHUFL QHOO·LQWHUQR GHOOR 6WDWR> +6, 'D]LR FRQVXPR> +7, 7DVVD VXOOH VXFFHVVLRQL R FRQWUDWWL> +8, 7DVVD VXL EH0 VWLDPL> +9, 7DVVD SHUVRQDOH R WDVVD JLXGL]LDULD1 'HO GLULWWR GL SHGDJJLR1
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
;<<
;;1 'HOO·LPSRVL]LRQH VXO VDOH HG LO WDEDFFR1 ;;,1 'HOOD PRQHWD1 +4, 1HFHVVLWj GHOOD PRQHWD> +5, ,QGROH GHOOD PRQHWD PHWDOOLFD> +6, 'HOOD IDEEULFD]LRQH GHOOD PRQHWD> +7, 6HJQL PRQHWDWL1 ;;,,1 'HOOD OLEHUWj GHOOD VWDPSD1 ;;,,,1 'HO FRPPHUFLR1 ;;,91 'HO FRPPHUFLR GHL JUDQL1 )X/ GXQTXH/ IDWDOH FKH VL IRUPDVVHUR GXH JDODVVLH GL JLXULVWL PRGHQHVL/ O·XQD XIILFLDOH/ O·DOWUD XIILFLRVD/ O·XQD SURJUHVVLYDPHQWH HJHPRQH LQ WXWWL L FHQWUL GL FXOWXUD H GL SRWHUH/ O·DOWUD ULGRWWD DOOD FODQGHVWLQLWj HG DO VLOHQ]LR/ O·XQD WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD H OHJLWWLPLVWD/ O·DOWUD FRQQRWDWD LQ FKLDYH WHQGHQ]LDOPHQWH OLEHUDOH H GDJOL XPRUL VHPSUH SL• ILOR0ULVRUJLPHQWDOL1 , JLXULVWL WUDGL]LRQDOLVWL PRQRSROL]]DURQR WXWWH OH FDULFKH SL• ULOHYDQWL GHO 'XFDWR/ GLUHVVHUR O·D]LRQH FXOWXUDOH GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj/ GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GHOOH 6FLHQ]H H GHOOD VWDPSD SHULRGLFD1 $ PDUJLQH VL DJJLUDYDQR JLXULVWL GLVVLGHQWL FRQ YDULH VIXPDWXUH/ SHUVHJXLWDWL/ YLVWL FRQ VRVSHWWR R/ SL• VHPSOLFHPHQWH/ HPDUJLQDWL GD TXDOVLYRJOLD SXEEOLFR LQFDULFR1 )UD L GLVVLGHQWL ULFRUGLDPR /XLJL 9LDQL/ /XGRYLFR %RVHOOLQL/ /XLJL &DUER0 QLHUL/ /XLJL &KLHVL/ (ULR 6DOD1 6H XQ /XLJL 9LDQL VYLOXSSz FODQGHVWLQDPHQWH LO VXR SHQVLHUR/ SUHVVRFKq LQHGLWR HG LQ DWWHVD G·HVVHUH DGHJXDWDPHQWH VWXGLDWR/ /XGRYLFR %RVHOOLQL IX LQGXEELDPHQWH OD ILJXUD GL PDJJLRU VSLFFR H EULOODQ0 WH]]D= HPDUJLQDWR D 0RGHQD/ UDJJLXQVH QRWHYROH IDPD LQ ,WDOLD HG DOO·HVWHUR1 ,Q TXHVWD VHGH FL LQWHUHVVDQR/ SHUz/ PDJJLRUPHQWH L WUDGL]LRQDOLVWL/ SHUFKp IXURQR FRVWRUR D TXDOLILFDUH O·LPPDJLQH GHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHOOD 5HVWDX0 UD]LRQH1 )UD L SLRQLHUL PHQ]LRQLDPR DOPHQR *LDPEDWWLVWD 9HUDWWL= LO VXR 6WXGLR OH0 JDOH IX LO FHQDFROR LQ FXL QHL SULPL DQQL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH 0DUF·$QWRQLR 3DUHQWL/ %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL H *LXVHSSH /XJOL VL IHFHUR GHPLXUJKL GHOOD VFXR0 OD WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD1 6X PROWL GL TXHVWL DXWRUL ILRULVFH XQ·DQHGGRWLFD DVVDL XWLOH D GLPRVWUDUH FRPH OD VFXROD GHL JLXULVWL XIILFLDOL VL FROORFDVVH QHOO·LPPDJLQDULR GHL FRQ0 WHPSRUDQHL1 )XURQR RVVHUYDQWLVVLPL GHOOH SUDWLFKH UHOLJLRVH H WDORUD VFDPELD0 WL SHU YHUL H SURSUL SUHWL/ FRPH DYYHQQH SL• YROWH D *LXVHSSH /XJOL/ PHQWUH GL $OIRQVR 7RVFKL VL GLFHYD FKH QHJOL DQQL GHJOL VWXGL XQLYHUVLWDUL D %RORJQD VL YHVWLVVH FRQ DELWL FOHULFDOL SHU WHQHUH DOOD ODUJD OH FDWWLYH FRPSDJQLH1 )XUR0 QR GHYRWLVVLPL DO 'XFD= SDUH FKH )LOLSSR &RFFKL PRULVVH GL FUHSDFXRUH SHU OD FDGXWD GHO 'XFDWR1 )XURQR GqGLWL 0 LQ SULPD SHUVRQD 0 DO VLVWHPDWLFR HVHU0
<33
0DUFR &DYLQD
FL]LR GHOOD FDULWj= VH QH ULFRUGDQR OH ORGHYROL LPSUHVH GL *LXVHSSH &XRJKL H VRSUDWWXWWR GL 0DUF·$QWRQLR 3DUHQWL1 'LPHQVLRQH VFLHQWLILFD/ GLPHQVLRQH FLYLOH H GLPHQVLRQH UHOLJLRVD HUDQR/ FRVu/ FRQJLXQWH DG XQLWj1 0D SDVVLDPR D YDOXWDUH FRQFUHWDPHQWH DOFXQL DVSHWWL TXDOLILFDQWL GHL FRQ0 WHQXWL GHO PHVVDJJLR WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD1 ,O IRQGDPHQWR XOWLPR/ OHJLWWLPDQWH GHO GLULWWR GRYHYD ULWURYDUVL QHOOD VXD HWHUQD LPPRELOLWj IRQGDWD VX GL XQ·LQYDULDQWH FXOWXUDOH/ TXHOOD GHL GRJPL GL XQD FDWWROLFLWj YLVVXWD LQ FKLDYH LQWUDQVLJHQWHPHQWH WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD1 /D VWRULD DOWUR QRQ HUD FKH LO EDQFR GL SURYD GHOOD YHULWj SULPLWLYD= OD VWRULD HUD LO OXRJR LQ FXL OD YHULWj HWHUQD YHQLYD D FLPHQWDUVL FRQ OH HIILPHUH WHQWD]LRQL GHOO·HUURUH/ FKH SRWHYD DVVXPHUH IRJ0 JH GLYHUVH GDOOH OHJJL GHJO·LPSHUDWRUL SDJDQL VLQR D TXHOOH GL 1DSROHRQH1 6L WUDWWz GL XQ·LPSRVWD]LRQH IRUWHPHQWH DQWLPRGHUQLVWD DQFKH VXO WHUUHQR SROLWLFR0VRFLDOH/ GRYH YHQQH VHQ]·DOWUR UHVSLQWD OD VRFLHWj LQGXVWULDOL]]DWD HG LQGLYLGXDOLVWD1 'L TXHVWD VL QHJDYD LQ UDGLFH OD FRQFH]LRQH GHO GLULWWR FRPH GLULWWR LQ PRYLPHQWR/ SUDJPDWLFR/ DYYLQWR DL IDWWL HG DOOH RSLQLRQL/ VLD SXUH PDJJLRULWDULH1 /D VFXROD JLXULGLFD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH DYUj/ D PRQWH G·RJQL VSHFX0 OD]LRQH JLXULGLFD/ LO WHUURUH GHO FDPELDPHQWR LQWHVR FRPH PRWRUH GL GHJHQH0 UD]LRQH H GLVRUGLQH= LO VXR PLWR q/ LQYHFH/ OD FRVWUX]LRQH GL XQ RUGLQDPHQWR LPPRWR/ IRQGDWR VX GL XQ RUGLQH QRQ WDQWR VWRULFR/ TXDQWR DUFDLFR/ QHO VHQ0 VR GL DUFKHWLSLFR1 ,O VLJQLILFDWR GHOOD GRWWULQD XIILFLDOH RWWRFHQWHVFD q WXWWR QHOOD FRVWDQWH ULFHUFD IUD SDVVDWR HG DUFDLFR/ IUD GLULWWR URPDQR0FRPXQH H GL0 ULWWR QDWXUDOH FDWWROLFR/ QHRWRPLVWD LQ ILHUL1 ,O PRGHOOR VRWWLQWHVR HUD TXHOOR GL XQD UHVWDXUD]LRQH SUHJQD GHL YDORUL FDWWROLFL WUDGL]LRQDOLVWL/ LQ GLUHWWD ILOLD]LR0 QH GDO PDJLVWHUR GHO %RQDOG H GHO SULPR /DPHQQDLV1 6L WUDWWDYD GL SURSRUUH FRQFUHWDPHQWH TXHL PHFFDQLVPL JLXULGLFL/ FKH WUDGXFHVVHUR L SULQFLSL GHO WUD0 GL]LRQDOLVPR FDWWROLFR/ LQ OLQHD FRQ O·HVSHULHQ]D G·DQWLFR UHJLPH1 $ SDUHU ORUR LO GLEDWWLWR JLXULGLFR GHO WHPSR VL IRQGDYD VX GL XQD FRQWUDS0 SRVL]LRQH UDGLFDOH/ TXHOOD WUD IDPLOLVPR HG LQGLYLGXDOLVPR1 /XQJR VLIIDWWR LWL0 QHUDULR/ OD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD XIILFLDOH DQGDYD HVDOWDQGR OH PRQDUFKLH G·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH SUH0VHWWHFHQWHVFKH/ DQWHULRUL/ FLRq/ D TXDOVLYRJOLD PHWD0 VWDVL GHOO·HWj GHL OXPL1 /H VXFFHVVLYH LVWLWX]LRQL/ LQYHFH/ VDUHEEHUR VWDWH FRQ0 WUDVVHJQDWH GDO GHYDVWDQWH LQGLYLGXDOLVPR DQWL0IDPLOLVWD/ JHUPLQDWR JUD]LH DOO·RPRJHQHL]]D]LRQH FXOWXUDOH/ DOO·LQQDO]DPHQWR GHO WHU]R VWDWR HG DOO·DIILHYROLPHQWR GHO VROLGDULVPR FULVWLDQR1 6L WUDWWDYD/ TXLQGL/ GL SLDQLILFDUH XQD VWUDWHJLD HIILFDFH SHU XQD SURQWD ULFRVWUX]LRQH IDPLOLVWD1
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
<34
6L FDSLVFH/ FRVu/ FRPH PDL DO FXRUH GHOO·XQLYHUVR JLXULGLFR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH QRQ VL WURYLQR OD SURSULHWj LQGLYLGXDOH R O·DXWRQRPLD QHJR]LDOH/ PD OD IDPL0 JOLD= XQD IDPLJOLD HVWHVD/ SDWULDUFDOH/ IRQGDWD VXO PDWULPRQLR FDQRQLFR H VX GL XQD UHWH GL UHOD]LRQL GL SRWHUH IRUWHPHQWH DVLPPHWULFKH/ LQ RVVHTXLR DOO·XQLWj GL FRPDQGR ILVVDWD VHFRQGR OH FRRUGLQDWH PDVFKLOL H JHQHUD]LRQDOL/ TXHOOD LQ0 FRQFXVVD GHO SDWHUIDPLOLDV1 ,O SDGUH QHOOD IDPLJOLD DQGDYD D FRQILJXUDUVL FRPH XQD VRUWD GL WXWRUH GHOOD IRUPD]LRQH WUDGL]LRQDOLVWD GHOOH QXRYH JHQHUD]LRQL/ H OD SURSULHWj GLYHQWDYD DWWULEXWR HVVHQ]LDOH GHO VRJJHWWR/ QRQ FRPH LQGLYL0 GXR/ PD FRPH PHPEUR GHOOD FRPXQLWj GRPHVWLFD1 )DFFLDPR TXDOFKH HVHPSLR FRQFUHWR1 , JLXULVWL DXVWUR0HVWHQVL VRVWHQQHUR LQIOHVVLELOPHQWH O·RPRJDPuD VRFLDOH 0 FRPH H SL• FKH QHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH 0/ PLUDQGR DG RVWDFRODUH LQIOHVVLELOPHQWH L PDWULPRQL IUD VRJJHWWL GL FHWR GLYHU0 VR/ PD DQFKH WXWWL TXHL PDWULPRQL FKH/ FODQGHVWLQL R SULYL GHO FRQVHQVR SD0 WHUQR/ PHWWHVVHUR LQ GLVFXVVLRQH OH VWUDWHJLH GHOOD ¶UDJLRQ GL IDPLJOLD· HODERUD0 WH GDL SDGUL1 , JLXULVWL GHOOD VFXROD XIILFLDOH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH IXURQR VSHVVR QH0 PLFL GHOOH FRGLILFD]LRQL RWWRFHQWHVFKH/ PD IXURQR DOILHUL GHL IHGHFRPPHVVL H GHOOD GLVHUHGD]LRQH/ DOILHUL GHOO·LQDVSULPHQWR GHOOD SDWULD SRWHVWj/ DOILHUL GL QXRYH QRUPH GLVFULPLQDWRULH GHL ILJOL QDWXUDOL/ WDORUD DGGLULWWXUD DOILHUL GHOOD UHLQWURGX]LRQH GHO VLVWHPD IHXGDOH H GHOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL GL PHVWLHUH1 /D SULPRJHQLWXUD/ OD SDWULD SRWHVWj H O·LQDOLHQDELOLWj GHO SDWULPRQLR LP0 PRELOLDUH DVVXUVHUR D VLPEROL GHOO·HVWUHPD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD HVSUHVVD GD 0R0 GHQD FDSLWDOH/ TXHOOD GHOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH1 ,O PDUFDWLVVLPR FDWWROLFHVLPR GHL SULQFLSDOL JLXULVWL ¶HVWHQVL· HPHUJH FRQ JUDQGH QLWLGH]]D LQ XQD OHWWHUD LQYLDWD GD /XGRYLFR %RVHOOLQL D %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL DOFXQL DQQL GRSR OD FDGXWD GHO 'XFDWR1 (· XQ GRFXPHQWR LQWHUHVVDQ0 WH/ XOWHULRUH WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOO·DPLFL]LD SHUVRQDOH FKH OHJDYD OH GXH ILJXUH GL PDJJLRU VSLFFR GHOO·XOWLPD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD HVWHQVH= LO SULPR HUD GL VHQWLPHQ0 WL ULVRUJLPHQWDOL H/ VLD SXU DPELJXDPHQWH/ SURJUHVVLYL/ LO VHFRQGR HUD DOILHUH GHOOH ¶VDQH GRWWULQH· UHVWDXUDWH H IHGHOLVVLPR GHL 'XFKL1 &RQ ORUR/ RUPDL FRQ0 VLGHUDWL HQWUDPEL ¶OHWWHUDVLQL· H PRUWL GL Ou D SRFKL DQQL/ VL HVWLQVH GHILQLWLYD0 PHQWH OD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD ¶HVWHQVH·1
<35
0DUFR &DYLQD
$33(1',&( >%,%/,27(&$ &2081$/( ', 0,5$1'2/$/ 5DFFROWD *DYLROLDQD1 $UFKLYLR 5RVVL09HUDWWL1 &DUWHJJLR 9HUDWWL %1/ ,0,,1 // 5/ '/ 809@ 0RGHQD 2 ,OO1PR H &KLDU1PR S1 &DY1 3URI1 $YYRFDWR %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL66 &DULVVLPR 9HUDWWL/ 1RQDQWROD 45 VHWWHPEUH 4;9: +R DYXWR LO 0RQLWRUH GH· WULEXQDOL H KR LYL ULOHYDWR FRQ GLVSLDFHUH OD PRUWH GHO EXRQ 0LW0 WHUPDLHU/ FKH LR DPDYR H VWLPDYR WDQWR1 0L SLDFHYD LO VXR FDUDWWHUH OHDOH H EXRQR1 1RQ HUD PROWR JDOORILOR1 (UD DGGRORUDWR GHOO·DOODUJDPHQWR GHOOD 3UXVVLD SHUFKq OR ULJXDUGDYD FRPH OD GLVWUX]LRQH GHOOD *HUPDQLD1 (G DYHYD UDJLRQH TXDQWXQTXH QRQ HVSULPHVVH R IRUV·DQFR QRQ FRQVLGHUDVVH O·LQWHUR FRQFHWWR OD *HUPDQLD SURWHVWDQWH PLUD DG DVVRUELUH OD *HUPDQLD FDWWR0 OLFD +LPEDVWDUGLWD SHUz GDO .DXQLW]/ GD *LXV1 ,, GD /HRSROGR ,, GDOOH WHRULH GHO )HEURQLXV,1 )HFL XQ DUWLFROHWWR FKH PDQGDL D =HUELQL SHUFKq OR IDFHVVH LQVHULUH QHO GLU1R FDWWROLFR1 'HEER DYHUH D 0RGHQD XQD EHOOD ELRJUDILD GL 0LWWHUPDLHU H XQR VWXGLR VXOOH VXH RSHUH IDWWD GD :LSSHOV1 9H OD GDUz TXDQGR VDUz D 0RGHQD1 3HU FRPELQD]LRQH YLGL FKH O·,PSDU]LDOH QH SDUOz JLRUQL VRQR/ PD q XQ JLRUQDOH FKH QRQ TXDOLILFKHUz GL HPSLR PD FKH q WXWWR QHOOH PRGHUQH LGHH QHOOD UHOLJLRQH QHOOD IUDPPDVVRQHULD1 1RQ GLFR FKH VLDQR IUDPPDVVRQL WXWWL L UHGDWWRUL/ GLFR FKH OH LGHH GL TXHVWD JRYHUQDQR TXHOOR1 9RUUHEEHUR PHWWHUVL G·DFFRUGR FRQ 'RPHQHG0 GLR SHUFKq GL FRPXQH DFFRUGR VL IDFHVVH XQD UHOLJLRQH DGDWWDWD DL WHPSL$ 6RQR IRUVH LQ SURJUHVVR PD VRQR GHO JHQHUH GHO IDPRVR $OIRQVR 5H GL &DVWLJOLD GHWWR LO 6DYLR FKH PHULWDYD IRUVH PH0 JOLR LO WLWROR GL PDWWR1 1HOO·,PSDU]LDOH VXOORGDWR YLGL PH H YRL DQQRYHUDWL IUD L OHWWHUDVLQL YLYHQ0 WL GL 0RGHQD1 9RL VDSHWH TXDOFKH OLQJXD LR QH VR PHQR PD QHSSXU YRL VDSHWH OD OLQJXD PRQ0 JROLFD FKH DGRSHUD IHOLFHPHQWH LO 3URI1 *ULPHOOL SHU QRQ HVVHUH LQWHVR DQFKH TXDQGR GLIHQGH OD YHULWj1 (· FXULRVR HJOL FRO FUHGHUVL XQD FRORQQD GHO FULVWLDQHVLPR VRVWHQHQGR LO FULVWLDQHVL0 PR PDVVRQLFR GH· QRVWUL XRPLQL GL 6WDWR$ 6H PDL YL VDOWDVVH OD FXULRVLWj GL VDSHU OD YHULWj GL TXH· GXH FDGDYHUL WURYDWL QHOOD FKLHVD DEED]LDOH GRPDQGDWHQH DO 3URI1 %UDQGROL/ FXL SHU VRGLVIDUH OD VXD PDQGDL LQ RULJLQDOH OD UHOD0 ]LRQH FKH PH QH IHFH 0RQV1 9LFDULR1 /HJJHVWH LO GLVFRUVR 3RJJL LQ 6HQDWR" FKH QH GLWH" 6HPSUHSSL• PL SHUVXDGR FKH L WHPSH0 UDPHQWL XPDQL QRQ SRVVRQR FKH JXDVWDUH OH FRVH GL 'LR1 6DUHEEH QHFHVVDULR FKH O·XRPR SRWHVVH QRQ GLFR QHSSXU FUHDUH H[ QLKLOR XQD SLDQWLFHOOD XQ SRYHUR DQLPDOHWWR$ /·XRPR QRQ SXz$ 111 0D OH FRVH QDVFRQR VSRQWDQHDPHQWH 111 PD FKL OH FRPLQFLz" 4XHVWR DPPDVVR GL FRVH q HWHUQR 111 H JOL DOWUL PRQGL" 4XDO XRPR OL IHFH" VRQR WXWWL HWHUQL1 &KL OL IRUPz FRVu VDSLHQWL" 6RQR XQD VRVWDQ]D VROD1 6RQR GXQTXH XQ 'LR/ PD FKH KD WDQWH EUXWWXUH/ VH QRL VLDPR SDUWH GL TXHO 'LR JOL IDFFLDP IDUH H GLUH WDQWH VFLRFFKH]]H" 4XHVWR XQLYHUVR FKH q 'LR KD GXQTXH XQD PHQWH GLUHWWULFH" )HUPL XQ SRFR1 4XHVWR q LO YH0
²²²²²²²² 66 ,O WHVWR q VFULWWR VXO UHWUR HG DL ERUGL GL XQ PDQLIHVWLQR D VWDPSD= 6LJ1 'RWW= )HUGLQDQ0 GR %DJQL 2 LQ SXQWR 2 GL SUHWHVD DOLHQD]LRQH GL XQ FDSR 2 5LVSRVWD DOOD FRQWUDULD 0HPRULD 2 7LS1 GL &HQWRª1
3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD JLXULGLFD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= IRQWL H SUREOHPL
<36
UR1 'LR FKH WXWWR ID FKH WXWWR GLULJH FKH QRQ q XQ LPSDVWR GL SHUIH]LRQH H GL LPSHUIH]LRQL FKH ID TXHO FKH YXROH/ FKH VH ID GHJOL HVVHUL OLEHUL FRPDQGD TXHOOR FKH YXROH FKH IDFFLDQR GLFH ORUR TXHOOR FKH QRQ SRVVRQR VDSHUH GD Vq1 ( FKL SRWUj GLUJOL= QRQ YL YRJOLR DVFROWDUH" 1RL FKH QRQ VLDPR 'LR WROOHUHUHPPR XQ VHUYLWRUH FKH FL GLFHVVH GL QRQ YROHUH REEHGLUH DOWURFFKq DL FRPDQGL GL FXL FRQRVFH L PRWLYL/ XQR VFRODUR LO TXDOH YROHVVH SULPD DYHUH LQWHVR FLz FKH JOL VL GHYH LQVHJQDUH" (· FXULRVR FKH L PRGHUQL SUHWHQGRQR FKH JOL DQWLFKL QRQ DYHVVHUR LGHD VDQD GHOOD SUR0 SULHWj FKH HVVL IDFHVVHUR OR 6WDWR SDGURQH GL WXWWR/ H SRL HVVL VROL KDQQR LGHDWR OH WHRULH GHOOD RQQLSRWHQ]D GHOOR 6WDWR/ GHOOD SURSULHWj JHQHUDOH GHOOR 6WDWR/ H SRL OD SURSULpWp F·HVW XQ YRO GL FXL 3URXGKRQ GHPDJRJR VL IDFHD EHOOR HG q XQD EULFFRQDWD Vu PD LQYHQWDWD GD DOWUL SHUFKq OD GLV0 VH DL WHPSL GH· JLDFRELQL %ULVVRW GL 9DXYLOOH1 1RQ GLPHQWLFR LO PLR GHELWR H L IUXWWL UHODWLYL1 ,R QRQ KR UXEDWR DOOD &KLHVD H LO UXEDPHQ0 WR GHL EHQL GL &KLHVD +DQ]L FRQILVFD/ QRQ GLFLDPR SL• VRODPHQWH LQFDPHUDPHQWR/ DQ]L QHSSXUH= GLFLDPR FRQYHUVLRQH/ SDVVDJJLR R PHJOLR OLTXLGD]LRQH, PL WRJOLH GL SRWHU YHQGHUH LO PLR/ RVVLD XQ IRQGR R GXH H SDJDUYL1 0D WDQWR IDUz FKH FL ULHVFLUz1 $II1PR 6XR 2 /1 %RVHOOLQL 47 H1 OHJJHWH XQD EHOOLVVLPD OHWWHUD GHO FRQVLJOLHUH GL &DVVD]LRQH /XLJL %RUVDUL/ H SRL PH OD UHVWLWXHUHWH SHUFKq PROWR PL SUHPH GL FRQVHUYDUOD1
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<38
&$50(/2 (/,2 7$9,//$
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
, SRWHUL JLXGL]LDUL SUHVVR L VLJQRUL G·(VWH DQGDURQR SUHFLVDQGRVL LQ VWUHWWD FRQFRPLWDQ]D FRQ O·RWWHQLPHQWR GHL YLFDULDWL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH GL TXHOOR DSRVWR0 OLFR VX )HUUDUD GD SDUWH GL 5LQDOGR , QHO 465<14 H GL TXHOOR LPSHULDOH VX 0R0 GHQD H )ULJQDQR GD SDUWH GL $OGRYUDQGLQR ,,, QHO 4687151 6SHFLILFDPHQWH/ TXHOOR LPSHULDOH GHO 4687 VX 0RGHQD H )ULJQDQR OHJLWWLPz JOL (VWHQVL DOO·HVHUFL]LR GHOOD JLXULVGL]LRQH YRORQWDULD H FRQWHQ]LRVD/ DG XQ JHQHUDOH SR0 WHUH GL FRQWUROOR VXL JLXGLFL H DOO·DYRFD]LRQH SUHVVR OD SURSULD SHUVRQD GHL SURFHVVL GL TXDOVLDVL JUDGR H LQ SDUWLFRODU PRGR GL TXHOOL G·DSSHOOR61 , ULFRQR0 VFLPHQWL SRQWLILFL H LPSHULDOL FRQWULEXLURQR LQROWUH D SURPXRYHUH LO SURFHVVR GL IRUPD]LRQH H FRQVROLGDPHQWR GHJOL RUJDQL FROOHJLDOL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H GL FR0 RUGLQDPHQWR GHOOH SRWHVWDWHV VLJQRULOL71 ²²²²²²²² 4
*1 '( 9(5*277,1,/ 1RWH SHU OD VWRULD GHO YLFDULDWR DSRVWROLFR/ JLj LQ 6FULWWL GL VWRULD H GLULWWR LQ RQRUH GL &1 &DOLVVH/ ,,,/ 0LODQR 4<6</ RUD LQ 6FULWWL GL VWRULD GHO GLULWWR LWDOLDQR/ D FXUD GL *1 5266,/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<::/ ,,/ SS1 8;: VV1 'D XOWLPR/ (1 0,/$12/ &DVD G·(VWH GDOO·DQQR 0LOOH DO 48<;/ LQ *OL (VWHQVL/ ,/ /D FRUWH GL )HUUDUD/ D FXUD GL 51 ,277,/ 0RGHQD/ ,O %XOLQR/ 4<<:/ SS1 57 6V1 5 *1 %('21,/ 0RGHQD/ 487:= OD VWRULFD ULIRUPD GHO GLULWWR SURFHVVXDOH FLYLOH/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ 47 +4<<5,/ S1 4441 6 ,ELGHP1 7 2OWUH DL FRQVLOLDULL GHO &RQVLOLXP PDUFKLRQDOH/ GL FXL VL SDUOHUj WUD EUHYH/ YDQQR VHJQDODWL L LXGLFHV FXULDH/ FRQVXOHQWL OHJDOL VSHFLDOL]]DWL PD RFFDVLRQDOL GHO VLJQRUH/ H L IDFWRUHV JHQHUDOHV/ D0 JHQWL H DPPLQLVWUDWRUL GHOOD &DPHUD GXFDOH1 6L YHGDQR )1 9$/(17,/ , &RQVLJOL GL JRYHUQR SUHVVR JOL (VWHQVL GDOOH RULJLQL DOOD 'HYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD/ LQ 6WXGL LQ RQRUH GL 5LFFDUGR )LODQJLHUL/ 1DSROL/ /·DUWH WLSRJUDILFD/ 4<8</ YRO1 ,,/ SS1 57 6V1> 31 ', 3,(752/ /D &DQFHOOHULD GHJOL (VWHQVL QHO SHULRGR IHUUDUHVH +4597048<;,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;/ 43 +4<:8,/ SS1 <:0<;> /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ GLU1 GD *1 *$/$662/ YRO1 ;9,,/ , 'XFDWL SDGDQL/ 7UHQWR H 7ULHVWH/ 7RULQR/ 87(7/ 4<:</ S1 5;>
<39
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
8QD SULPD DWWHVWD]LRQH IRUPDOH GHOOH FRPSHWHQ]H JLXGL]LDULH GHO SL• LP0 SRUWDQWH GL TXHVWL RUJDQL/ LO &RQVLOLXP GRPLQL PDUFKLRQLV/ JLj DWWLYR VLQ GDO 46:58/ YLHQH DWWXDWD GD 1LFFROz ,,, FRQ LO GHFUHWR < PDU]R 475891 ,O FROOHJLR GHL FRQVLOLDULL GHO VLJQRUH 0 LQWHJUDWR/ LQ VHGH JLXGL]LDULD/ GD DOFXQL ¶WHFQLFL·= LO JLXGLFH IHUUDUHVH GHL ´GRGLFL VDSLHQWLµ/ LO PDHVWUR FDPHUDULR/ LO YLFDULR JHQHUD0 OH GHOOD FXULD GXFDOH/ L GXH IDWWRUL JHQHUDOL H O·XIILFLDOH GHOOD EDQFKD VWLSHQGLRUXP ² DYUHEEH G·RUD LQ DYDQWL FRVWLWXLWR XQ YHUR H SURSULR WULEXQDOH FRQ DPSOLV0 VLPD JLXULVGL]LRQH +©111 XOWUD DUELWULXP DOLDV 111 FRQFHVVXP111ª, VXOOH FDXVH UL0 JXDUGDQWL SXSLOOL/ YHGRYH H ´PLVHUDELOLµ +©111 LQ TXLEXVFXPTXH FDXVLV SXSLOOR0 UXP HW YLGXDUXP DF PLVHUDELOLXP SHUVRQDUXP111ª, ² ULVHUYDWH WUDGL]LRQDOPHQ0 WH DOOD SULYLOHJLDWD FRJQL]LRQH LPSHULDOH: ² H VX TXHOOH GL FXL HVSUHVVDPHQWH IRVVH VWDWR LQYHVWLWR GDO VLJQRUH +©111 LQ HLVTXH TXH SHU 1RV VLEL FRPPLVVH IXHULQW111ª,/ VSHFLDOPHQWH TXDORUD IRVVH VWDWR UDYYLVDWR XQ VXSHULRUH LQWHUHVVH ¶SXEEOLFR· DOOD SL• UDSLGD FRQFOXVLRQH GHOOD OLWH +©111 SUR QRVWUR FRPPXQL HW FLYLXP VWDWX111/ OLWHV HW FDOXPQLDV VXFFLGHQGR111/ OLWHV HW VXEWHUIXJLD EUHYLDQ0 GRª,1 3HFXOLDULWj ULOHYDQWH GHO SURFHGLPHQWR LQQDQ]L DO &RQVLJOLR PDUFKLRQDOH IX TXHOOD GL SRQGHUDUH LO FDVR LQ JLXGL]LR ©KDEHQGR UHVSHFWXP DG 'HXP HW YHULWDWHPª/ FLRq VXOOD EDVH GL YDOXWD]LRQL HTXLWDWLYH/ DO GL Oj/ TXLQGL/ GL RJQL ²²²²²²²² (1 0$1(17,/ /R VSD]LR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR FHQWUDOH1 8Q·LQGDJLQH VXOOD VWUXWWXUD GHOOD &DPHUD 0DUFKLR0 QDOH SRL 'XFDOH (VWHQVH D )HUUDUD/ LQ /D FRUWH H OR VSD]LR= )HUUDUD HVWHQVH1 $WWL GHO VHPLQDULR/ )HUUDUD 53058 RWWREUH 4<;3/ D FXUD GL *1 3$3$*12 H $1 4821'$0/ 5RPD/ %XO]RQL/ 4<;5/ SS1 43: 6V1> 71-1 782+</ 6WUXWWXUD H VLVWHPD GL FRQWDELOLWj GHOOD &DPHUD HVWHQVH QHO 4XDWWURFHQWR/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ 7 +4<;5,/ SS1 448 6V1> :1 *81'(56+(,0(5/ )HUUDUD HVWHQVH1 /R VWLOH GHO SRWHUH/ WUDG1 LW1 +HG1 RU1 3ULQFHWRQ 11-1/ 4<:6,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;;/ SS1 5:05< H 446 6V1> 71 %$&&+,/ &DQFHOOHULD H VHJUHWDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;91 3ULPH ULFHUFKH/ LQ ©5LFHUFKH VWRULFKHª/ 5715 +4<<7,/ SS1 684 VV1 8 )1 9$/(17,/ , &RQVLJOL GL JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ SS1 530551 6XO &RQVLJOLR PDUFKLRQDOH/ VL YHGD DQ0 FKH ² SXU VRWWR DVSHWWL GLYHUVL GD TXHOOL SURSULDPHQWH JLXULGLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOL ² OD UHFHQWH LQGD0 JLQH GL /DXUD 785&+,/ /D JLXVWL]LD GHO SULQFLSH= PDJLVWUDWXUH VRYUDQH GHL GXFKL G·(VWH IUD ;9 H ;9, VHFROR/ WHVL GL GRWWRUDWR GL ULFHUFD LQ 6WRULD VRFLDOH HXURSHD/ 8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL VWXGL GL 9HQH]LD/ D1 4<<60<7/ UHODWRUH SURI1 *1 &2==,/ SS1 4:; 6V1 +OD FXL FRQVXOWD]LRQH GHEER DOOD FRUWHVLD GHOOD VWHVVD GRWW1VVD 7XUFKL/ FKH TXL ULQJUD]LR,1 9 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$ +G·RUD LQ DYDQWL $602,/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ /HJJL H GHFUH0 WL/ VH]1 %/ UHJLVWUR ,9/ F1 449U +S1 54:,1 6X WDOH GHFUHWR/ )1 9$/(17,/ , &RQVLJOL GL JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ SS1 55 6V1> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH1 /H]LRQL GL VWRULD GHO GLULWWR LWDOLDQR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<;:/ S1 5<> /1 785&+,/ /D JLXVWL]LD111 FLW1/ SS1 546 6V1 : 6HFRQGR TXDQWR JLj SUHYLVWR GDOOD IDPRVD ´OHJJH XQLFDµ JLXVWLQLDQHD GL &16147 +4XDQGR LPSHUDWRU LQWHU SXSLOORV YHO YLGXDV YHO PLVHUDELOHV SHUVRQDV FRJQRVFDW HW QH H[KLEHDQWXU,1
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<3:
FRQVLGHUD]LRQH IRUPDOH H YLQFRODQWH GHL WHVWL QRUPDWLYL H GHOOH SURFHGXUH/ FRQ OD FRQVHJXHQWH SLHQD OLEHUWj GL GHFLGHUH LQWHUDPHQWH OD FRQWURYHUVLD R GL GHOHJDUQH LQ WXWWR R LQ SDUWH OD FRJQL]LRQH DG DOWUL JLXGLFL1 ,Q FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ O·LQFUHPHQWDWD DWWLYLWj GHO &RQVLJOLR H LQ VHJXLWR DOO·DFTXLVL]LRQH GHO WLWROR LPSHULDOH GL GXFD GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR;/ LO QHR0 LQYHVWLWR %RUVR/ FRQ GHFUHWR 47 JHQQDLR 4786</ SURYYHGHYD DOO·LVWLWX]LRQH GL XQ RUJDQLVPR DG KRF/ LO &RQVLOLXP ,XVWLWLDH/ HVHPSODWR VXOO·DQDORJR PRGHOOR YL0 VFRQWHR GL 0LODQR43 H VXOO·DOWUR JRQ]DJKHVFR GL 0DQWRYD441 /·RSHUDWR GHL FRQVLJOLHUL VL VDUHEEH HVWHVR/ ©FXP DPSOD HW ODWLVVLPD SRWHVWDWHª/ DOOD ULVROX0 ]LRQH GL FDVL H GXEEL GL GLULWWR H GL JLXVWL]LD +©111 LQ RPQLEXV HW TXLEXVFXPTXH FDVLEXV HW GXELLV LXULV HW LXVWLWLDH111ª,> DOO·HVDPH GHOOH OHWWHUH GL VXSSOLFD LQGL0 UL]]DWH GLUHWWDPHQWH DO SULQFLSH +©111 VXSSOLFDWLRQHV HW SUDHFHV DF OLWWHUDV111ª,> DOOD FRJQL]LRQH/ VX FRPPLVVLRQH GXFDOH/ GL TXDOVLDVL WLSR GL FRQWURYHUVLD LQ FXL XQD GHOOH SDUWL ULVXOWDVVH VXGGLWR ¶LPPHGLDWR· GHJOL (VWH +©111 VXEGLWRV GL0 WLRQL HW LPSHULR 1RVWUR111ª,> LO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD DYUHEEH LQILQH IXQ]LRQD0 WR GD JLXGLFH RUGLQDULR GL VHFRQGD R WHU]D LVWDQ]D OLPLWDWDPHQWH DO WHUULWRULR IHUUDUHVH451 $ SDUWH TXHVW·XOWLPD LSRWHVL/ SHU LO UHVWR VL WUDWWDYD GL TXHOO·DPSLR SRWHUH GLVFUH]LRQDOH VSHWWDQWH DO GXFD LQ TXDQWR YLFDULR LPSHULDOH HG RUD H0 VSUHVVDPHQWH GHOHJDWR DO QXRYR RUJDQR FROOHJLDOH/ LO TXDOH O·DYUHEEH HVHUFLWD0 WR GL FRQFHUWR H LQ QRPH GHO VLJQRUH FRQ SURQXQFH LQDSSHOODELOL1 ²²²²²²²² ; /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 46 6V1> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 44/ 46/ 4:04;> 01 &$5$9$/(/ *OL RUGLQDPHQWL JLXULGLFL GHOO·(XURSD PHGLHYDOH/ %RORJQD/ LO 0XOLQR/ 4<<7/ S1 997> (1 0,/$12/ &DVD G·(VWH111 FLW1/ S1 7;1 < $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ /HJJL H GHFUHWL/ VH]1 %/ UHJLVWUR 9,/ FF1 455U0Y +SS1 56<0573,1 6X WDOH GHFUHWR/ ,1 )$51(7,/ /·HYROX]LRQH GHOOD JLXVWL]LD D )HUUDUD +UHSXEEOLFD 0 GXFDWR 0 JRYHUQR SRQWLIL0 FLR,/ LQ ©$WWL GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GHOOH VFLHQ]H GL )HUUDUDª/ 68 +4<8:08;,/ SS1 :<0;3 HG HGL]LRQH DOOH SS1 <3 6V1> )1 9$/(17,/ , &RQVLJOL GL JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ SS1 59 6V1> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 63064> /1 785&+,/ /D JLXVWL]LD111 FLW1/ SS1 56: 6V1 43 81 3(7521,2/ ,O 6HQDWR GL 0LODQR1 ,VWLWX]LRQL JLXULGLFKH HG HVHUFL]LR GHO SRWHUH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0LODQR GD &DUOR 9 D *LXVHSSH ,,/ ,/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<:5/ SS1 58 VV1 44 &1 02==$5(//,/ ,O 6HQDWR GL 0DQWRYD= RULJLQH H IXQ]LRQL/ LQ 0DQWRYD H L *RQ]DJD QHOOD FLYLOWj GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR1 $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR RUJDQL]]DWR GHOO·$FFDGHPLD 1D]LRQDOH GHL /LQFHL H GDOO·$FFDGHPLD 9LUJLOLDQD1 0DQWRYD 90; RWWREUH 4<:7/ 6HJUDWH/ (GLJUDI/ 4<:;/ S1 9;1 45 ,O ULFRUVR DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD GXFDOH HUD SUHYLVWR LQ FDVR GL DQQXOODPHQWR/ UHYRFD R UHIRUPDWLR GL VHQWHQ]D G·DSSHOOR +6WDWXWD FLYLWDWLV )HUUDULH/ )HUUDULH/ SHU 6HYHULQXP )HUUDULHQ0 VHP/ 47:9/ OLE1 ,,/ >UXE1 49@/ ´$Q D VHQWHQWLD ODWD LQ FDXVD DSSHOODWLRQLV OLFHDW DSSHOODUH HW GH PRGR SURFHGHQGLµ/ >F1 67U@,1 6XO IXQ]LRQDPHQWR GHOOD JLXVWL]LD FRPXQDOH IHUUDUHVH H OD VXD LQWHJUD]LRQH FRQ JOL RUJDQL GXFDOL/ VHFRQGR TXDQWR SUHYLVWR GDJOL VWDWXWL GHO 47:9/ /1 785&+,/ /D JLXVWL]LD111 FLW1/ SS1 5<5 6V1
<3;
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
/D PDJJLRUH QRYLWj LQWURGRWWD QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHO SHULRGR IHUUDUHVH 0 SRL HVSRUWDWD QHOOD QXRYD FDSLWDOH H ULGHILQLWD QHOOD ULIRUPD GHO 494<46 0 IX TXHOOD GL XQ XOWHULRUH VXSUHPR RUJDQR SROLWLFR0JLXGL]LDULR/ LO &RQVLJOLR GL 6HJQDWX0 UD/ LO TXDOH/ VHFRQGR WHVWLPRQLDQ]H LQGLUHWWH47/ IX LVWLWXLWR GD (UFROH ,, DWWRU0 QR DOOD PHWj GHO VHF1 ;9, DO ILQH GL DUJLQDUH LO IHQRPHQR GHOO·DFFRJOLPHQWR LQGLVFULPLQDWR GHOOH VXSSOLFKH GD SDUWH GHO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD1 /H VXSSOLFKH ULVXOWDYDQR RUD HVVHUH GL GXH WLSL/ GL JUD]LD H GL JLXVWL]LD/ H D WDOH ULSDUWL]LRQH DYUHEEHUR FRUULVSRVWR/ LQ SLHQD DGHVLRQH DO PRGHOOR YDWLFD0 QR/ XQD 6HJQDWXUD ´GL JUD]LDµ HG XQD ´GL JLXVWL]LDµ481 /H VXSSOLFKH ´GL JUD]LDµ VROOHFLWDYDQR XQ SURYYHGLPHQWR VWUDRUGLQDULR GHO VRYUDQR/ FKH SRWHYD FRQ0 FHGHUOR R PHQR VXOOD YDOXWD]LRQH GL FLUFRVWDQ]H GL RSSRUWXQLWj GL FDUDWWHUH SHUVRQDOH R SHU FRVu GLUH ¶SROLWLFR· SLXWWRVWR FKH VXOO·DFFHUWDPHQWR GL GHWHU0 PLQDWL SUHVXSSRVWL JLXULGLFL1 'HOOH TXHVWLRQL DJLWDWH LQYHFH GDO VHFRQGR WLSR GL VXSSOLFKH/ TXHOOH ´GL JLXVWL]LDµ/ LO SULQFLSH LQYHVWLYD OD 6HJQDWXUD/ FKH/ RYH DFFROWD O·LVWDQ]D/ SURYYHGHYD D VXD YROWD FRQ XQ ´UHVFULWWRµ49/ ILQDOL]]DWR/ GL UHJROD/ D ´FRPPHWWHUHµ OD FDXVD DG XQ JLXGLFH RUGLQDULR R GHOHJDWR RSSXUH/ ²²²²²²²² 46 )1 9$/(17,/ , &RQVLJOL GL JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ S1 6<> 3161 /(,&+7/ 6WRULD GHO GLULWWR LWDOLDQR1 ,O GLULW0 WR SXEEOLFR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<:516/ S1 679> /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 4370438> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ S1 6:06; H 73> *1 %('21,/ /·XIILFLR GL JRYHUQDWRUH QHL GXFDWL HVWHQ0 VL/ TXDOH RUJDQR SHULIHULFR FRQ FRPSHWHQ]D JHQHUDOH +485:04:;3,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD0 ]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ 48 +4<<6,/ S1 4:4> '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH QHO SHULRGR PRGHQHVH/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD GHJOL DUFKLYL GL 6WDWRª/ 881506 +4<<8,/ SS1 647 6V1 47 6HFRQGR XQD ¶PHPRULD· +FRQVHUYDWD LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ &RQVLJOL/ JLXQWH FRQVXOWH/ UHJJHQ]H/ EXVWD Qƒ 47E, GL *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD /DGHUFKL/ O·LQIOXHQWH VHJUHWDULR LPROHVH FKH VHJXu FRPH SURWDJRQLVWD OH YLFHQGH GHO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHOOD FDSLWDOH GD )HUUDUD D 0RGHQD1 6XO /D0 GHUFKL/ 51 0217$*1$1,/ *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD /DGHUFKL QHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH +48:50494;,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª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q/ 4<;</ SS1 <74 6V1 49 6XO FRQFHWWR GL ´UHVFULWWRµ/ LQWHVR TXDOH ©GHFLVLRQH VRYUDQD QHO FDVR VLQJROR/ VSHFLDO0 PHQWH LQ PDWHULD JLXGL]LDULDª/ VL YHGDQR OH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL SURSRVWH GD &1 02==$5(//,/ ,O 6HQDWR GL 0DQWRYD111 FLW1/ S1 ;5/ VXOOD VFRUWD GL TXDQWR JLj HYLGHQ]LDWR GD 81 1,&2/,1,/ /D SUR0 SULHWj/ LO SULQFLSH H O·HVSURSULD]LRQH SHU SXEEOLFD XWLOLWj1 6WXGL VXOOD GRWWULQD JLXULGLFD LQWHUPHGLD/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq 4<85 +ULVW1 GHOOD 4• HG1 4<73,/ S1 4;41
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<3<
ULFRUUHQGR FHUWH LSRWHVL/ DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD4:1 /H LSRWHVL GL ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ DO &RQVLOLXP ,XVWLWLDH FRLQFLGHYDQR LQ SDUWH FRQ TXHOOH JLj SUHYLVWH GDO GHFUHWR GL %RUVR GHO 4786= FDXVH ´SULYLOHJLD0 WHµ+SXSLOOL/ YHGRYH/ IDQFLXOOH/ SRYHUL/ LQIHUPL/ PDODWL PHQWDOL/ PD SRL DQFKH/ SHU HVWHQVLRQH/ ´FDXVH SLHµ/ GL DOLPHQWL H GRWDOL, H FDXVH G·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GL QRUPH H SURYYHGLPHQWL GXFDOL> DOWUH VL HUDQR SRL DQGDWH SUHFLVDQGR QRQ VROR LQ FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ OD TXDOLWj GL VXSHULRU IHXGDOH GHO GXFH/ PD DQFKH LQ IXQ0 ]LRQH GL TXHO JHQHUDOH SRWHUH VRYUDQR GL DFFRJOLHUH OH VXSSOLFKH GHL SULYDWL R GL LQWHUYHQLUH LQ TXDOVLDVL JUDGR GL JLXGL]LR TXDORUD IRVVHUR FRLQYROWL VXGGLWL ¶LPPHGLDWL·= FDXVH WUD IHXGDWDUL R WUD FRPXQLWj PXQLFLSDOL/ FRQ VSHFLILFR H ULOHYDQWH ULJXDUGR DJOL LOOHJLWWLPL ´DJJUDYLµ VXL VXGGLWL> FDXVH IHXGDOL> FRQIOLWWR GL JLXULVGL]LRQH WUD RUJDQL JLXGLFDQWL> FDXVH FULPLQDOL ´GL TXDOLWjµ/ FLRq UHODWL0 YH DL SL• JUDYL GHOLWWL4;> QXRYH DVVHJQD]LRQL GL WHUPLQL H LVWDQ]H G·DSSHOOR VWUDRUGLQDULR/ TXDOH OD UHYLVLRQH1 4XHVW·XOWLPD VDUHEEH VWDWD FRQFHVVD GDO VR0 YUDQR ©SHU JLXVWL]LD R SUREDELO FDXVDª VXOOD EDVH GL ©UDJLRQL QXRYDPHQWH GH0 GRWWHª H VDUHEEH VWDWD GHFLVD GDOOR VWHVVR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD LQWHJUDWR GD XQR R SL• FRQVLJOLHUL GL 6HJQDWXUD1 ,O &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD LQWHUYHQLYD TXLQGL GRSR OD ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ DG KRF GHOOD 6HJQDWXUD/ OD TXDOH DYHYD/ DOPHQR LQ OLQHD GL SULQFLSLR/ VROR LO FRPSLWR ²²²²²²²² 4: 8Q VDJJLR DVVROXWDPHQWH SDU]LDOH DL YROXPL GHL ´SURFHVVLµ GHO IRQGR UHODWLYR DL &RQVL0 JOL GL 6HJQDWXUD H GL *LXVWL]LD SHU LO VHF1 ;9,, +$602/ $UFKLYL JLXGL]LDUL/ &RQVLJOL GL 6HJQDWXUD H GL *LXVWL]LD, KD HYLGHQ]LDWR FRPH SHU OD PDVVLPD SDUWH LO SULPR GRFXPHQWR GHOO·LQFDUWDPHQWR SURFHVVXDOH FRQVLVWD QHOO·DFFRJOLPHQWR GHOOD VXSSOLFD GD SDUWH GHOOD 6HJQD0 WXUD/ FRQ FRQVHJXHQWH ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD1 2SSXUH YL q OD GHVFUL]LRQH GHO FDVR SULQFLSDOH GD SDUWH GL XQ FRQVLJOLHUH GL 6HJQDWXUD FRQ O·DFFRJOLPHQWR GHOOD ULFKLHVWD GL ´UHYRFDµ GHOOD VHQWHQ]D GL SULPR R VHFRQGR JUDGR HPHVVD GDO JLXGLFH RUGLQDULR1 4XDQWR DL GHFUHWL UHJLVWUDWL QHL YROXPL ´FLYLOH0GHFUHWLµ GHOOR VWHVVR IRQGR/ QRUPDOPHQWH O·LQFLSLW VH0 JQDOD LO WULEXQDOH SUHVVR FXL YLHQH GLVFXVVD OD FDXVD +©,Q FDXVD YHUVD HW YHUWHQWH FRUDP ,OO1PR &RQVLOLR 'XFDOL ,XVWLWLDH 0XW1ª,> D FXL VHJXH O·LQWHVWD]LRQH FRQ L QRPL GHOOH SDUWL H TXLQGL O·HVSUHVVLRQH ©IXLW DE HRGHP ,OO1PR &RQVLOLR GHFUHWDWXP HW GHFLVXP XW LQ LQIUDª> LQILQH LO GL0 VSRVLWLYR/ LQ FXL O·,OOXVWULVVLPR &RQVLJOLR +©,OOXVWULVVLPXP &RQVLOLXPª/ FKH q TXDVL VHPSUH TXHOOR GL *LXVWL]LD, ©GHFODUDYLWª/ ©FHQVXLWª/ ©DEVROYLWª/ ©FRQGHPQDYLWª/ ©PDQGDYLWª/ ©FRQILU0 PDYLWª HFF1 3HU XQ·DQDOLVL/ VHSSXU VRPPDULD/ GHOOD WLSRORJLD GHOOH VXSSOLFKH LQGLUL]]DWH DOOD 6HJQDWXUD/ '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL111 FLW1/ SS1 66406661 4; 1RQ HUD LQIUHTXHQWH FKH XQ VLQJROR FRQVLJOLHUH GL JLXVWL]LD IRVVH LQYHVWLWR GDO GXFD GL XQD YHVWH ¶LQTXLUHQWH· GL SL• DPSLD SRUWDWD= FRVu SHU $FKLOOH )DQWLQL/ FKH OH OHWWHUH SDWHQWL GHO 5; JLXJQR 48;8 SURYYLGHUR DG LQYLDUH LQ *DUIDJQDQD FRQ LO PDQGDWR GL DFFHUWDUH L FROSHYROL GL DOFXQL GHOLWWL H FRQ O·©DPSOD HW RQQLPRGD SRWHVWj GL FDUFHUDUH HW IDUH WXWWR TXHOOR FKH JLX0 GLFKHUj FRQYHQLHQWHª +$602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ 'HFUHWL H FKLURJUDIL VFLROWL/ E1 6,1
<43
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
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·DSSHOOR LO ULFRUVR RUGLQDULR DO JLXGLFH LQ PDOHILFLLV R DO SUHWRUH H/ QHOO·LSRWHVL G·LPSUDWLFDELOLWj GHOOD YLD RUGLQDULD/ DG XQ GRWWRUH GHO &ROOHJLR GHL JLXULVWL53= XQD GHOLFDWD TXHVWLRQH FKH ULVFKLDYD GL SRUUH LO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD LQ URWWD GL FROOLVLRQH FRQ OH LVWLWX]LRQL PRGH0 QHVL H FKH IX HVDPLQDWD QHL SULPL DQQL GHO ·933 GDL FROODERUDWRUL GHO GXFD54/ ULVROWD LQILQH QHO VHJQR GL XQ IRUPDOH ULVSHWWR GHJOL VWDWXWL/ VDOYD VHPSUH SHUz OD SRVVLELOLWj GL XQ·DYRFD]LRQH LQ VHJXLWR D ´VSHFLDO UHVFULWWRµ GXFDOH551 ²²²²²²²² 4<
9D FRPXQTXH VHJQDODWR FKH OD 6HJQDWXUD/ VHPSUH QHOOD VXD YHVWH GL UDSSUHVHQWDQWH LPPHGLDWD GHO SULQFLSH/ SRWHYD SURYYHGHUH GLUHWWDPHQWH H DXWRQRPDPHQWH LQ PDWHULD GL IH0 GHFRPPHVVL +SURURJD/ SHUPXWD H VRSUDWWXWWR GHURJKH,/ GL GHSRVLWR GL GHQDUR H GL VDOYDFRQ0 GRWWL/ DQFKH VH QRQ HUD HVFOXVD DQFKH SHU TXHVWH PDWHULH OD ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD FXP FDXVDH FRJQLWLRQH1 53 /LEUL TXLQTXH VWDWXWRUXP LQFO\WDH FLYLWDWLV 0XWLQDH/ 0XWLQDH/ DSXG ,RKDQQHP GH 1LFROLV/ 487:/ OLE1 ,,/ UXEU1 7</ ´$G TXRV DSSHOODQGXP VLWµ/ FF1 54Y055U1 &IU1 *1 %('21,/ 0RGHQD/ 487:111 FLW1/ SS1 453 H 4551 54 (PLOLR &DVDWL H *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD /DGHUFKL VL PRVWUDYDQR SUHRFFXSDWL GHOO·LQYDGHQ]D FKH LO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD DYUHEEH SRWXWR UDSSUHVHQWDUH SHU OH LVWLWX]LRQL PRGHQHVL> G·DOWUD SDUWH/ VH )XOYLR 3DFFLDQL ULWHQHYD LQXWLOH/ VH QRQ GDQQRVD/ OD GXSOLFLWj GL 6HJQDWXUD H &RQVL0 JOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ 0DWWHR %DUDFFKL/ FRQWHVWDQGR HVSOLFLWDPHQWH OH RSLQLRQL GHO 3DFFLDQL/ ULWH0 QHYD QHFHVVDULR DWWULEXLUH DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD L JLXGL]L GL WHU]D LVWDQ]D DQFKH SHU LO WHUUL0 WRULR PRGHQHVH1 ,O GLEDWWLWR TXL VLQWHWLFDPHQWH ULDVVXQWR q TXHOOR HPHUJHQWH GDOOH ¶PHPRULH· H UHOD]LRQL FRPPLVVLRQDWH GDO GXFD &HVDUH , WUD LO 4943 HG LO 4948 LQ YLVWD GL XQD ULIRUPD GHO VXSUHPR WULEXQDOH= FIU1 51 0217$*1$1,/ *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD /DGHUFKL111 FLW1/ SS1 473 H 483/ H '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL111 FLW1/ SS1 64506471 55 /H ´GLFKLDUDWLRQL H GHWHUPLQDWLRQLµ GL &HVDUH G·(VWH +$602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ &RQVLJOL/ JLXQWH/ FRQVXOWH/ UHJJHQ]H/ E1 47E,/ ULVDOHQWL DOOD ILQH GHJOL DQQL ·43 GHO VHF1 ;9, H GLUHWWH DL &RQVL0 JOL GL 6HJQDWXUD H GL *LXVWL]LD/ IDFHYDQR VDOYL WUD O·DOWUR WXWWL TXHJOL VWDWXWL ORFDOL/ LQ VSHFLDO PRGR GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ FKH DYHVVHUR SUHYLVWR SHU OH WHU]H LVWDQ]H XQ PDJLVWUDWR GLYHUVR GDO &RQVLJOLR GXFDOH/ PD LQ UHDOWj ILQLYDQR SHU YDQLILFDUH WDOH ULFRQRVFLPHQWR IRUPDOH Oj GR0 YH ULVHUYDYDQR DO GXFD OD IDFROWj LUULQXQFLDELOH GL XQD ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ LQ YLD VWUDRUGLQDULD DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD= ©V·LQWHQGD VHPSUH ULVHUYDWD OD QRVWUD YRORQWj/ SHUFKp VH LQ DOFXQD FDX0 VD SDUHVVH EHQH LO FRPHWWHUOH DO PHGHVLPR &RQVHJOLR/ YRJOLDPR FKH VL SRVVD IDUH/ KDYXWRQH SHUz O·RUGLQH QRVWUR HVSUHVVR LQ TXHO FDVR VROR R QRVWUR VSHFLDO UHVFULWWRª1
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<44
0D/ D SDUWH OD SULPD VLVWHPD]LRQH RSHUDWD GD &HVDUH QHL SULPL DQQL GL WUD0 VIHULPHQWR GHOOD &DSLWDOH56/ ELVRJQHUj DWWHQGHUH LO VHF1 ;9,,, SHUFKp O·LQL]LDWLYD GXFDOH LQ IDWWR GL JLXVWL]LD DVVXPD L FRQWRUQL GL XQ SURJHWWR GL UL0 IRUPD RUJDQLFR HG XQLWDULR1 (SSXUH LO SULPR LQWHUYHQWR LQ WDO VHQVR/ TXHOOR GHO FHOHEUH 5HJRODPHQWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, GHO 4:7307457/ VL SRQHYD SURJUDPPD0 ²²²²²²²² 56
/H ´GLFKLDUDWLRQL H GHWHUPLQDWLRQLµ GL FXL DOOD QW1 SUHF1 VL OLPLWDYDQR/ SHU OD 6HJQDWXUD/ D VDQ]LRQDUH DOFXQL FULWHUL SHU OD SUHVHQWD]LRQH GHOOH VXSSOLFKH/ O·HPLVVLRQH GHL UHVFULWWL/ OD FRQFHVVLRQH GHOOH ´LQLEL]LRQLµ 0 VHQVLELOPHQWH ULGRWWH 0 / OD ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ GHOOH FDXVH 0 GD UHDOL]]DUH ©VHQ]D SURFHVVR R IRUPD GL JLXGLWLR LQ XQD R GXH XGLHQ]Hª 0/ L ULFRUVL LQ DSSHOOR R LQ UHYLVLRQH/ OD OHJLWWLPD VXVSLFLRQH/ QRQFKp SHU O·DFFRJOLPHQWR GHOOH ULFKLHVWH GL GHURJKH/ VDOYDFRQGRWWL/ SULYLOHJL HFF1 4XDQWR DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ YHQLYD ULEDGLWD OD VXD FRPSH0 WHQ]D D ©FRQRVFHUH H GLIILQLUH OH FDXVH FLYLOL GD GHOHJDUVHJOL R SHU QRVWUR UHVFULWWR R SHU GH0 FUHWR GHO QRVWUR &RQVHJOLR GL 6HJQDWXUDª/ FDXVH SHU OH TXDOL DYUHEEH SURFHGXWR ©ULJXDUGDWD OD VROD YHULWj GHO IDWWR H FRQ PDQ UHJJLD/ VHQ]D VWUHSLWR H ILJXUD GL JLXGLWLR H VHQ]D VHUYDU DOFXQD VROHQQLWj/ RUGLQH RG LQVWDQ]D VWDWXWDULD R OHJDOHª> OD VXD JLXULVGL]LRQH DQGDYD HVWHVD LQROWUH D WXWWH TXHOOH PDWHULH GL FXL OD SUDVVL DYHYD QHO WHPSR/ GDO 4786 LQ SRL/ FRQVROLGDWR OD FRPSH0 WHQ]D/ FRQ XQD VSHFLDOH DWWHQ]LRQH DOOH UHYLVLRQL 0 GD ULFKLHGHUVL HQWUR TXDWWUR JLRUQL GDOOD SURQXQFLD GHILQLWLYD H GD FRQFHGHUVL QRQ VROR ©SHU JLXVWL]LD R SUREDELO FDXVDª/ PD ©DQFKH SHU UDJLRQL FKH QRYDPHQWH IRVVRQR GHGRWWLª 0 H DOOH FDXVH FULPLQDOL/ GHOHJDWH ©DG XQR GH· SUHGHWWL FRQVLJOLHUL RG DQFKH DO &RQVHJOLR WXWWR SUHGHWWR/ FRP·D 1RL SDUUj FRQYHQLUVLª1 /·XQLFD SUHFLVD]LRQH GL ULOLHYR HUD TXHOOD GL FRQVLGHUDUH OD 6HJQDWXUD FRPH O·HVFOXVLYD LQWHU0 SUHWH XIILFLDOH GL ´SULYLOHJLµ/ ´VWDWXWLµ H ´UHVFULWWLµ/ D WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOD SURJUHVVLYD FRQFHQ0 WUD]LRQH GL FRPSHWHQ]H SUHVVR WDOH RUJDQR H GHO SDUDOOHOR ULSLHJDPHQWR GHO &RQVLJOLR GL *LX0 VWL]LD VX XQ WHUUHQR SL• VTXLVLWDPHQWH JLXGL]LDULR/ DQFKH VH LQ YHULWj VL GHYH UHJLVWUDUH OD QRQ LQIUHTXHQWH SUDVVL GL ULXQLUH LQ VHGXWD FRQJLXQWD L GXH FRQVLJOL SHU OH FRQWURYHUVLH GL PDJJLRU SHVR/ FRPH SRWHYDQR HVVHUH TXHOOH GL FDUDWWHUH LQWHUSUHWDWLYR1 $OWUD QRYLWj TXHOOD UHODWLYD DJOL VWDWXWL ORFDOL GL FXL V·q GHWWR DOOD QW1 SUHF1 57 5HJRODPHQWR HG RUGLQL GL 61$1 6HUHQLVVLPD GD RVVHUYDUVL GDL FRQVLJOL/ PDJLVWUDWL H WULEXQDOL GL 0R0 GHQD SHU OR JRYHUQR SROLWLFR/ FLYLOH HG HFRQRPLFR GH· VXRL GRPLQv/ SXEEOLFDWR LO 63 GLFHPEUH 4:73 +PD JLj SUHGLVSRVWR O·DQQR SULPD, HG HQWUDWR LQ YLJRUH FRO 4ƒ JHQQDLR GHOO·DQQR VXFFHVVLYR +GXH HVHPSODUL LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 9/ Q1 49;/ H LYL/ &RQVLJOL/ JLXQWH/ FRQVXOWH/ UHJJHQ]H/ EXVWD Qƒ 47E,1 6X WDOH 5HJRODPHQWR/ /1 %8/)(5(77,/ /·DVVROXWLVPR LOOXPLQDWR LQ ,WDOLD +4:3304:;<,/ 0LODQR/ ,VWLWXWR SHU JOL VWXGL GL SROLWLFD LQWHUQD0 ]LRQDOH/ 4<77/ SS1 887088; +FKH VL OLPLWD D SXEEOLFDUH OD SDUWH GHO 5HJRODPHQWR UHODWLYD DO 0DJLVWUDWR GL &RPPHUFLR,> 01$1 $%(/621/ /H VWUXWWXUH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH QHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*LGHDOH GHO %XRQ *RYHUQR +4:6:04:88,/ LQ ©5LYLVWD VWRULFD LWDOLDQDª/ ;416 +4<9<,/ SS1 836 6V1> )1 /$1&(//277,/ /D QRUPDWLYD H OD OHWWHUDWXUD GL GLULWWR SURFHVVXDOH FLYLOH QHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGH0 QD/ 6171(101 0 0XFFKL/ 4<::/ SS1 89 QW1 6/ 47048 H QW1 58> /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 4540455> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 :6/ :;/ ;6/ 457/ 54<0558> *1 6(9(5,/ $F0 FHQWUDPHQWR H GLYLVLRQH GHL SRWHUL LQ DOFXQH ULIRUPH SROLWLFR0DPPLQLVWUDWLYH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, H GL (UFROH ,,, +4:8:04:;3,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH SURYLQFLH PRGHQH0 VLª/ V1 ;,/ ; +4<;9,/ SS1 6730674> &1 %$5*(//,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH QHL VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,,= DVSHWWL
<45
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
WLFDPHQWH SL• FKH DOWUR QHO VHJQR GL XQD ¶FULVWDOOL]]D]LRQH· GHOOD QRUPDWLYD H GHOOD SUDVVL YLJHQWL/ DO OLPLWDWR PD XWLOLVVLPR ILQH GL FKLDULUH OH ]RQH ODVFLDWH LQ RPEUD GD XQ·HVSHULHQ]D VHFRODUH QRQ SULYD GL LQFRQYHQLHQWL H LQFHUWH]]H1 ,Q UHDOWj/ HUD TXL SUHVHQWH LO WHQWDWLYR GL GDUH VWDELOLWj DO IXQ]LRQDPHQWR GL WXWWL JOL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL GHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH 0 GDOOD 6HJQDWXUD DO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL0 ]LD/ GDOOD &DPHUD GXFDOH DO 0DJLVWUDWR GL DFTXH H VWUDGH H D TXHOOR SHU LO FRPPHUFLR 0/ PD VHQ]D DOFXQD VRVWDQ]LDOH QRYLWj FKH QRQ IRVVH DSSXQWR TXHOOD GL XQD FRQVLGHUD]LRQH JOREDOH GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FHQWUDOH1 ,Q HVVR VL ULEDGLYD OD GLVWLQ]LRQH GL XQD 6HJQDWXUD ´GL JUD]LDµ HG XQD ´GL JLXVWL]LDµ= DOOD SULPD VSHWWDYDQR WXWWH OH FRQFHVVLRQL GL GLULWWR VLQJRODUH R HF0 FH]LRQDOH> DOOD VHFRQGD WRFFDYD SUHGLVSRUUH OD ´FRPPLVVLRQHµ GHOOH FDXVH ´SULYLOHJLDWHµ H GL DOWUH FKH IRVVHUR JLXQWH DOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GHOOD 6HJQDWXUD/ LQ0 YHVWHQGR LO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD GL TXHOOH GH PDLRULEXV/ FLRq GL YDORUH VXSH0 ULRUH DL 833 VFXGL/ FRQ HVFOXVLRQH GHOOH SHQDOL1 $OOD 6HJQDWXUD GL JLXVWL]LD LQ0 FRPEHYD SRL LO ULOHYDQWH FRPSLWR GL DYYLDUH/ RYH FRQVHQWLWR/ OD UHYLVLRQH GHO0 OH VHQWHQ]H SDVVDWH LQ JLXGLFDWR H/ QHL FDVL SL• ULOHYDQWL/ LQWHJUDUH LO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD QHOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHO FROOHJLR JLXGLFDQWH1 1RQ PDQFDYD LQROWUH OD ULDIIHUPD]LRQH GL XQ LQWHUHVVH VRYUDQR SUHGRPLQDQWH SHU OD JLXVWL]LD SHQD0 OH/ LQWHUHVVH UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDOO·XGLWRUH FULPLQDOH JHQHUDOH/ QRQ QXRYD PDJL0 VWUDWXUD FHQWUDOH DEROLWD DSSHQD TXDOFKH GHFHQQLR SL• WDUGL581 0D LO WUDYDJOLR ULIRUPLVWLFR HUD DQFRUD WXWWR GD YHQLUH1 'RSR O·HVSHULPHQWR GL UHQGHUH SL• ¶OLPSLGD· O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FHQWUDOH XQLILFDQGR OH IXQ]LRQL GL WULEXQDOH VXSUHPR SUHVVR OD 6HJQDWXUD59/ VL JLXQJHYD DO FKLUR0 JUDIR GHO 54 RWWREUH 4:94/ FKH VHJQDYD OD GDWD GL QDVFLWD GHO 6XSUHPR &RQVL0 ²²²²²²²² HFRQRPLFL H VRFLDOL D 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH/ LQ 'XHFHQWRFLQTXDQW·DQQL GL FHUDPLFD D 6DVVXROR/ YRO1 ,/ 'DOOD PD0 QLIDWWXUD DOOD ´)DEEULFDµ/ 0RGHQD/ &RSWLS/ 4<<4/ SS1 74075 H 76077> '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQ0 WUDOL111 FLW1/ SS1 659065:> &1(1 7$9,//$/ 8Q SURJHWWR GL ULIRUPD GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH +4:9:,/ LQ ©6WXGL SDUPHQVLª/ 75 +4<<9,/ SS1 57:057;1 58 8Q XGLWRUH ILVFDOH HUD VWDWR LQWURGRWWR FRQ L FDSLWROL GL )UDQFHVFR , GHO 54 PDU]R 496: +$602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 &/ Qƒ 659,/ GLYHQHQGR SRL ´FULPLQDOH JHQHUDOHµ FRQ L FDSLWROL GHO 55 JHQQDLR 4:34 +$602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 +/ Q1 <9, H GHO 46 DJRVWR 4:6; +ULSXEEOLFDWL LQ DSSHQGLFH DO 5HJR0 ODPHQWR GHO ·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
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<46
JOLR GL *LXVWL]LD5:1 &RQFHSLWR FRPH RUJDQR FROOHJLDOH GRWDWR GHOOD ©VXSUHPD JLXGLFDWXUD GHOOH FDXVH FLYLOL/ FULPLQDOL H PLVWHª/ HVVR VDUHEEH VWDWR LO GHVWLQD0 WDULR GL WXWWH OH LVWDQ]H ILQR DG DOORUD LQGLUL]]DWH DOOD 6HJQDWXUD/ SLHQR WLWRODUH GHL JLXGL]L GL UHYLVLRQH/ QRQFKp DXWRUHYROH VXSHUYLVRUH GHO IXQ]LRQDPHQWR GHOOD JLXVWL]LD ORFDOH1 ,QROWUH YHQLYDQR FRQVHJQDWL GHILQLWLYDPHQWH DO QXRYR DOWR WULEXQDOH/ DFFRJOLHQGR OD WUDGL]LRQH ULVDOHQWH DO GHFUHWR GL %RUVR GHO 4786/ O·HVDPH H OD GHFLVLRQH GL ©TXDOXQTXH GXEELR HG DUWLFROR OHJDOHª5; FKH DQFRUD LO 5HJRODPHQWR GHO ·73 DIILGDYD DL GXH FRQVLJOL GL 6HJQDWXUD H GL *LX0 VWL]LD LQ VHGXWD SOHQDULD/ ©PDVVLPDPHQWH TXDQGR IRVVHUR WDOL FDXVH G·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GL VWDWXWL R GL TXDOVLYRJOLD DUWLFROR JUDYHª5<1 0D QRQ GREELDPR SHQVDUH FKH O·LVWLWX]LRQH GL WDOH VXSUHPR RUJDQR WURQ0 FDVVH GL FROSR LO ILWWR LQWUHFFLR GL DPELJXLWj H LQFRQJUXHQ]H GD FXL LO VLVWHPD ²²²²²²²² 5: ,O FKLURJUDIR q HGLWR LQ *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 537053;11 ,O 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD q VWDWR IDWWR RJJHWWR DVVDL VSHVVR/ DQFKH VH QRQ VHPSUH LQ PDQLHUD DS0 SURIRQGLWD/ GHOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GHOOD VWRULRJUDILD JLXULGLFD H QRQ= ULFRUGLDPR LQ SDUWLFRODUH *1 6$/9,2/,/ 0LVFHOODQHD GL OHJLVOD]LRQH HVWHQVH/ 3DOHUPR/ 3XFFLR/ 4;<;/ S1 67> ,'1/ 6WRULD GHOOD SURFHGX0 UD FLYLOH H FULPLQDOH/ YRO1 ,,/ LQ 6WRULD GHO GLULWWR LWDOLDQR/ D FXUD GL 31 '(/ *,8',&(/ ,,,15/ 0LODQR/ +RHSOL/ 4<5: +ULVW1 DQ1 )UDQNIXUW D1010)LUHQ]H/ 6DXHU ) $XYHUPDQQ 0 *R]]LQL/ 4<9<,/ S1 6;> '1 &255$',1,/ *DUDQWLVPR H VWDWXDOLVPR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<:4/ SS1 53054> *1 *25/$/ , SUHFH0 GHQWL VWRULFL GHOO·DUW1 45 GLVS1 SUHO1 FRG1 FLY1/ RUD LQ ,'1/ 'LULWWR FRPSDUDWR H GLULWWR FRPXQH HXURSHR/ 0LOD0 QR/ *LXIIUq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q 4<:</ SS1 5<305<4> 01 7$58))2/ /D JLXVWL]LD FLYLOH LQ ,WDOLD GDO ·:33 D RJJL/ %RORJQD/ LO 0XOLQR/ 4<;3/ S1 63> 21 520%$/',/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH/ ,/ 6WDWR H VRFLHWj QHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH1 &RQWULEXWL GL VWXGLR/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;5/ SS1 66 VV1> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 ;30;6> 01 $6&+(5,/ 7ULEXQDOL JLXULVWL H LVWLWX]LRQL GDO PHGLRHYR DOO·HWj PRGHUQD/ %R0 ORJQD/ LO 0XOLQR/ 4<;</ S1 435> 51 6(9(5,/ $FFHQWUDPHQWR111 FLW1/ SS1 6740677 H 685> '1 &$53$1(772 0 *1 5,&83(5$7,/ /·,WDOLD GHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 &ULVL/ WUDVIRUPD]LRQL/ OXPL/ 5RPD0%DUL/ 5 /DWHU]D/ 4<<6 / SS1 5540555> $1 0$57,1,/ ,O FRGLFH FULPLQDOH HVWHQVH GHO 4;88/ LQ ,O GLULWWR SHQDOH GHOO·2WWRFHQWR1 , FRGLFL SUHXQLWDUL H LO FRGLFH =DQDUGHOOL/ D F1 GL 61 9,1&,*8(55$/ 3DGRYD/ &('$0/ S1 636> '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL111 FLW1/ SS1 65;065<1 6X TXHVWR VXSUHPR WULEXQDOH/ GDOOD GDWD GL FUHD]LRQH DOO·DYYHQWR GHOOH WUXSSH QDSROHRQLFKH/ FRQGXFR GD TXDOFKH DQQR XQD ULFHU0 FD GL FXL VSHUR WUD QRQ PROWR GL SXEEOLFDUH L ULVXOWDWL1 5; &RQ DOWUR FKLURJUDIR GHOOR VWHVVR 54 RWWREUH 4:94/ LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ 'HFUHWL H FKLURJUDIL VFLROWL/ E1 45> DOWUR HVHPSODUH/ LYL/ &KLURJUDIL GXFDOL/ YRO1 %/ F1 56; 1 5< 5HJRODPHQWR111 FLW1/ ©2EEOLJD]LRQL SDUWLFRODUL H FRPXQL GHOO·XQR H GHOO·DOWUR &RQVLJOLR GL 6HJQDWXUD H GL *LXVWL]LDª/ S1 681
<47
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
JLXGL]LDULR HVWHQVH/ DO SDUL GL DOWUL GHOO·HSRFD/ HUD FRQWUDVVHJQDWR1 1RQ VL H0 VWLQJXHYD LQ SULPR OXRJR OD GLDOHWWLFD FRQ OD 6HJQDWXUD ² ULTXDOLILFDWD GDO 4:9: FRPH 7DYROD GL 6WDWR/63 ² OD TXDOH QRQ ULQXQFLDYD LQ YLD ¶SROLWLFD· DG H0 VHUFLWDUH IRUPH GL SUHVVLRQH R GL DSHUWD LQJHUHQ]D VXOOD PDFFKLQD JLXGL]LDULD/ VRSUDWWXWWR VXO IURQWH SHQDOH1 1p WDQWR PHQR YHQLYD ULFRQGRWWD DG XQLWj OD PROWHSOLFLWj GHOOH JLXULVGL]LRQL/ GL PDWULFH IHXGDOH H PXQLFLSDOH/ FKH DQFRUD FRVWLWXLYDQR JUDQ SDUWH GHO FRQFUHWR VYROJHUVL GHOOD JLXVWL]LD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQ0 VL1 ,O VRIIHUWR UDSSRUWR FRQ OH JLXVGLFHQ]H ORFDOL WURYDYD XQ SXQWR GL VYROWD H GL SUHFDULR HTXLOLEULR QHJOL DQQL ·9609:1 ,O UHJRODPHQWR GHO 45 VHWWHPEUH 4:96 LQQDO]DYD LO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD D ©VROR JLXGLFH GL WXWWL JOL 6WDWL GL 0RGHQD LQ IDWWR FULPLQDOLWjª H VRWWRSRQHYD SHU OD SULPD YROWD DQFKH L JLXGLFL IHXGDOL DG XQD IRUPD GL VXERUGLQD]LRQH DOO·DOWR WULEXQDOH GXFDOH/ REEOLJDQGROL DG XQLIRUPDUVL QHOOD GHFLVLRQH DO ´VHQWLPHQWR ULVROXWLYRµ HVSUHVVR GDO 6X0 SUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD VWHVVR641 /·DFFHVD UHD]LRQH GHL IHXGDWDUL GLHGH YLWD TXDWWUR DQQL GRSR DG XQ XOWHULRUH DVVHWWR FKH VL OLPLWDYD DG DIILGDUH L JLXVGLFHQWL IHXGDOL DOOD FROODERUD]LRQH GL ©XQ LGRQHR FRQVXOWRUH R DXGLWRUH OHJDOHª651 /·LQWHUYHQWR QRUPDWLYR GL PDJJLRUH SRUWDWD H GL SL• DPSLR UHVSLUR q FR0 PXQTXH TXHOOR GHO 5 DSULOH 4:9</ GXH DQQL GRSR WUDVIXVR QHO &RGLFH661 ,O VX0 SUHPR FROOHJLR JLXGLFDQWH ² GLVWLQWR LQ GXH DXOH/ XQD FLYLOH HG XQD FULPLQD0 OH67 ² YHQLYD FRQIHUPDWR ©LO VROR WULEXQDOH FKH DEEUDFFL H FRPSUHQGD OD VX0 SUHPD JLXGLFDWXUD GL WXWWH LQGLVWLQWDPHQWH OH FDXVH FULPLQDOL H FLYLOL H PLVWHª> PD D WDOH JLj DPSOLVVLPD ´VXSUHPD JLXGLFDWXUDµ YHQLYDQR DVVRPPDWL DQFKH LO ²²²²²²²² 63 01$1 $%(/621/ /H VWUXWWXUH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH111 FLW1/ SS1 846 6V1> 91 %(//(,/ /H VWUXWWXUH JLXUL0 GLFR0JRYHUQDWLYH QHOOR VWDWR GL 0RGHQD DOOD ILQH GHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD0 ]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª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·DXOD FLYLOH FKH FULPLQDOH/ LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 ,,/ Q146;6> DOWUD FRSLD LYL/ 'HFUHWL H FKLURJUDIL VFLROWL/ EXVWD Q1451 6X GL HVVR/ )1 /$1&(//277,/ /D QRUPDWLYD111 FLW1/ S1 48> *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH111 FLW1/ SS1 ;50;61 67 &RQ FKLURJUDIR GHO 4; PDJJLR 4:9;/ LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 ++/ Q1 464:1
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<48
FRQWHQ]LRVR GHO VRSSUHVVR WULEXQDOH FDPHUDOH68 ² FRVD FKH SRUWDYD WXWWD OD PDWHULD IHXGDOH VRWWR OD JLXULVGL]LRQH GHO &RQVLJOLR/ ² TXHOOR DSSDUWHQXWR DO 0DJLVWUDWR GL &RPPHUFLR H $JULFROWXUD/ DQFK·HVVR VRSSUHVVR/69 QRQFKp TXHOOR UHODWLYR DL IHGHFRPPHVVL/ DO IRUR PLOLWDUH/ DOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH1 4XDQWR DL ULFRUVL SHU UHYLVLRQH/ OD YLD ´RUGLQDULDµ ² FRQVHQWLWD HVFOXVLYD0 PHQWH LQ SUHVHQ]D GL QXRYL HOHPHQWL QRQ GHGRWWL QHL SUHFHGHQWL JUDGL GL JLX0 GL]LR/ GL SUHWHVD LQJLXVWL]LD R GL SDOHVH LUUHJRODULWj ² HUD TXHOOD FKH SUHYHGHYD O·LQGLUL]]DPHQWR GHO ULFRUVR GLUHWWDPHQWH DO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD HQWUR LO WHUPLQH GL WUH PHVL GDOOD GHFLVLRQH FRQWHVWDWD H FRQVLVWHQWH R LQ ©GXH VHQWHQ]H FRQIRUPL GL JLXGLFL RUGLQDULLª R LQ XQ GHFUHWR GL JLXGLFH GHOHJDWR R/ DQFRUD/ LQ ©GHFUHWL HPDQDWL DQFKH D SLHQL YRWL GDOO·DXOD FLYLOHª +† ;;;,9,1 /H WUH LSRWHVL QRQ ULJXDUGDYDQR SHUz GHFLVLRQL SDVVDWH LQ ´UHJLXGLFDWDµ/ LO FKH DYYHQLYD TXDQGR OD SURQXQFLD GHO JLXGLFH LQIHULRUH IRVVH VWDWD FRQIHUPDWD GDO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR +† ;;;9,1 6XO YHUVDQWH SHQDOH/ LO 5HJRODPHQWR GHO ·9</ QHO QHJDUH OD UHYLVLRQH FRPH ULPHGLR RUGLQDULR DOOH VHQWHQ]H HPHVVH GDOO·DXOD FULPLQDOH GHO &RQVLJOLR/ QH DPPHWWHYD SHUz O·HYHQWXDOLWj ©VROWDQWR LQ FDVR GL VFLVVXUD R SHUSOHVVLWjª +† ;/9,,,,1 /·DVVHWWR GLVHJQDWR WUD ·9< H ·:4 YHUUj QXRYDPHQWH PHVVR LQ GLVFXVVLRQH GD (UFROH ,,, FRQ OD FUHD]LRQH/ QHOO·;8/ GHOOD &RQVXOWD GXFDOH/ RUJDQR SROLWL0 FR0OHJLVODWLYR H QRQ JLXGL]LDULR/ D FXL YHQQH WUD O·DOWUR ULDIILGDWD OD YDOXWD]LRQH GHOOD OHJLWWLPLWj GHOOH LVWDQ]H GL UHYLVLRQH6:1 5LJXDUGR SRL D TXHOOD IXQ]LRQH GL ´LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH DXWHQWLFDµ/ FRQIHUPDWD Vu GDO &RGLFH GHO ·:4 PD D FXL SHU OD YHULWj LO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD QRQ DYHYD PDL SRWXWR IDU IURQWH FRQ SLHQD UHJRODULWj/ HVVD YHQQH HJXDOPHQWH DWWULEXLWD DOOD QXRYD &RQVXOWD/ FKH LQ HIIHWWL GDOO·;8 ULXVFu DG DYYLDUH XQD UHJRODUH SURGX]LRQH GL ´GLFKLDUD]LRQLµ ILQDOL]]DWH DOO·DJJLXVWDPHQWR H DGDWWDPHQWR GHO &RGLFH VWHVVR6;1 4XHVWR PRWR WXWW·DOWUR FKH OLPSLGR GL FRQYXOVR ULIRUPLVPR YHQLYD EUX0 VFDPHQWH LQWHUURWWR QHO 4:<9 GDOO·LQYDVLRQH QDSROHRQLFD1 $ SDUWH LO EUHYH SH0 ULRGR GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD/ FKH YLGH XQ ´WULEXQDOH GL UHYLVLRQH R GL ²²²²²²²² 68
&RQ DOWUR FKLURJUDIR GHOOR VWHVVR 4; PDJJLR 4:9;/ LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ 'HFUHWL H FKLURJUDIL VFLROWL/ EXVWD Q1 451 69 &1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO·DJULFROWXUD PRGHQHVH GDOO·HWj GHOOH ULIRUPH DOOD ILQH GHOOD 5HVWDXUD0 ]LRQH/ LQ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR D 0RGHQD1 $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR/ 0RGHQD ;0< GLFHPEUH 4<94/ 0RGHQD/ 6171(101 0 0XFFKL/ 4<96/ S1 4791 6: &KLURJUDIR GHO 49 RWWREUH 4:;8/ LQ $602/ &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ *ULGDULR/ (/ *ULGH D VWDPSD LQ YROXPL/ YRO1 55/ Q1 5841 6; ¶1RYHOOD]LRQL· VL HEEHUR QHO 4:;9/ 4:;< H 4:<3> FIU1 )1 /$1&(//277,/ /D QRUPDWLYD111 FLW1/ S1 56 H QRWD 741
<49
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
FDVVD]LRQHµ DOWHUQDWLYDPHQWH DWWLYR WUD 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR6</ O·DGHVLRQH DOOD &LVDOSLQD H DO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD FRQGXVVH DOOD FRQFHQWUD]LRQH GL WXWWH OH FDXVH GL XOWLPR JUDGR SUHVVR XQ·XQLFD &RUWH GL &DVVD]LRQH XELFDWD D 0LODQR731 1HOO·H[0FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH UHVWDYD VROWDQWR XQD &RUWH GL JLXVWL]LD FLYLOH H FULPL0 QDOH GL SULPD LVWDQ]D74/ YLVWR FKH L WULEXQDOL G·DSSHOOR/ GL FXL YL IX SURYYLVR0 ULDPHQWH DQFKH XQD VHGH PRGHQHVH QHO 4:<975/ IXURQR FRQFHQWUDWL GDO 4;39 QHOOH VROH WUH FRUWL GL 0LODQR/ %RORJQD H %UHVFLD761 ,O ULWRUQR GHJOL (VWHQVL D 0RGHQD QHO ·47/ VH SXUH ULSRUWz LQ YLWD LO &RGLFH GHO 4::4 HG LO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ QRQ SURGXVVH XQ·LQWHJUDOH GL0 VPLVVLRQH GHJOL DVSHWWL JLXGL]LDUL SL• LQQRYDWLYL LQWURGRWWL GDO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD1 ,O SXQWR GL QRQ ULWRUQR HUD UDSSUHVHQWDWR VRSUDWWXWWR GDOOD VFRPSDUVD GHOOH JLXULVGL]LRQL PXQLFLSDOL/ IHXGDOL H SULYLOHJLDWH/ FRQ OD FRQVHJXHQWH DGR]LRQH GL XQ·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH JLXGL]LDULD DUWLFRODWD EXURFUDWLFDPHQWH LQ YLD JHUDUFKL0 FD1 , GHFUHWL 5; DJRVWR 4;4777 H 7 OXJOLR 4;4878 LQWHUYHQQHUR D ULGLVHJQDUH RU0 ²²²²²²²² 6<
,VWLWXLWR FRQ GHFUHWR GHO 55 RWWREUH 4:<9 +$602/ $UFKLYLR QDSROHRQLFR/ VHULH 76/ *ULGDULR QDSROHRQLFR/ YRO1 4/ Q1 86,1 6L YHGDQR 01 52%(57,/ 0LODQR/ FDSLWDOH QDSROHRQLFD1 /D IRUPD]LRQH GL XQR 6WDWR PRGHUQR 4:<904;47/ YRO1 ,,/ 0LODQR/ )RQGD]LRQH 7UHFFDQL GHJOL $OILHUL SHU OD VWRULD GL 0LODQR/ 4<7:/ S1 587> )1 9$/(17,/ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ LQ *XLGD JHQHUDOH GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR LWDOLDQL/ YRO1 ,,/ 5RPD/ 0LQLVWHUR SHU L EHQL FXOWXUDOL H DPELHQWDOL/ 4<;6/ S1 4366> $1 63$**,$5,/ ,VWLWX]LRQL PRGHQHVL GDO 4:<9 DO 4;48/ LQ 0RGHQD QDSROHRQLFD QHOOD FURQDFD GL $QWRQLR 5RYDWWL1 'DOO·DTXLOD LPSHULDOH DO ULWRUQR GHL )UDQFHVL/ 0RGHQD/ )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<:/ S1 99> 21 520%$/',/ /D 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<:/ S1 5;1 73 ,O VLVWHPD IUDQFR0QDSROHRQLFR/ JLj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j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q VWDWR LQROWUH ULSXEEOLFDWR WUD TXHOOL SUHPHVVL DOO·HGL]LRQH GHO 4;48 GHO &RGLFH HVWHQVH GHO 4::4/ SS1 < 6V1 6X WDOH GHFUHWR/ *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH1 /LQHDPHQWL/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/
/D JLXVWL]LD VXSUHPD QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +VHFF1 ;90;,;,
<4:
JDQLFDPHQWH LO VLVWHPD JLXGL]LDULR HVWHQVH/ DUWLFRODWR LQ WUHQWD JLXVGLFHQ]H/ GXH WULEXQDOL GL JLXVWL]LD D 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR H XQ 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LX0 VWL]LD XELFDWR QHOOD &DSLWDOH H FRPSRVWR GD XQ SUHVLGHQWH H TXDWWUR FRQVLJOLH0 UL/ FRQ IXQ]LRQL GL ©VXSUHPD JLXGLFDWXUD GL WXWWH OH FDXVH FLYLOL H FULPLQDOLª FRPSUHQGHQWH ©WXWWH TXHOOH FDXVH LQ FXL SRWUj DYHU OXRJR OD UHYLVLRQHª791 /D UHYLVLRQH/ XOWLPR H GHILQLWLYR JUDGR GL JLXGL]LR/ VL SRQHYD RUD FKLDUD0 PHQWH FRPH WHU]D LVWDQ]D SURSRQLELOH TXDORUD VL IRVVH UHJLVWUDWD GLVFUHSDQ]D WUD OD SULPD SURQXQFLD H TXHOOD G·DSSHOOR7:1 8Q HYHQWXDOH ULFRUVR LQ UHYLVLRQH FRQWUR ´GXH FRQIRUPLµ VDUHEEH VWDWR DPPHVVR ©DO VROR HIIHWWR GHYROXWLYRª/ DO ILQH FLRq GL WUDVSRUUH DO JLXGLFH VXSHULRUH OD PHUD FRJQL]LRQH GHL YL]L GHOOD VHQWHQ]D LPSXJQDWD7;1 ,QILQH LO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD YHQLYD FRQ0 IHUPDWR QHOOD VXD YHVWH GL DOWR YLJLODQWH GHO IXQ]LRQDPHQWR GHOOD JLXVWL]LD H GHOOD FRQGRWWD GHL JLXGLFL7< HG LQYHVWLWR GHOO·DVSHWWR FRQWHQ]LRVR UHODWLYR DOOH VXSSOLFKH H DL ULFRUVL ´GL JUD]LDµ831 'RSR XQD ULIRUPD QHO 4;5: ² FKH DUWLFRODYD LO VXSUHPR WULEXQDOH HVWHQVH LQ GXH LQFRQVXHWH VH]LRQL/ OD SULPD SHU JOL DIIDUL QRQ FRQWHQ]LRVL HG ´HFR0 QRPLFLµ H GL ´YRORQWDULD JLXULVGL]LRQHµ/ OD VHFRQGD SHU OH UHYLVLRQL84 ²/ VDUj QHO 4;85/ FRQ O·HQWUDWD LQ YLJRUH GHO QXRYR FRGLFH GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH/ FKH LO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ RUD ULQRPLQDWR 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDOH GL 5HYL0 VLRQH85/ YHUUj VHQVLELOPHQWH/ PD QRQ LQWHJUDOPHQWH/ DYYLFLQDWR DO PRGHOOR ²²²²²²²² 4<::/ SS1 <<0436> )1 9$/(17,/ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD111 FLW1/ S1 437:1 78 5HJRODPHQWR SHL *LXVGLFHQWL/ LQ &ROOH]LRQH GHOOH OHJJL/ FRVWLWX]LRQL/ HGLWWL/ SURFODPL HFF1 SHU JOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL/ W1 ,,/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4;48/ Q1 56/ SS1 ;: VV1 6X WDOH UHJRODPHQWR/ *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD «FLW1/ SS1 4330436> )1 9$/(17,/ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD111 FLW1/ S1 437:1 79 51 GHFUHWR 5; DJRVWR 4;47 FLW1/ DUW1 49/ S1 561 7: $L VHQVL GHOO·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·DWWLYD]LRQH GHL QXRYL UHJRODPHQWL LQWRUQR OH SURFHGXUH FLYLOH H FULPLQDOH111/ GDWDWR 53 GLFHPEUH 4;5: HG HQWUDWR LQ YLJRUH O·DQQR VXFFHVLYR/ LQ &ROOH]LRQH111 FLW1/ W1 ;,,,/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4;5:/ Q1 44/ SS1 68 6V1 85 &RPSRVWR GL XQ SUHVLGHQWH/ XQ SURFXUDWRUH JHQHUDOH H VHL FRQVLJOLHUL +DUW1 4 GHOO·(GLWWR VRYUDQR FRO TXDOH YHQJRQR ULRUGLQDWH H FRVWLWXLWH OH DXWRULWj JLXGL]LDULH GHOOR 6WDWR GHO 5: DJRVWR 4;85/ LQ &ROOH]LRQH111 FLW1/ W1 ;;;,/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4;85/ Q1 4:/ S1 ;3,/ GLYLVR LQ GXH VH]LRQL/ XQD FLYL0 OH H O·DOWUD FULPLQDOH +QRWLILFD]LRQH GHO 0LQLVWHUR GL *UD]LD H *LXVWL]LD GHO 53 RWWREUH 4;85/ LQ
<4;
&DUPHOR (OLR 7DYLOOD
IUDQFHVH GHOOD &DVVD]LRQH861 $ SDUWH LQIDWWL O·LSRWHVL RUGLQDULD GL ´WHU]R JUDGR GL JLXGL]LRµ/ OD UHYLVLRQH SRWHYD HVVHUH SURSRVWD ©WDQWR SHU FDSR GL QXOOLWj FKH G·LQJLXVWL]LDª +DUW1 ;87, DQFKH DYYHUVR VHQWHQ]H FLYLOL LQDSSHOODELOL R SDV0 VDWH LQ JLXGLFDWR QHOOH VHL LSRWHVL HOHQFDWH GDOO·DUW1 85 ² WUD FXL OD PDQLIHVWD YLROD]LRQH GL OHJJH LQ LXGLFDQGR R GL IRUPH HVVHQ]LDOL LQ SURFHGHQGR ²/ FRQ LO 6X0 SUHPR 7ULEXQDOH DELOLWDWR DG XQ ULHVDPH QHO PHULWR/ VHQ]D LO OLPLWH GHO PHUR DQQXOODPHQWR1 '·DOWUD SDUWH/ LO &RGLFH FULPLQDOH GHO ·88 VXSHUDYD O·RVWDFROR GHOOD ´GRSSLD FRQIRUPHµ ² QRUPDOPHQWH LQYLQFLELOH VXO YHUVDQWH FLYLOH ² OH0 JLWWLPDQGR DO ULFRUVR LO FRQGDQQDWR DG XQD SHQD VXSHULRUH DL 48 DQQL +DUW1 6;4,1 ,O 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDOH GL 5HYLVLRQH/ LQILQH/ PDQWHQHYD OD YHVWH GL GHFL0 VRUH GHL FRQIOLWWL GL FRPSHWHQ]D WUD RUJDQL JLXGLFDQWL +DUW1 85 Qƒ 8 FRG1 FLY1> DUWW1 838083: FRG1 FULP1 H SURF1 FULP1, H/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ YHQLYD UDIIRU]DWR QHO UXROR GL YHUWLFH JLXGL]LDULR GHO FRQWHQ]LRVR DPPLQLVWUDWLYR +DUW1 85 Qƒ 7 FRG1 FLY1,1 /H YLFHQGH SUHSDUDWRULH GHOO·8QLWj LWDOLDQD VHJQDQR O·XOWLPD WDSSD GHOOD QRVWUD HVVHQ]LDOH ULFRVWUX]LRQH1 ,O UHJLR GHFUHWR 59 QRYHPEUH 4;93/ FKH LQ0 WURGXVVH LO FRGLFH GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH VDUGR LQ (PLOLD/ DEROu FRQWHVWXDOPHQWH DQFKH O·DOWR FROOHJLR JLXGLFDQWH PRGHQHVH/ VRVWLWXLWR GDOOD &RUWH GL &DVVD]LR0 QH GL 0LODQR871 6L FKLXGHYD LQ WDO PRGR/ LQVLHPH DOOD OXQJD YLWD GHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ O·DOWUHWWDQWR OXQJD VWDJLRQH GHO VXR VXSUHPR RUJDQR GL JLXVWL]LD1
²²²²²²²² &ROOH]LRQH111 FLW1/ W1 ;;;,/ FLW1/ Q1 59/ SS1 677 6V1,1 86 $WWUDYHUVR OD PHGLD]LRQH IDWWDQH GDO FRGLFH GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH SDUPHQVH= FIU1 31 &$/$0$1'5(,/ /D &DVVD]LRQH FLYLOH111 FLW1/ SS1 9840985/ H $1 $/,$1,/ /D FRGLILFD]LRQH GHOOD SURFH0 GXUD FLYLOH QHJOL 6WDWL SDUPHQVL H O·LVWLWXWR GHOOD UHYLVLRQH/ LQ ©6WXGL SDUPHQVLª/ 64 +4<;5,/ SS1 546VV1/ VSHFLDOPHQWH SS1 586 6V1 87 31 &$/$0$1'5(,/ /D &DVVD]LRQH FLYLOH111 FLW1/ S1 9:31 ,O 7ULEXQDOH GL UHYLVLRQH FHVVDYD OD VXD DWWLYLWj LQ GDWD 63 GLFHPEUH 4;93 +/1 %26(//,1,/ ,QWRUQR DO FHVVDWR 7ULEXQDOH VXSUHPR GL UHYL0 VLRQH GL 0RGHQD/ LQ ©*D]]HWWD GHL WULEXQDOL1 *LRUQDOH XQLYHUVDOH GL OHJLVOD]LRQH H JLXULVSUXGHQ0 ]Dª/ UDFFROWD/ QQ1 <:0<;0<</ < IHEEUDLR 4;94/ SS1 ::8 6V1,1
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<4<
*,86(33( %('21,
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
0L SHUPHWWR XQD EUHYLVVLPD QRWD LQWURGXWWLYD ULJXDUGDQWH OD UHGD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH &LYLOH GHO 4;841 /D PDJJLRU SDUWH GHJOL VWRULFL ULFRQRVFH FKH O·XOWLPR 'XFD HVWHQVH/ )UDQ0 FHVFR 9/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, FKH FRQFHVVH SLHQD OLEHUWj DOOD FRP0 PLVVLRQH GL HVSHUWL GD OXL LQFDULFDWD GL SUHSDUDUH LO SULPR &RGLFH &LYLOH GHO 4::4/ LQWHUIHUu DVVLGXDPHQWH QHOOD UHGD]LRQH GHO VHFRQGR &RGLFH &LYLOH GHO 4;84 H FHUFD GL VSLHJDUH OH UDJLRQL GL TXHVWR FRPSRUWDPHQWR1 ,O %D\DUG 'H 9ROR JLXVWLILFD LO IUHTXHQWH LQWHUYHQWR GHO 'XFD SUHVVR OD FRPPLVVLRQH ULFKLDPDQGR PRWLYL HWLFL H UHOLJLRVL4/ PHQWUH LO /DWWHV OR VSLHJD LQGLFDQGR PRWLYL VRFLDOL HG HFRQRPLFL51 &RPXQTXH XQ GDWR q FHUWR= VWRULFDPHQWH FRQ WDOH FRPSRUWDPHQWR )UDQ0 FHVFR 9 GLHGH XOWHULRUH SURYD GL HVVHUH ULPDVWR DQFRUD YLQFRODWR SROLWLFD0 PHQWH DOOD WHRULD DXVWULDFD GHOOR 6WDWR GL 3ROL]LD/ QRQRVWDQWH LO VXR JRYHUQR FRLQFLGHVVH FRQ LO SDVVDJJLR GDO *LXVQDWXUDOLVPR PRGHUQR DO /LEHUDOLVPR JLXULGLFR1 2YYLDPHQWH L JLXULVWL H L SROLWLFL ILOR0OLEHUDOL/ WHQHQGR SUHVHQWH OH JDUDQ]LH RIIHUWH DL FLWWDGLQL GDOOR 6WDWR SLHPRQWHVH/ FRQWHVWDURQR O·RUGLQDPHQWR H0 VWHQVH/ SHUFKp LQ VRVWDQ]D QRQ WXWHODYD FRQ DSSRVLWL RUJDQL LVWLWX]LRQDOL/ UDS0 SUHVHQWDWLYL/ LO SRSROR FRQWUR JOL DEXVL OHJLVODWLYL GHOO·DXWRULWj JRYHUQDWLYD/ XQLFD HG HVFOXVLYD IRQWH GHOOD OHJJH1 3HU TXHVWR PRWLYR QRQ FRQGLYLGR LO SURYRFDWRULR JLXGL]LR HORJLDWLYR/ H0 VSUHVVR GDL GHYRWL GXFKLVWL/ FKH FHOHEUDURQR OD FRPSLOD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH &LYLOH GHO 4;84 ´LQIRUPDWD D SULQFLSLL SL• FRQVHQWDQHL DL WHPSL LQ OXRJR GL ²²²²²²²² 4 71 %$<$5' '( 92/2/ 9LWD GL )UDQFHVFR 9/ GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ +4;4<04;:8,/ 0RGHQD/ 7LSR0 JUDILD ,PPDFRODWD &RQFH]LRQH/ 4;:;0;8/ ,,/ S1 ,/ S1 6;1 5 $1 /$77(6/ /D IRUPD]LRQH GHO FRGLFH FLYLOH HVWHQVH/ 7RULQR/ 6XEDOSLQD 2SHV1/ 4<45/ S1 451
<53
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
TXHOOD YLHWD UDSVRGLD GHO VHFROR SDVVDWR/ GLVVHSSHOOLWD H UDIID]]RQDWD GD )UDQ0 FHVFR ,9 SHU RGLR DOOH QRYLWj GHOO·HUD QDSROHRQLFDµ61 &RQWHVWR SXUH LO JLXGL]LR GHO %UXJQROL/ LO TXDOH VFULVVH FKH )UDQFHVFR 9 FRPSUHVH ´OD QHFHVVLWj GL XQ VROR RUGLQDWR FRUSR GL OHJJL FKH DGDWWDWR IRVVH DL WHPSL/ DJOL DWWXDOL ELVRJQL/ DO JHQLR HG LQGROH GH·VXRL SRSROL/ DOOD IHUWLOLWj/ DO FRPPHUFLR/ DOOD VLWXD]LRQH GHO SDHVH GD JRYHUQDUVL/ H SXEEOLFz LO VXR &RGLFH &LYLOH/ FRQ FXL UHVH LQQHJDELOH EHQHILFLR D· VXRL VXGGLWLµ71 'HO UHVWR SULPD GL DFFHWWDUH O·RSLQLRQH HORJLDWLYD GHO %UXJQROL q EHQH ´UL0 OHJJHUHµ LO &RGLFH SUHFHGHQWH GHO 4::4/ GHILQLWR GDO *UDQGL XQD ´YLHWD UDS0 VRGLD GHO VHFROR SDVVDWRµ/ FRQIURQWDQGROR SRL FRQ TXHOOH GHO 4;841 )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ SUHVHQWDQGR LO &RGLFH &LYLOH/ ILUPDWR LO 59 DSULOH 4::4/ SUHFLVz FKH QHOOD VXD HODERUD]LRQH L FRPPLVVDUL &DJQROL/ )RQWDQD/ 9DQGHOOL/ 9DOGULJKL/ DYHYDQR WHQXWR SUHVHQWL WUH VFRSL= 4, 5,
ULGXUUH OH OHJJL FRPXQL H PXQLFLSDOL ´DOOD SL• VHPSOLFH XQLIRUPLWjµ> HOLPLQDUH ´TXHOOH JLj DQGDWH LQ GLVXVR/ R FKH SHU OD YDULHWj GH· WHPSL H GH· FRVWXPL QRQ VRQR SL• DGDWWDELOL D· WHPSL FRUUHQWLµ> 6, VWDELOLUH ´FROOH PDVVLPH GHOO·HTXLWj H GHOOD UDJLRQH L YHUL/ FKLDUL H VRGL SULQFLSLL GD RVVHUYDUVL VRSUD WDQWL DUWLFROL H TXHVWLRQL SL• RYYLH H IUH0 TXHQWL D VXVFLWDUVL QHOOD FRQWURYHUVLH IRUHQVLµ1
/D QXRYD OHJLVOD]LRQH/ GDO 'XFD TXDOLILFDWD ´VDOXWHYROH RSHUDµ/ VL GRYHYD RVVHUYDUH HG HVHJXLUH ´LQ WXWWL L GRPLQL WDQWR LPPHGLDWL FKH PHGLDWL H GD TXDOXQTXH SHUVRQD H FHWRµ HG DYHUH SULRULWj DVVROXWD VXO ´JLXV DQWLFR H PXQL0 FLSDOHµ H VX ´TXDOVLYRJOLD DOWUD SUHFHGHQWH OHJJH/ SUDPPDWLFD/ RSLQLRQH H FRQVXHWXGLQHµ> VROR LQ FDVR GL ODFXQH/ ´SHU VHUEDUH O·XQLIRUPLWj LQ WXWWD O·HVWHQVLRQH GHL GRPLQLLµ/ HUD DFFRQVHQWLWR LQ FDVR HVWUHPL GL ´ULFRUUHUH DOOD GLVSRVL]LRQH GHO JLXV FRPXQHµ H QHOOH 44: JLXULVGL]LRQL IHXGDOL DJOL 6WDWXWL GL 0RGHQD/ 0LUDQGROD/ *DUIDJQDQD/ &DUSL/ 0RQWHFXFFROR/ 61)HOLFH/ 6FDQGLDQR/ )ULJQDQR/ &RUUHJJLR/ 5HJJLR1 0HWRGRORJLFDPHQWH )UDQFHVFR ,,, ILQ GDO 5 PDJJLR 4:8</ PHQWUH HUD JR0 YHUQDWRUH D 0LODQR/ DYHYD UDFFRPDQGDWR DJOL HVSHUWL GL SUHQGHUH ´LQ FRQVL0 GHUD]LRQH TXDQWR VL q IDWWR LQ )UDQFLD/ 3LHPRQWH/ 3UXVVLDµ/ OH FXL OHJLVOD]LRQL HUDQR EHQ QRWH QHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH DWWUDYHUVR OH HVSHULHQ]H SHUVRQDOL IDWWH GD ²²²²²²²² 6 71 *5$1',/ &LUR 0HQRWWL H L VXRL FRPSDJQL1 /H YLFHQGH SROLWLFKH GDO 4;54 DO 4;64/ %RORJQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD $]]RJQLGL/ 4;;3/ S1 59<1 7 *1 %58*12/,/ ,QGLFH UDJLRQDWR GHO &RGLFH (VWHQVH/ 0RGHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L/ 4;85/ S1 9,1
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<54
*LXVHSSH 0DULD %RQGLJOL/ %DUWRORPHR 9DOGULJKL/ )LOLSSR *LXVHSSH 0DUFKL0 VLR/ FKH JRGHYDQR D &RUWH GL SRWHQWH SUHVWLJLR81 ,O GLULWWR FLYLOH IUDQFHVH HUD FRQRVFLXWR D 0RGHQD ILQ GDO 4935 TXDQGR LO FHOHEUH DYYRFDWR $QWRQLR )DEUR H )DYUH/ EDURQH GL 3pURJHV/ GD &KDPEHU\ JLXQVH QHOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH SHU GLIHQGHUH JOL LQWHUHVVL GL $QQD/ ILJOLD OHJLWWL0 PD GL (UFROH ,, H GL 5HQDWD/ QHOOD FDXVD FLYLOH SHU O·HUHGLWj/ GD OHL SURPRVVD FRQWUR LO GXFD &HVDUH/ VXR FXJLQR1 ,O )DYUH HUD VWDWR LO FRRUGLQDWRUH GHO ID0 PRVR ´&RGLFH )DEULDQRµ/ XWLOL]]DWR SRL QHOOD ULIRUPD OHJLVODWLYD SLHPRQWHVH GHO 4:561 0D LO YHUR VRVWHQLWRUH GHOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH IUDQFHVH IX LO PLQLVWUR %RQGLJOL FKH GDO 4:7: DO 4:7; HUD VWDWR XGLWRUH H JLXGLFH LQTXLUHQWH D 3DULJL/ 0RQWSHOOLHU/ 1L]]D91 'LYHQWDWR QHOO·DJRVWR GHO 4:8< PLQLVWUR GL 6WDWR GL &DVD G·(VWH/ HJOL HEEH OD SRVVLELOLWj GL VHJXLUH LO SURJHWWR FRQ RSSRUWXQL VXJJHUL0 PHQWL GRJPDWLFL H PHWRGRORJLFL/ DSSURILWWDQGR GHOOD VXD SUHFHGHQWH HVSH0 ULHQ]D GL PDJLVWUDWR1 $ VXD YROWD/ LO 9DOGULJKL/ FKH GDO 4:97 DO 4:99 SUHVVR OH IDFROWj GL *LXUL0 VSUXGHQ]D GL /LSVLD H +DOOH DYHYD FRPSOHWDWR HG DSSURIRQGLWD OD SURSULD IRUPD]LRQH JLXULGLFD/ FRPLQFLz DG HVSRUUH LO GLULWWR SUXVVLDQR QHJOL VFULWWL H QHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR SUHVVR OD FDWWHGUD XQLYHUVLWDULD GL 0RGHQD1 ,QILQH LO FRQWH 0DUFKLVLR/ FRQYLQWR JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWD/ UHJDOLVWD/ ODXUHDWRVL QHO 4:8: D 7RULQR/ DYHYD VWXGLDWR QHOOD 6DYRLD OH 5HJLH &RVWLWX]LRQL SLH0 PRQWHVL FKH/ ULWRUQDWR D 0RGHQD/ LQGLFz DO 'XFD GL WHQHU SUHVHQWL1 4XDQGR )UDQFHVFR ,,, FHVVz GL JRYHUQDUH LO /RPEDUGR09HQHWR H VL ULWLUz D 9DUHVH/ LO 0DUFKLVLR IX QRPLQDWR PLQLVWUR GHOOD *LXULVGL]LRQH 6RYUDQD H GL FRQVH0 JXHQ]D HEEH PDJJLRU SHVR QHOOD VWHVXUD GHO QXRYR &RGLFH1 1RQ YD SRL WUDVFXUDWR LO FOLPD IDYRUHYROH/ FKH QHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH VL HUD DQGDWR VYLOXSSDQGR/ FUHDWR GDO PRYLPHQWR JLXULGLFR OHJDWR DO SHQVLHUR PX0 UDWRULDQR FKH/ VRWWR OD GLUH]LRQH GHO VHJUHWDULR GL 6WDWR 'RPHQLFR 01 *LD0 FRED]]L/ DSSRJJLDYD OD ULIRUPD OHJLVODWLYD VHFRQGR XQ LQGLUL]]R JLXVQDWXUDOLVWLFR HG LOOXPLQLVWLFR1 ²²²²²²²² 8 %1 '21$7,/ /·RSHUD GL *101 %RQGLJOL QHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL JLXULGLFKH PRGHQHVL DOOD PHWj GHO VHF1 ;9,,,/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH 51 $FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH H $UWLª/ V1 ,9/ ,/ 0RGHQD/ 6RFLH0 Wj 7LSRJUDILFD $QWLFD WLSRJUDILD 6ROLDQL/ 4<59/ S1 46;1 9 $1 625%(//,0 $1 5$%(77,/ 'L]LRQDULR ELRJUDILFR IULJQDQHVH/ 3LHYHSHODJR/ HG1 6RFLHWj 6FRO0 WHQQD/ 4<85/ S1 498> %1 '21$7,/ /·RSHUD GL *LXVHSSH 0DULD %RQGLJOL «FLW1 S1 469> *1 %('21,/ ,O UXROR GL /1$1 0XUDWRUL H %1 9DOGULJKL QHOOD FRGLILFD]LRQH HVWHQVH GHO 4::4/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH $F0 FDGHPLD 1D]LRQDOH GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH H $UWLª/ V1 9,,/ ;,,,/ 4<<80<9/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<<:/ SS1 54<05651
<55
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
,QGXEELDPHQWH L FRPSLODWRUL HVWHQVL GHO &RGLFH XEELGLURQR DOO·HVRUWD]LRQH ORUR ULYROWD GD )UDQFHVFR ,,, GL VHJXLUH SRVVLELOPHQWH ´TXDQWR VL q IDWWR LQ 3UXVVLD/ )UDQFLD/ 3LHPRQWHµ1 /·HVHPSLR SL• VLJQLILFDWLYR q GDWR GDO IDWWR FKH/ FRPH OH ORUR OHJLVOD]LRQL DYHYDQR WHQXWR VHSDUDWH OH FRPSHWHQ]H LQ PDWHULD FLYLOLVWLFD WUD 6WDWR H &KLH0 VD SHU HYLWDUH FRQIOLWWL JLXULVGL]LRQDOL/ QHOOD VWHVVD PLVXUD LO &RGLFH GHO 4::4 GLVWLQVH OD QRUPDWLYD VWDWXDOH GD TXHOOD FDQRQLFD H VXERUGLQz OD VHFRQGD DOOD SULPD1 ,QIDWWL OD OHJLVOD]LRQH SURLEu OH QR]]H FODQGHVWLQH/ FRQWUDWWH VHQ]D IRUPDOLWj SXEEOLFKH H FHOHEUDWH LQ FKLHVD/ H ULFKLHVH O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH JRYHUQD0 WLYD SHU GLVSRUUH EHQL LPPRELOL H PRELOL LQ IDYRUH GL XQ HQWH PRUDOH HG HF0 FOHVLDVWLFR1 ,O &RGLFH GHO 4::4 ULSUHVH GDOOH &RVWLWX]LRQL GL 9LWWRULR $PHGHR ,, GHO 4:56 WDOXQL DUWLFROL LQVHULWL/ S1H1/ QHL OLEUL , H ,,/ ULJXDUGDQWL OH VHUYLW•/ O·XVXIUXWWR/ OD SUHVFUL]LRQL/ OH GRQD]LRQL/ LO PDWULPRQLR/ OD GRWH1 1RQ VROR= DG HVVH VL LVSLUDURQR L FRPSLODWRUL HVWHQVL SHU ULIRUPDUH OD GLVFLSOLQD FLUFD OD LVWL0 WX]LRQH GHOOH SULPRJHQLWXUH H GHL IHGHFRPPHVVL/ L TXDOL VL GRYHYDQR FRVWLWXL0 UH VXL EHQL LPPRELOL/ FHQVL ´DWWLYLµ/ FUHGLWL/ GHQDUR H SRWHYDQR HVVHUH YLQFROD0 WL ´WDQWR SHU FRQWUDWWR IUD YLYLµ/ TXDQWR SHU GLVSRVL]LRQH ´G·XOWLPD YRORQWjµ1 ,O 0DULQL SXQWXDOL]]D FKH IXURQR DEROLWL L IHGHFRPPHVVL GL VFDUVD HQWLWj/ SHUFKp QRQ VHUYLYDQR DG DOWUR FKH ´DG LQWUDOFLDUH FRQ SXEEOLFR H SULYDWR SUHJLXGL]LR OD OLEHUWj GL FRPPHUFLRµ/ H VL RVWDFRODURQR L GLULWWL GL PDQR0 PRUWD VXL EHQL GHL VXGGLWL HVWHQVL/ DIILQFKp ´PHJOLR H SL• DPSLDPHQWH VL UL0 VWDELOLVVH OD OLEHUWj GL FRPPHUFLRµ:1 5LFRUGDQGR LO SHQVLHUR GHO *LDFRED]]L/ L FRPSLODWRUL GHO &RGLFH GHGLFD0 URQR 69 DUWLFROL DOOD UHJRODPHQWD]LRQH GHOOD PDQRPRUWD/ WHUPLQH LQGLFDQWH OR VWDWR GHL EHQL FKH/ LQ TXDQWR DSSDUWHQHQWL DG HQWL PRUDOL HG HFFOHVLDVWLFL H TXLQGL SHUSHWXL/ DQGDYDQR JLXGLFDWL LQDOLHQDELOL H QRQ DVVRJJHWWDWL DOOH WDVVH GL VXFFHVVLRQH1 3RLFKp TXHVWR SULYLOHJLR DUUHFDYD QRWHYROL GDQQL DOOD OLEHUD FLUFROD]LRQH GHL EHQL H DO VLVWHPD ILVFDOH/ LO OLEUR ,, GHO &RGLFH LPSRVH D FROXL/ FKH DYHVVH GHFLVR GL GHVWLQDUH DG XQ HQWH PRUDOH R DG XQD LVWLWX]LRQH HFFOH0 VLDVWLFD OD SURSULHWj R LO SRVVHVVR GHL EHQL LPPRELOL H PRELOL/ GL FKLHGHUH SUH0 YHQWLYDPHQWH ´OLFHQ]D H GHFUHWR GL DPPRUWL]]D]LRQHµ DO 'XFD/ PLQDFFLDQGR LQ FDVR GL YLROD]LRQH D TXHVW·REEOLJR OD ORUR FRQILVFD1 1HO FDVR LQ FXL OH GR0 QD]LRQL IRVVHUR VWDWH FRQ WHVWDPHQWL H FRGLFLOOL GLVSRVWH ´LQ PRUWLV FDXVDµ VHQ]D O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH GXFDOH/ L EHQL VDUHEEHUR VWDWL WUDVIHULWL G·XIILFLR/ FRPH ²²²²²²²² : /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ GLUHWWD GD *1 *$/$662/ ;9,,/ 7RULQR/ 87(7/ 4<:</ S1 4751
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<56
VXFFHVVLRQH WHVWDPHQWDULD/ DJOL HUHGL H VROR OD VHVWD SDUWH GHO SDWULPRQLR GHO GH FXLXV VDUHEEH ULPDVWD DOOD PDQRPRUWD1 1RQRVWDQWH OD ULIRUPD FLYLOLVWLFD/ DSSRUWDWD GDO &RGLFH/ ULPDVHUR/ FRPH LQ 3UXVVLD/ OH GLVXJXDJOLDQ]H VRFLDOL/ FKH VL ULSHUFRVVHUR RYYLDPHQWH VXOOR VWDWR JLXULGLFR GHL VXGGLWL/ DSSDUWHQHQWL D GHWHUPLQDWL FODVVL1 ,QIDWWL HVVR FRQVHUYz LGHH PROWR UHVWULWWLYH VXOOD FDSDFLWj JLXULGLFD GHOOD GRQQD1 ,O OLEUR ,, +DUW1 ;/ WLW1 ,9, RUGLQz FKH QHOOD VWLSXOD]LRQH GHL FRQWUDWWL OD GRQQD/ SXUFKp PDJJLR0 UH GL DQQL 53/ GRYHYD HVVHUH UDSSUHVHQWDWD OHJDOPHQWH GDO PDULWR R GDO SL• SURVVLPR GHL VXRL FRQJLXQWL/ TXDORUD IRVVH VWDWD QXELOH1 /D TXDOH HUD HVFOXVD GDOOD VXFFHVVLRQH OHJLWWLPD HG LQWHVWDWD LQ IDYRUH GHL PDVFKL H VROR QHO FDVR GL LVWLWX]LRQH GL XQ HVWUDQHR R GL XQ DJQDWR DYHYD GLULWWR DOO· LQWHUD OHJLWWLPD1 ,O &RGLFH QRQ IX XQD ´VDOXWHYROH RSHUDµ VSHFLDOPHQWH QHL FRQIURQWL GHJOL DJULFROWRUL H GHL FRPPHUFLDQWL1 , SULPL QRQ PLJOLRUDURQR OD ORUR VLWXD]LRQH HFRQRPLFD/ OD TXDOH DQ]L DQGz DJJUDYDQGRVL H OL FRVWULQVH DOOD IXJD GDOOD WHUUD H DOOH ´YLHWDWH VSDWULD]LRQLµ/ VSHFLDOPHQWH GDOOH PRQWDJQH/ GHWHUPLQDWH GDOO·DXPHQWR HFFHVVLYR GHOOH LP0 SRVWH H GHOOH WDVVH ´SHUVRQDOLµ VWDELOLWH D ORUR FDULFR GD ´GLVFRUGL PXQLFLSDOL OHJJLµ H GDL IHXGDWDUL/ FKH LO &RGLFH QRQ FHUFz GL IUHQDUH VHFRQGR LO SULQFLSLR GHOO·HTXLWj1 $ QXOOD VHUYu OD VXFFHVVLYD UDFFRPDQGD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ UL0 YROWD DL SURSULHWDUL H DL FRQGXWWRUL GHL IRQGL/ GL ´IDUH RJQL SRVVLELOH VIRU]R SHU VRPPLQLVWUDUH DOOH IDPLJOLH GHL FRORQL LO VRVWHQWDPHQWR QHFHVVDULR VLQR DO IXWXUR UDFFROWRµ1 ,O 'XFD ORUR DVVLFXUz/ GD SDUWH VXD/ LO ULPERUVR GHO FUHGLWR/ ´ULFKLDPDQGR LQ YLJRUH +SHU TXHVWR FDVR VSHFLDOH, O·LSRWHFD OHJDOH VXL EHQL GHO PH]]DGUR FKH HUD DFFRUGDWD GDO &RGLFH HVWHQVH +OLEUR ,,/ WLW1 ;;;,/ SHUz JUD0 WXLWD/ SXU DVVRJJHWWDWD DOO·REEOLJR GHOOD WUDVFUL]LRQH D WXWHOD GHL WHU]Lµ1 3HU EORFFDUH OH HPLJUD]LRQL/ FKH VRWWUDHYDQR L FRQWDGLQL GDL FDPSL/ LO WLWR0 OR 9,,, GHO OLEUR ,, SURLEu ´ D TXDOVLDVL VXGGLWR/ PHGLDWR HG LPPHGLDWR/ OR VSDWULDUH VRWWR SHQD GHOOH FRQILVFD]LRQL GL WXWWL OL VXRL EHQL VWDELOL H PRELOL/ UDJLRQL H D]LRQL GL TXDOVLYRJOLD VRUWD H GHOOD SHUSHWXD LQDELOLWj D SRWHU VXFFH0 GHUH DE LQWHVWDWR R SHU WHVWDPHQWR R SHU GRQD]LRQH R SHU FHUWH GLVSRVL]LRQL R FRQWUDWWL LQ EHQL SRVWL QHOOR 6WDWRµ1 3HU IUHQDUH O·XVXUD/ LQ FDVR GL VRPPLQLVWUD]LRQH DG DOWUL GL GHQDUR/ LO WLWROR ;; GHO OLEUR ,, ILVVz XQ FHQVR FRQYHQ]LRQDOH QRQ PDJJLRUH ´GL XQ RWWR SHU FHQWLQDLRµ;1 ²²²²²²²² ; %1 9(5$77,/ /H /HJJL/ LQ $OOD PHPRULD GL )UDQFHVFR ,9> WULEXWR GHOOD 51 $FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH HG $UWL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ (UHGL 6ROLDQL WLSRJUDIL UHDOL/ 4;79/ S14;:1
<57
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
/D SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH VFDWHQR OD UHD]LRQH GHOOD &KLHVD/ OD TXDOH D0 YDQ]z OD SUHWHVD GL PRGLILFDUH SHUILQR DOFXQL DUWLFROL1 ,QIDWWL LO 3DSD VL ODPHQ0 Wz SHUFKp QRQ VL HUD WHQXWR FRQWR GHOOH LPPXQLWj/ VL HUD PDQRPHVVR LO GLULWWR GL DVLOR/ VL HUDQR SHUPHVVH OH XVXUH/ VL HUD DXWRUL]]DWD O·DIIUDQFD]LRQH GHL FHQ0 VL/ VL HUDQR PDQWHQXWH OH VDQ]LRQL SHU OH QR]]H IUD SHUVRQH GL GLYHUVH FRQGL0 ]LRQL VRFLDOL/ VL HUDQR DYRFDWH OH FDXVH GL VSRQVDOL H QXOOLWj GL PDWULPRQLR DOOD JLXULVGL]LRQH ODLFD/ FRQWUDYYHQHQGR LQ WDO PRGR DG DOFXQL SULQFLSLL GL GLULWWR FDQRQLFR<1 $ SURSRVLWR GL TXHVW·XOWLPR WHPD VL GHYH ULFRQRVFHUH FKH O·; PDJJLR 4;47 )UDQFHVFR ,9 FRQ DSSRVLWR SURYYHGLPHQWR OHJLVODWLYR PRGLILFz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´SXEEOLFD IHGHµ1 /·XIILFLDOH FRPXQDOH GRYHYD VROR DFFHUWDUH O·LQHVLVWHQ]D GL LPSHGLPHQWL FLYLOL DO PDWULPRQLR UHOL0 JLRVR H ULODVFLDUH XQ FHUWLILFDWR SHU LO SDUURFR> GRSR LO ULWR GRYHYD WUDVFULYHUH OD ´IHGHµ VXL UHJLVWUL GHO &RPXQH1 6H OD UHGD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH GHO 4::4 IX GHWHUPLQDWD GDOOD HVLJHQ]D/ FRPH HUD DYYHQXWR LQ 3LHPRQWH/ GL LPSRUUH QHO 'XFDWR XQD OHJLVOD]LRQH XQLIRUPH H JHQHUDOH DO SRVWR GHOOH GLYHUVH QRUPDWLYH VWDWXDULH/ FRPXQDOL H FRUSRUDWLYH YLJHQWL QHL VLQJROL &RPXQL PRGHQHVL H UHJJLDQL/ LQWHJUDWD LQ FDVR GL ODFXQH GDO GLULWWR FRPXQH/ OD SURPXOJD]LRQH GHO &RGLFH GHO 4;84 VL UHVH QHFHVVDULD SHU ´FUHDUH XQ FRUSR XQLIRUPH HG XQLFR GL RULHQWDPHQWL FLYLOL SHU WXWWR OR 6WDWR HVWHQVHµ/ DPSOLDWRVL DYHQGR GD WHPSR DFFRUSRUDWR GLYHUVL WHUULWRUL1 ,QIDWWL HVVR FRPSUHQGHYD LO GXFDWR GL 0DVVD H &DUUDUD/ DFTXLVWDWR SHU VXFFHVVLRQH DOOD ILQH GHO·5< SHU OD PRUWH GL 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH/ PDGUH GL )UDQFHVFR 9/ LO GXFDWR GL *XDVWDOOD/ )LYL]]DQR WRVFDQR/ 0LQXFFLDQR H *DOOL0 FDQR OXFFKHVL/ ULXQLWL SHU HIIHWWR GHOOD &RQYHQ]LRQH GL )LUHQ]H GHO 4; QR0 YHPEUH 4;77 LQ HVHFX]LRQH GHO WUDWWDWR GL 9LHQQD GHO 4;48 H LQILQH LO &R0 PXQH GL 5ROR/ RWWHQXWR GDOO·LPSHUDWRUH DXVWULDFR LQ FRQVHJXHQ]D GHOO·DFFRUGR GL 0LODQR GHO 4;7<1 ²²²²²²²² < *1 6$/9,2/,/ /D OHJLVOD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH 51 'HSX0 WD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH 3URYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ,9/ ,; +4;<<,/ S1 591
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<58
4XHVWL HQWL DXWRQRPL WHUULWRULDOL HUDQR VRJJHWWL DL SURSUL 6WDWXWL SDUWLFRODUL +OHJJL SDUPHQVL/ R WRVFDQH/ R OXFFKHVL/ R DXVWULDFKH,/ FKH LQHYLWDELOPHQWH FUH0 DYDQR FRQIOLWWL H GLVXJXDJOLDQ]H QRUPDWLYH H FKH RVWDFRODYDQR LQ TXHL WHUUL0 WRUL O·DSSOLFD]LRQH GHO GLULWWR FLYLOH YDOLGR SHU WXWWR OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ FUHDQGR FRQIXVLRQH H GL FRQVHJXHQ]D IDFHQGR YHQLU PHQR LO SULQFLSLR GHOOD FHUWH]]D GHO GLULWWR1 (WLFDPHQWH LO &RGLFH GHO 4;84 FHUFz GL DGDWWDUH LO SL• SRVVLELOH LO GLULWWR FLYLOH DOOD GRWWULQD GHO /LEHUDOLVPR/ VYLOXSSDWDVL GRSR OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH LQ 3LHPRQWH H LQ 7RVFDQD> WXWWDYLD QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH GRPLQz LQ JUDQ SDUWH LO SRVLWLYLVPR JLXULGLFR HUHGLWDWR GDO SDVVDWR/ SXU PRGLILFDWR TXD H Oj/ FKH ULQ0 IRU]z XQD FRQFH]LRQH QRUPDWLYLVWLFD HG LPSHUDWLYLVWLFD FKH QRQ RIIUu TXHOOD FRPSOHWD JDUDQ]LD GHOOD OHJDOLWj H GHOOD OLEHUWj/ VRVWHQXWD GDL JLXULVWL OLEHUDOL1 'L FRQVHJXHQ]D VRWWR TXHVWR DVSHWWR LO &RGLFH GHO 4;84 SXz HVVHUH FRQ0 VLGHUDWR LO SURVHJXLPHQWR JLXULVSUXGHQ]LDOH GHO &RGLFH GHO 4::4/ D SDUWH WD0 OXQH GLIIHUHQ]H WHFQLFKH H SURFHGXUDOL/ GHWWDWH GDOOD HVLJHQ]D GL XQLIRUPDUVL VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH DG DOWUH OHJLVOD]LRQL LWDOLDQH H GL VQHOOLUH O·DSSOLFD]LRQH GHOOH QRUPH1 /R VWHVVR )UDQFHVFR 9 LQFDULFz OD FRPPLVVLRQH/ LVWLWXLWD FRQ GHFUHWR GHO 9 DJRVWR 4;7< H IRUPDWD GDL JLXULVWL 3DOPLHUL/ 7RVFKL/ &RFFKL/ 0DQLQL/ %DWWL0 ODQL/ GL SUHSDUDUH XQD OHJLVOD]LRQH ´JHQHUDOH H FRQIRUPH DL ELVRJQL GHL WHPSL H LQ DUPRQLD FRQ TXHOOH GHJOL 6WDWL OLPLWURILµ/ RUGLQDQGR HVSUHVVDPHQWH FKH HVVD SUHQGHVVH SHU EDVH GHO SURSULR ODYRUR WUD L FRGLFL FLYLOL LWDOLDQL ´VSHFLDO0 PHQWHµ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z QHJDUH FKH GDOOD OHWWXUD FRPSDUDWLYD GHOOH OHJLVOD]LRQL SDU0 PHQVH HG HVWHQVH/ OHJDWH GDOOD FRQYHQ]LRQH GHO 53 PDJJLR 4;4:/ DSSDUH HYL0 GHQWH FKH LQ SDUHFFKLH PDWHULH OD GLVFLSOLQD QRUPDWLYD IX DQDORJD1 &LWR L FDVL SL• LQWHUHVVDQWL H VLJQLILFDWLYL1 $PEHGXH OH OHJLVOD]LRQL ULFRQREEHUR LO GLULWWR GL FLWWDGLQDQ]D D WXWWL L VXGGLWL/ QRELOL H ERUJKHVL/ ULFFKL H SRYHUL/ ´LQWULQVLFL HG HVWULQVLFLµ/ FDQFHOODQ0
<59
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
GR ILQDOPHQWH OD OHJJH GL DOELQDJJLR/ ULVDOHQWH DO URPDQR ´LXV DOELQDJLµ/ FKH GD VHFROL FROSLYD GL LQFDSDFLWj JLXULGLFD H GL DJLUH JOL HVLOLDWL/ JOL HVXOL/ L PHU0 FDQWL1 ,QVRPPD JOL VWUDQLHUL QRQ SRWHYDQR Qp DFTXLVWDUH SHU WHVWDPHQWR LQ DOFXQ PRGR WDQWR O·HUHGLWj/ TXDQWR L OHJDWL SHU XQ SULQFLSLR JHQHUDOH GL GLULWWR FLYLOH FKH OHJLWWLPDYD OD FRQILVFD GHL ORUR EHQL GD SDUWH GHO VRYUDQR/ Qp OLEH0 UDPHQWH GLVSRUUH GHL SURSUL EHQL LQ IDYRUH GHL OHJLWWLPL VXFFHVVRUL1 ,O &RGLFH FLYLOH SDUPHQVH/ DOO·DUW1 46/ FRQVLGHUz FLWWDGLQR FKL/ QDWR LQ XQ SDHVH VWUDQLHUR/ HUD ILJOLR GL SDGUH FLWWDGLQR GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D/ *XDVWDOOD1 5LSUHQGHQGR TXHVWD QRUPD/ LO &RGLFH HVWHQVH GHO 4;84 +DUW1 664, SUHVFULVVH FKH LO IRUHVWLHUR/ TXDORUD DYHVVH ULFKLHVWR OD FLWWDGLQDQ]D/ GRYHYD RWWHQHUH GDO 6RYUDQR UHJRODUH ´UHVFULWWRµ FKH SRL DQGDYD UHJLVWUDWR DOO·DQDJUDIH GHO &R0 PXQH GL QXRYD UHVLGHQ]D1 $OWUL SXQWL GL DQDORJLD ULJXDUGDURQR OD GLVFLSOLQD GHOO·DGR]LRQH/ GHOOH SUL0 PRJHQLWXUH H GHL IHGHFRPPHVVL1 ,QYHFH LQ DOWUH PDWHULH L FLQTXH OHJLVODWRUL HVWHQVL QRQ VHJXLURQR VHPSUH DOOD OHWWHUD OD YRORQWj GXFDOH1 ,QIDWWL/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GHO &RGLFH SDUPHQVH FKH WXWHODYD O·XJXDJOLDQ]D GL WXW0 WL L VXGGLWL GDYDQWL DOOD OHJJH/ TXHOOR HVWHQVH/ LPLWDQGR O·RUGLQDPHQWR SUXVVLD0 QR H FRSLDQGR OD QRUPDWLYD GHO 4::4/ FRQVHUYz OD ORUR GLVXJXDJOLDQ]D LQ UDSSRUWR DO VHVVR/ DOOD UHOLJLRQH/ DO FHWR VRFLDOH/ OD TXDOH LQIOXu QHJDWLYDPHQWH VXOOD QRUPDWLYD FRQWUDWWXDOH/ VXO GLULWWR GL IDPLJOLD/ VXO PDWULPRQLR/ VXOOH VXFFHVVLRQL WHVWDPHQWDULH H OHJLWWLPH1 /D GRQQD ULPDVH OD SL• GLVFULPLQDWD1 1RQ SRWHYD DEEDQGRQDUH OD FDVD SD0 WHUQD VH QRQ TXDQGR VL IRVVH VSRVDWD Qp SRWHYD HVHUFLWDUH OD WXWHOD D PHQR FKH QRQ IRVVH PDGUH R DYROD GHO PLQRUH QHL FDVL HVSUHVVL GDOOD OHJJH1 3XU JRGHQGR GHOOR VWDWXV GL PRJOLH QRQ SRWHYD/ VHQ]D O·DVVHQVR GHO PDULWR/ VWDUH LQ JLXGL]LR FRPH DWWULFH/ ´GRQDUH/ DOLHQDUH/ LSRWHFDUH/ DIILWWDUH ROWUH XQ TXLQ0 TXHQQLR/ DFTXLVWDUH D WLWROR JUDWXLWR R RQHURVRµ1 4XDORUD LO FRQLXJH IRVVH LQ0 WHUGHWWR/ PLQRUH TXDQWXQTXH HPDQFLSDWR/ HPLJUDWR/ FRQGDQQDWR DG XQD SH0 QD SHU GHOLWWR LQIDPDQWH/ OD GRQQD GRYHYD HVVHUH DVVLVWLWD GD XQ FXUDWRUH QRPLQDWR GDO JLXVGLFHQWH R GDO WULEXQDOH1 3HU HIIHWWR GHOO·DUW1 445 OD PRJOLH/ ´VHSDUDWD GHILQLWLYDPHQWH GL FRUSRµ/ DYHYD OD OLEHUD DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH H GL0 VSRQLELOLWj GHL SURSUL EHQL SDUDIHUQDOL H QRQ DYHYD ELVRJQR GHOO·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH GHO FRQLXJH VH QRQ QHL FDVL GL DOLHQD]LRQH HG REEOLJD]LR0 QH GL EHQL LPPRELOL H SHU VWDUH LQ JLXGL]LR FRPH DWWULFH1 6H LO PDULWR DYHVVH SRVWR XQ ULILXWR/ HUD VXIILFLHQWH O·DSSURYD]LRQH GHO JLXVGLFHQWH1 /·DUW1 <44 SUHVFULVVH FKH/ VH QHOOD HUHGLWj DYHVVHUR FRQFRUVR PDVFKL H
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<5:
IHPPLQH/ OD TXRWD GL FLDVFXQ PDVFKLR GRYHYD VXSHUDUH GHOOD PHWj TXHOOD FKH VSHWWDYD D FLDVFXQD IHPPLQD/ FRVLFFKp OD TXRWD GHO PDVFKLR VWDYD D TXHOOD GHOOD IHPPLQD FRPH WUH D GXH1 $QFKH QHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH WHVWDPHQWDULD L EHQH0 ILFLDUL ULPDVHUR VHPSUH H VROR L ILJOL/ L GLVFHQGHQWL/ JOL DVFHQGHQWL> VROR QHO FD0 VR LQ FXL TXHVWL IRVVHUR PDQFDWL/ LO WHVWDWRUH SRWHYD GLVSRUUH OLEHUDPHQWH GL WXWWL L VXRL EHQL +DUW1 ;68,1 6H IRVVH VRSUDYYLVVXWD DQFKH OD PRJOLH/ TXHVWD D0 YHYD GLULWWR ´DL FRQJUXL DOLPHQWLµ +DUW1 ;69,1 0RVVL GD SUHJLXGL]L UHOLJLRVL/ L FRPSLODWRUL H OR VWHVVR )UDQFHVFR 9 OLPLWD0 URQR OD OLEHUWj FLYLOH H O·DWWLYLWj FRPPHUFLDOH GHJOL HEUHL/ VHPSUH DVVRJJHWWDWL D UHJROH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH H D PLVXUH GL SROL]LD H SXEEOLFD VLFXUH]]D1 6LPLOH DOOH QRUPH FRQWHQXWH QHO WLWROR < GHO OLEUR , GHOOH 5HJLH &RVWLWX]LRQL GL 9LWWRULR $PHGHR/ JLj O·DUW1 444 GHO OLEUR ,,, GHO &RGLFH GHO 4::4 DYHYD GLVSRVWR FKH JOL LVUDHOLWL DYHVVHUR OD SRVVLELOLWj GL DIILWWDUH JUDQDL H QHJR]L/ DFTXLVWDUH LP0 PRELOL H FRPPHUFLDUH D GHELWD GLVWDQ]D GDOOH &KLHVH FDWWROLFKH H/ SXUFKp D0 YHVVHUR RWWHQXWR OD SUHYHQWLYD DXWRUL]]D]LRQH GHO VHJUHWDULR GL 6WDWR R GHL JRYHUQDWRUL/ DG XVFLUH GDO ORUR JKHWWR/ GHELWDPHQWH UHFLQWDWR ILQ GDO 496;1 ,O &RGLFH GHO 4;84 QRQ PLJOLRUz OD VLWXD]LRQH H QRQ FRQFHVVH DJOL HEUHL OD SDUL0 Wj FRPSOHWD GHL GLULWWL FLYLOL D GLIIHUHQ]D GHOOH OHJLVOD]LRQL LQ YLJRUH QHO /RP0 EDUGR09HQHWR/ D 3DUPD/ LQ 7RVFDQD/ WDQWR q YHUR FKH HVVL IXURQR HVFOXVL GD WXWWL L &RQVLJOL FRPXQDOL/ GDOOH VFXROH SXEEOLFKH/ GDL FLPLWHUL H FRVWUHWWL D SRUWDUH EHQ LQ HYLGHQ]D XQ VHJQR GLVWLQWLYR GL FRORU URVVR1 0D VRSUDWWXWWR OD QRUPDWLYD PDWULPRQLDOH VHJQz XQD GLIIHUHQ]D QHWWD WUD OH GXH OHJLVOD]LRQL HVWHQVL HG HEEH WDOXQL SXQWL GL DQDORJLD FRQ LO FRGLFH SDU0 PHQVH1 ,QIDWWL/ PHQWUH LO &RGLFH GHO 4::4/ DOO·DUW1 ; GHO WLW1 ;,,, +OLEUR ,,,/ ULFRQR0 VFHYD DL WULEXQDOL VHFRODUL OD FRPSHWHQ]D H OD JLXULVGL]LRQH D JLXGLFDUH OH FDX0 VH GL VHSDUD]LRQH WHPSRUDQHH H SHUSHWXH GHL FRQLXJDWL/ LO &RGLFH GHO 4;84/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GHOOD QRUPDWLYD GL 0DULD /XLVD/ UHFHSHQGR LO GHFUHWR HVHFXWLYR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 GHOO·; PDJJLR 4;74 H ULFKLDPDQGRVL DO FRQFRUGDWR DSSURYDWR GD *UHJRULR ;9,/ ULVHUYz DL JLXGLFL GHOOR 6WDWR RJQL GHFLVLRQH FRQFHUQHQWH OLPLWDWDPHQWH OH TXHVWLRQL IRUPDOL H VRVWDQ]LDOL FLUFD JOL HIIHWWL FLYLOL HG HFR0 QRPLFL/ DWWULEXHQGR DL JLXGLFL HFFOHVLDVWLFL OD FRPSHWHQ]D GL HVDPLQDUH JOL LPSHGLPHQWL GLULPHQWL +HWj/ LPSRWHQ]D/ GLVSDULWj GL FXOWR/ YRWR VROHQQH/ FRQ0 VDQJXLQHLWj/ DIILQLWj/ UDWWR/ GHOLWWR, H GL HPDQDUH OD UHODWLYD VHQWHQ]D1 3HU UL0 VSHWWDUH LO GLULWWR GHJOL HEUHL QHOOH GLVSRVL]LRQL WUDQVLWRULH YHQQH LQFOXVR LO GH0 FUHWR GHO 58 RWWREUH 4;84/ LQ FXL DOO·DUW1 ; IX ULFRQRVFLXWD/ FRPH D 3DUPD/ DL PLQLVWUL GHOOD UHOLJLRQH LVUDHOLWLFD LQ 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR OD FRPSHWHQ]D GL GHFL0
<5;
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
GHUH OH FDXVH OHJDOL FRQFHUQHQWL LO PDWULPRQLR/ LO GLYRU]LR H ´ORUR GLSHQGHQ0 ]Hµ1 &RPH HUD VWDWR VWDELOLWR DOO·DUW1 439 GHO &RGLFH &LYLOH SLHPRQWHVH H DOO·DUW1 68 GHO &RGLFH &LYLOH SDUPHQVH/ TXHOOR HVWHQVH SUHVFULVVH D VXD YROWD FKH SUL0 PD GHOOD FHOHEUD]LRQH LO QXEHQGR/ FDWWROLFR R HEUHR/ LQIHULRUH DL 58 DQQL GL HWj/ GRYHYD RWWHQHUH LO FRQVHQVR SUHYHQWLYR GDOO·HVHUFHQWH OD SDWULD SRWHVWj R GDOOD PDGUH/ VH TXHVWR HUD LQFDSDFH/ R GDO JLXGLFH VH PDQFDYDQR HQWUDPEL> DOO·DUW1 ;4 OR REEOLJz/ TXDORUD DYHVVH FRPSLXWR DQQL 58/ D FKLHGHUH ´FRQ DWWR ULVSHWWRVR LO FRQVLJOLR GHO SDGUH R/ LQ VXD PDQFDQ]D/ TXHOOR GHOOD PDGUHµ1 &RPH LO FRGLFH SDUPHQVH/ LO &RGLFH HVWHQVH DFFROVH GDOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH QD0 SROHRQLFD O·LVWLWXWR GHOOD RSSRVL]LRQH1 1HO SULPR IXURQR DXWRUL]]DWL D SUR0 SRUOD O·HVHUFHQWH OD SDWULD SRWHVWj/ LO SDGUH H O·DVFHQGHQWH HPDQFLSDQWH> QHO VHFRQGR IXURQR OHJLWWLPDWL D SUHVHQWDUOD/ LQ PDQFDQ]D GL DVFHQGHQWL/ DQFKH LO IUDWHOOR H OD VRUHOOD/ OR ]LR R OD ]LD QHO FDVR LQ FXL DYHVVHUR GLPRVWUDWR FKH LO IXWXUR FRQLXJH HUD DIIHWWR GD LPEHFLOOLWj/ GHPHQ]D R IXURUH1 /·LVWDQ]D/ PRWL0 YDWD GDO SURSRQHQWH/ DQGDYD LQGLUL]]DWD DO WULEXQDOH FLYLOH WHUULWRULDOPHQWH FRPSHWHQWH FKH VRPPDULDPHQWH SURQXQFLDYD FRQ VHQWHQ]D ´HQWUR 43 JLRUQL VXOOD GRPDQGD IDWWDµ1 $ SURSRVLWR GL DGHPSLPHQWL IRUPDOL/ ULFROOHJDQGRVL DOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH QD0 SROHRQLFD H SDUPHQVH/ O·DUW1 667 GHO &RGLFH HVWHQVH SUHVFULVVH FKH SULPD GHO0 OD FHOHEUD]LRQH L ILGDQ]DWL GRYHYDQR ´SUHVHQWDUVL DOO·XIILFLDOH SXEEOLFR GHO GRPLFLOLR GHOOD IXWXUD VSRVD H GLFKLDUDUH OD ORUR LQWHQ]LRQH GL XQLUVL LQ PD0 WULPRQLRµ/ FRQVHJQDQGRJOL ´OD IHGH DXWHQWLFD GL QDVFLWD JLXVWLILFDQWH OD ORUR HWjµ H O·DWWR DXWHQWLFR GHO FRQVHQVR SUHVWDWR GDOOH SHUVRQH LQGLFDWH QHJOL DUWL0 FROL :;2;41 ,O SXEEOLFR XIILFLDOH/ GRSR DYHU LQVHULWR L GXH GRFXPHQWL QHJOL VSHFLDOL ID0 VFLFROL/ ULODVFLDYD DOOH SDUWL XQ FHUWLILFDWR FKH DQGDYD SUHVHQWDWR DO SDUURFR/ LO TXDOH FRQVHJQDYD DJOL VSRVL OD ´IHGHµ DWWHVWDQWH O·DYYHQXWD FHOHEUD]LRQH1 0D QHL FDVL GL PDWULPRQL GHILQLWL ´GL FRVFLHQ]Dµ/ FKH OD &KLHVD SHUPHWWH0 YD/ FRPH VL SRWHYD ULVSHWWDUH O·DUW1 667" 3HU ULVROYHUH OD GHOLFDWD TXHVWLRQH LO GHFUHWR GXFDOH GHO : QRYHPEUH 4;88 DXWRUL]]z OD VRVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD SUHYHQWLYD SURPHVVD PDWULPRQLDOH FRQ OD IHGH GHO SDUURFR FKH O·XIILFLDOH GL VWDWR FLYLOH/ FRPH LO VROLWR/ WUDVFULYHYD QHO SXE0 EOLFR UHJLVWUR1 2YYLDPHQWH LO PLQLVWUR GHO FXOWR IX WHQXWR D FXUDUH JOL ´DFFHU0 WDPHQWL SUHOLPLQDULµ SHU DPPHWWHUH DOOD FHOHEUD]LRQH VDFUDPHQWDOH FKL OD UL0 FKLHGHYD SHU QRQ LQFRUUHUH QHO UHDWR GL RPLVVLRQH GL DWWL G·XIILFLR SXQLELOH FRQ SHQD SHFXQLDULD1
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<5<
,QROWUH LO GHFUHWR GXFDOH GLVFLSOLQz LO FDVR GHO PDWULPRQLR VHJUHWR/ FDQR0 QLFDPHQWH YDOLGR/ FKH IRVVH VWDWR VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH LPSXJQDWR GDYDQWL DL PD0 JLVWUDWL FLYLOL GDL JHQLWRUL1 ,QWHJUDQGR O·DUW1 <3 GHO &RGLFH/ LO SURYYHGLPHQWR GL )UDQFHVFR 9 SUHVFULVVH FKH/ RSSRQHQGRVL LO SDGUH R/ LQ VXD PDQFDQ]D/ OD PDGUH DOOD XQLRQH GHO ILJOLR FRQ XQD GRQQD VRFLDOPHQWH LQIHULRUH FKH UHFDYD SUHJLXGL]LR DO GHFRUR GHOOD IDPLJOLD/ H YHQHQGR WDOH RSSRVL]LRQH ULFRQRVFLXWD YDOLGD GDO WULEXQDOH FLYLOH/ L JHQLWRUL SRWHYDQR SULYDUH LO ILJOLR VWHVVR/ FKH QRQ VL HUD XQLIRUPDWR DOOD ORUR YRORQWj/ ´GHOOD PHWj DQFRUD GL TXHOOD TXRWD FKH JOL GRYUHEEH SHU OHJJH FRPSHWHUH VXOO·DVVH SDWHUQR H PDWHUQRµ> WXWWDYLD/ TXD0 ORUD O·RSSRVL]LRQH IRVVH VWDWD ULJHWWDWD GDO JLXGLFH/ OH SDUWL GRYHYDQR ULWHQHUVL ´UHJRODUPHQWH XQLWH DQFKH DJOL HIIHWWL FLYLOLµ1 8QD ULIRUPD VL HEEH QHOOD SURFHGXUD VRPPDULD FKH LO OLEUR , +WLW1 9,,, GHO &RGLFH GHO 4::4 DYHYD ULVHUYDWD QHOOH D]LRQL DYHQWL SHU RJJHWWR VDODUL/ PHUFH0 GL/ SHQVLRQL/ DIILWWL/ FRPSUD0YHQGLWD GL FRVH PRELOL/ PH]]DGULD H DYHQWL SHU DWWRUL H FRQYHQXWL OH YHGRYH/ L SXSLOOL/ L SRYHUL1 ,O &RGLFH GHO 4;84 HVWHVH TXH0 VWD SURFHGXUD DQFKH DOOH FDXVH PDWULPRQLDOL H SUHFLVDPHQWH SHU OH RSSRVL0 ]LRQL/ O·DSSHOOR/ OH LPSXJQD]LRQL1 ,QROWUH O·DUW1 565 GHO &RGLFH GL 3URFHGXUD FLYLOH DJJLXQVH TXHOOH FRQFHUQHQWL L FDQRQL/ OH GRWL H OH FRQWURYHUVLH DYHQWL SHU SHWLWXP XQ YDORUH PDJJLRUH GL ;3 OLUH LWDOLDQH/ PD LQIHULRUH D OLUH 833> O·DUW1 58; LQFOXVH OH FDXVH/ ´TXDOXQTXH QH VLD LO WLWROR/ LO PHULWR GHOOH TXDOL QRQ RO0 WUHSDVVD O·LPSRUWR GL LWDOLDQH OLUH ;3µ1 $ PLR SDUHUH/ QHOOD ULFHUFD VLVWHPDWLFD H VWUXWWXUDOH ULJXDUGDQWH LO GLULWWR FLYLOH OR VWXGLRVR QRQ SXz OLPLWDUVL VROR DG HVDPLQDUH OH LVWLWX]LRQL GL GLULWWR SULYDWR/ PD DQFKH OD JLXULVGL]LRQH RUGLQDULD FKH DVVLFXUD DL VLQJROL VRJJHWWL OD WXWHOD GHL ORUR GLULWWL H GHL ORUR LQWHUHVVL OHJLWWLPL1 $ TXHVWR ILQH O·RUGLQDPHQWR JLXGL]LDULR YLJHQWH QHO 'XFDWR HVWHQVH LQGLFz JOL RUJDQL/ PRQRFUDWLFL H FROOHJLDOL/ FRQ OH ORUR FRPSHWHQ]H SHU WHUULWRULR/ PDWHULD/ YDORUH GHO SHWLWXP/ GDYDQWL DL TXDOL WURYz HVSOLFD]LRQH OD IXQ]LRQH JLXGL]LDULD FKH RYYLDPHQWH VXEu YDULD]LRQL GDO 4::4 DO 4;8;1 ,O WLWROR ,,, GHO OLEUR ,9 GHO &RGLFH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ ULFKLDPDWD OD JULGD GXFDOH GHO < OXJOLR 4:83/ DWWULEXu DO 7ULEXQDOH 6XSUHPR GL *LXVWL]LD OD FRP0 SHWHQ]D D JLXGLFDUH OH FDXVH FLYLOL/ DIILGDQGRQH O·LVWUXWWRULD DL JLXGLFL GL ,ƒ JUDGR GHOOR 6WDWR LPPHGLDWR H DO IHXGDWDULR GHOOR 6WDWR PHGLDWR/ LO TXDOH VL DYYDOHYD GL SURSUL PDJLVWUDWL GD OXL VFHOWL D VXR DUELWULR1 &RQ GHFUHWR GHO 5; DJRVWR 4;47 )UDQFHVFR ,9 DWWULEXu OH FDXVH FLYLOL +PD0 WULPRQLDOL/ FRQWUDWWXDOL/ VXFFHVVRULH/ HFF1, LQ SULPD LVWDQ]D/ LQ UDSSRUWR DO YD0 ORUH GHO SHWLWXP/ DL WUHQWD JLXVGLFHQWL GLVWULEXLWL QHL WHUULWRUL PRGHQHVH/ UHJJLD0
<63
*LXVHSSH %HGRQL
QD/ JDUIDJQLQR H OXQLJLDQHVH/ QRQFKp H DL WUH WULEXQDOL GL *LXVWL]LD GL 0RGH0 QD/ 5HJJLR/ &DVWHOQXRYR GL *DUIDJQDQD/ H OH FDXVH LQ JUDGR GL DSSHOOR DO WUL0 EXQDOH GL 0RGHQD FRQWUR OH VHQWHQ]H GHL WULEXQDOL GL ,ƒ JUDGR GL 5HJJLR H &DVWHOQXRYR H DO WULEXQDOH GL 5HJJLR FRQWUR TXHOOH HPHVVH GDO WULEXQDOH GL ,ƒ JUDGR GL 0RGHQD1 $IILGz LQILQH DOOD VHFRQGD VH]LRQH GHO VXSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD O·XIILFLR GL JLXGLFDUH L ULFRUVL/ OH LPSXJQD]LRQL/ OH UHYLVLRQL GHOOH FDXVH FLYLOL GL WXWWR LO WHUULWRULR GXFDOH1 )UDQFHVFR 9/ LO 5 DJRVWR 4;7;/ GRSR DYHU FUHDWR LO 0LQLVWHUR SHU JOL DIIDUL GL *UD]LD H *LXVWL]LD H SHU JOL DIIDUL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ ULWRFFz O·RUGLQDPHQWR JLX0 GL]LDULR FKH ULVXOWz FRPSRVWR GDO 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ GDL WULEX0 QDOL GL DSSHOOR GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ 0DVVD/ GDL WULEXQDOL GL ,ƒ JUDGR GL 0RGH0 QD/ 5HJJLR/ 0DVVD &DUUDUD/ GDOOH JLXVGLFHQ]H H YLFH0JHUHQ]H GHL WHUULWRUL GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ /XQLJLDQD/ *DUIDJQDQD1 (QWUDWR LQ YLJRUH LO QXRYR &RGLFH GL SURFHGXUD FLYLOH LO 4ƒ QRYHPEUH 4;85/ VL HEEH XQ XOWHULRUH PRGLILFD SURFHVVXDOH1 9HQQHUR LVWLWXLWL LO 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDOH GL 5HYLVLRQH QHOOD FDSLWDOH/ L WULEXQDOL GL DSSHOOR GL 5HJJLR H 0DVVD/ L WULEXQDOL GL ,ƒ JUDGR D 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ &DUUDUD/ QXPHURVH JLXVGLFHQ]H QHO0 OH 3URYLQFLH PRGHQHVH/ UHJJLDQD/ PDVVHVH/ XIILFL GL FRQFLOLD]LRQH D 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR1 )UDQFHVFR 9 RUGLQz DL PDJLVWUDWL FKH WXWWH OH FDXVH FLYLOL YHQLVVHUR FHOHEUDWH FRQ ´GLEDWWLWR SXEEOLFRµ/ VHFRQGR OD SUDVVL SURFHVVXDOH VHJXLWD LQ 3LHPRQWH/ 1DSROL/ 7RVFDQD/ 3DUPD1 $OOR VFRSR GL HYLWDUH FKH JOL DSSHOOL H L ULFRUVL ´DEXVLYLµ LQWUDOFLDVVHUR O·D]LRQH SURFHVVXDOH/ LO PLQLVWUR GL *UD]LD H *LXVWL]LD &RFFKL/ LO 55 IHEEUDLR 4;8;/ SUHVFULVVH FKH FRQWUR L GHFUHWL R OH VHQWHQ]H GLFKLDUDWL H[ OHJH LQDSSHOOD0 ELOL/ LO JLXGLFH FLYLOH GL ,ƒ JUDGR GRYHVVH G·XIILFLR ULJHWWDUH O·LPSXJQD]LRQH R LO ULFRUVR1 $PPHVVR O·DSSHOOR/ OH SDUWL +DWWRUH H FRQYHQXWR, HUDQR REEOLJDWH D SURGXUUH LO OLEHOOR HQWUR LO SHUHQWRULR WHUPLQH GL GXH JLRUQL LQGLFDQGRYL OH PRWLYD]LRQL/ H D SUHVHQWDUH IRUPDOPHQWH LO PDWHULDOH SUREDWRULR1 ,O WULEXQDOH/ GDYDQWL DO TXDOH HUD VWDWD SURSRVWD O·LPSXJQD]LRQH/ LQ &DPHUD GL &RQVLJOLR/ VL SURQXQFLDYD HQWUR 8 JLRUQL1 1HOOD UHYLVLRQH FKL ULFRUUHYD GRORVDPHQWH SHU PDQLIHVWD YLROD]LRQH GL OHJJH R SHU LQIRQGDWH]]D GHL PRWLYL H UHVWDYD VRFFRPEHQWH/ ROWUH DG HVVHUH FRQGDQQDWR DOOH VSHVH JLXGL]LDULH/ GRYHYD SDJDUH XQD PXOWD QRQ PLQRUH GL OLUH 633 LQ IDYRUH GHOO·HUDULR1 $ WDOH RQHUH HUD WHQXWR/ LQ VROLGR FRQ LO SURSULR FOLHQWH/ DQFKH LO VXR SURFXUDWRUH OHJDOH/ LO TXDOH QRQ SRWHYD SUHWHQGHUH GD OXL OD SDUFHOOD1 2YYLDPHQWH O·DSSDUDWR JLXGL]LDULR H OD QRUPDWLYD SURFHVVXDOH GHFDGGHUR
,O GLULWWR FLYLOH QHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVL= GDO FRGLFH GHO 4::4 DO FRGLFH GHO 4;84
<64
LO 49 JLXJQR 4;8< SHU HIIHWWR GHO GHFUHWR GHO FRPPLVVDULR SURYYLVRULR /XLJL =LQL FKH FRQVHUYz SURYYLVRULDPHQWH LO 6XSUHPR 7ULEXQDOH GL 5HYLVLRQH/ LO WULEXQDOH GL DSSHOOR D 5HJJLR/ L WULEXQDOL GL ,ƒ JUDGR D 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR H L0 VWLWXu JLXVGLFHQ]H FLYLOL D 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ 0LUDQGROD1 &RQ GHFUHWR GHO 5: GLFHPEUH 4;8< LO )DULQL GDO 4ƒ PDJJLR LPSRVH O·DSSOLFD]LRQH GHL &RGLFL &LYLOH H GL 3URFHGXUD FLYLOH SLHPRQWHVL1 5LHSLORJDQGR/ VL SXz DIIHUPDUH FKH GDO FRQIURQWR WUD OH GXH FRGLILFD]LRQL HVWHQVL LO GLULWWR FLYLOH QRQ VXEu XQD QRWHYROH HYROX]LRQH/ SHU FXL VL SXz SDU0 ODUH GL FRQWLQXLWj OHJLVODWLYD HWLFDPHQWH VRVWDQ]LDOH/ D SDUWH PRGLILFKH WHFQL0 FKH H SURFHGXUDOL/ SXUDPHQWH IRUPDOL1 ,QVRPPD PDQFz XQD YHUD H SURSULD ULYROX]LRQH OHJLVODWLYD H OH XQLFKH LQ0 QRYD]LRQL IXURQR LPSRVWH GDOOD QHFHVVLWj GL XQLIRUPDUVL DOOH OHJLVOD]LRQL FLYL0 OLVWLFKH SLHPRQWHVH/ SDUPHQVH/ DXVWULDFD/ WRVFDQD1
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<66
$1*(/2 63$**,$5,
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
7UDWWHUHPR LO QRVWUR WHPD/ VFHJOLHQGR 0 FRPH SXQWR GL LQL]LR GHO GLVFRUVR 0 XQD GDWD LQWHUPHGLD QHO OXQJR DUFR GL GXUDWD GHOOR ´6WDWR GL 0RGHQDµ +48<;04;8<,1 3HU O·HVDWWH]]D/ FRPLQFHUHPR DG HVDPLQDUH OD VLWXD]LRQH GHJOL DUFKLYL QHJOL VWDWL HVWHQVL RVVHUYDELOH DOOD ILQH GHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ SHUFKp TXHO0 OR ´6WDWR GL 0RGHQDµ 0 SUHFLSLWRVDPHQWH QDWR QHO JHQQDLR 48<; 0 JLXVWR VXO ILQLUH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ VWDYD DFTXLVHQGR XQD VXD SHFXOLDUH ILVLRQRPLD4/ ULVFRQ0 WUDELOH SURSULR QHOOH VXH LVWLWX]LRQL/ IUD OH TXDOL GHYRQR HVVHUH FROORFDWL/ D SLHQR WLWROR/ JOL DUFKLYL1 ,Q DOWUH SDUROH/ OD VLWXD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD GL ILQH VHWWH0 FHQWR UDSSUHVHQWD 0 DOPHQR SHU OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD HG RYYLDPHQWH SHU O·DPELHQWH GHJOL DUFKLYL 0 XQ SXQWR GL DUULYR GHO WUDYDJOLR LVWLWX]LRQDOH GHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH HG XQ SXQWR GL SDUWHQ]D SHU OR VWDWR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH +4;470 4;8<, FKH DOOH LVWLWX]LRQL VHWWHFHQWHVFKH YROOH IDU ULIHULPHQWR SHU LO VXR JHQH0 UDOH GLVHJQR UHVWDXUDWLYR51 (EEHQH/ WUD OD ILQH GHO 4:;< H L SULPL PHVL GHO 4:<3 VL VYROVH D 0RGHQD XQD SLFFROD/ PD DEEDVWDQ]D UXYLGD/ GLVSXWD DUFKLYLVWLFD FKH FRLQYROVH LO ´GX0 FDOH &DSR $UFKLYLVWDµ 3HOOHJULQR 1LFROz /RVFKL/ UHVSRQVDELOH GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ HG LO ´0DVWUR GL &RQWR *LDQ %DWWLVWD 'DOO·2OLRµ/ UHVSRQVDELOH GHOO·$UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH1 'L TXHOOD GLVSXWD 0 FKH ULJXDUGDYD LO GLULWWR GHOO·XQR R GHOO·DOWUR GHL GXH PHQ]LRQDWL ´DUFKLYLµ/ GL FRQVHUYDUH L ´FDWDVWUL GHOOH LQYHVWLWXUH GHL VHFROL ;,9/ ;9 H ;9,µ/ H FKH VL ULVROVH/ DOORUD/ VHQ]D YLQWL H VHQ]D YLQFLWRUL/ LQWH0 ²²²²²²²² 4 )UD O·DEERQGDQWH ELEOLRJUDILD VXO VHWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH FLWLDPR/ D WLWROR GL HVHPSLR/ VROR L ODYRUL GL *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL IUD ULYROX]LRQH H UHVWDXUD]LRQH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0X0 UDWRULDQD/ 4<9: H GL *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<;61 3HU XQD YLVLRQH SL• JHQHUDOH GHOOD VWUXWWXUD GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH/ VL YHGD '1 *5$1$/ *OL RUJD0 QL FHQWUDOL GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH QHO SHULRGR PRGHQHVH/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWRª +5$6,/ /9+4<<8,/ Q1 506/ SS1 63706661 5 &IU1 *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<::1
<67
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
UHVVD TXL/ OD VHJXHQWH IUDVH GHOOD OHWWHUD GHO /RVFKL GHO 8 PDU]R 4:<31 'LFH LO /RVFKL ´DOOD SURPHPRULD LQDVSHWWDWD H WDQWR LQFRQJUXD GHO VLJQRU 'DOO·2JOLR/ ULVSRQGR VROR FKH LO 'XFDOH $UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR q O·XQLFD EDVH/ R DOPHQR LO SULQFLSDOH IRQGDPHQWR +SHU QXOOD GHWUDUUH DL ULVSHWWDELOLVVLPL $UFKLYL GHL 3XEEOLFKL LOOXVWULVVLPL GL TXHVWR VHUHQLVVLPR 'RPLQLR, GL WXWWL L GLULWWL GHO 6R0 YUDQR/ GHJOL 6WDWL H GH· 3DUWLFRODUL/ DO TXDO IRQWH/ G·RUGLQDULR QHOOH PDJJLRUL RFFRUUHQ]H VL ULFRUUH 111µ61 'DOOD YLFHQGD VRSUDULIHULWD H GDOOD IUDVH GHO /RVFKL VL LPSDUDQR PROWH FRVH VXJOL DUFKLYL GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD YHUVR OD ILQH GHOO· DQFLHQ UHJLPH1 *OL $UFKLYL (VWHQVL ,Q SULPR OXRJR DEELDPR XQ·XOWHULRUH FRQIHUPD GHOOD GLFRWRPLD GHJOL DU0 FKLYL GXFDOL FKH ULVXOWDYDQR IRUPDWL DSSXQWR GDOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ LVWL0 WXLWR H PDWHULDOPHQWH FRQVHUYDWR QHO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH GL 0RGHQD/ H GDOO·$UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH FKH VL FRQVHUYDYD/ LQ TXHJOL DQQL/ VHPSUH QHO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH/ PD LQ ORFDOL EHQ GLVWLQWL H FRQ XQD VSHFLILFD ´GLUH]LRQHµ71 ,Q VHFRQGR OXRJR/ OHJJHQGR DWWHQWDPHQWH OD IUDVH GHO /RVFKL/ FL UHQGLDPR FRQWR FKH O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH +R 'XFDOH $UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR, HUD ´VH0 JUHWRµ Vu/ PD/ DO WHPSR VWHVVR/ QRQ HUD LQDFFHVVLELOH/ YLVWR FKH/ HYLGHQWHPHQ0 ²²²²²²²² 6
&IU1 $1 63$**,$5,/ *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OD FXOWXUD DUFKLYLVWLFD GHO 6HWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH/ LQ *LUR0 ODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ 0LVFHOODQHD GL 6WXGL/ D FXUD GL $151 9(1785, %$5%2/,1,/ 0RGHQD/ %LEO1 (0 VWHQVH 8QLYHUVLWDULD/ 4<::/ SDJJ1 54805531 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD 3HOOHJULQR 1LFFROz /RVFKL +4:4<04:<4, q GD ULFRUGDUH FKH OR VWHVVR HUD QDWLYR GL &RUWLOH QHO FDUSLJLDQR/ FKH HUD ´GRWWR0 UHµ/ H FKH ² XQD YROWD WUDVIHULWRVL D 0RGHQD YHUVR LO 4:73 ² FRPLQFLz D IUHTXHQWDUH OD %LEOLR0 WHFD H O·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVL/ ILQFKp QRQ GLYHQQH ´$UFKLYLVWD &DSRµ GL TXHVW·XOWLPR QHO 4:9< H WDOH UHVWz ILQR DOOD PRUWH1 3HUVRQDJJLR HUXGLWR HG HVWURVR/ PD FRQ LO FDUDWWHUH ´VWUDYDJDQWH H FLQLFR DO GL Oj GL RJQL UDJLRQHYROH]]Dµ> ODVFLz QHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH WUDFFH QRWHYROL GHOOD VXD SHUVRQDOLWj1 &IU1 31 *8$,72/,/ &DUWHJJLR IUD O·$EDWH &DYDOLHUH *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H O·$YYRFDWR (XVWDFKLR &DEDVVL GL &DUSL/ LQ 0HPRULH VWRULFKH H GRFXPHQWL VXOOD FLWWj H VXOO·DQWLFR SULQFLSDWR GL &DUSL/ YRO1 9,/ &DUSL/ &RPPLVVLRQH &RPXQDOH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD H %HOOH $UWL/ 4;<704;<8191 DQFKH $1 6$00$5,1,/ %LEOLRJUDILD G·DXWRUL FDUSLJLDQL/ LQ 0HPRULH VWRULFKH/ 111FLW/ YRO1 ,,/ &DUSL/ 4;:<04;;31 7 'XUDQWH O·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ JOL XIILFL GL &DQFHOOHULD/ OH FXL FDUWH/ QDWXUDOPHQWH/ FRQIOXLYDQR YHUVR O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR ² HUDQR FRQFHQWUDWL TXDVL WXWWL LQ 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH/ PHQWUH JOL XIILFL ILQDQ]LDUL ² FKH YHUVDYDQR DOO·$UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH ² HUDQR GLVORFDWL DQFKH LQ VHGL HVWHUQH DO 3DOD]]R/ FRPH/ DG HVHPSLR/ LO 0DJLVWUDWR GHJOL DOORJJL H OD )HUPD *HQHUDOH FKH HUDQR FROORFDWL LQ GXH IDEEULFDWL GHO ´&RUVR &DQDOJUDQGHµ1 &IU1 )1 6266$,/ 0RGHQD GHVFULWWD/ 0RGHQD/ 7LS1 &D0 PHUDOH/ 4;74/ S1 :9> &IU1 *1 %(578==,/ ,O ULQQRYDPHQWR HGLOL]LR D 0RGHQD QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ ,,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;5/ SS1 :80<91 Ë LO FDVR GL ULFRUGDUH FKH/ GXUDQWH OD UHVWDXUD]LRQH/ DQFKH JOL XIILFL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL FR0 PLQFLDURQR D UHSHULUH OH ORUR VHGL IXRUL GHO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH ² &IU1 )1 6266$,/ 0RGHQD 11/ FLW1
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<68
WH FRQ LO SHUPHVVR GHO 6RYUDQR/ DQFKH L SULYDWL +GHILQLWL QHO JHUJR EXURFUDWLFR HVWHQVH ´SDUWLFRODULµ, SRWHYDQR DFFHGHUYL D WXWHOD GHL ORUR GLULWWL ULFKLHGHQGR SHU OR SL• FRSLH GL DWWL FKH YHQLYDQR ULODVFLDWH RUPDL GD WHPSR8 DXWHQWLFDWH GD XQ DSSRVLWR VLJLOOR SURSULR GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR1 ,Q VRVWDQ]D/ O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWR SHU VHFROL O·DUFKLYLR SURSULR GL XQD &DVDWD +TXHOOD GHJOL (VWH/ DSSXQWR, VL DYYLDYD DG HV0 VHUH/ VXO ILQLUH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ XQ DUFKLYLR GL &DVD/ &RUWH H 6WDWR9/ FRQ XQD PRGHVWD/ PD LQQHJDELOH/ DSHUWXUD YHUVR O·HVWHUQR1 /·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH +GHILQLWR GDO 'XFD )UDQFHVFR ,,, ´OD JHPPD SL• SUH]LRVD GHOOD SURSULD &DVDµ, YHQQH FRQVHUYDWR D )HUUDUD ILQR DO 48<;/ H IX RJJHWWR GL VSHFLILFKH DWWHQ]LRQL QHOOH &RQYHQ]LRQL )DHQWLQH GHO 46 JHQ0 QDLR 48<;/ FKH VDQFLURQR/ FRPH VDSSLDPR/ OD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH H FKH GHWHUPLQDURQR O·LQL]LR GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD1 /·DUWLFROR 7ƒ GL TXHVWH FRQYHQ]LRQL 0 FKH IXURQR/ SHU OD SUHFLVLRQH/ FRP0 SLODWH LQ OLQJXD LWDOLDQD H VHPSUH LQ LWDOLDQR IXURQR UHFHSLWH QHOOD EROOD FRQFL0 VWRULDOH GHO 4< JHQQDLR 48<; FKH DSSURYDYD OH ´&DSLWROD]LRQLµ 0 FRQVHQWLYD DO 'XFD &HVDUH GL ´PDQGDUH IXRUL GL )HUUDUD QHJOL 6WDWL VXRL LPSHULDOL OLEHUD0 PHQWH H VHQ]D DOFXQ LPSHGLPHQWR WXWWH OH VXH JLRLH/ RUL/ DUJHQWL HW DOWUH FRVH SUH]LRVH 111 H SRVVD DQFR PDQGDUH QHOOL GHWWL VXRL 6WDWL WXWWH OH VFULWWXUH GHO VXR $UFKLYLR HW L OLEUL GL &DPHUD GD YHGHUVL FRQ O·LQWHUYHQWR GL FKL VDUj GHSX0 WDWR GDOO·LOOXVWULVVLPR 6LJQRU &DUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQR/ SHU DYHUVL 6XD 6LJQRUuD ,OOXVWULVVLPD D ULWHQHUH TXHOOH VFULWWXUH FKH VL WURYHUDQQR DSSDUWHQHUH DOOD 6H0 GH $SRVWROLFD HW DOOH UDJLRQL GHOOD &DPHUD GL )HUUDUD 111µ1 $ TXHVWR SURSRVL0 WR/ LO 9DOHQWL:/ DJJLXQJH= ´'DO 0XUDWRUL LPSDULDPR SRL FKH ´QHO Gu 49 G·HVVR JHQQDLR +48<;, VL SRUWDURQR D )HUUDUD O·$UFLYHVFRYR GL 5DJXVL 0DWWHXFFL H 0DULR )DUQHVH> O·XQR SHU SUHQGHUH LQ FRQVHJQD OH VFULWWXUH VSHWWDQWL DOOD FLWWj HG DO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD/ O·DOWUR SHU SDUWLUH FRQ 'XFD OH DUWLJOLHULHµ ;1 1RQ VDSSLDPR HVDWWDPHQWH GL TXDQWR IX LPSRYHULWR O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR LQ TXHOOD WULVWH RFFDVLRQH/ PD VDSSLDPR FKH JUDQ SDUWH GHO PDWHULDOH DUFKLYLVWLFR YHQQH WUDVSRUWDWD D 0RGHQD/ VLVWHPDWD DOOD PHQR SHJJLR QHO &DVWHOOR HVWHQVH H VRWWRSRVWD/ QHJOL DQQL/ D SURJUHVVLYL ULRUGLQDPHQWL H ULRUJDQL]]D]LRQL GLUHWWL ²²²²²²²² 8 'DL WHPSL/ DOPHQR/ GL /1$1 0XUDWRUL FKH VL DGRSHUz SHU XQD HIIHWWLYD LVWLWX]LRQDOL]]D0 ]LRQH GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH1 &IU1 $1 63$**,$5, 0 *1 75(17,/ /1$1 0XUDWRUL H JOL (0 VWHQVL/ LQ &RUWH/ %XRQ *RYHUQR/ 3XEEOLFD )HOLFLWj/ 3ROLWLFR H FRVFLHQ]D FLYLOH QHO 0XUDWRUL/ )LUHQ]H/ 2O0 VFKNL/ 4<<9/ SS1 40461 9 &IU1 $1 %5(11(.(/ $UFKLYLVWLFD1 &RQWULEXWR DOOD WHRULD HG DOOD VWRULD DUFKLYLVWLFD HXURSHD1 7UD0 GX]LRQH LWDOLDQD GL 51 3(55(//$/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<9;1 : &IU1 )1 9$/(17,/ 3URILOR VWRULFR GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ 5RPD/ 0LQ1 ,QWHUQR/ 4<8;1 ; &IU1 /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOH DQWLFKLWj HVWHQVL/ W1,,/ 0RGHQD/ 6WDPSHULD 'XFDOH/4:73/ S1 7451
<69
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
D IDU Vu FKH LO PDWHULDOH DUFKLYLVWLFR DQWHULRUH DO 48<;/ XQLWDPHQWH D TXHOOR GL GDWD VXFFHVVLYD SRWHVVH FRVWLWXLUH OD EDVH GHOO·$UFKLYLR &HQWUDOH GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH/ GHOOD VXD &RUWH H GHO VXR 6WDWR/ RYYLDPHQWH DWWLYR QHOOD QXRYD FDSLWD0 OH FKH HUD DSSXQWR 0RGHQD1 /H YLFHQGH GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR HVWHQVH DPSLDPHQWH LOOXVWUDWH GDO 9DOHQ0 < WL VRQR LQ JUDQ SDUWH QRWH/ PD DOFXQL HSLVRGL SRVVRQR HVVHUH ULFRUGDWL LQ TXHVWD VHGH1 5LFRUGLDPR DG HVHPSLR LO IDWWR FKH O·$UFKLYLR YHQQH GLUHWWR GD /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL GDO 4:33 DO 4:7</ PD ULFRUGLDPR DQFKH FKH GRSR LO 4:<9 0 FRQ L JRYHUQL QDSROHRQLFL 0 O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR/ GHQRPLQDWR $UFKLYLR 1D]LR0 QDOH +SRL $UFKLYLR *RYHUQDWLYR, GLYHQQH XQ ´DUFKLYLR JHQHUDOH GL GHSRVLWRµ H FRPLQFLz DG DWWUDUUH JOL DUFKLYL GHOOH VRSSUHVVH PDJLVWUDWXUH GXFDOL/ QRQFKp XQD SDUWH GHOOH VFULWWXUH GHOO·DQWLFR $UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH FKH FRQWLQXDYD DG DYHUH YLWD DXWRQRPD1 3HUFKp VL DYHVVH OD ULXQLILFD]LRQH LQ XQ XQLFR LVWLWXWR GHL GXH JUDQGL UDPL GHOO·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVH +H FLRq ULSHWLDPR O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR H O·$UFKLYLR &DPH0 UDOH, ELVRJQz DWWHQGHUH DGGLULWWXUD O·8QLWj G·,WDOLD1 ,QIDWWL/ GXUDQWH OD 5HVWDX0 UD]LRQH PHQWUH O·DUFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH +FRQ LO QRPH ULQQRYDWR GL $UFKL0 YLR 6HJUHWR 5HDOH 0 R $UFKLYLR 3DODWLQR 0, WRUQDYD D ULSUHQGHUH LO UXROR GL ´DUFKLYLR GL &DVD/ &RUWH H 6WDWRµ/ QHOOD ULSULVWLQDWD &DSLWDOH/ 0RGHQD/ YHQLYD FRVWLWXLWR XQ $UFKLYLR *HQHUDOH GL 'HSRVLWR +4;7<, FRQ LO FRPSLWR GL UDFFR0 JOLHUH JOL DUFKLYL GHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR H GL SDUWH GL TXHOOL GHO SHULRGR DX0 VWUR0HVWHQVH1 5HVWDYDQR LQ YLWD QXPHURVL DUFKLYL VSHFLDOL]]DWL WUD L TXDOL VSLF0 FDYD O·$UFKLYLR 'HPDQLDOH FRQ JOL DQWLFKL IRQGL &DPHUDOL DGHJXDWDPHQWH GH0 VFULWWL GD )UDQFHVFR %RQDLQL/ QHO VXR QRWR VDJJLR VXJOL DUFKLYL HPLOLDQL431 ²²²²²²²² <
&IU1 )1 9$/(17,/ 3URILOR VWRULFR«FLW1 )1 %21$,1,/ *OL DUFKLYL QHOOH SURYLQFH GHOO·(PLOLD H OH ORUR FRQGL]LRQL DO ILQLUH GHO 4;93/ )LUHQ]H/ &HOOLQL/ 4;941 ,O %RQDLQL/ VHJQDOz/ SHU L WHUULWRUL JLj HVWHQVL/ YDUL DUFKLYL OLPLWDQGR/ SHUz/ OD VXD LQGDJLQH DOOH ORFDOLWj GD OXL ULWHQXWH SL• LPSRUWDQWL1 $ 0RGHQD QRWz= D, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &R0 PXQH> E, O·$UFKLYLR H[ 'XFDOH> F, XQ $UFKLYLR GL *DELQHWWR GHJOL H[ 'XFKL> G, XQ $UFKLYLR 'HPDQLDOH XQLWR DOO·$UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH> H, XQ $UFKLYLR *HQHUDOH GL 'HSRVLWR> I, XQ $UFKLYLR GHOOD 3XEEOLFD 6LFXUH]]D> J, XQ $UFKLYLR GHJOL DWWL ILQDQ]LDUL> K, GXH $UFKLYL GHJOL DWWL JLXGL0 ]LDUL> L, O·$UFKLYLR GHJOL DWWL QRWDULOL> O, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &ROOHJLR GHL 1RWDL> P, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &D0 WDVWR> Q, O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·2SHUD 3LD> R, O·$UFKLYLR 9HVFRYLOH H O·DUFKLYLR &DSLWRODUH> S, DOFXQL DUFKLYL SULYDWL1 $ 5HJJLR/ LO QRVWUR QRWz= D, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &RPXQH> E, O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·,QWHQGHQ]D VDEDXGD FRQ DQQHVVL DUFKLYL GL LVWLWXWL VWDWDOL SUHFHGHQWL> F, O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·2SHUD 3LD> G, O·$UFKLYLR GHJOL DWWL JLXGL]LDUL> H, O·$UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH> I, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &D0 WDVWR> J, O·$UFKLYLR 9HVFRYLOH H O·$UFKLYLR &DSLWRODUH> K, O·DUFKLYLR SULYDWR 7XUUL1 $ 1RQDQWR0 OD LO %RQDLQL QRWz= D, O·$UFKLYLR $EED]LDOH> E, O·$UFKLYLR &RPXQDOH> F, O·$UFKLYLR GHOOD *LX0 VGLFHQ]D1 (G/ LQILQH/ D 0DVVD 0 FKH HUD HQWUDWD D IDU SDUWH GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL VROR QHO 4;5< 0 LO %RQDLQL QRWz= D, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &RPXQH> E, O·$UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH> F, O·$UFKLYLR GHO &DWDVWR> G, 43
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<6:
&RQ O·8QLWj G·,WDOLD/ QHOO·LVWLWXWR FKH VDUHEEH GLYHQWDWR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ O·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH H O·$UFKLYLR &DPHUDOH YHQQHUR ULXQLWL TXDVL D FRVWLWXLUH XQ XQLFR ´IRQGR HVWHQVHµ/ VHQ]D SHUz FKH OH ORUR VSHFLILFKH LQGLYLGXDOLWj YHQLVVHUR FDQFHOODWH1 $ TXHVWR SXQWR FL VHPEUD GL DYHU GHWWR DEEDVWDQ]D GHJOL $UFKLYL FHQWUDOL GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH H FL VHPEUD RSSRUWXQR ULWRUQDUH VXOOD IUDVH GL 3HOOHJULQR 1LFROz /RVFKL/ FRQ OD TXDOH DEELDPR LQL]LDWR OH QRVWUH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL1 9RJOLDPR WRUQDUH DO SXQWR LQ FXL LO /RVFKL/ QHO VRVWHQHUH OD IRQGDPHQWDOH LPSRUWDQ]D GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ ULFRQRVFH O·HVLVWHQ]D GL DOWUL DU0 FKLYL GL JUDQGH LPSRUWDQ]D FRQ O·HVSUHVVLRQH ´SHU QXOOD GHWUDUUH DL ULVSHWWDEL0 OLVVLPL $UFKLYL GHL 3XEEOLFKL LOOXVWULVVLPL GL TXHVWR VHUHQLVVLPR 'RPLQLRµ1 &RQ TXHVWD HVSUHVVLRQH LO /RVFKL YROHYD DOOXGHUH TXDQWR PHQR DJOL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL HG DJOL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL/ PD IRUVH DQFKH DG DOWUL LVWLWXWL DUFKLYLVWLFL DIIL0 GDWL LQ TXHJOL DQQL DOOH SXEEOLFKH DPPLQLVWUD]LRQL GHL SULQFLSDOL OXRJKL GHOOR 6WDWR441 *OL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD JOL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL YHUL H SURSUL/ QRWLDPR FKH QHJOL ´6WDWL LPSHULDOLµ GHJOL (VWHQVL VSLFFDYDQR GXH JUDQGL DUFKLYL FRUULVSRQGHQWL DOOH FLWWj GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR/ OH TXDOL DYHYDQR DYXWR XQ QRWHYROH SHVR SROLWLFR QHO SHULRGR FRPXQDOH H VLJQRULOH H VYROJHYDQR DQFRUD/ SXUH QHO UH0 JLPH GL ´SULQFLSDWRµ/ UXROL IRQGDPHQWDOL QHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOR 6WDWR H0 VWHQVH1 3HU TXHVWD UDJLRQH/ JOL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL GL 5HJJLR45 H GL 0RGHQD46 SRWH0 ²²²²²²²² JOL $UFKLYL GHL 7ULEXQDOL> H, O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·RVSHGDOH> I, O·$UFKLYLR JLj 'XFDOH/ HG RJJL ´GL JR0 YHUQRµ1 44 1RQ SHQVLDPR FKH LO /RVFKL YROHVVH DOOXGHUH DOO·$UFKLYLR GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj SHUFKp LQ TXHJOL DQQL TXHVWR GRYHYD HVVHUH TXDOFRVD GL VLPLOH DG XQ PRGHUQR DUFKLYLR FRUUHQWH/ YLVWR FKH O·8QLYHUVLWj HUD VWDWD ULIRQGDWD VROR QHO 4::51 &·q SLXWWRVWR GD GRPDQGDUVL VH LO QRVWUR YROHVVH SDUODUH DQFKH GHJOL $UFKLYL GHOOH 2SHUH SLH GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR/ FKH/ SURSULR LQ TXHJOL DQQL/ VL DQGDYDQR DUULFFKHQGR GL GRFXPHQWL H GL DUFKLYL JLj DSSDUWHQXWL DG LVWLWXWL UHOL0 JLRVL VRSSUHVVL/ LQ DSSOLFD]LRQH GHOOD SROLWLFD JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFD1 0D SHU TXHVWR VL YHGD FR0 PXQTXH SL• DYDQWL1 45&IU181 '$//$5,/ ,/ 51 $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 5HJJLR QHOO·(PLOLD/ +5RFFD 6DQ &DVFLDQR/ &DS0 SHOOL/ 4<43,1+V1 ,,/ 9RO1 ,/ GHOOD FROODQD *OL DUFKLYL GHOOD 6WRULD G·,WDOLD D FXUD GL *1 0$==$7,17, H *1 '(*/, $==,, Y1 DQFKH $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ D FXUD GL *1 %$',1,/ LQ *XLGD JHQHUDOH GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR LWDOLDQL/ 5RPD/ 8II1 FHQWUDOH SHU L %HQL $UFKLYLVWLFL/ 4<;9/ SS1 <860 <<;1 46 &IU1 )1 9$/(17,/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ $UFKLYLR 6WRULFR &RPXQDOH/ LQ $UFKLYL 6WRULFL LQ (PLOLD0 5RPDJQD/ D FXUD GL *1 5$%277,/ %RORJQD/ (G1 $QDOLVL/ 4<<4/ SS1 76:077;1 ,Q TXHVWL XOWLPL
<6;
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
YDQR/ LQ XQ FHUWR VHQVR/ HVVHUH FRQVLGHUDWL FRPSOHPHQWDUL DOO·$UFKLYLR (0 VWHQVH1 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH SRL O·$UFKLYLR FRPXQDOH GL 0RGHQD FRQVHUYDYD DWWL GL ´0DJLVWUDWLµ +HV1 0DJLVWUDWR GL $FTXH H 6WUDGH, FKH SHU XQ FHUWR SHULRGR IX0 URQR FRPSHWHQWL SHU WXWWR OR ´6WDWR GL 0RGHQDµ/ SXU HVVHQGR/ VRVWDQ]LDO0 PHQWH/ RUJDQLVPL FRPXQDOL H QRQ VWDWDOL1 0D JOL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL DL TXDOL DOOXGHYD LO /RVFKL QRQ HUDQR VROR TXHOOL GHL GXH JUDQGL &RPXQL SDGDQL GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR= YL HUDQR DQFKH UHDOWj FRPXQDOL PLQRUL/ PD HJXDOPHQWH LPSRUWDQWL SHU OD SDUWLFRODUH VWUXWWXUD GHOOR VWDWR HVWHQVH1 )LQDOH/ DG HVHPSLR/ HUD GLYHQWDWR/ GRSR OD GHYROX]LRQH/ XQD WHUUD GL FRQ0 ILQH SLHQD GL FRPPHUFL H GL WUDIILFL/ FRQ DEERQGDQWH SRSROD]LRQH FKH FRP0 SUHQGHYD DQFKH XQD YLYDFH FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD471 (EEHQH/ D )LQDOH/ O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·,OOXVWULVVLPR 3XEEOLFR GHO )LQDOH/ ULRUGLQDWR GD &HVDUH )UDVVRQL QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ HUD +HG q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j VWDWDOL GLYHUVH GD TXHOOD HVWHQVH1 (UD LO FDVR GL &RUUHJJLR/ FKH HUD VWDWR GHL ´GD &RUUHJJLRµ ILQR DO 4964/ LO FDVR GL 1RYHOODUD FKH HUD VWDWD GHL ´*RQ]DJD GL 1RYHOODUDµ ILQR DO 4:5; HG HUD LO FDVR 0 GHO WXWWR SDUWLFRODUH 0 GL 0LUDQGROD +GHL 3LFR ILQR DO 4:44,/ GRYH JOL DWWL GHOO·DUFKLYLR FRPXQDOH DYUHEEHUR GRYX0 WR PRVWUDUH XQD JLJDQWHVFD ODFXQD GL FLUFD GXH VHFROL/ FRUULVSRQGHQWH DO SH0 ULRGR GL VRVWDQ]LDOH D]]HUDPHQWR GHOO·DWWLYLWj FRPXQLWDWLYD/ LPSRVWR GDL 3LFR D IDU WHPSR GDL SULPL GHFHQQL GHO VHFROR ;9,1 *OL DWWL GHO PHGHVLPR DUFKL0 YLR DYUHEEHUR GRYXWR ULFRPLQFLDUH FRQ LO 4:6;/ DQQR GL ULSULVWLQR GHOOD ´&RPXQLWjµ GD SDUWH GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH4;1 ²²²²²²²² DQQL/ SRL/ OH YDULH VHULH GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR &RPXQDOH VRQR VWDWH LOOXVWUDWH GD YDUL DXWRUL VX GXH FROODQH HGLWH GDO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD H GLUHWWH GD $OGR %RUVDUL1 47 &IU1 $1 0$6,1$/ /D FRPXQLWj HEUDLFD D )LQDOH QHO 6HLFHQWR/ 9HURQD/ )LRULQL/ 4<;;1 48 &IU1 )1 9$/(17,/ &RPXQH GL )LQDOH (PLOLD1 $UFKLYLR 6WRULFR &RPXQDOH/ LQ $UFKLYL 6WRULFL FLW1/ SS1 73<07461 49 &IU1 $UFKLYL 6WRULFL 111FLW1 DOOH VLQJROH YRFL1 4: &IU1 $UFKLYL 6WRULFL 111FLW1 DOOH VLQJROH YRFL1 4; &IU1 $1 63$**,$5,/ /·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOD &DVD/ GHOOD &RUWH H GHOOR 6WDWR GHL 3LFR1 'LVFRUVR DUFKLYLVWLFR1 LQ *LRYDQQL 3LFR GHOOD 0LUDQGROD/ D FXUD GL *1&1 *$5)$*1,1,/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<6<
'·DOWUD SDUWH q GD GLUH FKH WXWWH OH FRPXQLWj GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL ² LQ TXHOOR VFRUFLR GL $QWLFR 5HJLPH 0 FRQVHUYDYDQR L ORUR SURSUL DUFKLYL/ RJQXQR GHL TXDOL/ DQFKH VH/ WDOYROWD/ TXDQWLWDWLYDPHQWH DVVDL SLFFROR HUD LQ JUDGR GL UL0 VSHFFKLDUH OD YLWD FRPXQLWDWLYD4<1 ( TXL SRWUHPPR DQFKH FRQVLGHUDUH FKLXVR TXHVWR DUJRPHQWR PD GRE0 ELDPR LQYHFH UDPPHQWDUH FKH GXUDQWH OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ D IDU WHPSR GDOOD ´'LVWUHWWXD]LRQHµ/ GHO 4 JHQQDLR 4;48/ LO QXPHUR GHL &RPXQL GHJOL 6WDWL (0 VWHQVL YHQQH VHQVLELOPHQWH GLPLQXLWR/ SHU FXL/ QHO 4;7</ OD VLWXD]LRQH ² ULIHUL0 WD GDO 5RQFDJOLD53 ² HUD OD VHJXHQWH= 0RGHQD H )ULJQDQR/ &RPXQL Q153 +FRQ0 WUR JOL ;< GHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR,> 5HJJLR/ &RPXQL Q153 +FRQWUR L :3 GHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR,> *DUIDJQDQD/ &RPXQL Q149 +FRQWUR L 54 GHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR,1 4XDQWR VRSUD SURYRFz O·DJJUHJD]LRQH DO SDWULPRQLR GHL &RPXQL VXSHUVWL0 WL GL WXWWL L EHQL DSSDUWHQHQWL DL &RPXQL VRSSUHVVL LYL FRPSUHVL JOL DUFKLYL1 4XHVWL SLFFROL DUFKLYL ² TXDORUD VLDQR VWDWL FRQVHUYDWL ² ILJXUDQR DQFRUD RJJL/ FRQ OD TXDOLILFD GL ´DUFKLYL DJJUHJDWLµ QHJOL DUFKLYL VWRULFL FRPXQDOL GHL &R0 PXQL ULPDVWL DWWLYL/ GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH541 *OL $UFKLYL 1RWDULOL $FFDQWR DJOL DUFKLYL FRPXQDOL/ LO QRVWUR /RVFKL YHGHYD IXQ]LRQDUH JOL DU0 FKLYL QRWDULOL 0 JOL ´DUFKLYL SXEEOLFLµ SHU HFFHOOHQ]D 0 L TXDOL/ SXU DYHQGR/ FR0 PH VL VD/ RULJLQH FRPXQDOH HUDQR VWDWL RJJHWWR GL SDUWLFRODUL DWWHQ]LRQL GD SDUWH GHO JRYHUQR GXFDOH FKH DYHYD DFFROWR L VXJJHULPHQWL LQ PDWHULD GL /R0 GRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL1 4XHVWL/ LQIDWWL/ QHO VXR WDUGR WUDWWDWR VXOOD ´SXE0 EOLFD IHOLFLWjµ55 DYHYD UDFFRPDQGDWR= ´)UD OH DWWHQ]LRQL/ FKH LO VDJJLR SULQFLSH GHH DYHUH SHO EHQH H PDJJLRU EHQH GH· VXGGLWL/ QRQ q GL SRFD LPSRUWDQ]D OD IRQGD]LRQH/ PDQWHQLPHQWR H EXRQ RUGLQH GH· SXEEOLFL DUFKLYL/ H FLRq GL TXHL OXRJKL/ GRYH GHH FRQVHUYDUVL FRSLD GL WXWWL JOL VWUXPHQWL/ WHVWDPHQWL HG DOWUL FRQWUDWWL GXUHYROL FKH VL IDQQR GDL QRWDL111µ1 ²²²²²²²² 4<<:/ SS1 <804371 4< &IU1 $1 63$**,$5,/ /D ´&RURJUDILDµ GL /XGRYLFR 5LFFL H OR ´6WDWR GL 0RGHQDµ DOOD ILQH GHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ LQ /1 5,&&,/ &RURJUDILD GHL WHUULWRUL GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR H GHJOL DOWUL VWDWL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD &DVD G·(VWH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;;1 +5LVWDPSD DQDVWDWLFD GHOO·HGL]LRQH RULJL0 QDULD GHO 4;39,1 53 &1 521&$*/,$/ 6WDWLVWLFD JHQHUDOH GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ 0RGHQD/ 7LS1 9LQFHQ]L/ 4;7<04;831 54 &IU1 $UFKLYL VWRULFL 111 FLW1 55 /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOD 3XEEOLFD )HOLFLWj RJJHWWR GH· EXRQL 3ULQFLSL/ $UH]]R/ %HOORWWL/ 4:9:/ D S1 4:81
<73
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
*OL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL/ QHJOL DQQL GHO /RVFKL HUDQR LQ QXPHUR GL WUHGLFL 0 QR0 QRVWDQWH FKH OD JUDQGH ULIRUPD GHO 4::5 DYHVVH LQXWLOPHQWH WHQWDWR GL ULGXUOL D WUH +0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR H &DVWHOQXRYR GL *DUIDJQDQD, 0 HG HUDQR FRVu RUJD0 QL]]DWL= ´4ƒ= HVLVWHYDQR WUH ´$UFKLYL *HQHUDOLµ VLWXDWL D 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ &D0 VWHOQXRYR GL *DUIDJQDQD1 5ƒ= DOO·$UFKLYLR JHQHUDOH GL 0RGHQD HUDQR FRO0 OHJDWL JOL $UFKLYL SXEEOLFL GL &DUSL/ )LQDOH/ 0LUDQGROD/ 6DVVXROR/ 6HVWROD> DOO·DUFKLYLR JHQHUDOH GL 5HJJLR HUDQR FROOHJDWL JOL ´DUFKLYL SXEEOLFLµ GL= %UH0 VFHOOR/ &RUUHJJLR/ 0RQWHFFKLR/ 6FDQGLDQR/ 9DUDQR> DOO·DUFKLYLR JHQHUDOH GL &DVWHOQXRYR QRQ HUD FROOHJDWR DOFXQ DUFKLYLRµ1 4XHVWD VLWXD]LRQH GHJOL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL HUD GHVWLQDWD D GXUDUH ´GL IDWWRµ SUDWLFDPHQWH LPPXWDWD ILQR DO 4;4:/ TXDVL VFDYDOFDQGR LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQL0 FR HG LO VXR 5HJRODPHQWR GHO 4: JLXJQR 4;391 3RL/ GRSR LO 4;4: OH PRGLIL0 FKH WHUULWRULDOL HG LVWLWX]LRQDOL FRQVHJXHQWL DO UHVWDXUDWR GRPLQLR HVWHQVH SURYRFDURQR YDULD]LRQL QHOO·DQ]LGHWWD VLWXD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD SXU PDQWHQHQ0 GR XQD SOXUDOLWj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z VWDYDQR SUHQGHQGR FRUSR DOWUL DUFKLYL/ GLFLDPR/ GL LQWHUHVVH SXEEOLFR H GL QDWXUD SROLWLFR0DPPLQLVWUDWLYD1 (UDQR JOL DUFKLYL GHL *RYHUQDWRUDWL H JOL DUFKLYL GHOOH 2SHUH 3LH1
²²²²²²²² 56 2VVHUYLDPR TXL/ SULPD GL FRQFOXGHUH VX TXHVWR WHPD/ FKH JOL XQLFL DUFKLYL GHJOL VWDWL HVWHQVL GRWDWL GL QRUPH ULJXDUGDQWL LO ORUR IXQ]LRQDPHQWR IXURQR SURSULR JOL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL/ FRPH VL SRWUj YHGHUH GDO PLR ODYRUR LQ PDWHULD $1 63$**,$5,/ &HQQL VWRULFL VXJOL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL GHJOL 6WDWL GHL 'XFKL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ LQ ©$0'63$30ª/ V1 ;,/ ,, +4<;3,/ SS1 53:0559/ R PH0 JOLR DQFRUD GD DOFXQL ODYRUL ULJXDUGDQWL VSHFLILFL DUFKLYL/ FRPH TXHOOL GL *1 =$&&+(·0(1 0$1(17,0$1 *$587,/ /·$UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL &DUSL/ 5RPD/ ,O &HQWUR GL 5LFHUFD/ 4<;7/ GL *1 =$&&+(·/ /·$UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0LUDQGROD/ LQ 0LUDQGROD H OH WHUUH GHO EDVVR FRUVR GHO 6HFFKLD/ D FXUD GL *1 %(578==,/ YRO1 ,,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;7/ SS1 6780686/ GL )1 %21$77,/ /·DUFKLYLR 1RWDULOH H 6WRULFR GHO &RPXQH GL $XOOD/ +FRQ FRQWULEXWL GL *1 5,&&, H *1 60(5$*/,$/ $XOOD/ 4<;4/ WDQWR SHU IDUH DOFXQL HVHPSL1
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<74
*OL DUFKLYL GHL *RYHUQDWRUDWL 3UHVVR L *RYHUQDWRUDWL SL• LPSRUWDQWL GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL H FLRq 5HJJLR/ &DVWHOQXRYR *DUIDJQDQD/ &DUSL/ 6HVWROD/ )LQDOH H 0LUDQGROD/ GHILQLWL UHFHQ0 WHPHQWH57 ´RUJDQL SHULIHULFL FRQ FRPSHWHQ]D JHQHUDOHµ/ VL DQGDYDQR IRUPDQ0 GR 0 QHO VHF1;9,,, 0 YHUL H SURSUL DUFKLYL/ SRWUHPPR GLUH ´GL GHSRVLWRµ/ GL0 VWLQWL VLD GDJOL DUFKLYL GHOOD JLXVGLFHQ]D/ VLD GDOO·DUFKLYLR GHOOH FRPXQLWj/ VLD GDJOL DUFKLYL QRWDULOL1 1HO JHUJR EXURFUDWLFR GL ILQH VHWWHFHQWR TXHVWL DUFKLYL YHQLYDQR GHILQLWL DQFKH ´$UFKLYL GHOOD 3URYLQFLDµ/ FRPH VHPEUD SURYDUFL LO EHOO·DUFKLYLR GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD RJJL FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0DVVD/ FKH HEEH TXHVWD GHQRPLQD]LRQH JLj DOOD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR581 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD JOL DUFKLYL GHJOL DOWUL *RYHUQDWRUDWL/ RVVHUYLDPR FKH TXHOOR GL 5HJJLR q/ RJJL/ IDFLOPHQWH LQGLYLGXDELOH DOO·LQWHUQR GHO ULVSHWWLYR $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR59/ PHQWUH TXHOOL GL &DUSL H GL 0LUDQGROD VRQR LQGLYLGXDELOL DOO·LQWHUQR GHL ULVSHWWLYL $UFKLYL VWRULFL &RPXQDOL5:1 ,QWHUHVVDQWH q LO FDVR GHOO·$UFKLYLR GHO *RYHUQDWRUDWR GHO )ULJQDQR OH FXL FDUWH HUDQR LQ SDUWH FRQIOXLWH IUD TXHOOH GHOOD *LXVGLFHQ]D GL 6HVWROD5;1 0D XQ·DOWUD SDUWH +SLXWWRVWR SLFFROD SHU OD YHULWj, GL TXHVWD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH q ULHPHUVD UHFHQWHPHQWH LQ XQ PRGR DEEDVWDQ]D LQVROLWR= L SLDWWL DQWHULRUL GHOOH ILO]H GHOO·DUFKLYLR QRWDULOH GL 3DYXOOR5< ULVXOWDYDQR FRVWLWXLWL GD VWUDWL GL GR0 FXPHQWL GHOO·DUFKLYLR GHOOD 3URYLQFLD GHO )ULJQDQR DGHJXDWDPHQWH ULILODWL HG LQFROODWL XQR VXOO·DOWUR SHU UDJJLXQJHUH OR VSHVVRUH GL XQ FDUWRQH1 /H PRGHU0 QH WHFQLFKH GL UHVWDXUR VWDQQR FRQVHQWHQGR FRPXQTXH LO UHFXSHUR GL TXHVWR PDWHULDOH FKH SRUWHUj XQD QXRYD OXFH VXOO·DUFKLYLR GL TXHVWR *RYHUQDWRUDWR1 &KL VFULYH QRQ KD/ DWWXDOPHQWH/ GDWL SUHFLVL LQ PHULWR DOO·$UFKLYLR GHO *R0 YHUQDWRUH GL )LQDOH/ DQFKH VH q SUHVXPLELOH FKH TXHVWR/ VL WURYL IUDPPLVWR ²²²²²²²² 57*1
%('21,/ /·XIILFLR GHO *RYHUQDWRUH QHL 'XFDWL (VWHQVL/ TXDOH RUJDQR SHULIHULFR FRQ FRPSHWHQ]D JHQHUDOH +485: 0 4:;<,/ LQ ©$0'63$30ª/ V1 ;,/ ;9/ +4<<6,/ SS1 48:04;;1 58 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 0$66$/ ,QYHQWDULR VRPPDULR GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR/ 5RPD/ 4<851 59 &IU1 $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ D FXUD GL *1 %$',1, 111FLW1 5: 3HU 0LUDQGROD/ FIU1 01 *+,==21, 0 &1 38/,1,/ /·DUFKLYLR VWRULFR &RPXQDOH GL 0LUDQGROD FRPH IRQWH SHU OR VWXGLR GHOOD VWRULD ORFDOH/ LQ ,O SDWULPRQLR PDQRVFULWWR H D VWDPSD GHL IRQGL SXEEOLFL PL0 UDQGROHVL/ QXPHUR PRQRJUDILFR GHL ©4XDGHUQL GHOOD %DVVDª Q1 67 +D1 ;,,/ Q1 5/ GLF1 4<<;,/ SS1 ;40<41 3HU &DUSL/ FIU1 $UFKLYL VWRULFL H 111FLW1 5; 'REELDPR TXHVWD LQIRUPD]LRQH DO 3URI1 $50(12 )217$1$/ SURIRQGR VWXGLRVR GL FRVH IULJQDQHVL1 5< 4XHVWR DUFKLYLR QRWDULOH FKH HUHGLWz QHOO·2WWRFHQWR OH IXQ]LRQL H OH FDUWH GHOO·$UFKLYLR ´SXEEOLFRµ GL 6HVWROD/ q RJJL FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD1
<75
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
DOOH FDUWH GHOO·$UFKLYLR VWRULFR &RPXQDOH631 3ULPD GL FRQFOXGHUH VX TXHVWR DUJRPHQWR/ ULFRUGLDPR FKH L *RYHUQDWRUD0 WL HVWHQVL YHQQHUR VRSSUHVVL GDL JRYHUQL QDSROHRQLFL VXO ILQLUH GHO 4:<91 5L0 FRUGLDPR DQFKH/ FKH GXUDQWH OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ H SUHFLVDPHQWH DQWHULRUPHQ0 WH DOOH ULIRUPH GHO 4;7;64/ LO *RYHUQR $XVWUR0HVWHQVH ULSULVWLQz L *RYHUQDWR0 UDWL/ OLPLWDQGROL SHUz D TXDWWUR +0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ &DVWHOQXRYR *DUIDJQDQD H 0DVVD +GDO 4;69,,1 , UHODWLYL DUFKLYL VL FRQVHUYDQR SUHVVR JOL $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ GL 5HJJLR H GL 0DVVD FKH KD DWWUDWWR OH FDUWH GL &DVWHOQXRYR1 *OL DUFKLYL GHOOH 2SHUH 3LH (· QRWR65 FRPH WXWWR LO VLVWHPD GHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ0 ]D GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL VLD VWDWR RJJHWWR GL SURIRQGH ULIRUPH/ SHU WXWWD OD VH0 FRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 5LIRUPH FKH FRPSRUWDURQR XQ VRVWDQ]LDOH DFFRUSDPHQWR GHOOH YDULH RSH0 UH SLH VRUWH QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL LQ RUJDQLVPL VHPSUH SL• JUDQGL FKH YHQQHUR GHQRPLQDWL/ WDQWR SHU IDUH HVHPSL/ D 0RGHQD ´2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYH0 UL H D 5HJJLR &RQJUHJD]LRQH *HQHUDOH GHOOH 2SHUH 3LH1µ 4XHVWH RSHUH SL• ´JHQHUDOLµ VL WURYDURQR SRL D GRYHU DPPLQLVWUDUH QRWH0 YROL SDWULPRQL SURYHQLHQWL VLD GDJOL DQ]LGHWWL DFFRUSDPHQWL/ VLD GDOOH VRSSUHV0 VLRQL GL (QWL UHOLJLRVL L FXL SDWULPRQL YHQLYDQR GHYROXWL DSSXQWR DOOH RSHUH SLH ´JHQHUDOLµ1 &RUROODULR GL TXHVWH RSHUD]LRQL GL VRSSUHVVLRQH H GL FRQFHQWUD]LRQH/ IX LO IDWWR FKH OH RSHUH SLH ´JHQHUDOLµ VL WURYDURQR D GRYHU JHVWLUH XQ FRVSLFXR SD0 WULPRQLR DUFKLYLVWLFR DYHQWH OH SL• VYDULDWH SURYHQLHQ]H661 )X FRVu FKH D 0RGHQD H D 5HJJLR 0 PD IRUVH DQFKH LQ DOWUH ORFDOLWj GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL 0 OH RSHUH SLH ´*HQHUDOLµ RUJDQL]]DURQR JURVVL ODYRUL GL ULRUGL0 QDPHQWR GHL ORUR DUFKLYL/ FKH QRL YRUUHPPR FRQVLGHUDUH ´SXEEOLFLµ SURSULR SHUFKp OH RSHUH SLH DOOH TXDOL DSSDUWHQHYDQR HUDQR UHWWH GD &RQVLJOL GL DP0 PLQLVWUD]LRQH SXEEOLFL1 3UHVVR O·2SHUD 3LD *HQHUDOH GHL 3RYHUL GL 0RGHQD/ VL GLVWLQVH/ SRL/ XQ QR0 WDLR0DUFKLYLVWD *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD :DWWHQKRIHU67 FKH ODVFLz SUHJHYROL ODYRUL GL ²²²²²²²² 63
&IU1 $UFKLYL VWRULFL H111/ FLW1/ DOOD YRFH1 &IU1 *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD 111FLW1 65 &IU1 '1 *5$1$/ 3HU XQD VWRULD GHOOD SXEEOLFD DVVLVWHP]D D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWR0 ULDQD/ 4<<41 66 &IU1 $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ LQ *XLGD *HQHUDOH 111FLW/ SDJ1 439:1 67 *1%1 :DWWHQKRIHU/ HUD XQ QRWDLR FRQ VSLFFDWD SURSHQVLRQH SHU L SUREOHPL DUFKLYLVWLFL1 $WWLYR JLj QHO 4:8< GHGLFz JUDQ SDUWH GHOOD VXD YLWD D ULRUGLQDUH O·$UFKLYLR GHOO·RSHUD 3LD1 *OL YHQQH/ DOWUHVu/ DIILGDWR LO FRPSLWR GL ULRUJDQL]]DUH LO FRPSOHVVR GHL IRQGL DUFKLYLVWLFL GHL VRS0 64
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<76
DUFKLYLVWLFD VHWWHFHQWHVFD/ LQ EXRQD SDUWH/ GLUHWWL DG RUJDQL]]DUH H D GRPLQDUH OD JUDQGH PDVVD GRFXPHQWDULD FRQFHQWUDWD SUHVVR OD VWHVVD RSHUD SLD 681 (· VROR LO FDVR GL ULFRUGDUH FKH LO VLVWHPD GHOO·DVVLVWHQ]D SXEEOLFD/ JHVWLWD WUDPLWH ´HQWLµ/ FRQWLQXz VLD QHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR/ VLD QHO SHULRGR GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ GXUDQWH L TXDOL/ JOL HQWL VXELURQR TXDVL XQLFDPHQWH LO FDPELD0 PHQWR GHOOD GHQRPLQD]LRQH +&RQJUHJD]LRQH GL &DULWj/ ,QWHQGHQ]D JHQHUDOH GHOOH 2SHUH 3LH/ &RQJUHJD]LRQH JHQHUDOH GHOOH 2SHUH 3LH,1 1HO SHULRGR SRVW0 XQLWDULR L YDUL ´HQWLµ DVVLVWHQ]LDOL/ FROORFDWL SUHVVR RJQL &RPXQH GHO 5HJQR/ HEEHUR UHJRODPHQWD]LRQH H GHQRPLQD]LRQH XQLIRUPL YHQHQGR WXWWL GHILQLWL ´&RQJUHJD]LRQH GL &DULWjµ691 &RQ OD /HJJH 6 *LXJQR 4<6:/ Q1 ;7:/ OH &RQJUHJD]LRQL GL &DULWj YHQQHUR WUDVIRUPDWH LQ (QWL &RPXQDOL GL $VVLVWHQ]D +(1&1$1,/ L TXDOL SRL FRQIOXLURQR FRQ L ORUR SDWULPRQL QHOOH 8QLWj 6DQLWDULH /RFDOL6:1 *OL DUFKLYL GHL )HXGDWDUL &RQWLQXDQGR LO QRVWUR GLVFRUVR/ ULFRUGLDPR FKH JOL ´6WDWL HVWHQVLµ IXURQR IRUWHPHQWH FDUDWWHUL]]DWL GDO IHQRPHQR IHXGDOH ILQR DO 4:<91 , WHUULWRUL LQ0 IHXGDWL FRVWLWXLYDQR 0 FRPH q VWDWR SL• YROWH ULSHWXWR LQ TXHVWR QRVWUR &RQ0 YHJQR 0 LO FRVLGGHWWR ´6WDWR PHGLDWRµ SHU FXL PROWL UDSSRUWL SROLWLFL/ DPPLQL0 VWUDWLYL H JLXGL]LDUL YHQLYDQR LQWUDWWHQXWL GLUHWWDPHQWH GDO IHXGDWDULR/ VHQ]D JLXQJHUH DOOD &DQFHOOHULD H DOOD &DPHUD GHO 'XFD1 /D FRQVLGHUD]LRQH SRL FKH L IHXGDWDUL GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL HUDQR ROWUH FHQWR/ GRYUHEEH XOWHULRUPHQWH OHJLWWLPDUH LO GLVFRUVR VXJOL DUFKLYL IHXGDOL1 (· FKLDUR FKH JOL DUFKLYL IHXGDOL VL IRUPDYDQR SUHVVR OH IDPLJOLH GHL IHXGD0 WDUL/ H SURSULR SHU TXHVWD UDJLRQH 0 GRSR OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHO IHXGR +4:<9, 0 ILQLURQR FRO FRQIRQGHUVL FRQ JOL DUFKLYL SULYDWL GHOOH IDPLJOLH VWHVVH1 3HUWDQWR/ QHOO·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL ULQWUDFFLDUH L VLQJROL DUFKLYL IHXGDOL/ IRUQL0 UHPR/ TXL GL VHJXLWR/ LQ DSSHQGLFH/ XQ SURVSHWWR GDO TXDOH ULVXOWLQR OH YDULH ²²²²²²²² SUHVVL *HVXLWL1 68 >*1 %$5,2/$0 *1 %(5721,0 *1 1$6&,0%(1,@/ ,O SDWULPRQLR VWRULFR0DUWLVWLFR GHOOD &RQJUHJD]LRQH GL &DULWj GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 2UODQGLQL/ 4<531+Y1 SS1 870:8,1 691RQ q SRVVLELOH VLQWHWL]]DUH QHOOR VSD]LR GL XQD QRWD OD FRPSOHVVLWj GHL SUREOHPL FRQ0 QHVVL DOOD JHVWLRQH GHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL SXEEOLFKH GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D GHO SHULRGR SRVW0 XQLWDULR1 /LPLWDQGRFL DL QRVWUL WHUULWRUL ULQYLDPR/ SHU 0RGHQD D >*1 %$5,2/$0*1 %(5721,0 *1 1$6&,0%(1,@ ,O SDWULPRQLR 111FLW> H SHU 5HJJLR/ D 31 %$5$==21,/ /·$VVLVWHQ]D VRFLDOH D 5HJ0 JLR (PLOLD/ YROO1 ,0,,/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ (G1 /LWRJUDI/ 4<<;1 6: *LXVWD OD ´ULIRUPD VDQLWDULDµ/ VDQFLWD FRQ OD /HJJH 56 GLFHPEUH 4<:;/ Q1 ;661
<77
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
JLXULVGL]LRQL IHXGDOL DO 4:<36;/ OH IDPLJOLH WLWRODUL GHL ULVSHWWLYL IHXGL/ QRQFKp OH QRWL]LH VXO OXRJR GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHL ULVSHWWLYL DUFKLYL SULYDWL/ QHL TXDOL VL GRYUHEEHUR FRQVHUYDUH OH FDUWH IHXGDOL6<1 *OL DUFKLYL (FFOHVLDVWLFL $QFKH VH q SDFLILFR FKH JOL DUFKLYL HFFOHVLDVWLFL VLDQR LO ULVXOWDWR 0 QHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD FRPH QHJOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL SUHXQLWDUL 0 GHOO·DWWLYLWj GHJOL RUJDQLVPL SHULIHULFL GHOOD &KLHVD FDWWROLFD/ q DOWUHWWDQWR SDFLILFR FKH JOL RUJD0 QLVPL HFFOHVLDVWLFL DEELDQR ULFRSHUWR UXROL GL SULPR SLDQR QHOOD YLWD HFRQR0 PLFD/ SROLWLFD H FXOWXUDOH QHJOL 6WDWL GL DQWLFR UHJLPH H QHJOL 6WDWL GHOOD 5H0 VWDXUD]LRQH1 3HU TXHVWR/ JOL DUFKLYL GHJOL RUJDQLVPL HFFOHVLDVWLFL GHL QRVWUL WHUULWRUL DQ0 FKH VH QRQ SRVVRQR HVVHUH FRQVLGHUDWL/ D ULJRUH/ ´DUFKLYL GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVLµ/ DSSDLRQR IRUWHPHQWH OHJDWL DOOH YLFHQGH SROLWLFKH HG LVWLWX]LRQDOL GHJOL VWHVVL H SHUWDQWR GHEERQR TXL HVVHUH DOPHQR PHQ]LRQDWL1 5LFRUGLDPR/ JOL DUFKLYL 9HVFRYLOL H &DSLWRODUL GHOOH GXH DQWLFKH GLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR/ GHOOD GLRFHVL GL &DUSL GL LVWLWX]LRQH VHWWHFHQWHVFD H GHOOD GLRFHVL GL *XDVWDOOD73 GL LVWLWX]LRQH RWWRFHQWHVFD> O·DUFKLYLR GHOO·DEED]LD GL 1RQDQWROD74/ JOL DUFKLYL GHL 7ULEXQDOL GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH GL 5HJJLR H GL 0RGH0 QD75
²²²²²²²² 6; ,O SURVSHWWR LQ SDUROD q WUDWWR GDOO·HOHQFR GHL IHXGL +4:<3 0 4:<9, FRQVHUYDWR LQ $602/ &DPHUD 'XFDOH/ )HXGL/ 8VL/ /LYHOOL/ Q1 4771 91 DQFKH 21 520%$/',/ , 'XFDWL HVWHQVL GDO 4:;; DO 4:<9/ LQ ©&RQWULEXWLª/ 9, +4<;5,/ 44045/ SS1 46<0596/ Y1 LQ SDUWLFRODUH SS1 58405871 6< $UFKLYL GL IDPLJOLH H GL SHUVRQH1 0DWHULDOH SHU XQD JXLGD/ D FXUD GL *1 3(6,5,0 01 352&$&&,$0 ,131 7$6&,1,0/1 9$//21(/ FRRUG1 *1 '( /21*,6 &5,67$/',/ 5RPD/ 8&%$/ 4<<41 73 &IU1 *1 3/(66, 0 *1 %$',1,/ 5HSHUWRULR DUFKLYLVWLFR SHU L WHUULWRUL H[ HVWHQVL/ %RORJQD/ /D )R0 WRFURPR (PLOLDQD/ 4<::> *XLGD GHJOL $UFKLYL GLRFHVDQL G·,WDOLD/ D FXUD GL 91 021$&+,12/ (1 %2$*$0 /1 26%$70 61 3$/(6(/ 5RPD/ 8&%$/ 4<<3+Q1 94 GHOOD FROODQD ©4XDGHUQL GHOOD 5DV0 VHJQD GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWRª ,> *1 %$',1,/ *OL $UFKLYL HFFOHVLDVWLFL QHO WULHQQLR JLDFRELQR/ LQ ,O 7UL0 FRORUH GDOOD &LVSDGDQD DOOD &LVDOSLQD1,O WULHQQLR JLDFRELQR/ $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR GL VWXGL VWRULFL/ 0RGHQD/ 90: IHEEUDLR 4<<;/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<;1 74 /·$UFKLYLR GHOO·$EED]LD GL 1RQDQWROD YHQLYD LOOXVWUDWR SURSULR VXO ILQLUH GHO 6HWWHFHQ0 WR/ GD *1 7,5$%26&+,/ 6WRULD GHOO·DXJXVWD %DGLD GL 61 6LOYHVWUR GL 1RQDQWROD/ W1,,/ 0RGHQD/ 6RF1 7LSRJUDILFD/ 4:;81 75 ,O 7ULEXQDOH GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH GL 0RGHQD/ YHQQH VRSSUHVVR FRQ FKLURJUDIR 9 VHWWHPEUH 4:;8/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWR FRPSHWHQWH DQFKH SHU LO WHUULWRULR GL 5HJJLR GDO 4:;3 DO 4:;8/ SUR0 SULR SHUFKq LO WULEXQDOH GL 5HJJLR HUD VWDWR VRSSUHVVR QHO 4:;3 H OH VXH IXQ]LRQL HUDQR VWDWH DVVHJQDWH D TXHOOH GL 0RGHQD1 /·$UFKLYLR GHO 7ULEXQDOH GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH GL 0RGHQD/ FKH VL FRQVHUYD SUHVVR O·$602/ VWD ULFHYHQGR XQ·LQYHQWDULD]LRQH DQDOLWLFD D FXUD GL *1 7UHQWL H GL $1 6SDJJLDUL1 &IU1 61 6(,'(/ 0(1&+,/ , 7ULEXQDOL GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH LQ ,WDOLD= OH WDSSH
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
<78
H JOL DUFKLYL GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GHO *HV•761 0D/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ ULFRUGLDPR OD PLULDGH GL SLFFROL H JUDQGL DUFKLYL SDUURF0 FKLDOL L TXDOL/ GDO &RQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR LQ SRL/ H SUDWLFDPHQWH ILQR DOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHOO·RWWRFHQWR/ VYROVHUR XQ UXROR IRQGDPHQWDOH LQ TXHOOL FKH SRWUHPPR GHQRPLQDUH ´VHUYL]L GHPRJUDILFL/ GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVLµ771 $UFKLYL JLXGL]LDUL1 $UFKLYL FDWDVWDOL $ TXHVWR SXQWR LO QRVWUR GLVFRUVR GRYUHEEH ULYROJHUVL TXDQWR PHQR DJOL ´$UFKLYL GHJOL DWWL JLXGL]LDULµ H DOO· ´$UFKLYLR GHO &DWDVWRµ GL 0RGHQD FKH ² DO PRPHQWR GHOOD ULFRJQL]LRQH GHO %RQDLQL78 0 PRVWUDYDQR FKLDUDPHQWH OD IL0 VLRQRPLD GL DUFKLYL ´SXEEOLFLµ GL FRQFHQWUD]LRQH1 0D UDJLRQL GL WHPSR H GL VSD]LR FL LPSRQJRQR GL IHUPDUFL TXL/ ULPDQGDQ0 GR DG DOWUD RFFDVLRQH O·HVDPH GL TXHVWL DUFKLYL1 - - &L VHPEUD FRPXQTXH/ GL DYHU GLPRVWUDWR FRPH JOL DUFKLYL 0 GD TXHOOL ´FHQWUDOLµ SRVWL QHOOD &DSLWDOH D TXHOOL SHULIHULFL SRVWL PDJDUL LQ WHUUH UHPRWH H TXDVL LQDFFHVVLELOL 0 TXDOLILFKLQR OD JHQHUDOH ILJXUD GL XQR VWDWR= SHU GLUOD LQ EUHYH/ VH XQR ´6WDWRµ SXz VXVVLVWHUH VHQ]D OH UDFFROWH GL RSHUH G·DUWH/ VHQ]D OH UDFFROWH PXVHDOL/ DO OLPLWH DQFKH VHQ]D OH UDFFROWH GL OLEUL/ QRQ SXz FHUWD0 PHQWH VXVVLVWHUH VHQ]D JOL DUFKLYL GRYH VL FRQFOXGRQR H VL VHGLPHQWDQR L ´ULWL H OD VDSLHQ]D GHO GLULWWRµ SHU XVDUH XQD QRWD HVSUHVVLRQH GL )UDQFR &RUGHUR791 9L VRQR GXQTXH WDQWH EXRQH UDJLRQL SHU SDUODUH GL DUFKLYL TXDQGR VL GHOL0 ²²²²²²²² GHOO·HVSORUD]LRQH GRFXPHQWDULD/ LQ /·,QTXLVL]LRQH URPDQD LQ ,WDOLD QHOO·HWj PRGHUQD/ 5RPD/ 8&%$/ 4<<81 76 *OL DUFKLYL GHL YDUL ´FROOHJLµ GHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV•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·(PLOLD«FLW1 79 )1 &25'(52/ *OL DUFKLYL QHOOH SURYLQFH GHOO·(PLOLD«FLW1
<79
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
QHDQR JOL LVWLWXWL GL XQR 6WDWR SUHXQLWDULR1 1HO QRVWUR FDVR/ FLRq QHO FDVR GHO0 OR ´6WDWR GL 0RGHQDµ/ YL q XQD UDJLRQH LQ SL•1 )X SURSULR LQ XQD VDOD GL XQ DUFKLYLR GHL QRVWUL WHUULWRUL HG HVDWWDPHQWH QHOOD VDOD FHQWUDOH GHO QXRYR $UFKLYLR QRWDULOH GL 5HJJLR/ DGLELWD SHU O·RFFDVLRQH DG DXOD GL ULXQLRQL/ FKH LO &RQJUHVVR &LVSDGDQR/ QHOOD VHGXWD GHO : JHQQDLR 4:<:/ GHFUHWz FKH VL DGRWWDVVH/ LQ WXWWD OD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD/ ´OR VWHQGDUGR/ R %DQGLHUD &LVSDGDQD GL WUH FRORUL 9HUGH/ %LDQFR H 5RVVRµ7: YDOH D GLUH TXHO ´WULFRORUHµ LWDOLDQR/ FKH VDUHEEH GLYHQWDWR/ D IDU WHPSR GDJOL DQQL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR/ LO SL• HVDOWDQWH VLPEROR GHOO·8QLWj QD]LRQDOH1
²²²²²²²² 7:
81 %(//2&&+,/ ,O 7ULFRORUH= GXHFHQWR DQQL 4:<:04<<:/ 0RGHQD/ %DQFD SRSRODUH (PLOLD 5RPDJQD/ 4<<91
<7:
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL
$33(1',&( 'HQRPLQD]LRQH GHO )RQGR
&DVDWR GHO )HXGDWDULR
/XRJR GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHOO·DUFKLYLR SULYDWR
$OELQHD H DQQHVVL %DUWRORPHR +6DQ, LQ 6DVVR )RUWH %HEELR %HGRJQR H DQQHVVL %LDQHOOR H DQQHVVL %LVPDQWRYD H DQQHVVL %UDQGROD %XVDQD H DQQHVVL %XVDQHOOD &DELDQFD &DPRUDQD &DPSRVDQWR &DQRVVD &DUQLDQD H DQQHVVL &DUSLQHWL &DU• H DQQHVVL &DVWHOGDUGR &DVWHOODUDQR H DQQHVVL &DVWHOODUR QHO )ULJQDQR &DVWHOODUR VRWWR 0LQR]]R &DVWHOQXRYR GL VRWWR H DQQHVVL &DVWHOYHFFKLR &DYULDJR H DQQHVVL &HUq 0DUDELQR &HUUHGROR &HUYDUROR +SHU ó, &HUYDUROR +SHU ó, &HVDULR +6DQ, &KLRVFD GL 0RQWHILRULQR H DQQHVVL &ROODJQD H DQQHVVL &RULDQR H DQQHVVL &RVWD H DQQHVVL &UHYDUD 'HEELD 'HXVL 'RQQLQR +6DQ, GL /LJXULD 'RQQLQR +6DQ, GL 0DUROD )DUQHWD H DQQHVVL
)URVLQL %RULQL 0DUFKLVLR $QFLQL *DEEL /XFFKHVLQL =DYDJOLD =DPEHFFDUL %HQHGHWWL 9LOOD 2UVL 3RQWLFHOOL 9DOHQWLQL $UQDOGL 9DOGULJKL 6LJQRUHWWL 6HVVL 9DORWWD 3RJJL %RQDYHQWXUL *KHUDUGLQL 7DVVRQL &DORUL 0DODJX]]L 9DOHUL 6WRIIL *XLFFLDUGL 3LD]]L %RVFKHWWL 0DQ]RQL 9LJDUDQL 7RVFD &RQWL &DVWHOOL &DPSR 'DOOD 3DOXGH 0DULJOLDQL /D]]RQL 6SLQROD )RQWDQHOOL
$60R $65H
)HOLQD H DQQHVVL )RUPLJLQH H DQQHVVL *DWWD
&DVVROL /RUHQ]RWWL &KLRGLQL &DOFDJQLQL %LDQFKL 0XQDULQL
$60R 0 $65H
$6%R $6%R SUHVVR OD IDPLJOLD $60R
$65H $6)H $65H $60R $60R $6%R $65R
$60R $60R $60R $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD
<7;
$QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL
'HQRPLQD]LRQH GHO )RQGR
&DVDWR GHO )HXGDWDULR
*D]]XROR *LDQGHWWR H DQQHVVL *RPEROD H DQQHVVL *RWWDQR H DQQHVVL *RYD *XLJOLD H DQQHVVL /HJXLJQR /HYL]]DQR H DQQHVVL /LJRQFKLR H DQQHVVL 0DUWLQR +6DQ, LQ 5LR H DQQHVVL 0DUWLQR +6DQ, LQ 6SLQR H DQQHVVL 0DVVD GL 0RQWHILRULQR 0LFHQR 0RQWDOWR +SHU ó, 0RQWDOWR +SHU ó, 0RQWHEDEELR +SHU ó, 0RQWHEDEELR +SHU ó, 0RQWHEDUDQ]RQH H DQQHVVL 0RQWHFDVWDJQHWR 0RQWHFHQHUH H DQQHVVL 0RQWHJLEELR 0RQWHTXHVWLROR 0RQWHULFFR +SHU 42;, 0RQWHULFFR +SHU ó, 0RQWHVH H DQQHVVL 0RQWREL]]R 1LJRQH H DQQHVVL 1LUDQR
0RO]D %XVHWWL &HVL 6ROLDQL 5DVFKLQL 'DOOL 0RQWHFXFFROL /DGHUFKL 6FDSLQHOOL /HYL]]DQL &DQWXWL &DVWHOYHWUL 5DQJR G·$UDJRQD 0HQDIRJOLR 0DUFKLVLR 6FRWWL &KLDSSRQL &ULVSL )DEEUL]L 3ULQL &DEULHWWL *DOOLDQL &DOFDJQL 0RQWHFXFFROL /DGHUFKL &DQRQLFL 0XOD]]DQL 9H]]DQL 7RVFKL 0DODVSLQD 3UDWL %LDQFKL 9DOOLVQHUL 6FXWHOODUL $JOLDQL
1RYL
%HOOLQFLQL %DJQHVL
3DQWDQR 3DXOOR 5HJJLDQR 3LROR 3RMDJR 3RQWRQH 3RVVLGRQLR +6DQ, 3UDPRUD
6DQ $JDWD 6RUUD %HUQDUGL &DODQL 6LPRQD]]L 0DVWULJLDQL 7DFROL &DPSDQD
4XDUD 4XHUFLROD H DQQHVVL 5DQFLGRUR H DQQHVVL 5HEHFFR +SHU 429, 5HEHFFR +SHU 44257,
6DVVL 1LJUHOOL 6HOYDWLFL (VWHQVH 6DEDWWLQL 'DOOD 3DOXGH *ULOOHQ]RQL
/XRJR GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHOO·DUFKLYLR SULYDWR $60R
$60R
$60R
SUHVVR OD IDPLJOLD $60R $6)H
$65H $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD VFRQRVFLXWR VFRQRVFLXWR $60R VFRQRVFLXWR VFRQRVFLXWR $65H VFRQRVFLXWR
<7<
*OL DUFKLYL QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL 'HQRPLQD]LRQH GHO )RQGR
&DVDWR GHO )HXGDWDULR
5LSD 5RWRQGD
*UHFR
5RFFKHWWD 6DQGUL 5RPDQR +6DQ, H DQQHVVL
2UODQGLQL &RUWHVH
5RYHUHWR 6DOWLQR 6DOYDUDQR 6DUUD]RQD 6DU]DQR 6FDQGLDQR 6HFFKLR H &RVWDEXRQD 6HPHVH H DQQHVVL
)RVFKLHUL *XDOHQJKL 7DVVRQL (VWHQVH *KLVLOLHUL 3DJJLDUL &DUDQGLQL )HUUDUL 0DUFKHVH 5LQDOGR G·(VWH 0DUFKLVLR %HOOLQFLQL %DJQHVL
6ROLHUD 6RUGLJOLR H DQQHVVL 6SH]]DQR H )LRUDQR 6SLODPEHUWR H DQQHVVL +SHU ó,
&DPSRUL 3DULVHWWL &RFFDSDQL 5DQJRQL +0DUFK1 *KHUDU0 GR, 5DQJRQL +0DUFK1 /RWDULR, *XHUUD %DUWRORPDVL *UHJRUL 0DJQDQL 0RQWHFXFFROL 3DVVHULQL 6DFUDWL *LUROGL 0RO]D 9DOOLVQHUL 2QGHGHL &DVVROL $OGURYDQGL 0DUHVFRWWL %XRQFRPSDJQL /XGRYLVL 3DROXFFL %HOOLQFLQL
6SLODPEHUWR H DQQHVVL +SHU ó, 7RDQR H DQQHVVL 7RUULFHOOD 7UHQWLQR H DQQHVVL 7ULJQDQR 9DJOLR H DQQHVVL 9DOGDOEHUR 9DOHQWLQR +6DQ, H DQQHVVL 9DOHVWUD 9DOOLVQHUD 9HVDOH 9H]]DQR H DQQHVVL 9LDQR H DQQHVVL 9LJQROD H DQQHVVL 9LJRQD H DQQHVVL 9LOODEHU]D
/XRJR GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHOO·DUFKLYLR SULYDWR $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD $60R $6)H $6%R H %LEO1 $UFKLJLQQDVLR
$60R $60R $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD $60R H %(0R $60R SUHVVR OD IDPLJOLD SUHVVR OD IDPLJOLD
$60R $60R $65H $65H $6%R $UFK1 6HJU1 9DWLFDQR VFRQRVFLXWR $UFK1 6WRULFR &RP1OH GL 0LUDQGROD
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<84
/8,*, 38&&,
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR1
3URSULR D 0RGHQD/ GDO 4<:4 DO 4::6/ XVFLYD LO 1XRYR &RGLFH HVWHQVH FKH SRVVLDPR FRQVLGHUDUH DQFKH XQD GHOOH SULPH OHJLVOD]LRQL FRPPHUFLDOL LWDOLD0 QH41 8Q FRGLFH WXWWDYLD GRYH ILQR DOO·XOWLPR DYHYDQR SHVDWR L FRQGL]LRQD0 PHQWL GHOOD FXULD URPDQD FRQWUDULD DG LQWURGXUUH UHJROH WURSSR HVSOLFLWH LQ PDWHULD GL FUHGLWR H G·LQWHUHVVH51 'RYH VL HYLWDYD SXGLFDPHQWH GL QRPLQDUH OD SDUROD LQWHUHVVH VRVWLWXLWD GD IUXWWR H GRYH QRQ YHQLYD PDL QRPLQDWD OD FDP0 ELDOH/ FRQIXVD LQVLHPH DOOD OHWWHUD GL FDPELR/ HG DOWUL HIIHWWL H ´SROL]]Hµ1 7XWWR VRPPDWR/ XQ FRGLFH GL FXOWXUD FDPHUDOLVWLFD= QRQ D FDVR 9DOGULJKL/ FKH QH HUD VWDWR O·HVWHQVRUH GDO ¶97 DO ¶9;/ HUD DQGDWR D SHUIH]LRQDUVL D 'UH0 VGD/ /LSVLD/ H 9LHQQD1 8Q FRGLFH IUXWWR GL XQD YRORQWj YHUWLFLVWLFD/ PD VDUHE0 EH LQWHUHVVDQWH FKLHGHUFL/ ILQR D FKH SXQWR LQWRQDWR DQFKH DG XQ·DXWHQWLFD ULFKLHVWD GDO EDVVR1 ,O WHU]R VWDWR HVSULPHYD Vu GHOOH LVWDQ]H/ PD LQ JHQHUH HUDQR FRQIXVH HG DPELJXH1 &KL GDYD DG HVVH XQD IRUPD FRPSLXWD HUD OD FODVVH GHJOL DPPLQL0 VWUDWRUL LOOXPLQDWL/ GHL SURIHVVRUL/ GHJOL DEDWL/ GHL QRELOL GHFDGXWL H LQ FHUFD GL ²²²²²²²² 4
/1 38&&,/ /LQHDPHQWL GL XQD ERUJKHVLD LQ QHUR= PHUFDQWL/ XVXUDL H FRQWUDEEDQGLHUL D 0RGHQD QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ 0RGHQD 4<<51 5 %1 '21$7,/ /1$1 0XUDWRUL H OD JLXULVSUXGHQ]D GHO VXR WHPSR/ 0RGHQD 4<641 ,O SDUDJUDIR 'H0 JOL LQWHUHVVL YHQLYD DJJLXQWR DOO·XOWLPR PRPHQWR H FLz q SRVVLELOH FRQVWDWDUOR FRQIURQWDQGR LO FRGLFH D VWDPSD FRQ TXHOOR PDQRVFULWWR1 6L ULFRUUHYD SRL DG XQD IRUPXOD DPELJXD= VL DPPHW0 WHYDQR VL JO·LQWHUHVVL ´VHPSUHFKp LO WLWROR SURGXWWLYR GHL IUXWWL H GHJOL LQWHUHVVL QRQ VDUj GDOOH SUHVHQWL OHJJL ULSURYDWRµ1 , IUXWWL FHUWL QHOOD TXDQWLWj SRWUDQQR DFFXPXODUVL VXO FDSLWDOH H GDUH OXRJR DG DOWUL LQWHUHVVL +FDSLWDOL]]1 FRPS1,/ PD RFFRUUHUj XQ QXRYR FRQWUDWWR1 &IU1 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ /HJJL H GHFUHWL/ &RGLFH 0V1/ QXP1 GL VIROODP1 43;9166141 /LE1 ,, 7LW1 ;; SD0 UDJU1 ;9,> $602/ &DPHUD GXFDOH/ 3DUWLFRODUL GHOOR 6WDWR/ 5HOD]LRQH GHO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ ILO]D 7331
<85
/XLJL 3XFFL
IRUWXQD/ XQ·HVLJXD PLQRUDQ]D GL SHUVRQH FKH QXOOD R TXDVL DYHYD D FKH IDUH FRQ L SUREOHPL UHDOL1 9ROWDLUH VL HUD GLYHUWLWR D SUHQGHUH LQ JLUR L ILVLRFUDWL FKH/ GLFHYD/ GLVFXWHYDQR GL JUDQL H GL DUDWUL VHQ]D DYHUQH PDL YLVWR XQR1 4XHOOR FKH YROHYDQR L PHUFDQWL/ VFULYHYD 5RXVVHDX/ QRQ HUD O·XJXDJOLDQ]D/ PD OD SDFH6 H FLRq OD OLEHUWj GL FRPPHUFLDUH DO GL Oj GHL PRQRSROL/ GL DSULUH GHOOH DWWLYLWj DO GL Oj GHL FRQWUROOL GHOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH/ GL VSHFXODUH OLEHUD0 PHQWH VXOOH SURSULHWj GHOOH RSHUH SLH/ GL VWDELOLUH L SUH]]L DO GL Oj GHL FDOPLHUL/ GL DEROLUH L SHGDJJL/ GD]LL H JDEHOOH FKH LQWUDOFLDYDQR L WUDIILFL HFF1 6H VFRU0 ULDPR OH VXSSOLFKH GHL PHUFDQWL QRQ SRVVLDPR GDUH ORUR WRUWR/ HVVL VL PXR0 YHYDQR LQ XQ VLVWHPD FRQWUDGGLVWLQWR GD XQD EXURFUD]LD GHIDWLFDQWH/ VLPEROR GHOOD TXDOH HUD O·LPSDOFDWXUD GHO ´ERFFDWLFRµ GHO VDOH H TXHOOD UHODWLYD DOOH YD0 ULH ´DSHUWXUHµ/ FLRq FRQFHVVLRQL GLHWUR SDJDPHQWR/ FKH ELVRJQDYD RWWHQHUH SHU SRWHUH DYYLDUH GHL FRPPHUFL1 /D SL• SDUWH GHL PHUFDQWL VL FRQIRQGHYD FRQ L EDVVL VWUDWL GHO SRSROR/ QH SRVVHGHYD OD FXOWXUD H L SUHJLXGL]L1 $QFKH L PHUFDQWL SL• DSHUWL SHU HVHPSLR/ FRPH ,VUDHO )RUWL/ )UDQFHVFR %RVHOOLQL/ SDGUH GL &DUOR/ 0RLVp )Rj FKH XVFL0 YDQR GDL ULVWUHWWL DPELWL ORFDOL/ QRQ HUDQR DIIDWWR ´PRGHUQLµ FRPH FL VL SR0 WUHEEH DVSHWWDUH1 )RUWL HUD VRVSHWWRVR GHOOH LGHH OLEHULVWH H VPLWKLDQH ´FKH SRWHYDQR VHGXUUH VROR SRFKL H IDWXL FLWWDGLQLµ71 $QFKH 0RLVp )Rj/ SURFXUDWRUH OLEUDULR GHOOD GXFDOH ELEOLRWHFD/ D FRQWDWWR FRQ LOOXVWUL FOLHQWL +WUD L TXDOL SHUILQR %HFFDULD,/ IXWXUR GHSXWDWR GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVDOSLQD/ VWXSLVFH LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR SHU OD VXD DULD VHUYLOH/ SHU OH VXH FRQWLQXH SURWHVWH GL OHDOLVPR +DQFKH VH QRQ QD0 VFRQGHYD OD VXD LQVRIIHUHQ]D SHU OD FHQVXUD,1 3DU GL VHQWLUH OH SDUROH GL 0X0 QDULQL/ PLQLVWUR LOOXPLQDWR/ FKH FRQVLJOLDYD D 9DOGULJKL ´SUXGHQ]D VFUXSRORVD QHOOH SURSULH LGHHµ81 , PHUFDQWL SUHIHULYDQR ´LO PXJXJQRµ H ULPDQHUH OHJDWL DOOD YHFFKLD FXOWXUD PHUFDQWLOLVWLFD/ SLXWWRVWR FKH EXWWDUVL DYDQWL/ OD FRQFRUUHQ]D IDFHYD SDXUD/ XQ ²²²²²²²² 6
.1 32/$1<,/ /D JUDQGH WUDVIRUPD]LRQH/ 7RULQR 4<:7/ S1 431 $602/ $UFKLYLR SULYDWR 5LFFL/ E1 7:/ ´%XRQ *RYHUQRµ/ IDVF1 ,ƒ> /1 38&&,/ 0HUFDQWL HG HFR0 QRPLVWL WUD 6HWWH H 2WWRFHQWR1 $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL/ LQ ©,O SHQVLHUR HFRQRPLFR PRGHUQRª/ ;/ 4<<3/ 71 8 $602/ $UFKLYLR 9DOGULJKL/ 0D]]L 55057/ %/HWWHUD GL *10XQDULQL DO &RQWH %DUWRORPHR 9DOGULJKL /45 PDU]R 4:;6%> 8Q·DOWUD VSLD GHO GLVDJLR YHUVR OH LGHH HFRQRPLFKH PRGHUQH HUD FKH HVLVWHYD LO SRVWR YDFDQWH GL (FRQRPLD FLYLOH GLYHQXWR OLEHUR FRQ OD PRUWH GL $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL +4:;6,/ PD QRQ VL DYHYD DOFXQD IUHWWD D ULFRSULUOR LQ $602/ %/HWWHUD GHO 56 PDU]R GL 5LQDOGR %RFFRODUL D %DUWRORPHR 9DOGULJKL GD 0RGHQD%/ IDVF1 431 7
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<86
FUHGLWR DOODUJDWR VHPEUDYD WURSSR ULVFKLRVR1 6ROR LQ DOFXQL PRPHQWL FULWLFL SRVVLDPR SUHQGHUH FRQWDWWR FRQ OD YRFH DXWHQWLFD GHL PHUFDQWL/ FRPH HUD SHU HVHPSLR TXHOOD FKH ILOWUDYD GDL FDKLHUV GH GROHDQFHV FKH JLXQVHUR DOOH QXRYH DXWRULWj UHSXEEOLFDQH LQVLHPH DOOH GHQXQFLH GHL VRSUXVL GHO SDVVDWR UHJLPH/ QHO EUHYLVVLPR LQWHUYDOOR WUD OD IXJD GHO GXFD H OD SURFODPD]LRQH GHOOD 5H0 SXEEOLFD &LVDOSLQD1 ,Q TXHVWL DSSHOOL HPHUJHYD WXWWR O·RGLR YHUVR LO UHJLPH GHJOL LXV SULYDWLYL LPSRVWL GDOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH/ FKH HVFOXGHYD WXWWL TXHOOL FKH YROHYDQR IDUH/ SHU SUHPLDUH JO·LQILQJDUGL H JO·LQFDSDFL91 1HOO·,WDOLD VHWWHQWULRQDOH LO FHWR GHL PHUFDQWL HUD GHEROH H VFRPSDUu TXDVL VXELWR GRSR O·µLQWHUUDPHQWRµ SUHGLVSRVWR GDOOH DXWRULWj QDSROHRQLFKH= FKL DYHYD GHQDUR OR WUDVIHULYD QHOOD WHUUD/ FRPSHUDYD WLWROL QRELOLDUL H 6WHQGKDO UDSSUHVHQWDYD EHQH QHL VXRL URPDQ]L FRPH OD &HUWRVD GL 3DUPD H 5RVVR H QHUR TXHVWR FOLPD GD UHVWDXUD]LRQH1 &L IX WXWWDYLD XQ PRPHQWR PDJLFR QHOO·,WDOLD SDGDQD SHU L FHWL DWWLYL OHJDWL DL WUDIILFL HG q VWDWR TXHOOR FKH DQGDYD GDO 4::3 FLUFD DOOH SULPH &LVDOSLQH= XQ PRPHQWR GL TXDVL HFFLWD]LRQH GL FLUFD XQ WUHQWHQQLR FKH/ VH LQ (XURSD OH FR0 VH IRVVHUR HYROXWH LQ PRGR GLYHUVR/ DYUHEEH SRWXWR FRQIOXLUH LQ XQD VROX0 ]LRQH SROLWLFD PRGHUQD/ XQD XQLILFD]LRQH FRQWLQHQWDOH/ FRPH TXDVL FRQWHP0 SRUDQHDPHQWH DYYHQLYD VXOO·DOWUD VSRQGD GHOO·$WODQWLFR1 /D ULSUHVD GDO 4::3 LQ SRL 6H JOL DQQL ¶97 H ¶98 UDSSUHVHQWDQR LO SXQWR SL• EDVVR GHO FLFOR/ VL KD O·LPSUHVVLRQH SDOSDELOH/ VFRUUHQGR L YROXPL GHOO·DUFKLYLR JLXGL]LDULR: FKH GDO ¶:3 LQ SRL/ QHO 0RGHQHVH +FRPH GHO UHVWR QHJOL 6WDWL OLPLWURIL,/ OD ULSUHVD VL IDFFLD VHQVLELOH/ SHU IDUVL VHPSUH SL• FRQVLVWHQWH GRSR O·;31 &·q WXWWD XQD VHULH GL VLPEROL GHVFULWWLYL FKH ULYHUEHUDQR GD TXHOOH SDJLQH= OH VWUDGH QRQ HUDQR SL• ´IDQJRVHµ/ PD VFRUUHYDQR GULWWH H JKLDLDWH/ HUDQR GR0 WDWH GL QXRYL SRQWL VRVSHVL/ VFDYDOFDYDQR JOL $SSHQQLQL H FROOHJDYDQR LO 'X0 FDWR DOOD /RPEDUGLD H DOOD 7RVFDQD FDSRYROJHQGR LO VHFRODUH DVVH RUL]]RQWDOH FRQ 9HQH]LD1 ²²²²²²²² 9
*OL DSSHOOL H OH GHQXQFLH HUDQR TXHOOH FKH DUULYDYDQR DOOD 4XDUWD &RPPLVVLRQH +ILQDQ0 ]H, GHOOD QXRYD DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GLSDUWLPHQWDOH UHSXEEOLFDQD/ YHGL $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWH0 ULH/ $JULFROWXUD H FRPPHUFLR/ E1 827/ IDVF1 481 : $602/ $UFKLYLR *LXGL]LDULR/ &XULD GL 0RGHQD/ (VDPL LQ FRQWUDYYHQ]LRQH DOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH 4:9:04:;51
<87
/XLJL 3XFFL
(UDQR VROFDWH GD SHVDQWL ´FDUUDWRQLµ FRQ TXDWWUR H SL• FDYDOOL FKH IDFHYD0 QR OD VSROD FRQ 3LDFHQ]D/ SRUWD VXG GL 0LODQR/ GD YHORFL ´YRODQWLQLµ H SDUH TXDVL FKH XQD QXRYD QR]LRQH GL WHPSR VL IRVVH LPSDGURQLWD GHOOD JHQWH= VLPEROLFDPHQWH DSSDULYDQR L SULPL RURORJL VXOOH WRUUL H VXL FDPSDQLOL FKH SXQWHJJLDYDQR OD FDPSDJQD1 9HUVR JOL DQQL RWWDQWD XQD FHUWD IUHQHVLD GHO GHQDUR VHPEUz SHUYDGHUH OH FODVVL PHGLH H VXSHULRUL= VL WUDIILFDYD/ VL D]]DUGDYD/ VL DFTXLVWDYDQR L EHQL GHO0 OH RSHUH SLH LQ XQD JLJDQWHVFD JLRVWUD VSHFXODWLYD1 0D VL FRVWLWXLYDQR DQFKH VRFLHWj GL FRPPHUFLR/ GL DVVLFXUD]LRQH/ G·H[SRUW0LPSRUW/ TXDOFKH YROWD FRQ VRFL VWUDQLHUL/ JHQRYHVL/ SLDFHQWLQL> PLODQHVL H SLDFHQWLQL HUDQR QRQ UDUDPHQWH L SRVWLJOLRQL H JOL RVWL FKH JHVWLYDQR OH RVWHULH FRQ LO FDPELR GL FDYDOOL OXQJR OH VWUDGH;1 6XOOH WDYROH GHL ULFFKL FRPSDULYDQR SURGRWWL HVRWLFL FRPH LO FDFDR GHOOH $QWLOOH/ LO FDIIq GHOOD 0DUWLQLFD/ OR ]XFFKHUR GL &XED FKH FRQ LO ORUR SURIXPR H OD ORUR IUDJUDQ]D FRPXQLFDYDQR LO GHVLGHULR GL WHUUH ORQWDQH1 /D ERUJKHVLD QRQ QDVFHYD VROR FRPH DVFHVL SURIHVVLRQDOH/ PD DQFKH FRPH VRJQR/ YLDJJLR/ DYYHQWXUD/ ´IDQWDVFLHQ]Dµ1 1RQ D FDVR LO FRQWH 0XQDULQL/ SUHVLGHQWH GHOOD 7DYROD GL 6WDWR/ OHJJHYD L 9LDJJL GL &RRN<1 &RQ L YLDJJL HQWUDYDQR DQFKH OH QXRYH LGHH/ FRPH GLPRVWUDYDQR L OLEUL GL /RNH/ 6PLWK/ 4XHVQD\ H 0DOWKXV1 1HOOH WDVFKH GHL ULFFKL DFFDQWR DL FDUQHWV LQ IRJOLD G·RUR/ FRPLQFLDYDQR DG DSSDULUH JOL DVVHJQL/ VLPEROR GL XQD ULFRQTXLVWD ILGXFLD1 0D QRQ PDQFDYDQR WXWWDYLD OH RPEUH= L ULFFKL VSHFXODQGR/ GLYHQWDYDQR VHPSUH SL• ULFFKL/ PHQWUH L SRYHUL/ DEEDQGRQDWL D VH VWHVVL/ VHPSUH SL• SRYH0 UL1 ,O FRQVLJOLHUH 3HGUHWWL/ DPLFR GHOOD 3KLORVRSKLH/ FRVu VFULYHYD D /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR /RVFKL YHUVR OD ILQH GHO 4:;3/ FLRq LQ XQ SHULRGR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH GL VWDVL H GL DWWHVD +VWDYD PRUHQGR )UDQFHVFR ,,, H WXWWL ODPHQWDYDQR XQ·LQHU]LD QHOOH LQL]LDWLYH,= ²²²²²²²² ; (· LO FDVR GHOOD VRFLHWj IRQGDWD QHO 4:;3 GD XQ JHQRYHVH H XQ PRGHQHVH ´PXQLWL GL VXI0 ILFLHQWL FDSLWDOL SHU FRSULUH TXDOVLDVL ORUR LQWUDSUHVD FRQVLVWHQGR LO ORUR WUDIILFR LQ RJQL VRUWD GL GURJKH H GL VDOXPLµ H GL XQ·DOWUD GLWWD GHGLWD DO FRPPHUFLR DOO·LQJURVVR GHOOR ]XFFKHUR/ GHO VDOH G·,QJKLOWHUUD H GURJKH FKH DSSDUH LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ VRFLHWj JHQRYHVL H SDUPHQVL H DOOH FXL GLSHQGHQ]H ODYRUDQR FDUUHWWLHUL FRQ FRQYRJOL WUDVFLQDWL ILQR GD TXDWWUR FDYDOOL1 /H PHUFL YLDJJLDYDQR VRWWR ´VLJXUWjµ/ FLRq VLJLOODWH H DVVLFXUDWH +$602/ $UFKLYLR *LXGL]LDULR/ &XULD GL 0RGHQD/ (VDPL LQ FRQWUDYYHQ]LRQH DOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH 4:9:04:;5/ YRO1 6:</ S1 5<8 H 6V> YRO1 6<8/ SS1 685 H 6V, < $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH/ /HWWHUDWL/ E1 6428/ IDVF1 0XQDULQL/ %/HWWHUD GL *1%10XQDULQL D /1$1 /RVFKL 45 OXJOLR 4:;:%1
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<88
´,R QRQ KR DOFXQD UDJLRQH GL HVVHUH PDOFRQWHQWR GHOOD PLD VLWXD]LRQH/ PD QRQ YL q JLRUQR QHO TXDOH QRQ HVFD GL FDVD FKH QRQ RGD ODPHQWL H QRQ YHGD SDWHQWHPHQWH VXOOD IDFFLD GHL PLHL FRQFLWWDGLQL LPSUHVVR LO VHULR SUREOHPD GHO SDQH1 4XL LO ULVSDUPLR YD DOO·HFFHVVR1 6L WRJOLH XQD PHVFKLQD VXVVLVWHQ]D DJOL XRPLQL SHU LPSULJLRQDUH O·RUR LQ XQD FDVVD GL IHUUR FKLXVD LQ PRGR FKH QRQ SXz DSULUVL VH QRQ PHGLDQWH XQD FHUWD FRUGD D VXVWH FKH DJLVFH VROWDQWR WUH FDPHUH GLVWDQWL GDO OXRJR GHO SULJLRQLHUR WHVRUR1 ,O VLVWHPD WRJOLH DQQXDO0 PHQWH 93 PLOD ]HFFKLQL DOOD FLUFROD]LRQH H VRSUD JOL DVVHJQL VWDELOLWL VL HFR0 QRPL]]D DOO·LQILQLWR H TXHL SRFKL GHQDUL FKH VL VSHQGRQR VL EXWWDQR ULGLFRO0 PHQWHµ431 ,O FRQWUDEEDQGR= XQ·HFRQRPLD VRPPHUVD ,O FHWR FKH VL GHGLFDYD DJOL DIIDUL JRGHYD D 0RGHQD GL XQR VSHFLDOH SULYL0 OHJLR GL IDWWR H FLRq XQ IRUWH GLIIHUHQ]LDOH ILVFDOH WUD LO 'XFDWR H LO YLFLQR 6WD0 WR GHOOD &KLHVD/ GLIIHUHQ]LDOH FKH LQWHUHVVDYD WXWWH OH PHUFL/ GDWR FKH QHO YLFL0 QR %RORJQHVH LO UHJLPH GL WDVVD]LRQH HUD SL• EODQGR/ PD XQD LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ LO VDOH441 4XHVWR SURGRWWR VDFUR GHOO·DQFLHQ UpJLPH FKH FRQFHQWUDYD LQ Vp OD ´UDULWDVµ H OD ´QHFHVVLWDVµ QRQFKp LO SRWHUH UHSUHVVLYR GHOOD VRFLHWj/ QHO YLFLQR 6WDWR FRVWDYD FLUFD XQ WHU]R GL PHQR FKH QHO 'XFDWR1 2OWUHWXWWR/ SURYHQHQGR GL0 UHWWDPHQWH GDOOH VDOLQH GL &HUYLD H GL &RPDFFKLR/ HUD GL TXDOLWj VXSHULRUH D TXHOOR FKH LPSRQHYD D 0RGHQD OD )HUPD JHQHUDOH FKH HUD XPLGR H SHVDQWH H DVVRPLJOLDYD SLXWWRVWR D ´WHUUD GL VDOHµ1 4XHVWR GLIIHUHQ]LDOH ILVFDOH/ VFDWXULWR DOO·RULJLQH GD XQD GLYHUVD SROLWLFD GL RSHUH SXEEOLFKH/ JDUDQWLYD XQ JXDGDJQR FHUWR1 ,O WUDIILFR HUD LQWHQVR= YL VL GHGLFDYDQR QRELOL H ILJOL GL IDPLJOLD/ PHUFDQWL/ IDWWRUL/ PHUFLDUL/ SDUURFL/ XVXUDL HFF1 LQ JHQHUH SHU LQWHUSRVWD SHUVRQD/ H SRL DQFRUD PHGLDWRUL/ SURSULHWDUL GL PXOL H GL EDUFKH H YLD VFHQGHQGR/ VHUYL/ SR0 VWLJOLRQL H XQD IROOD GL JHQWH PLQXWD GDOOD SL• LQVRVSHWWDELOH SURYHQLHQ]D1 ²²²²²²²² 43
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH/ /HWWHUDWL/ /RVFKL /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR/ &DVV1 6429/ IDVF1 3HGUHWWL 3DROR/ %/HWWHUD 4 GLF1 4:;3%1 44 -1 &1 +2&48(7/ /·LPS{W GX VHO HW O·pWDW LQ= /H URL/ OH PDUFKDQG HW OH VHO/ 3UHVVH XQLY1 GH /LOOH 4<;:> 61 $16(/0,/ /D SROLWLFD GHO VDOH QHL GRFXPHQWL SXEEOLFL GHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR1 $SSXQWL SHU XQD ULFHUFD LQ= 6DOH H VDOLQH QHOO·$GULDWLFR +VHF1 ;90;;,/ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL VXO VDOH H OH VDOLQH LQ $GULDWLFR LQ HWj PRGHUQD/ %DUL 4<:<1
<89
/XLJL 3XFFL
4XHVWR DWWLYR FRQWUDEEDQGR FRQ R VHQ]D OD SURWH]LRQH GL XQD WRQDFD R GL XQD OLYUHD/ PHWWHYD XQ OXFH XQ FHWR VRPPHUVR H FRPSOLFH GHOOD QDWXUD YLQFR0 OLVWLFD GHOOR 6WDWR LO FKH VSLHJD LQ SDUWH OH WLPLGH]]H/ OH SDYLGLWj H OH GHEROH]]H FXOWXUDOL GL TXHVWD FODVVH FKH GD XQD SDUWH DVSLUDYD DO QXRYR/ PD GDOO·DOWUD JXDGDJQDYD VXO YHFFKLR1 'DO SXQWR GL YLVWD GHOOD UHSUHVVLRQH L FRGLFL GL FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHJOL ´H0 VHFXWRULµ HUDQR PLQX]LRVL/ SXQWLJOLRVL/ VDGLFL1 4XHVWL JDEHOOLHUL GHOOD )HUPD FKH OD JHQWH FKLDPDYD YROJDUPHQWH ´EXUODQGRWWLµ R ´ELUULµ HUDQR UDFFROWL WUD OD IHFFLD GHL 3DHVL YLFLQL1 (UDQR OD ´YHUPLQH GH O·pWDWµ45/ H DSSDUWHQHYDQR DG XQD RUJDQL]]D]LRQH/ OD )HUPD/ FKH 9ROWDLUH GHILQLYD ´XQH VRFLHWp GH SDUWL0 VDQVµ/ PHQWUH 6PLWK VFULYHYD FKH ´Oj R• OH UHYHQXH HVW HQ )HUPH/ Oj VRQW OHV ORLV OHV SOXV VDQJXLQDLUHVµ461 $L FRQWUDEEDQGLHUL/ DL YDJDERQGL/ DL EDQGLWL YHUL H SURSUL VL VRPPDYD OD SLDJD GHL IXUWL FKH FROSLYDQR OH FDPSDJQH GXUDQWH OD VWDJLRQH GHL UDFFROWL H SUDWLFDPHQWH WXWWH OH FDVH SDWUL]LH ILQR DO SDOD]]R GXFDOH/ OD FXL ´SDJJHULDµ HUD LO FRYR GL WXWWL L YL]L1 4XHVWR IHQRPHQR IDFHYD HPHUJHUH LO GLVDJLR GHL ´ILJOL GL IDPLJOLDµ FKH YLYHYDQR DO GL VRSUD GHOOH ORUR SRVVLELOLWj HG HUDQR SHUFLz DVVHGLDWL GD XQD WRUPD GL VWUR]]LQL H GL ULFHWWDWRUL FKH/ QHOO·RSLQLRQH FRPXQH/ HUDQR GRPLFLOLDWL VRSUDWWXWWR QHO JKHWWR1 $O FRQWUDEEDQGR SRL VL VRPPDYDQR LVWDQ]H UHOLJLRVH H SROLWLFKH1 'XUDQWH OD VRPPRVVD GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD +4::6, YHQQH DOOD OXFH XQD UHWH FODQGHVWLQD FKH FRPSUHQGHYD ULYROWRVL H FRQWUDEEDQGLHUL/ PHQWUH VXOOR VIRQGR/ PD LP0 SUHQGLELOH/ VL VWDJOLDYD OD FODVVH GHJOL ´DYYRFDWL H GHL GRWWRULµ1 'D TXHVWD YDULHJDWD PRUIRORJLD VRFLDOH VL FRPSUHQGH FRPH OD PHUFDWXUD VL PXRYHVVH FRQ FLUFRVSH]LRQH LQ XQ·DUHD GL FRQILQH FHUFDQGR GL VIXJJLUH DOOD SLRYUD GHOOD )HUPD JHQHUDOH/ YHUR 6WDWR QHOOR 6WDWR471 /·HFRQRPLD OLEHUD HUD SHUFLz SDUDOOHOD/ GHEROH H VRPPHUVD/ FRQGRWWD LQ SDUWH FRQ OD FRPSOLFLWj GH0 JOL VWHVVL XRPLQL GHOOD )HUPD FRUURWWL HG DVVRFLDWL QHL JXDGDJQL1 ( GDWR FKH LO ²²²²²²²² 45 %1 %5,$6/ /HV FRQWUHEDQGLHUV GX VHO1 /D YLH GH IDX[ VDXPLHUV DX WHPSV GH OD JDEHOOH/ 3DULV/ $X0 ELHU/ 4<<71 6LPEROR GL TXHVWR SRWHUH UHSUHVVLYR HUD LO ´VHO GX GHYRLUµ +´ERFFDWLFRµ, FLRq O·LPSRVWD IRU]RVD VX XQ GHWHUPLQDWR FRQVXPR VWDELOLWR D SULRUL GDO QXPHUR GHOOH ERFFKH1 46 ,ELG1 47 6DOYDWRUH 9HQWXULQL H LO FRQWH 5DQJRQH/ FKH OR DYHYD DLXWDWR QHL FDOFROL/ VWLPDYDQR LQ :13331333 GL OLUH PRGHQHVL O·HQWUDWD GHOOH ILQDQ]H GHOOR 6WDWR/ GL FXL <331333 VH QH DQGDYDQR SHU OH VSHVH H 418331333 HUD O·XWLOH GHJOL DSSDOWDWRUL1 9HGL %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ 5DFF1 &DPSRUL/ *KHUDUGR 5DQJRQH 7HU]L/ 6FULWWL GLYHUVL ' 4048 /HWWHUD D 61 6HU1 GHO 4 GLF1 4::; GL 61 9HQWX0 ULQL1
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<8:
SRWHUH GHOOD )HUPD HUD DXPHQWDWR QHJOL DQQL SDVVDQGR GDOOH PDQL GHL JHQR0 YHVL D TXHOOL GHL PLODQHVL +4:9;,/ QH FRQVHJXu FKH WXWWH OH DWWLYLWj SURGXWWLYH IRVVHUR VSLQWH VHPSUH SL• QHO VRPPHUVR1 (UD XQD ORWWD VHQ]D HVFOXVLRQH GL FROSL= OD )HUPD DWWDFFDYD LQ SURIRQGLWj L FHWL DWWLYL FROSHQGR VLD SXQWXDOPHQWH FKH GLIIXVDPHQWH1 3XQWXDOPHQWH/ FRQ LUUX]LRQL QHOOH D]LHQGH SULYDWH FRPH SHU HVHPSLR TXHOOH 'DOODUL +6DVVXROR,/ *DYLROL H 7RVDWWL +0LUDQGROD,/ 9HQWXULQL +0RGHQD,/ VFHOWH FRPH FDSUL HVSLD0 WRUL H FRPH VLPEROL GL XQ·LQWUDSUHQGHQ]D LQDPPLVVLELOH481 (UD XQD ORWWD WUD XRPLQL/ PD DQFKH H VRSUDWWXWWR G·LGHH1 /D )HUPD SRVVHGHYD DYYRFDWL/ JLXGL0 FL/ PH]]L GL SUHVVLRQH/ PD LO WHU]R VWDWR QRQ VRSSRUWDYD SL• L VXRL VLVWHPL HG HUD XQD ULYROWD RUPDL JHQHUDOH/ GD 0LODQR ILQR D 0RGHQD1 ,O SURFHVVR 9HQWX0 ULQL +4:::04:;3,/ XQR GHL SURFHVVL SL• LPSRUWDQWL GL WXWWD O·,WDOLD VHWWHQWULRQD0 OH/ q VWDWR OD FURQLVWRULD GL TXHVWR EUDFFLR GL IHUUR FKH VL FRPEDWWq VXO SLDQR ILVFDOH/ PD LQ UHDOWj PLVH LQ GLVFXVVLRQH O·HWLFD VWHVVD GHOO·DQFLHQ UpJLPH/ OD VXD FRQFH]LRQH GHO GHQDUR/ GHO FUHGLWR/ OD VXD YLVLRQH DQWLFUHPDWLVWLFD EDVDWD VXO SULYLOHJLR491 /R VWDWR VWDELOH QRELOLDUH YDFLOOD ,O SRWHUH GHOOD )HUPD FRUULVSRQGHYD DG XQD VLWXD]LRQH VRFLDOH VWDWLFD/ OH0 JDWD DL YLQFROL IHXGDOL/ FRPH L ILGHFRPPHVVL/ L PDJJLRUDVFKL/ OH SULPRJHQLWX0 UH/ OH GRWL/ OH PDQL PRUWH/ L YDUL SDWWL HVFOXVLYL FKH VRWWUDHYDQR L EHQL DOOD OLEH0 UD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHO PHUFDWR1 (UDQR WXWWDYLD VXFFHVVL GXH IDWWL FKH DOWHUDYDQR TXHVWR VHFRODUH HTXLOLEULR1 ,O SULPR HUD O·XVFLWD GHO &RGLFH JLj ULFRUGDWR> LO VHFRQGR OD YHQGLWD PDVVLFFLD D SDUWLUH GDL SULPL DQQL VHWWDQWD/ GHL EHQL GHOOH FRQIUDWHUQLWH H GHOOH RSHUH SLH1 4XHVWD HQRUPH PDVVD GL EHQL FKH /RGRYLFR 5LFFL YDOXWDYD D FLUFD XQ VHVWR GHOO·LQWHUR WHUULWRULR PRGHQHVH/ VL ULYHUVz VXO PHUFDWR PHWWHQGR LQ PRWR XQD JLUDQGROD LPPHQVD GL DIIDUL H GL DSSHWLWL/ XQLWDPHQWH DG XQ YHUWLJLQRVR JLUR GL GHQDUR H GL ULFFKH]]H1 $ TXHVWR SXQWR OR VWDWR VWDELOH QRELOLDUH FRPLQFLz D YDFLOODUH= OH VSHFXOD0 ]LRQL LPPRELOLDUL FUHDURQR XQ QXRYR FHWR DWWLYR FKH FRQILQDYD FRQ DSSURILW0 ²²²²²²²² 48
,ELGHP1 /138&&,/ ,O SURFHVVR 9HQWXULQL +4:::0;3,1 'DOOD ULYROWD ILVFDOH DL GLULWWL GHO FLWWDGLQR/ LQ © $WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 ;,/ ;9,,+4<<8,> ,'1 /LQHDPHQWL GL XQD ERUJKHVLD LQ QHUR 111FLW1 49
<8;
/XLJL 3XFFL
WDWRUL/ SUHVWDWRUL H VWUR]]LQL LQ XQ YRUWLFH FUHVFHQWH1 &RPH HUD SRVVLELOH LQ TXHVWD VLWXD]LRQH WHQHUH WXWWR LO UHVWR GHOO·HFRQRPLD EORFFDWR" ,Q XQ FHUWR VHQVR DYHYDQR UDJLRQH L WLPRUDWL H L FRGLQL= VL HUD YROXWR JLRFDUH FRQ LO GLDYR0 OR/ ´DEEDWWHUH OD FRORQQD VWUXPHQWDULD GHOOD &KLHVD D VROOLHYR GHL SRYHULµ/ QRQ VL SRWHYD RUD SUHWHQGHUH GL ULPDQHUH D PH]]D VWUDGD OHJDWL DO ´ERFFDWL0 FRµ GHO VDOH/ DOOR MXVWXP SUHWLXP GHO SDQH/ GHO YLQR H DOWUL FDOPLHUL1 7XWWD OD YHFFKLD LPSDOFDWXUD VDUHEEH FDGXWD D SH]]L/ ILQR D PHWWHUH LQ GXEELR OD VWHV0 VD LPPDJLQH DVVROXWLVWD GHO SULQFLSH1 $EELDPR ULFRUGDWR LO &RGLFH= XQD OHJLVOD]LRQH LQ UHDOWj LQ SURJUHVV SHUFKq DOOD SURPXOJD]LRQH GHL GXH YROXPL/ VL VXVVHJXLURQR D ULWPR VRVWHQXWR QRUPH G·DSSOLFD]LRQH/ ´HVWHQVLRQLµ/ ´DJJLXQWHµ +4::9 H ROWUH, DG RSHUD GL XQD FRP0 PLVVLRQH OHJLVODWLYD SHUPDQHQWH JXLGDWD GDL FRQVLJOLHUL 9DQGHOOL H 5XJD/ XQD VSHFLH GL VSDGD GL 'DPRFOH SHQGHQWH VXL FHWL SULYLOHJLDWL/ XQ·DUPD WUHPHQGD QHOOH PDQL GHO FHWR ULIRUPDWRUH1 /D FRPPLVVLRQH DEROu OD WRUWXUD/ LO WULEXQDOH GHO 6DQW·2IIL]LR/ LO FDUFHUH SHU GHELWL/ LVWLWXu LO GLIHQVRUH FLYLFR SHU L SL• SRYHUL/ VROOHYz D QXRYD GLJQLWjL PHUFDQWL RUGLQDQGR FKH DO ORUR FRJQRPH VL SUHPHWWHVVH ´LO VLJQRUµ VLPEROR GHO QXRYR VWDWXV UDJJLXQWR GDO FHWR PHUFDQWLOH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD VRFLHWj1 8Q EHO VDOWR/ VH SHQVLDPR FKH ILQR D TXDOFKH DQQR SULPD HUD LPSRVVLELOH DFFHGH0 UH DO &ROOHJLR GHL QRELOL VH LQ IDPLJOLD ILJXUDYD DQFKH VROR XQ PHUFDQWH1 1DWXUDOPHQWH QRQ HUDQR WXWWH URVH H YLROH SHUFKq VH LO &RGLFH FRQFHGHYD GHOOH DSHUWXUH LQ PDWHULD FRPPHUFLDOH/ VHPEUDYD ULEDGLUH OH SL• EHFHUH GL0 VFULPLQD]LRQL IHXGDOL QHL FRQIURQWL GHO JKHWWR H GHJOL HEUHL/ TXDVL DG RIIULUH XQD FRPSHQVD]LRQH +/LE1 ,,/ 7LW1 ,;,1 7XWWR VRPPDWR WXWWDYLD VL SXz DIIHUPDUH/ SHU ULSUHQGHUH XQ QHRORJLVPR/ FKH FRQ LO &RGLFH HVWHQVH/ LO 0RGHQHVH HQWUDYD LQ (XURSD> VL WUDWWDYD LQIDWWL GL XQ ´FRGLFH UHQDQRµ/ PRGHOODWR FLRq VXOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH WHGHVFD HG DXVWULDFD1 6H FRQFHGHYD VSD]LR DL EDQFKLHUL/ DO GHQDUR/ DL SUHVWLWL/ VH XIILFLDOL]]DYD O·LQWHUHVVH/ QRQ IDFHYD SHUz PHQ]LRQH GHOOD ERUVD YDORUL/ OD TXDOH ULPDQHYD XQD IURQWLHUD LUUDJJLXQJLELOH/ GL SDHVL ORQWDQL FRPH O·2ODQGD H O·,QJKLOWHUUD/ SRFR UDFFRPDQGDELOL VXO SLDQR HWLFR1 (UD RYYLR FKH IRVVH FRVu/ QHO PRGHOOR UHQDQR D FXL DGHUu LO &RGLFH/ LO FRPPHUFLR DYYHQLYD SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOR 6WDWR H OR 6WDWR ULPD0 QHYD FRQVHUYDWRUH/ LGHQWLILFDWR QHO SULQFLSH/ QRQ HUD SUHYLVWD DOFXQD FDUWD FRVWLWX]LRQDOH/ SDUODPHQWR H OLEHUWj GL HVSUHVVLRQH1 /D PRQHWD HUD GHEROH/ QRQ UDUDPHQWH HUD ODVFLDWD VYDOXWDUH/ PHQWUH LO PRGHOOR DQJORVDVVRQH HUD DOO·RSSRVWR EDVDWR VXOOD &RVWLWX]LRQH/ VXOOD PRQHWD IRUWH/ VXOOH HVSRUWD]LRQL H
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<8<
VXO FRPPHUFLR FRQ O·HVWHUR= VLJQLILFDYD XQ VLVWHPD FRPPHUFLDOH VROLGR FRQ XQD FODVVH GL PHUFDQWL GRPLQDQWH H SRWHQWH1 1RQ VL FUHGD FKH D 0RGHQD QRQ FL IRVVHUR GHJOL VSLULWL IRUWL FKH DVSLUDVVH0 UR DG XQD FRVWLWX]LRQH +QRQ VROR 9HUUL D 0LODQR/ PD DQFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR 5LFFL/ 0XQDULQL HFF1,1 1HOO·LQVLHPH WXWWDYLD LO FRPSURPHVVR HUD TXHVWR= VL DPPHWWHYD LO GHQDUR H OD EDQFD/ PD VRWWR O·HJLGD GHOOD FODVVH DULVWRFUDWLFD1 (UD XQ SDVVR DYDQWL QRWHYROH/ PD L SUHJLXGL]L HUDQR IRUWL LQ WXWWD (XURSD= UL0 FRUGLDPR FKH L JHQHUDOL WHGHVFKL SHQVDYDQR FRPH 0DFKLDYHOOL +PD QRQ FRPH 0RQWHFXFFROL, H FKH FLRq ´JOL XRPLQL H QRQ LO GHQDUR HUDQR LO QHUER GHOOD JXHUUDµ4:1 /H ´GHURJKHµ H LO PHUFDWR GHOOH ´1*LRLHµ 8Q DOWUR PHFFDQLVPR VFDUGLQDQWH PHVVR LQ PRWR GDO &RGLFH IX TXHOOR GHOOH ´GHURJKHµ FKH OD &DPHUD GXFDOH/ VHPSUH DVVHWDWD GL GHQDUR/ ULODVFLDYD SUHYLR SDJDPHQWR1 'HURJKH DL YLQFROL IHXGDOL FRQ OH TXDOL VL SRWHYD SHU H0 VHPSLR OLPLWDUH R WUDVIHULUH SULPRJHQLWXUH/ IHGHFRPPHVVL/ UHJLPL GRWDOL HFF1 VX DOWUH SRVVHVVLRQL R FDQFHOODUOH GHO WXWWR= RSHUD]LRQL HODERUDWH/ PD UHVH QH0 FHVVDULH GDOOD VLWXD]LRQH QRELOLDUH FKH VL HUD YHQXWD VHPSUH SL• GHWHULRUDQGR LQ TXHJOL DQQL4;1 &KL RWWHQHYD OH GHURJKH LQIDWWL HUDQR LQ UHDOWj L FUHGLWRUL LSR0 WHFDUL1 &·HUDQR Vu GHOOH SULPRJHQLWXUH ´LQ WHUPLQL VWUHWWLµ FKH HUDQR HVFOXVH GD TXHVWD FRQFHVVLRQH/ PD QHOOD SL• SDUWH GHL FDVL/ TXHVWH DSHUWXUH HEEHUR QRWHYROL ULSHUFXVVLRQL1 3HUPLVHUR DQ]LWXWWR O·LPPLVVLRQH VXO PHUFDWR GL XQ FHUWR EORFFR GL EHQL LPPRELOL SULPD LQDOLHQDELOL/ ULGLHGH TXLQGL YDORUH DG XQD PDVVD GL WLWROL GL FUHGLWR FDUWDFHL +SROL]]H YDULH VX VLJXUWj, FKH JLUDYDQR VHP0 SUH SL• VYLOLWL/ DO 53/ 63 SHU FHQWR GHO ORUR YDORUH GD XQD PDQR DOO·DOWUD GHL YD0 UL EDQFKLHUL1 6L WUDWWz GXQTXH GHOOD SURJUHVVLYD ULYLWDOL]]D]LRQH GL XQ PHUFDWR ILQDQ]LD0 ULR FKH JLDFHYD DEEDQGRQDWR H QHJOHWWR H TXHVWR QRQ q WDQWR LPSRUWDQWH SHU LO IDWWR LQ Vp/ TXDQWR SHU LO QXRYR VSLULWR GL ILGXFLD FKH GLIIXVH WUD OD FODVVH GHJOL LPSUHQGLWRUL ILQDQ]LDUL1 /D SURJUHVVLYD ULYDOXWD]LRQH GL TXHVWD PDVVD FUHGLWL]LD FKH FRUULVSRQGHYD DL GHELWL GL FXL VL HUDQR FRSHUWL L QRELOL +H L ILJOL GL IDPLJOLD, QHO FRUVR GHJOL ²²²²²²²² 4: 51 0217(&8&&2/,/ $IRULVPL GHOO·DUWH EHOOLFD/ 0LODQR 4<;:/ &DS1 ,, /7LW1 9= 'HO GHQDUR> ,'1/ , YLDJJL/ 0RGHQD 4<571 4; &RGLFH GHOOH OHJJL H GHOOH FRVWLWX]LRQL/ OLE1 ,,/ 7LW1 ;;;9,,1
<93
/XLJL 3XFFL
DQQL/ QRQ VROR OHJLWWLPz O·DVVDOWR DOOD PDQR0PRUWD QRELOLDUH GRSR TXHOOD HF0 FOHVLDVWLFD +DQFKH VH GL SURSRU]LRQL LQILQLWDPHQWH PLQRUL,/ PD HEEH FRPH FRQWUDFFROSR TXHOOR GL SURYRFDUH LO GHFOLQR GHO YDORUH GHOOH ´JLRLHµ1 ,O PHUFDWR GHOOH JLRLH R ELMRX[ HUD XQR GHL SL• FRPSOHVVL GHOO·DQWLFR UHJL0 PH= L JLRLHOOL HUDQR Vu XQ RUQDPHQWR/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR XQ FDSLWDOH FKH VL FRVWL0 WXLYD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOH GRWL +´VHUYL]LR GRWDOHµ, H GHL PDWULPRQL FRQ JUDQGL VDFULILFL HG LQGHELWDPHQWL1 /H JLRLH HUDQR LQ UHDOWj LQFDVWRQDWH GL GHELWL= GHELWL DOO·DFTXLVWR H ´VLJXUWjµ SHU L GHELWL VXFFHVVLYL1 /D GRQQD/ FRPH DQFRUD RJJL LQ FHUWL SDHVL0SUHFDSLWDOLVWLFL/ HUD GXQTXH FXVWRGH H WHVRULHUD GHOOD IDPLJOLD H GHO FODQ1 /·DQGDPHQWR GL TXHVWR PHUFDWR HUD WXWW·XQR FRQ LO SURJUHVVLYR LQGHELWD0 PHQWR GHOOD QRELOWj HG DOLPHQWDYD XQ JLUR G·DIIDUL FKH GD DUJHQWLHUH DG DU0 JHQWLHUH/ DUULYDYD ILQR DOOD SLD]]D GL 0LODQR GRYH HVLVWHYD XQ ´ERUVLQRµ FRQ DQQHVVD DVWD1 7XWWH OH JLRLH SHU HVVHUH VWLPDWH/ YHQLYDQR ULGRWWH LQ FDUDWL R LQ JUDQL/ HUDQR SHUFLz VPRQWDWH H GDWH LQ VWLPD DL SHULWL1 %UDFFLDOHWWL/ URVHWWLQH/ EDOOHWWH/ TXDGULJOLH/ ILDPPLQJKH/ FURFL/ FROOLHUV/ D0 QHOOL HFF1 GDYDQR SHUFLz OXRJR D FRQWURYHUVLH VXOOD YDOXWD]LRQH FKH ROWUH JOL XVXUDL LQWHUHVVDYDQR L PDOOHYDGRUL/ ILQR D UDJJLXQJHUH TXDOFKH YROWD L SRGHVWj H OR VWHVVR &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ FKLDPDWL LQ FDXVD GDL SURSULHWDUL GHIUDXGD0 WL1 ,O VLVWHPD HUD IDUUDJLQRVR HG DSSHVDQWLWR GDL PROWL SDVVDJJL/ GDL ULVFKL GL YLDJJLR/ GL IXUWR/ GL FRQWUDEEDQGR H DOOD ILQH GD YDOXWD]LRQL UDSDFL FKH ODVFLD0 YDQR LQ PDQR DO SURSULHWDULR QRQ ROWUH OD PHWj GHO YDORUH D VHFRQGD GHL SH0 ULRGL H GHOOD TXDOLWj GHL FRQWUDHQWL1 /H JLRLH HUDQR LQ UHDOWj OD PDQLIHVWD]LRQH GL XQD VRFLHWj VWDWLFD/ GLIILGHQWH GHO FUHGLWR H GL WXWWH OH DOWUH IRUPH PRGHUQH GL FDSLWDOH PRELOH1 3RVVLDPR GXQTXH FRQFOXGHUH GLFHQGR FKH O·LVWLWXWR GHOOD ´GHURJDµ/ IDYRUHQGR O·LPPLVVLRQH VXO PHUFDWR GHO FDSLWDOH LPPRELOLDUH QRELOLDUH/ ILQu SHU VSLD]]D0 UH TXHOOR GHL SUH]LRVL/ VSRVWDQGR O·LQWHUHVVH VX DOWUH IRUPH GL ´VLJXUWjµ H G·LQYHVWLPHQWR SL• VLFXUH H PRGHUQH1 &KL SRWq XVFu GDO PHUFDWR GHOOH JLRLH= VL HEEH TXLQGL XQ IXJJL H IXJJL SHU FRUUHUH VRWWR DOWUH SURWH]LRQL H VLJXUWj/ SUHYLD OD VROLWD RQHURVD FRQFHVVLRQH GD SDUWH GHOOD 'XFDO FDPHUD1 &KL QRQ ULXVFu D ULFLFODUH D WHPSR LO VXR FUHGLWR/ QH SDJz OH FRQVHJXHQ]H1 ,O SUH]]R GHOOH JLRLH/ D SDUWLUH GDOOD PHWj GHJOL DQQL ¶:3/ LQL]Lz XQ SURJUHVVLYR/ PD LUUHYHUVLELOH GHFOLQR LO TXDOH D VXD YROWD SURYR0 Fz XQD VHULH GL IDOOLPHQWL GL EDQFKLHUL H GL DUJHQWLHUL FKH/ FRPH XQ JLRFR GL
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<94
FDUWH/ VL SURSDJz D WXWWH OH FLWWj GHO QRUG ILQR D 0LODQR4<1 6L SXz GLUH GXQTXH FKH OH GHURJKH VSLDQDURQR OD VWUDGD DG XQD QXRYD FRQFH]LRQH GHO FDSLWDOH ´ERUJKHVHµ GRYH ´LO OLTXLGRµ HUD EDVDWR VHPSUH SL• VXO FUHGLWR H VXOOD PRQHWD UDSSUHVHQWDWLYD H EDQFDULD1 /D ´GHFUHVFHQ]D GHOOH JLRLHµ PLVXUD SHUFLz LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR LO WUHQG GL DPPRGHUQDPHQWR H GL VYL0 OXSSR GL TXHVWD VRFLHWj LQ WUDVIRUPD]LRQH1 7UDVIRUPD]LRQH D VXD YROWD VLP0 EROHJJLDWD GDOOD QXRYD QRUPDWLYD FUHGLWL]LD/ UHJRODWD GDO &RGLFH SHU FHQVL/ FDPEL/ DVVHJQL/ OHWWHUH GL FDPELR/ SROL]]H HFF1 FKH GLVFLSOLQDYDQR XQD PDWHULD FKH HUD ILQR DG DOORUD XQ VRWWRERVFR GL DEXVL H G·LOOHJDOLWj QHOOH PDQL GL EDQ0 FKLHUL H GL VWUR]]LQL531 6L HUD VSDUVD OD YRFH/ FRQ OD QXRYD QRUPDWLYD/ FKH QHOOD FDSLWDOH HVWHQVH ´VL HUDQR SHUPHVVH OH XVXUHµ SHU FXL DOFXQL LQROWUDURQR VXSSOLFKH SHU SRWHU DSULUH EDQFKL H SHUILQR XQD ´EDQFD FLYLOHµ541 ,Q UHDOWj OD EDWWDJOLD LQ FRUVR SHU GLVFKLXGHUH GHL YDUFKL DG XQD FRQFH]LRQH PRGHUQD GHO FUHGLWR H GHO FDSLWDOH QRQ HUD DQFRUD YLQWD1 3HU OD FDPELDOH H SHU OD ´JLUDWDµ LQIDWWL/ VLPEROR SHU HFFHOOHQ]D GHOOD QXRYD HWLFD ERUJKHVH/ QRQRVWDQWH OH SUHVVLRQL GHO JRYHUQR 0XQDULQL VXO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ ELVRJQHUj DVSHWWDUH DQFRUD ILQR DO 4:;5 H ROWUH/ PD OD ORUR UHJRODPHQWD]LRQH SURFHGHUj FRQ PROWH UHVWUL]LRQL ILQR DOO·DUULYR GHL IUDQFHVL +4:<9,551 ²²²²²²²² 4< 8QR GHL IDOOLPHQWL SL• ULOHYDQWL GHOO·HSRFD IX TXHOOR GL 0RLVp -RQD &DOLPDQR SDGUH H ILJOLR +4::8, SHU XQ DPPRQWDUH GL TXDVL 4331333 OLUH1 $QFKH TXHVWR IDOOLPHQWR GHULYDYD GDOOD ´GHFUHVFHQ]D FKH DYHYDQR VXELWR OH JLRLH QHO GHFRUVR GL TXHVWL XOWLPL DQQLµ SHU FXL PROWL FUHGLWRUL HUDQR ULPDVWL DOOR VFRSHUWR YHGL $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 3DUWLPHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ ILO]D 6<:/ IDVF1 %5HOD]LRQL GHO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD H GL DOWUL WULEXQDOL H PLQLVWUL GHOOD FLWWj GL 0R0 GHQD%1 9HGL DQFKH ,%,'1/ 5HOD]LRQH GHO &RQVLJOLR 6XSHULRUH GL *LXVWL]LD/ ILO]D 7341 8Q DOWUR IDOOL0 PHQWR ´JUDQGLRVRµ IX TXHOOR FKH FRLQYROVH LO FRQWH %DUWRORPHR 9DOGULJKL +4:;3, H FKH LQWH0 UHVVz L EDQFKL GL /HRQ 0RLVp 2UVL H 6DORPRPH $EUDP /HYL/ +$602/ $UFKLYLR 9DOGULJKL/ 0D]]L 55057/ IDVF1 91, 53 6H VL FRQIURQWD LO FRGLFH D VWDPSD FRQ TXHOOR PDQRVFULWWR VL QRWD XQ DOODUJDPHQWR GHO0 OR VSD]LR FRQFHVVR DOOH VFULWWXUH SULYDWH1 6L WUDWWDYD SXU VHPSUH GL ´SROL]]Hµ FKH DYHYDQR EL0 VRJQR GHOOD FRQYDOLGD QRWDULOH1 9HGL &RGLFH FLW1 OLE1 , 7LW1 ;; SDU1 ,, H &RGLFH PDQRVFULWWR SUHVVR $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH1 54 (· VLQWRPDWLFR FKH LO 'RWW1 *LDFRPR )HUUDUL FKLHGD GL HVVHUH DPPHVVR DOO·LQFDULFR VLD GHO QRWDULDWR VLD DOO·DSHUWXUD GL XQD EDQFD FLYLOH LQ 0RGHQD/ GDWR FKH OH GXH SURIHVVLRQL LQ TXHOO·HSRFD HUDQR DVVDL FRQQHVVH +JLUDWH/ DXWHQWLFD]LRQL HFF1, $602/&DPHUD GXFDOH/ 3DUWLPHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ 5HOD]LRQL GHO &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD H DOWUL PLQLVWHUL/ ILO]D 7331 55 0ROWH GL TXHVWH UHVWUL]LRQL ULJXDUGDYDQR DSSXQWR O·DVWUDWWH]]D GHO WLWROR H FLRq OD VXD DXWRQRPLD GDO UDSSRUWR VRWWRVWDQWH1 RFFRUUHYD SXU VHPSUH XQD VFULWWXUD QRWDULOH/ FRQ PDOOH0 YDGRUL H WHVWLPRQL VLD DOO·DWWR GHOOD VRWWRVFUL]LRQH VLD LQ RFFDVLRQH GL RJQL JLUDWD1 9HGL &RGLFH
<95
/XLJL 3XFFL
1RQ HUD XQ JUDQGH ULWDUGR ULVSHWWR DOOH QRUPDWLYH GHJOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL +3LHPRQWH GDO 4::; LQ SRL, H PLWWHOHXURSHL +*HUPDQLD ILQH 6HWWHFHQWR,/ PD QRWHYROH QHL FRQIURQWL GHOO·,QJKLOWHUUD H GHOOD )UDQFLD FKH JLj FRQRVFHYDQR XQD OHJLVOD]LRQH FDPELDULD DOOD ILQH GHO GLFLDVVHWWHVLPR VHFROR561 /D SURWHVWD ILVFDOH= GDOO·D]LHQGD ´'DOODULµ D TXHOOD ´9HQWXULQLµ ,O FRQFHWWR PRGHUQR GL FDSLWDOH FRPH FRPSOHVVR GL UDSSRUWL SURGXWWLYL/ GL HTXLSPHQWV H GL RUJDQL]]D]LRQH ILQDOL]]DWD DOOR VFRSR GHO OXFUR HUD VFDUVD0 PHQWH UHFHSLWR GDOO·LGHRORJLD GRPLQDQWH1 ,O ILQH GHO OXFUR/ SULPD GHOO·DSSDUL]LRQH GHO &RGLFH/ HUD DSSHQD WROOHUDWR/ DO SXQWR FKH FKL VXSSOLFDYD GL RWWHQHUH XQ PXWXR ´DG HIIHWWR GL DXPHQWDUH L FDSLWDOLµ/ SUHIHULYD GLFKLDUD0 UH FKH GRYHYD ´FRQWULEXLUH DO PDQWHQLPHQWR GHOOD IDPLJOLDµ571 4XHVWD GLIILGHQ]D q PHVVD LQ OXFH GDOOD VWHVVD YLFHQGD GHOOH VFULWWXUH FRQ0 WDELOL FKH HUDQR Vu UHFHSLWH GDO &RGLFH/ PD QRQ DQFRUD FRPH REEOLJDWRULH= LQ FDVR GL SURFHGXUD IDOOLPHQWDUH HUDQR XQD IDFLOLWD]LRQH SHU RWWHQHUH ´OD FHV0 VLRQH GHL EHQL SHU YLD QRQ LJQRPLQRVDµ +VSHFLH GL FRQFRUGDWR,/ QRUPD FKH WHQGHYD D SRUUH XQ DUJLQH DOOD SLDJD GLIIXVLVVLPD GHL IDOOLPHQWL GRORVL1 6ROR XQD SURYYLVLRQH VXFFHVVLYD/ YHUVR OD ILQH GHJOL DQQL ¶:3/ UHQGHYD RE0 EOLJDWRULD OD WHQXWD GHL OLEUL ´FRQWUDVVHJQDWLµ GDOO·8IILFLR FULPLQDOH ´SHU QRWD0 UH OH UREH DFTXLVWDWH H YHQGXWHµ581 0D VL WUDWWDYD GL XQD GLVSRVL]LRQH GLVDWWH0 VD H PROWL HUDQR L PHUFDQWL FKH QHJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL IXURQR ´UHDWL]]DWLµ D WDOH SURSRVLWR1 1HO FDVR GL VRFLHWj OH GLVSRVL]LRQL VXOOD REEOLJDWRULHWj GL VFULWWXUH GD FXL ULVXOWDVVHUR ´L FRQWL GHO PDQHJJLRµ VL IHFHUR QHJOL VWHVVL DQQL SL• VHYH0 UH H OH VFULWWXUH IXURQR VRJJHWWH/ LQ FDVR GL FRQWHVWD]LRQL R GLYHUJHQ]H WUD L VRFL/ D ´ORGRµ GD SDUWH GL ´FRPSURPLVVDULµ +VLQGDFL,1 &L VL DYYLDYD GXQTXH FRQ IDWLFD DG XQD OHJLVOD]LRQH PRGHUQD LQ PDWHULD/ ²²²²²²²² HVWHQVH 7RPR , OLE1 , 7LW1 9,,, H WLW1 ;;> 7RPR ,,/ /LE1 9/ 7LW1 ;,9 7LW1 ;;1 56 *1 6$/9,2/,/ 0LVFHOODQHD GL OHJLVOD]LRQH HVWHQVH/ 3DOHUPR 4;<;> ,G1/ /D OHJLVOD]LRQH GL )UDQFH0 VFR ,,, GXFD GL 0RGHQD LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH 'HSXWD]LRQH 6WRULD 3DWULD 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 ,9/ ,; +4;<<,> )1 )(55$5$ +-XQLRU,/ /D JLUDWD GHOOD FDPELDOH/ 5RPD 4<681 57 6XSSOLFD GL 1DGDHOH 3DYLD/ QHJR]LDQWH LQ IHUUDPHQWD YHGL $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 3DUWLPHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ ILO]D 6<7/ 47 QRY1 +4::4,1 58 $ ULSURYD GHOOH HVLWD]LRQL VL QRWL FKH QHO 061 GHO &RGLFH LO SDUDJUDIR UHODWLYR DOOH VFULWWX0 UH H FLRq OLEUL PDVWUL/ OLEUL FRSLDOHWWHUH/ JLRUQDOL H DOWUL UHFDSLWL/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWR UHGDWWR YH0 QLYD FDQFHOODWR YHGL $602/ 0V1 &RGLFH GHOOH FRVW1 FLW1 &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH FROO1 FLW1 OLE1 ,,/ 7LW1 ;;,9 SDU1 ;,,,1 9HGL DQFKH 6XSUHPR &RQVLJOLR *LXVL]LD1 &ULPLQDOH +4::<,/ /HWWHUD GL *1%1 &HQ0 WL/ VLQGDFR ILVFDOH/ 49 PDU]R 4::</ EXVWD 49;1
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<96
PD FL VL VFRQWUDYD FRQWUR OR VWUDSRWHUH GHOOD )HUPD SHU FXL HUDQR EHQ SRFKL JO·LQGDJDWL FKH DIIHUPDYDQR GL WHQHUH VFULWWXUH FKH SRWHYDQR GLYHQWDUH GHJOL DWWL GL DFFXVD1 'DOODUL GL 6DVVXROR/ 9HQWXULQL GL 0RGHQD/ 7RVDWWL GL 0LUDQGROD/ VROR SHU IDUH WUH HVHPSL WUD L WDQWL/ GLFKLDUDYDQR GL ´WHQHUH WXWWR D PHQWHµ H 9HQWXULQL LQ SDUWLFRODUH VL HUD GLIHVR DJJLXQJHQGR FKH HUD ´FDULFR GL DIIDUL H QRQ DYHYD IDWWRUH SHU FXL QRQ DYHYD VFULWWXUHµ591 0D FRQ WXWWD SUREDELOLWj ´OH VFULWWXUH GHO GDUH H GHOO·DYHUHµ/ FRQ LO ORUR GHWWDJOLDWR FDUWHJJLR/ HVLVWHYDQR HFFRPH QHO FDVLQR 9HQWXULQL GL 0XJQDQR HG HUDQR QHOOD VWDQ]D QHOOD TXDOH HJOL VL HUD DV0 VHUUDJOLDWR DOO·LUUX]LRQH QRWWXUQD GHL IHUPLHUL/ ULILXWDQGRVL GL XVFLUH1 ,O SUREOHPD q TXHOOR GL VWDELOLUH ILQR D FKH SXQWR/ DQFKH Oj GRYH HVLVWHYD0 QR GHL ULVWUHWWL H GHL ELODQFL/ GHL EROOHWDUL H GHL UHJLVWUL GL FDULFR H GL VFDULFR/ HVVL IRVVHUR GHL YHUL VWUXPHQWL GL JHVWLRQH/ VH FL IRVVH XQD ILQDOL]]D]LRQH VWUD0 WHJLFD/ VH SHU HVHPSLR YL FRPSDULVVH LO FRQFHWWR GL DPPRUWDPHQWR SHU TXRWH HFF1 6L KD O·LPSUHVVLRQH FKH QHL FDVL SL• IUHTXHQWL/ IRVVHUR GHJOL VWUXPHQWL DEEDVWDQ]D VWDWLFL/ GRYH LO FRQFHWWR GL SURGXWWLYLWj IRVVH TXDVL VFRQRVFLXWR5:1 0D FHUWR QRQ SRVVLDPR GLPHQWLFDUH FKH HVLVWHYDQR QHO 'XFDWR D]LHQGH FR0 PH TXHOOD GL $QJHOR %RQGu 6DQJXLQHWWL FKH SRVVHGHYD QXPHURVL ´ILODWRJOLµ VLD LQ 0RGHQD FKH LQ 5HJJLR R TXHOOD GHL )DQR +5HJJLR,/ XQD GLWWD ILQDQ]LDULD FKH LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR IDFHYD SUHVWLWL VX *HQRYD H VX 0LODQR HFF1 WXWWH LP0 SUHVH FKH FRQWDYDQR FHUWDPHQWH VX XQD FRQWDELOLWj VHJUHWD H VRILVWLFDWD5;1 )RUVH YDUUj OD SHQD VRIIHUPDUVL VXO FDVR GHOOD IDEEULFD GL PDMROLFD 'DOODUL +´R 'DOODUDµ, GL 6DVVXROR5< DFFXVDWD GDL ´SDWULRWLµ GL TXHO FRPSUHQVRULR QHO 4:<:/ GL DYHU WHQXWR SHU OXQJR WHPSR ´LQFHSSDWD O·LQGXVWULD GHL FLWWDGLQLµ H ´GL DYHU HVWHVR DEXVLYDPHQWH L VXRL SULYLOHJL ILQR D FRPSUHQGHUH DOWUL WLSL GL ODYRUD]LRQH FRPH OH PDLROLFKH ILQLµ FKH HVSRUWDYD SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH D 9HQH]LD631 /·D]LHQGD SURSULR QHOO·HVHUFLWDUH TXHVWL DEXVL VL HUD HVSRVWD DL ULVFKL GHOOD ²²²²²²²² 59
/1 38&&,/ /LQHDPHQWL FLW1 ,G1 ,O SURFHVVR 9HQWXULQL 111FLW1 )1 0(/,6/ 6WRULD GHOOD UDJLRQHULD1 &RQWULEXWR DOOD FRQRVFHQ]D HG LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GHOOH IRQWL SL• VLJQLILFDWLYH GHOOD VWRULD HFRQRPLFD/ %RORJQD 4<831 5; $602/ &DPHUD 'XFDOH/ 3DUWLPHQWL GHOOR 6WDWR/ &RQVLJOLR GL *LXVWL]LD/ ILO]D 6<;1 5< ,O SURFHVVR SHU FRQWUDEEDQGR GL VDOH FKH LPSOLFLWDPHQWH GHVFULYHYD OD PDQLIDWWXUD GL PDMROLFD 'DOODUL GL 6DVVXROR +4::3, VL WURYD LQ $602/ &XULD GL 0RGHQD/ $UFKLYLR *LXGL]LDULR/ (VDPL LQ FRQWUDYYHQ]LRQH FRQ OD )HUPD *HQHUDOH/ YRO1 6:5 +4:9<, H YRO1 6:31 63 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH $JULFROH H FRPPHUFLDOH/ E1 827/ IDVF1 481 5:
<97
/XLJL 3XFFL
FRQFRUUHQ]D FRQ O·HVWHUR H TXHVWR GLPRVWUDYD XQ FHUWR VSLULWR G·LQL]LDWLYD FKH O·DYHYD HVSRVWD D GHL ULVFKL1 (VVD LQIDWWL YHUVR LO 4::3 VL VWDYD ULSUHQGHQ0 GR GD XQ SHULRGR GL GHSUHVVLRQH GXUDQWH LO TXDOH F·HUDQR VWDWL OLFHQ]LDPHQWL H IXJKH GL PDHVWUL H ODYRUDQWL1 /D 'DOODUL YHUVR TXHOO·HSRFD/ LPSLHJDYD XQD YHQWLQD FLUFD GL RSHUDL/ LO ORUR VDODULR HUD SDJDWR LQ GHQDUR H QRQ LQ QDWXUD/ LO FKH ULYHODYD XQ FHUWR OLYHOOR GL HFRQRPLD PRQHWDULD1 6IUXWWDYD OD IRU]D LGUDXOLFD GHO OXRJR/ SDUWLFRODUPHQWH ULFFR GL DFTXH FRUUHQWL H FKH IDFHYD DQGDUH XQ ´PROLQHOOR SHU OD PDFLQD GHOOH YHUQLFLµ/ XQ PRUWDLR HG HUD GRWDWD GD XOWLPR GL XQD IRUQDFH SHU OD FRWWXUD GHL PDQXIDWWL1 1RQ HVLVWHYD XQD GLYLVLRQH GHO ODYRUR LQ VHQVR VPLWKLDQR/ PD L FRPSLWL HUDQR XJXDOPHQWH VFDQGLWL GDOOD QDWXUD VWHVVD GHOOH RSHUD]LRQL QHFHVVDULH1 %LVRJQDYD ´VFDYDU OD WHUUD H SXUJDUODµ/ TXLQGL ´VHWDFFLDUODµ DYHQGR FXUD GL EXWWDUH YLD ´OD IHFFLDµ> VL SURFHGHYD SRL DOO·LPSDVWR FKH VL SDVVDYD DO WRUQLR SHU OD ODYRUD]LRQH D PDQR R WXWW·DO SL• FRQ VWDPSL1 , VLQJROL RSHUDL/ GLYLVL LQ ILVVL H LQ DYYHQWL]L/ QRQ XEELGLYDQR DQFRUD DG XQD YHUD GLVFLSOLQD GL IDEEULFD LQ TXDQWR GLSHQGHYDQR SLXWWRVWR GDL PDHVWUL GHFRUDWRUL FKH HUDQR WUH HG XQR LQ SDUWLFRODUH SURYHQLHQWH GD )DHQ]D/ D ULEDGLUH XQD FRQWLQXLWj WUDGL]LRQDOH H SURIHVVLRQDOH FRQ O·DUHD FHUDPLFD YLFLQD1 3L• FKH GL XQD IDEEULFD LQ VHQVR PRGHUQR/ VL WUDWWDYD GL XQD JURVVD ERWWH0 JD DUWLJLDQDOH/ GRWDWD GL XQD FHUWD SURGX]LRQH GL VHULH1 1RQRVWDQWH TXHVWR H0 VLVWHYD JLj LQ ILHUL OD ILJXUD GHO PDQDJHU DQWH0OLWWHUDP/ EUDFFLR GHVWUR GHO SUR0 SULHWDULR/ FKH RUGLQDYD LO ODYRUR/ WHQHYD L UDSSRUWL FRQ O·HVWHUQR/ FRPSHUDYD OH YHUQLFL/ FRQWDWWDYD L SLWWRUL/ WUDWWDYD FRQ L SUHVWDWRUL/ DYHYD FLRq LQFDULFKL PXOWLSOL H QRQ EHQ GHILQLWL ROWUH FKH D GLSLQJHUH OXL VWHVVR GL ELDQFR OD FHUD0 PLFD JURVVD1 (· GXQTXH PROWR SUREDELOH FKH TXHVWD ILJXUD IRVVH DGGHQWUR DQFKH DL VHJUHWL ´PDQHJJLµ GHOOD FRQGX]LRQH D]LHQGDOH1 ,Q TXHVWR FDVR LO JLXGLFH YROHYD DFFHUWDUH VH LQ FRQVXPL GL VDOH LQGXVWULDOH +D WDULIID LQIHULRUH ULVSHWWR D TXHOOR DOLPHQWDUH, FRUULVSRQGHYDQR DO YHUR RS0 SXUH VH HVVR HUD YHQGXWR VRWWREDQFR SHU OXFUDUQH OD GLIIHUHQ]D1 ,O VDOH LQIDWWL/ FKH GRYHYD HVVHUH ELDQFR H GL SULPD TXDOLWj/ HQWUDYD QHOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHOOH YHUQLFL LQVLHPH DG ´DUHQDµ/ ´WDUVR GL ERWWHµ ´SLRPER H VWDJQRµ/ ´OD TXDO FRPSRVL]LRQH VL PHWWHYD LQ XQD IRUQDFH EHQ PLVFHODWD GHQ0 WUR GHL YDVL H TXDQGR O·DPPDVVR HUD FRWWR VL UHQGHYD SRL LQ SROYHUH H SRVFLD VL FRQYHUWLYD LQ YHUQLFHµ1 /H ´DYDQFHVµ GL FDSLWDOH HUDQR PRGHVWH= TXDOFKH PDFFKLQD LGUDXOLFD FR0
´,O FDSLWDOH GL WUDIILFRµ= DVSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO*HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR
<98
VWUXLWD LQ ORFR/ PROWL XWHQVLOL/ XQ FHUWR DPPRQWDUH GL PDWHULH SULPH H GL VDOD0 UL1 8QD ILJXUD GL SURSULHWDULR/ TXHOOD GL 'DOODUL/ FKH D GLIIHUHQ]D GL TXHOOD GL 9HQWXULQL/ HUD SURQD HG XPLOH GDYDQWL DO SRWHUH/ SLHQD GL WLPRUL ULYHUHQ]LDOL QHL FRQIURQWL GHOOH DXWRULWj H GHL IHUPLHUL641 ,Q XQR VFDWWR G·RUJRJOLR HJOL LQ UHDOWj DYHYD DEER]]DWR XQD GLIHVD ULFRU0 GDQGR FKH/ FRQ OD QXRYD )HUPD +4:9;,/ FKH DYHYD DEXVLYDPHQWH HVWHVR LO ERFFDWLFR DO 6DVVROHVH/ OH FRQGL]LRQL GL ODYRUR HUDQR SHJJLRUDWH LQVLHPH DOOD TXDOLWj GHO VDOH/ PD OD SURWHVWD ILQu Ou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u HXJXDOPHQWH OD VILGD DSHUWD/ O·DSSHOOR DOO·RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD H D TXHOOD LOOXPLQDWD1 3HUFLz GHFL0 VH GL DIIURQWDUH LO SURFHVVR/ FKH VL SURWUDVVH SHU EHQ WUH DQQL GDO ¶:: DOO·;3 FRPH VX XQD VFHQD SROLWLFD/ SHU SRUWDUH DYDQWL H UHQGHUH SXEEOLFD OD VXD YL0 VLRQH ´ERUJKHVHµ1 /D GLIIHUHQ]D HUD FKH PHQWUH 'DOODUL HUD XQD ILJXUD GHO EDVVR FHWR DUULFFKLWR/ VHQ]D FXOWXUD/ VHQ]D DPLFL]LH DOWRORFDWH HG RSHUDYD LQ XQ ULVWUHWWR DPELWR SURYLQFLDOH/ 9HQWXULQL HUD FROWR/ XRPR GL PRQGR/ HUD VWD0 WR PLQLVWUR H FRQVLJOLHUH GHO SULQFLSH/ DYHYD GLHWUR GL Vp XQ·RSLQLRQH/ XQ SDU0 WLWR1 (SSRL/ FRVD DQFRUD SL• LPSRUWDQWH/ OD VXD SURWHVWD DYYHQLYD LQ XQ DOWUR FOLPD SROLWLFR/ TXDVL GLHFL DQQL GRSR O·XVFLWD GHO &RGLFH1
²²²²²²²² 64
/1 38&&,/ ,O SURFHVVR 9HQWXULQL 111FLW1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<9:
$/%(572 5,1$/',
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
41 ,O FDWDVWR 5LFFL IX UHGDWWR WUD LO 4:;9 HG LO 4:<4 VX LQL]LDWLYD GHO GXFD (UFROH ,,, H SUHVH LO QRPH GD /RGRYLFR 5LFFL/ XQR GHL PDJJLRUL ULIRUPDWRUL GHO JDELQHWWR GL JRYHUQR HVWHQVH/ LQFDULFDWR GDO VRYUDQR GL LPSRVWDUH H GLUL0 JHUH L ODYRUL GL HVWLPR1 )XURQR FHQVLWL WXWWL L WHUUHQL H L EHQL VWDELOL VLWXDWL QHO0 OH SLDQXUH H FROOLQH GHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL> ULPDVH LQYHFH HVFOXVD OD PRQWDJQD41 ,O FDWDVWR 5LFFL HQWUz LQ YLJRUH QHO 4:<51 (VVR/ D GLIIHUHQ]D GL DOWUL FDWDVWL UHGDWWL LQ ,WDOLD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ q GHVFULWWLYR H QRQ JHRPHWULFR0SDUWLFHOODUH1 1HL FDWDVWL JHRPHWULFR0SDUWLFHOODUL/ LQIDWWL/ ©q LQGLYLGXDWD RJQL FHOOXOD FRVWLWX0 WLYD GHO SRVVHVVR/ PLVXUDWD H VWLPDWD GLVWLQWDPHQWH SHU XQLWj GL FROWXUD H GH0 VWLQD]LRQH H SHU JUDGR GL SURGXWWLYLWj/ H UDSSUHVHQWDWD GD XQ GLVHJQR QHOOD PDSSD1 /D VWLPD q SHULWDOH5ª1 ²²²²²²²² 4
6XOOD ILJXUD GL /RGRYLFR 5LFFL H VXOOD ORWWD SHU LO FDWDVWR QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FIU1 /1 38&&,/ /RGRYLFR 5LFFL1 'DOO·DUWH GHO EXRQ JRYHUQR DOOD ILQDQ]D PRGHUQD1 5LFHUFKH VXOOD YLWD H O·RSHUD GL /RGRYLFR 5LFFL/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<:41 5 51 =$1*+(5,/ ,O FDWDVWR FRPH IRQWH SHU OD VWRULD GHOOD SURSULHWj WHUULHUD/ LQ ,'1/ &DWDVWL H VWRULD GHOOD SURSULHWj WHUULHUD/ 7RULQR/ (LQDXGL/ 4<;5/ SS1 840851 /D UHDOL]]D]LRQH GL FDWDVWL JHRPHWUL0 FR0SDUWLFHOODUL IX OD SULQFLSDOH QRYLWj PDQLIHVWDWDVL QHO FDPSR GHOOD WHFQLFD FDWDVWDOH LQ ,WDOLD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 (VVL FRQVHQWLURQR XQD PLVXUD]LRQH HG XQD VWLPD GHO YDORUH GL FLDVFXQD SDUWL0 FHOOD GL WHUUHQR PROWR SL• DFFXUDWD ULVSHWWR DL WUDGL]LRQDOL FDWDVWL GHVFULWWLYL +$1 0(66('$*/,$/ ,O FDWDVWR H OD SHUHTXD]LRQH1 5HOD]LRQH SDUODPHQWDUH1 1XRYD HGL]LRQH D FXUD GL /1 0HV0 VHGDJOLD/ %RORJQD/ =DQLFKHOOL/ 4<69,1 ,O SULPR FDWDVWR DG HVVHUH LGHDWR FRPH JHRPHWULFR0 SDUWLFHOODUH IX TXHOOR WHUHVLDQR QHOOD /RPEDUGLD DXVWULDFD/ L ODYRUL SHU OD UHGD]LRQH GHO TXDOH IXURQR DYYLDWL QHO 4:4;1 (VVR/ SHUz/ HQWUz LQ YLJRUH VROR QHO 4:93/ H IX SUHFHGXWR QHOO·DWWLYD]LRQH GDO FDWDVWR GHO 'XFDWR GL 6DYRLD/ FKH/ LQL]LDWR VXO PRGHOOR PLODQHVH QHO 4:5;/ GLYHQQH RSHUDQWH GLHFL DQQL GRSR +51 =$1*+(5,/ /D ORWWD SHU LO FDWDVWR QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ LQ ,'1/ &DWDVWL H VWRULD111 FLW1,1 6XOOD UHDOL]]D]LRQH GHO FDWDVWR WHUHVLDQR LQ /RPEDUGLD/ FIU1 61 =$1,1(//,/ ,O QXRYR FHQVR GHOOR 6WDWR GL 0LODQR GDOO·HGLWWR GHO 4:4; DO 4:96/ 0LODQR/ 9LWD H 3HQVLH0
<9;
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
1HOOD FRPSLOD]LRQH GHO FDWDVWR 5LFFL/ LQYHFH/ QRQ IXURQR UHGDWWL GLVHJQL H PDSSH GHJOL DSSH]]DPHQWL FHQVLWL1 , SRVVHVVL IXURQR VROWDQWR GHVFULWWL/ DQFKH VH O·DSSUH]]DPHQWR GHOOH GHVWLQD]LRQL FROWXUDOL GHL WHUUHQL/ OD GHWHUPLQD]LRQH/ VXOOD EDVH GHOOH UHVH SRWHQ]LDOL GHO IUXPHQWR/ GHOOD ORUR ©IRU]D LQWULQVHFDª H LO FDOFROR GHO YDORUH G·HVWLPR QRQ IXURQR ODVFLDWL DOOH GHQXQFLH GHL SURSULHWDUL/ PD YHQQHUR DIILGDWL DOOH VWLPH GHL SHULWL H GHL IXQ]LRQDUL GHO &RQVLJOLR GL H0 FRQRPLD1 1HO FDWDVWR 5LFFL L EHQL VRQR LQWHVWDWL DO SRVVHVVRUH UHDOH= SLHQR SURSULHWD0 ULR/ HQILWHXWD/ XVXIUXWWXDULR H/ QHL FDVL GL DIILWWDQ]H FKH SUHYHGHVVHUR XQD SHUPDQHQ]D VX IRQGR VXSHULRUH D YHQW·DQQL/ DO ILWWDYROR1 1HL FDVL GL VHSDUD0 ]LRQH IUD GRPLQLR HPLQHQWH H GRPLQLR XWLOH/ SHUWDQWR/ LO FDWDVWR LQWHVWD OD SDUWLWD DOO·XWLOLVWD H QRQ ULSRUWD TXDVL PDL LO QRPH GHO GLUHWWDULR61 51 3UHVVR LO IRQGR (VWLPR H FDWDVWR GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD VRQR VWDWL WURYDWL L UHJLVWUL GL LPSLDQWR GHO FDWDVWR 5LFFL ² FKLDPDWL ©%DVWDUGHOOLª ² SHU 5; GHOOH 66 FRPXQLWj H IHXGL L FXL WHUULWRUL VRQR HQWUDWL D IDU SDUWH GHOO·RGLHUQD SURYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD71 /D VXSHUILFLH FDWDVWDOH FRPSOHVVLYD GHOOH 5; JLXULVGL]LRQL q GL 44:1<8: HWWDUL/ SDUL D EHQ LO <7/8( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FHQVL0 ²²²²²²²² UR/ 4<96 H ,'1 +D FXUD GL,/ /D SURSULHWj IRQGLDULD LQ /RPEDUGLD GDO FDWDVWR WHUHVLDQR DOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD/ 0LODQR/ 9LWD H 3HQVLHUR/ 4<;8/ YROO1 51 *OL DOWUL FDWDVWL JHRPHWULFR0SHUWLFHOODUL UHDOL]]DWL LQ ,WD0 OLD QHO ;9,,, VHFROR IXURQR TXHOOR SHUXJLQR +/1 '$/ 3$1(/ /R 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR H LO PRYLPHQWR ULIRUPDWRUH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<8</ SS1 469 6V1,/ L FDWDVWL *XHUUD]]L H 5LGROIL D ,0 PROD +&1 527(//,/ /D GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOD SURSULHWj WHUULHUD H GHOOH FROWXUH DG ,PROD QHO ;9,, H ;9,,, VHFROR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<99/ SS1 950;:, H LO FDWDVWR %RQFRPSDJQL D %RORJQD +51 =$1*+(5,/ /D SURSULHWj WHUULHUD H OH RULJLQL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR QHO %RORJQHVH1 4:;<04;37/ %RORJQD/ =DQLFKHOOL/ 4<94,1 *HRPHWULFR0SDUWLFHOODUL IXURQR SXUH DOFXQL FDWDVWL UHDOL]]DWL LQ YLD VSHULPHQWDOH GRSR LO 4:;3/ FRPH TXHOOL GL 0RQWHFDWLQL/ &KLXVL H 6LQDOXQJD +*1 %,$*,2/,/ /·DJULFROWXUD H OD SRSROD0 ]LRQH LQ 7RVFDQD DOO·LQL]LR GHOO·2WWRFHQWR= XQ·LQGDJLQH VXO FDWDVWR SDUWLFHOODUH/ 3LVD/ 3DFLQL/ 4<:8/ SS1 80 9,1 6 ,O FDWDVWR/ LQROWUH/ QRQ IRUQLVFH DOFXQD LQIRUPD]LRQH VX TXHO FRPSOHVVR GL SHVL H GL GL0 ULWWL UHDOL FKH/ QHJOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL FRPH QHOOH DOWUH VRFLHWj GHOO·DQWLFR UHJLPH/ JUDYDYDQR VXOOD WHUUD H OLPLWDYDQR OD OLEHUD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHOOD SURSULHWj H GHO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR/ FRPH GHFL0 PH/ FHQVL/ FDQRQL OLYHOODUL/ GLULWWL GL SDVFROR/ GL OHJQDWLFR/ H FRVu YLD1 7 6L WUDWWD GL $JJLXQWD GL *RU]DQR/ $JJLXQWD GL /HYL]]DQR/ &DELDQFD/ &DPSLJOLR/ &DPSR0 JDOOLDQR/ &DUSL/ &DVWHOQXRYR 5DQJRQH/ &DVWHOYHWUR/ )LQDOH/ )LRUDQR/ )RUPLJLQH/ /HYL]]DQR/ 0DJUHWD/ 0DUDQHOOR/ 0LUDQGROD/ 0RGHQD/ 0RQWHJLEELR/ 1LUDQR/ 1RQDQWROD/ 1RYL/ 5DYDULQR/ 5RYHUHWR/ 6DQ &HVDULR/ 6DQ )HOLFH/ 6DVVXROR/ 6SLODPEHUWR/ 6WXIILRQH H 9LJQROD1 3HU OD FRPX0 QLWj GL 0RGHQD VRQR VWDWL UHSHULWL VROR XQGLFL GHL GRGLFL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL/ L TXDOL/ SHUz/ FRSUR0 QR EHQ LO <8( GHO WHUULWRULR FRPXQDOH1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<9<
WD81 /D WDEHOOD 4 PRVWUD FKH DO PRPHQWR GHOO·DWWLYD]LRQH GHO FDWDVWR L SRVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL HUDQR 786 +LO 9/;( GHO WRWDOH, H VL HVWHQGHYDQR VX 4;1463 HWWDUL +LO 48/7( GHO WRWDOH,1 'L FRQYHUVR/ L SRVVHVVL LQWHVWDWL DOOH SHUVRQH ILVLFKH HUDQR LO <6/5( H FRQWUROODYDQR O·;7/9( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FHQVLWD1 , SRVVHGLPHQWL GHJOL HQWL YHGHYDQR XQD QHWWD SUHYDOHQ]D GL TXHOOL HFFOH0 VLDVWLFL/ FKH DQQRYHUDYDQR 744 GLWWH H 471:43 HWWDUL/ SDUL DO 45/8( GHOOD VX0 SHUILFLH FDWDVWDOH FRPSOHVVLYD1 , SRVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL QRQ HUDQR GL0 VWULEXLWL XQLIRUPHPHQWH VXO WHUULWRULR> HVVL WHQGHYDQR D FRQFHQWUDUVL QHOOD ]RQD GHOOD PHGLD HG DOWD SLDQXUD/ SL• IHUWLOH H PHJOLR FROWLYDWD/ H D IDUVL SL• UDUL QHOOH GXH ]RQH PHQR IHOLFL/ OD FROOLQD H OD EDVVD SLDQXUD1 7UDVFXUDELOH HUD LQYHFH O·LQFLGHQ]D GHJOL HQWL ODLFL/ WUD L TXDOL VSLFFDYD O·2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH GL 0RGHQD/ LO FXL SDWULPRQLR HUD SHUz LQ IDVH GL DYDQ]D0 WD OLTXLGD]LRQH91 3DVVDQGR DL SRVVHVVL GHOOH SHUVRQH ILVLFKH/ TXHOOL GHL QRELOL HUDQR 68: +LO 8/7( GHO WRWDOH,/ PD DQQRYHUDYDQR LO 66/<( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH DOOLEUDWD:1 /D QRELOWj GHWHQHYD OD SDUWH SUHYDOHQWH GHOOH WHUUH LQ WUH JLXULVGL]LRQL= 6DVVXROR/ GRYH YL HUD XQD YDVWD WHQXWD GL SURSULHWj GXFDOH/ 5DYDULQR/ IHXGR GHOOD FDVD 5DQJRQH 7HU]L GL 0RGHQD/ H &DELDQFD/ IHXGR GHOOD FDVD 9LOOD GL )HUUDUD1 , SRVVHVVL QRELOLDUL DSSDULYDQR FRQFHQWUDWL VRSUDWWXWWR QHOOD ]RQD GL SLDQXUD> LQ QHVVXQD JLXULVGL]LRQH GL FROOLQD/ LQIDWWL/ L QRELOL GHWHQHYDQR XQD TXRWD GHO0 OD VXSHUILFLH VXSHULRUH DOOD ORUR PHGLD JHQHUDOH1 %HQ O·;:/;( GHOOH GLWWH H LO 83/8( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH DSSDUWHQHYDQR DL SULYDWL ²²²²²²²² 8 6L WUDWWD GL $JJLXQWD GL *RU]DQR/ $JJLXQWD GL /HYL]]DQR/ &DELDQFD/ &DPSLJOLR/ &DPSR0 JDOOLDQR/ &DUSL/ &DVWHOQXRYR 5DQJRQH/ &DVWHOYHWUR/ )LQDOH/ )LRUDQR/ )RUPLJLQH/ /HYL]]DQR/ 0DJUHWD/ 0DUDQHOOR/ 0LUDQGROD/ 0RGHQD/ 0RQWHJLEELR/ 1LUDQR/ 1RQDQWROD/ 1RYL/ 5DYDULQR/ 5RYHUHWR/ 6DQ &HVDULR/ 6DQ )HOLFH/ 6DVVXROR/ 6SLODPEHUWR/ 6WXIILRQH H 9LJQROD1 3HU OD FRPX0 QLWj GL 0RGHQD VRQR VWDWL UHSHULWL VROR XQGLFL GHL GRGLFL UHJLVWUL UHGDWWL/ L TXDOL/ SHUz/ FRSUR0 QR EHQ LO <8( GHO WHUULWRULR FRPXQDOH1 9 /·2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH GL 0RGHQD IX FRVWLWXLWD QHO 4:97 VX LQL]LDWLYD GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ LO TXDOH DYHYD GLVSRVWR OD IXVLRQH LQ TXHVWR HQWH/ SRVWR VRWWR LO GLUHWWR FRQWUROOR GHOO·DXWRULWj VWDWDOH/ GL WXWWH OH RSHUH SLH GL 0RGHQD1 1HOOH PDQL GHOO·2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH VL FRQFHQWUz FRVu XQ SDWULPRQLR IRQGLDULR FRQVLGHUHYROH/ FKH QHJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL IX DOOLYHOODWR R YHQGXWR D SULYDWL +&1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO·DJULFROWXUD PRGHQHVH GDOO·HWj GHOOH ULIRUPH DOOD ILQH GHOOD UHVWDX0 UD]LRQH/ LQ ,'1/ )RVVL H FDYHGDJQH EHQHGLFRQ OH FDPSDJQH/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<;5/ SS1 4<904<<,1 : ,O SURFHGLPHQWR VHJXLWR SHU LGHQWLILFDUH L SRVVLGHQWL QRELOL q LOOXVWUDWR LQ $1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGDQLD WUD DUUHWUDWH]]D H PRGHUQL]]D]LRQH1 /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL GDOOD ILQH GHO ¶:33 DOO·8QLWj QD0 ]LRQDOH/ %RORJQD/ 3LWDJRUD/ 4<<8/ SS1 7907:1
<:3
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
QRQ QRELOL;1 (VVL GHWHQHYDQR XQD TXRWD GHO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR VXSHULRUH DO 83( LQ 4: GHOOH 5; JLXULVGL]LRQL/ PHQWUH QHOOH DOWUH HUDQR VXSHUDWL GDL GXH RUGLQL SULYLOHJLDWL1 /D SUHPLQHQ]D/ VLQ GDO 4:<4/ GHO SRVVHVVR FRQWDGLQR H ERUJKHVH FRQILJXUD XQ DVVHWWR GHO UHJLPH IRQGLDULR FKH FROORFD LO 0RGHQHVH LQ OLQHD FRQ OD SUHFRFH HYROX]LRQH VHWWHFHQWHVFD GHOOD SURSULHWj GHOLQHDWDVL LQ /RPEDUGLD/ PHQWUH OR DOORQWDQD GDO 9HQHWR H GDOOH OHJD]LRQL SRQWLILFLH/ GRYH SUHYDOHYD LO SRVVHVVR QRELOLDUH HG HFFOHVLDVWLFR<1 7DE1 41 3RVVHVVR IRQGLDULR LQ 5; FRPXQLWj H IHXGL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH &DWHJRULH GL SRVVLGHQWL 11 ( +D ( (17,= (FFOHVLDVWLFL 744 9/5 471:43 45/8 2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH 4 3/3 <;9 3/; $VVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D 48 3/5 :95 3/9 &ROOHJL H LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL : 3/4 6:5 3/6 &DPHUD GXFDOH 4 3/3 535 3/5 &RPXQLWj 48 3/5 413;: 3/< $OWUL 6 3/3 44 3/3 3(5621(= 1RELOL 68: 8/7 731369 66/< 1RQ QRELOL 81;76 ;:/; 8<1897 83/8 727$/( 91986 433/3 44:1<8: 433/3 )RQWH= $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ (VWLPR H FDWDVWR/ 8IILFLR FHQWUDOH GHO FHQVR/ &DWDVWR 5LFFL/ 5HJLVWUL ©%DVWDUGHOOLª1
²²²²²²²² ; /D IRQWH FDWDVWDOH QRQ FRQVHQWH/ SXUWURSSR/ GL LQGLYLGXDUH OD SRVL]LRQH VRFLDOH H OD FRQGL]LRQH SURIHVVLRQDOH GHJOL LQWHVWDWDUL SULYDWL QRQ DSSDUWHQHQWL DOO·RUGLQH QRELOLDUH1 /D FRPSRVLWD FDWHJRULD GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL FRPSUHQGHYD ILJXUH DVVDL GLYHUVH WUD ORUR= FRQWD0 GLQL/ QRWDELOL GL FDPSDJQD/ DUWLJLDQL LVFULWWL DOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL FLWWDGLQH/ SURIHVVLRQLVWL +PHGLFL/ QRWDL/ DYYRFDWL/ HFF1,/ PHUFDQWL/ LPSUHQGLWRUL PDQLIDWWXULHUL/ IXQ]LRQDUL SXEEOLFL/ FXUDWL GL FDPSDJQD/ SUHODWL QRQ QRELOL/ H FRVu YLD1 < &RVu/ QHO 4:;8/ O·44/:( GHOOH WHUUH PDQWRYDQH DSSDUWHQHYD DJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ LO 66/8( DL QRELOL H LO 83/5( DL ODLFL QRQ QRELOL +01 9$,1,/ /D GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOD SURSULHWj WHUULHUD H OD VRFLHWj PDQWRYDQD GDO 4:;8 DO 4;78/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<:6/ S1 5:3,> LQ 9HQHWR/ QHO 4:73/ LO 83/<( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH HUD LQ PDQR DL QRELOL/ O·;/<( DJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL H LO 68/:( DL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL +'1 %(/75$0,/ /D SHQHWUD]LRQH HFRQRPLFD GHL YHQH]LDQL LQ WHUUDIHUPD1 )RU]H GL ODYRUR H SURSULHWj IRQGLDULD QHOOH FDPSDJQH YHQHWH GHL VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,,/ 9HQH]LD/ ,VWLWXWR SHU OD FROODERUD0 ]LRQH FXOWXUDOH/ 4<94/ SS1 5550556,> QHOOD SLDQXUD ERORJQHVH/ QHO 4:;</ JOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL GHWHQHYDQR LO 4<( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH/ L QRELOL LO 88( H L QRQ QRELOL LO 53( +51 =$1*+(5,/ /D SURSULHWj WHUULHUD111/ FLW1/ SS1 ;90<4,> D 5DYHQQD/ QHO 4:76/ L GDWL FRUULVSRQGHQWL ULVXOWDYDQR SDUL DO 7:( SHU JOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ DO 57( SHU L QRELOL H DO 5;( SHU L SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL +*1 325,6,1,/ /D SURSULHWj WHUULHUD QHO &RPXQH GL 5DYHQQD GDOOD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9, DL JLRUQL QRVWUL/ 0L0 ODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<96/ S1 68,1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<:4
61 /·DQDOLVL GHOOD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOH SDUWLWH FDWDVWDOL SHU FODVVL GL DPSLH]]D +WDEHOOH 5/ 6/ 7 H 8, FRQVHQWH GL LQGLYLGXDUH WUH WLSL IRQGDPHQWDOL GL SRVVHVVR1 ,O SULPR HUD FRVWLWXLWR GD SLFFROL DSSH]]DPHQWL GL HVWHQVLRQH LQIHULRUH D FLQTXH HWWDUL/ H VSHVVR DQFKH DG XQ VROR HWWDUR/ FRVWLWXLWL SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH GD FKLXVXUH EUDFFLDQWLOL H GD IRQGL GL SURSULHWj GL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL SRYHUL1 )XURQR LQIDWWL FHQVLWL 7153< SRVVHVVL LQIHULRUL D FLQTXH HWWDUL> GL HVVL EHQ 61<63 +LO <6/7(, DSSDUWHQHYDQR D SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL1 4XHVWL SLFFROL DSSH]]D0 PHQWL WHQGHYDQR DG HVVHUH FRQFHQWUDWL QHOOH ]RQH SRVWH DOOH HVWUHPLWj GHO WHU0 ULWRULR FHQVLWR= OD FROOLQD H OD EDVVD SLDQXUD1 Ë HYLGHQWH FKH XQ IRQGR LQIHULR0 UH D FLQTXH HWWDUL EHQ GLIILFLOPHQWH SRWHYD FRQVHQWLUH LO VRVWHQWDPHQWR GL XQD IDPLJOLD FROWLYDWULFH> q TXLQGL LPSUREDELOH FKH IRVVHUR PROWL L SRVVHVVL GL TXHVWH GLPHQVLRQL FRQGRWWL D PH]]DGULD1 /·LSRWHVL SL• SODXVLELOH q FKH VL WUDW0 WDVVH/ QHOOD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL FDVL/ GL RUWL H FKLXVXUH DSSDUWHQHQWL D FDPHUDQ0 WL/ FRVWUHWWL/ SHU LQWHJUDUH LO SURSULR UHGGLWR/ D SUHVWDUH XQD SDUWH GHO SURSULR ODYRUR SUHVVR D]LHQGH DJULFROH DOWUXL R D VYROJHUH DWWLYLWj H[WUD0DJULFROH1 ,QIHULRUL D FLQTXH HWWDUL HUDQR DQFKH 554 GHL 744 SRVVHVVL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 6L WUDWWDYD/ VL q GHWWR/ GL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL SRYHUL/ WUD L TXDOL ULHQWUDYD OD JUDQGH PDJJLRUDQ]D GHL EHQHILFL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ GHOOH FDSSHOODQLH/ GHOOH PDQVLRQHULH/ GHJOL DOWDUL/ GHOOH FRQIUDWHUQLWH/ GHOOH FKLHVH SDUURFFKLDOL H SOHEDQH/ SHU L TXDOL LO SRVVHVVR GL XQ SLFFROR DSSH]]DPHQWR GL WHUUHQR ULXVFLYD D IDWLFD D SURYYH0 GHUH DO VRVWHQWDPHQWR GHL FKLHULFL H DL ELVRJQL GHO FXOWR1 ,O VHFRQGR WLSR GL SRVVHVVR HUD UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDL PHGL DSSH]]DPHQWL FRPSUHVL WUD 43 H 83 HWWDUL/ FKH SHU ROWUH O·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• GL 833 HWWDUL H WUH SL• GL PLOOH431 ²²²²²²²² 43 1RQRVWDQWH OH WHQXWH QRELOLDUL IRVVHUR LQ JHQHUH PROWR HVWHVH/ QRQ YL HUD DOFXQD IDPL0 JOLD FKH GHWHQHVVH YDVWL SRVVHGLPHQWL LQ WXWWH OH SULQFLSDOL ]RQH GHO 0RGHQHVH1 1RELOH HUD LO
<:5
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
$OOR VWHVVR PRGR/ XQ QXPHUR UHODWLYDPHQWH ULVWUHWWR GL 66 HQWL +O·;/7( GHO WRWDOH, GHWHQHYD LO ::/7( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH LQWHVWDWD DJOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL> GL HVVL/ RWWR DYHYDQR SL• GL 833 HWWDUL H GXH SL• GL PLOOH1 6L WUDWWDYD GL TXHOOL FKH DE0 ELDPR GHILQLWR JOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL ©ULFFKLª= FRQYHQWL/ PHQVH FRPXQL H YH0 VFRYLOL/ O·$EED]LD H OD &DWWHGUDOH GL 1RQDQWROD/ FDSLWROL/ FDQRQLFDWL H DUFLGLD0 FRQDWL/ FKH/ QRQRVWDQWH OH PLVXUH DGRWWDWH GD )UDQFHVFR ,,, VXO WHUUHQR JLXUL0 VGL]LRQDOLVWLFR/ FRQWLQXDYDQR D GHWHQHUH YDVWL SDWULPRQL IRQGLDUL441 7DE1 51 3RVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL LQ 5; FRPXQLWj H IHXGL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 SHU FODVVL GL VXSHUILFLH &ODVVL GL 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH VXSHUILFLH +KD, 11 ( +D ( 304 ;4 4</: 6< 3/6 408 473 67/4 6:7 5/8 8043 98 48/; 7:4 6/5 43083 ;6 53/5 41;57 45/7 830433 < 5/5 948 7/5 4330833 58 9/4 71<;: 66/< 833041333 9 4/8 71347 5:/6 2OWUH 5 3/8 516;; 49/5 )RQWH= $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ (VWLPR H FDWDVWR/ 8IILFLR FHQWUDOH GHO FHQVR/ &DWDVWR 5LFFL/ 5HJLVWUL ©%DVWDUGHOOLª1
²²²²²²²² PDJJLRUH SRVVLGHQWH LQ DVVROXWR ULOHYDWR GDO FDWDVWR/ LO PDUFKHVH (PLOLR 0HQDIRJOLR/ FKH SRVVHGHYD 6133; HWWDUL GL WHUUD> L VXRL IRQGL HUDQR SHUz VLWXDWL TXDVL SHU LQWHUR QHO GXFDWR GHOOD 0LUDQGROD1 $OOR VWHVVR PRGR/ LO VHFRQGR PDJJLRUH SRVVLGHQWH QRELOH/ LO FRQWH /HRQHOOR %RQDVL/ DYHYD OH SURSULH WHUUH +413;3 HWWDUL, FRQFHQWUDWH SHU LQWHUR QHO SULQFLSDWR GL &DUSL/ HG LO WHU]R/ OD FRQWHVVD 3DROD 6FXWHOODUL 3DROXFFL +4134; HWWDUL, QHO GXFDWR GHOOD 0LUDQGROD1 'L FRQYHUVR/ L PDJJLRUL SRVVLGHQWL QRELOL GHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD ² L PDUFKHVL /RWDULR $OIRQVR +;:< HWWDUL, H *KHUDUGR 5DQJRQL +953 HWWDUL, H L FRQWL *LDFRPR/ $QQLEDOH H 6LOYLR 6DVVL 1H0 JUHOOL +977 HWWDUL, ² QRQ ULVXOWDYDQR LQWHVWDWDUL GL QHSSXUH XQD SDUWLFHOOD GL WHUUHQR QHO &DUSL0 JLDQR H QHO 0LUDQGROHVH1 3L• YDULDPHQWH GLVWULEXLWL VXO WHUULWRULR HUDQR/ LQYHFH/ L IRQGL GHO PDUFKHVH 6LJLVPRQGR )RVFKLHUL *XDOHQJKL/ LO TXDOH SRVVHGHYD 7;8 HWWDUL QHO GXFDWR GL 0R0 GHQD H 654 HWWDUL QHO SULQFLSDWR GL &DUSL/ PD QHSSXUH XQ SDOPR GL WHUUD QHO GXFDWR GHOOD 0L0 UDQGROD1 1HSSXUH OH SURSULHWj DOORGLDOL GHO 'XFD ² FKH HUD VROR LO VHWWLPR SRVVLGHQWH QRELOH QHOOD JUDGXDWRULD SHU DPSLH]]D GHL IRQGL SRVVHGXWL ² VL GLVFRVWDYDQR GD TXHVWR VFKHPD= HVVH/ LQIDWWL/ SDUL D :;9 HWWDUL/ HUDQR FRQFHQWUDWH SHU LQWHUR QHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD +$1 5,1$/',/ /D 3DGDQLD111/ FLW1/ S1 8;,1 44 6XOOD SROLWLFD JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFD GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ YROWD DG DWWDFFDUH OH HVHQ]LRQL H OH LPPXQLWj ILVFDOL GHO FOHUR H D ULGXUUH O·HVWHQVLRQH GHOOD SURSULHWj HFFOHVLDVWLFD/ FIU1 *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL WUD 5LYROX]LRQH H 5HVWDXUD]LRQH +4:<304;48,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9:1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<:6
7DE1 61 3RVVHVVL GHL QRELOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL LQ 5; FRPXQLWj H IHXGL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 SHU FODVVL GL VXSHUILFLH &ODVVL GL 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH VXSHUILFLH +KD, 11 ( +D ( 304 46 6/9 6 3/3 408 5: :/9 :< 3/5 8043 4< 8/6 475 3/7 43083 457 67/: 6185< ;/; 830433 :9 54/6 81959 47/4 4330833 ;5 56/3 491;:; 75/5 833041333 46 6/9 ;19:4 54/: 2OWUH 6 3/; 81439 45/; )RQWH= $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ (VWLPR H FDWDVWR/ 8IILFLR FHQWUDOH GHO FHQVR/ &DWDVWR 5LFFL/ 5HJLVWUL ©%DVWDUGHOOLª1 7DE1 71 3RVVHVVL GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL LQ 5; FRPXQLWj H IHXGL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 SHU FODVVL GL VXSHUILFLH &ODVVL GL 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH VXSHUILFLH +KD, 11 ( +D ( 304 5145: 69/7 4158: 5/4 408 41;36 63/< 717;: :/8 8043 94< 43/9 71788 :/8 43083 4135; 4:/9 561799 6</7 830433 4;8 6/5 451:87 54/7 4330833 :; 4/6 441795 4</5 833041333 6 3/4 41<43 6/5 2OWUH 3 3/3 3 3/3 )RQWH= ,ELGHP1 7DE1 81 3RVVHVVL IRQGLDUL WRWDOL LQ 5; FRPXQLWj H IHXGL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 SHU FODVVL GL VXSHUILFLH &ODVVL GL 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH VXSHUILFLH +KD, 11 ( +D ( 304 51563 66/8 41635 4/4 408 41<:< 5</: 71<95 7/5 8043 :38 43/9 813;6 7/6 43083 4157: 4;/: 5<147: 57/: 830433 5:5 7/4 4<1454 49/5 4330833 4<4 5/< 671865 5</6 833041333 57 3/7 491649 46/; 2OWUH 8 3/4 :17<7 9/7 )RQWH= ,ELGHP1
<:7
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
71 3UHVVR LO IRQGR (VWLPR H FDWDVWR GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD VRQR GHSRVLWDWL/ ROWUH DL OLEUL GL LPSLDQWR GHO FDWDVWR 5LFFL/ DQFKH L UHJLVWUL GHOOH YROWXUH1 3HU XQGLFL JLXULVGL]LRQL q VWDWR SRVVLELOH UHSHULUH L UHJLVWUL FRQWHQHQWL OH YROWXUH VLQR DO 4;8</ DQQR LQ FXL LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD FHVVz GL HVLVWHUH H IX DQQHVVR DO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD1 3HU TXHVWH XQGLFL JLXULVGL]LRQL45 q VWDWD ULFR0 VWUXLWD OD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR LQ WUH GDWH GLYHUVH= LO PRPHQWR GHOO·LPSLDQWR GHO FDWDVWR/ QHO 4:<4/ LO 64 GLFHPEUH 4;47/ LQ FRLQFLGHQ]D FRQ OD FDGXWD GHO 5HJQR QDSROHRQLFR/ H LO 64 GLFHPEUH 4;8</ DOO·DWWR GHOO·DQQHVVLRQH GHL WHUULWRUL PRGHQHVL DO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD461 /H XQGLFL JLXULVGL]LRQL VL HVWHQGHYDQR QHO 4:<4 VX 591636 HWWDUL +WDE1 9,/ SDUL DO 55/6( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FHQVLWD QHOOH YHQWRWWR FRPXQLWj H IHXGL DQDOL]0 ]DWL QHOOD VH]LRQH 51 , SRVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL LQFOXGHYDQR LO 4:/<( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH GHO FDPSLRQH/ FRQWUR LO 48/7( ULVFRQWUDWR QHO FRPSOHVVR GHOOH YHQWRWWR JLXULVGL]LRQL1 $QFKH QHO FDPSLRQH OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL IRQGL SRVVHGXWL GDJOL HQWL DS0 SDUWHQHYD D TXHOOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ L TXDOL/ FRQ LO :/4( GHOOH GLWWH/ GHWHQHYDQR LO 46( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH/ XQD TXRWD QRQ GLVVLPLOH GD TXHOOD GHOO·LQVLHPH GHL WHUUL0 WRUL PRGHQHVL1 7UD JOL HQWL ODLFL/ O·2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH FRQWUROODYD O·4/7( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH/ JOL HQWL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D OR 3/7(/ L FROOHJL HG LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL OR 3/4( H OH FRPXQLWj ² WUD L SRVVHVVL GHOOH TXDOL LO FDPSLRQH LQFOXGHYD SHU LQWH0 UR OH WHUUH GHOOD 3DUWHFLSDQ]D GL 1RQDQWROD ² LO 6(1 , SRVVHVVL GHOOH SHUVRQH SULYDWH FRSULYDQR LQYHFH O·;5/4( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH GHO FDPSLRQH1 /D TXRWD GHL QRELOL HUD SDUL DO 5;/9(/ ULVSHWWR DO 66/<( ULVFRQ0 WUDWR QHO FRPSOHVVR GHL WHUULWRUL PRGHQHVL1 'L FRQYHUVR/ O·LQFLGHQ]D GHO SRV0 VHVVR GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL VL DWWHVWDYD VXO 86/9( H VXSHUDYD FRVu GL FLUFD WUH SXQWL SHUFHQWXDOL LO GDWR GHOOH YHQWRWWR JLXULVGL]LRQL HVDPLQDWH QHOOD VH]LR0 QH 51
²²²²²²²² 45
6L WUDWWD GL &DPSLJOLR/ &DPSRJDOOLDQR/ )LRUDQR/ )RUPLJLQH/ 0DJUHWD/ 1RQDQWROD/ 5DYDULQR/ 6DQ )HOLFH/ 6SLODPEHUWR/ 6WXIILRQH H 9LJQROD1 46 2FFRUUH RVVHUYDUH FKH/ LQ UHDOWj/ XQD ULFRVWUX]LRQH VLIIDWWD UHVWD VLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH LQ0 GLHWUR ULVSHWWR DOO·HIIHWWLYD HYROX]LRQH GHO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR/ GDWR FKH OH YDULD]LRQL GL SUR0 SULHWj/ R GL SRVVHVVR/ YHQLYDQR GL VROLWR UHJLVWUDWH DO FDWDVWR FRQ XQ QRWHYROH ULWDUGR ULVSHWWR DOOD ORUR HIIHWWXD]LRQH1 7XWWDYLD/ OH IRQWL GLVSRQLELOL QRQ KDQQR FRQVHQWLWR GL SHUYHQLUH DG XQD ULFRVWUX]LRQH SL• DFFXUDWD GL TXHOOD TXL SUHVHQWDWD1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<:8
7DE1 91 3RVVHVVR IRQGLDULR LQ XQ FDPSLRQH GL 44 JLXULVGL]LRQL GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4:<4 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH &DWHJRULH GL SRVVLGHQWL 11 ( +D ( (17,= (FFOHVLDVWLFL 439 :/4 61755 46/3 2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH 4 3/4 696 4/7 $VVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D 6 3/5 <6 3/7 &ROOHJL H LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL 6 3/5 54 3/4 &RPXQLWj 7 3/5 :;6 6/3 3(5621(= 1RELOL 1RQ QRELOL 727$/( )RQWH= ,ELGHP1
447 41733 41974
9/< ;8/6 433/3
:185: 4713<8 591636
5;/9 86/9 433/3
81 , GDWL GHO 4;47 PRVWUDQR LQ SULPR OXRJR XQD GLPLQX]LRQH GHOOD VXSHU0 ILFLH WRWDOH DOOLEUDWD QHL UHJLVWUL GHOOH YROWXUH/ GD 591636 D 531639 HWWDUL +WDE1 :,1 4XHVWD FRQWUD]LRQH q GRYXWD VROR LQ PLQLPD SDUWH DOO·HVFOXVLRQH GDOO·HVWLPR GL WHUUHQL SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH LQVHULWLYL SHU HUURUH R DG HUURUL FRP0 PHVVL QHOOD UHJLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH YROWXUH1 (VVD/ LQIDWWL/ VL FRQFHQWUD TXDVL SHU LQWHUR QHOOH FRPXQLWj GL 6DQ )HOLFH H )RUPLJLQH1 /·LSRWHVL SL• SUREDELOH ² DQFKH VH/ DO PRPHQWR/ QRQ YHULILFDWD ² q FKH/ DOO·DWWR GHO WUDVSRUWR GHOOH UHJL0 VWUD]LRQL FDWDVWDOL GDL OLEUL GL LPSLDQWR D TXHOOL GHOOH YROWXUH ² DYYHQXWR/ SHU TXDVL WXWWH OH FRPXQLWj GHO 0RGHQHVH/ WUD LO 4;36 HG LO 4;37 ² L WHUULWRUL GL DO0 FXQH YLOOH RULJLQDULDPHQWH LQVHULWH LQ TXHOOH GXH FRPXQLWj VLDQR VWDWL VFRUSR0 UDWL H VRWWRSRVWL DG XQD FDWDVWD]LRQH DXWRQRPD1 ,O FRQIURQWR WUD LO 4:<4 HG LO 4;47 HYLGHQ]LD LQQDQ]LWXWWR XQD GUDVWLFD UL0 GX]LRQH GHOOD TXRWD GHOOD VXSHUILFLH GHWHQXWD GDJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ LQ VHJXL0 WR DOOD VRSSUHVVLRQH GL PROWH FRUSRUD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH H DOOD FRQILVFD GHL ORUR EHQL DWWXDWH GDOOH DXWRULWj QDSROHRQLFKH1 *OL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL VFHVHUR GDO :/4( GHOOH GLWWH H 46( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH DO 7/6 H 5/<( ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH1 /H VRSSUHVVLRQL H OH FRQILVFKH GHJOL DQQL IUDQFHVL ULJXDUGDURQR VRSUDWWXWWR JOL HQWL ULFFKL/ TXDOL FRQYHQWL/ PHQVH YHVFRYLOL/ FDSLWROL/ DEED]LH H VHPLQDUL/ PHQ0 WUH PROWL HQWL SRYHUL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH WUD L EHQHILFL H OH FKLHVH SDUURFFKLDOL/ ULXVFLURQR D VDOYDUVL471 ²²²²²²²² 47 /·HOHQFR GHJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL VRSSUHVVL QHO GLSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR q VWDWR SXEEOLFD0 WR GD 2GRDUGR 5RPEDOGL1 ,O SDWULPRQLR IRQGLDULR FRQILVFDWR QHOOH ]RQH GL SLDQXUD H GL FRO0 OLQD VL HVWHQGHYD VX FLUFD 481333 HWWDUL/ FRUULVSRQGHQWL DO 45( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FHQVLWD QHO
<:9
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
7UDVFXUDELOL ULPDVHUR L SRVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL ODLFL/ WUD L TXDOL FRPSDUYHUR LO 'HPDQLR H O·,QWHQGHQ]D GL ILQDQ]D GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR/ PHQWUH VFRPSDUYH O·2SHUD SLD JHQHUDOH GL 0RGHQD/ OH DOLHQD]LRQL GHL FXL IRQGL IXUR0 QR SRUWDWH D WHUPLQH QHO 4:<51 /·LQFLGHQ]D GHL SRVVHVVL QRELOLDUL VL DWWHVWz VXO 56/4( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH/ FRQ XQD GLPLQX]LRQH/ OLHYH PD QRQ WUDVFXUDELOH/ ULVSHWWR DO 5;/9( GHO 4:<41 /·HURVLRQH GHL SRVVHGLPHQWL QRELOLDUL DSSDUH WDQWR SL• VLJQLILFDWLYD VH VL FRQ0 VLGHUD FKH HVSRQHQWL GL TXHVWR RUGLQH DYHYDQR SUHVR SDUWH DWWLYD DOO·DFTXLVWR GHL EHQL GHOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH VRSSUHVVH/ LPSRVVHVVDQGRVL GL ROWUH XQ TXDUWR GHOOD VXSHUILFLH DOLHQDWD481 2FFRUUH WXWWDYLD FRQVLGHUDUH FKH XQD OHJJH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD FLVDOSLQD GHO 59 OXJOLR 4:<: DYHYD GHFUHWDWR O·DEROL]LRQH GH0 JOL LVWLWXWL JLXULGLFL FRQVHUYDWLYL GHOOD SURSULHWj DULVWRFUDWLFD +IHGHFRPPHVVL/ PDJJLRUDVFDWL/ SULPRJHQLWXUH,/ UHQGHQGR LQ WDO PRGR SL• DJHYROH O·HURVLRQH GHO SDWULPRQLR IRQGLDULR GHOOH IDPLJOLH QRELOL GD SDUWH GHL FHWL HPHUJHQWL GHO WHU]R VWDWR491 /D FRQWUD]LRQH GHO SRVVHVVR QRELOLDUH IX OD FRQVHJXHQ]D GL XQ SURFHVVR GLIIHUHQ]LDWR WUD OH YDULH FRPXQLWj GHO FDPSLRQH1 ,QIDWWL/ LQ TXDWWUR GL HVVH O·HVWHQVLRQH GHL SRVVHGLPHQWL GHL QRELOL DXPHQWz/ PHQWUH QHOOH DOWUH VHWWH GLPLQXu1 ,O GDWR SL• VLJQLILFDWLYR q SHUz O·XOWHULRUH DYDQ]DWD GHO SRVVHVVR GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL/ FKH GDO 86/9( EDO]z DO 9</:( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FRPSOHVVLYD1 4XH0 VWD FLUFRVWDQ]D VL VSLHJD FRQ LO UXROR SUHSRQGHUDQWH VYROWR GDJOL HVSRQHQWL GHO WHU]R VWDWR QHOO·DFTXLVWR GHL EHQL FRQILVFDWL DOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH VRSSUHVVH H/ VLD SXUH LQ PLVXUD PLQRUH/ FRQ OH GLIILFROWj HFRQRPLFKH LQ FXL YHQQHUR D WURYDUVL DOFXQH FDVDWH QRELOLDUL/ FRVWUHWWH D FHGHUH XQD SDUWH GHL SURSUL SRVVHGLPHQWL IRQGLDUL DG DFTXLUHQWL SURYHQLHQWL GDJOL VWUDWL LQIHULRUL GHOOD VRFLHWj1 7UD L SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL/ DSSDUH SDUWLFRODUPHQWH FRQVLVWHQWH OD SURSRU]LRQH GHOO·LQFUHPHQWR GHOOH WHUUH SRVVHGXWH GD HVSRQHQWL GHOOD FRPX0 QLWj HEUDLFD1 1HO 4:<4 LO FDPSLRQH LQFOXGHYD VROR WUH GLWWH LQWHVWDWH DG LVUDHOL0 WL/ FKH RFFXSDYDQR :4 HWWDUL/ FRUULVSRQGHQWL DOOR 3/6( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH WRWDOH ²²²²²²²² 4:<4 QHL WHUULWRUL HQWUDWL D IDU SDUWH GHO GLSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDUR +21 520%$/',/ /·HFRQRPLD GHL WHUULWRUL QHL GXFDWL HVWHQVL/ LQ 5HJJLR H L 7HUULWRUL (VWHQVL GDOO·$QWLFR 5HJLPH DOO·(Wj 1DSROHRQLFD/ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR GL 6WXGL/ 4;04<053 PDU]R ¶::/ D FXUD GL 01 %(5(1*2 H 61 520$*12/,/ ,/ 3DUPD/ 3UDWLFKH/ 4<:</ SS1 ::0:;,1 48 ,ELG1/ SS1 :<0;;1 49 *1 &$1'(/252/ 6WRULD GHOO·,WDOLD PRGHUQD/ ,/ /H RULJLQL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR +4:3304;48,/ 6D HG1/ 0LODQR/ )HOWULQHOOL/ 4<;</ S1 55<1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<::
H DOOR 3/8( GL TXHOOD GHWHQXWD GDL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL1 1HO 4;47 JOL LQWHVWDWDUL HEUHL HUDQR VDOLWL D TXDWWRUGLFL H SRVVHGHYDQR ;;4 HWWDUL/ SDUL DO 7/6( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH WRWDOH H DO 9/5( GL TXHOOD GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL1
7DE1 :1 3RVVHVVR IRQGLDULR LQ XQ FDPSLRQH GL 44 FRPXQLWj GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4;47 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH &DWHJRULH GL SRVVLGHQWL 11 ( +D ( (17,= (FFOHVLDVWLFL 8; 7/6 8<3 5/< $VVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D 7 3/6 69 3/5 &ROOHJL H LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL 5 3/4 76 3/5 'HPDQLR GHO 'LS1 GHO 3DQDUR 4 3/4 6: 3/5 ,QWHQGHQ]D GL ILQDQ]D 4 3/4 5 3/3 &RPXQLWj 7 3/6 4< 3/4 3DUWHFLSDQ]D GL 1RQDQWROD 4 3/4 :63 6/9 3(5621(= 1RELOL <4 9/; 719<7 56/4 1RQ QRELOL 414;6 ;;/3 471487 9</: 727$/( 41678 433/3 531639 433/3 )RQWH= $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ (VWLPR H FDWDVWR/ 8IILFLR FHQWUDOH GHO FHQVR/ &DWDVWR 5LFFL/ 5HJLVWUL GHOOH YROWXUH1
91 /D WDEHOOD ; ULSRUWD OD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR QHOOH XQGLFL FRPXQLWj GHO FDPSLRQH DOOD ILQH GHO 4;8<1 5LVSHWWR DO 4;47 VL QRWD/ LQQDQ]L0 WXWWR/ XQ DXPHQWR QRQ WUDVFXUDELOH GHO QXPHUR GHOOH GLWWH LVFULWWH DO FDWDVWR ² GD 41678 D 41834 +.44/8(, ² D WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GL FRPH LO SURFHVVR GL DVFHVD DO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR GL QXRYH OHYH FKH VLQR D TXHO PRPHQWR QH HUDQR ULPDVWH HVFOXVH SURVHJXu DQFKH QHO SHULRGR FRPSUHVR WUD OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH H O·8QLWj QD]LRQDOH1 *OL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL UHFXSHUDURQR OHJJHUPHQWH OH SRVL]LRQL SHUGXWH QHJOL DQQL IUDQFHVL H VDOLURQR GDO 5/< DO 6/6( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH FHQVLWD1 6L WUDWWD/ LQ YHULWj/ GL XQ LQFUHPHQWR DVVDL PRGHVWR/ VH VL FRQVLGHUD FKH LO JRYHUQR UHVWDX0 UDWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 DYHYD RUGLQDWR OD UHVWLWX]LRQH DO FOHUR GHL EHQL FRQIL0
<:;
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
VFDWL GDOOH DXWRULWj QDSROHRQLFKH H ULPDVWL LQYHQGXWL4: H FKH LO FRQFRUGDWR VWLSXODWR QHO 4;74 WUD LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH DYHYD VWDELOLWR O·DEURJD]LRQH GHOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, FKH YLHWDYD GL WHVWDUH D IDYR0 UH GHOOH PDQRPRUWH4;1 /H QXRYH GRQD]LRQL HG LVWLWX]LRQL GL SDWULPRQL HFFOH0 VLDVWLFL IXURQR LQ UHDOWj DVVDL SRFKH H ULJXDUGDURQR TXDVL VHPSUH HVWHQVLRQL GL WHUUHQR LQIHULRUL DOO·HWWDUR1 7UDVFXUDELOL SHUPDQHYDQR L SRVVHVVL GHJOL HQWL GL DVVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D H GHL FROOHJL HG LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL1 $VVDL PRGHVWD HUD SXUH O·LQFLGHQ]D GHL SRV0 VHGLPHQWL GHJOL HQWL VWDWDOL +&DPHUD GXFDOH/ (FRQRPDWR GHOOD &DVD UHDOH H ,Q0 WHQGHQ]D FDPHUDOH, FKH/ SUHVL DVVLHPH/ QRQ VXSHUDYDQR O·4( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH GHO FDPSLRQH1 6WD]LRQDULH ULPDQHYDQR OH TXRWH GHOOH FRPXQLWj H GHOOD 3DUWH0 FLSDQ]D GL 1RQDQWROD/ PHQWUH FRPSDULYD SHU OD SULPD YROWD/ DQFKH VH FRQ XQ SRVVHVVR GL VROL 3/48 HWWDUL/ XQD VRFLHWj LPSUHQGLWULFH= OD FRPSDJQLD FRQFHV0 VLRQDULD GHOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD IHUURYLD GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH4<1 , SRVVHVVL QRELOLDUL UHJLVWUDURQR XQ DXPHQWR LPSHUFHWWLELOH/ GDO 56/4 DO 56/9( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH WRWDOH1 4XHVWD VRVWDQ]LDOH VWD]LRQDULHWj GHL SRVVHVVL QRELOLDUL VL UHJLVWUz QRQRVWDQWH OD FRPSDUVD GL 5;8 HWWDUL GL SURSULHWj DOORGLDOL GHO 'XFD/ DVVHQWL QHO 4;47/ H PDOJUDGR O·DYYHQXWD QRELOLWD]LRQH/ GXUDQWH LO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ GL DOFXQH IDPLJOLH GL SRVVLGHQWL FKH QHO 4;47 ILJXUD0 YDQR WUD L QRQ QRELOL1 ,QILQH/ L SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL DUUHWUDURQR OHJJHUPHQWH +GDO 9</: DO 9:/<( GHO0 OD VXSHUILFLH,/ FRQIHUPDQGRVL SHUz/ DO PRPHQWR GHOO·8QLWj QD]LRQDOH/ FRPH OD FDWHJRULD GL SRVVLGHQWL GL JUDQ OXQJD SUHYDOHQWH1 '·DOWURQGH/ LO ORUR OHJJHUR UHJUHVVR ULVSHWWR DO 4;47 IX GRYXWR HVFOXVLYDPHQWH DO SDVVDJJLR DOO·RUGLQH QRELOLDUH GL TXHO JUXSSR GL IDPLJOLH FXL VL q IDWWR ULIHULPHQWR1 ²²²²²²²² 4: %1 9(5$77,/ /H OHJJL/ LQ $OOD PHPRULD GL )UDQFHVFR ,91 7ULEXWR GHOOD 51 $FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH HG $UWL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4;79/ S1 5471 4; 'RFXPHQWL ULVJXDUGDQWL LO JRYHUQR GHJOL $XVWUR0(VWHQVL LQ 0RGHQD GDO 4;47 DO 4;8< UDFFROWL GD &RPPLVVLRQH DSSRVLWD LVWLWXLWD FRQ 'HFUHWR 54 OXJOLR 4;8< H SXEEOLFDWL SHU RUGLQH GHO 'LWWDWRUH GHOOH 3UR0 YLQFLH 0RGHQHVL/ ,/ 0RGHQD/ =DQLFKHOOL / 4;8</ S1 4381 4< /D FRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD IHUURYLD GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH/ FKH DYUHEEH GRYXWR FROOHJDUH OH OLQHH ORPEDUGR0YHQHWH FRQ TXHOOH WRVFDQH DWWUDYHUVR JOL $SSHQQLQL SDVVDQGR SHU LO 0RGHQHVH/ IX VWDELOLWD GD XQD FRQYHQ]LRQH LQWHUQD]LRQDOH VWLSXODWD LO 4ƒ PDJJLR 4;84 WUD O·$XVWULD/ LO 'XFD0 WR GL 0RGHQD/ LO 'XFDWR GL 3DUPD/ LO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD H OR 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR +01 520$1,/ 6WRULD HFRQRPLFD GHOO·,WDOLD QHO VHFROR ;,;/ %RORJQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<;5/ SS1 4;704;9,1 (V0 VD IX SHUz UHDOL]]DWD VROR GRSR LO UDJJLXQJLPHQWR GHOO·8QLWj QD]LRQDOH +91 =$0$*1,/ )HUURYLH H LQWHJUD]LRQH GHO PHUFDWR QD]LRQDOH QHOO·,WDOLD SRVW0XQLWDULD/ LQ 6WXGL LQ RQRUH GL *LQR %DUELHUL/ ,,,/ 3LVD/ ,SHP/ 4<;6/ S1 4969,1
,O SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR PRGHQHVH GDO VHF1 ;9,,, DO 4;8<
<:<
7DE1 ;1 3RVVHVVR IRQGLDULR LQ XQ FDPSLRQH GL 44 FRPXQLWj GHO 0RGHQHVH QHO 4;8< 'LWWH FDWDVWDOL 6XSHUILFLH &DWHJRULH GL SRVVLGHQWL 11 ( +D ( (17,= (FFOHVLDVWLFL 87 7/6 9:4 6/6 $VVLVWHQ]D H EHQHILFHQ]D ; 3/8 43< 3/8 &ROOHJL H LVWLWXWL HGXFDWLYL 4 3/4 4 3/3 &DPHUD GXFDOH 4 3/4 4: 3/4 (FRQRPDWR GHOOD &DVD UHDOH 4 3/4 44: 3/9 ,QWHQGHQ]D FDPHUDOH 4 3/4 9< 3/6 &RPXQLWj 8 3/6 : 3/4 3DUWHFLSDQ]D GL 1RQDQWROD 4 3/4 :63 6/9 &RPSDJQLD FRQFHVVLRQDULD GHOOD IHUURYLD GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH 4 3/4 3 3/3 3(5621(= 1RELOL ;7 8/9 71:;8 56/9 1RQ QRELOL 41667 ;;/< 461:8; 9:/< 727$/( 41834 433/3 531639 433/3 )RQWH= $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ (VWLPR H FDWDVWR/ 8IILFLR FHQWUDOH GHO FHQVR/ &DWDVWR 5LFFL/ 5HJLVWUL GHOOH YROWXUH1
:1 ,O WUDWWR SL• ULOHYDQWH GHOOH YLFHQGH HVDPLQDWH q GDWR GDO SURFHVVR GL D0 VFHVD DO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR GHL FHWL HPHUJHQWL GHO WHU]R VWDWR D VFDSLWR GHO FOHUR H GHOOD QRELOWj1 /·DYYLR GL TXHVWR SURFHVVR SXz HVVHUH FROORFDWR LQWRUQR DOOD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR H JLj DOO·LQL]LR GHOO·XOWLPR GHFHQQLR GL TXHO VHFROR DYHYD PDUFDWR GHL ULVXOWDWL VLJQLILFDWLYL/ WDQWR FKH L QRQ QRELOL HUDQR JLXQWL D GHWHQHUH SL• GHOOD PHWj GHOOH WHUUH LVFULWWH DO FDWDVWR1 (VVR FRQREEH XQD UDSL0 GD DFFHOHUD]LRQH QHJOL DQQL IUDQFHVL/ IDYRULWR GDOOD FRQILVFD H GDOOD VXFFHVVLYD DOLHQD]LRQH GHL SDWULPRQL GHOOH FRQJUHJD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH VRSSUHVVH H GDOO·DEROL]LRQH GHJOL LVWLWXWL FRQVHUYDWLYL GHOOD SURSULHWj DULVWRFUDWLFD1 $O PR0 PHQWR GHOOD FDGXWD GL 1DSROHRQH/ LO SRVVHVVR GHL SULYDWL QRQ QRELOL VILRUDYD LO :3( GHOOD VXSHUILFLH DOOLEUDWD1 1p OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH FRQVHQWu XQ·LQYHUVLRQH GL WHQGHQ]D= QHO 4;8</ DOO·DWWR GHOO·DQQHVVLRQH GHL WHUULWRUL GHO 'XFDWR GL 0R0 GHQD DO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD/ OD SUHPLQHQ]D GHL SRVVHVVRUL QRQ QRELOL SHUPDQHYD SUHVVRFKp LQDOWHUDWD1 /·DVFHVD DO SRVVHVVR IRQGLDULR GHL QRQ QRELOL IX LO ULVXOWDWR GL FRPSOHVVH VWUDWHJLH HFRQRPLFKH H IDPLOLDUL1 (VVL ILQLURQR SHU FRVWLWXLUH XQ FHWR GL SUR0 SULHWDUL FKH/ DOPHQR VLQR DO FROSR GL PDJOLR LQIHUWR GDOOD FULVL DJUDULD GHJOL XOWLPL GXH GHFHQQL GHO ;,; VHFROR/ QRQ GHYRQR HVVHUH YLVWL FRPH SDUWLFR0
<;3
$OEHUWR 5LQDOGL
ODUPHQWH SURJUHVVLYL RG LQWUDSUHQGHQWL1 1HOOD JHVWLRQH GHL IRQGL GL FXL HUDQR HQWUDWL LQ SRVVHVVR/ OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GL ORUR ULPDVH OHJDWD DOOH SUDWLFKH DJULFROH WUDGL]LRQDOL1 7XWWDYLD/ YL HUDQR DQFKH VRJJHWWL/ VRSUDWWXWWR WUD FRORUR FKH SRVVHGHYDQR GHOOH JUDQGL WHQXWH QHOOD EDVVD SLDQXUD/ GRYH OD ERDULD DYH0 YD VRSSLDQWDWR OD PH]]DGULD/ RULHQWDWL YHUVR XQD JHVWLRQH SL• GLQDPLFD HG LQQRYDWLYD GHL SURSUL SDWULPRQL IRQGLDUL1 6L WUDWWDYD GL XRPLQL G·DIIDUL FKH HUDQR DO WHPSR VWHVVR SURSULHWDUL WHUULHUL HG LPSUHQGLWRUL DJULFROL/ L TXDOL VL LPSHJQDURQR SHU DSSRUWDUH PLJOLRULH DL SURSUL IRQGL H UHQGHUOL SL• SURGXWWLYL/ LQWURGXFHQGR QXRYH H SL• DYDQ]DWH WHFQLFKH GL FROWLYD]LRQH531
²²²²²²²² 53 3HU XQD WUDWWD]LRQH DSSURIRQGLWD GL TXHVWL DVSHWWL/ VL ULPDQGD DOO·LQWHUYHQWR SURQXQFLD0 WR LO 56 QRYHPEUH 4<<8 GDO SURI1 0DUFR &DWWLQL DOOD )DFROWj GL (FRQRPLD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD/ LO FXL WHVWR q ULSRUWDWR LQ ©0RGHQD VWRULDª/ ,9 +4<<9,/ 46/ SS1 5:05;1
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<;4
*,25*,2 %2&&2/$5,
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
$JULFROWXUD (OHPHQWR IRQGDPHQWDOH H SUHPLQHQWH GHOO·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH IX/ SHU VHFROL/ O·DJULFROWXUD/ FKH SHUz YHQQH OXQJDPHQWH IUHQDWD QHO VXR VYLOXSSR GD0 JOL LPSDFFL LQWHUSRVWL GDO VLVWHPD IHXGDOH H GD DOWUL LQDFFHWWDELOL SULYLOHJL GD WHPSR UDGLFDWL LQ GHWHUPLQDWL VHWWRUL GHOOD YLWD FLYLOH TXDOL OD QRELOWj H LO FOHUR1 ,O SULPR WHQWDWLYR GL WHRUL]]DUH OD SURPR]LRQH GL DGHJXDWH ULIRUPH HFR0 QRPLFKH/ FKH SRWHVVHUR LPSULPHUH XQ QXRYR LPSXOVR DOOD SURGX]LRQH HG DL FRPPHUFL/ YHQQH GDO 0XUDWRUL/ LO TXDOH/ JLj QHOOD VXD RSHUD 'HL GLIHWWL GHOOD JLX0 ULVSUXGHQ]D GHQXQFLDYD JOL HIIHWWL SUHJLXGL]LHYROL GHO VLVWHPD IHXGDOH> PD IX VRSUDWWXWWR QHO WUDWWDWR 'HOOD SXEEOLFD IHOLFLWj FKH HVSUHVVH FRQ PDJJLRUH FRQ0 VDSHYROH]]D OH SURSULH LGHH ULIRUPDWULFL QHO FDPSR HFRQRPLFR H VRFLDOH/ DI0 IHUPDQGR FKH L YLQFROL IHXGDOL/ VLD HFFOHVLDVWLFL FKH ODLFL/ FRVWLWXLYDQR LO PDJ0 JLRUH RVWDFROR DOOR VYLOXSSR SURGXWWLYR GHOO·DJULFROWXUD1 ,QROWUH DXVSLFDYD XQD SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFD GL SXEEOLFL LQYHVWLPHQWL FKH IDYRULVVH LO VRUJHUH GL XQ VLVWHPD QXRYR GL FROWLYDUH OH WHUUH/ EDVDWR VXOO·LQWURGX]LRQH GHOOH UHFHQWL VFRSHUWH WHRULFKH GHOO·DJURQRPLD/ JUD]LH DOOH TXDOL OH SLDQWH GLYHQLVVHUR SL• SURGXWWLYH/ OD ORUR PROWLSOLFD]LRQH YHQLVVH IDFLOLWDWD H QXRYH VSHFLH YHQLVVHUR LQWURGRWWH RQGH DOODUJDUH OD YDULHWj GHL SURGRWWL1 ,Q WDO PRGR LO SURJUHVVR GHO VLVWHPD HFRQRPLFR DYUHEEH SRWXWR DIIURQWDUH H PLJOLRUDUH/ PD QRQ UL0 VROYHUH/ LO SUREOHPD GHO SDXSHULVPR WDQWR JUDYH DL VXRL WHPSL H GD OXL WUDWWD0 WR QHOOD VXD RSHUD 'HOOD &DULWj FULVWLDQD1 1RQ DSSURIRQGLUHPR/ LQ TXHVWD VHGH/ LO SHQVLHUR VRFLDOH HG HFRQRPLFR GHO 0XUDWRUL/ PD HUD LQGLVSHQVDELOH XQ VLD SXU PLQLPR FHQQR SHU FRPSUHQ0 GHUH LO VXFFHVVLYR VYLOXSSR GHOO·DUJRPHQWR1
<;5
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
1DWXUDOPHQWH TXHVWH HVRUWD]LRQL PXUDWRULDQH QRQ ULPDVHUR LQDVFROWDWH H/ LQ SURJUHVVR GL WHPSR/ HVHUFLWDURQR L ORUR HIIHWWL D SDUWLUH GDOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR JUD]LH DO JRYHUQR LOOXPLQDWR GHL GXFKL )UDQFHVFR ,,, HG (UFR0 OH ,,, G·(VWH1 9D GHWWR SHUz FKH/ QRQRVWDQWH L PLJOLRUDPHQWL DSSRUWDWL GD SURYYLGH OHJJL QHO VHWWRUH DJULFROR/ QRQ VL JLXQVH D PRGLILFDUH LQ PRGR VHQVLELOH L YLQ0 FROL H OH SUHURJDWLYH IHXGDOL/ FKH VROR QHOOD VXFFHVVLYD HWj QDSROHRQLFD SRWH0 URQR HVVHUH GHFLVDPHQWH GHEHOODWH1 ,QIDWWL TXDQGR O·DUPDWD IUDQFHVH HQWUz LQ 0RGHQD LO 9 RWWREUH 4:<9 H GLHGH YLWD DO FRVLGGHWWR ´&RPLWDWR GL JRYHUQRµ/ FKH VRVWLWXLYD JOL RUJDQL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL SUHFHGHQWL/ XQR GHL VXRL SULPL DWWL IX TXHOOR GL DEROLUH OH JLXULVGL]LRQL IHXGDOL H OD )HUPD JHQHUDOH1 ,Q VHJXLWR OR VWHVVR &RPLWDWR GL JRYHUQR DXWRUL]]z L OLYHOODUL DG DIIUDQFDUH L EHQL UXVWLFL GHJOL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL H GHOOH RSHUH SLH/ PHQWUH YHQLYDQR DEROLWL L PDJJLRUD0 VFKL/ L ILGHFRPPHVVL H OH SULPRJHQLWXUH1 /D VXFFHVVLYD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHOOH FRUSRUD]LRQL UHOLJLRVH H OD YHQGLWD DOO·DVWD GHL EHQL QD]LRQDOL FRQVHQWLURQR XQD UDGLFDOH WUDVIRUPD]LRQH GHOO·DVVHWWR GHOOD SURSULHWj IRQGLDULD FRO SDVVDJ0 JLR GL YDVWL DSSH]]DPHQWL GL WHUUD QHOOH PDQL GHO FHWR ERUJKHVH H PHUFDQWLOH/ FKH GLVSRQHYD GL LQJHQWL FDSLWDOL IRUPDWL FRQ XQ DFFRUWR HVHUFL]LR GHOOD PHU0 FDWXUD H DQFKH GHOO·XVXUD1 , JUDQGL FDPELDPHQWL YHULILFDWLVL QHOOD IRUPD GHOOD SURSULHWj IDYRULURQR XQD SL• DPSLD FLUFROD]LRQH PHUFDQWLOH GHOOD WHUUD/ WXWWDYLD QRQ VL YHULILFDURQR VHQVLELOL FDPELDPHQWL QHOOH IRUPH GL SURGX]LRQH/ SHUFKp OD PH]]DGULD FRQWL0 QXz DG HVVHUH SUHPLQHQWH LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR/ SXU FRQWLQXDQGR D GLIIRQGHUVL OD FRQVDSHYROH]]D FKH HVVD HUD GL RVWDFROR SL• FKH GL YDQWDJJLR DOOR VYLOXSSR GHOO·DJULFROWXUD1 ,Q TXHVWR VWDWR GL FRVH VL PROWLSOLFDURQR JOL VWXGL H OH ULFHU0 FKH WHVH D PLJOLRUDUH H D PRGLILFDUH OH SUDWLFKH WUDGL]LRQDOL JUD]LH DOO·D]LRQH GHOOD ´6RFLHWj $JUDULD GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GHO 3DQDURµ/ IRQGDWD QHO 4;37 LQ DS0 SOLFD]LRQH GL XQD OHJJH QDSROHRQLFD/ PD FKH FRPLQFLz D IXQ]LRQDUH QHO 4;39/ QRQ VROR FRPH RUJDQLVPR GL LQIRUPD]LRQH VFLHQWLILFD/ PD DQFKH FRPH FHQ0 WUR SURSXOVRUH GL DSSDVVLRQDWH GLVFXVVLRQL GL HFRQRPLD/ FKH WURYDURQR OLQID YLWDOH QHO YLYDFH DPELHQWH FXOWXUDOH PRGHQHVH1 , &RQFRUVL EDQGLWL GDOOD 6RFLHWj ULVFRVVHUR XQ JUDQGH VXFFHVVR JUD]LH DOOD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH GL HOHWWL LQJHJQL GDOOH FXL UHOD]LRQL VX VYDULDWL DUJRPHQWL/ FKH PHULWHUHEEHUR XQ DWWHQWR HVDPH GD SDUWH GHJOL VWXGLRVL/ HPHUVH FRPH SUR0 EOHPD SUHPLQHQWH OD QHFHVVLWj GHOO·LQWURGX]LRQH GHOOD SUDWLFD GL XQ UHJRODUH H FRQWLQXR DYYLFHQGDPHQWR QHOOD FROWLYD]LRQH GHOOH WHUUH/ JUD]LH DO TXDOH VL VD0 UHEEH SRWXWR PLJOLRUDUH O·DOOHYDPHQWR GHO EHVWLDPH DWWUDYHUVR LO UDIIRU]D0
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<;6
PHQWR GHOOD SURGX]LRQH IRUDJJHUD FRO FRQWHPSRUDQHR DXPHQWR GHOOD SURGX0 ]LRQH GHO JUDQR1 /·DSSOLFD]LRQH GL TXHVWL SULQFLSL SHUz LQFRQWUDYD RVWDFROL GL YDULD QDWXUD/ IUD L TXDOL/ QRQ XOWLPR/ TXHOOR GHOOD FRQGX]LRQH GHL SRGHUL D PH]]DGULD FKH VL VDUHEEH GRYXWD VRVWLWXLUH FRQ OD ERDULD/ FRVD FKH SHUz WDUGz PROWR D YHULILFDUVL1 0D QRQ SRVVLDPR GLOXQJDUFL/ LQ TXHVWD VHGH/ DG HVDPL0 QDUH D IRQGR WDOH SUREOHPD SXU GL IRQGDPHQWDOH LPSRUWDQ]D/ SHUFKp LO WHP0 SR QRQ FH OR SHUPHWWH1 $JJLXQJLDPR DQFRUD FKH/ QHO VHWWRUH DJULFROR/ LQ SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR/ VL HEEH D UHJLVWUDUH GD QRL XQD FHUWD GHFDGHQ]D QHOOD SURGX]LRQH GHOOD VHWD/ SULPD ILRUHQWLVVLPD/ D FDXVD GHOOH GLIILFROWj FRPPHUFLDOL QDWH GDO FRVLGGHWWR EORFFR FRQWLQHQWDOH H GD XQD JUDYLVVLPD PDODWWLD FKH VL GLIIXVH LQ TXHJOL DQQL QHL JHOVL1 9LFHYHUVD SRVVLDPR UHJLVWUDUH XQD FHUWD HVSDQVLRQH GHOOD FROWLYD0 ]LRQH GHO ULVR/ FKH/ LQ VHJXLWR/ WURYz XOWHULRUL FRQGL]LRQL IDYRUHYROL DOOD SUR0 SULD GLIIXVLRQH1 &DGXWR LO GRPLQLR IUDQFHVH H UHVWDXUDWR LO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH/ L SULPL SURYYHGLPHQWL GHO QXRYR VRYUDQR )UDQFHVFR ,9 IXURQR WXWWL ULYROWL D ULSUL0 VWLQDUH OD VLWXD]LRQH SUHFHGHQWH FRQ O·DEROL]LRQH GHOOH OHJJL QDSROHRQLFKH H TXLQGL FRO ULSULVWLQR GHL ILGHFRPPHVVL/ GHOOH SULPRJHQLWXUH H GHOOH PDQLPRU0 WH/ ULFRQRVFHQGR DQFKH/ DL QRELOL H DOOD FKLHVD/ LO GLULWWR DOO·LQGHQQL]]R GHL EH0 QL FRQILVFDWL1 1HOOR VWHVVR WHPSR VL FHUFDYD GL LQVWDXUDUH XQ FHUWR FRQVHUYD0 WRULVPR QHOOH IRUPH GL FRQGX]LRQH DJUDULD WHQWDQGR GL RVWDFRODUH LO GLIIRQ0 GHUVL GHL QXRYL RULHQWDPHQWL WHFQLFL SURGXWWLYL1 , ULVXOWDWL SHUz IXURQR SLXWWR0 VWR VFDUVL/ DQFKH SHUFKp OR VWHVVR 'XFD/ FKH SRVVHGHYD YDVWH ULVDLH/ WURYDYD QHOOD FROWLYD]LRQH GHO ULVR XQD QRWHYROH IRQWH GL UHGGLWR PHULWHYROH GL HVVHUH PDQWHQXWD1 'XQTXH LO IURQWH FRQVHUYDWRUH LQFRQWUDYD VHPSUH PDJJLRUL R0 VWDFROL D PDQWHQHUH OH SURSULH SRVL]LRQL/ FKH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH QHOOH ]RQH GHOOD EDVVD SLDQXUD/ DQGDYDQR SHUGHQGR TXRWD H/ FRPH VL GHVXPH GDOOD 6WDWLVWLFD *HQHUDOH GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL GHO 5RQFDJOLD/ VL VWDYD GLIIRQGHQGR OD WHQGHQ]D YHU0 VR OD FRQGX]LRQH DJULFROD LQ HFRQRPLD/ PHQWUH O·XVR GHOOD ERDULD VL DQGDYD GLIIRQGHQGR/ VSHFLDOPHQWH QHL IRQGL GL PDJJLRUH HVWHQVLRQH/ D VFDSLWR GHOOD PH]]DGULD1 1DWXUDOPHQWH L GXH PHWRGL GL FRQGX]LRQH DJUDULD FRQWLQXDURQR DG HVVHUH RJJHWWR GL IUHTXHQWL GLVFXVVLRQL DQFKH LQ FDPSR DFFDGHPLFR/ H OR VWHVVR VR0 YUDQR VRVWHQHYD OD SULRULWj GHOOD IRUPD PH]]DGULOH SHU UDJLRQL VTXLVLWDPHQWH SROLWLFKH1 ,QIDWWL HJOL ULWHQHYD FKH L PH]]DGUL IRVVHUR SL• DIIH]LRQDWL DO JR0 YHUQR/ PHQWUH OD ERDULD IDYRULYD O·DXPHQWR GHO SUROHWDULDWR QHOOH FDPSDJQH UHQGHQGR PDOVLFXUH OH SURSULHWj/ FRVD FKH VL GRYHWWH GRORURVDPHQWH FRQVWD0
<;7
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
WDUH TXDQGR PDVVH VHPSUH SL• QXPHURVH GL SUROHWDUL GLVRFFXSDWL/ VSHFLDO0 PHQWH QHL PHVL LQYHUQDOL/ FRPLQFLDURQR DG LQYDGHUH OH FDPSDJQH PHQGLFDQ0 GR H UXEDQGR XQ SR· GRYXQTXH LQFXUDQWL GHOOH PLQDFFH GHOOD IRU]D SXEEOLFD/ FKH QRQ IDFHYD SL• SDXUD1 /·DPSLH]]D GHO IHQRPHQR GLHGH RULJLQH DG XQ DPSLR GLEDWWLWR VXO SDXSH0 ULVPR/ FKH IX RJJHWWR GL GXH FRQFRUVL EDQGLWL QHO 4;7: GDOO·$FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH H $UWL GL 0RGHQD FRQ OR VFRSR GL DQDOL]]DUH OD VLWXD]LRQH H FHUFDUQH L ULPHGL SL• DGDWWL1 7XWWL L FRQFRUUHQWL IXURQR G·DFFRUGR QHOO·LQGLYL0 GXDUH OH FDXVH GHO IHQRPHQR QHOO·DEEDQGRQR GHOOD PH]]DGULD D YDQWDJJLR GHOOD ERDULD/ SHU FXL QXPHURVL ODYRUDWRUL HUDQR VWDWL HVSXOVL GDO SURFHVVR SUR0 GXWWLYR H SULYDWL TXLQGL GL RJQL PH]]R GL VRVWHQWDPHQWR1 , ULPHGL SURSRVWL HUDQR HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH LO JUDGXDOH ULWRUQR DOOD IRUPD GL FRQGX]LRQH PH]]DGULOH H OR VPHPEUDPHQWR GHL JUDQGL IRQGL LQ SLFFROL SRGHUL/ DIILGDQGRQH OD FRQ0 GX]LRQH D IDPLJOLH GL EUDFFLDQWL/ FKH DYUHEEHUR FRVu SRWXWR WURYDUH L PH]]L SHU LO ORUR VRVWHQWDPHQWR1 $QFKH LO 5RQFDJOLD HUD GHOOR VWHVVR DYYLVR H/ QHOOD VXD RSHUD/ FKH SXUH HVSULPHYD XQ SDUHUH XIILFLDOH/ PDQWHQHYD XQD SRVL]LRQH IDYRUHYROH DOOD ERD0 ULD/ VRVWHQHQGR FKH LO IHQRPHQR GHO SDXSHULVPR SRWHYD HVVHUH FRPEDWWXWR/ DQ]LFKp FRQ PH]]L FRDWWLYL/ FRQ O·DXPHQWR GHOOD SURGX]LRQH GD UDJJLXQJHUH DWWUDYHUVR OD GLPLQX]LRQH GHOOD SUHVVLRQH ILVFDOH H OD OLEHUDOL]]D]LRQH GHO FRPPHUFLR GHL SURGRWWL DJULFROL1 ,QROWUH HJOL FRQVLJOLDYD OD PRGHUQL]]D]LRQH GHL PHWRGL GL FROWLYD]LRQH DXPHQWDQGR OH FRQFLPD]LRQL/ VRVWLWXHQGR L YHFFKL VWUXPHQWL LQ XVR FRQ DOWUL SL• PRGHUQL/ HVWHQGHQGR OH ERQLILFKH/ PLJOLRUDQGR JOL DYYLFHQGDPHQWL DJULFROL/ LQWURGXFHQGR QXRYL WLSL GL FROWLYD]LRQL TXDOL LO OLQR H OH SDWDWH H LQFUHPHQWDQGR O·DOOHYDPHQWR GHL EDFKL GD VHWD1 4XHVWL VXJ0 JHULPHQWL IXURQR SUHVL LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GDO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ LO TXDOH/ QHO 4;86/ SUHSDUz XQ SURJHWWR GL OHJJH LQ WDO VHQVR/ SURJHWWR FKH SHUz/ QRQ VDS0 SLDPR SHU TXDOL UDJLRQL/ QRQ YHQQH SURPXOJDWR/ FRVu FKH OD VLWXD]LRQH VL WUD0 VFLQz VWDQFDPHQWH SHU GLYHUVL DQQL DQFRUD/ VHQ]D FKH LQ FDPSR DJULFROR VL PDQLIHVWDVVHUR FDPELDPHQWL GL ULOLHYR Qq DOORUD Qq LQ VHJXLWR/ SHU DOFXQL GH0 FHQQL/ GRSR O·XQLILFD]LRQH LWDOLDQD1 ,QGXVWULD ,O SUHPLQHQWH LQWHUHVVH SHU O·DJULFROWXUD FKH DEELDPR YLVWR DFFHQWXDUVL QHOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD H PDQWHQHUVL HOHYDWR DQFKH GRSR OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ JUD0
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<;8
]LH DOOD SRVVLELOLWj GL UHDOL]]DUH FRVSLFXL JXDGDJQL/ IDYRUu QRWHYROL LQYHVWLPHQ0 WL LQ TXHVWR VHWWRUH VRWWUDHQGR FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH FDSLWDOL DOO·LQGXVWULD/ FKH LPERFFz OD VWUDGD GHO GHFOLQR SHUGHQGR TXHOOD SURVSHULWj FKH/ VSHFLDO0 PHQWH LQ FHUWL VHWWRUL TXDOL OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD VHWD H GHOOD ODQD/ DYHYD JRGXWR QHL VHFROL SUHFHGHQWL1 1q PLJOLRUH HUD OD VLWXD]LRQH QHO VHWWRUH GHOO·DUWL0 JLDQDWR/ DJJUDYDWD XOWHULRUPHQWH GDOO·DEROL]LRQH GHOOH DQWLFKH FRUSRUD]LRQL DG RSHUD GHOOD OHJLVOD]LRQH IUDQFHVH1 &HUWR SDUODUH GL LQGXVWULD QHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH/ FRQ ULIHULPHQWR DL WHPSL GL FXL FL VWLDPR RFFXSDQGR/ q TXDQWR PHQR SUHWHQ]LRVR/ VH SHQVLDPR FKH LQ DOWUH SDUWL GHOO·(XURSD/ VRSUDWWXWWR LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD H LQ )UDQFLD/ HVVD VWDYD DY0 YLDQGRVL YHUVR TXHOOR VWUDRUGLQDULR VYLOXSSR FKH q QRWR FRO QRPH GL ULYROX0 ]LRQH LQGXVWULDOH1 $OOD ILQH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR OH QRVWUH LQGXVWULH WHVVLOL FRVWLWXLYDQR OD SL• LP0 SRUWDQWH DWWLYLWj PDQLIDWWXULHUD/ VSHFLDOPHQWH OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD VHWD/ VWUHW0 WDPHQWH OHJDWD DOOR VYLOXSSDWLVVLPR DOOHYDPHQWR GHO EDFR FKH HUD XQR GHL SURGRWWL SL• UHGGLWL]L GHOOH QRVWUH FDPSDJQH1 ,Q VHJXLWR SHUz HVVD DQGz SUR0 JUHVVLYDPHQWH GHFDGHQGR D FDXVD GHOOD FRQFRUUHQ]D GHOOH SL• SURJUHGLWH LQ0 GXVWULH OLRQHVL H GHJOL RVWDFROL IUDSSRVWL DOOH QRVWUH HVSRUWD]LRQL GDO EORFFR FRQWLQHQWDOH1 1HO 4;39 L ILODWRUL GHO 'LSDUWLPHQWR HUDQR YDOXWDWL LQ 533 XQLWj/ FRQWUR XQ WRWDOH GL 761333 HVLVWHQWL QHOO·DPELWR GHOO·DOORUD 5HJQR G·,WDOLD/ PHQWUH L WHVVLWRUL LPSLHJDWL QHOOH QRVWUH PRGHVWH PDQLIDWWXUH HUDQR 733 VX XQ WRWDOH GL ROWUH 5813331 &HUWR VL WUDWWD GL FLIUH TXDQWR PDL DSSURVVLPDWLYH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH TXHOOD GHL ILODWRUL/ FKH LQ UHDOWj GRYHYDQR HVVHUH PROWR SL• QX0 PHURVL/ PD GLIILFLOPHQWH FRQWUROODELOL/ HVVHQGR OD ILODWXUD XQD DWWLYLWj SUHYD0 OHQWHPHQWH FDVDOLQJD HVHUFLWDWD VSDUVDPHQWH QHOOH FDPSDJQH1 3DULPHQWL LPSRUWDQWH HUD OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD ODQD ORFDOL]]DWD D 0RGHQD QHOOD FRVLGGHWWD ´)DEEULFD GHL SDQQL GL ODQDµ/ LQ YHULWj O·XQLFD DWWLYD/ GXUDQWH LO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH/ OD TXDOH RFFXSDVVH XQ GLVFUHWR QXPHUR GL SHUVRQH/ DQFKH SHUFKp DYHYD DQQHVVD O·µ,PSUHVD JHQHUDOH GHO YHVWLDULR PLOLWDUHµ IRUQLWULFH GHOOH WUXSSH GXFDOL1 $QFK·HVVD SHUz SHUGHWWH PROWR GHOOD VXD LPSRUWDQ]D FRQ O·DYYHQWR GHO JRYHUQR IUDQFHVH SHU UDJLRQL IDFLOPHQWH FRPSUHQVLELOL/ WDQWR FKH/ QHO 4;38/ HVVD GDYD ODYRUR D VROL 433 RSHUDL FRQWUR L 833 LPSLHJDWL QHL WHPSL GL PDJJLRUH SURVSHULWj1 'D QRQ GLPHQWLFDUH LQILQH OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD FDQDSD/ FKH YHQLYD HVHUFL0 WDWD QHOOD &DVD GL ODYRUR IRU]DWR GL 6DOLFHWD 6DQ *LXOLDQR DG RSHUD GHL GHWH0 QXWL H D YDQWDJJLR GHOOD SXEEOLFD DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ PHQWUH GRYHYD HVVHUH PROWR SL• QRWHYROH OD SURGX]LRQH GL WHOH GL FDQDSD H GL OLQR IDEEULFDWH QHOOH
<;9
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
FDVH SULYDWH/ VSHFLDOPHQWH GL FDPSDJQD/ SHU LO IDEELVRJQR IDPLOLDUH H SHU XQ SLFFROR FRPPHUFLR ORFDOH/ FKH QHJOL DQQL GL PDJJLRUH SURVSHULWj VL HUD HVWHVR DQFKH QHO ERORJQHVH1 8Q DOWUR VHWWRUH PDQLIDWWXULHUR GL JUDQGH LPSRUWDQ]D SHU OD QRVWUD HFR0 QRPLD IX TXHOOR GHOOD ODYRUD]LRQH GHL FDSSHOOL GL WUXFLROR/ GL DQWLFD RULJLQH/ HVHUFLWDWD VRSUDWWXWWR QHOOH ]RQH GL &DUSL H GL 0LUDQGROD LQ UHJLPH GL SULYDWL0 YD> HVVD UDJJLXQVH LO FXOPLQH GHOOD VXD SURVSHULWj GXUDQWH LO 6HWWHFHQWR JUD]LH VRSUDWWXWWR DOO·LQWHQVD HVSRUWD]LRQH VXL PHUFDWL LQJOHVL GRYH TXHVWL SURGRWWL HUDQR PROWR DSSUH]]DWL1 'XUDQWH LO GRPLQLR IUDQFHVH TXHVWD LQGXVWULD FRQWL0 QXz D SURVSHUDUH QRQRVWDQWH O·DEROL]LRQH GHOOD SULYDWLYD DQFKH SHUFKp/ LQ UH0 JLPH GL OLEHUWj/ PLVH LQ FRQFRUUHQ]D IUD ORUR L GLYHUVL LPSUHQGLWRUL/ IUD L TXDOL HPHUVH SHU DELOLWj H VSLULWR GL LQL]LDWLYD *LXVHSSH 0HQRWWL/ SDGUH GL &LUR1 3XUWURSSR SHUz DQFKH TXHVWD PDQLIDWWXUD ULVHQWu EHQ SUHVWR JOL HIIHWWL UHVWULW0 WLYL GHO EORFFR FRQWLQHQWDOH SXU VH LQ PLVXUD PHQR VHQVLELOH GL WDQWH DOWUH1 )UD OH DOWUH LQGXVWULH PRGHQHVL GHO SULPR 2WWRFHQWR ULFRUGLDPR DQFKH XQD IRUQDFH SHU OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHO YHWUR/ JHVWLWD D 0RGHQD GDOOD GLWWD 0RQ0 WDQDUL H %HQL]]L/ OD FXL DWWLYLWj DYYHQLYD LQ PRGR VDOWXDULR H L FXL SURSULHWDUL JHVWLYDQR DQFKH XQD FRQFLD GL SHOOL/ FKH HUD OD SL• DFFUHGLWDWD GHOOD SURYLQFLD1 /·RWWLPD TXDOLWj GHL FRUDPL H GHOOH SHOOL GL YLWHOOR FKH XVFLYDQR GD TXHVWD IDEEULFD/ FROORFDWD IXRUL GHOOD FRVLGGHWWD 3RUWD &DVWHOOR/ DYYDORUDQGR XQD WUDGL]LRQH VHFRODUH VHFRQGR OD TXDOH 0RGHQD DYHYD JRGXWR ODUJD IDPD SHU L VXRL FXRL ILQ GDO PHGLRHYR/ IDFHYD Vu FKH OR VPHUFLR QH IRVVH DE0 ERQGDQWLVVLPR/ OLPLWDWDPHQWH DOOD FDSDFLWj SURGXWWLYD GL TXHVWD PDQLIDWWXUD/ FKH RFFXSDYD DSSHQD 6: RSHUDL1 6L ODYRUDYDQR LQIDWWL DQQXDOPHQWH 451333 FRUDPL H 9333 SHOOL GL YLWHOOR1 2OWUH D TXHVWD HVLVWHYDQR D 0RGHQD DOWUH FLQ0 TXH FRQFLH PLQRUL/ FKH ODYRUDYDQR VRSUDWWXWWR SHOOL GL SHFRUD/ DJQHOOR H VL0 PLOL1 8Q FHQWUR LPSRUWDQWH SHU OD SURGX]LRQH GHOOD FHUDPLFD SRL HUD 6DVVXR0 OR/ OD FXL SDVVDWD SURVSHULWj OH DYHYD SHUPHVVR GL GDUH ODYRUR D FHQWLQDLD GL SHUVRQH/ PD/ LQ VHJXLWR/ VL HUD UHJLVWUDWR XQ FHUWR GHFDGLPHQWR DWWHQXDWR SH0 Uz GXUDQWH LO JRYHUQR $XVWUR0(VWHQVH1 6HPSUH D 6DVVXROR VL ODYRUDYDQR DQ0 FKH RJJHWWL GL UDPH PD LQ PLVXUD PROWR OLPLWDWD1 ,QILQH QRQ GLPHQWLFKLDPR WXWWH OH DWWLYLWj WUDVIRUPDWULFL FRQQHVVH FRQ OD SURGX]LRQH DJULFROD/ YDOH D GLUH OD PROLWXUD GHO IUXPHQWR/ LO FDVHLILFLR/ OD GL0 VWLOOD]LRQH GHOO·DOFRRO H OD IDEEULFD]LRQH GHL OLTXRUL/ OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD FHUD H OD IDEEULFD]LRQH GHO VDSRQH1 ,Q TXHVWL FDVL SHUz QRQ VL SXz DVVROXWDPHQWH SDUODUH GL LQGXVWULD/ PD GL PLQXWR H VSDUVR DUWLJLDQDWR/ OD FXL SURGX]LRQH VHU0 YLYD SLFFROLVVLPL EDFLQL GL XWHQ]D1
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<;:
1HJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHO GRPLQLR QDSROHRQLFR LQ ,WDOLD OD VLWXD]LRQH GHOO·HFRQRPLD GHOOD SHQLVROD VL IHFH VHPSUH SL•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·DJULFROWXUD RQGH DWWLUDUH VHPSUH SL• LO IDYRUH SHU LO JRYHUQR GHOOH FODVVL FRQWDGLQH/ QHOOR VWHVVR WHPSR VL FHUFz GL LPSHGLUH FKH LO FRPPHUFLR H OH PDQLIDWWXUH SRWHVVHUR SUHQGHUH LO VRSUDYYHQWR VX GL HVVD/ ULSULVWLQDQGR OH OHJJL UHVWULWWLYH QHL ULJXDUGL GHJOL HEUHL/ SHU VRIIRFDUH LO ORUR VSLULWR G·LQL]LDWLYD H O·DELOLWj FRPPHUFLDOH/ H VXERUGLQDQGR FRVu JOL LQWHUHVVL HFRQR0 PLFL GHO SDHVH DOOH DVSLUD]LRQL SROLWLFKH GHO VRYUDQR/ FRPH DSSDUH FKLDUD0 PHQWH GDOOD SXEEOLFLVWLFD GL LVSLUD]LRQH GXFDOH/ FKH HUD SRL TXDVL OD VROD DG DYHUH SRVVLELOLWj GL GLIIXVLRQH1 1DWXUDOPHQWH UHVWDYD LO SUREOHPD GL DVVLVWHUH OH FODVVL SL• SRYHUH H IUD L SURYYHGLPHQWL SUHVL GDO VRYUDQR D TXHVWR VFRSR q GD FLWDUH O·LVWLWX]LRQH/ QHO 4;48/ GL XQD &DVD GL ODYRUR/ FKH YHQQH DSHUWD D 0RGHQD QHO FRVLGGHWWR $O0 EHUJR $UWL/ PHQWUH XQD DQDORJD VL DSULYD D 5HJJLR1 4XL YHQLYDQR DFFROWH OH SHUVRQH LQGLJHQWL H YHQLYDQR LPSLHJDWH QHOOD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD FDQDSD= FRQ0 FLDWXUD/ ILODWXUD/ GLSDQDWXUD/ WHVVLWXUD H FRUGDJJLR1 ,O QXPHUR GHJOL RFFXSDWL HUD QRWHYROH/ GD 4333 D 4733 DO JLRUQR/ PD / YLVWR FKH O·LQL]LDWLYD HUD LVSLUDWD GD XQR VSLULWR FDULWDWLYR H QRQ VSHFXODWLYR/ DQFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR QRQ VL SXz SDUODUH GL LQGXVWULD VHEEHQH OD TXDQWLWj GL PHUFH SURGRWWD IRVVH FRVSLFXD> H LQIDWWL LO ELODQFLR GL TXHVWD PDQLIDWWXUD ULVXOWz VHPSUH PROWR GHILFLWDULR SHU OR VWDWR VLD D FDXVD GHOOD FRQFRUUHQ]D GHL SUH]]L/ FKH HUDQR PROWR EDVVL SHU DQD0 ORJKL SURGRWWL ODYRUDWL QHOOH IDPLJOLH GL FDPSDJQD QHL ULWDJOL GL WHPSR/ VLD SHU O·LPSHUL]LD GHL ODYRUDWRUL/ L TXDOL YHQLYDQR DFFROWL SULYL GL TXDOVLDVL FDSDFLWj LQ TXHVWR ODYRUR/ FKH GRYHYD HVVHUH ORUR LQVHJQDWR FRQ GLVSHQGLR GL WHPSR H VFLXSLR GL PDWHULDOL1 6HEEHQH LO 'XFD IRVVH FRQWUDULR DG RJQL PRQRSROLR SULYDWR/ FLz QRQ JOL LPSHGu GL DPPHWWHUH LO PRQRSROLR GL VWDWR VX WDOXQL JHQHUL H VXOOD ORUR SUR0 GX]LRQH> FRVu QDFTXHUR DOFXQH LQGXVWULH GL VWDWR/ FRPH OD )DEEULFD GHL SDQQL QHOOD &DVD GL SHQD GL 6DOLFHWD VDQ *LXOLDQR/ FKH DEELDPR JLj ULFRUGDWR QHOOH VXH RULJLQL H QHO VXR GHFDGHUH GXUDQWH LO GRPLQLR QDSROHRQLFR H FKH RUD YH0
<;;
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
QLYD ULSRUWDWD D QXRYD YLWD/ H DOWUH FKH HUDQR FRQVHUYDWH LQ IRUPD GL PRQR0 SROLR D YDQWDJJLR GHO JRYHUQR/ PD FRO VLVWHPD GHOO·DSSDOWR/ FRPH OD IDEEULFD GHL WDEDFFKL H OD FRQFLD GHOOH SHOOL/ FKH SRVVRQR HVVHUH FRQVLGHUDWH LQGXVWULH GL XQD FHUWD HQWLWj1 5LPDQHYD OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOD VHWD/ GL DQWLFD WUDGL]LRQH/ PD FKH FRQWL0 QXDYD DG HVVHUH LQ XQR VWDWR GL HVWUHPD GHFDGHQ]D SHU UDJLRQL GL PHUFDWR H SHU OD PDQFDQ]D GL LQL]LDWLYH FKH QRQ WURYDYDQR DSSRJJLR QHOOR VWDWR1 9D EHQVu VHJQDODWR LO FRUDJJLRVR WHQWDWLYR GL &LUR 0HQRWWL/ FKH QHO 4;56 LPSLDQ0 Wz XQD PRGHUQD ILODQGD D 6DOLFHWR 3DQDUR/ GRWDQGROD GHOOH SULPH PDFFKLQH D YDSRUH H VXVFLWDQGR O·LQWHUHVVH GHO 'XFD> PD VL WUDWWz GL XQ HSLVRGLR GL EUH0 YLVVLPD GXUDWD/ SHUFKp DSSHQD GXH DQQL GRSR OR VWHVVR 0HQRWWL WUDVIRUPDYD OD IDEEULFD LQ XQD GLVWLOOHULD GL DOFRRO1 $ FRPSOHWDUH LO PRGHVWR TXDGUR GHOOD VLWXD]LRQH GHOO·LQGXVWULD PRGHQHVH LQ SHULRGR GXFDOH GREELDPR ULFRUGDUH XQD FHUWD ULSUHVD GHOOD PDQLIDWWXUD GHO WUXFLROR/ VHPSUH DG RSHUD GL *LXVHSSH 0HQRWWL/ DQFK·HVVD JXDUGDWD FRQ XQ FHUWR LQWHUHVVH GDO VRYUDQR/ FKH SHUz QHJz VHPSUH OD FRQFHVVLRQH GL TXHL SUL0 YLOHJL GL SULYDWLYD GL FXL HVVD LQ SDVVDWR DYHYD JRGXWR1 3HU WXWWR LO WHPSR GHO UHJQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 QRQ SRVVHGLDPR QRWL]LH SL• GHWWDJOLDWH FLUFD OD VLWXD]LRQH GHOO·DWWLYLWj PDQLIDWWXULHUD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ DQFKH SHUFKp LO VRYUDQR QRQ VL SUHRFFXSz PDL GL FKLHGHUH DL VXRL PLQLVWUL XQ TXDGUR FRPSOHWR GL HVVD1 (·VROR GRSR O·DYYHQWR DO WURQR GL )UDQ0 FHVFR 9/ LO TXDOH HEEH LO PHULWR GL IRQGDUH XQ 8IILFLR GL VWDWLVWLFD/ UHWWR GDO FRQVLJOLHUH &DUOR 5RQFDJOLD/ FKH SRVVLDPR GLVSRUUH GL QRWL]LH FRPSOHWH JUD0 ]LH DG XQD WDEHOOD GHWWDJOLDWD GHJOL ´2SLILFL H PDQLIDWWXUH GHO 'XFDWRµ ULIHULWD DOO·DQQR 4;831 ,Q YHULWj DQFKH GDOOD OHWWXUD GL TXHVWD WDEHOOD QRQ ULOHYLDPR JUDQGL QRYLWj ULVSHWWR D TXDQWR JLj FL HUD QRWR/ H VHEEHQH OD VLWXD]LRQH IRVVH XQ SR· PLJOLRUDWD QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL/ QRQ VL SXz FHUWR GLUH FKH D 0RGHQD/ DOOD PHWj GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ VLDQR ULVFRQWUDELOL L VLQWRPL GL DOFXQ ULVYHJOLR LQGXVWULD0 OH/ SHUFKp LQIDWWL TXL GD QRL OH PDQLIDWWXUH FRQWLQXDURQR D PDQWHQHUH TXHO ORUR FDUDWWHUH IUDPPHQWDULR H IDPLOLDUH FKH DYHYDQR DQFKH PH]]R VHFROR SULPD/ PDQWHQHQGRVL SL• R PHQR VWUHWWDPHQWH OHJDWH DOO·HFRQRPLD DJULFROD= FRVu QRWLDPR/ DG HVHPSLR/ FKH HVLVWHYDQR DOORUD/ QHOOD QRVWUD SURYLQFLD/ EHQ 59: PROLQL/ 7: FDVFLQH/ 464 EROOLWRUH RVVLD GLVWLOOHULH G·DOFRRO/ 75 IUDQWRL/ PD VL WUDWWDYD VHPSUH GL SLFFROLVVLPH D]LHQGH GL FDUDWWHUH IDPLOLDUH/ FLDVFXQD GHO0 OH TXDOL RFFXSDYD SRFKLVVLPL RSHUDL1 8Q FHQQR SDUWLFRODUH PHULWD LQYHFH O·LQGXVWULD GHO WUXFLROR/ FKH DEELDPR GHWWR LQ IDVH GL ULSUHVD JLj GD GLYHUVL DQQL/ LQIDWWL HVVD/ QHJOL DQQL FLQTXDQWD/
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<;<
UDJJLXQVH XQ QXRYR VSOHQGRUH/ JUD]LH DOOD ULFRQTXLVWD GHL PHUFDWL LQJOHVL/ DL TXDOL VL DJJLXQVHUR TXHOOL GHOOH ORQWDQH $PHULFKH1 ,Q HVVD HUDQR DOORUD RFFX0 SDWL 4633 RSHUDL GLVWULEXLWL LQ VROH VHWWH D]LHQGH1 &RVu SXUH DYHYD ULDFTXLVWDWR LPSRUWDQ]D O·LQGXVWULD GHOOD VHWD/ FKH RFFXSDYD <6: RSHUDL LQ 5: ILODQGH/ PHQWUH DOWUL 94: HUDQR RFFXSDWL LQ 8; WHOHULH1 'REELDPR ULFRQRVFHUH FKH )UDQFHVFR 9 QRQ UHVWz VRUGR DL FRQVLJOL GHJOL XRPLQL SL• OXQJLPLUDQWL H FDSDFL GHOOR VWDWR/ TXDOL HUDQR LO 5RQFDJOLD/ LO FRQWH /XLJL 6RUPDQL 0RUHWWL/ LO JLXULVWD )RUWXQDWR &DYD]]RQL 3HGHU]LQL H DOWUL/ FKH VROOHFLWDYDQR SURYYHGLPHQWL DWWL D ULVROOHYDUH OH VRUWL GHOO·HFRQRPLD GHOOR VWD0 WR1 /D OHJD GRJDQDOH VWLSXODWD QHO 4;86 FRQ O·$XVWULD H 3DUPD DSSRUWz QRQ SRFKL YDQWDJJL DOOH QRVWUH HVSRUWD]LRQL GL SURGRWWL DJULFROL/ PD VH FLz ´GLPL0 QXu OD QRVWUD PLVHULD/ QRQ DXPHQWz OD QRVWUD ULFFKH]]Dµ/ OD TXDOH/ VHFRQGR LO 6RUPDQL 0RUHWWL GRYHYD HVVHUH ULFHUFDWD/ ROWUH FKH LQ XQD FXOWXUD SL• LQWHQVL0 YD GHO VXROR/ QHOOD FUHD]LRQH GL QXRYH H PRGHUQH LQGXVWULH/ FKH SRWHVVHUR VYLQFRODUFL GDOOD QHFHVVLWj GL LPSRUWDUH GDOO·HVWHUR PROWL PDQXIDWWL1 4XHVWD IRUWH LQGXVWULD/ QHOOH WHUUH GHO GXFDWR (VWHQVH/ QRQ QDFTXH Qq DOORUD Qq SRL SHU PROWL DQQL/ WXWWDYLD q LQWHUHVVDQWH QRWDUH FKH/ QHO GHFHQQLR 4;8304;93/ FL IX XQ DJLWDUVL GL QXRYH LGHH H LO SURSRUVL GL QXRYH LQL]LDWLYH/ FKH UHVWDURQR EHQVu TXDVL VHPSUH DOOR VWDWR GL SURJHWWR/ PD WXWWDYLD VRQR LQGLFH GHL WHPSL QXRYL FKH VL IDFHYDQR VHQWLUH DQFKH QHL QRVWUL DQJXVWL FRQILQL1 5HDOL]]DWD O·XQLWj G·,WDOLD/ LQ XQ UDSSRUWR GHOO·8IILFLR GL VWDWLVWLFD GHO VHW0 WHPEUH 4;94/ VL OHJJH FKH OD 3URYLQFLH GL 0RGHQD QRQ DYHYD FKH ´SRFKH H LQVLJQLILFDQWL LPSUHVH LQGXVWULDOLµ H LQROWUH FKH ´O·DJULFROWXUD VWHVVD QRQ KD IDWWR FKH OHQWL SURJUHVVL1µ ´'·DOWUD SDUWH 0 FRQWLQXD OR VWHVVR UDSSRUWR 0 LO UH0 JLPH FKH WHQQH TXHVWL SDHVL GDO 4;47 DO 4;8</ VDFULILFDQGR WXWWR DOO·LQGXVWULD WHGHVFD SHVz FRQ DVVXUGL VLVWHPL VXOOH LQGXVWULH FKH DYHYDQR H OH DQQLHQWz/ FRPH SHU HVHPSLR DYYHQQH SHU OH IDEEULFKH GL SDQQL/ GL YHOL H OH ILODQGH GD VHWD1µ &RPPHUFLR 8QD VLWXD]LRQH DQDORJD VL SXz QRWDUH SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD LO FRPPHUFLR GRYXWD DOO·HVLJXLWj GHOOH LQGXVWULH H DOOD PDQFDQ]D GL FDSLWDOL/ DQFKH VH VL SXz UHJLVWUDUH/ LQ SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR/ XQD QRWHYROH DWWLYLWj QHOO·HVSRUWD]LRQH YHUVR L PHUFDWL GHJOL VWDWL OLPLWURIL GL WDOXQL SURGRWWL DJULFROL H GL EHVWLDPH/ JUD]LH DOOD WDULIID GD]LDULD GHO 55 VHWWHPEUH 4;36/ FKH DYHYD VWDELOLWR OD OLEHUD
<<3
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
FLUFROD]LRQH GHOOH PHUFL DOO·LQWHUQR GHO 5HJQR ,WDOLFR1 0D QRQ GLPHQWLFKLDPR FKH OD SROLWLFD GL 1DSROHRQH HUD GL WHQGHQ]H IRQGDPHQWDOPHQWH SURWH0 ]LRQLVWLFKH SHU FXL L GHFUHWL VXFFHVVLYL IXURQR RULHQWDWL DG RVWDFRODUH L WUDIILFL FRQ O·,QJKLOWHUUD ILQR D SURLELUOL DVVROXWDPHQWH QHO 4;39/ FRQ JUDYH GDQQR SHU OH QRVWUH HVSRUWD]LRQL GL VHWD H GL FDSSHOOL GL WUXFLROR ILQR DOORUD ILRUHQWL H GLUHWWL DSSXQWR YHUVR LO PHUFDWR GL /RQGUD1 $FFDQWR D TXHVWL DVSHWWL QHJDWLYL SHUz SRVVLDPR UHJLVWUDUH DQFKH WDOXQL IDWWL SRVLWLYL DVFULYLELOL DOO·RSHUD GL 1DSROHRQH LQ FDPSR FRPPHUFLDOH/ H FLRq O·LPSXOVR GD OXL GDWR DOOD FRVWUX]LRQH GL QXRYH VWUDGH H DO PLJOLRUDPHQWR GL TXHOOH HVLVWHQWL/ PD FRQ ILQL VRSUDWWXWWR VWUDWHJLFL H DPPLQLVWUDWLYL/ FKH WXWWD0 YLD QRQ PDQFDURQR GL LQIOXLUH SRVLWLYDPHQWH VXOOR VYLOXSSR FRPPHUFLDOH1 ,QROWUH YD ULFRUGDWD O·LVWLWX]LRQH/ D 0RGHQD/ GHOOD &DPHUD GL FRPPHUFLR FRQ DQQHVVR 7ULEXQDOH GL FRPPHUFLR H OD FUHD]LRQH GL XQ HQWUHS{W UHDOH/ RVVLD GL XQ GHSRVLWR SHU OH PHUFL SURYHQLHQWL GDOO·HVWHUR/ OH TXDOL/ LQ DWWHVD GL HVVHUH WUDVIHULWH LQ DOWUL OXRJKL/ JRGHYDQR GHOOD IUDQFKLJLD GRJDQDOH1 /D UDJLRQH SHU FXL 0RGHQD IX LQ WDO PRGR IDYRULWD q GD ULFHUFDUH QHO IDWWR FKH GD HVVD DYHYD RULJLQH OD JUDQGH VWUDGD SLVWRLHVH/ OXQJR OD TXDOH VL VYROJHYDQR L WUDIILFL GLUHWWL DO SRUWR GL /LYRUQR/ IDFHQGROD SUHIHULUH D TXHOOD FKH GD %RORJQD UDJJLXQJHYD OR VWHVVR SRUWR SDVVDQGR SHU )LUHQ]H/ JUD]LH DOOD PDJJLRUH FHOHULWj H FRPRGL0 Wj GL WUDVSRUWR1 /D UHVWDXUD]LRQH HVWHQVH GHO 4;47 VHJQz XQ SDVVR LQGLHWUR DQFKH LQ FDP0 SR FRPPHUFLDOH D FDXVD GHJOL LQQXPHUHYROL YLQFROL SRVWL GDO VRYUDQR DOO·D]LRQH GHOOD FODVVH ERUJKHVH FKH VL HUD YHQXWD IRUPDQGR QHO FOLPD GL PDJ0 JLRUH OLEHUWj RIIHUWR GDO JRYHUQR IUDQFHVH1 7XWWDYLD QRQ YD GLPHQWLFDWR FKH OR VSLULWR SDWHUQDOLVWLFR/ DO TXDOH/ FRPH VDSSLDPR/ VL LVSLUDYD LO JRYHUQR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9/ GLHGH RULJLQH D JHQHURVL SURYYHGLPHQWL/ SDUWLFRODUPHQWH GXUDQWH OD JUDYH FDUHVWLD FKH VL YHULILFz QHO GXFDWR IUD LO 4;48 H LO 4;4:/ SURY0 YHGLPHQWL FKH WHQGHYDQR D IDYRULUH O·LPSRUWD]LRQH GL PHUFL GL XVR FRPXQH SHU PH]]R GHOOD GLPLQX]LRQH GHL GD]L GL LQJUHVVR1 8QD DQDORJD OLQHD GL FRQGRWWD IX WHQXWD GDO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ FKH/ JUD0 ]LH DOOD VXD PDJJLRUH ODUJKH]]D GL YHGXWH/ DGRWWz LPSRUWDQWL SURYYHGLPHQWL YROWL D IDYRULUH LO FRPPHUFLR GHOOR 6WDWR D YDQWDJJLR VRSUDWWXWWR GHO SRSROR/ FRPH O·DGR]LRQH GHO VLVWHPD PHWULFR GHFLPDOH +4;86,/ OD FRQYHQ]LRQH VWLSX0 ODWD FRO JRYHUQR DXVWULDFR SHU OD FRVWUX]LRQH GL XQD OLQHD WHOHJUDILFD DWWUDYHU0 VR LO WHUULWRULR PRGHQHVH/ FROOHJDWD SRL FRQ OH UHWL WRVFDQD/ SRQWLILFLD H VDUGD/ O·LQWURGX]LRQH GHL IUDQFREROOL QHO VLVWHPD SRVWDOH +4;85,/ O·DGHVLRQH DO SUR0 JHWWR SHU OD FRVWUX]LRQH GL XQD IHUURYLD FKH FROOHJDVVH LO /RPEDUGR 9HQHWR
/·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH
<<4
DOOD 7RVFDQD SDVVDQGR DWWUDYHUVR 3DUPD/ 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR/ LQDX0 JXUDWD SHUz VROR GRSR OD SDUWHQ]D GHO 'XFD QHO 4;8<1 3XUWURSSR OH YLFHQGH SROLWLFKH H PLOLWDUL JOL LPSHGLURQR GL SURPXOJDUH XQ &RGLFH GL FRPPHUFLR/ LQ DYDQ]DWD IDVH GL SUHSDUD]LRQH/ FRVu FRPH QRQ SRWp HVVHUH UHDOL]]DWR LO SUR0 JHWWR GL EDWWHUH PRQHWD VHFRQGR LO VLVWHPD PHWULFR GHFLPDOH/ FKH DYUHEEH GRYXWR SRUUH ULPHGLR DO JUDQGLVVLPR GLVRUGLQH PRQHWDULR HVLVWHQWH QHO 'X0 FDWR1 4XHVWR GLVRUGLQH/ DFFRPSDJQDWR GD XQ·DOWUHWWDQWR JUDYH FDUHQ]D GL FD0 SLWDOL/ IDFHYD VHQWLUH OD QHFHVVLWj GL XQ LVWLWXWR GL FUHGLWR/ FKH VDUHEEH VWDWR GL YDOLGR DLXWR DOO·LQGXVWULD H DO FRPPHUFLR H DYUHEEH SRWXWR FRPEDWWHUH HIILFD0 FHPHQWH O·XVXUD SUHGRPLQDQWH1 1DVFHYD EHQVu D &DUSL/ QHO 4;76/ OD FDVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR/ VHJXLWD D EUHYH GLVWDQ]D GL WHPSR GD TXHOOD GL 0RGHQD +4;79,/ PD VL WUDWWDYD GL LVWLWX]LRQL GL FDUDWWHUH VRSUDWWXWWR SUHYLGHQ]LDOH/ IRQGDWH DO0 OR VFRSR GL IDYRULUH LO ULVSDUPLR HG DLXWDUH VSHFLDOPHQWH JOL RSHUDL H L FRQWD0 GLQL/ PHQWUH OD ERUJKHVLD QRQ QH VHQWLYD FKH LQ PLQLPD SDUWH O·XWLOLWj1 $QGz LQYHFH D EXRQ ILQH OD VWLSXOD]LRQH/ QHO 4;85/ GHO WUDWWDWR GHOOD /HJD GRJDQDOH $XVWUR0HVWHQVH0SDUPLJLDQD/ SURJHWWDWR ILQ GDO 4;79/ JUD]LH DOOD TXD0 OH DL SURGRWWL DJULFROL GHL GXFDWL HPLOLDQL VL DSULYDQR L YDVWL PHUFDWL GHO /RP0 EDUGR 9HQHWR H GL WXWWR O·LPSHUR DVEXUJLFR FRQ VHQVLELOLVVLPR YDQWDJJLR SHU L SURSULHWDUL WHUULHUL/ L TXDOL YLGHUR VDOLUH UDSLGDPHQWH LO YDORUH GHL IRQGL LQ UDJLRQH GHOO·DXPHQWDUH GHOOH ORUR UHQGLWH1 &Lz FRQVHQWu GL LQWUDSUHQGHUH FRQ0 VLVWHQWL RSHUH GL PLJOLRUDPHQWR IRQGLDULR IDYRUHQGR TXLQGL LO ODYRUR GHJOL RSHUDL/ GL FXL VL YHULILFz JUDQGH ULFKLHVWD FRQ FRQVHJXHQWH DXPHQWR GHL VDODUL1 4XHVWL VRQR L SULQFLSDOL DVSHWWL GHOO·HFRQRPLD PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR FKH DEELDPR FRQVLGHUDWR/ PD q FKLDUR FKH O·DUJRPHQWR PHULWHUHEEH XQD EHQ SL• DPSLD WUDWWD]LRQH H XOWHULRUL ULFHUFKH SHU SRWHU FRJOLHUH PHJOLR H SL• DSSUR0 IRQGLWDPHQWH WXWWL TXHL IHQRPHQL FKH DG HVVD VRQR FROOHJDWL H FKH DQFRUD QRQ VRQR VWDWL DGHJXDWDPHQWH VWXGLDWL1 1RWD %LEOLRJUDILFD /D ELEOLRJUDILD VXOOD VWRULD HFRQRPLFR0VRFLDOH GHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD QHO SHULRGR SUHVR TXL LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH q DVVDL VFDUVD H VX GL HVVD FLWLDPR DQ]LWXWWR GXH VWXGL GL FDUDWWHUH FRP0 SOHVVLYR/ TXHOOR GL &1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO·DJULFROWXUD PRGHQHVH GDOO·HWj GHOOH ULIRUPH DOOD ILQH GHOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH H TXHOOR GL *1 %2&&2/$5,/ $VSHWWL GHOO·LQGXVWULD H GHO FRPPHUFLR D 0RGHQD GDOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD DO 4;8</ HQWUDPEL SXEEOLFDWL QHO YROXPH $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6RF1 7LS1 (GLW1 0RGHQHVH/ 4<96> QHOOR VWHVVR YROXPH VL YHGD DQFKH= 31 '20(1,&+,1,/ 6XOO·DWWLYLWj EDQFDULD QHO 0RGHQHVH QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHOO·2WWRFHQWR1 'D VHJQDODUH SRL= /1 6250$1, 025(77,/ 'HOOD LQGXVWULD DJULFROD/ PDQLIDWWXULHUD H FRPPHUFLDOH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0R0
<<5
*LRUJLR %RFFRODUL
GHQD/ 0LODQR1 *XJOLHOPLQL/ 4;7;> &1 521&$*/,$/ 6WDWLVWLFD JHQHUDOH GHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ 0RGHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L/ 4;7<04;83> *1 %2&&2/$5, 0 $1 6(/0,/ 0RQHWH H FDPEL QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD GDO 4;4< DO 4;8</ LQ ©$UFKLYLR HFRQRPLFR GHOO·8QLILFD]LRQH LWDOLDQDª V1,/ ,,,0,9/ 6 +4<89,> )1 0$1=277,/ $OFXQL DVSHWWL GHOOD SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFR0VRFLDOH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 H )UDQFHVFR 9 G·(VWH D 5HJ0 JLR/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD 6WRULFD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ ;/,9/ ,,0,,, +4<8:,> 81 0$5&(//,/ 8Q SURJHWWR GL QHVVR VFRQRPLFR LWDOR0DXVWUR0JHUPDQLFR/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD VWRULFD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ ;/,9/ ,,0,,, +4<8:,> 21 520%$/',/ *OL (VWHQVL DO JRYHUQR GL 5HJJLR GDO 4856 DO 4;8</ 5HJJLR (1 $*(/ 4<8<> *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL WUD 5LYROX]LRQH H 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9:> /1 38&&,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL UHODWLYL DOOD SRYHUWj D 0RGHQD WUD 6HWWHFHQWR H 2WWRFHQWR/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD GL 0RGHQDª/ V1 ,;/ ,,, +4<;4,1
/$ &8/785$
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
<<8
*,25*,2 0217(&&+,
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
3HU OD SUHVHQ]D GHO GXFD H GHOOD VXD FRUWH LQ 0RGHQD/ DOO·LQL]LR GHO 6HLFHQ0 WR/ PROWH DWWLYLWj DUWLJLDQDOL H PHUFDQWLOL ULSUHVHUR QXRYR YLJRUH1 ,O SULPR WL0 SRJUDIR DG DSSURILWWDUQH IX *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL/ LO TXDOH DSUu QHOOD YLD GHO &DVWHOODUR OD VXD ERWWHJD1 (JOL FL KD DQFKH ODVFLDWR XQD HVDWWD GHVFUL]LRQH GHO0 OD VXD VWDPSHULD GDWDWD 5 OXJOLR 494441 /D VXD HUD XQD SLFFROD D]LHQGD FRQ GXH WRUFKL LQ WXWWR/ XQR SL• DPSLR H UREXVWR SHU VWDPSDUH IRJOL GL IRUPDWR ´UHDOHµ/ HG XQ DOWUR/ GHWWR ´FRPXQHµ/ SHU OD VWDPSD GL IRJOL PHQR JUDQGL1 (· LQWHUHVVDQWH QRWDUH FKH OD VXD WLSRJUDILD HUD GRWDWD GL XQD JUDQGH UDFFROWD GL OHJQL SHU VLORJUDILH 0 SL• GL PLOOH/ DQQRWD JHQHULFDPHQWH LO 9HUGL QHOOD VXD ´OL0 VWDµ1 5DSSUHVHQWDYDQR VRSUDWWXWWR ´VDQWL H ILJXUDPLµ GL WXWWH OH GLPHQVLRQL/ GDO IRUPDWR ´UHDOHµ/ FLRq GDOOH GLPHQVLRQL GL XQ IRJOLR GD VWDPSD FRPSOHWD0 PHQWH DSHUWR/ DOO·LQ RWWDYR SLFFROR1 ,QROWUH HJOL SRVVHGHYD DQFKH XQD EXRQD YDULHWj 0 FLUFD 533 SH]]L 0 GL ´DOIDEHWL LQWDJOLDWL LQ OHJQR GL YDULH VRUWHµ1 6X TXHVWD VWHVVD VWUDGD HG LQ TXHVWR DPELWR GL LQWHUHVVL VL VDUHEEH LQFDPPLQDWR/ GL Ou D SRFKL GHFHQQL/ DQFKH %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL> DQ]L QRQ VL SXz QHSSXUH H0 VFOXGHUH FKH TXHVWL OHJQL VLDQR SDVVDWL GDOOD ERWWHJD GHOO·XQR D TXHOOD GHOO·DOWUR1 *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL/ GD EXRQ VWDPSDWRUH LQWHUHVVDWR SULPD GL WXWWR DO ODYRUR LQ WLSRJUDILD/ QHOOD VXD ´OLVWDµ LQGLFDYD OD TXDQWLWj GHL FDUDWWHUL QRQ D SHVR/ PD VSHFLILFDQGR LO QXPHUR GL ´IRUPHµ FKH FRQ HVVL VL SRWHYDQR FRP0 ²²²²²²²² 4
$602/ $UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0RGHQD/ 1RWDLR *LRYDQQL 6DOVD/ E1 56:/ 47 JHQQDLR 4946= /L0 VWD GHOOD VWDPSD GL PH *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL GHO 5 OXJOLR 49441 &IU1 DQFKH (131 9,&,1,/ /D VWDPSD QHOOD SURYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD/ LQ 7HVRUL GHOOH ELEOLRWHFKH G·,WDOLD/ YRO1 ,/ 0LODQR/ +RHSOL/ 4<65/ SS1 7;80 8651 &IU1 DQFKH *1 0217(&&+,/ $]LHQGH WLSRJUDILFKH/ VWDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL D 0RGHQD GDO 4XDWWURFHQWR DO 6HWWHFHQWR/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL (GLWRUH/ 4<;;1 'D TXHVWD SXEEOLFD]LRQH q VWDWR HVWUDWWR/ FRQ DOFXQH YDULD]LRQL/ LO FRQWULEXWR TXL ULSURGRWWR1
<<9
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
SRUUH> LQ DOWUH SDUROH TXHOOR FKH SHU OXL FRQWDYD HUD LO ODYRUR GL FRPSRVL]LRQH HG LQ TXHVWD RWWLFD HUD XWLOH VRSUDWWXWWR VDSHUH TXDQWL IRJOL HJOL SRWHYD VWDP0 SDUH FRQ OH YDULH VRUWL GL FDUDWWHUL D VXD GLVSRVL]LRQH> SHU TXHVWR DQQRWDYD/ DG HVHPSLR/ GL SRVVHGHUH WDQWL FDUDWWHUL GL &DQRQ]LQR TXDQWL QH EDVWDYDQR SHU FRPSRUUH XQD IRUPD/ FLRq SHU VWDPSDUH O·LQWHUD IDFFLDWD GL XQ IRJOLR GD VWDPSD1 6DSSLDPR FRVu FKH OD FDSDFLWj GHO VXR ODYRUR GL FRPSRVL]LRQH FRQVL0 VWHYD LQ XQD IRUPD GL &DQRQFLQR> LQ GXH IRUPH GL &DQRQFLQR SLFFROR> LQ WUH IRUPH GL &RUVLYR JURVVR> LQ EHQ FLQTXH IRUPH GL 7HVWR G·$OGR> LQ WUH GL 6LOYLR> LQ DOWUH WUH GL $QWLFR FRPXQH> LQ TXDWWUR GL &RUVLYR FRPXQH> LQ GXH IRUPH GL *DUDPRQH H LQ XQD GL *UHFR1 2OWUH D WXWWL TXHVWL FDUDWWHUL HJOL SRVVHGHYD DQFKH ´RWWR FDVVHWWH FRQ OH VXH PDLXVFROH/ HW DOWUH FDVVHWWH FRQ IULVL/ H VHJQL FHOHVWL/ H TXDGUHWWL G·RJQL VRUWHµ/ QRQFKp ´XQ ODYDWRUH LQ OHJQR/ VFDQFHOOL/ EDQFKL/ DUPHUL/ FDVVHW0 WH H FDVVH/ PDUJLQL/ VWHOOHWWH/ OLQHH HW DYDQWDJJL/ HW DOWUH FRVH DSSDUWHQHQWL D GHWWD DUWHµ1 6L WUDWWDYD FLRq GL XQD D]LHQGD FDSDFH GL SURGXUUH/ DFFDQWR DG LPPDJLQL VDFUH H DG RSXVFROL GL SRFR YDORUH/ DQFKH OLEUL GL QRWHYROH LPSH0 JQR FRPH JOL 6WDWXWD WHUUDH 6DQFWL )HOLFLV GHO 49451 3RFR DOWUR/ SHUz/ SRLFKp DQ0 FKH SHU *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL OD IRQWH SULQFLSDOH GL JXDGDJQR UHVWDYD OD OL0 EUHULD> XQ LQYHQWDULR GHL VXRL DYHUL UHGDWWR QHO 4946/ VXELWR GRSR OD VXD PRU0 WH/ UHJLVWUD FLUFD 4733 WLWROL/ XQD TXDQWLWj FHUWR QRQ WUDVFXUDELOH SHU XQD ERW0 WHJD GL TXHO WHPSR1 ,QROWUH HJOL/ FRPH PROWL DOWUL OLEUDL/ HUD WLWRODUH GL XQ PX0 OLQR GD FDUWD VXO WRUUHQWH 1L]]ROD/ YLFLQR D &DVWHOQXRYR 5DQJRQH/ HG DYHYD LQ DSSDOWR OD UDFFROWD GHJOL VWUDFFL SHU OD FDUWLHUD LQ GLYHUVL SDHVL GHOOD FDPSD0 JQD PRGHQHVH H QHOOD VWHVVD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD1 , VXRL HUHGL/ FKLXVD OD VWDPSHULD HG DEEDQGRQDWR LO FRPPHUFLR OLEUDULR/ PDQWHQQHUR OD FDUWLHUD H O·DSSDOWR GHOOD UDFFROWD GHJOL VWUDFFL ILQ ROWUH OD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9,,/ HQWUDQGR VSHVVR LQ OLWH FRQ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL FKH HUD ULXVFLWR DG RWWHQHUH O·DSSDOWR GHJOL VWUDFFL LQ DOWUL SDHVL GHO WHUULWRULR PRGHQHVH51 ,O GDWR/ SHUz/ SL• VRUSUHQGHQWH GHOO·LQYHQWDULR GHOOD VWDPSHULD GL *LRYDQ0 QL 0DULD 9HUGL q GD FHUFDUH SURSULR QHOOD SUHVHQ]D GL TXHOOD JUDQ TXDQWLWj GL OHJQL SHU VLORJUDILH1 6L WUDWWD/ FRPH JLj SHU LO FURFLILVVR GL 3DROR *DGDOGLQR H SHU OH ´IRUPH GD ILJXUHµ LQFRQWUDWH QHOOD ERWWHJD GL $QWRQLR %HUJROOL/ GL OHJQL GD XWLOL]]DUH QRQ WDQWR QHL OLEUL R QHOOH FDUWH DG XVR GHOOD FXULD YHVFRYLOH H ²²²²²²²² 5
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%/ : DJRVWR 49871 ,Q TXHVWD VWHVVD EXVWD VL YHGD DQFKH O·LQWHUR IDVFLFROR FRQ DWWL ULJXDUGDQWL *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL H L VXRL HUHGL1 6X $QWRQLR %HUJROOL VL YHGDQR OH YRFL DSSDUVH QHO 'L]LRQDULR %LR0 JUDILFR GHJOL ,WDOLDQL +5RPD/ 7UHFFDQL/ 4<9:, H QHO 'L]LRQDULR GHL 7LSRJUDIL HG HGLWRUL LWDOLDQL1 ,O &LQ0 TXHFHQWR +0LODQR/ (GLWULFH %LEOLRJUDILFD/ 4<<:,
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
<<:
GHOOD FDQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ TXDQWR SLXWWRVWR GL OHJQL SHU VWDPSH VFLROWH/ VLD SHU XVR GHYR]LRQDOH +VDQWL, VLD GL VRJJHWWR SURIDQR SHU VFRSL SXUDPHQWH GHFRUD0 WLYL R QDUUDWLYL +ILJXUDPL,1 , FRQFRUUHQWL GHL 6ROLDQL= *LXOLDQR HG $QGUHD &DVVLDQL $QWRQLR &DSSRQL/ 'HPHWULR 'HJQL H )UDQFHVFR 7RUUL 4XDQGR FKLXVH L EDWWHQWL OD ERWWHJD GL *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL +4946,/ DYH0 YD JLj FRPLQFLDWR DG DIIHUPDUVL LQ 0RGHQD O·D]LHQGD GL *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL1 (JOL VYLOXSSz OD VXD DWWLYLWj LQ WUH GLUH]LRQL GLYHUVH1 ,Q SULPR OXRJR ULXVFu DG RWWHQHUH L SULYLOHJL HVFOXVLYL SHU OH VWDPSH FKH VHUYLYDQR DOOH FDQFHOOHULH FLW0 WDGLQH GHOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH/ GHOOD FRPXQLWj H GHO YHVFRYDGR> VL DVVLFXUz FRVu XQ WLSR GL FRPPLWWHQ]H FKH OR PHWWHYD DO ULSDUR GDOO·DQGDPHQWR VHPSUH DOHDWR0 ULR GHO PHUFDWR OLEUDULR61 ,Q VHFRQGR OXRJR VL ULYROVH DO SXEEOLFR PRGHQHVH FRQ WXWWH TXHOOH SURGX]LRQL GL SL• DPSLD GLYXOJD]LRQH TXDOL/ DG HVHPSLR/ OH RSHUH GL *LXOLR &HVDUH &URFH LQ FXL VL FLPHQWDYDQR XQ SR· WXWWL L WLSRJUDIL GHO WHPSR> LQROWUH/ QHO OXJOLR GHO 498;/ SHU WHQHUH DJJLRUQDWL L PRGHQHVL VXOOH LPSUHVH PLOLWDUL GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR , FRQWUR JOL VSDJQROL/ $QGUHD &DVVLDQL VWDPSz DQFKH OD SULPD JD]]HWWD GL 0RGHQD/ FRPSRVWD GD -DFRSR $OHRWWL1 ,Q WHU]R OXRJR VL LPSHJQz D IRQGR QHOO·HGLWRULD GL SL• DPSLR UHVSLUR OHJDQGR LO SURSULR QRPH DOOH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GHL GXH SRHWL HVWHQVL DOORUD SL• LQ DXJH/ FLRq GL $OHVVDQGUR 7DVVRQL H GL )XOYLR 7HVWL1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR LO ULVFKLR HUD EHQ FDOFRODWR= TXHOOR HFRQRPLFR DOPHQR/ SHUFKp SHU OH LQWHPSHUDQ]H DQWL0 VSDJQROH FRQWHQXWH QHOOH 5LPH GHO 7HVWL *LXOLDQR &DVVDQL SDVVz DOFXQL PHVL GHO 494: LQ FDUFHUH71 /·D]LHQGD GHJOL (UHGL &DVVLDQL DYHYD SXEEOLFDWR GD PHQR GL XQ DQQR OH VXH XOWLPH RSHUH/ TXDQGR/ QHO 49<6/ DSUu L SURSUL EDWWHQWL TXHOOD GHL VRFL $Q0 WRQLR &DSSRQL HG (UHGL 3RQWLUROL1 3UREDELOPHQWH OD VHFRQGD QRQ HUD DOWUR FKH OD FRQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOD SULPD> WDQWR SL• FKH *LRUJLR 3RQWLUROL 0 VHFRQGR XQD LQIRUPD]LRQH GHOOD &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH 0 HUD YHQXWR D 0RGHQD 0 ´SHU ULID0 UH GH FDUDWWHUL GD VWDPSD SHO &DVVLDQL/ H SHU WDOH HIIHWWR YL VL HUD DFFDVDWRµ81 $QWRQLR &DSSRQL/ JLj OLEUDLR LQ 0RGHQD ILQ GDO 49::/ ULPDVWR GRSR SRFKL ²²²²²²²² 6
6XOO·D]LHQGD GL *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL H GHL VXRL HUHGL VL YHGD $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $U0 WL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ &DVVLDQL1 7 6XO JLRUQDOH GL -DFRSR $OHRWWL H VXOOD FHQVXUD GHOOH RSHUH GHO 7DVVRQL H GHO 7HVWL VL YHGD *1 0217(&&+,/ $]LHQGH 111FLW1/ SS1 9<0:51 8 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 3DUWLFRODUL/ 3RQWLUROL1
<<;
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
DQQL O·XQLFR WLWRODUH GHOOD WLSRJUDILD/ ULXVFu DG RWWHQHUH LO SULYLOHJLR GL VWDPSD SHU OH FDUWH GHOOD FXULD YHVFRYLOH H/ SURSULR JUD]LH DO WLWROR GL ´VWDPSDWRUH YH0 VFRYLOHµ/ SDUH VLD DQFKH ULXVFLWR D WLUDUVL IXRUL GDL JXDL TXDQGR YHQLYD VRVSHW0 WDWR HG LQFULPLQDWR SHU FRPPHUFLR GL OLEUL SURLELWL= XQ JHQHUH GL DIIDUL QHO TXDOH VL FLPHQWDYDQR DOORUD TXDVL WXWWL L OLEUDL PRGHQHVL91 &RPH JLj L &DVVLDQL HJOL FHUFz GL XQLUH LO SURSULR QRPH DJOL VWXGLRVL DOORUD SL• DWWLYL D 0RGHQD= QHO 4:33 XVFu GDL VXRL WRUFKL OD SULPD HGL]LRQH GHO 'H PRUELV DUWLILFXP GL %HU0 QDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL1 1HO FDSLWROR VXOOH PDODWWLH GHL WLSRJUDIL DJJLXQWR QHOOD HGL]LRQH SDGRYDQD GL TXHVW·RSHUD GHO 4:46/ O·DXWRUH LOOXVWUz OH GLVDJHYROL FRQGL]LRQL LQ FXL VL ODYRUDYD QHOOH D]LHQGH WLSRJUDILFKH H SUREDELOPHQWH YL SRVVLDPR FRJOLHUH DQFKH XQ ULIHULPHQWR/ SHU TXDQWR YDJR H JHQHUDOH/ DOOD VWHVVD VWDPSHULD FDSSRQLDQD= ´0L ULFRUGR FKH D YROWH TXDQGR HUR VWDWR VHGX0 WR SHU FLUFD TXDWWUR RUH SUHVVR XQ WLSRJUDIR SHU OD FRUUH]LRQH GL XQD PLD R0 SHUD/ SL• WDUGL DOO·XVFLWD GHOOD WLSRJUDILD PDQWHQHYR LPSUHVVH QHJOL RFFKL SHU0 ILQR GXUDQWH OD QRWWH OH LPPDJLQL GL TXH· SLFFROL FDUDWWHUL FKH DYHYR ILVVDWR FRQ WDQWD LQWHQVLWjµ:1 /D VWDPSHULD GL $QWRQLR &DSSRQL IX O·XOWLPD D FRQWUDVWDUH LQ 0RGHQD LO SDVVR DOO·D]LHQGD GHL 6ROLDQL WUD 6HL H 6HWWHFHQWR/ GRSR FKH 'HPHWULR 'HJQL/ SRFR DFFHWWR D FRUWH SHU O·LQGLSHQGHQ]D GL JLXGL]LR FRQ FXL FRPSLODYD OD SURSULD JD]]HWWD/ IX FRVWUHWWR QHL SULPL DQQL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR D FKLXGHUH LO SUR0 SULR JLRUQDOH HG LO SURSULR QHJR]LR HG D WUDVIHULUVL QHL GRPLQL SRQWLILFL/ SULPD D &HVHQD H SRL D 3HVDUR;1 'D XQD QRWD QRQ VRWWRVFULWWD GHO 49<5 DSSUHQGLD0 PR FKH 'HPHWULR 'HJQL QHOOD VXD ERWWHJD SRVWD QHOOD VWUDGD 0DHVWUD/ FLRq QHOO·DWWXDOH YLD (PLOLD/ ROWUH D YHQGHUH JOL DYYLVL GD OXL FRPSLODWL H VWDPSDWL/ YL HVHUFLWDYD DQFKH XQ SLFFROR FRPPHUFLR GL OLEUL H GL FDUWD VRSUDWWXWWR SHU OH ²²²²²²²² 9 1RQ SRFKH QRWL]LH VX $QWRQLR &DSSRQL VL WURYDQR LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ &DSSRQL1 ,PSOLFDWR LQ XQ SURFHVVR FRQ O·DFFXVD GL FRP0 PHUFLR GL OLEUL SURLELWL LO &DSSRQL ULXVFu DG HYLWDUH RJQL FRQGDQQD> VL YHGD *1 25/$1',/ 1L0 FROz *LXUDWL ´DWHLVWDµ +498804:5;,1 8Q SURFHVVR GHOO·,QTXLVL]LRQH GL 0RGHQD DOO·LQL]LR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ LQ ©6SLFLOHJLXP +LVWRULFXP &RQJUHJDWLRQLV 661PL 5HGHPSWRULVª/ 57 +4<:9,/ SS1 :705481 : %1 5$0$==,1,/ 'H PRUELV DUWLILFXP GLDWULED 3DGRYD/ *1%1 &RQ]DWWL/ 4:46/ S1 6:91 ,O WHVWR ODWLQR FRQ XQD WUDGX]LRQH LWDOLDQD FRHYD GHO FDSLWROR GHGLFDWR GD %HUQDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL DOOH PDODWWLH GHL WLSRJUDIL/ VHJXuWR GD XQ PLR FRPPHQWR q VWDWR SXEEOLFDWR LQ ´/D %LEOLRILOLDµ/ ;< +4<;:,/ SS14:<05351 ; 6XL PRWLYL FKH VSLQVHUR 'HPHWULR 'HJQL DG DEEDQGRQDUH OD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD VL YHGD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD/ 0DQRVFULWWL ,WDOLDQL/ 01$1 /$==$5(//,/ ,QIRUPD]LRQL GHOO·$UFKLYLR GHO PRQDVWHUR GL 61 3LHWUR GL 0RGHQD/ SDUWH 9/ S1 6<71 6X GL OXL VL YHGD OD YRFH DSSDU0 VD VXO 'L]LRQDULR %LRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQL +5RPD/ 7UHFFDQL/ 4<;;,1
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
<<<
VFXROH> YL WHQHYD LQIDWWL/ ´DOFXQL SH]]L GL OLEUL XVDWL/ HW DOFXQL DOWUL SLFFROL GD VFXROD SHU IDQFLXOOL/ FRPH VRQR VDQWHULL/ DEDFKL/ JUDPPDWLFKH HW DOWUL VLPLOL/ H WUH ULVPH GL FDUWD WUD GD VFULYHUH H GD VWDPSDUH/ FRQ PROWL IDVFL G·DYLVL YHFFKL FKH DYDQ]DYDQR GL YROWD LQ YROWD/ H YLWH GHO *D]]HWWL +HUHPLWD 0RGRQHVH/ HW DOWUH VLPLOL FDUWDFFHµ<1 ,QVRPPD D 0RGHQD QHL SULPL DQQL GHO VHFROR ;9,,, %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ ILJOLR GL 9LYLDQR H QLSRWH GHOO·DOWUR %DUWRORPHR FKH YHU0 VR LO 4979 DYHYD FRPLQFLDWR D VWDPSDU OLEUL QHOOD ERWWHJD SRVWD LQ SLD]]D *UDQGH/ ULPDQHYD VHQ]D FRQFRUUHQWL SHU FLUFD VHWWDQW·DQQL 0 ILQR DOO·DSHUWXUD QHO 4:9; GHOOD WLSRJUDILD GL *LRYDQQL 0RQWDQDUL1 )UDQFHVFR 7RUUL/ LQIDWWL/ X0 VFLWR GDOOD VXD ERWWHJD H GLYHQWDWR VWDPSDWRUH LQ SURSULR GDO 4:68 DO 4:88 QRQ LQWHVH PDL FRQWUDVWDUH LO SULPDWR GHO VXR YHFFKLR PDHVWUR H SDGURQH431 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL GD ´VROGDWR DO UDVWHOORµ D VWDPSDWRUH GXFDOH 1HO 4955 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ DOO·HWj GL FLUFD WUHQW·DQQL/ HUD GL VHUYL]LR FRPH VROGDWR DOOH SRUWH GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD1 6L LQGHELWz LQ TXHOO·DQQR SHU FLUFD GXHFHQWR OLUH/ FLIUD FRQVLGHUHYROH SHU XQ VROGDWR1 0DUWLQR 9HQDOL/ G·DOWUD SDUWH/ ILJXUD QRQ WURSSR OLPSLGD GHO VRWWRERVFR HFRQRPLFR PRGHQH0 VH/ SHU EUHYH WHPSR LOOXVWUH RVSLWH GHO FDUFHUH FLWWDGLQR FRQ O·DFFXVD GL FRQ0 WUDEEDQGR/ QRQ HUD PROWR WHQHUR FRQ L VXRL QXPHURVL GHELWRUL SUHVVR L TXDOL QHO 495: YDQWDYD XQ FUHGLWR GL ROWUH GRGLFLPLOD OLUH GL 0RGHQD1 6WD GL IDWWR FKH LO ´VROGDWR DO UDVWHOORµ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL IX SHU LVWDQ]D GHO 9HQDOL FRQ0 GDQQDWR DO FDUFHUH SHU GHELWL QHO 4956/ TXDQGR DYHYD JLj DSSHVR OH DUPL DO PXUR H GD VROGDWR VL HUD IDWWR ´OLEUDURµ= GDOOH DUPL HUD FLRq SDVVDWR DL OLEUL441 9HUDPHQWH XQ FHUWR DPRUH SHU OH DUPL ULPDVH VHPSUH LQ OXL H QHOOD VXD IDPL0 JOLD/ WDQW·q YHUR FKH GL DUFKLEXJL H GL VSDGH VRQR SLHQL L GRFXPHQWL FKH SDU0 ODQR GL OXL H GHL VXRL HUHGL> LQROWUH QHO 4:85/ DOO·DOWUR HVWUHPR GHOOD SDUDEROD GHOOD VXD IDPLJOLD/ LO VXR XOWLPR GLVFHQGHQWH PDVFKLR/ SXUH OXL GL QRPH %DU0 WRORPHR/ ODVFLz XQD VSDGD D )UDQFHVFR 7RUUL/ GDSSULPD JDU]RQH QHOOD VXD ²²²²²²²²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
4333
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
ERWWHJD LQ SLD]]D *UDQGH H SRL VWDPSDWRUH D &DUSL H D 0RGHQD1 &RQGDQQDWR DO FDUFHUH SHU XQ GHELWR GL 533 OLUH 0 LSRWHVL VXJJHVWLYD= JOL VHUYLURQR SHU DYYLDUH LO FRPPHUFLR OLEUDULR" 0 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL QRQ SRWH0 YD IDU SURJUHVVL QHOOD VXD QXRYD SURIHVVLRQH FKH ULFKLHGHYD OD VXD FRQWLQXD SUHVHQ]D1 3HU TXHVWR LO JLRUQR 63 $SULOH 4956 SUHVHQWz XQD SHWL]LRQH SHU H0 YLWDUH OD GHWHQ]LRQH H QRQ DEEDQGRQDUH OD ´ERWHJD GL OLEUDURµ1 &HUWDPHQWH LO WHQHUOD DSHUWD HUD O·XQLFR PRGR GL UDFFDWWDUH XQ SR· GL TXHOOH OLUH FKH RUD JOL PDQFDYDQR GHO WXWWR1 1RQ VDSSLDPR EHQH FRPH DQGz D ILQLUH O·LQWHUD YLFHQ0 GD1 $G RJQL PRGR GL Ou D YHQW·DQQL/ QHO 4979/ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL JHVWLYD LQ SLD]]D *UDQGH XQD EHQ DYYLDWD OLEUHULD/ IRUQLWD DQFKH GL WHVWL GL JUDQGH DWWXD0 OLWj H GL VLFXUR VPHUFLR1 $OODUJz DOORUD OD SURSULD DWWLYLWj H VL PLVH D VWDPSDU OLEUL1 3DUWu GDO EDVVR FRQ DOFXQL GL TXHL OLEULFLQL LQ GRGLFHVLPR H GD SRFKL VSLFFLROL FKH WURYDYDQR IDFLOL DFTXLUHQWL WUD L IUHTXHQWDWRUL SL• DVVLGXL GHOOD VXD ERWWHJD R FKH/ VWDPSDWL VX RUGLQD]LRQH GL FRPPLWWHQWL ODLFL HG HFFOHVLD0 VWLFL/ HUDQR GD HVVL LQWHUDPHQWH SDJDWL1 8VFLURQR FRVu ULPH SHU QR]]H/ SHU PRQDFD]LRQL R SHU IHVWLYLWj UHOLJLRVH/ DUULQJKH GL DYYRFDWL/ H WHVWL GL LQWUDWWH0 QLPHQWR FRPH OD 7HUULELOH/ FUXGHOLVVLPD/ WUHPHQGD H VDQJXLQRVD JXHUUD WUD FDQL H JDWWL GHO ILRUHQWLQR $QWRQLR 0LFKHODVL451 *Lj LQ TXHVWL SULPL DQQL YLGHUR OD OXFH DQFKH DOFXQH RSHUH GL PDJJLRU LPSHJQR H GL DUJRPHQWR GHYR]LRQDOH FRP0 SRVWH GD UHOLJLRVL DOORUD DWWLYL D 0RGHQD H SHUWDQWR GL VLFXUD FROORFD]LRQH SUHVVR L ORUR IHGHOL R QHL ORUR FRQYHQWL VSDUVL LQ WXWWD ,WDOLD1 3ULPD GL WXWWR DSSDUYH QHO 4979 XQ WHVWR FKH LQ 0RGHQD VL UDFFRPDQGDYD SHU VH VWHVVR/ H SUHFLVDPHQWH 'HO FDSXFFLQR G·(VWH FKH IX QHO VHFROR LO 6HUHQLVVLPR $OIRQVR ,,, GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ GL FLUFD 833 SDJLQH LQ TXDUWR/ VFULWWR GD SDGUH *LRYDQQL $OELQHOOL GD 6HVWROD/ JLj FRQILGHQWH H FRQVLJOLHUH GL $OIRQVR ,,, SULPD GHO VXR LQJUHVVR QHOO·RUGLQH GHL FDSSXFFLQL H SRL/ FRQ TXHVW·RSHUD/ LO SULPR ELRJUDIR GRSR OD VXD PRUWH DYYHQXWD QHO 49771 /·DQQR VHJXHQWH SXEEOLFz LO 'DYLGH &RQYHUWLWR/ XQD OXQJD SDUDIUDVL GHL VDOPL SHQLWHQ]LDOL GL SDGUH 0 SXUH OXL FDSSXFFLQR$ 0 %RQDYHQWXUD GD 3DUPD/ DFFRPSDJQDWD GDO *LDUGLQR VSLULWXDOH GL 3DROR 0RULJL GHOO·RUGLQH GHL *HVXDWL/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH GL 683 H GL 783 SDJLQH/ TXHVWD YROWD QHO QXRYR IRUPDWR LQ GRGLFHVLPR FKH FRVWLWXLUj SRL XQD GHOOH FRVWDQWL GL WDQ0 WH SURGX]LRQL GHL 6ROLDQL1 &RQ TXHVWR IRUPDWR QHO 497: IX VWDPSDWR LO OXQJR URPDQ]R /D &DVVDQGUD GL *DXWLHU GH &RVWHV GH /D &DOSUHQqGH1 SXEEOLFDWR LQ ²²²²²²²² 45 *UD]LH DL /DYRUL SUHSDUDWRUL SHU JOL DQQDOL GHOOD WLSRJUDILD 6ROLDQL D FXUD GL (1 0,/$12 +0R0 GHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<;9,/ FKH UDFFRJOLH OH HGL]LRQL GHL 6ROLDQL FRQVHUYDWH LQ DOFXQH ELEOLRWHFKH GHOO·(PLOLD/ q RJJL SRVVLELOH VHJXLUH SL• GD YLFLQR OD SURGX]LRQH GHL 6ROLDQL GDO 4979 ILQR DOO·DQQR 4;331
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4334
)UDQFLD FLQTXH DQQL SULPD HG RUD WUDGRWWR LQ LWDOLDQR GD *LXVHSSH 5RQFKL1 $QFKH QHO VHWWRUH GHOOH ULPH/ DOORUD WDQWR LQ YRJD/ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL IH0 FH GHO VXR PHJOLR SHU QRQ OLPLWDUVL D TXHOOH FKH VL VWDPSDYDQR LQ JUDQ TXDQ0 WLWj LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOH ´IHOLFLVVLPH QR]]H GH· 6HUHQLVVLPL 3ULQFLSLµ GL WXUQR 0 LQ TXHO 497: VL HEEH DG HVHPSLR LO PDWULPRQLR WUD 0DUJKHULWD G·(VWH H )HU0 UDQWH *RQ]DJD GXFD GL *XDVWDOOD1 6L LQGXVWULz LQIDWWL DOOD PHJOLR SHU DVVLFX0 UDUVL L FRPSRQLPHQWL GHL SL• ORGDWL SRHWL HVWHQVL= DQFKH TXL GRSR OD VFRP0 SDUVD GL )XOYLR 7HVWL/ XQD WHRULD GL QXOOLWj/ GDL YHUVL GL -DFRSR $OHRWWL H GDO &RQTXLVWR GL *UDQDWD GL *LXOLDQR *UD]LDQL DOOH 3RHVLH GL &DUOR )RVFKLHUD /DGHU0 FKL1 4XHVWL IXURQR/ JURVVR PRGR/ JOL LQGLUL]]L FXOWXUDOL QHL TXDOL VL LQFDPPL0 Qz LO 6ROLDQL QHL SULPL GXH DQQL GL DWWLYLWj1 3RWUHPPR VHJXLUOR DQFRUD SHU PROWR WHPSR VX TXHVWD VWUDGD PD IRUVH LQFRQWUHUHPPR EHQ SRFKH QRYLWj GL ULOLHYR1 ,QIDWWL VDOYR UDULVVLPH HFFH]LRQL FKH VL SRVVRQR FRQWDUH VXOOH GLWD GL XQD PDQR/ OD SURGX]LRQH GHL 6ROLDQL QRQ DYUHEEH SL• DEEDQGRQDWR/ QHSSXUH QHL VHFROL VHJXHQWL/ TXHVWD SDWLQD GL FDPSDQLOLVPR TXDVL VRIIRFDQWH FKH UL0 VFRQWULDPR ILQ GDOO·LQL]LR1 $FFDQWR DOOH ULPH HG DL UDFFRQWL SLDFHYROL/ DFFDQWR DOOH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GL DWWL SURFHVVXDOL H GL GLVSXWH DFFDGHPLFKH/ DFFDQWR DOOH RUD]LRQL IXQHEUL HG DJOL RSXVFROL SHU OD SUDWLFD OLWXUJLFD H GHYR]LRQDOH/ VWDP0 Sz FHUWDPHQWH DQFKH RSHUH GL PDJJLRU LPSHJQR WLSRJUDILFR 0 EDVWL SHQVDUH DOO·,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR GHO 498< 0 PD UHVWz VHPSUH DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ SURJHWWR HGLWRULDOH FKH QRQ JXDUGDYD ROWUH L FRQILQL GHO GXFDWR H QHSSXUH WURSSR DO GL Oj GHOOH PXUD FLWWDGLQH1 $Q]L VL SXz IDFLOPHQWH RVVHUYDUH FKH DX0 WRUL/ FXUDWRUL H WUDGXWWRUL GHOOH SULQFLSDOL RSHUH VWDPSDWH GDL 6ROLDQL LQ TXHVWL SULPL DQQL 0 H VL SXz VXSSRUUH FKH VDUj FRVu DQFKH LQ IXWXUR 0 SURYHQLYDQR WXWWL GDOOD ULVWUHWWD FHUFKLD GHJOL XRPLQL FKH IUHTXHQWDYDQR DVVLGXDPHQWH OD FRUWH FRPH FRQVLJOLHUL/ SHGDJRJKL/ SUHGLFDWRUL R FRPH OHWWHUDWL H SRHWL1 ,O PRPHQWR HUD FHUWDPHQWH SURSL]LR DOO·HVSDQVLRQH GHOOD QXRYD D]LHQGD WLSRJUDILFD SRLFKp *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL/ RUPDL TXDVL RWWDQWHQQH/ VHPEUDYD GL0 VSRVWR DG DEEDQGRQDUH LO FDPSR1 $Q]L QHO 4985/ O·DQQR VWHVVR GHOOD PRUWH GL )XOYLR 7HVWL/ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL SURJHWWz OD VWDPSD GHOOD VXD 5DFFROWD JHQHUDOH GHOOH SRHVLH> GL XQ DXWRUH FLRq OHJDWR LQ YLWD DOOD WLSRJUDILD GHO &DVVLDQL LO TXDOH WUHQWDFLQTXH DQQL SULPD DYHYD DIIURQWDWR DQFKH LO FDUFHUH SHU DYHU SXEEOLFD0 WR OD SULPD HGL]LRQH PRGHQHVH GHOOH VXH 5LPH FRQWHQHQWL HVSUHVVLRQL QRQ JUDGLWH DJOL 6SDJQROL461 0D DQFKH %DUWRORPHR QRQ HUD SL• XQ JLRYLQRWWR/ SHU GL SL• LO ILJOLR 9L0 ²²²²²²²² 46
6L YHGD *1 0217(&&+,/ $]LHQGH 111FLW1/ SS1 9<0:31
4335
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
YLDQR QRQ VHPEUDYD VHPSUH LQWHQ]LRQDWR D VHJXLUH OH RUPH HG L SURJHWWL SD0 WHUQL1 7DQWR SHU FRPLQFLDUH YHQLYD IDFLOPHQWH DOOH PDQL/ DQ]L 0 PHPRUH GHOO·DQWLFR PHVWLHUH GHO SDGUH 0 VL VHSSH FRPSRUWDUH FRQ GHVWUH]]D FRQWUR XQ FHUWR &DUOR %UXQHWWL FKH/ QRQ VDSSLDPR SHU TXDO PRWLYR/ DYHYD SRVWR PDQR DOOD VSDGD SHU IHULUOR ´PHQWUH HUD LQ ERWWHJD LQ 3LD]]D GL 0RGHQD D ODYRUDUH/ HW VH QRQ VL GHIIHQGHYD FRQ XQ OHJQR UHVWDYD IHULWRµ471 0D TXHOOR FKH SUHRF0 FXSDYD PDJJLRUPHQWH LO YHFFKLR 6ROLDQL HUD LO IDWWR FKH LO ILJOLR/ SHU TXDQWR IHOLFHPHQWH VSRVDWR/ QRQ VHPEUDYD LQWHQ]LRQDWR D PHWWHUVL VXO VHULR DOO·RSHUD SHU LO EXRQ DQGDPHQWR GHOO·D]LHQGD1 ,QVRPPD 9LYLDQR D TXDUDQW·DQQL VXRQD0 WL/ FRQ XQ SDGUH FKH RUPDL QH DYHYD SL• GL RWWDQWD 0 FRVu DOPHQR VL GLFHYD LQ PDQFDQ]D GL XQ FRQWR SUHFLVR 0 QRQ VDSHYD QHSSXUH VFULYHUH1 &HUWR VDSHYD OHJJHUH TXHO WDQWR FKH EDVWDYD SHU IDUH DOOD PHJOLR LO SURSULR ODYRUR GL WLSR0 JUDIR H GL OLEUDLR1 4XHVWD SUHSDUD]LRQH VWUHWWDPHQWH SURIHVVLRQDOH/ SHUz/ QRQ HUD VXIILFLHQWH SHU LO YHFFKLR SDGUH FKH PLUDYD DG XQD DWWLYLWj HGLWRULDOH GL EHQ PDJJLRUL SUHWHVH FXOWXUDOL1 )HFH DQFKH ULFRUVR DOOD DXWRULWj GHO SULQFLSH &HVDUH/ VXR DELWXDOH SURWHWWRUH/ QHOOD VSHUDQ]D FKH LO ILJOLR/ RSSRUWXQDPHQWH DPPRQLWR/ PHWWHVVH ILQDOPHQWH OD WHVWD D SDUWLWR1 0D VROR LO WLPRUH GL HVVHUH FDFFLDWR GL FDVD H GL HVVHUH GLVHUHGDWR HEEH DOOD ILQH OD PHJOLR1 &RVu/ DOPHQR/ SDUH481 /D QHFHVVLWj GL DYHUH VHPSUH D GLVSRVL]LRQH XQD DEERQGDQWH TXDQWLWj GL FDUWD HUD GL VROLWR DOO·RULJLQH GHOOH PDJJLRUL SUHRFFXSD]LRQL GHL WLSRJUDIL/ WDQ0 WR SL• FKH LO FRVWR GHOOD FDUWD FRSULYD DOORUD LO 93( HG ROWUH GHOO·LQWHUR FRVWR GL SURGX]LRQH GHO OLEUR1 *Lj QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR JOL HUHGL GL *LR0 YDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL DYHYDQR DEEDQGRQDWR OD ERWWHJD OLEUDULD H OD VWDPSHULD SHU OD SURIHVVLRQH SL• UHGGLWL]LD GL FDUWDL> RUD QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHFROR/ *LRYDQQL 9HUGL JHVWLYD OD FDUWLHUD GHOOD 1L]]ROD HG DYHYD RWWHQXWR O·DSSDOWR GHOOD UDFFROWD GHJOL VWUDFFL SHU OD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD H SHU DOFXQL SDHVL GHO FRQ0 WDGR1 *OL VWUDFFL +DQFKH VH FLz SXz VRUSUHQGHUH, FRVWLWXLYDQR D TXHL WHPSL OD YHUD HG XQLFD PDWHULD SULPD GHO OLEUR D VWDPSD1 &RQWUROODUQH OD UDFFROWD YR0 OHYD GLUH SRUUH JLj XQD IRUWH LSRWHFD VXOOD SURGX]LRQH GHOOD FDUWD H GHO OLEUR> SHU GL SL• VHQ]D FRUUHUH DOFXQ ULVFKLR ILQDQ]LDULR1 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL QH RW0 WHQQH O·DSSDOWR SHU L FHQWUL GL 1RQDQWROD/ %RPSRUWR/ 6RUEDUD/ %DVWLJOLD H L ORUR WHUULWRUL1 *LRYDQQL 9HUGL QRQ UHVWz D JXDUGDUH1 1RQ DSSHQD 6ROLDQL HE0 EH UDFFROWR QHOOD VXD ERWWHJD GL 0RGHQD JOL VWUDFFL SURYHQLHQWL GD TXHVWH WHU0 ²²²²²²²² 47
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%/ 49851 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL/ OHWWHUH QRQ GDWDWH%/ PD GHO 4997 FLUFD1 48
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4336
UH H VL DSSUHVWDYD D IDUOL XVFLUH GDOOH SRUWH GHOOD FLWWj SHU SRUWDUOL DO PXOLQR GD FDUWD GL )UDQFHVFR 9DFFDUL D 6SLODPEHUWR/ JOL IHFH VHTXHVWUDUH WXWWR LO FDULFR FRO SUHWHVWR FKH VROR OXL GHWHQHYD O·DSSDOWR GHJOL VWUDFFL FKH XVFLYDQR GDOOD FLWWj1 $UJRPHQWD]LRQH SUHWHVWXRVD PD VLJQLILFDWLYD GHO FOLPD GL FRQFRUUHQ]D DSHUWD/ H QRQ VHPSUH OHDOH/ SHU LO FRQWUROOR GHJOL DSSDOWL GHOOD FDUWD/ FKH VL HUD VWDELOLWR WUD GL ORUR YHUVR LO 4989491 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL GLYHQWD LO SULQFLSDOH WLSRJUDIR GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD 8QD YROWD XVFLWR GL VFHQD *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL/ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL HUD EHQ GHFLVR DG RFFXSDUH LO SRVWR JLj GD OXL WHQXWR QHO SDQRUDPD HGLWRULDOH PRGH0 QHVH1 1HO 4989 VXSSOLFz LO SULQFLSH &HVDUH SHUFKp JOL RWWHQHVVH ´GD 0RQV1 9HVFRYR ,OOXVWULVVLPR TXHOOH FRQFHVVLRQL FKH GDOOL DOWUL VXRL $QWHFHVVRUL JOL VRQR VWDWH VHQ]D GLIILFXOWj DOFXQD SURPHVVHµ1 3RWHYD FRVu DOODUJDUH FRQ PDJ0 JLRU LQFLVLYLWj OD VXD SURGX]LRQH DQFKH DO VHWWRUH GHYR]LRQDOH/ FKH/ FRPH EHQ FRPSUHQGHYD ´UHFFDUj XWLOH/ HG KRQRUH DOOD VWDPSD GHOO·2UDWRUHµ4:1 1RQ WUD0 VFXUz QHSSXUH OD VWDPSD FRVLGGHWWD ´SRSRODUHµ1 1HO 498; LQ DSHUWD VILGD DG $QGUHD &DVVLDQL LQ XQ VHWWRUH VHPSUH UHPXQHUDWLYR/ FKLHVH DQFKH LO SULYLOH0 JLR HVFOXVLYR SHU OD VWDPSD GHO OXQDULR GL *LXVHSSH 5RVDFFLR> TXL SDUH SHUz FKH OD IRUWXQD QRQ VLD VWDWD GDOOD VXD SDUWH4;1 ,QILQH/ O·DQQR VHJXHQWH/ D SRFKL PHVL GDOOD PRUWH GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH/ SXEEOLFz/ FRQ SULYLOHJLR HVFOX0 VLYR/ OD &RURQD IXQHUDOH GHGLFDWD DOOD JORULRVD HG LPPRUWDOH PHPRULD GHO VHUHQLVVLPR 3ULQFLSH )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH/ FRPSRVWD GDO JHVXLWD 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL LO TXDOH VL VFXVDYD SUHVVR L OHWWRUL SHU ´OD UR]]D IRUPD GL TXHVWR VFRQFLR UDJJXDJOLR/ SRLFKp SDUWRULWR TXDVL SULPD G·HVVHU FRQFHSLWRµ4</ H SURPHWWHYD XQ·RSHUD GL PDJJLRU PROH H GL EHQ DOWUR SUHJLR= OD TXDOH IX VWDPSDWD VHPSUH GDO 6ROLDQL LQ TXHOOR VWHVVR DQQR FRO WLWROR ,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR LQ )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH/ VXSHUED HGL]LRQH GL ROWUH 933 SDJLQH LQ IROLR FRQ DQWLSRUWD/ ULWUDWWR H QXPHURVH DOWUH WDYROH LQFLVH LQ UDPH/ WURSSR QRWH SHU HVVHUH TXL ULFRUGDWH1 0ROWH HQHUJLH FRQVXPz LO 6ROLDQL LQ TXHVW·LPSUHVD FKH HUD DO OLPLWH GHOOH ²²²²²²²² 49
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
4337
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
VXH UHDOL SRVVLELOLWj1 1RQ SRWp DFFRQWHQWDUVL GHOOD FDUWD SURGRWWD D 6SLODP0 EHUWR/ PD GRYHWWH IDUQH JLXQJHUH GHOOD PLJOLRUH HG D FDUR SUH]]R GDOOD FDUWLH0 UD GL 6DQ &HVDULR1 ,QROWUH GRYHWWH DQFKH FKLHGHUH LQ SUHVWLWR XQ WRUFKLR DOOD &RPXQLWj GL &DUSL1 3HU GL SL• 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL QRQ DYHYD FHUWR XQ FD0 UDWWHUH IDFLOH HG DFFRPRGDQWH1 3ULPD GL WXWWR SUHWHVH FKH OD VXD RSHUD QRQ IRVVH VWDPSDWD QHOOD ERWWHJD GHO WLSRJUDIR/ PD QHO FRQYHQWR GHL *HVXLWL QHOOD VXD VWHVVD UHVLGHQ]D1 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ TXDQGR TXHVWD GLVSRVL]LRQH GLYHQ0 QH HVHFXWLYD/ IHFH SUHVHQWH D 6XD $OWH]]D ´LO GDQQR QRWDELOH H VFRQFHUWR JUDQGH GHOOD VWDPSD QHO OHYDUOD GDO VXR OXRJRµ H SUHFLVz FKH QHOOD VXD ERWWHJD VL HUDQR VWDPSDWH ´FRVH G·LQWHUHVVH GL 6WDWR/ H GHOOD 6HUHQLVVLPD FDVD/ FRP·DQFKH GL SUHVHQWH VL VWDPSD VFULWWXUH UDFFRPDQGDWH GDO 6HUHQLVVLPR GL 3DUPD531 0D OH FDVVH GHL FDUDWWHUL HUDQR VWDWH JLj SRUWDWH QHO &ROOHJLR GHL *H0 VXLWL H QHO WUDVSRUWR HUDQR DQGDWH SHUVH EHQ VHWWH OLEEUH GL FDUDWWHUL FKH LO 6R0 OLDQL VL IHFH ULVDUFLUH LQ VHJXLWR/ D VWDPSD XOWLPDWD1 'HOO·,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KH0 URH FULVWLDQR IXURQR WLUDWH 733 FRSLH SHU LO 6ROLDQL H 93 FRSLH SHU OD FRUWH1 4XHVW·XOWLPD LQ FDPELR IRUQu OD FDUWD SHU OH SURSULH FRSLH/ L UDPL H OD PHUFH0 GH SHU OD ORUR WLUDWXUD FKH IX YDOXWDWD XQ 3DROR RJQL FHQWR IRJOL/ YDOH D GLUH 8<5 OLUH GL 0RGHQD/ FRPSUHQVLYH DQFKH GHO FRVWR GHL IRJOL FKH SHU JOL HUURUL FRQWHQXWL HUDQR VWDWL WLUDWL XQD VHFRQGD YROWD1 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL QRQ IX VRGGLVIDWWR QHSSXUH LQ TXHVWR FDVR/ SRLFKp LO 6ROLDQL QRQ JOL DYHYD ODVFLDWR OH 58 R 63 FRSLH FKH ULWHQHYD JOL VSHWWDVVHUR FRPH DXWRUH1 7UD L GXH RUPDL HUD JXHUUD DSHUWD1 7DQWR FKH OD VHUD GHO 58 OXJOLR 4993 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ GD YHFFKLR VROGDWR TXDO HUD/ VL VIRJz DQFKH ´FRQ PRWWHJJL SLFFDQWLVVLPLµ H DI0 IHUPz FKH HJOL VH QH ULGHYD GHO ULFRUVR GHO *DPEHUWL DOOD SURWH]LRQH GXFDOH ´VHQGR TXHVWH PLQDFFH/ PROWH YROWH IDWWH/ PD VHQ]D HIIHWWRµ1 $Q]L LO SDGUH *DPEHUWL GRYHWWH/ IRUVH/ ULWHQHUVL IRUWXQDWR SRLFKp 0 FRPH VSLHJz QHO VXR ULFRUVR DO GXFD 0 LO 6ROLDQL H JOL DOWUL GXH ILJXUL FKH TXHOOD VHUD OR VSDOOHJJLDYD0 QR ´VROR SHO WLWROR GHOOD FKLHULFD PL SRUWDYDQR ULVSHWWRµ1 $ TXHVWR SXQWR VHPEUD SURSULR VXSHUIOXR IDU QRWDUH FKH QHO 4995/ DOOD PRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,9/ 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL QRQ IHFH VWDPSDUH O·2UD]LRQH IXQHUDOH D %DUWRORPHR 6R0 OLDQL/ PD SUHIHUu ULFRUUHUH DL VHUYLJL GHOOD VWDPSHULD &DVVLDQL541 3URSULR DOORUD $QGUHD &DVVLDQL FHUFDYD GL ULVROOHYDUH DOOD PHJOLR OH VRUWL ²²²²²²²² 53
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%1 ,Q TXHVWD EXVWD VRQR FRQVHUYDWL DQFKH L GRFXPHQWL GD FXL VRQR WUDWWH OH DOWUH FLWD]LRQL GL TXHVWR SDUD0 JUDIR1 54 '1 *$0%(57,/ 2UD]LRQH IXQHUDOH LQ ORGH GL $OIRQVR ,9 GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ $QGUHD &DVVLDQL/ 49961
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4338
GHOOD D]LHQGD GL FXL HUD GLYHQXWR DOORUD O·XQLFR SURSULHWDULR JUD]LH DOOD GLVSR0 VL]LRQH WHVWDPHQWDULD GHOOR ]LR VHFRQGR FXL QHVVXQ DOWUR HUHGH DYUHEEH SRWX0 WR ´SDUWHFLSDUH GHOOL JXDGDJQL H IUXWWL GH· FDSLWDOL GL OLEUHULD H VWDPSHULD VH QRQ TXHOOL FKH SUHVHQWHPHQWH DVVLVWHUDQQR HW RSHUHUDQQR LQ HVVDµ551 (JOL IH0 FH GL WXWWR SHU ULRFFXSDUH TXHOOD SRVL]LRQH GL SUHVWLJLR H TXDVL GL PRQRSROLR HGLWRULDOH FKH *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL DYHYD WHQXWR QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO VHFROR1 0D RUD ELVRJQDYD IDUH L FRQWL FRQ %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL1 4XHVWR FHUWDPHQWH q LO TXDGUR HQWUR FXL VL DQLPDURQR L FRQWUDVWL H OH OLWL WUD L GXH VWDPSDWRUL PR0 GHQHVL1 &L VIXJJRQR SHUz L WHPL VSHFLILFL GHOOH ORUR FRQWURYHUVLH1 1H FRQR0 VFLDPR SHUz OH FRQVHJXHQ]H1 $OPHQR VXO SLDQR JLXGL]LDOH YHUVR OD ILQH GHO 4993 $QGUHD &DVVLDQL VHPEUDYD RUPDL SURQWR D FDQWDUH ILQDOPHQWH YLWWRULD1 %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ RUPDL SL• FKH VHWWDQWHQQH/ HUD LQ FDUFHUH ´DG LVWDQ]D H SHU PDOLJQLWj G·$QGUHD &DVVLDQL/ SHU PH]]R GL /RGRYLFR 7DLDYLQRµ> DQFKH LO ILJOLR 9LYLDQR/ SHU JOL VWHVVL PRWLYL/ IX ´PHVVR FDWWXUDWRµ/ DYHYD FLRq VXOOH VSDOOH XQ PDQGDWR GL FDWWXUD H VL HUD GRYXWR ULIXJLDUH ´QHO &RQYHQWR GH 3D0 GUL GH 6HUYL/ KDYHQGR ODVFLDWD OD ERWWHJD H FDVD LQ DEEDQGRQR GH *DU]RQL H VHQ]D DOFXQD UDJLRQH/ HW SHUFKp VL WUDWWD GHOOD WRWDOH VSLDQDFLRQH G·XQ QHJR0 WLR/ HW GL XQD IDPLJOLDµ561 3HU TXHVWR VL ULVROVH D FKLHGHUH TXHOOD SURWH]LRQH GXFDOH FKH/ FRPH DYHYD JLj GHWWR SRFKL PHVL SULPD DO SDGUH *DPEHUWL/ WDU0 GDYD VSHVVR DG DUULYDUH1 (G DUULYz PROWR WDUGL DQFKH SHU OXL= LQ DVVHQ]D GL XQD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD SL• SUHFLVD/ SRVVLDPR VROR RVVHUYDUH FKH 0 IDWWR XQLFR 0 GHOO·DQQR 4994 q JLXQWD D QRL XQD VROD HGL]LRQH VRWWRVFULWWD GDL 6ROLDQL/ VL WUDWWD GL XQD GLIHVD GHOOH ULYHQGLFD]LRQL HVWHQVL VXL WHUULWRUL GL &R0 PDFFKLR FRQWUR OD &DPHUD $SRVWROLFD FRPSRVWD GDO JLXULVWD %DUWRORPHR *DWWL571 0D SRL %DUWRORPHR H 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL WRUQDURQR DOOD ORUR ERWWHJD H OR VFRQWUR FRQ $QGUHD &DVVLDQL VL VSRVWz VXO SLDQR HGLWRULDOH1 ,O QXRYR DVWUR QDVFHQWH GHOOD FXOWXUD PRGHQHVH HUD DOORUD /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL581 6H RVVHU0 YLDPR DWWHQWDPHQWH OH GDWH GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOH RSHUH GHO 9HGULDQL UHJL0 VWULDPR XQ IHQRPHQR FKH SDUH QRQ SRVVD HVVHUH FRQVLGHUDWR SXUDPHQWH FD0 ²²²²²²²² 55
$602/ $UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0RGHQD/ Q1 664</ 4< RWWREUH 4985/ %*LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL%1 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%1 57 %1 *$77,/ 5DJLRQL GHOD FDVD G·(VWH VRSUD OH 9DOOL GL &RPDFFKLR HW DOWUL EHQL DOORGLDOL FRQWUD OD 5HY1 &DPHUD $SRVWROLFD/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 49941 58 6X /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL H VXO SRVWR GD OXL RFFXSDWR QHOOD FXOWXUD PRGHQHVH GHO 6HLFHQWR PDQFD XQR VWXGLR UHFHQWH> ELVRJQD SHUWDQWR ULFRUUHUH D 7LUDERVFKL/ %LEOLRWHFD 0RGHQHVH/«FLW1/ YRO19/ SS1 69306951 56
4339
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
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·DQQR VHJXHQWH/ SHUz/ /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL IHFH VWDPSDUH OD VXD RSHUD GL PDJJLRU PROH H SUHVWLJLR D %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL1 'DL VXRL WRUFKL QHO 4999 XVFu LO SULPR YROXPH GHOOD +LVWRULD GL 0RGRQD GL 875 SDJLQH LQ TXDUWR> LO VHFRQGR YROXPH DSSDUYH O·DQQR VHJXHQWH H DUULYDYD D EHQ :73 SDJLQH1 ,O 9HGULDQL WRUQz VXELWR GRSR DO JHQHUH ELRJUDILFR H/ DQFKH TXHVWD YROWD SUHVVR LO 6ROLD0 QL/ YLGH OD OXFH QHO 499< LO VXR &DWDORJR GL YHVFRYL PRGRQHVL GL 553 SDJLQH LQ TXDUWR1 6HPEUD GXQTXH GL FDSLUH FKH /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL GRSR DYHU IDWWR VWDPSDU OLEUL VLD D %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ VLD DG $QGUHD &DVVLDQL/ DOOD ILQH TXDQGR FRPLQFLz D PDQGDU IXRUL OH VXH RSHUH GL PDJJLRU PROH FKH ULFKLHGH0 YDQR XQD EXRQD FDSDFLWj SURGXWWLYD HG XQD VDOGD VWUXWWXUD D]LHQGDOH/ SUHIHUu ULYROJHUVL GL QXRYR DOOD ERWWHJD GHL 6ROLDQL1 1HO 49:3 DOO·HWj GL ROWUH RWWDQW·DQQL %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ SDVVDWR FRPH VL VROHYD GLUH D PLJOLRU YLWD/ ODVFLz OD VXD D]LHQGD DO ILJOLR 9LYLDQR FKH IRUVH QHO IUDWWHPSR DYHYD DQFKH LPSDUDWR D VFULYHUH1 ,O QXRYR WLWRODUH GHOOD VWDPSHULD FRQWLQXz VXOOD VWUDGD JLj WUDFFLDWD GDO SDGUH= DG RQRU GHO YHUR GREELDPR DPPHWWHUH FKH/ D SDUWH OH ODPHQWHOH SDWHUQH VXOOD VXD VYRJOLDWH]]D IRUVH GD QRQ HQIDWL]]DUH SL• GHO QHFHVVDULR/ HJOL QRQ IX QHSSXUH GHO WXWWR HVWUDQHR DO ULODQFLR GHOO·D]LHQGD RSHUDWR QHO GHFHQQLR SUHFHGHQWH TXDQGR LO SDGUH/ TXH0 VWR QRQ YD GLPHQWLFDWR/ HUD RUPDL PROWR DQ]LDQR1 /D YLWD IX FHUWDPHQWH PRO0 WR SL• DYDUD FRQ OXL= LO 46 IHEEUDLR 49:; 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL/ SRFR SL• FKH FLQ0 TXDQWHQQH ´SDVVz D PLJOLRU YLWDµ VHQ]D QHSSXU IDU WHVWDPHQWR> ODVFLz OD PR0 JOLH /XFUH]LD )DULQD FRQ GXH ILJOL DQFRUD SLFFROL GL QRPH %DUWRORPHR H *LUR0 ODPR1 ,O ODYRUR QHOO·D]LHQGD WLSRJUDILFD GHL 6ROLDQL 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL ODVFLDYD XQ·D]LHQGD RUPDL FRQVROLGDWD> VLPLOH LQ WXWWR DOOH QXPHURVH DOWUH FKH GD FLUFD GXHFHQWR DQQL HUDQR RUPDL GLVVHPLQDWH QHOO·LQWHUD (XURSD1 ,O ODYRUR LQ TXHVWH D]LHQGH WLSRJUDILFKH DYHYD UDJJLXQWR
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
433:
XQ OLYHOOR GL VWDQGDUGL]]D]LRQH WDOH GD ULPDQHUH TXDVL FRPSOHWDPHQWH VHQ]D YDULD]LRQL SHU DQFRUD XQ DOWUR VHFROR H PH]]R= ILQR DOOD QDVFLWD GHOOH SULPH PDFFKLQH SHU OD FRPSRVL]LRQH HG DOOD LQWURGX]LRQH GHO WRUFKLR LQ PHWDOOR QRQ SL• D]LRQDWR D PDQR1 ,Q DOWUH SDUROH GDOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 4XDWWURFHQ0 WR ILQR 0 GL IDWWR 0 DOOD XQLILFD]LRQH LWDOLDQD HG DQFKH XQ SRFKLQR GRSR/ L WL0 SRJUDIL VHJXLURQR QHOOD SURGX]LRQH GHL OLEUL WHFQLFKH/ SURFHGXUH H FRQVXHWX0 GLQL FKH FRQREEHUR LQ TXHVWR DUFR GL WHPSR SRFKLVVLPH YDULD]LRQL1 /D VWDP0 SHULD GHL 6ROLDQL H GHL ORUR HUHGL IX DWWLYD QHL ORFDOL GL SLD]]D *UDQGH GDOOD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR ILQR DO 4;:6/ TXDQGR SDVVz LQ DOWUH PDQL= SURSULR QHO PR0 PHQWR LQ FXL OH WLSRJUDILH/ DQFKH OH PHQR DPEL]LRVH FRPH OD QRVWUD/ VL WURYD0 URQR QHOOD QHFHVVLWj GL FRPSLHUH XQ VDOWR YHUVR QXRYH WHFQRORJLH SHU QRQ FRUUHUH LO SHULFROR GL VFRPSDULUH591 /·DWWLYLWj GHL 6ROLDQL VL VYROVH GXQTXH TXDVL WXWWD LQ TXHOOR FKH IX GHILQLWR O·DQFLHQ UpJLPH WLSRJUDSKLTXH1 9DOH IRUVH OD SHQD ULYLVLWDUH TXHVWR PRQGR 0 WDQWR GLYHUVR GDO QRVWUR 0 DYHQGR GL PLUD VRSUDWWXWWR L PRYLPHQWL/ OH SURFHGXUH OH DWWLYLWj H OH DELWXGLQL TXRWLGLDQH GL TXDQWL ODYRUDYDQR QHOO·RIILFLQD GHL 6ROLDQL H QHOOH QXPHURVH DOWUH FKH 0 VHQ]D UDJJLXQJHUH OH DOWH]]H GL 0DQX]LR/ GL 3ODQ0 WLQ/ GL 'LGRW R GL %RGRQL 0 KDQQR VIRUQDWR XQD TXDQWLWj HQRUPH GL OLEUL= DO0 FXQL EHOOL/ DOFXQL SDVVDELOL HG DOWUL GHFLVDPHQWH EUXWWL 0 WXWWL/ SHUz/ IUXWWR GL XQ ODYRUR GXUR H VQHUYDQWH LQ FRQGL]LRQL DPELHQWDOL FKH/ DQFKH TXDQGR O·D]LHQGD VL WURYDYD VXOOD SLD]]D SULQFLSDOH GHOOD FLWWj/ VRQR RJJL LQLPPDJLQD0 ELOL1 6HQWLUHPR VX TXHVWR SXQWR OD YRFH GL XQ WHVWLPRQH LOOXVWUH/ LO PHGLFR PRGHQHVH %HUQDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL FKH FH QH SDUOD QHO FDSLWROR GHO 'H PRUELV DUWLILFXP GHGLFDWR DL WLSRJUDIL1 ,Q DOWUD VHGH PL VRQR JLj RFFXSDWR GHL ORFDOL GHOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD/ OD SL• LPSRUWDQWH VWDPSHULD GL 0RGHQD GHO VHFRQGR 6HWWHFHQWR/ DOORUD VLWXDWD QHOO·DOD 1RUG02ULHQWDOH GHO SDOD]]R GHL *HVXLWL GL ILDQFR DOOD FKLHVD GL VDQ %DUWRORPHR1 +R DOORUD LOOXVWUDWR EUHYHPHQWH DQFKH O·HGLILFLR LQ FXL DYHYD VH0 GH OD VWDPSHULD GHL 6ROLDQL1 4XL PL LQWHUHVVD VROR VRWWROLQHDUH XQ SXQWR IRQ0 GDPHQWDOH= D GLIIHUHQ]D GL TXDQWR VLDPR DELWXDWL D VXSSRUUH/ O·D]LHQGD WLSR0 JUDILFD GL DQWLFR UHJLPH HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH OH GXH VWDPSHULH PRGHQHVL 0 OH XQL0 FKH GXH VWXGLDWH LQ ,WDOLD GD TXHVWR SXQWR GL YLVWD 0 SUHVHQWDQR XQD VWUXWWXUD DUFKLWHWWRQLFD YHUWLFDOH1 *OL VSD]L GHO ODYRUR/ LQ DOWUH SDUROH/ QRQ VRUJHYDQR O·XQR DFFDQWR DOO·DOWUR/ PD VL VRYUDSSRQHYDQR XQR VXOO·DOWUR1 4XDQGR %DUWR0 ²²²²²²²² 59 1HO 4:85/ DOOD PRUWH GL %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL MXQLRU/ ILJOLR GL 9LYLDQR/ JOL (UHGL FRQWL0 QXDURQR D WHQHUH DWWLYD OD VWDPSHULD ILQR DO 4;:6 TXDQGR IX DFTXLVWDWD GDOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUD0 ILFD 0RGHQHVH/ SHU SRL FRQIOXLUH QHOO·DWWXDOH WLSRJUDILD GL 0XFFKL (GLWRUH1
433;
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
ORPHR 6ROLDQL QHO 4:65 SHQVz GL DXPHQWDUH OD SURGX]LRQH QRQ VL ´DOODUJzµ RFFXSDQGR JOL VSD]L YLFLQL PD IDFHQGR VFDYDUH XQ ´FDQWLQLQRµ VRWWR OD ERWWH0 JD H FKLHGHQGR DOOD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH DG LQQDO]DUH O·HGLILFLR DO GL VRSUD GHL VRODL= VL DOODUJz/ FLRq/ LQ SURIRQGLWj HG LQ DOWH]]D1 6R0 OR LQ XQ FDVR JOL ULXVFu GL RFFXSDUH VWDQ]H YLFLQH/ TXDQGR FRQ O·DSHUWXUD GL XQD SRUWD PLVH LQ FRPXQLFD]LRQH OD VWDPSHULD FRQ O·DSSDUWDPHQWR GL )UDQ0 FHVFR 7RUUL/ DOORUD XQR GHL VXRL RSHUDL5:1 $EELDPR DQFKH SRFKH LQIRUPD]LRQL VXO QXPHUR HIIHWWLYR GHOOH SHUVRQH FKH ODYRUDYDQR QHOOD VXD D]LHQGD1 $ SDUWH O·LQGLFD]LRQH JHQHULFD GHL ´JDU]R0 QLµ SUHVHQWL LQ ERWWHJD JLj QHO 49945;/ XQ ULIHULPHQWR SUHFLVR OR DEELDPR QHO0 OD PLQXWD GL XQD SHWL]LRQH QRQ GDWDWD/ VFULWWD DWWRUQR DO 4:93 TXDQGR 6DOYD0 WRUH 9HQWXULQL HUD UHVSRQVDELOH GHOOD FHQVXUD GXFDOH> LQ HVVD JOL (UHGL 6ROLDQL DVVLFXUDQR LO GXFD GL DYHU IDWWR GHO ORUR PHJOLR SHU SRWHQ]LDUH O·D]LHQGD DO IL0 QH GL UHQGHUOD FRPSHWLWLYD QHL FRQIURQWL GL TXHOOH GHJOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL= SHU TXHVWR DYHYDQR DQFKH DXPHQWDWR LO QXPHUR GHJOL RSHUDL ILQR DG DYHUQH EHQ YHQWLGXH1 0D SRL JOL (UHGL 6ROLDQL ULWRUQDURQR VXOOH ORUR GHFLVLRQL1 &RQIHU0 PDURQR FRVu GL YROHU PDQWHQHUH LO SURSULR UDJJLR G·D]LRQH HQWUR L FRQILQL SL• WUDQTXLOOL GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ FRQWUR OH DPEL]LRQL GHO GXFD H GHL VXRL PLQL0 VWUL FKH DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ SL• YDVWR SURJHWWR SROLWLFR H FXOWXUDOH GHVLGHUDYDQR YHGHU VRUJHUH XQD JUDQGH WLSRJUDILD DWWLYD H SUHVWLJLRVD5<1 4XHVWR SURJHWWR SHU LO TXDOH LQ XQ SULPR PRPHQWR VL HUD LPSHJQDWR DQFKH LO FHOHEUH WLSRJUD0 IR YHQH]LDQR $QWRQLR =DWWD/ GLYHQQH SRL O·RELHWWLYR GL *LRYDQQL 0RQWDQDUL FKH DFTXLVWz L FDSLWDOL GHOOD WLSRJUDILD ERORJQHVH GL &ROOH $PHQR PD GRSR WUH DQQL IX FRVWUHWWR D FHGHUH WXWWR 0 OLEUL H FDSLWDOL GL VWDPSHULD 0 DOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD FKH/ JUD]LH DOOD VDSLHQWH UHJLD GL 0RVp %HQLDPLQR )Rj/ VRGGLVIH0 FH LQ SLHQR OH PLUH GXFDOL631 *OL (UHGL GL %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL WHQQHUR IHGH DO ORUR RUPDL VHFRODUH EXRQ VHQVR DO VHUYL]LR GHL FLWWDGLQL H GHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL PRGHQHVL VHQ]D DOWUH DPEL0 ]LRQL1 ,QIDWWL QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR YHQWLGXH RSHUDL/ WUD FRPSRVL0 ²²²²²²²² 5: 6XL ORFDOL GHOOD VWDPSHULD GL %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL VL YHGD *1 0217(&&+,/ $]LHQGH111 FLW1/ SS47:047;1 5; $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%/ 49941 5< 6L YHGD LQ SURSRVLWR %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD +%(02,/ 0VV1 &DPSRUL/ $SS1 Q1 5338/ :1614/ &DUWHJJLR /LEUDULR1 63 6XOOD WLSRJUDILD GL &ROOH $PHQR VL YHGD 61 )(55$5,/ /D VWDPSHULD GL &ROOH $PHQR= O·LPSUHVD HGLWRULDOH GL XQ SDWUL]LR ERORJQHVH/ LQ 3URGX]LRQH H FLUFROD]LRQH OLEUDULD D %RORJQD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 $YYLR GL XQ·LQGDJLQH/ %RORJQD/ ,VWLWXWR SHU OD VWRULD GL %RORJQD/ 4<;:/ SS1 57605<71
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
433<
WRUL/ EDWWLWRUL/ WLUDWRUL PDJD]]LQLHUL H JDU]RQL DYUHEEHUR IDWWR IXQ]LRQDUH D SLHQR ULWPR XQD D]LHQGD GL FLUFD WUH R TXDWWUR WRUFKL1 8QD WDOH FDSDFLWj SUR0 GXWWLYD/ WHQXWR FRQWR DQFKH GHL ODYRUL DO VHUYL]LR GHOOD FDQFHOOHULD GXFDOH/ GHO0 OD FXULD YHVFRYLOH H GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH FLWWDGLQD/ DQGDYD EHQ ROWUH OH HVL0 JHQ]H GL XQD FLWWj/ GL XQD ´FDSLWDOHµ 0 SLXWWRVWR VSHQWD LQ YHULWj 0 FRPH 0R0 GHQD1 '·DOWURQGH QHO VHFROR ;9,,, L 6ROLDQL HUDQR SULPD GL WXWWR LQWHUHVVDWL DO FRPPHUFLR OLEUDULR/ LPSHJQDWL SULQFLSDOPHQWH GD XQD SDUWH D UDFFRJOLHUH DV0 VRFLD]LRQL DG HGL]LRQL GL DOWUL VWDPSDWRUL H GDOO·DOWUR D YHQGHUH DO SXEEOLFR PRGHQHVH TXDQWR L ORUR FROOHJKL GHOOH DOWUH FLWWj LWDOLDQH H VRSUDWWXWWR GL 9H0 QH]LD SRQHYDQR VXO PHUFDWR1 4XHVWR VRSUDWWXWWR FL WHVWLPRQLD DQFRUD RJJL LO ORUR FDUWHJJLR OLEUDULR FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD641 /·D]LHQGD GHL 6ROLDQL HUD GXQTXH WXWWR VRPPDWR DEEDVWDQ]D PRGHVWD1 8QD GHFLQD R SRFR SL• GL RSHUDL FRVWLWXLYDQR FRQ RJQL SUREDELOLWj LO VXR RUJDQLFR HIIHWWLYR DQFKH QHL WHPSL PLJOLRUL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 1HO 6HLFHQWR SRL/ FRQ L VXRL GXH WRUFKL H DOFXQL JDU]RQL QRQ ROWUHSDVVDYD GL PROWR OH GLPHQVLRQL ID0 PLOLDUL1 /·D]LHQGD GHL 6ROLDQL QHO 49:; 0D WRUQLDPR DO 49:;1 /XFUH]LD )DULQD/ XQ SR· GL WHPSR GRSR OD VFRPSDU0 VD GHO PDULWR 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL/ VL UHFz GD *LRYDQQL $QWRQLR )RQWDQD ´QRWDUR PRGHQHVH/ GRWWRUH GHOO·XQD H GHOO·DOWUD OHJJH/ *LXGLFH KRQRUDQGR DOO·RIILFLR GHL 6LJQRUL $YYRFDWL GHOO·,OO1PD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD SHU LO FRUUHQWH VHPH0 VWUH HOHWWR GHSXWDWRµ SHU RWWHQHUH OD WXWHOD GHL ILJOL1 /H IX FRQFHVVR GL GLYHQL0 UH QRQ VROR WXWULFH GHL SXSLOOL/ PD DQFKH ´DPPLQLVWUDWULFH GHL ORUR EHQL/ SXU0 FKp IDFFLD O·LQYHQWDULR GH· EHQL ORUR/ H TXHOOR HVLELVFD D PH QRWDLR SHU UHJL0 VWUDUVL QHO SUHVHQWH LVWUXPHQWRµ/ REEOLJDQGRVL SRL ´LQ ILQH GHOOD VXGGHWWD WX0 WHOD GL UHQGHU FRQWR D GHWWL SXSLOOL R ORUR HUHGLµ1 /·LQYHQWDULR IX UHGDWWR FRQ PROWD FXUD HG DWWHQ]LRQH> LQILQH IX UHJLVWUDWR GDO QRWDLR QHOO·DWWR FRO TXDOH LO 46 OXJOLR 49:; YHQLYD FRQFHVVD DOOD YHGRYD OD WXWHOD VXL SXSLOOL651 ²²²²²²²² 64
/H &DUWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD VWDPSHULD 6ROLDQL +OH SULPH ULVDOJRQR DOOD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR TXDQGR SUHVH LQ PDQR O*D]LHQGD %DUWRORPHR/ ILJOLR GL 9LYLDQR, VRQR FRQVHUYDWH LQ $602/ $FTXLVWL/ E1 51 65 *OL DWWL QRWDULOL GHOOD WXWHOD H O·LQYHQWDULR GHOOD VWDPSHULD VRQR FRQVHUYDWL LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0RGHQD/ %&RQWUDWWL%/ 49:;/ YRO1 8/ Q1 7;31 '·RUD LQ SRL/ SHU QRQ DSSHVDQWL0 UH LQXWLOPHQWH OD OHWWXUD/ OH FLWD]LRQL SUHVH GDOO·LQYHQWDULR GHOOD 6WDPSHULD 6ROLDQL UHGDWWR QHO 49:; VDUDQQR LQGLFDWH LQ QRWD FRQ LO ULIHULPHQWR= ,QYHQWDULR/ 49:;1
4343
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
&L q FRVu ULPDVWR XQ TXDGUR FRPSOHWR GHOOD D]LHQGD GHL 6ROLDQL YHUVR OD ILQH GHO ;9,, VHFROR/ XQD IRQWH GL FDSLWDOH LPSRUWDQ]D SHU FKLXQTXH YRJOLD RJJL FRQRVFHUH FRQFUHWDPHQWH XQD VWDPSHULD HG XQD OLEUHULD GL DQWLFR UHJL0 PH/ DO GL Oj GHOOD SXUD HOHQFD]LRQH GHL ORUR OLEUL RJJL FRQVHUYDWL QHOOH ELEOLR0 WHFKH SXEEOLFKH H SULYDWH1 ,O IDWWR GL WURYDUFL GL IURQWH DG XQD D]LHQGD GL LQWH0 UHVVH VWUHWWDPHQWH FLWWDGLQR H ORFDOH DXPHQWD H QRQ GLPLQXLVFH LO YDORUH GL TXHVWR LQYHQWDULR1 ,QIDWWL/ PHQWUH OH HGL]LRQL XVFLWH GDOOH LPSUHVH WLSRJUDIL0 FKH FKH SURGXFHYDQR OLEUL GL QRWHYROH SUHJLR HFRQRPLFR H FXOWXUDOH VRQR LQ JUDQ SDUWH JLXQWH ILQR D QRL/ WDQWR FKH SRVVLDPR VXSSRUUH LQ WXWWD WUDQTXLOOLWj FKH HVLVWD XQD GLIIHUHQ]D QRQ HFFHVVLYD H FRPXQTXH IDFLOPHQWH TXDQWLILFDEL0 OH WUD OH HGL]LRQL FKH QRL RJJL SRVVHGLDPR H TXHOOH FKH TXHVWH LPSUHVH PDJ0 JLRUL SURGXVVHUR/ SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD LQYHFH OH ERWWHJKH PLQRUL/ FRPH DS0 SXQWR TXHOOD GHL 6ROLDQL/ QRQ SRVVLDPR QHSSXUH LSRWL]]DUH LO GLYDULR 0 VHP0 SUH QRWHYROH 0 FKH LQWHUFRUUH WUD L OLEUL FRQVHUYDWL QHOOH QRVWUH ELEOLRWHFKH H TXHOOL FKH XVFLURQR GDL ORUR WRUFKL1 3URGXVVHUR RSXVFROL/ IRJOL YRODQWL/ OLEUHWWL H OLEULFLQL GL DWWXDOLWj FKH HQWUDURQR QHOOH FDVH/ QHOOH FKLHVH/ QHOOH ERWWHJKH HG HUDQR WDOPHQWH ´XVDWLµ GD HVVHUH QHO JLUR GL XQD R GXH JHQHUD]LRQL VRVWLWXLWL GD DOWUL WHVWL VLPLOL XVFLWL QHO IUDWWHPSR1 1DVFHYDQR QRQ SHU HVVHUH FRQVHUYDWL FRPH L ORUR IUDWHOOL SL• IRUWXQDWL/ PD SHU HVVHUH XVDWL H SRL JHWWDWL1 (QWUDYDQR GDSSHUWXWWR/ VL ORJRUDYDQR LQ FHQWR PLOD PRGL/ PD QRQ HQWUDYDQR PDL QHOOH ELEOLRWHFKH GHL GRWWL H GHL SRWHQWL1 4XHVWH XOWLPH FRPLQFLDURQR DG DSULUH OH ORUR SRUWH DOOD SURGX]LRQH HIILPHUD HG RFFDVLRQDOH VROR PROWR WDUGL= TXDQGR GDOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHOO·2WWRFHQWR VL SRVz DQFKH VX GL HVVD LO EHQHYROR LQWH0 UHVVDPHQWR GL DOFXQL ELEOLRILOL LPSHJQDWL D UDFFRJOLHUH OH XOWLPH UHOLTXLH GL XQ SDWULPRQLR OLEUDULR DQGDWR RUPDL TXDVL FRPSOHWDPHQWH GLVSHUVR> LQ DOWUL WHU0 PLQL/ WDQWR SHU UHVWDUH LQ FDVD QRVWUD/ JUDQ SDUWH GHOOD SURGX]LRQH PLQRUH PRGHQHVH GL DQWLFR UHJLPH FL q VWDWD FRQVHUYDWD VRSUDWWXWWR GDOOD SDVVLRQH H GDOO·LPSHJQR GHO FRQWH *LRUJLR )HUUDUL 0RUHQL H GL SRFKL DOWUL FXOWRUL GL PHPRULH SDWULH YLVVXWL WUD 2WWR H 1RYHFHQWR1 1HL ORUR IRQGL OLEUDUL/ FRQIOXLWL SRL LQ ELEOLRWHFKH SXEEOLFKH/ H LQ TXHOOL GHOOH FRVLGGHWWH FRUSRUD]LRQL UHOLJLR0 VH VRSSUHVVH VL FRQVHUYD JUDQ SDUWH GHOOD SURGX]LRQH HIILPHUD GHO 6HLFHQWR H GHO 6HWWHFHQWR= DQFRUD XQD YROWD GDOOD QRELOWj H GDO FOHUR FL YLHQH XQD XOWHULR0 UH WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOD YLWD GL DQWLFR UHJLPH661 ²²²²²²²² 66 $QFRUD WXWWD GD VFULYHUH OD VWRULD GHOOH DFTXLVL]LRQL ELEOLRJUDILFKH GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (0 VWHQVH QHO FRUVR GHOO·2WWRFHQWR> O·DWWHQ]LRQH ULYROWD/ JLXVWDPHQWH/ DO ULFFR IRQGR DQWLFR KD IDWWR GLPHQWLFDUH FKH L IRQGL GHL FROOH]LRQLVWL RWWRFHQWHVFKL 0 WUD HVVL *LXVHSSH &DPSRUL FRQ OD VXD UDFFROWD GL PDQRVFULWWL 0 KDQQR GDWR XQ QRWHYROH FRQWULEXWR DO UHFXSHUR GL SDWULPRQL
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4344
1RQRVWDQWH O·LQWHUHVVDPHQWR GHL ELEOLRILOL/ FLz FKH HVVL VRQR ULXVFLWL D FRQVHUYDUFL UHVWD DQFRUD XQD SLFFROLVVLPD UHOLTXLD GL TXDQWR IX HIIHWWLYDPHQ0 WH SURGRWWR1 $OPHQR SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD XQ EUHYH SHULRGR GHOO·DWWLYLWj GHOO·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL/ q SRVVLELOH VXSHUDUH LO GLYDULR WUD LO SRFR FKH FL q ULPDVWR H TXHOOR FKH DOORUD IX SRVWR LQ FLUFROD]LRQH> LQIDWWL/ JUD]LH DOO·LQYHQWDULR GHL EHQL ODVFLDWL GD 9LYLDQR DJOL HUHGL/ SRVVHGLDPR O·HOHQFR FRPSOHWR GHL OLEUL H GHOOH VWDPSH FKH JLDFHYDQR QHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 49:;1 ,QROWUH O·LQYHQWDULR FL RIIUH XQ TXDGUR FRPSOHWR GHOO·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL/ DOORUD DUWLFRODWD LQ TXDWWUR GLYHUVL VHWWRUL GL DWWLYLWj= OD ´]LWWDULDµ/ OD ´VWDPSDµ/ OD ´ERWWHJDµ H LO ´PDJD]]LQRµ= ,O QRWDLR 0 H TXHVWR SXUH q XQ IDWWR QRWHYROH 0 FL ODVFLD DQFKH XQD GHVFUL]LRQH SDUWLFRODUHJJLDWD GHOO·DELWD]LRQH GL 9LYLDQR 6R0 OLDQL FRQ WXWWL L VXRL EHQL/ FRQ OH ´PRELOLHµ/ FRQ L ´YHVWLPHQWLµ H FRQ OD ´ELDQ0 FKHULDµ1 (· XQD VFKHJJLD GHOOD YLWD GHO SDVVDWR FKH JLXQJH TXDVL LQWDWWD ILQR D QRL1 /D JHWWHULD 6L q VROLWL SHQVDUH FKH SRFKH VWDPSHULH GHO 6HLFHQWR SRVVHGHVVHUR XQD IRQGHULD SHU L FDUDWWHUL/ H FKH OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GL HVVH VL ULIRUQLVVH SUHVVR ERWWHJKH VSHFLDOL]]DWH1 &HUWDPHQWH HUD FRVu DOO·LQL]LR DQFKH SHU %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL1 1HO 4989 LQIDWWL DFTXLVWz D 9HQH]LD FDUDWWHUL QXRYL SHU 9333 OLUH PR0 GHQHVL671 0D L FDUDWWHUL VL ORJRUDYDQR LQ IUHWWD HG DVVLHPH DOOD FDUWD DQGDYDQR DG DXPHQWDUH LQ PRGR VSURSRVLWDWR LO FRVWR GL SURGX]LRQH GHO OLEUR1 3HU TXHVWR *LXOLDQR &DVVLDQL QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR DYHYD IDWWR YHQLUH D 0RGHQD D IRQGHUH FDUDWWHUL SHU OD SURSULD D]LHQGD *LRUJLR 3RQWLUROL681 , 6R0 OLDQL LQYHFH/ QRQ VDSSLDPR GL SUHFLVR TXDQGR/ DYHYDQR PHVVR LQ SLHGL XQD ORUR JHWWHULD SHU OD IXVLRQH GHL FDUDWWHUL GL FXL VL VHUYLYDQR QHOOD VWDPSD1 3HU PHJOLR OHJJHUH H FDSLUH LO QRVWUR LQYHQWDULR q EHQH ULFRUGDUH EUHYH0 PHQWH LO ODYRUR FKH VL VYROJHYD QHOOH JHWWHULH1 3ULPD GL WXWWR XQ LQFLVRUH SUH0 SDUDYD L SXQ]RQL GL DFFLDLR> VX RJQXQR GL HVVL HUD LQFLVR XQD OHWWHUD GHOO·DOIDEHWR/ XQ IUHJLR/ XQD QRWD PXVLFDOH R TXDOVLDVL DOWUR VHJQR VL YROHVVH SRL VWDPSDUH1 &RQ L SXQ]RQL YHQLYDQR SRL SUHSDUDWH OH PDWULFL/ QHO QRVWUR LQYHQWDULR FKLDPDWH ´PDGULµ/ FRQVLVWHQWL LQ XQ FXEHWWR GL UDPH FKH ULFHYHYD ²²²²²²²² DQWLFKL FRQVLGHUDWL XQ WHPSR GL PLQRUH LPSRUWDQ]D/ PD RJJL GLYHQXWL IRQGDPHQWDOL SHU OD FRQRVFHQ]D GHJOL DVSHWWL SL• ULSRVWL GHOOD YLWD GHO SDVVDWR1 67 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%/ 49891 68 $602/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ 3DUWLFRODUL/ 3RQWLUROL1
4345
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
LQ FDYR LO VHJQR GHO SXQ]RQH> OD PDGUH YHQLYD SRL VHUUDWD HQWUR XQD ´IRUPDµ/ JHQHUDOPHQWH GL RWWRQH R GL EURQ]R/ GHQWUR OD TXDOH YHQLYD DOOD ILQH FRODWD OD OHJD GL SLRPER H GHJOL DOWUL PHWDOOL GL FXL HUDQR FRPSRVWL L FDUDWWHUL WLSRJUDIL0 FL691 (QWULDPR RUD QHOOD ´]LWWDULDµ GHL 6ROLDQL= QHO 49:; YL HUDQR EHQ 6:5 SXQ0 ]RQL FRQ LQFLVH OHWWHUH/ VHJQL JUDILFL/ IUHJL H FDQWR IHUPR1 /H ´PDGULµ JLj SURQWH SHU OD IXVLRQH HUDQR LQ WXWWR 4;461 'L HVVH/ 475 DYHYDQR IUHJL HG DOWUL VHJQL/ DOWUH 49 FRQWHQHYDQR LQYHFH LO FDQWR IHUPR> TXHOOH UHVWDQWL 0 4988 LQ WXWWR 0 VHUYLYDQR DOOD IXVLRQH GL 47 GLYHUVH VHULH GL FDUDWWHUL DOIDEHWLFL/ GLVWLQ0 WDPHQWH LQGLFDWH FRQ L ORUR QRPL DOORUD LQ XVR> DG RJQL VHULH GL FDUDWWHUL FRU0 ULVSRQGHYD XQ QXPHUR GL PDWULFL FKH RVFLOODYD IUD OH FHQWR H OH FHQWRFLQ0 TXDQWD XQLWj> VROR SHU OD VHULH )LORVRILD WRQGR HUD VWDWR SUHSDUDWR XQ QXPHUR GRSSLR GL PDWULFL> IRUVH QH VWDYDQR IRQGHQGR SURSULR DOORUD GXH VHULH FRP0 SOHWDPHQWH LGHQWLFKH1 /D VWDPSHULD= L FRPSRVLWRUL ,O PDWHULDOH GHOOD IRQGHULD GL FDUDWWHUL HUD 0 D TXDQWR SDUH 0 RUGLQDWDPHQWH VLVWHPDWR QHOOD VWHVVD VWDQ]D LQ FXL DYYHQLYD OD FRPSRVL]LRQH> WUD JOL ´XWHQVL0 JOL GLYHUVL VSHWWDQWL DOOD ]LWWDULDµ LQFRQWULDPR/ LQIDWWL/ DQFKH ´GXH DYDQWDJJL JUDQGL/ YHQWL FRPSRVLWRUL/ FLQTXH FD]]HWWH/ XQD IRUPD GL OHJQR GD IDU OLQH0 Hµ6:1 ,O ODYRUR GHL FRPSRVLWRUL q UDSSUHVHQWDWR LQ XQD LQFLVLRQH GHOO·,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR GL 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL VWDPSDWD GD %DUWRORPHR 6R0 OLDQL QHO 498<6;1 ,O FRPSRVLWRUH q VHGXWR GDYDQWL DOOD JUDQGH FDVVD GHL FDUDWWH0 UL QHOO·DWWR GL SUHQGHUH FRQ OD GHVWUD OH OHWWHUH H GL LQVHULUOH QHO FRPSRVLWRLR/ XQ·DVWD GL OHJQR QHOOD TXDOH VL SRWHYD DOOLQHDUH XQD ULJD GL WHVWR> PHQWUH HJOL FRPSLH TXDVL DXWRPDWLFDPHQWH TXHVWH RSHUD]LRQL/ OHJJH LO WHVWR GD FRPSRUUH GD XQ HVHPSODUH VLVWHPDWR VX XQ YLVRULXP YLFLQR DOOD FDVVD1 4XDQGR LO FRPSRVLWRUH DYHYD ILQDOPHQWH WHUPLQDWR GL FRPSRUUH XQD ULJD GL WHVWR/ OD GHSRQHYD QHO YDQWDJJLR/ XQD VSHFLH GL FDVVHWWD GL OHJQR FKH FRQ0 WHQHYD XQD LQWHUD SDJLQD GL WHVWR1 1HOO·LQYHQWDULR GHO 49:; VRQR HVSUHVVD0 PHQWH QRPLQDWL VROR ´DYDQWDJJL JUDQGLµ= HYLGHQWHPHQWH HUDQR TXHOOL FKH VHUYLYDQR DOOD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHJOL LQ IROLR> JOL DOWUL YDQWDJJL FKH VHUYLYDQR DOOD ²²²²²²²² 69 6XOOD IDEEULFD]LRQH GHL FDUDWWHUL VL YHGD &1 )$+</ 'HVFUL]LRQL FLQTXHFHQWHVFKH GHOOD IDEEULFD0 ]LRQH GHL FDUDWWHUL H GHO SURFHVVR WLSRJUDILFR/ LQ ©/D %LEOLRILOLDª/ ;; +4<;9,/ SS1 7:0;91 6: ,QYHQWDULR/ 49:;1 6; 6L YHGD '1 *$0%(57,/ ,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR/ 0RGHQD/6ROLDQL/498</ S1 8861
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4346
FRPSRVL]LRQH GHL OLEUL LQ TXDUWR/ LQ RWWDYR H VRSUDWWXWWR LQ GRGLFHVLPR 0 L IRUPDWL PDJJLRUPHQWH XVDWL GDL 6ROLDQL 0 D FDXVD GHOOH ORUR GLPHQVLRQL ULGRW0 WH IXURQR UDJJUXSSDWL QHL ´PROWL DOWUL XWHQVLJOL H PRELOL GLYHUVL QHFHVVDUL SHU VHUYL]LR GHOOD VWDPSD6<1 /·DVVRUWLPHQWR GHL FDUDWWHUL/ VSHFLDOPHQWH VH FRQIURQWDWR FRQ TXDQWR SRVVHGHYD *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL DOO·LQL]LR GHO VHFROR/ DSSDUH DEEDVWDQ]D YD0 ULR1 6L VD FKH OD TXDOLWj H OD YDULHWj GHL FDUDWWHUL/ SL• DQFRUD FKH OD TXDQWLWj GHL WRUFKL/ FL SHUPHWWRQR GL YDOXWDUH FRQ EXRQD DSSURVVLPD]LRQH OD FDSDFLWj HG LO OLYHOOR GL SURGX]LRQH GL XQ·D]LHQGD WLSRJUDILFD1 4XDQGR XQ WLSRJUDIR YROH0 YD GDU IXRUL XQ·HGL]LRQH GL SUHVWLJLR HUD VRSUDWWXWWR GHOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH FKH GL VROLWR VL SUHRFFXSDYD1 , 6ROLDQL QHO 49:; SRVVHGHYDQR TXDWWRUGLFL VHULH FRPSOHWH GL FDUDWWHUL= OD GRSSLD VHULH +FRUVLYR H WRQGR, GHO *DUDPRQH/ GHOO·$QWLFR FRPXQH H GHO 7HVWR 3DUDJRQH> XQD VHULH GL WRQGR H GXH +XQD ORJRUD H O·DOWUD DSSHQD XVFLWD GDOOD JHWWHULD, GL 7HVWR G·$OGR/ SL• GXH VHULH GL WRQGR H GXH GL FRUVLYR +DQFKH TXL XQD YHFFKLD HG XQD QXRYD, GL 6LOYLR> LQILQH FKLXGH0 YD OD OLVWD GHL FDUDWWHUL XQ &DQRQFLQR WRQGR/ VHQ]D FRUVLYR/ VHJXLWR GD XQ YDVWR DVVRUWLPHQWR GL ´IUHJL GLYHUVL H OLQHHµ1 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL ROWUH D ULQQRYDUH GL FRQWLQXR L FDUDWWHUL 0 DEELDQR DSSHQD UHJLVWUDWR OD VHULH QXRYD GL 7HVWR G·$OGR FRUVLYR H OH GXH VHULH SXUH QXRYH GL 6LOYLR DIILDQFDWH GDOOH ULVSHWWLYH VHULH RUPDL ORJRUH 0 DYHYD GL FHUWR SURJHWWDWR/ SRFR SULPD GL PRULUH/ XQ DOODUJDPHQWR GHO VXR DVVRUWLPHQWR> LQIDWWL QHOO·,QYHQWDULR GHOOD ]LWWDULD q SUHVHQWH XQD JUDQGLVVLPD TXDQWLWj GL ´PDGULµ GL )LORVRILD WRQGR/ QRQ DQFRUD SUHVHQWH QHO FDPSLRQDULR GHOOD VDOD GL FRPSRVL0 ]LRQH1 8QD VLPLOH YDULHWj GL FDUDWWHUL UDSSRUWDWD DOOH GLPHQVLRQL HG DO OLYHOOR GL SURGX]LRQH GHO 6ROLDQL 0 TXDVL HVFOXVLYDPHQWH ORFDOH H FLWWDGLQD 0 FL ODVFLD O·LPSUHVVLRQH GL WURYDUFL GL IURQWH DG XQD D]LHQGD FKH SRVVHGHYD TXDQWR OH VHUYLYD SHU IDU IURQWH VHQ]D GLIILFROWj DOOH ULFKLHVWH IUDQFDPHQWH PRGHVWH GL XQD FLWWj FRPH 0RGHQD1 ,QROWUH OD JHWWHULD SHUPHWWHYD DL 6ROLDQL GL ULQQRYDUH DOO·RFFRUUHQ]D L ORUR FDUDWWHUL ORJRUL VHQ]D GRYHU ULFRUUHUH RJQL YROWD D IRUWL LQYHVWLPHQWL GL FDSLWDOL1 /·D]LHQGD HUD FLRq RUJDQL]]DWD LQ PRGR WDOH GD HVVHUH LQ XQ FHUWR VHQVR DXWRVXIILFLHQWH VLD QHOOD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHL FDUDWWHUL/ VLD/ SX0 UH/ QHO SURFXUDUVL OD FDUWD LO FXL SUH]]R YHQLYD LQ JUDQ SDUWH FRSHUWR GDOOD IRU0 QLWXUD DL IROOL GHJOL VWUDFFL UDFFROWL GDL 6ROLDQL LQ XQD SDUWH GHOOD FDPSDJQD PRGHQHVH731 1RQ VDSSLDPR VH TXHVWD SURGX]LRQH LQ SURSULR GL FDUDWWHUL VLD ²²²²²²²² 6< 73
,QYHQWDULR/ 49:;1 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%1
4347
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
GXUDWD DQFRUD SHU PROWR WHPSR> QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR DG RJQL PRGR LO ORUR DVVRUWLPHQWR HUD HQRUPHPHQWH DXPHQWDWR= OH VHULH GL FDUDWWHUL 0 FRPH DSSUHQGLDPR GD XQD 0RVWUD GH· FDUDWWHUL HVLVWHQWL QHOOD VWDPSHULD GHJOL HUHGL GL %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL 0 HUDQR RUPDL 59 DQFKH VH OH SUHWHVH GHOO·D]LHQGD HUDQR UL0 PDVWH PRGHVWH> DQFKH LQ 0RGHQD HVVD HUD VWDWD GHFLVDPHQWH VXSHUDWD SHU FDSDFLWj H TXDOLWj GL SURGX]LRQH SULPD GD *LRYDQQL 0RQWDQDUL H SRL GDOOD VWDPSHULD GHOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD GHJOL HEUHL 0RVp %HQLDPLQR )Rj HG (0 PDQXHOH 6DFHUGRWL1 ,O ODYRUR GL FRPSRVL]LRQH/ FHUWDPHQWH LO SL• TXDOLILFDWR DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD VWDPSHULD/ HUD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH SHVDQWH1 &RPH DO VROLWR q %HUQDUGLQR 5DPD]0 ]LQL/ QHO VXR FRORULWR ODWLQR GHO 'H PRUELV DUWLILFXP DG LQIRUPDUFL GHOOD ORUR ID0 WLFD H GHOOH ORUR PDODWWLH SURIHVVLRQDOL= L FRPSRVLWRUL ´VWDQGR TXDVL VHPSUH VHGXWL SUHQGRQR L FDUDWWHUL PHWDOOLFL GDL ORUR FDVVHWWLQL H FRPSRQJRQR OH SD0 UROH/ RSSXUH TXDQGR QRQ QH KDQQR SL• ELVRJQR/ VFRPSRQJRQR TXHVWL VWHVVL FDUDWWHUL H OL ULPHWWRQR DL ORUR SRVWLµ> HVVL ROWUH DOOH LQIHUPLWj GRYXWH DO IDWWR FKH VWDQQR VHPSUH VHGXWL/ ´YDQQR LQFRQWUR DG XQ·DOWUD PDODWWLD/ SRLFKp/ PHQWUH KDQQR VHPSUH ILVVL JOL RFFKL VX TXHL FDUDWWHUL GL FRORUH QHUR/ SHUGRQR SRFR DOOD YROWD OD FDSDFLWj GL YHGHUH> GL FRQVHJXHQ]D D FRORUR FKH QRQ KDQQR GHJOL RFFKL SURSULR VDQL/ VL RIIXVFD OD YLVWD FRQ FDWDUDWWH H DOWUH LQIHUPLWjµ1 %HUQDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL DJJLXQJH GL DYHU FRQRVFLXWR GXH IUDWHOOL WLSRJUDIL ´FKH VL WURYDURQR QHOOD QHFHVVLWj GL DEEDQGRQDUH O·DUWH/ SHU QRQ GLYHQLUH FRPSOH0 WDPHQWH FLHFKLµ741 $SSURIRQGLVFH SRL OD SURSULD DQDOLVL GHOOH PDODWWLH H FRQ0 VLJOLD FRQ XQD FKLDUH]]D YHUDPHQWH HVHPSODUH TXDOL D VXR DYYLVR GRYUHEEHUR HVVHUH L ULPHGL GD DGRWWDUH1 ,QILQH QRL/ RJJL/ QRQ SRVVLDPR FHUWR GLPHQWLFDUH Qp O·LQWRVVLFD]LRQH GD SLRPER/ Qp OH DOWUH PDODWWLH DPELHQWDOL FDXVDWH GDOOH PDOVDQH ERWWHJKH GHOO·HWj GL DQWLFR UHJLPH1 /D VWDPSHULD= L WRUFROLHUL (· RUPDL RUD GL ODVFLDUH L FRPSRVLWRUL DOOH ORUR FDVVH H GL ULYROJHUH OD QR0 VWUD DWWHQ]LRQH DJOL 8WHQVLJOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD VWDPSD1 1HOO·LQYHQWDULR GHO 49:; VRQR UHJLVWUDWL GXH WRUFKL GD VWDPSD= XQR ´SLFFROR FRQ YLGD/ SLDQR H PDGUH YLGD GL EURQ]Rµ/ HG XQR ´QRUPDOH FRQ YLGD/ PDGUH YLGD H SLDQR GL EURQ]Rµ1 &KL KD UHGDWWR O·LQYHQWDULR QRQ DYHYD/ SHUz/ PROWD SD]LHQ]D> SHU LO UHVWR VL OLPLWz LQIDWWL D VHJQDUH ´WUH WHOODUL GD WRUFKLR PH]]DQL/ GXRL WHOODUL SLFROLµ H ²²²²²²²² 74
6L YHGD LO WHVWR ODWLQR GL TXHVWH FLWD]LRQL LQ %1 5$0$==,1,/ 'H PRUELV 111FLW1/ SS16:706::1
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4348
SRL WDJOLz FRUWR= ´PROWL DOWUL XWHQVLJOL H PRELOL GLYHUVL QHFHVVDUL SHU LO VHUYL]LR GHOOD VWDPSDµ1 /·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL DOOD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR DYHYD GXQTXH WXH WRUFKL= XQR SLF0 FROR HG XQR QRUPDOH1 3RWHYD LQ VRVWDQ]D/ TXDQGR OD QHFHVVLWj OR ULFKLHGHYD/ PDQGDUH DYDQWL GXH ODYRUL FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH1 1RQ VL YD PROWR ORQWDQR GDO YHUR VH VL LSRWL]]D FKH 0 DOPHQR QHOOH LQWHQ]LRQL H QHL SURJUDPPL 0 LO WRU0 FKLR SLFFROR IRVVH LQ JHQHUH XWLOL]]DWR SHU OH VWDPSH FRUUHQWL/ TXDOL EDQGH/ JULGH/ VRQHWWL R FDQ]RQL G·RFFDVLRQH/ LQGXOJHQ]H/ SUHJKLHUH R LPPDJLQL GL VDQWL FKH VL SURGXFHYDQR H VL PHWWHYDQR LQ FLUFROD]LRQH QHO JLUR GL SRFKL JLRUQL> O·DOWUR WRUFKLR LQYHFH 0 TXHOOR ´QRUPDOHµ 0 VHUYLVVH SUREDELOPHQWH DOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHL OLEUL FKH ULFKLHGHYDQR XQD PDJJLRUH TXDQWLWj GL WHPSR H GL ODYRUR= VHUYLVVH LQVRPPD HVSUHVVDPHQWH DO SURJUDPPD HGLWRULDOH GHL 6ROLDQL1 'XH WRUFKL/ SHU ODYRUDUH DO SLHQR GHOOH ORUR SRVVLELOLWj/ FRPSRUWDYDQR OD SUHVHQ]D GL DOPHQR TXDWWUR WRUFROLHUL/ FLRq GL XQ EDWWLWRUH H GL XQ WLUDWRUH SHU RJQL WRUFKLR/ SL• XQ TXDOFKH JDU]RQH GL ERWWHJD1 , FRPSLWL GHO EDWWLWRUH H GHO WLUDWRUH VRQR LOOXVWUDWL FRPH DO VROLWR QHOO·LQFLVLRQH JLj ULFRUGDWD GDOO·,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR1 ,Q HVVD XQ XRPR 0 LQ YHULWj XQR VFKHOHWUR VHFRQGR O·DOOHJRULD XQ SR· PDFDEUD GHO *DPEHUWL FKH SDUDJRQD OD EUHYLWj GHOOD YLWD DO EUHYLVVLPR WHPSR FKH L OLEUL SDVVDQR LQ WLSRJUDILD= ´QRQ YXRO IDU JUDQGL VSH0 VH QHOO·LPSUHVVLRQH GHOO·KXPDQD YLWD OD 0RUWHµ75 0 LQFKLRVWUD L FDUDWWHUL EDW0 WHQGR FRQ L GXH PD]]L/ WDPSRQL VHPLVIHULFL PXQLWL GL XQ PDQLFR/ VXOOD IRU0 PD1 2JQL YROWD LQIDWWL LO FRPSRVLWRUH DYHYD XOWLPDWR XQD SDJLQD GL WHVWR/ HVVD YHQLYD LPSRVWDWD LQ XQD IRUPD/ FKH DYHYD VHPSUH OH GLPHQVLRQL GHO IRJOLR GD VWDPSDUH1 ,Q RJQXQD GL TXHVWH IRUPH YHQLYDQR FROORFDWH WDQWH SDJLQH TXDQWH QH HUDQR ULFKLHVWH GDOOD SLHJDWXUD FKH VL YROHYD GDUH DO IRJOLR DOORUFKp OR VL VDUHEEH WUDVIRUPDWR LQ XQ IDVFLFROR GHO OLEUR= GXH SDJLQH SHU O·LQ IROLR/ TXDWWUR SHU O·LQ TXDUWR/ RWWR SHU LQ RWWDYR/ GRGLFL SHU O·LQ GRGLFHVLPR H VHGLFL 0 RY0 YLDPHQWH 0 SHU O·LQ1VHGLFHVLPR1 /·DOWUR RSHUDLR DGGHWWR DO WRUFKLR VL FKLDPDYD WLUDWRUH> PHQWUH LO FROOHJD LQFKLRVWUDYD OD IRUPD/ HJOL LQVHULYD LO IRJOLR ELDQFR LQ XQ WHODLR IRUPDWR GD GXH SDUWL GHWWH ´WLPSDQRµ H ´IUDVFKHWWDµ FKH OR SURWHJJHYDQR VLD GDOO·HFFHVVLYD YLROHQ]D GHOOD SUHVVLRQH/ VLD GDOOH PDFFKLH DFFLGHQWDOL1 6XELWR GRSR WLUDYD O·LQVLHPH GL WLPSDQR/ IRJOLR/ IUDVFKHWWD H IRUPD PRQWDWL VX XQ FDUUR FRQ JXLGH LQ IHUUR/ VRWWR LO ´SLDQRµ GHO WRUFKLR1 &RQ XQ FROSR GL EDUUD 0 LO PHFFDQLVPR GL YLWH/ PDGUH YLWH H EDUUD HUD VLPLOH D TXHOOR XVDWR QHL WRUFKL ²²²²²²²² 75
'1 *$0%(57,/ ,GHD 111FLW1/ S1 8861
4349
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
GD YLQR 0 VFKLDFFLDYD LO ´SLDQR GL EURQ]Rµ VXOOD SULPD PHWj GHO FDUUR H VWDP0 SDYD FRVu OD SULPD PHWj GHO IRJOLR> VXELWR GRSR FRQ OD GHVWUD DOOHQWDYD OD EDU0 UD H ULVROOHYDYD LO SLDQR/ H FRQ OD VLQLVWUD IDFHYD DYDQ]DUH VRWWR LO SLDQR O·DOWUD PHWj GHO FDUUR= XQ QXRYR FROSR GL EDUUD IDFHYD VWDPSDUH DQFKH O·DOWUD PHWj GHO IRJOLR> D TXHVWR SXQWR LO WLUDWRUH IDFHYD ULVDOLUH LO SLDQR/ ULWLUDYD LO FDUUR QHOOD VXD SRVL]LRQH LQL]LDOH/ H/ PHQWUH LO EDWWLWRUH LQFKLRVWUDYD GL QXRYR OD IRUPD/ HJOL PHWWHYD LO IRJOLR VWDPSDWR DG DVFLXJDUH H QH ULPHWWHYD XQR ELDQ0 FR WUD WLPSDQR H IUDVFKHWWD SHU ULSUHQGHUH VXELWR GRSR GD FDSR1 3HU TXHVWR FLFOR FRPSOHWR GL VWDPSD L GXH WRUFROLHUL LPSLHJDYDQR FLUFD XQD YHQWLQD GL VHFRQGL> VWDPSDYDQR FLRq GD 4;3 D 533 IRJOL RJQL RUD1 ,Q XQD LQWHUD JLRUQDWD GL ODYRUR SRWHYDQR XVFLUH GDO WRUFKLR FLUFD PLOOH H FLQTXHFHQWR IRJOL761 $QFKH TXHVWD LQJHQWH IDWLFD QRQ VIXJJu DO EXRQ 5DPD]]LQL1 5LSUHQGLDPR SHUFLz OD VXD GHVFUL]LRQH= ´GLYHUVR WLSR GL ODYRUR 0 ULVSHWWR D TXHOOR GHL FRP0 SRVLWRUL 0 q TXHOOR GL FRORUR FKH VWDQQR LQ SLHGL DGGHWWL DO WRUFKLR H FRQ DP0 ER OH PDQL LPELELVFRQR L FDUDWWHUL FRQ XQR VWUXPHQWR GL SHOOH ULJRQILD H SLH0 QR GL ODQDµ> TXHVWR HUD LO ODYRUR FRPSLXWR GDO EDWWLWRUH1 ´/·DOWUR LQYHFH 0 LO WLUDWRUH 0 PXRYH FRQ OD GHVWUD OD SDUWH VXSHULRUH GHO WRUFKLR H ID XQD IRUWH SUHVVLRQH WDQWR FKH QHOOR VSD]LR GL XQ DWWLPR DSSDUH VWDPSDWR VXOOD FDUWD WXWWR FLz FKH VL QDVFRQGHYD QHL FDUDWWHUL> H GL FRQWLQXR ULSHWRQR DOOR VWHVVR PRGR TXHVWD RSHUD]LRQH ILQR D FKH WXWWR LO ODYRUR QRQ VLD VWDWR SRUWDWR D WHUPLQH QHOOD TXDQWLWj SUHVFULWWDµ1 /H PDODWWLH GHL WRUFROLHUL/ FL LQIRUPD LO 5DPD]]LQL/ VRQR TXHOOH FKH GL VROLWR FROSLVFRQR WXWWL FRORUR FKH IDQQR ODYRUL SHVDQWL1 ,O IDWWR SRL GL GRYHUVL ´IHUPDUH WXWWR LO JLRUQR G·LQYHUQR LQ OXRJKL VXUULVFDOGDWL SHU SRWHU ODYRUDUH HG DVFLXJDUH OH FDUWH VWDPSDWHµ/ ID Vu FKH XQD YROWD XVFLWL GL Ou/ VH QRQ VWDQQR DWWHQWL/ YDQQR LQFRQWUR D QXPHURVH PDODWWLH UHVSLUDWRULH H FXWDQHH1 ,QROWUH ´VRQR SUHGD GL TXHVWL PDOL VSHFLDOPHQWH FROR0 UR FKH ODYRUDQR DO WRUFKLR> LQIDWWL/ SRLFKp/ SHU TXHVWR ODYRUR F·q ELVRJQR GL XQ JUDQGH PRYLPHQWR GHOOH EUDFFLD H GL WXWWR LO FRUSR/ FRVWRUR QRQ GL UDGR HVFRQR GDOOD WLSRJUDILD PDGLGL GL VXGRUH H YDQQR LQFRQWUR DOOH PDODWWLHµ1 %HUQDUGLQR 5DPD]]LQL Gj SRL DL WLSRJUDIL FRQVLJOL SL• FKH DOWUR GL QDWXUD SUH0 YHQWLYD H FRQFOXGH ODQFLDQGR XQ DFFRUDWR DSSHOOR DL PHGLFL VXRL FROOHJKL= ´$G IHOLFLRUHP WDPHQ FXUDWLRQHP REWLQHQGDP ERQXP VHPSHU HULW/ VL PHGL0 FXV VFLDW/ TXDP DUWHP H[HUFHUH VLW VROLWXV/ TXHP FXUDQGXP VXVFHSLWµ771 ²²²²²²²² 76 6XO ODYRUR LQ WLSRJUDILD VL YHGD -1 9(<5,10)255(5/ )DEULTXHU XQ OLYUH DX ;9,H VLqFOH/ LQ +LVWRULH GH O·pGLWLRQ IUDQoDLVH/ YRO1,/ 3DULJL/ 3URPRGLV/ 4<;5/ SS1 5:<06341 77 %1 5$0$==,1,/ 'H PRUELV 111FLW1/ S1 6:;1
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
434:
/D VWDPSHULD= L OHJQL GHL 6ROLDQL 1HOO·LQYHQWDULR GHL EHQL ODVFLDWL QHO 49:; GD 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL DL ILJOL WUD JOL 8WHQVLJOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD VWDPSD WURYLDPR DQFKH ´XQD EDQFD SLHQD GL ILJXUH GL OHJQR JUDQGH H SLFROH GL YDULH VRUWL/ XQD FDVVD JUDQGH SLHQD GL ILJXUH GL OHJQR JUDQGH/ FLQTXH EDQFKH SHU ULSRUYL OL FDUDWWHUL/ XQ VFDQ]HOOR FRQ QRYH FDVVHWWL GL IUHJJL/ VDQWL HW DUPH HW DQFR PLQLDWXUH GLYHUVHµ1 (· TXHVWD XQD GHOOH LQ0 IRUPD]LRQL SL• LQWHUHVVDQWL GL WXWWR O·LQYHQWDULR1 /·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL JLj ILQ GDO 6HLFHQWR SRVVHGHYD XQ JUDQGH DVVRUWLPHQWR GL OHJQL SHU VLORJUDILH1 1RWHYROH VRSUDWWXWWR VH UDSSRUWDWD DL UDPL SHU LQFLVLRQL UHJLVWUDWL VXELWR GRSR= ´3HVL +FRVu/ DOOD PRGHQHVH/ SHU SH]]L, GL UDPH GD VWDPSDUH GL GLYHUVH ILJXUH/ Q1;µ1 /·HVLJXR QXPHUR GL UDPL QRQ GHYH VWXSLUH= HVVL 0 FRPH DEELDPR YLVWR SHU O·RSHUD GHO *DPEHUWL 0 HUDQR TXDVL VHPSUH LQWHUDPHQWH SDJDWL GDO FRPPLW0 WHQWH HG D OXL ULWRUQDYDQR GRSR OH WLUDWXUH LQ WLSRJUDILD781 7RUQLDPR DL OHJQL1 *Lj QHOOD ERWWHJD GHO VDFHUGRWH H WLSRJUDIR $QWRQLR %HUJROOL DYHYDPR QRWDWR FRQ VWXSRUH OD SUHVHQ]D GL EHQ 557 ´IRUPH GL ILJX0 UHµ791 8QD TXDQWLWj IRUVH VXSHULRUH GL ´VDQWL H ILJXUDPLµ LQ OHJQR VL WURYDYD QHOO·D]LHQGD GL *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL DOO·LQL]LR GHO 6HLFHQWR7:1 (· GLIILFLOH GDO0 OH JHQHULFKH HVSUHVVLRQL GL TXHVWR ,QYHQWDULR GHO 49:; FRQRVFHUH FRQ SUHFLVLR0 QH OD TXDQWLWj GHL OHJQL SRVVHGXWL DOORUD GDL 6ROLDQL1 (VVD/ JLj D TXHL WHPSL HUD ULWHQXWD FRQVLGHUHYROH> OR VL DUJXLVFH IDFLOPHQWH GDO IDWWR FKH L OHJQL VRQR FRQVHUYDWL LQ XQD ´EDQFDµ/ FLRq LQ XQD FDVVDSDQFD/ ´SLHQDµ/ LQ XQD FDVVD ´JUDQGHµ/ SXUH SLHQD HG LQ XQR ´VFDQ]HOORµ GL QRYH FDVVHWWL1 ,O QRWDLR/ DQFKH VHQ]D PHWWHUVL D FRQWDUH/ VHPEUD SURSULR YROHU GLUH FKH GL OHJQL FH Q·HUDQR ILQ FKH VL YROHYD= LQ DEERQGDQ]D1 6L RVVHUYL LQROWUH FKH QHOOD FDVVD VRQR FRQ0 VHUYDWH VROR ´ILJXUH GL OHJQR JUDQGHµ/ FLRq L OHJQL GL IRUPDWR SL• DPSLR 0 LQ IROLR RSSXUH LQ TXDUWR 0 PHQWUH QHOOD FDVVDSDQFD YL HUDQR OHJQL GL WXWWH OH GL0 PHQVLRQL= PDWHULDOH HWHURJHQHR H IRUVH QRQ SL• DWWXDOH1 4XHVWL OHJQL FKH D TXDQWR VL SXz FDSLUH HUDQR XVDWL TXDVL HVFOXVLYDPHQWH SHU OH VWDPSH VFLROWH HUDQR WHQXWL EHQ VHSDUDWL GDL ´IUHJLµ/ GDL ´VDQWLµ/ GDOOH ´DUPHµ H GDOOH ´PLQLD0 WXUHµ FKH/ GL GLPHQVLRQL SL• SLFFROH HG XVDWL DQFKH QHOOD VWDPSD GHL OLEUL/ H0 UDQR LQYHFH FRQVHUYDWL QHL QRYH FDVVHWWL GHOOR ´VFDQ]HOORµ1 ²²²²²²²² 78
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %6ROLDQL%1 $602/ $UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0RGHQD/ 0HPRULDOL/ Q1495/ 8 IHEEUDLR 486<1 7: $602/ $UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GL 0RGHQD/ QRWDLR *LRYDQQL 6DOVD/ E1 56:/ 47 JHQQDLR 4946= /L0 VWD GHOOD VWDPSD GL PH *LRYDQQL 0DULD 9HUGL GHO 5 OXJOLR 49441 79
434;
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
/·LQJRPEUDQWH SUHVHQ]D GL TXHVWL OHJQL FL DXWRUL]]D ILQ GD RUD D SHQVDUH FKH OD SURGX]LRQH GL VWDPSH FRQ VLORJUDILH QRQ IRVVH RFFDVLRQDOH H QHSSXUH GHO WXWWR VHFRQGDULD QHO TXDGUR JHQHUDOH GHOOH DWWLYLWj GHOO·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL1 $OWUH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H YHUUDQQR SL• DYDQWL GDOO·DQDOLVL GHOO·,QYHQWDULR GHO PDJD]]L0 QR1 3HU RUD q EHQH VRWWROLQHDUH FKH DQFKH LQ VHJXLWR TXHVWR LQWHUHVVH SHU OH VWDPSH VLORJUDILFKH QRQ YHQQH PDL PHQR1 3DUH FKH YHUVR OD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR ODYRUDVVH SHU 6ROLDQL FRPH LQWDJOLDWRUH GHL OHJQL DQFKH XQ VDFHUGRWH/ DO TXDOH VL ULYROJHYDQR 0 VHPSUH SHUz FRQ OD PHGLD]LRQH GHO 6ROLDQL 0 DQFKH VWDPSD0 WRUL GL DOWUH FLWWj1 /·44 QRYHPEUH 49<6 LO WLSRJUDIR ERORJQHVH 3DROR 0RQWL VFULVVH D %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL= ´OD SUHJR D IDYRULUPL GL GLUH D TXHO SUHWR/ FKH KD LQWDOLDWR DOWUL OHJQL/ FKH QH KD XQR LQ PDQR GHOOL PLH/ FKH VH O·KD LQWDOLDWR Vu R QR/ FKH VH O·DYHUj LQWDOLDWR PH OR PDQGL FKH VXELWR OR IDUz VRGLVIDUHµ7;1 $ 0RGHQD F·HUD GXQTXH FKL VDSHYD LQFLGHUH WDQWR EHQH OH PDWULFL GL OHJQR GD RWWHQHUH FRPPLWWHQ]H DQFKH GDOOD YLFLQD FLWWj GL %RORJQD1 'HO UHVWR O·DQQR VHJXHQWH 3DROR 0RQWL 0 QH VLDPR LQIRUPDWL GD XQ·DOWUD OHWWHUD LQGLUL]]DWD D %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL7< 0 ID SUHSDUDUH D 0RGHQD XQ IURQWHVSL]LR FKH FRQ WXWWD SUREDELOLWj/ VHFRQGR XQ·XVDQ]D DOORUD PROWR GLIIXVD/ HUD LQFLVR LQ OHJQR1 $QFKH QHO FRUVR GHO VHFROR ;9,,, QRQ YHQQH PDL PHQR TXHVWR LQWHUHVVH SHU OH VLORJUDILH= QHO 4:8: *LXVHSSH 0DULD &DYL/ GLUHWWRUH GHOOD WLSRJUDILD GH0 JOL (UHGL 6ROLDQL/ q LPSHJQDWR D FHUFDUH ´RWWLPR OHJQR GL EXVVRµ83 SHU IDUYL LQFLGHUH OR VWHPPD GHO FDQRQLFR *LXVHSSH )RJOLDQL GLYHQWDWR YHVFRYR GHOOD FLWWj GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD1 $EELDPR/ SHU LO UHVWR/ SRFKLVVLPH QRWL]LH GL TXHVWD SURGX]LRQH GL OHJQL> LQIDWWL VLD D FDXVD GHOOD WHFQRORJLD XWLOL]]DWD/ IUDQFDPHQ0 WH/ SLXWWRVWR SRYHUD/ VLD 0 GL FRQVHJXHQ]D 0 D FDXVD GHL EDVVLVVLPL FRVWL GL SURGX]LRQH/ HVVD QRQ FRVWLWXLYD GL FHUWR XQ JUDYH PRWLYR GL FRQWHQ]LRVR WUD DXWRUL/ OLEUDL H VWDPSDWRUL= WXWWR TXHVWR/ LQ XQ FRQWHVWR QHO TXDOH OH FRQWHVH FRVWLWXLYDQR VSHVVR O·XQLFD VWUDGD DWWUDYHUVR FXL/ JUD]LH DOOH UHJLVWUD]LRQL GHL WULEXQDOL/ YLFHQGH H SHUVRQDJJL DQFKH GL PLQRU ULOLHYR SRWHYDQR ODVFLDUH DL SRVWHUL XQ ULFRUGR GHO ORUR RSHUDWR/ VLJQLILFDYD HVVHUH SHU VHPSUH FRQGDQQDWL DOO·REOLR1 1HOOD FRQWHVD GHO 4:95 FKH VHJXu OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOD 6WRULD OHWWHUD0 ULD G·,WDOLD GL $QWRQ )UDQFHVFR =DFFDULD VWDPSDWD GD *LXVHSSH 5HPRQGLQL ²²²²²²²² 7;
$602/ $FTXLVWL/ E1 5/ &DUWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD VWDPSHULD 6ROLDQL/ Q147/ %OHWWHUD GL 3DROR 0RQWL% GHO 44 QRYHPEUH 49<61 7< $602/ $FTXLVWL/ E1 5/ &DUWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD VWDPSHULD 6ROLDQL/ Q14;/ %OHWWHUD GL 3DROR 0RQWL%GHO 46 DJRVWR 49<71 83 $602/ $FTXLVWL/ E1 5/ &DUWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD VWDPSHULD 6ROLDQL/ Q185/ %OHWWHUD GHO 7 RWWR0 EUH 4:8:%1
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
434<
SHU FRQWR GHL 6ROLDQL VL DFFHQQD VROR DOOH VLORJUDILH= SURSULR SHU ULFRUGDUH FKH ´OD VSHVD GHJOL LQWDJOL LQ OHJQRµ HUD VWDWD FRSHUWD LQWHUDPHQWH GDOO·DXWRUH HG HUD LUULVRULD ´GL SRFKH VHL/ RG RWWR OLUH SHU HVVHUH VWDWD DSSXQWR LQ OHJQRµ841 /D ERWWHJD H LO PDJD]]LQR GHL OLEUL &RPH OD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL WLSRJUDIL GHO 6HLFHQWR H GHO 6HWWHFHQWR L 6ROLDQL JHVWLYDQR DQFKH XQD ERWWHJD SHU OD YHQGLWD DO SXEEOLFR VLD GHL OLEUL GD HVVL VWHVVL VWDPSDWL H ULOHJDWL/ VLD GL TXDQWR VHUYLYD SHU OD VFULWWXUD= GDOOH ´SHQQH GD VFULYHUHµ +QH DYHYDQR EHQ 45 PLOD, DG RJQL VRUWD GL OLEUL LQ IROLR/ LQ TXDUWR HG LQ RWWDYR/ GL SHUJDPHQD R GL FDUWD/ OHJDWL ´DOOD UXVWLFDµ R LQ PRGR SL• ULFHUFD0 WR/ SURQWL SHU WXWWL JOL XVL/ SHU OD VFXROD/ SHU OH ERWWHJKH/ SHU OH FDQFHOOHULH H SHU OH FXULH1 $QFKH OD FDUWD FKH WHQHYDQR LQ ERWWHJD SRWHYD ULVSRQGHUH D WXW0 WH OH QHFHVVLWj GHL PRGHQHVL= HVVD HUD ´UHDOH LQ IRUPD GL %RORJQDµ/ ´UHDOH RU0 GLQDULDµ/ ´PH]]DQD UHDOHµ/ ´GXFDOH GL 3DUPDµ/ ´URPDQLQDµ/ ´GD ILQHVWUHµ/ ´GD VWUD]]Lµ/ ´EUXQHOOR JUDQGHµ H ´EUXQHOOR SLFFRORµ/ ´WXUFKLQD FKLDUD SLFFRODµ/ ´GL YDUL FRORULµ H ´PDUPRUDWDµ> LQVRPPD FH Q·HUD SHU WXWWL L JXVWL H SHU WXWWL JOL XVL1 1HOOD ERWWHJD LQROWUH L 6ROLDQL WHQHYDQR DQFKH EUHYLDUL/ GLXUQL/ RIIL]L H PHVVDOL FKH/ HVVHQGR VWDPSDWL LQ URVVR H QHUR/ QRQ XVFLYDQR GDOOD ORUR VWDP0 SHULD PD SURYHQLYDQR GDOOH D]LHQGH WLSRJUDILFKH YHQH]LDQH GHO 3H]]DQD H GHO %DJOLRQL1 3DUH/ SHUz/ FKH L 6ROLDQL VL ULYROJHVVHUR DOOH DOWUH WLSRJUDILH VROR SHU TXHVWL OLEUL LQ URVVR H QHUR H SHU DOFXQL OLEUL GD VFXROD ULFRUGDWL SL• DYDQWL> LQIDWWL WXWWL JOL DOWUL OLEUL UHJLVWUDWL VXELWR GRSR VRWWR OD UXEULFD &DSLWDOH GHO PDJD]]LQR HUDQR XVFLWL GDL ORUR WRUFKL1 /D ORUR HOHQFD]LRQH/ DQFKH VH VL WUDWWD GL XQD VRPPDULD LQGLFD]LRQH GL RJQL RSHUD VHJXLWD GDO QXPHUR GHOOH FRSLH SUHVHQWL LQ PDJD]]LQR/ RFFXSD JUDQ SDUWH GHOO·LQYHQWDULR GHO 49:;1 *Lj FRQRVFLDPR LO QRWHYROH GLYDULR HVLVWHQWH WUD O·LQWHUD SURGX]LRQH GL XQD SLFFROD VWDPSHULD GL PRGHVWH SUHWHVH FRPH TXHOOD GHL 6ROLDQL H TXDQWR GL HVVD q ULPDVWR QHOOH EL0 EOLRWHFKH SXEEOLFKH H SULYDWH1 ,O QRVWUR LQYHQWDULR FL SHUPHWWH/ SHU OR PHQR/ XQD YHULILFD= GHOOH FLUFD 483 RSHUH SUHVHQWL LQ XQ DOWLVVLPR QXPHUR GL FRSLH QHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL H GD ORUR VWDPSDWH QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9,,/ DSSHQD XQD FLQTXDQWLQD VRQR FRQVHUYDWH/ VSHVVR LQ XQ XQLFR HVHPSOD0 ²²²²²²²² 84 6XOOD 6WRULD OHWWHUDULD G·,WDOLD GL $QWRQ )UDQFHVFR =DFFDULD/ VL YHGD *1 *521'$/ 6WRULD OHWWHUDULD G·,WDOLD +0RGHQD/ 4:8704:88,/ 0RGHQD >PD 9HQH]LD@/ 4:8804:8<,/ LQ /D ELEOLRWHFD SHULRGL0 FD1 5HSHUWRULR GHL JLRUQDOL OHWWHUDWL GHO 6HL06HWWHFHQWR LQ (PLOLD H LQ 5RPDJQD/ YRO1 ,,= 4:7304:;7/ %ROR0 JQD/ ,O 0XOLQR/ 4<;:/ SS1 6405551
4353
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
UH/ QHOOH SULQFLSDOL ELEOLRWHFKH GHOO·(PLOLD/ FKH FL FRQVHUYDQR OH TXDVL WRWDOLWj GHOOH SXEEOLFD]LRQL XVFLWH GDOOH VWDPSHULH PRGHQHVL851 6ROR XQ WHU]R GHOO·LQWHUD SURGX]LRQH OLEUDULD GHL 6ROLDQL q JLXQWD ILQR D QRL1 $Q]L VL KD O·LPSUHVVLRQH/ IRQGDWD/ FKH VROR LO FDVR R FLUFRVWDQ]H IRUWXLWH DEELDQR FRQ0 VHQWLWR D TXHVWD SLFFROD SDUWH GL VDOYDUVL H GL JLXQJHUH D QRL LQ XQ QXPHUR GL HVHPSODUL ULGRWWLVVLPR1 1RQ SRWHYD QRQ HVVHUH FRVu1 /·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL QRQ VWDPSDYD SHU OH ELEOLRWHFKH H SHU L SRVWHUL= QHOOD 0RGHQD GHO ;9,,, VHFROR IRUVH VROR OH VWDPSHULH GL *LRYDQQL 0RQWDQDUL H GHOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD HEEHUR TXHVWD DPEL]LRQH1 , OLEUL GHL 6ROLDQL HUDQR GHVWLQDWL DG HVVHUH DFTXL0 VWDWL H ´FRQVXPDWLµ QHO JLUR GL XQD R GXH JHQHUD]LRQL1 8QD YROWD WUDVIRUPDWL LQ XQ FRQVXQWR DPPDVVR GL IRJOL TXDVL LOOHJJLELOL HVVL HUDQR GHVWLQDWL DG HVVH0 UH PDQGDWL DO PDFHUR H DG HVVHUH ULPSLD]]DWL GD DOWUL OLEUL XVFLWL GDOOD PHGH0 VLPD D]LHQGD1 $G HVVHUH RQHVWL IRUVH L 6ROLDQL SURGXVVHUR VROR GXH OLEUL DG IX0 WXUDP UHL PHPRULDP/ FRPH PRQXPHQWL GD WUDPDQGDUH DL SRVWHUL H QRQ VROR SHU L ORUR FRQWHPSRUDQHL= O· ,GHD G·XQ SUHQFLSH HW KHURH FULVWLDQR QHO 6HLFHQWR H /D VHF0 FKLD UDSLWD GL $OHVVDQGUR 7DVVRQL QHO 6HWWHFHQWR1 6L WUDWWDYD FRPXQTXH GL LP0 SUHVH FKH DQGDYDQR PROWR DO GL Oj GHOOH FDSDFLWj SURGXWWLYH H ILQDQ]LDULH GHOO·D]LHQGD OD TXDOH/ LQ YHULWj/ DYHYD LO ILDWR PROWR FRUWR H QRQ SRWHYD FHUWR DEERQGDUH QHOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL RSHUH FKH DFFDQWR DO SUHVWLJLR FXOWXUDOH QRQ JDUDQWLVVHUR/ QHO JLUR GL SRFKLVVLPL DQQL/ XQ VLFXUR SURILWWR1 &RQYLHQH RUD HQWUDUH 0 SHU FRVu GLUH 0 QHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL HG HVDPL0 QDUH XQ SR· SL• GD YLFLQR L OLEUL FKH YL VL FRQVHUYDQR QHO OXJOLR GHO 49:;1 /R VFUXSRORVR QRWDLR FKH FL ID GD JXLGD QRQ q LQ YHULWj PROWR ORTXDFH1 &L SUH0 VHQWD OH RSHUH DG XQD DG XQD/ FRVu FRPH VRQR DOOLQHDWH VXOOH VFDIIDODWXUH/ OL0 PLWDQGRVL SHU OD ORUR LGHQWLILFD]LRQH D VHJQDODUFHQH LQ PRGR VRPPDULR LO WL0 WROR RSSXUH O·DXWRUH/ VHQ]D DOFXQD GHVFUL]LRQH ELEOLRJUDILFD> QRQ FL GLFH Qp O·DQQR GL SURGX]LRQH H QHSSXUH 0 VDOYR UDULVVLPH HFFH]LRQL 0 LO IRUPDWR> TXHVW·XOWLPR D YROWH SXz HVVHUH IDFLOPHQWH LQWXLWR= XQ &LFHURQFLQR SLFROR RY0 YLDPHQWH QRQ SXz HVVHUH Qp LQ IROLR/ Qp LQ TXDUWR/ PD LQ RWWDYR R/ SL• SURED0 ELOPHQWH/ LQ GRGLFHVLPR1 ,QWHUHVVDWR FRP·q DO YDORUH SDWULPRQLDOH GHOOD PHU0 FH FKH UHJLVWUD LO QRVWUR QRWDLR FL Gj LQYHFH XQ·LQIRUPD]LRQH XWLOLVVLPD> LQGL0 FD TXDQWL HVHPSODUL R TXDQWH ULVPH GL RJQL HGL]LRQH VRQR FRQVHUYDWH LQ PD0 JD]]LQR1 ²²²²²²²² 85 /H HGL]LRQL XVFLWH GDL WRUFKL GHL 6ROLDQL WUD LO 4979 HG LO 49:; H FRQVHUYDWH QHOOH SULQFL0 SDOL ELEOLRWHFKH GHOO·(PLOLD VRQR FDWDORJDWH LQ /DYRUL SUHSDUDWRUL/«FLW1/ SS1 60551
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4354
/D VWDPSHULD SHU OD FKLHVD $IIH]LRQDWL FOLHQWL GHL 6ROLDQL HUDQR FHUWDPHQWH L IUDWL HG L SUHWL1 $Q]L VH QRQ IRVVH SHU O·RGRUH DFUH H SXQJHQWH GHOOD OLVFLYD H GHOOD FDUWD XPLGD FKH SURYLHQH GDOOD YLFLQD VWDPSHULD/ VL SRWUHEEH TXDVL WHPHUH GL HVVHUH HQWUDWL SHU HUURUH LQ XQD VDJUHVWLD/ WDOH q OD TXDQWLWj GL XIILFL/ GL EUHYLDUL/ GL QRYHQH/ GL PHVVDOL/ GL GRWWULQH H GL LPPDJLQL GL VDQWL DPPDVVDWH RYXQTXH1 6X 483 RSHUH SUHVHQWL ROWUH OD PHWj HUDQR GL DUJRPHQWR UHOLJLRVR1 'L TXDVL WXWWH TXHVWH H0 GL]LRQL RJJL QRQ FL q ULPDVWR TXDVL QXOOD1 /D GLVSHUVLRQH q VWDWD JUDQGLVVLPD/ QRQ WDQWR WUD OH QRQ PROWH HGL]LRQL GL PDJJLRU PROH H GL TXDOFKH SUHJLR/ TXDQWR SLXWWRVWR WUD JOL LQQXPHUHYROL RSXVFROL VFULWWL SHU OH SL• GLVSDUDWH HVL0 JHQ]H OLWXUJLFKH H GHYR]LRQDOL GHL EUDYL FDWWROLFL PRGHQHVL1 6HPEUD TXDVL GL DVVLVWHUH ILVLFDPHQWH DOOD WRWDOH FRQVXQ]LRQH GL TXHVWL OLEULFLQL GL SLFFROR IRUPDWR H GL FDUWD XQ SR· JLDOORJQROD QHOOH PDQL GHYRWH H WHVH DOOD YLWD HWHUQD GHL VDFHUGRWL H GHL ORUR IHGHOL QHOOH FKLHVH H QHOOH FDVH GL 0RGHQD> TXHVWL OLEUL DYUDQQR IRUVH LQGLFDWR DL ORUR SURSULHWDUL OD &KLDYH G·RUR SHU DSULUH LO 3DUDGLVR 0 FRPH UHFLWD LO IURQWHVSL]LR GL XQR GL HVVL 0 PD SHU PROWL GL HVVL QRQ FL IX DO0 FXQD SRVVLELOLWj GL VRSUDYYLYHQ]D= GHOOH FLUFD RWWDQWD RSHUH GL FRQWHQXWR UHOL0 JLRVR H GHYR]LRQDOH SUHVHQWL DOORUD LQ FHQWLQDLD GL HVHPSODUL QHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL VROR XQD YHQWLQD VL WURYDQR RUD QHOOH QRVWUH ELEOLRWHFKH1 6SHVVR/ SRL/ TXHVWH RSHUH FL VRQR JLXQWH QRQ QHOO·HGL]LRQH UHJLVWUDWD GDO QRVWUR LQYHQWDULR/ PD LQ HGL]LRQL SRVWHULRUL= DG HVHPSLR/ GHL 853 HVHPSODUL GHO /HJJHQGDULR GHOOH 6DQWLVVLPH 9HUJLQL QRQ FL q ULPDVWR QXOOD SRLFKp O·XQLFR H0 VHPSODUH GL WDOH RSHUD JLXQWR ILQR D QRL IX VWDPSDWR GDL 6ROLDQL VROR QHO 49;9/ TXDQGR HYLGHQWHPHQWH HUDQR JLj VWDWL YHQGXWL WXWWL L 853 HVHPSODUL GHO 49:;1 '·DOWUD SDUWH VL ID IDWLFD D SHQVDUH FKH JOL ;:7 HVHPSODUL GHO *LDUGLQR VSLULWXDOH GL 3DROR 0RULJL SUHVHQWL LQ PDJD]]LQR QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 49:; ULVDOJRQR DOO·HGL]LRQH GHO 497:/ O·XQLFD GL FXL VLD ULPDVWD WUDFFLD QHOOH QRVWUH ELEOLRWH0 FKH/ R QRQ SLXWWRVWR DG XQ·DOWUD HGL]LRQH WLUDWD QRQ PROWL PHVL SULPD H GL FXL QRQ FL q JLXQWD QHVVXQD FRSLD DQFKH VH/ D TXDQWR SDUH/ QH HUDQR VWDWL VWDPSD0 WL DOPHQR PLOOH HVHPSODUL1 6L RVVHUYL LQROWUH FKH LO /HJJHQGDULR HG LO *LDUGLQR VRQR RSHUH YROXPLQRVH/ QRQ GHL VHPSOLFL RSXVFROL= JOL HVHPSODUL VRSUDYYLV0 VXWL VRQR GL FLUFD 783 SDJLQH LQ GRGLFHVLPR1 3HU LO *LDUGLQR GXQTXH/ WLUDWR LQ PLOOH HVHPSODUL/ HUDQR VWDWL VWDPSDWL TXDVL YHQWLPLOD IRJOL/ SLHJDWL SRL LQ GR0 GLFHVLPR> L GXH WRUFROLHUL FKH DEELDPR LQFRQWUDWR SRFR ID FL DYHYDQR ODYRUD0 WR D SLHQR ULWPR SHU DOPHQR GXH R WUH VHWWLPDQH VHQ]D XQ DWWLPR GL VRVWD1 'L WDQWR ODYRUR FL q ULPDVWD VROR O·HVLOH LQGLFD]LRQH GL TXHVWD DVHWWLFD UHJLVWUD0
4355
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
]LRQH QRWDULOH1 &KH GLUH DOORUD GHJOL DOWUL LQILQLWL RSXVFROL GHYR]LRQDOL FKH VSHVVR QRQ DQGDYDQR ROWUH OH GLPHQVLRQL GL XQR R GXH IRJOL GL VWDPSD SHU XQ WRWDOH/ DO PDVVLPR/ GL XQD FLQTXDQWLQD GL SDJLQH" 4XL OD YLWD FKH VL VYROJHYD RJQL JLRUQR DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH ERWWHJKH H GHOOH VWDPSHULH QRQ KD ODVFLDWR DOFXQ VHJQR GHO SURSULR SDVVDJJLR1 1XOOD FL q ULPDVWR GL <4; XIILFL LQ VHGLFHVLPR/ GL DOWUL PLOOH H FLQTXHFHQWR LQ WUHQWDGXHVLPR/ GL WUH ULVPH +4833 IRJOL GL VWDPSD, GHO %UHYH GHO FRPSHQGLR GHO 'LYLQR 5RVDULR/ GL FLQTXH ULVPH GHOO·2UD]LRQH DOOD EHDWD 9HUJLQH GHO &DUPLQH1 /·HOHQFR SRWUHEEH FRQWLQXDUH= DG XQ FHUWR SXQWR SHUz UHVWLDPR TXDVL VHQ]D SDUROD GL IURQWH DOO·HQRUPH TXDQWLWj GL PDWHULDOH DQGDWR FRPSOHWDPHQWH GL0 VSHUVR= 47 ULVPH +VHWWH PLOD IRJOL GL VWDPSD, GL 9DULH 2UD]LRQL/ 49 ULVPH GL 'R0 WULQH GL %HODUPLQR DFFDQWR D 45 ULVPH GL 'RWULQH SLFROH1 1RQ GLPHQWLFKLDPR SRL FKH TXHVWR q VROR TXDQWR JLDFHYD LQ PDJD]]LQR QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 49:; H FKH VLDPR GL IURQWH DG XQ WLSR GL SXEEOLFD]LRQL FKH VL ULQQRYDYD TXDVL RJQL DQQR= L SDUURFL DUULYDYDQR/ FDULFDYDQR TXDQWR VHUYLYD/ SDJDYDQR H ULSDUWLYDQR VRG0 GLVIDWWL1 (· TXLQGL LPPHQVDPHQWH VXSHULRUH H TXDVL LQLPPDJLQDELOH LO QXPHUR GHO0 OH HGL]LRQL H GHL ORUR HVHPSODUL GL DUJRPHQWR UHOLJLRVR H GHYR]LRQDOH FKH VR0 QR XVFLWL GDL WRUFKL GHL 6ROLDQL QHJOL ROWUH GXHFHQWR DQQL GHOOD ORUR DWWLYLWj1 /D VWDPSHULD SHU OD VFXROD 1HOOD ERWWHJD GHL 6ROLDQL VL YHQGHYD WXWWR FLz FKH VHUYLYD DOOD VFXROD GDOOH SHQQH G·RFD DL OLEUL GD VFULYHUH> DQFKH OD VWDPSHULD ODYRUDYD D SLHQL ULWPR SHU JOL LQVHJQDPHQWL FKH VL WHQHYDQR QHOOH FRVLGGHWWH VFXROH EDVVH/ WUD OH TXDOL DO0 ORUD HUDQR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH VHJXLWH TXHOOH WHQXWH GDL *HVXLWL QHO ORUR SDOD]]R YLFLQR DOOD FKLHVD GL 6DQ %DUWRORPHR1 , 6ROLDQL WHQHYDQR D GLVSRVL]LRQH $EED0 FKL H 'RQDWL LQ DEERQGDQ]D H ULQQRYDYDQR LQ FRQWLQXD]LRQH OH ORUR VFRUWH= QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 49:; DYHYDQR GXH ULVPH GHL SULPL HG RWWR GHL VHFRQGL/ DVVLHPH D EHQ WUHGLFL ULVPH H PH]]R +9:83 IRJOL GL VWDPSD, GL *UDPDWLFKLQH SLFROH1 $ YROWH QH IDFHYDQR JLXQJHUH DQFKH GD 9HQH]LD/ LQGLFDQGRQH OD SURYHQLHQ]D/ FRPH SHU OH VHGLFL ULVPH +EHQ RWWR PLOD IRJOL GL VWDPSD, GL /LEUL GD VFXROD GL VWDPSD GL 9HQH]LD1 1RQ PDQFDYD SRL QHSSXUH OD *UDPDWLFD GL (PDQXHO $OYD0 UH]/ SUHVHQWH LQ ;97 HVHPSODUL/ GHOOD TXDOH QRQ FL q JLXQWD QHVVXQD FRSLD/ SRLFKp TXHOOD FRQVHUYDWD SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD SURYLHQH GD XQ·HGL]LRQH VHWWHFHQWHVFD/ PDQGDWD LQ VWDPSD IRUVH PROWR WHPSR GRSR FKH TXHVWD H IRUVH DQFKH DOWUH XVFLWH QHO IUDWWHPSR HUDQR DQGDWH FRPSOHWD0
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4356
PHQWH HVDXULWH1 ,O ULWPR FRQ FXL TXHVWH HGL]LRQL YHQLYDQR LPPHVVH VXO PHU0 FDWR GRYHYD HVVHUH DEEDVWDQ]D VRVWHQXWR VH GHO &DQGLGDWXV 5HWKRULFDH GL )UD0 QoRLV $QWRLQH 3RPD\/ VWDPSDWR QHO 49:9 LQ XQ QXPHUR GL FRSLH FKH GRYHYD DJJLUDUVL WUD OH RWWRFHQWR XQLWj H LO PLJOLDLR/ GXH DQQL SL• WDUGL TXHVWR VWHVVR LQYHQWDULR UHJLVWUDYD VRODPHQWH 5< HVHPSODUL/ H QH HUD JLj SURQWD XQD VHFRQ0 GD HGL]LRQH/ TXHVWD YROWD/ SDUH/ LQ OLQJXD LWDOLDQD GL ;45 HVHPSODUL GHOOD TXDOH QRQ DEELDPR QRWL]LH GDL FDWDORJKL GHOOH ELEOLRWHFKH HPLOLDQH 0 SUREDELOPHQWH OD OLQJXD SL• DFFHVVLELOH HG LO PDJJLRU XVR QH KDQQR IDFLOLWDWR OD GLVSHUVLRQH1 1RQ q ULPDVWR QXOOD QHSSXUH GHL VHWWHFHQWR HVHPSODUL TXL UHJLVWUDWL GL XQ·RSHUD 0 SUREDELOPHQWH GL FRQWHQXWR ILORORJLFR SL• FKH SHGDJRJLFR GDWR FKH YLHQH UHJLVWUDWD VXELWR GRSR XQ·HGL]LRQH FLFHURQLDQD 0 GHOO·XPDQLVWD -XDQ /XLV 9LYHV1 *OL DXWRUL FODVVLFL SUHVHQWL QHO PDJD]]LQR GL 6ROLDQL HUDQR VRODPHQWH TXHO0 OL PDJJLRUPHQWH ULFKLHVWL GDOOH VFXROH GL ODWLQR> JOL XQLFL GHL TXDOL VL SRWHVVHUR YHQGHUH LQ 0RGHQD GHFLQH GL FRSLH1 (· SHU TXHVWR FKH HVVL HUDQR DQFKH SUH0 VHQWL LQ XQ JUDQ QXPHUR GL HVHPSODUL= <77 FRSLH GL XQ·HGL]LRQH GL 9LUJLOLR/ GHO TXDOH VL KD DQFKH D SDUWH XQD HGL]LRQH GHOOH %XFROLFKH LQ 483 HVHPSODUL> ;53 FRSLH GL XQ 2YLGLR> 943 GL 4XLQWR &XUFLR> 53: GL &DWWRQH> 783 HVHPSODUL GL XQ &LFHURQFLQR SLFROR H 757 GL XQD HGL]LRQH GHOOH (SLVWROH FLFHURQLDQH1 $QFKH GL TXHVWL DXWRUL FODVVLFL FL q JLXQWR EHQ SRFR/ XOWHULRUH WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHO IDWWR FKH VHUYLYDQR VRSUDWWXWWR DOOD VFXROD1 /D VWDPSHULD SHU OD FRUWH H SHU OD FLWWj %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL/ SRFKL DQQL GRSR DYHU DSHUWR OD WLSRJUDILD/ RWWHQQH GDOOD FRUWH LO SULYLOHJLR GL VWDPSDUH WXWWR FLz FKH LQWHUHVVDYD DO EXRQ IXQ]LR0 QDPHQWR GHOOD FDQFHOOHULD H GHOOD FDPHUD GXFDOH/ GDOOH WDULIIH SHU OH GRJDQH/ DOOH JULGH HG DJOL DWWL XIILFLDOL= LO WLWROR FKH RWWHQQH GL ´VWDPSDWRUH GXFDOHµ LQ0 GLFDYD SULQFLSDOPHQWH TXHVWR VHUYL]LR/ VHQ]D DOFXQD SDUWLFRODUH LPSOLFD]LRQH GL WLSR HGLWRULDOH1 &Lz QRQRVWDQWH DEELDPR DQFKH RVVHUYDWR FKH ILQ GDOO·LQL]LR L SULPL DXWRUL FKH VWDPSDURQR SUHVVR 6ROLDQL HUDQR TXDVL WXWWL LQ TXDOFKH PRGR OHJDWL DOOD FRUWH1 6HPEUD DGGLULWWXUD FKH 9LYLDQR 6ROLDQL DEELD GDWR YLWD DG XQD VSHFLH GL FROODQD HGLWRULDOH QHOOD TXDOH VWDPSDYD/ QHO VXR FDUDWWHULVWLFR IRUPDWR LQ GR0 GLFHVLPR/ L GUDPPL SHU PXVLFD FKH VL UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR D FRUWH1 ,O 3UHQFLSH FRU0 VDUR GL *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *LDUGLQL H OD 6FKLDYD IRUWXQDWD GL *LRYDQQL $QGUHD 0RQLJOLD QHO 49:7/ LO *LUHOOR GL )LOLSSR $FFLDLROL QHO 49:8/ VHJXLWR QHO 49:9
4357
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
GDOO·$PRU IUD DUPL1 /·DWWHQ]LRQH GHL 6ROLDQL DOOD YLWD GL FRUWH FL q WHVWLPRQLDWD QRQ WDQWR GDOOH SXEEOLFD]LRQL PDQGDWH IXRUL LQ RFFDVLRQH GL QR]]H SULQFLSH0 VFKH R GL DOWUH YLFHQGH/ WULVWL R OLHWH/ GHOOD IDPLJOLD GXFDOH/ TXDQWR SLXWWRVWR GDOOD SUHVHQ]D QHO ORUR FDWDORJR GHL QRPL GHL SULQFLSDOL DQLPDWRUL GHOOD YLWD FXOWXUDOH GHOOD FRUWH= GD )XOYLR 7HVWL DL PROWR SL• PRGHVWL HG RJJL TXDVL FRPSOHWDPHQWH GLPHQWLFDWL -DFRSR $OHRWWL/ *LURODPR *UD]LDQL/ &DUOR )R0 VFKLHUD /HGHUFKL/ *LDPEDWWLVWD %RFFDEDGDWL H WDQWL DOWUL1 /·D]LHQGD 6ROLDQL/ SXU VWUHWWDPHQWH LQWHUHVVDWD DO PRQGR FKH UXRWDYD DW0 WRUQR DOOD FRUWH/ QRQ GL PHQR UHVWDYD VHPSUH SURIRQGDPHQWH LQVHULWD QHO FRQWHVWR D OHL SL• FRQJHQLDOH GHJOL LQWHUHVVL FKH DQLPDYDQR O·LQWHUD FRPXQLWj GL 0RGHQD> TXHVWL LQWHUHVVL/ DQFKH VH IXURQR SHVDQWHPHQWH FRQGL]LRQDWL GDOOD SUHVHQ]D GXFDOH/ QRQ VL LGHQWLILFDURQR PDL FRQ TXHOOL GHOOD FRUWH/ WDQWR FKH 0 VFKHPDWL]]DQGR 0 VL SRWUHEEH SDUODUH GHOOD SUHVHQ]D LQ 0RGHQD GL WUH GLYHUVL DPELHQWL FLWWDGLQL/ XQLWL GD XQD VRPPD LQGHILQLWD GL LQWHUUHOD]LRQL SHUVRQDOL/ PD QRQGLPHQR SHUIHWWDPHQWH GLVWLQWL H WXWWL H WUH SHUIHWWDPHQWH LQVHGLDWL H D ORUR DJLR DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH PXUD FLWWDGLQH= TXHOOR GHOOD FRUWH/ TXHOOR GHO FOHUR H TXHOOR GHJOL DOWUL FLWWDGLQL1 4XHVW·XOWLPR H FRPSRVLWR JUXSSR GL DUWLJLDQL/ GL FRPPHUFLDQWL/ GL SUR0 IHVVLRQLVWL H GL IXQ]LRQDUL HUD DWWHQWR VRSUDWWXWWR D TXDQWR VL VYROJHYD DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH FRQVRUWHULH FHUWDPHQWH SL• RPRJHQHH GHOOD FRUWH H GHO FOHUR/ H VHPEUDYD DOORUD TXDVL FRPSOHWDPHQWH HVWUDQHR DOOD YLWD FXOWXUDOH GHOOD FLWWj1 6ROR GL Ou D SRFKL DQQL FRQ OD IRQGD]LRQH GHOOR 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 6DQ &DUOR HG LQ DUPRQLD FRO SHQVLHUR H FRQ O·D]LRQH PXUDWRULDQD/ VL VDUHEEH DIIHUPDWR DO VXR LQWHUQR XQD DJJXHUULWD VFKLHUD GL VWXGLRVL H GL SURIHVVRUL FKH FRO WHP0 SR DYUHEEH FRQWULEXLWR QRQ SRFR DOOD FUHVFLWD FXOWXUDOH GHOOD FLWWj1 6H QH SR0 WHURQR SRL YHGHUH L IUXWWL ILQ GDOOD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR LQ TXHOOD FHUFKLD GL OHWWHUDWL/ GL PDWHPDWLFL/ GL QDWXUDOLVWL H GL ´ILORVRILµ FKH GDSSULPD SRVHUR L OR0 UR WDOHQWL DO VHUYL]LR GHO GXFD RWWHQHQGR LQ FDPELR DQFKH WLWROL QRELOLDUL/ PD LQ VHJXLWR IXURQR SURQWL D IDYRULUH LQ 0RGHQD OD GLIIXVLRQH GL TXHL OXPL FKH SHUPLVHUR GL DFFRJOLHUH FRQ HQWXVLDVPR OH DUPDWH QDSROHRQLFKH1 )RUVH/ SHUz/ DEELDPR FRUVR WURSSR= WRUQLDPR VXELWR DL JULJLRUL GHO 49:;1 8QD EXRQD SDUWH GHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL HUD RFFXSDWD GDOOH RSHUH VFULW0 WH GDO PDVVLPR HVSRQHQWH GHOOD FXOWXUD PXQLFLSDOH PRGHQHVH GHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR= LO VDFHUGRWH /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL1 'HOOH VXH RSHUH VWDPSDWH GDL 6ROLDQL QHJOL DQQL 6HWWDQWD TXHOOD FKH KD DYXWR PDJJLRU VXFFHVVR 0 HG HUD GD SUHYHGHUH 0 IX SURSULR OD +LVWRULD GHOOD DQWLFKLVVLPD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ GHOOD TXD0 OH QHO 49:; VL FRQVHUYDYDQR LQ PDJD]]LQR VROR :; HVHPSODUL/ GL IURQWH DL FLU0
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
4358
FD 533 GHO &DWDORJR GHL YHVFRYL PRGRQHVL HG DJOL ROWUH 633 GHOOD 5DFFROWD GH SLWWRUL/ VFXOWRUL HW DUFKLWHWWL PRGRQHVL H GHOOH 9LWH HW HORJL GH FDUGLQDOL PRGRQHVL1 $FFDQWR DOO·HUXGL]LRQH VWRULFD GHO 9HGULDQL WURYDURQR SRVWR DQFKH JOL LQ0 WHUHVVL VFLHQWLILFL= LO &KLPLFR GLVYHODWR/ O·,QHUSUHWH FKLPLFR/ L 7ULRQIL GHO PHUFXULR GL &DUOR /DQFLOORWWL HG LO *LDUGLQR GL YDUL ILRUL PHGLFLQDOL/ ILUPDWR GD VXD PRJOLH 7H0 UHVD 3HULOOR /DQFLOORWWL/ IXURQR VWDPSDWL QHO 49:: HG RUD/ DG XQ DQQR GL GL0 VWDQ]D/ HUDQR WXWWL SUHVHQWL LQ PDJD]]LQR LQ XQ QXPHUR GL FLUFD RWWRFHQWR H0 VHPSODUL1 6ROR 566 HVHPSODUL HUDQR LQYHFH ULPDVWL GHOOD 5HWWD OLQHD JQRPRQLFD GL *LXVHSSH 0DULD )LJDWHOOL/ VWDPSDWD SHUz WUH DQQL SULPD/ QHO 49:81 /·LQWHQVD DWWLYLWj IRUHQVH GHOOD 0RGHQD GHO 6HLFHQWR KD ODVFLDWR SRFKLVVL0 PH WUDFFH QHO PDJD]]LQR GHL 6ROLDQL> LQIDWWL OH DUULQJKH GHJOL DYYRFDWL/ L PH0 PRULDOL GHOOH DXWRULWj H WXWWH OH DOWUH QXPHURVH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GL TXHVWR WLSR HUDQR TXDVL VHPSUH LQWHUDPHQWH SDJDWH GDL FRPPLWWHQWL FKH SUHOHYDYDQR RJQL HVHPSODUH1 &L q ULPDVWD VROR OD QRWL]LD GL 43: HVHPSODUL GL XQ WUDWWDWR 'H ILGHFRPPLVVLV GL )UDQFHVFR $]]ROLQL FKH SDUH QRQ VLD SRL JLXQWR ILQR D QRL1 ,0 QROWUH QRQ VL SXz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·LURQLD H OD EDWWXWD DOOHJUD QRQ SRWHYDQR PDQFDUH1 , 6ROLDQL JXDUGD0 YDQR VRSUDWWXWWR D TXDQWR VL SXEEOLFDYD QHOOD YLFLQD %RORJQD H WHQHYDQR SURQWH LQ PDJD]]LQR 5:: FRSLH GHOOD UDFFROWD GL WXWWH OH RSHUH GL %DUWRORPHR %RFFKLQL/ LO ERORJQHVH =DQ 0X]]LQD GL FXL DYHYDQR SXEEOLFDWR XQ·HGL]LRQH QHO 4988 HG XQ·DOWUD QHO 4998> HVDXULWL DQFKH TXHVWL 5:: HVHPSODUL QH VWDPSD0 URQR XQD WHU]D HGL]LRQH QHO 49;61 0D VRSUDWWXWWR WHQHYDQR GLVSRQLELOL TXDW0 WUR TXLQWHUQL +FHQWR IRJOL GD VWDPSD, GL %HUWROGL/ 96 FRSLH GL %HUWROGLQL H 483 GL &DFDVHQQR1 ,QVRPPD DQFKH GL TXHVWL XOWLPL D 0RGHQD FH QH HUDQR VHPSUH LQ DEERQGDQ]D> VHQ]D SRL PHWWHUH QHO FRQWR L :8 TXLQWHUQL +4;:8 IRJOL, GL &UX0 GHOWj G·$PRUH/ JOL ;3 TXLQWHUQL +GXH PLOD IRJOL GD VWDPSD, GL 2OLPSLD G·$PRUH/ OH WUH ULVPH GL +LVWRULH GLYHUVH H OH 46 ULVPH +9833 IRJOL GL VWDPSD, GL 5RPDQ]L HW DOWUL OLEUHWWL GD EDQFR1 $O SXEEOLFR GL TXHVWH +LVWRULH QRQ GRYHYDQR QHSSXUH GLVSLDFHUH OH VLOR0 JUDILH H OH LQFLVLRQL FKH LQ JUDQ TXDQWLWj XVFLYDQR GDOOD VWDPSHULD GHL 6ROLDQL1 &HUWDPHQWH LO ORUR PDJD]]LQR QHO 49:; QH HUD EHQ IRUQLWR1 6LDPR JLj D FRQR0
4359
*LRUJLR 0RQWHFFKL
VFHQ]D GHO IDWWR FKH QHOOD VWDPSHULD XQD FDVVDSDQFD/ XQD ´FDVVD JUDQGHµ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q LO PRWLYR SHU FXL LO QRVWUR LQYHQWDULR UHJLVWUD/ DQFKH VH LQ JUDQ TXDQWL0 Wj/ HVFOXVLYDPHQWH YHQWDUROH/ FLRq VWDPSH FKH VHUYLYDQR DOOD SUHSDUD]LRQH GHL YHQWDJOL/ 6DQWL GL 0RGHQD H 6DQWL GL %RORJQD/ TXHOOL RYYLDPHQWH FKH HUDQR PDJ0 JLRUPHQWH ULFKLHVWL1 $ SURSRVLWR GHL VDQWL ERORJQHVL JLRYD ULFRUGDUH FKH YHU0 VR OD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR DQFKH LO WLSRJUDIR GL %RORJQD 3DROR 0RQWL VL ULYROJHYD DL 6ROLDQL SHU OH SURSULH VLORJUDILH861 ,O QRVWUR QRWDLR DQQRWD YHQWL ULVPH GL FDQ]RQL SHU YHQWDUROH/ FLRq GLHFLPL0 OD IRJOL SHU OD FRVWUX]LRQH GL YHQWDJOL FRQ VRSUD VWDPSDWD XQD FDQ]RQH/ SL• XQD ULVPD GL YHQWDUROH FRQ LQFLVLRQL LQ UDPH1 1RQ GREELDPR VWXSLUFL GL WDQWD DEERQGDQ]D/ SRLFKp O·LQYHQWDULR IX VWHVR DOO·LQL]LR GHOO·HVWDWH H OD ORUR YHQGLWD LQ SLD]]D SDUH UHQGHVVH QRQ SRFR/ WDQWR FKH LQ TXHJOL VWHVVL DQQL LO OLEUDLR $QWRQLR &DSSRQL/ FKH DYHYD OD VXD ERWWHJD LQ YLD (PLOLD/ WHQHYD LQ SLD]]D JUDQGH QRQ ORQWDQR GDL 6ROLDQL XQ EDQFR VXO TXDOH XQ VXR JDU]RQH YHQGHYD OLEUHWWL H YHQWDUROH871 3DUH FKH DQFKH QHOO·XQLFR TXDGUR VHFHQWHVFR GHO ODWR PHULGLRQDOH GL SLD]]D *UDQGH/ GRPLQDWR GDO SDOD]]R GHL *LXGLFL LQ FXL VL WURYDYD OD ERWWHJD GHL 6ROLDQL/ VLD UDIILJXUDWD XQD YHQGLWULFH GL YHQWDUROH/ R IRUVH VHPSOLFHPHQWH GL VWDPSH VFLROWH881 0D HUDQR VRSUDWWXWWR L 6DQWL D ULPD0 QHUH QHO VXR PDJD]]LQR D GLVSRVL]LRQH GHO SXEEOLFR LQ RJQL VWDJLRQH GHOO·DQQR1 1HOO·HVWDWH GHO 49:; YL VL WURYDYDQR GLHFL ULVPH GL 6DQWL QHUL LQ OHJQR/ GLHFL ULVPH GL 6DQWL GL %RORJQD FRORULWL SL• XQD ULVPD H PH]]R/ VIXJJLWD LQ XQ SULPR PRPHQWR DOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GHO QRWDLR H SHU TXHVWR DJJLXQWD DOOD ILQH/ GL 6DQWL GL 0RGHQD FRORULWL1 &L WURYLDPR GL IURQWH D ROWUH GLHFLPLOD VLORJUDILH GHOOH TXDOL QRQ q ULPDVWR QXOOD= Qp GL TXHVWH Qp GHOOH DOWUH GHFLQH H GHFLQH GL PL0 JOLDLD FKH GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO·2WWRFHQWR XVFLURQR GDOOD VWDPSHULD GHL 6ROLDQL1 $ ²²²²²²²² 86
$602/ $FTXLVWL/ E1 5/ &DUWH GL SURYHQLHQ]D GHOOD VWDPSHULD 6ROLDQL/ QQ1 47 H 4;/ %OHWWHUH GHOO·4 QRYHPEUH 49<6 H GHO 46 DJRVWR 49<7%1 87 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ $UWL H PHVWLHUL/ 6WDPSH H VWDPSDWRUL/ E1 69/ %&DSSRQL%/ 49;7 H 49<51 88 ,O TXDGUR q FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR LO 0XVHR &LYLFR GL 0RGHQD1
6WDPSDWRUL H OLEUDL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL
435:
TXHVWH VLORJUDILH YDQQR DJJLXQWH OH TXLQGLFL ULVPH GL 6DQWL LQ UDPH= :833 LQFL0 VLRQL FKH VRQR VWDWH DFTXLVWDWH/ KDQQR DGRUQDWR FDVH H ERWWHJKH GL 0RGHQD H SRL VRQR VFRPSDUVH QHO QXOOD 0 D WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOD ORUR HIILPHUD DSSDUL0 ]LRQH QHOOD YLWD TXRWLGLDQD PRGHQHVH GHOOD VRFLHWj GL DQWLFR UHJLPH FL UHVWDQR TXHVWH VFDUQH UHJLVWUD]LRQL QRWDULOL HG L OHJQL DQFRUD RJJL FRQVHUYDWL SUHVVR OD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD891
²²²²²²²² 89
)LQDOPHQWH GRSR GHFHQQL GL DEEDQGRQR/ L OHJQL LQFLVL GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH VRQR VWDWL O·RJJHWWR GL XQD DWWHQWD LQYHQWDULD]LRQH H GL XQD SULPD PHVVH GL VWXGL SHU L TXDOL VL YHGD O·RSHUD JLj ULFRUGDWD/ VX , OHJQL LQFLVL GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<;91 $OWUL OHJQL GHL 6ROLDQL/ JLj FRQVHUYDWL SUHVVR OD WLSRJUDILD 0XFFKL GL 0RGHQD/ HUHGH GHOO·DQWLFD VWDPSHULD GHL 6ROLDQL/ VRQR RUD FRQIOXLWL QHO IRQGR GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
435<
)$%,2 0$55,
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
'D ROWUH XQ TXDUWR GL VHFROR D 0RGHQD QRQ VL SDUOD GL 0XUDWRUL LQ XQ·RFFDVLRQH SURPRVVD GDL PDVVLPL UHVSRQVDELOL GHOOD FXOWXUD ORFDOH= GRSR LO JUDQGH FRQJUHVVR GHO 4<:5/ LO FRPSLWR GL WHQHUH GHVWD O·DWWHQ]LRQH VXO PDJ0 JLRUH OHWWHUDWR PRGHQHVH GL RJQL WHPSR q ULPDVWR DO &HQWUR GL VWXGL PXUDWR0 ULDQL/ DOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD/ DOO·$FFDGHPLD GL VFLHQ]H OHWWHUH H DUWL> D TXHVWL HQWL VL q DIILDQFDWD GDO 4<<4 OD VXD WHUUD QDWDOH/ LO FRPXQH GL 9LJQROD/ FKH ILQRUD KD DOOHVWLWR FRQ FDGHQ]D ELHQQDOH WUH JLRUQDWH GL VWXGLR1 %XRQ VHJQR/ DOORUD/ FKH OH FHOHEUD]LRQL GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH ULFRUGLQR DQ0 FKH XQD ILJXUD FRPH 0XUDWRUL/ FRQVLJOLHUH GHO VXR GXFD 5LQDOGR +TXDVL FRQ IXQ]LRQL GL PLQLVWUR, H LQWDQWR HGXFDWRUH GHOO·HUHGH DO WURQR +SRL GXFD )UDQ0 FHVFR ,,,, H DXWRUH/ QHO 4:7</ GL TXHOOD 3XEEOLFD IHOLFLWj RJJHWWR GH· EXRQL SUuQFLSL FRQVLGHUDWD XQR GHL JUDQGL PDQLIHVWL GHO ULIRUPLVPR LOOXPLQLVWLFR HXURSHR/ ROWUH FKH GHFLVLYD SHU OD VWHVVD JUDQGH VWDJLRQH GHOOH ULIRUPH QHOOD 0RGHQD GHO VHFRQGR 6HWWHFHQWR1 ,O UXROR SROLWLFR GL 0XUDWRUL ULVXOWz SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LPSRUWDQWH H GHOLFDWR QHL OXQJKL DQQL +4:3503:/ 4:67069/ 4:7407<, FKH L GXFKL HVWHQVL/ SHU QHFHVVLWj RG RSSRUWXQLVPR/ SDVVDURQR ORQWDQL GD 0RGHQD/ TXDQGR LO YLJQROHVH IX WUD L SRFKL IXQ]LRQDUL D UHVWDUH LQ VHGH1 $G HVHPSLR/ GXUDQWH OD JUDYRVD RFFXSD0 ]LRQH IUDQFHVH GHO 4:3503:/ IX OXL/ FRO FRQWH *DVSDUH *LRYDQDUGL H LO PLQL0 VWUR *LRYDQQL *DOOLDQL &RFFDSDQL/ D VEULJDUH JOL DIIDUL SXEEOLFL> H LQ VHJXLWR/ YLGH VXRL VFRODUL +FRPH 'RPHQLFR 01 *LDFRED]]L H *LXVHSSH %RQGLJOL, DF0 FHGHUH DOOH SL• DOWH FDULFKH VWDWDOL1 0D QRQ RFFRUUH TXL ULDVVXPHUH TXDQWR q HIILFDFHPHQWH GHOLQHDWR QHO FDSLWROR /1$101 H OH ULIRUPH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD GL 01 %LDQFKLQL H )1 9HURQL SHU OD UHFHQWH 6WRULD LOOXVWUDWD GL 0RGHQD FRRUGLQDWD GD *1 0X]]LROL H 31 *ROLQHOOL/4 FXL VL DIILDQFDQR L FRQWULEXWL/ GL DOWR OLYHOOR VFLHQWLILFR/ UDFFROWL QHO YROXPH &RUWH/ EXRQ JRYHUQR/ SXEEOLFD IHOLFLWj1 3ROLWLFD H FR0 ²²²²²²²² 4
0LODQR/ 11(1$1/ YRO1 ,,/ 4<<3/ SS1 97409931
4363
)DELR 0DUUL
VFLHQ]D FLYLOH QHO 0XUDWRUL/ GHO 4<<915 /D ULFHUFD YD DYDQWL/ H SXz SURILWWDUH/ RUD SL• FKH LQ SDVVDWR/ GHOO·HVSORUD]LRQH GHOOH FDUWH PXUDWRULDQH +FRQVHUYDWH/ SHU OD PDVVLPD SDUWH GHO QRWR/ DOOD ELEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH, LQ VHUYL]LR GHOO·HGL]LRQH QD]LRQDOH GHO FDUWHJJLR= ULVXOWD DG HVHPSLR SUH]LRVR/ H IRULHUR GL LPPHGLDWL YDQWDJJL/ O·LQYHQWDULR GL XQ DOWUR FRQVLVWHQWH IRQGR/ TXHOOR GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ VWDPSDWR RU RUD GD *LXVHSSH 7UHQWL DOO·LQWHUQR GHO VDJJLR /1 $1 01 H JOL (VWHQVL16 6H/ SDUWHQGR GDO FDUWHJJLR PXUDWRULDQR +FLRq QRQ VROR OH OHWWHUH GL 0XUD0 WRUL SXEEOLFDWH GD &DPSRUL WUD LO 4<34 H LO 4<55/ PD DQFKH TXHOOH VFULWWH GDOOH VXH FHQWLQDLD GL FRUULVSRQGHQWL, H VHJXHQGRQH OH VXJJHVWLRQL HQWULDPR QHOO·DUFKLYLR PDQRVFULWWR/ WURYLDPR LQGLFD]LRQL EDVLODUL/ GL SULPD PDQR/ VXOO·DWWLYLWj GHO QRVWUR= DQFKH VX TXHOOD SROLWLFD/ FKH LQHYLWDELOPHQWH OR RULHQ0 Wz +VLD SHU O·DWWHJJLDPHQWR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH/ VLD SHU XQD FRQYLQ]LRQH FKH PDWXUDYD DWWUDYHUVR JOL VWXGL, YHUVR LO PRQGR JHUPDQLFR/ GHOO·,PSHUR H GHOOD 5LIRUPD +R DOPHQR GL XQ FDWWROLFHVLPR SL• ¶LOOXPLQDWR·,1 )X XQD FRQYHQLHQ]D SROLWLFD +LO PDWULPRQLR GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR/ QHO 49<8/ FRQ OD SULQFLSHVVD &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD7 GL %UXQVZLFN,/ GD FXL VFDWXULURQR OH UL0 FHUFKH GL /HLEQL] VXOO·DQWLFD FRQQHVVLRQH GHOOH FDVH (VWH H %UXQVZLFN/ D IDU GHVLGHUDUH XQ PLJOLRUH RUGLQDPHQWR GHOO·DUFKLYLR GXFDOH/ DIILGDWR QHOO·DJRVWR 4:33 DO YHQWRWWHQQH 0XUDWRUL1 ( QHO 4:3; IX OD ULRFFXSD]LRQH LPSHULDOH GL &RPDFFKLR +JLj IHXGR HVWHQVH ILQR DO 48<;/ H GHO TXDOH O·LPSHUR QRQ DYHYD PDL FHVVDWR GL ULYHQGLFDUH LO SRVVHVVR/ LQYHVWHQGRQH JOL (VWH DQFKH QHO 6HL0 FHQWR, D VROOHFLWDUH XQ DSSURIRQGLWR YDJOLR GHOOH FDUWH DQWLFKH PRGHQHVL GD SDUWH GL 0XUDWRUL H DQFRUD GL /HLEQL]/ FKH RUFKHVWUDURQR LQVLHPH XQD FDP0 SDJQD LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL SXEEOLFD]LRQL SHU PRVWUDUH FRQ OD IRU]D GHL GRFX0 PHQWL QRQ VROR O·DSSDUWHQHQ]D GL &RPDFFKLR DOO·LPSHUR/ PD SL• LQ JHQHUDOH ²²²²²²²² 5
6RQR JOL DWWL GHOOD WHU]D JLRUQDWD GL VWXGL PXUDWRULDQL WHQXWD D 9LJQROD LO 471;14<<8 H SXEEOLFDWL D )LUHQ]H GD 2OVFKNL FRPH YRO1 ; GHOOD ´%LEOLRWHFD GHOO·HGL]LRQH QD]LRQDOH GHO FDUWHJJLR GL /1 $1 01µ1 6 5HGDWWR LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ $1 63$**,$5,= &RUWH/ EXRQ JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ SS1 40461 7 1HOO·RULJLQDOH/ &KDUORWWH )HOLFLWDV1 &KDUORWWH +$JODH/ GL %RUERQH02UOpDQV, VDUj SXUH LO QRPH GHOOD SULPD PRJOLH GHO ILJOLR GL 5LQDOGR H &KDUORWWH GL %UXQVZLFN/ LO IXWXUR GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,,= GL IURQWH D TXHVWL QRPL XJXDOL/ ULVXOWD FXULRVR FKH 51 ,277, +/D SROLWLFD GHOO·DPRUH/ LQ *OL (VWHQVL/ SDUWH ,/ /D FRUWH GL )HUUDUD= 0RGHQD/ ,O %XOLQR/ 4<<:/ S1 4:8, SDUOL/ D SURSRVLWR GHL FRQVRUWL GL FDVD G·(VWH/ GL ´QRPL ODQJXLGL DVSUL R JUD]LRVL D VHFRQGD FKH HVVL VLDQR YHQXWL GDOO·,QJKLOWHUUD/ GDOOD *HUPDQLD R GDOOD )UDQFLDµ/ ODVFLDQGR GXQTXH GHVXPHUH FKH &KDUORWWH +R &DUORWWD, VLD DVSUR VH GL SURYHQLHQ]D WHGHVFD/ JUD]LRVR VH IUDQFHVH1 ( QRQ YHGR FRVD FL VLD GL ´ODQJXLGRµ LQ *LDFRPR +-DPHV, ,, 6WXDUW/ PDULWR GL 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4364
O·LQIRQGDWH]]D GL WDQWH SUHWHVH WHUULWRULDOL SRQWLILFLH1 6HUJLR %HUWHOOL8 LQIRUPD FKH LO 6 DSULOH 4:3;/ XQ PHVH SULPD GHO FROSR VX &RPDFFKLR/ 0XUDWRUL IX DO0 OHUWDWR GD XQ GLVSDFFLR GHOO·LQYLDWR PRGHQHVH D 9LHQQD/ &DUOR $QWRQLR *LDQQLQL/ D WURYDUH SURYH FRQWUR LO SRWHUH HFFOHVLDVWLFR VX TXHOO·DUHD1 'D TXHVWH FLUFRVWDQ]H FRQWLQJHQWL +&DUORWWD )HOLFLWD PRUu JLj QHO 4:43> LO SRVVHVVR/ VHEEHQH QRQ LO SLHQR GLULWWR/ VX &RPDFFKLR IX UHVWLWXLWR DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH QHO 4:58 SHU XQ JLRFR FRPSOHVVR GL PXWXH FRQFHVVLRQL WUD JUDQGL QHO TXDOH 0RGHQD HEEH OD VRUWH GHO YDVR GL FRFFLR WUD YDVL GL IHUUR, QDFTXHUR FRQVHJXHQ]H EHQ SL• GXUDWXUH VRWWR LO SURILOR FXOWXUDOH= LO QXRYR PHWRGR VWR0 ULRJUDILFR PXUDWRULDQR +LQIOXHQ]DWR GDOOD ULIOHVVLRQH VXOOD ILORVRILD GHOOD VWRULD GL /HLEQL], H O·LPPDQH SURGRWWR GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL9 SULPD/ GHL 5HUXP ,WDOL0 FDUXP 6FULSWRUHV H GHOOH $QWLTXLWDWHV ,WDOLFDH SRL/ LQILQH GHJOL $QQDOL G·,WDOLD1 Ë VXSHUIOXR GLOXQJDUVL VX TXHVWL DUJRPHQWL GRSR OD VLVWHPD]LRQH FKH QH KD GDWD %HUWHOOL> VL SXz VROR DUULFFKLUH LO TXDGUR SHVFDQGR GD PDWHULDOL LQHGLWL/ GL FXL SXEEOLFR LQ DSSHQGLFH 0 SHU UDJLRQL GL VSD]LR 0 XQD PLQLPD VFHOWD1: 7DOL ²²²²²²²² 8 (UXGL]LRQH H VWRULD LQ / $101/ 1DSROL/ ,VWLWXWR LWDOLDQR SHU JOL VWXGL VWRULFL/ 4<93/ SS1 <;0 <<1 8Q SL• DPSLR H[FXUVXV VWRULFR VXOOD TXHVWLRQH FRPDFFKLHVH/ DFFRPSDJQDWR GD XQD GLOL0 JHQWH UDVVHJQD DQFKH GHL PDQRVFULWWL PXUDWRULDQL/ YLHQH GD XQD VWXGLRVD WHGHVFD/ *(6,1( *g6&+(/ 0(33(1/ 'DV ´%HOOXP GLSORPDWLFXPµ XP &RPDFFKLR ]X %HJLQQ GHV 4;1 -DKUKXQGHUWV/ 8QLYHUVLWj GL )UDQNIXUW DP 0DLQ +)DFKEHUHLFK 5HFKWVZLVVHQVFKDIW,/ 4<:6/ 448 SDJLQH1 9 (VVHQGR PDWHULD JLj WUDWWDWD GD &DPSRUL/ %HUWHOOL H DOWUL/ QRQ HQWUR QHO WHPD GHOOD FRQ0 QHVVLRQH WUD OH ULFHUFKH VX &RPDFFKLR H TXHOOH VXOOD VWRULD GHOOH FDVH G·(VWH H %UXQVZLFN1 8Q SURJHWWR RULJLQDULR SUHYHGHYD FKH OD VWHVVD ´ULVSRVWD YLQGLFHµ DYUHEEH FRPSUHVR HQWUDPEL JOL DUJRPHQWL> PD SRL IX GHFLVR GL FRQFHQWUDUVL VXOOD VROD TXHVWLRQH FRPDFFKLHVH/ LQ DWWHVD FKH OH DFTXH VL FDOPDVVHUR H L ULFHUFDWRUL LPSHULDOL +0XUDWRUL VRSUD WXWWL, SRWHVVHUR DFFHGHUH DG DUFKLYL GL SURSULHWj HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 $L GRFXPHQWL JLj QRWL +FIU1 %(57(//,/ 48< H 4;;04;<, DJJLXQJR O·´(VWUDWWR G·XQ UHVFULWWR GL 61$161 (OHWWRUH GL %UXQVZLFN DO VXR LQYLDWR DOOD FRUWH LPSHULDOH VRSUD OD *HQHDORJLD (VWHQVH/ FKH LQWHQGHYDVL SXEEOLFDUH DOO·RFFDVLRQH GHOOH GLIIH0 UHQ]H SHU JOL DIIDUL GL )HUUDUD H &RPDFFKLRµ +FRVu LO WLWROR DUFKLYLVWLFR,/ QRQ GDWDWR PD GHO 4:43044/ RJJL DOO· $602/ $UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ &DVD H 6WDWR/ &RQWURYHUVLH GL 6WDWR/ E1 85</ Q1 5;1 /·(OHWWRUH VXJJHULYD GL ULPDQGDUH O·LQGDJLQH GLQDVWLFD> VROR QHO 4:4: 0XUDWRUL/ GRSR XQD VL0 VWHPDWLFD FDPSDJQD GL ULFHUFKH/ SRWp VWDPSDUH OD SULPD SDUWH GHOOH VXH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL H ,WD0 OLDQH/ GHGLFDWD DSSXQWR DOO·HOHWWRUH GL %UXQVZLFN ++DQQRYHU,/ GLYHQXWR QHO IUDWWHPSR UH G·,QJKLOWHUUD FRO QRPH GL *LRUJLR ,1 6L YHGD DQFKH )1 0$55, H 01 /,(%(5/ 0XUDWRUL XQG 'HX0 WVFKODQG/ )UDQNIXUW DP 0DLQ HFF1/ /DQJ/ 4<<:/ SS1 4:054 H 7<0;;1 : /H IRQWL SL• XWLOL SHU GRFXPHQWDUH O·LPSHJQR SROLWLFR GL 0XUDWRUL VRQR/ ROWUH DOO·HGL]LRQH FRPSOHVVLYD GHOO·(SLVWRODULR PXUDWRULDQR FXUDWD GD 01 &$0325, LQ 47 YROXPL +0RGHQD/ 670/ 4<34055= (SLVW1,/ LQ FXL OD *g6&+(// S1 6:/ KD FRQWDWR FLUFD 5;3 ULIHULPHQWL D &RPDFFKLR/ H DL 48 YROXPL ILQRUD XVFLWL GHOO·(GL]LRQH QD]LRQDOH GHO &DUWHJJLR +)LUHQ]H/ 2O0 VFKNL/ 4<:80<<= &DUWHJJLR,/ JOL 6FULWWL LQHGLWL GL /1$101 FXUDWL GD &1 )28&$5' +%RORJQD/ =DQL0 FKHOOL/ 4;:5= q OD VH]LRQH FKH VHJXH DO FDWDORJR GHOO·$UFKLYLR PXUDWRULDQR FXUDWR GD /1
4365
)DELR 0DUUL
GRFXPHQWL/ ROWUH DOO·LPSRUWDQ]D VWRULFD H FXOWXUDOH FKH q IDFLOH LQWXLUH/ SUH0 VHQWDQR XQ LQWHUHVVH QRQ VHFRQGDULR QHO FDPSR OLQJXLVWLFR= OD SURVD GL 0XUD0 WRUL/ EHQFKp IRVVH DGGLWDWD GDO JORWWRORJR *1 ,1 $VFROL TXDOH XQ PRGHOOR GD VHJXLUH SHU OD VXD FODVVLFD FRUUHWWH]]D H LQVLHPH LO ULILXWR GHOOD UHWRULFD/ q DQ0 FRUD VWXGLDWD H VFKHGDWD PHQR GL TXDQWR RFFRUUHUHEEH/ VH SHQVLDPR FKH LO PDJJLRUH GHL QRVWUL YRFDERODUL/ LO *UDQGH 'L]LRQDULR %DWWDJOLD +*'/,,/ QH WLH0 QH FRQWR GLVWUDWWDPHQWH/ H OD SL• PRGHUQD LQL]LDWLYD LQIRUPDWLFD/ OD /HWWHUDWX0 UD ,WDOLDQD =DQLFKHOOL +/,=,/ QHSSXUH DOOD VXD WHU]D HGL]LRQH DFFUHVFLXWD GHO 4<<: KD VDSXWR WURYDUH VSD]LR/ QHO VXR FDSLHQWH &'05RP/ DOPHQR SHU DOFX0 QH RSHUH GHO QRVWUR1 6DUHEEH XQD JUDQGH LPSUHVD TXHOOD GL UHGLJHUH XQ JORV0 VDULR PXUDWRULDQR= TXL SRVVR VROR DJJLXQJHUH LQ QRWD SRFKH VFKHGH DOOH WDQWH DOWUH FKH KR SXEEOLFDWR VSDUVDPHQWH1 /D YLWD GL 0XUDWRUL DUFKLYLVWD H ELEOLRWHFDULR HUD WXWW·DOWUR FKH TXHOOD GL XQ WRSR GL ELEOLRWHFD/ H DL WHPSL GHOOD TXHVWLRQH GL &RPDFFKLR +VRSUDWWXWWR QHL SULPL/ IHEEULOL DQQL GDO 4:3; DL YDUL LQFRQWUL H FRQJUHVVL GL SDFH GHO 4:3<047, ULVXOWz SLXWWRVWR DJLWDWD1 &DUGLQL GHO UDJLRQDUH PXUDWRULDQR HUDQR= TXDQWR D &RPDFFKLR/ OD VXD DSSDUWHQHQ]D DOO·,PSHUR/ GRQGH OD FRQFHVVLRQH DJOL (0 VWHQVL H GXQTXH O·LOOHJDOLWj GHO SRVVHVVR SDSDOH> FLUFD )HUUDUD/ DPPHVVR H QRQ FRQFHVVR FKH LO GLULWWR GL LQYHVWLWXUD QH IRVVH VSHWWDWR DL SDSL H QRQ DO SRSR0 OR/ OD ´GHYROX]LRQHµ GHO 48<;/ PRWLYDWD FRQ O·LQHVLVWHQ]D GL HUHGL PDVFKL OH0 JLWWLPL GL $OIRQVR ,,/ HUD SUHWHVWXRVD/ HVVHQGR LO QXRYR GXFD &HVDUH G·(VWH QLSRWH OHJLWWLPR GL $OIRQVR , +FKH QH DYUHEEH VSRVDWD LQ H[WUHPLV OD QRQQD/ /DXUD (XVWRFKLD 'LDQWL,1 /·$UFKLYLR 0XUDWRULDQR GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH FRQVHUYD/ QHOOD )LO]D 49/ GXH FRSSLH GL RSHUH QHOOH TXDOL 0XUDWRUL DQDOL]]D/ FRQ XQD JUDILD OLQHDUH FR0 PH LO FRQFDWHQDUVL GHOOD VXD ORJLFD/ L GXH SUREOHPL VHSDUDWDPHQWH1 1RQ FL VRQR OH GDWH GL FRPSRVL]LRQH/ PD OD SULPD FRSSLD; GRYUHEEH HVVHUH SURSULR ²²²²²²²² 9,6&+,,/ H OD &RUULVSRQGHQ]D WUD /1 $1 01 H *1 *1 /HLEQL] DQFRUD D FXUD GL 01 &$0325, +0R0 GHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L/ 4;<5,1 6HJQDOR TXL LO UHFHQWLVVLPR LQWHUYHQWR GL $151 9(1785, FKH/ DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ GRFXPHQWDWR VWXGLR VX *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL ELEOLRWHFDULR H SUHIHWWR DOOD ´GXFDO OL0 EUDULDµ QHOOD 0RGHQD GHO VHFRQGR 6HWWHFHQWR +SS1 554069 GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL1 0LVFHOODQHD GL VWXGL/ 0RGHQD/ %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH 8QLYHUVLWDULD/ 4<<:,/ DQDOL]]D LO SUHFHGHQWH PXUDWRULDQR/ TXHOOD VXD ´GHYR]LRQH FKH DYUHEEH VSLQWR LO YLJQROHVH EHQ DO GL Oj GHL UXROL GL ELEOLRWHFDULR SHU GH0 ILQLUQH XQ LPSHJQR GL SROLWLFR H GL OHJDWRµ +559,1 ; )LO]D 49/ IDVFLFROR 8 $0%/ FRQ WLWROL ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH= 5DJLRQL GL 6XD 0DHVWj &HVDUHD VRSUD &RPDFFKLR +47 FDUWH, H %UHYH FRPSHQGLR GHOOH UDJLRQL FRQ FXL OD 6HUHQLVVLPD &DVD G·(VWH SUXRYD OD OHJLW0 WLPLWj GL GRQ $OIRQVR SDGUH GL GRQ &HVDUH GD (VWH +65 FDUWH,1 &1 )28&$5' +6FULWWL LQHGLWL/ SS1 93096> FIU1 61 %(57(//, 483084, GDWD DO OXJOLR 4:3; OD %UHYH QRWL]LD VWRULFD UHGDWWD GDO GRWW1 /1$101 GHL GLULWWL LPSHULDOL VX )HUUDUD> GHOOD RSSRUWXQLWj GL UHQGHU IRUWH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD LQ ,WDOLD/ LPSHJQDQGROR D
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4366
GHO 4:3;/ VH D FRQFOXVLRQH GHO VHFRQGR VFULWWR 0TXHOOR VXOOD OHJLWWLPLWj GHOOD GLVFHQGHQ]D GL $OIRQVR ,0 0XUDWRUL/ LQ XQD SHURUD]LRQH GDOO·HOHJDQWH WHVVLWX0 UD VLQWDWWLFR0UHWRULFD/ PD GDOOD VRVWDQ]D JKLEHOOLQD GL DWWR G·DFFXVD DO SRWHUH WHPSRUDOH GHL SDSL +H FKH TXL SXEEOLFR FRPH $OOHJDWR ,,/ DVVHULVFH FKH ´GR0 SR FHQWR H GLHFL DQQLµ OH SURYH DFFXPXODWH UHQGRQR GRYHURVD OD UHVWLWX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD1< $FFDQWR DOOD UHGD]LRQH GHOOH RSHUH D VWDPSD VXH SURSULH/ 0XUDWRUL VL LP0 SHJQz DQFKH D VXJJHULUH/ GL FRQFHUWR FRQ /HLEQL]/ DG DOWUL VFULWWRUL GL SDUWH PRGHQHVH H LPSHULDOH JOL DUJRPHQWL GD WUDWWDUH/ FRUUHVVH L ORUR HODERUDWL GH0 FLGHQGRQH R PHQR OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH>43 H QHO IUDWWHPSR FRQWLQXz LQVWDQFDELOH D VFDYDUH/ DG DSSURQWDUH PHPRULDOL/ D LVWUXLUH DPEDVFLDWRUL H SOHQLSRWHQ]LDUL/ D VFULYHUH GL VXR SXJQR GLUHWWLYH GXFDOL/ VHQ]D WUDVFXUDUH DOWUL SL• SUDWLFL DIID0 UL DPPLQLVWUDWLYL1 3HU TXHVW·XOWLPR VHWWRUH/ LQYLWR DOOD ULOHWWXUD GL XQ EHOOLVVLPR WHVWR +FKH QRQ SXEEOLFR LQ TXDQWR JLj D VWDPSD QHJOL 6FULWWL LQHGLWL/ 48809/ FRQ GDWD DS0 SURVVLPDWLYD 4:43049,/44 LQWLWRODWR GDOO·DXWRUH $OFXQL SLFFLROL ULFRUGL DO QRELO JHQLR GL EHQ IDUH GHO 3DGURQ 6HUHQLVVLPR/ H FKH HVSRQH WDQWH SLFFROH QHFHVVLWj GHL PR0 GHQHVL/ GDOOD VLVWHPD]LRQH GHO SRUWR DO VHOFLDWR GHOO·RGLHUQD SLD]]D 5RPD/ GDOO·HOLPLQD]LRQH GHOOH DFTXH VWDJQDQWL QHL JLDUGLQL GXFDOL +SHU QRQ PHWWHUH D UHSHQWDJOLR OD VDOXWH GHO SXEEOLFR FKH YD Ou SHU VXR ´GLYHUWLPHQWRµ, DOO·LVWLWX]LRQH GL XQD ´YDOOH SHVFDUHFFLDµ QHOOD EDVVD PLUDQGROHVH H GL XQ VHU0 YL]LR UHJRODUH GL FRUULHUD SHU 9HQH]LD> DOOD ILQH/ 0XUDWRUL DJJLXQJH R ULQQRYD O·HVRUWD]LRQH +SUR GRPR VXD/ PD QRQ VROR, D ULFRUGDUVL GL DUFKLYLR H ELEOLRWHFD HVWHQVH1 Ë XQD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D XPDQLVVLPD/ H GLUHL TXDVL FRPPRYHQWH/ GL TXDQWR LO JUDQGH 0XUDWRUL QRQ VWHVVH ULQFKLXVR QHOOD WRUUH G·DYRULR GHO SD0 OD]]R/ PD VL SUHQGHVVH LQYHFH D FXRUH TXHOOD FKH FKLDPz OD ´SXEEOLFD IHOLFL0 Wjµ/ ROWUH PH]]R VHFROR SULPD FKH OD FRVWLWX]LRQH DPHULFDQD LQFOXGHVVH OD ´UL0 FHUFD GHOOD IHOLFLWjµ WUD L GLULWWL GHOO·XRPR1 $OWUH FDUWH GHO JHQHUH +LQHGLWH/ PD FKH QRQ SXEEOLFR RUD SHU QRQ DOORQWD0 QDUPL GDO WHPD SURSRVWR, ULPDQJRQR QHOOD JLj FLWDWD )LO]D 8/ IDVF1 8 GHOO·$UFKLYLR 0XUDWRULDQR DOO·(VWHQVH/ DSSXQWR LQVLHPH FRQ XQ DEER]]R GHO0 ²²²²²²²² VRVWHQHUH TXHL GLULWWL1 < 8Q HJUHJLR H GRFXPHQWDWR ULDVVXQWR GHOOD TXHVWLRQH IHUUDUHVH H LQ SDUWLFRODUH GHOOH R0 ELH]LRQL HVWHQVL0PXUDWRULDQH DOOH SUHWHVH SDSDOL VXOO·LOOHJLWWLPLWj GL &HVDUH G·(VWH q IDWWR GDOOD *g6&+(// <9043;1 43 /D *g6&+(// S1 6: QRWD/ FRQWD XQD VHVVDQWLQD GL VFULWWXUH LQHGLWH/ G·DXWRUL DQRQLPL/ QHO VROR $6021 44 /·RULJLQDOH q DOO·$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH/ /HWWHUDWL/ E1 79 %/ IDVF1 54/ Q1 41
4367
)DELR 0DUUL
OD 3XEEOLFD IHOLFLWj= PHWRGL SHU PLJOLRUDUH OD FROWLYD]LRQH GHOOD FDQDSD +GRFX0 PHQWR E, H GHO JHOVR +GRF1 F,/ SURYYHGLPHQWL PRQHWDUL +GRF1 D,/ XQD ULFKLHVWD DO GXFD SHUFKp FHGD DL ´SRVVLGHQWL GHOOH YLOOH GL 61 &DWDOGR H 9LOODQXRYD GL TXDµ OH DFTXH FRUUHQWL PD QRQ UHJLPDWH WUD )UHWR H LO 6HFFKLD/ FRVu FKH SRV0 VDQR VHUYLUH DOO·LUULJD]LRQH +GRF1 U/ VFRQRVFLXWR DO FDWDORJR 9LVFKL,/ H XQD DF0 FRUDWD OHWWHUD DOOR VWHVVR GXFD/ GHO 8 DJRVWR 4:57 +GRF1 G/ QRQ FRPSUHVR QHOO·HGL]LRQH GHOO·(SLVW1, SHU XQD ULGX]LRQH GHL GD]L GRJDQDOL FKH IDYRULVFD LO FRPPHUFLR GHOOD EDYHOOD FRQVHQWHQGR XQ ODYRUR ´RQHVWRµ DOOH ´SRYHUH IDQ0 FLXOOHµ H LQ JHQHUDOH DOOH IDPLJOLH ELVRJQRVH1 3RFR SL• WDUGD q O·LQHGLWD VWHVXUD DXWRJUDID/ GDWDWD 631,14:5;/ GHO PRWX SUR0 SULR GXFDOH FRQ FXL LO JUDQGH VFLHQ]LDWR H VXGGLWR HVWHQVH 0 VHEEHQH GRFHQWH D 3DGRYD 0/ $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQHUL +499404:63,/ DPLFR GL 0XUDWRUL VWHVVR/ HUD QR0 PLQDWR FDYDOLHUH145 3XEEOLFR LO WHVWR FRPH $OOHJDWR ,,/ VRWWROLQHDQGR FKH O·RQRULILFHQ]D QRQ YD FRQVLGHUDWD XQ VHPSOLFH IDYRUH SULYDWR D XQ DPLFR/ PD ULHQWUD QHOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GL 0XUDWRUL YHUVR FLz FKH SRVVD JLRYDUH DOOD JHQWH FRPXQH= VFULYH LO GLVSRVLWLYR FKH LO SUHPLR GDWR DJOL VWXGLRVL GHYH HVVHUH ORUR VWLPROR ´DG DFFUHVFHUH DQFKH LO SXEEOLFR EHQHµ1 $EELDPR GXQTXH YLVWR O·LQVFLQGLELOLWj GHOO·RSHUD GHO 0XUDWRUL SROLWLFR GD TXHOOD GHOO·LQWHOOHWWXDOH= XQ LQJHJQR XQLYHUVDOH FRPH OXL FROOHJDYD IDFLOPHQWH IDWWL H SHUVRQDJJL/ H GD FRQWDWWL RFFDVLRQDOL/ RYYHUR GLUHWWL D WXWW·DOWUR ILQH/ VDSHYD SDUWLUH SHU FRLQ0 YROJLPHQWL SL• SURIRQGL QHOOD UHWH GHOOH VXH LQL]LDWLYH FXOWXUDOL1 ( LO PRQGR WHGHVFR DVVXPHYD XQ·LPSRUWDQ]D VHPSUH PDJJLRUH= VLD SHU OD FRQFH]LRQH VWRULRJUDILFD PXUDWRULDQD +FKH YHGHYD OD QDVFLWD GHOO·,WDOLD PHGLHYDOH FRPH SURGRWWR GHOOD IXVLRQH WUD ODWLQL H ORQJREDUGL/ H DG HVHPSLR/ QHO FDPSR GHOOD VWRULD GHOO·DUWH/ LPSOLFDYD OD ULYDOXWD]LRQH GHO FRVLGGHWWR JRWLFR,/ VLD SHU JOL HFKL GHO VXR ODYRUR/ DVVDL IRUWL D QRUG GHOOH $OSL ILQ GDL SULPL DQQL1 ²²²²²²²² 45 $602/ $UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH/ &DQFHOOHULD 'XFDOH/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH/ /HWWHUDWL/ E1 79 %/ IDVFLFROR 55/ GRFXPHQWR 4 +WLWROR DUFKLYLVWLFR= ´9DOOLVQHUL 'RWW1 $QWRQLR H GLVFHQGHQWL FUHDWL FDYDOLHULµ,1 ,Q WHVWD DO GRFXPHQWR VWD XQD GRSSLD GDWD]LRQH +DUFKLYLVWLFD,/ 4:3; H 4:5;/ RUL0 JLQDWD YHURVLPLOPHQWH GDO ´:3;µ FKH SDUH GL OHJJHUH QHOO·XOWLPD ULJD/ GL PDQR GHO FDQFHOOLHUH> PD OD GDWD HVDWWD q OD VHFRQGD/ FRPH FRQIHUPDQR VLD LO SUHDPEROR DOOD VWDPSD GHOO·DWWR/ QHOOH 2SHUH ILVLFR0PHGLFKH VWDPSDWH H PDQRVFULWWH GHO .DYDOLHU $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQHUL UDFFROWH GD $QWRQLR VXR IL0 JOLXROR +9HQH]LD/ &ROHWL/ 4:66/ WRPR ,/ SS1 /;9,0 /;9,,,/ VLD OR VFDPELR HSLVWRODUH LQWHUFRU0 VR WUD 0XUDWRUL H 9DOOLVQHUL GDO 63 JHQQDLR DO 7 IHEEUDLR 4:5;= FIU1 /1$101/ &DUWHJJL FRQ 8EDO0 GLQL1119DQQRQL/ D F1 GL 01/1 1,&+(77, 63$1,2 +)LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<:;> &DUWHJJLR/ YRO1 77,/ SS1 646071 $ XQ 0XUDWRUL FKH GLVVLPXODYD LO VXR UXROR QHOOD QRPLQD +´1XOOD VR> SXUH QRQ YR· ODVFLDUH GL UDOOHJUDUPL FRQ WXWWR LO FXRUH FRQ HVVR YRL GL FLz FKH YRL PHJOLR GL PH VDSHWHµ,/ 9DOOLVQHUL UHSOLFDYD= ´9RL PL VFULYHWH FKH QXOOD VDSHWH/ HG LR VR FKH VDSHWH WXWWR/ H FKH DYHWH HVWHVR OD WHVWD GHO GLSORPD FRQ TXHOO·DPRUH FK·q SURSULR GHO YRVWUR EHO FXRUHµ1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4368
*Lj O·RSHUD G·HVRUGLR GL 0XUDWRUL/ JOL $QHFGRWD /DWLQD VWDPSDWL D 0LODQR QHO 49<:0<; +PD YHQGXWL ILQR DG $XJVEXUJ/ QHOOD OLEUHULD .URQLJHU,/ IXURQR UHFHQVLWL FRQ ULOLHYR GD XQD GHOOH SL• LPSRUWDQWL ULYLVWH OHWWHUDULH HXURSHH/ JOL ´$FWD (UXGLWRUXPµ HGLWL D /LSVLD GDOOD IDPLJOLD 0HQFNH1 4XHVWD VWHVVD ULYLVWD SUHVH GHFLVD SRVL]LRQH D IDYRUH GL 0RGHQD H GHOO·LPSHUR GXUDQWH OD TXHVWLR0 QH FRPDFFKLHVH/ RVSLWDQGR DQFKH VFULWWL DQRQLPL FKH ULVDOLYDQR D 0XUDWRUL VWHVVR +HG q XQ·DFTXLVL]LRQH VFLHQWLILFD QXRYD,= QRQ VROR LO FDUWHJJLR WUD 0X0 UDWRUL H L 0HQFNH +DSSHQD SXEEOLFDWR,/ PD DQFKH DQQRWD]LRQL PDQRVFULWWH DSSRVWH DG HVHPSODUL GHJOL ´$FWD (UXGLWRUXPµ FRQVHUYDWL LQ *HUPDQLD GL0 PRVWUDQR FKH 0XUDWRUL IX O·DXWRUH/ R SHUORPHQR LO UHYLVRUH/ GL GXH DUWLFROL ODWLQL VX &RPDFFKLR +LQ SUDWLFD/ GXH DXWRUHFHQVLRQL, DSSDUVL QHO 4:44 H 4:4:/ GRSR FKH QHO 4:3< OR VWHVVR PRGHQHVH DYHYD IDYRULWR OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL XQ DQDORJR WHVWR GL /HLEQL]146 1XPHURVH IXURQR SRL OH HGL]LRQL LQ WHUULWRULR WHGHVFR GL RSHUH PXUDWR0 ULDQH/ RULJLQDOL R WUDGRWWH1 6H DQFKH HVFOXGLDPR VFULWWL FRPH L 3UROHJRPHQD DG YHULWDWLV HW SDFLV DPDQWHV/ PDL XVFLWL LQ ,WDOLD +DOPHQR XIILFLDOPHQWH/ SHU PRWLYL GL FHQVXUD,47 H SHUz VWDPSDWL D &RORQLD QHO 4:38 H D -HQD QHO 4:74> RSSXUH OH 5LIOHVVLRQL VRSUD LO EXRQ JXVWR +GHFLVLYH SHU O·HYROX]LRQH GHOO·HVWHWLFD HXURSHD,/ OD FXL SULPD HGL]LRQH LQWHJUDOH LQ GXH YROXPL UHFD OD GDWD GL &RORQLD 4:48 +PD GRYUHEEH WUDWWDUVL GL XQ IDOVR OXRJR,/ ULPDQH XQD OXQJD OLVWD GL WUDGX]LRQL= GDSSULPD LQ IUDQFHVH SHU DOFXQL OLEUL GHOOD SROHPLFD FRPDFFKLHVH +DG HVHP0 SLR OH 2VVHUYD]LRQL VRSUD XQD OHWWHUD LQWLWRODWD ¶,O GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GHOOD 6HGH $SRVWR0 OLFD VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR·111 GHO 4:3;/ XVFLWH DQFKH FRQ OD SUHVXPLELOPHQWH IDOVD LQGLFD]LRQH ´)UDQFIRUW 4:46µ/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR WUDGRWWH FRPH 2EVHUYDWLRQV VXU XQH OHWWUH LQWLWXOpH ¶/D VRXYHUDLQHWp WHPSRUHOOH >111@·/ /·$MD 4:43> SRL OD 3LHQD HVSR0 VL]LRQH GHL GLULWWL LPSHULDOL HG HVWHQVL VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR GHO 4:45/ GLYHQXWD /HV GURLWV GH O·(PSLUH VXU O·(VWDW HFFOpVLDVWLTXH/ 8WUHFKW 4:46,/ LQGL LQ WHGHVFR SHU QXPHURVH RSHUH/ D FRPLQFLDUH GDJOL (VHUFL]L VSLULWXDOL +XVFLWL D 0RGHQD GD 6R0 OLDQL QHO 4:53,/ GLYHQXWL *HLVWOLFKH hEXQJHQ DG $XJVEXUJ QHO 4:68/ ILQR DJOL $QQDOL G·,WDOLD/ L FXL QRYH WRPL GHOOD WUDGX]LRQH WHGHVFD DSSDUYHUR D /LSVLD WUD LO 4:78 H LO *83/ TXDVL FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH DOO·RULJLQDOH LWDOLDQR +45 WRPL/ 9HQH]LD/ 3DVTXDOL/ 4:7707<,1 /H WUDGX]LRQL FRQWLQXDURQR QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj ²²²²²²²² 46
6L YHGDQR O·LQYHQWDULR GHJOL DUWLFROL ULJXDUGDQWL 0XUDWRUL VXJOL ´$FWD (UXGLWRUXPµ GDO 49<; DO 4:84/ H LO FDUWHJJLR FRPSOHWR WUD LO QRVWUR H L TXDWWUR FRPSRQHQWL GHOOD IDPLJOLD 0HQFNH +49<:04:69,/ SXEEOLFDWL LQ )1 0$55, 0 01 /,(%(5/ 0XUDWRUL XQG 'HXWVFKODQG FLW1/ SS1 4390449 +D FXUD GL &1 :(<(56, H 44:06;1 6XO UDSSRUWR FRQ /HLEQL] FIU1 LYL/ SS1 460571 47 )LQR DOOD SXEEOLFD]LRQH LQ DSSHQGLFH GHOOD EHQHPHULWD DQWRORJLD 2SHUH GL /1$101 FXUDWD GD *1 )$/&2 H )1 )257, +0LODQR01DSROL/ 5LFFLDUGL/ 4<97,/ SS1 534:0537:1
4369
)DELR 0DUUL
GHO VHFROR GRSR OD PRUWH GL 0XUDWRUL/ FRQ XQ DSLFH FODPRURVR QHO FDVR GHOOD 5HJRODWD GLYR]LRQ GH· FULVWLDQL/ XVFLWD D 9HQH]LD +$OEUL]]L, QHO 4:7: H GL FXL VRQR VWDWH FRQWDWH YHQWL HGL]LRQL WHGHVFKH R DXVWULDFKH WUD LO 4:84 H LO *<81 $OWUH RSHUH/ ODWLQH/ IXURQR VWDPSDWH DOO·HVWHUR QHOOD OLQJXD RULJLQDOH= DG HVHPSLR/ LO 'H LQJHQLRUXP PRGHUDWLRQH LQ UHOLJLRQLV QHJRWLR FLUFROz QHOOH HGL]LRQL GL 3DULJL +4:47,/ &RORQLD +4:48, H )UDQFRIRUWH +4:49, EHQ SULPD GL XVFLUH LQ ,WD0 OLD +9HQH]LD/ &ROHWL/ 4:5:,> YHQQH SRL WUDGRWWR LQ WHGHVFR D SDUWLUH GDO 4:9</ FRQ XQ·XOWLPD VWDPSD D &REOHQ]D/ SUHVVR LO FHOHEUH HGLWRUH %DHGHNHU/ DGGLULW0 WXUD QHO 4;6:1 4XHVWL VFULWWL/ GL UHOLJLRQH H SROLWLFD LQVLHPH +FXL VL DJJLXQJD OD SL• YROWH FLWDWD 3XEEOLFD IHOLFLWj/ VWDPSDWD LQ GXH WUDGX]LRQL GLYHUVH D 0RQDFR QHO 4:8; H D /LSVLD QHO *<;,/ IHFHUR XQ·HQRUPH LPSUHVVLRQH VXO PRQGR WHGH0 VFR= O·LPSHUDWULFH 0DULD 7HUHVD QH IX LQIOXHQ]DWD/ HG q VWDWR GLPRVWUDWR LO OR0 UR DVFHQGHQWH SXUH VXOO·LQGLUL]]R SROLWLFR GHO GL OHL ILJOLR/ O·LPSHUDWRUH *LX0 VHSSH ,, +LO FRVLGGHWWR ´JLXVHSSLQLVPRµ,1 +D VFULWWR 0DULR 5RVD FKH 0XUDWRUL/ GDO 4:73 LQ SRL/ GLYHQQH ´LO OHDGHU GL XQD FRUUHQWH QRQ VROWDQWR FXOWXUDOHµ/ ´OD JXLGD GL XQ PRYLPHQWR LWDOLDQR H SRL/ LQ SDUWH/ HXURSHR/ GDOOH VIXPDWXUH ULJRULVWH H JLDQVHQLVWHJJLDQWLµ>48 H FKH OD VXD 5HJRODWD GLYR]LRQH ´GLYHQQH LO PDQXDOH GL RSSRVL]LRQH DXVWULDFD DOOD SLH0 Wj EDURFFDµ149 ( )UDQFR 9HQWXUL/ GRSR DYHU GHGLFDWR DPSLR VSD]LR/ QHO VXR SRGHURVR DIIUHVFR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR ULIRUPDWRUH/4: SULPD DOOD GLPLQX]LRQH GHOOH IH0 VWH UHFODPDWD D JUDQ YRFH GD 0XUDWRUL SHU ILQL XPDQLWDUL +H VDQFLWD QHO 4:7; GD SDSD %HQHGHWWR ;,9,/ SRL DL ULIOHVVL HXURSHL GHOOH GXH RSHUH PXUDWRULDQH 'HL GLIHWWL GHOOD JLXULVSUXGHQ]D H /D SXEEOLFD IHOLFLWj/ ´O·HVSUHVVLRQH SL• PDWXUD GL WXWWR LO SHQVLHUR ULIRUPDWRUH LQ ,WDOLD GXUDQWH OD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH DXVWULD0 FDµ/ ULEDGLVFH/ QHO FRQWULEXWR DSSDUVR VXO YRO1 ,,,/ 'DO SULPR 6HWWHFHQWR DOO·8QLWj/ GHOOD 6WRULD G·,WDOLD (LQDXGL/4; LO SURIRQGR UDGLFDPHQWR QHO PRQGR DXVWULDFR H LQ WXWWD (XURSD +FRPLQFLDQGR GDOO·DUHD GL FXOWXUD WHGHVFD H RODQ0 GHVH, GHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR PXUDWRULDQR FRQWUR OD VXSHUVWL]LRQH UHOLJLRVD1 ²²²²²²²² 48
5LIRUPDWRUL H ULEHOOL QHO ·:33 UHOLJLRVR LWDOLDQR +%DUL/ 'HGDOR/ 4<9<,/ FDS1 ,/ /·HWj ¶PXUDWRULDQD· QHOO·,WDOLD GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ SS1 <07: +LO FLWDWR GDOOD S1 49,1 49 3ROLWLFD H UHOLJLRQH QHO ·:33 HXURSHR +)LUHQ]H/ 6DQVRQL/ 4<:3,/ S1 751 6XJOL HFKL PXUDWRULDQL QHO PRQGR JHUPDQLFR VRQR GD OHJJHUH L FRQWULEXWL GL (1 *$506 &251,'(6/ 31 +(56&+(/ $1 .5$86/ *1 7(//(1%$&+/ (1 :,17(5 HG (1 =/$%,1*(5 QHL YROO1 ,, H ,,, GHJOL $WWL GHO &RQYH0 JQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL PXUDWRULDQL +)LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<:8,> GL ,1 01 %$77$)$5$12 QHO YR0 OXPH GD OXL FXUDWR 'HXWVFKH $XINOlUXQJ XQG ,WDOLHQ +)UDQNIXUW DP 0DLQ HFF1/ /DQJ/ 4<<5,1 8Q TXDGUR FRPSOHVVLYR q GDWR LQ )1 0$55, 0 01 /,(%(5/ SS1 5<0731 4: 9RO1 ,/ 'D 0XUDWRUL D %HFFDULD/ 7RULQR/ (LQDXGL/ 4<9</ SS1 46;094 H 4940;9 +LO FLWDWR GDO0 OD S1 494,1 4; /·,WDOLD IXRUL G·,WDOLD +4<:6,/ SS1 434;0561
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
436:
8Q UXROR LPSRUWDQWH SHU OD GLIIXVLRQH LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GHOOH LGHH PXUDWR0 ULDQH IX ULFRSHUWR DQFKH GDL FRQWDWWL HSLVWRODUL= H L WHGHVFKL VRQR L SL• QXPH0 URVL WUD JOL VWUDQLHUL TXDQWR DO QXPHUR GL OHWWHUH VFDPELDWH +FKH VLDQR ULPDVWH RJJL, FRQ 0XUDWRUL/ GDYDQWL DJOL VWHVVL IUDQFHVL1 7UD OH ILJXUH GL SULPLVVLPR SLDQR GHOOD FXOWXUD WHGHVFD D FROORTXLR FRQ 0XUDWRUL KR JLj ULFRUGDWR L 0HQ0 FNH +LO FDSRVWLSLWH 2WWR/ WUD LO 49<: H LO 4:37> LO ILJOLR -RKDQQ %XUFKDUG/ GDO 4:46 DO 4:64> L QLSRWL )ULHGULFK 2WWR/ FRQ WUH OHWWHUH GHO 4:65/ H &DUO 2WWR/ FKH FKLXVH LO FDUWHJJLR IDPLOLDUH FRQ XQD OHWWHUD LWDOLDQD GHO 4:69, H /HLEQL]/ OD FXL FRUULVSRQGHQ]D FRO QRVWUR H SHUVRQDJJL FRQQHVVL VL DYYLFLQD DO FHQWL0 QDLR GL SH]]L/ ULJXDUGDQWL GDSSULPD O·DIIDUH GL &RPDFFKLR/ LQGL OD SUHSDUD0 ]LRQH GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL +FXL LO WHGHVFR/ PRUWR QHO 4:49/ QRQ ULXVFu D IDU FRPEDFLDUH LO SURJHWWDWR OLEUR GDOOD SDUWH GHOOD FDVD GL +DQQRYHU/ FKH XVFLUj VROR QHO 4:83 GRSR OXQJKH LQWHJUD]LRQL DOWUXL,1 1HPPHQR LO VXFFHVVRUH GL /HLEQL] QHO UXROR GL VWRULFR EUXQVYLFHQVH/ -RKDQQ *HRUJ (FNKDUW/ IX FDSDFH GL FRPSOHWDUQH LO ODYRUR/ DEEDQGRQDQGR DQ]L QHO 4:57 +DQQRYHU SHU :•U0 ]EXUJ> L GXH DQQL GL FDUWHJJLR FRQ 0XUDWRUL +4:4:04<, HEEHUR SHUz O·HIIHWWR GL RWWHQHUH GDOOD FRUWH GL +DQQRYHU H /RQGUD LO SHUPHVVR GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL/ QRQRVWDQWH O·LQGLVSRQLELOLWj GHOOD SDUDOOHOD FRPSLOD]LR0 QH FKH VL HUD SDWWXLWD1 ,O SL• DQWLFR GL WXWWL L FRUULVSRQGHQWL WHGHVFKL GL 0XUDWRUL HUD VWDWR/ DGGL0 ULWWXUD GDO 49<9 +H ILQR DOOD VXD PRUWH QHO 4:38,/ O·HUXGLWR H SXEEOLFR DPPLQL0 VWUDWRUH GL 1RULPEHUJD -DFRE :LOKHOP YRQ ,PKRI/ FKH VL ULYROVH SHU LQIR0 PD]LRQL DQWLTXDULH DO JLRYDQLVVLPR 0XUDWRUL ELEOLRWHFDULR DPEURVLDQR/ H OR LQWURGXVVH DOOD FRQRVFHQ]D GL /HLEQL] VWHVVR1 'HO 4:3< q LQYHFH LO FDUWHJJLR FRO JUDQGH FODVVLFLVWD -RKDQQ $OEHUW )DEULFLXV GL /LSVLD/ FKH QHOOH VXH ELEOLR0 JUDILH VHJQDOz L SUHJL GHOOH SULPH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GL 0XUDWRUL/ ULFHYHQGRQH LQ RPDJJLR +FRPH GHGLFDWDULR, XQD GRWWD GLVVHUWD]LRQH PDQRVFULWWD VXOO·RULJLQH GHOOH EDVLOLFKH SUHVVR L SULPL FULVWLDQL1 &RQ XQ DOWUR )DEULFLXV +LO ELEOLRJUDIR -RKDQQ/ GL +HOPVWHGW, 0XUDWRUL FRUULVSRVH WUD LO 4:54 H LO *59 +YHGHQGR SXE0 EOLFDWD QHO 4:58 XQD SURSULD RQRUHYROH ELRJUDILD/ OD SULPD LQ DVVROXWR/ LQ XQ YROXPH GHOOR VWHVVR )DEULFLXV,/ H QHO 4:5; ULFHYHWWH D 0RGHQD OD YLVLWD GHO GL OXL ILJOLR 5XGROSK $QWRQ14< ,O GLVFRUVR VDUHEEH DQFRUD OXQJR VH YROHVVL SDVVDUH LQ UDVVHJQD JOL DOWUL WH0 GHVFKL FRQ FXL 0XUDWRUL IX LQ FRQWDWWR> OXQJR H VXSHUILFLDOH/ SHUFKp LQ PROWL FDVL OH OHWWHUH GHL FRUULVSRQGHQWL QRQ VRQR VWDWH DQFRUD HGLWH +H VSHVVR TXHOOH PXUDWRULDQH QRQ SRWUDQQR HVVHUOR ULVXOWDQGR GLVSHUVH,1 %DVWL DOORUD ULFRUGDUH ²²²²²²²² 4< 3HU SDUWLFRODUL SL• DPSL/ H LO FDUWHJJLR FRPSOHWR WUD 0XUDWRUL/ -RKDQQ $OEHUW H -RKDQQ )DEULFLXV/ VL YHGD LO FDS1 ,9 GL )1 0$55, 0 01 /,(%(5/ SS1 46<0941
436;
)DELR 0DUUL
GL VIXJJLWD53 ILJXUH FRPH LO SDVWRUH SURWHVWDQWH -RKDQQ -DFRE %UXFNHU GL $X0 JVEXUJ +FLWWj 0 FRPH YHGUHPR WUD SRFR 0 FKH JXDUGDYD D 0XUDWRUL FRQ GHYR0 ]LRQH,/ HGLWRUH QHO 4:75 GL XQ·DOWUD ELRELEOLRJUDILD GHO QRVWUR/ LQ ODWLQR H LQ WHGHVFR H FRQ XQ ULWUDWWR/ DSSDUVD QHOOD 3LQDFRWKHFD VFULSWRUXP QRVWUD DHWDWH OLWHULV LOOXVWULXP +RYYHUR %LOGHUVDDO KHXWLJHV 7DJHV OHEHQGHU DQG GXUFK *HODKUWKHLW EHU•KPWHU 6FKULIWVWHOOHU,/ HQFLFORSHGLD GHL SL• IDPRVL OHWWHUDWL HXURSHL YLYHQWL/ WUD FXL JOL LWDOLDQL SUHVFHOWL QRQ DUULYDURQR DOOD GHFLQD1 /·LQWHUHVVH GL %UXFNHU YHUVR 0X0 UDWRUL QRQ IX VROR HUXGLWR/ PD DQFKH XPDQR H UHOLJLRVR/ FRPH DSSDUH GDOOH VXH QRYH OHWWHUH FRQVHUYDWH DOO·(VWHQVH/ FKH DIIURQWDQR SHU HVHPSLR L WHPL GHO GRJPDWLVPR JHVXLWD H GHO SRVVLELOH ULDYYLFLQDPHQWR WUD OH FKLHVH FULVWLD0 QH1 'LFLDPR SRL GHO ODWLQLVWD *RWWOLHE .RUUWH +&RUWLXV,/ FKH SHU LQWHUFHVVLRQH GL -1 %XUFKDUG 0HQFNH RWWHQQH GD 0XUDWRUL LQIRUPD]LRQL ILORORJLFKH XWLOL SHU OD VXD HGL]LRQH GL /XFDQR +H SHU DOWUH LQGDJLQL VX 3OLQLR H 9LUJLOLR,> H LQILQH/ GL XQ FDVR SLXWWRVWR VLQJRODUH QHOOD VWRULD GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD LWDOLDQD/ TXHOOR GL XQ EDYDUHVH/ -RKDQQ 6LJLVPXQG 6FKHOKRUQ GD 0HPPLQJHQ/ FKH PDQGz D 0XUDWRUL +VFHOWR FRPH UHYLVRUH H JLXGLFH LQDSSHOODELOH, WUH SURSUL VRQHWWL LWD0 OLDQL PDQRVFULWWL1 $ WDOH FRPSLWR LO QRVWUR +PHPRUH GHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR PLOD0 QHVH GL &DUOR 0DULD 0DJJL/ H VXOO·RQGD GHO VXFFHVVR GHOOD 3HUIHWWD SRHVLD LWDOLDQD H GHJOL DOWUL VFULWWL GL HVWHWLFD, VL HUD FRUWHVHPHQWH YRWDWR D SL• ULSUHVH/ PD TXHVWD IX OD SULPD +FUHGR/ O·XQLFD, YROWD FKH XQD VLPLOH ULFKLHVWD JOL YHQLVVH GD XQR VWUDQLHUR= FLz D WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOD ODUJD GLIIXVLRQH LQWHUQD]LRQDOH DQFKH GL TXHOOH RSHUH GL FULWLFD OHWWHUDULD FRPSRVWH/ D WUHQW·DQQL R SRFR SL•/ SHUFKp O·RFFXSD]LRQH IUDQFHVH GL 0RGHQD JOL WRJOLHYD O·DGLWR D VWXGL SL• LPSHJQDWLYL1 0D D FRPSOHWDUH LO TXDGUR GHL UDSSRUWL WUD 0XUDWRUL H OD *HUPDQLD RFFRU0 UH WHQHU FRQWR/ ROWUH FKH GHL FRUULVSRQGHQWL WHGHVFKL YHUL H SURSUL/ DQFKH GHL PROWL LWDOLDQL UHVLGHQWL LQ *HUPDQLD/ YXRL FRPH GLJQLWDUL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ YXRL FRPH VHJUHWDUL GL SRWHQWL +YHVFRYL R SUuQFLSL GHOO·,PSHUR,/ H DQFKH FRPH SR0 HWL/ QHO VHFROR FKH XOWLPR FRQREEH L VXFFHVVL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL GHOOD QRVWUD OLQ0 JXD +VSHFLH VXOOH VFHQH GHOO·RSHUD OLULFD,1 'L PROWL 0XUDWRUL VL YDOVH SHU FRQ0 VROLGDUH L VXRL OHJDPL FRQ TXHJOL DPELHQWL= DG HVHPSLR PLVH LQ FDPSR XQ SLFFROR HVHUFLWR GL DPLFL SHU OD GHGLFD GHOOH $QWLTXLWDWHV ,WDOLFDH 0HGLL $HYL54 +GD PROWL ULWHQXWR LO VXR FDSRODYRUR, DO UH GL 3RORQLD HG HOHWWRUH GL 6DVVRQLD ²²²²²²²² 53
8QR VFKL]]R SRFR SL• YDVWR +LQ OLQJXD WHGHVFD/ FRPH WXWWR TXHO OLEUR, q DQFRUD LQ )1 0$55, 0 01 /,(%(5/ FDS1 9,,/ 4<405341 54 3HU DOWUH LQIRUPD]LRQL ULPDQGR DO FDS1 9 GL )1 0$55, 0 01 /,(%(5/ SS1 496049</ H +LQ YHUVLRQH LWDOLDQD, D )1 0$55,/ /D GHGLFD GHOOH ¶$QWLTXLWDWHV ,WDOLFDH·/ LQ &RUWH/ EXRQ JRYHUQR111 FLW1/ SS1 :40;91 0D TXL DJJLXQJR SDUWLFRODUL HPHUVL GD QXRYH HVSORUD]LRQL VXO FDUWHJJLR LQHGLWR1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
436<
)HGHULFR $XJXVWR ,,,/ GDO TXDOH VL ULSURPHWWHYD XQ EHQHILFLR HFRQRPLFR GD GHYROYHUH D ILQL FDULWDWLYL155 3HU VRQGDUH OD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHO UH +FKH/ QHO 4:45 TXDQGR HUD SULQFLSH HUH0 GLWDULR/ OR DYHYD FRQRVFLXWR SHUVRQDOPHQWH GXUDQWH XQ SDVVDJJLR GD 0RGH0 QD,/ FKLHVH DO VXR H[ VHJUHWDULR *LXVHSSH 5LYD +JLj DGGHWWR G·DPEDVFLDWD D /RQGUD H +DQQRYHU/ SUH]LRVR DO WHPSR GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL/ GHGLFDWH 0 FR0 PH VDSSLDPR 0 D *LRUJLR ,,/ RUD QHOO·DPEDVFLDWD PRGHQHVH D 9LHQQD/ GL PXRYHUH TXDOFKH SHGLQD/ FRPLQFLDQGR GDOO·DOWUR FRQFLWWDGLQR SUHVVR OD FRUWH LPSHULDOH/ LO YHVFRYR +IDQDQHVH G·RULJLQH, *LXOLDQR 6DEEDWLQL1 4XHVWL ULXVFu D RWWHQHUH O·LQWHUFHVVLRQH GHO SRWHQWH JHVXLWD ,JQD]LR *XDULQL/ FRQIHVVRUH H SUHGLFDWRUH GHO UH WHGHVFR/ FKH LQ EUHYH DFFHWWz OD GHGLFD SHU Vp H L SURSUL IL0 JOL> LO SULPR GL HVVL/ LO IXWXUR UH )HGHULFR &ULVWLDQR/ QHO 4:6< YLVLWz 0RGHQD H FRQREEH ´LO IDPRVR 0XUDWRULµ/ GLFHQGRQH QHO GLDULR= ´q LQFUHGLELOH TXDQWR DEELD VFULWWR GD VROR TXHVW·XRPRµ +HUDQR L WHPSL QHL TXDOL XQD YLVLWD D 0XUD0 WRUL HUD XQ REEOLJR SHU WXWWL JOL LQWHOOHWWXDOL FKH VFHQGHYDQR LQ ,WDOLD,156 , GHW0 WDJOL GD LPPHWWHUH QHOOD GHGLFD GHO SULPR/ SRL GHJOL DOWUL FLQTXH YROXPL +FR0 PH OH QRWL]LH SHUVRQDOL VX VRYUDQR H ILJOL,/ YHQQHUR LQ EXRQD SDUWH GD 6WHID0 QR %1 3DOODYLFLQL/ LO YHUVHJJLDWRUH GL 6DOz FKH 0XUDWRUL DYHYD VILRUDWR QHJOL DQQL GHOOD TXHVWLRQH FRPDFFKLHVH +TXDQGR HUD SRHWD H FRQVLJOLHUH GL FRUWH D '•VVHOGRUI/ SUHVVR O·HOHWWRUH GHO 3DODWLQDWR *LRYDQQL *XJOLHOPR,/ H DGHVVR LQWHUSHOOz SL• DVVLGXDPHQWH/ FRQRVFHQGROR DQFKH GL SHUVRQD FRPH DFFRP0 SDJQDWRUH GL )HGHULFR &ULVWLDQR QHO 4:6<1 /D SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHOOH $QWLTXLWDWHV VL SURWUDVVH ILQR D WXWWR LO 4:76/ TXDQ0 GR 5LYD H 3DOODYLFLQL HUDQR JLj PRUWL/ H 6DEEDWLQL VWDYD DYYLDQGRVL D GLYHQLUH YHVFRYR GL 0RGHQD> DQFRUD GL SL• WDUGz )HGHULFR $XJXVWR ,,, D FRPSHQVDUH 0XUDWRUL/ FKH SHU VROOHFLWDUH LO UH ULSDUWu GDO FURFHYLD GL 9LHQQD/ GDO VXR JLR0 YDQH FRUULVSRQGHQWH OLJXUH %ULFKLHUL &RORPEL +FLWDWR QHOOD SUHF1 QRWD 56/ H FKH JOL HUD VHUYLWR FRPH LQWHUPHGLDULR FRQ 3DOODYLFLQL,/ LO TXDOH RUD VFRPRGz SHUILQR LO FHOHEUH PXVLFLVWD $GROSK +DVVH +DWWLYR D 'UHVGD DQFKH VX OLEUHWWL GL 3DOODYLFLQL,> H GDO WUHQWLQR *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD *DVSDUL/ FKH QHO 4:75076 SDVVz GDOO·$XVWULD D 'UHVGD FRQ XQD OHWWHUD GL UDFFRPDQGD]LRQH GL 0XUDWRUL SHU XQ ²²²²²²²² 55 Ë DSSHQD LO OXRJR GL ULFRUGDUH FRPH/ LQ XQ·HSRFD FKH QRQ FRQRVFHYD L GLULWWL G·DXWRUH/ JOL XQLFL D JXDGDJQDUH GHQDUR IRVVHUR JOL HGLWRUL/ H OD VSHUDQ]D GL XQ ULFRQRVFLPHQWR SHU FKL VFULYHYD YHQLVVH GDOOD JHQHURVLWj GHL SRWHQWL1 56 ,O SULQFLSH ODVFLz XQ·RWWLPD LPSUHVVLRQH D 0XUDWRUL +QRQ VROR SHU DYHUJOL GRQDWR XQ PHGDJOLRQH G·RUR,/ FKH VFULYHQGR GXH DQQL GRSR +4:1914:74, D *LDQ 'RPHQLFR %ULFKLHUL &RORPEL/ OR ULFRUGDYD FRPH ´XQ DQJHOR GL FRVWXPLµ +VHSSXU GHELOLWDWR ILVLFDPHQWH,1 0D TXHO VRJJLRUQR SUHSDUz DQFKH OD JLj DFFHQQDWD/ SHU 0RGHQD QHIDVWD ´YHQGLWD GL 'UHVGDµ/ FRQFOX0 VD WUD LO GLFHPEUH 4:78 H O·DSULOH 4:791
4373
)DELR 0DUUL
LPSLHJR VWRULFR D FRUWH1 *DVSDUL/ IHUYHQWH PXUDWRULDQR PD WURSSR IRFRVR/ H VSHVVR QHL JXDL SHU OH VXH LQWHPSHUDQ]H/ QRQ FDYz XQ UDJQR GDO EXFR Qp SHU Vp Qp SHU LO PRGHQHVH/ FRO TXDOH VL VEULJz LQ XQD OHWWHUD GD 9LHQQD GHO 481;,,14:77 +O·XOWLPD ULPDVWDFL,/57 JURQGDQWH GLVSUH]]R SHU *XDULQL/ FKH DYH0 YD LQYHFH FRPSHQVDWR ODXWDPHQWH 0HWDVWDVLR SHU GXH OLEUHWWL G·RSHUD= ´'XQ0 TXH/ GLFHYD LR/ SHO 0HWDVWDVLR YH QH VRQR/ H SHO 0XUDWRUL QR" FKH FRQIURQWR/ FKH SDUDJRQH q TXHVWR" GRY·q LO GHFRUR/ GRY·q OD JLXVWL]LD"µ1 $QGz UHODWLYDPHQWH PHJOLR FRQ O·LQWHUPHGLD]LRQH GL %ULFKLHUL/ JUD]LH D FXL 0XUDWRUL DFFRVWz GXH FDUGLQDOL/ HQWUDPEL 0 LQ VXFFHVVLRQH 0 QXQ]L DSRVWROLFL LQ 3RORQLD/ &DPLOOR 3DROXFFL H $OEHULFR $UFKLQWR> SHU WHQHUVL EXRQR *XDUL0 QL/ JOL IHFH FRQVHJQDUH XQD FRSLD GHOOD VXD QXRYD RSHUD ,O FULVWLDQHVLPR IHOLFH QHO0 OH PLVVLRQL GH· SDGUL GHOOD FRPSDJQLD GL *HV• QHO 3DUDJXD\ +4:76,/ SUHVHQWDWD FRPH XQ RPDJJLR DL JHVXLWL GRSR OH WDQWH EDWWDJOLH WHRORJLFKH VXOO·,PPDFRODWD &RQFH]LRQH H FRQWUR LO FRVLGGHWWR ´YRWR VDQJXLQDULRµ1 0D IRUVH LO UH VDVVRQH SHQVDYD FKH QRQ HUD LO FDVR GL GDUH DOWUL VROGL D 0RGHQD GRSR L FHQWRPLOD ]HFFKLQL VERUVDWL SHU L IDPRVL FHQWR TXDGUL HVWHQVL/ H WHQQH VXOOH VSLQH 0XUD0 WRUL +FKH SURSULR QHOO·DJRVWR 4:79/ FLRq TXDWWUR PHVL GRSR OD FRQFOXVLRQH GHOOD YHQGLWD/ DYHYD IDWWR LQROWUDUH GD %ULFKLHUL DG $UFKLQWR XQD ´VXSSOLFDµ FRQWHQHQWH DQFKH OD SURVDLFD GLVWLQWD GHL FRVWL DIIURQWDWL, ILQR DOO·DSULOH 4:7;/ TXDQGR $UFKLQWR FRPXQLFz GD 'UHVGD OR VWDQ]LDPHQWR GL 633 WDOOHUL H WUH PHGDJOLH G·RUR1 1RQ PROWR SL• FKH XQ ULPERUVR/ FRPH VL ODPHQWz 0XUDWRUL LQ XQD OHWWHUD D %ULFKLHUL GHO 55 PDJJLR VHJXHQWH1 1RQRVWDQWH WDOL LPSLFFL H GHOXVLRQL/ LO QRVWUR FRQWLQXz VXOOD YLD GHOOH GH0 GLFKH ¶WHGHVFKH· GL RSHUH VXH/ LQDXJXUDWD PROWL GHFHQQL SULPD FRQ TXHOOH GHO0 OD 3LHQD HVSRVL]LRQH +4:45,/ SRL GHOOD &DULWj FULVWLDQD +4:56, H GHO SULPR YROXPH +LQ GXH WRPL/ 4:56058, GHL 5HUXP ,WDOLFDUXP 6FULSWRUHV DOO·LPSHUDWRUH &DUOR 9,/ H/ FRPH DEELDPR YLVWR/ GHOOD SULPD SDUWH GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL +4:4:, D *LRUJLR , G·,QJKLOWHUUD1 , EXRQL UDSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR HVWHQVH H OD FDVD UH0 JQDQWH GL +DQQRYHU FRQWLQXDURQR/ SHU RSHUD GL 0XUDWRUL/ DQFKH FRL VXFFHV0 VRUL DL ULVSHWWLYL WURQL/ )UDQFHVFR ,,, H *LRUJLR ,,1 Ë GL PDQR PXUDWRULDQD OD OHWWHUD ODWLQD +LQHGLWD/ FKH SXEEOLFR FRPH $OOHJDWR ,,,, PHGLDQWH OD TXDOH LO QXRYR GXFD GL 0RGHQD FRPXQLFDYD OD PRUWH GHO SDGUH 5LQDOGR/ DYYHQXWD LO 591;14:6:/ H LO SURSULR LQVHGLDPHQWR/ XIILFLDOL]]DWR LO 7 GLFHPEUH LQ FXL OD OHW0 WHUD q GDWDWD> Qp 0XUDWRUL RPLVH LO ULFKLDPR DJOL DQWLFKL H SL• UHFHQWL YLQFROL/ GLQDVWLFL H SROLWLFL/ WUD OH GXH FDVH1 3RFKL PHVL GRSR +SHU WRUQDUH DOOH GHGLFKH ¶HFFHOOHQWL·,/ QHOOR VWHVVR 4:6; LQ FXL FRPLQFLDURQR D XVFLUH OH $QWLTXLWDWHV/ 0XUDWRUL RIIUu O·RSHUD WHRORJLFD ²²²²²²²² 57
,QHGLWD/ QHOO·$UFKLYLR 0XUDWRULDQR GHOO·(VWHQVH/ )LO]D ;7 IDVF1 8<1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4374
'H 3DUDGLVR DO FDUGLQDO 'RPLQLN /DPEHUJ/ YHVFRYR0FRQWH GL 3DVVDX/ LO FXL VH0 JUHWDULR HUD O·LWDOLDQR 3LHWUR 0DULDQL +GHO TXDOH FL UHVWDQR 56 OHWWHUH DO PRGH0 QHVH/ SXEEOLFDWH QHO 4<<<,1 , TXDWWUR PDVVLFFL YROXPL GHO 1RYXV WKHVDXUXV YHWH0 UXP LQVFULSWLRQXP/ XVFLWL FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH DOOH $QWLTXLWDWHV WUD LO 4:6< H LO *75 +q LQFUHGLELOH/ SHU QRL FRPH SHU LO SULQFLSH )HGHULFR &ULVWLDQR GL 6DVVR0 QLD/ FRPH 0XUDWRUL SRWHVVH ODYRUDUH FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH D OLYHOOL VFLHQWLILFL GL XQD WDOH HFFHOOHQ]D,/ IXURQR GHGLFDWL D -RVHSK :HQ]HO/ EDURQH GHOO·,PSHUR H SULQFLSH GL /LHFKWHQVWHLQ> H DOOD GL OXL PRJOLH $QQD 0DULD DQGz QHO 4:7: OD 5HJRODWD GLYR]LRQ GH· FULVWLDQL/ WHVWR 0 FRPH GHWWR 0 GHVWLQDWR D XQ·HQRUPH ULVR0 QDQ]D QHO PRQGR JHUPDQLFR1 /·DOWUD JUDQGH RSHUD0WHVWDPHQWR GL 0XUDWRUL/ OD 3XEEOLFD IHOLFLWj GHO 4:7</ IX GHGLFDWD DO YHVFRYR0FRQWH GL 6DOLVEXUJR $QGUHDV -1 YRQ 'LHWULFKVWHLQ> PHQWUH DQFRUD GXH SUHODWL H SULQFLSL GHOO·,PSHUR/ LO FDUGLQDOH )HUGLQDQG -1 7UR\HU GL 2OP•W] +2ORPRXF/ LQ 0RUDYLD, H -RVHSK GL $VVLD0'DUPVWDGW/ YHVFRYR GHOOD ¶PXUDWRULDQD· $XJVEXUJ/ ULFHYHWWHUR YROHQWLHUL L OLEUL GL WHRORJLD H VWRULD HF0 FOHVLDVWLFD /LWXUJLD 5RPDQD YHWXV +4:7;, H 'H QDHYLV LQ UHOLJLRQHP LQFXUUHQWLEXV +4:7<,1 4XHVWD UHWH GL GHGLFKH VL VSLHJD PHJOLR VH DJJLXQJLDPR FKH VHJUHWDULR GL 7UR\HU HUD O·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·DFFRUGR FRO SDSD ERORJQHVH %HQHGHWWR ;,9 FKH 0 FRPH DQWLFLSDWR 0 DYHYD GLPLQXLWR OH WURSSH IHVWH FDWWROLFKH/ XQ ULDYYL0 FLQDPHQWR DOOH FRQIHVVLRQL SURWHVWDQWL1 3RVVLDPR DOORUD WHQWDUH XQ VLQWHWLFR ELODQFLR GL TXDQWR DEELDPR YLVWR= LQ XQ SLFFROR GXFDWR FRPH OD 0RGHQD VHWWHFHQWHVFD/ SUHVVRFKp LQGLIHVR GDYDQWL DOOH LQYDVLRQL H VSROLD]LRQL DOWUXL/ FRL GXFKL VHPSUH LQ SUHDOODUPH GL IXJD/ JOL DUFKLYL VSHVVR QDVFRVWL LQ OXRJKL ORQWDQL +DGGLULWWXUD 6HVWROD$,/ L TXDGUL SL• SUH]LRVL YHQGXWL SHU ULSLDQDUH LO GHILFLW/ YLVVH XQR VWXGLRVR LQIDWLFDELOH/ DOOH FXL SDUROH O·(XURSD JXDUGz FRQ XQD DWWHQ]LRQH GLYHQXWD SUHVWR YHQHUD]LRQH YHUVR XQ PDHVWUR H XQ XRPR FKH DYHYD SURIXVR WXWWD OD YLWD SHU JOL LGHDOL LQ FXL FUHGHYD/ H DYHYD WUDFFLDWR VWUDGH QXRYH H VDOLWR PRQWL LQYLRODWL +´QRQ VL SXz DPDUH O·,WDOLD/ R DQFKH OD VWRULD LQ JHQHUDOH/ VHQ]D FRQRVFHUH TXHVWR JUDQGH XRPRµ/ VFULYHUj TXDOFKH DQQR GRSR OD PRUWH GHO PRGHQHVH LO JUDQGH DVWURQRPR IUDQFHVH -RVHSK0-pU{PH GH /DODQGH/ FKH SXUH IHFH WDSSD D 0R0
4375
)DELR 0DUUL
GHQD GXUDQWH LO VXR ´WRXU G·,WDOLHµ,158 &RQ 0XUDWRUL/ OD YLOLSHVD 0RGHQD GX0 FDOH VHGHWWH DOOD SDUL GHOOH SL• ULVSHWWDWH FDSLWDOL GHOOD FXOWXUD HXURSHD1
²²²²²²²² 58
5LQJUD]LR SHU OD VHJQDOD]LRQH LO FROOHJD H DPLFR )UDQFHVFR %DUELHUL/ RIIUHQGR TXL GL VHJXL0 WR XQ DJJLRUQDPHQWR ELEOLRJUDILFR UHODWLYR D WHPL VYROWL QHOO·DUWLFROR1 9DULH FRUULVSRQGHQ]H PXUDWRULDQH GL FXL VL q WUDWWDWR VRQR VWDWH HGLWH= OH 49 OHWWHUH GL ,PKRI D 0XUDWRUL +FIU1 TXL S1 436:, VRQR SXEEOLFDWH H FRPPHQWDWH GD 0$5,$ /,(%(5 QHO VDJJLR -DNRE :LOKHOP YRQ ,PKRIV .RUUHVSRQGHQ] PLW 0XUDWRUL +49<904:38,/ DOO·LQWHUQR GHO YROXPH +FXUDWR GD OHL VWHVVD H GD FKL VFULYH, 'LH *O•FNVHOLJNHLW GHV JHPHLQHQ :HVHQV/ )UDQNIXUW DP 0DLQ HFF1/ /DQJ/ 4<<</ SS1 4:099> OH GXH OHWWHUH GL 6FKHOKRUQ +S1 436;, VRQR XJXDOPHQWH D VWDPSD LQ TXHO YROXPH/ QHO PLR VDJ0 JLR .XOWXUHOOH 6WUDWHJLHQ XQG VLQJXOlUH (SLVRGHQ LQ GHQ %H]LHKXQJHQ ]ZLVFKHQ 0XUDWRUL XQG GHU GHXWVFKHQ OLWHUDULVFKHQ :HOW/ SS1 :<0;:> O·LQWHUR &DUWHJJLR FRQ *1 'RPHQLFR %ULFKLHUL &RORPEL +FIU1 436;074, q XVFLWR QHOO·(GL]LRQH 1D]LRQDOH +YRO1 43/ ,/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<<<, D FXUD PLD H GL %$5%$5$ 3$3$==21, +IX %ULFKLHUL FKH FRPXQLFz OD GHFLVLRQH GHO *UDQGXFD GL 7RVFDQD GL GLPLQXLUH OH IHVWH VHFRQGR JOL DXVSLFL GL 0XUDWRUL= FIU1 TXL 436: H &DUWHJJLR/ 7980;/ OHWWHUH GDO 56 VHW0 WHPEUH DO 7 QRYHPEUH 4:7<,> OH OHWWHUH GL 3LHWUR 0DULDQL D 0XUDWRUL +FIU1 4374, VRQR VWDWH HGLWH QHO YRO1 5; GHOO· (GL]LRQH 1D]LRQDOH +&DUWHJJL FRQ 0DQVL111 0DUPL/ D FXUD GL &1 9,2/$/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<<</ SS1 463086,1 $QFRUD VXOOD IRUWXQD GL 0XUDWRUL LQ DUHD JHUPDQRIRQD +FIU1 43680:, KDQQR VFULWWR *8,//$80( 9$1 *(0(57 +01 LQ GHQ ´$FWD (UXGLWRUXPµ1 'HU )DOO &RPDFFKLR, H &+5,67,$1 :(<(56 +01 XQG (XURSD= =X GHQ %HVRQGHUKHLWHQ GHU 9HUEUHLWXQJ XQG 5H0 ]HSWLRQ PXUDWRULDQLVFKHU :HUNH/ FRQ XQD ELEOLRJUDILD GHOOH WUDGX]LRQL LQ WHGHVFR,/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQ0 WH DOOH SS1 9:0:; H ;<0447 GHO FLW1 YRO1 PLVFHOODQHR 'LH *O•FNVHOLJNHLW111/ GRYH DOOH SS1 448055 ',1$+ %85.(57 H $1'5($ )5,1*6/ 'LH 7DJHE•FKHU GHV 6lFKVLVFKHQ .XUSULQ]HQ )ULHGULFK &KUL0 VWLDQ/ VRQR WRUQDWH VXO YLDJJLR LQ ,WDOLD GHO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 6DVVRQLD +FIU1 436<073,1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4376
$//(*$7,
, %UHYH FRPSHQGLR GHOOH UDJLRQL FRQ FXL OD 6HUHQLVVLPD &DVD G·(VWH SUXRYD OD OHJLWWLPLWj GL GRQ $OIRQVR SDGUH GL GRQ &HVDUH GD (VWH/ 4:3; +FRQFOXVLRQH, ( WDQWR VLD SHU RUD GHOOH UDJLRQL H SUHVXQ]LRQL FKH SUXRYDQR OD OHJLWWLPLWj GL GRQ $OIRQVR159 0D LQ TXDQWR PDJJLRU QXPHUR DYUHEEH SRWXWR H ULWURYDU0 QH H DGGXUQH GRQ &HVDUH VXR ILJOLXROR VH 5RPD JOL DYHVVH GDWR WHPSR/ VLF0 FRPH UDJLRQ YROHD/ H GL FHUFDUOH H GL SURGXUOH" H VH FROO·LPSURYYLVH PLQDFFLH H FRO WHUURUH GHOOH VFRPXQLFKH H GHJOL HVHUFLWL/ H FROOH OXVLQJKH GH· FDSSHOOL H GHOOH PLWUH5: H FRQ DOWUL VLPLOL DUWL H YLROHQ]H QRQ DYHVVH OHYDWR LO FRPRGR D TXHO SULQFLSH GL ULQYHQLUOH/ H GL WURSSR LQWLPLGLWR R GL WURSSR DIIDVFLQDWR LO FXRUH GH· )HUUDUHVL/ RSHUDQGR FKH QLXQR SRWHVVH R YROHVVH VRPPLQLVWUDUH DO0 ORUD OXPL YDOHYROL D GLOXFLGDU PDJJLRUPHQWH OD YHULWj" &Lz SRVVLDPR EHQ JLX0 VWDPHQWH DUJRPHQWDUH/ GD FKH QRL VWHVVL/ DQFKH GRSR FHQWR H GLHFL DQQL/ H GRSR DYHUH L PLQLVWUL GHO 3DSD RFFXSDWH H VRSSUHVVH WDQWH PHPRULH H VFULWWX0 UH FKH SRWHDQR QXRFHUH DOOD ORU SUHWHQVLRQH>5; QRL/ GLFR/ WXWWDYLD DEELDPR XO0 WLPDPHQWH ULWURYDWH WDQWH DOWUH SUXRYH D QRL IDYRUHYROL/ OH TXDOL FRQJLXQWH FRQ DOWUH JDJOLDUGLVVLPH GHOOD FDVD G·(VWH VRSUD )HUUDUD SRVVRQR RUDPDL H GHEERQR PXRYHUH XQ 3RQWHILFH JLXVWR H SLR5< D UHVWLWXLUH GHELWDPHQWH FLz FKH GD· VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL IX JLj LQGHELWDPHQWH WROWR D GRQ &HVDUH GD (VWH1 ²²²²²²²² 59
$OIRQVR PDUFKHVH GL 0RQWHFFKLR/ ILJOLR GL $OIRQVR , H GL /DXUD (XVWRFKLD 'LDQWL/ SRL OHJLWWLPDWD FRPH PRJOLH VHFRQGR 0XUDWRUL/ FKH D TXHVWR IDWWR GHGLFKHUj XQR VSD]LR DPSOLV0 VLPR QHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL +,,/ FDS1 ;,9/ SS1 75;0838 H SDVVLP,1 5: /D VLPPHWULD FRVWUXWWLYD GHO SHULRGR +FRQFLQQLWDV, PXUDWRULDQD ID FDSLUH FKH OH ´PLQDF0 FLHµ IXURQR TXHOOH ULVHUYDWH DO GXFD HVWHQVH/ OH ´OXVLQJKHµ LQYHFH DO SRSROR IHUUDUHVH/ DO FXL SURSRVLWR O·DXWRUH ULSUHQGH XQD IUDVH GHO FRQFLWWDGLQR 7DVVRQL +6HFFKLD UDSLWD 9,, <, FKH WRU0 QHUj QHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL ,,/ 849= OD ´YROXELO JHQWHµ JLj VXGGLWD GHJOL (VWH ´RU SLHJD DO SDSD/ H QHOOD YDQD PHQWH 2 VHFR VRJQDQGR YD PLWUH H FDSSHOOLµ1 5; 6XOO·RFFXOWDPHQWR GD SDUWH GHL ´FDPHUDOL GHO SDSDµ GL VFULWWXUH IDYRUHYROL DJOL (VWHQVL 0XUDWRUL WRUQHUj QHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL/ SHU HV1 D SURSRVLWR GHO PDWULPRQLR GL $OIRQVR , H /DXUD 'LDQWL +,, 7:<,1 5< &OHPHQWH ;,/ FKLDPDWR D ULSDUDUH LO WRUWR GL &OHPHQWH 9,,,> PD JOL DSSHOODWLYL ´JLXVWR H SLRµ VRQR VROWDQWR GL FRQYHQLHQ]D/ RYYHUR SRQJRQR XQ DXW DXW= VH LO SDSD QRQ UHVWLWXLUj )HU0 UDUD/ QRQ SRWUj HVVHUH GHILQLWR LQ WDO PRGR1 $ PHQWH IUHGGD LO 0XUDWRUL GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL +,,/ 984 H 987, OR GLUj ´VDJJLRµ/ ´PDQVXHWR H LQFOLQDWR GDO VXR YLUWXRVR DQLPR D VHJXLWDU OH YLH GHOOD SDFH FRQVLJOLDWH GDOOD OHJJH VDQWD GL &ULVWRµ/ PD LVWLJDWR GD IUDQFHVL H VSDJQROL ´D ORU SURSULR YDQWDJJLRµ1
4377
)DELR 0DUUL
,, 1RPLQD D FDYDOLHUH GL $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQHUL H GLVFHQGHQWL/ 631,14:5;63 /H UDUH SUHURJDWLYH FKH FRQFRUURQR QHOOD SHUVRQD GHO GRWWRUH $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQLHUL/ VXGGLWR QRVWUR/ OH FXL RSHUH PHGLFKH64 JOL KDQQR DFTXLVWDWD JUDQ IDPD QRQ PHQ GHQWUR FKH IXRUL G·,WDOLD/ H SHU OH TXDOL q DQFKH VWDWR DO]DWR DO JUDGR GL PHGLFR GL FDPHUD GHOO·DXJXVWLVVLQR UHJQDQWH ,PSHUDGRUH/ H FRVWLWXL0 WR OHWWRUH SULPDULR65 QHOO·XQLYHUVLWj GL 3DGRYD> H L ULIOHVVL66 DQFRUD DOOD IDPL0 JOLD 9DOOLVQLHUL/ OD TXDOH GD PROWL VHFROL QHOOD QRVWUD FLWWj GL 5HJJLR JRGH WXW0 WL67 L GLVWLQWLYL GL YHUD HG DQWLFD QRELOWj/ H GD FXL JLj VL GLUDPz OD OLQHD G·HVVR GRWWRUH $QWRQLR/ FL VWDQQR GD JUDQ WHPSR GDYDQWL DOOD PHQWH1 ( SHUFKp JR0 GLDPR VLQJRODUPHQWH GL WURYDUH QH· VXGGLWL QRVWUL XQ PHULWR FKH OL GLVWLQJXD H UHQGD XWLOL H FHOHEUL QHO PRQGR/ HG q VHPSUH VWDWR FRVWXPH GH· QRVWUL VHUH0 QLVVLPL SURJHQLWRUL H QRVWUR DQFRUD GL SURPXRYHUH68 H SUHPLDUH OH SHUVRQH FKH FROOH ORUR ORGHYROL D]LRQL H PDVVLPDPHQWH SHU OD ULJXDUGHYROH ORUR OHWWH0 UDWXUD69 UHFDQR6: RQRUH QRQ VROR D VH VWHVVL PD DQFKH DOOD SDWULD> H SHUFKp ²²²²²²²² 63
,O WHVWR q VWDWR SDU]LDOPHQWH SXEEOLFDWR QHO WRPR , GHOOH 2SHUH ILVLFR0PHGLFKH FLW1/ SS1 /;9,0/;9,,/ FRQ TXHVWR EUHYH SURHPLR= ´$QFKH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD 5LQDOGR ,/ VRYUDQR GHO 9DOOLVQHUL H SULQFLSH JLXVWLVVLPR HVWLPDWRUH GHO YDORUH GHJOL XRPLQL/ YROOH ULFRQRVFHUH H IUH0 JLDUH LO PHULWR GL TXHVWR VXR LOOXVWUH YDVVDOOR1 6SHGu HJOL SHUz O·DQQR 4:5;/ VRWWR LO JLRUQR 63 GL JHQQDLR/ XQ GLSORPD VRWWRVFULWWR GL VXD PDQR/ LQ FXL GL PRWR SURSULR GLFKLDUz FDYDOLHUH LO QRVWUR 3URIHVVRUH/ $QWRQLR VXR ILJOLXROR/ H ORUR GLVFHQGHQWL LQ SHUSHWXRµ1 6HJXH LO WHVWR/ ILQR D ´SXEEOLFR EHQHµ/ FLRq OLPLWDWDPHQWH DOOD SDUWH VFULWWD GD 0XUDWRUL +WUDQQH O·XOWLPR FDSRYHU0 VR,= TXL LQGLFR OH YDULDQWL QRQ HVFOXVLYDPHQWH JUDILFKH GHOOD VWDPSD1 ,O GLSORPD IX ULSURGRWWR DQFKH GD *1 $57,&2 ', 325&Ï$/ 1RWL]LH GHOOD YLWD H GHJOL VWXGL GHO .DYDOLHU $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQHUL +GD OHJJHUH QHOO·HG1 D F1 GL '1 *(1(5$/,/ %RORJQD/ 3jWURQ/ 4<;9/ SS1 48506,1 5LQJUD]LR SHU OD FRQVXOHQ]D OR VWHVVR 'DULR *HQHUDOL H 'DQLHOD *LDQDUROL1 64 6HJXLYD O·KDQQR UHQGXWR/ FDVVDWR GD 0XUDWRUL1 /D VWDPSD 4:66 WRJOLH OD FRQFRUGDQ]D GHO SDUWLFLSLR= DFTXLVWDWR1 65 2VVLD ¶SURIHVVRUH SULQFLSDOH/ GL SULPR JUDGR·= LO *UDQGH 'L]LRQDULR %DWWDJOLD +*'/,, VH0 JQDOD HVHPSL VHWWHFHQWHVFKL GL PDHVWUR S1 +0DIIHL, H FDWWHGUD SULPDULD +9LFR/ *HQRYHVL,/ PHQWUH/ SHU OD /,=/ VROR 9LFR DYUHEEH XVDWR OHWWRU SULPDULR +R SULPDULR OHWWRU, TXDOFKH DQQR SULPD +$X0 WRELRJUDILD H 6FLHQ]D QXRYD/ 4:58,1 66 ¶/H FRQVLGHUD]LRQL UHODWLYH/ ULJXDUGDQWL·1 /D VWDPSD PRGLILFD DOOD LQ GHOOD1 67 6HJXLYD L JUDGL/ FDVVDWR1 68 /D VWDPSD KD SURPRYHUH/ IRUPD QRQ PXUDWRULDQD H GD FRQVLGHUDUVL VFRUUHWWD1 69 ¶$WWLYLWj LQWHOOHWWXDOH·1 6: 6RVWLWXLVFH IDQQR1
0XUDWRUL/ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OH UHOD]LRQL FRO PRQGR WHGHVFR
4378
QRVWUD SUHPXUD VL q GL DQLPDUH FRO SUHPLR HVVR6; GRWWRUH $QWRQLR H L VXRL GLVFHQGHQWL6< H LQVLHPH JOL DOWUL VXGGLWL QRVWUL DG HVHPSLR VXR/ DFFLRFFKp VL DYDQ]LQR VHPSUH SL• SHU OD YLD GHOOD YLUW• H GHO VDSHUH73 DG DFFUHVFHUH DQFKH LO SXEEOLFR EHQH= TXLQGL q FKH/ YROHQGR QRL GDUH DG HVVR GRWWRUH $QWRQLR XQ YLYR FRQWUDVVHJQR GHO QRVWUR SDU]LDOH74 ULJXDUGR YHUVR OD GL OXL SHUVRQD H L GL OXL GLVFHQGHQWL/ LQ YLUW• GHOOH SUHVHQWL QRVWUH/ GL FHUWD VFLHQ]D/ FROO·DQLPR HWF1 HWF175
²²²²²²²² 6;
6RVWLWXLVFH DQFKH OXL VWHVVR1 6RVWLWXLVFH ILJOLXROL1 73 6HJXLYD H GHO PHULWR/ FDVVDWR1 /D VWDPSD/ GRSR VHPSUH SL•/ DJJLXQJH WUD YLUJROH O·LQFLVR DG HVHPSLR VXR/ SUHVXPLELOPHQWH DWWHVWDWR QHO GRFXPHQWR XIILFLDOH1 74 ¶3DUWLFRODUH/ VSHFLDOH·= LQ TXHVWR VHQVR SRVLWLYR O·DJJHWWLYR HUD ODUJDPHQWH XVDWR QHO 6HWWHFHQWR H GDOOR VWHVVR 0XUDWRUL1 75 4XL VL LQWHUURPSH OD VWHVXUD PXUDWRULDQD> VHJXH/ GL PDQR GL XQ FDQFHOOLHUH/ OD IRUPXOD XIILFLDOH GHO FRQIHULPHQWR GHO WLWROR +FKH 0XUDWRUL DYHYD VROR DQWLFLSDWR/ GRSR GLVFHQGHQWL/ FRQ DEELDPR SHUFLz ULVROXWR GL FRVWLWXLUOR H GLFKLDUDUOR >111@/ FDVVDWR,= ´PRWX SURSULR GLFKLDULDPR H GHFRULDPR LO SUHGHWWR GRWWRU $QWRQLR 9DOOLVQHUL FRPH SXU $QWRQLR GL OXL ILJOLR H ORUR GHVFHQGHQWL LQ SHUSHWXR FRO WLWROR H QRPH GL FDYDOLHUL FRVWLWXHQ0 GROL LQ WDOH TXDOLWj QHOOD IRUPD H PRGR FK·q VWDWR VROLWR GD· SUHGHWWL VHUHQLVVLPL QRVWUL DQWH0 FHVVRUL H GL QRL SXUH GL QRPLQDUH H GLFKLDUDUH FDYDOLHUL OH SHUVRQH FKH GL WDOH WLWROR VLHQR VWD0 WH QH· WHPSL DQGDWL TXDOLILFDWH/ YROHQGR FK·HVVL QRQ VROR SRVVDQR XVDUH TXHVWR WLWROR H SUHUR0 JDWLYD PD FKH VLHQR QRPLQDWL/ ULFRQRVFLXWL H WUDWWDWL SHU FDYDOLHUL LQ RJQL IXQ]LRQH Vu SXEEOLFD FKH SULYDWD/ H JRGDQR GL WXWWH OH SUHURJDWLYH HW RQRUL FKH VRQR VROLWL JRGHUH JOL DOWUL GDL QRVWUL VHUHQLVVLPL DQWHFHVVRUL H GD QRL SXUH GLFKLDUDWL FDYDOLHUL1 ,Q IHGH HWF1 'DWR LQ 0RGHQD OL 63 JHQQDLR :5;µ >PD/ FRPH DQWLFLSDWR/ SDUH GL OHJJHUH ´:3;µ@1 $ WLWROR GL FXULRVLWj VHJQDOR FKH LO 9DOOLVQLHUL IHFH YROHQWLHUL XVR GHO WLWROR DVVHJQDWRJOL/ SUHGLOLJHQGR SHUz OD JUDILD NDYDOLHU FKH DQGDYD GL PRGD D 9HQH]LD HG HUD JLj VWDWD XVDWD GD XQ DOWUR FRQWHPSRUDQHR H VXGGLWR HVWHQVH/ $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL +VHQLRU,> VL SRQJD PHQWH DO WLWROR/ JLj ULFKLDPDWR/ 2SHUH ILVLFR0PHGLFKH VWDPSDWH H PDQRVFULWWH GHO .DYDOLHU $1 91 HFF1/ H SHU LO ULIHUL0 PHQWR D 3DUDGLVL H DOWUL LO PLR DUWLFROR 9HFFKLH GLVFXVVLRQL VXO ./ LQ ´/LQJXD 1RVWUDµ ;// 4<:</ SS1 7<0881 6<
4379
)DELR 0DUUL
,,, /HWWHUD D *LRUJLR ,,/ UH G·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
²²²²²²²² 76 'RYH VWDYD FRPEDWWHQGR +VHQ]D JUDQGH VXFFHVVR, QHOO·HVHUFLWR LPSHULDOH FRQWUR L WXU0 FKL1 6XL SULPL WHPSL GHO GXFDWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, LQIRUPDQR OH SDJLQH FRQFOXVLYH GHOOH $QWL0 FKLWj (VWHQVL/ ,, :3;0491 77 ,O 59 RWWREUH1 78 ;5 DQQL1 79 $SSXQWR LO 7 GLFHPEUH1 7: )UDQFHVFR HUD VWDWR RVSLWH/ DOOD ILQH GHO 4:68/ GL *LRUJLR ,, H GHOOD UHJLQD *XJOLHOPLQD GL %UDQGHQEXUJR1
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
437:
$11$ 526$ 9(1785,
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL= FHQQL ELRJUDILFL 3HU OD %LEOLRWHFD GHJOL (VWHQVL LO ;9,,, VHFROR q SDVVDWR DOOD VWRULD FRPH O·HSRFD GHL JUDQGL ELEOLRWHFDUL/ JUD]LH DOOH LQVLJQL ILJXUH FKH O·KDQQR SUHVWLJLR0 VDPHQWH GLUHWWD LQ OXQJKLVVLPL SHULRGL/ FRQQRWDQGROD GHOOD ORUR SUHVHQ]D H GHOOD ORUR DWWLYLWj1 6ROR YHQW·DQQL VHSDUDQR OD PRUWH GL /1$10XUDWRUL GDOO·LQJUHVVR GL *LUR0 ODPR 7LUDERVFKL DOOD QRPLQD QHOOD PHGHVLPD YHVWH H TXDOLILFD4> q OR VWHVVR LO 'XFD/ )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ FKH OR LQYLWD H OR DFFRJOLH/ VRQR FRQWLJXL O·HUHGLWj/ O·LPSHJQR VWRULFR H FXOWXUDOH FKH JUDYDQR HQWUDPEL/ DQFKH LQ UDSSRUWR DOOH LVWLWX]LRQL H DOOH DVSHWWDWLYH PXQLFLSDOLVWLFKH1 6L ULFRQRVFH IUD L GXH XQD VRVWDQ]LDOH FRQWLQXLWj/ SXU QHO FDPELDPHQWR1 ,QIDWWL/ QHO JLUR GL DOFXQL GHFHQQL/ PROWH FRVH KDQQR PXWDWR DVSHWWR/ GLYHUVR q OR VSLULWR FKH DQLPD OD SROLWLFD LQWHUQD HG HVWHUD GHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH/ OD SUR0 IHVVLRQH ELEOLRWHFDULD DVVXPH FRQQRWD]LRQL YLD YLD SL• SURSULH/ SL• WHFQLFKH/ XQ·DXWRQRPLD JHVWLRQDOH DWWLYD H VHQ]·DOWUR SL• YLYDFH1 ,O PRGR VWHVVR GL FRQIURQWDUVL FRQ O·LPSHJQR VWRULFR/ SXU SDUWHQGR LQ 7LUDERVFKL GDOOD OH]LRQH PXUDWRULDQD/ QRQ SXz QRQ WHQHU FRQWR GHOOH WHQVLRQL LOOXPLQLVWLFKH GL FXL OLH0 YLWD OD FXOWXUD LWDOLDQD/ VRSUDWWXWWR LQ /RPEDUGLD/ GRYH HJOL q QDWR HG KD DYX0 WR OD VXD SULPD IRUPD]LRQH1 4XHOOD /RPEDUGLD OHJDWD SHUDOWUR VWUHWWDPHQWH DO GXFDWR HVWHQVH DWWUDYHUVR OD ILJXUD GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ Ou JRYHUQDWRUH5 H D WDQWL SHUVRQDJJL PRGHQHVL H UHJJLDQL GHO VHFROR/ GD 3DUDGLVL D 6SDOODQ]DQL D 9HQ0 ²²²²²²²² 4
0XUDWRUL GLUHVVH O·(VWHQVH GDO 4:33 DO 4:83/ 7LUDERVFKL GDO 4::3 DO 4:<71 ,O 'XFD LQIDWWL/ JRYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR/ YL VRJJLRUQDYD DVVDL D OXQJR H TXL GHWHQHYD XQD SULYDWD ELEOLRWHFD/ ULFFKLVVLPD/ H VHPSUH LQ IHUYLGR FRQWDWWR GL VFDPELR H GL UHFLSURFR LQ0 FUHPHQWR FRQ O*(VWHQVH1 5
437;
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
WXUL6/ WXWWL RSHUDQWL H DWWLYL LQ GLYHUVL SHULRGL H LQ GLYHUVL LQFDULFKL1 *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL HUD QDWR D %HUJDPR QHO 4:641 /D VXD IRUPD]LRQH UL0 FDOFD JOL VFKHPL GL XQD FXOWXUD SURYLQFLDOH H SLFFROR ERUJKHVH= LVWUX]LRQH H0 OHPHQWDUH GD SDUWH GL YRORQWHURVL VDFHUGRWL H SRL LO SDVVDJJLR DL FROOHJL UHOL0 JLRVL1 0D FRQ XQD SHFXOLDULWj= OD FXULRVLWj/ O·DFXPH/ O·LQWHOOLJHQ]D H OD WHQDFLD FKH FRQWUDGGLVWLQJXHYDQR LO JLRYLQHWWR/ IDFHQGR SURQRVWLFDUH SHU OXL XQ IXWX0 UR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH EULOODQWH1 ,QILQH/ LQWRUQR DL TXLQGLFL DQQL/ OD VFHOWD GL HQ0 WUDUH QHOOD &RPSDJQLD GL *HV•/ VFHOWD FKH/ VH DSSDUH LQ XQ FHUWR VHQVR REEOL0 JDWD SHU OD FRQWLQXD]LRQH H O·DSSURIRQGLPHQWR GHJOL VWXGL/ VDUj YLVVXWD VHP0 SUH FRQ GHYRWD DGHVLRQH H FRPSLXWD GHGL]LRQH1 1HOO·DPELWR GHL VXRL DQQL GL QRYL]LDWR/ FKH VL VYROVH D *HQRYD H LQ VHJXLWR D 0LODQR H D 1RYDUD/ 7LUDERVFKL DSSURIRQGu WXWWL JOL VWXGL SUHYLVWL GDO VHYH0 ULVVLPR SURWRFROOR JHVXLWLFR H SDUWu FRQ O·LQVHJQDPHQWR OLFHDOH H OD SUHGLFD0 ]LRQH/ SHU DSSURGDUH SRL DOOH FDWWHGUH GL HORTXHQ]D H GL SRHVLD DOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL %UHUD71 'L TXHVWR SHULRGR/ FKH JLXQJH ILQR DO 4::3/ DQQR GHOOD FKLDPDWD D 0RGHQD SUHVVR OD 'XFDOH %LEOLRWHFD/ UHVWDQR OD SURGX]LRQH GL GLYHUVH RUD0 ]LRQL/ O·DPSOLDPHQWR H O·LQWHJUD]LRQH GHO 9RFDERODULR ODWLQR GL &DUOR 0DQGRVLR/ OD VWHVXUD GHL FDWDORJKL GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD %UDLGHQVH/ LO &DWDORJXV %LEOLRWKHFDH %UD0 \GHQVLV SHU OLEURUXP DUJXPHQWD GLJHVWXV LQ QRYH YROXPL PDQRVFULWWL/ H L 9HWHUD +XPLOLDWRUXP 0RQXPHQWD DGQRWDWLRQLEXV DF GLVVHUWDWLRQLEXV SURGURPLV LOOXVWUDWD/ XVFL0 WD D 0LODQR QHJOL DQQL 4:9909;1 6RQR VHJQDOL LQHTXLYRFDELOL GL XQ·DWWLYLWj SUHVWLJLRVD H VRSUDWWXWWR GL XQ·LPSRVWD]LRQH UD]LRQDOH H PHWRGLFD GL SHQVDUH H GL RSHUDUH FKH/ SXU QHO JUDQGH DPRUH FKH 7LUDERVFKL VHQWH SHU OH OHWWHUH H SHU OD SRHVLD/ FRQGXFH VR0 VWDQ]LDOPHQWH D VFHOWH RSHUDWLYH GL VWDPSR VWRULFR H ELEOLRJUDILFR1 6SLH GL XQD YRFD]LRQH FKH JLXVWDPHQWH )UDQFHVFR ,,, H VRSUDWWXWWR L VXRL PLQLVWUL GHOHJDWL/ &OHPHQWH %DJQHVL LQ WHVWD/ LQWHUSUHWDQR FRPH YDOLGD LSRWHFD VX XQD SRVVLELOH SURIHVVLRQH ELEOLRWHFDULD1 &KH YHUUj SLHQDPHQWH FRQIHUPDWD GDL UL0 ²²²²²²²² 6
/D]]DUR 6SDOODQ]DQL/ UHJJLDQR/ 4:5<04:<<> *LDPEDWWLVWD 9HQWXUL/ UHJJLDQR/ 4:7904:55> $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL/ YLJQROHVH/ 4:6804;591 7 3HU OD ELRJUDILD GHO 7LUDERVFKL VL ULPDQGD DO YROXPHWWR PRQRJUDILFR GL 3$2/$ ', 3,(752 /20%$5',/ *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ 5LPLQL/ /RXLVq/ 4<<91 ( DQFRUD D= *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL +4:6404:<7,1 0RVWUD GRFXPHQWDULR ELEOLRJUDILFD QHO VHFRQGR FHQWHQDULR GHOOD PRUWH/ 0RGHQD/ ,O EXOLQR/ 4<<9> D ©0RGHQD 6WRULDª/ QXPHUR PRQRJUDILFR VX *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL FRQ VFULWWL GL YDUL/ DQQR ,,,/ 44 +4<<8, H DO SL• UHFHQWH *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL1 0LVFHOODQHD GL VWXGL D FXUD GL $QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL/ 0RGHQD/ ,O EXOLQR/ 4<<:1
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
437<
VXOWDWL1 /D VXD FKLDPDWD D 0RGHQD VL FRQILJXUD LQIDWWL ULFFD GL DSSRUWL H GL LQ0 QRYD]LRQL/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR VHJQD XQ FRQVROLGDPHQWR/ XQD PHVVD D SXQWR GL SUHFHGHQWL HVSHULHQ]H FKH/ SURSULR SHU O·LPSDOFDWXUD UD]LRQDOH FXL VL q IDWWR FHQQR/ SRVVRQR DSSURGDUH FRQ OXL DG XQD FRPSLXWD UHDOL]]D]LRQH1 Ë QHFHVVDULR SHUz PLVXUDUH TXHVWL DSSRUWL SURSULR QHO FRQIURQWR GLUHWWR FRQ OH HUHGLWj GHO SDVVDWR SHU FRJOLHUQH DSSLHQR OH SHFXOLDULWj H OD VRVWDQ]D1 , ELEOLRWHFDUL GXFDOL QHO SHULRGR IHUUDUHVH 'XUDQWH LO SHULRGR IHUUDUHVH OD ELEOLRWHFD GXFDOH/ LQWLPDPHQWH IXVD FRQ O·DUFKLYLR/ HUD SDWULPRQLR HVFOXVLYR GHOOD FDVDWD/ VWUHWWDPHQWH OHJDWD DG XQD FRPPLWWHQ]D GLUHWWD/ DG XQD SURGX]LRQH HQFRPLDVWLFD HG HORJLDWLYD/ QRQFKq DG XQ SDWULPRQLR GRFXPHQWDULR GL VWUHWWD YDOHQ]D GLQDVWLFD= SDWULPRQLR SUL0 YDWR H GHOLFDWR/ GD HVVHUH JHVWLWR H PDQLSRODWR FRQ FDXWHOD H VHJUHWH]]D1 (VVR HUD LQIDWWL VRWWRSRVWR DOOD GLUHWWD VXSHUYLVLRQH GHL GXFKL FKH VL DIILGDYDQR FRPH ILGXFLDUL DG XRPLQL GL JUDQGH FXOWXUD PD FKH HUDQR VRSUDWWXWWR SHUVR0 QH GL HVWUHPD IHGHOWj H GL SURYDWD GHGL]LRQH81 8Q QRPH SHU WXWWL YDOH D HVHPSOLILFDUH TXHVWD WLSRORJLD= TXHOOR GL 3HOOH0 JULQR 3ULVFLDQR9 FKH/ D FDYDOOR IUD ;9 H ;9, VHFROR VL SUHVHQWD FRPH ELEOLR0 WHFDULR0DUFKLYLVWD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH/ VWRULFR GHOOD FDVDWD/ DVWURORJR H FRQVLJOLHUH GHL GXFKL H/ LQ FDVR GL GLVSXWH R GL FRQWURYHUVLH WHUULWRULDOL/ VD GRYH PHWWHUH OH PDQL LQ TXHOOH FDVVH FKH FRQWHQJRQR OH SUH]LRVH SHUJDPHQH FKH GRFX0 PHQWDQR OH YLFHQGH HVWHQVL1 Ë SURSULR OXL FKH DIIHUPD GL DYHU DSHUWR OH FDSVDV/ DSSXQWR SHU ULWURYDUYL LO PDWHULDOH DWWR D GLULPHUH OH FRQWURYHUVLH LQVRUWH FRQ 9HQH]LD VXO SUREOHPD GHO 3ROHVLQH1 Ë TXHVWD OD JHQHVL GHOOH +LVWRULDH )HUUDULDH H GHOOH WDQWH DPEDVFH0 ULH FKH HJOL IHFH LQ TXHO GL 3DGRYD H GL 9HQH]LD VRSUDWWXWWR1 (G q DQFRUD 3UL0 VFLDQR FKH VL RFFXSD GL SURFXUDUH OLEUL LQWURYDELOL/ WHVWL DQFKH VFDEURVL R LQ ²²²²²²²² 8 6HPSUH LQGLVSHQVDELOH SHU OR VWXGLR GHOO·DPELHQWH FXOWXUDOH HVWHQVH *1 %(5721,/ /D %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH H OD FXOWXUD IHUUDUHVH DO WHPSR GL (UFROH , G*(VWH/ 7RULQR/ /RHVFKHU/ 4<36> VL YHGD SRL :1 /1 *81'(56+(,0(5/ )HUUDUD HVWHQVH1 /R VWLOH GHO SRWHUH/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;; H LO SL• UHFHQWH *OL (VWHQVL1 /D &RUWH GL )HUUDUD/ 0RGHQD/ ,O EXOLQR/ 4<<:1 9 6XOOD ILJXUD GHO 3ULVFLDQR/ DQFRUD IRQGDPHQWDOH LO ODYRUR GL $1721,2 52721'Ò/ 3HO0 OHJULQR 3ULVFLDQL LQ ©5LQDVFLPHQWRª/ 44 +4<93,/ SS19;0443> YHGL DQFKH LO PLR WHVWR /D OLEUHULD GXFDOH H JOL VWXGL DVWURORJLFL QHOOD ULQDVFLWD IHUUDUHVH LQ $VWURORJLD= DUWH H FXOWXUD LQ HWj ULQDVFLPHQWDOH/ 0RGHQD/ ,O EXOLQR/ 4<<91
4383
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
RGRUH GL HUHVLD/ PDQXDOL WUDWWL GDOOD WUDGL]LRQH WDOPXGLFD H GDJOL VWXGL DVWUROR0 JLFL SHU SRWHU HVHJXLUH FDOFROL/ FKH HJOL VWHVVR UHDOL]]D/ LQ SUHYLVLRQH GL LPSRU0 WDQWL YLFHQGH EHOOLFKH R GLQDVWLFKH1 ,O UXROR GL VLIIDWWL ELEOLRWHFDUL +H FRO 3ULVFLDQR SRVVLDPR DQQRYHUDUH 6FL0 SLRQH )RUWXQD/ *HURODPR )DOOHWWL/ 1LFFROz 7RVVLFL111,/ SLXWWRVWR FKH TXHOOR GL FRPSLODU FDWDORJKL/ GL IDWWR VFDUQL HOHQFKL SDWULPRQLDOL DO SDUL GL WXWWR LO PD0 WHULDOH GHOOD *XDUGDURED/ HUD GL JHVWLUH LO PDWHULDOH DG XVR GHO VRYUDQR/ GL DI0 IRQGDUYLVL GHQWUR SHU UHGLJHUH VWRULH VX FRPPLVVLRQH/ ILQR DO SXQWR GD FRVWL0 WXLUH XQD ILJXUD GL YHUR H SURSULR VWRULFR GHOOD FDVDWD R GL DPEDVFLDWRUH H XRPR SROLWLFR1 7XWWD XQD VHULH GL SHUVRQDJJL EHQ ORQWDQL GDO FRQFHWWR H GDO UXROR FKH QRL RJJL ULVHUYLDPR DO ELEOLRWHFDULR1 , ELEOLRWHFDUL GXFDOL D 0RGHQD QHO 6HLFHQWR &RQ OD GHYROX]LRQH/ ELEOLRWHFD H DUFKLYLR YHQJRQR WUDVIHULWL D 0RGHQD= VRQR QRWH OH SHULSH]LH GL TXHVWR PDWHULDOH/ SRUWDWR D GRUVR GL PXOR HQWUR FH0 VWH FKH VILGDQR L ULJRUL GHOO·LQYHUQR 48<;/ H FKH/ VWRFFDWR LQ VHJXLWR SUHVVR FDVH GL QRELOL/ QRQ q UDUR FKH ILQLVFD FRQ O·HVVHUH LQFDPHUDWR R GLVSHUVR1 3DUWLFRODUPHQWH VLJQLILFDWLYH OH YLFHQGH GHL IRQGL OLEUDUL HVWHQVL ILQLWL QHOOH UDFFROWH SULYDWH GL $OIRQVR *LRLD H GL *LRYDPEDWWLVWD /DGHUFKL/ GHWWR O·,PROD:1 /H ULFFKH UDFFROWH JLDFHQWL SUHVVR O·LQJHJQHUH H SROLJUDIR IHUUDUHVH $OIRQVR *LRLD/ VRQR SHU EXRQD SDUWH LQHTXLYRFDELOPHQWH GL PDWULFH GXFDOH1 9L VL WURYDQR LQIDWWL OLEUL H FRGLFL VFULWWL H GHGLFDWL DL VRYUDQL;/ IUXWWR FHUWD0 ²²²²²²²² : 'L $OIRQVR *LRLD/ LQJHJQHUH IHUUDUHVH VL ULQWUDFFLDQR GRFXPHQWD]LRQL VLD LQ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD +GD TXL $602,/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH1 /HWWHUDWL/ VLD/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ LQ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL )HUUDUD GRYH DIILRUDQR OH WUDFFH GHO VXR SHUFRUVR ELRJUDILFR1 *1%1/DGHUFKL/ GHWWR O*,PROD/ IX LO FRQVLJOLHUH SL• LQIOXHQWH GHO GXFD &HVDUH/ FKH HVHUFLWz XQD VRUWD GL SRWHUH SHU0 VRQDOH1 3HU XQD SL• DSSURIRQGLWD DQDOLVL GL TXHVWD VXD SRVL]LRQH/ YHGL '1*5$1$/ *OL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL GHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH QHO SHULRGR PRGHQHVH LQ ©5DVVHJQD GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWRª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z/ /LRQHOOR/ %RUVR HG (UFROH ,111,1 9L VL WURYDQR DQFKH VWUX0
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
4384
PHQWH GL DSSURSULD]LRQL H GL XVXFDSLRQL1 7XWWDYLD/ TXHVWR IRQGR/ XVFLWR GDOOD SRUWD/ HEEH LO GHVWLQR GL ULHQWUDUH DOPHQR LQ SDUWH GDOOD ILQHVWUD/ FRQ LO ODVFLWR DOO·(VWHQVH GRSR OD PRUWH GHO *LRLD QHO 49;:1 /·,PROD/ O·RQQLSRWHQWH VHJUHWDULR /DGHUFKL/ GHWHQHYD SUHVVR GL Vq XQD YH0 UD H SURSULD VH]LRQH GHOOD OLEUHULD GXFDOH/ FRQ WDQWR GL FDWDORJR H GL LQGLFL/ UHGDWWL DQFRUD QHO 494;/ D EHQ XQ YHQWHQQLR GDOOD GHYROX]LRQH/ FRQVHUYDWL Ou SHU UDJLRQL GL SUHYHQ]LRQH<1 6XO IDWWR FKH VLDQR ULHQWUDWL F· q SHUz GD GXELWDU0 QH1 ( VL WUDWWD VROWDQWR GL GXH HVHPSL IUD L WDQWL$ $O GL Oj GL TXHVWD FRPSUHQVLELOH H SHUDOWUR QRWD GLDVSRUD/ OD ILVLRQRPLD GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD GXFDOH FRQWLQXD FRPXQTXH D ULYHVWLUH DQFKH SHU EXRQD SDUWH GHO 6HLFHQWR OR VWHVVR FDUDWWHUH SULYDWLVWLFR FKH DYHYD D )HUUDUD H FKL OD JHVWL0 VFH VD GL GRYHUH XQ WULEXWR GL WRWDOH GHGL]LRQH DOOD FDXVD1 &RVu VL FRPSRUWDQR )XOYLR 7HVWL H -DFRSR &DQWHOOL/ FRVu /XGRYLFR 7DJOLDYLQL/ O·,PROD HG LO %RFFD0 EDGDWL1 *Lj/ SHUFKq DQFKH )XOYLR 7HVWL/ ILQH OHWWHUDWR H VDJDFH SROLWLFR/ QHO 4953/ YLHQH FRQVLGHUDWR H GHILQLWR GDO GXFD FROXL ´FKH KD FXUD GHOOD PLD OL0 EUHULDµ43/ WDQWR FKH VL GHYH DWWHQGHUH LO VXR ULWRUQR SHU IDU ULFHUFDUH OH +LVWR0 ULDH GHO 3ULVFLDQR1 8QD FDUDWWHULVWLFD SHFXOLDUH q O·DWWULEX]LRQH GHOO·LQFDULFR D VFLHQ]LDWL/ ROWUH FKH D VWRULFL H D OHWWHUDWL= GXH VRQR JOL LPSRUWDQWL JHRJUDIL QHO 6HLFHQWR HVWHQVH DWWLYL FRPH ELEOLRWHFDUL/ *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD %RFFDEDGDWL H -D0 FRSR &DQWHOOL1 3URSULR ORUR/ DO SDUL GHJOL VWRULFL/ DYHYDQR XQ SUHFLVR LQFDULFR GL UHJLPH/ FRQQHVVR DOOD JHVWLRQH GL DUFKLYL H ELEOLRWHFKH1 /D FRQRVFHQ]D LQ0 IDWWL H OD FODVVLILFD]LRQH GHO WHUULWRULR QH IDFHYDQR VWUXPHQWL SUH]LRVL SHU LO SRWHUH/ WDQWR SL• LQ XQ·HSRFD GL ULYHQGLFD]LRQL WHUULWRULDOL GL QRQ SRFR SHVR1 $O WHPSR VWHVVR ULPDUFDQR XQD WHQVLRQH VFLHQWLILFD FKH IRUWHPHQWH LPSURQWD GL Vq LO 6HLFHQWR PRGHQHVH/ DQFKH DOO·LQWHUQR GL VHWWRUL LVWLWX]LRQDOL1 8QR VWDFFR SXz IRUVH ULFRQRVFHUVL QHOOD IDVH GHOOD JHVWLRQH %DFFKLQL> D EHQ JXDUGDUH HVVD/ GXUDWD DSSHQD GXH DQQL/ VHJQD SHU OD SULPD YROWD XQ SUH0 YDOHUH GHOOH LVWDQ]H WHFQLFKH H GHOOH HVLJHQ]H FDWDORJUDILFKH VX TXDOVLDVL DOWUD FRQVLGHUD]LRQH1 ,QROWUH HJOL KD IRUWH H ULJRURVR LO VHQVR GHOOD VXD SURIHVVLRQH UHOLJLRVD1 'D TXL OD SULPDULD HVLJHQ]D GL GDUH VSD]LR DOOD VWRULRJUDILD UHOLJLRVD ULVSHWWR DOOD VWRULRJUDILD GL FRUWH1 ²²²²²²²² PHQWD]LRQL GL SUHFLVLRQH H GL PLVXUD/ VIHUH DUPLOODUL H LO IDPRVR FRGLFH GHO FRVLGGHWWR 'DQWH HVWHQVH1 < $602/ $PPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOD &DVD1 %LEOLRWHFD1 6HULH FDWDORJKL 43 +,QGLFH,/ )LO]D 4 %/ 47 +,QYHQ0 WDULR,1 43 &RPH DWWHVWD LO PDQRVFULWWR FRQVHUYDWR DOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD +GD TXL %(02, ,W1;87 ¡1 614169/ FRVLGGHWWR &RSLDOHWWHUH *RQ]DJD/ WRPR ,,,/ F14;7U 1
4385
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
, WHPSL SHUz QRQ HUDQR DQFRUD PDWXUL= 5LQDOGR/ DWWHQWR DOOH TXHVWLRQL SD0 WULPRQLDOL H GLQDVWLFKH QRQ DYHYD DOFXQD LQWHQ]LRQH GL ULQXQFLDUH DG DOFXQD GL TXHOOH ULYHQGLFD]LRQL WHUULWRULDOL FKH SRWHVVHUR DSULUJOL SRVVLELOLWj GLYHUVH= FRJOLH TXLQGL LO GHVWUR SHU ULPXRYHUH GDO SURSULR LQFDULFR %DFFKLQL H SHU VR0 VWLWXLUOR FRQ LO VXR JLRYDQH DOOLHYR /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL1 8IILFLDOPHQ0 WH q LO VRYUDFFDULFR GL LPSHJQL GHO EHQHGHWWLQR D FRQGXUUH D WDOH VFHOWD> YRFL GL FRUULGRLR O·DWWULEXLVFRQR DOO·DVSRUWD]LRQH GL XQ FRGLFH LQL]LDWLFR44/ PD VXOOH UHDOL FDXVH QRQ q PDL VWDWD IDWWD FRPSLXWD FKLDUH]]D1 6L SHQVL FRPXQTXH FKH O·DOORQWDQDPHQWR ULVDOH DO 4:33 H %DFFKLQL PRULUj QHO 4:54$ ,Q XQ·HSRFD LQ FXL QRUPDOPHQWH VL FRQFOXGHYD OD SURSULD YLWD GLUHWWDPHQWH DO WDYROR GL ODYR0 UR$ &HUWR FRQ OD FKLDPDWD GL 0XUDWRUL/ 5LQDOGR FRJOLH QHO VHJQR= VL DJJLXGLFD XQD SUHVHQ]D GL VRPPR SUHVWLJLR FKH WXWWDYLD VD GLURWWDUH L SURSUL LQWHUHVVL LQL]LDOPHQWH YRWDWL DOOD 3HUIHWWD SRHVLD45 YHUVR O·LPPDQH VFDYR DUFKLYLVWLFR H OR VWXGLR GHOOH IRQWL1 ( WDOH ULFHUFD VDUj FRPXQTXH FRQWUDVVHJQDWD GDOOD WRWDOH GHYR]LRQH YHUVR L SURSUL GXFKL H L ORUR LQWHUHVVL H ULYHQGLFD]LRQL1 6H QH DF0 FRUVH 7LUDERVFKL TXDQGR FRQILGz DOO·$IIz O·XVR LPSURSULR IDWWR GDO VXR LOOX0 VWUH SUHGHFHVVRUH ODGGRYH +4:;7, OR ULPSURYHUD GL DYHU ´GLVVLPXODWRµ GHL GR0 FXPHQWL G·DUFKLYLR SHU QRQ GRYHU FRQIHVVDUH GL GRQD]LRQL PDWLOGLFKH GHO PRGHQHVH IDWWH DOOD FKLHVD461 ( QRQ q LO VROR DSSXQWR FKH LQ TXHVWR VHQVR 7L0 UDERVFKL JOL PXRYH1 (SSXUH/ JLj FRQ OD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR/ H DQFRU SL• QHO FRUVR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ OH ELEOLRWHFKH DVVXPRQR XQ QXRYR DVSHWWR= HQWUDQR QHOOH WDSSH GHL JUDQG WRXUV/ YDQQR YLHSSL• ULYHVWHQGR XQ UXROR VSHFLILFR H YDQQR DQFKH OHWWH/ SHU FKL OH SRVVLHGH H OH RUJDQL]]D/ FRPH SHFXOLDUH IRQWH GL SUHVWLJLR1 /HLEQL] QH HORJLD O·RUGLQDPHQWR H VL FRPSLDFH GL DYHUOD WURYDWD FRVu EHQ RUJDQL]]DWD> FRVu O·+DFNHUPDQQ FKH FRQWLQXHUj LO ODYRUR GHO /HLEQL]47 H FRVu LO 0RQWIDXFRQ/ FKH VL FRPSLDFH FRQ %DFFKLQL H VHJQDOD L SH]]L SL• SUHJHYROL ²²²²²²²² 44 6L WUDWWD GHO PDQRVFULWWR HVWHQVH FRQWHQHQWH LO WUDWWDWHOOR PDJLFR0QHJURPDQWLFR &ODYLFX0 OD 6DORPRQLV +,W153: ¡ :19163,/ OD FXL LQFDXWD FRQVHUYD]LRQH FRVWz DO %DFFKLQL XQ SURFHGL0 PHQWR GD SDUWH GHO WULEXQDOH GHOO*,QTXLVL]LRQH GL 0RGHQD H O*DOORQWDQDPHQWR GDOOD GLUH]LRQH/ FRPH DWWHVWD QHO VXR FDWDORJR GHL PDQRVFULWWL +FRQVHUYDWR LQ %(02 IUD L FDWDORJKL VWRULFL, *LRYDQQL $QWRQLR 3DQHOOL1 45 /1$1 085$725,/ 'HOOD SHUIHWWD SRHVLD/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:391 46 /HWWHUD GL 7LUDERVFKL DG $IIz/ LQ /HWWHUH GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL D 3DGUH ,UHQHR $IIz D FXUD GL &DUOR )UDWL/ 0RGHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L H 1LSRWL/ 4;<8/ S1 6431 47 &IU1 $1 52%,1(7/ /H VpMRXU GH *1:1/HLEQL] j 0RGqQH/ LQ ©0HPRULH GHOO*$FFDGHPLD 1D0 ]LRQDOH GL 6FLHQ]H /HWWHUH H $UWL GL 0RGHQDª/ V1 9,/ ;;9 +4<;6,/ SS1 59:06431
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
4386
GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD D FXL GHGLFD SL• SDJLQH GHO VXR 'LDULXP LWDOLFXP481 ,QGLUHWWD0 PHQWH TXHVWH VRQR WXWWH DSSURYD]LRQL GL XQ PHWRGR GL JHVWLRQH FKH LQYHVWH H FRLQYROJH %RFFDEDGDWL/ &DQWHOOL/ %DFFKLQL H FKH ID ULVDOLUH LO ULRUGLQDPHQWR D EHQ SULPD GL 0XUDWRUL H GL 7LUDERVFKL/ FRQWUDGGLFHQGR TXHOOD FKH q XQD OLQHD GL SHQVLHUR FRPXQH FKH WHQGH D VYLOLUH LO 6HLFHQWR PRGHQHVH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD ELEOLRWHFRQRPLFR1 6DUHEEH OXQJR/ H QRQ q TXHVWD OD VHGH SHU IDUOR/ FLWDUH OD OXQJD VHULH GL PDWHULDOL FDWDORJUDILFL ULVDOHQWL D TXHVWR SHULRGR/ WXWWL FRQVHUYDWL LQ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FKH WHVWLPRQLDQR XQD RSHURVD DSSOLFD]LRQH/ DQFKH VH DQFRUD VFDUVDPHQWH VFLHQWLILFD/ D WDOH DWWLYLWj H O·DGR]LRQH GL PHWRGL DWWULEXLWL SRL DO SHULRGR WLUDERVFKLDQR491 %LEOLRWHFD H ELEOLRWHFDUL QHO 6HWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH ,Q TXHVWR FRQWHVWR DQFKH L VRYUDQL VL UHQGRQR FRQWR GL FRPH OD ELEOLRWHFD QRQ SRVVD SL• UHVLVWHUH FRPH IDWWR SULYDWR/ LVRODWR/ HVFOXVLYR/ PD GHEED HVVH0 UH SURSRVWD FRPH LVWLWX]LRQH YLYD H YLWDOH/ FRPH RUJDQLVPR LQVHULWR HQWUR XQD FRPSOHVVD GLQDPLFD FXOWXUDOH DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ SURFHVVR GL VYLOXSSR1 Ë RSSRUWXQR YDOXWDUH FRQ HVWUHPR ULJRUH D FKL DIILGDUQH OD GLUH]LRQH= LO OLEUR FRO 6HWWHFHQWR QRQ q SL• RJJHWWR GL FROOH]LRQLVPR/ GD PRVWUDUH FRPH VL PR0 VWUHUHEEH XQD WDEDFFKLHUD/ PD q VWUXPHQWR GL VWXGLR H GL ODYRUR/ ULFKLHGH UD0 ]LRQDOLWj H LQWHOOLJHQ]D1 'LYHQWD G·REEOLJR FRQIURQWDUVL FRQ OH DOWUH DQDORJKH LVWLWX]LRQL/ FKH YDQQR YLD YLD DSUHQGR L ORUR EDWWHQWL DO SXEEOLFR/ FKH SXEEOL0 FDQR FDWDORJKL H UHSHUWRUL/ FKH PROWLSOLFDQR OH SURSULH LQL]LDWLYH1 )UDQFHVFR ,,, VL UHQGH FRQWR PROWR OXFLGDPHQWH GL TXHVWR VWDWR GL FRVH H VL SURSRQH LQ XQD YHVWH GL VRYUDQR LOOXPLQDWR PROWR WHVR DOOD ULRUJDQL]]D]LR0 QH GHOO·DSSDUDWR FXOWXUDOH/ GDOOH EDVVH VFXROH DOO·8QLYHUVLWj/ GDOOD %LEOLRWHFD DOO·HGLWRULD1 6L FLUFRQGD GL SHUVRQDOLWj D ORUR YROWD SURJUHVVLVWH HG DSHUWH/ 9DOGULJKL/ )RQWDQHOOL/ 5DQJRQL/ 3DUDGLVL111 DFFUHGLWDQGR LO SLFFROR GXFDWR FRPH VWDWR UL0 IRUPDWRUH LQ FXL VRYUDQR H ILORVRIR/ GHVSRWD LOOXPLQDWR H VDJJLR LPSHJQDWR IRUPDQR L FDUGLQL GHO EXRQ JRYHUQR1 )HUPL UHVWDQGR FRPXQTXH VHPSUH LO ²²²²²²²² 48
%(51$5' '( 0217)$8&21/ 'LDULXP ,WDOLFXP/ 3DULJL/ $QLVVRQ/ 4:351 '*DOWUR FDQWR DQFKH 0DELOORQ +0XVHXP ,WDOLFXP/ 3DULJL/ 0RQWDODQW/ 4:57/ WRPL 5, DYHYD SHUFRUVR QHO 49;8 O*,WDOLD LQ OXQJR HG LQ ODUJR H DYHYD DYXWR PRGR GL FRQRVFHUH/ DSSUH]]DUH H VWLPDUH %DFFKLQL/ FKH OR DVVLVWHWWH H OR DFFRPSDJQz SHU XQ WUDWWR GHO VXR SHUFRUVR EHQH0 GHWWLQR1 49
4387
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
ULJLGR FRQWUROOR GL FXL ID IRUVH OH VSHVH LO VHJPHQWR SL• HVSRVWR GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH/ DSSXQWR OD ELEOLRWHFD1 '·DOWUD SDUWH/ DQFKH VRWWR OD SD0 WHUQDOLVWLFD JHVWLRQH GHO GXFD/ OD ELEOLRWHFD HUD JLj GL IDWWR GHOOD FLWWj= QHO 4:97 DYHYD DYXWR LO VXR VROHQQH ´DSULPHQWRµ/ VRWWR OD GLUH]LRQH GL 3DGUH =DFFD0 ULD4:1 $SHUWXUD FKH/ DO GL Oj GHO SUHVWLJLR GL IDFFLDWD/ q GD OHJJHUVL IRUVH DQFKH FRQ RFFKLR SL• GLVLQFDQWDWR1 4XHVWD q LQIDWWL FHUWR XQD PRVVD LOOXPLQDWD GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ PD q DQFKH XQ SDVVR FDOFRODWR/ FKH SRQHYD TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD DO OLYHOOR GL PROWL DOWUL LVWLWXWL IUD L SL• DYDQ]DWL G·,WDOLD H/ LQ DPELWR LQWHUQR/ PHWWHYD OD FRUWH DO ULSDUR GD XQD SRGHURVD FRQFRUUHQ]D SULYDWD1 ,O ULIHULPHQWR FRUUH DOOD ELEOLRWHFD )RQWDQHOOL/ JLj GL IDWWR D GLVSRVL]LRQH GHJOL VWXGLRVL/ D TXHOOH 5DQJRQL/ )URVLQL +LO FXL FDWDORJR VL WURYD PDQRVFULWWR LQ %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH 4;, H TXHOOD GHL FRQWL 6HUWRULR FKH SURSULR QHO 4:87 IH0 FHUR DOOHVWLUH DOO·XRSR XQ·DOD GHO ORUR SDOD]]R H GL PROWH DOWUH/ DFFUHVFLXWH H DUULFFKLWH GD TXHJOL LQWHOOHWWXDOL FKH DQGDYDQR FRVWLWXHQGR XQD EHQ GHILQLWD pOLWH GL SHQVLHUR1 (VVL LQIDWWL VL ULWURYDYDQR LQ UDGXQDQ]H HG LQ SULYDWH DFFD0 GHPLH GL OLYHOOR HOHYDWR H XQ WDQWLQR WUDVJUHVVLYR/ OHJJHYDQR RSHUH IUDQFHVL SRQHQGR OH EDVL GL TXHOO·LQWHOOHWWXDOLWj FKH VL VDUHEEH IDWWD VHQWLUH LQ DQQL QRQ ORQWDQL1 $OOD PRUWH GL 0XUDWRUL FKH WDQWR OXVWUR DYHYD GDWR DOOD FXOWXUD GHOO·LQWHUR GXFDWR/ DQFKH VH PROWR PHQR VL HUD LPSHJQDWR VXO IURQWH GHOO·DWWLYLWj FDWD0 ORJUDILFD H GHOOR VSHFLILFR ELEOLRWHFDULR/ H GRSR LO VHVVHQQLR GHOOD JHVWLRQH GHO PDWHPDWLFR )UDQFHVFR 9DQGHOOL/ IXQHVWDWD GDOO·HSLVRGLR GHL IXUWL GHJOL RUQD0 PHQWL G·DUJHQWR GHOOD %LEELD GL %RUVR/ V·LPSRQH XQD VFHOWD PLUDWD1 6LDPR QHO 4:89= D 0RGHQD JRGRQR GL JUDQGH SUHVWLJLR H GL SHVR FXOWXUDOH L JHVXLWL H SURSULR D ORUR VL DSSRJJLD LO 'XFD1 Ë XQD VFHOWD GL FDPSR FKH SHUz QRQ YD HVHQWH GD PROWH FULWLFKH= QHOOD FLWWj VL q JLj IRUPDWD XQD IUDQJLD GL DQWDJRQLVWL FKH YHGRQR LQ WDOH RUGLQH XQD PHQWDOLWj UHWULYD H FRGLQD FKH FRQWUDVWD FRQ TXHO OLEHUR SHQVLHUR/ FRQ TXHO ULJRUH HPSLULFR FKH LPSURQWD GL Vq OD IDVFLD SL• DYDQ]DWD GHOO·LQWHOOHWWXDOLWj PRGHQHVH1 6LFFRPH IUD L SL• DFFDQLWL DQWLJH0 VXLWL FL VRQR SURSULR DOFXQL DGGHWWL DOOD ELEOLRWHFD H DOO·DUFKLYLR GXFDOH/ 3HOOH0 JULQR 1LFFROz /RVFKL H *LRYDQQL 3DQHOOL LQ WHVWD/ VL SXz EHQ LPPDJLQDUH LO FOLPD GL WHQVLRQH FKH VL q UHJLVWUDWR QHOO·DPELHQWH TXDQGR VL q DYXWD QRWL]LD ²²²²²²²² 4: )UDQFHVF*$QWRQLR =DFFDULD IX O*HVHFXWRUH LQ TXHVWR IUDQJHQWH GHO YROHUH GXFDOH H VL H0 VSUHVVH LQ XQD VROHQQH RUD]LRQH SXEEOLFDWD GDO 6ROLDQL D 0RGHQD QHOOR VWHVVR DQQR1 4; &DWDORJR GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD )URVLQL/ %(02/ PV1 ,W14749 ¡1 6141591
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
4388
GHOOD QRPLQD GL )UDQFHVF·$QWRQLR =DFFDULD4<1 2VWUX]LRQLVPR/ IRUPH TXDVL GL ERLFRWWDJJLR/ DPDUL VIRJKL H WHQVLRQL D QRQ ILQLUH VL SRWUHEEHUR HOHQFDUH/ WXWWH IHGHOPHQWH UHJLVWUDWH GDOOH GRFXPHQ0 WD]LRQL SUHVHQWL QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD53/ PD DQFKH LO IHUPR LQWH0 UHVVDWR LQWHUYHQWR GHOO·DXWRULWj D GLULPHUOH1 /D JHVWLRQH GHOOR =DFFDULD q FRQ0 WURYHUVD H ILQLUj FRO YHGHUH O·DOORQWDQDPHQWR XQ SR· LQIDPDQWH GHO ELEOLRWHFD0 ULR GRSR ROWUH GLHFL DQQL/ PD q DQFKH XQD GLUH]LRQH FKH VSDODQFD HQRUPH0 PHQWH JOL RUL]]RQWL GHOO·(VWHQVH= LQQDQ]LWXWWR OD SROLWLFD JHVWLRQDOH YLHQH PRGHUQL]]DWD H VL DYYDOH GHOOD FROODERUD]LRQH GL XQR VWDII DOWDPHQWH TXDOLIL0 FDWR/ LQ SDUWH GL PDWULFH JHVXLWLFD/ +7URLOL/ *DEDUGL11111 ,/ LQROWUH OR =DFFDULD q LQ FRQWDWWR FRQ XQD FRVSLFXD UDSSUHVHQWDQ]D GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD /HWWHUDULD/ FRQVDSHYROH GHO UXROR SULYLOHJLDWR FRQQHVVR DOOD GLUH]LRQH GL XQ VLPLOH LVWLWX0 WR FKH VD YDORUL]]DUH/ IDFHQGR SHUQR VXOOH VXH FRQRVFHQ]H H VXO IDWWLYR DS0 SRUWR GHO SURYYHGLWRUH 0RVq %HQLDPLQR )Rj1 Ë RSSRUWXQR ULFRUGDUH FKH FRVWXL/ DQFKH VH GD %HWWLQHOOL H GD &DQFHOOLHUL YLHQH TXDOLILFDWR ULGXWWLYDPHQWH ´O·HEUHRµ/ q DFXWR H VDJDFH FRQRVFLWRUH GHOO·HGLWRULD/ DSSUH]]DWR H VWLPDWR LQ ,WDOLD H IXRUL/ WDQWR FKH SHU OXL YLHQH IDWWD XQD GHURJD DOOD GHWHQ]LRQH GHL OLEUL SURLELWL/ L VXRL FDWDORJKL FLUFRODQR SHU WXWWD OD SHQLVROD H OR VWHVVR &HVDUH %HFFDULD HEEH FRQ OXL XQ EUHYH PD LQWHQVR FDUWHJJLR541 'LYHQWHUj IDPRVR LO VXR VRGDOL]LR FRO 7LUDERVFKL/ PD IX SURSULR OR =DF0 FDULD DG LQDXJXUDUOR1 1RQ q XQ FDVR TXLQGL FKH SURSULR VRWWR OD VXD JHVWLRQH DYYHQJD O·DSHUWXUD DO SXEEOLFR GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD GXFDOH QHO 4:971 0D D 0RGH0 QD OH SUHVVLRQL FRQWUR GL OXL QRQ VL FRQWDQR H OR VWHVVR 'XFD ILQu FRQ O·LQWUDYHGHUYL VPDQLH DXWRQRPLVWLFKH/ HFFHVVLYH SUHWHVH H XQD VPRGDWD GLOD0 WD]LRQH GL LQWHUHVVL H DPEL]LRQL1 4XHO VRGDOL]LR VRYUDQR0SKLORVRSKH PRVWUD QHUYL VFRSHUWL/ FRPH VL q JLj GHWWR/ SURSULR QHOO·LVWLWXWR SL• HVSRVWR H =DFFD0 ULD YLHQH ´ULFKLDPDWRµ D 5RPD1 5LVXOWD FRPXQTXH GL HVWUHPR LQWHUHVVH OD OHWWXUD GHOOH RWWDYH FRQWUR L JH0 VXLWL DG RSHUD GL LQWHOOHWWXDOL PRGHQHVL/ FRQWHQXWH QHO FRGLFH PLVFHOODQHR ²²²²²²²² 4<
9HGL DQFKH LO PV1 HVWHQVH ,W1454< ¡1 )16145/ 0LVFHOODQHD LWDOLDQD DOOH FF1 54 6V1 /H GDPH DJOL HVHUFL]L GHOOD VHWWLPDQD VDQWD DOOD FKLHVD GHL *HVXLWL/ VLOORJH GL FRPSRQLPHQWL VDWLULFL GL YDUL H0 VSRQHQWL/ DOFXQL %OLEHUWLQL%/ HVSRQHQWL GHOO*LQWHOOHWWXDOLWj PRGHQHVH DQWLJHVXLWLFD1 53 3(//(*5,12 1,&2/Ò /26&+,/ 0HPRULH GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ PDQRVFULWWR LQ $602/ $PPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOD &DVD/ %LEOLRWHFD1 54 :,//,$0 63$**,$5,/ 3DUDGLVL/ %HFFDULD H OD SRHVLD ILORVRILFD= VWRULD GHOO*RGH %/D IHOLFLWj GHOOD 6DSLHQ]D%/ LQ ©&RQWULEXWLª/ DQQR , +JHQQDLR0JLXJQR 4<::, Q14/ S1 ;31
4389
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
,W1454< GHOO·(VWHQVH551 4XL q SDGUH =DFFDULD LO EHUVDJOLR SULQFLSDOH FRQWUR FXL VL VFDJOLDQR OH IUHFFH SL• SHVDQWL/ SURSULR GD SDUWH GL TXHJOL LQWHOOHWWXDOL FKH/ UDSSUHVHQWDQGR OH IDPLJOLH 0RQWHFXFFROL/ &RGHEz/ &RUWHVH/ &RFFDSDQL/ FR0 VWLWXLVFRQR TXHOOD IURQGD DYDQ]DWD GL SHQVLHUR FXL VL q IDWWR FHQQR1 ,O JHVXLWD YLHQH YLVWR FRPH ULFHWWDFROR GL RJQL YL]LR H GLIHWWR/ VWROWR H DUULYLVWD/ FRGLQR H SDUYHQX/ PRUDOPHQWH VTXDOOLGR H FXOWXUDOPHQWH DSSURVVLPDWLYR1 ,O VXR FRQJHGR FRPSRUWD SHU )UDQFHVFR ,,, XQ·DWWHQWD H DFFRUWD YDOXWD0 ]LRQH FLUFD OD QRPLQD VXFFHVVLYD/ SHU PHWWHUVL DO ULSDUR GDOOH SROHPLFKH FKH O·DYHYDQR FRLQYROWR SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH1 $ELOPHQWH HJOL/ DIILGDQGR OD ELEOLRWH0 FD D SDGUH *UDQHOOL/ XQ DOWUR JHVXLWD/ DFFDQWRQD LO SUREOHPD SHU XQ WULHQQLR1 4XHVWL LQIDWWL/ GRFLOH/ DQ]LDQR H PDODWLFFLR QRQ SRQH Qp SUHWHVH Qp LVWDQ]H/ JRYHUQDQGR DOWUHVu VHQ]D SDUWLFRODUH OXVWUR1 ,O SUREOHPD VL ULSURSRQH QHO 4::3/ DOOD VXD PRUWH/ TXDQGR LO 'XFD GHYH DSSURQWDUH XQD QXRYD FDQGLGDWX0 UD/ XQD FDQGLGDWXUD GL SUHVWLJLR SHU QRQ IDU VELDGLUH TXHOO·LPPDJLQH FKH 0X0 UDWRUL DYHYD FRQIHULWR DOOD /LEUDULD1 ,O IDWWR FKH YRJOLD DWWLQJHUH DQFRUD GDOO·DPELHQWH JHVXLWLFR LQGLFD LQ )UDQ0 FHVFR OD FRQIHUPD GL XQD SUHFLVD FRQYLQ]LRQH/ FRVu FRPH OD VFHOWD GHL FDQGL0 GDWL/ LO PDQWRYDQR 6DYHULR %HWWLQHOOL LQ XQ SULPR WHPSR H LO EHUJDPDVFR *L0 URODPR 7LUDERVFKL LQ VHJXLWR/ VHJQDODQR XQD GHFLVD YRORQWj GL DIIHUPD]LRQH SHU O·LVWLWX]LRQH1 6L WUDWWD LQIDWWL GL SHUVRQH JLRYDQL/ QRWH H EULOODQWL/ WDOL GD IDU SUHYHGHUH XQ IXWXUR QRQ FHUWR RVFXUR SHU O·LVWLWXWR FKH JXLGHUDQQR1 %HWWLQHOOL SHUz KD IDPD GL OHWWHUDWR DQWLFODVVLFR/ GL LQWHOOHWWXDOH WUDVJUHVVLYR/ GDO JLXGL0 ]LR VSUHJLXGLFDWR/ UHGXFH GD HVSHULHQ]H H GD FRQWDWWL FRQ O·LQWHOOHWWXDOLWj IUDQFHVH1111 2JJL VL SXz IRUVH SDUODUH GL XQ DWWHJJLDPHQWR SURYRFDWRULR H GL XQ DQWLFODVVLFLVPR FHUWR PROWR SL• GL DSSDUHQ]D FKH GL VRVWDQ]D/ PD DO WHP0 SR FH Q·HUD DEEDVWDQ]D SHU IDU SHVDUH OD ELODQFLD D IDYRUH GL 7LUDERVFKL1 Ë XQD VFHOWD GL FDPSR= LO 'XFD QRQ YXROH SL• WURYDUVL LQ XQD SRVL]LRQH GL GHEROH]]D H D OXL ULFKLHGH LPSHJQL SUHFLVL= QRQ SXz GHWHQHUH D VXR SLDFLPHQ0 WR L OLEUL QHOOH SURSULH SULYDWH VWDQ]H/ QRQ SXz VRWWUDUVL DOOH LVSH]LRQL GHO SUH0 VLGHQWH )DEUL]L/ GHYH GDU FRQWR LQ PRGR HVWUHPDPHQWH FLUFRVWDQ]LDWR GHOOH VSHVH H IDU ULFKLHVWD SHU RJQL DFTXLVWR HFFHGHQWH LO EXGJHW SUHYLVWR1 6L WUDWWD GL FODXVROH YHVVDWRULH FKH XQ SR· FL VWXSLVFRQR/ DQFKH VH SRL LO VRYUDQR DQGUj JUDGXDOPHQWH DPPRUELGHQGROH/ LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GHL VHUYLJL FKH LO VXR IXQ]LRQDULR JOL RIIUH561 $ ULOHJJHUVL OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD ²²²²²²²² 55
6L WUDWWD GHO FLWDWR PDQRVFULWWR HVWHQVH ,W1454< ¡1 )16145 DOOH FF1 449045:1 3HU TXHVWH QRWL]LH/ ULFDYDELOL GDOOH GRFXPHQWD]LRQL LQ $602/ VHULH %LEOLRWHFD/ ULQYLR DL FLWDWL ODYRUL VXO 7LUDERVFKL D QRWD 71 56
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
438:
FH Q·q DEEDVWDQ]D SHU ULOHYDUH XQ·HVWUHPD GLIIHUHQ]D GL WUDWWDPHQWR IUD OXL H DOFXQL VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL= D FRVWRUR/ H VRSUDWWXWWR D 0XUDWRUL/ HUD FRQFHVVR TXDVL WXWWR= DYHYDQR PDQR OLEHUD QHOO·LVWLWXWR H OH ORUR UHOD]LRQL H L UHVRFRQWL WHFQLFL VRQR VFDUQL HG HSLVRGLFL/ FRQ EXFKL GL DQQL1 $O FRQWUDULR/ 7LUDERVFKL VL SUHVHQWD VXELWR FRPH XQ VROOHFLWR H GLOLJHQWH SURIHVVLRQLVWD= HODERUD SLDQL/ OL VRWWRSRQH DOO·DSSURYD]LRQH GXFDOH/ SUHVHQWD UHOD]LRQL GHWWDJOLDWH H SUHFLVH/ IDYRULVFH H SURPXRYH O·XWHQ]D/ O·DWWLYLWj FDWDORJUDILFD/ OD SROLWLFD GHJOL DFTXL0 VWL/ GHJOL VFDPEL/ O·DOLHQD]LRQH GHL GRSSL HVHPSODUL/ OD FRQVHUYD]LRQH H LO UH0 VWDXUR1 ,O UXROR H OH IXQ]LRQL GHO ELEOLRWHFDULR 7LUDERVFKL VHJQDQR XQ LPSRUWDQWH SDVVR DYDQWL= FRPH DOWUL JUDQGL FROOHJKL/ IUD FXL O·$XGLIIUHGL D 5RPD H LO 3D0 FLDXGL D 3DUPD/ QRQ q SL• VROR ILJXUD GL VWXGLRVR/ PD GL FRPSLXWR RUJDQL]]D0 WRUH1 1HL IDWWL HJOL DQWLFLSD OD OXQJD TXHUHOOH VX TXDOH GHEED HVVHUH LO UXROR GHO ELEOLRWHFDULR VH GL HUXGLWR SDOHRJUDIR DQWLTXDULR R GL RUJDQL]]DWRUH H SURPR0 WRUH GL FXOWXUD/ GLEDWWLWR FKH VL q WUDVFLQDWR ILQR DG RJJL FRQ JOL LQWHUYHQWL GL )UDQFHVFR %DUEHUL H GL (PDQXHOH &DVDPDVVLPD1 7LUDERVFKL GXQTXH/ SL• GRFLOH GL FDUDWWHUH/ PHQR YLQFRODWR DG RSHUD]LRQL GL VFDYR DUFKLYLVWLFR D ILQL FRUWLJLDQL/ GHO WXWWR HVRQHUDWR GD DPELJXH PLVVLR0 QL SROLWLFKH +ULFRUGLDPR OH OHWWHUH FKH 0XUDWRUL VFULVVH DO 'XFD GD 9HQH]LD57 H FKH EHQ SRFR ODVFLDQR DOO·LPPDJLQD]LRQH FLUFD XQ VXR UXROR GL SROLWLFR H GL GLSORPDWLFR$,/ PD QRQ PHQR FROWR H SUHSDUDWR GHL VXRL LOOXVWUL SUHGHFHVVRUL/ VYLOXSSD H FRQFUHWL]]D OD ILJXUD GHO ELEOLRWHFDULR PRGHUQR1 /D VXD HVSHULHQ]D DWWXDOL]]z QHO SLFFROR GXFDWR HVWHQVH XQ VLVWHPD YLYDFH H FRHUHQWH DOO·LQVHJQD GHOO·RSHUDWLYLWj= LO WHPSR DYUHEEH GLPRVWUDWR FKH VL WUDWWDYD GL XQD IRUPXOD0 ]LRQH YLQFHQWH/ EDVDWD VX FDUGLQL LQQRYDWLYL PD VROLGLVVLPL1 )UD TXHVWL VL ULFRQRVFRQR= OD SUHVHQ]D GL XQR VWDII GL JUDQGH DIILDWDPHQWR H ULJRUH/ LQ SDUWH HUHGLWDWR GDOOD JHVWLRQH =DFFDULD/ LQ SDUWH ULQQRYDWR/ XQR VFDPELR YLYDFH H FRVWDQWH FRQ DOWUL FROOHJKL +VL WURYDQR L ORUR FDUWHJJL QHOO·HSLVWRODULR PDQRVFULWWR GHO 7LUDERVFKL58,/ LO SULPDWR GHJOL DFTXLVWL H GHOO·XWHQ]D1 'D TXL GLVFHQGRQR XQD VHULH GL HVLJHQ]H/ SULPD IUD WXWWH TXHOOD FDWDORJUDILFD/ SRL L FRQWDWWL FRQ OH WLSRJUDILH H LO PRQGR HGLWRULDOH/ O·DWWHQ]LRQH DO JLRUQDOLVPR HUXGLWR GL FXL HJOL VWHVVR VL ID SURSXOVRUH59 H FKH ²²²²²²²² 57
&RQVHUYDWH LQ %(02/ ,W1;68 ¡1 *1414: +44,1 ,O FDUWHJJLR WLUDERVFKLDQR q FRQVHUYDWR/ ULOHJDWR LQ TXDUDQWDVHWWH YROXPL PDQRVFULWWL/ SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD1 59 )X LQIDWWL HGLWRUH HG DQLPDWRUH GHO ©1XRYR *LRUQDOH GHL /HWWHUDWL G*,WDOLDª GDO 4::6 DO 4:<31 58
438;
$QQD 5RVD 9HQWXUL
VHJXH DWWUDYHUVR WLWROL LWDOLDQL H VWUDQLHUL/ LO FRQWDWWR FRQ JOL DOWUL DPELHQWL GHO0 OD FXOWXUD/ GDOO·8QLYHUVLWj DOOH DFFDGHPLH1 6D HVVHUH JHVXLWD H VD QRQ HVVHUOR TXDQGR/ D WUH DQQL GDOOD QRPLQD/ O·RUGLQH YLHQH VFLROWR QHO GXFDWR1 6XR PHULWR q GL HVVHUH ULXVFLWR D SRUWDUH D FRPSLPHQWR HVSHULPHQWL JLj SDU]LDOPHQWH GHFROODWL/ PD PDL FRPSLXWDPHQWH VYROWL= OR VFDPELR/ OD YHQGLWD GHJOL HVHPSODUL GRSSL +FKH FRPH VL q YLVWR HUD SDUWLWD FRQ OD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR GXUDQWH OD GLUH]LRQH &DQWHOOL,/ XQD UD]LRQDOH FDWDORJD]LRQH FRUUHGDWD DQFKH GD LQGLFL UDJLRQDWL +%DFFKLQL DYHYD SHU SULPR LQWXLWR OD QHFHVVLWj GL GLYLGHUH L FDWDORJKL GHL PDQRVFULWWL GD TXHOOL GHOOH RSHUH D VWDPSD/ PD FL GHOXGH OD VFDU0 QD HVVHQ]LDOLWj GHOOH VXH VFKHGH,1 +D OD FRQVDSHYROH]]D GHOO·LPSRUWDQ]D GHOOH ELEOLRJUDILH/ LQ PROWL FDVL YDORUL]]D O·XVR GHOOH IHWWROLQH/ VFKHGH VX WDVVHOOL DQ0 WLFLSDWULFL GHOOH PRGHUQH VFKHGH PRELOL1 6D PXRYHUVL FRQ RFXODWH]]D QHO FDPSR GHOOH DFTXLVL]LRQL/ ILQDOL]]DQGROH DOOD SL• DPSLD SRVVLELOH LQWHJUD]LRQH GL RSHUH GL PDWULFH ORFDOH= VWDWXWL/ FUR0 QDFKH H SURGRWWL GHOO·HGLWRULD GHO WHUULWRULR/ TXDOL O·DFTXLVL]LRQH GHOOD 9LWD GL VDQ *HPLQLDQR GHO 3DUHQWH1 6RQR WXWWL SULQFLSL PDWXUDWL QHO WHPSR HG LQ SDUWH JLj HVSUHVVL QHOOH JLRYDQLOL RUD]LRQL 'H SDWULDH +LVWRULD5: H 'H %LEOLRWKHFDUXP XWL0 OLWDWH RUDWLR5;/ SULPD DQFRUD GHOOD VXD QRPLQD LQ (VWHQVH1 6SLQJH D OXQJR SHU OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHL FDWDORJKL H WHVVH DFFRUGL +RJJL GL0 UHPPR ID GHL SUHYHQWLYL, FRQ OH ORFDOL WLSRJUDILH/ DQFKH VH DOOD ILQH OD ULRWWRVL0 Wj GHO 'XFD OR FRVWULQJH DG DEGLFDUH DO SURJHWWR1 $QFKH QHL FRQIURQWL GHL JURVVL PRYLPHQWL GL OLEUL/ TXDOL OH FHVVLRQL H OH YHQGLWH GL LQWHUH ELEOLRWHFKH/ VL PRVWUD DWWHQWR H FRPSHWHQWH/ VHPSUH LQIRU0 PDWR GLUHWWDPHQWH R LQGLUHWWDPHQWH1 ( GL ELEOLRWHFKH/ IUD JOL DFTXLVWL/ L GRQL H OH VRSSUHVVLRQL UHOLJLRVH/ 7LUDERVFKL QH LQFDPHUD YHUDPHQWH WDQWH$ 7XWWL L VXRL ODYRUL GL VWRULFR H GL OHWWHUDWR SRJJLDQR VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH VX XQ·LPSDOFDWXUD ELEOLRJUDILFD H VRQR VSLD GL XQD IRUPD PHQWLV UD]LRQDOH HG HQFL0 FORSHGLFD1 6L WUDWWD LQIDWWL GL DWWHQWH FRPSLOD]LRQL/ GL GL]LRQDUL/ GL VWRULH OHWWH0 UDULH FKH KDQQR O·DVSHWWR GL YHUH H SURSULH HQFLFORSHGLH1 &XULRVR GHOOH IRQWL/ HJOL LQGDJD FRQ VROHU]LD H VL PHWWH D GLVSRVL]LRQH GHOOH DVSHWWDWLYH GHOOD FLWWj/ VRSUDWWXWWR FRQ RSHUH TXDOL OD %LEOLRWHFD PRGHQHVH/ OH 0HPRULH VWRULFKH H LO 'L]LR0 QDULR WRSRJUDILFR VWRULFR111115< ²²²²²²²² 5: 3XEEOLFDWR QHO 4:8</ FRQ GHGLFD DO FRQWH &DUOR GL )LUPLDQ +0LODQR/ 7LS1 0DUHOOLDQD,/ FRVWLWXLVFH GL IDWWR O*HVRUGLR XIILFLDOH GHO 7LUDERVFKL1 5; 4XHVWD RUD]LRQH/ ULVDOHQWH DO 47 GLFHPEUH 4:95/ VL FRQVHUYD PDQRVFULWWD H LQHGLWD/ LQ %(02/ ,W14339 ¡1 /1<1551 5< %LEOLRWHFD PRGHQHVH/ 0RGHQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD/ 4:;40;9> 0HPRULH VWRULFKH PRGHQHVL/ 0R0
*LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H OH ILJXUH GHL ELEOLRWHFDUL HVWHQVL QHOOD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH
438<
8Q VXR PHULWR LQGLVFXWLELOH q DYHU VDSXWR FUHDUH OH EDVL GL XQD FRQWLQXLWj LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ GL XQD SURIRQGD FRQVDSHYROH]]D GHO UXROR FKH KDQQR OD ELEOLR0 WHFD H FKL DO VXR LQWHUQR YL RSHUD QRQ VROR QHL FRQIURQWL GHO 6RYUDQR0 SDGURQH/ PD GHOOD PXQLFLSDOLWj LQWHUD1 3URSULR TXHVWD FRQWLQXLWj/ LQFDUQDWD VRSUDWWXWWR GD &DUOR &LRFFKL H GD $QWRQLR /RPEDUGL/ ULXVFLUj D WUDJKHWWDUH PLUDFRORVDPHQWH LQGHQQH OD ELEOLRWHFD DWWUDYHUVR OH YLFHQGH FRQWUDVWDWH GHO WULHQQLR JLDFRELQR/ GHOOH DVSRUWD]LRQL IUDQFHVL/ GHOOH LPSRVL]LRQL QDSROHRQL0 FKH H/ LQILQH/ GHOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH1 3HU PHULWR SURSULR GL TXHVWD LQWLPD SURIRQGD FRQYLQ]LRQH LO QRQ SL• JLRYDQLVVLPR /RPEDUGL VL UHFKHUj D 3DULJL QHO 4;48 D UHFODPDUH H D ULYHQGLFDUH FRQ IHUPH]]D H GLJQLWj TXDQWR ID SDUWH GHOOD VWRULD H GHOOD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH H VRSUDWWXWWR PRGHQHVH1 ( VDSUj DQ0 FKH RWWHQHUOR$ $ GLPRVWUD]LRQH FKH OD ELEOLRWHFD KD VDSXWR YLYHUH DQFKH VHQ0 ]D OD SDWHUQDOLVWLFD PDQR GL XQ 'XFD R GL XQ SDGURQH H FKH TXHOO·DXWRQRPLD q VWDWD IUXWWR VROR GL XQD SL• FKH PDWXUD FRQVDSHYROH]]D GL Vq1
,O SUHVHQWH FRQWULEXWR/ SUHVHQWDWR QHO 0DU]R 4<<; DO FRQYHJQR ´0RGHQD= XQD FDSLWDOH QHO FXRUH G·(XURSDµ/ UDFFRJOLH LO IUXWWR GL XQD VHULH GL ULFHUFKH/ SUHFHGHQ0 WHPHQWH FRQGRWWH VXOOD VWRULD GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH H GHL VXRL ELEOLRWHFDUL/ JLj LQ SDUWH FRQIOXLWH LQ DOWUH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GHOOD VFULYHQWH1
²²²²²²²² GHQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD/ 4:<60<7> 'L]LRQDULR WRSRJUDILFR VWRULFR GHJOL VWDWL HVWHQVL«2SHUD SRVWX0 PD111/ 0RGHQD/ 7LSRJUDILD &DPHUDOH/ 4;570581
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
4394
$/(66$1'5$ &+,$5(//,
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
4XHVWR SHUFRUVR LQHYLWDELOPHQWH PLQLPR H OLPLWDWR D SRFKL SXQWL HVVHQ0 ]LDOL GHOOD FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH GHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH SDUWH GD DOFXQH FR0 VWDQWL JHQHUDOL H FRPXQL DOO·LQWHUR TXDGUR VWRULFR= OD FRPSRQHQWH FLYLFD/ DV0 VRUELWD PD QRQ HOLPLQDWD QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH/ H LO IRUWH DFFHQWUDPHQWR GHOOD FRUWH VX RJQL DVSHWWR GHOOD FXOWXUD H TXLQGL DQFKH VXOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH1 9LFHQGH H QRPL GHOOD PXVLFD D 0RGHQD VRQR EHQ QRWL H GD GHFHQQL ULJR0 URVDPHQWH HVSRVWL GD XQD ULFFKLVVLPD SURGX]LRQH GL VWXGL VSHFLDOLVWLFL1 4XL JLRYD SLXWWRVWR GDUH D PR· GL DSSXQWL JOL DVSHWWL VDOLHQWL LQQHVWDWL VXOOH GXH FRVWDQWL VRSUD HQXQFLDWH/ VRWWROLQHDQGR FLz FKH IRUVH q PHQR QRWR H IDFHQGR VLVWHPDWLFR ULIHULPHQWR DO SDWULPRQLR FKH GD WXWWR TXHVWR q VWDWR SURGRWWR1 6L SDUOD VRSUDWWXWWR GHOOH IRQWL ELEOLRJUDILFKH H GRFXPHQWDULH= VHQ]D VRWWRYD0 OXWDUH O·HQRUPH ULFFKH]]D GL GDWL RIIHUWL GDOOH DOWUH FDWHJRULH GL IRQWL/ q WXWWD0 YLD RYYLR FKH OH YLFHQGH H LO UHSHUWRULR ULVXOWDQR VRSUDWWXWWR GDL GRFXPHQWL H GDOOD PXVLFD SHUYHQXWD1 /D YLWD PXVLFDOH VWUHWWDPHQWH OHJDWD DOOD FLWWj VL HVSOLFD GD VHPSUH VRSUDWWXWWR QHOOD FKLHVD H VXOOD SLD]]D 1HOOD &KLHVD OD GHVWLQD]LRQH UHOLJLRVD q GL SHU Vq LQ SURVSHWWLYD FRPXQLWD0 ULD1 ,O 'XRPR q LO FXRUH GHOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH GHOOD FLWWj/ ILQR DOOD ILQH GHO VHF1 491/ TXDQGR LO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHJOL (VWHQVL VSRVWD LO SHUQR GHOO·DWWLYLWj PXVLFD0 OH VXOOD &DSSHOOD GL FRUWH1 1RQ D FDVR/ TXLQGL/ SUHVVR OD FDWWHGUDOH VL WURYDQR/ ROWUH DO GHSRVLWR ELEOLRJUDILFR H GRFXPHQWDULR GHOOD UHODWLYD &DSSHOOD/ OH SUL0 PH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H PXVLFDOL PRGHQHVL WXWWH OHJDWH DO FXOWR GL 61 *HPLQLDQR1 /D &DSSHOOD GHO 'XRPR VHPEUD DWWLYD LQLQWHUURWWDPHQWH DOPHQR GDL SULPL
4395
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
GHFHQQL GHO 4XDWWURFHQWR/ FRQ XQ RUJDQR/ XQ RUJDQLVWD H XQ PDHVWUR/ PHQ0 WUH GDO 47:5 VRQR DWWHVWDWH VSHVH UHJRODUL> SHU XQR VJXDUGR G·LQVLHPH VX DWWL0 YLWj H RUJDQLFL QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL/ q DQFRUD YDOLGR LO ULIHULPHQWR DJOL VWXGL JLj SURGRWWL41 4XL EDVWL QRWDUH FKH OD YLWD PXVLFDOH GHO 'XRPR/ GRSR LO WUD0 VIHULPHQWR GHJOL (VWHQVL/ IX UHODWLYDPHQWH LQGLSHQGHQWH/ VHEEHQH XQ SULPR VJXDUGR FRPSDUDWLYR FRQ OH DOWUH DWWLYLWj PXVLFDOL LQ ORFR +FIU1 ROWUH H QHOOH QR0 WH VSHFLILFKH, PHWWD LQ OXFH OD SUHVHQ]D GL HOHPHQWL GHOO·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·XRSR/ RJJL WXWWH FRQVHUYDWH SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH H O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR,/ VH QHO VHF1481 ²²²²²²²² 4 6RSUDWWXWWR *1 521&$*/,$/ /D FDSSHOOD PXVLFDOH GHO 'XRPR GL 0RGHQD/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<8:1 0D DQFKH JOL VFULWWL SUHFHGHQWL= (1 3$1&$/',0*1 521&$*/,$/ 0DHVWUL GL FDSSHOOD GHO 'XRPR GL 0RGHQD«©'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU O·(PLOLD H OD 5RPDJQD1 6H]LRQH GL 0R0 GHQD/ 6WXGL H 'RFXPHQWLª/ ,+4<6<,/ 6/ SS1 59073> ,+4<73,/ 7 / SS1 48058> V 1;/ 7 +4<85,/ SS1 47<0494> V1;/ 9+4<87,/ SS1 9:0434> ,'1/ /D FDSSHOOD PXVLFDOH GHO 'XRPR GL 0RGHQD/«©'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU O·(PLOLD H OD 5RPDJQD1 6H]LRQH GL 0RGHQD1 6WXGL H 'RFXPHQWLª/ 5 +4<76,/ SS1 4:<04<;> V1 ;/ 4+4<7;,/ SS1 <3048:> *1 9(&&+,/ ,O ´&DQWR GHOOH VFROWH PRGHQHVLµ= OD QRWD]LRQH PXVLFDOH/ LQ ©&XOWXUD QHRODWLQDª/ 43+4<83,/ SS1 7<095> *1 521&$*/,$/ 0DHVWUL GL FDS0 SHOOD GHO 'XRPR GL 0RGHQD «LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD SDWULD SHU OH SUR0 YLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 ;/ :+4<88,/ SS1 44504881 5 01 %5(*2/, 58662 0 01 &$/25(/ 6SHWWDFROL GHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ %RORJQD/ $101,161/ 4<;31 *1 %(1$66$7,/ /D SUDWLFD GHO WRUQHR D 0RGHQD LQ HWj EDURFFD/ LQ ©,O &DUUREELRª/ 4<;31 *1 0$57,1(//, %5$*/,$/ &RQWULEXWL SHU XQD VWRULD GHOO·HIILPHUR QHO GXFDWR PRGHQHVH WUD 6HL H 6HWWHFHQWR= 7RPPDVR %H]]L/ LQ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULD0 QD/ 4<;61 01 &$/25(/ 6SHWWDFROL D 0RGHQD WUD &LQTXHFHQWR H 6HLFHQWR1 'DOOD FLWWj DOOD FDSLWDOH/ 0R0 GHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;51 1HO SUHVHQWH FRQYHJQR H LQ TXHOOR LQWLWRODWR D )RQWL H YLWD PXVLFDOH GHOOD 0RGHQD HVWHQVH +90< PDJJLR 4<<;,/ QHOO·DPELWR GHOOH FHOHEUD]LRQL SHU LO ,9 FHQWH0 QDULR GHO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHJOL (VWHQVL D 0RGHQD/ 0DULQD &DORUH KD ULIHULWR ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH VXJOL VSHWWDFROL LQ JHQHUDOH H VX TXHOOL GL SLD]]D LQ SDUWLFRODUH> *LXVHSSLQD %HQDVVDWL KD SUH0 VHQWDWR OR VWDWR GHL VXRL VWXGL QHOO·RWWLFD DUWLVWLFR0VFHQRJUDILFD QHOO·DPELWR GHO FLWDWR FRQYH0 JQR VXOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH1 6LD FRQVHQWLWR FLWDUH DQFKH $1 &+,$5(//,/ 3HU XQ SURILOR VLQWHWL0 FR GHOOH IHVWH G·DUPL D 0RGHQD QHO &LQTXH H 6HLFHQWR/ LQ 0XVLFD LQ WRUQHR QHOO·,WDOLD GHO 6HLFHQWR/ /XFFD/ /,0/ 4<<</ SS1 66097 FXL VL ULQYLD SHU DSSURIRQGLPHQWL H GHWWDJOL H SHU XQD GHVFUL]LRQH GHO0 OH IRQWL UHODWLYH DL VLQJROL VSHWWDFROL GDO &LQTXH DO 6HL PD FRQ TXDOFKH DSSHQGLFH QHO 6HWWH0 FHQWR1
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
4396
GDQQR DSSHQD XQ UDSLGR FHQQR DG HYHQWXDOL DVSHWWL GL SL• FRQVDSHYROH VSHW0 WDFRODULWj +SUHVHQ]D GL VWUXPHQWL QHL FRUWHL FDYDOOHUHVFKL R DOOHVWLPHQWL DFFX0 UDWL LQ DOFXQH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL VDFUH,/ GDOOD ILQH GHO 481 H VRSUDWWXWWR QHO 491 VHF1 WHVWLPRQLDQR LQIOXVVL GL FXOWXUD HVWHUQD/ VRSUDWWXWWR IHUUDUHVH/ FKH SRUWD0 QR DOO·XVR YLD YLD SL• IUHTXHQWH GL PDFFKLQH FRPSOHVVH1 &RVu JLj QHO FRUVR GHO VHF1 491/ QHOOH JUDQGL IHVWH G·DUPL SHU LO SDVVDJJLR GHL GXFKL/ DSSDUDWR HG HOHPHQWL GL WUDGL]LRQH FDYDOOHUHVFD H IHXGDOH VHUYRQR VROR D VDQFLUH OD JUDQGH]]D GHOOD GLQDVWLD H D PDJQLILFDUH OR VSHWWDFROR1 ,QILQH LO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHJOL (VWHQVL D 0RGHQD FKLHGH DOOD FLWWj GL DGHJXDUVL DO VXR QXRYR UXROR GL FDSLWDOH H SURYRFD XQD JUDGXDOH PD UDGLFDOH PHWDPRUIRVL QHOOD SRSROD]LRQH/ OHQWDPHQWH JXLGDWD YHUVR OD FRQVDSHYROH]]D GHO SUHVWLJLR HVWHQVH H TXLQGL YHUVR OD FRVFLHQ]D GL XQ SURSULR GLYHUVR GRYHU HVVHUH1 'D TXHVWR PRPHQWR VL DVVLPLODQR WUDGL]LRQL FLWWDGLQH H DSSRUWL HVWHUQL/ FRVu GD JHQHUDUH QXRYH HVSUHVVLRQL GL VSHWWDFROR1 /D IHVWD GL SLD]]D GLYLHQH VRSUDW0 WXWWR FHOHEUDWLYD= HVVD ULIOHWWH LO UDSSRUWR FRQ OD VLJQRULD GXFDOH +O·RFFDVLRQH GL ULFRUUHQ]H IDPLOLDUL R GL SUHVWLJLRVH YLFHQGH, H VL FRQILJXUD VX PRGHOOL FXO0 WXUDOL HVWHUQL +ROWUH DOOR VSHWWDFROR IHUUDUHVH/ OD FRPPHGLD H LO WHDWUR LQ JHQH0 UH,1 ( FRQWHVWXDOPHQWH OD FRUWH HVWHQVH FRPLQFLD D VYROJHUH OD VXD IXQ]LRQH FHQWULSHWD LQ RJQL DVSHWWR GHOOD YLWD FXOWXUDOH PRGHQHVH1 /D QDWXUD VWHVVD GHL QXFOHL GL IRQWL UHODWLYH DOOH IHVWH GL SLD]]D VRWWROLQHD O·DFFHQWUDPHQWR HVWHQVH QHL FRQIURQWL GHOOD GLPHQVLRQH FLYLFD1 ,QIDWWL/ SULPD WURYLDPR UHVRFRQWL GL FRUVH H FRPEDWWLPHQWL YHUL H SURSUL/ FRQ YHUL YLQFLWRUL H YLQWL LQ EDVH DOO·DELOLWj SHUVRQDOH> SRL/ FRQ LO SUHYDOHUH GHO WRUQHR D WHPD/ ´FDUWHOOLµ GL VILGD H GL ULVSRVWD/ DQFRUD FRQ ILJXUH H PRGL GHO WRUQHR GL WUDGL]LRQH PHGLHYDOH H FRQ YHUL FDPSLRQL1 0D YLD YLD D TXHVWL PDWHULDOL VXEHQWUDQR IRQWL VRSUDWWXWWR GL QDWXUD SDUHQHWLFD H G·RFFDVLRQH= VL WUDWWD SHU OR SL• GL GHVFUL]LRQL VWDPSDWH FRQ GHGLFD H FRQ OD VSHFLILFD]LRQH GHOO·RFFDVLRQH GLQDVWLFD/ FRUUHGDWH GL GLVH0 JQL R LQFLVLRQL GHOOD JUDQGLRVD H FRPSOHVVD VFHQRWHFQLFD/ FRQ XQR VYROJL0 PHQWR GHOO·D]LRQH D PR· GL VSHWWDFROR SUHRUGLQDWR LQ FXL LO FRPEDWWLPHQWR q DOOHJRULFR H D ULVXOWDWR VFRQWDWR> VSHVVR DOOH GHVFUL]LRQL VL DJJLXQJRQR YHUVL FDQWDWL GL FDUDWWHUH ODXGDWLYR1 /·DVSHWWR PXVLFDOH LQ VHQVR VWUHWWR q VHPSUH VFDUVDPHQWH GRFXPHQWDWR H VHQ]D UHSHUWRULR VXSHUVWLWH= TXD H Oj SRFKL FHQQL DOOD SUHVHQ]D GL VWUXPHQWL GXUDQWH OH HQWUDWH GHL FRPEDWWHQWL H DOOD ORFDOL]]D0 ]LRQH GHL FDQWDQWL/ VXOOH PDFFKLQH RSSXUH VX XQ SDOFKHWWR SUHGLVSRVWR/ VHQ]D QHVVXQ GHWWDJOLR1 3LX· DYDQWL VL YHGUDQQR DOWUL DVSHWWL UHODWLYL DJOL VSHWWDFROL GL SLD]]D/ DOOD OX0
4397
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
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• LPSRU0 WDQWH SURGX]LRQH GHO WHPSR/ GLYHQXWH LO SULPR QXFOHR GHOO·DWWXDOH IRQGR VSH0 FLILFR GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH, 6 H LO ULVWDELOLPHQWR GL XQ RUJDQLFR GL FRUWH QRQ LQGHJQR GHOO·DOWLVVLPD WUDGL]LRQH FXOWXUDOH H PXVLFDOH IHUUDUHVH +OH SHUVR0 QDOLWj GL ULIHULPHQWR VRQR VRSUDWWXWWR 2UD]LR 9HFFKL PD DQFKH *HPLQLDQR &DSLOXSL H *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 6WHIDQLQL,7/ FKH GD RUD VRVWLWXLVFH LO 'XRPR FRPH FHQWUR GHOO·DWWLYLWj ORFDOH ,O 6HLFHQWR H LQ SDUWLFRODUH LO SHULRGR GL )UDQFHVFR ,, q LO PRPHQWR GL SL• YLYR LPSXOVR FXOWXUDOH/ FXL YD GHO SDUL LO IHUYRUH GHOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH/ DUWLFRODWD H FRPSOHVVD PD DJJUHJD0 WD DWWRUQR DG DOFXQH FRVWDQWL= O·DWWLYLWj ORFDOH H LO UHODWLYR GHSRVLWR> O·LQWHUHVVH SHU OD FXOWX0 UD HVWHUQD/ GL QDWXUD PROWHSOLFH/ H OD UHODWLYD UDFFROWD GL WHVWLPRQLDQ]H1 /·DWWLYLWj q LPSHUQLDWD VXOOD FDSSHOOD GL FRUWH +GRFXPHQWDWD DOPHQR SDU0 ]LDOPHQWH GDO 4943, FKH DWWLUD DQFKH FRPSRVLWRUL H YLUWXRVL HVWHUQL +FRPH 'RPHQLFR *DEULHOOL/ 6LJLVPRQGR G·,QGLD/ H *LRYDQQL )UDQFHVFR *URVVL GHW0 WR 6LIDFH, H FRQWD PDHVWUL H VRWWRPDHVWUL GL QRWHYROH OHYDWXUD +FRPH *LXVHS0 SH &RORPEL/ $QWRQLR *LDQQHWWLQL H *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 9LWDOL,81 /D SURGX]LR0 ²²²²²²²² 6
(1 '85$17( ² $1 0$57(//277,/ &URQLVWRULD GHO &RQFHUWR GHOOH 'DPH SULQFLSDOLVVLPH GL 0DU0 JKHULWD *RQ]DJD G·(VWH/ )LUHQ]H/ 6131(161/ 4<:<> ,G1/ /·DUSD GL /DXUD1 ,QGDJLQH RUJDQRORJLFD/ DUWLVWLFD H DUFKLYLVWLFD VXOO·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·(VWH +GDO VHF1 ;9 DO ;9,,,,/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOH 551 'HSXWD]LRQL
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
4398
QH ORFDOH q IRUWHPHQWH FRQGL]LRQDWD GDOOH VFHOWH H GDL JXVWL GHO GXFD LPSURQ0 WDWL GL LQIOXVVL URPDQL +IRUVH SHU LO WUDPLWH GHOOD PDGUH /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ QL0 SRWH GHO FDUG1 0D]]DULQR,= LQIDWWL VRQR SULYLOHJLDWH OH IRUPH PXVLFDOL SUHGR0 PLQDQWL QHOO·DPELHQWH URPDQR/ FDQWDWH H RUDWRUL1 /H FDQWDWH QRQ SUHVHQWDQR FDUDWWHUL FRPSRVLWLYL RULJLQDOL= OD VROLWD DOWHU0 QDQ]D WUD UHFLWDWLYR H DULD/ L WHPL GLGDVFDOLFR0PRUDOHJJLDQWL1 ,O FDUDWWHUH SDUWL0 FRODUH GHOOH FDQWDWH PRGHQHVL VWD QHO ORUR FRQWHVWR SURGXWWLYR= O·DWWLYLWj GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GHL 'LVVRQDQWL1 6RQR LQIDWWL VX WHVWR GL $FFDGHPLFL +DG HV1 *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *LDUGLQL/ *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 5RVVHOOL *HQHVLQL/ 'DULR 6DQ0 JLRYDQQL, H SHU PXVLFD GL FRPSRVLWRUL D FRUWH= L FLWDWL &RORPEL H 9LWDOL/ QRQ0 FKq $QWRQLR *LDQQRWWL H *LRYDQQL 0DUFR 0DUWLQL91 $OFXQH IRQWL VRQR HGL0 ]LRQL GL GHGLFD/ FKH XQLVFRQR DO SUHJLR GHO FRQWHQXWR XQD UDIILQDWD YHVWH HGL0 WRULDOH FRQ EHOOH OHJDWXUH +FIU1 DG HV1 0XV1*153,1 6L WUDWWD GL XQD SURGX]LRQH D ILQDOLWj ODXGDWLYD/ FKH PRVWUD FRQ JOL VSHWWDFROL GL SLD]]D VRPLJOLDQ]H H GLI0 IHUHQ]H1 6RPLJOLDQ]H QHOO·LPSLDQWR FRPSRVLWLYR +DOWHUQDQ]D UHFLWDWLYR0DULD/ FHUWD SHU OH FDQWDWH/ VXSSRVWD GDO WHVWR SRHWLFR SHU OH IHVWH GL SLD]]D/ SULYH GL IRQWL PXVLFDOL,/ QHL WHPL +GLGDVFDOLFR0PRUDOLVWLFL H DOOHJRULFL,/ QHL ULIHULPHQWL DOOD FDVD G·(VWH H DOOH VXH YLFHQGH1 'LIIHUHQ]H VRSUDWWXWWR QHL PRGL GL HVSOLFL0 WDUH LO SUHVWLJLR FXOWXUDOH H SROLWLFR GHO FDVDWR= LQ XQ FDVR q SURFODPDWR DOO·HVWHUQR/ FRQ XQD PDVVLPD HVWHQVLRQH> QHOO·DOWUR q SURLHWWDWR DOO·LQWHUQR/ LQ XQ DPELWR HOLWDULR1 /H IRQWL VXJJHULVFRQR SRL DOWUL ULOLHYL1 /H DWWULEX]LRQL VRQR HVSOLFLWH SHU OH FDQWDWH/ WDFLXWH SHU OH IHVWH GL SLD]]D/ LO FKH SUREDELOPHQWH VH0 ²²²²²²²² GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVL H SDUPHQVLª/ V1 6/ 5+4;;6,/ SS1 74807<7> V1 6/ 6+4;;8,/ SS1 83:0856/ QRQFKp O·LQGDJLQH LQWHJUDWLYD GL *1 521&$*/,$/ /D PXVLFD DOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH GDO 4:3: DOOD FRVWLWX]LRQH GHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WR0 ULD 3DWULD SHU OH DQWLFKH SURYLQFLH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 43/ 4+4<99,/ SS1 58<05:;/ H/ D FRPSOHPHQWR GHOOH YLFHQGH DXVWUR0HVWHQVL VXELWR GRSR O·8QLWj/ OR VFULWWR GL $1 &$7(/$1,/ /D YHFFKLD FDSSHOOD GHOOD &RUWH HVWHQVH H OD FRPPLVVLRQH LQFDULFDWD GL RUJDQL]]DUH XQD QXRYD VFXROD GL PXVLFD LQ 0RGHQD/LQ ©/·$YYHQLUH1 *LRUQDOH SROLWLFR/ OHWWHUDULR H XPRULVWLFRª1 $ TXHVWL VL GHYRQR LQ PDVVLPD SDUWH OH QRWL]LH TXL ULSRUWDWH/ SHU OH TXDOL VL ULQYLD SHUz DQFKH D= *1 521&$*/,$/ ´0RGHQDµ/ 'LH 0XVLN LQ *HVFKLFKWH XQG *HJHQZDUW/ Y1 </ .DVVHO/ %DHUHQUHLWHU/ 4<94/ FROO1 6<90734> (1 685,$1/ ´0RGHQDµ/ 7KH 1HZ *URYH 'LFWLRQDU\ RI 0XVLF DQG 0XVLFLDQV/ Y1 45/ /RQGRQ/ 0DFPLOODQ/ 4<;3/ SS1 7830784> 01 ', 3$648$/(/ ´0RGHQDµ/ 'L]LRQDULR (QFLFORSHGLFR 8QLYHUVDOH GHOOD 0XVLFD H GHL 0XVLFLVWL1 ,O OHVVLFR/ Y1 6/ 7RULQR/ 87(7/ 4<;7/ SS1 49604981 9 ,O SULPR H SL• DPSLR VWXGLR LQ PHULWR q GL 21 -$1'(5/ 7KH &DQWDWD LQ $FFDGHPLD= 0XVLF IRU WKH $FFDGHPLD GH· 'LVVRQDQWL DQG WKHLU 'XNH/ )UDQFHVFR ,, G·(VWH/ LQ ©5LYLVWD 0XVLFDOH ,WDOLDQDª/ 43/ 4<:8/ SS1 84<0877> SHU XOWHULRUL QRWL]LH FL VL SHUPHWWH GL ULQYLDUH D &DQWDWDV E\ *LXVHSSH &RORPEL/ *LRYDQQL 0DULD %RQRQFLQL/ 'RPHQLFR *DEULHOOL/ *LRYDQQL 0DULD +$QJHOR, %RQRQFLQL1 6HOHFWHG DQG LQWURGXFHG E\ $OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL/ 1HZ <RUN/ *DUODQG/ 4<;91
4399
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
JQDOD OD FRQFH]LRQH GHOOD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH DOO·DSHUWR FRPH LQWUDWWHQLPHQWR IDVWRVR H JUDQGLRVR/ PD VWUHWWDPHQWH LQGLUL]]DWR DOOR VWXSRUH H DOOD SURFOD0 PD]LRQH GHOOD JUDQGH]]D HVWHQVH1 ,QROWUH O·DVSHWWR PXVLFDOH/ SXU DIILGDWR DO PDHVWUR GL FRUWH/ QRQ ULFHYH GRFXPHQWD]LRQH H QRQ ULYHOD TXLQGL DOFXQ SUR0 SRVLWR GL VWLOH> O·RUJDQLFR q UDUDPHQWH H VRPPDULDPHQWH DFFHQQDWR1 ,QYHFH OH FDQWDWH/ D GHVWLQD]LRQH HOLWDULD/ VRQR FKLDUDPHQWH FRQQRWDWH FRPH IRUPD PXVLFDOH FROWD/ FRQ HVSOLFLWD]LRQH GL DXWRUL GHO WHVWR H FRPSRVLWRUL/ WDOYROWD FRQ SXEEOLFD]LRQH LQ HVHPSODUL GL GHGLFD1 3HU HVVH VL q VXSSRVWR XQ LQWHQWR GL UHDOL]]DUH D 0RGHQD OR VWLOH URPDQR/ FRQ LVSLUD]LRQH DG $OHVVDQGUR 6WUD0 GHOOD/ VLD SHU LO FRQWHQXWR +GLEDWWLWR DFFDGHPLFR/ VXOOD VFRUWD GHO JLRFR LQWHO0 OHWWXDOH GL WUDGL]LRQH ULQDVFLPHQWDOH,/ VLD SHU O·XVR GHO FRQFHUWR JURVVR H FRQ0 FHUWLQR H FRPXQTXH SHU O·RUJDQLFR GL 809 VWUXPHQWL/ VSHVVR DJJUHJDWL DWWRUQR D XQ QXFOHR GL EDVH GL 5 YLROLQL H EDVVR/ DPSOLILFDWR LQ 6 R 7 YLROLQL R FRQ DJ0 JLXQWD GL YLROD,:1 /·LSRWHVL q WDQWR SL• SODXVLELOH VH VL FRQVLGHUD O·LQWHUHVVH GHO GXFD SHU OD PXVLFD VWUDGHOOLDQD +VRSUDWWXWWR HVWULQVHFDWD QHOOD UDFFROWD GL EXRQD SDUWH GHOOH VXH FRPSRVL]LRQL,;1 1HOOH FDQWDWH LQ $FFDGHPLD VL PDQLIHVWDQR TXLQGL WXWWH OH DUWLFROD]LRQL GHL OHJDPL WUD FRUWH H YLWD PXVLFDOH1 /·$FFDGHPLD/ QDWD VRWWR LO SDWURFLQLR GXFDOH/ FRQWD WUD L SRHWL 'DULR 6DQJLRYDQQL H *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *LDUGLQL/ SHUVRQDJJL FKLDYH GHOO·$FFDGHPLD VWHVVD> LQROWUH *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *LDUGLQL VHPEUD LO IXOFUR GHOOD YLWD FXOWXUDOH H PXVLFDOH= 6HJUHWDULR GL /HWWHUH GHO GXFD/ SULPR 6HJUHWDULR GHL 'LVVRQDQWL/ FRRUGLQDWRUH GHOOH DWWLYLWj FXOWXUDOL/ OLEUHWWLVWD GL DOFXQL RUDWRUL PRGHQHVL +PXVLFDWL GD *LRYDQQL 3DROR &RORQQD/ )UDQFHVFR 'H *UDQGLV/ %HUQDUGR 3DVTXLQL/ *LDFRPR $QWRQLR 3HUWL/ $OHVVDQGUR 6WUD0 GHOOD,1 3URSULR O·RUDWRULR ILQLVFH SHU SUHYDOHUH QHO SHULRGR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,= QDWR D 5RPD QHOO·DPELWR GHOOD &RQIUDWHUQLWD GL 61 )LOLSSR 1HUL/ JLj GD WHPSR SRUWD0 WR D %RORJQD WUDPLWH L )LOLSSLQL SRL GLIIXVR QHO UHVWR GHO WHUULWRULR HPLOLDQR/ VL LQQHVWD D 0RGHQD VXOOH DWWLYLWj GHOOD &RQIUDWHUQLWD GL 61 &DUOR= XQ FHQWL0 ²²²²²²²² :
21 -$1'(5/ 111FLW1/ S1 8761 6X $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD VL YHGD VRSUDWWXWWR OD VHULH GL VFULWWL SURGRWWL GD &DURO\Q *LDQ0 WXUFR/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH &1 *,$1785&20(1 0&&5,&.$5'/ $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD +496<049;5,= D WKHPDWLF FDWDORJXH RI KLV FRPSRVLWLRQV «/ 6WX\YHVDQW/ 3HQGUDJRQ/ 4<<4> &1 *,$1785&2/ $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD/ 496<049;5= KLV OLIH DQG PXVLF/ 2[IRUG/ &ODUHQGRQ/ 4<<71 6XOOH IDVL GL IRUPD]LRQH GHO QXFOHR VWUDGHOOLDQR VL YHGDQR L FRQWULEXWL GL 0DUWD /XFFKL H $OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL LQ $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD H 0RGHQD1 $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR ,QWHUQD]LRQDOH GL 6WXGL/ D FXUD GL &1 *,$1785&2/ 0RGHQD/ 7HDWUR &RPXQDOH/ 4<;81 ;
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
439:
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q IRUWHPHQWH LQJOREDWD QHO FRQWHVWR GXFDOH SHU LO WUDPLWH GL SHUVRQDJJL 0 FKLDYH GHOOD FXOWXUD PRGHQHVH/ FRPH TXHOOL JLj FLWDWL/ H GHOOD &RQIUDWHUQLWD GL 61 &DU0 OR1 , OHJDPL GL TXHVWD FRQ OD FRUWH VRQR HYLGHQWL ULVSHWWR HQWUDPEH OH VH]LRQL GHOOD &RQIUDWHUQLWD VWHVVD= TXHOOD GHQRPLQDWD GDOOD 1DWLYLWj/ WUD L FXL OXRJKL GL FXOWR q DSSXQWR O·RUDWRULR GL 61&DUOR 5RWRQGR/ H TXHOOD GHQRPLQDWD GDOO·$VVXQ]LRQH/ FXL IDQQR FDSR OD &KLHVD H LO &ROOHJLR<1 1HOOD &KLHVD/ OD SLF0 FROD FDSSHOOD PXVLFDOH YROXWD GDO OHJDWR 0RO]D +RUJDQLVWD/ FRPSRVLWRUH/ DO0 FXQL FDQWDQWL H VWUXPHQWLVWL/ ULSLHQL FRQYRFDWL DOO·RFFDVLRQH> QH SURVHJXRQR WHVWLPRQLDQ]H VROR JHQHULFKH ILQR DO 4:<;,/ QHOOH DVVXQ]LRQL q LQ SDUWH FRQGL0 ]LRQDWD GDOOR VWHVVR )UDQFHVFR ,,1 1HO &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL O·LQVHJQDPHQWR FRPSUHQGH DQFKH EDOOR/ ´PXVLFDµ +WHRULFD",/ DSSUHQGLPHQWR VWUXPHQWDOH/ FDQWR> VDJJLR XIILFLDOH H VROHQQH GHOOH DWWLYLWj VFRODVWLFKH VRQR OH $FFDGHPLH GL /HWWHUH H G·$UPL/ UDSSUHVHQWDWH SULPD QHO FRUWLOH GHO &ROOHJLR H QHO 7HDWUR GHOOD 6SHOWD/ D YROWH QHO 7HDWUR 'XFDOH GL 3LD]]D +SL• WDUGL/ GDO 4:86/ QHO 7HD0 WUR GHO &ROOHJLR,431 *UD]LH DOOH IRQWL LQ (VWHQVH +OH SDUWLWXUH H OH SDUWL ,, H ,,, GL XQD 5DFFROWD GL OLEUHWWL FRQ XQ WLWROR G·LQVLHPH FKH FLWD HVSUHVVDPHQWH O·DUFR FURQRORJLFR 49;3049;< H O·2UDWRULR GL 61 &DUOR/ GD LQWHQGHUVL SHU 61 &DUOR 5RWRQGR/ FR0 PH OXRJR GL HVHFX]LRQH,44 GL TXDVL WXWWL JOL RUDWRUL FL SHUYHQJRQR VLD L GDWL VWRULFL VLD LO UHSHUWRULR VWHVVR1 Ë QRWHYROH FKH LO QXFOHR HVWHQVH GL RUDWRUL SUHVHQWL IRUWL DQDORJLH ULVSHWWR DOWUL IRQGL SURGRWWL GDOO·DWWLYLWj PXVLFDOH FRHYD ²²²²²²²² <
3HU TXDOFKH FHQQR VXOO·RUDWRULR D 0RGHQD H VXL OHJDPL FRQ OD FRQIUDWHUQLWD/ FIU1 91 &52:7+(5/ 7KH 2UDWRULR LQ 0RGHQD/ 2[IRUG/ &ODUHQGRQ/ 4<<51 43 3HU XQ VRPPDULR SURILOR GHOOD PXVLFD QHO &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL VLD FRQVHQWLWR ULQYLDUH D $1 &+,$5(//,/ /D 0XVLFD/ LQ ,O &ROOHJLR H OD FKLHVD GL 61 &DUOR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ %DQFD 3RSROD0 UH GHOO·(PLOLD/ >4<<4@/ SS1 57<05881 44 %(02/ ;61,1809
439;
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
SUHVVR IDPLJOLH URPDQH1 &RVu QHO IRQGR 2WWRERQL VL WURYDQR/ LQ UHGD]LRQH PDQRVFULWWD/ PXVLFKH GL FHUWD R SUHVXQWD HVHFX]LRQH PRGHQHVH FRPH LO 61 $OHVVLR GL %HUQDUGR 3DVTXLQL H /D EHDWD 0DUJKHULWD GD &RUWRQD GHOOD FRSSLD PRGHQHVH *LDUGLQL0*LDQQHWWLQL> QHO IRQGR 3DPSKLOL VL WURYDQR RUDWRUL SUH0 VHQWL DQFKH LQ IRQWL HVWHQVL FRPH OD 0DGGDOHQD GL $OHVVDQGUR 6FDUODWWL H 61 0DULD 0DGGDOHQD GH· 3D]]L GL *LRYDQQL /RUHQ]R /XOLHU> LQROWUH QHO 49;:0;; FDQWD SUHVVR L 3DPSKLOL *LRYDQQL )UDQFHVFR *URVVL GHWWR ´6LIDFHµ/ YLUWXRVR GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD451 /·DOWUD IRUPD WLSLFD GHOO·DWWLYLWj ORFDOH IDFHQWH FDSR DOOD &DSSHOOD GL FRUWH q OD SURGX]LRQH VWUXPHQWDOH SHU DUFKL/ LQQRYDWD GD 0DUFR 8FFHOOLQL H TXL FRQWLQXDWD VRSUDWWXWWR GDL FLWDWL &RORPEL H 9LWDOL QRQFKq GD *LRYDQQL 0DULD %RQRQFLQL461 Ë TXHVWD D GDUH LPSXOVR DOOD SULPD VWDPSD PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH/ WXWWD LQ HVHPSODUL GL GHGLFD H GRYXWD LQ SDUWLFRODUH DL &DVVLDQL/ D &ULVWRIRUR &DQREL/ *DVSDUR )HUUL/ )RUWXQLDQR 5RVDWL/ $QWRQLR 9LWDOLDQL/ PHQWUH DL 6ROLDQL VL GH0 YRQR VRSUDWWXWWR OLEUHWWL/ H LQ JUDQGH TXDQWLWj471 (G q IRUVH O·XQLFD SURGX]LR0 QH GDYYHUR RULJLQDOH GD SDUWH GHOOD &DSSHOOD GL FRUWH/ VHEEHQH VL LVFULYD QHO FRQWHVWR ´HPLOLDQRµ DWWLYLVVLPR QHOOD PXVLFD SHU DUFKL +D VXD YROWD VXOOD VFRU0 WD GL XQ GLIIXVR IHUYRUH WXWWR LWDOLDQR,1 6HPSUH SHU GLUHWWR LQWHUYHQWR GL )UDQFHVFR/ PD FRPH FDVR DEEDVWDQ]D D ²²²²²²²² 45
6XOO·DPELHQWH PXVLFDOH URPDQR H L FRQWDWWL FRQ TXHOOR PRGHQHVH/ FIU1 )1 '(//$ 6(7$/ , %RUJKHVH +49<404:64,1 /D PXVLFD GL XQD JHQHUD]LRQH/LQ ©1RWH G·$UFKLYLR SHU OD VWRULD PXVLFDOHª/ Q1V1/ 4/ 4<;6/ SS1 46<053:> 91 *2/=,2/ 'RFXPHQWL DUWLVWLFL VXO 6HLFHQWR QHOO·$UFKLYLR &KLJL/ 5RPD/ 3DORPEL/ 4<6<> +1 -1 0$5;/ 'LH 0XVLN DP +RIH 3LHWUR .DUGLQDO 2WWRERQLV XQWHU $UFDQJHOR &RUHOOL/ LQ ©$QDOHFWD 0XVLFRORJLFDª/ 8/ 4<9;/ SS1 43804::> /1 0217$/72/ 8Q PHFHQDWH LQ 5RPD EDURF0 FD1 ,O FDUGLQDOH %HQHGHWWR 3DPSKLOL +498604:63,/ )LUHQ]H/ 6DQVRQL/ 4<88> +1 -1 0$5;/ 'LH ´*LXVWL0 ILFD]LRQL GHOOD FDVD 3DPSKLOLµ DOV 0XVLNJHVFKLFKWOLFKH 4XHOOH/ LQ ©6WXGL 0XVLFDOLª/ 45/ 4/4 <;6/ SS145404;:> 01 085$7$/ ,O FDUQHYDOH D 5RPD VRWWR &OHPHQWH ,; 5RVSLJOLRVL/ LQ ©5LYLVWD ,WDOLDQD GL 0XVLFRORJLDª/ 45/ 4/ 4<::/ SS1 ;50<;1 46 3HU OD SURGX]LRQH VWUXPHQWDOH EDVWL FLWDUH (1 6&+(1./ 2VVHUYD]LRQL VXOOD VFXROD LVWUXPHQ0 WDOH PRGHQHVH GHO VHF1 ;9,,/LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ OHWWHUH H $UWLª/ V1 8/ 43 +4<85,/ 6H]1 ,,,= 6WRULD/ /HWWHUH H $UWL/ SS1 6063> )1 *,*/,2/,/ 6RQDWH D GXH YLROLQL FRQ XQ EDV0 VHWWR YLROD VH SLDFH= RS1 ,9 +49:9, GL *LXVHSSH &RORPEL= WUDVFUL]LRQH HG DQDOLVL VWRULFR0FRPSRVLWLYD/ GLVV1 GL ODXUHD/ GV1/ 3LVD/ 4<:809> -1*1 68(66/ 7KH LQVWUXPHQWDO PXVLF PDQXVFULSWV RI *LXVHSSH &RORPEL RI 0RGHQD= D SUHOLPLQDU\ UHSRUW RQ WKH QRQ0GDQFH PXVLF IRU VROR YLROLQ RU YLRORQH/ LQ 6HLFHQWR LQHVSORUDWR1 /·HYHQWR PXVLFDOH WUD SUDVVL H VWLOH= XQ PRGHOOR GL LQWHUGLSHQGHQ]D1 $WWL GHO ,,, &RQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH VXOOD PXVLFD LQ DUHD ORPEDUGR0SDGDQD GHO VHF1 ;9,,/ &RPR/ $101,161/ 4<<6/ SS1 6;:073<1 47 7XWWR FLz ULVXOWD LPPHGLDWDPHQWH GD XQD ULFRJQL]LRQH UDSLGD VXOOH IRQWL HVWHQVL1
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
439<
Vq/ VL FRPSLH LO WHQWDWLYR GL VWDELOLUH XQ·DWWLYLWj WHDWUDOH ILVVD H L UHODWLYL VSHWWD0 FROL/ RYYLDPHQWH VXOOD VFRUWD GHOOH VWDJLRQL YHQH]LDQH VRSUDWWXWWR ULVSHWWR OD JUDQGH QRYLWj VHLFHQWHVFD GHOO·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD1 3HUWDQWR VL DWWLYDQR WHDWUL/ QXRYL R ULVWUXWWXUDWL VX DOWUL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH VL ULFRVWUXLVFH QHO 49;6/ GRSR XQ LQFHQGLR/ LO 7HDWUR )RQWDQHOOL +JLj 9DOHQWLQL, FKH DYYLD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL LQ PXVLFD GDO 49;8> D 5HJJLR LO 7HDWUR GHOOD &RPXQLWj GDO 49;6 Gj RSHUH D FD0 GHQ]D UHJRODUH GL XQD VWDJLRQH O·DQQR1 7XWWL L WHDWUL/ SXU GL IRQGD]LRQH SULYD0 WD/ FRQWDQR VXO VRVWHJQR ILVVR PD VXELVFRQR DQFKH LO FRQWUROOR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ VX VFHOWH UDSSUHVHQWDWLYH H VXOO·RUJDQLFR +ROWUH DJOL VWUXPHQWLVWL/ DQFKH L FDQWDQWL VRQR SHU OR SL• ´YLUWXRVLµ GXFDOL FRPH *LRYDQQL %X]]ROHQL/ 0DULD 0DGGDOHQD 0XVL/ $QJHOD H 0DUJKHULWD 6DOLFROL/ *LXVHSSH 6FDFFLD,481 $ TXH0 VWR WHQWDWLYR GL LQVWDXUDUH LO WHDWUR FRPH ´FDWHJRULDµ GL SURGX]LRQH H VSHWWD0 FROR VL GHYH O·DJJUHJD]LRQH/ LQ TXHJOL VWHVVL DQQL/ GL XQ JUDQGH QXFOHR GL IRQWL ORFDOL HG HVWHUQH= SDUWLWXUH GL PHORGUDPPL YHQH]LDQL R GL ORUR UHSOLFKH GL D0 UHD FKH SRWUHPPR GHILQLUH ´SDGDQDµ> DULH GD RSHUH YHQH]LDQH R GD UHSOLFKH GHOOD VWHVVD DUHD +GHL FRPSRVLWRUL SL• DFFUHGLWDWL/ FRPH $QWRQLR &HVWL/ *LR0 YDQQL /HJUHQ]L/ L 0HODQL/ &DUOR 3DOODYLFLQR/ JOL =LDQL,1 Ë QRWHYROH FKH WDOL IRQWL QRQ VL ULIHULVFDQR VROR DG RSHUH GDWH HIIHWWLYDPHQWH D 0RGHQD H D 5HJ0 JLR/ PD VLDQR VSHVVR XQD SXUD H VHPSOLFH GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GL FLz FKH GL PH0 JOLR VL Gj DO PRPHQWR QHOOD FLUFROD]LRQH RSHULVWLFD1 4XHVWR QXFOHR VWD TXLQGL D PHWj IUD OD UDFFROWD GL WHVWLPRQLDQ]H GL FXOWXUD HVWHUQD H O·DJJUHJD]LRQH GL VRVWHJQR DL WHDWUL ORFDOL/ TXDVL XQD EDVH GD FXL VHOH]LRQDUH JOL VSHWWDFROL1 ,Q FLz OD UDFFROWD HVWHQVH VL DSSDUHQWD D TXHOOD FRHYD GL 0DUFR &RQWDULQL/ DJJUH0 JDWDVL DWWRUQR DO WHDWUR FKH LO QRELOH YHQH]LDQR DSUu D 3LD]]ROD VXO %UHQWD> DQ0 FKH LQ WDO FDVR/ OH SDUWLWXUH SHUYHQXWH DWWHVWDQR LO UHSHUWRULR HIIHWWLYDPHQWH GDWR VXOOH VFHQH PD DQFKH TXHOOR VHPSOLFHPHQWH SURFXUDWR SHU FRQRVFHQ0 ]D491 1HOO·LPSRVVLELOH FRQIURQWR FRQ OH JUDQGL SURGX]LRQL YHQH]LDQH H LQ PDQ0 ²²²²²²²² 48 3HU JOL VSHWWDFROL/ FIU1 OH FURQRORJLH H OR VJXDUGR G·LQVLHPH IRUQLWR GD $1 725(//,0%1 %581(//, 0 $101 %21,6&217,/ ´0RGHQDµ/LQ (QFLFORSHGLD GHOOR 6SHWWDFROR/ Y1 :/ 5RPD/ OH 0D0 VFKHUH/ 4<93/ SS1 99;09:4> *1 521&$*/,$/ ´0RGHQDµ/ 'LH 0XVLN LQ *HVFKLFKWH XQG *HJHQZDUW/« FLW1 49 3HU XQR VJXDUGR G·LQVLHPH VXOO·LQWHUD UDFFROWD GL DULH SRVVHGXWD GDOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQ0 VH/ FL VL SHUPHWWH GL ULQYLDUH DG $1 &+,$5(//,/ &ROOH]LRQLVPR PXVLFDOH QHO WDUGR 6HLFHQWR= OH UDFFROWH PDQRVFULWWH GL DULH GD RSHUH LWDOLDQH QHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD/ GLVV1/ 'RWWRUDWR GL 5LFHUFD/ 8QLYHUVLWj GL %RORJQD/ D1D1 4<;809
43:3
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
FDQ]D GL XQ YHUR VLVWHPD LPSUHVDULDOH +IRQGD]LRQH DULVWRFUDWLFD H DSSDOWR LPSUHVDULDOH VL PHVFRODQR DO PHFHQDWLVPR H DO FRQWUROOR GXFDOH LQ XQD FRQIL0 JXUD]LRQH PLVWD QRQ LQVROLWD D TXHO WHPSR,4:/ OD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH FRQ PXVLFD VL RULHQWD VROR LQ SDUWH YHUVR LO PHORGUDPPD GL FXL QRQ q SRVVLELOH VRVWHQHUH D 0RGHQD XQ·LQWHQVD FDGHQ]D VWDJLRQDOH1 &RQWLQXDQR TXLQGL L JUDQGL VSHWWD0 FROL LQ SLD]]D H LQ FRUWH +SHU O·RFFDVLRQH GL VROHQQLWj IDPLOLDUL/ YLFHQGH SROLWL0 FKH/ YLVLWH LOOXVWUL,/ FRQ XQD VFHQRWHFQLFD JUDQGLRVD H FRQ LQWHQWL FHOHEUDWLYL LQ IXQ]LRQH SROLWLFD1 7HVWR H PXVLFD VRQR GHO 6HJUHWDULR GL /HWWHUH H GHO 0D0 HVWUR GL &RUWH YLD YLD LQ FDULFD1 ,O OXRJR q VHPSUH DOO·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j GHOOD FLUFR0 VWDQ]D H DO SUHVWLJLR GHOOD IDPLJOLD1 $QFKH HVHFXWRUL H RUJDQLFR VRQR WDFLXWL> VL FLWDQR/ H QRQ VHPSUH/ VROR L QRELOL FKH SDUWHFLSDQR R DO WRUQHR R DOOR VSHW0 WDFROR4;1 /H IRQWL ULSRUWDQR DOWUL HOHPHQWL GL SDUWLFRODUH LQWHUHVVH1 ,O SULPDWR HVWHQVH QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH FDYDOOHUHVFD H LO VXR SHUGXUDUH QHL VHFROL YLHQH DIIHU0 PDWR H ULEDGLWR SL• YROWH1 /·DXWRFHOHEUD]LRQH D ILQDOLWj SROLWLFD q WDOYROWD H0 VSOLFLWDWD RSSXUH q LPSOLFLWD LQ YDULH IRUPH= DG HV1/ LQ XQ WHQWDWLYR GL QRELOLWD0 UH LO JHQHUH GL VSHWWDFROR JUD]LH D XQD VRUWD GL ´JLXVWLILFD]LRQHµ VWRULFD +H0 VHPSL LOOXVWUL GL DQWLFKL SRSROL FKH FROWLYDURQR JOL HVHUFL]L G·DUPL DQFKH FRPH GLVFLSOLQD FKH SURGXFH ´VHQWLPHQWL YLUWXRVLµ/ UHJRODQGR JOL ´LQVWLQWL GHOOD QD0 WXUDµ PHGLDQWH ´LQVWLWXWL GHOO·HGXFD]LRQHµ,4<1 $FFDQWR DOOD SURGX]LRQH ORFDOH/ LO IRQGR PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH UDFFRJOLH TXHOOD ²²²²²²²² 4: 8Q UHVRFRQWR VX TXHVWR DVSHWWR GHOO·DWWLYLWj GHO 7HDWUR )RQWDQHOOL q VWDWR IRUQLWR GD 3DXO $WNLQ QHOO·DPELWR GHO FRQYHJQR )RQWL H YLWD PXVLFDOH GHOOD 0RGHQD HVWHQVHª/ 0RGHQD/ 90< PDJJLR 4<<;1 4; %DVWL YHULILFDUH OH IRQWL +GHVFUL]LRQL H WHVWL GHL YHUVL FDQWDWL, FRQVHUYDWH LQ DEERQGDQ]D VRSUDWWXWWR QHO GHSRVLWR ´0LVFHOODQHD 'UDPPDWLFDµ GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH1 3HU WXWWH OH IRQWL GHOOH QRWL]LH TXL ULSRUWDWH VXJOL VSHWWDFROL LQ SLD]]D/ FIU1 QRWD 51 4< 6L ULQYLD D /D *DUD GHOOH 6WDJLRQL27RUQHR $ &DYDOOR25DSSUHVHQWDWR LQ 0RGDQD2QHO 3DVVDJ0 JLR2'H 6HUHQLVVLPL $UFLGXFKL2)HUGLQDQGR &DUOR26LJLVPRQGR )UDQFHVFR2'*$XVWULD2(W $UFLGXFKHVVD $QQD2'L 7RVFDQD/ ,Q 0RGDQD/ SHU *LXOLDQ &DVVLDQL 6WDPSDWRU 'XFDOH/ 4985/ $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU 0DWHULH/ 6SHWWDFROL/ E1 < %/ IDVF1 %7RUQHL H *LRVWUH%/ 4935049931
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
43:4
HVWHUQD +VRSUDWWXWWR PHORGUDPPL YHQH]LDQL/ FDQWDWH GL VFXROD URPDQD H QX0 FOHL VLJQLILFDWLYL= DG HV1 PROWL ODYRUL GL $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD,> WUD L FRPSRVLWRUL SL• IDPRVL EDVWL DFFHQQDUH D *LDFRPR &DULVVLPL/ )UDQFHVFR &DYDOOL/ $QWRQLR &HVWL/ 'RPHQLFR )UHVFKL/ *LRYDQQL /HJUHQ]L/ &DUOR $PEURJLR /RQDWL/ L 0H0 ODQL/ &DUOR 3DOODYLFLQR/ %HUQDUGR 6DEDGLQL/ 0DULR 6DYLRQL531 /·DWWLYLWj FROOH0 ]LRQLVWLFD VL UHJJH VX XQ VHUYL]LR GL FRSLD H OHJDWXUD/ FRQ *LXVHSSH &RORPEL UHVSRQVDELOH GHOOH ULFKLHVWH SHU OD PDQXWHQ]LRQH GHO PDWHULDOH H *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD *LDUGLQL/ VHJUHWDULR GL /HWWHUH/ UHVSRQVDELOH GHL SDJDPHQWL1 /·DJJLRUQDPHQWR q DVVLFXUDWR GD XQD UHWH GL LQIRUPDWRUL H SURFXUDWRUL H DQ0 FKH GDOOD SUHVHQWD]LRQH DO GXFD GL RSHUH DSSHQD FRPSRVWH541 6L VRQR JLj QR0 WDWH OH VRPLJOLDQ]H FRQ DOWUH FROOH]LRQL VLJQRULOL GHO 6HLFHQWR> YD DJJLXQWR FKH WDOH SUDWLFD H OD VXD SHFXOLDUH PROWHSOLFLWj GL LQWHUHVVL VRQR LQ SDUWH WUDGL]LRQH HVWHQVH +HYLGHQWH DQFKH QHOOD UDFFROWD ELEOLRJUDILFD JHQHUDOH, LQ SDUWH ULIOHVVR GHOOD QXRYD DWWLWXGLQH FROOH]LRQLVWLFD/ DSHUWD DOO·HVWHUQR +DQ]L DOO·HVWUDQHR/ IL0 QR DOO·HVRWLFR, H DO QXRYR/ GRSR OH JUDQGL VFRSHUWH VFLHQWLILFKH H JHRJUDILFKH1 1HO VHF1 4;/ O·DWWLYLWj SURVHJXH LQ WRQR PLQRUH /H IHVWH GXFDOL/ LQ SLD]]D R SL• VSHVVR LQ FRUWH/ IDWWH GL D]LRQL LQ PXVLFD H EDOOL ILJXUDWL H YLD YLD SULYDWH GL DUPHJJLDPHQWL H DOOHVWLPHQWL HIILPHUL/ VRQR FRPSRVWH HG HVHJXLWH GD PXVLFLVWL +FRPH $QWRQLR *LDQQHWWLQL H $QWRQLR %RQRQFLQL, HG HVHFXWRUL GL FRUWH +FRPH $QQD H 5RVD G·$PEUHYLOOH/ $QWRQLR %HUQDFFKL/ )UDQFHVFR 'H *UDQGLV/ $QQD *XJOLHOPLQL/ )UDQFHVFR *XLFFLDUGL/ 9LHQQD 0HOOLQL/ *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD 5REHUWL,1 /D SURJUHVVLYD FRQWUD]LRQH GHJOL DUPHJJLDPHQWL D IDYRUH GL FDQWDWH/ GDQ]H H D]LRQL GUDPPDWLFKH Gj OXRJR DG XQD IRUPD VSHWWDFRODUH D Vq1 /D GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ LQ OLEUHWWL FRQWHQHQWL GH0 VFUL]LRQL H YHUVL FDQWDWL/ QH PRVWUD DQFRUD OD SURGX]LRQH RFFDVLRQDOH/ SHU FLU0 FRVWDQ]H IDPLOLDUL R LQ RFFDVLRQH GL SDVVDJJL LQ FLWWj GL SHUVRQDJJL LOOXVWUL1 , OXRJKL GHOOH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL/ FLWDWL QRQ VLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH/ VRQR SHU OR SL• VDOH GL FRUWH/ FRUWLOL H JLDUGLQL GL SDOD]]L/ PD WDOYROWD DQFKH WHDWUL1 /·DUJRPHQWR q VHPSUH O·DOOHJRULD GHOOD JORULD HVWHQVH/ VRWWR O·LQWUHFFLR GLGD0 ²²²²²²²² 53
'L QXRYR VL ULQYLD DOOH UHODWLYH IRQWL QHOOD UDFFROWD PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH1 3HU XQ SULPR TXDGUR VLQWHWLFR PD FRPSOHWR GHOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH H GHOOD UHODWLYD FROOH0 ]LRQH ELEOLRJUDILFD/ VRSUDWWXWWR DL WHPSL GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ VLD FRQVHQWLWR ULQYLDUH DG $1 &+,$5(//,/ , FRGLFL GL PXVLFD GHOOD UDFFROWD HVWHQVH1 5LFRVWUX]LRQH GDOO·LQYHQWDULR VHWWHFHQWHVFR/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<;:1 54
43:5
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
VFDOLFR/ PLWRORJLFR R OHJDWR DOOD OHJJHQGD1 /D VWUXWWXUD +GHVXQWD GDO WHVWR SR0 HWLFR VHPSUH LQ DVVHQ]D GL IRQWL PXVLFDOL, VHPEUD FRQVLVWHUH QHOO·DOWHUQDQ]D GL UHFLWDWLYR H DULD/ WLSLFD GHOOD FDQWDWD1 &RPSRVLWRUL/ SRHWL H LQWHUSUHWL/ TXDVL PDL ULSRUWDWL QHO VHF1 4:1/ QHO 4;1 FRPSDLRQR SL• GL IUHTXHQWH/ VHEEHQH QRQ VLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH/ H VL WUDWWD VHPSUH GL PXVLFLVWL H YLUWXRVL GL FRUWH/ VHJQR SHUWDQWR GHOO·HOHYDWR OLYHOOR GL HVHFX]LRQH551 &RQWLQXD PHQR LQWHQVD O·DWWLYLWj GHO WHDWUR= LO 71 'XFDOH GL 3LD]]D ILQLVFH SHU RVSLWDUH VROR FRPPHGLH R ´D]LRQL DFFDGHPLFKHµ GHO &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL/ SRL q ULGRWWR D PDJD]]LQR H GLVWUXWWR QHO 4:9<> LO 71 'L &RUWH +GDO 4:<9 GH0 QRPLQDWR 1D]LRQDOH,/ SULPD XWLOL]]DWR TXDVL VROR SHU IHVWH GXFDOL/ RVSLWD SRL RSHUH FRQ EDOOL> QHO 71 5DQJRQL VL GDQQR SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH FRPPHGLH> GDO 4:46 LO 7HDWUR 0RO]D Gj FRPPHGLH H RSHUH D VSHVH GHO &RPXQH VROR ILQR DO 4:97561 1HO &ROOHJLR 61 &DUOR/ OH $FFDGHPLH GL /HWWHUH H G· $UPL/ SXQWD GHOO·DWWLYLWj PXVLFDOH LQWHUQD/ GDSSULPD DOWHUQDQR EUDQL UHFLWDWL H FDQWDWL FRQ JLRFKL G·DUPH> GDO VHFRQGR 6HWWHFHQWR VRQR YHUH H SURSULH UHFLWH/ GD WUDJHGLH R FRPPHGLH QRWH/ FRQ EDOOL H JLRFKL G·DUPH LQ IXQ]LRQH DFFHVVRULD571 1HOOH SUHID]LRQL H DOORFX]LRQL DO /HWWRUH GHL OLEUHWWL GL RSHUH H IHVWH GL FRU0 WH FRQVHUYDWL QHOOD ´0LVFHOODQHD 'UDPPDWLFDµ GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ VL WURYDQR VSHVVR FHQQL DO GLEDWWLWR VXL JHQHUL H VXOOD PRUDOLWj GHO WHDWUR= OD ´TXHUHOOHµ FKH RSSRQH LO ULVSHWWR GHL FDQRQL DULVWRWHOLFL DOOD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GHOOH SDVVLRQL H DOOR VYROJLPHQWR GUDPPDWLFR/ LO ILQH GL SXULILFDUH HG HGXFDUH D TXHOOR GL VWXSLUH H GL GLOHWWDUH> L FHQQL LQVLVWRQR VXOOD JLXVWLILFD]LRQH PRUDOH GHO WHDWUR FRQWUR OH SROHPLFKH VXL SHULFROL GL WDOH QDWXUD LQVLWL QHOOD SUDWLFD WHDWUDOH581 'XUDQWH O·LQYDVLRQH QDSROHRQLFD/ OD FULVL SROLWLFD VL WUDGXFH LQ XQD FDGXWD GHO0 OD YLWD FXOWXUDOH H PXVLFDOH &RQ OD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH H LO JRYHUQR/ SHU GLULWWR HUHGLWDULR LQ OLQHD IHPPLQLOH/ GL ²²²²²²²² 55 $QFRUD XQD YROWD VL ULQYLD DOOH IRQWL VRSUDWWXWWR OLEUHWWLVWLFKH QHOOD 0LVFHOODQHD 'UDP0 PDWLFD 56 6L ULQYLD D TXDQWR ULSRUWDWR D QRWD 481 57 6L ULQYLD D QRWD 431 58 8QD ULFRJQL]LRQH VLVWHPDWLFD VX XQD FDPSLRQDWXUD VHL H VHWWHFHQWHVFD q VWDWD FRQGRWWD H FRPSLODWD GDOOD VFULYHQWH QHOO·DPELWR GHL FRUVL GHO 'RWWRUDWR GL 5LFHUFD LQ 0XVLFRORJLD/ 8QLYHUVLWj GL %RORJQD/ DD1DD1 4<;604<;91 8QD SULPD VLQWHVL UDSLGD PD HIILFDFH VXOOD TXHUHOOH q JLj LQ $1 3/$1(//,/ 'HOO·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ D FXUD GL )1 '(*5$'$/ )LHVROH/ 'LVFDQWR/ 4<;41
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
43:6
)UDQFHVFR ,9 GL $VEXUJR0(VWH/ OD ´FHQWUDOLWjµ GHOOD FRUWH QHL FRQIURQWL GHOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH SURVHJXH Vu/ PD VWUHWWDPHQWH LQWUHFFLDWD DOOD FRPSRQHQWH FLYLFD1 ,QIDWWL LO FLUFXLWR GL DWWLYLWj/ DSHUWR DG DVSHWWL QXRYL FRPH TXHOOR GHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR D ILQL SURIHVVLRQDOL/ q LPSHUQLDWR VXOO·RUJDQLFR GL FRUWH/ SHUDOWUR GL RWWLPD IDPD/ FKH SHUz KD REEOLJR GL VHUYL]LR QHO 7HDWUR &RPXQD0 OH> WDOYROWD JOL VWHVVL HVHFXWRUL FRPSDLRQR LQ &ROOHJLR H QHO 'XRPR1 3UHYDOH OR VSHWWDFROR LQ WHDWUR/ VHQ]D FRQWULEXWR VLJQLILFDWLYR GL SURGX]LRQH ORFDOH= VLD TXHOOR GL &RUWH R 'XFDOH VLD LO &RPXQDOH +9HFFKLR H 1XRYR, RVSLWDQR OD SURGX]LRQH GHL 0DHVWUL GL FRUWH $QWRQLR H $OHVVDQGUR *DQGLQL/ PD VRSUDW0 WXWWR LO UHSHUWRULR HVWHUQR GHOO· RSHUD LWDOLDQD SL• WUDGL]LRQDOH591 /D FDUDWWHULVWLFD SL• RULJLQDOH GHOO·2WWRFHQWR PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH q QHOO·DPELWR GHOO·DWWLYLWj GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH H YDORUL]]D]LRQH GHO SDWULPRQLR GHO SDVVDWR1 Ë LO SHULRGR GHJOL VSHFLILFL RUGLQDWRUL GHO IRQGR PXVLFDOH/ FKH OD0 VFLDQR WUDFFLD GHL ORUR RUGLQDPHQWL QHL ULVSHWWLYL FDWDORJKL5:= *LRYDQQL %DWWL0 VWD 'DOO·2OLR/ )HGHULFR 5RHWKHU/ SRVWLOODWR GD /XLJL )UDQFHVFR 9DOGULJKL/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR $QJHOR &DWHODQL/ FXUDWRUH VLD GHOOD UDFFROWD PXVLFDOH SXEEOLFD VLD GHO IRQGR GXFDOH SULYDWR5;1 0XVLFLVWD GL YDORUH H GL RWWLPD IRUPD]LRQH/ +VWX0 GLz DQFKH DO &RQVHUYDWRULR GL 1DSROL,/ VWLPDWR GD 5RVVLQL FRQ FXL LQWUDWWHQH0 YD DPLFKHYROL UDSSRUWL HSLVWRODUL +FIU1 OH OHWWHUH WXWWRUD SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH,5< SURGXVVH PXVLFD/ LQ SDUWH OHJDWD DOOH VXH IXQ]LRQL GL PDHVWUR GL FDSSHOOD LQ 'XRPR +4;7:04;99,63/ QRQFKp VWXGL VXOOH IRQWL PXVLFDOL D OXL DI0 ILGDWH QHOO·DUFKLYLR GXFDOH H QHOOD %LEOLRWHFD 641 ,QIDWWL IX RUGLQDWRUH GHO IRQ0 ²²²²²²²² 59 6L ULQYLD VRSUDWWXWWR DL FRQWULEXWL GL *KHUDUGR *KLUDUGLQL/ $OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL H 0DUWD /XFFKL +QHOO·RUGLQH GHO WHVWR,/ LQ 7HDWUR/ 0XVLFD H &RPXQLWj GD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH D 0RGHQD LWDOLDQD/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<81 5: 3HU XQ SULPR UHQGLFRQWR GHL FDWDORJKL GL PXVLFD H XQ EUHYH WUDFFLD FURQRORJLFD GHJOL RUGLQDWRUL VL ULQYLD DQFRUD D $1 &+,$5(//,/ , FRGLFL GL PXVLFD GHOOD UDFFROWD HVWHQVH111/ FLW1/ SS1 60491 8Q HOHQFR SXQWXDOH VDUj IRUQLWR LQ XQD SURVVLPD SXEEOLFD]LRQH/ LQ YLD GL FRPSLOD]LRQH1 5; 3HU OD VXD YLWD/ SURGX]LRQH H ILJXUD/ EDVWL FRQIURQWDUH OH 0HPRULH DXWRELRJUDILFKH GHOOR VWHVVR &DWHODQL/ LQ /1)1 9$/'5,*+,/ 0XVXUJLDQD/ 0RGHQD/ 4;<61 5< %(02/ )RQGR &DWHODQL1 63 *1 521&$*/,$/ /D FDSSHOOD PXVLFDOH GHO 'XRPR « / FLW1/ SS1 54905651 64 'L TXHVWL EDVWL FLWDUH VRSUDWWXWWR (SLVWRODULR GL DXWRUL FHOHEUL LQ PXVLFD/ ©*D]]HWWD 0XVLFDOH GL 0LODQRª/ 4;85088> 'HOOD YLWD H GHOOH RSHUH GL 2UD]LR 9HFFKL/ LYL/ 4;8;> 'HOOD YLWD H GHOOH RSHUH GL &ODXGLR 0HUXOR/ LYL/ 4;93> /*$UFKLYLR 0XVLFDOH GHO 'XRPR GL 0RGHQD/ LYL/ 4;9405> 'HOOH RSHUH GL $1 6WUDGHOOD HVLVWHQWL QHOO*$UFKLYLR 0XVLFDOH GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD 3DODWLQD GL 0RGHQD111 LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD GL 0RGHQDª/ V1 4/ +4;98,/ SS1 64<06871
43:7
$OHVVDQGUD &KLDUHOOL
GR PXVLFDOH GXFDOH SULYDWR H GL TXHOOR HVWHQVH SXEEOLFR +IRUVH GDO 4;88 ILQR DOOD PRUWH/ DYYHQXWD QHO 4;98,/ ROWUH FKH UHJRODWRUH GHOOH IXQ]LRQL GD FKLHVD SUHVVR OD FRUWH +GDO 4;79 DO 4;8<,1 'RSR O·8QLWj/ VL LQWHUHVVz SDUWLFRODUPHQWH GHOO·LVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD 6FXROD *RYHUQDWLYD GL 0XVLFD 651 /·RSHUD GHO &DWHODQL q PLQX]LRVD H FDSLOODUH DQFKH QHOO·HVDPH GLUHWWR GHL VLQJROL SH]]L= DQFRUD RJJL VL OHJJRQR OH VXH DQQRWD]LRQL/ VSHVVR GL LGHQWLILFD]LRQH R FRPXQTXH GL JXLGD VWRULFD WXWWRUD YDOLGD/ FKH GHQRWDQR FRPSOHWH]]D GL IRUPD]LRQH H GL DWWLYLWj H DPSLD FXOWXUD1 4XHVWD VL ULVFRQWUD DQFKH QHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D FRQ SHUVRQDJ0 JL TXDOL LO 5RVVLQL H *DHWDQR *DVSDUL/ ELEOLRWHFDULR GHOO·DOORUD /LFHR 0XVLFDOH GL %RORJQD, 66 /D FRPSHWHQ]D GHO &DWHODQL ELEOLRWHFDULR PXVLFDOH q DWWHVWDWD GDJOL LQGLFL GHOO·DUFKLYLR SULYDWR H GDJOL VFULWWL GL WLSR FDWDORJUDILFR 67 ,QILQH OD VXD UDFFROWD ELEOLRJUDILFD/ FRVWLWXLWD GL RSHUH SURSULH R GD OXL UDFFROWH 68/ q SHU OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH LO SL• FRVSLFXR LQFUHPHQWR PXVLFDOH GL SURYHQLHQ]D ORFDOH QHOO·2WWRFHQWR1 7DOH DWWLYLWj/ OD SURGX]LRQH FRPSRVLWLYD H O·LPSHJQR GL JXLGDUH LO SDVVDJJLR GHOOD SURIHVVLRQDOLWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH DO QXRYR 6WDWR LWDOLDQR IDQQR GL OXL OD ILJXUD IRUVH SL• HPLQHQWH LQ WDOH DPELWR1 &RQ WDOH SDV0 VDJJLR/ DWWLYLWj H SURGX]LRQH YHQJRQR DVVRUELWH GDOOH LVWLWX]LRQL FRPXQDOL/ H ULSRUWDQR DOOD GLPHQVLRQH FLYLFD LO FHQWUR GHOOD YLWD PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH1 4XHVWL DSSXQWL SHU XQ SURILOR VLQWHWLFR VXOOD FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH VL FKLXGRQR SHUFLz FRQ O·LQWUHFFLDUVL GHJOL LQWHUHVVL GHO GXFD H GHOOD &RPXQLWj SHU UHFXSHUDUH H YDORUL]]DUH OD JUDQGH WUDGL]LRQH GHO SDVVDWR1 ,Q TXHVWD RWWLFD/ VL DJJLXQJH O·DXVSLFLR FKH G·RUD LQ SRL JOL VWXGL VXO SDWULPRQLR PXVLFDOH FRPH IRQWH SHU OD VWRULD GHOOD PXVLFD D 0RGHQD WURYLQR ²²²²²²²² 65 /D YHFFKLD FDSSHOOD GHOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH H OD FRPPLVVLRQH LQFDULFDWD GL RUJDQL]]DUH XQD QXRYD VFXROD GL PXVLFD LQ 0RGHQD/ LQ ©/·$YYHQLUH1 *LRUQDOH SROLWLFR/ OHWWHUDULR HG XPRULVWLFRª/ ,,/ 7/ JLRYHGu 54 JLXJQR 4;93/ SS1 47048> $1 725(//,/ 1RWL]LH VWRULFKH/ GRFXPHQWL/ FURQDFKH VXO /LFHR 0XVLFDOH ´2UD]LR 9HFFKLµ111/ 0RGHQD/ &RRSHUDWLYD 7LSRJUDIL/ 4<87/ VRSUDWWXWWR SS1 :50<<> VXO &DWHODQL/ SS1 :50;41 66 2OWUH DOO*HSLVWRODULR SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH +5RVVLQL q WUD L FRUULVSRQGHQWL,/ VL UL0 FRUGD LO FDUWHJJLR FRQ LO *DVSDUL/ XELFDWR SUHVVR LO &LYLFR 0XVHR %LEOLRJUDILFR 0XVLFDOH GL %RORJQD= FIU1 91 %$==2&&+,/ %/*LOOXVWUD]LRQH GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD% GHO /LFHR 0XVLFDOH GL %RORJQD QHO FDU0 WHJJLR *DVSDUL0&DWHODQL +4;7904;99,/ LQ ©/*$UFKLJLQQDVLRª/ :;/ 4<;6/ VRSUDWWXWWR S1 5:71 67 6XO IRQGR SULYDWR GXFDOH UHVWDQR IRQWL FDWDORJUDILFKH FRQVHUYDWH SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH= 0XVLFD HFFOHVLDVWLFD111 H 6SDUWLWL WHDWUDOL HVLVWHQWL QHOO*$UFKLYLR SULYDWR GHOOD 51 &RUWH GL 0RGHQD/ PVV1/%(02/ ODW1 4<141 $0% 686L YHGD $151 9(1785,/ ,O ODVFLWR H OH UDFFROWH $QJHOR &DWHODQL DOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ LQ ©$FFD0 GHPLH H %LEOLRWHFKH G*,WDOLDª/ 94/ Q1V1/ 77/ 6/ OXJOLR0VHWWHPEUH 4<<6/ SS1 :30:61
/D FLYLOWj PXVLFDOH PRGHQHVH QHO SHULRGR HVWHQVH +VHFF1 ;9,,0;,;,
43:8
XQD FRUQLFH VLVWHPDWLFD H XQLILFDQWH D FDGHQ]D ILVVD/ WDQWR GD DUULYDUH D GHOL0 QHDUH YLD YLD XQ JUDQGH SURILOR/ DUWLFRODWR H FRPSOHWR/ LPSHUQLDWR VRSUDWWXW0 WR VXO SHULRGR HVWHQVH1 4XDOFRVD VL q JLj IDWWR/ TXDOFRVD VL VWD PXRYHQGR/ TXDOFRVD q JLj DSSURGDWR D XQ SURJHWWR FRHUHQWH1 /·DXVSLFLR q FKH WDOL SUR0 JHWWL WURYLQR DVFROWR SUHVVR FKL SXz FUHDUH OH FRQGL]LRQL SHU UHDOL]]DUOL1
,O SUHVHQWH FRQWULEXWR/ SUHVHQWDWR QHO PDU]R 4<<; DO &RQYHJQR ´0RGHQD= XQD FDSLWDOH QHO FXR0 UH G·(XURSDµ/ ULXQLVFH LQ VLQWHVL L ULVXOWDWL GL XQD VHULH GL ULFHUFKH SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH FRQGRWWH VXO IRQGR PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH H LO VXR FRQWHVWR FXOWXUDOH VSHFLILFR/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH VXOOD VWRULD GHOO·DWWLYLWj PXVLFDOH LQ 0RGHQD/ H JLj FRQIOXLWH SHU OD PDJJLRU SDUWH LQ DOWUH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GHOOD 6FULYHQWH1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43::
0$5,1$ &$/25( 9(&&+,
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO·2WWRFHQWR
4 0 ,O GXFDWR PRGHQHVH GL &HVDUH G·(VWH HVRUGu VSHWWDFRODUPHQWH DOO·LQVHJQD GHL ´FRPLFLµ FKH/ GDOO·; DSULOH GHO 48<;/ FRPLQFLDURQR D ´IDUH FRPPHGLH LQ LO SDOD]]R GHOOL 5DQJRQL GD 61 'RPHQLFRµ1 6L WUDWWDYD/ FRQ RJQL SUREDELOLWj/ GHOOD FRPSDJQLD GHL *HORVL/ JXLGDWD GD )UDQFHVFR HG ,VDEHOOD $QGUHLQL/ VRYHQWH QHJOL DQQL WUDVFRUVL RVSLWH JUDGLWD GL $OIRQVR ,,/ OD TXDOH RUD/ FRQ OD VXD SUHVHQ]D/ DYYDOODYD OD FRQWLQXLWj GHOOD 6LJQRULD (VWHQVH DO GL Oj GHOOH UHFHQWL YLFLVVLWXGLQL H/ FRQ OD VXD LQGLVFXVVD EUDYXUD/ UHFDYD OXVWUR DO QXRYR GXFD1 6SHWWDWRUH DVVLGXR DOOH UHFLWH/ GRQ &HVDUH DL SULPL GL PDJJLR VL HUD WURYDWR FRVWUHWWR D UHFDUVL LQ 5RPDJQD SHU XQ DEERFFDPHQWR FRQ &OHPHQWH 9,,,/ ULYHODWRVL VXELWR WDQWR IRUPDOH/ LQXWLOH H SHQRVR GD LQGXUOR D SUHQGHUH EUX0 VFDPHQWH FRQJHGR1 5LIHULVFH SHUz *1 %DWWLVWD 6SDFFLQL FKH PHQWUH JOL DOWUL FRUWLJLDQL GHO VHJXLWR VL WUDWWHQHYDQR SHU UHQGHUH RPDJJLR D SDSD $OGREUDQ0 GLQL/ ´LO VLJ1 'XFD GLVVH DO VLJ1 FR1 *HUDUGR 5DQJRQL EXUODQGR VHFR= *HUDUGR/ LR YRJOLR DQGDUH DOOD FRPPHGLD LQ 0RGHQD/ VH WX YXRL YHQLUH/ YLHQLµ1 )DWWL FHUFDUH GHL FDYDOOL IUHVFKL/ L GXH SDUWLURQR DO JDORSSR H VHQ]D VRVWH JLXQVHUR LQ SURVVLPLWj GL %RORJQD1 4XL/ SHU FRPSLDFHUH LO YLFHOHJDWR/ DWWUDYHUVDURQR OD FLWWj GD SRUWD D SRUWD/ SHU SRL SXQWDUH GULWWL VX 0RGHQD1 ´)LQDOPHQWH VRQR VPRQWDWL PROWR GL EXRQD YRJOLD> VXELWR VPRQWDWL VRQR DQGDWL DOOD FRPPH0 GLDµ41 ²²²²²²²² 4
&IU1 *1%1 63$&&,1,/ &URQDFD PRGHQHVH/ D FXUD GL (131 9,&,1,/ LQ 0RQXPHQWL GL 6WRULD 3DWULD1 'HOOD 51 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU O·(PLOLD H OD 5RPDJQD1 6H]LRQH GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<4;/ WRPR ;9,1 ,O FURQLVWD/L Q YLD HFFH]LRQDOH/ DQQRWD QRQ VROR LO JLRUQR LQ FXL OH UHFLWH HEEHUR LQL]LR +; DSULOH,/ PD DQFKH TXHOOR LQ FXL VL FRQFOXVHUR +55 PDJJLR,1 (JOL QRQ FLWD LO QRPH GHOOD FRPSDJQLD PD XQ SDLR GL LQGL]L IDUHEEHUR SURSHQGHUH SHU LGHQWLILFDUOD FRQ TXHOOD GHL *HOR0 VL= FRVu OD SUHVHQ]D QHO UHSHUWRULR GL XQD 3D]]LD GL ,VDEHOOD/ UHFLWDWD GDOO·$QGUHLQL ILQ GDO 48;<
43:;
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
,O FXULRVR HSLVRGLR/ FKH LOOXPLQD GL OXFLGD LURQLD OD SHUVRQDOLWj GL &HVDUH G·(VWH +PHJOLR OD UHFLWD GHL FRPLFL FKH OD IDUVD GHOOD FXULD SRQWLILFLD,/ QRQ q QHPPHQR LVRODWR SRLFKp SL• ROWUH VL DSSUHQGH FKH DQFKH L 6LJQRUL GHOOD 0L0 UDQGROD/ RVSLWL GL GRQ &HVDUH/ SXU QRQ YROHQGR PDQFDUH GL YLVLWDUH D 5HJJLR LO VDQWXDULR GHOOD 0DGRQQD GHOOD *KLDUD/ DYHYDQR FRPSLXWR LO SLR SHOOHJUL0 QDJJLR LQ JUDQ IUHWWD SHU HVVHUH GL ULWRUQR D 0RGHQD ´j O·KRUD GL FRPHGLDµ51 6H OH UHFLWH GHL IDPRVL FRPPHGLDQWL DYHYDQR DYXWR FRPH VSHWWDWRUL SULYL0 OHJLDWL FRUWLJLDQL HG RVSLWL GL UDQJR/ LQ JUDGR GL DSSUH]]DUH OH VIXPDWXUH YLU0 WXRVLVWLFKH GHOOD 3D]]LD GL ,VDEHOOD/ FDYDOOR GL EDWWDJOLD GHOO·$QGUHLQL/ DOOD FLWWD0 GLQDQ]D WXWWD HUDQR ULYROWH OH ´FRPPHGLHµ SURSRVWH LQ OXJOLR GDO JLRYDQH *LRYDQQL %ULJD VX FXL OR 6SDFFLQL IRUQLVFH SUH]LRVL UDJJXDJOL= ´*LRYDQQL %UL0 JD/ PRGHQHVH/ GHWWR GD WXWWL =DQ %ULJKHOOD/ YDOHQWKRPR GHOOL SULPL FKH VLDQR XVFLWL IXRUL SHU IDUH FRPPHGLH D VXD SRVWD/ IDFHQGR HFFHOOHQWHPHQWH TXHOOH SDUWL FKH RUGLQDULDPHQWH VL IDQQR LQ OH FRPPHGLH/ ROWUH D WXWWL L OLQJXDJJL FKH ID/ IDFHQGR YHUVL EXRQLVVLPL/ TXHOOR FKH ID VWXSLUH q FKH QRQ VD OHJJHUH/ KD FRPLQFLDWR D IDUH FRVWu FRPPHGLHµ61 $QFRUD GXH FRPSDJQLH GL FRPLFL VL DOWHUQDURQR QHO 48<<= GXUDQWH LO FDU0 QHYDOH D SDOD]]R 5DJRQL ´GD 61 'RPHQLFRµ H LQ HVWDWH DO VHJXLWR GHOOD FRUWH FKH DQGz D YLOOHJJLDUH D %XRQSRUWR1 1HO 4933 LQYHFH WURYLDPR ULSURSRVWH VHPSUH ´FRPPHGLHµ PD WUD DSULOH H PDJJLR LQ YHUVLRQH SHU FRVu GLUH FRUWL0 ²²²²²²²² LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOH QR]]H JUDQGXFDOL ILRUHQWLQH/ FRVu OD VFHOWD GL PHWWHUH LQ VFHQD LQ IRUPD SULYDWD H FRUWLJLDQD OD 0LUWLOOD/ SDVWRUDOH FRPSRVWD GDOOD VWHVVD $QGUHLQL/ TXDVL VL WUDWWDVVH GL XQ RPDJJLR DOO·LQGLPHQWLFDELOH LQWHUSUHWH1 5 ,Q GDWD 47 PDJJLR 48<; OR 6SDFFLQL UHJLVWUDYD= ´(· YHQXWR LO 3ULQFLSH H OD 3ULQFLSHVVD GHOOD 0LUDQGROD/ LQYLGDWL GDO VLJ1 'XFD DOOD FRPPHGLD FKH VL ID· RJJL/ FKH q /D 3D]]LD GHOOD ,VDEHOOD/ RSHUD EHOOLVVLPDµ1 *UDGLWR VRPPDPHQWH TXHVWR SULPR VDJJLR/ JOL RVSLWL QRQ DYHYD0 QR YROXWR PDQFDUH GL DVVLVWHUH DOOH UHFLWH OD VHUD VHJXHQWH1 6 /D FLUFRVWDQ]LDWD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHOOR 6SDFFLQL q IRUVH GD DWWULEXLUVL DG RUJRJOLR FDPSD0 QLOLVWLFR QHL FRQIURQWL GL XQ FRQFLWWDGLQR LQ JUDGR GL ULYDOHJJLDUH FRQ L FRPLFL ´IRUHVWLHULµ1 (VVD ULVXOWD TXDQWR PDL SUH]LRVD GDO PRPHQWR FKH TXHVWR DWWRUH YLHQH LJQRUDWR QRQ VROR GDL UHSHUWRUL DQWLFKL +)1 %$572/,/ 1RWL]LH LVWRULFKH GH· &RPLFL LWDOLDQL +111,/ 3DGRYD/ &RQ]DWWL 4:;40 ;5/ YROO15,/ PD DQFKH GD TXHOOL SL• UHFHQWL H GRFXPHQWDWL +/1 5$6,/ , &RPLFL LWDOLDQL1 %LRJUDILH/ ELEOLRJUDILD/ LFRQRJUDILD/ )LUHQ]H 4;<:04<38/ 5 YROO1> .101 /($/ ,WDOLDQ 3RSXODU &RPHG\/ 2[IRUG 4<67,1 'HO WXWWR LQHGLWD O·DIIHUPD]LRQH FKH OD PDVFKHUD GHO VHFRQGR =DQQL/ %ULJKHOOD/ DYUHE0 EH WUDWWR RULJLQH GDO FRJQRPH GHO IDQWDVLVWD PRGHQHVH1 'D OXL VRWWRVFULWWH VRQR SHUYHQXWH XQD VXSSOLFD VHQ]D GDWD ULYROWD D 0DUJKHULWD *RQ]DJD/ WHU]D PRJOLH GL $OIRQVR ,, +LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ &RPLFL/ EXVWD XQLFD,/ H XQD ULFKLHVWD/ GLUHWWD DL &RQVHUYDWRUL QHO 4935/ ´ GL YROHUOL FRQFHGHUH OD VDOD GHOOH &RPPHGLH SHU GDUH WUDWWHQLPHQWR DOOD FLWWjµ + LQ $6&02/ $WWL GHOOD &RPXQLWj,1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43:<
JLDQD/ QHOOR VSD]LR FKLXVR GL XQD VDOD/ H D GLFHPEUH QHOOD IRUPD SL• SRSRODUH/ DOO·DSHUWR/ FRPH FL LQIRUPD LO FURQLVWD= ´$O SUHVHQWH VL ULWURYD FRVWu XQ FDQ0 WLPEDQFR QRPLQDWR LO 6FRWWR FKH j FRQ OXL GD RWWR SHUVRQH HW GXH GRQQH/ LO TXDOH YHQGH XQ OLTXRUH SHU OD PLO]D HW DOWUL PDOL/ LQ YDVHWWL GD VROGL 53 O·XQR/ GD 73 VLQR LQ ;3 HW RJQL JLRUQR GHO FRQWLQXR SLJOLD GD VFXGL 63/ GRSR FKH q YHQGXWR IDQQR FRPPHGLD FKH GXUD VLQ·D XQ·KRUD GL QRWWH/ HW Y·q VHPSUH GD 5333 SHUVRQH D YHGHUH HW DQFR DOOH YROWH GL SL•/ HW q VHL JLRUQL FKH VRQR FR0 VWuµ1 /HWWHUDOPHQWH L ´FDQWLPEDQFKLµ HUDQR FRORUR FKH FRVWUXLYDQR VXOOH SLD]0 ]H XQ SDOFKHWWR SURYYLVRULR H FKH/ GD TXHOOD SRVWD]LRQH HOHYDWD/ QRQ VROR PDJQLILFDYDQR OH YLUW• GHL SURGRWWL FKH LQWHQGHYDQR YHQGHUH PD RIIULYDQR DQFKH HVLEL]LRQL GL DUWH YDULD SHU DWWUDUUH XQ SL• QXPHURVR SXEEOLFR GL SR0 WHQ]LDOL DFTXLUHQWL1 &HUWR WUD L GLDORJKL IDUVHVFKL GHL GLHFL FRPSDJQL GHOOR 6FRWWR/ OH FRQWUDIID]LRQL FDULFDWXUDOL GL *LRYDQQL %ULJD H L OHWWHUDUL FHQWRQL GHL FRPLFL *HORVL F·HUD XQ QRWHYROH GLYDULR TXDOLWDWLYR SHU FXL DO WHUPLQH GL ´FRPPHGLDµ/ XVDWR FRPXQHPHQWH GDOOH FURQDFKH/ VL GHYH DWWULEXLUH VROR LO JHQHULFR VLJQLILFDWR GL HVLEL]LRQH SXEEOLFD GD SDUWH GL ´LVWULRQLµ SHU SURIHV0 VLRQH1 &KH SRL IRVVHUR ´FRPLFLµ R ´FLDUODWDQLµ SRFR LPSRUWD/ FRVWRUR GHWH0 QHYDQR LQ SUDWLFD LO PRQRSROLR GHJOL VSHWWDFROL WHDWUDOL SURSULR JUD]LH DOOD X0 QLYHUVDOLWj GHO ORUR OLQJXDJJLR/ DOOD IDFLOH LGHQWLILFD]LRQH GHL UXROL/ XQLWD DOOD YDULHWj GHOOH WHFQLFKH HVSUHVVLYH1 1HO ORQWDQR 488; L SULPL FRPLFL LQYHUR HUDQR VWDWL DFFROWL D 0RGHQD FRQ PDODJUD]LD GDO JRYHUQDWRUH $OIRQVR 7URWWL/ WLPRURVR FKH OD ORUR SUHVHQ]D WXUEDVVH O·RUGLQH SXEEOLFR71 ,Q VHJXLWR WXWWDYLD/ FRO EHQHSODFLWR GHO GXFD $O0 IRQVR ,, FKH WDQWR OL DSSUH]]DYD/ HVVL DYHYDQR LQWHQVLILFDWR L ORUR SDVVDJJL FRVLFFKp JLj GD TXDOFKH GHFHQQLR LO SXEEOLFR PRGHQHVH/ RPRORJDWR LQ FLz DO UHVWR GHOO·,WDOLD VHWWHQWULRQDOH/ DYHYD SUHVR D IDPLOLDUL]]DUH D WDO SXQWR FRQ =DQQL/ 3DQWDORQL H 3HGUROLQL/ FRQ OH WLUDWH GHO 'RWWRUH H FRQ OH VSDFFRQDWH GHL &DSLWDQL FKH FRQGLYDQR GL DUWLILFL VHPSUH QXRYL OH WHQXL WUDPH VHQWLPHQ0 WDOL GHOOH FRPPHGLH/ GD WUDUUH PDWHULD SHU XQ FDSRODYRUR PXVLFDOH1 &RPSR0 QHQGR LO WHVWR H OD PXVLFD GHOO· $PILSDUQDVR8/ LO PRGHQHVH 2UD]LR 9HFFKL DYH0 ²²²²²²²² 7
$602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ &RPLFL/ FLW1/ /HWWHUD GL $OIRQVR 7URWWL DO 'XFD LQ GDWD ; GL0 FHPEUH 488;1 (VVD ID SDUWH GHOO·HVLJXR QXPHUR GL GRFXPHQWL UHODWLYL DOOD SUHVHQ]D GHL FRPLFL D 0RGHQD QHO ;9, VHFROR1 8 /·$PILSDUQDVR FRPHGLD KDUPRQLFD G·+RUDWLR 9HFFKL +111,/ 9HQH]LD/ *DUGDQR/ 48<:1 /D VWDPSD YHQH]LDQD VHJXLYD GL TXDOFKH DQQR OD FRPSRVL]LRQH H XQD VHULH GL IRUWXQDWH HVHFX]LRQL/ OD SULPD DYYHQXWD LQ SUHVHQ]D GHO FDUGLQDO $OHVVDQGUR G·(VWH1 ,O WHVWR DOWHUQDWR DOOD SDUWLWXUD/ GLVWULEXLWR LQ WUH DWWL SUHFHGXWL GDO SURORJR/ HG RUQDWR GL SUHJHYROL [LORJUDILH/ FRVWLWXLVFH XQ
43;3
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
YD GDWR LQIDWWL FRQWLQXLWj GUDPPDWXUJLFD DG XQD VHTXHQ]D GL PDGULJDOL GLDOR0 JLFL H GL FDQ]RQL SROLIRQLFKH/ EHQ FRQVDSHYROH FKH OD IDQWDVLD GHJOL XGLWRUL VDUHEEH VWDWD LQ JUDGR GL ULFUHDUH OH DPELHQWD]LRQL/ L JHVWL/ OH VLWXD]LRQL VXQ0 WHJJLDWH QHJOL ´DUJRPHQWLµ H FKH RUPDL IDFHYDQR SDUWH GL XQ DFTXLVLWR EDJD0 JOLR GL HVSHULHQ]H 1HJOL DQQL VHJXHQWL O·DWWLYLWj GHL FRPLFL/ FRQIXVD H RIIXVFDWD GD XQD SUR0 IXVLRQH GL PDVFKHUDWH FDUQHYDOHVFKH/ GDOOD QRYLWj GHJOL VSHWWDFROL GL PDWULFH FRUWLJLDQD R VHPSOLFHPHQWH GDOO·LQFDO]DUH GHJOL HYHQWL/ QRQ WURYD SL• DGHJXD0 WR VSD]LR QHOOH FURQDFKH PRGHQHVL1 /D ORUR SUHVHQ]D D 0RGHQD SHUz q VLFX0 UD/ QRQ IRVVH DOWUR FKH SHU DQDORJLD FRQ DOWUH FRUWL DPLFKH/ FRPH TXHOOD GHL 6DYRLD/ R SHU OD YLFLQDQ]D GL XQD FLWWj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´LPSUHVDUL QRELOLµ GHO WHPSR= (Q]R %HQWLYRJOLR H '1 *LRYDQQL GH· 0HGLFL/ YDULDPHQWH OHJDWL DOOD IDPLJOLD G· (VWH/ PHQWUH O·LQFDULFR GL VDJ0 JLDUH GL YROWD LQ YROWD OD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHJOL DWWRUL IX DIILGDWD VRYHQWH DO FRQWH ERORJQHVH 5LQDOGR $ULRVWL91 (· QRWR LQIDWWL FKH OD FRPSOHVVD PDFFKLQD RUJD0 QL]]DWLYD FKH UHJRODYD JOL VSRVWDPHQWL GHOOH FRPSDJQLH FRPLFKH SL• DFFUHGL0 WDWH FRLQYROJHYD WXWWD XQD VHULH GL LQWHUPHGLDUL LQFDULFDWL GL IRUQLUH VHJQDOD0 ²²²²²²²² PRQXPHQWR LPSHULWXUR DOOD WULRQIDQWH &RPPHGLD GHOO·$UWH1 (· IRUVH VXSHUIOXR ULEDGLUH FKH O· $PILSDUQDVR QRQ YD SRVWR WUD L SUHFXUVRUL GHO PHORGUDPPD +VL WUDWWD SHUz GL XQ OXRJR FR0 PXQH ULFRUUHQWH,/ WDQWR SL• FKH O·DXWRUH/ ILQ GDO SURORJR/ SUHFLVD O·HVWUDQHLWj GL XQD PHVVD LQ VFHQD1 9 8Q WHQWDWLYR SHU FRQRVFHUH TXDQWL SL• GDWL SRVVLELOL VXOO·DWWLYLWj GHL FRPLFL q VWDWR FRP0 SLXWR PHGLDQWH OR VSRJOLR VLVWHPDWLFR GHL FDUWHJJL UHODWLYL DG DOFXQL GL HVVL +*1%1 $QGUHLQL/ 11 %DUELHUL/ 3101 &HFFKLQL/ 61 )LRULOOL/ )1 6FDOD, LQ &RPPHGLD GHOO·$UWH1 &RUULVSRQGHQ]H/ D FXUD GL &1 %85$7(//, 0 '1 /$1'2/), 0 $1 =,1$11,/ )LUHQ]H 4<<6/ 5 YROO1 3HU JOL VSRVWDPHQWL H L YLDJ0 JL FRPSLXWL GDL FRPLFL H O·DWWLYLWj LPSUHVDULDOH VYROWD GDO IHUUDUHVH (Q]R %HQWLYRJOLR H GDO ILRUHQWLQR GRQ *LRYDQQL GH· 0HGLFL VL ULPDQGD D 61 )(5521(/ $WWRUL PHUFDQWL FRUVDUL1 /D &RPPHGLD GHOO·$UWH LQ (XURSD WUD &LQTXHFHQWR H 6HLFHQWR/ 7RULQR 4<<61 3HU JOL LQFDULFKL DVVROWL GDO FRQWH 5LQDOGR $ULRVWL/ DO VHUYL]LR GHJOL (VWHQVL GDO 494; DO 4999/ FIU1 $602/ &DUWHJJLR $PED0 VFLDWRUL/ %$ULRVWL FR1 5LQDOGR%/ E1 :1 ,Q VHJXLWR IXQVHUR GD LQWHUPHGLDUL )XOYLR 7HVWL H *LUROD0 PR *UD]LDQL1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43;4
]LRQL/ FXUDUH SDWWHJJLDPHQWL H VFDPEL1 $QFKH SHU TXHVWR SHULRGR/ FRPXQTXH/ VL FRQVHUYD XQD GLVFUHWD GRFXPHQ0 WD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD/ IDWWD GL VXSSOLFKH/ PDQGDWL GL SDJDPHQWR/ QRWH LQIRUPD0 WLYH/ QRQ SULYD GL LQWHUHVVH1 9L VL SRVVRQR FRJOLHUH LQGL]L GL ULYDOLWj DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD FRUWH:/ GL SUHWHVH DYDQ]DWH GDL YDUL FRPLFL/ GHOO·HVLVWHQ]D GL FHQVXUH FKH OL SHUVHJXLWDYDQR/ GHOOD SUHVHQ]D VXO WHUULWRULR GL WURXSHV QRQ VROR LWDOLDQH PD DQFKH VSDJQROH;1 6L DSSUHQGH LQROWUH OD QHFHVVLWj GHOOD FRUWH GL UHFOXWDUH XQD EXRQD FRPSDJQLD SHU LQWUDWWHQHUH RVSLWL GL ULJXDUGR FRPSHQVDQGR EHQH WDOL VHUYLJL< H FKH DOO·LQWHUQR GHO GXFDWR VL VWDYD FUHDQGR XQ FLUFXLWR WHDWUDOH FRPSUHQGHQWH/ ROWUH DOOH SHULRGLFKH VRVWH LQ 0RGHQD/ DQFKH EUHYL WDSSH D 5HJJLR H &DUSL +4943,/ RSSXUH D &DUSL H DO )LQDOH +4953,1 1RQ q IDFLOH VWDELOLUH LQ TXDOH DQQR H LQ EDVH D TXDOL DFFRUGL VL JLXQVH D IRUPDUH OD SULPD FRPSDJQLD FRPLFD ´DO VHUYL]LR GL 61$1 LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQDµ/ PD WDOH FRVWLWX]LRQH ID SDUWH GL XQD VHULH GL LQL]LDWLYH YROWH DG RUJDQL]]DUH LQ PDQLHUD SL• UD]LRQDOH JOL VSHWWDFROL/ FRPLQFLDQGR GDJOL VWHVVL OXRJKL WHDWUDOL/ ²²²²²²²² : 1HOOD SULPDYHUD GHO 493; F·HUDQR EHQ GXH FRPSDJQLH FKH DWWHQGHYDQR GL HVVHUH LQYLWD0 WH D 0RGHQD/ O·XQD UDFFRPDQGDWD GD ,SSROLWR %HOOHQFLQL H O·DOWUD GDO PDUFKHVH 7DVVRQL1 6L LJQRUD TXDOH YHQQH VFHOWD1 /D OHWWHUD SURYHQLHQWH GD )HUUDUD LQ GDWD 59 PDU]R H GLUHWWD DO GX0 FD &HVDUH/ VL FRQVHUYD LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ &RPLFL/ FLW1/ DVVLHPH D WXWWL JOL DOWUL GR0 FXPHQWL SL• ROWUH VXQWHJJLDWL1 ; 6HPSUH QHO 493; L FRPLFL &RVWDQWL FKLHGHYDQR IRVVHUR DQWLFLSDWH OH VSHVH GHO YLDJJLR PHQWUH O·DQQR VHJXHQWH 3HGUROLQR FRQ JOL 8QLWL SUHWHQGHYD OD ´SULYDWLYDµ VXJOL VSHWWDFROL WHD0 WUDOL PRGHQHVL> QHO 4943 HUD LQYHFH XQ FDUGLQDOH D SUHWHQGHUH FKH IRVVH LPSHGLWR GL HVLELUVL D 5HJJLR H D &DUSL D )ODPLQLR 6FDOD LO TXDOH/ GXUDQWH XQ FRUVR GL UHFLWH D 5DYHQQD/ JOL DYHYD DUUHFDWR ´LO PDJJLRU GLVJXVWR FKH SRVVD XQ XRPR GHOOD VXD FRQGL]LRQHµ1 1HO 494< OD FRP0 SDJQLD GLUHWWD GD -HDQ GH /HRQ FKLHGHYD OLFHQ]D GL UHFLWDUH D 0RGHQD> DQDORJD ULFKLHVWD YHQL0 YD DYDQ]DWD QHO 496< GD XQD FRPSDJQLD VSDJQROD GL SDVVDJJLR GLUHWWD D 0LODQR1 < 1HO 494:/ RQGH FRPSHQVDUH FRQ GXHPLOD VFXGL L FRPLFL SHU XQD HVLEL]LRQH VWUDRUGLQD0 ULD/ DYHYDQR SDUWHFLSDWR DOOH VSHVH YDUL PHPEUL GHOOD FRUWH= LO 'XFD/ LO &DUGLQDOH/ O·,QIDQWD/ LO 3ULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR/ OD SULQFLSHVVD *LXOLD H TXHOOD GL 9HQRVD1 1HO 494< JUD]LH DOO·LQWHUHVVDPHQWR GHO FDUGLQDO &DSSRQL/ /HJDWR GL %RORJQD/ VL HEEH ´LQ SUHVWLWRµ SHU TXDOFKH JLRUQR OD FRPSDJQLD GL )ODPLQLR 6FDOD FRQ FXL DOOLHWDUH LO VRJJLRUQR GHJOL RVSLWL )DUQHVH PHQWUH QHO 4953/ SHU OD YHQXWD GL 7RPPDVR GL 6DYRLD/ )UDQFHVFR *DEULHOOL GHWWR 6FDSLQR IHFH ´LQ &DVWHOOR WUH &RPHGLHµ/ HFF1 6L WUDWWD/ LQ WXWWL JOL HVHPSL ILQRUD HVSRVWL/ GL TXHVWLRQL ULJXDUGDQWL FRPSDJQLH SUHVWLJLRVH/ FRPSRVWH GD DWWULFL HG DWWRUL ULFHUFDWL H FRQWHVL1 (VVL SHUz IXURQR/ FRPH VL q YLVWR/ VROR OD SXQWD GL GLDPDQWH GL XQ IHQRPHQR ODUJDPHQWH GLIIXVR +FKH GLUH GHO FRPLFR *LURODPR &KLHVD/ LQ UHOD]LRQH FRO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ GL FXL SDUOD LO 3DGUH 2W0 WRQHOOL R GHOO·DOWUR FRPLFR 3LHWUR 3DROR FKH QHO 4973 ULFRUUHYD DOO·DXWRULWj GXFDOH SHU IDFFHQ0 GH SHUVRQDOL",/FRLQYROJHQWH QRQ VROR OH FRUWL PD OH VLQJROH FRPXQLWj FLWWDGLQH1
43;5
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
YDOH D GLUH FRQ OD VLVWHPD]LRQH GHFRURVD GHOOH ´VDOH GD FRPPHGLDµ JLj HVL0 VWHQWL D 0RGHQD FRPH D 5HJJLR/ FRQ OD FRVWUX]LRQH GHO WHDWUR GL &DUSL H GL TXHOOR GHOOD IDPLJOLD 9DOHQWLQL LQ 0RGHQD1 /·DYHUH DOOH GLSHQGHQ]H XQD FRP0 SDJQLD GXFDOH/ DVVLFXUDQGR DL VXRL FRPSRQHQWL XQ FRPSHQVR ILVVR H RIIUHQ0 GR OD SURSULD SURWH]LRQH/ EHQ V·DFFRUGD LQROWUH FRQ OD SROLWLFD GL SUHVWLJLR DYYLDWD GRSR JOL DQQL ¶73 GHO VHFROR GD )UDQFHVFR ,/ FKH VHJXLYD LQ FLz O·HVHPSLR GHL )DUQHVH/ PD ULHQWUD DQFKH QHOOD ORJLFD GHO WHPSR431 0DOJUDGR O·DVVHQ]D GL GRFXPHQWL FKLDULILFDWRUL/ q SUREDELOH FKH OD FRPSDJQLD GXFDOH DEELD SUHVR FRQVLVWHQ]D FRQ O·DUULYR GL VSHULPHQWDWL DWWRUL FRPH (UFROH 1HO0 OL/ *LXOLR &HVDUH 7RUL/ %HUQDUGR &RULV/ *LR1 $QGUHD =DQRWWL/ H GRYHWWH WUDW0 WDUVL GL XQD IRUPD]LRQH YDOLGD VH QHO 4984YHQLYD ULFKLHVWD FRQ LQVLVWHQ]D GDO PDUFKHVH 'HJOL 2EL]]L D 3DGRYD H GDO WHDWUR YHQH]LDQR GL 61 /XFD1 ,O 'XFD LQIDWWL/ IDWWRVL LQ XQ FHUWR VHQVR ´LPSUHVDULRµ/ ROWUH DG DYHUH DVVLFXUDWH QHOO·DUFR GHOO·DQQR XQ SDLR GL VWDJLRQL GL GLYHUWLPHQWR/ SRWHYD GLVSRUUH GL LPSHJQL H VSRVWDPHQWL GHL SURSUL FRPPHGLDQWL RWWHQHQGR LQ FDPELR/ VH QRQ XQ JXDGDJQR PDWHULDOH/ XQ EHQHILFLR GL LPPDJLQH FKH SRWHYD WUDGXUVL LQ YDQ0 WDJJLR VXO SLDQR GHL UDSSRUWL GLSORPDWLFL/ LQ SULPR OXRJR TXHOOL LQWUDWWHQXWL FRQ OD )UDQFLD/ GRYH LQIDWWL QHO 4993 LO EUDYR ´2WWDYLRµ =DQRWWL DQGDYD DG LQJURVVDUH OH ILOH GHOOD 7URXSH GX 5RL441 ²²²²²²²² 43 ,O SURJUHVVLYR VFLRJOLPHQWR GHOOH JUDQGL FRPSDJQLH FKH DYHYDQR GRPLQDWR QHO SULPR WUHQWHQQLR UHVH GLVSRQLELOL PROWL DWWRUL FRPH TXHO *LDFRPR $QWRQLR )LGHQ]L GHWWR &LQ]LR + JLj OHJDWR DL FRPLFL $FFHVL H FRPSDJQR GL 1LFFROz %HOWUDPH/ PRUWR SURSULR D 0RGHQD QHO 4974,/ OD FXL SUHVHQ]D LQ FLWWj q GRFXPHQWDWD1 6L SURVSHWWDYD SRL D WXWWL L FRPPHGLDQWL LO SH0 ULFROR VLD GHOOD UHFLSURFD FRQFRUUHQ]D H VLD GHOO· LQWHUHVVH VXVFLWDWR GDOOD QDVFHQWH RSHUD LQ PXVLFD1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD L OXRJKL WHDWUDOL/ OLPLWDQGRFL D 0RGHQD/ VL VD FKH OD 6DOD GHOOD 6SHOWD YHQQH ULSULVWLQDWD QHO 4967 H LO WHDWUR )RQWDQHOOL/ OD FXL HVLVWHQ]D SHU OXQJR WHPSR VL JLXVWLILFD VROR FRQ OH SHULRGLFKH UHFLWH GL FRPLFL/ VDOWDWRUL R IDQWDVLVWL/ IX LQDXJXUDWR QHO 49761 5RYLQDYD WUD OH ILDPPH QHO 49;4 SURSULR TXDQGR DYUHEEHUR GRYXWR LQL]LDUH OH UHFLWH GL *LXVHSSH 7RUWRULFL GHWWR 6FDUDPXFFLD1 44 , QRPL GL ´=DFFDJQLQRµ 7RUL/ H GL ´2WWDYLRµ =DQRWWL FRPSDLRQR QHL FDUWHJJL PRGHQH0 VL QHO 497:/ TXHOOL GHO SULPR =DQQL 1HOOL +FKH UHFLWDYD FRQ OD PRJOLH $QJLROD,/ H GL (XVWD0 FKLR /ROOL/ ´)LFKHWWRµ/QHO 49841 ,QYHUR HVLVWH DQFKH XQ HOHQFR GHL FRPSRQHQWL PDVFKLOL OD WURXSH GXFDOH/ GDWDWR 4983/ PD q GL VFDUVR DLXWR SRLFKp PHVFROD/ FRPH FRQVXHWXGLQH/ QRPL GL EDWWHVLPR FRQ QRPL G·DUWH1 $ WHVWLPRQLDUH LO JUDGLPHQWR GHO SXEEOLFR SHU OD FRPSDJQLD UHVWDQR DOFXQL VRQHWWL D VWDPSD +6ROLDQL 4988, LQ ORGH GL $QJLROD 1HOOL H ´2WWDYLRµ =DQRWWL LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD UHFLWD GL XQD WUDJLFRPPHGLD GDO SUHVXQWR WLWROR GL 0DWLOGH H $OHVVDQGUR FRQGDQ0 QDWL D PRUWH1 /D SDUWHQ]D GHO ERORJQHVH =DQRWWL SHU 3DULJL DYYHQQH QHO 4993 H TXL/ FRPH QDU0 UD LO %DUWROL +FIU1 1RWL]LH LVWRULFKH«FLW1/ ,,/ SS1 5;90;:,/ LO EUDYR ´2WWDYLRµ IHFH WDQWD IRUWXQD GD IDU ULWRUQR LQ SDWULD QHO 49;7 FRQ FRVSLFXH UHQGLWH FKH JOL FRQVHQWLURQR GL DYYLDUH L ILJOL D
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43;6
/D FDQFHOOHULD GL $OIRQVR ,9 IX VRYHQWH LPSHJQDWD QHOOH YLFHQGH GHL SUR0 SUL FRPLFL/ PD OD 5HJJHQWH/ /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ SUHVXPLELOPHQWH OLFHQ]Lz OD FRPSDJQLD GXFDOH1 &Lz QRQ HVFOXGH LO SURVHJXLPHQWR/ DQFKH LQ XQ GHFHQQLR SRFR IDYRUHYROH DOOH DUWL/ GHL FRQVXHWL FRUVL GL UHFLWH VLD DO WHDWUR 9DOHQWLQL/ FRPH JLj GLPRVWUz LO *DQGLQL/ VLD QHO UHVWR GHO GXFDWR1 1HO 49:7/ TXDQGR )UDQFHVFR ,, ULSUHVH D SURPXRYHUH JOL VSHWWDFROL VL WURYz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j R LQ YLOOHJJLDWXUD/ H DG DIIURQWDUH L GLVDJL GL XQ YLDJJLR D /RQGUD QHO 49:< SHU GHOL]LDUH OD GXFKHVVD GL <RUN1 3RL L FDPELDPHQWL LQWHUQL GLYHQQHUR VHPSUH SL• IUHTXHQWL ILQR D JLXQJHUH DO0 OD VRVWLWX]LRQH GHOOH FRSSLH )LDOD H &RVWDQWLQL/ FRQ TXHOOH GHL 7RUUL H 5LFKLHUL/ H SRFR DSSUHVVR FRQ TXHOOH GHL &RSSD H $UFDJLDWL471 0D/ FRPH DYHYD GHWWR LO ²²²²²²²² SUHVWLJLRVH FDUULHUH1 45 &IU1 $1 *$1',1,/ &URQLVWRULD GHL WHDWUL GL 0RGHQD GDO 486< DO 4;:4/ 0RGHQD 4;:6/ ,,/ S1 981 'DOOH FDUWH G·DUFKLYLR SRL VL ULFDYD FKH QHO 4996 ,SSROLWD *DEULHOOL LQ TXDOLWj GL FDSRFR0 PLFD FKLHGHYD OLFHQ]D GL UHFLWDUH ´RSHUH H FRPPHGLHµ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´IRUHVWLHULµ1 1HJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL/ SHULRGLFDPHQWH/ YHQJRQR UHGDWWL HOHQFKL FKH UHJLVWUDQR L FDPELDPHQWL VRSUDYYHQXWL DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD WURXSH/ XQLWL D QRWH GL SDJDPHQWR VHPSUH SL• YDULDELOL ILQR D ULGXUVL DOOD VROD FRSHUWXUD GHL JLRUQL HIIHWWLYL GL UHFLWD D 0RGHQD/ GDO PRPHQWR FKH SHU JUDQ SDUWH GHOO·DQQR OD FRPSDJQLD VL HVL0 ELYD DOWURYH ULFDYDQGRQH VXIILFLHQWL SURILWWL1 47 1HO 4:;9 OD IRUPD]LRQH GXFDOH DSSDUH SURIRQGDPHQWH PXWDWD FRQ O·DUULYR GHOOH SUL0 PHGRQQH ´/DYLQLDµ 7RUUL H ´9LWWRULDµ 5LFKLHUL/ GHL SULPL DPRURVL *DHWDQR &DFFLD H /XFD 5LFKLHUL/ HFF1 5DGLFDOL FDPELDPHQWL VL SURVSHWWDQR DQFKH SHU LO 49;</ FRQ O·LQJDJJLR DG H0 VHPSLR GL $QJLROD ,VROD H GHO QDSROHWDQR *HQQDUR 6DFFKL +&RYLHOOR,/ QRQFKp QHO 49<3 FRQ
43;7
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
'XFD GL 0DQWRYD= ´9DULDQGRVL DOOH YROWH G·DQQR LQ DQQR OL FRPLFL/ VL SURYD PDJJLRU GLOHWWD]LRQHµ1 ,QILQH/ GRSR OD PRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,/ OD FRPSDJQLD ILQu FROO·HVVHUH GL0 VFLROWD/ H FLz DYYHQQH LQ VLQWRQLD QRQ VROR FRQ OD SROLWLFD GL PDJJLRU ULJRUH YROXWD GDO GXFD 5LQDOGR PD DQFKH FRQ O·HYROYHUVL GHL WHPSL/ GHO JXVWR H GHO PRGR GL IDUH WHDWUR1 1HO 49<9 /XLJL 5LFFRERQL/ JLRYDQH ILJOLR GL TXHOO·$QWRQLR FKH/ QHO UXROR GL 3DQWDORQH/ HUD VWDWR VLFXUR VRVWHJQR GHOOD FRPSDJQLD GXFDOH/ LQYLDYD XQD DFFRUDWD VXSSOLFD DO GXFD FKLHGHQGR GL SRWHU URPSHUH L FRQWUDWWL/ DEEDQGRQDUH OH VFHQH H VHJXLUH OD YRFD]LRQH UHOLJLRVD SRLFKp ULWHQHYD O·DUWH FRPLFD ´GL WDQWR VXR SUHJLXGL]LRµ H OD FDWHJRULD GHJOL DWWRUL ´VHQ]·DQLPD H SLHQL GL LQLTXLWjµ481 0D FRPH OD UDJLRQ GL VWDWR DYHYD WUDVIRUPDWR LO FDUGLQDO 5LQDOGR LQ GXFD/ FRVu OH UDJLRQL GHOO·DUWH LPSRVHUR D /XLJL 5LFFRERQL GL FRQWLQXDUH D UHFLWDUH VXR PDOJUDGR H GL GLYHQWDUH SUHVWR XQ FDSRFRPLFR VSHULPHQWDWRUH HG LQQRYDWRUH1 6L q ULWHQXWR RSSRUWXQR GHGLFDUH TXHVWR OXQJR H[FXUVXV DOO·DWWLYLWj GHL FR0 PLFL QHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH SHUFKp DQFKH TXL OD ORUR SUHVHQ]D/ SHU WXWWR O·DUFR GHO VHFROR ;9,,/ FRVWLWXu LO WHVVXWR FRQQHWWLYR GHJOL VSHWWDFROL WHDWUDOL1 (· SXU YHUR FKH EHQ SRFR/ LQ FRQFUHWR/ VL FRQRVFH GHL ORUR VSRVWDPHQWL/ GHOOD IUH0 TXHQ]D GHOOH ORUR UHFLWH/ L FXL FRQWHQXWL SDLRQR VHPSUH ODVFLDWL LQ RPEUD/ PD HVVL IXURQR XQ DSSXQWDPHQWR ILVVR/ LPSUHVFLQGLELOH/ PRWLYR GL DWWUD]LRQH QHOOH VDOH WHDWUDOL D SDJDPHQWR/ GL DQLPD]LRQH VXOOH SLD]]H/ QRQFKp RJJHWWR GL LQWUDWWHQLPHQWL FRUWLJLDQL/ TXDQGR DQFRUD O·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD DSSDULYD FRPH XQD YDULDELOH1 1HOO·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL ULFRVWUXLUH QDWXUD H UDJLRQL GHO SUHVVRFKp XQDQLPH JUDGLPHQWR ULVFRVVR GDL FRPLFL SUHVVR LO SXEEOLFR/ H/ GL FRQWUR/ GHOO·DFFDQLPHQWR GL SUHGLFDWRUL H SROHPLVWL QHL ORUR FRQIURQWL49/ q GRYHURVR FRPXQTXH SUHQGHUH DWWR GHO ORUR FRQWULEXWR DOOD YLWD WHDWUDOH1 ²²²²²²²² O·DYYLFHQGDPHQWR GL XQ·DOWUD SULPD DWWULFH/ $QJLROD $UFDJLDWL/ H OD GLUH]LRQH GHOOD WURXSH DI0 ILGDWD D *LXVHSSH &RSSD1 48 &IU1 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ &RPLFL/ FLW1/ %5LFFRERQL /XLJL%/ 49<91 7DOH VXSSOLFD/ FKH SURVSHWWD XQD VHULH GL VFUXSROL UHDOL R ILWWL]L +YL VL SXz FRJOLHUH DG HVHPSLR XQD FHUWD LQVRIIH0 UHQ]D QHO GLSHQGHUH GDOOH GHFLVLRQL GHO FRQWH 5DQJRQL/ DWWXDOH ´3URWHWWRUH GHL &RPLFLµ, q DVVDL XWLOH SHU FRQRVFHUH L SUHVXSSRVWL GL TXHOO·DQHOLWR DO ULQQRYDPHQWR H TXHOO·DWWLWXGLQH DOOD ULIOHVVLRQH FKH IXURQR OD FDUDWWHULVWLFD GL TXHVWR JUDQGH DWWRUH H WHRULFR GHO WHDWUR/ SHU LO TXD0 OH VL ULPDQGD D ;1 '( &2859,//(/ 8Q DSRWUH GH O·DUW GX WKpDWUH DX ;9,,, VLqFOH= /XLJL 5LFFRERQL GLW /HOLR/ 3DULJL 4<7604<8;/ YRO161 49 &IU1 )1 7$9,$1,/ /D IDVFLQD]LRQH GHO WHDWUR/ 5RPD 4<9</ WHVWR QHO TXDOH YLHQH UDFFROWD XQ·DPSLD UDVVHJQD GHJOL VFULWWL FRQWUR LO WHDWUR GHJOL DWWRUL GL SURIHVVLRQH1 0RWLYR FRPXQH GHOOH ULFRUUHQWL FULWLFKH IX FRPXQTXH OD ´FRQWXUEDQWHµ SUHVHQ]D IHPPLQLOH VXOOH VFHQH1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43;8
5 0 'RSR HVVHUVL HVLELWD SHU GXH DQQL FRQVHFXWLYL FRQ VXFFHVVR QHO WHDWUR GL 5XD *UDQGH/ GL UHFHQWH DFTXLVWDWR GDL 5DQJRQL/ OD FRPSDJQLD GLUHWWD GD /XL0 JL 5LFFRERQL QHO JHQQDLR GHO 4:43 VL DSSUHVWDYD D FRJOLHUH XOWHULRUL FRQVHQVL PD QRQ DYHYD IDWWR L FRQWL FRQ XQD LPSUHYLVWD FRQFRUUHQ]D= ´6L GLFH FKH LO 5LFFRERQL/ VXOOH VFHQH LO /HOLR/ IX IDWWR DUUHVWDUH DG LVWDQ]D D 61$1 61 GL DOFXQL FDYDOLHUL L TXDOL QHOOD VHUD GHOOL 44 JHQQDLR 4:43 DYHQGR UHFLWDWR/ H VSHUDQGR GL DYHUH OD &RUWH/ TXHVWD LQYHFH DQGz DO 7HDWUR RYH UHFLWDYD LO /HOLRµ4:1 , SHUPDORVL ´FDYDOLHULµ FLWDWL HUDQR FRORUR FKH DYHYDQR DSSHQD PHVVR LQ VFHQD QHO WHDWUR GL &RUWH O·$QGURPDFD GL 5DFLQH/ GRSR DYHU FXUDWR OD WUDGX]LRQH LQ YHUVL GHOO·RULJLQDOH IUDQFHVH H XQD EHOOD HGL]LRQH D VWDPSD4;> H JOL RWWR ´SDJ0 JLµ/ FXL HUD DIILGDWD OD UHFLWD/ ULHQWUDYDQR QHO QRYHUR GHJOL DWWRUL GLOHWWDQWL/ XQD FDWHJRULD YDVWD H LQHVSORUDWD/ SRFR DSSDULVFHQWH PD VHPSUH YLWDOH1 ,QYHUR SHU WXWWR LO ;9,, VHFROR HUDQR VWDWL FRPSUHVHQWL/ VHQ]D FKH PDL VL JLXQJHVVH DG HSLVRGL GL DSHUWD FRQFRUUHQ]D/ GXH PRGL GL IDUH WHDWUR= O·XQR RUJDQL]]DWR/ SLDQLILFDWR H GLVWULEXLWR VXO WHUULWRULR GDL FRPLFL GL PHVWLHUH/ O·DOWUR RFFDVLRQDOH/ ´VSHULPHQWDOHµ/ FLUFRVFULWWR LQ DPELWL ORFDOL/ SURSRVWR GD TXDQWL VL SUHVWDYDQR D UHFLWDUH SHU SHUVRQDOH GLOHWWR SULPD DQFRUD FKH SHU LO SLDFHUH GHJOL VSHWWDWRUL/ ULFDYDQGRQH XQD HIILPHUD QRWRULHWj/ XQ FHUWR FUHGLWR VRFLDOH H TXDVL XQ DWWHVWDWR GL YLYDFLWj FXOWXUDOH1 /D GLIIHUHQ]D SL• SHUFHSLELOH VHPPDL FRQVLVWHYD QHO IDWWR FKH WUD L GLOHWWDQWL QRQ VL HVSRQHYDQR GRQQH VXO0 OD VFHQD1 5LSHUFRUUHQGR OD &URQDFD GHOOR 6SDFFLQL ILQ GDL SULPL DQQL GHO GXFDWR PR0 GHQHVH VL SXz FRQVWDWDUH O·HVLVWHQ]D GL GLYHUVL JUXSSL GL GLOHWWDQWL +VFRODUL/ JLRYDQL PRGHQHVL H JLRYDQL FDUSLJDQL/ DULVWRFUDWLFL UDPSROOL/ HFF1, SURQWL D UH0 FLWDUH LQ DPELWL SULYDWL H PDJDUL DQFKH D JDUHJJLDUH VHQ]D SUREOHPL FRQ DWWRUL SURIHVVLRQLVWL4<1,Q VHJXLWR/ VRQR LOOXPLQDQWL LQ SURSRVLWR OH QRWL]LH/ GHVXQWH ²²²²²²²² 4:
,O SDVVR FURQDFKLVWLFR/ ULSRUWDWR GD $1 *$1',1, +&URQLVWRULD 111FLW1/ ,,/ SS1 <50<6,/ SUR0 VHJXH LQIRUPDQGRFL FKH LO 5LFFRERQL VL ODVFLz FRQGXUUH LQ FDUFHUH PD YHQQH OLEHUDWR SHU RUGLQH GHO GXFD JLXVWR LQ WHPSR SHU ULSUHQGHUH OH UHFLWH1 4; $QGURPDFD WUDJHGLD GHO 6LJ1 5DFLQH WUDVSRUWDWD GDO )UDQ]HVH LQ 9HUVL ,WDOLDQL1 5DSSUHVHQWDWD H GH0 GLFDWD GD· 6LJQRUL 3DJJL GL &RUWH DOO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD GHO 6LJ1 3ULQFLSH GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:431 /D SUHJHYROH VWDPSD q LPSUH]LRVLWD GD XQD LQFLVLRQH H UHFD/ DFFDQWR DOO·HOHQFR GHL SHU0 VRQDJJL/ L QRPL GHL UHFLWDQWL1 1RQRVWDQWH O·DFFXUDWR DOOHVWLPHQWR/ FRUUHGDWR GD EDOOL FKH IXQ0 VHUR GD LQWHUPH]]L WUD JOL DWWL/ OR VSHWWDFROR QRQ HUD QXRYR +H FLz JLXVWLILFKHUHEEH OD SUHGLOH0 ]LRQH DFFRUGDWD DL FRPLFL GDO GXFD,/ SRLFKp OD PHGHVLPD WUDJHGLD/ SXU FRQ GLIIHUHQWL WUDGX0 ]LRQL/ HUD JLj VWDWD UDSSUHVHQWDWD QHL GXH DQQL SUHFHGHQWL H VHPSUH WHPSHVWLYDPHQWH HGLWD1 4< $ SDUWH O·RYYLD FRQVLGHUD]LRQH FKH OD ULQDVFLWD GHO WHDWUR QHO 5LQDVFLPHQWR/ DYYLDWD LQ DPELWL HOLWDUL H FRUWLJLDQL/ HEEH FDUDWWHUH VSHULPHQWDOH H GLOHWWDQWHVFR/ YDOH OD SHQD ULFRUGDUH
43;9
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
GDOOR VSRJOLR GHL GRFXPHQWL/ WUDVFULWWH D VXR WHPSR GDO &URFLRQL SHU 5HJJLR/ R TXHOOH VDVVXROHVL ULSRUWDWH GDO &LRQLQL53> PD LQIRUPD]LRQL DQDORJKH VL RW0 WHQJRQR FRQVXOWDQGR JOL DUFKLYL VWRULFL GL &DUSL/ )LQDOH/ &RUUHJJLR/ HFF1 ,Q DOWUL WHUPLQL/ QHOOH UHDOWj SHULIHULFKH/ GRYH OH FRPSDJQLH FRPLFKH FRPSLYDQR VROR EUHYL VSRUDGLFKH VRVWH/ R GRYH SRL QRQ IX SRVVLELOH O·DOOHVWLPHQWR GHOOD FRVWRVD RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ D PDQWHQHUH LQ YLWD OH VDOH WHDWUDOL GL FXL/ SHU DOWUR/ RJQL FHQWUR GL XQD FHUWD LPSRUWDQ]D HUD GRWDWR/ FL SHQVDURQR L GLOHWWDQWL ULX0 QLWL WDORUD LQ DFFDGHPLH/ H QRQ GL UDGR LQQHVWDQGR XQ SURFHVVR LPLWDWLYR QHL FRQIURQWL GHL FRPLFL541 0D GLOHWWDQWL IXURQR DQFKH L ´FDYDOLHULµ FKH D 0RGHQD UHFLWDYDQR/ EDOOD0 YDQR/ FDQWDYDQR LQ FRUWH R L FRQYLWWRUL GHO &ROOHJLR 61 &DUOR SHU L TXDOL OD SUDWLFD VFHQLFD ULHQWUDYD QHL SURJUDPPL HGXFDWLYL/ SURPRWRUL H IUXLWRUL WXWWL GL XQD VSHWWDFRODULWj VHSDUDWD/ SHU OR SL• DVVRUELWD GD FHOHEUD]LRQL GL VWDPSR FRUWLJLDQR PD LQ JUDGR DQFKH GL VSHULPHQWDUH H DSSUH]]DUH LO PRGHOOR GL WHD0 WUR OHWWHUDULDPHQWH GLJQLWRVR H FRQWHQXWLVWLFDPHQWH JUDWLILFDQWH FKH YHQLYD ²²²²²²²² FKH QHO IHEEUDLR GHO 4933 SHU PHWWHUH LQ VFHQD D FDVD GHO FRQWH 7DVVRQL OD IDYROD SDVWRUDOH GL ,VDEHOOD $QGUHLQL VL HUDQR XQLWL DL JLRYDQL PRGHQHVL DQFKH DOFXQL FDUSLJLDQL> FKH GXUDQWH LO FDUQHYDOH GHOO·DQQR VHJXHQWH IXURQR GHL IDQFLXOOL D UHFLWDUH XQ·DOWUD SDVWRUDOH/ PHQWUH QHO JLXJQR GHO 4935 LQ FDVD GL /XGRYLFR 5RQFKL VL GLHGHUR GXH FRPPHGLH GL VHJXLWR/ OD SULPD UHFLWDWD GDJOL VFRODUL GL &HVDUH 3DVTXDOLQR/ OD VHFRQGD GD FRPLFL GL PHVWLHUH1 53 &IU1 *1 &52&,21,/ , WHDWUL GL 5HJJLR QHOO·(PLOLD/ 5HJJLR 4<3: H 11 &,21,1,/ 7HDWUR H DUWL D 6DVVXROR/ 0RGHQD 4<351 $ 5HJJLR HUDQR L GLOHWWDQWL/ HUHGL GHO UHVWR GL XQD WUDGL]LRQH GUDPPD0 WXUJLFD RULJLQDOH H FDSDFH GL JUDQGLRVL DOOHVWLPHQWL/ DG LQDXJXUDUH QHO 496:/ FRQ OH ORUR ´RSH0 UH YLUWXRVHµ/ LO WHDWUR SXEEOLFR ULQQRYDWR FKH GRYHYD VHUYLUH DSSXQWR ´D VRPPLQLVWUDUH RF0 FDVLRQH j JLRYDQL GHOOD FLWWj GL UHQGHUVL SURQWL QHOOH SXEEOLFKH DWWLRQL FRO SRUJHUH D Vp PHGH0 VLPL H DJOL DOWUL TXHOOH KRQHVWH ULFUHDWLRQL FKH GD WDOL VSHWWDFROL GHULYDQRµ1 $QFKH GRSR FKH O·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ LQWURGRWWD FRPH DOOHWWDQWH FRUUHGR GHOOD )LHUD/ VL LPSRVH QHO WHDWUR UHJJLD0 QR/ L GLOHWWDQWL FRQWLQXDURQR D ULWDJOLDUVL XQ SURSULR VSD]LR FRQ QRQ PHJOLR SUHFLVDWH SURGX0 ]LRQL GL URXWLQH GD FXL HPHUJRQR L QRPL GL /HRQH 3DULVHWWL H *LXOLR $JRVWL1 $ 6DVVXROR OD FRQVXHWXGLQH GHOOD JLRYHQW• ORFDOH GL UHFLWDUH FRPPHGLH D FDUQHYDOH/ SUHYLD VRYYHQ]LRQH SXEEOLFD/ q GRFXPHQWDWD GDO 49441 6L VD LQROWUH FKH LO SULPR OXRJR WHDWUDOH D &RUUHJJLR YHQQH FRQFHVVR QHO 4983 SURSULR D GHL JLRYDQL GLOHWWDQWL H FKH D SURPXRYHUH VSHWWDFROL DO )LQDOH IXURQR JOL DFFDGHPLFL )OXWWXDQWL/ D &DUSL JOL $SSDUHQWL1 54 (· YHUR FKH L GLOHWWDQWL IXURQR L GHVWLQDWDUL GL SDUWH GHOOD FRSLRVD GUDPPDWXUJLD ´UHJR0 ODUHµ SURGRWWD QHO FRUVR GHO VHFROR/ PD SL• VSHVVR HVVL SUHIHULURQR FLPHQWDUVL LQ TXHOOH LEUL0 GH IRUPH GL VSHWWDFROR FKH YDQQR VRWWR LO QRPH GL ´WUDJLFRPPHGLHµ/ OLEHUDPHQWH LVSLUDWH DO FRHYR WHDWUR VSDJQROR/ DGRWWDQGR IRUPH GL VFULWWXUD DVVDL VLPLOL DJOL ´VFHQDULµ/ FRPH JLj ID0 FHYDQR L FRPLFL GL SURIHVVLRQH/ H FLz UHQGH QRQ IDFLOH DWWULEXLUH DJOL XQL R DJOL DOWUL L FDQR0 YDFFL VHFHQWHVFKL D QRL SHUYHQXWL +VH QH YHGD DG HVHPSLR XQ EXRQ QXPHUR LQ $602/ $UFKL0 YLR SHU PDWHULH/ 6SHWWDFROL SXEEOLFL/ &RPSRQLPHQWL WHDWUDOL PVV1/ E1 7,1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43;:
G·ROWUDOSH L FXL WHVWL/ RSSRUWXQDPHQWH WUDGRWWL H DGDWWDWL/ JLj FLUFRODYDQR LQ ,WDOLD551 6H OH WUDJHGLH GHO &DPSLVWURQ/ GHL GXH &RUQHLOOH/ JLXQVHUR D 0RGHQD VROR QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL GHO ;9,, VHFROR/ ULPEDO]DQGR GD 5RPD H GD %RORJQD DWWUDYHUVR LO FDQDOH GHL FROOHJL QRELOLDUL/ GDO &OHPHQWLQR URPDQR D TXHOOR GHO 3RUWR ERORJQHVH/ IX SURSULR D 0RGHQD FKH SUHVH DYYLR VXO SULQFLSLDUH GHO QXRYR VHFROR XQD YDVWD ULIOHVVLRQH VXO WHDWUR QHL VXRL YDUL DVSHWWL FKH QRQ ULPDVH FLUFRVFULWWD QHOO· DPELWR GHOOH WHRULH PD ILQu SHU FRLQYROJHUH WXWWL JOL ´DGGHWWL DL ODYRULµ1 &HUWR FRQVHJXHQ]D GHOO·LPSXOVR DO ULQQRYDPHQWR LPSUHV0 VR GDOO·$UFDGLD/ HVVD IX LO IUXWWR GHOO·LQWUHFFLR GL HVSHULHQ]H FRPXQL H GL UHOD0 ]LRQL SHUVRQDOL FKH YLGH UDFFROWL LGHDOPHQWH/ H QRQ VROR/ LQWRUQR D /1 $1 0X0 UDWRUL/ DULVWRFUDWLFL DSSDVVLRQDWL GL WHDWUR FRPH LO PDUFKHVH 2UVL/ GUDPPDWXU0 JKL FRPH LO 0DUWHOOR HG DQFKH XQ DWWRUH GL SURIHVVLRQH/ /XLJL 5LFFRERQL561 $ SUHVFLQGHUH GDO WRQR SROHPLFR DGRWWDWR GDO PDUFKHVH 2UVL LO TXDOH/ FRQIXWDQGR OH FHQVXUH IDWWR GDO JHVXLWD SDGUH %RXKRXUV/ DYHYD SHUz SUHVR ²²²²²²²² 55 6DUj LO FDVR GL UDPPHQWDUH/ SXU QRQ YROHQGR DIIURQWDUH O·DUJRPHQWR/ FKH JOL XOWLPL DQ0 QL GHO VHFROR IXURQR DIIROODWL GL VSHWWDFROL FHOHEUDWLYL OH OLHWH ULFRUUHQ]H FKH VL VXVVHJXLURQR LQ FRUWH/ GDOOH QR]]H GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR DOOD QDVFLWD H EDWWHVLPR GHO SULPRJHQLWR )UDQFHVFR1 3HU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD OD GLIIXVLRQH LQ ,WDOLD GHL WHVWL WHDWUDOL IUDQFHVL VL ULPDQGD DOO·RUPDL FODVVLFR WHVWR GL /1 )(55$5,/ /H WUDGX]LRQL LWDOLDQH GHO WHDWUR WUDJLFR IUDQFHVH QHL VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,,1 6DJJLR ELEOLRJUDILFR/ 3DULJL 4<58 H DO SL• UHFHQWH VDJJLR GL *161 6$17$1*(/2 0 &1 9,17,/ /H WUDGX]LRQL LWDOLDQH GHO WHDWUR FRPLFR IUDQFHVH QHL VHFROL ;9,, H ;9,,,/ 5RPD 4<;41 1HO QRYHUR GHL WUDGXWWRUL VHFHQWHVFKL WURYD SRVWR DQFKH *1$1 =DQRWWL/ LO FHOHEUH FRPLFR ´2WWDYLRµ/ FKH SHU L GLOHWWDQWL ERORJQHVL WUDGXVVH LO &LG GL &RUQHLOOH/ VRWWR LO WLWROR GL +RQRUH FRQWUR $PRUH/ HGLWR QHO 49<<1 6XOOH OH SULPH WUDGX]LRQL H PHVVH LQ VFHQD PRGHQHVL QHOO·DPELWR GHO &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL VL YHGD 01 &$/25(/ )DUH WHDWUR LQ FROOHJLR1 *OL VSHWWDFROL DO 61 &DUOR GL 0RGHQD QHO ¶:33/ %RORJQD 4<<31 9HQLYDQR VWDPSDWH GDL 6ROLDQL QHO 49<< OH YHUVLRQL ´PRGHQHVLµ GHO )RFLRQH GHO 'H &DPSLVWURQ H GHOO·(UDFOLR GL 31 &RUQHLOOH/ VHJXLWH QHO 4:35 GD TXHOOD GHO 0LWULGDWH GL 5DFLQH1 56 5DSSRUWL SHUVRQDOL H FRPXQDQ]D GL LQWHUHVVL/ DYHQWH VSHVVR FRPH GHQRPLQDWRUH FR0 PXQH LO WHDWUR/ VL ULFDYDQR GDOOR VSRJOLR GHJOL HSLVWRODUL SUHVHQWL QHOO·$UFKLYLR 0XUDWRULDQR +LQ %(02,/ FRPH KDQQR GLPRVWUDWR L VDJJL GL $1 3$5,6,/ /1 5LFFRERQL +D SURSRVLWR GL XQ FDUWHJJLR LQHGLWR FRQ /1$1 0XUDWRUL,/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 51 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD SDWULD SHU OH SURY1 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 ,,,/ 9,, +4<66,/ H GL 61 ,1*(*12 *8,',/ 3HU OD VWRULD GHO WHDWUR IUDQFHVH LQ ,WDOLD= /1$1 0XUDWRUL/ *1*1 2UVL/ 31 -1 0DUWHOOR/ LQ ©/D UDVVHJQD GHOOD /HWWHUDWXUD ,WDOLDQDª/ /;;9,,,/ V1 9,,/ QQ1 405/ JHQQDLR0 DJRVWR 4<:7/ SS1 970<71 6HPSUH LO 0XUDWRUL VWHQGHYD OH 0HPRULH LQWRUQR DOOD YLWD GHO 0DUFKHVH *LRYDQ *LRVHIIR 2UVL ERORJQHVH +0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:68, SHU FRPPHPRUDUH LO QRELOH DPLFR FKH GDO 4:45 VL HUD VWDELOLWR GHILQLWLYDPHQWH D 0RGHQD1 8QD YLVLRQH G·LQVLHPH GHOOD SUREOHPDWLFD YLHQH SURSRVWD GD *1 *8&&,1,/ 3HU XQD VWRULD GHO WHDWUR GHL GLOHWWDQWL= OD ULQDVFLWD WUDJLFD LWDOLDQD QHO ;9,,, VHFROR/ LQ 8RPLQL GL WHDWUR QHO 6HWWHFHQWR LQ (PLOLD H 5RPDJQD/ D FXUD GL (1 &$6,1, 523$ 0 01 &$/25( 0 *1 *8&&,1, 0 &1 9$/(17,/ 0RGHQD 4:;9/ ,/ SS1 59<064:1
43;;
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
DWWR GHOOD VXSHULRULWj GHO WHDWUR IUDQFHVH/ LO SURJUDPPD ULIRUPLVWD WUDFFLDWR GDO 0XUDWRUL FRQ LO WUDWWDWR 'HOOD SHUIHWWD SRHVLD LWDOLDQD/ SXU UHVWDQGR GL PDWULFH OHWWHUDULD/ VL DOODUJDYD GDOOD GUDPPDWXUJLD DO FDPSR GHOOD OLEUHWWLVWLFD H GHOOD SUDWLFD WHDWUDOH571 ,Q VLQWHVL/ SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD JOL VSHWWDFROL WHDWUDOL/ LO 0X0 UDWRUL/ GRSR DYHU FRQVWDWDWR FKH O·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD VL SURVSHWWDYD FRPH XQ SHULFRORVR FRQFRUUHQWH SHU LO WHDWUR UHFLWDWR/ SURSRQHYD FKH TXHVW·XOWLPR GL0 YHQWDVVH/ RSSRUWXQDPHQWH ULYHGXWR QHOOD IRUPD H QHL FRQWHQXWL/ ´XQD GLOHW0 WHYROH VFXROD GH· EXRQL FRVWXPL H XQD VRDYH FDWWHGUD GL /H]LRQL 0RUDOLµ1 $L JRYHUQDQWL IRUQLYD FRQVLJOL= ´&RWDQWR VL JHWWD SHU IDU WHVVHUH/ H UDSSUHVHQWDUH L 'UDPPL 0XVLFDOL/ FRPSRQLPHQWL VHQ]D IDOOR SRFR IDYRUHYROL DOOH &LWWj= SHUFKp QRQ SRWUHEEH XVDUVL TXDOFKH OLEHUDOLWj SHU DYHU QRELOL/ H SXUJDWH 7UD0 JHGLH H &RPPHGLH/ OH TXDOL RJQL DQQR SRWUHEERQVL OH VWHVVH UDSSUHVHQWDU VXO 7HDWUR FRQ Vu RQHVWD/ H SURILWWHYROH ULFUHD]LRQH GH· &LWWDGLQL"µ1 $JOL DVSLUDQWL GUDPPDWXUJKL ULYROJHYD HVRUWD]LRQL= ´0XRYDQVL DGXQTXH D XQD WDOH LPSUHVD JO·,QJHJQL YDORURVLµ1 /·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ DQFRUFKp FRQ OLEUHWWL YLD YLD SL• GLJQLWRVL/ FRQWLQXz DG HVVHUH DVVDL GLVSHQGLRVD HG DFFDWWLYDQWH1 9D GHWWR SHUz LO GXFD 5LQDOGR VL PRVWUz IDYRUHYROH DOO·LQQDO]DPHQWR GL OLYHOOR GHJOL VSHWWDFROL WHDWUDOL FXL VL GHGLFDURQR XRPLQL GL VXD ILGXFLD/ H FKH OD ULVSRVWD GHJOL ´LQJHJQL YDORURVLµ DOO·DSSHOOR PXUDWRULDQR IX LPPHGLDWD +D FRPLQFLDUH GDO PRGHQHVH $OIRQVR &DYD]]L FKH LQ SRFKL DQQL VIRUQDYD FLQTXH WUDJHGLH, H YDOLFz SUHVWR L FRQILQL GHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH581 3URSULR D 0RGHQD QHO JLXJQR GHO 4:46 LQIDWWL/ GDYDQWL DG XQ SXEEOLFR DWWHQWR H SUHSDUDWR HVRUGLYD VXOOH VFHQH OD 0HURSH GL 6FLSLRQH 0DIIHL/ WUDJHGLD FKH FRO VXR FODVVLFR ULJRUH DYUHEEH GRYXWR VHUYLUH GD PRGHO0 OR SHU OD ULQQRYDWD GUDPPDWXUJLD LWDOLDQD/ WDQWR GD IDU GLUH DO PDUFKHVH 2UVL/ FKH QH DYHYD FDOGHJJLDWR OD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH H FXUDWR OD VWDPSD GHO WHVWR= ´6L UDOOHJUL GXQTXH O·,WDOLD/ H UDOOHJUDWL WX LQVLHPH/ R DPLFR /HWWRUH/ FRPH LQWHUHV0 VDWR DOOD VXD JORULD/ PHQWUH YHGL WROWR DG DOWUD GRWWD 1D]LRQH LO SUHWHVWR GL ²²²²²²²² 57 &IU1 *1*1 256,/ &RQVLGHUD]LRQL VRSUD XQ IDPRVR /LEUR )UDQ]HVH +111,1 'LDORJKL QH· TXDOL V·DJLWDQR 4XLVWLRQL 5HWWRULFKH H 3RHWLFKH/ %RORJQD/ 3LVVDUUL/ 4:36 H /1 $1 085$725,/ 'HOOD SHUIHWWD SRHVLD LWDOLDQD VSLHJDWD H GLPRVWUDWD FRQ YDULH RVVHUYD]LRQL/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:39/ 51 YROO1 $OOD GL0 VDPLQD GHJOL VSHWWDFROL WHDWUDOL VRQR GHGLFDWL L FDSLWROL 9 +´'H· GLIHWWL FKH SRVVRQR RVVHUYDUVL QH· PRGHUQL 'UDPPLµ,H 9, +´'HOOD QHFHVVLWj GL ULIRUPDUH OD 3RHVLD 7HDWUDOHµ,/ GHO /LEUR ,,,1 58 ,O FRQWULEXWR GL TXHVWR OHWWHUDWR H SDVWRU DUFDGH/ RJJL GLPHQWLFDWR/ IX QRWHYROH1 'RSR DYHU GDWR SURSULD YHUVLRQH GHOO·$QGURPDFD GL 5DFLQH +6ROLDQL 4:3;,/ FRPSRQHYD FLQTXH WUD0 JHGLH LQ SURVD +0RQWH]XPD LPSHUDWRUH GHO 0HVVLFR/ 1LVR HG (XULDOR/ $GHODLGH/ 3DUWLQDFH/ /DRGLFH, H XQD SDVWRUDOH/ &ORUL/ VWDPSDWH GDO 6ROLDQL WUD LO 4:3< H LO 4:48 H WXWWH SXQWXDOPHQWH UHFLWDWH1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43;<
ULPSURYHUDUH DOOD QRVWUD/ FKH GL 3RHWL QHOO·RUGLQH WUDJLFR VFDUVHJJLDVVHµ591 $O VXFFHVVR GHOO· DOJLGD 0HURSH PROWR FRQWULEXu OD EUDYXUD GHL FRPLFL FKH VL SUHVWDURQR D UDSSUHVHQWDUOD GDYDQWL DO GXFD HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH GL (OHQD %DO0 OHWWL GHWWD )ODPLQLD/ PRJOLH GHO 5LFFRERQL1 ,Q DQQL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH VHJXHQWL/ SURSRVWH GD JUXSSL GL GLOHWWDQWL/ FRPSDUYHUR VXOOH VFHQH SXEEOLFKH DQFKH OH WUDJHGLH GHO 0DUWHOOR5:1 0D VL WUDWWz GL HSLVRGL LVRODWL SHUFKp L YDOLGL WUDJHGLR0 JUDIL LQ ,WDOLD FRQWLQXDURQR D VFDUVHJJLDUH H GDO FRQIURQWR XVFu YLQFLWRUH/ SHU JUDQ SDUWH GHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ LO WHDWUR IUDQFHVH/ FRQWUDVWDWR PDJDUL LQ YLD WHR0 ULFD PD LQ SUDWLFD FRQWLQXDPHQWH WUDGRWWR/ DGDWWDWR/ DPPLUDWR FRPH PRGHOOR GL VWLOH HOHYDWR H GL QRELOL VHQWLPHQWL/ H DQFRUD SL• DSSUH]]DWR TXDQGR GLYHQ0 QH/ FRQ 9ROWDLUH/ XQ WUDPLWH SHU OD GLYXOJD]LRQH GHOO·LGHRORJLD LOOXPLQLVWD1 /D VXD FRQVLVWHQWH SUHVHQ]D VXOOH VFHQH HVWHQVL/ LQ SDUWH UDIIRU]DWD GDOOR VWDQ]LDPHQWR D SL• ULSUHVH GL JXDUQLJLRQL IUDQFHVL QHO GXFDWR R FRQ OD YHQXWD GL &DUORWWD $JODH G·2UOHDQV/ ´YLYDFHµ VSRVD GHO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR5;/ VL FRQ0 WUDGGLVWLQJXH VHPPDL SHU LO SUHJLR GHOOH WUDGX]LRQL/ H SUHVXPLELOPHQWH GHOOH UHDOL]]D]LRQL VFHQLFKH/ FXUDWH GD XRPLQL +LO PDUFKHVH 2UVL/ *LRYDQQL &ODXGLR 5DQJRQH/ 9LQFHQ]R $OIRQVR )RQWDQHOOL/ HFF1, GL SURYDWD FRPSHWHQ]D/ DFTXL0 VLWD GXUDQWH L ORUR IUHTXHQWL VRJJLRUQL SDULJLQL5<1 (· FRPXQTXH LQWHUHVVDQWH ²²²²²²²² 59 &IU1 /D 0HURSH WUDJHGLD GHO PDUFKHVH 6FLSLRQH 0DIIHL GHGLFDWD DOO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD GL 5LQDOGR , 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR/ HFF1+111,/ 0RGHQD/ &DSSRQL/ 4:47/ $YYHUWLPHQWR DO /HWWRUH +GL *1*1 2UVL,/ S1 ;;;91 5: $O WHDWUR 0RO]D GXUDQWH LO FDUQHYDOH GHO 4:49 ´YDUL DFFDGHPLFLµ UHFLWDYDQR OD 3HUVHOLGH GL 31-1 0$57(//2/ QHO 4:4: LO 4XLQWR )DELR/ DQFRUD GHO 0DUWHOOR H LO 3HULQDFH GL $/)2162 &$9$==, +FIU1 PDQLIHVWL D VWDPSD LQ $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ 6SHWWDFROL SXEEOLFL/ E1 8,1 5; *Lj QHO QRYHPEUH GHO 4:35/ FRPH ULIHULVFH LO *DQGLQL +&URQLVWRULD/ FLW1/ ,/ S1 ;8,/ L )UDQ0 FHVL FKH RFFXSDYDQR 0RGHQD IHFHUR YHQLUH D ORUR VSHVH XQD FRPSDJQLD GL FRPPHGLDQWL> PD GXUDQWH LO FDUQHYDOH GHO 4:69 IXURQR LQYHFH JOL XIILFLDOL GHOOD JXDUQLJLRQH D SUHVWDUVL FRPH DWWRUL QHOOD UHFLWD GL DOFXQH FRPPHGLH/ GD 5HJQDUG D 0ROLqUH/ IDFHQGR VWDPSDUH L OLEUHWWL GL VDOD H FRSLRVL VRQHWWL LQ ORGH DJOL LQWHUSUHWL SL• EUDYL +FIU1 $602/ $UFKLYLR SHU PDWHULH/ 6SHWWDFROL SXEEOLFL/ E1 8,1 $ 5HJJLR LQYHFH OD SDVVLRQH SHU LO WHDWUR UDFLQLDQR FUHEEH FRQ O·DUULYR GL &DU0 ORWWD $JODH G·2UOpDQV D WDO SXQWR FKH QHO 4:55 VL VHJQDOD XQ %DMD]HW LQ FDVD GL ,VDEHOOD $UORWWL/ XQ $OHVVDQGUR LQ FDVD GL ,SSROLWR 0DODJX]]L QRQFKp XQD %HUHQLFH UHFLWDWD GDOOD SULQFLSHVVD LQ SHUVRQD1 5< ,O FRQWH *LRYDQQL &ODXGLR 5DQJRQH/ FKH SHU LQFDULFR GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR VYROVH XQD LQ0 WHQVD DWWLYLWj GLSORPDWLFD/ IX WUD L SURPRWRUL GL WUDGX]LRQL LQ YHUVL H UHFLWH GL WUDJHGLH IUDQFH0 VL/ PHQWUH DO PDUFKHVH )RQWDQHOOL/ FKH SXUH LQWUDSUHVH OD FDUULHUD GLSORPDWLFD/ VSHWWD TXDQWR PHQR LO PHULWR GL DYHU LQWURGRWWR LQ ,WDOLD OH SULPH WUDJHGLH GL 9ROWDLUH/ FXUDQGRQH SHUVR0 QDOPHQWH OD WUDGX]LRQH/ OD PHVVD LQ VFHQD H OD GLYXOJD]LRQH1 3HU DPEHGXH VL ULPDQGD DOOH VFKHGH ELR0ELEOLRJUDILFKH LQ 8RPLQL GL WHDWUR QHO 6HWWHFHQWR LQ (PLOLD H 5RPDJQD«FLW1/ ,/ SS1 4380
43<3
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
FRQVWDWDUH/ DFFDQWR DOOH FRQVXHWH UHFLWH GHL SDJJL GL FRUWH/ GHJOL VWHVVL SULQFL0 SLQL/ GHL FRQYLWWRUL GHO &ROOHJLR 61 &DUOR/ LO GLIIRQGHUVL GL DQDORJKL HVSHUL0 PHQWL LQ SURYLQFLD H O·HVWHQGHUVL GHOOD IUXL]LRQH D SL• DPSLH IDVFH VRFLDOL63> PD q LQWHUHVVDQWH FRQRVFHUH DQFKH LO SDUHUH GL XQ DWWRUH +DQFRUD LO 5LFFRER0 QL,/ VX WXWWR TXHVWR IHUYRUH SHU OH WUDJHGLH IUDQFHVL= ´*OL XRPLQL GL OHWWHUH H GL EXRQ JXVWR +111, OH WURYDQR EHOOLVVLPH> LO UHVWR GHJOL VSHWWDWRUL QRLRVH H LQ0 VRSSRUWDELOLµ641 (JOL ULWHQHYD LQIDWWL PROWR SL• DJHYROH ´ULIRUPDUHµ LO JHQHUH WUDJLFR GL TXDQWR QRQ OR IRVVH TXHOOR FRPLFR SHUFKp SURSRQHQGR DO SXEEOL0 FR VROR ´RQHVWH IDYROH +111, VR SHU SURYD TXDQWR GLIILFLOH VLDVL PXRYHUH DO UL0 VRµ ,O SXEEOLFR LQ HIIHWWL HUD DELWXDWR/ SHU FRVu GLUH/ DOOH ´VROLWHµ FRPPHGLH FRQGLWH LPEURJOL/ HTXLYRFL/ WUDYHVWLPHQWL/ PD TXDQGR DSSDUYHUR QHL WHDWUL TXHOOH GL *ROGRQL/ WDQWR YLFLQH DO PRGR FRPXQH GL VHQWLUH/ IXURQR EHQ DF0 FROWH1 /D YHGRYD VFDOWUD/ DG HVHPSLR/ GDWD SHU OD SULPD YROWD D 0RGHQD QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 4:7; SLDFTXH DJOL VSHWWDWRUL GHO 5DQJRQL FRPH DL &RQYLWWRUL GHO 61 &DUOR FKH OD LQVHULURQR QHL ORUR UHSHUWRUL/ H LO VXFFHVVR VL ULQQRYz QHJOL DQQL VHJXHQWL FRQ XQD VHULH GL IRUWXQDWH WRXUQpHV GHO 0HGHEDFK1 &DVR YROOH FKH QHO 4:87/ DFFDQWR DL WHVWL JROGRQLDQL/ VL UHFLWDVVHUR DOFXQH FRPPHGLH GHOO·DEDWH &KLDUL H FKH JOL VSHWWDWRUL ILQLVVHUR SHU GLYLGHUVL/ FRPH JLj HUD DF0 FDGXWR D 9HQH]LD WUD VRVWHQLWRUL GHOO·XQR H GHOO·DOWUR1 *OL DFFDGHPLFL PRGH0 ²²²²²²²² 43: H 53605381 63 'RSR OH JLj ULFRUGDWH UHFLWH GHL SDJJL QHO WHDWUR GL FRUWH WUD LO 4:3: H LO 4:43/ H TXHOOH SHULRGLFKH GHL FRQYLWWRUL GHO 61 &DUOR/ WURYLDPR QHO 4:4; LPSHJQDWL JOL VWHVVL ´6HUHQLVVLPL 3ULQFLSL (VWHQVLµ QHOOD PHVVD LQ VFHQD GHOO·2UD]LR UDFLQLDQR VRWWR OD GLUH]LRQH GL )1 11 )UDV0 VRQH +FIU1 01 &$/25(/ 'D )UDQFHVFR 1LFROD D &HVDUH )UDVVRQL1 8Q VHFROR GL WHDWUR DO )LQDOH/ LQ $F0 FDGHPLD GHL )OXWWXDQWL1 $WWL GHOOD JLRUQDWD GL VWXGLR SHU LO ,9 FHQWHQDULR GHOOD IRQGD]LRQH/ 0RGHQD 4<<7/ SS1 44<0475,1 1HO 4:4< HUDQR SHUz JOL DFFDGHPLFL GL &RUUHJJLR D UHFLWDUH OD %HUHQLFH LQWUHF0 FLDQGROD FRQ XQR 6FKHU]R SRHWLFR SHU PXVLFD GL ORUR FRPSRVL]LRQH/ VHJXLWL GD GLOHWWDQWL PRGHQH0 VL UHFDWLVL DO )LQDOH SHU IDU FRQRVFHUH O·(UDFOLR GL &RUQHLOOH/ H GD TXHOOL GL &DUSL FKH QHO O:5; VL FLPHQWDYDQR QHO 7DPHUODQR1 ( DQFRUD/ PD O·HOHQFR QRQ q DIIDWWR HVDXVWLYR/ XQ %DMD]HW YHQLYD UHFLWDWR GD JLRYLQHWWL QHO WHDWULQR SULYDWR GHOOD FDVD GL 1LFRGHPR %DVWDUGL +GHVWLQDWR D GLYHQ0 WDUH QHJOL DQQL VHJXHQWL XQ OXRJR WHDWUDOH IUHTXHQWDWR GD LQWHQGLWRUL, H XQ VRQWXRVR DOOHVWL0 PHQWR GHO %ULWDQQLFR QHO WHDWUR SULYDWR GL &DUOR $QWRQLR *ULOOHQ]RQL DO )LQDOH DWWLUDYD QHO 4:85 FROj OD ´6HUHQLVVLPD 3DGURQDQ]Dµ PHULWDQGR FRVu XQD VHJQDOD]LRQH VXOOH SDJLQH GH ´,O 0HVVDJJLHUHµ1 64 /1 5,&&2%21,/ 'LVFRUVR GHOOD FRPPHGLD DOO·LPSURYYLVR H VFHQDUL LQHGLWL/ D FXUD GL ,1 0$0&=$5=/ 0LODQR 4<:61 ,Q HIIHWWL LO 5LFFRERQL/ LQ XQR GHL VXRL VFULWWL WHRULFL +2EVHUYDWLRQV VXU OD &RPHGLH HW VXU OH JHQLH GH 0ROLqUH/ 3DULV 4:69, SURSRQHYD DL IXWXUL FRPPHGLRJUDIL LWDOLDQL GL SUHQGHUH D PRGHOOR 0ROLqUH/ FKH SULPD G·HVVHU FRPPHGLRJUDIR HUD VWDWR DWWRUH1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43<4
QHVL/ L GXFDOL 'LVVRQDQWL FDSHJJLDWL GDOO·DEDWH 9LFLQL/ QRQ YROOHUR SHUGHUH O·RFFDVLRQH SHU HQWUDUH QHO SLHQR GHO GLEDWWLWR VXOOH FRPPHGLH FKH WDQWR DS0 SDVVLRQDYD LO PRQGR OHWWHUDULR GL TXHJOL DQQL H GLHGHUR WHPSHVWLYDPHQWH DOOH VWDPSH XQ OLEHOOR/ LQWLWRODWR 'HOOD YHUD SRHVLD WHDWUDOH/ VPDFFDWDPHQWH IDYRUHYR0 OH DO &KLDUL1 )X XQD PRVVD VEDJOLDWD/ GRYXWD DOO·HFFHVVLYD IUHWWD651 3UHVWR LO OL0 EHOOR YHQQH GLPHQWLFDWR H *ROGRQL +GL IDPLJOLD PRGHQHVH/ SHU DOWUR,/ FRP0 PHGLRJUDIR H OLEUHWWLVWD/ GLYHQQH DQFKH QHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH O·DXWRUH SUHGLOHW0 WR/ SL• UDSSUHVHQWDWR HG LPLWDWR1 6 0 1HO 496: XQ JUXSSR GL ´/HJJLDGUL 0XVLFLµ URPDQR0YHQHWL/ FDSHJJLDWL GDO UHJJLDQR %HQHGHWWR )HUUDUL/ VSHULPHQWDYD QHO WHDWUR GL 61 &DVVLDQR D 9H0 QH]LD/ SUHVR LQ DIILWWR GDOOD IDPLJOLD 7URQ FKH QH HUD SURSULHWDULD/ OD UDSSUH0 VHQWD]LRQH GL XQ·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD LQWLWRODWD $QGURPHGD/ RWWHQHQGR XQ LQVSHUD0 WR VXFFHVVR1 0D O·$QGURPHGD/ FRPH OD VXFFHVVLYD 0DJD IXOPLQDWD H WXWWR TXDQ0 WR YHQQH FRPSRVWR H UDSSUHVHQWDWR LQ EUHYH YROJHU GL WHPSR/ SUHQGHYD VSXQWR GD TXHOOH IRUPH VSHWWDFRODUL FRPSRVLWH GUDPPDWLFR0PXVLFDOL H GL DU0 JRPHQWR PLWRORJLFR0FDYDOOHUHVFR/ FKH VL HUDQR IDWWH VHPSUH SL• IUHTXHQWL QHJOL XOWLPL DQQL1 &RQFHSLWH FRPH HYHQWL HFFH]LRQDOL R PDQLIHVWD]LRQL LUULSH0 WLELOL GL XQ PHFHQDWLVPR ILQH D VH VWHVVR/ VL HUDQR PDQWHQXWH VHPSUH HOLWDULH QHOOD IUXL]LRQH HG HIILPHUH ILQ QHOOD VFHOWD GHL OXRJKL GHVWLQDWL DG DFFRJOLHU0 OH661 /·LGHD YLQFHQWH/ VH FRVu VL SXz GLUH/ GHOOD ´6RFLHWjµ FRVWLWXLWD GDO )HUUDUL H GD )UDQFHVFR 0DQHOOL/ FRQVLVWHYD DSSXQWR QHOOD SURGX]LRQH GL VSHWWDFROL VL0 ²²²²²²²² 65 8Q·DPSLD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH VXOOH IRUWXQH PRGHQHVL GL *ROGRQL q ULSRUWDWD QHO YROXPH PLVFHOODQHR 0RGHQD D &DUOR *ROGRQL QHO VHFRQGR FHQWHQDULR GHOOD VXD QDVFLWD/ 0RGHQD 4<3:1 /D SUH0 WHVWXRVD HG LQIHOLFH SROHPLFD VXVFLWDWD GDOO·DEDWH 9LFLQL YLHQH LQYHFH HVSRVWD GDOOD VFULYHQWH QHO VDJJLR &XOWXUD WHDWUDOH QHJOL 6WDWL (VWHQVL/ LQ 7HDWUR H PXVLFD QHO ¶:33 (VWHQVH/ D FXUD GL *1 9(&&+, H 01 &$/25(/ )LUHQ]H 4<<7/ SS1 :5045;/ FKH FRQWLHQH DQFKH OD ULSURGX]LRQH GHO OLEHOOR LQWLWRODWR 'HOOD YHUD SRHVLD WHDWUDOH +0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:87,/ FRQVLVWHQWH LQ XQD VHTXHQ]D GL ´HSLVWROH SRHWLFKHµ LQ YHUVL PDUWHOOLDQL/ RSHUD GHL 'LVVRQDQWL H SULQFLSDOPHQWH GHO 9LFLQL1 &KH VL WUDWWz GL XQ HTXLYRFR R PHJOLR GL XQ DPEL]LRVR SURJHWWR LQFRPSLXWR OR VL q VFRSHUWR OHJJHQGR JOL LQHGLWL GHO ILQDOHVH &HVDUH )UDVVRQL/ DO TXDOH GDO FRQWHUUDQHR 9LFLQL HUD VWDWD DI0 ILGDWR LO FRPSLWR GL VWHQGHUH XQD XOWHULRUH HSLVWROD HORJLDQWH *ROGRQL FKH QRQ IHFH LQ WHPSR DG HVVHUH VWDPSDWD1 66 6L YHGD LQ SURSRVLWR LO VDJJLR GL 31 3,(752%(//,/ /·µ(UPLRQDµ GL 3LR (QHD GHJOL 2EL]]L H L SULPL VSHWWDFROL GHOO·RSHUD YHQH]LDQD/ LQ ©4XDGHUQL GHOOD 5DVVHJQD 0XVLFDOHª/ ,,, +4<98,/ SS1 4580 46;/ FKH LGHQWLILFD QHO WRUQHR/ FRPSOHWDPHQWH PXVLFDWR/ LGHDWR GDOO·HFOHWWLFR 3LR (QHD GHJOL 2EL]]L/ O·LPPHGLDWR SUHFHGHQWH DOOD UHDOL]]D]LRQH GHO SULPR PHORGUDPPD YHQH]LDQR1
43<5
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
PLODUL/ LQWHUDPHQWH PXVLFDWL/ PD UHDOL]]DWL LQ VFDOD ULGRWWD PHGLDQWH XQ ODYRUR GL pTXLSH/ FRQ VSHVD FRQWHQXWD/ H LQ PRGR WDOH GD HVVHUH/ SUHYL SLFFROL DGDW0 WDPHQWL/ ULSURGXFLELOL/ VHPSUH FKH YL IRVVHUR WHDWUL VWUXWWXUDWL LQ PRGR LGR0 QHR DG RVSLWDUOL1 &RQ OD SRVVLELOLWj/ IDWWRUH DVVROXWDPHQWH LQHGLWR/ GL WUDUQH GHL SURYHQWL1 %RORJQD IX OD SULPD FLWWj D FRJOLHUH O·RIIHUWD/ VHJXLWD GD 3LDFHQ0 ]D/ /XFFD/ )HUUDUD/ HFF1 $QFKH LO WHDWUR GL 5HJJLR/ ULVWUXWWXUDWR H JHVWLWR FRQ XQD FHUWD LQWUDSUHQGHQ]D LQWRUQR DJOL DQQL ¶73 GHO VHFROR GDJOL DPEL]LRVL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOO·ROLJDUFKLD ORFDOH/ DFFHWWz OD SURSRVWD671)HFHUR FRVu OD FRPSDUVD VXOOH VFHQH UHJJLDQH LO 61 $OHVVLR +SRHVLD GHO 5RVSLJOLRVL H PXVLFD GHO /DQGL, QHO 4978 H OD )LQWD SD]]D +SRHVLD GL *1 6WUR]]L H PXVLFD GL )1 6D0 FUDWL, QHO 497;1 )X FRPXQTXH XQ·HFFH]LRQH FKH GRYHWWH DWWHQGHUH TXDVL XQ YHQWHQQLR SHU ULSHWHUVL1 4XHVW·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ GL WLSR ´LPSUHVDULDOHµ/ VFDUVDPHQWH DWWHFFKu LQYH0 FH LQ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH/ EHQFKp D VHUYL]LR GHJOL (VWHQVL VL IRVVHUR SRVWL GXH PXVLFLVWL DL TXDOL VL GRYHYDQR L PDJJLRUL VXFFHVVL GHO WHPSR LQ FDPSR PHOR0 GUDPPDWLFR= )UDQFHVFR 6DFUDWL WUD LO 497<083 H OR VWHVVR )HUUDUL GDO 4978 DO 4984/ VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH GDO 4987 DO 4995 HG DQFRUD GDO 49:7 ILQR DOOD PRUWH681 $ 0RGHQD LQIDWWL O·LQJRPEUDQWH SUHVHQ]D GHOOD FRUWH/ FRQ OH VXH HVLJHQ]H GL LPPDJLQH H L VXRL HQIDWLFL ULWXDOL GD ULVSHWWDUH/ HUD GHVWLQDWD LQHYLWDELOPHQWH D FRQGL]LRQDUH OH VFHOWH VSHWWDFRODUL H DG DOWHUDUH OD GLDOHWWLFD GHO PHUFDWR FKH ULFKLHGHYD XQD SUHVHQ]D FRQVLVWHQWH GL VSHWWDWRUL SDJDQWL1 1HOOD SROLWLFD GL SUHVWLJLR SRVWD LQ DWWR ´GDOO·DQLPR VHPSUH JUDQGHµ GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ SHU XVDUH XQ·HVSUHVVLRQH GHO VXR SDQHJLULVWD *DULPEHUWL/ ULHQWUz LQ HIIHWWL DQFKH OD YRORQWj GL GRWDUH OD FDSLWDOH GL XQD VDOD WHDWUDOH GL UDSSUH0 VHQWDQ]D/ PD LO 7HDWUR *UDQGH GL 3LD]]D FKH QHO 4989 YHQLYD SRUWDWR D WHU0 PLQH/ ULVXOWz EHQ SUHVWR PDO JHVWLELOH/ FRVWRVR H SHUWDQWR LQDGDWWR DOO·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD1 ,O VXR GHVWLQR IX OD VRWWRRFFXSD]LRQH/ FRPH DFFDGGH SHU DQDORJKL PRWLYL DO 7HDWUR )DUQHVH1 3L• VIRUWXQDWR GL TXHOOR SHUz/ LO JUDQ WHDWUR YLJDUD0 ²²²²²²²² 67 &IU= /1 %,$1&21, 0 71 :$/.(5/ 'DOOD ´)LQWD SD]]Dµ DOOD ´9HUHPRQGDµ1 6WRULH GL )HELDU0 PRQLFL/ LQ ©5LYLVWD ,WDOLDQD GL 0XVLFRORJLDª/ ;/ 4<:8/ SS1 6:<07871 /D YRFD]LRQH WHDWUDOH GL 5HJJLR q VWDWD HVDXULHQWHPHQWH LQGDJDWD LQ 7HDWUR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ D FXUD GL 61 520$*12/, H (1 *$5%(52/ )LUHQ]H 4<;3/ 5 YROO1 68 4XHVWR FHOHEUH YLUWXRVR GL WLRUED/ FRPSRVLWRUH H GLVFUHWR OLEUHWWLVWD/ HEEH VFDUVD IRU0 WXQD FRQ JOL (VWHQVL SUHVVR L TXDOL SXUH ULFRSUu D YDULH ULSUHVH O·LQFDULFR GL 0DHVWUR GL &DS0 SHOOD/ GRSR DYHU DEEDQGRQDWR 9HQH]LD QHO 49771 6L LOOXVH IRUVH FKH FRQ OD FRVWUX]LRQH GHO JUDQ 7HDWUR 'XFDOH LO PHORGUDPPD SRWHVVH YHQLU LQWURGRWWR D 0RGHQD PD LO VXR FRQWULEXWR VL OLPLWz DOOD FRPSRVL]LRQH GHOOH PXVLFKH GHOO· (URVLOGD/ VX OLEUHWWR GL *1 9LJDUDQL/ PHVVD LQ VFHQD QHO 498;1
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43<6
QLDQR YHQQH DOOD ILQH VPDQWHOODWR691 'HO UHVWR/ OD VFDUVLWj GL QRWL]LH FKH VL KDQQR LQWRUQR DOOD VXD LQDXJXUD]LRQH H DL SRFKL VSHWWDFROL FKH LQ HVVR HEEHUR OXRJR ILQR DOOD PRUWH GHO GXFD/ q LQGLFDWLYD GHO IDWWR FKH VL GLHGH SL• LPSRU0 WDQ]D DOOD IDEEULFD PRQXPHQWDOH H DOO·HYHQWR PRQGDQR/ FKH DOOR VSHWWDFROR LQ Vp6:1 (· QRWR FKH XQR GHL SULPL DWWL FRPSLXWL GDOOD 5HJJHQWH/ LQ YHQD GL HFR0 QRPLH/ IX TXHOOR GL ´OHYDUH WXWWD OD PXVLFDµ / H FKH WUD OH SULPH LQL]LDWLYH SUH0 VH GDO JLRYDQLVVLPR )UDQFHVFR ,, FL IX OD ULDSHUWXUD GHL WHDWUL/ DOOXGHQGR FRQ FLz QRQ DO WHDWUR 9DOHQWLQL/ FKH PDL DYHYD FKLXVR L EDWWHQWL/ PD DO WHDWUR 'X0 FDOH *UDQGH FKH ULSUHVH DG RVSLWDUH O·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ LQ PRGR SDUFR SHUz= VHWWH DOOHVWLPHQWL LQ WXWWR/ PD JUDQGLRVL H EHQ HVHJXLWL GDL YLUWXRVL FKH TXHVWR GXFD PHORPDQH WHQHYD DO SURSULR VHUYL]LR1 3RL LO WHDWUR GL 5XD *UDQGH R GHL 9DOHQWLQL/ URYLQDWR GD XQ LQFHQGLR QHO 49;4/ SURQWDPHQWH ULFRVWUXLWR FRQ DPSLH]]D WDOH GD RVSLWDUH ´ RSHUH PXVLFDOLµ/ H SDVVDWR GL SURSULHWj DOOD IDPL0 JOLD )RQWDQHOOL/ ULDSUu QHO 49;8/ FRQ OD PHVVD LQ VFHQD GH ,O 9HVSDVLDQR/ GUDP0 PD LQ PXVLFD GL &DUOR 3DOODYLFLQR/ VX OLEUHWWR GL *1&1 &RUUDGL1 3HU LO WHDWUR 'XFDOH *UDQGH FRPLQFLz OD GHFDGHQ]D/ PD SHU 0RGHQD IX ILQDOPHQWH O·DYYLR GL XQD UHJRODUH DWWLYLWj PHORGUDPPDWLFD/ SHU OR SL• FRQVLVWHQWH HG DJ0 ²²²²²²²² 69 6XOOH OH YLFHQGH FRVWUXWWLYH GHO WHDWUR 'XFDOH *UDQGH/ GHO TXDOH SHU DOWUR PDQFD XQD DGHJXDWD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH LFRQRJUDILFD/ VL YHGD $1 *$1',1, +&URQLVWRULD«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u GLVWLQJXHUVL SHU OD JUDQGLRVLWj GHL WRUQHL/ QRQ PDQFD LO ULFRUGR GL TXDOFKH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GL GUDPPL LQ PXVLFD1 /D SULPD QRWL]LD DWWHVWDQWH XQR VSHWWDFROR PXVLFDOH/ GHO TXDOH VL WDFH LO WLWROR/ SURPRVVR GD &RUQHOLR 0DOYDVLD H DOOHVWLWR QHOO·HVWDWH GHO 4984 D 6DVVXROR/ YLHQH ULSRUWDWD FROOD UHODWLYD GRFXPHQWD0 ]LRQH/ GD $1 &LRQLQL +7HDWUR HG DUWL/ FLW1/ SS1 5:05<,1 ,Q RFFDVLRQH GHOOH QR]]H GHO GXFD FRQ 0DUJKHULWD )DUQHVH/ DYYHQXWH QHO 4987/ YHQQH UDSSUHVHQWDWR LO GUDPPD PXVLFDOH LQWLWRODWR *OL $PRUL G·$OHVVDQGUR FRQ 5RVVDQH/ PD LO SUHJHYROH OLEUHWWR FKH YHQQH VWDPSDWR/ VL OLPLWD D IRUQLUFL LQWHUHVVDQWL UDJJXDJOL VXOO·DSSDUDWR VFHQRWHFQLFR H VXJOL LQWHUSUHWL YRFDOL/ VHQ]D VSH0 FLILFDUH GRYH HEEH OXRJR1 3HU TXHOOH WUD LO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR $OIRQVR FRQ /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ QHO 4989/ YHQQH UDSSUHVHQWDWR ,O 6DQFLR/ FKH IX SUHVXPLELOPHQWH OR VSHWWDFROR LQDXJXUDOH GHO 7HDWUR 'XFDOH *UDQGH/ PHQWUH q GD ULWHQHUVL IDQWDVLRVD OD QRWL]LD QRQ VXIIUDJDWD GL XQD UL0 SUHVD GHOO·$QGURPHGD GHO )HUUDUL QHO PHGHVLPR DQQR1
43<7
0DULQD &DORUH 9HFFKL
JLRUQDWD/ DQFKH VH UDUDPHQWH FDUDWWHUL]]DWD GD SULPH HVHFX]LRQL6;1 3HU XQ EXRQ WUHQWHQQLR LO WHDWUR GL 5XD *UDQGH +FKH QHO 4:39 PXWDYD DQ0 FRUD LO QRPH LQ WHDWUR 5DQJRQL, QRQ HEEH FRQFRUUHQWL LQ FLWWj/ PD QHO 4:46 LO FRQWH 1LFFROz 0RO]D YROOH IDUVL SURSULHWDULR GL XQ WHDWUR1 2WWHQQH ´LQ OLYHOOR SHUSHWXRµ OD FRQFHVVLRQH GHOOD VDOD GHOOD 6SHOWD ´FRO WHDWUR $QDWRPLFR LQ HV0 VD HVLVWHQWHµ/ OD IHFH WUDVIRUPDUH LQ XQ WHDWUR HOHJDQWH H DOOD PRGD/ FKH FR0 PLQFLz D IXQ]LRQDUH TXDVL LQ VRUGLQD/ SRL VL ODQFLz LQ XQD DSHUWD FRQFRUUHQ0 ]D/ FRPEDWWXWD D VXRQ GL LQJDJJL GHL PLJOLRUL FDQWDQWL/ FKH WRFFz LO FXOPLQH WUD LO 4:53 H LO 4:55/ TXDQGR LO GXFD LPSRVH OD FKLXVXUD GHO 5DQJRQL +XIIL0 FLDOPHQWH UHTXLVLWR ´SHU XVR GHOOD FRUWHµ,1 &KH YHQLYD ULDSHUWR VROR GXUDQWH OD VHFRQGD RFFXSD]LRQH GL 0RGHQD GD SDUWH GHOOH WUXSSH IUDQFHVL1 0D RUPDL SHU LO WHDWUR 0RO]D/ FRVWUXLWR LQ IUHWWD H SRFR FDSLHQWH/ HUD SURVVLPD OD ILQH1 *LXVWR LQ WHPSR SHU HVVHUH ULPSLD]]DWR/ QHO IDYRUH GHOOD EXRQD VRFLHWj GDO WHDWUR GL &RUWH FKH LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ DEEDQGRQDQGR OD FLWWj/ DYHYD DSHU0 WR DO SXEEOLFR SDJDQWH GRSR DYHUOR XVDWR SHU OH SURSULH IHVWH JRGHUHFFH/ EULRVDPHQWH GHVFULWWH GDO GH %URVVHV6<1 $O GL Oj GL TXHVWH ULYDOLWj WUD WHDWUL H GHOOH SDUWLJLDQHULH FRQQHVVH/ SHU WXWWR LO ;9,,, VHFROR O·RSHUD LQ PXVLFD/ VHULD R JLRFRVD/ H FRUUHGDWD GD LQWHUPH]]L R EDOOL/ D VHFRQGD GHL PXWDPHQWL GHO JXVWR H GHOOD FRQVLVWHQ]D GHOOH ULVRUVH ILQDQ]LDULH D GLVSRVL]LRQH/ ULPDVH OR VSHWWDFROR WHDWUDOH SHU HFFHOOHQ]D QHL 'XFDWL (VWHQVL FRPH DOWURYH/ FRQ EXRQD SDFH GHO 0XUDWRUL1 $ 5HJJLR DVVXQ0 VH LQROWUH OD IXQ]LRQH GL ULFKLDPR SHU TXHOOD )LHUD FKH WDQWD SDUWH DYHYD QHOO·HFRQRPLD FLWWDGLQD73/ PHQWUH QHL FHQWUL GL SHULIHULD IX XQ DPEL]LRVR SUR0 JHWWR GD UHDOL]]DUH SUHVWR R WDUGL XQHQGR JOL VIRU]L H FKLDPDQGR D UDFFROWD L ²²²²²²²² 6; 3HU OD FURQRORJLD GHOOH RSHUH LQ PXVLFD GDWH LQ TXHVWR WHDWUR VL ULPDQGD DOOD FKLDUD H0 VSRVL]LRQH GL *1 *+(53(//,/ /·RSHUD QHL WHDWUL GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD 4<;;/ SS1 4<805381 &RQ OH VXH DOWHUQH YLFHQGH IDWWH GL LQFHQGL/ ULFRVWUX]LRQL/ SDVVDJJL LPSURYYLVL GL SURSULHWj/ FKLXVXUH IRU]DWH/ FRQ OD VXD JHVWLRQH VHPSUH LQFHUWD WUD SXEEOLFR H SULYDWR/ LO WHDWUR )RQWDQHOOL0 9DOHQWLQL0 5DQJRQL0 &RPXQDOH 9HFFKLR/ IX XQ VLFXUR ULIHULPHQWR SHU GXH VHFROL GL YLWD WHD0 WUDOH PRGHQHVH/ RIIUHQGR D ULWPR VHUUDWR VSHWWDFROL PXVLFDOL DOWHUQDWL DOOH UHFLWH GHOOH FRPSD0 JQLH FRPLFKH1 6< &IU1 &1 '( %5266(6/ 9LDJJLR LQ ,WDOLD/ WUDG1 LW1 GL %1 6FKDFKHUO/ %DUL 4<:6/ SS1 958096<1 ,O GH %URVVHV SHU WUH VHUH IX LQYLWDWR DO 7HDWUR GL &RUWH GRYH YLGH O·RSHUD/ FRQVXPz XQ ODXWR EDQFKHWWR QHOOD SODWHD WUDVIRUPDWD LQ VDOD GD SUDQ]R H JLRFz D ELULELVVR QHO SDOFR GHOOH GX0 FKHVVD/ LO WXWWR FRQGLWR GD LQLQWHUURWWH FKLDFFKLHUH H SHWWHJROH]]L1 73 3HU XQD HVDXVWLYD FURQRORJLD GHJOL VSHWWDFROL PXVLFDOL UHJJLDQL VL YHGD GL 31 )$%%5,051 9(57,/ 'XH VHFROL GL WHDWUR SHU PXVLFD D 5HJJLR (PLOLD1 5HSHUWRULR FURQRORJLFR 497804;8:/ 5HJJLR (0 PLOLD 4<;91
/D YLWD WHDWUDOH D 0RGHQD GDO 6HLFHQWR DOO*2WWRFHQWR
43<8
WDOHQWL PLVFRQRVFLXWL GHL GLOHWWDQWL741 'RSR OD SDUWHQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, SHU OD /RPEDUGLD/ OH VRYYHQ]LRQL GL0 VWULEXLWH GDOOD &DPHUD 'XFDOH DL SULQFLSDOL WHDWUL GHOOR 6WDWR SHU PDQWHQHUH DOWR LO OLYHOOR GHJOL VSHWWDFROL PXVLFDOL VL ULGXVVHUR VHQVLELOPHQWH1 &Lz LQ XQ SULPR WHPSR SRUWz DG XQD SL• UD]LRQDOH GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOH ULVRUVH PD DOOD ILQH SURYRFz XQ GLIIXVR DSSLDWWLPHQWR/ FXL FRUULVSRVH SHUz LO GHFROOR GHL WHD0 WUL PLQRUL/ GL &DUSL H GHO )LQDOH LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ FKH HQWUDYDQR FRVu D IDU SDUWH GHL FLUFXLWL WHDWUDOL/ SURQWL WXWWL DG DFFRJOLHUH OD YHQWDWD JLDFRELQD1
²²²²²²²² 74
8Q LQWHUHVVDQWH HVHPSLR YLHQH IRUQLWR GDOOD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GHO GUDPPD LQ PXVLFD /D IHGH QH· WUDGLPHQWL D )LQDOH (PLOLD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD )LHUD GHO 4:56/ H VRSUDWWXWWR GDOO·DWWHQWD OHWWXUD GHO OLEUHWWR FKH YHQQH VWDPSDWR/ GD FXL VL DSSUHQGH FKH JOL DFFDGHPLFL ILQDOHVL/ SURPRWRUL GHOOR VSHWWDFROR/ VL GLHGHUR GD IDUH DQFKH FRPH LPSUHVDUL1 (VVL XWLOL]]D0 URQR SHU O·RUFKHVWUD H SHU OH VHFRQGH SDUWL YRFDOL GHL GLOHWWDQWL GL PXVLFD ORFDOL PD LQJDJJLD0 URQR SHU OH SDUWL SULQFLSDOL XQ GLVFUHWR FDVW GL SURIHVVLRQLVWL QHO TXDOH ILJXUDQR )UDQFHVFR %HOOLVDQL/ *LRYDQQD )RQWDQD/ 'LDPDQWH *XDODQGL H $QJHOD %UDFFL1
3$2/$ ', 3,(752 /20%$5',
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD= LO FRQWULEXWR GHL SULQFLSDOL LVWLWXWL FXOWXUDOL PRGHQHVL
/·+LVWRULD4 GHO 9HGULDQL/ SXU DQFRUD IRQGDWD HVVHQ]LDOPHQWH VX WUDGL]LRQL SRSRODUL QRQ VHPSUH DWWHQGLELOL/ q DG XQ WHPSR WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GHO SDVVDJJLR DG XQD PHWRGRORJLD QXRYD/ QHOOD TXDOH/ DFFDQWR DO SHUPDQHUH GHOO·HOHPHQWR IDYROLVWLFR/ VL LPSRQH VHPSUH GL SL• O·HVLJHQ]D GL FRQVLGHUDUH FULWLFDPHQWH/ DOOD OXFH GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH H GHOOD ULFHUFD G·DUFKLYLR/ JOL DYYHQLPHQWL JLj QDUUDWL LQ WDQWH FURQDFKH FLWWDGLQH1 ,O 9HGULDQL WHQWDYD GXQTXH GL FRQIHULUH YHULGLFLWj H RUJDQLFLWj DOOD JUDQ PROH GL QRWL]LH UDFFROWH VXOOD VWRULD GHOOD FLWWj/ WUDFFLD VXOOD TXDOH VL PRVVHUR JOL VWRULFL VHWWHFHQWHVFKL/ 0XUDWRUL H/ VRSUDWWXW0 WR/ 7LUDERVFKL FRQ LO GLVFRUVR SUHOLPLQDUH DOOD VWRULD GHOOD %DGLD GL 1RQDQWROD H FRQ OH 0HPRULH VWRULFKH PRGHQHVL51 /·HUHGLWj WLUDERVFKLDQD IX UDFFROWD GDJOL DXWRUL RWWRFHQWHVFKL FKH GDJOL DU0 FKLYL WUDVVHUR WXWWH OH QRWL]LH HUXGLWH SHU XQ QXPHUR VHPSUH FUHVFHQWH GL R0 SHUH VX 0RGHQD1 /D SURGX]LRQH ULVXOWz DEERQGDQWH/ PD SDU]LDOH= &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL VFULVVH LQIDWWL QRWL]LH VXOOD FLWWj/ FRPH SUHPHVVD DOOD 'LFKLDUD]LRQH GHJOL DQWLFKL PDUPL PRGHQHVL +4;5;,6/ FRQ XQD SDU]LDOLWj VSLHJDELOH FRQ LO VXR LQ0 WHUHVVH SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH DUFKHRORJLFR> *LXVHSSH %DUDOGL SXEEOLFz XQ FRP0 ²²²²²²²² 4
/1 9('5,$1,/ +LVWRULD GHOO·DQWLFKLVVLPD &LWWj GL 0RGRQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 499909:1 &IU1 DQFKH *1 %2&&2/$5,/ /RGRYLFR 9HGULDQL H OD VWRULD GL 0RGHQD LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD0 ]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª > G·RUD LQ SRL '63@/ V1 : +4<:5,/ 43/ S1 840961 5 *1 7,5$%26&+,/ 'HOOR VWDWR GL 0RGHQD GD· WHPSL SL• DQWLFKL DO SULQFLSLR GHO VHFROR ;,, LQ 6WRULD GHOOD %DGLD GL 6DQ 6LOYHVWUR GL 1RQDQWROD/ 0RGHQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD/ 4:;7> *1 7,5$%26&+,/ 0HPRULH VWRULFKH 0RGHQHVL/ FRO &RGLFH 'LSORPDWLFR LOOXVWUDWR FRQ QRWH/ 0RGHQD/ 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD/ 4:<60<81 6 &1 &$9('21,/ 1RWL]LH GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD GDL SULPL WHPSL GL HVVD D WXWWR LO VHFROR ,9 GL &ULVWR/ LQ 'LFKLDUD]LRQH GHJOL DQWLFKL PDUPL PRGHQHVL FRQ OH QRWL]LH GL 0RGHQD DO WHPSR GHL 5RPDQL/ 0RGHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L/ 4;5;1
43<;
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
SHQGLR VWRULFR/ DEEDVWDQ]D RUJDQLFR/ FRPSUHQGHQWH JOL DYYHQLPHQWL ILQR DO 4:<9 +4;79,7/ 1LFRPHGH %LDQFKL VFULVVH GHO GXFDWR HVWHQVH QHO SHULRGR GDO 4;48 DO 4;83 +4;85,8/ 6LOYLR &DPSDQL SXEEOLFz XQ FRPSHQGLR FKH VL SUHILJ0 JHYD GL RIIULUH DJOL VWXGHQWL XQR VWUXPHQWR DJLOH H VHPSOLFH SHU DYYLFLQDUOL DOOR VWXGLR GHOOD FLWWj +4;:8,91 ,Q HSRFD SRVW0XQLWDULD VL LPSRVHUR DOO·DWWHQ]LRQH GHJOL VWRULFL DQFKH SUR0 EOHPL GL FDUDWWHUH VRFLDOH HG HFRQRPLFR/ FKH WURYDYDQR OD ORUR UDGLFH QHOOH LGHH PDWXUDWH GDOO·,OOXPLQLVPR H GDOOD 5LYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH1 $ TXHVWD VWRULR0 JUDILD/ WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GL WHPSL QXRYL/ VL DIILDQFDYD DQFKH OD ULHYRFD]LRQH GL XQ SDVVDWR RUPDL DUFKLYLDWR1 6L IHFHUR GXQTXH VHQWLUH GXH GLIIHUHQWL YRFL/ TXHOOD GHL GXFKLVWL/ QRVWDOJLFL/ DQFRUD OHJDWL DO YHFFKLR UHJLPH H DOOD 0RGHQD GXFDOH/ H TXHOOD GL FRORUR FKH DIIURQWDYDQR LO SDVVDWR GD XQ·DQJROD]LRQH QXRYD/ SURLHWWDWL YHUVR XQ IXWXUR VYLQFRODWR GDO IDQWDVPD HVWHQVH1 %DVDWD VX GRFXPHQWL GL SULPD PDQR/ VX LPSUHVVLRQL GHULYDQWL GDOOD IUHTXHQWD]LRQH TXRWLGLDQD SULPD H GDOOR VFDPELR HSLVWRODUH SRL FRQ LO 'XFD LQ HVLOLR/ QHO 4;:; XVFu XQ·DPSLD ELRJUDILD GL )UDQFHVFR 9 VFULWWD GD 7HRGRUR %D\DUG 'H 9ROR/ WULEXWR SHU LO 3ULQFLSH GHO TXDOH O·DXWRUH DYHYD FRQGLYLVR OD VRUWH H GL FXL FRQVHUYz VHPSUH VLQFHUR ULFRUGR/ PD FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH DQFKH ULIOHV0 VR GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD FLWWj:1 6ROR QHO 4;<7 XVFu OD 6WRULD GL 0RGHQD SXEEOLFDWD GD $QJHOR 1DPLDV/ RSHUD D FDUDWWHUH DQWRORJLFR SHUFKp DFFRVWD/ FDSLWROR SHU FDSLWROR/ EUDQL GL DXWRUL YDUL VFHOWL LQ EDVH D VSHFLILFKH FRPSHWHQ]H;1 /D SDUWH DUFKHRORJLFD IX DIILGDWD LQIDWWL D &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL H DG $UVHQLR &UHVSHOODQL/ OD VWRULD GHO GLDOHWWR D *LRYDQQL *DOYDQL/ OD VWRULD PHGLHYDOH H GHL &RPXQL D *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL H D &HVDUH &DPSRUL/ PHQWUH LO 0XUDWRUL IX O·DXWRUH SUHVFHOWR SHU LOOXVWUDUH JOL (VWHQVL> OH QRWL]LH GL FDUDWWHUH HFRQRPLFR IXURQR DIILGDWH DJOL VFULWWL GL /R0 GRYLFR %RVHOOLQL H PROWH QRWL]LH UHODWLYH DO SHULRGR GL )UDQFHVFR 9 IXURQR ²²²²²²²² 7
*1 %$5$/',/ &RPSHQGLR VWRULFR GHOOD &LWWj H 3URYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD GDL WHPSL GHOOD 5RPDQD UHSXE0 EOLFD VLQR DO 4:<9/ 0RGHQD/ &DSSHOOL/ 4;791 8 11 %,$1&+,/ , GXFDWL HVWHQVL GDO 4;48 DO 4;83/ 7RULQR/ 6RF1 (G1 ,WDOLDQD/ 4;851 9 61 &$03$1,/ &RPSHQGLR GHOOD VWRULD GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6RF1 7LS1/ 4;:8 +ULVW1 DQDVW1/ 0R0 GHQD/ (G1 $OGLQH/ 4<:9,1 : 71 %$<$5' '( 92/2/ 9LWD GL )UDQFHVFR 9/ 'XFD GL 0RGHQD +4;4<04;:8,/ 0RGHQD0 7RULQR00LODQR/ ,PP1 &RQF1/ 0DULHWWL/ 3DJOLDQL/ 4;:;04;;81 /D PRQRJUDILD q VWDWD ULSXEEOLFD0 WD QHO 4<;6 GDOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVL QHOOD VHULH ´%LEOLRWHFDµ1 ; 6WRULD GL 0RGHQD H GHL SDHVL FLUFRVWDQWL GDOOH RULJLQL VLQR DO 4;93/ D FXUD GL $1 1$0,$6/ 0RGH0 QD/ 1DPLDV/ 4;<7 +ULVW1 DQDVW1/ %RORJQD/ $WHVD/ 4<;:,1
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
43<<
WUDWWH GDOO·RSHUD VWRULFD GL 1LFRPHGH %LDQFKL1 &RPH LO 1DPLDV DIIHUPD QHOOD SUHID]LRQH/ PDQFDQGR 0RGHQD GL XQD VXD VWRULD/ FKH JLj WDQWH DOWUH FLWWj YL0 FLQH DYHYDQR/ ´LO WUDU IXRUL 111 XQ·RSHUD DUPRQLFD HG RUJDQLFD/ VDUHEEH YHUD0 PHQWH XQ·LPSUHVD EHOOD H JORULRVDµ/ PD VXSHULRUH DOOH VXH IRU]H> O·$XWRUH q GXQTXH ULFRUVR D TXDOFRVD GL SL• IDFLOH H GL SL• PRGHVWR/ PD XJXDOPHQWH GL JUDQGH XWLOLWj/ LQ DWWHVD GL TXHOO·RSHUD RULJLQDOH H QXRYD FKH QRQ q PDL VWDWD SURGRWWD/ DO SXQWR FKH OD VWRULD GHO 1DPLDV q DQFRUD RJJL VWUXPHQWR GL ULFHU0 FD1 8QR VWXGLR VXOOD VWRULD GL 0RGHQD FRQGRWWR GD &HVDUH &DPSRUL QRQ q PDL VWDWR SXEEOLFDWR HG q RJJL FRQVHUYDWR DXWRJUDIR SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD GL 0RGHQD1 ,O OLYHOOR VL q PDQWHQXWR PRGHVWR DQFKH QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO 1RYHFHQWR/ VH SHQVLDPR DOOD EL]]DUUD 0RGHQD G·XQD YROWD GL $UWXUR 5DEHWWL +4<69,/ XQD ´VWRULDµ WXWWD SDUWLFRODUH/ OHJDWD DG DVSHWWL PLQXWL H FXULRVL GHOOD YLWD FLWWDGLQD FRQWHPSRUDQHD/ FRQ VLPSDWLFL DQHGGRWL H ULFRUGL SHUVRQDOL/ FRQ TXDOFKH UL0 PLQLVFHQ]D GHOO·HSRFD SDVVDWD/ VRSUDWWXWWR LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOD ILJXUH GL &LUR 0HQRWWL H GHL 'XFKL<1 /·DQQR VXFFHVVLYR XVFu LO SUHFLVR/ PD DOTXDQWR VXFFLQ0 WR/ SURILOR VWRULFR GL (PLOLR 3DROR 9LFLQL +4<6:,43> ELVRJQD DWWHQGHUH ILQR DO 4<94/ FHQWHQDULR GHOO·8QLWj G·,WDOLD/ SHUFKp 0RGHQD DEELD SHU O·RFFDVLRQH D FXUD GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD/ OD SULPD RSHUD VWRULFD DPSLD/ VHULD H VLJQLILFDWLYD/ DQFKH VH SDU]LDOH/ SHUFKp UHODWLYD DG XQ DUFR WHPSRUDOH GHOLPL0 WDWR= 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH GL /XLJL $PRUWK441 /D ULFFKH]]D GL LQIRUPD]LRQL/ GL GR0 FXPHQWL H GL ULIHULPHQWL ELEOLRJUDILFL/ SXU QHOOD FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GL XQ SHULRGR FURQRORJLFDPHQWH ULVWUHWWR DOOD SUHVHQ]D HVWHQVH LQ 0RGHQD/ ID GL TXHVW·RSH0 UD DQFRUD RJJL XQ YDOLGR VWUXPHQWR GL FRQVXOWD]LRQH H GL VWXGLR1 'RSR OH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GL GRQ 3DVTXLQR )LRUHQ]L45/ GL $OEHUWR %DUELHUL46/ GL GRQ $QWRQLQR /HRQHOOL47/ WXWWH GHO 4<98/ H OD VWRULD GL *LDQFDUOR 6LOLQJDUGL GHO 4<:3/ GHVWLQDWH VRSUDWWXWWR DJOL VWXGHQWL/ QHO 4<:4 q XVFLWD/ D FXUD GL ²²²²²²²² <
$1 5$%(77,/ 0RGHQD G·XQD YROWD/ 5RPD/ )RUPLJJLQL/ 4<691 (131 9,&,1,/ 3URILOR VWRULFR GHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6RF1 7LS1 0RGHQHVH/ 4<6:1 44 /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH= VWRULD GL 0RGHQD H GHL VXRL GXFKL GDO 48<; DO 4;93/ 0LODQR/ 0DUWHOOR/ 4<941 /·RSHUD q VWDWD ULVWDPSDWD QHO 4<9: HG q XVFLWD LQ XQD QXRYD HGL]LRQH D FXUD GHOOD %DQFD 3RSRODUH GHOO·(PLOLD QHO 4<<91 45 31 ),25(1=,/ 0RGHQD1 6WRULD LOOXVWUDWD/ 0RGHQD/ 6171(101/ 4<981 46 $1 %$5%,(5,/ 0RGHQD LHUL H RJJL/ 0RGHQD/ 6171(101/ 4<981 47 $1 /(21(//,/ /D VWRULD GL 0RGHQD QDUUDWD DL UDJD]]L GL WXWWH OH HWj/ 3DUPD/ 61,1&1/ 4<981 43
4433
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
*LRUGDQR %HUWX]]L/ 0RGHQD1 9LFHQGH H 3URWDJRQLVWL48/ XQD YDOLGD UDFFROWD GL VDJ0 JL GL DXWRUL YDUL VX DVSHWWL GLVSDUDWL GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD FLWWj1 8OWLPD/ SHU RUGLQH FURQRORJLFR/ D GLVWDQ]D GL YHQW·DQQL/ q OD 6WRULD LOOXVWUDWD GL 0RGHQD/ GDOOD SUHLVWRULD DL JLRUQL QRVWUL/ SXEEOLFDWD QHO 4<<30<4 D FXUD GL 3DROR *ROLQHOOL H GL *LXOLDQR 0X]]LROL49/ FKH FRVWLWXLVFH XQ·RWWLPD VLQWHVL GL ULJRUH VFLHQWLILFR H GL YRORQWj GL GLYXOJD]LRQH1 1HOOD FROODQD ´6WRULD GHOOH FLWWj LWD0 OLDQHµ GHOOD /DWHU]D q VWDWD SXEEOLFDWD QHO 4<<6 OD PRQRJUDILD 0RGHQD GL *LX0 OLDQR 0X]]LROL4:/ FRQ OD TXDOH O·DXWRUH RIIUH XQ FRQWULEXWR DOOH FRQRVFHQ]H HFRQRPLFKH/ SROLWLFKH/ VRFLDOL GHOOD FLWWj LQ HWj SRVW0XQLWDULD/ QHOO·LQWHQWR GL RIIULUH XQ FRPSOHWDPHQWR GHO TXDGUR VWRULFR FLWWDGLQR FRQ LO SULPR VWXGLR VXOO·HSRFD SL• UHFHQWH H FRQWHPSRUDQHD1 /D FRQVXOWD]LRQH GHOOH IRQWL PDQRVFULWWH FRQVHUYDWH LQ DUFKLYL H ELEOLRWH0 FKH q GLYHQXWD QHJOL XOWLPL WUHQW·DQQL VHPSUH SL• LQWHQVD H YLYDFH/ FRPH WH0 VWLPRQLD O·DXPHQWDWD DIIOXHQ]D GL VWXGLRVL QHOOH VDOH GL VWXGLR GL DUFKLYL H EL0 EOLRWHFKH1 6WXGL GL LQWHUHVVH ORFDOH YHQJRQR VYROWL VHPSUH SL• IUHTXHQWHPHQ0 WH DQFKH DOO·LQWHUQR GL YDUL LVWLWXWL FXOWXUDOL FLWWDGLQL/ VWDWDOL H QRQ/ FKH DWWUD0 YHUVR O·DWWLYLWj GL ULFHUFD VL VRQR XOWHULRUPHQWH DYYLFLQDWL DO SXEEOLFR/ VL VRQR LQVHULWL SL• FRQFUHWDPHQWH QHOOD YLWD GHOOD FLWWj/ IDFHQGR FRQRVFHUH DL 0RGH0 QHVL/ H TXLQGL YDORUL]]DQGROR/ LO SURSULR SDWULPRQLR OLEUDULR/ DUWLVWLFR H GR0 FXPHQWDULR/ DQFKH WUDPLWH O·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GL PRVWUH1 2JQXQR GL HVVL KD QD0 WXUDOPHQWH DSSURIRQGLWR DVSHWWL SDUWLFRODUL GHOOD VWRULD FLWWDGLQD/ LQ UHOD]LRQH DOOH VLQJROH FRPSHWHQ]H H DOOH UDFFROWH FRQVHUYDWH1 6L ULFRUGDQR TXL OH DWWLYLWj SL• VLJQLILFDWLYH VYROWH GDL SULQFLSDOL ,VWLWXWL FLWWDGLQL/ QDWXUDOPHQWH VHQ]D OD SUHWHVD GL IRUQLUH XQD ELEOLRJUDILD HVDXVWLYD/ PD VROWDQWR FRQ O·LQWHQWR GL SUH0 VHQWDUH XQ SDQRUDPD GHJOL VWXGL ILQR DG RJJL VYROWL VXOOD 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH/ XQD VRUWD GL JXLGD ELEOLRJUDILFD RULHQWDWLYD SHU JOL VWXGLRVL/ DO ILQH GL LQGLYL0 GXDUH JOL DPELWL GL ULFHUFD GD DSSURIRQGLUH PDJJLRUPHQWH R GD DIIURQWDUH SHU OD SULPD YROWD/ DJJLXQJHQGR DOOH JLj HVLVWHQWL GHOOH WHVVHUH QXRYH QHOOD SUR0 VSHWWLYD GL DUULFFKLUH LO PRVDLFR GHOOD VWRULD PRGHQHVH1 1HJOL DQQL 2WWDQWD/ OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH KD SDUWHFLSDWR DOOH FHOHEUD]LRQL GH ´,O 6HWWHFHQWR HVWHQVHµ QRQ VROWDQWR FRQ O·DOOHVWLPHQWR GHOOD PRVWUD ´/D 7L0 SRJUDILD 6ROLDQL LQ GXH VHFROL GL DWWLYLWj1 0RGHQD 497904;33µ/ GL FXL q XVFLWR ²²²²²²²² 48
0RGHQD1 9LFHQGH H SURWDJRQLVWL/ D FXUD GL *1 %(578==,/ %RORJQD/ (GLVRQ/ 4<:41 6WRULD LOOXVWUDWD GL 0RGHQD/ D FXUD GL 31 *2/,1(//, H *1 08==,2/,/ 0LODQR/ 1XRYD HGL0 WRULDOH $LHS/ 4<<30<41 4: *1 08==,2/,/ 0RGHQD/ %DUL/ /DWHU]D/ 4<<61 49
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
4434
XQ VHPSOLFH FDWDORJR VHJQDOHWLFR GHL SH]]L HVSRVWL +4<;9,4;/ PD DQFKH FRQ OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH/ FXUDWD GD (UQHVWR 0LODQR/ /DYRUL SUHSDUDWRUL SHU JOL $QQDOL GHOOD 7LSRJUDILD 6ROLDQL +4<;9,4</ FKH KD ULFRVWUXLWR OD YLWD GHOOD 6WDPSHULD 'XFDOH1 &RQ XQD PRVWUD H UHODWLYR FDWDORJR53/ FRQ XQ YROXPHWWR GHOOD VHULH ´1XRYL 3URILOLµ/ D FXUD GHOOD VRWWRVFULWWD54/ H XQD PLVFHOODQHD GL VWXGL55 GL UHFHQWLVVL0 PD SXEEOLFD]LRQH/ H FKH VDUj SURVVLPDPHQWH SUHVHQWDWD LQ %LEOLRWHFD QHOO·DPELWR GHOOD 6HWWLPDQD SHU L %HQL &XOWXUDOL/ O·(VWHQVH KD ULFRUGDWR LO VH0 FRQGR FHQWHQDULR GHOOD PRUWH GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ LO ELEOLRWHFDULR FKH KD FXUDWR H VYLOXSSDWR OD %LEOLRWHFD 'XFDOH/ DGHJXDQGROD DOOH QXRYH HVLJHQ]H GL XQD FDSLWDOH1 1HOOD FROODQD ´,O JLDUGLQR GHOOH (VSHULGLµ/ GLUHWWD GD (UQHVWR 0LODQR/ XVFLUj HQWUR O·DQQR/ R DO PDVVLPR DJOL LQL]L GHO ¶<</ LO YROXPH GL VDJJL FKH DFFRPSDJQHUj/ FRPH LO SULPR UHODWLYR DOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH GL )HUUDUD/ OD QXRYD PRVWUD VXOOD FRUWH HVWHQVH GL 0RGHQD/ QHOO·DPELWR GHOOH FHOHEUD]LRQL GL ´0RGHQD &DSLWDOHµ1 /D 6RSULQWHQGHQ]D DL %HQL 6WRULFL H $UWLVWLFL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR KD SXEEOLFDWR QHO 4<;9/ SHU OH FHOHEUD]LRQL GHO 6HWWHFHQWR HVWHQVH/ /·DUWH GHJOL (VWHQVL56 H , OHJQL LQFLVL GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH57/ FDWDORJKL GHOOH UHODWLYH PRVWUH/ GHOOH TXDOL OD VHFRQGD KD IDWWR FRQRVFHUH D XQ SL• DPSLR SXEEOLFR OD ULFFD UDFFROWD GHL OH0 JQL 6ROLDQL1 1HO 4<<7 *DHWDQR *KLUDOGL KD UHDOL]]DWR LO FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD 3DUYD SLFWXUD58/ VSRQVRUL]]DWD GDOOD &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 9LJQROD FRPH OD VXFFHVVLYD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHO 4<<9/ D FXUD GL -DGUDQND %HQWLQL/ 6FXOWXUH D &RUWH 591 1HOOD FROODQD ´0DWHULDOL SHU OD VWRULD GL 0RGHQD PHGLHYDOH H PRGHUQDµ GL ²²²²²²²² 4;/D
7LSRJUDILD 6ROLDQL LQ GXH VHFROL GL DWWLYLWj1 0RGHQD 497904;3310RVWUD GRFXPHQWDULR0 ELEOLRJUDILFD/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<;91 4< /DYRUL SUHSDUDWRUL SHU JOL $QQDOL GHOOD 7LSRJUDILD 6ROLDQL/ D FXUD GL (1 0,/$12/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<;91 53 *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL1 0RVWUD GRFXPHQWDULR0ELEOLRJUDILFD/ 0RGHQD/ ,O %XOLQR/ 4<<91 54 31 ', 3,(752 /20%$5',/ *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ 5LPLQL/ /XLVq/ 4<<91 55 *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL1 0LVFHOODQHD GL VWXGL/ D FXUD GL $151 9(1785, %$5%2/,1,/ 0RGHQD/ ,O %XOLQR/ 4<<:1 56 /·DUWH GHJOL (VWHQVL= OD SLWWXUD GHO 6HLFHQWR H GHO 6HWWHFHQWR D 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;91 57 , OHJQL LQFLVL GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH= TXDWWUR VHFROL GL VWDPSD QHOO·,WDOLD VHWWHQWULRQDOH/ 0RGHQD/ &RRSWLS/ 4<;91 58 3DUYD SLFWXUD= SLFFROD TXDGUHULD HVWHQVH/ D FXUD GL *1 *+,5$/',/ >0RGHQD@/ *DOOHULD HVWHQ0 VH> >9LJQROD@/ )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 9LJQROD/ 4<<71 59 6FXOWXUH D FRUWH1 7HUUHFRWWH/ PDUPL/ JHVVL GHOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH GDO ;9, DO ;,; VHFROR/ D FXUD GL -1 %(17,1,/ 0RGHQD/ *DOOHULD (VWHQVH> 9LJQROD/ )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 9LJQROD/ >4<<9@1
4435
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
)UDQFR &RVLPR 3DQLQL (GLWRUH VRQR XVFLWH OH WUDVFUL]LRQL GL YDUL LQYHQWDUL VHL0VHWWHFHQWHVFKL FRQVHUYDWL SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H UHODWLYL DOOD *DOOHULD (VWHQVH1 $O 4<;9 ULVDOJRQR /·LQYHQWDULR 4::4 GHOO·DUUHGR GHO 3DOD]]R 'XFDOH GL 0RGHQD FRQ LQTXDGUDPHQWR VWRULFR H LOOXVWUD]LRQH GL )LOLSSR 9DOHQWL H GL 3DWUL]LD &XUWL5:/ 'HVFUL]LRQH GHOOH SLWWXUH HVLVWHQWL LQ 0RGHQD QHOO·HVWHQVH 'XFDO *DOOHULD +4:77, GL 3LHWUR (UFROH *KHUDUGL/ D FXUD GL *LRUJLR %RQVDQWL5;/ $UWL0 JLDQDWR H RJJHWWL GL DUWLJLDQDWR D 0RGHQD GDO 4983 DO 4;33 D FXUD GL )LOLSSR 9DOHQ0 WL15< 6L VRQR VXVVHJXLWL QHO 4<<3 OD 'XFDO *DOOHULD (VWHQVH1 'LVVHJQL/ 0HGDJOLH H DO0 WUR63/ QHO 4<<6 $UUHGL/ VXSSHOOHWWLOL H ´SLWWXUH IDPRVHµ GHJOL (VWHQVL64/ QHO 4<<7 ,QYHQ0 WDULR ULVWUHWWR GL 0XJQDQR1 &DWWDORJR GHOOL TXDGUL GL 0XJQDQR65/ WXWWL D FXUD GL -D0 GUDQND %HQWLQL H GL 3DWUL]LD &XUWL1 /·XOWLPR FRQWULEXWR/ UHDOL]]DWR GDOOD 6R0 SULQWHQGHQ]D VX &'0URP/ q XQD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD *DOOHULD 'XFDOH VHWWHFHQ0 WHVFD/ LO FXL SHUFRUVR YLUWXDOH FL PRVWUD OD GLVORFD]LRQH GHOOD UDFFROWD HVWHQVH DOO·LQWHUQR GHO SDOD]]R GXFDOH SULPD GHOOD YHQGLWD GL 'UHVGD/ VXOOD EDVH GHOOD WHVWLPRQLDQ]D GL 3LHWUR (UFROH *KHUDUGL GHO 4:77/ H GRSR GHWWD YHQGLWD/ VH0 FRQGR TXDQWR ULSRUWD OD JXLGD GL &HVDUH GHOOD 3DOXGH GHO 4:;71 /R VWXGLR/ FX0 UDWR GD 3DWUL]LD &XUWL H GD *LRYDQQD 3DROR]]L 6WUR]]L/ VDUj SUHVHQWDWR SURV0 VLPDPHQWH/ GXUDQWH OD 6HWWLPDQD GHL %HQL &XOWXUDOL1 8PEHUWR 'DOODUL/ )LOLSSR 9DOHQWL/ $QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL/ VXVVHJXLWLVL WUD JOL DOWUL QHOOD GLUH]LRQH GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR/ KDQQR DPSLDPHQWH LQGDJDWR LO ULFFKLVVLPR PDWHULDOH FRQVHUYDWR LQ TXHVWR ,VWLWXWR/ FRPXQLFDQGR L ULVXOWDWL GHOOH SURSULH ULFHUFKH VRSUDWWXWWR WUDPLWH FROODERUD]LRQL FRQ ULYLVWH/ (QWL H ,VWLWX]LRQL YDULH1 )RQGDPHQWDOH UHVWD OR VWXGLR GL )1 9DOHQWL FKH KD GHOLQHDWR XQ SURILOR VWRULFR GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH66/ FRQWULEXWR LQGLVSHQVDELOH ²²²²²²²² 5: /·LQYHQWDULR 4::4 GHOO·DUUHGR GHO 3DOD]]R GXFDOH GL 0RGHQD/ D FXUD GL )1 9$/(17, H 31 &857,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;91 5; 31(1 *+(5$5',/ 'HVFUL]LRQH GHOOH SLWWXUH HVLVWHQWL LQ 0RGHQD QHOO·HVWHQVH 'XFDO *DOOHULD +4:77,/ D FXUD GL *1 %216$17,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;91 5< $UWLJLDQDWR H RJJHWWL GL DUWLJLDQDWR D 0RGHQD GDO 4983 DO 4;331 &DWDORJR GL XQD PRVWUD LPSRVVLEL0 OH/ D FXUD GL )1 9$/(17,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;91 63 'XFDO *DOOHULD (VWHQVH1 'LVVHJQL/ PHGDJOLH H DOWUR= JOL LQYHQWDUL GHO 499< H GHO 49:4/ D FXUD GL -1 %(17,1, H 31 &857,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ >4<<3@1 64 $UUHGL/ VXSSHOOHWWLOL H ´SLWWXUH IDPRVHµ GHJOL (VWHQVL= LQYHQWDUL 4996/ D FXUD GL -1 %(17,1, H 31 &857,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ >4<<6@1 65 ,QYHQWDULR ULVWUHWWR GL 0XJQDQR1 &DWWDORJR GHOOL TXDGUL GL 0XJQDQR/ D FXUD GL -1 %(17,1, H 31 &857,/ 0RGHQD/ 3DQLQL/ >4<<7@1 66 )1 9$/(17,/ 3URILOR VWRULFR GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR (VWHQVH1 ,QWURGX]LRQH SUHSRVWD DOO·LQYHQWDULR GHO0 OD VH]LRQH ´&DVD H 6WDWR GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6HJUHWR HVWHQVH/ LQ ©3XEEOLFD]LRQL GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWRª/ HGL0
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
4436
SHU OD FRQRVFHQ]D GHO QRVWUR ULFFR SDWULPRQLR GRFXPHQWDULR1 /D VFXROD GL SDOHRJUDILD DQQHVVD DOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR KD SXEEOLFDWR GXH TXDGHUQL GHOOD FROODQD ´6FXROD GL 3DOHRJUDILD/ 'LSORPDWLFD H $UFKLYLVWLFD GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD1 /H]LRQL H ULFHUFKHµ UHODWLYL DO SDQRUDPD GHOO·DUFKLYLR/ D FXUD GL )1 9DOHQWL67/ H DOOD ELEOLRJUDILD GHOOH IRQWL/ GL (WWRUH )DOFRQL681 3DUWLFRODUPHQWH YLYDFH q O·DWWLYLWj GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ OH FXL SXEEOLFD]LRQL VRQR SDWURFLQDWH GDO &RPXQH> $OGR %RUVDUL QH FXUD WUH FROODQH ´$WWL HG ,QYHQWDUL GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFRµ/ ´4XDGHUQL GHOO·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFRµ H ´&URQDFKHµ1 1HOOD SULPD FROODQD VRQR FRPSDUVL QHJOL DQQL 1RYDQWD 0DJLVWUDWR GL $FTXH H 6WUDGH69 GL *LDQQD 'RWWL 0HVVRUL +4<<5,/ $WWL GL $PPLQLVWUD]LRQH JHQHUDOH GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD6: GL &DWHULQD /LRWWL H 3DROD 5RPDJQROL +4<<8,/ 6SHWWDFROL H DUWH D 0RGHQD QHOO·2WWRFHQWR 6;GL *LDQQD 'RWWL 0HVVRUL +4<<9,1 /H XOWLPH GXH SXEEOLFD]LRQL , FRQWL ULWURYDWL1 /D ´&RQWDELOLWj 2UGLQDULDµ GHOOD &RPXQLWj GL 0RGH0 QD LQ $QWLFR 5HJLPH D FXUD GL 'RUD $QQD %DUHOOL/ 0DQXHOD *KL]]RQL H &KLDUD 3XOLQL +4<<:, H 3DWULPRQLR GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL 6WXGL/ D FXUD GL *LDQQD 'RWWL 0HVVRUL +4<<;, VDUDQQR SURVVLPDPHQWH SUHVHQWDWL DO SXEEOLFR1 /D VHFRQGD FROODQD SUHVHQWD LO &RPSDVVR JHRPHWULFR GL GRQ *LRYDQQL 0DUFHOOLQR 9LJQDUR0 OL6</ RSHUD FXUDWD GD )UDQFHVFR %DUELHUL H GD 0DUJKHULWD =DQDVL +4<<4,1 /D SXEEOLFD]LRQH 0HUFDQWL H EDQFKLHUL D 0RGHQD GDO ;,,, DO ;9,,, VHFROR/ FXUDWD GD 0DUFR &DWWLQL/ H VSRQVRUL]]DWD GDOOD %DQFD 3RSRODUH GHOO·(PLOLD 5RPDJQD/ VDUj SUHVHQWDWD DO SXEEOLFR SURVVLPDPHQWH1 /D WHU]D FROODQD ´&URQDFKHµ/ QD0 ²²²²²²²² WD GDO 0LQLVWHUR GHOO·,QWHUQR/ Q1 46/ 4<861 67 )1 9$/(17,/ 3DQRUDPD GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<96/ ´6FXROD GL 3DOHRJUDILD/ 'LSORPDWLFD H $UFKLYLVWLFD GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD1 /H]LRQL H ULFHU0 FKH/ 4µ1 68 (1 )$/&21,/ %LEOLRJUDILD GHOOH IRQWL GRFXPHQWDULH PHGLHYDOL/ FRQ SDUWLFRODUH ULIHULPHQWR DL WHUULWRUL GL 3LDFHQ]D/ 3DUPD/ 5HJJLR H 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6RF1 7LS1 (GLW1 0RG1/ 4<98/ ´6FXROD GL 3DOHRJUD0 ILD/ 'LSORPDWLFD H $UFKLYLVWLFD GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD1 /H]LRQL H ULFHUFKH/ 5µ1 69 02'(1$/ 0DJLVWUDWR GL DFTXH H VWUDGH= LQYHQWDULR/ >D FXUD GL@ *1 '277, 0(6625,/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<51 6: 02'(1$/ $WWL GL DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH JHQHUDOH GHO &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4:<904;86= LQYHQWDULR/ D FXUD GL &1 /,277, 0 31 520$*12/,/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<81 6; *1 '277, 0(6625,/ 6SHWWDFROL H DUWH D 0RGHQD QHOO·2WWRFHQWR= LQYHQWDULR/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<<81 6< *101 9,*1$52/,/ &RPSDVVR JHRPHWULFR/ D FXUD GL )1 %$5%,(5, 0 01 =$1$6,/ 0RGHQD/ $UFKLYLR 6WRULFR/ 4<<41
4437
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
WD UHFHQWHPHQWH/ VL q DSHUWD FRQ OD WUDVFUL]LRQH/ FRUUHGDWD GD LQWHUYHQWL GL YD0 UL DXWRUL/ GHOOD FURQDFD GL $QWRQLR 5RYDWWL +4:<904;34,/ OD FXL SXEEOLFD]LRQH q VWDWD VSRQVRUL]]DWD GDOOD )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD173 /·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR QHJOL XOWLPL WHPSL KD RUJDQL]]DWR DQFKH XQD VH]LRQH GLGDWWLFD/ FRQ OR VFRSR SUHFLSXR GL DYYLFLQDUH JOL VWXGHQWL DOOD VWRULD GHOOD FLW0 Wj LQ FXL YLYRQR1 /·XOWLPD SURGX]LRQH q VWDWD GHGLFDWD D 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH1 $OGR %RUVDUL KD FXUDWR DQFKH 7HDWUR 0XVLFD H &RPXQLWj GD 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH D 0RGHQD LWDOLDQD +4<<9,74/ LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ LO 7HDWUR &RPXQDOH/ FKH LQ SL• RFFDVLRQL KD SDUWHFLSDWR D PDQLIHVWD]LRQL LQFHQWUDWH VXOO·DWWLYLWj PXVLFDOH H WHDWUDOH PRGHQHVH GHO SHULRGR GHOOD &DSLWDOH1 ,O SL• LPSRUWDQWH FRQWULEXWR GHO 7HDWUR DJOL VWXGL VXOOD 0RGHQD HVWHQVH q OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHJOL DWWL GHO &RQYHJQR ,QWHUQD]LRQDOH GL 6WXGL VX $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD/ D FXUD GL &DURO\Q *LDQWXUFR +4<;8,751 1HOOD VWDJLRQH 4<;;0;< OD SULPD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH PR0 GHUQD GH ´/D 6HFFKLD 5DSLWDµ GL $QWRQLR 6DOLHUL/ DOOHVWLWD DO 7HDWUR &RPXQD0 OH/ q VWDWD FRUUHGDWD GD XQD PRVWUD ELEOLRJUDILFD SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ FKH JLj QHO 4<;6 DYHYD DOOHVWLWR XQ·HVSRVL]LRQH GRFXPHQWDULD SHU ULFRUGDUH $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD761 9DULH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL/ RUJDQL]]DWH GDO 7HDWUR/ QRQ VR0 QR VWDWH GRFXPHQWDWH FRQ XQ FDWDORJR/ PD VL VRQR ULYHODWH LPSRUWDQWL FRQ0 WULEXWL DOOD VWRULD WHDWUDOH H PXVLFDOH HVWHQVH/ GL FXL XQ HVHPSLR q/ WUD OH DOWUH/ OD PRVWUD UHODWLYD DO 483ƒ DQQR GHO QXRYR 7HDWUR &RPXQDOH +4<<4,1 /D %LEOLRWHFD &LYLFD G·DUWH 3ROHWWL FRQVHUYD L GLVHJQL GL *LXVHSSH )DQWDJX]]L/ GRQDWL QHO 4;;7 GD *LXVHSSH &DPSRUL HG HVSRVWL QHO 4<:8 QHOOD PRVWUD GH0 GLFDWD DOO·DUWLVWD PRGHQHVH/ FRQ FDWDORJR D FXUD GL (1 &HFFKL *DWWROLQ771 $Q0 FKH DWWUDYHUVR O·HVSRVL]LRQH GHL GLVHJQL H GHOOH LQFLVLRQL GL *LRYDQQL *XHUUD OD ´3ROHWWLµ KD FRQWULEXLWR D YDORUL]]DUH LO SURSULR SDWULPRQLR DUWLVWLFR H DG ²²²²²²²² 73
$1 529$77,/ /·DOEHUR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ 4:<904:<:> 0RGHQD UHSXEEOLFDQD/ 4:<;04:<</ 0RGHQD/ )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD/ >4<<904<<:@1 747HDWUR/ PXVLFD H FRPXQLWj= GD 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH D 0RGHQD LWDOLDQD/ D FXUD GL $1 %256$5,/ VDJJL GL $1 &+,$5(//,0*1 *+(5$5',1,001 /8&&+,/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ $VVHVVRUDWR DOOD FXOWXUD H EHQL FXOWXUDOL/ 4<<91 75$OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD H 0RGHQD1 $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR ,QWHUQD]LRQDOH GL 6WXGL/ D FXUD GL &1 *,$1785&2/ 0RGHQD/ 7HDWUR &RPXQDOH/ 4<;81 76$QWRQLR 6DOLHUL H 0RGHQD1 0XVLFD 'RFXPHQWL ,PPDJLQL/ 0RGHQD/ &RRSWLS/ 4<;6/ FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD RUJDQL]]DWD QHOO·DPELWR GHOOH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL FKH 0RGHQD KD GHGLFDWR DO 6HWWH0 FHQWR (VWHQVH1 77&HQWR GLVHJQL GL *LXVHSSH )DQWDJX]]L +0RGHQD 4::404;6:,/ D FXUD GL (1 &(&&+, *$772/,1/ 0RGHQD/ &RRS1 7LSRJUDIL/ 4<:81
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
4438
LOOXVWUDUH XQ·DOWUD WUDQFKH GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD &DSLWDOH781 4XHVWR LVWLWXWR FRQVHUYD DOWUHVu OD TXDVL WRWDOLWj GHL GLVHJQL GL $QWRQLR &RQVHWWL/ GRQDWL GDO &DPSRUL H RJJHWWR QHO 4<;5 GL XQD PRVWUD RUJDQL]]DWD QHOO·DPELWR GHOOH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL VXO 6HWWHFHQWR HVWHQVH/ LO FXL FDWDORJR IX FXUDWR GD (QULFKHWWD &HFFKL *DWWR0 OLQ791 /·,VWLWXWR KD UHFHQWHPHQWH LQDXJXUDWR OD FROODQD ´4XDGHUQL GHOOD %L0 EOLRWHFD 3ROHWWLµ/ D FXUD GL 0HULV %HOOHL H GL *LRUGDQD 7URYDEHQH1 /D QXRYD FROODQD/ QDWD FRQ O·LQWHQWR GL RIIULUH DJOL VWXGLRVL H DO SXEEOLFR XQ SDQRUDPD GHL IRQGL OLEUDUL H GRFXPHQWDUL GL TXHVWR ,VWLWXWR VSHFLDOL]]DWR QHOOD VWRULD GHOO·DUWH H GHOO·DUFKLWHWWXUD/ KD SUHVHQWDWR FRQ LO VHFRQGR YROXPH/ D FXUD GL /XFLDQR 5LYL/ /HWWHUH DOO·DUWLVWD7:/ O·HSLVWRODULR GL $GHRGDWR 0DODWHVWD1 /D UDF0 FROWD GHOOH OHWWHUH GHL FRUULVSRQGHQWL GHOO·DUWLVWD PRGHQHVH FRSUH JOL XOWLPL YHQWLFLQTXH DQQL GHOOD &DSLWDOH H DQQRYHUD JOL VFULWWL GL DUWLVWL FRPH JOL $VLROL R /XLJL 0DQ]LQL/ GL PHPEUL GHOOH SL• LPSRUWDQWL IDPLJOLH/ FRPH L %DJQHVL/ L &RFFDSDQL/ L 6DOLPEHQL/ QRQFKp GHOOR VWHVVR 'XFD1 1HO VXR ULFFR FDWDORJR HGLWRULDOH DQFKH LO 0XVHR &LYLFR G·$UWH 0HGLHYDOH H 0RGHUQD SUHVHQWD RSHUH UHODWLYH DO SHULRGR LQ FXL 0RGHQD IX FDSLWDOH GHO GXFDWR> VL WUDWWD LQ SDUWLFRODUH GL FDWDORJKL GL PRVWUH VXOOD FHUDPLFD VDVVROH0 VH7;/ VX /XLJL 0DLQRQL7< H VX $GHRGDWR 0DODWHVWD831 ,O 0XVHR &LYLFR KD LQRO0 WUH FXUDWR XQD VH]LRQH GLGDWWLFD ULYROWD DOOD VFXROD GHOO·REEOLJR LQ FXL FRP0 SDLRQR VFKHGH GL ODYRUR VXOOD 0RGHQD GXFDOH184
²²²²²²²² 78
/LEUL GL LPPDJLQL/ GLVHJQL H LQFLVLRQL GL *LRYDQQL *XHUUD +0RGHQD 487705RPD 494;,/ D FXUD GL (1 &(&&+, *$772/,1/ 0RGHQD/ &RRSWLS/ 4<:;1 79 , GLVHJQL GHL &RQVHWWL QHOOH FROOH]LRQL GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD &LYLFD GL 6WRULD GHOO·$UWH /XLJL 3ROHWWL1 ,DFRSL0 QR H $QWRQLR &RQVHWWL1 0RGHQD 498404:59249;904:99/ D FXUD GL (1 &(&&+, *$772/,1/ 0RGH0 QD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<;51 7: /HWWHUH DOO·DUWLVWD1 7HVWLPRQLDQ]H G·DUWH QHOO·2WWRFHQWR GDOO·HSLVWRODULR GL $GHRGDWR 0DODWHVWD/ D FX0 UD GL /1 5,9,/ 0RGHQD 4<<;1 7; &HUDPLFKH VHWWHFHQWHVFKH GHO GXFDWR PRGHQHVH= 6DVVXROR H FHQWUL PLQRUL/ FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD/ D FXUD GL )1 /,9(5$1,/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<;3> /D FHUDPLFD GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH D 6DVVXROR/ FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD/ D FXUD GL )1 /,9(5$1,/ 6DVVXROR/ &RPXQH GL 6DVVXROR/ 4<;51 7< /XLJL 0DLQRQL H OD VFXOWXUD GL SULPR 2WWRFHQWR/ FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD/ FRQ VDJJL GL YDUL/ 0RGH0 QD/ 3DQLQL/ 4<<81 83 0RGHOOL G·DUWH H GL GHYR]LRQH1 $GHRGDWR 0DODWHVWD 4;3904;<4/ FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD +0RGHQD H 5HJJLR (PLOLD,/ 0LODQR/ 6NLUD/ 4<<;1 84 0RGHQD GXFDOH1 6FKHGH GL ODYRUR +/D VFXROD H L PXVHL FLYLFL,/ D FXUD GL 01 $50$1',001 &$129$0'1 1$6,/ 0RGHQD/ &RPXQH GL 0RGHQD/ 4<:;1
4439
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
/·8QLYHUVLWj KD IDYRULWR YDULH LQL]LDWLYH ILQDOL]]DWH DG XQ DSSURIRQGLPHQWR GHOOD VXD VWHVVD VWRULD/ SURPXRYHQGR QHO 4<:3 OR 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 61 &DUOR85/ SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL 3HULFOH 'L 3LHWUR VXOO·,VWLWX]LRQH XQLYHUVLWDULD H VXL VXRL GR0 FHQWL/ H QHO 4<:8 XQ DJJLRUQDPHQWR/ D FXUD GHOOR VWHVVR DXWRUH/ GHOOD 6WRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD GL &DUOR *XLGR 0RU86/ GDOOD FKLDPDWD GL 3LOOLR GD 0HGLFLQD DOOR 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 61 &DUOR/ DOO·8QLYHUVLWj ULIRUPDWD GD )UDQ0 FHVFR ,,,1 6ROR SHU FLWDUH TXDOFKH HVHPSLR/ WUD OH SXEEOLFD]LRQL GHOO·,VWLWXWR *LXULGLFR/ q OD PRQRJUDILD GHO 4<;6 GL *LRYDQQL 6DQWLQL /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH87/ RSHUD QHOOD TXDOH/ GRSR DOFXQL DFFHQQL DOOH RULJLQL/ O·LQWHUHVVH q LQFHQWUDWR VXOOR 6WDWR QHO SHULRGR LQ FXL 0RGHQD IX FDSLWDOH GHO 'XFDWR1 $QFKH LO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL PDWHPDWLFD ´*1 9LWDOLµ KD FROODERUDWR DPSLDPHQWH DOOD GHOLQHD]LRQH GL ILJXUH VWRULFKH GL PRGHQHVL FRPH 3DROR 5XIILQL88/ 3LHWUR 5LFFDUGL89/ )HUGLQDQGR -DFROL8: FRQ VFULWWL D FXUD GL )UDQFH0 VFR %DUELHUL H GL )UDQFD &DWWHODQL 'HJDQL1 /H FHOHEUD]LRQL GHO 1RYDQWRWWR YHGRQR LPSHJQDWR DQFKH O·,VWLWXWR SHU OD 6WRULD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR FKH LQ TXHVWD RFFDVLRQH VL q SDUWLFRODUPHQWH DWWLYDWR/ DYYDOHQGRVL/ SHU OD UHDOL]]D]LRQH GHO SURVVLPR FRQYHJQR GL VWXGL RUJDQL]]DWR SHU LO VHFRQGR FHQWHQDULR GHOOD QDVFLWD GL &LUR 0HQRWWL/ GHO SDWURFLQLR GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH/ GHOOD )RQGD]LRQH 5ROR %DQFD 47:6 H GHOOD )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL &DUSL/ ROWUH FKH GHJOL RUJDQL GL FDUDWWHUH SL• VWUHWWDPHQWH ²²²²²²²² 85
31 ', 3,(752/ /R 6WXGLR 3XEEOLFR GL 61 &DUOR LQ 0RGHQD +49;504::5,1 1RYDQW·DQQL GL VWRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 6171(101/ 4<:31 86 &1 *1 025 031 ', 3,(752/ 6WRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD/ )LUHQ]H/ 2OVFKNL/ 4<:81 87 *1 6$17,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH WUD ULIRUPH H ULYROX]LRQH1 /H VWUXWWXUH DPPLQLVWUDWLYH PRGHQHVL GHO ;9,,, VHFROR/ 0LODQR/ *LXIIUq/ 4<;61 88 )1 %$5%,(5,0)1 &$77(/$1,/ &DWDORJR GHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GL 3DROR 5XIILQL/ 3LVD/ (76/ 4<<:> )1 %$5%,(5,0)1 &$77(/$1,/ 3DROR 5XIILQL WUD UHOLJLRQH H SROLWLFD/ LQ © $WWL GHOOD 'HSXWD0 ]LRQH 6WRUD 3DWULDª/ 44/ 4; +4<99,/ S1 56;0583> )1 %$5%,(5,/ $OFXQL FRQWULEXWL GL 3DROR 5XIILQL DOO·DOJHEUD/ LQ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR= ,O SHQVLHUR PDWHPDWLFR QHOOD ULFHUFD VWRULFD LWDOLDQD/ $QFRQD 4<<51 89 )1 %$5%,(5,/ ,O FRQWULEXWR GL 3LHWUR 5LFFDUGL DOOD VWRULRJUDILD PDWHPDWLFD/ LQ DWWL GHO FRQYHJQR= 3LHWUR 5LFFDUGL +4;5;04;<;, H OD VWRULRJUDILD GHOOH PDWHPDWLFKH LQ ,WDOLD/ D FXUD GL )1 %$5%,(5, 0 )1 &$77(/$1, '(*$1,/ 0RGHQD 4<;:> )1 %$5%,(5,/ 3LHWUR 5LFFDUGL= FHQQL VWRULFL LQWRUQR DOOR VWXGLR HG DL FXOWRUL GHOOH VFLHQ]H ILVLFR0PDWHPDWLFKH SXUH HG DSSOLFDWH/ QHOOD FLWWj H SURYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD/ LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H /HWWHUH HG $UWL GL 0RGHQDª/ :1 V1 : +4<;<0<3,/ S1 ;60 463> )1 %$5%,(5,/ 3LHWUR 5LFFDUGL QHOOD FXOWXUD H QHOOD 6RFLHWj PRGHQHVH GHO VHFRQGR 2WWRFHQWR/ LQ ©© $WWL GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH 6WRUD 3DWULDª/ 44/ V1 43 +4<;;,/ S1 64;06761 8: )1 %$5%,(5,/ )HUGLQDQGR -DFROL VWRULRJUDIR GHOOH PDWHPDWLFKH/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD IULJQDQHVHªµ/ 58 +4<;80;9,
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
443:
DPPLQLVWUDWLYR18; ,O &HQWUR GL 6WXGL 0XUDWRULDQL FXUD O·HGL]LRQH QD]LRQDOH GHO FDUWHJJLR GL /R0 GRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL/ SURPXRYHQGR TXLQGL VWXGL VXO ELEOLRWHFDULR H DU0 FKLYLVWD GXFDOH/ QRQFKp VXO 6HWWHFHQWR LQ JHQHUDOH/ H QRQ VROR PRGHQHVH/ FRQVLGHUDWD OD ILWWD UHWH GL FRUULVSRQGHQWL GHO 0XUDWRUL1 /·$FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H /HWWHUH HG $UWL YROJH LO SURSULR LQWHUHVVH VRSUDWWXWWR DO VHWWRUH VFLHQWLILFR/ LQ TXDQWR/ SXU FRPSUHQGHQGR DQFKH XQD VH]LRQH GL OHW0 WHUH/ SHU WUDGL]LRQH ODVFLD O·DUJRPHQWR VWRULFR IRQGDPHQWDOPHQWH DOOD 'HSX0 WD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD1 $WWXDOPHQWH O·$FFDGHPLD VWD DWWXDQGR/ FRQ OD SDUWH0 FLSD]LRQH GHOOH WUH VH]LRQL/ XQD VHULH GL VHGXWH GL VWXGLR SHU FHOHEUDUH TXHVWR TXDUWR FHQWHQDULR GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH1 $QDORJD LQL]LDWLYD q VWDWD SUHVD DQFKH GDOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVL FKH KD LQ SURJUDPPD DOFXQH VHGXWH GHGLFDWH DO FHQ0 WHQDULR1 3HU LO VXR FRPSLWR LVWLWX]LRQDOH GL VWXGLDUH OD VWRULD GHJOL VWDWL SUHXQL0 WDUL/ ILQ GD 4;97/ GDWD GHOOD VXD FRVWLWX]LRQH/ q O·,VWLWXWR FKH KD IRUQLWR LO PDJJLRU QXPHUR GL FRQWULEXWL DOOD ULHYRFD]LRQH DWWHQWD H GRFXPHQWDWD GHO SDVVDWR/ DWWUDYHUVR OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHL ´0RQXPHQWL GL 6WRULD 3DWULDµ SULPD H GL ´$WWL H 0HPRULHµ SRL1 ,O VRGDOL]LR PRGHQHVH/ FKH VL DYYDOH DOWUHVu GHOO·DSSRUWR GHOOH VH]LRQL GL 5HJJLR (PLOLD H GL 0DVVD/ KD ULYROWR O·DWWHQ]LRQH DQFKH DO SHULRGR IHUUDUHVH GHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ FRQVLGHUDQGROR SHUz VRVWDQ0 ]LDOH FDPSR GL LQYHVWLJD]LRQH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH )HUUDUHVH1 /·DWWLYLWj GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH q VHPSUH VWDWD SLXWWRVWR LQWHQVD H FRQWLQXD DG HVVHUH DQFRUD RJJL PROWR YLYDFH/ VLD SHU LO QXPHUR GL LVFULWWL/ VLD SHU OD TXDQWLWj GHOOH FRPXQLFD]LRQL SUHVHQWDWH H DQFKH SHU OD ULFFKH]]D GHOOD FROOD0 QD ´%LEOLRWHFDµ/ QHOOD TXDOH FRPSDLRQR WUD OH DOWUH SXEEOLFD]LRQL/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL WUD 5LYROX]LRQH H 5HVWDXUD]LRQH GL *LXVHSSH 2UODQGL +4<9:,8</ /D]]DUR 6SDOODQ]DQL GL 3HULFOH 'L 3LHWUR +4<9:,93/ /H FKLHVH GL 0RGHQD GL *XVPDQR 6ROL +4<:7,94/ 6FULWWL LQHGLWL GHO 7DVVRQL D FXUD GL 3LHWUR 3XOLDWWL +4<:8,95/ /D VWUXWWXUD ²²²²²²²² 8; /D &RQJLXUD (VWHQVH1 &RQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL VWXGL SURPRVVR GDOO·,VWLWXWR SHU OD VWRULD GHO 5L0 VRUJLPHQWR ,WDOLDQR ² &RPLWDWR SURYLQFLDOH GL 0RGHQD/ LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ LO 'LSDUWLPHQWR GL 'LVFLSOLQH 6WRULFKH GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL %RORJQD/ LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO ELFHQWHQDULR GHOOD QDVFLWD GL &LUR 0HQRWWL 4:<;04<<;/ 0RGHQD0&DUSL06SH]]DQR/ :0< PDJJLR 4<<;1 8< *1 25/$1',/ /H FDPSDJQH PRGHQHVL IUD ULYROX]LRQH H UHVWDXUD]LRQH +4:<304;48,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9:1 93 31 ', 3(752/ /D]]DUR 6SDOODQ]DQL/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<9:1 94 *1 62/,/ &KLHVH GL 0RGHQD/ D FXUD GL *1 %(578==,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<:71 95 $1 7$6621,/ 6FULWWL LQHGLWL/ D FXUD GL 31 38/,$77,/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV PXUDWRULDQD/ 4<:81
443;
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR $XVWUR0(VWHQVH GL *LRUGDQR %HUWX]]L +4<::,96/ 3HU OD VWRULD GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD GL *LXVHSSH 2UODQGL +4<;4,97/ 0H0 PRULH GL TXDQWR GLVSRVL/ YLGL HG XGLL GL )UDQFHVFR 9 G·$XVWULD0(VWH/ D FXUD GL *LX0 VHSSH 2UODQGL +4<;4,98/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO VHWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH GL DXWRUL YDUL +4<;5,99/ ,O PLOOHQDULR GL 61 3LHWUR GL )LOLSSR 9DOHQWL +4<;8,9:/ *OL VWHPPL HVWHQVL HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVL GL $QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL H GL *LXVHSSH 7UHQWL +4<;8,9; H PROWR UHFHQ0 WHPHQWH /D 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD GL 2GRDUGR 5RPEDOGL +4<<:,9</ 1RELOWj H &RPXQH D 0RGHQD GL 5RQDOG 5|ONHU +4<<:,:3 H 5HWL PRQDVWLFKH QHOO·,WDOLD SDGDQD GL 9LWWRULR &DUUDUD +4<<;,:41 7UD L WDQWL LQWHUYHQWL SUHVHQWDWL GDL VRFL/ DQFKH VROR FRQVLGHUDQGR JOL VWXGL SL• UHFHQWL/ +PD SXUH WUD TXHOOL GL SL• YHFFKLD GDWD VH QH WURYDQR GL DQFRUD YDOLGLVVLPL, VL SRVVRQR HQXFOHDUH YDUL WHPL UHODWLYL DOOH SUREOHPDWLFKH HVVHQ0 ]LDOL GL 0RGHQD/ FDSLWDOH GHJOL (VWHQVL1 6L SUHVHQWDQR VROR DOFXQL HVHPSL/ OL0 PLWDWL D 0RGHQD/ H SHU L WLWROL GHL VLQJROL LQWHUYHQWL/ DL FXL DXWRUL VL ID SL• RO0 WUH FHQQR/ VL ULPDQGD DOO·LQGLFH SHU DXWRUL GL ´$WWL H 0HPRULHµ FXUDWR GD 7RPPDVR 6RUEHOOL:5 H DO QXRYR LQGLFH SHU DXWRUL/ PLWWHQWL/ GHVWLQDWDUL GL OHW0 WHUH H SHU VRJJHWWL/ SXEEOLFDWR:6 UHFHQWHPHQWH1 ,O 6HLFHQWR q VWDWR LQGDJDWR LQFHQWUDQGR OD ULFHUFD VXOOH ILJXUH FKH KDQQR ²²²²²²²² 96 *1 %(578==,/ /D VWUXWWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHO 'XFDWR $XVWUR0(VWHQVH1 /LQHDPHQWL/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV PXUDWRULDQD/ 4<::1 97 *1 25/$1',/ 3HU OD VWRULD GHOOD PDVVRQHULD QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD GDOOH RULJLQL DO 4:88/ 0RGH0 QD/ $HGHV PXUDWRULDQD/ 4<;41 98 )5$1&(6&2 9 '·$8675,$0(67(/ 0HPRULH GL TXDQWR GLVSRVL/ YLGL HG XGLL GDOO·44 JLXJQR DO 45 OXJOLR 4;8</ D FXUD GL *1 25/$1',/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;41 99 $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO VHWWHFHQWR PRGHQHVH/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV PXUDWRULDQD/ 4<;51 9: )1 9$/(17,/ ,O 0LOOHQDULR GL 61 3LHWUR GL 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;81 9; $1 63$**,$5,0*1 75(17,/ *OL VWHPPL HVWHQVL HG DXVWUR0HVWHQVL1 3URILOR VWRULFR/ 0RGHQD/ $H0 GHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<;81 9< 21 520%$/',/ /D 5HSXEEOLFD &LVSDGDQD/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV PXUDWRULDQD/ 4<<:1 :3 51 5g/.(5/ 1RELOWj H &RPXQH D 0RGHQD= SRWHUH H DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH QHL VHFROL 451 H 461/ 0RGH0 QD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<:1 :4 91 &$55$5$/ 5HWL PRQDVWLFKH QHOO·,WDOLD SDGDQD= OH FKLHVH GL 6DQ 6LOYHVWUR GL 1RQDQWROD WUD 3D0 YLD/ 3LDFHQ]D H &UHPRQD/ VHFF1 <10461/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<;1 :5 71 625%(//,/ ,QGLFH *HQHUDOH SHU $XWRUL H SHU 6RJJHWWR GL ´$WWL H 0HPRULHµ GL ´6WXGL H 'RFX0 PHQWLµ GHL ´0RQXPHQWLµ H GHOOH ´3XEEOLFD]LRQL YDULHµ HGLWR GDOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH QHL SULPL FHQWR DQQL GL YLWD1 4;9304<931 9RO1 ,/ ,QGLFH JHQHUDOH SHU $XWRUL/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<961 :6 ,QGLFH JHQHUDOH SHU DXWRUL/ SHU GHVWLQDWDUL H SHU VRJJHWWR GL ´$WWL H 0HPRULHµ H GL ´6WXGL H GRFXPHQ0 WLµ +4;9304<<;, D FXUD GL 31 ', 3,(752 /20%$5',/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/ 4<<</ +'632%LEOLRWHFD/ 11 6HULH Q1 48<,1
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
443<
JLRFDWR XQ IRQGDPHQWDOH UXROR SROLWLFR FRPH /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L +$0257+,/ )UDQFHVFR ,, LO FXL GXFDWR IX LQ ELOLFR WUD )UDQFLD H $XVWULD +%(/75$0,,/ OR VWRULFR %HQHGHWWR %DFFKLQL +*2/,1(//,,/ *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD /DGHUFKL DWWLYR QHO JRYHUQR HVWHQVH WUD )HUUDUD H 0RGHQD +0217$*1$1,,/ )XOYLR 7HVWL +%2&&2/$5,,1 ,O 6HWWHFHQWR q VWDWR DIIURQWDWR QHOOH VXH OLQHH JHQHUDOL/ SUHQ0 GHQGR LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH L UDSSRUWL GLSORPDWLFL WUD OR VWDWR HVWHQVH H LO JRYHU0 QR GL 9LHQQD DJOL LQL]L GHO VHFROR +1$6$//,,/ LQGDJDQGR OH PDJLVWUDWXUH GXFD0 OL H LO GLVSRWLVPR LOOXPLQDWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, +$%(/621,/ OH FRPSHWHQ]H GHOO·XIILFLR GHO *RYHUQDWRUH/ TXDOH RUJDQR SHULIHULFR GHO 'XFDWR/ FRQ XQR VWXGLR FRPSOHVVLYR FKH SDUWH GDO 485: +%('21,, H OD FDULFD GL 3RGHVWj FRQ LO FDWDORJR GL TXHVWL IXQ]LRQDUL GDO 4669 DO 4:<9 +9,&,1,,1 Ë VWDWD VWXGLDWD OD IL0 JXUD GHL 'XFKL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH TXHOOH GL 5LQDOGR H GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, OD FXL SROL0 WLFD KD SRUWDWR DOO·DVVRUELPHQWR GHO 'XFDWR GD SDUWH GHOO·$XVWULD +6,0(21,,/ GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, LPSHJQDWR LQ XQ WHQWDWLYR GL UHFXSHUR GL &RPDFFKLR +0$(675,,/ GL (UFROH ,,, +*1 &$0325,, H GHL ORUR VWUHWWL FROODERUDWRUL/ FRPH )HOLFH $QWRQLR %LDQFKL FKH/ LQ DVVHQ]D GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ JRYHUQDWRUH D 0LOD0 QR/ WHQQH OH ILOD GHO JRYHUQR GXFDOH +3,6721,,1 1RQ q GD SDVVDUH VRWWR VLOHQ0 ]LR LO SUREOHPD GHOOD GLIIXVLRQH GHOOD 0DVVRQHULD QHO 'XFDWR QHOOD SULPD PH0 Wj GHO VHFROR +25/$1',,> DPSLR VSD]LR q VWDWR GDWR DJOL VWXGL VXOOD 5LYROX0 ]LRQH IUDQFHVH H VXOO·DUULYR D 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 0RGHQD H 0DVVD GHOOH WUXSSH QDSROHRQLFKH +$*267,> &$&&,$ '20,1,21,> 0,&+(/8&&,,1 'D XQ HVDPH/ DQFKH UDSLGR/ GHO QXRYR LQGLFH GL $WWL H 0HPRULH/ HPHUJH XQR VSLFFDWR LQWHUHVVH SHU O·2WWRFHQWR/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH SHU LO SHULRGR FKH YD GDOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH +$92172> &(&&23,(5,00$58)),, DOO·8QLWj +%2&&2/$5,,1 7DQWR q VWDWR VFULWWR VXO 5LVRUJLPHQWR/ VXOOD &DUERQHULD/ VXL PRWL ULYROX]LRQDUL GHO 4;63064 H VXOOD ILJXUD GL &LUR 0HQRWWL +%$&&+,> %$//(77,> %('21,> %(578==,> %2&&2/$5,> &$1(9$==,> &5(021$0 &$62/,> )(55$5,> ),1=,> *$9,2/,> /$9$*1,1,> 0(1=,$1,> 0255(77$> 0256(//,> 3,&&,1,1,> 58)),1,> 6$17$*$7$> 625%(//,> 78&&,058)),1,> 9,//$1,,1 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH LQ TXHVWL XOWLPL DQQL JOL VWXGL VXO 5LVRUJLPHQWR PR0 GHQHVH VL VRQR DUULFFKLWL GL QXRYL DSSRUWL/ FRQ O·HVDPH GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH UHODWLYD DOO·HVHUFLWR HVWHQVH +0(1=,$1,, H DOOH GLYLVH PLOLWDUL HVWHQVL +7,1Ë,1 , GXFKL (VWHQVL H OH GRQQH GL &DVD G·(VWH FRVWLWXLVFRQR LQ JHQHUDOH XQ FDPSR GL ULFHUFD SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LQGDJDWR QRQ VROWDQWR GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD GHOOD SROL0 WLFD LQWHUQD H GHOOD SROLWLFD HVWHUD/ PD DQFKH VRWWR DVSHWWL PHQR XIILFLDOL1 $L ODYRUL VX &HVDUH G·(VWH +%$//(77,> 520%$/',,/ VX $OIRQVR ,,, +&$9$==87,,/ VX (UFROH ,,, +0(6625,0521&$*/,$, VL DIILDQFDQR LQWHUYHQWL
4443
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
FKH WUDWWDQR OD PDWHULD GD DQJROD]LRQL GLYHUVH= OD VRUWH GHOOH VDOPH GL 'XFKL H 3ULQFLSL HVWHQVL +&5(63(//$1,> 6$1'211,1,,/ L GXFKL JXHUULHUL +6&+(1(77,,/ VWDWXH PHGDJOLH H RQRULILFHQ]H SHU L 'XFKL +)251,> 0$(675,,1 6RQR VWDWH ULFRVWUXLWH OH ELRJUDILH GL YDUL GXFKL +520%$/',, H OH ILJXUH GL /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ GL 0DULD GL 0RGHQD/ GL (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH/ GHOO·DUFLGXFKHVVD $GHOJRQGD H GL DOWUH SULQFLSHVVH VRQR VWDWH RJJHWWR GL VWX0 GLR GD SDUWH GL SDUHFFKL VRFL +'$//$5,> 0$(675,> )251,> 0(6625,0 521&$*/,$,1 )UDQFHVFR ,9 H )UDQFHVFR9 VRQR VWDWL VWXGLDWL DPSLDPHQWH/ VRSUDWWXWWR LQ TXHVW·XOWLPR SHULRGR +%(578==,> *$9,2/,> 0$50,52/,,1 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH )UDQFHVFR *DYLROL KD SRWXWR XWLOL]]DUH DQFKH LO ULFFKLVVLPR PDWH0 ULDOH FRQWHQXWR QHOO·$UFKLYLR %DJQHVL/ GD OXL DFTXLVLWR SHU OD VXD UDFFROWD SHU0 VRQDOH/ HG RUD FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD &RPXQDOH GL 0LUDQGROD1 Ë VWDWD VWXGLDWD OD SROLWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH/ DWWUDYHUVR O·LQGDJLQH GHL UDSSRUWL FRQ O·,QJKLOWHUUD/ WUDPLWH LO PDWULPRQLR GL 0DULD GL 0RGHQD FRQ *LDFRPR 6WXDUW +'$//$5,> 0$(675,,/ H GHL UDSSRUWL FRQ LO 'XFDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ0 ]D/ WUDPLWH OH QR]]H GL (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH FRQ )UDQFHVFR )DUQHVH +0$(675,,1 *OL (VWHQVL VRQR VWDWL FRQVLGHUDWL DQFKH GD XQ·DQJROD]LRQH QXRYD/ DWWUD0 YHUVR O·RFFKLR GHO PHGLFR FKH GDOOH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH VRPDWLFR0ILVLRQRPLFKH ULHVFH D ULFDYDUH LQIRUPD]LRQL VX HYHQWXDOL SUREOHPL GL VDOXWH GL VLQJROL 'XFKL H 3ULQ0 FLSL/ FRPH $OIRQVR ,9/ $OPHULFR H )UDQFHVFR 9 +1$11,1,,1 9HGHUH FRPH IXQ]LRQDYD OR 6WDWR/ TXDO HUD OD VXD RUJDQL]]D]LRQH LQWHUQD H GD TXDOL OHJJL HUD UHJRODWR/ KD FRVWLWXLWR LO FHQWUR G·LQWHUHVVH GHL 6RFL IRUPDWL LQ TXHVWR SDUWLFRODUH VHWWRUH= OH ULIRUPH SROLWLFR0DPPLQLVWUDWLYH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, H GL (UFROH ,,, +6(9(5,,/ OD OHJLVOD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, +6$/9,2/,,/ OD OHJLVOD]LRQH PDWULPRQLDOH HVWHQVH +%('21,, H LQ SDUWLFRODUH TXHOOD GL )UDQFH0 VFR 9 +58662,/ OD FHQVXUD QHJOL VWDWL HVWHQVL +%(578==,,1 /D FXOWXUD LQ JHQHUDOH q VWDWD YLVWD DQFKH GDJOL (VWHQVL FRPH YDOLGR VWUXPHQ0 WR GL JRYHUQR/ QRQ VROWDQWR SHUFKp FDSDFH GL RIIULUH XQD FHUWD LPPDJLQH GHO0 OD IDPLJOLD DO SRWHUH/ PD DQFKH SHUFKp FDSDFH GL LQGLUL]]DUH LQ XQ FHUWR PR0 GR O·RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD1 ,QHYLWDELOH TXLQGL FKH O·DWWHQ]LRQH GL PROWL VWXGLRVL ORFDOL VLD VWDWD ULYROWD D TXHOOH LVWLWX]LRQL FKH PHJOLR ULIOHWWRQR OD SROLWLFD FXO0 WXUDOH GHO 'XFDWR1 /D %LEOLRWHFD q VWDWD VWXGLDWD/ ROWUH FKH QHO VXR DUUHGR VWRUL0 FR +0$57,1(//,0%5$*/,$,/ QHO VXR IXQ]LRQDPHQWR JHVWLWR GD ELEOLRWHFDUL HUXGLWL H SDUWLFRODUPHQWH VLJQLILFDWLYL FRPH %DFFKLQL +$1'5(2/,,/ 0XUDWRUL +$1'5(2/,/ *$/%,$7,,/ 7LUDERVFKL +%$//(77,> *1 H 01 &$0325,> &$9$==87,> &255$',> 0256(//,> 5$==2/,> 6$1'211,1,> 6$17,> 6,021(77,> 9,&,1,, H &DYHGRQL +38/,$77,,1
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
4444
/D ILJXUD GL /XGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL q VWDWD DPSLDPHQWH LQGDJDWD GDL 6RFL L FXL FRQWULEXWL VRQR LQVHULWL QHOOD VH]LRQH ´0XUDWRULDQDµ GL ´$WWL H 0H0 PRULHµ1 'L SDUWLFRODUH ULOLHYR VRQR OD ELEOLRJUDILD PXUDWRULDQD +625%(//,, H OD SULPD HGL]LRQH GHO FDUWHJJLR +01 &$0325,,1 5HFHQWHPHQWH q VWDWR ULFRUGD0 WR LO VHFRQGR FHQWHQDULR GHOOD PRUWH GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL FRQ PRQRJUDILH H DUWLFROL FRPSDUVL LQ PLVFHOODQHH R ULYLVWH QRQ JHVWLWH GDOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH/ PD LQ PDVVLPD SDUWH SHU RSHUD GL 6RFL GL TXHVWD +%21$&,1,> 3$2/$ ', 3,(752> &$38&&,> *2/,1(//,> 25/$1',> 9(1785,,:71 /D VWRULD GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ RSHUD DQFRUD RJJL IRQGDPHQWDOH/ q X0 VFLWD QHO 4<58 FRPH PRQRJUDILD GHO VRFLR 'RPHQLFR )DYD:8> XQ DOWUR SURILOR GHOOR VWHVVR ,VWLWXWR q VWDWR GHOLQHDWR D ILQH 2WWRFHQWR GD XQ DOWUR VRFLR/ /XL0 JL &DUERQLHUL:9/ DQFK·HJOL 'LUHWWRUH GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD1 $QFKH O·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVH q VWDWR VWXGLDWR QHOOD VXD FRPSRVL]LRQH H QHOOD VXD VWRULD +&$03,> '$//$5,> $1 63$**,$5,,/ SDUDOOHODPHQWH FRQ O·$UFKLYLR 6WRULFR GHO &RPXQH +%25*+,, H O·$UFKLYLR 1RWDULOH GHOOD FLWWj +%25*+,> 0$5&+(77,,1 *OL VWXGL IRQGDPHQWDOL VXOO·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVH/ EDVLODUL SHU TXDOVLDVL FRQRVFHQ0 ]D GHOOR VWHVVR/ VRQR XVFLWL QRQ SHU LQWHUHVVDPHQWR GLUHWWR GHOOD 'HSXWD]LR0 QH/ PD DG RSHUD GL VRFL +'$//$5,> 9$/(17,,1 $QFKH O·8QLYHUVLWj/ ULFRVWLWXLWD SHU YROHUH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, QHO 4::6/ q UL0 IOHVVR LPSRUWDQWLVVLPR GHOO·DWWLYLWj GHJOL (VWHQVL YROWD DOOD IRUPD]LRQH GHOOD FODVVH GLULJHQWH1 7URYLDPR FRVu QHOO·HOHQFR GHL FRQWULEXWL GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH VDJJL VXOOH FRQGL]LRQL JLXULGLFKH GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj QHOO·DUFR GL WHPSR 49;50 4::6 +025,/ VXL GRFHQWL FKH KDQQR VYROWR OD SURSULD RSHUD GDOOD 5HVWDXUD0 ]LRQH DOOD ILQH GHOO·2WWRFHQWR +'21$7,,/ VXO ODVFLWR GL &ULVWRIRUR %RUJKL +%(//(,,/ VXJOL LQVHJQDPHQWL LYL WHQXWL +3(5,&/( ', 3,(752,1 $ VRWWROLQHDUH O·LPSRUWDQ]D GL TXHVWD ,VWLWX]LRQH VL q FRVWLWXLWR XQ ´&RPLWDWR 3HUPDQHQWH SHU OD 6WRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWjµ +&$1(9$==,> '21$7,, H/ SHU ULFRUGDUH O·RWWDYR FHQWHQDULR GHOO·$WHQHR/ q XVFLWD OD 6WRULD GHOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD D FXUD GHL VRFL 0RU H 3HULFOH 'L 3LHWUR1 /D JLRYHQW• PRGHQHVH YHQLYD LVWUXLWD DQFKH SUHVVR LO &ROOHJLR 61 &DUOR/ R &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL +&1 &$0325,,/ LQ VHQR DO TXDOH VL FRVWLWXu QHO ;9,, VHFROR O·$FFDGHPLD OHWWHUDULD GHJOL (OSRPHQL +)(55$5,0025(1,,1 6LD L GRFHQWL XQLYHUVLWDUL FKH L GRWWL GHOOD &RUWH SXEEOL0 FDYDQR LO IUXWWR GHOOH SURSULH IDWLFKH SHU L WLSL GHOOD 6RFLHWj 7LSRJUDILFD GL ²²²²²²²² :7
&RQWULEXWL SXEEOLFDWL VXOOD ULYLVWD ©0RGHQD 6WRULDª/ D1 ,,,/ Q1 44 VHWWHPEUH 4<<81 '1 )$9$/ /D %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH QHO VXR VYLOXSSR VWRULFR/ 0RGHQD/ 9LQFHQ]L/ 4<581 :9 /1 &$5%21,(5,/ &HQQL VWRULFL GHOOD 51 %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH LQ 0RGHQD FRQ DSSHQGLFH GL GRFXPHQWL/ 0RGHQD/ &DSSHOOL/ 4;:61 :8
4445
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
0RGHQD/ DQFK·HVVD GLYHQXWR RJJHWWR GL LQWHUHVVDQWH GLVDPLQD +0217(&&+,,1 /D 'HSXWD]LRQH KD VHPSUH FRQVLGHUDWR OD FLWWj QHOOD VWRULD GHOOD FRPSOHV0 VLWj GHL VXRL DVSHWWL XUEDQLVWLFL/ DUFKLWHWWRQLFL/ DUWLVWLFL1 3LD]]DOH 61 )UDQFHVFR +%(578==,,/ L FDQDOL GHOOD FLWWj +0$1,&$5',> 0(6625,0521&$*/,$,/ OD FKLH0 VD GL 61 $JRVWLQR +0$1,&$5',,/ OD FKLHVD GL 61 9LQFHQ]R +0$57,1(//,0 %5$*/,$,/ O·HGLILFLR GHOO·$OEHUJR GHL 3RYHUL +91 61 %$5,2/$> %$5$&&+,,/ LO SDOD]]R GXFDOH +%$5*+,1,> 9$1 %(5*(,-.> 9,&,1,,/ OD 0RGHQD VFRPSDUVD +1$11,1,, FRPSDLRQR QHL YROXPL GL ´$WWL H 0HPRULHµ DFFDQWR D VWXGL GL LQ0 WHUHVVH SL• VSHFLILFDWDPHQWH DUWLVWLFR FRPH OD TXDGUHULD (VWHQVH/ JOL LQYHQWDUL GL RSHUH GHO SDOD]]R GXFDOH/ OH VRSSUHVVLRQL QDSROHRQLFKH H LO UHFXSHUR GD SDUWH GL $QWRQLR %RFFRODUL GHOOH RSHUH G·DUWH DVSRUWDWH +%$5$&&+, *,29$1$5',,/ OD *DOOHULD &DPSRUL +01 &$0325,,/ RSHUH GL DUWLVWL PRGHQHVL FRPH $GHRGDWR 0DODWHVWD/ /XLJL 0DQ]LQL/ /XLJL 3ROHWWL +*8$1'$/,1,> 0$57,1(//, %5$*/,$> /8&&+(6,,/ QRQFKq OH $FFDGHPLH GL SLWWXUD +%$5$&&+,> *5$1$> 0$/086,, H IXRUL FLWWj OH RSHUH JUDQGLRVH GHO VRVWHJQR GL %RPSRUWR +&(//,,/ GHOOD UHJRODPHQWD]LRQH GHL ILXPL +%2572/, *,//,,/ GHOO·DSHUWXUD GHOOD YLD 9DQGHOOL +*1 %2572/277,> *,520,1,,/ SHU QRQ WDFHUH GHJOL DIIUHVFKL FKH DGRUQDQR LO SDOD]]R GXFDOH GL 6DVVXROR +0256(//,, H GHO0 OH FHUDPLFKH VDVVROHVL FKH DUULFFKLYDQR OD WDYROD GHJOL (VWHQVL +/,9(5$1,,1 &KH JOL (VWHQVL DPDVVHUR GLYHUWLUVL q GRFXPHQWDWR DPSLDPHQWH GDO ORUR LQWHUHVVH SHU OH IHVWH/ OD PXVLFD H OH UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQL WHDWUDOL +$1'5(2/,> /8&&+,> /8,1> 521&$*/,$,1 1RQ PDQFDQR QRWH VXOO·DPSOLVVLPR H LPSRUWDQWLVVLPR DUFKLYLR PXVLFDOH FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH/ FKH FRPSUHQGH DQFKH XQD ULFFD VHULH GHOOH RSHUH GL $OHVVDQGUR 6WUDGHOOD +&$7(/$1,,1 ,O WHD0 WUR HUD IUHTXHQWDWR VLD D 0RGHQD +%$//(77,, FKH D 6DVVXROR +&,21,1,, H PROWR VSHVVR YHQLYDQR UDSSUHVHQWDWH FRPPHGLH XVFLWH GDOOD SHQQD GL VFULW0 WRUL ORFDOL/ FRPH ´/D FDVD GL FRUUH]LRQHµ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
0RGHQD QHOOD VWRULRJUDILD SRVW0XQLWDULD
4446
/·DVSHWWR VFLHQWLILFR q QDWXUDOPHQWH PHQR UDSSUHVHQWDWR/ FRQVLGHUDWD DQFKH OD IRUPD]LRQH FXOWXUDOH GHOOD PDJJLRU SDUWH GHL 6RFL/ HG HVVHQGR TXHVWR FD0 UDWWHUH IRQGDPHQWDOH GHOO·$FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH HG $UWL1 , PHGLFL DSSDUWHQHQWL DO VRGDOL]LR KDQQR QDWXUDOPHQWH WUDWWDWR PROWR VSHVVR O·DUJRPHQWR VWRULFR0PHGLFR/ VRWWROLQHDQGR JOL DVSHWWL SULQFLSDOL GHJOL VWXGL DQDWRPLFL D 0RGHQD/ OR VYLOXSSR GHOO·8IILFLR GHL &RQVHUYDWRUL GHOOD 6DQLWj GDOO·HSRFD IHUUDUHVH ILQR DOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD H SUREOHPL GL LQTXLQDPHQWR DW0 PRVIHULFR +3(5,&/( ', 3,(752,/ OD PHGLFLQD LQ HWj LOOXPLQLVWLFD +1$11,1,,1 Ë VWDWR DIIURQWDWR/ QDWXUDOPHQWH GD XQ SXQWR GL YLVWD VWRULFR/ O·DUJRPHQWR GHOOH JUDQGL HSLGHPLH FKH VL VRQR DEEDWWXWH VXO 'XFDWR/ LO FROHUD D 0DVVD +%$5$77,1,,/ LO FROHUD D 3LHYHSHODJR +*+,%(//,1,,/ OD SHVWH D 0RGHQD +5$6(//,,/ OD SHVWH D )RUPLJLQH +9$/'5,*+,,/ LO WLIR D 0DVVD +686,1,,1 $OWUL VWXGL ULJXDUGDQR LO FROOH]LRQLVPR ERWDQLFR +$1721,1,,/ DFFDGHPLH H FRQJUHVVL GL VFLHQ]LDWL +%$//(77,,/ OD PDWHPDWLFD H L PDWHPDWLFL 5LFFDUGL H 5XIILQL +%$5%,(5,,/ LO SHWUROLR GL 0RQWHJLEELR +7(55$&+,1,,/ DQWLFKH PLVXUH GL FDSDFLWj +7$5',1,,/ JOL VWXGL JHRJUDILFL GL *LDFRPR &DQWHOOL +9,6&+,,1 ,Q VHQR DOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH q VWDWR DIIURQWDWR DQFKH O·DVSHWWR HFRQRPLFR ULJXDU0 GDQWH 0RGHQD/ OD %DVVD 0RGHQHVH H 0DVVD &DUUDUD/ LQ JHQHUDOH +%$5$77,1,/ &$77,1,/ *+,'21,/ 38&&,, H FRJOLHQGR DVSHWWL SDUWLFRODUL/ FRPH O·HFRQRPLD H OD WUDGL]LRQH GLVWLOODWRULD D 0RGHQD +%(5*21=,1,,/ OD VWRULD GHOOH IHUURYLH PRGHQHVL H DO ULJXDUGR L UDSSRUWL WUD )UDQFHVFR 9 H %D\DUG 'H 9ROR +%25*+,0=$*121,,/ OD ODYRUD]LRQH GHOOH SLHWUH GXUH +*1 &$0325,,/ OD FRO0 WXUD GHOOD FDQDSD D )LQDOH DO WHPSR GL &HVDUH )UDVVRQL +)5$662/'$7,,/ O·DJULFROWXUD DOO·HSRFD GHO 0XUDWRUL +3$5,6,,/ OD ULYROWD ILVFDOH GHO 4:6: H O·DVVDOWR DO ERVFR GHOOD 6DOLFHWD LQ HSRFD QDSROHRQLFD +38&&,,/ OH GRJDQH H OD PDULQD PHUFDQWLOH HVWHQVH +*,$03$2/,,1 $OFXQL FRQWULEXWL GL FDUDWWHUH DUFKHRORJLFR SRVVRQR HVVHUH ULFROOHJDWL DOO·HSRFD GL 0RGHQD &DSLWDOH= OD ULFHUFD GHOO·LQWHUHVVH VWRULFR0DUFKHRORJLFR QHOOD SXE0 EOLFLVWLFD GHOOD SURYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD GDO 4;33 LQ SRL +%$==$1,, H OD WRSRQR0 PDVWLFD QHJOL VWXGL GHO SDGUH JHVXLWD 6WDQLVODR %DUGHWWL/ WHRORJR GL &RUWH +&$/=2/$5,,1 $QFKH O·DPELWR VWRULFR0UHOLJLRVR q VWDWR WRFFDWR/ SHU OD SUHVHQ]D WUD L VRFL GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL FXOWRUL GHOOD PDWHULD H GL UHOLJLRVL1 6RQR VWDWL VWHVL XQD VWRULD GHOO·RUGLQH GHL 6HUYLWL GL %RPSRUWR +%2572/, *,//,, H XQ TXDGUR GHOOD UH0 VWDXUD]LRQH GHJOL RUGLQL IHPPLQLOL D 0RGHQD VRWWR 3LR 9,, +58662,1 /HJDWR DOO·LQWHUHVVH SHU OD VWRULD GHJOL RUGLQL UHOLJLRVL q DQFKH OR VWXGLR GHOOH YDULH RSH0 UH DVVLVWHQ]LDOL= LO 0RQWH GL 3LHWj D 5HJJLR +%$//(77,, H D 0RGHQD +0$/086,,/
4447
3DROD 'L 3LHWUR /RPEDUGL
LO 0RQWH GHL 3HJQL H O·$OEHUJR GHL 3RYHUL +%$5$&&+,,/ LO 'HVFR GHL 3RYHUL 9HUJRJQRVL +3(5,&/( ', 3,(752/ 0$/086,,/ OD 6DQWD 8QLRQH GHJOL ,VWLWXWL 3LL GL 0RGHQD/ LO &ROOHJLR GHOOH RUIDQH GL 61 *HPLQLDQR +0$/086,,/ JOL RVSH0 GDOL GL 0RGHQD H GL 5HJJLR +%(572/$1, '(/ 5,2,/ O·DVVLVWHQ]D DJOL LQYDOLGL QHO SHQVLHUR PXUDWRULDQR +3(5,&/( ', 3,(752,1 /D UHDOL]]D]LRQH GL PROWH GHOOH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL FXOWXUDOL FLWWDGLQH q OHJDWD DOO·DWWLYLWj SURPR]LRQDOH VYROWD GDOOH EDQFKH PRGHQHVL/ FRPH OD )RQGD]LRQH 5R0 OR %DQFD 47:6/ OD %DQFD 3RSRODUH GHOO·(PLOLD 5RPDJQD/ LO %DQFR 61 *HPL0 QLDQR H 61 3URVSHUR ² %DQFD 3RSRODUH GL 9HURQD/ OD )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5L0 VSDUPLR GL 9LJQROD/ OD )RQGD]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL &DUSL/ OD )RQGD0 ]LRQH &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0RGHQD H OD &DVVD GL 5LVSDUPLR GL 0LUDQGROD/ FKH KDQQR FXUDWR FRQYHJQL/ PRVWUH H VRSUDWWXWWR OD ULHGL]LRQH GL RSHUH IRQ0 GDPHQWDOL SHU OD FRPSUHQVLRQH GHOOD VWRULD GHO QRVWUR SDVVDWR/ VSRQVRUL]]DQ0 GR SXEEOLFD]LRQL H FDWDORJKL1 )LQR DG RUD VRQR VWDWL SUHVL LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH L SHULRGL SL• LPSRUWDQWL GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD FLWWj/ GDOOD 0RGHQD HVWHQVH SULPD GHO WUDVIHULPHQWR GHOOD &DSLWDOH/ DOO·HSRFD VHWWHFHQWHVFD H ULVRUJLPHQWDOH ILQR DOO·8QLWj1 &RQ O·LQWHJUD]LRQH GHJOL VWXGL DUFKHRORJLFL FRQGRWWL VXOO·HWj SUHLVWRULFD/ VXOO·HSRFD URPDQD H VXO 0HGLRHYR/ OD VWRULRJUDILD PRGHQHVH SRVW0XQLWDULD WHQGH JLj YHU0 VR XQD VWRULD GHOOD FLWWj/ PD XQD VWRULD JOREDOH HG RUJDQLFD QRQ HVLVWH DQFRUD/ DQFKH VH WDQWR PDWHULDOH q VWDWR VYLVFHUDWR H YDOXWDWR/ PROWLVVLPL GRFXPHQWL VRQR VWDWL ULSRUWDWL LQ OXFH GDL QRVWUL DUFKLYL H L WHPL IRQGDPHQWDOL FKH UL0 JXDUGDQR LO SHULRGR GHOOD &DSLWDOH VRQR JLj VWDWL GLVFXVVL1 *OL VWXGLRVL DGDWWL D LPSHJQDUVL QHOOH ULFHUFKH VXOOD VWRULD PRGHQHVH GDOOH RULJLQL DL QRVWUL JLRUQL QRQ PDQFDQR/ PD/ FRQVLGHUDWD OD FRQVLVWHQ]D GHO PDWHULDOH/ QRQ VL SXz SHQ0 VDUH FKH XQ·XQLFD SHUVRQD DIIURQWL LO JUDYRVR LPSHJQR GHOO·LQGDJLQH DUFKLYL0 VWLFD H GHOOD ULHODERUD]LRQH GL TXDQWR JLj SURGRWWR LQ PDWHULD1 (· QHFHVVDULR O·LQWHUYHQWR GL SL• DXWRUL/ VSHFLDOLVWL QHL YDUL VHWWRUL/ DVVLVWLWL GD XQ FRRUGLQD0 WRUH SHU FRQIHULUH DOO·RSHUD RUJDQLFLWj H XQLWDULHWj1
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
4448
0$57,12 &$38&&,
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
1RQ q SRVVLELOH GDUH TXL XQD GHVFUL]LRQH R QRWL]LD VWRULFD/ DQFKH VROR DE0 ER]]DWD/ GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD LQ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH1 1HPPHQR OD OHWWHUDWXUD SL• VFDOFLQDWD SRWUHEEH HVVHUH FRPSUHVVD QHL OLPLWL ULFKLHVWL1 /D OHWWHUDWXUD GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH VL VWHQGH SHU 595 DQQL H VH QH GHYH SDUODUH QRQ VHFRQGR LO FRQFHWWR FKH RJJL DEELDPR GL OHWWHUDWXUD/ PD WHQHQGR FRQWR GL TXHO SULQFL0 SLR GL XQLWj H FRQYHUJHQ]D GHL VDSHUL FKH q SURSULR GHOOD FXOWXUD GL DQFLHQ Up0 JLPH/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH GDOOD PHWj GHO 6HL DOOD ILQH GHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ H SHU LO TXDOH/ DFFDQWR D SRHWL H SURVDWRUL/ WHDWUDQWL/ VWRULFL/ RUDWRUL H WUDWWDWLVWL/ VWDQQR ² H VSHVVR VRQR OH VWHVVH SHUVRQH ² QDWXUDOLVWL/ VFLHQ]LDWL/ PHGLFL/ ILORVRIL/ JLXULVWL/ PDWHPDWLFL/ JUDPPDWLFL H FXOWRUL GHOOH DUWL/ SHUFKp DQFKH OH EHOOH DUWL/ FRPH SRL DYUHEEH GHWWR 7LUDERVFKL/ KDQQR QHFHVVDULD FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ OH VFLHQ]H1 6HPEUD QHO FRPSOHVVR SL• XWLOH SURSRUUH LQ TXHVWD VHGH DOFXQH TXHVWLRQL JH0 QHUDOL H WUDFFLDUH ² LQ PRGR FHUWDPHQWH DSSURVVLPDWLYR ² DOFXQH OLQHH GRPL0 QDQWL/ FKH GLVHJQDQR XQ TXDGUR GL VWRULD OHWWHUDULD FRPSRVLWR H SXUH GL VLQ0 JRODUH FRHUHQ]D +FKH QRQ q XQLIRUPLWj,/ R SHU LO ULVDOWR FKH DVVXPRQR LQ TXH0 VWR WHUULWRULR R SHUFKp ULVSRQGRQR D WUDGL]LRQL GL OXQJD GXUDWD1 &Lz QHOOR VSL0 ULWR GHOO·DXVSLFLR SL• YROWH IRUPXODWR +GD XOWLPR/ LQ TXHVWD VHGH/ GD $OEDQR %LRQGL, FKH VL JLXQJD D SURGXUUH TXHOOD JUDQGH VWRULD GL 0RGHQD GL FXL D0 YUHPPR ELVRJQR H FKH LO ULOLHYR GHL IDWWL JLXVWLILFD DPSLDPHQWH1 3URFHGHUz GXQTXH SHU SXQWL HVVHQ]LDOL/ FRQ SDVVDJJL EUXVFKL H OLEHUR LQWUHFFLR GL DUJR0 PHQWL/ PD DQFKH FRQ IUHTXHQWL UHIHUHQ]H FURQRORJLFKH/ SHUFKp VLDQR IDWWL VDOYL L UHDOL UDSSRUWL QHO WHPSR1 D, 7HUULWRULR H FXOWXUD 0 Ë DSSHQD LO FDVR GL GLUH FKH SHU OD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD LWDOLDQD TXHVWR QHVVR KD VHPSUH XQ VLJQLILFDWR SULPDULR +SHU QHVVXQD FXOWXUD FRPH SHU OD QRVWUD VL SRWHYD VFULYHUH XQ JUDQ OLEUR LQWLWRODQGROR *HRJUDILD H
4449
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
VWRULD GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD LWDOLDQD,/ H LO GXFDWR HVWHQVH QRQ ID HFFH]LRQH1 1HO WHUULWR0 ULR +R/ SLXWWRVWR/ LQ XQ YDULHJDWR VLVWHPD WHUULWRULDOH/ QHO TXDOH VL GRYUHEEHUR FRQVLGHUDUH PXWDPHQWL/ GLVWDFFKL/ DQQHVVLRQL= OD SHUGLWD GL )HUUDUD/ O·DYYHQWR GHOOD &DSLWDOH/ OH VSHFLILFKH WUDGL]LRQL GL FXOWXUD ORFDOH/ GHO 5HJJLDQR/ GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ GL &DUSL/ GHOOD 0LUDQGROD, KDQQR HYLGHQ]D VSLFFDWD OH VSHFLILFLWj FXOWXUDOL ORFDOL H DQFKH/ SHUz/ XQD VLQJRODUH FRQWLQXLWj GL SURVSHWWLYH HWLFR0 LQWHOOHWWXDOL/ YHULILFDELOH VX WHPSL OXQJKL/ FKH YDQQR ROWUH ² SULPD H GRSR ² OH GDWH GHO 'XFDWR1 1RQ q XQ FDVR FKH SURSULR TXL/ SHU RSHUD GL XQ DEDWH EHU0 JDPDVFR SHUIHWWDPHQWH LQWHJUDWR QHOOD UHDOWj HVWHQVH/ YHQJD IXRUL WUD 4::5 H 4:<7/ QHOOH VXH GXH HGL]LRQL/ TXHOOD VWRULD GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD LWDOLDQD FKH FRPH QHVVXQ·DOWUD/ SULPD H GRSR/ KD VDSXWR UDSSUHVHQWDUH LQ PRGR HVHPSODUH XQ·LGHD HVWHQVLYD H RUJDQLFD +LQ XQD SDUROD/ WHUULWRULDOH, GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD> DQ0 FKH SHU LO ULOLHYR +QXRYR/ LQ TXHOOD SURVSHWWLYD, GDWR DOOD SUHVHQ]D GHOOH LVWLWX0 ]LRQL= WLSRJUDILD H HGLWRULD/ XQLYHUVLWj H VFXROD/ VRFLHWj DFFDGHPLFKH H VFLHQWL0 ILFKH1 1HO WHUULWRULR DOFXQH SHUPDQHQ]H VL RVVHUYDQR VHQ]D GLIILFROWj> SHU HVHP0 SLR OR VYLOXSSR VLFXUR GHJOL VWXGL GL ILORORJLD R LO IDWWR FKH LQ RJQL GLVFRUVR GL FXOWXUD q VHPSUH GRPLQDQWH XQD FRQVDSHYROH SURVSHWWLYD VWRULFD1 ,Q XQD VWR0 ULD GHOOD ILORORJLD URPDQ]D LWDOLDQD OD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH +H VL SXz DQGDUH GD *LDPPDULD %DUELHUL D *LXOLR %HUWRQL, KD XQD SUHVHQ]D GL YDORUH IRQGDWLYR1 $QFKH SL• ULOHYDWD OD FRPXQH GLVSRVL]LRQH D SURSRUUH RJQL GLVFRUVR LQ WHU0 PLQL GL FRQRVFHQ]D VWRULFD/ VL WUDWWL GL OLQJXD R GL OHWWHUDWXUD/ GL VWRULD ORQJR0 EDUGD H PHGLHYDOH/ GL DQDOLVL GHO EXRQ JXVWR R GHOOD WUDGL]LRQH SRHWLFD LWDOLD0 QD1 6SLULWL GL HWHURGRVVLD IXURQR VHPSUH QHOO·DULD> R/ SHU GLUH SL• VHPSOLFH0 PHQWH/ VHPSUH YLJLOH IX O·HVHUFL]LR GHOOR VSLULWR FULWLFR1 1HOOD FXOWXUD GHO 'X0 FDWR q/ LQ JHQHUH/ ULOHYDELOH LQ PRGR FKLDUR O·DXWRQRPLD GD WURSSR SUHVVDQWL WXWHOH HVWHUQH1 $QFKH OD FXOWXUD GL VFUXSRORVD RUWRGRVVLD FDWWROLFD IX WXWWDYLD DOLHQD GD VSLULWL ¶URPDQL·= SHUVLQR JOL HVWUHPLVWL GHO OHJLWWLPLVPR RWWRFHQWHVFR IXURQR JLXGLFL WXWW·DOWUR FKH WHQHUL GHOOH SUXGHQ]H FXULDOL/ FRQ XQ ULJRUH UHD0 ]LRQDULR GL FXL SXz HVVHUH EXRQ WHVWLPRQH XQ DGHSWR YLFLQR DOOH IRQWL HVWHQVL FRPH LO FRQWH 0RQDOGR /HRSDUGL1 /·RVVHUYD]LRQH VXOO·DXWRQRPLD GD LPSRVL0 ]LRQL FXULDOL YDOH VHQ]D GXEELR SHU DXWRUL FRPH %DFFKLQL H 0XUDWRUL1 1HO 4:45/ LQ XQ PHPRULDOH DO GXFD/ %HQHGHWWR %DFFKLQL YHQLYD JLXGLFDWR XQ FHU0 YHOOR WRUELGR/ WURSSR LQFOLQH D VRVWHQHUH OH LGHH LUUHJRODUL1 ,O JLXGL]LR q PDOH0 YROR PD QRQ SURSULDPHQWH IDOVR= LQ HIIHWWL LO %DFFKLQL q LO URYHVFLR GHO SHU0 VRQDJJLR ´URPDQRµ/ LQ QHVVXQ PRGR DVVLPLODELOH DOOD SXU PROWR YDULD IHQR0
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
444:
PHQRORJLD GHO SHUVRQDOH SROLWLFR0LQWHOOHWWXDOH SURGRWWR GDOOD &XULD URPDQD1 5RPD QRQ JOL SLDFHYD H/ DSSXQWR VFULYHQGR DO 0XUDWRUL/ GLFHYD FKH QRQ FL VDUHEEH YLVVXWR D QHVVXQ SDWWR/ QHSSXUH VH OR DYHVVHUR OHJDWR FRQ ODFFL G·RUR R GL SRUSRUD1 3L• SUXGHQWH/ PD QRQ GLYHUVDPHQWH RULHQWDWR/ LO 0XUDWRUL1 1HO FRQWULEXWR FKH 0XUDWRUL Gj DOOD FXOWXUD LWDOLDQD QRQ PHQR ULOHYDQWH GHOOR VWXGLR GHO PHGLRHYR q OD FXUD FRVWDQWH GL XQD VSLULWXDOLWj PLVXUDWD H VSUHJLX0 GLFDWD1 3HUVLQR LO YHUVDQWH ORFDOH GHOOD VXD FXULRVLWj/ D FXL DSSDUWHQJRQR OH ELRJUDILH GL DOFXQL PRGHQHVL LOOXVWUL +&DVWHOYHWUR/ 6LJRQLR/ 7DVVRQL,/ DWWHVWD OD VROOHFLWXGLQH YHUVR SHUVRQDJJL GL VHPSUH YLJLOH LQWHOOLJHQ]D FULWLFD1 ,Q XQ WH0 VWR FRPH LO 'H LQJHQLRUXP PRGHUDWLRQH LQ UHOLJLRQLV QHJRWLR +4:47,/ VHPSUH PROWR HQHUJLFR q LO ULFKLDPR DOOD QHFHVVLWj GL LQGDJDUH VX RJQL YHULWj/ H VXOOD YHULWj GHOOD IHGH SL• FKH VXOOH DOWUH/ VH VL YXROH GLPRVWUDUH/ FRPH q GRYHUH GHO GRWWR FDWWROLFR/ FKH OD IHGH QRQ UHSXJQD DOOD UDJLRQH1 0XUDWRUL DYHYD IDWWR WHVRUR GL XQ·RVVHUYD]LRQH GHO ERORJQHVH $QWRQ )HOLFH 0DUVLOL FKH JLXGLFDYD OD VWRULD VDFUD SL• PDOVLFXUD HG DSRFULID GHOOD SURIDQD= VH QH GHGXFHYD FKH PLUDFROL/ UHOLTXLH/ YLWH GL VDQWL/ ULYHOD]LRQL YDQQR VRWWRSRVWH D HVDPH ULJRURVR/ SHUFKp OD VWRULD HFFOHVLDVWLFD QRQ q RJJHWWR GL IHGH1 'HO UHVWR DQFKH GHO GRJPD q OH0 FLWR HVDPLQDUH UD]LRQDOPHQWH H FULWLFDPHQWH OH IRUPH LQ FXL VWRULFDPHQWH VL PDQLIHVWD H OH UDJLRQL JLXVWLILFDWLYH1 Ë GXQTXH JHQHUDOPHQWH YHULILFDELOH LQ DUHD HVWHQVH OD GLVWDQ]D FXOWXUDOH FRO PRQGR URPDQR H ¶XPDQLVWLFR· GL LPSLDQWR RUDWRULR> DVSHWWR FKH QHO FRU0 VR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR VL DFFHQWXD/ FRPH PRVWUDQR EHQH OH IUHTXHQWD]LRQL LQWHOOHW0 WXDOL H OH HVSHULHQ]H GL XRPLQL FRPH $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL +4:6904:;6, H /RGR0 YLFR 5LFFL +4:7504:<<,1 Ë EHQ YHUR FKH LO 3DUDGLVL JLRYLQHWWR FRPSLH L VXRL VWXGL QHO URPDQR &ROOHJLR 1D]DUHQR/ VROLGR EDOXDUGR GL LVWUX]LRQH XPDQLVWL0 FD/ PD O·LQVLHPH GHOOH FRPXQLFD]LRQL GHWHUPLQDQWL QHOOD VXD JHRJUDILD LQWHO0 OHWWXDOH VRQR EHQ DOWUH/ H YDQQR GDOOH WUDGX]LRQL GL 9ROWDLUH H &RQGLOODF DJOL VWXGL GL HFRQRPLD SROLWLFD DL UDSSRUWL FRO %HFFDULD H/ LQ VHQVR ODWR/ FRQ OD FXO0 WXUD ORPEDUGD1 E, 6WRULD GHOOD SRHVLD ² 'DOO·LGHD HVWHQVLYD GL OHWWHUDWXUD/ FKH SURSULR LQ TXH0 VWR WHUULWRULR KD LO VXR PDJJLRUH VWRULFR/ VL ULFDYD XQ IDFLOH FRUROODULR= QRQ q SHU OD OHWWHUDWXUD G·LQYHQ]LRQH FKH TXHVWD FDSLWDOH VL VHJQDOD1 ,O VXR/ QRQ VR VH PDJJLRUH PD FHUWR SL• UDSSUHVHQWDWLYR SRHWD/ 7DVVRQL/ YLYH SHU OR SL• ORQWDQR GD 0RGHQD= YL WRUQz WUH DQQL SULPD GHOOD PRUWH TXDQGR )UDQFHVFR ,/ FRQ XQ LQYHVWLPHQWR SHU O·LPPDJLQH QRQ WURSSR RQHURVR/ JOL RIIUu XQD SHQ0 VLRQH GL 633 VFXGL H VWDQ]D LQ FDVWHOOR1 6H VL JXDUGD DOO·LQVLHPH GHOOD SURGX0
444;
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
]LRQH WDVVRQLDQD ULHVFH GLIILFLOH LSRWL]]DUH XQ·LPSHWXRVD YRFD]LRQH SRHWLFD1 ,PSHWXRVD IX OD VXD YRFD]LRQH FULWLFD/ SUDWLFDWD FRQ XQD LQFRHUFLELOH WHQGHQ0 ]D DO SDUDGRVVR1 3XU VHQ]D SUHWHQGHUH GL DVVRJJHWWDUH DQFKH LO SRHPD D XQ·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH VHULD/ VHPEUD WXWWDYLD UDJLRQHYROH VRVWHQHUH FKH OD ULGX0 ]LRQH GHO 7DVVRQL DOOD FDWHJRULD GHO FRPLFR QRQ UHQGH JLXVWL]LD DOOD VXD RSH0 URVLWj OHWWHUDULD H QRQ DLXWD D FDSLUH OD PDVVLPD SDUWH GHL VXRL VFULWWL1 3HU OD 6HFFKLD 7DVVRQL VWHVVR SDUODYD GL ©VWUDOXQDWD SRHVLDª H VDUHEEH LO FDVR GL DVVH0 FRQGDUH OR VFULWWRUH QHO VXR WHQWDWLYR GL SURSRUUH GL Vp XQ ULWUDWWR ´JUDYHµ1 8Q VLQWRPR GL TXHVWD VHULHWj q DQFKH O·DOWD IUHTXHQ]D GL DWWHJJLDPHQWL/ QRWH/ ULIOHVVLRQL FKH KDQQR YDOHQ]D SROLWLFD1 &HUWR q GLIILFLOH VWRULFL]]DUH OH SRVL0 ]LRQL SROLWLFKH GHO 7DVVRQL/ VHPSUH IRUWHPHQWH XPRUDOL/ R TXDQWR PHQR JXDUGDUH D TXHVWR SUREOHPD VRWWUDHQGRVL DJOL DQDFURQLVPL FKH O·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH ULVRUJLPHQWDOH KD SRL LQFURVWDWR VXJOL VFULWWL SROLWLFL GHO 7DV0 VRQL1 5HVWD LO IDWWR FKH O·LQWHUHVVH SROLWLFR q YLYR H IUHTXHQWH> H ULHQWUD/ SL• LQ JHQHUDOH/ QHOOD FRVWDQWH LQFOLQD]LRQH GHOOR VFULWWRUH YHUVR LO JLXGL]LR QHWWR/ QRQ DPELJXR/ ¶VFDQGDORVR·/ VLD FKH ULJXDUGL DYYHQLPHQWL/ VLQJROL SHUVRQDJJL R LQWHUL SRSROL/ VLD FKH VL DSSXQWL VXOO·HVHUFL]LR LUUDJLRQHYROH H FLQLFR GHO SR0 WHUH1 ,Q RJQL SDJLQD VL PLVXUD OD VSUH]]DWXUD DULVWRFUDWLFD ² VSHVVR FHUWR DQD0 FURQLVWLFD ² GHOOR VFULWWRUH> VHPSUH GD DVFULYHUH DO VXR JXVWR/ XQ SR· LVSLGR H FHUWDPHQWH VFRPRGR/ GL QRQ HGXOFRUDUH OD UHDOWj1 6L YHGH EHQH/ GXQTXH/ FKH OD OH]LRQH WDVVRQLDQD WUDYDOLFD GL PROWR L FRQILQL GL XQD ULIOHVVLRQH GL SRHWLFD1 0D VH DQFKH YROHVVLPR FLUFRVFULYHUH DOOD VROD SRHVLD O·HVSHULHQ]D GHOOR VFULW0 WRUH/ YL GRYUHPPR ULFRQRVFHUH/ DO GL Oj GHL SL• HVWHULRUL HOHPHQWL FRPLFL H WDOYROWD IDUVHVFKL/ XQD ULFKLHVWD GL DXWHQWLFLWj FKH UDGLFDOPHQWH GLIIHULVFH GD SRHWLFKH FRHYH FRQQRWDWH GDOOD WHQVLRQH HVWUHPD YHUVR O·DUWLILFLR1 ,Q XQD VWRULD SHU JHQHUL/ DOFXQL YXRWL +GHOOD QRYHOOD H GHO URPDQ]R/ GHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD WHDWUDOH/ FRVu YLWDOH QHOOD )HUUDUD HVWHQVH/ WUD *1%1 *LUDOGL/ $JRVWL0 QR %HFFDUL/ 7DVVR/ *XDULQL, VDUHEEHUR DGGLULWWXUD YLVWRVL1 $QFKH VH OD 6HFFKLD UDSLWD H O·$GRQH +TXDVL LQ FRQWHPSRUDQHD = 4955/ 4956, FRQWULEXLURQR SHU YLH GLYHUVH D UHQGHUH LQIHFRQGR LO WHUUHQR VX FXL SRWHYD PHWWHU UDGLFL LO SRHPD/ O·DUHD HVWHQVH UHVWz LQ TXDOFKH PRGR SURGXWWLYD/ DQFKH FRQ HVLWL SL• FKH GH0 FRURVL/ DOPHQR QHO FDVR GHO &RQTXLVWR GL *UDQDWD +4983, GHO PDUFKLJLDQR *L0 URODPR *UD]LDQL/ QRQ SHU QXOOD VXFFHVVRUH GHO 7HVWL FRPH SRHWD +H VHJUHWD0 ULR= OD FRQQHVVLRQH PHULWD XQD VRWWROLQHDWXUD, HVWHQVH1 3HUDOWUR/ QHSSXUH O·DXUD HVWHQVH SRWHYD ULYLWDOL]]DUH XQ JHQHUH RUPDL FRQGDQQDWR GD PROWH UD0 JLRQL +QRQ XOWLPD O·DIIHUPD]LRQH FUHVFHQWH GHO GLVFRUVR LQ IRUPD URPDQ]H0 VFD,= YHUVR OD ILQ GHO VHFROR LO ´3RHPD HURLFRµ GHO JDUIDJQLQR )UDQFHVFR 3LH0
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
444<
UHOOL/ OD 9LHQQD GLIHVD +49<3, q WDQWR j OD SDJH SHU O·DUJRPHQWR TXDQWR PDUJLQD0 OH QHOOD VWRULD RUPDL GHFOLQDQWH GHOO·HSRSHD1 ,Q TXDOFKH FDVR OD OHWWHUDWXUD HVWHQVH KD FDUDWWHULVWLFKH HFFHQWULFKH ULVSHW0 WR D WHQGHQ]H GL JXVWR SL• FKLDVVRVH R ODUJDPHQWH DIIHUPDWH LQ XQ TXDGUR QD]LRQDOH1 /·RVVHUYD]LRQH ULJXDUGD SULPDULDPHQWH PD QRQ HVFOXVLYDPHQWH OD VWRULD GHOOD SRHVLD1 /·HVHPSLR GL PDJJLRUH HYLGHQ]D q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·DVVLOOR GHOOD VFDODWD VRFLDOH SHU YLH SROLWLFKH H GLSORPDWLFKH/ L VRJQL VPLVXUDWL FROWLYDWL LQ XQD FRU0 WH SURYLQFLDOH FRQ LQHYLWDELOL HVLWL GL IUXVWUD]LRQH/ LO GUDPPD GL XQ·DPEL]LRQH YRWDWD DO IDOOLPHQWR1 ,O PDJLVWHUR WHVWLDQR IX XQ IHQRPHQR WDUGLYR/ FKH PLVH UDGLFL SDVVDWD OD PHWj GHO VHFROR/ TXDQGR OD UHVLVWHQ]D DO EDURFFR VL DUPz DQFKH GL UDJLRQL WH0 RUHWLFKH1 $QFKH D OHWWHUDWL GL DOWLVVLPR ULOLHYR FRPH &DUOR GH· 'RWWRUL/ OD SR0 HVLD GHO 7HVWL SDUYH OD ULVSRVWD SL• VHULD H GXUDWXUD/ DQFKH SHUFKp SDVVLRQDO0 PHQWH PRWLYDWD/ D WXWWH OH SRHWLFKH GHOO·µHFFHVVRµ FRQFHWWLVWLFR R GHOO·HVWHQXD]LRQH ODVFLYD1 ,Q VHJXLWR/ L ULJLGL DSRORJHWL IUDQFHVL GHO FODVVLFLVPR FRPH %RXKRXUV H 5DSLQ DYUHEEHUR VDOYDWR LO VROR 7HVWL QHOOD FRUURWWD SRHVLD LWDOLDQD> H DQFRUD QHO JLXGL]LR OHRSDUGLDQR 7HVWL q/ D FRQWL IDWWL/ LO PDJJLRU SRHWD GHO 6HLFHQWR= VH IRVVH YHQXWR LQ HWj PHQR EDUEDUD VDUHEEH VWDWR LO QR0 VWUR 2UD]LR/ IRUVH SL• FDOGR/ YHHPHQWH H VXEOLPH GHO ODWLQR> JLXGL]LR LQDFFHW0 WDELOH H QRQGLPHQR VLJQLILFDWLYR1 4XDQGR ² GRSR OH YDULH H FRQWUDGGLWWRULH HVSHULHQ]H JLRYDQLOL ² DUULYz D GHILQLUH OH FRRUGLQDWH GHO SURSULR JXVWR OHWWH0 UDULR/ 7HVWL QRQ HEEH GXEEL QHO ULFRQRVFHUH LQ 2UD]LR XQD JXLGD FRVWDQWH H VLFXUD1 &RQ TXHVWH SUHPHVVH/ q VFRQWDWR FKH LO WHVVXWR GL IRQGR GHOOD VXD SR0 HVLD VLD RUDWRULR= OD PRUDOLWj DIILRUD VHPSUH FRPH LQVHUWR HVRUQDWLYR LQ RJQL FRPSRVL]LRQH> FRPH VHPSUH q PDQLIHVWD OD SUHRFFXSD]LRQH GL SHUYHQLUH D XQ GLVFRUVR SRHWLFR GHQVR/ FKH DO OHWWRUH FKLHGH WHQVLRQH HPRWLYD SL• FKH QRQ JOL FRQFHGD SDXVH ULSRVDWH H GLVWHVH1 7XWWDYLD/ ULFRQRVFLXWL L SHVDQWL OLPL0 WL RUDWRUv/ YD GHWWR FKH LO FODVVLFLVPR WHVWLDQR HUD DQLPDWR GD XQD DXWHQWLFD SDVVLRQH PRUDOH H GDOOD FRQYLQ]LRQH/ LQJHQXD PD VFKLHWWD/ FKH IRVVH SRVVLEL0 OH ULQQRYDUH OD SRHVLD GDOO·LQWHUQR QRQ SHU PHUR HVHUFL]LR IRUPDOH PD SHU
4453
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
YLUW• ULJHQHUDWULFH GL YDORUL HWLFL1 &RQFHWWL GL TXHVWR JHQHUH/ LQ XQ TXDGUR GL FRQYLQ]LRQL SRHWLFKH ´RUD]LDQHµ KDQQR XQD OXQJD YLWDOLWj QHOOD VWRULD GHOOD SRHVLD HVWHQVH1 4XL QRQ DWWHFFKLURQR VSHULPHQWDOLVPL VRYYHUWLWRUL GHOOD PL0 VXUD FODVVLFD H GRPLQDURQR L YDORUL GHOOD FRQWLQXLWj/ XQ VLFXUR OHJDPH FRQ OD WUDGL]LRQH JUHFR0ODWLQD/ FRQ XQ SDUWLFRODUH RFFKLR GL ULJXDUGR SHU 2UD]LR/ PDVVLPR PRGHOOR LGHDOH= FRVu DQFKH SHU WXWWD OD SRHVLD GHO VHFRQGR 6HWWHFHQ0 WR/ GL $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL +4:6904:;6,/GL /XLJL &HUUHWWL +4:6;04;3;,/ GL )UDQ0 FHVFR &DVVROL +4:7<04;3;,> DXWRUL/ QRQ D FDVR/ WXWWL YDULDPHQWH LPSRUWDQWL QHOOD IRUPD]LRQH GHO )RVFROR/ GHO /HRSDUGL/ GHO JLRYDQH 0DQ]RQL1 F, &DSLWDOH H &RUWH ² 4XHOOD GHO 'XFDWR q OHWWHUDWXUD GL FDSLWDOH/ QRQ/ SUR0 SULDPHQWH/ OHWWHUDWXUD FRUWLJLDQD1 6HQ]D QHJDUH O·HVLVWHQ]D GHO OHWWHUDWR0VHUYR/ O·RYYLR UDSSRUWR GL VXERUGLQD]LRQH GHOO·XRPR GL FXOWXUD QRQ YDUFD SHU OR SL• L FRQILQL GHOOD GLJQLWj/ DQFKH VH/ QDWXUDOPHQWH/ TXHO UDSSRUWR q YDULDELOH/ GL0 SHQGHQGR GDOOH FRQFUHWH VLWXD]LRQL VWRULFKH/ GDOOH FRPSHWHQ]H GHL OHWWHUDWL R PDJDUL GD PXWHYROL XPRUL GHO WHPSR1 ,QVRPPD/ JOL VFULWWRUL HVWHQVL QRQ IX0 URQR LQ JHQHUH YROJDUL WURPEHWWLHUL GHO SRWHUH1 %DVWL FRQVLGHUDUH/ DQFKH VROR QHOOH VXH OLQHH JHQHUDOL/ TXHOOD FKH SUREDELOPHQWH q O·LPSUHVD PDVVLPD GL JOR0 ULILFD]LRQH HVWHQVH= O·DSRWHRVL R/ DQ]L/ VXEOLPD]LRQH IXQHUDOH GHO SRWHUH FKH 'RPHQLFR *DPEHUWL 61-1 GLHGH QHOOD LSHUWURILFD ,GHD GL XQ 3UHQFLSH HW (URH FKUL0 VWLDQR LQ )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH111 HIILJLDWD FR· SURILOL GHOOH YLUW• GD 3UHQFLSL VXRL PDJJLRUL H0 UHGLWDWH/ UDSSUHVHQWDWD DOOD SXEEOLFD OXFH FR·O IXQHUDOH DSSDUDWR VSRVWR QHOOH VROHQQL HVHTXLH GDOO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD GL $OIRQVR ,9 VXR SULPRJHQLWR/ VWDPSDWD GD %DUWRORPHR 6ROLDQL1 )UDQFHVFR , HUD PRUWR LO 47 RWWREUH 498;> O·DSSDUDWR IXQHUDOH HUD GHOO·DSULOH GHO ¶8</ O·LPSULPDWXU GHOO·DSULOH 4993/ PD OD GDWD FKH LO WLSRJUDIR DS0 SRVH DO IURQWHVSL]LR q WXWWDYLD 498<1 6DUHEEH GHVLGHUDELOH FKH TXDOFXQR PHW0 WHVVH ILQDOPHQWH OH PDQL LQ TXHVWH 947 SDJLQH LQ IROLR H QH PHWWHVVH D QXGR O·DUWLFROD]LRQH FRPSOHVVD H O·DPEL]LRVD LQWHQ]LRQH GL GHULYDUH/ GDOOD YLWD H GDOOD PRUWH GHO SL• DUGLPHQWRVR VRYUDQR HVWHQVH/ XQ PRGHOOR GL HVHPSODULWj HWLFR0SROLWLFD1 /·LSRWHWLFR VWXGLRVR VL WURYHUHEEH GL IURQWH D XQ FRORVVDOH H0 VHUFL]LR HQFRPLDVWLFR/ PD LQ QHVVXQ PRGR/ FUHGR/ SRWUHEEH OLTXLGDUOR FRPH HVHUFL]LR GL VHUYLOH R PHUFHQDULD GHGL]LRQH1 /HWWHUDWXUD QRQ VHUYLOH= OD FRQVWDWD]LRQH QRQ WRJOLH QXOOD/ FRP·q QDWXUDOH/ DO GXUR UDSSRUWR GHJOL LQWHOOHWWXDOL FRQ OD &RUWH> DQFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR O·HVSHULHQ]D GHO 7HVWL q OD SL• VLQWRPDWLFD1 /D &RUWH IX LO FHQWUR GHO PRQGR PHQWDOH H PRUDOH WHVWLDQR= YHUR FRPSHQGLR GHOO·XQLYHUVR H SLHWUD GL SDUDJR0 QH GHJOL LQJHJQL1 ,Q TXHVWR PRQGR 7HVWL VL PRVVH LQ JHQHUH FRQ VFDUVD DJLOLWj/
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
4454
DGRSHUDQGRVL LQ YDUv PDQHJJL UHJRODUPHQWH IDOOLWL> H FLz LQGXFH D SHQVDUH FKH O·XRPR IRUVH YDOHYD SL• GHO FRUWLJLDQR1 1RQ q LQVLQFHUR +DQFKH VH SRUWD LO VXR WULEXWR D XQD PRGD GHO WHPSR, TXDQGR VFULYH= ©,R VRQR LQ PDVFKHUD H UDSSUHVHQWR XQD SHUVRQD FKH QRQ q OD PLDª1 Ë DSSHQD LO FDVR GL UDPPHQWDUH TXDQWR VLD YLYDFH SHU WXWWD OD SULPD PHWj GHO VHFROR OD GLVFXVVLRQH LQWRUQR DOOD ILJXUD H DOOH IXQ]LRQL GHO ´VDYLRµ LQ &RUWH1 ,O SRHWD HVWHQVH q XQ WHVWLPR0 QH GUDPPDWLFDPHQWH YLYR GHO FRQIOLWWR WUD OH UDJLRQL LQGLYLGXDOL H OD GXUD OR0 JLFD GHO SRWHUH1 ,O VXR LQWHUHVVH VWD IRUVH DQFKH QHO UDSSUHVHQWDUH XQD SRVL0 ]LRQH GL SDVVDJJLR ² H SHU FLz LQVWDELOH ² WUD LO OHWWHUDWR SXUR FKH QDYLJD QHO SHODJR GHOOD &RUWH H LO IXQ]LRQDULR FKH GHYH IDUH L FRQWL FRQ OH WHFQLFKH GHO JRYHUQR1 1HO GRPLQLR HVWHQVH/ ILQ GDL WHPSL GHO %DUELHUL/ O·XRPR GL FXOWXUD q/ FRQ DOWD IUHTXHQ]D/ IXQ]LRQDULR SLXWWRVWR FKH JDUUXOR OHWWHUDWR FRUWLJLDQR1 (QWUD0 QR LQ JLRFR YDORUL H FRRUGLQDWH GL JLXGL]LR FKH KDQQR D FKH IDUH FRQ O·HVHUFL]LR GHOOD UHVSRQVDELOLWj H GHOOH FRPSHWHQ]H SHUVRQDOL SLXWWRVWR FKH FRO SULQFLSLR GHO GRYXWR RPDJJLR DO VLJQRUH FRQ TXDOFKH FLFDODWD VHUYLOH1 $O YHU0 WLFH GL TXHVWD VFDOD GL UDSSRUWL GLJQLWRVL/ LQ FXL LO GRYHURVR RVVHTXLR DO VRYUD0 QR QRQ q VHUYLOLVPR/ VWDQQR XRPLQL FRPH %DFFKLQL/ 0XUDWRUL H 7LUDERVFKL/ PD OD OLVWD q OXQJD1 $QFKH LO 7HVWL KD/ LQ UDSSRUWR FRQ OD &RUWH/ XQD SRVL]LRQH FKH XQ SRHWD WDQWR SL• LPSRUWDQWH H GL UHSXWD]LRQH LQWHUQD]LRQDOH FRPH *LDPEDWWLVWD 0DULQR QRQ HEEH PDL1 1RQ FRQRVFLDPR FDGXWH FRUWLJLDQH QHO VHUYL]LR HVWHQVH GHO 0XUDWRUL1 1HO0 OD GHGLFD GHOOH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL +4:4:/ ,, SDUWH 4:73, D *LRUJLR , G·,QJKLOWHUUD +FLRq LQ XQD VHGH QDWXUDOPHQWH FHULPRQLDOH, q DIIHUPDWD VXELWR FRQ YLJRUH O·LQWHQ]LRQH GL WUDWWDUH OH RULJLQL HVWHQVL H OH DQWLFKH PHPRULH LQ PDQLHUD FKH YL FRPSDLD VROR OD ©VRGD PDHVWj GHO 9HURª H PDL VL IDFFLDQR DYDQWL ©OH EHOOH EXJLH GHOO·$GXOD]LRQHª> SURSRVLWR SRL EHQ DUJRPHQWDWR QHOOD VXFFHVVLYD OHW0 WHUD DL OHWWRUL/ GRYH VHQ]D PH]]L WHUPLQL q DVVHULWD O·LQIRQGDWH]]D FULWLFD GHJOL VFULWWRUL FKH KDQQR WUDWWDWR O·DQWLFKLWj H RULJLQH GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH1 0XUDWRUL VDSHYD EHQH FKH PROWL VWRULFL QRQ DYHYDQR OD FKLDYH SHU ULQYHQLUH OD YHULWj SHU OD EXRQD UDJLRQH FKH HUDQR SUH]]RODWL1 /H JHQHDORJLH HUDQR XQ WHUULWRULR GRYH DYHYDQR FRUVR OH IDYROH SL• LQGHFHQWL1 &L VRQR TXL SDJLQH GXUH FRQWUR OD SUDWLFD GL JHQHDORJLVWL VSUHJLXGLFDWL1 ,O VHQWLPHQWR GHO GHOLFDWR H QRQ VHPSUH LQFRQWURYHUWLELOPHQWH GHILQLELOH UDSSRUWR WUD LO PHVWLHUH GHOOR VWRULFR H OD YHULWj QRQ HUD QDWR FHUWR FRO 0XUD0 WRUL/ PD QHO WHPSR GL 0XUDWRUL TXHO UDSSRUWR VL DIIDFFLD LQ WHUPLQL JHQHUDOL/ FRQ XQD VWUXPHQWD]LRQH PHWRGLFD QXRYD H FRO VXVVLGLR GL XQD VHULH GL VFLHQ0
4455
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
]H DXVLOLDULH FUHVFLXWH LPSHWXRVDPHQWH QHO FRUVR GL DOFXQL GHFHQQL1 ,Q TXHVWD VHGH/ LO GHFLVR ULILXWR GHOOH IROH JHQHDORJLFKH KD YDORUH DQFKH FRPH VHJQR G·LQGLSHQGHQ]D GDOOD FDVD UHJQDQWH1 G, /D YLJLODQ]D FULWLFD FRPH FRVWDQWH H OD ULFHUFD VWRULFD 0 /D FXOWXUD HVWHQVH WXWH0 Oz JHORVDPHQWH L GLULWWL GHO JLXGL]LR FULWLFR1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR FDVR O·RVVHUYD]LRQH WUDYDOLFD L WHUPLQL FURQRORJLFL GHOOD FDSLWDOH SROLWLFD= EDVWL SHQ0 VDUH DOO·LQTXLHWD H VSHVVR LUULVSHWWRVD HWj GL /RGRYLFR &DVWHOYHWUR/ FRVu ULFFD GL IHUPHQWL HUHWLFDOL1 /·LQVHGLDPHQWR GHL VRYUDQL LPSRVH VHQ]·DOWUR GHL IUHQL H FLz LPSOLFD LO FRQWUROOR +DQFKH ULJLGR, GHL FRPSRUWDPHQWL PD QRQ VLJQLILFD GL SHU Vp FKH YL VLD XQ SURJHWWR GHO SRWHUH SROLWLFR SHU O·HVHUFL]LR GHOOD FXOWXUD1 /·DQWLFRQIRUPLVPR GHO 7DVVRQL/ DG HVHPSLR/ q IRUVH SL• JXVWR GHO SDUD0 GRVVR H GHOOR VEHUOHIIR FKH IUXWWR GL OLEHUWj PHQWDOH H LQWUDSUHQGHQ]D VSLUL0 WXDOH/ PD QRQ VL SXz QHJDUH FKH FRPXQTXH LVWUXWWLYD HUD OD OH]LRQH GL LQGL0 SHQGHQ]D FKH OR VFULWWRUH DYHYD GDWR VHPSUH1 7DVVRQL SRUWDYD D HVLWL QXRYL OR VSHULPHQWDOLVPR FLQTXHFHQWHVFR FRQ O·DYYLR GL XQ QXRYR JHQHUH OHWWHUDULR H FRO JXVWR GL XQD FULWLFD FDXVWLFD H SDUDGRVVDOH1 1DWXUDOPHQWH QRQ VL FHUFKH0 Uj LQ OXL SURIRQGD FRVFLHQ]D H QHSSXUH FRHUHQWH H VLFXUD HODERUD]LRQH WHRULFD +WDQWR q YHUR FKH VX XQ SUREOHPD FUXFLDOH SURSRVWR GDOOD VFLHQ]D DOOD FR0 VFLHQ]D PRGHUQD 7DVVRQL VWDUj FRL GLIHQVRUL GHOO·LPPRELOLWj GHOOD WHUUD,/ PD q SXU YLWDOH OD PRELOLWj GHJOL XPRUL UHFDOFLWUDQWL D XQD ULJLGD GLVFLSOLQD H GXQ0 TXH FDSDFL GL DFTXLVWDUH LQ FXULRVLWj LQTXLHWD TXHO FKH SHUGHYDQR GL LQFLVLYLWj VWRULFD1 ,Q DPELWR VWUHWWDPHQWH OHWWHUDULR/ ULVXOWD QLWLGD QHOOD FXOWXUD PRGHQH0 VH OD OLQHD GL FULWLFD DO PRGHOOR SHWUDUFKHVFR/ H LQVLHPH D TXHVWD OD FULWLFD GHO FHQWUDOLVPR OLQJXLVWLFR1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR ULVXOWDYD OD SULPRJHQLWXUD GHO &DVWHOYHWUR1 /D FXOWXUD FKH YHQQH SRL VL QXWUu GL PHQR ULJRURVH GLVWLQ]LRQL GRWWULQDOL/ PD GL DQFKH SL• DFXPLQDWL VSLULWL SROHPLFL H/ QHO FDVR GHO 7DVVRQL/ SDURGLFL1 1HOOH &RQVLGHUD0 ]LRQL VRSUD OH 5LPH GHO 3HWUDUFD GHO 493< LO SRHWD GHO 7UHFHQWR q SXU VHPSUH LO ´SULQFLSH GH· OLULFLµ/ FRPH/ LQ DOWUR DPELWR/ $ULVWRWLOH H 2UD]LR UHVWDQR SXQWL GL ULIHULPHQWR VDOGL PD D 7DVVRQL HUD YHQXWR D QRLD O·RVVHTXLR FRQYHQ]LRQDOH FKH VL WUDGXFHYD +H O·LQWXL]LRQH UHVWD IHOLFH, LQ XQ LPSDFFLR R LQLEL]LRQH SHU FKL IDFFLD PHVWLHUH GL SRHVLD1 1HO 4:44 0XUDWRUL ULVWDPSDYD OH FRQVLGHUD]LRQL WDVVRQLDQH PDQGDQGROH LQVLHPH DOOH SURSULH RVVHUYD]LRQL VXOOH ULPH GHO 3H0 WUDUFD> DFFRVWDPHQWR FKH GL SHU Vp YDOHYD FRPH VHJQR GL JLXGL]LR LQGLSHQ0 GHQWH QHL FRQIURQWL GHO QRVWUR PDJJLRU OLULFR1 $QFRU SL• VLQWRPDWLFD GHOOD YLYDFLWj FULWLFD q OD GLVFXVVLRQH LQWRUQR DOOD QRUPD OLQJXLVWLFD/ GD &DVWHOYHWUR
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
4456
LQ SRL RVWLOH DOOD UHJROD]LRQH EHPEHVFD R FUXVFDQWH1 /·DSSDUL]LRQH GHO YRFD0 ERODULR GHOOD &UXVFD QHO 4945 VXJJHULYD DO 7DVVRQL XQD YLYDFH UHD]LRQH LQ GL0 IHVD GHL PRGHUQL H GHO ORUR XVR OLQJXLVWLFR1 7DVVRQL QRQ QHJDYD LO SULPDWR WRVFDQR PD FRQWHVWDYD/ VLD SXUH LQ IRUPH SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH LPSUHVVLRQLVWLFKH/ LO FRQFHWWR GL XQ·DXWRULWj QRQ OLPLWDWD QHO WHPSR/ ULILXWDYD O·DEXVR GL DUFDL0 VPL/ PRVWUDYD XQ QRWHYROH LQWHUHVVH SHU L GLDOHWWL LWDOLDQL ² FLRq SHU OD SOXUDOL0 Wj OLQJXLVWLFD ² FRQVLGHUDQGROL XWLOL SHU GHILQLUH LO FRQFHWWR GL XVR1 /D IRU]D GHOOD OLEHUWj PHQWDOH V·LQFDUQD DQFKH LQ DOFXQL LPSRUWDQWL HSLVRGL VFLHQWLILFL= TXHOOR FLQTXHFHQWHVFR GL *DEULHOH )DOORSSLR +485604898, H TXHOOL/ FKH ULHQWUDQR QHL WHUPLQL GL TXHVWD UHOD]LRQH H YL GRYUHEEHUR DYHUH DQ]L VL0 JQLILFDWR FHQWUDOH/ GL *HPLQLDQR 0RQWDQDUL +4966049;:,/ GL %HUQDUGLQR 5D0 PD]]LQL +496604:47, H GL /D]]DUR 6SDOODQ]DQL +4:5<04:<<,1 ,Q WXWWL TXHVWL FD0 VL LO UDSSRUWR FRO WHUULWRULR HVWHQVH q LQVWDELOH R SURYYLVRULR1 /D JLRYLQH]]D GL 0RQWDQDUL q PROWR PRELOH H VROR DOO·LQL]LR GHO 4994 $OIRQVR ,9 OR ULFKLDPz D 0RGHQD FRPH VXR ILORVRIR H PDWHPDWLFR/ PD GL Ou D SRFR LO GXFD PRUu H 0RQWDQDUL SDVVz D %RORJQD VX XQD FDWWHGUD GL PDWHPDWLFD H SL• WDUGL D 3D0 GRYD VXOOD FDWWHGUD GL DVWURQRPLD1 3DGRYD q OD ILQDOH GHVWLQD]LRQH DFFDGHPL0 FD GL 5DPD]]LQL/ PD LO OHJDPH FRQ OD FXOWXUD H OD VRFLHWj HVWHQVH IX IRUWH/ SHU UHOD]LRQL SHUVRQDOL H SHU O·LQVHJQDPHQWR PHGLFR1 1HO ¶<6 IX QHOOD UHGD]LRQH GHO JLRUQDOH EDFFKLQLDQR1 3L• WDUGL DQFKH OR 6SDOODQ]DQL/ DOODUJDQGRVL L VXRL LQWHUHVVL GDOO·LQL]LDOH FDPSR GHOOD ILVLRORJLD D RUL]]RQWL GL SL• RUJDQLFD DP0 SLH]]D/ SDVVz D 3DYLD/ VXOOD FDWWHGUD GL VWRULD QDWXUDOH RIIHUWDJOL GD 0DULD 7H0 UHVD1 ,O UDGLFDPHQWR GL WXWWL TXHVWL VWXGLRVL QHOOD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH q VHQ]·DOWUR SURIRQGR PD QRQ FRQWLQXDWLYR +DQFKH SHU )DOORSSLR LO SXQWR G·DUULYR q SD0 GRYDQR,= VH QH SXz IRQGDWDPHQWH GHGXUUH FKH OD FXOWXUD GHO 'XFDWR QRQ VHSSH RIIULUH VWUXWWXUH DGHJXDWH +DFFDGHPLFKH H XQLYHUVLWDULH, DOOD ULFHUFD VFLHQWLILFD> PD VHPEUD DQFKH IRQGDWR LO ULOLHYR FKH QHOOD SUDWLFD GL TXHVWL VFLHQ]LDWL OD SURVSHWWLYD VSHULPHQWDOH H OD FRQFUHWH]]D GHO GLVFRUVR FRQRVFLWL0 YR GL JUDQ OXQJD SUHYDOJRQR VXOOH VLVWHPD]LRQL WHRUL]]DQWL> D ULSURYD GHO UDGL0 FDWR LPSLDQWR VWRULFR H +VH GHO FDVR, ILORORJLFR GHOOD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH1 /D FDSDFLWj GL SHQVDUH VWRULFDPHQWH q LO OHJDWR PDVVLPR GHOOD FXOWXUD GL TXHVWR WHUULWRULR1 /LEHUWj PHQWDOH/ GLVSRVL]LRQH VFLHQWLILFD/ ULJRUH PRUDOH DJL0 URQR LQVLHPH/ SRWHQ]LDWL DO PDVVLPR QHOOD ULFHUFD VWRULFD1 ,O SULRULWDULR ULIHUL0 PHQWR DO 0XUDWRUL QRQ GHYH LPSHGLUH GL YHGHUH FKH LO SURFHVVR GL UHYLVLRQH H UHFXSHUR GHOOD PHPRULD VWRULFD QHJOL XOWLPL GHFHQQL GHO 6HLFHQWR H QHO SUL0 PR TXDUDQWHQQLR GHO 6HWWHFHQWR q XQR GHL SL• JUDQGL PRPHQWL XQLWDUL QHOOD VWRULD LQWHOOHWWXDOH GHOO·(XURSD1 $QFKH SHU TXHVWD UDJLRQH OD FXOWXUD GHO WHP0
4457
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
SR VD SURJHWWDUH LQ JUDQGH/ SHUFKp SXz FRQWDUH VX XQ DOWR OLYHOOR GL FLUFROD0 ]LRQH GHOOH LGHH/ SHUFKp q DWWHQWD DOOD RUJDQL]]D]LRQH HQFLFORSHGLFD GHO VDSH0 UH H DQFKH SHUFKp FRQRVFH XQ·DOWD WHQVLRQH PRUDOH/ FRQVDSHYROH FKH LO ODYR0 UR GHO OHWWHUDWR WURYD RUGLQH H VLJQLILFDWR DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ VLVWHPD GL UHOD]LR0 QL1 ,Q XQD SDJLQD HVHPSODUH GHOOD OHWWHUD DXWRELRJUDILFD DO FRQWH GL 3RUFuD 0XUDWRUL KD UDFFRQWDWR OD VXD YRFD]LRQH DOOR VWXGLR GHO 0HGLRHYR FRPH UL0 FRQRVFLPHQWR GL XQD UDGLFDOH VFHOWD HWLFD/ FLRq FRPH OD VFRSHUWD FKH LO YHUR YD SHUVHJXLWR SHU VH VWHVVR/ TXDQGR DQFKH VL PDQLIHVWL QHOOH IRUPH VJUD]LDWH H SHUVLQR RUULGH GL XQD HWj FKH JLXGLFKLDPR EDUEDULFD1 /LEHUR GDO SUHFRQFHWWR FODVVLFLVWLFR/ OR VFULWWRUH VL DSUH D XQ·LGHD LQWHJUDOH GL VWRULD/ FKH KD OD VXD UD0 JLRQ G·HVVHUH SL• SURIRQGD QHO ULFRQRVFLPHQWR GHO YROWR DXWHQWLFR GHO UHDOH= ©OD YHULWj SHU VH VWHVVD q VHPSUH XQ JUDQ EHOORª1 6LD OD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DOOD JXHUUD GL VFULWWXUH SHU LO GRPLQLR GL &RPDFFKLR/ VLD OH FRPSOHVVH ULFHUFKH SHU OH $QWLFKLWj (VWHQVL IXURQR IRQGDPHQWDOL QHOO·RULHQWDPHQWR GHJOL VWXGL GL 0X0 UDWRUL/ DQFKH SHUFKp VYLOXSSDURQR LQ OXL FRPSHWHQ]H GL DPELWR JLXULGLFR/ GL0 SORPDWLFR/ OLQJXLVWLFR/ QXPLVPDWLFR/ JHQHDORJLFR1 6H QRQ F·q GXEELR VXOOD FHQWUDOLWj GHJOL VWXGL LQWRUQR DO 0HGLRHYR/ YD SH0 Uz DIIHUPDWD FRQ FKLDUH]]D OD ORUR SURIRQGD FRQQHVVLRQH FRQ WXWWL JOL DOWUL LQWHUHVVL GL 0XUDWRUL1 /D ULFHUFD HUXGLWD DYHYD DQFKH TXHVWR JUDQGH PHULWR/ FKH HVVD FRQGXFHYD D XQD YLVXDOH FKH GDYD LO VHQVR GHOOD FRPSOHWH]]D H GHO UHVSLUR XQLWDULR GHOOD VWRULD/ SXUFKp QDWXUDOPHQWH OR VWXGLR IRVVH FULWLFDPHQWH RULHQWDWR1 /D ULFHUFD FRQVLGHUDYD L IDWWL/ OL SHVDYD H YDJOLDYD/ FRVWLWXHQGR XQ UHWLFRODWR GL SLFFROH YHULWj= DQFKH TXHVWR HUD XQ PRGR GL XVFLUH GD TXHOO·LGHD GL UHODWLYLVPR DVVROXWR FKH UHQGH QRQ GHWHUPLQDELOH ² H TXLQGL GL IDWWR LQHVL0 VWHQWH ² OD YHULWj1 ,O 0HGLRHYR FKH YHQLYD IXRUL GDOO·LPPDQH ODYRUR PXUDWR0 ULDQR HUD LPPXQH GD WXUEDPHQWL HVWHWL]]DQWL/ PLVWLFKHJJLDQWL/ VSLULWXDOLVWLFL1 (UD FRVWUXLWR VXOOH IRQGDPHQWD GL XQD VROLGLVVLPD WUDPD/ GHWWDJOLDWD H VLFXUD QHO VXR GLVSLHJDUVL QHO WHPSR> HVWHVD/ DQFKH VH QRQ HVDXVWLYD/ QHOO·RUL]]RQWH JHRJUDILFR> H VL GHYH GLUH FKH ILQDOPHQWH OD UHDOWj WHUULWRULDOH IDFHYD DJJLR VXO0 OH LQWHUSUHWD]LRQL G·LQVLHPH H GDYD XQD ULVSRVWD SUHYHQWLYD DOOH GLVWRUVLRQL LGHRORJLFKH VX FXL WDQWD FXOWXUD ILORVRIHJJLDQWH GHO SLHQR H WDUGR 6HWWHFHQWR VL VDUHEEH HVHUFLWDWD1 /R VWXGLR GHO 0HGLRHYR VL SURLHWWDYD SRL LQ XQD SUR0 VSHWWLYD QD]LRQDOH= OD QD]LRQH HUD LO JUDQGH VRVWUDWR VHJUHWR FKH VL HVSULPHYD QHO WUDYDJOLR GXULVVLPR GHL VHFROL RVFXUL FRPH VL HUD HVSUHVVR DWWUDYHUVR OD FLYLOH GRPLQD]LRQH GL 5RPD> H FRPH +DJJLXQJLDPR, VL VDUHEEH GRYXWR H0 VSULPHUH/ QHL WHPSL SL• VHUHQL FKH O·XPDQLWj GHO ;9,,, VHFROR RUPDL FRQR0
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
4458
VFHYD/ QHL WHUPLQL H QHOOH IRUPH GL XQ EXRQ JRYHUQR PLVXUDWR XPDQR UDJLR0 QHYROH1 8Q PRGR GL UDJLRQDUH/ GXQTXH/ FRQVXVWDQ]LDOPHQWH VWRULFR= QHO TXDOH LO QHVVR FULWLFD0YHULWj q OD VSLQD GRUVDOH VHQ]D OD TXDOH QRQ VL Gj QHSSXUH ULFHU0 FD1 /·LQFLSLW GHO 'LVFRUVR SUHOLPLQDUH DOOH OH]LRQL GL VWRULD GL $JRVWLQR 3DUDGLVL VXR0 QD FRVu= ©/D 6WRULD q GHJQD GHO QRPH GL VFLHQ]Dª HG q VXELWR FROOHJDWD DOOD VFLHQ]D SUDWLFD H VSHULPHQWDOH1 0D UHVWD/ GHOOD VWRULD/ XQ·LGHD FDOGDPHQWH RUD0 WRULD H LQ FHUWR PRGR GUDPPDWLFD/ D FRQIHUPD GHO IDWWR FKH QRQ VL Gj/ LQ TXHVWD FXOWXUD/ PHWRGR IULJLGR1 /D QDWXUD ¶VSHULPHQWDOH· YXRO VRWWUDUUH O·LGHD GL VWRULD DOOD VSHFXOD]LRQH DVWUDWWD/ PD OH ODVFLD WXWWD OD GUDPPDWLFLWj GHOOD SUHVD GLUHWWD FRQ L IDWWL1 /·DUFKHWLSR PXUDWRULDQR +H VLJRQLDQR, q LPSUHVFLQ0 GLELOH PD RUPDL SHU PROWL DVSHWWL ORQWDQR1 )RQGDPHQWDOH QHO ODYRUR VWRULFR DSSDUH LO PRPHQWR GHOOD FRQFDWHQD]LRQH GHL IDWWL/ ©SHU PRGR FKH FLDVFKHGX0 QR VL YHJJD HVVHUH O·HIIHWWR GL TXHOOR FKH OR SUHFHGH/ H OD FDXVD GL TXHOOR FKH OR VHJXH> FRVLFFKp JOL DYYHQLPHQWL VL FRQFDWHQLQR QHO PRQGR PRUDOH FRQ TXHOOD VWHVVD FRQWLJXLWj FKH VL RVVHUYD QHO PRQGR ILVLFRª> DVVHU]LRQH LOOXPL0 QDQWH SHU PLVXUDUH OD VRVWDQ]LDOH GLVWDQ]D GDO 0XUDWRUL H SHU FRQYHUVR OD SURVVLPLWj FRQ WHVL GD LGpRORJXH1 &·q EHQVu O·RPDJJLR DOO·HUXGL]LRQH/ PD O·DSSDUDWR GL HUXGL]LRQH q JLXGLFDWR VXSHUIOXR H TXDVL LQXWLOH TXDQGR OR VWRUL0 FR QRQ VL SURSRQJD ©XQ SL• QRELOH RJJHWWR/ H SL• JORULRVR/ TXHOOR GHOOD SXE0 EOLFD IHOLFLWjª1 ,O QHVVR q PXUDWRULDQR> PD LO VHQWLPHQWR FKH VL KD GHOOD VWRULD FRPH ©WULEXQDOH GL YHULWjª q TXL LUULJLGLWR1 /R VWRULFR SUH]]RODWR/ FKH SURIRQ0 GH ORGH ©FRQWUR OD HTXLWj H OD UDJLRQHª QRQ KD VFDPSR= ©/D VHYHUD ILORVRILD SHUz QRQ VL ODVFLD LQJDQQDUHª> VSLD VLJQLILFDWLYD GL XQD RWWLPLVWLFD DVWUD]LRQH/ VWDQWH FKH/ QHO 6HWWHFHQWR FRPH GRSR/ OD VWRULRJUDILD SUH]]RODWD R DOWULPHQWL HQJDJpH QRQ q PHQR IUHTXHQWH FKH QHO SDVVDWR DQWLFR1 ,Q TXHVWH SDJLQH VL SUH0 FLVD GL IDWWR LO UDSSRUWR FRO 0XUDWRUL/ FLWDWR IRUVH SL• SHU GRYHUH FKH SHU FRQVHQVR VSLHJDWR H WRWDOH1 9L VRQR/ RYYLDPHQWH/ YDORUL PXUDWRULDQL RUPDL DFTXLVLWL VWDELOPHQWH/ PD HVVL VRQR DVVRJJHWWDWL D XQD IRUPD GL WRUVLRQH LGHR0 ORJLFD= HYLGHQWH LO IDWWR FKH QRQ SL• HOLPLQDELOH q OD ULFKLHVWD GHO ¶TXDGUR ILOR0 VRILFR·1 H, /D FRPXQLWj GHL GRWWL 0 ,Q XQD VWRULD LGHDOH GHOOD UHSXEEOLFD GHOOH OHWWHUH +PD WDORUD VL GRYUHEEH SDUODUH/ FRQ FRQFHWWR SL• LPSHJQDWLYR H PHQR UXJLD0 GRVR/ GL RSLQLRQH SXEEOLFD, OD FXOWXUD GHO 'XFDWR KD/ D SDUWLUH GDOOD ILQH GHO 6HLFHQWR/ XQD SUHVHQ]D VLJQLILFDWLYD> LQ XQ SDLR GL FDVL DVVROXWDPHQWH FHQWUDOH H GL RUL]]RQWH HXURSHR1 6WXGL UHFHQWL/ GRSR XQ VLOHQ]LR GXUDWR D OXQJR/ UHVWL0
4459
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
WXLVFRQR D %HQHGHWWR %DFFKLQL +498404:54, TXHOOD SUHVHQ]D FHQWUDOH FKH JOL FRPSHWH QHOOD VWRULD GHOO·HUXGL]LRQH WUD L GXH VHFROL> H LO YHUVDQWH PRGHQHVH GHO PDJLVWHUR EDFFKLQLDQR q VHQ]·DOWUR ULOHYDQWLVVLPR/ FRQVLVWHQGR QHOOD FRQ0 WLQXD]LRQH GHO ´*LRUQDOH GH· /HWWHUDWLµ H QHOOD VRFUDWLFD VFXROD GHO PRQDVWHUR GL 6DQ 3LHWUR/ ROWUH FKH QHOOD SL• YDJD PD QRQ PHQR VRVWDQ]LDOH LQIOXHQ]D H0 VHUFLWDWD VXO JLRYDQH 0XUDWRUL1 /·HVSHULHQ]D GHO %DFFKLQL H TXHOOD/ WDQWR SL• ULFFD/ GHO 0XUDWRUL VRQR SUH]LRVH DSSXQWR SHUFKp FL FRQGXFRQR QRQ QHOO·DWPRVIHUD/ WXWWR VRPPDWR ILWWL]LD H XQ SR· YDSRURVD/ GHOOD UHSXEEOLFD GHL GRWWL PD GHQWUR OH DUWLFROD]LRQL UHDOL GHL UDSSRUWL WUD XRPLQL GL FXOWXUD1 %DF0 FKLQL DYHYD FRVFLHQ]D OXFLGLVVLPD GHO IDWWR FKH LO ODYRUR GHO ´OHWWHUDWRµ WURYD RUGLQH H VLJQLILFDWR VROWDQWR DOO·LQWHUQR GL XQ VLVWHPD GL UHOD]LRQL H VDSHYD EHQH +H QH VFULYH DSSXQWR DO JLRYDQH 0XUDWRUL, FKH OD ULFHUFD HUXGLWD VL PR0 YHYD WUD GLIILFROWj HQRUPL/ HVVHQGR QHFHVVDULR PD WXWW·DOWUR FKH SDFLILFR LO UDSSRUWR FRQ OH JHUDUFKLH UHOLJLRVH H SROLWLFKH HG HVVHQGR DOWLVVLPL L FRVWL= OD PROWLWXGLQH GHL OLEUL GL FXL ELVRJQDYD SURYYHGHUVL VX XQ PHUFDWR HXURSHR/ LO FRVWR GHL FRSLVWL/ OD GLIILFLOH FLUFROD]LRQH GHJOL VFULWWL/ OD YDQLWj GL PHFHQDWL SL• LQWHUHVVDWL D XQ SUHVWLJLR GL IDFFLDWD FKH DOOD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHL OLEUL1 4XH0 VWD HVSHULHQ]D LQWHOOHWWXDOH FRVu JUHPLWD GL RVWDFROL KD QHO VXR IRQGR/ FRPH YDORUH DVVROXWR/ OD GHGL]LRQH VWUHQXD DOOR VWXGLR LQWHVD DQFKH FRPH FRQTXLVWD H JDUDQ]LD GL OLEHUWj LQWHULRUH1 7XWWDYLD OD IHOLFLWj GHJOL VWXGL QRQ q HVSHULHQ]D VROLWDULD> HVVD/ DQ]L/ SLHQDPHQWH VL FRPSLH QHO ULRUGLQDPHQWR GL ELEOLRWHFKH H DUFKLYL/ FKH VRQR LO OXRJR SULPDULR/ QRQ VROR VLPEROLFR/ GL TXHVWD YLFHQGD> QHOO·LQVHJQDPHQWR> QHOOD FRPXQLFD]LRQH GHL ULVXOWDWL> QHO ILWWLVVLPR VFDPELR HSLVWRODUH WUD L OHWWHUDWL/ FRQ XQ RUL]]RQWH FKH QRQ HVFOXGH SL• QHVVXQD FXOWX0 UD HXURSHD1 $QFKH LQ TXHVWR DPELWR OD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH SXz RIIULUH XQ PR0 QXPHQWR FRPH LO FDUWHJJLR PXUDWRULDQR1 1RQ HVLVWH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR LWDOLDQR XQ FRUSXV HSLVWRODUH FRVu PRQXPHQWDOH H YDULR GL LQWHUHVVH> FRVu FRPH HVWHVLV0 VLPD q OD WRSRJUDILD GHL FRUULVSRQGHQWL1 *OL LWDOLDQL SUHYDOJRQR LQ WXWWL L VHQVL VXJOL VWUDQLHUL> DQFKH VH QRQ PDQFDQR L FRUULVSRQGHQWL VWUDQLHUL GL YDORUH DV0 VROXWR= /HLEQL] VRSUD WXWWL1 7XWWDYLD/ GRSR OH JLRYDQLOL LQFOLQD]LRQL/ IDYRULWH GDOO·LPSLHJR QHOOD %LEOLRWHFD $PEURVLDQD/ YHUVR OD ILORORJLD ODWLQD H JUHFD/ 0XUDWRUL GHFLVDPHQWH RSWz SHU PDWHULH QD]LRQDOL/ SULPD LQ WHUPLQL OHWWHUDUL H GL ULIRUPD GHOOD FXOWXUD/ SRL QHOO·LPSHJQR GHOOR VWXGLR GHOOH IRQWL GHOOD VWRULD LWDOLDQD H GHOOD ORUR VLVWHPD]LRQH VWRULFD1 $QFKH GD XQD UDSLGLVVLPD HVSORUD0 ]LRQH GHO FDUWHJJLR PXUDWRULDQR ULVXOWD OD VLQJRODUH YDULHWj GL LQWHUHVVL> FDUDW0 WHUH FKH GLSHQGH VLD GDOOD SHUVRQDOLWj VWHVVD GHOOR VFULWWRUH/ LQFDSDFH GL FKLX0 GHUVL LQ XQ ULVWUHWWR FDPSR GL ULFHUFD/ VLD GDOOD UDPLILFD]LRQH YDULDWLVVLPD GHO0
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
445:
OH UHOD]LRQL VWDELOLWH QHO FRUVR GL XQ VHVVDQWHQQLR1 ,O JLRYDQH 0XUDWRUL JRGp GL XQ SUHFRFH SUHVWLJLR ILQ GDJOL DQQL PLODQHVL H YHQQH D WURYDUVL QDWXUDOPHQWH DO FHQWUR GL XQ VLVWHPD GL UHOD]LRQL PROWR YDULHJDWR1 /·LQVLHPH GHL FDUWHJJL FRQVHQWH GL UDFFRJOLHUH XQD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH SDUWLFRODUHJJLDWD VXOOD FLUFROD0 ]LRQH GHL OLEUL H VXO PHUFDWR OLEUDULR/ VXOOD YLWD GL DUFKLYL H ELEOLRWHFKH/ VXOOR VWDWR GHOOD ULFHUFD VWRULFR0HUXGLWD QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO VHFROR/ VSHVVR DQFKH VXJOL XPRUL GHL OHWWHUDWL/ FRQ QRQ GLVSUH]]DELOL FKLDULPHQWL GL RUGLQH HWLFR0 VRFLRORJLFR1 5LOLHYR VSHFLDOH KDQQR L FRUULVSRQGHQWL LQWHUHVVDWL R FRLQYROWL QHOOD JLJDQWHVFD UDFFROWD H UHYLVLRQH GHOOH IRQWL GHOOD VWRULD LWDOLDQD1 ,Q TXHVWL FDVL +PD QRQ VROR LQ TXHVWL, 0XUDWRUL q VRSUDWWXWWR XQ FROOHWWRUH GL LQIRUPD0 ]LRQH FRPH VH JXDUGDVVH OD VLWXD]LRQH FXOWXUDOH/ VH QRQ GDO GL IXRUL/ FHUWR GDOO·DOWR1 4XL VL PLVXUD/ FRQ SURYH FDSLOODUL H FRO PDVVLPR GL HYLGHQ]D/ OD IXQ]LRQH FRHVLYD H SURSXOVLYD GL 0XUDWRUL LQ XQ WHVVXWR GL FXOWXUD SURYLQFLD0 OH PROWR YDULR1 0XUDWRUL VHSSH SURPXRYHUH XQD FXOWXUD FKH VSHVVR/ GL SHU Vp/ HUD SRYHUD GL ILDWR/ OD IHFH HQWUDUH LQ XQ FLUFXLWR GRYH DQFKH PRGHVWL VWX0 GLRVL SURYLQFLDOL SRWHYDQR GDUH LO PHJOLR GL Vp1 I, , JLRUQDOL 0 6HQ]D QXOOD WRJOLHUH DO IDWWR FKH OD FXOWXUD GHOOD FDSLWDOH VL H0 VSUHVVH/ LQ IRUPD VXSUHPD/ QHOO·DWWLYLWj GHO 0XUDWRUL/ QHVVXQ FDPSR FRPH OD VWDPSD SHULRGLFD FRQVHQWH WXWWDYLD GL YHGHU PHJOLR QHOOH OXFL H QHOOH RPEUH OD SURLH]LRQH DOO·HVWHUQR GHOOD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH1 3HU XQ VHFROR H PH]]R/ WUD LO 49<5/ TXDQGR LO SDGUH %DFFKLQL WUDVIHUu TXL/ GD 3DUPD/ LO VXR ´*LRUQDOH GH /HWWHUDWLµ SXEEOLFDQGRQH TXDWWUR DQQDWH SLXWWRVWR LUUHJRODUL +4:<5/ ¶<6/ ¶<9/ ¶<;,/ H OD PHWj GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ 0RGHQD IX XQD GHOOH FDSLWDOL GHO JLRUQDOLVPR OHWWHUDULR1 /D ULSUHVD EDFFKLQLDQD VL FRQILJXUDYD FRPH LGHDOH FRQWLQXLWj GL XQ XQLFR ´JLRUQDOH GHL OHWWHUDWLµ D FXL L GRWWL FRQWULEXLYDQR FRPH RSHUD FRPXQH DYYLD0 WD GDO ´-RXUQDO GHV 6oDYDQVµ D 3DULJL QHO 4998 H ULSUHVD D 5RPD WUH DQQL GR0 SR/ FRQ TXHO JLRUQDOH ¶FRQFHUWDWR· WUD LO 1D]DUL/ LO &LDPSLQL/ LO 5LFFL D FXL/ SR0 FR R WDQWR/ WXWWL L SURPRWRUL GL LPSUHVH JLRUQDOLVWLFKH VL HUDQR ULFKLDPDWL LQ VHJXLWR FRPH OHJLWWLPL HUHGL1 /D FRPXQLWj GHL GRWWL DYHYD ULFRQRVFLXWR QHL JLRUQDOL XQR VWUXPHQWR FKH GDYD ULVRQDQ]D SXEEOLFD SURQWD HG HXURSHD DO GLDORJR HSLVWRODUH/ DVVLFXUDQGR XQD WHPSHVWLYD H FDSLOODUH LQIRUPD]LRQH OL0 EUDULD> H QH DYHYD DQFKH VWDELOLWR VXELWR ILQ GDO VXR DUFKHWLSR SDULJLQR OD IRUPD SHUIHWWDPHQWH IXQ]LRQDOH1 ,O JLRUQDOH GHO %DFFKLQL VWD SHU LQWHUR GHQ0 WUR OD VWRULD DOWD GHO JLRUQDOLVPR HXURSHR/ FRQ OD JLXQWD/ IRUVH/ GL XQ TXLG GL WHQVLRQH GUDPPDWLFD FKH PDQFD DL SHULRGLFL FKH DYHYDQR DOOH VSDOOH LVWLWX0
445;
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
]LRQL DFFDGHPLFKH XQLYHUVLWDULH H SUHVWLJLRVL JUXSSL LQWHOOHWWXDOL RSHUDQWL LQ VLQWRQLD FRO SRWHUH SROLWLFR H FRQVDSHYROL GHOOD SURSULD IRU]D1 /·RUL]]RQWH HX0 URSHR IX XQD FRVWDQWH GHO JLRUQDOH EDFFKLQLDQR/ DQFKH TXDQGR OH FUHVFHQWL GLIILFROWj HGLWRULDOL DYUHEEHUR ULGRWWR O·DIIOXVVR GL OLEUL VWUDQLHUL1 5LVSHWWR DO JLRUQDOH GHO %DFFKLQL/ TXHOOL GL )UDQFHVFDQWRQLR =DFFDULD 61-1 YHQLYDQR GRSR XQ YXRWR SL• FKH FLQTXDQWHQQDOH1 4XDQGR/ FKLDPDWR DOOD GL0 UH]LRQH GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD HVWHQVH QHO 4:87/ DYYLz/ FRO VHVWR WRPR/ OD VHULH PR0 GHQHVH GHOOD ´6WRULD OHWWHUDULD G·,WDOLDµ +SRL SUHVWR SVHXGR0PRGHQHVH SRLFKp LO JLRUQDOH IX GL QXRYR VWDPSDWR D 9HQH]LD/ PD FRQ GDWD GL 0RGHQD,/ OR =DF0 FDULD VYLOXSSDYD XQ VXR FRHUHQWH SURJUDPPD GL SROLWLFD FXOWXUDOH GDQGR FRU0 SR D XQ PRGHOOR GL SHULRGLFR D FXL VDUHEEH UHVWDWR IHGHOH QHOOD VXD OXQJD FDUULHUD GL SXEEOLFLVWD/ WUD 9HQH]LD/ 0RGHQD H 3HVDUR1 /D ´6WRULDµ DQGz DYDQ0 WL ILQR DO ¶8< H IX FRQWLQXDWD/ WUD LO ¶95 H LO ¶97/ GDJOL ´$QQDOL OHWWHUDUL G·,WDOLDµ1 ,QWRUQR DL GXH SHULRGLFL PDJJLRUL/ LO ´6DJJLR FULWLFR GHOOD FRUUHQWH OHWWHUDWXUD VWUDQLHUDµ H OD VXFFHVVLYD ´%LEOLRWHFD GL YDULD OHWWHUDWXUD VWUDQLHUD DQWLFD H PRGHUQDµ YHQQHUR TXDVL D FRVWLWXLUH XQD YHUD FRVWHOOD]LRQH/ PD Qp TXHOOD SROLWLFD FXOWXUDOH Qp OD IRUPD JLRUQDOLVWLFD DYHYDQR PROWR GD VSDUWLUH FRO PR0 GHOOR EDFFKLQLDQR1 5HVWDYD O·LPSLDQWR HQFLFORSHGLFR PD SLXWWRVWR FRPH DVSL0 UD]LRQH D XQ FHQVLPHQWR HVDXVWLYR GL TXDQWR QHL YDUL VHWWRUL SURGXFHVVH O·LQGXVWULD HGLWRULDOH/ FKH QRQ FRPH YRORQWj GL FDSLUH H GHVFULYHUH L QHVVL/ OH LQWHUIHUHQ]H/ OH JHUDUFKLH FKH UHJRODQR OH YDULH UHJLRQL GHO VDSHUH H L ORUR UDSSRUWL1 4XHVWL JLRUQDOL HUDQR LO EROOHWWLQR GL XQ DWWHQWR ELEOLRWHFDULR FKH QRQ VRSSRUWD ODFXQH JUDYL QHOOD VXD OLEUHULD H DQ]L LGHDOPHQWH OD YRUUHEEH GRWDWD GL WXWWD OD SURGX]LRQH FRUUHQWH/ WUDWWRQH IRUVH TXDOFKH OLEUR ¶SHUYHUVR· SURGRWWR GD XQD FXOWXUD UHOLJLRVDPHQWH LQGLVFLSOLQDWD H LQGLVFLSOLQDELOH1 'HO EXRQ ELEOLRWHFDULR OR =DFFDULD KD SHUz OH EXRQH TXDOLWj= OD FXUD GHOO·LQIRUPD]LRQH ELEOLRJUDILFD DWWHQWD H SUHFLVD/ OD FDSDFLWj GL VWDELOLUH FKLDUH H IXQ]LRQDOL FODVVLILFD]LRQL/ ULIOHVVR GL XQD PHQWH RUGLQDWULFH1 &RPSOHWDPHQ0 WH GLVSHUVR LO SDWULPRQLR GL DSHUWXUD YHUVR OH SRVL]LRQL DOWHUQDWLYH1 /D YLUX0 OHQ]D SROHPLFD GHO JHVXLWD =DFFDULD +FRQWUR JLDQVHQLVWL/ LQGLIIHUHQWLVWL/ PDWH0 ULDOLVWL H DQFKH QHL FRQIURQWL GL DOWUL RUGLQL UHOLJLRVL/ DJRVWLQLDQL H EHQHGHWWLQL DYDQWL D WXWWL, SURSRQHYD O·DWWLYLWj SXEEOLFLVWLFD LQ WHUPLQL UDGLFDOPHQWH GL0 YHUVL GD TXHOOL EDFFKLQLDQL1 9HUR q FKH QRQ JOL PDQFz LO SDWURFLQLR HVWHQVH/ H TXLQGL OD OHJLWWLPD UDSSUHVHQWDQ]D GL XQD FXOWXUD YLYDFH DQFKH VH RUPDL LQH0 YLWDELOPHQWH VXOOD GLIHQVLYD1 )UDQFHVFR ,,, FRSUu FRVWDQWHPHQWH LO JLRUQDOLVWD QHOOH VXH FRQWURYHUVLH FRQ O·RUGLQH H DQFKH GL IURQWH DL VXRL VWHVVL VXSHULRUL SUHRFFXSDWL GHOO·LPSDWWR FKH L JLRUQDOL SURGXFHYDQR FRQ OD IRU]D VWHVVD GHO
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
445<
VXR ODUJR RUL]]RQWH/ LPSDWWR SRWHQ]LDWR SRL GDOOD EDWWDJOLHUD GLVSRQLELOLWj GHO SDGUH =DFFDULD D SROHPL]]DUH VHQ]D UHPRUH1 6ROR YHUVR LO ¶97 OD WXWHOD GHO SR0 WHUH HVWHQVH VL DIILHYROu H LO GXFD ULFKLDPz OR =DFFDULD DL VXRL SULRULWDUL GRYHUL GL ELEOLRWHFDULR HVWHQVH1 0D L WHPSL HUDQR VHPSUH SL• RVFXUL SHU O·RUGLQH L0 JQD]LDQR/ FKH GL Ou D SRFR VDUHEEH VWDWR VRSSUHVVR1 /D VWRULD GHO JLRUQDOLVPR PRGHQHVH VL FKLXGHYD QHO 6HWWHFHQWR FRQ XQ YH0 UR PRQXPHQWR/ LO ´1XRYR JLRUQDOH GHL OHWWHUDWLµ GL *LURODPR 7LUDERVFKL/ LQ XQD DWPRVIHUD GL VRVWDQ]LDOH FRQWLQXLWj ULVSHWWR DOOD SUDWLFD HUXGLWD GHOOD FXO0 WXUD HVWHQVH1 6RQR GLFLRWWR DQQL GL GXUDWD +4::604:<3, SHU XQ WRWDOH GL 76 WRPL= GXUDWD H PROH QRQ XVXDOL SHU XQ JLRUQDOH VHWWHFHQWHVFR> WDQWR SL• FKH GRSR OD URWWXUD FRO JUXSSR URPDQR GL *LRYDQ /RGRYLFR %LDQFRQL FKH DYHYD LQL]LDOPHQWH SURPRVVR LO SHULRGLFR/ LO FDULFR GHOOD FRPSLOD]LRQH JUDYz TXDVL GHO WXWWR VXOOH VSDOOH GHO ELEOLRWHFDULR HVWHQVH1 7XWWDYLD LO JLRUQDOH IX XQD GHOOH SL• VLFXUH H PDWXUH/ DQFKH VH QRQ GHOOH SL• YLYDFL YRFL GHOOD SXEEOLFLVWLFD LWD0 OLDQD QHOOR VFRUFLR GHO VHFROR1 ,O PDWHULDOH UHFHQVLWR HUD SHU OR SL• LWDOLDQR> VFHOWD GL RUJRJOLR QD]LRQDOH/ PD LPPXQH GD ERULD SURSULR SHUFKp FRQVDSH0 YROH GHO JUDYH H FUHVFHQWH ULWDUGR FKH VL HUD DQGDWR FRVWLWXHQGR LQ SRFKL GH0 FHQQL FRQ OH DOWUH FXOWXUH HXURSHH1 ,O JLRUQDOH SURSRVH XQ ODUJR YHQWDJOLR GL LQWHUHVVL/ WUD L TXDOL YD DOPHQR VHJQDODWD OD SUHVHQ]D IRUWH H RULJLQDOH GHOOD FXOWXUD PDWHPDWLFD H VFLHQWLILFD/ FRQ FULWHUL GL JLXGL]LRVR H HTXLOLEUDWR HPSL0 ULVPR H LQ FHUWR VHQVR YHQQH D FRVWLWXLUH/ D ILDQFR GHOOD VWRULD GHOOD OHWWHUDWX0 UD/ TXDVL XQD VWRULD GHOOD FXOWXUD FRQWHPSRUDQHD1 J, )UDWWXUH H FRQWLQXLWj 0 &KL VWXGLD OD FXOWXUD PRGHQHVH GDO WUDVSRUWR GHOOD FDSLWDOH LQ SRL/ WURYD QDWXUDOH DUUHVWDUVL DO 4:<9/ DOO·DUULYR GHL )UDQFHVL1 /D IUDWWXUD q HYLGHQWH/ IRUWH/ SHU FHUWL DVSHWWL ULVROXWLYD H GHILQLWLYD1 (VVD FL FRQ0 VHJQD XQ DVVHWWR FRPSOHVVLYDPHQWH RPRJHQHR/ FRHUHQWH H LQ TXDOFKH PRGR SURJUHVVLYR GHOOD VRFLHWj H GHOOD FXOWXUD HVWHQVH OXQJR GXH VHFROL1 0D FUHGR FKH VLD XWLOH JXDUGDUH D TXHOOD VWRULD SHU O·LQWHUR DUFR GHOOD VXD HVWHQVLRQH/ GDOO·LQL]LR DOOD ILQH/ GDOOD GHYROX]LRQH GHL WHUULWRUL IHUUDUHVL ILQR DOOR VFLRJOL0 PHQWR GHO GXFDWR GHQWUR XQ FRUSR VWDWXDOH QXRYR1 4XHVWR q VHQ]·DOWUR XQR VIRU]R XWLOH SHU PLVXUDUH OH OLQHH GL IUDWWXUD/ TXHOOH GHOOD FRQWLQXLWj H LO ORUR VHQVR1 $QFRUD XQD YROWD QXOOD PHJOLR GHL JLRUQDOL FRQVHQWH GL HQWUDUH QHO YLYR GL XQD PXWD]LRQH/ DO WHPSR VWHVVR PLVXUDQGRQH OH FRQWLQXLWj/ DQFKH VH GL PL0 QRU ILDWR1 $ TXDOH FDPELDPHQWR SRUWL O·LUUX]LRQH GHOOD SROHPLFD SROLWLFD VL YHGH DQFKH GD YHORFL VRQGDJJL1 ,O 46 RWWREUH 4:<9/ VHWWH JLRUQL GRSR O·DUULYR
4463
0DUWLQR &DSXFFL
GHL )UDQFHVL/ DSSDULYD LO PDQLIHVWR/ H LO 49 RWWREUH YHQLYD SXEEOLFDWR LO SULPR QXPHUR GHO ´*LRUQDOH UHSXEEOLFDQR GL SXEEOLFD LVWUX]LRQHµ/ FKH FHUWDPHQWH HQWUz QHO PHULWR GL XQD VLWXD]LRQH UHDOH ² TXHOOD GHO YHFFKLR VWDWR HVWHQVH H LQ SDUWLFRODUH GHOOH FDPSDJQH ² H VL FKLHVH FRPH VL GRYHVVHUR LQFDUQDUH QHO FRUSR VRFLDOH L ´VDFUL SULQFLSLµ H TXLQGL/ SHU HVHPSLR/ FRPH VL SRWHVVHUR VRW0 WUDUUH DOOD PLVHULD/ DOO·DEEUXWLPHQWR H DOO·LJQRUDQ]D OH SRSROD]LRQL GHOOD FDP0 SDJQD> YHGHQGR LQ TXHVWR XQD FRQGL]LRQH QHFHVVDULD H QRQ DFFHVVRULD SHUFKp VL SRWHVVHUR GLUH DWWXDWL L SULQFuSL GHOOD GHPRFUD]LD1 1RQ IX SHUz LO UDGLFDOL0 VPR HYDQJHOLFR D IDU VRSSULPHUH LO JLRUQDOH QHOO·DXWXQQR GHO ¶<; PD LO ULOLHYR GHOOH LQJHUHQ]H IUDQFHVL QHJOL DIIDUL LQWHUQL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD &LVDOSLQD> QRQ GXQTXH O·LGHRORJLD/ LQ TXDQWR WDOH VHPSUH ULDVVRUELELOH/ PD OD SROLWLFD/ FLRq XQ JLXGL]LR FKH SRWHYD HVVHUH OD SUHPHVVD GL XQ SURJHWWR1 1HL IDWWL/ SXU FRO QRFFLROR GL DOWH H QRELOL LQWHQ]LRQL/ OH IRUPH GHOOD SROHPLFD SROLWLFD H GHO GL0 VFRUVR JLRUQDOLVWLFR IXURQR WXWW·DOWUR FKH HFFHOVH1 'L FLz UHQGH FRQWR OR VWHV0 VR ´*LRUQDOH UHSXEEOLFDQRµ H/ DQFKH GL SL•/ OH DQWDJRQLVWLFKH ´0HPRULH GL PRUDOH/ SROLWLFD H OHWWHUDWXUDµ/ FRPSDUVH OD SULPD YROWD LO 54 PDU]R GHO 4:<:/ SHULRGLFR XPRUDOH/ FRQ XQ IRQGR +FRPH LO GL SRFR SRVWHULRUH ´9DJOLR FULWL0 FRµ, ´EDUHWWLDQRµ/ PD VHQ]D OD JHQLDOLWj/ OD OHJJHUH]]D/ O·HVWUR OLEHUR H FDSULF0 FLRVR GHO %DUHWWL1 1RQ HUD SURSULDPHQWH OD PHGLRFULWj D FXL OD SURYLQFLD q FRQGDQQDWD TXDQGR YHQJRQR PHQR O·DQFRUDJJLR D JUDQGL FRRUGLQDWH GL FXO0 WXUD R OD SRVVLELOLWj GL ULIHULUVL D XQ SHUVRQDJJLR FHQWUDOH/ LQFRQWURYHUWLELO0 PHQWH JUDQGH1 &RQ TXHL IRJOL LUURPSHYD OD FKLDFFKLHUD> DIILRUDYD LO IDQDWL0 VPR/ LO JXVWR GHOOD ]XIID= RJQL IDVFLFROR VYLOXSSD LQWHUURPSH ULSUHQGH GHL ILOL/ FRQ TXHO FKLDFFKLHULFFLR FRQWLQXR SURSULR GHL OXRJKL GL SDVVDJJLR1 7XWWDYLD q EHQH QRQ IHUPDUVL DJOL VFKHPL/ FKH YRUUHEEHUR LQFROPDELOL FH0 VXUH WUD OD 0RGHQD UHD]LRQDULD H OD JUDQGH FXOWXUD PXUDWRULDQD LQWULVD GL DVSL0 UD]LRQL DOOD SXEEOLFD IHOLFLWj H DO EXRQJRYHUQR1 1HO 4;55 FRPSDULYDQR OH ´0HPRULH GL UHOLJLRQH/ GL PRUDOH H GL OHWWHUDWXUDµ PD FRO SUHFHGHQWH RUJDQR GHO PRGHUDWLVPR DQWL0JLDFRELQR +FKH QRQ YLHQH PDL UDPPHQWDWR, FRQGLYLGH0 YDQR DOO·LQJURVVR VROR LO WLWROR> QRQ O·DUWLFROD]LRQH Qp LO OLQJXDJJLR VFLDWWR Qp/ WDQWR PHQR/ OD YROJDULWj LQWHOOHWWXDOH1 1HOO·LQWURGX]LRQH SURJUDPPDWLFD VL GL0 FKLDUD FKH OD UDFFROWD q ©VWUDQLHUD DIIDWWR D TXLVWLRQL SROLWLFKHª H LQWHQGH DQ0 FKH HVVHUH LPPXQH GD TXHO JHQHUH GL GLVSXWH GRYH VL q SL• SUHVL GDOOR VIRJJLR GL ©VHGXFHQWH HORTXHQ]Dª R ©FDYLOORVD GLDOHWWLFDª FKH GDOOD ULFHUFD GHOOD YHULWj1 /·LQWHQVLWj GHOOD ULIOHVVLRQH UHOLJLRVD q DOWD/ PD O·XUWR GHOO·HVWUHPLVPR OHJLWWL0 PLVWLFR UHVWD IXRUL1 1RQ VL q ORQWDQL/ PL VHPEUD/ GDOOR VSLULWR GHOOD JUDQGH HUXGL]LRQH FKH FRQVLGHUD HVVHQ]LDOH SHU LO ULJRUH GHOOR VWXGLR DQFKH XQD FRQ0
/HWWHUDWXUD GL XQD &DSLWDOH
4464
GL]LRQH SVLFRORJLFD VLQH LUD HW VWXGLR1 1HO 4;8: FRPSDLRQR JOL ´2SXVFROL UHOL0 JLRVL/ OHWWHUDUM H PRUDOLµ/ FKH VL SURSRQJRQR FRPH FRQWLQXD]LRQH GLUHWWD GHOOH ´0HPRULHµ1 $QFRUD SL• ODELOH q O·LGHD GL XQ·DSSDUWHQHQ]D UHD]LRQDULD +FKH SXUH ULJXDUGD SL• GL XQ FROODERUDWRUH= SHU HVHPSLR/ XQ XRPR FRHUHQWH FRPH %DUWRORPHR 9HUDWWL, H QRQ PDQFD DQ]L XQD QRWD GL FRPSLDFLPHQWR SHU LO YROJHUH GHOOH YLFHQGH ©WRUQDWR QRYDPHQWH SURSL]LR D· SDFLILFL VWXGMª1 ,Q XR0 PLQL FRPH 9HUDWWL/ 0DUFDQWRQLR 3DUHQWL/ &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL DJLYD DQFRUD OD OH]LRQH PHWRGLFD GHOO·HUXGL]LRQH PD QRQ O·DQLPXV ULIRUPDWRUH= VL DYYHUWH LQ ORUR TXHOOD VSHFLH GL SHUIH]LRQH SURIHVVLRQDOH/ SURSULD GHOOR VWXGLRVR WHFQL0 FDPHQWH LPSHFFDELOH PD LQFDSDFH GL ODUJR UHVSLUR VWRULFR H LQ TXDOFKH PRGR FRQGDQQDWR DO WULWXPH HUXGLWR H GRFXPHQWDULR1 1RQGLPHQR TXHOOD WUDGL]LR0 QH GL SL• ODUJR UHVSLUR QRQ HUD HVWLQWD= SRVVLDPR EHQ FRQVLGHUDUOD YLWDOH LQ *LXVHSSH &DPSRUL +DQFKH SHU OD FRQQHVVLRQH FRVWDQWH WUD SUREOHPL GHOOD VWRULRJUDILD/ VWRULD OHWWHUDULD/ VWRULD GHOO·DUWH, H/ SL• WDUGL/ LQ $GROIR 9HQWXUL1
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
4466
5(1$72 %(57$&&+,1,
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
1HO 4;7;/ O·DQQR IDWLGLFR GHOOH ULYROX]LRQL LQ (XURSD/ DOOD QRWL]LD GHOOH &LQTXH *LRUQDWH LQVXUUH]LRQDOL D 0LODQR H GHOOD JXHUUD DOO·$XVWULD GLFKLDUDWD GDO 3LHPRQWH/ LO WRVFDQR &DUOR /RUHQ]LQL ² IXWXUR &ROORGL SDGUH GL 3LQRFFKLR ² SDUWH GD )LUHQ]H LO < DSULOH FRPH ´PLOLWH YRORQWDULR GHOOD FRORQQD PRELOHµ1 ,O JUDQGXFD /HRSROGR ,, H LO PLQLVWUR PRGHUDWR &RVLPR 5LGROIL KDQQR GHFL0 VR OD SDUWHQ]D GHL YRORQWDUL QRQ VROR SHU JHVWR GLPRVWUDWLYR GL FRQFUHWD SDU0 WHFLSD]LRQH DOOD IDVH IHGHUDOLVWD GHOOD SULPD JXHUUD G·LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ PD DOOR VFRSR/ QRQ PHQR SUHVVDQWH/ GL DOORQWDQDUH SUR0 WHPSRUH GDO *UDQGXFDWR JUXS0 SL GL JLRYDQL SROLWLFDPHQWH LQTXLHWL1 $UULYDWR VXL FDPSL GHOOD /RPEDUGLD LQ JLXEED QHUD ² OD GLYLVD WHPXWLVVLPD GDJOL DXVWULDFL/ L TXDOL ´DIHU +DYHUH, PROWD SDXUD GL EULJDQWL QHUL H QLHQWH SDXUD GL EULJDQWL ELDQFKHµ/ FLRq GHL VROGDWL UH0 JRODUL/ GHL JUDQGXFKLVWL LQ DVVLVH ELDQFD ² LO UHSXEEOLFDQR PD]]LQLDQR /RUHQ0 ]LQL VFULYH WUH OHWWHUH41 1HOO·LPPLQHQ]D GHOOD EDWWDJOLD GL 0RQWDQDUD +HURLFD UHVLVWHQ]D GHL YRORQWDUL H GHJOL VWXGHQWL WRVFDQL D &XUWDWRQH H 0RQWDQDUD,/ OD OHWWHUD GDWDWD 47 DSULOH 4;7;/ DWWHQGHQGR LO EDWWHVLPR GHO IXRFR +´VYHUJLQDUH L IXFLOLµ,/ ULHYRFD OD OHQWH]]D H L VRVSHWWL GHOOD PDUFLD YHUVR OD /RPEDUGLD> IRU0 WXQRVR WUDVIHULPHQWR/ FRQWUDVVHJQDWR D 0RGHQD GDOOD IUHGGD DFFRJOLHQ]D GHO0 OD FLWWj HVWHQVH H GDO ULYHODWRUH LQFRQWUR GHO ´EULJDQWH QHURµ/ GHO YRORQWDULR GHPRFUDWLFR &DUOR /RUHQ]LQL FRQ LO ILJOLR GL &LUR 0HQRWWL= ´,O QRVWUR YLDJJLR/ GD )LUHQ]H DO 3R/ q VWDWR XQ YLDJJLR WXWW·DOWUR FKH VHQWLPHQWDOH1 3DUWLWL LQ IUHWWD H IXULD/ GRYHPPR DVVRJJHWWDUFL D WXWWL L GLIHWWL H LQFRQYHQLHQ]H G·XQD FRVD LPSURY0 YLVDWD +«,1 3HU WXWWR H GD WXWWL/ DEELDPR DYXWR EXRQD DFFRJOLHQ]D/ PHQRFKq D 0RGHQD/ GRYH
²²²²²²²² 4 , FXL RULJLQDOL VRQR FRQVHUYDWL WUD OH FDUWH FROORGLDQH GHOOD %LEOLRWHFD 1D]LRQDOH GL )L0 UHQ]H> FIU1 51 %(57$&&+,1,/ ,O SDGUH GL 3LQRFFKLR19LWD H RSHUH GHO &ROORGL/ 0LODQR/ &DPXQLD/ 4<<6/ DO FDS1 ,/ ´%ULJDQWH QHUR D 0RQWDQDUDµ1
4467
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
FL DVSHWWDYDPR PROWR H DYHPPR SRFR/ SHU QRQ GLU QXOOD1 ,Q FRGHVWD FLWWj/ YL q XQ JUDQ SDUWL0 WR JHVXLWLFR H GXFDOH H VX TXHVWR SURSRVLWR PL GLFHYD LO ILJOLR GL &LUR 0HQRWWL= &UHGLPL/ VH 0RGHQD HVHUFLWDVVH VXO 0RGHQHVH O·LQIOXHQ]D FKH 3DULJL HVHUFLWD VXOOD )UDQFLD/ )UDQFHVFR 9 >ILJOLR GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ PRUWR QHO 4;79/ UHVSRQVDELOH GHOO·LPSLFFDJLRQH GHO ´SDWULRWDµ 0HQRWWL@ WRUQHUHEEH VXO WURQRµ1
/·DPDUD FRQVWDWD]LRQH GL $FKLOOH 0HQRWWL/ SULPRJHQLWR GHO ´PDUWLUHµ &L0 UR/ GHOOD SHUVLVWHQ]D D 0RGHQD GL ´XQ JUDQ SDUWLWR JHVXLWLFR H GXFDOHµ q FRQIHU0 PDWD GDO TXDGUR JLRUQDOLVWLFR0FXOWXUDOH DOO·HSRFD GHOOH LQVXUUH]LRQL TXDUDQWRW0 WHVFKH1 1HO GXFDWR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ D GHVWUD VL FROORFD LO ELVHWWLPDQDOH ´'LDULR PRGHQHVHµ +56 PDU]R ² 63 DJRVWR 4;7;,/ UHGLYLYD LQFDUQD]LRQH GHO ´)RJOLR GL 0RGHQDµ/ L FXL UHGDWWRUL/ ´XRPLQL G·RUGLQH H FDWWROLFL LQQDQ]L WXWWRµ/ FRQ0 WLQXDQR D]LRQL LGHRORJLFKH VRUGDPHQWH UHVWDXUDWLYH/ OHJLWWLPLVWH/ DQWLOLEHUDOL1 3URYYLVRULD/ HSLVRGLFD DO FRQIURQWR OD SXEEOLFLVWLFD OLEHUDOH1 6RVWLHQH SRVL0 ]LRQL PRGHUDWH ´/·,QGLSHQGHQ]D LWDOLDQDµ +59 PDU]R ² ; JLXJQR 4;7;/ ELVHW0 WLPDQDOH, HGLWD GDO OLEUDLR 1LFROD =DQLFKHOOL> L VXRL FROODERUDWRUL/ /XGRYLFR %RVHOOLQL/ /XLJL &DUERQLHUL/ &HVDUH 5RYLJKL H /XLJL =LQL ² DXWRUH GHO WDUGLYR URPDQ]R VWRULFR 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL GL FXL SDUOHUHPR SL• DYDQWL ² DXVSLFDQR O·DQQHVVLRQH DO 3LHPRQWH LQ QRPH GHOO·LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ SUREOHPD SULRULWDULR VX TXHOOR GHOOD OLEHUWj1 'DOOD IXVLRQH GH ´/·,QGLSHQGHQ]D LWDOLDQDµ H GH ´/·,WDOLD FHQWUDOHµ +WULVHWWLPDQDOH/ 7 DSULOH ² ; JLXJQR 4;7;/ IRQGDWR GD *LRYDQQL 6DE0 EDWLQL, GHULYD LO ´9HVVLOOR LWDOLDQRµ +43 JLXJQR ² 6 DJRVWR 4;7;/ WULVHWWLPDQDOH, L FXL UHGDWWRUL/ WUD L TXDOL $FKLOOH 0HQRWWL/ VL GLFKLDUDQR ´OLEHUDOL PRGHUDWL/ SHU UDJLRQH/ SHU FRQYLQFLPHQWR/ SHU LQWHUHVVH EHQ LQWHVRµ51 /D PRGHQHVH/ OHJLWWLPLVWD ´9RFH GHOOD 9HULWjµ DXVSLFD H RWWLHQH OD VRSSUHVVLRQH D )L0 UHQ]H GHOO·´$QWRORJLDµ/ QD]LRQDOH HG HXURSHD> LO SULQFLSLR IUDQFHVH GHO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR H OD ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ 4;64 DO FHQWUR GHL 'LDORJKHWWL GHO FRQWH 0RQDOGR /HRSDUGL> L ´FDUER0 QDULµ VXOO·$SSHQQLQR H GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL FRQGDQQDWR D PRUWH QHO SRHPD /·HVXOH GL 3LHWUR *LDQQRQH> YHUVL SDWULRWWLFL GL 'RPHQLFR *D]]DGL H GL *LRYDQQL 9HFFKL1 6FKLHUDPHQWL H UHWURVSHWWLYH LGHRORJLFR0FXOWXUDOL QRQ PLJOLRUDQR FHUWR VH/ GDO 4;7; SURFHGHQGR YHUVR L PRWL GHO 4;64/ FRQVLGHULDPR QHOOR VSHFLILFR L GLVOLYHOOL GL VLWXD]LRQH VWRULFR0SROLWLFD )LUHQ]H20RGHQD1 /D ULYLVWD ILRUHQWLQD ´$QWRORJLDµ GL *LRYDQ 3LHWUR 9LHXVVHDX[ H GL *LQR &DSSRQL/ SHU LO VXR R0 ²²²²²²²² 5 3HU TXHVWD SDUWH/ FIU1 )1 '(//$ 3(587$/ ,O JLRUQDOLVPR GDO 4;7: DOO·8QLWj/ LQ ©/D VWDPSD LWDOLDQD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ %DUL/ /DWHU]D/ 4<:;/ S1 74<1
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
4468
ULHQWDPHQWR QD]LRQDOH HG HXURSHR WROOHUDWR LQ 7RVFDQD/ VXELVFH L FRQWLQXL H IXULRVL DWWDFFKL GHOOD ´9RFH GHOOD 9HULWj0*D]]HWWD GHOO·,WDOLD &HQWUDOHµ/ PD0 QRYUDWD QHO GXFDWR GD )UDQFHVFR ,9 H GDO VXR FRQVLJOLHUH VDQIHGLVWD/ LO 3ULQ0 FLSH GL &DQRVD1 ,O SHULRGLFR ILRUHQWLQR YLHQH VLVWHPDWLFDPHQWH EROODWR FRPH ´WHPHUDULR SURPXOJDWRUH GL LQLTXLVVLPH PDVVLPH LQIHUQDOL/ GHJQR GL HVVHU FRQVHJQDWR DOOD EHQ PHULWDWD HVHFUD]LRQHµ1 /·DWWDFFR ODQFLDWR LO 54 PDU]R 4;66 ID WUDERFFDUH LO YDVR1 ,O GLUHWWRUH GHOO·´$QWRORJLDµ/ O·XPDQR/ OLEHUDOH H ´VRFLDOHµ 9LHXVVHDX[ VFULYH D *LXOLDQR 5LFFL= ´&Lz QRQ PL VSDYHQWD1 $Q]L/ PL VHQWR SL• FRUDJJLR FKH SULPD SHU GLIHQGHUH FLz FKH FUHGR OD YHULWj H LO SUR0 JUHVVR/ FRQWUR JOL DWWDFFKL GL RJQL VSHFLH GL JHVXLWL/ H VRSUDWWXWWR FRQWUR OD FDQDJOLD GL 0RGHQDµ1 3RFR GRSR/ LO 59 PDU]R 4;66/ XQ UHVFULWWR GHO *UDQGXFD/ VXO TXDOH SUH0 PRQR JOL DPEDVFLDWRUL GL $XVWULD H 5XVVLD D )LUHQ]H/ GHFUHWD OD VRSSUHVVLRQH GHO SHULRGLFR1 'ROHQWL UDPPDULFKL H ULVHQWLWH SURWHVWH FRUURQR GDOOD 7RVFDQD DOO·(XURSD1 $ )LUHQ]H/ EROOHWWLQL H DIILVVL/ LQGLJQDWL H EHIIDUGL/ FKLDPDQR LQ FDXVD/ DFFRPXQDQR QHO PHVWLHUH GL LJQRELOL ´IRUFDLROLµ LO *UDQGXFD WRVFDQR H LO 'XFD PRGHQHVH1 8Q PDQLIHVWR DQRQLPR GLFH DOODUPDWR= ´7RVFDQL$ 2 QRL VLDPR VRWWR LO JRYHUQR GL 0RGH0 QD/ R LO *UDQGXFD GL 7RVFDQD q XQ GXFD GL 0RGHQD +«,1 /·,WDOLD WXWWD LQRUULGLVFH D TXHVWR VIUHJLR QRYHOOR/ H LO JULGR QRQ q SL• GL ODPHQWR/ PD GL YHQGHWWDµ1 ( XQ DOWUR= ´(YYLYD$ (YYL0 YD$ 2K JLRLD$ ² LO WRVFDQR *UDQGXFD ² q GLYHQWDWR LO %RLD ² GHO 0RGHQHVH 'XFDµ61
$ VIRJOLDUH ´/D 9RFH GHOOD 9HULWjµ/ LO WHPD SROLWLFR GHO JLRUQR/ FLRq OD GL0 VFXVVLRQH VXO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR SDVVD LQ VXERUGLQH ULVSHWWR DOO·HYLGHQWH SURJUDP0 PDWR OLQFLDJJLR HWLFR0SROLWLFR GL &LUR 0HQRWWL FRPH ´OLEHUWLQRµ/ ´YLRODWRUH PDQLIHVWR GHOOD VDQWLWj FRQLXJDOHµ ROWUH FKH LPSHUGRQDELOH ´FRQJLXUDWR ID0 ]LRVRµ/ ´ULYROX]LRQDULR XVXUSDWRUHµ1 ,O QRQ LQWHUYHQWR ULFHYH LQYHFH SDUWLFRODUH VRWWROLQHDWXUD DOO·LQWHUQR GHL 'LDORJKHWWL VXOOH PDWHULH FRUUHQWL QHOO·DQQR 4;647 ILU0 ²²²²²²²² 6 &IU1 $1 *$/$17( *$5521(/ , JLRUQDOL GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH LQ ©/D VWDPSD LWDOLDQD GHO 5LVRU0 JLPHQWRª«FLW1/ S1 4:3 7 3HU LO WHVWR GHL 'LDORJKHWWL / 3HVDUR/1RELOL/4;64/ ULIHULWL QHOOD SULPD HGL]LRQH +VWDQWH LO JUDQGH VXFFHVVR/LQ SRFKL PHVL VH QH WLUDURQR VHL HGL]LRQL/ GHOOH TXDOL L GXH GL 0RGHQD H XQD LQ 2UYLHWR,/ULPDQGLDPR D= 021$/'2 /(23$5',/ $XWRELRJUDILD H 'LDORJKHWWL/ D FXUD GL $1 %5,*$17,/ LQWURGX]LRQH GL &DUOR *DEOHU/ +%LEOLRWHFD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR,/ %RORJQD/ &DSSHOOL /4<:51 , 'LDORJKHWWL FRQWDQR XQD ULVWDPSD VHFRQGR LO WHVWR GHOOD VHFRQGD HGL]LRQH/ FRO WLWROR ,O YLDJJLR GL 3XOFLQHOOD D FXUD GL $1 025$9,$/ 5RPD/ $GULDWLFD/4<771 6XOO·DUJRPHQWR FIU1 *1
4469
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
PDWL GDO FRQWH 0RQDOGR /HRSDUGL/ SDGUH GHO SRHWD1 6H TXHL ´VR]]L H IDQDWLFL GLDORJDFFLµ IHFHUR XVFLUH GDL JDQJKHUL *LDFRPR /HRSDUGL/ TXDQGR OL WURYz/ SHU HUURUH R PDOL]LD/ DIILEELDWL D OXL VWHVVR> q DQFKH YHUR FKH FRQVHUYDQR DQ0 FRU RJJL SDJLQH GL HVWURVD TXDQWR OHJJLELOH SHUWLQHQ]D1 8QD VPLWL]]DWD/ VSHV0 VR LURQLFD YLVLRQH GHOOH FRVH ´FRUUHQWLµ GLVWLQJXH LO ORUR DXWRUH QHOOD VFKLHUD GHL SXEEOLFLVWL UHD]LRQDUL1 'LVWLQ]LRQH LQ SRVLWLYR/ SUHFLVLDPR/ SL• SHU PHULWL OHWWHUDUL FKH QRQ SHU HVSOLFLWD WHRUL]]D]LRQH GHO SHQVLHUR OHJLWWLPLVWD GL 0R0 QDOGR /HRSDUGL1 'DO SXQWR GL YLVWD HVSUHVVLYR0VWLOLVWLFR/ D QRL LQWHUHVVD VR0 SUDWWXWWR LO 'LDORJR TXDUWR FRQ L UHODWLYL LQWHUORFXWRUL/ ´LO 0RQGR/ OD *XHUUD/ OD 0RGHUD]LRQH/ OD /HJLWWLPLWjµ FKH SDUODQR LQ GLUHWWD GL 0RGHQD 4;641 6H LO 0RQGR q ´URYLQDWR/ VJDQJKHUDWR H VEXGHOODWRµ SHJJLR FKH DOO·HSRFD GHO %R0 QDSDUWH/ OD FROSD q GHOOD 5LYROX]LRQH/ ´TXHOOD FDURJQDµ FKH VWD GLODJDQGR QHO 9HFFKLR &RQWLQHQWH8= %3ULPD LQ )UDQFLD VHFRQGR LO VROLWR/ H GL Oj KD FRUVR FRPH XQ IXOPLQH SHU TXDVL WXWWD O·(XURSD1 ,O %HOJLR VL q ULYROWDWR +58 DJRVWR 4;63,> OD 3RORQLD VL q ULYROWDWD +5< QRYHPEUH 4;63,> OD 6YL]]HUD/ OD 6DVVRQLD +OD &RQIHGHUD]LRQH VYL]]HUD RWWLHQH OD ULIRUPD FDQWRQDOH> QHOOD &RQIHGHUD]LRQH JHUPDQLFD PROWL SUuQFLSL GHYRQR FRQFHGHUH OD &RVWLWX]LRQH,1 )XJXUDWHYL> DQFKH TXHL EDUGDVVL >UDJD]]DFFL/ JLRYLQDVWUL@ G·,WDOLDQL VL VRQR LQYHSHULWL1 0RGHQD KD IDWWR OD ULYROX]LRQH/ 3DUPD KD IDWWR OD ULYROX]LRQH/ H ILQR L ELULFFKLQL GL %RORJQD KDQQR IDWWR OD ULYR0 OX]LRQH >LQ VHJXLWR DOO·DUUHVWR GL &LUR 0HQRWWL/ 6 IHEEUDLR 4;64/ H DOOR VFRSSLR GHOOH ULYROX0 ]LRQL D %RORJQD H D 3DUPD/ 7 IHEEUDLR/ 0RGHQD LQVRUJH LO 8 IHEEUDLR@% /D JXHUUD H OD UHSUHVVLRQH FKH 0RQDOGR /HRSDUGL YHGUHEEH YROHQWLHUL VFD0 WHQDWH FRQWUR L OLEHUDOL IUDQFHVL H L ORUR VHJXDFL LWDOLDQL LQFRQWUD O·RVWDFROR GL XQ ´SHUVRQDJJLRµ DOORUD PROWR LQ YRJD= LO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR1 0D WUDVFULYLDPR OH EDWWXWH FKH/ QHO 'LDORJR TXDUWR/ VL VFDPELDQR JOL LQWHUORFXWRUL *XHUUD/ 0RQGR/ 0RGHUD]LRQH/ WUD YHULWj H SDUDGRVVR/ VSRVWDQGR DG DUWH OD TXHVWLRQH GDO SLD0 QR ORJLFR D TXHOOR SL• SURSULDPHQWH UDSSUHVHQWDWLYR> GD QRWDUH FRPH/ QRQ VHQ]D DUJX]LD/ OH LGHH VLDQR SHUVRQDOL]]DWH/ VFHQHJJLDWH LQ DOWUHWWDQWL ULWUDWWL9=
²²²²²²²² &$9$==87,/ 0RQDOGR /HRSDUGL H L UHGDWWRUL GHOOD 9RFH GHOOD 9HULWj LQ ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 5HJLD $FFDGHPLD GL 6FLHQ]H/ /HWWHUH H $UWL GL 0RGHQDª/ V1 9/ ,,+4<6:,/ S1 536 H 6V1 8 &IU1 01 /(23$5',/ $XWRELRJUDILD H 'LDORJKHWWL/ HGL]1 4<:5/ FLW1 S1 57<1 9 ,ELGHP/ SS1 585086
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
446:
´*8(55$1 /H FRVH GHO PRQGR VRQR DFFRPRGDWH" 02'(5$=,21(1 1LHQWH DIIDWWR«/D ULYROX]LRQH q SL• WHPHUDULD GL SULPD/ L ULEHOOL WULRQIDQR LQ WXWWH OH SDUWL/ OD FDXVD GHL UH VWD LQ ELOLFR PLQDFFLDWD VHPSUH GL SUHFLSL]LR/ H OH FRVH GHO PRQGR FDPPLQDQR D URWWD GL FROOR1 &RQ WXWWR FLz L VRYUDQL QRQ SRVVRQR IDUH OD JXHUUD1 021'21 ( SHUFKp QRQ OD SRVVRQR IDUH" 02'(5$=,21(1 3HUFKp JOLH OR KD SURLELWR LO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR1 *8(55$1 &KL q TXHVWR VFDSDWHOOR FKH SUHWHQGH GL OHJDUH OH PDQL DL UH/ H GL WHQHUH VRWWR0 VRSUD LO PRQGR" 02'(5$=,21(1 3DUODWH FRQ ULVSHWWR/ SHUFKp q XQ SHUVRQDJJLR GL ULJXDUGR1 021'21 0D LQVRPPD FKL q" 02'(5$=,21(1 (· LO ILJOLXROR GHOOD ULYROX]LRQH GL )UDQFLD1 021'21 6SLHJDWHYL XQ SRFR PHJOLR/ SHUFKp LR QRQ Y·LQWHQGR1 02'(5$=,21(1 /D )UDQFLD KD GLFKLDUDWR FKH RJQXQR H SDGURQH GL ULYROWDUVL/ H FKH QHVVXQR GHYH VRFFRUUHUH L SULQFLSL OHJLWWLPL FRQWUR L ORUR VXGGLWL ULYROWRVL1 4XHVWR H QRQ DO0 WUR q LO SULQFLSLR GHO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR1 *8(55$1 8QD EDJDWHOOD GD QLHQWH«µ1
$OOH VSHUDQ]H GHL ´VXGGLWL ULYROWRVLµ GHVWDWH GDO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR VXFFHGH OD GRFFLD IUHGGD= LO PLQLVWUR 3pULHU/ UDSSUHVHQWDQWH GHO SDUWLWR GHOOD UHVLVWHQ]D DOOD FRUWH GHO UH ´ERUJKHVHµ /XLJL )LOLSSR G·2UOHDQV/ GLFKLDUD FKH LO VDQJXH GHL IUDQFHVL DSSDUWLHQH VROR DOOD )UDQFLD> FRVu O·LQWHUYHQWR DXVWULDFR SHUPHWWH LO ULHQWUR GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 D 0RGHQD LO < PDU]R> UHFLGLYR LQWHUYHQWR SXQWXDOPHQ0 WH UHJLVWUDWR QHO SURVLHJXR GHO 'LDORJR TXDUWR:= ´*8(55$1 'HOOH FRVH G·,WDOLD VDUHWH EHQH LQIRUPDWR" 02'(5$=,21(1 $QFKH QHOO·,WDOLD FL HQWUD LO QRQ LQWHUYHQWR1 021'21 9HGHWH FKH VLHWH XQD EXJLDUGD" ,R VWHVVR KR YHGXWR FRQ JOL RFFKL PLHL L VRO0 GDWL WHGHVFKL GHOO·$XVWULD TXDQGR VRQR DQGDWL LQ ,WDOLD D PHWWHUH LO FHUYHOOR D SDUWLWR DL ULEHOOL GL 3DUPD/ GL 0RGHQD H GHOOR 6WDWR GHO 3DSDµ1
$QFRUD XQD YROWD/ LQVLHPH DO SUHYHGLELOH FRPSLDFLPHQWR OHJLWWLPLVWD/ VFDW0 WD VXOOD SDJLQD GLDORJDWD GHO FRQWH 0RQDOGR FHUWD VXD QDWLYD WHQGHQ]D DOO·LURQLD H DOOD FDULFDWXUD SROLWLFD= FRQWURUGLQH SHU OR ´VFDSSDWHOORµ QRQ LQWHU0 YHQWR/ DFFRPRGDWR/ DJJLXVWDWR FRPH LQWHUYHQWR/ LQ PRGR FKH ² SURILWWDQGR GHO0 ²²²²²²²² :
,ELGHP/ S1 58;
446;
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
OD VXD QXRYD/ UHVWDXUDWLYD FRQIHUPD ² L VROGDWL WHGHVFKL SRVVDQR ´PHWWHUH LO FHUYHOOR D SDUWLWR DL ULEHOOLµ1 %LVRJQD ULFRQRVFHUH FKH L ´GLDORJDFFLµ GL /HRSDUGL SDGUH VL IDQQR OHJJHUH SHU OD ORUR JXVWRVD/ VROOHFLWD DWWXDOLWj/ DYHQGR SRFR R QXOOD GD LQYLGLDUH/ VXO IURQWH GHOOD FXOWXUD UHD]LRQDULD GHOO·HSRFD/ DL SRHWL H DJOL HVHJHWL GHOOD ´VFXROD JXHOIDµ/ DL YHUVHJJLDWRUL/ DL OHWWHUDWL OHJLWWLPLVWL H GXFKLVWL GL 0RGHQD1 4XHVWL XOWLPL/ QRQRVWDQWH O·LQGLVFXVVD IHGHOWj DO JRYHUQR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ QRQ PHUL0 WDQR OD WUDFFLD DSULRULVWLFD/ LQFRQGL]LRQDWD GL GLVDPRUH YHUVR O·,WDOLD1 $QFKH VH OD ORUR q XQ·,WDOLD GL DFFDGHPLFKH PHPRULH/ XQD SDWULD LWDOLFD YDJKHJJLDWD TXDOH JORULRVR/ PLWLFR DFTXLVWR GD FRQVHUYDUH H YDQWDUH DQFRUD H VHPSUH QHO QRPH GHL YDWL 3HWUDUFD +´,WDOLD PLD/ EHQFKp ¶O SDUODU VLD LQGDUQR« µ, H 'DQWH +´$KL VHUYD ,WDOLD GL GRORUH RVWHOOR« ,1 $ UDSSUHVHQWDUH XQD WUDGL]LRQH OHWWHUD0 ULD ´LWDOLDQDµ GL PDUFD VDQIHGLVWD FLWLDPR 3DROR $EEDWL 0DUHVFRWWL +4;450 4;:5,1 ,O TXDOH/ DQFRUD QHO FDUPH /D SDFH +4;75,/ JHQWLOL]LR RPDJJLR DO SULQ0 FLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 0RGHQD/ )UDQFHVFR 9 +LO ´GXFKHUHOORµ FRPH OR GHILQLYD *LXVHSSH *LXVWL,/ QRPLQDWR FRPDQGDQWH GHOOH WUXSSH HVWHQVL/ LQWURGXFH O·,WDOLD/ PDGUH GHOOH VFLHQ]H H GHOOH DUWL/ VHFRQGR XQ·LGHD ILJXUDWLYD GL SDWULD XIILFLDOPHQWH/ GHFLVDPHQWH FODVVLFLVWD/ VHQ]D DOFXQ SHULFROR GL FHQVXUD> DFFHW0 WDWD DQ]L/ IDYRULWD GDOOD VWHVVD SROLWLFD FXOWXUDOH GHO WURQR H GHOO·DOWDUH= ´*Lj OH VFLHQ]H VWULQJRQVL D O·DUWL LQ IRUWH VSHPH/ HG q O·,WDOLD LO WHPSLR FKH OH UDFFRJOLH LQVLHPH/ HG q GL SDFH LO *HQLR FKH LQ PH]]R D ORU VL VWDµ1
, QRQ OHJLWWLPLVWL LQYHFH/ L FRQJLXUDWL H JOL HVXOL GHO SULPR 2WWRFHQWR/ L FDUERQDUL H PD]]LQLDQL/ 3LHWUR *LDQQRQH/ 'RPHQLFR *D]]DGL/ *LRYDQQL 9HFFKL/ )UDQFHVFR 0DQIUHGLQL/ *LXVHSSH &DPSL SHQVDQR URPDQWLFDPHQWH DOO·,WDOLD FRPH QXRYD UHDOWj VWRULFR0SROLWLFD/ FRPH SURJHWWR GL SDWULD QD]LRQD0 OH GD DWWXDUH QHOO·(XURSD PRGHUQD DOO·LQVHJQD FRPEDWWLYD GHOOD OLEHUWj H GHOO·LQGLSHQGHQ]D GDL GRPLQDWRUL DXVWULDFL H GDL ´WLUDQQLµ ORFDOL> SURQWL JOL DQ0 WLOHJLWWLPLVWL/ VXO WHUUHQR GHOOD FUHDWLYLWj/ D VDFULILFDUH L YDORUL DXWRQRPL GHOO·DUWH SHU REEHGLUH DL GRYHUL SUDWLFL/ SURSDJDQGLVWLFL GHOOD PLVVLRQH FLYLOH/ LQVXUUH]LRQDOH DIILGDWD DOOD OHWWHUDWXUD1 $SUH OD VWUDGD O·DSRVWROR SROLWLFR/ LO GHPRFUDWLFR ´JDODQWXRPRµ 3LHWUR *LDQQRQH/ ´SRYHUHWWR VHQ]D SDFH/ VHQ]D
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
446<
WHWWR2VHQ]D UHIULJHULR2YHQWRWW·DQQL KD WULERODWR2RVWLQDWR QHO SHFFD0 WR2GHOO·DPRU GL 3DWULDµ/ TXDOH OR ULFRUGHUj *1 *LXVWL QH /D UHSXEEOLFD;1 1DWR LO 48 PDU]R 4:<5 D &DPSRVDQWR +SURYLQFLD GL 0RGHQD,/ QHOO·HVLOLR LQ WHUUD GL )UDQFLD/ LO *LDQQRQH YHUVR LO 4;5< VFULYH L TXLQGLFL FDQWL GHOO·(VXOH<1 3XEEOL0 FDWR D 3DULJL H GLIIXVR FODQGHVWLQDPHQWH LQ ,WDOLD/ LO SRHPD GLYHQWD SUHVWR SHU PROWL JLRYDQL ´LO FUHGR GHOOD IHGH QD]LRQDOHµ1 $O *LDQQRQH VSHWWD OD TXDOLILFD GL SRHWD PRGHQHVH GHOO·HVLOLR LQ WHUPLQL WRWDOL VLD QHOOD YLWD FKH QHOO·RSHUD1 $ GLIIH0 UHQ]D GHO ORPEDUGR *LRYDQQL %HUFKHW H GHOOH VXH VRJQDQWL )DQWDVLH UHWURGDWD0 WH DO WHPSR GHL FRPXQL H GHOOD /HJD ORPEDUGD/ /·HVXOH GL *LDQQRQH SXQWD OH VXH FDUWH GLUHWWDPHQWH VXOOH GRORURVH/ PLOLWDQWL YLFHQGH GHOOD UHDOWj SROLWLFD FRQWHPSRUDQHD1 (GPRQGR/ XQ ´SRSRODQRµ PRGHQHVH/ GDOO·HVLOLR D /RQGUD/ WRUQD GL QDVFR0 VWR LQ SDWULD FRQ GXH RELHWWLYL= ULYHGHUH OD ILGDQ]DWD (PLOLD/ FRQYLQFHUOD D VH0 JXLUOR/ H XFFLGHUH LO ULQQHJDWR $GROIR1 6EDUFD YLFLQR D &DUUDUD/ VXSHUD LQVLGLH/ VSLDWH H SHULFROL G·RJQL JHQHUH/ ILQFKp LQFRQWUD VXOO·$SSHQQLQR L &DUERQDUL/ SRFKL/ ´PD LQGRPDELOL/ PD IRUWL2SHU HVHUFL]LR GL VYHQWXUDµ1 4XL/ DOOD PDF0 FKLD/ WUD LO QRWWXUQR VLOHQ]LR GHL ERVFKL/ KD XQD YLVLRQH> JOL DSSDUH/ QHO VXR ´XPLO YHVWLU VDFHUGRWDOHµ/ OD VDFUD LPPDJLQH GL GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL/ YLW0 WLPD GHL UHFHQWL SURFHVVL GL 5XELHUD1 'LVFHVR DO SLDQR/ XQD WUHPHQGD GHOX0 VLRQH DWWHQGH (GPRQGR= OD ILGDQ]DWD/ O·LQIHGHOH (PLOLD/ VL q VSRVDWD FRO WUDGL0 WRUH $GROIR GLYHQXWR LO FDSR GHOOD SROL]LD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH1 ,O IDOOLPHQWR LQ DPRUH QRQ LPSHGLVFH LO VHFRQGR RELHWWLYR1 (GPRQGR HVHJXH OD ´FRQVDFUDWDµ YHQGHWWD/ XFFLGHQGR D FROSL GL SXJQDOH LO ULQQHJDWR VELUUR +VWRULFDPHQWH *LX0 OLR %HVLQL/ SUHIHWWR GL SROL]LD GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9, QHO VXR VWHVVR SDOD]]R1 3RL ULSDUWH H VFRPSDUH SHU VHPSUH1 &DUERQDUR/ SHUVHJXLWDWR GDOOD JHQGDUPHULD GXFDOH/ 'RPHQLFR *D]]DGL +6DVVXROR/ 4:;;04;9;, QHOO·LQQR 3HU JOL HVHUFLWL LWDOLDQL ULIOHWWH OH SDWULRWWLFKH VSHUDQ]H DFFHVH GDOOD IDVH IHGHUDOLVWD GHOOD SULPD JXHUUD G·LQGLSHQGHQ]D1 &RPSRVWD GL YHUVL JULGDWL/ XUODWL SL• FKH VFULWWL +´6XRQz O·RUD GHL JUDQGL FLPHQ0 WL= 3UHVWR D O·DUPL/ LWDOLDQL JXHUULHU$µ,/ OH GLHFL VWURIH GHOO·LQQR ODQFLDQR/ FLDVFXQD/ OD SDUROD G·RUGLQH XOWLPDWLYD= ´)XRU G·,WDOLD LO SURWHUYR VWUDQLHU$µ> LQFLWDQGR DO FR0 UDJJLRVR GRYHUH GHOO·LQGLSHQGHQ]D/ EROODQGR D RJQL VWURID QHJDWLYDPHQWH O·LQYDVRUH FRPH ´EHIIDUGR/ EUXWDOH/ PDOYDJLR/ EXJLDUGR/ IHURFH/ LQJRUGR/ PD0 OLJQR/ ULEDOGR/ UDSDFHµ1 ²²²²²²²² ;
&IU1 *1 *,867,/ 2SHUH/ D FXUD GL *1 6$%%$7,1,/ 7RULQR/ 8WHW/ 4<:9/ S1 8731 3DULJL/ 'HODIRUHV/ 4;5<> /·(VXOH= SRHPD FRQ DJJLXQWD GL FHUWH VXH SRHVLH LQHGLWH/ )LUHQ0 ]H/ 7LS1 GHO *LJOLR/ 4;9;1 <
4473
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
/DXUHDWR LQ PHGLFLQD H LQ FKLUXUJLD/ IHUYLGR PD]]LQLDQR LPSOLFDWR QHL PRWL GHO 4;64/ *LRYDQQL 9HFFKL +6FDQGLDQR/ 4;3804;;8, QHOOD FDQ]RQH $OFX0 QL LOOXVWUL HVWLQWL LWDOLDQL43/ PHQWUH HVDOWD OD SDWULRWWLFD/ DXGDFH LQVXUUH]LRQH/ ULYH0 OD LQ HVVD RPEUH SHULFRORVH H PRWLYDWH GLIILGHQ]H FLUFD LO UXROR GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD1 ,QVRIIHUHQWH +DOPHQR LQ DSSDUHQ]D, GHOOD WXWHOD DXVWULDFD/ O·DPEL]LRVR )UDQFHVFR ,9 VWUXPHQWDOL]]D LO JHQHURVR SURJHWWR PHQRWWLDQR GL IRUPDUH XQD PRQDUFKLD QHOO·,WDOLD &HQWUDOH> ILQJH LQWHUHVVDPHQWR DO QXRYR 6WDWR GL FXL DYUHEEH GRYXWR FLQJHUH OD FRURQD/ PD LO VXR VFRSR VHJUHWR q TXHOOR GL DYHUQH WHPSHVWLYH LQIRUPD]LRQL VXL FRQJLXUDWL H SUHGLVSRUUH LO WUD0 GLPHQWR1 6RVSHWWL H LQWHUURJDWLYL DPDUHJJLDQR LO 9HFFKL TXDQGR GHYH FRQVWD0 WDUH LO VDQJXLQRVR IDOOLPHQWR GHOOD ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ H OD UHVWDXUD]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR ,91 ´7RUQz/ H OR VSHQVH >LO PDUWLUH 0HQRWWL FKH LO GXFD DYHYD SRUWDWR FRQ Vp LQ FDWHQH QHOOD IRUWH]]D GL 0DQWRYD@> H VHSSHOOu FRQ HOOR XQ GHOLWWR FKH JOL XRPLQL QRQ VDQQR1 6L IH· O·(VWHQVH D O·DXVWUR VLU UXEHOOR" 2 SUHSDURVVL DG LQJDQQR" 2 WUDGLD WXWWL"«µ1 'RORURVH/ LUULVROWH SHUSOHVVLWj FKH QRQ WURYHUDQQR VSD]LR QH /D &HFFKHLGH GHO OLEHUDOH H GDQWLVWD *LXVHSSH &DPSL> LO VXR SRHPD HURLFRPLFR/ YHGUHPR/ FHQWUD TXDOH LQGLVFXVVR EHUVDJOLR SROHPLFR LO GXFD ´&HFFRTXDWWURµ1 ´(VHUFL]L JUDPPDWLFDOLµ GL XQ GDQWLVWD SDWULRWD= FDUFHUDWR/ HVXOH/ DXWRUH GHOOD VDWLULFD/ DQWLGXFKLVWD &HFFKHLGH/ LO VDQIHOLFLDQR *LXVHSSH &DPSL FXUD LO 'DQWH GHOOD 0LQHUYD H O·HGL]LRQH WRULQHVH GHOOD &RPPHGLD> LO ELEOLRWHFDULR HVWHQVH/ GRQ &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL ULFR0 VWUXLVFH JOL VWXGL ELEOLFL GL 'DQWH1 ,O GDQWLVPR GL *LXVHSSH &DPSL +6DQ )HOLFH VXO 3DQDUR/ 4:;;04;:6,/ GLUHW0 WRUH GRSR O·8QLWj GHJOL $UFKLYL VWDWDOL GL 0RGHQD/ VL SUHVWD DG XQD SURILFXD/ GRSSLD OHWWXUD ILORORJLFD H SROLWLFD441 $QFKH TXDQGR ODYRUDYD GD ILORORJR H ²²²²²²²² 43
0RGHQD/ 7LS1&DSSHOOL/4;971 3HU *LXVHSSH &DPSL/ FIU1 &1 &(5(77,/ &RPPHPRUD]LRQH GHOO·LQJHJQHUH FRPP1 *1&1/ 0RGH0 QD> *1 &$1(9$==,/ 8Q SDWULRWD ELEOLRILOR H ILORORJR/ *1&1/ VDJJLR LQFOXVR LQ 0LVFHOODQHD LQ RQRUH GL *16IRU]D/ 7RULQR0/XFFD/ %DURQL/ 4<4:/ SS1 8:60<</ H SXEEOLFDWR DQFKH D SDUWH> (1(6326,72/ 9RFH *1&1 LQ (QFLFORSHGLD GDQWHVFD/ 5RPD/ 7UHFFDQL/ 4<:4, YRO1 ,/ S1 ;:4> 7UHYHV/ 9RFH *1&1 LQ 'L]LRQDULR %LRJUDILFR GHJOL ,WDOLDQL/ 5RPD/ 4<:7/ YRO1 ;9,,/ SS1 848053/ FRQ ELEOLRJUDILD/ &1 44
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
4474
OHVVLFRJUDIR HVSHUWR GL DQWLFKH VFULWWXUH/ VWRULFDPHQWH LQWHUHVVDWR DOOD OLQJXD GL 'DQWH/ LO &DPSL QRQ HUD WXWWDYLD XQ SXUR OHWWHUDWR GD WDYROLQR1 &DUERQDUR/ SDWULRWD GL SULPR SLDQR FRQ &LUR 0HQRWWL GXUDQWH LO PRWR GHO IHEEUDLR 4;64/ VXELVFH LO FDUFHUH DXVWULDFR D 9HQH]LD> QHO 4;7; OR WURYLDPR VXOOH EDUULFDWH D 0LODQR> H LQ VHJXLWR SURSXJQDWRUH ² FRQWUR OHJLWWLPLVWL H VDQIHGLVWL ² GHOO·DQQHVVLRQH GHO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH DO 3LHPRQWH1 /D SDVVLRQH SROLWLFD H LO PHVWLHUH SUDWLFR GHOO·DJURQRPR H GHOO·LQJHJQHUH FLYLOH DIILDQFDQR +D SDUWH LQ0 WHUYDOOL H SDUHQWHVL SHU FDXVH GL IRU]D PDJJLRUH, OD VXD DWWLYLWj HGLWRULDOH0 OHWWHUDULD1 1HOO·DSULOH 4;4</ FKLDPDWR D 3DGRYD/ GLUHWWRUH GHOOD 7LSRJUDILD H )RQGHULD GHOOD 0LQHUYD/ FXUD ² GL QRPH LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ )1)HGHULFL H *10DIIHL/ PD QHL IDWWL TXDVL GD VROR ² O·HGL]LRQH GHO FRVLGGHWWR 'DQWH GHOOD 0LQHUYD/ 4;55056451 'HO UHVWR SHU LO GDQWLVWD SDWULRWD GL 6DQ )HOLFH/ LO FRQYHUJHQWH LQFRQWUR GHOOD VYHQWXUD H GHOOD SDVVLRQH SROLWLFD FRQ OD ODERULRVD DWWLYLWj OHWWHUDULD DY0 YLHQH SURSULR QHO QRPH GL 'DQWH1 3ULJLRQLHUR QHO FDUFHUH YHQH]LDQR GL 6DQ 6HYHUR/ FRPSRQH /D &HFFKHLGH/ SRHPHWWR GL WHU]D ULPD HURLFRPLFR0VDWLULFR FKH PDQWLHQH FRPH SURWDJRQLVWD H EHUVDJOLR SROHPLFR LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ UHVSRQVDELOH GHOO·HVHFX]LRQH GL &LUR 0HQRWWL H 9LQFHQ]R %RUHOOL1 /DYRUDWH VXOO·LPLWD]LRQH OHVVLFDOH GL 'DQWH H GL $ULRVWR/ OH WHU]LQH GHOOD &HFFKHLGH UL0 PDQGDQR DOO·DWWXDOLWj GHOOD ´FRQJLXUD HVWHQVHµ H DOO·LQVXUUH]LRQH GHO 6 IHE0 EUDLR 4;64 SHUVRQDOPHQWH YLVVXWH GDO &DPSL/ DYHQGR FRPH UHWURVSHWWLYD/ GRORURVD H YLQGLFH L PRWL 4;530541 /D SURWDVL GLFKLDUD O·LQWHQWR EXUOHVFR GL FHOHEUDUH )UDQFHVFR ,9 H LO VXR JRYHUQR= ©&KL YXRO VDSHU GL &HFFRTXDWWUR G·(VWH GDO Gu SDUWHQGR FK·HL IX IDWWR 'XFD OH JHVWD JUDQGL H O·RSHUH PRGHVWH/ PL DVFROWL «ª ²²²²²²²² 5$*$==,, /·DWWLYLWj OHVVLFRJUDILFD GL *1&1 GDJOLµ (VHUFL]L GL OLQJXDµ DOOD FROODERUD]LRQH DO 7RPPD0 VHR0%HOOLQL/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6W1 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URY1 0RGHQH0 VLª/ V1 ;,/ 9+4<;6,/ SS15:50656> 5$*$==,/ *LXVHSSH &DPSL/ SDWULRWD H OHWWHUDWR VDQIHOLFLDQR GHOO·;33/ 0RGHQD/ $HGHV 0XUDWRULDQD/4<;;1 45 ,O WLWROR SHU HVWHVR HUD /D 'LYLQD &RPPHGLD GL 'DQWH $OLJKLHUL FRO FRPPHQWR GHO 31 $OHVVDQGUR /RPEDUGL RUD QXRYDPHQWH DUULFFKLWR GL PROWH LOOXVWUD]LRQL HGLWH HG LQHGLWH D FXUD GL *1 &$03,/ )1 )('(5,&, H *1 0$))(,1 3DGRYD/ 7LSRJUDILD GHOOD 0LQHUYD/ 4;55056/ YROO1 8/ LQ ;ƒ1
4475
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
+H VXELWR/ DOO·HVRUGLR/ LO GLVSUHJLDWLYR &HFFR SHU )UDQFHVFR DXPHQWD OD GRVH L0 URQLFD GLYHQWDQGR O·XQLILFDWR GLQDVWLFR H LUULGHQWH &HFFRTXDWWUR,1 $ VWDPSD/ VXO JLRUQDOH SROLWLFR OHWWHUDULR PRGHQHVH ´/·,WDOLD FHQWUDOHµ LO 58 PDJJLR 4;7;/ YLHQH SXEEOLFDWR XQ XQLFR IUDPPHQWR GHOOD &HFFKHLGH= TXHOOR ULJXDUGDQWH LO VD0 FULILFLR GHOO·DOWUR ´JUDQ PDUWLUH GHOOD 6DQWD FDXVD LWDOLDQDµ/ GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL1 'RSR DYHU ULHYRFDWR L PRWL FDUERQDUL GHO 4;54/ L ´SRFKL YHUVLµ WUDWWL GDO FDQWR ,,, UDFFRQWDQR OD WUDJLFD YLFHQGD GHO VDFHUGRWH FRVSLUDWRUH> LQXWLOPHQWH XQ YHVFRYR FRUUH ILQR D 9HURQD +IRUWH]]D GHO 4XDGULODWHUR/ URF0 FDIRUWH GHOO·DVVROXWLVPR DXVWULDFR, SHU VXSSOLFDUH FKH D GRQ *LXVHSSH YHQJD FRPPXWDWD OD SHQD> LO VDFHUGRWH q FRQGDQQDWR> LO JLRUQR IDWDOH GHOO·HVHFX]LRQH/ LO JLRYDQH SUHWH ´YROHQWLHU SHUGRQDµ +&RPPHGLD/ 3XUJDWRULR/ Y1453, DL VXRL QHPLFL> VDOH VXO SDOFR ´WUD OD SLRJJLD GLURWWD H OH VDHWWHµ/ YLWWLPD GHO ´OXSR YRUDFHµ +)UDQFHVFR ,9,/ ´DXWRUH GHO JUDQ GHOLWWRµ> OD FRQFOXVLRQH SUHVHQWD DFFHQWL DQFRUD GDQWHVFKL/ PXWXDWL GDOO·HSLVRGLR GHO FRQWH 8JROLQR= ´$O FDVR DWURFH/ PLVHUDQGR H WHWUR EHQ q FUXGHO FKL QRQ q PRVVR DO SLDQWR$µ1
1HL PHVL GL SULJLRQH/ LO &DPSL ODYRUD DO ´VXR 'DQWH/ VRWWRSRQHQGR OH R0 SHUH GHO SRHWD DOOD VFKHGDWXUD H DO YDJOLR OLQJXLVWLFR1 ( D FKL JOL ULPSURYHUD GL SHUGHUH WHPSR LQ ´DULGLWj ILORORJLFKH H PLVHULH JUDPPDWLFDOLµ/ ULVSRQGH FKH JOL VWXGL ILORORJLFL KDQQR DVFHQGHQ]D H LPSRUWDQ]D DQFKH SDWULRWWLFD LQ TXDQ0 WR/ ´SLHWUD IRQGDPHQWDOH G·RJQL DOWUD XPDQD H VFLHQWLILFD GLVFLSOLQDµ/ IDQQR FRQRVFHUH D XQ SRSROR LO SURSULR SDWULPRQLR OLQJXLVWLFR1 /H OXQJKH RUH GHO FDUFHUH *LXVHSSH &DPSL OH WUDVFRUUH ULHPSLHQGR YDUL TXDGHUQL GL ´HVHUFL]L JUDPPDWLFDOLµ/ FRPH DPDYD FKLDPDUOL1 1HO TXDGHUQR , OHJJLDPR= 4XL FRPLQFLDQR OH $QQRWD]LRQL VRSUD OD '1&1/ D FRU0 UH]LRQH H JLXQWD GHO *UDQ 'L]LRQDULR GHOOD /LQJXD LWDOLDQD/ LQFRPLQFLDWH LO 5: GL IHE0 EUDLR +4;65, QHOOH FDUFHUL SROLWLFKH GL 61 6HYHUR LQ 9HQH]LD1 6RQR 95:9 DUWLFROL OHVVL0 FDOL1 1HO TXDGHUQR ;,9/ WHUPLQDWR OR VSRJOLR GHOOH GXH SULPH FDQWLFKH/ DQQR0 WD= ´11%1 7HUPLQDL TXHVWD FDQWLFD +,QIHUQR, DOOH RUH ; DQWLPHULGLDQH GHO 64 PDJJLR/ XOWLPR GHOOD PLD SULJLRQLD QHOOH FDUFHUL SROLWLFKH GL 6DQ 6HYHUR GL 9HQH]LD/ GRYH IXL VRVWHQXWR LQGH0 ELWDPHQWH SHU TXDWWRUGLFL PHVL1 ,Q 9; JLRUQL/ KR SRWXWR FRUUHUH WDQWD YLD QHOOD 6HJUHWD Q186µ1
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
4476
6HPSUH QHOO·DPELWR GHO GDQWLVPR PRGHQHVH GHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ VXO WHUUHQR HUXGLWR YDOJRQR OH LQGDJLQL ELEOLFR0UHOLJLRVH H L ULOLHYL VWRULFR0OLWXUJLFL GL PRQVLJQRU 9HQDQ]LR &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL +/LYL]]DQR/ 4:<800RGHQD/ 4;98,/ FDWWHGUDWLFR GL 6DFUD 6FULWWXUD H /LQJXD HEUDLFD DOO·8QLYHUVLWj GL 0RGHQD QHO 4;63> ELEOLRWHFDULR GXFDOH H GLUHWWRUH GHO 0HGDJOLHUH (VWHQVH QHO 4;781 (0 VSHUWR DUFKHRORJR H QXPLVPDWLFR/ SXEEOLFD FRPH GDQWLVWD QHO 4;94 XQ 6DJJLR GL RVVHUYD]LRQL VRSUD JOL VWXGL ELEOLFL GL 'DQWH $OLJKLHUL46/ LQTXDGUDWR QHOOD SURVSHW0 WLYD GL XQ SL• DPSLR GLVFRUVR VXJOL VFULWWRUL GHO 7UHFHQWR OHWWL H ULYLVLWDWL QRQ VROR GDO YHUVDQWH OLQJXLVWLFR H SXULVWD PD SHU OD VLVWHPDWLFD SUHVHQ]D GL UL0 PDQGL H VHJQDOL UHOLJLRVL RIIHUWL GDOOH ORUR SDJLQH1 /HJJHUH 'DQWH FRQ 'DQWH/ ULYHGHUH OR VYROJHUVL UHOLJLRVR0FXOWXUDOH GHO ´SRHPD VDFURµ LX[WD SULQFLSLD VXD/ VFDYDUH QHOOD WUDGL]LRQH H QHOOH IRQWL ULIDFHQGR O·LWLQHUDULR GHJOL VWXGL FKH DW0 WUDVVHUR H LPSHJQDURQR LO 3RHWD/ DOOD OXFH IRUPDWLYD GHOOH VXH LQGLYLGXDOL HG HSRFDOL FRQYLQ]LRQL= TXHVWL SURSRVLWL VLWXDQR &HOHVWLQR &DYHGRQL IXRUL GDO ´VRJJHWWLYLVPRµ URPDQWLFR H SROLWLFDPHQWH SDVVLRQDOH/ FKH QRQ FHVVD +VH PDL, GL GHSUHFDUH1 1HOO·LQWURGX]LRQH DO 6DJJLR GL RVVHUYD]LRQL VRSUD JOL VWXGL ELEOLFL GL '1$1/ GLFKLD0 UD HVSUHVVDPHQWH FKH SHU FRPSUHQGHUH O·DXWRUH WUHFHQWHVFR GHOOD &RPPHGLD/ ´QHFHVVDULD FRQGL]LRQHµ q O·DFFHWWDUH L VXL ´SULQFLSL UHOLJLRVL/ ILORVRILFL/ SROLWL0 FL/ VHQ]D FHUFDUH GL VRVWLWXLUOL FRQ XQ VRJJHWWLYLVPR IXRU OXRJR FKH FL GLHGH OH VFLRFFKH]]H GHOO·$URX[ >O·DOOXVLRQH LQYHVWH L JLXGL]L DQWLGDQWHVFKL IRUPXODWL GD $URXHW )UDQFRLV 0DULH/ GHWWR 9ROWDLUH/ LQ SL• OXRJKL GHOOH VXH RSHUH@/ OH XWRSLH GL 5RVVHWWL >*DEULHOH 5RVVHWWL FKH YROOH OHJJHUH LO SRHPD GHOO·$OLJKLHUL LQ FKLDYH PDVVRQLFD H DQWLSDSDOH@/ H WDQWH LQWHUSUHWD]LRQL GHO 9HOWUR FKH IX YROXWR JXHOIR R JKLEHOOLQR D VHFRQGD FKH JXHOIL R JKLEHOOLQL IXURQR L FRP0 PHQWDWRULµ1 /D ULFHUFD GHO &DYHGRQL SURFHGH SHU XQ·DOWUD VWUDGD/ GLYHUVDPHQWH DWWHQWD DOOD FRVFLHQ]D H DOOD FXOWXUD ELEOLFR0HYDQJHOLFD GL 'DQWH/ XRPR FULVWLDQR GHO 0HGLRHYR1
²²²²²²²² 46
&IU1µ2SXVFROL UHOLJLRVL/OHWWHUDUL H PRUDOLµ/ 0RGHQD/ (UHGL 6ROLDQL/ ;/ S1 494 H VV1> TXLQGL LQ 5DIIURQWL WUD JOL DXWRUL ELEOLFL H VDFUL H OD 'LYLQD &RPPHGLD/ FRQ SUHI1 H SHU FXUD GL 51 081$5,/ &LW0 Wj GL &DVWHOOR/ 61 /DSL/ WLSRJUDIR HGLWRUH/4;9<1 3HU LO GDQWLVPR PRGHQHVH H OD VXD IRUWXQD YH0 GL= 51 %(57$&&+,1,/ ,Oµ SRHPD VDFURµ H L GDQWLVWL D 0RGHQD/ LQWURGX]1 DOOD ´/HFWXUD 'DQWLV PRGHQH0 VHµ/ YRO1,/ ,QIHUQR/ %DQFD 3RSRODUH GHOO·(PLOLD0&RPLWDWR SURYLQFLDOH 'DQWH $OLJKLHUL/4<;7/ SS1 ;,0/;,1
4477
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
5LVRUJLPHQWDOLVPR ´VSHFXODWLYRµ GL /XLJL =LQL> QHO VXR WDUGLYR URPDQ]R VWRULFR 6DQ0 IHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL ULVDOWDQR OH FRQWUDSSRVWH ILJXUH GHO ´6RFUDWH FULVWLDQRµ/ LO VDFHUGRWH )RUWLQL2$QGUHROL H GHO SUHIHWWR GL SROL]LD %RUJRYHFFKLR2%HVLQL1 ,O ´3DQDURµ/ LQ GDWD 55 VHWWHPEUH 4;73/ QHOO·DQQXQFLDUH OD PRUWH GL /XLJL =LQL/ DYYHQXWD OD VHUD GHO 54 VHWWHPEUH GRSR OXQJD PDODWWLD/ VFULYHYD= ´« XRPR GL SURQWR H YHUVDWLOH LQJHJQR/ GL EHOOD FXOWXUD H GL YLUW• QRQ FRPXQL1 1HOOH GLVFLSOLQH VWRULFKH SRL SDOHVz LQFRQWUDVWDWR YDORUH/ VHEEHQH LQ OXL VSHV0 VR SUHYDOHVVHUR L FULWHUL H OH DIIHUPD]LRQL GHOOH SDUWL D LQWRUELGDUH TXHOOD VHUH0 QD HVSRVL]LRQH GHJOL DYYHQLPHQWL/ VHQ]D FXL QRQ F·HUD YHUD VWRULD1 $Pz H VHUYu O·,WDOLD H QHO 4;8< IX/ LQ 0RGHQD VXD SDWULD/ FRPPLVVDULR SURYYLVRULR SHU LO UH GL 6DUGHJQD1 ,Q WDOH YHVWH ILUPz GHFUHWL PHPRUDELOLµ1 &RQ OHWWHUD DO %RQL GHO 58 IHEEUDLR 4;<7/ OR VWHVVR =LQL/ GL VXR SXJQR/ DYHYD WXWWDYLD SUH0 PHVVR= ´«6EDOHVWUDWR GDL FDVL/ SULPD SHU O·HVLOLR/ DSSUHVVR SHU UDJLRQL G·XIILFLR/ GL OXRJR LQ OXRJR/ LQFDO]DWR GDOOH FXUH GHO VHUYL]LR SXEEOLFR/ LQ UHDOWj LR SUHVL SRFD SDUWH DOO·LPSUHVD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR QD]LRQDOH/ VH QRQ FRO FXRUH/ FROO·DQLPR/ FROOR VWXGLR= SHUWDQWR SL• VSHFXODWLYDPHQWH FKH PDWHULDOPHQWH« µ1 7HVWLPRQLDQR TXHVWR ULVRUJLPHQWDOLVPR VSHFXODWLYR GHOOR =LQL OD 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ JOL 6FULWWL OHWWHUDUL HGLWL HG LQHGLWL/ LO URPDQ]R 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL1 8VFLWD GDO 4;99 DO 4;9</ OD 6WRULD G·,WDOLD FRQWLQXD H VL DGHJXD D TXHOOD GL *LXVHSSH )DULQD/ ULFRQRVFHQGR DO SUHGHFHVVRUH VH QRQ SURSULR ´O·DOWH]]D GHL QRVWUL FODVVLFLµ/ LO SUHJLR SHUDOWUR GHO ´QDUUDWRUH SLDQR H IDFLOH DG XQ WHPSR VHQ]D SXQWR GDUH QHO EDVVR H QHO YROJDUHµ1 1RWD FRPXQH DJOL 6FULWWL OHWWHUDUL UHVWD OD PHVVD LQ GLVFXVVLRQH GHL FRQWHP0 SRUDQHL 9HUJD/ 6DYLQL/ *LRYDJQROL/ %DUULOL/ )DULQD/ SRUWDYRFL GL XQD OHWWHUDWX0 UD ´GD ULJDWWLHULµ/ FRQWHVWDWL/ GHSUH]]DWL/ DO FRQIURQWR GHL URPDQWLFL GHO SULPR 2WWRFHQWR/ 0DQ]RQL H *XHUUD]]L/ *URVVL/ '·$]HJOLR H &DWWDQHR471 3RVL]LRQH DQDFURQLVWLFD= PD QRQ SULYD GL LQWHUHVVH TXDQGR VL SHQVL FKH FRVWLWXLVFH OD FRQVHTXHQ]LDOH/ SUDWLFD UDJLRQH/ LO PRYHQWH LGHDWLYR FKH FRQGXUUj OR =LQL/ LQ SLHQR 4;;;/ D FRQFHSLUH 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL48 FKH/ DOO·DWWR GHOOD SXEEOLFD]LR0 QH QHO 4;;</ VL IUHJLD GHO VRWWRWLWROR VROHQQH H EORFFDWR GL URPDQ]R VWRULFR1 &RPH VL VSLHJD XQ VLPLOH DIILGDUVL DO JHQHUH VWRULFR LQ XQ 2WWRFHQWR ILQ GH VLqFOH FKH VYLOXSSD HVSHULHQ]H QDUUDWLYH EHQ GLYHUVDPHQWH RULJLQDOL H DJJLRUQD0 ²²²²²²²² 47 &IU1 /1 =,1,/ 6FULWWL OHWWHUDUL HGLWL HG LQHGLWL/FRQ DJJLXQWH DOFXQH OHWWHUH GL )1'1*XHUUD]]L DOO·DXWRUH/ 0RGHQD/ 7LS1317RVFKL/ 4;;5/S1771 48 &IU1 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL/ URPDQ]R VWRULFR GL /1 =,1,/ 7RULQR/ *1%13DUDYLD/4;;<1
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
4478
WH" 5LIOHWWLDPR DOOH GDWH= 9HUJD KD JLj VFULWWR 9LWD GHL FDPSL/ , 0DODYRJOLD H SURSULR QHO 4;;; ² O·DQQR GL FRPSRVL]LRQH GL 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL 0 VFULYHUj 0DVWUR GRQ *HVXDOGR/ FRPSOHWDQGR LO ´FLFOR GHL YLQWLµ1 1HO 4;;9/ (GPRQGR 'H $PLFLV FRQ &XRUH KD DYYLDWR OD PRGHUQD OHWWHUDWXUD HGXFDWLYD1 $QWRQLR )R0 JD]]DUR QHO 4;;4 KD FRPSRVWR 0DORPEUD/ LQL]LDQGR TXHOOD OHWWHUDWXUD LQWLPL0 VWD0UHOLJLRVD FKH JOL GDUj IDPD1 *DEULHOH '·$QQXQ]LR/ RVSLWH GHO SLWWRUH )1 3DROR 0LFKHWWL QHO ´FRQYHQWRµ 6DQWD 0DULD 0DJJLRUH D )UDQFDYLOOD D 0DUH/ IUD LO OXJOLR H LO GLFHPEUH 4;;;/ UHDOL]]D ,O 3LDFHUH1 0HQWUH OD QDUUDWLYD LWDOLDQD GHOO·XOWLPR 2WWRFHQWR VWD DOOLQHDQGRVL FRQ JOL LQWHUHVVL WHPDWLFL HXURSHL H L QXRYL VWDWXWL GHO 9HULVPR2'HFDGHQWLVPR/ TXDOH JLXVWLILFD]LRQH SXz DYHUH O·LQFDPPLQDUVL GHO QRVWUR =LQL SHU OD VWUDGD RUPDL FKLXVD GHO URPDQ]R VWRULFR" 3HU LO PHPRULDOLVPR URPDQ]HVFR GHO PRGHQHVH FKH LQ 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQD0 UL ULHYRFD L SURFHVVL GL 5XELHUD 4;53054/ GRYUHPR SHQVDUH QRQ VROR D XQ SHUGXUDQWH/ GRYHURVR LPSXOVR GL FDULWj SDWULD/ PD DQFKH H VRSUDWWXWWR DO UL0 VHQWLPHQWR SRVW0XQLWDULR/ DO IRUWH DQWLFOHULFDOLVPR FKH DQLPDYD OR =LQL/ XR0 PR SROLWLFR GHOOD 6LQLVWUD1 &RQ O·DYYHQWR GHOOD 6LQLVWUD DO SRWHUH +4;:9, WUR0 YLDPR LQIDWWL OR =LQL LQWHQGHQWH JHQHUDOH H SUHIHWWR D 0RGHQD/ H SRL D )HUUD0 UD/ 6LHQD/ %UHVFLD1 ( FKH FL WHQHVVH D IDU YDOHUH OD VXD GHFLVD DSSDUWHQHQ]D DOOD 6LQLVWUD/ LGHH H SURJUDPPL FRPSUHVL/ OR GLPRVWUDQR OH VXH /HWWHUH/ SULYDWH H SXEEOLFKH/ HGLWH LQ SDUWH QHO 4;:9/ LQ SDUWH QHO 4;;3/ DOO·LQVHJQD 'HL FULWHUL H GHL PRGL GL *RYHUQR= OH SULPH FRQ O·DJJLXQWD ´QHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLDµ H OH VHJXHQWL FRQ O·DJJLXQWD/ DQFKH SL• UHVSRQVDELOPHQWH HVSOLFLWD H VLJQLILFDWLYD/ ´GHOOD 6LQLVWUD QHO 5HJQR G·,WDOLDµ1 7RUQDQGR DO URPDQ]R/ QRQ VDUj GXQTXH VXIILFLHQWH IHU0 PDUVL VXO VHPSOLFH WLWROR/ Qp DWWHQGHUH DOOD PDWHULD VROWDQWR/ DQWL0OHJLWWLPLVWD H ULVRUJLPHQWDOH WUDWWDWD D SRVWHULRUL1 1HO URPDQ]R/ ULSHWLDPR/ YHQJRQR ULSUHVL L SURFHVVL GL 5XELHUD 4;53054/ LVWLWXLWL GDO ´7ULEXQDOH VWDWDULRµ HVWHQVH SHU JLXGLFDUH XQ JUXSSR GL VRVSHWWL DGHUHQWL DOOD &DUERQHULD> QHO FRUVR GHOO·LVWUXWWRULD LO GLUHWWRUH GHOOD SROL]LD GX0 FDOH/ *LXOLR %HVLQL/ FKH OD YRFH SXEEOLFD DFFXVD GL DYHU XVDWR VLVWHPL GLVX0 PDQL GXUDQWH JOL LQWHUURJDWRUL/ FDGH SXJQDODWR> O·XFFLVLRQH FRQIHUPD D )UDQ0 FHVFR ,9 ² HUHGH GHJOL (VWHQVL H DUFLGXFD DVEXUJLFR/ VRVWHQLWRUH GHOOD VRYUD0 QLWj DVVROXWD ² OD SHULFRORVD/ FROSHYROH FRQVLVWHQ]D GHO FRPSORWWR/ DJJUDYDQ0 GR OD SRVL]LRQH GHJOL DFFXVDWL1 /·44 VHWWHPEUH 4;55 L SURFHVVL GL 5XELHUD WHUPLQDQR FRQ < FRQGDQQH D PRUWH H 6; DO FDUFHUH> WUD L FRQGDQQDWL D PRUWH +PD : VRQR FRQWXPDFL H O·RWWDYR/ )UDQFHVFR &RQWL/ KD FRPPXWDWD OD SHQD, OD VHQWHQ]D FDSLWDOH YLHQH FRQIHUPDWD VROR D GRQ *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL/ ´UHR FRQ0
4479
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
FRQYLQWR H FRQIHVVRµ GHO GHOLWWR GL ´OHVD PDHVWjµ H ´SHU HVVHUH GL SL• VWDWR VHGXWWRUH GHOOD JLRYHQW• HG DWWLUDUOD QHOOD 6RFLHWj GHL &DUERQDUL/ D FXL HJOL DSSDUWHQHYDµ1 2OWUH FKH ULHYRFDUH/ FRPPHPRUDUH O·DOED JORULRVD H GRORURVD GHO 5LVRU0 JLPHQWR/ WLWROR H UHODWLYD PDWHULD/ 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL/ DUJRPHQWR H VFHOWD GHO VRJJHWWR URPDQ]HVFR WRUQDQR VXJJHULWL GD UDJLRQL FRQWLQJHQWL/ ULYHQGLFDWL DO0 OD OXFH GHO SUHVHQWH SRVWXQLWDULR1 /D ULSUHVD/ O·DWWXDOL]]D]LRQH GHL WHPL FDUER0 QDUL/ FRPH GL TXHOOL VDQIHGLVWL H FRQFLVWRULDOL +´SLH VRFLHWj FDWWROLFKH ² VL GLFH ² QHOOH TXDOL HUD JLj LO JHUPH VHWWDULR SROLWLFR,49/ DYYLHQH LQ FKLDYH GHFLVDPHQ0 WH DQWLWHPSRUDOLVWLFD 4;:3/ LQ FOLPD GL DSHUWR FRQIOLWWR 6WDWR2&KLHVD/ GL SRWH0 UL ODLFL VWDWXDOL FRQWUR XQ 9DWLFDQR RVWLOH DO +QRQ PDL ULFRQRVFLXWR, 5HJQR G·,WDOLD1 /D ULSUHVD GHJOL DQQDOL 4;53055 GL YLFHQGH H SHUVRQDJJL LQWHUHVVDQWL SUR H FRQWUR LO VDQIHGLVPR GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH LQGLFD LO SHUGXUDUH SUHVVR OR =LQL GL SUHJLXGL]LDOL DQWLFXULDOLVWH ULQIRFRODWH GDOO·LQJUHVVR GHL EHUVDJOLHUL D 5RPD SHU OD EUHFFLD GL 3RUWD 3LD> FKLDULVFH O·DWWLYR/ SODXVLELOH LQVRUJHUH GD SDUWH VXD GL XQ FUHGR GHPRFUDWLFR H DQWLSDSDOH> FRQIHUPD DO SXEEOLFLVWD H DO0 OR VFULWWRUH SROLWLFR TXHOO·DFFHVR/ IUHPHQWH ODLFLVPR FKH FDUDWWHUL]]D OD 6LQL0 VWUD DO JRYHUQR H LO JUXSSR GHL VXRL GHSXWDWL1 3HU OD FRPSLXWD LQWHOOLJHQ]D GHO URPDQ]R 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL RFFRUUH UL0 FRUGDUH FKH/ VRWWR LO QRPH GL 'RQ *LDQQDQWRQLR )RUWLQL/ VL FHOD O·$QGUHROL> FRPH 61$1 5HDOH VXJJHULVFH RYYLDPHQWH )UDQFHVFR ,9> PHQWUH OD WULVWH PD0 VFKHUD GHO &DYDOLHUH *LRUJLR GL %RUJRYHFFKLR UDSSUHVHQWD DO YLYR LO FDSR GHO0 OD SROL]LD *LXOLR %HVLQL1 'DSSULPD JLRYDQH VDQIHGLVWD/ QHO GLVLQJDQQR FKH SUHVWR VHJXH DOO·LQL]LD]LRQH FOHULFDOH/ LO VDFHUGRWH )RUWLQL2$QGUHROL DEEUDFFLD LQ VHJUHWR OD &DUERQHULD VHQWHQGR FRLQFLGHUH DPRU GL SDWULD H DSRVWRODWR FUL0 VWLDQR/ ´SRLFKp OD FDULWj GHOOD SDWULD VL FRQJLXQJH EHQLVVLPR FRO WLPRU GL 'LR H FRQ OD FDULWj GHO SURVVLPRµ1 &ROSLWR H VFRQYROWR GDOOD VFRPXQLFD/ HQWUD LQ FULVL1 8QD VRUWD GL WHPSHVWD GHO GXEELR UHOLJLRVR/ ROWUH FKH PRUDOH H SROLWLFR/ ULVFKLD GL WUDVIRUPDUOR LQ ´OLEHUR SHQVDWRUHµ1 0D SRL DFFHWWD LO PDUWLULR/ VRIIUH ILQR LQ IRQGR OD FRQ0 GDQQD LQIDPDQWH FKH OR YXROH SUHWH VFRQVDFUDWR SULPD GHOO·HVHFX]LRQH FDSL0 WDOH1 ,O VDFHUGRWH SDWULRWD/ LO ´6RFUDWH FULVWLDQRµ $QGUHROL VSLFFD SHU FRQWUDVWR QHOOR VFKLHUDPHQWR GHL SUHODWL FKH OR =LQL VFKHPDWL]]D QHJDWLYDPHQWH LQ IXQ0 ]LRQH GHOOH ORUR LGHH UHWULYH1 'RQ 'RPHQLFR/ DOLDV 'RQ 6SDXUDFFKLR/ LO SL• ULJLGR FRQIHVVRUH ´OLFHQ]LDWR GDO &RQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR LQ SRLµ/ DSSDUH FRQ ²²²²²²²² 49
&IU1 6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDUL 111FLW1/ S1 58;1
$YYHQLPHQWL H SHUVRQDJJL SROLWLFL PRGHQHVL QHOOD FLYLOWj OHWWHUDULD GHOO·2WWRFHQWR
447:
O·DVSHWWR LVSLGR H GXUR GHO ´WHUURULVWD LQHVRUDELOHµ1 $OO·RSSRVWR/ 'RQ 5LQDO0 GR/ DOLDV 3DGUH $PRURVR/ ´IDWWR/ FLPDWR/ EDJQDWR H WDJOLDWR D SRVWD SHU FRQ0 IHVVRUH GL VLJQRUHµ4:/ ULYHOD XQD GROFH]]D VIXJJHQWH HG HTXLYRFD1 $ VXD YROWD LO JHVXLWD 3DGUH 6FDUXIIL/ GHXV H[ PDFKLQD GHOO·D]LRQH SROLWLFR0UHOLJLRVD VDQIHGL0 VWD QHO GXFDWR/ PDQWLHQH XQ ODPSHJJLDUH G·RFFKL SHQHWUDQWH/ XQ SRUWDPHQWR JUDYH ´H GLFLDPR SXUH DOWHURµ TXDOH VL DGGLFH DOOD EDOGDQ]D/ DOO·DUULYLVPR GHOO·2UGLQH GHL *HVXLWL/ IUHVFR GHOOD ULQDVFLWD DYYHQXWD D 0RGHQD ILQ GDOO·DJRVWR GHO 4;471 (IILFDFH/ QDUUDWLYDPHQWH ULXVFLWR/ LO FROORTXLR GL 61$1 5HDOH FRO 3DGUH 6FDUXIIL/ GXH DXURULWj/ GXH +PDQ]RQLDQH, FDQL]LH= XQ SLFFROR FDSRODYRUR GL GLSORPD]LD SROLWLFD UHVWDXUDWLYD/ FKH UHQGH EHQH OD GLIILFLOH VL0 WXD]LRQH LQ FXL YHQJRQR D WURYDUVL L GXH LQWHUORFXWRUL> GD XQ ODWR LO 3ULQFLSH SUHRFFXSDWR GL QRQ GHOXGHUH/ GL QRQ DYYLOLUH L 6DQIHGLVWL +DOOHDWL IHGHOL GHO SURJUDPPD DVVROXWLVWLFR,> GDOO·DOWUR LO 3DGUH LQ YHVWH GL PLQLVWUR SOHQLSRWHQ0 ]LDULR GHOOD &RPSDJQLD/ VHPSUH SL• HVLJHQWH H LQYDGHQWH/ WDQWR GD YROHUH SHU L FRUUHOLJLRQDUL JHVXLWL O·DIILGDPHQWR H OD JHVWLRQH GLUHWWD GL WXWWH OH VFXROH VH0 FRQGDULH GHO GXFDWR4;1 &RORULWXUH DOOD *XHUUD]]L SLXWWRVWR FKH DOOD 0DQ]RQL LQYHVWRQR LO FDSR GHOOD SROL]LD *LRUJLR %RUJRYHFFKLR1 $ SDUWH FHUWH IDVWLGLRVH SDUHQWHOH FKH OR ULFDOFDQR VXO IDFVLPLOH OHWWHUDULR GHL PLQLVWUL FUXGHOL H WLUDQQLFL/ GL ´WDQWL PDH0 VWUL G·DOWD SROL]LDµ/ GD 6HLDQR H 7LJHOOLQR D PHVVHU &HUUHWWLHUL GL 9LVGRPLQL +FDQFHOOLHUH GL *XDOWLHUL GXFD G·$WHQH, H D VHU 5DPLUR G·2UFR +DQLPD GDQQDWD GL &HVDUH %RUJLD,4<> LO SHUVRQDJJLR %RUJRYHFFKLR2%HVLQL SUHVHQWD L FRQQRWDWL SODXVLELOL GL XQD PRGHUQD ILJXUD VDWDQLFD/ ULFFD GL FRPSOHVVL PRWLYL= JOL DQQL JLRYDQLOL LUUHTXLHWL H VPDQLRVL/ O·DPEL]LRQH UHSUHVVD/ TXHO VXR IDUVL VWUDGD WH0 QDFHPHQWH RVWLQDWR/ HJOL QRQ QRELOH/ QRQ LVFULWWR QHO ´OLEUR G·RUR GHL WLWRODWLµ1 $VFLXWWH]]D H FRQFHQWUD]LRQH WUDVSDLRQR QHO ULWUDWWR LQL]LDOH53= ´«QRQ HUD Qp EHOOR Qp VLPSDWLFR/ PD QHPPHQR YROJDUH1 'L PH]]DQD VWDWXUD/ EUXQR D WLSR TXDVL VSDJQROR/ XQ SURILOR DQJRORVR D EHFFR GL VSDUYLHUR/ OD SHOOH ROLYD0 VWUD ULOHYDWD GDL WRQL VFXUL GHOOD EDUED VHPSUH UDVDWD GL IUHVFR/ RFFKL QHUL H LQ0 FDYDWL/ RQGH OD GXUH]]D GHOOR VJXDUGR HUD WHPSHUDWD GD OHQWL WXUFKLQLFFH PRQWDWH LQ RUR «µ1 ²²²²²²²² 4:,ELGHP/
S1 861 S1 4661 4<,ELGHP/ S1 5381 53,ELGHP/ S1 681 3HU DOWUH QRWL]LH/ FIU1 51 %(57$&&+,1,/ 8Q WDUGLYR URPDQ]R VWRULFR GHOO·RWWRFHQWR PRGHQHVH= ´6DQIHGLVWL H &DUERQDULµ HVWUDWWR GD ©$WWL H 0HPRULH GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH $QWLFKH 3URYLQFLH 0RGHQHVLª/ V1 9,,,/ ;,, +4<93,/ SS1 40481 4;,ELGHP/
447;
5HQDWR %HUWDFFKLQL
7UD OH ]RQH GLDORJLFKH YROWH DG HYLGHQ]LDUH LO FRPSRUWDPHQWR LQTXLVLWRULR GHO SHUVRQDJJLR FLWLDPR LO GLDORJR/ SHUILGR H LQVLQXDQWH/ FRQ O·DYYRFDWR &DUOR )HUUDFDQL/ GHVLJQDWR GDO %RUJRYHFFKLR2%HVLQL D GLIHQGHUH JOL LQWHUHVVL GHOOR 6WDWR SUHVVR LO 7ULEXQDOH FKH GRYHYD JLXGLFDUH L UHL GL DYHU HFFLWDWR D VHGL0 ]LRQH OH PLOL]LH LPSHULDOL/ JOL XQJKHUHVL GL SDVVDJJLR D 0RGHQD= SULPD PRVVD/ FDOFRODWD H DVWXWDPHQWH HTXLYRFD/ SHU DWWLYDUH OD PDFFKLQD VSLRQLVWLFD/ QHFHV0 VDULD SUHPHVVD DO PRQWDJJLR GHO SL• JUDYH/ FUXGHOH SURFHVVR FRQWUR L &DUER0 QDUL D 5XELHUD1
02'(1$ ( */, 67$7, (8523(,
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,PSHUR
4484
+8%(57 *$66(5
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,PSHUR
0L VLD FRQVHQWLWR GL LQL]LDUH ULFRUGDQGR TXHO JHVWR FXULRVR H VRUSUHQGHQWH FKH SRUWD XQ HVSRQHQWH GHOOD FDVD G·(VWH WUD OH PRQWDJQH WLUROHVL= TXHOO·$OIRQVR ,,, FKH QHO 495</ SRFR GRSR DYHU SUHVR SRVVHVVR GHO GXFDWR +495;,/ ODVFLD LO JRYHUQR SHU IDUVL IUDWH1 (JOL ULFHYH OH RUGLQD]LRQL D 0HUDQR DOOD ILQH GHO 495< H/ VRWWR LO QRPH GL SDGUH *LRYDQQL %DWWLVWD/ ULPDQH SHU DO0 FXQL DQQL LQ WHUUD WLUROHVH/ PD OD YLWD PRQDVWLFD JOL VWD VWUHWWD H/ WRUQDWR D YL0 YHUH D 0RGHQD QHJOL DQQL 496604969/ FRQWLQXD D LQWURPHWWHUVL QHJOL DIIDUL GHOOR 6WDWR (VWHQVH ILQ TXDQGR YLHQH FRQYLQWR D ULWLUDUVL D &DVWHOQXRYR LQ *DUIDJQDQD +496904977,1 1RQ q TXHVWR LO OXRJR SHU GLOXQJDUFL VXL PRWLYL GL TXHVWR JHVWR14 &L EDVWL ULFRUGDUH FKH q VLFXUDPHQWH DQFKH HVSUHVVLRQH GL XQ GLVDJLR FKH KD FROSLWR OD FDVD (VWHQVH TXDQGR QHO 48<; q VWDWD PXWLODWD GHOOD SDUWH SL• LPSRUWDQWH GHO SURSULR VWDWR= LO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD1 4XHVWR GLVDJLR FRQWLQXD D PDQLIHVWDUVL D IDVL DOWHUQH H LQ PDQLHUH GLYHUVH DQFKH GRSR/ VLD QHO WHQWDWLYR GL UHFXSHUDUH DOPHQR XQD SDUWH GHOOH SHUGLWH VXELWH +&RPDFFKLR,/ VLD FHUFDQGR GL ULQYHUGLUH L IDVWL SDVVDWL FRQ GLYHUVL WHQWDWLYL GL DOODUJDUH/ WUD0 PLWH D]LRQL GL JXHUUD H JLRFKL GL DOOHDQ]H/ OD SURSULD VIHUD GL LQIOXHQ]D1 &UHGR FKH VLD TXHVWR O·DSSURFFLR SL• SURILFXR DQFKH SHU GHOLQHDUH L UDSSRUWL FKH LQ0 WHUFRUVHUR WUD GXFDWR H LPSHUR/ WUD OD FDVD (VWHQVH H JOL $VEXUJR1 3HU TXDVL WXWWR LO 6HLFHQWR OD SROLWLFD HVWHUD GHO GXFDWR QRQ YHGH O·,PSHUR FRPH LQWHUORFXWRUH SULYLOHJLDWR/ PD q RULHQWDWD YHUVR L VXRL QHPLFL/ LQ SULPR OXRJR OD )UDQFLD1 0D VHJXLDPR OH YLFHQGH FRQ RUGLQH1 ,O VXFFHVVRUH GL $OIRQ0 VR ,,,/ )UDQFHVFR , +495<0498;,/ QHO FRUVR GHOOD JXHUUD GHL 7UHQW·DQQL q DOOHD0 WR GHJOL VSDJQROL H ULHVFH DG HQWUDUH LQ SRVVHVVR GL &RUUHJJLR1 1RQ WURYDQGR DOWUH VRGGLVID]LRQL VL DYYLFLQD QHO 497: DOOD )UDQFLD DOODFFLDQGR UDSSRUWL FRQ ²²²²²²²² 4
&IU1 )1 %5$9,/ ,O SULQFLSH IUDWH/ %RO]DQR 4<:51
4485
+XEHUW *DVVHU
LO 0D]]DULQR1 4XHVWD DOOHDQ]D FRQ L IUDQFHVL DSSURGD LQ XQ·D]LRQH PLOLWDUH FRQWUR &UHPRQD +497<, FKH SHUz QRQ Gj ULVXOWDWL1 $G XQ ULVXOWDWR VL JLXQJH LQYHFH LQ XQ VHFRQGR PRPHQWR TXDQGR/ QHO 4987/ VL FHOHEUD LO PDWULPRQLR GHO ILJOLR +$OIRQVR, FRQ /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ QLSRWH GL 0D]]DULQR1 ,Q VHJXLWR +4989, )UDQFHVFR GLYHQWD FRPDQGDQWH GHOOH WUXSSH IUDQFHVL LQ ,WDOLD H FRQ0 GXFH YDULH FDPSDJQH LQ /RPEDUGLD/ FRPSUHVR XQ DVVHGLR D 0LODQR1 3HUz YLHQH FROSLWR GDOOD PDODULD SHU FXL SUHVWR PXRUH +498;,1 1RQ PXWD LO TXDGUR GL DOOHDQ]H FRQ LO VXFFHVVRUH/ $OIRQVR ,9 +498;0 4995,1 3RL/ SHU LO JLRYDQH )UDQFHVFR ,,/ QDWR QHO 4993/ q OD PDGUH /DXUD 0DU0 WLQR]]L DG DVVXPHUH OD UHJJHQ]D +ILQR DO 49:7,1 , OHJDPL FRQ OD )UDQFLD UL0 PDQJRQR FRPXQTXH EHQ VDOGL ILQR DOOD PRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR +49<7,1 &RQ 5LQDOGR +49<704:6:,/ ]LR GL )UDQFHVFR ,, H JLj FDUGLQDOH/ DYYLHQH XQ UDGLFDOH PXWDPHQWR QHOO·RULHQWDPHQWR HVWHUR GHO GXFDWR1 5LQDOGR LQIDWWL VSR0 VD &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD GL %UXQVZLFN +49<8,1 ( TXDWWUR DQQL GRSR YLHQH FHOHEUDWR D 0RGHQD LO PDWULPRQLR WUD LO ILJOLR GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH /HRSROGR/ *LXVHSSH +IX0 WXUR LPSHUDWRUH,/ H XQD VRUHOOD GL &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD/ $PDOLD *XJOLHOPLQD1 +D FRVu LQL]LR XQ LQWUHFFLR GL UDSSRUWL SL• VWUHWWL FRQ TXHOOD FDVD FKH DQFKH JUD0 ]LH DG XQ·DFFRUWD SROLWLFD IDPLOLDUH H GL DSSDUHQWDPHQWR q ULXVFLWD DG DIIHU0 PDUVL H D FRQVROLGDUVL QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL H DG LQVHULUVL FRPH FRPSULPDULD WUD OH JUDQGL SRWHQ]H HXURSHH1 6L WUDWWD GHJOL $VEXUJR1 , VROL OHJDPL LVWLWX]LRQDOL WUD GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H ,PSHUR QRQ HUDQR PDL YDOVL D LQVWDXUDUH XQ UDSSRUWR GL VWUHWWD DOOHDQ]D WUD OH GXH HQWLWj1 /R 6WDWR H0 VWHQVH VL HUD VYLOXSSDWR QHO FRUVR GHL VHFROL VXOOD EDVH GL LQYHVWLWXUH IHXGDOL GD SDUWH GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH H GD SDUWH GHOOR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD15 4XHVWH LQYHVWL0 WXUH YHQQHUR VHPSUH FRQIHUPDWH/ ILQFKp OD FDVD HVWHQVH ULXVFu DG DYHUH GL0 VFHQGHQWL LQ JUDGR GL DFFRJOLHUOH1 &RQGL]LRQH YHQXWD PHQR SHU OH LQYHVWLWXUH SDSDOL GRSR OD PRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,, +48<:,/ TXDQGR OD FDVD G·(VWH VL WURYz SULYD GL GLVFHQGHQ]D PDVFKLOH OHJLWWLPD H IX HVWURPHVVD GDO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD +&RQYHQ]LRQH )DHQWLQD/ 48<;,1 /·LPSHUDWRUH QRQ DYHYD LQYHFH GLIILFROWj D ULFRQRVFHUH FRPH QXRYR GXFD &HVDUH/ FXJLQR GL $OIRQVR ,, H ILJOLR GL $OIRQ0 VR/ D VXD YROWD ILJOLR QDWXUDOH +LQ VHJXLWR OHJLWWLPDWR WUDPLWH PDWULPRQLR GHL ²²²²²²²² 5 , YDUL GLSORPL GL LQYHVWLWXUD VRQR ULSRUWDWL GDO 0XUDWRUL QHOOH VXH PHPRULH HODERUDWH LQ GLIHVD GHL GLULWWL GHL GXFKL GL 0RGHQD VX &RPDFFKLR= 2VVHUYD]LRQL VXO GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GHOOD 6HGH $SRVWROLFD VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR/ 0RGHQD 4:3;> 6XSSOLFD GL 5LQDOGR , GXFD GL 0RGHQD SHU OH FRQ0 WURYHUVLH GL &RPDFFKLR/ 0RGHQD 4:43> 4XHVWLRQL FRPDFFKLHVL/ 4:44> 3LHQD HVSRVL]LRQH GH L GLULWWL LPSH0 ULDOL HG HVWHQVL VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR/ 4:45> 'LVDPLQD GL XQD VFULWWXUD LQWLWRODWD ´5LVSRVWD D YDULH VFULWWXUH LQ SURSRVLWR GHOOD FRQWURYHUVLD GL &RPDFFKLRµ/ 4:531
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,PSHUR
4486
JHQLWRUL, GL $OIRQVR ,16 /R 6WDWR (VWHQVH/ PRQFR SHU OD SHUGLWD GL )HUUDUD/ FRQWLQXD OD VXD HVLVWHQ]D LQ EDVH DOOH LQYHVWLWXUH LPSHULDOL1 /·LQYHVWLWXUD/ EHQ0 FKp FRQVLGHUDWD FRO SDVVDUH GHL VHFROL XQD PHUD IRUPDOLWj/ FRQWLQXD FRPXQ0 TXH DG HVSOLFDUVL VHFRQGR OH FRQVXHWXGLQL PHGLHYDOL1 %DVWD SHUz RVVHUYDUH LO FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHL GXFKL GL 0RGHQD QHO FRUVR GHO VHF1 ;9,,/ H SL• DQFRUD QHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO VHF1 ;9,,, +GXUDQWH OH YDULH JXHUUH GL VXFFHVVLRQH,/ SHU FDSLUH FKH OD IHGHOWj SURPHVVD QRQ HUD SL• VHQWLWD FRPH FRQGL]LRQH IRQGDQWH GHOO·LQYHVWLWXUD1 &Lz QRQ WRJOLH FKH DG RJQL PRUWH/ GL GXFD R GL LPSHUDWRUH/ LO GXFD GRYHWWH PHWWHUVL QHL SDQQL XPLOLDQWL GL TXHVWXDQWH GL IURQWH DOO·LPSHUDWRUH17 6H HVDPLQLDPR SL• DWWHQWDPHQWH L GLULWWL GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH VX TXHOOD SDUWH GHOO·,WDOLD GL SHUWLQHQ]D LPSHULDOH/ WUD FXL 0RGHQD/ FL DFFRUJLDPR FKH HVVL VL ULGXFRQR D EHQ SRFR= LO FRQIHULPHQWR GL FHWR/ OD VXSUHPD JLXULVGL]LRQH VXJOL LPPHGLDWL GHOO·LPSHUR/ O·LPSRVL]LRQH GL WULEXWL QRQFKp OD VRYUDQLWj IHXGDOH VXL IHXGL LPSHULDOL18 6LFFRPH D TXHVWL GLULWWL VRQR LQ OLQHD GL PDVVLPD FROOHJDWL GHL ULFDYL q IDFLOPHQWH FRPSUHQVLELOH FKH LO WLWRODUH GL WDOL GLULWWL FHUFKL GL FRQVHUYDUOL1 $QQRWD LO %UDXQHGHU= ´$QFRUD DOO·LPSHUDWRUH *LXVHSSH ,, XQ SD0 UHUH UDFFRPDQGDYD GL WHQHUVL VWUHWWDPHQWH L GLULWWL LPSHULDOL LQ ,WDOLD D FDXVD GHOOD ORUR XWLOLWj1µ9 ²²²²²²²² 6
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j GL &RPDFFKLR/ 4:45,1 7 $ QXOOD SRVVRQR YDOHUH ULPRVWUDQ]H GL VGHJQR QHL FRQIURQWL GL TXHVWD SURFHGXUD/ FRPH HPHUJH S1 HV1 LQ /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH/ 4<<;/ SDJ1 <6/ FKH VXOO*LQYHVWLWXUD GL 5LQDOGR , +49<7, FRVu VL HVSULPH= ´+111, DOO*,PSHUR +D FXL SDUH DYHVVH GRYXWR FKLHGHUH/ FRPH VL q GHWWR JLj SRF*DQ]L/ O*LQYHVWLWXUD GHL VXRL VWDWL H D FXL VDUj VHPSUH VHQWLPHQWDOPHQWH OHJDWR, +111,µ 8 &IU1 :1 %5$81('(5/ ,PSHUR H 6WDWR D VXG GHOOH $OSL QHO ;9,,, VHFROR/ LQ $QQDOL GHOO*,VWLWXWR VWRULFR LWDOR0JHUPDQLFR/ TXDGHUQR 4:/ %RORJQD 4<;8/ SS1 980991 9 ,ELGHP1
4487
+XEHUW *DVVHU
1HO FRUVR GHL VHFF1 ;9 H ;9, O·,WDOLD ´LPSHULDOHµ +VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH O·,WDOLD D QRUG GHOOR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD/ DG HFFH]LRQH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD GL 9HQH]LD, JUDYLWDYD QHOO·RUELWD GHOOD OLQHD VSDJQROD GHJOL $VEXUJR1 &RQ O·HVWLQ]LRQH GL TXHVWD OLQHD QRQ VL DSUH VROWDQWR LO FRQWHQ]LRVR SHU OD VXFFHVVLRQH LQ 6SDJQD +JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH,/ PD DQFKH OD TXHVWLRQH VXOOD VXFFHVVLRQH QHL GLULWWL LPSHULDOL LQ ,WDOLD1 1HO FRUVR GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD q O·LPSHUDWRUH *LXVHSSH ,/ VDOLWR DO WURQR QHO 4:38/ D GDUH PDJJLRU SHVR DJOL LQWHUHVVL LQ ,WDOLD H D SRUVL O·RELHWWLYR GL VXEHQWUDUH DO SUHFHGHQWH SUHGRPLQLR VSDJQROR H GL HVHUFLWDUH LQ SURSULR L GLULWWL LPSHULDOL ILQRUD VYROWL GDOOD FRURQD VSDJQROD1: ,O VXFFHVVR GL TXHVWR GLVHJQR VL LQVHULVFH LQ TXHOO·DYDQ]DPHQWR GHOOR VWDWR DXVWULDFR VXOOD VFHQD HXURSHD FKH/ GRSR LO FRLQYROJLPHQWR LQ XQD VHULH GL JXHUUH QHO FRUVR GHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR +VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD/ VXF0 FHVVLRQH SRODFFD/ VXFFHVVLRQH DXVWULDFD/ YDULH FDPSDJQH FRQWUR L 7XUFKL H LQILQH OD JURVVD VILGD FRQ OD 3UXVVLD,/ OR YHGH DOOD ILQH LQVHULWR LQ PRGR VWDELOH QHOOD FHUFKLD GHOOH JUDQGL SRWHQ]H HXURSHH1 (· TXHVWD VWHVVD HVSDQVLRQH GL SRWHQ]D FKH JDUDQWLVFH OD FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHL GLULWWL LPSHULDOL LQ ,WDOLD/ SURSULR SHUFKp HUD LQ JUDGR GL VRVWHQHUOL DOO·RFFRUUHQ]D DQFKH FRQ OD IRU]D GHOOH DU0 PL1; 1HO FRQWHPSR LO SHVR GHJOL $VEXUJR LQ ,WDOLD YLHQH LUUREXVWLWR GD OHJDPL GLQDVWLFL FKH VL YHQJRQR DG LQVWDXUDUH FRQ YDUL FDVDWL LWDOLDQL +0DQWRYD/ 7R0 VFDQD/ DOOD ILQH OR VWHVVR GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD,1 ,Q TXHVWR PRGR L GLULWWL LPSHULD0 OL FRPH WDOL/ EHQFKp VHPSUH SUHVHQWL QHJOL DWWL IRUPDOL H QHOOH LVWDQ]H GDYDQWL DO FRQVLJOLR DXOLFR/ YHQJRQR D FROORFDUVL LQ VHFRQGR SLDQR ULVSHWWR DOO·HIIHWWLYD FDSDFLWj GL LQWHUYHQWR GHOOD GLQDVWLD DXVWULDFD1 6HFRQGR LO %UDX0 QHGHU ´SRWHUH GLQDVWLFR H LGHD GHOO·LPSHUR VL IXVHUR LQ VLPELRVL +111,/ O·HIIHWWLYR SRWHUH LPSHULDOH LQ ,WDOLD FRQVLVWHYD TXLQGL LQ XQD PHVFRODQ]D GL GLULWWR LPSHULDOH H SRWHUH GLQDVWLFR> OD UDJLRQH GL FLz QRQ VWDYD SHUz WDQWR QHO SRWHQ]LDPHQWR GHL GLULWWL LPSHULDOL SHU VH VWHVVL/ TXDQWR QHO FRQVROLGDPHQWR ²²²²²²²² :
&IU1 /1 $8(5/ =XU 5ROOH ,WDOLHQV LQ GHU |VWHUUHLFKLVFKHQ 3ROLWLN XP GDV VSDQLVFKH (UEH/ LQ ©0LWWHL0 OXQJHQ GHV gVWHUUHLFKLVFKHQ 6WDDWVDUFKLYVª/ 64/ 4<:;/ SS1 9809;1 91 DQFKH (1 =g//1(5/ *H0 VFKLFKWH gVWHUUHLFKV/ :LHQ00•QFKHQ 4<<3/ TXDQGR RVVHUYD FKH ´L GLULWWL LPSHULDOL YHQLYDQR VRW0 WROLQHDWL SL• GL TXDQWR OR IRVVHUR QHO PH]]R VHFROR GRSR OD JXHUUD GHL 7UHQW*$QQLµ +S1 593, H FKH D FRQFOXVLRQH GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD ´WUD L WHUULWRUL JXDGDJQDWL TXHOOL LWDOLD0 QL DYHYDQR LO PDJJLRU YDORUHµ +SDJ1 597,1 ; ´$ 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D LO SULQFLSH (XJHQLR UDFFROVH OH LPSRVWH LPSHULDOL XJXDOPHQWH FRQ O*DLXWR GHOOD IRU]D PLOLWDUHµ RVVHUYD LO %UDXQHGHU +:1 %5$81('(5/ ,PSHUR H 6WDWR 111 FLW1/ S1 :3,1 ,OOXPLQDQWH D TXHVWR SURSRVLWR q DQFKH O*LQVHGLDPHQWR GL XQ DPPLQLVWUDWRUH DXVWULDFR D 0RGHQD QHJOL DQQL 4:7504:7;1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,PSHUR
4488
GHO PRGHUQR 6WDWR GHO SULQFLSH1µ< 7RUQDQGR DOOH YLFHQGH PRGHQHVL QHO 6HWWHFHQWR/ QRWLDPR FKH GXUDQWH OD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD +4:3304:47, LO GXFDWR YLHQH RFFXSDWR GD WUXSSH IUDQFHVL H LO GXFD 5LQDOGR/ FKH DYHYD GLFKLDUDWR OD VXD QHXWUDOLWj/ VL YHGH FRVWUHWWR D FHUFDUH ULIXJLR D %RORJQD> OD VWHVVD FRVD VL ULSHWH GXUDQWH JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH SRODFFD +4:6604:68,1 ,QWDQWR LO ILJOLR GHO GXFD/ )UDQFH0 VFR/ VL HUD VSRVDWR QHO 4:53 FRQ &DUORWWD $JODH G·2UOHDQV H VL ULDOODFFLDQR FR0 Vu SL• VWUHWWL UDSSRUWL FRQ OD )UDQFLD1 )UDQFHVFR/ GXUDQWH OD JXHUUD GL VXFFHV0 VLRQH SRODFFD/ ULSDUD LQVLHPH DOOD PRJOLH D *HQRYD H SURVHJXH SRL SHU 3DULJL H /RQGUD H DSSURGD LQILQH D 9LHQQD GRYH RIIUH L VXRL VHUYL]L DOO·LPSHUDWRUH QHOOD JXHUUD FRQWUR L 7XUFKL1 /·LPSHUDWRUH OR QRPLQD JHQHUDOH G·DUWLJOLHULD1 'RSR OD PRUWH GL 5LQDOGR +4:6:, )UDQFHVFR ULHQWUD D 0RGHQD SHU SUHQGHUH OH UHGLQL GHO GXFDWR FRPH )UDQFHVFR ,,,1 /H QR]]H GHO ILJOLR GL )UDQFHVFR/ (UFROH/ FRQ 0DULD 7HUHVD &\ER 0DODVSLQD +4:74,/ DOOD SUHVHQ]D GL 0DULD 7H0 UHVD G·$XVWULD +DOORUD JUDQGXFKHVVD GL 7RVFDQD, DVVLHPH D )UDQFHVFR GXFD GL /RUHQD/ FUHDQR XQ RFFDVLRQH SHU UDYYLYDUH L UDSSRUWL FRQ JOL $VEXUJR1 0D OD QXRYD JXHUUD +GL VXFFHVVLRQH DXVWULDFD/ 4:7304:7;> QHO 4:75 LO FRQ0 IOLWWR VL HVWHQGH DQFKH DOO·,WDOLD, ODVFLD SRFR VSD]LR DL IHVWHJJLDPHQWL/ DQ]L/ FRQWULEXLVFH D JXDVWDUH L UDSSRUWL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL GHO GXFDWR1 ,QIDWWL/ )UDQFH0 VFR/ PLUDQGR DG XQ DFFRUGR FRQ OD 6SDJQD/ VL ULIXJLD D 3DGRYD1 ,O GXFDWR YLHQH RFFXSDWR GD IRU]H DXVWUR0SLHPRQWHVL/ O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH PRGHQHVH SDVVD VRWWR LO GLUHWWR FRQWUROOR GL XQ ´DPPLQLVWUDWRUH JHQHUDOHµ DXVWULDFR1 )UDQFHVFR VL PHWWH DO VHUYL]LR GHJOL VSDJQROL +GLYHQWD FDSLWDQR JHQHUDOH GHOO·HVHUFLWR LQ /RPEDUGLD,/ FHUFD SHUz DQFKH XQ DFFRUGR FRQ L IUDQFHVL1 4XHVWR GRSSLR JLXRFR QRQ VROR QRQ JOL IUXWWD QXOOD/ PD GDQQHJJLD QRWHYRO0 PHQWH OD VXD SRVL]LRQH VXOOD VFHQD LQWHUQD]LRQDOH= QRQ JRGH SL• VLPSDWLH GD SDUWH GL QHVVXQD GHOOH SRWHQ]H HXURSHH1 $OOD ILQH GHOOD JXHUUD +FKH WHUPLQD FRQ OD UHVWLWX]LRQH UHFLSURFD GL WXWWH OH FRQTXLVWH, HJOL ULHQWUD FRPXQTXH LQ SRVVHVVR GHO GXFDWR143 3RFR GRSR/ FRQ OD PRUWH GHO VHFRQGR ILJOLR GL )UDQFHVFR/ %HQHGHWWR/ VL SDYHQWD LQYHFH XQ DOWUR SHULFROR= OD FDVD HVWHQVH ULVFKLD GL ULPDQHUH VHQ]D H0 UHGH PDVFKLOH> LO SULPRJHQLWR GL )UDQFHVFR/ (UFROH/ DYHYD XQD VROD ILJOLD D FXL ²²²²²²²² <
:1 %5$81('(5/ ,PSHUR H 6WDWR 111 FLW1/ S1 :41 )UDQFHVFR ,,, ULHQWUD D 0RGHQD ´VHQ]D DYHU SRWXWR HYLWDUH Qp O*RFFXSD]LRQH VWUDQLHUD Qp O*HVLOLR> H LO UDQFRUH GHOO*$XVWULD/ OD PDOHYROHQ]D GL 6SDJQD/ OD VWDQFKH]]D GL )UDQFLD QHO VRFFRUUHUOR HUDQR L IUXWWL FKH DYHYD UDFFROWL FRO VXR WHQWDWLYR GL XQD SROLWLFD QRQ SDVVLYDµ1 /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH 111 FLW1/ S1 4391 43
4489
+XEHUW *DVVHU
VDUHEEH DQGDWR LO GXFDWR GL 0DVVD/ PD QRQ TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD SHU LO TXDOH YL0 JH OD OHJJH GL VXFFHVVLRQH VDOLFD1 &RQ L EXRQL XIILFL GHO UH G·,QJKLOWHUUD VL JLXQJH QHO 4:86 DG XQ DFFRUGR WUD OD FDVD (VWHQVH H JOL $VEXUJR SHU FXL/ FRQ O·LQJUHVVR GL XQ HVSRQHQWH DVEXUJLFR QHOOD IDPLJOLD PRGHQHVH/ VL FUHD XQD QXRYD OLQHD GLQDVWLFD +GHJOL $XVWUR0(VWHQVL, FKH SHUPHWWH OD SHUPDQHQ]D GH0 JOL (VWHQVL QHO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 /·DFFRUGR SUHYHGH LO PDWULPRQLR GL 0DULD %HDWULFH 5LFFLDUGD +QDWD QHO 4:83,/ ILJOLD GL (UFROH +SULPRJHQLWR GL )UDQFHVFR ,,,,/ H /HRSROGR/ VHFRQGRJHQLWR GHOO·LPSHUDWULFH 0DULD 7HUHVD1 ,O PDWULPR0 QLR YHQQH FHOHEUDWR QHO 4::3/ SHUz QRQ FRQ /HRSROGR G·$XVWULD FKH LQWDQWR HUD GLYHQWDWR JUDQGXFD GL 7RVFDQD/ PD FRQ VXR IUDWHOOR/ )UDQFHVFR1 'D TXH0 VWR PDWULPRQLR QDVFH )UDQFHVFR FKH/ GRSR LO GXFD (UFROH ,,, +4:;304:<:, H GRSR OH YLFLVVLWXGLQL GHO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR/ UHJJHUj OH VRUWL GHO GXFDWR FRO QRPH GL )UDQFHVFR ,9 GDO 4;47 DO 4;791 /·DFFRUGR GHO 4:86 FRQWLHQH FRPXQTXH DOFXQH FODXVROH FKH SRVVLDPR LQ0 WHUSUHWDUH FRPH FRQWURSDUWLWD GD SDUWH GHJOL $VEXUJR H FRPH JDUDQ]LD SHU OD FRQWLQXLWj GHO GXFDWR PRGHQHVH= LQQDQ]LWXWWR LO GXFDWR GHYH ULPDQHUH XQ·HQWLWj VHSDUDWD GDOO·$XVWULD H 0RGHQD GHYH ULPDQHUH OD VXD FDSLWDOH> OR VSRVR GRYUj DVVXPHUH LO FRJQRPH HVWHQVH H ILVVDUH OD VXD UHVLGHQ]D QHO GXFD0 WR> H TXDORUD OR VSRVR YHQLVVH FKLDPDWR VXO WURQR DXVWULDFR GRYHYD ULQXQFLD0 UH D IDYRUH GHO ILJOLR R/ LQ PDQFDQ]D GL ILJOL/ D IDYRUH GL XQ TXDOVLDVL PHPEUR GHOOD IDPLJOLD LPSHULDOH/ SXUFKp QRQ UHJQDQWH LQ $XVWULD> LQILQH GRYHYD HVVH0 UH DIILGDWR DO GXFD )UDQFHVFR LO FRPDQGR GHOOH WUXSSH LPSHULDOL H LO JRYHUQR LQ /RPEDUGLD144 /D FRQFOXVLRQH GL TXHVWR DFFRUGR ULDFFHQGH LQ FDVD G·(VWH XQD YHFFKLD VSHUDQ]D= LO UHFXSHUR GL &RPDFFKLR1 /H GRWWH GLVTXLVL]LRQL GHO 0XUDWRUL H GL /HLEQLW] QRQ HUDQR YDOVH D FRQYLQFHUH OD &DPHUD $SRVWROLFD FKH &RPDFFKLR IRVVH XQ IHXGR LPSHULDOH1 *OL VWHVVL $VEXUJR/ GRSR DYHU RFFXSDWR &RPDF0 FKLR QHO 4:3;/ QRQ DYHYDQR LQVLVWLWR SHU IDU YDOHUH L SURSUL GLULWWL1 3RVVLDPR DUJXLUH FKH FLz VLD DYYHQXWR SHU QRQ WXUEDUH L IUDJLOL HTXLOLEUL HVLVWHQWL LQ ,WD0 OLD WUD 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD/ )UDQFLD H $XVWULD145 2UD/ FRQ O·DYYLFLQDUVL GHO PD0 WULPRQLR (VWH0$VEXUJR/ OD GLSORPD]LD HVWHQVH ID XQ XOWLPR WHQWDWLYR QHO 4:9< LQYLDQGR D 9LHQQD LO FRQWH $OIRQVR 3RJJL LQ TXDOLWj GL LQYLDWR VWUDRUGL0 QDULR146 3HUz DQFKH TXHVWD YROWD OH VSHUDQ]H HVWHQVL YHQJRQR GHOXVH1 0ROWR ²²²²²²²² 44
,ELG1/ SS1 43<04431 &IU1 /1 $8(5/ =XU 5ROOH ,WDOLHQV 111/ FLW1/ S1 851 91 DQFKH /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR (VWHQVH/ LQ 6WRULD G*,WDOLD/ ;9,,/ 7RULQR 4<:</ SS1 44404461 46 &IU1 OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD FRQVHUYDWD QHOO*$5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ 45
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,PSHUR
448:
LOOXPLQDQWH 0 LOOXPLQDQWH VLD SHU JOL HTXLOLEUL HVLVWHQWL LQ ,WDOLD VLD SHU LO SHVR FKH XQ GXFDWR FRPH TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD SRWHYD DYHUH LQ TXHVWR FRQWHVWR 0 PL SDUH D WDOH SURSRVLWR XQ·DQQRWD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD VX XQ IDVFLFROR GHO IRQGR HVWHQVH=47 /HWWHUD GHO VLJ1 0DVL H PROWH DOWUH GHO VLJ1 FRQWH 3RJJL LQYLDWR DOOD FRUWH GL 9LHQQD/ VFULWWH DO VLJ1 PDUFKHVH %DJQHVL/ DOOH TXDOL VRQR XQLWH GLYHUVH PLQXWH GL ULVSRVWD H WXWWH ULJXDUGDQWL O·DIIDUH GL &RPDFFKLR/ OL GLVFRUVL FLRq WHQXWL SULPD FROOL PLQLVWUL LPSHULDOL H JOL DOWUL FRQ VXD 01VWj O·,PSHUDWRUH LQ GLYHUVH XGLHQ]H DYXWH> WHUPLQz LO WUDWWDWR SHUFKp O·,PSHUDWRUH YROHYD FKH OH FRUWL GL 6SDJQD H )UDQFLD PRVWUDVVHUR LPSHJQR SUHVVR OD 01VWj 6XD/ H OH DOWUH GXH SRWHQ]H QH YROHYDQR VHQWLUH XQ WRFFR GDOO·,PSHUDWRUH/ H FRVu Qp O·XQR Qp JOL DOWUL SDUODURQR/ H O·DIIDUH VL SRVH LQ VLOHQ]LR1 3HU FRQFOXGHUH ULWHQJR GRYHURVR DFFHQQDUH DL IRQGL DUFKLYLVWLFL DXVWULDFL UHODWLYL DO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ SUHFLVDPHQWH FLz FKH VL WURYD D 9LHQQD QHOOR +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY1 7UD JOL ´$WWL GL IDPLJOLDµ WURYLDPR QHOO·´$UFKLYLR GL IDPLJOLD GHJOL $VEXUJR0/RUHQDµ GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GHJOL DQQL 4::304:;3 UHODWLYD DO PDWULPRQLR WUD O·DUFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR H 0DULD %HDWULFH GL 0RGHQD1 9L VL WURYD LQROWUH XQ IDVFLFROR LQWLWRODWR ´9RUWUlJH •EHU GLH +HL0 UDW XQG GHQ (UEYHUWUDJ PLW 0RGHQD 4:85086µ +PHPRULH VXO PDWULPRQLR H VXO FRQWUDWWR GL VXFFHVVLRQH FRQ 0RGHQD,148 1HOOD VH]LRQH ´,WDOLHQ06SDQLVFKHU 5DWµ VRQR ULSRUWDWL VRWWR OD YRFH ´0R0 GHQDµ JOL DWWL UHODWLYL DOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH DXVWULDFD QHJOL DQQL 4:7504:7< H 4:<<04;33149 6L WUDWWD GL GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GL QDWXUD DPPLQLVWUDWLYD1 3L• GLIIL0 FLOH VL SUHVHQWD OD VLWXD]LRQH UHODWLYD DJOL DWWL GL SROLWLFD HVWHUD/ OD FRUULVSRQ0 GHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD14: *UDQ SDUWH GL TXHVWL IRQGL YHQQH SRUWDWD YLD GDOOH WUXS0 SH QDSROHRQLFKH TXDQGR QHO 4;3< HQWUDURQR D 9LHQQD= 474 FDVVH FRQ DWWL UL0 JXDUGDQWL O·,WDOLD H OH 3URYLQFH LOOLULFKH YHQQHUR SRUWDWH D 3DULJL/ 0LODQR H /XEOLDQD1 1HOO·DUFKLYLR PLODQHVH GL 61 )HGHOH ILQLURQR TXHOOL UHODWLYL DOOD /RPEDUGLD/ D 0RGHQD/ DOOR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD H D 9HQH]LD1 6ROR XQD SLFFROD ²²²²²²²² &DQFHOOHULD GXFDOH HVWHQVH/ &RQWURYHUVLH GL 6WDWR/ E1 691 47 ,ELG1/ E1 69 +VHFRQGR OD YHFFKLD VHJQDWXUD= FDVVD ;,/ ILO]D 1/ Q1 9,1 48 &IU1 OD YRFH ´)DPLOLHQDNWHQ/ GDV KDEVEXUJLVFK0ORWKULQJLVFKH )DPLOLHQDUFKLYµ LQ *HVDPWLQYHQWDU GHV :LHQHU +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ 41 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<69/ S1 4<1 49 /D VHULH/ PXQLWD GL VFKHGDULR/ VL DUWLFROD FRPH VHJXH= ,1 .RUUHVSRQGHQ] GHV *HQHUDODGPLQL0 VWUDWRUV 4:74 ELV 4:86 )]1 408> GHV 6WDWWKDOWHUV 4:7504:7< 9/:> ,,1 &ROOHFWDQHD= $XIVWDQG/ 3ROL]HL/ -X0 VWL]/ .LUFKH/ 0LOLWlU/ 9HUZDOWXQJ/ +DQGHO X1D1 4:75 ELV 4:7< )]1 ;> )LQDQ]ZHVHQ 4:6904:7;/ <> ,,,1 1DFKWUDJ= gVWHUUHLFKLVFKH $GPLQLVWUDWLRQ 4:<<04;33 )] 43/ 441 &IU1 *HVDPWLQYHQWDU GHV :LHQHU +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ 71 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<6;/ SDJ1 :81 4: &IU1 *HVDPWLQYHQWDU GHV :LHQHU +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ 41 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<69/ S1 8761
448;
+XEHUW *DVVHU
SDUWH YHQLYD ULSRUWDWD QHJOL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL D 9LHQQD14; 4XHVWL HYHQWL KDQQR SURYRFDWR LUULPHGLDELOL SHUGLWH HG KDQQR ODFHUDWR LO SUHHVLVWHQWH RUGLQH DU0 FKLYLVWLFR1 6ROR QHJOL DQQL 4;;:04;<3 FL IX XQ SDU]LDOH ULRUGLQDPHQWR GL TXH0 VWL IRQGL/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH TXHOOL ULJXDUGDQWL OD /RPEDUGLD H 0RGHQD/ DG RSHUD GL /RGRYLFR 2EHU]LQHU/4< RULJLQDULR GL 7UHQWR/ FKH LQ TXHJOL DQQL SUHVWDYD VHUYL]LR QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 9LHQQD1
²²²²²²²² 4;
*HVDPWLQYHQWDU GHV :LHQHU +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ 71 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<6;/ SDJJ1 8:08;1 2EHU]LQHU/ QRQ ULXVFHQGR DG RWWHQHUH XQ LPSLHJR DGHJXDWR D 9LHQQD/ VL UHFz VXFFHVVL0 YDPHQWH LQ ,WDOLD HG LQVHJQz QHOOH VFXROH PHGLH GL YDULH FLWWj/ WUD FXL DQFKH 0RGHQD +4;<90 4;<:,1 1HO 4;<: WRUQz D 7UHQWR GRYH GLYHQWz GLUHWWRUH GHOOD ELEOLRWHFD FLYLFD H GHO PXVHR1 &IU1 *HVDPWLQYHQWDU GHV :LHQHU +DXV0/ +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ 41 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<69/ SDJJ1 <;0<<1 4<
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
448<
/8,*, /21'(, 0 0$5,1$ 025(1$
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH-
41 /D FRQFRUGLD GL )DHQ]D1 $VSHWWL SROLWLFL H SDWULPRQLDOL /D YLFHQGD GHL UDSSRUWL WUD 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD VHGH SUHQGH QHFHVVDULD0 PHQWH OH PRVVH GDOO·DWWR VWHVVR GL FRVWLWX]LRQH GHO GXFDWR PRGHQHVH H FLRq OD FRQFRUGLD GL )DHQ]D GHO 46 JHQQDLR 48<;4 IUD LO SRQWHILFH &OHPHQWH 9,,, H LO ²²²²²²²² - 6RQR GL 01 025(1$ L SDUDJUDIL 4 H 5> GL /1 /21'(, L SDUDJUDIL 6 H 71 4&IU1 $1 *$63$5,1,/ &HVDUH G·(VWH H &OHPHQWH 9,,,/ 0RGHQD/ 67(0/ 4<93/ SS1 54805591 4XHVWR YROXPH FRQWLHQH/ QHOO·DSSHQGLFH GRFXPHQWDULD/ OD ©&DSLWROD]LRQH GL )DHQ]Dª VWLSXOD0 WD LQ GDWD 46 JHQQDLR 48<; IUD LO SRQWHILFH &OHPHQWH 9,,, H &HVDUH G·(VWH1 ,O SUREOHPD GHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH q XQ DUJRPHQWR FXL VRQR GHGLFDWL QXPHURVL VWXGL1 6L YHGDQR D WDO SURSRVLWR= /1 %$/'8==,/ /· LVWURPHQWR ILQDOH GHOOD WUDQVD]LRQH GL )DHQ]D SHO SDVVDJJLR GDJOL (VWHQVL DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH +46 JHQQDLR 48<;,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD U1 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH SURYLQFH GL 5RPDJQDª/ V1 ,,,/ ,;+4;<4,> *1 3$5',/ 6XOOH FDXVH GHOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD GHSXWD]LRQH IHUUDUHVH GL 6WRULD SDWULDª/ ;;,9/ 4<55> (1 &$//(*$5,/ /D GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH/ LQ ©5LYLVWD VWRULFD LWDOLD0 QDª/ 4;<8/ IDVF14> 91 35,1=,9$//,/ /D GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH VHFRQGR XQD UHOD]LRQH LQHGLWD GL &DPLOOR &DSLOXSL/ LQ ©$WWL GHOOD 'HSXWD]LRQH IHUUDUHVH GL VWRULD SDWULDª/ 4;<;/ Y1 ;> *1 %$//$5',1,/ /D FRQYHQ]LRQH IDHQWLQD GHO 48<:/ LQ ©$UFKLYLR VWRULFR LWDOLDQRª/ 4<39/ ,,> /1 3$6725/ 6WRULD GHL SDSL/ 4<5</ YRO1 ;,/ FDS1 ;,1 5LWHQLDPR LQROWUH RSSRUWXQR VHJQDODUH DOFXQH IRQWL DUFKLYLVWLFKH FKH PHULWHUHEEHUR GL HVVHUH DSSURIRQGLWH= $UFKLYLR VHJUHWR YDWLFDQR/ $1 $1/ $UP1 ,0;9,,,/ Q1 7;8;/ %0LQXWH LQ SDUWH RULJLQDOL GL EROOH H EUHYL GL &OHPHQWH 9,,, SHU OD GHYROX]LRQH GHO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD H SHU OD UDWLILFD GHOOD FRQFRUGLD IDHQWLQD%> LELGHP/ 6HJU1 6WD0 WR/ 0LVF1/ $UP1,/ Q1 539/ &DXVD IUD &HVDUH G·(VWH / GXFD GL 0RGHQD H OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD +DQ14946,> ,ELGHP/ )RQGR 3LR/ OHJD]LRQH GL )HUUDUD/ VHJQ1 75 II15 0 ;< +DQ1 48<;, = 5HOD]LRQH GHOO·,PSUHVD GL )HU0 UDUD> LELGHP/ VHJQ1 5;8 II1 69606:6= &URQDFD GL )HUUDUD GDOOD VXD GHYROX]LRQH DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH ILQR DO 49661 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 520$ +G·RUD LQ DYDQWL $65RPD,/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 4396/ %/HWWHUH GHO FDUGLQDO $OGREUDQGLQL DO FDUG1 &HVL SHO DFTXLVWR GL )HUUDUD +48<:0<;,1% /R VWHVVR
4493
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
GXFD &HVDUH G·(VWH= LQ YLUW• GL HVVD DOOD 6DQWD VHGH HUD GHYROXWD )HUUDUD FRQ LO WHUULWRULR GHOO·H[ GXFDWR/ FRPSUHQGHQWH/ IUD O·DOWUR/ &RPDFFKLR H OH VXH YDOOL/ QRQFKp OD 5RPDJQD HVWHQVH +/XJR/ %DJQDFDYDOOR/ &RWLJQROD/ 0DVVDORPEDU0 GD/ 6DQW·$JDWD H &RQVHOLFH,/ &HQWR H 3LHYH GL &HQWR51 $O GXFD &HVDUH G·(VWH/ DVVROWR GD WXWWH OH FHQVXUH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH6/ YHQLYD GDOOD 6DQWD VHGH JDUDQWLWR LO ²²²²²²²² GLFDVL SHU L GRFXPHQWL LQGLFDWL QHOOH QRWH 7 H 81 5 &IU1 *1 %1 '( /8&$/ &RPPHQWDULD DG FRQVWLWXWLRQHP 661 '1 11 '1 ,QQRFHQWLL ;, GH 6WDWXWDULLV VXFFHVVLRQLEXV/ 5RPD/ %X]]RWWR *1/ 49;71 $ SURSRVLWR GHOOD /HJD]LRQH GL )HUUDUD LO 'H /XFD VFULYH= ©4XHVWD LOOXVWUH FLWWj FRQ L VXRL DQQHVVL FRVWLWXLVFH XQR VWDWR FKH SHU SDUHFFKL VHFROL HEEH TXHOOD QDWXUD GL PHGLDWR/ GL FXL VL q IDWWD PHQ]LRQH VRSUD DO Q14/ SRLFKp IX SRVVHGXWR LQ IHXGR R YLFDULDWR/ FRQ OH UHJDOuH HG LO GLULWWR GL SULQFLSDWR/ GDOOD LOOXVWUH IDPLJOLD GHJOL DWHVLQL R HVWHQVL/ FRQ GLJQLWj SULPD PDU0 FKLRQDOH H SRL/ SHU FRQFHVVLRQH GL 3DROR ,,/ GXFDOH1 6XFFHVVLYDPHQWH YHQQH GHYROXWR H UHVWLWXLWR DO VXR DQWLFR FRUSR/ ULHQWUDQGR FRVu D IDU SDUWH GHOOR VWDWR LPPHGLDWR/ SHU OD PRUWH VHQ]D SUROH GHO GXFD $O0 IRQVR ,,/ DO WHPSR GL &OHPHQWH 9,,, H SHU OD FRQFRUGLD FRQ LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR/ &HVDUH G·(VWH/ VRWWRVFULWWD LQ )DHQ]D +H SHUFLz GHQRPLQDWD YROJDUPHQWH FRQFRUGLD IDHQWLQD, H SL• YROWH FLWDWD QHO 7HD0 WUR1 ,Q TXHVWD RFFDVLRQH/ &OHPHQWH 9,,, FRQFHVVH PROWL SULYLOHJL DOOD FLWWj/ FKH q JRYHUQDWD GD XQ FDUGL0 QDOH OHJDWR ² LO TXDOH ILJXUD FRPH O·DQWLFR GXFD ² H FKH PDQWLHQH L SURSUL VWDWXWL/ IUD FXL YL q TXHOOR FKH HVFOXGH OH IHPPLQH1 )DFHYD XQD YROWD SDUWH GHO GLVWUHWWR GL )HUUDUD O·LPSRUWDQWH SDHVH GL &DUSL/ VXFFHV0 VLYDPHQWH GLVPHPEUDWR/ SHU FXL RJJL VL GLEDWWH VH VL GHEEDQR DQFRUD RVVHUYDUH JOL VWDWXWL GL )HUUDUD1 1HOO·DWWXDOH VWDWR H OHJD]LRQH GL )HUUDUD/ VHQ]D HQWUDUH QHOOD TXHVWLRQH GL TXDOL VLDQR GHO GLVWUHWWR GHOOD GRPLQDQWH H DG HVVD VRJJHWWH/ IDQQR SDUWH L VHJXHQWL OXRJKL QRWHYROL/ WUDODVFLDWL OH SLFFROH YLOOH H ERUJKL= $UJHQWD/ $ULDQR/ %DJQDFDYDOOR/ &HQWR/ &RGLJRUR/ &RPDFFKLR/ &RWLJQROD/ &UHVSLQR/ )RVVLJQDQR/ /XJR/ 0DVVD /RPEDUGD/ 0HODULD/ 3LHYH GL &HQWR/ 7UHFHQWD1ª 6 &RQ OD PRUWH GL $OIRQVR ,, G·(VWH/ DYYHQXWD QHO 48<:/ LQ PDQFDQ]D GL ILJOL/ O·HUHGH GH0 VLJQDWR GDOOR VWHVVR GXFD DOOD VXFFHVVLRQH IX VXR FXJLQR &HVDUH G·(VWH1 4XHVWL VL DIIUHWWz D LQYLDUH LO IUDWHOOR $OHVVDQGUR D )HUUDUD D SUHQGHUH SRVVHVVR LQ VXR QRPH GL 0RGHQD H 5HJ0 JLR1 (JOL/ GRSR DYHU ULFHYXWR OD EHQHGL]LRQH QHO GXRPR GL )HUUDUD GDO YHVFRYR/ ULFHYHWWH DQ0 FKH LO JLXUDPHQWR GL IHGHOWj GD SDUWH GHL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOD FLWWDGLQDQ]D1 &HVDUH VL DIIUHWWz D LQYLDUH D TXDVL WXWWH OH FRUWL G·(XURSD OD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH GHOOD VXD QXRYD LQYHVWLWXUD1 ,QWDQWR D 5RPD JLXQJHYDQR FKLDUDPHQWH JOL HFKL GL FLz FKH DYYHQLYD D 0RGHQD1 ,O SRQWHILFH &OH0 PHQWH 9,,, VHJXHQGR L SULQFLSL JLj DGRWWDWL GD DOFXQL VXRL SUHGHFHVVRUL/ TXDOL DG HVHPSLR *LXOLR ,,/ H FRQVLVWHQWL QHO UHFXSHUDUH DOOD YDFDQ]D JOL DQWLFKL VWDWL LQIHXGDWL GDOOD &KLHVD/ UL0 WHQHQGR TXLQGL FKH &HVDUH QRQ DYHVVH JLXVWR WLWROR GL VXFFHGHUH D TXHOOR GL )HUUDUD/ VL DFFLQ0 VH DG HVSHOOHUOR GDO GXFDWR1 1RQRVWDQWH JLXQJHVVH XQ DPEDVFLDWRUH GD )HUUDUD SHU VXSSOLFDUH LO SDSD D ULFRQRVFHUH &HVDUH TXDOH VXFFHVVRUH GL $OIRQVR ,,/ OD UHSOLFD GL &OHPHQWH 9,,, IX VRVWDQ]LDOPHQWH PROWR GXUD LQ TXDQWR HJOL LQWLPz FKH GRQ &HVDUH ODVFLDVVH LPPHGLDWDPHQWH OR 6WDWR/ DOWULPHQWL VDUHEEH VWDWR WUDWWDWR GD XVXUSDWRUH/ SXQLWR FROOH FHQVXUH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH H FDFFLDWR FRQ OD IRU]D1 ,O SDSD/ QRQRVWDQWH YDUL WHQWDWLYL GLSORPDWLFL/ GLFKLDUz GHYROXWR OR VWD0 WR GL )HUUDUD DOOD &KLHVD/ H LQWLPz D GRQ &HVDUH OD GLPLVVLRQH VRWWR SHQD GL VFRPXQLFD H LQ0 ILQH JOL DVVHJQz 48 JLRUQL SHU FRPSDULUH D 5RPD H SURGXUUH GL SHUVRQD OH VXH SUHWHVH1 &HVDUH DSSRJJLDWR DQFKH GDOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH GHOOD UHSXEEOLFD GL 9HQH]LD/ FKH FHUFDYD GL WHQHUH ORQWD0 QR GDO SURSULR FRQILQH XQR 6WDWR SL• WHPLELOH ULVSHWWR D TXHOOR HVWHQVH/ IHFH YDULH FRQWUR0
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
4494
SDFLILFR SRVVHVVR GHJOL VWDWL FKH HJOL ULWHQHYD LQ IHXGR GDOO·,PSHUR/ FLRq 0R0 GHQD/ 5HJJLR H 5XELHUD FKH/ GRSR OXQJKH FRQWURYHUVLH WUD OD 6DQWD VHGH H JOL (VWHQVL/ HUDQR VWDWL DVVLFXUDWL D TXHVWL XOWLPL/ GRSR XQ LQWHUYHQWR D ORUR IDYR0 UH GD SDUWH GL &DUOR 9/ FRQ XQ WUDWWDWR VWLSXODWR QHO 486< FRQ LO SDSD 3DROR ,,,1 &RQ OR VWHVVR WUDWWDWR/ HUD VWDWD ULQQRYDWD DO GXFD (UFROH O·LQYHVWLWXUD GL WXWWR LO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD GLHWUR XQ SDJDPHQWR XQD WDQWXP GL 4;3 PLOD GXFDWL/ H TXLQGL GL XQ FHQVR GL : PLOD GXFDWL DQQXL1 /D FRQFRUGLD IDHQWLQD DVVLFXUDYD D &HVDUH OD OLEHUD SURSULHWj H FRQVHJXHQ0 WHPHQWH LO GLULWWR GL DVSRUWDUH GD )HUUDUD WXWWL L EHQL PRELOL7 FKH HJOL SRVVH0 GHYD LQ TXHVWD FLWWj FRPSUHVR O·DUFKLYLR/ DG HFFH]LRQH GHOOH VFULWWXUH FRQFHU0 QHQWL LQWHUHVVL HFRQRPLFL GD WUDVIHULUH DOOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD/ H FRPSUHVH/ LQROWUH/ PHWj GHOOH DUWLJOLHULH H PXQL]LRQL SUHVHQWL QHOOD VWHVVD )HUUDUD1 $O GXFD &HVDUH HUDQR DOWUHVu ODVFLDWL L EHQL DOORGLDOL8 SUHVHQWL QHO GXFDWR/ FRVWLWXLWL VRSUDWWXWWR GD TXHOOL SHUYHQXWLJOL LQ YLUW• GHO WHVWDPHQWR GHO GXFD $OIRQVR/ ROWUH FKH GD EHQL SURSUL1 4XHVWL EHQL/ SHUz/ QRQ HUDQR VSHFLILFDWL GDOOD FRQYHQ]LRQH FKH/ DOO·DUW1 8/ VL OLPLWDYD DG HOHQFDUH HVSOLFLWDPHQWH VROR OH WHUUH/ SUDWL/ YDOOL H SRVVHVVLRQL/ FDVH/ RVWHULH H PXOLQL GL /XJR H %DJQDFDYDOOR/ PHQWUH/ SHU LO UHVWR/ FRQVLGHUDYD EHQL9DOORGLDOL TXHOOL FKH QRQ DYHYDQR DQQHV0 ²²²²²²²² SURSRVWH SULPD IUD OH TXDOL TXHOOD GL ULPHWWHUH OD FRQWURYHUVLD DO JLXGL]LR GL TXDOFKH VRYUDQR R GL TXDOFKH WULEXQDOH1 ,O SRQWHILFH QRQ DFFHWWz SHUz QHVVXQD GL TXHVWH SURSRVWH GL QHJR]LD0 ]LRQH H LQ EUHYH GHFLVH GL XVDUH OH IRU]D1 6XR QLSRWH LO FDUGLQDOH 3LHWUR $OGREUDQGLQR IX SR0 VWR D FDSR GHOO·HVHUFLWR H VL VWDELOu LQ )DHQ]D1 &HVDUH LQGHEROLWR GDOOD VFRPXQLFD FKH RYXQTXH VL SXEEOLFDYD/ FRQVLJOLDWR GD XQ SDGUH JHVXLWD VXR WHRORJR/ VL GHFLVH DG LQYLDUH D )DHQ]D OD GXFKHVVD G¶8UELQR /XFUH]LD/ VRUHOOD GL $OIRQVR ,,/ SHU FRQFHUWDUH FRQ LO FDUGLQDOH $OGREUDQ0 GLQR XQ DFFRUGR PHQR GDQQRVR SRVVLELOH FRQFOXVRVL SHUz QHOOD FDSLWROD]LRQH GL )DHQ]D1 ,Q JHQHUDOH SHU 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH GHOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH FIU1= /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH1 6WRULD GHL VXRL GXFKL GDO 48<; DO 4;93/ 0LODQR/ $1 0DUWHOOR +0DHVWUL $UWL *UDILFKH,/ 4<9:1 6XOOH YLFHQGH GHL GLYHUVL GLVFHQGHQWL GL TXHVWD GLQDVWLD VDUj XWLOH FRQVXOWDUH OH YRFL ORUR GHGLFDWH LQ= 'L]LR0 QDULR ELRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQL/ ,VWLWXWR GHOO·(QFLFORSHGLD LWDOLDQD/ 5RPD/ 4<<6/ SS1 5<7077:1 7 $ GRQ &HVDUH HUD GXQTXH SHUPHVVR GL IDUH XVFLUH GD )HUUDUD WXWWH OH JLRLH/ RUL/ DUJHQWL HG DOWUH FRVH SUH]LRVH/ ROWUHFKp L VDOL/ L JUDQL/ OH ELDGH/ OH IDULQH1 8 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 6(*5(72 9$7,&$12/ $1 $/ $UP1,0;9,,,/ E1 7;8;/ %6FULWWXUH SHU OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD QHOOD FDXVD )HUUDULHQVLV HW &RPDFFKLHQVLV >111@ FLRq FRQWUR OH SUHWHQVLRQL HFFLWDWH GDO GXFD GL 0RGHQD H VXL PLJOLRUDPHQWL IHXGDOL H VXOOH YDOOL GL &RPDFFKLR H VRSUD DOWUL EHQL SUHWHVL DOORGLDOL FRPH LO ERVFR GHOO·(OLVHD H DOFXQH FDVH LQ )HUUDUD> 1RWH GHOOH SUH0 WHQVLRQL GHO GXFD%1 9 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 4396/ %$IILWWR GHL EHQL GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD VXO IHUUDUH0 VH+4:8:08;,> ,ELGHP/ E1 4674/ %0LVFHOODQHD IUD FXL EHQL H OLYHOOL HFFOHVLDVWLFL QHO GXFDWR PRGH0 QHVH%1
4495
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
VD JLXULVGL]LRQH IHXGDOH/ LQROWUH ULPDQHYDQR LQ VXR SRVVHVVR= FDVH/ VWDOOH/ FDQ0 WLQH/ H JUDQDL SRVWL IXRUL GDO &DVWHOOR GL )HUUDUD H VXH IRVVH/ FRVu FRPH WXWWL L JLDUGLQL H RUWL HFFHWWR TXHOOL VXL WHUUDJOL GHOOD FLWWj JLj LQ VXR SRVVHVVR1 8QD FODXVROD VWDELOLYD FKH/ LQ FDVR/ GL DFTXLVWR GD SDUWH GHOOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD HJOL VDUHEEH VWDWR REEOLJDWR D YHQGHUH DG XQ JLXVWR SUH]]R1 &HVDUH LQROWUH RW0 WHQHYD GDOOD &DPHUD 481333 VDFFKL GL VDOH GL &HUYLD RJQL DQQR H LO OLEHUR WUDQVLWR SHU LO 3R H GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD VHQ]D SDJDPHQWR GL DOFXQ GD]LR1 2OWUH D FLz PDQWHQHYD LO JLXVSDWURQDWR VXOOH SUHSRVLWXUH GL 3RPSRVD H GHOOD 3LHYH GL %RQGHQR1 51 ,O FRQWHQ]LRVR FRQ OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD1 &RPDFFKLR 4XHVWR WUDWWDWR DSUu XQ OXQJR FRQWHQ]LRVR FRQ OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD DP0 SLDPHQWH GRFXPHQWDWR VLD LQ YDUL IRQGL GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 5RPD/ FKH LQ TXHOOL GHOO·$UFKLYLR VHJUHWR YDWLFDQR H FKH LPSURQWz O·LQWHUD WUDPD GHL UDSSRUWL IUD 0RGHQD H 5RPD SHU DOPHQR L GXH VHFROL VXFFHVVLYL1 $OOR VFRS0 SLR GHOOD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR:/ QHO 4973/ LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH; SURJHWWz/ ²²²²²²²² :: &IU1 01 &$5$9$/(0$1 &$5$&&,2/2 / /R 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR GD 0DUWLQR 9 D 3LR ,;/ 0LODQR/ 87(7/ 4<:;/ SS1 76:07731 ,O GXFDWR GL &DVWUR H 5RQFLJOLRQH UDSSUHVHQWDYD XQ· LPSRUWDQWH HQFODYH QHO WHUULWRULR GHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR FRQFHVVD DOOD IDPLJOLD GHL )DUQHVH GXUDQWH LO SRQWL0 ILFDWR GL 3DROR ,,, )DUQHVH +48670487<,1 /·DQQHVVLRQH GD SDUWH GHO SRQWHILFH GL TXHVWR GXFD0 WR IX XQ·RSHUD]LRQH VLFXUDPHQWH PROWR GLIILFLOH ROWUHFKp FRVWRVD1 6L WUDWWDYD SHUz GL XQD SURYLQFLD YLFLQD D 5RPD H PROWR LPSRUWDQWH SHU LO ULIRUQLPHQWR DQQRQDULR GHOOD VWHVVD/ WDOH TXLQGL GD ULFKLDPDUH O·DWWHQ]LRQH GL PROWL SRQWHILFL VXFFHVVRUL GL 3DROR ,,,1 2VWDFROR DOOH PL0 UH SRQWLILFLH HUD SHUz LO IDWWR FKH L )DUQHVH HUDQR XQD JUDQGH GLQDVWLD FKH UHJQDYD VXOO·LPSRUWDQWH GXFDWR SDGDQR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D/ H WUDGL]LRQDOPHQWH OHJDWD DOOD )UDQFLD1 7XWWR FLz VL RSSRQHYD GXQTXH DL SURJHWWL SRQWLILFL GL DQQHVVLRQH GL XQ WHUULWRULR/ FKH VL SUH0 VHQWDYD FRPH O·XQLFR UHVLGXR GL YHUD DXWRQRPLD IHXGDOH VRSUDYYLVVXWR HQWUR L FRQILQL WUDGL0 ]LRQDOL GHOOR 6WDWR1 ,Q HIIHWWL L SRQWHILFL DYHYDQR/ FRQ RSSRUWXQH PRVVH/ FRQVROLGDWR OD SUR0 SULD IURQWLHUD VXO 3R FRQ O·DFTXLVWR GL )HUUDUD DO WHPSR GL &OHPHQWH 9,,, +48<504938, H VL HUDQR LPSDGURQLWL DQFKH GL 8UELQR/ GXUDQWH LO SRQWLILFDWR GL 8UEDQR 9,,, %DUEHULQL +49560 4977,1,Q SDUWLFRODUH FRQ TXHVW·XOWLPD DQQHVVLRQH/ FXL VHJXu O·LPSRQHQWH FRVWUX]LRQH GHO )RU0 WH 8UEDQR GL IURQWH DO FRQILQH FRQ LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ LO WHUULWRULR GHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR VL HVWHQGHYD FRVu GDO 3R ILQR DO UHJQR GL 1DSROL1 7XWWR FLz QRQ SRWHYD FKH SUHRFFXSDUH WXWWL JOL VWDWL YLFLQL = 7RVFDQD/ 6SDJQD +SUHVHQWH D 1DSROL H D 0LODQR,/ 9HQH]LD/ 3DUPD H 0RGHQD1 )UD TXHVWL VROWDQWR 3DUPD DYHYD OD QHFHVVLWj GL ULPDQHUH LQ EXRQL UDSSRUWL FRQ 5RPD/ JLDFFKp LO SDSD DYHYD FRQFHVVR DO GXFD/ SHU VRSSHULUH DOOD VXD QHFHVVLWj GL GHQDUR/ GL ODQFLDUH XQ SUHVWL0 WR VXO PHUFDWR ILQDQ]LDULR FDSLWROLQR1 /D JDUDQ]LD GL WDOH SUHVWLWR HUD FRVWLWXLWD GDOOH UHQGLWH
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
4496
DSSURILWWDQGR GHOOD GHEROH]]D GHO SUHVLGLR SRQWLILFLR GL )HUUDUD/ XQD LQL]LDWL0 YD PLOLWDUH SHU ULFRQTXLVWDUH DO VXR FDVDWR OD FLWWj/ PD O·LQL]LDWLYD ULHQWUz HV0 VHQGRVHQH DYYHGXWR LO FDUGLQDOH OHJDWR/ *LQQHWWL/ FKH SUHGLVSRVH OH RSSRUWX0 QH FRQWURPLVXUH1 'LYHQXWD LPSUDWLFDELOH OD VROX]LRQH PLOLWDUH/ LO GXFD WHQWz TXHOOD GHOOD GLSORPD]LD H/ QHO 4976/ IHFH SXEEOLFDUH XQ PDQLIHVWR< FRQ FXL ²²²²²²²² GHL GXH IHXGL GHOOD FDVD )DUQHVH SRVWL QHO 3DWULPRQLR GL 6DQ 3LHWUR/ YDOH D GLUH &DVWUR H 5RQFLJOLRQH1 /D JXHUUD PROWR VDQJXLQRVD/ FKH VL FRPEDWWp DQFKH SHU PDUH/ YLGH FRLQYROWL GD XQ ODWR 8UEDQR 9,,, %DUEHULQL FRDGLXYDWR GDL VXRL QLSRWL )UDQFHVFR/ $QWRQLR/ H 7DGGHR/ GDOO·DOWUR 2GRDUGR )DUHVH GXFD GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D1 8QD SULPD PRVVD SRQWLILFLD IX TXHOOD GL SURSRUUH/ LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD YLVLWD FRPSLXWD D 5RPD GDO GXFD/ O·DFTXLVWR GL &DVWUR H 5RQ0 FLJOLRQH FRQ XQD IRUWH VRPPD GL GHQDUR/ ROWUHFKp O·LQVWDXUDUVL GL YLQFROL IDPLJOLDUL IUD OH GXH IDPLJOLH/ PD WDOH RIIHUWD QRQ LQFRQWUz LO IDYRUH GHL )DUQHVH FKH OD ULILXWDURQR1 $OOD ULFKLHVWD/ DYDQ]DWD GL Ou D SRFR/ GHL FUHGLWRUL URPDQL GHO 'XFD GL HVVHUH VRGGLVIDWWL/ LO SRQWHILFH/ LQ XQ FOLPD GL LQFHUWH]]H H GL SUHVVLRQL GD SDUWH GHOOD &XULD/ GHFLVH GL LQWLPDUH LO SDJDPHQWR GRYX0 WR H LO GLVDUPR GHOO·LPSRQHQWH SUHVLGLR GL &DVWUR H 5RQFLJOLRQH1 2GRDUGR/ SHU QXOOD LQWLPR0 ULWR/ RUGLQz DQ]L PDJJLRUL IRUWLILFD]LRQL H WDJOL DL SDJDPHQWL FKH VL IDFHYDQR D IDYRUH GL VXG0 GLWL SRQWLILFL VRWWRVFULWWRUL GL OXRJKL GL PRQWH1 ,PPHGLDWD OD ULWRUVLRQH SRQWLILFLD = GLYLHWR QHO OLEHUR FRPPHUFLR GHL JUDQL GD &DVWUR QHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR/ UHYRFD GHOOD FRQFHVVLRQH LQ EDVH DOOD TXDOH LO WUDIILFR FRPPHUFLDOH GD 5RPD DOOD 7RVFDQD SDVVDYD SHU 5RQFLJOLRQH/ EORFFR GHL FUHGLWL H DOWUH PLVXUH QHOO·HVWDWH VXFFHVVLYD1 4XLQGL VL SDVVz QHOO·RWWREUH GHO 4974 DOO·RFFXSD]LRQH GL &DVWUR H DOOD GLFKLDUD]LRQH GHOOD GHFDGHQ]D GHO GXFD GDO IHXGR IDFHQGR ULFRUVR/ FRPH HUD G·XVR/ DOOD FHQVXUD HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 ,O GXFD TXLQGL FHUFz HG RWWHQQH O·DLXWR GL 9HQH]LD/ )LUHQ]H H 0RGHQD FKH VL VWULQVHUR/ FRO EHQHVWDUH GHOOD )UDQFLD/ LQ XQD OHJD QHOO·DXWXQQR GHO 49751'RSR DOWHUQH YLFHQGH 8UEDQR 9,,, IX FRVWUHWWR LO 64 PDU]R 4977 D ULFRQVHJQDUH &DVWUR H 5RQFLJOLRQH DL )DUQHVH1 'D QRWDUH FKH VROWDQWR FLQTXH DQQL GRSR L )DUQHVH SHUGHWWHUR LO IHXGR SHU FXL DYHYDQR WDQWR ORWWDWR1 $Q]L LQ VHJXLWR DOOD FRVLGGHWWD ©VH0 FRQGD JXHUUD GL &DVWURª QHO 497</ GLFKLDUDWD GDO SDSD ,QQRFHQ]R ; +497704988, DO VXFFHVVR0 UH GL 2GRDUGR/ 5DQXFFLR ,,/ ULWHQXWR UHVSRQVDELOH GHOO·XFFLVLRQH GHO YHVFRYR GL &DVWUR/ &UL0 VWRIRUR *LDUGD/ OD FLWWDGLQD GL &DVWUR/ GRSR HVVHUH VWDWD RFFXSDWD GDOOH WUXSSH SRQWLILFLH IX UDVD DO VXROR QHO VHWWHPEUH 497<1 6L FRQFOXGHYD FRVu GUDPPDWLFDPHQWH XQD OXQJD YLFHQGD FKH WRJOLHYD SHU VHPSUH DL )DUQHVH LO SRVVHVVR GL TXHVWL WHUULWRUL1 &IU1 D WDO SURSRVLWR LO UHFHQ0 WH FRQWULEXWR GL &1 3$2/(77,/ /D SULPD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR +497304977,1 *OL DVSHWWL QDYDOL GHOOD ORWWD FRQWUR O·HVSDQVLRQLVPR SDSDOH GD SDUWH GHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL GHO &HQWUR QRUG/ VWD LQ ©5LYLVWD PDULWWLPDª/ 4<<;/ SS1 ;<0433 H LQROWUH 51 &+,29(//,/ &URQRORJLD GHOOD SULPD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR +49740 4977, QHOOH &DUWH %DUEHULQL SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD 9DWLFDQD/ LQ ©%LEOLRWHFD H VRFLHWj1 4XDGHUQL GHOOD 5LYLVWD GHO &RQVRU]LR SHU OD JHVWLRQH GHOOH ELEOLRWHFKH FRPXQDOL GHJOL DUGHQWL H SURYLQFLDOH $QVHOPR $QVHOPL GL 9LWHUERª/ Q1 531 6XL YDUL GLVFHQGHQWL GHOOD SRWHQWH IDPLJOLD GHL )DUQHVH VDUj XWLOH FRQVXOWDUH OH YRFL ORUR GHGLFDWH LQ= 'L]LRQDULR ELRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQL/ ,VWLWXWR GHOOD HQFLFORSHGLD LWDOLDQD/ 5RPD/ 4<<8/ SS1 85048<1 ; &IU1 /1 6,0(21,/ )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH H OD SROLWLFD LWDOLDQD GHO 0D]]DULQR/ %RORJQD/ 4<551 < &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 4396/ %6FULWWXUD SXEEOLFDWD SHU SDUWH GHO VHUHQLVVLPR 'X0
4497
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
YHQLYDQR SXEEOLFDPHQWH ULEDGLWH OH SUHWHVH/ QRQ PDL VRSLWH/ GHJOL (VWHQVL VX )HUUDUD H LO VXR GXFDWR/ FRQVLGHUDWH FRPH ©OD PDJJLRUH H PLJOLRU SDUWH GHL OR0 UR 6WDWL/ UHQGLWH H IDFROWjª1 9HQLYD LQ SULPR OXRJR FRQWHVWDWD OD YDOLGLWj VWHVVD GHOOD FRQFRUGLD IDHQWLQD/ ULWHQXWD QXOOD SHUFKp HVWRUWD D &HVDUH FRQ OD PLQDF0 FLD GL ©HVVHUFLWL QXPHURVL H111 RFFXOWH DUWLILFLRVH QHJR]LD]LRQLª/ ROWUHFKp FRQ OH FHQVXUH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH1 ,Q RJQL FDVR/ DG DYYLVR GHO GXFD/ QHO SDWWR GL )DHQ]D QRQ SRWHYDQR HVVHUH ULFRQRVFLXWH OH WHUUH 0 SULQFLSDOH GL HVVH &RPDFFKLR 0 FKH QRQ IDFHYDQR SDUWH GHO GXFDWR GL )HUUDUD H FKH HUDQR ULWHQXWH GDJOL (0 VWHQVL D WLWROR IHXGDOH/ GLIIHUHQWH GD TXHOOR GHOOD FDSLWDOH1 (UD SRL VRVWHQXWD OD OHJLWWLPLWj GHL QDWDOL GHOOR VWHVVR &HVDUH/ HG LQILQH YHQLYDQR ODPHQWDWH XVXU0 SD]LRQL GHL EHQL DOORGLDOL FKH OD FRQFRUGLD IDHQWLQD DYHYD ODVFLDWR DJOL (VWHQ0 VL1 4XHVWH SUHWHVH YHQQHUR GLIIXVH DQ]LWXWWR SUHVVR LO JRYHUQR YHQHWR H SRL SUHVVR DOWUH FRUWL/ HG LQROWUH LO GXFD LQYLz D 5RPD XQ SURSULR UDSSUHVHQWDQ0 WH43/ DOOR VFRSR GL DYYLDUH XQD WUDWWDWLYD FKH EHQ SUHVWR DQGz LQ IXPR1 9LVWD FRVu SUHFOXVD OD ULFRQTXLVWD GL )HUUDUD/ D )UDQFHVFR QRQ UHVWz FKH WHQWDUH DQ0 FRUD OD YLD GHOOH DUPL FRQ O·LQWHUYHQWR/ D ILDQFR GHL )DUQHVH44/ FRPH VL q GHW0 WR/ QHOOD JXHUUD45FKH LQWHUHVVz QXPHURVH ]RQH GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUR0 VHWWHQWULRQDOH1 1HO 4977 VL FRQFOXVH TXHVWD SULPD IDVH GHO FRQIOLWWR VHQ]D FKH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ QRQRVWDQWH FKH L VXRL SRVVHGLPHQWL IRVVHUR VWDWL WHDWUR GL VDFFKHJJL H EDWWDJOLH/ ULXVFLVVH D FRQVHJXLUH ULVXOWDWL FRQFUHWL1 $G HVVD ULVDOH OD IRUWLILFD]LRQH GHL FRQILQL IUD LO WHUULWRULR SRQWLILFLR GL %RORJQD H TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD H/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ O·HGLILFD]LRQH GHO IRUWH 8UEDQR1 /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH QRQ LQWHUYHQQH SRL QHOOD VHFRQGD IDVH GHOOD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR46/ FRQFOXVDVL/ ²²²²²²²² FD GL 0RGHQD>% ,ELGHP/ E1 4674/ %6FULWWXUD SXEEOLFDWD SHU SDUWH GHO VHUHQLVVLPR GXFD GL 0RGHQD H 5L0 VSRVWD GHOOH UDJLRQL FKH OD VHUHQLVVLPD FDVD G·(VWH KD FRQ OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD%> $65RPD/ &DPHUDOLD GLYHUVD/ &ROOHFWLR ,,/ E1 779/ II1 89:08;3/ %&RQWURYHUVLD IUD LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HYHUHQGD FDPHUD DSRVWROLFD%1> FIU1 LQROWUH $65RPD/ %LEOLRWHFD/ %5LVWUHWWR GHOOH UDJLRQL FKH OD VHUHQLVVL0 PD &DVD G·(VWH KD FROOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD FRPSLODWR FRQ RFFDVLRQH GL UHSOLFDUH DOOD 5LVSR0 VWD GL 5RPD/ V1G%> $65RPD/ 0LVFHOODQHD GL FDUWH SROLWLFKH H ULVHUYDWH/ IDVF 57<= 4976/ %,QIRUPDWLR0 QH D 61 6DQWLWj VRSUD OH SUHWHQVLRQL FKH LO 6HU1 PR GL 0RGHQD KD FRQ OD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD%1 43 6L WUDWWDYD GHO PDUFKHVH GL *XLOLD/ PDJJLRUGRPR GHO GXFD G·(VWH1 44 3UHFHGHQWHPHQWH F·HUDQR VWDWL DO FRQWUDULR GHL GLVVDSRUL IUD JOL (VWHQVL H L ORUR FRQIL0 QDQWL )DUQHVL 1 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 6(*5(72 9$7,&$12/ $1 $1/ $UP1 ,0 ;9,,,/ E1 7;8;/ SS1 59/ 64/% /HWWHUD GL 01 )DUQHVH VXOOH SUHWHQVLRQL GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD ULJXDUGR DOOH DUWLJOLHULH/ DOOR VSD]LR GHO WHUUDJOLR SUHVVR OD IRUWH]]D +5 JLXJQR 4937,% 1 45 6L WUDWWD/ FRPH JLj GHWWR/ GHOOD SULPD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR +497404977,1 46 &IU1 01 &$5$9$/( 0 $1 &$5$&&,2/2/ /R 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR«FLW1/ SS1 76<07731 ,QQRFHQ]R
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
4498
FRPH QRWR LO 5 VHWWHPEUH GHO 497</ FRQ OD GLVWUX]LRQH GL TXHVWD FLWWj H OD GH0 YROX]LRQH DOOD 6DQWD VHGH GHJOL DQWLFKL 6WDWL IDUQHVLDQL GL &DVWUR H 5RQFLJOLR0 QH1 'L Ou D SRFKL DQQL/ LO GXFD $OIRQVR ,9 0 FRQWLQXDQGR OD SROLWLFD RUPDL WUDGL]LRQDOH GHOOD VXD FDVDWD 0 DSSURILWWDQGR GHO VXR UXROR GL FRPDQGDQWH GH0 JOL HVHUFLWL IUDQFHVL LQ ,WDOLD QHO FRQIOLWWR FKH YHGHYD FRQWUDSSRVWH OD )UDQFLD H OD 6SDJQD/ ULXVFu/ FRQVLJOLDWR GDO FDUGLQDO 0D]]DULQR D VWLSXODUH XQD SDFH VHSDUDWD FRQ OD 6SDJQD47/ D IDU LQVHULUH OH SURSULH SUHWHVH VX &RPDFFKLR48 QHOOD SDFH GHL 3LUHQHL GHO 498<1 6XFFHVVLYDPHQWH/ ULXVFu DG LQWURPHWWHUVL/ SHU VRVWHQHUH WDOL SUHWHVH/ QHOOH JUDYL GLYHUJHQ]H LQVRUWH IUD LO SDSD $OHVVDQGUR 9,, HG LO UH GL )UDQFLD /XLJL ;,9 FKH/ SUHQGHQGR D SUHWHVWR DWWHQWDWL IDWWL QHO 4993 GDOOH WUXSSH FRUVH GHO SDSD FRQWUR O·DPEDVFLDWD IUDQFHVH D 5RPD/ DYHYD RFFXSDWR $YLJQRQH H LO FRQWDGR YHQDVVLQR1 1HO 4997/ YHQQH LQILQH VWLSXODWD D 3LVD OD SDFH WUD )UDQFLD H 6WDWR HFFOHVLDVWLFR= LQ HVVD LO QXRYR GXFD GL 0R0 GHQD/ )UDQFHVFR ,,/ VXEHQWUDWR DOO·HWj GL VROL GXH DQQL DO SDGUH $OIRQVR ,9/ ²²²²²²²² ; 3DPSKLOL FRQWUDSSRQHQGRVL DO GXFD 5DQXFFLR ,, )DUQHVH/ ULXVFu DG DQQHWWHUVL LO GXFDWR FD0 VWUHQVH1 4XHVWR QXRYR FRQIOLWWR YD VRWWR LO QRPH GL VHFRQGD JXHUUD GL &DVWUR H VL FRQFOXVH QHO VHWWHPEUH 497< FRQ OD FDSLWROD]LRQH GHO GXFDWR FDVWUHQVH H OD VXFFHVVLYD GHPROL]LRQH GHOO·LQWHUD FLWWj1 9HGL QRWD Q1 : 1 47 /D SDFH IX FRQFOXVD VHSDUDWDPHQWH LQ GDWD 7 PDU]R 498< H IX SRL FRQIHUPDWD QHO WUDW0 WDWR GHL 3LUHQHL1 &IU1 *1 48$==$/ 3UHSRQGHUDQ]D VSDJQROD/ LQ ©6WRULD SROLWLFD G·,WDOLDª/ 0LODQR/ 9DOODUGL/ 4<7;1 48 8Q VHFFR GDQQR HFRQRPLFR SHU JOL (VWHQVL HUD VWDWD/ LQ VHJXLWR DOOD &DSLWROD]LRQH GL )DHQ]D GHO 48<; OD SHUGLWD GL &RPDFFKLR H GHOOH VXH YDOOL/ GD FXL HVVL ULFDYDYDQR DOFXQH GHOOH HQWUDWH PDJJLRUL1 0ROWR VYLOXSSDWD QHO WHUULWRULR FRPDFFKLHVH HUD LQIDWWL ILQ GDL WHPSL DQWLFKL O·DWWLYLWj GL SHVFD/ FRQVHUYD]LRQH H YHQGLWD GHOOH DQJXLOOH FRVu FRPH XQ DOWUR LPSRUWDQWH HOH0 PHQWR GHOO·HFRQRPLD ORFDOH HUD FRVWLWXLWR GDO VDOH FKH VL HVWUDHYD GDOOH VDOLQH GL &RPDFFKLR1 ,QWHUHVVDQWH SHU XQD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GHOOD VWRULD GL &RPDFFKLR LO YROXPH UHFHQWHPHQWH SXEEOL0 FDWR= 6WRULD GL &RPDFFKLR QHOO·HWj PRGHUQD/ *UDILV (G1/ 4<<8/ FRQ DPSLD ELEOLRJUDILD1 $QFKH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD DUFKLYLVWLFR/ QRWHYROH q VWDWD OD SURGX]LRQH GRFXPHQWDULD1 6HJQDOLDPR SULQFL0 SDOPHQWH/ VHQ]D OD SUHWHVD GL HVVHUH LQ TXHVWD VHGH HVDXVWLYL = $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ EE1 <370 <97/ FKH FRQWHQJRQR IUD O·DOWUR SUHJHYROL FDUWRJUDILH GHO WHUULWRULR FRPDFFKLHVH H GHOOH VXH YDOOL1 ,QROWUH FIU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOLD GLYHUVD 0&ROOHFWLR 5XELQR/ E1 834/ DQQR 498</ %(OHQFR GHL GRFXPHQWL HVLVWHQWL QHOO·$UFKLYLR VHJUHWR YDWLFDQR FLUFD OH FRQWURYHUVLH WUD OD &DPHUD H LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD FLUFD OD SUHWHQVLRQH GL TXHVW·XOWLPR GL DOFXQH YDOOL GL &RPDFFKLR%1 ,QWHUHV0 VDQWH LQROWUH $1 5,&&,/ 5HOD]LRQH GHOOH UDJLRQL HQWUDWH H SUHJLXGL]L GHOOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD QHOOD FLWWj/ YDOOL/ H ERVFKL GL &RPDFFKLR1 &RPSLODWD QHO 495; SHU LQFDULFR GL 8UEDQR 9,,,/ FIU1 $65RPD/ %LEOLRWHFD/ 0DQRVFULWWL Q1 5391 /·DXWRUH GHOOD UHOD]LRQH/ FRPSLODWD SHU RUGLQH GHO SRQWHILFH 8UEDQR 9,,, H GHVWLQDWD DG LOOXVWUDUH DJOL XIILFLDOL GHOOD 5HYHUHQGD FDPHUD DSRVWROLFD/ GD FXL GLSHQGHYD O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH YDOOL/ O·HIIHWWLYD VLWXD]LRQH ORFDOH H L UHODWLYL SUREOHPL HFRQRPLFR0 JLXULGLFL/ HUD O·H[ JRYHUQDWRUH SRQWLILFLR GL &RPDFFKLR H GHO VXR WHUULWRULR1
4499
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
GHFHGXWR QHO 4995/ RWWHQQH/ VH QRQ &RPDFFKLR/ DOFXQH LPSRUWDQWL FRQFHV0 VLRQL GDO JRYHUQR GL 5RPD1 (VVH IXURQR= LO SDJDPHQWR GHOOD VRPPD GL 73 PLOD VFXGL/ LO WUDVIHULPHQWR D FDULFR GHOOR VWHVVR JRYHUQR URPDQR GHJOL RQHUL GHO PRQWH HVWHQVH/ LVWLWXLWR LQL]LDOPHQWH D 5RPD D FDULFR GHL GXFKL GL 0RGH0 QD HG DPPRQWDQWH/ IUD FDSLWDOH H IUXWWL QRQ SDJDWL D 683 PLOD VFXGL/ ROWUH DG XQ SDOD]]R LQ 5RPD HG DOOD FRQIHUPD GHL JLXVSDWURQDWL VXOOH DEED]LH GL 3RPSRVD H DUFLSUHWXUD GL %RQGHQR1 /·DFFRUGR QRQ IX VRGGLVIDFHQWH SHU QHVVXQD GHOOH GXH SDUWL/ LO SDSD SURWH0 VWz GL HVVHUYL VWDWR LQGRWWR GDOOD ©YLROHQ]Dª GHOOH FLUFRVWDQ]H H DQFKH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ QRQRVWDQWH L QRWHYROL YDQWDJJL HFRQRPLFL FRQVHJXLWL/ VL PRVWUz VFRQWHQWR SHU QRQ DYHU UDJJLXQWR O·RELHWWLYR SROLWLFR GHOOD UHFXSHUD GL &R0 PDFFKLR/ RELHWWLYR FKH/ SHUDOWUR/ DYHYD DQFKH XQ LPSRUWDQWH ULVYROWR HFR0 QRPLFR SHU OD ULFFKH]]D GHL SURYHQWL FKH GHULYDYDQR GDOOR VIUXWWDPHQWR GHOOH ULVRUVH +VRSUDWWXWWR OD SHVFD, GHOOH YDOOL1 1XRYD RFFDVLRQH SHU ULDFFHQGHUH LO IXRFR GHOOH FRQWURYHUVLH YHQQH SUH0 VWDWD GDOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD FKH/ DSHUWDVL QHOO·DQQR 4:33/ LQWH0 UHVVz EHQ SUHVWR WXWWD O·,WDOLD/ HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH OD SLDQXUD SDGDQD/ GLYHQXWD WHUUHQR GL VFRQWUR IUD L FRQWUDSSRVWL HVHUFLWL IUDQFHVH HG DXVWULDFR1 ,O SRQWHIL0 FH &OHPHQWH ;,/ LQYLVR DOO·,PSHUR SHU DYHU VRVWHQXWR OD FDQGLGDWXUD GL )LOLS0 SR 9 DO WURQR GL 0DGULG/ VL YLGH/ LO 57 PDJJLR 4:3;/ RFFXSDUH &RPDFFKLR GD WUXSSH LPSHULDOL DO FRPDQGR GHO JHQHUDOH %RQQHYDO1 &RQ RJQL SUREDELOLWj/ O·LPSUHVD YHQQH VXJJHULWD GDO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ 5LQDOGR ,/ FKH HUD FRJQDWR GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH *LXVHSSH ,491 ,O JRYHUQR URPDQR WHQWz GL UHDJLUH FRQ OD IRU0 ]D/ DOOHVWHQGR XQ HVHUFLWR FKH/ DO FRPDQGR GHO JHQHUDOH 0DUVLJOL/ WHQWz GL UH0 FXSHUDUH &RPDFFKLR1 'RSR DOFXQH RSHUD]LRQL/ VDQJXLQRVH TXDQWR LQXWLOL/ &OHPHQWH ;, GRYHWWH DFFHWWDUH/ LO 48 JHQQDLR 4:3</ O·XOWLPDWXP DXVWULDFR H O·XPLOLDQWH SDFH FKH QH VHJXu1 &RPDFFKLR ULPDVH LQ PDQR LPSHULDOH H YHQQH UHVWLWXLWD DO JRYHUQR SRQWLILFLR VROR QHO 4:571 'RSR O·RFFXSD]LRQH GL &RPDFFKLR/ XQD YROWD FRQFOXVD OD IDVH PLOLWDUH/ VL DSUu XQ FRQWHQ]LRVR GLSORPDWLFR IUD 0RGHQD H 5RPD FKH VL LPSHUQLz VXOOD SURGX]LRQH GL WHVWL H GRFXPHQWL D VRVWHJQR GHOOH UDJLRQL GHOO·XQR H GHOO·DOWUR SULQFLSDWR VXOOD FLWWDGLQD1 &DPSLRQL GHOOD FDXVD SRQWLILFLD IXURQR 3LHU *LXVWR )RQWDQLQL H /RUHQ]R =DFFDJQL PHQWUH SHU LO GXFD VFHVH LQ FDPSR /XGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL14: ²²²²²²²² 49&IU1 /1 *,$&2%$==, ', 9,67$5,12/ 3DVVLRQL/ VFDQGDOL H LQWULJKL QHO SULPR VHWWHFHQWR URPDQR H DOOD FRUWH G·(VWH1 'DOOH PHPRULH GL XQ GLSORPDWLFR HVWHQVH/ 0LODQR/ *DU]DQWL/ 4<8<1 4: 6LD FRQVHQWLWR DSULUH XQD SDUHQWHVL1 1HOOD ULFHUFD GD QRL IDWWD SHU TXHVWR ODYRUR/ FL
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
449:
4XHVWD EDWWDJOLD OHWWHUDULD VL DSUu/ QHOOR VWHVVR 4:3;/ FRQ O·RSHUD GHO )RQ0 WDQLQL GDO WLWROR= ©,O GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GHOOD VHGH DSRVWROLFD VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR 111ª4;/ FXL VHJXu TXHOOD GHO 0XUDWRUL LQWLWRODWD= ©/HWWHUD GLUHWWD DG XQ SUHODWR GL 5RPD LQ ULVSRVWD DO GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GL &RPDFFKLR 111ª4<1 /D GLVSXWD SURVHJXu VLQR DO 4:53/ FRQ XQ·RSHUHWWD GHO )RQWDQLQL1 /D TXHVWLRQH/ SRL/ SHUVH GL LQWHUHVVH SHUFKp GL Ou D SRFR VHJXu OD UHVWLWX]LRQH GL &RPDFFKLR DO SDSD531
²²²²²²²² VLDPR LPEDWWXWL LQ XQD OHWWHUD GL /1 $1 085$725, D %HQHGHWWR ;,9 LQ FXL O·LQVLJQH VWXGLRVR SURSRQH GHOOH LQWHUHVVDQWL LQL]LDWLYH FKH ULWHQLDPR GL GRYHU VHJQDODUH/ QRQRVWDQWH HVXOLQR GDO GLVFRUVR FKH VWLDPR IDFHQGR1 ,O 0XUDWRUL VXJJHULVFH OD SUHSDUD]LRQH GL XQ·RSHUD LQWLWRODWD 1XRYD ,WDOLD 6DFUD1 6L WUDWWDYD TXLQGL GL LQGLYLGXDUH XQD SHUVRQD GD LQYLDUH QHJOL DUFKLYL VR0 SUDWWXWWR GHL PRQDVWHUL DQWLFKL DO ILQH GL UDFFRJOLHUH QRWL]LH VIXJJLWH D )HUGLQDQGR 8JKHOOL JLj DXWRUH GL= ,WDOLD 6DFUD VLYH GH HVSLVFRSLV ,WDOLDH/ 9HQH]LD/ 61 &ROHWL/ 4:4:1 ,O 0XUDWRUL SRL ID XQD VHFRQGD SURSRVWD FLUFD XQ·DOWUD RSHUD LQ VRVWLWX]LRQH GHOOD GHVFUL]LRQH GHOO·,WDOLD IDWWD GD /H0 DQGUR $OEHUWL ERORJQHVH +FIU1 /1 $/%(57,/ 'HVFULWLRQH GL WXWWD O·,WDOLD H LVROH SHUWLQHQWL DG HV0 VD«$JJLRQWRYL GL QRYR«WXWWR TXHOOR/ FKH VXFFHVVR VLQR O·DQQR 48::/ ,Q 9HQHWLD/ DSSUHVVR *1 01 /HQL/ 48::/ W1 5,1 6DUHEEH VWDWR XWLOH LQIDWWL VHFRQGR LO SDUHUH GHO 0XUDWRUL LQFDULFDUH XQD SHUVRQD SHU IDUJOL YLVLWDUH WXWWD O·,WDOLD FRDGLXYDWD GD XQ JHRJUDIR SHU ULIDUH OH WDYROH GL *LRYDQQL $1 0DJLQL +FIU1 *1 $1 0$*,1,/ ,WDOLD GL *1 $1 0DJLQL / GDWD LQ OXFH GD )DELR VXR ILJOLXROR/ %RORJQD 49531 7DOH SHUVRQD SRL DYUHEEH GRYXWR YLVLWDUH = WXWWR TXDQWR GL EHOOR H UDUR VL FRQWLHQH LQ FDGDXQD FLWWj/ WDQWR QHOOH IDEEULFKH/ TXDQWR QHO SROLWLFR/ H QHO GLVWUHWWR G·HVVH SHU OD VWRULD QDWXUDOH FRQ DOWUH QRWL]LH DSSDUWHQHQWL DG DOWUH DUWL H DOO·HUXGL]LRQH1 ,O 0XUDWRUL LQILQH VHJQDOD XQ JLRYDQH GL VXD FRQRVFHQ]D DWWR D IDUH WDOH RSHUD +WDO GRWW1 0RQWHIDQL,1 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 6(*5(72 9$7,&$12/ 6HJU1 6WDWR/ 3ULQFLSL / Q1 5731 4; *1 )217$1,1,/ ,O GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GHOOD 6DQWD 6HGH DSRVWROLFD VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR SHU OR VSD]LR FRQWLQXDWR GL GLHFL VHFROL/ HVSRVWR DG XQ SULQFLSH> ,GHP/ 'LIHVD VHFRQGD GHO GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GHO0 OD VHGH DSRVWROLFD VRSUD OD FLWWj GL &RPDFFKLR/ 5RPD/ 4:44> ,'1/ 5LVSRVWD D YDULH VFULWWXUH FRQWUR OD 6DQWD 6HGH LQ SURSRVLWR GL &RPDFFKLR/ SXEEOLFDWH GRSR LO 4:44/ 5RPD/ 4:531 4< /1$1 085$725,/ /HWWHUD GLUHWWD DG XQ SUHODWR GL 5RPD LQ ULVSRVWD DO GRPLQLR WHPSRUDOH GL &R0 PDFFKLR> ,GHP/ 8PLOLVVLPD VXSSOLFD GL 5LQDOGR G·(VWH GXFD GL 0RGHQD DOOD 61 &1 01 GL *LXVHSSH , LP0 SHUDWRUH SHU OD FRQWURYHUVLD GL &RPDFFKLR> ,'1/ 5LIOHVVLRQL VRSUD OD YRFH VSDUVD GDOOD FRUWH GL 5RPD SHU OD UHVWLWX]LRQH GHO SRVVHVVR GL &RPDFFKLR1 53 &IU1 /1 6$1'5,/ /D TXHVWLRQH GL &RPDFFKLR DWWUDYHUVR OH FDUWH GHO FDUG1 *DOHD]]R 0DUHVFRWWL/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL VWRULD GHOOD &KLHVD LQ ,WDOLDª/ ,9/ 4<83> &1 )($/ ,O GLULWWR VRYUDQR GHOOD 61 6HGH VRSUD OH YDOOL GL &RPDFFKLR/ 5RPD/ 4;671 &IU1 LQROWUH *1 48$==$/ ,O SUREOHPD LWDOLDQR DOOD YLJLOLD GHOOH ULIRU0 PH +4:53²4:6;,/ ©$QQXDULR GHOO·,VWLWXWR VWRULFR LWDOLDQR SHU O·HWj PRGHUQDª/ 4<87/ 9,/ SS1 580 631
449;
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
61 /·DFTXLVWR GHOOD WHQXWD GHOOD 0HVROD 1HO FRUVR GHO ;9,,, VHFROR VXEu XQD VLJQLILFDWLYD HYROX]LRQH DQFKH OD TXHVWLRQH GHL EHQL DOORGLDOL HVWHQVL QHO IHUUDUHVH/ LO SL• LPSRUWDQWH GHL TXDOL HUD OD WHQXWD GHOOD 0HVROD1 1HO 4:8: LO JRYHUQR SRQWLILFLR LQWUDSUHVH XQ SDV0 VR/ SUHVVR OD FRUWH GL 0RGHQD/ SHU SUHQGHUH LQ DIILWWR SHUSHWXR LO FRPSOHVVR GHL EHQL VRSUD GHWWL= VL WUDWWDYD/ RYYLDPHQWH/ GL XQD IRUPD GL DOLHQD]LRQH PD0 VFKHUDWD/ LQ TXDQWR L GXFKL GL 0RGHQD QRQ DYUHEEHUR SL• DYXWR OD SRVVLELOLWj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j SRQWLILFLH FKH VL VHQWLYDQR LQ TXDOFKH PLVXUD FRQWUROODWH QHOOD ORUR D]LRQH1 $QDORJR HIIHWWR SURGXFHYD OD SUHVHQ]D LQ )HUUDUD GL DOWUL LQWHUHVVL PRGHQHVL/ IUD L TXDOL VHJQDOLDPR OD TXHVWLRQH GHO GLULWWR GL SRVWD/ FKH DVVLFXUDYD LO WUDVSRUWR D VSHVH GHO JRYHUQR SRQWLILFLR GL WXWWH OH FRUULVSRQGHQ]H GD H SHU 0RGHQD/ WUDQVLWDQWL SHU )HUUDUD1 *OL VFKHPL GL FRQWUDWWR GL DIILWWR SHUSHWXR/ HODERUDWL QHJOL XIILFL URPDQL/ SUHYHGHYDQR LQIDWWL DQFKH O·DEEDQGRQR GL WXWWL L GLULWWL H LQWHUHVVL FKH OD FDVD HVWHQVH DYHYD QHOOD OHJD]LRQH IHUUDUHVH1 /D WUDWWDWLYD DQGz DYDQWL SHU FLUFD GXH DQQL/ H VL JLXQVH DOOD UHGD]LRQH GL XQD ER]]D GL WUDWWDWR55/ FKH SHUz QRQ DQGz LQ SRUWR D FDXVD GL XQ LQWHUYHQWR GHOOD FRUWH GL 9LHQQD1 4XHVWD DYHYD VWLSXODWR XQ WUDWWDWR GL PDWULPRQLR WUD O·DUFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR/ ILJOLR GL 0DULD 7HUHVD/ H 0DULD %HDWULFH 5LFFLDUGD/ ILJOLD SULPRJHQLWD GHOO·DOORUD HUHGH DO WUR0 QR GXFDOH (UFROH 5LQDOGR/ HG DQFRUD EDPELQD1 3HU VLFXUH]]D GHOOD GRWH HUDQR VWDWL REEOLJDWL L EHQL HVWHQVL QHO )HUUDUHVH= DSSURILWWDQGR GL FLz/ HG XIILFLDO0 ²²²²²²²² 54 'DOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD L EHQL DOORGLDOL GHJOL HVWHQVL SRVWL QHO )HUUDUHVH IXURQR DPPLQLVWUDWL SHU FRQWR GL 61 $1 6HUHQLVVLPD SHU PH]]R GL VXRL FRPPLVVDUL UHVLGHQWL LQ )HUUD0 UD/ FKLDPDWL DOORUD FRO WLWROR GL IDWWRUL GXFDOL1 6HEEHQH ILQ GD TXHOO·HSRFD DOFXQL GL TXHVWL EHQL IRVVHUR DIILWWDWL/ FRPH OH YDOOL GL 9RODQR/ DOWUL FRQFHVVH D OLYHOOR/ DOWUL YHQGXWH/ OD &DPHUD GX0 FDOH GL 0RGHQD FRQVHUYz VHPSUH D )HUUDUD LO 0LQLVWHUR GHJOL DOORGLDOL FRPSRVWR G·XQ FRPPLV0 VDULR RVVLD IDWWRUH GXFDOH/ XQ DUFKLYLVWD VHJUHWDULR/ XQ FRPSXWLVWD HG XQ IDWWRUH FDYDOFDQWH1 7DOL EHQL LQROWUH DYHYDQR OD WRWDOH HVHQ]LRQH GD TXDOXQTXH GD]LR/ WDVVD R LPSRVL]LRQH WDQWR FDPHUDOH/ TXDQWR FRPXQLWDWLYD1 55 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 43961
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
449<
PHQWH SHU FRQWLQXDUH D JDUDQWLUH OD VLFXUH]]D GHOOD GRWH GHOOD JLRYDQLVVLPD SULQFLSHVVD/ OD FRUWH GL 9LHQQD DYDQ]z D TXHOOD GL 0RGHQD OD ULFKLHVWD GL FRQ0 VHJXLUH O·HIIHWWLYR SRVVHVVR GHL EHQL VWHVVL1 /·LQWHUYHQWR/ SHU TXDQWR VROLGH SRWHVVHUR HVVHUH OH VXH PRWLYD]LRQL HFRQRPLFKH/ DYHYD LQ UHDOWj XQ FRQWHQX0 WR SROLWLFR/ SRLFKp VL YROHYD LPSHGLUH XQ SLHQR HVSOLFDUVL GHOOD VRYUDQLWj SD0 SDOH VXO WHUULWRULR IHUUDUHVH1 9DQH LQIDWWL IXURQR WXWWH OH FRQWURSURSRVWH UR0 PDQH YROWH D JDUDQWLUH LQ DOWUD PDQLHUD JOL LQWHUHVVL HFRQRPLFL GL 9LHQQD561 /D WHQXWD GL 0HVROD57 IX QHO 4:8< YHQGXWD GDO GXFD )UDQFHVFR DOO·LPSHUR DX0 ²²²²²²²² 56
5LFDSLWRODQGR q GD WHQHU SUHVHQWH FKH O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH YDULH WHQXWH +6DPPDUWL0 QD/ 'LDPDQWLQD/ %HOULJXDUGR/ HWF1, HVWHQVL/ SRVWH QHO WHUULWRULR IHUUDUHVH/ GD SDUWH GHL UDSSUH0 VHQWDQWL GHOO·$]LHQGD HVWHQVH GXUz ILQR DO 4:8<1,Q WDOH GDWD LQIDWWL OD &DVD LPSHULDOH DXVWULDFD SUHVH SRVVHVVR GL TXHVWL EHQL DOORGLDOL HVWHQVL LQ HVHFX]LRQH GHO FRQWUDWWR VWLSXODWR IUD OH FRUWL LPSHULDOL GL 9LHQQD H GL 0RGHQD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO JLj FLWDWR PDWULPRQLR IUD 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH H O·DUFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR1 7DOL EHQL IXURQR VWLPDWL DOO·HSRFD LQ 7931333 VFXGL URPDQL/ H/ GDWR FKH PDQFDYDQR PROWL DQQL DOOD FHOHEUD]LRQH GHO PDWULPRQLR/ VL VWDELOu LQROWUH FKH OD &DPHUD LPSHULDOH DYUHEEH SDJDWR RJQL DQQR D TXHOOD GL 0RGHQD L IUXWWL FRPSHQVDWLYL GL WDOH VRPPD1 7DOH FRPSHQVR IX VWDELOLWR LQ 461;4: VFXGL DQQXL1 ,O PDWULPRQLR/ HVVHQGR OD VSRVD DQFRUD EDPELQD/ VL FHOHEUz VROWDQWR QHO 4::4/ TXDQGR OD &DVD LPSHULDOH FRQWLQXz O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOO·$]LHQGD FRQ OR VWHVVR VLVWHPD RUJDQL]]DWLYR FKH YLJHYD VRWWR JOL (0 VWHQVL1 ,QIDWWL JUD]LH DOOD QRPLQD GL XQ DOWUR FRPPLVVDULR UHVLGHQWH LQ )HUUDUD/ VXERUGLQDWR HG LPPHGLDWDPHQWH GLSHQGHQWH GDO JRYHUQDWRUH SOHQLSRWHQ]LDULR GHOOD /RPEDUGLD DXVWULDFD/ FRQWLQXz LQ WDO PRGR O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOO·$]LHQGD FRQ OR VWHVVR VLVWHPD RUJDQL]]DWLYR FKH YLJHYD VRWWR JOL (VWHQVL1 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 465:/ %0HPRULH ,VWRULFKH ULVJXDUGDQWL O·$]LHQGD GHL EHQL JLj DOORGLDOL HVWHQVL/ SRL LPSHULDOL HG RUD FDPHUDOL SRQWLILFL SRVWL QHO 'XFD0 WR GL )HUUDUD«UDFFROWH GDOO·DEDWH '1 *LRYDFFKLQR ,KDXVL *LURQ 3URWRQRWDULR H GL GHWWD FDPH0 UDOH 3RQWLILFLD $]LHQGD $UFKLYLVWD H 6HJUHWDULR%1 57 ,O QRPH 0HVROD VHPEUD GHULYDUH GD PH]]·LVROD/ D FDXVD GHOOD VXD IRUPD WULDQJRODUH«D0 YHQGR HOOD D VLQLVWUD LO 3R GL $ULDQR/ FKH LQ SDUWH OD FLQJH H D GHVWUD LO 3R PRUWR1 0HVROD/ FKH QHOOH DQWL0 FKH FDUWH q ULFRUGDWD FRO QRPH GL 0HQVXOD R 0HVXOD 0DJQD/ IX JLj VRWWRSRVWD DOOD FRPXQLWj GL $ULDQR1 6XFFHVVLYDPHQWH QHOO·DQQR 47<3/ FRPH ULIHULWR GD $1 /1 0XUDWRUL/ LO GXFD (UFROH FRPSHUz GD $QWRQLR 0DULD GH· 3HQGDVL TXHVWD YDVWD WHQXWD FKH FRVu HQWUz LQ SRVVHVVR GHJOL (VWHQVL GXFKL GL )HUUDUD/ FKH OD WUDVPLVHUR SRL GDO 48<; DJOL (VWHQVL GL 0RGHQD1 $ PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9,,, SHUz )UDQFHVFR ,,, OD YHQGHWWH DOO·LPSHUDWRUH )UDQFHVFR ,1 5LVXOWD LQIDWWL D WDOH SURSRVLWR FKH O·LQWHUD WHQXWD GHOOD 0HVROD VLWD QHO )HUUDUHVH/ 9DOOL GL 9RODQR/ SDOD]]R/ FDVH H ERWWHJKH LQ )HUUDUD DQQHVVL H FRQQHVVL HG LQ TXHO PRGR VWHVVR FKH DWWXDOPHQWH Vu QHOO·DWWLYR FKH QHO SDVVLYR VL JRGRQR GD 6XD 0DHVWj ,PSHULDOH LQVLHPH DOOH DQQXH UHQGLWH SHFXQLDULH G·DIILWWL/ OLYHOOL/ FHQVL/ GLULWWL/ XQLWDPHQWH DOOL SULYLOHJL/ HVHQ]LRQL/ SRVWH/ RVWHULH/ PDJD]]LQL111 SHUYHQQH DOOD FDVD G·$XVWULD FHGXWD GDOOD &DVD G·(VWH LQ VHJXLWR DG XQD VFULWWXUD GHO 57 DSULOH 4:8;/ ILUPDWD GDL FRQWL &ULVWLDQL H 6DEDWLQL ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH PLQLVWUL GHOHJDWL GHOOH GXH &RUWL1 &IU1 D WDO SURSRVLWR $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ EE1 4657046581 1HO 4:;8 TXLQGL OD 0HVROD SDVVz GL QXRYR GL SURSULHWj LQ TXDQWR IX YHQGXWD GDOO·LPSHUDWRUH *LXVHSSH ,, DO SRQWHILFH 3LR 9, +4::804:<<,1 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1
44:3
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
VWULDFR/ H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH ULDFTXLVWDWD GDO SRQWHILFH 3LR 9, QHO 4:;:/ HQ0 WUDQGR FRVu D IDU SDUWH GHOOH SURSULHWj GHOOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD H/ GD TXHVWD/ DO GHPDQLR GHOOR 6WDWR LWDOLDQR1
²²²²²²²² 465:/ %9HQGLWD GD 61 01 *LXVHSSH ,, D 61 61 3DSD 3LR 9, H 51 &1 $1 GHO 7HQLPHQWR GHOOD 0H0 VROD H EHQL DGGHWWL«%/D VRPPD GL <331333 VFXGL SDWWXLWD SHU WDOH YHQGLWD HUD LQGXEELDPHQWH DVVDL FRQVLVWHQWH SHU OH FDVVH SRQWLILFLH/ SHUWDQWR LO SRQWHILFH 3LR 9, GHSXWz LO PDUFKHVH $Q0 WRQLR *QXGL D VWLSXODUH XQ SUHVWLWR GD XQD R SL• SHUVRQH SUHVVR *HQRYD R DOWUL OXRJKL1 ,Q HIIHWWL LO PDUFKHVH *QXGL VYROVH HJUHJLDPHQWH LO VXR PDQGDWR ULXVFHQGR D UHSHULUH TXDQWR VHJXH LQ GHWWDJOLR= VRYYHQWRUL GLYHUVL GHOOD SLD]]D GL *HQRYD VRYYHQWRUL GLYHUVL GHOOD FLWWj GL 5RPD 'DOO·(1PR VLJ1 FDUG1 %RUURPHR 'DO 6DJUR 0RQWH GL 3LHWj 'DOOD 'DWDULD DSRVWROLFD 'DOOD WHVRUHULD DSRVWROLFD GL )HUUDUD 'DOOD WHVRUHULD DSRVWROLFD GL %RORJQD
VFXGL VFXGL VFXGL VFXGL 6FXGL VFXGL VFXGL
:781333 4831333 81333 <31333 :31333 431333 4<1756
'D QRWDUH FKH GDL <331333 VFXGL SDWWXLWL VL DUULYz D GRYHU SDJDUH VFXGL 413;<18<91 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUDOH ,,,/ E1 465/ %5LVWUHWWR GHO UHQGLPHQWR GH FRQWL IDWWR GDO VLJ1 PDUFKHVH *QXGL LQ JLXJQR 4:;: SHU O·DFTXLVWR GHOOD WHQXWD GHOOD 0HVROD HG DOWUL DQQHVVL/ YHQGXWD GD 61 01 O·LPSHUDWRUH DOOD 51 &1 $1 LQ YLUW• GHO FKLURJUDIR GL 11 6LJ1 UH GHO Gu : PDJJLR 4:;8%1 6RW0 WR LO SRQWLILFDWR GL /HRQH ;,, +4;5604;5<, TXHVWD WHQXWD UHQGHYD DO JRYHUQR VFXGL 4;13331 ,QILQH GXUDQWH LO SRQWLILFDWR GL *UHJRULR ;9, O·RVSHGDOH GL 61 6SLULWR LQ 6DVVLD GL 5RPD QH DFTXLVWz OD SURSULHWj LQ IRU]D GL YHQGLWD IDWWD GDOOD &DPHUD DSRVWROLFD1 &IU1 $65RPD/ &DPHUD0 OH ,,/ &RPSXWLVWHULD/ E1 ;/ %5HOD]LRQH GHO YLDJJLR IDWWR GDO WHVRULHUH JHQHUDOH SHU OR VWDWR HFFOHVLDVWLFR QHO 4::8%/ H TXDQWR GHWWR D WDO SURSRVLWR LQ 01 025(1$/ ,O &RQJUHVVR DFFDGHPLFR URPDQR H OD UHGD0 ]LRQH GHO &DWDORJR GHOOH PDQLIDWWXUH GHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR/ 5RPD/ 6FXROD GL DUFKLYLVWLFD/ SDOHRJUDILD H GLSORPDWLFD/ ©6WXGL H VWUXPHQWL1 <ª/ 4<<:/ SS1 90451 'D QRWDUH FKH GHOOD WHQXWD GHOOD 0HVROD VL RFFXSD DQFKH LO WUDWWDWR GL 7ROHQWLQR DOO·DUW1 4: =«LO 3DSD FHGH LQ WXWWD SURSULHWj DOOD UHSXEEOLFD WXWWL L EHQL DOORGLDOL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD 6DQWD VHGH QHOOH WUH SURYLQFH GL %RORJQD/ GL )HUUDUD H GHOOD 5RPDJQD H VHJQDWDPHQWH OD 7HUUD GHOOD 0HVROD H VXH GLSHQGHQ]H«1 &IU1 LQROWUH 51 '( )(/,&(/ /D YHQGLWD GHL EHQL QD]LRQDOL QHOOD UHSXEEOLFD URPDQD GHO 4:<;0<</ 5RPD/ (G1 GL VWRULD H OHWWHUDWXUD/ 4<9</ SS1 7907:1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
44:4
71 4XHVWLRQL GL SROLWLFD HFFOHVLDVWLFD *OL DQQL VXFFHVVLYL DOOD PDQFDWD FRQFHVVLRQH LQ DIILWWR SHUSHWXR/ IXURQR FD0 UDWWHUL]]DWL GD DOWUL FRQIOLWWL/ GL FDUDWWHUH TXHVWD YROWD JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWD/ IUD LO SRQWHILFH &OHPHQWH ;,,, H LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR/ FKH DYHYD OHYDWR LPSRVWH VXO FOHUR VHQ]D LO FRQVHQVR SRQWLILFLR/ LQ SUHFHGHQ]D VHPSUH ULFKLHVWR HG RWWHQX0 WR1 $ FLz VL DJJLXQVHUR SURYYHGLPHQWL GXFDOL GL UHVWUL]LRQH GHO GLULWWR GL DVLOR SUHVVR L FRQYHQWL H GL VRSSUHVVLRQH GL DOFXQL HQWL HFFOHVLDVWLFL1 8OWHULRUL PR0 WLYL GL FRQIOLWWR YHQQHUR SURYRFDWL GDOO·HPDQD]LRQH/ QHO 4::4/ GHO FRGLFH FLYL0 OH HVWHQVH58/ GL FXL YHQQHUR GDO SRQWHILFH FRQGDQQDWL QXPHURVL DUWLFROL/ SHU0 FKp LQ FRQWUDVWR FRQ L FDQRQL GHO FRQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR1 6L JLXQVH FRVu DOO·LQYDVLRQH QDSROHRQLFD GHOO·,WDOLD= QHO 4:<:/ SHU HIIHWWR GHO WUDWWDWR GL &DPSRIRUPLR59/ L GXFDWL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR 5:YHQQHUR DJ0 ²²²²²²²² 58
4XHVWR SULPR FRGLFH GHOO·LOOXPLQLVPR LWDOLDQR IX SURPXOJDWR GD )UDQFHVFR ,,, GD 0LODQR LQ GDWD 59 DSULOH 4::4 H SRFR GRSR IDWWR SXEEOLFDUH LQ 0RGHQD1 &IU1 D WDO SURSRVLWR /1 0$5,1,/ /R VWDWR HVWHQVH/ 7RULQR/ 87(7/4<:</ SS1 464 H VHJJ1 ,O FRGLFH LQIDWWL DYHYD WRFFDWR LPSRUWDQWL DUJRPHQWL FRPH OH PDQRPRUWH / OH LPPXQLWj GHOOH FKLHVH/ H LQ JHQHUDOH L SULYLOHJL HFFOHVLDVWL0 FL1 &IU1 D WDO SURSRVLWR &1 321,/ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHOO·DJULFROWXUD PRGHQHVH GDOO·HWj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·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·$QWLFR 5HJLPH DOO·HWj QDSROHRQLFD/ $WWL GHO FRQYHJQR= 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 4;053 PDU]R 4<::/ D FXUD GL 01 %(5(1*2 H 61 520$*12/,/ 4<:<1
44:5
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
JUHJDWL DOOD UHSXEEOLFD FLVDOSLQD/ PHQWUH O·XOWLPR GXFD GHOOD OLQHD HVWHQVH/ (U0 FROH 5LQDOGR ,,,/ ULFHYHWWH/ D VHJXLWR GHOOD SDFH GL /XQHYLOOH GHO 4;34/ SRVVH0 GLPHQWL LQ *HUPDQLD5;1 3HU WXWWR LO SHULRGR QDSROHRQLFR QRQ VL SXz RYYLDPHQWH SDUODUH GL UHOD0 ]LRQL WUD JOL VWDWL HFFOHVLDVWLFR H PRGHQHVH/ LQ TXDQWR TXHVW·XOWLPR/ VFRPSDU0 VR FRPH WDOH/ VHJXu OH VRUWL GHOOD UHSXEEOLFD FLVDOSLQD/ SRL LWDOLDQD/ SRL UHJQR G·,WDOLD/ PHQWUH LO SULPR/ VHEEHQH ULFRVWLWXLWR FRQ OH VROH SURYLQFH GHO /D]LR/ 8PEULD H 0DUFKH QHO 4:<</ YLVVH GL YLWD VWHQWDWD VLQR D FKH OH 0DUFKH QRQ IXURQR DQQHVVH DO UHJQR LWDOLFR QHO 4;3;/ HG LO /D]LR H 8PEULD DOO·LPSHUR IUDQFHVH QHO 4;3<1 1HO 4;47 LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ GHOOD OLQHD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ ULHQWUz LQ SRV0 VHVVR GHO VXR 6WDWR H/ IRUWH GHJOL VWUHWWL OHJDPL GL SDUHQWHOD FRQ OD FDVD LPSH0 ULDOH H GL TXHOOR PDWULPRQLDOH FRQ L 6DYRLD/ LQWUDSUHVH VXELWR WHQWDWLYL SHU LQ0 JUDQGLUH LO VXR 6WDWR/ LQ GLUH]LRQH GHOOD /LJXULD5< H/ DQFRU SL•/ YHUVR JOL DQWL0 FKL SRVVHGLPHQWL HVWHQVL QHO )HUUDUHVH/ QHL FXL FRQIURQWL ULYHQGLFDYD OD QRQ PDL FHGXWD VRYUDQLWj GHO VXR FDVDWR631 /D SUHWHVD YHQQH DQ]L DYDQ]DWD QHO FRQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD/ PD/ FRPH q QRWR/ O·DELOLWj GHO VHJUHWDULR GL VWDWR SRQWL0 ILFLR/ FDUG1 &RQVDOYL/ VHSSH UHVSLQJHUH WXWWL JOL DWWDFFKL FRQWUR O·LQWHJULWj GHOO·DQWLFR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD/ FKH YHQQH ULFRVWLWXLWR QHL FRQILQL DQWHULRUL DO 4:<9/ FRQ O·HVFOXVLRQH GL XQD IUDQJLD GL WHUULWRULR VXOOD ULYD VLQLVWUD GHO 3R/ JLj DSSDUWHQHQWH DOOD OHJD]LRQH GL )HUUDUD HG RUD DJJUHJDWR DO 9HQHWR DXVWULDFR641 /·HWj VXFFHVVLYD DOOD UHVWDXUD]LRQH/ ILQLWR LO FRQWHQ]LRVR UHODWLYR DO )HUUD0 UHVH/ q FDUDWWHUL]]DWD/ SHU TXDQWR FRQFHUQH L UDSSRUWL IUD 0RGHQD H 5RPD/ GDOOD PDWHULD UHOLJLRVD65 H VROR VHFRQGDULDPHQWH GD TXHOOD SROLWLFD1 /· XQLFR ²²²²²²²² 5; ,O GXFD (UFROH ,,, LQ YLUW• GHOOD SDFH GL /XQpYLOOH +< IHEEUDLR 4;34, DYHYD ULFHYXWR LQ FDPELR GHL GXH GXFDWL GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR LO %ULVJDX H O·2UWHQDX1 5< /·DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR LQ XQD QRWD FRQILGHQ]LDOH LQGLUL]]DWD DO SULQFLSH GL 0HWWHUQLFK/ IUD O·DOWUR/ GLFKLDUDYD GL ULWHQHUH HVWUHPDPHQWH YDQWDJJLRVR SRVVHGHUH XQ SRUWR VXO 0HGLWHUUDQHR/ RQGH DYHUH FRVu DSHUWD XQD YLD IDFLOH H VLFXUD SHU FRPXQLFDUH FROOD VXGGHWWD LVROD GL 6DUGHJQD1 &RWHVWR SRUWR QRQ SRWUHEEH HVVHUH VH QRQ TXHOOR GHOOD 6SH]LD111 &IU1 11 %,$1&+,/ 6WRULD GHOOD GLSORPD]LD HXURSHD LQ ,WDOLD/ 7RULQR/ 87(7/ 4;98/ YRO14 +4;4704;53,/ SS1 760771 63 ,ELGHP/ S1 77 64 (1 $1&+,(5,/ $QWRORJLD VWRULFR0GLSORPDWLFD1 5DFFROWD RUGLQDWD GL GRFXPHQWL GLSORPDWLFL/ SROLWLFL/ PHPRULDOLVWLFL/ GL WUDWWDWL H FRQYHQ]LRQL GDO 4;48 DO 4<73/ 5RPD/ ,VWLWXWR SHU OD VWRULD GL SROLWLFD LQWHUQD/ 4<741 65 )UDQFHVFR ,9 DSSHQD VDOLWR VXO WURQR ULYROVH VXELWR OD VXD DWWHQ]LRQH YHUVR OD UHOLJLRQH H LO FOHUR/ WDQW·q FKH FKLHVH VXELWR D 5RPD FRRSHUD]LRQH SHU ULSULVWLQDUH FRQYHQWL H PRQDVWH0 UL1 ,Q VHJXLWR DG DOFXQH FRQWURYHUVLH IX VXELWR FKLDUR FKH LO GXFD QRQ HUD GLVSRVWR D ODVFLDU OD
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
44:6
HSLVRGLR GL ULOLHYR LQ WDOH FDPSR IX LQIDWWL LO UXROR JLRFDWR GD 0RGHQD TXDQ0 GR 3LR ,;/ VSLQWR GDO YHQWR ULIRUPLVWD/ DYYLz QHO 4;7: OH QRWH WUDWWDWLYH SHU OD FUHD]LRQH GHOOD OHJD GRJDQDOH IUD JOL VWDWL LWDOLDQL661 /D WUDWWDWLYD/ EHQ SUHVWR DUHQDWDVL/ HEEH WDOH LQIHOLFH HVLWR DQFKH D FDXVD GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ FKH SUHIHUu DYYLDUH WUDWWDWLYH FRQ O·$XVWULD/ VWUDYROJHQGR FRVu LO VHQVR GHOO·LQL]LDWLYD GL 3LR ,;1 1RQ ULHQWUDQR LQYHFH QHO QRVWUR DUJRPHQWR OH TXH0 VWLRQL FRQFHUQHQWL OD ULYROX]LRQH GHO 4;64 FKH/ LUUDJJLDWDVL SURSULR GD 0RGH0 QD/ GLODJz D %RORJQD H QHOOH SURYLQFH SRQWLILFLH PHULGLRQDOL/ VLQR D ODPELUH OD VWHVVD 5RPD1 1HOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHF1 ;9,,, LO GXFDWR PRGHQHVH/ DGHJXDQGRVL DOO·LQGLUL]]R JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFR GHOOD FRUWH DXVWULDFD/ DYHYD FRPLQFLDWR D LQ0 WURGXUUH HOHPHQWL FKH DYHYDQR WXUEDWR OD VLQ Ou LQLQWHUURWWD SDFH UHOLJLRVD FRQ OD 6DQWD VHGH671 /H SULPH TXHVWLRQL LQVRUWH DYHYDQR ULJXDUGDWR LO WUDWWDPHQWR ILVFDOH GHL EHQL GHO FOHUR= GLYHUVH YROWH LO GXFD DYHYD RWWHQXWR FKH LO SDSD UL0 QXQFLDVVH WHPSRUDQHDPHQWH DOO·HVHQ]LRQH ILVFDOH GL WDOL EHQL LQ RFFDVLRQH GL FLUFRVWDQ]H HFFH]LRQDOL +4:53/ SHU VDQDUH L GHELWL FRQWUDWWL LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQXROD> 4:6:/ SHU OD WDVVD SHU JOL DOORJJLDPHQWL DOOH WUXSSH VWUDQLHUH LQ WUDQVLWR QHO GXFDWR> 4:6</ WDVVD SHU L ELVRJQL GL JXHUUD FRQWUR L WXUFKL,1 0D JLj QHO 4:84 VL HYLWz GL FKLHGHUH O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH SRQWLIL0 FLD H L EHQL GHO FOHUR UHJRODUH H VHFRODUH YHQQHUR VRWWRSRVWL D WDVVD]LRQH VWD0 ELOH/ QHO 4:85 OH FRQIUDWHUQLWH ODLFDOL IXURQR VRWWRSRVWH DOOD YLJLODQ]D GHO PD0 JLVWUDWR GHJOL DOORJJL/ QHO 4:87 H 4:88 LO FOHUR YHQQH VRWWRSRVWR DO SDJDPHQWR GHOOD WDVVD VXO EHVWLDPH1 &OHPHQWH ;,,,/ QHO 4:99/ GLHGH XQD VDQDWRULD D WDOH VLWXD]LRQH FRQ XQD EROOD LQ FXL VL GLFKLDUDYD FKH LO FOHUR HUD WHQXWR DG DOOHYLD0 ²²²²²²²² PDQR OLEHUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH LQ PDWHULD GL JLXULVGL]LRQH HFFOHVLDVWLFD1 &IU1 ,ELGHP/ SS1 5;605;71 66 &IU1 )1 *(17,/,/ , SUHOLPLQDUL GHOOD OHJD GRJDQDOH H LO SURWHVRULHUH 0RULFKLQL/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD VWR0 ULFD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ ,/ ,9/ 4<47/ SS1 896 H VHJJ1 8Q DFFRUGR GL PDVVLPD FLUFD OD OHJD HUD VWDWR UDJJLXQWR WUD 5RPD/ 7RULQR H )LUHQ]H1 3HU PRWLYL GL RSSRUWXQLWj SROLWLFD IX SHUz LQWHU0 SHOODWR VROR OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ H QRQ TXHOOL GL 3DUPD H GHO /RPEDUGR09HQHWR1 ,Q HIIHWWL WDOH HVFOXVLRQH WUDGLYD XQR VFRSR SL• SROLWLFR FKH FRPPHUFLDOH H DQGDYD LQ VHQVR DQWLDXVWULDFR1 ,O GXFD )UDQFHVFR QRQ DYHYD LQWHQ]LRQH GL SDUWHFLSDUH DOOD OHJD/ PD FHUFz QHO 4;7: GL SUR0 SRUUH XQD FRQYHQ]LRQH FRPPHUFLDOH FRQ O·$XVWULD RWWHQHQGRQH XQ ULILXWR= &IU1 /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH1 6WRULD GHL VXRL GXFKL111 FLW1/ S1 67:1 67 &IU1 31 )251,/ , FRQFRUGDWL HVWHQVL GHO 4;74 H 4;84/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL VWRULD GHOOD &KLHVD LQ ,WD0 OLDª/ 4<87/ 9,,,/ 6/ SS1 68906;51 'D QRWDUH O·LQWHUHVVH VXVFLWDWR SUHVVR TXHVWD FRUWH LQ RFFD0 VLRQH GHO FRQFODYH SHU OD PRUWH GL /HRQH ;,, H O·HOH]LRQH GHO QXRYR SRQWHILFH1 &IU1 LELGHP/ SS1 75<0641 &IU1 11 %,$1&+,/ 6WRULD GHOOD GLSORPD]LD HXURSHD111/ FLW1/ YRO1 5 +4;53063,/ SS1 53< H VHJJ1/ H SS1 75<07641
44:7
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
UH LO FDULFR ILVFDOH GHL ODLFL1 $OWUH YHUWHQ]H ULJXDUGDURQR LO IRUR HFFOHVLDVWLFR68/ FKH YHQLYD VRWWRSRVWR DG DOFXQH OLPLWD]LRQL HG DQFRUD L EHQL GHL FRQYHQWL/ R PDQL PRUWH/ LQ RUGLQH DL TXDOL VL VWDELOu FKH L EHQL GHL VLQJROL PHPEUL GHOOH FRQJUHJD]LRQL QRQ GRYH0 YDQR SL• DQGDUH D TXHVWH/ PD DL SDUHQWL GHJOL LQWHUHVVDWL/ PHQWUH OH SURSULHWj DFTXLVWDWH GDOOH FRQJUHJD]LRQL ULPDQHYDQR VRWWRSRVWH DJOL VWHVVL SHVL/ QHL FRQIURQWL GHO ILVFR H GHL SULYDWL/ FXL HUDQR VRWWRSRVWH SULPD GHOO·DFTXLVL]LRQH1 1HO 4:8: YHQQH LVWLWXLWR XQ PDJLVWUDWR/ WUDVIRUPDWR QHO 4::5 LQ VXSUHPD JLXQWD GL JLXULVGL]LRQH/ SHU OD YLJLODQ]D VXOOD FRQGRWWD GHOOH DXWRULWj HFFOHVLD0 VWLFKH/ VXOOD FROOD]LRQH GHL EHQHILFL H VXOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHOOH RSHUH SLH1 9DQH IXURQR OH SURWHVWH FKH/ VRSUDWWXWWR LO SDSD &OHPHQWH ;,9 DYDQ]z LQ GLIHVD GHOOH SUHURJDWLYH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH H FRQWUR LO JLj ULFRUGDWR FRGLFH FLYLOH1 1HL SULPL WHPSL GRSR OD UHVWDXUD]LRQH VL HEEH/ SXU QHO FDPELDPHQWR GHL WHPSL/ XQD FHUWD FRQWLQXD]LRQH GHL WUDGL]LRQDOL LQGLUL]]L JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFL H VROR QHO 4;5; VL HEEH XQ DYYLR GL VHULH WUDWWDWLYH WUD 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD VHGH VXOOH TXHVWLRQL UHOLJLRVH18Q LQGXEELR HOHPHQWR GL WHQVLRQH IX/ LQ TXHVW·HSRFD/ OD FRQGDQQD D PRUWH/ SHU DVVRFLD]LRQH DOOD FDUERQHULD/ GHO VD0 FHUGRWH *LXVHSSH $QGUHROL/ HVHJXLWD VHQ]D FKH DOO·DFFXVDWR IRVVH DFFRUGDWR LO SULYLOHJLR GHO IRUR/ QRQRVWDQWH OH SURWHVWH GHO YHVFRYR H FKH OR VWHVVR SULYL0 OHJLR QRQ IRVVH/ DOO·HSRFD/ IRUPDOPHQWH DEROLWR1 /H WUDWWDWLYH IXURQR FRQGRWWH GDO FRQWH 5LFFLQL/ FKH JLXQVH D 5RPD QHO IHEEUDLR 4;5; ULHQWUDQGR/ QHO VXFFHVVLYR PHVH GL OXJOLR/ FRQ XQD EROOD HG XQ EUHYH GHO SRQWHILFH /HRQH ;,,/ FKH UHJRODYDQR OH QRPLQH GHL FDQRQLFL GHOOD FDWWHGUDOH H GHOOH FROOHJLDWH/ QHO VHQVR FKH L UHODWLYL GHFUHWL VDUHEEHUR VWDWL HPDQDWL GDL YHVFRYL/ PD OH GHVLJQD]LRQL VDUHEEHUR VSHWWDWH DO GXFD1 $L YH0 VFRYL 0 SL• GHO SDSD YLFLQL DO GXFD H SL• VHQVLELOL TXLQGL DOOH VXH HVLJHQ]H 0 HUD DOWUHVu GHOHJDWD/ SHU LO SHULRGR GL FLQTXH DQQL/ OD IDFROWj GL VDQ]LRQDUH L FRQ0 WUDWWL GL DOLHQD]LRQH H SHUPXWD GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL HQWUR LO YDORUH 0 SLXWWRVWR HOHYDWR 0 GL PLOOH VFXGL URPDQL/ SDUL D ROWUH 8 PLOD OLUH1 4XHVWH FRQFHVVLRQL YHQQHUR ULQQRYDWH GD 3LR 9,,,/ VXFFHGXWR D /HRQH ;,,/ D VHJXLWR GL XQ XOWHULRUH YLDJJLR GHO 5LFFLQL/ UHFDWRVL D 5RPD GDO IHE0 EUDLR DO VHWWHPEUH 4;5</ SHU UHFDUH JOL RPDJJL GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9 DO QXR0 YR SRQWHILFH1 $OOD VFDGHQ]D GHO 4;66/ OH IDFROWj GHL YHVFRYL LQ RUGLQH DOOH D0 ²²²²²²²² 68 &IU1 $1 0(5&$7,/ 5DFFROWD GL FRQFRUGDWL VX PDWHULH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH WUD OD 6DQWD 6HGH H OH DXWRULWj FLYLOL/ YRO1 4 +43<;04<47,/ 5RPD/ 7LS1 3ROLJORWWD 9DWLFDQD/ 4<871 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH = &RQFRUGDWR WUD *UHJRULR ;9, H )UDQFHVFR ,9 GXFD GL 0RGHQD VXO IRUR H DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL +4;74,/ SS1:6<0:7:1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH
44:8
OLHQD]LRQL GHL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL YHQQHUR/ GDO SDSD *UHJRULR ;9,/ SURURJDWH SHU XQ DOWUR TXLQTXHQQLR HG DQFRUD SHU XQ DOWUR WULHQQLR DOOD VFDGHQ]D GHO 4;6;1 ,Q TXHVWR SHULRGR/ SHU SRUUH VX EDVL SL• VWDELOL L UDSSRUWL IUD OD 6DQWD VHGH HG LO GXFDWR/ VL DYYLDURQR WUDWWDWLYH SHU OD VWLSXOD GL XQ YHUR H SURSULR FRQFRUGDWR FKH/ FRQGRWWH GDOO·RUPDL HVSHUWR FRQWH 5LFFLQL/ SRUWDURQR/ GRSR DOWHUQH YLFHQGH/ DOOD HPDQD]LRQH GL XQ EUHYH SRQWLILFLR/ GHO 63 DSULOH 4;74/ H GL XQ FRUULVSRQGHQWH HGLWWR GXFDOH/ GHO VXFFHVVLYR ; PDJJLR/ FRQ FXL YHQQH UHJRODWD OD TXHVWLRQH GHO IRUR HFFOHVLDVWLFR/ FRQ ODUJR VSD]LR DFFRUGDWR DL WUL0 EXQDOL VWDWDOL/ H GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL EHQHILFL YDFDQWL/ DIILGDWD DG XQD FRPPLVVLRQH IRUPDWD GD GXH FDQRQLFL GHOOD FDWWHGUDOH H GD XQ SURFXUDWRUH JRYHUQDWLYR/ VRWWR OD SUHVLGHQ]D GHO YHVFRYR1 /·DVSHWWR SROLWLFDPHQWH SL• VLJQLILFDWLYR HUD O·DEURJD]LRQH GHOOH QRUPH VHWWHFHQWHVFKH VXOOH PDQL PRUWH HFFOHVLDVWLFKH/ FKH LPSOLFDYD XQ DEEDQGRQR GHL WUDGL]LRQDOL LQGLUL]]L JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWLFL/ OLQHD GL WHQGHQ]D FRQIHUPDWD DQ0 FKH GDO PDQWHQLPHQWR GHO GLULWWR GL DVLOR QHL FRQYHQWL FKH/ SHU TXDQWR WHP0 SHUDWR GDO ULJXDUGDUH OH VROH SHUVRQH H QRQ DQFKH L EHQL GHL UHL/ H FRQ O·HVFOXVLRQH GL XQ OLPLWDWR QXPHUR GL UHDWL JUDYL/ WHVWLPRQLDYD VHPSUH OD SUH0 URJDWLYD GHOOD FKLHVD VXOOH DXWRULWj GHOOR VWDWR1 1HO 4;78/ D VHJXLWR GL XOWHULRUL WUDWWDWLYH/ OH IXQ]LRQL GHOOD FRPPLVVLRQH DPPLQLVWUDWULFH GHL EHQHILFL YDFDQWL YHQQHUR HVWHVH DQFKH DOO·DPPLQL0 VWUD]LRQH GHOOH FRQJUHJD]LRQL GL FDULWj/ RVSHGDOL/ RUIDQRWURIL/ RSHUH SLH1 1HO 4;7; LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FKH JLj QHO 4;63 VL HUD LQJUDQGLWR FRQ LO WHUULWRULR GHO GXFDWR GL 0DVVD/ IX XOWHULRUPHQWH DFFUHVFLXWR FRQ *XDVWDOOD/ )LYL]]DQR HG DOFXQH WHUUH JLj SDUPHQVL1 3UHQGHQGR VSXQWR GDOO·HVLJHQ]D GL XQLIRUPDUH/ LQ WXWWL L VXRL WHUULWRUL/ OD GLVFLSOLQD FRQFHUQHQWH L UDSSRUWL IUD VWDWR H FKLHVD/ LQ TXDQWR QHL WHUULWRUL GL QXRYD DFTXLVL]LRQH YLJHYDQR OH QRUPDWLYH SUHFH0 GHQWL O·DQQHVVLRQH/ LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ VDOLWR DO WURQR QHO 4;79/ LQFDULFz QHO 4;83 LO PLQLVWUR GHJOL HVWHUL/ FRQWH )RUQL/ GL ULDSULUH OH WUDWWDWLYH FRQ OD 6DQWD VHGH/ FKH YHQQHUR FRQGRWWH D 5RPD GD *LRYDQQL *DOYDQL1 ,QWHQ]LRQH GL )UDQFHVFR 9 HUD TXHOOD GL OLPLWDUH LO GLULWWR GL DVLOR/ IHUPDUH OD SUROLIHUD]LRQH GHOOH PDQL PRUWH HG RWWHQHUH XOWHULRUL FRQFHVVLRQL LQ WHPD GL EHQHILFL HFFOH0 VLDVWLFL1 ,O 57 IHEEUDLR 4;84 YHQQH SURPXOJDWR XQ HGLWWR GXFDOH FKH/ VRWWR OD IRUPD GHOO· HVWHQVLRQH DL WHUULWRUL GL QXRYD DFTXLVL]LRQH GHOOH GLVSRVL]LRQL GHO FRQFRUGDWR GHO 4;74/ LQWURGXFHYD DG HVVR/ FRO FRQVHQVR SDSDOH/ LQQRYD]LRQL QHO VHQVR GHOOD IRUWH OLPLWD]LRQH GHO GLULWWR GL DVLOR H GL XQD PHQR IRUWH OLPL0 WD]LRQH GHL SULYLOHJL GL IRUR HFFOHVLDVWLFR1 &LUFD OH PDQL PRUWH/ LO GXFD ULXVFL0 YD DG RWWHQHUH FKH L ODVFLWL H GRQD]LRQL SLH IRVVHUR OLPLWDWL DOOD VROD PHWj GL
44:9
/XLJL /RQGHL ² 0DULQD 0RUHQD
TXDQWR GLVSRVWR GDO WHVWDWRUH R GDO GRQDQWH1 'XUDQWH OH WUDWWDWLYH VL HUD LQROWUH SDUODWR GL XQ DOWUR LPSRUWDQWH DUJRPHQ0 WR/ H FLRq O·HUH]LRQH GL 0RGHQD LQ DUFLYHVFRYDGR69= LO GXFD DYUHEEH GHVLGHUD0 WR FKH OD QXRYD HQWLWj DYHVVH/ FRPH VXIIUDJDQHH OH GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR/ &DUSL/ 0DVVD H *XDVWDOOD1 /·RSHUD]LRQH LPSOLFDYD LO GLVWDFFR GL 5HJJLR GDOOD PHWUR0 SROLWDQD GL %RORJQD H TXHOOR GL 0DVVD GDOOD PHWURSROLWDQD GL 3LVD1 ,Q UHDOWj/ DOOD SULPD YDFDQ]D GHOO·DUFLGLRFHVL GL %RORJQD/ QHO 4;88/ YHQQH HUHWWD OD QXR0 YD DUFLGLRFHVL GL 0RGHQD FRQ VXIIUDJDQHH 5HJJLR/ &DUSL H *XDVWDOOD1 /·XOWLPR DWWR GL XQ TXDOFKH ULOLHYR QHL UDSSRUWL IUD 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD VH0 GH IX O·DFFRUGR GHO 4;8: 6:UHODWLYR DG DOFXQH FDWHJRULH GL EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ LQ RUGLQH DL TXDOL LO GXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ DXWRUL]]DWR GD XQ EUHYH SRQWLILFLR GHO 56 JLXJQR/ HPDQz LO 47 QRYHPEUH XQ HGLWWR LQ IRU]D GHO TXDOH OH GRWD]LRQL GXFD0 OL DJOL RUGLQL UHOLJLRVL PRGHQHVL QRQ SRWHYDQR HVVHUH/ VHQ]D DXWRUL]]D]LRQH/ DVVHJQDWH D FRQJUHJD]LRQL/ DQFKH GHO PHGHVLPR RUGLQH/ HVLVWHQWL LQ XQ DOWUR VWDWR/ PHQWUH SRWHYDQR HVVHUH D WDOH VFRSR SHUPXWDWH GD XQ RUGLQH DOO·DOWUR1 (UDQR LQROWUH DWWULEXLWL LQ OLEHUD SURSULHWj DOOD &DPHUD GXFDOH WXWWL L EHQL HF0 FOHVLDVWLFL DPPLQLVWUDWL GDOOD VWHVVD &DPHUD1 $YHYD FRVu WHUPLQH XQD YLFHQGD FKH/ SDUWLWD GD LQGLUL]]L JLXULVGL]LRQDOLVWL H GL FRQWUDSSRVL]LRQH DOOD FXULD UR0 PDQD/ VHJQDYD/ QHO VHFROR ;,; XQD SDUDEROD GL ULHQWUR GHO GXFDWR GL 0RGH0 QD QHOOD SL• ULJRURVD RUWRGRVVLD URPDQD/ LQ DUPRQLD/ GHO UHVWR/ FRQ JOL LQGL0 UL]]L UHD]LRQDUL DVVXQWL GDOOR VWHVVR GXFDWR LQ TXHO VHFROR1 ²²²²²²²² 69
&IU1 $5&+,9,2 6(*5(72 9$7,&$12/ 6HJU1 6WDWR/ (S1 0RGHUQD/ Q1 5:7/ FF1 4<60594= LO 6H0 JUHWDULR GHOOD 61 &RQJUHJD]LRQH FRQFLVWRULDOH 5XJJHUR $QWLFL 0DWWHL VFULYH DO 6HJUHWDULR GL 6WDWR FDUGLQDOH $QWRQHOOL LQ GDWD 5: DJRVWR 4;88 FLUFD O·DSSURYD]LRQH GD SDUWH GHO SRQWHILFH GHOOD IRUPD]LRQH GL XQD QXRYD SURYLQFLD HFFOHVLDVWLFD PRGHQHVH LQQDO]DQGR OD VHGH GL 0RGHQD DO UDQJR H SUHURJDWLYH GL PHWURSROLWLFD/ FRQ VXIIUDJDQH OH FKLHVH GL 5HJJLR/ 0DVVD/ &DUSL/ GDOOD VRJJH]LRQH GHO PHWURSROLWD GL %RORJQD >« @/ TXHOOD GL 0DVVD GDOOD VRJJH]LRQH GHO PHWURSROLWD SLVDQR/ H TXHOOD GL *XDVWDOOD GDOOD VRJJH]LRQH LPPHGLDWD GHOOD 61 6HGH DSRVWROLFD«&IU1 ,ELGHP/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH S1 55<1 ,O IDVFLFROR LQL]LD LQ GDWD < RWWREUH 4;85 H FRQWLHQH OD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D IUD LO GLSORPDWLFR FRQWH )RUQL H OD VHJUHWHULD GL 6WDWR QHOOD SHU0 VRQD GHO FDUGLQDOH $QWRQHOOL H ULIHULVFH OD ULFKLHVWD GD SDUWH GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD GL XQLUH DOOD GLRFHVL GL 5HJJLR WXWWH OH SDUURFFKLH FKH VL WURYDQR GL Oj GHO ILXPH (OVD +FKH VHJQDYD LO FRQ0 ILQH WUD LO GXFDWR GL 3DUPD H 0RGHQD, H YLFHYHUVD TXHOOH DOGLOj GHOOR VWHVVR ILXPH/ GLSHQGHQWL GDO YHVFRYR GL 5HJJLR/ XQLUOH DOOD GLRFHVL GL 3DUPD1 6: &IU1 $1 0(5&$7,/ 5DFFROWD GL FRQFRUGDWL111 FLW1/ SS1 ;:90;;3/ %$FFRUGR WUD 3LR ,; H )UDQ0 FHVFR 9 GXFD GL 0RGHQD VX EHQL HFFOHVLDVWLFL +4;8:,%1 'D ULFRUGDUH LQROWUH FKH QHO 4;84 )UDQFHVFR 9 DYHYD VWLSXODWR XQ DOWUR FRQFRUGDWR FRQ LO SRQWHILFH 3LR ,; LQ FXL YHQQHUR FRQFHVVH GHOOH GLVSRVL]LRQL FKH VRQR YDOLGH D WXWW·RJJL= O·XQD UHODWLYD DOO·HOHYD]LRQH GHOOD VHGH YHVFRYLOH GL 0RGHQD D VHGH DUFLYHVFRYLOH H O·DOWUD LQ PHULWR DOOD FUHD]LRQH GHOOD SURYLQFLD HF0 FOHVLDVWLFD $WHVWLQD1 &IU1 /1 $0257+/ 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH1 6WRULD GHL VXRL GXFKL111 FLW1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 6DQWD 6HGH 44::
)LJ1 41 9HGXWD GHO 3DOD]]R GHOOD 0HVROD GDOOD SDUWH GL /HYDQWH1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44:<
$11$ %(//,1$==, ² )5$1&(6&2 0$57(//,
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD QHL FDUWHJJL SROLWLFL GHO 3ULQFLSDWR PHGLFHR
/H EUHYL ULIOHVVLRQL FKH LQWHQGLDPR SUHVHQWDUH ULJXDUGDQR OH IRQWL GRFX0 PHQWDULH SROLWLFR0GLSORPDWLFKH GHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL )LUHQ]H UHODWLYH DL UDSSRUWL IUD LO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD H OR 6WDWR (VWHQVH/ QHOOH VXH GXH FRQ0 ILJXUD]LRQL WHUULWRULDOL/ SULPD IHUUDUHVH/ SRL VRSUDWWXWWR/ LQ VLQWRQLD FRO WHPD GL TXHVWR FRQYHJQR/ PRGHQHVH1 5LJXDUGR DOO·DPELWR FURQRORJLFR SUHVR LQ HVDPH QHO QRVWUR LQWHUYHQWR/ OD QDWXUD H OD TXDOLWj GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ ROWUH DOOH VXH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH VWUXWWX0 UDOL/ KDQQR FRQVLJOLDWR GL LQFHQWUDUH O·DWWHQ]LRQH VX XQ SHULRGR GL SL• DFFHQ0 WXDWD YLWDOLWj GHOOH UHOD]LRQL GLSORPDWLFKH FKH/ FRP·HUD SUHYHGLELOH/ FRLQFLGH FRQ DOFXQH IDVL IRUWL GHO UDSSRUWR IUD L GXH 6WDWL/ FRPSUHVH IUD OD PHWj GHO &LQTXHFHQWR H TXHOOD GHO VHFROR VXFFHVVLYR1 3ULPD/ WXWWDYLD/ GL GDU FRQWR GL DOFXQH SRVVLELOL OLQHH GL ULFHUFD VXJJHULWH GDOO·HVDPH GHL FRQWHQXWL GRFXPHQWDUL GHJOL DUFKLYL SUHVL LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH/ YRUUHPPR/ DQFKH VH EUHYHPHQWH/ ULIHULUFL DOOH IRQWL QHO ORUR FRPSOHVVR= LQ TXHVWR FDVR/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ DOO·DUFKLYLR 0HGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ FKH DFFRJOLH 0 ULYH0 ODQGR IRUWL H VLJQLILFDWLYH DQDORJLH FRQ TXHOOR HVWHQVH 0 ROWUH DOOH FDUWH UHODWLYH DOOD IDPLJOLD H DOOD GLQDVWLD PHGLFHD/ O·DUFKLYLR GL JRYHUQR1 6·LQWHQGH LQ TXHVW·DFFH]LRQH TXHOOD SDUWH UHODWLYD DOOD GLUH]LRQH GHOOR 6WDWR QHL VXRL UDS0 SRUWL FRQ O·LQWHUQR H FRQ O·HVWHUR FKH DWWHQHYD GLUHWWDPHQWH DO VRYUDQR H FKH HJOL HVSOHWDYD DWWUDYHUVR VHJUHWDUL H/ IXRUL GHOOR 6WDWR/ WUDPLWH GLSORPDWLFL HG DPEDVFLDWRUL1 4XDOFKH PLOLRQH GL GRFXPHQWL GDOOD QDVFLWD GHO SULQFLSDWR PH0 GLFHR DOO·DYYHQWR GHL /RUHQD/ SURGRWWL TXDVL WXWWL LQ IRUPD HSLVWRODUH H RUGL0 QDWL FURQRORJLFDPHQWH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOH JUDQGL VHULH GHO IRQGR/ FKH UDSSUH0 VHQWDQR OD SULQFLSDOH WHVWLPRQLDQ]D DWWUDYHUVR OD TXDOH VHJXLUH OH ILOD GHOOD WUDWWD]LRQH SROLWLFD GHJOL DIIDUL1 'L TXHVWL/ OD SDUWH SL• FRVSLFXD H WUDGL]LR0 QDOPHQWH SL• FXUDWD VL SUHVHQWD LQ IRUPD GL FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD1
44;3
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
1HOOD ULIOHVVLRQH FRQGRWWD GD PROWL DQQL VXL FDUWHJJL SROLWLFL GHOO·HWj PR0 GHUQD/ FL KD VHPSUH FROSLWR FRPH OD IRUPD]LRQH GHL QXFOHL GRFXPHQWDUL SUR0 GRWWL VWRULFDPHQWH GDOO·DWWLYLWj GL JRYHUQR/ LQWHUQR HG LQWHUQD]LRQDOH/ GL DOFX0 QH JUDQGL FDVDWH UHJQDQWL/ SUHVHQWDVVH VXO SLDQR DUFKLYLVWLFR/ FDUDWWHUL QRQ GLVVLPLOL1 4XHVWR/ SXUWURSSR/ QRQ ULVXOWD DSSUH]]DELOH DWWUDYHUVR OD *XLGD JHQHUDOH GH0 JOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR/ GRYH O·DUFKLYLR 0HGLFHR/ QHOOD VXD VLQWHWLFD GHVFUL]LRQH/ UL0 PDQH TXDVL PLPHWL]]DWR H D PDODSHQD GLVYHODWR ULVSHWWR DOOD IOXHQWH HG H0 VSDQVD DQDOLWLFLWj GHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQWH YRFH PRGHQHVH4/ FXUDWD GD )LOLSSR 9DOHQWL FRQ OD FROODERUD]LRQH GL $QJHOR 6SDJJLDUL1 7XWWDYLD L GXH DUFKLYL/ PHGLFHR HG HVWHQVH/ DG XQ·DQDOLVL DQFKH VRPPDULD FRQGRWWD VXL ULVSHWWLYL VWUXPHQWL GL FRUUHGR/ UHGDWWL H SXEEOLFDWL TXDVL LQ VLQFURQLD/ ULYHODQR VRVWDQ0 ]LDOL DQDORJLH 51 $QDORJLH IRUWL/ OHJDWH DG XQD SDUDOOHOD HYROX]LRQH GHO UHJJL0 PHQWR SROLWLFR QHOOD IRUPD GL 6WDWR WHUULWRULDOH SULQFLSHVFR/ DOOD VLPLODULWj GHOOD VWUXWWXUD]LRQH LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ QRQFKp DOO·KXPXV FXOWXUDOH QHO TXDOH OH FDUWH VRQR VWDWH SURGRWWH61 $ FRQIHUPD GHO QHVVR SURIRQGR FKH OHJD IUD ORUR L JUDQGL DUFKLYL SULQFL0 SHVFKL IRUPDWLVL LQ SUHVHQ]D GL XQ YHUWLFH SROLWLFR GLQDVWLFDPHQWH VWDELOH/ SR0 WUHPPR ULFKLDPDUH DOWUL HVHPSL LWDOLDQL GRYH OD VHGLPHQWD]LRQH GRFXPHQWD0 ULD ULVSHFFKLD XQD FRQFH]LRQH GL JRYHUQR SULYDWLVWLFD HG DFFHQWUDWULFH/ QRQ PHQR FKH SDWULPRQLDOH/ GHO GRPLQLR FRPH SRVVHVVR HUHGLWDULR GHOOD IDPLJOLD ²²²²²²²² 4
&IU1 0,1,67(52 3(5 , %(1, &8/785$/, ( $0%,(17$/,/ 8)),&,2 &(175$/( %(1, $5&+,9,67,&,/ *XLGD JHQHUDOH GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR LWDOLDQL/ GLUHWWRUL 3,(52 '·$1*,2/,1,/ &/$8',2 3$921(/ ,,/ 5RPD/ 0%&$/ 8&%$/ 4<;6/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH DOOH SS1 9909: +$6 ),/ 0HGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR,/ SS1 433604349 +$602/ $UFKLYLR VHJUHWR HVWHQVH,1 5 &IU1 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', ),5(1=(/ $UFKLYLR PHGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR1 ,QYHQWDULR VRPPDULR/ 5RPD/ 0LQLVWHUR GHOO·,QWHUQR/ 3XEEOLFD]LRQL GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR/ ,/ 4<84> $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', 02'(1$/ $UFKLYLR VHJUHWR HVWHQVH/ VH]LRQH ´&DVD H 6WDWRµ1 ,QYHQWDULR/ D FXUD GL )1 9$/(17,/ 0LQLVWHUR GHOO·,QWHUQR/ 3XEEOLFD]LRQL GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR/ ;,,,/ 5RPD/ 4<861 6 &L ULIHULUHPR/ SHU ULFKLDPDUH VROR GXH HVHPSL GHL SL• QXPHURVL FKH SRWUHEEHUR HVVHUH IDWWL/ D GXH JUDQGL SDUWL]LRQL GHOO·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVH FKH ULFKLDPDQR QHOOH WLWROD]LRQL VWHVVH/ RO0 WUH FKH QHOOH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH FRPSOHVVLYH GHO GHSRVLWR GRFXPHQWDULR/ VHULH FRQ GRFXPHQWD0 ]LRQH VLPLODUH QHOO·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR> LQ SDUWLFRODUH DOO·LQWHUQR GHOOD ´&DQFHOOHULDµ GHOO·$UFKLYLR HVWHQVH/ DOOD VH]LRQH µ,QWHUQRµ/ OD JUDQGH VHULH GHL &DUWHJJL GHL UHWWRUL GHOOR 6WDWR/ FXL ID GD FRUULVSHWWLYR QHOO·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR/ TXHOOD GHL *RYHUQL GL FLWWj H OXRJKL VRJJHWWL1 $QDOR0 JDPHQWH/ DOOD PRQXPHQWDOH VHULH GHL &DUWHJJL GL RUDWRUL/ DJHQWL/ H FRUULVSRQGHQWL SUHVVR OH FRUWL/ SDUWH LQWHJUDQWH GHOOD VH]LRQH ´(VWHURµ GL 0RGHQD/ FRUULVSRQGH/ QHOO·DUFKLYLR ILRUHQWLQR/ O·DOWUHWWDQWR FRVSLFXD VHULH GHOOH 5HOD]LRQL FRQ 6WDWL LWDOLDQL HG HVWHUL1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44;4
VRYUDQD1 /H GLIIHUHQ]H/ FKH SXUH QRQ PDQFDQR/ FL VHPEUDQR SHUz DVFULYLELOL QRQ WDQWR DOOD IDVH GL IRUPD]LRQH GHL GLYHUVL QXFOHL GRFXPHQWDUL H/ SHUWDQWR/ DOOD YLFHQGD SROLWLFD GL PHGLR H OXQJR SHULRGR/ TXDQWR/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ DL GLYHUVL LWLQHUDUL VHJXLWL GD TXHVWL DUFKLYL QHO SHUFRUVR GHOOD WUDVPLVVLRQH GRFXPHQWD0 ULD17 /H VHULH UHODWLYH DOOD SROLWLFD HVWHUD VRQR VLFXUDPHQWH/ DOO·LQWHUQR GHOO·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR/ TXHOOH SL• RUJDQLFDPHQWH VWUXWWXUDWH/ H SDOHVDQR O·DWWHQ]LRQH GHJOL DQWLFKL RUGLQDWRUL TXDVL DOO·DWWR VWHVVR GHO GHSRVLWR81 $ TXH0 VWD FRPSOHWH]]D HG RUJDQLFLWj GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH QRQ FRUULVSRQGH SHUz/ D QRVWUR DYYLVR/ D WXWW·RJJL/ XQ·DGHJXDWD FRQRVFHQ]D GHL FRQWHQXWL GRFXPHQWD0 UL1 9DOJD/ SHU LO UDSSRUWR IUD L 0HGLFL H JOL (VWH/ OD VFDUVH]]D GHJOL VWXGL GL0 VSRQLELOL/ VH QRQ IRUVH VXOO·DQQRVD/ SHUDOWUR GRFXPHQWDWLVVLPD/ TXHVWLRQH GHO0 OH SUHFHGHQ]H FKH VL DYYDOH GL XQ GLVFUHWR YHQWDJOLR GL VWXGL RJJL/ WXWWDYLD/ DEEDVWDQ]D GDWDWL1 9 ²²²²²²²² 7 6L SHQVL DJOL HVHPSL GL 0DQWRYD H 3DUPD GD XQ ODWR/ L FXL DUFKLYL SULQFLSHVFKL SUHVHQWD0 QR DQFRU RJJL XQD VWUXWWXUD FRPSOHVVLYD FKH OL DSSDUHQWD D TXHOOL GL )LUHQ]H H 0RGHQD/ H GL 0LODQR HG 8UELQR GDOO·DOWUR/ FKH KDQQR YLVWR LQYHFH/ IUD 6HWWH HG 2WWRFHQWR/ XQ FRPSOHWR VFRQYROJLPHQWR GHO SURSULR VWRULFR RUGLQDPHQWR/ H XQD SDUDOOHOD ULFRVWUX]LRQH VHFRQGR VFKHPL WHRULFL EDVDWL VX HVWULQVHFL FULWHUL FODVVLILFDWRUL 1 6X TXHVWL WHPL/ VL YHGDQR OH FRQVLGH0 UD]LRQL GL $1 %(//,1$==,/ &1 /$0,21,/ &DUWHJJL SROLWLFL GHOO·HWj PRGHUQD= DSSXQWL FULWLFL H GL PHWRGR1 /·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ LQ 'DJOL DUFKLYL DOO·$UFKLYLR1 $SSXQWL GL VWRULD GHJOL DUFKLYL ILRUHQWLQL/ D FXUD GL &1 9,92/,/ )LUHQ]H/ (GLILU/ 4<<4/ SS1 8609;1 3HU XQ VLQWHWLFR PD SXQWXDOH TXDGUR G·DVVLHPH GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH G·LQWHUHVVH GLSORPDWLFR FRQVHUYDWD QHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR LWDOLDQL/ FIU1 31 &$58&&,/ /D GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR SHU OD VWRULD GHOOH UHOD]LRQL LQWHUQD0 ]LRQDOL/ LQ )RQWL GLSORPDWLFKH LQ HWj PRGHUQD H FRQWHPSRUDQHD/ $WWL GHO &RQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH/ /XFFD/ 53058 JHQQDLR 4<;</ 5RPD/ 0LQLVWHUR SHU L %HQL &XOWXUDOL H $PELHQWDOL/ 8IILFLR &HQWUDOH %HQL $UFKLYLVWLFL/ 4<<8/ SS1 730891 8 /H VFDUQH QRWL]LH GLVSRQLELOL VXOOD IDVH GL IRUPD]LRQH GHOO·DUFKLYLR PHGLFHR IDQQR ULIH0 ULPHQWR FRQ FKLDUH]]D DOO·DWWLYLWj GL RUGLQDPHQWR FRQGRWWD YHUVR OD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR GD 8JR &DFLRWWL H/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ VXOOD ILQH GHOOR VWHVVR VHFROR/ GD )DEUL]LR &HFLQL VXL FDUWHJJL GL0 SORPDWLFL FKH DOO·HSRFD UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR JLj XQD UDFFROWD GRFXPHQWDULD FRVSLFXD1 6XOOD IDVH GL IRUPD]LRQH GHOO·DUFKLYLR PHGLFHR VL YHGD &DUWHJJLR XQLYHUVDOH GL &RVLPR , GH 0HGLFL/ $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL )LUHQ]H/ ,QYHQWDULR/ D FXUD GL $1 %(//,1$==,/ &1 /$0,21,/ )LUHQ]H/ *LXQWD 5HJLRQDOH 7RVFDQD0/D 1XRYD ,WDOLD/ 4<<5/ ,QWURGX]LRQH/ SS1 /,0/;;91 9 )UD JOL DOWUL/ FIU1 *1 021'$,1,/ /D TXHVWLRQH GL SUHFHGHQ]D WUD LO GXFD &RVLPR , GH· 0HGLFL H $OIRQVR ,, G·(VWH/ )LUHQ]H/ 5LFFL/ 4;<;> 31 *5,%$8',/ 4XHVWLRQL GL SUHFHGHQ]D IUD OH FRUWL LWDOLDQH QHO VHFROR ;9,1 &RQWULEXWR DOOD VWRULD GHOOD GLSORPD]LD LWDOLDQD/ LQ ©5LYLVWD GL VFLHQ]H VWRULFKHª/ , +4<37,/ ,;/ SS1 49704::> ;/ SS1 5:;05;8> ;,/ SS1 6770689> ,, +4<38,/ ,,/ SS1 ;:0<7> ,,,/ SS1 5380549> 9,/ SS1 7:807;8> 9,,/ SS1 5<06;> 9,,,/ SS1 45904741
44;5
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
/D GRFXPHQWD]LRQH SL• FRVSLFXD q FRQFHQWUDWD QHOOD VHULH ´5HOD]LRQL FRQ JOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL HG HVWHULµ H VXGGLYLVD WUD OH GXH WLWROD]LRQL GL )HUUDUD +48690 48<;, H 0RGHQD +GDO 48<; LQ SRL,1 4XHVWR ULRUGLQDPHQWR WRSRJUDILFR0 FURQRORJLFR GHOOH FDUWH/ PRGHOODWR VXOOH UDJLRQL GHOOD SURYHQLHQ]D HSLVWRODUH/ DSSLDWWLVFH LQHYLWDELOPHQWH O·HYLGHQ]D GHO TXDGUR LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ DQFKH LQ SUH0 VHQ]D GL XQ IRUWH/ LQ TXHVWR FDVR GUDPPDWLFR/ FDPELDPHQWR1 $QDORJDPHQWH/ VXO YHUVDQWH RSSRVWR GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH FRQVHUYDWD QHOO·DUFKLYLR HVWHQVH/ QRWLDPR FRPH OD FRQWLQXLWj GHOOD SUDVVL EXURFUDWLFD QHO GHSRVLWR GRFXPHQWDULR IDFFLD D PDOD SHQD UHJLVWUDUH LO GUDPPDWLFR WUDSDVVR GL ILQH &LQTXHFHQWR1 $OO·LQWHUQR GHOOH GXH VHULH GHOO·DUFKLYLR ILRUHQWLQR/ DWWLQHQWL DOOH OHJD]LRQL GL )HUUDUD H 0RGHQD/ OH FDUWH VRQR GLVSRVWH VHFRQGR OD VXFFHVVLRQH GHJOL DPEDVFLDWRUL UHVLGHQWL R VWUDRUGLQDUL1 &ROSLVFH FRQVLGHUDQGR L QRPL GHOOH SHUVRQH LPSHJQDWH/ OD TXDOLWj GHJOL DPEDVFLDWRUL VFHOWL QHO QRYHUR GHOOH IDPL0 JOLH DULVWRFUDWLFKH SL• YLFLQH H IHGHOL DO *UDQGXFD +5LFDVROL/ 6HUULVWRUL/ 3DQ0 GROILQL/ 0HGLFL, :1 (· G·DOWUD SDUWH WUDWWR VLJQLILFDWLYR GHOOD SROLWLFD GL &RVLPR ,/ QHO GHVLGHULR 0FRURQDWR GD VXFFHVVR0 GL OHJLWWLPDUH OD GLQDVWLD FRVu UHFHQ0 WHPHQWH FRQVROLGDWD H GL FRVWUXLUH XQD SUHFLVD H IRUWH LGHQWLWj LQWHUQD]LRQDOH DO VXR 6WDWR/ OD JUDQGH DWWHQ]LRQH SUHVWDWD QHOO·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOH UDSSUH0 VHQWDQ]H HVWHUH;1 8Q DVSHWWR FXUDWR PROWLVVLPR DQFKH GDJOL (VWHQVL/ FKH XWLOL]]DYDQR FRP·q QRWR OD GLSORPD]LD SHU LQVHULUVL H PDQWHQHUVL QHO FRPSOHVVR JLXRFR GL HTXLOL0 EUL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL/ DOOR VFRSR GL FRPSHQVDUH OD VHPSUH SL• HYLGHQWH GLPLQX0 ]LRQH GHO ORUR SHVR SROLWLFR <1 ²²²²²²²² : 4XHVWL HOHPHQWL ULVDOWDQR LQ PDQLHUD DVVDL HYLGHQWH GDJOL VSRJOL GHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HWWHFHQWR +,QGLFH GHOOD VHJUHWHULD YHFFKLD/ 71 ,,,/ /HJD]LRQL LWDOLDQH/ )HUUDUD H 0RGHQD, FKH ULSRUWLD0 PR LQ $SSHQGLFH D TXHVWR LQWHUYHQWR1 ; /·DOWR SURILOR GHL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GLSORPDWLFL SUHVFHOWL GD &RVLPR , q JLXVWDPHQWH VRWWR0 OLQHDWR FRQ IRU]D GD $OHVVDQGUD &RQWLQL LQ XQ LPSRUWDQWH VDJJLR VXOOD GLSORPD]LD PHGLFHD QHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ GL LPPLQHQWH SXEEOLFD]LRQH +$1 &217,1,/ $VSHFWV RI 0HGLFHDQ 'LSORPDF\ LQ WKH 6L[WHHQWK &HQWXU\/ LQ 3ROLWLFV DQG 'LSORPDF\ LQ (DUO\ 0RGHUQ ,WDO\= WKH 6WUXFWXUH RI 'LSORPDWLF 3UDFWLFH/ 478304;33/ D FXUD GL '1 )5,*2/ GL SURVVLPD SXEEOLFD]LRQH SHU OD &DPEULGJH 8QLYHUVLW\ 3UHVV/ /RQGRQ,1 'HVLGHULDPR ULQJUD]LDUH VHQWLWDPHQWH O·DPLFD H FROOHJD $OHVVDQ0 GUD &RQWLQL SHU DYHUFL PHVVR D GLVSRVL]LRQH LO WHVWR GHO VXR ODYRUR1 6XOO·LPSHJQDWLYD HG DELOH VWUDWHJLD PHVVD LQ RSHUD GD &RVLPR , SHU LO UDIIRU]DPHQWR GHO VXR 6WDWR QHO SDQRUDPD LQWHU0 QD]LRQDOH/ q DQFRUD XQ YDOLGR WHUPLQH GL ULIHULPHQWR O·HGL]LRQH/ ULYHGXWD H DJJLRUQDWD/ GL *1 63,1,/ &RVLPR , GH· 0HGLFL H O·LQGLSHQGHQ]D GHO SULQFLSDWR PHGLFHR/ )LUHQ]H/ 9DOOHFFKL/ 4<;31 < &IU1 *1 2*1,%(1(/ /H UHOD]LRQL GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH FROO·HVWHUR/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD 5HJLD
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44;6
$O GL Oj GL TXHVWH VLPLOLWXGLQL/ YD SHUz ULPDUFDWD OD GLYHUVLWj GHOOD YLFHQGD GHL GXH 6WDWL QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO &LQTXHFHQWR1 8QD GLYHUVLWj FKH q WDOH GD IDU VFULYHUH DG $OHVVDQGUD &RQWLQL 43GL XQD ´SDUDEROD URYHVFLDWD ´ GD SDUWH GHL GXH 6WDWL QHJOL HTXLOLEUL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL GHOO·HSRFD1 ´8QR 6WDWR UDIIRU]DWR 0 TXHOOR PHGLFHR0 FXL O·LQWUDSUHQGHQ]D H LO GHQDUR/ QRQFKp OD VDSLHQ]D GHOOD PHGLD]LRQH/ IUXWWDYDQR XQR VSD]LR QXRYR/ JLXULGLFDPHQWH ULFRQRVFLXWR ´> XQD SDUDEROD GLVFHQGHQWH QHO FDVR GHJOL (VWH/ FXL QRQ EDVWDURQR L PDJJLRUL WLWROL Qp OD SL• FDYDOOHUHVFD QRELOWj/ SHU RVWDFRODUH OD FDGXWD GL SUHVWLJLR/ FKH LQWUHFFLDQGRVL D VFHOWH GL FDPSR QRQ YLQFHQWL H DG LQL]LDWLYH GLSORPDWLFKH VFDUVDPHQWH RFXODWH GD SDUWH GHOO·XOWLPR 'XFD IHUUDUHVH +WUDGL]LRQDOH DOOHDQ0 ]D IUDQFHVH/ SROLWLFD YHUVR LO SDSDWR, QRQFKp LQ XOWLPD DQDOLVL D YLFHQGH GL WL0 SR VWUHWWDPHQWH ELRORJLFR/ SRUWz DOOD ILQH DOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DO SDSD0 WR1 3HU FRQWUR/ GD SDUWH PHGLFHD VL UHJLVWUDYDQR QHO IUDWWHPSR FRQVLVWHQWLV0 VLPL LQJUDQGLPHQWL WHUULWRULDOL/ FRQ OD FRQTXLVWD GHOOR 6WDWR GL 6LHQD QHO 488:/ SRL O·RWWHQLPHQWR GHO WLWROR JUDQGXFDOH +GDO SDSD QHO 489</ GDOO·LPSHUDWRUH QHO 48:9, 441 &RQ TXHVWR VXFFHVVR/ SUHSDUDWR PHGLDQWH XQ·LQWHQVD H VDSLHQWH FDPSDJQD SROLWLFR0GLSORPDWLFD D YDVWR UDJJLR/ L 0HGLFL ULVXOWDURQR QHOOD VR0 VWDQ]D SLHQDPHQWH YLQFHQWL QHOO·DFFDQLWD FRQWURYHUVLD VXO GLULWWR GL SUHFHGHQ0 ]D FKH OL DYHYD YLVWL LPSHJQDWL SURSULR FRQWUR JOL (VWH ILQ GDJOL DQQL TXDUDQWD GHO VHFROR1 8QD GLYHUVLWj/ TXHOOD IUD 6WDWR WRVFDQR HG HVWHQVH/ LQFDUQDWD DO SL• DOWR OLYHOOR GD TXHOOD FKH LQWHUFRUUH IUD L GXH GXFKL VWHVVL= GL DQWLFD QRELOWj FD0 YDOOHUHVFD H PLOLWDUH/ O·HVWHQVH/ FLUFRQGDWR GD XQD FRUWH VRQWXRVD H UDIILQDWD/ GHJQD GL XQ JUDQGH PRQDUFD> SULQFLSH QXRYR/ LO VHFRQGR/ HVSOLFLWR H OXFLGR VRVWHQLWRUH GHO SULPDWR GHO ´GLYHQWDUHµ ULVSHWWR DO ´QDVFHUHµ/ FRQ DWWRUQR D Vp XQ JUXSSR GL VHUYLWRUL H FROODERUDWRUL IHGHOL/ LQ PDVVLPD SDUWH QRQ FLWWDGL0 QL/ PD VHOH]LRQDWL IUD L FHWL HPHUJHQWL WHUULWRULDOL1 8QD GLYHUVLWj SURIRQGD GL FRVWXPL H PHQWDOLWj IUD OH FODVVL VXSHULRUL GHL GXH 6WDWL/ FKH HPHUJH LQ PDQLHUD QLWLGD GDO GHWWDJOLDWR ULWUDWWR GHOOD QRELOWj ²²²²²²²² 'HSXWD]LRQH GL 6WRULD 3DWULD SHU OH SURYLQFH PRGHQHVLª/ V1 9,,, +4<37,/ SS1 55606481 3HU UL0 IHULPHQWL ELEOLRJUDILFL SL• DJJLRUQDWL/ VL SXz IDU ULIHULPHQWR D 6WRULD GHJOL DQWLFKL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ D FXUD GL *1 *5(&2 H 01 526$/ %DUL/ /DWHU]D/ 4<<9/ HG LQ SDUWLFRODUH DO VDJJLR GL '1 )5,*2/ 3ROLWLFD HVWHUD H GLSORPD]LD= ILJXUH/ SUREOHPL H DSSDUDWL +SS1 44:0495,1 43 $1 &217,1,/ $VSHFWV RI 0HGLFHDQ111 FLWDWR1 44 6X TXHVWL WHPL SRUWDQWL GHOOD VWRULD GHOOR 6WDWR PHGLFHR DO WHPSR GL &RVLPR ,/ VL YHGD )1 ',$=/ ,O *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD1 , 0HGLFL/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD GLUHWWD GD *1 *$/$662/ ;,,,/ 7R0 ULQR/ 87(7/ 4<:9/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH LO FDS1 ,,1
44;7
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
IHUUDUHVH IDWWR GD 2UD]LR GHOOD 5HQD QHOOD VXD IDPRVD UHOD]LRQH VXOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH FRPSRVWD QHO 48;</ TXDQGR ULFRSULYD OD FDULFD GL VHJUHWDULR GL OHJD0 ]LRQH D )HUUDUD1 (· DSSHQD LO FDVR GL ULFRUGDUH TXL FRPH TXHVW·RSHUD GL 2UD0 ]LR GHOOD 5HQD VLD XQ UDUR HVHPSLR GL IRQWH GL WLSR GLSORPDWLFR ULJXDUGDQWH L UDSSRUWL 0HGLFL (VWH FKH VLD VWDWD RJJHWWR GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH H GL DPSLD XWLOL]0 ]D]LRQH QHJOL VWXGL VWRULFL 451 /D TXDOLWj H TXDQWLWj GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ FKH FUHVFH FRVWDQWHPHQWH SHU WXWWR LO &LQTXHFHQWR/ YD/ LQYHFH/ FRQWUDHQGRVL D SDUWLUH GDO YHUR H SURSULR GHFLVLYR VSDUWLDFTXH UDSSUHVHQWDWR GDOOD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOR 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR 461 3HU TXDQWR OH WHPDWLFKH SURSRVWH GD TXHVWR FRQYHJQR VXJJHUL0 VFDQR GL VSRVWDUH O·DQDOLVL VXO ;9,, VHFROR/ FL VHPEUD FKH OD VWRULD GHL UDS0 SRUWL IUD LO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD H LO 'XFDWR (VWHQVH D 0RGHQD QRQ SRVVD SUHVFLQGHUH GDOO·HVDPH GHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH VX )HUUDUD GHOO·XOWLPR VFRUFLR GHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ TXDQGR/ GLYHQXWD RUDPDL FHUWD O·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL XQD VXF0 FHVVLRQH GLUHWWD DO GXFD $OIRQVR/ GD SDUWH HVWHQVH VL PROWLSOLFDURQR JOL VIRU]L GLSORPDWLFL SHU FHUFDUH GL HYLWDUH OD VHPSUH SL• LQFRPEHQWH PLQDFFLD GHOOD SHUGLWD GL )HUUDUD1 ,Q TXHVWD IDVH LO VHFRQGR PDWULPRQLR 0HGLFL (VWH +LO SUL0 PR ULVDOLYD DJOL DQQL VHVVDQWD IUD /XFUH]LD GL &RVLPR , H $OIRQVR ,,, VDQFLVFH/ QHO 48;9/ XQ WHQWDWLYR GL ULQVDOGDUH L VHPSUH SUREOHPDWLFL UDSSRUWL IUD OH GXH GLQDVWLH/ LQ XQ PRPHQWR SHU JOL (VWH GL JUDQGH GLIILFROWj H GL DVVROXWD QHFHV0 VLWj GL WURYDUH DOOHDWL1 6L WUDWWDYD/ FRPH QRWR/ GHO PDWULPRQLR IUD 9LUJLQLD/ IL0 JOLD GL &RVLPR , H GHOOD VXD VHFRQGD PRJOLH/ &DPLOOD 0DUWHOOL/ H GRQ &HVDUH G·(VWH/ SDUHQWH GHO GXFD $OIRQVR ,, H FDQGLGDWR DOOD VXD VXFFHVVLRQH 471 /D GRFXPHQWD]LRQH ILRUHQWLQD q QDWXUDOPHQWH PROWR ULFFD QHO UHVRFRQWR GHOOH WUDWWDWLYH PDWULPRQLDOL/ FRVu FRPH ODUJR VSD]LR q GDWR DOOD GHVFUL]LRQH GHOOH IHVWH H DSSDUDWL GL ULFHYLPHQWR DSSURQWDWL D )HUUDUD SHU DFFRJOLHUH OD VSRVD1 ²²²²²²²² 45 5HOD]LRQH GHOOR 6WDWR GL )HUUDUD GL 2UD]LR 'HOOD 5HQD1 48;</ D FXUD GL *1 $*1(//,/ LQ ©$WWL H PHPRULH GHOOD GHSXWD]LRQH IHUUDUHVH GL VWRULD SDWULDª/ ; +4;<9,/ SS1 57:06551 6XO GHOOD 5H0 QD/ FIU1 'L]LRQDULR %LRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQL/ DOOD YRFH/ FXUDWD GD '1 72&&$)21',1 46 0HQWUH OD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD FRQ )HUUDUD/ GDO 486: DO 48<;/ RFFXSD 69 ILO]H +0HGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ ILO]H FRPSUHVH IUD L QQ1 5;:< H 5<47, TXHOOD VXFFHVVLYD FRQ 0RGHQD/ GDO 48<; DOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 6HLFHQWR 0 ULFRUGDQGR SHUz FKH GDO 4976 LO *UDQGXFD QRQ WHQQH SL• XQ DPEDVFLDWRUH UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD 0 QH RFFXSD LQYHFH 561 47 6XL PDWULPRQL 0HGLFL (VWH QHO &LQTXHFHQWR H VXOOH FLUFRVWDQ]H QHOOH TXDOL VL YHULILFD0 URQR/ FIU1 OH YRFL $OIRQVR ,, G·(VWH H &HVDUH G·(VWH/ H OD ELEOLRJUDILD LQ HVVH FLWDWD/ D FXUD ULVSHW0 WLYDPHQWH GL 51 48$==$ H 71 $6&$5,/ LQ 'L]LRQDULR ELRJUDILFR GHJOL LWDOLDQL/ +DG YRFHP,1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44;8
Ë DQ]L TXHVWR GHOOH GHVFUL]LRQL GL IHVWH H VSHWWDFROL/ SHU L TXDOL OD &RUWH H0 VWHQVH DQGDYD IDPRVD/ XQR GHJOL HOHPHQWL ULFRUUHQWL QHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GHJOL LQYLDWL ILRUHQWLQL/ OXQJR WXWWR LO FRUVR GHO VHFROR481 1HO JHQQDLR 48<;/ O·DPEDVFLDWRUH ILRUHQWLQR D )HUUDUD/ PDUFKHVH 0DOD0 VSLQD GL 7UHJJLDQD/ VHJXu LO GXFD &HVDUH H OD VXD FRUWH QHOOD QXRYD UHVLGHQ]D 0RGHQHVH/ PHQWUH D )HUUDUD IX LQYLDWR LQ PLVVLRQH VWUDRUGLQDULD XQR GHJOL HOHPHQWL GL PDJJLRU VSLFFR GHOOD VHJUHWHULD ILRUHQWLQD/ &XU]LR 3LFFKHQD/ SHU FRPSOLPHQWDUVL H PDQLIHVWDUH O·DSSRJJLR JUDQGXFDOH DO FDUGLQDOH $OGREUDQ0 GLQL/ QXRYR OHJDWR SRQWLILFLR QHOO·H[ IHXGR HVWHQVH1 1HOO·,VWUX]LRQH LPSDUWLWD LQ TXHVW·RFFDVLRQH DO 3LFFKHQD/ GRSR DYHUOR DYYHUWLWR GHOOD SDUWHQ]D SHU 0RGH0 QD GHOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH ILRUHQWLQR/ VL FRQIHVVD O·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL IRUQLUJOL/ FRP·HUD FRQVXHWXGLQH LQ TXHVWL FDVL/ QRPLQDWLYL GL UHIHUHQWL GL ILGXFLD ORFDOL/ GDWR 0 VL DIIHUPD QHOO·,VWUX]LRQH 0 FKH HUDQR SDUWLWL SHU 0RGHQD/ DO VHJXLWR GHO 'XFD/ L PLQLVWUL H JHQWLOXRPLQL ´SL• FRQILGHQWLµ FKH OD FRUWH WRVFDQD DYHVVH D )HUUDUD1 ( D TXHVWR SXQWR/ O·HVWHQVRUH GHOO·,VWUX]LRQH VL ODVFLD VIXJJLUH XQ LQ0 WHUHVVDQWH LQFLVR/ SRL FDVVDWR QHOOD UHGD]LRQH GHILQLWLYD/ FKH ULPDQGD GL FROSR DL EXUUDVFRVL UDSSRUWL DJLWDWLVL IUD OH FRUWL &RUWL HVWHQVH H PHGLFHD QHOO·DUFR GHO FLQTXDQWHQQLR SUHFHGHQWH= ´«VH SXU VL SXz GLUH FKH YH QH KDYHVVLQR DO0 FXQR >GL FRQILGHQWL@µ491 1HO FRUVR GHL GHFHQQL VXFFHVVLYL/ LO OLYHOOR JHQHUDOH GHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD FRQ 0RGHQD YD DVVHVWDQGRVL DWWRUQR DG XQ WRQR PLQRUH GL URXWL0 QH/ LQWHUYDOODWR GD VHPSUH SL• SUROXQJDWL SHULRGL GL YDFDQ]D QHOOD UHVLGHQ]D +493<04944/ 495;04965, ILQR D FKH/ FRO 4976/ O·DPEDVFLDWRUH UHVLGHQWH QRQ YLHQH GD SDUWH WRVFDQD SL• ULQQRYDWR H OH VXFFHVVLYH PLVVLRQL GL LQYLDWL VWUD0 RUGLQDUL ULJXDUGDQR/ SUHVVRFKp WRWDOPHQWH/ RFFDVLRQL ´GL FRPSOLPHQWRµ= DQ0 QXQFL H IHOLFLWD]LRQL SHU QDVFLWH R PDWULPRQL H FRQGRJOLDQ]H SHU GHFHVVL GL PHPEUL GHOOH GXH FDVDWH1 %HQ SULPD GL TXHVWD GDWD/ FRPXQTXH/ OR VYXRWD0 PHQWR GL FRQWHQXWL H OD SHUGLWD GL LPSRUWDQ]D/ DOPHQR DJOL RFFKL WRVFDQL/ GHOO·DPEDVFLDWD GL 0RGHQD/ DSSDUH FRQ WXWWD HYLGHQ]D1 *Lj QHO 4947 HUD DEL0 WXGLQH FRQVROLGDWD QRQ DVVHJQDUH SL• DO UHVLGHQWH XQ VHJUHWDULR GL OHJD]LRQH LQFDULFDWR GD )LUHQ]H/ PD ODVFLDUQH OD VFHOWD D GLVFUH]LRQH GHOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH VWHVVR/ GDWR FKH/ FRPH VL VFULYH QHOO·LVWUX]LRQH GL TXHOO·DQQR DO QXRYR UHVL0 GHQWH PRGHQHVH/ *LXOLR 0HGLFL/ ´QRQ KDYHQGR QRL RUGLQDULDPHQWH QHJR]LL ²²²²²²²² 48 6L YHGDQR/ VX TXHVWL DVSHWWL/ L UHJHVWL VHWWHFHQWHVFKL ULSRUWDWL LQ $SSHQGLFH DO SUHVHQWH VDJJLR1 49 0HGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ 596:/ F1 483Y1 3HU OH OHWWHUH VFULWWH GDO 3LFFKHQD DOOD VHJUHWHULD JUDQGXFDOH/ FIU1 LELG1/ 5<441
44;9
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
LQ TXHOOD &RUWH/ QRQ VLDPR VROLWL WHQHUYL VHJUHWDULR GHOO·DPEDVFLDWDµ 4:1 1p/ FRPH DYYLHQH LQ DOWUL FDVL/ O·LQDULGLWR FDQDOH GLSORPDWLFR DSSDUH VRVWLWXLWR R VXIILFLHQWHPHQWH LQWHJUDWR GD GLYHUVH IRUPH/ PDJDUL PHQR IRUPDOL]]DWH/ GL FRPXQLFD]LRQH H LQWHUPHGLD]LRQH WUD L GXH JRYHUQL1 5LVSHWWR DG XQ TXDGUR FRPSOHVVLYR VLIIDWWR/ FHUWR QRQ VWULGRQR OH FRQ0 VXHWH/ SLFFROH FRQWURYHUVLH GL FRQILQL FKH D SL• ULSUHVH FRQWLQXDQR DG DFFHQ0 GHUVL GDOOH SDUWL GL *DUIDJQDQD H /XQLJLDQD/ Qp OH ULFRUUHQWL TXHVWLRQL GL HWL0 FKHWWD/ VROR SDOOLGD H ORQWDQD HFR GHOO·DFFHVR FRQWUDVWR GL SUHFHGHQ]D FKH D0 YHYD RSSRVWR QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9, L GXFKL &RVLPR , GHL 0HGL0 FL H $OIRQVR ,, G·(VWH/ FRLQYROJHQGR/ ROWUH DJOL DOWUL 6WDWL GHOOD SHQLVROD/ OH FDQFHOOHULH LPSHULDOH/ SDSDOH H GHJOL DOWUL PDJJLRUL SRWHQWDWL HXURSHL1 6L LQGLYLGXDQR IRUVH GXH VROL PRPHQWL QHL TXDOL/ LQ GLSHQGHQ]D GD DYYH0 QLPHQWL HVWHUQL/ L UDSSRUWL WUD L GXH 6WDWL FRQRVFRQR XQD QHWWD LQWHQVLILFD]LR0 QH/ SXQWXDOPHQWH UHJLVWUDWD GDOO·LQILWWLUVL H GDOO·DFFUHVFHUVL GL WRQR GHOOD FRUUL0 VSRQGHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD1 ,O SULPR VL VLWXD QHO 4946/ TXDQGR GD 0RGHQD VL QHJz SHU TXDOFKH WHPSR LO SDVVDJJLR DOOH WUXSSH LQYLDWH GDO *UDQGXFD GL 7RVFDQD D VRVWHJQR GHO 'XFD GL 0DQWRYD/ PLQDFFLDWR GDO 6DYRLD1 'RSR PRPHQWL GL WHQVLRQH H TXDOFKH VFDUDPXFFLD VXL FRQILQL/ WXWWR DQGz SUHVWR D SRVWR/ FRQ O·DVVHQVR PRGHQHVH DO SDVVDJJLR GHOOH WUXSSH WRVFDQH/ GRYXWR QRQ WDQWR D WLPRUH SHU L 7RVFDQL/ TXDQWR DOO·LQWHUYHQWR RSHUDWR VXO GXFD &HVDUH GD SDUWH GHOOD 6SDJQD4;1 ,O VHFRQGR/ SL• VLJQLILFDWLYR PRPHQWR ULJXDUGD OH WUDWWDWLYH FKH SRUWDURQR DOOD FRQFOXVLRQH GHOOD OHJD IUD 7RVFDQD/ 0RGHQD H 9HQH]LD LQ DLXWR GL 2GR0 DUGR )DUQHVH/ GXFD GL 3DUPD H FRQWUR SDSD 8UEDQR 9,,, %DUEHULQL> FXL IHFH VHJXLWR OD FRVLGGHWWD ´JXHUUD GL &DVWURµ +497504977, 4<1 (SLVRGLR FHUWR GL FRUWR UHVSLUR/ LQ XQ DVVHWWR LWDOLDQR L FXL GHVWLQL HG HTXLOLEUL GLSHQGHYDQR RUPDL GD WHPSR GDL JLRFKL GHOOH JUDQGL SRWHQ]H HXURSHH/ H VXO TXDOH VL q VSHVVR LURQL]]DWR/ D SDUWLUH GDO IDPRVR JLXGL]LR GHO JUDQGH 0XUDWRUL> HSLVR0 ²²²²²²²² 4:
,ELG1/ 596</ FF1 536 H 6V1 ,ELG1/ 5<55/ OHWWHUH GHOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH WRVFDQR UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD/ *HUPDQLFR (UFRODQL +5 DSULOH 4944055 QRYHPEUH 4947,> 5<59/ OHWWHUH GHO *UDQGXFD H GHOOD VHJUHWHULD DOO·(UFRODQL +5; VHWWHPEUH 4943064 PDU]R 4947,1 4< ,ELG1/ 5<65= FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GL 'HVLGHULR 0RQWHPDJQL H %DUWRORPPHR 8JROLQL/ H OHWWH0 UH GL /RUHQ]R *XLFFLDUGLQL/ FRPPLVVDULR GHOOH WUXSSH LQYLDWH D 0RGHQD/ FRQ PLQXWH GL UL0 VSRVWD GHOOD VHJUHWHULD GDO IHEEUDLR 4975 DO JLXJQR 4976 H 5<67= FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GL 8JROLQR *ULIRQL H 'RPHQLFR 3DQGROILQL LQYLDWR VWUDRUGLQDULR H GL %HUQDUGR 0RQDQQL VHJUHWDULR FRQ PLQXWH GL ULVSRVWD GDO 49 JLXJQR 4976 DO 58 JLXJQR 49771 4;
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44;:
GLR FKH SHUz FRQVHQWu 0 SHU GLUOD FRQ )XULR 'LD]0 ´D TXHL FDSL GL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ DO FRPDQGR GL SLFFROL HVHUFLWL/ PDQRYUDQGR FRQWHPSRUDQHDPHQWH OH DUPL H OD GLSORPD]LD/ GL VHQWLUVL LPSURYYLVDPHQWH GL QXRYR JUDQGL FDSLWDQL H JUDQGL SROLWLFLµ531 &RQFOXGHUHPR TXHVWR QRVWUR LQWHUYHQWR ULFRUGDQGR FRPH VL DVVL0 VWD DWWXDOPHQWH D XQD ULSUHVD GHOO·DQDOLVL H GHJOL VWXGL VXOOH IRQWL GLSORPDWL0 FKH/ QRQ VROR FRPH VWRULD GHOOD GLSORPD]LD/ PD DQFKH FRPH VWRULD GHOOH LVWL0 WX]LRQL/ GHJOL DSSDUDWL H GHJOL XRPLQL/ GHOOD FXOWXUD SROLWLFD H JLXULGLFD/ ULSUHVD WHVWLPRQLDWD DQFKH GDO ULFFR FRQYHJQR LQWHUQD]LRQDOH GL /XFFD QHO 4<;< VXOOH IRQWL GLSORPDWLFKH LQ HWj PRGHUQD H FRQWHPSRUDQHD541 6L UHJLVWUD DQFKH/ LQ TXHVW·DPELWR/ XQD ULSUHVD GHOOH HGL]LRQL GLSORPDWLFKH/ SURVHJXLWH FRPXQTXH LQ WXWWR LO GRSRJXHUUD VXOOD OLQHD GHOOD JUDQGH WUDGL]LRQH GHOO·,VWLWXWR 6WRULFR ,WDOLDQR 551 ,Q TXHVWR FOLPD FL VHPEUD LPSRUWDQWH ULFKLDPDUH O·DWWHQ]LRQH VXOOD RSSRU0 WXQLWj GL DSSURIRQGLUH OD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOOH QXWULWH VHULH GRFXPHQWDULH FKH WH0 VWLPRQLDQR O·DWWLYLWj GLSORPDWLFD H OH UHOD]LRQL HVLVWHQWL IUD OH GXH GLQDVWLH H L GXH 6WDWL PHGLFHR HG HVWHQVH/ FRQVHUYDWH QHJOL DUFKLYL ILRUHQWLQR H PRGHQH0 VH> RSSRUWXQLWj FKH SURSULR GD TXHVWR FRQYHJQR SRWUHEEH WURYDUH LPSXOVR/ FRQ O·DYYLR GL XQ SURJHWWR GL HODERUD]LRQH GL VWUXPHQWL GL ULFHUFD SL• DQDOLWL0 FL/ PD VRSUDWWXWWR SL• PLUDWL/ ULVSHWWR D TXHOOL DWWXDOPHQWH GLVSRQLELOL1 ,QIDWWL/ QHOOH EUHYL ULIOHVVLRQL ILQRUD HVSRVWH DEELDPR IDWWR ULIHULPHQWR DG XQD VROD ²²²²²²²² 53
)1 ',$=/ ,O *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD111 FLW1/ S1 6:;1 *OL DWWL GHO FRQYHJQR OXFFKHVH VRQR VWDWL SXEEOLFDWL D FXUD GHOO·8IILFLR &HQWUDOH %HQL $UFKLYLVWLFL= FIU1 )RQWL GLSORPDWLFKH LQ HWj PRGHUQD H FRQWHPSRUDQHD«FLW1> VL YHGDQR DQFKH/ D WHVWL0 PRQLDQ]D GL XQD ULSUHVD GL LQWHUHVVH SHU JOL VWXGL GL VWRULD GLSORPDWLFD/ LQ XQD ULQQRYDWD SUR0 VSHWWLYD G·LQGDJLQH FRPSDUDWLYD FKH DEEUDFFL DQFKH OH ´LVWLWX]LRQL/ JOL DSSDUDWL/ JOL XRPLQL/ OD FXOWXUD SROLWLFDµ +'1 )ULJR,/ L EUHYL PD VWLPRODQWL VDJJL GHOOD VWHVVD )ULJR/ GL 01 %HODUGLQL/ $1 &RQWLQL/ &1 %LWRVVL +GHGLFDWL/ ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH/ D 0DQWRYD/ 6WDWR 3RQWLILFLR/ 7RVFDQD H *HQR0 YD, FRPSDUVL LQ ©/H FDUWH H OD VWRULD1 %ROOHWWLQR VHPHVWUDOH GHOOD 6RFLHWj SHU JOL VWXGL GL VWRULD GHOOH LVWLWX]LRQLª/ ,, +4<<9,/ 4/ SS1 47604951 55 6L SHQVL DG DOFXQH UHFHQWL HG LPSHJQDWLYH LQL]LDWLYH GL SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL HVWHVH IRQWL GL0 SORPDWLFKH/ TXDOL OH FRUULVSRQGHQ]H GLSORPDWLFKH YHQH]LDQH GD 1DSROL/ R LO SURJHWWR GL HGL0 ]LRQH GHOOH UHOD]LRQL H FRUULVSRQGHQ]H GHJOL DPEDVFLDWRUL PDQWRYDQL D 0LODQR QHOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO 4XDWWURFHQWR/ FRQGRWWR LQ FROODERUD]LRQH WUD O·8QLYHUVLWj GHJOL VWXGL GL 0LODQR/ O·8IILFLR &HQWUDOH %HQL $UFKLYLVWLFL +'LYLVLRQH 6WXGL H 3XEEOLFD]LRQL, H O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 0DQWRYD1 5LFRUGLDPR DQFKH XQ·LQL]LDWLYD FKH VL q DSSHQD DYYLDWD SUHVVR O·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL )LUHQ]H/ H SUHYHGH OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH/ LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ O·8QLYHUVLWj GL 3LVD/ GHOOD FRUUL0 VSRQGHQ]D GD 5RPD GHO FDUGLQDOH )HUGLQDQGR GHL 0HGLFL +IXWXUR JUDQGXFD )HUGLQDQGR ,, FRO SDGUH &RVLPR , H FRO IUDWHOOR/ )UDQFHVFR ,> XQD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D ILWWLVVLPD GL YDOHQ]H GL0 SORPDWLFKH/ DWWLQHQWL DL UDSSRUWL IUD OD FRUWH GL 7RVFDQD H TXHOOD SRQWLILFLD1 54
44;;
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
GHOOH VHULH GHOO·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ DQFKH VH VLFXUDPHQWH OD SL• LP0 SRUWDQWH SHU OR VWXGLR GHL UDSSRUWL GLSORPDWLFL PHGLFHR0HVWHQVL1 0D O·$UFKLYLR PHGLFHR/ SHU OH FDUDWWHULVWLFKH VWUXWWXUDOL FKH SUHVHQWD/ DQGUHEEH LQYHVWLJDWR LQ PROWH DOWUH GHOOH VXH VHULH/ GDOOH PLQXWH JUDQGXFDOL DL FDUWHJJL GHL VHJUHWDUL H GHL SULQFLSL PHGLFHL/ DOOH ´LVWUX]LRQLµ ROWUH FKH DO PDWHULDOH YH0 UR H SURSULR GHOOH OHJD]LRQL1 3DUWLFRODUPHQWH QHO &LQTXHFHQWR/ TXHVWR IRQGR ULIOHWWH/ LQIDWWL/ QHOOD VWUXWWXUD GHO GHSRVLWR GRFXPHQWDULR/ O·DQFRU VFDUVD IRU0 PDOL]]D]LRQH GHJOL DSSDUDWL GL YHUWLFH/ FKH HUDQR FRRUGLQDWL GLUHWWDPHQWH GDO VRYUDQR H DYHYDQR FRPSHWHQ]H QRQ VHPSUH FKLDUDPHQWH SUHFLVDWH1 6L VHQWH SHUFLz O·HVLJHQ]D/ FL VHPEUD/ QRQ WDQWR GL VWUXPHQWL SL• DQDOLWLFL GL TXHOOL RJJL HVLVWHQWL +FKH SHUDOWUR SHU DOFXQH VHULH GHO IRQGR VL VWDQQR JLj DSSURQWDQGR, 56/ TXDQWR GL XQD JXLGD0LQYHQWDULR FKH/ LQ TXHVWR FRPH LQ DOWUL WHPL GL ULFHUFD/ RIIUD XQ TXDGUR UDJLRQDWR H LO SL• SRVVLELOH FRPSOHWR GHOOH IRQWL GLVSRQLELOL/ WUDFFLDQGR LWLQHUDUL H VXJJHUHQGR OHJDPL H FROOHJDPHQWL IUD OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH1 ,Q TXHVWD SURVSHWWLYD/ QRQ VDUHEEH QHSSXUH VXIILFLHQWH DOODUJDUH O·LQGDJLQH DOO·LQWHUR IRQGR 0HGLFHR GHO SULQFLSDWR/ PD VL GRYUHEEHUR SUHQGHUH LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH DQFKH DOWUL DUFKLYL GL JUDQGH LPSRUWDQ]D H DG HV0 VR FRUUHODWL1 ,Q SULPR OXRJR OD 0LVFHOODQHD PHGLFHD/ XQ GHSRVLWR GRFXPHQWDULR VWUHWWDPHQWH FRPSOHPHQWDUH DOO·DUFKLYLR PHGLFHR/ PD DQFKH OD 3UDWLFD VHJUHWD/ FRQVLJOLR GL YHUWLFH GHO 3ULQFLSH/ DO TXDOH HUDQR VRWWRSRVWH OH TXHVWLRQL SL• GHOLFDWH H ULOHYDQWL DQFKH GL SROLWLFD HVWHUD/ OH &DUWH VWUR]]LDQH/ RYH VRQR FRQ0 IOXLWL/ LQ RULJLQDOH R LQ FRSLD/ QXFOHL GL FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GL ULOHYDQWH LQWHUHVVH DQFKH GLSORPDWLFR/ SURYHQLHQWL GD DUFKLYL VLD SXEEOLFL VLD SULYDWL1 '·DOWURQGH/ DQFKH PROWL DUFKLYL GL IDPLJOLD/ FKH KDQQR DYXWR WUD L ORUR PHPEUL GHJOL H0 VSRQHQWL GHOOD GLSORPD]LD R GHOO·DOWR IXQ]LRQDULDWR JUDQGXFDOH/ FRQVHUYDQR DO ²²²²²²²² 56 ,Q TXHVWR VHQVR q VWDWD DYYLDWD/ ILQ GDOOD PHWj GHJOL DQQL VHWWDQWD/ LQ FROODERUD]LRQH FRQ OD 5HJLRQH 7RVFDQD/ O·LQYHQWDULD]LRQH DQDOLWLFD H OD SXEEOLFD]LRQH GHO &DUWHJJLR XQLYHUVDOH GHO JUDQGXFD &RVLPR ,/ QXFOHR GRFXPHQWDULR FRPSUHQGHQWH ROWUH 5331333 OHWWHUH/ GL JUDQGH UL0 OLHYR DQFKH SHU OD VWRULD SROLWLFR GLSORPDWLFD/ VSHFLDOPHQWH LQ WXWWD OD SULPD IDVH GHO UHJQR GHO VHFRQGR 'XFD PHGLFHR/ GXUDQWH OD TXDOH OH VSHFLILFKH VHULH GHO FDUWHJJLR GLSORPDWLFR QRQ DSSDLRQR DQFRUD FKLDUDPHQWH GHOLQHDWH1 /D SXEEOLFD]LRQH GL TXHVW·LQYHQWDULR q VWDWD SURJUDPPDWD LQ 4: YROXPL/ GHL TXDOL VRQR JLj GLVSRQLELOL= &DUWHJJLR XQLYHUVDOH GL &RVLPR , GHL 0HGLFL/ YROO1 , H ,,/ D FXUD GL $1 %(//,1$==, H &1 /$0,21,/ )LUHQ]H/ *LXQWD UHJLRQDOH 7RVFD0 QD0/D 1XRYD ,WDOLD/ 4<;5 H 4<;9> YRO1 ,9/ D FXUD GL 91 $55,*+,/ )LUHQ]H/ *LXQWD UHJLRQDOH 7RVFDQD0(GLWULFH %LEOLRJUDILFD/ 4<<3> YRO1 9/ D FXUD GL &1 *,$0%/$1&2 H '1 72&&$)21',/ )LUHQ]H/ *LXQWD UHJLRQDOH 7RVFDQD0(GLWULFH %LEOLRJUDILFD/ 4<<3> YROO1 9,,, H ,;/ D FXUD GL 01 0259,'8&&,/ )LUHQ]H/ *LXQWD UHJLRQDOH 7RVFDQD/ 4<<3 H 4<<;1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44;<
ORUR LQWHUQR ² VL SHQVL/ SHU IDUH VROR GXH HVHPSL/ DOOH FDUWH 0DJDORWWL R DOO·DUFKLYLR 6HUULVWRUL 0 LPSRUWDQWL QXFOHL GRFXPHQWDUL UHODWLYL DL UDSSRUWL FRQ O·HVWHUR1 ,QILQH/ TXDVL RYYLD q OD PHQ]LRQH GHL 7UDWWDWL LQWHUQD]LRQDOL/ DUFKLYLR FRVWLWXLWR YHUVR OD PHWj GHOO·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·DYYLR GDOOD QDVFLWD GHO SULQFLSDWR PHGLFHR/ FKH q OD GDWD DOOD TXDOH VL DUUHVWD O·LQYHQWDULR GHO &DUWHJJLR ´0HGLFL0(VWHµGL 'HO 3LD]]R/ EUHYH JXLGD0 LQYHQWDULR DQWH OLWWHUDP GHOOH UHOD]LRQL PHGLFHR HVWHQVL FRQGRWWD VXL FDUWHJJL SROLWLFL GL HQWUDPEH OH GLQDVWLH FRQVHUYDWL QHL GXH $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR GL )LUHQ]H H 0RGHQD571
²²²²²²²² 57 01 '(/ 3,$==2/ ,O FDUWHJJLR ´0HGLFL0(VWHµ GDO VHFROR ;9 DO 48641 5HJHVWL GHOOH OHWWHUH FRQVHUYD0 WH QHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR GL )LUHQ]H H 0RGHQD/ +4XDGHUQL GHOOD ©5DVVHJQD GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWRª/ Q1 67/ 5RPD/ 0LQLVWHUR GHOO·,QWHUQR/ 4<97,1
44<3
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
$33(1',&( /D FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GLSORPDWLFD GHJOL LQYLDWL JUDQGXFDOL D )HUUDUD H 0RGH0 QD DWWUDYHUVR L VHWWHFHQWHVFKL 6SRJOL GHOOD 6HJUHWHULD YHFFKLD1 /·$UFKLYLR 0HGLFHR GHO 3ULQFLSDWR/ LO JUDQGH IRQGR FRPSUHQGHQWH/ LQ EHQ 975< YROXPL/ OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GL IDPLJOLD H GL JRYHUQR GHOOD FDVDWD JUDQGXFDOH PHGLFHD GDOO·DYYHQWR DO SULQFLSDWR DOOD VXD HVWLQ]LRQH +4865 0 4:6:,/ q VWDWR RJJHWWR/ D SDUWLUH GDO 6HWWHFHQWR/ GL XQD QXWULWLVVLPD VHULH GL LQWHUYHQWL GL GHVFUL]LRQH H LQYHQWDULD]LRQH/ FKH/ FRQGRWWL FRQ ILQDOLWj H PHWR0 GL GLYHUVL/ KDQQR SURGRWWR XQ DOWUHWWDQWR QXPHURVR HG HWHURJHQHR JUXSSR GL VWUXPHQWL GL FRUUHGR1 )UD TXHVWL/ XQ VLQJRODUH ULOLHYR ULYHVWRQR L 55 YROXPL GL 6SRJOL GHOOD 6HJUHWHULD YHFFKLD +WUDGL]LRQDOPHQWH FKLDPDWL ©6SRJOL URVVLª, HODERUDWL VX LQFDULFR JUDQGXFDOH GD 5LJXFFLR *DOOX]]L H )HUGLQDQGR )RVVL WUD LO 4::5 H LO 4::9/ FKH FRVWLWXLURQR OR VFDYR GRFXPHQWDULR VXOOD FXL EDVH OR VWHVVR *DO0 OX]]L HGLILFz LQ TXHJOL DQQL OD VXD PRQXPHQWDOH VWRULD GHOOD 7RVFDQD PHGL0 FHD581 2OWUH D IRUQLUFL XQ·LPPDJLQH G·LQVLHPH GHOO·DUWLFROD]LRQH H GHOO·DVVHWWR GHO FRPSOHVVR GHJOL DUFKLYL PHGLFHL/ JOL 6SRJOL FRQVHQWRQR XQ SULPR/ VSHVVR HIILFDFLVVLPR DSSURFFLR DOOD ULFHUFD/ SRLFKp RIIURQR SHU RJQL EXVWD GL GRFX0 PHQWL XQ SL• R PHQR VLQWHWLFR UHJHVWR GHL FRQWHQXWL H VRQR FRUUHGDWL GL SUH0 ]LRVH LQIRUPD]LRQL VWRULFKH1 1DWXUDOPHQWH/ QHOOD ORUR XWLOL]]D]LRQH ELVRJQD WHQHUH EHQ SUHVHQWH FKH VL WUDWWD GL GHVFUL]LRQL GL FRQWHQXWL FKH ULVSRQGRQR DG XQD VFHOWD/ VSHVVR DVVDL VHOHWWLYD/ HIIHWWXDWD GDL GXH FXUDWRUL VHWWHFHQWHVFKL IUD O·HQRUPH JDPPD GL DUJRPHQWL WUDWWDWL QHOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ FKH DP0 PRQWD D GLYHUVH FHQWLQDLD GL OHWWHUH SHU FLDVFXQD EXVWD1 9D DQFKH GHWWR/ G·DOWUD SDUWH/ FKH L FULWHUL GL VHOH]LRQH DGRWWDWL GD *DOOX]]L H )RVVL PHWWHYDQR LQ SULPD ILOD SURSULR L FRQWHQXWL LQHUHQWL L WHPL SROLWLFR GLSORPDWLFL/ YLVWL FR0 PH XQR GHL ILOL HVVHQ]LDOL DOOD ULFRVWUX]LRQH GHOO·RSHUDWR GL JRYHUQR GHOOD RU0 PDL HVWLQWD GLQDVWLD PHGLFHD1 , UHJHVWL FKH VHJXRQR VRQR WUDWWL GDOO·,QGLFH GHOOD VHJUHWHULD YHFFKLD/ WRPR ,,,/ /HJD]LRQL LWDOLDQH/ SS1 43<046: Y/ ´6SRJOLR GL FDUWHJJL H DIIDUL FRQ OD FRUWH GL )HUUDUDµ/ ´6SRJOLR H LQGLFH GL FDUWHJJL FRQ OD FRUWH GL 0RGHQDµ1 , UHJHVWL VRQR VWDWL WUDVFULWWL LQWHJUDOPHQWH59> DFFDQWR DOOD QXPHUD]LRQH LQ ²²²²²²²² 58 51 *$//8==,/ ,VWRULD GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD VRWWR LO JRYHUQR GHOOD FDVD 0HGLFL/ )LUHQ]H/ &DPELDJL/ 4:;41 59 'HVLGHULDPR ULQJUD]LDUH 'DQLHOD 7DWLQL SHU OD SUH]LRVD FROODERUD]LRQH SUHVWDWD QHOOD WUDVFUL]LRQH GHL UHJHVWL1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44<4
FLIUH URPDQH/ FKH FRUULVSRQGH DOO·DQWLFD QXPHUD]LRQH SHU VHULH/ HVLVWHQWH DOO·HSRFD GHJOL VSRJOL/ q VWDWR ULSRUWDWR WUD SDUHQWHVL LO QXPHUR DWWXDOH GL FLD0 VFXQD ILO]D/ FKH ULVSRQGH DOO·DWWXDOH RUGLQDPHQWR GHO IRQGR 0HGLFHR/ FRPH ULVXOWD GDOO·LQYHQWDULR D VWDPSD VRSUD FLWDWR1 6SRJOLR GL FDUWHJJL H DIIDUL FRQ OD &RUWH GL )HUUDUD , +)1 5;:<, /HWWHUH GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD GDO 4869 DO 486<= FRQFHUQHQWL FRQWURYHUVLH GL FRQILQL FRQ OD *DUIDJQDQD> SUHGH H GDQQL IDWWL VXL FRQILQL GDL ULVSHWWLYL VXGGLWL> FRQYHQ]LRQH GL UHVWLWXLUVL L EDQGLWL H L GHOLQTXHQWL1 1HO 4883= VFULYH DOOD 'XFKHVVD/ H JOL VSHGLVFH LO 3DJDQR SHUFKp WUDWWL H FRQFOXGD OD UHFRQFLOLD]LRQH WUD HVVR H LO 'XFD &RVLPR1 ,O 'XFD &RVLPR JOL ULVSHGLVFH 3LHU )LOLSSR 3DQGROILQL SHU TXHVWR HIIHWWR1 'RSR TXHVWD ORUR ULXQLRQH VL FR0 PXQLFDQR VFDPELHYROPHQWH OH QRWL]LH HG DOFXQH VRQR LQ FLIUD VRSUD O·DYYHOHQDPHQWR VHJXLWR LQ )UDQFLD GHO 'XFD GL *KLVD1 7UDWWDQR GHOOH FRVH GL 6LHQD/ H LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD QRQ DSSURYD OD ULVROX]LRQH SUHVD GDO 'XFD &RVL0 PR GL PXRYHU OD JXHUUD DL )UDQFHVL1 0DWULPRQLR IUD OD /XFUH]LD/ ILJOLD GHO 'XFD &RVLPR/ FRQ $OIRQVR ILJOLR GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD/ FRQFOXVR QHO JLXJQR GHO 488;1 /XQJKH OHWWHUH GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD GL VXR SURSULR SXJQR VRSUD OD UHVWLWX]LRQH GHOOH 3LD]]H GHOOR 6WDWR GL 6LHQD WHQXWH GD 'RQ )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH/ H VRSUD LO SURFXUDUVL GDO 'XFD &RVLPR OD UHFRQFLOLD]LRQH GHOOD FDVD GL )HUUDUD FRO UH GL 6SDJQD1 6L FRPXQLFDQR L QHJR]LDWL SHU O·HVHFX]LRQH GHOOD SDFH GHO 488</ QHO TXDO DQQR SRL PXRUH LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD (UFROH ,,/ H JOL VXFFHGH $OIRQVR VXR ILJOLR/ PDULWR GL /XFUH]LD GHL 0HGLFL1 ,, +)1 5;;3, /HWWHUH GL $OIRQVR 'XFD GL )HUUDUD D &RVLPR , VXR VXRFHUR H DO *UDQGXFD )UDQFHVFR/ GDO 4893 DO 48:<1 3DUODVL PROWR GHOOD PDODWWLD GHOOD 'XFKHVVD /XFUH]LD/ SHU FXL &RVLPR , VSHGu D )HUUDUD 0DHVWUR $QGUHD 3D0 VTXDOL/ VXR PHGLFR> PRUWH GHOOD PHGHVLPD QHO PDJJLR 48941 9L VRQR DOWUH OHW0 WHUH GL 3ULQFLSL GL TXHOOD FDVD/ WXWWH GL FRPSOLPHQWR/ UDFFRPDQGD]LRQH/ R DI0 IDUL GL SRFR PRPHQWR1 ,,, +)1 5;;4, &RQWLQXDQR OH OHWWHUH GHL 3ULQFLSL GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH GDO 48;3 DO 48;<1 3RFKH VRQR TXHOOH GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD/ SHUFKp SHQGHQWH OD FRQWUR0 YHUVLD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D VIXJJLYDQR WXWWH OH RFFDVLRQL GL FDUWHJJLR1 /D PDJ0 JLRU SDUWH VRQR GHO SULQFLSH $OIRQVR/ SDGUH GL 'RQ &HVDUH/ FKH IX SRL 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ H GL 'RQ &HVDUH PHGHVLPR1 &RQFHUQRQR LO PDWULPRQLR GHOOD SULQFLSHVVD (OHRQRUD GHL 0HGLFL FRO SULQFLSH GL 0DQWRYD/ LQ FXL IX PHGLDWRUH
44<5
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
LO GHWWR SULQFLSH $OIRQVR/ SDUWLFRODUPHQWH QHOO·DIIDUH GHOOD SURYD> LO PDWULPR0 QLR FRQFOXVR WUD 'RQ &HVDUH H 'RQQD 9LUJLQLD/ ILJOLD GL &RVLPR , H GHOOD &DPLOOD 0DUWHOOL/ QHO 48;81 ,O ULPDQHQWH VRQR FRPSOLPHQWL H FRPPHQGDWL]LH1 ,9 +)1 5;;5,&RQWLQXDQR OH OHWWHUH GHOOD &RUWH GL )HUUDUD GDO 48<3 ILQR DO 5: GL RWWREUH 48<:/ LQ FXL PRUu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·DPLFL]LD GHO 'XFD &RVLPR SHUFKp OR DLXWL DG HVVHUH HOHWWR 3DSD1 'HWWDJOLR PLQXWR GL WXWWH OH FR0 VH GL )HUUDUD> DYYLVL1 9, +)1 5;;7, &RQWLQXD LO FDUWHJJLR GHO %DEEL GD )HUUDUD QHOO·DQQR 4885/ FRQFHUQHQWH OD JXHUUD GL 3DSD *LXOLR 7HU]R FRQWUR LO 'XFD GL 3DUPD/ O·DVVHGLR GHOOD 0LUDQGROD H GL 3DUPD IDWWR GDO 9LWHOOL/ OD OHJD WUD LO 3DSD H O·,PSHUDWRUH/ H GHOO·DFFRPRGDPHQWR VHJXLWR WUD LO 3DSD H LO 5H GL )UDQFLD SHU PH]]R GHO &DUGLQDOH GL 7RXUQRQ1 ,O 'XFD &RVLPR FKLHGH DO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD LO SDVVR OLEHUR SHU OD *DUIDJQDQD GHL VDOL SHU LO FRQVXPR GL )LYL]]DQR1 'RSR ULWLUDWR OH WUXSSH GHO 3DSD/ VHJXLWDQGR FRQ PDJJLRU DUGRUH OD JXHUUD DOOD 0L0 UDQGROD H D 3DUPD WUD O·,PSHULDOL H L )UDQFHVL/ LO %DEEL LQIRUPD GL WXWWH OH FLU0 FRVWDQ]H GHOOD PHGHVLPD1 ,O 'XFD GL )HUUDUD H LO FDUGLQDOH VXR IUDWHOOR VRP0 PLQLVWUDQR JUDQGL DLXWL DL )UDQFHVL/ L TXDOL DFTXLVWDQR JUDQ SDUWLWR LQ ,WDOLD/ SHUFKp O·,PSHUDWRUH q WDUGR H QRQ SDJD OH VXH WUXSSH1 0DHVWUR *LXOLR 9HUL/ PHGLFR VDQHVL/ YD D )HUUDUD SHU WUDWWDUH FRQ TXHO FDUGLQDOH XQD FRQJLXUD SHU VFDFFLDUH JOL 6SDJQROL GL 6LHQD> FRQ HVVR YHQJRQR DOWUL FLWWDGLQL VHQHVL1/ FLRq *LRYDQQL 3ODFLGL/ *LRYDQQL 0DULD %HQHGHWWL/ H *LXVHSSH 7XWL1 5LVROX]LRQH
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44<6
GHL )UDQFHVL G·LPSDGURQLUVL GL 6LHQD SHU SDVVDUH SRL DOOD FRQTXLVWD GHO 5HJQR GL 1DSROL1 'LVHJQDQR SDULPHQWH G·LPSDGURQLUVL GL /XFFD SHU SRWHU SL• ID0 FLOPHQWH VRUSUHQGHUH LO 'XFD &RVLPR> GL WXWWH TXHVWH FRVH QH YLHQH HVVR DY0 YHUWLWR GDO 3HUR/ FKH HUD VHJUHWDULR GHO &DUGLQDOH GL )HUUDUD1 6ROOHYD]LRQH GL 6LHQD H FRQFRUGDWR IUD LO 'XFD &RVLPR H TXHOOD FLWWj1 , 6HQHVL HVVHQGRVL QXRYDPHQWH SRVWL VRWWR OD SURWH]LRQH GHO 5H GL )UDQFLD/ HJOL YL VSHGLVFH SHU VXR OXRJRWHQHQWH LO &DUGLQDOH GL )HUUDUD1 'RYHQGR YHQLUH D 6LHQD OR 6WUR]]L/ LO %DEEL FRQVLJOLD LO 'XFD &RVLPR D PHWWHU JHQWH LQ FHUWL SRVWL SHU DVVDVVLQDU0 OR1 9,, +)1 5;;8, &RQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OHWWHUH GHO %DEEL GD )HUUDUD DO 'XFD &RVLPR QHOO·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·DQQR 48871 &RQWHQJRQR OH VROLWH QRWL]LH VHJUHWH/ OD GLVFRUGLD WUD LO &DU0 GLQDOH GL )HUUDUD H 3LHUR 6WUR]]L/ JO·LQWULJKL GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD FRQ L )UDQFH0 VL1 &DUWHJJLR FXULRVR HW LQWHUHVVDQWH FKH GXUD ILQR DO 5: DSULOH 4888> LQ FXL LO %DEEL IX ULFKLDPDWR H VH QH WRUQz D )LUHQ]H1 6DOOXVWLR 3LFFRORPLQL/ UHVLGHQWH D )HUUDUD GDO 4894 DO 4896 ,; +)15;;:, 1RQ VL WURYD FKH LO 'XFD &RVLPR PDQGDVVH DOWUL 5HVLGHQWL D )HUUDUD/ FKH QHOO·DQQR 4894/ LQ FXL IX VSHGLWR FRQ TXHVWR LQFDULFR 6DOOXVWLR 3LFFRORPLQL1 3DUOD HJOL GHOOD FDXVD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D HG HVVHQGRVL GROXWR FKH L PLQLVWUL GL )HUUDUD QHL FRQVLJOL GHL GRWWRUL ODVFLDYDQ FRUUHUH GHOOH FRVH QRQ YHUH H SUHJLXGLFLDOL DOO·RQRUH GHOOD &DVD 0HGLFL/ TXHO 'XFD RUGLQD FKH GHWWL &RQVLJOL/ SULPD GL HVVHUH SXEEOLFDWL/ VLDQR PRVWUDWL DO 3LFFRORPLQL1 6L IDQQR FRQWLQXH GRJOLDQ]H GD DPEHGXH OH SDUWL VRSUD OH VFULWWXUH LPSURSULH FKH VL VWDPSDYDQR LQWRUQR OD FDXVD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D1 $YYLVL GHWWDJOLDWL GHOOH FRVH GL )UDQFLD/ GHO &RQFLOLR GL 7UHQWR H GHOOD &RUWH GL )HUUDUD1
44<7
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
%HUQDUGR &DQLJLDQL/ UHVLGHQWH D )HUUDUD GDO 4897 DO 48:< ; +)1 5;;;, /HWWHUH GL %HUQDUGR &DQLJLDQL/ UHVLGHQWH D )HUUDUD/ GHOO·DQQR 4897 H 48981 ,QIRUPD GHO PDWULPRQLR FRQFOXVR WUD TXHO 'XFD H O·$UFLGXFKHVVD %DUEDUD/ H OD JDUD QDWD FRQ LO 3ULQFLSH GL )LUHQ]H/ FKH HUD VSR0 VR GHOO·DUFLGXFKHVVD *LRYDQQD/ PLQRUH GHOOD VXGGHWWD> FKL GHL GXH DYHVVH D0 YXWR GDOO·,PSHUDWRUH OD VSRVD D VFHOWD/ SUHWHQGHQGR LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD/ FKH LO SULQFLSH GL )LUHQ]H DYHVVH RWWHQXWR TXHOOD FKH HUD VWDWD ULFXVDWD GD OXL1 ,O 'X0 FD GL )HUUDUD/ HVVHQGR VWDWR FLWDWR D 5RPD GD 3LR 9 D FRQWR GHL VDOL VRWWR OD SHQD GL 433 PLOD VFXGL/ VRVSHWWD FKH TXHVWR FROSR JOL YHQJD GDO 'XFD GL )L0 UHQ]H1 &RUUH YRFH FKH LO 3DSD YRJOLD GDUH DO 'XFD &RVLPR ,PROD H )RUOu/ VXO0 OH TXDOL FLWWj HVVR DYHYD GLULWWR SHU OD GRWH GL &DWHULQD 5LDULD VXD DYROD1 &RQ0 JLXUD VFRSHUWD FRQWUR LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD1 'HVFUL]LRQH GL IHVWH VROLWH IDUVL LQ )HUUDUD/ H IDWWH LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOH QR]]H GHO 'XFD FRQ O·$UFLGXFKHVVD %DUED0 UD1 ;, +)1 5;;<, &RQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OHWWHUH GHO &DQLJLDQL GHO 4898 H 4899/ FRQFHUQHQWL O·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q IUD )DSSRQHLFKR/ YLOOD GHO IHXGR GL 9DUDQR/ FRQ &DVWLJOLRQH GHO 7HU]LHUH1 $UUHVWR GHO &DSLWDQR 'RPH0 QLFR 7RQHOOR/ 0RGHQHVH/ SHU DYHU PDFFKLQDWR FRQWUR OD YLWD GHO 'XFD &RVL0 PR/ H VRVSHWWR FKH HJOL IRVVH GL LQWHOOLJHQ]D FRO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD1 'HWWDJOLDWH GHVFUL]LRQL GHOOH IHVWH IDWWH LQ )HUUDUD QHOOD YHQXWD GHOO·$UFLGXFD &DUOR LQ TXHOOD FLWWj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·RUR FRQ O·DTXLOD (VWHQ0
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44<8
VH/ H FRO PRWWR 0D[LPD LQ PD[LPLV/ SHU FRQWUDSSRVWR GHO WLWROR GL 0DJQXV 'X[1 0RUWH GHOOD 'XFKHVVD GL )HUUDUD/ FRJQDWD GHO *UDQ 3ULQFLSH )UDQFHVFR1 1XRYH TXHUHOH SHU FRQWR GHL %DUJKLJLDQL> TXHUHOH SHU OH ]XIIH FKH VHJXRQR WUD L SRSROL GL 9DUDQR H TXHOOL GL *URSSR 6DQ 3LHUR1 ;9, +)1 5;<7, &DUWHJJLR GHO &DQLJLDQL GHJOL DQQL 48:7 H 48:81 ,O &DQLJLD0 QL YD D 9HQH]LD FRO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD SHU IDU OD &RUWH DO UH $UULJR 7HU]R GL )UDQFLD H GL 3ROORQLD/ FKH VL WURYDYD LQ TXHOOD FLWWj/ H FKH GL SRL SDVVz D )HU0 UDUD/ H GHVFULYH L ULFHYLPHQWL H IHVWH IDWWHOL LQ TXHVWH GXH FLWWj1 $YYLVL H QXRYH GHWWDJOLDWH GL TXHOOD &RUWH/ PROWR FXULRVH1 ;9,, +)1 5;<8, 6HJXLWDQR OH OHWWHUH GHO &DQLJLDQL GHJOL DQQL 48:9 H 48::1 ,O &DQLJLDQL RWWLHQH GDO *UDQ'XFD XQ SULYLOHJLR SHU OD VWDPSD GHO SRHPD GHO 7DVVR/ FKH HUD VXR DPLFR1 /·,PSHUDWRUH DYHQGR GHFLVR LQ FDXVD GHOOD SUHFH0 GHQ]D D IDYRUH GHO *UDQGXFD/ LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD H WXWWD TXHOOD FRUWH QH PR0 VWUDQR XQ QRWDELOH GLVSLDFHUH1 ,O &DQLJLDQL q VSHGLWR DOOD &HVDUHD D SRUWDUH OD QXRYD GHOOD QDVFLWD GL XQ ILJOLR PDVFKLR DO *UDQGXFD )UDQFHVFR1 6HJXLWR GL DYYLVL/ QRWL]LH/ SLFFROL UHJDOL WUD XQD &RUWH H O·DOWUD1 ;9,,, +)1 5;<9, FRQWLQXD]LRQH GHO FDUWHJJLR GHO &DQLJLDQL SHU OL DQQL 48:; H 48:<1 ,QIRUPD GHL WUDWWDWL GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD GL SUHQGHU SHU WHU]D PRJOLH XQD ILJOLD GHO 'XFD GL 0DQWRYD1 ,O 7DVVR VL ODPHQWD FKH LO *UDQGXFD ODVFL YLWXSHUDUH LO VXR SRHPD GDL ILRUHQWLQL1 1XRYH VROLWH H VXR ULWRUQR D )L0 UHQ]H1 4XHVWR FDUWHJJLR GHO &DQLJLDQL q SLHQR GL VWRULHWWH JDODQWL GL )HUUDUD/ GL GHWWDJOL GL IHVWH H GL WXWWR TXHOOR VL IDFHYD LQ TXHOOD FLWWj1 5LHVFH PROWR FX0 ULRVR HG LQWHUHVVDQWH SHU O·LVWRULD GHL FRVWXPL GL TXHO WHPSR1 ;,; +)1 5;<:, H ;; +)1 5;<;, 6RQR GXH ILO]H GL PLQXWH GL OHWWHUH VFULWWH DOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH &DQLJLDQL GDO 4895 DO 48:4 VRSUD L VXGGHWWL DUJRPHQWL1 &DYDOLHUH 2UD]LR 8UEDQL/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD GDO 48:< DO 48;7 ;;, +)1 5;<<, /HWWHUH GL 2UD]LR 8UEDQL DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD/ GHJOL DQ0 QL 48:< H 48;31 ,QIRUPD DO VROLWR GL WXWWH OH QXRYH GL )HUUDUD/ H SDUWLFRODU0 PHQWH GHOOH OLYHOOD]LRQL GL TXHOO·DFTXH H ODYRUL IDWWL DOOH PHGHVLPH1 5LFHYL0 PHQWR IDWWR D )HUUDUD D 'RQ *LRYDQQL GHL 0HGLFL TXDQGR SDVVz SHU TXHOOD FLWWj SHU DQGDUH D 9HQH]LD D FRPSOLUH FRQ TXHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO PDWULPRQLR GHO *UDQGXFD FRQ OD %LDQFD &DSSHOOR/ H VLFFRPH HVVHQGR DUULYD0 WR D 3DGRYD IX VRUSUHVR GDO YDLROR/ FRVu LQIRUPD GHO VXR VWDWR DWWXDOH1 3UDWL0 FKH GL GRQ $OIRQVR GD (VWH SHU JXDGDJQDUVL OD EHQHYROHQ]D GHO *UDQGXFD H
44<9
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
OD VXD SURWH]LRQH LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD PDQFDQ]D GL SUROH QHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD SHU OD VXFFHVVLRQH D TXHOOL VWDWL1 3DUHQWDGR IUD LO 0DUFKHVH GL 0DVVD H 'RQQD 0DUILVD G·(VWH/ IDWWR GDO *UDQGXFD1 ,QIRUPD]LRQL VRSUD L EDVWDUGL GHOOD &DVD G·(VWH/ H GLULWWR GL 'RQ &HVDUH GL VXFFHGHUH DOOR 6WDWR GL )HUUDUD LQ YLJRUH GL XQD EROOD GL 3DROR ,9/ FKH UHQGH DELOL L ILJOL QDWXUDOL OHJLWWLPDWL DOOD VXFFHV0 VLRQH GL TXHOOR 6WDWR1 ,O *UDQGXFD ID RVVHUYDUH JOL DQGDPHQWL GHOOD 'XFKHVVD YHGRYD GL 8UELQR GLPRUDQWH LQ )HUUDUD/ H O·8UEDQL QH LQIRUPD PLQXWDPHQWH1 ,O 'XFD GL )HUUDUD/ VHQWHQGR FKH OD *UDQGXFKHVVD HUD SHU DQGDUH D 9HQH]LD/ OD LQYLWD D SDVVDUH SHU TXHOOD FLWWj1 $YYLVL1 ;;,, +)1 5<33, &RQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OHWWHUH GHOO·8UEDQL QHJOL DQQL 48;4 H 48;51 &RQJLXUD RUGLWD FRQWUR 'RQ $OIRQVR GD (VWH1 &XULRVH QRWL]LH DWWLQHQWL DO 3ULQFLSH GL 0DQWRYD H DOOD 3ULQFLSHVVD GL 3DUPD VXD PRJOLH/ FLUFD O·LPSRVVLELOLWj GL HIIHWWXDUH LO PDWULPRQLR IUD ORUR/ H OH RSHUD]LRQL GD IDUVL SHU TXHVWR HIIHWWR1 'HWWDJOLDWL DYYLVL/ H QXRYH FXULRVH GL )HUUDUD1 ;;,,, +)1 5<34, 6HJXLWR GHOOH OHWWHUH GHOO·8UEDQL GD )HUUDUD QHJOL DQQL 48;6 H 48;7= LO 3ULQFLSH GL 0DQWRYD WUDWWHQHQGRVL LQ )HUUDUD SHQGHQWH OD FDXVD GHOOD SRWHQ]D PDWULPRQLDOH GHOOD VXD VSRVD/ O·8UEDQL LQIRUPD LO *UDQ0 GXFD PLQXWDPHQWH GL WXWWR TXHVWR DIIDUH H GHJOL DQGDPHQWL H GHO FDUDWWHUH GL GHWWR 3ULQFLSH1 ,O 3RPDUDQFLH/ VHJUHWDULR GHO 3ULQFLSH/ RIIHULVFH DOO·8UEDQL XQ·DSHUWXUD GL WUDWWDWR PDWULPRQLDOH FRQ OD ILJOLD SULPRJHQLWD GHO *UDQGXFD/ H JLXVWLILFD OD SRWHQ]D GHO SULQFLSH FRQ HVLELUVL GL SURYDUH FKH OD ILVWROD FKH OR WUDYDJOLD q ORQWDQD GDO VHVVR LQ PRGR GD QRQ LPSHGLUQH OL HIIHWWL1 ,O &DUGLQDOH %RUURPHR/ GHOHJDWR GDO 3DSD QHOOD FDXVD PDWULPRQLDOH/ QHOOD YLVLWD IDWWD DO 3ULQFLSH DVVLHPH FRQ L PHGLFL DYHYD WURYDWR FKH VHEEHQH LO 3ULQFLSH DEERQ0 GDVVH LQ TXDQWLWj/ QRQ HUD SHUz SHUIHWWR LQ TXDOLWj/ FKH DOOH YROWH VL ULFKLHGHYD XQR VIRU]R1 ,QIRUPD GHOOH FRVH GHO 7DVVR/ FKH VL WURYDYD ULWHQXWR LQ FDUFHUH FRPH PDQLDFR/ H PDQGD DO *UDQGXFD L VXRL GLDORJKL/ DGGLWDQGR FKH LQ TXHOOR GHO SLDFHUH RQHVWR/ D FDUWD 448 GHOO·HGL]LRQH GL 9HQH]LD/ YL VRQR GHOOH LPSHU0 WLQHQ]H FRQWUR OD FDVD GHL 0HGLFL1 ,QWURGXFH WUDWWDWR FRQ 'RQ $OIRQVR GL PDULWDUH D 'RQ &HVDUH/ VXR ILJOLR HG HUHGH SUHVXQWLYR GL FDVD G·(VWH/ 'RQQD 9LUJLQLD/ ILJOLD GL &RVLPR , H GHOOD &DPLOOD 0DUWHOOL/ H LQ TXHVWD RFFDVLRQH VD PROWH SDUWLFRODULWj VXOO·LPSRWHQ]D GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD1 'RQ $OIRQVR YD D 5RPD H DO ULWRUQR SDVVD GL )LUHQ]H/ H ULFHYH GDO *UDQGXFD LQILQLWH FRUWHVLH1 &RQWURYHUVLH GL FRQILQL QHOOD /XQLJLDQD1 /·8UEDQL ULWURYD D 5HJJLR XQ VFULW0 WXUD SHU VFKLDULPHQWR GHL FRQILQL WUD &RPDQR H 0LVFRVR/ H FKH VHUYu SRL GL IRQGDPHQWR SHU OD VHQWHQ]D GL %LDJLR &XULQL LQ TXHVWD FDXVD1 ,O 'XFD GL )HU0 UDUD ID LVWDQ]D FKH QRQ VLD SHUPHVVD OD VWDPSD GHOO·LVWRULD GHO 0DUFHOOLQR/
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44<:
SHUFKp QHOOD FDXVD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D SDUOD GL OXL SRFR FRQYHQLHQWHPHQWH1 'RQ $OIRQVR/ HVVHQGR D )LUHQ]H/ FRQFOXGH GD Vp LO PDWULPRQLR GL 'RQ &HVD0 UH FRQ 'RQQD 9LUJLQLD1 1HO WUDWWDWR PDWULPRQLDOH FRQ 0DQWRYD/ HVVHQGRVL LQ SULQFLSLR FRQWHQWDWR LO *UDQGXFD FKH TXHO 3ULQFLSH IDFHVVH OD SURYD FRQ O·DVVLVWHQ]D GL 'RQ $OIRQVR/ LO &DYDOLHUH 8UEDQL LQIRUPD FKH HJOL QRQ KD YR0 OXWR VRWWRSRUYLVL1 &XULRVH SDUWLFRODULWj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·$OEL]L JLX0 VWLILFD DO *UDQGXFD QRQ HVVHUH VWDWR PDO IUDQFHVH1 &RQWURYHUVLH H DUELWULR GHO JRYHUQDWRUH GL 6HVWROD FRQWUR L VXGGLWL GHO *UDQGXFD GHO WHUULWRULR GL %DUJD D PRWLYR GHO /DJR 6DQWR1 1XRYD FRQWURYHUVLD WUD LO *UDQGXFD H LO 'XFD GL )HU0 UDUD VRSUD L WLWROL/ SUHWHQGHQGR TXHVW·XOWLPR O·$OWH]]D H LO 6HUHQLVVLPR/ LO FKH WUDWWLHQH OD YHQXWD GL 'RQ &HVDUH D )LUHQ]H/ OD TXDOH GRYHQGRVL HIIHWWXDUH QHO JLXJQR 48;8/ VHJXH SRL QHO IHEEUDLR VXVVHJXHQWH1 ,O ULPDQHQWH GHO FDUWHJJLR FRQFHUQH O·DSSDUDWR GHOOH QR]]H/ LO ULFHYLPHQWR IDWWR D )HUUDUD DOOD VSRVD/ DY0 YLVL/ QXRYH1 9L VRQR/ LQ ILQH GL TXHVWD ILO]D/ YDULH OHWWHUH GL 5DIIDHOOR GHL 0H0 GLFL/ FKH HUD DQGDWR D )HUUDUD DG DFFRPSDJQDUH 'RQQD 9LUJLQLD/ H FKH SRL UHVWz LQ OXRJR GHOO·$OEL]L1 ;;9 +)1 5<36, &RQWLHQH TXHVWD ILO]D OH PLQXWH GHOOH OHWWHUH FKH O·$OEL]L VFULYHYD DO *UDQGXFD H OH OHWWHUH RULJLQDOL GHO *UDQGXFD DO PHGHVLPR/ H LQ FRQVHJXHQ]D QRQ q FKH XQ GXSOLFDWR GHOO·DQWHFHGHQWH1 5DIIDHOOR 0HGLFL/ $PEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD GDO 48;: DO 48<5 ;;9, +I1 5<37, /HWWHUH GL 5DIIDHOOR 0HGLFL/ QXRYR DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUD0 UD/ QHJOL DQQL 48;: H 48;;1 6L WUDWWD GL XQD JLWD GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD D )LUHQ]H SHU DEERFFDUVL FRO *UDQGXFD/ H FRQFHUWDUH LO PRGR GL VWDELOLUH OD VXFFHVVLRQH
44<;
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
GHL VXRL 6WDWL LQ 'RQ &HVDUH1 ,O 'XFD GL 0DQWRYD SUHWHQGH PHWj GHOO·HUHGLWj GHO *UDQGXFD )UDQFHVFR/ PRUWR VHQ]D ILJOL PDVFKL1 7XUEROHQ]H WUD LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD H TXHOOR GL 0DQWRYD DFFRPRGDWH GDO *UDQGXFD1 5HIHULVFH O·DPEDVFLDWRUH LO SRFR EXRQ DQLPR GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD YHUVR LO *UDQGXFD/ EHQFKq PRVWUL GL DPDUOR/ H O·RSLQLRQH/ FKH FRUUH LQ TXHOOD FRUWH/ FKH HJOL QRQ VLD SL• DWWR DOOD JHQHUD]LRQH/ H FKH HVVHQGR DQFKH QHOO·LVWHVVR JUDGR DQFKH 'RQ 3LHWUR/ VL OXVLQJDQR LQ FRQVHJXHQ]D FKH OD FDVD 0HGLFL VLD SHU ILQLUH1 ,O *UDQGXFD V·LQWHUSRQH FRO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD SHUFKp SURFXUL D 'RQ &HVDUH O·LQYHVWLWXUD GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR1 3UDWLFKH WHQXWH D 5RPD SHU DYHUH O·LQYHVWLWXUD GL )HUUDUD SHU 'RQ &HVDUH1 $YYLVL1 ;;9,, +)1 5<38, &RQWLQXDQR OH OHWWHUH GL 5DIIDHOOR 0HGLFL GHOO·DQQR 48;<1 3DUOD GHOOH JXHUUH FLYLOL GL )UDQFLD/ H GHOO·LQWHUHVVH FKH YL SUHQGHYD LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD1 0HGLD]LRQH GHO *UDQGXFD QHOOH FRQWURYHUVLH VXVFLWDWH IUD 0DQWRYD/ H )HUUDUD1 ,O *UDQGXFD LQYLWD LO 'XFD DOOH VXH QR]]H1 ,O 0HGLFL q VSHGLWR D 9HQH]LD SHU FRPSOLUH FRQ OD 5HSXEEOLFD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHO PDWUL0 PRQLR GHO *UDQGXFD FRQ 0DGDPD &ULVWLQD1 1HOO·DVVHQ]D GHO 0HGLFL ULPDQH LQ )HUUDUD LO VHJUHWDULR 2UD]LR GHOOD 5HQD1 3UDWLFKH FLUFD O·LQYHVWLWXUD GL 0R0 GHQD H OD VXFFHVVLRQH GL )HUUDUD SHU 'RQ &HVDUH/ PHQWUH LO 'XFD GL 6DYRLD OD SURFXUDYD SHU LO 0DUFKHVH G·(VWH1 $EERFFDPHQWR GHO VHJUHWDULR 9LQWD FRQ 'RQ &HVDUH D 3LDQRUR SHU TXHVWR HIIHWWR1 6HJUHWL SURSRVWL DO *UDQGXFD SHU PROWLSOLFDUH O·RUR1 1HJR]LR WUDWWDWR GDO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD SHU ULPHWWHUH LQ JUD0 ]LD GHO *UDQGXFD 3LUUR 0DOYH]]L1 $YYLVL H QXRYH1 ;;9,,, +)15<39, &RQWLQXD OD OHJD]LRQH GHO 0HGLFL D )HUUDUD GHOO·DQQR 48<3 H OHWWHUH GL 2UD]LR GHOOD 5HQD/ VHJUHWDULR G·DPEDVFLDWD1 5LJXDUGD SULQ0 FLSDOPHQWH OH LVWDQ]H IDWWH GDO *UDQGXFD D TXHOOD FRUWH SHU O·DUUHVWR GL $OIRQ0 VR 3LFFRORPLQL/ OH LQIRUPD]LRQL VRSUD LO PHGHVLPR H VRSUD OD SRFD SUHPXUD GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD SHU IDYRULUH LO *UDQGXFD1 ,QIRUPD]LRQL VHJUHWH VRSUD OD FRPSHWHQ]D GHO PDUFKHVH G·(VWH H GL 'RQ &HVDUH G·(VWH DOOD VXFFHVVLRQH GHO 'XFD1 &DUDWWHUH/ H PRYLPHQWL GL DPEHGXH SHU YHQLUH D TXHVWD VXFFHVVLRQH1 ,Q TXHVWD ILO]D YL VRQR DQFRUD DOFXQH FLIUH GHO 0HGLFL GHO PDU]R 48<3/ TXDQ0 GR GDOOD *UDQGXFKHVVD &ULVWLQD IX VSHGLWR LQ /RUHQD SHU LQGXUUH TXHO 'XFD DG DFFRPRGDUVL FRO UH GL 1DYDUUD/ H PHWWHUJOL LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH FKH/ HVVHQGR LO/ 3DSD GLVSRVWR D ULFRQRVFHUOR SHU FDWWROLFR H OD 6SDJQD LPSRWHQWH D VRFFRU0 UHUH OD OHJD/ RUPDL SDUHYD FKH QLXQR JOL SRWHVVH SL• FRQWUDVWDUH OD VXFFHVVLR0 QH GL )UDQFLD1 'D TXHVWH FLIUH DSSDULVFH DQFRUD TXDQWR LO *UDQGXFD IRVVH LQ0 WHUHVVDWR HG XQLWR FRO 5H GL 1DYDUUD1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
44<<
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·HVWLUSD]LRQH GHL EDQGLWL GHOOD 5RPDJQD1 ,Q GHWWR WHPSR LO *XLFFLDUGLQL IX VSHGLWR LQ *HUPDQLD D FRPSOLPHQWDUH GLYHUVL GL TXHL 3ULQFLSL/ H YL VRQR DO0 FXQH OHWWHUH1 5LWRUQD D )HUUDUD/ GRYH HVVHQGR PDODWR TXHO GXFD/ LO OHJDWR GL %RORJQD PDQGD WUXSSH DL FRQILQL SHU HVVHU SURQWR D SUHQGHUH SRVVHVVR GL TXHOOR 6WDWR1 'LIIHUHQ]H GL FHULPRQLDOH LQVRUWH LQ )LUHQ]H WUD LO 1XQ]LR H O·DPEDVFLDWRUH GL )HUUDUD DOOD FRUWH GL 7RVFDQD/ DFFRUGDWH SRL GDO *UDQGXFD1 $YYLVL1 ;;; +)1 5<3;, 6L FRQWHQJRQR LQ TXHVWD ILO]D OH OHWWHUH RULJLQDOL VFULWWH GDO JUDQGXFD DOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH *XLFFLDUGLQL VRSUD L VXGGHWWL DUJRPHQWL/ H OH PLQX0 WH GHO *XLFFLDUGLQL DO *UDQGXFD1 7RUTXDWR 0DODVSLQD 0DUFKHVH GL 6XYHUR/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD GDO 48<6 DO 48<7 ;;;, +)1 5<3<, /HWWHUH GHO 0DUFKHVH 0DODVSLQD/ QXRYR DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD/ GHJOL DQQL 48<6 H 48<7/ H GL 0LFKHOH 5RFFD VXR VHJUHWDULR1 6RVSHWWL GHJOL 6SDJQROL FKH L 3ULQFLSL G·,WDOLD VL VLDQR XQLWL FRO 3DSD H DEELQR IRUPDWR XQD OHJD SHU VFDFFLDUOL G·,WDOLD1 ,O *UDQGXFD FRPXQLFD DO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD TXHVWR VRVSHWWR/ H JOL LQVLQXD GL JLXVWLILFDUVL DVVLHPH SUHVVR LO UH FDWWROLFR1 ,Q0 IRUPD]LRQL VRSUD XQ QHJR]LDWR GL 'RQ 3LHWUR GH· 0HGLFL LQ )HUUDUD SHU WUR0 YDU GHQDUL LQ TXHOOD FLWWj1 $YYLVL H SLFFROL DIIDUL GL SRFR PRPHQWR1 )UDQFHVFR 0DODVSLQD 0DUFKHVH GL 7UHJJLDQD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD GDO 48<8 DO 48<: ;;;,, +)1 5<43, /HWWHUH GHO 0DUFKHVH )UDQFHVFR 0DODVSLQD GL 7UHJJLDQD GDO 48<8 DO 48<:1 5LJXDUGDQR SULQFLSDOPHQWH TXHVWH OH SUDWLFKH GL TXHO 'XFD SHU RWWHQHUH GDOO·,PSHUDWRUH O·LQYHVWLWXUD GL 0RGHQD H 5HJJLR SHU 'RQ &HVD0
4533
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
UH/ L WUDWWDWL WHQXWL LQ 5RPD SHU RWWHQHUH GDO 3DSD TXHOOD GL )HUUDUD/ OD PDODW0 WLD H OD PRUWH GL TXHO 'XFD/ OD VXFFHVVLRQH GL 'RQ &HVDUH FRQWUDVWDWD GDO 3D0 SD/ OH LVWDQ]H IDWWH DO *UDQGXFD SHUFKp OR VRFFRUUD H L YDUL SUHWHVWL DGGRWWL GDO *UDQGXFD SHU QRQ LPSHJQDUVL FRQWUR LO 3DSD/ PDVVLPDPHQWH SHUFKp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u DO PHGHVLPR LO VHJUHWDULR 3LFFKHQD SHU FRPSOLPHQWDUOR/ LQFDULFDQGROR LQWDQWR GL VROOHFLWDUH SUHVVR LO PHGHVLPR OD VSHGL]LRQH GHOOD FDXVD WUD HVVR H 'RQ 3LHWUR VXR IUDWHOOR/ FRPPHVVD GDYDQWL DO 3DSD1 ,QIRUPD LO *UDQGXFD GHOOH QRYLWj IDWWH LQ )HUUDUD GDO FDUGLQDOH $OGREUDQGLQR H GHO SHQVLHUR GHO 3DSD GL IDEEULFDUYL XQD IRUWH]]D/ H GHOOD JHORVLD FKH QH SUHQGHYDQR L 9HQH0 ]LDQL1 6L WUDWWLHQH LO 3LFFKHQD LQ )HUUDUD ILQR DOO·DUULYR GHO 3DSD/ FKH HUD VHJXL0 WDWR GDOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH 1LFFROLQL1 ;;;,9 +)1 5<45, 0LVFHOODQHD GL YDULH FRVH DWWLQHQWL D )HUUDUD1 6FULWWXUH FLUFD O·DFFRPRGDPHQWR GHO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD FRO 5H GL 6SDJQD WUDWWDWR GDO 'XFD &RVLPR H LO PDWULPRQLR GHOOD /XFUH]LD 0HGLFL FRO 3ULQFLSH GL )HUUDUD1 /HWWHUH GHL 'XFKL GL )HUUDUD GDO 4883 DO 4893 VRSUD L VXGGHWWL DUJRPHQWL1 /HWWHUH H ELJOLHWWL G·,SSROLWR 3DJDQR/ UHVLGHQWH GL )HUUDUD D )LUHQ]H/ VFULWWL D &RVLPR , VLPLOPHQWH VRSUD L GHWWL DUJRPHQWL1 )DVFHWWH GL OHWWHUH GHO %DEEL GD )HUUDUD GHO 4883/ FRQ QXRYH VHJUHWH GHO WHPSR1 &RSLH GL OHWWHUH GHO 'RWWRU 5LVFDO]R/ VSHGLWR GDO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD DOOD &RUWH &HVDUHD SHU WUDWWDUH O·DIIDUH GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D1 )DVFHWWR GL OHWWHUH RULJLQDOL GHO *UDQGXFD )HUGLQDQGR , DO PDUFKHVH 7RUTXDWR 0DODVSLQD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD/ VRSUD JOL DUJRPHQWL QRWDWL DO Q1 ;;;,1 )DVFHWWR GL OHWWHUH GL %HUQDUGR &DQLJLDQL DO *UDQGXFD H VXRL VHJUHWDUL/ GL SRFR PRPHQWR1 ;;;9 +)1 5<46, 0LVFHOODQHD GL YDULH VFULWWXUH DWWHQHQWL DOOD FDXVD GL SUH0 FHGHQ]D WUD LO *UDQGXFD/ H LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD1 )DVFLR GL VFULWWXUH GLYHUVH DWWH0 QHQWL DOOD FDXVD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D1 /HWWHUD GL )UDQFHVFR 9LQWD DO 'XFD &RVL0
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
4534
PR/ WRFFDQWH DOFXQL GRFXPHQWL GL &DVD 0HGLFL/ FKH SURSRQH VLDQR VWDPSDWL1 &RSLD GHOOD ULVSRVWD GDWD GDOO·,PSHUDWRUH DOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH GL )HUUDUD VRSUD OD SUHFHGHQ]D /Ou 9 VHWWHPEUH 48941 'HFUHWR GHOO·,PSHUDWRUH )HUGLQDQGR , GHFODUDWRULR GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D IUD 7RVFDQD H )HUUDUD/ GHOO·RWWREUH 48931 3URFHVVR QHOOD FDXVD GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D GHO 'XFD GL )LUHQ]H FRQWUR TXHOOR GL )HUUDUD DYDQWL LO &DUGLQDOH &LFDOD/ JLXGL0 FH GHOHJDWR GDO 3DSD 3LR ,91 3URFHVVR LQ FDXVD GL SUHFHGHQ]D WUD LO *UDQGXFD H LO 'XFD GL )HUUDUD D0 YDQWL O·,PSHUDWRUH 0DVVLPLOLDQR ,,/ O·DQQR 48:31 &RQVXOWL GL YDUL 'RWWRUL H XQLYHUVLWj LQ GHWWD FDXVD1 ;;;9, +)1 5<47, 5DFFROWD GL FRQVXOWL IDWWL GDL SULQFLSDOL JLXUHFRQVXOWL H XQLYHUVLWj GHOO·(XURSD LQ IDYRUH GHO 'XFD &RVLPR QHOOD FDXVD GL SUHFHGHQ]D FRQ )HUUDUD/ H VRQR L VHJXHQWL1 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 4; 4< 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 4: 4; 4< 53 54
,QIRUPD]LRQH VRSUD OH UDJLRQL GHOOD SUHFHGHQ]D1 5LVSRVWD DOO·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
4535
55 56 57 58 59 5: 5; 5< 63 64 65 66 67
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
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
6SRJOLR H LQGLFH GL FDUWHJJL FRQ OD &RUWH GL 0RGHQD , +)1 5<48, /HWWHUH GHO 'XFD &HVDUH GL 0RGHQD H DOWUL SULQFLSL (VWHQVL DO *UDQGXFD H VXRL VHJUHWDUL/ FKH FRPLQFLDQR GDO 48<;/ TXDQGR OD FDVD G·(VWH/ HVSXOVD GD )HUUDUD/ VL ULWLUz D 0RGHQD/ ILQR DO 493<> QHO TXDO DQQR VHJXu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q OD FRQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OHWWHUH FRPH VRSUD GDO 4958 DO 49871
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
4536
0DUFKHVH 0DODVSLQD GL 7UHJJLDQD/ $PEDVFLDWRUH D )HUUDUD/ H SRL D 0RGHQD/ ILQR DO 4934 9 +)1 5<4<, 5LWLUDWRVL GD )HUUDUD 'RQ &HVDUH D IRUPD GHOOH FDSLWROD]LRQL IDWWH FRQ OD &KLHVD/ LO PDUFKHVH GL 7UHJJLDQD QHO IHEEUDLR 48<; DE LQFDUQDWLRQH OR VHJXLWz D 0RGHQD FRQ O·LVWHVVR FDUDWWHUH GL DPEDVFLDWRUH1 &RQFHUQH TXHVWR FDUWHJJLR LO PLQXWR GHWWDJOLR GHOOH FRVH GHO 'XFD &HVDUH WDQWR SHU O·HVHFX]LRQH GHO FDSLWRODWR FRO 3DSD TXDQWR SHU OR VWDELOLPHQWR GHO *RYHUQR H UHVLGHQ]D QHOOD FLWWj GL 0RGHQD/ OH SHQGHQ]H SHU FRQWR GL 6DVVXROR H FLUFD LO PHWWHUH LQVLHPH LQ TXHOOL VWDWL XQD FRPSDJQLD GL IDQWL SHU LO *UDQGXFD1 /HOLR 7RORPHL/ UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD GDO 4934 DO 4938 9, +)1 5<53, /HWWHUH GL /HOLR 7RORPHL 6HQHVH UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD GDO 46 RWWREUH 4934 D WXWWR RWWREUH 49381 (VVHQGR O·DQQR 4933 ULFKLDPDWR GD 0R0 GHQD LO PDUFKHVH GL 7UHJJLDQD/ JLj DPEDVFLDWRUH GL )HUUDUD/ FKH DYHYD VHJXL0 WDWR LO 'XFD &HVDUH QHOOD VXD ULWLUDWD GD TXHOOD FLWWj/ VSHGu LO *UDQGXFD SHU VXR UHVLGHQWH SUHVVR LO 'XFD &HVDUH /HOLR 7RORPHL1 3DUODVL GHOO·LPSHJQR SUH0 VR GD TXHO 'XFD GL ULWHQHUH LO IHXGR GL 6DVVXROR/ WROWR DOOD FDVD 3LR/ QRQR0 VWDQWH XQD VHQWHQ]D ,PSHULDOH H XQD HVRUWD]LRQH GHO 3DSD D ULODVFLDUOR1 ,O *UDQGXFD VL DGRSHUD SHUFKq TXHVWH GXH FRUWL QRQ VL LQDVSULVFKLQR FRQWUR LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD1 *XHUUD WUD LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD H L /XFFKHVL D FRQWR GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ GD ORUR SUHWHVD GHYROXWD DOOD 5HSXEEOLFD GRSR O·HVWLQ]LRQH GHL 'XFKL GL )HUUDUD1 5HFODPL IDWWL SHU SDUWH GHO *UDQGXFD DO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ SHUFKq QHOOD VXD ]HFFD VL EDWWHYDQR GHL *LXOL H GHOOH 3LDVWUH FRQ O·LPSURQWD GL TXHOOL GL )LUHQ]H/ H GL OHJD DVVDL LQIHULRUH1 ,PSHJQR SUHVR GDO 7RORPHL FRO %DUJHOOR GL 0RGHQD/ H VRGGLVID]LRQL DYXWH GD TXHO 'XFD1 (VVHQGR LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD PDO VRGGLVIDWWR GHJOL 6SDJQROL/ SHUFKq QRQ OR DYHYDQR YROXWR OLEH0 UDUH GDOOH PROHVWLH GHL /XFFKHVL/ LO *UDQGXFD OR FRQIRUWD D QRQ GDUVL LQ EUDF0 FLR GHL IUDQFHVL H D SHUVHYHUDUH QHO SDUWLWR VSDJQROR> D WDO HIIHWWR OR FRQVLJOLD D VFLRJOLHUH DOFXQL WUDWWDWL FKH WHQHYD GL PDULWDUH LQ )UDQFLD OH VXH ILJOLH1 1H0 JR]LDWL FRO &DUGLQDOH G·(VWH H FRO &DUGLQDOH )DUQHVH SHU IDU 3DSD LO &DUGLQDOH GL )LUHQ]H/ FKH IX SRL /HRQH ;,/ H LO *UDQGXFD QH ID ULQJUD]LDUH LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD H TXHOOR GL 3DUPD1 0LQXWH LQIRUPD]LRQL GHO *RYHUQR GL 'RQ &HVD0 UH> QXRYH FRUUHQWL> UHVWLWX]LRQL GL GHOLQTXHQWL H VSHGL]LRQL GL FRQGDQQDWL DOOD JDOHUD1
4537
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
6HQDWRUH *LRYDQQL %RQL/ $PEDVFLDWRUH UHVLGHQWH D 0RGHQD GDO 4938 DO 493< 9,, +)1 5<54, $YHQGR LO *UDQGXFD ULFKLDPDWR GDOO·DPEDVFHULD GL 0RGHQD /HOLR 7RORPHL/ JOL VRVWLWXWLVFH LQ TXHOOD FDULFD LO VHQDWRUH *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD %RQL/ GL FXL HVLVWH LQ TXHVWD ILO]D LO FDUWHJJLR GDO QRYHPEUH 4938 D WXWWR OX0 JOLR 493<1 ,O 'XFD GL 1HPRXUV LQWHUSRQH LO *UDQGXFD SHU DYHUH LQ VSRVD XQD ILJOLD GHO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ H LO *UDQGXFD FRQVLGHUDQGR FKH TXHVWR SDUHQWD0 GR SRWUHEEH HVVHUH XWLOH D TXHO 'XFD SHU IDU YDOHUH OH SUHWHQVLQL FKH KD LQ )UDQFLD/ OR FRQVLJOLD DG DFFRUGDUOR1 ,O *UDQGXFD RUGLQD DO %RQL GL IHUPDUH LQ WXWWL L PRGL DO VXR VHUYL]LR 0DHVWUR *LURODPR 9LDQR/ )DEEULFDWRUH GL &HU0 ERWWDQH1 &HQVL GHO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD FRQ L *HQRYHVL FRPSUDWL GDO *UDQGXFD1 /D GXFKHVVD 9LUJLQLD HVVHQGR GLYHQXWD GHOLUDQWH H PDOLQFRQLFD/ LO %RQL LQ0 IRUPD LO *UDQGXFD FKH OH FDXVH GL TXHVWR PDOH SRVVRQR HVVHUH OD JHORVLD GHO PDULWR/ H OD PDQFDQ]D GL GHQDUL SHU SDJDUH L GHELWL1 'HWWDJOLDWH LQIRUPD]LRQL LQ FLIUD GHOOD PDODWWLD/ H VWUDYDJDQ]H GL GHWWD SULQFLSHVVD1 1R]]H GHO SULQFLSH GL 0RGHQD FRQ XQD SULQFLSHVVD GL 6DYRLD/ QHOOD TXDOH RFFDVLRQH LO *UDQGXFD PDQGD 'RQ $QWRQLR GHL 0HGLFL D FRPSOLPHQWDUH JOL VSRVL1 'LIIHUHQ]H H FRQWURYHUVLH GL HWLFKHWWD1 $YYLVL FRUUHQWL1 &RQWH *HUPDQLFR (UFRODQL/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD GDO 4944 DO 4947 9,,, +)1 5<55, $FFRPRGDWH SHU TXDQWR VL ULOHYD DOFXQH FRQWURYHUVLH GL H0 WLFKHWWD/ LO *UDQGXFD O·DQQR 4944 PDQGz SHU VXR DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD LO FRQWH *HUPDQLFR (UFRODQL/ ERORJQHVH/ FKH GXUz LQ TXHOOD FDULFD ILQR DO 49471 $YHQGR O·DQQR 4946 LO 'XFD GL 6DYRLD PRVVH OH DUPL FRQWUR LO &DUGLQDOH 'X0 FD GL 0DQWRYD SHU FRQWR GL VXH SUHWHQ]LRQL VRSUD LO 0RQIHUUDWR/ LO &DUGLQDOH 'XFD/ YLVWRVL DVVDOWDWR GH IDFWR PHQWUH O·DIIDUH VL WUDWWDYD DPLFKHYROPHQWH/ UL0 FRUVH DO *UDQGXFD &RVLPR ,, SHU DLXWR1 ,O *UDQGXFD VL GLFKLDUz VXELWR GL VRFFRUUHUOR FRQ GXH PLOD IDQWL H VHL FRPSDJQLH GL FDYDOOL/ HG LO SULQFLSH 'RQ )UDQFHVFR/ VXR IUDWHOOR/ VL RIIHUVH GL DQGDUH LQ SHUVRQD D VHUYLUH D 0DQWRYD FRQ GHWWR VRFFRUVR1 1RQ SRWHQGRVL DOORUD WUDVSRUWDUH GHWWD JHQWH SHU PDUH/ VL SHQVz GL SURFXUDUH XQ SDVVR SHU WHUUD/ H VL JLXGLFDURQR L SL• FRPRGL/ R TXHOOR GHO %RORJQHVH/ R TXHOOR GHOOD *DUIDJQDQD1 )X FKLHVWR LO SULPR DO 3DSD/ FKH GLFKLDUDQGRVL GL YROHUH HVVHUH QHXWUDOH OR GHQHJz DVVROXWDPHQWH1 )X FKLHVWR LO VHFRQGR DO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ FKH SHU O·LVWHVVD UDJLRQH OR GHQHJz DQFK·HJOL SHU EHQ GXH YROWH H GRSR TXHVWD QHJDWLYD IHFH DL FRQILQL GHOOH EDU0
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
4538
ULFDWH H GHL IRUWL DL TXDOL PHVVH GXHPLOD XRPLQL GL JXDUGLD1 6GHJQDWR LO *UDQ0 GXFD/ FKH LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ GD HVVR WDQWR EHQHILFDWR H SURWHWWR/ SURFHGHV0 VH VHFR LQ WDO JXLVD/ GHOLEHUz GL YROHUH QRQ RVWDQWH SDVVDUH SHU LO 0RGHQHVH FRQ IRU]DUH L ULSDUL H OH WULQFLHUH GL TXHO 'XFD1 $ WDOH HIIHWWR PHVVH LQVLHPH 43 PLOD IDQWL SHU VSDOOHJJLDUH L GXHPLOD GHO VRFFRUVR1 $O SULQFLSLR GHO JLXJQR GHO VXGGHWWR DQQR PDQGz WXWWD TXHVWD JHQWH VXO FRQILQH GL 0RGHQD1 $ WDOH DYYLVR L PRGHQHVL DYHYDQR DPPDVVDWR FLUFD 58 PLOD IDQWL H 4333 FDYDOOL/ FR0 PDQGDL GDO SULPRJHQLWR GHO 'XFD/ H FRQ HVVL VL DYDQ]DURQR D IURQWH GHOOD JHQWH 7RVFDQD1 $ PLVXUD SHUz FKH L 7RVFDQL VL DYDQ]DYDQR/ OH WUXSSH 0RGH0 QHVL VL DQGDYDQR ULWLUDQGR/ ILQWDQWR FKH DUULYDWL DG XQ OXRJR GHO 0RGHQHVH GHWWR 3RPSRQLD/ SUHVVR D XQR VWUHWWR IRUWLILFDWR H GLIHVR GD GXH PLOD PRGH0 QHVL/ FKLHVHUR L WRVFDQL DPLFKHYROPHQWH LO SDVVR/ H JOL IX UHSOLFDWR YROHUQH VHQWLU SULPD OH ULVROX]LRQL GHOOD &RUWH1 /D OXQJD WDUGDQ]D GL TXHVWH ULVROX]LRQL IDFHQGR FUHGHUH DL WRVFDQL GL HVVHU EXUODWL/ FRPLQFLDURQR D JULGDUH= ´GHQWUR/ GHQWURµ H IRU]DWL L SDVVL VXSHUDURQR L IRUWL H QH VFDFFLDURQR L PRGHQHVL1 *XDGDJQDWR FRVu LO SDVVR/ OD JHQWH 7RVFDQD VL DFFDPSz LQ XQ OXRJR GHWWR OD *KLDUD H TXL FRPSDUYH DO SULQFLSH 'RQ )UDQFHVFR XQ VHJUHWDULR GHO 3ULQFLSH GL 0RGHQD/ LO TXDOH LQ QRPH GHO 'XFD JOL RIIHUVH LO SDVVR DPRUHYROPHQWH1 3URFHGHYD WDO YDULD]LRQH GHO 'XFD GD XQ RUGLQH YHQXWRJOL GDO *RYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR/ LO TXDOH LQ YLUW• GHOOD FDSLWROD]LRQH FKH TXHO 'XFD WHQHYD FRQ LO UH GL 6SDJQD JOL RUGLQz GL ODVFLDU SDVVDUH OD WUXSSD 7RVFDQD1 4XHVWR q O·DIIDUH SULQFLSDOH/ GL FXL VL WUDWWL LQ TXHVWD ILO]D1 6L SDUOD DQFRUD GHOOD HYDVLRQH GDOOH FDUFHUL GHOOD 5HOLJLRQH GL 3LVD GL 'RQ &RVLPR GH· 0HGLFL/ ILJOLR GL 'RQ 3LH0 WUR IUDWHOOR GHO 'XFD )HUGLQDQGR ,/ LO TXDOH VL HUD ULIXJLDWR D 0RGHQD SHU SRL SDVVDUH LQ 6SDJQD1 1XRYH FRUUHQWL1 &DYDOLHUH *LXOLR 0HGLFL/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD GDO 4947 DO 4953 ,; +)1 5<56, 5LFKLDPDWR GD 0RGHQD O·(UFRODQL/ IX GDO *UDQGXFD VRVWLWXL0 WR LQ VXR OXRJR LO FDYDOLHUH *LXOLR 0HGLFL/ GL FXL VL FRQWHQJRQR LQ TXHVWD ILO]D OH OHWWHUH GDO 4947 DO 494:1 LQIRUPD GL WXWWL L PRYLPHQWL GHO 'XFD GL 6DYRLD/ GHO WUDWWDWR GL PDULWDUH XQD ILJOLD GHO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD D TXHOOR GL 0DQWRYD/ GHOOH QXRYH FRUUHQWL1 ; +)1 5<57, &RQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH OHWWHUH GHOO·$PEDVFLDWRUH 0HGLFL GD 0R0 GHQD GDO 494: DO 49531 &RQWURYHUVLH GL FRQILQL IUD JOL XRPLQL GL &DPSLRQH/ WHUULWRULR GL )LYL]]DQR/ H TXHOOL GL 9DUDQR/ H IUD 6WD]]HPD H )RUQRYRODVFR1 ,O
4539
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
ULPDQHQWH VRQR DYYLVL H QRWL]LH GHOOH FRVH FRUUHQWL1 ;, +)1 5<58, 5HJLVWUR FKH FRQWLHQH OH PLQXWH GL OHWWHUH DL VXGGHWWL DPED0 VFLDWRUL ILQR DO 4947/ H YH QH VRQR DOFXQH DO 0DUFKHVH GL 7UHJJLDQD TXDQGR HUD DQFRUD D )HUUDUD1 ;,, +)1 5<59, /HWWHUH RULJLQDOL GHL *UDQGXFKL H VHJUHWDUL DL VXGGHWWL DPED0 VFLDWRUL ILQR DO 49471 %DOL )HUGLQDQGR 6XDUH]/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD GDO 4954 DO 495; ;,,, +)1 5<5:, 'RSR ULFKLDPDWR LO FDYDOLHUH 0HGLFL/ SHU VHL PHVL FKH IX YDFDQWH O·DPEDVFHULD VFULYHYD OH QXRYH GL 0RGHQD %DUWRORPHR *XLGRQL1 1HO QRYHPEUH 4954 IX GDOOH 7XWULFL VSHGLWR SHU DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD LO %DOu )HUGLQDQGR 6XDUH]/ GL FXL VL FRQWHQJRQR OH OHWWHUH LQ TXHVWD ILO]D D WXWWR O·DQQR 49571 3DUODVL PROWR GHOOD FRQJLXUD FRQWUR LO 3ULQFLSH $OIRQVR G·(VWH PDFFKLQDWD SULQFLSDOPHQWH GDJOL 2EL]L H GDL 3HSSROL1 ,VWDQ]H SHU O·DUUHVWR GL GLYHUVL EDQGLWL ULIXJLDWL QHOOR VWDWR GL 0RGHQD1 1XRYH FRUUHQWL1 ;,9 +)1 5<5;, &RQWLQXDQR OH OHWWHUH GHOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH )HUGLQDQGR 6XDUH] GDO 4958 DO 495;1 ,QIRUPD]LRQL VRSUD OH FRVH GHOOD 9DOWHOOLQD/ H SDUWLFRODU0 PHQWH GHOOH YHUWHQ]H WUD LO 'XFD GL 6DYRLD H L *HQRYHVL1 5XPRUL GL 0DQWRYD SHU OD VXFFHVVLRQH LQ TXHOOR VWDWR GHO 'XFD GL 1LYHUV1 $YYLVL VROLWL1 8JR 5LQDOGL/ $PEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD GDO 4965 DO 4974 ;9 +)1 5<63, 'DO 495; DO 4965 UHVWz YDFDQWH O·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·LPEDUFR DO 3ULQFLSH 1LFFROz G·(VWH QHOOH VXH JDOHUH SHU O·DQGDWD H ULWRUQR GD 1DSROL/ D VSRVDUH OD SULQFLSHVVD GL &RQFD1 ,QIRUPD]LRQL VRSUD OD JXHUUD GHO 'XFD GL 3DUPD FRQ JOL VSDJQROL QHO 49691 1HJR]LDWL SHU
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
453:
O·HVWLUSD]LRQH GHL EDQGLWL H PDOYLYHQWL1 0ROWL DIIDUL GL SDUWLFRODUL/ FRPPHQGD0 WL]LH/ DYYLVL1 ;9,, +)1 5<64, &RQWLQXDQR OH OHWWHUH GHO 5LQDOGL GDO 496; DO 4974 VRSUD OL VWHVVL DUJRPHQWL/ H SDUWLFRODUPHQWH VRSUD OH SULPH PRVVH GHO 'XFD GL 3DUPD FRQWUR L %DUEHULQL1 %DUWRORPHR 8JROLQL/ DPEDVFLDWRUH D 0RGHQD QHJOL DQQL 4975 H 4976> VHJUHWDULR 0RQWHPDJQL GDO IHEEUDLR DO OXJOLR 4975 ;9,,, +)1 5<65, 1HOO·DSULOH GHO 4975/ GRSR GL HVVHUH VWDWD SHU TXDOFKH PHVH YDFDQWH O·DPEDVFHULD GL 0RGHQD/ LO *UDQGXFD VRVWLWXLVFH DO 5LQDOGL %DU0 WRORPHR 8JROLQL/ GL FXL FRQWHQJRQVL LQ TXHVWR IDVFLR OH OHWWHUH GHJOL DQQL 4975 H 49761 $SSHQD WRUQDWR LO 5LQDOGL IX LQWHULQDOPHQWH VSHGLWR D 0RGHQD LO VHJUHWDULR 'HVLGHULR 0RQWHPDJQL/ SHU HVSORUDUH O·DQLPR GL TXHO 'XFD VR0 SUD OH FRVH LQVRUWH WUD LO 'XFD GL 3DUPD H L %DUEHULQL1 3RQH LO *UDQGXFD FRQ0 VLGHUD]LRQH DO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ FKH QRQ DYHQGR EXRQ HVLWR O·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH GHO UH GL )UDQFLD/ H PROWR PHQR TXHOOD GHO UH GL 3ROORQLD/ LO 'XFD GL 3DUPD/ HVVHQGR LQ QHFHVVLWj GL IDUH OD JXHUUD/ H GRYHQGR JHWWDUVL LQ EUDFFLR D TXDOFKH SRWHQ]D/ QRQ IXVVH LWDOLDQD/ SHUFKp VH FLz VHJXLVVH FRQ L 9HQH]LDQL/ HVVHQGR HVVL GHVLGHURVL GL HVSDQGHUVL HVVR FRUUHUHEEH LO ULVFKLR GL HVVHUH GD ORUR LQ0 JRLDWR/ FKH QRQ YL q DOWUR SDUWLWR SHU VRVWHQHUOR/ VH QRQ FKH R HJOL DFFHWWL L 58 PLOD GXFDWL LO PHVH FKH JOL RIIULVVH LO UH GL 1DSROL/ RYYHUR FKH VL IRUPL XQD OHJD GL SULQFLSL LWDOLDQL LQ VXR IDYRUH1 4XHVWH SURSRVL]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFD VR0 QR JXVWDWH GDO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ FKH QRQ ODVFLD GL LQVLQXDUOH DO 'XFD GL 3DU0 PD1 ,O 'XFD GL 0RGHQD SURSRQH SHU LO PLJOLRU FRPSHQVR O·XQLRQH GL SL• 3ULQFLSL/ FKH FRQWULEXLVVHUR SHU O·HVWLQ]LRQH GHO PRQWH )DUQHVH/ H TXDQGR FLz QRQ ULXVFLVVH IRUPDUH XQD OHJD1 ,O SURJHWWR GL HVWLQJXHUH L PRQWL WURYD WURSSH GLIILFROWj SHU OD PDQFDQ]D GHO GHQDUR1 ,QWDQWR LO *UDQGXFD ID OHYD GL WUXSSH LQ *HUPDQLD GL 4333 IDQWL H 633 FDYDOOL H QH RWWLHQH LO SDVVR GDO JRYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR H GDO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD1 ,O *UDQGXFD H LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD LQVLVWRQR SUHVVR OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL 9HQH]LD SHUFKp FRQFRUUD DG DOORQWDQDUH LO IXRFR FKH VL DFFHQGH LQ ,WDOLD/ HG HVVD ULVSRQGH FRQ WHUPLQL JHQHUDOL1 ,Q WDO VWDWR GL FRVH DUULYD D 0RGHQD O·8JROLQL/ H LO 0RQWHPDJQL VH QH SDUWH SHU 0LODQR1 2FFXSD0 WR LQWDQWR GDL 3DSDOLQL OR 6WDWR GL &DVWUR/ LO *UDQGXFD H LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ YHGHQGR FKH QRQ YL HUD SL• WHPSR GD SHUGHUH LQ SURJHWWL/ VWULQJRQR LO QHJR0 ]LDWR FRQ OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL 9HQH]LD SHU OD FRQFOXVLRQH GL XQD OHJD1 ,O 'XFD GL
453;
$QQD %HOOLQD]]L ² )UDQFHVFR 0DUWHOOL
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j PRWR D FRQFOXGHUVL SL• VSHGLWD0 PHQWH OD OHJD WUD OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL 9HQH]LD/ LO *UDQGXFD H LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ SHU TXDOH HIIHWWR q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p FLPHQWDUVL FRQ OL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ SRQHQGRJOL LQ YH0 GXWD FKH OD OHJD q VWDWD FRQFOXVD QRQ SHU DJLUH/ PD SHU LQGXUUH LO 3DSD SL• ID0 FLOPHQWH DG XQ DPLFKHYROH DFFRPRGDPHQWR1 &Lz QRQ RVWDQWH/ HVVHQGR HJOL HQWUDWR QHOOR VWDWR HFFOHVLDVWLFR/ OD OHJD VL GHWHUPLQD GL VWDU QHXWUDOH H YHGHU O·HVLWR GL TXHVWD VSHGL]LRQH1 $EERFFDPHQWR GHO 'XFD GL 3DUPD FRO *XLFFLDU0 GLQL LQ 0RGHQD> GHVFUL]LRQH GHOOH VXH WUXSSH/ H VXRL VHQWLPHQWL VX TXHVWD VSHGL]LRQH1 3DUODVL LQ VHJXLWR GHL SURJUHVVL GHO 'XFD GL 3DUPD/ GHO 1HJR]LDWR GL &DVWHO *LRUJLR/ GHO VXR ULWRUQR LQ /RPEDUGLD SHU OD 7RVFDQD H GL WXWWH OH RFFRUUHQ]H GHOOD WUXSSD GHO *UDQGXFD ILQFKq VWHWWH QHJOL VWDWL GL 0RGHQD1 4XHVWR FDUWHJJLR/ FRQWHQHQGR LO GHWWDJOLR GHOOD JXHUUD H GHL FRQFHUWL SUHVL GDL FROOHJDWL/ q PROWR FXULRVR H LQWHUHVVDQWH1
/H UHOD]LRQL GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD FRQ OR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD
453<
;,; +)1 5<66, &RQWLHQH TXHVWD ILO]D OH PLQXWH GHOOH OHWWHUH VFULWWH GDOOD VHJUHWHULD DOOL DPEDVFLDWRUL= 6XDUH]/ 5LQDOGL H 8JROLQL1 ;; +)1 5<67, 6L FRQWHQJRQR LQ TXHVWD ILO]D SL• H GLYHUVL FDUWHJJL1 ,O SULPR IDVFLR FRQWLHQH LO FDUWHJJLR WUD OD 6HJUHWHULD GL 6WDWR H LO FRPPHQGDWRUH 8JR0 OLQR *ULIRQL/ VSHGLWR GDO *UDQGXFD QHO JLXJQR 4976 D 0RGHQD SHU O·HVHFX]LRQH GHOOD OHJD VWDELOLWD FRQ L YHQH]LDQL H FRQ TXHO 'XFD OL 59 PDJJLR 4976= ULVHGHUH QHOOD FRQVXOWD GL JXHUUD QHO QRPH GHO *UDQGXFD H WHQHUOR LQ0 IRUPDWR GL WXWWR O·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q LQYHVWLWXUH/ WHVWDPHQWL DSSDUWHQHQWL DOOD FDVD G·(VWH WDQWR GL )HUUDUD/ FKH GL 0RGHQD/ GHL TXDOL YL q XQ LQGLFH LQ IURQWH GHOOD ILO]D PHGHVLPD1 ;;,, +)1 5<69, &RQWHQJRQVL DQFKH LQ TXHVWD ILO]D GLYHUVH FRSLH GL GRFX0 PHQWL ULJXDUGDQWL SDUWLFRODUPHQWH OD FDSLWROD]LRQH GL 'RQ &HVDUH VRSUD )HU0 UDUD/ DOFXQH OHWWHUH H PLQXWH VRSUD XQD GLIIHUHQ]D GL FRQILQL WUD 6WD]]HPD/ H )RUQRYRODVFR QHO 493</ H UHJRODPHQWR GL HWLFKHWWD SHU O·DPEDVFLDWRUH GL 7R0 VFDQD D 0RGHQD1 ;;,, +)1 5<6:, 0LVFHOODQHD GL FRVH GLYHUVH1 )DVFLR GL VFULWWXUH H GRFX0 PHQWL DWWLQHQWL DL SULQFLSL GL &RUUHJJLR/ H GLYHUVL QHJR]LDWL SHU DFFRPRGD0 PHQWR GL GLIIHUHQ]H WUD ORUR/ H FRQ L 'XFKL GL )HUUDUD/ 0DQWRYD H 3DUPD1 $YYLVL/ FRSLD OHWWHUH GL 0RGHQD GL QRQ PROWD LPSRUWDQ]D1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4544
0$5,1$ %52*,
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
'$ 81$ /(7785$ ', &$57( ',3/20$7,&+( /8&&+(6,= ´&217(6( ( &257(6,(µ 75$ '8( &$3,7$/,
2JJHWWR GL ULFHUFD $IIURQWDQGR O·HVDPH GHL UDSSRUWL WUD LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD KR ILQLWR FRO WUDWWDUH/ FRPH ULVXOWD HYLGHQWH DQFKH DG XQD UDSLGD OHW0 WXUD/ GL HVWHQXDQWL OLWL/ VFDUDPXFFH/ JXHUUH HG DELOL LQWUHFFL GL UHOD]LRQL GLSOR0 PDWLFKH LQWHUFRUVH WUD GXH FDSLWDOL GL 6WDWL/ FKH HEEHUR FRPH SULQFLSDOH RJ0 JHWWR GHO ORUR FRQWHQGHUH O·LUUHTXLHWR GRPLQLR VXOOH WHUUH GL FRQILQH QHOOD *DUIDJQDQD VWRULFD1 /H GXH pQFODYHV OXFFKHVL GL &DVWLJOLRQH H 0LQXFFLDQR LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ LQVLH0 PH DO IUDVWDJOLDWR FRQILQH FRQ OD 9LFDULD GL *DOOLFDQR/ UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR LQIDWWL XQD TXRWLGLDQD RFFDVLRQH GL ´PROHVWLH/ WUDYDJOLµ HG DWWL WXUEDWLYL SHU TXHOOD ´TXLHWHµ WDQWR FRQWLQXDPHQWH SURFODPDWD QHJOL LQWHQWL GHL JRYHUQL/ TXDQWR VSHVVR LQIUDQWD GDJOL DELWDQWL ORFDOL1 )RQWL/ RELHWWLYL/ OLPLWL H PHWRGR GL ODYRUR /H PDL VRSLWH FRQWHVWD]LRQL WUD L *DUIDJQLQL HVWHQVL H TXHOOL OXFFKHVL VRQR SHUWDQWR OD FDXVD GHWHUPLQDQWH GHOOD TXDQWLWj FRQVLGHUHYROH GHOOH FDUWH/ SUR0 GRWWH GDJOL RUJDQL LVWLWX]LRQDOL GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD HG RJJL FRQVHUYDWH QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR LQ /XFFD/ DYHQWL ULOHYDQ]D SHU XQD ULFHUFD VWRULFD VX ´FRVH PRGRQHVLµ1 6HQ]D GLOXQJDUFL RUD LQ XQ PLQX]LRVR HOHQFR GHOOH IRQWL FRQVHUYDWH LQ WDOH
4545
0DULQD %URJL
$UFKLYLR4/ EDVWL TXL DFFHQQDUH DO IDWWR FKH/ DFFDQWR DL GRFXPHQWL SURGRWWL L0 VWLWX]LRQDOPHQWH/ q QHFHVVDULR DIILDQFDUH TXHOOH IRQWL ULVFRQWUDELOL QHL FRSLRVL DUFKLYL GL IDPLJOLH H SHUVRQH GHOO·ROLJDUFKLD OXFFKHVH/ L FXL PHPEUL ULFRSULUR0 QR OH QRQ WURSSR DPELWH FDULFKH GLSORPDWLFKH GL $JHQWH/ GL ,QYLDWR R GL $PEDVFLDWRUH GL /XFFD DOOH &RUWL HVWHUH1 $O ILQH GL XQD SL• DJHYROH FRPSUHQVLRQH GHOOD VHOH]LRQH GRFXPHQWDULD HI0 IHWWXDWD QHO FRUVR GL TXHVWD ULFHUFD/ q RSSRUWXQR ULFRUGDUH FKH OD 5HSXEEOLFD OXFFKHVH/ VRSUDWWXWWR QHL VXRL GXH XOWLPL VHFROL HG DOGLOj GHOO·DSSDUHQWH ´ODU0 JDµ SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DL SXEEOLFL SRWHUL/ YLHQH D ULSRUUH SURSULR ´QHOOD IDPLJOLD QRELOLDUH LO SHUQR FRQFUHWR GD FXL PXRYH WXWWR LO FRPSOHVVR LQJUDQDJJLR GL FDULFKH H SRWHUL JRYHUQDWLYLµ1 4XDQWR DO FRUSR GLSORPDWLFR OXFFKHVH UHVWD/ LQYHFH/ GD HYLGHQ]LDUH FRPH ´ODPHQWHOH H ULFKLHVWH GL HVVHUH ULFKLDPDWL R VRVWLWXLWLµ ULVXOWLQR ULFRUUHUH FRQ IUHTXHQ]D H QRQ VLDQR ´VXIILFLHQWHPHQWH VSLHJDELOL SHU OH GLIILFROWj HFRQRPL0 FKH H OD ORQWDQDQ]D GD FDVD1 ,Q TXHVWR VQREEDUH LO SUHVWLJLR SHUVRQDOH FRQQDWXUDOH DOOD FDUULHUD GLSOR0 PDWLFD q GLIILFLOH HVFOXGHUH XQ·LQFLGHQ]D GL TXHOOD PHQWDOLWj OLYHOODWULFH H0 VSUHVVD GDOO·ROLJDUFKLD DO SRWHUH= OD SUHPLQHQ]D GHO GHFRUR GHOOD IDPLJOLD/ O·RVWLOLWj SHU FKL YXROH OD JORULD LQGLYLGXDOH H OD ULFHUFD DSSDVVLRQDWD GHOOD PH0 GLHWDVµ/ FKH VDSSLDPR RUPDL FRVWLWXLUQH L FDUDWWHUL VDOLHQWL51 /D IXQ]LRQH GL GLUH]LRQH H FRQWUROOR VXO SHUVRQDOH GLSORPDWLFR q FROOH0 JLDOPHQWH HVHUFLWDWD GDJOL $Q]LDQL/ FLRq GLUHWWDPHQWH GDOO·RUJDQR HVHFXWLYR GHO JRYHUQR OXFFKHVH/ DQFKH VH SRL LO ORUR ILWWR FDUWHJJLR VL VPLVWD DWWUDYHUVR XQ·DUWLFRODWD WUDWWD]LRQH SUHVVR DOWUL 2IIL]L> LQ SUDWLFD= QRQ SL• HVFOXVLYDPHQ0 WH FRQ JOL (FFHOOHQWLVVLPL 6LJQRUL GL JRYHUQR/ FRPH DYYHQLYD ILQR DJOL LQL]L GHO ;9, VHFROR1 'D TXL OD QHFHVVLWj GL SXQWXDOL ULVFRQWUL WUD OH GLYHUVH VHULH GHL IRQGL +$Q0 ]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ 2IIL]LR VRSUD OH GLIIHUHQ]H GH· FRQILQL/ &RQVLJOLR *HQHUDOH,/ ²²²²²²²² 4 6HPEUD RSSRUWXQR VROOHFLWDUH SHUz O·DYYLR GL VSHFLILFL 5HSHUWRUL H TXLQGL XQD ORUR VL0 VWHPDWLFD UDFFROWD LQ XQ JHQHUDOH UHSHUWRULR GHOOH IRQWL DUFKLYLVWLFKH SHU 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH> D WDO ILQH SRWUHEEH FRVWLWXLUH XQ YDOLGR PRGHOOR GL ULIHULPHQWR= OD ULFHUFD GL IRQWL SHU /D ULYROX0 ]LRQH IUDQFHVH +4:;:04:<<,1 5HSHUWRULR GHOOH IRQWL DUFKLYLVWLFKH H GHOOH IRQWL D VWDPSD FRQVHUYDWH LQ ,WDOLD H QHOOD &LWWj GHO 9DWLFDQR/ 3XEEOLFD]LRQL GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR/ 6XVVLGL/ Q1 7/ 5RPD/ 4<<41 5 ,Q PHULWR VL ULQYLD D 01 %52*,/ 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD/ LQ /D ULYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH +4:;:04:<<,11 FLW1/ SS1 48804<7/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH S1 48;> HG LQROWUH= ,'1/ $ /XFFD WUD ULYROX]LRQH IUDQFHVH H 1DSROHR0 QH= FRQVLGHUD]LRQL VXOO·DSSDUHQWH PRQROLWLVPR ROLJDUFKLFR/ LQ ©$FWXP /XFH1 5LYLVWD GL VWXGL OXFFKHVLª/ ;,,,/ 405/ 4<;;/ SS1 <:04551
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4546
FKH FRQVHQWRQR GL ULSHUFRUUHUH O·LWHU WLSLFR= GDOOH LVWUX]LRQL GHWWDWH SHU O·DPEDVFHULD/ DOOH FDUWH RULJLQDOL GHOOD FRUULVSRQGHQ]D +LQ FDVR GL QHFHVVLWj DQFKH FLIUDWD,/ TXDOH ULVXOWD LQWHUFRUVD WUD LO GLSORPDWLFR GL WXUQR H JOL $Q]LDQL RSSXUH DOWUL IXQ]LRQDUL GL 2IIL]L RUPDL LQ FUHVFHQWH DXWRULWj/ FRPH LO &DQFHO0 OLHUH 0DJJLRUH +FKH VL DYYDOH GL QXPHURVL FRQILGHQWL H UHJJH WUDWWDWLYH QRQ VROWDQWR XIILFLDOL, R FRPH DOWUL RIIL]LDOL GHOOH 'LIIHUHQ]H R GHL &RQVHUYDWRUL GL 6DQLWj +VSHFLH LQ PRPHQWL GL PDJJLRU HPHUJHQ]D,1 ,O WXWWR VHQ]D WUDVFXUDUH OH UHOD]LRQL ´D YRFHµ VXOOH DPEDVFHULH VYROWH +FRVu FRPH ULIHULWH D &RQVLJOLR ULX0 QLWR,/ Qp OH UHOD]LRQL VFULWWH GHSRVLWDWH LQ &DQFHOOHULD HG LQFOXVLYH DQFKH GL TXDQWR QRQ HUD VWDWR JLXGLFDWR SUXGHQWH ULIHULUH WUDPLWH SRVWD/ QHO FRUVR GHO0 OD PLVVLRQH GLSORPDWLFD VWHVVD1 3HU ILQLUH FRQ XQ XOWHULRUH/ HYHQWXDOH/ ULVFRQ0 WUR WUD OH FDUWH SULYDWH GL TXHL VLQJROL GLSORPDWLFL> FRVu GD ULSHUFRUUHUH OR VYROJHUVL GHJOL DYYHQLPHQWL ULFKLDPDWL QHOOH ORUR PROWHSOLFL VIDFFHWWDWXUH1 5,&26758=,21( 6725,&$ ', (9(17, *$5)$*1,1,
/D WHPDWLFD SULQFLSDOH= TXHVWLRQL GL FRQILQL /·DYYHQWR GL 0RGHQD FDSLWDOH QRQ FRPSRUWD DOFXQ UHSHQWLQR PXWDPHQWR QHL UDSSRUWL GHJOL (VWHQVL FRQ OD 5HSXEEOLFD OXFFKHVH= OD TXHVWLRQH SULQFLSDOH UHVWD OD *DUIDJQDQD HG DQFRUD VRQR LQ YLJRUH L SDWWL VRWWRVFULWWL D &DVWHOQXR0 YR LO 6 JLXJQR 4875 H OD IDWLFRVD WHUPLQD]LRQH GHL FRQILQL GHOO·DQQR SULPD FLUFD OD YHVVDWD TXHVWLR GHOOD 5RQFDJOLDQD/ DQFKH VH +FRPH VHPSUH LQ TXHL OXR0 JKL, LO IXRFR FRYD VRWWR OD FHQHUH1 &RQ GHFUHWR GHO 43 QRYHPEUH 4933 q VWDELOLWR O·LQYLR GL 1LFRODR 6DQPL0 QLDWL TXDOH DJHQWH DOOD &RUWH GHOO·,PSHUDWRUH ´SHU OH FRVH GL *DUIDJQDQDµ H VXFFHVVLYDPHQWH VL UHGLJRQR OH GHWWDJOLDWH LVWUX]LRQL SHO VHWWHPEUH GHO 4934= FRPSLWR SULQFLSDOH GHOOD PLVVLRQH q ´LPSLHJDUH RJQL SRWHUH SHUFKp OD FDXVD VLD GHOHJDWD DO 6HQDWR GL XQR GL TXHVWL WUH OXRJKL= 0LODQR/ 1DSROL R 7XULQRµ61 6L WUDWWD LQIDWWL GHOOD 9HUWHQ]D &HVDUHD SHU OD GHILQL]LRQH GHL GLULWWL OXFFKH0 VL VXOOD *DUIDJQDQD/ UHFODPDWL VXOOD EDVH GHOOH DQWLFKH VFULWWXUH FRQWUR OD GR0 PLQD]LRQH HVWHQVH1 8QD TXHVWLRQH FRPSOLFDWD SHUz GDOO·DFXLUVL GHOOH WHQVLRQL VSHFLDOPHQWH D VHJXLWR GHO PXUR FRVWUXLWR GDL 3LHYDULQL DOOD FRQIOXHQ]D FRQ ²²²²²²²² 6 $5&+,9,2 ', 67$72 ', /8&&$ +G·RUD LQ SRL $6/8,/ $Q]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ Q1 958/ D1 4934 VHWW1/ SS1 64067= %,VWUXWLRQH GDWD D 01 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL VSHGLWR DJHQWH DOOD &RUWH GHOO·,PSHUDWRUH SHU OH FRVH GL *DUIDJQDQD GL VHWWHPEUH 4934 SHU GHFUHWR GH· ; QRYHPEUH 4933%1
4547
0DULQD %URJL
OD VWUDGD 'XFDOH/ SHU RVWUXLUH OD YLD FKH FRQGXFHYD D &DVWHOQXRYR VHQ]D SDV0 VDUH GDOOD 3LHYH )RVFLDQD> FRQ O·DJJUDYDQWH FKH WDOH PXUR +DQFKH D VHJXLWR GL DWWHQWL DFFHUWDPHQWL, ULVXOWDYD FRVWUXLWR VX WHUULWRULR OXFFKHVH1 6L WUDWWDYD TXLQGL GL XQ LQDFFHWWDELOH VFRQILQDPHQWR GHL 3LHYDULQL D GDQQR GHOOD &RPX0 QLWj GL &DVWLJOLRQH FKH SHUz WUDYDOLFDYD O·DVSHWWR ORFDOLVWLFR DQGDQGR DG LQ0 WDFFDUH L GLULWWL GL JLXULVGL]LRQH GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD= HUD VWDWR VIHUUDWR XQ DWWDFFR OHVLYR SHU O·DXWRULWj GL /XFFD71 ,QWDQWR OD VLWXD]LRQH VWD SUHFLSLWDQGR H/ FRPH VL DSSUHQGH GDOOH VXFFHVVL0 YH LVWUX]LRQL8 SHU OR ´VSHWWDELOH 'DPLDQR %HUQDUGLQL DQGDWR D 0LODQR O·DQQR 4935 QH· URPRUL GL *DUIDJQDQDµ/ OD 5HSXEEOLFD VL SUHRFFXSD GL GDUH OD SUR0 SULD YHUVLRQH GHL IDWWL DJJLRUQDQGR LO *RYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR H IDFHQGR VRWWR0 OLQHDUH WXWWD OD YRORQWj GL QRQ EHOOLJHUDQ]D GHL /XFFKHVL/ QDWXUDOPHQWH ILQ0 FKp= ´HVVHQGR HQWUDWL TXHOOL GL 0RGHQD LQ WDQWR QXPHUL GL DUPDWL KRVWLOPHQWH QHO QRVWUR 6WDWR/ VLDPR VWDWL IRU]DWL D SUHQGHU O·DUPD SHU GLIHQGHUOR H VFDF0 FLDUYHOLµ/ PD OD 5HSXEEOLFD q VRSUDWWXWWR LQWHUHVVDWD D VDSHUH/ WUDPLWH LO GL0 SORPDWLFR/ ´TXDO q O·RSLQLRQH GHO &RQWHµ1 ,O %HUQDUGLQL QRQ PDQFD GL ULIHULUH9 FRPH/ DO ULWRUQR GD 0RGHQD GHOO·DJHQWH LQYLDWRYL GDO &RQWH GL )XHQWHV SHU VROOHFLWDUH O·LPPHGLDWD GHSRVL0 ]LRQH GHOOH DUPL/ OR VWHVVR *RYHUQDWRUH DEELD DIIHUPDWR FKH ´OD 5HSXEEOLFD DQGDYD FHUFDQGR FRVH YHFFKLH GL 483 DQQL SHU WUDYDJOLDUH Vp HW DOWUL> HW TXHVWR PH OR GLVVH ² SUHFLVD LO %HUQDUGLQL ² LQ SUHVHQ]D GL GRQ *LRUJLR 0DQULTXH]/ VRJJLXQJHQGRPL FKH TXHVWR QRQ SLDFHUHEEH D 6XD 0DHVWj TXDQGR O·LQWHQGHVVHµ1 $OOD QDWXUDOH UHSOLFD GHOO·DJHQWH OXFFKHVH/ IDWWD SHU UDPPHQWDUH FKH OD 6SDJQD GDYD DSSRJJLR DOOH ULYHQGLFD]LRQL OHJDOPHQWH VRVWHQXWH GDOOD 5HSXEEOLFD/ LO &RQWH VL ]LWWu/ QHOO·LPPHGLDWR/ PD LQ DOWUD FLUFRVWDQ]D ODQFLz DO %HUQDUGLQL O·DYYHUWLPHQWR D ´FKH TXHVWD WDQWD FRQILGHQ]D GL SURWH]]LRQL QRQ FDJLRQDVVH LQ QRL >/XFFKHVL@ WDQWR DUGLUH FKH PROHVWDVVLPR DOWUL FRQ SRFD UD0 JLRQHµ1 /·RSLQLRQH GHO *RYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR/ GRQ 3HGUR (QULTXH] GH $FHQHGR &RQWH GL )XHQWHV/ q GXQTXH DVVDL FKLDUD H UDIIRU]DWD GD DOWUH LQGLVFUH]LRQL VX ´TXDOFKH SDUWLFRODUHµ VXD LQWHVD YHUVR LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD FRO TXDOH KD FRQ0 ²²²²²²²² 7
,Q PHULWR D WDOL YLFHQGH VL ULQYLD LQ SDUWLFRODUH DO FDWDORJR GHOOD PRVWUD UHDOL]]DWD D /XF0 FD/ : GLFHPEUH 4<;:043 JHQQDLR 4<;;/ D FXUD GL 51 0$57,1(//,/ 7HUUH GL FRQILQH0/D FDUWRJUDILD GHOOD 9DO GL 6HUFKLR WUD GRPLQLR OXFFKHVH HG HVWHQVH QHL VHF1 ;9,0;9,,,/ /XFFD/ &,6&8/ 4<;: 1 8 $6/8/ $Q]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ Q1 958/ D1 4935 OXJ1 49/ SS1 940951 9 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4935 RWW1 57/ SS1 55<0577/ %5HOD]LRQH GHOOR VSHWWDELOH 'DPLDQR %HUQDU0 GLQL WRUQDWR GL 0LODQR%1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4548
GRWWR OD QHJR]LD]LRQH SHU OD SURWH]LRQH VSDJQROD= XQD ´FRVD PROWR FRPRGDµ VH VL FRQVLGHUD OD SRVL]LRQH JHRJUDILFD GHL YDUL 6WDWL FKH OD 6SDJQD ´SRVVLHGH LQ ,WDOLD/ SHU KDYHUH FRQJLXQWR OD /RPEDUGLD FRQ OD 7RVFDQD GL TXHOOD SDUWHµ> LQIDWWL LO 'XFD VL q DVVXQWR O·REEOLJR ´GL ULFHYHUH/ VHPSUH FKH SDUUj D 61 01/ WXWWR TXHO QXPHUR GL VROGDWL FKH JOL SLDFHUj PDQGDUFLµ1 9DO OD SHQD DJJLXQJHUH FKH O·HSLVRGLR GHOO·LQFHQGLR GL &DVFLR q VWDWR LQ0 WHUSUHWDWR GHO WXWWR D VIDYRUH GL /XFFD LQ DPELHQWH PLODQHVH/ WDQWR q YHUR FKH ´TXDVL GD WXWWL PL q VWDWR ULVSRVWR FKH QRL VLDPR VWDWL L SULPL D IDUH OD JXHUUD FRO IXRFRµ/ FRPH VHJQDOD FRVWHUQDWR LO %HUQDUGLQL:1 Ë LQROWUH GD FRQVLGHUDUH FKH LO JRYHUQR GL 0LODQR q GHWWR RUPDL ´DUELWUR GL WXWWH OH FRVH G·,WDOLDµ FRPH DIIHUPD DQFRUD O·LQYLDWR OXFFKHVH/ FLWDQGRQH D ULSURYD O·LQWHUHVVDWD SUHVHQ]D GHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL FRQ SURSUL UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GL0 SORPDWLFL +GD 9HQH]LD DOOD 6DYRLD/ GDO *UDQ 'XFD DO 'XFD GL 3DUPD/ PD DQ0 FKH 0DQWRYD/ 8UELQR H 0RGHQD, H 111WXWWL DIIDFFHQGDWL D IDUVL YHGHUH D &RUWH/ TXDVL RJQL JLRUQR$ 1H FRQVHJXH FKH RUPDL DJOL RFFKL GHO JRYHUQR GL /XFFD LO TXDGUR q JLj DVVDL EHQ GHOLQHDWR= LQ RFFDVLRQH GL XQ TXDOVLDVL FRQWUDVWR/ VDUj 0RGHQD D SUHYDOHUH1 ,O PHGHVLPR FRQFHWWR HVFH ULEDGLWR QHOOD UHOD]LRQH VFULWWD GD 3DROR 1LHUL;/ WRUQDWR GD 0LODQR/ +59 RWWREUH 4935, GRY·HUD VWDWR VSHGLWR LQ WXWWD IUHWWD D GDU FRQWR DO *RYHUQDWRUH GHJOL XOWLPLVVLPL HYHQWL= D VHJXLWR GHOOD GHSRVL]LR0 QH GHOOH DUPL ILUPDWD WUD LO &DSLWDQR *UHJRULR 5LFFR +DJHQWH GHO &RQWH, H LO 0DUFKHVH %HQWLYRJOLR +&DSLWDQR JHQHUDOH GL 0RGHQD, VL HUDQR YHULILFDWL DOWUL ´WXUEDPHQWL SHU SDUWH GL TXHOOL GL 9DOLFRµ1 ,O VXFFHVVLYR LQYLR GHO 0DUFKHVH 0DOYH]]L SHU GLULPHUH OD QXRYD FRQWURYHUVLD FRPSRUWD GL ULFKLDPDUH GD 0L0 ODQR LO &DSLWDQR 5LFFR/ FKH VHPEUD HVVHUVL FRQWUDGGHWWR DYHQGR ODVFLDWR DL /XFFKHVL XQD VFULWWD GLYHUVD GD TXDQWR YHUEDOPHQWH DIIHUPDWR LQ &DVWHOQXR0 YR GL IURQWH D WHVWLPRQL<1 ²²²²²²²² : $6/8/ ,ELGHP1 /H QRWL]LH ULIHULWH LQWHJUDQR OD FRQRVFHQ]D GHOOH YLFHQGH JDUIDJQLQH/ GHO UHVWR JLj SL• YROWH GLYXOJDWH GDJOL VWXGLRVL ORFDOL1 9ROHQGR HYLWDUH RJQL LQXWLOH ULSHWL]LRQH GL FLWD]LRQL ELEOLRJUDILFKH QHO FRQWHVWR GHO PHGHVLPR YROXPH GL DWWL/ VL ULQYLD DOO·LQWHUYHQWR GL 3LHU /XLJL 5DJJL SHU HYHQWXDOL ULIHULPHQWL VXOOD FRSLRVD SXEEOLFLVWLFD1 ; $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4935 RWW1 59/ SS1 5540558= %5HOD]LRQH GHO PDJQLILFR 3DROR 1LHUL WRUQDWR GD 0LODQR%> PD FIU1 DQFKH ,ELGHP/ D1 4935 RWW1 43/ SS1 6806;= %,QVWUXWWLRQH GDWD D 01 3DROR 1LHUL PDQGDWR D 0LODQR DO 6LJQRU &RQWH GL )XHQWHV%1 < 3HU O·HVDWWH]]D= VL DVVLFXUD FKH HJOL WRUQDQGR KD FRQIHUPDWR DO JRYHUQR GL /XFFD FKH QRQ DYHYD GDWR DO %HQWLYRJOLR LO SRVVHVVR GHOOD WHUUD FRQWHVWDWD/ GDL /XFFKHVL ULPHVVD QHOOH PDQL GHO *RYHUQDWRUH ILQR DOOD GHILQL]LRQH GHOOD GLIIHUHQ]D/ PD FKH ´VROR O·KDYHD GDWR OLFHQ0
4549
0DULQD %URJL
$O UHVRFRQWR GHO 1LHUL/ FLUFD O·DPELJXR FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHO &DSLWDQR/ LO *RYHUQDWRUH ULEDGLVFH GL FRQRVFHUH EHQH OD TXHVWLRQH H FKH ´WXWWR VL WHUPL0 QHUj SHU JLXVWL]LDµ/ PD QRQ PDQFD GL DPPRQLUH FKH FRPXQTXH ´ELVRJQDYD TXLHWDUVL/ SHUFKp FRL URPRUL PDL VL JXDGDJQDµ1 &RVu/ PHQWUH VXL FRQILQL VL PROWLSOLFDQR OH UHFLSURFKH SURYRFD]LRQL WUD JOL XRPLQL GHOOH RSSRVWH &RPXQLWj/ OD 5HSXEEOLFD GLVSLHJD XQD ILWWD UHWH GL D0 ]LRQL GLSORPDWLFKH +EHQ VHWWH GD PDU]R D JLXJQR,= LO 6 PDU]R 4936 LQYLD D 0LODQR ´OR VSHWWDELOH 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWLµ IRUQHQGROR GHOOH VROLWH LVWUX]LRQL VXO ´UHQGHUH FRQWRµ DO *RYHUQDWRUH GHOOH XOWLPH ´DQJKHULHµ GD SDUWH PRGH0 QHVH43/ VRQR SHUz DJJLXQWH D SDUWH GHWWDJOLDWH LVWUX]LRQL44 VX TXDQWR PDJ0 JLRUPHQWH SUHPH DOOD 5HSXEEOLFD= LO GLSORPDWLFR GHYH HYLGHQ]LDUH FRPH /XFFD DEELD SUHIHULWR DUULYDUH DG XQ JLXGL]LR ´DPLFKHYROHµ FRQ OD &DVD G·(VWH/ FKH SXUH ´WLHQH LQGHELWDPHQWH RFFXSDWD XQD EXRQD SDUWH GHOOD SUR0 YLQFLD GHOOD *DUIDJQDQDµ/ VHQ]D LPEDUFDUVL LQ XQ OXQJR SURFHGLPHQWR RUGL0 QDULR1 'D TXL LO VXR ULFRUVR DOO·,PSHUDWRUH H OD FRQFHVVLRQH GHOOD GHOHJD D WUDWWDUH OD FDXVD LQ ,WDOLD SUHVVR LO *RYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR1 1H ULVXOWD HYLGHQWH O·RJJHWWR SULQFLSDOH GHOOD PLVVLRQH GHO 6DQPLQLDWL= SUHSDUDUH LO WHUUHQR SL• IDYRUHYROH D WDOH HVVHQ]LDOH YHUWHQ]D1 ,QWDQWR GD /XFFD LO &ROOHJLR GHJOL $Q]LDQL SURYYHGH D LQYLDUH &XU]LR )UDQFLRWWL GDO 'XFD GL 3DUPD SHU VROOHFLWDUH ´GL SRWHU DVVROGDUH ILQR D 833 VROGDWL QHL VXRL 6WDWL/ SHU DYHUOL SURQWL D VHUYLUH SHU GLIHVDµ GHOOD 5HSXEEOL0 FD451 Ë LO 58 DSULOH 4936 H JLj LO 49 PDJJLR VL DIIUHWWD D GHWWDUH LVWUX]LRQL DG DOWUL GLSORPDWLFL SHU YLD GH· ´UXPRUL GL *DUIDJQDQDµ= 0DUWLQR %XRQYLVL q ´VSHGLWR DPEDVFLDWRUH DO 3DSDµ> /RUHQ]R %XRQYLVL q LQYLDWR TXDOH DPEDVFLDWRUH DO &RQWH GL )XHQWHV/ FRQ SDUWHQ]D LPPHGLDWD1 ,O SULPR46 KD O·LQFDULFR GL ULYHULUH 6XD 6DQWLWj H/ YDOXWDQGR OD VLWXD]LRQH ²²²²²²²² ]D GL SRWHU FRJOLHUH FHUWL IUXWWL SHQGHQWL DFFLz QRQ DQGDVVHUR D PDOHµ1 3DVVDWR SRL D &DVWHO0 QXRYR DGGLULWWXUD KD FRQIHUPDWR/ TXHVWD YROWD FRQ VFULWWXUD/ FKH DYHYD DIILGDWR LO SRVVHVVR GHO OXRJR DO 0DUFKHVH %HQWLYRJOLR1 43 1HOOR VSHFLILFR= O·LOOHFLWD HVHQ]LRQH GL JDEHOOD HIIHWWXDWD LQ &DVWHOQXRYR VXOOH ´PXQLWLR0 QL HW YHWWRYDJOLHµ GLUHWWH D &DVWLJOLRQH H 0LQXFFLDQR/ SHU FRQWR SXEEOLFR1 44 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 PDU1 6/ SS1 9:0:5= %,QVWUXWLRQL GDWH D 01 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL VSHGL0 WR D 0LODQR SHU OH QRYLWj GL *DUIDJQDQD HW SHU OD OLWH GD PXRYHUVL FRQWUR LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD1 3DUWu D Gu 6 PDU]R 4936%1 45 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 DSU1 58/ SS1 ;50;6= %,QVWUXWLRQH GDWD DOOR VSHWWDELOH &XU]LR )UDQ0 FLRWWL DOOL 58 DSULOH 4936 SHU 3DUPD%1 46 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 PDJ1 49/ SS1 ;<0<6= %,QVWUXWLRQH GDWD D 0DUWLQR %RQYLVL VSHGLWR
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
454:
HVSORVLYD LQ *DUIDJQDQD/ WDOH FKH ´GD RJQL KRUD VL SXz IDUH TXDOFKH IDWWR G·DUPH GL FRQVLGHUDWLRQHµ/ GHYH ULFRUGDUH DO 3DSD TXDQWR /XFFD GHVLGHUL VHPSUH OD TXLHWH/ PD DQFKH TXDQWR ´VLDPR ULVROXWL GL GLIHQGHUH FRQ WXWWH OH IRU]H OH FRVH QRVWUH FRPH RJQL UDJLRQ ULFKLHGHµ> VHQ]D WUDVFXUDUH LQROWUH GL FRQVLGHUDUH FRPH DSSDUH ´VSURSRU]LRQDWRµ OR VIRU]R FRQWUR OD 5HSXEEOLFD IDWWR GDO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD LQ *DUIDJQDQD/ DO SXQWR FKH ´FL KD GDWR RFFDVLRQH GL GXELWDUH FKH SRVVL KDYHUQH TXDOFKH IRPHQWRµ/ DQ]L GDOOH XOWLPH OHWWHUH SHUYHQXWH GD 0LODQR ULVXOWD FKH ´LO &DUGLQDOH GD (VWH VLD VWDWR SURPRWRUH GL TXHVWL PRWLYL G·DUPLµ H FKH LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD ´KD LQJURVVDWR OH VXH JHQWL LQ *DUIDJQDQD HW IDWWR PDJJLRUL SURYYLVLRQLµ1 ,O VHFRQGR GLSORPDWLFR47 KD O·LQFDULFR GL DJJLRUQDUH LO &RQWH GL )XHQWHV ULEDGHQGR ´FKH QRL GHVLGHULDPR OD TXLHWH HW VDUHPR SURQWL D GLVDUPDUH HW REHGLUH DL FRPDQGDPHQWL GL 6XD (FFHOOHQ]D/ VHPSUH FKH VLDPR VLFXUL GL QRQ KDYHUH D ULFHYHUH RIIHVHµ/ FRVD TXDQWR PDL LPSUREDELOH YLVWR LO JUDQ PRYL0 PHQWR GL IRU]H= D &DVWHOQXRYR F·q LO 0DUFKHVH %HQWLYRJOLR FRQ ;333 VROGDWL FLUFD/ QHO )ULJQDQR FL VRQR ´433 ODQFLH/ 733 DUFKLEXJLDUL D FDYDOOR HW PLOOH IDQWLµ1 6L VRVSHWWD FKH FLz DYYHQJD ´FRQ TXDOFKH JUDQ IRPHQWR GHO *UDQ 'X0 FDµ SHU FXL QRQ VL q SRWXWR IDU DOWUR FKH ´SURYHGHUH FRQ OH QRVWUH IRU]H L QR0 VWUL OXRJKL GL *DUIDJQDQD HW JOL DOWUL GHOOR 6WDWR QRVWUR> HW OH FRVH VRQR LQ WHUPLQH FKH GD RJQL KRUD SRQQR VXFFHGHUH LQFRQYHQLHQWL HW GLVRUGLQL GL JUDQ FRQVLGHUDWLRQHµ1 ,QWDQWR 'DPLDQR %HUQDUGLQL48 YLHQH LQFDULFDWR GL UHFDUVL D )LUHQ]H GDO *UDQ 'XFD H VXELWR GRSR GD 6XD 0DHVWj LQ 6SDJQD49/ PHQWUH DQFRUD XQ DOWUR ²²²²²²²² $PEDVFLDWRUH DO 3DSD GL JLXJQR O·DQQR 4936 SHU L URPRUL GL *DUIDJQDQD%1 47 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 PDJ1 49/ SS1 <:0<<= %,QVWUXWWLRQH GDWD D /RUHQ]R %RQYLVL VSHGLWR $PEDVFLDWRUH DO &RQWH GL )XHQWHV SHU OH FRVH GH· URPRUL GL *DUIDJQDQD1 3DUWu DOOL 49 PDJ0 JLR%1 48 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936/ SS1 4330434= %,QVWUXWLRQH GDWD DOOR VSHWWDELOH 'DPLDQR %HUQDUGLQL SHU )LUHQ]Hµ SHU UHQGHUH FRQWR/ LQVLHPH DOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH UHVLGHQWH/ GHOOH FRVH JDUIDJQLQH HYLGHQ]LDQGR OD QHFHVVLWj GL GLIHQGHUVL FRQ OH DUPL D FDXVD GHJOL ´DLXWL FKH VRQR VWDWL GDWL GDO0 OR 6WDWR GL 61 $1 FRQWLQXDPHQWH HW GL PXQLWLRQL GD YLYHUH HW GD JXHUUD HW GL VROGDWL HW G·RJQL DOWUD FRVD QHFHVVDULDµ> IDFHQGR DOWUHVu QRWDUH FKH= ´VH EHQH DOOH YROWH VL VRQR KDYXWL DOFXQL GLVSLDFHUL FRO 'XFD $OIRQVR/ PDL HVVR 'XFD KD WHQWDWR GL HVSXJQDUH FDVWHOOL GL TXHVWR 6WDWR%1 49 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 JLX1 4:/ SS1 :<0;4= %,QVWUXWLRQH GDWD DOOR VSHWWDELOH 'DPLDQR %HU0 QDUGLQL VSHGLWR SHU 6SDJQD DOOL 4: JLXJQR 4936%1 +D LO FRPSLWR GL VSLHJDUH OD QHFHVVLWj SHU /XFFD GL ´ULFRUUHUH D 6XD 0DHVWj µ DIILQFKp IDFFLD DYYHUWLUH LO *UDQGXFD ´FKH WXWWH OH FRVH FKH VDUHQQR IDWWH FRQWUD TXHVWD 5HSXEOLFD/ UHSXWHUj IDWWH DOOL 6WDWL VXRL SURSULµ1 &RQ OH SHU0 VRQH GL PDJJLRUH FRQILGHQ]D SRWUj HVVHUH SL• SUHFLVR H FKLDULUH FKH DO QXRYR *RYHUQDWRUH
454;
0DULQD %URJL
,QYLDWR/ $QGUHD 'H 1RELOL4: q VSHGLWR D 3DUPD +47 JLXJQR 4936,> QHO IUDW0 WHPSR GRSR FKH /XFFD KD GHFUHWDWR O·HVSXOVLRQH SHU ´WXWWL L VXGGLWL GHO 'XFD GL 0RGHQDµ +56 DSULOH 4936, H FKH QHOOH WHUUH GL *DUIDJQDQD VL q JXHUUHJJLDWR FRQ OH DUPL LQ SXJQR +55 PDJJLR= DVVHGLR GL &DVWLJOLRQH> 5; PDJJLR= SUHVD GL 3DOOHURVR,/ VL q LQILQH DSSURGDWR DOOD WUHJXD FRQ UDWLILFD GHO 7 JLXJQR GD SDUWH GHO JRYHUQR OXFFKHVH> OD ILUPD GHOOD SDFH q VLJODWD4; LO 49 OXJOLR 49361 'L SDUWLFRODUH LQWHUHVVH ULVXOWD OD UHOD]LRQH4< IDWWD GD 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL DO VXR ULWRUQR GRSR EHQ 49 PHVL GL VHUYL]LR D 0LODQR/ SRLFKp LQVLHPH DOOH DFXWH RVVHUYD]LRQL ULIHULWH/ RIIUH OR VSXQWR D TXDOFKH FRQVLGHUD]LRQH GL PRGHUQD DWWXDOLWj VX WHPL JLXULGLFL1 ,QIDWWL HJOL QRQ PDQFD GL QRWDUH OD YLJLOH DWWHQ]LRQH FRQ FXL L PLQLVWUL GHO 'XFD &HVDUH G·(VWH VHJXRQR O·DQGDPHQWR GHOOD FDXVD HG DYYHUWH FKH FHUWR L 0RGHQHVL QRQ ODVFHUDQQR QLHQWH GL LQWHQWDWR ´SHU FRQVHJXLUH LO ILQH GHO GHVL0 GHULR ORURµ> VHJQDOD DOWUHVu TXHOOH FKH VRQR OH ORUR SHUVRQH GL ILGXFLD= D 0R0 GHQD KDQQR LO 6LJ1 ,PROD HG DOWUL GHSXWDWL FKH WXWWR ULYHGRQR H QRQ ´ODVFLDQR DGLHWUR SDUWLFRODUH EHQ PLQLPR FKH JOL SRVVD DUHFDUH JLRYDPHQWR H IDFLOLWDUH OD VHQWHQ]D D ORU IDYRUHµ> D 0LODQR KDQQR GXH DYYRFDWL GL ULFRQRVFLXWR PHUL0 WR H YDORUH +LO 0DOHPEUD H LO 9LVXQWLQR, FXL KDQQR DJJLXQWR XQ WHU]R ´QRPL0 QDWR LO &LYDOLHUL/ VROR SHU HVVHUH IDPLOLDUH HW FUHDWXUD GHO VLJQRU UHODWRUHµ/ EHQ FRQRVFHQGR O·LPSRUWDQ]D GL JXDGDJQDUH O·RSLQLRQH GL FRVWXL DOOD SURSULD SDU0 WH1 4XDQWR DO PRGR GL DJHYRODUH OD VROX]LRQH GHOOD VHQWHQ]D LQ VHQVR SRVLWL0 YR SHU /XFFD/ HJOL VXJJHULVFH WHVWXDOPHQWH= ´L PH]]L VRQR GXL/ O·XQR SULQFLSD0 OLVVLPR HW SRWHQWLVVLPR FKH GHSHQGHUj LPPHGLDWDPHQWH GDOO·HUDULR HW ERUVD GHOO·(FFHOOHQWLVVLPR &RQVLJOLR/ O·DOWUR XWLOH HW QHFHVVDULR FKH VDUj LO IDYRUH GH· 3ULQFLSL HW 6LJQRUL FRQILGHQWL DOOD 5HSXEEOLFDµ1 3DUROH FKLDUH FXL VL DJJLXQJH O·HOHQFR FRPPHQWDWR VXL QRPLQDWLYL GHL PHPEUL GHO 6HQDWR JLXGLFDQWH GLVWLQJXHQGR= FRORUR FKH ´QHVVXQR LQWHUHVVH JOL YROWHUj PDL GD TXHOOR FKH SHU JLXVWL]LD VHQWLUDQQRµ/ ULVSHWWR D FRORUR FKH SRVVRQR UHSXWDUVL SL• IDFLOL DG HVVHUH/ D WHPSR GHELWR/ FRUURWWL FRQ LO SULPR ²²²²²²²² GL 0LODQR VL GHVLGHUD VLDQR GDWH LVWUX]LRQL DIILQFKp IDFFLD DUULYDUH DO *UDQGXFD O·DYYHUWLPHQWR1 4: $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4936 JLX1 47/ SS1 :90::1 4; &IU1 51 0$57,1(//, +D FXUD GL,/ 7HUUH GL FRQILQH«FLW1/ SS1 ;40;71 4< $6/8/ $Q]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ Q1 958/ D1 4937 OXJ1 55/ SS1 4;404<3= %5HODWLRQH GL 01 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL ULWRUQDWR GD 0LODQR RYH HUD VWDWR PDQGDWR SHU OH QRYLWj GL *DUIDJQDQD HW SHU OD OLWH FRQWUD LO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD%1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
454<
GHL PH]]L JLj VXJJHULWL1 1p PDQFD GL VHJQDODUH FKL q JLj VLFXUDPHQWH GL SDUWH PRGHQHVH H TXDQWR ´PROWR SXROH LQ TXHOOD SLD]]D DQFRUD LO 'XFD GL 0DQWRYDµ/ FKH QRQ SXz FRQVLGHUDUVL IDYRUHYROH DL /XFFKHVL YLVWH OH VXH UHOD]LRQL GL SDUHQWHOD FRQ LO 'XFD &HVDUH/ PHQWUH LQYHFH LO 'XFD GL 3DUPD SXz ULXVFLUH XWLOH DOOD 5HSXE0 EOLFD GL /XFFD1 0ROWR SUDWLFDPHQWH VHJQDOD TXLQGL OD SRVVLELOLWj GL DFTXLVWDUVL XQR GHL VH0 QDWRUL JLXGLFDWR ´DYH]]R D YHQGHUH LO YRWR VXR SOXV RIIHUHQWLµ1 &RQVLGHUD]LRQL GL FLQLFD PRGHUQLWj DIILRUDQR FHUWR DOOD PHQWH GL FLDVFX0 QR$111 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL FRQFOXGH TXLQGL OD VXD UHOD]LRQH VFULWWD FRQ SRFKH/ PD LOOXPLQDQWL/ ULIOHVVLRQL VXOOD SROLWLFD VSDJQROD= DO *RYHUQDWRUH JLRYD SL• ´GLVVLPXODUHµ LO FRQFUHWR DLXWR ILRUHQWLQR GDWR DO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD VXL IURQWL JDUIDJQLQL/ SLXWWRVWR FKH ´WURYDUYL XQ DGHJXDWR ULPHGLRµ> H GHO UHVWR ´SHU TXDOVLYRJOLD WUDYDJOLR FKH SRWHVVH YHQLUH DOOD UHSXEEOLFD +FKH 'LR QRO YRJOLD,/ QRQ VL VLD PDL GD L PLQLVWUL UHJLL LQ ,WDOLD SHU DO]DU O·DUPH LQ DLXWR GL HVVDµ/ HV0 VHQGR FHUWR FKH ´LO SULQFLSLDU XQD JXHUUD SHU GHIHVD GL DOWUL VHQ]D VFRUJHUH LO ILQH GRYH SRVVD SRUWDUH QRQ q DWWLRQH GL VSDJQXROL/ L TXDOL FDPLQDQR VHPSUH OHQWR SHGH HW IDQQR OH FRVH ORUR FRQ PDWXULWj GL WHPSR H GL FRQVLJOLRµ531 8QD OHQWH]]D EHQ FRPSURYDWD QHOOH ´FRVH GL *DUIDJQDQDµ VH DQFKH VRO0 WDQWR VL FRQVLGHUD FKH TXHO ´PXUDFFLRµ VXOOD VWUDGD/ FDXVD VFDWHQDQWH QHOOD SULPD JXHUUD JDUIDJQLQD/ SHU SDWWR GL SDFH SRL GHPDQGDWDQH RJQL GHFLVLRQH DO *RYHUQDWRUH GL 0LODQR/ QHO 4:66 OR VL ULWURYD DQFRUD Ou= LQ DWWHVD GL VDSHUVL D FKL FRPSHWH OD VXD GHPROL]LRQH H VHPSUH D IRPHQWDUH VSLFFLROH GLVFRUGLH1 6ROWDQWR GRSR L QRWL54 HSLVRGL= GHOOD SULPD VHQWHQ]D VIDYRUHYROH DOOH UL0 YHQGLFD]LRQL GHL GLULWWL OXFFKHVL +4939,> GHJOL DIIDQQL SHU O·HVWHQXDQWH ULFRUVR LQ DSSHOOR DO &RQVLJOLR $XOLFR H SHU OD VHFRQGD JXHUUD LQ *DUIDJQDQD +4946,> FRPLQFLD D WUDVSDULUH FRQ FUHVFHQWH FKLDUH]]D SHU HQWUDPEL L JRYHUQL OD QH0 FHVVLWj GL VXSHUDUH O·RWWLFD ULGXWWLYD GHOOH VFDUDPXFFH ORFDOL DWWUDYHUVR XQD FRQFUHWD SROLWLFD GL ´EHQ YLFLQDUHµ EDVDWD SLXWWRVWR VX SLFFROH FHVVLRQL SHU TXDOFKH WHUUD LQ FRQWHVWD]LRQH/ VX DFFRUGL GL SDFLILFD]LRQH SHU OH UHFLSURFKH ²²²²²²²² 53 ,ELGHP/ OD UHOD]LRQH GL 1LFRODR 6DQPLQLDWL q ULFFD GL SDUWLFRODUL LOOXPLQDQWL OD FRPSOHVVD TXHVWLRQH1 54 ,Q PHULWR/ ROWUH D FRQVXOWDUH JOL RUPDL FODVVLFL H TXDVL DEXVDWL OLEUL GL VWRULD VXOOD *DUID0 JQDQD +GDOOH RSHUH SL• DQWLFKH/ FLRq SDUWHQGR GDL PDQRVFULWWL VHLFHQWHVFKL GL 61 %(57$&&+,/ $1 0,&277,/ 91 &$5/,/ / ILQR DOOH RSHUH D VWDPSD GL '1 3$&&+, / GL 51 5$))$(//, H GL &1 '( 67()$1, QHOOH ORUR SL• UHFHQWL ULHGL]LRQL, VL ULQYLD LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ SHU OH YLFHQGH TXL WUDWWDWH/ D= 51 0$57,1(//, +D FXUD GL,/ 7HUUH GL FRQILQH«FLW1/ S1 ;71
4553
0DULQD %URJL
FRQGDQQH GL VXGGLWL OLWLJLRVL/ VX D]LRQL GL FROODERUD]LRQH QHOOD FDWWXUD GHL UL0 VSHWWLYL EDQGLWL LQ IXJD/ LQYHFH FKH LQVLVWHUH VXOOH LQWHUPLQDELOL ULSLFFKH JLXUL0 VGL]LRQDOL GL OLPLWDWD SRUWDWD1 /D OHWWXUD GHOOH VFULWWXUH GLSORPDWLFKH PRVWUD WDOH OHQWR PXWDPHQWR/ PD TXHVWR SULPR LQGXJLDUH VXJOL HYHQWL JDUIDJQLQL G·LQL]LR VHFROR LQWHQGH UL0 VSRQGHUH DO SUHFLVR VFRSR GL IDU VHQWLUH LO ULWPR VWHVVR GHJOL HYHQWL LQ TXHO ORUR ULSHWHUVL HG DFFDYDOODUVL FRQ SUHWHVWL VHPSUH QXRYL HSSXUH VHPSUH XJXDOL +FRQWHVH PLQXWH= RUD SHU OD SHVFD RUD SHU OD OHJQD/ RSSXUH SHU OH YDFFKH R SHU OH FDSUH 111,> TXLQGL XQ SUHFLVR LQWHQWR GL IDU ULVDOWDUH OD FHQWUDOLWj GHOOH ´FRVH GL *DUIDJQDQDµ QHO FRPSOHVVR GHOOH FDUWH HVDPLQDWH/ LO SRUVL GL WDOH TXHVWLRQH FRPH O·HIIHWWLYR ILOR GL $ULDQQD GD VHJXLUH QHOO·LQWUHFFLR GL TXHOOD FRVSLFXD PROH GL VFULWWXUH FRQVHUYDWH QHOO·$UFKLYLR OXFFKHVH1 8QD FHQWUDOLWj WDQWR UDGLFDWD FKH OH VWHVVH GLYHUVH WHPDWLFKH HPHUJHQWL QHJOL DQQL FRQVHUYDQR SXU WXWWDYLD XQ FHUWR FROOHJDPHQWR D TXHO WHPD SULQ0 FLSDOH= FRVu DYYLHQH QDWXUDOPHQWH QHOOH WUDWWDWLYH SHU OD UHPLVVLRQH R FDWWXUD GL EDQGLWL> PD DQFRUD RJQL RFFDVLRQDOH FLUFRVWDQ]D GL HYHQWL OXWWXRVL R IHOLFL0 WD]LRQL SHU QDVFLWH SULQFLSHVFKH q SHU OR SL• JXDUGDWD H VIUXWWDWD SHU WUDUUH XWLOL QRWL]LH H SHURUDUH LQWHUHVVL JDUIDJQLQL> IRUVH LO YLQFROR q PHQR VWUHWWR QHO FDVR GL SURYYHGLPHQWL VDQLWDUL LQWHVL D SUHYHQLUH LQWHUH SRSROD]LRQL +GL SHU0 VRQH H GL DQLPDOL, GD SHULFRORVL FRQWDJL> PD ULVXOWDQR EHQ SL• VYLQFRODUVL GDO0 OH SDOXGDQWL TXHVWLRQL SHU GLIIHUHQ]H GL FRQILQL TXHL JXVWRVL ULWUDWWL GL 'XFKL/ 'XFKHVVH H SHUVRQDJJL GL &RUWH FKH DIILRUDQR GDOOH FDUWH LQVLHPH DOOH GHWWD0 JOLDWH DQQRWD]LRQL VXL FHULPRQLDOL R VXOO·HWLFKHWWD VHJXLWD LQ RFFDVLRQH GL YLVL0 WH H WUDWWHQLPHQWL1 'RYUj TXL EDVWDUH/ SHU VXJJHULUH TXHVWD ULFFKH]]D GRFXPHQWDULD WXWWD GD DSSURIRQGLUH/ TXDOFKH FLWD]LRQH HVHPSOLILFDWLYD GHOOH WHPDWLFKH SL• ULFRUUHQ0 WL1 8QD WHPDWLFD DVVDL IUHTXHQWH= UHPLVVLRQH H FDWWXUD GHL EDQGLWL &RQ SL• VSRUDGLFKH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H QHO FRUVR GHO ;9,, VHFROR/ PD LQ FUH0 VFHQWH XVR QHO ;9,,,/ FRPSDLRQR OH ULFKLHVWH H JOL DFFRUGL VWLSXODWL SHU RWWH0 QHUH YLFHQGHYROL FDQFHOOD]LRQL GHOOH FRQGDQQH HPHVVH GD FLDVFXQ 6WDWR FRQ0 WUR L VXGGLWL GHOO·DOWUR/ FRPH SXUH SHU FRRSHUDUH DOOD FDWWXUD GL SL• R PHQR SHULFRORVL EDQGLWL1 ,Q FHUWL FDVL DOOD EDVH GHOO·DFFRUGR VWDQQR SUHRFFXSDWH R VFDOWUH FDXWHOH= FRVu DG HVHPSLR QHOOH LVWUX]LRQL ´SHU OR VSHWWDELOH )LOLSSR 0HLµ/ LQYLDWR D &D0
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4554
VWLJOLRQH/ VL GLFH HVSUHVVDPHQWH FKH VH LO *RYHUQDWRUH GL &DVWHOQXRYR HQWUHUj QHO GLVFRUVR PDQLIHVWDQGR GL DYHU ULFHYXWR GDO 'XFD GL 0RGHQD DXWRULWj SHU SURFHGHUH DG XQD UHPLVVLRQH GL EDQGLWL/ LO /XFFKHVH GHEED ´UHQGHUOR FHUWRµ FKH OD PHGHVLPD GLVSRVL]LRQH q SURSULD GHOOD 5HSXEEOLFD/ PD SURYL D ´SHU0 VXDGHUOLµ D WHQHU FRQWR GL ´TXHOOL GL &DVWLJOLRQH FRVu LQJLXVWDPHQWH EDQGLWLµ/ LQ PRGR GD HVFOXGHUH ´LQ TXHVWR SULPR WUDWWDPHQWR/ TXHOOL GHOOD 3LHYH/ HV0 VHQGR GLYHUVLVVLPD OD FDJLRQH GHO ORUR EDQGRµ1 'RYUj LQYHFH JXDGDJQDUH WHPSR HG DWWHQGHUH QXRYL RUGLQL DOORU ´TXDQGR LO PHGHVLPR *RYHUQDWRUH LQ0 VLVWHVVH QHOOD FRULVSRQGHQ]D SHU OD UHPLVVLRQH GH· VXGGHWWL GHOOD 3LHYH HW DO0 WULµ55/ QRQ JLXGLFDQGRVL RSSRUWXQD O·DSSOLFD]LRQH GL XQ WUDWWDPHQWR SDULWHWL0 FR1 ,Q GLYHUVL FDVL O·DFFRUGR LPSOLFD XQD PDJJLRUH R PLQRUH DPSLH]]D QHOOD OLEHUD]LRQH GDOOD SHQD LQIOLWWD= FRQ O·LQVWUXPHQWXP GHO 496: YLHQH IDWWD UHPLV0 VLRQH GHOOH FRQGDQQH SHU TXDOVLDVL FDXVD56 DL EDQGLWL GL FLDVFXQ 6WDWR H SHU0 WDQWR VX WXWWL ´L GHWWL ORU EDQGL/ FRQGDQQDJLRQL HW SUHJLXGLWLL GHEEDQR HVVHUH VHQ]D VSHVD DOFXQD GHOOH SDUWL FDVVDWL HW FDQFHOODWL GD GHWWL OLEUL RYH VL WURYDV0 VHUR DFFHVLµ> QHO 4985/ DQ]LFKp XQ SHUGRQR JHQHUDOH/ WURYLDPR LQYHFH XQ LQ0 VWUXPHQWXP57 RULJLQDOH GL SRUWDWD GHOLPLWDWD D SL• VSHFLILFKH TXHVWLRQL/ SHU FXL q GLVSRVWR FKH= ´VLDQR ULPHVVL HW OLEHUDWL GDL ORUR EDQGL WDQWR SHUSHWXL FRPH WHPSRUDOL HW GD TXDOXQTXH VRUWH GL FRQGHQQDJLRQH/ WDQWR SHUVRQDOH TXDQWR SHFXQLDULD R PLVWD/ ILQR DO SUHVHQWH JLRUQR SHU FDXVD HW RFFDVLRQH GL FRQILQL/ SUHVD GL EHVWLD R WXUEDPHQWR GL MXULVGLWWLRQHµ1 ,Q DOWUL FDVL VL YHULILFDQR VSHFLILFKH ULFKLHVWH VX VLQJROL58 H GHWHUPLQDWL EDQGLWL VLD WUDPLWH L GLSORPDWLFL QHO FRUVR GHOOD PLVVLRQH/ VLD DWWUDYHUVR LO &DQFHOOLHUH 0DJJLRUH1 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH q QHL FRSLDUL GL TXHVW·XOWLPR FKH VL UHJL0 VWUDQR FRQ PDJJLRU IUHTXHQ]D WDOL LVWDQ]H= LQ DOFXQL FDVL ULVDOWD LO IDWWR FKH D0 JOL RUGLQL HPHVVL SHU O·DUUHVWR QRQ VLDQR VHJXLWL JOL HIIHWWL YROXWL/ PD DGGLULWWX0 ²²²²²²²² 55 $6/8/ $Q]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD OLEHUWj/ Q1 95</ D1 4974/ SS1 7460748= %,QVWUXWWLRQH SHU OR 6SHWWDELOH )LOLSSR 0HL SHU &DVWLJOLRQH%1 &IU1 DQFKH ,ELGHP/ 4974 RWW1 56/ SS1 95:0963= %5HOD0 WLRQH GL )LOLSSR 0HL WRUQDWR GL &DVWLJOLRQH«´ SHU L GHWWDJOL1 ,Q SDUWLFRODUH VX FRPH LO *RYHU0 QDWRUH GRSRL OD FHOHEUD]LRQH GHO FRQWUDWWR/ DO TXDOH LQWHUYHQQHUR GD :3 R ;3 SHUVRQH GHOO·XQR H GHOO·DOWUR 6WDWR/ SDUOz QRPLQDWLYDPHQWH FKLDPDQGR WXWWL TXHOOL GHOOD 3LHYH%1 56 $6/8/ &DSLWROL Q1 7:/ SS1 4<8053:1 57 $6/8/ &DSLWROL/ Q1 79/ SS1 69<06:91 58 $6/8/ $Q]LDQL DO WHPSR GHOOD /LEHUWj/ Q1 965/ SS1 54605471
4555
0DULQD %URJL
UD VLD VWDWD LQIOLWWD OD FDUFHUD]LRQH DG XQ LQQRFHQWH59 RSSXUH FKH YHQJDQR GL0 VDSSURYDWH OH PRGDOLWj GL FDWWXUD5:1 4XHVWLRQL RFFDVLRQDOL= VDQLWj/ YLVLWH H WUDWWHQLPHQWL 7DOYROWD GDL FDUWHJJL HPHUJRQR QRWL]LH VX TXHOOH PLVXUH GL SUHYHQ]LRQH VDQLWDULD GHFLVH VXOOD EDVH GL XQ WHPSHVWLYR VFDPELR GL LQIRUPD]LRQL FRQ DOWUL 6WDWL= HFFR TXLQGL FRPH/ DSSUHVR FKH D 9LHQQD ´FRQWLQXDQR L PDOLµ HG DQ]L L SHULFROL GHO FRQWDJLR VRQR ´ULDSSDUVL QHO )HUUDUHVH H &UHPDVFRµ/ YLHQH LP0 SDUWLWR RUGLQH SHUHQWRULR GL YLJLODUH DL FRQILQL +EHQFKp FLz SURYRFKL GDQQRVH UHVWUL]LRQL QHO FRPPHUFLR,5;/ DOPHQR ILQR DOOD GHFLVLRQH GHO VRVSLUDWR EDQGR GL UHYRFD5<1 &RVu FRPH SXUH HPHUJRQR OH GHQXQFH GL WUDVJUHVVLRQH SHUSHWUD0 WH D GDQQR GHOO·LQWHUD FRPXQLWj= VL KD LO GLIIRQGHUVL GL XQ·HSLGHPLD ERYLQD LQ RFFDVLRQH GHOOD TXDOH YLHQH LQWURGRWWR EHVWLDPH LQIHWWR GDO PRGHQHVH DYYD0 OHQGRVL GL PHQGDFL ´DWWHVWD]LRQLµ FKH VL WUDWWL GL DQLPDOL ´VHQ]D LQIH]LRQH H SURFHGHQWL GD OXRJR QRQ VRVSHWWR D VLPLOL PDOLµ> SHUWDQWR VL VROOHFLWDQR OH DX0 WRULWj FRPSHWHQWL DG XQD SL• GLOLJHQWH RVVHUYDQ]D631 0ROWR SL• RFFDVLRQDOL OH TXHVWLRQL LQWDYRODWH VX WUDVJUHVVLRQL QHO FHULPR0 QLDOH/ PD SXU VHPSUH SXQWLJOLRVDPHQWH ULEDGLWH= HVHPSODUH LO FDVR VROOHYDWR GD 7RPDVR %DULOL QHO 49;: SHU LO ´GLPLQXLWRµ WUDWWDPHQWR D OXL ULVHUYDWR QHOO·XGLHQ]D GDO 3ULQFLSH &DUGLQDOH +DPPHVVR D SDUODUH LQ SLHGL,/ ULVSHWWR D TXHOOR SL• RQRUHYROH XVDWR JLj QHO 4998 FRQ XQ DOWUR QRELOH OXFFKHVH/ *LX0 VHSSH $OWRJUDGL +LQYHFH DPPHVVR D SDUODUH VHGXWR, 641 1p ULVXOWD GD PHQR ²²²²²²²² 59 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 986/ D1 4:46 DJR1 44/ S1 9<3= LO &DQFHOOLHUH 0DJJLRUH FRPXQLFD D 1LFR0 ODR /XFFKHVLQL FKH DJOL RUGLQL GDWL SHU O·DUUHVWR GHL GHOLQTXHQWL QRQ QH VHJXLURQR JOL HIIHWWL GHVLGHUDWL DQ]L/ HVVHQGR VWDWR DUUHVWDWR XQ LQQRFHQWH ´FKH SRUWD O·LVWHVVR QRPH/ VHQ]D SHUz LO FRJQRPHµ/ YD SHUFLz SURQWDPHQWH VFDUFHUDWR$ 5: $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4:46 QRY1 58/ SS1 :360:37= LO &DQFHOOLHUH UHQGH QRWD DO &RPPLVVDULR GL *DOOLFDQR OD GLVDSSURYD]LRQH GHO PRGR FRQ FXL q VWDWD HIIHWWXDWD OD FDWWXUD GL *LRYDQQL %HU0 WXFFL H Gj XQD ULVHUYDWD FRPXQLFD]LRQH GL FLz/ DIILQFKp LO &RPPLVVDULR SRVVD JLXVWLILFDUVL SHU O·LQYRORQWDULR HUURUH FRPPHVVR QHOOD SXU QHFHVVDULD HVHFX]LRQH GHJOL ´RUGLQL WUDVPHVVLOL GD /RUR (FFHOOHQ]Hµ1 3HU LO VHJXLWR GHOOD YLFHQGD FIU1 ,ELGHP/ 4:47 JHQ1 47/ S1 :4<1 5; $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4:46 DJR1 47/ S1 9;<= ´>111@ H VL YHGHQR FRQ VRPPR ORUR UDPPDULFR SUH0 FOXVD ILQ KRUD OD VWUDGD DOOD OLEHUWj GHO FRPPHUFLR/ FKH WDQWR GHVLGHUDQRµ1 5< $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4:46 GLF1 5</ S1 :3:= GLIIXVD ´FRQWHQWH]]Dµ SHU OD UHYRFD GHO EDQGR GL VDQLWj HPHVVD GDO JLXVGLFHQWH GL &DVWHOQXRYR1 63 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ D1 4:48 RWW1 9/ S1 ::51 64 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 965/ D1 49;: PDJ1 43/ SS1 5350536= OD TXHVWLRQH q SRL ULVROWD IDFHQGR
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4556
´O·LQFRQYHQLHQWH FKH VHJXLYD SHU QRQ UHVWLWXLUVL OD YLVLWD GHO 6LJQRU *RYHUQD0 WRUH GL &DVWHOQXRYR DO 6LJQRU &RPPLVVDULR GL &DVWLJOLRQHµ/ DIIDUH GL FXL LQ SL• OHWWHUH WUDWWD LO &DQFHOOLHUH FRQ O·LQYLDWR D 0RGHQD/ 1LFRODR /XFFKHVLQL651 ,QWHUHVVDQWL QRWL]LH DQFKH VXL ´UHJDOL GL FLUFRVWDQ]Dµ= FRPH ´VWXFFKL/ DFTXH H JXDQWLµ R UDUH HGL]LRQL66 RSSXUH FRPH TXHOOR RIIHUWR D /RGRYLFR $QWRQLR 0XUDWRUL/ FKH OD 5HSXEEOLFD FRPPLVVLRQz DOO·$EDWH %HUQDUGLQL GDQGRJOL RWWR GREOH GD VSHQGHUH SHU ´XQ SLFFROR UHJDOR GL FRVH GL TXHVWR 3DHVHµ H SRL FRQFUHWL]]DWR QHO GRQR GL ´XQ VXSHUELVVLPR FDOLFH DOOD &KLHVD GHOOD 3RPSR0 VD/ $EED]LD GHO 6LJQRU 3UHQFLSH *LRYDQQL )HGHULJRµ167 3L• VWX]]LFDQWL/ SHU TXDQWR VSRUDGLFL/ L ULWUDWWL GL SHUVRQDJJL GHOOD &RUWH (VWHQVH GHOLQHDWL GD DOFXQL GLSORPDWLFL VDJDFL H VHQVLELOL DL PLQLPL SDUWLFRODUL/ WDOYROWD ILQR D GDUFL OD SHUFH]LRQH YLVLYD GL TXHJOL DUUHGL GL 3DOD]]R GHO FXL XVR VL HUDQR VHQWLWL RQRUDWL GXUDQWH LO SURSULR VRJJLRUQR1 2WWLPD HVHPSOLILFD]LRQH QH RIIUH *LURODPR 0LQXWROL QHO UHVRFRQWR GHOO·HVSOHWDWD PLVVLRQH D 0RGHQD DQ]L/ DWWUDYHUVR OH VXH SDUROH/ q IDFLOH WUR0 YDUVL FRQGRWWL LQVLHPH D OXL ´FRQ GXH FDUUR]]H HW VWDIILHUL GL &RUWH/ FRQ TXDW0 WUR WRUFLH DFFHVHµ ILQR DO 3DOD]]R GXFDOH H Ou RVSLWDWL ´ LQ XQ ULFFR HW QRELOH DSSDUWDPHQWR GL VHWWH VWDQ]H VHJXLWH FRQ LO EDOGDFFKLQR DO]DWR GL YHOOXWR FUHPL]Lµ1 /D VXD VWDQ]D ULVXOWD ´DGGREEDWD QRELOPHQWH GL SDUDPHQWL HW OHWWR GL YHOOXWR FUHPL]L FRQ WULQH G·RUR HW FRVu OH DOWUH VWDQ]H D SURSRUWLRQH SHU FRPPRGR GHL JHQWLOKXRPLQL HW VHUYLW•1µ *UDQGL JOL DSSUH]]DPHQWL ´QRQ VROR SHU O·DEERQGDQ]D QHOOH YLYDQGHµ/ PD DQFKH SHU O·RQRUH GL DYHUH SRVWR ´VRFWR LO %DOGDFFKLQR HW VHUYLWL WXWWL GDL 3DJJL GL 6XD $OWH]]D/ VFRSHUWL/ FKH VRQR 6L0 JQRUL WLWRODWL/ FRQ VFDOFR HW VRWWRVFDOFR HW WULQFLDQWH WXWWR LQ QHUR HW VHJXLWR FRQ RJQL VRUWD GL HVTXLVLWH]]D«µ1 1p PDQFD GL PDJQLILFDUH OD YLVLWD DO SULPRJHQLWR 3ULQFLSLQR $OIRQVR ´FKH VWDYD LQ IDVFH LQ XQD EHOOLVVLPD FXOOD G·DUJHQWR/ DFFRPRGDWD HW UHWWD GD TXDW0 WUR FRORQQH FRO VXR VRSUDFLHOR WXWWR G·DUJHQWR HW SRVWRYL VRSUD WXWWR LO %DO0 GDFFKLQR D FXL DVVLVWHYDQR DOFXQH PDWURQHµ> FRVu FRPH QRQ PDQFD GL IRUQLUH TXDOFKH DSSHWLWRVD QRWL]LD VXO 'XFD )UDQFHVFR ,/ DOORUD JLRYDQH SDGUH GL ´56 DQQL LQ FLUFD >111@ DOWR GL YLWD HW EHQ FRPSOHVVR GL FRUSR HW GL FDUQDWR ROLYD0 VWUR/ YHVWH DOOD 6SDJQROD SHU OD FLWWj/ PD LQ FDPSDJQD DOOD )UDQVHVH1 7XWWL VL ²²²²²²²² DSSHOOR DOO·LQYDULDELOLWj GHOOD QRUPD GL ULFHYHUH JOL LQYLDWL LQ SLHGL/ VDOYR QHFHVVLWj GRYXWH DG LQGLVSRVL]LRQH R ´ D PRWLYR G·LQFRPPRGR µ1 65 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 986/ D1 4:48 DJR1 5;/ VHW1 53/ RWW1 9/ SS1 :990:9</ ::61 66 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 965/ D1 49;: PDJ1 43/ S1 5731 67 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 986/ D1 4:49 RWW1 54/ SS1 ;450;461
4557
0DULQD %URJL
DFFRUGDQR DG HVVDJHUDUH OH RWWLPH TXDOLWj GL TXHVWR 3UHQFLSH GDQGROL SHU SULQFLSDOH DWWULEXWR XQD VLQFHUD HW EXRQD FRQVFLHQ]D> q ]HODQWLVVLPR QHO VHU0 YL]LR GL 'LR> GL XQD KDELOLWj HW LQWHOOLJHQ]D VWUDRUGLQDULD/ DVVLGXR HW IUHTXHQWH DL QHJRWLL/ L TXDOL FRQVXOWD HW GLVSDFFLD OD PDWWLQD SHU WHPSR> HW TXDQGR JOL UHVWD FRPRGLWj V·LPSLHJD LQ HVHUFLWLL FDYDOOLHUHVFKL/ FRPH GL FDYDOFDUH/ JLRFDUH D SDOOD D FRUGD/ DO PDJOLR/ HW DQGDUH DOOD FDFFLDµ> Qp WUDODVFLD GL DQQRWDUH FKH OD 'XFKHVVD 0DULD +GD 3DUPD, ´q XQD EHOOLVVLPD VLJQRUD HW SDVVD IUD ORUR WDOH DPRUH HW FRULVSRQGHQ]D FKH QRQ SXz GDUVL DXJXPHQWRµ H VRSUDWWXWWR FKH ´QRQ V·LQIUDPHWWH LQ QHJRWLL/ PD VH VL VFRSUH GHVLGHURVD GL TXDOFKH FRVD QRQ JO·q QHJDWDµ168 8Q ULWUDWWR GL GRQQD FKH PHJOLR VL SUHFLVD FRQ 3DROLQR 6DQWLQL QHO 4979/ DOORUFKp QH FRPPHQWD OD PRUWH TXDOH ´JUDQGLVVLPR GDQQRµ/ HVVHQGR FRQ /HL ´FDVFDWD OD FRORQQD SULQFLSDOH/ FKH VRVWHQHYD LO SHVR TXDVL WXWWR GHO *RYHU0 QRµ GDWR FKH LO 'XFD EDGD DOOH UHOD]LRQL HVWHUH/ PHQWUH /HL LQYHFH ´PLUDYD DO FHQWUR HW DOOL LQWHUHVVL SURSUL GHOOR 6WDWRµ169 8Q DOWUR EXRQ HVHPSLR GL VLPLOL ULWUDWWL GL &RUWH q RIIHUWR GD 7RPDVR %D0 ULOL FKH/ GL ULWRUQR GDOOD VXD PLVVLRQH GLSORPDWLFD LQ 0RGHQD QHO PDJJLR 49;:/ FRQ SRFKH SHQQHOODWH DSSURSULDWH GLVHJQD DOFXQL LQWHUHVVDQWL SURILOL WUD FXL TXHOOR VX )UDQFHVFR ,,= ´,O 6HUHQLVVLPR 6LJQRU 'XFD q SUHVHQWHPHQWH LQ HWj GL 5: DQQL/ GL VWDWXUD EHQ JUDQGH/ GL FRPSOHVVLRQH H VDOXWH DOTXDQWR JUDFL0 OH/ GL JHQLR H VHQWLPHQWL SLLVVLPL/ GL FRQVFLHQ]D LOOLEDWD H FKH QHOOD VXD JLR0 YHQW• ODVFLDWD D SDUWH RJQL SL• OLEHUD LQFOLQD]LRQH H WUDWWHQLPHQWR/ VL GLYHUWH VRODPHQWH TXDOFKH YROWD FRQ OD PXVLFD GL FXL JUDQGHPHQWH VL GLOHWWD WUDWWDQ0 GR FRQ EXRQL VWLSHQGL PROWL GHL PLJOLRUL FDQWRUL> DPPHWWH TXDVL RJQL JLRUQR DOO·XGLHQ]D OL VXRL VXGGLWL FKH O·DPDQR H O·DGRUDQR> VRSU·LQWHQGH FRQ DWWHQ0 ]LRQH SDUWLFRODUH DO JRYHUQR GH VXRL 6WDWL HW DPPLQLVWUD FRQ VFUXSRORVLWj OD JLXVWL]LD/ SRLFKp KDYHQGR SRFKL DQQL VRQR/ VRSUD UHODWLRQH GH VXRL PLQLVWUL/ IDWWR PRULUH XQ VXR DWWXDO VHUYLWRUH SUHWHVR UHR GL IXUWR TXDOLILFDWR QHOO·LVWHVVD VXD FDPHUD GL ULSRVR/ SHU HVVHUVL GRSRL GLVFRSHUWR LO PHGHVLPR LQQRFHQWH H ULWURYDWR FROSHYROH XQ SDJJLR G·KRQRUH GL IDPLJOLD QRELOH/ FKH KDYHQGR VHUYLWR GL WHVWLPRQLR SHU DJJUDYDUH O·LQQRFHQWH JLj FRQGDQQDWR/ IX FRQ PRUWH VHJUHWD H YLROHQWD SULYDWR GL YLWD QHOOH FDUFHUL GHOOD )RUWH]]D/ V·q UHVR GRSRL LQ TXD FRVu LUUHVROXWR QHO WHUPLQDUH OH FDXVH FDSLWDOL FKH >«@ OH OD0 VFLD WXWWDYLD SHQGHQWL/ UHVWDQGR SHU TXHVWD FDJLRQH SL• GHOLQTXHQWL QHOOH FDU0 ²²²²²²²² 68 69
$6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 95</ D1 4967 PDJ1 7/ SS1 44<04731 $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 963/ D1 4979/ S1 6431
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OD 5HSXEEOLFD GL /XFFD
4558
FHUL GD GXH R WUH DQQL LQ TXD UHIHULWL QHOOD SHQD GHOO·XOWLPR VXSSOLFLRµ16: 1DWXUDOPHQWH QH HVFRQR GHOLQHDWL VROWDQWR ULWUDWWL DEER]]DWL/ FKH QHFHVVL0 WDQR GL XOWHULRUL FRQIURQWL H VWLPRODQR SL• FDSLOODUL ULFHUFKH VXJOL DQWLFKL GR0 FXPHQWL> PHQWUH LQWDQWR DOWUL SURILOL ELRJUDILFL DQFRUD UHVWDQR GD VFRSULUH HG HVSORUDUH6;/ PDJDUL OHJJHQGR QHOOH FRUULVSRQGHQWL FDUWH PRGHQHVL= SHU YHGHUH OH PHGHVLPH FRVH DQFKH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD GHOO·DOWUD &DSLWDOH1
²²²²²²²² 6: $6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 965/ D1 49;: PDJ1 43/ SS1 55305541 6HJXRQR QRWL]LH VXO ´3UHQFLSH &DU0 GLQDOH >111@ GL 65 DQQL/ GL VWDWXUD PHGLRFUH/ PDFLOHQWR LQ YROWR H JUDFLOH GL FRUSRUDWXUD1 3UHQ0 FLSH GL FRVWXPL LQFRUURWWL/ GL YLUW• VLQJRODUL H GL SHUIHWWD FRJQL]LRQH QHOOH VFLHQ]H OHJDOL H WHR0 ORJDOL/ YLYH VHQ]D OXVVR FRQ JUDQGLVVLPD PRGHUD]LRQH HW HFRQRPLD >111@µ1 4XDOFKH UDSLGR FHQQR DQFKH VXL 3ULQFLSL /XLJL/ )RUHVWR/ &HVDUH ,JQDWLR/ QRQFKp VXL WUH ´6HJUHWDUL GL 6WDWR FKH JLRUQDOPHQWH FRQVXOWDQR OH FDXVH H ULVROXWLRQL SL• JUDYL FRQ 6XD $OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD H FKH LQ PROWH ULVROYRQR GD SHU ORUR LVWHVVL1 $ YLFHQGD H SHU WXUQR D TXDWWUR PHVL SHU FLDVFKH0 GXQR VRSU·LQWHQGRQR DOOD GLUH]LRQH GHO JRYHUQR HW DOOD VSHGL]LRQH GH· QHJR]LL SHU 0RGDQD/ 5HJJLR H OD *DUIDJQDQD FRQ OL ORUR DQQRQFL GHSHQGHQGR WXWWL OL *RYHUQDWRUL H ,XVGLFHQWL QHO0 OH ULVROX]LRQL GD SUHQGHUH GDOOD ORUR DXWRULWj HW DUELWULR1 )DQQR TXHVWL 0LQLVWUL OD SULPD ILJXUD H VHQ]D ULJXDUGR DOOD EDVVH]]D GHOOD QDVFLWD G·DOFXQL GL HVVL VRQR GD WXWWL ULYHULWL ILQR DG KDYH0 UH OD SUHFHGHQ]D H OD PDQR GD SULPDULL FDYDOLHUL GHOOD &RUWH«µ 6;'L SDUWLFRODUH LQWHUHVVH JOL RFFDVLRQDOL DFFHQQL DOOD ILJXUD GHO ´3DGUH *LRYDQ %DWWLVWD G·(VWH FDSSXFFLQRµ/ VLD QHO VRWWROLQHDUH ©>111@ FKH DOFXQL FRQWLQXDYDQR D WUDWWDUOR G·$OWH]]D HW SDUWLFRODUPHQWH L 0LQLVWUL GHO 3UHQFLSH/ PD FKH GD ORUR QRQ HUD DSSURYDWR/ QRQ HVVHQGR SL• 'XFD PD Vu EHQH VWLPDYDQR DJJLXVWDWR GL WUDWWDUOR GL 6HUHQLVVLPRµ SHU ULJXDUGR DOOD QDVFLWD FRPH DOOD VFHOWD UHOLJLRVD> VLD QHO ULIHULUH GHOOD VLFXUD ´FRQVROD]LRQH FKH VHQWH GL HVVHUVL ULWLUD0 WR GDL SHQVLHUL GHO PRQGR SHU KDYHU FRPRGLWj GL VHUYLUH 'LR HW D TXHVWR HIIHWWR VL HUD DOORQ0 WDQDWR GL 0RGHQD HW WUDWWHQXWRVL LQ $OHPDJQD HW SXU KRUD VWD SHQVDQGR GL VHJUHJDUVL SL• FKH VDUj SRVVLELOH GD TXHOOH FRQWUDGH/ SHUFLz KD LQ DQLPR GL IDUVL IDEEULFDUH XQ SRFR GL FRQYHQWR LQ *DUIDJQDQD µ1 $OWUHWWDQWR LQWHUHVVDQWH DSSUHQGHUH FKH LO 'XFD ´ULYHULVFH JUDQGHPHQWHµ VXR 3DGUH H FKH ´EHQ VSHVVR OR YD D YLVLWDUH DO FRQYHQWRµ EHQFKp (JOL ´SDUH FKH VROR V·LPSLHJKL FRQ LO ILJOLR SHU TXHL QHJRWLL FKH SRUWDQR FRQ ORUR FRQVHJXHQ]D GL TXLHWH HW KDE0 ELQR DSSDUHQ]D GL FDULWj«ª +$6/8/ ,ELG1/ Q1 95</ D1 4967 PDJ1 7/ SS1 4560457/ 46<,1
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
455:
5,7$ 6(9(5,
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O·,QJKLOWHUUD QHO ·9331 ,O VRJQR GL 0DULD GL 0RGHQD UHJLQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD
0RGLQD/ FKH FLWWj q PDL TXHVWD" (UD OD FLWWj GL *XLGR 0D]]RQL/ VFXOWRUH GL WHUUHFRWWH SROLFURPH FKH (QULFR 9,, YROHYD DWWLUDUH LQ ,QJKLOWHUUD SHU IDUVL FRVWUXLUH XQ VHSROFUR DOOD PDQLHUD LWDOLDQD> HUD OD FLWWj GHO JLXULVWD *LURODPR 3UHYLGHOOL4 FKH GLIHVH OD FDXVD GL GLYRU]LR GL (QULFR 9,,, SUHVVR OD 6DQWD 6H0 GH/ HUD OD FLWWj GHO SLWWRUH 1LFKRODV %HOOLQ FKH GD )RXQWDLQHEOHDX VL UHFz D /RQGUD SHU SRL SDVVDUH DG DIIUHVFDUH LO SDOD]]R UHDOH GL 1RQVXFK51 8Q GUDPPD DQRQLPR GHO 48<3/ LQWLWRODWR /DHOLD q DPELHQWDWR/ SHU WXWWD OD SULPD SDUWH/ D 0RGHQD D PHWj GHO VHFROR ;9,1 1HOO·DWWR WHU]R GXH SURYHUEL YHQJRQR FLWDWL LQ ODWLQR LQ PRGR FULSWLFR= ©7DXUXV PRGHQHQVLV KDEHW GXUXP FRUQX VHG PROOH FRULXPª H ©6HPHO LQ DQQR WDXUXV QRQ UHSHULHWXU 0RGHQDHª1 ,O GUDPPDWXUJR 7KRPDV 0LGGOHWRQ QHOO·DWWR TXLQWR/ VFHQD SULPD GHOOD VXD FRPPHGLD GL PDJJLRU VXFFHVVR/ 7KH 5RDULQJ *LUO +4943,/ PHWWH LQ VFHQD XQ SHUVRQDJJLR/ 7UDSGRRU/ FKH VL YDQWD GHL VXRL YLDJJL/ G·DYHU YLVWR SL• GL GRGLFL FLWWj LWDOLDQH/ H/ WUD TXHVWH 0RGHQD1 3RFR SL• GL XQ·DQQR GRSR LO PDWULPRQLR GL 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH FRO GXFD GL <RUN/ -DPHV 6WXDUW6/ IX UDSSUHVHQWDWD XQD FRPPHGLD LQWLWRODWD/ 7UDSSROLQ/ 7KH 6XSSRVHG 3ULQFH GL $VWRQ &RNDLQ +UL0 SUHVR DQFKH QHO 49;7,7/ FKH ULVDOLYD/ FRPH GDWD GL FRPSRVL]LRQH/ DOO·LQL]LR ²²²²²²²² 4 &RQVLOLXP '1 +LHURQ\PL 3UHYLGHOOL SUR LQYLFWLVVLPR 5HJH $QJOLDH/ %RORJQD 4865 R 5RPD/ $1 %ODGR/ 48651'XH FRSLH GHOO·RSHUD VL WURYDQR SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD (VWHQVH GL 0RGHQD FRQ VHJQDWXUD 091+1 <4; +4, H +5,1 5 &IU1 51 3,&&,1(//,/ 1LFRODV %HOOLQ/ LQ ©0RGHQD 6WRULDª/ ,9/ 48 VHWWHPEUH 4<<9/ SS1 60:1 6 3HU XQD VRPPDULD ELEOLRJUDILD VXOO·HYHQWR ULPDQGR D ,O PDWULPRQLR UHDOH GL 0DULD GL 0RGH0 QD27KH 5R\DO :HGGLQJ RI 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD1 7HVWL H LPPDJLQL GDOO·,QJKLOWHUUD2:RUGV DQG 3LFWXUHV IURP (QJODQG +49:7049;;,/ D FXUD GL 51 6(9(5,/ 0RGHQD 4<<6/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ SS1 :0591 7 &IU1 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV RI WKH 5HVWRUDWLRQ 499304:33/ D FXUD GL 31 '$1&+,1/ 1DQF\ 4<;7/ 3DUW ,,= 49::049<3/ YRO1 7/ S1 8781
455;
5LWD 6HYHUL
GHO VHFROR1 $QFKH TXL LO YLDJJLDWRUH +RUDWLR QDUUD GHL VXRL YLDJJL LWDOLDQL H GHOOH PDJQLILFKH FLWWj YLVLWDWH/ WUD OH TXDOL ©0RGHQD/ KDSSLHVW RI WKHP DOOª81 0RGHQD/ GRSR LO 49:6/ q OD FLWWj GHOOD PRJOLH GHO GXFD GL <RUN/ SHUFLz XQ RPDJJLR DOOD JLRYDQH H EHOOD 0DULD %HDWULFH HUD G·REEOLJR/ PD 0RGHQD JLj VSOHQGHYD GL OXFH SURSULD SULPD DQFRUD GHOOD VXD QDVFLWD1 )UDQFHVFR , FRO VXR JRYHUQR LOOXPLQDWR H VRSUDWWXWWR SHU DOFXQL DVSHWWL GHO VXR PHFHQDWLVPR IX G·HVHPSLR DOOR VWHVVR /XLJL ;,9 GL )UDQFLD1 6L FRVWL0 WXu/ LQ QRPH GHOOH EHOOH DUWL/ XQ DVVH 3DULJL00RGHQD/ VHFRQGR 3HWHU %XUNH9 1 (QWUDPEL TXHVWL SULQFLSL VL IHFHUR IDUH XQ EXVWR GDO %HUQLQL QHOOD VWHVVD SRVD LPSHULRVD/ HQWUDPEL JRGHWWHUR GHL VHUYLJL GHOO·DUFKLWHWWR *DVSDUH 9LJDUDQL/ DELOH DQFKH QHJOL DOOHVWLPHQWL SHU OH IHVWH D FRUWH1 /XLJL ;,9 FRQFHVVH XQD SHQVLRQH DO VHJUHWDULR GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD/ *LURODPR *UD]LDQL/ DIILQFKp OR JORULILFDVVH1 /H GHVFUL]LRQL GHOO·LQFRURQD]LRQH H GHOOH QR]]H GHO UH IUDQFHVH IXURQR SXEEOLFDWH LQ LWDOLDQR SHU RWWHQHUH PDJJLRUH ULVRQDQ]D SUHVVR LO 9DWL0 FDQR/ SULPD GL WXWWR/ H SRL QHOOH SLFFROH FRUWL GDOOH JUDQGL WUDGL]LRQL DUWLVWL0 FKH/ FRPH L 0HGLFL HG L *RQ]DJD/ H SUREDELOPHQWH IXURQR GLUDPDWH GD 0R0 GHQD FKH YDQWDYD LO UXROR GL LQWHUORFXWRUH SULYLOHJLDWR FRQ OD )UDQFLD LQ TXH0 VWR PRPHQWR1 1RQ q XQ FDVR/ GXQTXH/ FKH LO ILJOLR GL )UDQFHVFR ,/ $OIRQVR ,9/ SDGUH GL 0DULD %HDWULFH/ DEELD VSRVDWR /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L/ QLSRWH GHO FDU0 GLQDOH 0D]DULQR/ LO SRWHQWH SULPR PLQLVWUR GHO UH DVVROXWLVWD/ /XLJL ;,91 /D )UDQFLD/ OD FRUWH GHO 5H 6ROH/ q DQFKH OD PHGLDWULFH SHU OH QR]]H GL 0DULD %HDWULFH FRQ -DPHV 6WXDUW/ GXFD GL <RUN1 -DPHV HUD FUHVFLXWR D 9HUVDLO0 OHV1 'RSR OD WUDJHGLD GHOOD GHFDSLWD]LRQH GHO SDGUH &DUOR ,/ HJOL VL HUD ULIXJLD0 WR QHOOD SDWULD PDWHUQD/ GRYH OR ]LR/ LO UH/ QRQ SRWHYD FKH WUDWWDUOR FRPH XQ SDUL 1 $ FRQWDWWR TXRWLGLDQR FRQ OD PDJQLILFHQ]D GL 9HUVDLOOHV/ FRQREEH DQ0 FKH ©WKH SRZHU DQG GLVSOD\ª/ LO SRWHUH H O·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²²²²²²²² 8 &IU1 (1 +1 68*'(1/ $ 7RSRJUDSKLFDO 'LFWLRQDU\ WR WKH :RUNV RI 6KDNHVSHDUH DQG KLV )HOORZ 'UDPDWLVWV/ 0DQFKHVWHU 4<58/ YRFH= ´0RGHQDµ H 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV RI WKH 5HVWRUDWLRQ 499304:33/ D FXUD GL 31 '$1&+,1/ 1DQF\ 4<;4/ 3DUW ,= 4993049:9/ YRO14/ S1 9541 9 31 %85.(/ /D IDEEULFD GHO 5H 6ROH/ 0LODQR 4<<6/ S1 5881
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
455<
FKH O·DEEDWH 5L]]LQL/ UHVLGHQWH PRGHQHVH D 3DULJL HUD JLj VWDWR DYYHUWLWR1 Ë FRVu FKH HQWUD LQ VFHQD OD JLRYDQH LQJHQXD 0DULD %HDWULFH FDWWROLFD H ILOR0 IUDQFHVH/ PRJOLH LGHDOH SHU LO GXFD GL <RUN:1 8QD VFHOWD GLQDVWLFD PROWR LQIHOLFH/ LQYHFH/ VHFRQGR OD +RXVH RI &RP0 PRQV1 'DOOH WUDVFUL]LRQL GHO &DOHQGDU RI 6WDWH 3DSHUV/ LQ GDWD 6 QRYHPEUH 49:6/ VL DSSUHQGH GL XQ ©DGGUHVV111 DJDLQVW WKH 'XNH RI <RUN·V PDUULDJH ZLWK WKH 'XFKHVV RI 0RGHQDª;1 ,QIDWWL OD FDPHUD GHL &RPXQL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH ERFFLz LO PDWULPRQLR H/ WXWWDYLD/ LO UH LQ SHUVRQD VL UHFz D 'RYHU SHU ULFHYHUH OD JLRYDQH 'XFKHVVD/ OR ]LR H OD PDGUH DO ORUR DUULYR/ FRPH ULIHULVFH LO &DOHQ0 GDU RI 6WDWH 3DSHUV/ LQ GDWD 54 QRYHPEUH<1 '·DOWURQGH OH LQTXLHWXGLQL LQJOHVL HUDQR PRWLYDWH1 ,O 4< VHWWHPEUH 49:6/ SDSD &OHPHQWH ;/ LQVROLWDPHQWH/ LQ0 YLDYD XQ EUHYH D 0DULD %HDWULFH SHU HVRUWDUOD DOOH QR]]H SHU XQ QRELOH VFRSR UHOLJLRVR/ TXHOOR GL IDUVL VWUXPHQWR GHOOD YHUD IHGH= ©RUWKRGR[ D UHOLJLR SHU WH LQ H[FHOVR SRVLWD SULVWLQDH LWHUXP OXFL DF VHFXULWDWL UHGGHUHWXUª431 $ FRUWH 0DULD %HDWULFH IX DFFROWD FRPH XQD ILJOLD/ LQYHFH /DXUD 0DUWL0 QR]]L VXVFLWz VROR DQWLSDWLD H VGHJQR WUD OH GDPH/ XQ SR· SHU LO VXR FRPSRU0 WDPHQWR VXSHUER GDYDQWL DOOD UHJLQD &DWHULQD GL %UDJDQ]D/ XQ SR· SHUFKp LO VXR DUULYR D /RQGUD/ OD VXD IDPD GL FDWWROLFD LQWUDQVLJHQWH/ QLSRWH GHO FDUGL0 QDOH 0D]DULQR/ GLHGH OXRJR DG XQD PDQLIHVWD]LRQH SRSRODUH D 6RXWKZDUN/ DO GL Oj GHO 7DPLJL/ GXUDQWH OD TXDOH IX EUXFLDWD XQ·HIILJLH GHO SDSD GHO SHVR GL 83 OLEEUH1 8Q FRPPHQWR VX TXHVWL DYYHQLPHQWL/ UHSHULWR QHJOL DUFKLYL UHDOL/ LQ GDWD 4 GLFHPEUH/ 49:6/ UHFLWD=? ZH DUH OLNH WR EH LQYROYHG LQ PDQ\ XQDYRLGDEOH WURXEOHV/ EXW IRU SDUWLFXODUV , UHIHU \RX WR IDU EHWWHU KDQGV/ DQG DXWKRUV PRUH DXWKHQWLF !441 6L SURILODYDQR GHL JURVVL JXDL1 8QD OXQJD LQWHUURJD]LRQH/ LQWLWRODWD 9HUEXP VDSLHQWLV/ IX SUHVHQWDWD DOOH GXH FDPHUH QHO JHQQDLR GHO 49:7 SHU DYHUH VSLHJD]LRQL VXOO·DVWHQVLRQH GD SDUWH GHO GXFD GL <RUN GDL VDFUDPHQWL GHOOD &KLHVD G·,QJKLOWHUUD/ ©DV D IDQDWLF RU DV D 3DSLVWª +´FRPH ²²²²²²²² : &IU1 0$548,6( &$03$1$ '( &$9(//, +(0,/< 52:/(6,/ /HV GHUQLHUV 6WXDUWV j 6DLQW0 *HUPDLQ HQ /D\H/ 3DULV 4;:4/ YRO1 ,1 SS1 60: ; &DOHQGDU RI 6WDWH 3DSHUV/ 'RPHVWLF 6HULHV/ 1RY1 4VW 49:6 WR )HE1 5;WK 49:8 3UHVHUYHG LQ 7KH 3XEOLF 5HFRUG 2IILFH/ D FXUD GL )1 +1 %/$&.%851( '$1,(/// /RQGRQ 4<37/ S1 71 < ,ELGHP/ S1 581 43 &IU1 0$548,6( &$03$1$ '( &$9(//,/ /HV 'HUQLHUV 6WXDUWV j 6DLQW0*HUPDLQ HQ /D\H/ FLW1/ YRO1 4/ SS1 9909:1 44 ´3UREDELOPHQWH VDUHPR FRLQYROWL LQ PROWL JXDL LQHYLWDELOL/ PD SHU L GHWWDJOL ULYROJLWL D PDQL SL• VLFXUH H DG DXWRULWj SL• YHULWLHUHµ1 /D QRWD DQRQLPD VL WURYD LQ &DOHQGDU RI 6WDWH 3D0 SHUV/ FLW1/ SS1 730741
4563
5LWD 6HYHUL
IDQDWLFR R FRPH SDSLVWDµ,> SHUFKq YL HUDQR JLj UDJLRQHYROL GXEEL ©WKDW WKRVH ZKR KDYH DW SUHVHQW WKH FKLHI GLUHFWLRQ RI DIIDLUV FDUU\ RQ D ZLFNHG DQG WUHDVRQDEOH GHVLJQ WR VXEYHUW WKH IXQGDPHQWDO ODZV RI WKLV NLQJGRP E\ LQWURGXFLQJ 3RSHU\ DQG VHWWLQJ XS DQ DUELWUDU\ JRYHUQPHQWª +´FKH FRORUR FKH DWWXDOPHQWH JRYHUQDQR YRJOLRQR DWWXDUH XQ SURJHWWR FUXGHOH H VHGL]LRVR SHU VRYYHUWLUH OH OHJJL IRQGDPHQWDOL GL TXHVWR UHJQR FRQ O·LQWURGX]LRQH GHO 3DSDWR H O·LVWLWX]LRQH GL XQ JRYHUQR DUELWUDULRµ,> H SHUFKp ©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ª +´LO IDWWR FKH HJOL DEELD VFHOWR FRPH VHFRQGD PRJOLH XQD SDSLVWD LWDOLDQD/ ILJOLD GL XQ SDGUH H GL XQD PDGUH FKH VRQR JOL HUHGL ED0 VWDUGL GL XQ 3DSD H GL XQ &DUGLQDOH/ LO IDWWR GL LQVXOWDUH DSHUWDPHQWH OD UHOL0 JLRQH 3URWHVWDQWH/ OH VXH DVSUH LQYHWWLYH FRQWUR L YHVFRYL H LO FOHUR 3URWHVWDQ0 WH/ OH SURPR]LRQL GD OXL FRQIHULWH DL VDQJXLQDUL SDSLVWL LUODQGHVL D SRVWL GL SR0 WHUH H ILGXFLD/ OD VXD GLVDSSURYD]LRQH GL WXWWL JOL DOWUL/ H +FLz FKH q SL• FKLDUR,/ LO VXR ULILXWR GL GHQXQFLDUH TXHOOD FUHGHQ]D WLSLFD GL 5RPD/ OD GRWWULQD GHOOD WUDQVXVWDQ]LD]LRQH/ WXWWH TXHVWH QRQ VRQR IRUVH EDVL VXIILFLHQWL SHU FRQFOXGH0 UH FKH HJOL q XQ SDSLVWD FRQIHUPDWR"µ451 8Q DQQR SL• WDUGL/ LO 5< JHQQDLR 49:8/ DL FRPXQL IX SUHVHQWDWD XQD FRSLD GHOOD *D]]HWWD GL &RORQLD/ GRYH *XJOLHOPR/ SULQFLSH G·2UDQJH H QLSRWH GL &DUOR ,,/ GD SDUWH GHOOD PDGUH 0DULD/ ILJOLD GL &DUOR , 6WXDUW/ GDOO·$LD/ GRYH ULFRSULYD OD FDULFD GL VWDWROGHU/ ULODVFLDYD XQD GLFKLDUD]LRQH GL VILGXFLD QHL UL0 JXDUGL GHOO·,QJKLOWHUUD SHUORPHQR ILQFKp LO GXFD GL <RUN/ HUHGH DO WURQR/ QRQ IRVVH HVFOXVR GDOOD VXFFHVVLRQH H/ QHO FDVR FKH LO UH IRVVH PRUWR VHQ]D HUHGL/ OD FRURQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD YHQLVVH WUDVIHULWD D OXL GL GLULWWR461 1HO IUDWWHPSR 0DULD %HDWULFH WHQHYD XQD FRQGRWWD HVHPSODUH D FRUWH H VL IDFHYD DSSUH]]DUH SHU OD VXD FXOWXUD1 3DUODYD H VFULYHYD FRUUHQWHPHQWH LQ WUH OLQJXH/ OHJJHYD OD *HUXVDOHPPH OLEHUDWD/ GRYH LO YHFFKLR SRHWD GL FRUWH/ (G0 PXQG :DOOHU/ DYHYD VFULWWR FKH ©WKH KHUR·V UDFH H[FHOV WKH SRHW·V WKRXJKWª +´OD UD]]D GHOO·HURH VXSHUD LO SHQVLHUR SRHWLFRµ,/ HVDOWDQGR LQ WDO PRGR O·HUHGH ²²²²²²²² 45 46
,ELG1/ SS1 45;04651 ,ELG1/ S1 94<1
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
4564
GHOOD GLQDVWLD (VWHQVH/ H VL JRGHYD JOL VSHWWDFROL GL FRPPHGLD GHOO·DUWH FKH LO IDQWDVLRVR 7LEHULR )LRULOOR +493;049<7,/ LO JUDQGH ©6FDUDPRXFKHª/ VWLSHQGLDWR GDO 5H 6ROH/ PHWWHYD LQ VFHQD D FRUWH47 H OD SDURGLD GHL YL]LRVL FRUWLJLDQL 6WXDUW/ L IRSV/ QHOOD EULOODQWH FRPPHGLD GL 6LU *HRUJH (WKHUHJH/ 7KH 0DQ RI 0RGH /RU / 6LU )RSOLQJ )OXWWHU/ GHO 49:9 FKH SLDFTXH WDQWR DQFKH DO PDUFKHVH &DWWDQHR/ UHVLGHQWH PRGHQHVH D /RQGUD/ FKH PDQGz QRWL]LH VXOO·HYHQWR WHD0 WUDOH DO GXFD GL 0RGHQD481 *OL DQQL GL FULVL HUDQR LQ DJJXDWR1 1HO IHEEUDLR GHO 49:: XQD EDOHQD PR0 VWUXRVD VL DUHQz D <DUPRXWK H WUD DSULOH H PDJJLR XQD FRPHWD LQIXRFz LO FLH0 OR491 ,O : QRYHPEUH/ 49:: 0DULD %HDWULFH GLHGH DOOD OXFH XQ PDVFKLR/ SURSULR QHO SHULRGR LQ FXL IHUYHYDQR L SUHSDUDWLYL SHU OH QR]]H GHOOD SULPRJHQLWD GHO GXFD GL <RUN/ 0DU\ FRQ *XJOLHOPR G·2UDQJH1 ,O UHVLGHQWH IUDQFHVH QHO ULIHUL0 UH JOL HYHQWL LQ SDWULD/ DJJLXQJH FKH OD JHQWH GL /RQGUD QRQ PRVWUD DOFXQD IH0 OLFLWj SHU LO SLFFROR <RUN/ DQ]L TXHVWD QDVFLWD KD SRUWDWR XQ·RPEUD DOOH PDQL0 IHVWD]LRQL GL JLRLD SHU O·DOOHDQ]D FRQ LO SULQFLSH G· 2UDQJH1 ,O ELPER PRUu SR0 FKL JLRUQL GRSR H 0DULD %HDWULFH IX FROWD GD XQD FULVL GL YHUR VFRQIRUWR1 ,Q SUHGD DOOD GHSUHVVLRQH HEEH XQ LQFXER QHO TXDOH OH DSSDUYH OD JRYHUQDQWH UH0 DOH/ /DG\ )UDQFHV 9LOODUV/ FK·HUD PRUWD LO PHVH SULPD/ FKH LQ VRJQR OH GLFHYD FK·HUD SHUGXWD H OD WRFFDYD FRQ XQD PDQR LQIXRFDWD1 /D GLFLDQQRYHQQH 0D0 ULD %HDWULFH UDFFRQWz LO VRJQR D FRUWH H L IDPLOLDUL GL ODG\ 9LOODUV VL SUHRFFX0 SDURQR H LO SHWWHJROH]]R UDJJLXQVH OD FLWWj/ WDQWR FKH VL SHQVDYD FKH TXDOFKH LQIDXVWR HYHQWR VDUHEEH FDSLWDWR4:1 $QFKH LO WHDWUR FRPH VSHFFKLR GHL WHPSL GDYD YRFH DOOD SURWHVWD SRSROD0 UH= FRQWUR L SUHWL FDWWROLFL4;/ FRQWUR OH LQYDVLRQL GHJOL DWWRUL VWUDQLHUL4</ FRQWUR L IUDQFHVL53 H FL IXURQR QXPHURVH ©SRSH EXUQLQJ FHUHPRQLHVª +GLPRVWUD]LRQL SRSRODUL GXUDQWH OH TXDOL YHQLYD EUXFLDWR XQ IDQWRFFLR FKH UDIILJXUDYD LO 3D0 SD, SHU WXWWR LO ELHQQLR 49::0:;1 1HO 49:; VFRSSLz XQD FULVL WUD 0DQWRYD H 0RGHQD SHU LO SRVVHVVR GHO WHUULWRULR GL %UHVFHOOR1 0DULD %HDWULFH DVVLFXUz LO IUDWHOOR FKH VH OH FRVH VL FRPSOLFDYDQR DYUHEEH FKLHVWR DLXWR SHUVLQR DO UH ²²²²²²²² 47
&IU1 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV«FLW1/ YRO1 ,/ S1 879/ S1 9:4 H S1 9;;1 &IU1 01 +$,/(/ 4XHHQ 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD1 +HU /LIH DQG /HWWHUV/ /RQGRQ 4<38/ S1 931 49 &IU1 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV«FLW1/ YRO1 6/ S1 691 4: &IU1 01 +$,/(/ 4XHHQ 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD«FLW1/ SS1 9:09;1 4; &IU1 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV«FLW1/ YRO1 6/ S1 ;1 4< ,ELG1/ S1 661 53 ,ELG1/ S1 4361 48
4565
5LWD 6HYHUL
&DUOR1 0D WXWWR IX ULVROWR FRQ XQ LQWHUYHQWR FRQFLOLDWRULR GDYDQWL DOO·LPSHUDWRUH1 %HQ SL• JUDYH IX OD FULVL FKH VL SURILOz D /RQGUD DOOD ILQH GHOO·DQQR1 1HOO·DJRVWR GXH HVDOWDWL/ 7LWXV 2DWHV H ,VUDHO 7RQJH/ IHFHUR FLUFR0 ODUH XQD YRFH FKH L JHVXLWL VWDYDQR SUHSDUDQGR XQD FRQJLXUD SHU DVVDVVLQDUH LO UH1 /H ORUR ULSHWXWH LQVLQXD]LRQL DFFRPSDJQDWH GD DOFXQH SURYH/ FKH DYH0 YDQR DELOPHQWH FRQWUDIIDWWR/ RWWHQQHUR OD FUHGLELOLWj GHO FRQVLJOLR SULYDWR +SULY\ &RXQFLO, H VL LQDXJXUz TXHOOD WULVWH VWDJLRQH GL FDFFLD DL FDWWROLFL/ QRWD FRPH 3RSLVK 3ORW/ FKH GXUz ILQR D WXWWR LO 49;41 &LUFD 68 SHUVRQH IXURQR JLXVWL]LDWH H/ IUD TXHVWH/ LO VHJUHWDULR SHUVRQDOH GHOOD GXFKHVVD GL <RUN/ (0 GZDUG &ROHPDQ541 1HO 49:< LO YHVFRYR DQJOLFDQR/ 7KRPDV %DUORZ SXEEOLFz XQ SDPSKOHW/ 3RSHU\= RU/ WKH SULQFLSOHV DQG SRVLWLRQV DSSURYHG E\ WKH &KXUFK RI 5RPH +ZKHQ UHDOO\ EHOLHY·G DQG SUDFWLV·G, DUH YHU\ GDQJHURXV WR DOO/ SHU FRQWUDVWDUH O·HIIHWWR GL JUDQGH SLHWj FKH L GLVFRUVL GHL FDWWROLFL FRQGDQQDWL D PRUWH DYHYDQR VXVFL0 WDWR VX PROWL DQJOLFDQL SUDWLFDQWL1 4XHVWR OLEHOOR IX ULVWDPSDWR WUH YROWH QHO JLUR GL SRFKL PHVL H LOOXVWUz DOFXQH DUJRPHQWD]LRQL FRQWUR L FDWWROLFL FKH GL0 YHQWHUDQQR PROWR SRSRODUL GXUDQWH LO EUHYH UHJQR GL *LDFRPR ,,1 %DUORZ UL0 FRUGD FRPH L FDWWROLFL VLDQR VWDWL VDQJXLQDUL H UHSUHVVLYL QHL ULJXDUGL GHL 9DO0 GHVL H GHJOL 8JRQRWWL H FRPH DEELDQR IRPHQWDWR LO *XQSRZGHU 3ORW GHO 4938 H FRPH HVVL VRQR VRJJHWWL GRYXQTXH H/ SULPD GL WXWWR/ DO SDSD H SHUFLz QRQ SRVVRQR HVVHUH OHDOL VXGGLWL GL QHVVXQ UH551 'LHWUR OD IRUWH LQVLVWHQ]D GHL :KLJV/ FKH UDSSUHVHQWDYDQR JOL LQWHUHVVL GHOOD ULFFD ERUJKHVLD DQWL0FDWWROLFD/ LO SDUODPHQWR FKLHVH O·HVFOXVLRQH GHO GXFD GL <RUN GDOOD VXFFHVVLRQH/ PD LO UH PDQGz OD FRJQDWD HG LO IUDWHOOR LQ 6FR]LD LQ WHPSRUDQHR HVLOLR H/ DOOD ILQH/ OD PR]LRQH QRQ SDVVz1 7XWWR TXHVWR QRQ DWWHQXz OD UHOLJLRVLWj GL 0DULD %HDWULFH/ DQ]L/ O·; DSULOH 49:</ VFULYHYD DG ,QQRFHQ]R ;,= ©QRQ PDQFKHUz PDL LQ RJQL RFFDVLRQH FKH VL SUHVHQWHUj GL FRQWULEXLUH TXDQWR SRWUz/ DOOD SURSDJD]LRQH GHOOD 6DQWD )HGH &DWWROLFD LQ ,QJKLOWHUUDª561 /D UDJD]]D QRQ HUD PROWR VDJJLD H LO SDSD/ PROWR ²²²²²²²² 54 &IU1 %1 &2:$5'/ 7KH 6WXDUW $JH/ /RQGRQ01HZ <RUN/ 4<;;/ SS1 5;405;81 6XOOD SUHWH0 VWXRVLWj GHOOH DFFXVH FRQWUR &ROHPDQ1 %RZOH VL SURQXQFLD -RKQ (YHO\Q +495304:39,/ LQ 7KH 'LDU\ RI -RKQ (YHO\Q/ VFHOWR H FXUDWR GD -1 %2:/( /2[IRUG 4<;8/ S15:61 55 6L YHGD )1 -1 01 .2567(1/ 7KH 5HOLJLRXV &RQWURYHUV\ XQGHU -DPHV ,,= $ &ROOHFWLRQ RI 7UDFWV DQG 3DPSKOHWV DW 1LMPHJHQ 8QLYHUVLW\ /LEUDU\/ LQ ©/,$6ª/ 49 +4<;<,/ SS1 94096 HG DQFKH 7KH 3UR0 ORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV/ FLW1/ YRO1 6/ S1 4:7 GRYH YLHQH GHVFULWWD OD IDUVD SROLWLFD/ 7KH ([FRPPXQLFD0 WHG 3ULQFH/ RU/ 7KH )DOVH 5HOLTXH +49:<", FKH SUREDELOPHQWH IX VWDPSDWD SHU IDUH SURSDJDQGD FRQWUR L FDWWROLFL1 56 &IU1 0$548,6( &$03$1$ '( &$9(//,/ /HV 'HUQLHUV 6WXDUW j 6DLQW0 *HUPDLQ HQ /D\H« FLW1/ YRO1 4/ S1 5841
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
4566
SL• DFFRUWR/ ULPSURYHUz D OHL H DO GXFD O·HFFHVVR GL ]HOR FRQ XQ EUHYH/ GDWDWR : RWWREUH 49:<571 'D 0RGHQD DUULYz XQ PRPHQWDQHR VROOLHYR QHOOD SHUVRQD GHO VRSUDQLVWD *LRYDQQL )UDQFHVFR *URVVL/ QRWR FRPH 6LIDFH SHU OD SDUWH FKH DYHYD PLUD0 ELOPHQWH LQWHUSUHWDWR QHOO·RSHUD GL &DYDOOL/ 6FLSLRQH O·$IULFDQR +9HQH]LD 49:;,581 /D FRUWH IX OHWWHUDOPHQWH LQFDQWDWD GDOOD YRFH GL 6LIDFH1 (YHO\Q/ 3HS\V/ %XUQH\ VL SURFODPDURQR VXRL DPPLUDWRUL H LO PDHVWUR 3XUFHOO FRPSR0 VH XQ JUD]LRVR EUDQR SHU DUSLFRUGR/ ©6HIDXFKL·V )DUHZHOOª/ FKH HVSULPH OD WUL0 VWH]]D GHOOD FRUWH SHU OD VXD SDUWHQ]D1 /·DQLPRVLWj FRQWUR L GXFKL GL <RUN VL IDFHYD SHUz SL• RUJDQL]]DWD HG LU0 UXHQWD1 'DO 49:; DO 49;4 YL IXURQR QXPHURVLVVLPH PDQLIHVWD]LRQL DQWL0 SDSDOL1 1HO 49;4 VL WHQQH XQD SURFHVVLRQH DQWL0SDSDOH/ GXUDQWH OD TXDOH IXUR0 QR LQVFHQDWL SDJHDQWV FRQWUR YDUL PHPEUL GHOOD FRUWH1 ,O 3DSD YHQLYD UDSSUH0 VHQWDWR FRQ LO GLDYROR DO VXR ILDQFR1 4XDQGR OD SURFHVVLRQH JLXQVH QHOOH SURVVLPLWj GL 7HPSOH %DU/ OD IROOD DFFHVH XQ JUDQGH IDOz QHO TXDOH IX EXWWDWD O·HIILJLH GHO SDSD VHJXLWD GD TXHOOH GHL VXRL DFFROLWL1 7XWWR TXHVWR DYYHQLYD LQ PH]]R DO WULSXGLR HG DOOD DFFODPD]LRQH GHOOD IROOD ORQGLQHVH591 /D VFULWWULFH/ $SKUD %HKQ/ GL WHQGHQ]D 7RU\/ VL VFDJOLz FRQWUR TXHVWD ©ORRVH PXOWLWXGHª +´PROWLWXGLQH VFLROWDµ,5:/ PD DQFKH LO WHDWUR GLHGH XQD PDQR DOOD FDXVD DQWL0 SDSLVWD ULHVXPDQGR OD VWRULD GHOOD SDSHVVD *LRYDQD5;1 6ROR DO 'XNH·V WKHDWUH H DG (GLQEXUJR VL IDFHYD O·HORJLR VSHUWLFDWR GHOOD FRSSLD GL <RUN D VFHQD D0 SHUWD/ QHL SURORJKL HG HSLORJKL GHL GUDPPL5<1 ,Q TXHOO·DQQR OD GXFKHVVD GL <RUN DYHYD SRUWDWR D EXRQ ILQH XQD JUDYLGDQ]D HG HUD QDWD XQD ILJOLD63/ PD/ SRFR GRSR/ DQFKH TXHVW·LQIDQWH PRUu H 0DULD %HDWULFH/ UDVVHJQDWD/ VFULVVH D VRUHOOD 0DULD /DXUD GHO &RQYHQWR GHOOD 9LVLWD]LRQH GL 0RGHQD= ©'RPLQXV GHGLW/ 'RPLQXV DEVWXOLW/ VLW QRPHQ 'RPLQL EHQHGLFWXPª +64 PDU]R 49;4,641 ²²²²²²²² 57
,ELG1/ SS1 63706381 8QD IXJDFH PHQ]LRQH GHO FDQWDQWH VL WURYD SUHVVR -1 6287+251/ 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD 4XHHQ &RQVRUW RI -DPHV ,, DQG 9,,/ 5R\DO 6WXDUW 3DSHUV ;// +XQWLQJGRQ/ 4<<5/ S171 59 61 :,//,$06/ 7KH 3RSH0%XUQLQJ 3URFHVVLRQV RI 49:</ 49;3 DQG 49;4/ LQ ©-RXUQDO RI WKH :DUEXUJ DQG &RXUWDXOG ,QVWLWXWHVª/ 54/ 4<8;/ SS1 437044;1 5: &IU1 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV«FLW1/ YRO1 6/ S1 6771 5; ,ELG1/ S1 5681 5< ,ELG1/ S1 586/ S1 636 H S1 73;> 7KH 3URORJXHV DQG (SLORJXHV«FLW1/ YRO1 7/ S1 746 H S1 794/ GR0 YH VL QDUUD GHOOD FDOGD DFFRJOLHQ]D FKH OD FRSSLD UHDOH ULFHYHWWH DG 2[IRUG1 63 /D QDVFLWD IX SXQWXDOPHQWH FHOHEUDWD LQ YHUVL/ FIU1 $ 3RHP WR KHU 5R\DO +LJKQHVV XSRQ WKH ELUWK RI KHU GDXJKWHU/ /RQGRQ 49;5/ FRQVHUYDWR SUHVVR OD %ULWLVK /LEUDU\ ;391N1491+445-1,1 64 &IU1 0$548,6( &$03$1$ '( &$9(//,/ /HV 'HUQLHUV 6WXDUWV j 6DLQW0*HUPDLQ HQ /D\H/ FLW1 58
4567
5LWD 6HYHUL
&L PDQFDYD VROR OD YLVLWD GL :LOOLDP G·2UDQJH D :LQGVRU QHO OXJOLR GHO 49;465 SHU SHJJLRUDUH XOWHULRUPHQWH OD VLWXD]LRQH/ SHUFKp OD VXD VROD SUHVHQ0 ]D LQWHQVLILFDYD O·RGLR GHL :KLJV QHL ULJXDUGL GHL 7RULHV1 ,QWDQWR D 0RGHQD/ LO FRQVLJOLHUH GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,/ &HVDUH ,JQD]LR G·(VWH DYHYD FUHDWR FRQ OH VXH PLUH DPEL]LRVH XQ FOLPD GL LQWROOHUDQ]D FKH IHFH DOORQWDQDUH GDO GXFDWR DQFKH /DXUD 0DUWLQR]]L1 (OOD/ LQ XQ SULPR WHP0 SR/ VH QH DQGz D 3DULJL/ SRL D 5RPD QHO 49;7/ GRYH IRQGz XQ FRQYHQWR GL 2UVROLQH1 $ 5RPD OH SHUYHQQH OD QRWL]LD FKH &HVDUH ,JQD]LR FRQ OD VXD VX0 SHUILFLDOLWj GLSORPDWLFD DYHYD FDXVDWR XQ LQFLGHQWH GL URWWXUD QLHQWHPHQR FKH FRQ /XLJL ;,91 /D FROSD GL &HVDUH ULVLHGHYD QHOO·DYHU SHUPHVVR DOOD VR0 UHOOD $QJHOLFD &DWHULQD GL VSRVDUH LO SULQFLSH $PHGHR GL &DULJQDQR VHQ]D FKLHGHUH O·DXWRUL]]D]LRQH DO UH IUDQFHVH FKH DYHYD LQ PHQWH GL PDULWDUH LO JLR0 YDQH SULQFLSH/ VXR IHXGDWDULR/ DG XQD GDPD IUDQFHVH1 3URQWDPHQWH/ 0DULD %HDWULFH VFULVVH XQD OHWWHUD DOO·DPEDVFLDWRUH IUDQFHVH VFKLHUDQGRVL GDOOD SDUWH GHO UH /XLJL66/ LO TXDOH/ YLVWR LO PRPHQWR IDYRUHYROH/ QRQ SHUVH O·RFFDVLRQH SHU SURSRUUH XQD QRELOH IUDQFHVH FRPH VSRVD SHU LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD67/ PD OD SURSRVWD DOOD ILQH QRQ IX DFFROWD H )UDQFHVFR VSRVz 0DUJKHULWD GL 3DUPD QHO 49<51 ,O 49 IHEEUDLR 49;8/ UH &DUOR ,, PRUu/ GRSR DYHU ULFHYXWR L VDFUDPHQWL GD XQ SUHWH FDWWROLFR1 0DULD H *LDFRPR GLYHQWDURQR L UHJQDQWL GL XQ SDHVH SUR0 IRQGDPHQWH SURWHVWDQWH/ GRYH LO UH UDSSUHVHQWDYD OD IHGH SURWHVWDQWH1 /·LQFRURQD]LRQH DYYHQQH LQ SRPSD PDJQD/ PD WXWWL QRWDURQR FKH LO UH H OD UHJLQD VL HUDQR DVWHQXWL GDL VDFUDPHQWL GHO ULWR DQJOLFDQR1 3L• GL XQ SRHPD GL FLUFRVWDQ]D68 H/ XQ·RGH VLQFHUD GD SDUWH GL $SKUD %HKQ/ FHOHEUDURQR 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH/ PD LO FOLPD ULPDVH WHVR1 /D WUDJHGLD ILQDOH VWDYD SHU VFRSSLD0 UH/ LQHYLWDELOH H OHJJHQGDULD/ VRSUDWWXWWR/ TXDQGR/ QHO 49;; QDFTXH XQ HUHGH VDQR H IRUWH FKH/ GD SDUWH SURWHVWDQWH/ VL GLVVH IRVVH VWDWR LQWURGRWWR QHO OHWWR GHOOD SDUWRULHQWH GHQWUR D XQR VFDOGDOHWWR1 ²²²²²²²² YRO1 4/ SS1 68706881 65 &IU1 01 +$,/(/ 4XHHQ 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD«FLW1/ S14371 66 ,ELGHP/ SS1 44704481 67 ,ELGHP/ S1 4491 68 &IU1 -1 %$%(5/ $ 3RHP XSRQ WKH &RURQDWLRQ/ /RQGRQ/ 51 (YHULQJKDP/ 49;8 H $ 3RHP RQ DQG WR +HU *UDFLRXV 0DMHVW\ XSRQ WKH 'D\ RI +HU +DSS\ &RURQDWLRQ E\ RQH RI +HU 0DMHVWLHV 6HUYDQWV/ /RQGRQ/ 1DWKDQLHO 7KRPSVRQ/ 49;81 ,Q ,WDOLD VL IHVWHJJLDYD DOOD JUDQGH DQFKH FRQ EDOOL H PXVLFD/ FRPH TXHOOL FRPSRVWL GD *,29$11, %$77,67$ 9,7$/,/ %DOOL LQ VWLOH IUDQFHVH D FLQTXH VWURPHQWL FRQVHFUDWL DOOD VDFUD UHDO PDHVWDGL 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH 6WXDUGD UHJLQD GHOOD *UDQ %UHWDJQD/ 0RGRQD/ $QWRQLR 9LWDOLDQL/ 49;81
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
4568
'XH VWDPSH GHO 49;;/ FRQVHUYDWH SUHVVR OD %LEOLRWHFD 9DWLFDQD/ FRPPHQ0 WDQR O·HYHQWR1 1HOOD SULPD +ILJ1 4,/ XQ·LQFLVLRQH GL $UQROGR YRQ :HVWHUKRXW/ XQ EXH DUURVWLWR LQWHUR/ ULSLHQR GL GLYHUVL DQLPDOL FRPPHVWLELOL YLHQH RIIHUWR DOO·LQJRUGLJLD GHO YROJR QHOOD SXEEOLFD SLD]]D SHU IHVWHJJLDUH OD QDVFLWD GHO SULQFLSH691 1HOOD VHFRQGD LQFLVLRQH GL 'RPHQLFR $QWRQLR (UFROH +ILJ1 5,/ VL YHGH LO SULQFLSH PHQWUH YLHQH ULFHYXWR QHOOD 6DOD 5HJLD GDO 1XQ]LR $SRVWROL0 FR H PRVWUDWR DL JUDQGL GHO UHJQR6:1 1HL 3DHVL %DVVL/ O·HYHQWR GLYHQWz XQ WH0 PD SUHIHULWR GHOOD VDWLUD SROLWLFD1 8QD VWDPSD GHO SHULRGR/ DWWULEXLWD D 3LHWHU 6FKHQFN/ PRVWUD 0DU\ GL 0RGHQD DFFDQWR DOOD FXOOD GHO SULQFLSLQR/ PHQWUH LO JHVXLWD/ SDGUH 3HWUH OH DFFDUH]]D YROXWWXRVDPHQWH LO FROOR6;1 /·DOOXVLRQH H OD PDOLJQLWj VRQR FKLDUH/ PD D FRUWH QRQ VH QH WHQHYD FRQWR +ILJ16,1 1HL WUH DQQL GHO VXR UHJQR *LDFRPR ,, PROWLSOLFD D GLVPLVXUD OD SUHVHQ]D GHL FDWWROLFL D FRUWH/ ID HULJHUH 4; FDSSHOOH FDWWROLFKH QHOOD FLWWj GL /RQGUD/ LQ0 FRUDJJLD L %HQHGHWWLQL D JLUDUH SHU OD FLWWj FRQ LO ORUR FRQVXHWR DELWR H FDS0 SXFFLR +%ODFN )ULDUV,/ JHQHUDOPHQWH GLVSUH]]DWR GDOOD SRSROD]LRQH/ FKLHGH FKH XQ YLFDULR DSRVWROLFR YHQJD LQYLDWR D /RQGUD H LQYLWD L SUHWL LQJOHVL/ VSDU0 VL QHO FRQWLQHQWH D WRUQDUH LQ SDWULD6<1 ,O VXR VWHVVR FRPSRUWDPHQWR q LP0 SURQWDWR DOOD SL• VWUHWWD RUWRGRVVLD FDWWROLFD1 , SDPSKOHWV GHOO·RSSRVL]LRQH VRQR FRVu QXPHURVL FKH LO UH GHYH UDFFRJOLHUH WXWWH OH VXH IRU]H SHU FRQWUDVWD0 UH WDQWD SURSDJDQGD QHJDWLYD1 1HO 49;9 HJOL IHFH SXEEOLFDUH GXH WHVWLPR0 QLDQ]H LQ IDYRUH GHO FDWWROLFHVLPR= &RSLHV RI WZR SDSHUV ZULWWHQ E\ WKH ODWH .LQJ &KDUOHV ,,1 7RJHWKHU ZLWK D FRS\ RI D SDSHU ZULWWHQ E\ WKH ODWH 'XFKHVV RI <RUN73 1 6L WUDWWD GL GXH IRJOL PDQRVFULWWL QHL TXDOL LO UH &DUOR ,, H OD SULPD PRJOLH GL *LDFRPR/ $QQH +\GH/ FRQIHVVDQR OD ORUR OHDOWj DOOD FKLHVD FDWWROLFD FRPH XQLFD YHUD GHSRVLWDULD GHOOD SULPLWLYD IHGH FULVWLDQD1 ,QROWUH L GXH LOOXVWUL SHU0 VRQDJJL VSLHJDQR OD ULIRUPD DQJOLFDQD GL (QULFR 9,,, LQ EDVH D PRWLYD]LRQL SHUVRQDOLVWLFKH= OD OXVVXULD GHO UH FKH OR DYHYD DFFHFDWR H L JURVVL LQWHUHVVL LQ ULFFKH]]D H SRWHUH FKH SRWHYD PLHWHUH GDL SRVVHGLPHQWL GHL FDWWROLFL LQ ,Q0 JKLOWHUUD1 7XWWR FLz QRQ HUD VROR VFRQYHQLHQWH/ ULVXOWDYD DQFKH SRFR FRQYLQ0 ²²²²²²²² 69
%,%/,27(&$ $32672/,&$ 9$7,&$1$/ &KLJ1 0LVFHOO1 ,,1 43:<1 I1 :;1 ,ELGHP/ I1 :: 6; /D VWDPSD VL WURYD DO %ULWLVK 0XVHXP HG q VWDWD SXEEOLFDWD QHO FDWDORJR/ 7KH 3ULQW LQ 6WXDUW %ULWDLQ 4936049;</ D FXUD GL $1 *5,)),7+6 FRQ OD FROODERUD]LRQH GL 51 $1 *(5$5'/ /RQGRQ 4<<;/ S16331 6< &IU1 )1 -1 01 .2567(1/ 7KH 5HOLJLRXV &RQWURYHUV\ XQGHU -DPHV ,,= $ &ROOHFWLRQ RI 7UDFWV DQG 3DPSKOHWV DW 1LMPHJHQ 8QLYHUVLW\ /LEUDU\«FLW1/ S1 951 73 ,ELGHP/ S1 981 6:
4569
5LWD 6HYHUL
FHQWH1 'L WXWWD OD YDVWD PROH GL VFULWWL SXEEOLFDWL LQ TXHJOL DQQL LO SL• LQWHUHVVDQWH q OD QRYHOOD 2URRQRNR +49;;,/ GL $SKUD %HKQ FKH QDUUD GHOO·DPRUH FRQWUDVWDWR GHO SULQFLSH QHUR 2URRQRNR SHU OD SULQFLSHVVD ,PRLQGD / GHOOD ORUR ULGX]LRQH LQ VFKLDYLW• H GHOOD ORUR ULEHOOLRQH SHU OD TXDOH SDJKHUDQQR FRQ OD YLWD1 'DWL L SUHFHGHQWL GL $SKUD %HKQ FRPH VSLD DO VHUYL]LR GL &DUOR ,, H VXFFHVVLYDPHQ0 WH FRPH 5R\DOLVW H FRQYLQWD VRVWHQLWULFH GHOOH FDXVH 6WXDUW / OD QRYHOOD GL 2UR0 RQRNR q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·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·,QJKLOWHUUD HG HVWLUSD0 UH OD UHOLJLRQH SURWHVWDQWH VL VLD WUDVIRUPDWR LQ XQ LQFXER GL GLVIDWWLVPR SROL0 WLFR761 ²²²²²²²² 74
&IU1 01 '8))</ ,QWURGXFWLRQ/ D 2URRQRNR/ /RQGRQ 4<;9/ S144 H ,G1/ 7KH 3DVVLRQDWH 6KHSHUGHVV $SKUD %HKQ 49730;</ /RQGRQ 4<;</ SS1 5:705:81 75 &RPH VSLHJD 31 %85.(/ /D IDEEULFD GHO 5H 6ROH«FLW1/ S1 4;:1 76 *OL DWWDFFKL GLUHWWL DOOD FRURQD LQJOHVH VL PROWLSOLFDURQR H IXURQR VHPSUH SL• YHHPHQWL1 (OHQFR DOFXQL GHJOL VFULWWL VDWLULFL FKH HEEHUR ODUJD GLIIXVLRQH= 'LDORJXH1 %HWZHHQ 01 +0DU\ RI 0RGHQD, DQG -1 +-DPHV ,,,/ /RQGRQ 49;;/ 'HQ RXGHQ %DVWDDUG +/XLJL ;,9, %HVFKHUPHU YDQ GHQ 1LHXZHQ +,O SULQFLSH *LDFRPR,= RI GH 3URVWLWXWH YDQ GH .RQLQJHQ +0DU\ GL 0RGHQD, RP GH EHVFKHU0 PLQJ GHV 3ULQVHQ YDQ :DOOHV/ $PVWHUGDP 49;</ 7KH DPRXUV RI 0HVVDOLQD/ ODWH TXHHQ RI $OELRQ1 ,Q ZKLFK DUH EULHIO\ FRXFK·G VHFUHWV RI WKH LPSRVWXUH RI WKH &DPEULRQ SULQFH/ WKH *RWKLFN OHDJXH DQG RWKHU FRXUW LQWULJXHV RI WKH IRXU ODVW \HDUV UHLJQ/ QRW \HW PDGH SXEOLFN1 %\ D ZRPDQ RI TXDOLW\/ ODWH FRQILGHQW RI 41 0HVVDOLQD/ /RQGRQ 49;</ /D &RXU GH 6W1 *HUPDLQ/ RX OHV LQWULJXHV JDODQWHV GX 5R\/ HW GH OD 5HLQH
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
456:
0D TXDO· HUD VWDWR LO VRJQR GL 0DULD %HDWULFH" )RUVH TXHOOR JLRYDQLOH GL SDVVDUH L VXRL JLRUQL QHO &RQYHQWR GHOOD 9LVLWD]LRQH GL 0RGHQD"77 6DUHEEH VWDWR SRVVLELOH/ PD FKH SHFFDWR SULYDUH 0RGHQD GHO VXR VRJQR GL XQD UHJLQD G·,QJKLOWHUUD781
²²²²²²²² G·$QJOHWHUUH +0DU\ GL 0RGHQD,/ GHSXLV OHXU VpMRXU HQ )UDQFH/ 6DLQW *HUPDLQ 49<8 H $ 'LDORJXH EHWZHHQ WKH )UHQFK .LQJ DQG WKH ODWH .LQJ -DPHV DW 6W1 *HUPDLQ HQ /D\H/ /RQGRQ 49<:1 77 6FULYHYD &ULVWLQD GL 6YH]LD +4959049;<,= ´Ë PLD RSLQLRQH FKH OH GRQQH QRQ GRYUHEEH0 UR PDL JRYHUQDUH1 ( VRQR D WDO SXQWR FRQYLQWD GL FLz FKH/ VH PDL PL IRVVL VSRVDWD DYUHL FHU0 WDPHQWH SULYDWR OD PLD GLVFHQGHQ]D IHPPLQLOH GL WXWWL L GLULWWL HUHGLWDUL DO WURQR VYHGHVH1 +111, 3HU XQD GRQQD DVVROYHUH GHJQDPHQWH L GRYHUL GL XQ WDOH LQFDULFR q FRVD TXDVL LUUHDOL]]DELOH/ VLD FKH JRYHUQL D VXR WLWROR R LQ YHFH GL XQ PLQRUH1 /D PDQFDQ]D GL FXOWXUD/ OD GHEROH]]D VSL0 ULWXDOH/ ILVLFD HG HPRWLYD GHOOH GRQQH OH UHQGH LQDGDWWD DOOD YRFD]LRQH GL SULQFLSH +111, ( SHU QHVVXQ YHUVR PL FRQVLGHUR XQ·HFFH]LRQH D TXHVWD UHJRODµ/ FLWDWR LQ $1 01 9(51$/ 'RQQH GHO *UDQG 6LqFOH/ 0LODQR 4<<7/ S143;1 &RPH FKLDULVFH O·$1/ O·DYYHUVLRQH DO SRWHUH IHPPLQLOH q VHPSUH HVLVWLWD SHUFKp OD VRYUDQLWj q XQ·HPDQD]LRQH GHOOD YRORQWj GLYLQD1 ,Q SLHQR DVVROXWL0 VPR/ %DUXFK 6SLQR]D ULWHQHYD FKH OH GRQQH GRYHVVHUR HVVHUH HVFOXVH DQFKH GDOOD UHJJHQ]D1 78 /D YLFHQGD GL 0DULD %HDWULFH GL 0RGHQD KD LVSLUDWR DOFXQL URPDQ]LHUL/ GD 'HODULYLHU 0DQOH\ D 0DWXULQ/ H/ UHFHQWHPHQWH/ -$1( /$1(/ %ULGJH RI 6LJKV/ /RQGRQ 4<:6 H '2527+< <281*/ 7KH %ULGH IURP 0RGHQD/ /RQGRQ 4<:;1
456;
5LWD 6HYHUL
)LJ1 41 6WDPSD1 %LEOLRWHFD $SRVWROLFD 9DWLFDQD/ &KLJL ,,/ 43:<1 I1 :;1
5DSSRUWL WUD LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD H O*,QJKLOWHUUD GHO ·933
)LJ1 51 6WDPSD1 %LEOLRWHFD $SRVWROLFD 9DWLFDQD/ &KLJL ,,/ 43:<1 I1 ::1
456<
4573
5LWD 6HYHUL
)LJ1 61 6WDPSD1 $WWULE1 D 3LHWHU 6FKHQFN/ 0DU\ RI 0RGHQD ZLWK WKH 3LQFH RI :DOHV DQG )DWKHU 3HWUH +/RQGRQ/ %ULWLVK 0XVHXP,1
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4574
8*2 &29$
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
/H YLFHQGH GLQDVWLFKH GHOOD &DVD G·$VEXUJR H OD JUDQGH SROLWLFD HXURSHD GHOOD SULPD PHWj GHO ;9,,, VHFROR SRUWDURQR/ SHU O·,WDOLD/ FRPH q QRWR/ SUR0 IRQGL PXWDPHQWL GL FDUDWWHUH LVWLWX]LRQDOH/ HFRQRPLFR/ VRFLDOH/ FKH LQYHVWL0 URQR/ VHSSXU FRQ LQFLVLYLWj H PRGDOLWj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· GDSSHUWXWWR QHJOL 6WDWL GHOO·(XURSD RFFLGHQWDOH1 )XURQR VYLOXSSL VXFFHVVLYL/ LQ VHJXLWR D PXWDWH FRQGL]LRQL SROLWLFKH HG HFRQRPLFKH/ HG DO ULVYHJOLR GHOOH FRVFLHQ]H QD]LRQDOL D OLYHOOR HXURSHR/ D GHWHUPLQDUH XQD VLWXD]LRQH SULPD GL GLVWDFFR H SRL GL D0 SHUWD FRQIOLWWXDOLWj IUD OR 6WDWR DXVWULDFR HG L WHUULWRUL LWDOLDQL VRWWRSRVWL DO VXR GLUHWWR GRPLQLR R DOOD VXD SHVDQWH WXWHOD SROLWLFR0PLOLWDUH1 7RUQDQGR DL SULPL DQQL GHO ¶:33 q GD ULFRUGDUH FKH/ LQL]LDWRUH/ D FDYDOOR IUD 6SDJQD HG $XVWULD/ GHO QXRYR LQGLUL]]R DXVWULDFR GL SUHGRPLQLR VX ODUJD SDUWH G·,WDOLD/ IX O·XOWLPR UDSSUHVHQWDQWH PDVFKLR GHOOD OLQHD GLUHWWD GHOOD &D0 VD G·$VEXUJR/ TXHO &DUOR FKH GXUDQWH OD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH VSDJQROD HUD VWDWR UH GL 6SDJQD FRO QRPH GL &DUOR ,,,1 ,Q VHJXLWR SRL DOOD PRUWH SUHPDWXUD VHQ]D GLVFHQGHQ]D PDVFKLOH/ QHO 4:44/ GHO IUDWHOOR *LXVHSSH ,/ VDFUR URPDQR LPSHUDWRUH/ HJOL DEEDQGRQz OD SHQLVROD LEHULFD SHU ULVWDELOLUVL QHL WHUULWRUL DYL0 WL GHJOL $VEXUJR G·$XVWULD/ L F1G1 3DHVL HUHGLWDUL DXVWULDFL4 SHU DVVXPHUQH LO ²²²²²²²² 4
3HU XQR VJXDUGR FRPSOHVVLYR VXOOD VLWXD]LRQH VWRULFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOH GL TXHO SDUWLFRODUH
4575
8JR &RYD
JRYHUQR1 1HO GLFHPEUH GHO 4:44 IX LQFRURQDWR HJOL VWHVVR VDFUR URPDQR LP0 SHUDWRUH/ FRO WLWROR GL &DUOR 9,1 &RO VXR WUDVIHULPHQWR GD %DUFHOORQD D 9LHQQD/ HJOL DYHYD WUDVSRUWDWR QHOOD FDSLWDOH GHL VXRL SRVVHGLPHQWL DXVWULDFL DQFKH LO &RQVHMR GH (VSDxD/ FRUSR FRO0 OHJLDOH GL JRYHUQR/ DO TXDOH HUD VWUHWWDPHQWH FRQQHVVR LO &RQVHMR GH ,WDOLD/ FXL HUD DIILGDWD O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHL WHUULWRUL LWDOLDQL VRWWRSRVWL DOOD &RURQD VSD0 JQROD1 $O VHJXLWR GHO VRYUDQR FRQIOXu TXLQGL D 9LHQQD WXWWR XQ FRGD]]R GL IXQ]LRQDUL VSDJQROL JUDQGL H SLFFROL/ SHU SURVHJXLUH O·DWWLYLWj GL JRYHUQR GL &DUOR TXDOH UH GL 6SDJQD1 6HJXu TXHVW·DSSDUDWR DQFKH XQD SDUWH GHOO·DUFKLYLR SURGRWWR GDL FLWDWL RUJDQL GL JRYHUQR/ SHU LO SURVHJXLPHQWR GHJOL DIIDUL LVWUXLWL LQ WHUUD VSDJQROD1 &RPH JLj LQ 6SDJQD LO &RQVHMR GH ,WDOLD/ FRVu D 9LHQQD O·,WDOLHQLVFKHU 5DW +&RQVLJOLR G·,WDOLD, SURVHJXu OD SURSULD DWWLYLWj/ GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD GHO WLSR GL FRPSHWHQ]H VSHWWDQWHJOL/ IRQGDPHQWDOPHQWH VX XQ GRSSLR ELQDULR/ TXHOOR VWUHWWDPHQWH DPPLQLVWUDWLYR GHL WHUULWRUL JRYHUQDWL/ H TXHOOR GLSORPDWLFR/ QHO FDPSR GHO VHWWRUH GHOOD SROLWLFD HVWHUD DXVWULDFD LQ ,WDOLD1 $QFKH TXDQGR/ QHO 4:47/ L WHUULWRUL LWDOLDQL JLj VSHWWDQWL DOOD 6SDJQD +0LODQR/ 1DSROL H OD 6DUGH0 JQD/ VFDPELDWD SRFR SL• WDUGL FRQ OD 6LFLOLD, SDVVDURQR VRWWR VRYUDQLWj DX0 VWULDFD/ TXHOO·RUJDQR GL JRYHUQR D 9LHQQD FRQWLQXz OD SURSULD DWWLYLWj VHFRQ0 GR LO FLWDWR LQGLUL]]R JHQHUDOH1 'DO 4:68/ FRQ OD SHUGLWD GL 1DSROL H GHOOD 6LFL0 OLD/ O·,WDOLHQLVFKHU 5DW +&RQVLJOLR G·,WDOLD, YLGH ULGRWWD OD SURSULD FRPSHWHQ]D DO VROR 'XFDWR GL 0LODQR1 ,Q VHJXLWR D VXFFHVVLYH GHILQL]LRQL GHOOD VWUXWWXUD GHJOL RUJDQL FHQWUDOL GL JRYHUQR YLHQQHVL/ QHL TXDOL QRQ DYHYD SL• UDJLRQ G·HVVHUH OD VXVVLVWHQ]D GHOO·DSSDUDWR LVWLWX]LRQDOH GL PDUFD VSDJQROD/ JLj QHO FRUVR GHO ¶:33 OD FRP0 SHWHQ]D VWUHWWDPHQWH DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHL WHUULWRUL LWDOLDQL +SUDWLFDPHQWH OD /RPEDUGLD, IX DIILGDWD DOOD ,WDOLHQLVFKH +RINDQ]OHL +&DQFHOOHULD DXOLFD LWDOLDQD,5/ PHQWUH OD WUDWWD]LRQH GHJOL DIIDUL GLSORPDWLFL SHU O·,WDOLD YHQQH DIILGDWD DG XQ ²²²²²²²²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¶:33,1 6XOOD VXD RULJLQH QHO ¶833 DG RSHUD GL 0DVVLPLOLDQR , G·$VEXUJR H VXOOR VYLOXSSR GHOOH VXH IXQ]LRQL ILQR DOOD SULPD PHWj GHO ¶:33/ FIU1 (1&1 +(//%/,1*/ gVWHUUHLFKLVFKH 9HUIDVVXQJV0 XQG 9HUZDOWXQJVJHVFKLFKWH/ :LHQ 4<89/ SS1 57405761 (VLVWHYDQR ULSDUWL]LRQL LQWHUQH GHOOD &DQFHOOHULD/ D VHFRQGD GHL WHU0 ULWRUL DPPLQLVWUDWL1 )X &DUOR 9, D FUHDUH O·LWDOLHQLVFKH +RINDQ]OHL1
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4576
'LSDUWLPHQWR LWDOLDQR GHOOD +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVNDQ]OHL +&DQFHOOHULD GL &DVD/ &RUWH H 6WDWR,61 /D GRFXPHQWD]LRQH FXVWRGLWD D 9LHQQD GDOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY +$UFKLYLR GL &DVD/ &RUWH H 6WDWR, q LO IUXWWR GHOOD UDFFROWD GL IRQGL DUFKLYLVWLFL H VHULH GRFXPHQWDULH ULWHQXWL ULOHYDQWL/ DL WHPSL GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD/ SHU OD VWRULD GHOOR 6WDWR H GHL IDVWL GHOOD GLQDVWLD UHJQDQWH1 7DOL UDFFROWH ULVXO0 WDQR GDOO·DFFRVWDPHQWR IUD GL ORUR GL VHULH H GRFXPHQWL VSHVVR QRQ FROOHJDWL IUD GL ORUR GD XQ ULJRURVR QHVVR DUFKLYLVWLFR/ SHU FXL HVLVWRQR QHOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY/ QXFOHL GRFXPHQWDUL VSHVVR DUWLILFLRVL/ QRQ SL•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·,VWLWXWR DUFKLYLVWLFR/ SXEEOLFDWL D 9LHQQD IUD LO 4<69 H LO 4<737/ ULJXDU0 GDQWL HVSOLFLWDPHQWH LO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 ,O SULPR GL HVVL ID SDUWH GHO IRQGR DUFKLYLVWLFR ,WDOLHQ ² 6SDQLVFKHU 5DW/ QHO TXDOH VL WURYD/ IUD WDQWH DOWUH/ XQD ULSDU0 WL]LRQH 0RGHQD1 6L WUDWWD GL XQD UDFFROWD GL DWWL/ FKH GRSR WUDYHUVLH LQFUHGLELOL +IUD O·DOWUR WUDVIHULPHQWL D 3DULJL H D 0LODQR, FKH FRPSRUWDURQR JUDYL SHUGLWH ULVSHWWR DOOD VXD FRQVLVWHQ]D RULJLQDULD/ IX YHUVDWD QHO 4;3< DJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR DXVWULDFL GD SDUWH GHOOD &DQFHOOHULD DXOLFD GL 9LHQQD81 ,O PDWHULDOH LQ TXHVWLRQH q FRVWLWXLWR/ QHOOD PDVVLPD SDUWH/ GD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH UHODWLYD DOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHO GXFDWR IUD LO 4:75 H LO 4:7</ TXDQGR/ LQ VHJXLWR DOOR ²²²²²²²² 6
/D *HKHLPH +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVNDQ]OHL +&DQFHOOHULD VHJUHWD GL &DVD/ &RUWH H 6WDWR, HUD VWDWD IRUPDWD QHO 4:75 SHU YRORQWj GL 0DULD 7HUHVD/ VRWWUDHQGR FRVu DOOD &DQFHOOHULD DXOLFD OH PD0 WHULH SL• VWUHWWDPHQWH DWWLQHQWL OD SROLWLFD HVWHUD H JOL DIIDUL GHOOD IDPLJOLD LPSHULDOH1 /R 6WDD0 WVNDQ]OHU HUD/ LQ SUDWLFD/ LO PLQLVWUR GHJOL (VWHUL1 &IU1 (1&1 +(//%/,1*/«FLW1/ S1 5<31 7 ,O SULPR YROXPH GHL *HVDPWLQYHQWDUH GHOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY DSSDUYH QHO 4<69/ LO VHFRQGR QHO 4<6:/ LO WHU]R QHO 4<6;/ LO TXDUWR SXUH QHO 4<6;/ LO TXLQWR QHO 4<731 8 /RF1 FLW1 LQ QRWD 41
4577
8JR &RYD
VFRSSLR GHOOD JXHUUD GL VXFFHVVLRQH DXVWULDFD HG DOOD FRQVHJXHQWH IXJD GHO GXFD GDL VXRL SRVVHGLPHQWL/ D 0RGHQD HUD VWDWR LQVWDOODWR XQ $PPLQLVWUDWRUH JHQHUDOH DXVWULDFR/ FKH JRYHUQz SHU DOFXQL DQQL TXHL WHUULWRUL1 6L WUDWWD/ TXLQGL/ GL PDWHULDOH GL QDWXUD VRSUDWWXWWR DPPLQLVWUDWLYD/ VXGGL0 YLVR LQ WUH YRFL JHQHUDOL= &RUULVSRQGHQ]D GHOO·$PPLQLVWUDWRUH JHQHUDOH GDO 4:74 DO 4:86 +)DV]LNHO GDOO·4 DO 8,9> FRUULVSRQGHQ]D GHO /XRJRWHQHQWH GDO 4:75 DO 4:7< +)DV]L0 NHO 9 H :,1 ,,, &ROOHFWDQHD +LQVXUUH]LRQH/ SROL]LD/ JLXVWL]LD/ DIIDUL HFFOHVLDVWLFL/ DIIDUL PLOL0 WDUL/ FRPPHUFLR/ DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH LQ JHQHUH, GDO 4:75 DO 4:7< +)DV]LNHO ;,> ILQDQ]H GDO 4:69 DO 4:7; +)DV]LNHO <,1 ,,,, $WWL VXSSOHPHQWDUL +1DFKWUDJ,= DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH DXVWULDFD GDO 4:<< DO 4;33 +)DV]LNHO 43 H 44,1
,,
,O VHFRQGR QXFOHR DUFKLYLVWLFR ULJXDUGDQWH 0RGHQD q GL FDUDWWHUH GLSOR0 PDWLFR H ID SDUWH GHO IRQGR GHQRPLQDWR 6WDDWHQDEWHLOXQJHQ +YHUHLQLJWH GLSORPDWL0 VFKH $NWHQ, + 5LSDUWL]LRQL 6WDWL= DWWL GLSORPDWLFL XQLILFDWL,1 ,O IRQGR q ULSDUWLWR LQ GXH JURVVH VHULH= $ ² 'HXWVFKH 6WDDWHQ +6WDWL WHGHVFKL,> % ² $XVVHUGHXWVFKH 6WD0 DWHQ +6WDWL QRQ WHGHVFKL,:1 ,Q TXHVW·XOWLPD VHULH/ XQD ODUJD SDUWH q GHGLFDWD DJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL SUHXQLWDUL +$EWHLOXQJ ,WDOLHQ/ 'LSORPDWLVFKH .RUUHVSRQGHQ],/ IUD FXL LO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 6L WUDWWD/ DQFKH TXL/ GL XQD UDFFROWD GL GRFXPHQWL GL GLYHUVD SURYHQLHQ]D= &RQ0 VLJOLR GL 6SDJQD/ &RQVLJOLR G·,WDOLD/ &DQFHOOHULD GHO 6DFUR 5RPDQR ,PSHUR/ &DQFHOOHULD DXOLFD/ &DQFHOOHULD GL &RUWH H 6WDWR1 *OL DWWL LQ TXHVWLRQH VRQR X0 QLILFDWL GDOO·XQLFR FRPXQ GHQRPLQDWRUH GL ULJXDUGDUH L UDSSRUWL GLSORPDWLFL IUD 9LHQQD H 0RGHQD1 &RPH JLj GHWWR SHU LO QXFOHR SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH FLWDWR/ DQFKH TXHVWR q DE0 ERQGDQWHPHQWH VIURQGDWR VRSUDWWXWWR D FDXVD GL WUDVIHULPHQWL RSHUDWL LQ H0 SRFD QDSROHRQLFD H LQ PRPHQWL VXFFHVVLYL1 8QD SULPD SDUWH IX YHUVDWD DJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR YLHQQHVL QHO 4;5<1 6HJXLURQR DOWUL YHUVDPHQWL QHO SULPR GH0 ²²²²²²²² 9
,O )DV]LNHO q O·XQLWj DUFKLYLVWLFD WUDGL]LRQDOH DXVWULDFD/ FRUULVSRQGHQWH JHQHUDOPHQWH DG XQ DUJRPHQWR H/ VSHVVR/ DG XQD FODVVLILFD GHWHUPLQDWD/ SHU FXL OD VXD FRQVLVWHQ]D q/ QHOOD QRU0 PD/ PROWR YDULDELOH1 : /D VHULH $XVVHUGHXWVFKH 6WDDWHQ q UHGDWWD GD -1.1 0$<5/ RS1 FLW1 LQ QRWD 4/ 41 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<69/ S1 85; VHJJ1 3HU OD ULSDUWL]LRQH ,WDOLHQ/ 'LSORPDWLVFKH .RUUHVSRQGHQ]/ FIU1 SS1 87408961 3HU 0RGHQD/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ SS1 87608771
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4578
FHQQLR GHO ¶<331 1HO 4<53 XQD OLPLWDWD TXDQWLWj GL DWWL GL DXWRULWj VWDWDOL PR0 GHQHVL IUD LO 4;7; H LO 4;83 IX FHGXWD DOO·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• UHFHQWH GHOO·DUFKLYLR GHOO·DPEDVFLDWD DXVWULDFD D 0RGHQD +4;8304;8<,1 6L WUDWWD GL XQ IRQGR YHUVDWR ILQ GDO 4;9; QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR YLHQQHVH1 (· IRUPDWR GD 75 )DV]LNHO RUGLQDWL FURQRORJLFDPHQWH H SHU QXPHUR GL SURWRFRO0 OR1 &L VRQR SXUH WUH UHJLVWUL GL SURWRFROOR1 0D/ ILQ GDO PRPHQWR GHOOD FRVWLWX]LRQH D 9LHQQD/ QHO 4:7</ SHU YRORQWj GHOO·LPSHUDWULFH 0DULD 7HUHVD/ GL XQ $UFKLYLR JHQHUDOH43 FKH XQLILFDVVH LQ XQ XQLFR LVWLWXWR GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH OH WHVWLPRQLDQ]H GRFXPHQWDULH ULJXDUGDQWL VRSUDWWXWWR OH YLFHQGH GHOOD GLQDVWLD DVEXUJLFD/ VSDUVH ILQR DOORUD LQ YDULH VHGL VWRULFKH GL VYROJLPHQWR GHOOD YLWD H GHOO·DWWLYLWj SROLWLFD GHL VXRL PHPEUL/ DS0 SDUYH FKLDUR FKH XQR GHL ILQL SULPDUL GHOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY HUD SURSULR TXHOOR GL GRFXPHQWDUH/ QHO PRGR SL• DWWHQWR SRVVLELOH/ L IDVWL GHOOD &DVD ++DXV, G·$XVWULD QHOOD VXD OXQJD YLFHQGD IDPLOLDUH H GL SRWHUH1 ,O WHQDFH H SUROXQJDWR ODYRUR GL HVWUD]LRQH GD SDUWH GL VROHUWL IXQ]LRQDUL GD WXWWL L IRQ0 GL DUFKLYLVWLFL D GLVSRVL]LRQH GHOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY GHL GRFXPHQWL LQHUHQWL OD IDPLJOLD GHJOL $VEXUJR/ SRUWz DOO·DFFRVWDPHQWR IUD GL ORUR/ FRQ XQ·RSHUD]LRQH FKH IDUHEEH RJJL UDEEULYLGLUH TXDOVLDVL DUFKLYLVWD EHQSHQVDQWH/ GL DWWL GL VYDULDWD SURYHQLHQ]D/ SULYL GL XQ TXDOVLDVL QHVVR GL FDUDWWHUH DUFKLYL0 VWLFR1 ,O ULVXOWDWR IX OD IRUPD]LRQH GL XQD UDFFROWD GRFXPHQWDULD DPSOLVVLPD/ RUPDL FULVWDOOL]]DWD QHOOH VXH FRPSRQHQWL/ FKH SRUWD LO QRPH GL +DEVEXUJ0 /R0 ²²²²²²²² ;
&IU1 ,ELGHP/ S1 8771 ,ELGHP/ S1 7<51 43 /1 %,771(5/ (LQOHLWXUJ1 'LH JHVFKLFKWOLFKH (QWZLFNOXQJ GHV DUFKLYDOLVFKHQ %HVLW]VWDQGHV XQG GHU (LQULFKWXQJHQ GHV +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLYV/ LQ *HVDPWLQYHQWDU111 FLW1/ 41 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<69/ S1 4:1 <
4579
8JR &RYD
WKULQJLVFKH )DPLOLHQDUFKLY +$UFKLYLR GHOOD IDPLJOLD $VEXUJR0/RUHQD, H FKH FRP0 SUHQGH QRQ VROR OD OLQHD GLUHWWD GHJOL $VEXUJR G·$XVWULD/ HVWLQWDVL FRQ &DUOR 9,/ PD/ HQWUR L OLPLWL GHO SRVVLELOH/ DQFKH GL TXHOOL GL 6SDJQD H SRL GHJOL $0 VEXUJR0/RUHQD H GL DOWUL UDPL PLQRUL GHOOD IDPLJOLD1 9DOH TXL OD SHQD GL DF0 FHQQDUH DSSHQD FKH DOOD PRUWH GL &DUOR 9, QHO 4:73/ VXFFHVVH DO SDGUH/ QHOOD WLWRODULWj GHL SRVVHGLPHQWL HUHGLWDUL GL &DVD G·$XVWULD H GHL 5HJQL G·8QJKHULD H GL %RHPLD/ LQ PDQFDQ]D G·XQ HUHGH GL VHVVR PDVFKLOH/ OD ILJOLD 0DULD 7HUH0 VD/ LQ EDVH DL SULQFLSL HQXQFLDWL QHOOD 3UDPPDWLFD VDQ]LRQH GHO 4:57/ FKH DO0 ODUJDYD DQFKH DL GLVFHQGHQWL GL VHVVR IHPPLQLOH GHJOL $VEXUJR OD GLJQLWj VR0 YUDQD441 ,Q VHJXLWR DO PDWULPRQLR QHO 4:69 IUD 0DULD 7HUHVD H )UDQFHVFR 6WH0 IDQR GL /RUHQD/ GLYHQXWR SRL VDFUR URPDQR LPSHUDWRUH/ HEEH RULJLQH OD GLQD0 VWLD GHJOL $VEXUJR0/RUHQD1 )XURQR FRVu VDFUL URPDQL LPSHUDWRUL L ORUR ILJOL *LXVHSSH +,,, H /HRSROGR +,,,1 8OWLPR VDFUR URPDQR LPSHUDWRUH IX LO ILJOLR GL /HRSROGR/ )UDQFHVFR1 4XDOH VDFUR URPDQR LPSHUDWRUH IX )UDQFHVFR ,, H/ FRPH SULPR LPSHUDWRUH HUHGLWDULR G·$XVWULD/ IX )UDQFHVFR ,1 4XHVW·XOWLPR WLWROR OR DYHYD DVVXQWR JLj LO 47 DJRVWR 4;37/ PHQWUH LO 9 DJRVWR 4;39 HJOL D0 YHYD ULQXQFLDWR D TXHOOR GL VDFUR URPDQR LPSHUDWRUH/ LQ VHJXLWR DOOD FRVWLWX0 ]LRQH GHOOD &RQIHGHUD]LRQH GHO 5HQR YROXWD GD 1DSROHRQH/ FKH VYXRWDYD GL TXDOVLDVL UHVLGXR VLJQLILFDWR XQD GLJQLWj JLj GD WHPSR SULYD GL XQ FRQWHQXWR SROLWLFR FRQFUHWR1 8Q UDPR FDGHWWR GHJOL $VEXUJR0/RUHQD ULFRSUu OD GLJQLWj GL JUDQGXFKL GL 7RVFDQD ILQ GDOOD PHWj GHO ¶:33/ PHQWUH QHL SULPL DQQL GHO VHFROR VXFFHVVLYR XQD GLQDVWLD DVEXUJLFD VXFFHVVH DOOD IDPLJOLD G·(VWH QHO 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD1 1HO 4;36/ FRQ OD PRUWH GHO GXFD (UFROH ,,,/ VL HUD HVWLQWD OD OLQHD PDVFKLOH GHOOD IDPLJOLD G·(VWH1 3RFKL PHVL SULPD GHOOD VXD PRUWH LO GXFD DYHYD DIILGDWR O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GHO VXR 6WDWR DOO·DUFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR G·$VEXUJR0/RUHQD/ PDULWR GL VXD ILJOLD 0DULD %HDWULFH1 3HUGXWR GDOO·DUFLGXFD LO 'XFDWR FRQ OD SD0 FH GL 3UHVEXUJR GHO 59 GLFHPEUH 4;38/ OD VRYUDQLWj VX TXHO WHUULWRULR YHQQH XIILFLDOPHQWH ULFRQRVFLXWD DOOD QHRFRVWLWXLWD &DVD $XVWULD0(VWH/ GRSR OD SD0 UHQWHVL QDSROHRQLFD/ GDO &RQJUHVVR GL 9LHQQD1 $JOL $XVWULD0(VWH IXURQR UHVWL0 WXLWH SXUH/ QHO 4;5</ 0DVVD H &DUUDUD451 ,O 53 DJRVWR 4;8< OD GLQDVWLD IX GLFKLDUDWD GHFDGXWD GDOOH VXH IXQ]LRQL H SRFR SL• WDUGL LO WHUULWRULR GHO GXFDWR IX DQQHVVR DO 5HJQR GL 6DUGHJQD1 ²²²²²²²² 44 6XO VLJQLILFDWR LVWLWX]LRQDOH H GLQDVWLFR GHOOD 3UDPPDWLFD VDQ]LRQH/ FIU1 (1&1 +(//%/,1*111 FLW1/ SS1 5:905;31 45 )1 921 5(,1g+// 'DV +DEVEXUJ0/RWKULQJLVFKH )DPLOLHQDUFKLY/ LQ *HVDPWLQYHQWDU 111FLW1/ 51 %DQG/ :LHQ 4<6:/ S1 8;1
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
457:
/·XOWLPR GXFD/ )UDQFHVFR 9/ PRUu QHO 4;:8 H OH VXH SURSULHWj/ XQLWDPHQWH DO WLWROR $XVWULD0(VWH/ IXURQR FRQIHULWL DOO·DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR )HUGLQDQGR G·$VEXUJR/ LO IXWXUR VXFFHVVRUH GHVLJQDWR GHOO·LPSHUDWRUH )UDQFHVFR *LX0 VHSSH VXO WURQR DXVWUR0XQJDULFR/ DVVDVVLQDWR/ FRPH q QRWR/ D 6DUDMHYR LO 5; JLXJQR 4<471 *OL VXFFHVVH QHO WLWROR O·DUFLGXFD &DUOR FKH VDUHEEH GLYHQXWR/ DOOD PRUWH GHO YHFFKLVVLPR )UDQFHVFR *LXVHSSH QHO 4<49/ O·XOWLPR LPSHUDWR0 UH GHOO·$XVWULD08QJKHULD +&DUOR ,,/ VSD]]DWR YLD GXH DQQL SL• WDUGL FRQ OD FRQFOXVLRQH GHOOD , JXHUUD PRQGLDOH461 ,Q VHJXLWR D WUDWWDWLYH SURWUDWWHVL IUD LO 4;9; H LO 4;:5/ LO GXFD0DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR 9 RWWHQQH GDO 5HJQR G·,WDOLD GL SRWHU PDQWHQHUH LQ HVLOLR SUHVVR OD GHWURQL]]DWD GLQDVWLD O·DUFKLYLR IDPLOLDUH GHJOL $XVWULD0(VWH1 'HWWR DUFKLYLR/ FRQVHUYDWR LQ XQ SDOD]]R YLHQQHVH/ YHQQH/ DOOD PRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR 9/ LQ SDU0 WH GLVSHUVR R GLVWUXWWR1 /D SDUWH ULWHQXWD GHJQD GL FRQVHUYD]LRQH YHQQH QHO 4;:9 DIILGDWD LQ HUHGLWj DO VRSUD ULFRUGDWR DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR )HUGLQDQGR1 $SSHQD GRSR OD WUDJLFD PRUWH GL TXHVW·XOWLPR/ O·DUFKLYLR GHOOD IDPLJOLD $X0 VWULD0(VWH IX YHUVDWR/ QHO 4<48/ DOOR +DXV0 +RI0 XQG 6WDDWVDUFKLY1 0D LQ GHWWR IRQGR DUFKLYLVWLFR HUDQR DQFKH RUPDL FRQIOXLWL FRQVLVWHQWL QXFOHL GRFXPHQ0 WDUL IDFHQWL FDSR DOO·DUFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR )HUGLQDQGR R UHODWLYL DG DOWUL PHPEUL GHOOD IDPLJOLD $VEXUJR0/RUHQD1 /·LQWHUYHQWR GHOO·DUFLGXFD &DUOR/ LO IXWXUR LPSHUDWRUH &DUOR ,/ TXDOH VXFFHVVRUH WHVWDPHQWDULR GL )UDQFHVFR )HUGLQDQGR/ SRUWz QXRYL VFRQYROJLPHQWL QHOO·DUFKLYLR DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ FKH QRQ SHU QXOOD ULPDVH SHU OXQJR WHPSR LQ XQR VWDWR GL VHPLDEEDQGRQR471 'RSR OD , JXHUUD PRQGLDOH IXURQR FHGXWH DOO·,WDOLD +QHO 4<54 H QHO 4<58, DOFXQH VHULH GL DWWL GL SURYHQLHQ]D LWDOLDQD481 )UD LO 4<58 H LO 4<65 LO IRQGR IX LQYHQWDULDWR/ PD LO VXR VWDWR GL RUGLQDPHQWR QRQ q FHUWR PROWR VRGGLVIDFHQ0 WH1 )UD L TXDVL ;33 )DV]LNHO FKH FRPSUHQGRQR LO IRQGR/ VROR DOFXQH YRFL FL VHPEUDQR HVVHUH GL LQWHUHVVH HVWHQVH/ R SHUORPHQR LWDOLDQR/ FKH FL SDUH TXLQ0 GL XWLOL HVWUDSRODUH GDOO·HVLVWHQWH LQYHQWDULR GHOO·gVWHUUHLFKLVFK0(VWHQVLVFKHV +DX0 VDUFKLY +$UFKLYLR IDPLOLDUH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH,1 9HQJRQR SXUH ULSRUWDWH LQ ILQH DO0 FXQH YRFL GL GXEELD DWWULEX]LRQH1
²²²²²²²² 46
,ELGHP/ SS1 8;08<1 ,ELGHP1 48 ,ELGHP/ S1 931 7UDWWDVL GL DUFKLYL GL DJHQ]LH FRQVRODUL HVWHQVL H GL DWWL GL XQD %ULJDWD HVWHQVH GHJOL DQQL GDO 4;6; DO 4;961 47
457;
8JR &RYD
)DV]1 4047
'RFXPHQWL LQ RULJLQDOH H LQ FRSLD GHOOH ID0 PLJOLH 3DUSDOHRQH HG (VWH00DVVD &DUUDUD VHF1 ;90;9,,,
)DV]1 48055
$WWL H GRFXPHQWL GL IDPLJOLD
)DV]1 56
+PDQFD,
)DV]1 5706<
$WWL GL IDPLJOLD H FRUULVSRQGHQ]D
4:9504;5<
)DV]1 559055<
$UFLGXFD )HUGLQDQGR ,9/ GXFD GL 0RGHQD= RSHUD]LRQL FRQWUR 0XUDW> HSLVWRODULR> DWWL
4;48 4;47 VHJJ1
$UFLGXFD )UDQFHVFR 9/ GXFD GL 0RGHQD= WHVWDPHQWR GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,9/ HSLVWROD0 ULR/ DWWL
+4;94,
)DV]1 5830585
$WWL GHO 'XFDWR GL /XFFD
4;3804;:4
)DV]1 5860587
$WWL GHO UHVLGHQWH PLQLVWHULDOH GL /XFFD D 9LHQQD/ EDURQH )DEUL]LR GH 2VWLQL
4;7704;96
$WWL GHOO·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH GL $JQDQR/ (P0 SROL H GHL EHQL LQ 7RVFDQD
474704;88
)DV]1 5630573
)DV]1 593076< )DV]1 7730:;6
$WWL UHODWLYL DO SDWULPRQLR H DOO·DPPLQLVWUD0 ]LRQH IDPLOLDUH DUFLGXFDOH +", 5HJLVWUL 40<9 /LEUL GL FDVVD +",
4:8;04;77
498604<38 4::404;;9
8QD VHULH D SDUWH ULVSHWWR DOO·gVWHUUHLFKLVFKHV0 (VWHQVLVFKHV +DXVDUFKLY q TXHOOD GHQRPLQDWD 6FKORVVDUFKLY &DWDMR0 8UNXQGHQ +$UFKLYLR GHO FDVWHOOR GL &DWDLR0 'RFXPHQWL,1 1RQ YLHQH GDWD OD FRQVLVWHQ]D GHOOD VHULH/ PD VROR XQD YDJD/ PD VLJQLILFD0 WLYD LQGLFD]LRQH GHOOH GDWH LQL]LDOL H WHUPLQDOL= ;,,0;9,,, VHFROR1 6L GLFH VROR FKH O·DUFKLYLR GL &DWDLR HUD SHUYHQXWR LQ SURSULHWj GHOOD IDPLJOLD $XVWULD0 (VWH DVVLHPH DO IHGHFRPPHVVR 2EL]]L QHO 4;36491 'HOXGHQWL VRQR VWDWH OH ULFHUFKH GL GDWL VX 0RGHQD QHJOL DOWUL YROXPL GHOOH ²²²²²²²² 49
,ELGHP/ SS1 930941
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
457<
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j DUFKLYLVWLFKH UHODWLYH DG XQ PRPHQWR GUDPPDWL0 FR SHU L 'XFDWL SDGDQL H L OLPLWURIL WHUULWRUL GHOOR 6WDWR SRQWLILFLR/ YLVWR GDOOD SDUWH GHOO·RFFXSDWRUH PLOLWDUH DXVWULDFR1 'RSR TXHVWD UDSLGD FDYDOFDWD DUFKLYLVWLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOH FKH FL KD LQWURGRW0 WR VXL UDSSRUWL HVLVWHQWL/ VRWWR O·DVSHWWR GLQDVWLFR/ DPPLQLVWUDWLYR H PLOLWDUH/ IUD O·$XVWULD H 0RGHQD/ FL VHPEUD RSSRUWXQR HVDPLQDUH XQ VHWWRUH SDUWLFROD0 UH/ TXHOOR GHL UDSSRUWL FRPPHUFLDOL QHO SHULRGR LPPHGLDWDPHQWH DQWHULRUH D TXHOOR GHOO·DQQHVVLRQH GHL 'XFDWL SDGDQL DOOR 6WDWR VDEDXGR1 6L WUDWWD GL XQ VHWWRUH GL SDUWLFRODUH ULOLHYR/ FKH WHVWLPRQLD O·LQWHUHVVH DXVWULDFR D PDQWHQHUH QRQ VROR FRQ OH DUPL/ PD DQFKH FRQ DUJRPHQWD]LRQL GL FDUDWWHUH HFRQRPLFR/ OD SURSULD VXSUHPD]LD SROLWLFD VX XQD GHOOH SDUWL SL• ULFFKH H/ VRWWR YDUL DVSHW0 WL/ SL• SURJUHGLWH GHOO·,WDOLD SUHXQLWDULD1 ( O·LQWHUHVVH DXPHQWD VH YLHQH SUHVR LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH O·DWWHJJLDPHQWR GHO *RYHUQR DXVWULDFR VX WDOH DUJRPHQWR LQ XQ SHULRGR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH FUXFLDOH SHU OH VRUWL GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJL0 FD1 *OL DQQL LPPHGLDWDPHQWH DQWHULRUL DO 4;7; YHGRQR LQIDWWL XQ ,PSHUR DX0 VWULDFR UHWWR/ PD VROR QRPLQDOPHQWH/ GD XQ VRYUDQR LQHWWR HG LQFDSDFH +)HU0 GLQDQGR ,, H JRYHUQDWR R/ PHJOLR DPPLQLVWUDWR/ GDJOL DOWL IXQ]LRQDUL SUHSRVWL DL JUDQGL 'LFDVWHUL GL &RUWH/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH LO 0HWWHUQLFK SHU OD SROLWLFD HVWHUD H LO .•EHFN SHU TXHOOD ILQDQ]LDULD/ QHO FOLPD VWDJQDQWH HG RSSUHVVLYR GL XQR 6WDWR GL SROL]LD LQFDSDFH GL FRPSUHQGHUH L PXWDPHQWL VRFLDOL/ SROLWLFL HG HFR0 QRPLFL FKH SUHPHYDQR GDL VHWWRUL SL• HYROXWL GHOOD ERUJKHVLD QHOOH YDULH SUR0 YLQFH GHOO·,PSHUR1 3RL YHQQHUR L PRWL ULYROX]LRQDUL GHO 4;7;/ FKH FRVWULQVHUR SULPD OD IDPLJOLD LPSHULDOH D IXJJLUH GD 9LHQQD H SRL O·LPSHUDWRUH )HUGLQDQ0 GR DG DEGLFDUH D IDYRUH GHO JLRYDQLVVLPR )UDQFHVFR *LXVHSSH/ FKH DVVXQVH OD GLJQLWj LPSHULDOH LO 5 GLFHPEUH 4;7;1 /D ULSUHVD G·DXWRULWj GHOOD FODVVH GR0 ²²²²²²²² 4:
,QYHQWDU GHV .ULHJVDUFKLYV :LHQ/ ,, %DQG/ :LHQ 4<86/ S1 71
4583
8JR &RYD
PLQDQWH FRPSRUWz LQL]LDOPHQWH LO VXSHUDPHQWR GHJOL HQWXVLDVPL ULYROX]LRQD0 UL DWWUDYHUVR OD FRQFHVVLRQH GL XQD &RVWLWX]LRQH PRGHUDWD O·; PDU]R 4;7< H SRL/ DOOD ILQH GHO 4;84/ OD SUHVD GHO SRWHUH GD SDUWH GL XQ JRYHUQR QHRDVVROX0 WLVWLFR FKH DEROu OD &RVWLWX]LRQH/ LO 3DUODPHQWR H L GLULWWL IRQGDPHQWDOL GHL FLW0 WDGLQL1 /·,PSHUR ULHEEH XQD &RVWLWX]LRQH DSSHQD QHO GLFHPEUH 4;9:/ TXDQGR OR 6WDWR DVEXUJLFR PXWz OD SURSULD VWUXWWXUD LVWLWX]LRQDOH DWWUDYHUVR XQD IRU0 PD ´GXDOLVWLFDµ= LQ EDVH DO FRPSURPHVVR DXVWUR0XQJKHUHVH/ O·LPSHUR GLYHQQH DOORUD XQR 6WDWR GL WLSR IHGHUDOH/ FDPELDQGR SXUH OD SURSULD GHQRPLQD]LRQH GD ,PSHUR DXVWULDFR/ D ,PSHUR DXVWUR0XQJDULFR1 &L VHPEUD TXLQGL VLQJRODUH QRWDUH/ QHL UDSSRUWL GL SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH FRQ JOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ QRQRVWDQWH L PXWDPHQWL LVWLWX]LRQDOL LQ DWWR/ WHVWq VXF0 FLQWDPHQWH ULFRUGDWL/ XQD FHUWD FRQWLQXLWj G·LQGLUL]]R GD SDUWH DXVWULDFD/ QHOO·DIIHUPD]LRQH GHO SURSULR UXROR SUHGRPLQDQWH LQ ,WDOLD1 0D TXDO HUD OD VLWXD]LRQH SROLWLFD HG HFRQRPLFD GHL 'XFDWL SDGDQL/ FKH RIIULYD DOO·$XVWULD O·HVWUR GL JLRVWUDUH SHU O·DWWXD]LRQH GL XQ GLVHJQR GL SHQHWUD]LRQH QHO WHVVXWR FRQQHWWLYR VRFLR0HFRQRPLFR GL TXHL WHUULWRUL" 6LD LO GXFDWR GL 3DUPD4;/ VRWWR OD GLQDVWLD GHL %RUERQL +GRSR OD PRUWH QHO 4;7: GHOOD PRGHUDWD H OXQJLPLUDQWH 0DULD /XLVD G·$VEXUJR/ JLj PRJOLH GL 1DSROHRQH ,, FKH TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD/ VRWWR OD GLQDVWLD GHJOL $XVWULD ² (VWH/ H VRSUDWWXWWR TXHVW·XOWLPR/ FRVWLWXLURQR/ DOOD PHWj GHO ;,; VHFROR/ XQ SUH]LRVR SXQWR G·DSSRJJLR SHU OD FRQGX]LRQH GL XQ LQGLUL]]R GL SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFD H FRPPHUFLDOH GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD LQ ,WDOLD FKH/ VH ULXVFLWR/ DYUHEEH FRQGRWWR DOOD FUHD]LRQH GL XQ·DPSOLVVLPD ]RQD GL OLEHUR VFDPELR/ FRPSUHQ0 GHQWH QRQ VROR JUDQ SDUWH GHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL SUHXQLWDUL/ PD SXUH O·LPSHUR DX0 VWULDFR H OR =ROOYHUHLQ JHUPDQLFR1 /·DSHUWD GLVFUHSDQ]D IUD LO IUD]LRQDPHQWR SROLWLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOH H OD FUHVFL0 WD HFRQRPLFR0VRFLDOH GHOO·,WDOLD GHOOD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH/ DYHYD SRUWDWR DO PDQLIH0 VWDUVL/ D YDUL OLYHOOL/ GL LVWDQ]H GLUHWWH DOO·XQLILFD]LRQH GHOOD PXOWLIRUPH H FRQ0 ²²²²²²²² 4; 4XHVWD SDUWH GHO WHVWR/ ILQR DOOD ILQH/ q WUDWWD LQWHJUDOPHQWH GDO PLR YROXPH LQWLWRODWR &RPPHUFLR H QDYLJD]LRQH D 7ULHVWH H QHOOD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD GD 0DULD 7HUHVD DO 4<48/ &LYLOWj GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR 78/ 8GLQH 4<<5/ SS1 4;804<31 6XOOH ULIRUPH QHL GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 0RGHQD YHGL VRSUDWWXWWR (1 3$66(5,1 '·(175e9(6/ /·,WDOLD QHOO·HWj GHOOH ULIRUPH/ LQ 11 9$/(5,/ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ ,,,/ 7RULQR 4<98/ SS1 45<0468> /1 0$5,1,/ /R 6WDWR HVWHQVH/ LQ *1 *$/$662/ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ 7RULQR 4<:</ ;9,,/ SS1 4790483> *1 72&&,/ ,O GXFDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD111 FLW1 SS1 5<4064:> 61&1 :22/)/ /D VWRULD SROLWLFD H VRFLDOH/ LQ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD/ ,,,/ 'DO SULPR 6HWWHFHQWR DOO·8QLWj/ 7RULQR 4<:6/ SS1 476047<1
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4584
WUDGGLWWRULD UHDOWj LWDOLDQD/ VLD LQ FDPSR SROLWLFR FKH LQ TXHOOR HFRQRPLFR1 &RQVFL GHOOD SUHFDULHWj GHOOD ORUR SRVL]LRQH VXO SLDQR SROLWLFR/ VRVWHQXWD SUH0 YDOHQWHPHQWH GDOOD SRWHQ]D PLOLWDUH DXVWULDFD/ DOFXQL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL PRVVHUR OH ORUR GLSORPD]LH DOOD ULFHUFD GL DFFRUGL SHU OD FUHD]LRQH GL XQ QHVVR IHGHUDWLYR FKH OL DYYLFLQDVVH IUD GL ORUR VRWWR XQ SURILOR SROLWLFR0LVWLWX]LRQDOH4< R SHU OD VWLSXOD]LRQH GL XQD XQLRQH GRJDQDOH/ FKH HOLPLQDVVH OH EDUULHUH GL QDWXUD H0 FRQRPLFD FKH OL GLYLGHYDQR1 0HWWHQGR/ LQIDWWL/ D WDFHUH OH LVWDQ]H GL XQD ODUJD SDUWH GHOOD ERUJKHVLD LWDOLDQD/ IDYRUHYROH DOOD OLEHUD FLUFROD]LRQH GHOOH PHUFL QHOOD SHQLVROD/ VDUHEEHUR VWDWL WROWL/ FRQ FRQFHVVLRQL VXO SLDQR GHOOD SROLWLFD HFRQRPLFD/ DL IDXWRUL GL XQR 6WDWR QD]LRQDOH LWDOLDQR/ DOFXQL GHJOL DUJRPHQWL SL• FRQFUHWL H SL• VHQWLWL GDOOD FODVVH FRPPHUFLDOH H LPSUHQGLWRULDOH RSHUDQWH QHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL SUHXQLWDUL531 (· ORJLFR FKH O·$XVWULD YHGHVVH GL EXRQ RFFKLR/ LQL]LDOPHQWH VRSUDWWXWWR SHU L GHVFULWWL PRWLYL GL QDWXUD SROLWLFD/ XQ·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH IUD JOL 6WDWL LWDOLD0 QL/ TXDORUD WDOH XQLRQH IRVVH GD HVVD RSSRUWXQDPHQWH RUFKHVWUDWD FRQ XQD GLUHWWD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DOOD VWHVVD LQ XQD SRVL]LRQH DGHJXDWD1 *Lj QHO 4;74 HUD LQWHUFRUVR IUD LO .•EHFN H LO 0HWWHUQLFK XQR VFDPELR GL OHWWHUH VX WDOH DUJR0 PHQWR= OD SURSRVWD GHOOR +RINDPPHUSUlVLGHQW GL FUHDUH XQ·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH DXVWUR0LWDOLFD HUD YLVWD IDYRUHYROPHQWH DQFKH GDO 0HWWHUQLFK/ PD SHU LO PR0 PHQWR HUD GD OXL ULWHQXWD LQDWWXDELOH541 8Q FHUWR DOODUPH VXVFLWz QHJOL DPELHQWL JRYHUQDWLYL DXVWULDFL LO WHQWDWLYR/ DYYHQXWR QHO 4;7:/ GHOOD FRVWLWX]LRQH GL XQD ´/HJD GRJDQDOH LWDOLDQDµ SUR0 PRVVD GD SDSD 3LR ,;/ GDOOD TXDOH O·$XVWULD YHQLYD WHQXWD SDOHVHPHQWH DO GL IXRUL1 1HO QRYHPEUH 4;7: L UDSSUHVHQWDQWL GHOOR 6WDWR GHOOD &KLHVD/ GHO 5H0 JQR GL 6DUGHJQD H GHO *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD DYHYDQR/ LQIDWWL/ VRWWRVFULWWR D 7RULQR XQD GLFKLDUD]LRQH SURJUDPPDWLFD GL FRVWLWX]LRQH GL OHJD GRJDQDOH DO0 OD TXDOH YHQLYDQR LQYLWDWL D SDUWHFLSDUH SXUH LO 5HJQR GHOOH GXH 6LFLOLH HG LO ²²²²²²²² 4<
$101 *+,6$/%(57,/ /D VHFRQGD 5HVWDXUD]LRQH +4;7<04;85,/ LQ )1 9$/(5,/ 6WRULD G·,WDOLD« FLW1/ ,,,/ SS1 ;670;6;> *1 /8==$772/ 6WRULD HFRQRPLFD GHOO·HWj PRGHUQD H FRQWHPSRUDQHD/ SDUWH ,,/ 3DGRYD 4<93/ SS1 66606671 53 81 0$5&(//,/ 8Q SURJHWWR GL QHVVR HFRQRPLFR LWDOR0DXVWUR0JHUPDQLFR SHUVHJXLWR GD 9LHQQD IUD LO 4;7< H LO 4;8</ LQ ©5DVVHJQD 6WRULFD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ /;,9/ IDVF1 ,,0,,, +4<8:,/ SS1 77;0 77<> 61 )85/$1, 0 $1 :$1'586=.$/ $XVWULD H ,WDOLD D GXH YRFL/ %RORJQD 4<:7/ S1 4771 54 $1 %((5/ 'LH |VWHUUHLFKLVFKH +DQGHOVSROLWLN LP QHXQ]HKQWHQ -DKUKXQGHUW/ :LHQ 4;<4/ SS1 6890 68:> ,1$1 */$=,(5/ ,O FRPPHUFLR HVWHUR GHO 5HJQR /RPEDUGR0YHQHWR GDO 4;48 DO 4;98/ LQ $UFKLYLR HFR0 QRPLFR GHOO·XQLILFD]LRQH LWDOLDQD/ V1 ,/ ;9/ IDVF1 XQLFR/ S1 6<> &1 5$,121(/ &RQVHQVL H FRQWUDVWL SHU O·DGHVLRQH GHO 5HJQR GHOOH GXH 6LFLOLH DO SURJUDPPD GL XQLRQH GRJDQDOH LWDOLDQD/ LQ ©5DVVHJQD 6WRULFD GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWRª/ ,,0,,,/ +4<8:,/ SS1 7;607;71
4585
8JR &RYD
'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ PD GDOOD TXDOH HUD WHQXWR IXRUL LO 5HJQR /RPEDUGR0 YHQHWR551 1RQRVWDQWH JOL HQWXVLDVPL VXVFLWDWL LQ YDUL DPELHQWL LWDOLDQL GDOO·LQL]LDWLYD/ OH FXL ILQDOLWj DQWLDXVWULDFKH HUDQR WUDVSDUHQWL/ HVVD QRQ HEEH PDL DWWXD]LRQH1 /H SUHVVLRQL RVWLOL DG HVVD RSHUDWH GDOOD GLSORPD]LD DVEXUJLFD VX 1DSROL H 0RGHQD HEEHUR EXRQ JLRFR/ DO SXQWR GD VXVFLWDUH FRPPHQWL QH0 JDWLYL GD SDUWH GHOOD *UDQ %UHWDJQD/ FKLDUDPHQWH LQWHUHVVDWD DG XQ·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH LWDOLDQD VHQ]D SDUWHFLSD]LRQH DXVWULDFD561 &RQWULEXu D VSHJQHUH JOL HQWXVLDVPL VXVFLWDWL GDL *RYHUQL GL 7RULQR/ )L0 UHQ]H H 5RPD/ OD VWLSXOD]LRQH IUD $XVWULD H L 'XFDWL GL 0RGHQD H 3DUPD/ QHO GLFHPEUH 4;7:/ GL XQ WUDWWDWR GL DOOHDQ]D FKH OHJDYD TXHVWL XOWLPL LQWLPDPHQ0 WH D 9LHQQD/ LQ FRUULVSRQGHQ]D VRSUDWWXWWR DOOH FRQYLQ]LRQL SROLWLFKH GHO GX0 FD GL 0RGHQD )UDQFHVFR 9 GL $XVWULD 0 (VWH/ FKH YHGHYD LO IXWXUR SROLWLFR HG HFRQRPLFR GHOO·,WDOLD LQGLVVROXELOPHQWH FRQQHVVR D TXHOOR GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD571 1RQ GHYH TXLQGL PHUDYLJOLDUH O·LQL]LDWLYD DVVXQWD GD TXHO GXFD/ QHOO·XOWLPR VFRUFLR GHO 4;7:/ GLUHWWD DOOD VWLSXOD]LRQH GL XQ WUDWWDWR GL FRPPHUFLR FRQ O·$XVWULD/ LQ VHJQR GL ULILXWR DOO·LQL]LDWLYD DVVXQWD GDJOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ FRPH SXUH HUD ORJLFD OD EXRQD GLVSRVL]LRQH DXVWULDFD D WUDWWDUH FRQ )UDQFHVFR 91 *Lj LO 58 JHQQDLR 4;7; HUD SURQWR XQ WUDWWDWR SUHOLPLQDUH/ FKH FRQFHGHYD/ LQ SDUWLFRODUH/ D 0RGHQD/ IDFLOLWD]LRQL GRJDQDOL SHU O·HVSRUWD]LRQH LQ WHUULWRULR DXVWULDFR GL SURGRWWL ]RRWHFQLFL HG DJULFROL GHO GXFDWR581 /·DGHVLRQH DO FLWDWR WUDWWDWR DQFKH GHO 'XFDWR GL 3DUPD LO 5 OXJOLR 4;7</ FRVWLWXu O·RFFDVLRQH SHU O·LQL]LR GL XQD WUDWWDWLYD/ SRFR SL• WDUGL/ SHU XQD YHUD H SURSULD XQLRQH GRJDQDOH IUD $XVWULD/ 0RGHQD H 3DUPD591 ,O GLVHJQR GL WDOH XQLRQH/ IDYRULWD DOORUD GDO %UXFN TXDOH PLQLVWUR GHO FRPPHUFLR DXVWULDFR/ HEEH OD VXD GHILQL]LRQH FRQ OD VWLSXOD]LRQH GHO WUDWWDWR IUD $XVWULD/ 0RGHQD H 3DUPD LO < DJRVWR 4;855:1 /D GXUDWD GHOO·XQLRQH GRYHYD FRUUHUH GDO IHEEUDLR ²²²²²²²² 55
&1 5$,121(/ FLW1/ S1 7;7> FIU1 SXUH %((5/«FLW1/ S1 68:1 &1 5$,121(/ FLW1/ S1 7<4> FIU1 SXUH +$860+2)081' 67$$76$5&+,9 +:,(1, + ++6$,/ 7RVNDQD $GP1 $NWHQ/ %HULFKWH/ :HLVXQJHQ 4;7904;85/ OHWWHUD ULVHUYDWD GHOO·LQFDULFDWR G·DIIDUL DXVWULDFR SUHVVR OD &RUWH WRVFDQD/ EDURQH YRQ +•JHO DO SULQFLSH GL 6FKZDU]HQEHUJ/ GDWDWD )LUHQ]H/ 64 OXJOLR 4;83> HVWUDWWR GL XQ UDSSRUWR ULVHUYDWR GHOOR +•JHO D 6FKZDU]HQEHUJ GDWD0 WR )LUHQ]H 6 DJRVWR 4;831 57 $101 *+,6$/%(57, FLW1/ S1 ;68> &1 5$,121(/ FLW1/ S1 7<41 58 $1 %((5/ FLW1/ SS1 68:068;1 59 ,ELGHP/ S1 68;1 5: ,ELGHP> ,1$1 */$=,(51 FLW1/ S1 6<> =ROO0(LQLJXQJV09HUWUDJ ]ZLVFKHQ 2HVWHUUHLFK/ 0RGHQD XQG 3DUPD YRP <1 $XJXVW 4;85/ 51*1%1 1U1 636> .XQGPDFKXQJ GHU 0LQLVWHULHQ GHU )LQDQ]HQ XQG GHV 56
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4586
4;86 DOO·RWWREUH 4;8:1 1HOOH LQWHQ]LRQL DXVWULDFKH/ D GHWWR WUDWWDWR DYUHEEHUR SRWXWR DGHULUH DQFKH DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ 3LHPRQWH FRPSUHVR/ FKH/ DOPHQR LQL0 ]LDOPHQWH/ QRQ HUD VHPEUDWR SUHJLXGL]LDOPHQWH FRQWUDULR DOO·LQL]LDWLYD1 $O IL0 QH GL DWWULEXLUH XQ FDUDWWHUH LWDOLDQR DOO· XQLRQH/ IX SUHYLVWR XQ UDSSRUWR SL• VWUHWWR IUD 3DUPD H 0RGHQD FRQ LO 5HJQR /REDUGR0YHQHWR/ FKH FRO UHVWR GHO0 OD 0RQDUFKLD5;1 0RGHQD H 3DUPD IXURQR WHQXWH/ LQ VHJXLWR DO WUDWWDWR VRWWRVFULWWR/ DG D0 GRWWDUH OD OHJLVOD]LRQH GRJDQDOH DXVWULDFD FRQ OD WDULIID GHO 9 QRYHPEUH 4;84/ ROWUH DL UHJRODPHQWL VXL PRQRSROL GL 6WDWR/ DOOD QRUPDWLYD SHQDOH DXVWULDFD H DOO·RUJDQL]]D]LRQH GHOOD *XDUGLD GL ILQDQ]D GHO 4ƒ DJRVWR 4;765<1 6L SURYYLGH DG XQ·HTXD GLVWULEX]LRQH GHOOH UHQGLWH GRJDQDOL IUD LO /RPEDUGR0YHQHWR H L GXH GXFDWL LQ SURSRU]LRQH DOOD ULVSHWWLYD SRSROD]LRQH1 /·LQVHULPHQWR GL 0RGHQD H 3DUPD QHO WHUULWRULR GRJDQDOH DXVWULDFR SUR0 YRFz/ LQQDQ]L WXWWR/ XQ WUDFROOR SHU L WUDGL]LRQDOL UDSSRUWL FRPPHUFLDOL GL TXHL GXFDWL FRQ OD *UDQ %UHWDJQD/ OD )UDQFLD H OD 6YL]]HUD HG XQ DIIOXVVR YL0 VWRVR LQ HVVL GL PDQXIDWWL DXVWULDFL/ LQ VRVWLWX]LRQH GL TXHOOL SURYHQLHQWL GDL GHWWL 3DHVL1 6L DFFUHEEHUR D GLVPLVXUD L UDSSRUWL FRPPHUFLDOL IUD L GXFDWL H LO /RPEDUGR0YHQHWR/ YHUR EHQHILFLDULR GHOO·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH/ FKH HVSRUWz QHL GXFDWL WHVVXWL H ILODWL GL ODQD/ FRWRQH H VHWD/ ]XFFKHUR/ IHUUDPHQWD/ FDUWD/ OLEUL H DOWUR1 0HQR IDYRULWL IXURQR L 3DHVL HUHGLWDUL DXVWULDFL= GL XQ FHUWR ULOLHYR IX O·HVSRUWD]LRQH GL WHVVXWL GL ODQD GL 9LHQQD H GL IHUUR VWLULDQR1 , SURGRWWL DJUL0 FROL H ]RRWHFQLFL GHL GXFDWL HEEHUR ODUJR VPHUFLR QHO /RPEDUGR0YHQHWR FKH/ SULPD GHOO·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH/ DYHYD DYXWR UDSSRUWL UHODWLYDPHQWH VFDUVL FRQ L GXH SLFFROL 6WDWL VXOOD ULYD GHVWUD GHO 3R631 $OOR VFDGHUH GHO WUDWWDWR/ O·XQLRQH/ FKH SXUH DYHYD FUHDWR FRUUHQWL GL WUDI0 ILFR QRQ WUDVFXUDELOL/ QRQ IX ULQQRYDWD/ LQ VHJXLWR DO ULILXWR GL 3DUPD641 8Q·HSLGHPLD GL FROHUD/ YDOXWD]LRQL GL QDWXUD SROLWLFD/ ILQDQ]LDULD HG HFRQRPL0 FD/ VXJJHULURQR TXHVWR SDVVR1 8Q SHVR QRWHYROH LQ TXHVWD VLWXD]LRQH HEEH VHQ]·DOWUR LO YLVWRVR DXPHQWR GHL SUH]]L GHL JHQHUL DJULFROL QHL GXFDWL/ YHULIL0 FDWRVL LQ VHJXLWR D FDWWLYL UDFFROWL QHO /RPEDUGR0YHQHWR/ ROWUH DOO·LPSRVVLELOLWj/ SHU O·DUWLJLDQDWR ORFDOH/ GL UHJJHUH DOO·XUWR GHOO·DIIOXVVR GHL ²²²²²²²² +DQGHOV YRP 4:1 2FWREHU 4;85/ EHWUHIIHQG GHQ 9ROO]XJ GHU |VWHUUHLFKLVFK0PRGHQHVLVFK0SDUPHQVLVFKHQ =ROO0 (LQLJXQJ/ 51*1%1 1U1 5491 5; $1 %((5 FLW1/ S1 68<1 5< ,1$1 */$=,(5 FLW1/ S1 6<1 63 ,ELGHP/ SS1 6<0731 64 *1 7$/$02/ /·,WDOLD GL &DYRXU/ LQ 11 9$/(5,/ FLW1/ YRO1 ,9/ S1 <;1
4587
8JR &RYD
PDQXIDWWL SURGRWWL GDOOD SL• HYROXWD LQGXVWULD DXVWULDFD651 0D OD YHUD FDXVD GHO PDQFDWR ULQQRYR GHO WUDWWDWR IXURQR O·LQGHFLVLRQH HG L FRQWUDVWL GL LQWH0 UHVVL IUD JOL 6WDWL GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH FKH/ QHL SURJHWWL GHO %UXFN/ DOORUD PLQL0 VWUR GHOOH ILQDQ]H/ DYUHEEHUR GRYXWR SDUWHFLSDUH DG XQ·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH DO0 ODUJDWD DXVWUR0LWDOLFD/ VHQ]D OD SDUWHFLSD]LRQH GHO 3LHPRQWH1 1HO 4;8: IHEEULOH IX O·DWWLYLWj GLSORPDWLFD DXVWULDFD FRQ JOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ PD L ULVXOWDWL IXURQR GHOXGHQWL661 1HOOH LQWHQ]LRQL GHO %UXFN/ LQ FXL VL PHVFRODYDQR HVSHULHQ]H GL JUDQGH XRPR G·DIIDUL +HUD VWDWR IUD L IRQGDWRUL GHO /OR\G $XVWULDFR D 7ULHVWH, FRQ GLUHWWLYH SROLWLFKH H ILQDQ]LDULH GL DOWR OLYHOOR/ JOL 6WDWL GHOO·,WDOLD FHQWUDOH JLj XQLWL IUD GL ORUR H FRQ O·$XVWULD GD DFFRUGL GL FDUDWWHUH SRVWDOH/ WHOHJUDILFR/ IHUURYLDULR H GL QDYLJD]LRQH IOXYLDOH/ DYUHEEHUR GRYXWR SDUWHFLSDUH/ XQHQGRVL DOO·$XVWULD LQ XQ XQLFR QHVVR GRJDQDOH/ DG XQ JUDQGH PHUFDWR HXURSHR/ FRP0 SUHQGHQWH SXUH OR =ROOYHUHLQ JHUPDQLFR/ LQ FXL OD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD DYUHE0 EH GRYXWR ULYHVWLUH XQD IXQ]LRQH LQGLVSHQVDELOH GL SHUQR H GL WUDPLWH1 4XH0 VWR OXQJLPLUDQWH SURJHWWR/ FKH VSRVDYD LQGLUL]]L WLSLFL GHO OLEHUDOLVPR HFR0 QRPLFR/ DYUHEEH FRPSRUWDWR/ VXO SLDQR SROLWLFR/ O·LVRODPHQWR GHOOD 3UXVVLD LQ *HUPDQLD H GHO 5HJQR GL 6DUGHJQD LQ ,WDOLD/ LQ FRUULVSRQGHQ]D DJOL LQWHUHVVL YLWDOL GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD671 9LVWD O·LQGLVSRQLELOLWj GL 3DUPD H O·LQFHUWR FRPSRUWDPHQWR GHJOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ WUDWWDWLYH IXURQR FRQGRWWH IUD LO 4;89 H LO 4;8: FRQ LO VROR GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ FKH SRUWDURQR/ LO 48 RWWREUH 4;8:/ DOOD VWLSXOD]LRQH GL XQ WUDWWDWR GL XQLRQH GRJDQDOH DXVWUR0PRGHQHVH1 'L IDWWR/ SHUz/ LO WHQRUH GL TXHVW·XOWLPR IX WDOH GD LQGXUUH D FUHGHUH FKH QRQ VL WUDWWDVVH GL XQ SXUR H VHPSOLFH ULQQR0 YR GHOO·DFFRUGR SUHFHGHQWH/ TXDQWR/ SLXWWRVWR/ GL XQ QXRYR WUDWWDWR GL FRP0 PHUFLR FRQ FDUWHOOR GD]LDULR/ VLPLOH D TXHOOR HVLVWHQWH IUD OD 0RQDUFKLD H OR =ROOYHUHLQ JHUPDQLFR681 (VVR ODVFLz XQD FHUWD DXWRQRPLD DOOD GRJDQD GL 0R0 GHQD/ SXU FRPSRUWDQGR/ SHU TXHVW·XOWLPD/ O·DGR]LRQH GHOOD WDULIID GRJDQDOH DXVWULDFD VHFRQGR OD FODVVLILFD]LRQH DXVWULDFD GHOOH PHUFL1 ,O VRVSHWWR FKH QRQ VL WUDWWDVVH GL XQ·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH LQ VHQVR VWUHWWR VX0 VFLWz OH UHD]LRQL GHOOR =ROOYHUHLQ JHUPDQLFR H GHO 5HJQR GL 6DUGHJQD/ GLHWUR DL TXDOL VWDYD SUREDELOPHQWH O·LQWHUHVVDWD DWWHQ]LRQH GHOOD 3UXVVLD1 )X GHFLVLYD LQ SURSRVLWR/ XQD OHWWHUD GHO &DYRXU GHO < GLFHPEUH 4;8; DO *RYHUQR DX0 ²²²²²²²² 65
,1$1 */$=,(5 FLW1/ S1 73> $1 %((5 FLW1/ S1 693> 81 0$5&(//, FLW1/ S1 7781 $1 %((5 FLW1/ SS1 68<06951 67 81 0$5&(//, FLW1/ SS1 779077;> 61 )85/$1, $1 :$1'586=.$ FLW1/ SS1 47604771 68 81 0$5&(//, FLW1/ S1 778> $1 %((5 FLW1/ SS1 698> 69:1 3HU LO WHVWR GHO WUDWWDWR FIU1 =ROOHLQLJXQJV0 9HUWUDJ ]ZLVFKHQ 2HVWHUUHLFK XQG 0RGHQD YRP 481 2FWREHU 4;8:/ 51*1%1 1U1 5551 66
$XVWULD H 0RGHQD= DUFKLYL/ UDSSRUWL GLQDVWLFL/ SROLWLFD FRPPHUFLDOH
4588
VWULDFR1 ,Q HVVD YHQLYD VRVWHQXWD O·LQHVLVWHQ]D JLXULGLFD GHOO·XQLRQH GRJDQDOH IUD $XVWULD H 0RGHQD H YHQLYD HVSOLFLWDPHQWH ULFKLHVWD O·HVWHQVLRQH DO 3LH0 PRQWH GHL EHQHILFL DFFRUGDWL DO GXFDWR SDGDQR/ LQ DWWXD]LRQH GHO WUDWWDWR GL FRPPHUFLR DXVWUR0SLHPRQWHVH GHO 4;84/ FKH SUHYHGHYD/ IUD OD 0RQDUFKLD DVEXUJLFD HG LO 5HJQR GL 6DUGHJQD/ OD FODXVROD GHOOD QD]LRQH SL• IDYRULWD QHL UHFLSURFL UDSSRUWL FRPPHUFLDOL691 /R VWHVVR WUDWWDPHQWR DYUHEEH SRWXWR FKLHGHUH OR =ROOYHUHLQ JHUPDQLFR1 9LVWD OD VLWXD]LRQH/ YHQQH DSSOLFDWD XQD FODXVROD VHJUHWD GHO WUDWWDWR GHO 4;8: FKH OR UHVH LQRSHUDQWH GRSR SL• GL XQ DQQR GL YLJRUH6:1 9HQQHUR FRVu D FDGH0 UH L SUHVXSSRVWL SHU LO JUDQGH SURJHWWR GHO %UXFN/ FRQGLYLVR SXUH GDO %XRO/ PLUDQWH D FRVWUXLUH XQ XQLFR JUDQGH PHUFDWR DXVWUR0JHUPDQLFR0LWDOLDQR/ LQ FXL LO SLFFROR GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD DYUHEEH GRYXWR DYHUH XQD IXQ]LRQH SURSXO0 VLYD LQL]LDOH LQ ,WDOLD1 ,O *RYHUQR DXVWULDFR QRQ VL UDVVHJQz SHUz D TXHVWD VFRQILWWD GLSORPDWLFD1 ,O %XRO VL PRVVH DQFRUD SHU LQGXUUH LO GXFD GL 0RGHQD D ULSUHQGHUH L FRQWDWWL FRQ JOL DOWUL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL H ULDOODFFLDUH OD UHWH JLj SDU]LDOPHQWH LQWHVVXWD1 0D RUPDL JOL DYYHQLPHQWL SUHFLSLWDYDQR= O·DOOHDQ]D IUDQFR0SLHPRQWHVH DFFHQWXz OD SUXGHQ]D GHOOH &RUWL H GHL *RYHUQL GHJOL 6WDWL LWDOLDQL/ FRQVFL/ DOPHQR LQ SDUWH/ GHO SHULFROR FKH LQFRPEHYD VX GL ORUR6;1 /D JXHUUD GHO 4;8< DQQXOOz WUDXPDWLFDPHQWH L SURJHWWL GL DPSLR UHVSLUR HFRQRPLFR GL FXL O·$XVWULD VL HUD IDWWD SURPRWULFH/ L TXDOL VROL DYUHEEHUR SRWXWR JDUDQWLUH/ VH DWWXDWL/ XQD SROL0 WLFD GL SUHGRPLQLR GHOOD 0RQDUFKLD D OLYHOOR QRQ VROR LWDOLDQR/ PD PLWWHOHX0 URSHR1
²²²²²²²² 69
81 0$5&(//, FLW1/ S1 785> 61 )85/$1,0$1 :$1'586=.$/ FLW1/ S1 477> $1 %((5/ FLW1/ S1
69:1 6: 6;
81 0$5&(//, LELGHP1 81 0$5&(//, FLW1/ S1 7861
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
458:
0$5,$ 3$5(17(
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
'RSR OD GHYROX]LRQH GL )HUUDUD DOOD 6DQWD 6HGH/ H FLRq GRSR LO 48<;/ L UDSSRUWL WUD OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H OR 6WDWR HVWHQVH ² JLj IUHTXHQWL DQFKH SUHFHGHQWHPHQWH/ VH QRQ DOWUR D FDXVD GL TXHOOD VRWWLOH H QRQ VHPSUH UD]LRQDOH OLQHD GL FRQILQH FKH GLYLGHYD L GXH 6WDWL SDGDQL ² GLYHQQHUR DQFRUD SL• VWUHWWL SURSULR D FDXVD GL XQ HYLGHQWH DYYLFLQDPHQWR GHOOH GXH ULVSHWLYH &RUWL1 6RQR ULVFRQWUDELOL/ LQIDWWL/ QHO FRUVR GHJOL DQQL QXPHURVL PDWULPRQL WUD (VWHQVL H )DUQHVH/ L TXDOL SURGXVVHUR SRL OHJDPL GL VDQJXH FKH DOOD ILQH ILQLURQR IRUVH FRO PLQDUH OD YLWDOLWj GHOOH GXH JUDQGL IDPLJOLH/ PD FKH IDYRULURQR FHUWR L UDSSRUWL GL EXRQ YLFLQDWR IUD GXH SRWHQ]H GL HJXDOH LPSRUWDQ]D1 'LFLDPR VXELWR FKH LO QRVWUR ODYRUR FRQVLVWHUj/ SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH/ QHO PRVWUDUH LO ULIOHVVR GHL UDSSRUWL WUD L )DUQHVH +SRL %RUERQL, GL 3DUPD H JOL (VWHQVL GL 0RGHQD QHL IRQGL GHOO·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·DQDOLVL DSSURIRQGLWD/ SHUFKp/ FRPH VL q GHWWR/ OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH q SDUWLFRODUPHQWH ULFFD1 ²²²²²²²² 4 &IU1 $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 3DUPD/ D FXUD GL 01 3$5(17(/ LQ *XLGD JHQHUDOH GHJOL $UFKLYL GL 6WDWR LWDOLDQL/ YRO1 ,,,/ 5RPD/ 8IILFLR &HQWUDOH %HQL $UFKLYLVWLFL/ 4<;9/ SS1 694076;1 91 LQ SDUWLFRODUH DOOH SS1 69:069;1
458;
0DULD 3DUHQWH
*XDUGLDPR LQWDQWR OD SROLWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH GHOOH GXH FDVDWH HG RVVHUYLDPR/ DG HVHPSLR/ OD YLFHQGD PDWULPRQLDOH GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH1 4XHVWL VSRVz GDSSULPD/ QHO 4964/ 0DULD )DUQHVH/ ILJOLD GHO 'XFD 5DQXFFLR ,1 4XDQGR 0DULD PRUu GL IHEEUH SXHUSHUDOH QHO 4979 GDQGR DOOD OXFH LO SRFR YLWDOH 7HEDOGR/ )UDQFHVFR QRQ WURYz GL PHJOLR FKH VSRVDUH OD VRUHOOD GHOOD GHIXQWD H FLRq TXHOOD 9LWWRULD )DUQHVH FKH VDUHEEH SHUz PRUWD/ DQFK·HVVD GL SDUWR/ JLXVWR O·DQQR GRSR LO PDWULPRQLR H FLRq QHO 497<1 $ SDUWH LO QRWR VWXGLR GHOOD 0D]]D 0RQWL5/ QRQ VL FRQRVFRQR ODYRUL VX TXHVWH GXH 'XFKHVVH GL FDVD )DUQHVH/ PD OD VWDPSD FHOHEUDWLYD D ORUR FRQWHPSRUDQHD FL WUDPDQGD TXDOFRVD/ FRPH OH RSHUH GL *LRYDQQL 5KR 'HOOH ORGL GL 0DULD )DUQHVH GXFKHVVD GL 0RGHQD6> RSSXUH GL 3LHWUR 9DOHVWUL/ FKH FHOHEUD *OL DPRUL RVVHTXLRVL7 FLRq XQ·RGH FRPSLODWD DSSXQWR SHU OH QR]]H GL )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH H GL 0DULD )DUQHVH1 5DQXFFLR ,, )DUQHVH/ FKH DYHYD VSRVDWR/ QHO 4993/ 0DUJKHULWD 9LRODQWH GL 6DYRLD/ H QH HUD ULPDVWR YHGRYR/ LQ VHFRQGH H WHU]H QR]]H SUHVH OH GXH ILJOLH GL )UDQFHVFR , G·(VWH= QHO 4996 ,VDEHOOD H QHO 499: 0DULD1 (QWUDPEH PRULURQR SLXWWRVWR JLRYDQL H SHU 0DULD G·(VWH/ WUD OH DOWUH FRVH/ OD VWRULRJUDILD FRQWHPSRUDQHD FHOHEUD XQ 7ULRQIR GHOO·DQLPD VRSUD LO WULRQIR GHOOD PRUWH81 4XLQGL FLz FKH UHVWD GL TXHVWD VWRULD/ ROWUH DL GRFXPHQWL G·DUFKLYLR/ VRQR DSSXQWR TXHVWL RSXVFROL H TXHVWH RSHUH FHOHEUDWLYH/ LQWHUHVVDQWLVVLPH QHOOD ORUR YHVWH WLSRJUDILFD/ DQFKH SHUFKp FL GDQQR O·LGHD GHO FDWDIDOFR H GHOOH DOWUH SRPSDH GRORULV FKH DQGDYDQR VWUDRUGLQDULDPHQWH GL PRGD QHO 6HLFHQWR H GL WXWWL JOL DSSDUDWL VFHQRJUDILFL WLSLFL GHO VHFROR1 $OFXQL DQQL SL• WDUGL XQ DOWUR 'XFD GL 0RGHQD/ H SUHFLVDPHQWH )UDQFHVFR ,,/ VSRVz LO 47 OXJOLR 49<5 XQD SULQFLSHVVD GL FDVD )DUQHVH/ H FLRq 0DUJKHULWD/ ILJOLD GHO VXQQRPLQDWR 'XFD 5DQXFFLR ,, H GL ,VDEHOOD G·(VWH H/ SHUWDQWR/ FXJLQD GL SULPR JUDGR GHO GXFD HVWHQVH1 $QFKH SHU OH QR]]H GL ,VDEHOOD VL HEEHUR LQ 3DUPD L FRQVXHWL IHVWHJJLDPHQWL H OH FRQVXHWH FHOHEUD]LRQL ULFRUGDWL LQ XQD FRUSRVD OLULFD GL ²²²²²²²² 5
1191 0$==$ 0217,/ /H GXFKHVVH GL 0RGHQD/ 5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 7HFQRJUDI/ 4<::1 *1 5+2/ 'HOOH ORGL GL 0DULD )DUQHVH GXFKHVVD GL 0RGHQD1 2UD]LRQH1 0RGHQD/ &DVVLDQL/ 49791 7 31 9$/(675,/ *OL DPRUL RVVHTXLRVL1 2GHSHU OH QR]]H GL )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH H 0DULD )DUQHVH/ +V1Q1W1,/ 49641 8 *1%1 /$1',/ 7ULRQIR GHOO·DQLPD VRSUD LO WULRQIR GHOOD PRUWH UDSSUHVHQWDWH QHOOH VROHQQL HVHTXLH FHOHEUDWH GDOOD ,OOXVWULVVLPD &RPXQLWj GL 3LDFHQ]D/ PHPRULD GHOOD 6HUHQLVVLPD 0DULD G·(VWH )DUQHVH/ GXFKHVVD GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D/ HFF1/ UHJRODWR GDO 6LJ1 &RQWH *LRDPEDWWLVWD /DQGL/ 3LDFHQ]D/ 7RPDVR =DPEHOOL/ 49;7 +FRQ XQD JUDQ WDYROD UDIILJXUDQWH LO FDWDIDOFR,1 6
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
458<
EHQ VHLFHQWR YHUVL GHO SRHWD ,JQD]LR 0DOLJLQ91 4XHVWR PDWULPRQLR/ FKH DYUHEEH SRWXWR HVVHUH XQ·XQLRQH IHOLFH/ SHUFKp JOL VSRVL PRVWUDYDQR GL DPDUVL ´SURSULR FRPH GXH LQQDPRUDWLµ/ HUD GHVWLQDWD LQYHFH D GXUDUH SRFR/ SHUFKp )UDQFHVFR ,, G·(VWH VL VSHQVH/ D VROL 67 DQQL/ LO 9 VHWWHPEUH 49<71 &RVu OD VFRQVRODWD 0DUJKHULWD IX FRVWUHWWD D WRUQDUH DOOD FRUWH GL 3DUPD/ GRYH OD VXD GLVDYYHQWXUD PDWULPRQLDOH H OD FRQVHJXHQWH GLDWULED JLXGL]LDULD FRQQHVVD DL VROLWL SUREOHPL GL GRWH/ QRQ WXUEDURQR LO FOLPD GL FRUGLDOLWj H GL DPLFL]LD YHUVR 0RGHQD1 6RQR QRWL/ LQIDWWL/ DOWUL IHVWHJJLDPHQWL DSSDUHQWHPHQWH SHQVDWL SHU RQRUDUH L VRYUDQL GL 0RGHQD/ FRPH OD UDSSUHVHQWD]LRQH GHO 5XJJLHUR/ GL WDO *LRYDQQL 7DPDJQL:/ RUJDQL]]DWD SHU IHVWHJJLDUH ´OD FRPSDUVDµ GHO 'XFD 5LQDOGR H GHOOD VXD FRQVRUWH &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD GL %UXQVZLFN/ QHO 49<</ R FRPH O·RSHUD ,O WULRQIR GHO YDORUH/ FRPSRVWD QHO 4:53/SHU IHOLFLWDUH LO SDVVDJJLR QHOOR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD GL &DUORWWD ´$JODLGH GL 9DORLVµ ² FRVu OD FKLDPD O·DXWRUH ² FKH DQGDYD VSRVD DO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 0RGHQD/ )UDQFHVFR 0DULD +IXWXUR )UDQFHVFR ,,,,/ ILJOLR GL 5LQDOGR;1 0D GL TXHVWL DYYHQLPHQWL/ FKH VRQR DEEDVWDQ]D SLDFHYROL GD LQGDJDUH/ QRQ ULPDQH TXDVL WUDFFLD QHOOD ELEOLRJUDILD SDUPHQVH RWWR0QRYHFHQWHVFD1 )D HFFH]LRQH O·XOWLPR PDWULPRQLR IUD UDPSROOL GHOOH FDVH G·(VWH H )DUQHVH/ FKH KD DWWLUDWR O·DWWHQ]LRQH GL YDUL VWRULFL SHU OH VXH FRQVHJXHQ]H/ VLD SXUH GL EUHYH GXUDWD/ H SHU LO PRPHQWR VWRULFR SDUWLFRODUH LQ FXL YHQQH D FROORFDUVL1 ,O 8 IHEEUDLR 4:5; $QWRQLR )DUQHVH/ VXFFHGXWR DO IUDWHOOR 2GRDUGR O·DQQR SUHFHGHQWH/ VSRVz (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH ILJOLD GHO GXFD 5LQDOGR1 7XWWR IDFHYD SUHVXPHUH FKH $QWRQLR/ VFDSROR TXDUDQWRWWHQQH DPDQWH GHOOD EHOOD YLWD H GHOOD EXRQD WDYROD/ DIIHWWR SHU GL SL• GD XQD SLQJXHGLQH PRVWUXRVD/ VDUHEEH VWDWR O·XOWLPR UDSSUHVHQWDQWH GHOOD FDVDWD H FKH LQ YLUW• GHO WUDWWDWR GL /RQGUD GHO 4:7; JOL VDUHEEHUR VXFFHVVL L ILJOL GL (OLVDEHWWD )DUQHVH/ UHJLQD GL 6SDJQD H GL )LOLSSR 9 GL %RUERQH1< /H QR]]H IXURQR FHOHEUDWH FRQ SRPSD JUDQGLVVLPD> O·DEDWH &DUOR ²²²²²²²² 9
0191 0$==$ 0217,/ /H GXFKHVVH FLW1/ S1 449 *1 7$0$*1,/ ,O 5XJJLHUR/ 'UDPPD PXVLFDOH IDWWR UDSSUHVHQWDUH GD 61$1 )UDQFHVFR ,/ 'XFD GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D/ HFF1 SHU IHVWHJJLDUH OD FRPSDUVD GHOOD $OWH]]D 6HHQLVVLPD 5LQDOGR , H &DUORWWD )HOLFLWD GL %UXQVZLFK/ 3DUPD/ 3D]]DQL H &HUWL/ 49<< ; ,O WULRQIR GHO YDORUH1 5LFHYLPHQWR IHVWRVR FRQFHUWDWR GDL 6LJJ1UL &RQYLWWRUL GHO 'XFDOH &ROOHJLR GH· 1RELOL GL 3DUPD/ LQ XQ WRUQHR D SLHGL PLVWR GL YDULH R]LRQL FDYDOOHUHVFKH H FRURQDWH GL XQ EDOOHWWR D FDYDOOR/ SHU O·DUULYR LQ 3DUPD GHOOD 6HUHQLVVLPD 6LJQRUD 3ULQFLSHVVD $JOHLGH GL 9RODLV/ VSRVD GHO 3ULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 0RGHQD/ 3DUPD/ 5RVDWL/ 4;53 < 11 0$)5,&,/ )DVFLQR H SRWHUH GL XQD 5HJLQD1 (OLVDEHWWD )DUQHVH VXOOD VFHQD G·(XURSD/ &DYD GHL 7LUUHQL/ $YDJOLDQR/ HG1/ 4<<< :
4593
0DULD 3DUHQWH
,QQRFHQ]R )UXJRQL/ SRHWD GL FRUWH/ OD LQRQGz GHL VXRL YHUVL43> YL IXURQR L VROLWL WRUQHL GHL FRQYLWWRUL GHO FROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL H OD FRPXQLWj GL 3DUPD QRQ SRWq VRWWUDUVL DG XQ GRQDWLYR VSRQWDQHR GL EHQ :31333 JHQRYLQH/ PHQWUH PLQLVWUL H SOHQLSRWHQ]LDUL GL ,PSHUR/ 6SDJQD H 3DSDWR ULPDVHUR LQ DWWHVD GHJOL HYHQWL FKH EHQ SUHVWR VL YHULILFDURQR VHFRQGR OH SUHYLVLRQL1 ,QIDWWL $QWRQLR )DUQHVH PRUu LO 4; JHQQDLR 4:64/ PDQFR D GLUOR/ D FDXVD G·LQGLJHVWLRQH> PD PHQWUH FL VL SUHSDUDYD DG XQ WUDSDVVR GL GLQDVWLD/ LO SUREOHPD GHOOD VXFFHVVLRQH ULPDVH LQ VRVSHVR SHU DOFXQL PHVL/ SURSULR SHUFKq LO WHVWDPHQWR GHO 'XFD ODVFLDYD HUHGH GHL VXRL VWDWL LO ©YHQWUH SUHJQDQWHª GHOOD VXD GLOHWWLVVLPD FRQVRUWH1 3XUWURSSR LO YHQWUH GL (QULFKHWWD HUD WXWW·DOWUR FKH ©SUHJQDQWHª/ PD SHU DOFXQL PHVL FL VL LOOXVH/ H IRUVH (QULFKHWWD VWHVVD SHU SULPD/ FRQIRUWDWD LQ FLz GDO SDUHUH GL FLQTXH OHYDWULFL JLXUDWH1 /D 'XFKHVVD GLYHQWz UHJJHQWH H LQ WDO YHVWH ULFHYHWWH DQFKH LO JLXUDPHQWR GL IHGHOWj GHL IHXGDWDUL H GL YDULH &RPXQLWj GHO 'XFDWR/ DG HVHPSLR GL %DUGL H GL &RPSLDQR +FRPH GLPRVWUDQR OH FDUWH G*DUFKLYLR, HG DWWHVH/ PD L PHVL SDVVDURQR VHQ]D FKH QDVFHVVH QXOOD HG LO 46 VHWWHPEUH 4:64 IX FRVWUHWWD DG DPPHWWHUH SXEEOLFDPHQWH O·LQHVLVWHQ]D GHOOD PDWHUQLWj441 ²²²²²²²² 43
&1,1 )58*21,/ 3RHVLH QHOOH QR]]H GL $QWRQLR )DUQHVH FROOD 3ULQFLSHVVD (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH1 3DUPD/ WLS1 'XFDOH/ 4:5;/ 7ƒ +FRQ ULWUDWWR,1 &1,1 )58*21,1 ,O WULRQIR GH· SXEEOLFL YRWL1 6HUHQDWD SHU OH QR]]H )DUQHVH ² '·(VWH1 3DUPD/ WLS1 'XFDOH/ 4:5;/ ;ƒ1 $1 &(67(//,/ $O JLXELOR IHVWLYR GL WXWWD ,WDOLD SHU OH QR]]H DSSODXGLWH GHOO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD '1 $QWRQLR )DUQHVH GXFD GL 3DUPD H GL (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH SULQFLSHVVD GL 0RGHQD1 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 6WDPS1 'XFDOH/ 4:5;/ 7ƒ1)HVWD LQ WHDWUR SHU OH JORULRVLVVLPH H IHOLFLVVLPH QR]]H GHOO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQD $QWRQLR , GXFD GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D HFF1 FROO·$OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD GL (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH/ IDWWD GDL 6LJQRUL &RQYLWWRUL GHO GXFDOH &ROOHJLR GHL 1RELOL1 3DUPD/ 5RVDWL/ 4:5;/ 7ƒ/ SS1 9416HJXH/ VHQ]D QXPHUD]LRQH GL SDJLQD/ LO ´QRPH/ FRJQRPH H SDWULD GHL 6LJQRUL FRQYLWWRUL FKH QHOO·DFFDGHPLFD D]LRQH KDQQR RSHUDWR/ FRQ D FLDVFXQR FLzDJLXQWR FKH LQ SDUWLFRODUH KD IDWWR 01 6&$5$%(//,1 3DULGH LQ &RORUQR1 5LPH HG D]LRQH VFHQLFD FRQ SURVD SHU OH QR]]H GHOOD SULQFLSHVVD G·(VWH FRO 'XFD $QWRQLR )DUQHVH1 0RGHQD/ 6ROLDQL/ 4:5;1&1,1 )58*21,/ 0HORGUDPPD SHU PXVLFD/ GD UDSSUHVHQWDUVL QHO QXRYR GXFDO WHDWUR GL 3DUPD OD SULPDYHUD GHOO·DQQR 4:5;1 3DUPD/ 0RQWL/ 4:5;/ 7ƒ1 &1,1 )58*21,1 /H QR]]H GL 1HWWXQR O·HTXHVWUH FRQ $QILWULWH1 O·HTXHVWUH FRQ $QILWULWH1 ,QWURGX]LRQH SHU PXVLFD DOOD GDQ]D GD UDSSUHVHQWDUVL D FDYDOOR GD VHGLFL FDYDOLHUL FRQYLWWRUL GHO GXFDO FROOHJLR GHL QRELOL QHO JUDQGH WHDWUR GL SDUPD LQ RFFDVLRQH FKH VL IHVWHJLDQR OH DQJXVWH QR]]H GHOOD $OWH]]D 6HUHQLVVLPD 'RQ $QWRQLR )DUQHVH/ GXFD GL 3DUPD HFF1 H GL (QULFKHWWD 3ULQFLSHVVD G·(VWH1 3DUPD/ 6WDPSHULD GL 61$161/ 4:5; 44 3HU TXHVWR HSLVRGLR VL ULQYLD DOO·RSHUD GL /1 9,67$5,12 *,$&2%$==,/ (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH )DUQHVH GXFKHVVD GL 3DUPD/ 0LODQR/ *DU]DQWL/ 4<741
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
4594
,O FRQWH 6WDPSD/ SOHQLSRWHQ]LDULR GHOO·,PSHUDWRUH/ VL GLFKLDUz $PPLQLVWUDWRUH JHQHUDOH GHL GXFDWL H 'RURWHD 6RILD GL 1HXEXUJ/ YHGRYD GHL GXFKL 2GRDUGR H )UDQFHVFR/ DVVXQVH OD UHJJHQ]D SHU LO QLSRWH &DUOR GL %RUERQH1 'LFHYDPR FKH TXHVWL UDSSRUWL/ IDPLOLDUL/ GLSORPDWLFL H GL FRUWH VL LQWHUUXSSHUR FRQ OD ILQH GHOOD GLQDVWLD IDUQHVLDQD/ DQFKH VH O·DPLFL]LD WUD 0RGHQD H 3DUPD FRQWLQXz1 , %RUERQH GHO VHFROR ;9,,,/ LQIDWWL/ QRQ WHQQHUR GLPRUD FRQWLQXDWLYD/ D 3DUPD/ PD SUHIHULURQR VWDELOLUYL R DJHQWL R OHJDWL/ SHU FXL QRQ SRWHURQR PHWWHUH LQ DWWR XQD YHUD H SURSULD SROLWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH QHL FRQIURQWL GHL ´YLFLQLµ (VWHQVL1 ,O VROR HSLVRGLR GL SROLWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH ERUERQLFR0HVWHQVH VHPEUD HVVHUH TXHOOR ULIHULWR GDO /LWWD45 ULJXDUGDQWH DSSXQWR LO WHQWDWLYR GHO SULQFLSH HUHGLWDULR GL 0RGHQD GL IDU VSRVDUH DO GXFD GL 3DUPD O·XQLFD HUHGH GL &DVD G·(VWH H FLRq 0DULD %HDWULFH1 (· FRPXQTXH LO FDVR GL UDPPHQWDUH FKH TXHVWR WHQWDWLYR ² VHPSUH FKH YL VLD VWDWR ² IDOOu/ SHU OD QHWWD RSSRVL]LRQH GHO GXFD UHJQDQWH/ H FLRq )UDQFHVFR ,,,/ FKH DYHYD LQWHQ]LRQH GL IDU VSRVDUH 0DULD %HDWULFH DG XQ $VEXUJR0/RUHQD1 &RVD FKH VL YHULILFz QHO 4::4 FRQ LO PDWULPRQLR WUD O·DQ]LGHWWD 3ULQFLSHVVD H O·$UFLGXFD G·$XVWULD )UDQFHVFR )HUGLQDQGR/ PDWULPRQLR FKH GLHGH RULJLQH DOOD &DVD G·$XVWULD ² G·(VWH/ GHVWLQDWD D UHJQDUH D 0RGHQD ILQR DO 4;8<1 4XHVWR/ SHU TXDQWR DWWLHQH DOOD SROLWLFD PDWULPRQLDOH GHL GXH FDVDWL ULVSHWWLYDPHQWH HVWHQVL H ERUERQLFL1 9ROHQGR SHUz HVWHQGHUH O·LQGDJLQH DL SL• JHQHUDOL UDSSRUWL WUD L GXH FDVDWL/ VL SXz IDFLOPHQWH FRQVWDWDUH FKH/ QRQRVWDQWH O·DEERQGDQWH GRFXPHQWD]LRQH DUFKLYLVWLFD +FKH FRPSURYD O·LQWHQVLWj GHL UDSSRUWL,/ OD SXEEOLFLVWLFD FRQWHPSRUDQHD SDUPHQVH VHPEUD TXDVL GHO WXWWR DVVHQWH LQ SURSRVLWR1 %LVRJQHUj DWWHQGHUH OD VWRULRJUDILD GL ILQH 2WWRFHQWR/ SHU YHGHUH ULDFFHQGHUVL O·LQWHUHVVH SDUPHQVH YHUVR HSLVRGL EHQ SUHFLVL GL TXHL UDSSRUWL1 ,O SULPR HSLVRGLR IX TXHOOR FKH YLGH &DUOR GL %RUERQH +LO IXWXUR GXFD GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D &DUOR ,,,/ DGGLYHQLUH DO EHQ QRWR WUDWWDWR GL )LUHQ]H GHO 5; QRYHPEUH 4;77/ LQ EDVH DO TXDOH ² PHQWUH HUD DQFRUD YLYHQWH H IHOLFHPHQWH UHJQDQWH 0DULD /XLJLD ² VL VWDELOLURQR JOL DJJLXVWDPHQWL GL FRQILQH WUD *UDQGXFDWR GL 7RVFDQD/ 'XFDWR GL 0RGHQD H 'XFDWR GL ²²²²²²²² 45
7DYROD LQ 31 /,77$/ )DPLJOLH FHOHEUL LWDOLDQH/ '·(VWH/ 0LODQR/ )HUUDULR/ 4;65/ ;9,, HG XOWLPR1
4595
0DULD 3DUHQWH
3DUPD46. ,Q SDUWLFRODUH/ SHU TXDQWR VL ULIHULYD DL UDSSRUWL WUD 0RGHQD H 3DUPD/ TXHVW·XOWLPD FHGHYD DO GXFD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH LO ULFFR 'XFDWR GL *XDVWDOOD LQ FDPELR GL SRYHUH WHUUH VXOO·$SSHQQLQR/ SHU FXL VL GLVVH DOORUD FKH &DUOR DYHYD FHGXWR ©JUDQDLR H FDQWLQDª SHU OD ©OHJQDLDª H VL GLVVH DQFKH FKH JOL 6WDWL GL ©3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D H 6WDWL DQQHVVLª HUDQR GLYHQWDWL JOL VWDWL GL ©3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D H VDVVL DQQHVVLª1 6X TXHVWR HSLVRGLR OD VWRULRJUDILD SDUPHQVH VL q VRIIHUPDWD DOTXDQWR/ DQFKH SHUFKp q XQD VWRULRJUDILD GL WLSR RWWRFHQWHVFR/ FRPH TXHOOD GL (PLOLR &DVD47/ SHU HVHPSLR/ FKH QDUUD OD ILQH GHL GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D1 (UD XQD VWRULRJUDILD GL VWDPSR OLEHUDOH HG DYHYD TXLQGL XQD YLVLRQH PROWR FULWLFD QHL ULJXDUGL GHL FRVLGGHWWL ©VHFRQGL %RUERQHª/ FLRq GHOOD GLQDVWLD ERUERQLFD FKH ² GRSR DYHU DYXWR /XFFD ² WRUQDYD VXO WURQR GL 3DUPD DOOD OD PRUWH GL 0DULD /XLJLD1 4XHVWD VWRULRJUDILD IX DEEDVWDQ]D FULWLFD DQFKH FRQ OD YHGRYD GHO VRYUDQR &DUOR ,,, GL %RUERQH/ FRQ FXL FL VL DYYLD DOOD ILQH GHOOR 6WDWR GHL GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D SHU LO FRPSLHUVL GHOO·XQLWj G·,WDOLD1 7UD L YDUL WUDWWDWL FKH IXURQR VWLSXODWL LQ TXHVWR SHULRGR/ XQR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH LQWHUHVVDQWH ² PD QLHQWH DIIDWWR IDYRUHYROH DL GXFDWL ² IX OD OHJD GRJDQDOH FKH VWULQVH DVVLHPH O·,PSHUR $XVWURXQJDULFR/ 3DUPD H 0RGHQD481 4XHVWD =ROOYHUHLQ SRUWDYD GHL YDQWDJJL DOO·$XVWULD/ PD FHUWR QRQ QH SRUWDYD Qp D 3DUPD Qp D 0RGHQD/ SHU TXDQWR ULJXDUGD LO FRPPHUFLR GHL JUDQL H OD OLEHUD QDYLJD]LRQH1 ,QIDWWL /XLVD 0DULD GL %HUU\/ FKH JRYHUQz OR VWDWR GL 3DUPD H OR SHUVH SRL QHO 4;8< PDOJUDGR OD VXD QHXWUDOLWj/ DG XQ FHUWR SXQWR GLVGLVVH TXHVWD OHJD/ SURSULR SHUFKp VL HUD UHVD FRQWR FKH QRQ HUD SHU QXOOD IDYRUHYROH SHU OH ILQDQ]H H SHU O·HFRQRPLD GHO 'XFDWR1 0D VH VL VFRUURQR JOL DUFKLYL IDUQHVLDQR H ERUERQLFR/ SHU YHGHUH DSSXQWR OD TXDQWLWj GL GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GD HVSORUDUH RQGH ULGHILQLUH TXHOOL FKH SRVVRQR HVVHUH VWDWL L UDSSRUWL WUD 3DUPD H 0RGHQD/ VL YHGH FRPH HIIHWWLYDPHQWH YL VLDQR PROWLVVLPL IRQGL GD HVSORUDUH/ VRSUDWWXWWR SHU TXHOOD FKH QRL RJJL SRWUHPPR FKLDPDUH OD ©JHVWLRQH GHO WHUULWRULRª1 6H SHU HVHPSLR SUHQGLDPR LQ FRQVLGHUD]LRQH LO IRQGR &RQILQL/ JLj ²²²²²²²² 46
3HU LO WUDWWDWR GL )LUHQ]H/ VL YHGD ROWUH DOOD ELEOLRJUDILD SDUPHQVH/ *1 %(578==,/ ,O WUDWWDWR GL )LUHQ]H GHO 5; QRYHPEUH 4;77/ LQ $0'6300RGHQD/ V1 ;/ ,,, +4<9;,/ SS1 4;604<<1 47 (1 &$6$/ 3DUPD/ GD 0DULD /XLJLD LPSHULDOH D 9LWWRULR (PDQXHOH ,,/ 4;7:04;93/ 3DUPD/ 5RVVL =HEDOGL/ 4<341 48 3HU OD /HJD GRJDQDOH GDO SXQWR GL YLVWD PRGHQHVH/ VL YHGD 21 520%$/',/ /D /HJD DXVWUR0HVWHQVH0SDUPLJLDQD/ LQ $VSHWWL H SUREOHPL GHO 5LVRUJLPHQWR D 0RGHQD/ 0RGHQD/ 0XFFKL/ 4<96/ SS1 6340668
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
4596
VROWDQWR DG XQ SULPR HVDPH DQFKH DEEDVWDQ]D VXSHUILFLDOH/ GL TXHOOL FKH HUDQR L UDSSRUWL WUD OR VWDWR GL 3DUPD H TXHOOR GL 0RGHQD UHODWLYDPHQWH DL FRQILQL GHOO·(Q]D/ FL UHQGLDPR FRQWR FKH YL q WXWWD XQD VHULH GL DUJRPHQWL GD VWXGLDUH/ FRPH OD UHJLPHQWD]LRQH GHOOH DFTXH/ OD WHQXWD GHL FDQDOL GL VFROR/ OD YLDELOLWj/ L SDVVDJJL/ OH GRJDQH1 $ TXHVWR SURSRVLWR VHPEUDQR HVVHUH LQ JUDGR GL ULDVVXPHUH YLFHQGH VHFRODUL GL JHVWLRQH GHO WHUULWRULR L &DSLWROL H GLFKLDUD]LRQL IDWWH GDO VLJQRU 2WWDYLR =REROL/ GHOHJDWR GDO 6HUHQLVVLPR GL 3DUPD SHU XQD SDUWH/ H GDO VLJQRU /XGRYLFR $OORWWL GHOHJDWR GDO 6HUHQLVVLPR GL 0RGHQD SHU O·DOWUD/ GD FRQIHUPDUVL GDL ORUR ULVSHWWLYL 3DGURQL/ UHODWLYDPHQWH DOO·HOH]LRQH GHJOL DUELWUL SHU OD YLVLWD GHL FRQILQL GHL GXH 6WDWL SHU OH ERQLILFD]LRQL GHOOH DFTXH GHO ILXPH (Q]D WUD 3RYLJOLR HG DOWUH YLOOH GHO 3DUPLJLDQR> RSSXUH OD 5HOD]LRQH GHOO·LQJHJQHU 6PHUDOGR 6PHUDOGL FRQFHUQHQWH OL FDYL IDWWL GDOOL VXGGLWL GL 3DUPD H GL 0RGHQD HG DOWUH RSHUD]LRQL FRQFHUWDWH GD XQD SDUWH H GDOO·DOWUD1 4XHVWD UHOD]LRQH GHOOR 6PHUDOGL/ GHO 4936/ q XQD GHOOH WDQWH SUHVHQWL LQ DUFKLYLR GL TXHVWR LQJHJQHUH SDUPLJLDQR/ FKH q XQD SHUVRQDOLWj LQWHUHVVDQWLVVLPD DWWLYD WUD OD ILQH GHO &LQTXHFHQWR H O·LQL]LR GHO 6HLFHQWR1 ,QJHJQHUH DO VHJXLWR GL 5DQXFFLR , )DUQHVH/ FL KD ODVFLDWR VHL YROXPL PDQRVFULWWL LQ FXL GHVFULYH WXWWH OH YLVLWH WHFQLFKH GD OXL IDWWH SHU FRQWR GHO GXFD D WXWWL L OXRJKL GHO GXFDWR1 &RQ TXHVWH UHOD]LRQL LQ JUDQ SDUWH LQHGLWH H FRQ WXWWH OH GHFLVLRQL H JOL DOWUL DWWL FKH WURYLDPR QHOO·8IILFLR GHL &RQILQL H DQFKH QHOOD &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHL &DYDPHQWL/ SRVVLDPR ULFRVWUXLUH O·DVVHWWR GHO WHUULWRULR WUD 3DUPD H 0RGHQD/ H YHGHUH TXHOOD FKH HUD XQD SROLWLFD/ WXWWR VRPPDWR/ FRPXQH/ SHU OH ERQLILFD]LRQL/ SHU OH DUJLQDWXUH/ SHU L SRQWL H SHU LO PDQWHQLPHQWR GHOOH VWUDGH1 ,QROWUH OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH GHOO·8IILFLR GHL &RQILQL q DFFRPSDJQDWD GD XQD VHULH GL VWDPSH H GL PDSSH FKH VRQR LQWHUHVVDQWLVVLPH SURSULR SHUFKp GLPRVWUDQR TXDOH HUD O·DVVHWWR GHO WHUULWRULR WUD &LQTXHFHQWR H 6HLFHQWR/ FLRq QHO SHULRGR LQ FXL PDJJLRUPHQWH VL DVVHVWDYDQR TXHVWL UDSSRUWL WUD 0RGHQD H 3DUPD/ H LQWHUHVVDQWLVVLPH VRQR VRSUDWWXWWR OH PDSSH GHOOR 6PHUDOGL1 /H TXHVWLRQL GL FRQILQL FRQWLQXDURQR DQFKH QHO 6HWWHFHQWR H QHOO·2WWRFHQWR/ HG/ RYYLDPHQWH/ DOWUL GRFXPHQWL GHO FLWDWR IRQGR/ PHJOLR LQGLFDWL LQ ´DSSHQGLFHµ/ FL DLXWHUDQQR QHOOR VWXGLR GL GHWWL SUREOHPL1 4XHVWR q XQR GHL WDQWL HVHPSL FKH SRVVLDPR IDUH LQ PHULWR DOO·XWLOL]]R GL TXHVWR PDWHULDOH/ TXDVL FRPSOHWDPHQWH LQHGLWR/ FKH SXz HVVHUH G·DLXWR DL ULFHUFDWRUL SHU LPSRVWDUH XQD QXRYD VWRULRJUDILD VXL UDSSRUWL WUD TXHVWL GXH VWDWL1 3ULPD GL FKLXGHUH QRQ SRVVLDPR GLPHQWLFDUH LO ODYRUR GHOOD GLSORPD]LD ULIOHVVR QHL GRFXPHQWL GHO &DUWHJJLR )DUQHVLDQR +HVWHUR,1
4597
0DULD 3DUHQWH
4XL EHQ YHQWLWUq EXVWH GL GRFXPHQWL ULVXOWDQR GHGLFDWH DOOR 6WDWR HVWHQVH HG RIIURQR XQ·LQWHUSUHWD]LRQH/ LQ JUDQ SDUWH LQHGLWD GHOOH ´FRVH GL 0RGHQDµ SHU LO SHULRGR FKH YD GDO 48<; DO 4:<9491
$SSHQGLFH 6L Gj GL VHJXLWR XQ HOHQFR GL IRQGL H VHULH FRQVHUYDWL QHOO·$UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 3DUPD/ FKH VRQR SDUWLFRODUPHQWH ULFFKL GL GRFXPHQWD]LRQH ULJXDUGDQWH L UDSSRUWL IUD L GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 0RGHQD FRQ LQGLFD]LRQH GHL GRFXPHQWL UHODWLYL/ VHQ]D OD SUHWHVD GL HVVHUH HVDXVWLYL PD QHOOD FRQYLQ]LRQH FKH SRVVDQR FRVWLWXLUH XQD WUDFFLD EDVWHYROH SHU O·LPSLDQWR GL ULFHUFKH PLUDWH1 &DVD H &RUWH )DUQHVLDQH +473: ² 4:65, EE1 :4 4XHVWR IRQGR q IRUPDWR SUHYDOHQWHPHQWH GDJOL DWWL SHUWLQHQWL DOOD SHUVRQD GHO GXFD H GHL VXRL IDPLOLDUL HG DL VXRL SRWHUL VXSUHPL1 6HULH , 0 ,QYHVWLWXUH H JLXUDPHQWL GL IHGHOWj E1 5
IDVF1 := JLXUDPHQWR GL IHGHOWj GHOOD FRPXQLWj GL %DUGL HG (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH1 )DUQHVH +4:63/ IHEEU1 4, IDVF1 < LGHP F1V1 GHOOD FRPXQLWj GL %RUJRWDUR +4:63/ JHQQ1 5<, IDVF1 44 LGHP F1V1 GHOOD FRPXQLWj GL &RPSLDQR +4:63/ JHQQ1 5<,1
6HULH ,, ² 'RFXPHQWL H FDUWHJJL GL SHUVRQH GHOOD IDPLJOLD )DUQHVH E1 63 IDVF1 7= 5DQXFFLR ,, )DUQHVH= FDUWHJJLR H VFULWWXUH GLYHUVH UHODWLYH DO VXR VHFRQGR PDWULPRQLR FRQ ,VDEHOOD G·(VWH +4996, IDVF1 8= LGHP F1V1 +4997, IDVF1 9= LGHP F1V1 UHODWLYDPHQWH DO VXR WHU]R PDWULPRQLR FRQ 0DULD G·(VWH +499:0499;,1 ²²²²²²²² 49
&IU1 $UFKLYLR GL 6WDWR GL 3DUPD/ D FXUD GL 01 3$5(17(/ FLW1/ DOOH VLQJROH YRFL1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
4598
E1 64 IDVF1 5= ,VDEHOOD G·(VWH/ VHFRQGD PRJOLH GHO GXFD 5DQXFFLR ,,1 6FULWWXUH UHODWLYH DOOD VXD PRUWH +49990499:, IDVF1 6= 0DULD G·(VWH/ WHU]D PRJOLH GHO GXFD 5DQXFFLR ,,1 6FULWWXUH UHODWLYH DOOD VXD PRUWH +49;5049;7,1 E1 66 IDVF1 5= 0DUJKHULWD )DUQHVH/ ILJOLD GHO GXFD 5DQXFFLR ,, H PRJOLH GL )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH1 6FULWWXUH GLYHUVH +499704:55,1 E1 73 IDVF1 5= $QWRQLR )DUQHVH= DWWL UHODWLYL DO VXR PDWULPRQLR FRQ (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH H VFULWWXUH GLYHUVH +4:5:04:64, IDVF1 6= LGHP F1V1 +V1G1, IDVF1 9= (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH/ PRJOLH GHO GXFD $QWRQLR1 &DUWHJJL H VFULWWXUH GLYHUVH +4:5;04:64,1 6HULH 9 ² 7UDWWDWL H FRQYHQ]LRQL +473: ² ;9,,, H ;, E1 7< IDVF1 4= 7UDWWDWL H FRQYHQ]LRQL WUD OH FRPXQLWj GL 3DUPD H 5HJJLR (PLOLD H WUD L GXFDWL IDUQHVLDQR HG HVWHQVH +473:04:47,1 6HULH 9, ² ,QYLDWL GHL GXFKL GL 3DUPD SUHVVR FRUWL H 6WDWL HVWHUL +4938 ² 49;3, E1 84 IDVF1 43= 2WWDYLR /LQDWL/ LQYLDWR D 0RGHQD SHU LQYLWDUH D 3DUPD $OPHULFR G·(VWH +498:/ PDJJLR 4<, IDVF1 47= &RQWH $OHVVDQGUR 0DUD]]DQL/ LQYLDWR D 0RGHQD +498;/ IHEEU1 8,1
6HULH ,; ² &HULPRQLDOL +483: ² 4:5:, E1 88 IDVF1 ;= (VHPSL GL FHULPRQLDOH1 0RGHQD +499<049<4,1 6HULH ; ² /XWWL GL &RUWH +4945 0 4:55,
4599
0DULD 3DUHQWH
E1 88 IDVF1 54= 3DUWHFLSD]LRQL H FRQGRJOLDQ]H SHU PRUWL GL SULQFLSL GL 7RVFDQD/ ,QJKLOWHUUD/ 0RGHQD/ 3RORQLD/ 6SDJQD +4:44 ² 4:55,1 6HULH ;, ² 5LFHYLPHQWL H WUDQVLWL GL 6RYUDQL/ 3ULQFLSL/ 'LJQLWDUL HWF1 +48<8 ² 4:58, E1 89 IDVF1 45= %ODVFR G·$UDJRQD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH VSDJQROR D 0DQWRYD H 0RGHQD +493;/ GLF1 5:,1 E1 8: IDVF1 4= 3ULQFLSL GHOOD IDPLJOLD G·(VWH +493;,> IDVF1 5= LGHP F1V1 +4947/ DJR 8,> IDVF1 6/ 7 H 8= LGHP F1V1 +4953,> IDVF1 9= 0DULD %HDWULFH G·(VWH/ GL $OIRQVR ,9/ PRJOLH GL *LDFRPR 6WXDUW +49:6049:7,1 E1 8; IDVF1 4;= &RQWH )UDQFHVFR 0R]]D/ LQYLDWR GHO FDUG1 G·(VWH +4955/ JLX1 59,> IDVF1 64= /RUHQ]R GHOOD 3RUWD/ LQYLDWR GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD +4953/ PDU]R,> IDVF1 74= 6DJUDWL/ VHJUHWDULR GL JLXVWL]LD H LQYLDWR GHO GXFD GL 0RGHQD +4957/ PDU]R 9,> IDVF1 ;9= )UDQFHVFR =DSDWD/ DPEDVFLDWRUH GHOO·LQIDQWD GL )LDQGUD D 0DQWRYD H 0RGHQD +495:/ JHQQ1 4;,1 'D]L H FDULFKL SXEEOLFL +4778 ² 4:6<, EE1 471 4XHVWR IRQGR UDFFRJOLH OH FDUWH VXSHUVWLWL GL TXHVWD SDUWLFRODUH DWWLYLWj GHOOD GXFDO FDPHUD IDUQHVLDQD> VL YHGD LQ SDUWLFRODUH OD EXVWD Q1 4= UHJRODPHQWL LQ PDWHULD GD]LDULD GL 6WDWL HVWHUL +4778 ² 4937,1
8IILFLR GHL &RQILQL +VHFF1 ;9, ² 4;35 FRQ GRFF1 LQ FRSLD GDO VHF1 ;, E1 6;: 8QD LPSRUWDQWH IXQ]LRQH VYROWD GDOOD &DPHUD GXFDOH HUD TXHOOD GL YLJLODUH VXL FRQILQL GHOOR 6WDWR1 9L SURYYHGHYD D PH]]R GL XQ FRPPLVVDULR JHQHUDOH/ FKH GRYHYD WXWHODUH OH UDJLRQL GHOOR 6WDWR LQ PDWHULD GL FRQILQL1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
459:
'DWD OD GHOLFDWD PDWHULD H OH IUHTXHQWL FRQWURYHUVLH FKH VRUJHYDQR FRQ JOL 6WDWL FRQILQDQWL/ O·DUFKLYLR GL TXHVWD PDJLVWUDWXUD FRQVHUYD FDUWH GL QRWHYROH LPSRUWDQ]D> PROWH GL TXHVWH ULWRUQDWH GD 1DSROL GRYH HUDQR VWDWH WUDVSRUWDWH/ IXURQR ULRUGLQDWH/ SHU FRQWR GHO JRYHUQR ERUERQLFR/ WUD LO 4:95 H LO 4:97 H GRWDWH GL XQ UHSHUWRULR FKH VHUYH DQFRU RJJL1 /·XIILFLR FRQWLQXz D IXQ]LRQDUH DQFKH LQ SHULRGR ERUERQLFR1 3DUWLFRODUPHQWH LQWHUHVVDQWH SHU L UDSSRUWL IUD 0RGHQD H 3DUPD OH FRQVXOWD]LRQL GHOO·,QGLFH JHQHUDOH GHOOH VFULWWXUH GHOO·RIIL]LR GHL FRQILQL ULVJXDUGDQWL OR 6WDWR 3DUPLJLDQR FRPLQFLDQGR GDOOD ERFFD GHOO·(Q]D H SURVHJXHQGR DOO·LQV• D WUDWWR SHU WUDWWR ILQR DOOD FRQWHUPLQD]LRQH GL %HUFHWR FRQ %RUJRWDUR/ RUGLQDWH H GLVSRVWH QHOO·DQQR 4:961 &RQ XQ ´HVHPSODUH GHOO·RUGLQH H PHWRGR FRQ FXL VRQR GLVSRVWH H UHJRODWH OH VHQWHQ]H GHOO·XIIL]LR GHL FRQILQL ULVJXDUGDQWL OR 6WDWR 3DUPLJLDQR/ FRPLQFLDQGR GDOOD ERFFD GHOO·(Q]D H SURVHJXHQGR DOO·LQV• VLQR DOOD FRQWHUPLQD]LRQH GL %HUFHWR FRQ %RUJRWDUR +4:96,µ1 6L YHGDQR DOFXQL HVHPSL= $$ ² 9RO1 ,/ ILO]D 9= &RQILQL GHO 3DUPLJLDQR FKH FRPLQFLDQR GD %HQVR H SURVHJXRQR ILQR DOOD VWUDGD &ODXGLD1 11 9= 4935/ GLFHPEUH 5 ² ILQR DOOL 48 JHQQDLR 4936= &DSLWROL H GLFKLDUD]LRQL IDWWH GDO 6LJ1 2WWDYLR =REROL GHOHJDWR GDO 6HU1PR GL 3DUPD SHU XQD SDUWH H GDO 6LJ1 /XGRYLFR $UORWWL GHOHJDWR GHO 6HU1PR GL 0RGHQD SHU O·DOWUD/ GD FRQIHUPDUVL GDL ORUR ULVSHWWLYL SDGURQL/ UHODWLYDPHQWH DOO·HOH]LRQH GHJOL DUELWUL SHU OD YLVLWD GHL FRQILQL GHL GXH 6WDWL H SHU OH ERQLILFD]LRQL GHOOH DFTXH GHO ILXPH (Q]D WUD 3RYLJOLR H DOWUH YLOOH GHO 3DUPLJLDQR/ FRQ *XDOWLHUL1 11 : ² 4936/ 57 IHEEUDLR ILQR DOOL JLXJQR1 9LVLWD/ FDSLWROD]LRQL/ DWWL/ YRWL/ ODXGL H VLPLOL/ IDWWL GDO FRQWH $OIRQVR 6DVVR SHU SDUWH GHO 6HU1PR GL 0RGHQD H GHO 'U1 2WWDYLR =REROL SHU SDUWH GHO 6HU1PR GL 3DUPD/ DUELWUL HOHWWL SHU DFFRPRGDUH OD GLIIHUHQ]D GHL FRQILQL H SHU OD ERQLILFD]LRQH H FDYL GD IDUVL GHOOH DFTXH WUD 3RYLJOLR HG DOWUH YLOOH GHO 3DUPLJLDQR H *XDOWLHUL1 3HU URJLWR GL *LXOLR *KLQDUGX]]L QRWDLR SDUPLJLDQR1 11 < ² 4936/ 9 QRYHPEUH= 5HOD]LRQH GHOO·LQJHJQHUH 6PHUDOGR 6PHUDOGL FRQFHUQHQWH OL FDYL IDWWL GDOOL VXGGLWL GL 3DUPD H GL 0RGHQD HG DOWUH RSHUD]LRQL FRQFHUWDWH GD XQD SDUWH H O·DOWUD1 11 44 ² 4937/ 57 RWWREUH= 5HOD]LRQH GHOOR VWHVVR LQJHJQHUH SHU OH YLVLWH GHOOH ERQLILFD]LRQL IDWWH DOO·(Q]D/ D 3RYLJOLR/ *XDOWLHUL HG LQ DOWUL OXRJKL GL FRQILQH1
459;
0DULD 3DUHQWH
11 49 ² 4957/ 63 DJRVWR1 &DSLWXOD LQLWD LQWHU FRQVLOLDULRV %XOJDUHOOXP GHSXWDWXP 6HU1PL GXFLV 3DUPDH H[ XQD HW %HOPHVVHULXP GHSXWDWXP 6HU1PL GXFLV 0XWLQDH H[ DOWHUD/ VXSHU GLYLVLRQHP DTXDUXP 3RQWLV $OWL/ HDUQLPTXH GHFXUVXP LQWHU 3DUPHQVHV GH 3XSLOLR HW 5HJLHQVHV GH %UL[LOOR1
9RO1 ,/ ILO]D 9,,,/ OHWWHUD $$1 11 47 ² 49::/ 4< OXJOLR= &DUWHJJLR GHO 6HU1PR 6LJ1 3ULQFLSH GL 0RGHQD 5LQDOGR G·(VWH FROOH 6HU1PD GXFKHVVD GL 3DUPD 0DULD G·(VWH/ SHU O·DPLFKHYROH FRPSRQLPHQWR GHOOH GLIIHUHQ]H GL FRQILQL WUD OH JLXULVGL]LRQL SDUPLJLDQD H PRGHQHVH1 11 55 ² 49;9/ 49 OXJOLR= 5LVSRVWD DOOH GRJOLDQ]H GHO 6HU1PR GL 0RGHQD FRQWUR OL VXGGLWL GHO 6HU1PR GL 3DUPD SHU LQQRYD]LRQL SUHWHVH IDWWH GD TXHVWL LQ PDWHULD G·DFTXH WUD LO 3DUPLJLDQR H LO %UHVFHOOHVH LQ SUHJLXGL]LR GHL VXGGLWL GL 0RGHQD1 11 57 ² 49<3/ < QRYHPEUH1 /HWWHUD GHO 6HU1PR 6LJ1 GXFD )UDQFHVFR G·(VWH DO 6HU1PR GL 3DUPD/ ULVJXDUGDQWH OD UHJLRQH GHOO·DFTXH GHO FDQDOH QRPDWR GL 61 ,ODULR1 1HOOD UDFFROWD GHOOH PDSSH H GLVHJQL DOFXQL YROXPL VL ULIHULVFRQR DL FRQILQL GHO GXFDWR +YROO1 64/ 7707:, PHQWUH PROWH DOWUH PDSSH VRQR DQFRUD DOOHJDWH DOOD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH /HWWHUD &&1 9RO1 ,/ ILO]D 9,= &RQILQL GHO 3DUPHQVH QHOOH 9DOOL GHL &DYDOLHUL1 11 45 ² 494:/ 6 PDU]R1 /HWWHUD GHO 6HU1PR GL 0RGHQD/ LQ FXL ULFKLHGH DO 6HU1PR GL 3DUPD FKH VLDQR IHUPDWL GXH DVVDVVLQL GHO OXRJR GL &HUHWR/ EDQGLWL FDSLWDOPHQWH GDJOL 6WDWL GL 0RGHQD H FKH SUDWLFDQR IUHTXHQWHPHQWH D 1LYLDQR VWDWR GL 3DUPD +H DOWUH OHWWHUH UHODWLYH,1 &RQJUHJD]LRQH GHL &DYDPHQWL1 +47:5 ² 4;93 FRQ GRFXPHQWL LQ FRSLD GDO 44;6 ² EE1 9:8 H SDFFKL 6:;,1 0DJLVWUDWXUD FKH DVVRPPDYD SRWHUL OHJLVODWLYL/ DPPLQLVWUDWLYL H JLXGL]LDUL/ FRVWLWXLWD QHO 488< GDO GXFD 2WWDYLR )DUQHVH SHU OD UHJRODPHQWD]LRQH GHO
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
459<
UHJLPH GHOOH DFTXH/ ILQR D TXHO PRPHQWR EDVDWD VXO ,9 OLEUR GHJOL 6WDWXWL FRPXQDOL1 ,O GXFD 5DQXFFLR ,/ QHO 48<:/ QH ILVVz GHILQLWLYDPHQWH OD FRVWLWX]LRQH H OD FRQIHUPz FRPH WULEXQDOH VXSUHPR LQ PDWHULD GL ILXPL/ FDQDOL/ DUJLQL/ FDYL/ SRUWL H VWUDGH1 4XHVWD PDJLVWUDWXUD HEEH YLWD OXQJKLVVLPD/ FRQWLQXDQGR D IXQ]LRQDUH ILQR DO 4;3</ TXDQGR IX VRSSUHVVD LQ SLHQR JRYHUQR QDSROHRQLFR1 ,O VXR DUFKLYLR FRVWLWXLVFH XQ FRUSR XQLFR HG RPRJHQHR GDO TXDOH/ QHO FRUVR GHO VHFROR ;;/ IX VWUDOFLDWD OD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH LFRQRJUDILFD SHU IRUPDUH OH UDFFROWH GHOOH 0DSSH H GLVHJQL H 0DSSH GL ILXPL H VWUDGH1 0ROWD GRFXPHQWD]LRQH/ FRPH VL SXz EHQ FRPSUHQGHUH/ ULJXDUGD DQFKH SDUWH GHO WHUULWRULR GHOOR VWDWR HVWHQVH> QHOOD VHULH &DQDOL H WRUUHQWL +44;6 LQ FRSLD GHO VHF1 ;9, ² 4[6<, ULFFD GL EHQ 6;8 EXVWH/ ULSDUWLWH LQ VH]LRQL H VXGGLYLVH LQ RUGLQH DOIDEHWLFR/ FLWLDPR/ D WLWROR HVHPSOLILFDWLYR= &HOOD1 &DQDOH GHULYDQWH +VH]1 ;9,> &LDQR +FDQDOH GL, +VH]1 ;,;,> (Q]D H FRUVR GHO WRUUHQWHµ+VH]1 ;9,0 ;9,,,> 2OWU·(Q]D +VH]1 ;9,,, ² ;,;,> *DPEDORQH PRUWR +VH]1 ;9,,,> *DPEDORQH YLYR +VH]1 ;9,,,,> /X]]DUD= ODYRUL D GLIHVD GHJOL 6WDWL GL 3DUPD/ 0RGHQD H 0DQWRYD FRO FRQFRUVR GHOOD VRFLHWj SHU OH GXJDJQH GL 0DQWRYD H *XDVWDOOD +VH]1 ;,;,> /X]]DUD/ ULSDUL FRQWUR LO 3R +VH]1 ;,;,> 5DVHWR GL 0RQWHFFKLR0&DQDOH +VH]1 ;,;,> 5HJJLROR +VH]1 ;,;,1
0LOL]LH +4886 ² 4:<5, EE1 751 E1 43
3DVVDJJL H VWD]LRQL GL WUXSSH VWUDQLHUH SHU 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D +49;; ² 49<4,
EE1 44065
3DVVDJJL H DOORJJL GL WUXSSH +49<4 ² 4:76,
*ULGDULR +44<4 ² LQ FRSLD GHO VHF1 ;9, ² 4:76, YROO1 :31 *OL DUFKLYLVWL GHO VHF1 ;,; UDFFROVHUR WXWWH OH JULGD HPDQDWH QHO WHUULWRULR GHL GXFDWL1 , SULPL 96 YROXPL VRQR FRUUHGDWL GD LQGLFL SHU PDWHULD1 6RWWR OD YRFH ´&RQILQLµ VL LGHQWLILFD= 49:9/ 4< DJRVWR= 5HFRJQL]LRQH GHL FRQILQL GL 3DUPD H 5HJJLR YHUVR 3RYLJOLR H &DVWHOQRYR GL 6HWWR/ ILO1 751 $O 4:76/ < IHEEUDLR 3DUPD SHU OD FRQVHUYD]LRQH GHL FRQILQL1
45:3
0DULD 3DUHQWH
&DVD H &RUWH ERUERQLFKH +4974 ² 4;68, ,O IRQGR q FRVWLWXLWR GDOOH FDUWH VXSHUVWLWL UHODWLYH DOOD FDVD H DOOR 6WDWR GHO , JRYHUQR ERUERQLFR +4:7< ² 4;35, EE1 84 6HULH , ² 7LWRODUL/ IRUPXODUL/ FHULPRQLDOL H OXWWL GL FRUWH1 E1 5
IDVF1 := &HULPRQLDOH SHU L IXQHUDOL GL &DUORWWD ILJOLD GL )LOLSSR G·2UOpDQV/ GXFKHVVD GL 0RGHQD +4:94/ JHQQ1,1 IDVF1 <= &HULPRQLDOH SHU O·DQQLYHUVDULR GHOOD PRUWH GL )UDQFHVFR ,,, G·(VWH GXFD GL 0RGHQD +4:;3/ IHEE1 59,1
E1 6
IDVF1 5= ,GHP F1V1 SHU 0DULD 7HUHVD &\ER GXFKHVVD GL 0RGHQD +4:<3/ GLF1 63,1
6HULH 9, ² 3HUVRQDJJL GHOOD IDPLJOLD %RUERQH H ORUR SDUHQWL1 E1 4< IDVF1441 &DUWHJJL GL 'RURWHD 6RILD GL 1HQEXUJ FRQ )UDQFHVFR ,,, G·(VWH GXFD GL 0RGHQD +4:74,1 6HULH 9,, ² 3HUVRQDJJL GHOOH IDPLJOLH (VWH H $VVLD0'DUPVWDGW +49<3 ² 4:;7, EE1 GDOOD Q1 68 DOOD Q1 6< E1 6< (QULFKHWWD G·(VWH/ PRJOLH LQ SULPH QR]]H GL $QWRQLR )DUQHVH GXFD GL 3DUPD/ LQ VHFRQGH GL /HRSROGR G·$VVLD0'DUPVWDGW/ IDVF1 8045/ FDUWHJJL +4:66 ² 4:::,1 6HULH 9,,, ² &RUWL H 6WDWL HVWHUL E1 77 IDVF1= 44 0RGHQD/ FRQGRJOLDQ]H SHU OD PRUWH GHO GXFD )UDQFHVFR ,,, G·(VWH +4:8< ² 4:;3 ",1 $UFKLYLR GHO PLQLVWUR 'X 7LOORW + 4:7<04::4 , EE1 <71 ,O IRQGR q FRVWLWXLWR GDOOH FDUWH GHOOD 6HJUHWHULD SDUWLFRODUH GL *XJOLHOPR 'X 7LOORW/ FKH IX PLQLVWUR GHJOL 6WDWL SDUPHQVL GDO 4:7< DO 4::3> FRQWLHQH GRFXPHQWD]LRQH UHODWLYD DOOD VWRULD SROLWLFD/ UHOLJLRVD HG DPPLQLVWUDWLYD GHL GXFDWL SDUPHQVL RUGLQDWD DOIDEHWLFDPHQWH SHU PDWHULD1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
45:4
3ULYLOHJL HG HVHQ]LRQL Q1 5< &DUWH FRQFHUQHQWL O·HVHQ]LRQH GHO SDJDPHQWR GHO SHGDJJLR VXO SRQWH GHOO·(Q]D FRPSHWHQWH D FLWWDGLQL SDUPLJLDQL DELWDQWL LQ 3DUPD SHU OD FRQGRWWD GHL JHQHUL SURFHGHQWL GD EHQL FK·HVVL WHQJRQR QHO UHJJLDQR1 +V1G1, 6WUDGH Q1 57 /HWWHUH GHO 0DUL/ LQ FXL VL SDUOD GHOOD VWUDGD FKH VWD IRUPDQGRVL QHOOR 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD +4:9:/ 44 DSULOH,1 Q1 58 0HPRULD VRSUD OD VWUDGD QXRYD FKH GD 3LVWRLD FRQGXUUj VXO FRQILQH GL 0RGHQD +V1G1,1 &DVD H &RUWH GL 0DULD /XLJLD +4;43 ² 4;7<, EE1 9361 4XHVWR IRQGR UDFFRJOLH/ GLVWLQWL SHU VHULH/ WXWWL JOL DIIDUL/ OH FRUULVSRQGHQ]H H OH VSHVH ULJXDUGDQWL OH SHUVRQH H OH FDUWH GL 01 /XLJLD G·$XVWULD/ FKH JRYHUQz L GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D GDO 4;47 DO 4;7:1 6HULH ,,, ² 9LDJJL VRJJLRUQL H YLOOHJJLDWXUH GL 61 0DHVWj 01 /XLJLD G·$XVWULD +4;49 ² 4;79, E1 6;3
9LDJJL H VRJJLRUQL GL 01 /XLJLD DOO·HVWHUR= 7ULHVWH/ 9LHQQD/ 0RGHQD/ 0LODQR/ 0DQWRYD/ 9DOOHJJLR +4;6: ² 4;6<,1
E1 6;7
,GHP F1V1 D 9LHQQD/ 0LODQR/ ,VFKO/ 0RGHQD +4;78 ² 4;79,1
'LSDUWLPHQWR GHJOL $IIDUL (VWHUL +4;7: ² 4;8<, EE1 53;1 6HULH 9 ² 7UDWWDWL H FRQYHQ]LRQL +GDOOD E1 67 DOOD E1 78/ 4;7< ² 4;8<, E1 73 &RQYHQ]LRQL SRVWDOL +WUD 3DUPD/ 3LHPRQWH H 0RGHQD, 4;7; ² 4;8;>
45:5
0DULD 3DUHQWH
E1 74 &RQYHQ]LRQH WHOHJUDILFD FRQ JOL 6WDWL HVWHQVL +4;84 ² 4;87,> E1 75 /HJD GRJDQDOH +4;7< ² 4;85,> E1 76 ,GHP F1V1 +4;85 ² 4;8;,> E1 77 &RQYHQ]LRQH GHO 6 OXJOLR 4;7< VXOOD OLEHUD QDYLJD]LRQH VXO 3R +4;83 ² 4;85,1 6HULH 9,,, ² &RQILQL H YLROD]LRQL GL WHUULWRULR E1 ;6 &DUWHJJL UHODWLYL DOOH LVROH DOOXYLRQDOL GHO 3R1 &DUWH WRSRJUDILFKH GHL GXFDWL GL 3DUPD H 0RGHQD ULGRWWH FRQIRUPL DO WUDWWDWR GL )LUHQ]H GHO 5; QRYHPEUH 4;771 'LVHJQL ULJXDUGDQWL OD OLQHD GL FRQILQH GHO /XVVHQVH H 5HJJLROHVH FRO 51 /RPEDUGR 9HQHWR HWF1 +4;7< ² 4;86,> E1 ;7 (VHFX]LRQH GHO WUDWWDWR GL )LUHQ]H GHO 4;77= GHPDUFD]LRQH GHL FRQILQL WUD OD SURYLQFLD IHUUDUHVH HG HVWHQVH GHOOD /XQLJLDQD1 'HOLPLWD]LRQH GHO 7KDOZJ GHO 3R/ DO ILQH GL GHWHUPLQDUH D TXDOL GHJOL 6WDWL FRQILQDQWL +3DUPD/ $XVWULD H 0RGHQD, DSSDUWHQJRQR OH LVROH GHO 3R1 +4;7< ² 4;8<,1 &RQILQL= OLQHD HVWHQVH= YHUWHQ]D 6XYHUR0 5RVVDQHVH VXL GLULWWL GL SURSULHWj GHO %RVFR GL *DPEDWDFFH1 6HULH ;9,,, ² 0LVFHOODQHD E1 4;; )RJOL ULVHUYDWL H OHWWHUH SDUWLFRODUL= OHJD GRJDQDOH +4;7< ² 4;8<,1 6HJUHWHULD GL 6WDWR H GL *DELQHWWR +4;38 ² 4;7;, EE1 7631 )LQ GDO 4;49 XQD 6HJUHWHULD GL *DELQHWWR FRQ D FDSR XQ 6HJUHWDULR GL *DELQHWWR FRRUGLQz 01 /XLJLD SHU DIIDUL FKH OH FRQFHUQHVVHUR SL• SHUVRQDOPHQWH/ FRPH OH VXSSOLFKH H L UDSSRUWL FRQ O·HVWHUR1 4XHVWR XIILFLR GLYHQWz VHPSUH SL• LPSRUWDQWH ILQFKp LO 63 DSULOH 4;54 IX LVWLWXLWD XQD 6HJUHWHULD GL 6WDWR H GL *DELQHWWR/ FRQ D FDSR XQ 6HJUHWDULR GL 6WDWR/ FKH IXQ]LRQz FRPH FHQWUR GL WXWWD O·DPPLQLVWUD]LRQH SXEEOLFD/ YHQHQGR DG HUHGLWDUH OH SUHURJDWLYH GHO SUHFHGHQWH PLQLVWHUR/ FRQ SDUWLFRODUH ULJXDUGR DJOL DIIDUL HVWHUL/ VRSUDWWXWWR GRSR LO 4;641 ,O VHJUHWDULR GL 6WDWR HEEH OH
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
45:6
VWHVVH IXQ]LRQL GHO 0LQLVWUR GL 6WDWR1 (· IRQGR VLQLVWUDWR GDOOD JXHUUD SHU FXL VL ULVFRQWUDQR PROWH ODFXQH QHOOD VHULH1 6HJUHWHULD LQWLPD GL *DELQHWWR H GHOOH UHOD]LRQL HVWHUH +4;47 ² 4;8<, EE1 4<61 (·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·ROWU·(Q]D H GHO *XDVWDOOHVH DO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD/ GL %D]]DQR H 6FXUDQR DO GXFDWR GL 3DUPD1 4;7;/ JHQQ1 ;1 &HVVLRQH GDO GXFDWR GL 0RGHQD D TXHOOR GL 3DUPD GHL WHUULWRUL GL 7UHVFKLHWWR/ 9LOODIUDQFD/ &HVWDUROL H 0XOD]]R1 533 &RQYHQ]LRQH SHU DEROLUH O·DOELQDJJLR +4;4:/ PDJJLR 53,1 &IU1 51*1/1 4;4:/ Q1 6<> 534 &RQYHQ]LRQH SHU OD ULQXQFLD UHFLSURFD DOOH UHQGLWH GL WHUUHQL DO GL Oj H DO GL TXD GHOO·(Q]D +3DUPD/ 4;4;/ JLXJQR 56,> 535 5DWLILFD PRGHQHVH GHOO·DWWR GHO 48 DJRVWR 4;53 SHU LO ULIHUWR GHO PRQWH 1DSROHRQH +0RGHQD/ 4;53/ JHQQ1 58,>
45:7
0DULD 3DUHQWH
536 7UDWWDWR IUD 6101 H 61$151 )UDQFHVFR ,9 GXFD GL 0RGHQD SHU PRGLILFKH GL FRQILQH WUD 5HJJLDQR H *XDVWDOOHVH +5HJJLR (PLOLD/ 4;54/ GLF1 46, 51*1/1 4;55 Q1 5> 537 6FULWWXUH YDULH/ UHODWLYH D XQD YHUWHQ]D PRGHQHVH ² SDUPHQVH VXO FDQDOH GL &RUUHJJLR +4;58,> 538 &RQYHQ]LRQH VXL GD]L GL WUDQVLWR SHU JHQHUL GL SULYDWLYD +4;5:/ JLXJQR 58,> 539 6FULWWXUH GLYHUVH ULJXDUGDQWL WUDWWDWLYH SHU O·DEROL]LRQH GHO GLULWWR GL DOELQDJJLR +4;63,1 53: 'LFKLDUD]LRQH GHL JRYHUQL GL 3DUPD H 0RGHQD H GHOOD 7RVFDQD SHU O·DOORQWDQDPHQWR GHL YDJDERQGL/ FRQ UHODWLYR FDUWHJJLR +4;79,> 53; $JJLXQWD DOOD FRQYHQ]LRQH GHO 53 PDJJLR 4;4: ULJXDUGDQWH L UHLQVHULWL DOOD OHYD PLOLWDUH +4;7:/ OXJOLR 53,> 53< 5DWLILFD PRGHQHVH DO WUDWWDWR DXVWUR0PRGHQHVH0SDUPHQVH/ VRWWRVFULWWR D 9LHQQD LO < DJRVWR 4;85 +/HJD 'RJDQDOH ² 3DYXOOR/ 4;85/ DJRVWR 5:,> 543 5DWLILFD PRGHQHVH DG DOFXQL DUWLFROL GHO WUDWWDWR SUHGHWWR +3DYXOOR/ 4;85/ DJRVWR 5:,1 11%1 6RQR WXWWL SXEEOLFDWL QHOOD 5DFFROWD *HQHUDOH GHOOH /HJJL SHU JOL 6WDWL GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D H *XDVWDOOD/ ´DG DQQXPµ1 &IU1 DQFKH )$7725,1,/ ,QGLFH DQDOLWLFR HG DOIDEHWLFR GHOOD 5DFFROWD *HQHUDOH GHOOH /HJJL DOOH YRFL ´WUDWWDWLµ H ´FRQYHQ]LRQLµ1
/R 6WDWR GL 0RGHQD H OR 6WDWR GL 3DUPD H 3LDFHQ]D
45:8
%LEOLRJUDILD JHQHUDOH1 $))2 ,1/ 0HPRULH GHJOL VFULWWRUL H OHWWHUDWL SDUPLJLDQL1 3DUPD/ 6WDPSHULD UHDOH/ 4:;<04:<:/ YROO1 81 3(==$1$ $1/ &RQWLQXD]LRQH GHOOH PHPRULH GHJOL VFULWWRUL H OHWWHUDWL SDUPLJLDQL1 3DUPD/ 7LSRJUDILD GXFDOH/ 4;5804;66/ YROO1 71 11%1 &·q O·LQGLFH JHQHUDOH GHJOL DXWRUL H GHL VRJJHWWL1 0(/, /83, ', 625$*1$ 51/ %LEOLRJUDILD VWRULFD H VWDWXDULD GHOOH SURYLQFLH SDUPHQVL1 3DUPD/ 51 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD SHU OH 3URYLQFH 3DUPHQVL/ 4;;9/ SS1 5871 11%1 /·RSHUD q RUGLQDWD SHU VRJJHWWL1 $/,129, (1/ %LEOLRJUDILD SDUPHQVH GDOOD VHFRQGD PHWj GHO VHF1 ;,;/ LQ $UFKLYLR VWRULFR SHU OH 3URYLQFH SDUPHQVL/ ,, 4<35 +PD 4<38, SS1 40551 11%1 /·RSHUD q RUGLQDWD SHU DXWRUL1 ,QGLFH HVVHQ]LDOH D VRJJHWWR1 /277,&, 6106,77, *1/ %LEOLRJUDILD JHQHUDOH SHU OD VWRULD SDUPHQVH/ 3DUPD/ =HUELQL/ 4<37 ;;0759 H 3DUPD/ &RRS1 3DUPHQVH/ 4<3:1 11%1 /·RSHUD q RUGLQDWD SHU VRJJHWWL1 )(/,&( '$ 0$5(72 31/ %LEOLRJUDILD JHQHUDOH GHOOH DQWLFKH 3URYLQFH SDUPHQVL1 3DUPD/ 'HSXWD]LRQH GL VWRULD SDWULD/ 4<:604<:7/ YROO1 51 /$6$*1, 51/ %LEOLRJUDILD SDUPLJLDQD/ 3DUPD/ %DWWHL/ 4<<41
3HU OD VWRULD GHO VHF1 ;,; q GL XWLOH FRQVXOWD]LRQH = )$7725,1,/ ,QGLFH DQDOLWLFR HG DOIDEHWLFR GHOOH OHJJL/ FKH ULPDQGD DOOD 5DFFROWD JHQHUDOH GHOOH OHJJL SHU JOL 6WDWL GL 3DUPD/ 3LDFHQ]D H *XDVWDOOD> GL SDUWLFRODUH XWLOLWj OH FRQVXOWD]LRQL GHOOH VHJXHQWL ´YRFLµ1 $OELQDJJLR/ YRO1 , +4;47 ² 4;68, &LDQR/ YRO1 , +4;4704;68, &RQILQL/ YRO1 ,, +4;4704;68,/ YRO1 9,,, +4;7904;83, 'RJDQH/ YRO1 ,, +4;4704;68, 0DOIDWWRUL/ YRO1 ,,, +4;4704;68, 0RGHQD/ YRO1 ,,, +4;4704;68,/ YRO1 ,; +4;7904;83, /HJD GRJDQDOH DXVWUR0HVWHQVH/ YRO1 ; +4;8404;86, /XQLJLDQD/ YRO1 ,; +4;79 ² 4;83, 5HL H GLVHUWRUL/ YRO1 ,; +4;7904;83,
%,%/,2*5$),$
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1279
1295-1900: Bonifica e cavo Parmigiana Moglia nei documenti scelti da Giovanni Ramusani, a cura di G. Badini, Reggio Emilia 1995. aBelson, a.M., Il magistrato del buon governo e l’opposizione contro il dispotismo illuminato nel ducato di Modena (1748-1755), in «AMDSP-Modena», s. X, VI (1971), pp. 53-67. aBelson, a.M., Le strutture amministrative del Ducato di Modena e l’ideale del Buon Governo (17371755), in Rivista Storica Italiana, LXXXI (1969), pp. 501-526. acidini luchinat, c., Una nota sull’iconografia secolare nella committenza estense: Sassuolo, la chiave ritrovata, in Q.B. Sassuolo e la sua storia, 1, 1993, pp. 59-65. adorni, G., Cronaca aullese degli anni 1848-49 in Cronaca e storia di Val di Magra, I, 1972. aGosti, G., L’espulsione dei frati e dei monaci forestieri nel territorio della Confederazione Cispadana, in Il Tricolore dalla Cispadana alla Cisalpina: il triennio giacobino, Modena, 1998, pp. 97-123. Alberico 1° Cybo-Malaspina. Il Principe, la Casa, lo Stato (1553-1623), Atti del Convegno, Massa 1994, Modena 1995. Albo della Società d’incoraggiamento per gli artisti degli Stati Estensi.Triennio 1848-1850, Modena 1851. Albo della Società d’ incoraggiamento per gli artisti degli Stati Estensi.Triennio 1851-1853, Modena 1854. Alessandro Stradella e Modena. Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi, Modena 15-17 dicembre 1983, a cura di c. Gianturco, Modena 1987. aMorth, l. - Boccolari, G. - roli Guidetti, c., Residenze estensi, Modena 1973. aMorth, l., Modena Capitale. Storia di Modena e dei suoi duchi dal 1598 al 1860, Modena 1967 (rist. 1998). anceschi, F. -Fresta, a., La devozione per S. Possidonio al tempo dei Pico (secc. XIV-XVIII), in San Possidonio: un santo, un territorio, Mirandola 1999, pp. 115-133. anceschi, G., Il secolo dei Lumi. Le riforme, in Storia illustrata di Reggio Emilia LX, I, pp. 273-288. andreolli, B., Il Castello e la rocca di San Felice nel basso Medioevo, in La rocca estense di San Felice sul Panaro. Studi e ricerche su un fortilizio dell’area padana dal Medioevo all’età moderna, a cura di M. calzolari ( et al.), San Felice sul Panaro 1994. andreolli, B., Il «castrum« di Finale Emilia nelle cronache medievali dell’Italia settentrionale, in Finale Emilia. Popolo e castello, Modena 1985, pp. 233-246. andreolli, B., Le cacce dei Pico. Pratiche venatorie, paesaggio e società a Mirandola tra Medioevo ed Età Moderna, San Felice sul Panaro (MO) 1988. andreolli, B., Per un profilo sociale del castello dei Pico a Mirandola. Considerazioni preliminari, in «Quaderni della Bassa Modenese. Storia, tradizione, ambiente», III (1989), 2, pp. 9-20. andreolli, B., Signori e contadini nelle terre dei Pico. Potere e società rurale a Mirandola tra Medioevo ed Età Moderna, Modena 1988. Antonio Salieri e Modena. Musica Documenti Immagini, Modena 1983.
1280
Bibliografia
Bacchi e M. Mussini, Torino 1996, pp. 59-85. Bacchi, t., Pellegrino Prisciani e la sua vocazione cartografica, in «Schifanoia», 6 (1988), pp. 187191. Bacchi, t.,Cancelleria e segretari estensi nella seconda metà del secolo XV. Prime ricerche, in «Ricerche storiche», 24, 2 (1994), pp. 351-359. Badini, G.- Milani, F., I libri parrocchiali della diocesi di Reggio Emilia, in Ricerche di archivistica e scienze ausiliarie, a cura di G. Plessi, Bologna 1973. Badini, G. – serra, l., Storia di Reggio, Reggio Emilia 1985. Badini, G., I libri parrocchiali della diocesi di Guastalla, in Ricerche di archivistica e scienze ausiliarie, dirette da G. Plessi, Bologna 1976. Badini, G., Il Monte e la vita civile in Reggio dal secolo XVII alla Restaurazione in Il santo Monte di Pietà e la Cassa di Risparmio in Reggio Emilia: cinque secoli di vita e di promozione economica e civile, Milano 1994, pp.132-138. Badini, G., Lo sviluppo demografico, in Storia illustrata di Reggio Emilia, III, pp. 705-720. Badini, G., Reggio al tempo dell’Ariosto dalle relazioni del Guicciardini e dai documenti d’archivio in Ludovico Ariosto: il suo tempo la sua terra la sua gente, Atti del convegno di studi, Reggio Emilia 1974, Reggio Emilia 1974. Badini, G., Gli Archivi ecclesiastici nel triennio giacobino in Il Tricolore dalla Cispadana alla Cisalpina. Il triennio giacobino, Atti del convegno di studi storici, Modena 1998, Modena 1998. Baldelli, F., I Conservatori della Città di Modena (1700 - 1800), in Formazione e controllo dell’opinione pubblica a Modena nel ‘700, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1986,pp. 129-164. Balduzzi, l., L’istrumento finale della transazione di Faenza pel passaggio di Ferrara dagli Estensi alla S. Sede (13 gennaio 1598), in «AMDSP-Romagna», s. III, IX(1891), pp. 80-110. Ballardini, G., La convenzione faentina del 1597, in «Archivio storico italiano», II(1906). Balletti, a., F.D. Ceccati, in «La Provincia di Reggio», II(1923), pp. 266-272. Balletti, a., Gli Ebrei e gli Estensi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.V, VII(1913), pp. 161-397. Balletti, a., Il Santo Monte della Pietà di Reggio nell’Emilia. Ricerche storiche, Reggio Emilia 1894. Balletti, a., Storia di Reggio nell’Emilia, Reggio Emilia 1925. Ballista, d. – Mundici, V., La chiesa di S. Ignazio di Carpi e l’opera di Antonio Loraghi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XVIII (1996), pp. 217-235. BalsaMo, l., Editoria e biblioteche della seconda metà del Settecento negli Stati Estensi, in Reggio e i Territori Estensi, II, Parma 1979, pp. 510-535. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., Arte alla Corte di Cesare d’Este, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XVIII(1996), pp.153-193. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., Il Duomo di Modena nel ‘700 (restauri e progetti - i falegnami Manzini), in Aspetti e problemi del Settecento modenese, Modena 1982, pp. 53-60. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., Il gioco del «Ballone», in Lo sport nel medioevo e nei secoli successivi, Atti del Convegno, Modena 1985. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., L’ Albergo dei Poveri di Modena, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, V
Bibliografia
1281
Architetture a Mirandola e nella Bassa modenese, a cura di V. Vandelli, Modena 1989. Archivi Notarile (Gli) e Storico del Comune di Aulla, Inventario, a cura di F. Bonatti, con contributi di G. ricci e G. sMeraGlia, Aulla 1981. Archivi parrocchiali (Gli) della Provincia di Modena, a cura di F. Baldelli, Modena 1993. Archivi, territori, poteri in area Estense (sec.XVI-XVIII), Atti del Convegno: Nuove ricerche nel patrimonio archivistico degli antichi stati padani, Ferrara 9-12 dicembre 1994, a cura di e. FreGni, Roma 1999. Archivio di Stato di Massa, Inventario sommario dell’Archivio di Stato, Roma 1952 (PAS/VIII). Archivio di Stato di Modena, a cura di F. Valenti, in Guida Generale degli Archivi di Stato Italiani, II, a cura del Ministero Per i Beni culturali - Uff. Centr. Beni Archivistici, Roma 1983, pp. 993-1088. Archivio di Stato di Modena, Archivio segreto estense, sezione «Casa e Stato». Inventario, a cura di F. Valenti, Roma 1953 (PAS/XIII). Archivio di Stato di Parma, a cura di M. Parente in Guida generale degli Archivi di Stato italiani, III, Roma 1986, pp. 361-438. Archivio di Stato di Reggio Emilia a cura di G. Badini, in Guida generale degli Archivi di Stato italiani, III, Roma 1986, pp. 953-998. arMandi, M., Giardini estensi a Modena in Natura e Cultura Urbana a Modena, Catalogo della mostra, Modena 1983, pp. 101-161. arManini, M.G., Progettazione e realizzazione della «strada della Tambura« sul versante massese attraverso le fonti archivistiche in La via Vandelli, strada ducale del settecento da Modena a Massa, Modena 1989, pp. 61-71. Arredi, suppellettili e «pitture famose» degli Estensi: inventari 1663, a cura di J. Bentini e P. curti, Modena 1993. Arte (L’) degli Estensi: la pittura del Seicento e del Settecento a Modena e Reggio, Catalogo della mostra, Modena 1986. Artigianato e oggetti d’artigianato a Modena dal 1650 al 1800. Catalogo di una mostra impossibile, a cura di F. Valenti - P. curti, Modena 1986. ascari t. voce Boccabadati Giovan Battista in Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani, Roma 1970. Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena, Modena 1963. Aspetti e problemi del Settecento modenese, 2 voll., Modena 1982. astolFi, i., Serie storico-cronologica dei bibliotecari dell’Estense, Modena 1887. Atti del I Convegno internazionale di studi muratoriani, Firenze 1975. Atti (Gli) del Congresso Cispadano nella città di Reggio, Roma 1897. Atti di amministrazione generale del Comune di Modena.Prodotte degli atti della Municipalità - Prodotte degli atti della Comunità in Atti di Amministrazione Generale del Comune di Modena (1796-1853), Inventario, a cura di c. liotti e P. roMaGnoli, Modena 1995. Bacchi, a., Le Sculture, in Il Santuario della Madonna della Ghiara a Reggio Emilia, a cura di a.
1282
Bibliografia
BarGhini, a., Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena nei disegni di Robert de Cotte, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XVI(1994), pp. 284-292. BariGazzi, c., Filippo Buonarroti e i patrioti reggiani (1796-1831) in «L’Almanacco», 26-27, (1995-1996), p. 32. Bariola, V.s., L’Edificio del grande Albergo dei poveri a Modena, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. X, V (1970), pp. 41-46. Bariola,G.- Bertoni, G.- nasciMBeni, G., Il patrimonio storico-artistico della Congregazione di Carità di Modena, Modena 1920. Barocco romano e Barocco italiano. Il teatro, l’effimero, l’allegoria, a cura di M. FaGiolo dell’arco e M.l. Madonna, Roma -Reggio Calabria 1985. Barozzi, M.V., Notizie sull’urbanistica di Sassuolo nel sec. XV, dai protocolli del notaio Antonio Paffi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, I(1979), pp.49-61. Basini, G.l., L’uomo e il pane.Risorse, consumi e carenze alimentari della popolazione modenese nel Cinque e Seicento, Milano 1970. Basini, G.l., Le terre di un monastero, un’azienda agraria emiliana dal 1650 al 1750, Bologna 1979. Basini, G.l., Zecca e monete a Modena nei secoli XVI e XVII, Parma 1967. Battini, a., La cultura a corte nei secoli XV e XVI attraverso i libri dedicati, in Gli Estensi. La corte di Ferrara, a cura di r. iotti, Modena 1997, pp. 314-322. Bayard de Volo, t.,Vita di Francesco V,Duca di Modena (1819-1875), voll. I-IV, Modena 1879-1885 (rist. Modena 1983). Bedoni, G., Il ducato di Massa e Carrara dal 1815 al 1829: stato patrimoniale o stato di polizia in Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione, Massa-Modena 1980, pp. 262-263. Bedoni, G., Il piano menottiano del 1830 (nota storico-giuridica) in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, IV (1982), pp. 285-302. Bedoni, G., Il ruolo di L.A. Muratori e B. Valdrighi nella codificazione estense del 1771, in «Memorie Accad. Naz. Scienze, Lett. Arti», s.VII, XIII (1995-96), pp. 219-232. Bedoni, G., L’ufficio del Governatore nei Ducati Estensi, quale organo periferico con competenza generale (1527-1789), in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XV (1993), pp.157-188. Bedoni, G., La Provincia della Garfagnana dal 1430 al 1619 in La Garfagnana storia, cultura e arte. Atti del convegno, Castelnuovo 1993, Modena 1993, pp. 87-111. Bedoni, G., Il ducato di Massa e Carrara dal 1829 al 1859. Riforme strutturali ed istituzionali operate dalla legislazione estense in Massa e Carrara da Maria Beatrice a Vittorio Emanuele II (18291859), Modena 1990, pp. 125-151. Bedoni, G., Modena 1547: la storica riforma del diritto processuale civile, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, 14 (1992), pp. 109-142. Bellini, a., Confraternite e devozioni speciali in Diocesi di Carpi, in Notizie storiche riguardanti la Diocesi di Carpi, Carpi s.d. Bellini, a., Cronisti e storiografi carpigiani e mirandolesi nel secolo di L. A. Muratori, in «aMDSP-
Bibliografia
1283
(1983), pp. 147-165. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., L’ Accademia di pittura nel Palazzo Comunale di Modena (secc. XVIIXVIII), in «AMDSP- Modena», s. XI, III (1981), pp. 63-90. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., La Piazza Grande negli Atti della Comunità di Modena dal 1412 al 1580, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, I(1979), pp. 67-92. Baracchi GioVanardi, o., Modena: Piazza Grande, Modena 1981. Baracchi, o.-Manicardi, a., Modena: quando c’erano i canali, Modena 1985. Baraldi, G.,Compendio storico della Città e Provincia di Modena dai tempi della Romana repubblica sino al 1796, Modena 1846. Barazzoni, P., L’Assistenza sociale a Reggio Emilia, 3 voll., Reggio Emilia 1998. BarBieri , a., Modena ieri e oggi, Modena 1965. BarBieri , a., Storia di Sassuolo. Il Seicento e il Settecento, Sassuolo 1992. BarBieri, F.- cattelani, F., Catalogo della corrispondenza di Paolo Ruffini, Pisa 1997. BarBieri, F.- cattelani, F., Paolo Ruffini tra religione e politica, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XVIII, XI(1966), pp. 238-250. BarBieri, F., Alcuni contributi di Paolo Ruffini all’algebra, in Il pensiero matematico nella ricerca storica italiana, Atti del Convegno, Ancona 1992. BarBieri, F., Ferdinando Jacoli storiografo delle matematiche, in «Rassegna frignanese», 25 (198586). BarBieri, F., Il contributo di Pietro Riccardi alla storiografia matematica, in Pietro Riccardi (18281898) e la storiografia delle matematiche in Italia, Atti del convegno, Modena 1987, a cura di F. BarBieri, F. cattelani deGani, Modena 1987. BarBieri, F., Pietro Riccardi nella cultura e nella Società modenese del secondo Ottocento, in «aMDSPModena», s.X, XI(1988), pp. 318-343. BarBieri, F., Pietro Riccardi: cenni storici intorno allo studio ed ai cultori delle scienze fisico-matematiche pure ed applicate,nella città e provincia di Modena, in «Memorie Accad.Scienze Lett.ArtiModena», s.VII, VII(1989-90), pp. 83-130. BarBieri, u., Modena memorie storiche, Modena 1945. BarBolini Ferrari, e.-Boccolari, G., Argenti estensi. L’arte orafa nel ducato di Modena e Reggio, Milano 1994. BarBolini Ferrari, e.-Boccolari, G., L’arte del ferro nel ducato estense, Modena 1996. BarBoni yans, G., Contributo alla storia della gestione degli spettacoli nel ducato Estense, in Teatro e musica nel ‘700 Estense, a cura di G. Vecchi - M. calore, Firenze 1994, pp. 225-326. BarGelli, c., Lo Stato estense nei secoli XVII e XVIII: aspetti economici e sociali a Modena capitale, in Duecentocinquant’anni di ceramica a Sassuolo, I, «Dalla manifattura alla Fabbrica », Modena 1991, pp. 31-48. BarGelli, c., Pauperismo, economia e società a Modena nei secoli XVIIXVIII, Verona 1998.
1284
Bibliografia
Bertuzzi, G., Le grandi opere murarie del Settecento, in L’arte muraria a Modena. Storia di uomini e di pietre, Modena 1993, pp. 141-148. Bertuzzi, G., Modena scomparsa. L’abbattimento delle mura, Modena 1990. Bestor, J.F., Bastardy and Legitimacy in the Formation of a Regional State in Italy: the Estense Succession, in «Comparative Studies in Society and History», 38 (1996), 3, pp. 549-585. Bestor, J.F., Kinship and Marriage in the Politics of an Italian Ruling House: the Este of Ferrara in the Reign of Ercole I (1471-1505), Chicago University 1992, (in corso di stampa), pp. 388398. BiaGi Maino, d., «La fatica, lo studio, l’Opera et il sasso«. La scultura a Modena fra Sei e Settecento, in «Il Carrobbio», XVII(1991). Biagio e Anacarsi Nardi patrioti del Risorgimento. Studi e celebrazioni, Modena-La Spezia 1983. Bianchi, n., I ducati estensi dal 1815 al 1850, Torino 1852. Bianchini, M.-Veroni, F., L.A. Muratori e le riforme nel Ducato di Modena in Storia illustrata di Modena, II, pp. 641-660. Biondi, a., Don Antonio Rovatti e la tradizione delle cronache modenesi, in Modena Napoleonica. L’albero della Libertà 1796-1797, Milano 1995, pp. 45-48. Biondi, a., Duchisti, patrioti e francesi a Modena nel triennio 1796-99 in Modena Napoleonica, pp. 11-27. Biondi, a., Gli ebrei e l’Inquisizione negli Stati Estensi, in L’Inquisizione e gli ebrei in Italia, a cura di M. luzzatti, Roma-Bari 1994, pp. 265-286. Biondi, a., I ducati dell’Emilia occidentale nel periodo dell’antico regime, in Storia dell’Emilia Romagna, II, Bologna 1977, pp. 35-64. Biondi, a., I secoli del San Carlo, in Il Collegio e la chiesa di San Carlo a Modena, Modena 1991, pp. 27-78. Biondi, a., Lunga durata e microarticolazione nel territorio di un Ufficio dell’Inquisizione: il “Sacro Tribunale” a Modena (1292-1785) in «Annali dell’Istituto storico italo-germanico in Trento», VIII, 1982, pp.73-90. Biondi, a., Carpi nel ducato estense, in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi (in corso di stampa). Biondi, a., Come una prefazione: Modena nel 1796 in Formazione e controllo dell’opinione pubblica a Modena nel Settecento, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1986, pp. 9-22. Biondi, G., Per una storia dell’attività consiliare del Comune di Modena dal Medioevo alla fine dell’Antico Regime (1796), in I registri delle Deliberazioni consiliari del Comune di Modena dal XIV al XVIII secolo, a cura di c. liotti e P. roMaGnoli, Modena 1987. Bocchi, F., Il dominio estense (1527-1796), in Atlante storico delle città italiane.Carpi, a cura di F. Bocchi, Bologna 1986, pp. 22-25.
Bibliografia
1285
Modena», s.VIII, 5 (1953), pp. 105-115. Beloch, K.J., Ricerche sulla storia della popolazione di Modena e del Modenese, in «Rivista italiana di Sociologia», XII, I, 1908. BeltraMi, G., Il Ducato di Modena tra Francia e Austria (Francesco II d’Este,1674-1694), in «AMDSP-Modena», s.VIII, IX (1957), pp. 100-142. Benassati, G., La pratica del torneo a Modena in età barocca. Appunti per una fenomenologia dello spettacolo nel Ducato Estense, in «Il Carrobbio», VI (1981), pp. 56-60. Benassati, G., Note sull’attività del veneziano Tommaso Bezzi a Modena (1700-1727), in «Il Carrobbio», VIII (1982), pp. 24-26. Benati, d., La quadreria, in La Collegio e la Chiesa di San Carlo in Modena, a cura di d. Benati-l. Peruzzi- V. Vandelli, pp. 199-210.. Bentini, J., «Otium Regium«. I privilegi del principe collezionista, ovvero le qualità della Galleria del Serenissimo Duca di Modena, in Sovrane passioni. Le raccolte d’arte della Ducale Galleria Estense, Catalogo della mostra, a cura di J. Bentini, Milano 1998, pp. 18-43. Bentini, J., La collezione di disegni dei duchi d’Este a Modena, in Disegni da una grande collezione. Antiche raccolte estensi dal Louvre e dalla Galleria di Modena, Catalogo della mostra, a cura di J. Bentini, Milano 1998, pp. 12-15. Bentini, J., Pittura veneta nelle raccolte estensi di Modena, in La pittura veneta negli Stati Estensi, Modena 1996, pp. 259-315. Bernieri, a., La politica marmifera di Maria Teresa nel quadro della trasformazione sociale del principato di Carrara in Carrara ed il marmo nel ‘700:società, economia, cultura. Atti del convegno, in «Annuario della Biblioteca Civica di Massa 1982/83», Pisa 1984, pp. 43-60. Berselli, a., Movimenti politici e sociali a Modena dal 1796 al 1859 in Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena cit., pp. 26-27. Bertacchini, r., Il «poema sacro« e i dantisti a Modena, introduz. alla «Lectura Dantis modenese», I, Inferno, Modena 1984, pp.XI-LXI. Bertacchini, r., Un tardivo romanzo storico dell’Ottocento modenese: «Sanfedisti e Carbonari« in «AMDSP- Modena», s.VIII, XII (1960), pp.146-160. Bertelli, s., Erudizione e storia in Ludovico Antonio Muratori, Napoli 1960. Bertoni, G. - Vicini e.P., Il castello di Ferrara ai tempi di Niccolò III, Bologna 1909. Bertoni,G., La Biblioteca Estense e la cultura ferrarese al tempo di Ercole I d’Este, Torino 1903. Bertoni,G., Notizie sugli amanuensi degli Estensi nel Quattrocento, in «Archivum Romanicum», II (1918), pp. 55-57. Bertuzzi, G., Il rinnovamento edilizio a Modena nella seconda metà del Settecento, 3 voll., Modena 1981-83. Bertuzzi, G., Il Trattato di Firenze del 28 novembre 1844, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.X, III(1968), pp. 173-199. Bertuzzi, G., La struttura amministrativa del Ducato Austro-Estense. Lineamenti, Modena 1977.
1286
Bibliografia
Branchi , e., Storia della Lunigiana feudale, I, Pistoia 1890. BraVi , F., Alfonso III, il principe frate, Bolzano 1972. BreGoli russo, M.- calore, M. Spettacoli del Rinascimento negli Stati Estensi, Bologna 1980. Brenni, P.- hacKMann, W., Gli strumenti scientifici in L’eredità scientifica di Leopoldo Nobili, Catalogo della mostra, Reggio Emilia 1984, pp. 29-30. BruGnoli , G., Indice ragionato del Codice Estense, p.VI, Modena 1852. Brunelli B., Capricci e scandali alla corte di Modena, Milano 1935. BuFFa, P., Il Libro de’ conti del laboratorio di Giovan Battista Amici (Modena 1786-1863), in «Giornale di Fisica», XXIX(1988), 2-3, pp. 115-123. BulGarelli, M., L’affare delle sepolture a Modena nella seconda metà del XVIII secolo. Questioni mediche, amministrative, tecniche, architettoniche, militari, in «Storia urbana», 51 (1990), pp. 3-41. BulGarelli, M., 1798-1830 Rivoluzione e Restaurazione. Da Palazzo Nazionale a Palazzo Reale in Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena, pp. 279-318. caBassi, e., Notizie degli artisti carpigiani, …a cura di a. Garuti, Modena 1986 (rist.). cadoPPi, G., Gabinetti fisici e strumentaria nel Ducato di Modena, in «Giornale di Fisica», XXIX(1988), 2-3, pp. 97-114. calleGari, e., La Devoluzione di Ferrara alla Santa Sede (1598) da documenti inediti dagli Archivi di Stato di Modena e Venezia, in «Rivista Storica Italiana», XII, I(1895), pp. 1-57. calore, M., Da Francesco Nicola a Cesare Frassoni. Un secolo di teatro al Finale, in Accademia dei Fluttuanti, Atti della giornata di studio per il IV centenario della fondazione, Modena 1994, pp. 119-142. calore, M., Fare teatro in collegio. Gli spettacoli al S. Carlo di Modena nel ‘700, Bologna 1990. calore, M., Il teatro degli Estensi, in Storia illustrata di Modena, II, a cura di P. Golinelli e G. Muzzioli, Milano 1990,pp. 501-520. calore, M., Spettacoli a Modena tra Cinquecento e Seicento. Dalla città alla capitale, Modena 1982. caMPana, a., Gli Incunaboli della Biblioteca Estense e il loro catalogo, Ferrara 1929. caMPani s., Compendio della storia di Modena, Modena 1875 (rist. anast. Modena 1976). caMPanini, n., Ars siricea Regij. Vicende dell’Arte della seta in Reggio nell’Emilia dal secolo XVI al secolo XIX, Reggio Emilia 1888. caMPi G., Cenni storici intorno l’Archivio segreto Estense ora diplomatico, in «AMDSP-Modena» 2(1864), pp. 335-362. caMPori, G., Della istituzione delle Guardie svizzere in Italia e particolarmente in Modena, in «L’Indicatore Modenese», 20-21 (1852). caMPori, G., Gli artisti italiani e stranieri negli Stati Estensi. Catalogo storico corredato di documenti inediti, Modena 1855 (rist. anast. Roma 1969).
Bibliografia
1287
Bocchi, F., Introduzione in Carpi,immagine e immaginario.Viaggiatori, storici, letterati, osservatori, a cura di G. zacchè, Bologna 1987, pp. 14-15. Boccia, G.l., Le armerie Estensi nel Settecento, Firenze 1988. Boccia, G.l., Armi d’attacco da difesa e da fuoco. La collezione d’armi del Museo d’Arte Medievale e Moderna di Modena, Modena 1996. Boccolari, G., Aspetti dell’industria e del commercio a Modena dall’età napoleonica al 1859, in Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena, pp. 67-122. Boccolari, G., Ciro Menotti e i moti del 1831, in Storia illustrata di Modena, II. Boccolari, G., Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena. Vicende storiche in Residenze Estensi, Modena 1973, pp. 12-32. Boccolari, G., Kronos. Storia della misurazione del tempo a Modena, Modena 1993. Boccolari, G., L’ “Arte degli Orefici” a Modena (secc. XV-XIX), Modena 1991. Boccolari, G., Lodovico Vedriani e la storia di Modena in «AMDSP-Modena», s.X, VII(1972), pp. 51-63. Boccolari, G., L’ultimo dominio di Casa d’Este, in «Memorie. Accad. Scien.Lett.Arti-Modena», s.VI, XIII (1971), pp. 151-166. Boccolari, G.- selMi, a., Monete e cambi nel Ducato di Modena dal 1819 al 1859, in «Archivio economico dell’Unificazione italiana», III-IV(1957), III, pp.1-51. BoloGnini aMorini, a., Elogio di Angelo Venturoli, Bologna 1827. Bona (La) opinione. Cultura, misura e scienza negli Stati estensi 1598-1860, Catalogo della mostra, a cura di d. daMeri (et al.), Modena 1997. Bonacini, c., La fondazione dell’Osservatorio di Modena attraverso il carteggio di Gianbattista Amici, in Nel primo Centenario dell’Osservatorio 1827-1927, Modena 1927, pp. 15-34. Bonacini, c., La storia dell’Osservatorio, in Nel primo Centenario, pp.V – XXXVII. Bonaini, F., Gli archivi nelle province dell’Emilia e le loro condizioni al finire del 1860, Firenze 1861. Bonatti, F., La Lunigiana nel secolo XV attraverso i protocolli del notaio Baldassare Nobili, Pisa 1977. Bonatti, F., Gli Istituti culturali del ducato di Massa Carrara nell’età delle riforme in Carrara ed il marmo, pp. 139-167. Bondanini, a., Contributi per la storia della cartografia ferrarese, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», XXXIX (1981), pp. 17-19. Bonsanti, G., Galleria Estense, Modena 1977. Borsettus, F., Historiae Almi Ferrariae Gymnasii, II, Ferrariae 1735. Bosellini, l., Francesco IV e Francesco V di Modena, Torino 1861. Bosellini, l., Intorno al cessato Tribunale supremo di revisione di Modena, in «Gazzetta dei tribunali. Giornale universale di legislazione e giurisprudenza», 97-98-99(1861), pp. 775 ss.
1288
Bibliografia
cattini, M., I contadini di San Felice. Metamorfosi di un mondo rurale nell’Emilia dell’Età moderna, Torino 1984. cattini, M., L’economia modenese tra Quattro e Cinquecento, in Storia Illustrata di Modena, Milano 1990, pp. 421-440. cattini, M., Nel basso Modenese: una crisi agricola alle origini delle depressione demografica seicentesca, in «Rivista di Storia dell’Agricoltura», 2 (1978), pp. 64-66. cattini, M., Pastori e contadini della montagna reggiana (note sulla demografia dell’Appennino emiliano in Età moderna), in «Cheiron», 7/8(1988), pp. 63-84. caValieri, G., Il Dipartimento del Crostolo. I frequenti cambiamenti nella sua periferia territoriale nello stato dei distretti e dei comuni, in «Il Pescatore Reggiano», 1985-1987. caVatorti, V., Storia dell’Università di Reggio Emilia, Reggio Emilia 1997. caVazzoni Pederzini, F., La Compagnia della Carità di L. A. Muratori, in «Opuscoli Religiosi, Letterari e Morali», 1(1857), pp. 382-395. caVazzoni, e., Pazzi, mentecatti, furiosi negli Stati estensi tra età delle Riforme ed età napoleonica in Reggio e i Territori Estensi dall’Antico Regime all’Età Napoleonica, a cura di M.BerenGo e s. roMaGnoli, I, Parma 1979, pp. 295-328. caVazzuti , G., Di Alfonso III d’Este, Modena 1906. caVazzuti, G., Monaldo Leopardi e i redattori della Voce della Verità in «Memorie Accad. Scienze,Lett. Arti-Modena», s.V, II (1937), pp. 203-268. caVedoni, c., Notizie della città di Modena dai primi tempi di essa a tutto il secolo IV di Cristo, in Dichiarazione degli antichi marmi modenesi con le notizie di Modena al tempo dei Romani, Modena 1828. caVina, M., Il codice dimenticato. Un misterioso codice di procedura civile [1830ca] di Francesco IV d’Austria-Este, in «Rivista di storia del diritto italiano», 68 (1995), pp. 233-245. caVina, M., Elogio del diritto immoto. Rappresentazioni estensi, in «Materiali per una storia della cultura giuridica», 26(1996), pp. 101-120. caVina, M., Il potere del padre, II, La scuola giuridica estense e la promozione della patria postestà nel Ducato di Modena (1814-1859), Milano 1995. caVina, M., Itinerari della scuola giuridica austro-estense (con l’edizione di un documento ‘rivoluzionario’ contro il consilium sapientis iudiciale), in «Memorie Accad.Scienze Lett. e Arti-Modena», s.VII, 12(1994-1995), pp. 191-223. cazzola, F., Problemi d’acque e tecnica cartografica: l’Hidrologia di Giovan Battista Aleotti, in «Schifanoia», 6 (1988), pp. 199-204. Cento disegni di Giuseppe Fantaguzzi (Modena 1771-1837), a cura di e. cecchi Gattolin, Modena 1975. Ceramiche settecentesche del ducato modenese: Sassuolo e centri minori, Catalogo mostra, a cura di F. liVerani, Modena 1980. ceretti, F., L’assedio della Mirandola nel 1502, Mirandola 1877.
Bibliografia
1289
caMPori, G., Gli intagliatori di stampe e gli Estensi, in «AMDSP-Modena», n.s.,VII(1882), 2 p.te, pp. 69-91. caMPori, G., Memorie biografiche degli scultori, architetti, pittori di Carrara, Modena 1873. caMPori, G., Memorie storiche di Marco Pio di Savoia signore di Sassuolo, Modena 1871. caMPori, M., Corrispondenza tra L. A. Muratori e G.G. Leibniz conservata nella R. Biblioteca di Hannover, Modena 1892. caMus, G., I Codici francesi della R.Biblioteca Estense, Modena 1889. caneVazzi, G., La scuola militare di Modena (1756-1914), 2 voll., Modena 1914-1920. caneVazzi, G., Un Deputato all’Assemblea Nazional Modenese del 1859, Modena 1912. caneVazzi, G., Un patriota bibliofilo e filologo,Giuseppe Campi, in Miscellanea in onore di G.Sforza, Torino-Lucca 1917, pp. 573-599. caneVazzi, G., Ricordanze di Luigi Generali in «Archivio Emiliano del Risorgimento Nazionale», I (1907), pp. 24-25. Cantatas by Giuseppe Colombi, Giovanni Maria Bononcini, Domenico Gabrielli, Giovanni Maria (Angelo) Bononcini. Selected and introduced by Alessandra Chiarelli, New York 1986. caPece Galeoti zuccoli, V., Maria di Modena, regina d’Inghilterra, Milano 1940. Capitoli, ordini e privilegi concessi da’ Serenissimi a benefizio della sua diletta, e fedel Milizia, approvati e confirmati dall’Altezza Serenissima di Rinaldo I, Modena 1707. Capitulationi fatte tra N.S.Papa Clemente VIII et il S.D. Cesare d’Este nella pace et accomodamento delle cose di Ferrara et suo Ducato, adì 13 gennaio 1598 in Faenza, et confirmati in Concistoro alli 19. detto mese, Ferrara 1598. caPPelli, a., La Biblioteca Estense nella prima metà del secolo XV, in «Giornale storico della letteratura italiana», XIV (1889), pp. 1-30. caPPi, a., La Chiesa del Vandelli. 150° della Chiesa Parrocchiale di Lesignana, Soliera 1994. carandini, G., Il Real Corpo Militare del Genio, Modena 1859, pp. 4-15. carBonieri, l., Cenni storici della R. Biblioteca Estense con appendici e documenti, Modena 1873. carrara, V., Reti monastiche nell’Italia padana: le chiese di San Silvestro di Nonantola tra Pavia, Piacenza e Cremona, secc.9.-13., Modena 1998. casari, u.,Giuseppe Luosi e altri intellettuali estensi alla fine del Settecento,Verona 1995, pp. 39-52. casoli, P.B., La Chiesa degli Stati Estensi e il vescovo di Modena Luigi Reggianini, in «La Scuola Cattolica», Milano 1902. catelani, a., Delle opere di A. Stradella esistenti nell’Archivio Musicale della Biblioteca Palatina di Modena... in «AMDSP-Modena», 3 (1865), pp. 319-354. cattini, M.- roMani, M.a., Tra faida familiare e rivolta politica: banditi e banditismo nella montagna estense (sec. XVII), in Bande armate banditi, banditismo e repressione di giustizia negli stati europei d’antico regime, a cura di G. ortalli, , Roma 1986, pp. 53-65.
1290
Bibliografia
Collegio (Il) e la Chiesa di San Carlo a Modena, a cura di d. Benati- l. Peruzzi e V. Vandelli, Modena 1991. colli d., I secoli della meraviglia. Il Seicento e il Settecento, a cura di d. colli-a. Garuti- G. Martinelli BraGlia, Modena 1998, pp. 9-58. colli, d.- Garuti, a.-Pelloni, r., Vallate appenniniche e tesori nascosti tra Reno e Secchia, Modena 1997. colli, d.- Garuti, a.-Pelloni, r., La scagliola carpigiana e l’illusione barocca, Modena 1990. coloMBi Ferretti, a., I paliotti in scagliola, in Vita di borgo e artigianato,Cultura Popolare nell’Emilia Romagna, Milano 1980, pp. 220-239. coMune di carPi, Catalogo ragionato delle edizioni del Comune di Carpi corredato da notizie essenziali sulle fonti per la storia locale, a cura di G. zacchè, Carpi 1991, pp. 53-65. conForti, c., Il «funeral teatro« a Modena nel Seicento, in Barocco romano e Barocco italiano, pp. 217-227. corradini, c., “Notizie Storiche Di Correggio”: attribuzione ed analisi, in «Strenna del Pio Istituto Artigianelli», 1987, pp. 86-97. corradini, e., Le raccolte estensi di antichità. Primi contributi documentari, in L’impresa di Alfonso II. Saggi e documenti sulla produzione artistica a Ferrara nel secondo Cinquecento, a cura di J. Bentini e l. sPezzaFerro, Bologna 1987, pp. 163-192. corradini, e., Effingere vultus: le prime medaglie degli Estensi, in Gli Estensi. La Corte di Ferrara, a cura di r. iotti (et al.), Modena 1997, pp. 357-377. corsi s., Spinario in Sculture a Corte.Terrecotte,marmi, gessi della Galleria Estense dal XVI al XIX secolo, Catalogo mostra, a cura di J. Bentini, Modena 1996. Corte, buon governo,pubblica felicità.Politica e coscienza civile nel Muratori, Atti della III giornata di studi muratoriani,Vignola 1995, Firenze 1996. cortese, n., La Garfagnana Estense durante la dominazione francese (1796-1799), Torino 1929. cottaFaVi, e., I Seminari della diocesi di Reggio nell’Emilia. L’università reggiana nel secolo XVIII, Reggio Emilia 1907 cresPellani, a., La Zecca di Modena nei periodi comunale ed estense, Modena 1884. Crisi del Ducato di Modena 1859. Atti del Convegno, Mirandola, 30 giugno 1995, Carpi 1996. crisPi, a., Elogi di uomini illustri della città di Reggio di Lombardia, Reggio 1874. crocioni, G., I teatri di Reggio nell’Emilia, Reggio 1907. Cronaca della Mirandola, dei figli di Manfredo e della corte di Quarantola scritta da Ingrano Bratti, continuata da Battista Papazzoni, a cura di F. ceretti, Mirandola 1872. Cronaca modenese di Tommasino dè Bianchi o Lancellotti, a cura di c. BorGhi, Parma 1862-1882 (Monumenti di S.P., serie delle Cronache, t. XII-XIII). croWther, V., The Oratorio in Modena, Oxford 1992. cuccaGni, l., Vita di Francescantonio Zaccaria, Roma 1796.
Bibliografia
1291
cesari, c., Modena, Modena 1929. chiaPPini, l., 1598: diario di una svolta, in «Ferrara», 7 (1997), pp. 17-27. chiaPPini, l., Gli Estensi, Varese 1967. chiaPPini, l., Il territorio ferrarese nella carta inedita dei Ducati Estensi di Marco Antonio Pasi (1571), in «AMDSP-Ferrara», XIII (1973), s.III, pp. 187-222. chiaPPini, l., La Corte Estense alla metà del Cinquecento, Ferrara 1984. chiarelli, a., I codici di musica della raccolta estense. Ricostruzione dall’inventario settecentesco, Firenze 1987. chiarelli, a., La Musica, in Il Collegio e la chiesa di S. Carlo a Modena, Modena 1991, pp. 249255. chiarelli, a., Per un profilo sintetico delle feste d’armi a Modena nel Cinque e Seicento, (in corso di stampa). chiarelli, a., Collezionismo musicale nel tardo Seicento: le raccolte manoscritte di arie da opere italiane nella Biblioteca Estense di Modena, Bologna 1985-1986. chiesi, l., Reggio nell’Emilia sotto i pontefici Giulio II,Leone X,Adriano VI e Francesco Guicciardini, governatore della città, Reggio Emilia 1892. ciardi, r., L’Accademia ducale di Belle Arti di Carrara nel periodo delle riforme in Carrara ed il marmo, pp. 85-137. cionini, n., Cenni e documenti su Marco Pio, signore di Sassuolo, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. III, II(1883), pp.497-544. cionini, n., Teatro ed arti a Sassuolo, Modena 1902. ciroldi, s., Musici e mecenati alla Corte dei Gonzaga di Novellara e Bagnolo nel 1500, in Documenta. Luoghi di Studio e studio di luoghi. Bagnolo tra Reggio e Novellara, Bagnolo in Piano 1995, pp. 56-57. cittadella, l.n., Il Castello di Ferrara, Ferrara 1875. Civitas Geminiana. La città e il suo patrono, Catalogo della mostra, a cura di F. Piccinini, Modena 1997. coccioli MastroViti, a., Gli altari della Chiesa, in Il Collegio e la Chiesa di San Carlo a Modena, pp. 131-147. coccioli MastroViti, a., L’Accademia di Belle Arti di Modena, in L’architettura nelle accademie riformate. Insegnamento, dibattito culturale, interventi pubblici, a cura di G. ricci, Milano 1992, pp. 353-362. coccioli MastroViti, a., Tipologie e apparati decorativi per gli altari del Settecento: il caso degli altari sassolesi, in «Q.B. Sassuolo e la sua storia», 2 (1996), pp. 154-157. Codice di leggi e costituzioni per gli stati di sua Altezza serenissima, Modena 1771. coFFin, d.r., Pirro Ligorio and Decoration of the Late Sixteenth Century at Ferrara, in «Art Bulletin», 37 (1955), pp. 167-185.
1292
Bibliografia
di Pietro loMBardi, P., Riflessi sull’opinione pubblica modenese dell’apertura della biblioteca privata degli Estensi a metà Settecento, in Formazione e controllo dell’opinione pubblica a Modena nel ‘700, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1986, pp.119-128. di Pietro loMBardi, P., La Cancelleria degli Estensi nel periodo ferrarese (1264-1598) in «AMDSP-Modena», s.X, 10 (1975), pp. 91-99. di Pietro, P., L’ospedale di Modena, Modena 1965. di Pietro, P., Lazzaro Spallanzani, Modena 1967. di Pietro, P., L’insegnamento della teologia nell’Università di Modena, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.X, 4 (1969), pp. 93-122. di Pietro, P., Lo Studio Pubblico di S. Carlo in Modena (1682-1772). Novant’anni di storia dell’Università di Modena, Modena 1970. di Pietro, P., Medicina e igiene a Modena dalla peste del 1630 ai giorni nostri, in Storia illustrata di Modena, II, Modena 1990, pp. 581-600. Diario Ferrarese, a cura di G. Pardi in «RIS 2», t. XXIV, VII. Disegni (I) dei Consetti nelle collezioni della Biblioteca Civica di Storia dell’Arte Luigi Poletti. Iacopino e Antonio Consetti. Modena 1651-1726/1686-1766, a cura di e. cecchi Gattolin, Modena 1982. Disegni della Galleria Estense di Modena, a cura di J. Bentini, Modena 1989. doMenichini, P., Sull’attività bancaria nel Modenese nella prima metà dell’Ottocento in Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena, pp. 219-227. donati, B., L.A. Muratori e la giurisprudenza del suo tempo, Modena 1931. donati, B., L’opera di G.M. Bondigli nelle istituzioni giuridiche modenesi alla metà del sec. XVIII, in «Memorie Accad.Scienze, Lett. e Arti-Modena», s.IV, I(1926), pp. 131-154. donati, B., L’Università di Modena nel Seicento ai tempi del Muratori discepolo, Modena 1935. donati, P., La demolizione della chiesa massese di S. Pietro e la dispersione del suo arredo in Ai confini del Principato: Massa e Carrara in Il principato napoleonico dei Baciocchi (1805-1814). Riforma dello Stato e Società, Lucca 1984, pp. 509-689. dotti Messori, G., Spettacoli e arte a Modena nell’Ottocento: inventario, Modena 1995. draGoni, G., G.B. Amici: il microscopio a riflessione. Anticipazioni storiche, caratteristiche tecniche, in «Giornale di Fisica», XXIX (1988), 2-3, pp. 141-142. Ducal Galleria Estense. Dissegni, medaglie e altro: gli inventari del 1669 e del 1671, a cura di J. Bentini e P. curti, Modena 1990. durante, e.- Martellotti, a., L’arpa di Laura. Indagine organologica, artistica e archivistica sull’arpa estense, Firenze 1982. durante, e.- Martellotti, Un decennio di spese musicali alla corte di Ferrara (1587-1597), Fasano 1982. durante,e.-Martellotti, a., Cronistoria del Concerto delle Dame principalissime di Margherita
Bibliografia
1293
Cultura ebraica in Emilia-Romagna, a cura di s.M. Bondoni - G. Busi, Rimini 1984. curti, P., Note sull’arredo del Palazzo Ducale dal XVII al XIX secolo, in Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena, pp. 257-268. dall’olio, G.B., I Pregi del Regio Palazzo di Modena, Modena 1811. Dallari (I) e la ceramica a Sassuolo nel Settecento, Catalogo mostra, Faenza 1996. dallari, u., IL R. Archivio di Stato di Reggio nell’Emilia, in Gli archivi della Storia d’Italia, s. II, I, a cura di G. Mazzatinti e G. deGli azzi, Rocca San Casciano 1910. dallari, u., Il matrimonio di Giacomo Stuart, duca di York, con Maria d’Este (1673),in «AMDSPModena», s.IV, VIII (1898), pp. 1-46. daVoli, a., L’incisione reggiana dal ‘400 all’800. Rassegna storica, Reggio Emilia 1961. daVoli, z., L’arte dell’incisione, in Storia illustrata di Reggio Emilia, IV, pp. 1025-1040. daVoli, z., La Madonna della Ghiara in tre secoli di storia dell’incisione, in Un santuario e una città, Catalogo della mostra, Reggio Emilia 1974. daVoli, z., Le incisioni classiche reggiane, Reggio Emilia 1978. daVoli, z., Le raccolte di stampe dei Civici Musei, I,Stampe di autore e di interesse reggiano, Reggio Emilia 1983. daVoli, z., Stampe reggiane di apparati religiosi e civili dei secoli XVII e XVIII, in In forma di festa. Apparatori, decoratori, scenografi, impresari in Reggio Emilia dal 1600 al 1875, Catalogo della mostra, a cura di M. PiGozzi, Reggio Emilia 1985, pp. 77-110. De Bello in Caferoniana gesto anno MDCXIII, a cura di P.l.raGGi -P.taGliasacchi, Lucca 1987. de steFani, c., Storia dei Comuni di Garfagnana, Pisa 1978. de VerGottini, G., Il diritto pubblico italiano nei secoli XII-XV, a cura di c. dolcini, Milano 1993. dean, t., Terra e potere a Ferrara nel tardo medioevo. Il dominio estense, 1350-1450, (trad. it. di G. trenti), Modena-Ferrara 1990. Degli Statuti e Regolamenti del Grande Spedale degl’Infermi di Modena ed opere annesse, Modena 1759. del Piazzo, M., Il carteggio “Medici-Este” dal secolo XV al 1531. Regesti delle lettere conservate negli Archivi di Stato di Firenze e Modena, in «RAS», 34 (1964). del Giudice, c.a., Il catasto geometrico di Maria Beatrice (1820-1824) in Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione, pp. 195-230. del Giudice, c.a., Provvedimenti dei duchi di Modena a favore della agricoltura massese. I canali irrigatori (1840-1856) in Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione, Atti del Convegno, Modena 1980, pp. 153-185. del Vecchio, e., Il crepuscolo della politica estera del Ducato di Modena in Francesco IV e Francesco V duchi di Modena, Atti del convegno, Modena 1992, Modena 1993, pp. 43-72. di Pietro loMBardi, P., Girolamo Tiraboschi, Rimini 1996.
1294
Bibliografia
FaVa, d., La Biblioteca Estense nel suo sviluppo storico, Modena 1925. Fea, a., Il diritto sovrano della S. Sede sopra le valli di Comacchio, Roma 1834. Federzoni, l., Domenico Vandelli e la cartografia del suo tempo in La via Vandelli, strada ducale del ‘700 da Modena a Massa. Dal Frignano alla Garfagnana e al ducato di Massa, a cura di M. PelleGrini - F.M. Pozzi, Modena 1989, pp. 7-16. Federzoni, l., Misure e simboli nella cartografia estense, in La Bona Opinione, pp. 263-276. Federzoni, l., Tre mappe manoscritte di argomento idrografico, opera di Domenico Vandelli, in «Arte. Documento. Rivista di Storia e Tutela dei Beni Culturali», 7 (1993), pp. 415-418. Ferrari, F., Isabella di Savoia, principessa di Modena, Modena 1938 Ferrari, e.- Boccolari, G., Ceramiche nel Ducato Estense dal XVI al XIX secolo, Bologna 1997. Ferriani, d., Luigi Manzini, in La virtù delle arti, p. 268. Finzi, r., Correggio nella storia e nei suoi figli, Reggio Emilia 1968. Finzi,V., Notizie storiche sulla R. Biblioteca Estense di Modena, in «Centralblatt für Bibliothekswesen», 1898, pp. 50-56. Fiorenzi, P., Modena, storia illustrata, Modena 1965. Fiorina, u., Inventario dell’Archivio Falcò Pio di Savoia, Vicenza 1980. Fiorini, V., Alcune lettere di I. Lamberti sul secondo Congresso di Modena in «Rivista del Risorgimento», II (1897), p. 396. Folin, M., Feudatari, cittadini, gentiluomini. Forme di nobiltà negli stati estensi fra Quattro e Cinquecento, (in corso di stampa). Folin, M., Ipotesi di ricerca sugli officiali estensi di Carpi (secoli XVI-XVII), in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi ..., (in corso di stampa). Folin, M., Le cronache a Ferrara e negli Stati estensi (XV-XVI), in Storia di Ferrara,VIII. Folloni, u., Il Trattato di Firenze e la costituzione della Lunigiana Parmense, in «Studi Lunigianesi», I (1971). Fontana, a., La Provincia di Sestola: Documenti di Governo, in «Rassegna Frignanese», 1997. Fontanesi, P., Supplemento alla Biblioteca Modenese del Tiraboschi per ciò che riguarda gli scrittori reggiani tratto dai manoscritti di Prospero Fontanesi e del Conte Achille Crespi aggiuntovi qualche annotazione e correzione da Giuseppe Turri, Reggio Emilia 1873. Fontanini, G., Difesa seconda del dominio temporale della sede apostolica sopra la città di Comacchio, Roma 1711. Fontanini, G., Risposta a varie scritture contro la Santa Sede in proposito di Comacchio, pubblicate dopo il 1711, Roma 1720 Forni, P., I concordati estensi del 1841 e 1851, in «Rivista di storia della Chiesa in Italia», VIII (1954), 3, pp. 356-382. Forni, P., Note intorno ai Concordati Estensi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.VIII, VIII(1956), pp. 148-154.
Bibliografia
1295
Gonzaga d’Este, Firenze 1979. Edizione Nazionale del Carteggio di L.A.Muratori, Firenze 1975-97. erta, M., Aulla e Licciana nei primi anni della dominazione estense, in «Cronaca e storia di Val di Magra», II (1973). erta, M., Aulla nei primi anni della dominazione estense, in «Cronaca e storia di Val di Magra», I (1972). erta, M., Cronaca e storia di Tresana dal 1840 al 1849 e i Governi Provvisori di Alcuni Comuni della media Val di Magra, in «Cronaca e storia di Val di Magra», III/2 (1974). erta, M., Gli Estensi. La Corte di Ferrara, a cura di r. iotti (et al.), Modena 1997. FaBBri, l., Da Firenze a Ferrara: gli Strozzi tra Casa d’Este e antichi legami di sangue, in Alla corte degli Estensi. Filosofia, arte e cultura a Ferrara nei secoli XV e XVI, a cura di M. Bertozzi, Ferrara 1994, pp. 91-108. FaBBri, P.-Verti, r.,Due secoli di teatro per musica a Reggio Emilia. Repertorio cronologico 16451857, Reggio Emilia 1986. FaBBrici, G., Alcune considerazioni sulle fonti documentarie e sulla storia delle Comunità ebraiche di Modena e Carpi (secoli XIV-XVIII), in Le Comunità ebraiche a Modena e a Carpi. Dal medioevo all’età contemporanea, a cura di F. Bonilauri e V. MauGeri, Firenze 1999, pp. 51-65. FaBBrici, G., Alcune osservazioni sul rapporto tra Ebrei ed Estensi tra Basso Medioevo ed Età Moderna (secolo XV - XVII), in «AMDSP- Modena», s. XI, XXI (1999), pp. 143-161. FaBBrici, G., L’archivio dei Gonzaga di Novellara, Bologna 1977-1978. FaBriani, s., Vita di Mons.Giuseppe Baraldi, Modena 1834. Fano, c., Francesco IV: Documenti di vita reggiana, Reggio Emilia 1932. Fano, c., Francesco V: il Risorgimento nel Ducato di Modena e Reggio dal 1848 al 1849, Reggio Emilia 1941. Farioli, e., Antonio Fontanesi, in Arte emiliana dalle raccolte storiche al nuovo collezionismo, a cura di G. Manni- e. neGro- M.Pirondini, Modena 1989, pp. 236-241. Farioli, e., Giuseppe Ugolini, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 194-195. Farioli, e., Prospero Minghetti 1786-1853. Nel laboratorio di un artista neoclassico, Catalogo della mostra, Bologna 1993. Farioli, e., Prospero Minghetti, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 268-269. Farneti, i., L’evoluzione della giustizia a Ferrara (repubblica- ducato - governo pontificio), in «Atti dell’Accademia delle scienze di Ferrara», 35 (1957-58), pp. 79-80. Fasano Guarini, e., Centro e periferia, accentramento e particolarismi, dicotomia o sostanza degli Stati in età moderna, in Origini dello Stato. Processi di formazione statale in Italia fra medioevo ed età moderna, a cura di G. chittolini- a. Molho- P.a. schiera, Bologna 1994, pp. 147-185. Fatica, M., La regolarizzazione dei mendicanti attraverso il lavoro: l’Ospizio dei Poveri di Modena nel Settecento, in «Studi storici», 4 (1982), pp. 756-761.
1296
Bibliografia
Garuti, a.- colli, d., Carpi. Guida storico-artistica, Carpi 1990. Garuti, a.- colli, d., Carpi. Museo Civico. I dipinti, Bologna 1990. Garuti, a.- colli, d., Il monastero di Santa Chiara in Carpi, Carpi 1993. Garuti, a.- colli, d., Il palazzo dei Pio di Savoia nel «Castello» di Carpi. Appunti per la storia edilizia e artistica dell’edificio, Modena 1983. Garuti, a.- colli, d., La dispersione del patrimonio artistico a Carpi durante le soppressioni napoleoniche, in Chiese locali in epoca napoleonica (1789-1823), Atti del convegno, Carpi 1987, pp. 37-53. Garuti, a.- colli, d., Le opere pie raggruppate di Carpi, in Arte e pietà. I patrimoni culturali delle opere Pie, Bologna 1980, pp. 236-242. Garuti, a.- colli, d., Tra arte e artigianato nell’alta valle del Secchia, in d. colli-a. Garuti -r. Pelloni, La Secchia, Modena 1988. GasParini, a., Cesare d’Este e Clemente VIII, Modena 1960. Gazzetti, e.- BarBieri, a., Cardinali vescovi abati nella storia della Diocesi di Modena e Nonantola (secc.IV- XX), S.Pietro in Cariano (VR) 1993. Genealogia dei principi d’Este.Commentario al codice, a cura di e. Milano - M. Bini, Modena 1996. GerMani, M., Dai Malaspina agli Austro-Estensi, s.n.t. GhelFi, c.- Baracchi, o., La comunità ebraica a Modena, Modena 1995. GhelFi, c., Il verde pubblico dalla fine del Settecento alla fine dell’Ottocento, in Natura e cultura urbana a Modena, Catalogo mostra, Modena 1983, pp. 245-323. Gherardi, P.e., Descrizione delle pitture esistenti in Modena nell’estense Ducal Galleria (1744), a cura di G. Bonsanti, Modena 1986. GherPelli, G., L’opera nei teatri di Modena, Modena 1988. GhidiGlia QuintaValle, a., Artisti alla corte di Francesco I d’Este, Modena 1963. Ghidini, a., Il Teatro Comunale Bonifazio Asioli, Correggio 1982. Ghidini, a., Aspetti e vicende del Principato di Correggio nel XVII secolo in Archivi, Territori poteri in area Estense (secc.XVI-XVIII), pp.469-497. Ghidoni, e., Il movimento riformatore e le campagne mirandolesi alla fine del ‘700, in «AMDSPModena», s. X, XII(1977), pp. 179-196. Ghiraldi, G., La Galleria Estense. Doni, lasciti, acquisti. 1884-1990, Modena 1990. Ghiraldi, G., Le chiese della terra di Formigine, in Formigine, un paese,la sua storia,la sua anima, a cura di G. Ferrarini (et al.), Milano 1997, pp. 107-154. Ghiraldi, G., Parva Pictura. Piccola quadreria estense, Catalogo della mostra, Modena 1994. Ghizzoni, M.- Pulini, c., L’archivio storico Comunale di Mirandola come fonte per lo studio della storia locale, in Il patrimonio manoscritto e a stampa dei fondi pubblici mirandolesi in «Quaderni della Bassa Modenese», XII ( 1998), 34, pp. 81-91. Ghizzoni, M., La pietra forte. Carpi: città e cantieri alle fortificazioni (XII-XVIII secolo), Bologna 1997.
Bibliografia
1297
Francescano (Un) al tempo dei lumi. Le opere e i giorni di fra’ Stefano da Carpi (1710-1796), a cura di a. Garuti, Carpi 1996. Franceschini, a., Nuovi documenti relativi ai docenti dello Studio di Ferrara nel sec. XVI, Ferrara 1970. Francesco IV e Francesco V Duchi di Modena. Atti del Convegno, Modena, 3 ottobre 1992, Modena 1993. Francesco V d’austria-este, Memorie di quanto disposi, vidi ed udii dall’11 giugno al 12 luglio 1859, a cura di G. orlandi, Modena 1981. Frascaroli, e., La scuola dei Cadetti Matematici Pionieri. Un politecnico nel Ducato Estense, Modena 1998. FriGo, d., I Gonzaga di Novellara e le relazioni tra gli Stati padani, in I Gonzaga e Novellara, pp. 97-122. Frizzi, a., Memorie per la storia di Ferrara, 5 voll., Ferrara 1847-1848. FuMaGalli, G., L’Arte della legatura alla corte degli Estensi a Ferrara e a Modena dal sec. XVI al XIX, Firenze 1913. FuMaGalli, V., Matilde di Canossa. Potenza e solitudine di una donna del Medioevo, Bologna 1996. Gaddi, P., Intorno all’arte della litografia in Modena, in «Memorie Accad.Scienze, Lett. ArtiModena», III (1861), pp. 3-14. GalaVotti, i., La realizzazione del Palazzo Ducale dal 1658 al 1795 secondo i progetti di Bartolomeo Avanzini, in Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1987 pp. 219-249. GalVani, c., Memorie istoriche intorno la vita di S.A.R. Francesco IV, 4 voll., Modena 1846-1854. GalVani, G., La R.D. Biblioteca Estense sotto il regno di Francesco IV. Nota cronologica, Modena 1846. GaMBerti, d., L’idea di un prencipe et eroe christiano in Francesco I d’Este, Modena 1659. GaMBerti, d., Corona funerale dedicata alla gloriosa ed immortale memoria del Serenissimo prencipe Francesco I d’Este..., Modena 1659. GaMBerti, d., Oratione funerale nelle solenni esequie di Alfonso IV, Modena 1663. GaMBi, l., Stato degli studi sulla produzione cartografica presso la corte degli Este, in G.PaPaGno - a. QuondaM, La corte e lo spazio: Ferrara estense, Roma 1982, pp. 228-231. Gandini, a., Cronistoria dei teatri di Modena dal 1539 al 1871, Modena 1873. Gandini, a., La gioventù di Francesco III duca di Modena, in «Il Muratori», V (1873). Gandini, r., Ceramiche dell’Ottocento: la fabbrica dei Bocelli a Scandiano, in I Rubbiani e la ceramica dell’Italia Unita a Sassuolo, a cura di F. liVerani, Faenza 1983. GarBero, e., I luoghi teatrali nei secoli XVI-XVIII. Dalla Sala delle Commedie al Teatro Vecchio. Lo stanzone per i comici dell’Arte. Il teatro di Cittadella, in Teatro a Reggio Emilia, I, a cura di S. roMaGnoli e e. GarBero, Firenze 1980, I, pp. 85-96. Garuti, a., Bernardino Rossi, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 271-272.
1298
Bibliografia
Grandi, e., Armi e nozze alla corte di Francesco I d’Este, Alessandria 1907. Grandi, t., Ciro Menotti e i suoi compagni. Le vicende politiche dal 1821 al 1831, Bologna 1880. Graziani, G., Il conquisto di Granata. Dedicato al Serenissimo Principe Francesco d’Este duca di Modena..., Modena 1650. GreGori, G.l., Genealogie estensi e falsificazione epigrafica, Roma 1990. GriBaudi, P., Questioni di precedenza fra le corti italiane nel secolo XVI. Contributo alla storia della diplomazia italiana, in «Rivista di scienze storiche», I (1904), IX. GriMaldi, e., Massa Finalese e la sua antica pieve, San Felice sul Panaro 1985. Grossi, l., Pesi e misure del Ducato Estense nel Museo Civico di Arte Medievale e Moderna di Modena, in La Bona opinione, pp. 193-204. Guaitoli, P., Carteggio fra l’Abate Cavaliere Girolamo Tiraboschi e l’Avvocato Eustachio Cabassi di Carpi, in Memorie storiche e documenti sulla città e sull’antico principato di Carpi, VI, Carpi 18941895. Guandalini, G.- Martinelli BraGlia, G., Note su Giovan Battista Codebue (Modena 1567-1606)«eccellente Architetto, Pittor et Scultore», in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XIV(1992), pp. 143-157. Guenzi, a., Il sistema annonario di Carpi alla fine dell’età moderna, in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi. Istituzioni, economia, società e cultura in epoca estense (secc. XVI-XVIII), (Carpi 22-24 ottobre 1998) (in corso di stampa). Guida dell Appennino reggiano, Reggio Emilia 1930. GundersheiMer, W.l., Ferrara estense. Lo stile del potere, Modena 1988. GundersheiMer, W.l., Bartolommeo Goggio: a Feminist in Renaissance Ferrara, in «Renaissance Quarterly», 33 (1980), pp. 175-200. haile, M., Queen Mary of Modena. Her Life and Letters, London 1905. honnacKer, h., L’origine della casa d’Este fornita nell’Orlando furioso di Ludovico Ariosto nelle edizioni del 1516 e del 1521: una genealogia fra leggenda e storia, in «Schifanoia», 17-18 (1997), pp. 125-133. illeVir, P., Modena antica e moderna ossia breve compendio della di lei storia, Bologna 1814. In excelsis. Arte e devozione nell’Appennino Reggiano (XII-XVIII sec.), Catalogo della mostra, a cura di F. Bonilauri - V. MauGieri, Roma 1994. inGeGno Guidi, s., Per la storia del teatro francese in Italia: L.A. Muratori, G.G. Orsi, P. J. Martello, in «La rassegna della Letteratura Italiana», LXXVIII, VII (1974), 1-2, pp. 64-94. Inventario ristretto di Mugnano. Cattalogo delli quadri di Mugnano, a cura di J. Bentini e P. curti, Modena 1994. Inventario (L’) 1771 dell’arredo del Palazzo ducale di Modena, a cura di F. Valenti e P. curti, Modena 1986. Inventario delle statue, vasi ed altre cose di guardaroba del Duca Alfonso II(1584), in Documenti inediti
Bibliografia
1299
GiacoBazzi di Vistarino, l., Passioni, scandali e intrighi nel primo settecento romano e alla corte d’Este, Milano 1959. GiacoBazzi di Vistarino, l., Enrichetta d’Este, duchessa di Parma.Congiure ed intrighi intorno a un trono, Milano 1941. GiaMButi, l., L’abbazia di S. Bartolomeo di Linari dalle origini alla soppressione, in «Società civile e società religiosa in Lunigiana e nel vicino Appennino dal IX al XV secolo», 1986. Gianturco, c.- Mc cricKard, e., Alessandro Stradella (1639-1682): a thematic catalogue of his compositions, Stuyvesant 1991. Gianturco, C., Alessandro Stradella,1639-1682: his life and music, Oxford 1994. GioVanni alBinelli da sestola, Il Cappuccino d’Este, Modena 1647. Giovanni Fontanesi, Alessandro Prampolini, Alfonso Beccaluva,Catalogo mostra, a cura di E. Monducci, Reggio Emilia 1984. GioVannini, c.- tollari, P., Antichi organi italiani.La provincia di Modena, Modena 1991. Giraldi cinzio, G.B., Commentario delle cose di Ferrara et de’ principi da Este, Ferrara 1556. Girolamo Tiraboschi. Miscellanea di studi, a cura di a.r. Venturi, Modena 1997. Girolamo Tiraboschi in “Modena storia”, III (1995), pp. 1-37. Girolamo Tiraboschi (1731-1794). Mostra documentario bibliografica nel secondo centenario della morte, Modena 1996. Gloria (La) e’ l Tempo festeggianti la nascita del Serenissimo Principe di Modana. Armeggiamento a cavallo fatto alla presenza delle Ser.me Altezze di Parma, etc. nel teatro eretto innanzi al Ducal Palazzo nel mese di Febbraio l’anno 1700, Modena 1700. Goldoni, M., La raccolta di legni della Galleria Estense, in I legni incisi, pp.11-29. Gonzaga (I) e Novellara. Geografia e Storia di una Signoria Padana, Atti del Convegno di Studio, Reggio Emilia 1997. Gorani, G., L’Italia nel XVIII secolo, VI, Ducato di Modena e Reggio, a cura di G.caciaGli, Modena 1987. Göschel MePPen, G., Das “Bellum diplomaticum” um Comacchio zu Beginn des 18. Jahrhunderts, Frankfurt am Main 1973. Governo (Al) del Comune. Tremila cinquecento modenesi per la Comunità locale dal XV secolo ad oggi, Appendice documentaria, a cura di M. cattini, Modena 1996. Gozzi, a., Sull’arrivo in Correggio di Sua Altezza Reale Francesco IV Principe Reale d’Ungheria e Boemia Arciduca d’Austria Duca di Modena Reggio e Mirandola, Carpi s.a. Grana, d., L’accademia modenese di Belle Arti, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, VIII(1986), pp. 313-331. Grana, d., Per una storia della pubblica assistemza a Modena, Modena 1991. Grana, d., Gli organi centrali del governo estense nel periodo modenese in «RAS», LV (1995), pp. 304-333.
1300
Bibliografia
liVerani, F., Il Conte Ferrari Moreni e la ceramica nella prima metà dell’Ottocento a Sassuolo, Faenza 1986. liVerani, F., Il graffito estense. Una proposta di studio, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XI(1989), pp. 157-168. liVerani, F., Tracce biografiche di Pietro Lei «Pittore abilissimo di Maioliche«. Sassuolo 1740-1814, in «I Quaderni dell’ Emilceramica», 14 (1991), pp. 3-7. locatelli, F., La fabbrica ducale estense delle artiglierie, Bologna 1985. lodi, l., Immagini della genealogia estense, in L’impresa di Alfonso II. Saggi e documenti sulla produzione artistica a Ferrara nel secondo Cinquecento, Bologna 1987, pp. 151-162. lorusso de leo, F.,in Restauri fra Modena e Reggio,Catalogo mostra, a cura di G. Bonsanti, Modena 1978. lucchi, M., Musica e teatro a Mirandola nel Settecento e nell’Ottocento: documenti, in Mirandola e le terre del basso corso del Secchia dal Medioevo all’Età Contemporanea, II, Modena 1984, pp. 191204. lucchi, M.- chiarelli, a., in Alessandro Stradella a Modena. Atti del Convegno Internazionale di Studi, Modena 1985. Ludovico Ariosto: documenti immagini e fortuna critica, a cura di G. Badini, Roma 1992. Luigi Mainoni e la scultura di primo Ottocento, Catalogo della mostra, Modena 1995. Maestri, a., Accordi segreti fra Rinaldo d’Este duca di Modena ed il marchese di Priè Ambasciatore Cesareo per l’acquisto della Mirandola (1708-1711), Modena 1911. MaGGi, G., Memorie historiche della città di Carpi, Carpi 1707. MaGnanini, V., Memoria sulle cause che produssero la caduta del principato di Correggio, in «AMDSPModena», s. III, VI (1890-91), pp. XXXI-XXXIII; XXXV-XXXVI. MalaGoli, c., Ceto dirigente municipale e rappresentanza politica (1859 - 1995), in Al Governo del Comune, pp. 112-123. Manenti, e., Lo spazio amministrativo centrale. Un’indagine sulla struttura della Camera Marchionale poi Ducale Estense a Ferrara, in La corte e lo spazio: Ferrara estense. Atti del seminario, Ferrara 20-25 ottobre 1980, a cura di G. PaPaGno e a. QuondaM, Roma 1982, pp. 107-116. ManFredi, e., Orazione funebre nelle esequie del Serenissimo Principe Clemente Gianfederigo Cesare d’Este, recitata dal P. Emilio Manfredi della Compagnia di Giesù, Modena 1727. Manicardi, l., Il Convitto Nazionale «Rinaldo Corso« in Correggio. Cenni storico-statistici, Correggio 1909. Manni, e., Di Fulvio Testi diplomatico e della sua ambasceria massima, Modena 1928. Manni, G., I maestri della scagliola in Emilia Romagna e Marche, Modena 1997. Manni, G., La polemica cattolica nel Ducato di Modena (1815-1861), Modena 1968. MantoVi, F., Ricordando Giovanni Spaggiari il contadino intagliatore, in «Reggio Storia», V, 1982, pp. 62-65.
Bibliografia
1301
per servire alla storia dei musei d’Italia, III, Firenze-Roma 1880, pp. 6-22. Inventario generale di tutte le armi e capi diversi componenti l’Armeria nobile di Sua Altezza Serenissima, a cura di l.G. Boccia, Modena 1995. iotti, l., Alfonso Chierici, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 192-193. iotti, l., Domenico Pellizzi, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 200-201. iotti, r., La politica dell’amore, in Gli Estensi, I, La corte di Ferrara, Modena 1997, pp. 147-181. Istruzione, Educazione e Collegio in Correggio dal XVII al XX secolo, a cura di a. Ghidini, Correggio 1984. JacoPetti, J.n.-ruBini, M., Massa e Carrara da Maria Teresa alla costituzione della Repubblica, Cremona 1977. Jander, o., The Cantata in Accademia: Music for the Accademia de’ Dissonanti and their Duke, Francesco II d’Este, in «Rivista Musicale Italiana», 10 (1975), pp. 519-544. Jarrard, a.G., Theaters of power. Francesco I d’Este and the Spectacle of Court life in Modena, (Columbia University 1993), Ann Arbor 1993. KolsKy, s.,’The Good Servant’: Mario Equicola. Court and Courtier in Early Sixteenth Century Italy, in «The Italianist», 6 (1986), pp. 34-60. lancellotti, F., La normativa e la letteratura di diritto processuale civile nel ducato di Modena, Modena 1977. lattes, a., La formazione del codice civile estense, Torino 1912. Lavori preparatori per gli Annali della Tipografia Soliani, a cura di e. Milano, Modena 1986. lecchini, r., Alfonso III Duca di Modena e Reggio, P. Giambattista d’Este cappuccino, Modena 1979. Leggi, proclami, avvisi e disposizioni del Governo provvisorio degli Stati estensi, I, Modena 1814. Legni (I) incisi della Galleria Estense: quattro secoli di stampa nell’Italia settentrionale, Modena 1986. lenzi, d., I teatri, in L’arte del Settecento emiliano. Architettura, scenografia, pittura di paesaggio, Catalogo mostra, Bologna 1980, pp. 106-107. leonelli, a - Montanari, G.c. - BarBieri, a., Storia dell’Arcidiocesi di Modena-Nonantola, 2 voll., Modena 1997. leonelli, a., La storia di Modena narrata ai ragazzi di tutte le età, Parma 1965. Leopoldo Nobili e la cultura scientifica del suo tempo, Atti del convegno di studi, Reggio Emilia 25-27 ottobre 1985, a cura di G. tarozzi, Bologna s.d. Lettere all’artista. Testimonianze d’arte nell’Ottocento dall’epistolario di Adeodato Malatesta, a cura di l. riVi, Modena 1998. Lettere di Girolamo Tiraboschi a Padre Ireneo Affò, a cura di c. Frati, Modena 1895. Libri di immagini, disegni e incisioni di Giovanni Guerra (Modena 1544-Roma 1618), a cura di e. cecchi Gattolin, Modena 1978.
1302
Bibliografia
Carpi 1998, pp. 40-41. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Vicende della bottega artigiana del fabbro Giambattista Malagoli e i suoi riflessi nell’idea di decoro edilizio della Modena di Francesco III e Ercole III, in «Bollettino dei Musei ferraresi», 8 (1978), pp. 75-90. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Ottocento e Novecento a Modena nella Raccolta d’Arte della Provincia, Modena 1997, pp. 76-77. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Dal Barocco al Rococò. Note su alcuni palazzi modenesi, in G. Bertuzzi, Il rinnovamento edilizio a Modena nella seconda metà del Settecento, III, Modena 1983, pp. 135191. Martinelli, r., La vicaria di Castiglione, in Terre di confine, pp. 73-98. Masina, a., La comunità ebraica a Finale nel Seicento, Verona 1988. Masoni, V., Dall’età napoleonica all’Unità d’Italia in Correggio identità e storia di una città, Parma 1991, pp. 117-143. Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione. Il governo di Maria Beatrice Cybo d’Este, Atti del convegno, Massa e Carrara 31 agosto-2 settembre 1979, Modena 1980. Massinelli a.M., Gli artisti carpigiani, in Scagliola, l’arte della pietra di luna, Roma 1997, pp. 93-136. Materiali per la storia urbana di Carpi, a cura di a. Garuti - F. MaGnanini- V. saVi, Carpi 1977. Matrimonio (Il) reale di Maria di Modena/The Royal Wedding of Mary of Modena. Testi e immagini dall’Inghilterra/Words and Pictures from England (1674-1688), a cura di r.seVeri, Modena 1993, pp. 7-26. Matteucci, a.M., Ai margini del giardino all’italiana: originalità e tradizione nella cultura estense di Gaspare Vigarani in Il giardino storico all’Italiana, Atti del Convegno, Saint Vincent 22-26 aprile 1991, a cura di F. nuVolari, Milano 1992, pp. 67-76. Matteucci, a.M., Il Palazzo Ducale nel dibattito sulle residenze di corte, in Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena, pp. 83-127. Matteucci, a.M., Per il Palazzo Ducale di Sassuolo, in «Q.B.Sassuolo e la sua storia», 1(1993), pp. 67-74. Mazza Monti, M.V., Le duchesse di Modena, Modena 1977. Memoria al direttorio della Repubblica Cisalpina per la Provincia di Garfagnana, Modena 1797, pp. 16-17. Mercati, a., Accordo tra Pio IX e Francesco V duca di Modena su beni ecclesiastici (1857) in Raccolta di concordati, pp. 876-880. Mercati, a., Raccolta di concordati su materie ecclesiastiche tra la Santa Sede e le autorità civili, vol. I(1098-1914),Concordato tra Gregorio XVI e Francesco IV duca di Modena sul foro e amministrazione dei beni ecclesiastici (1841) Roma 1954, pp. 739-747. Merendoni, a.G., La cultura del duello nel cinquecento in Italia prima del Concilio Ecumenico di Trento (1563) ed il marchese Alberico 1° Cybo-Malaspina in Alberico 1° Cybo-Malaspina, pp.
Bibliografia
1303
Manzotti , F., Alcuni aspetti della politica economico-sociale di Francesco IV e Francesco V d’Este a Reggio, in «Rassegna Storica del Risorgimento», XLIV (1957), II-III. Manzotti , F., Ferdinando Asioli artista e patriota, in Asioliana, Modena 1957, pp. 8-17. Manzotti , F., Il Duca Francesco I D’Este (1629-1658), Modena 1992. Manzotti , F., La fine del Principato di Correggio nelle relazioni italo-imperiali del periodo italiano della guerra dei trent’anni, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.VIII, VI (1954), pp. 43-59. Marcelli, u., Aspetti della Restaurazione nel ducato di Massa e Carrara in Massa Carrara nella Restaurazione. Il governo di Maria Beatrice Cybo-d’Este, pp. 13-44. Marchetti, l., Il Trattato di Firenze del 1844 in «Annali di Scienze Politiche dell’ Università di Pisa», 1937. Marini, G., Disegni e stampe nelle raccolte di Modena e Reggio, in La pittura veneta negli Stati Estensi, Modena 1996, pp. 393-415. Marini, l., Lo Stato Estense, in Storia d’Italia, I Ducati Padani, Trento e Trieste, XVII, a cura di G. Galasso, Torino 1979 (rist. Torino 1987). Marini, l., Per una storia dello Stato estense, I,Dal Quattrocento all’ultimo Cinquecento, Bologna 1973. Marri, F.- lieBer, M., Muratori und Deutschland, Frankfurt am Main 1997, pp. 17-21. Marri, F., La dedica delle ‘Antiquitates Italicae’, in Corte, buon governo,pubblica felicità.Politica e coscienza civile nel Muratori, Atti III giornata studi muratoriani, Modena 1986, pp. 71-86. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Contributi per una storia dell’effimero nel ducato modenese tra Sei e Settecento: Tommaso Bezzi, in Aspetti e problemi del Settecento modenese, II, Modena 1983, pp. 131-167. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Contributi per una storia dell’effimero nel Ducato Modenese tra Sei e Settecento: Tommaso Bezzi, in Aspetti e problemi del Settecento modenese, pp. 142-145. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Documenti per una storia dell’arredo nel Settecento Estense: il Progetto della Biblioteca Ducale, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, VI(1984), pp. 177-195. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Due miniature di Ippolito Bianchini Ciarlini, pittore carpigiano di primo Ottocento, in «Quaderni della Bassa Modenese», 28 (1995). Martinelli BraGlia, G., Giuseppe Maria Soli, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 37-39. Martinelli BraGlia, G., La Galleria di Francesco Stringa nel Palazzo Ducale di Modena, (in corso di stampa). Martinelli BraGlia, G., La nuova dogana: Pietro Termanini e l’architettura illuministica, in Il palazzo Comunale di Modena, a cura di G. Guandalini, Modena 1985, pp. 183-185. Martinelli BraGlia, G., La pittura dell’Ottocento in Emilia Romagna, in La pittura in Italia. L’Ottocento, Milano 1991. Martinelli BraGlia, G., La vicenda artistica, in La Chiesa di San Paolo a Modena. Otto secoli di storia, a cura di G. Martinelli BraGlia, Modena 1998, pp. 92-93. Martinelli BraGlia, G., Un «macchiaiolo« a Carpi. Albano Lugli (1834-1914),Catalogo mostra,
1304
Bibliografia
Monducci, e.- nironi, V., Arte e storia nelle Chiese reggiane scomparse, Reggio Emilia 1976. Monducci, e.- nironi, V., Il duomo di Reggio Emilia, Reggio Emilia 1984. MontaGnani, r.,Giovan Battista Laderchi nel governo estense(1572-1618),in «AMDSP- Modena», s.X, XII(1977), pp. 101-153. Montalcini, c., Le Assemblee della Repubblica Cisalpina, Bologna 1917. Montecchi, G., Aziende tipografiche, stampatori e librai a Modena dal Quattrocento al Settecento, Modena 1988 Montecchi, G., L’azienda tipografica dei Soliani tra Seicento e Settecento, in I legni incisi della Galleria Estense, pp. 35-57. Montecuccoli, r., Aforismi dell’arte bellica, Milano 1987. Mor, c.G.- di Pietro, P., Storia dell’Università di Modena, 2 voll., Firenze 1975. Mor, c.G., La condizione giuridica dell’Università di Modena dal 1682 al 1773, in «AMDSPModena», s.III, 2 (1949), pp.148-157. Morandi, F., Luigi Manzini, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 196-199. Morolli, G., Giuseppe Maria Soli, architetto modenese (1745-1822), in Architettura in EmiliaRomagna dall’Illuminismo alla Restaurazione, Firenze 1977, pp. 116-117. Moti (I) dell’Animo. Passioni, affetti e fisiognomica nell’arte dell’Ottocento,Catalogo mostra, Modena 1998. Muratori, l.a., Della Pubblica Felicità oggetto de’ buoni Principi, Venezia 1749. Muratori, l.a., Delle antichità estensi continuazione o sia parte seconda, composta e dedicata all’Altezza Serenissima di Francesco III Duca di Modena, Modena 1740. Muratori, l.a., Epistolario, a cura di M. caMPori, 14 voll., Modena 1901-22. Muratori, l.a., Opere di L.A. Muratori, a cura di G. Falco e F. Forti, Milano-Napoli 1964. Muratori, l.a., Rudimenti di filosofia per il Principe ereditario di Modena, in Scritti inediti, a cura della R. accad. scienze, lett. arti-Modena, Modena 1872. Muratori, l.a., Delle antichità estensi ed italiane, 2 voll., Modena 1717-1740. Muzzarelli, M.G., Ferrara, ovvero un porto placido e sicuro tra XV e XVI secolo in Vita e cultura ebraica nello Stato Estense. Atti del I convegno internazionale di studi, a cura di E. FreGni, M. Perani, Nonantola 1993, pp. 235-257. Muzzioli, G., Modena, Bari 1993. naMias, a., Storia di Modena e dei paesi circostanti, Modena 1894 (Rist. anast. Bologna 1969). nannini, M.c.,Un delitto di Cesare d’Este, in «Bollettino Camera di Commercio di Modena», 5 (1960). Natura e cultura urbana a Modena, Catalogo della mostra, Modena 1983. neiGeBauer, G., Die Bibliotheken und Archive zu Modena, in «Blatt zur Serageum», 23 (1860), pp. 177-182.
Bibliografia
1305
263-283. Messori roncaGlia, M.t., Il Palazzo Estense di Rivalta, in «Cronache d’arte», 1928. Messori roncaGlia, M.t., Incontro di Ercole III coi Francesi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. VIII, III(1950), pp.74-81. Micotti, a., Descrittione cronologica della Garfagnana Provincia di Toscana, a cura di P. Bacci, Lucca 1980. MiGliorini, l.,Cronistoria della Garfagnana dal 1631 al 1800, Castelnuovo Garfagnana 1900. Milano, e., Biblioteca Estense Modena, Firenze 1987. Milano, e., Casa d’Este dall’anno Mille al 1598, in Gli Estensi, I, La corte di Ferrara, a cura di r. iotti, Modena 1997, pp. 9-94. Milano, e., Genealogia e genealogie. Documenti per una storia della casa d’Este, Commentario al codice, Modena 1996. Milano, e., Il Mappamondo catalano Estense. [Commentario al facsimile], Dietikon - Zurigo 1995. Milano, e., La carta del Cantino, Modena 1991. Milano, e., La Charta del navicare. [Commentario al facsimile], Torino 1994. Milano, e., Xilografia dal Quattrocento al Novecento, percorso storico-artistico sui fondi della Biblioteca Estense, Modena 1993. Miniature e disegni nei manoscritti della Biblioteca Estense (secoli X-XX), Catalogo mostra, Modena 1984. Missere Fontana, F., Relazione sulla schedatura del fondo G. Soli. L’Archivio di famiglia, in «Memorie Accadem.Scienze, Lett. Arti-Modena», s.VII, VIII, 1990-91, pp. XXXIIIXXXVII ; s. VII, IX, 1991-92, pp. XXXVII-LVIII. Mitchell, B., 1598. A year of Pageantry in Late Medieval Ferrara, Binghampton-New York 1990. Modelli d’arte e di devozione. Adeodato Malatesta 1806-1891,Catalogo mostra, Modena-Reggio Emilia 1998, Milano 1998. Modena ducale. Schede di lavoro(La scuola e i musei civici), a cura di M. arMandi, M. canoVa, d. nasi, Modena 1978. Modena. Atti di amministrazione generale del Comune di Modena, 1796-1853: inventario, a cura di c. liotti, P. roMaGnoli, Modena 1995. Modena. Magistrato di acque e strade: inventario, a cura di G. dotti Messori, Modena 1992. Modena.Vicende e protagonisti, a cura di G. Bertuzzi, Bologna 1971. Mondaini, G., La questione di precedenza tra il duca Cosimo I de’ Medici e Alfonso II d’Este, Firenze 1898. Monducci, e.- Badini, G., Matteo Maria Boiardo: la vita nei documenti del suo tempo, con la partecipaz. di G. trenti, Modena 1997.
1306
Bibliografia
menti ed ornato di Modena, Parma 1854 (rist. Modena 1980). Pancaldi, e.- roncaGlia, G., La cappella musicale del Duomo di Modena in «AMDSP-Modena», n.s., 2(1943), pp. 179-198; s. 8, 1(1948), pp. 90-157. Panciroli, G., Storia della città di Reggio, Reggio Emilia 1848. Panini, G., Palazzo Ducale e dintorni, Modena 1997. Panini, G., Porta S.Agostino e dintorni. Fotocronache modenesi, I, Modena 1993. Panizzi, a., Documenti riguardanti il governo degli Austro - Estensi , Modena 1859. Pantanelli, G., La detenzione del principe erditario Ercole III d’Este, Modena 1901. PaPaGno, G., Le piccole corti padane tra la loro identità storica e il mondo attuale, in I Gonzaga e Novellara, pp. 11-40. PaPotti, F.i., Annali o Memorie Storiche della Mirandola, 2 voll., Mirandola 1876-77. Paradisi, a., Nel solenne aprimento dell’Università di Modena, Modena 1772. Pardi, G., La Suppellettile dei palazzi estensi in Ferrara nel 1436, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», XIX(1908),1, pp. 5-181. Pardi, G., Lo Studio di Ferrara nei secoli XV e XVI con documenti inediti, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», XIV(1903). Pardi, G., Sulle cause della devoluzione di Ferrara alla Santa Sede, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», XXIV(1922). Parisi, a.,L.Riccoboni (a proposito di un carteggio inedito con L.A. Muratori), in «AMDSP-Modena», s. VII, VIII(1933), pp. 234-276. ParMiGGiani, l., Mille anni. Lo sviluppo urbanistico di Correggio dalle origini agli inizi del XX secolo., Correggio 1994. Patrimonio (Il) storico artistico della Congregazione di Carità in Modena, Modena 1920. Pecoraro, M.- Garuti, a., L’assistenza a Carpi dal Trecento ai giorni nostri, Modena 1997. Pecoraro, M., Ciro Menotti, un uomo che fece l’Italia, Modena 1996. Pecoraro, M., Le istituzioni ospedaliere di Carpi nei secoli, Mantova 1981. PelleGrinetti, G., La Garfagnana nel Dipartimento delle Alpi Apuane (1797-1798), in «AMDSPModena», s.XI, VII(1985), pp. 255-278. PelleGrini, M.-Pozzi, F.M., La via Vandelli, strada ducale del ‘700 da Modena a Massa. Dal Frignano alla Garfagnana e al ducato di Massa, Modena 1989. PePe, l., La cultura scientifica e l’Università, in Storia illustrata di Ferrara, II, a cura di F. Bocchi, Milano 1987, pp. 609-624. Piccinini, F., Antonio Simonazzi, in La virtù delle arti, pp. 214-217. Piccinini, G., Francesco d’Este e Aglae d’Orleans nelle cronache reggiane del tempo, Reggio Emilia 1941.
Bibliografia
1307
oGniBene, G., Le relazioni della Casa d’Este coll’estero, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.V, III (1904), pp. 223-315. oGniBene, G., Una missione del conte Fulvio Testi alla corte di Spagna, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. III, IV (1886), pp. 1-168. orlandi, G., «Quelle fetenti case de li artigiani poveri«. Condizioni igieniche e situazione sanitaria a Carpi negli anni 1793-1794, in «Quaderni della Bassa Modenese.Storia, tradizione, ambiente», 14, 1988, pp. 45-58. orlandi, G., I religiosi nella Diocesi di Modena fra ‘700 e ‘800, Frosinone 1993. orlandi, G., Le campagne modenesi fra Rivoluzione e Restaurazione (1790-1815), Modena 1967. orlandi, G., Liturgia, agiografia e politica nel Ducato di Modena tra Sei e Settecento, in «Lateranum», 47 (1991), pp. 471-513. orlandi, G., Per la storia della massoneria nel Ducato di Modena dalle origini al 1755, Modena 1981. orlandi, G., I religiosi nella diocesi di Modena tra ‘700 e ‘800, in Severino Fabriani nel bicentenario della nascita: il suo tempo e l’educazione dei sordomuti, Atti del Convegno di studi, Modena, 16-17 ottobre 1992, Modena 1994. orlandi, G., La Compagnia di Gesù a Modena, al tempo di Girolamo Tiraboschi, in «Modena. Storia», 3 (1995), pp. 32-37. orlandi, G., Liturgia, agiografia e politica nel Ducato di Modena tra Sei e Settecento, in «Lateranum», 47 (1991), pp. 471-513. P. Paolucci, Garfagnana Illustrata, Modena 1720. P. GioVanni da sestola, Del cappuccino d’Este che fu nel secolo il ser.mo Alfonso III, Modena 1646. Pacciani, r., Temi e strutture narrative dei festeggiamenti nunziali estensi a Modena nel Seicento, in Barocco romano e Barocco italiano, pp. 204-216. PaGani, G., Le Pitture e sculture di Modena, Modena 1770. PaGella, e., Gli strumenti scientifici del Museo Civico d’Arte Medievale e Moderna di Modena, in Instrumenta, Il patrimonio storico e scientifico italiano: una realtà straordinaria, Atti del convegno di studi, Bologna 10-11 marzo 1990, a cura di G. draGoni, Bologna 1991, pp. 141-145. Palazzo (Il) Ducale di Modena: sette secoli di uno spazio cittadino, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1987. Palazzo (Il) Ducale, a cura di W. Baricchi, Reggio Emilia 1989. Palazzo (Il) Carandini di Modena, a cura di G. Bertuzzi, Modena 1987. Palazzo (Il) Comunale di Modena. Le sedi, la città, il contado, a cura di G. Guandalini, Modena 1985. Palazzo (Il) Ducale di Modena: Regia mole maior animus, a cura di e.corradini e e. Garzillo, Milano 1999. PalMieri, a., Memorie dall’anno 1738 al 1796 per servire alla storia delle fabbriche, restauri, abbelli-
1308
Bibliografia
Pucci, l., Lineamenti di una borghesia in nero: mercanti, usurai e contrabbandieri a Modena nella seconda metà del Settecento, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XIV(1992), pp. 259-276. Pucci, l., Aspetti e problemi relativi alla povertà a Modena tra Settecento e Ottocento, in «AMDSPModena», s. XI, III(1981), pp. 165-180. Pucci, l., Economia e società del Settecento Modenese, in Storia Illustrata di Modena, II, pp. 661-680. Pucci, l., Il processo Venturini (1777-80).Dalla rivolta fiscale ai diritti del cittadino, in «AMDSPModena», s.XI, XVII (1995), pp. 301-340. Pucci, l., Il processo Venturini (1777-80).Dalla rivolta fiscale ai diritti del cittadino, in «AMDSPModena», s.XI, XVII (1995), pp. 301-340. Pucci, l., Ludovico Ricci, Dall’arte del buon governo alla finanza moderna (1742-1799), Milano 1971. Pucci, l., Mercanti ed economisti tra Sette e Ottocento. Aspetti e problemi, in «Il pensiero economico moderno», X, 4 (1990). PuGlia, a., Elogio del Cav. Prof. Leopoldo Nobili, in «Memorie Accad.Scienze, Lett. ArtiModena», XII, 1871, pp. 50-51. Puliatti, P., La fortuna grafica della «Secchia rapita» di Alessandro Tassoni, Modena-Milano 1965. QuattroFrati, F.M., Vita del Venerabile Servo di Dio F. Pietro Gazzetti eremita modonese, Modena 1691. raBetti, a., Modena d’una volta, Roma 1936. Raccolta ufficiale di leggi, decreti e proclami, 4 voll., Modena 1859-60. raFFo MaGGini, o., L’Accademia dei Rinnovati e la censura durante il governo di Francesco IV e di Francesco V in «Annuario della Biblioteca Civica di Massa», 1987-1988, pp. 238-243. raFFo MaGGini, o., L’istituzione a Massa Ducale della Congregazione delle Figlie di Gesù per le scuole di Carità presso il conservatorio di S. Luigi di Volpigliano (1841) in Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione, cit., pp.255-268. raFFo MaGGini, o., L’istituzione della Congregazione dei Filippini a Massa Ducale nel 1844 in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XV (1996), pp. 245-252. raFFo MaGGini, o., Le fonti archivistiche relative a Massa, Carrara e Montignoso durante il principato dei Baciocchi (1806-1814) censite nell’ambito del territorio: analisi e loro utilizzazione in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XII (1990), pp. 217-230. raFFo MaGGini, o., Ludovico Ariosto, Commissario generale della Garfagnana e Alfonso 1° d’Este, duca di Ferrara (1522-1525) in La Garfagnana, storia, cultura, arte, Atti del Convegno di studi, Castelnuovo di Garfagnana, 12-13 settembre 1992, Modena 1993, pp. 113-122. raFFo MaGGini, o., Niccolao Giorgini Prefetto di Massa (1807-1809), in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XVIII(1996), pp. 299-307. raGazzi, c., Giuseppe Campi, patriota e letterato sanfeliciano dell’800, Modena 1988. raGazzi, c., L’attività lessicografica di Giuseppe Campi. Dagli “Esercizi di lingua” alla collaborazione
Bibliografia
1309
Piccinini, G., L’invasione spagnola dello Stato Estense e l’assedio di Reggio (1655), Reggio Emilia 1925. Piccioli, c., Gli agri marmiferi del comune di Carrara, Carrara 1956. Piccioli, c., L’ordinamento giuridico degli Stati di Massa e Carrara dopo la Restaurazione (18151829) in Massa e Carrara nella Restaurazione... cit., pp. 305-331. Piccioli, c., Riflessi dell’Illuminismo giuridico nel ducato di Massa e Carrara in Carrara ed il marmo… cit., pp. 71-83. PiGna, G.B., Historia de’ Principi d’Este, Venezia 1533. PiGozzi, M., I teatri, i palazzi, le chiese, in In forma di festa, Reggio Emilia 1985, pp. 49-51. PiGozzi, M., L’edilizia pubblica nel Ducato Estense da Francesco III a Ercole III. La laicizzazione della scena urbana, in L’edilizia pubblica nella città dell’illuminismo, a cura di G. siMoncini, Firenze 2000. PiGozzi, M., I disegni di architettura nelle collezioni dell’Archivio di Stato di Reggio Emilia: Domenico Marchelli (1764-1832), in Il disegno di architettura, Atti del convegno, a cura di P. carPeGGiani e l. Patetta, Milano 1989, pp. 45-50. Pilot, a., Don Cesare d’Este e la satira, in «Ateneo Veneto», XXXV, 2 (1907). Pinelli, i., Isabella di Savoia d’Este nerlle corti Estense e Sabauda, Vasto 1924. Pirondini, M., Arte del legno nell’Appennino reggiano (secoli XVII e XVIII), Reggio Emilia 1978. Pistoni, G., Pistoni G., Il seminario metropolitano di Modena, Modena 1953. Pistoni, G., L’attività missionaria nelle Diocesi di Modena e Nonantola, Modena 1967. Pistoni, G., Un ministro di Francesco III: Felice Antonio Bianchi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, VI (1984), pp. 155-176. Planelli, a., Dell’opera in musica, a cura di F. deGrada, Fiesole 1981. Plessi, G. - Badini G., Repertorio archivistico per i territori ex estensi, Bologna 1977. Poesie liriche del cavaliere Fulvio Testi all’Altezza Sereniss.ma del Prin.e Alfonso d’Este, Modena 1627. Poni, c., Aspetti e problemi dell’agricoltura modenese dall’età delle riforme alla fine della restaurazione, in Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena, cit. Prandi, a., Il patrimonio fondiario dei Pio nello “Stato” di Carpi, in Società, politica e cultura a Carpi ai tempi di Alberto III Pio, II, Padova 1981, pp. 470-502. Pratissoli, V., Dalla dominazione estense alla fine dell’antico regime: istituzioni, cultura e società, in Correggio identità e storia di una città, a cura di V. Masoni, Parma 1991, pp. 103-114. Primi (I) anni della Restaurazione nel Ducato di Modena, Modena 1981. PrinziValli, V., La devoluzione di Ferrara alla Santa Sede secondo una relazione inedita di Camillo Capilupi, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», X (1898), pp. 120-333 ProVerBio, e.- tucci P., Giovan Battista Amici costruttore di telescopi e cannocchiali acromatici, in «Physis», XXX, 1993, 1, p. 146.
1310
Bibliografia
riGhi Guerzoni, l., Il marchese Tacoli e la manifattura di San Possidonio nel Ducato Estense in «I Quaderni dell’Emilceramica», 14, 1992, pp. 3-19. riGhi Guerzoni, l., Note sulla Massoneria nel Ducato Estense nei primi anni della Restaurazione, in I primi anni della Restaurazione nel Ducato di Modena, Modena 1981. riGhi, c., L’Inquisizione ecclesiastica a Modena nel ‘700 in Formazione e controllo dell’opinione pubblica a Modena nel ‘700, a cura di a. Biondi, Modena 1986. rinaldi, a., La Padania tra arretratezza e modernizzazione. Le campagne modenesi dalla fine del ‘700 all’Unità nazionale, Bologna 1995. Rivoluzione Francese e società modenese, Mirandola 1990. roBinet, a., Le séjour de G.W.Leibniz à Modène, in «Memorie Accad. Nazion.Scienze Lett. e Arti-Modena», s.VI, XXV (1983), pp. 267-310. rodolico, n., L’abdicazione di Alfonso III d’Este, Bologna 1901. rolKer, r., Nobiltà e Comune a Modena: potere e amministrazione nei secoli 12. e 13., Modena 1997. roMBaldi, o., Aspetti e problemi di un secolo di governo estense a Modena e a Reggio Emilia. Da Alfonso IV a Rinaldo I (1658-1737), Modena 1995. roMBaldi, o., Cesare d’Este al governo dei ducati estensi (1598-1628), Modena 1992. roMBaldi, o., Correggio città e Principato, Modena 1983. roMBaldi, o., Gli Estensi al governo di Reggio dal 1523 al 1859 (ricerche), Reggio Emilia 1959. roMBaldi, o., I Ducati estensi dal 1788 al 1796, in «Contributi», VI (1982), 11-12, pp.139-263; pp. 251-254. roMBaldi, o., Il duca Francesco I d’Este (1629-1658), Modena 1992. roMBaldi, o., L’economia dei territori nei ducati estensi, in Reggio e i Territori Estensi dall’Antico Regime all’Età Napoleonica, Atti del Convegno di Studi, 18-19-20 marzo 1977, a cura di M. BerenGo e s. roMaGnoli, I, Parma 1979, pp. 77-78. roMBaldi, o., L’istruzione superiore in Reggio dal 1750 al 1861, Reggio Emilia 1955. roMBaldi, o., La Lega austro-estense-parmigiana in Aspetti e problemi del Risorgimento a Modena cit., pp. 301-336. roMBaldi, o., La Repubblica Cispadana, Modena 1997. roMBaldi, o., Mirandola dai Pico agli Estensi: problemi, in Mirandola e le terre del basso corso del Secchia dal Medioevo all’età contemporanea, I, Modena 1984. roMBaldi, o., Rapporti politico-amministrativi tra Modena e Reggio nella vita teatrale, in Teatri a Reggio Emilia, 2 voll., a cura di s. roMaGnoli- e. GerBero, Firenze 1980. roMBaldi, o., Ricerche sulla storia del ducato di Reggio dal 1523 al 1859, in «Annuario 1957-1958 del Liceo-Ginnasio L.Ariosto», Reggio Emilia 1959, pp. 9-10. roMBaldi, o., Stato e società nel Ducato Estense. Contributi di studio, in Aspetti e problemi del Settecento modenese, I, pp. 13-98.
Bibliografia
1311
al Tommaseo-Bellini, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, V(1983), pp. 272-323. raGGi, o., Modena ne’ suoi monumenti antichi e moderni preceduta da un sommario della sua storia dalle origini fino al 1860, Modena 1869. raGGi, P.l., Il Convento dei Cappuccini in Castelnuovo di Garfagnana, in La Garfagnana storia cultura e arte cit., pp. 123-140. ranzani, c.,Veridico racconto dell’origine, progressi, et miracoli della Madonna di Reggio, Modena 1666. reGGi, G.l., Ceramica a Carpi dal XV al XVII secolo nelle civiche collezioni, Catalogo mostra, Imola 1981. Reggio e i Territori Estensi dall’Antico Regime all’Età Napoleonica, a cura roMaGnoli, Parma 1979.
di
M. BerenGo e s.
Regolamento dell’Università degli Studi di Ercole III, Modena 1780. Regolamento pei Giusdicenti, in Collezione delle leggi, costituzioni, editti, proclami per gli Stati Estensi, II, Modena 1815. Relatione de’ funerali solenni celebrati nel tempio di S. Domenico in Modena per ordine di Sua Altezza Serenissima il dignor Duca Francesco III gloriosamente regnante alla fu Serenissima Signora Duchessa Carlotta Aglae Borbone d’Orleans d’Este amatissima sua consorte, Modena 1761. Relazione dello Stato di Ferrara di Orazio Della Rena.1589, a cura di G.aGnelli, in «AMDSPFerrara», 8 (1896), pp. 245-322. ricci, G., Cenni storici sul territorio già estense di Aulla, patria dei Nardi, in Biagio e Anacarsi Nardi, patrioti del Risorgimento, La Spezia 1983. ricci, l., Riforma degli Istituti Pii della Città di Modena, Milano 1805. ricci, l., Corografia dei territori di Modena, Reggio e degli altri stati già appartenenti alla casa d’Este, Modena 1806 (rist. 1988). ricci, M., Il libro e il monumento: miniature ed iscrizioni per la gloria degli Estensi, in Gli Estensi. La corte di Ferrara cit., pp. 233-278. riccò, a., La stampa naturale perfezionata da Felice Riccò, Modena 1873. riccoMini, e., Ordine e vaghezza. La scultura in Emilia nell’età barocca, Bologna 1972. riccoMini, e., Vaghezza e furore. La scultura del Settecento in Emilia e Romagna, Bologna 1977. Ricerche archeologiche nel Castello della Rocca di Finale Emilia,Catalogo mostra, a cura di s. Gelichi, Finale Emilia 1987. Riforma (La) degli Istituti Pii della città di Modena, Modena 1788. Riforma delle Opere Pie di Reggio ordinate da Ercole III, Reggio Emilia 1789. riGhi Guerzoni, l., “Al Padre ottimo della Patria, al restauratore della pubblica felicità”: il monumento equestre di Francesco III in Modena capitale, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XIX (1997), pp. 221-244. riGhi Guerzoni, l., Giuseppe Fantaguzzi, in La virtù delle arti cit., pp. 46-47.
1312
Bibliografia
Archivi, territori, poteri in area estense (secc.XVI-XVIII)…cit., pp. 65-80. santini, G., Lo Stato Estense tra riforme e rivoluzione, Milano 1987. Il Santuario della Madonna della Ghiara a Reggio Emilia, a cura di a. Bacchi e M. Mussini, Torino 1996. sardi, G., Libro delle historie ferraresi, Ferrara 1556. scaraVelli, i., Il carteggio Muratori-Leibnitz e gli antecedenti di un’edizione critica, in «AMDSPModena», s XI, 19(1997), pp. 367-395. schenetti, M., Storia di Sassuolo centro della valle del Secchia, Modena 1966. schenK, e., Osservazioni sulla scuola istrumentale modenese del sec. XVII, in «Memorie Accad. Scienze, Lett. Arti-Modena», s.5, 10(1952), sez. III, pp. 3-30. sciPione, c., Modena nelle Lettere, nelle Arti, nelle Scienze, Grottaferrata 1911. Scritti inediti di L. A. Nuratori, a cura di c. Foucard, Bologna 1880. Sculture a corte. Terrecotte, marmi, gessi della Galleria Estense dal XVI al XIX secolo, Catalogo mostra,Vignola 1996, a cura di J. Bentini, Modena 1996. secco suardo, G., Lo Studio di Ferrara a tutto il XV secolo. Indagini […] corredate da documenti inediti, in «AMDSP-Ferrara», s. I, 6(1894), pp. 25-294. selVelli c., Laura dei Martinozzi di Fano, duchessa estense di Modena e madre di una regina Stuarda, Fano 1948. seMPer, h.- schulze, F.o.- Barth, W., Carpi una sede principesca del Rinascimento, a cura di l. Giordano, trad. di a. d’aMelio e a.e. Werdehausen, Pisa 1999. serra, G., La peste dell’anno 1630 nel Ducato di Modena, Modena 1960. seVeri, r., Accentramento e divisione dei poteri in alcune riforme politico-amministrative di Francesco III e di Ercole III d’Este (1757-1780), in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, 8 (1986), pp. 339-366. seVeri, s. Modena nel giudizio dei viaggiatori, in Storia illustrata di Modena, II, a cura di P. Golinelli, G. Muzzioli, Milano 1990, pp. 781-800. sForza, G., Contributo alla vita di Giovanni Fantoni, Genova 1906. sForza, G., Il dittatore di Modena Biagio e Anacarsi Nardi e il suo nipote Anacarsi, Milano-Napoli, 1916. sForza, G., Il generale Rusca a Lucca e la sollevazione della Garfagnana e di Carrara negli anni 17961797 in «Il Risorgimento Italiano», XV, III-IV, pp. 31-32. sForza, G., La rivoluzione del 1831 nel ducato di Modena.Studi e documenti, Roma-Milano 1909. sForza, G., Le «Memorie storiche di Varano« scritte da Giovanni Sforza, in «Giornale Storico della Lunigiana», XXII-XXIII, 1971-1972. sForza, G., La rivoluzione del ‘31 studiata nelle carte segrete del R. Archivio di Stato di Massa in «Nuova Antologia», s. III, XLIV (1893), p. 461. silinGardi, G. - BarBieri, a., Enciclopedia modenese, Verona 1994. silVestro, F., Un quadro di Alfonso Chierici: “Lo studio del pittore”, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI,
Bibliografia
1313
roMBaldi, o., Storia di Novellara, Reggio Emilia 1968. roMBaldi, o., Contributo alla conoscenza della storia economica dei Ducati Estensi dal 1771 all’Età Napoleonica, Parma 1964. roMBaldi, o., Il Seminario Collegio e l’Università di Reggio Emilia (1750-1758), in «Il pescatore reggiano», 1981. roncaGlia, c., Statistica generale degli Stati Estensi, 2 voll., Modena 1849-1850. roncaGlia, G., La musica alla corte estense dal 1707 alla costituzione del Regno d’Italia in «AMDSPModena», s.X, 1(1966), pp. 259-278. roncaGlia, G., Maestri di cappella del Duomo di Modena …in «AMDSP-Modena», s.VIII, 7(1955), pp. 112-155. roncaGlia, G., «Modena», Die Musik in Geschichte und Gegenwart, 9, Kassel 1961. roncaGlia, G., La cappella musicale del Duomo di Modena, Firenze 1957. ronzoni, G., Ceramiche graffite dalla Rocca di Campogalliano, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, V(1983), pp. 107-126. rotelli, e.- Piacentini r., Storia di Sassuolo. dalle origini alla fine della Signoria Pio, Bologna 1989. rotondò, a., Pellegrino Prisciani (1435 ca.-1518), in «Rinascimento», XI (1960), 1, pp. 69-110. roVatti, a., Cronaca modonese, in Modena napoleonica nella cronaca di Antonio Rovatti. Modena repubblicana 1798-1799, a cura di G.P. Brizzi e e. corradini, Milano 1996. roVatti, a., Modena napoleonica nella cronaca di Antonio Rovatti. L’albero della libertà 1796-1797, Milano 1995. ruFFini, G., Il sacrificio di Vincenzo Borelli, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. VIII, VI (1954), pp. 111161. ruFFini, G., Le cospirazioni del 1831 nelle memorie di Enrico Misley, Bologna 1931. ruGGeri, r., Antiche fotografie nelle collezioni civiche modenesi,Catalogo mostra, Modena 1981. salVioli, G., La legislazione di Francesco III Duca di Modena, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. IV, IX (1899), pp. 1-42. salVioli, G., Miscellanea di legislazione estense,Palermo 1898. saMMarini, a., Bibliografia scientifica storica letteraria d’autori carpigiani, in Memorie storiche e documenti sulla città e sull’antico principato di Carpi.Studi della Commissione di Storia Patria…, II, Carpi 1879-1880. sandri, l., La questione di Comacchio attraverso le carte del card. Galeazzo Marescotti, in «Rivista di storia della Chiesa in Italia», IV, 1950. santi, V., Il passaggio dei toscani per il Modenese nel 1613, Modena 1886. santi, V., La precedenza tra gli Estensi e i Medici e l’Historia de’ principi d’Este di G. Battista Pigna, Ferrara 1897. santini, G., Giurisdizioni locali, magistrature cittadine e territorio nell’area estense in antico regime, in
1314
Bibliografia
Terre di confine: la cartografia della Val di Serchio tra i domini lucchese ed estense, a cura di r. Martinelli, Lucca 1987, pp. 15-18. sPaGGiari, a., Cenni storici sugli archivi notarili degli Stati dei Duchi di Modena e Reggio, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, II(1980), pp. 207-226. sPaGGiari, a., Dallo «Stato di Ferrara« allo «Stato di Modena», in Storia illustrata di Modena, II, a cura di P. Golinelli e G. Muzzioli, Milano 1991, pp. 621-640 sPaGGiari, a., Documenti dell’Archivio di Stato di Modena riguardanti territori già estensi della Lunigiana e della Garfagnana, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, IV(1982), pp. 345-357. sPaGGiari, a., Il principato di Carpi nelle carte dell’archivio estense, in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi, (in corso di stampa). sPaGGiari, a., L’amministrazione della Casa, della Corte e dello Stato dei Pico. Discorso archivistico, in Giovanni Pico della Mirandola, a cura di G.c. GarFaGnini, Firenze 1997, pp. 95-104. sPaGGiari, a., La «Corografia« di Ludovico Ricci e lo «Stato di Modena« alla fine dell’antico regime, in l. ricci, Corografia dei territori di Modena, Reggio e degli altri stati appartenenti alla Casa d’Este, Modena 1988. (Rist.anastat.) sPaGGiari, a., Le istituzioni estensi nel secondo Settecento e le trasformazioni istituzionali del periodo napoleonico, in Rivoluzione Francese e società modenese cit., pp. 38-39. sPaGGiari, a., Marfisa d’Este Cybo nelle carte dell’Archivio di Stato di Modena in Alberico d’Este Cybo Malaspina. Il Principe, la Casa, lo Stato… cit., pp. 243-252. sPaGGiari, a., Massa e Carrara negli Archivi centrali austro-estense dopo 1829 in Massa e Carrara da Maria Beatrice a Vittorio Emanule II°, Modena 1990, pp. 313-325. sPaGGiari, a., Politica e istituzioni nel ducato estense nel ‘700 in Carrara ed il marmo nel ‘700: società, economia, cultura, Atti del convegno…cit, pp. 23-41. sPaGGiari, a., Girolamo Tiraboschi e la cultura archivistica del Settecento modenese, in Girolamo Tiraboschi, Miscellanea di Studi, a cura di a.r. Venturi BarBolini, Modena 1977, pp. 215220. sPaGGiari, a., Istituzioni modenesi dal 1796 al 1815, in Modena napoleonica nella cronaca di Antonio Rovatti.Dall’aquila imperiale al ritorno dei Francesi, a cura di G.P. Brizzi, Modena 1997, pp. 65-80. sPallanzani, M.F., Per una storia delle idee scientifiche nelle istituzioni culturali, in Reggio e i Territori Estensi, cit., II, pp. 399-431. sPreaFico, s., La Chiesa di Reggio Emilia tra antichi e nuovi regimi, I, L’agonia del poteri temporali, Bologna 1979 . staFFetti, l., Giulio Cybo-Malaspina, Modena 1892. staFFetti, l., Il cardinale Innocenzo Cybo-Malaspina, Firenze 1894. staFFetti, l., Il libro dei ricordi dei Cybo, Genova 1909. staFFetti, l., Origine e vicende dell’Accademia de’ Rinnovati di Massa, Massa 1980 ( Rist. anastat.). stanislao da caMPaGnola, Adeodato Turchi: uomo-oratore-vescovo (1728-1803), Roma 1961.
Bibliografia
1315
XVIII(1996), pp. 291-298. siMeoni, l., Francesco I d’Este e la politica italiana del Mazarino, Bologna 1922. siMeoni, l., L’assorbimento austriaco del ducato estense e la politica dei duchi Rinaldo e Francesco III, Modena 1919 ( rist. Modena 1986). sMarGiassi, M., Genesi del piccone demolitore. Un secolo e mezzo di trasformazioni urbane a Modena (1760-1915), in «Storia urbana», XIII, 1989, 47, pp. 129-173. soli, G., Le chiese di Modena, 3 voll., Modena 1974. soli, G.F., Vita del Muratori, Arezzo 1767. sorBelli, a.- raBetti, a., Dizionario biografico frignanese, Pievepelago 1952. sorMani Moretti, l., Della industria agricola, manifatturiera e commerciale nel Ducato di Modena, Milano 1848. sorrentino, t., Aspetti e problemi di vita economica e sociale nel ducato di Modena e Reggio in età moderna: materiali di studio delle attività di operatori ebrei nell’area di Sassuolo, in Vita e cultura ebraica nello stato estense, Atti del I° convegno internazionale di studi, Nonantola 15-16-17 maggio 1992, a cura di e. FreGni, Bologna 1993, pp. 329-337. sorrentino, t., Profilo di Sassuolo in “Antico Regime” in Duecentocinquant’anni di ceramica a Sassuolo, I, a cura di G.l. Basini e M. cattini, Modena 1991-93. sorrentino, t., Storia di Sassuolo. Dall’Antico regime all’età contemporanea. Lineamenti di storia economica e sociale, Bologna 1996. sossaJ, F., Modena descritta, Modena 1841. southorn, J., Mary of Modena Queen Consort of James II and VII, Royal Stuart Papers XL, Huntingdon 1992. southorn, J., Power and Display in the Seventeenth Century. The Arts and their Patrons in Modena and Ferrara, Cambridge 1988. Sovrane passioni. Le raccolte d’arte della Ducale Galleria Estense, Catalogo mostra, Modena 1998, a cura di J. Bentini, Milano 1998. sPaccini, G.B., Cronaca di Modena, anni 1588-1602, a cura di a. Biondi, r. Bussi e G. GioVannini, Modena 1993. sPaccini, G.B., Cronaca modenese (1588-1636), a cura di G. Bertoni, t. sandonnini, P.e. Vicini, 3 voll., Modena 1911-1919-1936. sPaGGiari, a.- trenti, G., Gli stemmi estensi ed austro-estensi. Profilo storico, Modena 1985. sPaGGiari, a. - trenti, G., L.A. Muratori e gli Estensi, in Corte, Buon Governo, Pubblica Felicità, Politico e coscienza civile nel Muratori, Firenze 1996, pp. 1-13. sPaGGiari, a. - trenti, G., Matilde di Canossa nella prosopografia Estense, in Matilde di Canossa nelle culture europee del secondo millennio: Dalla storia al mito, Atti del convegno internazionale di studi, Bologna 1999, pp. 81-93. sPaGGiari, a., Ai confini con la Repubblica di Lucca. Frignano e Garfagnana nello “Stato estense”, in
1316
Bibliografia
cura di r. Martinelli, Lucca 1998. Tipografia (La) Soliani in due secoli di attività. Modena 1646-1800,Catalogo mostra, Modena 1986. tiraBoschi, G., Biblioteca modenese o notizie della vita e delle opere degli scrittori natii degli stati del serenissimo Signor Duca di Modena, Modena 1781-1786. tiraBoschi, G., Dizionario topografico storico degli Stati Estensi, Modena 1821-1825. tiraBoschi, G., Notizie dei Pittori, Scultori, Incisori e Architetti natii degli Stati del Serenissimo Duca di Modena, Modena 1786. tiraBoschi, G., Storia dell’augusta Badia di S. Silvestro di Nonantola, 2 voll., Modena 1785 tiraBoschi, G., Memorie storiche modenesi col codice diplomatico illustrato con note, 5 voll., Modena 1793-1795. tocci, G., Piccole e grandi città negli stati italiani (secoli XV-XVII), in Giovanni Pico della Mirandola, Convegno Internazionale di studi, Firenze 1997, pp. 53-94. toMMasi, a.c., L’Ottocento nei rapporti tra il Veneto e Modena, in La pittura veneta negli Stati Estensi, a cura di J. Bentini e a. Mazza, Verona 1996, pp. 419-446. toniolo, F., Genealogia dei principi d’Este, in Le Muse e il principe. Arte di corte nel Rinascimento padano, I, Modena-Ferrara 1991, pp. 49-57. torelli, a.- Brunelli, B.- Bonisconti, a.M. «Modena», Enciclopedia dello Spettacolo, 7, Roma 1960, pp. 668-671. torelli, a., Notizie storiche, documenti, cronache sul Liceo Musicale «Orazio Vecchi», Modena 1954. Trattato della città di Modena et suo Ducato et delle cose in esso accadute. Diviso in tre libri, Ms. sec. XVII, (BEU. It. 1734 = α.G.10.3). (Il) Tricolore della Cispadana alla Cisalpina: il triennio giacobino. Atti del Convegno di studi storici per la celebrazione del bicentenario del Tricolore, Modena, 6-7 febbraio 1998, Modena, 1998. Trionfo (Il) dalla Cispadania alla Cisalpina: il triennio giacobino. Atti del Convegno di studi storici per la celebrazione del bicentenario del Tricolore, Modena, 6-7 febbraio 1998, Modena, 1998. Trionfo (Il) della Virtù. Festa d’armi a cavallo, rappresentata nella nascita del Serenissimo Signor Principe di Modana l’anno MDCLX, Modena 1660. troMBetti Budriese, a.l., Sul rapporto tra i Pio e gli Estensi in Società, politica e cultura a Carpi ai tempi di Alberto III Pio, Atti del convegno internazionale, Carpi 19-21 maggio 1978, II, Padova 1981, pp. 395-425. tuohy, t.J., Struttura e sistema di contabilità della Camera estense nel Quattrocento, in «AMDSPModena», s. XI, 4 (1982), pp. 115-139. turchi, l., L’amministrazione della giustizia locale all’epoca della transizione da principato minore al dominio estense in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi... (in corso di stampa). Uomini di teatro nel Settecento in Emilia e Romagna, a cura di M. calore, 2 voll., Modena 1986. urBini, s., San Barnaba, in I luoghi sacri dell’Arte. Itinerario nelle chiese modenesi di proprietà comunale, a cura di c. Franzoni e l. riVi, Modena 1994, pp. 72-77. ValdriGhi, l.F., Musurgiana, Modena 1879 (rist. anast. Bologna 1970).
Bibliografia
1317
stanislao da caMPaGnola, Cattolici intransigenti a Modena agli inizi della Restaurazione, Modena 1984. Storia di Modena e dei paesi circostanti dalle origini sino al 1860, a cura di a. naMias, Modena 1894 (rist. anast. Bologna 1987). Storia illustrata di Modena, a cura di P. Golinelli e G. Muzzioli, 3 voll., Milano 1990-1991. Storia degli antichi Stati italiani, a cura di G. Greco e M. rosa, Bari 1996. Storia illustrata di Ferrara, a cura di F. Bocchi, 4 voll. Milano 1987. Storia illustrata di Reggio Emilia, a cura di M. Festanti e G. GherPelli, 4 voll., Milano 1987. suess, J.G., The instrumental music manuscripts of Giuseppe Colombi of Modena: a preliminary report on the Non-Dance music for solo violin or violone, in Seicento inesplorato. L’evento musicale tra prassi e stile: un modello di interdipendenza, Atti del III Convegno internazionale,Como 1993, pp.387409. sueur, h., Per la storia e la fortuna della collezione di disegni dei duchi d’Este, in Disegni... cit., pp. 20-28. taBarroni, G., Il processo storico di formazione del nucleo di strumenti scientifici del Museo Civico di Modena, in Gli strumenti nella storia e nella filosofia della scienza, a cura di G. tarozzi , Bologna 1983, pp. 11-15. taBarroni, G., Scienza e tecnologia a Modena fra il Settecento e l’Ottocento. Ragioni e conseguenze della strumentazione topografica di G. B. Amici, in «Giornale di Fisica», XXIX, 1988, 2-3, pp. 85-88. tarasconi, F., Giovanni Maria Ferraroni «Brigo» 1662-1755, architetto reggiano, in«Bollettino Storico Reggiano», 50, 1981, pp. 20-21. tassoni estense, n., La crisi e l’evoluzione dell’aristocrazia estense dopo la Devoluzione di Ferrara alla S.Sede, attraverso le vicende della famiglia Tassoni, in «AMDSP-Modena», s.XI, XX (1998), pp. 105-118. tassoni, a., Scritti inediti, a cura di P. Puliatti, Modena 1975. taVilla, c.e, L’amministrazione centrale della giustizia negli Stati estensi. Dalle origini ferraresi alla Restaurazione, in «Rivista di storia del diritto italiano», LXXI, 1998, pp. 177-236. taVilla, c.e, Politica e riforme giudiziarie nel Settecento estense, Modena 1996. taVilla, c.e, Politica e riforme nel Settecento estense, I, Separazione dei poteri, amministrazione della giustizia, resistenze feudali (1740-1767), Bologna-Modena 1996. taVilla, c.e, Un progetto di riforma del governo estense (1767), in «Studi parmensi», 42 (1996), pp. 247-248. Teatro, musica e comunità: da Modena capitale a Modena italiana, a cura di a. Borsari, Modena 1996. Tempo (Il) di Alberico (1553-1623). Alberico 1° Cybo-Malaspina Signore, Politico e Mecenate a Massa e a Carrara, Catalogo mostra, a cura a. GiuMelli e o. raFFo, Pisa 1991. Terre di confine: la cartografia della Val di Serchio tra dominio lucchese ed estense nei sec.XVI- XVIII, a
1318
Bibliografia
Vecchi, G., Il «Canto delle scolte modenesi«: la notazione musicale in «Cultura neolatina», 10, 1950, pp. 49-62. Vedriani, l., Historia dell’antichissima città di Modona, 2 voll., Modena 1666-1667. Vedriani, l., Raccolta de’ pittori, scultori et architetti modenesi più celebri, Modena 1662. Veduta della città di Modena e delle Villeggiature Estensi. 24 incisioni di Guglielmo Silvestri, a cura di M. Bini- d. scaraBelli- G. Bertuzzi, Modena 1978. Vendita (La) di Dresda, a cura di J. WinKler, Modena 1989. Venturi, a., La R.Galleria Estense in Modena, Modena 1882, ( rist. Modena 1989). Venturi, a., Velasquez e Francesco I d’Este in «Nuova Antologia», LIX (1881). Venturi, a.r., Il lascito e le raccolte Angelo Catelani alla Biblioteca Estense, in «Accademie e Biblioteche d’Italia», s.44, 61(1993), pp. 70-73. Venturi, a.r., La libreria ducale e gli studi astrologici nella rinascita ferrarese, in Astrologia: arte e cultura in età rinascimentale, Modena 1996. Venturi, a.r., Sulle tracce della scienza: fonti documentarie e manoscritti estensi per la storia dell’astronomia e delle matematiche, in La Bona Opinione. Cultura scienza e misure negli stati estensi, 15981860 cit., pp. 205-218. Venturini, G.c., Note al Trattato di Firenze del 1844, in «Studi Lunigianesi. Miscellanea in onore di Manfredo Giuliani», 1965. Veratti, B., Le leggi, in Alla memoria di Francesco IV. Tributo della R. Accademia di Scienze, Lettere ed Arti di Modena, Modena 1846, pp. 157-216. Via (La) Vandelli nel quadro della viabilità settecentesca nel modenese, Atti del convegno, Pavullo 1986, Modena 1987. Via (La) Vandelli strada ducale del ‘700 da Modena a Massa, Modena 1987. Viaggi e viaggiatori del Settecento in Emilia e in Romagna, a cura di G. cusatelli, 2 voll., Bologna 1986. Viani, G., Memorie dei Cybo, Pisa 1808. Vicini, e.P., Profilo storico della città di Modena, Modena 1937. Vie d’acqua nei Ducati Estensi, Reggio Emilia 1990. ViGnaroli, G.M., Compasso geometrico, a cura di F. BarBieri, M. zanasi, Modena 1985. Virtù (La) delle arti. Adeodato Malatesta e l’Accademia Atestina, Catalogo mostra, a cura di d. Ferriani, Modena 1998. Visconti, a., La storia dell’Università di Ferrara, Bologna 1950. Vita e cultura ebraica nello stato estense, Atti del 1° convegno internazionale di studi, Nonantola 15-16-17 maggio 1992, a cura di e. FreGni, Bologna 1993. Vitali, G.B., Balli in stile francese a cinque stromenti consecrati alla sacra real maestà di Maria Beatrice d’Este Stuarda regina della Gran Bretagna, Modena 1685.
Bibliografia
1319
ValdriGhi, l.F., Nomocheliurgografia, Modena 1884 (rist. anast. Bologna 1967). ValdriGhi, l.F., Cappelle, concerti e musiche di Casa d’Este (dal sec.XV al XVIII) in «AMDSPModena», s.III, II(1883), pp. 415-495. ValdriGhi, l.F., Dizionario storico-etimologico delle contrade e spazi pubblici di Modena, Modena 1880. Valenti, F., Comune di Finale Emilia. Archivio Storico Comunale, in Archivi Storici in EmiliaRomagna, a cura di G. raBotti, Bologna 1991, pp. 409-413. Valenti, F., I Consigli di governo presso gli Estensi dalle origini alla Devoluzione di Ferrara, in Studi in onore di Riccardo Filangieri, II, Napoli 1959, pp. 19-40 (ora in: F. Valenti, Scritti e lezioni di archivistica diplomatica e storia istituzionale, a cura di d. Grana, Roma 2000). Valenti, F., Il Millenario di S. Pietro di Modena, Modena 1985 (Rist. in: F.Valenti, Scritti e lezioni cit.). Valenti, F., Panorama dell’Archivio di Stato di Modena, Modena 1963. Valenti, F., Comune di Modena. Archivio Storico Comunale, in Archivi storici in Emilia-Romagna cit., pp. 437-448. Valenti, F. - curti, P., L’Inventario 1771 dell’arredo del Palazzo Ducale di Modena. Inquadramento storico e illustrazione, Modena 1986. Vallisneri, a., Opere fisico-mediche stampate e manoscritte del Kavalier Antonio Vallisneri raccolte da Antonio suo figliuolo, I, Venezia 1733. Van der Meer, h., in Le raccolte d’Arte del Museo Civico di Modena, a cura di e. PaGella, Modena 1992, pp. 134-137. Vandelli, V., Dalla Rocca al Palazzo: la costruzione seicentesca e le trasformazioni nel XVIII secoli, in Palazzo Ducale di Sassuolo, a cura di M. Pirondini, Genova 1982. Vandelli, V., Il palazzo dei Musei: da grande iniziativa filantropica a sede dei prestigiosi istituti cittadini, in Le raccolte d’arte del Museo Civico di Modena…cit., pp. 61-76. Vandelli, V., L’ultimo volo dell’Aquila bianca: le riforme urbane e territoriali di Ercole Rinaldo III d’Este, in Gli architetti del Pubblico a Reggio Emilia dal Bolognini ai Marchelli. Architettura e urbanistica lungo la via Emilia (1770-1870), a cura di M. PiGozzi, Reggio Emilia 1990, pp. 151-192. Vandelli, V., Le forme del Collegio dei Nobili e della chiesa. Il contesto urbano e l’architettura, in Il Collegio e la Chiesa di San Carlo a Modena,…cit. Vandelli, V., Per imparare a guardare Sassuolo con occhio diverso ossia breve guida alla sua storia urbanistica e architettonica, in Album sassolese. La «nobil terra», a cura di e. Baroni- r. costir. Venturi, Modena 1996, pp. 49-75. Vecchi, a., Il libro che il Muratori non scrisse sulla riforma del Clero, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. VIII, X(1958), pp. 231-247. Vecchi, a., Lodovico Antonio Muratori e il caso di Comacchio (1708), in «Anecdota.Quaderni della Biblioteca Lodovico Antonio Muratori», I (1991), 2, pp. 63-75.
1320
Bibliografia
VolPi, G., Note alla Serie cronologica dei parroci di Massa Finalese in Per una storia di Massa Finalese, a cura di c. Frison, Modena 1985, pp. 136-141. Waltherius-Gualtieri. Dal Castrum all’Unità Nazionale, Atti del convegno,Gualtieri 1987, Reggio Emilia 1990. WittKoWer, r., Gian Lorenzo Bernini, Londra 1955. younG, d., The Bride from Modena, London 1978. zaccaria, F.a., Nel solenne aperimento della pubblica ducal libreria di Modena, Modena 1764. zaccaria, F.a., Regolamento per la Ducale Biblioteca, Modena 1765. zacchè, G.- Manenti, e.- Garuti, a., L’Archivio Notarile di Carpi, Roma 1984. zacchè, G., L’Archivio Notarile di Mirandola, in Mirandola e le terre del basso corso del Secchia, a cura di G. Bertuzzi, II, Modena 1984, pp. 345-353. zacchè, G., Patriziato cittadino e amministrazione comunitativa, in Nuove ricerche archivistiche sul principato di Carpi… (in corso di stampa). zacchè, G., Patriziato e comunità a Carpi in epoca estense(1527-1796), in Archivi,territori,poteri in area estense (secc.XVI-XVII) cit., pp. 225-244. zacchè, G., Rassegna degli studi sulla storia urbana di Carpi, in «Storia urbana», 1989, 46, pp. 245-264. zaGhi, c., Gli atti del terzo Congresso Cispadano di Modena, Modena 1935. zanuGG, l., Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena. Il problema della sua costruzione, in «Rivista del Regio Istituto di Archeologia e Storia dell’Arte», IX (1942), I, pp. 212-252 zarri, G., La proprietà ecclesiastica a Carpi fra Quattrocento e Cinquecento, in Società, politica e cultura a Carpi ai tempi di Alberto III Pio, Atti del Convegno, Carpi 1978, Padova 1981, pp. 533 -552. zecchini, a., I principali provvedimenti legislativi nel periodo della Restaurazione di Massa e Carrara (1815-1859) in L’Archivio di Stato di Massa ed il suo patrimonio documentario ad un secolo dalla sua fondazione, Sarzana 1987, pp. 147-164. zerBinati, G.M., Croniche di Ferrara quali comenzano dell’anno 1500 sino al 1527, a cura di M.G. Muzzarelli, Ferrara 1988. * * * Mille (I) volti della Modena Ducale. Memorie presentate all’accademia Nazionale di scienze Lettere e Arti in occasione delle celebrazioni di Modena Capitale, a cura dell’Accademia di Scienze Lettere e Arti di Modena, Modena 2000. Modena 1598. L’invenzione di una capitale, a cura di M. BulGarelli, c. conForti, G. curcio, Milano 1999. Quarto Centenario di Modena Capitale. Contributi, in «AMDSP-Modena», s. XI, XXI (1999), pp. 143-492.
,1',&( '(, 120, ', 3(5621$ ( ', /82*2
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Abadie (d’), *****, maggiore, 703 n. Abamonti, Giuseppe, 75 Abate (Dell’), Nicolò, 193, 862, 863 Abbati, Ercole, 116 Abelson, Michael A., 1109 Abetone (PT), 256, 555 Acciaioli, Filippo, 1024 Achimi, Tomaso, 748 n. Addison, Joseph, 860 Adige, valle, 20 Adriani, Marcello (d. Marcellino), 1197 Adriano VI, papa, 519, 520 Adriatico, mare, 594 Affò, Ireneo, 630, 1052 Agatea, Mario, 435 Agliano (Minucciano) (LU), 558 Agnano (S.Giuliano Terme) (PI), 1248 Agnino (Fivizzano) (MS), 542 Agosti, Giulio, 1086 n. Agosti, Guido, 1109 Agostini, Pier Simone, 1067 Agostino di Duccio, 143 Ala Ponzoni, Filippo, 234 Alai, Antonio, 349 Albareto (Modena), 205 Albergotti, Francesco, 560 Alberguccio di Mocogno, 503 n. Alberti, Giovanni Vincenzo, 744 Alberti, Leandro, 861, 461 n., 1167 n. Alberti delle Pomarance, Andrea, 1196 Albertini, Fabrizio, 681 Alberto da Como, 683 Albiano Magra (Aulla) (MS), 542, 553, 558 Albinea (RE), 312, 517 Albinelli, Andrea, 889 n. Albinelli, Giovanni, 558, 1000 Albinelli, Lodovico, 503 n. Albini, Gentile, 487 n. Albizi, Camillo, 1197 Alboino, re dei Longobardi, 14 Alciato, Andrea, 890 Aldobrandini, Pietro, cardinale, 24, 25, 593, 688, 693-695, 1161 n., 1185, 1200 Alduini, Giovanni, 562 Aleotti, Giacomo, 997, 1001, 1024 Aleotti, Giovanni Battista (d. l’Argenta),
1323
452, 454 n. Alessandro VII, papa, 1165 Alfieri, Vittorio, 611 Alfonso de’ Liguori, santo, 759 n. Algardi, Alessandro, 330, 331, 334, 339 Algeri, Giuseppe, 359 Algeri, Nicola, 164 Alighieri, Dante, 1138, 1140-1143 Allegra, Luciano, 794 Allotti, Lodovico, 1263, 1268 Almagià, Roberto, 454, 459, 461 Aloisi, Bartolomeo, 565 n. Alpi, 638, 857, 1035 Altagnana (MS), 660 Altogradi, Giuseppe, 1223 Alvarez, Emanuel, 1023 Amadei, Gaetano, 239 Amboise (d’) de Chaumont, Charles, 141 n. Ambreville (d’), Anna, 1071 Ambreville (d’), Rosa, 1071 Ambrogio, santo, 720 America, 451, 834, 989 Amici, Giovanni Battista, 362, 364 Amorotto (Domenico Bretti, d.), 503 n., 519, 520 Amorotto (Vitale Bretti, d.), 520 Amorth, Luigi, 95, 1099, 1108 Amsterdam, 865 Ancarani, Pier Giovanni, 889 n. Ancini, Luigi, 540 Ancini, Pietro, 347, 357 Ancona, 107 Andrea da Faenza, fra, 578 Andreini, Francesco, 1077, 1078 Andreini, Giovanni Battista, 1080 n. Andreini, Isabella, v. Canali Andreini, Isabella Andreoli, Aldo, 1110, 1112 Andreoli, Carlo, 539 Andreoli, Giuseppe, 38, 537, 539, 612, 737, 837, 839, 876, 1134, 1139, 1142, 1143, 1145, 1174 Angeli, Bernardo, 358 Angelini, Antonio, 569 Angelini, Francesco Maria, 309 Anguissola Boschetti Scotti, Giovanni, 269,
1324
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Austria (d’) d’Este, Ferdinando Carlo, 233, 260 Austria (d’) d’Este, Francesco IV, duca di Modena, 26, 37, 42, 102, 108, 110, 171173, 175, 176, 185, 232, 242, 360 n., 362, 424, 535, 536, 568-570, 611, 612, 651, 660-664, 666, 705-708, 734, 735, 737739, 746 n., 799, 833, 834, 838-844, 868878, 882, 896, 920, 924, 927, 930, 977, 983, 984, 988, 990, 1072, 1110, 1134, 1135, 1137, 1139-1141, 1145, 1146, 1156, 1172, 1174, 1248, 1274 Austria (d’) d’Este, Francesco V, duca di Modena, 26, 38, 39, 43, 107, 108, 110, 111, 176-178, 233, 242, 373, 374, 424, 538, 540, 570, 614, 663, 665, 666, 707, 708, 718, 721, 736, 738-741, 845, 879, 880, 882, 919, 920, 924, 925, 929, 984, 985, 988-990, 1098, 1108, 1110, 1113, 1134, 1138, 1173, 1175, 1176, 12461248, 1252 Austria (d’) d’Este, Maria Beatrice, 373 Austria (d’) d’Este, Massimiliano, 362, 424, 833, 706 n. Austria (d’), Barbara, duchessa di Ferrara, 678, 805, 810, 815 n., 1194 Austria (d’), Giovanna, granduchessa di Toscana, 1194 Avanzini, Antonio, 333 Avanzini, Bartolomeo, 29, 85, 87-89, 155, 333, 1070 Avignone, 1165 Avila (d’), Verduglio, 555 Avonto, Luigi, 1109 Azeglio (d’) Taparelli, Massimo, 235, 615, 1144 Azzi, Girolamo, 569 Azzolini, Francesco, 1025 Babbi, Francesco, 1192, 1193, 1200 Baccarani, Gaetano, 240 Baccelli, Liberato, 608 Bacchi, Giulio Francesco, 706 n. Bacchi, Igino, 1109 Bacchini, Benedetto, 9, 156-158, 463, 1051-
1053, 1058, 1109, 1110, 1116, 1121, 1126, 1127 Bacciolani, Lotario, 843 Baciocchi, Felice, 568 Badelli, Antonio, 329 Baggiovara (Modena), 204 Bagnacavallo (RA), 25, 1160, 1161 Bagnesi, Clemente, 1048 Bagnesi, Ippolito, 276, 277 Bagni, Ferdinando, 902 n. Bagnolo in Piano (RE), 529, 635-639, 642-644 Bagnone (MS), 546 Baini, Carlo Antonio, 337 Baini, Domenico, 337 n. Baini, Giovanni Martino, 336, 340 n. Baiso (Reggio E.), 517 Balcani, 794 Baldi, Angelo, 348 Baldigiani, Giovanni Maria, 849, 850 Balletti, Andrea, 536, 540, 792, 796, 1109, 1110, 1114 Balletti, Elena (“Flaminia”), 1089 Balugola, Alberto, 455-457, 459, 469 Bandiera, Attilio, 548 Bandiera, Emilio, 548 Baracchi Giovanardi, Orianna, 1112, 1114 Baracchi, Matteo, 910 n. Baraldi, Giuseppe, 152, 171, 414 n., 736, 1097 Baratta, Andrea, 328, 334, 340-342 Baratta, Francesco, 330, 331 n. Baratta, Giacomo, 333 Barattini, Maurizio, 1113 Barberi, Carlo, 434 Barberi, Francesco, 1057 Barberini, Antonio, 1162 n. Barberini, Francesco, 1162 n. Barberini, Lucrezia, duchessa di Modena, 30, 32, 389 n., 723, 823, 849, 850 Barberini, Taddeo, 1162 n. Barbieri, Alberto, 726, 1099 Barbieri, Biagio, 836 n. Barbieri, Francesco, 1103, 1113,1042 n. Barbieri, Giovanni, 694 Barbieri, Giovanni Maria, 8, 1116, 1121 Barbieri, Nicolò, 1080 n.
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
274 Ansaloni, Antonio, 353, 354 n. Ansaloni, Giuseppe, 163 Ansaloni, Liliana, 125 n., 424 n. Antichi, Bartolomeo, 757 Antille, isole, 954 Antognano (Minucciano) (LU), 553 Antolini, Carlo, 675 Antona (Massa) (MS), 660 Antonelli, Giacomo, cardinale, 1176 n. Antonetti, Alfonso, 545 Antonini, Eraldo, 1113 Antonino, vescovo di Modena, 720 Antonio da Faie, 542 Antonio da Genova, 518 Anversa, 167 Apella (Licciana Nardi) (MS), 541-544, 547, 548 Apparuti, Antonio, 351 n., 356, 357 Appennino, 275, 280, 354, 355, 381,465, 466, 519, 543, 554, 589, 660, 662, 666, 716, 717, 856, 857, 861, 953, 1139, 1262 Appiani, Andrea, 226 Aquileia (UD), 15 Aragona (d’), Blasco, 1266 Aragona (d’), Caterina, regina d’Inghilterra, 811 Aragona (d’), Eleonora, duchessa di Ferrara, 805, 806, 809-811 Aragona (d’), Giovanna, regina di Castiglia, 811 Aragona, Antonio, 333 Araldi, Giovanni Battista, 752 n., 769 n., 772 n. Araldi, Michele, 608 Arcagnati (o Arcagiati), Anna (“Rosaura”), 2083, 1084 n. Arceto (Scandiano) (RE), 538 Archinto, Alberico, 1040 Archinto, Giuseppe, 707 Ardingo, ebreo modenese, 783 Aregliari, Teodora (“Vittoria”), 1083 Arezzo, 130 Arienti, Sabatino, 809 Arieri, Agostino, 362, 363 n. Ariosto, Alessandro, 689
1325
Ariosto, Lodovico, 517, 652, 656, 783, 1141 Ariosto, Rinaldo, 1080 Aristotele, 57, 827, 1122 Arlotti, Isabella, 1089 n. Armani, Pietro, 264 Armentano, Lucia, 576 n., 577, 578 Arno, fiume, 15 Arran, Charles Butler, 860 Asburgo (d’), Carlo, arciduca, 1194 Asburgo (d’), Maria Luisa, duchessa di Parma, 568, 927, 1250, 1261, 1262, 1271, 1273 Asburgo-Lorena (d’), Ferdinando, granduca di Toscana, 26, 35-37, 259, 658, 734 n., 833, 1156, 1157, 1168, 1169 n., 1246. 1247, 1261 Asburgo-Lorena (d’), Leopoldo II, granduca di Toscana, 569 Ascani, Pellegrino, 417 Ascari, Tiziano, 1112 Ascoli, Graziadio Isaia, 1032 Asioli, Bonifacio, 614 Asioli, Ferdinando, 614 Asioli, Giuseppe, 404, 1105 Asioli, Luigi, 234, 235, 240, 242, 1105 Asioli, Raffaele, 240, 614 Assereto, Gioacchino, 202 Assia-Darmstadt (d’), Joseph, vescovo, 1041 Assia-Darmstadt (d’), Leopoldo, langravio, 1041, 1270 Asti, 15 Astolfi, Isnardo, 174 Atkin, Paul, 1070 n. Atlantico, oceano, 953 Attila, re degli Unni, 141 n. Attolini, Giampietro, 891 Audiffredi, Giovanni Battista, 1057 Auer, Luigi, 360 Augier, Pierre-François, 706 Augsburg, 1035, 1038, 1041, 1041 Augustoni, Girolamo, 892 Aulla (MS), 547, 662, 940 Aurispa, Giovanni, 1050 n. Austria, 22, 70, 373, 562, 739, 1040, 1108, 1135, 1241, 1246, 1249-1252, 1254, 1255 Austria (d’) d’Este, Anna Beatrice Teresa, 26
1326
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Bentivoglio, Cornelio, 521, 580 n. Bentivoglio, Enzo, 689, 1080 Bentivoglio, Guido, 692 Bentivoglio, Ippolito, 521, 553-556, 689, 711, 1215, 1216 n., 1217 Bentivoglio, Matilde, 723 Berchet, Giovanni, 1139 Berceto (PR), 1268 Bergamo, 70, 166, 1048 Bergeijk (Van), Herman, 1112 Berger, Lorenz, 421 Bergiola (c/o Massa), 553 Bergolli, Antonio, 996, 1017 Bergonzini, Renato, 1113 Berlino, 879 Bernacca di Vallico, 553 Bernacchi, Antonio, 1071 Bernardini, Cesare Ignazio, 1223 Bernardini, Damiano, 1214, 1215, 1217 Bernardo da Lugano, 346 Berni, Francesco, 196, 1050 n. Bernini, Gian Lorenzo, 30, 86, 155, 328332, 335, 340, 341, 386, 1228 Berry (de), Luisa Maria Teresa, duchessa di Parma, 1262 Bertacchi, Carlo, 561 Bertacchi, Giovanni, 164 Bertacchi, Pellegrino, vescovo di Modena, 721 Bertani, Domenico, 363 n. Bertazzoli, Bartolomeo, 889 n. Bertelli, Sergio, 1031 Berthier, Louis-Alexandre, 73 Bertolani Del Rio, Maria, 1114 Bertoni, Giulio, 1112, 1116 Bertoni, Mario, 801 n. Bertucci, Giovanni, 1222 n. Bertuzzi, Giordano, 315, 317 n., 940, 1100, 1108-1110, 1112 Berutti, Giuseppe, 354 Besenzi, Paolo Emilio, 346 Besini, Giulio, 175, 737, 836 n., 837, 839, 875, 1139, 1143, 1145, 1146, 1148 Besini, Ottavio, 175 Bestor, Jane Fair, 801 n. Bettinelli, Saverio, 761 n., 1055, 1056
Bevilacqua, Bonifacio, cardinale, 684, 693 Bevilacqua, Ercole, 684, 695 Bevilacqua, Ernesto, 689 Bevilacqua, Giovanni Battista, 580 n. Bevilacqua, Onofrio, 580 n. Beza, Paolo, 171 Bezzi, Pietro, 163, 419 Bezzi, Tomaso, 397, 398 n., 1070 Bezzuoli, Giuseppe, 229, 234, 235, 239 Bianchi (de’) (o Lancellotti), Iacopino, 126, 142 Bianchi (de’) (o Lancellotti), Tommasino, 9, 142 Bianchi, Agostino, 757 n. Bianchi, Baldassarre, 1070 Bianchi, Felice Antonio, 267, 271, 274, 315, 728 n., 749 n., 752 n., 767, 768, 1109 Bianchi, Francesco, 849 n. Bianchi, Giovanni Andrea, 497 n. Bianchi, Giuseppe, 742 n. Bianchi, Marco, 465, 466 Bianchi, Nicomede, 537, 1098, 1899 Bianchini Ciarlini, Ippolito, 228 Bianchini, Giovanni, 154 Bianchini, Marco, 1029 Bianconi, Giovanni Lodovico, 1129 Bianello (c/o Quattro Castella) (RE), 521 Bibiena (Il) (Antonio Galli, d.), 312, 347, 348 Bibiena (Il) (Ferdinando Galli, d.), 257, 347, 348 Bibiena (Il) (Francesco Galli, d.), 257, 347, 348 Bibiena (Il) (Giuseppe Galli, d.), 257, 347, 348 Bidelli, Matteo, 432 Bimbi, Angelo, 567 n. Bimbi, Giuseppe, 565, 567 n. Bimbi, Saverio, 567 n. Bini, Mauro, 141 n. Biondi, Albano, 579, 580 Biondo, Flavio, 461 n. Bisi, Ciro, 351 n. Bitossi, Carlo, 1187 n. Blaeu, Willem Janszoon, 461 Boccabadati, Giovanni Battista, 116, 117, 155, 157 n., 305, 461-462, 469, 891 n.,
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Barcellona, 1242 Bardetti, Stanislao, 1113 Bardi (PR), 1260, 1265 Barelli, Dora Anna, 575 n., 1103 Baretti, Giuseppe, 1130 Barga (LU), 505, 1197 Barghini, Andrea, 1112 Barigazzo (Lama Mocogno) (MO), 499 Barili, Tommaso, 1222, 1224 Bariola, Valeria Silvia, 1112 Barlow, Thomas, 1232 Baroni, Domenico,234 Barrili, Anton Giulio, 1144 Bartoli, Cosimo, 454 Bartoli, Flaminio, 402 Baruffaldi, Girolamo, 199, 200 Baruffi, Gaetano, cardinale, 741 n. Barzelli, Marco, 352 Basi, Muzio, 649 Basini, Gian Luigi, 52, 67 Bassano del Grappa (VI), 339 Bassi, Giovanni Battista, 1041 Bassoli, Cesare, 341 Bastardi, Nicodemo, 1090 n. Bastianino (Il)(Sebastiano Filippi, d.), 370 Bastiano da Finale, 1193 Bastiglia (MO), 463, 719, 1003 Battaglia, Francesco Maria, 694 Battilani, Luigi, 925 Battini, Annalisa, 801 n. Baviera (di), Adelgonda, duchessa di Modena, 38, 107, 373, 537, 741, 1110 Bavois (de) de Saussure, George, 713 Bayard de Volo, Nicolò,838 Bayard de Volo, Teodoro, 373, 662, 742 n., 882, 887, 896, 919, 1098, 1113 Bazzani, Margherita, 1113 Bazzano (Neviano degliArduini) (PR), 1273 Bassano, Giovanni, 8 Beaufort (De), *****, capitano, 703 n. Beauharnais, Giuseppina, imperatrice dei Francesi, 310 Bebbi, Paolo, 503 n. Bentini, Jadranka, 309, 385, 1101, 1102 Beccari, Agostino, 1118 Beccari, Nicola, 678
1327
Beccaria, Cesare, 952, 1055, 1117 Beckerhin, Franz, 704, 705 Bedizzano, torrente, 665 Bedoni, Giusepe, 552, 660, 663, 666, 1109, 1110 Beffi, Lodovico, 689 Begarelli, Lodovico, 327 Beger, Lorenzo, 421 Behn, Aphra, 1233, 1234, 1236 Belardinelli, Bianca, 348 n. Belgio, 1136 Bellaia, Alfonso, 682 Bellaria di Mugnano (c/o Modena), 256, 423 Bellei, Meris, 1105 Bellentani, Alessandro, 892 n. Bellerio Sidoli, Giuditta, 538 Bellerio, Andrea, 538 Belli, David Enzo, 549 Bellin, Nicholas, 1227 Bellincini, Ippolito, 497 n., 1081 n. Bellini, Antonio, 575 n. Bellisani, Francesco, 1095 Belmesseri, Angelo, 490, 1268 Belriguardo, “delizia” estense (c/o Voghiera) (FE), 458 Beltrame, Nicolò, 1092 n. Beltrami, Giacomo, 1108 Beltrami, Girolamo, 347 Benassati, Giuseppina, 1062 n. Benassi, Giovanni, 279 Benatti, Argimiro, 580 n. Benatti, Arturo, 580 n. Benavida de Caracena, Luis, 30 Benedelli, Baldassarre, 889 n. Benedetti, Giovanni Maria, 1193 Benedetti, Giuseppe, 401 n. Benedetto XIV, papa, 259, 263, 727, 1036, 1041 Beneventi, Alessandro, 357 Beneventi, Antonio Maria, 357 Beneventi, Giovanni, 357 Benincasa, Francesco, vescovo di Carpi, 574 n. Bentinck, William, lord, 834 Bentivoglio, Annibale, 330 Bentivoglio, Claudio, 882
1328
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Borselli, Orfeo, 331 n. Bortoli Gilli, Aroldo, 1112, 1113 Bortolotti, Pietro, 1112 Boschetti, *****, colonnello, 715 Boschetti, Claudio, 873 Boschetti, Luigi, 872 Boschetti, Paolo, 722 Boselli, Ercole, 139 Bosellini, Carlo, 836, 895, 952 Bosellini, Francesco, 952 Bosellini, Lodovico, 163, 164, 899, 901, 1098, 1134 Botta Adorno, Antonio, 624 Bottignana (Fivizzano)( MS), 546 Bouchardon, Edme, 280 n. Boucher de la Richarderie, Gilles, 861 Bouhours, Dominique, 1088 Boulanger, Jean, 526 n., 858 Bouquoi (de), *****, conte, 770 n. Bourdin, Charles, 864 Bovio, Giambattista, 889 n. Bovio, Giovanni Lodovico, 1202 Bracci, Angela, 1095 n. Braganza (di), Caterina, regina d’Inghilterra, 1220 Braida, Antonio, 357 Brandoli, Bartolomeo, 747 n. Brandoli, Placido, 902 Bratti, Ingramo, 619 Brauneder, Wilhelm, 1153, 1154 Brefort, Adam-Claude (d. il Lorenese), 331 Brescello (RE), 239, 462, 516, 520, 528, 535, 554, 560, 701, 702, 704-708, 711, 940, 1231, 1268, 1269 Brescia, 70, 639, 1145 Bressencourt, Jean-François, 713 Brichieri Colombi, Gian Domenico, 1039 n., 1040 Brici, Sebastiano, 683 Briga, Giovanni, 1078, 1079 Briglia, Baldassarre, 556, 557 Brissot de Warville, Jacques-Pierre, 903 Broni (PV), 145 Brosses (de), Charles, 308, 861, 864, 866, 1093 n., 1094 Bruck (de), Carl Ludwig, 1252, 1254, 1255
Brucker, Johann, 1038 Brugnoli, Giuseppe, 920 Brune, Guillaume-Marie-Anne, 73 Brunelli, Gabriele, 339 Brunetti, Carlo, 1002 Bruni, Bruno, 608 Brunswick-Lüneburg (di), Carlotta Felicita, duchessa di Modena, 33, 395, 397, 421, 725 n., 825, 1030, 1152, 1259 Brunswick-Lüneburg (di), Giorgio Lodovico, 421 Brunswick-Lüneburg (di), Guglielmina Amalia, imperatrice, 1152 Brusantini, Paolo, 596, 689 Bruxelles, 370 Bruzen de la Martinière, Antoine-Augu-stin, 857 Bucarest, 840 Budapest, 840 Budrio (Correggio) (RE), 610, 611 Bulgarelli, Girolamo, 1268 Buol-Schauenstein (von), Karl Ferdinand, 1255 Buonarroti, Filippo, 836, 846 Buoni, Giovanni, 358 Buono, Giovanni, 113 Buonvisi, Lorenzo, 1216 Buonvisi, Martino, 1216 Burckhardt, Jacob, 790 Burke, Peter, 1228 Burney, Charles, 1233 Busi, Emilio, 234 Butio, Pompeo, 649 Buzzoleni, Giovanni, 1069 Cà Bianca (Finale E.) (MO), 969 Cabassi, Girolamo, 578 Caccia Dominioni Giorgi di Vistarino, Rosanna, 1109 Caccia, Gaetano, 1083 n. Caciotti, Ugo, 1181 n. Cadè (Reggio E.), 535 Cagnoli, Giampiero, 920 Cagnoli, Luigi, 535, 536 Caiano (Firenze), 376
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1024, 1051, 1053 Bocchini, Bartolomeo, 1026 Bocchini, Scipione, 1202 Boccia, Lionello, 357 Boccolari, Antonio, 172, 1112 Boccolari, Giorgio, 1109, 1112 Boccolari, Rinaldo, 952 n. Bodoni, Giovanni Battista, 1007 Boiardo, Feltrino, 515 Boiardo, Giulia, 619 Boiardo, Matteo Maria, 517, 518 Bolelli, Lorenza, 317 n. Bologna, 33, 50, 77, 85, 89, 171, 193, 194, 196-198, 200, 201, 206-209, 227, 229, 236, 283, 285, 310, 339, 376, 396, 400, 416, 421, 434-436, 457, 458, 553, 558, 559, 564, 569, 607, 719, 723, 725, 732, 741, 840 , 842, 857, 860, 862, 900, 990, 1018, 1019, 1025, 1026, 1066, 1074, 1077, 1080, 1087, 1092, 1123, 1136, 1155, 1164, 1173, 1176, 1199 Bolognana (Gallicano) (LU), 557 Bolognese, territorio, 504, 505, 511, 618, 955, 1204 Bolognini, Lodovico, 264, 279, 282, 284, 532 Bolognini,Taddeo, 581 n. Bolzoni, Andrea, 399 Bombarda, Pietro, 662 Bomporto (MO), 98, 112, 1003, 1078, 1112, 1113 Bonacini, Pierpaolo, 1111 Bonafini, Caterina, 315 Bonaini, Francesco, 936, 945 Bonald (de), Louis-Gabriel-Ambroise, 900 Bonaparte Baciocchi, Elisa, 568 Bonaparte, Carlo Luigi, 843 Bonaparte, Napoleone Luigi, 843 Bonarelli, Guidobaldo, 152, 689 Bonarelli, Pietro, 649 Bonasi, Leonello, 972 n. Bonatti, Franco, 543 Bonaventura da Parma, cappuccino, 1000 Bondanini, Andrea, 454 n. Bondeno (FE), 98, 1162, 1166 Bondì da Barigazzo, 498 n. Bondì Sanguinetti, Angelo, 963
1329
Bondigli, Giuseppe Maria, 18, 920, 1029 Bonelli, Giovanni Battista, 1208 Bonetti, Pietro, 357 Bonfati, Giuseppe, 357 Boni, Egidio, 1144, 1204 Boni, Giuseppe, 178 Bonifacio da Morano, 619 Bonneval (de), Claude, 1166 Bononcini, Antonio Maria, 1071 Bononcini, Giovanni, 1067 Bononcini, Giovanni Maria, 435, 1068 Bononi, Carlo, 184 Bonsanti, Giorgio, 1102 Bontempelli, fratelli, 704 Bonvicini, Bartolomeo, 399 Bonvisi, Martino, 1217 n. Borbone (di), Carlo I, duca di Parma, 1257, 1261 Borbone (di), Carlo II, duca di Parma, 1261, 1262 Borbone (di), Carlo III, duca di Parma, 1262 Borbone (di), Carlo Lodovico, duca di Parma, 1273 Borbone (di), Maria Luisa, duchessa di Lucca, 568 Bordeaux, 11 Borelli, Vincenzo, 737, 844, 876, 877, 1141 Boretto (RE), 516, 521 Borghi, Carlo, 142 n., 176-179, 1111 Borghi, Cristoforo, 188 Borghi, Gian Paolo, 1113 Borgia, Cesare, 518, 1147 Borgia, Lucrezia, duchessa di Ferrara, 518, 519, 809, 810 n. Borgo (Da), Lodovico, 684 Borgognoni, Annibale, 701, 704 Borgo Val di Taro (PR), 1265, 1268 Borromeo, Barbara, 648 Borromeo, Federico, cardinale, 196 Borromini, Francesco, 155 Borroni, Carlo, 70 n. Borsari, Aldo, 125 n., 427 n., 481 n., 1103, 1104 Borsari, Bonifacio, 361 n. Borsari, Giovanni, 359 Borsari, Luigi, 903
1330
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Carletto da Marzio, 498 n. Carli, Carlo, 566, 568 n. Carlo Borromeo, santo, 721 n., 1196 Carlo Emanuele III di Savoia, re di Sardegna, 562 Carlo Felice di Savoia, re di Sardegna, 842 Carlo I d’Asburgo-Lorena, imperatore d’Austria-Ungheria, 1247 Carlo I Stuart, re d’Inghilterra, 1228, 1230 Carlo II d’Asburgo, re di Spagna, 559 Carlo II Stuart, re d’Inghilterra, 332 n., 1230, 1232, 1234-1236 Carlo IV di Lussemburgo, imperatore, 619 Carlo Magno, imperatore, 820, 822 Carlo V d’Asburgo, imperatore, 503 n., 573, 574 n., 645, 1161 Carlo VI d’Asburgo, imperatore, 34, 137, 1040, 1241, 1242, 1246 Carlo VII di Valois, re di Francia, 132 Carlo VIII di Valois, re di Francia, 518, 546 Carloni, Domenico, 339 Carnevali, Domenico, 193 Carpi (MO), 4, 24, 67, 204, 206, 228, 229, 233, 240, 337, 340, 352, 380, 459, 462, 465, 528, 571-573, 575-577, 579-582, 584-588, 590-592, 594, 612, 618, 625, 639, 689, 702, 708, 741, 785, 844, 871, 872, 920-941, 944, 986, 991, 1000, 1004, 1081, 1082, 1086, 1095, 1106, 1116, 1176 Carpineti (RE), 520 Carracci, Agostino, 194, 197 Carracci, Annibale, 182, 194, 197, 198 Carracci, Lodovico, 194, 197, 198 Carrara (MS), 333, 341, 469, 563, 567, 568, 570, 623, 651-653, 655, 657, 659, 661663, 716, 741, 930, 940, 1113, 1139, 1246 Carrara, Vittorio, 1108 Carrarese, territorio, 718 Carrione, torrente, 665 Casa, Emilio, 1262 Casa Gionima, alfiere albanese, 710 Casalgrande (RE), 521, 538 Casalgrandi, Felice, 349, 350 Casalgrandi, Giuseppe, 349, 350
Casali, Luigi, 240 Casalpietra, Maria Teresa, 663 Casamassima, Emanuele, 1057 Casati, Paolo Emilio, 689, 910 n. Cascio (Molazzana) (LU), 466, 556, 557, 1215 Caselgrandi, Giovanni, 164 Caselgrandi, Giuseppe, 354 n. Casella, Francesco, 228, 229 n. Casiglia (c/o Sassuolo), 704 Casinalbo (Formigine) (MO), 144 Casini, Antonio, 356 Casoli, Biagio, 887 Casoli, Pier Biagio, 728, 742 n. Cassano (Polinago) (MO), 719 Cassiani Ingoni, Giuseppe, 887 Cassiani, Andrea, 997, 998, 1003-1006 Cassiani, Giuliano sr., 145, 997, 998, 1001, 1003, 1005, 1011 Cassiani, Paolo, 426 n., 427 n. Cassiani, stampatori, 400 Cassini di Thury, Francesco, 467 Cassini, Gian Domenico, 361 n. Cassoli, Francesco, 1120 Castaldi, Filippo, 891, 892 n. Castel d’Aiano (BO), 759 Castel S.Pietro (BO), 207 Castelfranco Emilia (MO), 309, 618 Castellamonte, Carlo, 29, 707 Castellarano (RE), 306, 527, 893 Castellari, Cesare, 567 n. Castelnovo di Sotto (RE), 516, 520, 521, 535, 938, 1270 Castelnuovo Monti (RE), 514, 522, 560 Castelnuovo di Garfagnana (LU), 19, 546, 555, 556, 558-567, 569, 570, 660, 708, 871, 940, 941, 942, 1151, 1213-1215, 1217, 1221, 1223 Castelnuovo di Tortona, v. Castelnuovo Scrivia Castelnuovo Scrivia (AL), 516 Castelnuovo G., vicarìa, 551 Castelnuovo Rangone (MO), 996 Castelvecchio Pascoli (FI), 546 Castelvetro, Lodovico, 1112, 1117, 1123 Castevoli (Mulazzo) (MS), 1273 Castiglione (Bagnone) (MS), 1194 Castiglione del Terziere, v. Castiglione (Bagnone)
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Calabria, 548 Calcagni, Francesco, 391 n. Calcagnini, Guido, 692, 695, 696 Caldani, Lazzaro, 354 Calefati, Pietro, 1201 Caleffi, Ercole, 701 Caleffi, Adeodato, vescovo di Modena, 737 Calimano, Mosè Jona, 961 n. Callafasi, Giuseppe Maria, 36 Callot, Jacques, 393, 394 Calomini (Vergemoli) (LU), 558 Calore, Marina, 1062 n., 1112 Calori, *****, dona libri alla Biblioteca ducale, 154 Calori, Pomponio, 276 Calvi Parisetti, Carlo, 613 Calvino, Giovanni, 166 Calzolari, Mauro, 1113 Cambray-Digny, Guglielmo, 570 Camerino (MC), 693 Campagnola (RE), 602, 609-611 Campana, Cesare, 574 n. Campani, Angelo, 538 Campani, Silvio, 1098 Campani, Umberto, 360 n. Campanini, Naborre, 1113 Campi, Giuseppe, 375, 1109, 1111, 1131, 1138, 1140-1142 Campione (c/o Fivizzano)(MS), 1205 Campistron (de), Jean-Gualbert, 108, 1087 n. Campogalliano (MO), 240, 314 Camporaghena (Comano) (MS), 546 Camporgiano (LU), 466, 555, 562, 564, 566, 567 Camporgiano, vicarìa, 566 Campori, Cesare, 1098, 1099, 1111 Campori, Giuseppe, 185, 712 n., 882, 1104, 1105, 1010 n., 1110, 1113 Campori, Matteo, 1030, 1110, 1113 Campori Seghizzi, Anna, 228 Camposanto (MO), 1139 Camuccini, Vincenzo, 227 Camurana (Medolla) (MO), 202, 461 Camurani, Angelo, 538 Canai, Giacomo, 1202 Canali Andreini, Isabella, 1077, 1086 n.
1331
Canani, Giulio, vescovo di Modena, 720 Cancellieri, Francesco, 1055 Canevara (Massa C.), 660 Canevazzi, Giovanni, 1109, 1111, 1112 Canigiani, Bernardo, 1194, 1195, 1200 Canobi, Cristoforo, 1068 Canolo (Correggio) (RE), 521, 610-611 Canonici, Roberto, 184 Canosa (di) Capece, Antonio, principe, 242, 841, 842, 1135 Canossa (Ciano d’Enza) (RE), 521 Canova, Antonio, 227 Cantarini, Simone, 202 Cantelli, Giacomo, 155-157, 1051, 1053, 1058, 1113 Cantino, Alberto, 179, 451, 452 Canton Ticino, 333 Cantoni, Abramo, 795 n. Canuti, Domenico Maria, 203 Capelli, Annibale, 683 Capello, Bianca, granduchessa di Toscana, 1195 Capilupi, Geminiano, 433, 1064 Capponi, Antonio, 997, 998, 1027 Capponi, Gino, 1134 Capponi, Luigi, cardinale, 194, 1081 n. Caprigliola (Aulla) (MS), 542 Capua (di) Colonna, Vittoria, 648 Capucci, Martino, 1111 Capurro, Francesco, 201 Caracena (de), marchese, v. Benavida de Caracena, Luis Carandini, Annibale, 49, 481 Carandini, Bartolomeo, 555, 889 n. Carandini, Giuseppe, 468, 878 Carandini, Prospero, 836 Carassiti, Giuseppe, 780 n. Caravaggio (Il) (Michelangelo Merisi, d.), 182, 239 Carbonieri, Luigi, 177, 899, 1111, 1134 Carchini, Filippo, 341 n. Cardi, Giovanni Pietro, 145 Cardoso (Gallicano) (LU), 557 Carignano (TO), 13 Cariola, Antonio, 196 Carissimi, Giacomo, 1070
1332
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Ciano d’Enza (RE), 537, 1276 Ciardi, Federico, 629, 633 Ciardi, Roberto Paolo, 657 Ciarlini, Giovanni Battista, 891 Ciarlini, Ippolito, 892 n. Cibei, Giovanni Antonio, 280 Cicala, Giovanni Battista, 1201 Cifrondi, Antonio, 206 Cignani, Carlo, 206, 207 Cigola, Giovanni Battista, 228 Cimador, Giovanni Andrea (“Finocchio”), 1083 Cimicelli, Giovanni Battista, 560, 561 Ciocchi, Carlo, 164, 166, 168, 171, 1059 Cioffi, Antonio, 1201 Cionini, Natale, 598, 1086, 1112 Cirillo *****, carmelitano scalzo, 768 n. Ciroldi, Sergio, 348 n. Ciroldi, Stefano, 648 Cisa, passo, 20 Cittadella, Luigi Napoleone, 153 Cittadini, Pier Francesco, 235 Civalieri, *****, avvocato milanese, 1218 Cividale (Mirandola) (MO), 625 Cividale del Friuli (UD), 15 Claudia, strada, 1268 Clemente (Il), v. Sogari, Prospero Clemente Maria Hofbauer, santo, 759 n. Clemente VII, papa, 148, 1092 Clemente VIII, papa, 3, 23, 24, 413, 454, 574 n., 593, 680, 688, 1043 n., 1077, 1159, 1160 n., 1162 n. Clemente X, papa, 1229 Clemente XI, papa, 1166 Clemente XIII, papa, 728, 1170, 1173 Clemente XIV, papa, 729, 1174 Cluny, 785 Clüver, Philipp, 859, 861 Coblenza, 1036 Coccapani Imperiali, Lodovico, 882 Coccapani Imperiali, Luigi, 872, 873 Coccapani, Alfonso, 595 Coccapani, Camillo, 188 Coccapani, Ercole, 689 Coccapani, Paolo, vescovo di Reggio E., 184, 402 n.
Coccapani, Pietro, 505 n. Cocchi, Filippo, 900, 925, 930 Cochin, Charles-Nicolas, 858, 859 Cock, Jérôme, 456 Codebò, Andrea, 711 n., 790, 791 Codebue, Giovanni Battista, 327, 353 Cognento (c/o Correggio) (RE), 610, 611 Cokain, Aston, 1227 Colbert de Croissy, Charles, 1228 Coleman, Edward, 1232 Colfi, Antonio, 374 Collecchia (Fivizzano) (MS), 544 Colognora (Pescaglia) (LU), 552 Colombaro (Formigine) (MO), 719 Colombi, Giuseppe, 435, 1064, 1065, 1068, 1071 Colombi, Luca, 333, 336 Colombini, Leonardo, 1202 Colombo, Cristoforo, 451 Colonge (de) Remaille, Louis, 703 Colonia, 1035, 1036 Colonna, Antonio, 434 Colonna, Ascanio, 105 Colonna, Giovanni Paolo, 435, 1066, 1067 Coltri, Giovanni Battista, 143 n. Comacchio (FE), 24, 50, 623, 693, 955, 10301032, 1035, 1037, 1123, 1151, 1156, 1160, 1164, 1166-1167 Comano (MS), 545 Comini, Giovanni (d. il Trevisano), 339 Compiano (PR), 1260, 1265 Concina, Daniello, 750 n. Concordia sul Secchia (MO), 624, 625, 631 Condillac (De), Étienne-Bonnot, 1117 Confalonieri, Federico, 838 Consalvi, Ercole, cardinale, 833, 1172 Conselice (RA), 25, 1160 Consetti, Antonio, 207, 208, 1105 Consiglio, Bonaventura, 784 Contardo d’Este, santo, 139, 146-148, 334, 419, 819 Contarelli, Francesco, 418 Contarini, Marco, 1069 Conti, Francesco, 737 n., 1145 Contini, Alessandra, 1182 n., 1183, 1187 n. Contri, Giovanni Battista, 510
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Castiglione di Garfagnana (LU), 27, 27, 554, 554-557, 568, 569, 930, 1211, 1214, 1218, 1221 Castiglione di Garfagnana, vicarìa, 551 Castiglione, Baldassarre, 809 Castiglioni, Silvestro, 877 Castro (BG), 1165, 1208 Castro, Paolo, 109 Catelani, Angelo, 179, 1073, 1074, 1112 Catellani, Domenico, 264 Cati, Lodovico, 1201 Cato da Castagneto, 503 n., 520 Cattajo, villa estense (c/o Padova), 173, 464, 841, 1248 Cattaneo, Carlo, 1144 Cattaneo, Gaetano, 748 n. Cattaneo, Giuseppe, 748 Cattaneo, Guglielmo, 1231 Cattaneo, Perseo, 654 Cattani, Alfonso, 681 Cattani, Filippo, vescovo, 539 Cattelani Degani, Franca, 1106 Cattini, Marco, 125 n., 576, 577, 582, 630, 1103, 1113 Caula, Sigismondo, 208, 341, 342 Cavalli, Francesco, 435, 1070, 1233 Cavani, Pierluigi, 125 n. Cavazzi, Alfonso, 1088, 1089 n. Cavazzoli (Reggio E.), 538 Cavazzoni Pederzini, Fortunato, 989 Cavazzuti, Giuseppe, 1109, 1110, 1113 Cavedoni, Bartolomeo, 836 Cavedoni, Celestino, 173, 175, 177, 179, 424, 1097, 1111, 1131, 1140, 1142, 1143 Cavedoni, Giacomo, 194, 1098 Cavedoni, Serafina Teresa Luigia, 762 n. Cavezzi, Fabrizio, 681 Cavezzo (MO), 229 Cavi, Giuseppe Maria, 1018 Cavicchi, Bonifacio, 771 Cavicchioli, Rinaldo, 357 Cavicchioli, Tamara, 125 n., 427 n. Cavour (di) Benso, Camillo, 1255 Cavriago (RE), 358, 516, 521, 535 Cazzola, Franco, 575 Carlo Alberto di Savoia-Carignano, re di
1333
Sardegna, 539, 834, 838, 840, 879 Ceccati, scultori e intagliatori, 355 Ceccati, Francesco Domenico, 355 Cecchi Gattolin, Enrichetta, 1104, 1105 Cecchi, Domenico, 465, 466 Cecchini, Pier Maria (“Fritellino”), 1080 n. Ceccopieri Maruffi, Franco, 1109 Ceccopieri, Felice, 632 Ceccopieri, Pietro, 658 Cecini, Fabrizio, 1181 n. Celeri, Francesco, 567 n. Cella (Della), Guglielmo, 722 n. Cella (Reggio E.), 535 Celli, Beatrice, 1112 Cellini, Benvenuto, 359 Censori, Anchise, 701 Cento (FE), 1160 Ceppelli, Ferdinando, 167 Ceretti, Felice, 362 n., 626, 627, 629 n. Cerreto, passo, 280, 560 Cerreto Alpi (Collagna) (RE), 1269 Cerretti, scultori e intagliatori, 355 Cerretti, Luigi, 658 n., 770 n., 1112, 1120 Cervi, Bernardino, 194-197, 199, 201, 202, 206, 208, 401, 402 n. Cervia (RA), 955, 1162 Cesena (FO), 236, 998 Ceserana (Fosciandora) (LU), 558 Cesi, Bartolomeo, 194 Cesi, Giovanni Battista, 505 n. Cestellino (Il), v. Traeri, Antonio Cesti, Antonio, 1069, 1070 Chambéry, 921 Chiabrera, Gabriello, 1119 Chiappini, Alessandra, 454 n. Chiappini, Luciano, 96, 691, 845 Chiari, Pietro, 1090, 1091 Chierici, Alfonso, 238, 240 Chierici, Gaetano, 538 Chiesa, Girolamo, 1081 n. Chiesi, Luigi, 899 Chiodelli, *****, speziale modenese, 775 n. Chiodini, Tommaso, 752 n. Chiusi (SI), 15 Cialdini, Francesco, 877 Ciampini, Giovanni Giusto, 1127
1334
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Cybo-Malaspina, Alberico I, principe di Massa, 652-54 Cybo-Malaspina, Alberico III, principe di Massa, 654 Cybo-Malaspina, Alderano, duca di Massa, 655, 665 Cybo-Malaspina, Alderano, marchese di Carrara, 653, 654 n. Cybo-Malaspina, Carlo I, principe di Massa, 654 Cybo-Malaspina, Carlo II, principe di Massa, 654 Cybo-Malaspina, Lorenzo, marchese di Massa, 652 Cybo-Malaspina, Maria Teresa, duchessa di Modena, 34-36, 134, 256, 275, 654-658, 665, 708, 1155, 1270
D’Annunzio, Gabriele, 1145 D’India, Sigismondo, 1064 Da Ponte, Oldrado, 890 n. Dal Sole, Giovan Gioseffo, 208 n. Dall’Oca, Carlo, 683 Dall’Olio, Giovanni Battista, 356, 934, 1073 Dall’Orto, Paolo, 684 Dallari, Giovanni, 383 Dallari, Giovanni Maria, 381-83, 963, 965 Dallari, Umberto, 1102, 1110, 111 Dalmazia, 71 Danti, Egnazio, 453 n., 457-459 David, Jacques-Louis, 227 De Amicis, Edmondo, 1144 De Grandis, Francesco, 1066, 1071 De Mauro, Marcello, 1201 De Nobili, Andrea, 1218 De Re, Natale, 395, 397 De Vergottini, Giovanni, 75 Degni, Demetrio, 998, 999 n. Deiana, Antonella, 585 n. Del Giudice, Carlo Alberto, 665 Della Bella, Stefano, 391, 393 Della Palude, Cesare, 708, 712, 714, 1102 Della Porta, Francesco, 1202 Della Porta, Lorenzo, 1267
Della Rena, Orazio, 1183, 1198 Della Rovere, Giulia, 680 Del Medico, *****, capitano, 703 n. Del Monte, Mario, 549 Del Piazzo, Marcello, 1189 Del Rio, Carlo, 538 Del Rio, Ercole, 561 Desani, Pietro, 199 Deseine, François-Jacques, 626, 863 Di Pietro Lombardi, Paola, 1111 Di Pietro, Pericle, 1106, 1107, 1111, 1113, 1114 Dianti, Laura Eustochia, duchessa di Ferrara, 24, 670, 683, 811, 814-817, 1032, 1043 n. Diaz, Furio, 1187 Didot, Firmin, 1007 Dietrichstein (von), Andreas Jacob, 1041 Dinazzano (Casalgrande) (RE), 538 Dinelli, Giulio, 498 n. Discalzi, Sigismondo, 1200 Dolce, Pietro, 834 Dolci, Carlo, 235 Domenichino (Il) (Domenico Zampieri, d.), 239 Domenico da Lugo, 432 Domenico di Cursini di Collecchia, 544 Domiziano, Tito Flavio, imperatore, 130 Donati, Benvenuto, 1111, 1112 Donati, Giovanni Battista, 364 n. Donizone di Canossa, 808 Donzi, Giovanni, 332 n., 387, 415, 417 Doria, Andrea, 1193 Dosso, Battista (B. Luteri), 370 Dosso, Dosso (Giovanni Luteri), 183, 370 Dotti Messori, Gianna, 1103 Dottori (de’), Carlo, 1119 Dover, 1229 Dragoni, Massimiliano, 595 Dresda, 36, 185, 195, 371, 951, 1040, 1102 Drugman, Giuseppe, 235 Dumont, Gabriel-Martin, 257 Duquesnoy, Frans, 329, 332 Düsseldorf, 1039 Du Tillot, Guillaume-Léon, 1271 Eckhart, Johann Georg, 1037
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Cook, James, 954 Cook, Thomas, 865 Coppa, Aurelia, 1083 Coppa, Giuseppe (“Virginio”), 1083, 1084 Copparo (FE), 458 Coppini, Matteo, 436 Cordero, Franco, 949 Cordovero, Moshe, 794 Corfù, 548 Corinaldi, Giuseppe, 107 Coriolano, Bartolomeo, 401 n. Coriolano, Giovanni Battista, 400, 401 Coris, Bernardo, 1082 Corletto (c/o Formigine) (MO), 595 Corlo (Formigine) (MO), 595 Corneille, Pierre, 1087, 1090 n. Corneille, Thomas, 1087 Coronelli, Vincenzo Maria, 860 Corradi, Augusto, 1110, 1113 Corradi, Bernardino, 702 Corradi, Domenico, 700, 703 Corradi, Giulio Cesare, 1093 Corradi d’Austria, Domenico, 463, 464, 700, 703 Corrado II di Franconia, imperatore, 818 Correggese, territorio, 466 Correggio (RE), 4, 54, 67, 234, 343, 349, 453, 461, 465, 521, 524, 526, 528, 535, 555, 562, 586, 601-605, 607-611, 613-615, 622, 702, 708, 712, 920, 938-940, 1086, 1151, 1274 Correggio (da), Gilberto, principe, 606 Correggio (da), Girolamo, cardinale, 649 Correggio (da), Maurizio, principe, 603, 605, 606 Correggio (da), Siro, principe, 139, 602, 603, 605, 622 Correggio (Il) (Antonio Allegri, d.), 386, 526 n., 863-865 Corsi, Lorenzo, 862 Corsini, scultori e intagliatori, 355 Corso, Rinaldo, 890 Corte (da), Giusto, v. Le Court, Just Cortenova (Corte) (c/o Novellara) (RE), 642 Cortese, Diofebo, 836 Cortese, Tiburzio, vescovo di Modena, 731-
1335
736, 763, 772 n., 781 n. Cortile (Carpi) (MO), 229 Cosenza, 548 Costa, *****, capitano, 703 n. Costa, Antonio Maria, 338 Costa, Cesare, 102, 103, 282 Costantini, Costantino (“Gradellino”), 1083 Costantini, Domenica (“Corallina”), 1083 Costes de la Calprenède (de), Gautier, 1001 Cotignola (RA), 25, 1160 Cotte (de), Robert, 863 Covarruvias (de), Carlo, 703 Cozza, Giuseppe, 567 n. Cracovia, 794 Cremasco, territorio, 1222 Cremona, 50, 526, 1152 Cremona Casoli, Antonio, 1109 Crescini, Francesco, 337 n. Crespellani, Arsenio, 360 n., 1098, 1110 Crespolani, Camillo, 235 Creti, Donato, 206 Cricca, Giacomo, 432 Cristiani, Beltrame, 1169 n. Cristina Wasa, regina di Svezia, 1237 n. Crivelli, Camillo, 892 n. Croce, Francesco, 270, 273 Croce, Giulio Cesare, 997 Crocioni, Giovanni, 1086 Crostolo, fiume, 284, 521, 525, 532, 637 Crotti, Giovanni, 890 n. Cuba, 954 Cucchiari, Domenico, 662 Cugini, Amtonio, 257 Cugini, Francesco Emilio, vescovo di Modena, 740,742 Cunegonda (o Cunizza) di Baviera, 818, 821 Cuoghi, Giuseppe, 900 Cuppini, Matteo, 353 Curini, Biagio, 1196 Curtatone (MN), 1133 Curti, Bernardino, 401-403 Curti, Patrizia, 162, 309, 317, 357, 1102 Cusatri, Beltramino, 517 Cybei, Giovanni Antonio, 855 Cybo, Francesco Maria, 339 Cybo, Maria, principessa della Mirandola, 621
1336
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
340 n., 529, 725, 826 n., 1225 n., 1234 Este (d’), Cesare, duca di Modena, 3, 13, 23-28, 40, 50, 53-55, 93, 94, 105, 106, 109, 116, 128-131, 133-135, 137, 141, 144, 145, 151-154, 182, 197, 306, 328, 329 n., 369, 370, 379, 385, 386, 388, 413, 432, 433, 481, 506, 523, 553, 555, 556, 580, 594, 596, 669, 670, 676, 679-684, 688-696, 699, 709, 711, 719-722, 816, 817, 826, 858, 910 n., 911, 921, 935, 1002, 1003, 1032, 1033 n., 1050 n., 1077, 1078, 1081 n., 1109, 1152, 1159-1162, 1164, 1184, 1186, 1191, 1192, 11961198, 1202, 1203, 1209, 1218 Este (d’), di S.Martino, Sigismondo, 620, 672 n., 812 n. Este (d’), Eleonora di Alfonso, 1081 n. Este (d’), Elisabetta, 167 Este (d’), Enrichetta, langravia d’AssiaDarmstadt, 1041, 1110, 1259, 1260, 1265, 1266, 1270 Este (d’), Ercole I, duca di Ferrara, 29, 126, 127, 133, 134, 140, 141, 153, 181, 380, 500, 505 n., 517, 519, 542, 543, 546, 589, 590, 620, 644, 672 n., 786, 804, 806, 812 n., 814, 858, 1050 n., 1051 n., 1223 Este (d’), Ercole II, duca di Ferrara, 130, 133, 137, 153, 370, 502, 520, 572 n., 574 n., 670, 676, 678, 681, 699, 721, 811, 814, 816, 908, 921, 1108, 1110, 1161, 1191 Este (d’), Ercole III, duca di Modena, 26, 34, 36, 42, 78, 89, 99, 100, 119, 134, 136138, 167-170, 171, 173, 209, 274, 275, 280, 285, 288, 310, 315, 383, 419, 426 n., 534, 564, 567, 584, 655, 707, 708, 715, 730-734, 770, 772, 773, 777, 797, 859, 915, 968, 983, 1109, 1155, 1156, 1169, 1172, 1246 Este (d’), Foresto di Borso, 32, 100, 200, 305, 306, 826 n., 1225 n. Este (d’), Foresto di Cesare, 557 Este (d’), Francesco di Alfonso I, 681, 815, 816, 1191 Este (d’), Francesco I, duca di Modena, 6, 18, 26, 29, 30, 41, 56, 57, 59, 60, 64, 65,
105, 134, 135, 137, 138, 144, 145, 148 n., 155, 181-184, 199, 200, 305, 328, 330, 336, 361 n., 369, 385, 389 n., 392, 414, 416 n., 423, 432, 433, 489, 492, 493 n., 524, 526, 559, 584 n., 594, 595, 603-605, 622, 701, 710, 724, 818-820, 826 n., 862, 912 n., 1004, 1082, 1093, 1117, 1120, 1151, 1162, 1169 n., 1228, 1257, 1258 Este (d’), Francesco II, duca di Modena, 19, 26, 31, 32, 42, 59, 60, 134, 136, 154-157, 160, 185, 328, 331, 332 n., 338, 340 n., 341, 369, 394, 417, 435, 489, 527, 529, 572 n., 702, 712, 725, 758 n., 819, 822, 824, 826 n., 827, 849, 1064, 1066, 1067, 1071 n., 1083, 1084, 1093, 1152, 1165, 1224, 1234, 1258, 1259, 1269 Este (d’), Francesco III, duca di Modena, 19, 26, 34-36, 42, 59, 61, 63, 78, 96, 99, 101 n., 108, 134, 136, 137, 139, 149, 160165, 167, 168, 172, 173, 185, 188, 259, 258, 261, 265, 266, 268, 271, 273-275, 277, 278, 280, 285, 286, 288, 307, 310, 313-315, 328 n., 365, 372, 381, 396, 417, 419, 422, 426, 437, 463, 464, 465 n., 529531, 533, 562, 563, 574 n., 585, 597, 624, 625, 631, 654, 655, 657, 703, 708, 712, 713, 715, 725 n., 726-730, 731 n., 733, 767 n., 770, 772, 773, 794, 851, 852, 855, 856, 866, 911, 919, 920-922, 929, 935, 954, 969 n., 972 n., 978, 982, 1029, 1030 n., 1040, 1041, 1042, 1046-1048, 1053, 1054-1056, 1087 n., 1093 n., 1094, 1095, 1106, 1109-1111, 1128, 1155, 1156, 1169, 1170, 1259, 1261, 1265, 1270 Este (d’), Francesco Maria, vescovo di Reggio E., 736 n., 746 Este (d’), Gian Federico, 397, 1223 Este (d’), Giulia, 1081 n. Este (d’), Ippolito (II), cardinale, 621, 670, 683, 816 Este (d’), Isabella, duchessa di Parma, 31, 1258, 1265 Este (d’), Isabella, marchesa di Mantova, 620, 809 Este (d’), Laura, duchessa della Mirandola, 619, 621, 654
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Emilia, 15, 46, 70, 456, 548-560, 628, 857, 918, 1027 Emilia, via, 20, 35, 96, 97, 99, 102, 106, 111, 115, 227, 262, 268, 314, 457, 460, 522, 528, 998, 1027 Empoli (FI), 1248 Enrico III di Valois, re di Francia, 1195 Enrico IV di Borbone, re di Francia, 24, 593, 700 Enrico VII di Lussemburgo, imperatore, 619 Enrico VII Tudor, re d’Inghilterra, 1227 Enrico VIII Tudor, re d’Inghilterra, 890 n., 1235 Ens, Gaspar, 859 Enza, fiume, 67, 516, 638, 1263, 1267, 1268, 1271, 1273, 1274, 1276 Equicola, Mario, 806, 809 Ercolani, Germanico, 1186 n., 1204, 1205 Ercole, Domenico Antonio, 1235 Erodoto di Alicarnasso, 9 Erri (degli), Benedetto, 141, 327 Erta, Manlio, 549 Este (PD), 24 Este (d’) (“Trotti”), Cesare (o Paolo), 681, 692, 696 Este (d’) , Federico Benedetto, 118 Este (d’) di S. Martino, Carlo Filiberto, 433 Este (d’) di S. Martino, Filippo, 681 Este (d’) di S. Martino, Lucrezia, marchesa di Massa, 652 Este (d’), Alberto Azzo II, 808, 818, 821 Este (d’), Alberto, signore di Ferrara, 784 Este (d’), Aldobrandino di Obizzo II, 818 Este (d’), Aldobrandino I, signore di Ferrara, 145 Este (d’), Aldobrandino III, signore di Ferrara, 905 Este (d’), Alessandro, cardinale, 24, 28, 152, 385, 671, 696, 724 n., 1079 n., 1160 n., 1217 Este (d’), Alfonsino, 681, 814 Este (d’), Alfonso di Alfonso I, 24, 679, 680, 683, 814, 816, 1044, 1152, 1191, 1192, 1195-1197 Este (d’), Alfonso I, duca di Ferrara, 24, 29,
1337
48, 133, 134, 144, 153, 181, 183, 487, 518-520, 546, 574 n., 591, 652, 670, 673 n., 678, 699, 811, 814-817, 823, 1032, 1033, 1043 n., 1153, Este (d’), Alfonso II, duca di Ferrara, 23, 24, 48, 109, 127-129, 131, 133, 134, 153, 157, 181, 182, 328, 380, 413, 432, 453, 455, 458, 504, 521, 572 n., 594, 653, 669, 670, 675-684, 686, 689, 691, 692, 694, 699, 709, 805, 811, 812, 815., 816, 823, 1032, 1077, 1078 n., 1079, 1152, 1160., 1161 n., 1184, 1186, 1191, 1192, 1217 n. Este (d’), Alfonso III, duca di Modena, 17, 25, 28, 29, 41, 48, 146, 155, 160, 195, 385, 493, 524, 556, 558, 594, 670, 693, 722, 723, 724 n., 790, 792, 817, 818, 826 n., 1000, 1109, 1151, 1206, 1225 n. Este (d’), Alfonso IV, duca di Modena, 26, 30, 31, 41, 134, 135, 155, 184, 331, 388, 392 n., 395, 414, 416, 419, 421 n., 433, 526, 527, 702, 711, 724, 819, 822-823, 1004, 1083, 1093 n., 1110, 1120, 1124, 1152, 1165, 1223, 1228, 1267 Este (d’), Almerico, 1110, 1266 Este (d’), Angela Maria Caterina, 824, 826 n., 1234 Este (d’), Anna, 921 Este (d’), Anna Beatrice, 619, 621 Este (d’), Azzo VI, 814 Este (d’), Azzo VIII, signore di Ferrara, 141 n., 483, 818 Este (d’), Beatrice (I), beata, 147, 334, 418, 819 Este (d’), Beatrice (II), beata, 147, 418, 819 Este (d’), Benedetto, 1156 Este (d’), Bianca Maria, 619, 620 Este (d’), Borso di Cesare, 481, 482, 557, 826 Este (d’), Borso, duca di Ferrara, di Modena e di Reggio, 13, 29, 132, 133, 153, 161, 169, 178, 335, 379, 507 n., 516, 517, 543, 551, 644, 807, 818, 907, 909, 913, 1051 n., 1153 n. Este (d’), Carlo Alessandro, 584 n. Este (d’), Cesare Ignazio, 31-33, 200, 332,
1338
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Farioli, Elisabetta, 228 Farioli, Giacomo, 839 Farnese, Antonio, duca di Parma, 1110, 1259, 1260, 1266, 1270 Farnese, Elisabetta, regina di Spagna, 1259 Farnese, Francesco Maria, duca di Parma, 397 n., 1261 Farnese, Margherita, duchessa di Modena, 32, 725, 827, 1093 n., 1234, 1258, 1259, 1265 Farnese, Maria, duchessa di Modena, 29, 1224, 1257, 1258, 1269 Farnese, Mario, 935 Farnese, Odoardo, duca di Parma, 30, 1162 n., 1163 n., 1259, 1261 Farnese, Ottavio, duca di Parma, 1276 Farnese, Ranuccio I, duca di Parma, 1258, 1263, 1276 Farnese, Ranuccio II, duca di Parma, 31. 1163 n., 1164 n., 1258, 1265 Farnese, Vittoria, duchessa di Modena, 30, 1258 Fasanini, Costanza, 890 n. Fasanini, Iacopo, 890 Fattori, Carlo, 838 Fattori, Giuseppe, 838 Fattori, Sante, 173 Fava Ghislieri, Nicolò, 75 Fava, Domenico, 159, 169, 173, 178, 1111, 1112 Favre de Péroges, Antoine, 921 Fazzano (Reggio E.), 609, 611 Febronio, Giustino, 902 Fedele (Il), informatore di Cesare d’Este, 695 Fedeli, organari ferraresi, 437 Federici, Fortunato, 1141 Federico II di Hohenzollern, re di Prussia, 125, 1039, 1040 Federico II di Svevia, imperatore, 105, 115, 126 Federico III d’Asburgo, imperatore, 132, 551 Federico III, di Schleswig-Holstein, re di Danimarca, 421, 1153 n. Federico Augusto III di Sassonia, re di
Polonia, 36, 64, 258, 422, 1039 Felice, Giovanni, 1201 Fellicarolo (Fanano) (MO), 355 Fenis, Bartolomeo, 393 n., 401 Fenis, Francesco, 393 Ferdinando I d’Asburgo-Lorena, imperatore, 1201, 1249 Ferdinando VI di Borbone, re di Spagna, 657 Fermo (AP), 784 Ferrara, 13, 16, 17, 23, 25, 27, 30, 45, 48, 50, 54, 67, 87, 93, 98, 109, 116, 127, 130132, 134, 140, 151-156, 157, 182, 184, 188, 194, 196, 305, 327, 329, 369, 379, 385, 413, 414, 418, 431, 432, 454, 457, 483, 513, 523, 542, 552, 565, 571, 589591, 593, 594, 619, 623, 636, 640, 641, 643, 644, 646, 647, 653, 669, 679, 683, 688-690, 695, 709, 723, 783, 789, 804, 808, 811, 813, 815, 816, 818, 823, 825, 857, 888, 905, 935, 936, 969, 1033, 1043, 1051, 1064, 1092, 1116, 1118, 1145, 1153, 1160, 1162-1164, 1168, 1172, 1182, 1184, 1185, 1190-1203, 1209, 1257 Ferrarese, territorio, 28, 48, 50, 454, 457, 458, 464, 1169, 1172, 1222 Ferraresi, Baldissera, 771 Ferrari (de’), Orazio, 202 Ferrari, Benedetto, 1091, 1092, 1093 n. Ferrari, Francesco, 142 n. Ferrari, Giacomo, 961 n. Ferrari, Giovanni Andrea, 381 Ferrari, Luigi, vescovo di Modena, 739 n., 740 Ferrari, Nicolò, 505 n. Ferrari, Paolo, 351 n. Ferrari, Paolo (d. il Burrasca), 567 n. Ferrari Moreni, Giorgio, 1010 Ferrari Moreni, Giovanni Francesco, 383, 1111 Ferrarini, Carlo, 535, 537 Ferraroni, Giovanni Maria, 262 Ferrati, Ercole, 340 n. Ferrero, Guglielmo, 71 Ferretti Garsi, Lorenzo, 317 n. Ferretti, Prospero, 892 n.
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Este (d’), Leonello, signore di Ferrara, 132, 153, 516, 507 n., 1051 n. Este (d’), Lucrezia, duchessa di Urbino, 24, 25, 593, 671, 675, 1161 n. Este (d’), Luigi di Borso, 200, 1225 n. Este (d’), Luigi di Cesare, 32, 199, 306, 556, 557 Este (d’), Luigi, cardinale, 671, 677, 678, 681, 683, 684, 695 Este (d’), Marfisa, 653, 654, 681, 1196 Este (d’), Margherita, duchessa di Guastalla, 1001 Este (d’), Maria, duchessa di Parma, 1258, 1265 Este (d’), Maria Beatrice, regina d’Inghilterra, 31, 332 n., 724, 725 n., 824, 1110, 1227-1237, 1267 Este (d’), Maria Beatrice Ricciarda, duchessa di Massa, 26, 35-38, 96, 169, 651, 655, 658-660, 663, 734 n., 833, 924, 1156, 1157, 1168, 1169 n., 1246, 1261 Este (d’), Nicolò (Pietro), 494 n., 1206 Este (d’), Nicolò di Rinaldo Maria, 620 Este (d’), Nicolò I, signore di Ferrara, 618 Este (d’), Nicolò III, signore di Ferrara, 7, 112, 132, 133, 153, 514-516, 541, 588, 589, 636, 637, 805, 906, 1051 n. Este (d’), Obizzo II, signore di Ferrara, 495, 498, 811 Este (d’), Obizzo, vescovo di Modena, 199, 401, 595, 723 Este (d’), Renata, 619 Este (d’), Rinaldo, cardinale (I), 329-331, 335, 401, 723, 724 n. Este (d’), Rinaldo, duca di Modena, 19, 26, 31, 33, 34, 42, 59, 60-62, 134, 136, 137, 143, 145, 147, 148, 149, 156-158, 160, 174, 255, 331, 341, 396, 397, 417, 463, 488, 528-530, 559, 560, 562, 617, 622, 624, 701, 705, 706, 712, 724, 725-727, 820 n., 822-824, 826, 849, 850, 1029, 1040, 1044 n., 1052, 1084, 1087 n., 1088, 1109, 1152, 1155, 1166, 1259, 1269 Este (d’), Rinaldo, signore di Ferrara, 905 Este (d’), Sigismonda, 23, 814 Este (d’), Tedaldo, 1258
1339
Estense-Tassoni, v. Tassoni-Estense Etherege, George, 1231 Eugenio da Alessandria, francescano, 749 n. Europa, 15, 22, 29, 35, 61, 258, 315, 559, 593, 595, 641, 657, 658, 817, 821, 833, 838, 851, 868, 869, 953, 958, 985, 1007, 1042, 1124, 1133, 1135, 1136, 1138, 1241 Evangelista da Gubbio, 683 Evelyn, John, 1232 n. Ezechiele, profeta, 822 Fabbri, *****, capitano, 703 n. Fabbriche di Vallico (LU), 552, 556, 557, 561 Fabbrico (RE), 602, 609-611, 639 Fabriani. Severino, 736 Fabrici, Pellegrino, 656 Fabricius, Johnann Albert, 1037 Fabricius, Rudolph Anton, 1037 Fabrizi, Carlo, 877 Fabrizi, Francesco, 703, 715 Fabrizi, Giuseppe, 1056 Fabrizi, Luigi, 877 Fabrizi, Nicola, 568, 843, 877 Fabrizi, Paolo, 569 Facchetti, Giovanni Battista, 433 Facci, Carlo, 78 Faenza (FO), 25, 381, 384, 593 Falconi, Bernardo, 333, 340 Falletti, Girolamo, 196, n., 812, 816, 821, 1050 Falloppia, Gabriele, 1123 Fanano (MO), 355, 499, 505, 507, 511 Fano (PS), 23 Fantaguzzi, Giuseppe, 228, 1104 Fantin, Benedetto, 579 Fantini, Achille, 909 n. Fantini, Bonifacio, 403 n. Fantoni, Giovanni (d. Labindo), 565 Fantuzzi, Giovanni Battista, 614 Farina, Giuseppe, 1144 Farina, Lucrezia, 1006, 1009 Farina, Salvatore, 1144 Farini, Luigi Carlo, 189, 548, 736 n., 738, 741, 931
1340
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Fosdondo (Correggio) (RE), 609, 611 Fossa (c/o Bibbiano) (RE), 521 Fossalta (Modena), 719 Fossi, Ferdinando, 1190 Foucault, Michel, 851 Fouché, Joseph, 73 Frabetti, Ariodante, 179 Francavilla al Mare (CH), 1144 Francesco da Lugano, 346 Francesco da Porto, 188 Francesco Giuseppe d’Asburgo-Lorena, imperatore d’Austria-Ungheria, 1247, 1249, 1250 Francesco II d’Asburgo-Lorena, imperatore, 1246 Francesco Stefano I di Lorena, imperatore, 1155, 1246 Franchi, Giuseppe, 282 Franchi, Lorenzo, 346 Franchini, Giuseppe, 363 n. Franchini, Sargente, 552 Francia, 7, 53, 61, 70, 73, 309, 467, 519, 559, 593, 677, 701, 740, 845, 849, 861, 920, 921, 962, 985, 987, 1001, 1082, 1108, 1136-1139, 1151, 1152, 1155, 1191, 1194, 1203, 1228, 1253 Francia (di), Renata, duchessa di Ferrara, 27, 670, 675, 810, 811, 823, 921 Francia, Francesco Maria, 396, 397 n., 401 Franciotti, Curzio, 1216 n. Francoforte sul Meno, 167, 1036 Frassoldati, Carlo, 1113 Frassoni, Cesare, 938, 1091 n., 1113 Frassoni, Francesco Nicola, 1090 n. Frassoni, Giacomo, 503 n. Fratta, Domenico Maria, 399, 401 n. Fregoso, Paolo, 649 Freschi, Domenico, 1070 Freto (c/o Modena), 1034 Frezza, Domenico, 396 Frignano, 11, 18, 19, 453, 459, 465, 469, 495501, 503, 505- 507, 509, 510, 551, 556, 563, 618, 716, 740, 842, 905, 920, 939, 941 Frigo, Daniela, 647, 1187 Friuli, 15
Frizzi, Antonio, 152, 690 Frosini, Alessandro, 312 Frugoni, Carlo Innocenzo, 1259 Fuentes (de) de Azevedo, Pedro, 553, 1214, 1215 n., 1217 Fuga, Ferdinando, 264 Gabardi, Gioacchino, 162, 166, 168, 1055 Gabrieli, Vincenzo, 123 Gabrielli, Domenico, 1064, 1067 Gabrielli, Francesco (“Scapino”), 1081 n, Gabrielli, Ippolita, 1083 n. Gadaldino, Paolo, 996 Gaddi, Giuseppe, 404 n. Gaffard, *****, governatore francese in Garfagnana, 561, 562 Gages (de) Dumont, Jean-Bonaventure, 563 Gaggio (Castelfranco E.) (MO), 310 Gagliardi, Scipione, 694 Galaverna (Il), v. Malagoli, Cristoforo Galbiati, Giovanni, 1110, 1112 Galeazzi, Girolamo, 681 Galeno, Claudio, 827 Galiani, Ferdinando, 74 Galilei, Galileo, 18 Galliani Coccapani, Giovanni, 892 n., 1029 Gallicano (LU), 553, 554, 556, 568, 924 Gallicano, vicarìa, 551, 569, 1211 Gallina, Franca, 801 n. Gallo, Agostino, 37 Galloni, Antonio, 264, 537 Galluzzi, Riguccio, 1190 Galvani, Cesare, 175 Galvani, Giovanni, 156, 165, 170-177, 665, 1098 Gambalone, canale, 1276 Gambara, Veronica, 649 Gambatacce, bosco, 1272 Gamberti, Domenico, 392, 394, 395, 401 n., 622, 820, 821-826, 1003-1005, 1012, 1015, 1017, 1093, 1120 Gambi, Lucio, 461 n. Gamorra, Gaetano, 839 Gandini, Alessandro, 1073, 1083 Gandini, Antonio, 1073
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Ferri, Antonio, 626 Ferri, Gaspare, 1068 Ferriani, Daniela, 226 Fiaccadon, Pietro, 142 n. Fiala Narici, Marzia (“Flaminia”), 1093 Fiala, Giuseppe Antonio, 1083 Fiandre, 184 Fiaschi, Angelo, 662 Fiasella, Domenico, 201 Fiattone (Gallicano) (LU), 557 Ficarelli, Angelo, vescovo di Reggio E., 537, 539 Fidenzi, Giacomo Antonio (“Cinzio”), 1082 n. Fieschi, Scipione, 652 Figatelli, Giuseppe Maria, 1025 Filippi, Camillo, 130 Filippo III d’Asburgo, re di Spagna, 135 Filippo IV d’Asburgo, re di Spagna, 137 Filippo V di Borbone, re di Spagna, 528, 1166, 1259 Finale Emilia (MO), 58, 67, 98, 112, 118, 209, 227, 380, 437, 455, 586, 618, 736, 789, 871, 938, 940-942, 1081, 1086, 1095, 1113 Finelli, Giuliano, 331 Finzi, Riccardo, 1109 Fiorano Modenese (MO), 198, 230, 237, 595, 723 Fiordibello, Giroldo, 516 Fiorenzi, Pasquino, 1099 Fiorilli, Silvio, 1080 n. Fiorilli, Tiberio (“Scaramuccia”), 1231 Fiorini, Vittorio, 75 Firenze, 12, 15, 50, 53, 200, 227, 229, 230, 233, 234, 236, 376, 417, 542, 546, 570, 666, 775, 842, 861, 990, 1134, 1135, 1185, 1193, 1195-1197, 1199, 1200, 1203, 1217, 1252 Firmian, Carlo, 1041, 1058 n. Fiumalbo (MO), 239, 499, 505, 507, 736 Fivizzano (MS), 542, 660, 924, 940, 1175, 1192, 1194, 1205, 1206 Flori, Ezio, 657 Florio, Francesco, 684 Florio, Giovanni Battista, 506 n.
1341
Florio, Gismondo, 693 Foà, Beniamino, 775 n. Foà, Mosè Beniamino, 164, 167, 952, 1008, 1014, 1055 Fogazzaro, Antonio, 1145 Foglia, Pietro, 612 Fogliani, Giuseppe Maria, vescovo di Modena, 727, 729, 731, 1019 Fogliani, Lucio, 497 n. Fogliani, Stefano, vescovo di Modena, 726, 727, 728 n. Fogliani Malchiavelli, Guido, 892 n. Fontainebleau, 193, 1227 Fontana, Armeno, 942 n. Fontana, Carlo Camillo, 896, 920 Fontana, Francesco, 393 Fontana, Francesco, 392 n., 393 Fontana, Giacomo, 136 Fontana, Giovanna, 1095 n. Fontana, Giovanni, 401 Fontana, Giovanni Antonio, 1009 Fontana, Giovanni, vescovo di Modena, 24 Fontana, Roberto, vescovo di Modena, 724 Fontanelli, Achille, 843 Fontanelli, Alfonso Maria, 689 Fontanelli, Alfonso Vincenzo, 161, 167, 256 n., 277, 656, 714, 1053, 1090 Fontanelli, Decio, 1083 n. Fontanesi, Giovanni, 238, 240-242, 350 Fontanini, Giusto, 1167 Forlì, 207, 436, 784, 1194 Formiggini, Angelo Fortunato, 799 Formiggini, Bonaventura, 118 Formiggini, Moisè, 798 Formigine (MO), 237, 336, 595, 618, 719, 975, 1113 Forni, Giuseppe, 662, 664, 1176 n. Forni, Paolo, 1110 Forno (Del), Mesino, 620 Fornovalasco (Vergemoli) (LU), 556, 1205, 1209 Forti, Israel, 952 Fortuna, Scipione, 1050 Foschiera Laderchi, Carlo, 1001, 1024 Foschieri Gualenghi, Sigismondo, 972 n. Foscolo, Ugo, 611, 1120 n. Fosdinovo (MS), 542, 658, 660, 662
1342
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Giffoni, Annibale, 352 Giganti, Antonio, 421 Gigli, Lorenzo, 495, 497 n. Giglioli, Alfonso, 684, 693 Giglioli, Francesco, 694 Giglioli, Girolamo, 153 Giglioli, Scipione, 692 Ginetti, Marzio, cardinale, 1163 Ginevra, 593 Gioacchino Murat, re di Napoli, 1248 Gioia, Alfonso, 153, 255, 1050, 1051 Giorgio I di Hannover, re d’Inghilterra, 1031 n., 1039, 1040, 1121 Giorgio II di Hannover, re d’Inghilterra, 1040, 1046 Giovagnoli, Raffaello, 1144 Giovanardi, Gaspare, 1029 Giovanardi, Sante, 353 Giovannetti, Francesco, 1201 Giovanni da Bazzano, 8 Giovanni da Sestola, cappuccino, v. Albinelli, Giovanni Giovanni di Toniolo, 488 Giovanni Guglielmo, conte palatino, v. Zweibrücken-Neuburg (di), Giovanni Guglielmo Giovanni Paolo II, papa, 741 n. Giovanni XXII, papa, 17 Giovannini, Carlo, 356 Giraldi, Giovanni Battista (d.Cinzio), 813, 118 Giraldi, Lelio Gregorio, 813 Giraldi, Orazio, vescovo di Comacchio, 693 Girolamo da Carpi, 370 Giromini, Renzo, 1112 Girouard, Mark, 369 Giulio II, papa, 503, 519, 1160 n. Giulio III, papa, 1192 Giuseppe I d’Asburgo, imperatore, 1152, 1154, 1166, 1241 Giuseppe II d’Asburgo-Lorena, imperatore, 148 n., 770 n., 777, 902, 1036, 1153, 1169 n., 1246 Giusti, Giuseppe, 1139 Giustiniani, Paolo, 787 n. Gnudi, Antonio, 1169 n., 1170 n.
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang, 857, 861 Goldoni, Carlo, 258, 1090, 1091 Goldoni, Carlo (n. 1822), 235, 238, 242 Golinelli, Paolo, 1029, 1100, 1109, 1111 Gonzaga, Curzio, 649 Gonzaga, Giovanni Francesco II, marchese di Mantova, 620, 642 Gonzaga, Margherita, duchessa di Ferrara, 109, 128, 678, 823, 1078 n. Gonzaga, Vincenzo, duca di Mantova, 128 Gonzaga di Guastalla, Ferrante III, duca, 1001 Gonzaga di Novellara, Alessandro I, 645 Gonzaga di Novellara, Alfonso I, 648 Gonzaga di Novellara, Annibale, 645 Gonzaga di Novellara, Camillo I, 648 Gonzaga di Novellara, Feltrino I, 636-638, 642, 646 Gonzaga di Novellara, Feltrino II, 642 Gonzaga di Novellara, Filippo Alfonso, 33 Gonzaga di Novellara, Francesco II,647, 648 Gonzaga di Novellara, Giacomo, 642 Gonzaga di Novellara, Giovanni Pietro, 644, 646 Gonzaga di Novellara, Guido, 636-638 Gonzaga di Novellara, Luigi, 636 Gonzaga di Novellara, Ricciarda, duchessa di Massa, 655 Gorani, Giuseppe, 307, 626, 715, 731 n., 798 Gorfigliano (Minucciano) (LU), 558 Gorini, Giovanni, 128, 130-132 Gozzadini, Giovanni, 519 Gragnola (Fosdinovo) (MS), 542, 546 Gran Bretagna, 1253 Grana, Daniela, 1112 Grandi, Alessandro, 413 Grandi, Taddeo, 920 Granelli, Giovanni, 162, 166, 1056 Granet, François-Marius, 241 Grassaleoni, Nascimbene, 590 Grassetti, Giovanni Antonio, 417 Grassi, Giovanni Battista, 649 Graziani, Girolamo, 490, 724, 1024, 1080 n., 1118, 1228
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Gandolfi, Gaetano, 236 Gandolfi, Mauro, 236 Garbi, Carlo Antonio, 333, 336 Garbieri, Lorenzo, 196 Garfagnana, 11, 18, 27, 28, 34, 36, 46, 48, 256, 453, 458, 459, 461, 465-467, 469, 523, 551-570, 623, 656, 660, 662, 665, 710, 712, 716, 872, 878, 920, 939, 941, 956, 1116, 1186, 1191, 1192, 1194, 1204, 1211, 1213, 1214, 1216-1220 Garimberti, Andrea, 725, 822 Garni, Domenico, 204 Garofali, Francesco, 497 n. Garuti, Alfonso, 197 n., 228, 231, 233, 235, 580 n. Gaspari, Gaetano, 1074 Gaspari, Giovanni Battista, 1040 Gastaldi, Giacomo, 457 Gattatico (RE), 534 Gatti, Bartolomeo, 338 n., 527, 724, 892 n., 1005 Gavasseti, Camillo, 649 Gavasseto (Reggio E.), 517 Gavassini, Cesare, 817 n. Gavazzi, Modesto, vescovo di Alife, 693 Gavignani, Giovanni, 352 Gavioli, Francesco, 1109, 1110 Gavioli, Giacomo, 365 n. Gavioli, Lodovico, 351 n., 365 Gazzadi, Domenico, 1134, 1138, 1139 Gazzata (S. Martino in Rio) (RE), 239 Gazzetti, Pietro, 753, 999 Gazzotti, Eugenio, 374 Gelasio II, papa, 720 Gello (Pescaglia) (LU), 557 Geminiano (I), santo, 125 n., 139, 140, 142145, 147-149, 719, 720, 850, 863, 1062 Geminiano da Montecreto, 498 n. Gemma “Frisio”, Rainer, 454, 464 Generali, Dario, 1044 n. Generali, Luigi, 836, 839 Gennari, Benedetto, 332 Genova, 50, 53, 166, 207, 270, 273, 652, 744, 855, 856, 963, 1048, 1155 Genovesi, Antonio, 74 Gerardo Maiella, santo, 759 n.
1343
Germania, 339, 426, 427, 519, 623, 639, 740, 861, 902, 962, 1035, 1036, 1038, 1172, 1194 Gerusalemme, 794 Gescomelli Alberini, Anna Alessandra, 761 n. Gessani, Pietro, 503 n. Gfollner, Johannes Maria, 796 n. Gherardi, Pietro Ercole, 185, 258 n., 1102 Gherardini, scultori e intagliatori, 355 Gherardini, Francesco, 332 n. Gherardini, Maurizio, 417 Gherardo di Zannino, 498 n. Ghibellini, Mario, 1113 Ghidoni, Enzo, 1113 Ghinarduzzi, Giulio, 1268 Ghiraldi, Gaetano, 228, 427 n., 1101 Ghisalberti, Carlo, 38 Ghizzoni, Manuela, 1103 Giacobazzi, Domenico Maria, 18, 148, 381, 921, 922, 1029 Giacobazzi, Luigi, 662 Giacomi, Nicolò (d. Fiorentino), 1202 Giacomo II Stuart, re d’Inghilterra, 31, 332 n., 724, 824, 1030 n., 1110, 1227, 1228, 1234-1237, 1267 Giacomo Trevisano, facchino, 684 Giampaoli, Stefano, 1113 Gianaroli, Daniela, 1044 n. Giannecchini, Giuseppe, 757 Giannettini, Antonio, 435, 436, 1064, 1067, 1068, 1071 Giannone, Pietro jr, 837, 1134, 1138, 1139 Giannotti, Antonio, 1065 Gianoli, Giuseppe Annibale,145 Gianturco, Carolyn, 1104 Giarda, Cristoforo, vescovo di Castro, 1163 n. Giardini, Giovanni Battista, 435, 1024, 1065-1068, 1071 Giardini, Pietro Giovanni, 703 n. Giardini, via, 64, 280, 511, 563 Giarini, Carlo Antonio, 336 Gibbon, Edward, 7, 422, 423, 865, 866 Gibbons, Grinling, 332 Gienietti, Nicolò, 418
1344
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Isachi, Antonio, 402 Ischl, 1271 Isola, Angiola, 1084 n. Istria, 71 Italia, 22, 70, 73, 93, 96, 184, 207, 241, 257, 264, 307, 418, 457, 518, 538, 557, 559, 589, 593, 615, 630, 746, 784, 790, 799, 806, 826, 857, 859, 862, 864, 867, 868, 937, 987, 989, 1000, 1034, 1042, 1044, 1054, 1087-1089, 1134, 1137-1140, 1144, 1153, 1154, 1157, 1165, 1166, 1192, 1199, 1215, 1219, 1237, 1241, 1242, 1247, 1251, 1254 Ivrea (TO), 15 Jacobi, Georg Arnald, 856 Jacoli, Ferdinando, 498 n., 1106 Jena, 1035 Jones, Thomas, 857, 859 Juan de Leon, 1081 n. Kant, Emmanuel, 71 Karcher, Giovanni, 370 Kauffmann, Angelica, 226 Kaunitz-Rietberg (von), Wenzel Anton, 902 Keller, Hagen, 14 Konopiste, castello (c/o Praga), 372 Korrte, Gottlieb, 1038 Kübeck, Carl Friedrich, 1249, 1251 La Binon, *****, commissario d’artiglieria, 700 La Spezia, 549 Laderchi, Giovanni Battista (d. l’Imola), 152, 153, 484, 485, 580, 689, 892, 908 n., 910 n., 1050, 1051, 1109, 1218 Lafayette (de), Marie-Joseph, 840 Lafreri, Antonio, 457 Lago Santo, 1197 Lalande (de), Joseph-Jérôme,165, 307, 419, 423, 860, 866, 1042 Lamberg, Dominik, cardinale, 1041 Lamberti, Giuseppe, 538
Lamberti, Iacopo, 75-77, 538, 895 Lamia, Salvatore, 502 n. Lammennais (de), Félicité-Robert, 900 Lamprecht, Johann, 701 Lana, Lodovico, 139, 144, 199-202, 206, 208, 231, 237, 401, 862 Lancellotti, v. Bianchi (de’) (o Lancellotti) Lancillotti, Carlo, 1026 Landerniani, Luigi, 89 Landi, Elisabetta, 309 Landi, Stefano, 1092 Lanfranco, Giovanni, 203 Langallerie (de) de Gentils, Philippe, 560 Lanzi, Pietro, 775 n. La Platière (de), Jean-Marie-Roland, 855, 857 Lasso (Di), Orlando, 649 Latis, Israele, 836 Lattes, Alessandro, 919 La Vallière (de), Jean-Florent, 701 La Vallière (de), Louise-Françoise, 1236 Lavagnini, Luigi, 1109 Lazio, 504, 1172 Lazzarelli, Mauro Alessandro, 202 Lazzoni, Andrea, 337, 339, 340 Lazzoni, Giovanni, 147, 332, 334, 336, 337, 339, 340 Lazzoni, Tommaso, 337, 339, 340 Lecco, 714 Le Court, Just, 338 Legnago (VR), 236 Legrenzi, Giovanni, 435, 1069, 1070 Lei, Pietro, 382 Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm, 421, 623, 825, 1030, 1031, 1033, 1035, 1037, 1052, 1126, 1156 Lelli, Ercole, 282 Lemasle, Luigi Nicola, 242 Lemizzone (Correggio) (RE), 610, 611, 613 Lemmi, Antonio, 562 Leonardi, Pietro, 664 Leone X, papa, 519, 520 Leone XI, papa, 1203 Leone XII, papa, 1170 n., 1173 n., 1174 Leonelli, Antonino, 725, 1099 Leoni, Pompeo, 130
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Graziani, Giuliano, 1001 Graziosi, Giuliana, 277 n. Greco, Francesco, 314 Greco, Ottavio, 626, 627 Gregorio XIII, papa, 23, 144, 453 n., 458 Gregorio XIV, papa, 23, 682 Gregorio XV, papa, 574 n. Gregorio XVI, papa, 738, 927, 1170 n., 1175 Greppi, Antonio, 658 n. Grifoni, Antonio, 1209 Grifoni, Ugolino, 1186 n. Grigoletti, Michelangelo, 239 Grillenzoni, Carlo Antonio, 1090 n. Grimelli, Geminiano, 902 Grodno, 794 Groppo S.Pietro (c/o Fivizzano) (MS), 542, 545, 546, 1195 Grossi, Giovanni Francesco (“Siface”), 1064, 1068, 1233 Guaitoli, Paolo, 571 n. Gualandelli, Lancillotto, 498 n. Gualandi, Diamante, 1095 n. Gualenghi, Camillo, 692, 695, 696 Gualenghi, Galeazzo, 696 Gualtieri (RE), 516, 521, 524-526, 823, 1268 Gualtieri, Crisostomo, 363, 364 n. Gualtiero, arcivescovo di Ravenna, 720 n. Guandalini, Gabriella, 1112 Guareschi, Francesco, 683 Guarini, Alessandro, 689 Guarini, Giovanni Battista, 1050 n., 1118 Guarini, Guarino, 849 Guarini, Ignazio, 1039, 1040 Guastalla (RE), 54, 452, 453, 465, 521, 528, 529, 534, 536, 539, 741, 926, 940, 948, 1175, 1176, 1276 Guastallese, territorio, 1273, 1274 Guelfo IV, duca di Baviera, 821 Guenzi, Alberto, 573, 576 n. Guercino (Il) (Francesco Barbieri, d.), 184, 200, 203, 402 n. Guerra, Domenico, 772 n. Guerra, Giovanni, 144, 1105 Guerra, Giovanni Battista, 705 Guerrazzi, Francesco Domenico, 1144, 1147 Gugli, scultori e intagliatori, 355
1345
Guglielmini, Anna, 1071 Guicciardi, Francesco, 1071 Guicciardi, Luigi, 735 Guicciardini, Francesco, 519, 520 Guicciardini, Francesco jr., 1199 Guicciardini, Lorenzo, 1186 n., 1208 Guidelli, Angelo, 876 Guidi, Domenico, 331, 340 n. Guidi, Giuseppe, 333 Guidoni, Bartolomeo, 1206 Guidoni, Francesco, 116 Guidoni, Giovanni Battista, 502 n. Guidugli, Antonio, 567 n. Guiglia (MO), 711 Guisa (di) Lorena, Claudio, 1191 Guzzaletti, Giovanni Maria, 144 Hackermann, Friedrich August, 1052 Halle, 921 Hameran, Ottone, 148 Hamilton, Gavin, 226 Hannover, 1037, 1039, 1041 Haskell, Francis, 182 Hasse, Adolf, 1040 Hermans, Willem, 434, 435 Hesse-Cassel (zu), Karl, 863 Hinojosa (de la), v. Mendoza (de), Juan Hurtado Hügel (von), Karl, 1252 n. Hyde, Anna, regina d’Inghilterra, 1235 Iddiano (Pavullo n. Frignano) (MO), 499, 505 Imhof (von), Jacob Wilhelm, 1037 Imola (BO), 1194 Ingannati, Rinaldo, 488 n. Inghilterra, 13, 31, 824, 860, 958, 962, 985, 1227, 1230, 1232, 1236, 1237, 1266 Ingone, vescovo di Modena, 783 Ingoni, Giovanni Battista, 193 Innocenzo IX, papa, 23 Innocenzo X, papa, 1163 n., 1164 n. Innocenzo XI, papa, 1232 Innocenzo XII, papa, 33 Ionie, isole, 71
1346
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Luigi XV di Borbone, re di Francia, 280 n. Lulier, Giovanni Lorenzo, 1068 Lunigiana, 36, 280, 469, 541, 542, 546-549, 567, 568, 662, 716, 838, 878, 930, 1186, 1196, 1206, 1272 Luosi, Giuseppe, 632 Lutero, Martino, 166 Luzio, Alessandro, 647, 834 Luzzara (RE), 521, 528, 1276 Mabillon, Jean, 743 n., 1053 n. Mac Donald, Jacques-Étienne, 733 Maccari, Giovanni (d. il Mirandolano), 361 n., 362 n. Macerata, 162, 555 Machiavelli, Niccolò, 71, 637, 959 Madrid, 54, 137, 555 Maestri, Augusto, 1109, 1110 Maestri, Giuseppe, 757 Maffei, Giuseppe, 1141 Maffei, Scipione, 417, 1088 Maggesi, Pietro Paolo, 566, 567 n. Maggi, Carlo Maria, 1038 Magini, Giovanni Antonio, 458-461, 860, 1167 n. Magnani, Enea, 621 Magnani, Teresa, 771 Magnanini, Pellegrino, 503 n. Magnoni, Lodovico, 757 Mainardi, Francesco, 700 Mainardo da Renno, 498 n. Mainoni, Luigi, 1105 Majocchi, Francesco Antonio, 753 n. Malagoli, Cristoforo (d. il Galaverna), 116, 117, 312, 313 Malagoli, Giambattista, 164, 274, 365 Malagoli, Giovanni Andrea, 836 Malaguzzi Valeri, Ippolito jr., 538 Malaguzzi Valeri, Ippolito sr., 1089 n. Malakh, Haym, 794 Malamini, Baldassarre, 434 Malascaja, Squadrone, 517 Malaspina, Alessandro, 855, 859 Malaspina, Alfonso, 694 Malaspina, Annibale, 580 n.
Malaspina Antonio Alberico II, marchese di Massa, 652 Malaspina, Cornelio jr, 581 n. Malaspina, Federico, 581 n. Malaspina, Galeotto, 546 Malaspina, Giovanni Battista, 855 Malaspina, Leonora, 652 Malaspina, Ricciarda, marchesa di Massa, 652 Malaspina di Castel dell’Aquila, Galeotto, 545 Malaspina di Castel dell’Aquila, Leonardo, 545 Malaspina di Olivola, Bernabò, 541 Malaspina di Olivola, Opizzone, 541 Malaspina di Olivola, Raffaele, 541 Malaspina di Suvero, Torquato, 1199, 1200 Malaspina di Treggiana, Francesco, 1185, 1199, 1203 Malaspina Cornelio sr, 694 Malatesta, Adeodato, 225, 229, 231-239, 242, 404 n., 1105, 1112 Malatesta, Massimiliano, 236, 237 Malavolti, *****, capitano, 1208 Malembra, *****, avvocato milanese, 1218 Maligin, Ignazio, 1258 Malmusi, Carlo, 266, 269, 1112-1114 Malmusi, Giuseppe, 740 Malthus, Thomas Robert, 954 Malvasia, Anton Galeazzo, 889 n. Malvasia, Carlo Cesare, 89, 206 Malvasia, Cesare, 285 Malvasia, Cornelio, 361 n., 1093 n. Malvasia, Innocenzo, 57 Malvezzi, Girolamo, 694 Malvezzi, Pirro, 553, 555, 1198, 1215 Mancasale (Reggio E.), 538 Mandosio, Carlo, 1048 Mandrio (Correggio) (RE), 609, 611 Mandriolo (Correggio) (RE), 609, 611 Mandrisi, Cesare, 710 Manelli, Francesco, 1092 Manfredi, Carlo, 398, 39 Manfredi, Leopoldo, 391 n. Manfredini, Francesco,1138 Manganelli, Rosa, 535
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Leopardi, Giacomo, 1120, 1136, 1138 Leopardi, Monaldo, 1116, 1134-1137 Leopoldo I d’Asburgo, imperatore, 822, 1152 Leopoldo II d’Asburgo, imperatore, 909, 1246 Leroy, Jean-François, 264 Lesignana (Modena), 231 Levante, 133, 136 Levatella, canale (c/o Carrara), 665 Levi, Abram Lustro, 148 n. Levi, David, 148 n. Levi, Salomone Abram, 961 n. Levizzani, Ippolito, 873, 878 Levizzani, Orazio, 506 Levizzano Rangone (Castelvetro) (MO), 160, 1142 Licciana Nardi (MS), 546, 547, 549, 662 Liechtenstein (di), Anna Maria, principessa, 1041 Ligonchio (Reggio E.), 520 Ligorio, Pirro, 182, 196, 413, 813 Ligorzano (Serramazzoni) (MO), 362 Liguria, 549, 1172 Linari, strada, 542, 545-547 Linati, Claudio, 840 Linati, Ottavio Lione, 61, 167, 264 Lipsia, 167, 421, 535, 921, 951, 1035-1037 Lirelli, Antonio, 836 n. Lisbona, 178 Litta, Antonio, 562 Litta, Pompeo, 1261 Liverani, Francesco, 1112 Livorno, 238, 283, 583, 990 Locatelli, Francesco, 704 Locke, John, 954 Lodi (MI), 381, 714 Lodi, Giovanni, 205 n. Lodi, Rodolfo, 205 n. Lodoli, Carlo, 287 Loiani, Francesco, 681 Lolli, Eustachio (“Fichetto”), 1082 n. Lolli, Flaminio, 628 Lombardi, Antonio, 154, 157, 159, 163, 167169, 171-176, 334, 1059 Lombardia, 15, 30, 71, 96, 258, 259, 275, 307,
1347
468, 567, 833, 857, 953, 1041, 1047, 1133, 1152, 1155-1158, 1208, 1209, 1215, 1242 Lombardo-Veneto, 927, 990, 991, 1253 Lonati, Ambrogio, 1070 Londra, 31, 32, 167, 309, 332, 359, 583, 840, 841, 990, 1037, 1039, 1083, 1139, 1155, 1227-1229, 1231, 1232, 1235 Longhena, Baldassarre, 338 Longo, Pietro, 498 n. Loraghi, Antonio, 336, 337 Loraghi, Tommaso, 88, 332, 333, 336 Lorena, 1198 Lorena (di), Cristina, granduchessa di To-scana, 1198 Lorena (di), Leopoldo II, granduca di To-scana, 364 n., 570, 879, 1133 Lorena-Mercoeur (di) de Vaudemont, *****, madamigella, 680 Lorena-Mercoeur (di) de Vaudemont, Luigia, regina di Francia, 680 Lorenzini, Carlo (d. Collodi), 1133 Lorenzo da Massenzatico, 196 Loreto (AN), 861 Loschi, Lodovico Antonio, 288, 954 Loschi, Pellegrino Nicolò, 161, 162, 288, 933-935, 937, 938, 940, 1054 Lubiana, 1158 Lucano, Marco Anneo, 1038 Lucca, 15, 27, 337, 566, 568, 1092, 1187, 1193, 1194, 1212, 1214, 1215-1218, 1248, 1262 Lucchesi, Carlo, 1112 Lucchesia, territorio, 505, 567 Lucchesini Francesco, 581 n. Lucchesini, Iacopo, 554 n. Lucchesini, Niccolò, 581 n., 1222 n., 1223 Lucchi, Marta, 1112 Lucenti, Domenico, 97, 267, 273, 311 Lugli, Giuseppe, 887, 900 Lugo (RA), 25, 1160, 1161 Luigi Filippo di Borbone-Orléans, re dei Francesi, 841, 1137 Luigi XIV di Borbone, re di Francia, 146, 147, 148 n., 370, 559, 700, 706, 863, 1165. 1228, 1234
1348
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1246 Massa, Giovanni, 352 Massalombarda (RA), 25, 816, 1160 Massard, Jacques, 1236 Massari, Giovanni Battista, 99, 276, 311 Massenzatico (Reggio E.), 610 Massese, territorio, 708 Massimiliano I d’Asburgo, imperatore, 645, 646, 1242 n. Massimiliano II d’Asburgo, imperatore, 1201 Matilde di Canossa, 188, 589, 720, 758 n., 807, 813, 817, 818 n. Matteucci, Anna Maria, 307, 311, 317 n. Matteucci, Girolamo, vescovo di Ragusa, 935 Mattia I Corvino, re d’Ungheria, 176 Mattioli Bertacchini, Giacomo, 878 Mattioli, *****, armaiolo modenese, 362 Mattioli, Lodovico, 396 Maturin, Charles-Robert, 1237 n. Mazelli, Marco, 352 Mazza, Angelo, 237 Mazza, Francesco, 710 Mazza, Giuseppe Maria, 348 Mazza Monti, Maria, 1258 Mazzarelli, Andrea, 680 Mazzarino, Giulio, cardinale, 30, 146, 526, 559, 723, 724, 820, 823, 1152, 1165, 1229 Mazzarino, intagliatore, v. Mazzerini, Marc’Antonio Mazzarino, Margherita, 146, 820 Mazzaroli, Giovanni, 701 Mazzerini, Marc’Antonio, 342 Mazzini, Giuseppe, 538, 836, 846 Mazzoli Leazzari, Gherardo, 889 n. Mazzoli, Gherardo, 785 Mazzoni, Giuseppe, 341 n. Mazzoni, Guido (d. il Modanino), 327, 1227 Medebach, Girolamo, 1091 Medici (de’), Antonio, 1204 Medici (de’), Cosimo di Pietro, 1205 Medici (de’), Cosimo I, duca di Toscana, 680, 816, 1182 n., 1183 n., 1184, 1186, 1187 n., 1188 n., 1191-1194, 1196, 1200,
1201 Medici (de’), Cosimo II, granduca di Toscana, 555, 1204 Medici (de’), Eleonora, duchessa di Mantova, 1191 Medici (de’), Ferdinando I, granduca di Toscana, 1187 n., 1200, 1202, 1205 Medici (de’), Francesco, 1204, 1205 Medici (de’), Francesco (Maria) I, granduca di Toscana, 1187 n., 1191, 1195, 1198 Medici (de’), Giovanni, 1080, 1195 Medici (de’), Giulio, 1185, 1205 Medici (de’), Lucrezia, duchessa di Ferrara, 678, 1184, 1191, 1200 Medici (de’), Pietro, 1199, 1200, 1205 Medici (de’), Virginia, duchessa di Modena, 670, 676, 680, 682, 689, 816, 1184, 1192, 1196, 1197, 1204 Medici, Raffaello, 1197, 1198 Mediterraneo, mare, 452 Medolla (MO), 202, 461 Mei, Filippo, 1221 Melani, Alessandro, 1069, 1071 Melani, Iacopo, 1069, 1071 Mellan, Claude, 394 Mellini, Vienna, 1071 Melzi d’Eril, Francesco, 610 Memmingen, 1038 Menafoglio, Emilio, 972 n. Mencke, Carl Otto, 1035, 1037 Mencke, Friedrich Otto, 1035, 1037 Mencke, Johann Burchard, 1035, 1037, 1038 Mencke, Otto, 1035, 1037 Menconi, Pietro, 662 Mendez, Ferdinando, 1201 Mendoza (de) Hurtado, Juan, 556 Menotti, Achille, 1134 Menotti, Celeste, 841 Menotti, Ciro, 13, 21, 38, 547, 704, 737, 836, 837, 839, 841-846, 877, 986, 988, 1099, 1106, 1109, 1133-1136, 1140, 1141 Menotti, Giuseppe, 986, 988 Menotti, Virginia, 845 Menziani, Alberto, 1109 Merano, 1151 Mercati, Angelo, 1112
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Manicardi, Antonella, 1112 Manini, Romualdo, 25 Manley de la Rivière, Mary, 1237 Mannheim, 425 Manni, Graziano, 372 Manodori, Pietro, 539 Manoello, Vitale, 784 Manriquez, Giorgio, 1214 Mantes, Gaio Petronio, 358 Mantova, 50, 54, 65, 177, 373, 459, 523, 569, 593, 622, 624, 625, 636, 638-643, 647, 714, 842, 845, 861, 907, 1155, 1198, 1204, 1206, 1215, 1231, 1276 Mantovani, Francesco, 329, 330 n. Mantovano, territorio, 48, 50, 628 Manuzio, Aldo, 1007 Manzini, Camillo Lodovico, 840, 841 Manzini, Ferdinando, 231, 360 Manzini, Giacomo, 354 Manzini, Giovanni, (s. XV), 542 Manzini, Giovanni, (s. XIX), 351 n. Manzini, Giuseppe, 359 Manzini, Luigi, 229-234, 237, 242, 1105, 1112 Manzini Della Motta, Giovanni, 542 Manzoni, Alessandro, 1120, 1144 Manzotti, Giovanni, 835 Manzuoli, Camillo, 555 Maranesi, Francesco, 836 Maratozzi, Giuseppe, 119 Marazzani, Alessandro, 1266 Marcelli, Umberto, 78, 658, 659 Marche, 50, 784, 1172 Marchelli, Domenico, 350 Marchelli, Giuseppe, 350 Marchelli, Pietro, 350 Marchello, Giuseppe, 205 n. Marchetti, Carlo, 662 Marchetti, Enrico, 1111 Marchetti, Paolo, 329 n. Marchino, garzone reggiano, 522 Marchisio, Filippo Giuseppe, 426, 920 Marcellino, v. Adriani, Marcello Marco da Brescia, 126 Maremma, 509 Mari, *****, corrispondente parmense, 1271 Maria Laura, suora della Visitazione, 1233
1349
Maria Teresa d’Asburgo, imperatrice, 35, 37, 96, 532, 562, 734 n., 777, 1036, 1123, 1155, 1243 n., 1245, 1246 Mariani, Pietro, 1041 Marigliana (c/o Castelnuovo Garf.) (LU), 556 Marigny (de) Poisson, Abel, 858 Marinali, Orazio, 332, 339 Marinelli, Giuseppe, 418 Marini, *****, p., minore osservante, 747 n. Marini, Chiara, 315 Marini, Lino, 27, 922 Marino, Giovanni Battista, 1119, 1121 Mario, Baldassarre, 331 n. Marmiroli, Renato, 1110 Maroncelli, Pietro, 838, 842 Marsiglia, 538, 843 Marsili, Anton Felice, 1117 Marsili, Luigi Ferdinando, 206, 1166 Martelli, Camilla, 680, 1184, 1192, 1196 Martello, Pier Iacopo, 1087, 1089 Martinelli Braglia, Graziella, 164, 1110, 1112 Martinelli, Giuseppe, 893 n. Martinengo, Camillo, 689 Martini, Giovanni Marco, 1065 Martinica, 954 Martino, Giovanni, 337 n. Martinozzi, Laura, duchessa di Modena, 6, 26, 30-32, 41, 146, 155, 331, 337, 395, 414, 419, 433, 435, 526, 527, 724, 802, 819, 822, 824-826, 827, 1065, 1083, 1093 n., 1109, 1110, 1152, 1228, 1229, 1234 Marzari, Francesco, 1201 Mascherpa, Romualdo, 836 n. Maschio, Lattanzio, 146, 333, 335-338, 342, Giuliano, 817 n. Masdoni, Lodovico, vescovo di Modena, 725, 726 Masdoni, Marcello, 396 n. Masdoni, Maurizio, 581 n. Masdoni, Tiburzio, 329 Masi, Giovanni Battista, 1157 Masotti, Angelo, 567 n. Massa, 4, 34, 36, 261, 337, 463, 465, 469, 566-568, 570, 623, 651, 652, 655, 656, 659, 661, 662, 665, 704, 705, 708, 716, 717, 741, 930, 942, 1109, 1113, 1176,
1350
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Montechiarugolo (PR), 537 Montecreto (MO), 499 Montecuccoli, Alfonso, 580 n. Montecuccoli, Antonio, 713 Montecuccoli, Enea, 689, 580 n. Montecuccoli, Giovanni Battista, 580 n. Montecuccoli, Luigi, 692, 694 Montecuccoli, Massimiliano, 497 n., 552, 581, 694 Montecuccoli, Raimondo, 21, 30 Montecuccoli Laderchi, Raimondo, 361 n. Montecuccolo (Pavullo n. Frignano) (MO), 497, 499, 505, 920 Montefani Caprara, Lodovico Antonio, 1167 n. Montefiorino (MO), 356, 505 Monteforte (c/o Montese) (MO), 499 Montegarullo (c/o Pavullo n. Frignano) (MO), 499 Montegibbio (Sassuolo) (MO), 1113 Montemagni, Desiderio, 1186 n., 1207 Monteperpoli (c/o Castelnuovo Garf.) (LU), 556 Monterotondo (c/o Castelnuovo Garf.) (LU), 556 Montesquieu (de) de Secondat, Charles, 311, 864 Monte Simone, v. Monti (Licciana N.) Montetortore (Zocca) (MO), 760 Montfaucon (de), Bernard, 158, 1053 Monti (Licciana N.) (MS), 542 Monti, Gian Giacomo, 337, 1070 Monti, Paolo, 1018, 1026 Montini, Camillo, 684 Montini, Montino, 680 Montpellier, 921 Monzani, Geminiano, 363 n. Monzone (Pavullo n. Frignano) (MO), 437, 498 Mor, Carlo Guido, 1106, 1111, 1112 Morandi, Giuseppe, 163 Morano (da), Giovanni Antonio, 876 Moreali, Giovanni, 837 Morelli, Lazzaro, 331 Morelli, Pietro, 337 n. Morely, *****, epigono di P. Clüver Moreni, Giacomo, 497 n. Mori, Ferrante, 682 Mori, Giulio, 682 Morigi, Paolo, 1000, 1022
Morini, Mariano, 362 Morretta, Rocco, 1109 Morselli, Alfonso, 1109, 1110, 1113 Mortier, Pierre, 865 Mosti-Estense, Ercole jr, 497 n. Mosti-Estense, Ercole sr, 152, 695 Mosti-Estense, Tommaso, 152 Motrone (Borgo a Mozzano) (LU), 552, 557 Mottet (de), Beat Ludwig, 713 Mozza, Francesco, 1267 Mucciatella (Quattro Castella) (RE), 521 Mugnano, v. S. Martino di Mugnano Mulazzo (MS), 548, 1273 Müller, Teresa, 233 Munari, Pellegrino, 143 n. Munarini, Giovanni Battista, 730, 770 n., 772 n., 773, 852-853, 952, 954, 959, 961 Mundici, Geminiano, 236 Muratori, Lodovico Antonio, 7, 9, 34, 35, 61-63, 156, 158, 160-162, 170, 174, 255, 256, 258, 260, 261, 266, 272, 275, 278, 284, 286-288, 307, 381, 401, 417, 418, 421, 463, 464 n., 606, 608, 623, 725, 726, 730, 743, 744, 748 n., 769n., 784, 799, 825-827, 857, 894, 935 n., 939, 981, 1029-1041, 1043 n., 1044 n., 1045 n., 1047, 1052-1054, 1056, 1057, 1087, 1088, 1094, 1098, 1107, 1111, 1112, 1113, 1116, 1117, 1121-1127, 1156, 1167, 1186, 1223 Murillo, Bartolomé Esteban, 237 Murray Baillie, Hugh, 370 Museto (di), Guglielmo, 784 Musi, Maria Maddalena, 1069 Mussati, Giovanni, 209 Muzioli, Andrea, 161 Muzioli, Giovanni, 161 Muzzioli, Giuliano, 1029, 1100 Nachtel, François, 748 n. Namias, Angelo, 1098, 1099 Namur, 700 Nannini, Marco Cesare, 1110, 1112, 1113 Napoleone I Bonaparte, imperatore dei Francesi, 26, 69-78, 80, 169, 288, 310,
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Mercatore (Gerhard Kremer, d.), 461 Mercurio, canale (c/o Massa), 665 Mercy (de), Florimonde-Claude, 529 Mesola (FE), 1168, 1169 Messori Roncaglia Mari, Maria Teresa, 1109, 1110, 1112 Metastasio (Pietro Trapassi, d.), 1040 Metra (Minucciano) (LU), 553 Metternich (von), Klemens, 611, 833, 834 n., 841, 879, 1172 n., 1249, 1251 Miari, Aurelio Agostino, 893 n. Michelasi, Antonio, 1000 Michele da Ferrara, 327 Michele da Firenze, 140 Michele Ungaro, 338 Micheletti, Daniele, 694 Michelucci, Massimo, 1109 Michetti, Paolo, 1145 Middleton, Thomas, 1227 Mignoni, Angelo, 242 Milanese, territorio, 6, 723 Milano, 11, 13, 14, 35, 54, 70, 71, 78-80, 96, 119, 123, 158, 165, 167, 255, 259, 273, 274, 282, 314, 315, 354, 376, 404, 522, 553, 554, 556, 557, 567, 640, 644, 710, 713, 714, 720, 732, 740, 838, 857, 907, 916, 918, 920, 925, 954, 957, 959, 960, 961, 963, 1048, 1133, 1152, 1157, 1213, 1215, 1216, 1218, 1242, 1276 Milano, Ermesto, 125 n., 427 n., 1101 Milanti, Bonaventura, 747 n. Milizia, Francesco, 257 n., 273 Minardi, Tommaso, 227, 228, 238 Minari, Fedele, 362, 363 n. Minerbetti, Vittorio, 130 Minghetti, Prospero, 227-229, 238, 241 Minozzo (Villa Minozzo) (RE), 517 Minucciano (LU), 924, 1211 Minucciano, vicarìa, 553, 568 Minutoli, Girolamo, 1223 Mirandola (MO), 4, 50, 54, 67, 230, 313, 453, 459, 461, 465, 563, 576, 586, 617-626, 628-630, 632, 639, 702, 703, 708, 713, 715, 871, 920, 931, 939-941, 957, 963, 986, 1078, 1110, 1115, 1116, 1192 Mirandola, Giulio, 128, 129
1351
Mirandolese, territorio, 48, 466 Mirteto (Massa C.), 660 Mischioso (c/o Frassinoro) (MO), 505 Misley, Enrico, 836, 838-843, 845, 846 Misson, Maximilien, 859-863, 866 Mitelli, Giuseppe Maria, 403 Mittermayer, Karl Josef Anton, 902 Menafoglio, *****, colonnello dei Dragoni, 714 Modena, Baruch, 794 Modenese, territorio, 7, 380, 453, 455, 457, 553, 570, 593, 594, 630, 733, 938, 953, 958, 975, 1205 Modestino Pistoiese, 1201 Molazzana (LU), 553, 558 Molière (Jean-Baptiste Poquelin, d.), 539, 1089 n. Molza, Alfonso, 682 Molza, Carlo, vescovo di Modena, 850 Molza, Ettore, vescovo di Modena, 401, 725 Molza, Francesco Maria, 141 n. Molza, Giuseppe, 177 Molza, Nicolò, 1094 Molza, Tarquinia, 722 Monaco di Baviera, 1035 Monanni, Bernardo, 1186 n., 1209 Moncalieri (TO), 376 Moncerrato (Prignano s. Secchia) (MO), 753 Monferrato, 555, 1204 Monge, Gaspar, 169 Moniglia, Giovanni Andrea, 1024 Montagioli, Cassiodoro, 743, 744 Montagnani, Roberto, 1109 Montaltissimo (Molazzana) (LU), 556 Montanara (Curtatone) (MN), 1133 Montanari, Geminiano, 361, 1123 Montanari, Giovanni, 999, 1008, 1014, 1020 Monte Alfonso, forte (c/o Castelnuovo Garf.), 466, 555, 561, 563, 565, 566, 701, 702, 708, 717 Montecassino (Cassino) (FR), 744 Montecatini, Antonio, 152, 692 Montecchi, Giorgio, 141 n., 281, 1111 Montecchio (RE), 520, 537, 594, 816, 938-940, 1276 Montecenere (Lama Mocogno) (MO), 499
1352
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Orsini, Giuseppe, 666 Ortalli, Giuseppe, 658, 660 Ortelio, Abramo, 461 Ortonovo (SP), 660 Ostini (de), Fabrizio, 1248 Ottonelli, Giovanni Domenico, 1081 n. Ottonelli, Giulio, 152, 153 Ottoni, Lorenzo, 341 n. Owen, John, 856 Oxford, 383 Pacchioni, Antonio, 435 Pacchioni, Francesco, 195, 346 Pacchioni, Prospero, 329, 346 Pacciani, Fulvio, 890, 910 n. Pacciaudi, Paolo Maria, 1057 Pacifici, Bonaiuto, 795 n. Padana, valle, 559, 568, 575, 589 Padova, 339, 362, 888, 1044, 1049, 1082, 1123, 1141, 1155, 1195 Paesi Bassi, 1235 Pagani, Gian Filiberto, 202, 310 Pagani, Ippolito, 1200 Paggiari, Domenico, 425-427 Paglia, Giovanni, 264 Palestina, 793 Pallavicini, Stefano Benedetto, 1039 Pallavicino, Carlo, 1069, 1071, 1093 Palleroso (Castelnuovo Garf.) (LU), 553, 556, 1218 Palliot, Jean, 394, 395 n. Palmieri, Antonio, 97, 256, 285, 307 Palmieri, Giuseppe, 74, 308 Palmieri, Vincenzo, 925 Pamphili, Teresa, principessa di Massa, 654 Panacchia di Ceccarello, 498 Panaro, fiume, 20, 36, 111, 112, 284, 313, 456 Pancetti, Andrea, 142 n. Pancetti, Venceslao, 497 n. Pancieri, Giuseppe, 418 Panciroli, Alberto, 890 n. Panciroli, Ercole, 340 Panciroli, Guido, 890 Pandolfini, Domenico, 1186 n., 1209 Panelli, Giovanni Antonio, 1052 n., 1054
Panerverco, Giovanni, 683 Panetti, Battista, 808 Panie, monti, 660 Panini, Franco Cosimo, 1102 Panizzi, Antonio, 846 Pantaleoni, Antonio, 357 Paolo II, papa, 132, 133 Paolo III, papa, 23, 890 n., 1161, 1162 n. Paolo IV, papa, 1196 Paolo da Lignago, 810, 812, 814, 821 Paolozzi Strozzi, Giovanna, 1102 Paolucci, Baldissera, 681 Paolucci, Camillo, 1040 Paolucci, Girolamo, 561 n. Paolucci, Giuseppe Francesco, 625 Papazzoni, Francesca, 762 n. Papotti, Francesco Ignazio, 624, 631 Paradisi, Agostino jr, 35, 165, 258, 277, 288, 530, 533, 608, 894, 952 n., 1045 n., 1047, 1048 n., 1053, 1117, 1120, 1125 Paradisi, Agostino sr, 1045 n. Paradisi, Giovanni, 69, 71-74, 80, 81, 284, 288, 533 Paradisi, Taddeo Agostino, 894 Paraguay, 853 Parente, Giovanni Maria, 141, 143, 1058 Parenti, Giovanni, 332 n., 338 Parenti, Luigi Serafino, 747 n. Parenti, Marc’Antonio, 742 n., 887, 900, 1131 Pariana (Massa C.), 660 Parigi, 11, 15, 31, 169, 172, 242, 309, 468, 560, 582, 840-842, 855, 857, 921, 1036, 1059, 1127, 1139, 1155, 1157, 1228, 1229, 1234, 1243, 1249 Parigi, Giulio, 613 Parisetti, Leone, 1086 n. Parisi, Ottavio, 1113 Parisini, Giuseppe, 363 n. Parma, 31, 54, 65, 194, 196, 197, 208, 235, 274, 308, 339, 403, 456, 514, 521, 528, 534, 539, 607, 623, 641, 700, 723, 842, 855, 857, 859, 862, 865, 926-28, 991, 1000, 1004, 1019, 1057, 1119, 1127, 1136, 1137, 1192, 1298, 1218, 1234, 1252-1254, 1259-1263, 1266, 1267,
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
423, 534, 535, 564, 566-568, 587, 731, 732, 733 n., 734, 738 n., 779, 833, 868870, 900, 979, 990, 1171 n., 1246 Napoleone III Bonaparte, imperatore dei Francesi, 842 Napoli, 14, 15, 53, 201, 272-274, 837, 1073, 1206, 1213, 1242, 1252, 1267 Narbona, 713 Nardi, Anacarsi, 548 Nardi, Biagio, 549, 844 n. Nardi, Emilio, 374, 548 Nardi, Gregorio, 547 Nardini, Leonardo, 569 Narici, Bernardo (“Sergio”), 1083 Natan di Gaza, 793 Naviglio (di Modena), canale, 37, 110-112, 117, 118, 308, 463, 625 Naviglio (di Reggio), canale, 643, 792 Nazzano, canale (c/o Carrara), 665 Nazzari, Francesco, 1127 Nelli, Angiola, 1082 n. Nelli, Ercole, 1082 Nerone, Lucio Domizio, imperatore, 131 Nesi, Giuliano, 568 n. Neuberg (di), Dorotea Sofia, duchessa di Parma, 397 n., 1261, 1270 Nicciano (Piazza al Sechio) (LU), 557, 562 Niccoli, Ottavia, 801 n. Niccolini, Angelo, cardinale, 1201 Niccolini, Giovanni, 1200 Nicola (Ortonovo) (SP), 660 Nicola di Antonio Pino, 544 Nicola I Romanov, zar di Russia, 834, 840 Nicolò V, papa, 551 Nicolò Tedesco, 451 Nieri, Paolo, 1215, 1216 Nirano (Fiorano M.) (MO), 198, 595 Niviano (Rivergaro) (PC), 1269 Nizza, 921 Nizzola, torrente, 996, 1002 Nobili, Baldassarre, 543, 544 Nobili, Leopoldo, 364, 538 Nobili, Pellegrino, 538, 567 Noceti di Bagnone, Pier Francesco, 546 Nollet, Jean-Antoine, 362 Nonantola (MO), 30, 235, 238, 456, 720, 755,
1353
871, 938, 948, 972, 974, 978, 1003 Nonsuch, 1227 Norimberga, 1037 Norsa, Nataniele, 795 n. Notari, Pietro, 565, 566 Novara, 570, 1048 Novella (c/o Minucciano) (LU), 533 Novellara (RE), 67, 193, 235, 346, 348, 465, 529, 535, 536, 610-611, 635-639, 641, 643-647, 655, 938 Novi di Modena (MO), 201, 639 Nugent, Laval, 171 Oates, Titus, 1232 Obelerio, Antenoreo, 824 Oberziner, Lodovico, 1158 Obizzi (degli), Pio Enea II, 1082 Obizzi, Roberto, 689 Obizzi, Tommaso, 173 Olanda, 958 Olivari, Modesto, 362, 363 n. Olivieri, Gian Domenico, 657 Olìvola (Aulla) (MS), 542 Olmütz, 1041 Oltrepò mantovano, 623 Omobono, santo, 139, 147 Onorio, Flavio, imperatore, 720 Opprandino da Iddiano, 498 n. Orange (d’), Guglielmo III, statholder d’Olanda, 700, 1230, 1234 Orazio, Quinto Flacco, 1119, 1120, 1122 Oretti, Marcello, 310 Orlandi, Francesco, 537 Orlandi, Giuseppe, 1083 Orlandi, Giuseppe p., 726, 1107-1109, 1111 Orlandini, Umberto, 434 Orléans (d’), Carlotta Aglae, duchessa di Modena, 33, 307-309, 398, 531-533, 1030 n., 1089, 1155, 1259, 1270 Orléans (d’), Philippe (II), 531, 1270 Orsati, Orsato, 132 Orsi, Giovan Gioseffo, 1087-1089 Orsi, Giuseppe, 9 Orsi, Lelio, 193, 649 Orsi, Moisè Leone, 961 n.
1354
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Pietro Giovanni di S. Lorenzo, 517 Pieve di Cento (BO), 1160 Pieve Fosciana (LU), 556, 557, 565, 569, 1214, 1221 Pieve Modolena (Reggio E.), 349 Pieve S.Lorenzo (Minucciano) (LU), 553 Pievepelago (MO), 505, 507, 1113 Piganti, Giulio, 152 Pigna, Giovanni Battista, 196, 813, 816, 889 n. Pilla, Giovanni Battista, 195 Pillio da Medicina, 187, 1106 Pinerolo (TO), 13 Pio IV, papa, 1201 Pio V, papa, 23, 24, 51, 760, 1194 Pio VI, papa, 574 n., 729, 732, 733 n., 1169 n., 1170 Pio VII, papa, 734, 738 n., 1114 Pio VIII, papa, 1174 Pio IX, papa, 177, 539, 740, 741 n., 742, 879, 1173, 1176 n., 1251 Piò, Angelo, 350 Pio, Enea, 520, 692 Pio, Galasso, signore di Carpi, 580 n. Pio, Guido, 618 Pio, Manfredo, signore di Carpi, 618 Pio di Savoia, Alberto III, signore di Carpi, 459 n., 520, 573, 574 n., Pio di Savoia, Enea, 487 n. Pio di Savoia, Giberto, signore di Sassuolo, 589, 590 Pio di Savoia, Marco III, signore di Sassuolo, 26, 592 Pio di Savoia, Rodolfo, cardinale, 182 Pioppi, *****, brigadiere dei Dragoni, 844 Pirandello, Luigi, 838 Pirani, Giuseppe, 404 n. Pirondi, Prospero, 840 Pisa, 888, 1165, 1176 Piso, Wilelm, 416 n. Pistoia, 207, 234, 256, 861, 1271 Pistoni, Antonio, 894 n. Pistoni, Giuseppe, 1109, 1112 Pizzighettone (CR), 714 Placidi, Giovanni, 1193 Plantin, Christophe,1007 Plauti, Camillo, 1201
Plinio, Caio Secondo sr, 1038 Po, fiume, 15, 48, 118, 275, 452, 456, 460, 464, 528, 576, 637, 638, 645, 704, 706, 714, 857, 1162, 1172, 1253, 1272, 1276 Poerio, Alessandro, 836 Poggi, Alfonso, 1157 Poggi, Camillo, 277 Poggi, Enrico, 902 Poggi, Geminiano, 335 Poggio a Caiano (Carmignano) (FI), 376 Polesella (RO), 620 Polesine, 458, 1049 Poletti, Luigi, 1112 Polinago (MO), 719 Pollastri. Antonio, 356 Polonia,1040, 1136, 1266 Pomarance, v. Alberti delle Pomarance, An-drea Pomata, Gianna, 802 Pomay, François-Antoine, 1023 Pompadour (de) Poisson, Jeanne-Antoinette, 858 Pomposa (Codigoro) (FE), 1162, 1166 Poni, Carlo, 67 Pontecosi (Pieve Fosciana) (LU), 556 Ponticelli, Alfonso, 561 Pontiroli, Giorgio, 997, 1011 Pontremoli (MS), 541 Pontremolese, territorio, 1273 Ponzoni, Antonio, 875 Porcari (LU), 557 Porcia (di), Giovanni Artico, 1124 Porro Lambertenghi, Luigi, 277 Porro, Camillo, 1201 Portocarrero, Francesco, 703 Portogallo, 787 Possidonio, Orazio, 893 n. Poviglio (RE), 534, 1263, 1268, 1270 Pozzetti, Pompilio, 168, 171, 608 Pozzuoli, Giovanni, 352 Praga, 794 Prampolini, Alessandro, 240 Pratofontana (Reggio E.), 610-611 Preti, Mattia, 202 Previdelli, Girolamo, 888, 890, 1227 Prisciani, Pellegrino, 153, 452, 807, 808 n.,
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1270, 1271 Parmense, territorio, 560, 1263, 1268, 1269 Pasi, Marco Antonio, 452, 453 n., 454 n., 455, 457, 458 Pasinelli, Lorenzo, 206 Pasquale II, papa, 720 Pasquali, Andrea, 1191 Pasqualino, Cesare, 1086 n. Pasquin, Antoine-Claude, 175 Pasquini, Bernardo, 1066-1068 Passau, 1041 Passerini, Paolo, 417 Passerotti, Bartolomeo, 194 Passerotti, Tiburzio, 194 Pasti, Santo, 689 Pavia, 145, 555, 713, 888, 1123 Pavullo (MO), 507, 871, 940, 941 Pedretti, *****, fabbricante di cannoni, 701 Pedretti, Carlo, 853, 954 Pegolotti, Gabriele, 581 n. Pegolotti, Ippolito, 710 Pelizzi, Domenico, 238, 533 Pellicciari, Lazzaro, vescovo di Modena, 721 Pellico, Silvio, 838 Pepoli, Ercole, 28 Pepys, Evelyn, 1233 Perani, Mauro, 796 Peri, Ercole, 683 Périer, Casimir-Pierre, 1137 Perillo Lancillotti, Teresa, 1025 Perlhefter, Baer, 794 Perondoli, Giulio, 682 Perpoli (Gallicano) (LU), 557 Perrault, Claude, 864 Personali, Achille, 889 n. Personali, Carlo Antonio, 749 n. Personali, Francesco, 889 n. Perti, Giacomo Antonio, 1066, 1067 Perugia, 792 Pesari, Giambattista, 201 Pesaro, 382, 998, 1128 Pescarola (Prignano s.Secchia) (MO), 381 Peterborough, Heny Mordaunt, 1228 Petrarca, Francesco, 156, 658, 1122, 1138 Petrozzani, Giuseppe, 659, 661, 663 Petrucci, Armando, 802 n.
1355
Piacentino, territorio, 460 Piacenza, 20, 50, 65, 457, 514, 623, 700, 723, 857, 926, 954, 1092, 1269 Pianaccio (c/o Castelnuovo Garf.) (LU), 556 Pianoro (BO), 1198 Piattoli, Scipione, 772 n. Piazza al Serchio (LU), 567 Piazza, Carlo Francesco, 338, 342 Piazzola sul Brenta (PD), 1069 Picchena, Curzio, 694, 1185, 1200 Piccinini, Guglielmo, 1109 Piccolomini, Alfonso, 1198, 1199 Piccolomini, Sallustio, 1193 Picenardi, Ottavio, vescovo di Reggio E., 528 Pico, Alessandro I, duca della Mirandola, 617, 619, 621, 630 Pico, Alessandro II, duca della Mirandola, 617, 619, 681 Pico, Federico (I), 620 Pico, Francesco Maria, duca della Mirandola, 623 n., 624 Pico, Fulvia, principessa di Massa, 654 Pico, Galeotto (IV), 621 Pico, Galeotto I, signore della Mirandola, 619, 620 Pico, Galeotto II, signore della Mirandola, 620 Pico, Giovanni Francesco I, signore della Mirandola, 619, 620 Pico, Lodovico I, signore della Mirandola, 620 Pico, Lodovico II, signore della Mirandola, 619 Pico, Maria, 621 Piemonte, 13, 15, 920, 921, 924, 925, 962, 1134, 1140, 1254, 1272 Pieracchi, Luigi, 565 Pieracchi, Pietro, 561 Pierelli, Francesco, 1118 Pieroni, Paolo, 565 n., 567 Pierotti, Ermete, 569 Pietrasanta (LU), 1194 Pietro da Modena (p.), v. Gianoli, Giuseppe Annibale Pietro da Taponecco, 545
1356
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Rennes, 11 Renno (Pavullo n.Frignano) (MO), 499 Reschigna, Pier Maria, 664 Revere (MN), 624 Rho, Giovanni, 1258 Riccardi, Pietro, 1106, 1113 Ricchetti, Marzia, 125 n., 427 n. Ricchiari, “Vittoria”, 1083 n. Ricchiari, Luca, 1083 Ricci, Carlo, 878 Ricci, Claudio, 705 Ricci, Giuliano, 1135 Ricci, Giulivo, 549 Ricci, Giuseppe, 878 Ricci, Lodovico, 74, 274, 282, 284, 288, 582, 608, 730, 770, 771 n., 772 n., 797, 853, 894, 957, 959, 967, 968, 974, 1117 Ricci, Michelangelo, cardinale, 1127 Ricci, Milena, 801 n. Riccini, Girolamo, 735 n., 737, 842, 1174, 1175 Riccioli, Pietro, 375 Riccò, Amelia, 360 n. Riccò, Annibale, 360 n. Riccò, Felice, 351 n., 360, 361 Ricco, Gregorio, 1215 Riccoboni, Antonio (“Pantalone”), 1083, 1084 Riccoboni, Luigi Andrea (“Lelio”), 1084, 1085, 1087, 1088, 1090 Riccomini. Eugenio, 335 Richecourt (de), Dieudonné-Emmanuel, 744 Richetti, Sergio, 487 n. Richilda, beata, 820, 822 Ridolfi, Cosimo, 1133 Righi, Luigi, 351 n. Rigoso (Monchio delle Corti) (PR), 545 Riminaldi, Florinda, 682 Rimini, 20, 460, 538 Rinaldi, Pellegrino, 503 n. Rinaldi, Tommaso, 359, 360 n. Rinaldi, Ugo, 1206, 1207, 1209 Rinaldo da Verica, 498 n. Rio Saliceto (Reggio E.), 609, 611 Riolunato (MO), 355, 505
Ripola (c/o Tavernelle) (Licciana N.) (MS), 541, 542, 547 Riva, Giuseppe, 1039 Rivalta (Reggio E.), 34, 256, 309, 422, 534 Rivi, Luciano, 1105 Rizzi, Carlo, 206 Rizzini, Gaspare, 1229 Roberti, Giovanni Battista, 1071 Rocca Frigida (c/o Massa) (MS), 660 Rocca Michele, 1199 Rocca, Giuseppe, 359 Roccapelago (Pievepelago) (MO), 505 Rococciola, Domenico, 141 Rodolfo II d’Asburgo, imperatore, 24, 594 Roether, Federico, 1073 Rogissart (de), *****, 865 Roito, Aurelio, 680 Rolando da Monteforte, 498 n. Rölker, Roland, 1108 Rolo (RE), 610, 925 Roma, 6, 20, 32, 53, 88, 132, 143, 148, 166, 182, 193, 201, 207, 209, 227, 233, 238, 239, 241, 270, 329-331, 334, 337, 339, 341, 377, 457, 520, 579, 683, 704, 727, 729, 740, 797, 824, 842, 861, 883, 1055, 1057, 1066, 1087, 1117, 1123, 1127, 1146, 1162, 1164-1167, 1173, 1174, 1175, 1194, 1198, 1200, 1234, 1252 Romagna, 48, 70, 78, 381, 388, 396, 413, 492, 842, 843, 1077, 1160, 1199 Romani, Giuseppe, 204, 206 Romano, Giulio, 346 Rombaldi, Odoardo, 66, 67, 723, 975 n., 1108-1110 Roncaglia, Carlo, 469, 983, 984, 988, 989 Roncagliana (c/o S.Pellegrino) (LU), 1213 Ronchi, Giuseppe, 1001 Ronchi, Lodovico, 1086 n. Ronciglione (VT), 1165 Rondinelli, Antonio, 502 Rondinelli, Camillo, 689 Rondinelli, Ercole, 525, 689 Rosa, Mario, 1036 Rosa, Michele, 279 Rosaccio, Michele, 1003 Rosati, Ferdinando, 1068
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
811, 812, 814-816, 821, 1049-1051 Procaccini, Camillo, 194, 195 Prouhon, Pierre-Joseph, 903 Prussia, 902, 920, 922, 921, 1154, 1255 Pucci, Luigi, 67, 1113 Puccini, Niccolò, 234 Puglia, 50 Pugliano (Minucciano) (LU), 553 Puliatti, Pietro, 1107, 1111 Pulini, Chiara, 1103 Purcell, Henry (II), 1233 Puscini, Antonio, 758 Puttini, Pietro, 97 Quarantoli (Mirandola) (MO), 619 Quattro Castella (RE), 521 Querini Tommaso (Pietro), 787 n. Querini, Stefano, 353 Quesnay, François, 954 Rabetti, Arturo, 1099 Racconigi (CN), 376 Racine, Jean, 1085, 1087 n., 1089 n. Radcliffe, Ann, 856 Raffaele *****, mercante reggiano di cappelli, 757 m. Raffaelli, Francesco, 567 n. Raffaelli, Nicolao, 567 Raffaello Sanzio, 183, 239, 415, 421, 864 Raffo, Isidoro, 664-666 Raggi, Ercole Antonio, 332, 335, 340 n. Raggi, Pierluigi, 1215 n. Raimondi, Ezio, 3 Ramaggini, Giovanni Giuseppe, 1041 Ramazzini, Bernardino, 798, 998, 1007, 1014, 1016, 1123 Rancidoro (c/o Polinago) (MO), 505 Rango d’Aragona, Paolo, 314 Rangoni Lotario Alfonso, 310, 972 n. Rangoni, Alessandro, vescovo di Modena, 721 Rangoni, Bonifacio jr, 174, 310, 713, 771 Rangoni, Bonifacio sr, 580 n. Rangoni, Claudio, vescovo di Piacenza, 146 n.
1357
Rangoni, Emilia, 764 n. Rangoni, Francesco, 876 Rangoni, Gherardo jr, 35, 730, 956 n., 957 n., 972 n., 1053 Rangoni, Gherardo sr, 1077 Rangoni, Giovanni, 309 Rangoni, Giovanni Claudio, 1084 n., 1089 Rangoni, Giuseppe, 873, 878 Rangoni, Guido, 710 Ranuzzi, Annibale, 375 Ranzani, Cherubino, 403 Raselli, Odoardo, 1113 Rathruil, *****, principe tedesco, 339 Ravarino (MO), 969 Ravenna, 21, 519, 719, 720 Razzoli, Anna Maria, 1110, 1113 Re, Antonio, 535, 536, 872, 873 Recke (von der), Elisa, 626 Redù (Nonantola) (MO), 235, 238 Reggianini, Luigi, vescovo di Modena, 735, 736 n., 739 Reggiano, territorio, 7, 48, 518, 524, 525, 528, 529, 553, 594, 618, 711, 716, 939, 1117, 1194, 1274 Reggio Emilia, 4, 11, 18, 24, 54-58, 60, 78, 126, 133, 139, 175, 184, 193, 195, 196, 203-206, 227, 228, 238, 240, 241, 257, 261, 263, 264, 266, 268, 277, 280, 282284, 286, 288, 343, 345, 346, 349, 350, 401, 459, 465, 469, 513-520, 522-524, 526-531, 533, 535, 537-540, 560, 562, 564, 565, 567, 576, 588, 597, 602, 609, 610, 613, 619, 625, 636-638, 642, 643, 660, 702, 708, 712, 715-718, 741, 745, 746, 753, 759, 760, 762, 764, 766, 771, 773, 777, 780, 792, 793, 838, 853, 856, 857, 859, 860, 862, 863, 865, 866, 872, 896, 907, 916, 917, 920, 927, 930, 931, 937-942, 944, 946-963, 987, 1019, 1044, 1069, 1078, 1081, 1082, 1086, 1092, 1094, 1109, 1113, 1114, 1161, 1176, 1196, 1198, 1199, 1266, 1270 Reggiolo (RE), 643, 1276 Regnard, Jean-François, 1089 n. Remondini, Giuseppe, 1019 Reni, Guido, 184, 194-201, 203, 239, 349
1358
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Salvatori, Antonio, 309 Salvemini, Gaetano, 20 Salvi, Francesco, 348 Salvioli, Giuseppe, 1110 Sandonnini, Tommaso, 1110, 1113 Sandoz de Noiraigue, *****, colonnello, 414 n. Sangiovanni, Dario, 1065, 1066 Sanguinetti, Benedetto, 836 Sanminiati, Nicolò, 1213, 1216, 1218 Sant’Agata sul Santerno (RA), 25, 1160 Sant’Ambrogio (S.Cesario s. Panaro) (MO), 284 San Biagio (Correggio) (RE), 609, 611 San Cataldo (Modena), 1034 San Cesario sul Panaro (MO), 1004 San Donnino Nizzola (Modena), 436 San Felice Circeo (Terracina), 240 San Felice sul Panaro (Modena), 618, 630, 712, 871, 920, 938, 975 San Giacomo Roncole (Modena), 625 San Giovanni della Fossa (Reggio E.), 644 Sant’Iago di Compostela, 145 Sant’Ilario d’Enza (RE), 535, 835, 1269 Santa Maria della Fossa (Reggio E.), 644 San Martino di Vallata (Modena), 233 San Martino di Mugnano (Modena), 356, 369, 423, 425, 963 San Martino in Rio (Reggio E.), 23, 306, 314, 433, 521, 609, 611, 938 San Martino in Spino (Modena), 624, 625 San Martino Secchia (Modena), 462 San Michele della Fossa (Reggio E.), 610, 611 San Pellegrino, passo, 560, 561 San Polo d’Enza (Reggio E.), 521 San Possidonio (Modena), 382, 619, 625 San Prospero (Modena), 207, 461 San Prospero (Reggio E.), 609, 611 San Tomaso della Fossa (Reggio E.), 642, 644 Santachiara, Umberto, 735 n. Santagata, Pierpaolo, 1109 Santhià (VC), 30, 155, 723 Santi, Giovanni, 1106 Santi, Giovanni Antonio, 567 n. Santi, Pellegrino, 567 n. Santi, Venceslao, 95, 1110, 1113 Santini, Giovanni, 1106
Santini, Paolo, 1224 Saracchi, Battista, 152 Sarajevo, 1247 Sardegna,1242 Sardi, Alessandro, 813 Sardi, Gaspare, 196, 813-815 Sarti, Domenico, 333 Sarzana (SP), 544, 660 Sassalbo (Fivizzano)(MS), 546 Sassi, Alfonso, 1268 Sassi Negrelli, Annibale, 972 n. Sassi Negrelli, Giacomo, 972 n. Sassi Negrelli, Silvio, 972 n. Sassolese, territorio, 965 Sassonia, 808, 1136 Sassonia (di), Federico Cristiano, principe elettore, 1039, 1041 Sassonia (di), Giovanni Giorgio, duca,339 Sassorosso (Villa Colemandina) (LU), 566 Sassuolo (MO), 26, 27, 29, 31, 32, 58, 59, 88, 199, 205, 256, 328, 333-336, 340, 341, 345, 349, 369, 380, 383, 417, 422, 586592, 594-598, 704, 714, 722, 725, 858, 861, 871, 938, 940, 957, 963, 986, 1112, 1139, 1203 Savi, Giovanni, 393 Savioni, Mario, 1071 Savoia, 921 Savoia (di), Eugenio, 21, 528, 560, 654 Savoia (di), Amedeo VI, conte, 784 Savoia (di), Carlo Emanuele I, duca,28 Savoia (di), Emanuele Filiberto, duca, 13 Savoia (di), Isabella, duchessa di Modena, 28, 195, 693, 792 Savoia (di), Margherita Violante, duchessa di Parma, 1258 Savoia (di), Maria Beatrice, duchessa di Modena, 232, 833, 838 Savoia di Carignano (di), Emanuele Filiberto, 824, 1234 Savona, 380 Scaccia, Giuseppe, 1069 Scala, Flaminio, 1080 n., 1081 n. Scandiano (RE), 306, 345, 349, 362, 516, 535, 536, 920, 940, 1140 Scannaroli, Giambattista, 893 n.
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Rosati, Franco, 465 Rosi, Michele, 835 Rospigliosi, Giulio, v. Clemente VII, papa Rosselli, Camillo, 628 Rosselli Genesini, Giovanni Battista, 1064, 1067 Rossena (Ciano d’Enza) (RE), 521 Rossetti, Alessandro, 497 n. Rossetti, Biagio, 106 Rossetti, Gabriele, 1143 Rossi di Tavernelle, Pietro, 541 Rossi, Battista, 684 Rossi, Bernardino, 229, 230, 237, 238, 242 Rossi, Fortunato, 836 n. Rossi, Francesco, 757 n. Rossi, Guido, 568 n. Rossi, Nunzio, 201 Rossi, Pellegrino, 143 Rossini, Gioacchino, 1073, 1074 Rota, Filippo, 744 Röther, Feredico, 1073 Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, 952, 898 Rovatti, Antonio, 4, 8, 118, 732, 1104 Rovere (Della), Giulia, 24, 816 Roverella, Guidobaldo, 689 Rovereto sul Secchia (Novi di Modena) (MO), 201 Rovighi, Cesare, 1134 Rovigo, 24 Rovigo, Abram, 793 Rovigo, Leone, 794 Rovio (Canton Ticino), 333 Rubbiani, Antonio, 384 Rubbiani, Carlo, 384 Rubbiani, Giovanni Maria, 384 Rubbiani, Giuseppe Maria, 747 n. Rubbiano (Montefiorino) (MO), 757 Rubiera (RE), 284, 462, 515, 516, 537, 538, 702, 717, 835, 1139, 1145, 1148, 1161 Rucellai, Giovanni, 862 Rucellai, Giulio, 744 Ruer, Thomas, 339 Ruffini, Anna, 840 Ruffini, Guido, 1109 Ruffini, Maria Francesca, 840 Ruffini, Paolo, 189, 1106, 1113 Ruga, Giovanni Antonio, 958
1359
Ruggi, Francesco Veronico, 757 n. Ruggi, Giovanni Andrea, 567 n. Ruini, Carlo, 888, 890 Rusca, Giovanni Battista, 566 Russia, 1135 Russo, Giuseppe, 1112, 1114 Sabadini, Bernardo, 1071 Sabbatini, Alessandro, 1169 n. Sabbatini, Giovanni, 1134 Sabbatini, Giuliano, vescovo di Modena, 727, 1039 Saccani, Giovanni, 1113 Sacchi, Alfonso, 893 Sacchi, Antonio, 836 Sacchi, Gennaro (“Coviello”), 1084 n. Saccozzi, Agostino, 612, 716 n., 717 Sacerdoti, Emanuele, 1014 Sacrati, Francesco, 580 n. Sacrati, Francesco, cardinale, 684, 693 Sacrati, Francesco Paolo, 1092 Sacrati, Giulio, 761 n. Sacrati, Orazio, 689 Sacrati, Scipione, 1267 Sacrobosco, Giovanni, 451 Sade (de), Donatien, 859 Saffi, Aurelio, 836 Saint-Frémont (de), *****, generale francese, 561, 562 n. Saint-Peter (de), *****, maresciallo di campo del re di Francia, 561 Sala, Erio, 899 Salerno, Giulio, 1202 Saliceta, bosco, 1113 Saliceto Panaro (Modena), 201, 783, 988 Saliceto S.Giuliano (Modena), 985, 987 Salicoli, Angela, 1069 Salicoli, Margherita, 1069 Salieri, Antonio, 1104 Salimbeni, Filippo, 877 Salimbeni, Valerio, 883 Salis, Giovanni, 735 n. Salisburgo, 1041 Salito, Carlo, 336 Salò (BS), 1040
1360
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Soliani, Domenico Maria, 893 n. Soliani, Girolamo, 1006 Soliani, stampatori, 5, 398 Soliani, Viviano, 999, 1001, 1002, 1005, 1006, 1009, 1011, 1013, 1017, 1024 Soliani Raschini, *****, conte, 375 Sommariva, Giuseppe, vescovo di Modena, 737 Sommi, Leone, 649 Sommocolonia (Barga) (LU), 546, 558 Soragna (PR), 348 Sorbara (Bomporto) (MO), 1003 Sorbelli, Albano, 498 n. Sorbelli, Tommaso, 1108, 1109, 1111 Sorgato, Ferruccio, 285 n. Sormani Moretti, Luigi, 989 Sossaj, Francesco, 8 Soufflot, Jacques-Germain, 264 Southwark, 1229 Sozzi, Antonio, 207 Sozzi, Giuseppe, 263 Spaccini, Giovanni Battista, 8, 52, 94, 144, 196, 305, 691, 694, 789, 858, 1077, 1078, 1085 Spada, Leonello, 195 Spadolini, Giovanni, 838, 844 Spaggiari, Angelo, 427 n., 549, 574, 653, 655, 1102, 1108, 1111, 1180 Spaggiari, Giovanni, 351 n., 354, 355 Spagna, 53, 54, 61, 557, 1242, 1246, 1266 Spallanzani, Lazzaro, 1047, 1123, 1048 n. Spezzani, Giovanni Paolo, 315, 770 n. Spezzano (Modena), 595, 861 Spilamberto (Modena), 204, 342, 711, 1004 Spinelli, Alessandro Giuseppe, 1112 Spinola, Brigida, principessa di Massa, 654 Spinoza, Baruch, 1237 n. Stacchini, Antonio, 502 n., 503 n. Stadano (Aulla) (MS), 542 Staffetti, Luigi, 665 Staggia (S. Prospero) (MO), 207 Stanislao da Campagnola p., v. Santachiara, Umberto Stanzani, Antonio, 282 Stanzani, Giuseppe, 843 Starkey, David, 369
Stazzema (LU), 1205 Stefanini, Giovanni Battista, 1064 Stefano da Carpi, 347 Stendhal (Henry Beyle), 953 Stiano (c/o Corneto) (Toano) (RE), 355 Stigliani, Tommaso, 1119 Stoccarda, 421 Stolberg-Stolberg (zu), Friedrich Leopold, 860 Stradella, Alessandro, 1066, 1070, 1104, 1112 Stringa, Francesco, 145, 146, 147, 202-204, 206, 208, 339, 340 n., 354 n., 392 n., 393 n., 394, 395, 419, 1070 Strozzi, Anna Laura, 125 n., 424 n. Strozzi, Giulio, 1092 Strozzi, Pietro, 1193 Strucchi, Gherardo, 540 Stuart, Maria I, regina d’Inghilterra, 1230 Suarez, Ferdinando, 1206, 1209 Susani, Giovanni, 235 Susari, Alessandro, 681 Susari, Antonio Maria, 712 Susari, Nicolò, 820 Susini, Paolo, 1113 Susio, Giambattista, 889 n. Svizzera, 1136, 1253
Tacconi, Giuseppe, 351 n. Tacoli, Achille, 382, 625 Tacoli Canacci, Alfonso, 86, 87 Tadolini, Francesco Maria, 279 Tadolini, Petronio, 350 Tagliavini, Lodovico, 154, 820, 1005, 1051 Tagliazucchi, scultori e intagliatori, 355 Tagliazucchi, Domenico, 353 Tamagni, Giovanni, 1259 Tambura, strada, 34, 256, 656 Tamigi, fiume, 1229 Tampellini, Antonio, 877 Tampellini, Gaetano, 877 Tampellini, Giulio Cesare, 877 Taponecco (Licciana N.) (MS), 541-547, 1194 Tarabino, *****, cavalcatore modenese, 678
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Scannelli, Francesco, 183 Scapinelli, Marc’Antonio, 129 Scarabelli Chiavenna, Giuseppe, 465 Scarabelli Pedocca, Angelo, 278, 362 n., 703 Scaramuccia, Luigi, 183, 200, 201 Scaramuzza, Francesco, 238, 533 Scarlatti, Alessandro, 1067, 1068 Scarlattini, Giulio, 888, 890 Scarpa, Antonio, 278 Schedoni, Bartolomeo, 142 n., 194, 197 Schelhorn, Johann Sigismund, 1038 Schenck, Pieter, 1235 Schenetti, Matteo, 588 n., 1110 Schiassi, Antonio, 349, 350 Schiavoni, Natale, 242 Scholem, Gershom, 793, 794 Schott, Franciscus, 856, 862 Schwarzenberg (von), Felix, 1252 n. Scodobio, Bernardino, 889 n. Scotto, saltimbanco, 1079 Scozia, 7 Scozia, Rinaldo, 38, 740 Scurani, Prospero, 348 Scurano (Neviano d. Arduini) (PR), 1273 Scutellari Paolucci, Paola, 972 n. Secchia, fiume, 20, 36, 111, 284, 313, 456, 462, 516, 521, 589, 631, 638, 1034 Secchiari, Giulio, 196 Seghizzi, Agostino, 392 n. Seghizzi, Andrea, 257 Seghizzi, Paolo, 205 n. Segneri, Paolo jr, 726 Segni, Beatrice, 682 Segni, Violante, 681 Seidenari, Giuliano, 97 Selvatico, Alfonso, 129 Selvatico, Antonio, 129 Selvatico, Lodovico, 129-131, 135, 138 Selvatico, Paolo, 116 Senofonte, 56 Serafini, Serafino, 140 Serchio, fiume, 546, 564 Sermezzana (c. Minucciano) (LU), 557 Serrazzone (Fanano) (MO), 758 Sestola (MO), 497, 501, 502, 504, 505, 562, 629, 701, 702, 708, 715, 940-941, 1000,
1361
1041, 1197 Settevecchi, Lodovico, 813 Seuter, Matteo, 860 Sfondrati, Paolo, 23, 682 Sforza, Giovanni, 1112 Sforza, Muzio Attendolo, 514, 515 Sgarbi, Antonio, 363 n. Sgarbi, Giuseppe, 363 Shearman, John, 181 Sicilia, 15, 739, 1242 Sidoli, Giovanni, 538 Siena, 504, 1145, 1192, 1193 Sigonio, Carlo, 9, 18, 170, 174, 188, 1112, 1117 Silingardi, Gaspare, vescovo di Modena, 434, 481, 719, 720 Silingardi, Giancarlo, 1099 Silingardi, Luca, 317 n. Sillano (LU), 560 Sillicagnana (S. Romano in Garf.) (LU), 566 Silva, Cristoforo, 710 Silvester, Guglielmo, 403, 419, 859 Silvestro, Filippo, 238 Simeoni, Luigi, 26, 34, 1109 Simonazzi, Antonio, 236 Simone di Trento, 785 Simonetti, Francesco, 569 Simonetti, Giuseppe, 1111, 1113 Sirotti, Elisabetta, 317 n. Sisto V, papa, 23, 144 Siviglia, 787 Skippon, Philip, 416 Smeraldi, Smeraldo, 1263, 1268 Smith, Adam, 954, 956 Socii, Giuseppe, 97 Sogari, Prospero (d. il Clemente), 345, 346 Solerti, Angelo, 653 Soli, Giuseppe Maria, 89, 100, 101, 209, 226, 278, 281, 282, 285 Soli, Teobaldo, 103 Soli Muratori, Francesco, 161 Soliani, Angelo, 356 Soliani, Bartolomeo jr, 399, 818, 995, 996, 1000, 1007, 1009 n., 1018 Soliani, Bartolomeo sr, 394 n., 999, 1000, 1002-1006, 1011, 1012, 1024
1362
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Tossici, Nicolò, 1050 Tournon (de), François, cardinale, 1192 Traeri, Agostino, 432 Traeri, Antonio (d. “Cestellino”), 327, 342, 448, 353, 436 Traeri, Domenico, 436 Traiano, Ulpio, imperatore, 131 Trapani (Da), Agostino, 363 n. Trapani (Da), Vincenzo, 363 n. Trassilico (Gallicano) (LU), 466, 558, 567 Trassilico, vicarìa, 552 Trecchi, Giuseppe, 581 n. Trenti, Giuseppe, 125 n., 427 n., 1030, 1108 Trentino (Fanano) (MO), 505 Trento, 207 Treppignana (Fosciandora) (LU), 558 Tresana (MS), 662 Treschietto (Bagnone) (MS), 1273 Trevisi, Pellegrino, 433 Treviso, 37 Trieste, 1254, 1271 Trivelli, tessitori reggiani, 530 Trivulzio, Francesca, 620 Trivulzio, Giovanni Giacomo, 620 Troili, Domenico, 162, 166, 1055 Trotti, Diana, 681 Trotti, Alfonso, 1079 Trotti, Carlo, vescovo di Bagnorea, 693 Trotti, Cesare, v. Este (d’) “Trotti”, Cesare Trotti, Ercole, 694 Trotti, Ferrante, 692 Trotti, Giacomo, 681 Trouvé, Claude-Joseph, 73 Trovabene, Giordana, 1105 Troyer (von), Ferdinand Julius, cardinale, 1041 Tucci Ruffini, Vittoria, 1109 Turcato, Stefano, 125 n., 427 n. Turchetto Candiotto, castellano estense, 680 Turchi, Adeodato, vescovo di Parma, 747 n. Turchi, Alfonso, 692, 695 Turchi, Laura, 574 Turci, Angelo, 752 n. Turigliano, canale (c/o Carrara), 665 Turri, Giuseppe, 567 n. Turrite, fiume, 552
Tuti, Giuseppe, 1193 Uccellini, Marco, 1068 Ughelli, Ferdinando, 1167 n. Ugolini, Bartolomeo, 1186 n., 1207, 1209 Ugolini, Giuseppe, 240 Umbria, 1172 Urbani, Orazio, 1195-1197 UrbanoVIII, papa, 30, 723, 1162 n., 1163 n., 1165 n., 1186 Urbino, 53, 182, 1215 Vaccari, Francesco, 1003 Vaccari, Riccardo, 801 n. Vacchi, Francesco, 621 Vagli (LU), 558 Vaglio (Lama Mocogno) (MO), 505 Valdrighi, Bartolomeo, 19, 35, 277, 288, 920, 951, 952, 961 n., 1054 Valdrighi, Luigi, 288, 565, 566, 895, 925 Valdrighi, Luigi Francesco, 8, 356, 783, 1073, 1113 Valdrighi, Mario, 177, 179 Valeggio sul Mincio (VR), 1271 Valenti, Filippo, 162, 935, 1102, 1103, 1108, 1111, 1180 Valentini, Giacomo, 487 n. Valesio, Gian Luigi, 402 Valestri, Pietro, 1258 Vallico (Fabbriche di Vallico) (LU), 552, 553, 556-558, 1215 Valli dei Cavalieri, 1269 Vallini, Luigi, 549 Vallisneri, Antonio jr, 1044 n., 1045 n. Vallisneri, Antonio sr, 167, 861, 1034, 1044, 1045 n. Vallotta, Gaudenzio, 763 n., 772 Valtellina, 1206 Valverde (c/o Rubiera) (RE), 524 Vandelli, Domenico, 151, 154, 156, 157 n., 160, 413, 418, 463-465, 467, 469, 631, 860 Vandelli, Eugenio, 282 Vandelli, Francesco, 102, 103, 160, 162, 359,
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Tarabusi, Andrea, 100, 262, 269, 273, 279, 311 Tardini, Giuseppe, 1113 Tarello, Camillo, 57 Tascher de la Pagerie, Marie-Josèphe-Rose, v. Bonaparte, Giuseppina Tasso, Torquato, 814, 1118, 1196 Tassoni, *****, marchesa, 689 Tassoni, Alessandro, 399, 855, 997, 1020, 1043 n., 1117, 1118, 1122, 1123 Tassoni, Ercole, 684 Tassoni-Estense, Ercole, 689, 1081 n., 1086 n. Tassoni-Estense, Ferrante, 689 Tassoni-Estense, Galeazzo, 689, 692 Tassoni-Estense, Ottavio, 684, 693 Tatini, Daniela, 1190 n. Tavernelle (Massa C.), 541, 542, 545-547 Tenerani, Francesco, 662 Termanini, Pietro, 97-100, 163, 174, 267, 269, 270, 273, 275, 285, 311, 314, 354 n., 356, 418 Terrachini, Paolo, 1113 Terrachini, Pier Giacinto, 538 Terre Nuove, vicarìa, 551 Terzi, Ottobono, 514, 515 Terzi, Terzo, 705 Teseo, Gioseffo, 139 Testi, Costantino, 401 Testi, Fulvio, 200, 329, 723, 997, 1001, 1024, 1051, 1080 n.,1109, 1119, 1121 Thiene, Antonio, 621 Thiene, Giulio, 689, 692 Thiene, Ippolito, 621 Thornton, Peter, 369 Thouin, André, 582 Tiberio, Claudio Nerone, imperatore, 131 Tiburtini Magnani, Teresa, 771 Tinè, Concetto, 1109 Tinti, Lorenzo, 392 n., 393, 395, 401 Tintoretto (Il)(Iacopo Robusti, d.), 239 Tiraboschi, Girolamo, 6, 7, 9, 112, 136, 162, 166-168, 207, 285, 457 n., 498 n., 572 n., 601, 608, 761 n., 1047, 1048, 1052, 1053, 1055-1058, 1097, 1098, 1101, 1111, 1112, 1115, 1121, 1129
1363
Tirelli, Antonio, 613 Tirelli, Pietro Paolo, 359 Tirreno, mare, 594, 655 Tisi, Giovanni Battista, 353 Tivoli (Roma), 282 Tiziano Vecellio, 183 Tizzano Val Parma (PR), 514 Tocci, Giovanni, 573, 575, 578 Todeschi, Francesco, 203 Todeschini, Giacomo Francesco, 206 Tognone da Camporgiano, 562 Tolomei, Cesare Lelio, 27, 1203 Tolomeo, Claudio, 452 Tolone, 713 Tolosa, 11 Tommasi, Anna Chiara, 237 Tommaso di Savoia, re di Sardegna, 1081 n. Tondelli, Leone, 1112 Tonelli, Domenico, 1194 Tonelli, Giovanni Matteo, 502 n. Tonge, Israel, 1232 Tonini, Carlo Antonio, 758 n. Tordino da Montecuccolo, 498 n. Torello, Salinguerra, 569, 662 Tori, Giulio Cesare, 1082 Torino, 13, 15, 21, 241, 270, 282, 374-376, 404, 538, 562, 1213, 1252 Torm, Tesme, 1201 Tornioli, Nicolò, 201 Torreggiani, Alfonso, 263, 311-312 Torreggiani, Andrea, 836 n. Torri, Anna Maria (“Lavinia”), 1083 n. Torri, Flaminio, 202, 309, 311 Torri, Francesco, 342, 1008 Torri, Giulio Cesare, 1082, 1083 Torriani, Orazio, 88 Torti, Francesco, 114 Tortorici, Giuseppe (“Scaramuccia”), 1082 n. Toscana, 6, 20, 35, 64, 258, 280, 504, 509, 511, 532, 558, 559, 563, 567, 570, 660, 843, 862, 925, 927, 953, 991, 1134, 1135, 1155, 1186, 1190, 1199, 1201, 1215, 1248, 1266 Toschi, Alfonso, 900, 925 Toschi, Domenico, cardinale, 893 Toschi, Lorenzo, 278
1364
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Vignaroli, Michele, 355 Vignola (MO), 155, 711, 861, 871, 1101 Vigona (c/o Mirandola) (MO), 625 Villa Cadè, v. Cadè Villa Gazzata, v. Gazzata Villafranca in Lunigiana (MS), 548, 1273 Villani, Alessandro, 1109 Villani, Francesco Antonio, 1202 Villanova (Modena), 1034 Villars, Frances, 1231 Vinacciara (c/o Minucciano) (LU), 553 Vincenzi, Alfonso, 682 Vincenzi, Geminiano, 226-230, 232, 358 n. Vincenzi, Giacomo, 258, 259 Vinta, Francesco, 1200 Violi, Ttito, 375 Virgiglio da Castagneto, 520 Virgilio Marone, Publio, 1023, 1038 Vischi, Luigi, 1034, 1113 Viscomti, Bernabò, signore di Milano, 636638, 642 Visconti, Caterina, 638 Visconti, Caterina, duchessa di Milano, 514 Visconti, Filippo Maria, duca di Milano, 516 Visconti, Gian Galeazzo, duca di Milano, 514 Visconti, Giovanni Maria, duca di Milano, 514 Visdomini, Sisto, vescovo di Modena, 720 Vismara, *****, affiliato alla Massoneria, 836 n. Visuntino, *****, avvocato milanese, 1218 Vitali, Giovanni Battista, 435, 1064, 1065, 1067, 1068, 1234 Vitali, Pier Paolo, 772 n. Vitaliani, Antonio, 1068 Vitelli, Alessandro, 1192 Vitriola (Montefiorino) (MO), 355 Vittorio Amedeo II, re di Sardegna, 922 Vittorio Emanuele I, re di Sardegna, 838 Vittorio Emanuele II, re d’Italia, 742 Vives, Juan Luis, 1023 Vivi, Giovanni Battista, 415 Volkmann, Johann, 861 Volpigliano (c/o Massa) (MS), 663 Voltaire (François-Marie Arouet, d.), 258,
952, 956, 1089, 1117, 1147 Vrieu, *****, certosino francese, 749 Waller, Edmund, 1230 Waterloo, 423 Watt, James, 362 Wattenhofer, Giovanni Battista, 943, 948 n. Wenzel, Joseph, principe di Liechtenstein, 1041 Werth (de), Jacques, 649 Westerhout (von), Arnold, 1235 Wippels, *****, studioso di K.J.A. Mittermaier, 902 Wisard, Antonio, 715 Worm, Ole, 421 Worning, Andreas, 360 Würzburg, 1037 Young, Arthur, 630 Zaccagni, Lorenzo, 1167 Zaccaria, Francesco Antonio, 162-167, 1019, 1054-1057, 1128, 1129 Zaccheri, Girolamo, 269, 270 Zagabria, 178 Zaghi, Carlo, 79 Zamboni, Francesco, 357 Zambotti, Bernardino, 620 Zanardi, Teresa, 761 n. Zanasi, Margherita, 1103 Zanelli, Nicolò, 504 n. Zanfi, Giacomo, 356 Zanichelli, Nicola, 1134 Zannini, Giovanni Francesco, 100, 277, 279 Zanoni, Giacomo, 416, 421 n. Zanotti Cavazzoni, Giovanni Andrea, 1082, 1087 n. Zanotti, Giovanni Pietro, 206 Zapata, Francesco, 1267 Zatta, Antonio, 1008 Zattera, Giuseppe, 236, Zatti, Carlo, 238-240, 242 Zeno, Apostolo, 397
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1053 Vandelli, Giovanni Battista, 361, 363 n. Vandelli, Luigi, 359 Vandelli, Tommaso, 920, 958 Vandelli, via, 34, 64, 256, 280, 656, 1112 Vandelli, Vincenzo, 88, 273, 414 n. Vanelli, Iacopo Antonio, 662 Vanucci, Girolamo, 342 Vanulli, Girolamo, 209 Varano (Licciana N.) (MS), 541-543, 545-547, 940, 1194, 1195, 1205 Varese, 35, 96, 730 Vari, Isidoro, 610 Varignana (Castel S.Pietro T.) (BO), 208 Varion, Jean-Pierre, 382 Vasari, Giorgio, 130 Vaudemont (de), v. Lorena-Mercoeur (di) Vaudemont Vecchi, Alberto, 750, 1112 Vecchi, Angiola Celeste, 762 n. Vecchi, Giovanni, 1134, 1138-1140 Vecchi, Giuseppe, 762 n. Vecchi, Orazio, 432, 433, 788, 1064, 1079 Vecchi, Teresa Fortunata, 762 n. Vedriani, Lodovico, 5, 6, 129, 203, 327, 401, 456, 1005, 1006, 1025, 1097 Velazquez, Diego, 30, 184, 386 Vellani, Francesco, 208, 231, 313, 399 Velli, G****, attore veronese, 836 n. Venali, Martino, 999 Veneto, 970, 1172 Venezia, 37, 50, 53, 54, 60, 67, 71, 118, 169, 207, 236, 239, 274, 282, 287, 331, 333, 338, 339, 388, 397, 413, 417, 423, 432, 435, 464, 517, 522, 732, 740, 775, 838, 856, 953, 1011, 1023, 1033, 1036, 1049, 1057, 1091, 1128, 1139, 1157, 1186, 1195, 1196, 1198, 1208 Venturelli, Paolo Antonio, 567 Venturi, Adolfo, 242, 341, 354, 373, 376, 385 Venturi, Anna Rosa, 125, 427 n., 1111 Venturi, Franco, 894, 1036 Venturi, Giovanni Battista, 174, 362, 363 n., 427 n., 1048 Venturini, Ascanio, 581 n.
1365
Venturini, Salvatore, 35, 956 n., 957, 963, 965, 1008 Venturoli, Angelo, 85, 89, 311 Veratti, Bartolomeo, 742 n., 887, 900, 901, 1131 Veratti, Giovanni Battista, 899 Veratti, Giovanni Flaminio, 756 n. Veratti, Orazio, 415 Vercellesi, Sebastiano, 196 Vercelli, 723 Verdi, Giovanni Maria, 995-997, 1003, 1013, 1017 Verga, Giovanni, 1144 Vergalli, Nicolò, 538 Veri, Giulio, 1192 Verica (Pavullo n. Frignano) (MO), 499 Verona, 50, 338-340, 522, 639, 663, 1142, 1142 Veronesi, Giovanni, 624, 633 Veroni, Francesca, 1029 Verri, Gabriele, 16, 20 Verri, Pietro, 959 Verrucole (S.Romano in Garf.) (LU), 466, 546, 561, 562, 702, 708 Versailles, 34, 532, 1228 Versilia, 556 Verstappen, Martin, 241 Vespasiano, Tito Flavio, imperatore, 131 Vezzano sul Crostolo (RE), 238, 354, 380, 535 Viani, Girolamo, 1204 Viani, Luigi, 887, 896, 899 Vicini, Antonio, 229 Vicini, Emilio Paolo, 1099, 1109, 1111, 1112 Vicini, Giovanni Battista, 1091 Vico, Enea, 182, 413 Vienna, 13, 14, 35, 70, 172, 175, 207, 226, 242, 360, 372, 468, 529, 557, 559, 605, 606, 660, 735, 773, 840, 841, 868, 879, 951, 1031,1040, 1109, 1155-1158, 1168, 1169, 1222, 1242-1245, 1248, 1249, 1253, 1271 Vieusseux, Giovanni Pietro, 1134, 1135 Vigarani, Carlo, 1092 n. Vigarani, Gaspare, 88, 90, 155, 285, 347, 863, 1070, 1228 Vignaroli, Giovanni, Marcellino, 1103
1366
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
Zerbini, Antonio, 423, 426 Zerbini, Pietro jr, 902 Zerbini, Pietro sr, 387 n., 418, 423 Ziani, Marc’Antonio, 1069 Ziani, Pietro Andrea, 1069 Zini, Luigi, 741, 931, 1134, 1143-1146 Zinzani, Carlo, 418 Zoboli, Cesare, 363 n. Zoboli, Giacomo, 399 Zoboli, Giuseppe, 362
Zoboli, Ottavio, 1263, 1268 Zuccardi, Francesco, 601, 604 Zuccardi, Ubertino, 890 Zucchi, Carlo, 538, 836 n., 843 Zucchi, Vincenzo, 716 Zuccoli, Ilario, 566 Zweibrücken-Neuberg, Giovanni Guglielmo, conte palatino, 1039
,1',&( '(*/, $8725,
1369
andreolli Bruno, Mirandola e i Pico di fronte a Modena e agli Estensi Badini Gino, La Città ed il Ducato di Reggio nello Stato di Modena (1598-1859) Baracchi orianna, Vie, piazze, canali di Modena capitale Bedoni GiusePPe, Il diritto civile negli Stati estensi: dal codice del 1771 al codice del 1851 Bellina anna - Martelli Francesco, Le relazioni del Granducato di Toscana con lo Stato di Modena nei carteggi politici del Principato mediceo Bentini JadranKa, Collezionismo di corte: una sintesi e alcune riflessioni Bertacchini renato, Avvenimenti e personaggi politici modenesi nella civiltà letteraria dell’ottocento Bertuzzi Giordano, Rinnovamento edilizio di una capitale Biondi alBano, Tempi e memorie della città Biondi Grazia, Comunità e Corte a Modena nel periodo di formazione della capitale Bitossi carlo, Lo Stato di Modena e Genova Boccolari GiorGio, Gli Estensi di Modena Boccolari GiorGio, L’economia modenese nel periodo austro-estense Brizzi Gian Paolo, L’istruzione nello Stato di Modena BroGi Marina, Lo Stato di Modena e la Repubblica di Lucca calore Vecchi Marina, La vita teatrale a Modena dal Seicento all’Ottocento canoVa Maria, La tradizione artigiana nella Modena ducale caPucci Martino, Letteratura di una Capitale cattini Marco, Per un profilo dell’economia modenese nei secoli XVII e XVIII caVani Pier luiGi, v. Corradini Elena caVina Marco, Per una storia della cultura giuridica negli stati estensi: fonti e problemi chiarelli alessandra, La civiltà musicale modenese nel periodo estense (secc. XVII-XIX) corradini elena - caVani Pier luiGi, “La preziosa galleria delle medaglie e ricco Museo” degli Estensi nel palazzo Ducale di Modena
617 513 105 919 1179 181 1133 93 3 481 23 981 1211 1077 351 1115 45 887 1061 413 125
Indice degli autori
1370
Modena Montanari Gian carlo, Il Vescovato poi Arcivescovato di Modena (1598-1859) Montecchi GiorGio, Stampatori e librai nella Modena capitale degli Estensi Morena Marina, v. Londei Luigi Mussini MassiMo, La comunicazione grafica negli Stati estensi noBili uMBerto, Sculture in stucco nel territorio reggiano tra Sei e Settecento orlandi GiusePPe, I religiosi dello Stato di Modena nel Settecento tra riforme e rivoluzione Parente Maria, Lo Stato di Modena e lo Stato di Parma e Piacenza
1241 369 187 1097 635 451 495 1151 601
Pecoraro Mario, Massoneria, società segrete e “congiura estense” 855 PiGozzi Marinella, L’architettura del Pubblico a Modena e a Reggio Emilia al tempo di Francesco III e di Ercole III Pucci luiGi, “Il capitale di traffico”: aspetti e problemi dell’economia modenese del Settecento raFFo olGa, Il Ducato di Massa ed il Principato di Carrara nello Stato austro-estense raGGi Pier luiGi, La Garfagnana negli Stati Estensi ricci GiuliVo, La Lunigiana interna e gli Estensi riGhi Guerzoni lidia, La scultura a Modena nel Seicento: collezionismo e commissioni ducali rinaldi alBerto, Il possesso fondiario modenese dal sec. XVIII al 1859 roMBaldi odoardo, Dalla Repubblica Cispadana alla Repubblica Cisalpina. Giovanni Paradisi e Jacopo Lamberti santini GioVanni, Lo Stato Estense nel quadro degli ordinamenti italiani preunitari selMi Paolo, Lo Stato di Modena e Venezia seVeri rita, Rapporti tra il ducato di Modena e l’Inghilterra nel ’600. Il sogno di Maria di Modena regina d’Inghilterra sorrentino tullio, La nascita e il perdurare del “mito” dello Stato di Sassuolo sPaGGiari anGelo, Gli archivi negli Stati estensi
431 847 669 379 1159 867 1029 225 85 193 699 151
Indice degli autori
corradini elena, La zecca ducale di Modena: 1598-1796 coVa uGo, Austria e Modena: archivi, rapporti dinastici, politica commerciale curti Patrizia, Note sull’arredo ducale tra il XVIIe XIX secolo di Pietro Pericle, Rapporti degli Estensi con l’Università di Modena di Pietro loMBardi Paola, Modena nella storiografia post-unitaria: il contributo dei principali istituti culturali modenesi FaBBrici GaBriele, Riflessioni sulla genesi della Contea gonzaghesca di Novellara Federzoni laura, Gli Stati di Casa d’Este nella cartografia Fontana arMeno, Il Frignano nello Stato di Modena Gasser huBert, Lo Stato di Modena e l’Impero Ghidini alBerto, La Città ed il Principato di Correggio nello Stato di Modena Giannetti anna, Viaggiatori stranieri a Modena: alla scoperta di una città GioVannini carlo, La diffusione dell’arte organaria negli Stati estensi fra Seicento e Ottocento Grana daniela, Le istituzioni di assistenza e beneficenza di Modena capitale Guerzoni Guido, Le corti estensi nella devoluzione del 1598 liVerani Francesco, La ceramica nello Stato di Modena londei luiGi - Morena Marina, Lo Stato di Modena e la Santa Sede MalaGoli cesare, Comunità, nobiltà e borghesia nel periodo austroestense Marri FaBio, Muratori, Lo Stato di Modena e le relazioni col mondo tedesco Martelli Francesco, v. Bellinazzi Anna Martinelli BraGlia Graziella, La pittura nel Ducato austroestense Matteucci arMandi anna Maria, Il Palazzo Ducale di Modena e i disegni di Angelo Venturoli Mazza anGelo, Pittura “estense”" a Modena nei secoli XVII-XVIII. I maestri dell’Accademia di pittura Menziani alBerto, L’esercito estense ed austro-estense (1598- 1859) Milano ernesto, Vicissitudini della Biblioteca Estense alla Corte di
1371
719 995 385 345 743 1275 833 255 951 651 551 541 327 967 69 11 1227 587 933 905
1372
Indice degli autori
taVilla carMelo elio, La giustizia suprema negli Stati Estensi (secc. XV-XIX) turchi laura, Matrimoni e memoria genealogica fra tardo medioevo ed età moderna (genealogie estensi secc. XV-XVII) Vandelli Vincenzo, “...pour la beauté de ses bâtiments”: Modena e l’architettura aristocratica Venturi anna rosa, Girolamo Tiraboschi e le figure dei bibliotecari estensi nella Modena capitale zacchè GilBerto, La Città e il Principato di Carpi nello Stato di Modena. Istituzioni, economia e società (secc. XVI-XVII) zanardo andrea, Gli ebrei negli Stati estensi
801 305 1047 571 783
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1373
INDICE SOCIETÀ Guido Guerzoni - Le corti estensi nella devoluzione del 1598 alBerto Menziani - L’esercito estense ed austro-estense (1598-1859) Giancarlo Montanari - Il Vescovato poi Arcivescovato di Modena (1598-1859) GiusePPe orlandi - I religiosi dello Stato di Modena nel Settecento tra riforme e rivoluzione andrea zanardo - Gli ebrei negli Stati estensi laura turchi - Matrimoni e memoria genealogica fra tardo medioevo ed età moderna Mario Pecoraro - Massoneria, società segrete e “congiura estense” daniela Grana - Le istituzioni di assistenza e beneficenza di Modena Capitale anna Giannetti - Viaggiatori stranieri a Modena: alla scoperta di una città cesare MalaGoli - Comunità, nobiltà e borghesia nel periodo austroestense
669 699 719 743 783 801 833 847 855 867
IL DIRITTO E L’ECONOMIA Marco caVina - Per una storia della cultura giuridica negli Stati estensi: fonti e problemi carMelo elio taVilla - La giustizia suprema negli Stati estensi (secc. XV-XIX) GiusePPe Bedoni - Il diritto civile negli Stati estensi: dal codice del 1771 al codice del 1851 anGelo sPaGGiari - Gli archivi negli Stati estensi luiGi Pucci - “Il capitale di traffico”: aspetti e problemi dell’economia modenese del Settecento alBerto rinaldi - Il possesso fondiario modenese dal sec. XVIII al 1859 GiorGio Boccolari - L’economia modenese nel periodo austro-estense
887 905 919 933 951 967 981
LA CULTURA GiorGio Montecchi - Stampatori e librai nella Modena capitale degli Estensi FaBio Marri - Muratori, lo Stato di Modena e le relazioni col mondo tedesco anna rosa Venturi - Girolamo Tiraboschi e le figure dei bibliotecari estensi nella Modena Capitale alessandra chiarelli - La civiltà musicale modenese nel periodo estense (secc. XVII-XIX) Marina calore Vecchi - La vita teatrale a Modena dal Seicento all’Ottocento Paola di Pietro loMBardi - Modena nella storiografia post-unitaria: il contributo dei principali istituti culturali modenesi Martino caPucci - Letteratura di una Capitale renato Bertacchini - Avvenimenti e personaggi politici modenesi nella civiltà letteraria dell’Ottocento
995 1029 1047 1061 1077 1097 1115 1133
1374
Indice
MODENA E GLI STATI EUROPEI huBert Gasser - Lo Stato di Modena e l’Impero luiGi londei – Marina Morena - Lo Stato di Modena e la Santa Sede anna Bellinazzi – Francesco Martelli - Le relazioni del Granducato di Toscana con lo Stato di Modena nei carteggi politici del principato mediceo Marina BroGi - Lo Stato di Modena e la Repubblica di Lucca rita seVeri - Rapporti tra il ducato di Modena e l’Inghilterra nel ’600. Il sogno di Mariadi Modena regina d’Inghilterra uGo coVa - Austria e Modena: archivi, rapporti dinastici, politica commerciale Maria Parente - Lo Stato di Modena e lo Stato di Parma e Piacenza
1227 1241 1257
Bibliografia
1277
Indice dei nomi di persona e di luogo
1321
Indice degli autori
1367
1151 1159 1179 1211