Rural News Issue 498

Page 1

Dairy converts

Oilseed option

Success starts with the calves for Hawkes Bay farmers Karen & Donald Fraser. page 33

Biodiesel area continues to grow but price questions remain. page 15

Rural NEWS to all farmers, for all farmers

august 23, 2011: Issue 498

A Te Puke maize grower is coming back for more.

page 52

www.ruralnews.co.nz

New fears over TAF

snow bother

Rural News columnist Anna Holland’s dog Chloe moves these sheep on. Elsewhere calves were the concern. Snow reports pages 6-7; Holland’s column, p40

SUD ESH K I SSUN

Devil in the detail A FORMER Fonterra Shareholders Council chairman says 100% farmer control and ownership is essential under TAF. Blue Read says the TAF concept is “rock solid” and is the way forward for the co-op. However, it should not compromise on ownership and control. “The devil will be in the detail,” he told Rural News. “Outside capital is needed by the co-op but it must not come at a cost to farmer ownership and control. The council has to do a due diligence and understand the downstream

implications of TAF.” Read is aware of grumblings among farmers on the impact of investors on governance. He has received a few phone calls. Read is also aware of Eddie Glass’ group in Canterbury raising concerns on TAF. “I think farmers will be eagerly waiting for the next round of meetings.” As Rural News went to press, board member John Wilson was off to Canterbury to meet with the Glass group. Read, who chaired the shareholders council during TAF’s launch, believes the concept can work.

TAF includes a Fonterra Shareholders Fund developed to create additional liquidity and options to help supplying farmers stay in the cooperative. The fund would help supplying shareholders retain shares in Fonterra they might otherwise want to sell, or help farmers buy shares if they need them. Investors would be able to buy units in the fund. Unit holders would not own shares in Fonterra and therefore would not have voting rights. All voting rights would remain with supplying shareholders who would own the shares. • Shareholder exlplains concerns p5.

FONTERRA IS facing dissent among shareholders over its trading among farmers (TAF) scheme. One year after endorsing TAF some shareholders question whether they would keep 100% ownership and control of the co-op. A South Island group led by Ashburton farmer Eddie Glass is leading the charge. He voted last year for TAF, but says there is a “hidden agenda” to allow investors greater say in Fonterra’s governance. They fear investors holding dividend-bearing non-vot- Simon Couper ing units would end up appointing non-farmer directors, favouring higher dividends at the expense of milk price paid to suppliers. Shareholders would have to rubber-stamp appointments at annual meetings. Investor-friendly directors would lead to tensions between the dividend and milk price, Glass told Rural News. “We’d have a ‘Clayton’s vote’ in that we would be ratifying outside directors already vetted by the investors so we’d end up with all outside directors in favour of dividend returns as opposed to milk price. This is typical of the tensions between milk price and dividend yield as each has a dramatic effect on

When it comes to insurance, one size doesn’t fit all. Every property, business, or family is unique – with a unique set of risks. Which is why we don’t give you pre-packaged insurance policies. It’s just one of the things that makes us different.

Ask around about us, call for some advice on 0800 366 466 or search ‘FMG Insurance’ on

That’s what works out here. FMG 0030Y

hybrid you can trust

the other and therein lies the problem. “How can a board serve two masters? In history there has never been a co-op that has taken investors’ capital and survived as a co-op.” Glass also takes a swipe at the Fonterra Shareholders Council, saying it isn’t “asking the hard questions” on their behalf. The final TAF vote has been left to the council but Glass is worried. “When we look into this it is nothing other than a Clayton’s vote set up as a box-ticking exercise.” However, council chairman Simon Couper says “a good process” is in place to review TAF before final approval is given. Couper has not been contacted by Glass or his group but says criticism of the council is “a cheap shot”. He refused to discuss appointment of investorbacked directors, saying he was bound by a confidentiality agreement. But he conceded investors would want more say in running the co-op. “Ownership and control of the co-op is essential to our core beliefs. If investors interfere with control and ownership, then it will not be a box-ticking exercise for us,” he says. Fonterra chairman Henry van der Heyden says it is discussing governance to page 3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.