Shibam Eco-Tourist Desert Resort

Page 1

Shibam Eco-Tourist Desert Resort:

Cultural and Traditional Sustainable Architecture in Yemen

A Thesis Submitted to the Faculty of the Architecture Department in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Architecture at Savannah College of Art and Design

Saleh Salem Ahmed Almurshedi

Savannah, GA © May 2023

Prof. Huy Ngo, Thesis Chair

Emad Afifi, Arch. D, Thesis Committee

Dr. Ali Mohammed Bazarah, Thesis Committee

Acknowledgements

For my beloved parents,

Thank you for your unwavering support, love, and guidance. You have shaped me into the person I am today. Your belief in me and encouragement to pursue my passions mean the world to me. I am grateful for the incredible upbringing you provided. Your love and support will fuel my determination to make a positive impact on the world.

With heartfelt appreciation, For Sponsor -

I deeply appreciate your invaluable assistance. Your generosity has empowered me to pursue my academic goals, and I will forever cherish the impact of your contribution.

I’m sincerely grateful for your unwavering patience, consistent support, and inspiring words of encouragement. Your presence and guidance have been invaluable throughout this journey. Thank you.

Thank you for your continuous support and attentive ear during my thesis journey. Your architectural perspectives have been truly inspiring, motivating me to push the boundaries to their fullest extent. I sincerely appreciate your unwavering support.

Thank you for your unwavering support and valuable guidance during my thesis. Your insightful suggestions and encouragement played a pivotal role in this thesis.

I deeply appreciate your contribution.

For you -

Who believes our lives and historical sites hold boundless potential for improvement and transformation, embracing optimistic visions of countless idealistic possibilities.

To the Building Arts faculty -

You shaped the designer I’m today, every achievement belongs to you. Years of joy, thanks to all of you.

Table of Contents List of Figures ............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 01 Abstract ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 10 01- Prologue .............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 11 01.1- Introduction - Shibam – A UNESCO World Heritage Site .............................................................................................. 12 01.2- Shibam – A Popular Tourist Destination .............................................................................................................................. 14 01.3- Location ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 16 01.4-Users .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 17 01.5- Architectural Response .............................................................................................................................................................. 18 01.6- Architecture Project ................................................................................................................................................................... 18 01.7- Contribution to the Discipline ................................................................................................................................................. 18 02- Traditional Architecture in Shibam 19 02.1- Background .................................................................................................................................................................................... 20 02.2- Eco-tourism ................................................................................................................................................................................... 21 02.3- Applications of Traditional Sustainable Yemen Architecture ..................................................................................... 23 02.4- Shibam Sustainable Mudbrick Houses ............................................................................................................................. 24 03- Case Studies .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 26 03.1- Preser ving Shibam Surroundings: In the Face of Rapid Change ............................................................................. 27 03.1.1 Rational ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 27 03.2- Case Study One Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort & Spa .................................................................................................. 28 03.2.2- Project General Information ............................................................................................................................................. 28 03.2.3- Project Description .............................................................................................................................................................. 28 03.2.4 Site Location .......................................................................................................................................................................... 28 03.2.5- Project Program ................................................................................................................................................................... 30 03.2.6- Spaces and Leisure Activities ........................................................................................................................................... 30 03.2.7- Conclusion ............................................................................................................................................................................. 31 03.3.1- Case Study Two: Wadi Rum Resort ................................................................................................................................ 32 03.3.1- Project General Information .............................................................................................................................................. 32 03.3.2- Project Description ............................................................................................................................................................... 32 03.3.3- Project Concept and Philosophy ................................................................................................................................ 33 03.3.4- Site Location ............................................................................................................................................................................. 33 03.3.5- Structure ................................................................................................................................................................................... 36 03.3.6- Built Area Percentage ........................................................................................................................................................ 37 03.3.7- Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................................. 37 03.4.1- Case Studies Three : Amangiri Resort & Spa .................................................................................................................... 38 03.4.2-Project Description ................................................................................................................................................................... 38 03.4.3- Project Concept and Philosophy ..................................................................................................................................... 38 03.4.4- Project (Space Distribution) ............................................................................................................................................. 41 03.4.5- Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................... 41 04 - Site Analysis ...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 42 04.1- Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................. 43 04.2- Site Selection Criteria ................................................................................................................................................................. 43 04.3-Location ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 43 04. 4 - Site inventory and analysis ...................................................................................................................................................... 45 04.5- The Sewage Disposal System ................................................................................................................................................... 47 04.6- Weather and climate in Shibam ............................................................................................................................................. 48 04.7- Summary of the Climate ............................................................................................................................................................. 50 05- Architecture Program .................................................................................................................................................................................. 51 05.1- Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................. 52 05.2- Project users .................................................................................................................................................................................... 52 05.3- Eco-resort Project Component ................................................................................................................................................ 53 05.4- Accommodations .................................................................................................................................................................... 54 05.5- Restaurants .................................................................................................................................................................................... 56 05.6- Coffee Shop ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 57 05.7- Spa and wellness .......................................................................................................................................................................... 57 05.8- Fitness .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 57 05.9- Administration ............................................................................................................................................................................... 58 05.10- Staff Building .............................................................................................................................................................................. 59 05.11- Support Facilities .................................................................................................................................................................... 59 05.12- Outdoor Activity ................................................................................................................................................................... 60 05.13- Other Facilities ................................................................................................................................................................... 60 06 Goals and Objectives ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 61 06.1 Goals and Objectives .................................................................................................................................................................... 62 07- Design Development and final design .................................................................................................................................................. 63 07.1 -Concept Generation ................................................................................................................................................................... 64 07.2- Conceptual Design Development .......................................................................................................................................... 65 07. 3 - Program Distribution ................................................................................................................................................................. 66
07.4- Site Architecture and Views to Landscape ...................................................................................................................... 66 07.5- Site Section and Views to Landscape ............................................................................................................................... 67 07.6- Chalet Type A ............................................................................................................................................................................... 68 07.7- Chalet Type B ............................................................................................................................................................................... 68 07.8- Chalet Type C ............................................................................................................................................................................... 69 07. 9 - Cluster Chalets .................................................................................................................................................................... 69 07.10 - Construction techniques of wall building .................................................................................................................. 70 07.11- Construction techniques of roof building .................................................................................................................. 72 07.12- Exhibition Boards .................................................................................................................................................................... 74 Bibliography ...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 78

Yemen.” Embassy of Yemen RSS. accessed November 12, 2022.

13, 2020. https://misfitsarchitecture.com/2014/08/02/the-buildings-of-yemen/.

Mosleh. “A Study on the Global Economic Impact on the Tourism Industry in Yemen.” ResearchGate. October 11, 2018.

James Pasley, “Inside War-Torn Yemen’s Ancient Skyscraper City, Dubbed the ‘Manhattan of the Desert,’ That’s on the Brink of Ruin.” Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/photo s-show-shibam-yemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

Figure 1.7: Location of Shibam in Yemen

CARR, KATE. “Going to the Hadhramaut, Imagine A World Dedicated To Love, A World Which Knows Only The Way Of Humanity.” April 15, 2016. https://travel196-.weebly.com/yemen.html.

Figure 1.8: Theis Project Site Proposal

Google Earth. “Shibam.” Imagery date July 7, 2022. https://earth.google.com/web search/- Shibam,+Yemen/.

Figure 1.9: Art work model of Shibam

CARR, KATE, “Going to the Hadhramaut, Imagine A World Dedicated To Love, A World Which Knows Only The Way Of Humanity,” April 15, 2016,https://travel196.weebly.com/yemen.html.

Figure. 2.1Cultural and Traditional (Design by Author)..............................................................................................................................

1 List of Figures Figure 1.1: Shibam City ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 11 Atif,
Sa’adi.
/content/shibam-hadramout-
Figure 1.2: Wall of Shibam City ............................................................................................................................................................................ 12 “Visit
http://embassy-of-
Figure. 1.3. Aerial View of the Shibam City .................................................................................................................................................. 12 McKay,
June
Figure 1.4: Table of International Tourism Receipts (Table) -Yemen 2007-2010. ............................................................................... 13 Alnajjar, Mosleh.
ResearchGate.
_A_Study_on_the_Global_Economic_Impact_on_the_Tourism_Industry_in_Yemen. Figure 1.5: Table of International Tourism Receipts (Graph) -Yemen 2007-2010. .............................................................................. 14 Alnajjar,
Figure 1.6: Top view of Shibam .......................................................................................................................................................................... 16
Al
Alaa, Askol. United Nations. August 18, 2022. https://www.-un.org/ungifts
manhattan-desert.
yemen.pl/en/home/visit-yemen/.
Graham. “The Buildings of Yemen Misfits’ Architecture.”
“A Study on the Global Economic Impact on the Tourism Industry in Yemen.”
October 11, 2018. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330279306-
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330279306_A_Study_on_the_Global_Economic_Impact_on_the_Tourism_Industry_in_Yemen.
.................................................................................................................................................. 15
16
............................................................................................................................................................
..............................................................................................................................................................
18
20

Figure 2.2: View of Shibam

Khan, Gulnaz. “This Ancient Mud Skyscraper City Is the ‘Manhattan of the Desert’.”Travel. National Geographic, May 4, 2021. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article-/shibam-mud-skyscraper-yemen.

Figure 2.3: Visitors of Shibam

James Pasley, “Inside War-Torn Yemen’s Ancient Skyscraper City, Dubbed the ‘Manhattan of the Desert,’ That’s on the Brink of Ruin,” Business Insider, accessed March 19, 2023, https://www.businessinsider.com /photos-show-shibam-yemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

Fig. 2.4. Elevtion of Shibam ...................................................................................................................................................................................

Super User, “Shibam Hadramuot,” Yemen Tourism Promotion Board - Shibam Hadramuot, accessed March 9,2023,https://www.yementourism.com/explore-yemen/historical-tourism/40-shibam-hadramuot.com/ photos-show-shibam-yemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

Fig. 2.5: wall of Shibam

UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Old Walled City of Shibam,” UNESCO World Heritage Centre, https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/192/.

Fig. 2.6. Restoration of mud brick buildings

Laylin, Tafline. “Yemen’s Manhattan of the Desert Is 400 Towers Made from Clay.” Green Prophet, October 22, 2020. https://www.greenprophet.com/2011/12/yemen-clay-towers/.

Fig. 2.7 Drying of mud bricks

Chulov, Dmitry. “Mud Brick Factory, Shibam, Hadhramaut Valley, Yemen.” 123RF. https://www. 123rf.com/photo_34686272_mud-brick-factory-shibam-hadhramaut-valley-yemen.html.

Figure 3.1: Shibam from above ....................................................................................................................................................................

Figure 3.1: Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort &Spa. Top view of the resort. ..............................................................................................

Healy, Melinda. “Qasr Al Sarab.” The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, January 13, 2016. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/- destinations/middle-east/united-arab- emirates /abu-dhabi/hotels/qasr- al-sarab-hotel/.

Figure 3.2: A Type of chalet .................................................................................................................................................................................

Resorts & Spas Anantara Hotels, “Where Is Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara Located?,” Qasr Al Sarab Abu Dhabi. https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-alsarab-abu-dhabi.

22

Figure 3.3: Location of Qasr Al Sarab

“Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara.” Anantara. Accessed November 15, 2022.

https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-al-sarab-abu-dhabi/contact.

Figure 3.4: Resort Layout

Google Earth View of Qasr Al Sarab. Sunny. “1001 Tales from the Arabian Desert.” theinnersun, September 23, 2014. https://theinnersun.wordpress.com/2014/- 09/23/1001-tales- from-the- arabian-desert/.

Figure 3.5: Master Plan .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 29

23

Eerie, Bucyrus. “Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort.” Bucyrus Mines Stuff, February 20, 2015. https:// bucyrusmines.wordpress.com/2015/02/20/qasr-al-sarab-desert-resort/

Fig. 3.6: 196 Luxuriously appointed rooms, suites & villas (Table)............................................................................................................ 29

24

“Escape to a 5-Star Hotel Oasis in the Deserts of Abu Dhabi.” Accommodation. Accessed November 15, 2022. https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-al- sarab-abu-dhabi/rooms.

Figure 3.7: Camel Trekking

Writer, Staff. “12 Things to Know about Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort.” cntravellerme, April 23, 2019. https://www.cntravellerme.com/dest i nations/middle-east/uae/1859-10-things- to-knowabout-qasr-al-sarab-desert-resort

Figure 3.8: Archery ....................................................................................................................................................................................................

25

“Sunset Walk - Picture of Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara, Hamim.” Tripadvisor. Accessed November 16, 2022.https://www.tripadvisor.com/LocationPhoto Dir ectLink-g1597051- d1479615i374957244Qasr_Al_Sarab_Desert_Resort_b y_Anantara-

27

Figure 3.9: Outdoor Sitting. The rooftop Suhail is Qsar Al Sarab’s fine grill restaurant

28

Oseid, John. “Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara: An Oasis Inn Blooms in Abu Dhabi.” Forbes. Forbes Magazine, June 26, 2019. https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnoseid/2017/04/12/qasr-alsarab-desert-resort- by-anantara- an-oasis- inn-blooms-in-abu-dhabi/?sh=13f76321469d.

Figure 3.10: Wadi Rum Resort ...........................................................................................................................................................................

28

Luxigon. “Luxury Wadi Rum Desert Resort by Oppenheim Architecture.” 88DesignBox, May 16, 2015. http://88designbox.com/architecture/luxury-wadi- rum-desert-resort-by- oppenheim- archtiecture-421.html.

Figure 3.11: Location of the Rum resort on Google Maps ......................................................................................................................... 32

“The Resort Is Located in 70 Kilometers South of Jordan, in Wadi Rum.” Google maps. Google.Accessed May 10, 2022.

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Wadi+Rum+Village,+Jordan- /@29.5733571,35.4174796,16z/data=!3m1! 4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x150092cf983251f9:0x13e9c812 0714754!8m2!3d29.5742989!4d35.4210371.

Figure 3.12: Main zoning of the resort

Luxigon. “Luxury Wadi Rum Desert Resort by Oppenheim Architecture.” 88DesignBox, May 16, 2022. http:// 88designbox.com/architecture/luxury-wadi-rum- desert-resort-by- oppenheimarchtiecture-421.html.

33

2 3
...............................................................................................................................................................
28
......................................................................................................................................................................................
29
...................................................................................................................................................................................
30
30
.................................................................. 31
31
............................................................................................................................................................
..................................................................................................................................................................................
21
................................................................................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................................................................................
...................................................................................................................................................
25
................................................................................................................................................................................

Figure 3. 13: Lodge Floor Plan

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2022. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum- eco-resort-by-oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3. 14: Welcome Floor Plan

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com,May 17, 2022. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by-oppenheim- architecture/.

Figure 3.15: Entrance Area .....................................................................................................................................................................................

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/.

Figure 3.16: Main Entrance ................................................................................................................................................................................

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06 wadi-rum-desert-resort/.

Figure 3.17: Spa Floor Plan. “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort

34 Oppenheim_Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www.arch2o.com-/mountain-carved wadi-rum-eco-resort-by- oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3.18: Pools Floor Plans

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by- oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3. 19: Tent View

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www.toxel.com /inspiration /2012/11/06/wadirum-desert-resort/.

Figure 3. 20: Tent Section

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3. 21: Suites Section ................................................................................................................................................................................. 35

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by- oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3. 22: Interior View of Suites

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadirum-desert-resort/.

Figure 3. 23: Glazed Suites

McManus, David. “Wadi Rum Lodges Jordan Luxury Resort - e-Architect.” e-architect, February 19, 2020. https://www.e-architect.com/jordan/wadi-rum-lodges.

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/. Figure 3. 25: Night View

David. “Wadi Rum Lodges Jordan Luxury Resort - e-Architect.” e-architect, February 19, 2020. https://www.e-architect.com/jordan/wadi-rum-lodges.

“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort- by-oppenheim-architecture/.

Figure 3. 27: Outdoor Pool

“Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/. Figure 3. 28: Built Area Percentage

“10 Most Expensive Luxury Hotels in the US.” Luxury Travel Magazine, July 18, 2019. https://www.luxurytravelmagazine.com/news-articles/10-most- expensive-luxury-hotels-in-the-us.

Figure 3. 30: View from Swimming Pool

“Amangiri.” Ker & Downey - A World of Difference, July 30, 2020. https://kerdowney.com/- destinations/ united-states/national-parks/amangiri/.

Figure 3. 31: Desert Lounge ............................................................................................................................................................................... 39

Staff, Geartide, and Geartide Staff GEARTIDE covers cars. “Amangiri Is a Bucket List Worthy Resort in the American Southwest.” Geartide, April 16, 2017. https://www.geartide.com- /amangiri- resort-american-southwest/.

Figure 3. 32: Suite View .....................................................................................................................................................................................

Staff, Geartide, and Geartide Staff GEARTIDE covers cars. “Amangiri Is a Bucket List Worthy Resort in the American Southwest.” Geartide, April 16, 2017.https://www.geartide.com/ namangiri- resort-american-southwest/.

Figure 3. 33: Living Area ........................................................................................................................................................................................

“Amangiri Resort.” Contract Design, July 20, 2017.https://www.contractdesign.com/galle ries /projectshospitality/amangiri-resort/#5.

Figure 3. 34: Dining Area ......................................................................................................................................................................................

“Amangiri: Hotels in the US.” Audley Travel, May 12, 2020. https://www.audleytravel.com/ca/usa/acco mmodation/amangiri.

Figure 3. 35: Spa Sauna ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 40

“The Amangiri Spa & Resort Brings Modern Luxury to Southern Utah That Blends in.” If It’s Hip, It’s Here (Archives). Accessed November 16, 2022. https://ifitshipitshere.blogspot-

4 5
3.
.................................................................................................................................................................................. 36
Figure
24: Outdoor View
..................................................................................................................................................................................... 36 McManus,
........................................................................................................................................................................................ 37
Figure 3. 26: Tent Area
................................................................................................................................................................................... 37
................................................................................................................................................................... 37 By Author
3.
Amangiri Resort & Spa ................................................................................................................................................................... 37
Figure
29:
........................................................................................................................................................... 38
39
39
39
............................................................................................................................................................................
33
.......................................................................................................................................................................
33
34
34
................................................................................................
............................................................................................................................................................................
34
..........................................................................................................................................................................................
34
..................................................................................................................................................................................
35
.................................................................................................................................................................... 35
.................................................................................................................................................................................. 36

Figure 3. 36: Treatment Room ............................................................................................................................................................................

Dubin, Alesandra. “Pamper Yourself at These 10 Hotel Spas in the US, from Arizona’s Hot Springs to New York’s Finger Lakes.” Insider. Insider, May 10, 2022. https://www-.insider.com/guides/travel/best-hotels-with-spas-us.

Figure 3. 37: A single row of lights glow

Samanthabrown. “4 Amazing Adventures in Canyon Point, Utah.” Samantha Brown’s Places to Love, December 5, 2017. https://samantha- brown.com/destinations/desert-dreaming- canyon-point-utah-amangiri/. Figure 3. 38: Built

(n.d.). Retrieved December 5, 2022, from https:// geology.com/world/yemen-satellite- image.shtml

Figure 4. 2: Report: Yemen’s Agriculture in Distress

CEOBS. (2022, January 4). Retrieved December 5, 2022, from https://ceobs.org/yemens- agriculture-in-distress/

Figure

Lucarelli, Fosco, and For Reliable urban Planning Services Choose HPC Urban Design Planning says. “The Walled City of Shibam, a ‘Manhattan of the Desert’.” SOCKS, February 24, 2019. https://socks-studio.com/2012/08/12/the-walledcity -of-shibam-a-manhattan-of-the-desert/.

Figure 4. 9: sun path and direction buildings in Shibam Hadramout city ......................................................................................... 48

Alabsi, Akram Ahmed Noman. “The Applications Of Traditional Building Technologies In Contemporary Architecture In Yemen.” researchgate, May 2013. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/By-used-Ecotect-program-sunpath-and-direction-buildings-inShibam-Hadramout-city_fig25_336124405.

Figure 4.10: Comparison of ambient temperature with inside temperature of mud house......................................................... 48

Alabsi, Akram Ahmed Noman. “The Applications Of Traditional Building Technologies In Contemporary Architecture In Yemen.” researchgate, May 2013. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/By-used-Ecotect-program-sunpath-and-direction-buildings-inShibam-Hadramout-city_fig25_336124405.

6 7 Figure 4.11: Outside temperature (Chart) .................................................................................................................................................... 49 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/. Figure 4. 12: Precipitation (rainfall) - (Chart) .................................................................................................................................................. 49 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/. Figure 4.13: Daily sunshine hours (Chart) ...................................................................................................................................................... 50 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/. Figure 4. 14: Humidity (Chart) .............................................................................................................................................................................. 50 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/. Figure 5. 1 Eco-Resort users’ classification .................................................................................................................................................. 52 By Author Figure 5. 2: Eco-resort Project Component .................................................................................................................................................. 53 By Author Figure 5. 3: Chalet Type A ................................................................................................................................................................................... 54 By Author Figure 5. 4: Chalet Type B ................................................................................................................................................................................... 55 By Author Figure 5. 5: Chalet Type C .................................................................................................................................................................................... 55 By Author Figure 5. 6: Restaurants ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 56 By Author Figure 5. 7: Coffee Shop ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 57 By Author Figure 5. 8: Spa and Fitness ............................................................................................................................................................................... 57 By Author Figure 5. 9: Fitness ................................................................................................................................................................................................. 58 By Author Figure 5. 10: Administration .............................................................................................................................................................................. 58 By Author Figure 5. 11: Staff Building ................................................................................................................................................................................... 59 By Author
40
........................................................................................................................................................ 40
Percentage (Chart) ............................................................................................................................................. 41 By Author Figure 3.
Total Area Percentage (Chart) ................................................................................................................................................... 41 By Author Figure 4. 1: Yemen map .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 43
up Area
39:
geology.
................................................................................................................................. 44
......................................................................................................................................................... 54 By Author Figure 4. 4: Camel .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 44 By Author Figure 4.
Road ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 44 By Author Figure 4. 6: Site analysis and views of Shibam ............................................................................................................................................ 45 By Author
4. 7: Site analysis ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 46 By Author
4.
Disposal System ...................................................................................................................................................... 47
4. 3: Site inventory and analysis
5: Camel
Figure
Figure
8: The Sewage

Dmitry. “Mud Brick Factory, Shibam, Hadhramaut Valley, Yemen.” 123RF. https://www. 123rf.com/photo_34686272_mud-brick-factory-shibam-hadhramaut-valley-yemen.html.

Gray-Grant, “He Has a Hay Bale of Hair on His Head...: The Publication Coach,” Publication Coach, March 1, 2022, https://www.publicationcoach.com/johanna-schneller/.

Rainey, “Man Making Bricks by Hand,” 123RF, accessed June 1, 2023, https://www.123rf.com/photo_ 6940140_man-making-bricks-by-hand.html.

Centre, “Old Walled City of Shibam,” Gallery - UNESCO World Heritage Centre, accessed June 1, 2023, https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/192/gallery/&index=13&maxrows=12.

Resort - Hotel Reviews (Ḩayd Al Jazīl, Yemen),” Tripadvisor, https://www.tripadvisor.com-/Hotel_Review-g15522224-d7306837-Re views-Hayd_Al_Jazeel_Resort-Ayd_al_Jazil_Hadhramout.html.

8 9 Figure 7. 12: Chalet Type (C) Perspective ...................................................................................................................................................... 69 By Author Figure 7. 13: Cluster Chalets Perspective ...................................................................................................................................................... 69 By Author Figure 7.14: Drying of mud bricks .................................................................................................................................................................... 70 Chulov,
Figure 7.15: The Chopped straw ....................................................................................................................................................................... 70 Daphne
Figure 7.16: Mud brick moulds .......................................................................................................................................................................... 70 Jerry
Figure 7. 17: Construction Techniques Walls and roof .............................................................................................................................. 71 By Author Figure 7. 18: Construction Techniques Walls and Foundations ............................................................................................................. 71 By Author Figure 7. 19: Construction Techniques Foundations ................................................................................................................................ 71 By Author Figure 7. 20 Timber column, and joists ........................................................................................................................................................... 72 UNESCO
Figure 7. 21: Construction techniques of roof building ........................................................................................................................... 72 By Author Figure 7. 22 timber joists ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 72 “Hayd Al-Jazeel
Figure 7. 23 (Board #1) ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 73 By Author Figure 7. 24 (Board #2) ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 74 By Author Figure 7. 25 (Board #3) ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 75 By Author Figure 7. 26 (Board #4) ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 76 By Author Figure 5. 12: Prayer Hall ......................................................................................................................................................................................... 59 By Author Figure 5. 13: Event Hall .................................................................................................................................................................................... 59 By Author Figure 5. 14: Outdoor Activity ........................................................................................................................................................................... 60 By Author Figure 5. 16: Other Facilities .............................................................................................................................................................................. 60 By Author Figure 6. 1: The goals: Other Facilities ........................................................................................................................................................... 62 By Author Figure 6. 2: Goals and Objectives Other Facilities ..................................................................................................................................... 62 By Author Figure 7. 1 Concept generation of chalets .................................................................................................................................................... 64 By Author Figure 7. 2: Concept generation of master plan ......................................................................................................................................... 64 By Author Figure 7. 3: Conceptual massing ...................................................................................................................................................................... 64 By Author Figure 7. 4: Site with Program Distribution .................................................................................................................................................. 66 By Author Figure 7. 5: View the resort from Shibam City ............................................................................................................................................. 66 By Author Figure 7. 6: Site Section ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 67 By Author Figure 7. 7: Chalet Type (A) Plan ....................................................................................................................................................................... 68 By Author Figure 7. 8: Chalet Type (B) Plan ........................................................................................................................................................................ 68 By Author Figure 7. 9: Chalet Type (A) Perspective ......................................................................................................................................................... 68 By Author Figure 7. 10: Chalet Type (B) Perspective ....................................................................................................................................................... 68 By Author Figure 7. 11: Chalet Type (C) Plan ...................................................................................................................................................................... 69 By Author
World Heritage

Abstract

Shibam Eco-Tourist Desert Resort: Cultural and Traditional Sustainable Architecture in Yemen

This thesis examines the architectural and cultural significance of Shibam, a 16th-century walled city in Yemen designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. It focuses on the exceptional traditional Hadrami Yemeni architecture displayed in Shibam’s multi-storeyed mud brick houses. The city’s well-preserved layout, skyline, and integration with the surrounding landscape showcase its outstanding universal cultural and historical value. To address the need for sustainable tourism development, the thesis proposes an eco-tourist resort outside the city’s walls, aiming to accommodate increasing tourism demands, generate income for local residents, and preserve Shibam’s architectural character. Furthermore, the study explores the role of architecture in preserving cultural artifacts and enhancing human experiences in heritage sites. By advocating for culturally relevant designs, the thesis aims to promote sustainable development and responsible tourism practices while preserving Shibam’s historical identity. The research and design presented contribute to the understanding and appreciation of Shibam’s unique urban and architectural heritage in the context of tradition and modernity.

Keywords-

Yemen; Hadhramout; Shibam;Traditional Architectural; Cultural heritage; UNESCO World Heritage Site; Mud brick Houses; Eco-resort; Eco-tourism; Sustainable Architecture; Architectural identity.

10
Saleh Salem Ahmed Almurshedi
01 Prologue

1.1

Introduction - Shibam – A UNESCO World Heritage Site

Yemen, a country in the Arabian Peninsula, includes many distinctive historical cities listed on the World Heritage List by UNESCO. One of the most impressive listings is the 16th- century walled city of Shibam in the Hadhramout region of Yemen. Listed by UNESCO in 1982 on the UNESCO World Heritage List, it was described as the ‘Manhattan’ of the desert by English traveler Freya Stark in the 1930s.1 Shibam played an important role in the 3rd century when it became the capital of the Hadhramout during the age of the incense trade.2 Shibam City, the name Shibam is named after Shibam bin Al-Harith bin Hadhramout bin Saba Al- Asghar, the king of Shibam.3 Shibam has been used since ancient times as a residential space tmade of mud

brick materials from the same environment. Shibam was a prosperous city forcenturies because it was a stopover place for those traveling along the spice and incense routes during the spice trading era. Moreover, on its northern, western, and eastern borders, the city is surrounded by palm trees and fields reserved for cultivation. Hence, we find that the horizontal expansion of the city consisted merely of the construction of a few buildings outside its southern walls.4

Shibam city lies in the Wadi Hadhramout Region. This city exemplifies exceptional urban planning and development dating back to ancient times, characterized by its multistoreyed constructions. It stands as a remarkable testament to traditional Hadrami urban architecture, evident in its well-organized grid street system, inviting squares, and the striking visual presence of its tower-like mud brick

houses. Situated amidst a floodplain, the city’s elevated form beautifully emerges, showcasing the mastery of construction techniques employed throughout history.

The city is surrounded by a palm grove on three sides, and is perched upon a rocky spur and surrounded by a giant flood wadi. Its elevated position shields it from flooding while maintaining proximity to its primary source of water and agriculture. Also, flood protection is provided by a wall around the tightly clustered tall buildings on a hill. Unlike other historical cities in the world, Shibam has a unique architectural heritage because it is predominately constructed out of mud brick structures integrated into vertical construction. Thus, it was referred to as a “high-rise” city in ancient times. Shibam’s traditional architecture has a unique artistic legacy that reflects the culture of peoples and the continuing history of successive civilizations.5

buildings, and the relationship between the city and its

1 Gulnaz Khan, “This Ancient Mud Skyscraper City Is the Manhattan of the Desert,” National Geographic Travel, April 3, 2017, https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article/shibam-mud- skyscraper-yemen.

2 Naji Thawaba, “Shibam (Yemen): General Information,” Organization of World Heritage Cities, September 27, 2018, https:// www.ovpm.org/city/shibam-yemen-2/.

3 Ronald Lewcock, “Wadi Hadramawt and the Walled City of Shibam,” Unesdoc.unesco.org, July 15, 1986, https://unesdoc. unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000071939.

4 Anwar Baeissa, “Mud-Brick High-Rise Buildings Architectural Linkages for Thermal Comfort in Hadhramout Valley, Yemen,” Fdocuments.net, October 5, 2013, https://fdocuments.net/document/mud- brick-high-rise-buildings-architecturallinkages-for-thermal-comfort-in-hadhramout-valley- yemen.html?page=1.

Shibam has remained unchanged for centuries. The attributes that carry Outstanding Universal Value include the city layout, the city skyline, the city wall, the traditional

In addition, the site preserves its intangible cultural heritage passed down from generation to generation. Residents of Shibam have lived for decades in strong social relationships, and their religious and cultural heritage contributed to Shibam society and to the city as a whole. Shibam, as a city, consists of many architectures that were designed and constructed to closely reflect the people, the

5 “Shibam – the Oldest Skyscraper City.” Ritebook, April 21, 2014. https://www.ritebook.in/2014/04/the-oldest-skyscrapercity-shibam-yemen.html.

6 UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Old Walled City of Shibam,” Accessed May 8, 2022. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/192/.

12 13
Fig. 1.2. “Visit Yemen,” Embassy of Yemen RSS, accessed November 12, 2022,http://embassy-of-yemen.pl/en home/visityemen/. Fig. 1.3. McKay, Graham, “The Buildings of Yemen Misfits’ Architecture,June 13, 2020, https://misfitsarchitecture. com/2014/08/02/the-buildings-of-yemen/ Fig. 1.1 Al Sa’adi Atif, Alaa, Askol, United Nations, August 18,2022,https://www.-un.org/ungifts/content/shibam hadramoutmanhattan-desert.

culture, and its place identity.

Shibam has a unique urban and architectural heritage that’s located on the threshold between past and present, tradition and modernity. This walled city of vertical mudbrick high-rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds its own iterative narrative in a stunning, almost

meters tall, with only one gate.

1.2 Shibam – A Popular Tourist Destination

Tourism has become increasingly important in Yemen as a whole and Shibam specifically because of the changing in the economy. With the disappearance of the old trade

Yemen is ranked 137 in the world in terms of tourism. “In 2015, according to data published by the Ministry of Tourism – Yemen, it recorded a total of 398,000 to the Shibam City.”7

One contributing factor of such low ranking is due to the lack of appropriate accommodation infrastructure at the site for visitors and tourists to stay while visiting the city. The lack of accommodation infrastructure is due to several factors, the most important of which is the city itself and its geographical location. It is located in the middle of a valley and is surrounded by a wall to

preserve it from geographic and climatic conditions. As a result, it can expand outward with new construction and development. Furthermore, as a UNESCO designation, its cultural, architectural, and archaeological heritage must be preserved, and it is prohibited from having any new construction within the city walls. Nevertheless, as tourism becomes more popular in the city and since economic resources will help to sustain the indigenous population of the city, Shibam will need to create resort accommodations to support tourism for those visiting the site.

*Note: in the Graph above, the researcher relied on tourism statistics for 2010 due to the suspension of tourism statistics reports issued by the ministry of tourism in Yemen for 2010 due to the decade of civil war in Yemen.

7 “Yemen Tourism Statistics,” CEIC, accessed September 20, 2022,https://www.- ceicdata.- com/en/yemen/tourism-statistics.

15
Fig. 1.5. Alnajjar, Mosleh, “A Study on the Global Economic Impact on the Tourism Industry in Yemen,” ResearchGate, October11,2018,https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330279306-_A_Study_on_the_Global_Economic_Impact_ on_the_Tourism_Industry_in_Yemen.

1.3 Location:

The proposed site is in the Country of Yemen, the Mid Region of the Hadhramaut Governorate Area, and in the City of Shibam.

Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/photos-show-shibamyemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

https://earth.google.com/web/search/ Shibam,+Yemen/.

14 Users:

The Visitors (The tourists) and Resort Staff.

The architecture project will consist of an Eco-hotel Resort covering approximately 35,000 sq. ft.The resort capacity is 100 visitors spread among three types of chalets to accommodatethem, one can accommodate 6 people and with an area of 650 ft² and the second one can accommodate 2 people and with an area of 360 ft². There are 32 employees divided into different categories.

There is a need for a resort to assist with the growing demand for tourism to the city. In a similar style to the historical city, this project will design an eco-tourist resort overlooking the city. There will be a variety of cultural and historical art shows at the resort, as well as desertrelated activities such as camping, camel riding, rest, relaxation, and meditation, allowing local and foreign visitors to enjoy activities reflective of the local traditions.

16 17
Fig. 1.8. Google Earth. “Shibam,” Image date April 7, 2022, 1.5 Architectural Response Fig. 1.7. CARR, KATE, “Going to the Hadhramaut, Imagine a World Dedicated to Love, a World Which Knows Only the Way of Humanity,” April 15, 2016,https://travel196.weebly.com/yemen.html. Fig. 1.6. Top view of Shibam. James Pasley, “Inside War-Torn Yemen’s Ancient Skyscraper City, Dubbed the ‘Manhattan of the Desert,’ That’s on the Brink of Ruin.”

1.6 Architecture Project

This thesis aims to improve Shibam’s architecture to accommodate more tourism. In addition, increasing tourism can provide income to local residents who live in Shibam and support families to compensate for decreased revenues. This thesis aims to design innovative and sustainable projects for traditional architecture in Yemen, with a focus on creating designs that are both culturally relevant and responsive to contemporary needs and challenges.The resort site will be outside the city’s wall borders not only to improve tourism, social, economic, and cultural conditions but also to preserve the identity and architectural character of Shibam city. Further, this study will enhance the historical identity of Shibam’s traditional architecture. Studying Yemeni traditional architecture is also an inspiration. Meanwhile, this study will enhance the role of tourism by creating an eco-resort in line with sustainable development goals and sufficient tourist accommodations for visitors. Finally, this thesis will establish guidelines that need to be followed according to the conditions of the specific location and the important goals of reducing destructive tourism in protected areas that have a unique historical value.

1.7 Contribution to the Discipline

Preserving designated architectural heritage is essential to society because it provides the documentation of the physical environment which mankind has constructed and reflects the socially and culturally significant expression of human society. This thesis will contribute to the body of knowledge of architecture by expressing how society as a whole sees itself and views the built environment that as it reflects human cultural development. By exploring how the demand for contemporary architecture fulfills a human need, architecture can also play an active role in supporting the pre-existing historic cultural artifacts in its proximity. This thesis project will focus on fostering the human experience and understanding at both the individual and community levels by providing an invaluable resource for public architecture usage heritage sites. The research and design conducted for this thesis will advocate that fostering human social experience design will make a positive contribution to the cultural and heritage understanding of a place at a designated architectural heritage site.

18
02 Traditional Architecture in Shibam
Fig. 1.9. CARR, KATE, “Going to the Hadhramaut, Imagine A World Dedicated To Love, A World Which Knows Only The Way Of Humanity,” April 15, 2016,https://travel196.weebly.com/yemen.html.

2.1 Background:

At the intersection of tradition and modernity, Shibam’s urban and architectural heritage can be described as unique. “Shibam has a unique urban and architectural heritage which is located on the threshold between past and present, tradition and modernity, this walled city of vertical mudbrick high- rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds its own iterative narrative in a stunning, almost oneiric topography.”8 Due to Shibam’s important location as a stopover on the spice, incense, and frankincense route, it has experienced centuries of prosperity. After a period of deterioration in the economic situation of the city as a result of the disappearance of thatancient trade of spices, incense, and frankincense, a new era of prosperity begins

as successive pre-war governments worked to support farmers to compensate for the lost trade revenues. On the other hand, there is an interest in cultural and architectural heritage to highlight and preserve it. In terms of initiatives and early endeavors to preserve the city of Shibam. The Government of Democratic Yemen, in collaboration with UNESCO, has developed a global initiative to protect and preserve them. This campaign, inaugurated in Shibam on December 22, 1984, by the Director-General of UNESCO, has a twofold objective: to safeguard the visual beauty of these monuments and to foster positive attitudes and support, both at home and abroad, for the challenging endeavor of restoration.9

Since the economy has been transformed and the old trade routes have almost completely disappeared from Yemen in general and Shibam in particular, the tourism sector has become increasingly important. Tourism is one of the most important contributors to human stability in the city of Shibam, after the absence of the spice and incense trade, a major source of income for some families, and the easing of displacement and migration. UNESCO also has an important role in revitalizing tourism and shedding light on the city of Shibam to achieve a balance that aims to preserve its cultural, architectural, and archaeological heritage. In addition to foreign exchange earnings, tourism has contributed to community development.

source of foreign income in many countries in cultural and historical reserves. In contrast, the trend of global tourism has evolved from traditional tourism or general tourism to a specific type or sector, such as eco-tourism. The purpose of eco-tourism is to achieve high profitability with social and environmental benefits. Therefore, eco-tourism must be understood and implemented successfully in eco-resorts, in order to achieve sustainability and meet customer expectations.

2.2 Eco-tourism

The overall definition of “eco-tourism” and its relationship to cultural aspects is a topic that has been discussed in many research papers. The definition of Eco-tourism refers to “Tourism that involves traveling to relatively undisturbed or uncontaminated natural areas with the specific object of studying, admiring, and enjoying the scenery and its wild plants and animals, as well as in any existing cultural aspects (both past and present) found in these areas.”10

In addition, ecotourism will establish some of the guidelines that have to be followed according to the conditions of the specific location and the important goals to reduce destructive tourism in protected areas, that have a unique nature or historical value. Furthermore, the Shibam ecotourist resort will preserve the environmental and cultural heritage of Shibam city, and eco-tourism will encourage tourists to become involved in conservation as the general purpose of this thesis.

Meanwhile, eco-tourism marketing and infrastructure creation are sensitive and crucial. since tourism is a major

10 Héctor Ceballos-Lascurain, “[Pdf] Tourism, Ecotourism, and Protected Areas: The State of Nature ...,” Semantic Scholar, September 1, 1996, https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/-Tourism%2C-Ecotourism%2C-and-Protected-Areas%3A-The-State-Ceballos-Lascura%CC%81in/fad55ef5b43171fbb0ce90e364b041fcd8204f13.

20 21
Fig. 2.2. Khan, Gulnaz. “This Ancient Mud Skyscraper City Is the ‘Manhattan of the Desert’.”Travel. National Geographic, May 4, 2021. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/ article-/shibam-mud-skyscraper-yemen.
Fig. 2.1 Cultural and Traditional (Design by Author) ECOTourism
Society Environment Sustainabilty Cultural Heritage Ecology Shibam has a unique urban and architectural heritage that’s located on the threshold between past and present, tradition and modernity. This walled city of vertical mudbrick high-rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds its own iterative narrative a stunning, almost oneiric topography.6 Shibam’s tall houses are made of sunbaked mud bricks that impressively raise to seven stories out of the edge of the cliff of Wadi Hadhramout. usurpations, all having direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States. To prove this, let Facts be submitted to candid world. CULTURAL AND TRADITIONAL SUSTAINABLE ARCHITECTURE IN SHIBAM 8 Aga Khan, “Intervention Architecture: Building for Change,” in Intervention Architecture: Building for Change, ed. Pamela Johnston (London: I.B. Tauris & Co Ltd., 2007), https://www.archnet.org/publications/5256. 9 “Wadi Hadramawt and the Walled City of Shibam.” Unesdoc.unesco.org, accessed Jan, 2023, https://unesdoc.unesco. org/ark:/48223/pf0000071939.

Generally, eco-tourism promotes sustainable tourism, while sustainability aims to protect and preserve natural resources. Sustainability in architecture goes beyond just the construction phase of a building. The overall definition of sustainability; Attia refers to the comprehensive concept of sustainability, such as what was done by the United Nations global committees on environment and development, as an art whose mandate is to provide services for current generations while preserving natural resources for future generations and meeting their needs.11 This indicates the importance of preserving natural resources and not

https://www.businessinsider.com/photos-show-shibam-ye

overly using them, especially in architecture, because to build one house, many different materials taken from nature’s resources are used. Preserving natural resources is extremely important in mudbrick architecture because it uses natural materials from the same environment. Resources must be conserved sufficiently for the needs of future generations.Furthermore, sustainable architecture has become part of the worldwide sustainability system. Sustainability is an architectural approach that involves the use of greener and more efficient means to achieve a longer service life and not damage the environment.

2.3 Applications of Traditional Sustainable Yemen Architecture:

Traditional Yemeni architecture has a long history of being sustainable thanks to its meticulous construction, using natural materials that blend harmoniously with the region’s geographical and climatic conditions. On the other hand, sustainability and environmental preservation have a strong connection with traditional architecture in Yemen. This section offers a brief overview of traditional architecture types, and a traditional house analysis provides an example of sustainable architecture in Yemen. Attia refers to the types of houses in traditional Yemeni architecture, classifying traditional Yemeni houses into four types.12 As a result of the difference in geography, weather, and building materials available in the regions of Yemen, there are different styles of traditional Yemeni architecture. In general, Attia classifies traditional Yemeni houses into four types: The first type is a small one-floor house made of cane and mud. The second type is more sophisticated, consisting of two floors and built of stone and cement bricks. It has an external stair to the second floor. The third type is the multistory house which is mostly three floors or more. The fourth type is the skyscraper and these are considered the first skyscraper in the world constructed of mud bricks with seven to nine floors in Shibam city in Hadhramout, Yemen.13 In addition, Attiya analyzes the spaces and materials of one type of traditional Yemeni house as an example of sustainable architecture in Yemen.14

Analysis of this example of the third type of traditional

house, which has more than two floors located in the city of Sana’a, proves the sustainability of the traditional Yemeni architecture. First, the multistory house is built from the same natural material environment. Next, the multistory house spaces are distributed according to function, needs of the owner, and climatic orientation to introduce natural lighting and ventilation. At last, the multistory house has an outdoor patio with a well of water for the plants and a drinking water source.

accessed March 19,2023,https://www.yementourism.com/explore-yemen/ historical-tourism/40-shibam-hadramuot.com/photosshow-shibam-yemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

12 Ahmed Attia, “Traditional Yemeni Architecture and Its Impact on Energy Efficiency,” ResearchGate, August 2020, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356595813_Traditional_Yemeni_Architecture_and_Its_Impact_on_Ener gy_Efficiency.

13 Ibid., 381.

14 Ibid., 386.

22 23
Fig. 2.4.1Super User, “Shibam Hadramuot,” Yemen Tourism Promotion Board - Shibam Hadramuot, 11 Ahmed Attia, “Traditional Yemeni Architecture and Its Impact on Energy Efficiency,” ResearchGate, August 2020, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356595813_Traditional_Yemeni_Architecture_and_Its_Impact_on_Ener gy_Efficiency. Fig. 2.3 James Pasley, “Inside War-Torn Yemen’s Ancient Skyscraper City, Dubbed the ‘Manhattan of the Desert,’ That’s on the Brink of Ruin,” Business Insider, accessed March 19, 2023, men-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10.

2 4 Shibam

Mudbrick Shibam houses have a unique architectural style with a special interior distribution. The mudbrick house looks the same color as mud and has a rectangular facade with square windows. Jerome, Chiari, and Borelli represent that design of houses in traditional mudbrick architecture was not done by an architect but by builders.15 Homeowners design their houses or delegate them to skilled builders at buildings that are mudbrick. Homeowners rely on skilled builders with expertise in constructing mudbrick structures. These builders possess in-depth knowledge of local building techniques, materials, and climate, resulting

in functional and beautiful homes. The mudbrick house is directed according to a study of the direction of sunlight and wind. “Ideally, the best rooms are often placed along the south facade, with the bathrooms along the north.”16 The sea is in the south, so the wind which comes from the south is loaded with moisture. On the northern side is a desert, so the wind is loaded with dry and hot air. The overall layout plan of the house is square, and the roofs are used for sleeping outdoors during summer because air conditioners are rarely used, but some homes used evaporative desert air coolers.

The Shibam house emphasizes privacy and functionality in its interior design, particularly in dividing spaces between the guest and family sections. The ground and first floors are dedicated to storage and animal housing, while open rooms on each level cater to dining, sleeping, and business activities. The upper floor features a spacious hall called the Diwan, exclusively reserved for guests, entertainment, and special events. This thoughtfully designed layout ensures distinct areas for various activities, fostering privacy and efficiency within the house. Furthermore, the mudbrick houses still continue to have the same traditional design and appearance because mudbrick is made in the same traditional way these days. In this specific regard, a comprehensive explanation of the mudbrick-making technique used in the traditional mudbrick houses as a fundamental material in the Hadhramout region in Yemen is required. Jerome, Chiari, and Borelli mention mudbricks are one of the best building materials as they are resistant to the elements of the dry climate, and are manufactured in the same method from the past.17 The mudbricks are used from the same dry environment, so their components and particles manufacturing technology today because

modern technology has not directly interfered with the technique of repairing mudbricks yet. The method adapt to hot and cold climate change. For example, the city of Shibam, the oldest skyscraper in the world, which is used for living these days is built of mud bricks from the same environment since ancient times. In addition, mudbricks still use the same of selecting the clay used in the manufacture of mudbrick is very important and is done by experienced builders. The chopped straw is also mixed with the clay and the mudbricks are left exposed to the sun for a few days until it becomes solid.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269825587_The_Architecture_of_ Mud_Construction_and_Repair_Technology_in_the_Hadhramaut_Region_of_Yemen. 16 Ibid.

In Shibam, the traditional mud brick architecture has survived for centuries, but all its parts must be continuously renewed; some of them need renewal every year, such as whitewashing, while mud plaster renewal takes place every ten years, and plastered parts need to be renewed approximately every thirty years. Fresh coats of mud are applied to stop cracking and to maintain the walls’ strength. The mixture is made from soil, hay, and water, and is left to harden in the sun over a number of days.

Chiari, and Caterina Borelli, “The Architecture of MUD: Construction and Repair Technology in The ...,” ResearchGate, January 1999, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269825587_The_Architecture_of_ Mud_Construction_and_Repair_Technology_in_the_Hadhramaut_Region_of_Yemen.

17 Pamela Jerome,

24 25
Fig. 2.6. Laylin, Tafline. “Yemen’s Manhattan of the Desert Is 400 Towers Made from Clay.” Green Prophet, October 22, 2020. https://www.greenprophet.com/2011/12/yemenclay-towers/. Fig. 2.7 Chulov, Dmitry. “Mud Brick Factory, Shibam, Hadhramaut Valley, Yemen.” 123RF. https://www.123rf.com/ photo_34686272_mud-brick-factory-shibam-hadhramaut-valley-yemen.html. Giacomo Sustainable Mudbrick houses: 15 Pamela Jerome, Giacomo Chiari, and Caterina Borelli, “The Architecture of MUD: Construction and Repair Technology in The ...,” ResearchGate, January 1999, Fig. 2.5 UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Old Walled City of Shibam,” UNESCO World Heritage Centre, https://whc.unesco. org/en/list/192/.

03 Case Studies

3.1 Preserving Shibam Surroundings: In the Face of Rapid Change

Yemen’s economy is growing at a marked rate but in an unplanned architectural and industrial direction. Most Yemeni cities are experiencing urban development as a result of the growing population. In Shibam city, the planning and architectural features of city settlements provide residents with a sense of identity so they continue preserving their historical identity. As opposed to Shibam, some of the surrounding cities had an overlap between historical and emerging architecture that undermined their historical and traditional character. The emerging trend of modernization and the urgent need for infrastructure and housing projects have caused an ongoing hasty shift from traditional to modern. The traditional Yemeni buildings aren’t well adjusted to the hardships of the different climatic regions of the country, together with the inefficient use of non-local resources. On the other hand, modern and modern/traditional buildings are over-designed and inefficiently implement imported construction technologies and materials, focusing on cost reductions that are achieved by lowering the quality, consequently creating a less attractive built environment and unsustainable buildings. This hasty transition has made it important to preserve the architectural character and identity of the city of Shibam due to its historical and cultural value andpart of the UNESCO World Heritage List.

Introduction In this chapter I will analyze different case studies that will help to overview relevant projects to understand the requirement of the project. This chapter will provide us with data about the program of the function and its zoning. Also, will analyze zones, space programs, site criteria, and design solutions for relevant projects’ which will help to prepare for the next stages

of the project’s thesis. These studies are based on main zones, space programs, and choosing a site. Moreover, this chapter will focus on several case studies that show the unique design concept, structural materials, sustainability, culture ... Etc

3.1.1 Rational

In accordance with the Antiquities Law of 1997 and the Building Law of 2002 in Yemen, the Old City of Shibam is protected. Furthermore, being a UNESCO designation; its cultural, architectural, and archaeological heritage must be preserved, and it is prohibited from including any new construction within the city walls. Nevertheless, Shibam will need to create sustainable resort accommodations outside the city walls to support tourism for those visiting the site.

27
Figure 3.1 Super User, “Shibam Hadramuot,” Yemen Tourism Promotion Board - Shibam Hadramuot, https://www. yementourism.com/explore-yemen/historical-tourism/40-shibam-hadramuot.

3.2 Case Study One: Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort & Spa

that can be interconnected for families. This resort has all the facilities that make for a perfect holiday including a spa with hamman, tennis courts, a kids club and three dining options. Moreover, there is a desert excursions centre that can organize trips into the desert including camel treks, 4x4 desert safaris, and hikes to give guests a real feel for the location.

Qasr Al Sarab is located just eight kilometers away from the coast of Jebal Dhanna, on a private island named Sir Bani Yas. It is located 2 hours (190km) from Abu Dhabi city.

3.2.2 Project General Information:18

Project name: Qaser Al Sarab Resort in Desert.

Project Type: Relaxation and Recreation Location:

Abu Dhabi. Architect: Dubarch

Interior Designer: Hirsch / Bedner Associates Built-up area: 53,000 square meters

Client: Tourist Development Investment Company Hotel

Operator: Anantara

Construction period: 2006 -25th October 2009

sarab-abu-dhabi.

ler/22926203196/in/photostream/.

3.2.3 Project Description

Qasr Al Sarab features stylish suites with attractive Arabian style decoration all of which has stunning views over the dunes. Also, it includes different types and sizes of rooms

https://www.anantara. com/en/qasr-al-sarab-abu-dhabi/contact.

18 Anantara Hotels, Resorts &Spas, “Where Is Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara Located?” Qasr Al Sarab Abu Dhabi. accessed Dec,2022. https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-al-sarab-abu-dhabi.

28 29
Fig. 3.4. Sunny. “1001 Tales from the Arabian Desert.” theinnersun, September 23, 2014. https:-//theinnersun.wordpress.com/2014/- 09/23/1001-tales- from-the-arabiandesert/. Fig. 3.5. Nguyen, TuAnh. “Dsc_4710 Rub-Al Khali, UAE: Anantara Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort in the Sand Dunes.” Flickr.https://www.flickr.com/photos/wanderlusttrave Fig. 3.6 Eerie Bucyrus. “Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort,” Bucyrus Mines Stuff, February 20, 2015, https://bucyrusmines.wordpress.com/2015/02/20/qasr-al-sarab-desert-resort/. 3.2.4 Site Location Fig. 3.2. Healy, Melinda. “Qasr Al Sarab.” The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, January 13, 2016. https://www. telegraph.co.uk/travel/-destinations/middle-east/united-arab-emirates/abu- dhabi/hotels/qasr- al-sarab-hotel/. Fig. 3.3. Resorts & Spas Anantara Hotels, “Where Is Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara Located?,” Qasr Al Sarab Abu Dhabi. https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-al- Fig. 3.3 “Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara.” Anantara. Accessed November 15, 2022.

3.2.5 Project Program -Accommodation Size

 Outdoor activies

1. Archery.

2. The Workout Room.

3. Camel Trekking.

4. Biking.

5. Dune Bashing.

6. Desert Walks. Spa Facilities

Fig. 3.7 “Escape to a 5-Star Hotel Oasis in the Deserts of Abu Dhabi.” Accommodation. Accessed November 15, 2022. https://www.anantara.com/en/qasr-al- sarab-abu-dhabi/ rooms.

3.2.6 Spaces and

Leisure Activities

To fulfill the requirements of the different users the resort will house the following: Public Areas

1. Administration.

2. Swimming pool.

3. Three Restaurants.

4. Desert lounges

5. Library and business center.

6. Spa and yoga.

7. Fitness Centre& Kids Club.

8. 3 flood light tennis courts.

1- Four Luxurious Couple Treatment Suites

2- Traditional Moroccan Hammam

3- Ice Room and Jacuzzi

4- Hammam with heated marble.

November 16, 2022. https://www.tripadvisor.com/LocationPhoto Dir ectLink-g1597051-d1479615- i374957244Qasr_Al_Sarab_Desert_Resort_b y_Anantara-

3.2.7 Conclusion

The resort is located in the middle of the desert in Abu Dhabi. It reflects the culture, heritage and natural beauty of the UAE. This is a main point I would like to address in my project, the importance of integrating the cultural heritage of Shibam into the design. Furthermore, the designs reflect the functional aim for the project. The resort features different activities such as camel trekking.

cntravellerme.com/dest i nations/middle-east/uae/185910-things- to-know-about-qasr-al-sarab-desert-resort

Fig. 3.10 Oseid, John. “Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara: An Oasis Inn Blooms in Abu Dhabi,” Forbes June 26, 2019,https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnoseid/- 2017/04/12/qasr-al- sarab-desert-resort- by-anantara-an-oasis- innblooms-in-abu-dhabi/?sh=13f76321469d.

30 31
Fig. 3.9 “Sunset Walk - Picture of Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort by Anantara, Hamim.” Tripadvisor. Accessed Fig. 3.8 Writer, Staff. “12 Things to Know about Qasr Al Sarab Desert Resort.” cntravellerme, April 23, 2019.https://www.

3.3.1 Case Study Two : Wadi Rum Resort

Client: Aqaba Regional Authority

Construction Cost: 10,330,000 $

3.3.1- Project General Information 19

Project name: Wadi Rum Resort.

Project Type: Desert Resort.

Architect: Oppenheim Architecture.

Location: Wadi Rum, Jordan.

Total Site Area: 4,000,000 m²

Built up area: 80,000 square feet of area. = 7.432 square meters.

Completion date: 2014.

3.3.2 Project Description

In a global competition for a new luxury destination in Wadi Rum, Jordan, Oppenheim Architecture + Design‘s submitted the winning proposal, Wadi Resort. The Wadi Rum project seeks to establish a new standard for design, quality and sustainability in the natural environment. The project is comprised of 47 desert lodges setting forth a future primitive experience and providing an ecologically sensitive design solution.

This project included the study and development of the existing village and creation of a new village, as well as the design of a visitor’s centre, an entrance gateway, in addition to a design of a new road and infrastructure, and the conservation of the environment through the implantation of plants and trees that are compatible with the characteristic nature of Wadi Rum.

3.3.3 Project Concept and Philosophy

The project explores the attractive natural beauty of the desert to establish accommodations that are uniquely elemental and luxurious. The fundamental purpose of constructing suitable architecture in desert regions, incorporating elements such as shading, natural ventilation, and thermal mass, is to significantly contribute to maintaining a comfortable microclimate for guests while also offering an authentic desert experience. Also, great care has been given to utilizing local materials as well as various water conservation measures for both human and site irrigation. The architecture is inserted in the landscape with nominal impact and original style, synchronizing that suitable wis with the topography. The project is a clear and suitable type with surrounding nature by taking full advantage of the mystical valley where desert sand meets the desert stone. The suites will be carved directly into the sandstone cliff face and the building elements will be made from rammed earth and cement mixed with local red sand.

3.3.4

Site Location

19 ArchEyes Team, “Wadi Rum Desert Resort / Oppenheim Architecture,” ArchEyes, April 10, 2016. https://archeyes.com/ wadi-rum-desert-resort-oppenheim/.

tp://88designbox.com/architecture/luxury-wadi- rum-desert- resort-by- oppenheim-archtiecture-421.html.

www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum- eco-resortby-oppenheim- architecture/.

32 33
Fig. 3.12 Luxigon. “Luxury Wadi Rum Desert Resort by Oppenheim Architecture.” 88DesignBox, May 16, 2015. ht-
Welcome Area Spa Lodge Tent Lodge Rock Lodge Reserve Lodge Rock Lodge Entrance area
Fig. 3.13 Luxigon. “Luxury Wadi Rum Desert Resort by Oppenheim Architecture.” 88DesignBox, May 16, 2015. http://88designbox.com/architecture/luxury-wadi- rum-desert- resort-by- oppenheim-archtiecture-421.html. Fig. 3. 14 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2022. https:// Fig. 3.11 Luxigon. “Luxury Wadi Rum Desert Resort by Oppenheim Architecture.” 88DesignBox, May 16, 2015. http://88designbox.com/architecture/luxury-wadi- rum-desert- resort-by- oppenheim-archtiecture-421.html.

di-rum-desert-resort/.

https://www.e-architect.com/jordan/wadi-rum-lodges.

www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resortby- oppenheim- architecture/.

arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by-

34 35
Fig. 3.20 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://
-
Fig. 3. 21 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www.toxel.-com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi rum-desert-resort/.
Bedroom Living room Bathroom
Fig. 3. 22“Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www. arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by- oppenheim- architecture/. Fig. 3.16 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wa Fig. 3.19 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www. oppenheim- architecture/. Fig. 3.17 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www.toxel.com/inspiration-/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/. Fig. 3. 18 McManus, David. “Wadi Rum Lodges Jordan Luxury Resort - e-Architect.” e-architect, February 19, 2020. Fig. 3. 15 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2022. https:// www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rumeco-resort-by-oppenheim-architecture/. Meeting Room Services

3.3.5 Structure

The structure of the suites will be carved into the sandstone cliffs, utilizing the existing geological geometries of the rock to devise the form. Other structures are comprised of rammed earth and cement mixed with the local red sand. The minimal yet powerful gestures of the architecture both built and carved serves to create harmony, and balance while framing and amplifying the surroundings. The interior and exterior are deliberately blurred establishing maximum impact with minimum effort.

Inspired by the primordial, Oppenheim used his expertise in sustainable design to create passive means of cross ventilation, taking full advantage of the natural cooling effect of the rocks, and proper positioning allowing the project to minimize energy consumption and maximize Fig. 3. 23 “Wadi

2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration-/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/.

comfortable healthy living. Oppenheim said: “We tapped the inherent power of the desert through primal and instinctual design moves, informed by the forces, rhythms and patterns of nature—past, present and future,”

Oppenheim devised a passive means of cross ventilation for the project, taking full advantage of the natural cooling effect of the rocks and allowing the project to minimize energy use while keeping guests comfortable. The resort merges silently with its amazing setting, exploiting and enhancing the natural beauty of the desert to establish accommodations that are uniquely elemental and luxurious.

This case study has a strong concept that aims to provide a direct connection between man and nature. Thus it left many elements of the design raw and honest to its surrounding. Its form is composed of intriguing geometric cut-out spaces emerging from the landscape like an uncovered stone.

To further emphasize the concept, the architecture is inserted into the natural topography of the land, resulting in simple and elemental forms that aim to enhance and embrace the site.

Another amazing point can attract people to come to this resort is the availability of natural freshwater from the wadi rum.

36 37
3.3.6 Built Area Percentage 3.3.7 Conclusion Fig. 3. 26 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012. https://www-.toxel.com/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/. Fig. 3. 27 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https:// www.arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resortby-oppenheim- architecture/. Fig. 3. 28 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com-/inspiration/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/. Fig. 3. 29 Built Area Percentage. Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November Fig. 3. 25 “Mountain Carved Wadi Rum Eco-Resort: Oppenheim Architecture.” Arch2O.com, May 17, 2021. https://www. arch2o.com/mountain-carved-wadi-rum-eco-resort-by-oppenheim- architecture/. Fig. 3. 24 “Wadi Rum Desert Resort.” Toxel, November 2012.https://www.toxel.com/inspiration-/2012/11/06/wadi-rum-desert-resort/.

3.4.1 Case Studies Three: Amangiri Resort &

Spa

3.4.2

Project Description

3.4.3 Project Concept and Philosophy

Location: In the Lake Powell region of the U.S. state of Utah.

3.4.1 Project General Information

Project name: Amangiri Resort & Spa.

Project Type: Relaxation.

Architect: Marwan Al-Sayed, Wendell Burnette & Rick Joy.

Location: Southern Utah, The USA.

Site Area: 7.246 square meters Completion date: October 2009.

The Amangiri Resort &Spa was opened in October 2009. The resort is sensitively located beside a low entrada sandstone rock formation like an olden settlement, allowing each guest to experience the simplicity and pure natural beauty of the surrounding mesas and mesmerizing light shows. Poetically emphasizing the pure essence of this nice landscape: water, rock, and sky. This resort includes several functions such as a luxury hotel; the setting is a living room lounge, a spectacular swimming pool, spa, fitness center, and a central pavilion that contains a library, an art gallery, and private-public dining areas.

In this area there is Escalante National Monument, who built around a central pool. The main swimming pool is a large space, 46 m (150 ft.) high, sandstone rock, forming a striking background to the pool and its surrounding terrace with impressive views.

Exterior courtyards on the different steppes introduce the guests in a more intimate way to the topography, and connected with the interior so that the outdoor experience is maybe more important than the indoor.

Each of the guest rooms includes a living room area, bathroom, and a floor-to- ceiling glass door that opens onto a private terrace comprising a fireplace and pool

Most Expensive Luxury Hotels in the US.” Luxury Travel Magazine, July 18, 2019. https://www.luxurytravelmagazine.com/news-articles/10-most- expensive-luxury- hotels-in-the-us.

38 39
Fig. 3. 31 “Amangiri.” Luxury Explorer - The World Atlas of Luxury Travel. https://www.luxuryexplorer.com/USA/ The-National-Parks/Amangiri. Fig. 3. 33 “Amangiri.” Luxury Explorer - The World Atlas of Luxury Travel. https://www.luxuryexplorer.com/USA/ The-National-Parks/Amangiri. Fig. 3. 34 Staff, Geartide, and Geartide Staff GEARTIDE covers cars. “Amangiri Is a Bucket List Worthy Resort in the American Southwest.” Geartide, April 16, 2017. https://www. geartide.com-/amangiri-resort-american-southwest/. Fig. 3. 32 “Amangiri.” Ker & Downey - A World of Difference, July 30, 2020. https://kerdowney-.com/destinations/united-states/national-parks/amangiri/. Fig. 3. 30 “10

The architect’s focus of the hotel setting is the main pavilions dining, reception, living areas, library, guest rooms and spa. Also, the architects focusing on the interiors, lighting, furnishings, all the design with the blend in with the architecture and the surrounding landscape.

blogspot.com/2010/07/amangiri-spa-resort-brings-modern.html

In addition to the hotel, the architects also designed the Spa, located on the south wing. The designed spa inspired by the rock formations formed by wind and water and streams of light, offering a number of unique treatment venues. The spa walls, floors and ceiling are clad in darkcolored walnut wood.

The spa complex includes features a steam room, a dry sauna. Also, double treatment rooms in addition to two outdoor treatment terraces with amazing views of the mesas.

This case study showed how to successfully integrate the building with the site. The masses complemented the mountainous topography to create a dramatic appearance for the users. There is a good ratio between outdoor and indoor spaces, allowing users to enjoy both the desert environment as well as indoor activities. Moreover, design solutions and materials used to fit the site of the project which is Southern Utah, in America.

40 41
3.4.4 Project (Space Distribution) 3.4.5 Conclusion Fig. 3. 40 Samanthabrown. “4 Amazing Adventures in Canyon Point, Utah.” Samantha Brown’s Places to Love, December 5, 2017. https://samantha- brown.com/destinations/ desert-dreaming- canyon-point-utah-amangiri/. Fig. 3. 39 “Amangiri.” Luxurylink.com. Accessed March 25, 2023. https://www.luxurylink.com/5star/hotels/canyonpoint-utah/amangiri. Fig. 3. 38 Built up Area Percentage Fig. 3. 39 Total Area Percentage Fig. 3. 35 “Amangiri Resort.” Contract Design, July 20, 2017. https://www.- contractdesign.com/galle ries/projectshospitality/amangiri-resort/#5. Fig. 3. 37 “The Amangiri Spa & Resort Brings Modern Luxury to Southern Utah That Blends in.” If It’s Hip, It’s Here (Archives). Accessed November 16, 2022. https://ifitshipitshere. Fig. 3. 38 Dubin, Alesandra. “Pamper Yourself at These 10 Hotel Spas in the US, from Arizona’s Hot Springs to New York’s Finger Lakes.” Insider. Insider, May 10, 2022. https:// www.insider-.com/guides/travel/best-hotels-with-spas-us. Figure 3. 36 Dining Area. “Amangiri: Hotels in the US.” Audley Travel, May 12, 2020. https://www.audleytravel-.com/ ca/usa/acco mmodation/amangiri.

4.1 Introduction

This chapter will discuss the different phases that are taken in order to select the site for this project. Selecting a suitable site is vital to the success of a project and to adding value to the location it inhabits. The site for this thesis project is Shibam, Hadhramout Central Region of Yemen. This project specifically its location will be outside the city’s wall borders not only to improve tourism, social, economic, and cultural conditions but also to preserve the identity and architectural character of Shibam city. As a result, after selecting the site of the best fit, a thorough site analysis will be conducted on the selected site and any problematic factors that arise will be addressed and discussed.

noise.

Physiographic elements: The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered

Expansion capability: Whether the site has the capability for future expansion or not.

Parking capacity: The site’s capacity to hold parking spaces.

Utilities: Infrastructure: The functions around the site and how this project can utilize them like electrical, and water.

4.3 The Location

4.2 Site Selection Criteria Site Comparison Evaluation

Accessibility: It is critical to select a site that can be easily accessible by visitors and within walking distance of some potential users.

Visibility: A panoramic view similar to the historical city overlooking it.

Views: In order for the project to be accepted by visitors, there should be enjoyable views. Therefore, it should be studied how to manipulate the wanted views and avoid unwanted views. The site should be placed in an area with a strong positive identity and image. The project will have a main and major view of the old city. This will assist in creating recreational areas and interesting outdoor spaces for incomers.

Privacy: The site should not be surrounded by any buildings.

Noise levels: It is important to not place the project in residential areas or in the middle of the city because of the

Yemen is located in the Middle East. Yemen is bordered by the Red Sea to the west, the Gulf of Aden and the Arabian Sea to the south, Saudi Arabia to the north, and Oman to the east. Shibam is a town in Yemen located in the Hadhramaut Governorate, which is in the southeastern part of the country. Shibam is known for its historic old town and attracts visitors from around the world who come to see its unique architecture and learn about its cultural heritage.

43
04 Site Analysis
Fig. 4. 1 geology. (n.d.). Retrieved December 5, 2022, from https:// geology.com/world/yemen-satellite- image.shtml

Shibam city lies in the Wadi Hadhramout Region. Wadi Hadhramout is a striking 100km long valley sunk 300m into the Jol Plateau, which sits at around 1km above sea level. Many tributary wadis feed into the main valley, and again agriculture relies on spate water.

Shibam has historically been known as a center of commerce and culture in the region. Camel caravans have traditionally been used to transport spices and other goods along the ancient trade routes that pass through Shibam, connecting it to other important cities in Yemen and beyond.

Site Boundary

In centuries past, Shibam served as an important stop on caravan routes connecting the Arabian Peninsula to the Mediterranean. Camel caravans transported spices, incense, and other valuable goods through the town, which was strategically located at the crossroads of several major trade routes.

44 45
Fig. 4. 2 CEOBS. (2022, January 4). Retrieved December 5, 2022, from https://ceobs.org/yemens-agriculture- in-distress/ Fig. 4. 3 Site inventory and analysis. Google Earth. “Shibam,” Imagery date December 5, 2022, https://earth.google. com/web/search/ Fig. 4. 4 Camel Fig. 4. 5 Camel Road Fig. 4. 6 Site analysis and views of Shibam 4. 4 Site inventory and analysis

Site Boundary

The Mean Road

Visitors Vehicular Road

Pedestrian Access and Camels Road

Torrent Valley

Parking of the Visitors Vehicular

Animal Shelter

Site Analysis

-A shelter should be provided in each pen where camels are kept over 35 °C. The shaded area projected by the shelter should also be large enough to provide shade for all the camels in the pen and for placing drinking and feeding points.

-Main parking is very far from the eco-resort range to keep the site quiet and not damage the wildlife to enjoy and the natural life

4.5 The Sewage Disposal System

a- Organization of a blind alley line yellow on the urban plan to discharge the solid and liquid waste dropping from the houses.

The urban plan of Shibam. Each house has a waste disposal system provided with external outlets (marked in black). The latter overlooks narrow back streets, blind alleys, or perimeter paths (drawn in brown).

b- The two-outlet toilet which allows the separation of liquid and solid excrement.

b- The facade of a building equipped with sewage shafts and excrement collection baskets.

https://socks-studio.com/2012/08/12/the-walledcity-of-shibam-a-manhattan-of-the-desert/.

46 47
The Old City Wall of Shibam
4. 7
Fig. Fig. 4. 8 Lucarelli, Fosco, and For Reliable urban Planning Services Choose HPC Urban Design Planning says. “The Walled City of Shibam, a ‘Manhattan of the Desert’.” SOCKS, February 24, 2019.

Shibam enjoys a hot desert climate in accordance with the Köppen-Geiger classification.

The yearly average maximum temperature in Shibam is 86°F (ranging from 77°F in January to 97°F in June). Annual rainfall is 4.9in, with a minimum of 0.1in in December and a maximum of 1.3in in November.

Between the months of January and April, the climate is very good. On average, in the morning it is 72°F and, in April, 0 days of rain are expected.

In the month of May, the climate is favorable. The record temperature this month is 103°F.

Between June and August, the climate is not good, but still OK. At lunchtime, it’s 94°F on average and you can expect to have 0.6in of rainfall/per month during this period.

In the month of September, the climate is favorable. By early evening, the temperature averages 88°F and it rains in September about 0.4in.

From October to December, the climate is perfect. The temperature rises to 81°F and you can expect to have 0.1in of rainfall/month during this period.18

Charts: temperature and rainfall in Shibam

In the charts below, you can see the following seasonal norms for the city of Shibam: the minimum and maximum outdoor temperature, the risk and amount of monthly rainfall, daily average sunshine, and relative humidity for each month of the year.

The weather is good all year round in Shibam. On average, the warmest months are May, June, July, August and September.

Shibam has dry periods in January, February, March, April, May, September, October, and December

- Outside temperature

city_fig25_336124405.

18 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

Fig. 4. 11 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

- Precipitation (rainfall)

Fig. 4. 12 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

48 49
4.6 Weather and climate in Shibam By used Ecotect program -sun path and direction buildings in Shibam Hadramout city Comparison of ambient temperature with inside temperature of mud house for summer in Sieyoun Fig. 4. 10 Alabsi, Akram Ahmed Noman. “The Applications Of Traditional Building Technologies In Contemporary Architecture In Yemen.” researchgate, May 2013. https:// www.researchgate.net/figure/By-used-Ecotect-programsun-path-and-direction-buildings-in-Shibam-Hadramout- Fig. 4. 9 Alabsi, Akram Ahmed Noman. “The Applications Of Traditional Building Technologies In Contemporary Architecture In Yemen.” researchgate, May 2013. https://www. researchgate.net/figure/By-used-Ecotect-program-sunpath-and-direction-buildings-in-Shibam-Hadramout-city_fig25_336124405.

- Daily sunshine hours

Fig. 4. 13 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

- Humidity

Fig. 4. 14 Weather2Travel.com, “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen,” Weather2Travel.com, accessed Feb 3, 2023, https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

4.7

to have 0.6in of rainfall/per month during this period.

- Between the months of January and April, the climate is very good. On average, in the morning it is 72°F and, in April, 0 days of rain are expected.

- In the month of may the climate is favorable. The record temperature this month is 103°F.

- Between June and august the climate is not good, but still OK. At lunchtime, it’s 94°F on average and you can expect

-In the month of September, the climate is favorable. By early evening, the temperature averages 88°F and it rains in September about 0.4in.

- From October to December the climate is perfect. The temperature rises to 81°F and you can expect to have 0.1in of rainfall/month during this period.

50
Summary of the Climate
05 Architecture Program

5.1 Introduction

Chapter Five will discuss the program of the project in detail such as (activities, area distributions, and functions). Each function related to the project will be calculated based on standard studies of the project functions as well as the analysis of the case studies from the third chapter. The chapter will be supported by standard studies, functional analysis, space calculation, and site analysis, to assure a successful building design.

5.2 Project users

The resort Chalets’ capacity is 100 visitors having Three types of chalets to accommodate them, one can accommodate 6 people and its area is 650 ft² and the second one can accommodate 2 people and its area is 360 ft². Employees are 32 people divided into different categories as will be shown below.

52 53
Fig. 5. 1 Eco-Resort users’ classification 5.3 Eco-resort Project Component: Fig. 5. 2 Eco-resort Project Component

Once the four chapters were complete, the project became more evident. After analyzing earlier case studies and the site analysis, I developed the basic zoning of the site for this study, and I ultimately chose the site based on the most crucial factors.

In the end, the earlier chapters have helped me to build a clear vision of how I want my project to operate and seem. Possessing this thesis will be helpful to me when I get to the spaces program and the design phase in the next step.

5.4 Accommodations: (10000 ft²) Number of users: 120 Persons.

-There are 20 chalets different in design so we have three types of chalets (class “A” – Class “B”- Class “C”), each of which is characterized by a direct main view of the old city.

-The resort chalets provide dramatic valley views from guestrooms and suites.

54 55
Fig. 5. 3 Chalet Type A Chalet Type A: Area:550 ft² (2Bedrooms), Capacity: 6 people, No. 10 units Chalet Type B (1 Bedroom): Area: 700 ft², Capacity: 4 people, No. 5 units Fig. 5. 4 Chalet Type B Chalet Type C (3 Bedrooms): Area: 600 ft², Capacity: 8 persons, No. 5 units. Fig. 5. 5 Chalet Type C

Restaurant: The restaurant should be accessed from the reception area and should include a foyer and private restrooms.

The restaurant should include private dining for 60 People. The restaurant should be characterized by a direct main view of the old city.

-The Eco-Restaurant concept aims to optimize a restaurant’s performance in all environmental aspects. This includes waste prevention, reducing energy and water consumption, and reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions.

- restaurant interior design in terms of creating spatial experiences through color, display aesthetic, lighting, material, seating arrangement, and spatial composition.

56 57
5.5 Restaurants Fig. 5. 6 Restaurants 5.6 Coffee Shop: Area:660 ft² Capacity 15 Tables. Fig. 5.7 Coffee Shop Fig. 5.8 Spa and Fitness 5.7 Spa and wellness. (1735 ft²)

5.8 Fitness (2730 ft²)

5.9 Staff Building: Area:1770 ft², Capacity 30 Employees

5.10 Support Facilities:

5.10.1 Prayer Hall (560 ft²) Number of users: 150 Persons

5.10.2 Event Hall (1045 ft²) Number of users = 1000 persons

58 59
Fig. 5.9 Spa and Fitness Fig. 5. 10 Administration 5.8 Administration Fig. 5. 11 Staff Building Fig. 5. 12 Prayer Hall Fig. 5. 13 Event Hall

06 Goals and Objectives

60
5.11 Outdoor Activity (6440 ft²)
Activity
Fig.
5. 14 Outdoor
Other
(1169
Fig.
5. 15 Other Facilities 5.12
Facilities.
ft²)

6.1 Goals and Objectives

When conservation goes beyond preserving the external appearance of historic structures and meets the local needs of the population, it becomes environmentally, economically, and culturally sustainable. Sustainability

62
Fig. 6. 2 Goals and Objectives
07 Design
Fig. 6. 1 The goals
Development and Final Design

Concept Generation

7.1 Concept Generation

The next step after solidifying.

The project must provide visitors with enjoyable views in order to be successful. Consequently, the project site provides visitors with a wonderful view of the landscape and a strong sense of identity. The topographical elements: The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered.

A space program was the game boarding process. Starting from the macro scale, the relationships of the units were analyzed as individual buildings. This process then resulted in a deeper analysis. of the spatial relationships in each building. After several iterations, the final design of the master-planned site was configured.

Given that this project is located in a remote location of the walled city and based on the site analysis, incorporating this program into one single building would not fit into the context of the surrounding environment. Due to this, the program was divided into several different buildings, based on their functions. This decision allows for a more intimate experience to be had throughout the resort evoking deep thought and a mental transition as one departs from their housing unit and meanders through the desert to get deference experiences.

7.2 Conceptual Design Development

In honor of the eternal preservation of “ Manhattan of the desert; Shibam...

Creating an eco-resort in line with sustainable development goals that should reflect the unique culture, heritage, and natural beauty of the Shibam and Hadhramout in Yemen. The project must provide visitors with enjoyable views in order to be successful. Consequently, the project site provides visitors with a wonderful view of the landscape and a strong sense of identity. The topographical elements: The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered.

Given that this project is located in a remote location of the walled city and based on the site analysis, incorporating this program into one single building would not fit into the context of the surrounding environment. Due to this, the program was divided into several different buildings, based on their functions. This decision allows for a more intimate experience to be had throughout the resort evoking deep thought and a mental transition as one departs from their housing unit and meanders through the desert to get deference experiences.

Creating a semi-replicating space has an important role in providing climatic comfort conditions and the continuity of visual communication with the surrounding environment. Due to the slope of the land, this resort is built in steps. In such a way that the roof of the unit is a yard for the upper unit. Also, the paths of the resort pass by the sides and roofs of nearby chalets.

Articulation of massing and integration of architecture and landscape to offer magnificent views overlooking the historical city. Formation of an integrated, layered terrace community with associated three dimensional spatial experiences. The rooms contain lower windows closer to Mashrabiya It consists of two parts the external part is wooden faced with decorations, and part internal of window shutters can open and close to control, this unique design will help on the entry of air into spaces with blocking direct sunlight and to increase the control by making behind Mashrabiy a white curtains punctuated the air and toreflect the sun’s rays. The upper windows open when you need to do high-speed air movement by pulling hot air out of the building.

The project must provide visitors with enjoyable views in order to be successful. Consequently, the project site provides visitors with a wonderful view of the landscape and a strong sense of identity. The topographical elements: The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered.

Given that this project is located in a remote location of the walled city and based on the site analysis, incorporating this program into one single building would not fit into the context of the surrounding environment. Due to this, the program was divided into several different buildings, based on their functions. This decision allows for a more intimate experience to be had throughout the resort evoking deep thought and a mental transition as one departs from their housing unit and meanders through the desert to get deference experiences.

Creating a semi-replicating space has an important role in providing climatic comfort conditions and the continuity of

Fig. 7. 2 Concept generation of master plan Fig. 7. 3 Conceptual massing
Environment Sustainable Environment Eco-Tourism Low-Carbon Tourism Alternative Tourism Society
Sustainable Development Sustainable T ourism Sustainable Society Community Tourism Accessible Tourism Population and Culture Goals of Shibam Eco-Resort Sustainable Culture Heritage Integrity Culture Tourism T Sustainable
Key Elements

Articulation of massing and integration of architecture and landscape to offer magnificent views overlooking the historical city. Formation of an integrated, layered terrace community with associated three-dimensional spatial experiences.

- The design solutions and materials for the units will be integrated with the site, with the masses complementing the mountainous terrain to give it a dramatic appearance. In addition, Shibam’s cultural heritage will be incorporated into the design.

- As in the symphonic, the main facades have a continuous horizontal and vertical rhythm.

- The exterior decoration around the windows is a simple frame, and most of the decorations on the windows and doors are designed of wooden panels.

- Architectural structures provide psychological content and beauty through their naturopathic touch, creating harmony with the environment and simplicity and flexibility in shaping the environment, as well as enhancing cultural experiences and social traits.

- Harmony and compatibility between the elevations and the simple decoration on the outside and inside of the formation. There are a variety of shapes for the holes on the frontages’ surfaces, but they all have rectangular openings.

66 67
7.4 Site Architecture and Views to Landscape Fig. 7. 5 View the resort from Shibam City.
Society ECOTourism Environment Sustainabilty Cultural Heritage Ecology tage that’s located on the threshold between past and present, tradition and modernity. This walled city of vertical mudbrick high-rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds own iterative narrative a stunning, almost oneiric topography.6 Shibam’s tall houses are made sunbaked mud bricks that impressively raise to seven stories out of the edge the cliff of Wadi Hadhramout. usurpations, all having direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States. prove this, let Facts be submitted to a candid world. tourism economy, sustainable tourism remains a challenge. One of the challenges that the Shibam tourism industry faces is that it is still being operated in an unorganized framework. Especially the fact that it does not have sufficient resorts to accommodate visitors to the heritage site. Outdoor Theatre & Cafe Spa & Fitness and Swimming Pool Chalet Type B Chalet Type A Chalet Type C Restaurants Shops and Showroom Arts & Crafts Administration - HouseKeeping Loundry &Staff Building Prayer Hall (The mosque) Visitors Drop-off & Pick-up Area Parking
comfort conditions and the continuity of visual communication with the surrounding environment. Due to the slope of the land, this resort is built in steps. In such way that the roof of the unit is a yard for the upper unit. Also, the paths of the resort pass by the sides and roofs of nearby chalets. 3D Section with Details Perspective of the Clusters: Cluster One :No. units. One unit type A - One unit type B One unit type C. - Cluster Two No. units. One unit type A. One unit type Two unit type C. Perspective from the Vally Economy Sustainable Economy Circular Economics Political Economics Behavioral Economics -Design solutions and materials of units should be integrated with the site, with the masses complementing the mountainous terrain to give it a dramatic appearance. The building captures the lower winter sunlight to warm the interior and roof decks, but blocks the higher summer sun with flat, adobe roof, maintaining ideal. Summer Winter Mud brick walls have high thermal mass due to the thickness and organic material that composes it. These walls absorb much of the solar heat but later emit during colder night hours. Solar Heat Gain The treatments of natural ventilation. Good control on insert and ejecting air. Mud brick Clay with Straw CMU bond beam Membrane Plywood sheathing Rigid Insulation Cant Strip Heavy timber girder Heavy timber column Mud brick Flashing Concrete lintel CMU Retaining wall Rebar Perforated drainpipe Concrete foundation Concrete footing
Fig. 7. 6 Site Section

7.6

(2Bedrooms), Capacity: 6 people, No. 4 units

(3

Capacity: 8 persons, No. 5 units.

(1

One unit type A

One unit type B

One

One

One unit type B

Two units type C

68 69
Chalet Type A: Fig. 7. 7 Chalet Type (A) Plan 7.7 Chalet Type B: Bedroom): Capacity: 4 people, No. 9 units. Fig. 7. 9 Chalet Type (A) Perspective Fig. 7. 8 Chalet Type (B) Plan Fig. 7. 10 Chalet Type (B) Perspective Bedrooms): 7. 9 Cluster Chalets Fig. 7. 11 Chalet Type (C) Plan Fig. 7. 12 Chalet Type (C) Perspective 7.8 Chalet Type C: Fig. 7. 13 Cluster Chalets Perspective Cluster One: No. 3 units. unit type C Cluster Two: No. 4 units. unit type A

3D Section with Details.

https://www.123rf.com/photo_34686272_mud-brick-factory-shibam-hadhramaut-valley-yemen.html.

The method of selecting the clay used in the manufacture of mud brick is very important and is done by experienced builders. The chopped straw is also mixed with the clay and the mud bricks are left exposed to the sun for a few days until it becomes solid.

Worker is preparing mudbrick

Perspective from the Vally

2022, https://www.publicationcoach.com/johanna-schneller/.

Perspective

June 1, 2023, https://www.123rf.com/photo_6940140_man-making-bricks-by-hand.html.

3D

70 71
7.10 Construction techniques of wall building Fig. 7.14 Chulov, Dmitry. “Mud Brick Factory, Shibam, Hadhramaut Valley, Yemen.” 123RF. Fig. 7.15 Daphne Gray-Grant, “He Has a Hay Bale of Hair on His Head...: The Publication Coach,” Publication Coach, March 1, Fig. 7.16 Jerry Rainey, “Man Making Bricks by Hand,” 123RF, accessed
Mud brick Clay with Straw CMU bond beam CMU Retaining wall Rebar Perforated drainpipe Concrete foundation Concrete footing
Section with Details.
captures the lower warm the interior and blocks the higher summer with a flat, adobe roof, maintaining Mud brick walls have high thermal mass due to the thickness and organic material that composes it. These walls absorb much of the solar heat but later emit it during colder night hours. Solar Heat Mud brick Clay with Straw CMU bond beam Membrane Plywood sheathing Rigid Insulation Heavy timber girder Heavy timber column Mud brick Flashing Concrete lintel CMU Retaining wall Rebar Perforated drainpipe Concrete foundation Concrete footing

The roof consists of the timber of the trees Sidr and placed palm fronds or branches of some other plants and then placed on it cloth such as cloth tent to act as water insulation and placed above the mud.

The Palm is the main source for the production of household supplies and is involved in the construction materials of the houses of the plantation, along with some plants and trees from the local environment.

Due to the limited use of the external openings and their small size, the internal heat can be maintained properly when increasing outside temperatures in the morning and decreasing them at night.

7.12 Exhibition Boards

SHIBAM ECO-TOURIST DESERT RESORT

CULTURAL AND TRADITIONAL SUSTAINABLE ARCHITECTURE IN YEMEN

72 73
7.11 Construction techniques of roof building Fig. 7. 21 Construction techniques of roof building Fig. 7. 22 “Hayd Al-Jazeel Resort - Hotel Reviews (Hayd Al Jazīl, Yemen),” Tripadvisor, https://www.tripadvisor.com-/ Hotel_Review-g15522224-d7306837-Reviews-Hayd_Al_ Jazeel_Resort-Ayd_al_Jazil_Hadhramout.html. Fig. 7. 20 UNESCO World Heritage Centre, “Old Walled City of Shibam,” Gallery - UNESCO World Heritage Centre, accessed June 1, 2023, https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/192/ gallery/&index=13&maxrows=12. Fig. 7. 23 (Board #1)
Society ECOTourism Environment Sustainabilty Cultural Heritage Ecology Shibam has unique urban and architectural heritage that’s located the threshold present, tradition walled city of vertihigh-rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds narrative stunning, almost oneiric topography.6 houses are made bricks that impressively raise seven stories out the edge the cliff Wadi Hadhramout. usurpations, having direct object the establishment of an absolute Tyranny over these States. To prove this, Facts be submitted CULTURAL AND TRADITIONAL SUSTAINABLE ARCHITECTURE IN SHIBAM Shibam – UNESCO – World Heritage List Shibam on the Historic Road of Spices and Incense Shibam has unique ban and a chi e tu al he itage th loc ed on the th eshold be ween past and p esen adition and mode ni One of the most imp essi listings is the 16the tu walled ci of Shibam in the Hadh amout gion of Yemen. Lis ed y UNES O in 1982 on the UNESCO Wo ld He itage Lis as desc ibed as the anh tta of the dese English eler ta in the 1930s Shibam pla ed an impo tan ole in the d c ntu y when it became the capital of the Hadh amout du ing the age of the in ense ade Shibam named er its King Shibam bin Al-Ha ith bin Hadh amout bin Saba -Asgha Shibam came a p ospe ous ci or c ntu ies because became a opo er pla e or those veling along the spi e and incense ou du ing the spi e ading a. Sa’adi Atif, Alaa, Askol, United Nations, August 2022, https://www.-un.org/ungifts/content/shibam-hadramout- manhattan-d uin.” Business Insider, https://www.businessinsider.com/photos-show-shibam-yemen-as-ancient-city-crumbles-2019-10. Yemen is country in the southern Arabian Peninsula. Shibam city lies Wadi Hadhramout in the southeast of Yemen. Location The proposed site is in the Country of Yemen, the Mid Region of the Hadhramaut Governorate Area, and in the City of Shibam. geology. (n.d.). Retrieved December 2022, from https:// geology.com/world/yemen-satellite- image.shtml Despite efforts to improve and revitalize Shibam’s tourism economy, sustainable tourism remains challenge. One of the challenges that the Shibam tourism industry faces is that still being operated in an unorganized framework. Especially the fact that it does not have sufficient resorts to accommodate visitors to the heritage site. Residents of Shibam who have lived such city for decades establish strong social relationship with their religious, cultural heritage and societal development help shapes Shibam architecture physical construct. Shibam, as city, consists of many architectures that designed and constructed to closely reflect the people, the culture, and its place identity. Shibam has remained unchanged for centuries. The physical makeup of Shibam consists of many tall houses that are made of sun-baked mud bricks that impressively raise to seven stories out of the edge of the cliff of Wadi Hadhramout. Shibam’s architecture established from a distinctive architectural fact that was meticulously constructed from natural materials sourced from its local geographical location. It includes sustainability living principles due to its throughout the city. This walled city of vertical mudbrick high-rises, with its labyrinthine streets and lanes, unfolds its iterative narrative in a stunning, almost oneiric topography.7 Shibam’s tall houses are made of sun-baked mud bricks that impressively raise to seven stories out of the edge of the cliff of Wadi Hadhramout. The city’s distinctiveness lies in its emphasis on sustainability, which permeates every aspect of its architectural style and functionality. As result of Shibam’s densely packed design, most of its buildings are shaded from the intense desert were used for livestock and grain storage, while the floors for socializing. heat. In addition, the windowless ground floors uppermost levels typically served as communal Outdoor Theatre & Cafe Spa & Fitness and Swimming Pool Chalet Type B Chalet Type Chalet Type C Restaurants Shops and Showroom Arts & Crafts Administration - HouseKeeping Loundry &Staff Building Prayer Hall (The mosque) Visitors Drop-off & Pick-up Area Parking
74 75
Design solutions and materials of units should be integrated with the site, with the masses complementing the mountainous terrain to give dramatic appearance. Efficient use of energy, water, and other resources. Use of renewable energy, such as solar energy. Creating an eco-resort in line with sustainable development goals and sufficient tourist accommodations for visitors Privacy: The site must be located away from the city and not surrounded by buildings. Pollution and waste reduction measures, and the enabling of reuse and recycling. Good indoor environmental air quality. There will be variety of cultural and historical art shows at the resort, as well as desert-related activities such as camping, camel riding, rest, relaxation, and meditation Use of materials that are nontoxic, ethical, and sustainable. Consideration of the environment in design, construction, and operation. Consideration of the quality of life of occupants in design, construction, and operation. Future Development: Considering the future expansion. A design that makes a building future proof, short term and long term. A design that enables adaptation to changing environment. Society Environment Economy Cultural, Social, and Economic Aspects Social Environment Environmental Economics Shibam Eco-Resort The Cultural Heritage Integrating the cultural heritage of Shibam into the design. The eco-resort should reflect the culture, heritage, and natural beauty of the Shibam and Hadhramout in Yemen. Goals and Objectives Unlike other historical cities in the world, Shibam has a unique architectural heritage because predominately constructed out of mud brick structures integrated into vertical construction. This project will contribute to the body of knowledge of architecture by expressing how society as a whole sees itself and views the built environment that reflects human cultural development. This project will focus on fostering the human experience and understanding at both the individual and community levels providing an invaluable resource for public usage of architecture at a heritage site. The design conducted will advocate that fostering human social experience design will have positive contribution to the cultural and heritage understanding of a place at designated architectural heritage site. In honor of the eternal preservation of “Manhattan of the desert; Shibam... Creating an eco-resort in line with sustainable development goals that should reflect the unique culture, heritage, and natural beauty of the Shibam and Hadhramout in Yemen. The approach to design involves integrating the units seamlessly with the site, taking inspiration from the rich cultural heritage of Shibam. We strive to create sustainable environment that aligns with the principles of the historic city, blending the allure of the past with the contemporary comforts of the present. To achieve this, we carefully select materials and design solutions that harmonize with the surroundings and ensure sustainable future. Therewill be a variety of cultural and historical art shows at the resort,as well as desert-related activities such as camel riding,rest, relaxation, and meditation. Physiographic elements The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered View the resort from Shibam City. Wadi Hadhramout is striking 100km long valley sunk 300m into the Jol Plateau, which sits at around 1km above sea level. Many tributary wadis feed into the main valley, and again agriculture relies on spate water The Site of Project The Site Torrent Valley shelter should be provided in each pen where camels are kept over 35 °C. The shaded area projected by the shelter should also be large enough to provide shade for the camels the pen and for placing drinking and feeding points. Main parking is very far from the eco-resort range to keep quiet and not damage the wildlife to enjoy and the natural life. Parking the Visitors Vehicular. Animal Shelter Site Boundary isitors Vehicular Road. Pedestrian Access and Historical Camels Road Spices and The Old City Wall Shibam. The Mean Road This project aims to improve the city’s tourism Shibam to accommodate more tourism. Increasing tourism up to provide income to local residents who live Shibam, and support families to compensate for decreased revenues. This project will engage in the design of sustainable traditional architecture Yemen that can be unique to the time. The resort site will be outside the city’s wall borders not only to improve tourism, social, economic, and cultural conditions but also to preserve the identity and architectural character of Shibam city. This project will enhance the historical identity of Shibam’s traditional architecture. This project will enhance the role of tourism by creating an eco-resort line with sustainable development goals and sufficient tourist accommodations for visitors. This project will establish guidelines that need to be followed according to the conditions of the specific location and the important goals of reducing destructive tourism in protected areas, which have unique historical value. The project must provide visitors with enjoyable views order to be successful. Consequently, the project site provides visitors with wonderful view of the landscape and a strong of identity. The topographical elements: The topography is the most powerful aspect of the site, the orientation, and the climatic aspects are considered. Given that this project is located in remote location of the walled city and based on the site analysis, incorporating this program into one single building would not fit into the context of the surrounding environment. Due to this, the program was divided into several different buildings, based on their functions. This decision allows for more intimate experience to be had throughout the resort evoking deep thought and mental transition as one departs from their housing unit and meanders through the desert to get deference experiences. Creating semi-replicating space has an important role in providing climatic comfort conditions and the continuity of visual communication with the surrounding environment. Due to the slope of the land, this resort is built in steps. In such a way that the roof of the unit is yard for the upper unit. Also, the paths of the resort pass by the sides and roofs of nearby chalets. Concept Generation 3D Section with Details Perspective of Chalet Type B Perspective of the Clusters: - Cluster One :No. units. One unit type One unit type One unit type C. - Cluster Two No. units. One unit type A. One unit type B Two unit type C. Perspective from the Vally Perspective of Chalets Environment Sustainable Environment Eco- ourism Low-Carbon ourism Alternative ourism Society Key Elements Sustainable Development Sustainable T ourism Sustainable Society Community ourism Accessible ourism Population and Health Culture Goals of Shibam Eco-Resort Sustainable Culture Heritage Integrity Culture Tourism Rural ourism Economy Sustainable Economy Circular Economics Political Economics Behavioral Economics -Creating an eco-resort in line with sustainable development goals and su ficient tourist accommodations for visitors. -Integrating the cultural heritage of Shibam into the design. -The eco-resort should reflect the culture, heritage, and natural beauty of a Shibam and Hadhramout in emen. -E ficient use of ene g wate and other resources. -Use of renewable ene g such as solar ene y -Privacy: The site must be located away from the city and not surrounded by buildings. -Good indoor environmental air qualit -Pollution and waste reduction measures, and the enabling of reuse and recycling -A design that enables adaptation to a changing environment. -There will be a variety of cultural and historical art shows at the resort, as well as desert-related activities such as camping, camel riding, rest, relaxation, and meditation. -Use of materials that are nontoxic, ethical, and sustainable. -Consideration of the environment in design, construction, and operation. -Consideration of the quality of life of occupants in design, construction, and operation. -Future Development: Considering the future expansion. -A design that makes building future proof, short term and long term. -Design solutions and materials of units should be integrated with the site, with the masses complementing the mountainous terrain to give a dramatic appearance. On average March, April, The upper windows open when you need do high-speed air movement by pulling hot air out of the building. The building captures the lower winter sunlight to the interior and roof decks, higher with flat, adobe roof, maintaining ideal. Summer Winter Mud brick walls have high thermal due to the organic composes walls absorb much the solar heat but later emit during colder night hours. Solar Heat Gain The treatments natural ventilation. Good control on insert and ejecting air. Mud brick Clay with Straw CMU bond beam Membrane Plywood sheathing Rigid Insulation Cant Strip Heavy timber girder Heavy timber column Mud brick Flashing Concrete lintel CMU Retaining wall Rebar Perforated drainpipe Concrete foundation Concrete footing city. Formation of an integrated, layered terrace community wit Articulation of massing and integration of architecture and landscape to offer magnificent views overlooking the historical h associated three-dimensional spatial experiences. The rooms contain lower windows closer Mashrabiya consists two parts the external part wooden faced with decorations, and part internal window shutters can open and close control, this unique design will help on the entry of air into spaces with blocking direct sunlight and to increase the control by making behind Mashrabiy white curtains punctuated the air and toreflect the sun's rays.
Fig. 7. 24 (Board #2) Fig. 7. 25 (Board #3)
76 77 Mud brick Wall Foundations, floors, and roofs The method of selecting the clay used in the manufacture of mud brick very important and done by experienced builders. The chopped straw also mixed with the clay and the mud bricks are left exposed to the sun for few days until becomes solid. The straw prevents cracking and adds strength. All buildings have a hard rock foundation, commonly of cyclopean stone often from wadi boulders. Foundations are dug until the solid ground reached, the rule being that “until the soil is too hard for the pick to enter”. Foundations are dug until the solid ground reached, the rule being that “until the soil is too hard for the pick to enter”. This accounts for foundations being or meters deep in alluvial soils and very shallow in rocky areas. The foundation may not be apparent, is in much of the earth construction, or may be raised to form part of the ground floor walling. In this way when the top floors are of earth, the ground floor may appear as high stone foundation. Floors and roofs are built by providing a load-bearing structure of parallel beams - very often just rough tree trunks - at 40 to 60 cm centers. Twigs are then spread between and covered with thick (around 30 cm) layer of sifted, dampened, and compacted earth. This may be left exposed or covered with coarse aggregate or surfaced with water-resistant lime mortar. The roof consists of the timber of the trees Sidr and placed palm fronds or branches of some other plants and then placed on cloth such as cloth tent to act as water insulation and placed above the mud. The Palm is the main source for the production of household supplies and involved in the construction materials of the houses of the plantation, Construction Techniques for Building along with some plants and trees from the local environment The architecture project will consist of an Eco-hotel Resort covering approximately 35,000 sq. ft.The resort Chalets’ capacity is 100 visitors having Three types of chalets to accommodatethem. Utilizing surfaces as garden roof provides tranquil retreat for the residents, particularly during hot summer nights, when refreshing breezes gracefully sweep through Night Perspective Mud brick The chopped straw Chalet Type C (3 Bedrooms): Capacity: 8 persons, No. 5 units. Plan of Chalet Type C Plan of Chalet Type B Plan of Chalet Type A Chalet Type B: (1 Bedroom): Capacity: 4 people, No. 9 units. Chalet Type A: (2Bedrooms), Capacity: 6 people, No. 4 units.
you for being part of this journey.
Fig. 7. 26 (Board #4)
Thank

Attia, Ahmed. “Traditional Yemeni Architecture and Its Impact on Energy Efficiency.” ResearchGate, August 2020. https:// www.researchgate.net/publication/356595813_Traditional_Yemeni_Architecture_and_Its_Impact_on_Ener gy_Efficiency.

Baeissa, Anwar. “Mud-Brick High-Rise Buildings Architectural Linkages for Thermal Comfort in Hadhramout Valley, Yemen.” Fdocuments.net, October 5, 2013. https://fdocuments.net/- document/mud-brick-high-rise-buildings-ar chitectural-linkages-for-thermal-comfort-in-hadhramout- valley-yemen.html?page=1.

Ceballos-Lascurain, Héctor. “[Pdf] Tourism, Ecotourism, and Protected Areas: The State of Nature ...” Semantic Scholar, September 1, 1996. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/-Tourism%2C-Ecotourism%2C-and-Protec ted-Areas%3A-The-State-Ceballos-Lascura%CC%81in/fad55ef5b43171fbb0ce90e364b041fcd8204f13.

Centre, UNESCO World Heritage. “Old Walled City of Shibam.” Accessed May 8, 2022. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/192/.

Gulnaz, Khan. “This Ancient Mud Skyscraper City Is the ‘Manhattan of the Desert.” National Geographic Travel. May 4, 2021. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article/shibam-mud- skyscraper-yemen.

Jerome, Pamela, Giacomo Chiari, and Caterina Borelli. “The Architecture of MUD: Construction and Repair Technology in The ...” ResearchGate, January 1999. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269825587_The_Architecture_of_ Mud_Construction_and_Repair_Technology_in_the_Hadhramaut_Region_of_Yemen.

Khan, Aga. “Intervention Architecture.” Bloomsbury, November 15, 2007. https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/interven tion-architecture-9781845116736/.

Leiermann, Tom. “Rehabilitation of Historic Shibam and Zabid, Yemen as an Impulse for Community and Economy.” Built Heritage 5, no. 20, 2021, SpringerOpen. Springer Singapore. December 9, 2021. https://built heritage. sprin geropen.com/articles/10.1186/s43238-021-00044-8.

Weather2Travel.com. “Shibam Weather Averages: Best Time to Go: Yemen.” Weather2Travel.com. Accessed Feb 3, 2023. https://www.weather2-travel.com/yemen/shibam/.

Thawaba, Naji. “Shibam (Yemen): General Information.” Organization of World Heritage Cities. September 27, 2018. https://www.ovpm.org/city/shibam-yemen-2/.

“Yemen Tourism Statistics.” CEIC. accessed September 20, 2022, https://www. ceicdata.- com/en/yemen/tourismstatistics.

Lewcock, Ronald. “Wadi Hadramawt and the Walled City of Shibam.” Unesdoc.unesco.org. July 15, 1986. https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000071939.

78 79 Bibliography

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.