www.apsnet.org
November 2012 • Volume 46 • Number 10
2012 Phytopathology Survey Results Show Journal Maintains High Significance George Sundin, Phytopathology Editor-in-Chief, sundin@msu.edu In April 2012, a survey concerning all things Phytopathology was sent to all APS members and to authors (including nonmembers) who had published in Phytopathology between 2007 and 2012. The survey was completed by 593 of 4,383 APS members (13.5%) and 658 of 3,910 Phytopathology authors (16.8%). I want to personally thank everyone who completed the survey for their time and input. The results have been compiled and analyzed, and I provide a summary of them below. The main goals of this survey were to assess the current stature of Phytopathology, the importance of various criteria authors use in deciding to submit manuscripts to Phytopathology, authors’ satisfaction with the peer-review process of Phytopathology, and their opinions concerning page charges and to evaluate potential interest in new modes of information dissemination of Phytopathology content, including via tablets and smartphones. The stature of Phytopathology previously and in 2012 as a leading journal reporting fundamental advances in plant pathology research can be quantified by measures such as the Journal Citation Reports’ impact factor, which is currently 2.799, and the five-year impact factor, which is currently 2.924. These values lead all other journals that predominantly publish on a broad range of topics in plant pathology. In addition, among all plant pathology journals, Phytopathology by far had the highest total when the total number of citations to the journal is enumerated, receiving 12,574 in 2011. Quantitative statistics such as these, as well as the opinions of scientists based on aspects such as their perception of the quality of papers published, ultimately influence the overall reputation of a journal. The April 2012 survey results revealed that 88% of both the APS member When asked how Phytopathology ranked and Phytopathology author respondents among other plant pathology journals: indicated that the reputation and importance of Phytopathology among other plant pathology subject journals was “high” (ranked with the best journals) or “above average” (ranked above Below Average .6% most journals). High 58.5%
Average 11.1% Above Average 29.7%
When asked to rate the importance of various criteria determining where to submit manuscripts (scale of 0 to 4), the most important criteria identified were “subject matter of the journal” at 3.32 and “reputation of the journal” at 3.29. Other criteria scoring highly were “electronic subscription access by institutions and individuals” (2.98), “speed to publication” (2.95), “good past experience
Results from the 2012 Phytopathology Survey continued on page 168
News PDMR Accepting Submissions for Volume 7 (2013) As in the past, Plant Disease Management Reports (PDMR) will be published in two installments, allowing authors to submit reports twice a year. Submissions to the first installment are due to the editor-in-chief for assignment by December 10, 2012. Publication charges are $40 per report and are payable with submission of the final approved report by February 22, 2013. The submission date for the second installment will be in late spring or early summer 2013. The exact date will be announced on the submission instructions webpage and in Phytopathology News. The submission form will be available November 12, 2012. Instructions for submission preparation and procedure can be found at www.scientificsocieties.org/aps/pdmr/ guidelines. n
APS Is Thankful for Members Like You! Recharge Your Membership
As a society, we have almost 5,000 things to be thankful for: our members! APS is a member-driven organization, and we are truly grateful each and every time you renew your membership for another year (or three)! Whether you renew on the APS website (www.apsnet.org/renew) or by calling the Membership Department (+1.651.994.3806), we hope that you renew today and enjoy all the APS membership benefits you know and depend on for another year to come! n
In this Issue Editor’s Corner ........................................ 166 Letter to the Editor ................................. 167 APS Foundation .......................................172
Public Policy Board ................................. 173 People ..................................................... 174 Classifieds ................................................ 177
APS Journal Articles ................................ 179 Calendar of Events .................................. 180