VZ SF
VISION ZERO SF
VISION ZERO ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
EVERY YEAR IN SAN FRANCISCO, about 30 people lose their lives and over 500 more are severely injured while traveling on city streets. These deaths and injuries are unacceptable and preventable, and San Francisco is committed to stopping further loss of life. The City and County of San Francisco adopted Vision Zero, a policy that commits us to ending traffic fatalities, in 2014. Vision Zero San Francisco commits city agencies to build better and safer streets, educate the public on traffic safety, enforce traffic laws, and adopt policy changes that save lives.
A note from the Mayor In 2014, San Francisco adopted Vision Zero, a plan committed to eliminating all traffic deaths in our city. At the core of Vision Zero is a simple and powerful philosophy: traffic deaths are unacceptable and preventable. Across the United States, cities have joined us in adopting Vision Zero as a policy. We know zero traffic fatalities may sound like an ambitious goal, but it is the right one. Too many people have died on our streets and too many families still cope with the tragic loss of their loved ones. Today, just 13 percent of San Francisco’s streets account for 75 percent of the city’s severe traffic injuries and fatalities. With this knowledge, the city has doubled down on our street safety investments, from engineering projects and education campaigns to enforcement operations. In the past five years, San Francisco has implemented more than 230 miles of safety improvements, initiated more than a dozen public awareness campaigns, and issued almost 175,000 citations for the most dangerous traffic violations. These violations included red light running, running stop signs, violating pedestrian rights-of-way, speeding, and failure to yield to pedestrians while turning. While our city has reached an all-time low in traffic deaths over the past two years, even one loss of life on our roads is still one too many. Through this Action Strategy, San Francisco is not only recommitting itself to our Vision Zero goal, we are also stating that to get to zero traffic deaths, more work is needed. While we will continue to build safer streets, enforce the rules of the road, and increase public awareness, it is imperative that San Francisco advocate for and spearhead new, and proven initiatives that can save lives. From using automated technology to enforce speed limits to piloting new tools to mitigate congestion, this Action Strategy is proposing a transformative policy agenda focused on getting to zero traffic fatalities. Through the actions outlined in this strategy and the policy agenda proposed, we are reaffirming San Francisco’s commitment to doing more to finally achieve the ultimate goal of Vision Zero. Sincerely,
London Breed Mayor of San Francisco
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
ACTION STRATEGY OVERVIEW This Vision Zero Action Strategy outlines the initiatives and actions Vision Zero San Francisco will take to advance Vision Zero—ending traffic fatalities in San Francisco. The strategy was developed by the City and County of San Francisco, co-chaired by the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency and the Department of Public Health, with leadership from the Mayor’s Office, President of the Board Norman Yee and the Board of Supervisors, and in coordination with local community groups and advocacy organizations. Since 2014, Vision Zero SF has published an Action Strategy that lays out the strategic actions for city departments and agencies to reach the city’s Vision Zero goal. This third version of the Action Strategy reaffirms the city’s long-term commitment to Vision Zero and for the first time expands beyond standard engineering, enforcement, and education actions to be clear about the broader policies and goals needed to achieve Vision Zero. This Action Strategy springboards policy areas that the State of California can advance to immediately improve street safety—automated enforcement, pricing to reduce vehicle miles traveled, urban speed limit setting, and local regulations of Transportation Network Companies. The Action Strategy also acknowledges that the city must be serious and advance complementary city goals to get to zero—goals like more people walking, biking and taking transit, reducing greenhouse gas emissions from the transportation sector, and building more housing for all San Franciscans, so that sustainable choices are a viable option for most trips. Critically, this Action Strategy ensures that implementation of Vision Zero projects and programs has a strong foundation in advancing equity, and that the goals, policies, and actions of this Strategy do not exacerbate existing inequities and instead improve health outcomes for the city’s vulnerable populations.
4 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
GETTING TO ZERO
STRATEGIC ACTIONS
TRANSFORMATIVE POLICIES
COMPLEMENTARY GOALS
EQUITY FOCUS
This Action Strategy proposes three key areas that will need to advance for the city to get to zero. These key areas are rooted in a foundation of equity, that historic injury inequities in vulnerable communities are addressed through actions, policies and coordination with complementary goals and that initiatives do not contribute to or exacerbate existing inequities. • Strategic Actions: Key actions valued at $65 million annually in investment for Vision Zero SF agencies to commit to and act on to improve traffic safety outcomes within a Safe Systems framework. • Transformative Policies: Four key legislative needs for San Francisco that have proven nationally and internationally to dramatically reduce crashes and save lives. • Complementary Goals: City policies that complement and advance Vision Zero by reducing vehicle miles traveled, a major predictor of crashes.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 5
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
VISION ZERO CORE PRINCIPLES San Francisco’s Vision Zero program is guided by the core principles that traffic fatalities are preventable, and that traffic safety interventions will mitigate the likelihood that a collision results in death. The program uses a data-driven approach with a focus on strategies and actions that are proven to reduce instances of vehicle speeding— the most critical factor in predicting a traffic fatality.
6 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in in City SanOur Francisco
Saving Lives Safety and the preservation of human life is our highest priority.
Prevention Traffic deaths are preventable and unacceptable.
Equity The transportation system should be safe for all road users, for all modes of transportation, in all communities and for people of all incomes, races and ethnicities, ages, and abilities.
Speed People are inherently vulnerable and speed is a fundamental predictor of crash survival. The transportation system should be designed for speeds that protect human life.
Safe Streets Human error is inevitable and unpredictable; we should design the transportation system to anticipate error so the consequence is not severe injury or death. Transportation and land use development policies, standards, programs, and design decisions should prioritize preserving lives.
Safe People and Safe Vehicles Safe human behaviors, education about and enforcement of safety rules, and vehicle technologies are essential contributors to a safe system.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 7
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
COMPLEMENTARY GOALS
SING U O H /
N
AC
S
FIR
T A M
E
AN
TIO
VZ SF
TR IT
MO DE
IFT SH
LAND US E
San Francisco’s Vision Zero goal works together with other city goals and policies that prioritize walking, biking and improved transit, while reducing driving and vehicle miles traveled on our streets. Meeting the goal of zero traffic deaths depends on the city’s advancement of these related policy goals.
ST
8 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
C LI
Eliminating
Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in San in Our Francisco City
Mode Shift The city will shift 80% of trips to sustainable travel choices by 2030. More people walking and biking on safe streets in San Francisco—getting health benefits from physical activity, cleaner air, and less traffic noise— helps makes it safer for everyone on every street.
Transit First The SFMTA’s Transit First policy prioritizes public transit, bicycling and walking on San Francisco’s streets. A strong public transit system is critical to realize Vision Zero and shift people out of their cars. The rapidly changing transportation landscape and emerging technologies will need to elevate safety as a key goal.
Climate Action By 2050 San Francisco will reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 80% from 1990 levels. Central to this goal is reducing transportation emissions which contribute an estimated 50% of GHGs in California. Reducing vehicle miles traveled as the city improves traffic safety strengthens Vision Zero.
Land Use/Housing San Francisco will create 30,000 new housing units by 2020, including 50% for middle income households and 30% permanently affordable. Building housing closer to jobs, schools and services is proven to increase the number of trips made by walking and biking; making this housing affordable and the nearby streets safe is critical to a sustainable future.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 9
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
TRANSFORMATIVE POLICY AGENDA Getting to zero will require political will and public support for ambitious and transformative policies.
AUTOMATED ENFORCEMENT
The four policies recommended for Vision Zero SF and state partners: • require local legislative authority, • are evidence-based to reduce severe and fatal injuries, and • are high-impact initiatives that will significantly move San Francisco towards its Vision Zero goal.
PRICING AND REDUCING VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED
URBAN SPEED LIMIT SETTING
LOCAL REGULATION OF TRANSPORTATION NETWORK COMPANIES
10 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
POLICY AGENDA
AUTOMATED ENFORCEMENT Using automated technologies and programs that complement traditional enforcement methods (for violations such as red light running, speeding, and illegal turns) to reduce dangerous driving behaviors and save lives. Traffic violations can be targeted through automated enforcement technologies, such as speed cameras. These cameras use vehicle detection to capture images of vehicles that are violating traffic laws, such as red light running and speeding. Although some red light cameras and illegal turn cameras exist in San Francisco, state legislation is required to authorize automated speed enforcement.
Needed Legislative Change Ability to enforce traffic laws through automated technology. Strategic Action Being Advanced Now Engage State Zero Traffic Fatalities Task Force, to be convened in 2019, to advance automated enforcement in future legislative cycle. Impact: More for Vision Zero Automated enforcement is a proven tool in reducing traffic fatalities and injuries. Washington D.C. experienced a 73 percent reduction in traffic fatalities with its speed cameras, and a 34 percent decrease in traffic related injuries.1 Because of its effectiveness, the National Transportation Safety Board recommends that current laws be amended to authorize state and local agencies to use automated speed enforcement.2
1
https://www.sfmta.com/projects-planning/projects/automated-speed-enforcement
2
https://www.ntsb.gov/news/events/Documents/2017-DCA15SS002-BMG-Abstract.pdf
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 11
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
POLICY AGENDA
Needed Legislative Change
PRICING AND REDUCING VEHICLE MILES TRAVELED Implementing a demand management strategy to reduce traffic, encourage public transit ridership, improve safety conditions, and reduce traffic injuries. Charging drivers a fee for the use of specific roadways is a way to manage demand for driving on the most congested streets. It also helps make traffic flow more efficiently for public transit and remaining car traffic, while improving conditions for people walking and biking. Cities that have implemented congestion charges have identified strong benefits as a result for traffic safety.
State legislative authority to use congestion mitigation tools like pricing or other mechanisms to reduce vehicle miles traveled in San Francisco. Strategic Action Being Advanced Now Develop recommendations for pricing strategies that advance the city’s collaborative Mobility, Access and Pricing Study, with a focus on how the policy can improve safety conditions and not disproportionately burden lowincome communities. Impact: More for Vision Zero London experienced a 40 percent reduction in the number of collisions in the city after implementing a congestion charge.3 SFDPH conducted a health impact assessment of a potential pricing policy in San Francisco and found significant potential reductions in pedestrian injuries in future conditions with road pricing, compared to one without.4
3
Green CP, Heywood JS and Navarro M (2016) ‘Traffic accidents and the London congestion charge’, Journal of Public Economics, 133: 11–22. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0047272715001929
4
https://www.sfdph.org/dph/files/opp/SFroad-pricing-fullreport.pdf
12 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
POLICY AGENDA
URBAN SPEED LIMIT SETTING Adopting alternative approaches to set speed limits that incorporate safety and mobility goals Speed is the leading predictor of whether or not someone survives a crash. Just five miles over the limit is twice as likely to kill. Speed limits are generally set using the speed at which most vehicles are observed to travel. Allowing the speed limit setting process to consider safety could help to lower speed limits on city streets, reduce crashes, and save lives. The city currently cannot use a different methodology without state legislative change.
Needed Legislative Change State legislative authority for cities to set speed limits that consider safety outcomes. Strategic Action Being Advanced Now Engage State Zero Traffic Fatalities Task Force to advance alternatives to current speed limit setting methods as soon as possible. Impact: More for Vision Zero Speeding is one of the top factors in San Francisco’s severe and fatal collisions, and a leading predictor of crash survival. The City of Boston lowered speeds from 30 mph to 25 mph citywide as part of its Vision Zero program. As a result, there was a 29 percent reduction in episodes of excessive speeding.5 Twenty mile per hour speed limits and speed zones have been found to be an effective means of reducing injuries.6
5
https://visionzeronetwork.org/cities-can-look-to-boston-iihs-for-inspiration-to-reduce-speed-limits/
6
Cairns J et al. Go slow: an umbrella review of the effects of 20 mph zones and limits on health and health inequalities. Journal of Public Health, Volume 37, Issue 3, 1 September 2015, Pages 515–520.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 13
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
POLICY AGENDA
Needed Policy Change
LOCALLY REGULATE TRANSPORTATION NETWORK COMPANIES Transportation Network Companies (TNCs), such as Uber and Lyft, are regulated at the state level under the authority of the CA Public Utilities Commission. As of 2018, more than 15% of all daily weekday trips within San Francisco are TNCs. Currently, the TNCs are not required to participate in city driver training or fleet inspection. Further, when curb space is not available, TNC vehicles can create safety hazards by blocking traffic, transit and bicycle lanes, or driving unsafely. Local authority to regulate TNCs would allow our city to more effectively manage traffic flow, reduce crashes and improve safety and access for bicyclists and pedestrians.
7
Local regulatory authority for Transportation Network Companies (TNCs) to effectively manage safe pickup and drop-offs, educate drivers, and ensure a safe fleet. Strategic Action Being Advanced Now Projects, including piloting more flexible passenger loading zones in high TNC activity areas. Impact: More for Vision Zero TNCs comprise almost half of the increase of over 630,000 vehicle miles traveled each weekday in San Francisco seen between 2010-2016.7 Local regulation of this new fleet of drivers circulating on our streets can help ensure that TNC driver education, training, and vehicle policies would be aligned with San Francisco’s Vision Zero goal and be responsive to safety concerns unique to the TNC industry.
https://www.sfcta.org/sites/default/files/content/Planning/ /TNCs_Congestion_Report_181015_Final.pdf
14 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating
Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in in Our City San Francisco
COMMITMENT TO EQUITY Equity is a core principle of Vision Zero. The transportation system should be safe for all road users, for all modes of transportation, in all communities and for people of all incomes, races and ethnicities, languages, ages, abilities, and housing status. Vision Zero initiatives must be developed and implemented with an equity lens to achieve just outcomes and save lives. This means advancing actions that prioritize our most vulnerable populations and are sensitive to community context.
Defining Inequities Inequities in severe and fatal injuries are avoidable disparities in injury outcomes that result from unjust and unfair differences in social, economic, environmental and political conditions. Vulnerable populations: Communities experiencing or at-risk for severe or fatal traffic injuries include older adults, youth, homeless or marginally housed residents, lowincome people, people of color, non-English speaking people, immigrants and people with disabilities. There is also intersectionality between many of these communities. Geographic inequities: San Francisco’s Vision Zero High Injury Network is disproportionately concentrated in low-income communities and communities of color. Vulnerable road users: Pedestrians, cyclists, and motorcyclists are more likely to experience severe or fatal injuries when they are involved in a traffic collision due in part to current transportation system design and historic prioritization of motor vehicle speed and mobility over safety. Bias and unintended consequences: Vision Zero projects and programs should not exacerbate existing inequities in implementation or result in any unintended consequences, including interactions with law enforcement and issues of racial profiling, bias, and deportation. The SF Police Department stands for safety with respect for all and commits to engage in just, transparent, unbiased and responsive policing.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 15
DRAFT 01-25-19
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
EXISTING INEQUITIES Only by advancing equity and focusing on communities and road users disproportionately impacted by traffic deaths will we be able to reach our Vision Zero goal. Based on our current data we know: • Seniors account for approximately half of pedestrian deaths8 but only fifteen percent of the city’s population. • People with disabilities are particularly vulnerable. People with mobility, hearing, and visual disabilities represent six percent of trauma center admissions involving transportation injury.9 • People experiencing homelessness and marginally housed residents account for 20 percent of pedestrian deaths but less than one percent of the SF population.8 • People of color represent the majority of those impacted by traffic death.8 • Communities of Concern, areas with high concentrations of low income residents, immigrants, and non-English speaking residents and seniors, are where half of all severe and fatal injuries occur. • People walking comprise two-thirds of traffic deaths; people biking and motorcycling are also disproportionately impacted.8
8
9
2017-2018 Fatality data 2013-2014 Trauma data
16 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in in City SanOur Francisco
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 17
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
To advance equity for vulnerable populations and road users, this Strategy commits to:
Deepening community engagement
Prioritizing and monitoring improvements
with community leaders and local stakeholders to ensure that strategic actions reduce injury inequities and do not exacerbate existing inequities.
on the high injury network, in Communities of Concern, and where there are concentrations of severe/fatal injuries to seniors and people with disabilities and other vulnerable populations to address historic differences in resource allocation.
18 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Ensuring Vision Zero transformative policies consider and address equity impacts on vulnerable populations, including the impact of fines and fees on low income residents.
Eliminating
Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in San in Our Francisco City
Implementing data-driven, culturally competent, multilingual education, engagement and enforcement campaigns targeted in impacted areas.
Developing and institutionalizing an injury surveillance system to ensure that injury crash data is accurate, publically available, and includes an analysis of vulnerable populations.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 19
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
ME RC
HA
SAN FRANCISO’S HIGH INJURY NETWORK
D LV NB TO ING SH WA
KO
ILW E
LL
ST
RD
GD
SHIN
Y
LE
PER
ST
The Vision Zero High Injury Network (HIN) guides the city’s investments in infrastructure and programs, and ensures that Vision Zero projects support those most in need.
W
OLN BLVD
RD
LINC
GIB
AVE SEACLIFF SCENIC WAY
M
L
O
IN
M
EL
CA
ST
18TH AVE
21ST AVE
19TH AVE
20TH AVE
28TH AVE
30TH AVE
29TH AVE
32ND AVE
34TH AVE
33RD AVE
37TH AVE
36TH AVE
35TH AVE
38TH AVE
DR
41ST AVE
40TH AVE
44TH AVE
43RD AVE
42ND AVE
45TH AVE
BALBOA ST
31ST AVE
46TH AVE
LA PLAYA
47TH AVE
48TH AVE
39TH AVE
ANZA ST
22ND AVE
UNNAMED 010
S AVE
23RD AVE
24TH AVE
VETERANS
25TH AVE
27TH AVE
26TH AVE
CLEMENT ST
UNNAMED 018
POINT LOBO
Y IE WA
MERR
31ST AVE
7
LAKE
SEA VIEW TER
FORT MILEY 3
FORT MILEY SEAL ROCK DR
DE
HOWARD RD
WEST CLA Y ST
MCLAREN AVE
AR
R
N
SO
BO
CABRILLO ST
CROSSOVER
PARK PRESI DR
CHA
DR
TR
KES
F LA
IN O
OK ERLO OV MIDDLE WEST DR
SE
ER
SV
DR
AN
STOW
DR
MARTIN LUTHER KING JR DR
28TH AVE
27TH AVE
SUNSET BLVD
21ST AVE
LAWTON ST
20TH AVE
25TH AVE
32ND AVE
31ST AVE
33RD AVE
26TH AVE
30TH AVE
NORIEGA ST
ORTEGA ST
24TH AVE
34TH AVE PACHECO ST
35TH AVE
42ND AVE
46TH AVE
GREAT HWY
47TH AVE
41ST AVE
48TH AVE
GREAT HWY
29TH AVE
37TH AVE
MORAGA ST
22ND AVE
23RD AVE
KIRKHAM ST
38TH AVE
40TH AVE
39TH AVE
45TH AVE
44TH AVE
43RD AVE
GREAT HWY
PINO ALY
LA PLAYA PACHECO ST
IRVING ST
PACHECO
QUINTARA ST
QUINTARA ST RIVERA ST
23RD AVE
ULLOA ST
VICENTE ST
ESCOLTA
WAY
WAWONA ST
21ST AVE
25TH AVE
24TH AVE
23RD AVE
EVERGLADE DR
EUCALYPTUS DR BUCKINGHAM
ARMORY
R WINSTON DR ST AT ED R
Low-income communities, communities of color, seniors and people who rely on walking and transit as their primary means of transportation.
G
RD
STA TE
IN
RD
DR
VD BL
TAPIA DR
VIDAL DR
HOLLOWAY AVE
PINTO AVE
SERRANO DR
HIGUERA AVE RE
CA
BU
BROTHERHOOD WAY
SKYLINE BLVD
20 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
LV A
GARCES DR
DR
IJA
UIR
GR
NM
DR
LI
JOH
DR
CR
ES
PI
LAKE MERCED BLVD
T
N
FO
HA
DR
AVE
E DR
22ND AVE
26TH AVE
SYLVAN DR
INVERNESS DR
RIVERTON DR
FOREST VIEW DR
41S T
TLAK
MIDDLEFIELD DR
BD
DR
CRES
SLOAT BLVD
SPRINGFIELD DR
CLU
CLEARFIELD DR
LAKESHORE DR
TRY
D
OR
ZO
DR MORNINGSIDE GELLERT DR
UN
CO
The 13% of streets where 75% of severe and fatal collisions occur.
ST RBA ESCONDIDO AVE
YO
YORBA ST
MEADOWBROOK DR
High Injury Network
Metropolitan Transportation Commission Communities of Concern
36TH AVE
38TH AVE
40TH AVE
39TH AVE
MAP LEGEND
25TH AVE
TARAVAL ST
26TH AVE
27TH AVE
SANTIAGO ST
SUMMIT
UN ED
M NA 9
12
NO
I UE R EN AV INT D O HP RT
MARINER DR
TI
TH
13
I
TREASU RE ISL AND RD NIMITZ DR
D UN TB O ES W I-8 0 D UN ST BO EA I-8 0 ST R BE
P
M
RA N O S 80 I-2
ST GS IN
AT R
ST ES
ST ES
H
ST
CH
ST
HA W
ST
H
RL
ST
FIT LA SA
AV E
LLE AV
GA
D
AV E
LV E
ZA VE
R
E
W AL US IO EL
G
RO
AV E
FT
AV E
HO LS FIT WA Y H ST
W AY
ER ON
M
GR
NIC
CA
ON
NC
FIT H S ST T GIA NT S DR Y
EG
FIT
BE
ZG
ER
RT AV E D AV E
AL
AL T
DO
NA
GIL
HU
RO
IF
ALE
AV E
OL
AR
TR
BA
NIN
KD
RR
ST
GA
MS
GS
IN
ST
AR
JE N
ST
OA
ON
AV E
JE
RD
KE
AV E
ES
HA W
HA W
AV E
S
RD
E
AV E
GR BAYV IE
AV E
AV E
DS
NE
KA
CRISP RD
FIT
CE
AV E
NA VY
HU
IN KIS
IF
FT
AV E
R
E
ST
AV E
RO
KE
TE
AL
LN
IF
LA
AF
AA VE
E
GR
W AL
D
AS
KD
AD
S
E
LL
MIT
OO
DY
SH
OM
AV E
OA
GR IF
LA
ST
ST
VA N
SE
AV E
RW
RE
ES
EA
BE
H KE IT
QU
INDIA ST
FIT
ST H
ST NE
CT
IC
RE
AV E
ST
NE
LUCY ST
FT
ER
E
JE NN
IT KE
DE L
CT
ST
MM
TH
DE
YO
LA NE
RO
CO
AV E
RK
IRONWOOD WAY MIDDLE POINT RD
LS
T
RE
BU
D FR ON IE AH DE U LL E S ST T CO LE MA N ST
ST HA LL
ST ST LL
REUEL
ME
W
HA
SH
ME N
ST
PH EL
T QU IN
ST T QU
R
NE W
PS
ST RA NK IN
ST GEV BRID LS
T VENU S ST
OU
ST
W AY
W PA
RK RD
BO
UN BO TH
OU
80 S NK IN RA ST
APOLLO
AL WH NE
LN E
AV E
DR
D
TO L I-2
ST
Y LB SE
SELBY
ST
ST AN D
ST TO N
PA TT ER ST S MIS
TUNN
EL AV
E
BLAN
KEN
LATH RO
AVE
P AV
E
ST
RA
CIN
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 21 LN
BO AL T
LOO
T AL PH
AS
ERVI NE ST DELT AS T
AND ST
RUTL
PEA BOD TALB YS T ERT ST DES MO ND ST
RY
P
M
RA
N
O
W
0
I-8
ST G
HWY 101 N ON RAMP
OUND
UTHB 101 SO
HWY
ST BARNEV ELD
ER ST BREW ST
ON
PERALTA AVE FRANCONIA ST
NEVADA ST PUTNAM ST BRONTE ST BRADFORD ST PERALTA AVE HOLLADAY AVE HILTON ST
T HR S
ST
LOE
REY
SAW YER
AVE ON
T
RIS
RIN S
GAR
SCH WE
ST
T NS
IN
TREA T AVE
BO N BO VIE CA W S NA T WOOL ST ST
ANDOVER ST MOULTRIE ST ANDERSON ST ELLSWORTH ST GATES ST FOLSOM ST BANKS ST PRENTISS ST
ARNOLD AVE
QU ED CIE R LI ESQ TO DR UIN AD CAR R RIZ AL S SA T NT OS ST PAS ADE NA ST
PAR
DR
ACK
HAH
ST H NIC MU
IEW D
ISIS
KIN
NA MIN TO N M AS A T ST
ST
YA VE FA N TIF
LE RID GE ST PR O WIN SPEC FIE T A V EL LD S E SIE T ST
CO
ST YS
R TE R MA
VA L
AC T
ST
IN
OW SC MO
MU NIC H PR ST AG UE ST DU BL IN ST
AV E
SE GO OT
ST SIE
AD GL
EL
ST N
SIO
IS M
SS T EN AT H
AV E
AV E
NO
JO SE N
LA
SA
DE
PRINCETON ST
ST RG BU NE W
RD AV E BROM PTON AVE
BADEN ST
CONGO ST
AV E AN OR OL
AVE
RC T TE SH AF
ST A BR AM
ELK ST
MIZPAH ST
DR LT A MA
EDNA ST OT
ND ON PA ST RIS LIS ST BO N MA ST DR ID ED S IN T BU RG NA H ST PL ES VIE ST NN AS T
LEE AVE
ACADIA ST
GAVIOTA WAY ARRO YO WA Y
EG A
AV EA E VE
ST JE
IN
MA
CA
UP
YUKON ST
TW
5 D 11 ME
VERNA ST
FOERSTER ST
PHELAN AVE EDGAR AVE HO WT LO HS UIS T BU RG TA ST RA ST I-280 S OF F RA WEST RD I-280 MP N ON RAMP
HAROLD AVE
IC
GRANADA AVE
BRIGHTON AVE PLYMOUTH AVE
LIPPA
IN
ST
GARD ENSID BUR E DR NETT AVE
CR E PE ST W AK A SB Y LVD
MID NA UN
MIRAMAR AVE
R DO TE
FAXON AVE
DORA
JULES AVE
FAXON AVE CAPITOL AVE
SAN JOSE AVE
AV E T ET RB CO
SKYVIEW WAY
KNOLLVIEW WAY
MOLIMO DR
GENNESSEE ST
W AY
ASHTON AVE ORIZABA AVE
BRIGHT ST
HEAD ST HEAD ST
MARK ET
OK AV
DELL
BRO
LA AV ANZA
PANORAMA DR
O
ID
AV E LO PA B N SA TO CIN JA N
DR
KEYSTONE WAY
OR
ST SO TO ST TO RIA ST DE
VIC
HIGH ST
E
DA
DR
LLS KNO EST FOR
QU B EZ HE ALC AV RN E E AN TA A VE DE RA ZA AV VE E
VA S
WA Y X NO LE
SA
AV E
DR
ES
MA N
TG AT E
AP
RAMSELL ST
VICTORIA ST
LO
DLE B
SANCHES ST
QU A
EDGEWOOD AVE
KORET WAY
OAK PARK DR
LO PE ZA EN VE AD AA VE ST CA BLVD
CLAREM ONT
E E AV AV E
TO S
RAMSELL ST
NC
WAY
ST
CIR BA
CA
VE
COVE
SAD
AV E
D
AR D BA RN
RR YR
INFA NTR Y TE R
AL H
R ED
AC
PA L
RIL EY TA AV YL E OR NT RD GO ME RY ST AH A M M ST FU ES NS A S TO T NA VE HALLE CK ST GIR AR DR D
GR
MO
MA FIR IN D ST R DR EA
ST
SE CO ND
DR
MCDOWELL AVE
HWY 1 SOUTHBOUND
PA RK BLV ND D
W
SI
AV E
RD
T
PA L
O
LN
NA
AV E
FA X
T R T C BO RIS AR H
RO
RG
FA IR
HA RT
CO
CA
ALD EMER
ARCH ST
AV E
AV E
UN OR
ON
AV E
AV E
E
MS AVE
P
NG
E
MA
BAY VIE W
AM
LO
AV E
MB
NR SO
DE
RK
BE
AV E
RD
AN T
RALSTON AVE
OU
E E AV SID
RON
EST
MAD
FOR
03RD ST
RT AL
ST
MARYLAND ST
DELAWARE ST
MICHIGAN ST
MISSISSIPPI ST
MASSACHUSETTS
MICHIGAN ST
ILLINOIS ST
TEXAS ST
PO
A ST
R
IOWA ST
TE
CO
AV E
W CIR
AV E RT AV E
IS
MICHIGAN ST
ER
IA AVE
BAYVIE
NC
LO
LOUISIAN
INDIANA ST
PENNSYLVAN
D
E
N
D
OO
LL
W
BA
AV E
YA VE
TENNESSEE ST
MINNESOTA ST
HBOUND
MISSISSIPPI ST
I-280 NORT
T
MP
RA
ES
BLVD
FF
SO
OWENS ST
80
I-2
AS
COIS TERRY A FRAN
04TH ST
FIFTH ST
SIXTH ST
ST
ST
RIC
SK
ST
LU
BO
H
RALSTON ST
C
NE
WILLIA
EGBE
SA
NO
S
OL
NTON AV
IA
AMADOR ST
BU
DS
NE
RR
KW
LA KIN
01
VERNON ST
IT
AV E
THOR
LY D
ISLAIS ST
AV E
HU
IN
JE
KIR
Y1
KEMPTON AVE
ST
R
MB
HW
M P
D
R
FO
AN ST
MISSOURI ST
MARIN ST
MC
AV E
24TH ST
26TH ST
TULARE ST AR TH UR
ST
ER
DD
HUMBOLDT ST
CU DA ST VID ER SO S AV N AV AV E E E
ELS
RA
AMP
ST
RN
TU CO
AV E
W
CK
TE
22ND ST
23RD ST
CA RR OL PAUL LA DO AVE VE NN ER EG BE AV FIT RT E ZG GIL SALIN AV ER AS AV MA E E AL ST HO N D AV LL AV JA NE E IN IS E ME LA GE TE ST LE RS R ME O A CO KE ON VE AD W N Y NT E AV AV AV AV E E E E AV E E M EA DE AV E AVE ILDE
SS BRU
FF
FF R
P
TEXAS ST
NE
BLVD
E
ED 042
UNNAM
19TH ST
AV E
ORE
O
WO
O D
CECILIA AVE
I-80
ST
N
W
ST
02
SAN RAFAEL WAY
ST
E
LO
LA VE
ST
LUNADO WAY
T
N
AL
O
BE
ST
AY
MISSOURI ST
RE
OL
ARD
ISO
AIN
ST
M
R
KE
SB
AV E
AS
S AV
18TH ST
EV AN
SH BAY
ALV
R
EA
ST AN
ZA VE AV E
S
OM
GIR
JUNIPERO SERRA BLVD JUNIPERO SERRA BLVD
SP
ST
EC
ST
ARKANSAS ST
CONNECTICUT
VE
SOUTH ST UNNAMED 191
25TH ST
RAMP
BEVERLY ST
ST
EM
FR 01
TR
ON
NE
TH
AVE
BYXBEE ST
T AR
ST
RE
I-280
MONTICELLO ST
EU ST
ST
WISCONSIN ST
LV E
IN
W
AV E
NO BRU
E
GA
HU
N
PIERPOINT LN
TUBBS ST
23RD ST
LEO
PO
NA
AVE TU
ST
CHINA BASIN ST
MARIN ST
1 TO
CHESTER AVE CHESTER AVE
ST
DAVIS
U
DS
SAN
AVE
LL
T NS
10 HWY
ALE
AVE
JR
CAMPUS WAY
Z ST
E AV VE VE A KA E A IA PE A F OT T TO NT SC D S SA E ST AR VILL DY WATER LE
NYD
LL Y
BLVD NORTH MISSION BAY BLVD SOUTH MISSION BAY
ST
E BB
H
CAROLINA ST
ELMIRA ST
ST
S
DRUMM
CT ST
W IR
WISCONSIN ST
SAN BRUNO AVE
STEUBEN ST
80
DAVIS Y ER
M
O
CAROLINA ST
UTAH ST
T
N AV
SUN
KANSAS ST
VERMONT ST
ES
Y ST
DOIN
COLB
RIS EW AY VELA SCO AVE
GA
E
VIS
ITAC IO
KNES
DE
TIO
ST
IN
CESAR CHAVE
BOW
ST
-2
ST
FRONT
BATTERY CAULF IELD RD
DAVIS
ST
O ST FRONT
HA YS
ER TG
N
WYM AN AVE HW Y1 NO RT HB
AD Y ST BATTER
SAN BRUNO AVE HIR
S MP
LA GU N WO ITA OD S D AC R RE DR
RC
VERMONT ST
D ST
DE HARO ST
RHODE ISLAN
HA
AVE
TY ST
SUN
AN
IL
G
RO
TRE
PO
ST
AVE
M
UTAH ST
N ILTO
ST
E AK
DR
ST
ST
T
T
GS
DR
ALE
WA Y
O
ST T L IE P ST T S RT BE 7TH T 0 S N TO G N
D
HAMPSHIRE ST
S ST SSEL ST BRU GEN TIN T ST ERSE
SOM
GOET
HAM
OR
DOVA
ER
NB
CANYON
GO
R
AR
UTAH ST YORK ST
ST
BLYT HD
ICA
YL NA
COR
TTE
ST SON D ST
GU
CH
AR
SAN BRUNO AVE
HAMPSHIRE ST
OKE
ST
ALLI
COR CON
W
BALT
AVE
PE
BLAIR TER
D ST
ST
HAR
WIL
LL AV
ARLE TA AV MO ND E AVE LELA ND AVE
NY
R
26TH ST
STEA
KE
C
BR
G
N
LO
D AY
22ND ST
RR
AN
KE
ST
E
G
ID
EL
SIERRA ST
CA
OLM
CAM
BROOKDALE
H
OA
ST
P
ALANA
WAY
CRESCENT
WAY
NEY
HAR
WAY
FRESNEL WAY
L RD FORE ST RD
ST LIN
H
BO
ST
HOLY
ELL ST
E
R
NO
OLS N CT KARE
MANS
VA AV
M
ST
E
FLORIDA ST
ALABAMA ST
ST
ST
AV E
N
N
AN
H
NB
KIN
EY ST
WO
RIN
CO
ST
O
O
KD AL E AV E WAY E REL AV APPA RMAN L ST DO TRIA S U IND
T ST
IGH
DW
AV E
HS
GENE
LN
LA
R
BROADMOOR DR
RD SIGNA
PL
PL
ST
EL
AN
C
MC
ST ND
ERSI
ST
O
ST
RY
R
BE
SIO
AUGUSTA ST
LA WAY
PBE
T
A
ST
O
TREAT AVE
STONECREST DR
LLA
O
MARIN ST
HELENA ST
BA
N
C
20TH ST
AS
CON
ZE
N
D
BALMY ST
LP
ST IN PRAGUE DIN G W A LA IMO Y RIS RE WAY W AY
PO
LAND WAY F SHELL EY DR
ST
MARIPOSA ST
OM
ST
IS
LA
IS
RAY
RO
L LN ROYAN ST TO NEW
ST TIS CUR
POPE
E AV
ST
S ST
ERST
E AV
E
LE
E AV A TER AW A TT SAL E AV TE O FO
O
RSE
ST
UNIV
A R
ITA LY AV E AZ ON AV E
ST
JOHN
E
ST
MIS
TH
ST EN T GAV YS EEN T SW S LE HA AVE VER SIL
ST
ON CET
AV E
IA
IL
RA
ROW
BUR
AMH
CE
E AV
E A AV IAG N
A
AN
AZ
RS
BU
MP
PRIN
EC N
LE
O
SE
IN
E AV
M
FR
PE
AV E
BR
Y ST
IA
AM
SS
S ST
W RRO
COLB
SS
O
SE
AJ AV
N
RU
AV E
RA VE
IMAN
ON FELT
ST GE BRID CAM ST ORD OXF
IO
ST
ST
COST FAIT A ST HS T
ST
SE
CA
01 Y1
OH 0T
I-28
SILL
ST
LS
YALE
ON
CE
D ST VAR HAR ST BIER N ST ISO MAD
T
AV AL
EX
AV E
GAM
OS
RU
POWHATTAN AVE
ST DOIN BOW ST H ST DOIN MOUT DART
ST
LE
ON DA GA BA AV LH E IC ON T EID AA VE
ST
CHE
PE
RIPLEY ST
W
GLADSTONE DR
PIO
MULLEN AVE
MONTCALM ST
BOW
Y
MAYNARD ST
ST MANCHESTER SHOTWELL ST
LE
EL
AM
O
H
23RD ST
EUGENIA AVE
I-280 S OFF RAMP ALEMANY BLVD
NEY ST
IO
ALAMEDA ST
ALABAMA ST
VIRGIL ST
ST
G
TIN
E AV
LIA
AR W
N
H
KAMILLE CT
CRESCENT AVE
RAMP
I-280 N OFF
R
ST
20TH ST
LUCKY ST
BENTON AVE JUSTIN DR
TRUMBULL ST
O
DIVISION ST
15TH ST
TREAT AVE
N ST MILTO
ROUSSEAU
STILL ST
EN
BU
N
ST
ST
SHOTWELL ST
ST R
TD ER
LV
MURRAY ST
TH
ST
MISTRAL ST
PARK ST
RICHLAND AVE
LIN
AW
ST
ER
LILAC ST
OSAGE ALY
CYPRESS ST
POPLAR ST
ST
ON GT
EN
PARK ST
ST
H
ST
ON
BERNAL HEIGHTS BLVD
DA VE
AR
ER ST
TH C ER SA CO ES NT NT AS A TT AY RO ER ING T SA SA FR ST ST AN BE AV CIS LA E VE SA ST N HA JU RR AN IN AV GT SA E O NT N ST AY NE ZA VE ON
AN
HIGHLAND AVE
L UE
ST
Y ER
ST
N
IP
ST
N
ST SI DIVI
CAPP ST
BARTLETT ST ORANGE ALY
DOLORES ST
IG
ST
CH
WILD
CA
TO N
RT L
M
EY
L
ID
LA
EY
AV E
M
BE
ST
RR
OR
SANCHEZ ST
HARPER ST
SU
EX
GS
CO
ST
BA
ST
ST
Y ST KA TE
TH
ST
H
JU
K
13TH ST
NATOMA ST MINNA ST
MERSEY ST ST CHATTANOOGA SEVERN ST
AMES ST FAIR OAKS ST QUANE ST
NELLIE ST VICKSBURG ST BLANCHE ST SANCHEZ ST
ST
SS
AV E
ST A ST N IN MA O AT
M
R
TH LE
16TH ST
SO
EW
N
06
ST
ES
ST
T 11
TH
10
E
OL
15TH ST
CO
JE
N
ADAIR ST
ST SAN CARLOS LEXINGTON ST
LINDA ST
OAKWOOD ST
CHURCH ST
ST
IS
KIN
Y ST
ST H
S
TH
R
09
O
D
E
HOFF ST JULIAN AVE RONDEL PL VALENCIA ST
GUERRERO ST
SHARON ST
ALBION ST
LANDERS ST
T
SU
TH
H ST
RANDALL ST
FAIRMOUNT ST
IT
LN
PO
ORT
AA VE
FF
SWISS AVE
Y PP
O M
MO
DIA
ST T ON Y S AC IGB D
ST
ST
ND
BE
M
30TH ST
SON
D
L GO
ADDI
LN
N PL ZIRCO
Y ORA WA
UE
E
IN
DR
TRINIT
Y AR C
ER
08
ST
SS AV
BELCHER ST
NOE ST
COLLINGWOOD ST
ST
DOUGLASS ST
CT
ST
TH
TO
G
N
G
E
N NE
PEARL ST
RF
ST
M
LA
D
O
AC
R
H
ST
IE
SS
NIE
05
ST
ST
R
G
H VA
AM
ST
PRECITA AVE
DAY ST
AN
YE
TON ST
SS
O
ST A
NO
ST
M AU
IE
SOUT
TH
26TH ST
29TH ST
N ST BELDE E LN CLAUD
STOCK
IN ST
SK
LA
ST
POLK ST
R
H
TE
ME ST SANSO
Y ST
MAGN
ST
GOUGH
OCTAVIA ST
AN ST
12
27TH ST
VALLEY ST
H EIG H TS TO BL PA VD Z W AY
ST BARTOL
QUINC
CYRIL
ADA CT
ST T S A IN M OMR U AT SS N
SC
CK ST
HALLE
AC ST R K IF AL AN BE AR M BO RIZ LM A TA H P ST TIL SO UT TIN OL RY S ST ER SO EN F N M P ST O Y T LE IS E T C S R L S P ST IP RA AR M SH ST AN H SH LA RA N EL N F C W LO AN OF E E BR 0 ST FRE I-8 H LS E W ST T ST N ST ST G E YA D M N KIN BR SE XO N U W BL TO
A
23RD ST
28TH ST
IAL ST
N LN
IE
N
ST
BA EM
E ST CASTL Y ST KEARN NES ST AVE GRANT
VAREN
LY PL WAVER L TON TUN STOCK TON ST STOCK ST JOICE ST STONE ST POWELL E ST WETMOR ST MASON N ST
T ST
SS
T
LIA
PLUM ST
22ND ST
DUNCAN ST
AV E
JE
ST S N IE SO ESS EN J
JU
J
HILL ST
CLIPPER ST
E
ST PL
S
CUSHMA
RTH ST AN
ST
ST ERIE ST ERIE
ELIZABETH ST
BU
COMMERC
18TH ST
24TH ST
TH
CHILD
ST OMERY MONTG ST HROP Y ST KEARN
JASPER
FANO
ST AUBURN
WO LEAVEN
ELL ST
LARKIN
LIN ST
BUCHAN
POND ST
CASTRO ST
HARTFORD ST
DIAMOND ST
19TH AVE
CA
E Y AV HEAL
MA
WINT
ST
VIA BU
ST ST
REED ST
ST
TAYLOR
JONES
ST
EV
S ES
21ST ST
ALVARADO ST
GEARY
ST
LIBERTY ST
HILL ST
LAND
ST
FRANK
ER ST
ST
19TH ST
SCOT
JANSEN
IA ST
WEBST
A ST
ST
SCOTT
EUREKA ST
Y WA
STRATFORD DR
E AV
EB
MS
NU
L PA
E AV
NIA
OR
LIF
CA
EI
HE FT EO
ST
TI
KEARNY
ST
ST
TAYLOR
OCTAV
ST
LAGUN
INCA LN
PIERCE
T
TS
ST
M
MERCHAN
N PL
OFARR ST TONIO
SYCAMORE ST
SA
CRO
ST CT ON BYR T RS VE NO HA
15TH ST
LIBERTY ST
JERSEY ST
P VE RAM RA OFF LA CU I-280 N CIR
LD
MO
ST
ROSA PARKS LN
A LN
CUMBERLAND
D
Y WA
AS ICK
HOLLIS
E ST
ST
FLIN
ISE
UO
U
BR
FILLMOR
PIERCE
TER
HOMESTEAD
RQ
EL
W NS
ST
ALPINE
WORTH ST
HOFFMAN AVE
AVE
FOUNTAIN ST
GRAND VIEW
TU
G
LIN
DERO
DIVISA
ST
R
N
TO
E AV
HYDE ST
AN ST
ST AVERY R ST
UR ST
IN
RW
R
TE
AV E
AN ST
IA ST
STEINE
SEYMO
HATTIE ST
CO
N
TE
OW
LA
CR
VIL
AG
S
N
BIGC ST
N TO
ST
AC
E
ST
RS IVE
RIC
M
OL
HE
ST
E AV N O E R U AV H AE R
E AV
ET
S
R EA
E
O
ST
E AV
N
RT H
PA U
T
ST
N
ST
A
G
U AY
AY W
N
C
Y
P
AM
NR
NO
LIE
EE
E S AV ME A G RO U
A
SO
NO
LN
R
G
IL
UR
ST
80
EN
E
ST
A ET
O
I-2
O
BOSW
MA
JOOST AVE
AY
P
RA
U
ER
S
R
O
AR
PL
W
GE
S
O
HEARST AVE
IS
T R ST WALLE IN ST O MCCOPP
CHUL
HANCOCK ST
25TH ST
ARBOR ST
MELROSE AVE
AW N
RID
O
LA
PE
BE
80
I-2
FF
M
NIQ
STILLINGS AVE
C
BROAD ST
SADOWA ST
FL
CT
DR
CUBA ALY
087
M
FARALLONES ST
SAGAMORE ST
ES
RIO
TTA
MANGELS AVE
LOBOS ST
PALMETTO AVE
AK
AG
SH
W LA
SH
CR
CT
JUDSON AVE
MED
ST
O DR ASER
CHUM
STANLEY ST
IA
RIE
RY ST
HICKO
LU
MAIDE
PL
AVE N GATE
IE
LILY ST
CO
CAMPTO COSMO
GOLDE
ST
ROSE ST
DORLAND ST
ELIZABETH ST
A LN
D
MA
20TH ST
SAFIR
MARSTON AVE
IT MM
DR
MINERVA ST
ST
21ST ST
R DR
STAPLES AVE
SU
CAMBON
EZ DR GONZAL
THRIFT ST
RANDOLPH ST
DR
FLOOD AVE
UNNA
MONTANA ST
D
ST
AMBE
CLOUD CIR
LAKEVIEW AVE
SARGENT ST
AY W
WILDWOOD WAY
GRAFTON AVE
ST
E ST
DENSLOWE DR
ST
TI
NU
D
NU
RD
E AV
UE EN AV
E AV
TH
04
03
ST
N
H
E
T
TH
05
TI
ST
GREEN
D
D ST
GROVE
ST
T ST FILBER ALTA ST
AVE
ELLIS ST
REDWOO
14TH ST
FORD ST
WAY
JUDSON AVE
DE MONTFORT AVE
SHIELDS ST
E
16TH ST
LAR
ST
AY BROADW PACIFIC
ST
TURK ST
CLINTON PARK BROSNAN ST
HENRY ST
ST
OLIVE
CH ST
IVY ST LINDEN
T ST LAUSSA ST R WALLE IA ST GERMAN RMANN ST HE
BEAVER ST
MY
WA Y
ELM ST
ROSE ST T ST HAIGH T ST LAUSSA
STATES ST
RO
EDDY ST
LILY ST
DUBOCE AVE
RTLE ST
ASH ST
ST
ORD ST
ER BELVED
W AY
WAY
PICO AVE
GARFIELD ST
ALY
AR
ICK ST
EY ST
LULU
AVE OD LWO E HAZE EZ AV COLON AVE VALD
OD
WO
KEN
TA
VIS
DR
TA
VIS
BR
RO
IN
RC
ESTA S P CR AL MO SD R
W AY
CT
Y WA
DO
L BE
E
D AV
PIZ
DR
LA
DR
LO
AVE
URBANO
BL VD
E AV
CEDRO AVE CERR ITOS AVE
X
A AVE
AY W
PALOM
RE
WAY
LANSDALE AVE
OO ENTW
R DD OO AVE YW LIPE MA SAN FE
CADA
ND DR
TL
SUNVIEW DR
ENCLINE
SA
O EP
R
HOOD
AS SIT
UPLA
MON
DR
DARIEN WAY
DR
ES
EVEL YN
MYRA WAY
ROBIN
CA
OOD
NW RAVE
AVE
WAY
SANTA CLARA AVE
SAN LEANDRO
20TH AVE
SAN BENITO WAY SANTA ANA AVE
SELMO SAN AN
AA VE
CR
AY W
A IT
DALEWOOD WAY
MIRALOMA
EN
UM
CASELLI AVE SE W AR
IN MA
W IE RV CT FA W AY VIE W W AIR VIE CL MAR
ROCKDALE DR
N
BU
D
CT
AGUA WAY
TO
R
BRODER ST
DOWN AVE
PALO ALTO AVE
AN
JU
G
A
ED
SE
SATURN ST
WOODSIDE AVE
IN
RB
AC
AL AVE
N ST CLAYTO E ST
VD BL VE EY D A EW CE D ER E M ROCK AV AWAY Z E AVE U SQ VA HL KASH KNOC NS
RR
MU
OR
ING
NUT ST ST FIELDING
CHEST
ST
WILLOW
BIRCH
R
TE
R
LOWER TER
DAWNVIEW WAY
KE
14TH AVE
15TH AVE
YE
TE
S AVE
CENTR
RY ST
E AV
M
IST
HAYES
CEDAR
CT
CLEARY
FELL ST
LYON ST
ASHBU
AVE
BAKER
AL AVE
R
MAGELLAN
LYON ST
CENTR
AY TE HEMW
D LV
AB A
EL
C
AR
JOSEPH
NIDO AVE
R ST
N ST
OLYMPIA WAY
ER ST
MCALL
ROOSEVELT WAY
PE
UP
CARMEL ST
SAINT GERMAIN
ND
AVE
SAINT
ST
N ST
ER BELVED
COLE ST
SHRADE
STANYA
DR
R
HO
12TH AVE
FUNSTON AVE
09TH
VA JA
ST
ST PINE ST NORRIS FRANK ST BUSH ST FERN ST FERN ST R ST K ST SUTTE HEMLOC
RK
LN
ZAMPA
TROY ALY
AUSTIN
ST AR
ST FULTON
PAGE ST
17TH ST
BELGRAVE AVE AVE NDON CLARE
ED
PIERCE
NIC AVE
EMERSO
COLE ST
R ST
SHRADE
ER
PH TO
TO N
ELLIS ST
ST GROVE
CLAY ST
POST ST
ICK ST
MASO
N ST CLAYTO
R ST
COLE ST
SHRADE
NS
AVE
NA
ALTON AVE
BRODER
IO AVE
ST
AL TER
JOH
R
GU
DR
CRAGMONT AVE
15TH AVE
16TH AVE
ROCK
LYON ST
PRESID
COLLINS
ST
TEMESC
FREDE
AN ST GRATT ALMA ST
WA Y
TD
ON
LA
ANGLO ALY
RIDGE
WAY
OCTAV
BUCHAN
T ST
BLAKE
ST
ER
R ST
RICK ST
SUS AVE
PARNAS
D ST
NT
WILLAR
HILLWAY AVE
02ND AVE
04TH AVE
CE
RIS CH WARREN DR
RIVERA ST
T WAY
AL
ISTA AVE
WALLE
ORTEGA ST
ORTEGA WAY
NT
03RD AVE
AVE
NORIEGA ST
MOUNT LN
DIC
WIL
OAK ST
CARL ST
BEHR
RIE
ST
ME
TM
ES
CR
SLEY
MORAGA ST
05TH AVE
AUTO DR
LOCK
ST
18TH AVE
17TH AVE
VE AA
OH
AA VE
NO
07TH AVE
08TH AVE
12TH AVE
INE
RL
LU AL
LAWTON ST
OH
06TH AVE
11TH AVE
10TH AVE
FUNSTON AVE
15TH AVE
14TH AVE
JUDAH ST
WOOD
COOK
NS ST
RTH
PARSO
D ST NO
ST BEULAH
LN W AY
HUGO ST
E
AV STA
A VI
D
LINCO
FO
WALNU
L ST
IRIS AVE
WILLAR
PARK PRESIDIO BLVD
R
RD
MOT ST
ST GARDEN BLVD GEARY ELL ST OFARR
TURK BLV
EDY DR
R
KEZA
NIA ST
BAY ST ST WATER ISCO ST FRANC ER ST PFEIFF ST
RAY LN
ST
MENTO
SACRA
CALIFOR
TERR
F KENN
W LAKE DR
WASHING
ST
POINT
NORTH
ST GLOVER Y TUNL T C LEV ROBER ST
N ST TON ST
ST
MACOND
LYNCH
PL
PERINE
E
NE AV
LUPI
ST BONITA O ST VALLEJ
JACKSO
WASHING
CLAY ST
ANZAV
SI D
PELO
CY
NAN
GA
ST
BLVD
LAURE
T ST
EN CT
AVE PARKER ONT AVE BEAUM N BLVD STANYA AVE ROSSI
ALMAD
ST EDWARD
JOHN
R
ST
E AV
LOCUS
PALM AVE
ARGUELLO BLVD
JORDAN AVE
03RD AVE
02ND AVE
04TH AVE
07TH AVE
06TH AVE
05TH AVE
08TH AVE
11TH AVE
10TH AVE
09TH AVE
12TH AVE
17TH AVE
14TH AVE
FUNSTON AVE
16TH AVE
15TH AVE
EUCLID AVE
IDIO BYPASS DR
O ST
BAKER
T ET G LIG
ST
ST
E ST
MAPLE
SPRUC
CHERRY
AVE NORTH 15TH
T PA
WES
NS ST HAVE
AY BROADW
TON ST
CORNWALL ST
AL
ST
GREEN
AVE
CIFIC
T PA
WES E
AV CIFIC
PL
HARRIS
ST
UNION
IR DR MAYFA
ANZA ST
ON ST MOULT WICH ST GREEN ST PIXLEY T ST FILBER
RD
LOOP
IDIO PRES
RODRIGUEZ ST
ST PORTOLA
R AVE MACARTHU
SIB
DR
NDS
NUT ST A ST MAGNOLI
CHEST
D ST LOMBAR
SHERMAN
SIMO
WATER
ISCO ST
FRANC
EASTM
AN
AV E
D
LE TO
ISCO ST
FRANC
AY OW
BEACH
VANDE
POLK ST
GA
ST
ST LARKIN
RA
OP
LO
T ER
YA LE VE TT ER M
RD
MO
L
POINT
NORTH
PIERCE
AN RD
NAUM
NE
AVILA ST
TO R
BAY ST
ST
DR
P O LO
CO
RT H
ER PIP
RD
NO
LYON ST
E ON MPT
ST
ST
POINT
ST
FO
ER
OW
ST
BEACH
ST
BEACH NORTH
ST
PRADO
SON ST
JEFFER
BAKER
E
RD ROD
E AV
N AV UPTO
OBB
LES
LYON ST
COW
ST MASON SON ST OUND OLD MA SOUTHB HWY 101 GO RG AS AV ED E IE RD
ST
SA W WA AY Y
O
ON
AS
M RT
CA
RIC
AVE NESS VAN
10
MASON
DR
A GREEN
MARIN
PE PO
Y
AV E
RUCKMAN AVE
RD
HT
YAC
CH RD EAST BEAST JAUSS
MASON
JEFFER
GRANT AVE
SON ST
E CT M G AV LON RU ND LE RD AD ND TE U IS HBO M AR ORT N 1
HW
EY
TH
06
T IS
AL SCOMA WAY
MARINE DR
ST OR
M
EF
T
S OK TI INO 09TH
CH
UE EN AV
NU
TH PA ER ET
CT
UE EN AV
T 11
T
UE EN AV
T
IS
HT
ST
TC
UE EN AV
RIM PE
ON
IBU
L HA
E AV
GE
UE EN AV
UR
ST TI TH T 12 IS HT 11T ST TI TH 10
ST
TI ST
RAMP
13TH ST
I-80 E ON
R
ED
SID
BAY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
22 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
STRATEGIC ACTIONS The actions outlined in the following pages are critical elements to reducing traffic deaths. They were developed by San Francisco’s city agencies with significant input and ideas from community groups, advocates, and the public in Summer 2018. Over 300 new ideas were shared through a one-day workshop and eleven community outreach events; the Vision Zero SF team heard from over 200 community members and staff throughout the city. Vision Zero SF commits to continued and broadened engagement for the program as reflected in many of the identified actions, and thanks San Franciscans for their continued advocacy and participation in ending traffic fatalities.
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 23
DRAFT 01-25-19
Eliminating
Eliminating Traffic Deaths Traffic Deaths in San in Our Francisco City
Safe Streets Safe Streets actions advance the design and engineering of San Francisco streets, and specifically the High Injury Network, for safety and to reduce the instances of speeding vehicles.
ACTION
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
2 years/ 5 years
SFMTA
CORE Increase the total miles of high-impact sustainable travel lanes - transitonly lanes, protected bicycle facilities, and wider sidewalks - by 8 miles annually to improve safety for sustainable modes.
Reduce delivery timelines for high priority corridor projects-6th St and 2 years Taylor St- through improved Public Works and SFMTA project coordination.
SFMTA and Public Works
Reduce delivery timelines through quick-build projects - work done entirely by city crews- on five corridors to advance short-term safety benefits at high priority corridors including Valencia and Townsend.
SFMTA and Public Works
2 years
Advance legislation for urban speed limit setting and enforcement through 2 years State Zero Traffic Fatalities Task Force.
SFMTA
Complete near-term improvements - signal timing and intersection crossing upgrades- at all intersections on the Vision Zero High Injury Network (HIN). This includes retiming all High Injury network signals for slower walking speeds.
5 years
SFMTA
Perform rapid-response engineering at fatal collision locations to identify and implement immediate improvements.
Ongoing
SFMTA
Implement a permanent strategic street closure for private vehicles on Market Street from 10th Street to Main Street in both directions to improve safety for sustainable transportation users.
2 years
SFMTA and Public Works
Implement two neighborhood traffic calming plans under Safe Streets for People with Disabilities program to improve streets for seniors and/or people with disabilities.
2 years
SFMTA
Construct 75 additional Pedestrian Countdown Signals and 75 Audible Pedestrian Signals on the HIN.
5 years
SFMTA
Implement countermeasures on two corridors identified in Safer Intersections work to address turn-related collisions.
2 years
SFMTA
Complete four curb management pilot projects on the HIN to reduce curb and vehicle lane safety issues.
2 years
SFMTA
PROGRAM
24 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
Develop and complete two neighborhood-specific safety/transportation plans by partnering with community organizations in two San Francisco neighborhoods.
2 years
SFMTA
Update Condition of Approval for new development to include transportation mitigation measures that advance transportation safety.
2 years
SF Planning
Develop guidance on culturally competent outreach based on past successful projects and train Sustainable Streets project managers.
2 years
SFMTA
Develop recommendations for pricing strategies that advance the San Francisco County Transportation Authority’s (SFCTA) Mobility, Access and Pricing Study.
2 years
SFCTA
Evaluate effectiveness of five street safety improvements every year to develop best practices for safety.
2 years/ 5 years
SFMTA
Create and implement improved design policies for accessibility and protected bicycle facilities and present findings to the Mayor’s Office on Disability (MOD), and the Multimodal Accessibility Advisory Committee (MAAC), key stakeholder partners that represent vulnerable populations.
2 years
SFMTA
ACTION PLANNING
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 25
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in Our City
Safe People Safe People focuses on actions that address the human aspects of traffic safety and encourage safer human behavior through strategies such as education campaigns, high visibility enforcement, and policy.
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
Issue 50% of traffic citations for top five causes of collisions (Focus on the Five).
2 years
SFPD
Extend safe speeds enforcement program with monthly ongoing speed enforcement activities rotating through high injury network (HIN) corridors.
2 years
SFPD
Seek support for legislation allowing use of transit cameras to reduce illegal parking in bus stops.
2 years
SFMTA
Conduct High Visibility Enforcement actions along a HIN corridor each quarter to target unsafe driver behaviors related to crashes.
2 years
SFPD
Continue safe speeds education campaign to reach people through communication tools (bus ads/shelter ads, radio, social media) in San Francisco about the dangers of speeding.
2 years / 5 years
SFMTA
ACTION ENFORCEMENT
EDUCATION (BEHAVIOR CHANGE)
Develop multi-lingual and culturally sensitive driving, biking, and walking 2 years guides on new street designs targeting people who drive, bike, and walk in San Francisco.
SFMTA
Launch an education campaign focused on changing driver behavior to reduce collisions resulting from left-turns.
2 years
SFMTA
Advance cultural competency by initiating a program partnering community organizations to reduce injury disparities in the Chinese community.
2 years
SFMTA
Develop and implement a high visibility education and enforcement campaign on cannabis and driving safety to people who drive in San Francisco.
2 years
SFDPH/ SFMTA
Create transportation network company (TNC) ride-hail passenger education program and distribute education materials to major TNC companies operating in the city.
2 years
SFMTA
Enhance the Safe Routes to Schools program at 103 SF Unified School District schools.
2 years
SFMTA
26 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
Create a TNC driver training program to be distributed to major TNC companies operating in the city.
2 years
SFMTA
Facilitate 6 training opportunities for San Francisco motorcycle riders in partnership with the California Motorcyclist Safety Program to encourage safe and informed riding.
2 years
SFMTA
Create user training protocols for emerging mobility and sharing technology including e-scooters and e-bikes and disseminate to respective target audiences (e.g. companies, users).
2 years
SFMTA
Fund a contractor to conduct 32 trainings each year on bicycle education, safety, and laws to adults.
2 years
SFMTA
Through 14 community grants and 30 multilingual presentations, engage seniors, service providers, and community based organizations on Vision Zero to build support for safer streets.
2 years
SFDPH
Convene city agencies and community stakeholder groups to identify existing efforts and needs, and secure funding to engage people with disabilities on Vision Zero to build support for Safer Streets.
2 years
MOD/ SFDPH
Complete the city’s Defensive Driver Training Program.
1 year
City Admin. Office
Share city accomplishments through press releases and social media.
2 years
SFMTA
Train outreach street team on culturally competent outreach to vulnerable populations.
2 years / 5 years
SFMTA
Increase engagement of the San Francisco Bay Area Families for Safe Streets group which includes survivors and family members of those severely injured or killed in traffic crashes.
2 years
SFMTA
Ensure coordinated city agency crisis response to every traffic fatality in San Francisco to provide support to victims' families.
2 years
SFDPH
ACTION TRAINING PROGRAMS
COMMUNICATIONS AND CULTURE CHANGE
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 27
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in Our City
Safe Vehicles Safe Vehicles actions ensure that San Francisco’s vehicle fleet has the latest technology to prevent collisions and that private fleet, including autonomous vehicles, transportation network companies (TNCs) and e-scooters, prioritize using the safest vehicles for city streets.
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
Develop and release an Automated Vehicle Technology Vision & Policy Playbook in partnership with key stakeholders evaluating safety opportunities and risks and identifying near and long-term actions to facilitate potential positive impacts and mitigate potential negative impacts on San Francisco streets.
2 years
SFMTA
Ensure that federal, state and local public policies related to autonomous vehicles are informed by San Francisco initiatives to implement the Vision Zero SF policies, as well as the SFMTA’s Emerging Mobility Guiding Principles. Actively engage in legislative process and participate in regulatory proceedings initiated by the US Department of Transportation, CA Department of Motor Vehicles, and CA Public Utilities Commission to communicate these policies and goals.
Ongoing
SFMTA
Establish guidelines for incorporating safety features in specifications for new city vehicle purchases (e.g. sideguards, sensors, etc.).
3 years
City Admin. Office
Conduct two targeted analyses of factors related to transit-related collisions involving severe and fatal injuries to inform targeted safety improvement recommendations for SFMTA implementation.
2 years
SFMTA
Implement SmartDrive light rail vehicle system on Muni light rail vehicles to evaluate city driver behaviors.
2 years
SFMTA
Issue annual public-facing report on driving behavior trends.
2 years
City Admin. Office
Explore additional collision avoidance technologies for SFMTA city fleet.
5 years
SFMTA
Launch a Mobility Permit Harmonization program for new and emerging mobility that elevates safety as a key consideration and ensures data availability for planning, monitoring and enforcement.
2 years
SFMTA
Evaluate emerging mobility pilots with a focus on safety outcomes.
Ongoing
SFMTA
Release a transportation network company (TNC) safety study that identifies impacts of TNCs and implement at least 2 recommendations from the study to improve safety.
2 years
SFMTA
ACTION AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES
CITY FLEET
NEW MOBILITY
28 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in Our City
Data Systems
Data Systems actions improve data that informs and monitors targeted Vision Zero efforts to save lives, delivered in partnership with the Vision Zero Injury Prevention Research Collaborative. The Collaborative includes epidemiologists, trauma surgeons, emergency physicians, and key staff from the SF Department of Public Health and Zuckerberg SF General Hospital and Trauma Center.
TIME FRAME
LEAD AGENCY
Increase transparency and accountability by integrating the transportation-related Injury Surveillance System, the dataset linking police, hospital and emergency medical service (EMS) data, as allowable by privacy law into TransBaseSF.org.
2 years
SFDPH
Expand transportation-related injury monitoring by integrating SFMTA's transit injury data and exploring 911/EMS response data.
2 years
SFDPH
Integrate SFPD Collision Data into Crime Data Warehouse for timely, efficient reporting and sharing of SFPD-reported injury collisions.
5 years
SFPD
Issue an annual research brief to address injury inequities related to homelessness, race/ethnicity, language, income, and immigration status (one topic each year) to inform policies, projects, programs and needed data quality improvements.
5 years
SFDPH
Issue an annual report on Severe Injuries utilizing Zuckerberg SF General Hospital and Trauma Center (ZSFGH) and police data.
Annual
SFDPH
Develop an Emerging Mobility Injury Monitoring system to evaluate emerging mobility services including e-scooters and identify intervenable factors associated with injury and injury severity.
2 years
SFDPH
Develop and implement Vehicle Speed Monitoring system to standardize data collection on speed and improve access to data for Vision Zero monitoring.
2 years
SFMTA/ SFDPH/ SFCTA
Update the HIN to enable SFMTA, San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) and other key stakeholders to utilize the latest injury data to inform safety improvements.
2 years
SFDPH
Develop Pedestrian Injury Predictive Model to assess factors that predict pedestrian injuries and make recommendations to city agencies on preventive measures.
2 years
SFDPH
ACTION EVALUATION AND REPORTING
VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY | 29
Eliminating Traffic Deaths in San Francisco
MEASURING PROGRESS METRIC
2021/2024 TARGETS
Fatalities 2018: 23 fatalities
Zero by 2024
Sustainable travel lanes miles added, Citywide 2014-2018: 40 miles
16 Miles / 40 Miles
Safety treatments installed on the High Injury Network 2018: 9 miles on the HIN
More than 13 miles of safety treatments on HIN annually
Percentage of safety treatments installed in Communities of Concern (CoC) 2018: 38% of HIN miles in CoC
Miles implemented in CoC equal to or greater than the proportion of the HIN falling within those communities
Focus on the Five violation citations, proportion of citywide total 2018: Citywide 41%
Citywide 50%
Vision Zero outreach 2018: Over 250 million media impressions and over 15,000 people reached at events
15,000 people annually at community events and 250 million digital media impressions
Vision Zero community awareness 2016: 11% Awareness
20% Awareness / 30% Awareness
Vision Zero street team events 2018: 52 community events, 100% with translated materials and interpretation services
47 community events annually, 100% with translated materials and interpretation services
Youth and Senior programming 2018: Seniors: 2,100 people reached, 56% in a language other than English 2018: Schools: 27 schools participating with programming in Spanish and Chinese
Seniors: 2,500 people annually (55% in non-English language) Schools: 103 schools participating annually, with programming in Spanish and Chinese
Public Health grants for community engagement 2018: 9 awards
8 awards per year
In addition to these metrics, Vision Zero SF will report annually on the number of fatal and severe injuries by travel mode, age, sex, and race/ethnicity. Vision Zero SF will also report annually on the proportion of fatal and severe injuries in Communities of Concern. For detailed reporting on Vision Zero SF severe and fatal injuries, please visit: http://visionzerosf.org/maps-data/
30 | VISION ZERO SF 2019 ACTION STRATEGY
VZ SF
VISION ZERO SF
VISION ZERO PLEDGE The Vision Zero Action Strategy outlines the commitments and actions the city will take to eliminate traffic fatalities. On behalf of the following city agencies, we commit to further institutionalizing Vision Zero for all city employees. We will work together and in partnership with stakeholders to implement this strategy to eliminate all traffic fatalities.
Mayor London Breed San Francisco Board of Supervisors Norman Yee, President of the Board and Vision Zero Committee Chair, District 7 Sandra Lee Fewer, District 1 Catherine Stefani, District 2 Aaron Peskin, District 3 Gordon Mar, District 4 Vallie Brown, District 5 Matt Haney, District 6 Rafael Mandelman, District 8 Hillary Ronen, District 9 Shamann Walton, District 10 Ahsha SafaĂ, District 11
VZ SF
VISION ZERO SF
visionzerosf.org
Project Team Chava Kronenberg, Vision Zero Task Force Co-Chair San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Megan Wier, Vision Zero Task Force Co-Chair San Francisco Department Public Health Ryan Reeves, Vision Zero Program Lead San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Mike Jacobson, Vision Zero Program Planner San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency Published February 28, 2019