ɉɟɱɚɬɶ ɞɨɤɭɦɟɧɬɚ
ФЕДЕРАЛЬНЫЙ АРБИТРАЖНЫЙ СУД ПОВОЛЖСКОГО ОКРУГА ПОСТАНОВЛЕНИЕ от 1 февраля 2012 г. по делу N А554740/2011 ȐȏȊȓȍȟȍȕȐȍ
ǼȍȌȍȘȈȓȤȕȣȑ ȈȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȣȑ șțȌ ǷȖȊȖȓȎșȒȖȋȖ ȖȒȘțȋȈ ȘȈșșȔȖȚȘȍȊ Ȋ ȖȚȒȘȣȚȖȔ șțȌȍȉȕȖȔ ȏȈșȍȌȈȕȐȐ ȒȈșșȈȞȐȖȕȕțȦ ȎȈȓȖȉț șȍȓȤșȒȖȝȖȏȧȑșȚȊȍȕȕȖȋȖ ȗȘȖȐȏȊȖȌșȚȊȍȕȕȖȋȖ ȒȖȖȗȍȘȈȚȐȊȈ ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ș ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ȕȈ ȘȍȠȍȕȐȍ ǨȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȖȋȖ șțȌȈ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ȖȚ Ȑ ȗȖșȚȈȕȖȊȓȍȕȐȍ ǶȌȐȕȕȈȌȞȈȚȖȋȖ ȈȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȖȋȖ ȈȗȍȓȓȧȞȐȖȕȕȖȋȖ șțȌȈ ȖȚ ȗȖ Ȍȍȓț 1 Ǩ ȗȖ ȐșȒȖȊȖȔț ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȐȦ șȍȓȤșȒȖȝȖȏȧȑșȚȊȍȕȕȖȋȖ ȗȘȖȐȏȊȖȌșȚȊȍȕȕȖȋȖ ȒȖȖȗȍȘȈȚȐȊȈ ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ș ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ǰǵǵ ǶǫǸǵ Ȓ ȖȚȒȘȣȚȖȔț ȈȒȞȐȖȕȍȘȕȖȔț ȖȉȡȍșȚȊț ǿȍȓȕȖ ǪȍȘȠȐȕșȒȈȧ ȔȈȠȐȕȕȖ ȚȍȝȕȖȓȖȋȐȟȍșȒȈȧ șȚȈȕȞȐȧ ș ǹȚȈȘȖȍ ȅȠȚȍȉȍȕȤȒȐȕȖ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ǰǵǵ ǶǫǸǵ Ȗ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȕȐȐ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘȈ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȖȚ 1 ȕȍȌȍȑșȚȊȐȚȍȓȤȕȣȔ Ȑ ȕȍȏȈȒȓȦȟȍȕȕȣȔ țșȚȈȕȖȊȐȓ Ȋ ǨȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȣȑ șțȌ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ȖȉȘȈȚȐȓșȧ șȍȓȤșȒȖȝȖȏȧȑșȚȊȍȕȕȣȑ ȗȘȖȐȏȊȖȌșȚȊȍȕȕȣȑ ȒȖȖȗȍȘȈȚȐȊ ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ȌȈȓȍȍ ǹǷDz ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ȐșȚȍȞ ș ȐșȒȖȔ Ȓ ȖȚȒȘȣȚȖȔț ȈȒȞȐȖȕȍȘȕȖȔț ȖȉȡȍșȚȊț ǿȍȓȕȖ ǪȍȘȠȐȕșȒȈȧ ȔȈȠȐȕȕȖ ȚȍȝȕȖȓȖȋȐȟȍșȒȈȧ șȚȈȕȞȐȧ ȌȈȓȍȍ ǶǨǶ ǿȍȓȕȖ ǪȍȘȠȐȕșȒȈȧ ǴǺǹ ȖȚȊȍȚȟȐȒ Ȗ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȕȐȐ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘȈ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȖȚ 1 ȌȈȓȍȍ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȖȚ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘ 1 ȔȕȐȔȖȑ șȌȍȓȒȖȑ ȕȍȏȈȒȓȦȟȍȕȕȣȔ ȊȊȐȌț ȍȋȖ ȉȍȏȌȍȕȍȎȕȖșȚȐ Ǫ șțȌȍȉȕȖȔ ȏȈșȍȌȈȕȐȐ ȐșȚȍȞ țȚȖȟȕȐȓ ȐșȒȖȊȣȍ ȚȘȍȉȖȊȈȕȐȧ ȗȘȖșȐȓ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȚȤ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘ 1 ȕȍȏȈȒȓȦȟȍȕȕȣȔ ǷȘȐ ȥȚȖȔ ȗȘȍȌșȚȈȊȐȚȍȓȤ ȐșȚȞȈ Ȋ șțȌȍȉȕȖȔ ȏȈșȍȌȈȕȐȐ ȗȖȧșȕȐȓȈ ȟȚȖ ȕȍșȔȖȚȘȧ ȕȈ țȒȈȏȈȕȕȖȍ țȚȖȟȕȍȕȐȍ ȐșȒȖȊȖȋȖ ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȐȧ ȐșȚȍȞ ȗȖȌȌȍȘȎȐȊȈȍȚ ȘȈȕȍȍ ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȕȖȍ ȚȘȍȉȖȊȈȕȐȍ Ȗ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȕȐȐ ȊȣȠȍțȒȈȏȈȕȕȖȋȖ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘȈ 1 ȔȕȐȔȖȑ șȌȍȓȒȖȑ ȕȍ ȖȚȒȈȏȣȊȈȍȚșȧ ȖȚ ȕȍȋȖ Ǫ șȊȧȏȐ ș ȟȍȔ șțȌȖȔ ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȕȣȑ ȐșȒ ȘȈșșȔȖȚȘȍȕ ȗȖ ȗȍȘȊȖȕȈȟȈȓȤȕȖ ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȕȣȔ ȚȘȍȉȖȊȈȕȐȧȔ ǸȍȠȍȕȐȍȔ ǨȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȖȋȖ șțȌȈ ǹȈȔȈȘșȒȖȑ ȖȉȓȈșȚȐ ȖȚ ȖșȚȈȊȓȍȕȕȣȔ ȉȍȏ ȐȏȔȍȕȍȕȐȧ ȗȖșȚȈȕȖȊȓȍȕȐȍȔ ǶȌȐȕȕȈȌȞȈȚȖȋȖ ȈȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȖȋȖ ȈȗȍȓȓȧȞȐȖȕȕȖȋȖ șțȌȈ ȖȚ Ȋ ȐșȒȍ ȖȚȒȈȏȈȕȖ ǵȍ șȖȋȓȈșȐȊȠȐșȤ ș ȗȘȐȕȧȚȣȔȐ șțȌȍȉȕȣȔȐ ȈȒȚȈȔȐ ȐșȚȍȞ ȖȉȘȈȚȐȓșȧ ș ȒȈșșȈȞȐȖȕȕȖȑ ȎȈȓȖȉȖȑ Ȋ ȒȖȚȖȘȖȑ ȗȘȖșȐȚ Ȑȝ ȖȚȔȍȕȐȚȤ Ȋ șȊȧȏȐ ș ȕȍșȖȖȚȊȍȚșȚȊȐȍȔ ȊȣȊȖȌȖȊ șțȌȖȊ ȜȈȒȚȐȟȍșȒȐȔ ȖȉșȚȖȧȚȍȓȤșȚȊȈȔ ȌȍȓȈ Ȑ ȐȔȍȦȡȐȔșȧ Ȋ Ȍȍȓȍ ȌȖȒȈȏȈȚȍȓȤșȚȊȈȔ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȚȤ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȖȚ ȕȍȏȈȒȓȦȟȍȕȕȣȔ ǼȍȌȍȘȈȓȤȕȣȑ ȈȘȉȐȚȘȈȎȕȣȑ șțȌ ǷȖȊȖȓȎșȒȖȋȖ ȖȒȘțȋȈ ȗȘȖȊȍȘȐȊ ȏȈȒȖȕȕȖșȚȤ ȖȉȎȈȓțȍȔȣȝ șțȌȍȉȕȣȝ ȈȒȚȖȊ ȐȏțȟȐȊ ȔȈȚȍȘȐȈȓȣ ȌȍȓȈ ȌȖȊȖȌȣ ȒȈșșȈȞȐȖȕȕȖȑ ȎȈȓȖȉȣ ȕȍ ȕȈȝȖȌȐȚ ȖșȕȖȊȈȕȐȑ Ȍȓȧ țȌȖȊȓȍȚȊȖȘȍȕȐȧ ȒȈșșȈȞȐȖȕȕȖȑ ȎȈȓȖȉȣ DzȈȒ șȓȍȌțȍȚ Ȑȏ ȔȈȚȍȘȐȈȓȖȊ ȌȍȓȈ ȗȘȍȌȔȍȚȖȔ ȏȈȧȊȓȍȕȕȖȋȖ ȐșȒȈ ȧȊȓȧȍȚșȧ ȚȘȍȉȖȊȈȕȐȍ Ȗ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȕȐȐ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘȈ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȖȚ 1 ȔȍȎȌț ǶǨǶ ǿȍȓȕȖ ǪȍȘȠȐȕșȒȈȧ ǴǺǹ ȏȈȐȔȖȌȈȊȍȞ Ȑ ǹǷDz ǩȈȋȈȕȈ ȏȈȍȔȡȐȒ ȔȕȐȔȖȑ șȌȍȓȒȖȑ ȕȍȏȈȒȓȦȟȍȕȕȣȔ ȊȊȐȌț ȍȋȖ ȉȍȏȌȍȕȍȎȕȖșȚȐ ǷȖ țșȓȖȊȐȧȔ ȌȈȕȕȖȋȖ ȌȖȋȖȊȖȘȈ ȏȈȑȔȈ ȏȈȐȔȖȌȈȊȍȞ ȗȍȘȍȌȈȍȚ Ȋ șȖȉșȚȊȍȕȕȖșȚȤ ȏȈȍȔȡȐȒț ȊȍȡȐ ȖȗȘȍȌȍȓȍȕȕȣȍ ȘȖȌȖȊȣȔȐ ȗȘȐȏȕȈȒȈȔȐ Ȉ ȏȈȍȔȡȐȒ ȖȉȧȏțȍȚșȧ ȗȘȐȕȧȚȤ Ȑ ȊȖȏȊȘȈȚȐȚȤ Ȋ șȘȖȒ ȌȖ ȊȍȡȐ ȚȖȋȖ Ȏȍ ȘȖȌȈ ȒȈȟȍșȚȊȈ Ȑ ȒȖȓȐȟȍșȚȊȈ KWWS EDVH FRQVXOWDQW UX FRQV VWDWLF B B B GRFIUDPHVLPSOHBSULQW KWP"EDVH $39 Q PRGH SDUDV & & SDJH UHY