How long was the Macedonian sarissa? - Duncan B. Campbell

Page 1

~•

• • • • • •• •

An obscure debate over a very long spear

HOW LONG W\S HE MACEIDNIAN SARLSSA? Nineteenth-century historians were fascinated by the Macedonian phalanx and its characteristic weapon, the sarissa. However, some were convinced that reports of the sarissa's extreme length must be incorrect, while others struggled to reconcile the testimony of different ancient writers and even resorted to altering the original texts. looking back over a century-and-a-half of scholarship, we can see how the debate was derailed by misinformation and finally brought back on track by the discovery of an unexpected source. By Duncan B Campbell

I

n 1854, the eminent hi stori an George Grote wa s hard at work on the twelfth and fi nal vo lume of hi s amb iti ous His­ tory of Greece, in w hi ch he ca rri ed the story from the access ion of Al exa nder the G l'eat in 336 BC down to th e death of Agatho cles in 288 BC Natu l'all y, military affairs bu lked large, and so, in order to

present the latest wisdom on the su bject,

Grote consulted the recently publi shed

Geschichte des griechischen Kriegswesens by the Germ an military historian s W ilhelm Rustow and Hermann Koc hl y, On e topi c req uiri ng spec ial ex plan a­ ti on was the long pike know n as the sa ris­ sa, w hich wa s the hallmark of the M acedo­ ni an p halanx, (Purists consider sarisa to be the correct for m, but th e G reeks used both versi on s, and the spellin g with a double's' has passed into co mm on En gl ish usage,) Grote assured hi s read ers that the len gth

48

Ancient Warfare VIII-3

of thi s new weapo n was "so prodi gious and so unw ieldy, th at we sho uld ha rdly be lieve it, if it did not co me attested by the distinct asse rtion of an histori an li ke Poly­ b iu s" , When th e vo lume duly appea red in 1856, he deci ded th at th e chapter on 'The As iatic Campa igns of Al exa nder' should be fo llowed by a short appendi x 'O n the length of the M acedoni an sa rissa or pi ke', exp la ining the matter to hi s readers,

The ancient writers According to Ru stow and Koch ly, th e Mac­ edonian sa rissa was "1 4-16 feet in length", but Grote's read ing of the anc ient sou rces convin ced him th at "(the sarissa) of the in­ fantry in pha lan x was not less tha n 21 feet lon g" , How had suc h a di screpa ncy ari sen? In fact, the Germ an histori ans had reached th eir con clusion by convolu ted rea­ soning, First, they con ceded that "all reports, w ith the single exception of Arrian's in the Taktika, give the length of the Macedoni an sari ssa as 16 cubits or 24 feet", Thi s is not


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.