SP's Aviation July 2012

`100.00 (India-based buyer only)

Aviation SP’s

An SP Guide Publication

News Flies. We Gather Intelligence. Every Month. From India.

www.spsaviation.net

Boeing & Embraer join hands for

KC-390 story on page 24

- Farnborough -

RNI NUMBER: DELENG/2008/24199

Some of Key Highlights - SP's Exclusives

 Business

July • 2012

Aviation: Seat Configurations  Regional Aviation: Optimum Locations in India  ISRO: An Introspection  IAF's PGM Capability plus much more...

CFM. always exCeeding our proMises.

CFM* customers are used to pleasant surprises. Our history proves we not only keep our word, we deliver way beyond it.

Building our customers’ trust. Building our customers’ profits. With better than expected technology upgrades, engine reliability, maintenance cost reduction, time on wing performance and strong asset values. The list is nearly as long as the life of one of our engines. Visit www.cfm56.com and see why, when we make promises, they don’t melt away.

CFM, CFM56 and the CFM logo are all trademarks of CFM International, a 50/50 joint company of Snecma (Safran Group) and GE.

*

Aviation SP’s

Table of Contents

An SP Guide Publication

News Flies. We Gather Intelligence. Every Month. From India.

Issue 7 • 2012

The Boeing C-17 Globemaster III airlifter, which is likely to be delivered to the Indian Air Force by next year,will be on flying display at the Farnborough Air Show

First

4

Autonomous Flight

SP’s ExclusiveS

7

8

9

IUSAV India’s Stealthy Aircraft AMCA Indigenous Development LCH On Sea-level Trials

Civil

10 Business Aviation

Seat Matrix

lead story Spirits high Farnborough 2012 will serve as a platform for about 1,400 exhibitors from the aerospace, defence, space and security sectors from across the world showcasing their latest technologies

• `100.00 (INDIA-BASED BUYER ONLY)

22

Military

18

20

Laser-Guided Bombs Building LGB Capability Technology The Wonder Radar

News Flies. We Gather Intelligence. Every Month. From India.

Boeing & Embraer join hands for

KC-390 STORY ON PAGE 24

- FARNBOROUGH -

SOME OF KEY HIGHLIGHTS - SP'S EXCLUSIVES

RNI NUMBER: DELENG/2008/24199

Regional Aviation Green Light for Growth

AN SP GUIDE PUBLICATION

www.spsaviation.net

Ergonomics to the Fore

15

Aviation SP’s



JULY • 2012

 Business Aviation: Seat Configurations Regional Aviation: Optimum Locations in India  ISRO: An Introspection  IAF's PGM Capability plus much more...

SP's Aviation Cover 07-12.indd 1

04/07/12 12:32 PM

Cover Photo: Boeing and Embraer have announced an agreement to collaborate on marketing and developing technologies for the Embraer’s transport aircraft KC-390.

Image By: Embraer

Space

31

Exploration Year of Reckoning

Seminar

33

AEW&C For Strategic Independence

Regular Departments

3 5

A Word from Editor

NewsWithViews

– 49 per cent FDI a Far Cry – China’s Successful Shenzhou-9 Spacecraft

35 Hall of Fame

Geoffrey de Havilland (1882-1965) 36 40

NewsDigest LastWord Survival in Doubt

Next Issue: Business Aviation and Environment

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 1

Table of Contents PLUS...

Publisher And Editor-in-Chief Jayant Baranwal Assistant Group editor R. Chandrakanth Senior Visiting Editor Air Marshal (Retd) V.K. Bhatia

design Holistic Directions: Jayant Baranwal Senior Art Director: Anoop Kamath Designers: Vimlesh Kumar Yadav, Sonu Singh Bisht Research Assistant: Graphics Survi Massey DIRECTOR SALES & MARKETING Neetu Dhulia

Senior Technical Group EditorS Air Marshal (Retd) B.K. Pandey

09

Lt General (Retd) Naresh Chand Light Combat Helicopter Sea Trials

Senior Copy editor & Correspondent Sucheta Das Mohapatra Contributors India Air Marshal (Retd) N. Menon Group Captain (Retd) A.K. Sachdev Group Captain (Retd) Joseph Noronha Europe Alan Peaford

10

Business Aviation: Seat Matrix

USA & Canada LeRoy Cook Chairman & Managing Director Jayant Baranwal Planning & Business Development Executive Vice President: Rohit Goel ADMIN & COORDINATION Bharti Sharma Owned, published and printed by

15

Regional Aviation: Green Light for Growth

Jayant Baranwal, printed at Kala Jyothi Process Pvt Ltd and published at A-133, Arjun Nagar (Opposite Defence Colony), New Delhi 110 003, India. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, photocopying, recording, electronic, or

www.spguidepublications.com

2 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

otherwise without prior written permission of the Publishers.

SALES & MARKETING General Manager Sales: Rajeev Chugh SP’s websites Sr Web Developer: Shailendra Prakash Ashish Web Developer: Ugrashen Vishwakarma © SP Guide Publications, 2012 Annual Subscription Inland: Rs 1200 • Foreign: US$ 320 Email: subscribe@spguidepublications.com LETTER TO EDITOR editor@spsaviation.net expert@spsaviation.net FOR Advertising details, contact: guidepub@vsnl.com neetu@spguidepublications.com rajeev.chugh@spguidepublications.com SP GUIDE PUBLICATIONS PVT LTD A-133 Arjun Nagar, (Opposite Defence Colony) New Delhi 110 003, India.

Tel: +91 (11) 24644693, 24644763, 24620130 Fax: +91 (11) 24647093 Email: guidepub@vsnl.com Representative Office BENGALURU, INDIA 534, Jal Vayu Vihar Kammanhalli Main Road Bengaluru 560043, India.

Tel: +91 (80) 23682534 MOSCOW, RUSSIA LAGUK Co., Ltd., (Yuri Laskin) Krasnokholmskaya, Nab., 11/15, app. 132, Moscow 115172, Russia.

Tel: +7 (495) 911 2762 Fax: +7 (495) 912 1260

www.spsaviation.net

A Word from Editor

Even though labeled to be a fully Indian effort, it is understood that the DRDO has held discussions with EADS, Saab, Dassault and BAE Systems for possible technological partnerships for the IUSAV programme

T

he aviation world is once again all set to congregate in the UK for the July 9-15 ‘Farnborough 2012’ Air Show. Despite the dark clouds of gloom hovering over the European economy, the organisers are upbeat about the show’s outcome. Their high spirits are not misplaced as Farnborough is ready to serve as a platform for over 1,400 exhibiters from the aerospace, defence, space and security sectors from across the world to showcase and demonstrate aircraft, equipment and related technologies.

For the first time, visitors to Farnborough will be able to witness the future of space travel with Virgin Galactic – the world’s first ‘Spaceline’ – showcasing ‘Space Ship Two’ that will offer passengers the opportunity to experience suborbital space travel including weightlessness.

Keeping in view the success of the indoor flying area for unmanned aerial systems (UAS) created for the first time in 2010; the organisers have decided not only to have a central location to showcase the UAS but will also provide a purposebuilt net for flying and ground systems’ demonstrations.

Inspired by metamorphic vision of the Indian Air Force (IAF), to transform itself into a first-class strategic force with global reach and effect, the DRDO has been nudged into undertaking a slew of indigenous development programmes.

On the heels of the Tejas project which has concurrently moved from the development phase to limited series production (LSP), the DRDO has embarked upon the design and development of the next generation fighter. In an exclusive report, SP’s Special Correspondent covers the advanced medium combat aircraft (AMCA) programme—a stealthy twinengine strike fighter that is intended to be an Indian take on the US F-22 Raptor. On the rotary-wing front, India’s light combat helicopter (LCH) is in the midst of sea-trials off India’s East Coast just outside Chennai.

It is slowly becoming clear as to what India’s hush-hush stealth unmanned combat air vehicle would look like. The Indian Unmanned Strike Air Vehicle (IUSAV) under preliminary definition and development by the Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) is intended as a stealthy autonomous strike aircraft. But even though labeled to be a fully Indian effort, it is understood that the DRDO has held discussions

with the likes of EADS, Saab, Dassault and BAE Systems for possible technological partnerships.

On space exploration, however, while China demonstrated its prowess by successfully launching and recovering a manned docking mission, India’s space programme appears to have been halted in its tracks because of the twin failures of GSLV launches. While ISRO claims to have unraveled the cause of the back-to-back failures, it must make the GSLV Mk II operational as quickly as possible and move onto the GSLV Mk III to keep its tryst for a 2016 or so manned space mission.

The bottom line in a business jet purchase remains on how well it does on ergonomics. This edition carries a wellresearched article on business jet seat matrix, which speaks of what high-net-worth individuals are looking for. Then there is also an article on regional aviation which states how judiciously chosen regional airports can translate to increased revenue since connectivity itself generates demand.

Do join us in the cooler climes of Farnborough for a scintillating air show.

In the meantime, Happy Reading.

Jayant Baranwal

Publisher & Editor-in-Chief Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 3

First

F Au t o n o m o u s

Flight

Photograph: Boeing

B

oeing’s Phantom Eye unmanned airborne system (UAS) has completed its first autonomous flight at NASA’s Dryden Flight Research Center at Edwards Air Force Base, California.

The 28-minute flight began at 6:22 a.m. as the liquidhydrogen powered aircraft lifted off its launch cart. Phantom Eye climbed to an altitude of 4,080 feet and reached a cruising speed of 62 knots. After touching down, the vehicle sustained some damage when the landing gear dug into the lakebed and broke.

“This day ushers in a new era of persistent intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (ISR) where an unmanned aircraft will remain on station for days at a time providing critical information and services,” said Darryl Davis, President, Boeing Phantom Works. “This flight puts Boeing on a path to accomplish another aerospace first—the capability of four days of unrefueled, autonomous flight.”

Phantom Eye is the latest in a series of Boeing-funded 4 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

Boeing Phantom is designed to remain airborne for up to four days while reaching altitudes of 65,000 feet rapid prototyping programmes, which include Phantom Ray, Echo Ranger, ScanEagle Compressed Carriage, and an associated Common Open Mission Management Command and Control (COMC2) system capable of managing all of the company’s unmanned assets. The flight took place following a series of taxi tests in April that validated ground guidance, navigation and control, mission planning, pilot interface and operational procedures.

Phantom Eye’s innovative and environmentally responsible liquid-hydrogen propulsion system will allow the aircraft to stay on station for up to four days while providing persistent monitoring over large areas at a ceiling of up to 65,000 feet, creating only water as a by-product. The demonstrator, with its 150-foot wingspan, is capable of carrying a 450-pound payload. SP For Videos visit: www.spsaviation.net www.spsaviation.net

NewsWithViews

49 per cent FDI a far cry

There seems to be little enthusiasm among international airlines over the government’s plan to allow them to pick 49 per cent stake in their Indian counterparts. In spite of a high and sustained growth in passenger traffic, the financial strength of almost all Indian airlines is severely affected leading foreign carriers to be disinclined to invest at the moment. Top aviation officials who met at the 68th annual meet of the International Air Transport Association (IATA) in Beijing mid-June, spoke about strict regulations, lack of reforms and the Indian Government backing Air India as factors which came in the way of the competition.

VIEWS

Photograph: SP guide Pubns

T

he Indian Government’s much talked about and long-awaited but yet to be announced decision to allow foreign direct investment (FDI) by foreign airlines in the Indian air carriers was indeed discussed at length during the recently held International Air Transport Association’s 68th annual meet in Beijing. It may be recalled that a proposal to allow foreign carriers to own up to 49 per cent in Indian airline companies has been pending for months now for consideration by the Indian Cabinet because of political opposition. But even if the political consensus came through allowing the Indian Government to tweak the policy as planned, there seems to be no guarantee that it would open the floodgates for foreign airlines rushing in to invest in the Indian carriers. Views expressed by the leaders/CEOs of international carriers during the Beijing conference amply proved the point. Their collective views were brought out comprehensively

by Tim Clark, President Emirates during a recent interview to an Indian newspaper. “India’s proposed policy to allow global airlines to acquire equity stakes in domestic airlines is rational as these carriers have much to offer in terms of expertise, connectivity and convenience. However, a change in the FDI policy alone will not suffice to attract investments. Investors in addition would need the comfort of a ‘ring fence’. Why would a foreign airline infuse capital in a cashstrapped Indian airline company like Kingfisher or Air India unless its investment is protected?” According to Clark, the Indian Government should offer foreign airlines some incentives; a clean balance sheet, no debts, firewalls against interference and freedom to procure assets in a transparent way.

From the above, it is abundantly clear that much more would have to be done by the Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) to attract FDI infusion into the Indian civil aviation market, if it is really serious to help domestic airlines which are struggling hard to stay afloat amidst worsening financial woes. Kingfish-

er and Air India are already on the brink, but all other airlines barring perhaps the low-cost IndiGo are running in the red. But poor management cannot be the sole reason for their financial ill-health as it is being attributed by some aviation pundits and especially the ones belonging to the government circles. Actually, much of the problem has been created by the government itself, which by taking fragmented and at times irrational decisions has literally axed the growth of what was emerging as one of the fastest growing sectors in the country.

At the heart of the problem lies the skewed aviation turbine fuel (ATF) pricing policy of the government. India’s ATF market is afflicted by anti-competitive practices largely due to the oligopolistic environment created by the government-owned companies which supply it to the domestic airlines; that too in a manner which is anything but transparent. For example domestic airlines are paying at least 50 per cent more for the ATF in India compared with places like Singapore and Sharjah. In addition, a differential policy is followed for jet fuel whereby it costs less for international flights than domestic flights. What could possibly be the reason for this inexplicable disparity, unless it has something to do with the government mindset that anybody who flies within India has to be from a rich background and therefore can be discriminately taxed.

But the ATF pricing policy is not the only problem, the ailing civil aviation sector needs a slew of policy reforms if it has to attract the FDI it is seeking. As a top honcho of a foreign airline group remarked, “India is an attractive destination for us to serve, but I am not sure if India will be an attractive destination for us to invest in.”

Lastly, if India continues to pitch it’s state-owned, fullysubsidised ‘White Elephant’ Air India and private carriers to slug it out against one another, there is little chance of foreign airlines risking their investments in a highly uneven playing field. SP —Air Marshal (Retd) V.K. Bhatia Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 5

NewsWithViews

China’s Successful Shenzhou-9 spacecraft

On June 16, 2012, China successfully launched the Shenzhou-9 spacecraft, which carried a crew of three, including the country’s first female astronaut Liu Yang. The astronauts completed the country’s first manned docking mission, an important step in China’s ambitious plan to build a space station by 2020. The successful launch, from a remote desert in western China, powered by a Long March 2F rocket, was televised live from the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Centre in the Gobi Desert. The crew came back on June 29, after docking with the orbiting Tiangong-1 space lab module­—launched earlier in September 2011—to conduct experiments and live for a time in the space module.

VIEWS

Photograph: Cast

I

n the year 1999, the space agency of the People’s Republic of China known as the China National Space Administration (CNSA), initiated its three-phase manned space programme described as Project 921.

The project included the launching of manned spacecraft, establishment of a space station and eventually a mission to land a Chinese astronaut on the moon. Compared with the 400-tonne International Space Station or even the smaller Russian Mir or the US Skylab, China’s Tiangong 1 (Heavenly Palace) space lab module currently in orbit at an altitude of 343 km above the surface of the earth, is relatively small, weighing only 8.5 tonnes. Building a space station larger than Heavenly Palace and a more permanent one will be the third and last phase of Project 921, which is scheduled to be completed by 2020. This is expected to be followed by the manned lunar mission.

The notable milestones in China’s manned space programme so far have been sending its first man into space in 2003, a space walk by a Chinese astronaut in 2008 and now a manned docking mission with the orbiting space station Heavenly Palace. A remote controlled docking of the Shenzhou 8 with the Tiangong 1 orbital module was achieved in November last year. However, what made the fourth manned mission on June 16 of the Shenzhou-9 spacecraft particularly significant is the fact that the crew of three included China’s first female astronaut and the 57th in the world, a 33-year-old Chinese air force pilot named Liu Yang, mother of one. Liu’s mission made China the third country after Russia and the US to send a woman into space. The two male astronauts accompanying Liu Yang on the mission were Liu Wang and the Mission Commander Jing Haipeng. This two-week manned mission comes nearly four years after the last successful mission in September 2008. While by Western yardsticks, this mission may appear elementary and in technical terms a 6 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

repeat of docking capability already demonstrated, it certainly reflects the level of aggressive commitment to Project 921, overall synergy in the Chinese space programme and the pace at which it is moving ahead. It is only a matter of time before China’s space endeavours will match or even surpass those of the other leading space powers. It would be reasonable to assume that China’s space ambitions will not end with the lunar mission but will extend to exploration of deep space and possibly manned missions to Mars and beyond. In the immediate future, several more docking missions however, will be required to be undertaken by the CNSA to complete the construction of the space station as well as for its sustained manning. Reports indicate that docking was successfully completed in less than eight minutes.

As against China’s impressive forward march in its space programme, the proposal by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) for manned space flight appears to have lost steam. Formally mooted in 2006, despite periodical rhetoric, there appears to have been no significant progress on this front in the last six years. It is understood that the Indian manned space flight programme has actually not progressed beyond the initial studies for the identification of challenges and the preparation of cost estimates. The lack of progress is partly attributable to the failures of India’s geosynchronous space launch vehicles (GSLV), one fitted with an indigenously developed cryogenic engine and another with a Russian engine. Initially envisaged for 2016, it appears unlikely that ISRO would be able to get its act together to send a man into space even by 2020. In fact, given the track record of ISRO especially in the last decade, an Indian lunar mission does not appear to be in the realm of possibility in a respectable time frame. SP —Air Marshal (Retd) B.K. Pandey www.spsaviation.net

SP’s Exclusive IUSAV

India’s Stealthy Aircraft The DRDO has held discussions at various levels with Saab, EADS, Dassault and BAE Systems for possible technological partnerships on the IUSAV

I

t is finally clear what India’s hush-hush stealth unmanned combat aerial vehicle (UCAV) will look like, with images emerging from the project’s design and definition stage finally providing a definite picture. The Indian unmanned strike air vehicle (IUSAV), under preliminary definition and development by the Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) in Bangalore under the stewardship of aeronautical scientist and project Director Dr Biju Uthup, is intended as a stealthy autonomous bomber aircraft, incorporating flying wing aerodynamics, low observable features, long endurance capabilities, and the ability to deploy precision guided weapons over enemy territory.

Several different laboratories are currently engaged in various sub-systems that will go into the IUSAV, which the

Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) intends to begin flight testing by 2015-16, an ambitious target by current standards. The project has an initial investment of `100 crore, but with additional sanctions, the amount could go up to a total of $1.5 billion (`8,250 crore) overall.

At this stage, the primary user of the intended platform, the Indian Air Force, has insisted that the secret project be a fully Indian effort. However, it is understood that the DRDO has held discussions at various levels with Saab, EADS, Dassault and BAE Systems for possible technological partnerships on the IUSAV. Earlier this year, Defence Minister A.K. Antony informed Parliament that efforts were on to modify the Kaveri jet engine for possible use on the IUSAV. SP —By SP’s Special Correspondent Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 7

SP’s Exclusive AMCA

Indigenous Development The AMCA will be powered by 2 x 90KN engines with vectored nozzles— likely to be the new GTRE-Snecma engine under development

W

ith so much attention paid to India’s light combat aircraft (LCA) Tejas and the IndoRussian fifth generation fighter aircraft (FGFA – but officially designated prospective multi-role fighter or PMF) programme, it is important to remember that the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) is also designing and developing India’s own next generation medium fighter, the advanced medium combat aircraft (AMCA), a stealthy twin-engined strike fighter that is intended to be an Indian take on the F-22 Raptor.

The computer design images from the Advanced Projects & Technologies (AP&T) Directorate of India’s Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) provide valuable impressions on the stealth design elements that are known to be going into India’s AMCA. Serpentine air intakes (with minimum flow distortion and robust pressure recovery) and internal weapons bays, depicted in the images above, are some of the most critical nose-on low observability design elements going into the programme.

8 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

As part of the multidisciplinary design optimisation (MDO) currently on for the AMCA—a wind tunnel model of which was first publicly displayed at Aero India 2009— that design-based stealth features will include further optimised airframe shaping, edge matching, body conforming antennae and a low IR signature through nozzle design, engine bay cooling and work on reduced exhaust temperature.

Radar absorbent materials and paints, special coatings for polycarbonate canopy and precision manufacturing will all be part of the effort to make the AMCA India’s first stealth airplane.

With aerodynamic design optimisation near complete, the AMCA’s broad specifications are final.

The aircraft will have a weight of 16-18 tonnes (with two-tonnes of internal weapons and four-tonnes of internal fuel with a combat ceiling of 15 km), max speed of 1.8 Mach at 11 km. The AMCA will be powered by 2 x 90KN engines with vectored nozzles—likely to be the new GTRE-Snecma engine under development. SP ­—By SP’s Special Correspondent www.spsaviation.net

SP’s Exclusive LCH

On sea-level trials The LCH, yet to be given a formal name like the Tejas or Sitara, will, later this year, be put through cold and hot weather trials

Photographs: HAL

I

ndia’s light combat helicopter (LCH) is off to a successful start to sea-trials. The second prototype of the programme is now three days into a complex list of testpoints to be completed over 10 days on the East Coast just outside Chennai. The LCH prototype is being filmed and recorded by an IAF Mi-8 from Yelahanka Air Force Station.

The pilots and test team are currently extremely pleased with the helicopter’s handling and manoeuvrability at sea level, since for the last three years, both prototypes have been confined to altitudes of 3,000 metres and above at Bangalore.

Sources involved with the trials said, “The helicopter is maturing well and promises to be a very good platform once ready. We are putting it through the necessary paces as required by the IAF and by us to bring the platform up to maturity.” The LCH, yet to be given a formal name like the Tejas or Sitara, will, later this year, be put through cold and hot weather trials, following which its first crucial weapons trials will begin. The helicopter is expected to deploy rocket pods, the HELINA air-launched anti-armour missile and the MBDA Mistral air-to-air missile initially, but could be configured for other munitions as well. SP —By SP’s Special Correspondent Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 9

Civil Business Aviation

Large & Heavy: Boeing Business Jet interiors (above)

Seat Matrix Ergonomics to the fore The bottom line in a business jet purchase, however, remains how it does well on ergonomics

Photograph: Boeing

U

nless one is traveltheir executives to accomplish more,

By R. Chandrakanth ling business or first etc. A study by the National Business class, seats in some airAviation Association (NBAA) revealed lines can be quite uncomthat small and mid-size companies that fortable with very little use private jets produce a 219 per cent elbow room or leg space. higher earnings growth rate than those Comfort in the skies is key and without that strictly fly commercial.

Having said that, the question that many corporate doubt business aviation promises to provide that. On this count, among other advantages, business aviation scores houses and also high-net-worth individuals ask themselves, before making a purchase of such costly machines, is ‘what over airlines.

No wonder the corporate world has realised the plus seat configuration’ to go for? As per the individuals and the points of business aviation and are propping up the sectors corporates’ requirements, there are five segments to choose growth. Corporate houses, entrepreneurs, celebrities and from—very light jets (example Cessna Citation Mustang: 4-5 high-net-worth individuals (HNWIs) have understood the passengers); light jets (Hawker 400: 7-9 passengers); midvalue of business aircraft, delivering many times over their size jets (Embraer Legacy 500 up to 12 passengers); super investment. Teal forecasts deliveries of 10,249 traditional mid-size jets (Gulfstream IV: 14-19 passengers); and large business jets worth about $250 billion (`13,75,000 crore) and heavy jets (Boeing Business Jets: 8 to 50 passengers). between 2012-21. Teal’s forecast in such a corporate-driven More seats, more space, more luxury environment hardly comes as a surprise.

The greatest factors driving growth of business aviation The heavy and large cabin jets are Boeing Business Jets, have been that corporate are able to ‘manage effectively’, get Airbus Corporate Jets, Embraer’s Lineage 1000 and Das10 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

www.spsaviation.net

Civil Business Aviation

Highpoints: Embraer Legacy 600’s versatile layout

sault Falcon 7X, which can seat from eight to 50 passengers ultra comfortably.

BBJ’s 807 sft of cabin space

Take the Boeing Business Jet (737 family) which has an extra large cabin measuring 807 square feet, well beyond any other private jet. The cabin can be configured almost any way desired by the customer, but most configurations divide the cabin into four compartments comprising a board room, a lounge, a VIP bedroom, a business office, and two lavatories with showers. Alternate suggested configurations include an office and an exercise room, high-density seating for 60 passengers or 24 extra-large seats for sleeping.

offers a selection of different floor plans, organised in three lounges from 12 to 16 seats. The seats are ergonomically adjustable, while the cabin has a full-length wardrobe, standup lavatory, full-size galley and 28 large windows to give the passenger comfort, relaxation and spectacular views.

Super mid-size that’s super

Super mid-size jets are the quick way to get there in luxury.

Capable of high altitude, speed and the ultimate in range, these aircraft also offer wide body comfort. The examples of this segment include Dassault Falcon 900DX, the Cessna Citation X, Embraer’s Legacy 600 and the Hawker 4000.

Seats with full berthing capability

Photograph: Embraer

ACJ pegs on freedom of movement

The Airbus ACJ319, the newest in the Comlux fleet, is certified to carry 19 passengers, and features lounge areas, club seating and two private rooms that convert to bedrooms, one of which has an en suite bathroom. Over 15 Airbus corporate jets are offered for VVIP charter worldwide by almost 15 companies highlighting their popular appeal. The ACJ family can be outfitted as per the customers configuration needs.

Handsomely-proportioned suite

Dassault’s Falcon 7X is classified as a large cabin business jet as the cabin is high, wide and has a handsomely-proportioned executive suite, featuring three spacious areas. It

Representing this category is Embraer’s Legacy 600 which has three spacious cabin zones, offering outstanding cabin comfort and productivity. The seats can be fully reclined, so also the divan can be converted into a berth, thanks to its superior cabin volume.

The highpoint of Legacy 600 is that it throws up multiple interior configurations. With a versatile layout, the business jet can accommodate up to 14 passengers in three distinct cabin zones, besides having a conference table area. The third private zone is configurable with two divans.

Living environment

The Gulfstream G650 offers the longest, widest, tallest, most Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 11

Civil Business Aviation

Superb Interiors: G650’s comfort zone

comfortable cabin in its class, a living environment designed to provide maximum comfort, safety and productivity on those 7,000 nm (12,964 km) trips to distant world capitals.

Gulfstream G650 has increased length of the fuselage by 24 inches (61 cm), the width by 14 inches (36 cm) and the height by three inches (8 cm) over the Gulfstream G550. For enhanced productivity, Gulfstream increased the length of the living area in the cabin to improve the seat incline and provide more legroom. The additional cabin width offers wider seats, more aisle space and a conference grouping with three-across seating for meetings or meals accommodating up to six people. It gives a larger stateroom option that includes a single seat, a divan that berths into a double bed, a large, 26-inch (66 cm) pop-up LCD monitor and two windows on each side, resulting in an airy, well-lit, productive or restful cabin environment.

Photograph: Gulfstream

Adding space: Global 7000 and 8000

Almost in response to the G650, Bombardier has an offering with more range and fuel efficiency. The Global 7000 is stretched by eleven feet three inches, and the 8000 is stretched by two feet three inches. Considering the range, it is assumed that it can take 10 passengers and four crew on the 7000, and eight passengers and four crew on the 8000.

Citation Sovereign (Cessna); Falcon50 (Dassault); Legacy 450 and 500 (Embraer); Gulfstream 150 and Gulfstream 250; Hawker 750; 850XP and 900XP. Long-legged Learjet

Representative of this segment, Learjet 85, has a cabin that is larger than the 60XR’s almost by one-third. Bombardier claims the 85 will have 19 per cent more cabin volume than its closest competitor. The cabin is 24 feet, nine inches long; six feet, one inch wide; and six feet tall, yielding 665 cu ft of passenger space and 130 cu ft of luggage stowage, including three large cabin closets with a combined 30 cu ft of storage.

Bombardier offers several different configurations, including eight single executive seats in a double-club layout or six single seats and a three-place divan. The single seats are pitched at 30 inches and recline into full-berthing positions. The divan and the berthing seats reflect the 85’s 3,000-nm transcontinental/transatlantic design range (four passengers). This longer-legged Learjet also features a full galley and an aft cabin lavatory. Like several other contemporary cabin designs, the 85 will feature larger passenger cabin windows, 12 by 16 inches each, and more monolithic, streamlined headliners and sidewalls.

Legacy, designed for comfort

Mid-size, more than a go-between

These aircraft are suitable for longer range travel such as transcontinental flights and for travel with larger passenger capacity requirements. The aircraft include Learjet 60XR, Learjet 85 (Bombardier); Citation Columbus, Citation XLS, 12 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

In the mid-size segment, the options are plenty. Embraer Legacy 450 and 500 fit the bill. The 500’s fuselage is around four and half feet longer than the 450, while both will have a six-foot stand-up cabin with a flat floor, a fully equipped galley and an externally serviced aft lavatory. The 500 is being www.spsaviation.net

DNA. It Matters.

Examine each and every aspect of a Falcon and you’ll find genius at work.

But what makes a Falcon a Falcon is in its genes. Lightweight strength and maneuverability, battle-tested in Mirage and Rafale jet fighters.

Unrivalled credentials for engineering excellence and technological innovation.

And generation after generation of business aircraft that consistently prove best in class for performance and efficiency. And for pure genius.

Find out why. Scan the code.

Or visit falconjet.com/dna

Civil Business Aviation

customised ergonomics: cessna’s citation X

designed to have a range of 2,800 nm as against the 450 with a range of 2,300 nm at long-range cruise.

The 500 can be configured to carry up to 12 passengers in a cabin that is near super mid-size, and there is a generous amount of baggage space: 150 cu ft (110 external). The cabin measures 26 feet, 10 inches long and 6 feet, 10 inches wide. Embraer announced that several different cabin layouts will be available. There is the option between a large forward galley opposite galley annex storage or a single, side-facing seat ideal for a cabin attendant. Or else there is a side-facing, two-place divan opposite a small refreshment centre. Behind that is the two-zone main cabin with seating for eight or nine more passengers.

Possible configurations include two club-four groupings of single seats or a forward club-four followed by a half-club with a three-place, berthing divan on either the right or left side.

Photograph: cessna

Light but versatile

Light jets have been a staple of the business aviation industry since the advent of Learjet 23 in the early 1960s. Light jets have a versatility that is difficult to find in a larger aircraft, one of which is landing at much smaller airfields.

These aircraft can take three to nine passengers comfortably. Some of the aircraft include the Learjet 45; Citation CJ2; Phenom 300; Grob; Hawker 400, etc.

Citation’s redesigned seats

Citation CJ2 has spacious cabin keeping passenger’s ultimate comfort in mind. It has redesigned seats for improved comfort and seating controls for more intuitive seat move14 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

ment. The cup holder area has been redesigned for more flexible storage to hold any variety of loose personal items, from beverage cups to smart phones. It can seat up to seven passengers.

Small is beautiful

Very light jets, also known as micro jets, are designed to cater to small community/town airports. Some of the aircraft in this category include the Citation Mustang and Cirrus Vision SF50. The Mustang can take four to five passengers with a crew of 1 or 2.

Market Trends

Market trends indicate that the very light jets have taken a beating in the global recession while there continues to be a healthy demand for super mid-size and large business jets, spurred by corporate houses looking to move a decent number of executives around. Similarly, HNWIs have gone in for the big jets, keeping in mind comfort, luxury and other accoutrements.

Forecast International reported in 2010 that the business jet industry had become a ‘tale of two markets’. In terms of sales and deliveries, large-cabin and long-range business jets were doing considerably better than light and mid-size segments. In general, the customer base for large cabin and long-range jets is composed of wealthy individuals and large corporations. Buyers of smaller jets tend to be less wealthy individuals, small or mid-size companies and fleet operators such as fractional providers, air taxi services and charter outfits. The bottom line in a business jet purchase, however, remains how it does well on ergonomics. SP www.spsaviation.net

Civil Regional Aviation await optimisation: bombardier’s q400 in spicejet livery

Green light for Growth Photograph: Anoop Kamath

Judiciously chosen regional airports can translate to increased revenue since connectivity itself generates demand.What is needed is a regional carrier bold enough to move in.

I

ndia’s airports handled an all-time high of true demand and vindicate the airlines’ marked preference 162.30 million passengers during the Financial Year for the inter-metro routes?

2011-12. That’s cause for celNot really. A survey of the thousands of ebration, dispelling some of the travellers who make their way to Delhi airgloom over the current state of port every day, for instance, would reveal the airline industry. However, where they come from and what their inBy Joseph Noronha, although the government-owned Airtended destinations are. It would probably Goa ports Authority of India (AAI) has 84 show that large numbers are not citizens of operational airports, the six metros the metro. They have been forced to travel by relatively slow and uncomfortable alone corner almost 70 per cent of the traffic. Do these numbers reflect the modes of surface transport from outlying Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 15

Civil Regional Aviation cities and towns that either lack an airport or do not have a convenient flight. Ignoring passengers who reside within 150 km of Delhi (since they can find their way to the airport anyway) a list could be made of the main cities of origin of the passengers. The process could be repeated at the other metros. This would provide a useful start point to identify cities where new regional services might be introduced or new airports built to expand the regional aviation industry. And a fast-growing industry it certainly is—according to AAI estimates, traffic from non-metro airports may surge to 45 per cent of the total within just five years.

Force or Freedom?

After a long period of inaction, the government seems to be in a hurry to kick-start regional aviation. There are stray signs that it may try to coerce airlines to operate feeder flights into the metros and large cities from nearby smaller towns and cities. Minister for Civil Aviation Ajit Singh reportedly said, “The idea is to have regional connectivity to the local hub. For example, there is a huge market around Delhi that would like to fly into the capital and then take connecting flights. We are planning to make it a must for airlines to have such flights.” SpiceJet, which earlier had only Boeing B737 jets, is the main carrier currently championing the cause of air connectivity to Tier-II and Tier-III cities, with the help of 15 Bombardier Q400 turboprop aircraft already being acquired. Jet Airways is doing its bit with 20 ATR 72-500 turboprops suitable for regional operations, although not

Annual Domestic Passenger Traffic Increase from 2010-11 to 2011-12 (per cent)

Annual Domestic Aircraft Movements Increase from 2010-11 to 2011-12 (per cent)

Ahmedabad 22.8 Ahmedabad Varanasi 36.5 Varanasi Goa 17.5 Goa Madurai 31.7 Bhubaneswar Trivandrum 43.1 Trivandrum Bhubaneswar 19.9 Indore Guwahati 15.5 Srinagar Indore 26.6 Visakhapatnam Srinagar 57.0 Delhi Visakhapatnam 34.6 Jammu Amritsar 66.6 Hyderabad Jammu 28.4 Vadodara Delhi 21.6 Pune Imphal 29.0 Raipur Pune 17.3 Lucknow Raipur 50.7 Ranchi Lucknow 34.3 Tiruchirapalli Ranchi 35.7 Bhopal Patna 21.8 Jaipur Bhopal 31.9 Amritsar Tiruchirapalli 42.3 Aurangabad 50.6 Chandigarh 24.3 Leh 42.7 Source: Airports Authority of India 16 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

22.7 30.6 17.9 24.5 42.6 16.5 35.2 30.7 20.9 15.5 23.3 16.5 25.4 39.1 34.0 43.4 125.2 21.2 31.6 19.0

all are deployed on strictly regional routes. But IndiGo and GoAir have all-Airbus A320-200 fleets which prevent them from using shorter regional runways while Air India and Kingfisher Airlines are pale shadows of their former selves.

How then will compulsion work?

The airlines are unsurprisingly reluctant to operate lowdensity routes that may take many years to break even. The much-reviled route dispersal guidelines (RDG) already oblige the major carriers to operate to the Northeast and Kashmir, but these have met with mixed results. Making additional unattractive destinations mandatory is not the answer. A far better proposal is the creation of an Essential Air Services Fund (EASF) for subsidising loss-making routes connecting smaller airports. The aim would be to auction commercially unviable routes that attract lower passenger numbers for three to five years till they reach some level of maturity. A transparent process of competitive bidding would culminate in the airline bidding for the lowest subsidy being offered the route. Basically, smaller cities would be serviced using smaller planes which do not pay parking and landing charges and lift aviation fuel at a discounted VAT of four per cent, compared to as much as 30 per cent for larger aircraft.

Taking the EASF scheme to its logical conclusion, the next step should be complete abolition of the RDGs—a hangover from India’s erstwhile command economy. This would help major airlines focus their energies on the main routes and encourage the emergence of small specialised regional airlines to operate regional, short-haul and feeder routes.

Any measure that increases passenger numbers and aircraft movements through the smaller airports will be welcomed

by AAI since only 14 of its airports are currently profitable.

AAI statistics (see table) can help to identify promising cities for the next spurt of regional growth. For instance, domestic passenger numbers at various airports for 2011-12 vis-à-vis 2010-11, showed a remarkable increase of over 50 per cent year-on-year at airports like Amritsar, Srinagar, Raipur and Aurangabad. Similarly, domestic aircraft movements surged over 40 per cent at Tiruchirapalli, Leh and Trivandrum.

Statecraft

A large number of institutional clearances are necessary for new airport projects and hence the active involvement and support of state governments is crucial. Beginning with planning and land acquisition in the case of Greenfield airports or expansion of existing ones, unless the state government is committed to the project, it is likely to flounder. State level facilitation measures include multi-modal connectivity, provision of utilities and other services, adequate security and reduced VAT on aviation fuel. Given the inescapable fixed costs and lower traffic, the financial viability of smaller airports is a matter of concern. The state governments, inevitably, need to extend financial support and incentives to the developers and airlines serving Tier-II and Tier-III cities, otherwise they are unlikely to take off.

In a commendable move aiming to operationalise 225 airports across the country by 2020, AAI recently asked state governments to prepare plans for airports, helipads and unused airstrips which they want to develop or upgrade. Depending on the traffic density forecast, connectivity with state capitals and possibility of generating non-aeronautical revenue by using surplus land, AAI would develop these airports. AAI www.spsaviation.net

Civil Regional Aviation

contributor to growth: JET AIRWAYS IS ONE OF THE MAJOR OPERATORS OF ATR

should also formulate a viable ‘no-frills’ airport model without compromising on the safety and security. State governments can help by promoting non-aeronautical revenue measures.

Many progressive state governments are getting into the act. In Madhya Pradesh, for instance, the government has offered to pay for three seats on an average for 16-seat turboprop aircraft flying between selected airports, including Bhopal, Gwalior, Indore and Khajuraho. Gujarat is following suit, offering to subsidise private players who are interested in providing regional air services in the state. It feels that diamond merchants would be keen on flights from Surat to Saurashtra areas. In Andhra Pradesh, on the request of the government and after evaluation by the AAI, Kurnool, Nellore, Ongole, Nizamabad and other cities have been assessed as feasible for regional airports. In Karnataka, airports at Gulbarga, Shimoga, Hassan, Bijapur and Bellary are in various stages of development. These and other projects where the state government is supportive should be fast-tracked. It is clear that regional operations have a long gestation period and require patience. SpiceJet, for instance, estimates it will take at least two years for its Q400 operations to turn profitable.

Photograph: ATR

Start Small

Gulbarga, Karnataka, will soon see the launch of a small but interesting experiment in regional aviation—an airport built

by Regional Airport Holdings International (RAHI). Since airports of this kind take under-20-seat aircraft and no commercial airline will be willing to operate in this space,

RAHI hopes to launch its own airline—Rahi Air—as a nonscheduled air transport service. However, from this small beginning, once traffic picks up, there could emerge a strong network of scheduled regional services. RAHI has set itself an ambitious target of developing 99 regional airports by 2025. It rightly believes that to be commercially successful a regional airport must be supported by an ecosystem—an industry cluster that helps the city attract investments and create value for the local community.

Another worthwhile impending small-scale initiative is the all-turboprop airline, Air Costa, which plans to start operations from hubs at Hyderabad and Chennai. It hopes to keep the operating costs low, an essential ingredient of viable regional aviation.

India’s aviation industry, despite its current status as the world’s ninth largest market, is currently passing through the most difficult phase in more than a decade. Soaring fuel costs, a weak rupee, high airport charges and increased service tax have all conspired to reduce margins and place the airlines in a precarious financial state. Yet, all the signs are that many non-metro cities will become future hubs of commercial activity with a growing need for air connectivity. Judiciously chosen regional airports can translate to increased revenue since connectivity itself generates demand. It’s a win-win situation because more opportunities will be created to earn non-aeronautical revenue and more jobs will become available to the local people. What is needed is a regional carrier bold enough to move in. SP Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 17

Military Laser-Guided Bombs

Building LGB Capability

The IAF still has a long way to go before it acquires desired level of ‘PGM’ capability, which incidentally could run into thousands for a two-front scenario June 30, 1999: The gleaming twin-seat Mirage 2000 had taken off from Adampur (its operational base) for a daylight mission against Pak intruders sitting on the Kargil heights.

Equipped with a recently acquired Israeli Litening pod and armed with an indigenous 1,000 lb dumb iron bomb but converted into a smart weapon with the help of a laser-guided bomb (LGB) strap-on kit, it climbed quickly to a height of 30,000 ft heading north. In less than 15 minutes, it was over Dras sector searching for its prey on top of the—by now famous—Tiger Hill. Strapped in the rear seat was the AOCin-C, Central Air Command, with the job of acquiring and engaging the target through the Litening pod after its location had been generally determined visually. The aircraft had plenty of fuel, so there was lots of time available for a proper search of the target, which even though a Battalion HQ of the enemy, was nothing more than a cluster of stone and rock Sangars, making them extremely difficult to spot from the air because of the way they so perfectly blended with the surrounding terrain. It was in the second pass, the intended target was picked up with clarity. The desperate enemy had by now launched a couple of Stinger missiles but couldn’t harm the aircraft as it was maintaining height out of the missile’s lethal envelope. In the third and the final pass, the target was acquired, designated, illuminated and engaged with the lone LGB. Bomb away, Cursor firmly on the target till impact, it was a direct hit, devastating the enemy position to smithereens.

Getting Ready: Indigenous 1000 lb bombs equipped with Paveway laser guidance kits being loaded on Mirage 2000

Photograph: Sp guide pubns

T

he Indian Air Force Indian Army deployed in and around

By Air Marshal (Retd) (IAF) used the laser-guided Dras, was effectively neutralised by the V.K. Bhatia bombs for the first time Mirage LGB attacks. So much so, it was during the 1999 Kargil War. a literal cakewalk for the Army when it However, it was decided set out to recapture it. not to use the highly exBut for the uninitiated, how does pensive Matra LGBs only a handful of a laser-guided bomb function? Simply which had been acquired from France put, a LGB is a guided bomb that uses as ‘Special’ precision guided munitions semi-active laser homing to strike a (PGMs) for the Mirage 2000 aircraft. Instead, as stated ear- designated target with greater accuracy than an unguided lier, the indigenous 1,000 lb iron bombs were transformed bomb. LGBs are one of the most common and widespread into smart weapons with the help of strap-on LGB kits. guided bombs, used by a large number of the world’s air These were most ingeniously mated to the Mirage airframe. forces. Laser-guided munitions use a laser designator to Innovatively modified, the combination of Litening pod and mark (illuminate) a target. The reflected laser light (sparthe indigenous LGBs proved to be a lethal mix against the kle) from the target is then detected by the seeker head of enemy. Tiger Hill, which was causing untold havoc to the the weapon, which sends signals to the weapon’s control

18 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

www.spsaviation.net

Photographs Left to right: Sp guide pubns, Lockheed Martin

Military Laser-Guided Bombs surfaces to guide it towards the designated point. Laser-guided bombs are generally unpowered, using small fins to glide towards their targets.

Most laser-guided bombs are produced in the form of strapon kits: seeker heads, and steering fins that can be attached to a standard general-purpose bomb or penetration bomb. Such kits are modular, allowing relatively easy upgrades, and are considerably cheaper than purpose-built weapons.

Laser-guided weapons were first developed in the United States in the early 1960s and used operationally in Vietnam, starting in 1968. Although there were a variety of technical and operational problems, the results were generally positive. LGBs proved to offer a much higher degree of accuracy than unguided weapons but without the expense, complexity and limitations of guided air-to-ground missiles. The LGB proved particularly effective against difficult fixed targets like bridges, which previously had required huge loads of ‘dumb’ ordnance to destroy.

The most dramatic example of successful LGB attacks in Vietnam War was against the Thanh Hoa Bridge, 110 km south of Hanoi, a critical crossing point over the Red River.

Starting in 1965, US pilots had flown 871 sorties against it, losing 11 planes without managing to put it out of commission. In 1972, the Dragon’s Jaw bridge was attacked with Paveway bombs and 14 jets managed to do what the previous 871 had not: drop the span, and cut a critical North Vietnamese supply artery.

While LGBs are highly accurate under ideal conditions, they present several challenges for successful use. The first problem is target designation. To ensure accurate guidance, the target must be illuminated by a laser designator and the pilot must deliver the weapon within the “weapon basket” (the zone in which the weapon seeker can observe the laser target marker and the weapon has sufficient energy to guide to the target). Laser guided bombs can be launched without the laser designator turned on, in which case, it will follow a ballistic path, until such time as the seeker picks up the reflected laser signal. This allows the aircraft to deliver an LGB using techniques such as loft or toss bombing. However, if the designator is turned off and the laser spot moved, the laser signal is blocked (for example by cloud or smoke), the weapon’s accuracy will be greatly reduced. A particular problem with laser designation can be path length under certain environmental conditions. Laser designators operate in the infrared wavebands and attenuation of the laser signal by the moisture content of the atmosphere can reduce the signal strength below the threshold of the seeker. Laser designators modulate their output on a number of discrete codes and to guide correctly, the bomb and designator must be matched.

To overcome these problems, GPS guidance is being seen as a viable backup to upgrade LGBs to function in all weather conditions. These weapons such as the US Air

Commonly used: IAF’S Mirage 2000S which dropped 1000 lb indegenous free fall bombs during kargil operations (left); Paveway II plus laser-guided bomb (Above)

Force Enhanced Guided Bomb Unit (part of the Paveway family of LGBs), use laser designation for precision attacks, but contain an inertial navigation system (INS) with GPS receiver for back-up, so that if the target illumination is lost or broken, the weapon still continues to home in on the GPS coordinates of the original target.

The IAF learnt its lessons well from the Kargil experience and has made sincere efforts to enhance its precision attack capabilities by widening the use of LGBs on its different combat aircraft fleets. Today, practically all its frontline fighter aircraft have the capability to launch LGBs either in a buddy mode through manned and unmanned aircraft or through self-lasing modes. The IAF also continues to enhance its arsenal of LGBs through indigenous and direct import routes. For example, it has been recently revealed by Lockheed Martin that the IAF plans to induct more than 100 bunker-buster laser-guided bombs (LGBs) for its warplanes and that they have offered the IAF their highly successful Paveway II LGBs. It may be recalled, the IAF had issued a global request for proposal (RFP) for the purpose last year, and Lockheed Martin along with Raytheon and Israeli Rafael had taken part in the tender. However, the IAF sources have indicated a figure of as much as 850 LGBs for this tender.

On the home front, the Bangalore-based Aeronautical Development Establishment (ADE), a DRDO laboratory with technological support from the Instrument Research and Development Establishment (IRDE), Dehradun, has been able to develop an Indian LGB-kit for the IAF. Named after the famous weapon Sudarshan Chakra sported by one of the major Indian deities, the ‘Sudarshan’ incorporates an advanced laser guidance kit for 1,000 lb bombs to improve accuracy. The guidance kit consists of a computer control group (CCG), guidance canards attached to the front of the warhead for providing steering commands and a wing assembly attached to the aft end to provide lift. First successful trials were conducted in June 2010 with the IAF’s help and a CEP of 10 m was achieved. A programme to extend the kit’s capability to further increase its range using GPS is ongoing.

It is expected to rival GBU-12 Paveway II in performance.

It is hoped that the programme will soon fructify for Sudarshan’s operational induction into service. The IAF still has a long way to go before it acquires the desired level of PGM capability, which incidentally could run into thousands for a two-front scenario. SP Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 19

Military Technology

T h e Wo n d e r

Radar Built on a modular philosophy, AESA radars can receive upgrades to remain updated with the latest available technologies

Photograph: Thales

I

n the days of yore, dish anphase delay/gain elements. ConseBy Air Marshal (Retd) tennas of fighter radars were mequently, rather than power supply for A.K. Trikha chanically steered concave reflecthe radar’s microwave energy being tors. To generate a desired beam concentrated in a single high voltpattern, they had to be fabricated age source, in an AESA design, power to a very high degree of mechaniis distributed amongst hundreds or cal accuracy. Transmitters had to be fed even thousands of TR modules. Each high voltage power supplies to generTR module in an AESA antenna is ate the necessary amount of microwave therefore required to handle much energy. In addition to presenting large radar signature, the lesser power (of the order of tens of Watts only) fed from design also tended to produce undesirable large side-lobes. relatively low voltage supplies. The design thus side steps all The breakthrough occurred with the advent of electronic problems associated with high voltage, high power systems. steering. Each of the several planar array elements of the anDigital control over functioning of all TR modules under tenna now had an electronically controlled device which could the authority of a command computer makes it possible manipulate delay in time or phase of the microwave signal to shape the beam precisely as also make it extremely agpassing through it. Systems using signal phase as the control- ile. These capabilities combined with extremely high scan ling parameter came to be known as ‘phased array radars’. rates achievable with electronic scanning yield a number The antennae of these radars were still passive beam of unprecedented capabilities. Thus AESA radars are disshaping devices while the source of microwave energy re- tinguished by their ability to undertake multiple tasks siquired for driving resided elsewhere. Thus they acquired the multaneously. By interleaving the highly agile beam in near nomenclature ‘passive phased array’ or ‘passive electroni- real time, APG-79 fielded on US Navy’s F/A-18E/F Super cally steered array’ (PESA) radars. Electronic beam steering Hornet can operate simultaneously in air-to-air and air-toin this design provided unparalleled beam agility, which in ground modes. A unique resource manager, it automatically turn made it possible to incorporate concurrent operation of schedules tasks to optimise radar functions and minimise diverse operational modes on a time share basis. However, the workload of the air crew. The radar can thus continue while innovation of antenna design enhanced overall radar scanning while communicating with other aircraft and capcapability by an order of magnitude, certain limitations re- turing ground imagery and can simultaneously guide mulmained unchanged. Transmitters continued to be saddled tiple weapons to multiple targets widely spaced in azimuth, with problems associated with high power travelling wave elevation and range. tubes (TWT).

Compared to a concave dish antenna of conventional The answer to more and more powerful TWTs lay in em- radar, a flat phased array offers a much smaller radar bedding several smaller, low powered trans-receivers in the cross-section signature when illuminated. Digital control antenna itself, centrally controlled by a command computer enables precise beam shaping, control over TR module to produce the desired beam pattern. However, cost, density gain, power management, and very significant reduction and power handling issues remained to be resolved. With of side-lobes. Radar warning receivers (RWRs) typically passage of time, a host of new devices of mass consumption work by integrating received signals over a short period discovered the virtues of the same chip and the active elec- to identify a threat over random background noise. Fretronically scanned array (AESA) radars were evolved quency and PRF of detected pulses is compared against a threat library to identify the type of threat. AESA radars AESA radar can change frequency with every pulse and generally do so An AESA radar essentially consists of several antenna ele- using pseudo-random sequence. Thus integration process ments each having its own transmit receive (TR) module, over a short period of time doesn’t help to pull the signal complete with a power amplifier and digitally controlled out of background noise. PRF also being randomly variable 20 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

www.spsaviation.net

Military Technology helps conceal the radar’s identify. Thus AESA design makes for a low probability of intercept.

Digital control also enables an AESA to change its operating frequency across a wide band with every pulse and even within a pulse. This attribute makes a jammer’s task much more difficult. Jammers could employ broadband white noise in an effort to swamp all possible frequencies.

But the effectiveness of such a technique is vastly degraded.

AESA could in the event switch to ‘receive only’ mode and use the powerful jamming signal to track the source for counterattack.

In addition to performing diverse radar functions simultaneously viz. searching volumes of airspace for aerial targets, designation of multiple targets for air-to-air missile engagements, ground mapping, etc, AESA radars can also be employed for non-traditional ISR, as well as electronic attack. For example, some of the elements could be designated to transmit and receive signals modulated with a data link waveform. By combining with state-of-the-art high-speed data links, Raytheon has demonstrated that an AESA radar can serve as a highly advanced communication node capable of such tasks as transmitting large amounts of data (like a SAR map of a target or other battlefield intelligence) with unprecedented speed—while continuing to perform full range of traditional radar functions. Raptor F-22’s AESA radar has demonstrated data transmission at 548 mbps and reception of signals at gigabit speed. To put it in perspective, Link 16 system transfers data at just over 1 mbps.

Active arrays of AESA radar can be put to other functions too. Since each of the TR elements is a powerful radio receiver on its own right, several of them could be dedicated to reception of radio signals to substitute for a separate RWR. In addition to the tremendous versatility, AESA radar’s design offers several other advantages. Transmitter power being distributed across a large number of modules implies that failure of a few modules may lead only to marginal degradation of performance rather than total loss of antenna function. This feature enables accommodation of some failures until the radar can be taken down for scheduled servicing. The cumulative benefit of AESA design features means that the antenna may have to be removed for repair/servicing once in a few years only, rather than the typical every few hundred or even lower hours of operations Limitations

As always, there is a cost attached to high performance.

AESA modules dissipate a lot of heat which must be extracted efficiently to maintain reliability of GaAs MMIC chips. High packaging density of the modules precludes the possibility of air-cooling techniques traditionally used in avionic hardware. Thus relatively more elaborate liquid cooling methods involving pumps to drive the coolant through channels in the antenna, heat exchangers, etc have to be adopted. Therefore, in comparison to a conventional aircooled fighter radar, while AESA delivers far greater performance and is much more versatile, it requires more electrical power and more complex cooling systems.

Compared to conventional radars, an AESA also relies much more heavily on enormous amounts of data and the integrity of its processing. It is a software intensive system which could conceal vulnerabilities of interference.

Current Scenario

The United States is the undisputed leader in AESA technology. In 2000, it fielded the world’s first operational AESA fighter radar—the APG-63(V)2 for the F-15C. Since then it has maintained its lead in advancing AESA technologies.

Currently, only American F-15 Strike Eagles, F-16s, and F/A-18E/F Super Hornets are offered with AESA radars.

France’s Dassault received the first RBE2-AA AESA radar for its Rafale production line in March 2012. The first French Air Force frontline squadron will receive the Rafales, equipped with the AESA radar only by early 2014. Saab is also still developing its own ES-05 Raven AESA radar for the JAS-39E/F Gripen NG. Europe’s Typhoon fighter is not likely to be available with operational AESA radar before 2015.

Israel has developed EL/M-2052 AESA radar which it put on display at Aero India 2005. The US Government restrictions prevent Elta or its parent company, Israel Aircraft Industries Ltd, from integrating it in US-built F-16 and F-15 fighters flown by the Israel Air Force. Therefore, Elta’s principal focus for the EL/M 2052 is the international fighter upgrade market. Considering that India and Israel have signed a deal for co-development of a multi-mode radar for the LCA, it is more than likely that Israeli AESA technology developed for the EL/M 2052 will find its way in the LCA radar.

India has had some experience with electronically scanned radars. It has developed Rajendra fire control radar for the Akash SAM which is built on a passive electronically scanned array (PESA). With Israeli assistance, it has also developed 3D AESA long-range tracking radar (LLTRsimilar to Elta’s Green Pine) for tracking high speed ballistic missile targets. Many of the LLTR’s critical components including high power, L B and TR modules were designed and manufactured in India. Thus while it has gained considerable expertise with this complex technology, there is yet no evidence to suggest that it is on the threshold to develop a successful operational system either for the LCA under development or to upgrade IAF’s current inventory of fighters.

Finally

Being so versatile in their capability and so much simpler to maintain, AESA systems are clearly there to stay. Built on a modular philosophy, AESA radars can receive upgrades to remain updated with the latest available technologies. The solid-state TR modules currently based on Gallium-arsenide semiconductor technology could perhaps be fabricated with more advanced elements, thus significantly enhancing performance.

In the realm of reliability, modern AESA radars define new standards. Raytheon claims that the mean time between critical failures of its APG-79 radar (on US Navy’s Super Hornets) is in excess of 15,000 hours of operation, and that the antenna might require no maintenance for 10 to 20 years. Northrop Grumman is so confident in the reliability of the joint strike fighter’s APG-81 radar that it may even recommend sealing of the nose radome.

And what about the future? It is quite conceivable that in the not too distant future we may see fighter aircraft radar evolving to the point where instead of sitting nice and snug inside a radome, it is built directly into the skin of the aircraft. SP Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 21

show Preview Farnborough Air Show C-130J super hercules taking off

Spirits High

Photograph: Sp guide pubns

Besides the magnificent static displays, Farnborough 2012 promises to have stunning aerobatic teams, high-end business jets, military craft, beautifying the London skies with their dazzling performances. It may once again serve as a platform for business deals and negotiations or set the stage for future agreements and pacts.

F

arnborough 2010 was a success with orders worth $47 billion, 1,455 exhibitors and over 1,20,000 trade visitors, including 70 delegations from more than 40 countries. The show this year to be held from July 9 to 15, promises much more. Though the European economy is yet to recover from the downturn, the Farnborough organisers’ spirit seems to be quite high.

According to organisers, Farnborough 2012 will once again serve as a platform for about 1,400 exhibitors from

22 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

the aerospace, defence, space and security sectors from across the world to showcase and demonstrate aircraft, equipment and technologies. The show is specifically designed to facilitate tailor-made and unrivalled opportunities to meet, negotiate and announce business transactions. It may once again serve as a platform for business deals and negotiations or at least set the stage for future agreements and pacts. And besides the spectacular static displays, there would be stunning aerobatic teams, high-end business jets, www.spsaviation.net

show Preview Farnborough Air Show military craft, beautifying the London skies with their dazzling performances.

Visitors to Farnborough this year will be the first to witness the future of space travel with Virgin Galactic, the world’s first ‘space line’, the Virgin Galactic Space Ship Two, a six-passenger, two-pilot spaceship that will offer passengers the opportunity to experience sub-orbital space travel.

Virgin Galactic is leading the development of privately-funded manned space ships for tourism, research, educational and other commercial purposes. The first Virgin sub-orbital passenger space flight is likely to take place by 2013.

Besides leading companies like Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Embraer, Hawker, Finmeccanica companies, etc Pilatus Aircraft Ltd will have the PC-21 and the PC-12 NG on static display. For the first time, Farnborough 2010 had an unmanned aerial systems (UAS) Indoor Flying area which proved to be one of the most popular features of the show. Keeping its popularity in mind, this year, the unmanned systems showcase will not only have a central location but will also feature

a purpose-built net for flying and ground systems demonstrations. The show will also have a business aircraft park too. On flying displays, there will be the Boeing C-17, the 787 Dreamliner, Saab Gripen, Yak 130, Apache, V-22 Osprey, Avro Vulcan, Sukhoi SU 27, Typhoon and much more.

The Farnborough International Air Show will this year host the Innovation Zone, an area dedicated to the research and technology sector offering a platform to showcase the latest technological advances to an audience of leading businesses, governments and peers from around the world.

There would also be the Futures Day for the younger audience and the Jubilee Day on July 13, 2012.

Though during the public weekend (July 14 and 15), the four trade exhibition halls will be closed, there will be patriotic flying displays to mark the 60th anniversary of Queen Elizabeth II, themed activities on the ground and the inspirational ‘Innovation Day’. Turn the pages to know more about the highlights of some of the major global aviation players at the air show. SP

A380 and A400M on static and flying displays

Photograph: Sp guide pubns

A

irbus’ newest commercial and military aircraft will be on display at the show. The A380 and the A400M will perform daily flying displays and will also be on static display. On static display will be many aircraft including a customer A380, an Airbus A320 equipped with Sharklet fuel saving wing tip devices, an A318 corporate jet, and the Airbus Beluga transport plane. The military aircraft will include the A400M and a Portuguese Air Force C295 maritime patrol plane on static display.

The pavilion will focus on new and future programmes and include an A350 XWB cut-away model and movie theatre showcasing ‘efficiency’. Other models will include the A320neo and the C295 in airborne early warning (AEW) and anti-submarine warfare (ASW) configurations. Airbus will also show a 3D movie offering a vision of the future of flight.

Airbus is also the headline sponsor of the Farnborough Innovation Zone and Future’s Day. Airbus experts will be there to discuss alternative energies, future solutions and future talent. The company is also hosting a series of career workshops for those considering a future in aerospace. SP

A400m aims for the sky

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 23

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

KC-390

Boeing & Embraer Join Hands

Photograph: Embraer

T

he Boeing and Embraer have announced an agreement to collaborate on the KC-390 aircraft programme. Under this agreement, Boeing and Embraer will share some specific technical knowledge and evaluate markets where they may join their sales efforts for medium-lift military transport opportunities.

“Boeing has extensive experience in military transport and air refuelling aircraft, as well as deep knowledge of potential markets for the KC-390, especially those which were not considered in our original marketing plan,” said Luiz Carlos Aguiar, President and CEO of Embraer Defesa e Segurança. “This agreement will strengthen the KC-390’s position in the global military transport market.”

The KC-390 collaboration is part of a broader agreement that Boeing and Embraer signed in April. The company had previously announced that they are exploring ways to cooperate in commercial airplane efficiency and safety, research and technology, and sustainable aviation biofuels. Boeing and Embraer will conduct a joint market assessment for the medium-lift military transport market and analyse business collaboration models. The market assessment includes potential customers that had not been considered in the initial market prospects for the KC-390.

“Embraer is a leading global innovator and we both understand the value of working in partnership to provide high-quality, affordable customer solutions,” said Dennis Muilenburg, President and CEO of Boeing Defense, Space & Security. “This collaboration matches Boeing’s proven excellence in military transport with Embraer’s KC-390 ac24 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

Specifications: KC-390 Crew: 2 Capacity: 84 passengers or 64 airborne troops or 6 pallets (68” x 108”) or 84 litter patients with 4 medical personnel or 2-3 HMMWV and Marrua or an Astros II or a LAV III and VBTP-MR Guarani Cargo compartment: Length 17.75 m x width 3.45 m x height 2.9 m Payload: 23.6 tonnes (52,029 lb) Length: 33.91 m (111.3 ft) Wingspan: 35.06 m (115 ft) Height: 10.26 m (33.8 ft) Loaded weight: 74.0 tonnes (163,142 lb) Max. takeoff weight: 81.0 tonnes (178,574 lb) Powerplant: 2 × IAE V2500-E5 turbofan, 120-129 kN (27,000-29,000 lbf) each Fuel capacity: 37.4 tonnes (74,800 lb, 33,929 kg) Performance Maximum speed: Mach 0.8 (300 KCAS, 850 kmph) Range: 2,600 nmi (4,815 km, 2,992 mi) (with 13,335 kilograms 29,400 lb payload) Range with full payload: 1,400 nmi (2,593 km, 1,611 mi) Ferry range: 3,250 nmi (6,019 km, 3,740 mi) Service ceiling: 36,000 ft (10,973 m)

complishments to further advance this highly capable and efficient medium-lift aircraft.”

The KC-390 is a Brazilian Air Force project for which Embraer signed the development contract in April 2009. It is the biggest aircraft to be manufactured by the Brazilian aerospace industry and will set new standards in the medium-lift market in terms of performance, cargo capacity, flexibility and life cycle costs. SP www.spsaviation.net

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

A

t the Farnborough air show, Lockheed Martin will have an F-16 and C-130 on static display.

However, according to the company, there would be no aircraft on flying display.

The company will brief the media on MH-60 programme: an overview of the international interest in the aircraft since the announcement of the first foreign military sale to Australia last year; F-35 Lightning II: pilots who have flown the F-35 will discuss the aircraft’s capabilities; F-16 Fighting Falcon: 4,500 deliveries and still outperforming; C-130: an overview of how the C-130J Super Hercules is meeting the needs of multiple countries and missions; KC-46, etc. SP

F-35 lightning II

Gripen in the Air capabilities Photograph: Saab Group

a file photograph of RTAF Gripen and Saab 340 AEW, Erieye

I

n the Saab chalet, the company will present Gripen, the centre piece of its air superiority offer as well as cutting-edge capabilities in airborne surveillance. Gripen will also participate in the flying display at the event, as also be exhibited at the static display together with the Saab 340 maritime security aircraft (MSA).

Gripen is the first of the new generation, multi-role fighter aircraft to enter operational service. Using the latest technology, it is capable of performing an extensive range of air-to-air, air-to-surface and reconnaissance missions employing the latest weapons. Gripen is designed to meet the demands of existing and future threats, while simultaneously meeting strict requirements for flight safety, reliability, training efficiency and low operating costs.

The Saab 340 MSA is a multi-role surveillance aircraft for detection, classification and identification of maritime contacts.

It is also a powerful search-and-rescue aircraft capable of operating independently or in unison with other marine and landbased assets. SP Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 25

Photograph: Lockheed Martin

Lockheed at the Show

Show Preview Farnborough Air Show BAE Systems Hawk Mk128

BAE’s latest

B

AE Systems will showcase its world-leading capabilities in the design, manufacture, support and upgrade of combat aircraft. This year’s exhibition will also profile the latest developments in its unmanned air systems programmes as well as demonstrate the company’s technologies and cyber and security solutions.

In addition a UK showcase will describe how BAE Systems supports the United Kingdom’s economy and its skills-base, as well as providing engineering solutions to British sport.

The company will brief the media on new technologies

like degraded visual environment (DVE) solutions such as the brownout landing aid system technology (BLAST); BAE Systems’ Innovative “fly-by-wire” technology; Hawk AJT; advanced precision kill weapon system (APKWS) – HighTech EDGE; An Affordable Solution to F-16 Upgrades; ASTRAEA System, etc.

There will also be a joint briefing by BAE Systems and Dassault Aviation on UK and French Governments collaboration on the design, development, production and support of a MALE UAS. SP

Photographs top to below: Baesystems, HBC

Hawker’s Special Mission capabilities

A

t the show, Hawker Beechcraft will highlight its defense and special mission capabilities and will display four aircraft including a Beechcraft T-6C military trainer, Beechcraft King Air 350ER special mission demonstrator, a King Air 350 Flight Inspection aircraft and a King Air B200. The King Air B200 is operated by the Government of Malta. Both B200 and King Air 350 will be outfitted with highly sophisticated Aerodata surveillance and flight inspection equipment, which is outfitted with highly sophisticated Aerodata surveillance equipment. The B200, which is used by the Mediterranean island nation for maritime border patrol missions, also incorporates search radar, EO/IR sensors and other mission equipment. SP 26 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

Beechcraft King Air 350ER

www.spsaviation.net

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

Dreamliner flights

T

he Boeing Company has announced that its 787 Dreamliner will participate for the first time in flying displays at Farnborough. Boeing also will present its Enduring Awareness Pavilion, a comprehensive display of advanced command, control, communication, computer, intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance (C4ISR) capabilities.

“We are showcasing a full range of innovative new products, systems and services from our commercial, defence, space and security businesses,” said Tom Downey, Senior Vice President, Boeing Communications. “We’re looking forward to the opportunities the show provides to meet with customers, partners and other stakeholders.”

A Boeing 787 Dreamliner in Qatar Airways livery will be on static display and Boeing plans to fly the fuel-efficient airplane in the daily show displays. In addition, Korean Air will

display its newest Boeing 737-900ER July 9-12. Boeing will feature the new 737 MAX with a programme update, and a full-scale model of the 737 MAX Advanced Technology winglet will be on view in the Boeing static display area.

The Enduring Awareness Pavilion is an interactive exhibit focused on C4ISR across every operational domain—air, land, sea, space and cyberspace. It will showcase more than 20 technologies—including the P-8A Poseidon, space-based space surveillance system, airborne early warning and control, eXMeritus HardwareWall, unmanned airborne systems from ScanEagle to Phantom Eye, and other capabilities.

During the show’s daily flying display, Boeing will demonstrate the capabilities of its advanced, multi-role F/A-18E/F Super Hornet fighter. Also on the flying programme will be the Bell Boeing V-22 Osprey tiltrotor and the tactical and strategic C-17 Globemaster III airlifter. The company and its customers will display several other systems, including the F-15E Eagle fighter and the AH-64D Apache Longbow attack helicopter.

Together with the Royal Aeronautical Society, Boeing will present airplanes built by students at the Yateley School (Hampshire) and the Marling school (Gloucestershire). They are the first two complete planes among the six being built by schools participating in the “Schools Build a Plane Challenge”, an initiative providing young people in UK secondary schools with the opportunity to build an operational light aircraft from a kit. SP

Photograph: Thales Group

interior view of Boeing 787 dreamliner

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 27

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

EADS Broad Portfolio

Photograph: Eurocopter

E

ADS and its divisions—Airbus/Airbus Military, Astrium, Cassidian and Eurocopter—will have a diverse portfolio of products, services and technologies on display at Farnborough.

Visitors will be able to see the unrivalled capabilities of the EADS Group in the defence and security field, ranging from aircraft platforms and missiles to secure communications systems.

Cassidian, the defence & security division of EADS, will present its wide array of security solutions and systems. These include the Tanan vertical take-off and landing (VTOL) unmanned aerial system, the Tracker mini-UAS as well as the new Cassidian CyberSecurity solutions for Cyber Defence & Professional Services, Trusted Infrastructure and Secure Mobility. During Eurosatory, Cassidian will also launch a new member of the Spexer Security Radar family: the Spexer 1500. Using the latest active electronically scanning array (AESA) technology, it is specifically designed for the mobile protection of border regions and sensitive industrial or military installations.

MBDA will present its range of missiles and missile systems on a separate stand. EADS is a shareholder in MBDA. Airbus Military will display models of its A400M turboprop airlifter and the A330 multi-role tanker transport aircraft.

The versatile A400M, which can perform both tactical and long-range strategic/logistic missions as well as refuelling, has already been ordered by Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, Spain, Turkey, the UK as well as Malaysia. The MRTT has been ordered by Australia, the UK, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates with six aircraft delivered to three customers last year.

Astrium, the European leader in space-born defence and security systems developing the complete weapon system for the M45 and M51 French ballistic missiles, will showcase projects such as the geostationary observation space surveillance system (GO-3S) which is an earth observation satellite designed to operate in geostationary orbit within 10 years.

Once in orbit it would be able to gather real-time information for security and defence purposes and humanitarian missions. Astrium will also display the welfare communication services it can provide to European armed forces for troops on overseas operations, and some of its solutions, in the frame of NATO’s anti-ballistic missile defence programme, for the protection of European populations, territories and troops, such as the Exoguard interceptor concept.

Eurocopter will display some of its key helicopters for military, security and patrol missions. These include the longrange 11-metric-tonne twin-engine EC725, whose capabilities are being demonstrated in Afghanistan with the French Armed Forces in its Caracal version; the AS565 Panther which is particularly suited to security and defence missions, marine surveillance, tracking, search and rescue; the EC635 which offers high performance and manoeuvrability for use in scout28 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

EUROCOPTER EC725 in action

ing, anti-piracy and public security missions; and the AS550 Fennec, a highly-capable multi-role military helicopter that is well suited for combat missions, firefighting support, observation, protection and training missions. A model of the EC665 Tiger—the best-performing attack helicopter in the world currently being operated in Afghanistan—will also be on display.

In addition, the NH90 and the Tiger will be displayed in the French Army’s stand. Also making its first appearance will be Eurocopter’s EC175, a new medium twin-engine helicopter designed to offer superior mission versatility and to set the standards in offshore oil and gas operations, search and rescue, VIP/corporate transport and other missions. It will be present in both the flying and static displays SP www.spsaviation.net

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

The New Legacy 500

A

t the show, Embraer will have the Legacy 650, the mock-up of the new Legacy 500, an Embraer 190 and an ERJ 145 on static display.

The Legacy 500 can fly 3,000 nm with four passengers. With eight aboard it can still fly 2,800 nm at Mach 0.80. This means the Legacy 500 can fly the US coast-to-coast mission with eight passengers at Mach 0.80, even against 99 per cent of annual winds, and still land with NBAA fuel reserves. There’s room to stand up in a cabin that’s taller than any other, room to relax in a cabin that’s wider and even room to stretch one’s legs on the expansive flat floor.

The Embraer Legacy 650 business jet has an enviable flying range of 3,900 nm and a maximum operating altitude of 41,000 ft. ERJ 145 is known for its versatility and can be deployed to replace turboprops. It has a capacity of 50 seats and a range of 1,550 nm. Likewise, the 100-seat capacity, Embraer 190, is both for short and long haul and has a range of 2,400 nm. SP

legacy 500

Selex Sistemi Integrati

In the area dedicated to security, the company will put on show solutions for an integrated airport. The solution is designed to deliver a fully operational airport system, based on the development of integrated airside and land side systems.

In air traffic control and management, Selex Sistemi Integrati is a turnkey supplier, relying on its capabilities in designing, manufacturing and installing different operational set ups according to the customer needs.

In naval systems, there will be the Kronos radar system, one of its state-of-the-art products. It is a tri-dimensional multi-role C band radar, born from the successful experiinmeccanica company Selex Sistemi Inte- ence of the EMPAR system and totally produced with the grati will showcase its most important products in company’s proprietary technology. More than 20 Kronos, in the radar systems domain and in the design and de- their different versions, which include naval and land convelopment of large systems for figurations, have been sold in several homeland protection. countries worldwide until now.

In the static exhibition area of FinmecIn the area dedicated to land syscanica, Selex Sistemi Integrati will put on tems, the company is showcasing the show Aulos, a new passive radar system new SIACCON and the advanced comdeveloped by the company, which takes mand and control system C2 Advanced, its name from an ancient Greece wind inboth of which have been designed and strument. The system exploits the electrorealised within the Forza NEC promagnetic energy available in the environgramme aimed at the battlefield digiment, as radio frequency FM emissions, talisation. The company will display making it wholly compatible with the enthe Masterzone system, designed for vironment. Guaranteed “environmentallysurveillance and monitoring through friendly” surveillance is in fact one of the unattended sensor net. Selex Sistemi advantages of passive radar technology. It Integrati also designs and realises netdoesn’t generate additional electromagcentric architectures able to work in an netic pollution, and it may be operated inter-force, interoperable environment environ friendly in and around inhabited areas and, more with the purpose of gaining superiority passive radar system specifically, urban environments. of information. SP

Photographs top to below: embraer, Selex Sistemi

F

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 29

show Preview Farnborough Air Show

Bell Showcasing Rotorcraft

bell helicopter 407GX in corporate configuration will be on display

A

t Farnborough, Bell Helicopter will showcase its mock up of the new Bell 525 Relentless super medium helicopter for the first time in Europe.

There will be flight demonstrations and two stateof-the-art commercial aircraft on display as well.

There will be demonstration flights of the spacious and versatile Bell 429 in corporate configuration. In addition, a Bell 429 in emergency medical services configuration and the technologically advanced Bell 407GX in corporate configuration will be on display at the trade exhibition. The highly-recognised V-22 Osprey will demonstrate its power and versatility by flying in the air show and will be on display for visitors to have a closer look.

“Farnborough marks the European debut of our new Bell 525 Relentless helicopter following a successful launch in February at HeliExpo in Dallas, Texas. We are excited to give our customers in Europe the opportunity to see our mock up of this game-changing aircraft,” said John L. Garrison, President and CEO of Bell Helicopter.

Danny Maldonado, Bell Helicopter’s Executive Vice President of Commercial Sales and Marketing, stated, “Bell Helicopter is and will continue to be a leader in the world of aviation. Europe is mission critical region for Bell Helicopter and participating at Farnborough gives us an opportunity to talk with our customers, learn more about their plans and share our mutual goals for the future. It is an exciting time to be involved in aviation and to be a part of Bell Helicopter. We have high expectations for ourselves and the industry.” SP

Griffin 824 Explosives Detection System

Photograph: bellhelicopter

F

LIR Systems has created an airport environment allowing visitors to experience the latest in airport security and trace detection systems. Using the company’s Ranger family of radars, placed at either end of the Farnborough runway, FLIR will demonstrate its perimeter intrusion detection (PID) and command and control (C2) capabilities, automated via its’ CommandSpace Adaptive C2 software suite.

The other technologies on display will be perimeter intrusion detection: detection + identification + tracking via radar and EO/IR sensors located on the airfield and linked to the ASZ’s command and control area; baggage and cargo screening: trace detection and analysis for explosives, narcotics and radiation; mobile response: handheld trace detection of explosives, narcotics and radiation; security checkpoints: trace detection and analysis of explosives, narcotics and radiation; command and control: fusion and automation of trace detection, radiation detection, perimeter 30 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

security and HVAC monitoring; HVAC monitoring: threat detection and mitigation monitoring for chemical and biological threats; Griffin 824: FLIR Systems will also launch the Griffin 824 trace detection mass spectrometer (TD-MS), a new-generation system for detection and identification of explosives and other materials; surveillance technologies: In Chalet C4, FLIR Systems will showcase its ever-evolving line of Star SAFIRE HD family of sensors. The Star SAFIRE infrared sensor product line is the first true family of interchangeable and digital, high definition, single LRU imaging systems providing a full spectrum of ISR capabilities, including laser target designation. Multiple products will be demonstrated, and the new UltraForce 350-HD, an all-European content system, will also be shown.

The Star SAFIRE 380-HD will be used for the first time at the Farnborough Air Show to provide live overhead coverage of the daily aerobatics demonstrations from FLIR’s PC12 aircraft. SP www.spsaviation.net

Space Exploration

Year

GSLV-D3

of

Reckoning ISRO must make the GSLV Mk II operational as quickly as possible and move onto the GSLV Mk III. After the twin setbacks of 2010, this may indeed be ISRO’s turnaround year.

By Group Captain (Retd) Joseph Noronha

Photograph: Isro

T

he Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) has enjoyed some major triumphs in the highstakes space exploration enterprise. At other times, it has plumbed the depths of despair. One high point was the launch of Chandrayaan-1, India’s first moon probe, on October 22, 2008. Although the mission was not an unqualified success, it put the national flag on the surface of the moon and was the first spacecraft to detect signs of water on earth’s nearest neighbour. No mean achievement. Soon thereafter, ISRO announced a low-cost programme intended to launch the first Indian spacecraft carrying an Indian as early as 2016. It was hoped that a planned series of human spaceflight missions would culminate in an Indian walking on the moon’s surface around 2020. The world’s media began to speculate about another space race brewing—this time between China and India. It all seemed too good to be true, and so it turned out.

April 15, 2010, was the day set for a vital test of India’s most advanced rocket, the geosynchronous satellite launch vehicle (GSLV), at the Satish Dhawan Space Centre at Sriharikota. That’s when things began to unravel. It had been an eagerly awaited mission because it was the first to feature indigenous cryogenic capability—technology painstakingly developed by ISRO in the wake of stringent US sanctions, ostensibly because it could be “misused” to power long-range missiles. However, after a flawless lift-off, the crucial cryo-

genic upper stage of the GSLV-D3 underperformed and the costly rocket went spinning out of control. And on Christmas Day, the same year, the GSLV-F06 rocket was launched, but it failed to develop its rated thrust, and veered off course, rendering its destruction unavoidable. After detailed investigation, ISRO claims to have uncovered the causes of the back-to-back failures and is getting ready to move on. But the memories of these fiascos are yet to be erased.

Giant GSLV

Why is the GSLV so important? ISRO is understandably keen to acquire the ability to launch heavy satellites entirely on its own. This would give it a thick slice of the lucrative satellite launch cake. The powerful GSLV can inject a communications satellite into geosynchronous transfer orbit (GTO) from where the satellite’s on-board propulsion system can lift it to its intended geosynchronous earth orbit (GEO), almost 36,000 km from earth. ISRO’s ambitions of sending Indian astronauts into space will remain a pipe dream as long as a reliable launch vehicle of the GSLV class is not available. Just now it isn’t. It will probably take several consecutive successful missions for the GSLV to evolve into a reliable unmanned launch system. And human-capable spacecraft cannot have a failure rate of more than two per thousand flights. ISRO also needs to work on areas like thermal protection; life support and crew escape systems. The present schedule calls for about two launches per year, so Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 31

Space Exploration

ISRO is understandably keen to acquire the ability to launch heavy satellites entirely on its own

getting the GSLV “man-rated” could take several more years. Therefore, the buzz now emanating from ISRO, points to a more realistic 2020 target for an indigenous astronaut launch; contingent on the GSLV quickly tasting success.

In contrast, the GSLV’s predecessor—the polar satellite launch vehicle (PSLV)—is a major success story. It has already notched 20 continuous successful flights. Using PSLV rockets and some foreign launch facilities, ISRO has fashioned two major satellite constellations. The Indian National Satellite (INSAT) System, the largest national communications system in the Asia-Pacific region, consists of geosynchronous satellites that satisfy the telecommunications, broadcasting, meteorology and search-and-rescue needs of India. The Indian Remote Sensing (IRS) Satellite System, useful for earth observation, is the largest constellation of civilian remote sensing satellites anywhere in the world. ISRO shortly intends to launch the first satellite in a third constellation—the Indian Regional Navigation Satellite System (IRNSS). When the seven-satellite IRNSS becomes fully functional around 2014, it will be India’s equivalent of the global positioning satellite (GPS) system and make the country completely selfreliant in satellite navigation services.

However, launching communication satellites using the PSLV is rather uneconomical since it can only lift 1,060 kg into geosynchronous transfer orbit (GTO). A large satellite is vastly preferable. Most advanced communications satellites nowadays are of the six-tonne class, enabling a large number of transponders and other communications equipment to be included. That is why ISRO hopes to launch the next GSLV Mk II, with an indigenous cryogenic third stage,

by October 2012. However, the more advanced and capable GSLV Mk III will have to wait till at least 2014. That would be able to orbit communications satellites weighing up to five tonnes. Alternatively, it could be used to deliver more than 10 tonnes into low earth orbit.

The demand for transponders in the country is increasing by the day and since ISRO has barely half its planned transponders in orbit currently, it is forced to acquire extra ones on lease. GSAT-11, ISRO’s biggest ever advanced communications satellite with 32 transponders in the Ka and Ku bands, is planned to be launched by 2014. However, the much-delayed launch of the dedicated communications and surveillance satellite Rohini, intended for the Indian Navy, may not take place till next year. Only after that can the Indian Air Force and Indian Army hope for their own satellites.

Outward Bound

ISRO also has ambitious space exploration plans. India’s second mission to the moon Chandrayaan-2, planned in 2014, is weighty enough to be blasted off by a GSLV rocket, unlike Chandrayaan-1 which was launched using a PSLV. At least two GSLV rockets will be tested at an interval of six months before the third is entrusted with the moon exploration payload. Chandrayaan-2 will have an Orbiter and Lander-Rover 32 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

module. ISRO will be responsible for the Orbiter and Rover, while Roskosmos of Russia will be responsible for the Lander. The Rover will travel on wheels across the lunar surface, do a chemical analysis of soil samples, and relay the data back to earth via the Orbiter.

Before the moon, ISRO has Mars on its radar. The Mars Orbiter mission is intentionally light, low-cost and simple in payload. Since Mars launch windows come around just once every 26 months, ISRO hopes to seize the next chance in November 2013, using the most powerful version of its workhorse PSLV rocket— the PSLV-XL. The Mars Orbiter, with nearly 25 kg of scientific payload on-board, will be placed in an elliptical orbit of 500 x 80,000 km around Mars. It is likely to focus on the climate and geology of Mars and the origin, evolution and sustainability of life on the planet. ISRO has also formulated preliminary plans for a mission to Venus in 2015. The aim would be to study its atmosphere and examine the origin and evolution of the planet.

Increasing Competition

ISRO’s launch vehicle programme has progressed over the years, but the space agency faces numerous challenges— among them a sharp rise in the number of launch vehicle operators which is expected to spark fierce competition.

Can ISRO change the established pecking order in the satellite launch business? The United States charges more than $50,000 per kg to launch a spacecraft while ISRO hopes to bring this down to $18,000 per kg. ISRO’s main competition could come from cut-rate private players, particularly in America. In 2008, NASA signed contracts with Orbital Sciences (OSC) and Space Exploration Technologies (SpaceX) for supply missions to the International Space Station (ISS).

SpaceX’s Falcon 9 launch vehicle and Dragon capsule completed their first operational mission to the ISS in May while OSC’s Taurus II and Cygnus capsule are expected to make their first commercial cargo flights to the ISS before the end of the year. The companies will probably foray into satellite launches later.

Meanwhile, the Chinese space programme is proceeding apace. Last year, for the first time in history, China executed more space launches than the US—second only to Russia.

China has already sent a spacecraft to the moon. It is also one of the only three countries to have achieved human spaceflight capability. Last year, it staged its first docking in space, when the unmanned Shenzhou-8 spacecraft gently linked up with the Tiangong-1 space laboratory module in a successful docking test. In June this year, Shenzhou-9 crew had successfully docked and separated by manual operation providing final validation of the Tiangong-1space laboratory.

ISRO desperately needs to get ahead if it wants to be taken seriously in the space industry. It must make the GSLV Mk II operational as quickly as possible and move onto the GSLV Mk III. After the twin setbacks of 2010, this may indeed be ISRO’s turnaround year. SP www.spsaviation.net

Seminar AEW&C

embraer 145 AEW&C in flight

By Sucheta Das Mohapatra

For Strategic Independence

From what emerged at the seminar on Airborne Early Warning & Control in New Delhi; AEW&C systems will remain classic for many years to come

Photograph: Embraer

A

irborne early warning and control (AEW&C) systems are expensive and yet a price defence forces have to put up with to get strategic independence. What emerged from the seminar on Airborne Early Warning & Control organised by Tangent Link in collaboration with the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) in New Delhi, was that AEW&C will not die in next to no time and will remain classic for many years to come.

The day-long seminar held on June 26 began with the opening address by Air Commodore (Retd) Jasjit Singh, Director, Centre for Air Power Studies, followed by an address

by Rear Admiral (Retd) Terry Loughran CB FRAeS, Chairman, Tangent Link, who highlighted on the increasing role of AEW&C in humanitarian assistance, disaster relief, homeland security, besides securing the borders. Sharing his experience with the Royal Navy, he stated instances wherein there were fatalities because of the lack of technological developments like AEW&C. Delivering the inaugural address, Air Marshal (Retd) Vinod Patney, Former Vice Chief of Air Staff reiterated the necessity of the Services to “See Better, See Further, See First” and the need for a detailed contingency plan if there is an attrition of AEW&C system. “The AEW&Cs capability is great but capability is always finite and there are drawbacks.” The in-

augural session ended with vote of thanks by Gurpal Singh, Principal Advisor and Head Defemce/Aerospace/Security, CII. Session I: Indian Air Force (IAF) & AEW&C

The session on “Indian Air Force (IAF) & AEW&C” was chaired by Air Marshal (Retd) T.M. Asthana, former Commander-in-Chief, Strategic Forces Command. “The ability to look down is an advantage and one who controls electromagnetic power controls the airpower. Despite having both high level and low level radars, because of India’s extensive borders it becomes difficult to cover all.”

Air Vice Marshal (Retd) Arvind Agrawal, former SMSO, South Western Air Command, IAF, spoke on “AEW&C: A New Technological Paradigm in IAF.” He said, AEW&C accelerates “observation, orientation, decision, action” (OODA) loop.

Swift tactical decisions can be taken the faster we gather the information, distribute, analyse and understand it. Stating that the Gulf Wars were a demo of the new technologies involved, he said that China has already announced a more technological force and India should also think on those lines.

Speaking on “IAF Operations Under AEW&C Environment”, Air Marshal (Retd) P.K. Mehra, former AOC-in-C, South Western Air Command, IAF, said that there are two aspects; technology and tactics. AEW&Cs development was started to fill the gap as Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 33

Seminar AEW&C it is difficult to provide radars for comprehensive low level coverage in a country like India with vast borders and especially mountainous terrain. AEW&Cs extends the eyes and ears of the commander. Stating examples of Korean War, Vietnam, Gulf War, etc, he said that it has been proved that in a war the side which has AEW&Cs has been successful. “IAF has to develop tactics to fight in a symmetric AEW&C environment which will be challenging for both men and machines. AEW&C should be able to call up swing role fighters to take advantage of a fleeting opportunity to open up a new front. He emphasised on the need for a seamless radar cover with adequate overlap along the border and coastal areas so that redundancy is taken care of. “The rest of the country can be covered with both primary and secondary radars.” On the vulnerabilities and limitation of AEW&Cs, he said that these need protection from saboteurs; must be equipped with an array of passive and active countermeasures; and be able to operate with a robust data link with the ground-based sensors and aircraft of all the three Services.

“Despite the evolution of a fifth-generation aircraft like F-35 having the capability of distributed aperture systems, AEW&C will still have a major role to play.” He concluded by saying that IAF must acquire AEW&Cs in adequate numbers and must have plans to induct them, as required.

Issues like the need to standardise doctrines and principles required for integration and the importance of conventional systems like U-2 which will exist, were taken up during the panel discussion that followed.

Session II: Naval Aspects of AEW&C

“If knowledge is power, the knowledge of enemies on the seas is significant sea power,” said Vice Admiral (Retd) Pradeep Kaushiva, Director, National Maritime Foundation, chairing the session on “Naval Aspects of AEW&C”. “AEW&C can control and contribute battle space management by state-of-the-art and cutting edge technologies. AEW&C aircraft are the best force-multipliers. The induction of P8I will take the AEW&C a full generation forward.”

Representing the industry were Captain (Retd) Tom Trudell, Manager, International Business Development, Northrop Grumman, and Bruce Wais, Business Development, Airborne Early Warning Surveillance Radar Programs, Lockheed Martin, who gave details of the E-2D Hawkeye system and the radar system on it, the APY-9 radars. He began his presentation with evolution from AEW to BMC 2 and spoke about the new Chinese J-20 stealth fighters. “Interoperability is the key to effective AEW&C. Emerging threats require revolutionary capabilities; a new air defence strategy, advanced cruise missile.” On the E-2D he said that it was designed for 21st century threats, having 360 degree situational awareness. It has capability for long-range detection, sea target tracking, precision tracking, expands surveillance, etc. E-2D is a state-of-the-art capability for ‘today and tomorrow’ and is designed for future growth. Bruce Wais spoke about the APY9 radar and said that it provides maximum detection flexibility, enhanced sector scan, enhanced tracking sector, etc.

Yoram Savir, Director, Maritime Patrol Aircraft, Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI) ELTA Systems, gave out details of ELTAs AEW&C solutions for maritime domain awareness. On the G550 conformal AEW, he said that the development on this business class platform started in 2001. ELTA’s third-generation of conformal airborne early warning and 34 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

control (CAEW) systems, the EL/W-2085, is mounted on a modified long-range, high-performance and low operating cost Gulfstream 550 business jet. Likewise, he spoke about Airbus Military and ELTA C295 multi-mode AEW&C. He said it provides 360 degree coverage, has fully integrated tactical system (FITS) signal intelligence (SIGNIT), electronic scan and fast rotation, separate optimised radar and IFF arrays and is low in weight and high in efficiency. Savir informed that ELTA is proposing ELM 2022 multi-mode belly radar for maritime and air surveillance. It complements AEW radars and is mounted under fuselage. He said that while IAI is a platform house and ELTA a sensor house, both together are providing system of system 2022 AEW&C. Session III- International Operations

The third and final session was chaired by Air Marshal (Retd) V.K. Bhatia, Senior Technical Editor, SP’s Aviation. In his opening remarks, he traced the gradual but steady build up of IAF’s early warning, air defence and command and control capabilities, and emphasised how these have been boosted by the acquisition of Phalcon-mounted three IL-76 AWACS aircraft with the figure going up to five systems in the near future. The AEW&C capability will be further augmented by the planned induction of the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) developed radar and other electronic surveillance sensors mounted on the Brazilian Embraer Emb-145 airframes. He said that in India’s context a judicious mix of ground-based, ground-tethered and airborne platforms would be desirable to perform the AEW&C tasks. Keeping in view the large size of the country, he suggested India, like the US, look into the possibility of deploying lighter-than-air so-called ‘air-tethered’ systems, capable of staying afloat for long durations at stratospheric altitudes to provide surveillance cover over a vast surface area. The more expensive platforms such as the AWACS and AEW&C aircraft should be selectively used in proactive offensive-defensive scenarios. On the naval front, he was hopeful the Indian Navy would seriously consider installation of the latest catapult systems on its planned second indigenous aircraft carrier – to take on fixed-wing platforms such as the E-2D Hawkeye aircraft, which would help to greatly enhance the Carrier Task Force’s in-built AEW&C capabilities.

The third session included three international military speakers who covered the AEW capabilities of their respective services/country. Rear Admiral Terry Loughran of formerRoyal Navy, UK, described as to how a lack of this capability resulted in the loss of five Royal Navy ships during the Falklands War and now, under the changed circumstances, how the AEW assets, especially the rotary-wing kind were helping the warfighters in the coalition wars against terror. Wing Commander Norrasage Boonruang covered the AEW capabilities of the Royal Thai Air Force which is centred on Saab 340 platform wielding the Swedish ‘Erieye’ system. The Brazilian Naval Attaché in India Captain Carlos Eduardo Dantas was the third speaker who gave a detailed briefing on the AD set up in Brazil and on the Erieye-mounted home-produced E-99, and R-99 platforms based on Emb-145 airframes. These were essentially AEW&C and surveillance platforms. He also talked about an additional AWACS role for the underdevelopment indigenous Emb KC-390 cargo plane which was under serious consideration by the Brazilian Government. SP www.spsaviation.net

Hall of Fame

M

aking motorcycles and steam cars is a stepping stone towards building aeroplanes—or so Geoffrey de Havilland thought. Born on July 27, 1882, in Buckinghamshire, England, the young Geoffrey was of a mechanical bent. In the summer of 1908, he sweet-talked his grandfather into giving him his £1,000 inheritance in advance. Then he quit his job, engaged a mechanic, Frank Hearle, and began making a plane of wire, wood and cloth.

Geoffrey’s wife Louise was roped in to stitch the stiff linen fabric stretched over the wings. A 45-hp engine provided power to the twin pusher-propeller machine. Geoffrey had little knowledge of aircraft designing and no training whatsoever in flying. This did not deter him from getting into the plane at the Hampshire downs and coaxing it to get airborne, helped by Hearle. But although the aircraft had a better aerodynamic shape than earlier biplanes, it stubbornly remained earthbound. When it finally did lift off, it came down with a crash about 100 feet away and was wrecked. Fortunately, de Havilland was unharmed. He managed to salvage the engine and some material from the site and took them back to the workshop, determined to rebuild the machine.

The aircraft that next emerged was stronger and simpler in concept with a single propeller. Barely six months later, in early 1910, the new plane took to the air and Geoffrey taught himself to fly. His confidence grew in leaps and bounds, so much so that he soon took Hearle, then his wife and eight-week-old son, for joyrides. Thereafter progress was rapid. In 1912, his BE.2 aircraft set a new British one-passenger altitude record of 10,560 feet. When the British Army decided to induct aeroplanes, de Havilland and Hearle produced some of Britain’s first military machines. World War I broke out in 1914 and the BE.2 became the standard aircraft of the Royal Flying Corps. Then de Havilland designed a number of new planes in quick succession. They included single and twoseat fighters and single and twin-engine bomber aircraft. Most of the planes

were manufactured by Airco, where he was employed. The Airco DH.4 was easy to fly, could travel at over 100 mph and had a high ceiling of 23,500 feet. It was rated the best single-engine bomber of the war. It was mass-produced in the United States after that country entered the conflict in 1917, and the 5,000 planes manufactured remained in service through much of the 1920s. Overall

Geoffrey de Havilland (1882 - 1965)

He and his company designed and built a large number of aircraft, including the Moth family—the Giant Moth, Hawk Moth, Puss Moth, Swallow Moth,Tiger Moth, Fox Moth, Leopard Moth, and Hornet Moth— used as private planes, trainers and light airliners 33 per cent of Allied aircraft strength and 95 per cent of all American wartime production were machines designed by de Havilland. His design philosophy was simple and direct. “I like a thing to look right,” he once remarked, “If it does not, although I may not be able to prove it wrong scientifically, I have often found out later that it is.”

After World War I ended, the de Havilland Aircraft Company was founded in 1920 (eventually absorbed into Hawker Siddeley). He and his company designed and built a large number of aircraft, including the Moth family—the Giant Moth, Hawk Moth, Puss Moth, Swallow Moth, Tiger Moth, Fox Moth, Leopard Moth, and Hornet Moth—used as private planes, trainers, and light airliners. These kick-started the flying club movement in Great Britain and many parts of the British Empire and made the company financially successful. During World War II their most successful product was the twin-engine Mosquito, a high-speed, all-purpose fighter-bomber of plywood construction. Faster than the Spitfire, it went into squadron service in 1941 and could outfly virtually anything in the air. It played a formidable role in World War II and some consider it the most versatile military aircraft ever built. In 1944, de Havilland was knighted for designing the Mosquito.

The de Havilland Aircraft Company was also among the first to produce jet-propelled aircraft, including the Vampire and Venom jet fighters. The Comet, the world’s first commercial jet plane and the precursor of today’s jet airliners, should have been the crowning success of de Havilland’s long and illustrious career as a designer and builder of aircraft. It entered service in 1949 and quickly captured the imagination of the travelling public. But during 1954, two Comets broke up in flight with heavy loss of life. By 1958, the larger and stronger Comet 4 was launched, only to be driven out of the market by the Boeing 707 and the Douglas DC-8, both of which were faster and less costly to operate.

Although Geoffrey de Havilland died peacefully on May 21, 1965, aviation brought tragedy to his family. His youngest son died in a midair collision involving two Mosquitoes in 1943. Later, in 1946, another son was killed while attempting a sonic dive in the jet-powered DH 108 Swallow. Consequently, Louise de Havilland suffered a nervous breakdown and died in 1949. SP —Group Captain (Retd) Joseph Noronha, Goa Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 35

Digest

news

BY SP’s Special Correspondent IAF modernisation to be completed by 2022 Signalling a push to modernisation of air power assets and shoring up of dwindling squadron strength, IAF Chief Air Chief Marshal N.A.K. Browne said that the current spate of IAF modernisation would be complete by 2022. "All the contracts which are signed during the 11th Five Year Plan are about `1,12,000 crore and they will be executed till 2017. At least 65 to 70 per cent of modernisation will be accomplished by 2017, and the rest by 2022. So 12th and 13 Five Year Plans are very crucial for IAF," said the IAF Chief. The massive capital commitment includes the monumental medium multi-role combat aircraft (MMRCA), likely to be contracted to Dassault Aviation by the end of this year for 126 Rafale jets, primary trainer aircraft, Boeing C-17 Globemaster III heavy lift transports, many more medium transports and several miscellaneous special mission aircraft and helicopters. In addition, the IAF will be investing in backbone network-centric architecture to consolidate AFNET, and begin investments in space-based assets as well. • IAF's C-130Js on a roll

HAL scouts engine for HTT-40 basic trainer The HAL has floated a bid for the supply of a turboprop engine for the in-development HTT-40 ab initio trainer programme. For the three-tonne basic trainer, HAL has stipulated to turboprop OEMs that it requires an operating envelope of Mach number 0-0.6M, calibrated air speed of maximum 500 km/h and ceiling altitude of 7,000 metres. The HTT-40, first unveiled as a model at Aero India 2011, will progressively replace India's HPT-32 Deepak trainers that have been grounded since July 2009. The Indian Government also recently placed an order for 75 Pilatus PC-7 Mk.2 basic trainers. • HAL turbofan engine The Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd has decided to go in for ab initio development of a new turbofan engine for military and civil use.

The proposed 20 kN jet engine, to be designed and developed by the Engine Test Bed Research & Development Centre (ETBRDC), will be aimed at powering trainer aircraft, military transports, business jets, light tactical aircraft, UCAVs and reconnaissance drones. The project will affect India's third project aimed at creating an engine for unmanned aircraft use. The other two are the modified Kaveri and the HAL-Safran Laghu Shakti. HAL has already begun scouting for a technology partner. • US Secretary of Defense Panetta in India

As India gears up to order six more C-130Js, the six aircraft in country are stretching their legs well. After landing at the Car Nicobar airbase recently, the 77 Squadron 'Veiled Vipers' based at Hindon is now pushing the aircraft fleet to its limits, flying in formation, exercising with the Army in combat drills and generally setting the stage for a larger number of the force-multiplying aircraft. The C-130Js, the newest aircraft in the IAF inventory, have proved themselves well and the IAF has reported very positively on the ownership experience so far. In fact, costs saved on early deliveries of the first six aircraft will be discounted from the contract price on the follow-on six aircraft, a figure pegged at approximately $80 million—something that has gone down extremely well with the IAF. • mid-air refueller contest Winner to be known soon Airbus A330 multi-role tanker transport (MRTT) at leh during trials in november 2011

EADS/Airbus will be waiting with baited breath for an impending decision on the winner of the Indian Air Force's mid-air refueller competition. The tender, a second iteration after the first was aborted in 2009, is a delicate one for EADS. It's Airbus A330 multi-role tanker transport (MRTT), which emerged the winner in the last competition, lost out when the tender was scrapped citing the cost of the system.

Airbus has fielded the same aircraft for the current competition, facing off against the Russian Ilyushin-78M, six of which are already ­operational with the IAF at its Agra airbase.• 36 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

On the back of a slew of high value defence deals with the US, India has conveyed that it is no longer interested in remaining in a buyerseller relationship and will exercise its rights as a customer to get the technologies that it needs. The US Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta met his Indian counterpart A.K. Antony on June 7 for an hour, a meeting where Antony is said to have said in no uncertain terms that military trade needed to move beyond simply the transfer of equipment.

In a statement, the MoD said, "During the discussion of the defence trade, Antony emphasised that the priority for India is to move beyond the buyer-seller transactions and to focus on transfer of technologies and partnerships to build indigenous capabilities. The US Secretary of Defense assured the Indian side that the US Government will initiate measures to facilitate technology access and sharing."

Secretary Panetta on his part assured Antony that every effort would be made to meet India's technology demands. • For complete versions log on to: www.spsaviation.net & www. spsmai.com www.spsaviation.net

Digest

news

Military

a nationwide network at the cost of `7,000 crore (approx $1.25 billion).

Asia-Pacific Defence Acquisition Council clears IAF proposals At a meeting of the Defence Acquisition Council on June 22, proposals amounting to approximately `11,000 crore (about $2 billion) were cleared for the IAF which included procurement of additional 14 Dornier aircraft, simulators for the Su-30 MKI aircraft and establishment of Integrated Command and Control Systems (IACCS).

Also, after the success of the pilot project of the Air Force Network (AFNET), it has been decided to implement it as

Americas Northrop demonstrates SmartNode Pod

Northrop Grumman Corporation has completed a series of test flights that has demonstrated the transmission

of imagery, video, voice and digital messages using a podbased airborne communications system. The SmartNode Pod is based on the battlefield airborne communications node (BACN) technology that allows real-time information to be exchanged among many different military and commercial radios and relays full-motion video—a critical capability for deployed warfighters.

Boeing delivers 100th modified Chinook to US Army On June 22, Boeing delivered the 100th modified CH-47F Chinook helicopter to the US Army in a ceremony at the company's modification centre in Millville. Boeing

Lockheed Martin has a new office

A

s a part of the ongoing process of resources’ optimisation, Lockheed Martin has moved its India office to The Grand Plaza Hotel at Vasant Kunj. Henceforth, the new office address will read as: Lockheed Martin India Pvt Ltd The Grand Plaza, The Grand Hotel Nelson Mandela Road, Vasant Kunj, Phase - II New Delhi 110070 It will be important to have a quick look at the company’s agenda for the country. As per Roger Rose, Chief Executive, Lockheed Martin India, not only has some important projects ongoing in hand but also has long-term plans for the country which quite interestingly include some highly diversified areas.

The company is apparently quite positive about its successful C-130J programme for the Indian Air Force which it claims has been “under budget” and delivered well “ahead of time”. While the supply of a total of six initial aircraft has been concluded, the US Government has offered a countersigned LoA in response to a request from the Ministry of Defence (MoD) for additional six aircraft. “There is a strong potential of additional orders from the Indian Air Force, if we continue to perform,” adds Roger Rose.

The India Meteorological Department is seriously considering the WC-130J weather version of the aircraft, known in the US as the “Hurricane Hunter”. Lockheed Martin, is also considering offering C-130’s maritime patrol aircraft (MPA) version to the Indian Navy and the Indian Coast Guard. An ongoing joint venture (JV) with Tata Advanced Systems in Hyderabad is involved in production of tail sections and centre wing box components for global customers.

The company is currently at the initial stages of discussions of potential provision of PAC-3 Air Defence System (operational in various countries including USA) to the Indian Army. Javelin, the shoulder-fired weapon system jointly produced by Raytheon and Lockheed Martin is another potential which is being pursued to meet the requirements floated by the Indian Army. A few other major programmes such as Boeing’s Apache for Indian Air Force, MH-60 R/S helicopter (with Sikorsky) for the Indian Navy, laser-guided bombs for the Indian Air Force, and the emergency high frequency antenna on Scorpene submarines are being actively worked upon by Lockheed Martin.

The world’s largest defence contractor’s Corporate Engineering & Technology group is active on highly diversified areas such as the multi-objective ocean thermal energy conversion (MOOTEC) project with the National Institute of Ocean Technology (NIOT) in Chennai. It is also pursuing a few unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) programmes with several different organisations such as Delhi Technical University and a LNG-powered C-130J initiative with Aeronautical Development Agency and Tatas.

Even though the company has been eliminated from the big ticket MMRCA programme, it continues to expand its disciplined programme performance on the C-130J programme and maintains full respect towards the steps taken by the Ministry of Defence to modernise the Indian military. •

QuickRoundUp Airbus Military • Airbus Military has successfully demonstrated the loading of NH Industries NH90 and Eurocopter EC725 helicopters onto the A400M new generation airlifter.

ATR • ATR, the manufacturer of turboprop aircraft, has announced that the ATR 42-600, a new member of its family of airplanes has obtained certification from the European Aviation Safety Agency.

AeroVironment • AeroVironment has received a firm fixed-price order for 12 hybrid small unmanned aircraft systems from the Swedish Defence Materiel Administration (Försvarets Materielverk) on behalf of the Swedish Army. The order consists of Puma AE and Wasp air vehicles, ground stations, training, and logistics support. The order is the result of a competitive evaluation and procurement process. Contract options could increase the procurement to a total of 30 systems.

BAE Systems • BAE Systems has been awarded a £15.5 million (about $24.3 million) contract by the UK Ministry of Defence for the conversion of two BAe 146-200QC (Quick Change) aircraft from commercial to military configuration for use by the Royal Air Force.

Boeing • Boeing has confirmed that Jakartabased Lion Air has made a commitment to order 787 Dreamliners for its newly launched premium carrier Batik Air. CAE • CAE has announced that it was awarded a series of military contracts valued at more than C$110 million.

They include contracts to develop a suite of fixed-wing training devices, and to continue providing in-service support for Canada's CF-18 fleet.

Denmark • The Danish Acquisition and Logistics Organisation has announced at Eurosatory that it has awarded Aero-

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 37

Digest

news

Appointments Indian Air Force Air Marshal P.S. Gill has been appointed Senior Air Staff Officer (SASO) of Western Air Command. Prior to moving to Delhi, he was on a similar assignment at HQ Central Air Command (CAC) based at Bamrauli, Allahabad.

Boeing Boeing has announced the appointment of Raymond L. Conner as President and CEO, Boeing Commercial Airplanes.

Boeing has announced that George Maffeo, Vice President of 787 Supplier Management, Boeing Commercial Airplanes will succeed Boeing Japan President Mike Denton, who will retire from the company in October.

Embraer José Antonio Filippo has been named Chief Financial Officer of Embraer. Filippo worked for important Brazilian and multinational groups, prior to taking over the Embraer ­assignment.

EADS As of June 1, Alexander Reinhardt has been appointed as Head of Public Affairs Germany. In this role, he is responsible for EADS’ relations with public sector and political organisations and institutions in Germany.

Following the appointment by the EADS Board of Directors, Fabrice Bregier, previously Airbus Chief Operating Officer, has taken over as Airbus President and CEO. Safran Pascal Legrain and Philippe Boulan have been appointed as Vice President for Human Resources at Safran group companies Turbomeca and Herakles, respectively. modifies the helicopters under an Initial Production and Fielding Support contract that also includes training support on the upgrades for Army Chinook units. Boeing deploys two New Equipment Training teams, consisting of CH-47F mechanics and technicians, to support Army units around the world.

Joint Flight Testing of X-47B

Northrop Grumman Corporation and the US Navy have successfully concluded the first major phase of flight testing of X-47B unmanned combat air system (UCAS) demonstrator aircraft at Edwards Air Force Base. The airworthiness test phase, which comprised 23 flights by

two air vehicles, proved that the X-47B will perform properly at all speeds, weights and altitudes associated with the Navy's UCAS Demonstration (UCAS-D) programme.

Europe International Close Air Support in London Coming September senior Air Force and Army officials will be gathering at the 10th Annual International Close Air Support event in London.

Confirmed attendees include Royal Air Force, Turkish Air Force, Indian Air Force, Royal Jordanian Air Force, Czech Air Force, Royal Canadian Air Force, Spanish Air Force, US DoD, Brazilian Air Force and French Air Force.

Russia confirms fifthgeneration bomber plans Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev has reiterated plans to develop a new, fifthgeneration strategic bomber.

“Alongside a fifth-generation fighter there are also plans

38 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

to develop an advanced long-range aviation complex.

I am talking about a new strategic bomber,” he said.

He added that “maintenance and modernisation of the existing strategic bombers is not enough”. Russia had announced plans way back in 2009 to develop a new strategic bomber featuring stealth technology by 2025.

The new bomber is expected to replace the Tu-95MC Bear, Tu-160 Blackjack strategic bombers, and Tu-22M3 Backfire long-range bombers currently in service with Russia’s strategic aviation.

Sagem's drone contract French defence procurement agency, DGA, has awarded Sagem (Safran group) a contract for five Sperwer Mk II drones, which will join the fleet of Système de Drones Tactiques Intérimaires (SDTI) tactical drones already in service with the French Army. The new systems will be delivered between the second half of 2012 and mid-2013, and will enable the French Army to maintain its tactical drone capability.

Evaluation of ASMPA nissile France’ strategic air force command has successfully carried out the first operational evaluation launch of the integrated weapon system, comprising a C-135 tanker, a Rafale strike aircraft, and the ASMPA nuclear stand-off missile according to a representative of a real mission.

During five hours, the mission brought together all the important phases of flight: high altitude cruise, low altitude penetration, terrain following, in-flight refuelling from tanker aircraft (C-135 tanker).

Civil Aviation Asia-Pacific Airbus enhanced customer support network in India Airbus has launched an enhanced Customer Support Network in India which combines numerous individual Field Service support stations into one integrated team.

Through this network, Airbus now has a continuous and

QuickRoundUp Vironment a firm fixed-price order of $9.6 million to supply the Danish Armed Forces with the company’s Puma AE small unmanned aircraft systems. AeroVironment was selected following a competitive evaluation.

Elbit • Elbit Systems Ltd has announced that its wholly-owned Israeli subsidiary Elbit Systems-Cyclone Ltd, has been awarded an approximately $80 million contract for the supply of structural components to the Boeing Company. The contract will be performed over seven years.

Eurocopter • Eurocopter, the world’s leading helicopter manufacturer on the civil and para-public markets, and Héli-Union, the leading French civil helicopter operator, celebrated the inauguration of a new simulator for the Dauphin AS365 N3/N3+ developed and built in partnership with Thales. The simulator certified last February is operational at Héli-Union’s training centre in Angoulême, in the Charente region of France.

Europe • The first MEADS power and communications unit has recently completed acceptance testing in Germany and will power the first multifunction fire control radar during integration tests at Pratica di Mare, Italy. The truckmounted power and communications unit provides power for the MEADS MFCR and the surveillance radar.

GKN Aerospace • GKN Aerospace has been awarded a contract by Boeing, to supply complex machined titanium and aluminium parts and assemblies for the horizontal stabiliser of the 787-9 Dreamliner. Manufacture and assembly work will be undertaken at GKN Aerospace facilities in Long Island and St. Louis, USA. Israel • El Al Israel Airlines has begun the process of renewing its fleet of aircraft over the next two decades to the tune of an estimated $2.4 billion to $2.7 billion. The company's Board of Directors has approved a memorandum of understanding for receiving www.spsaviation.net

Digest

news

Show Calendar 9–15 July FARNBOROUGH INTERNATIONAL AIRSHOW Farnborough Airport, Farnborough, UK www.farnborough.com/­ airshow-2012 23–29 July EAA AIRVENTURE Wittman Regional Airport, Oshkosh, USA www.airventure.org 15–17 August LATIN AMERICAN BUSINESS AVIATION CONFERENCE & EXHIBITION (LABACE) Congonhas Airport, São Paulo, Brazil www.abag.org.br/labace2012 4–7 September BEIJING INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS AVIATION SHOW Flight Inspection Center of CAAC, Beijing www.cibas-beijing.com/CIBAS/ index.php 11–16 September ILA BERLIN AIR SHOW Berlin ExpoCenter Airort, Berlin www.ila-berlin.de/ila2012/ home/index.cfm 17–18 September Jordan Air Defence Summit Amman, Jordan www.jordanairdefencesummit. com 17–18 September THE FUTURE OF BUSINESS JETS Cambridge Airport, Cambridge, UK www.quaynote.com/ankiti/ www/?code=jet12&f=home 25–27 September International Close Air Support 2012 76 Portland Place, London, UK www.closeairsupportevent. com 27–29 September JET EXPO Business Aviation Terminal, Vnukovo-3 Airport, Moscow www.2012.jetexpo.ru

extended Field Service presence, operating from two city hubs at Mumbai and Delhi, to offer 24x7 regional support and services. This Field Service initiative is part of Airbus’ evolution of its Support and Services organisation in the region given the continued and rapid fleet growth in the coming years. To sustain domestic and international growth in India alone, the region needs around 1,040 more aircraft by 2030.

First MAS A380 revealed in special livery

Bangalore-based Bharat Electronics Limited (BEL).

The subassembly provides cockpit floodlighting compatible with the aircraft's night vision imaging system.

Europe Surrogate UAV prepares for maiden flight The aircraft will fly using Instrument Flight Rules under air traffic control. In preparation, trials taking place this month include the world’s first use of autonomous, vision-based weather-avoidance routing and the first UK surrogate flight of a fully functional visual sense-andavoid system which includes collision avoidance tests using a second aircraft.

Industry Asia-Pacific Boeing delivers EA-18G Growler with BEL cockpit Boeing has delivered to the US Navy the first EA-18G Growler electronic attack aircraft with a cockpit subassembly produced by

$40-million loan from Boeing Capital Corporation, the Boeing Company's financial arm.

Americas

Lockheed Martin

Embraer and Avic JV During China´s Prime Minister Wen Jiabao’s recent visit to Brazil for the Rio+20 Conference, in a signing ceremony witnessed by leaders from both nations, Embraer and Aviation Industry Corporation of China (AVIC) signed an agreement to build Embraer’s Legacy 600/650 executive jets in China, using the infrastructure, financial resources and workforce of their joint venture Harbin Embraer Aircraft Industry.

• Lockheed Martin (LMT) has delivered the fifth P-3 Orion with new mid-life upgrade (MLU) modifications to US Customs and Border Protection more than 50 days ahead of schedule. The MLU replaces all fatigue life-limiting structures with enhanced-design components and incorporates a new metal alloy that is five times more corrosion resistant than the original material.

Europe The first A380 for Malaysia Airlines (MAS) was unveiled on June 26, bearing its special celebration livery, ahead of entry-into-service early July on the Kuala LumpurLondon route. The livery was designed by MAS specifically for it its new A380 flagship and was applied post-delivery

by Airbus in Toulouse.

QuickRoundUp

Sagem Patroller Drone Sagem has successfully completed a new series of test flights of its long-endurance.

Patroller drone system, in a multi-sensor, multi-mission configuration. The 18 test flights in this series demonstrated Patroller’s ability to fuse information from different sensors and to transmit them to a command and control centre for coastal surveillance.

Patroller is a one-tonne class drone, based on an aircraft certified by the European Aviation Safety Agency.

Space Asia-Pacific China's Shenzhou-9 spacecraft returns to earth A Chinese space capsule carrying three crew members has returned to earth following a 13-day mission.

The astronauts, including China's first woman in space, carried out a successful manual docking with the Tiangong-1 laboratory module. The Shenzhou-9 mission posted a series of firsts: the first manned automatic and manual dockings; the first long-duration spaceflight; and the first crew to live aboard a permanently orbiting module, Tiangong-1. •

NetJets • In the largest aircraft purchase in private aviation history, NetJets Inc., has announced that it will add up to 425 new aircraft to its worldwide fleet under purchase agreements with Cessna and Bombardier. The transaction has a total value of $9.6 billion and launches the new NetJets Signature Series of aircraft.

Norway • Norwegian, one of the largest lowcost carriers in Europe, has firmed up its order for 100 A320neo aircraft with Airbus for which a commitment was signed in January 2012. The order makes Norwegian a new Airbus customer, and as well, one of the biggest A320neo customers.

Thales • Thales UK has announced that it has been awarded a further four-year contract, valued at £29 million (about $44.4million), from the UK Ministry of Defence to support the intelligence surveillance target acquisition and reconnaissance mission support system (ISTAR MSS). ISTAR MSS is a vital operational capability that provides users with mission planning, information management and information exchange.

US Air Force • The US Air Force has awarded Northrop Grumman Corporation a three-year $108 million contract to develop and implement cryptography upgrades as part of the intercontinental ballistic missile cryptography upgrade II engineering and manufacturing development programme.

Issue 7 • 2012 SP’S AVIATION 39

Word

Last

Survival in

Doubt

Illustration: SP Guide Pubns

T

he 58-day strike by over 400 pilots of Air India who are members of the Indian Pilots’ Guild (IPG), was called off on Tuesday July 3 only after intervention by the Delhi High Court. Earlier, the Court had suggested that the parties involved explore possibilities of an amicable out-of-court settlement. The Court also advised the management of the airline to adopt a “parental attitude’’ towards the pilots. The other faction in Air India is the domestic segment consisting of pilots of erstwhile Indian Airlines represented by the Indian Commercial Pilots’ Association (ICPA).

The reason that had apparently triggered the strike by IPG this time was a decision by the management to include members of the ICPA for training on the Boeing 787 Dreamliner to be inducted in the near future. The IPG believes that as international operations have largely been their prerogative, members of ICPA ought not to be included for training on the Dreamliner. Apart from the turf war, pilots of the IPG are apprehensive that inclusion of pilots from ICPA will impinge on their career progression and promotion prospects.

The latest confrontation between the management and the IPG was a clear manifestation of the utter failure of the policy of the Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) enunciated in 2007 to merge the two national carriers. In the stalemate, the services of over 100 pilots had been terminated and 200 of the remaining 300 were also threatened with precipitate action.

During the nearly two months that the situation was adrift, at no time was there any evidence on the part of the management of a clear plan of action to break the deadlock.

While the government is usually prepared to negotiate even with the terrorists, no effort was made to initiate dialogue with the striking pilots to resolve issues. Pilots were only too willing to talk but tragically, the management was “missing in action”. And all this while the management had been claiming near normalcy with international operations. How this was possible with 15 of the 20 Boeing 777 aircraft grounded, defies logic. The management was not only misleading the nation, it also appeared totally unconcerned about the deleterious financial implications of the impasse. Accountability has never been a virtue with Air India in any case. Factually, international operations remained severely disrupted.

Executive pilots deployed to operate international flights complained of being overstretched and under severe stress, a situation not at all conducive to air safety. Their sympathies undoubtedly lay with the striking faction of pilots as is evident from their communication with the management to this effect. Besides, 22 of the 120 executive pilots reported sick on June 19. All this while, Air India continued to lose money at a phenomenal rate and with the financial plight of the air40 SP’S AVIATION Issue 7 • 2012

line worsening on account of the rapidly rising burden of Air India’s cumulative cumulative losses, the airline was fast losses have reached approaching a point staggering proportions. beyond redemption.

While the present crisis While in the recent episode, strike appears to be over, in by the IPG had been the absence of proper declared illegal and accountability, there is the conduct of pilots was regarded no hope of revival or as reprehensible, survival. the management did not cover itself with glory either. The IPG had its own litany of complaints such as underpayment or non-payment of emoluments on time, discriminatory policies biased unduly in favour of the ICPA in respect of pay and promotions, denial of equal opportunity to members of the IPG, etc.

Pronouncements by the MoCA about the intended course of action in the future were somewhat bizarre to say the least. Measures suggested by the management such as to immediately dispense with the services of 300 trained pilots enmasse, to train freshly hired pilots to replace those sacked as also to employ expatriates who incidentally would be available at more than twice the cost, are not only symptomatic of desperation amongst the management, these also reflected complete lack of understanding of the airline industry and crisis management. Even with minimal understanding of civil aviation one would know that to train a pilot to operate as commander with type rating on an aircraft such as the ­Boeing 777, involves an expenditure of over a crore of rupees and takes years. These steps if ever taken would surpass in folly the disastrous and thoughtless exercise of merger in 2007, which is yet to see the light of the day and probably never will, the Dharmadhikari report notwithstanding.

Air India’s cumulative losses have reached staggering proportions and the airline continues to descend deeper into a mess. The state Air India is in today is a result of years of mismanagement and neglect. But till date no one has been held responsible or accountable. While the present crisis appears to be over, in the absence of proper accountability at every level of management, there is no hope of revival or survival for the Maharaja. SP — Air Marshal (Retd) B.K. Pandey www.spsaviation.net

www.spsmilitaryyearbook.com www.spsaviation.net www.spslandforces.net www.spsnavalforces.net www.spsairbuz.net www.spsmai.com

Web World of SP’s

Since 1964