LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
71
NOCTUA ORBONA (HUFNAGEL) LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEYS IN THE SANDLINGS DURING 2002 TO 2005 A. W. PRICHARD Introduction The Lunar Yellow Underwing Noctua orbona is a National Biodiversity Action Plan species of moth. In the latter half of the 20th Century the species underwent a national decline in its distribution and is now mainly known from areas of the Breck in Norfolk and Suffolk with only scattered colonies being found elsewhere in Britain. The moth is in its adult phase (Plate 10) from June through to October, with aestivation (summer hibernation) occurring during the hotter midsummer months, particularly July. It is a species associated with open dry habitats; acid and calcareous soils where fine-leaved grasses grow. It is in its larval stage (Plates 11 & 12) from September through to late April or May with the larvae feeding at night primarily on fine-leaved grasses. During the larval stage it may be readily found, where present, by searching with lights at night. The advantages of surveying for larvae are that the precise location and habitat used by the species can be identified and a more accurate assessment of populations can be achieved.
Map of all adult and larval Lunar Yellow Underwing records – half filled circles for adults and full circles for larvae.
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
72
Suffolk Natural History, Vol. 41
In the winter of 2001/2 Gerry Hagget et al. were formally surveying Breckland sites for N. orbona larvae, as part of a Butterfly Conservation (BC) sponsored survey (Haggett, 2002). Records of adult N. orbona attracted to light in the late 1990s seemed to suggest that populations of the moth may exist in the Sandlings area. In early 2002 nocturnal larval searches in the Sandlings located N. orbona larvae at two sites; Ipswich Golf Course and Rendlesham Forest. For the winter of 2002/3 the BC sponsored survey was extended to include surveying for larvae in the Sandlings. The methodology used was aligned with that of the Breckland surveys being carried out by Gerry Haggett et al. and was reported in Haggett & Prichard (2003). Since then annual winter larval surveys have been carried out by members of the moth group in the Sandlings area using the same methodology and the results reported in Prichard (2004 and 2005). Aims of the survey The aims of the survey during the first year of formal surveying were to better understand the species distribution within the Sandlings and to provide information on larval habitat and foodplant preferences that could be used for comparison/contrast with the survey work being carried in the Norfolk and Suffolk Brecks. Subsequent surveys, in addition to the above aims, have included a monitoring aspect in their aims. During the first year’s survey larvae were found in fine-leaved grass habitats where a short sward resulted from rabbit grazing, an unusual habitat preference not previously noted in the Breckland surveys. Later surveys have sought to investigate the daytime resting places of larvae in this type of habitat. Method Known areas of heathland in the Sandlings were identified and visited during the day to assess the habitat for its suitability for supporting N. orbona larvae. Identified suitable sites were then visited at night, when larvae were searched for with lights. The larva has a habit of climbing dried grass stems or other vegetation while it is dark and can be easily spotted in the light beam of a torch. The larva, with some experience, is readily identifiable and particularly in its early instars has a distinctive chocolate-coloured underside. Experience of the larval habitat preferences from the Breckland survey proved useful in identifying potential survey sites in the Sandlings Searches were carried out for noted periods of time with the number of larvae found being recorded. When this information is combined with the number of surveyors it allows the production of adjusted larval counts that can be used for comparison of results from different sites. This technique relies much on individual surveyor ability to locate larvae but the impact of this on the results of the surveys should be limited as the majority of survey work has been carried out by the same two to three surveyors. Survey Site Descriptions Over the survey period 45 sites have been visited and surveyed. The following table summarises the details of each site surveyed.
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
73
Table 1 Details of Survey Sites Site name Aldringham Walks Blaxhall Heath
Grid reference TM466611 TM380565
Ipswich Golf Course
TM208432
Martlesham Common
TM243463
Martlesham Heath
TM237447
Minsmere RSPB
TM464671
North Warren RSPB
TM455589
Purdis Heath
TM213427
Rendlesham Forest Site A
TM344506
Rendlesham Forest Site B
TM345505
Rendlesham Forest Site C
TM354486
Rendlesham Forest Site D
TM350480
Rendlesham Forest Site E
TM345475
Rendlesham Forest Site F
TM354473
Rendlesham Forest Site G
TM362477
Rendlesham Forest Site H
TM304493
Rendlesham Forest Site I
TM3350
Rendlesham Forest Site J
TM346471
Description Heather and Festuca clumps Heather heathland with scattered clumps of Festuca Heathland golf course with scattered areas containing mixture of Festuca and Agrostis Acid grassland with primarily Festuca Acid grassland with primarily Festuca and other coarser grasses Acid grassland, primarily Agrostis Acid grassland, recently cleared, with Agrostis and Festuca Area cleared of bracken with recently established Agrostis Acid grassland with mixture of Festuca and Agrostis, scattered bramble clumps Acid grassland with primarily Agrostis Forest track verge with mixture of Festuca and Agrostis Forest track verge with mixture of Festuca and Agrostis Forest track verge with mixture of Festuca and Agrostis Heather with clumps of Festuca interspersed Forest track verge with mainly Agrostis Forest track verges with mainly Agrostis Acid grassland, with primarily Agrostis and occasional bramble clumps and conifers Forest track verge, with primarily Festuca
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
74
Suffolk Natural History, Vol. 41
Table 1 continued Site name
Grid reference
Description
Rendlesham Forest Site K
TM359466
Rendlesham Forest Site L
TM357465
Roadside verge, with Agrostis and Festuca and other grasses, overshadowed by trees Forest track verge, mixture of Agrostis and Festuca with heather and bracken Forest track verge, heather, Agrostis and Festuca and bracken Acid grassland, primarily Festuca, with heather clumps and birch scrub Acid grassland, primarily Agrostis, with clumps of willowherb and wood-sage Acid grassland with scattered gorse and bracken, grass primarily Festuca Forest ride with heather and rough grasses with a small proportion of fine-leaved grasses Mixture of heather and Festuca Recently cleared area of heathland, with colonisation by fine-leaved grasses, primarily Deschampsia Small area of Festuca next to golf course fairway Area cleared of gorse with newly established fine-leaved grasses, primarily Agrostis Acid grassland with Festuca and Agrostis Acid grassland with Festuca and Agrostis with heather and bracken, managed by mowing Heather with areas of acid grassland, alongside track, with birch scrub
Rendlesham Forest Site M TM358464 Rendlesham Forest Site N
TM329491
Rendlesham Forest Site O
TM334502
Rendlesham Forest Site P
TM337493
Rendlesham Forest Site Q
TM357496
Rushmere Heath Site A Rushmere Heath Site B
TM198445 TM202447
Rushmere Heath Site C
TM203448
Rushmere Heath Site D
TM202449
Sutton Heath
TM306476
Thorpeness Golf Course
TM457607
Tunstall Common Site A
TM377553
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
75
Table 1 continued Site name
Grid reference
Description
Tunstall Common Site B
TM375547
Tunstall Common Site C
TM377548
Tunstall Common Site D
TM375551
Tunstall Common Site E
TM374547
Tunstall Forest Site A
TM390554
Tunstall Forest Site B
TM384554
Tunstall Forest Site C
TM396550
Upper Hollesley Common Site A
TM333472
Upper Hollesley Common Site B
TM332473
Walberswick, East Hill
TM482739
Wenhaston Black Heath
TM423748
Westleton Common
TM442686
Westleton Heath
TM457696
Acid-grassland, grasses primarily Festuca and Agrostis Clumps of primarily Agrostis amongst heather Acid-grassland, with some heather and gorse, grasses primarily Festuca Acid-grassland, primarily Agrostis and Festuca Heather and acid grassland along forest track, predominantly Festuca Rough grassy area with gorse and heather along forest track, predominantly Festuca Heather and acid grassland strip along forest track, predominantly Festuca Unmanaged area of acid grassland, predominantly Festuca Unmanaged area of acid grassland, predominantly Festuca Acid grassland with mixture of Festuca and Deschampsia Heather and acid grassland mosaic, predominantly Festuca Heather with some areas of Festuca Predominantly heather with areas of Festuca interspersed
Summaries of larval counts Adjusted larval counts remove the variation in larval counts produced by differing lengths of search periods and the number of people searching. The formula used for calculating adjusted larval counts is as follows : Adjusted larval count = (60 Ă— larval count)/( search period in minutes Ă— no of surveyors)
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
Suffolk Natural History, Vol. 41
76
Table 2. Summary of larval counts for 2002–3 The following three tables summarise for each year the N. orbona counts made at each visit to a survey site Date
time N. orbona numbers No. mins recorders actual
14.12.02 21.12.02 27.12.02 27.12.02 28.12.02 28.12.02 14.01.03 14.01.03 14.01.03 16.01.03 16.01.03 16.01.03 24.01.03 26.01.03 26.01.03 07.02.03 07.02.03 07.02.03 08.02.03 08.02.03 08.02.03 23.02.03 23.02.03 25.02.03 25.02.03 03.03.03 07.03.03 20.03.03 20.03.03 20.03.03 25.03.03 14.04.03 14.04.03 17.04.03 17.04.03
65 110 60 60 60 45 20 20 45 30 40 45 145 65 25 45 15 35 25 30 18 30 30 50 30 60 60 25 25 30 60 30 40 50 15
temp Site no: location °C
adjusted
18 4 16 14 0 50 9 4 3 0 28 23 29 30 0 18 30 2 30 14 18 25 9 51 28 12 23 2 1 0 0 1 11 8 1
8 1 5 5 0 33 9 4 1 0 21 15 12 9 0 8 51 1 36 14 30 25 9 15 14 4 11 2 1 0 0 1 8 5 2
*2 for 15 mins, 1 for 5 mins
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
2 2 3 3 2 2 3 3 3 2 2 2 1 3 3 3 2* 3 2 2 2 2 2 4 4 3 2 2 2 2 3 2 2 2 2
7·5 7 8 8 8·5 8·5 9 9 9 6 6 6 7·5 12 13 7 7 7 7·5 7 7 5·5 5·5 5 5 7·5 7·5 4·5 4·5 2·5 1·5 13·5 13 7 6
Rendlesham Forest Site A Rendlesham Forest Site I Rendlesham Forest Site G Rendlesham Forest Site F Tunstall Common Site A Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Forest Site A Tunstall Forest Site B Tunstall Forest Site C Rendlesham Forest Site J Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Ipswich Golf Course Thorpeness Golf Course Aldringham Walks Sutton Common Upper Hollesley Common Rendlesham Forest Site H Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Common Site C Rendlesham Forest Site A Rendlesham Forest Site B North Warren Martlesham Heath Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Rendlesham Forest Site G Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D Tunstall Common Site D Tunstall Common Site B
LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
77
Table 3. Summary of larval counts for 2003–4 Date
time mins
N. orbona numbers
No. temp Site no: location recorders °C
actual adjusted 05.01.04 05.01.04 05.01.04 05.01.04 10.01.04 10.01.04 10.01.04 19.01.04 19.01.04 19.01.04 19.01.04 23.01.04 23.01.04 31.01.04 31.01.04 02.02.04 02.02.04 11.02.04 11.02.04 13.02.04 13.02.04 03.03.04 03.03.04 05.03.04 05.03.04 06.03.04 06.03.04 06.03.04 13.03.04 13.03.04 17.03.04 17.03.04 19.03.04 19.03.04 21.03.04 21.03.04 21.03.04 01.04.04 01.04.04 03.04.04 11.04.04 11.04.04 15.04.04 15.04.04
15 30 30 15 30 30 20 20 30 15 15 25 20 20 15 25 30 35 35 35 30 35 30 45 50 15 20 15 40 35 25 15 35 30 25 20 20 45 15 30 15 20 20 25
7 21 29 1 75 92 26 15 0 0 3 0 2 19 2 6 9 103 50 2 47 26 16 2 10 2 16 2 12 0 7 0 12 9 1 14 5 16 8 2 0 0 0 3
14 21 29 2 50 62 26 15 0 0 4 0 2 28 4 5 6 88 43 1 31 22 16 1 6 3 16 3 5 0 6 0 5 5 1 14 5 7 11 1 0 0 0 2
2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 3 3 2 2 3 3 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 4 3 3 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 2 3 3
9 9 9 9 9 9 9 10 10 10 10 7·5 7·5 12 11·5 12 12 8 8 7·5 7·5 6 6 4·5 4·5 4·5 4·5 4 7 6·5 14 13 10·5 9 8·5 8·5 8·5 11·5 11·5 10·5 2·5 2 8 8
Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site D Tunstall Common Site A Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Upper Hollesley Common Site A Rendlesham Forest Site K Rendlesham Forest Site M Rendlesham Forest Site L Blaxhall Heath Tunstall Common Site C Rendlesham Forest Site A Rendlesham Forest Site N Rendlesham Forest Site N Rendlesham Forest Site O Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site G Rendlesham Forest Site F Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D Tunstall Forest Site C Tunstall Forest Site A Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site C East Hill, Walberswick Westleton Heath Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site G Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site C Sutton Common Upper Hollesley Common Site A Upper Hollesley Common Site B Martlesham Heath Purdis Heath Minsmere RSPB Reserve Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
Suffolk Natural History, Vol. 41
78
Table 4. Summary of larval counts for 2004–5 Date
time mins
05.12.04 05.12.04 12.12.04 13.12.04 13.12.04 16.12.04 16.12.04 16.12.04 23.12.04 23.12.04 23.12.04 29.12.04 29.12.04 29.12.04 29.12.04 29.12.04 30.12.04 30.12.04 31.12.04 31.12.04 31.12.04 02.01.05 06.01.05 06.01.05 06.01.05 07.01.05 07.01.05 20.01.05 20.01.05 20.01.05 30.01.05 30.01.05 03.02.05 03.02.05 04.02.05 04.02.05 11.02.05 11.02.05 11.02.05 11.02.05
30 25 35 20 20 30 20 20 25 20 15 15 15 8 10 17 20 25 35 20 15 45 20 15 10 15 35 30 15 15 15 15 25 25 45 20 20 15 15 25
N. orbona numbers actual
adjusted
8 1 8 77 236 4 2 3 119 72 48 8 59 19 58 52 17 10 105 2 18 14 182 15 90 0 0 22 6 9 113 81 46 44 24 14 7 5 8 26
6 1 14 77 236 4 3 5 71 72 48 16 118 71 174 92 26 12 60 2 24 19 182 20 180 0 0 22 12 18 226 162 55 53 16 21 11 10 16 31
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
No. temp ° Site no: location recorders C
3 3 1 3 3 2 2 2 4 3 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 1 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2
2 2 6 7·5 7 7·5 7 7 12 12 11·5 10 10 10 10 10 8 8 8 4·5 2·5 6 10 10 9 12 11 10 9 9 8 8 8·5 7 7 7 7 7 7 7
Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Martlesham Common Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Common Site E Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Upper Hollesley Site A Upper Hollesley Site B Sutton Heath Rushmere Heath Site A Rushmere Heath Site B Rushmere Heath Site C Rushmere Heath Site D Purdis Heath North Warren Westleton Common Rendlesham Forest Site P Rendlesham Forest Site Q Rendlesham Forest Site A Martlesham Heath Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site D Tunstall Common Site B Rendlesham Forest Site G Rendlesham Forest Site F Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site D Martlesham Heath Martlesham Common Wenhaston Black Heath Thorpeness Golf Course Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E Rendlesham Forest Site C Rendlesham Forest Site A
LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
79
Table 4 continued Date
21.03.05 21.03.05 23.03.05 23.03.05 27.03.05 28.03.05 28.03.05
time mins
25 15 20 20 25 20 10
N. orbona numbers actual
adjusted
2 2 12 6 5 0 0
5 8 36 18 12 0 0
No. temp ° Site no: location recorders C
1 1 1 1 1 2 2
11 11 9 9 9 5 5
Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site B Tunstall Common Site E Tunstall Common Site B Upper Hollesley Site A Rendlesham Forest Site D Rendlesham Forest Site E
Results and Discussion Distribution and abundance Over the three years of surveying N. orbona larvae were found at forty survey sites within the Sandlings area of Suffolk, with the majority of sites occurring in the more southerly heathland areas. The species was found to be more widespread and abundant than previously accepted based on records of adults at light. This finding is conservation significance as this population of the moth now represents the largest known population of the moth in the country after the Breckland population. Adjusted larval counts from several of the Sandling sites have been significantly higher than any from the Breckland sites, suggesting that some of the Sandling habitats support a higher density of the larvae and presumably adult moth. Why this should be has not yet been established but climactic conditions will certainly vary between the two areas with the Sandlings areas having milder winters closer to the coast. Larval mortality is rather high and may be due to a number of factors, including parasitism. Most larval predators maybe inactive during the winter months but parasitic wasps were often observed searching the grass for larvae (not necessarily just for N. orbona larva) and later parasite cocoons were found on grass stems at survey sites. Habitats The larvae utilise variations of the broadly classified acid-grassland habitat found within the Sandlings. The following three types of acid-grassland produced high larval counts during the surveys
• A dense sward consisting of Festuca clumps with no other grass species of note, at Upper Hollesley Common Site A. • A tufted sward containing of a mixture of Festuca and Agrostis clumps, with bare patches between clumps, at Tunstall Common Site B and E • Forest ride-side grass verges consisting of very short swards (due to rabbit grazing) with only a few Agrostis stalks upon which N. orbona larvae were mainly found, at Rendlesham Forest Sites D and E.
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
80
Suffolk Natural History, Vol. 41
The latter type of sites (track-side short sward grass verges – termed ‘lawn’ sites) would appear to offer the greatest contrast in habitat preference with the Breckland populations where a short sward due to sheep grazing is not beneficial. The grass verges would appear to be predominantly Agrostis with occasional scattered dry stalks that the larvae climb up during the hours of darkness. Our experience from the sites surveyed was that these short swards maintained by rabbit grazing supported above average numbers of N. orbona larvae. This presumably indicates that there will be some difference between the short swards due to sheep grazing and those due to rabbit grazing that is important to N. orbona larvae. Larval foodplants Larvae were rarely noted feeding during the earlier instars and even in later instars sightings of feeding were not commonplace given the numbers of larvae found. Historically it appears that the foodplants of this species were not well known with some books listing ‘various grasses and lowing-growing plants’ and others not even listing the foodplants. Based on the results of the surveys it would appear that the two main foodplants used within the Sandlings are Festuca and Agrostis and to a lesser extent Deschampsia flexuosa and Holcus. Deschampsia is not a particularly common grass in the Sandlings compared with Festuca and Agrostis but is used by the larvae when present. Larvae reared in captivity will accept coarser grasses and feed up well on them. Daytime resting site The generally accepted daytime behaviour of N. orbona larvae is that they spend the day sheltered within the bases of clumps of their foodplant. Other larvae of species in this group of moths are known for burrowing into the soil during the daytime but N. orbona is not generally recognised to have this behaviour. The ‘lawn’ sites have a very short sward (approximately 1–1·5 cm) over much of their area and would appear to offer very little cover for the larger larvae to hide up in during the day. Surveys made in April 2003 at these sites when final instar larvae were present showed that these large larvae could still be found in areas with a very short sward. As the larvae are thought to be relatively sedentary it is possible that they might be burrowing into the soil, although this remains to be confirmed. Attempts to verify this in subsequent years has not been possible due to low numbers of late instar larvae in these habitats. Conservation Almost all survey sites within the Sandlings have been managed by means other than sheep-grazing. In the Brecks it has been shown that sheep-grazing has a detrimental effect on larval counts and presumably following from that on the population of the moth. It is a concern that sheep-grazing may be introduced as a more widespread habitat management regime on the Sandlings heaths and have a comparable effect on the population of this species as it has in the Brecks. Other significant threats to suitable habitat are encroachment of the habitat by other plants, most notably bracken and to a lesser extent Carex arenaria
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
LUNAR YELLOW UNDERWING LARVAL SURVEY
81
sand sedge. Larvae were rarely found in any numbers in areas of grassland where there is more than a scattered covering of bracken. During the winter any bracken present will have died back and so appears to have little impact on the habitat but it must be remembered that when the adult moth is laying eggs in late summer the bracken will alter the structure of the habitat and may cause shading of the foodplant. Some evidence has been found of the moth readily exploiting newly created habitats during the last two winters. At Purdis Heath an area cleared of bracken and colonised by Agrostis in scattered clumps produced significant numbers of larvae. At Rushmere Heath where gorse clearance has opened up areas that have been colonised by fine-leaved grasses, mainly Deschampsia and Agrostis, larval counts were again significantly high. For monitoring of populations the period from December to January with its higher larval counts is the preferred time for surveying. Sites should also be visited on more than one occasion as counts may vary from night to night, even under apparently similar weather conditions. The surveying carried out so far has produced base line data against which the status of populations in future surveys may be assessed. Acknowledgements I would like to thank those who helped with the larval surveying, most notably Neil Sherman and Graham Bull who have spent many hours with myself in the field carrying out the surveys, and also Matthew Deans, Steve Woolnough, Mark Nowers, Nick Mason and Jon Clifton. I would like to thank Gerry Haggett who provided invaluable assistance and guidance in the initial stages of the survey on the types of habitat to search and tips on larval identification. I would also like to thank the landowners who gave the group permission to carry out surveys on their land; Richard Davies (Forest Enterprise), Tunstall Parish Council, Dave Thurlow (RSPB), Adam Burrows (English Nature), Robin Harvey (RSPB) and Thorpeness Golf Club. Finally I would like to thank Butterfly Conservation who provided general support during the survey and financial assistance to cover travel expenses during the first year of the survey. References Haggett, G. M. (2002). Lunar Yellow Underwing Noctua orbona (Hufnagel), larval survey in Norfolk and Suffok Breckland. Haggett, G. M. & Prichard, A. W. (2003). Lunar Yellow Underwing Noctua orbona (Hufnagel) larval survey in Norfolk and Suffolk Breckland and Suffolk Sandlings. Butterfly Conservation. Prichard, A. W. (2004). Lunar Yellow Underwing Noctua orbona (Hufnagel), larval survey in the Suffolk Sandlings during 2003–2004. Suffolk Moth Group. Prichard, A. W. (2005). Lunar Yellow Underwing Noctua orbona (Hufnagel), larval survey in the Suffolk Sandlings during 2004–2005. Suffolk Moth Group. A. W. Prichard, 3 Powling Road, Ipswich, Suffolk, IP3 9JR
Trans. Suffolk Nat. Soc. 41 (2005)
A. W. Prichard A. W. Prichard
Plate 10: Lunar Yellow Underwing (Noctua orbona) adult – Rendlesham Forest (2003), reared (p. 71).
Plate 11: Lunar Yellow Underwing, Tunstall Common (23 February 2003). Early instar larva showing darker underside and habit of resting on dried grass stems (p. 71).
A. W. Prichard Plate 12: Lunar Yellow Underwing larva – final instar (Rendlesham Forest, 14 April 2003) (p. 71).