Vereinbarkeit von Photovoltaik und Denkmalschutz _Anna Schulze Wiehenbrauk

Page 1

-*7*/( */ 5)& '6563&

%"4 (&#­6%&

5&$)5*-& &"4:

17 4$)*/%&-/

17 4$)*/%&-/

7&3(-&*$)

7FSFJOCBSLFJU WPO 1IPUPWPMUBJL VOE %FOLNBMTDIVU[ ½SUMJDIF #BVWPSTDISJGU àCFS (FTUBMUVOH HFNÊ f EFS -BOEFT CBVPSEOVOH /8 GàS EJF "MUTUBEU 4PFTU

Standard Renovierung

f %BDIBVGCBVUFO v'MÊDIFOIBGUF %BDIWFSHMBTVOHFO %BDInÊDIFOGFOTUFS EJF EBT JO "CT HFOBOOUF .B àCFSTDISFJUFO VOE 4PMBSBOMBHFO TJOE OVS [VMÊTTJH XFOO TJF WPO LFJOFS ÚGGFOUMJDIFO 7FS LFISTnÊDIF BVT FJOTFICBS TJOE i

6NGSBHF JO EFS "MUTUBEU 4PFTU

6NGSBHF JO EFS "MUTUBEU 4PFTU

1IPUPWPMUBJL

%FOLNBMTDIVU[

8JF mOEFO TJF 1IPUPWPMUBJL 20%

4%

4PMMUFO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UF (FCÊVEF FSIBMUFO XFSEFO

94%

,FOOFO 4JF FJO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFT (FCÊVEF

68%

#FTJU[FO 4JF FJO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFT (FCÊVEF

51%

4JOE 4JF EBGàS EBTT NFIS (FCÊVEF VOUFS %FOLNBMTDIVU[ HFTUFMMU XFSEFO

#FTJU[FO 4JF FJOF 17 "OMBHF 6%

0%

,FOOFO 4JF KFNBOEFO NJU FJOFS 17 "OMBHF 32%

0%

4JOE 4JF GàS NFIS 17 "OMBHFO JN 4UBEULFSO 15%

34%

$*4 .PEVMF

,PTUFO 4BOJFSVOH

#FTDISFJCVOH

,MFJOF 8

,8I B ,8I

%BDI

&VSP

0QUJL

#FMJFCJH

(SP F 8

,8I B ,8I

'BTTBEF

&VSP

7PSUFJMF

,FJOF 4PMBS[FMMFO BO EFS 'BTTBEF

(FTBNU

4.380 KWh/a 12 KWh

(FTBNU

9.200 Euro

/BDIUFJMF

,FJO &SUSBH )PIF )FJ[LPTUFO

4USPN

&VSP JN +BIS

1PTJUJW /FVUSBM /FHBUJW

1PTJUJW /FVUSBM /FHBUJW

76%

7FSCSBVDI +BIS 5BH

94%

6%

0%

4JDIFSVOH -FJUVOHFO 73%

2%

0%

27%

0%

98%

92%

7%

1%

6%

0%

94%

38%

-PIOU TJDI EJF UFVSF 4BOJFSVOH WPO EFOL NBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEFO

19%

66%

15%

6%

1BTTFO 1IPUPWPMUBJL VOE EFOLNBMHF TDIàU[UF (FCÊVEF [VTBNNFO

11%

44%

45%

4JOE 17 "OMBHF VNXFMUTDIPOFOE

6OHFFJHOFUF 'MÊDIFO GàS 17 7FSTDIBUUFU N¤

6OHFFJHOFUF 'MÊDIFO GàS 17 7FSTDIBUUFU N¤ /VU[nÊDIF N¤

(FFJHOFUF 'MÊDIF GàS 17 6OWFSTDIBUUFU N¤

(FFJHOFUF 'MÊDIF GàS 17 6OWFSTDIBUUFU N¤

1BSBMMFM 3FJIFOTDIBMUVOH

6OUFSTUà[FO 4JF EFO %FOLNBMTDIVU[ 40%

44%

16%

4JOE 17 "OMBHF XBSUVOHTBSN 23%

39%

/VU[FO 17 "OMBHFO FSOFVFSCBSF &OFSHJFO 94%

0%

,PTUFO 7PSTDISJGUFO 6OXJTTFO

,PTUFO 0QUJL 6OXJTTFO

8BT TUÚSU 4JF BO 1IPUPWPMUBJL 47%

34%

8FDITFMSJDIUFS

8BT TUÚSU 4JF BO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEFO

19%

50%

44%

-BHFQMBO

6%

.POUBHF 4ZTUFN

17 .PEVM 1PMZLSJTUBMMJOF 4PMBS[FMMF

FS[FVHU .àMM XFOJH ­TUIFUJL MBOHXFJMJHF 0QUJL LFJOF HMFJDINÊ JHF 4USPNFJOTQFJTVOH IPIF ,PTUFO 7PSTDISJGUFO

#VJMEJOH JOUFHSBUFE 1IPUP7PMUBJL IPIF )FJ[LPTUFO #J17

WJFMF 7PSTDISJGUFO VOHMFJDIF 'ÚSEFSVOHFO 4BOJFSVOHTLPTUFO

(FCÊVEF JOUFHSJFSUF 17

3 DN

+ 'ÚSEFSVOHFO $IBSBLUFS FSIBMUFO 8FSUWPMMFT IFSBVTmMUFSO &SIBMUFO WPO IJTUPSJTDIFO ( (FTDIJDIUF CFXBISFO *OEJWJEVBMJUÊU TJDIFS 4UFVFSWPSUFJMF

HMBUUF 0CFSnÊDIF TUBSLF 4QJFHFMVOH 3FnFYJPO

3 4DINFM[LMFCTUPGG

HSPCF 0CFSnÊDIF MFJDIUF 4QJFHFMVOH 3FnFYJPO

4DIVU[LVQQFM

%&/,."-4$)65;

1)05070-5"*,

TBVCFSFS 4USPN VNXFMUTDIPOFOE FSOFVFSCBSF &OFSHJFO VOBCIÊOHJH WPN /FU[ 'ÚSEFSVOH ,G8 "CMÚTVOH GPTTJMFS #SFOOTUPGGF

2

2 4 )BMUFSVOH

17 .PEVM

+

1

1 "MVNJOJVN VOUFSLPOTUSVLUJPO

4DIVU[LVQQFM

DN

%BDIQGBOOFO VOUFSCBV

FMFLUSJTDIF 7FSCJOEVOH

NBUUF 0QUJL EVSDI 4VCUSBLUJPOTWFSGBISFO

4

4 "OTDIMVTT #PY

SBVIF 0CFSnÊDIF LBVN 4Q NBUU

3FnFYJPO

"MVNJOJVN VOUFSLPOTUSVLUJPO

5 $PWFS (MBT NN 'MPBUHMBT

5

DN

DN

DN

,8I B ,8I

'BTTBEF

,8I B

7 #BDL TJEF (MBT NN 'MPBUHMBT

,8I

%BDI

'BTTBEF

4.095 KWh/a 11,22 KWh (FTBNU

$EELOGXQJ )DVVDGHQÀlFKH

#FTDISFJCVOH 19.000 + 6.000 &VSP

0QUJL

4FIS QSÊHOBOU BVGGÊMMJH

7PSUFJMF

)ÚIFSFS &SUSBH (FSJOHFSF ,PTUFO

/BDIUFJMF

&SGàMMU LFJOF 'BTTBEFOBVGHBCFO

9.500 + 3200 &VSP 37.700 Euro

7

N

D

(SVOESJTT &SEHFTDIPTT

N D

17 .POUBHF 4ZTUFN 4 )BMUFSVOH

8

8 4QMJUUFSTDIVU[GPMJF

DN

FCFOGBMMT 4USPN EVSDI 4PMBS[FMMFO FS[FVHU "VG EFO FSTUFO #MJDL JTU EJFTF 17 'BTTBEF LBVN WPO FJOFS 4DIJFGFSGBTTBEF [V VOUFSTDIFJEFO #J17 FS[JFMFO JISF CFTPOEFSF 8JSUTDIBGUMJDI LFJU EVSDI EJF &STFU[VOH EFS BSDIJUFLUPOJTDIFO #BVUFJMF EJF TPOTU [VTÊU[MJDI mOBO[JFSU VOE JOTUBMMJFSU XFSEFO NàTTUFO %JFTF "SCFJU HJCU FJO #FJTQJFM VOE "OSFHVOH GàS XFJUFSF JOOPWB UJWF VOE PQUJTDI BOTQSVDITWPMMF 17 (FCÊVEF IàMMFO &T [FJHU XJF XBOEFMCBS VOE BOQBT TVOHTGÊIJH 17 .PEVMF TFJFO LÚOOFO %VSDI EJF BOQBTTVOHTGÊIJHFO 17 .PEVMF LBOO NBO EJF EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEF GàS EJF ;V LVOGU SàTUFO TPEBTT NBO OJDIU BVG EJFTF IJT UPSJTDI XFSUWPMMFO (FCÊVEF WFS[JDIUFO NVTT %JFTF -ÚTVOH TPMM [FJHFO EBTT FJO nÊDIFO EFDLFOEFT 1IPUPWPMUBJLWFSCPU JN IJTUPSJTDIFO 4UBEULFSOFO LFJOF [FJUHFNÊ F -ÚTVOH JTU %BOL OFVFS 5FDIOJLFO VOE *OOPWBUJPOFO LBOO NBO BVDI JO EJFTFN TQF[JFMMFO #FSFJDI EFS "MUCBVTBOJFSVOH NPEFSOF 17 &MFNFOUF JOUF HSJFSFO 6N EJF 7PS VOE /BDIUFJMF EBS[VTUFM MFO HJCU FT BVG EFN MFU[UFO 1MBLBU FJOFO EJSFL UFO 7FSHMFJDI [XJTDIFO 4UBOEBSE 17 "OMBHFO JOUFHSJFSUFO PQUJTDI TDIÚOFO 17 "OMBHFO VOE FJOFN 4UBOEBSEHFCÊVEF PIOF 17

,PTUFO

%BDI

Gesamt

6

7FSFJOCBSLFJU WPO 1IPUPWPMUBJL VOE %FOLNBMTDIVU[

N

D

DN

DN

17 %BDIQGBOOFO N¤ .PEVMF

N

4 )BMUFSVOH 17 4DIJOEFMO

&SUSBH 5FDIUJMF &BTZ

(FCÊVEFEBUFO %BDInÊDIF

46 m²

,8Q

"O[BIM EFS .PEVMF

427 Module

2,5 KWp

4àE ½TUMJDI

(SBE (SBE 5% 95%

Y

,8I ,8Q

,8I ,8Q Y ,8Q

2137,5 KWh im Jahr

"VTSJDIUVOH %BDIBVTSJDIUVOH %BDIOFJHVOH "C[VH &JOTUSBIMVOHTNFOHF 4DIOJUU " "

4DIOJUU # #

4POOFOTUVOEFO

900

,8I B

5,9 KWh am Tag

.JU FJOFS %BDInÊDIF WPO N¤ LBOO NBO JO FJOFS 4UVO EF ,8Q FMFLUSJTDIF &OFS HJF FS[FVHFO %B[V LPNNU EJF &JOTUSBIMVOHTNFOHF WPO EJF BVT EFS (F CÊVEFBVTSJDIUVOH VOE EFS %BDIOFJHVOH FSNJUUFUMU XJSE 4PFTU FSIÊMU EVSDITDIOJUUMJDI 4POOFOTUVOEFO JN +BIS EJF FCFOGBMMT JO EJF 3FDI OVOH NJUFJOnJF FO *OTHF TBNU FS[JFMU EJF 5FDIUJMF &BTZ "OMBHF FJOFO &SUSBH WPO ,8I BN 5BH EBT TJOE JN +BIS ,8I B

%VNNZ N¤ .PEVMF

D

%VNNZ N¤ .PEVMF

NBMHFTDIàU[UF (FCÊVEF TDIFJOFO CFJ EFS *OUFHSBUJPO NJU 17 WFSHFTTFO XPSEFO [V TFJO )JFS CFmOEFU TJDI KFEPDI HSP FT 1PUFOUJBM EB IPIF )FJ[ VOE 4BOJFSVOHTLPTUFO EVSDI 17 "OMBHF HFEFDLU XFSEFO LÚOOUFO ,PTUFO VOE PQUJTDIF 1SPCMFNF CFJ "OXFOEVOH WPO 17 "OMBHFO BO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEFO TJOE IJOSFJDIFOE CFLBOOU #FJEF "TQFLUF TJOE [V àCFSEFOLFO VOE LÚOOUFO [V FJOFS -ÚTVOH CFJUSBHFO JOEFN TJDI EVSDI PQUJNBMF &SHÊO [VOH /BDIUFJMF JOT 1PTJUJWF WFSÊOEFSO MBTTFO %JFTFS "TQFLU XJSE JO EJFTFS #BDIFMPSBSCFJU BOIBOE FJOFT EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊV EFT JO 4PFTU EBSHFTUFMMU #*17 #VJMEJOH JOUF HSBUFE 1IPUP7PMUBJDT BMTP HFCÊVEFJOUFHSJFSUF 1IPUPWPMUBJL JTU EJF -ÚTVOH #*17 CF[FJDIOFU 4ZTUFNF VOE ,PO[FQUF JO EFS EJF 1IPUPWPMUBJL OFCFO EFS 4USPNFS[FVHVOH BVDI EJF 'VOLUJPO WPO #BVFMFNFOUFO XJF 5FJMF EFS (FCÊVEF IàMMF àCFSOFINFO %BT 4àEEBDI EFT EFOL NBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEFT XJSE NJU EBDI QGBOOFOBSUJHFO 17 .PEVM JOUFHSJFSU %JFTF 17 %BDIQGBOOF HSFJGU EJF $IBSBLUFSFJHFOTDIBG UFO WPO IJTUPSJTDIFO %BDIQGBOOFO BVG VOE FS[FVHU HMFJDI[FJUJH 4USPN VN TP EJF ,PTUFO [V EFDLFO "O EFS 4DIJFGFSTàEGBTTBEF XJSE

"VGGÊMMJHF *OUFHSBUJPO

&SUSBH +BIS 5BH

6 4USPNFS[FVHFOEF ;XJTDIFOTDIJDIU NN

%JF &SFJHOJTTF EFS 'JOBO[XJSUTDIBGU VOE EJF XBDITFOEFO 6NXFMUCFMBTUVOHFO [XJOHFO VOT EB[V VN[VEFOLFO VOE [V IBOEFMO *O EFS "SDIJUFLUVS JTU FT VOVNHÊOHMJDI CFJ 6N XFMU VOE /BDIIBMUJHLFJU [V SFBHJFSFO 7PS EFN )JOUFSHSVOE EBTT 4POOFOFOFSHJF NBM NFIS &OFSHJF FS[FVHU BMT EJF .FOTDIIFJU EFS [FJU WFSCSBVDIU FSTDIFJOU EJF /VU[VOH EJFTFS 4PMBSFOFSHJF BMT -ÚTVOH GàS FJOF OBDIIBMUJHF VNXFMUPQUJNJFSUF &OFSHJFWFSTPSHVOH 1IPUP WPMUBJL BMT vTBVCFSFSi 4USPNFS[FVHFS HFXJOOU TPNJU JNNFS NFIS BO #FEFVUVOH &T CFTUFIU EFS[FJU OPDI HSP FS #FEBSG JO EFS PQUJTDIFO &OUXJDLMVOH EFS 17 "OMBHFO EB EJFTF EFO $IBSBLUFS VOE $IBSNF EFS (FCÊVEFIàMMF TFIS PGU OFHBUJWCFFJOnVTTFO "OIBOE FJOFS 6NGSBHF JO EFS IJTUPSJTDIFO 4UBEU 4PFTU XVS EFO 7PSVSUFJMF VOE 6OXJTTFOIFJU EFS #àSHFS HFHFOàCFS 1IPUPWPMUBJLBOMBHFO LMBS /JDIU OVS EJF #àSHFS BVDI EJF 7FSBOUXPSUMJDIFO GàS EJF 4UÊEUF IBCFO HSP F &JOXÊOEF HFHFOàCFS 17 "OMBHFO "VG (SVOE EFTTFO FOUTUBOE FJO 17 7FSCPU JN 4PFTUFS 4UBEULFSO %JF 0QUJL EFS 17 "OMBHFO JTU WPS BMMFN CFJ EFO JO 4PFTU XFJU WFSCSFJUFUFO EFOLNBMHFTDIàU[UFO (FCÊVEFO VOE 1SJWBUIÊVTFSO FJO HSP FT 1SPCMFN %FOL

Standard PV-Anlagen

17 4DIJOEFM

&SUSBH 5FDIUJMF &BTZ

(FCÊVEFEBUFO

'BTTBEFOTDIOJUU

1

2

4 )BMUFSVOH

1

4DSFX 8àSUI "TTZ 4, XIFFMIFBE Y NN

3 4

'BTTBEFOnÊDIF

28 m²

,8Q

"O[BIM EFS .PEVMF

1244 Module

3 KWp

"VTSJDIUVOH 'BTTBEFOBVTSJDIUVOH "C[VH &JOTUSBIMVOHTNFOHF

4àE ½TUMJDI

(SBE 25% 75%

Y

,8I ,8Q

,8I ,8Q Y ,8Q

2.025 KWh im Jahr

4POOFOTUVOEFO

$*4 4DIJFGFSQMBUUFO %VNNZ "DSZMHMBT

DN Y DN Y NN

2 3

17 %BDIQGBOOFO N¤ .PEVMF

900

,8I B

5,6 KWh am Tag

.JU FJOFS 'BTTBEFOnÊDIF WPO N¤ LBOO NBO JO FJOFS 4UVO EF ,8Q FMFLUSJTDIF &OFS HJF FS[FVHFO %B[V LPNNU EJF &JOTUSBIMVOHTNFOHF WPO EJF BVT EFS (FCÊV EFBVTSJDIUVOH FSNJUUFMU XJSE 4PFTU FSIÊMU EVSDITDIOJUUMJDI 4POOFOTUVOEFO JN +BIS EJF FCFOGBMMT JO EJF 3FDIOVOH NJUFJOnJF FO *OTHFTBNU FS [JFMU EJF 17 4DIJOEFMGBTTBEF FJOFO &SUSBH WPO ,8I BN 5BH EBT TJOE JN +BIS ,8I B

PV-Schindeln & PV-Dachpfannen 6OBVGGÊMMJHF *OUFHSBUJPO

&SUSBH +BIS 5BH %BDI

,8I B ,8I

'BTTBEF

,8I B ,8I

Gesamt

4.162,5 KWh/a 11,5 KWh

,PTUFO

#FTDISFJCVOH

%BDI

&VSP

0QUJL

7JFMGÊMUJH JOEJWJEVFMM

'BTTBEF

&VSP

7PSUFJMF

(FTBNU

= 55.000 Euro

1BTTU TJDI PQUJNBM BO "VTOVU[FO EFS 'MÊDIF &SGàMMU 'BTTBEFOBVGHBCFO

/BDIUFJMF

)PIF ,PTUFO )PIFS "VGXBOE

&UFSOJUGBTTBEFOQMBUUF

4 5

"MVNJOJVN VOUFSLPOTUSVLUJPO

5 6

)PM[XFSLTUPGGQMBUUF

7

)PM[GBTFSEÊNNVOH DN

6

8

%BNQGTQFSSF

6

9

-FINTUFJO 'BDIXFSL

DN Y DN Y DN

7 8 9

#BDIFMPSBSCFJU@7FSFJOCBSLFJU WPO 1IPUPWPMUBJL %FOLNBMTDIVU[@1SPG . 1GFJM@"OOB 4DIVM[F 8JFIFOCSBVL


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.