CAMPUS T
W
R
P2
Ohio State has distributed another survey to assess the campus climate surrounding sexual harassment.
ARTS&LIFE
ALGER MAGAZINE
P5
P9
The CCWA-affiliated magazine contributed commentary about Russia’s relationship with Syria.
A local musician is on tour with Magic Man during its Hotline Spring tour.
SPORTS
P12
An Ohio State synchronized swimmer won a national title at the U.S. Collegiate Championships.
The student voice of the Ohio State University
Wednesday, April 20, 2016
thelantern.com
Timeline of The Lantern’s public-records requests and university responses Dec. 24 The Lantern sends initial public-records request to OSU.
Feb. 26 OSU fulfills The Lantern’s records requests.
March 4 The Lantern challenges the university’s fulfillment of the request.
@TheLantern
Michigan/Michigan State
Ohio State March 21 The Lantern sends public-records requests to U-M and MSU.
Year 136, Issue No. 37
April 8 OSU stands behind its use of FERPA and provides more data sets.
April 12 U-M and MSU fulfill The Lantern’s records request.
Online calculus class attracts big numbers Jay Panandiker
DENNY CHECK | MANAGING EDITOR FOR DESIGN
A timeline showing when The Lantern requested and received information from three universities regarding athletes’ academic performance.
Athletic records requests partially denied Amanda Vaughn
News Director vaughn.246@osu.edu
Alex Drummer
Managing Editor for Content drummer.18@osu.edu This is the first article in a twopart series. The second article will focus on the data provided regarding the relationship between athletics and academics. The performance of college athletes is often put on display under the bright lights of stadiums and gymnasiums. Information about these students’ performance in the classroom, though, is sometimes kept in the dark. To evaluate the relationship between athletics and academics, The Lantern submitted public records requests to Ohio State seeking information about athletes’ GPAs and attendance rates, among other things. The university’s response included redacted columns of data and inconsistencies. Though it was asked for 10 years of data, OSU only provided the average GPAs for each sports team for seven years, from 2009
Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State respond inconsistently to The Lantern’s requests for athletes’ academic data to 2015. OSU initially also only provided Spring Semester data, although Autumn Semester data was later provided upon another request. In a document containing average sports team GPAs that OSU provided to The Lantern, several columns in the tables were blacked out. These columns contained the number of players who fell within certain GPA ranges. When The Lantern challenged this redaction, Director of Public Records Rob Moormann stood by OSU’s decision, and he said sharing the information would violate the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, a federal law that aims to protect the privacy rights of students. “In combination with other available information, the redacted GPA data is linkable to specific students and would allow others to identify the student,” Moormann
said in an email. “The redacted data is therefore consistent with FERPA’s definition for ‘personally identifiable information.’” Frank LoMonte, lawyer and executive director of the Student Press Law Center, said he sees universities using and misinterpreting FERPA as a common practice when dealing with data sets. “Years ago, the Department of Education issued some advice about releasing small numerical sets and how a very small numerical set could compromise FERPA privacy. But this is what they meant by that: Don’t release a small numerical set if that set itself gives away something confidential about an identifiable person,” LoMonte said in an email. LoMonte went on to explain that if someone requesting information about students asked for an ethnicity breakdown of the data,
and, hypothetically there were only two Latino students, people might be able to identify them if the information was made public, and thus the use of FERPA would be appropriate. “But that’s all they meant: Don’t release the number if the number actually exposes confidential information from a student’s record,” LoMonte said. “The way that schools have sometimes interpreted this — particularly schools with very dumb lawyers or very obstructionist lawyers — is, ‘Don’t ever release any small numbers,’ which is not at all what the federal government said or could have intended.” Chris Davey, an OSU spokesman, stood by OSU’s application of FERPA in this request. “We have no interest in shielding records from the media. We do have an interest in protecting the privacy of our students not only because it is federal law, but because it is the right thing to do,” Davey said in an email. He maintained that the shielded data could be used to identify certain students. “We stand by our own lawyers’ RECORDS CONTINUES ON 3
President’s Prize encourages grads to engage with the world Shangquan Shi Lantern reporter shi.719@osu.edu
SAMANTHA HOLLINGSHEAD | PHOTO EDITOR
University President Michael Drake.
Ohio State recently founded the President’s Prize in order to support graduating seniors who are passionate about social change. Starting this year, two will be chosen annually as President’s Prize scholars. For this year, the award is open to any full-time senior students with a minimum 2.0 GPA who will graduate in Autumn 2016, Spring 2017 or Summer 2017. Students need to submit an original and creative project idea aimed at improving people’s lives in a local, national or global community. “Ohio State is focused on help-
ing to solve the critical issues of our time,” University President Michael Drake said in a release. “I look forward to seeing the incredible innovations of our newest alumni as they harness the power and knowledge of Buckeye Nation for change.” Each of the recipients will not only receive a living stipend of $50,000 and another $50,000 in startup funding, but they will also have various opportunities to connect with OSU faculty staff, donors and alumni, as well as outside partners and companies, according to OSU’s website. The project proposals do not need to be associated with students’ areas of study, according to OSU’s website. Students from all areas of study will be consid-
ered as long as they care about the welfare of others and are aware of social inequalities. Some students who are interested in social change are excited about this new prize. Maryem Menad, a fourth-year in biology, is involved with Alpha Phi Omega, a fraternity that does service activities on and off campus. “I think it’s definitely a great opportunity for people who are trying to make differences to be able to get benefits because there are a lot of people taking a lot of loans to continue their education,” Menad said. “So being able to have a good portion of it covered would definitely be beneficial.” Sterling Clemmons, a first-year PRIZE CONTINUES ON 4
Engagement Editor panandiker.1@osu.edu How many people can take a calculus class? The limit does not exist. Calculus is a class that people take as a prerequisite for dozens of majors around campus and at colleges across the country. One course, titled Calculus One or Mooculus, functions as an introduction to calculus both for those who are new to the subject and those who just want to review concepts. So far, hundreds of thousands of people have taken part in the course on Coursera, an online-education website that partners with universities around the country, and more than 250,000 have participated through the OSU website, said Jim Fowler, an assistant professor in the Department of Mathematics. The YouTube channel also just recently surpassed 1 million views.
OSU professors created massively open online course Mooculus is a collaborative effort between several math professors at OSU and is led by Fowler. The course is a mooc, or massively open online course, which means that anyone with a computer and an Internet connection can learn topics, such as limits and derivatives. Mooculus is made up of three components: lecture videos, an online textbook and interactive homework problems, Fowler said. Fowler said he started Mooculus because he finds teaching math fun and rewarding. He added that he thought the course could fill a new niche. There are a lot of videos that show the process of solving calculus problems, but fewer that celebrate the concepts behind calculus. He said the Mooculus videos try to explain a lot of these concepts and that the homework component is also more interactive. Fowler said the group of professors who organized the project chose to do calculus because it is often the gateway STEM course that is needed to get into many majors. “I think a lot of people see a calculus textbook, and maybe they don’t find the words and CALC CONTINUES ON 4