the LION’S
ROA R
Non-Profit Organization U.S. Postage PAID Boston, MA Permit No. 54523
Volume 31, Issue 2 140 Brandeis Road Newton Centre, MA 02459
Newton South High School’s Student Newspaper · Newton, MA · Established 1984 · September 5, 2014
City responds to Fleishman’s plagiarism Newton community reacts to the School Committee’s handling of the incident, discusses the impact the issue will have on the school system and district Nathaniel Bolter & Hyunnew Choi
Sr. News Editor, Editor-in-Chief Superintendent David Fleishman stepped up to the podium on June 9 and gave a graduation speech that the Newton community would certainly remember. The superintendent’s speech, as reported by The Roar in a July 23 special online edition, had included five passages plagiarized from Governor Deval Patrick’s May 18 commencement speech delivered at Boston University. In response to the The Roar’s article, Fleishman issued a statement acknowledging his wrongdoing and the School Committee issued a concurrent statement announcing that Fleishman would be docked a week’s pay — roughly $5,000 — for his actions. Fleishman also sent a letter of apology to Newton parents and spoke publicly about the incident at a School Committee meeting, at which committee members appeared ready to put the graduation speech behind them and move on to tackling other issues of the 2014-15 school year. Some in the Newton community, however, are reluctant to do so, unhappy with both the plagiarism itself and the manner in which the city handled the situation. Addressing the Issue
photo by Bella Ehrlich
School Committee Chair Matt Hills (right) gives a statement regarding the plagiarism incident at a public school committee meeting on Aug. 13 as Superintendent David Fleishman (left) looks on.
Several community members expressed their discontent with how Fleishman first addressed the incident. Fleishman’s statement on July 24 recognized his mistake, but did not include an apology.
Fleishman, however, clarified that the first statement was just an acknowledgement that was sent to The Roar and select media outlets intended to notify them that he was open to interviews — not a letter to the Newton community — and expressed his regrets about failing to release the apology sooner. “The most important message I really want out there is that I made a serious mistake, acknowledged it [and learned] from it and really just how much I regret and apologize for my actions,” he said. Junior Emma Henderson said the School Committee also failed to appropriately address the issue, citing the committee’s awareness of the incident since June 27, but their failure to act until the information was made public. “We’re taught to be honest and transparent about what we turn in our school work, and for them to not be upfront about the entire thing, even though they were made aware for the incident, does not set a good example for anyone in the Newton Public Schools,” she said. School Committee Chair Matt Hills, on the other hand, said the committee dealt with the issue according to protocol. “[We] handled this as we would handle any personnel issue — confidentially. There is no circumstance under which our discussion of this personnel issue was going to be handled publicly,” he said. “We were hoping to meet in executive session the beginning of the week of July 28 to make SUPERINTENDENT, 3
Union, School Committee at odds over PARCC test Nathaniel Bolter & David Li Sr. News Editors
The School Committee voted unanimously at a meeting on July 16 to adopt the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) test for grades three through eight for the 2014-15 school year rather than continue with the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS). The decision has exacerbated tensions between the School Committee and the teachers’ union, the Newton
Teachers Association (NTA), which publicly objected to the switch. Unlike the MCAS, which determines student competency, the PARCC test, which is aligned with the Common Core standards that were a product of President Obama’s 2009 Race to the Top initiative, is designed to measure college readiness. The Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education will vote on the adoption of PARCC as the state’s official standardized test in the fall of 2015. In order to gather more information on the new test, school systems will be provided with the option to admin-
ister the PARCC exam instead of the MCAS for the 2014-15 school year. PARCC’s implementation in Newton will be limited to grades three through eight because the MCAS is still required of high school students to determine graduation eligibility. Newton Public Schools’ (NPS) switch to the PARCC test, which will also be used to evaluate teacher performance, was not just up to the School Committee, according to NTA President Michael Zilles. PARCC, 2
INSIDE THIS ISSUE:
Nicotine regulations
New restrictions issued on tobacco and nicotine products to minimize youth use.
13
common app
The Roar begins to follow four seniors in their college application process.
15
State level rugby
Three seniors discuss their experience playing on the state select rugby team this summer.
20
NEWS 2 GLOBAL UPDATE 5 EDITORIALS 6 OPINIONS 9 CENTERFOLD 12 FEATURES 15 SPORTS 20