C YNIC
Harry Potter is back, more morbid and dark than before
THE VERMONT
6
The University of Vermont’s independent voice since 1883
NEWS
w w w . v e r m o n t c y n i c . c o m | Tu e s d a y , D e c e m b e r 7 , 2 0 1 0 – Vo l u m e 1 2 7 I s s u e 1 4 | B u r l i n g t o n , Ve r m o n t
Knodell declines proposed 1-3 public course evaluations
Local wood harvested for Aiken
LIFE
‘Debonaires’ debut on UVMtv
4-5
ARTS
Lazerdisk Party Sex profiled
6
SPECTACLE A look through the lens: Potbelly
7
OPINION
‘My Wiki is leaking’
Student reactions mixed over SGA’s boycott Photo Illustration by Damir Alisa
By Katy Petiford Staff Writer After the Student Government Association asked students to boycott course evaluations, Interim Provost Jane Knodell responded on Dec. 5, declining to support the resolution. “The timing of your resolution made it an almost certainty that we would be unable to meet your ‘demands,’ to say nothing of the fact that I’d like not to think of ours as a community that proposes change and innovation by way of demand,” Knodell said in an email. ! "#$! %&'()*'+,! -./! 0'+(12! sent a campuswide email on Dec. 2 to students asking them to participate in the boycott. “The [SGA] at the University of Vermont calls for a publishable questions section, drafted by the [SGA], to be added as part of the course evaluations offered at the end of the spring semester 2011,” the resolution stated. The SGA asked the provost, council of deans and United Academics to realize students’ desire to have access to course evaluation results by Dec. 1, the resolution stated. “Use this opportunity to stand with us and take a stand against course evaluations and show the faculty and administration that we are serious about this matter,” 0'+(123(!'451)6!(,1,'*7 Knodell said that she recieved the resolution on Nov. 15, right before Thanksgiving break, and was unable to consult with those necessary to make a decision in that time frame. “Further confounding our
ability to make progress was the fact that your resolution did not include the publishable questions themselves,” she said. SGA Senator Asher Lober said that he was not surprised that the SGA did not hear back from the administration by Dec. 1. “The administration’s lack of response was expected,” he said. “Student perceptions of academic 8916),:! 1,! ;<0! 5'1+! +.,2)+=! ,.! them. They are quite content to dole out merit pay and deliver promotions to tenure based upon research records and research records alone. They don’t feel the need to enter into a dialogue with anyone who doesn’t already hold a doctorate.” In addition to providing more information to students, publishable evaluations would show information about changes (,9*'+,(!>1+,?!0'+(12!(1)*7
However, many students are not backing up the boycott. Sophomore Dan Suder said he doesn’t like the idea because he thinks class evaluations have an important place. @"'&A)B'(!6)C'!D1,'0:%&.E'((.&! &'166:!>.&C!/+'?F!"9*'&!(1)*7!!@G2'! argument that they only contain extremely polar opinions is true, but I question the difference we’d see when results of course evaluations were shared.” Academic Affairs Committee Chair Gisele Nelson said that she feels some students may not be taking the course evaluations seriously. @",9*'+,(!,21,!*.+3,!6)C'!/66)+=! them out might use the boycott as 1+!'HB9('!E.&!+.,!/66)+=!,2'5!.9,?F! Nelson said. However, the SGA is not asking students to deny professors of feedback altogether because they
recognize that evaluations are used to improve classes, she said. “[The] SGA strongly encourages students to use the ‘comments’ section of the course evaluations to provide productive feedback to professors,” Nelson said. I+! 1**),).+! ,.! J:'&(! 1&.9+*! campus to notify people of the boycott, students will make announcements to their class after the professor has left the room 1+*! K'E.&'! 'A1691,).+(! 1&'! /66'*! out, SGA Vice President David 01B)'>)BL!(1)*7 “The declaration of a boycott is a most unfortunate position for the SGA to take,” Knodell said. “If students choose not to participate in the course evaluation process, it will only serve to diminish their voices, and I urge you to reconsider the advice you have given your colleagues and rescind your call for a boycott.”
Burlington Free Press. “This has caused a lot of problems, and some have even gone so far as suggesting that having exams on Saturdays is indicative of an underlying suppression of Judaism, because the Jewish Sabbath is Saturday and it never crossed anybody’s mind to hold exams on Sunday,” Speaker of the SGA Senate Claire Chevrier said. Between 1,800 and 2,000 undergraduate students are Jewish, as well as 400 graduate and medical students, according ,.! ,2'! ;<0! M'>)(2! B.559+),:! Hillel’s website. “I think Saturday exams 1&'! 9+E1)&! (N'B)/B166:! K'B19('! it’s always been a weekend day throughout growing up,” Wolfson
(1)*7!!@I,3(!16>1:(!K''+!/A'!*1:(!1! how many days universities must week of school, with Saturday and have classes,” Chevrier said. “The Sunday off.” Faculty Senate decided that there would be exams on Saturday.” %1&,!.E!,2'!&'1(.+!;<0!*)*!+.,! “It conflicts with ... meet the required class quota is my faith. I’m sure they because students had a full week didn’t even consider off for Thanksgiving, Chevrier said. 01+:! (,9*'+,(! >)66! 21A'! ,.! the fact that they have having Sunday exams accept a Saturday exam, but Jewish due to religious students can request rescheduling from their professors based on reasons.” religious guidelines, according to ;<03(!1B1*'5)B!N.6)B:7!! Wolfson said that he is happy Ben Wolfson to hear that the administration will UVM senior discontinue Saturday exams. This fall exam schedule will “It’s unfortunate they decided include exams Saturday, Dec. 11 to do this to begin with,” he said. through Friday, Dec. 17. “But it’s good to hear that they “There are certain guidelines for won’t make the mistake again.”
8-9 To synagogue or Saturday exams
DISTRACT Check out this week’s comics
10
SPORTS
The ‘what if’ of college playoffs
11-12
By August Kuron Cynic Correspondent When senior Ben Wolfson heads into his entrepreneurship exam, many others of his faith will be headed to synagogue. The administration’s decision to hold Saturday exams this semester has a caused a stir in the Jewish community, due to a B.+J)B,!>),2!,2'!"1KK1,27!! “It’s not fair,” Wolfson said. “It B.+J)B,(!>),2!5'!K')+=!M'>)(2!1+*! my faith. I’m sure they didn’t even consider having Sunday exams due to religious reasons.” The Faculty Senate voted to remove Saturday exams from future academic years, but this semester’s Dec. 11 exams will remain due to scheduling, according to the