Russian Disinformation after the Outbreak of War in Ukraine
On February 24th, Russia initiated a full-scale war with Ukraine, accompanied by a coordinated disinformation campaign aimed at various audiences, including Russian, Ukrainian, Western, and even those from Asia and Africa. The main objectives of this disinformation were to justify Russia’s actions, create a negative image of Ukraine, and weaken the relationship between Ukraine and Poland and other Western countries.
In the early days of the war, Russian disinformation targeted primarily its society, to prevent access to accurate information about the war. As a result, false news was widely broadcast on Russian television. After the start of the aggression, Russian propaganda centers primarily reported that the “special military operation” was necessary to remove the so-called “Nazis” who were allegedly ruling Ukraine. The West was also accused of planning to attack Russia with the help of Kyiv. It was claimed that Ukrainians were torturing Russian civilians in the eastern regions of Ukraine and that Russia’s
actions were necessary to liberate them. There were even reports that Kyiv was planning to gas people in concentration camps, and Russia could not allow it. These narratives aimed to justify Russia’s actions and blame Ukraine and Western countries.
An important aspect of Russian disinformation efforts directed at Western societies was the denial of crimes committed by Russian military forces. At the onset of the war, disinformation was widely disseminated claiming that Russia was not targeting civilian objects or civilians, but only military targets, to overthrow the “Nazi government” in Ukraine. In reality, Russian military forces have been attacking residential buildings, schools, preschools, and hospitals, as well as committing crimes against the civilian population from the very beginning of the war. Additionally, they were bombing military-educational facilities, airports, and other vital infrastructure. A significant event that generated a lot of false information was the massacre in Bucha,
wojna dezinformacyjna przeciwko Polsce, CAPD, Warszawa 2017, https://pulaski.pl/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/RAPORT-Rosyjska-wojna-dezinformacyjna-przeciwko-Polsce.pdf, s. 9.
6 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
5. K. Wóycicki, M. Kowalska, A. Lelonek, Rosyjska
committed by Russian soldiers. When this crime was exposed, Russian propaganda outlets claimed that the footage of dead bodies in the streets of the town had been fabricated by the Ukrainians and was being used to conceal previously disclosed video recordings that allegedly showed Ukrainians brutally torturing Russian prisoners of war. Another disinformation narrative suggested that the massacre was a psychological operation carried out by Great Britain. However, it is clear that the massacre in Bucha was committed by
Russian soldiers during their occupation of the town. They killed around 400 civilians, and this has been confirmed by reputable sources such as Bellingcat 6 , Atlantic Council 7, and BBC 8 . Evidence of Russian war crimes in Ukraine has been compiled by organizations such as Human Rights Watch. Its Director for Europe and Central Asia, Hugh Williamson, stated that the documented cases constitute unspeakable cruelty and violence against Ukrainian civilians and that rape, murder, and other acts of violence
6. E. Higgins, Russia’s Bucha ‘Facts’ Versus the Evidence, April 4, 2022, https://www.bellingcat.com/ news/2022/04/04/russias-bucha-facts-versus-the-evidence/.
7. Russian War Report: Kremlin claims Bucha massacre was staged by Ukraine, Atlantic Council, April 4, 2022, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/new-atlanticist/russian-war-report-kremlin-claims-bucha-massacre-wasstaged-by-ukraine/#bucha.
8. Bucha killings: Satellite image of bodies site contradicts Russian claims, BBC, April 11, 2022, https://www.bbc.com/ news/60981238.
7 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
SOURCE: JAKUB SZYMCZUK KPRP
committed by Russian forces should be investigated as war crimes 9 .
About the Bucha massacre, Russian propaganda centers employed their usual tactic of denying facts and placing blame elsewhere. Another example is the statement of Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, who in March 2022, when interviewed after a meeting with Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmitry Kuleba, stated that Russia did not attack Ukraine and does not plan to attack other countries 10 .
Another event around which Russian propaganda outlets regularly disseminate false information is the missile attack in Kramatorsk, which Russia carried out on April 8, 2022. Approximately 50 people were killed, and over 100 were injured 11 . Russia attempted to blame Ukraine for the attack, reporting that a Tochka-U missile, which is used by Ukrainian armed forces, was used in it.
Moscow stated that its forces withdrew Tochka-U missiles and are not using them anymore. It was argued that the attack was related to the fact that Ukraine considers the population of Kramatorsk to be disloyal. In reality, the Russian army still uses this missile system, as confirmed by video footage of transports passing through Belarus in March 2022. The BBC, among other sources, reported on the vast documentation of the use of Tochka-U against Ukrainian targets 12 .
One of the key areas of focus for Russian disinformation efforts is energy. In September of last year, when the Nord Stream and Nord Stream 2 gas pipelines were damaged, Russian propagandists sought to blame Poland, claiming that it was acting on orders from the United States. They suggested that the United States wanted European countries to import American LNG gas instead of Russian gas while ignoring the fact that Russia
9. Ukraine: Apparent War Crimes in Russia-Controlled Areas, Human Rights Watch, March 3, 2022, https://www.hrw. org/news/2022/04/03/ukraine-apparent-war-crimes-russia-controlled-areas.
10. S. Ankel, Russia repeats claim it didn’t attack Ukraine, saying it was forced to defend to pro-Kremlin regions, Business Insider, 10 III 2022, https://www.businessinsider.com/russia-repeats-claim-did-not-attack-ukraine-2022-3?IR=T.
11. The situation of human rights in Ukraine in the context of the armed attack by the Russian Federation, The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, 24 February to 15 May 2022, https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/country-reports/situation-human-rights-ukraine-context-armed-attack-russian-federation, p. 12.
12. Ukraine war: What weapon killed 50 people in station attack?, BBC, April 13, 2022, https://www.bbc.com/ news/61079356.
8 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
SOURCE: TOMASZ BIDERMANN SHUTTERSTOCK
had been using gas blackmail against Germany by regularly restricting deliveries 13. Likely, the damage to the pipelines was actually caused by Russia to exacerbate the energy crisis in Europe and increase uncertainty and chaos in the market.
Russian propagandists also frequently use false narratives about supposed Polish plans to take over the western part of Ukraine. These narratives have been repeated since the start of the war, including in a November 2022 speech by Vladimir Putin on Russia’s Unity Day. He claimed that some Polish political elites were supporting the idea of creating a large state from sea to sea, and emphasized that the idea of Poland absorbing Ukraine was still alive and well, with Russia as the guarantor of Ukraine’s security. This statement was later repeated on various pro-Russian websites.
In addition to these false narratives, these websites also claimed that Poland’s aid for Ukrainian refugees was merely a facade and that there were political discussions in Poland about borders, with some elites in power considering the territory of western Ukraine and western Belarus to be Polish, which could lead to attempts to reclaim those lands. Furthermore, they suggested that Poland was increasing the size of its army near the border with Belarus, which could pose a significant threat to that country. These narratives are primarily directed at Ukrainians, Belarusians, and Russians, and aim to create an image of Poland as a dangerous state. Similar messages have also been directed against Polish society, suggesting that Ukraine is striving to occupy eastern territories in Poland. However, these narratives are completely false, and in reality, neither Poland nor Ukraine have any territorial claims against each other.
One aspect of Russian disinformation targeting Poland is its alleged involvement in the ongoing war. In the latter part of last year, false information was circulated claiming that Polish special services had participated in the war. Specifically, it was alleged that a team of Polish special forces officers had appeared in the town of Marhanec in the Dniepropetrovsk region to identify and repress pro-Russian residents. These officers were said to be dressed in Ukrainian uniforms and operating under NATO command in cooperation with the Security Service of Ukraine. These baseless accusations against Poland and NATO are intended to depict the Russian-Ukrainian war as a confrontation with a „Russophobic” NATO and to portray the actions of Poland and NATO as aggressive towards Russia. By claiming that NATO is directly involved in the war in Ukraine, Russia aims to justify its actions as purely defensive.
Similar false reports had earlier emerged about the alleged involvement of Polish mercenaries in the war, with claims that about 1,200 of them had died. These claims stem from the fact that the International Legion of Defense of Ukraine (ILDU), to which more than 20,000 foreign volunteers, including Poles, have applied, is participating in the war in Ukraine 14. However, it is important to note that volunteers sign up to serve voluntarily, according to a special procedure, and their motivation is not financial, therefore they should not be classified as mercenaries.
In addition to these false claims, Russian disinformation also focused on the UN grain agreement, concerning the safe export of Ukrainian grain through the Black Sea. In October, the President of Russia announced the suspension of Russia’s participation in the agreement, only to tell about a return to the agreement a few days later,
13. M. Menkiszak, Rosja: przygotowania do wojny gazowej, OSW, July 22, 2022, https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/ analizy/2022-07-22/rosja-przygotowania-do-wojny-gazowej.
14. I.C. Tang, The Latest in a Long Line: Ukraine’s International Legion and a History of Foreign Fighters, Harvard International Review, 2 IX 2022, https://hir.harvard.edu/the-latest-in-a-long-line-ukraines-international-legion-and-ahistory-of-foreign-fighters/
9 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
warning that Moscow could withdraw again 15 . The reason for withdrawing from the agreement was the alleged use by Ukraine of the humanitarian corridor as a shield for an attack on Sevastopol, and it was also claimed that it was used to blow up the Crimean Bridge. These accusations were false, as the UN representative responsible for monitoring the humanitarian corridor stated that no ships were in the corridor during the air attack on Sevastopol and that drones could not have been launched from it 16 .
On November 15, 2022, Russia conducted a massive missile attack on Ukraine, during which it launched approximately 100 maneuvering missiles from the air and sea. Although most of
the missiles were shot down, some of them hit Ukrainian territory, particularly energy infrastructure objects, significantly escalating the situation in the country. On the day of the attack, two Russian-made missiles fell on Polish territory near the border with Ukraine, resulting in the deaths of two civilians. Initially, it was stated that they could have been stray Russian missiles, but later findings revealed that they were likely Ukrainian anti-aircraft missiles that had been launched to destroy Russian missiles but missed their target and hit Polish territory.
The event was quickly exploited by Russian propaganda. Narratives then emerged suggesting that Poland was planning to drag NATO into a
15. I. Wiśniewska, Rosja wraca do porozumienia zbożowego, OSW, 3 XI 2022, https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/ analizy/2022-11-03/rosja-wraca-do-porozumienia-zbozowego.
16. T. Tvauri, Did Ukraine use the humanitarian corridor for a drone attack on Sevastopol?, Mythdetecotr, November 7, 2022, https://mythdetector.ge/en/did-ukraine-use-the-humanitarian-corridor-for-a-drone-attack-on-sevastopol/.
10 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
SOURCE: THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE OF UKRAINE FACEBOOK
war with Russia and that the West was trying to start World War III. This was commented on by, among others, the Vice Chairman of the Russian Federation Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev, who wrote on Twitter that “the incident with the alleged Ukrainian missile strike on a Polish farm proves only one thing: by conducting a hybrid war with Russia, the West is getting closer to a world war.” It was also suggested that Ukraine posed
a threat to Poland and other NATO countries. Meanwhile, according to another narrative, Russia was not conducting missile attacks on targets near the border with Poland at the time. The goal of the Russian messages about this event was to create panic and chaos in Polish society and weaken Poland’s support for military aid to Ukraine.
Disinformation about Ukrainian Refugees in Poland
Disinformation about Ukrainian refugees in Poland has been prevalent since the start of the Russian aggression. The conflict has led to a large number of Ukrainian citizens fleeing threatened territories and seeking refuge in Poland. Polish authorities and society have shown exceptional commitment to helping those in need, yet propaganda centers have been spreading false information in Poland about Ukrainian refugees to incite fear and create a negative image of Ukrainians, thus discouraging Poles from helping and supporting them.
At the onset of the war, when the first wave of refugees began to arrive in Poland, reports emerged falsely claiming that people of color were coming from Ukraine and attacking Polish women and children. False information was spread that crimes such as attacks, rapes, and burglaries had occurred in Przemyśl and the surrounding area, creating a sense of danger and calls for defense. These actions were aimed at inciting hatred and questioning the sense of accepting
people coming from Ukraine.
In May 2022, a tragic incident occurred in Warsaw when a young man was murdered on a popular street. Unfortunately, this event was exploited by Russian propaganda, which disseminated false information claiming that Ukrainians were responsible for the murder. Furthermore, it was falsely suggested that most crimes committed in Poland were committed by Ukrainian citizens 17. Old materials were also manipulated and presented as evidence of Ukrainian crimes, further fueling hostility between Poles and Ukrainians. It is crucial to be aware that any similar event that evokes strong emotions may be used by Russia to spread disinformation about Ukrainians.
Russia has been engaged in a sustained disinformation campaign targeting Poland and Ukraine for years, to undermine the relationship between the two countries and discredit them on the international stage. These efforts have accelerated
17. K. Lipka, Nie, podejrzanymi o zabójstwo na Nowym Świecie nie są obcokrajowcy, FakeNews.pl, May 20, 2022, https://fakenews.pl/spoleczenstwo/nie-podejrzanymi-o-zabojstwo-na-nowym-swiecie-nie-sa-obcokrajowcy/.
11 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
since 2014, with a particular focus on Russia’s aggression toward Ukraine. Initially, Russia sought to justify its actions and downplay the failures of its military operations. Currently, a significant portion of Russian disinformation is focused on discrediting Ukraine and accusing Poland and the West of hostile actions towards Russia. Additionally, there are dangerous false reports about Ukrainian refugees in Poland, aimed at stirring up hostility toward providing aid to Ukraine. Moscow will likely continue to use disinformation to target both countries in the future. Disinformation is a powerful and accessible tool with a wide reach and low costs, and with the advent of new technologies, it is becoming even more efficient.
To effectively combat the threat of Russian disinformation campaigns, both Ukraine and Poland
must take a proactive approach. This includes identifying and diagnosing these campaigns, understanding their methods and goals, and limiting their reach and influence. One important aspect of this approach is prebunking, proactively exposing and debunking false narratives before they have a chance to spread. The goal of prebunking is to educate the public and empower them to counter disinformation. Additionally, building trust and promoting transparency in government and public institutions is crucial in the fight against disinformation. Low trust in government makes disinformation campaigns more successful while fostering trust and transparency makes it more likely for people to recognize and reject false narratives.
12 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
SOURCE: THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE OF UKRAINE FACEBOOK
References
Ankel, S., Russia repeats claim it didn’t attack Ukraine, saying it was forced to defend to pro-Kremlin regions, Business Insider, March 10, 2022, https://www.businessinsider.com/russia-repeats-claim-did-not-attack-ukraine-2022-3?IR=T.
Bucha killings: Satellite image of bodies site contradicts Russian claims, BBC, April 11, 2022, https:// www.bbc.com/news/60981238.
Higgins, E., Russia’s Bucha ‘Facts’ Versus the Evidence, April 4, 2022, https://www.bellingcat. com/news/2022/04/04/russias-bucha-facts-versus-the-evidence/.
Kurowska, X., Reshetnikov, A., Russia’s trolling complex at home and abroad , European Union Institute for Security Studies, 2018.
Lipka, K., Nie, podejrzanymi o zabójstwo na Nowym Świecie nie są obcokrajowcy, FakeNews. pl, May 20, 2022, https://fakenews.pl/spoleczenstwo/nie-podejrzanymi-o-zabojstwo-na-nowymswiecie-nie-sa-obcokrajowcy/
Menkiszak, M., Rosja: przygotowania do wojny gazowej, OSW, July 22, 2022, https://www.osw. waw.pl/pl/publikacje/analizy/2022-07-22/rosja-przygotowania-do-wojny-gazowej.
Pellegatta, A., Disinformation from Russia: Kremlin info-ops in Europe, Italian Institute for International Political Studies, June 3, 2020, https://www.ispionline.it/en/pubblicazione/disinformation-russia-kremlin-info-ops-europe-26796.
Russian War Report: Kremlin claims Bucha massacre was staged by Ukraine, Atlantic Council, April 4, 2022, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/ blogs/new-atlanticist/russian-war-report-kremlin-claims-bucha-massacre-was-staged-byukraine/#bucha.
Tang, I. C., The Latest in a Long Line: Ukraine’s International Legion and a History of Foreign Fighters , Harvard International Review, September 2, 2022, https://hir.harvard.edu/thelatest-in-a-long-line-ukraines-international-legion-and-a-history-of-foreign-fighters/.
13 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
The situation of human rights in Ukraine in the context of the armed attack by the Russian Federation , The Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, 24 February to 15 May 2022, https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/country-reports/situation-human-rights-ukraine-context-armed-attack-russian-federation
Tvauri, T., Did Ukraine use the humanitarian corridor for a drone attack on Sevastopol?, Mythdetecotr, November 7, 2022, https://mythdetector. ge/en/did-ukraine-use-the-humanitarian-corridor-for-a-drone-attack-on-sevastopol/.
Ukraine: Apparent War Crimes in Russia-Controlled Areas, Human Rights Watch, March 3, 2022, https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/04/03/ ukraine-apparent-war-crimes-russia-controlledareas.
Ukraine war: What weapon killed 50 people in station attack?, BBC, April 13, 2022, https://www. bbc.com/news/61079356.
Author’s bio:
Mikołaj Rogalewicz
Wasiuta, O., Wasiuta, S., Kremlowska dezinformacja w Internecie i reakcja społeczeństw zachodnich, Przegląd Geopolityczny 34 (2020), http://cejsh.icm. edu.pl/cejsh/element/bwmeta1.element.desklight-fa9f1fc7-ca37-4e98-b76f-d7d08d86d7cb/c/ XXXIV-07-Wasiuta2.pdf
Wiśniewska, I., Rosja wraca do porozumienia zbożowego, OSW, November 3, 2022, https://www. osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/analizy/2022-11-03/rosja-wraca-do-porozumienia-zbozowego.
Wojna informacyjna w Internecie. Przeciwdziałanie prokremlowskiej dezinformacji w państwach Europy Środkowej i Wschodniej , Centrum Stosunków Międzynarodowych, 2017.
Wóycicki K., Kowalska M., Lelonek A., Rosyjska wojna dezinformacyjna przeciwko Polsce, CAPD, Warsaw, 2017, https://pulaski.pl/wp-content/ uploads/2015/02/RAPORT-Rosyjska-wojnadezinformacyjna-przeciwko-Polsce.pdf.
Senior analyst at the Demagog Association, a fact-checking organization. Author of numerous articles and analyses devoted to international relations, fact-checking, and disinformation. Participant of Kremlin Watchers Movement project, in which he deals with Russian disinformation. At various conferences, he presented papers on disinformation, cyberterrorism, Russian-Ukrainian conflict, and efforts to solve it, as well as actions of the EU aimed at combating terrorism. He is a mentor of the Akademia Fact-Checkingu.
14 www.warsawinstitute.org Special Report RUSSIAN DISINFORMATION AGAINST POLAND AND UKRAINE
© COPYRIGHT 2023 Warsaw Institute
opinions
and the positions
in materials
Warsaw Institute Wilcza St. 9, 00-538 Warsaw, Poland +48 22 417 63 15 office@warsawinstitute.org +48 22 417 63 15 THE TASK IS FINANCED BY NARODOWY INSTYTUT WOLNOŚCI - CENTRUM ROZWOJU SPOŁECZEŃSTWA OBYWATELSKIEGO UNDER THE GOVERNMENT PROGRAM FOR THE DEVELOPMENT FOR CIVIC ORGANIZATIONS PROO1A FOR 2018-2030.
The
given
held
in the Special Report solely reflect the views of authors.