Invicta sandstone dials by Watch Geeks

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Invicta sandstone dial is not natural sandstone.

A friend sent me a dial, movement and caseback from a Blue sandstone Invicta Model number 0050 and asked if I could have it examined by an expert. Today I met with a geologist at an area college and he informed me that no the dial was not natural sandstone and that it was probably glass with manmade grown crystals inside (you know the sparkly stuff). After my lesson in sandstone formation and observing the dial under a microscope I too am convinced that this dial is in no way natural by any stretch of the imagination. Just last Friday Eyal was asked just this question and his reply was "natural". My only question is why?

3 Lastest Threads by qwikfix Thread

Forum

General Invicta Watch Discussions

Last Poster

Replies Views

SeaVulture

219

5239

08-31-2010 03:01 PM

jskelton

425

07-28-2010 09:33 AM

secondplace

252

05-24-2010 12:14 AM

Invicta sandstone dial is not natural sandstone.

ASK JIM Truthful info should be out there for all to see.

General Japanese or Asian Watch Brands These TX models are stunning

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

Today, 03:03 PM

Last Post

Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Central Missouri Posts: 965 Real Name: Donnell

DJRock Senior Member Veteran Geek

OOPS!!! __________________

DJRock View Public Profile Send a private message to DJRock Send email to DJRock Find all posts by DJRock Add DJRock to Your Contacts

Today, 03:05 PM Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Suburbs of Beantown Posts: 1,945 Real Name: Jeff

OmegaMeister Senior Member Super Geek

Is it Swiss or Chinese "faux" sandstone? I only like the fake Swiss stuff myself. __________________

OmegaMeister View Public Profile Send a private message to OmegaMeister Find all posts by OmegaMeister Add OmegaMeister to Your Contacts #4

Today, 03:07 PM

mrblue

Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 2,441

Senior Member Super Geek

Here we go again .......................... Eyal had better reply .. or Diamond J or Meijun .. before this one gets outta hand too .. Blue

mrblue View Public Profile Send a private message to mrblue Find all posts by mrblue Add mrblue to Your Contacts

Today, 03:07 PM

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

If this is true, and I'm not saying I disbelieve you, then it's tragic in many ways. __________________

Hot fun in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#6 Today, 03:08 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Cleveland,Ohio Posts: 326 Real Name: Bob Stokes

rjaybass Senior Member Senior Geek

Here we go folks. Controversy time! Hope you packed a lunch cause it's gonna be a long trip...

rjaybass View Public Profile Send a private message to rjaybass Send email to rjaybass Find all posts by rjaybass Add rjaybass to Your Contacts

Today, 03:09 PM Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,394 Real Name: Jim

WatchGeek4Life Senior Member Super Geek

Now what!!! First we have the swiss made issue Then we have crystals instead of diamonds and now this!!! What is next, that our Meteorite dials are not real meteorite? I would like to hear the explanation from Invicta on this one. __________________

Breitling Bentley

WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

Today, 03:12 PM Join Date: May 2009 Location: Everett Wa. Posts: 4,020 Real Name: C.J.

reliefcp

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Here we go again! __________________

reliefcp View Public Profile Send a private message to reliefcp Find all posts by reliefcp Add reliefcp to Your Contacts #9

Today, 03:12 PM

strutn45

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

Senior Member True WatchGeek

Proof? Sounds like that other site's BS to me? __________________ "WHO DAT"

strutn45 View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#10 Today, 03:13 PM

rbart

Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: RI Posts: 818 Real Name: Ron Bartone

Senior Member Veteran Geek

Came from the same company that did the crystals - (diamonds) on that ladies watch they made. Wasn't there a post about that a few weeks ago? I wish Invicta used a totally different name instead of Invicta II. Its really effecting the brand Ron __________________ rbart

rbart View Public Profile Send a private message to rbart Send email to rbart Find all posts by rbart Add rbart to Your Contacts

#11

Today, 03:14 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

IF it's not sandstone there is a man made substance called Goldstone. The two photos below are Goldstone and not Sandstone.

Definition of Goldstone from wikipedia. "Goldstone is a type of glittering glass made in a low-oxygen reducing atmophere. The finished product can take a smooth polish and be carved into beads, figurines, or other artifacts suitable for semiprecious stone, and in fact goldstone is often mistaken for or misrepresented as a natural material." __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts #12

Today, 03:16 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 Proof? Sounds like that other site's BS to me? That's harsh. John's a respected member of this forum and he's talking about a personal experience. __________________

Hot fun in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB

Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#13

Today, 03:18 PM

rjones1994 Senior Member Super Geek

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sanford, Florida Posts: 1,056 Real Name: BOB

Ok what is up? I hope that this is not true, but even Swiss Legend uses a sandstone. Minds want to know.

rjones1994 View Public Profile Send a private message to rjones1994 Find all posts by rjones1994 Add rjones1994 to Your Contacts

#14

Today, 03:22 PM

WatchYaThink

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Sunnyvale, CA Posts: 3,139 Real Name: Larry

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

You know, I saw a report by at least one other person who had taken a Sandstone Invicta apart and commented that there was no way that was natural sandstone. I understand that dial has been sent to a geological institute for analysis. That was why I asked Eyal the other day when he was online if the Invicta sandstone dials were actual natural sandstone, or created sandstone. He replied "Natural!" Now we have the report from John in the OP that a professional has confirmed that the material in the Invicta sandstone dials is NOT natural sandstone. If this other report comes back the same way, I think that will constitute pretty conclusive proof. After the issue with the diamonds with no reply from Invicta, on top of the D-D and Swiss issues (and a few others) .... even though Eyal said outright in reply to my question that it was natural sandstone ..... at this point I wouldn't put anything past them, and with that recent history I think the burden of proof falls squarely on Invicta to come forward with a response to this (yet once again).

Maybe Eyal ordered these sandstone dials from the same company he ordered the diamond accent botiques from .... and he anticipated genuine sandstone and genuine diamonds, and didn't know what he was getting. AND ... as bad as that would be, it's actually the least possible bad scenario. __________________ "He who marches in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, for him a spinal cord would fully suffice" - Albert Einstein

WatchYaThink View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchYaThink Send email to WatchYaThink Find all posts by WatchYaThink Add WatchYaThink to Your Contacts

#15

Today, 03:22 PM Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

strutn45 Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB That's harsh. John's a respected member of this forum and he's talking about a personal experience. I'm talking about proof...thats harsh? __________________

"WHO DAT"

strutn45 View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#16 Today, 03:25 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 I'm talking about proof...thats harsh? No, it was the sounds like BS part. Forget it. __________________

in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB

Hot fun

Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts #17

Today, 03:27 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Springfield, MA Posts: 140

WatchFanatico Senior Member Senior Geek

I doesnt matter to me if its real sand or man made. What would bother me is being lied to, if it turns out that what John says is true. Not saying that I dont believe it.

WatchFanatico View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchFanatico Find all posts by WatchFanatico Add WatchFanatico to Your Contacts #18 Today, 03:28 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 Proof? Sounds like that other site's BS to me? What proof would be adequate? And more importantly how would this proof personally affect you?

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix

Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

#19

Today, 03:28 PM

invictaisthebestwatch

Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 31

Member Member Geek

In before thread is locked!

invictaisthebestwatch View Public Profile Send a private message to invictaisthebestwatch Find all posts by invictaisthebestwatch Add invictaisthebestwatch to Your Contacts

#20

Today, 03:30 PM

WatchYaThink

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Sunnyvale, CA Posts: 3,139 Real Name: Larry

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 I'm talking about proof...thats harsh? You don't consider a microscopic analysis of an actual Invicta dial by a geologist to be proof? __________________ "He who marches in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, for him a spinal cord would fully suffice" - Albert Einstein

WatchYaThink View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchYaThink Send email to WatchYaThink Find all posts by WatchYaThink

Add WatchYaThink to Your Contacts

#21

Today, 03:30 PM Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: The Beautiful Eastern Shore of Virginia Posts: 4,101 Real Name: Rich

RLFierro Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by invictaisthebestwatch In before thread is locked! CLASSIC!!!!!! __________________

FCCS(SW) USN(ret) 1982-2005

RLFierro View Public Profile Send a private message to RLFierro Send email to RLFierro Find all posts by RLFierro Add RLFierro to Your Contacts

#22

Today, 03:30 PM

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Northeast Ohio Posts: 271 Real Name: Mel

Bondson Senior Member Senior Geek

Wow this is crazy. I have a swiss SW200 pro diver sandstone or is it not???

Bondson View Public Profile Send a private message to Bondson Send email to Bondson Find all posts by Bondson Add Bondson to Your Contacts #23

Today, 03:30 PM Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: San Antonio,TX Posts: 1,743

Z4MC Senior Member Super Geek

LOL I bought a "standstone" Ocean Reef in silver a couple weeks back- Got it in and it didnt have that "sandstone" sparkle - so I sent it back- maybe I got REAL sandstone! If thats the case- I'll take the man made "fake" stuff that sparkles like the "night sky" as Jim says. Just got in a couple of tungsten SWI sandstones in red and blue and they sparkle like crazy- love them. __________________ The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money. ...Alexis de Tocqueville after travelling to America 1834

Z4MC View Public Profile Send a private message to Z4MC Find all posts by Z4MC Add Z4MC to Your Contacts

#24

Today, 03:31 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sanford, Florida Posts: 1,056 Real Name: BOB

rjones1994 Senior Member Super Geek

As a point I might think that Invicta was the goat in a scam some how. Either way you look at it is a bad thing if true.

rjones1994 View Public Profile Send a private message to rjones1994 Find all posts by rjones1994 Add rjones1994 to Your Contacts

#25

Today, 03:32 PM

strutn45

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix What proof would be adequate? And more importantly how would this proof personally affect you? Well, guess that means you can't prove it so it really doesn't matter...does it. __________________

"WHO DAT"

MrAutoGuy

Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Elk Grove, CA Posts: 110

Senior Member Senior Geek

No comments. I only pick Invicta up from bargain sites so can't complain. __________________ Current: Seiko Frankenmonster, Seiko 007, Orient Big Mako, Citizen Orca, SANIII Auto, Invicta Grand Diver, SeaGull dress, G-Shock 'BumbleBee'

MrAutoGuy View Public Profile Send a private message to MrAutoGuy Find all posts by MrAutoGuy Add MrAutoGuy to Your Contacts #27

Today, 03:40 PM

WatchYaThink

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Sunnyvale, CA Posts: 3,139 Real Name: Larry

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Remember when Invicta first instroduced sandstone dials in the Lupah reserve? Man they made such a huge thing over how exotic and rare and expensive and exclusive it was to be using sandstone dials ....... now, we see 5000 pieces of sandstone dial classique for a hundred bucks ..... hmmmm, makes one wonder about those original statements about how expensive and exclusive sandstone dials actually are? Z, you might be right, it could well be that man made sandstone actually has more sparkle and looks better and natural sandstone would look ..... but, how it looks is not actually the

point, is it? __________________ "He who marches in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, for him a spinal cord would fully suffice" - Albert Einstein

WatchYaThink View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchYaThink Send email to WatchYaThink Find all posts by WatchYaThink Add WatchYaThink to Your Contacts

#28 Today, 03:41 PM

doublel

Join Date: May 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 3,918 Real Name: Larry

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by MrAutoGuy No comments. I only pick Invicta up from bargain sites so can't complain. Me too. Buy other brands from Shop. Can always find my Invictas for a lower price elsewhere. I have a Swiss Legend Blue Sandstone dial. Never gave any thought regarding the Sandstone. Will be interested to see if there is a response one way or another. __________________ Larry Live Long and Prosper

doublel View Public Profile Send a private message to doublel Send email to doublel Find all posts by doublel Add doublel to Your Contacts

#29

Today, 03:49 PM

Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Atlanta, GA Posts: 595 Real Name: James

jade330i Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by OmegaMeister Is it Swiss or Chinese "faux" sandstone? I only like the fake Swiss stuff myself. Maybe what Eyal ment was it was "SWISS" sand....... __________________

More government is not the cure for the defect of less personal responsibility, it's an enabler; if people aren't accountable for their own actions then who is?"

jade330i View Public Profile Send a private message to jade330i Send email to jade330i Find all posts by jade330i Add jade330i to Your Contacts

#30

Today, 03:50 PM

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 Well, guess that means you can prove it so it really doesn't matter...does it. Exactly...

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts #31

Today, 03:51 PM

mbgalg

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

Member Member Geek

Quote:

in this area but it sure sounds like pretty incriminating evidence that we are being lied to. personally i couldn't care less whether its sandstone, meteorite or petrified whale terd just be honest. i don't know how far you want to take this but would this geologist be willing to write a short note as to his or her findings? it really isn't worth the negative energy.

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#32 Today, 03:55 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Simi Valley, CA Posts: 109 Real Name: John

WTF Senior Member Senior Geek

Look, it all depends on what the meaning of "natural" means. __________________ It's better to have loved and lost, then to never have had that special watch...

WTF View Public Profile Send a private message to WTF Find all posts by WTF Add WTF to Your Contacts

#33

Today, 03:55 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 9 Real Name: Ron

invictamatic Junior Member New Geek

You can see from my Avatar, I recently bought this watch from the Sunday Run. This is another disappointment from the Mothership. Yikes! __________________ Collecting Value, One Invicta At A Time!

invictamatic View Public Profile Send a private message to invictamatic Find all posts by invictamatic Add invictamatic to Your Contacts

#34

Today, 03:59 PM Join Date: Jul 2010 Posts: 16

Onceinawhile Junior Member New Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix What proof would be adequate? Until it comes from Jim, its LIES ALL LIES!!! __________________

For I will not trust in my bow, neither shall my sword save me.

Onceinawhile View Public Profile Send a private message to Onceinawhile Find all posts by Onceinawhile Add Onceinawhile to Your Contacts #35

Today, 04:04 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Atlanta, GA Posts: 595 Real Name: James

jade330i Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Onceinawhile Until it comes from Jim, its LIES ALL LIES!!! Pal, you gotta pull you head outta the sand.....stone. __________________

More government is not the cure for the defect of less personal responsibility, it's an enabler; if people aren't accountable for their own actions then who is?"

jade330i View Public Profile Send a private message to jade330i Send email to jade330i Find all posts by jade330i Add jade330i to Your Contacts

#36

Today, 04:05 PM

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

mbgalg Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RLFierro I do believe an advanced degree is a requirement to be a professor, correct??? incorrect! you can be a low level professor with just a bachelor's or master's degree or higher up in the teaching chain with a phd. some fields require the paper along with experience but in some areas experience is enough to qualify as an expert.

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#37

Today, 04:08 PM

rottieluv Senior Member Super Geek

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Zellwood, FL (near Orlando) Posts: 1,637 Real Name: Denise

I applaud the investigational queries by qwikfix, WatchYaThink, timeman and other WGs who don't just accept as fact every aspect of a sales pitch. No matter how innocently or innocuously information about the watches we buy is dispatched, the fact is many of us have come to realize that sometimes we are given incorrect information about these watches, and that is just wrong. ~ Denise rottieluv View Public Profile Send a private message to rottieluv Find all posts by rottieluv Add rottieluv to Your Contacts

#38

Today, 04:10 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: THA BRONX Posts: 376

sunaru Senior Member Senior Geek

Another day a other fiasco. Lol is anybody really shocked i mean let's be honest here. This type of thing is nothing new, and is exactly why my hard earned cash is spent elsewhere.

sunaru View Public Profile Send a private message to sunaru Find all posts by sunaru Add sunaru to Your Contacts #39 Today, 04:14 PM

the watcher

Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: 677

Senior Member Veteran Geek

"I did not have sexual relations with that woman"...Bill "slick willy" Clinton. And so it goes........????????

the watcher View Public Profile Send a private message to the watcher Find all posts by the watcher Add the watcher to Your Contacts

#40

Today, 04:16 PM

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 1,002

warpig Senior Member Super Geek

Foreign market sandstone? __________________ Ah, pigs: an omnivorous, domesticated, cloven-hoof vertebrate that defecates the same place it consumes.

warpig View Public Profile Send a private message to warpig Find all posts by warpig Add warpig to Your Contacts

#41 Today, 04:18 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Macomb, MI Posts: 22 Real Name: Kevin

Pass_It_Forward Junior Member New Geek

This is wild. I do not care if it is man made or real sandstone. I just do not like being lied to. This is now the third issue that shows some type of possible deception. I think this needs to be addressed because I really like Invicta and would rather be told the truth then mislead. I would buy a man made dial if it looked nice, and My Classique Sandstone is beautiful. Well I hope there is an answer soon.

Pass_It_Forward View Public Profile Send a private message to Pass_It_Forward Find all posts by Pass_It_Forward Add Pass_It_Forward to Your Contacts

#42

Today, 04:21 PM

Bourbon City

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Indianapolis Posts: 396 Real Name: Dale

Senior Member Senior Geek

I think any experienced rock hound could tell real sandstone from a man made look-a-like material. I would also think a Geology Grad Student could do the samething, let alone a Professor of Geology. Likewise a Certified Professional Geologist. Usually a College Professor is a person with a Doctorate Degree. Associate Professors can have a Masters Degree. Oh well, I am sure we'll hear an interesting explaination from someone at Invicta, unless by some happening this issue will just go-away. BC

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 1,002

warpig

Senior Member Super Geek

Foreign market sandstone? __________________ Ah, pigs: an omnivorous, domesticated, cloven-hoof vertebrate that defecates the same place it consumes.

warpig View Public Profile Send a private message to warpig Find all posts by warpig

Add warpig to Your Contacts

#41

Today, 04:18 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Macomb, MI Posts: 22 Real Name: Kevin

Pass_It_Forward Junior Member New Geek

Pass_It_Forward View Public Profile Send a private message to Pass_It_Forward Find all posts by Pass_It_Forward Add Pass_It_Forward to Your Contacts

#42

Today, 04:21 PM Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Indianapolis Posts: 396 Real Name: Dale

Bourbon City Senior Member Senior Geek

Oh well, I am sure we'll hear an interesting explaination from someone at Invicta, unless by some happening this issue will just go-away. BC

Bourbon City View Public Profile Send a private message to Bourbon City Find all posts by Bourbon City Add Bourbon City to Your Contacts

#43 Today, 04:23 PM Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 95

mbgalg Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RLFierro Slow down there big fella, you'll notice the question marks at the end of correct, indicating that it's in fact a question. The incorrect! on your part was a bit over the top. That being said, if he has the credentials to TEACH then I would think he can tell glass from rock. please accept my apology if the exclamation point eroded your very fragile and thin skin. in a court of law and subsequently in the court of public opinion not everybody that teaches a subject has distinguished himself as a recognized expert. geology is a science that requires many years of study to master so your comments regarding glass from rock are rather flippant.

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#44

Today, 04:24 PM

WatchYaThink Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Sunnyvale, CA Posts: 3,139 Real Name: Larry

MOP stickers, rare exotic sandstone, white glove service, Swiss = Swiss Made, working closely with D-D, genuine diamond accents ..... and now fake sandstone. Is anyone counting? I mean, for any one of those we might say, okay, we can cut you some slack and you get a pass on that one ..... BUT, does anyone else see a consistent pattern here? It's like debacle de jour with this company, and it's really a shame because I believe that they do make some great watches, and they are actually trying to bring us quality watches at affordable prices .... for some strange reason it seems they just can't manage to tell the truth? Just say they are crystals if they are crystals, just say it is created sandstone if it is created sandstone, they would probably still sell just as many without the deception ..... although it may be unintentional, but then that's a whole different problem. __________________ "He who marches in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, for him a spinal cord would fully suffice" - Albert Einstein

WatchYaThink View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchYaThink Send email to WatchYaThink Find all posts by WatchYaThink Add WatchYaThink to Your Contacts

#45

Today, 04:25 PM Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 2,288

KOKONUTZ Senior Member Super Geek

I'll steer away from the real or Memorex issue here...what I find fascinating is the degree that all companies go to to differentiate their products to sell more of what IMHO has been a long commodities category. Let's count the ways: Sandstone MOP Wood Carbon Fiber Ceramic Tungsten Titanium

Stainless Steel Polycarbonate Italian Leather Swiss PVC Cables, bullets, meteorites Diamonds, crystals, rubies, sapphires Flame-Fusion, Krysterna, Hardlex Tritium Tubes, Luminova, Super Luminova, Tritnite

KOKONUTZ View Public Profile Send a private message to KOKONUTZ Find all posts by KOKONUTZ Add KOKONUTZ to Your Contacts #46

Today, 04:28 PM

WatchGeek4Life

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,385 Real Name: Jim

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by rottieluv

I applaud the investigational queries by qwikfix, WatchYaThink, timeman and other WGs who don't just accept as fact every aspect of a sales pitch. No matter how innocently or innocuously information about the watches we buy is dispatched, the fact is many of us have come to realize that sometimes we are given incorrect information about these watches, and that is just wrong. ~ Denise Amen Debbie, and I applaud them also. We all like Invicta watches, but we want the truth about the products we are spending our money on. Deceit is not the way to do business. __________________

Breitling Bentley WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

#47

Today, 04:29 PM Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Indianapolis Posts: 396 Real Name: Dale

Bourbon City Senior Member Senior Geek

I have always like the advertisement: Made with real wood. Really. Maybe Ralph Nader should be called into this. LOL BC

Bourbon City View Public Profile Send a private message to Bourbon City Find all posts by Bourbon City Add Bourbon City to Your Contacts #48 Today, 04:30 PM

MukilteoJason

Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Mukilteo, WA Posts: 458 Real Name: Jason

Senior Member Senior Geek

I knew I should have gotten the meteorite

MukilteoJason View Public Profile Send a private message to MukilteoJason Send email to MukilteoJason Find all posts by MukilteoJason Add MukilteoJason to Your Contacts #49

Today, 04:32 PM

mbgalg

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 95

Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RLFierro I suggest you step back into your corner. I served 23 years in our military so my skin is quite thick. I need not banter with you any further.........it is below me. for your military service to our country i thank you but for your lack of intellect i pity you.

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#50

Today, 04:33 PM

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: TEXAS Posts: 629 Real Name: Tina/Tj

tj6988@sbcglobal.net Senior Member Veteran Geek

Rut Row ~~~

__________________

Tina/Tj Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,665 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

we need to calm down fellow geeks or this thread will be no more. __________________

Hot fun in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#52 Today, 04:34 PM

mdhorner

Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 1,251 Real Name: Michael

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg for your military service to our country i thank you but for your lack of intellect i pity you. I think you're stepping out of line here. __________________

A flush always beats a straight unless the guy with the straight carries a gun. Norman Chad

mdhorner View Public Profile Send a private message to mdhorner Find all posts by mdhorner Add mdhorner to Your Contacts

#53

Today, 04:34 PM Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,929 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

strutn45 Senior Member True WatchGeek

__________________

"WHO DAT"

strutn45 View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#54

Today, 04:35 PM Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 95

mbgalg Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RLFierro You must be very lonely with that charming personality you possess. 4100 posts versus 90, who's lonely?

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#55

Today, 04:37 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,665 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

__________________

Hot fun in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts #56

Today, 04:39 PM Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Massachusetts Posts: 5,927 Real Name: Special K ;)

abduksion Senior Member True WatchGeek

Whats next their not using real steel lol. __________________

abduksion

View Public Profile Send a private message to abduksion Send email to abduksion Find all posts by abduksion Add abduksion to Your Contacts #57

Today, 04:42 PM Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,386 Real Name: Jim

WatchGeek4Life Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB we need to calm down fellow geeks or this thread will be no more.

Agreed Charlie.....guys lets get back to the topic here, we don't want Jim or Michael to close this down, it is a very important issue. __________________

Breitling Bentley WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

#58

Today, 04:42 PM

Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: The Beautiful Eastern Shore of Virginia Posts: 4,100 Real Name: Rich

RLFierro Senior Member Master WatchGeek

OP.........I apologize for stealing your thread. On the advice of many of my fellow geeks I have pulled my comments from this thread. I will not be sucked into an argument. To my friends that saw where this was going, thanks for the advice, I would have said something I would come to regret. __________________

FCCS(SW) USN(ret) 1982-2005

RLFierro View Public Profile Send a private message to RLFierro Send email to RLFierro Find all posts by RLFierro Add RLFierro to Your Contacts

#59

Today, 04:43 PM

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: THA BRONX Posts: 376

sunaru Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB we need to calm down fellow geeks or this thread will be no more. It'll probably end up with the DD section that magically no longer exsist. I mean really where did that whole section go?

sunaru View Public Profile Send a private message to sunaru Find all posts by sunaru Add sunaru to Your Contacts #60 Today, 04:47 PM

mdhorner

Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 1,251 Real Name: Michael

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RLFierro OP.........I apologize for stealing your thread. On the advice of many of my fellow geeks I have pulled my comments from this thread. I will not be sucked into an argument. To my friends that saw where this was going, thanks for the advice, I would have said something I would come to regret. Class act, buddy. I for one am also interested of what happens to this thread. I hope it is simply a "diamond vs. crystal" thing again, and that not all of them are like this. __________________

A flush always beats a straight unless the guy with the straight carries a gun. Norman Chad

mdhorner View Public Profile Send a private message to mdhorner Find all posts by mdhorner Add mdhorner to Your Contacts

#61

Today, 04:48 PM Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: New York City Posts: 251 Real Name: Guy

Sir watch Senior Member Senior Geek

Sandstone is not even considered a semi precious stone. Synthetic or natural this material has fantastic scintillation. I would cut some slack. __________________

Sir watch View Public Profile Send a private message to Sir watch Find all posts by Sir watch Add Sir watch to Your Contacts

#62

Today, 04:50 PM

mdhorner

Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 1,251 Real Name: Michael

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sir watch

Sandstone is not even considered a semi precious stone. Synthetic or natural this material has fantastic scintillation. I would cut some slack. I believe people are po'd because they were (potentially) lied to (again). __________________

A flush always beats a straight unless the guy with the straight carries a gun. Norman Chad

mdhorner View Public Profile Send a private message to mdhorner Find all posts by mdhorner Add mdhorner to Your Contacts

#63

Today, 04:55 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: THA BRONX Posts: 376

sunaru Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sir watch

Sandstone is not even considered a semi precious stone. Synthetic or natural this material has fantastic scintillation. I would cut some slack. Real or fake is not the issue here. It's the repeated lies that loyal customers are being told.

sunaru View Public Profile Send a private message to sunaru Find all posts by sunaru Add sunaru to Your Contacts

#64

Today, 04:55 PM Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Virginia Posts: 33 Real Name: Harry

QUANTICO SPEEDLOADERS Member Member Geek

Lets follow Rich's lead and end this before it gets out-of-hand...please... __________________

"Now I ask you...What good is a dead Ninja?":

Jim Skelton 06/27/2010 @ 2105

hours, Shop NBC

QUANTICO SPEEDLOADERS View Public Profile Send a private message to QUANTICO SPEEDLOADERS Find all posts by QUANTICO SPEEDLOADERS Add QUANTICO SPEEDLOADERS to Your Contacts

#65

Today, 04:56 PM

Mark Szorik

Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 21

Junior Member New Geek

I am by NO means an expert yet, however, I am currently finishing the forth year of my second BS degree in Geology at Utah State University so I would like to offer some comments. Please take this as my attempt to be informative and not act as a "know it all". Sandstone is a sedimentary rock that is composed of grains that were previously eroded from other rocks - i.e igneous, feldspar, quartz, etc. and subsequently deposited, cemented or lithified (i.e. calcite cementation or extreme pressure over time). If I were to analyze this dial material I would characterize (identify) what the grains are made of, again quartz, feldspar, etc. - this is relatively easy to determine without destroying the dial (need high microscopic magnification). Additionally, a determination of the type of cementation that is holding the grains together would help determine if the material is natural versus synthetic. Conducting this type of test is typically destructive (acid or microscopic thin section). While I have never personally seen sandstone in these vibrant colors that does NOT by mean that

they are not produced by nature. Invicta's supplier may have used a dye to create the vibrant optical effect. Occasionally geologists use dyes to help identify certain rock and mineral types. I suspect that producing sandstone dials this thin are well within the capabilities of the watch industry, but overall durability would be a function of material thickness and how it is bonded to the dial base (if this is what they have done). The origin of this raw material is should be relatively easy for Invicta to prove if they desire to do so. Then again, for a competitive advantage many companies tend to keep their material source internal (secret) for a competitive advantage. Kind Regards.

Mark Szorik View Public Profile Send a private message to Mark Szorik Find all posts by Mark Szorik Add Mark Szorik to Your Contacts

#66

Today, 04:57 PM Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,386 Real Name: Jim

WatchGeek4Life Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mdhorner I believe people are po'd because they were (potentially) lied to (again).

Agreed Michael, what is this now, the 5th incident? I think Larry is right a pattern has formed.......and will it ever end?????? __________________

Breitling Bentley

WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

#67

Today, 05:03 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 692 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Szorik I am by NO means an expert yet, however, I am currently finishing the forth year of my second BS degree in Geology at Utah State University so I would like to offer some comments. Please take this as my attempt to be informative and not act as a "know it all". Sandstone is a sedimentary rock that is composed of grains that were previously eroded from other rocks - i.e igneous, feldspar, quartz, etc. and subsequently deposited, cemented or lithified (i.e. calcite cementation or extreme pressure over time). If I were to analyze this dial material I would characterize (identify) what the grains are made of, again quartz, feldspar, etc. - this is relatively easy to determine without destroying the dial (need high microscopic magnification). Additionally, a determination of the type of cementation that is holding the grains together would help determine if the material is natural versus synthetic. Conducting this type of test is typically destructive (acid or microscopic thin section). While I have never personally seen sandstone in these vibrant colors that does NOT by mean that they are not produced by nature. Invicta's supplier may have used a dye to create the vibrant optical effect. Occasionally geologists use dyes to help identify certain rock and mineral types. I suspect that producing sandstone dials this thin are well within the capabilities of the watch industry, but overall durability would be a function of material thickness and how it is bonded to the dial base (if this is what they have done). The origin of this raw material is should be relatively easy for Invicta to prove if they desire to do so. Then again, for a competitive advantage many companies tend to keep their material source internal (secret) for a competitive advantage. Kind Regards. You are correct about the sandstone analysis. When this material is viewed under a microscope you can clearly see well defined patterns of triangles, and octogons. The problem is that under a microscope you can see the cross section of these shapes and they are essentially one dimensional. You would expect some if not most of these particles would be three dimensional but they are not. As for the cement there is none, just these one

dimensional specs floating in clear glass.

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

#68

Today, 05:06 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 480

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

This thread has got me thinking... Has anyone checked or verified to see if the Meteor Dials are real? I'm not trying to open a Pandora's Box...please understand this. But after all, after spending a certain amount of money on my collection...I which I do love to do. Plus this(forum/website) is a great way to network...I want to know if my stuff is real? __________________

B I B L E = Basic Instructions Before Leaving Earth The Watch Whisper View Public Profile Send a private message to The Watch Whisper Find all posts by The Watch Whisper Add The Watch Whisper to Your Contacts

#69 Today, 05:11 PM

407guy Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: 407 area code Posts: 376

Just last Friday Eyal was asked just this question and his reply was "natural". Naturally not real?

407guy View Public Profile Send a private message to 407guy Send email to 407guy Find all posts by 407guy Add 407guy to Your Contacts

#70

Today, 05:13 PM

dross

Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Valdosta, GA Posts: 227 Real Name: Dave

Senior Member Senior Geek

Who knows how it is manufactured, compressed and created into a dial???? It is most likely a form of NATURAL stone manufactured into a dial. these are some that can be purchased http://www.hktdc.com/sourcing/produc...cessories.htm#

dross View Public Profile Send a private message to dross Find all posts by dross Add dross to Your Contacts

#71 Today, 05:14 PM

tednan@optonline.net

Join Date: Apr 2008 Posts: 48

Member Member Geek

The last Invicta watch (es) that I purchased were the Speedway Elite w/"D.D." mov't. I sent both back for a refund. Neither Invicta, nor the Shop, offered us the opportunity to repurchase these watches once they were repaired. That was the last Invicta watch that I

purchased. Even when I see an Invicta aired that I would like I think of that experience I simply can not purchase that Invicta. This feeling has not wavered or dulled.

tednan@optonline.net View Public Profile Send a private message to tednan@optonline.net Find all posts by tednan@optonline.net Add tednan@optonline.net to Your Contacts

#72

Today, 05:15 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 9 Real Name: Ron

invictamatic Junior Member New Geek

Where does this end? What about the watches that are supposed to have "high quality natural" sapphire,tsavorites & mozambique garnets, and ruby bezels? __________________ Collecting Value, One Invicta At A Time!

invictamatic View Public Profile Send a private message to invictamatic Find all posts by invictamatic Add invictamatic to Your Contacts

#73 Today, 05:16 PM

Panda03Bear Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Silver Spring, MD. Posts: 8,575 Real Name: Adam

Originally Posted by invictaisthebestwatch In before thread is locked! Hahahahaha! Too funny. And yes here we go again. If you like it, like it, stop trying to disprove it. Now if, and I stress if, eyal lied that isn't right, but it could have been a simple misunderstanding or an explanation needed. Either way I could care less, unless he lied of course and only he knows that answer __________________

- Family, that's what's up - Black Eye Dye

Panda03Bear View Public Profile Send a private message to Panda03Bear Send email to Panda03Bear Find all posts by Panda03Bear Add Panda03Bear to Your Contacts

#74

Today, 05:17 PM Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: New York City Posts: 251 Real Name: Guy

Sir watch Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by sunaru Real or fake is not the issue here. It's the repeated lies that loyal customers are being told. Sorry, I am not knowledgeable of this issue. I am relatively new here and do not watch these programs with any regularity. I basically go on ShopNBC.com site and buy what I like. I was just responding to the look of what is used in this timepiece and the common Sedimentary rock Sandstone. __________________

Sir watch View Public Profile Send a private message to Sir watch Find all posts by Sir watch Add Sir watch to Your Contacts

#75 Today, 05:18 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Atlanta, GA Posts: 590 Real Name: James

jade330i Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchGeek4Life

Agreed Michael, what is this now, the 5th incident? I think Larry is right a pattern has formed.......and will it ever end??????

And let's not forget that outside of this forum very few consumers hear about any of this....... __________________

More government is not the cure for the defect of less personal responsibility, it's an enabler; if people aren't accountable for their own actions then who is?"

WatchYaThink

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Sunnyvale, CA Posts: 3,139 Real Name: Larry

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Dave, a gemologist described it under a microscope as one-dimensional triangle and octagon specs floating in glass ..... from what part of that description do you conclude that it is "most likely a form of NATURAL stone" ?? Sounds to me more like a metal flake paint job. __________________ "He who marches in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, for him a spinal cord would fully suffice" - Albert Einstein

WatchYaThink View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchYaThink Send email to WatchYaThink Find all posts by WatchYaThink Add WatchYaThink to Your Contacts

#77

Today, 05:20 PM

actor

Member Member Geek

There really are weapons Quote:

Join Date: May 2008 Posts: 57

Originally Posted by the watcher "I did not have sexual relations with that woman"...Bill "slick willy" Clinton. And so it goes........???????? of mass destruction in Iraq. GWB

actor View Public Profile Send a private message to actor Find all posts by actor Add actor to Your Contacts

#78

Today, 05:25 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 692 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchYaThink Dave, a gemologist described it under a microscope as one-dimensional triangle and octagon specs floating in glass ..... from what part of that description do you conclude that it is "most likely a form of NATURAL stone" ?? Sounds to me more like a metal flake paint job. The man who gave his opinion on this material is a geologist and his title starts with Doctor.

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

#79

Today, 05:25 PM

Panda03Bear

Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Silver Spring, MD. Posts: 8,575 Real Name: Adam

Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchGeek4Life

Amen Debbie, and I applaud them also. We all like Invicta watches, but we want the truth about the products we are spending our money on. Deceit is not the way to do business. My thought is, let's be fair, someone break open their SL sandstones and have them tested. Seems like we are picking on the big guy here. Keep in mind I have no investment in either company or any sandstone watches. But calling eyal a liar over and over again, well, becomes uninteresting and tedious __________________ - Family, that's what's up - Black Eye Dye

Panda03Bear View Public Profile Send a private message to Panda03Bear Send email to Panda03Bear Find all posts by Panda03Bear Add Panda03Bear to Your Contacts

#80

Today, 05:28 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: NYC Posts: 145 Real Name: Irene

Peaceful75 Senior Member Senior Geek

Some of this is rather curious to think about, but I own a Classique Pinnacle w/ the midnight blue sandstone, and you know what? The watch is gorgeous. Even if it is the Goldstone that Timeman posted pics of, it's still gorgeous. I would be interested to see what Invicta says about this, if anything, but I will still love and wear my Pinnacle either way...who knows? The information does sound compelling that something stinks here, but hopefully one of our big-wigs here will step forward and give some information on this...? __________________ Even a broken watch is right twice a day. With a 5-year warranty, I'd rather get it fixed!

Peaceful75 View Public Profile Send a private message to Peaceful75 Send email to Peaceful75 Find all posts by Peaceful75 Add Peaceful75 to Your Contacts

#81 Today, 05:28 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: THA BRONX Posts: 376

sunaru Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sir watch Sorry, I am not knowledgeable of this issue. I am relatively new here and do not watch

these programs with any regularity. I basically go on ShopNBC.com site and buy what I like. I was just responding to the look of what is used in this timepiece and the common Sedimentary rock Sandstone. well just stick around and keep reading you be able to make your own assessment soon enough.. welcome to the board..

sunaru View Public Profile Send a private message to sunaru Find all posts by sunaru Add sunaru to Your Contacts

#82

Today, 05:32 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 480

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

I buy what I like and like what I buy. I'm not buying to make a profit and to have them and save them to see if later on there worth more $$$. I dont even sell my watches, think about selling or even think about trading them. I keep all my watches. But the botom line is...I want to make sure what I buy is real. So I trust Eyal, Jim and Mike if and when they tell me what the product is. But in what evewr I buy...what ever it is. A car, house, or a watch...I just to make sure I'm buying the real deal. __________________

Today, 05:33 PM

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Beaverton, Oregon, USA Posts: 1,190 Real Name: Isn't it obvious? :)

Beau Hudspeth Photography Senior Member Super Geek

I guess that there is a reason I do not have any of the watches that contain these erroneous elements: I have simple tastes and most of the high-end, cool watch elements don't sing to me. In the case of all the Invicta issues, I guess that that makes me lucky as I have yet to be affected by them. This saddens me, non the less, for those who have. __________________

•

My Flickr Watch Slideshow •

My WG Wallpapers •

Watch Count=9 •

Beau Hudspeth Photography View Public Profile Send a private message to Beau Hudspeth Photography Send email to Beau Hudspeth Photography Visit Beau Hudspeth Photography's homepage! Find all posts by Beau Hudspeth Photography Add Beau Hudspeth Photography to Your Contacts

#84

Today, 05:35 PM Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Massachusetts Posts: 5,927 Real Name: Special K ;)

abduksion Senior Member True WatchGeek

Does this mean, Invicta is using fake Stainless Steel lol. __________________

abduksion View Public Profile Send a private message to abduksion Send email to abduksion Find all posts by abduksion Add abduksion to Your Contacts

#85

Today, 05:39 PM Join Date: May 2010 Location: San Diego,calif Posts: 56 Real Name: Dary

goat Member Member Geek

Man, this is better than the Friday night fights...... ... I suppose the next shop NBC show will feature michael stapped into a lie detector,....stay tuned

watchdude

Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 313 Real Name: Bill

Senior Member Senior Geek

wow, if this is true for invicta I wonder About Swiss Legend. Could this be intentional or were the watchmakers also fooled. If this is factual I think those that bought with the understanding this was a natural formation should be offered their money back or some attorney will look into a class action suit I would imagin.

watchdude View Public Profile Send a private message to watchdude Find all posts by watchdude Add watchdude to Your Contacts

#87

Today, 05:49 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Ohio Posts: 1,754

MATTNATTI Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchYaThink MOP stickers, rare exotic sandstone, white glove service, Swiss = Swiss Made, working closely with D-D, genuine diamond accents ..... and now fake sandstone. Is anyone counting? I mean, for any one of those we might say, okay, we can cut you some slack and you get a pass on that one ..... BUT, does anyone else see a consistent pattern here? It's like debacle de jour with this company, and it's really a shame because I believe that they do make some great watches, and they are actually trying to bring us quality watches at affordable prices .... for some strange reason it seems they just can't manage to tell the truth? Just say they are crystals if they are crystals, just say it is created sandstone if it is created sandstone, they would probably still sell just as many without the deception ..... although it may be unintentional, but then that's a whole different problem. how about adding the invicta impact boxes to that list. arent they in litigation over those? __________________ Did you see that? Do they all got hedges like that? Do they?

MATTNATTI View Public Profile Send a private message to MATTNATTI Send email to MATTNATTI Find all posts by MATTNATTI Add MATTNATTI to Your Contacts

#88

Today, 05:50 PM

curiousgeorge Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Mpls Posts: 2,646 Real Name: George

Considering sandstone is used often for silica to make glass this isn't remotely surprising. Technically if they used sandstone to make the glass dial, dyed it which it is since there really isn't natural blue sandstone. Then they can say they used natural sandstone to make the dial. Sandstone isn't remotely hard to find, is used in building and paving constantly. To be honest it's not remotely valuable. At all. Unbelievably plentiful. Much like lab-created rubies and sapphires you can actually make gems with heat in a lab. This is probably the same concept and a technicality which they can say it is natural sandstone. They used the sandstone to make glass ornaments basically.

curiousgeorge View Public Profile Send a private message to curiousgeorge Find all posts by curiousgeorge Add curiousgeorge to Your Contacts

#89

Today, 05:58 PM

407guy

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: 407 area code Posts: 377

Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Watch Whisper But the botom line is...I want to make sure what I buy is real. So I trust Eyal, Jim and Mike if and when they tell me what the product is. But in what evewr I buy...what ever it is. A car, house, or a watch...I just to make sure I'm buying the real deal. Using your post and not picking on you, but you make a good point here. If you are buying a house for $10,000 that is supposedly valued (i.e. MRSP) at $100,000 shouldn't that raise a red flag regarding the price you're paying? What I mean is there has to come a point when you (any buyer) should be thinking.... how is possible that I get W, X, Y and Z in this watch that supposedly retails for $3,000 and FOR TONIGHT ONLY it's $198.76? Yes, it will be sad if this is another situation where Invicta says one thing and it's not true. I feel for anyone who has purchased this watch and must be thinking, "what did I pay for?" It has to suck. Peace.

. __________________

Current rotation: Rolex Submariner, Breitling Chrono Avenger M1, TAG Heuer Formula 1, Lum-Tec Bull45, Chase-Durer Air Assault, Citizen (several), Seiko (several), Timex Ironman, G-Shock and Invicta (several).

407guy View Public Profile Send a private message to 407guy Send email to 407guy Find all posts by 407guy Add 407guy to Your Contacts

#90

Today, 06:04 PM Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 4

gantzj

Junior Member New Geek

I was really looking at the reddish sandstone a few nites ago on SNBC. So...it's NOT sandstone?

gantzj View Public Profile Send a private message to gantzj Find all posts by gantzj Add gantzj to Your Contacts

#91

Today, 06:08 PM

wvuguy Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda03Bear

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: West Chester OH (originally from Canonsburg, PA) Posts: 210 Real Name: Donn

My thought is, let's be fair, someone break open their SL sandstones and have them tested. Seems like we are picking on the big guy here. Keep in mind I have no investment in either company or any sandstone watches. But calling eyal a liar over and over again, well, becomes uninteresting and tedious Adam may be correct about that, but I honestly think Eyal can take it. I also don't see anyone here attempting to deny him, or his representatives, every opportunity to address the question in any manner they deem fit......and if they so choose. While I have no dog in this hunt, I do consider myself an interested observer in it. With that said, I personally would like to see at least some official response at some point by Invicta.

wvuguy View Public Profile Send a private message to wvuguy Find all posts by wvuguy Add wvuguy to Your Contacts

#92

Today, 06:09 PM

Genezilla Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sunny Southern Cali Posts: 2,680 Real Name: Gene

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix A friend sent me a dial, movement and caseback from a Blue sandstone Invicta Model number 0050 and asked if I could have it examined by an expert. Today I met with a geologist at an area college and he informed me that no the dial was not natural sandstone and that it was probably glass with manmade grown crystals inside (you know the sparkly stuff). After my lesson in sandstone formation and observing the dial under a microscope I too am convinced that this dial is in no way natural by any stretch of the imagination. Just last Friday Eyal was asked just this question and his reply was "natural". My only question is why? Against my better judgement I'm going to ask a few questions. 1. Why did you friend send you parts of a watch? 2. Why did he want you to verify what the dial was made of? 3. Can you verify that the dial actually came from the watch in question? I ask this because the watch was disassembled. 4. Are you going to post pictures of the watch parts? 5. Are you going to post a copy of the report? Please don't take any of this the wrong way. I don't have an opinion on the matter and I

haven't taked sides. Thank you.

Genezilla View Public Profile Send a private message to Genezilla Find all posts by Genezilla Add Genezilla to Your Contacts

#93

Today, 06:09 PM

new2watches

Join Date: May 2008 Posts: 172

Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by curiousgeorge Considering sandstone is used often for silica to make glass this isn't remotely surprising. Technically if they used sandstone to make the glass dial, dyed it which it is since there really isn't natural blue sandstone. Then they can say they used natural sandstone to make the dial. Sandstone isn't remotely hard to find, is used in building and paving constantly. To be honest it's not remotely valuable. At all. Unbelievably plentiful. Much like lab-created rubies and sapphires you can actually make gems with heat in a lab. This is probably the same concept and a technicality which they can say it is natural sandstone. They used the sandstone to make glass ornaments basically. Not calling you out on your post, I am sincerely not. Following the "technicality" concrete would be considered natural since the components in it are natural; originally quicklime, volcanic ash and pumice (as used by the Romans) and modified over time but should concrete be called "natural" just because its components are?

new2watches View Public Profile Send a private message to new2watches Find all posts by new2watches Add new2watches to Your Contacts

#94

Today, 06:10 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 484

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

Didn't take it bad or get offended 407Guy. The only reason I bring this up in most cases the manufactor/company/retail store would also include a certificate of some kind to prove the item is genuine. __________________

#95

Today, 06:15 PM Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Santa Clarita, CA Posts: 3,154 Real Name: Nate

NG111 Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by invictaisthebestwatch In before thread is locked! +1

Hilarious post, btw!

NG111 View Public Profile Send a private message to NG111 Send email to NG111 Find all posts by NG111 Add NG111 to Your Contacts #96

Today, 06:15 PM

curiousgeorge Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Mpls Posts: 2,646 Real Name: George

Quote:

Originally Posted by new2watches Not calling you out on your post, I am sincerely not. Following the "technicality" concrete would be considered natural since the components in it are natural; originally quicklime, volcanic ash and pumice (as used by the Romans) and modified over time but should concrete be called "natural" just because its components are?

Your points are pretty much what I'm saying. But what I'm saying is this would be a likely answer from the company. It would be interesting if we ever get a response on this one.

curiousgeorge View Public Profile Send a private message to curiousgeorge Find all posts by curiousgeorge Add curiousgeorge to Your Contacts

#97

Today, 06:19 PM

new2watches Senior Member Senior Geek

Join Date: May 2008 Posts: 172

Quote:

Originally Posted by curiousgeorge Your points are pretty much what I'm saying. But what I'm saying is this would be a likely answer from the company. I'm with ya George.

new2watches View Public Profile Send a private message to new2watches Find all posts by new2watches Add new2watches to Your Contacts

#98

Today, 06:19 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Genezilla Against my better judgement I'm going to ask a few questions. 1. Why did you friend send you parts of a watch? 2. Why did he want you to verify what the dial was made of? 3. Can you verify that the dial actually came from the watch in question? I ask this because the watch was disassembled. 4. Are you going to post pictures of the watch parts? 5. Are you going to post a copy of the report? Please don't take any of this the wrong way. I don't have an opinion on the matter and I

haven't taked sides. Thank you. Best post on this thread Gene! Who actually knows where the aforementioned dial or any other parts came from? __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#99 Today, 06:20 PM Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Santa Clarita, CA Posts: 3,154 Real Name: Nate

NG111

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

You are just a big bully, Rich. LOL

NG111 View Public Profile Send a private message to NG111 Send email to NG111 Find all posts by NG111 Add NG111 to Your Contacts

#100

Today, 06:20 PM

strutn45

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

"WHO DAT"

Genezilla Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sunny Southern Cali Posts: 2,680 Real Name: Gene

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Best post on this thread Gene! Who actually knows where the aforementioned dial or any other parts came from? Thanks Rick.

Genezilla View Public Profile Send a private message to Genezilla Find all posts by Genezilla Add Genezilla to Your Contacts

#102

Today, 06:25 PM

Mark Szorik

Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 24

Junior Member New Geek

Meteorite dials will typically all have a distinct crystal pattern or crystal "signature" that is accentuated by an acid wash after thin sectioning the material. In a general sense all of these dials should have a "family" resemblance as the material is originating from the same space rock - i.e Gibbon? This distinct crystal structure can be seen under a microscope or as is the case with the said dials by eye since these crystals are macroscopic - hence the

interest and beauty. Additionally, this material will also have a distinctive and somewhat consistent mineral identity - percent iron, percent nickel, organics, etc. This of course requires sophisticated equipment and in some cases a destructive wet chemical analysis to prove or disprove. Once again, if Invicta chooses to share the provenance of this material it will be relatively easy for them to do so. Personally, if I sold watches with these types of materials I would include a certificate of authenticity to satisfy the collectors and general customers. I know that other watch manufactures offer these types of dials, but I do not know if they provide a document proving that they are indeed authentic as sold. I hope that they are real and that anyone that has purchased them or plans on doing so enjoys them for what they are. Take Care.

Mark Szorik View Public Profile Send a private message to Mark Szorik Find all posts by Mark Szorik Add Mark Szorik to Your Contacts #103

Today, 06:26 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

since he does not live close to any available experts I volunteered to have this done to satisfy my own curiosity. 3. Well the watch dial did have Invicta on it. 4. He has the original pics of him disassembling the watch and I could probably post them with his permission. 5. There is no hardcopy in existence. The geologist stated that he could not provide written documentation because he is forbidden by the college to do so. I

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

#104

Today, 06:27 PM

ZRXBILL

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Sand Springs, OK. Posts: 366 Real Name: Bill

Senior Member Senior Geek

Can't wait to see how this turns out.

ZRXBILL View Public Profile Send a private message to ZRXBILL Find all posts by ZRXBILL Add ZRXBILL to Your Contacts

#105 Today, 06:28 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix 1. He broke open the watch because he did not believe it was genuine sandstone. 2. After he inspected it he thought it was glass and others questioned his judgement and since he does not live close to any available experts I volunteered to have this done to satisfy my own curiosity. 3. Well the watch dial did have Invicta on it. 4. He has the original pics of him disassembling the watch and I could probably post them with his permission. 5. There is no hardcopy in existence. The geologist stated that he could not provide written documentation because he is forbidden by the college to do so. I You can say it all you want, we want actual documented proof, video etc..... Come on, how are we supposed to actually believe this? I can say i banged Rihanna rite now, without proof, the whole forum would laugh at me. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts #106

Today, 06:30 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchYaThink Z, you might be right, it could well be that man made sandstone actually has more sparkle

and looks better and natural sandstone would look ..... but, how it looks is not actually the point, is it? Real / Natural sandstone is not man made. __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts

#107

Today, 06:32 PM

mdhorner

Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 1,256 Real Name: Michael

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up You can say it all you want, we want actual documented proof, video etc..... Come on, how are we supposed to actually believe this? I can say i banged Rihanna rite now, without proof, the whole forum would laugh at me. No way Rick!!! You lucky son of a gun! __________________

A flush always beats a straight unless the guy with the straight carries a gun. Norman Chad

mdhorner View Public Profile Send a private message to mdhorner Find all posts by mdhorner Add mdhorner to Your Contacts

#108

Today, 06:32 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Dallas, TX Posts: 137

soundbite Senior Member Senior Geek

Can anybody that purchased one of the sandstone dial watches tell us if it mentions sandstone on the back of the watch? I ask because Renato does it with their Onyx dial watches. __________________

It is with our judgments as with our watches: no two go just alike, yet each believes his own...Alexander Pope

soundbite View Public Profile Send a private message to soundbite Find all posts by soundbite Add soundbite to Your Contacts #109

Today, 06:32 PM Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Central Ohio Posts: 1,221 Real Name: John

jb182

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg is this geologist a professor with an advanced degree? i'm not sure what constitutes expert in this area but it sure sounds like pretty incriminating evidence that we are being lied to. personally i couldn't care less whether its sandstone, meteorite or petrified whale terd just be honest. i don't know how far you want to take this but would this geologist be willing to write a short note as to his or her findings? it really isn't worth the negative energy. But how would we know if it was petrified whale turd or petrified shark turd? Any marine biologists out there?

jb182 View Public Profile Send a private message to jb182

Find all posts by jb182 Add jb182 to Your Contacts

#110

Today, 06:33 PM

WatchGeek4Life

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,394 Real Name: Jim

Senior Member Super Geek

@ Rick.......You Stud you!!!! __________________

Breitling Bentley WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

#111 Today, 06:33 PM

Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Hey Slomo, you gonna get a pat on the back from Alain for this? WatchLords in the house guys. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#112 Today, 06:34 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 484

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

Thanks Mark...(the explanation on meteor) It's just now a days with so many ways of faking, dupicating, maunfactoring everything...and I mean everything. We all have to be carefull whats out there and whats real and whats not? __________________

B I B L E = Basic Instructions Before Leaving Earth

The Watch Whisper View Public Profile Send a private message to The Watch Whisper Find all posts by The Watch Whisper Add The Watch Whisper to Your Contacts

#113

Today, 06:35 PM Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: East Fallowfield PA Posts: 557 Real Name: Russell

Russell3 Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up You can say it all you want, we want actual documented proof, video etc..... Come on, how are we supposed to actually believe this? I can say i banged Rihanna rite now, without proof, the whole forum would laugh at me. NOW I'M NOT TAKING SIDES!!!! But Rick can we disprove what he's saying?

Btw, is Rihanna any good in bed? I've heard conflicting reports

Russell3 View Public Profile Send a private message to Russell3 Find all posts by Russell3 Add Russell3 to Your Contacts

#114 Today, 06:35 PM

strutn45 Senior Member True WatchGeek

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Hey Slomo, you gonna get a pat on the back from Alain for this? WatchLords in the house guys. LOL... How bout geeknomo?? __________________ "WHO DAT"

strutn45 View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#115

Today, 06:36 PM

tymebandit Member Member Geek

Join Date: May 2010 Location: Las Vegas Posts: 67 Real Name: Arthur

After reading through this thread I had my jeweler disassemble both my MOP escursion and my sun-ray dial venom chrono and had the dials sent to Sal's community College/Hair Salon testing lab (back room) and it was determined that not only is there no natural sunlight in the sun-ray but the "of pearl" is only "uncle" at best and nowhere near being "mother". My only consilation was when I was told that the cost of MOP, UOP, natural sandstone, unnatural sandstone, sun-ray, and sunless-ray were all within a few dollars of each other, and I am no less happy with the looks and performance of my watches and I've never met anyone but a WG, that cared or knew the difference, I would keep my collection. Anyone getting the picture here? Pump your brakes Geeks, lets just enjoy our watches. P.S. after re-assembly my Escursion now has a sunless-ray dial and my Venom now has an Uncle of Pearl dial. Yeah, you know you want em!

tymebandit View Public Profile Send a private message to tymebandit Send email to tymebandit Find all posts by tymebandit Add tymebandit to Your Contacts

#116

Today, 06:36 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: St. Louis, MO Posts: 1,007 Real Name: Larry

BocephusSTL Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 407guy Using your post and not picking on you, but you make a good point here. If you are buying a house for $10,000 that is supposedly valued (i.e. MRSP) at $100,000 shouldn't that raise a red flag regarding the price you're paying? Most of the time, yes, but not necessarily. Foreclosure properties are dirt cheap, especially in Florida. I was just looking at a 4 yr old 3000 sf home in Cape Coral that was previously valued at $375,000. It's now bank-owned and for sale at $99,000. That price for that size home in practically brand-new condition is a great deal any way you look at it. And yes, I know watches and homes are apples and oranges. But it proves a point with regard to your belief that a low price must mean something is wrong with the product. Quote:

Originally Posted by 407guy What I mean is there has to come a point when you (any buyer) should be thinking.... how is possible that I get W, X, Y and Z in this watch that supposedly retails for $3,000 and FOR TONIGHT ONLY it's $198.76? For most of the examples provided, I would agree with you. But in this case, we're talking sandstone. I don't know what all is involved in making a sandstone dial, so I can't speak to the cost of doing so. But sandstone is practically everywhere, and has no intrinsic value. As someone else said, it's not even considered semi-precious. It's unlikely any manufacturer would use a very expensive fabrication process on a pretty much worthless stone. Sandstone alone doesn't justify a high price tag. So, after having said all that, my point is that no, a $198 price on a watch with a sandstone dial would not raise any red flags for me. A $198 price on a meteorite dial? You bet it would. I think the whole point of this thread is that we were told one thing, and it appears it may not be true. Value is clearly not the issue here - it's sandstone after all. The issue is honesty and factual correctness. I have no comment about whether this particular issue was or was not a lie, and of course we don't have all the facts as far as written geological reports, information on manufacturing processes, or what Invicta ordered from their supplier versus what was received. But a

pattern of similar occurrences has been well-established, and it obviously strikes a nerve with many members of this forum. As always, CAVEAT EMPTOR. If you're not comfortable with what's happening with one brand, there are plenty more to choose from. __________________ Quote:

Originally Posted by jskelton You will not become a ninja by wearing one. You will not become a trained soldier by wearing one. You will not become a sex-crazed spy by wearing one.....

BocephusSTL View Public Profile Send a private message to BocephusSTL Send email to BocephusSTL Visit BocephusSTL's homepage! Find all posts by BocephusSTL Add BocephusSTL to Your Contacts

#117

Today, 06:36 PM

mbgalg

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up You can say it all you want, we want actual documented proof, video etc..... Come on, how are we supposed to actually believe this? I can say i banged Rihanna rite now, without proof, the whole forum would laugh at me. after looking at your picture, if i was in the bedroom while you were in the sack with rihanna and i myself had the video camera i still wouldn't believe it!

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#118 Today, 06:38 PM

Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg after looking at your picture, if i was in the bedroom while you were in the sack with rihanna and i myself had the video camera i still wouldn't believe it! Dude, i'm a handsome mofo. You can't see that? I get more ass than a toilet seat. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#119 Today, 06:38 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 LOL... How bout geeknomo?? Yup, another whiny bastard who couldn't handle it here, Mr. Exe! __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#120

Today, 06:41 PM

mbgalg

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Dude, i'm a handsome mofo. You can't see that? I get more ass than a toilet seat. who did that song? eminem?

mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#121

Today, 06:41 PM

Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: East Fallowfield PA Posts: 557 Real Name: Russell

Russell3 Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Dude, i'm a handsome mofo. You can't see that? I get more ass than a toilet seat. ROTFLMAO!

Russell3 View Public Profile Send a private message to Russell3 Find all posts by Russell3 Add Russell3 to Your Contacts

#122

Today, 06:42 PM

strutn45 Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Yup, another whiny bastard who couldn't handle it here, Mr. Exe! Yeah, we got another one in this thread too...just sent you a PM. __________________ "WHO DAT"

strutn45

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#123

Today, 06:42 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg who did that song? eminem? No his brother, Reeses Pieces. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#124

Today, 06:43 PM

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russell3 NOW I'M NOT TAKING SIDES!!!! But Rick can we disprove what he's saying? Btw, is Rihanna any good in bed? I've heard conflicting reports The best thing any of you can do is take your own sandstone dial watch to a geologist and have them look at it under a microscope. Maybe they can see it through the crystal. Find out for yourself what it is and draw your own conclusions.

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts

#125

Today, 06:45 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Russell3 NOW I'M NOT TAKING SIDES!!!! But Rick can we disprove what he's saying?

Btw, is Rihanna any good in bed? I've heard conflicting reports Agree with your point, but its like innocent until proven guilty, in my book. Lets see the proof, then tar and feather. And, yes, she's the shiznit! __________________

Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: The home of quality frankfurts, NYC USA Posts: 1,684

Bahoomba Senior Member Super Geek

quikfix, In the past, I've enjoyed your posts and I have no reason to dispute your findings. Sorry to hear this stuff...the truth can hurt, and a lot.

Bahoomba View Public Profile Send a private message to Bahoomba Find all posts by Bahoomba Add Bahoomba to Your Contacts

#127

Today, 06:45 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: St. Louis, MO Posts: 1,007 Real Name: Larry

BocephusSTL Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg after looking at your picture, if i was in the bedroom while you were in the sack with rihanna and i myself had the video camera i still wouldn't believe it! Who cares if you believe it, as long as the tabloids do. They pay big bucks for these tapes! And leave Rick alone - he's a STUD!!! (Hey Rick, you can just Paypal me the $20 for saying that.)

__________________ Quote:

Originally Posted by jskelton You will not become a ninja by wearing one. You will not become a trained soldier by wearing one. You will not become a sex-crazed spy by wearing one..... Last edited by BocephusSTL; Today at 06:47 PM. Reason: typo

BocephusSTL View Public Profile Send a private message to BocephusSTL Send email to BocephusSTL Visit BocephusSTL's homepage! Find all posts by BocephusSTL Add BocephusSTL to Your Contacts

#128

Today, 06:45 PM

mbgalg

Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Dude, i'm a handsome mofo. You can't see that? I get more ass than a toilet seat. maybe i should put my glasses on

mbgalg

View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#129

Today, 06:46 PM

PUCKSK8R

Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: On the Jersey Shore Posts: 3,574 Real Name: Daren

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

I will also wait to pass judgement but so far I am seeing some very valid points. I see the perspective on the unique "play on words" but one point I thought particularly interesting was the cavaet emptor perspective. I guess we will all wait and see. Should be interesting for sure. __________________ Class...Quelle heure est il? - Madame Eno (My 8th grade French Teacher)

PUCKSK8R View Public Profile Send a private message to PUCKSK8R Find all posts by PUCKSK8R Add PUCKSK8R to Your Contacts

#130

Today, 06:47 PM

ZRXBILL Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by BocephusSTL

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Sand Springs, OK. Posts: 366 Real Name: Bill

I think the whole point of this thread is that we were told one thing, and it appears it may not be true. Value is clearly not the issue here - it's sandstone after all. The issue is honesty and factual correctness. Exactly. Even the $5 coaster my drink is on is sandstone and it's way bigger than any dial.

ZRXBILL View Public Profile Send a private message to ZRXBILL Find all posts by ZRXBILL Add ZRXBILL to Your Contacts

#131

Today, 06:47 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by mbgalg maybe i should put my glasses on You should, cuz it seems to me you're calling me ugly. That shyt don't fly with me. Come out and say it or shut your piehole! __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up

Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#132 Today, 06:48 PM Join Date: Feb 2009 Posts: 99

mbgalg Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by BocephusSTL Who cares if you believe, and long as the tabloids do. They pay big bucks for these tapes! And leave Rick alone - he's a STUD!!! (Hey Rick, you can just Paypal me the $20 for saying that.)

the fact that you claim he's a stud and how you come about this information ain't none of my business. mbgalg View Public Profile Send a private message to mbgalg Find all posts by mbgalg Add mbgalg to Your Contacts

#133

Today, 06:49 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Dallas, TX Posts: 137

soundbite Senior Member Senior Geek

soundbite View Public Profile Send a private message to soundbite Find all posts by soundbite Add soundbite to Your Contacts

#134

Today, 06:50 PM

Russell3

Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: East Fallowfield PA Posts: 557 Real Name: Russell

Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Agree with your point, but its like innocent until proven guilty, in my book. Lets see the proof, then tar and feather. And, yes, she's the shiznit! I can live with that.

You lucky Dog!

Russell3 View Public Profile Send a private message to Russell3 Find all posts by Russell3 Add Russell3 to Your Contacts

#135

Today, 06:51 PM

Mastersergeant30yrRet Member Member Geek

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Lakeridge, VA. Posts: 48 Real Name: Terry

P.S. after re-assembly my Escursion now has a sunless-ray dial and my Venom now has an Uncle of Pearl dial. Yeah, you know you want em![/quote] Yeah, but now you've voided your warranty!!

Mastersergeant30yrRet View Public Profile Send a private message to Mastersergeant30yrRet Find all posts by Mastersergeant30yrRet Add Mastersergeant30yrRet to Your Contacts

#136

Today, 06:52 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 24

Mark Szorik Junior Member New Geek

You are welcome Wisper. I read somewhere recently that someone has even attempted to counterfeit a vintage Ferrari, did a reasonable job of it, and pocketed a ton of cash as a result of it. Take Care.

Mark Szorik View Public Profile Send a private message to Mark Szorik Find all posts by Mark Szorik Add Mark Szorik to Your Contacts

#137 Today, 06:52 PM Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Staten Island New York Posts: 12,406 Real Name: Nick

Chief68 WatchGeeks Moderator True WatchGeek

Guys Lets Play Nice - OKay __________________

NYPD Emergency Service Unit

Chief68 View Public Profile Send a private message to Chief68 Send email to Chief68 Visit Chief68's homepage! Find all posts by Chief68 Add Chief68 to Your Contacts #138

Today, 06:53 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chief68

Guys Lets Play Nice - OKay Ok, Nick. He called me ugly (just about) though. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#139

Today, 06:55 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: St. Louis, MO Posts: 1,007 Real Name: Larry

BocephusSTL Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Ok, Nick. He called me ugly (just about) though. Well I called you a stud, but that doesn't make it true. Just kidding, Rick! __________________ Quote:

Originally Posted by jskelton You will not become a ninja by wearing one. You will not become a trained soldier by wearing one. You will not become a sex-crazed spy by wearing one.....

BocephusSTL View Public Profile

Send a private message to BocephusSTL Send email to BocephusSTL Visit BocephusSTL's homepage! Find all posts by BocephusSTL Add BocephusSTL to Your Contacts

#140

Today, 06:55 PM

karns944

Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Ohio Posts: 254 Real Name: Matthew

Senior Member Senior Geek

Wow......... guess all I care about is if I like the watch or not. The best thing to do is just mute the TV and buy the watch you like. Oh well just my 2 cents

karns944 View Public Profile Send a private message to karns944 Find all posts by karns944 Add karns944 to Your Contacts

#141

Today, 06:56 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peaceful75 Some of this is rather curious to think about, but I own a Classique Pinnacle w/ the midnight blue sandstone, and you know what? The watch is gorgeous. Even if it is the Goldstone that Timeman posted pics of, it's still gorgeous. I would be interested to see what Invicta says about this, if anything, but I will still love and wear my Pinnacle either

way...who knows? The information does sound compelling that something stinks here, but hopefully one of our big-wigs here will step forward and give some information on this...? I doubt if Invicta will comment on this. When I bought my wife the diamond accented Invicta Classique from SNBC, that turned out to be crystals instead, Invicta or anyone associated with them spoke of it. I wrote Rebecca who is the head customer service representative of Invicta an e-mail on this. I NEVER even received an acknowledgment e-mail back NOTHING. It would be great if Invicta spoke of this, to clear this matter up. I don't think it will happen. Hope I'm proven wrong. __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts

#142

Today, 06:56 PM

WatchGeek4Life Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chief68

Guys Lets Play Nice - OKay I knew this was coming....getting a little heated in here. __________________

Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Rochester, NY Posts: 2,394 Real Name: Jim

Breitling Bentley WatchGeek4Life View Public Profile Send a private message to WatchGeek4Life Find all posts by WatchGeek4Life Add WatchGeek4Life to Your Contacts

#143

Today, 06:57 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Chicago Posts: 1,049 Real Name: Mike

reddog1 Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up dude, i'm a handsome mofo. You can't see that? I get more ass than a toilet seat. that was toooooooo much!!!:rolf: __________________

"JUST LET ME TRY THE WATCH ON"

reddog1 View Public Profile Send a private message to reddog1 Send email to reddog1 Find all posts by reddog1 Add reddog1 to Your Contacts

#144 Today, 06:58 PM Join Date: May 2009 Location: Everett Wa. Posts: 4,019 Real Name: C.J.

reliefcp

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Rick I think we have a winner in HTs busted lip prize. __________________

reliefcp View Public Profile Send a private message to reliefcp Find all posts by reliefcp Add reliefcp to Your Contacts #145 Today, 07:00 PM

RipitRon

Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Vancouver, Wa Posts: 2,761

Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Ok, Nick. He called me ugly (just about) though. You are Ugly, so what? LOL like me you have been that way for some time, get over it Rick!!! __________________ Not the official Invicta complain Dept

RipitRon View Public Profile Send a private message to RipitRon Find all posts by RipitRon Add RipitRon to Your Contacts #146 Today, 07:06 PM

chitown

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Tampa Florida Posts: 1,914

Senior Member Super Geek

On one of the shows, Mike was talking about fake sandstone with Tim, and he said he thought it would just be a matter of time before a company would do that. Now Mike and Tim I'm sure didn't know, and knowingly lied about it, but why after things were just starting to go Invicta's way with the CS and thing, it really sucks.

chitown View Public Profile

Send a private message to chitown Send email to chitown Find all posts by chitown Add chitown to Your Contacts #147

Today, 07:07 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by RipitRon You are Ugly, so what? LOL like me you have been that way for some time, get over it Rick!!! Hey, speak for yourself! LMAO!! __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#148

Today, 07:07 PM

Jch2707 Member Member Geek

Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Fort Worth, Tx Posts: 37 Real Name: Clint

I like the pack your lunch part! Ha

Jch2707 View Public Profile Send a private message to Jch2707 Find all posts by Jch2707 Add Jch2707 to Your Contacts

#149 Today, 07:08 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by reliefcp Rick I think we have a winner in HTs busted lip prize. Agreed, CJ! __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#150

Today, 07:08 PM Join Date: Jun 2008 Posts: 337

Da Mad Scientist Senior Member Senior Geek

Fellow geeks, the issue of sandstone being natural or not is all relative. How do you define natural? I think most of us are under the impression that 'natural' constitutes as a sandstone slice pulled directly from nature and not modified in any manner. This is extremely naive. This probably explains why so many geeks have an issue. What about the components of the sandstone itself? Are all the components natural? Is only one component natural? Is the color natural? Has it been dyed? Are the components natural, and the manner in which the dial is made unnatural? Who exactly defines natural to begin with? I can't imagine there being a sanctioning body that establishes strict parameters on what exactly sandstone is, but I'm sure a geologist would tell you a different opinion. Take this one word for example....'affordable'. How do you define affordable? It's all relative. What's an affordable watch? Are you using some computer algorithm to determine the average income of watch buyers and the average they spend on a watch to define an 'affordable' watch? Here's another example..... Romain Jerome... famous watchmaker that designed the Titanic DNA watch states that their watch is made from steel that built the Titanic - which isn't technically true. Technically speaking, the steel made for the DNA watch was pulled from Titanic's shipyard (Harland & Wolff), and not actually from Titanic itself. It was treated (possibly in an acid bath) but Romain Jerome won't comment on that to make the bezels appear to have an aged and weathered patina. Does this make Romain Jerome liars? ....you be the judge. ShopNBC makes countless claims all the time that are questionable, but again, it's all relative. Invicta doesn't use top grade materials, but ShopNBC and Invicta say they do. 316L is not a top grade material. Rubber is not top grade. Using friction pins is not top grade construction. There are plenty of other maufacturers using better material. Then again..... how do you define 'top grade materials'? Encasing a watch in solid gold would be a better material over 316L from a purist point of view, but from a durability persepective, gold isn't very durable at all.

To be honest, I take what ShopNBC says and well as any other manufactuers with a LARGE grain of salt. You'd be very naive to think what they state is 100% accurate. At the very least, it's an elasticity of the truth, and a great one at that. Join Date: May 2009 Location: Mission Viejo, CA Posts: 1,387 Real Name: Sam

samuelrz Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchYaThink .... hmmmm, makes one wonder about those original statements about how expensive and exclusive sandstone dials actually are? Sandstone is actually very plentiful. __________________

SAM -

samuelrz View Public Profile Send a private message to samuelrz Send email to samuelrz Find all posts by samuelrz Add samuelrz to Your Contacts

#152

Today, 07:12 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: OHIO Posts: 8,576

GeorgeTheWatchGuy WatchGeeks Moderator True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB we need to calm down fellow geeks or this thread will be no more. Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Hey Slomo, you gonna get a pat on the back from Alain for this? WatchLords in the house guys. Quote:

Originally Posted by strutn45 LOL... How bout geeknomo?? OK ... We are way off topic now... __________________

"There are Two Types of Pain in this World: The Temporary Pain of Discipline, or the Permanent Pain of Regret"... GTWG

GeorgeTheWatchGuy View Public Profile Send a private message to GeorgeTheWatchGuy Find all posts by GeorgeTheWatchGuy Add GeorgeTheWatchGuy to Your Contacts

#153

Today, 07:18 PM

Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Brentwood,Northern CA Posts: 769

Franco Senior Member Veteran Geek

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandstone some reading

Franco View Public Profile Send a private message to Franco Find all posts by Franco Add Franco to Your Contacts

#154

Today, 07:20 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Ok, the OP is a WatchLord and so is the guy he got the watch from. Take this thread for what its worth, absolutely nothing. That site has it in for everthing WG's and Jim/Michael, Invicta and Shopnbc. Trust me. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up

Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#155

Today, 07:21 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: USA Posts: 121

baker.bjs Senior Member Senior Geek

This is like the twilight zone. One bizarre story after another. At some point some of these allegations will prove to be true and then what? Aren't we all victims if they are playing us as fools. __________________

Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves. ~Abraham Lincoln

baker.bjs View Public Profile Send a private message to baker.bjs Find all posts by baker.bjs Add baker.bjs to Your Contacts #156

Today, 07:23 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

I see we are back. Thread was locked down now it's reopened? __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts

#157

Today, 07:23 PM Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Southern New Jersey Posts: 645 Real Name: Moses

06Pastmaster Senior Member Veteran Geek

I think Invicta is losing credibility and will continue to do so until it comes clean and personally answers all allegations and makes good on any product not being produced the way it is described __________________ " If Time is Money, How come I have all the Time and still no Money? "

06Pastmaster View Public Profile Send a private message to 06Pastmaster Send email to 06Pastmaster Find all posts by 06Pastmaster Add 06Pastmaster to Your Contacts #158

Today, 07:24 PM

Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: NYC Posts: 149 Real Name: Irene

Peaceful75 Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by soundbite Can anybody that purchased one of the sandstone dial watches tell us if it mentions sandstone on the back of the watch? I ask because Renato does it with their Onyx dial watches. OK, I just ran and took these with my cell, this is my Classique Pinnacle Sandstone, front and back. There is no mention of sandstone on the back..

__________________ Even a broken watch is right twice a day. With a 5-year warranty, I'd rather get it fixed!

Peaceful75 View Public Profile Send a private message to Peaceful75 Send email to Peaceful75 Find all posts by Peaceful75 Add Peaceful75 to Your Contacts

#159

Today, 07:25 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: USA Posts: 121

baker.bjs Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 06Pastmaster I think Invicta is losing credibility and will continue to do so until it comes clean and personally answers all allegations and makes good on any product not being produced the way it is described Just like Roger Clemens...deny, deny, deny __________________

Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves. ~Abraham Lincoln

baker.bjs View Public Profile Send a private message to baker.bjs Find all posts by baker.bjs Add baker.bjs to Your Contacts

#160

Today, 07:26 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: NYC Posts: 149 Real Name: Irene

Peaceful75 Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by timeman I see we are back. Thread was locked down now it's reopened? Yes, it seems so. When I first went to post my pics, it was locked, and then poof, it was opened __________________ Even a broken watch is right twice a day. With a 5-year warranty, I'd rather get it fixed!

Peaceful75 View Public Profile Send a private message to Peaceful75 Send email to Peaceful75 Find all posts by Peaceful75 Add Peaceful75 to Your Contacts

#161

Today, 07:27 PM

strutn45

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: "Da Swamp" LA. Posts: 9,933 Real Name: John "WHO DAT"

Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

"WHO DAT"

strutn45 View Public Profile Send a private message to strutn45 Find all posts by strutn45 Add strutn45 to Your Contacts

#162

Today, 07:28 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: USA Posts: 121

baker.bjs Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peaceful75 OK, I just ran and took these with my cell, this is my Classique Pinnacle Sandstone, front and back. There is no mention of sandstone on the back..

http://www.shopnbc.com/Invicta_Men_s_or_Women_s_Classique_Pinnacle_Stainl ess_Steel_Bracelet_Watch/J179201.aspx?storeid=1&cm_re=SearchList-_-N-_N&page=LIST&category=Watches|t311&prop=Invicta|483 &catprop=483 From the renowned Classique Pinnacle collection comes a striking sandstone dial with mother-of-pearl subdials __________________

Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves. ~Abraham Lincoln

baker.bjs View Public Profile Send a private message to baker.bjs Find all posts by baker.bjs Add baker.bjs to Your Contacts

#163

Today, 07:29 PM Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Southern New Jersey Posts: 645 Real Name: Moses

06Pastmaster Senior Member Veteran Geek

I have many watches and none of them have dial desciptions engraved on the caseback. If they say its sandstone it better be sandstone... bottom line! __________________

" If Time is Money, How come I have all the Time and still no Money? "

06Pastmaster View Public Profile Send a private message to 06Pastmaster Send email to 06Pastmaster Find all posts by 06Pastmaster Add 06Pastmaster to Your Contacts

#164

Today, 07:29 PM

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by timeman I see we are back. Thread was locked down now it's reopened? Interesting. A few of the usual Invicta defenders try to hijack this thread and close it down with their typical inane off topic babble, but it comes back. I'm impressed. __________________

in the summertime!

Hot fun

CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#165

Today, 07:31 PM

chitown

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Tampa Florida Posts: 1,914

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark Szorik I am by NO means an expert yet, however, I am currently finishing the forth year of my second BS degree in Geology at Utah State University so I would like to offer some comments. Please take this as my attempt to be informative and not act as a "know it all". Sandstone is a sedimentary rock that is composed of grains that were previously eroded from other rocks - i.e igneous, feldspar, quartz, etc. and subsequently deposited, cemented or lithified (i.e. calcite cementation or extreme pressure over time). If I were to analyze this dial material I would characterize (identify) what the grains are made of, again quartz, feldspar, etc. - this is relatively easy to determine without destroying the dial (need high microscopic magnification). Additionally, a determination of the type of cementation that is holding the grains together would help determine if the material is natural versus synthetic. Conducting this type of test is typically destructive (acid or microscopic thin section). While I have never personally seen sandstone in these vibrant colors that does NOT by mean that they are not produced by nature. Invicta's supplier may have used a dye to create the vibrant optical effect. Occasionally geologists use dyes to help identify certain rock and mineral types. I suspect that producing sandstone dials this thin are well within the capabilities of the watch industry, but overall durability would be a function of material thickness and how it is bonded to the dial base (if this is what they have done). The origin of this raw material is should be relatively easy for Invicta to prove if they desire to do so. Then again, for a competitive advantage many companies tend to keep their material source internal (secret) for a competitive advantage. Kind Regards. Your right about the manufacturer adding things to the gems. They say it right on the gem site and before the gem stone shows.

chitown View Public Profile Send a private message to chitown Send email to chitown Find all posts by chitown Add chitown to Your Contacts

#166

Today, 07:31 PM

Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: NYC Posts: 149 Real Name: Irene

Peaceful75 Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by baker.bjs http://www.shopnbc.com/Invicta_Men_s_or_Women_s_Classique_Pinnacle_Stainl ess_Steel_Bracelet_Watch/J179201.aspx?storeid=1&cm_re=SearchList-_-N-_N&page=LIST&category=Watches|t311&prop=Invicta|483 &catprop=483 From the renowned Classique Pinnacle collection comes a striking sandstone dial with mother-of-pearl subdials Hey Baker, I'm not disputing the fact, I purchased this watch because I adore it, I was only answering the request made __________________ Even a broken watch is right twice a day. With a 5-year warranty, I'd rather get it fixed!

Peaceful75 View Public Profile Send a private message to Peaceful75 Send email to Peaceful75 Find all posts by Peaceful75 Add Peaceful75 to Your Contacts

#167

Today, 07:33 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB Interesting. A few of the usual Invicta defenders try to hijack this thread and close it down with their typical inane off topic babble, but it comes back. I'm impressed. Maybe it was a consensus of minds, and our exchange of opinions was permitted to continue. __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts

#168

Today, 07:34 PM

ZRXBILL

Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Sand Springs, OK. Posts: 366 Real Name: Bill

Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

I'm lost..................what site?

ZRXBILL View Public Profile Send a private message to ZRXBILL Find all posts by ZRXBILL Add ZRXBILL to Your Contacts

#169

Today, 07:34 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Philadelphia, PA Posts: 227 Real Name: Jon

jwin66 Senior Member Senior Geek

I for one hope that's not the case. If Invicta is intentionally misrepresenting the true nature of the stone, natural or man made, then it constitutes fraud. If however they purchased the dials not knowing their authenticity then that's another matter. Either way Invicta needs to set the record straight about the authenticity of all of the materials it sources, if the observation by said geologist has merit. Jon

Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchGeek4Life

Now what!!!

First we have the swiss made issue Then we have crystals instead of diamonds and now this!!! What is next, that our Meteorite dials are not real meteorite? I would like to hear the explanation from Invicta on this one. Last edited by jwin66; Today at 07:48 PM. Reason: editing

jwin66 View Public Profile Send a private message to jwin66 Send email to jwin66 Find all posts by jwin66 Add jwin66 to Your Contacts

#170

Today, 07:36 PM Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Beautiful Gulfcoast of Florida Posts: 1,754 Real Name: Patrick

heronmark Senior Member Super Geek

I tried to start a drinking game for complaint threads to do a shot everytime we go way the heck off topic.........................I passed out on page three, where do we stand now? __________________

heronmark

View Public Profile Send a private message to heronmark Send email to heronmark Find all posts by heronmark Add heronmark to Your Contacts

#171 Today, 07:37 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 860

Franky5Angels Senior Member Veteran Geek

I think this answerfrom Eyal says a lot

#109 08-27-2010, 04:14 PM

WatchGeeks VIP Senior Geek Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 314

TeamInvicta

Ask any racer. Any real racer. It don't matter if you win by an inch or a mile. Winning's winning

Franky5Angels View Public Profile Send a private message to Franky5Angels Find all posts by Franky5Angels Add Franky5Angels to Your Contacts

#172

Today, 07:37 PM

Arifani247 Member Member Geek

What other untruths are there ?

Arifani247 View Public Profile Send a private message to Arifani247 Send email to Arifani247 Find all posts by Arifani247 Add Arifani247 to Your Contacts

#173

Today, 07:38 PM

Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 59

Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZRXBILL I'm lost..................what site? WatchLords. Its a site made up of banned WG members who have it in for WG's, Jim, Michael, Invicta and Shopnbc. They were members here and for whatever reason(s), chose to open their site and totally talk about (all the time) and trash everything here on their site. This will get copy/pasted on their site very shortly, i'm sure. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#174

Today, 07:39 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Live Free or Die NH Posts: 426

Knifemaker Senior Member Senior Geek

All that stuff has to be stabilized with acrylics weather it be vacuum through or pressed

together. Even the green turquoise that the Shop sells on rings and jewelry is stabilized so do not think that sandstone isn't it would crumble like a house of cards if it where not. I work with exotic materials whether it burl woods Woolly Mammoth Ivory & tooth and stones of every type lapidary is my trade. Very messy and Tuff on the lungs also So do not sweat it be happy be glad the stuff is stabilized it keeps it together and workable. I am and I do not even own a sandstone watch. Just someone would works it every day making fancy knives. Look at the spacer between the stag and Ironwood on the handle below... . __________________

for the serious collectors

Stebbins Handmade Damascus Knives

Knifemaker View Public Profile Send a private message to Knifemaker Send email to Knifemaker Visit Knifemaker's homepage! Find all posts by Knifemaker Add Knifemaker to Your Contacts

#175

Today, 07:41 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: USA Posts: 121

baker.bjs Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up WatchLords. Its a site made up of banned WG members who have it in for WG's, Jim, Michael, Invicta and Shopnbc. They were members here and for whatever reason(s), chose to open their site and totally talk about (all the time) and trash everything here on their site. This will get copy/pasted on their site very shortly, i'm sure. Just because Lords hates us doesn't mean this or any of the other issues are less real __________________ Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves. ~Abraham Lincoln

Knifemaker

Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Live Free or Die NH Posts: 426

Senior Member Senior Geek

All that stuff has to be stabilized with acrylics weather it be vacuum through or pressed together. Even the green turquoise that the Shop sells on rings and jewelry is stabilized so do not think that sandstone isn't it would crumble like a house of cards if it where not. I work with exotic materials whether it burl woods Woolly Mammoth Ivory & tooth and stones of every type lapidary is my trade. Very messy and Tuff on the lungs also So do not sweat it be happy be glad the stuff is stabilized it keeps it together and workable. I am and I do not even own a sandstone watch. Just someone would works it every day making fancy knives. Look at the spacer between the stag and Ironwood on the handle below... . __________________

Knives for the serious collectors

Stebbins Handmade Damascus

Knifemaker View Public Profile Send a private message to Knifemaker Send email to Knifemaker Visit Knifemaker's homepage! Find all posts by Knifemaker Add Knifemaker to Your Contacts #175 Today, 07:41 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: USA Posts: 121

baker.bjs Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves. ~Abraham Lincoln

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Denver Posts: 696 Real Name: John

qwikfix Senior Member Veteran Geek

Here are a couple of interesting searches Goldstone Aventurine glass and a really good one is to use google images and do a search aventurine glass watch dials.

qwikfix View Public Profile Send a private message to qwikfix Find all posts by qwikfix Add qwikfix to Your Contacts #177 Today, 07:43 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 484

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

A quote everyone's mom said to everyone as we were all little kids. "Your all having fun now...until someone gets their eyes poked out" LMAO.... __________________

B I B L E = Basic Instructions Before Leaving Earth The Watch Whisper View Public Profile Send a private message to The Watch Whisper Find all posts by The Watch Whisper

Add The Watch Whisper to Your Contacts

#178

Today, 07:44 PM Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: AZ. Posts: 67

phish

Member Member Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Franky5Angels I think this answerfrom Eyal says a lot

#109 08-27-2010, 04:14 PM

WatchGeeks VIP Senior Geek Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 314

TeamInvicta

Your gotta be kidding me that there are no watch tech's in Fla... *** I refuse to debate this with you, that is how I run my company. When you open your own watch company feel free to run it as you like I followed the back and forth between you guys. I thought his comments were uncalled for in this type of forum. __________________

Bears, Cubs, Bulls and Hawks!

phish View Public Profile Send a private message to phish Find all posts by phish Add phish to Your Contacts

#179

Today, 07:44 PM Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Braintee, MA. Posts: 13,095 Real Name: Rick

50mm&up Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by baker.bjs Just because Lords hates us doesn't mean this or any of the other issues are less real Agreed, but it brings into question what the OP is trying to say/do here. Don't you think? There is no proof, someone you don't know posted a problem with their, excuse me, a "friend" of theirs watch that was in pieces when the OP recieved it. You are that trustworthy, right off the bat? I need proof, thats just me, i don't even own a sandstone dialed watch. __________________

50mm&up View Public Profile Send a private message to 50mm&up Send email to 50mm&up Find all posts by 50mm&up Add 50mm&up to Your Contacts

#180 Today, 07:45 PM

chitown

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Tampa Florida Posts: 1,914

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Franco http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sandstone some reading So after reading that Sandstone is compressed water, quartz,etc. So Eyal was right natural, they didn't paint it on and put glitter in it, would be worth the same I guess, but it's not like a diamond,or gold, it is sand no big deal. Never heard any host say it was worth more just that it was beautiful, and like Midnight Sky. They all told the truth.

chitown View Public Profile Send a private message to chitown Send email to chitown Find all posts by chitown Add chitown to Your Contacts

#181

Today, 07:45 PM

Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: Staten Island New York Posts: 12,406 Real Name: Nick

Chief68 WatchGeeks Moderator True WatchGeek

Lets stay on topic and give Invicta a chance to see this thread so Eyal can answer some questions . He has been very active here as of late so give him the chance. We do not want to close the thread so stay within the TOS and have an ON TOPIC conversation. THANKS __________________

NYPD Emergency Service Unit

Chief68 View Public Profile Send a private message to Chief68 Send email to Chief68 Visit Chief68's homepage! Find all posts by Chief68 Add Chief68 to Your Contacts #182

Today, 07:46 PM

curiousgeorge Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Mpls Posts: 2,646 Real Name: George

Quote:

Originally Posted by timeman

IF it's not sandstone there is a man made substance called Goldstone that looks like this

artifacts suitable for semiprecious stone, and in fact goldstone is often mistaken for or misrepresented as a natural material." This?

curiousgeorge View Public Profile Send a private message to curiousgeorge Find all posts by curiousgeorge Add curiousgeorge to Your Contacts

#183

Today, 07:48 PM

pirate

Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: bakersfield,ca Posts: 433 Real Name: terry

Senior Member Senior Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by watchdude wow, if this is true for invicta I wonder About Swiss Legend. Could this be intentional or were the watchmakers also fooled. If this is factual I think those that bought with the understanding this was a natural formation should be offered their money back or some attorney will look into a class action suit I would imagin. my SL sandstone dial watch caseback reads "genuine high grade sandstone dial". My Invicta sandstone has no such inscription..........just say'n..............

pirate View Public Profile Send a private message to pirate Send email to pirate Find all posts by pirate Add pirate to Your Contacts

#184

Today, 07:53 PM

pirate Senior Member Senior Geek

Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: bakersfield,ca Posts: 433 Real Name: terry

Quote:

pirate View Public Profile Send a private message to pirate Send email to pirate Find all posts by pirate Add pirate to Your Contacts

#185 Today, 07:54 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chief68

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts

#186

Today, 07:58 PM Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Central VA. Blue Ridge MTNS. Posts: 3,090 Real Name: Lynn

bugduck Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Wow, Sorry to see this Contoversy. I will have to say, I NEED Documented Fact to beleive this one. Personally, I Do NOT Think EYAL is Lying, as Some have stated.

bugduck View Public Profile Send a private message to bugduck Send email to bugduck Find all posts by bugduck Add bugduck to Your Contacts #187

Today, 07:59 PM

chitown Senior Member Super Geek

Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Tampa Florida Posts: 1,914

Quote:

chitown View Public Profile Send a private message to chitown Send email to chitown Find all posts by chitown Add chitown to Your Contacts #188 Today, 07:59 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Long Island, New York Posts: 5,480 Real Name: Jerry

timeman Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by timeman

Quote:

Originally Posted by curiousgeorge This? The above photos are that of Goldstone and not Sandstone. Goldstone is man-made glass and contain certain metals to give the star sparkle effect. __________________

timeman View Public Profile Send a private message to timeman Find all posts by timeman Add timeman to Your Contacts #189 Today, 08:01 PM

curiousgeorge Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Quote:

Join Date: Apr 2009 Location: Mpls Posts: 2,646 Real Name: George

Originally Posted by timeman The above photo is that of Goldstone and not Sandstone. Goldstone is made of glass and contain certain metals to give the star sparkle effect. That's why I re-posted your early post so people could see it for themselves. Looks a hell of lot like what is being sold.

curiousgeorge View Public Profile Send a private message to curiousgeorge Find all posts by curiousgeorge Add curiousgeorge to Your Contacts

#190

Today, 08:02 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: San Antonio Texas Posts: 484

The Watch Whisper Senior Member Senior Geek

I agree with Chief & Timeman... Its only right and fair to have them(the people at Invicta)reply to this discussion/topic. But after all this a forum is designed to be able to discuss these type of questions? As long as we do it in a respectfull way. __________________

#191

Today, 08:11 PM

Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 855

RGILLER Senior Member Veteran Geek

I can honestly say that I have never known of another watch company with so much controversy. I hope Eyal clears this up in a timely manner..Roy __________________ God Bless the USA

RGILLER View Public Profile Send a private message to RGILLER Find all posts by RGILLER Add RGILLER to Your Contacts

#192 Today, 08:32 PM

mrblue

Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 2,441

Senior Member Super Geek

Rick .. 50 mm and up .. Thanks for the entertaining banter, and though off topic at times your points hit the mark bro !! Let me say this: .... well, cause I'm Mr Blue .. THE TRUTH IS THE LIGHT. IT HAS NO SHADOW !! .. BUT ONE LIE IS SHADOWED BY ANOTHER ........ Confucius S____. What was that ? ... Who said that .. huh ? ....................................... Blue

mrblue View Public Profile Send a private message to mrblue Find all posts by mrblue Add mrblue to Your Contacts #193

Today, 08:54 PM Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: st. louis, missouri Posts: 650 Real Name: Dave

uman Senior Member Veteran Geek

this is an interesting and humerous thread. My take is don't care if its fake, real, or some hybrid thereof, do not own any sandstone dial watches but would not hesitate in buying if I GOT THE URGE.. What caught my eye was post 39 where brother geek the watcher took a little shot at slick willy Clinton, and yes he was wearing his sandstone dial watch while enjoying the friendly advances of an "all in" admirer .

uman View Public Profile Send a private message to uman Send email to uman Find all posts by uman Add uman to Your Contacts #194

Today, 09:01 PM

rgmb2 Senior Member Senior Geek

Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Chicago Posts: 294 Real Name: Mike

Just saw a cool episode of "how the earth was made." the sahara has lots of sandstone and it allows water to flow through which ultimately gets trapped below ground. Maybe we should spill something on the dials and see if the cases act as aquafers.....

rgmb2 View Public Profile Send a private message to rgmb2 Find all posts by rgmb2 Add rgmb2 to Your Contacts

#195 Today, 09:03 PM

Join Date: Mar 2008 Posts: 2,717

Watch_Crazy Senior Member Master WatchGeek

GAHD! ... Now I'm wonderin' whUT Eyal's so-called "Mother-Of-PEARL" really iZ !!! ...

_______________________________ ⌘ _______________________________ I sure hope it does NOT have ANYTHING to do with "MOTHER Love Bone" ...

...

... ... and Mssrs. Vedder, Ament, Gossard, McCready, and Cameron ...

...

YouTube- Pearl Jam - Black

_______________________________ ⌘ _______________________________ c'mon ... you really can't "pasticize" dat stuff an' turn it into watch dialZ ... er, can you ??? ... _______________________________ ⌘ _______________________________ NB: Like so many of my poZtZ, this one may be 'over the HEAD' of some folks! ... ...

__________________ HI! - I'm Larry & I'm Wacky About Watches -

… So, You Can Also Call Me … 'Crazy LARRY' -

Watch_Crazy

View Public Profile Send a private message to Watch_Crazy Find all posts by Watch_Crazy Add Watch_Crazy to Your Contacts

#196

Today, 09:06 PM

oceanghost39

Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: ladson SC Posts: 102 Real Name: robbie lee beebe jr.

Senior Member Senior Geek

show me the proof,anyone can say anything,or write anything show proof or shut up!show me that a license gemoligist signes off on that with his name,where invicta can sue them.or shut up stop being a hen and stop rumors,ts not cool with out proof

oceanghost39 View Public Profile Send a private message to oceanghost39 Find all posts by oceanghost39 Add oceanghost39 to Your Contacts

#197

Today, 09:11 PM Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Brentwood,Northern CA Posts: 769

Franco Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by rgmb2 Just saw a cool episode of "how the earth was made." the sahara has lots of sandstone and it allows water to flow through which ultimately gets trapped below ground. Maybe we should spill something on the dials and see if the cases act as aquafers..... Just saw the same episode

Franco View Public Profile Send a private message to Franco Find all posts by Franco Add Franco to Your Contacts #198

Today, 09:15 PM

robertjk

Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Staten Island New York Posts: 769 Real Name: Bob

Senior Member Veteran Geek

Guys,if you purchsed the watch because you liked the design and the look I really don't see the big deal. Real sandstone,Natural sandstone,Manufactured sand stone is not going to change the value one way or the other. If you bought a 2 ct diamond for 20,000 dollars and found out it was'nt real that would be an issue. Things are said on Shop NBC to enhance the sale of what ever the product is.Remember you bought a great looking time piece at a reasonable price wear it in good health and enjoy what it is you purchased. I don't think anyone on the shop is intentionally trying to mislead you there just doing there job selling watches.just my 2 cents. __________________ Advice is what we ask for when we already know the answer but wish we didn't.

robertjk View Public Profile Send a private message to robertjk Send email to robertjk Find all posts by robertjk Add robertjk to Your Contacts #199

Today, 09:22 PM Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Atlanta, GA Posts: 595 Real Name: James

jade330i Senior Member Veteran Geek

So almost 200 posts and still no proof..........hummmmmm........ __________________

More government is not the cure for the defect of less personal responsibility, it's an enabler; if people aren't accountable for their own actions then who is?"

jade330i View Public Profile Send a private message to jade330i Send email to jade330i Find all posts by jade330i Add jade330i to Your Contacts #200

Today, 09:27 PM Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Quad Cities (Moline, IL.) Posts: 1,161 Real Name: Joe

MamboKing Senior Member Super Geek

Lets not jump to quick conclusions gentlemen .... Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Virginia Posts: 517 Real Name: JayD

Stew Senior Member Veteran Geek

Proof would be in order. __________________ "Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Anyone Who Threatens It"

Stew View Public Profile Send a private message to Stew Send email to Stew Find all posts by Stew Add Stew to Your Contacts

#202

Today, 09:33 PM

SeaVulture

Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: San Antonio, Texas Posts: 2,389 Real Name: William

Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by oceanghost39 show me the proof,anyone can say anything,or write anything show proof or shut up!show me that a license gemoligist signes off on that with his name,where invicta can sue them.or shut up stop being a hen and stop rumors,ts not cool with out proof AMEN, Bro!! Quote:

Originally Posted by qwikfix What proof would be adequate? And more importantly how would this proof personally affect you? Perhaps the Gemologist can write a certification to this effect. Otherwise there is no point bringing this subject up except to create a problem. Quote:

Originally Posted by WatchYaThink You don't consider a microscopic analysis of an actual Invicta dial by a geologist to be proof? Not without documentation. Otherwise it is hearsay, and assumption. Put your name and reputatuion to it, like you've done to Jim, Eyal, and Michael. And don't hide your name. Quote:

Originally Posted by rottieluv I applaud the investigational queries by qwikfix, WatchYaThink, timeman and other WGs who don't just accept as fact every aspect of a sales pitch. No matter how innocently or innocuously information about the watches we buy is dispatched, the fact is many of us have come to realize that sometimes we are given incorrect information about these watches, and that is just wrong. ~ Denise What's wrong, is to bring a thing like this to light without evidence. You've planted a seed on this forum, and cannot back up your claim. Once again, you've outed yourselves and your intentions, without a backup. Let's see if this really requires a response. It doesn't for me. I did not buy a watch to see if what the salesman said was true. I did not buy a watch to try to prove something that may not be true. What a waste of money and time. I read every post before mine, and I have much more to say. I'll put it in terms that most here can understand. If you cannot find something nice to talk about, take it somewhere else. __________________

Welcome to The Invicta Reserve SubAqua Venom Valgrange A07.211 Automatic WatchGeek Registry! http://watchgeeks.net/showthread.php?t=90044

SeaVulture View Public Profile Send a private message to SeaVulture Find all posts by SeaVulture Add SeaVulture to Your Contacts

#203

Today, 09:33 PM Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Ohio Posts: 603 Real Name: Bill

MathGeek Senior Member Veteran Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by 50mm&up Ok, the OP is a WatchLord and so is the guy he got the watch from. Take this thread for what its worth, absolutely nothing. That site has it in for everthing WG's and Jim/Michael, Invicta and Shopnbc. Trust me. What's sad is that the other site has been going on about this watch that some hater tore apart for weeks. They were even more upset that none of use had mentioned it. This thread is a plant. It is meant to get us worked up so that the other site can post "OUR THREAD" and make fun of us.

MathGeek View Public Profile Send a private message to MathGeek Find all posts by MathGeek Add MathGeek to Your Contacts

#204

Today, 09:36 PM

CMORRISON

Join Date: May 2009 Posts: 1,680

Senior Member Super Geek

I dont own the watch, but when I initially saw the price I was confused. When the Reserve Titanium Lupah launched the cost (around $1000 if I remember) was

justified by the high end Seiko movement, Ti case and the dial (expensive and rare Sandstone or Meteorite) How did things change in less the a year to in price and availability to offer a watch for 1/10 the cost (albeit with a less expensive case and movement)

CMORRISON View Public Profile Send a private message to CMORRISON Find all posts by CMORRISON Add CMORRISON to Your Contacts

#205

Today, 09:42 PM Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: San Antonio, Texas Posts: 2,389 Real Name: William

SeaVulture Senior Member Super Geek

Perhaps they're operating with a less expensive cost, and a lower profit margin, so they can get you the watch you want. Eyal's bee saying for a while, that he is trying to get the csts down, so you can have the value you want. I was listening, and got some great deals. __________________

Welcome to The Invicta Reserve SubAqua Venom Valgrange A07.211 Automatic WatchGeek Registry! http://watchgeeks.net/showthread.php?t=90044

SeaVulture View Public Profile Send a private message to SeaVulture Find all posts by SeaVulture Add SeaVulture to Your Contacts

#206

Today, 09:43 PM Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 15,529 Real Name: "Diamond Jim" Skelton

jskelton

WatchGeeks Owner True WatchGeek

This thread has gotten very long, very quickly. I apologize for not being here earlier. I don't know where each brand is sourcing their dial materials for the sandstone offerings, but I have never been able to see a difference between Invicta, Swiss Legend, or the Tourneau branded watches I have held. There could be 10 sources or only one... not sure. As far as it being misunderstood and actually being Goldstone, I also cannot answer, although both examples posted in the first page do look very much like what we've been seeing in all of these watches. Whatever the case, I will be asking as well. If I was given wrong information, I want to know about it. Eyal has been notified about this topic and we should hopefully get a response for you soon. I will also be talking to Lior since he too works with Sandstone dials, and to my eye, they appear to be identical in every respect. All I know is that various Sandstone dial watches have gone through my hands, Lior's hands, Eyal's hands, and Juan Lopez-Davies... and I don't know that any of us have had any reason to question their validity... but if there is a story here, we would all want to know about it. I don't mention Lior and Juan to connect them to this situation, but rather to exhibit that more than just Invicta uses this material, and I don't see a visual difference. I have also shown the Sandstone chunk on-air a few times, and one side was polished (the rest was left natural), and that polished area of the large chunk looked identical to the dial in the watch I displayed... so again, no reason to believe anything except it would be authentic. Let's not get carried away with accusations, conspiracy theories, or angry words until we have more information. I also believe we would benefit from actual documentation from this geologist to back up the 1st side of this story so that we have both sides under equal

scrutiny with hopes that we can get a definite answer quickly, and the outcome is clear. __________________

Quote:

Living well is the best revenge. -George Herbert

Quote:

Originally Posted by charleswatts Your candor in the explanation reveals the nature of the relationship you have formed with your viewers.

jskelton View Public Profile Send a private message to jskelton Visit jskelton's homepage! Find all posts by jskelton Add jskelton to Your Contacts

#207

Today, 09:49 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by jskelton This thread has gotten very long, very quickly. I apologize for not being here earlier. I don't know where each brand is sourcing their dial materials for the sandstone offerings, but I have never been able to see a difference between Invicta, Swiss Legend, or the Tourneau branded watches I have held. There could be 10 sources or only one... not sure. As far as it being misunderstood and actually being Goldstone, I also cannot answer, although both examples posted in the first page do look very much like what we've been seeing in all of these watches. Whatever the case, I will be asking as well. If I was given wrong information, I want to know about it. Eyal has been notified about this topic and we should hopefully get a response for you soon. I will also be talking to Lior since he too works with Sandstone dials, and to my eye, they appear to be identical in every respect. All I know is that various Sandstone dial watches have gone through my hands, Lior's hands, Eyal's hands, and Juan Lopez-Davies... and I don't know that any of us have had any reason to question their validity... but if there is a story here, we would all want to know about it. I don't mention Lior and Juan to connect them to this situation, but rather to exhibit that more than just Invicta uses this material, and I don't see a visual difference. I have also shown the Sandstone chunk on-air a few times, and one side was polished (the rest was left natural), and that polished area of the large chunk looked identical to the dial in the watch I displayed... so again, no reason to believe anything except it would be authentic. Let's not get carried away with accusations, conspiracy theories, or angry words until we have more information. I also believe we would benefit from actual documentation from this geologist to back up the 1st side of this story so that we have both sides under equal scrutiny with hopes that we can get a definite answer quickly, and the outcome is clear. A very fair, reasonable and informative response. __________________

Hot fun in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#208 Today, 09:51 PM Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 15,529 Real Name: "Diamond Jim" Skelton

jskelton

WatchGeeks Owner True WatchGeek

Quote:

Originally Posted by MathGeek What's sad is that the other site has been going on about this watch that some hater tore apart for weeks. They were even more upset that none of use had mentioned it. This thread is a plant. It is meant to get us worked up so that the other site can post "OUR THREAD" and make fun of us. I too believe this to be true, at least at its Genesis.... But if it turns out that we needed to take a closer look here, then I am appreciative. I only hope that we're not taking all this time chasing our tails.

The OP of this topic (at the other forum) was someone I spent considerable time helping on a personal level, and as far as I know has quit smoking because of the time I spent helping him and providing info for him, so hopefully he remembers this and is actually trying to do something helpful rather than vindictive here... Of course many of my haters got a lot out of me on a personal level before turning around and taking their turn piling on, so what's one more? I suppose I should have always stuck to my "job" and never helped anyone, or offered up any of my personal time for their benefit, and maybe their expectations would not have gotten so high. But that's a separate issue really, and not on topic. __________________

Quote:

Living well is the best revenge. -George Herbert

Quote:

Originally Posted by charleswatts Your candor in the explanation reveals the nature of the relationship you have formed with your viewers.

jskelton View Public Profile Send a private message to jskelton Visit jskelton's homepage! Find all posts by jskelton Add jskelton to Your Contacts #209

Today, 09:51 PM

Genezilla Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sunny Southern Cali Posts: 2,680 Real Name: Gene

Jim I'm glad you're on this and we all look forward to the facts. Thanks again.

Genezilla View Public Profile Send a private message to Genezilla Find all posts by Genezilla Add Genezilla to Your Contacts #210

Today, 09:52 PM Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: NEW YORK CITY Posts: 1,280 Real Name: V.C.

subaquaviva Senior Member Super Geek

Rick, don't bother getting all worked up over this issue. You'll only get agita and you can't win with some of these people. The truth will come out either way. The haters will continue to hate, but we can go on loving our collections. __________________

subaquaviva

View Public Profile Send a private message to subaquaviva Send email to subaquaviva Find all posts by subaquaviva Add subaquaviva to Your Contacts

#211

Today, 09:56 PM Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 2,295

KOKONUTZ Senior Member Super Geek

Jim, Thanks for taking a leadership position on this issue. You have always conducted yourself to find the truth in any matter that evokes controversy, misunderstanding, inaccuracies, non truths, and the like

KOKONUTZ View Public Profile Send a private message to KOKONUTZ Find all posts by KOKONUTZ Add KOKONUTZ to Your Contacts #212

Today, 09:56 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Ohio Posts: 1,754

MATTNATTI Senior Member Super Geek

Although I don't own and never will own a sandstone dial it is very interesting subject and it is also refreshing to see ownership of this forum to come in so even keeled and say that he is going to look into it further.

Thanks jim __________________ Did you see that? Do they all got hedges like that? Do they?

MATTNATTI View Public Profile Send a private message to MATTNATTI Send email to MATTNATTI Find all posts by MATTNATTI Add MATTNATTI to Your Contacts #213

Today, 10:04 PM Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: On the Puget Sound, WA Posts: 12,672 Real Name: Charlie

CharlieB Senior Member True WatchGeek

There's no question in my mind that Jim and the whole Invicta team will tell us exactly what the reality is. __________________

in the summertime! CharlieB View Public Profile Send a private message to CharlieB

Hot fun

Find all posts by CharlieB Add CharlieB to Your Contacts

#214

Today, 10:05 PM Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Overland Park Posts: 1,194 Real Name: Jake

bentley85 Senior Member Super Geek

Just provide proof when making a claim like this. It is one thing to make a statement or call into question the sandstone being real but when you start making claims and saying they are true without physical proof you really are not accomplishing anything productive on this fourm! __________________ If it don't make dollaz...Then it don't make sense!

bentley85 View Public Profile Send a private message to bentley85 Find all posts by bentley85 Add bentley85 to Your Contacts #215

Today, 10:06 PM

Join Date: Aug 2008 Location: San Antonio,TX Posts: 1,743

Z4MC

Senior Member Super Geek

Not the original topic but have both of Lior's Tungsten Sandstone dials and I LOVE them the blue and red (really a cinnamon brown) if I find they are not real sandstone I will ...keep my watches and love them anyway! But the SWI actually SAY sandstone on the dial so I will believe this to be true until told otherwise. __________________ The American Republic will endure until the day Congress discovers that it can bribe the public with the public's money. ...Alexis de Tocqueville after travelling to America 1834

Z4MC View Public Profile Send a private message to Z4MC Find all posts by Z4MC Add Z4MC to Your Contacts

#216

Today, 10:08 PM Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 15,529 Real Name: "Diamond Jim" Skelton

jskelton

WatchGeeks Owner True WatchGeek

Just like I don't want to see people wantonly bashing Invicta, I don't want to see any more bashing of John for posting this. I do hope that John will provide some documentation because this is a serious allegation, but no one should feel the need to go off on him. He has a right, like everyone else, to express himself on the forum as long as it stays within the rules. __________________

Quote:

Living well is the best revenge. -George Herbert

Quote:

Originally Posted by charleswatts Your candor in the explanation reveals the nature of the relationship you have formed with your viewers.

jskelton View Public Profile Send a private message to jskelton Visit jskelton's homepage! Find all posts by jskelton Add jskelton to Your Contacts

#217

Today, 10:13 PM Join Date: Apr 2010 Location: Ohio Posts: 1,754

MATTNATTI Senior Member Super Geek

Yes and for the op to take it to a guy that "cannot document because the school won't let him" well in my opinion if you are going to make these type of claims then lay down the cash and do the proper thing and take pics and take the dial to someone who can document the results. Don't just come in here with your flamethrower. __________________ Did you see that? Do they all got hedges like that? Do they?

MATTNATTI View Public Profile Send a private message to MATTNATTI Send email to MATTNATTI Find all posts by MATTNATTI Add MATTNATTI to Your Contacts #218 Today, 10:14 PM Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 2,295

KOKONUTZ Senior Member Super Geek

Quote:

Originally Posted by CharlieB There's no question in my mind that Jim and the whole Invicta team will tell us exactly what the reality is. Agree & Thank you Charlie !!!

KOKONUTZ View Public Profile Send a private message to KOKONUTZ Find all posts by KOKONUTZ Add KOKONUTZ to Your Contacts

#219 Today, 10:15 PM

Genezilla Senior Member Master WatchGeek

Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Sunny Southern Cali Posts: 2,680 Real Name: Gene

Jim, I completely agree with you. In my first post I asked for documentation, pics, etc. as I tried to keep an open mind. Of course some people think I have an open mind because I have holes in my head but that's a whole other issue.

Genezilla View Public Profile Send a private message to Genezilla Find all posts by Genezilla Add Genezilla to Your Contacts

#220

Today, 10:21 PM Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: San Antonio, Texas Posts: 2,389 Real Name: William

SeaVulture Senior Member Super Geek

My wife says My head's full of Rock.

Of course, it's Natural Sandstone..... I know the difference, __________________

and it's real...

Welcome to The Invicta Reserve SubAqua Venom Valgrange A07.211 Automatic WatchGeek Registry! http://watchgeeks.net/showthread.php?t=90044