Whitman Pioneer Fall 2011 Issue 10

Page 1

Students sound off about campus health care and Welty Center responds to concerns over treatment

The

PIONEER

HOW DIVERSE NEED-SENSITIVE SWITCH IS WHITMAN? PROVOKES CONCERN

Undocumented Students Statement proposal to go before Board of Trustees by SHELLY LE News Editor

U

ndocumented students who pursue a secondary education run into a number of obstacles that may hinder their educational goals. Whitman currently accepts applications from all students, regardless of citizenship status, and will often offer private financial aid to undocumented students who otherwise are not eligible to receive federal financial aid. This practice is not generally known among undocumented students when applying to college. The Undocumented Students Statement proposal will be brought in front of the Board of Trustees Thursday, Nov. 17, and may soon make this practice more visible. If the proposal passes, starting in 2012, all newly printed college catalogs will include a statement in support of undocumented students on campus. It will also make Whitman the first liberal arts college and the second institution in the United States to include such a statement in its college catalog. “It’ll be the first time a liberal arts school will voice its support for undocumented students in such a concrete way,” senior ASWC President Matt Dittrich said. “That’s an incredible stand to take right now.” The Undocumented Students Statement will include the administration’s willingness to admit and provide private financial aid to undocumented students who apply to Whitman. “This is one of the most important things that we can pass for our student body during this time,” Dittrich said. “The investment from Whitman College can drastically change anyone’s life, but the impact that it can have for someone who’s undocumented is incredible, and you can’t put a value on that.” Just like Whitman’s current statement on diversity, the catalog will include a statement on the administration’s support of undocumented students and their pursuit of a college education. “This is one of the most important things that we can pass for our student body during this time,” Dittrich said. “The investment from Whitman College can drastically change anyone’s life, but the impact that it can have for someone who’s undocumented is incredible and you can’t put a value on that.”

The proposal comes after last year’s ASWC DREAM Act Resolution which states that, as a governing body, ASWC supports the DREAM ACT, a congressional bill that would grant legal permanent residency for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children. Senior Ariel Ruiz, who co-wrote the ASWC DREAM Act Resolution, believes that passing the statement will allow Whitman to show others that the college is ready to openly talk about undocumented status and that the college sees undocumented students as important to the campus. “It will set a standard for Whitman to show the community that we can take a public stance on an educational issue for the safety of our students,” Ruiz said. “It shows to ourselves that this is an issue we need to talk about.” Ruiz further stressed that passing the statement goes beyond simply accepting undocumented students on campus and would help Whitman progress into a more open and transparent campus. “This movement is not just about undocumented students,” Ruiz said. “It’s about how we establish ourselves and how we foster a safe and progressive environment that allows all of our students, including undocumented students, to achieve academically. Dittrich noted that acknowledging students with an undocumented status is crucial to expanding diversity on campus. “I think that exchanging different perspectives is a critical component of a liberal arts education. So, by its very nature, I would argue that an institution like Whitman College supports and promotes diversity of thought,” Dittrich said. Although the Admissions Office does not take into account students’ documentation status and makes undocumented students eligible for private financial aid, the college does not publicly explain this. Consequently, many undocumented students often choose not to apply to Whitman. “All students face challenges when they’re applying to colleges and jobs, and undocumented students face particular barriers inherent to their immigration status. Many fear being deported and don’t think they can apply for college at all,” said senior Katie DeCramer. see UNDOCUMENTED, page 3

60% 40% 20% Wh itm an Col leg e Wa b as hC olle Swa ge rthm ore Col leg e Ree dC olle ge Pom ona Col leg Occ e ide nta l Co lleg e Obe rlin Col leg e Kno xC olle Hav ge erfo rd Col leg e Grin nel l Co lleg Col e ora do Col leg e Col by C olle ge Car leto nC olle ge Bel oit Col leg e

0%

INFOGRAPHIC BY HENDERSHOT AND HUANG

cludes both need- and merit-based aid. The Admissions Office usually aims for a number around 33 percent. “We needed to maybe even have a lower discount rate this year to be able to make up a budget for this year because of the higher spending of the

two previous years. You have to go lower to balance it out,” Dyerly said. With the lower discount rate for this year, students worry that the campus’s overall diversity will be significantly impacted. “For a liberal arts education,

Race at Whitman: 2003-2010

100% 80% 60% 40% 20%

2009-10

0

2007-08

9-1

native american international pacific islander other 200

asian hispanic black white

2005-06

7- 8

2004-05

200 4-5

2003-04

200 3-4

0% INFOGRAPHIC BY HENDERSHOT AND HUANG

R

ecently, students have been raising concerns regarding the switch in the admissions policy from need-blind to need-sensitive admission. At an ASWC town hall meeting Oct. 24 and in comments since then, students have discussed the policy, especially in terms of its effect on the diversity and the makeup of campus. “Diversity has become a more pressing concern of students over the last four years,” said ASWC President Matt Dittrich. “We’re becoming more and more aware of how imperative it is to have diversity of thought in a liberal arts education.” The switch, implemented last year for the admission of the class of 2015 and continuing for this year’s prospective class, raises questions about a few of the most obvious forms of ethnic and socioeconomic diversity. “Quite arguably, [the switch to need-sensitive admissions] added to a lessening of cultural diversity on campus,” said Dittrich. Need-blind policies completely separate the question of an applicant’s admittance from the amount of financial aid they receive, while need-sensitive practices take financial need as a factor in the admissions process.

Director of Admission Kevin Dyerly says that the amount of financial aid awarded to the class of 2015 was not significantly lower than in previous years, and the Admissions Office is still thoroughly committed to diversity in many forms. “I think we need to be careful about being too quick to say [the switch to need-sensitive admissions] has dramatically changed the makeup of the Whitman community, because it really hasn’t,” said Dyerly. “While we certainly were more aggressive in lowering the discount rate in this past year, part of it was because of the last two high entering classes.” For the classes of 2013 and 2014, the discount rates were 38.3 percent and 39.5 percent, respectively. “[The financial aid spending for the last two classes was] dramatically higher than where we had been before that,” said Dyerly. “A lot of that is due to the economy and certainly economic constraints on families and students, but more classes like that would not have been sustainable for the college. We still have finite resources, so it was primarily a financially driven decision.” The discount rate for the class of 2015 was 31.4 percent, which means that 31.4 cents on every dollar were given back to students in the form of Whitman scholarships. This in-

ISSUE 10 November 10, 2011 Whitman news since 1896

80%

CHART: THE RACIAL MAKEUP OF WHITMAN AND THE PANEL OF 14 SCHOOLS Non-citizen white Pacific Islander black Multiracial hispanic American CHANGE IN asian Asian ADMISSIONS native american Hispanic POLICY IMPACTS multiracial DIVERSITY OF pacific islander Black INCOMING CLASSES international White Staff Reporter

Friday: Check our website for an update on Walla Walla County Elections www.whitmanpioneer.com

100%

THE RACIAL MAKEUP OF WHITMAN

by A LLISON WOR K

This Week On Web

200

Get to know the Northwest Conference: Athletic and academic profiles of Whitman’s rival schools

Feature pg. 6

200 5-6

Sports pg. 5

as people are exposed to a variety of different disciplines, if the liberal arts education were attaining its highest ideals, it would expose students to diverse cultures,” said sophomore Alyssa Goard. But Dyerly says this year’s decrease in tangible diversity is not necessarily as big a deal as it seems. “You’re coming off a year where as far as ethnic minorities, the sophWhite omores are the most diverse class in the history of the college,” said Dyerly. “This year’s [about] 18 percent,. Other When you look at the enrollment this year versus enrollments over the last Hispanic few years, is about the exact same.” Dyerly also stressed that Indian WhitmanAmerican was one of the last of its “peer colleges” to make the switch to need-sensitive admissions. Asiankind of dictated that “Realities the fiscally responsible thing to do was to go to a need-sensitive apBlack proach, by which for about 10 percent of our applicants, financial need Non-citizen would be one of the many factors in the admissions process,” Dyerly said. The peer colleges are the Panel of 14—a selected 14 schools including Pomona, Colorado College, Swarthmore and Carelton College—that the Whitman website calls “a combination of peer and aspirant institutions.” see NEED-SENSITIVE, page 3

SELFISHNESS, PROTEST FEATURE IN ‘A LTRUISTS’

Sam Halgren ‘14 (left), Olivia Clingman-White ‘14 (middle) and Thomas Knook ‘12 (right) rehearse a scene from ‘The Altruists,’ directed by senior theatre major Sarah Wright. The play delves into timely themes of social disconnect and protest, as captured in the lives of a group of young radicals in New York. These would-be revolutionaries unconsciously mirror dynamics of counterculture and hypocrisy currently unfolding in elements of the Occupy Wall Street movement. Photo by Felt

read the article in A&E, page 4

Recently proposed Pell Grant cuts would most impact students on border of receiving aid by DY L A N T U LL Staff Reporter

S

tudents understand the necessity of financial aid— without it, many brilliant and hard-working students would not be able to attend Whitman. So what happens when certain government financial aid is cut completely? Hopefully students won’t have to find out, but in an effort to balance the federal budget, the government is considering cutting financial aid funding in the form of Pell Grants and Washington State Need Grants. When government spending is too high and the federal budget needs to be re-worked, education is an area that classically tends to get hit. The date for the decision about cutting Pell Grants is not known, but if students want to help fight for theirs and their peer’s financial aid, the time to make their voices heard is now.

Tyson Harlow, assistant director of financial aid services, explained what exactly the Pell Grant is. “The Pell Grant is a needbased federal grant for students who come from families with fairly low income—what we call high-needs students,” he said. The students that will be effected by the potential cut will be students with the most need. A Pell Grant cut means that the threshold for those who are eligible for financial aid will be lowered. Marilyn Ponti, director of financial aid services, talked about how it would effect students seeking financial aid. “[Legislators] are looking at reducing the income level, so for those kids whose income level is a certain amount, they would lower it, which means that even the really, really needy students are going to lose Pell Grants,”

she said. “Somebody who was marginal before, maybe getting $500 or less in Pell Grant, could possibly lose it for next year.” The impact of the Pell Grant cut would not be felt for current students making use of the federal grant. But if Pell Grants were to be cut in the near future, the next incoming class would feel its effects. “Ultimately, as an institution, we’ll probably have less funds to spread out amongst all of our students, and it would just mean that were not able to help as many,” Harlow said. “It would probably have the greatest impact on the new incoming class, because we try to help our current students as much as possible.” Senior Bryant Fong, former Opinion writer for The Pioneer, outlined the importance of the Pell Grant in the U.S. education system via email. see PELL GRANTS, page 3


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.