Design project. Comparision Dutch & Spanish project

Design Project Spanish project (Madrid) CARABANCHEL HOUSES FOA architects

Dutch project (Amsterdam) DE BREDE HOED KENK architects

Alejandro Quinto

DESIGN PROJECT - Carabanchel Houses (FOA architects) - De Brede Hoed (Kenk Architecten) COMPARISION in diferent aspects - basic information (dates, costs, situation, architects) - context (awards, urbanistic plan, orientation, aspect facade...)

- general sizes, dimensions, accesibility, parking, elevations, 多how we access to the building? 多and how access the disable people?

- Uses. Secondary uses. Kind of spaces - kind of apartments (m2, orientation, way of living, comfortability) - construction (details), installations, insulation, materials, sizes, PROBLEMS, POLEMICS, POSSIBLE INTERVENTIONS & SOLUTIONS CARABANCHEL HOUSES - 多mocks the name of sustainability?.

Bamboo defciences. Against & in favour about bamboo and green facade.

- Psychology. Aspect of the building. Weird buildings in Carabanchel Carabanchel as laboratory?. social discrimination?

- accesibility. 7 elevators, why? (Suppositions) - Rue de Suisse in Paris, by Herzog & de Meuron in 2000. Plagiarism? Architecture as inspiration.

Basic information.

Completion date: 2007

Completion date: 2013

Budget: 5.2m Euro

Budget: 5.9m Euro

88 apartments (social housing)

33 rental apartments

Total area: 9,600sqm Gross internal area: 8183,65 sqm (apartments)

(26 public sell and 7 for social rent)

3200,62 sqm (parking and storage) 11384,27 sqm (total) AZPA/FOA team AZPA/FOA Partner-in-charge Alejandro Zaera Polo & Farshid Moussavi

KENK ARCHITECTEN

Basic information.

Carabanchel Houses Client: EMVS Completion date: 2007 Budget: 5.2m Euro Total area: 9,600sqm Gross internal area: 8183,65 sqm (apartments) 3200,62 sqm (parking and storage) 11384,27 sqm (total) AZPA/FOA team AZPA/FOA Partner-incharge Alejandro Zaera Polo

Context.

Bamboo house is located in Madrid Carabanchel PAU. In this place there are a number of buildings "unique" not without controversy, but worth a visit from the architectural point of view. awards: MIES van der ROHE award (2009) Madrid Pavilion in Expo 2010 (Shanghai) Architecture RIBA award (Royal Institute of British Architects)

Carabanchel Houses

Context.

Carabanchel Houses

Context.

Carabanchel Houses

Carabanchel Houses

Situation. Orientation

N

S

Situation. Orientation

Diemen is situated in the East of the city.

9km to the center of Amsterdam.

De Brede Hoed building has a lot of facilities near.

De Brede Hoed

Aspect.

Carabanchel Houses

Aspect. Sizes.

Carabanchel Houses

Aspect. Sizes.

Carabanchel Houses

Aspect. Sizes.

Carabanchel Houses

Aspect. Materials facade.

Carabanchel Houses

Aspect. Materials facade.

De Brede Hoed

Aspect. Materials facade.

De Brede Hoed

Aspect. Materials facade.

De Brede Hoed

Aspect

De Brede Hoed

Aspect (interior)

De Brede Hoed

Orientation.

De Brede Hoed

Dimensions.

The building consists of a single structure, 100 meters long by 16.40 meters deep and 19.20 meters high

Carabanchel Houses

Dimensions.

Accesibility

De Brede Hoed

Accesibility

De Brede Hoed

Accesibility

De Brede Hoed

Accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Other uses.

De Brede Hoed

Other uses.

De Brede Hoed

Other uses.

De Brede Hoed

Other uses.

Carabanchel Houses

The building occupies 38.31% of the land, the rest of which remains free for common areas that will be devoted to playgrounds and green areas.

Carabanchel Houses

Parking access.

Parking accesibility

Carabanchel Houses

Parking accesibility

De Brede Hoed

Carabanchel Houses

Kind of apartments

Carabanchel Houses

Kind of apartments

Carabanchel Houses

Kind of apartments

Carabanchel Houses

Kind of apartments

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

Carabanchel Houses

Way of living

De Brede Hoed

construction/detail

Carabanchel Houses

Construction

Carabanchel Houses

ventilation holes

construction/detail

Carabanchel Houses

construction/detail

Carabanchel Houses

Construction

Carabanchel Houses

The rooftop plant is not visible from below, as the bamboo-clad facades are extended upwards on steel frames to conceal it. The bamboo is treated to last, freproofed, and can easily be cut of the mesh and replaced.

Carabanchel Houses

Construction

metal frames

Construction

De Brede Hoed

Construction

De Brede Hoed

Installations

De Brede Hoed

Installations

De Brede Hoed

Details

Details

Details. Insulation layer

construction/detail

De Brede Hoed

construction/detail

De Brede Hoed

construction/detail

De Brede Hoed

¿Sustainability?

Carabanchel Houses ¿mocks the name of sustainability? ¿it's the nature a decoration, just for the image of the building? ¿it's the bamboo reusable? ¿how often the bamboo has to be replaced?

多Sustainability?

Carabanchel Houses

多Sustainability?

The building is situated on top of its car park on concrete plinth, which has been disguised and 'landscaped' by cladding it with grass turf. The turf is pinned onto the plinth on top of a special nutrient mat and has automatic sprinklers embedded in it to provide water.

Carabanchel Houses

多Sustainability?

Carabanchel Houses

climate / confort

Carabanchel Houses 多how work the bamboo against the light/wind/cold/rain?

climate / confort

Carabanchel Houses - control how much light and heat enters their home..

architecture / psychology /cultural

多Carabanchel as laboratory? 多Social discrimination?

Carabanchel Houses

architecture / psychology /cultural

Carabanchel Houses

architecture / psychology /cultural

Carabanchel Houses

architecture / psychology /cultural

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility. 7 elevators, why? suppositions

Carabanchel Houses

Accesibility. 7 elevators, why? suppositions

Carabanchel Houses

Carabanchel Houses

多plagiarism or inspiration?

Carabanchel houses

Rue de Suisses

FOA architects Constructoin year: 2007 Residential

Herzog & De Meuron Construction year: 2000 Residential