Report
of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Qatar Charity قطر الخيرية February 2016
2015 ديسمبر
Report
Of The Multi-Sector Survey To Assess Damages
Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Qatar Charity قطر الخيرية February 2016
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
4
List of Tables
7
List of Maps and Figures
9
Chapter One: Study Introduction
10
The financial costs of the required interventions in the survey sectors
11
Introduction
12
Yemeni crisis through international organizations reports
13
Objectives of the survey
14
The importance of the survey
14
The survey methodology
14
The technical team of the survey formation
16
Fieldwork Formation
17
Implementation of the Survey Plan
18
The Survey population
20
The temporal and spatial boundaries of the survey
21
The Moral Aspect of the Survey
22
Data Updating Mechanism
22
Classification of targeted people who have given data and the
22
The Difficulties and Obstacles of the Study and the Ways of Overcoming them
23
Chapter Two: Water and Sanitation Sector
24
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Water and Sanitation Sector
25
Introduction
26
The Damages Caused to the Water and Sanitation Sector
26
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
27
Photos of Some Damages in the Water Sector
29
Chapter Three: Education Sector
32
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Education Sector
33
4
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
Introduction
34
Damages Caused to the Education Sector
34
Photos of the Damages Caused to the Education Sector
35
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
38
The Damages Caused to the Community Colleges and the Vocational
39
Photos of Some Damages in the Education Sector
40
Chapter Four: Health Sector
44
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Health Sector
45
Introduction
47
Damages Caused to the Health Sector
48
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
55
Photos of the Damages in the Health Sector
56
Chapter Five: Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
62
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
63
Introduction
64
Damages Caused to the Food Security Sector
65
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
67
The Field of Malnutrition
69
Interventions Required in the Field of Malnutrition
69
Photos of Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
71
Chapter Six: Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
72
The required interventions costs in shelter and displaced people sector
73
Introduction
74
Damage in Displaced People and the shelter Sector
74
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
77
Photos of some damages in the Shelter and Displaced People Sector
81
Chapter Seven: Livelihood Support Sector
86
The Required Interventions Costs in Livelihood Support Sector
87
The Required Interventions Costs in the Fisheries Sector
88
The Required Interventions Costs in the Agriculture Sector
88
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
5
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
The Required Interventions Costs in the Grazing Sector
89
The Required Interventions Costs in the Workers and Employees Sector
89
Introduction
90
Damage in the livelihoods sector
90
Fishing field
92
Photos of the damages caused to the fisheries sector
94
Agricultural field
96
Photos showing the damage caused to the agricultural sector
98
Grazing sector
100
Photos of damages caused to the gazing sector
102
Workers and employees sector
103
Photos of the damages caused to the shops
107
Chapter Eight: The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
108
Appendices
118
Field Work Form
119
Supervisor’s Form
129
Focus Groups Interviews Guide
131
Photos of the Input Program
135
Selected Photos
136
Field Supervisors Data
158
Tables attached
159
Tables attached: The water sector
160
Table attached: The private education sector
161
Table attached: The private health sector
162
Table attached: Interventions in livelihood support sector
163
6
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
List of Tables
Table (1) The targeted field survey provinces
12
Table (2): The distribution of researchers working in the field survey of governorates
17
Table (3): Implementation of the field survey plan
18
Table (4): Training program for supervisors provinces
18
Table (5): The names of the affected districts in the targeted provinces
21
Table (6): The Costs of Water Sector Interventions in the Affected Provinces
27
Table (7): Damages in the Education Sector and their Costs
36
Table (8): The total number of the students deprived of education due to the recent events and the financial costs by province
37
Table (9): The Affected Community Colleges and the Vocational and Technical Institutes
39
Table (10): Units and health centres that have been totally or partially destroyed and their costs
50
Table (11): Rural and public hospitals that have been totally or partially destroyed and their costs Table (12): The costs of the intervention needed to repair the non-constructional damages caused to health facilities. Table (13): The number of families that have been affected, due to the damage caused to the health institution.
51
52
53
Table (14): The health interventions contained in the supervisor form
54
Table (15): Social and humanitarian interventions related to the health sector
54
Table (16): Data about the food security of the affected families
66
Table (17): The number of affected families in the field of food security and the costs of the required intervention
68
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
7
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
Table (18): The targeted provinces that will be provided with malnutrition treatment and the
70
Table (19): The relative distribution of the accommodation of displaced people
77
Table (20): The number of displaced people who deserve water filters and personal toiletry bag
78
Table (21): The number and the cost of the damaged in terms of the scale of damage and the
79
Table (22): The relative distribution of the main sources of income in the affected communities
91
Table (23): The number of areas that experienced by damage in fishing sector and the interventions required Table (24): Interventions in fishing sector (the cost of the boats) Table (25): The number of areas that affected in the agricultural sector and the interventions required
92 93 96
Table (26): Interventions in the agricultural sector
97
Table (27): The number of affected areas in grazing sector and the interventions required
100
Table (28): Interventions in the grazing sector
101
Table (29): The number of the affected areas in the workers and employees categories and the interventions required
104
Table (30): Interventions in workers and employees sector
105
Table (31): The number and the cost of the affected shops
106
8
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
List of Maps and Figures
Map (1): The target provinces in the field survey
13
Figure (1): The distribution of districts in the targeted and affected provinces
20
Figure (2): The percentage of citizens’ access to the basic health services
48
Figure (3): The Nutrition Situation of Yemeni Children
69
Figure (4): The problems related to accommodation in the affected provinces
76
Figure (5): Distribution of the main sources of income in the affected communities
91
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
9
Chapter One Survey Introduction
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
The Financial Costs of theRequired Interventions in the Survey Sectors
$46,500,060 Water and sanitation sector
$179,387,490 Education sector
$46,500,060 Health sector
$1,010,287,160 The food security and malnutrition sector
$790,701,094 Shelter and displaced people sector
$112,392,360 6
Livelihood sector
Total
$2,450,105,904 The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
11
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
1. Introduction Due to the circumstances and the events that took place in Yemen during 2014 and 2015, and affected the lives of citizens in all fields of life, directly and indirectly, it was necessary to give a clear image about the damage caused to the sectors of the survey, and the interventions required by the authorities and organizations that desire to relief Yemen. Qatar Charity has adopted this survey, which is an initiative to facilitate the work of humanitarian organizations in Yemen. Qatar Charity is a non-governmental organization that was founded in 1991 by a group of well-known Qatari persons known for their integrity and credibility. Qatar Charity operates in more than 67 countries in Asia ,Africa and Europe, both through its field offices in some countries or through partnership and cooperation with local non-governmental development organizations. Qatar Charity is also operating in the State of Qatar to contribute to the social and cultural development efforts. Qatar Charity adopts a message that is based on “supporting the most needy people according to the principles of human dignity and social justice, in cooperation with development and labor rights” partners. Qatar Charity is committed to its basic humanitarian principles such as the “humanity”, “independence”, “neutrality” and “non-discrimination”, which share with most international non-governmental organizations. Qatar Charity in Yemen is working in developmental and humanitarian fields since the early nineties, and has opened a field office in Yemen in 2013. Qatar Charity Association has studied the needs of people in Yemen in the wake of the crisis plaguing the country since 2014. It has carried out a field study to determine the necessary and basic needs that are needed by the affected communities in many sectors, including: 1 Food and food security, and 2. Health, and 3. Water and environmental sanitation, and 4. Shelter and non-food items, and 5. And livelihoods, and 6. Education to determine the appropriate interventions to meet these needs and alleviate the suffering of the citizens. The survey targeted, in the first phase, fourteen provinces:
The provinces that has suffered and still exposed to the waves of violence Aden
Taiz
Abyan
Marib
Ibb
Dalea
Hajjah
Al Hudaydah
Affected provinces of Tshabala and Meg Hurricanes
Hajj
Hadramout Shabwa
Al Baydav
Table (1): The targeted field survey provinces
12
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Al Mahrah Socotra
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
Map (1): The target provinces in the field survey
2.
Yemeni crisis through international organizations reports The United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in collaboration with Human-
itarian partners specified an action plan for rapid response to 2015, and developed a plan for humanitarian response in Yemen that met the most vulnerable needs of the population. The plan has been prioritized to ensure concentration on the protection of civilians and to provide life-saving aids for humans. To ensure the implementation of the revised plan, the humanitarian organizations are to expand the scope of operations by increasing the number of employees within Yemen and promoting supplies intended for the country to ensure the aids are reached to those who need them most. More than 12 million people were affected by the conflict directly, a million people were forced to migrate, and more than 42 thousand Yemeni people fled. The victims of conflict include civilians, women and children, but the death toll is of a large proportion of the adult male. This has led to the loss of the families male breadwinner . In general, civilians critically lack protection, where violations of international humanitarian law and international human rights law continue. The violations that affect the civilian population include; the use of explosive weapons in areas of the densely populated; attacking civilian infrastructure facilities; recruitment of children; and targeting the humanitarian workers. Reports said that there is outbreak of military unexploded ordnance in 13 provinces. Many related studies were also conducted to investigate the impact of the conflict on the citizens, for example, a study on Multi-Cluster/Sector Initial Rapid Assessment (MIRA), which was carried out by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UNOCHA) in several governorates, including studies that have been carried out in the island of Socotra. The findings showed that the most important priorities of the island of Socotra residents largely centered in the provision of housing, education and water supply.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
13
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
3.
Objectives of the survey The main objective of this survey is to assess the damage in the following sectors: Food security, food,
health, water, environmental sanitation, shelter, non-food items, ways of living, and education), and to identify the necessary needs of affected people in some governorates as a result of recent events, according to a typical scientific approach of the damage assessment. A number of objectives emerge from this main objective as follows: • Evaluating and estimating the size of the losses sustained in the sectors under study. • Preparing a clear idea about the urgent needs to cope with the tragic circumstances in the sectors under study. • Preparing a number of programs and activities that can help in the economic recovery and securing the livelihoods of the communities affected by the armed conflict. • Seeking to achieve genuine integration between relief and development.
4.
The importance of the survey The importance of the survey is as follows: • The survey relied on a comprehensive survey of the damage caused in the targeted areas in various sectors of the study, as it is for the first time the use of this methodology in the overall survey in the society organizations in Yemen. • The survey created a database covering all the affected areas in the Republic of Yemen, where any organization or institution willing to intervene, get this data easily, and the data can be updated regularly. • This survey has provided data on the affected areas and the interventions required of the survey, as well as the size and cost of the damage. • The survey tools were designed according to local needs after discussing them with various local humanitarian organizations working in this field, and without the application of a particular rigid model. Different scientific methods were considered. • All the photos of the damage occurring in the survey sectors were documented with different data.
5.
The survey methodology
To ensure the achievement of the objectives of the survey, it has been relying on two main sources of the survey which are: 1. Primary Sources These sources are the main forms that have been filled from the field, namely: • Fieldwork Form: It is the form that researchers had filled out in the field, where data were collected from the affected areas, persons and entities most familiar and closest to the study topics. • Supervisor Form: It is the form that the supervisors had collected their data on the county-level at the center of the province of government agencies or entities operating in the relief organizations, international institutions and organizations concerned with the axes of the study. The data sources were
14
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
documented in the same form. • Focus-group interviews and observations of researchers form: They are the forms that were filled out by the researchers via the method of focus group interviews of the affected families and codification of all the notes found by the researchers in the field. 2. Secondary Sources: They are the sources that were collected from the agencies and organizations related to the axes of the study sources. CSO data are secondary sources. A comparison of all sources has been carried out within the work of data analysis for the study to obtain a clear image about the damages and needs to be addressed.
First: The Quantitative Survey The survey relies on the questionnaire, and is considered one of the best tools used in quantitative data collection. It is an important tool because it depends on the personal interview between the interviewer and the interviewee. This helps to get the real data of the respondent. The questions were formulated in simple language which is easily understood by the targeted people. The survey was formulated in six main topics are: 1 Food and food security, and 2. Health, and 3. Water and environmental sanitation, and 3. shelter and non-food items 0.4. And livelihoods, and 5. Education). All the documents and previous studies in this area have been taken advantage of, including: • Rapid Initial Assessment form (MIRA) to determine the humanitarian needs of the model questionnaire. • Damage assessment methodology adopted by the World Bank . • Evaluating food security form in the emergency circumstances, which was prepared by a number of international organizations working in Yemen. • Questions form for impact assessment, which was prepared by the Social Fund for Development. • As well as the documents of income and expenditure surveys and household budget implemented by the Central Bureau of Statistics.
Secondly: The Qualitative Survey The qualitative survey methods, including focus-groups’ discussion (FGD), is one of the important research methods used to obtain data. (Observation Field) is also used. It is direct personal notes, in which the researcher and his team in the field try to detect the damage caused to different sectors of the study. Observation is different from the interview because the observer does not ask the respondent directly, but it can be written in several ways, as in the case of the codification of the interview data. Due to the special circumstances that prevailed in the provinces during the study period and the importance of preserving the documents of the field work, as well as taking advantage of the time to get things done as required, an excel program has been designed and sent to the data entry in the governorates. This program included many of the rules of consistency and protecting data from any mistakes that could occur by the data entry. The data is entered once they are collected to be reviewed and signed by supervisor. The open answers have been classified into categories and encoded so that all the data will be ready to be entered in the computer and pro-
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
15
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
cessed statistically. Researchers used the SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences) version 22, which is used for the processing and analysis of statistical data. It is a statistically integrated system including the frequency tables, the statistical tests of hypotheses and the multiple statistical analyses. As for the analysis of the findings of the qualitative surveys methodology, the supervisors had a key role in analyzing the qualitative data according to the axes of group interviews manual, where observations was sorted in each topic of the survey separately, deriving the similarities and differences of opinions. The findings of the qualitative survey have been presented (which is the most important way to view the findings in this kind of surveys). It has also been focusing on in-depth interviews with specialists and leaders working in the areas of community development and those associated with the assessment of emergency needs. Form has been met for each residential community (isolated in the countryside/ urban neighborhood).
6.
The technical team of the survey formation A technical survey team has been formed to revise the documentation and approve them, specify various
mechanisms to follow up the progress of work in the field, and to contribute to the solution of problems and obstacles. This team is made up of: 1. Supervision and follow-up team in Doha: 1. Muhammad Ali Al-Ghamdi, Executive Director of International Development at Qatar Charity. 2. Abed Rabi bin Sahraa, Director of Planning and International Cooperation Department / Qatar Charity. 3. Jassim Saadi Alnjemaoa, Director of the Department of International Follow-up and Evaluation / Qatar Charity. 4. Dr. / Abdul Majeed Farhan, Executive Team Advisor. 2. Executive Team of Survey in Yemen: 1. Dr. Abdalwasa Allowasai, Executive Director of the Survey Team. 2. Dr. Tareq Yehia Kibsi, Main Researcher. 3. Abbas Zaid Aburas, Assistant Main Researcher. 4. Dr. Khaled Almontasr, a Secretary. 5. Mohammed Abdullah al-Saidi, Coordinator of the Affected Provincial in the Events. 6. Mohammed Almazb, Coordinator of the Affected Provincial in the hurricane. 7. Aladdin Abdul Malik Alywsfy, Director of Data Entry Team. 8. Afrah Yahya Alqazahi, Executive Secretary of the For Human Development Organization. 9. Nada Abdullah Fakhir, General Manager of Yemen for Volunteer Work. 10. Yahya Suleiman, Survey Accountant. 11. Ameen Alkibab, Maps.
16
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
7.
Fieldwork Formation The number of provinces supervisors is (14 supervisors), and the number of assistants supervisors is (14 assis-
tants), while the number of researchers has reached (133 researchers). Conditions were specified to select the best job applicants in the survey, as follows: 1. Academic qualifications, supervisors must have a university degree. 2. Experience in these kinds of surveys. 3. The ability to deal with the various groups of society. 4. Priority for the people of the affected areas to work in this study. 5. Gender is considered when selecting the researchers. Workers in the field have been distributed according to the number of districts affected in each province, which has been identified by the executive team and the survey supervisors of the provinces. The number of researchers is different from some provinces, although the two provinces have the same number of districts affected, due to the different size of damage and geographical scope of the directorates. Researchers have been distributed according to the table as follows: Staff No
Province
The number of districts affected
Number of
The number of Manager As-
Supervisors
researchers
sistant
Total
1
ibb
17
1
19
1
21
2
Taiz
17
1
18
1
20
3
Abyan
6
1
16
1
18
4
Hadramout
10
1
10
1
12
5
Al Hudaydah
13
1
9
1
11
6
Lahij
7
1
9
1
11
7
Shabwa
10
1
9
1
11
8
Dhale
4
1
8
1
10
9
Al Bayda
9
1
8
1
10
10
Marib
6
1
7
1
9
11
Aden
8
1
10
1
12
12
Hajjah
10
1
5
1
7
13
Al Mahrah
3
1
4
1
6
14
Socotra
2
1
1
1
3
122
14
133
14
161
Total
Table (2): The distribution of researchers working in the field survey of provinces
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
17
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
8.
Implementation of the Survey Plan
First: The program schedule of survey The survey was conducted in a period of a month and a half (6 weeks) that was divided according to the following schedule No 1
Activity
Date
Preparing, processing the survey documents and selecting the staff
1
2
3
4
5
6
15-23/11
2
Supervisors Training (the first phase)
24-25/11
3
Researchers Training (the second phase)
29-30/11
4
Field work and data entry
1-14/12
5
Data analysis and writing the final report
15-24/12
Table (3): Implementation of the field survey plan
Secondly: Training Given the importance of the training, two phases of the training have been adopted: Primary phase: Provinces Supervisors training This training took place at the Yemeni capital Sanaa, where the training has active participation of some supervisors and specialists, as well as the participation of the technical team of the survey according to the schedule of the special session of training during the period 24-25 / 11/2015 as follows:
The second day
The opening session The objectives of the study
Discussing the survey form
Approving the Discussing documents in the superviits final form sor tasks
Break 10:30 to 11:00
Fourth Lecture 11:00 to 12:00
Discussing the survey form
Discussing the distribution of the affected areas
Break Sixth lecFifth lecture 12:00 ture 13:00 to 14:00 to 14:00–15:00 13:00 A break for prayer and lunch
First day
The second lecture 9:30 to 10:30
Breakfast break
Day and date
The first lecturer 8:30 to 9:30
Table (4): Training program for supervisors provinces
18
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Discussing the survey form
Discussing the researcher form report
Discussing the criteria for selecting researchers
General discussion
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
A photo during the opening training session for supervisors of governorates survey
The second phase: The training of researchers in targeted provinces and districts The trained supervisors in Sanaa, returned to the provinces to train the researchers team who have been selected. Training of researchers has been conducted in the provincial centers or in some local organizations. The supervisors taught the researchers the objectives of the study, methods of collecting data and information from the field through the field survey during the period 29-30 / 11/2015.
Photos during the training of researchers in the targeted governorates
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
19
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
9.
The Survey population It was agreed that the survey population is all the affected areas due to the recent events, in addition to the
affected provinces of Tshabala and Meg Hurricanes. The number of affected districts reached (122 directorates) and distributed over 14 provinces according to the following chart:
Aden
Al Hudaydah
Taiz
Hajj
Ibb
Al Bayda
Shabwah
Number of directorates
Dalea
Marib
Hadramout
Abyan
Hajjah
Al Mahrah
Socotra
Number of affected provinces
Figure (1): The distribution of districts in the targeted and affected provinces
As noted, the affected directorates ratio reached 52% of the total number of districts in the targeted provinces. Aden Province, has the largest percentage (100%), where it has the most affected directorates as result of war and armed confrontations. The proportion of districts affected in Socotra province was (100%) as a result of Tshabala and Meg Hurricanes . As for the provinces of Ibb and Taiz, we note that the number of districts affected (17 affected directorates in each province).
20
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
10. The temporal and spatial boundaries of the survey Data was collected during the period of 1 - 12/14/2015, at fourteen provinces and122 Directorate as follows: Number of province
districts
The names of the affected districts
Affected
Hadramout
10
Aden
8
Al Hudaydah
13
Ridh, and Gosaiar, Doan, stone, Shahr, rural areas of Mukalla, Dees East, Gazprom Mayfa’a, Gail bin right, Aldilaah, Mukalla Sheikh Osman, Khor Maksar, Dar Saad, Mansura, Mualla, Sira, Tawahi, Brega Port, Ad Dahi District, Al Luḩayyah, Al Ahli, Bayt al-Faqih, Al Hawak District, Salif, Mansuriyah, Althita, Nectarine, Zabid, Luhais, Kamran Mawza District, Mqubnp, Hdnan, Maoist, Sbermoadm, Salon, Khadder, Jabal
Taiz
17
Lahij
7
Habashi, Bab al-Mandab, Allowazeip, Alamaafr, Muzaffar, Almsrakh, Mocha, Cairo, Achammaatin, consolation
Arh, Al Madaribah , Alqbith, navigator, Almsimir, Tuban , Hota Hobeish, Al Qafr, Almkhadr, Mvek, Udayn packages, Yarim, Alrdmh, COPD,
ibb
17
An Nadirah, Dhi As Sufal, a Alsval, Sayani, Jiblah, Almcnh, Al Dhihar, Sbrh, Ash Sha’ir Al Bayda, Radaa, Wald Rabi’, Quraysh, Dhi Na’im, Mukeiras, Ash Sharyah, As
Al Bayda
9
Shabwa
10
Mephaath, Rudum, Hibbaan, Bayhan, Ain , Asilan, Ataq, As Said
Ad Dhale’e
4
Dali City, Qadoba, Damt, Al Hussein
Marib
6
Marib city, Majzar, Hreib, Serwah, Alwadi, Medghal
Abyan
6
Mahvd, Al Wade’a, Khanfar, Zanzibar, Lauder, Mudiyah
Hajjah
10
Al Mahrah
3
Hsoan, Al Masilah, Qishn
Socotra
2
Hdebouh, Qlencih
Total
122
Sawadiyah, Az Zahir
Hajjah City, Bakeel Al Meer, MIDI, Harad, Sharas, Bani Qa’is, Abs, Kushar, Khayran Al Muharraq, Mustaba
Table (5): The names of the affected districts in the targeted provinces
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
21
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
11. The Moral Aspect of the Survey The moral aspects of the survey were considered by getting the approval that is based on full knowledge of the objectives of the study. It has been asserted that the form data will not be used in non-research purposes, and that the participants have the right to refuse to participate or to answer the questionnaire. The local authorities have been informed about the objectives and methodology of the study. The data was collected through in-depth interviews as well as observations of researchers from the field.
12. Data Updating Mechanism To take advantage of this data as long as possible during the ongoing conflict in the Republic of Yemen, the supervisors will be informed in order to enter any new data according to the sectors of the survey, as well as delete any damages that have been processed or interfered by other organizations. For example, what happened in the province of Aden to repair the damage in the education sector to ensure the restoration of the city schools by the United Arab Emirates during the months of October and November 2015.
13. Classification of targeted people who have given data and the supporting authorities 1. The findings of the field study showed that the numbers of people who responded to the survey questions amounted to approximately (938 persons) as follows: • Members of local councils and the local authority in the provinces under study. • Social and legal persons in the affected areas. • Offices directors interested in study topics. • Officials and coordinators of associations and non-governmental organizations working in the humanitarian field and relief. • Activists in the field of human rights. • The population affected by these events, and the people of the affected areas. 2. The services provided by government and private bodies had a significant impact on the success of the work, and the most important bodies include: • Social Reform Charitable Society and its branches in the governorates, which facilitated the use of its offices and infrastructure in the survey service in various stages. • Civil society organizations such asHuman Development Foundation, which had a significant role in the survey. • Yemeni Foundation for Voluntary Work that contributed directly to the survey sucess, and communicated with local and international organizations working in Yemen. • Office of the United Nation for the Coordination Human Affairs had a big role in reviewing, scanning
22
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter One || Survay Introduction
documents and giving technical advice and assistance, technical observations and opinions to contribute to the success of the survey work. • Personalities and some assistants in the districts where they accompanied the team members to cooperate with them during the process of collecting data for the survey. • All volunteers who collaborated with the team of researchers and they are estimated by 270 volunteers in all target provinces. They had a prominent role in facilitating the work of researchers in the provinces. • A coalition of humanitarian relief in the provinces, especially in the province of Taiz, which has contributed significantly to meet the required data there through providing researchers in different areas of the county. • Social center for the displaced in the Hajjah province, which has provided researchers, as well as the survey data.
14. The Difficulties and Obstacles of the Study and the Ways of Overcoming them: 1. The military confrontations and clashes in some provinces. 2. Continuing aerial bombardment during the field work. 3. Distances between centers and areas of conflict. 4. Time pressure on the fields researchers. 5. Some researchers have suffered from the security detention for a brief period due to lack of understanding of the nature of the survey before they were released due to prior coordination with the concerned authorities. 6. The lack of services to assist in the work of researchers and research management such as the lack of electricity in most of the target provinces and the slowness of the internet access. 7. Difficulty of communicating with some of the general managers of the district / provincial center to identify needs because they cannot exist in their offices. These difficulties and obstacles were surmounted by the following ways: 1. Choosing a qualified team able to work under pressure. 2. Choosing the team and some of the mentors of the affected districts. 3. Communicating with officials to facilitate the implementation of the fieldwork for the survey in their areas. 4. Seizing the right opportunities for fieldwork at the right time. 5. Continue to work for several periods. 6. Following-up detainees’ researchers and using more than one way and more than a broker to get them out.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
23
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
Chapter Two Water and Sanitation Sector
24
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Water and Sanitation Sector
Intervention
Costs
Water Tanks Repairs
$2,145,600
Intervention
Costs
Water Systems Rehabilitation
$39,512,200
Intervention
costs
Buying Water Pumps
$5,842,260
Total
$46,500,060 The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
25
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
1.
Introduction Having access to safe drinking water is a fundamental human right. Due to the lack of surface water and rain
shortfall in Yemen, it is one of the most water scarce countries in the world. The country’s annual water deficit is one billion cubic meters.(1). The water situation is getting worse due to the cultivation and groundwater depletion. The issue of water focuses on the level of water supply in the areas affected from the current conflicts, the nature of damages resulting from these conflicts and the interventions as well as the solutions required. The findings of the demographic health survey in 2013 revealed that the percentage of families that have access to safe drinking water has reached 59% of families in Yemen, including (safe sources of water obtained through a government system, a civil system, artesian wells, rainwater or bottled water). 20% of the people have used a government system, and up to 14 % have used the artesian well.
2.
The Damages Caused to the Water and Sanitation Sector The survey findings indicated that wells are the common source of drinking in general, which reached about
72%, with exception of the drinking water collected from the rooftops. Many families, especially in Taiz province, have drinking water from rooftops instead of the artesian wells, which have been broken down due to the recent events in Yemen or to the interruption in supplying oil derivatives, especially the diesel used for operating well pumps. The water and sanitation sector has been affected by the events in Yemen. The most significant manifestations of this impact have been contained in the results of focus groups interviews as follows: • The high maintenance and fuel costs, which increase the cost of water extraction with a rate of (100%). Thus, this negatively affects the living conditions of many families. • The outbreak of many diseases due to the use of contaminated water and the spread of sewage disposals with a rate of (30%). • The girls’ dropout of school owing to their involvement in bringing water from distant places with a rate of (18%). • Most water pumps have stopped and broken down due to lack of diesel, so they have used other alternatives by (50%). • The water system and many projects have been damaged due to the lack of maintenance. The survey findings has demonstrated that the number of drinking water sources in the surveyed areas reached (4,358). (581 sources) have been affected by approximately 13%. The highest percentage of damages was in Lahij province by (70%) then Aden by (58.8%) and then Hadhramaut province by (48%). The number of families affected by the events in the water and sanitation sector is (656, 747), and the highest percentage of damages was in Taiz province, followed by Aden province.
(1) The Millennium Development Goals Needs Assessment Report, the Ministry of Planning and International Cooperation, Sanaa 2005
26
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
3.
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
Province
The number of the affected water tanks
The total horsepower of the affected pumps
The total lengths of the affected water systems in meters
The cost of water tanks repair *
ibb
16
2482
45,261
230,400
670,140
2,263,050
Abyan
29
1583
114,220
417,600
427,410
5,711,000
Al Bayda
8
827
17,425
115,200
223,290
871,250
Al Hudaydah
2
0
0
28,800
0
0
Dhale
22
273
43,174
316,800
73,710
2,158,700
Al Mahrah
1
161
16,925
14,400
4,470
846,250
Taiz
39
3815
99,600
561,600
1,030,050
4,980,000
Hajjah
11
151
4,750
158,400
40,770
237,500
Hadhramaut
23
433
129,335
331,200
116,910
6,466,750
Socotra
3
180
54,560
43,200
48,600
2,728,000
Shabwah
6
335
31,042
86,400
90,450
1,552,100
Aden
--
389
2,040
0
105,030
102,000
Lahij
1
190
6,128
14,400
51,300
306,400
Ma’rib
1
0
0
14,400
0
0
Total
162
10,819
564,460
2,332,800
2,921,130
28,223,000
The cost of The cost of pumps repair water systems ** repair ***
Table (6): The Costs of Water Sector Interventions in the Affected Provinces
* Water tanks repairs: The cost of water tanks repairs per cubic meter was estimated at $ 400 and a total of $14,400. ** Water pumps repairs: The cost of buying a pump according to its horsepower was estimated at $ 20 per horsepower unit. *** The cost of water systems repair: The cost of water systems repair was estimated at $ 50 per meter. For more information about the damages caused to the water sector and their costs, please refer to the water sector table in the appendices. There are many needs and interventions in the water field as indicated in the collective and individual interviews, including: • Rehabilitating the suspended projects by repairing the damaged water pumps, systems and tanks. • Conducting awareness-raising programs about the dangers of sewage disposals and the rationalization of water use. • Establishing collective groves or sanitation and completing the existing water system. • Providing water tanks to the affected areas.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
27
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
• Providing fuel, and especially diesel to operate equipment. • Constructing the collection reservoirs to save the water springs. A question has been asked about the most important priorities of the affected communities. The survey findings indicated that the number of priorities is higher than the number of damages, and this is a logical finding as the needs exceed the damage caused to all sectors, especially the water sector. The findings revealed that the most important priorities with respect to the water sector in the affected communities were as follows: 1. Repairing or providing pumping units for the water projects. 2. Repairing water systems 3. Repairing water tanks The other responses focused on the following: 1. Drilling additional wells and a desalination plant for the drinking water. 2. Building dams, dikes and caravans. 3. Providing plastic tanks. 4. Rehabilitating the damaged wells and completing some water projects.
28
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
Photos of Some Damages in the Water Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
29
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
30
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Two || Water and Sanitation Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
31
Chapter Three || Education Sector
Chapter Three Education Sector
32
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Education Sector
Restoration and construction of classrooms
32,275,200 $
Constructing colleges and technical institutes
131,400,000 $
Classes furnishing
7,608,000 $ Providing bag and uniforms
6,199,530 $
Hiring temporary classrooms 941,400 $ for six months
Providing tents
963,360 $
Total 179,387,490 $
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
33
Chapter Three || Education Sector
1.
Introduction The educational level is a distinctive feature and a meaningful way in our time to determine the progress and
development of any community. Further, it indicates the extent of urbanization and awareness among nations. Education builds the human personality, broadens his knowledge and understanding, and develops his skills and experiences and the scientific and practical capacities. In addition, it provides the individual with the information necessary to help him perform his work successfully. As a result, the standard of living and the well-being of his family members would be improved and the objectives related to the progress and development of society would be realized. As learning has countless advantages, illiteracy has many disadvantages on the peoples’ lives. Therefore, governments exert great efforts to spread education among the people, modernize the curricula and improve the educational level from time to time to cope with the changes and developments in its various courses and fields. Education is one of the basic determinants of the people’s social and economic development as it provides them with the sciences, knowledge and skills needed to contribute effectively to the construction and development process. It is now recognized that the essential foundation to overcome underdevelopment is the community’s intensive investment in education. Yemen, like other developing countries, continues to experience illiteracy that impedes the improvement of the standard of living and the progress and prosperity of society in spite of its low levels among the population. The findings of the demographic and health survey conducted in 2013 indicate that there is a gap in in the school enrolment rate between males and females in general, where about 80% of the males have already access to education, and only about 57% of females have access to it. The enrolment rate of both males and females has significantly changed over the years. It is clearly illustrated that the urban population is more likely to enroll and continue the education than their rural peers. The findings also indicated that the males’ enrolment is higher than the females’ enrolment at the provincial level. This survey aimed to examine the impacts of the recent events in Yemen on the education sector, and the interventions required to address these damages.
2.
Damages Caused to the Education Sector By asking the targeted people about the structural damages in all targeted areas, the survey findings con-
firmed that the number of the affected areas is 450 out of 577 targeted areas, so the various degrees of damages caused to the education sector reached about 78% of the affected areas. The number of the schools that were deeply affected in Al Bayda and Socotra will be discussed later. Undoubtedly, the low percentage in Aden province is due to the repair of damaged schools by the UAE Red Crescent.
34
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
Photos of the Damages Caused to the Education Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
35
Chapter Three || Education Sector
The number Province
of the structurally affect-
Classes that need furni-
ed classrooms
ture
The need for tents and temporary classrooms
The cost of The cost of
The cost of
providing
building
classes fur-
tents and hir-
classrooms $
nishing $
ing temporary classrooms $
ibb
221
371
221
2,121,600
742,000
226,392
Abyan
207
660
207
1,987,200
1,320,000
166,056
Al Bayda
222
262
222
2,131,200
524,000
57,768
Al Hudaydah
139
98
139
1,334,400
196,000
150,144
Dhale
300
132
300
2,880,000
264,000
125,064
Al Mahrah
73
21
73
700,800
42,000.00
44,592
Taiz
983
1,115
983
9,436,800
2,230,000
770,664
Hajjah
292
181
352
2,803,200
362,000
71,136
Hadhramaut
207
74
207
1,987,200
148,000
76,032
Socotra
253
226
253
2,428,800
452,000
93,864
Shabwah
141
169
141
1.353,600
338,000
8,352
Aden
90
299
90
864,000
598,000
30,672
Lahij
132
102
132
1,267,200
204,000
26,520
Ma’rib
102
94
108
979,200
188,000
57,504
Total
3362
3,804
3428
32,275,200
7,608,000
1,904,760
Table (7): Damages in the Education Sector and their Costs
The cost of rebuilding the affected classes was estimated at approximately ($ 9,600) per class, and the cost of classes that need to be re-furnished is about ($ 2,000). The cost of one tent’s monthly rent is ($600). The monthly rent for one class is ($ 72) for six months (one school year). For more information about the damages and costs in the education sector, please refer to the education sector table in the appendices The survey findings indicted that the total number of schools in the survey areas is about (2,987 schools) where (949) of them have been affected with a rate of 32% of the total schools in the area. The highest percentage of the damaged schools was in Socotra, Abyan and Hadramaut because the number of schools was already lower due to the low number of population in these areas. The total number of classes in the survey areas reached (28.885) with an average of 10 classes in each school. (3569 classes) were structurally damaged with a rate of 12% of the total classrooms in the area. The highest percentage of the number of damaged classrooms was in Taiz and Hadramout. (3878 classrooms) have been looted and their furniture was damaged, representing approximately 13% of the total classrooms in the area. The largest number of these classes was in Taiz and Abyan knowing that they may be among the structurally damaged schools.
36
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
The targeted people in the affected areas were asked about the number of needed temporary classrooms or tents. It was revealed that the people of the affected areas need (1927 temporary classes) and about (1708 tents). It is noteworthy that one classroom may need more than one intervention including an urgent one (Rent or provide tents ...), or long-term intervention, such as the reconstruction or restoration of the classroom. This indicates that the total numbers should not be equal to the number of the affected classrooms in the area. The number of stuProvince
dents in the governorate*
The number of affected students
The financial cost of Percentage**
the bag and supplies ***
Ibb
679,990
19,275
62.1
299,244
Abyan
88,493
19,131
38.7
185,092
Al Bayda
140,532
11,626
86.1
250,250
Al Hudaydah
476,396
7,715
31.6
60,949
Dhale
165,757
2,341
27.3
15,977
Al Mahrah
23,087
1,380
75.0
25,875
Taiz
768,971
334,306
57.1
4,772,218
Hajjah
306,918
10,211
24.2
61,777
Hadhramaut
295,878
11,815
46.8
138,236
Socotra
----
3,298
80.0
65,960
Shabwah
117,062
20,468
37.9
193,934
Aden
148,759
5,192
22.9
29,724
Lahij
210,348
13,660
18.9
64,544
Ma’rib
63,784
7,150
20.0
35,750
Total
679,990
467,568
44.8
6,199,530
Table (8): The total number of the students deprived of education due to the recent events and the financial costs by province
* The source: Central Bureau of Statistics (The Statistical Yearbook for 2013). ** The percentage of the students affected, due to their inability to get a uniform and school bag. *** The financial cost of the bag and supplies: The costs of the bag and school needs was estimated at ($ 25) for each one.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
37
Chapter Three || Education Sector
The targeted people were asked about the number of students who were deprived of education due to the damage caused to the educational institution. The number of affected female/male students was nearly (476,568), and the highest number of students was in Taiz (334,306 students), followed by Dhale (23,411 students), followed by Shabwah (20,468 students), and so on for the rest of the provinces. The dropout rate due to the events experienced by the affected areas was about 60%, and the highest percentage of dropout was in Ma’rib and Taiz. The findings showed that the highest percentage of the reasons behind the students’ dropout is that they cannot provide school supplies (45%), especially in Albayda and Socotra. The second reason was security concerns by (43%), and the highest percentage was in Ma’rib and Albayda, while the third reason was the damage caused to the school due to the recent events by (36%), and the highest percentage was in Albayda and Ma’rib. The results of the collective and individual interviews pointed out that these damages are mainly as follows: 1. The dropout due to the conflict, the reluctance of some parents to send their sons and daughters to school in fear for their lives, and the administrative chaos of students and the educational administration. 2. The low achievement and the weakness of the educational outcomes. 3. The deterioration and destruction of the educational facilities. 4. The shortage of schools textbooks and teachers as many of them cannot return to their schools as well as the stoppage of the graduates’ recruitment. 5. Overcrowded classrooms, because the displaced people have come to some provinces and the affected students have transferred to other schools due to the bombing. 6. The lack of personal hygiene among students due to the bad conditions of the school bathrooms and water. 7. The damage and looting of school furniture. 8. The families’ low-income lead to the children dropout in order to help their families and provide their needs. 9. The high costs and the difficulty to have access to remote schools and especially in rural areas.
3.
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions The survey findings indicated that the most important needs identified by the community members in the
education sector are: 1. Restoring the partially or totally destroyed schools. 2. Providing the furniture and the educational equipment. 3. Providing school supplies. The other responses stressed the importance of providing security for the students and faculty members, providing teachers and compelling the rest of the teachers to come to school, building additional classrooms and schools for girls, providing drinking water, refrigerators and water tanks, providing the school curriculum and the school bag and all the school supplies to poor families, and providing sums of money to the volunteers in schools to make up the shortage of teachers.
38
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
4. The Damages Caused to the Community Colleges and the Vocational and Technical Institutes The findings of the survey supervisors in the provinces revealed that a number of community colleges and vocational and technical institutes have been damaged. The percentage of the damages is different in the facilities. (Al Bayda, Taiz, Al Hudaydah, Lahij) have the highest number of affected colleges and institutes with (4 institutes / colleges) in each province, followed by Dhale that has 2 affected facilitates, followed by Ibb and Ma’rib, and Lahij that have one affected facility in each province. The following table describes the extent of the damages and the required intervention costs of repair:
Province Ibb Dhale
Al Bayda
Ma’rib
Taiz
Al Hudaydah
Hajjah
Lahij
College/Institute
The percentage of damage
The intervention costs of reconstruction and equipping
Community College / Yarim
100 %
2,000,000
Technical Institute / Dhale
100 %
2,000,000
Community College / Dhale
50 %
1,000,000
Technical Industrial Institute/Al
90 %
1,800,000
Technical Institute informational /
100 %
2,000,000
Vocational Institute / Albayda
100 %
2,000,000
Vocational Institute /Sawadiyah
70 %
1,400,000
Vocational Institute / Sirwah
50 %
1,000,000
Technical Industrial Institute /
70 %
1.400.000
Technical Industrial Institute / Al Hasab
80 %
1,600,000
Commercial Technical Institute / Al
70 %
1,400,000
Commercial Technical Institute /
50 %
1,000,000
Vocational Industrial Institute / Al
70 %
1,400,000
Technical Industrial Institute / Al
50 %
1,000,000
Vocational Industrial Institute / Al-
70 %
1,400,000
Vocational Industrial Institute / Bajil
50 %
1,000,000
Technical Industrial Institute / Abs
70 %
1,400,000
Boumediene Vocational Training
70 %
1,400,000
Agricultural and the commercial
70 %
1,400,000
Vocational Industrial Institute / Al
100 %
2,000,000
Vocational Industrial Institute / Al
50 %
1,000,000
Total
131,400,000
Table (9): The Affected Community Colleges and the Vocational and Technical Institutes
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
39
Chapter Three || Education Sector
Photos of Some Damages in the Education Sector
40
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
42
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Three || Education Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
43
القطاع الصحي || الرابعSector الفصل Chapter Four || Health
Chapter Four Health Sector
44
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
املسح امليداني متعدد القطاعات لتقييم األضرار الناتجة م2016 عن األزمة الحالية يف اليمن – يناير
44
Chapter Four || Health القطاع الصحي || الرابعSector الفصل
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Health Sector
Building, restoring and equipping health units
7,960,000 $ Building, restoring and equipping health centres
12,680,000 $ Physical therapy centers
200,000$ Building, restoring and equipping rural hospitals Building, restoring and
36,500,000 $
equipping public hospitals
75,500,000 $ Providing furniture and medical equipment
2,260,000 $ Providing surgical devices and instruments
4,455,000 $
Providing laboratory equipment
Equipping Intensive care
4,896,000 $
and emergency
3,050,000 $
Providing medical equipment (rays)
3,240,000$ Mobile Clinic
4,158,000 $ Providing medicines
4,080,000 $
Total
$158,979,000 The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
45
Chapter Four || Health Sector
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Health Sector
Spraying campaigns to combat fevers
1,512,000 $ Surgical Camps
10,509,000 $ First aid training
1,899,300 $ Buying ambulances
1,470,000 $ Awareness-raising and psychotherapy campaigns
2,472,000 $ Travelling abroad for treatment
31,020,000 $ Orphan guardianship (for a year)
93,816,000 $
Guardianship for people with disabilities
8,587,200 $ Providing wheelchairs for people with disability
573,240 $
Total
$ 151,858,740
Total Interventions in the Health Sector 310,837,740 $
46
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
1.
Introduction The health situation of any society is one of the most important indicators of its development, and the level of
its awareness and urbanization. The health issues are also given a priority in all development plans and strategies, as the sound health situation remains the greatest goal for everyone, regardless of their social and economic conditions, and for the family and society as a whole. Moreover, the health status plays a prominent role in developing the human capacities and affecting the production and innovation process. In contrast, the health indicators, both the quantitative and the qualitative, are affected by a number of other elements and variables like the country’s general development levels, the development patterns, the per capita income, the health infrastructure, the availability of facilities and the geographical proximity to the individuals, the educational level and quality , medical and paramedical specialists, the sound management of the health systems situation, the distribution of roles, the quality of services provided and the extent of achieving social justice when the services are distributed and provided, and supporting the needy people by adopting the policies of sponsorship taking into account the environmental situation. The individuals’ awareness of the health status importance and their engagement in the prevention programs and mechanisms has a significant impact on the promotion of public and individual health. Due to the recent events in Yemen, the health system in the country has been affected in general. Epidemics have emerged, the shortage of pharmaceutical items has increased, the therapeutic services and medicine prices have risen, and the health facilities have threatened to stop. All the indicators confirm that the health situation in Yemen is potentially catastrophic, while the international response is weak, particularly in the field of relief and humanitarian aids and human health. This study mainly aimed to measure the damages of the public and the private health sector, as the current crisis has indicated the importance of the private health sector in terms of meeting the needs of citizens. The targeted people have been asked about the most important health services provided by the health facilities in their areas. The highest percentage of the health service they receive was the vaccination campaigns with a rate of (88%), the periodic vaccination campaigns by (79%), followed by transportation services (from home to home by 66%), as described in the figure (4/1).
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
47
Chapter Four || Health Sector
Vaccination Periodic campaigns vaccination
Diseases TransHealth Malnutrition Pregnant women, Combat portation education Treatment maternal and Campaigns campaigns and neonatal care such as (from house counseling spraying to house)
Gyneco logical care
The Diagnostic Hospital Disciplinary Services Consultations Medicare Surgical (Laboratory, of Outpatient Services Clinics’ Rays) patients
Figure (2): The percentage of citizens’ access to the basic health services
2.
Damages Caused to the Health Sector The survey findings revealed that nearly two-thirds of the surveyed communities confirmed that the health
sector was affected, and the highest percentages was Ma’rib, followed Socotra, Abyan, Albayda and Taiz (100%, 100%, 94.6%, 91.4%, 83.1% respectively). The number of health units in the affected governorates is (369), the highest number was in Hadramout, Abyan and Taiz, where the number of affected health units was (180), and the number of health centres The following tables show the number of the different types of health facilities, which have been damaged totally or partially (50%), or (25%) in addition to the estimated costs of the damages repair.
48
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
Photos of the Damages in the Health Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
49
Chapter Four || Health Sector
The following table shows the number of institutions that have been affected in terms of damage/ loss of furniture and supplies (227 health facilities), damage/ loss of (laboratory) medical equipment (144 health facilities), damage/ loss of medical equipment (rays) (72 health facilities) , damage/ loss, medical (surgical) equipment (99 health facilities), damage/ loss of medical equipment (intensive care and emergency) (61 health facilities), or the running out of essential medications in these institutions (272 health facilities). It is worth noting that the health facilities need more than one intervention. Health Units Province
Total Destruction
Health Centers
Partial Destruction
Total Destruction
Partial Destruction
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
ibb
1
130,000
11
480,000
1
230,000
24
2,360,000
Abyan
4
520,000
21
1,120,000
0
0
11
1,040,000
Al Bayda
4
520,000
11
520,000
1
230,000
4
400,000
Alhudaydah
1
130,000
3
120,000
2
460,000
2
200,000
Dhale
1
130,000
10
480,000
1
230,000
5
440,000
Al Mahrah
1
130,000
4
160,000
0
0
2
160,000
Taiz
5
650,000
6
320,000
8
1,840,000
7
760,000
hajjaH
1
130,000
2
120,000
4
920,000
3
360,000
Hadramout
6
780,000
6
300,000
0
0
6
600,000
Socotra
1
130,000
3
160,000
0
0
0
0
Shabwah
1
130,000
4
180,000
0
0
5
480,000
Aden
0
0
1
40,000
2
460,000
11
1,000,000
Lahij
0
0
5
220,000
1
230,000
2
200,000
Ma’rib
2
260,000
2
100,000
0
0
1
80,000
Total
28
3,640,000
89
4,320,000
20
4,600,000
83
8,080,000
Table (10): Units and health centres that have been totally or partially destroyed and their costs
(For more details, please refer to the table of health units and centres damages in the appendices)
50
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
Rural hospitals Province
Total Destruction
Public hospitals
Partial Destruction
Total Destruction
Partial Destruction
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
Number
Cost
Ibb
1
2,300,000
3
2,200,000
0
0
4
5,300,000
Abyan
0
0
5
3,800,000
0
0
3
5,600,000
Al Bayda
1
2,300,000
1
600,000
0
0
4
5,300,000
Alhudaydah
0
0
2
1,600,000
0
0
0
0
Dhale
0
0
2
1,200,000
1
4600000
1
1,000,000
Al Mahrah
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Taiz
1
2,300,000
6
4,400,000
2
9200000
5
11,500,000
Hajjah
2
4,600,000
1
1,000,000
2
9200000
2
4,600,000
Hadramout
0
0
2
1,200,000
0
0
2
2,000,000
Socotra
0
0
2
1,600,000
0
0
0
0
Shabwah
0
0
1
600,000
1
4600000
3
4,300,000
Aden
0
0
0
0
0
0
4
5,300,000
Lahij
0
0
2
1,200,000
0
0
1
1,000,000
Ma’rib
2
4,600,000
1
1,000,000
0
0
2
2,000,000
Total
7
16,100,000
28
20,400,000
6
27,600,000
31
47,900,000
Table (11): Rural and public hospitals that have been totally or partially destroyed and their costs
(For more details, please refer to the table of rural and public hospitals damages in the appendices)
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
51
Chapter Four || Health Sector
There are other non-constructional damages like the damage or loss of medical devices and equipment. The following table shows the necessary intervention to repair these damages:
The cost of
Province
The cost of
The cost of dam-
damaged/
aged/lost med-
lost furniture
ical equipment
and supplies
(laboratory).
The cost of
damaged/
The cost of dam-
damaged/
lost medical
aged/lost medical
lost medical
equipment
equipment (rays)
equipment
(Intensive
(surgical)
Care and Emergency)
The cost of providing essential medication
Ibb
250,000
408,000
180,000
360,000
100,000
630,000
Abyan
420,000
1,122,000
720,000
1,170,000
750,000
525,000
Al Bayda
290,000
748,000
225,000
405,000
50,000
480,000
Alhudaydah
40,000
102,000
45,000
45,000
100,000
75,000
Dhale
70,000
102,000
45,000
90,000
100,000
270,000
Al Mahrah
50,000
0
45,000
0
0
75,000
Taiz
240,000
612,000
450,000
810,000
600,000
660,000
Hajjah
40,000
68,000
90,000
45,000
0
45,000
Hadramout
360,000
442,000
135,000
225,000
200,000
510,000
Socotra
80,000
68,000
0
0
0
120,000
Shabwah
120,000
272,000
180,000
180,000
150,000
180,000
Aden
180,000
612,000
720,000
720,000
650,000
270,000
Lahij
90,000
238,000
270,000
270,000
250,000
165,000
Ma’rib
30,000
102,000
135,000
135,000
100,000
75,000
Total
2,260,000
4,896,000
3,240,000
4,455,000
3,050,000
4,080,000
Table (12): The costs of the intervention needed to repair the non-constructional damages caused to health .facilities
(For more information, please refer to the table of the non-constructional damages in the appendices) The following table shows the number of the affected families due to the health institution’s destruction. The number of the affected families reached about (631 421), where Taiz province had the highest rate (37%), followed by the governorate of Aden (13%) of the total affected families in the survey. If we would like to know the percentage of affected families in the governorate to the total families living in the same province, Socotra, Abyan, Aden, Taiz and Ma’rib are the most affected provinces compared to the rest of provinces.
52
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
Province
Total number of families in
Number of affected
% Of the total families in
the province
familiesw
the province
Ibb
397,770
66,095
16.6
Abyan
75,538
61,264
81.1
Al Bayda
87,074
23,058
26.5
Alhudaydah
501,406
14,401
2.9
Dhale
88,842
18,396
20.7
Al Mahrah
22,647
1,272
5.6
Taiz
478,904
234,012
48.9
Hajjah
273,040
22,731
8.3
Hadramout
167,567
43,550
26.0
Socotra
8,139
6,898
84.8
Shabwah
69,822
11,500
16.5
Aden
137,673
83,963
61.0
Lahij
139,641
27,994
20.0
Ma’rib
37,720
16,286
43.2
Total
2,485,783
631,420
25.4
Table (13): The number of families that have been affected, due to the damage caused to the .health institution The collective and individual in-depth interviews indicated that there were some damages in the health sector as follows: • The lack of necessary medicines including the nutritional medicines. • The power outage in the health facilities, which lead to shortcomings in performing the required tasks. • The damage of vaccines (immunization). • Stopping the laboratory works at the health facilities (testing). • There were some death cases in the dialysis centre because the dialysis machine has been damaged. • The lack of petroleum derivatives to run the health facilities. • Poor access to health facilities to receive treatment in the appropriate time. • The outbreak of some diseases due to the use of contaminated water. • The halting of services in many health facilities such as the sanitation and the Hygiene Fund. • The absence of the local and executive authority’s role in terms of oversight and accountability. • Many medical teams and missions left the affected centres to other places. • The lack of community health awareness and the outbreak of epidemics without being combated by the competent authorities.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
53
Chapter Four || Health Sector
• The inability to find drugs in markets due to the disruption of outlets and the high prices. The supervisor form obtained the information from the competent authorities in the targeted governorates indicating an urgent need for intervention in the following areas: Number of targeted
Intervention
provinces
Cost
Remarks 18 campaigns
Spraying campaigns to combat fevers
14
1,512,000
Surgical camps
10
10,509,000
Physical Therapy Centres
4
200,000
Medical convoys(mobile clinics)
14
4,158,000
14
1,899,300
Buying ambulances
14
1,470,000
35 ambulances
Travelling to treat complex cases abroad
9
31,020,000
Giving treatment for 3102 cases
11
2,472,000
in 103 Directorates
Providing the volunteers with first aid training
Awareness-raising and psychotherapy campaigns Total
38 camps to treat 21,018 injured people The centre can provide services for more than one province 99 convoys, including 13 fixed clinics in Aden For 6331 volunteers - with first-aid kit bag
53,240,300
Table (14): The health interventions contained in the supervisor form
Based on what is contained in the supervisor form, there are a number of social and humanitarian consequences related to the health sector, which have been represented in several interventions, listed in the following table: Number of tar-
Intervention
The sum of money
Remarks
13
8,587,200
for 7156 peoples with disability
12
573,240
for 4777 peoples with disability
10
7,818,000
For 13 030 orphans for one year only
geted provinces
Guardianship for people with disability Providing wheelchairs for peoples with disability Orphan Guardianship
Total
16,978,440
Table (15): Social and humanitarian interventions related to the health sector
For more details, please refer to the medical interventions table contained in the supervisor form in the appendices
54
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
3.
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions
The survey findings revealed that the most important needs and priorities identified by the community members in the health sector are: 1. Rebuilding health facilities. 2. Providing basic medicines for chronic diseases. 3. Providing furniture and medical supplies. The collective interviews highlighted some needs: • Providing petroleum derivatives to the health facilities. • Implementing health awareness programs by forming and distributing volunteer field teams. • Establishing fieldwork mobile clinics to treat malnutrition. • Training and rehabilitating women from the affected areas. • Providing transportation means for patients in emergencies. • Providing medical staff, and recruiting qualified missions with rare medical specialities through medical camps. • Launching campaigns for combating the epidemics in the region. • Opening and rehabilitating the closed health centres. • Establishing centres for rehabilitation and physical therapy. • Establishing fixed or mobile clinics to treat malnourished children. • Providing all first aid kits. • Activating the role of health offices in the directorates and centres. • Providing supported central pharmacies to help the poor people. • Encouraging organizations working in the health field to implement health projects in the provinces. • Motivating and supporting the human medical staff by conducting training courses, and providing it with financial support to prevent them from working in the private hospitals and leave the government hospitals. • Providing psychological fixed clinics for the large displaced gatherings and mobile clinics for the sporadic gatherings (while ensuring that medicines are provided on a regular basis for the injured peoples).
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
55
Chapter Four || Health Sector
Photos of Damages in the Health Sector
56
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
57
Chapter Four || Health Sector
58
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
59
Chapter Four || Health Sector
60
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Four || Health Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
61
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
Chapter Five Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
62
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
The Costs of Required Interventions in the Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
465,187,320 $ six months
Food Basket
413,499,840 $ to be distributed 6 times
Cash Assistance (for a year)
131,600,000 $ for a year
Total
Giving Treatment to Malnutrition Cases
$1,010,287,160
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
63
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
1.
Introduction There are two essential issues related to food security. The first is the amount and type of food required for
achieving food security, and the second is how to get food from both domestic and foreign sources as well as ensuring the supply of this food from these sources regularly. Thus , food security can be defined as the (purchasing power) the community’s ability to provide the food needs (potential) for its members, so that they could live healthy and actively. In addition, the food should be ensured for those who cannot get it, whether through the domestic production or importing depending on the own resources. By adopting this definition, the society can achieve food security through producing the food locally or importing it from other communities. Accordingly, the higher the percentage of the community’s food needs that is locally produced or (the higher the percentage of food self-sufficiency), the more sustainability and food security could be achieved. There is no doubt that in Yemen, one out of every five people suffers from food insecurity, and is in desperate need for food aids. There is also no doubt that the security situation in Yemen remains tense, as the military operations across the country largely affected the ability of international organizations in general, and the World Food Programme, in particular to deliver food, especially in the volatile provinces. Tshabala and Meg Hurricanes had an impact on large parts of Yemen, especially in the southern coastal provinces of Hadramout, Shabwah, Al Mahrah and the island of Socotra.
UN Food and Agriculture Organization has warned from an exacerbated famine in Yemen, where more
than 500,000 children suffer from malnutrition. A study conducted by the World Food Programme revealed that nearly 13 million people are facing acute food insecurity, including 6 million individuals who are facing “ a state of emergency,” as they cannot have their daily bread and suffer from acute malnutrition, and that the situation has become too serious because 1.3 million displaced Yemeni suffer from food insecurity. Food is one of the largest difficulties facing the population, especially the displaced people, as most families have lost their sources of income, which pushed them to sell everything in order to buy food. Further, some displaced people cheaply sold the aids they had received to buy food items that meet their needs. The displaced people have obtained the first food ration after eight months of suffering. The tragic situation wasn’t limited to the displaced people only, but also it directly affected the hosting community, where individuals also lost their sources of income, such as farms, and most of them lost their jobs, particularly those who were working in the border governorates. Many families have been begging because of the urgent need for food, as women and children often go out to beg in markets, where they are often exposed to (sexual and physical violence). This situation may lead to a humanitarian catastrophe if it would not be remedied early.
64
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
2.
Damages Caused to the Food Security Sector The latest findings of the food security surveys, especially the comprehensive survey of the food security,
which was conducted during March-April 2014, indicated that more than 40% of the population suffer from food insecurity, especially in the rural areas. The findings showed that half of the countryside population and quarter of the urban population suffer from food insecurity. Malnutrition spreads among female-headed households, where one out of every ten children suffers from malnutrition, and more than one third of the rural children suffer from underweight. In order to measure the food change phenomena like (the amount of consumed food, the change in the types of daily meals, the consumed amount of food has not changed, a decrease in the productivity (agricultural, fisheries and livestock production), the weakness of food purchasing power, loss of income or part of it), the survey findings were logical and showed that the food and food security have been affected in all governorates. However, it was noted that the consumed amount of the food has not changed, as nearly 16% of the affected areas reported that the consumed amount of food has not changed because of the recent events, and the highest percentage was in the governorates of Ma’rib, Aden and Abyan (20%, 31%, and 33% respectively). There is no doubt that all over the Republic of Yemen has been affected by the issue of food security due to the recent events, and this was confirmed by the survey findings which indicated that about 99% of the affected areas have suffered from food insecurity, and there are no clear differences between the governorates. The affected families that cannot get enough food totaled around (861,458), and about (6.202, 000 million people) at all the affected areas, and the highest number of such families was in Taiz (310, 673), followed by Ibb (75, 215). These indicators are clearly linked to the number of population in each governorate. In terms of percentages, the highest percentage was for the governorates of Abyan, Socotra, and Taiz (68.6%, 66.6%, and 64.9%, respectively).
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
65
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
The percentage of families that are suffering Number of af-
from food insecurity *
The governorate
fected families
The percentage of families that cannot
Acute
Moderate
Total
Ibb
19.6%
23.3%
42.9%
75,215
18.9
Abyan
20.6%
27.9%
48.5%
51,834
68.6
Al Bayda
24.8%
31.5%
56.3%
30,735
35.3
Taiz
23.3%
20.0%
43.3%
63,381
12.6
Hajjah
31.9%
21.7%
53.5%
22,994
25.9
Alhudaydah
10.0%
27.9%
37.9%
5,540
24.5
Hadramout
4.6%
8.3%
12.9%
310,673
64.9
Shabwah
31.5%
25.6%
57.1%
55,870
20.5
Aden
8.1%
13.7%
21.9%
80,360
48.0
Lahij
35.2%
23.1%
58.3%
5,417
66.6
Ma’rib
23.5%
11.7%
35.2%
22,817
32.7
Al Mahrah
1.0%
7.1%
8.1%
68,618
49.8
Dhale
29.0%
25.6%
54.6%
57,210
41.0
Socotra
10.2%
14.4%
24.6%
10,794
28.6
Total
19.3%
21.8%
41.1%
861,458
34.7
get enough food **
Table (16): Data about the food security of the affected families
* The Comprehensive Food Security Survey -2014 ** The percentage was calculated based on the total number of the families in the governorate. The results of the collective and individual interviews revealed that many damages in the food security and malnutrition sector have been incurred as follows: • The complete closure of the entire main and sub entrances in the city of Taiz and in some governorates, which block the access to food and fuel for cooking. • The doubling of food process), which exceeds the purchasing power of the individual, in all the affected provinces. • The lack of main food items and baby milk in addition to the high prices of transferring them to the villages in the provinces of armed conflict. • The complete suspension of the restaurants and furnaces work because of the siege and the lack of cooking gas especially in the province of Taiz. • The emergence of malnutrition symptoms on children in the most affected areas. • The decline of the agricultural and livestock production because of the erosion and the damage caused to the grazing lands as well as the fisheries production as the boats have broken and lost, which affected the availability of food in the affected areas (Socotra, Hadramout, Al Mahrah, Shabwah). • A number of breadwinners suffered low income in all targeted provinces due to the following:
66
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
1. Inability to travel to the neighbouring countries 2. The interruption of remittances from some expatriates. 3. Some of them were fired from their jobs 4. Economic recession.
3.
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions When targeted people were asked about the interventions required to address food shortages in these areas,
about 84% of them assured that they are in need for food baskets. The highest percentage was in (Aden and Lahij and Al bayda), but in terms of cash assistance, the percentage has reached about 12% of the total affected areas, and the highest percentages were in the provinces of Socotra, Abyan, Hajjah. Yet, other people in Ibb stressed their need for other supplies other than food baskets and cash assistance. A number of suggestions have been made as follows: 1. Food for Work. 2. Capacity-building support. 3. Implementing small income-generating projects. The costs of the food basket for each affected family has been estimated at ($ 90), and the urgent cash assistance for each family has been estimated at ($ 80) in each time. The total costs of food baskets that would be distributed 6 times for a year reached about ($ 465,187,320), while the costs of urgent cash assistance that would be distributed 6 times for a year reached approximately ($ 413,499,840). The following table shows the costs of intervention in the field of food security in each of the targeted provinces.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
67
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
The costs of food
The costs of cash assistance
Number of affected
For a year at a rate of 6
families
times
Ibb
75,215
40,616,100
36,103,200
Abyan
51,834
27,990,360
24,880,320
Al Bayda
30,735
16,596,900
14,752,800
Alhudaydah
63,381
34,225,740
30,422,880
Dhale
22,994
12,416,760
11,037,120
Al Mahrah
5,540
2,991,600
2,659,200
Taiz
310,673
167,763,420
149,123,040
Hajjah
55,870
30,169,800
26,817,600
Hadramout
80,360
43,394,400
38,572,800
Socotra
5,417
2,925,180
2,600,160
Shabwah
22,817
12,321,180
10,952,160
Aden
68,618
37,053,720
32,936,640
Lahij
57,210
30,893,400
27,460,800
Ma’rib
10,794
5,828,760
5,181,120
Total
861,458
465,187,320
413,499,840
Province
For a year at a rate of 6 times
Table (17): The number of affected families in the field of food security and the costs of the required intervention
The surveyed areas were asked to arrange the relief items according to their importance and the community need. These commodities were (flour, wheat, oil /butter, sugar, rice, pulses). The most important food commodity for the community was flour followed by rice. There is no doubt that these findings are logical; according to our knowledge with the nature of Yemeni society. The most important answers were as follows: 1. Infant milk. 2. Dates and tea. 3. Food supplements such as tuna and eggs. Some people also asked for providing cooking gas, which clearly and indirectly affected the food, where many families have become unable to buy the cooking gas because its price was doubled about three times compared to the previous period (before the recent events).
68
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
Second: The Field of Malnutrition 1.
Malnutrition Indicators Due to the importance of malnutrition indicators, it has been relied on the nutrition survey data, which was
implemented by the Ministry of Public Health and Population and in collaboration with UNICEF during the year 2015-2014. It is difficult to collect this type of data because it is costly and needs a long time to be conducted. The availability of recent data helped to rely on these indicators. According to the latest studies and surveys, malnutrition indicators were as follows:
80 % 60 % 40 %
58% 2,505,600
20 %
42.90 1,853,280
32% 1,382,400
0% Stunting
Underweight
Underweight babies
15.9% 686,880 Wasting
Figure (3): The Nutrition Situation of Yemeni Children
2.
Interventions Required in the Field of Malnutrition Due to the varying rates of malnutrition in the targeted provinces between acute and moderate, we think that
only provinces that suffer acute malnutrition rate will have intervention through establishing clinics to treat malnutrition cases. These directorates have been identified based on the malnutrition rates of 2015. There will be an Intervention in the directorates whether they are included in the current field survey or not. This intervention will be for an entire year. The following table shows the provinces that will be provided with treatment, and the costs of this intervention.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
69
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
Number of Province
directorates
General malnu- Acute malnutri-
targeted
trition rate
tion rate
Alhudaydah Taiz Hajjah Hadramout Aden Lahij
23 6 20 28 8 9
31.0% 17.4% 20.9% 18.0% 19.2% 17.1%
8.9% 3.3% 3.8% 6.0% 2.5% 1.8%
Total
94
Acute malnutrition moderate
The costs of intervention *
rate
22.1% 14.1% 17.1% 12.0% 16.7% 15.3%
32,200,000 8,400,000 28,000,000 39,200,000 11,200,000 12,600,000 131,600,000
Table (18): The targeted provinces that will be provided with malnutrition treatment and the costs of intervention
* The costs of the private clinic of malnutrition treatment reach $ 1,400,000 in the directorate for a year.
70
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Five || Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
Photos of Food Security and Malnutrition Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
71
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
Chapter six Shelter, Non-Food Items NFI) and Displaced( People Sector
72
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The required interventions costs in shelter and displaced people sector
Monthly rents
1 2 3 4
49,375,200 $ for a year six times
Building and repairing damaged houses
725,235,000 $
providing home appliances
8,229,200 $
personal toiletry bag
2,896,608 $
5 6
Water filters
2,660,910 $
Social protection activities
2,304,176 $
Total
$790,701,094
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
73
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
1.
Introduction United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) report indicates that the number of
displaced people in Yemen has increased since Marsh 2015 by 9% from the statistics recorded on November 2014. The sixth report confirmed that the number of displaced people have reached 2,509,068 pointing out that the number is eight times the number of displaced people in March 2015. According to resources, half million were displaced from Taiz towards rural areas and provinces. The report also pointed out that the displacement rate has been declined in the southern provinces and increased in Northern provinces. 45% of the displaced people fled their homes and return to their original provinces, while 55% of them fled to other provinces, explaining that Taiz, Imran, Hajjah, Sana’a, Abyan are the most affected provinces, where the ratio of displacement from these provinces were 1.5 million, which represents 48% of the total displaced people. The report also confirmed that 30,000 persons were killed or injured. In a report about the humanitarian needs of the Yemenis for 2016, more than 21 million Yemenis, about 82% of the population, are in need of assistance in light of the worsening humanitarian situation as well as years of poverty. The report also stated that more 7.6 million people are in need of emergency food assistance to stay alive, and warned that the health system is on the verge of collapse, while 14 million people are lacking access to medical services, and nearly 600 medical facilities have been closed. The total number of internally displaced people reached 2.500.000, an increase of eight times compared with the number at the beginning of the conflict. Moreover, according to the report, the economic situation has worsened, where wheat prices have risen by 74%, Petroleum products have doubled to reach 273%, and the prices have risen in some areas to more than 100 times, as in Taiz. More than 1.8 million children were deprived of education, where more than 1000 schools are unable to receive students and 174 of them were completely destroyed. Therefore, it has become necessary to highlight the issues of displaced people in terms of their numbers, geographic and administrative distribution, the type of shelter, and basic needs, and this is what we will seek to explain below.
2.
Damages Caused to the Displaced People and the Shelter Sector With regard to shelter, the targeted people were asked about the type of shelter they are residing in, and their
answers confirmed the following: 1. A separate house or apartment, 44.4% 2. Partially damaged houses, 24.2% 3. Tents or temporary shelter 22.9% 4. Buildings used as collective shelters 2%. This priority will vary according to the provinces. Their answers were centered in (shops, caves, small backyard, and rooms inside the courtyards, in the open and ruined houses).
74
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
Photos of Shelter and Displaced People Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
75
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The targeted people in the affected areas were asked about the most important problems relating to shelter. The following figure shows their answers.
40 30
35.1
30.8
20 10
13.5
11.5
9.1
0 Small/ narrow/ overcrowded house
Demolished houses
The place is not a shelter
There is a shortage in the appliances
Houses are located in dangerous places
Figure (4): The problems related to shelter in the affected provinces
The affected people were asked about the shelter of the displaced people and the highest ratio was the houses of relatives and friends (88%), in the rented houses (63%), in schools and government buildings (37%) and in dispersed population groups (34%).
76
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
In school Governorate
/ government building
In the homes of rela-
In tents
tives and
In the
Rented
Planned
open
homes
camps
Random camps / informal
dispersed population groups
Ibb
26.5%
friends 94.5%
Abyan
75.0%
94.1%
23.5%
7.7%
93.8%
0.0
20.0%
27.3%
Al Bayda
10.7%
85.7%
3.8%
11.5%
51.9%
0.0
7.7%
12.0%
Al Hudaydah
5.0%
87.5%
0.0
5.0%
79.2%
0.0
20.0%
55.0%
Dhale
81.8%
100.0%
50.0%
50.0%
100.0%
0.0
50.0%
50.0%
Al Mahrah
0.0
66.7%
0.0
0.0
66.7%
0.0
0.0
0.0
Taiz
60.0%
98.4%
15.4%
37.8%
75.5%
2.8%
22.5%
58.1%
Hajjah
8.7%
70.4%
38.5%
66.7%
28.0%
0.0
37.0%
53.8%
Hadhramaut
51.3%
79.1%
20.0%
30.8%
15.4%
2.6%
12.8%
33.3%
Socotra
0.0
30.0%
30.0%
20.0%
10.0%
0.0
0.0
10.0%
Shabwah
50.0%
100.0%
11.1%
0.0
50.0%
0.0
11.1%
0.0
Aden
6.9%
83.3%
0.0
0.0
83.3%
0.0
0.0
6.9%
Lahij
54.5%
100.0%
0.0
9.1%
50.0%
0.0
0.0
20.0%
Ma’rib
80.0%
100.0%
100.0%
75.0%
100.0%
0.0
100.0%
100.0%
average
37.3%
88.4%
15.5%
22.7%
62.3%
1.6%
15.1%
34.3%
8.6%
5.9%
71.7%
5.7%
2.9%
33.3%
* Table (19): The relative distribution of the displaced people shelter
* The question allows multiple answers and this means that the total in the columns is not necessarily equal to 100%
3.
The Appropriate Needs and Interventions More than 82292 families have fled their homes, where the highest rate of displaced people was in Taiz, Ibb,
Hadramout and Abyan (18%, 15%, 12%,10% respectively) Given to the ongoing movements of the displaced persons and instability, so the number is increasing and decreasing according to the position of displaced families and the current situations. This accounts for the difference in figures between human organizations clusters of the UN and our field survey.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
77
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The number of displaced Governorate
families (from the clusters)
The number of displaced families (Through surveys)
The cost of water filters *
The cost of
Household
personal
Monthly
items
toiletry bag
rents ***
***
**
Social protection activities
Ibb
23,311
12,406
779,160
831,104
7,443,600
1,240,600
347,368
Abyan
30,068
2,050
242,400
258,560
1,230,000
205,000
57,400
Al Bayda
24,046
3,718
41,610
45,344
2,230,800
371,800
104,104
Al Hudaydah
6,394
2,807
19,500
20,800
1,684,200
280,700
78,596
Dhale
27,397
2,449
63,660
66,304
1,469,400
244,900
68,572
Al Mahrah
17
16
480
512
9,600
Taiz
45,654
34,151
624,060
696,192
20,490,600
3,415,100
956,228
Hajjah
46,245
6,313
453,390
483,616
3,787,800
631,300
176,764
Hadramout
17,814
2,555
17,940
40,512
1,533,000
255,500
71,540
Socotra
0
1,117
19,500
20,800
670,200
111,700
31,276
Shabwah
7,443
447
7,500
0
268,200
44,700
12,516
Aden
59,035
3,255
244,110
276,064
1,953,000
325,500
91,140
Lahij
7,416
2,774
600
0
1,664,400
277,400
77,672
Marib
8,216
8,234
147,000
156,800
4,940,400
823,400
230,552
Total
303,056
82,292
2,660,910
2,896,608
49,375,200
8,229,200
1,600
448
2,304,176
Table (20): The number of displaced people who deserve water filters and personal toiletry bag and their cost
* 30$ per filter ** 32$ per personal toiletry bag. *** 100% for monthly rent and the intervention will be for a year at a rate of 6 times. **** 100$ for household items. ***** 40% for social protection activities per capita. Knowing that these figures represent only the number of displaced people in areas affected by military events or floods, despite the existence of displaced people in the scope of the districts, but they are not within the scope of the study and not covered by the survey. The official authorities and public bodies were asked about the damages suffered by shelter sector. The following table shows the number and the cost of intervention in this sector. Table (6/3) shows the number and the cost of the affected houses in the targeted areas. The results in the targeted areas have shown that the total number of totally affected houses was (9.095) at a cost of (227,375,000 $), while the total number of partially affected houses was (49.786) at a cost of ($ 366 013 905).
78
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
Governorate
completely damaged
cost
Partially damaged
Cost **
Ibb
78
1,950,000
205
2,050,000
Abyan
1825
45,625,000
10340
103,400,000
Al Bayda
69
1,725,000
198
1,980,000
Al Hudaydah
25
625,000
0
0
Dhale
70
1,750,000
1260
12,600,000
Al Mahrah
112
2,800,000
692
6,920,000
Taiz
5250
131,250,000
29750
297,500,000
Hajjah
64
1,600,000
165
1,650,000
Hadhramaut
52
1,300,000
295
2,950,000
Socotra
221
5,525,000
309
3,090,000
Shabwa
537
13,425,000
790
7,900,000
Aden
175
4,375,000
995
9,950,000
Lahij
382
9,550,000
3837
38,370,000
Marib
235
5,875,000
950
9,500,000
Total
9095
227,375,000
49786
497,860,000
Table (21): The number and the cost of the damaged houses in terms of the scale of damage and the governorates
* $ 25,000 per totally affected house. ** $ 10,000 per partially affected house.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
79
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The targeted people in the affected areas were asked about the most important needs for shelter and for the displaced people. their answers confirmed the following: 1. Providing shelter. 2. Providing basic household items 3. Providing additional shelters. 4. Removing the shelter to a suitable place . 5. Providing the skills required for repairing or constructing the camps. These priorities would certainly be different for different governorates Other answers related to shelter and the most important needs had been received from the targeted people and were focused on (providing water to houses, hiring homes, providing mobile homes, reasonable shelter, in-kind assistance for the displaced people, building shelters for displaced families and getting the displaced families out from the schools. Some answers about the basic needs of the displaced people had been received in the collective and individual interviews, the most important of which were as follows • Providing adequate food for all displaced families and poor families from the host country. • Providing fixed psychiatric clinics for large groupings of displaced persons, and a mobile clinic for loose groupings, ensuring drugs for the injured. • Providing adequate shelter for the displaced families. • Providing building materials. • Rehabilitating and training community members in professional and vocational field to reduce unemployment. • Establishing revenue-generating projects for the displaced, and priority will be given to persons with special needs • Providing clothing for the displaced families, especially for women and children. • Launching awareness campaigns about gender violence, child labor risks, rights and duties. • Finding new markets to reduce unemployment.
80
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
Photos of some damages in the shelter and displaced sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
81
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
82
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
83
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
84
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Six || Shelter, Non-Food Items (NFI) and Displaced People Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
85
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Chapter seven Livelihood Support Sector
86
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
The Required Interventions Costs in Livelihood Support Sector
The fisheries sector
9,702,000 $
Agriculture sector
876,000 $
Grazing sector
876,000 $
Workers and Employees
99,787,860 $
Total
360 ,392 ,112$
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
87
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
First: The Fisheries Sector
providing and repairing fishing boat
9,702,000 $
Total
9,702,000 $
Secondly: Agriculture Sector
Providing ploughs
Cash assistance to farmers
396,000 $
480,000 $
Total
88
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
876,000 $
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Third: The Grazing Sector
conducting training courses in the field of veterinary
Buying animals
728,500 $
118,000 $
Concessionary loans for shepherds
1,180,000 $
Total
2,026,500 $
Fourth: Workers and Employees Sector
Training and skills development
Granting loans
60,052,200 $
18,015,660 $
Repairing shops
21,720,000 $
Total
99,787,860 $ The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
89
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
1.
Introduction This chapter highlights the livelihood sector. This constitutes a major challenge for disaster risks reduction and
adapt to the changes taking place due to these events. People ignore the imminent risk of such areas in order to support their families, even at the cost of their own lives. They prefer to live in a place that provides working opportunities and sources of income, at all cost. The term (livelihoods) is not used in high-income countries, but it is used widely in low/middle-income countries In several parts of the world, the household constitutes the basic economic unit and the decision maker about the means of livelihood. The resources are used in several ways to make living through a process in which every member of the household involved (which includes several children in low-income countries). Some family members don’t make their living directly (are often women and children) , but they have an essential role to play in fetching water, buying fuel, preparing food, looking after children, and caring for the elderly. In general, people who live in such areas do not pay enough attention to the real risks that agencies of disaster risk reduction seek to address. However, their focus is on the problems of everyday life so they live in dangerous areas to make their living. Governments in some cases call for evacuation such areas, depriving them livelihoods. The poverty is forcing many people to live in dangerous areas. In spite of such difficulties, there are interesting examples show that there is a relationship between disaster risks reduction and livelihoods. Providing additional funds to protect livelihoods will lead to a significant reduction in the costs assigned to respond to disasters and achieving economic recovery. Larger size interventions are needed in the field of livelihoods to reduce natural disasters.
2.
Damage in the livelihoods Sector The targeted people in the affected areas were asked about the major sources of income in their community.
Results of the survey showed that agriculture is the main source of income, followed by daily labor, public sector, private sector and finally grazing. These results are consistent with the results of labor force surveys.
90
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Construc-
means of
Employ-
Employ-
tion and
transport and
ment in
ment in
General Agriculgovernorate
Small-scale
Fishing
Immigrant’s trades and
ture
contracting
communica-
the public
the private
Daily labor
Grazing
businesses
remittances crafts
business
tions
sector
sector
ibb
0.0
11.9%
6.6%
9.6%
13.0%
6.9%
17.6%
17.9%
13.0%
7.0%
19.6%
Abyan
5.9%
9.6%
15.4%
11.5%
14.2%
18.8%
11.9%
7.1%
7.2%
12.1%
.7%
Al Bayda
0.0
6.7%
1.1%
1.9%
7.6%
2.3%
5.7%
10.7%
8.5%
5.9%
17.6%
Al Hudaydah
20.8%
4.6%
14.3%
9.6%
3.8%
3.1%
11.3%
2.7%
5.6%
4.7%
4.6%
Dhale
0.0
8.1%
1.1%
4.5%
6.6%
6.9%
3.8%
6.3%
7.2%
9.0%
3.3%
Al Mahrah
10.9%
2.6%
2.2%
3.2%
.3%
3.1%
0.0
0.0
3.2%
2.0%
7.2%
Taiz
5.9%
12.8%
13.2%
20.4%
11.7%
8.0%
22.0%
22.3%
12.5%
10.9%
8.5%
Hajjah
2.0%
8.1%
8.8%
6.4%
1.6%
.4%
4.4%
6.3%
5.8%
9.0%
9.8%
Hadhramaut
30.7%
21.7%
24.2%
11.5%
9.5%
16.9%
8.8%
9.8%
16.4%
22.3%
10.5%
Socotra
6.9%
2.3%
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
2.7%
3.9%
0.0
Shabwah
3.0%
2.9%
2.2%
2.5%
7.6%
6.1%
1.9%
1.8%
4.0%
4.3%
13.7%
Aden
10.9%
.6%
7.7%
13.4%
13.3%
17.2%
6.3%
12.5%
7.7%
.8%
3.3%
Lahij
3.0%
7.5%
2.2%
5.1%
9.8%
9.2%
6.3%
1.8%
6.4%
7.8%
.7%
Marib
0.0
.6%
1.1%
.6%
.9%
1.1%
0.0
.9%
0.0
.4%
.7%
Total
9.5%
30.9%
6.2%
9.8%
24.7%
19.0%
13.4
9.7
35.5
24.5
15.6
Table (22): The relative distribution of the main sources of income in the affected communities
Agriculture
Small-scale business
Day labor
Public Sector
Private Sector
Grazing
Expat Remittance
Fishing
Construction and Contracting Business
Figure (5): Distribution of the main sources of income in the affected communities
* small-scale businesses included employees in services such as (means of transport and communications, open Air Marketalls, general trades and crafts)
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
91
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
First: Fishing field The targeted people were asked about damages in fishing sector. The coastal governorates were affected (Hadramout, Hodeidah, Al Mahrah, Socotra) and Hadramout was the most affected. The targeted people were also asked about the most wanted requirements of the affected people in fishing sector. the most important of which were as follows: 1. Providing fishing gear 2. concessionary loans for fishermen. 3. repairing damaged boats. 4. providing places for storage and freezing.
Total damages
Interventions required Damaged
Governorate
Damaged
Damaged
boats
fishing gear
storage and
Providing repairing
freezing equip- current boats
providing
places for
concessionary
fishing gear
storage and
loans
ment
freezing
al hudayah
17
17
13
16
19
17
19
Al Mahrah
11
11
4
11
11
7
11
Taiz
6
5
4
4
5
5
4
Hajjah
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
Hadhramaut
31
31
22
30
31
22
30
Socotra
6
6
3
6
7
7
6
Shabwah
3
3
1
2
2
1
2
Total
76
75
49
71
77
61
74
Table (23): The number of areas that experienced by damage in fishing sector and the interventions required
92
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
the number of missing
Governorate
boats
the cost
Al Hudaydah
8
78,400
Al Mahrah
174
1,705,200
Taiz
30
294,000
Hajjah
25
245,000
Hadhramaut
285
2,793,000
Socotra
245
2,401,000
Shabwah
223
2,185,400
Total
990
9,702,000
)Table (24): Interventions in fishing sector (the cost of the boats
The cost of the boat is $ 9.800 The problems in fishing sector as identified in focus group meetings. The most important of which were as follows: 1. Lack of petroleum products. 2. damaged seafood products due to power outages and the lack of the means of energy production. 3. Fishing places and most of islands were targeted directly by aerial bombardment, such as Ocban island in AlHudaydah governorate in which many fishers were martyred and injured, leading to the interruption of fishing due to the fear of aerial bombardment, affecting many families. 4. The damages to fisheries industry at home and abroad. 5. Some fishing boats were directly targeted, depriving the families of an important source of income.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
93
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Photos of the damages caused to the fisheries sector
94
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
95
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Secondly: Agricultural field The targeted people were asked about damages in agricultural sector, and the damages were as follows: 1. Breaking down water wells 2. Losing or breaking down of agricultural machinery 3. Destructing waterwheels. 4. Dredging arable land The indicators vary between provinces. The results of the study showed that the most wanted requirements in the agriculture were as follows: 1. Repairing and providing agricultural machinery 2. Repairing water wells 3. Providing seeds 4. Rehabilitating degraded lands. 5. Spraying insecticide and providing fertilizers
The significant damages
The most wanted requirements repair-
breaking Governorate
dredged
down
arable
agri-
lands
cultural machin-
Damaged irrigation systems
out breaking of crop pests
break-
ing or
spraying
dam-
ing
rehabili-
pro-
insecti-
repair-
main-
aged
down
tating of
viding
cide and
ing
taining
water-
of the
degrad-
agri-
pro-
water-
water
wheels
water
ed lands
cultural
viding
wheels
wells
ma-
fertilizers
wells
ery
providing seeds
chinery
Al Mahrah
11
7
8
6
11
8
11
8
7
11
9
9
Hadhramaut
80
35
53
41
79
47
80
64
56
82
56
51
Socotra
1
5
2
3
4
1
2
2
3
4
5
Shabwah
8
6
7
8
9
9
8
7
9
9
9
6
Total
100
6
73
57
102
68
100
81
74
105
78
71
Table (25): The number of areas that affected in the agricultural sector and the interventions required
96
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Governorate
the number of
Al Mahrah
ploughs 1
Hadhramaut
the cost
The number of farmers who
the cost***
66,000
deserve aid ** 30
2
132,000
100
200,000
Socotra
1
66,000
50
100,000
Shabwah
2
132,000
60
120,000
Total
6
396,000
240 Farmer
480,000
60,000
Table (26): Interventions in the agricultural sector
The plough cost is 66,000$ ** This aid aimed at defraying the costs of repairing irrigation systems and the providing seeds, fertilizer and Insecticides. *** Cash assistance for farmers: $ 2,000 per capita. The problems in agricultural sector identified in focus group meetings. The most important of which were as follows: 1. The lack of diesel fuel in the domestic market and rise in prices in the black market, leaving the land without planting, which caused such suffering to the farmers. 2. Workers in the export business incurred losses 3. Some of the farms were directly targeted such as farms in the valley of Tehama. 4. Most of the workers lost their sources of income in the agriculture sector. 5. Some farmers fleeing their villages and their farms for fear of targeting and internal fighting. 6. Some of the weekly markets were targeted, including Zabid market in Hodeidah .
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
97
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Photos showing the damage caused to the agricultural sector
98
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
99
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Third: Grazing sector The targeted people were asked about the damages caused to grazing sector, the results were as follows: 1. The death of livestock. 2. The outbreak of animal diseases affecting livestock 3. Damaged pasture land. The damages suffered by the grazing sector were as follows: 1. High cost of feed. 2. Over logging and the lack of pasture land 4. Decline in rainfall and DE vegetation 1. Pasture land affected by the conflict because of mined agricultural areas. 2. Lower livestock prices owing to financial constraints. 3. Lack of veterinary clinics 4. Shutting down Livestock markets.
the damages in the grazing sector
Interventions required
The outbreak of Governorate
buying animals
conducting
instead of that
training courses
died
in veterinary
19 26 12 10 21 2 25 18 56 2 9 17 2
35 47 14 9 25 8 31 22 56 10 7 20 3
36 46 13 15 30 9 33 24 67 10 9 23 2
219
288
318
the death of
animal diseases
damaged pas-
livestock
affecting live-
ture land
ibb Abyan Al Bayda Al Hudaydah Dhale Al Mahrah Taiz Hajjah Hadhramaut Socotra Shabwah Lahij Marib
34 44 15 9 26 4 33 22 57 8 9 21 2
stock 33 31 12 7 22 3 30 21 48 5 9 23 3
Total
285
248
Table (27): The number of affected areas in grazing sector and the interventions required
100
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
The most wanted requirements of grazing sector provided by the targeted people were as follows: 1. Buying animals instead of that died. 2. Providing Training courses in veterinary. As for the most important requirements for the grazing sector, they were as follows: (improving pasture land and developing solutions for dredging lands, demining, providing medicines for livestock, conducting training courses in marketing and rising animals, buying fodder and beehives)
conductGovernorate
Buying animals *
ing training The cost
courses in the
concessionThe cost
field of veteri-
ary loans for
The cost
shepherds ***
nary ** Al Hudaydah
298
74,500
60
24,000
80
160,000
Al Mahrah
90
22,500
20
8,000
40
80,000
Taiz
504
126,000
60
24,000
100
200,000
Hajjah
408
102,000
40
16,000
100
200,000
Hadhramaut
720
180,000
65
26,000
140
280,000
Socotra
200
50,000
20
8,000
30
60,000
Shabwah
694
173,500
30
12,000
100
200,000
Total
2914
728,500
295 trainee
118,000
590 Shepherd
1,180,000
Table (28): Interventions in the grazing sector
* The value of dead animals was estimated at $ 250. ** The cost of training courses in veterinary was estimated at $ 400. *** The cost of concessional loan was estimated at $ 2,000. The problem of the grazing sector as appeared in the focus group interviews, among the most important were the following: 1. Mining of some pasture lands. 2. Fearing from conflicts. 3. The difficulty of transport of livestock to local markets due to the lack of petroleum products. 4. The declining standard of living of the workers in this sector (Shepherds- Cattle traders- workers- local markets).
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 101 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Photos of the damages caused to the gazing sector
102
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Fourth: Workers and employees sector: The targeted people were asked about the damage in the sources of income of workers, and employees, The results showed that the reasons are as follows: 1. Low income. 2. Loss of income. 3. Lack of employment opportunities 4. The workplace is not safe. 5. The market of this category was closed . The targeted people were asked about the most wanted requirements to improve the living situation for workers and employees, among the most important were the following: 1. Granting micro credit and capacity building 2. Conducting vocational training courses. 3. Finding new markets. As for other answers, the requirements were as follows: 1. Establishing small income-generating projects. 2. Providing working opportunities, for example, (cash for work). Bearing in mind that this study did not address the damages caused to the private sector such as factories, large companies that were affected, because such sectors needs an independent study.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 103 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
The crucial damage in workers and employees categories
conduct-
The Governorate
The most important interventions required
work-
The market
place is
was closed
unsafe
Loss of income source
Low of
Granting mi-
Providing
income
cro credit
new market
ing vocational training
ibb
48
21
54
56
58
21
courses. 54
Abyan
45
16
60
54
58
20
55
Al Bayda
30
4
19
28
31
10
24
Al Hudaydah
28
21
34
32
31
20
30
Dhale
28
23
30
28
33
18
32
Al Mahrah
8
3
16
16
16
4
16
Taiz
73
56
76
73
77
61
75
Hajjah
28
23
30
27
31
23
31
Hadhramaut
34
25
71
79
82
49
79
Socotra
3
1
10
10
9
9
9
Shabwah
18
9
14
21
23
10
22
Aden
5
13
12
12
1
6
Lahij
26
13
28
29
31
24
32
Marib
5
3
4
4
5
4
5
Total
379
218
459
469
497
274
470
Table (29): The number of the affected areas in the workers and employees categories and the interventions required
The question was directed by supervisors to the official and popular bodies in the provinces and those who are interested in determining the number of damages in the shops, and the scale of the damage, the following table shows the number and the cost of intervention in this sector.
104
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Governorate
The number of affected
ibb
householders 13,575
Abyan
The cost of loans *
The cost of training and
6,787,300
development ** 2,036,190
11,277
5,638,500
1,691,550
Al Bayda
4,932
2,466,200
739,860
Al Hudaydah
4,128
2,063,900
619,170
Dhale
3,910
1,954,800
586,440
Al Mahrah
140
70,200
21,060
Taiz
51,841
25,920,400
7,776,120
Hajjah
6,067
3,033,300
909,990
Hadhramaut
10,034
5,017,200
1,505,160
Socotra
629
314,700
94,410
Shabwah
2,278
1,139,000
341,700
Aden
3,430
1,715,100
514,530
Lahij
6,105
3,052,600
915,780
Marib
1,758
879,000
263,700
Total
120,104
60,052,200
18,015,660
Table (30): Interventions in workers and employees sector
* The value of the loan was estimated at $ 500 per capita. ** The cost of training and rehabilitation was estimated at $ 300 for half the number of affected households.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 105 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Governorate
completely damaged the cost* 90,000
Partially damaged
ibb
the number 9
the number 52
the cost** 312,000
Abyan
29
290,000
87
522,000
Al Bayda
29
290,000
32
192,000
Al Hudaydah
8
80,000
13
78,000
Dhale
14
140,000
33
198,000
Al Mahrah
0
0
0
0
Taiz
450
4,500,000
1,450
8,700,000
Hajjah
109
1,090,000
0
0
Hadhramaut
11
110,000
0
0
Socotra
0
0
0
0
Shabwah
13
130,000
117
702,000
Aden
35
350,000
233
1,398,000
Lahij
93
930,000
197
1,182,000
Marib
19
190,000
41
246,000
Total
819
8,190,000
2,255
13,530,000
Table (31): The number and the cost of the affected shops
* The cost of repairing the totally damaged shop: $ 10,000 ** The Cost of repairing the partially damaged shop : $ 6,000 The problem of agricultural sector which appeared in the focus group interviews, the most important of which were as follows : 1. Losing of employment 2. Widespread unemployment. 3. The increase of the poor workers group, due to the stoppage of workers’ sources.   Collective focus and individual interviews have confirmed that living conditions are harsh in some provinces where most people rely mainly on agriculture, grazing and herding sheep. The salaries of employees in the government are barely enough to cover the basic needs. The agricultural sector, irrigation channels and torrents have been damaged, affecting agriculture and grazing. Many banana, feed and vegetable farms have ceased their production. The fisheries and commercial sector have also affected due to the block of exports and imports, where the affected houses of 2011 have still not been built.
106
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Seven || Livelihood Support Sector
Photos of the damages caused to the shops
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 107 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Chapter Eight The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
108
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
First: Water Sector Findings
Recommendations
• Number of projects that have been dam-
• Rehabilitation of the suspended projects
aged due to the events (735 resource)
by fixing the damaged water pumps, net-
which represent (17%) of the total projects
works and tanks.
in the targeted areas. • The damaged water tanks reached (149 ), and the pumps that damaged (214), however, the damaged water networks reached (218). • Families that were affected due to the damage of the water and the sewage sector (656747 families). • Maintenance and fuel costs increased that led to the increase of the water extraction costs, which negatively influenced inhabi-
• Conducting awareness-raising programs on the waste water and how to use it properly. • Establishing sewage networks and completing existing ones. • Providing water to be delivered by vehicles to damaged areas. • Providing fuels especially Diesel to operate equipment. • Constructing the collection reservoirs to save the water springs.
tants. • The usage of polluted water and the increase of sewage wastes caused the outbreak of diseases. • Dropout of female students from school increased in order to be able to provide water from far areas due to its lack. • • The girls’ dropout of school owing to their involvement in bringing water from distant places. • The stoppage of many projects and networks due to the lack of maintenance.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 109 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Second: Education Sector Findings • Findings of the survey showed that 78% of
• Most important priorities in the education
the damaged areas may affect the educa-
sector is to rehabilitate partially and fully
tion sector.
damaged schools.
• Total number of schools, where the survey has been conducted is around (2987), (949)
• Providing furniture and educational equipment.
were damaged which represent (32%) of
• Providing educational stationary.
the total schools in the area.
• Providing security for students and teach-
• Number of classes damaged were around (3569) which represent (12%) of the total classes in the area. • Classes that were looted and damaged
ers. • Providing teachers and encouraging them to attend to schools. • Establishing extra classes.
were(3878) which represent (13%) of the
• Establishing schools for girls.
total classes in the area.
• Providing drinking water and water tanks.
• Number of needed tents is about (1762) and the number of the temporary classrooms is (2171). • Number of students who were educationally deprived due to the damage on the educational sector reached (488,638). • Education suspension percentage due to the events occurred in the damaged areas was around (60%) in the affected areas.
110
Recommendations
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
• Providing educational curriculum. • Providing schools uniforms, bags, and all the needed supplements for the poor families. • Providing the volunteers in schools with rewards to overcome the shortfall of the teachers
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Third: Health Sector Findings • The highest ratio of health service provided to citizens was vaccination campaign (88%) and regular vaccinations (79%), fol-
Recommendations • Reconstruction of health facilities. • Securing basic medications for chronic disease.
lowed by the delivery services (from home
• Providing furniture and health needs.
to home 66%)
• Providing oil and fuel.
• Around two thirds of the survey’s commu-
• Conducting health awareness-raising pro-
nities confirmed that there were damages
grams and forming voluntary field teams.
in the health sector. • Number of damaged facilities, in terms of loss of furniture and supplies was (227) • Loss or damage of medical equipment(lab) (144) • Loss or damage of medical equipment (X-ray) (72 health facilities) • Loss or damage of medical equipment (surgery) (99 health facilities) • Loss or damage of health machines (intensive care and emergency) (61 facilities) • The running out of essential medications in health facilities (272 health facilities) • Affected families in health sector, were around 631,42. • One of the most important problems of health sector is the scarcity of medications and malnutrition. • Power outrage in health facilities that badly influenced the performance. • Damage of vaccinations. • Stoppage of laboratories work in health facilities.
• Establishing mobile field clinics to treat malnutrition. • Training and rehabilitating midwives from inhabitants of the damaged areas. • Providing transportation means for emergencies. • Providing medical staff, and recruiting qualified missions with rare medical specialities through medical camps. • Launching campaigns for combating the epidemics in the region. • Opening and rehabilitating the closed health centres. • Establishing centres for rehabilitation and physical therapy. • Establishing fixed or mobile clinics to treat malnourished children. • Providing all first aid kits. • Activating the role of health offices in the directorates and centres. • Providing supported central pharmacies to help the poor people. • Encouraging organizations working in the health field to implement health projects in the provinces.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 111 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Findings • The difficulty of patient movement and
• Motivating and supporting the human
their inability to reach health facilities to
medical staff by conducting training cours-
receive treatment in the appropriate time.
es, and providing it with financial support
• The outbreak of some diseases due to the
to prevent them from working in the pri-
use of contaminated water. • Stopping the work in many health facilities such as the sanitation and the Hygiene Fund
vate hospitals and leave the government hospitals. • Providing psychological fixed clinics for the large displaced gatherings and mobile
• The absence of the local and executive au-
clinics for the sporadic gatherings (while
thority’s role in terms of oversight and ac-
ensuring that medicines are provided on a
countability
regular basis for the injured peoples)
• Many medical teams and missions left the affected centres to other places. • The lack of community health awareness and the outbreak of epidemics without being combated by the competent authorities. • The inability to find drugs in markets due to the disruption of outlets and the high prices.
112
Recommendations
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Fourth: Food Security and Malnutrition Sector Findings • All areas in Yemen were affected by recent events in terms of nutrition; the survey findings confirmed that 99% of areas were affected. • Total of damaged families that cannot have enough food around 861,458 families. • Many manifestations emerged affecting food security and malnutrition, for example: • The complete closure of the entire main and sub entrances in all governorates, which prevents the entry of food and fuel for cooking. • The prices increases to multiples, which exceeds the purchasing power of the individual, in all the affected provinces. • The lack of main food items and baby milk • The complete suspension of the restaurants and furnaces work because of the siege.
Recommendations • Around 84% confirmed their need for food packages. • The rate of need for cash assistance reached around 12% from the total of damaged areas. • Working for Food • Supporting capacity building • Implementing small income-generating projects • The most important commodity for the affected communities was flour, then rice • Some of affected people asked for providing cooking gas. • Establishing medical clinic to save and treat children suffering acute malnutrition.
• Loss of income sources • The emergence of malnutrition symptoms on children in the most affected areas. • Lack of cooking gas. • The decline of the agricultural and livestock production. • Number of breadwinners suffered low income in all targeted provinces because of their Inability to travel to the neighboring countries and the interruption of remittances from some expatriates. • High increase in prices due to rugged roads and high prices of transportations. • The decline of fisheries production as the boats have broken and lost, which affected the availability of food in the affected areas. • Increase in the rates of malnutrition among children less than 5 Y in targeted areas.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 113 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Fifth: Shelter and Displaced People sector Findings
Recommendations
• The first type of shelter was an indepen-
• The study results shown that the most import-
dent home or apartment, followed by par-
ant shelter needs is firstly provision of shelter,
tially damaged housing units, then tents
secondly provision of basic home supplies,
or temporary shelters, and partially used buildings. • Other sorts of shelters appeared (shops,
thirdly provision of extra places for sheltering, fourthly transferring location of shelter to appropriate place, fifthly provision of needed skills to fix or build camps.
caves, rooms inside backyards, in open
• Providing water in shelters.
spaces, and demolished houses)
• Assistance in renting homes and supporting
• The most important shelters problems are:
renters.
firstly, they are small or crowded, in second
• Providing mobile homes.
place lack of tools and home supplies, in
• Providing proper shelter, cash assistance and
third place that these shelters are not specified for sheltering, in fourth place units are demolished and incompatible for living, in fifth place shelters exist in dangerous areas. • Findings showed that displaced people exist in around two thirds of areas. • The findings showed that displaced people shelters are in houses of relatives and friends 88%, second in rented homes 63%, third in governmental building of schools 37%, fourth in people gatherings 34%
food and basic domestic supplies for displaced people. • Building housing units for families and emptying schools to enable launching the educational process in schools. • Providing sufficient food for all displaced people and poor families from the hosting community. • Providing mental health clinics for displaced people, in addition to mobile clinics for shattered gatherings, with access to medication to disadvantaged people. • Providing building materials to reconstruct homes and housing damaged people. • Providing vocational training to individuals to decrease unemployment level. • Implementing Displaced people income-generating projects with priority to handicapped. • Providing clothes for displaced people, especially children and women. • Raising awareness on gender-based violence and risks of child labor. • Finding alternative markets to reduce unemployment.
114
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Sixth: Livelihoods support sector Findings
Recommendations
• The survey findings showed that agricul-
• The survey findings showed that the most
ture represents the main income source,
important needs for all areas of Livelihoods
and then comes the daily labor, thirdly the
support sector are as following:
public sector, fourthly the private sector
Fishing sector:
and fifthly grazing.
• Rehabilitation and maintenance of ships.
• It also showed that affected livelihoods were jobs and business, then the agricul-
Agricultural sector:
ture sector, then grazing and finally fishing.
• Land reclamation
Most damaged areas were coast areas as
• Provision of seeds, Fertilizers and pesti-
(Hadhramaut, Al Hudaydah, Al Mahrah, So-
cides.
cotra)
Fishing sector:
Grazing sector:
• Damaged boats and fishing tools.
• Buying animals instead of those dead.
• Agriculture sector:
• Capacity building and training in veteri-
• Most damaged manifestations were in agricultural sector including: • Halt in water tanks
nary. • Reclamation of grazing lands and get solutions for deserting.
• Loss or halt agriculture tools (ploughs)
• Demining in areas for crazing.
• Demolishing of water resources.
• Medications for livestock.
• Eroding of agricultural lands.
• Training and rehabilitation for marketing
Grazing sector:
and raising livestock.
• Death of livestock and animals.
• Supporting buying fodder.
• Emergence of new livestock disease.
• Purchasing beehives
• Damaged areas for grazing.
• Small loans for projects
• High cost of fodder. • Timber cutting for trees and decrease of pastures. • Less rain and decrease of flora. • Impact of ongoing conflict on grazing, mines for example. • Decrease livestock prices due to money need. • Lack of veterinary clinics. • Halt of livestock markets.
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 115 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
Jobs and employment sector:
Jobs and employment sector:
• This sector issues are:
• Establishing income-generating projects.
• No business and halt of work in specializa-
• Rehabilitation and maintenance of facto-
tions. • Loss of incomes. • Low income. • No job security. • Closure of markets of this group.
116
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
ries and small factories. • Job creation programs (cash for work)
Chapter Eight || The Most Important Findings and Recommendations of the Survey
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 117 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Chapter Nine Appendices
118
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 119 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
120
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 121 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
122
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 123 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
124
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 125 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
126
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 127 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
128
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Supervisor’s form
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 129 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
130
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
3-Focus Groups Interviews Guide
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 131 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
132
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 133 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Work Form
134
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of the Input Program
Field Work Form
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 135 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The selected photos
Photos of training supervisors
136
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of the training survey team in the governorates
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 137 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
138
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos during the implementation of the field survey
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 139 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
140
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 141 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of the focal group meetings
142
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 143 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of meetings with some of the affected families
144
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 145 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of some damage in water and sewage sector
146
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 147 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
148
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of damages in the education sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 149 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
150
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of damages in the health sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 151 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of the food security and malnutrition
152
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of accommodations and displaced people sector
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 153 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
154
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 155 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Photos of livelihood sector
156
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 157 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Field Supervisors Data
158
No
Name
Governorate
Phone Number
1
Abu Bakr Awad Bakir
Hadramout
771540873
abubaker999999@gmail.com
2
Nayef Mohammed Hussein Ali
Al Mahrah
772182062
khalaginaif@yahoo.com
3
Hassan Rashid Alahudla
Hodeidah
772431309
alhowdali@gmail.com
4
Ibrahim Ahmed Jaber
Al Bayda
733808283
ib.jabber@gmail.com
5
Ahmed Mohamed Ali Saeed Bahaj
Shabwah
716559209
amb511@hotmail.com
6
Fadel Thabit Salih Alqouh
Abyan
7
Amin Mohamed Abdel Kawi Tahiri
ibb
8
Ghassan Yahya Said Dawla
Lahij
9
Maaz Mohamed Alwan Almqurma
Hajjah
10
Abdullah Al Tayyar
Dhale
11
Ammar Alkhchiba
Aden
700055707
eng.amn1987@gmail.com
12
Ahmed Aeraqbi
Socotra
777502965
aalarqbi@yahoo.com
13
Jamil al-Jabri
Taiz
777812241
Gyemen2012@gmail.com
14
Saleh Qassem
Marib
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
733090327 733413229 773827582 772920691 739873968 777275593 711809329 737549835
770310068 715967677
cssw-abyen@hotmail.com ameen.99al3@gmail.com doolh888@gmail.com moath777275593@gmail.com altayyar6@gmail.com
maerb1cssw@hotmail.com
The cost of
105,030
51,300
-
2,921,130
5,842,260
71,400
214,480
-
19,756,100
39,512,200
2,145,600
57600
28800
28800
100800
72000
316800
144000
561600
28800
259200
0
100800
403200
375
14.3
70
58.8
5.5
45
48.1
7.8
14.7
23.5
43.3
0.8
8.4
29.9
5.3
sources
water
affected
of the
portion
1,128,920
564,460
-
6,128
2,040
31,042
54,560
129,335
4,750
99,600
16,925
43,174
17,425
114,220
218
4
6
16
11
9
45
8
33
5
12
0
19
38
12
systems
meter
45,261
water
destroyed-
ber of thr
The num-
networks by
the affected
lengths of
The total
21,638
10819
0
190
389
335
180
433
151
3815
161
273
827
1583
2482
ed pumps
hpfor affect-
the total of
214
4
6
12
8
4
34
5
38
5
9
4
16
34
35
pumps
ed water
of affect-
the number
149
4
2
2
7
5
22
10
39
2
18
0
7
28
3
voirs
reser-
water
ber of
num-
the
4,358
84
20
51
477
40
210
295
750
51
90
502
502
334
952
region
in the
sources
of water
number
The af-
445
15.9
4.6
97.2
21.8
57.3
39.9
6.1
48.6
7.1
19.4
1.2
28.7
81.9
15.7
holds
house-
fected
*** The cost of repairing water systems: The cost of repairing water systems was estimated at $ 50 per linear meter
** Repairing water pumps: The cost of buying the pump, according to hp estimated at $ 20 per hp.
* Repairing water tanks: The cost of repairing water tanks per cubic meter was estimated at $ 400 and a total of $ 14.400
90,450
40,770
166,250
1,086,470
1,030,050
3,486,000
48,600
43,470
592,375
1,909,600
73,710
1,511,090
116,910
223,290
609,875
4,526,725
427,410
3,997,700
tanks *
pumps **
43200
repair water
repairing
670,140
the cost to
The cost of
1,584,135
***
ter systems
repairing wa-
The pro-
Tables attached No (1): The water sector
656,747
5,980
6,373
133,819
15,204
4,667
66,859
16,687
232,927
1,610
17,255
6,230
24,998
61,830
62,308
families
affected
ber of
the num-
2,485,783
37,720
139,641
137,673
69,822
8,139
167,567
273,040
478,904
22,647
88,842
501,406
87,074
75,538
397,770
norate
the gover-
holds in
house-
number of
the total
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
ate
governor-
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
Tables attached
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 159 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
160
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
51,000
97,800
36,600
121,200
59,400
9,600
381,000
50,400
24,000
71,400
3,600
0
11,400
48,000
965,400
175,392
68,256
21,168
28,944
65,664
34,992
389,664
20,736
76,032
22,464
4,752
30,672
15,120
9,504
963,360
7,608,000
188,000
204,000
598,000
338,000
452,000
148,000
362,000
2,230,000
42,000
264,000
196,000
524,000
1,320,000
742,000
furnishing Classes
32,275,200
979,200
1,267,200
864,000
1,353,600
2,428,800
1,987,200
2,803,200
9,436,800
700,800
2,880,000
1,334,400
2,131,200
1,987,200
2,121,600
Building classes
2,230
22
35
71
11
52
176
48
902
81
152
67
49
158
406
The need for classrooms
1,609
80
19
0
6
119
40
84
635
16
99
202
61
163
85
The need for tents
3,804
94
102
299
169
226
74
181
1115
21
132
98
262
660
371
Classrooms need to be
3,362
102
132
90
141
253
207
292
983
73
300
139
222
207
221
The number of the affect-
28,855
829
557
2528
1005
507
3290
1484
7431
625
1524
1555
1311
1755
4454
The number of classrooms
classroom properties
79,629
2,555
5,496
1,816
3,995
----
7,279
8,492
15,294
897
3,792
9,391
3,892
3,451
13,279
The number of classrooms
489
11
39
14
18
94
42
31
30
17
53
14
38
63
25
%
949
26
31
18
30
59
146
66
167
11
62
23
64
126
120
the number of damaged schools
2,987
241
80
129
164
63
347
213
552
64
117
162
170
200
485
The number of schools
School properties
9,914
451
675
119
567
-
776
1,434
1,472
127
451
1,306
570
461
1,505
The number of schools
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
governorate
* The cost of rebuilding the affected classes was estimated at ($ 9,600) per class, and ($ 2,000) for the classes that need refurbishing . ($ 600) per tent, and ($ 72) for monthly rent for a class.
Buying tents
Temporary rent
The cost of the affected classrooms
Table attached No (2): The private education sector
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
5
4
9
1
215
6
11
18
9
297
72
2
2
3
5
2
0
3
5
9
3
15
3
6
14
71
1
3
0
3
1
7
6
8
7
4
16
5
4
6
Hospital
public
0
191
122
75
196
616
5
479
840
220
999
128
120
705
Pharmacies / pharmaceu-
0
6
2
1
6
37
1
46
38
43
34
20
3
25
Medical Centers
252
0
18
0
3
12
21
10
21
25
28
43
17
3
51
medical unit
*private sector
100
0
5
0
0
0
9
1
9
14
5
29
12
0
16
hospital
2742
0
144
50
104
222
25
175
382
402
247
394
171
137
289
the total of government facilities
2005
0
116
39
75
180
0
135
303
328
200
228
110
117
174
Units of primary health care
565
0
24
7
9
27
20
25
61
58
36
138
50
12
98
Health centers
* Public sector
135
0
3
3
18
13
1
14
14
12
9
18
11
7
12
Rural hospital
39
0
1
1
2
2
4
1
4
4
2
10
2
1
5
public Hospital
* the source: Central Statistical Organization CSO The Statistical Yearbook of the Year 2013 ** through the results of the field study
3
5
26
23
24
11
14
6
39
40
10
9
23
18
12
30
27
35
29
65
Health center
Health Unit
Rural hospital
Health facilities in the affected * * provinces
Total
Socotra
Dhale
Al Mahrah
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Hadramout
Hodeidah
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
governorate
Table attached No(3): The private health sector shows the number of health facilities in the public and private sector and their
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 161 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
162
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
13
7
2
1
4
2
2
-
3
-
3
8
1
1
47
1,040,000
560,000
160,000
80,000
320,000
160,000
160,000
-
240,000
-
240,000
640,000
80,000
80,000
3,760,000
4,320,000
-
120,000
360,000
240,000
-
360,000
360,000
600,000
-
120,000
120,000
240,000
480,000
the cost
36
-
1
3
2
-
3
3
5
-
1
1
2
4
11
Partially 50%
4,600,000
-
230,000
460,000
-
-
-
920,000
-
230,000
460,000
230,000
-
230,000
the cost
20
-
1
2
-
-
-
4
8
-
1
2
1
-
1
totally
in the region (health center
2,040,000
40,000
160,000
40,000
120,000
40,000
120,000
-
80,000
160,000
240,000
120,000
280,000
280,000
360,000
the cost
51
1
4
1
3
1
3
2
4
6
3
7
7
9
Partially<25%
2,280,000
60,000
60,000
-
60,000
120,000
180,000
120,000
240,000
-
240,000
-
240,000
840,000
120,000
the cost
38
1
1
-
1
2
3
2
4
-
4
-
4
14
2
Partially
3,640,000
260,000
-
-
130,000
130,000
780,000
130,000
650,000
130,000
130,000
130,000
520,000
520,000
130,000
The cost
28
2
-
-
1
1
6
1
5
1
1
1
4
4
1
totalďż˝) )ly
Structurally damaged health facilities in the region
The cost of the totally affected health center is $ 230,000, $ 120,000 for affected health center by 50%, $ 80,000 for affected health center by 25%
The cost of the totally affected health unit is $ 130,000, and $ 60,000 for affected health unit by 50%, and $ 40,000 for affected health unit by 25%.
Partially
the cost
:)structurallyaffected health facilities
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
governorďż˝ ate
Table attached No (4): The private health sector shows the number of health facilities and their cost in the affected provinces by type
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
3
1
3
0
1
0
0
0
2
0
2
3
1
2
18
3,000,000
1,000,000
3,000,000
0
1,000,000
0
0
0
2,000,000
0
2,000,000
3,000,000
1,000,000
2,000,000
18,000,000
29,900,000
0
0
2,300,000
2,300,000
0
0
4,600,000
11,500,000
0
0
0
2,300,000
4,600,000
2,300,000
the cost
13
0
0
1
1
0
0
2
5
0
0
0
1
2
1
27,600,000
0
0
0
4600000
0
0
9200000
9200000
0
4600000
0
0
0
0
the cost
6
0
0
0
1
0
0
2
2
0
1
0
0
0
0
total� ly
11,400,000
0
1,200,000
0
600,000
600,000
1,200,000
0
2,400,000
0
1,200,000
600,000
600,000
1,800,000
1,200,000
the cost
19
0
2
0
1
1
2
0
4
0
2
1
1
3
2
-25%
9,000,000
1,000,000
0
0
0
1,000,000
0
1,000,000
2,000,000
0
0
1,000,000
0
2,000,000
1,000,000
the cost
9
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
2
0
0
1
0
2
1
Partially 50%
16,100,000
4,600,000
0
0
0
0
0
4,600,000
2,300,000
0
0
0
2,300,000
0
2,300,000
the cost
: )Structurally damaged facilities in the area (rustichospital
7
2
0
0
0
0
0
2
1
0
0
0
1
0
1
to� tally
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
governor� ate
The cost of totally affected public hospital is $4,600,000 , $2,300,000 for affected public hospital by 50%, and $ 1,000,000 for affected public hospital by 25%
The cost of totally affected rural hospital is $2,300,000 , $ 1,000,000 for affected rural hospital by 50%, and $ 600,000 for affected rural hospital by 25%
-25%
the cost
Partially 50%
:)structurally affected utilities In the region (public hospital
Table attached No. (5): The private health sector shows the number of health facilities and their cost in the affected provinces by type (rural hospital, a )public hospital
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 163 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
164
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
42
35
32
5
18
5
44
3
34
8
12
18
11
5
272
630,000
525,000
480,000
75,000
270,000
75,000
660,000
45,000
510,000
120,000
180,000
270,000
165,000
75,000
4,080,000
3,050,000
100,000
250,000
650,000
150,000
0
200,000
0
600,000
0
100,000
100,000
50,000
750,000
100,000
the cost
61
2
5
13
3
0
4
0
12
0
2
2
1
15
2
number
Damage / loss of medical equipment (Intensive Care )and Emergency
4,455,000
135,000
270,000
720,000
180,000
0
225,000
45,000
810,000
0
90,000
45,000
405,000
1,170,000
360,000
the cost
99
3
6
16
4
0
5
1
18
0
2
1
9
26
8
the num-
Damage / loss, medical devices )(surgical devices
3,240,000
135,000
270,000
720,000
180,000
0
135,000
90,000
450,000
45,000
45,000
45,000
225,000
720,000
180,000
the cost
72
3
6
16
4
0
3
2
10
1
1
1
5
16
4
the num-
Damage / loss of medical equipment )( X-ray machines
4,896,000
102,000
238,000
612,000
272,000
68,000
442,000
68,000
612,000
0
102,000
102,000
748,000
1,122,000
408,000
the cost
144
3
7
18
8
2
13
2
18
0
3
3
22
33
12
number
Damage / loss of medical devices )(laboratory devices
2,260,000
30,000
90,000
180,000
120,000
80,000
360,000
40,000
240,000
50,000
70,000
40,000
290,000
420,000
250,000
the cost
226
3
9
18
12
8
36
4
24
5
7
4
29
42
25
the
Damage / loss of furniture and accessories
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
governorate
The cost of the damaged furniture and medical supplies is $ 10,000.,the cost of the loss of medical laboratory equipment is $ 34,000), the cost of the loss of medical equipment and surgical radiation is $ 45,000, the cost of the loss of Intensive Care devices is $ 50,000 and the cost of providing basic drugs is $ 15,000
number
the cost
run out of the essential drugs
Table attached No. (6): The health sector shows the number of health facilities that have been damaged in the affected provinces by the type of damage
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
6
9
13
4
5
1
-
2
8
7
6
103
2,472,000
6
1
7
35
1,470,000
1,899,300
6,331
100
500
251
40
80
400
200
3,000
40
625
300
400
275
120
Training volunteers in first aid bag with a first-aid kit
4,158,000
99
10
15
fixed 13
4
2
4
8
17
2
10
10
8
5
4
Medical convoys (providing primary )health care
7,818,000
18,460
1,365
381
645
-
500
ـــ
13,100
70
1,248
-
425
300
426
orphanages
200,000
4
1
1
1
-
1
establishing physical therapy centers
31,020,000
3,102
356
251
1,050
10
-
-
1,100
-
121
-
122
62
30
Travelling abroad
573,240
4,777
100
114
618
30
150
-
3,200
10
338
80
32
90
15
whale cheer
8,587,200
7,156
189
213
1,222
25
300
ـــ
120
3,100
30
493
474
60
120
810
guardianship for a person with disability
10,509,000
38
3
6
4
1
-
-
3
12
-
4
-
1
1
3
Surgical camps
10,509,000
21,018
3,112
2,917
105
450
240
10,079
5
1,382
369
201
1,890
268
Physical injury
1,512,000
18
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
3
1
1
The cost
Total
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwa
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah 2
Abyan 1
Al Bayda
Ibb 1
1
governorate
Fever (malaria, )dengue
The cost of spraying campaigns is $ 48,000, the cost of treating physical injuries through the surgical camps is $ 500 for each case, the cost of the guardianship of a person with disability is $100 per month for one year, and the cost of wheelchair is $120, and the cost of traveling abroad is $10,000, the cost of establishing a surgical center is $ 50,000, the cost of orphan guardianship is $ 600 for one year by 6 times, the cost of a medical convoy is $ 42,000, the cost of training volunteers on first aid with first-aid kit is $ 300 per trainee, the cost of implementing awareness and psychotherapy campaigns is $ 24,000, and the cost of buying an ambulance is $ 42,000
6
3
10
ـــ
17
8
17
1
1
Awareness and psychotherapy campaigns
The destruction of ambulances
Table attached No. (8): The private health sector shows health interventions contained in the supervisor form
Chapter Nine|| Appendices
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages 165 Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
166
350,000
930,000
190,000
87
32
13
33
0
1,450
0
0
0
117
233
197
41
2,255
522,000
192,000
78,000
198,000
The Report of the Multi-Sector Survey to Assess Damages Caused by the Current Crisis in Yemen
0
8,700,000
0
0
0
702,000
1,398,000
1,182,000
246,000
13,530,000
8,190,000
130,000
0
110,000
1,090,000
4,500,000
0
140,000
80,000
290,000
290,000
819
19
93
35
13
0
11
109
450
0
14
8
29
29
9
Totally
18,015,660
263,700
915,780
514,530
341,700
94,410
1,505,160
909,990
7,776,120
21,060
586,440
619,170
739,860
1,691,550
2,036,190
The cost of training
60,052,200
879,000
3,052,600
1,715,100
1,139,000
314,700
5,017,200
3,033,300
25,920,400
70,200
1,954,800
2,063,900
2,466,200
5,638,500
6,787,300
The cost of loans
120,104
1,758
6,105
3,430
2,278
629
10,034
6,067
51,841
140
3,910
4,128
4,932
11,277
13,575
The number of affected workers and employees
Interventions for workers and employees
2
132,000
6
1
66,000
396,000
2
1
the number
132,000
66,000
the ost
Buying ploughs
480,000
120,000
100,000
200,000
60,000
the ost
240
60
50
100
30
the number
Aid for farmers
The agriculture sector
1,180,000
200,000
60,000
280,000
200,000
200,000
80,000
160,000
the cost
590
100
30
140
100
100
40
80
the number
Concessional Loans
40
16,000
295
728,500
-
-
118,000
-
-
173,500
50,000
-
30
20
180,000
102,000
126,000
22,500
-
12,000
8,000
65
60
24,000
26,000
20
8,000
-
74,500
24,000
-
-
-
60
-
-
the cost
-
the number
-
the cost
245,000
408
2,914
694
200
9,702,000
-
-
-
2,185,400
2,401,000
2,793,000
294,000
504
720
1,705,200
-
78,400
-
-
-
the cost
90
298
the number
990
223
245
285
25
30
174
8
the number
Fishing boats
Training in veterinary Buying animals
the fisheries sector
Grazing sector
اإلجمالي
Marib
Lahij
Aden
Shabwah
Socotra
Hadramout
Hajjah
Taiz
Al Mahrah
Dhale
Hodeidah
Al Bayda
Abyan
Ibb
Governorate
90,000
52
312,000
the ost
partially
the ost
the affected shops
workers and employees sector
Table attached No. ( 7): Interventions in livelihood support sector from supervisor form
Chapter Nine|| Appendices