The Irish Volunteer - Volume 2 - Number 41

Page 1

THE

·EDlTED BY EOIN MAC NEILL. Vo l. 2 ,

I

No, 141

(New Series).

NOTES.

A letter signed " Trav Her " in the Jrislt J'i111es makes some remarkal.Jle statements. The writer poses as a strong oppo1ient of militari ·m \1·hen it is German militarism. Like man;. others of the same school, he quite unconsciously endorse. the whole militarist programme, forgetting that any recognition of the right of militarism to dominate nations is a condonation of militarism in .general. If militarism is allo~ed to be a main factor in international relations, then the better organised and more. efficient militarism is worthi of the highest esteem. To my mind, such a doctr ine of ,~,oriel politics is sheer barbarism, whether it is 'p~aised by Thomas Carlyle, preached by Bernhardi , or accepted by a . co~respondent of the Jrisl1 Times.

SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 18,

191~ .

lm]_Jer ial arts into the ·notion that their ad,·antage li es in sectarian strife, but they are not deluded so .far as to believe in the rectitude of British Imperiali sm. Accordingly thi s "Traveller " has found that, " if the); arc nu t exactly Pro-Germau s, tfiey arc not enthusia st ic over the prese~t 11-a.r. " H e also" was mor~ than arnazed to find that s01~1e Irish Ca~holics in the east of Ireland were Pro-German in their sympathies." H e deprecates thi s attitude, because " Germany n~i .the r ]o,·es nor admires them, and, if they come under h~r militari st heel, their lot will be a hard and I.Jitter one." Perha]_Js, if thi · traveller was less of a tra~·ell c r, if he \·vas more at home in Ireland, if hi s uut- · look on Ireland was less fore ign, if he '.could see the inward and · the outward design s and consequences of English rule in Ireland since ' the Union, he would not be so much amazed .

*

*

,

Price One Penny.

experience has forbidden them t~ be ProEngJish, will naturally at !)resent be p roGerman. But there is a .saner bel ief abroad in Ireland , and a sounder pu rpose; and we may tha nk God that Ireland, am id tb is present orgy uf militari sm, is shaping her resoh·e to be no ma,,;ter·s l.Jondma id and no em1) ire·s ga!S- . way. I

,

-l(·

·K

.

•*

T u "L'b 1· erta;; ·D.eo ju,·aute,"--the ausw:er is, nut till this time . Another correspondent writes to ask me whether _it is consistent with J rish ~ ationalist principles to enter the Civil Serv ice under the Brit ish Governme1Jt. I make no pr~te'.1ce to be the keeper of other people'spr_mctpks, and ' wheu a question of principle anses, it is clea rly every 1rni.n's duty to decide how his own conduct is to be governed. It is clear e nough to me that an Irish l\ ationalist ought not to make h~m self the servant and instrument of. <tny , G01·ernment · · · purposes · · · . for

"I ha,:e lived in Germany," be· wr'ites, "an.cl ·X· know what the typical German thinks. I in- which a1:c direct.ly cuun ected with keeiJin•t b * "A Jew days agu, " says tbi,,; curreopundenl, ,·ariabl y · fuunJ .that, while the Ge rman kLtcd I rcland in a state of ~ubjugatlon. H e ouuht b " 1 asked a very strong Irish Nationalist why the English' with a _perfect batreci aud rather nut tu accept, a position in which be must expe.c t be did not go in for an Irish RepulJlic "-the liked the S~o tch, be utterly desp ised the · tu be required to usc hi s uwn IJOdi ly and mental v.<.:r,y strong Nationa.list to whom su treasona\Jlc Catholic 1rish-·they wert: lazy, dirty, behind pu1n;rs in personal conflict \1iith his feJlo,~­ , . a question was propounded was naturally not the times, superstitiou" and very litt le irl cuuntrymen in their rightful efforts to keep the one of the not . very strong new Imperialist advance of_ primitive savag~s . " Did it e\-er Nat ion aliYe, and to make •it free, prosperous, Grand- " antl his brief answer was, ' Because oc.c ur to ·our traveller to inquire how, where, and honoured. ~f he fiuds that be is required J. fea r Germany.' .My friend mea1)t that if · through what channel the typical Ger!llan, .to act in that way, it i~ h is duty to refuse. He Englani gave up Jrel~nd, Germany. would li,·ing in Germany, acqui1:ed the~·e notions of ought. not to accept duties that involve ' spying seize the Gateway of the Great West, as I once the Irish? Whose interest has it ueen to keep and reporting on the rightful political actioi:is heard a Germ.an characterise Ireland. And he before the world this. picture of the lazy Irish, of hi s fellow-countfymen, applying the antithe dirty Iri sh, the backward Irish the national act ion of anti-national laws to them was right ." ' ·X· superstitious Irish? Whose policy and what or us.ing force or .oppressi911 to suppress their' ·X· ·X· Su, according Lu' tbi~ ant<iguni,,;t uf militaiiolll pol icy was· thi s pictun; of the Iri ·b qlcu la Led . rightful acti1 ity in the National inte~es t. lf (when it is German nulitarism), the right and· tu ju ~tif y lo the minds uf Contineutal peoples? . his duties an; of a vague and general cha'~·acter , natural function of Ireland is to be a gateway Of course, ju~t now the lazy, dirt'y, backward, I.Jut if he is called upon to do anyt[)ing· in parfor this or that Empire, to be held l.Jy force and su]_Jerst itiou s Irish have 1.Jecome the valiant ticular that he knows to be anti-.:\ ational , be only given up to force . Ireland is to be the Iri sh. will refuse to do that thin o· o* * * victim and the tool of one milit~rism or another. * * If most Irishmen are not absolutely and She i~ al ways to stand in fear of England or Apa~t from - governmental work which · Germany or whateYer other Empire ·may be in recklessl y Pro-German or Pro-Turki sh: .it is necessarily or . usually involves anti-N<1ti~nal the ascendant at the time . H er ·choice is not the fault of English domination up t~ da.tc. activity un the part of tl10se engaged· ·upon it, alway· to be between two lo,·etess ma~ters, the Our country 'has beei1 de]_Jopulated, our people ·_!here arc other cla~scs uf gU'l·ernmcntal ·wu;k <..:hoice that Deirdre rejected, choos ing death in degraded, our industries destroyed; .an which· are necess<uy for the transactiu.n uf preference. If Engl~1id holds Ireland as her incredible plunder, mounting to thousands of public business under any political system. It gateway, can any intelligent man be surprised millions sterling, has been exhorted from us; is true that, while the .system . in existence is to find that Irishmen who are not captives .in we have ~en set at each other's throa:ts. If anti-National, every pers.o n employed . in its soul look on English denunciations of H ell itself were to j:urn against English policy, administration helps in'. a way to keep it in us, we might be pardoned for as·1it is known existence. Bu.t th.e -same may be said of other militarism as rank hypocrisy? taking the side of Hell. Those Irishmen who people not in goYernment employme:nt. · In * * The testimony of thi · conversing and con- surrender to the prospect that the wixld must making use· of the machinery of governThe remain at the -mercy'of militarism, may-believe ment, · they help in a way to maintain versant "Traveller " lS remarkable. section, of Irishm.~n who have put Sir Edw:ird . that Ire] 3.Ild, like Deirdre; has no choice except the· existing system ._ ,E veryone who t'akes Carson in power are unfortunately deluded by between t\~O masters, and suth people, if

to


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.