Hydroponics vs Aquaponics

WHAT’S IN A WORD HYDROPONICS vs

Researched by Kelly-Ann Scrase

One could easily be forgiven for thinking that hydroponics and aquaponics are interchangeable and that they both refer to growing plants using water rather than soil – after all the word 'hydro' means water and the word 'aqua' means water. The truth, however, may sound a bit fishy, but they are actually two different but equally fascinating systems of cultivating plants.

Most people are probably more familiar and have probably seen some form of hydroponics – a gardening method that allows for plants to be grown without the use of soil. It uses only chemicals and water and is most commonly used to grow plants such as lettuces, tomatoes and other greens.

Hydroponics works by growing plants in a water-based solution that is rich in nutrients. The roots of the plants are suspended directly in the nutrient-rich water, which gives them access to the substances they need to grow. At the same time, the remainder of the plants has access to oxygen, which allows the growing process to continue with ease.

The main advantage of hydroponics is that of consistent quality and high yields. There are many different types of hydroponic systems, which determine how the water flows and reaches the plants.

Aquaponics on the other hand involves growing fishes and plants together within the same environment. This totally natural system is a sustainable process.

When you use this growing method, the waste from the fishes is converted directly into nitrates by the surrounding bacteria. These nitrates are used as food for the plants before the remaining water is returned to the fishes free from harmful contaminants, which creates an effective and efficient growth cycle that is referred to as the nitrogen cycle.

While accumulation of the waste eventually becomes toxic for the fishes inside of the tank, the bacteria that is introduced to the water converts the waste into helpful nitrates before any of the fish can be adversely affected. The aquaponics farming and growing method is fairly straightforward and as with hydroponics, there are many different systems that can be used.

Both methods can be effective and beneficial depending on the application for which they are used. However, certain plants do grow more effectively with one method or the other.

1. COST OF CHEMICAL NUTRIENT:

Hydroponic systems require the use of chemical nutrients, which can be very costly, whereas the fish feed that is used in an aquaponics system is much more affordable.

2. RETAIN NUTRIENT SOLUTION:

The high concentration of nutrients in the water used for hydroponics can become toxic to the plants. As a result, water needs to be disposed of regularly. In an aquaponics system, nitrogen is perfectly balanced in the water, which means that the water should never have to be replaced.

THE DIFFERENCE AQUAPONICS VS HYDROPONICS

3. PRODUCTIVITY:

Aquaponics gardening is slightly more efficient and has higher yield when compared to a hydroponics system. 4. EASE OF MAINTENANCE: Aquaponics systems require 5. ORGANIC GROWTH: The environment in a hydroponic system is manmade, whilst an aquaponics system is designed to replicate a completely natural ecosystem, which makes very little maintenance. On the other hand, the electrical conductivity of the water in a hydroponic system will need to be checked on a daily basis. the system organic.

SIMILARITIES BETWEEN AQUAPONICS VS HYDROPONICS

1. GROWING SEASON: Both of these systems are known for having lengthy growing seasons when compared to traditional growing methods. Because these systems are typically placed indoors, you will be able to grow plants all throughout the year.

2. LESS ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT: Because plants are grown indoors with aquaponic and hydroponic systems, there are very little weed and pest issues to deal with, therefore less pesticides need to be used.

3. FASTER GROWTH: Because both systems don't use soil, they are able to grow at a rate of 30-50 percent faster than their traditional soil-based counterparts. This quick growth occurs because the plants have access to a higher amount of oxygen.

4. HIGHER YIELDS: Plants grown in a hydroponic system or aquaponics system yield around 30-40 percent more than other growing methods.