1001SovSecr17_2020_SV by antinoob-2020

)\(anyetACI HO···

KaK HanMcaTb KonneKTMBHYIO lKano6y M IteM Ha OTnM~taeTCR OT 06bi114HOM? Ecm1 CHTYa4HS! HapywaeT He TOilbKO eawH nHY· Hble npaea, HO 111 npaea .QpyrHx rpa>K.QaH , HanpH· Mep coce,Qel'i , TO see noTepneewHe MOrYT o6b· e,QHHHTbCS! Ill HanHCaTb KOilileKTHBHYIO >Kano6y.

y goH'<f1\"-

KaK HanMcaTb )l(ano6y B opraHM3a"'MIO MnM opraHbl BnaCTM? 3aKOHQAaTenb He yCTaHaBilHBaeT oco6ol'i cpopMbl AilS! HanHCaHHS! >Ka1106, B TOM YHCile Ill npH nO,QaYe HX B rocy.QapCTBeHHble 111 MYHH4HnailbHble opraHbl BilaCTH. 0,QHaKO Cyll.\eCTByiOT 06Ll.\He Tpe60BaHHS! K OcpOpMne· HHIO 6yMar TaKoro pQAa, KOTOpble cne.Qyer co6nto,QaTb npH Be.QeHHH ,Qenoeol'i nepenHCKH:

• np11 Hani1GaHI111 TeKCTa >KM06bl Henb3s:l 11CnOnb30BaTb Hel..leH3ypHble Bblpa>KeHI1s:!, >KaproHHYIO neKCI1KY, a TaK>Ke OCKOp611TenbHble Bblpa>KeHI1s:l B a,Qpec KOro-n1160. 06pall.\eHI1s:l, He OTBeYaiOLl.\11e npe.Qbs:!BneHHbiM Tpe60BaHI1s:IM, MOryT 6b1Tb ocrasneHbl 6eJ paccMorpeHI1R KpoMe roro, OHI1 nl1waIOT ompas11rens:~ npasa CCblnarbcs:~ Ha co6niO.QeHI1e .QOCy.Qe6Horo nop51.QKa yperyn11posaHI151 cnopos. • TeKcr .QOn>KeH 6b1Tb naKOHI14eH 11 TOYeH. He cne.QyeT

KonneKTI1BHolil Ha3b1Baercs:~ n106a51 >Kano6a , s Koropolil npereH31111 BbiCKa3biBaer He O.Q11H, a HecKonbKO 4enoseK, 4bl1 npasa 6blnl1 HapyweHbl s paMKax O.QHOVI (o6Ll.lelil) c11rya1..11111 . 06pa3el..l Hanl1caHI1s:l KonneKTI1BHolil >Kano6bl Mano 4eM om114aerc51 or Hanl1caHI1s:l >Kano6bl o6bi4Holil (11HA11B11.QyanbHolil). Pa3HI11..1 a 3aKnl04aercs:~ n11wb s TOM , 4TO KonneKTI1BHas:~ >Kano6a .QOn>KHa orpa>KaTb o6Ll.lee MHeHI1e scex rpa>K,QaH no e.QI1HOMY sonpocy, a raK>Ke oni1CbiBaTb see cny411swe ecs:~ c Ka>K.QbiM 113 norepnesw11x. nocne Hani1CaHI151 npereH31111 see n111..1a, yKa3aHHble s KonneKTI1BHOiil >Kano6e, .QOn>KHbl nocrasi1Tb ni14Hble no.Qn11CI1 , Koropble 6y.Qyr BblcrynaTb s Ka4ecrse no.Qrsep>K,QeHI1s:l corna c11 s:~ 11x c 06CTOs:!TenbCTBaMI1, 113nO>KeHHbiMI1 B >Kano6e.

'ITO e~e He06XOAMMO 3HaTb o lKano6ax? CaMoe sa>KHoe - o 4eM HI1KaK Henb3s:l 3a6biBaTb! ocrasns:~Tb y ce6s:~ sropolil 3K3eMnns:~p >Kano6bl. TYT TaiOKe Hy>KHO cKa3aTb, YTO ecnH Bbl no,Qaere >Kano6y IlHYHO, TO eCTb CaMOCTOS!TeilbHO OTHOCHTe ee B npHeMHYIO AOil>KHOCTHOrO 111114a 11111111 opraHH·

paCTS!rHBaTb CBOIO >Ka1106y Ha HecKOilbKO IlHCTOB: MaK·

3a4HIO, TO Ha BaWeM 3K3eMnnstpe ,QOil>KHa 6b1Tb

CHMailbHO C>KaTO OnHWHTe CHTYa4HIO, 3aOCTpS!S! BHHMa·

OCTaBileHa OTMeTKa 0 TOM , KOr,Qa Ill KTO npHHS!Il

Hille TOilbKO Ha TeX MOMeHTaX, KOTOpble ,QeMCTBHTeilbHO

He 11cnonb3ylilre B CBOei/i peYI1 Bblpa>KeHI1ill, KOTOpble MO>KHO rpaKTOBaTb paJni14HbiMI1 cnoco6aMI1, KOTOpble 11Mel0r nepeHocHoe JHa4eHI1e 11 r. n. Bee cyll.lecrseHHble ,[11151 paccMorpeHI151 cnopa ,[laHHble ,[IOn>KHbl 6b1Tb ,[IOCTOBepHbiMI1 (.QaTbl , 411Gna, HOMepa, a.Qpeca 11 r . .Q.). • 8HI1MaTenbHO Gne,[II1Te Ja TeM , KOMy Bbl a,Qpecyere CBOIO >Kano6y. 3TO MO>KeT 6b1Tb pyKOBO,[II1Tenb OT,[Iena, opraHI13aL\1111, n116o Ha.Q30pHbllil opraH. Or npas11nbHOCTI1 Bbl6opa a,Qpecara 3aBI1CI1T He TOnbKO onepaTI1BHOCTb paCCMOTpeHI1s:l >KM06bl, HO 11 Ka4eCTBO TaKOro paCCMOTpeHI1R KpoMe TOro, He cro11r 3a6blsarb, 4TO scer.Qa 11 se3,[1e .Qelilcrsyer HernacHbllil npi1HL\11n OYepe,QHOCTI1. 3TO 3Ha411T, 4TO, Hanp11Mep, Ha npo.QaBI..Ia He o6513aTenbHO >Kanosarbcs:~ cpa3y .QI1peKTopy roprosolil cer11 - .QOCTaTOYHO 6y.QeT HanpaBI1Tb npereH31110 a.QMI1H11Crparopy 11n11 ynpasn5110Ll.leMy Mara311HOM. • Cne.Q11Te 3a rpaMOTHOCTbiO pe411, co6n10.Qalilre npas11na CI1HTaKCI1Ga 11 nyHKryaL\1111. rpaMOTHas:l peYb - O,[IHO 113 Hal16onee sa>KHbiX ycnos11Vi np11 se.QeHI111 .Qenosolil nepeni1CKI1 . Ba>KHbl AilS! eepHol'i 04eHKH cnyYHBwerocst.

l:iP.jiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~

sawy npeTeHJHIO. 3ro Heo6xO.QI1MO no ABYM np11411HaM: BO-nepBbiX, C 3TOV! ,[laTbl 6y.QeT OTCYI1TbiBaTbCs:l CpOK Afls:l OTBeTa; 80-BTOpbiX, 3TO CnY>KI1T np51MbiM no.Qrsep>K,QeHI1eM cpaKTa nonyYeHI1s:l npereH31111 a.QpecaroM . Ecn11 Bbl ornpasns:~ere npereH31110 noYrolil , TO He06XO,[II1MO COXpaHI1Tb KBI1TaHL\1110 06 OTnpaBKe ni1CbMa 11n11 .QO>K,QaTbCS'I, noKa saM sepHeTC51 yseAOMneHI1e o ero spy4eHI111. Cne.QYIOLl.lee, 4TO sa>KHO 3HaTb, - 3TO CpOK OTBeTa Ha npeTeH31110. 0H 3aBI1CI1T OT TOro, KOMY Bbl Hanpasn51eTe npeTeH31110 11 B CBS'1311 c KaK11M HapyweHI1eM . Ecn11 npereH311s:l no.Qna.Qaer no.Q .Qei/icrs11e 3aKoHa o 3all.\11Te npas norpe611renelil (Hanpi1Mep, ecn11 Bbl ryn11n11 HeKaYecrseHHbllil rosap 11 ornpasn51ere npereH31110 npo.QaBLIY), ro cpoK Afl51 orBeTa Ha npeTeH31110, B COOTBeTCTBI111 C ,[lei/iCTBYIOLl.\11M 3aKoHO.QarenbCTBOM, 6y.Qer paseH 10 .QHS'IM. Ecn11 >Ke Bbl o6pall.laerecb s opraHbl rocy.QapcrseHHOiil snacr11 11n11 MecrHoro caMoynpasneHI1s:l, ro s .Qelilcrs11e scrynaer cpe.QepanbHbllil 3aKOH «0 nop51.QKe paccMorpeHI151 o6pall.\eHI1ill rpa>K,QaH Pocc11illcKolil <l>e.QepaL\1111», s COOTBeTCTBI111 C KOTOpbiM OTBeT ,[IOn>KeH 6b1Tb ,QaH He

no3,[1Hee, 4eM Yepe3 30 .QHelil c MoMeHra nonyYeHI151 o6pall.\eHI1R

rAe B3.RTb o6pa3el.\ )l(an06bl Ha 'IMHOBHMKa? AaHHa~ ~ano6a cocrasn~erc~ s cso6o,QHOil1 cpopMe, KpoMe roro, Ka~ .Qblill cnyYaill o6pall.!eHVI~ VIH.QVIBVI.QYaneH, no3TOMY o6pa3el..l ~ano6bl Ha YVIHOBHVIKa B IIIHTepHeTe Bbl Bp~,Q flVI Haiii,Qere. EcnVI npVI cocrasneHVIVI ~a no6bl y sac B03HVIKator npo6neMbl, o6parV~recb 3a noMOil.!biO e cocrasneHVIVI K npocj:leCCVIOHaflbHbiM IOpVICTaM . KaK npaaMnbHO nOAaTb )l(an06y Ha 'IMHOBHMKa? no,Qarb csoe o6pall.!eHVIe Bbl MO~ere .QBYM~ cnoco6aMVI : nVIYHO nV~6o no noYre. 8 nepsoM cnyYae saM noHa,Qo6~rc~ ,QBa 3K3eMnn~pa ~ano6bl. O.QVIH 3K3eMnn~p Bbl no,Qaere s KaHI..Ien~pVIIO, BTOpoi/1, C HOMepOM VI ,Qaroi/1 sxo.Q~Il.!ero ,QOKyMeHra, ceraere~ y sac Ha pyKax. EcnVI Bbl xorV~re HanpaBVITb ~ano6y no noYre, ro He 3a6y,QbTe B3~Tb yse,QOMneHVIe: 3TO rapaHTVI~ roro, YTO sawa ~ano6a nona,Qer s KaHI..Ien~pVIIO VI 6y,Qer 3ape-

KyAa *anoaaTbCR Ha HeA06pOCOBeCTHOrO 'IMHOBHMKa? BHe 3aBVICVIMOCTVI or roro, KaKoill VIMeHHO roccny~all.!VIill HapywV~n eawVI npasa, npVI no,QaYe ~ano6bl cyll.!ecrsyer yHV~sepcanbHOe npaBVIno: o6pall.!aTbC~ cne,Qyer no sepTVIKanVI snacrVI Hasepx. To ecrb, s nepsy10 oYepe.Qb saM Heo6xo,QVIMO no,QaTb ~ano6y Henocpe,QcrseHHOMY pyKOBO,QVITento He,Qo6pocosecrHoro roccny~all.!ero . Yall.!e scero 3roro ,QocraroYHO ,Qn~ 6blcrporo peweHVI~ npo6neMbl. O.QHaKo, ecnVI o6pall.!eHVIe K HaYanbCTBY He npVIHeCnO HY~HbiX pe3yflbTaTOB, Bbl MO~ere no,QaTb ~ano6y s nepsy10 Bblwecro~ll.!YIO VIHcraHI..\VIIO VI ,Qanee no eepTVIKanVI .

KaK cocTaBMTb *ano6y npe>K,Qe scero, XOTenOCb 6bl HanOMHMTb OYeBMAHYIO MCTMHy: AflSI Toro, YT06bl sawa ~ano6a 6bsna paccMoTpeHa, oHa AOn~Ha rV~crpV~posaHa. , 6b1Tb npaBMflbHO oQ>opMneHa. K co~aneHVIIO , MHOrVIe o6 3TOM 3a6blsator, VI e pe3ynbrare o6pall.!eHVI~. HanV~caHHble Hepa360pYVIBbiM noyepKoM, co,Qep~all.!VIe xaMCKVIe Bblpa~eHVI~ VlnVI yrpo3bl nonpocry ocratorc~ 6e3 orsera. no3TOMY croVIT npo~BVITb ysa~eHVIe KroMy, KTO 6y,Qer YVITaTb sawe o6pall.!eHVIe: nVIWVITe aKKyparHo VI pa36opYVIBO, 6e3 noMapoK, peKOMeH,Qyerc~ V~cnonb3oearb 6yMary cpopMara A4 . EcnVI ecrb B03MO~HOCTb, pacneYaraillre reKcr ~ano6bl Ha KOMnbtorepe. 6y.QbTe naKOHVIYHbiMVI, nyYwe scero, ecnVI TeKCT 6y,QeT He CflVIWKOM ,QflVIHHbiM, OnTVIManbHbli/1 pa3Mep ~an06bl - 2-3 CTpaHVII..\bl. IIITaK, C Yero CTOVIT HaYaTb cocrasneHVIe ~ano6bl Ha YVIHOBHVIKa? HaYaTb croMT c JanonHeHMSI «wanKM» JaSisneHMSI. 8 Helit He06XOAMMO yKaJaTb cneAYIOil.!Me AaHHble: • TOYHOe Ha3BaHVIe yype~eHVI~ , B KOTOpoe Bbl o6pall.!aerecb; • <t>IIIO ,QOfl~HOCTHOrO flVII..\a , Ha VIM~ KOTOporo Bbl Ha-

npasn~ere ~ano6y ;

• BaWVI ,QaHHble (cpaMVIflVI~ , VIM~, OTYeCTBO, KOHTaKTHbli/1 renecj:lOH , nOYTOBbli/1 a,Qpec, no KOTOpOMy Bbl XOTVITe nonyYVITb nVICbMeHHblill orser). • Aanee cne,Qyer Henocpe,QcrseHHO reKcr sawei/1 ~a no6bl. 0YeHb ea~Ho He ,Qasarb sonVI 3MOI..IVI~M! Bawe 3a~sneHV~e ,Qon~Ho 6b1Tb HanV~caHo KparKo VI no cyll.!ecrsy. • Yro croVIT yKa3aTb s recre ~ano6bi? • 0nVICaHVIe ,QeiiiCTBVIi/1 ,QOfl~HOCTHOrO flVII..\a, KOTOpble Bbl CYVITaere HenpaBOMepHbiMVI; • AaHHble ,QOn~HOCTHoro DVII..Ia, HapywV~swero 3aKoH (cpaMVIflVI~, ,QOfl~HOCTb VI T. ,Q.); • Ba~Hble ,QeranVI npoV13owe,Qwero (HoMepa ,QOKYMeHros, ,QaTbl VIr. .Q.); • CraTbVI, no,Q Koropble no,Qna,Qaer sawa CVITYai..IVI~; • CraTbVI 3aKOHa, comaCHO KOTOpbiM Bbl XOTVITe npVIsneYb YVIHOBHVIKa K OTBeTCTBeHHOCTVI. • 3asepweHVIeM ~ano6bl ,Qon~Ho craTb no~enaHVIe cKopeillwero paccMorpeHVI~ VI no~cHeHVI~ cV~ryai..IVIVI s

CoAeP*aHMe *ano6bl B 11106oilt opraHI13al..ll111 KH~<~ra AOJt)I(Ha HaxoA11TbC.R Ha s~<~AHOM AJl.R noTpe6~<~Te11eill ·M ecTe . npe,QOCTaSI1Tb ee ,[\011>KHbl no nepSOMY Tpe6osaHI110. Ec1111 ee npe,QOCTaSI-11111 s sawe no11b3osaH~<~e no STOpOMY Tpe6osaHI110 , TO 3TO TO>Ke

A011>KHO 6b1Tb oTpa>KeHo s saweilt >Ka11o6e. 06bpe>t<Ae "!eM o6pallJ,aTbC.R c >t<ano6olil B Poc-

.RCH.RTb KOMy-111160 , 3aYeM OHa saM S,Qpyr no-

noTpe6HaA30p, HY>KHO 3anacntcb AOKa3aTenbHOiil 6a30H. 1.1 nOMO>KeT BaM B 3TOM >Kano6Ha.R KHHra.

o6.R3aHbl npe,Qb.RS11.RTb cso11 AOKyMeHTbl. GaMy

Ha,Q061111aCb, Sbl He o6.R3aHbl. TeM 6o11ee He >Ke 3ani1Cb .CTOI1T C,Qe11aTb KaK MO>KHO 6011ee no,Qpo6Hoill . Ho He CTO~<~T war 3a waroM 11311a-

Tpe6oaaHM.R K *ano6Hoit KHMre

raTb npo~<~Jowe,Qwee, T011bKO CyTb. HanpHMep:

HacTO.RllJ,a.R KHHra >t<ano6 H npeAflO>KeHHiil nonHoCTbiO npoHyMepoBaHa, npowHypoBaHa H c ne"'aTbiO

«npoAaBe~ (<1>.1.1.0.) He o6cny>t<Mn MeH.R B 00 "'aCOB 00 MHHyT. npH 3TOM 6blfl a6COfliOTHO

H3 cypry"'a. 3To AenaeTc.R Afl.R Toro, "'T06bl y HeAo6pocoBeCTHoro npoAaB~a He 6bmo co6na3Ha Bbl-

CB060AeH, a Ha npOCb6y YAeflHTb MHe BHM-

pBaTb HeyrOAHYIO CTpaHH~y. Bo3ne ne"'aTH AOfl>KHa CTO.RTb noAnHcb pyKOBOAHTen.R. BHyTpH TeTpaAH Ha OAHOM CTOpOHe - MeCTO Afl.R KOHTaKTOB H KOMMeHTapHeB 3AMHHHCTpa~HH, Ha Apyrolil- Afl.R caMolil >Kano6bl. BHeWHe TeTpa,QKa MO>KeT 6b1Tb Jli060i/t, HO rnaSHOe , "'T06bl OHa 6blfla OcpOpM11eHa OTSeTCTSeHHbiM 111-li..IOM. 8 CaMOM Ha"'a11e KHI1rl1, Ha nepsoi/t CTpaHI11..1e, ,Q011>KHa 6b1Tb noMellJ,eHa 11HCTPYK1..111.R. 3a,QaYa 3TOill 11HCTpyKl~l111 - nOMOYb Ye110SeKy, KOTOpbii/t peWI-111 snepSble SOCn011b30SaTbC.R KH~<~roill . TaM >Ke AOfl>KHbl 6b1Tb yKa3aHbl Tene~OHbl Ha"'aflbCTBa, a TaK>Ke rocTOprHHCneK~HH , AenapTaMeHTa noTpe6pbiHKa H ycnyr ropoAa, aAMHHHCTpa~HH paliloHa H ropOAa. To eCTb 11MeHHO TeX opraHI13al..ll1ill, S KOTOpble Ha 3TY CaMyiO cp11pMy MO>KHO no>Ka11osaTbC.R. HeKoTopble AYMaiOT, YTO KH~<~ra OT3blsos - 3TO TaKa.R TeTpa,QKa S KlleTOYKY (111111 S 1111HeeYKy, KOMY KaK 6o11bwe Hpas~<~TC.R). Ha caMoM ,Qe11e - 3TO o¢~<~1..111a11bHblill AOKyMeHT. 111, KaK 11106oilt o¢~<~ll~<~a11bHblill ,QOKyMeHT, OHa nO,Q11e>KI1T per11CTpa1..11111 , KOHeYHO, np11 ycnos1111, YTO 3TO npasl111bHa.R KH~<~ra . B npoT~<~SHOM c11yYae - 3TO nOSOA AJl.R o6pallJ,eHI1.R S KOHTp01111py10W,11e opraHbl. npaSI111bHO OcpOpM11eHHYIO KHI1ry >Ka1106 HI1KTO He 11MeeT npasa Sbl6pOCI1Tb . H11 0,[\I-IH npo,QaSel..l TOSapa 111111 yc11yr11 He noilt,QeT Ha 3TOT war. Be.Qb 3aMeH~<~Tb CTapyiO KHI1ry Ha HOSYIO MO>KHO T011bKO np11 n011HOM 3an011HeHI111 scex ee cTpaHI-11..1. Tpe6osaTb KH~<~ry OT3blsos 11 npeAJlO>KeH~<~ill Sbl MO>KeTe s 11106oilt opraH~<~3al..l~<~~<~ 111111 cf>~<~pMe, KOTopa.R oKa3blsaeT yc11yr11 111111 npo,QaeT Tosap.

MaHHe oTpearHpoBan ~pa3ol1: «MHe HeKorAa» . CaM >t<e B 3TO BpeM.R pa3roBapHBan no M06HnbHOMY Tene~oHy». YeM 6o11bWe no,Qpo6Hoill 11HcpOpMal..ll111 Sbl OCTaSI1Te , TeM 6011bWe waHc, YTO Mepbl 6y.QyT np~<~H.RTbl. KcTaT~<~, no 3aKOHY sac A011>KHbl o6ecneYI1Tb He T011bKO pyYKoill AJl.R Hani1CaHI1.R >Ka1106bl, HO 11 npe,QOCTaSI1Tb CT011 11 CTy11. He 1111WHI1M 6y,QeT npo,QeMOHCTpl-1posaTb 3TO csoe 3HaH~<~e He,Qo6pocosecTHbiM pa6oTHI1KaM cpl1pMbl.

CpoKM paccMoTpeHM.R *ano6bl CornacHo TOMY >Ke 3aKOHOAaTe11bCTsy pyKonpe,Qnp~<~.RTI1.R 111111 ero 3aMeCT~<~Te11b 06.R3aHbl paCCMOTpeTb SHeCeHHYIO S KH~<~ry >Kaso,Q~<~Te11b

1106y s TeYeH~<~e ,Qsyx AHeill . To ecTb Sbl snpase paCCYI1TbiSaTb Ha TO, YTO sawe 3aMe"'aHI1e YSI-1,Q.RT caMoe 6011bwee Yepe3 ,Qsa AH.R. 3aTeM s TeYeHI1e n.RTI-1 ,QHei/t OHI1 06.R3aHbl SHI1MaTe11bHO pa3o6paTbC.R s CyT~<~ sonpoca 11 np11H.RTb Mepbl K ycTpaHeHI-110 He,QOCTaTKOS 11 HapyWeHI1H S pa60Te npe,Qnpi1.RTI1.R . ,Qn.R Toro "'T06bl y3HaTb, 6blflH nH npHH.RTbl 3TH caMble Mepbl, AOcTaTO"'HO CHOBa noceTHTb npeAnpH.RTHe H 3arn.RHYTb B KHMry. Ha Apyrolil cTopoHe Toro flHCTa, rAe Bbl BbiCKa3aflH CBOe 3aMe"'aHHe, AOfl>KHa 6b1Tb OTMeTKa 0 npHH.RTbiX Mepax. KcTaTH, ecnH Bbl ocTaBHnM CBOM aApec, BaM 06.R3aHbl B n.RTHAHeBHbiM CpOK BbiCflaTb ellJ,e H nHCbMeHHbiM OTBeT. CTOI1T nOMHI1Tb, YTO 11HcpOpMai..II1.R , ocTas11eHHa.R saM~<~ s KH~<~re >Ka11o6, He .RS11.ReTC.R KOHcpi1,QeH1..111a11bHOill , n03TOMy SOCn011b30SaTbC.R e10 MO>KeT 111060i/t Ye110SeK, S3.RSWI1ill s pyK~<~ KH~<~ry. Ec1111 no KaK~<~M-TO np~<~Y~<~HaM Ha np~<~H.RT~<~e Mep no saweilt >Ka11o6e Tpe6yeTC.R 6011bWe speMeHI-1 , TO 06 3TOM TO>Ke ,[\011>KHbl Han~<~CaTb Ha o6opOTHOill CTOpOHe 1111CTa . 3TOT 6011bWI1ill CpOK HI-I S KOeM C11yYae He ,[\011>KeH npesbiWaTb n.RTHa.QI..IaTI-1 ,QHeill . Bee , YTO 6bi110 nepeY~<~C11eHo Sblwe, 3TO s 11,Qea11e. B pea11bHOCT~<~ >Ke 3aKOHbl 0 >Ka1106ax S KHI1re OT3biSOS 11 npe.Q110>KeH~<~ill pe,QKO co61110.QaiOTC.R . To eCTb Ha sawy >Ka11o6y MOryT KaK OTpear~<~posaTb, TaK 11 HeT. npas,Qa , c Ka>K,QbiM ro,QOM PYKOS0,[\11Te11eill, KOTOpble o6paw,aiOT SH~<~MaH~<~e Ha >Ka11o6bl noTpe6~<~Te11eilt, CTaHOSI1TC.R SCe 6011bWe 11 6011bWe.

>Kano6a Ha OTKa3 a npeAOCTaaneHMM )l(ano6MOM KHMrM Ya~e ecero ecrpeYaewbc~ npocro c orKa3oM npe,o,ocrae1.nb KH~ry. OrroeopK~ Moryr 6btrb caMbte pa3Hbte. Moryr CKa3arb, Yro oHa Ha per~crpa~~~ (:no caMa~ pacnpocrpaHeHHa~ np~Y~Ha orKa3a). V1Im, YrO HaYanbCrBO pew~nO C Het:i 03HaKOM~rb C~ 6n~}l{e , ~ renepb oHa y H~X (Hero, Hee) ,o,oMa. A Moryr eoo6~e H~Yero He cKa3arb, npocro n~w~rb eac 3aKOHHoro npaea. no 3aKoHy, Aa}l{e ecn111 KHIIIra HaXOAIIITCJ'I Ha periiiCTpal..lllllll, BaM 06J'I3aHbl BbiAaTb ABa niiiCTa 6yMarlll. Ha HIIIX He06XOAIIIMO 1113n0}1{111Tb CYTb CBOIIIX npeTeH3111H B ABYX 3K3eMnnHpax. OAIIIH 1113 niiiCTOB ocTaHeTCJ'I e Mara3111He. ,Qpyrolli 3K3eMnnHp, Ha KOTOpOM 6yAeT CTOJ'!Tb pocn111cb o nony~eHIIIIII }l{ano6bt, ocTaHeTcH y sac. B cnyYae nonHoro orKa3a e npe,o,ocraeneH~~ 3aKOHHOro npaea no}l{anoearbc~ ecrb ,o,ea Bbtxo,o,a. nepBbtt:i ~3 H~X - 3rO nOnbtrarbC~ Bbtt:ir~ Ha BbtWeCrOs:J~ero corpy,o,H~Ka ~ o6bs:JCH~rb c~rya~~IO . no-

~as:JCs:l

CnPAW~BAfl~-OTBE4AEM

A pa3Be KHHry OT3biBOB KTO-TO OTMeHSIA? MHe He noHpaelllnOCb o6cny}I{IIIBaHIIIe B napiiiKMaxepCKOH, BOnOCbl nOKpaCIIInlll npocTo 6e3o6pa3HO. ~ noTpe6oeana )f(ano6Hyto KHIIIry. Ho ee He Aanlll, cKa3anlll, ~T06bt "' YXOAIIIna. LITO AenaTb? Pa3Be KHIIIry OT3biBOB OTMeHIIInlll? ,QepeBHHKO En1113aeeTa, r. 3aeon>Kbe

ee He orMeHs:Jn. Ha npe,o,np~~r~s:~x o6cnynpocro He n106s:1r rex, Kro n~wer ry,o,a }l{ano6bl. V1 OrKa3 B npep,ocraeneH~~ KH~r~ Or3biBOB, KOHeYHO, He3aKOHeH . BaM ,D,OI1}1{Hbl ,o,aearb KH~ry or3bteoe ~ npeikKypaHr no nepeoMy rpe6oeaH~IO . (Crarbs:J 2 rnaebt 2 npae~n 6btrOBOfO o6cny}I{~BaH~s:l HaceneH~s:! . ) n1060t:i npop,aee~ o6s:~3aH ceoeepeMeHHO npe,o,ocraens:~rb norpe6~ren10 He06XO,D,~MYIO ~ ,D,OCroeepHyiO ~Hcj:lOpMa~~IO 0 roeapax (pa6orax, ycnyrax), o6ecneY~BatO~YIO B03MO}I{HOCrb ~x npae~nbHoro Bbt6opa. (Crarbs:J 10 3aKoHa Pet> «0 3a~~ re npae norpe6~renet:i». Ecn~ orKa3bteatarcs:~ ,o,arb KH~ry, Cro~r nonpoc~rb 6yMary, Yr06bt ~3J10}1{~rb rHeBHbte MbiCI1~ B }l{ano6e PYKOBO,D,Crey COMH~rei1bHOro canoHa.) npereH3~10 n~w~re e ,o,eyx 3K3eMnns:~pax . O,o,~H 3K3eMnns:~p (c ,o,arot:i , orMerKot:i o np~eMe ~ no,o,n~CbiO np~Hs:Jewero) ocraercs:~ y eac. Apyrot:i- e 3nononyYHOt:i nap~KMaxepcKot:i. Ecn~ OTKa3btBaiOTCs:l np~H~MaTb , MO}I{HO ornpae~Tb }l{ano6y 3aKa3HbiM n~CbMOM C yee,D,OMneH~eM . C BaM~ ,D,OI1}1{Hbl CBs:J3aTbCs:J ~n~ ornpae~Tb oreer no noYre e reYeH~e 10 ,D,Het:i. no3TOMY 06s:J3arenbHO OCTaBbTe CBO~ KOOp,D,~Ha Tbl. A ecn~ }l{ano6bt (oco6eHHO cepbe3Hbte ~ Heo,o,HoKparHbte) nona,o,yrcs:~ Ha rna3a KOHTpon~pyta~~M opraHaM, ro 3rO MO}I{eT CTaTb OCHOBaH~eM ,D,ns:J npoeepOK ~ WTpacpOB. no3rOMy, ecn~ BaM He ,D,aJ1~ KH~ry OT3biBOB, Bbl MO}I{ere no3BOH~rb e Pocnorpe6Ha,D,3op ~ coo6~~Tb o6 3TOM eon~ta~eM cpaKre. Ocrae~Tb coo6~eH~e MO}I{HO ~ Ha cat:ire cny}l{6bt Pocnorpe6Ha,D,3op. Her,

3r~X 06bs:JCHeH~t:i «~CYe3HYBWas:J» ~n~

HaXO,D,s:ly «HaYanbCrBa» KH~ra 06btYHO HaXO,D,~rCs:J . Ho He ecer,o,a. Ecn111 He Hawnacb, He CTOIIIT 6onbwe TepJ'ITb BpeMJ'I • HY)f(HO COCTaBnJ'ITb niiiCbMeHHYIO )f(ano6y Ha OTKa3 B npeAOCTaBneHIIIIII KHIIIrlll )f(ano6. 06H3aTenbHO e ABYX 3K3eMnnHpax. Cl>opMa COCTaBneHIIIJ'I npOIII3BOnbHaJ'I, HO CTOIIIT nOA· po6Hee OTMeTIIITb cl>aKTbl: IIIMeHa, BpeMJ'I, AaTy... 0AIIIH 1113 3K3eMnnHpOB OTAaeTCJ'I npeACTaBIIITento OpraHIII3al..lllllll, Ha KOTOpyto )f(anyeTeCb, BTO• polli, c noAniiiCbiO o nony~eHIIIIII )f(ano6bt, ocTaeTCH y sac. Ecn~ np~Hs:Jrb }l{ano6y orKa3bteatarcs:~, ee MO}I{HO ornpae~rb 3aKa3HbiM n~CbMOM C yee,D,OMneH~eM 0 epyYeH~~ . TaK}I{e cro~r OTnpae~rb KOn~IO }l{ano6bt ~ e AenapraMeHr norpe6~renbCKoro pbtHKa ropo,o,a, ~ e repp~rop~anbHoe ynpaeneH~e Pocnorpe6Ha,o,3opa. PaccMorperb eawy }l{ano6y ~ np~Hs:Jrb cooreercrey10~~e Mepbt 06s:J3aHbl B reYeH~e Mecs:~~a. BaM }l{e - Hanpae~rb no,o,po6Hbtt:i orYer o np~Hs:JrbtX Mepax. cne

Mory AH sepHyrb o6ysb npoAasuy, ecAH ee npoAaAH MHe 6e3 YeKa? Ha pbiHKe KYn111na o6yeb An~'~ pe6eHKa. HIIIKaKoro ~eKa MHe He Aanlll. "'epe3 HeAento 60TIIIHO~KIII nopeaniiiCb. Mory n111 "' eepHyTb o6yeb npoAaBI..IY? Ecn111 Aa, TO Ha ~To Mory pacc~HTbtBaTb: MHe eepHyT AeHbrlll 111n111 o6MeHHIOT Ha Apyryto napy? >Kapoea CeeTnaHa, r. HeaHoeo

H~Kro

}I{~BaH~s:J

Bbt MO}I{ere norpe6oearb KaK 3aMeHy roeapa, raK ~ B03Bpar ynnaYeHHOt:i CYMMbl. np~ 3rOM 06yBb C He,D,OCTaTKaM~ Bbl ,D,0I1}1{Hbl eepHyrb npo,o,as~y. Orcyrcre~e y sac Kaccosoro ~n~ roeapHoro YeKa He s:~ens:~ercs:~ ocHoeaH~eM ,D,ns:l OrKa3a.

I H~!~r~e~!!~~aK no>KanosaTbCJI B Pocnorpe6Ha3AOP 111 B KaKHX cny"laJIX 3TO AenaTb, KaKHe nonHOMO"'IIIJI ecTb y 3Toro rocyAapcTBeHHoro opraHa, 'ITO OH MO>KeT IIIHIIIL\IIIIIIpOBaTb • Y3HaMTe 1113 Hawero Marep111ana.

B KaKMX cny'laRx MOlKHO a PocnoTpe6HaA3op?

o6pa~aTiaCR

• np~-1 HapyweHL-11<1 3aKOHO,QaTe11bCTBa B ccpepe 3al1.11<1Tbl npas norpe61<1Te11eei (see, 'ITO Kacaerc~ Kyn111<1npo.Qa>KL-1, o6MeHa HeKaYecreeHHoro roeapa , o6c11y>KL-1saHL-1~. sceei c¢epbl yc11yr, BKiliOYa~ rypi<1CTL-1YecKL-1e) . • np~-1 HapyweHL-11<1 HOpM , KaCaiOL1.11<1XC~ CaHL-1TapH03n1<1,QeML-10110rl<1"leCKOro 611arono11yY1<1~ Hace11eHL-1~ . • np~-1 HapyWeHL-11<1 >KL-1111<1L1.1HbiX npas, HeKaYeCTBeHHbiX KOMMyHa11bHbiX yc11yr, 3aBbiWeHL-11<1 paCl,leHOK Ha KOMMyHa11bHble yc11yr1-1 co cropoHbl YK 1-1 TC>K, HenpaBL-111bHOM HaYL-1C11eHL-11<1 OAH 1-1 n11ar 3a KanpeMOHT, HeHa,[\Jle>KallleM Kani<1Ta11bHOM 1<1 TeKyl1.1eM peMOHTe >KL-111biX noMel1.1eHL-1Ci (.Qa>Ke eC111<1 Bbl He,QOB011bHbl TeM , YTO y SaC ,[\OMa X0110,[\Hble n011bl - 1<1 ,Qa>Ke TOr,Qa MO>KHO o6pa111aTbC~ s Pocnorpe6Ha.Q30p).

-..To MOMCeT CAenaT~a PocnoTpe6HaA30p no OTHOWeHMIO K npaBOHapyWMTenRM? • npoBeCTL-1 BHen11aHOBYIO nposepKy ,Qe~Te11bHOCTL-1 opraHL-13al.IL-11<1/111n. • norpe6oBaTb npeceYb HapyWeHL<le 3aKOHO,QaTe11bCTBa. • np1<1B11eYb K OTBeTCTBeHHOCTL-1 111<1!.1, COBepWL-1BWL-1X (.QonycTL-1BWL-1x) HapyweHL<le o6~aare11bHbiX rpe6osaHL-1Ci 3aKOHO.QaTe11bCTBa s o611acr1-1 3al1.11<1Tbl npas norpe61-1re11eei. • 06paTL-1TbC~ B cy,Q C 3a~B11eHL-1eM B 3al1.11<1TY npae norpe61-1Te11eei, aaKOHHbiX L<lHTepecos Heonpe.Qe11eHHoro Kpyra norpe61-1re11eei. • 8cryni<1Tb e paccMorpeHL<le cy.QOM .Qe11a no csoeei 1<1HL-1l.IL-1aTL-1Be 1<1111<1 no 1<1HL-1l.IL-1aTL-1Be 111<1!.1, yYaCTBYIOL1.11<1X B .Qe11e, ,QJl~ .Qa"'L-1 aaKJliOYeHL-1~ no .Qe11y s 1.1e11~x aa1111<1Tbl npae norpe61-1re11eei. • OKaaaTb npasosy10 no,[\,[\ep>t<Ky, 6ecn11arHoe KOHcy11bTL-1posaHL-1e no seeM sonpocaM, sxo.Q~l1.11<1M s ero KOMneTeHl,IL-110. if1HbiML-1 C110BaML-1, BaM MOryr OKa3aTb npaKTL-1YeCKYIO nOMOlllb B COCTaB11eHL-11<1 npeTeH31<11<1 1<1111<1 L<lCKosoro 3a~s11eHL-1~ no TOMY 1-1111-1 1<1HOMY sonpocy.

06paTMTiaCR B PocnoTpe6H8A30p MOMCHO: • nl<lCbMeHHO no nO"'Te; • Yepea o¢1<1LIL-1a11bHblei caeir, aan011HL-1B cnet.~L-1a11b HYIO cpopMy; • no re11e¢oHy 6ecn11arHoei rop~Yeei 111<1HL-11<1 8-800-1 00-0004.

npaaa noTpe61f1TeJ1SI

~eAepanbHbiM

3ro • opraH HcnonHHTenbHOM snacr111, ocyllleCTBnJitol.l.IHM ~yHKI..\111111 no Bblpa6oTKe Ill peanH3al..\llllll roCyAapCTBeHHOM nOniiiTIIIKIII Ill HOpMaTIIIBHO-npaBOBOMy perynlllpOBaHIIIIO B c~epe Jal.l.IHTbl npas norpe6111renel1, no pa3pa6orKe 111 yrsep>KAeHHto rocyAapcrseHHbiX CaHHTapH0·3nHAeMHOnOrH"leCKIIIX npaBIIIfl Ill rHrllleHH"leCKIIIX HOpMaTIIIBOB, a TaK>Ke no opraHHJal..\111111 111 ocy1.1.1ecrsneHMto ~eAepanb Horo rocyAapcrseHHoro caHHTapHo-3nHAeMHonorH"lecKoro HaA3opa 111 ~eAepanbHOro rocyAapcrseHHoro HaA3opa B o6nacr111 Jal.l.IIIITbl npas norpe6111renel1 (cornacHo nono>KeHHto o <l>eAepanbHOM cny>K6e no HaA3opy B c~epe Jal.l.IHTbl npas norpe6111renel1 111 6naronony"'HJI "lenoseKa, yrs. nocraHosneHHeM npaBHTenbCTBa Pel> OT 30.06.2004 N!! 322). Pocnorpe6HaA30p ocyl.l.leCTBnReT nonHoMo"'MJI KaK CaMOCTOJITenbHO, TaK Ill "lepe3 CBOIII reppiiiTOpHanbHble OTAeneHHJI, pacnono>KeHHble B Ka>KAOM cy6'beKTe Pel>.

KyAa noAaaaTia •ano6y MnM HanpaanRTia o6pa~eHMe? Cse,QeHL-1~ o Mecre Haxo>K.QeHL-1~ repp1<1TOp1<1a11bHbiX opraHos Pocnorpe6Ha.Q3opa, noYTOBbiX a,Qpecax ,[\11~ Hanpas11eHL-1~ o6pallleHL-1Ci, o pyKOBO.QL-1Te11e, re11e¢oHHbiX HOMepax 1-1 a,Qpecax 311eKTpOHHOCi nOYTbl ,[\11~ HanpaB11eHL-1~ o6pal1.1eHL-1Ci nOML<lMO 1<1HcpOpMal,IL-10HHbiX CTeH,[\08, HaXO,Q~1.1.11<1XC~ B noMellleHL<l~X 061.1.1eCTBeHHbiX npl<leMHbiX Pocnorpe6Ha,Qaopa 1-1 ero repp1<1rop1-1a11bHbiX opraHOB, pa3Mel1.1eHbl Ha caeire Pocnorpe6Ha,Qaopa s if1HTepHeTe.

KaKMe ecT~a aapMaHTial AnR nOA8'1M MCano61a1? • n1-1YHO B Teppi<1TOp1<1a11bHOe no,Qpa3,Qe11eHL-1e Pocnorpe6Ha.Q3opa s csoeM cy6beKre P~. 111H¢opMal.IL-1~ o Mecre np1o1eMa, o6 ycraHOB11eHHbiX .Q11~ np1!1eMa .QH~x 1-1 Yacax .QOBO.Q1!1TC~ .QO cse,QeHI!1~ rpa>K.QaH , KaK npas1o1110, nyreM ee paaMellleHL-1~ Ha 1!1HcpOpMal,II!10HHbiX CTeH,QaX 1!1 Ha Ocp1!1l,ll!1aflbHbiX caeirax Pocnorpe6Ha.Qaopa ..., ero repp1!1TOp1!1a11bHbiX opraHOB. · • no nOYTe C yse,QOM11eHI!1eM 0 spyYeHI!11!1 B Tepp1<1TOp1!1a11bHblei opraH Pocnorpe6Ha.Q3opa s ceoeM cy6beKTe P~ . • 8 cpOpMe 311eKTpOHHOrO ,[\OKyMeHTa C 1!1Cn011b30BaHL-1eM cnet.~l!1a11bHOC1 ¢opMbl Ha caeire Pocnorpe6Ha.Q3opa csoero cy6beKTa P~. • 8 cpopMe 311eKTpOHHOrO ,[\OKyMeHTa, Hanpas11~eMoro no a,Qpecy 311eKTpOHHoei noYTbl Pocnorpe6Ha.Q3opa (depart@gsen.ru). • ~aKCI!1MI!111bHbiM ni!1CbMeHHbiM o6pal1.1eHI!1eM no HOMepy (499) 973-26-43 1!1111!1 no re11e¢oHY 6ecn11arHoei rop~Yeei 111!1HI!11!1 - 8-800-1 00-0004 (YBbl, ,[\03BOHI!1TbC~ KpaeiHe C110>KHO).

B KaKMX cny~taRx opraHbl PocnoTpe6HaA30pa anpaae He pearMpoaaTb Ha o6pa~eHMe?

~To

yKa3aTb a *ano6e? B o6pall.\eHIIIIII 11111111 >t<a11o6e HaAo yKaJaTb:

• Hal-1MeHOBaHI-1e rocy,QapCTBeHHOrO opraHa, B KOTOpbli1 Hanpasn51eTC51 o6pall.\eH!-1e (PocnoTpe6Ha.Q3op), n1-160 cpaMI-1nl-110, l-1M51, OT4eCTBO COOTBeTCTBYIOil.lero ,QOn>KHOCTHOrO n!-11..\a, n1-160 ,QOn>KHOCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOIl.lero n1-11..1a: • CBOI-1 cpaM!-1nl-110, l-1M51, OT4eCTBO (nocne,QHee - npl-1 Hanl-141-11-1); • a,Qpec 3neKTpOHHOi1 n04Tbl (eCnl-1 OTBeT ,QOn>KeH 6b1Tb HanpasneH B cpopMe aneKTpOHHoro .QOKyMeHTa); • n04TOBbli1 a,Qpec, no KOTOpOMY ,QOn>KHbl 6b1Tb HanpasneHbl OTBeT, yse,QoMneH!-1e o nepea,~:~pecal..ll-11-1 o6pall.\eHI-151; • CYTb npe.Qno>KeHI-151, 3a51sneHI-151 1-1n1-1 >t<ano6bl; • nl-14HYIO no.Qnl-1cb 1-1 .QaTy. TaK>Ke >Ke11aTe11bHO np111110>KIIITb K raKoMy o6pall.leHIIIIO He06XOAIIIMble AOKyMeHTbl Ill MaTepllla11bl B 311eKTpOHHOM cpopMe 1111160 HanpaBIIITb 3TIII AOKY· MeHTbl Ill MaTepllla11bl 11111111 IIIX KOnllllll B mtCbMeHHOM cpopMe (n. 1 CT. 5 3aKOHa OT 02.05.2006 N!! 59-<1>3). np111 11111~HOM o6pall.\eHMM HaAO MMeTb npM ce6e AOKYMeHT, YAOCToeepfiiOil.\MM 11M~HOCTb. <l>aKT 11M~ Horo o6pall.\eHMfl He 11Mwaer eac npaea cocraeMTb nMCbMeHHOe o6pall.\eHMe B MOMeHT npMeMa A011>K· HOCTHbiM 11ML\OM.

• B nl-1CbMeHHOM 06pall.\eHI-11-1 He yKa3aHbl: cpaMI-1nl-151 rpa>K.QaH!-1Ha, HanpaBI-1BWero o6pall.\eH!-1e, ero n04TOBbli1 a,Qpec, no KOTOpOMy ,QOn>KeH 6b1Tb HanpasneH OTBeT; • reKCT o6pall.\eHMfl He noAAaeTCfl npo~Te HMIO. 06 3TOM B Te~eHMe CeMM AHeM CO AHfl perMCTpai..\MM o6pall.\eHMfl BaM A011>KHbl C006· ll.\MTb, ec11M yAaCTCfl npo~ecTb eawy cpaMM11MIO M no~TOBbiM aApec; • B o6pall.\eHI-11-1 CO,Qep>KaTC51 Hel..\eH3ypHble nl-160 OCKOp61-1TenbHble Bblpa>KeHI-151, yrp03bl >Kl-13Hl-1, 3,1:10pOBbiO 1-1 l-1MYil.\eCTBY ,QOn>KHOCTHOrO nl-11..\8, a TaK>Ke YneHOB ero CeMbl-1 . Ha TaKOe o6pall.\eH!-1e BaM MOrYT He OTBeTI-1Tb, HO yse,QOMI-1Tb BaC 0 He,QonyCTI-1MOCTI-1 3noynoTpe6neHI-151 npasoM; • ec11M oreer no cyll.lecrey nocTaBileHHoro e o6pall.\eHMM eonpoca He MO>KeT 6bJTb AaH 6e3 paJrnaweHMfl CBeAeHMM, COCTaB11fiiOil.\MX rocyAapCTBeHHYIO M11M MHYIO oxpaHfleMyiO cpeAepa11bHbiM JaKOHOM TaMHy; • B o6pall.\eHI-11-1 CO,Qep>Kl-1TC51 BOnpOC, Ha KOT0pbli1 rpa>K,QaHI-1HY MHOroKpaTHO ,QaBanl-1Cb nt.1CbMeHHble OTBeTbl.

KaKOM OTBeT PocnoTpe6HaA30p 06R3aH npeAOCTaBMTb, ecnM ace Tpe6oaaHMR no o6pa~eHMIO 6blnM co6niOAeHbl?

• n1-160 OTBeT B cpopMe aneKTpOHHOro ,QOKyMeHTa , Hanpasn51eMoro no a.Qpecy aneKTpOHHOi1 no4Tbl , yKa3aHHOMY B o6pall.\eHI-11-1, 1-1n1-1 B nl-1CbMeHHOi1 cpopMe no n04TOBOMy a,Qpecy, yKa3aHHOMY B o6pall.\eHI-11-1 , 1-1n1-1 c sawero cornacl-151 ycTHO, ecn1-1 l-13nO>KeHHble B YCTHOM 06pall.\eHI-11-1 cpaKTbl 1-1 06CT051TenbCTBa 51Bn5110TC51 04eBI-1,QHbiMI-1 1-1 He Tpe6yiOT ,~:~ononHI-1TenbHOi1 nposepKI-1 (n. 4 CT. 10, n. 3 cT. 13 3aKOHa OT 02 .05.2006 N2 59-<1>3); • n1-160 OTKa3 B paCCMOTpeHI-11-1 o6pall.\eHI-151 B YCTHOi1, nl-1CbMeHHOi1 cpopMe 1-1n1-1 B cpopMe aneKTpOHHOrO ,QOKyMeHTa C l-13nO>KeH!-1eM npl-141-1H OTKa3a. • 061l.ll-1i1 CpOK paCCMOTpeHI-151 nl-1CbMeHHbiX 06pall.\eHI-1i1 - 30 .QHei1 co .QH51 pert.1cTpal..\l-111. B 11CKni0411TenbHbiX cnyYa51x , a TaK>Ke s cnyYae HanpasneHI151 Janpoca cpoK MO>KeT 6b1Tb npo,~:~neH He 6onee YeM Ha 30 .QHei1, o YeM 3a51BI1TenpaKTMKa n51 yse.QoMn51npaKTIIIKa noKa3biBaeT, YTO ecn1-1 3a51sneH!-1e Han1-1caHo no seeM npas1-1naM, co6mo.QeHbl IOT (n . n. 1, 2 see cpopManbHOCTI-1 , PocnoTpe6Ha.Q3op .QOCTaTOYHO onepaTI-1BHO pear1-1pyeT Ha o6pall.\eHI-151 CT. 12 3aKOHa rpa>K.QaH . O.QHaKo 6biBaiOT 1-1 ,~:~pyr1-1e Cl-1Tya1..11-11-1, paccMoTpl-1M HecKonbKO npl-1Mepos c OTKaOT 02.05.2006 30M or paccMoTpeHI-151 npeTeH31-1i1. npl-1Mep, Ha cai1T rocycnyr nocTyn1-1no o6pall.\eHI-1e c >KaN2 59-<1>3). no6oi1 Ha pa6oTy PocnoTpe6Ha.Q3opa. B 3a51sneHI-11-1 yKa3biBanocb, YTO rpa>K.QaHI-1H no,Qan >Kano6y s PocnoTpe6Ha.Q3op Yepe3 o¢1-11..11-1anbHbli1 cai1T, HO B paccMoTpeHI-11-1 6blnO OTKa3aHO. 8 XO,Qe pa60Tbl no >Kano6e BCnnblnl-1 HeKOTOpble HIOaHCbl: 3a51Bl-1Tenb yKa3an CBOI-1 V10, HO He ocTaBI-1n nacnopTHble .QaHHble, HOMep TenecpoHa 1-1 a,~:~pec nponl-1CKI-1 . 06pall.\eHI-1e 6blnO paCI..\eHeHO KaK aHOHI-1MHOe, COOTBeTCTBeHHO B paCCMOTpeHI-11-1 >Kano6bl 6bln0 OTKa3aHO. ,[lo He.QaBHero epeMeHI-1 aHOHI-1MHble o6pall.\eHI-151 Yepe3 V1HTepHeT 6blnl-1 ,~:~onycTI-1Mbl 1-1 ,___ _ _ _ _....~ npl-1Hl-1Manl-1Cb Ha paccMoTpeHI-1e, c 2017 ro.Qa no,~:~o6Ha51 3a51sneHI-1i1 He saeTC51 .

KaK nOAaTb MCKOBOe 3aRBneHMe B CYA?

a KaKOM CYA o6paU4aTbCR? AaHHbllil sonpoc yperyn1!1posaH craTbSlMI!1 2224, 29, 32 rpa>K,QaHCKOro npOI..\eCcyanbHOrO KO,QeKCa P<t>, a ra101<e crarbelil 17 3aKoHa P<t> «0 Jall.li!1Te npas norpe61!1Tenelil». Aena no 1!1CKaM s Jall.lli1Ty npas norpe61!1renelil no,Qse,QOMCTBeHHbl cy,QaM 06ll.lelil 10pli1C,Qii1KI..\1!11!1. 3aKOHOM npe,QyCMOTpeHa anbTepHaTI!1BHaSl nO,QCy,QHOCTb CnOpOB no Jall.li!1Te npas norpe61!1Tenelil, 4TO ,Qaer norpe61!1Tenl0 (1!1CTI..IY) npaso CaMOCTOSlTenbHOfO Bbl6paTb, B KaKOLil cy,Q eMy o6pall.laTbCSl : 1) s CY.Q no Mecry Haxo>K,QeHI!1Sl opraH1!1Jal..lli11!1 (no 10pli1,QI!14ecKoMy a,Qpecy 10p1!1,Qii14ecKoro n1!11..1a), a eCnli1 OTBeT41!1KOM SlBnSleTCSl li1H,Qii1Bii1,QyanbHbllil npe,Qnp1!1HI!1Marenb - no Mecry ero >KI!1Tenbcrsa; 2) s cy,Q no Mecry >Kii1Tenbcrsa (Mecry OQlli11..11!1anbHOLil perli1crpal..\li11!1) 1!1nli1 npe6biBaHI!1Sl (speMeHHolil perl!1crpal..\1!11!1) 1!1CTI..Ia; 3) JaKfll04eHI!1Sl 1!1nli1 1!1cnonHeHI!1Sl ,Qorosopa. Ecnl!1 1!1CK K opraHI!1Jal..lli11!1 BbiTeKaer 1!1J ,QeSlrenbHOCTI!1 ee cp1!1nli1ana 1!1nli1 npe,QCTaBI!1TenbCTBa, OH MO>KeT 6b1Tb npe,QbSlBneH s cy,Q no Mecry Haxo>K,QeH1!1Sl ee cp1!1nl!1ana 1!1nli1 npe,Qcrasi!1Tenbcrsa. o~eHb ~aCTO B AOfOBOpbl c noTpe6111T811SIMII1 npOAaBI..Ibl

(11111111

yc11oe111e o TOM,

111Cn011HII1T811111)

~To

BKlliO~aiOT

ece BOJHII1Katoll.lll1e no AO-

roeopy cnopbl 6YAYT paccMaTpii1BaTbCst no M8CTY HaXO>KA8HII1SI npOAaBI..Ia (11111111 111Cn011HII1• Te11st). TaKoe yc11oe111e HeJaKOHHO.

nneHyM BepxoBHOro Cy,Qa P<t> OT 28 1!110HSl 2012 r. N2 17 "0 paccMorpeHI-11!1 cy,QaMI!1 rpa>K,QaHCKI!1X ,Qen no cnopaM o Jall.li!1Te npas norpe61!1Tenelil" yKaJan , 4TO cy,Qbl He snpase soJspaTI!1Tb 1!1CKosoe JaSlBneHI!1e CO CCblnKOLil Ha nyHKT 2 4aCTI!1 1 CTaTbli1 135 rnK P<t>, TaK KaK B CY1ny 4aCTelil 7, 10 CTaTbli1 29 rnK P<t>, Bbi60p Me>K,Qy HeCKOnbKI!1Mii1 cy,QaMI!1, KoropbiM no,Qcy,QHO ,Qeno, np1!1Ha,Qfle>Kii1T norpe61!1Tenl0 (Y1CTLIY).

111CTI..Ibl no 111CKaM, CBSIJaHHbiM C HapyweHII18M npaB noTpe6111T8118H, OCB060>KAaiOTCSI OT yn11aTbl roCnOW11111Hbl.

8 npaBa nOTpe6HTe11fl

--·

AnSl Ha4ana >KenarenbHO o6paTI!1TbCSl KCflel..lli1anli1CTY no Jall.li!1Te npas norpe61!1Tenelil , 10p1!1cTy ,QfiSl cdcrasneH1!1Sl rpaMOTHoro 1!1CKosoro JaSlsneHI!1Sl. C,Qenarb 3TO MO>KHO 1!1 CaMOCTOSlTenbHO, HO CO CCblnKaMI!1 Ha J3K0Hbl 1!1 1!1Hble HOpMaTI!1BHO-npaBOBble aKTbl , 060CHOBbiBaiOll.lli1e sawl!1 rpe6osaHI!1Sl . Heo6xo,QY1MO c,Qenarb KOnli11!1 ,QOKyMeHTOB B ,QBYX 3KJeMnnSlpaX, ,QnSl cy,Qa 1!1 OTBeT41!1Ka . AoKyMeHTbl ,QOn>KHbl OTHOCI!1TbCSl K cylllecrsy 1!1CKa (4eKI!1 , KBI!1TaHI..\Ii11!1 , JaKfll04eHI!1Sl 3KCnepTY1Jbl , nepeni!1CKa c orseT41!1KOM 1!1 ,Qp.). Hy>KHO yJHaTb np1!1eMHble ,QHI!1 CY,Qbli1 1!1 nO,QOLiiT1!1 B yKaJaHHbllil ,QeHb nli160 HanpaBI!1Tb 1!1CKOBOe JaSlsneHY1e no n04Te (JaKaJHbiM nli1CbMOM C yse,QOMneHI!1eM 0 Bpy4eH1!11!1). 06paTI!1Te BHY1MaH1!1e, 4TO cy,QbSl KOHCynbTai..I1!1Lil He ,QaeT 1!1 He 6y,QeT noMoraTb BaM B COCTasneHI!11!1 1!1CKOBOrO JaSlsneHI-151, n03TOMY Ha np1!1eM K Cy,Qbe He06XO,QY1MO 1!1,QTI!1 C rOTOBbiM naKeTOM ,QoKyMeHros. Cy,QbSl s re4eHI!1e ns:~TI!1 ,QHelil co ,QH51 nocrynneHI!1Sl 1!1CKOBOro JaSlsneHI!151 B cy,Q 06SlJaH paCCMOTpeTb sonpoc o ero np1!1HSlTY11!1 K npo1!1JBO,QCTBY cy,Qa . nocne 3Toro cy,Qb51 BbiHOCI!1T onpe,QeneHI!1e, Ha ocHosaHii11!1 KOTOpOro BOJ6y>K,QaeTCSl rpa>K,QaHCKOe ,QenO B Cy,Qe nepsolil 1!1HCTaHI..IIi11!1. nocne np1!1HSlTI!1Sl JaSlsneHI!1Sl cy,QbSl BbiHOCI!1T onpe,QeneHI!1e o no,QrorosKe ,Qena K cy,Qe6HoMY paJ61!1parenbcrsy 1!1 yKaJblsaer ,Qelilcrs1!1Sl, Kor opble Heo6xo,QI!1MO cosepw1!1Tb cropoHaM.

KaK aecTM ce6R a cyAe6HOM 3aceAaHMM? np1!1 sxo,Qe cy,Qelil s Jan cy,Qe6Horo Jace,QaHI!1Sl see npli1CYTCTBYIOll.ll!1e B Jane BCTaiOT. 06bSlBneHI!1e peweHii1Sl cy,Qa , a ra101<e o6bSlsneHI!1e onpe,QeneHI-151 cy,Qa, KOTOpblM JaKaH41!1BaeTCSl ,Qeno 6eJ np1!1HSlTI!1Sl peweHii1Sl, see npli1CYTCTBYIOll.ll!1e B Jane JaCe,QaH1!1Sl BbiCnyWI!1BaiOT croSl . Y4aCTHI!1Kii1 npo1..1ecca o6pall.laiOTCSl K CY,QbSlM CO CnOBaMI!1 : «YBa>KaeMbllil cy,Q! » 1!1 CBOI!1 noKaJaHI-151 1!1 06bS'ICHeHI!1Sl ,QaiOT CTOSl. 0TCTynneHI!1e OT 3Toro npasl!1na MO>KeT 6b1Tb ,Qonyll.leHo c paJpeweHI!1Sl npe,Qce,QarenbCTBYIOll.lero. Cy.Qe6Hoe paJ61!1parenbcrso npo1!1CXO,Qii1T s ycnosi!1SlX, o6ecne41!1Bal0ll.lli1X Ha,Qne>Kall.lY1Lil nopSl,QOK so speMSl cy,Qe6Horo Jace,QaHI!1Sl 1-1 6eJonacHOCTb y4aCTHI!1 KOB npo1..1ecca . Ha,Qne>Kall.leMy nopSl.QKY so speMSl cy,Qe6Horo Jace,QaHI!1Sl He ,QOn>KHbl MewaTb ,QeliiCTBI-151 rpa>K,Qa H, npli1CYTCTBYIOll.lY1X B Jane Jace,QaHI!1Sl 1!1 ocyll.lecrsnSliOll.lli1X paJpeweHHble cy,QoM QJOTOCbeMKY 1!1 BI!1,QeOJani!1Cb, TpaHCnSll..\1!110 cy,Qe6HOrO Jace,QaHI!1Sl no pa,QI!10 1!1 renesli1,QeHI!110. 3Tii1 ,Qelilcrs1!1Sl ,QOn>KHbl ocyll.lecrsnSlTbCSl Ha yKaJaHHbiX cy,QoM Mecrax B Jane JaCe,QaHI!1Sl 1!1 , C y4eTOM MHeHI!1Sl y4aCTBYIOll.lli1X B ,Qene nli11..1, Moryr 6b1Tb orpaHI!14eHbl cy,QoM so speMeH1!1. Y4aCTHI!1Kii1 npol..\ecca 1!1 see npli1CYTCTBYIOll.lli1e s Jane cy,Qe6Horo Jace,QaHI!1Sl rpa>K,QaHe o6s:~ 3aHbl co6niO,QaTb ycTaHOBneHHbllil nopSl,QOK B cy,Qe6HOM JaCe,QaHI!11!1.

06pa3eU. MCKOBOrO 3aRaneHMR

B ____________________ (Haii1M8HOBaHII18 cy,Qa) V1cTe1..1:

--:-:--=:--=-:-:-=::-;::;~~~

(<l>V10 nOilHOCTbiO, a,Qpec)

0TB8T4111K: - - - - - - - - (Haii1M8HOBaHII18 10p.Illl11..1a 111Illl1 ~eHall1cKa :

<l>VIO npe,Qnp111HII1Maren~) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

~CKOBOE3A~BnEH~E

o 3a~lt1Te npas norpe6111reneVI r. ~ BCTynii1Il BO B3aii1MOOTHOW8HII1~ C OTB8T4111KOM

«_»

(Onii1CaTb Ha4ailO B03-

HII1KHOB8HII1~ B3aii1MOOTHOW8HII1H C OTB8T4111KOM , KaK OHII1 6bii1111 OcpOpMI18Hbl, KaKII18 ,QOKyMeHTbl np111 3TOM CO-

CTaBil~Ilii1Cb). no YCI10BII1~M ,QOroeopa OTB8T4111K 6b1Il 06~3aH

(yKa3aTb , KaKII18 06~3aT8IlbCTBa npii1-

H~Il Ha ce6~ oreeT4111K) . 3a npo,QaHHbliil roeap (oKaaaHHYIO ycnyry) MHOIO 6biilO onnaYeHa cyMMa

py6 .

(yKa3aTb , B 48M 3aKI1104a8TC~ HapyWeHII18 npaB 111CTI..Ia

0,QHaKO OTB8T4111K HapyWII1Il MOII1 npaea

CO CTOpOHbl OTB8T4111Ka, KaKII18 ,Q8HCTBII1~ COrilaCHO CTaTb~M

18 111Illl1 29 3aKOHa «0 3al1.1111Te npaB norpe6111Te-

I18H» ,Q0Il>K8H 6b1Il BblnOI1HII1Tb OTB8T4111K 111 n048My) .

s=l o6pal1.1ai1C~ K OTB8T4111KY C Tpe6oeaHII1~MII1 06 ycrpaH8HII1111 Bbi~BI18HHbiX H8,QOCTaTKOB, B TOM 4111CI18 Ha(yKa3aTb, KaKII18 Tpe6oeaHII1~ 6b1Illl1 1113IlO>K8Hbl B npe-

npaBII1Il nii1CbM8HHYIO npeTeH311110, B KOTOpOil!

T8H3111111, KTO 111 KOr,Qa ee nOI1Y4111Il , KaKOH 6b1Il ycraHOBI18H CpOK ,Qil~ ycrpaHeHII1~ Bbi~BI18HHbiX He,QOCTaTKOB). 8 ycTaHOBI18HHbiH CpOK OTB8T4111K Ha MOIO np8T8H311110 He OTB8TII1Il (111I1111 OTB8T111Il , HO OTB8T 111CTI..Ia H8 ycrpOII1Il, np111B8CTII1 np1114111Hbl, no KOTOpbiM ,QOBO,Qbl OTB8T4111Ka ~Bil~IOTC~ H8060CHOBaHHbiM111). AeiilcTBII1~MII1 oreeT4111Ka MHe np1114111H8Hbl HpaecreeHHble crpa,QaHII1~. KOTOpble aaKI1104aiOTC~ e cne,QyiOL1.1eM

_ _ _ _ (nep84111CI1111Tb HpaBCTB8HHbl8 CTpa,QaHII1~. 111CnbiTaHHbl8 111CTI..IOM BCI18,QCTBII18 HenpaBOMepHbiX ,Q8HCTBII1H OTB8T4111Ka), np1114111H8HHbiH MOpailbHbiH epe,Q ~ 01..18HII1Bal0 B CyMMe

py6.

3a OTKa3 OT ,Q06pOBOilbHOrO BblnOI1H8HII1~ MOII1X Tpe60BaHII1H C OTB8T4111Ka nO,QI18>KII1T B3biCKaHII110 WTpacp B pa3Mepe

50 %

OT B3biCKaHHOH Cy,QOM CYMMbl B MOIO nOilb3y.

Ha OCHOBaHII1111 1113IlO>K8HHOrO, PYKOBO,QCTBY~Cb CTaTb~MII1

131-132 rpa>K,QaHCKOro npOI..IeccyailbHOro KO,QeK-

ca P<l>, npowy:

06~3aTb OTB8T4111Ka

HII1MaTei1~)

(Haii1M8HOBaHII18 OTB8T4111Ka 10pii1,QII148CKOrO Illl11..1a 111Illl1 <l>V10 npe,Qnp111-

(yKaaarb rpe6oeaHII1~ 1113 crarbll1

18 111r1111 29 3aKoHa «0 aal1.1111Te npae norpe6111reneiil» ) .

83biCKaTb C OTB8T4111Ka ynna48HHYIO MHOIO CYMMY B pa3Mepe

py6. (np111 Hai11114111111 Tpe6oeaHII1H

0 B3biCKaHII1111 ,QeHe>KHOH CYMMbl).

3. 4.

83biCKaTb C OTB8T4111Ka KOMneHCal..lll110 MOpailbHOro Bpe,Qa B CYMM8

py6 .

83biCKaTb C OTB8T4111Ka WTpacp 3a OTKa3 OT ,Q06pOBOilbHOrO Y.QOBI18TBOpeHII1~ 111CKOBbiX Tpe60BaHII1H.

nepe48Hb np111naraeMbiX K 3a~BI18HII110 ,QOKyMeHTOB (KOnll1111 no 4111CI1Y Illl11..1, y4aCTBYIOL1.1111X B ,Qene):

Kon111~ 111CKOBOro 3a~BI18 H II1~

AoKyMeHTbl, no,Qreep>K,Qal0l1.1111e Hai11114111e ,QoroeopHbiX orHoweHII1iil c oreer4111KOM

AoKyMeHTbl, no,Qreep>K,Qal0l1.1111 e onnary aa np111o6pereHHbliil roeap 111r1111 oKaaaHHYIO ycnyry

npeT8H3111~ 111 ,QOKyMeHTbl, nO,QTB8p>K,QaiOL1.11118 ee nOI1Y48HII18 OTB8T4111KOM

5. 6.

AoKyMeHTbl, no,Qreep>K.Qa10l1.11118 He,QocrarKII1 roeapa 111r1111 BbmonHeHHbiX pa6or gpyr111e ,QOKaaarenbcrea, no,Qreep>K,Qal0l1.1111e ocHoeaHII1~ 111CKoeoro aa~eneHII1~ o 3al1.1111Te npae norpe6111-

ren~

Aara no,Qa4111 aa~eneHII1~ " __" _ _ __ _

•.-:"'~.o--.

----------·-

no,Qn111Cb 111CTI..Ia: _ __

......---.... '1>~---~

---

-------·--------- -

npaBa nOTpe6MTeiUJ -- - -- - ---

9 -

AnropMTM aawMx AeiilcTaMiil nepBbiM ,D,efiOM norpe6y~Te y a,D,MIIIhiiiCTpal..\~111 a3ponopra cnpasKy o TOM, noYeMy saw pe111c 3a,D,ep>Kafllll, C yKa3aHIIIeM cpaKTIIIYeCKOrO BpeMeHIII BblfleTa. 111fllll nO,D,O~,D,IIITe K CTO~Ke periiiCTpal..\111111 sawe~ as!llaKoMnaHIIIIII - raM Ha saw 6111rrer ,D,Ofi>KHbl nOCTaBIIITb WTaMn, KOTOpbl~ 6yp,eT nO,D,TBep>K,D,eHIIIeM 3ap,ep>KKIII pe~ca. 06s:r3aTeflbHO coxpaHs:r~re see YeKIII, KOTOpble nO,D,TBep,D,s:IT, YTO BaM npiiiWfiOCb HeCTIII paCXO,D,bl caMocros:rrerrbHO. 3ro pacnpocrpaHs:rercs:r Ha ep,y, rreKapcrsa, rpaHcnopr. Co6111pa~re 111 xpaHHTe see YeKIII, ,D,a>Ke eCfllll Bbl Kynlllfllll TOflbKO 6yrblfiKY BO,D,bl. EC~III Bbl on03,D,afllll Ha CTbiKOBOYHbl~ pe~C O,D,HOIII aslllaKoMnaHIIIIII, sac nocap,s:rr Ha crrep,yIOll.llll~ pe~C. npo6rreMa B03HIIIKHeT, eCfllll Bbl fleTIIITe pe~caMIII pa3HbiX aslllaKoMnaHIII~ - np111p,ercs:r noKynarb ell.le O,D,IIIH 6111rrer. Op,HaKo Kon11110 3Toro 6111rrera Bbl o6s:r3aTeflbHO ,D,Ofi>KHbl COXpaHIIITb - paCXO,D,bl Ha noKynKy BTOpOrO 6v1fleTa BaM ,D,Ofi>KHa B03MeCTIIITb aslllaKoMnaHHs:r, Ye~ pe~c 3ap,ep>Karrcs:r . Korp,a Bbl sce-raKIII p,o6eperecb p,o nyHKTa Ha3HaYeHIIIS'I, HaniiiWIIITe npereH311110 K aslllaKOMnaHIIIIII, nplllfiO>KIIIB K He~ KOnllll-1 ,D,OKyMeHTOB, nO,D,TBep>K,D,aiOll.liiiX sawe npaso Ha KOMneHCal..\11110: 6111rrer CO WTaMnOM nepeB03YIIIKa lllfllll cnpaBKY OT a,D,MIIIHIIICTpal..\111111 a3ponopra, YeKIII, KOnllllll 6pOHIII B orerre lllfllll sayYepbl Ha Typbl Ill 3KCKypCIIIIII, KOTOpble COpBafiiiiCb. npeTeH311110 Ill naKeT ,D,OKyMeHTOB He06XO,D,IIIMO ornpaBIIITb Ha IOPIII,D,IIIYecKIII~ ap,pec asl-1anepeso3YIIIKa .

ny"4aeTCSI, "4TO OTnycK Hai.4HHaeTCSI lllfllll 3aKaH"4111BaeTCSI HenpiiiSITHOCTSIMIII: BaW pe&ilc 3aAep>KaH lllfllll BOBCe OTMeHeH. HH>Ke Bbl HaHAeTe IIIHQlOpMat.tllltO, KOTOpas:r BaM MO>KeT nOH3A06111TbCSI B TaKOM CHTyat.tHIII.

Baw peiilc 3aAep>KanM MnM OTMeHMnM Cyll.lecrsy10r 3aKoHop,arerrbHO ocpopMrreHHble HOpMbl, YTO ,D,Ofi>KeH ,D,eflaTb aB!IIanepeB03YIIIK s crryYae 3ap,ep>KKIII pe~ca. OHIII npon111caHbl s «06ll.liiiX npaBIIIflaX B03,D,YWHbiX nepeB030K nacCa>KIIIpOB, 6ara>Ka , rpy3oB 111 rpe6osaH!IIs:r K o6crry>KIIIBaHIIIIO nacca>KIIIpOB, rpy300TnpaBII!Tefle~, rpy30norryYaTefle~», KOTOpble BCTynlllfllll B ClllfiY 21 OKTS'I6ps:r 2007 rop,a . 3TH npaBIIIfla p,e~CTBYIOT BHe 3aBIIICIIIMOCTIII OT TOro, no KaKIIIM npiiiYIIIHaM npo11130Wfla 3ap,ep>KKa pe~ca. CornacHo 3TOMY p,oKyMeHTY Bbl IIIMeere npaso: • Ha KOMHaTy MaTeplll Ill pe6eHKa, eCnlll Bbl eAeTe c AeTbMIII MnaAwe 7 neT;

• Ha 2 TerrecpOHHbiX 3BOHKa lllfll-1 2 niiiCbMa no nOYTe, eCfllll pe~C OTKfla,D,biBaiOT 60rree YeM Ha 2 Yaca; 3fleKTpOHHO~

• Ha npoxnaAHTenbHbre HanHTKH, ecn111 pe&llc 3aAep>KHBaiOT 6onee "4eM Ha 2 1.4.;

• Ha rops:rYee nii!TaHHe, ecrr111 >K,D,ere pe~ca 6orrbwe 4 Yacos. Aarree Ka>K,D,ble 6 Y. - s p,HesHoe speMs:r 111 Ka>K,D,bre 8 Y. - B HOYHoe speMs:r sac o6s:r3aHbl KOpMIIITb; • Ha HOMep B rOCTIIIHIIIt.te, ecn111 Bbl >KAeTe Bbl· neTa 6onee 8 1.4. AHeM 111n111 6onee 6 1.4. H0"4b10;

• Ha rpaHccpep or a3ponopTa p,o rocTIIIHIIII..\bl 111 o6parHo s rex crryYas:rx, Korp,a rocTIIIHIIII..Ia npep,ocTasrrs:rercs:r 6e3 B3111MaHHs:r p,onorrHHTerrbHO~ nrraTbl; • Ha xpaHeHHe 6ara>Ka.

06pall.laeM Bawe BHIIIMaHIIIe Ha TO, YTO BCe 3TH ycrryr111 as!llanepeso3YIIIK o6s:r3aH npep,ocrasrrs:rTb 6ecnrraTHO.

KoMy >KanoaaTbCR 111TaK, npeTeH3111s:l HaniiiCaHa Ill OrnpasrreHa. nyYWe cp,errarb 3TO cpa3y no np111rrery p,oMo~ . xors:r cpopMaflbHO y sac ecrb Ha 3TO norrrop,a. Ho s pearrbHOCTIII YeM 6orrbwe Bbl rs:rHere c nop,aye~ npereH3111111, reM MeHbWe WaHCOB norryYIIITb KOMneHCal..\11110. ABIIIanepeB03YIIIK ,D,Ofi>KeH paCCMOTpeTb >Karro6y Ill BbiHeCTIII peweH!IIe B reYeHI-1e 30 ,D,He~. Ecrr111 npowerr Mecs:r1..1 Ill Bbl He norryYIIIfllll OTBeT, nopa III,D,TIII B cyp,. ECfllll peWIIITe o6pall.laTbCS'I B cyp, CaMOCTOS'ITeflbHO, TO K I-1CKOBOMy 3as:IBfleHIIIIO He06XO,D,IIIMO nplllfiO>KIIITb KOnllllll as111a6111fleTa C OTMeTKO~ 0 3ap,ep>KKe pe~ca, CYeTOB 3a roCTIIIHIIII..\Y, nlllraH!IIe, rerrecpoHHble neperosopbl, a raK>Ke sawy nHCbMeHHYIO npereH311110 s ap,pec aslllanepeso3YIIIKa 111 orser ero npep,cras111rerre~ (ecrr111 ecrb). Ho noMHI-1Te: ecrr111 6yp,er p,oKa3aHo, YTO 3ap,ep>KKa np011130Wfla no TeXHIIIYeCKIIIM npiiiYIIIHaM lllfllll l-13-3a He6rraronpllls:ITHbiX MeTeOyCfiOBIII~, TO Bbl He B npase rpe6osarb KOMneHCcil..lllllll . BaM o6s:r3aHbl B03MeCTIIITb yll.lep6 rr111wb s roM crryYae, ecrr111 nepeso3YIIIK He npep,ocras111rr saM nepeYeHb ycrryr s a3ponopry - niiiTaHIIIe, rocTIIIHIIII..Ia 111 raK p,arree . Bbl raK>Ke MO>KeTe o6paTIIITbCS'I B periiiOHaflbHOe OT,D,efleH!IIe Pocnorpe6Ha,D,30pa, Koropbl~ snpase nplllsrre'lb aslllanepeB03YIIIKa K a,D,MIIIHIIICTpaTIIIBHO~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI-1 no Yacrlll 1 crarblll 14.8 KoAn P<l> «HapyweHIIIe IIIHbiX npas norpe6111rerre~» 3a HapyweH!IIe npasa norpe6111rerrs:r Ha He06XO,D,IIIMYIO Ill ,D,OCTOBepHyiO IIIHcpOpMal..\11110 o speMeHIII Bbrrrera. Bee 3TH npas111rra pacnpocrpaHs:rIOTCs:r 111 Ha crryYalll, Korp,a pe~c nepeHocs:rr.

c=o.oac'-"""'"""'_, _ _ ""-'"'"-',., -""'"'=

= ~,.,

.. '-'""'-'-"""""

npasa OTAbiXatO~IflX lf1 nyTeWeCTBYtO~IflX ~

-~- - --

' . -. ""-'. - "",. "' ... --

~~-

-- ---

....

KTO B OTBeTe 3a J.1Cnop4eHHbU::i ornycK? Ha OAHO MeCTO npOAaHO ABa 6J.1Aera 3ApaecTeylltTe! npeACTaBII.ReTe MOe YAMBIIeHMe, KOrAa, 3aliiA.R e noe3A, .R yBMAen, "'TO Ha MOeM MecTe y>Ke exan nacca>KMp. npOBOAHMKM HM"'ero Bpa3yMMTe11bHO· ro MHe He OTBeTMIIM lo1 06.R3a11M AOnnaTMTb AO CTOMMOCTH KYneMHOrO 6r.t11eTa H exaTb e KYne. KyAa .R Mory no>KanoeaTbC.R? ApTeMoe AHApelll, r. Yllb.RHOBCK Ecm1 sawe Mecro s noe3.Qe oKa3anocb 3aHsno ( npo,~:~aHbl 2 61mera Ha O.QHO Mecro), Bbl 1.1Meere npaso: • nOilYYI-1Tb MeCTO 6onee BbiCOKOill KaTerop!.-11.1 6e3 ,~:~onnarbl; • MeHee BbiCOKOi/1 C B03BpaTOM pa3HI.1l..lbl s 1..1eHe; • ecn~.-1 s noe3,~:~e Mecr Her, sac .QOil>KHbl ornpaBI.1Tb Cile,QyiOll.II-1M ; • OTKa3aTbC51 OT noe3,QKI.1 1.1 nOilYYI-1Tb Ha3a,Q CT01.1MOCTb 61.1IleTa . Ho nocKOIIbKY HH"'TO M3 nepe"'McneHHoro BaM npeAIIO>KeHO He 6bl110, TO Bbl MO>KeTe o6paTMTbC.R B CYA C MCKOM 0 803• Mel.l.leHMM MOpallbHOrO lo1 MaTepr.tallbHOrO epeAa.

EcAJ.i noe3A ono3AaA Haw noe3A ono3Aa11 Ha 4 "'aca, H3-3a "'ero Mbl ono3Aa111o1 Ha CaMOIIeT lo1 BeCb OTAbiX 6bl11 Mcnop"'eH. KyAa HaM >KanoeaTbC.R? ronoeaHoea ~pMHa, r. BnaAMMr.tp np~.-1 60ilbW1.1X On03,QaHI.151X BaM eCTb 3a YTO 6opOTbC51. 3a npocpOYKY ,QOCTaBKI-1 nacCa>K1.1pa 1.1Ill.1 6ara>Ka s nyHKT Ha3HaYeHI.151 nepeso3YI.1K ynnaYI.1Baer wrpa¢ s pa3Mepe 25% ycTaHOBileHHOfO 3aKOHOM MI.1HI.1MailbHOfO pa3Mepa onnarbl rpy,~:~a (MPOT) 3a Ka>K.Qbl ill Yac npocpoYKI-1 , HO He 6onee 50% CTOI.1MOCTI.1 61.1IleTa. ECIIH, KOHe"'HO, He AOKa>KeT, "'TO npocpo"!Ka cny"'r.tnacb lo13·3a cpopcMa>KOpHbiX 06CTO.RTe11bCTB: npHpOAHbiX KaTaK111o13MOB , CpO"'HOrO peMOHTa CaMOIIeTa HIIM nOe3Aa (CT. 120 Bo3AYWHoro KOAeKca PC!>). CpoK AaeHocTM • He n03AHee 6 MeC.RI..IeB (Ha BHyTpeHHHX nepeB03KaX) lo1 14 AHeM (Ha Me)I(AyHaPOAHbiX MapwpyTaX).

npasa

HaM MCnOpTMIIM OTnycK: OTellb OKa3a11C.R ropa3AO xy>Ke, "!eM o6e1.1.1a11 MeHeA>Kep np1o1 noAnHcaHMM AOroeopa, a 3KCKYPCHH OTMeHHIIIrt. KyAa >KanoeaTbC.R? <J>pOIIOB naeen, r. MOCKBa Ecn~.-1 c MOMeHra sawero B03Bpall.leHI.151 He npowno 20 .QHeill, HaYI.1HaTb Ha,~:~o c ,~:~ocy,~:~e6Horo pa361-1parenbcrsa. Hani-1WI.1Te npereH31.110 rypareHrcrsy, r,~:~e noKynanl.-1 nyresKy, I11<16o ryponeparopy, KTO opraHI.130BbiBan ryp . B TeKcTe yKa>KMTe: KOrAa npHo6penM nyTeBKY; "'TO npeAnonaranocb H "'TO nOIIY"'HIIM B peallbHOCTM; B "'eM KOHKpeTHO HapyWeH AOroeop; KaK eena ce6.R npMHMMatol.l.la.R cTopoHa. "'eTKO CcpOpMy11HpyMTe CBOM Tpe6oeaHH.R: BblnllaTMTb "'aCTb CTOMMOCTM Typa (>KellaTellbHO npMIIO>KHTb pac"'eT), eo3MecTHTb MopanbHbiM y1.1.1ep6. B reYeHI-1e 10 AHeill Typ<f>1.1pMa ,QOil>KHa OTBeTI.1Tb. ECill-1 OHa He pear1.1pyer 1.1Il1.1 Bbl nponycri-1Ill.1 npereH31.10HHblill cpoK, He orYal.1saillrecb. Typ1.1cT 1.1Meer npaso s reYeHI.1e 3 ner co .QH51 B03spall.leHI.151 no,~:~asarb 1.1CK s cy,~:~ c rpe6osaHI.1eM B03Mell.leHI.151 y6biTKOB (CT. 196 rK P<t>). WaHCbl Ha ycnex - 90%, npo1.1rpbiW - 10% (ecn~.-1 y sac cosceM Her Bell.IAOKOB: Q:>ororpa¢1.1111, BI-1.Qeo3anl-1ceill, KB1.1TaHL.11.1il11.13 OTei151).

HeAOC4J.1TaAJ.1Cb 4eMoAaHoB 0AMH lo13 HaWMX "'eMOAaHOB 6bl11 yTep.RH, pa60THMKH a3pOnOpTa TOIIbKO pyKaMM pa3BOAH· 111o1. "'To AenaTb? BonKoea EneHa, r. EKaTepr.tH6ypr 06pall.laerecb K npe,~:~crasi.1Tefll0 asl.1aKOMnaHI.11.1 1.1Ill.1 s a.QM1.1H1.1CTpal..ll.110 a3ponopra. B 1.1x np1.1cyrcrs1.11.1 cocrasnfleTc51 no,~:~po6Hblill KOMMepYeCKI-1111 aKr: c np1.1MeraMI.1 6ara>Ka 1.1 co,~:~ep>K1.1MbiM . Ba>KHO .QOKa3aTb CTOI-1MOCTb norep~.-1, no3TOMY np1.1ro.Q51TC51 CB!.1.Qeren1.1 (nonyrY1.1KI.1 , po,~:~crseHHI.1KI1 1.1Ill1 APY3b51). BepHyrb norep10 11Ill1 ,~:~eHbrl1 (s roM YI1Cile 3a Bell.ll1 nepsoi/1 He06XO,Q11MOCTI.1 - 3y6Hyl0 ll.I9TKy, py6awKy C raflCTYKOM 11Ill1 nilaTbe) ,QOil>KHbl MaKCI-1MYM Yepe3 MeC51l..l. noIIY"'HB nHCbMeHHbiM OTKa3 Ha npeTeH3Hto, onHCbiBaeTe CBOH CTpaAaHH.R B cyAe6HOM HCKe.

OTAbiX310U-\If1X fr1 nyTeWeCTBYIOU-\HX

'ITO npeAnPMHRTb COTPYAHMKY a cny~ae HeBblnnaTbl 3apnnaTbl? • rpe6oeaTb ebmnaTbl KOMneHca'-'"'"' CornacHo cTaTbe 236 TpyAosoro KOAeKca , B cnyYae 3aAep)I{KI!I BbmnaTbl 3apnnaTbl pa6oToAaTeilb o6~3aH Bbmnannb npw.unaiOLl.IYIOC~ 3apnnaTy c npo4eHTaM111. 06~3aHHOCTb no ynnaTe yKa3aHHOVI KOMneHCa41tU1 HacTynaeT y pa6oTOAaTen~ y)l{e c nepsoro AH~ 3aAep)I{Kiil 3apnnaTbl. AeHe)I{Ha~ KOMneHca4111~ cocTasn~eT He MeHee 1/300 OT AeVtCTBYIOLl.leVl B :no BpeM~ CTaBKI!I pecpi!IHaHCI!IposaHI!I~ L.leHTpo6aHKa (c 16 MapTa 2015 roAa aHa cocTasn~eT 14%). 3Ty 4111¢py HY)I{HO YMHO)I{I!ITb Ha CYMMY 3aAOil)l{eHHOCTI!I 3a Ka)I{AbiVl AeHb 3aAep)I{KI!I . <f>opMyna AJ1SI pacYeTa KOMneHCa4MM:

KoMneHca4111~ 3a 3aAep)I{KY 3apnnaTbl 3aAOil)l{eHHOCTb no 3apnnaTe x 1/300 CTaBKIII peQli!IHaHcl!lposaHI!I~ (14%) X KOili!IYeCTBO AHeVi 3aAe )I{KI!I.

• rpe6oeaTb MHAeKCa4MM 3apnnaTbl KpoMe KOMneHCa4111111 , pa6oTHI!IK I!IMeeT npaso noTpe6osaTb I!IHAeKCa41!1111 cyMM 3aAep)l{aHHOVI 3apa6oTHOVI nnaTbl 1!13-3a o6ec4eH111BaH111~ AeHer B CB~31!1 C liiHQli1~4111eVt . 06 3TOM roBOpi!ITC~ B n. 55 nocTaHOBileHI!I~ nneHyMa BepXOBHOfO cyAa Pet> aT 17 MapTa 2004 r. N2 2. • Tpe6oBaTb KOMneHCa4MM MOpanbHOrO epeAa Pa60THI!IKI!I MOryT npeTeHAOBaTb Ha KOMneHCa41!110 MOpailbHOfO BpeAa . 8 COOTBeTCTBI!IIil CO CT. 237 TK Pet>, MopanbHbiVI speA B03Mell.laeTc~ COTPYAHIIIKY s AeHe)I{HOVI cpopMe B pa3Mepax, onpeAen~eMbiX cornaweHI!IeM cTopoH TPYAOBoro AOrosopa. B cnyYae B03HI!IKHOBeHI!I~ cnopa cpaKT npi!IYI!IHeHI!I~ pa60THIIIKY MOpailbHOfO BpeAa Ill pa3Mepbl era B03Mell.leHIII~ onpeAeil~IOTC~ CYAOM. • npMOCTaHOBMTb BblnOnHeHMe pa60Tbl Ec11111 3aAeP)I{Ka s BbmnaTe 3apnnaTbl 6onbwe 15 AHeV!, TO COTPYAHI!IKI!I Moryr npl!locTaHOBI!ITb pa6oTy AO BblnilaTbl CYMMbl nOilHOCTbiO, ni!ICbMeHHO 1!13BeCTI!IB 06 3TOM pa60TOAaTeil~ (CT. 141 TpyAoBoro KOAeKca Pet>).

• rpe6oeaTb owrpaQ>oeaTb pa6oTOAaTenst MMIIIHI!ICTpaTI!IBHo - npasosa~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a HeBblnilaTy 3apa6oTHOV! nnaTbl HacTynaeT TOilbKO np111 Haili!IYI!IIil BI!IHbl pa60TOAaTeil~ Ill 3aKpenneHa B CTaTbe 5.27 KoAeKca o6 aAMI!IHI!ICTpaTI!IBHbiX npasoHapyweHI!I~x.

0Ha, B YaCTHOCTI!I , npeAYCMaTpi!IBaeT: .... WTpacp OT 1000 AO 5000 py6neV! Ail~ AOil)I{HOCTHbiX 111114, .... WTpacp OT 1000 AO 5000 py6neV! 11111111 npi!IOCTaHOBileHiile Ae~TeilbHOCTI!I Ha cpoK AO 90 cyroK Ail~ IIIHAIIIBIIIAYanbHbiX npeAnpi!IHI!IMaTeneVI , .... WTpacp OT 30 000 AO 50 000 py6neV! 11111111 npi!IOCTaHOBIleHI!Ie Ae~TeilbHOCTI!I Ha CpOK AO 90 CYTOK Ail~ IOPIIIAI!IYeCKI!IX 111114. Ec11111 HeBbmnaTa 3apa6oTHOVI nnaTbl nosneKila T~)I{ KI!Ie nocneACTBI!I~ Ail~ COTPYAHI!IKa, TO pa3Mep WTpacpa yseili!IYI!IBaeTC~ Ill MO)I{eT 6b1Tb ycTaHOBileH CYAOM B pa3Mepe OT 200 AO 500 TbiC~Y py6neV!. rpo31!1T 11111 pa60TOAaTei110 YfOilOBHOe HaKa3aHI!Ie 3a HeBbmnaTy 3apnnaTbl? YronosHa~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a 3aAep)I{KY 3apa6oTHoVI nnaTbl HacTynaeT no cTaTbe 145.1 YronosHoro KOAeKca 111 so3naraeTc~ TOilbKO np111 ycTaHosneHI!IIil BIIIHbl. Ec11111 3apa6oTHa~ nnaTa He BbmnaYI!IBaeTc~ YaCTI!IYHO (T. e. BblnilaYI!IBaeTC~ MeHee nOilOBI!IHbl CyMMbl) CBblwe 3 MeC~4eB , TO pa60TOAaTeilb HeceT OTBeTCTBeH: HOCTb s BIIIAe wTpacpa s pa3Mepe AO 120 000 py6ne111 11111111 Ili!IWeHI!I~ CB060Abl Ha CpOK AO 1 fOAa . Ec11111 3apa6oTHa~ nnaTa He BbmnaYI!IsaeTc~ nonHoCTbiO CBbiWe 2 MeC~4eB , TO pa60TOAaTei110 rp031!1T OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb B BIIIAe WTpacpa B pa3Mepe OT 100 AO 500 Tb i C~Y py6neV! 11111111 Ili!IWeHI!I~ CB060Abl Ha CpOK AO 3 neT c Ili!IWeHI!IeM npasa 3aHI!IMaTb onpeAeneHHble AOil)I{HOCTI!I Ha CpOK AO 3 neT.

KyAa HYMC:HO o6paiL\aTbCR, ~To6bl B3biCKaTb C pa60TOAaTenR 3apa6oTHYIO nnayY? Pa6oTHI!IK MO)I{eT o6paTI!ITbC~ c 3a~sneHI!IeM o HeBblnilaTe 3apnnaTbl s KOMIIICCIIIIO no TPYAOBbiM cnopaM (KTC), KOTOpa~ C03AaeTC~ B 10-AHeBHbiVl CpOK 1113 paBHOfO KOili!IYeCTBa npeACTaBIIITeneV! pa60TOAaTeil~ Ill pa-

3a51BileHI.-1e pa60THI.-1Ka nOAfle)f{I-1T 06513aTeilbHOCi per1.-1crpa1..11-11-1 B KTC, a TPYAOBOCI cnop AOil)f{eH 6b1Tb paccMorpeH B reYeHI.-1e 10 KaneHAapHbiX AHeei co AH51 noAaYI-1 3a51BneHI.-151 . Ecn~.-1 rpe6oBaHI-151 corpyAHI.-1Ka 6YAYT npi-13HaHbl KOMI-1CCI.-1eei 060CHOBaHHbiMI-1, TO OHI-1 YAOBIleTBOp5110TC51 B nonHoM o6beMe. Ecn1.1 peweHI-1e KTC He 6biilO 1.-1cnonHeHo, ro pa6orHI-1Ky Bb1Aai:iTC51 cne1..11-1ai1bHOe YAOCTOBepeHI.-1e, KOTOpoe 51BI151erc51 l-1cnonHI-1TenbHbiM AOKyMeHTOM. B reYeHI.-1e rpexMeC51YHoro cpoKa co AH51 BbiAaYI.-1 3TY 6yMary CileAyer npeAb51BI-1Tb B Cfly)f{6y CyAe6HbiX npi-1CTaBOB Afl51 npi-1HYAI-1TeilbHOro I-1CnOI1HeHI-151 . 8 IIIHCneKI..IIIIIO no TPYAY )l(ano6y o HeBbmnare 3apnnarbl MO)f{HO HanpaBI.-1Tb B rocyAapCTBeHHYIO 1.1HCneKI..II-110 no TPYAY· B o6pall.leHI.-11.1 Heo6xOAI-1MO yKa3aTb ¢aMI-1Ill-110, 1.1M51, OTYeCTBO, nOYTOBblei aApec, HOMep rene¢oHa , a TaK)f{e nepi.-10A, 3a Koropblei He BblnilaYI.-1Banacb 3apnnara, o6Ll.IYIO cyMMY 3aAOil)f{eHHOCTI.-1 1-1 APYrl.-1e o6cro51renbCTBa, I.-1Mei0Ll.ll-1e OTHOWeHI-1e K Aefly. PeKOMeHAyeTC51 npi.-1I10)f{I-1Tb K o6pall.leHI.-110 KOnl.-110 TPYAOBoro AOroBopa, a TaK)f{e AOKa3arenbCTBa HeBbmnaTbl 3apnnaTbl, eCill-1 OHI-1 I.-1MeiOTC51 . 06pall.leHI.-1e MO)f{HO nOAaTb Ili.-1YHO I-1Ill-1 HanpaBI.-1Tb no nOYTe 3aKa3HbiM ni-1CbMOM c yBeAOMileHI-1eM o BpyYeHI-11-1. KpoMe roro, ero MO)f{HO nepeAaTb 1.-1 Yepe3 1.1HTepHeT B ¢opMe 3IleKTpOHHOrO AOKyMeHTa . 06pall.leHI-1e paccMarp!.-1Baerc51 B reYeHI.-1e 30 AHeei co AH51 ero nonyYeHI.-151 . Ecn1.1 ¢aKT 3aAep)f{KI.-1 3apa6orHoei nnaTbl 6yAeT ycraHoBneH , TO pa60TOAaTei110 6yAeT BbiAaHO npeAni.-1CaHI-1e o Bbmnare BaM 3apnnarbl , a raK)f{e npot.~eHTOB 3a ee 3aAep)f{Ky. KOHTpOill-1pyer I-1CnonHeHI.-1e npeAni-1CaHI-151 I.-1HcneKI..II-151 no TPYAY· 8 paHOHHbiH CYA norpe6oBaTb BblnilaTbl 3aAOfl)f{eHHOCTI-1 no 3apnnare MO)f{HO, nOAaB I-1CKOBOe 3a51BileHI-1e B paeioHHblei CYA I-1Ill-1 K Ml-1pOBOMY CYAbe no Mecry Haxo)f{AeHI.-151 pa6oroAaren51 . K 1.1CKY Heo6XOAI-1MO npi-1Il0)f{I.-1Tb AOKyMeHTbl , nOATBep)f{AaIOLl.ll-1e ¢aKT pa60Tbl B opraHI-13al..ll-11-1 (TPYAOBOCi AOroBop, npi-1Ka3 o npl-1eMe Ha pa6ory, 3an1-1cb B TPYAOBoei KHI-1)f{Ke , cnpaBKI-1 or pa6oroAareIl51), 1.-1 AOKyMeHTbl , nOATBep)f{AaiOLl.ll-1e HeBblnnary 3apnnaTbl (pacYeTHble Ili-1CTKI-1 , Bblni-1CKI-1 1.-13 6aHKa, CBI-1AeTeilbCKI-1e nOKa3aH!.-151). 8 MlllpOBOH CYA Ecn1-1 3apa6orHa51 nnara 6b1na HaYI.-1CileHa, HO He BblnilaYeHa, Bbl MO)f{eTe o6paTI.-1TbC51 B M!.-1poBoei CYA 3a BbiAaYeei cyAe6Horo np!.-1Ka3a, KOTOpblei 1.-1 6yAeT 1.1CnOilHI.-1TeilbHbiM AOKyMeHTOM. 8 np!.-1Ka3HOM nOp51AKe MO)f{HO B3biCKaTb KaK CYMMY AOilra , TaK 1-1 HaYI-1CileHHble npOI..\eHTbl 3a HeCBOeBpeMeHHYIO Bbmnary. CyAe6Hblei np!.-1Ka3 AOil)f{eH 6b1Tb BbiHeCeH B TeYeHI.-1e n51TI-1 AHeei co AH51 o6pall.leHI.-151 B CYA. nocne BbiHeceHI.-151 peweHI.-151 ero MO)f{HO o6)f{anoBaTb B reYeHI.-1e 10 AHeei .

4ro AeAaTb, ecAH He nAarstr «4epHyiO» 3apnAary? fl pa6oTato B KOMnaHMM ceKpeTapeM. Pa6oTOAaTenb nnaTM11 MHe «'fepHyto» aapnnaTy B KOHBepTe Halllll'fHbiMIII. no CllOBaM AMpeKTopa, OH He XO'feT Oci>OpM11HTb MeHH, 'fT06bl CHIII3111Tb paCXOAbl. ,[\0 HeAaBHero BpeMeHIII Bbl· nna'fMBanocb ace ceoeepeMeHHO. Ho cel4'fac Hawy «'fepHyto» JapnnaTy JaAep>KMBatoT. Y>Ke 6onee ABYX HeAenb. LitMeto 11111 H npaeo 'fTO·TO Tpe6oeaTb? KyAa-To no>KanoeaTbCH? Hn111 «'fepHaH» aapnnaTa COBCeM HIIIKaK He 3all.IMLl.leHa JaKOHOM? IOrOHI..IeBa HpMHa, r. BopoHe>K ,[l,n51 nOHI.-1MaHI.-151 CI-1Tya1..11-11-1 BaM CileAyeT 3HaTb, YTO pa6ora B KOMnaHI.-11-1 6e3 o¢opMileHI.-151 TPYAOBbiX OTHOWeHI-1Ci 3TO HapyweHI.-1e TPYAOBoro 3aKOHOAarenbCTBa. Pa6oroAarenb o6513aH 3aKiliOYI-1Tb c corpyAHI-1KOM cornaweHI.-1e He noJ,QHee, YeM Ha rper1-1Ci AeHb nocne HaYana l.-1cnonHeHI.-151 I-1M cso1.1x o6513aHHocreei (cr. 68 TK Pet>). 0 3aYI-1CileHI.-11-1 pa60THI-1Ka B WTaT COCTa8Il51eTC51 npi-1Ka3, C KOTOpbiM ero AOil>KHbl 03HaKOMI-1Tb. nepBblei 3K3eMni151p AOrosopa xpaHI-1TC51 B KOMnaHI.-11-1, a Bropoei- nepeAaerc51 corpyAHI-1Ky. To, YTO Bbl BblnOilH51eTe nopyYeHHble HaYailbHI-1KOM JaAaHI-151, o3HaYaer Hani-1YI.-1e TPYAOBbiX orHoweHI.-1Ci. Ho 3TO He rapaHTI-1pyer nOilHOCi 3all.II-1Ll.leHHOCTI-1 BaWI-1X npaB. ,[l,n51 3all.II-1Tbl CBOI-1X I-1HTepeCOB BaM norpe6yeTC51 AOKa3aTb, YTO pa6ory Bbl BblnOilH51ere no nopyYeHI.-110 HenocpeACTBeHHOro pyKoBOAI.-1Tei151, a He no saweMy Ili-1YHOMY >KenaHI.-110 . .QoKa3aTb 3TO 6onee YeM peailbHO. ,[l,n51 3TOrO BaM noHaA0651TC51 CBI-1AeTeilbCKI.-1e noKa3aHI-151, noATBep)f{AeHI.-151 ¢aKTos nepeAaYI-1 AeHer, ayAI-10- I-1Ill-1 BI-1AeocBI-1Aerenbcrsa, AOKyMeHrailbHble AOKa3aT9IlbCTBa 1.-1 npoyee. ,[l,n51 3all.II-1Tbl CBOI-1X 3aKOHHbiX npaB Bbl I.-1Meere B03MO>KHOCTb: 1. npi-10CTaHOBI.-1Tb pa6ory, eCill-1 3aAep>KKa BblnilaTbl 3apnnarbl cocras1.-1na 6onee 15 AHeei. ,[l,n51 3Toro HY>KHO yseAOMI-1Tb pa6oroAaren51 1-1 yroYHI-1Tb y 10p1.-1cra, AOnycri.-1MO Ill-1 BaM npi-10CTaHOBI-1Tb I-1CnOI1HeHI.-1e CBOI-1X 06513aHHOCTeei. 2. CocraBI.-1Tb >Kano6bl B 111HcneKI..II-110 no TPYAY 1-1 npoKyparypy o HapyweHI.-11.-1 TPYAOBoro 3aKOHOAarenbcrsa. On1-1carb c1.-1rya1..11-110 Heo6XOAI-1MO noApo6Ho. PeKoMeHAyeM >KanoBaTbC51 He TOilbKO Ha HeBblnilaTy «YepHOCi» 3apnnaTbl, a Ha HapyweHI.-1e ycnos1.-1Ci TPYAa - orcyrcrBI.-1e TPYAOBoro cornaweHI-151 . TaK y sac 6onbwe waHcos pa3pewi-1Tb c1-1rya1..11-110. 3. TaK)f{e Bbl MO)f{ere noAaTb I-1CK B CYA· B CI-1TYal..ll-11-1 c pa6oroei 6e3 o¢opMneHI.-151 TPYAOBoro cornaweHI-151 1-1 Bblnnaroei «YepHOCi» 3apnnaTbl saM norpe6yerc51 B paMKax cyAe6Horo pa361.-1parenbcrsa AOKa3aTb, Yro: cyll.leCTBosaIll.-1 ¢aKTI.-1YeCKI-1e TPYAOBble orHoweHI.-151; 3a BblnOilHeHHYIO pa6ory Bbl He nonyYI-1Ill-1 onnary. Pa3Mep 3anpaw1-1saeMoei s I-1CKe onnarbl raK)f{e norpe6yerc51 o6ocHosarb. ,[J,n51 3Toro Ill.-160 npeAOCTaBI.-1Tb CBI-1AeTeilbCTBa npeAb1AYLl.II-1X BblnilaT «YepHOCi » 3apnnarbl, ecn1-1 cyMMa 6b1Ila OAI.-1HaKosoei Ka>KAblei MeC511..\, n1-16o 6a3bl Afl51 pacYera 3apnnaTbl. B KpaC!HeM cnyyae, MO>KHO onl-1paTbC51 Ha cpeAHIOIO 3apnnary no peri.-10HY Afl51 Baweei AOil>KHOCTI.-1 . -·-----------------

TpyAOBoe npaso

B~ti6MpaeM cnoco6 o6paii.\8HMA noAaTb >Kano6y MO>KHO: - Il~YHO; - 3aKa3HbiM n~CbMOM; - 3JleKTpOHHOiil nOYTOi/i (Ha aApec, yKa3aHHbllil Ha caliiTe Tepp~Top~anbHoro opraHa); - Yepe3 ~HcpopMa~~OHHO-KOHCYilbTa~~OH Hbllil nopTan PoCTPYAa www. oHnaliiH~HcneK ~~~.pep.

n~CbMeHHOe o6palJ.leH~e

B TPYAOBYIO ~H no 3aKOHY paCCMOTp~T B TeYeH~e 30 AHelil co AH~ ero per~cTpa~~~. B oco6biX cnyYa~x (Hanp~Mep, HY>KHa BbleJAHa~ npoeepKa) 3TOT cpoK npoAJ1~T. HO He 6onee YeM Ha 30 AHelil . cneK~~IO

TPYAOBa~ ~HcneK~~~ o6~3aHa npoeecT~ npoeepKy no >Kano6e mo6oro YenoeeKa. OH He o6~3aTenbHO AOil>KeH 6b1Tb COTPYAH~KOM npeAnp~~T~~/opraH~3a~~~ . TPYA~H cneK~~~ npoeep~T ~ 3a~BileH~e co~cKaTen~. KOTOpbllil CY~TaeT, YTO eMy He3aKOHHO OTKa3ail~ B np~eMe Ha pa60Ty. ECI1~ npeAnp~~T~e nnaT~T 3apnnaTy e KOHBepTe (nonHOCTbiO ~n~ YaCT~YHo) , a TPYA~HcneK~~~ noATBepA~T 3TOT cpaKT, TO OTBeYaTb np~AeTC~ He TOilbKO pa60TOAaTeIliO, HO ~ COTPYAH~KaM . no 3aKOHy, Aa>Ke c «Cepolil» 3apnnaTbl rpa>K,QaH~H AOil>KeH 3annaT~Tb HA<llfi. TpyA~HcneK ~~~ nepeAaCT ~HcpopMa~~IO e HanoroeyiO, a Ta HaY~cn~T Hanor Ha nonyYeHHYIO paHee 3apnnaTy e KOHeepTe. rocyAapcTBeHHa~ ~HcneK~~~ TPYAa: - np~H~MaeT ~ paccMaTp~eaeT n~cbMa , 3a~eneH~~ . >Kano6bl, a TaK>Ke APYr~e o6palJ.leH~~ rpa>K,QaH c yKa3aH~eM Ha HapyweH~~ ~x TPYAOBbiX npae; - npeAnp~H~MaeT Heo6xoA~Mble Mepbl no ycTpaHeH~IO HapyweH~Iil . a TaK>Ke BOCCTaHOBJleH~IO HapyweHHbiX npae.

Aa>Ke ecn~ TPYAOBa~ ~HcneK~~~ np~MeT peweH~e o TOM, YTO B AeliiCTB~~X pa60TOAaTeJl~ HapyweH~~ 3aKOHa He Ha6JliO,D,aeTC~, ~HCneKTOp ,IJ,OI1>KeH 6yAeT 060CHOBaTb ero B HanpaeneHHOM BaM OTBeTe, nOAKpen~B pe3yilbTaTaM~ npOBeAeHHOiil npoeepK~ . C nonyYeHHbiM OTBeTOM Bbl MO>KeTe 06paT~TbC~ B BbiWeCTO~lJ.l~e opraHbl Ail~ 06>KaIlOBaH~~ peweH~~ TPYAOBOIII ~HcneK~~~ .

BbiACHAeM, KyAa lKanoaaTbCA ~ano6a noAaeTc~ no MecTy per~cTpa~~~ pa6oTOAaTen~ . 06biYHO 3TO IOP~A~YeCK~Iil aApec opraH~3a~~~/ npeAnp~~T~~. Ecn~ 3aBOA HaXOA~Tc~ e CapaToee, Ho 3aper~crp~poeaH e MaxaYKane - To >Kanoearbc~ np~AeTc~ ~MeHHO e AarecTaH. A,Qpeca Tepp~Top~anbHbiX opraHOB <lleAepanbHolil cny>K6bl no TPYAY ~ 3aH~TOCT~ pa3MelJ.leHbl Ha caliiTe http://www.rostrud .ru/. Ha pa6oTOAaTenelil, KOTOPble 3aper~cTp~poea H bl e MoCKBe ~ MocKoecKolil o6nacT~ . >Kano6y HY>KHO noAaBaTb e rocyAapCTBeHHYIO TPYAOBYIO ~HcneK~~IO MOCKBbl.

TpyAoBoe npaso

MolKHO nM lKanoaaTbCA aHOHMMHO? B HeKOTOpbiX CilyYa~x pa60TH~K XOYeT no>KailOBaTbC~ Ha HaYanbcTeo ~HKOrH~To. Hanp~Mep , KOrAa Tep~Tb pa6oTy Bbl He xoT~Te, a ~cnpae~Tb HecnpaeeAf1~BOCTb HY>KHO. An~ 3Toro e o6palJ.leH~~ yKa>K~Te, YTO eo3pa>KaeTe npoT~B coo6lJ.leH~~ pa6oTOAaTeniO eaw~x AaHHbiX. B 3TOM cnyyae 3aKOH o6~3b1Baer ~HcneKropa xpaH~Tb raliiHy o6 ~CTOYH~Ke >Kano6bl (cT. 358 TK P<ll). YKa3aTb ceo~ AaHHble e 3a~eneH~~ see paeHo np~AeTc~ - aHOH~MHble >Kano6bl ocTaIOTC~ 6e3 paCCMOTpeH~~ Ha BnOJlHe 3aKOHHbiX OCHOBaH~~X . Ho B KOJlileKT~Be H~KTO He Y3HaeT, KTO no>Kanoeanc~ e TPYA~HcneK~~IO . Ecn~ Me>K,Qy saM~ ~ HaYailbCTBOM npo~3owen KOHcpil~KT ~ Bbl Ha rpaH~ YBOilbHeH~~ - Tep~Tb y>Ke HeYero. ~anyliiTeCb OTKpbiTO.

H3 nHCEM ~HTATEI1E~ ... *** OCTailOCb nOilrOAa, ~ TYT MeH~ pew~n~ «BbiTYP~Tb» , cMeHI1B Ha npore>Ke. Ha MeH~ HaYan~ AaBI1Tb, YT06bl ~ yeon~n

«AO

neHC~~

c~. OCKOp6Il~Il~ np~ KOJlileKT~Be . 06paT~IlC~

~HcneK~~IO . Konner~

AaeneH~~.

B ~Tore~

noATeepA11Ill1 cpaKT pa6ory». HeaHC.

coxpaH~Il

*** «rl pa6oTaiO 6yxramepoM. Bee ycrpa~ea er, KpOMe OCHalJ.leH~~ 0cp11ca: KOMnbiOTepbl cro~T P~AOM, Ayxora , wyM, KOHA~~I10Hepbl He pa6oraiOT. rl no>Kanoeanc~ e TPYAOBYIO ~HcneK~~IO. cKa3an, YTO pacKpbiBaTb ceoe 11M~ nepeA HaYailbCTBOM He XOYy. B ~Tore ~H cneK~~~ npoeena npoeepKy ~ BbiAana pa6oTOAaTei110 np9An11caH11e ycrpaHI1Tb HapyweH~~ . TaK YTO AO c~x nop pa6oTaiO, H~KaK~x npo6neM c HaYanbCTBOM He 6biilO. 3aro nocne npoeepK~ HaM Aan~ OTAenbHOe noMelJ.leHI1e noA 6yxramep~10 ~ nocTae~n~ KOHA~~~OHepbl». So uc T.

nMW8M

o6pa~eHM8

B 3as:~eneHI!ll!l o6s:~3aTenbHO yKa)I(I!!Te, KaKI!le I!!MeHHO TPYAOBble npaea HapywaeT pa6oTO,QaTenb. npi!II10)1(1!1Te ,QOKyMeHTbl , KOTOpble no,QTBep)I(,QaiOT 1!13IlO)I(eHHble e 3as:~eneHI!ll!l cpaKTbl. '-ITO 06fl3aTei1bHO yKa3biBaTb B 3afiBI1eHI!ll!l: • nonHoe Hai!!MeHoeaHI!le opraHI!13al..ll!ll!l; • ,QOil)I(HOeTb 3afiBI!!Tei1fl; • ¢aKTI!14eeKI!li.1 a,Qpee npe,Qnpl!lfiTI!lf!/opraHI!l3al..ll!1111 ; • ¢aMI!II11!110, I!!Mfll!l OT4eeTeo pyKoeo,QI!!Tens:~; • een111 1!13BeeTHbl, yKa3aTb Tene¢oHbl a,QMI!lHI!leTpal..ll!ll!l (npl!leMHOi-1 pyKOBO,QI!!Tens:~, pyKoeo,QI!!Tens:~ OT,Qena Ka,Qpoe 111 T. n.); • eyTb )l(ano6bl; • 4TO ,QOI1)1(Ha e,QenaTb TPY.QI!!HeneKI..II!lfl: npoeeeTI!l npoeepKy, np111eneYb pa6oTo,QaTens:~ K OTBeTeTBeHHOeTI!l, npi!!Hf!Tb Mepbl ,Qnfl BOeeTaHOBileHI!lfl HapyweHHbiX Tpy,QOBbiX npae; • no,Qnl!leb 111 ,QaTa . Een111 3as:~eneHI!le KonneKTI!IBHoe, 3TO TO)I(e eTOI!IT yKa3aTb 1!1 nO,Qnl!leaTbefl seeM pa6oTHI!!KaM. Een111 pa60THI!IKOB eni!IWKOM MHOro, TO no,Qnl!lel!l e paew1!1¢poeKaMI!l ¢aMI!II11!1i.1 BbiHeei!!Te Ha OT,QeilbHbli-1 Ill!leT 111 np~!!Kpeni!!Te K )l(aIl06e. AneKeei-1 1113 Teepl!l pa60Tai1 B MOeKOBeKOi-1 ¢1!1pMe eaxTOBbiM MeTO,QOM. B noene,QHI!li-1 ro,Q ,QeHbrl!l 3a,Qep)I(I!!Banl!l . B ~!!Tore 3aKa3bl Ha pa6oTy 111ees:~Knl!l, a npe,Qnpl!lfiTI!le oeTanoeb ,QOil)I(HO MY)I(4111He no4TI!l 200 Tblefl4 py6nei.1. 06111,Qenl!l 111 ,Qpyri!IX KOnner. no3TOMy OHI!l Bee BMeeTe Hanl!leanl!l KonneKTI!IBHoe 3as:~eneHI!le no MeeTy perl!leTpal..ll!ll!l KOMnaHI!ll!l, B Tepp~!!TOpl!lailbHOe OT,QeneHI!le TPY.QI!!HeneKI..II!ll!l e Teep111.

noAaeM 3aRaneHMe • ni!14HO. B TPY.QI!!HeneKI..II!IIO B03bMI!!Te 2 3K3eMnns:~pa 3as:~eneHI!lfl. O,QI!IH oeTaHeTes:~ y eae, npoene,QI!!Te, 4T06bl Ha HeM eeKpeTapb noeTaBI!ln HOMep exo,Qflll.lero ,QOKYMeHTa 111 ,QaTy npi!!Hf!TI!lfl. • B Te4eHI!le 30 ,QHei-1 e 3TOi-1 ,QaTbl (e l!leKni041!1TenbHbiX enyYaflx - 60 ,QHei-1) Ha npe,Qnpl!lfiTI!llll ,QOI1)1(Ha 6b1Tb npoee,QeHa npoeepKa. B npoTI!IBHOM enyYae )l(anyi-1Teeb e npoKypaTypy. • no4TOi-1 Poeel!ll!l . 3anOI1HI!!Te yee,QOMileHI!le 0 ,QOeTaBKe . Kor,Qa yBe,QOMileHI!le BepHeTefl, Ha HeM 6y,QeT eTOf!Tb ,QaTa 111 no,Qnl!leb Ill!ll..la, npi!!Hf!Bwero nl!lebMO. «0Te4eT» epeMeHI!l ,Qnfl npoeepKI!l 6y,QeT l!l,QTI!l e 3TOi.1 ,QaTbl. • '-lepe3 V1HTepHeT. CaMbli-1 npoeToi-1 111 3¢¢eKTI!IBHbli.1 enoeo6. Ho eeTb O,QI!IH HIOaHe - npe,Qeapi!!TenbHO HY)I(HO 3aperl!leTp1!1poeaTbefl Ha eai-1Te roeyenyr www.gosuslugi. ru. KaK 3TO e,QenaTb, 4111Tai-1Te e I!!HeTPYKLII!ll!l «3aperl!leTp1!1poeaTbes:~ Ha nopTane roey,QapeTBeHHbiX yenyr» . • V1TaK, 3ai.1,QI!!Te Ha eai-1T OHnai-1HI!!HeneKI..II!lfl.p¢. Ha)I(MI!!Te «Coo6Ll.II!!Tb o npo6neMe» . 8b16ep111Te TeMy 111 pe3ynbTaT, KOTOpbli-1 XOTI!!Te nony41!1Tb: npoeepKa npe,Qnpl!lf!TI!lfl , np1!1Bfle4eHI!le BI!IHOBHbiX K OTBeTeTBeHHOeTI!l l!lfll!l KOHeynbTal..ll!lfl no peweHI!IIO npo6neMbl. noene ompaBKI!l cpopMbl Ha n04TY npl!l,QeT 1!13Bell.leHI!le 0 TOM, 4TO )l(afl06a npi!!Hf!Ta K paeeMoTpeHI!IIO. Bee. )l(ano6y, no,QaHHYIO 4epe3 V1HTepHeT, 06fl3aHbl paeeMOTpeTb, KaK 111 06bi4HYIO 6yMa)I(HyiO, B Te4eHI!le 30 ,QHei-1. >Kano6y MOryT OCTaBMTb 6e3 paCCMOTpeHMR no cneAytoll.IMM npMlfMHaM: ~ Een111 eee,QeHI!lfl o 3afiBI!!Tene He yKa3aHbl l!lfll!l yKa3aHbl He,QOeTOBepHO. ~ B TeKeTe )l(ano6bl I!!MeiOTefl Hel..leH3ypHble Bblpa)l(eHI!lfl ~!!Ill!! OeKOp6neHI!lfl .

CneAyeT 3HaTbl • Een111 Bbl He eornaeHbl e BbiBO,QaMI!l eoTpy,QHI!!Ka rpy,Q-I!!HeneKI..II!ll!l no pe3ynbTaTaM npoeepKI!l - )l(anyi-1Teeb Ha I!!HeneKTopa ero pyKoBO,QI!!TeniO. Een111 111 pyKOBO,QI!lTenb TPY.QI!!HeneKI..II!ll!l He noMor - o6pall.lai-1Teeb e npoKypaTypy 111 e ey,Q. C,QenaTb 3TO MO)I(HO 111 He ,QO)I(I!l,Qas:~eb OKOH4aHI!lfl npoeepKI!l Tpy,QI!!HeneKI..II!ll!l . • npe)I(,Qe 4eM o6paTI!!Tbefl B Tpy,QI!!HeneKI..II!IIO, Hanl!lWI!!Te pyKOBO,QI!!TeniO npeTeH31!110 e npoeb6oi.1 pewi!!Tb npo6neMy e pa3yMHbli.1 epoK. • He ni!IWI!!Te 3as:~eneHI!le o6 yeonbHeHI!ll!l «no eo6eTeeHHOMY )l(enaHI!IIO» . ,[\a)l(e een111 ,QI!lpeKTop oYeHb npoei!IT. no,Q,Qa,QI!!Teeb Ha yroeopbl - PYKOBO,QeTBO e 41!1eToi-1 eoeeeTbiO Ili!IWI!IT Bae 4aeTI!l 06f!3aTeflbHbiX KOMneHeal..ll!li-1 np111 eoKpall.leHI!ll!l . 6e3 eeeKI!IX OeHOBaHI!li-1, npe,QyeMOTpeHHbiX TPYAOBbiM 3aKoHo,QaTenbeTBOM, yeoni!!Tb Bae HI!IKTO He MO)I(eT. • Een111 Hanl!leanl!l TaKoe 3as:~eneHI!le, noMHI!!Te: ero MO)I(HO OT03BaTb. C,QenaTb 3TO Ha,QO B nl!lebMeHHOM Bl!l,Qe. Tpy,Qoeoi-1 KO,QeKe Pc:t> npe,QyeMaTpl!leaeT, 4TO pac 6oTHI!IK He ~!!MeeT npaea OT03BaTb 3as:~eneHI!le o6 yeonbHeHI!ll!l TOilbKO B enyYae, KOf,Qa Ha ero MeeTO B nl!lebMeHHOi-1 ¢opMe np111rnaweH ,Qpyroi-1 pa6oTHI!IK, KOTopoMy He MO)I(eT 6b1Tb OTKa3aHO B 3aKn104eHI!ll!l ,QOrQBOpa.

TpyAoBoe npaso

CKynoil nnaTHT ABa)I(At.l

4,5 MeTpa Ha Ka)I(Aoro 0YeHb YaCTO S L!eilSIX 3KOHpML-'H1 pa60TO,QaTei11.1 Ca>KaiOT CS01.1X nO,QOneYHbiX 6yKSailbHO ,Qpyr ,Qpyry Ha fOilOSbl. 3TO He3aKOHHO . 3anOMHI.1Te : S oqmce pa60Yee npocrpaHCTSO O,QHOro COTpy,QHI.1Ka ,QOil>KHO 3aH1.1MaTb He MeHee 4 ,5 KSa,QpaTHbiX Merpos. 111 aro np1.1 ycnos1.11.1, Yro Ha ero pa6oYeM crone CTOSIT TOilbKO CI.1CTeMHbllil 6IlOK 1.1 MOHI.1TOp, a np1.1 Hai11.1YI.11.1 ,QOnOilHI.1TeilbHOfO o6opy,QOSaHI.151 (KOTOpoe SISilSleTCSI ,QOnOilHI.1TeilbHbiM 1.1CTOYHI.1KOM 3IleKTpOMarHI.1THOfO 1.13IlyYeHI.151 - np1.1HTep, CKaHep, cpaKc) nilOLL!a.Qb ,QOil>KHa 6b1Tb eLL~e 6onbwe .

Ecnu ycnoeuR pa6o&~eeo Mecma eac cMy~a10m, cMeno JKanyumec& e Tpyooey10 uHcneK~UIO, npot<ypamypy u Pocnompe6Hao3op. Ha&~an&HUKY e&muwym wmpacjJ, u eMy npuoemcR pewam& eonpoc c pacwupeHueM pa6o&~eeo npocmpaHcmea.

HH rapaHTMH, HH KOMneHCai4MM rapaHTL-11.1 1.1 KOMneHCal..!L-11.1 3aSI.1CSIT OT MHOfi.1X cpaKTOpOS 1.1 ycraHaBI11.1SaiOTCSI He seeM pa6oTHI.1KaM . K rapaHTI.1SIM 1.1 KOMneHcal!I.1SIM OTHOCSITCSI : COKpaLL!eHHaSI npO,QOil>K1.1TeilbHOCTb pa60Yero speMeHL-1, ,QononHI.1TeilbHble ornycKa, ,QeHe>KHble SblnnaTbl, npe,QyCMOTpeHHble KaK 3aKOHOM, TaK 1.1 IlOKailbHbiMI.1 aKTaMI.1 pa6oro,Qaren51 , 1.1 MHoroe ,Qpyroe. Ecn1.1 , Hanp1.1Mep, rosop1.1Tb o pa6oTHI.1Kax, SblnOilHSIIOLL!I.1X pa6ory so spe,QHbiX ycnosi.1SIX rpy,Qa, TO rapaHTI.1SIMI.1 6y,QeT SISilSITbCSI ,QOnOilHI.1TeilbHbllil OTnYCK He MeHee 7 KaneH,QapHbiX ,QHelil, 36-YacosaSI npo,QOil>KI.1TeilbHOCTb pa6oYero speMeHI.1, 4% .~:~onnaTbl K rap1.1cpHolil crasKe (oKila.QY). O,QHaKo see SbiWenepeL~1.1cneHHble rapaHTL-11.1 1.1 KOMneHcal..!L-11.1 He scer,Qa orpa>KeHbl s rpy,QosoM ,Qorosope. Ecn1.1 sawa pa6ora npe,Qnonaraer ,QononHI.1TeilbHbllil ornycK 1.1Ill.1 np1.16asKy K OKila,Qy, a Sbl H1.1 roro, HL-1 ,Qpyroro ,Qa>Ke s ,Qorosope He SI.1,Qei11.1 , aro noso,Q KaK MI.1HI.1MYM nO,QHSITb 3TOT sonpoc C HaYailbCTSOM 1.1 KaK MaKCI.1MYM o6paTI.1TbCSI S Tpy,QOSyiO 1.1HCneKL!I.110.

He BHec a AOroaop nyHKT o aapnnaTe? nnaTH wTpact:t K HapyweHI.1SIM S o6naCTI.1 OnilaTbl rpy,Qa OTHOCI.1TCSI 1.1 HeyKa3aHI.1e s rpy,QosoM ,Qorosope ,Qsyx ,QaT sbmnaTbl 3apa6orHolil nnaTbl, ycnos1.1ill nonyYeHI.1Sl 3apa6orHolil nnaTbl , pa3Mepa OKila,Qa, SCeS03MO>KHbiX SI.1,QOS nOilO>KeHHbiX Ha,Q6aSOK 1.1 ,QOnnar, Kp1.1rep1.1es npeM1.1posaHI.1Sl 1.1 npoYI.1X sonpocos, OTHOCSILL!I.1XCSI K onnare rpy.Qa.

TpyAoaoe npaao

Ka3anocb 6bl , oYesi.1,QHO , YTO, ,QonycKaSI corpy,QHI.1KOS K pa6ore 6e3 npoxo>K,QeHL-151 o6Sl3arenbHbiX npe,Qsap1.1TeilbHbiX 1.1Ill.1 nep1.10,QI.1YecKI.1X Me,QI.1L!I.1HCKI.1X OCMOTpOS, pa60TO,QaTeilb HapywaeT 3aKOHO,QaTeilbCTSO, O,QHaKO MHOfi.1X HaYailbHI.1KOS 3TO MailO OCTaHaSI11.1Saer. no 3TOMY HapyweHL-110 CTaTI.1CTI.1Ka 3aWKai11.1Saer, npaKTI.1YeCKI.1 S Ka>K,Qoi/1 STOpoi/1 opraH I.13al!l.11.1 OCMOTpbl He nposo,QSITCSI. fi1.16o O,QHI.1 , n1.16o .~:~pyr1.1e . A Me>K,Qy reM pa6oro,QarenSI wrpacpy10r 3a Ka>K,Qoro pa6oTHI.1 Ka , Koropbllil He npowen Me,QI.1L!I.1HCK1.1ill OCMOTp . (4eHa SOnpoca - OT 15 TbiCSIY ,QO 130 TbiCSIY py6nelil . 3TO HapyweHI.1e paccMarp1.1saercSI no orHoweHL-110 KO seeM pa6oTHI.1KaM opraHI.13al!l.11.1 , KOTOpble ,QOil>KHbl npOXO,QI.1Tb npe,Qsap1.1TeilbHble 1.1 nep1.10,QI.1YeCKI.1e Me,QI.1L!I.1HCKI.1e OCMOTpbl. ECI11.1 >Ke y pa60TO,QaTei1Sl eCTb cnel!l.1anbHble Karerop1.11.1 pa6oTHI.1KOS, Hanp1.1Mep , SO,QI.1Tei11.1 , TO np1.1 HapyweHL-11.1 nopSI,QKa npoxo>K,QeH1.1Sl Me.Q1.1L!I.1HCKI.1X ocMorpos y HI.1X np1.1MeHI.1M el!.!e O,QI.1H SI.1,Q a,QM1.1HI.1CTpaTI.1SHOiil OTSeTCTSeHHOCTI.1 ,QOnOilHI.1TeilbHOiil crarbelil, r,Qe wrpacpbl or 2 000 ,QO 50 000 py6nelil .

3a yrp03bl npMAeTCR OTBe'laTb HacroliiY1.1Sble rpe6osaHI.1Sl pyKoso,QI.1TeIlSI Han1.1carb 3aSlsneHI.1e no co6crseHHOMY >KenaHL-110 , conposo>K,QaeMble yrpo3aMI.1 YSOI11.1Tb no CTaTbe , MOryT CTaTb nOSO,QOM o6palL!eHI.1Sl S Tpy,QOSYIO 1.1HCneKL!I.110 ,QilSI npose,QeHI.151 nposepKL-1 . Y pa6oro,QareI1Sl Her 3aKOHHbiX cnoco6os .Q061.1sarbCSI ysonbHeHI.1Sl corpy,QHI.1Ka no co6crseHHOMY >KenaHL-110 . 8r1.1 ,Qelilcrsi.1Sl s np1.1HL!I.1ne npori.1S03aKoHHbl. Tpa.QI.1L!I.10HHble Mero,Qbl , Sbi>KI.1SaHI.1Sl" HeycrynYI.1SOfO pa60THI.1Ka 1.13 opraHI.13al!l.11.1 npe,QcrasnSIIOT co6olil pa3H006pa3Hble sap1.1al!l.11.1 rex 1.1Ill.1 1.1HbiX npas HaHI.1MaeMoro (s nepsy10 oYepe,Qb rpy,Qosoro ,Qorosopa). B c1.1ny ,QaHHoro o6CTOS!Tenbcrsa nose,QeHI.1e pyKoso,QI.1TenSI MO>KeT 6b1Tb 1.1CnOilb30SaHO KaK nOSO,Q ,QilSI Sbi,QSI.1>KeHI.1Sl cy,Qe6Horo 1.1CKa : no o6si.1HeHI.110 s Kilesere (CT. 128.1 YK P<l> ), OCKOp6IleHI.11.1 (CT. 5 .61 KoAn) 1.1 T. ,Q .

3a CO,Qep>KaH~e >K~nbiX ,QOMOB, B TOM 4~Cne 3a 4~CTOTY KpOBHeCeT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb ynpaBmHOl.l.laSl KOMnaH~Sl. CHer, CKOn~BW~~CSl Ha K03blpbKaX 6anKOHOB ~ no,Q>K~~ . TaK>Ke ,QOn>KeH y6~paTbCSl C~naM~ ynpaBnSltol.l.le~ KOMnaH~~ . nn~Tbl 6anKOHOB ~ BHeWHSlSl CTeHa, K KOTOpO~ ,QaHHble 6anKOHbl np~MbiKatoT, OTHOCSlTCSl K 06l.l.leMy ~Myl.l.leCTBY MHOrOKBapT~pHOro ,QOMa, a nep~na , OKHa, ,QBep~ yKa3aHHbiX 6anKOHOB SlBnSltoTCSl 4aCTbiO >K~noro noMel.l.leH~Sl , TO eCTb 06beKTOM ~H,Q~B~,QyanbHO~ C06CTBeHHOCT~ . 3a 4~CTOTO~ KOMMep4eCK~X noMel.l.leH~~ : Mara3~HOB , anreK ~ TOprOBbiX l.leHTpOB, 06Sl3aHbl cne,Q~ T b ~ HecyT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb sna,Qenbl.\bl 3,QaH~~ . Ecn~ s ,Qorosope apeH,Qbl 3Ta OTBeTCTBeHn~ .

1. 06paT~Tecb B asap~~HO-,Q~cneT4epcKyto cnY>K6Y sawe~ ynpasnSltol.l.le~ KOMnaH~~ ~ paccKa~Te no,Qpo6HO 0 npo6neMe. 06paT~TbCSl MO>KHO KaKYCTHO no TenecpoHy, TaK ~ n~CbMeHHO. 8 nto60M cny4ae ,Q~CneT4ep 06Sl3aH 3aHecT~ sa we 3aSlsneH~e B >KYPHan. 06Sl3aTenbHO cnpoc~Te y np~HSlBwero y sac ,Q~cneT4epa ero cpaM~n~to ~ ~MSl , a TaK>Ke per~ cTpal.I ~ OH H bl~ HOMep sawero o6pal.l.leH~R 2. B cnY4ae, ecn~ ynpasnSltol.l.laSl KOMnaH~Sl n peTeH3~~ npo~rHop~pyeT, a onaCHble .QnSl >K~3H~ Hane,Q~ ocTaHYTCSl Ha TOM >Ke MeCTe, onOBeCT~Te B n~CbMeHHO~ cpopMe 0 6e3,Qe~CTB~~ >K3Ka a,QM~H~CTpal.\~10 pa~OHa ~ lopO,QCKYIO >K~n~l.l.IHYIO ~HcneKL.\~10 . 06bi4HO TaK~e o6pal.l.leH~Sl paCCMaTp~BaiOTCSl He3aMe,Qn~TenbHO, noTOMy 4TO Hane,Q~ MOryr yrpo>KaTb >K~3H~ ~ 3,QOpOBbiO, a TaK>Ke ~Myl.l.leCTBy. TaK~e o6pal.l.leH~Sl B 60nbW~HCTBe CnY4aeB pewatoT npo6neMy. Y6opKa KpbiW npo~3BO,Q~TCSl csoespeMeHHO. 3a HapyweH~e npas~n CO,Qep>KaH~Sl >K~nbiX ,QOMOB, HeCBOespeMeHHYIO 04~CTKY KpbiW~ OT CHera ~ Hane,Q~ pyKoBo,Q~Ten~ ynpasnSltol.l.I~X KOMnaH~~ ~ caM~ opraH~3al.l~~ no,Qne>KaT a,QM~H~CTpaT~BHOMY HaKa3aH~to. npeAYCMOTpeHHOMY cTaTbe~ 7.22 Ko,QeKca o6 a,QM~H~cTpaT~BHbiX npasoHapyweH~SlX, B B~,Qe wTpacpa s pa3Mepe: Ha ,QOn>KHOCTHbiX n~l.l - OT 4 ,QO 5 TbiCSl4 py6ne~; Ha opraH~3al.\~~- OT 40 ,QO 50 TbiCSl4 py6ne~ , a np~ HaCTynneH~~ TSl>KK~x nocne,QCTB~~- yronosHo~ OTBeTCTBeHHOCT~ no cTaTbe N2 293 YronosHoro KO,QeKca P<l> «XanaTHOCTb».

EcnM onacHa.ae cocyna.KM Ha KapHM3e Mara3MHa 1. 06paT~Tecb c npeTeH3~e~ K aJ)eH,QaTopy ~n~ co6cTseHH~KY 3,QaH~R noTpe6y~re ycrpaHeH~Sl HapyweH~~ . 2. Ecn~ co6crseHH~K He pear~pyer Ha >Kano6bl, o6par~recb c n~CbMeHHO~ >Kano6o~ s a,QM~H~crpal.\~10 ropo,Qa.

06PA3EI...I

3A~BflEHLo1~

_ __ _ _ __ OT___________ ~ , yn . _ _____ _ __ PyKoBo,Q~rento

T. _ _ _ _ _ __ nPETEH3Lo1~

, co6crseHH~ K KBapr~pbl N2 npo>K~Bato B ,QOMe, o6cny>K~saeMoM Bawe~ opraH~3al.l~e~ . rlsnSlSlCb ~cnonH~reneM ycnyr no co,Qep>KaH~to o6l.l.lero ~Myl.l.lecrsa, Bawa OpraH~3al.\~Sl He3aB~C~MO OT cpopMbl C06CTBeHHOCT~ ~ opraH~3al.\~OHHO-npaBOBO~ cpOpMbl 06Sl3aHa npe,QOCTaB~Tb norpe6~Tento ycny r~ . COOTBeTCTBYIOl.l.l~e no Ka4eCTBY 06Sl3aTenbHbiM rpe60BaH~SlM CTaH,QapTOB, CaH~Tap HbiX npas~n ~ HOpM , ycraHosneHHbiM HOpMar~saM ~ ycnoB~SlM ,Qorosopa, a raK>Ke ~HcpopMal.l~~ o >K~n~l.l.IHbiX ycnyrax . no3TOMY 04~CTKa 06l.l.le,QOMOBOrO ~Myl.l.leCTBa >K~nbiX ,QOMOB OT CHera, Hane,Q~ (cocyneK), npe,QCTaBnSlIOl.l.I~X yrpo3y >K~3H~ ~ 3,QOpOBbiO rpa>K,QaH , ,QOn>KHa OCyl.l.leCTBnSlTbCSl ynpaBnSltol.l.I~M~ opraH~3al.\~SlM~. rl ceo~ o6Sl3arenbcrsa no ,Qorosopy ~cnonHSlto perynSlpHo, nna4y 3a ycnyr~ no co,Qep>KaH~to 06l.l.lero ~Myl.l.le crsa . Coo6l.l.lato, 4TO Ha Kpblwe Hawero ,QOMa cne,Qyer npo~3Becr~ cpo4HYto y6opKy cHera ~ Hane,Q~ . WanKa, cKon~swaSlcSl Ha Kposne , rpo3~T o6san~ T bCSl np~ nepso~ onenen~ Ha npoxo>K~x ~n~ np~napKosaHHble asroMo6~n~. npowy np~HSlTb Mepbl. _ __ _ __ .20_ r. ( no,Qn~cb) rl,

._._._._._._._~ . ~~~·u ·~ ~ ·-

~~1

MOMEIITA.TJI.HO IIPII OGPAmEIIIIH

3anpoc o npooepKe npas•nbHOCT" """"c!

JleHIMI pa3Mepa nnaTbl 3a KOMMyHaJlbHble ycnyr1o1, 3a,Q01l}l{eHHOCTio1 1o1111o1 nepennaTbl, npaslo11lbHOCTio1 Ha41o1ClleHio1~ norpe61o1remo HeycroeK (wrpacpos, neHei'l). }f(ano6a o6 o6Hapy}l{eHio11o1 3anaxa ra3a s noMell.leHio'l~x 111o160 Ha ,QBOpOBOi'l Tepplo1TOplo11o1.

C9 ~ORBneH•e

0 COCTOBneHH"

nponlo1Tio11o1 . V1H<!>OpMal..llo1~ 0 ,Qe~TellbHOCTio'l ynpaBJl~IO ll.lelo'l opraHio13al..llo11o1 : - o6ll.la~ lo1Hcj:>OpMal..llo1~ o6 YK, TC}f(, }f(CK, }f(K; - 06 OCHOBHbiX noKa3aTeJl~X cp1o1HaHCOBO-X0-

3~i'lCTBeHHOi'l ,Qe~nellbHOCTio'l ;

- o MK,O,, cocrase o6ll.lero lo'IMYll.lecrsa; - o BblnOllH~eMbiX pa6orax (oKa3biBaeMbiX ycnyrax) no co,Qep}l{aHio'lto "' peMOHTY o6ll.lero lo'IMYll.lecrsa B MK,O, 1o1 1o1x crolo'IMOCTio'l; - 06 OKa3biBaeMbiX KOMMyHallbHbiX ycnyrax, B TOM 41o1CJle CBe,QeHio'l~ 0 nOCTaBll.llo'!KaX KOMMYHallbHbiX pecypcos, rap1o1cpax "' HOpMaTio'!Bax, o6 lo'!CnOJlb30BaHio11o1 o6ll.lero lo'IMYll.lecrsa B MK,O,; - 0 Kanlo'!TaJlbHOM peMOHTe 06ll.lero lo'IMYll.leCTBa B MK,O,; - o npose,QeHHbiX OCC, 1o1x pe3yllbrarax (pe-

nocrynneHio'l~.

weHio'l~x);

- o cnyYa~x nplo1Blle4eHio1~ YK, TC}f(, }f(K K a,QMio1Hio1CTpaTio1BHOi'l OTBeTCTBeHHOCTio'l 3a HapyweHio'l~.

Ynpasn~toll.la~ opraHio13all"'~ o6~3aHa HanpaBio'!Tb no 3anpocy 3a~Bio1Ten~ CCblllKY Ha pecypc B lo'IHTepHere, r,Qe ,QaHHa~ lo1HcpopMal..llo1~ pacKpbiTa . 3anpoc ,QaHHbiX, KOTOpble YO"' TC}f( pa3Mell.lator Ha CTeH,QaX, ,QOCKaX 06b~BlleHio1i'l, BbiBeCKaX, Ha cai'lTe opraHio13al..llo11o1 lo1 B rV1C }f(KX, comacHo n.n . 31,32 nn P<l> NQ416. V1Hcj:>OpMal..llo1~ 0 nOKa3aHio1~X 06ll.le,QOMOBbiX np1o16opos yYera. }f(ano6a Ha KaYecrso npe,QocrasneHio'l~ KOMMyHaJlbHbiX ycnyr. B reYeHio'le cyroK, ecn1o1 nplo141o1Ha lo13secrHa. Ec111o1 Her, ror,Qa Heo6xo,Qio1MO comacosarb ,Qary "' speM~ npose,QeHio'l~ nposepK1o1 KaYecrsa ycnyr1o1 . nocne nonyYeHio'l~ aKTa nposepKio'l 1o1 3aKllto4eHio1~ 3KcnepTio13bl YK o6~3aHa orserlo'!Tb s reYeHio'le 5 ,QHei'l co ,QH~ no,Qnlo'lcaHio'l~ aKTa 1o1111o1 3KCnepTio13bl .

B Te4eHio1e ,QBYX 4aCOB C MOMeHTa perlo'ICTpal..llo'llo'l 3a~BKio1, HO He paHee 8 Yacos yrpa 1o1 He no3,QHee 23 Yacos seYepa np1o1 KpymocyT04HOM nplo'leMe 3a~BOK.

KoMMyHallbHble x11onoTbl

3 4

I ~

=------- ·- ---··-

~ ~3MeHeH~~ IJ\ ~ 1V1Ha~ ~HcpopMal.\lr1~. cop,ep>KaH~e

.·· BTEt.IEHIIE 10 ,li,HEti

8 TEqEHIIE 2

3a~sneH~e

o6 paaMepa nnaTbl aa

B TEqEHIIE 3_ ,li,HEii _

IJ\ ~ 1V1HcpopMal.\~~

o (o6): . . - noMeC~4HbiX o6beMax norpe6neHHbiX KOMMyHanbHbiX pecypcos no noKaaaH~~M OAnY; - cyMMapHOM o6beMe KY, norpe6neHHbiX B

noMell.leH~~x

MK,Q;

- 06beMaX KOMMyHaDbHbiX ycnyr, paCC4~TaH HbiX C np~MeHeH~eM HOpMaT~BOB norpe6neH~~ ;

- o6beMax KP, norpe6n~eMbiX B 1.1en~x cop,ep>KaH~~ o6Ll.lero ~Myll.lecrsa s MK,Q; - noKaaaH~~x OAnY aa nep~op, He 6onee 3 neT CO ,IJ,H~ CH~H1~ noKa3aH~Lil . He noap,Hee 3 pa6o4~x p,HeLil co p,H~ nocrynneH~~ aanpoca. Kon~~ cnep,ytoll.I~X p,oKyMeHros: - aKra o np~4~HeH~~ yll.lep6a >K~3H~. 3,1J,Op0Bbl0 ~ ~Myll.leCTBY C06CTBeHH~Ka ~n~ nonbaoearen~ noMell.leH~~ B MK,Q, OV1 B MK,Q; - aKra HapyweH~~ Ka4ecrsa ~n~ npeBblweH~~ ycraHosneHHOLil npop,on>K~renbHOCT~ nepepb!Ba B oKaaaH~~ ycnyr ~n~ BblnOnHeH~Ir1 pa6or; - aKra nposepK~ npep,ocrasneH~~ KY HeHap,ne>Kall.lero Ka4ecrsa ~n~ c nepepbiBaM~. npeBb1Watoll.llr1Mir1 ycraHosneHHyto npop,on>K~renb HOCTb. 3a~sneHir1e Ha nepepac4eT nnaTbl aa KY HeHap,ne>Kall.lero Ka4ecrsa. 3a~BneHir1e 0 BBO,D,e V1nY B 3KCnnyaTai.\~IO . nocne cornacosaH~~ pa6or YO o6~aaHa BblnODHir1Tb BBO,IJ, V1nY B Te4eH~e 30 ,D,HeLil C MOMeHTa ycraHOBK~ . >Kano6a Ha Ka4ecrso npep,ocrasneH~~ KOMMyHanbHOLil ycnyr~ no o6pall.leHir1to c TKO.

3 4

~•

17\

~--

- -····

--~~~

B TEqEHIIE 5 ,li,HEH•

V1HcpOpMal.\lr1~ 0 nepe4H~X, o6beMax, Ka4ecrse ~ nep~op,~4HOCT ~ OKa3aHHbiX ycnyr ~ (~n~) BblnODHeHHbiX pa60T. 3a~eneH~e o nepepacYere nnarbl aa KOMMyHanbHble ycnyr~ Ha cpoK speMeHHoro

orcyrcrs~~ norpe61r1ren~ .

5 pa6o4~X p,HeLil nocne nony4enlr1CbMeHHoro aa~eneH~~ o nepepacYere P,O neplr10,Qa BpeMeHHOrO OTCyrCTB~~ - n1r160 B re4eH~e 30 pa6o4~X p,HeLil nocne OKOH4aHir1~ nep1r1op,a speMeHHoro orcyrcrs~~B

Hir1~

Te4eH~e

He nepe41r1cneH-

Ha~ B nyHKTaX 31-34 nn P<l> 416, OT-

HOC~Ll.la~c~

>K~noro noMell.leH~~-

K ynpasneH~to MK,Q. o nposepKe V1nY. 3anpoc c rpe6osaH~eM yMeHbWeH~~ onnarbl aa oKaaaHHble ycnyr~ YO ~n~ B03Mell.leH~~ y6biTKOB, B03Hir1KW~X ~3-3a TOfO, 4TO norpe61r1Tenb CaMOCTO~TeDbHO 1r1cnpasn~n Hep,opa6orK~ aa YO (1r1n~ HaH~Man rperbe n~1.10) . A raK>Ke rpe6osaH~e o soaspare p,eHer, KOTOpble y>Ke ynna4eHbl, 1r1 B03Mell.leHir1~ pacxop,os, KOropble B03H~Kn~ 1r1a-aa orKaaa or BbmonHeH~~ p,orosopa.

3a~sneH~e

~ l'i'\

co6crseHH~KOM

RBJlR>O!Jl"MCR aosareneM noMe "'"""" B MKJ1.

\;;./

I {

~n~

nonb-

I · '

k::1:aoaneH~~~ ~

npoBBAe""" o6u,ero co-

6paH~~ co6crseHH~KOB (OCC) B nlr1Cb-

MeHHOLil cpopMe. 3TOM ycnyra ,QOD>KHa 6b1Tb npep,OCTaBneHa He noap,Hee 4eM aa 10 p,HeLil p,o p,arbl nposep,eH~~ 06Ll.lero co6paH~~ - npep,cras~ren~ YO raK>Ke o6~3aHbl ysep,oMir1Tb o nposep,eHir1~ co6paH~~ Ka>K,D,oro co6crseHH~Ka np~

noMell.leH~~ -

nepeexamt

HOBYIO

KBapTHpy

npH

o~opMneHHH AOKyMeHTOB a ynpaenfiiOll.leM

KOMnaHHH c YAHBneHHeM o6Hapy>KHnH, "'TO CTapble X03SieBa OCTaBHnH HaM B npHAa"'y AOnrH no >KHnHUIHO-KOMMyHanbHbiM ycnyraM. LITo HaMAenaTb? CaMOXHHa 0. 111., HH>KeropoACKafl o6n.

Aa>Ke np~ nposeAeH~~ CAenoK Yepe3 p~enTopos ~n~ areHTCTBa MOryT B03H~KH)ITb npo6neMbl C AOnraM~ npe>KH~X BnaAenbl..leB. K CYaCTbiO, 3aKOH Ha CTOpOHe HOBbiX xo3~es, xoT~ ynpasn~IOLl.l~e KOMnaH~~ noYT~ scerAa nbiTaiOTC~ o6~3aTb ~x ynnaY~BaTb AOnr~. AOCTasw~ec~ ~M

no HacneACTBy. B cT. 153 >K~n~Ll.lHOro KOAeKca P<l> np~Mo CKa3aHO, YTO 06~3aHHOCTb no OnnaTe KOMMyHanbHbiX ycnyr ~ COAep>KaH~IO >K~nb~ y C06CTBeHH~Ka KBapT~pbl, KOMHaTbl ~ npoYero >K~nb~ B03H~~aeT c MOMeHTa np~o6peTeH~S'l npasa co6cTBeHHOCT~ Ha 3TY >K~nnnoll.laAb. C IOP~A~Ye cKoi/1 TOYK~ 3peH~S'l 3T~M MOMeHTOM CY~TaeTCS'l AaTa BbiAaY~ HOBOMy X03S'l~HY KBapT~pbl CB~AeTenbCTBa 0 npase co6cTBeHHOCT~. CooTBeTCTBeHHO, see AOnr~ no >KKX, noS'IB~Bw~ecs:~ AO 3Toli1 AaTbl, o6s:~3aH onnaT~Tb npeAbiAYLl.\~111 X03S'l~H KBapT~pbl. LJT06bl o6e3onac~Tb ce6s:~ OT no.Qo6HbiX npo6neM, HY>KHO npeAnp~HS'ITb HeCKOnbKO waroB. npe)I(Ae YeM nOAn~CaTb AOrOBOp 0 noKynKe KBapT~pbl, 3an~W~Te noKa3aH~S'l CYeTY~KOB Ha CBeT ~ BOAY ~ yKa>K~Te ~X B aKTe np~eMa-nepeAaY~ >K~nbS'l. V1n~ COCTaBbTe OTAenbHbiH aKT 0 TeKYLl.\~X noKa3aH~S'IX np~6opoB yYeTa. noAn~caTb 6yMary AOn>KHbl ~ Bbl, ~ npoAaBel..l KBapT~pbl. Kon~10 aKTa 3aTeM HanpaBbTe >K3Ky, YT06bl ~MeHHO 3T~ AaHHble CY~Tan~Cb HaYanbHbiM~ np~ npoBeAeH~~ HaY~cneH~S'l saM nnaTbl 3a «KOMMyHanKy» . TaK Bbl 6yAeTe onnaY~BaTb TonbKO Te K~ nosanbl ~ Ky6oMeTpbl, KOTOpble ~cTpaT~n~ caM~. B npoT~BHOM Cnyyae YCTaHOB~Tb, «CKOnbKO >Ke 6blnO Ha CYeTY~Ke» Ha MOMeHT nepeAaY~ BaM KBapT~pbl, He YAaCTCS'l, ~ np~AeTcs:~ nnaT~Tb 3a TO, YTO noTpe6~n aKc-snaAeneL.~ .

EcnM ynpaanRIO"'aR KOMnaHMR He xo~teT nepeo*opMnRTb AaHHble nM~eaoro C'teTa Ha aawe MMR M3·3a cTapbiX AOnroa Han~w~Te 3as:~sneH~e Ha ~MS'l A~peKTopa YK ~n~ npeACeAaTens:~ TC>K. B npo~3BOnbHoli1 cpopMe On~W~Te C~Tya1..1~10, YTO Bbl CTan~ HOBbiM C06CTBeHH~KOM KBapT~pbl ~ He 06S'l3aHbl HecT~ 3aTpaTbl Ha ee COAep>KaH~e 3a npeAbiAYLl.l~X xo3s:~es . CcbmaliiTecb Ha cT. 153 >K~ n~Ll.\Horo KOAeKCa. np~nO>K~Te KOn~IO CB~Ae TenbCTBa o npase co6CTBeHHOCT~. 3as:~sneH~e pacneYaTaliiTe B ABYX 3K3eMnns:~pax . Ha OAHOM ~3 H~X nOTpe6yi/1Te KOMMyHanbll.\~KOB pacn~ CaTbCS'l, YTO OH~ nonyY~n~ ero.

EcnM a nnaTe)I(HbiX AOKyMeHTax 3a HOBbiH pac~teTHbliil nepMOA cyM· Ma AOnra npOAOn)I(Mna OTpa)l(aTbCR >KanyeMcs:~ B npoKypaTypy, fJKV1 ~n~ s PocnoTpe6HaA30p (o6pa31..1bl 3as:~sneH~Ii1 - B KOHI..Ie TeKCTa). rocyAapCTBeHHble opraHbl no 3aKOHY «0 nops:~AKe paccMoTpeH~S'l o6pall.\eH~Ii1 rpa>KAaH P<l>» AOn>KHbl AaTb OTBeT He noJAHee YeM Yepe3 30 AHei/1 . B TeYeH~e aTOro cpoKa HaA3opHble opraHbl nposeAYT nposepKy ~ s cnyYae, ecn~ ycTaHOBS'IT cpaKT HapyweH~Iil. HanpaBS'IT B aApec KOMMyHanbll.\~KOB npeAn~CaH~e.

E"'e HecKona.Ko coaeToa:

nepeO*OpMnReM n•n"eBOH C'teT Cpa3y nocne nonyYeH~S'l cB~AeTenbCTBa o npase co6CTBeHHOCT~ B PocpeecTpe C op~r~HanOM ~ KOn~ei/1 3TOrO AOKyMeHTa ompasns:~eMcs:~ B YK ~n~ K npeACeAaTeniO TC>K. KoMMyHanbll.l~K~ BHeCYT ~3MeHeH~S'l B n~L.~eBoi/1 cYeT: AaHHble CTapbiX BnaAenbL.~eB ~3MeHS'IT Ha saw~ . Tenepb see KB~TaHI..I~~ 6YAYT BbiCTaBnS'ITb Ha sawe ~MS'l.

• Bo-nepBbiX, AO noAn~caH~S'l AOrosopos ~ nepeAaY~ AeHer Tpe6yli1Te OT co6cTBeHH~KOB KBapT~pbl cnpaBOK OT KOMMyHanbLl.\~KOB, YTO AOnrOB no KBapT~pe HeT. .QOKyMeHTbl, He06XOAHMble AnSI nepeoct>opMneHHSI:

- KcepoKon~s:~ ~ op~r~Han cB~AeTenb CTBa 0 rocyAapCTBeHHOH per~cTpa1..1~~; - cnpasKa ~3 nacnopTHoro cTona o cocTase ceMb~ c AaToi/1 Bbln~CK~ npe>KH~x >K~nbi..IOB;

K~MMyHanbHble

xnonoTbl

- np~ anbHbiX

Han~Y~~

np~60pOB

B KBapT~pe ~HA~B~AY yYeTa - aKTbl BBOAa B

3KCnnyaTaLIHIO, TeXHHYeCKHe nacnopTa H noKa3aHHSl npH60pOS Ha MOMeHT nepeAaYH KsapTHpbl 3a nOAnHCbiO npoAas4a H

noKynaTens:~.

nycTb noKa)f{YT cnpasKH H3 ynpaSils:IIOW,el:1 KOMnaHI111, SOAOKaHana, 3Heproc6b1Ta 11!111 APYri1X yype)f{AeHI11:1 06 OTCYTCTSI111 AOilroS . • 8o-sTOpbiX, TaKytO HHcpopMalll110 MO)f{HO nonyYI1Tb caMOCTOS'ITeilbHO. Hanp11Mep, no3SOHI1Tb s ynpasIls:IIOW,YIO KOMnaHI110 11 Y3HaTb, YI1CI111TCS'I n11 KsapT11pa s cn11cKe AOI1)f{HI1Kos. Mo)f{HO nposepHTb AOI1rl1 11 s TepM11Hane «C6ep6aHKa» - no aApecy KsapT11pbl 11 HOMepy Ili11..\9SOro cYeTa. 8 Kpai:1HeM cnyYae nposepbTe X03SlHHa 11 scex )f{I1Ilbl.IOS no 6aHKY 11cnonH11Tei1bHbiX npo113SOACTS Cny)f{6bl cyAe6HbiX np11cTasos. 8-TpeTbi1X, np11 nOAn11CaHHI1 aKTa np11eMa-nepeAaYI1 KSapT11pbl 0Tpa311Te S HeM see KOHeYHble AaHHble 11HA11S11AyanbHbiX cYeTYI1Kos Ha cseT, SOAY. oTonneHI1e . 8 cnyYae cnopos c KOMMyHailbW,11KaMI1 y sac 6yAeT AOKyMeHTailbHOe nOATSep)f{AeHI1e TeX noKa3aHI11:1, 3a KOTOpble OTSeYaeT npe)f{HI11:1 SilaAeilel.l .

O&PA3El-' 3AJIBnEHMJ1 PyKOSOA11TentO opraHa )f{I1Ili1W,Horo HaA30pa (Ha3saHI1e cy6beKTa Pel>)

(Cl> .Ill. 0 . pyKOSOA11T9Ils:l) OT~~---------------

(CI>.III .O.

3as:ISI1T9Ils:!)

co6cTseHHI1Ka KsapTI1Pbl N2_ _ , panOI10)f{9HHOL:1 S MHOroKsapTI1pHOM AOMe noaApecy : ~-----------yn. , A._ _ Ten .:_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

>KAfl05A B r>KII'I

np0)f{I1Sal0 S MHOroKsapT11pHOM )f{I1IlOM AOMe no SbiWeyKa3aHHOMY aApecy. np1106pen npaso C06CTS8H-

20_

HOCTH Ha AaHHYIO KSapT11py «_»

r. YnpaSils:IIOW,as:l opraHI13alii1Sl OTKa3blsaeTCSl np0113-

seCTI1 KOppeKT11pOSKY Ili1LieSOrO CYeTa MOei:1 KSapTI1pbl 11 He Cni1CbiSaeT 3aAOil)f{eHHOCTb no )f{I1Il11W,HO-KOMMyHailbHbiM ycnyraM 3a npeAbiAYW,I11:1 nep110A, HeCMOTps:! Ha TO YTO, S COOTSeTCTSI111 CO CT.

153 >K11I111W,HOrO

KOAeKca Pel>, AOI1rl1 no )f{I1Ili1W,HO-KOMMyHailbHbiM ycnyraM AOil)f{eH onnaYI1SaTb co6cTseHHI1K, KOTOpb11:1 snaAen HeAS11)f{I1MOCTbiO S nep110A S03HI1KHOSeHI1Sl AOnra. HI13alll110 «

HeOAHOKpaTHO o6paw,ailCSl S ynpaSils:IIOW,YIO opra-

» C YCTHbiM11 11 ni1CbMeHHbiMI1 3as:ISileHI1SlMI1

(yKa3aTb ee nonHoe Ha3saH11e) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --

- - - --

- - - -- · (nepeYI1CI111Tb AaTbl o6paw,eH111:1) 8 pe3yilbTaTe MOI1X 06paUJ,eHI11:1 ynpaSils:IIOW,as:l opraHI13al.II1Sl He SblnOilHI1Ila MOI1X 3aKOHHbiX Tpe6osaHI11:1 , YeM HapyWI1Ila MOI1 npasa 11 HOpMbl )f{I1Il11W,HOrO 3aKOHOAaTeilbCTSa .

Ha OCHOB3HIIIIII BbiWel!l3110)f{eHHOrO npowy: 1. nposeCTI1 nposepKy no AaHHOMY cpaKTY 11 np11SileYb SI1HOSHbiX !1111..1 K aAM11HI1CTpaTI1SHOL:1 OTSeTCTSeH HOCTI1 .

2. 06s:~3aTb ynpaSils:IIOW,YIO opraHI13alll110 «

(yKa3aTb ee nonHoe Ha3saH11e) np0113SeCTI1 nepepaCYeT 3a ycnyr11 )f(IO( MOei:1 KSapT11pbl 11 S AailbHei:1weM He OTpa)f{aTb SbiWe yKa3aHHYIO 3aAOil)f{eHHOCTb S npeAOCTaSils:leMbiX MHe nnaTe)f{HbiX AOKyMeHTaX, a TaK)f{e Cni1CaTb AOI1rl1 npe)f{HI1X C06CTS9HHI1KOS . 0 pe3yilbTaTaX npowy np011HcpOpM11pOSaTb M9HS'I ni1CbM9HHO no yKa3aHHOMy SbiWe aApecy S ycTaHOSileH Hble 3aKOHOM «06 06paUJ,eHI111 rpa)f{AaH» CpOKI1 . nplllllO)f{eHIIIe:

npi1Il0)f{I1Tb KOnl111 AOKyMeHTOS, nOATS9p)f(AaiOW,I1X 113Il0)f{9HHble SaMV1 cpaKTbl (eCI111 OHI1 11M910TCSl), nepeYI1CI111S Ka)f{Abli:1 113 H11X, Hanpi1Mep :

1. Kon11s:1

CS11AeTenbcTsa o co6cTseHHOCTI1.

2. Kon11s:1 aKTa np11eMa-nepeAaYI1 KsapT11pb1.

3. Kon11s:1 4. Kon11s:1

OTseTa ynpasns:~tOw,el:1 opraHI13alll111. nnaTe)f{HbiX AOKyMeHTOS

- ======-

KoMMyHanbHble xnonoT

I~U

KaK AOKa3aTb, '-ITO B KBapn~pe

YrenASIT AJ-1 CTeHy?

XOAOAHO?

B HeCKOflbKMX KBapTMpax Ha HaWeM 3Ta>Ke MHOrOKBapTMpHOrO AOMa xonoAHee, ~eM Ha APYrMx 3Ta>Kax. Mbl, >KMTenM, c~MTaeM, ~To npo6neMa a TOM, ~To HY>KHO yTennMTb ~aCTb CTeHbl CHapy>KM. CKa>KMTe, MO>KeM nM Mbl o6paTMTbCH a AYK c 3aHaneHMeM o He06XOAMMOCTM TeKYll.lero peMOHTa B BMAe yTenneHMfl CTeHbl? MMpoHoa n. A, r. KMpoa

B KaapTMpe y>KacHo xonOAHO, a ynpaanfltoll.lafl KOMnaHMfl OTKa3biBaeTCfl Aa>Ke npMMTM 3aMepMTb TeMnepaTypy. Mo>KHO nM Bbi3BaTb 3KCnepTOB M3 KaKOM•TO Apyrol4 opraHM3a .... MM? C!>ponoaa AHHa, r. BopoHe>K 4T06bl COCTaBIIITb aKT nposepKIII Ka4eCTBa KOMMyHaflbHO~ ycnyrlll, He06~3aTeflbHO npiiiCYTCTBIIIe npeACTaBIIITefl~ ynpasn~IOLl.\e~ KOMnaHIIIIII. V1 y>K reM 6onee

B coorsercTBIIIIII c nplllno>KeHIIIeM N!! 8 nocra-

He HaAO nplllsneKaTb APYryiO opraHIII3al.IIIIIO. An~ aroro MO>KHO nplllrnaCIIITb ABYX COCeAe~. KOTOpble He CB~3a Hbl c saMIII POACTBeHHbiMIII yJaMIII. Xopowo, ecn111 cpeAIII HIIIX 6yAeT npeACeAarenb cosera AOMa . HaniiiWIIITe s aKTe, Ha 4TO >Kanyerecb, yKa>KIIITe reMneparypy, speM~. AaTy Ill ¢>V10 CBIIIAeTene~ C nOAniiiC~MIII (B TOM 4111Cfle CBOIII). 4epe3 HeCKOflbKO AHe~ MO>KeTe nOBTOpiiiTb npo4eAypy. Ornpasbre aKT s ynpasn~IOLl.\YIO KOMnaHIIIIO, Kon11110 (ecn111 YK 6e3Ae~crsyer) B roc>KIIIfliiiHCneKl.IIIIIO. TeMneparypa B KBapTIIIpe He AOfl>KHa 6b1Tb HIII>Ke +18 rpaAYCOB. 3a Ka)I{Abl~ 4aC OTKflOHeHIII~ OT HOPMbl nonmKeH nepepacYeTnnara AOfl>KHa 6b1Tb yMeHbweHa Ha 0,15%. YK

HosneHIII~ roccrpo~ P¢> or 27 ceHr~6p~ 2003 r.

06~3aHa

Bbi~CHIIITb

np1114111HY 111 ycrpaHIIITb npo6neMy.

B noABaAe

npopsaAo

KaHaAJ.13aUJ.itO: KOMY y6J.ipaTb? EcnM a noAaane AOMa npoM3owen npopbiB KaHanM3a .... MM, KOTOpbiM 6bln ycTpaHeH, TO KTO AOfl>KeH flMKBMAMPO· aaTb nocneACTBMfl npopbiBa? Ky3He ....oa Erop, r. BopoHe>K 0TBeT3aBIIICIIITOTTOro, OTHOCIIITC~fllll nOABan K06Ll.\eAOMOBOMY IIIMYLl.\eCTBY lllfllll HeT. 3aBIIICIIIT 3TO OT Hafllll4111~ B nOABane IIIH>KeHepHbiX KOMMYHIIIKal.llll~ (CTaTb~ 36 >KIIIfllllll.\HOrO KOAeKca). EcnVI no noABany npoxoA~T rpy6blnoAsan ~sn~erc~ 06l1.1eAOMOBbiM IIIMYL1.\9CTBOM. Ecn111 Tpy6 HeT, TO nOABan HaXOAIIITC~ B 4aCTHO~ C06CTBeHHOCTIII. B TOM cnyYae, 9Cfllll nOABan 06Ll.\9AOMOBO~ , TO o6cny>KIIIBaTb ero AOfl>KHa ynpasn~IOLl.\a~ opraHIII3al.llll~ (4aCTb 2 CTaTblll 162 >KIIIfllllll.\HOro KOA9KCa P¢>). noaroMY B nocTaHOBfleHIIIIII npaBIIIT9flbCTBa OT 03 .04 .2013 N!! 290 CKa3aHO, 4TO B OTHOW9HIIIIII nOABaflOB ynpasn~ IOLl.\a~ opraHIII3al.llll~ o6~3aHa o6ecne4111Tb «npiiiH~TIIIe Mep, IIICKnl04aiOLl.\IIIX noATonneHIIIe, JaxnaMneHIIIe, 3arp~3HeHIIIe Ill 3arpOMO>K,QeHIII9 TaKIIIX nOMell.\9HIII~» . no3TOMY nOCfl9ACTBIII~ npopb!Ba KaHafllll3al.lllllll fliiiKBIIIAIIIpyeT ynpasn~IOLl.\a~ opraHIII3al.IIIIR

N!! 170 "06 yrsep>K,QeHIIIIII npaBIIIfl Ill HOpM TeXHIII4eCKO~ 3KCnnyaTal.lllllll >KIIIfllllll.\HOrO QJOHAa" yre-

nneHIIIe >KIIIflbiX 3AaHIII~ (pa60Tbl no ynyYWeHIIIIO Tenno3all.\IIITHbiX CBO~CTB orpa)I{AaiOLl.\IIIX KOHCTpyK1.1111~ , ycTpO~CTBO OKOHHbiX 3anonHeHIII ~ C TpO ~ HbiM OCTeKneHIIIeM , ycTpO~CTBO Hapy>KHbiX TaM6ypos) npOIII3BOAIIITC~ B nop~AKe pa60T no KaniiiTaflbHOMy peMOHTy, a He TeKyll.\eMy. 0AHaKO o6paTIIITe BHIIIMaHIIIe, 4TO B nop~AKe TeKyll.\ero peMOHTa MOryr npOBOAIIITbC~ pa60Tbl no ycraHOBKe , 3aMeHe Ill BOCCTaHOBfleHIIIIO pa60TOCnOC06HOCTIII OTAeflbHbiX 3fleMeHTOB Ill 4aCTe~ 3fleMeHTOB BHyrpeHHIIIX CIIICTeM l.leHTpanbHOro OTOnneHIII~ , BKfll04a~ AOMOBble KOTeflbHble, a TaK>Ke repMeTIII3al.llll~ CTbiKOB , 3aAeflKa Ill BOCCTaHOBfleHIIIe apXIIITeKTypHbiX 3fleMeHTOB CTeH Ill cpaCaAOB ; CMeHa yYaCTKOB 06WIIIBKIII AepeB~HHbiX CTeH , peMOHT cpaCaAOB . Ecn111 y sac B03HIIIKna Heo6XOAIIIMOCTb cpo4HO nposeCTIII BHennaHOBbl~ TeKYllllll~ peMOHT, 06paTIIITeCb B AOMOynpaBfl~IOLl.\YIO KOMnaHIIIIO C 3a~sneHIIIeM.

ECAJ-1 naHAYC He COOTBeTCTByeT HOpMaM MoH MaMa y~acTHMK BOB, el4 91 rOA, OHa MHBanMA·KOflfiCO~HMK. 4epe3 CYA fl A06Mnacb ycTaHOBKM naHAyca. Ero ycTaHOBMnM , HO c HapyweHMHMM, o~eHb KpyToM noA'beM, C'bexaTb npocTo HeB03MO>KHO. 06pall.lanacb c >Kano6aMM B YK, HO OHM OTKa3biBaiOT B 3aMeHe naHAyca. KaK A06MTbCfl, ~T06b l naHAYC nepeAenanM? 6epAfleBa HaTanbH, r. Tyna B03bMIIITe s cyAe. Koropbl~ BbiHec peweHIIIe no ycTaHOBKe naHAyCa , IIICnOflH III TeflbHbl~ fliiiCT Ill OTHeCIIITe ero s cny>K6y cyAe6HbiX np111crasos. OHIII npeAniiiWYT KOMnaHIIIIII ycraHOBIIITb naHAYC HaAne>Kall.IIIIM o6pa30M. ECfllll KOMnaHIII~ He IIICnOflHIIIT yKa3aHIII~ , Ha Hee MOryT 6b!Tb HaflO>KeHbl WTpacpHble caHKLIIIIIII . Cr. 30 ¢>eAepanbHoro 3aKoHa or 02 .10.2007 r. N!! 229-¢>3 «06 IIICnOflHIIITeflbHOM npOIII3BOACTBe» .

KyAa >KaAosarbcst, ecAH H3 KpaHa reYeT p>KaBaSI BOAa? Y MeHSI H3 KpaHa Te'leT p>KaBaSI BO,Qa. PaCCKa• >KHTe, KYAa >KanosaTbcst? 6enosa HHHa, r. PocTOB·Ha-AoHy Ecn111 p)f(asas:l so,qa nos:lBII1nacb BHe3anHo, TO, cKopee scero, npo6neMbl Ha BO.QOKaHane. Ho )1(111Tenelil He .QOJl)f(Ha BOJlHOBaTb npii1YII1Ha . no >K111llll1l.J..IHOMY KO,QeKcy, 3a K8YeCTBO BO,Qbl B KpaHe OTBeYaeT 111CnOJ1HII1TeJ1b KOMMyHallbHbiX ycnyr: ynpaBJls:liOI.J..Ias:l KOMnaHII1s:l (YK), TC>K 111n111 BO.QOKaHan (ecn111 B .QOMe MeHbWe 16 KBapT111p). Ha,qo np111rnac111Tb npe,qcTaBII1Tens:l YK 111 3acp111KC111posaTb Q:>aKT no.QaYII1 p)f(asolil BO.Qbl, YT06bl saM c,qenan111 nepepacYeT. ECJ1111 HII1KTO He np111,QeT, C03biB8LiiTe COCe,Qelil, COCTaBlls:lliiTe aKT 111 HeCII1Te ero s roc)f(II1J1111HcneK1..111110. KpoMe Toro, He,qasHo roc,QyMa P<l> np111Hs:llla nonpaBKII1 B >K111llll1l.J..IHbllil KO,QeKC, KOTOpble snepBble npe,qycMaTp111BatoT wTpacpbl 3a HeKaYeCTBeHHble ycnyr111. Pa3Mep wTpacpos 111 nops:l.QOK 111x HaYII1CileHII1s:l .QOil)f(HO YCT8HOBII1Tb npaBII1TeJ1bCTBO.

KyAa o6parHTbCSI AASI ycrpaHeHHSI ryAa BKBapTHpe? KynHJlH KBapTHpy. 8 Hell! CHJlbHbiH ryn OT Be• Tpa. noKa He nOHSillH, OTKY.Qa. 803MO)f(HO, seTep rynsteT B CTOSIKe HllH B BbiTSI>KKe. Y HaC ,QOM o6cny)f(HBaeT TC>K. Ky.Qa cne.QyeT o6paTHTbCst, KaK 3TO npaBHJlbHO C,QenaTb? nasneHKO Ceprelil, r. HH)f(HHH HosropoA nepBOHaYallbHO He06XO.Q111MO o6paTII1TbCs:l C 38s:lBileHII1eM B a,qpec Tosap1111.J..1eCTBa co6cTBeHHII1KOB )1(111Ilbs:l , ocyi.J..IeCTBils:ltoI.J..Iero ynpasneHII1e MHOroKBapTII1pHbiM ,QOMOM, B KOTOpOM np11106peTeHa KsapT111pa, 1113J10)1(111B CYTb npo6neMbl. Tosapll1l.J..IeCTBOM .QOJl)f(HO 6b1Tb np01113Be,QeHO 06Cile,QOBaHII1e Ha npe,QMeT Bbls:lBIleHII1s:l np111YII1H noBbiWeHHOro ypoBHSI wyMa. Ecn111 sawa 38s:lBKa 6y,QeT npOII1rHOpll1pOBaHa 111J1111 npii1YII1Hbl 6y.QyT BbiSIBileHbl, HO Mep K 111x ycTpaHeHII1to npe,qnp111Hs:lTO He 6y.QeT, 1..1enecoo6pa3Ho o6paTII1TbCs:l s a,qpec perll1oHailbHoro opraHa rocy,qapcTBeHHoro )1(111Illl1l.J..IHOro Ha,Q30pa, cpyHK1..1111111 KOTOpOrO 111CnOJ1Hs:leT rocy,qapCTBeHHas:l )1(111Illl1l.J..IHas:l 111HcneK1..1111s:l H111)f(eropo,qcKolil o6nacTII1.

AsapH~Hbl~

nOABaA

noMOrHTe, no>KanylilcTal ~ >KHBY B KBapTHpe Ha 1 3Ta>K8, H o'!eHb <~acTo H3 no,Qsana no.Q· HHMaeTCSI KaHallH3a~HSI B Tya• neT H BaHHy H TOnHT HaC, >KKX npH'IHHY He ycTpaHSI8T. YTO ,QenaTb? 3HHOBbeB EsreHHiil, r. Ye6oKcapbl Ecn111 Bbl o6pai.J..Ianii1Cb s YK 111 Y>KKX ropo,qa C nii1CbMeHHbiMII1 )f(afl06aMII1, COCTaBneHHbiMII1 B COOTBeTCTBII1111 C Tpe60B8HII1s:lMII1 3aKOHa, HO, Ha HII1X He OTpearll1pOB8J1111, 8bl snpase o6)f(anosaTb s npoKypaTypy 6eJ.QelitcTBII1e .QOJl)f(HOCTHbiX Illl1l..l YK 111 Y>KKX ropo.Qa. >Kano6a no,qaeTCs:l s nii1CbMeHHOM BII1.Qe s ,qsyx 3K3eMnils:lpax, Ha saweM 3K3eMnnS~pe B K8HI..Ieils:lp111111 yYpe)f(.QeHII1SI CTaBII1TCSI BXO.QSII.J..III11ii HOMep 111 .QaTa npii1Hs:lTII1s:l )f(ano6bl. Tpe6osaHII1s:l K nops:l.QKY 111 Q:>opMe no.QaYII1 )f(ano6 rpa)f(.QaH 3aKpenneHbl s CTaTbe 7 <l>e,qepanbHoro 3aKoHa N259-<l>3 oT 02.05.2006 r. «0 nops:l.QKe paccMOTpeHII1s:l o6pai.J..IeHII11ii rpa)f(,qaH Poccll11iiCKOiil <l>e,qepal..lll1111». np111 no,QaYe nii1CbMeHHolil )f(ano6bl no noYTe rpa)f(.QaHII1H B 06s:l3aTeJ1bHOM nOps:l,QKe ,QOil)f(eH yKa3aTb: Haii1MeHosaHII1e rocy,qapcTBeHHoro opraHa, B KOTOpoe HanpaBils:leT nii1CbMeHHOe o6pa1.J..1eHII1e, Illl160 cpaMII1Illl110, 111Ms:l, OTYeCTBO CO· OTBeTCTBYIOI.J..Iero .QOJl)f(HOCTHOro J11111..1a, Illl160 ,QOil)f(HOCTb COOTBeTCTBYIOI.J..Iero Il111l.la, CBOII1 cpaMII1J111110, 111Ms:l, OTYeCTBO (nOCJle,QHee - np111 Hailii1Y111111), nOYTOBbllit a,qpec, no KOTOpOMY .QOil)f(Hbl 6b1Tb HanpasneHbl OTBeT, yse,QOMileHII1e o nepea,qpeca1..1111111 o6pai.J..IeHII1R >Kano6bl rpa)f(.QaH, He CO,Qep)l(ai.J..III1e BbiWeyK838HHbiX ,QaHHbiX, npii13HaiOTCs:l aHOHII1MHbiMII1 111 He pacCM8Tp111BaiOTCs:l. 8 CaMOM TeKCTe )f(afl06bl He06XO.QII1MO on111caTb CYTb HapyweHII1s:l npas, 06CTOs:lTellbCTBa, np111 KOTOpblX OHO np011130WilO, yKa3aTb no,qpo6Hble cse,qeHII1s:l o6 opraHII13al..lll1111, .QOil)f(HOCTHbiX Illl11..1aX, CO CTOpOHbl KOTOpblX ,qonyi.J..IeHO HapyweHII1e. ECI1111 eCTb B03MO)f(HOCTb npe,QOCTaBII1Tb .QOKyMeHT8IlbHble CB111,QeTeilbCTB8, He06XO.QII1MO B )f(afl06e npocTaBII1Tb CCbiilKII1 Ha HII1X, a ell.le nyYwe np111Il0)1(111Te 111x Kon111111 K )f(ano6e. KpoMe Toro, B KOHI..Ie )f(ail06bl He06XO.Q111MO yKa3aTb npii1IlO)f(eHII1s:l C Onii1Cbl0 npii1KI18.QbiBaeMbiX KOnll1ill .QOKyMeHTOB, yKa3aB KOilii1YeCTBO 3K3eMnilSIpOB. 8 3asepweHII1e )f(ano6bl npocTaBJls:leTCs:l ,qaTa cocTasneHII1s:l 111 no.Qnii1Cb. 06l.J..III11ii cpoK paCCMOTpeHII1SI )f(afl06bl - .QO 30 .QHelil CO .QHSI ee per111cTpa1..1111111. Ecn111 )f(e nii1CbMeHHble )1(8no6bl s YK 111 Y>KKX ropo,qa saMII1 He HanpasIls:lilii1Cb 111Illl1 6b1Illl1 COCTaBileHbl HesepHO npe)f(.Qe scero, cne,qyeT o6paTII1TbCs:l B csoto ynpaBils:liOI.J..IYIO KOMnaHII110 (YK), a 38TeM B Y>KKX ropo,qa (ecn111 sonpoc He pewii1TCs:l}.

-------------------------------------------------=-------~------~------ -

------

MoMeHTOM B0306HosneHI!1S~ ycnyrl!1 S~s aKT OKa3aHII1Sl KaYeCTSeHHOii! ycnyr111. AaHHbllil aKT ,D,On)f{Hbl cocTaSI!1Tb ynpasn51tOLl.laS~ opraHII13al!II1S~ 111 npe,D,ce,D,aTenb CoseTa ,D,OMa 1!1nll1 3aS~SII1Tenll1 . nep1110,IJ, c MOMeHTa cocTasneHII1S~ aKTa o HeoKa3aHHoli1 ycnyre 111 no MOMeHT cocTasneHI/151 aKTa o so306HosneHII1111 npe,D,OCTasneHII1S~ ycnyrl!1 6y,D,eT 51SnS~TbC51 nep1!10,IJ,OM , 3a KOTOpbllil co6cTseHHI!1KI!1 noMell.leHI!1171 MKA snpase noTpe6osaTb nepepacYeT.

War N2 3 06pa111aeMCS! B ynpaBnS~IOLl.IYIO opraHII13al!1!110 1!1 coo6111aeM o HeHaAfle)f{all.leM COCT051HII1111 npii1,1J,OMOBOii1 Tepp111TOp1!1111, yKa3biBa51 KOHKpeTHO , B YeM COCTOI!1T HeCOOTBeTCTBII1e HOpMaM 111 npaBII1naM 1113-3a OTCYTCTB1!1Sl y6opK111 1!1 HaAJle)f(all.lero o6cny)f{II1BaHII1S~. 06513aTenbHO Ha,D,O C006Ll.III1Tb, YTO TaKOe nonO)f{eHI!1e ,D,en CBS~3aHO C OTCYTCTBYleM . y6opKII1 ,IJ,BOpa. 06paTI!1TbCSI MO)f{HO nii1CbMeHHO. np111 3TOM 3aS~sneHII1e ,D,On)f{HO 6b1Tb cocTasneHo B ,D,Byx 3K3eMnnS~pax 111 nepe,D,aHo B ynpasnS~IOLl.IYIO opraHI!13al!l!110. B ynpasnS~tOLl.lelil opraHII13al!ll11!1 ero ,D,On)f{Hbl 3aperll1cTp111posaTb, nocTaBII1Tb ,D,aTy 111 perii1CTpal!I!10HHblli1 HOMep Ha BTOpOM 3K3eMnn51pe 111 sepHyrb ero saM . Mo)f{HO TaK)f{e o6paTII1TbCS~ no TenecpoHy. B 3TOM cnyYae Bbl ,D,On)f{Hbl C006Ll.III1Tb CBOII1 cpaMII1n11110, 111MSI, OTYeCTBO, a,D,pec ,D,OMa, TenecpoH, a TaK)f{e YeTKO ccpopMynlllposaTb, KaK1!1e HapyweHI!1S~ no co,D,ep)f{aH1!110 np111,D,OMosoli1 Teppii1TOp111111 111MetOTCR COTPYAH1!1K, npii1HS~BWII11i1 oT sac TenecpoHorpaMMy, ,D,On)f{eH C006Ll.I111Tb BaM CBOII1 cpaM111n11110 , 111MS!, OTYeCTBO 111 per111crpal!II10HHblli1 HOMep sawero 3aS~sneHII1S~ .

War N2 1

B TeYeHII1e ,D,Byx Yacos (ecn111 111HOe speMS~ He cornacosaHo c saM111) ynpasnS~tOLl.laS~ opraHII13al!II1S~ o6513aHa HanpaBII1Tb csoero npe,D,cTaBII1TenS~ KBaM B ,D,OM AflS~ nposepKII1 sawero 3aS~sneHII1S~ 1!1 cocTasneHII1S~ aKTa. Ecn111 )f{e ynpasnS~tOLl.IYIO opraHII13a!..!11110 yse,D,OMII1Tb He npe,D,CTaBnS~eTCSI B03MO)f{HbiM (Hanp111Mep, ,D,I!1CneTYepcKa51 cny)f{6a He pa6oTaeT) 1!1nll1 ecn111 B ycTaHosneHHoe speM51 npe,D,cTaBI!1Tenb YK He S~BIIlnCS~ , TO aKT cocTasnS~eTCS~ )f{l!1nbl!aMII1 CaMOCT051TenbHO 111 no,D,nii1CbiSaeTCSI He MeHee YeM ,IJ,BYMSI )f{II1Ten51MII1 ,IJ,OMa (Hanp111Mep, SaMI/1 111 sawii1M coce,D,OM) 111 npe,D,ce,D,aTeneM CoseTa MHOroKsapT111pHoro ,D,OMa. )l{enaTenbHO np111 cocTasneHI/1111 aKTa c,D,enaTb cpoTorpacpll1111, KOTOpble no,D,Tsep,QS~T Hanii1YII1e HeHaAJle)f(all.lero co,£J,ep)f{aHI!1S~ ,D,sopa 111 111Hble cpaKTbl HapyweHII151 y6opKII1 MeeT o6111ero nonb30SaHII1S~ .

War N2 2

A y Hac so ABope

nS~eTcS~

PacCYII1TblsaeM cyMMY nepepacYeTa 111 cocTasn51eM npeTeH311110 Ha nepepacYeT. AnSI Toro YT06bl paccYII1TaTb cyMMY nepepacYeTa, He06XO,IJ,II1MO 3HaTb, CKOnbKO S COCTase CTpOKII1 «CO,D,ep)f{aHII1e 1!1 TeKYLl.lll11i1 peMOHT» COCTaSn51eT CTOII1MOCTb ycnyrll1 no y6opKe MeeT o6111ero nonb30saHII151. 3Ta cTOI!1MOCTb YMHO)f{aeTCSI Ha KOnii1YeCTSO KSa,D,paTHbiX MeTpOS noMell.leH1!11i1, np111Ha,D,ne)f{all.I111X C06CTSeHHI!1KaM, ,D,enii1TCSI Ha 30 111 YMHO)f{aeTCSI Ha KOnii1YeCTSO ,D,Helil, KOr,D,a ycnyra He OKa3biSanaCb. VIMeHHO TaKyiO CYMMY ,D,On)f{Ha sepHyrb ynpasnS~tOLl.laS~ opraHII13al!II1S~ co6cTseHHII1KaM, pa3,£J,enll1s ee Me)f{,IJ,y HI!1MII1 nponopl!lllOHanbHO nnoll.la,D,II1 KSapT111p. nonyYII1Tb 111HcpOpMal!ll110 0 Tap1!1cpe Ha y6opKy MeeT o6111ero nonb3osaHI!1S~ MO)f{HO 1!1 Ha cali!Te «PecpopMa )I{KX» no a,D,pecy: www.reformagkh .ru. PacKpbiTb Ha Cali!Te 111HcpOpMal!l!110 0 CTOI!1MOCTII1 CSOII1X ycnyr SISnS~eTCSI o6513aHHOCTbiO ynpasnS~tOLl.lelil opraHII13a!..!111111. 3a 3T111M cne,D,II1T IJKVI. Hanp1!1Mep, CTOII1MOCTb y6opK1!1 MeCT o6111ero nonb3osaHII151 s CTPYKType Tap1!1cpa cocTasn51eT 4 py6nS~ . Ycnyra He oKa3blsanacb s TeYeHYle 25 ,D,Helil. np111 3TOM B ,IJ,OMe pacnOnO)f{eHbl 5678 KS. M )f{lllnbiX nOMell.leHI/1111 . 4 py6nS~ * 5678 KS. M 5678 py6neli1 / 30 * 25 18 926,67 py6neli1 . Ha 3TY cyMMY YK o6513aHa yMeHbW111Tb onnaTy 3a co,£J,ep)f{aHI!1e 111 TeKyll.lelil peMOHT s cne,D,ytOLl.leM MeCS~L!e SCeM C06CTSeHHII1KaM nponOPL!IIlOHanbHO nnOLl.la,IJ,I/1 KsapTII1p. Ecn111 y sac Ha pyKax HeT ,D,orosopa ynpasneHI!151 MKA. s KOTopoM HanlllcaHo, cKonbKO CTOS~T pa6oTbl no y6opKe ,D,sopa, To ero HY)f{HO 3anpoci!1Tb s YK. 3anpoc COCTaSnS~eTCSI S CS060,D,HOii1 cpOpMe. BaM He06S~3aTenbHO CaMOCTOS~TenbHO npOSO,IJ,II1Tb 6yxranTepCKI!1e pacYeTbl, TaK KaK 3TO o6S~3aHa ,D,enaTb ynpasnS~tOLl.la51 opraHII13al!II1S~ . no3TOMY war no npose,D,eHI!110 pacYeTos Sbl MO)f{eTe nponycTI!1Tb 111 cpa3y nepeli1TII1 K 3aS~sneHII110 o nepepacYeTe. 3aS~sneHII1e npe,D,naraeM HanlllcaTb no o6pa3L!Y. np1!1se,D,eHHOMY ,D,anee. K 3a51sneHII110 np1!1nO)f{II1Te KOnll11!1 aKTos 111 cpoTorpacp1111!1.

WarN24

Ecn111 ynpass:1 10 ll.l a s:1 opraHII13al..\111fl He orser111na 111 He np111sena B COOTBeTCTBYIOll.lee CaHII1TapHbiM HOpMaM 111 npas111naM COCTOS'IHII1e ABOp, a raiOKe orKaJanacb Aenarb nepepacyer, ro o6pall.laeMcs:~ c >Kano6o~ B rocyAapCTBeHHYIO >KII1nll1ll.IHYIO 111HCneKI..\11110. fiKVI nposeAeT nposepKy 111 BbiAacr PYKOBOACTBY )1(3Ka npeAn111caHII1e o6 ycrpaHeHII1111 HapyweHII1~ . YK AOn>KHa orseTII1Tb saM B TeYeHII1e 10 AHe~. 3TOT CpOK ycraHOBneH 3aKOHOM «0 3all.III1Te npas norpe6111rene~». as HaweM cnyYae norpe6111rens:~M111 s:!Bns:IIOTCS'I C06CTBeHHII1KII1 KBapT111p AOMa , KOTOpble He nonyYII1nll1 HaAne>Kall.IYIO ycnyry. 3a HeHaAne>Kall.lee coAep>KaHII1e np111AOMOBO~ reppii1TOpll1111 (HapyweHII1e npas111n coAep>KaHII1fl 111 peMOHTa >KII1nbiX AOMOB) AOn>KHOCTHble n1111..1a HepaA111BO~ YK Moryr 6b1Tb owrpacposaHbl Ha CYMMY OT 4 AO 5 TbiCS'IY py6ne~, a caMa YK - OT 40 AO 50 TbiCS'IY py6ne~ (cr. 7.22 KoAn PC!>).

War N2 5

ECN-1 BO ABOpe p>KaBblt:1 a

Y>Ke MHOrO neT BO ABOpe p>KaBeeT 6poweHHaSI MaWMHa. K KOMY o6parMTbCSI, YT06bl ee y6panM? none>Kaee MMXaMn, r. H. HoeropOA

BOOPOC- OTBET 3a 3TO OTBeYaiOT aAM111HII1CTpaTII1BHO-TeXHII1YeCKas:l 111HCneKI..\111s:l, KOTOpaSI eCTb B Ka>K,L:IOM perii10He, yYaCTKOBbl~ 111 MYHII11..1111nanii1TeT. 0HII1 C03Aa10T KOMII1CCII110, KOTOpaSI 111 pewaer, KaKo~ asroxnaM HY>KHO yAans:~rb co ABOpos . Ha rpaHcnoprHoe cpeAcrso np111Kpenns:~10r npeAynpe>K,£1eHII1e o TOM, YTO asroxnaM cneAyer y6parb Yepe3 5 AHe~ . Ecn111 snaAene1..1 He nos:~s111ncs:~, era npo6y10r Ha~ TII1 Yepe3 rV15AQ. Ecn111 111HcpOpMal..\111111 HeT, TO MeCTHas:l aAMII1HII1CTpai..\111S'I AOn>KHa Bb1Be3TII1 aero Ha wrpacpcros:~HKy. Yepe3 ABa MeCSII..\a, ecn111 xo3s:~111H raK 111 He o6bs:!BII1ncs:~ , MaWII1HY Yepe3 CYA Moryr np1113HaTb 6ecxo3HO~ 111 yr111n1113111posarb 3a eYer roc610A>Kera. Ecn111 s 3TOT MOMeHT snaAene1..1 3axoYer 3a6parb aero, eMy np111Aercs:~ 3annarii1Tb Ja 3BaKyal..\11110 111 xpaHeHII1e 111MYll.leCTBa.

O&PA3E'-' 3ARBnEHMJI PyKoBOA111TeniO YK - - - - - - - - - - or~~---------------(C!>.VI.O.) npo>KII1Bal0ll.lero no aApecy: r. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , yn . , A· , KB ._ __ ren .: _ _ _ _ _ _ __

3aSieneHMe co6crseHHII1KOM Ksaprll1pbl N2_ no aApecy: r. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , yn. , A. _ _ . YnpasneHII1e AOMOM ocyll.lecrsns:~er sawa opraHII13ai..\111S'I . Ycnyra no y6opKe MeCT 06Ll.lero nonb30BaHII1s:! (ABOpOBO~ repp111TOP111111) npeAOCTaBnSieTCS'I C HapyWeHII1SIMII1,aii1MeHHO: __________________________ ~ s:~sns:~IOCb

(nOAp06HO Hanii1CaTb 0 HapyweHII1s:!X B COAep>KaHII1111 np111AOMOBO~ Tepp111TOp111111) Y6opKa He npOII13BOA111TCS'I s reYeHII1e _ _ AHe~ . 8 COOTBeTCTBII1111 c n. 108 npaBII1n , yrsep>K,L:IeHHbiX nocraHOBneHII1eM npaBII1TenbCTBa PC!> N2354, npowy sac no yKa3aHHbiM cpaKTaM opraHII130BaTb npoBeAeHII1e nposepK111 C M0111M yYaCTII1eM He n03AHee AByx YaCOB C MOMeHTa nonyYeHII1SI HaCTOS'Ill.lero 3as:!BneHII1s:l . no pe3ynbTaTaM nposepK111 COCTaBII1Tb aKT C MOII1M yYaCTII1eM.

---~-~-~/

(noAn111cb) (pacw111cpposKa noAn111c111)

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 201 r.

PernaMeHT pa6oTW KonneKTopa c AOn>KHMKOM

Konnetcropbl MOryT o6ll.laTbCJI c .QOI1)KHI!tKaMI!t ronbKO cne.QytOll\l!tMI!t cnoco6aMH:

1. ni1YHble

BCTp9YI1, HO He 6011ee O,QHOrO pa3a

B He,QeiliO. 2. nocpe,~:~crsoM renecpoHHbiX neperosopos, HO: - He 6011ee

1 pa3a

,QeniO; - He 6o11ee

B cyrK11; - He 6o11ee

pa3 B He-

8 pa3 B MeC5ll..l.

TenerpacpHbiMI1,

reKcTOBbiM11 ,

ro110COBbi-

MI1 11 11HbiMI1 coo6ll.leHI15lMI1 (s TOM YI1CI1e SMS), Ho: - He 6o11ee

pa3 s cyrKI1; - He 6o11ee

pa3 B

He.QeniO; - He 6o11ee 16 pa3 B MeC5ll..l. 4. OrnpasKolil mo~ceM . Ko1111eKTOpb1 Moryr 3BoHI1Tb saM, n11caTb SMS 111111 np11XO.Q11Tb T011bKO c

08.00 AelilcTBMR KonneKTopoa He AGn>KHiol BloiXOAM'flo 3a paMKM 3aKOHa

,QO

22.00

no 6y,QH5lM 11 C

09.00

,QO

20.00

BbiXOAHble 11 npa3.QHI1YHble .QHI1. BpeM5l B 3aKoHe yKa3aHo no Mecry )1{11Tenbcrsa 3aeMll\11Ka, a He no

C11e,1:1yer OTMeH1Tb, YTO noH~ITI1e «K01111eKTOp» B 3aKOHO,Qa-

MeCTY pacn0110)KeHI15l K01111eKTOpCKOiil cp11pMbl. np11

TeilbCTBe He 3aKpen11eHO. 111CnOI1b3yeTC5l nOH5lTI1e «Kpe,Q11TOp

3TOM 3aKOHQAaTeilb yKa3ai1, YTO B3ai1MO,Qeli!CTBI1e

111111 11111..10, ,QeliiCTBYIOll.lee or ero 11MeHI1 11 (111111) B ero 11HTepe-

KOI111eKTopa c 11106biM11 rpeTbi1MI1 11111..1aM11 (Y11e-

cax»! B :noli! 11HCTPYK1..11111 Mbl norosop11M o corpy.QHI1Kax cne-

HaMI1 ceMbl1 ,Q011>KHI1Ka, po,QCTBeHHI1KaMI1, 11Hb1MI1

803-

np0)1{11Bal0ll\11MI1 C ,Q011)KHI1KOM Ill11..1aM11, COce,Q5l-

spaTOM npocpOYeHHOiil ,QeHe>KHOiil 3a,Q011)KeHHOCTI1 rpa)K.QaH .

1..111ai111311poBaHHOiil opraHI13al..ll111,

KOTOpa5l

3aH11MaeTC5l

MI1 11 nl06biMI1 .Qpyr11MI1 11111..1aM11) MO)KeT ocyll.lecr-

C110BOM, o rex 1110,D,5lX, KoropbiX np11H5lTO Ha3biBaTb «K01111eK-

BI15lTbC5l TOilbKO np11 OAHOBpeMeHHOM C06niO,QeHI111

ropaMI1». AeliiCTBI15l K01111eKTopos no BHecy.Qe6HOMY B03Bpary

,QByx YCI10BI1Iil: 1. Ecrb ni1CbMeHHOe cornac11e .QOil)KHI1Ka;

,QOilrOB CTporo pernaMeHT11pOBaHbl ¢>e,Qepai1bHbiM 3aKOHOM OT

03.07.2016

230-<1>3

«0 3all\11Te npas 11 3aKOHHbiX 11Hrepecos

2. Tperbi1M Ill1l.IOM He Bblpa)KeHo Hecornac11e Ha

cp11311YecKI1X 11111..1 np11 OCyll\ecTBI1eHI111 ,Qe5lTeilbHOCTI1 no 803-

ocyll\ecTBI1eHI1e c HI1M B3ai1MO.Qelilcrsi1R TaK )Ke

Bpary npocpOYeHHOiil3a,QOJl)KeHHOCTI1 11 0 BHeceHI111 113MeHeHI1Iil

K01111eKTOpaM 3anpell\eHO pacKpbiBaTb CBe,QeHI15l 0

B ¢>e,Qepai1bHbllil 3aKOH «0 M11KpOcp11HaHCOBOiil ,Qe5lTeilbHOCTI1 11

npocpOYeHHOiil 3a,Q011)KeHHOCTI1 HeorpaHI1YeHHOMY

M11KpOcp11HaHCOBbiX opraHI13al..ll15lX» (.Qanee no TeKCTY - <l>e,Qe-

Kpyry Il111..1, B TOM YI1Cile nyreM pa3Mell\eHI15l CBe-

pailbHbllil 3aKOH

NQ 230-<1>3). 83ai1MO.Qelilcrsosarb c

.Q011)KHI1KOM

,QeHI1Iil s 111HrepHere, Ha )1{11110M noMell\eHI111, .QOMe,

no 80npocy B03Bpara npocpOYeHHolil 3a.Q011)KeHHOCTI1 snpase

3.QaHI111, crpoeHI111 , coop~eHI111 , a TaK)Ke coo6ll.le-

Henocpe,QCTBeHHO Kpe.Q11TOp (6aHK) 111111 11111..10 (K01111eKTop), ocy-

HI15l no Mecry pa6oTbl .QOil)KHI1Ka.

ll.leCTBI15liOll.lee .Qe5lTeilbHOCTb no B03spary

npocpOYeHHOiil

3a,QOJl)KeHHOCTI1

B KaYeCTBe OCHOBHOro BI1,Qa ,Qe5lTei1b-

'tTO RBnReTCR He3aKOHHioiM B AeRTenbHOCTM KonneKTopa

HOCTI1, BKI110YeHHOro B roCy,QapCTBeH-

8 np11MeHeHI1e K ,Q0Jl)KHI1KY 11 11HbiM Ill11..1aM cp11311YeCKOiil CI1Ilbl Ill160

Hbllil peecrp. rocy,QapcTBeHHbllil peecrp

yrpo3 ee npi1MeHeHI15l, yrp03a y611liiCT80M 11Ill1 np11YI1HeHI1eM Bpe,Qa 3,QQ-

10p11,Q11YeCKI1X 11111..1,

poBbiO.

ocyll.leCTBI15liOll\11X

,Qe5lTei1bHOCTb no B03BpaTy npocpOYeHHOiil 3a,Q011)KeHHOCTI1 B KaYeCTBe OCHOBHOrO BI1,Qa ,Qe5lTei1bHOCT11, Be,QeTC5l Ha

• YHI1YTO)KeHI1e 11n11 nospe)f(,qeHI1e 11Myll.lecrsa n116o yrpo3a YHI1YTO)KeHI15l 11n11 nospe)f(,qeHI15l . 8 np11MeHeHI1e MeTQAOB, onaCHbiX ,QI15l )1{113HI1 11 3,QOpOBb5l IliO,Qelil.

6yMa)KHOM 11 311eKTpOHHOM HOCI1Tei15lX

8 0Ka3aHI1e nCI1XOI10ri1YeCKOro ,QaBI1eHI15l Ha ,Q0Jl)KHI1Ka 11 11HbiX 11111..1,

¢>e,Qepai1bHOiil Cil~Oiil cy,Qe6HbiX npi1-

11cnonbJOBaH11e Bblpa)KeHI1Iil 11 cosepweHI1e 11HbiX ,QelilcTBI1Iil, YHI1)Kal0ll\11X

CTaBOB. Cse,~:~eHI15l peecrpa 5lBI15liOTC5l

YeCTb 11 ,QOCTOI1HCT80 ,Q0Jl)KHI1Ka 11 11HbiX Ill11..1.

orKpbiTbiMI1 11 pa3Mell\aiOTC5l Ha calil-

8Be,QeHI1e ,QOil>KHI1Ka 11 11HbiX 11111..1 B 3a6ny)f(,qeHI1e OTHOCI1Tei1bHO:

re CCn fssprus .ru . CTOI1T OTMeTI1Tb,

a) npasosolil np11pO.Qbll1 pa3Mepa Hel1cnonHeHHoro o65l3aTenbcrsa, npi1-

YTO

M11Kpocp11HaHCOBble

OpraHI13al..ll111

YI1H ero Hei1CnOI1HeHI15l ,Q0Il)KHI1KOM, CpOKOB 11CnOI1HeHI15l 065l3aTeilbCTBa;

(MO) MOryT np11BI19Yb K01111eKTOpOB

6) nepe,~:~aYI1 sonpoca o so3spare npocpOYeHHOiil 3a.Q011)KeHHOCTI1 Ha

.QI15l ocyll.leCTBI1eHI15l ,Qe5lTeilbHOCTI1 no

paccMorpeHI1e cy.Qa, nocne,QCTBI1Iil Hel1cnonHeHI15l o65l3aTenbcrsa .QI15l

B03Bpary npocpOYeHHOiil 3a,Q011)KeHHQ-

,QOJl)KHI1Ka 11 11HbiX 11111..1, 803MO)KHOCTI1 np11MeHeHI15l K ,Q0Jl)KHI1KY Mep a,QMI1-

CTI1.

HI1CTpaTI1BHOrO 11 yro110BHO-npOI..IeCCYai1bHOro B03,Qeli!CTBI15l 11 yro110BHOrO

Ho caMOCT05lTeilbHO B3biCKI1BaTb

3a.Q011)KeHHOCTb MO He 11MeiOT npasa. B

cnyYae HapyweHI15l <l>e,~:~epanbHoro

3aKOHa

NQ 230-<1>3,

MO Hecyr a.QM11HI1-

crpari1BHYIO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb, COrilaCHO Y.

CT.

14.57

Ko,QeKca Pet>

a,QMI1HI1-

crpaTI1BHbiX npaBOHapyweHI15lX (KoAn P<l>), YTO BI19YeT Hai10)KeHI1e WTpacpa OT

200 000 .QO 2 000 000 py6nelil.

npecne,~:~osaHI15l;

B) npi1Ha,QI1e)KHOCTI1 Kpe,Q11TOpa 11Ill1 Ill11..1a, ,QeliiCTBYIOll.lero OT ero 11MeHI1 11 (11n11) s ero 11Hrepecax, K opraHaM rocy.QapcrseHHolil BI1acr11 11 opraHaM MeCTHOro caMoynpaBI1eHI15l. 8 n1060e ,Qpyroe Henpa80MepHoe npi1YI1HeHI1e Bpe,Qa ,Q0Il)KHI1KY 11 11HbiM

Ill11..1aM 111111 3Iloynorpe6neHI1e npasoM. • TaKI1M o6pa30M, ecn11 y sac o6pa3osanacb npocpOYeHHa5l 3a.QOil)KeHHOCTb, B03HI1KWa5l 113 ,QeHe)I{HbiX 065l3aTeilbCTB, 3TO He ,Qaer HI1KOMY npasa yrpo)KaTb, YHI1)KaTb 11 np11YI1H5lTb KaKolil-n116o spe,~:~ saM 1111YHO, saweMy

<1>111 Ha HCbl

11MYll\eCTsy 11 BaW11M 6ni13KI1M .

EcnM KonneKTop HapywaeT pernaMeHT 3BOHKa no TenectJoHy Ecn111 COTPYAHIIIKM Konn9KTOPCKOH cny>K6bl 69cnoKOSIT eac '-1811.19 ycTaHoBn9HHoro JaKO· HOM p9rn8M9HT8, '-18CTO HapywaSI COH, n9plll· OAIII'-19CKIII X8MSIT Ill CblnniOT yrp038MIII • nopa npiiiHIIIM8Tb M9pbl.

n1-1w1-1re )Kano6y s non~-11..11<110. YHI<1)KeHI<1e YeCTI-1 1<1 ,D,OCTOI<1HCTBa CO CTOpOHbl KOnneKTOpa ~sn~erc~ HapyweHI<1eM cr. 5.61 Kop,eKC8 o6 a,D,MI<1HI<1CTp8TI<18HbiX npaBOHapyweHI<1~X «0CKOp6neHI<1e». ni<1WI<1Te )Kano6y 8 npoKyparypy 1<1 Pocnorpe6Ha,D,30p. B )Kano6e yKa)KI<1Te cpaKTbl npOTI<1BOnp88HbiX p,ei/ICTBI-1111 KOnneKTOpOB: OCKOp6neH1<1~, 3BOHKI<1 8 HeypOYHOe BpeM~ , yrp03bll<1 T. P,. Ecn~-1 KonneKTopbl p,oxo~r p,o np~MbiX 3 yrp03 8 saw ap,pec, TO 8 1<1X p,ei/ICTBI<1~X MO)KeT ycM8TPI<1B8TbC~ cocras npecrynneHI-1~, npep,EcnM BaM no3 BoHMn KonneKTop ycMorpeHHoro cr. 163 YK P<l> «BbiMOr8TenbCTBO». Op,I<1H 1-1 3 ocHOBHbiX 1<1HcrpyMeHTOB KonneKrop 8 _ reneB 3TOM cnyYae ni<1WI<1Te 3a~sneH!-1e s non~-11..11<110 . cpOH . KonneKTOpCKI<1e cp1<1pMbl o6~3aHbl BeCTI-1 ay,D,I<103ani<1Cb 1<1, HaK~Hel..l, )KanyliiTeCb B KOHTpOnbHOscex cnyyaes Henocpep,crseHHoro B3ai<1MOp,elilcrsl<1~ c p,on)K_ Ha,D,30pHbll<1 opraH - YnpasneHI<1e <l>ep,ep8nbHI<1KaMI<1 1-1 1<1HbiMI<1 n1<11..1aM1<1 , HanpasneHHbiX H8 8038 p8T npoHOI-1 cny)K6bl cyp,e6HbiX np1<1CTaBOB, T. K. Hapywa: cpoYeHHolil 3ap,on)KeHHOCT1<1, npep,ynpe)K,D,aTb s HaYane pa3ere~ cr. 14.57 KoAn «HapyweHI<1e rpe6os8HI<11<1 rosopa Q Be,D,eHI-11<1 TaKOi/1 3an1<1CI<1 1-1 xpaHI<1Tb 8yp,l<1o 3ani<1CI<1 B 38KOHO,D,8TenbCTBa 0 3al1\1<1Te np88 1<1 3aKOHHbiX TeYeHI<1e rpex ner. KaK npaBI<1no, «BbiWI<16anbl» 1<1rHop!-1pyiOT 1<1HTepecos cpi<131<1YecKI<1X nl-11..1 npl-1 ocyll.lecr~eHI-11<1 raKI<1e p,elilcTBI-1~ . y3HaTb, c KeM Bbl 1<1Meere p,eno , MO)KHO c p,e~TenbHOCTI-1 no so3sp8ry npocpoYeHHOI-1 3anepsoro p,1-1anor8. Ecn~-1 KonneKrop He npep,cras1-1nc~ . a 3TO p,on)KeHHOCTI-1», YTO sneYeT Hano)KeHI<1e wrpacpa era o6~3aHHOCTb , norpe6ylilre or KonneKTopa Ha3B8Tb cpaHa ~PI<1P.I<1YecKoe n~-11..10 or 20 000 p,o 200 000 pyMI<1ni<110 ,1<1M~ . orYecrBo, opraHI<13al..ll<110, oT .............._._.Gn._ e•l-1 •. ................................~ 1<1MeHI<1 KOTOpoi/1 OH BaM 3BOH1<1T, KOHTaKTbl ECnM KOnneKTOpbl npMWnM K BaM B AOM 3Tolil opraHI<13al..ll<11<1 . 3ra 1<1HcpopMal..ll<1~ no3anoMHIIIT9: ny1.1w9 eoo611.19 He enycKaTb Konn9KTopoe e Keaprpe6yerc~ BaM p,n~ Han1<1caH1<1~ )Kano6 s TMpy. Ecn~-1 ecrb Heo6xop,I<1MOCTb norosop1<1Tb, p,en8illre 3TO Yepe3 3apa3m1YHble 1<1HCTaH1..11<11<1 , ecn~-1 Bbl nocYI-1KpbiTYIO p,sepb. HaYHYT noM8Tb 38MKI<1, cryYaTb s p,sep~-1- cpoYHO 3Bor aere p,elilcTBI-1~ KonneKTopos npoTI<1BOHI<1Te s non~-11..11<110. npep,ynpep,1-1re He3BaHbiX rocrelil o csoeM 3BOHKe s npasooxpaH!-1TenbHble opraHbl. Ho ecn~-1 sce-raKI-1 Bbl ,D,Bepb OTKpbtnl-1: npaBHbiMI-1. Ecn ~-1 npocpoYeHHoro p,onra y sac Her, ro coo6ll.II<1Te o6 3TOM KonneKnorpe6ylilre or KonneKTopoB npep,crasi<1Tbc~: Ha3sarb cpaMI-1ropy. 3BOHKI<1 He npeKpaTI<1ni<1Cb? n1-1W1<1Te n~-110, 1-1M~ OTYeCTBO, opraHI-1381..11<110, KOTOpyiO npe,D,CTaBn~IOT, )Kano6y s npoKyparypy 1-1 Pocnorpe6KOHTaKTbl 3Tolil opr8HI<1381..11<11<1. Hap,3op. Ecn~-1 npocpoYeHHa~ 3ap,on)KeHHe nycKalilre KonneKropos s Ksapr1-1py. Bxop,I<1Tb s noMell.leHI<1e HOCTb y sac ecrb, o6b~CHI<1Te KonneKTo6e3 sawero cornac~-1~ OHI-1 He 1<1MeiOT npas8. Ecn~-1 )Ke KonneKpy np1<1YI<1Hy, no KOTOpoi/1 OHa no~BI<1naCb. TOpbl nbiTaiOTC~ BOiiiTI-1 8 KBapr1-1py npOTI-18 sawei/1 BOnl-1, 3BOHI<1Te B Coo6ll.II<1Te, YTO nnaH1-1pyere p,orosop1<1Tbnon~-11..11<110 (02, 112- ep,I<1Ha~ cny)K6a cnaceHI-1~) . c~ c 6aHKOM o cpoKax noraweHI-1~ nnare3 Ecn1-1 KonneKTOpbl sopsani<1Cb s noMell.leHI<1e 6e3 Bawero corn8)Ka, o6rosop1<1Tb B03MO)KHOCTb pecrpyKc~-1~. npep,ynpep,1-1re 1-1x o6 yronosHolil orsercrseHHOCTI-1. Coo6ryp1<13al..ll<11<1 p,onra. Ho nn8TI<1Te ronbKO l1\1<1Te, YTO pewarb son poe o 3a,D,On)KeHHOCTI<1 c HI<1MI<1 He co61-1paerecb, no peKBI<131<1TaM 6aHKa, s KOTopoM 6pan1-1 a cnop pa3pew1-1re s cyp,e6HOM nop~p,Ke. AelilcTBI-1~ KonneKropos s Kpep,vn, He BHOCI<1Te nnaTe)K Ha «neBble» p,aHHOM cnyYae nop,nap,a10r no cr. 139 YK P<l> «HapyweH!-1e Henpi-1CYera. no 803MO)KHOCTI<1 3ani<1Cb1Bai11Te KOCHOBeHHOCTI-1 )KI<1nl<1ll.la» . nocne 1<1X yxop,a Hani<1WeTe 3a~sneHI<1e 8 pa3ro sopb1 c KonneKropaMI-1 Ha ,D,I<1KTOnon~-11..11<110 c rpe6osaHI<1eM np1-1sneYb KonneKTopos K yronosHolil orsercpoH. CospeMeHHble annapaTbl (cra1..11<1crseHHOCTI-1 . oHapH ble renecpoHbl 1-1 M061<1nbHble) no4 Ecn1-1 KonneKTopbl yrpo)KaiOT saM Hac1-1n1<1eM 1-1n1-1 np1<1MeH~IOT 3son~ IOT BeCTI-1 3an!-1cb p83rosopos 6e3 cp1<131<1YecKyiO c1-1ny, 30BI<1Te Ha noMOll.lb cocep,ei/1, nonbiTalilrecb np 1<1M €H€HI<1~ Cn€1..11<1anbHbiX T€XHI<1Y€CKI<1X n03BOHI<1Tb 8 nOnl-11..11<110. no B03M0)KHOCTI<1 Bbllii,D,I<1T€ Ha neCTHI<1YHYIO ycrpolilcTB. 06~3arenbHO npep,ynpep,1-1re KneTKY 1-1 nocryYI<1Te s p,sep~-1 cocep,HI<1X KBapr1<1p n~-160 Bbllii,D,1<1Te so co6ecep,HI<1Ka o TOM , YTO sep,ere ,D,I<1KTOp,sop 1-1 nonpoc1-1re o noMOll.ll-1. 3Halilre, YTO s p,aHHOM cnyY8e p,ei/1cpoH HYIO 3ani<1Cb. 3TO MO)KeT 1<136aBI<1Tb CTBI-1~ KOnneKTOpOB MOryT KB8n1<1cp1<11..11<1POBaTbC~ no CT. 163 YK P<l> sac or Hen p1<1~ THbiX Bblnap,os cera cro«BbiMorarenbCTBO» , cr. 119 YK P<l> «Yrpo38 y61<1YICTBOM 1-1n1-1 npi<1YI<1pOHbl. HeHI<1eM T~)KKOrO Bpep,a 3,D,Op0Bbl0» . n1-1W1<1Te 3a~BneHI<1e 8 non~-11..11<110.

4Hy

<!>f..1H3HCbl

>Ka11o6a Ha np1.1craeoe noAaeTC51 e Te4eH!.1e 1 0 A He~ co AH51 coeepweH!.-151 !.1Mt.1 KaKOr0-111.160 He3aKOHHOro, Ha saw B3ff151A, Ae~CTB!.-151 , 111.160 ycTaHOB11eH!.151 cpaKTa

6e3Ae~cTB!.1R

Hanpt.1Mep,

npt.1-

H51Tb Mepbl no 83biCKaH!.110 3aA011)1(eHHOCT!.1 npt.1CTaB A011>KeH B CpOK AO 2 MeC51l.leB. Ec111.1 3TO CAe11aTb He no11y4aerc51 , cpoK Moryr npoAJ1eBaTb .. . Ho Ht.14TO He MewaeT BaM Ha Hero CCbl11aTbC51. CT. 30, 36 3aKOHa P<t> «06 !.1Cn011Ht.1Te11bHOM np0!.13BOACTBe» . np1.1 3TOM, eCJlt.-1 Bbl Ecm1 Bbl He comacHbl c Ae~CTBIMIM!.-1 1.1111.1 6e3Ae~cret.1eM npt.-1-

C11!.1WKOM n03AHO Y3Ha11!.1 o6 3Tt.1X Ae~

craea, HY>KHO npaB!.111bHO 1.1 ocpt.1l\!.1a11bHO Han1.1carb >t<a11o6y ero

CTB!.151x-6e3Ae~cTB!.151X, TO MO>KHO nOAaTb

HenocpeACTBeHHOMY Ha4a11bH!.1KY - crapweMy CyAe6HOMY npt.-1-

>t<a1106y B Te4eH!.1e 10 A He~ C MOMeHTa,

craey. 8bl MO>KeTe 3anpOC!.1Tb B OTAe11e, KOTOpbl~ 3aH!.1MaeTC51

KOrAa Bbl Y3Ha11!.1 0 HapyweH!.-11.1 CB0!.1X

np0!.13BOACTea .

npae. Orser saM A011>KHbl Hanpaet.1Tb

0rKa3aTb He t.1Me10r npaea. Cr. 50 3aKoHa «06 1.1cno11Ht.1TenbHOM

TaK>Ke e 1 0-AHeBHbl~ cpoK noc11e no11y-

np0!.13BOACTBe» .

4eH!.151 eawe~ >Ka1106bl. Cr. 122, 126 <t>3

eawt.1M

Ae110M,

Marept.1a11bl

!.1Cn011Ht.1Te11bHoro

no npae1.111aM, >t<a11o6a, noAaHHa51 e nop51AKe noA4!.1HeHHOCT!.1 ,

«06 !.1Cn011Ht.1Te11bHOM np0!.13BOACTBe» .

A011>KHa 6b1Tb paccMorpeHa A011>KHOCTHbiM 11!.1l\OM c11y>t<6b1 HbiX npt.1CTaBOB, npaBOM04HbiM paCCMaTpt.1BaTb yKa3aHHOe o6pa~eH!.1e e re4eH!.1e AeC51Tt.1 AHe~ co AH51 nocryn11eHt.1R

Cr. 126 3aKoHa «06 !.1Cn011Ht.1Te11bHOM npot.13BOACTBe» . Ec111.1 Ha4a11bCTBO He pear1.1pyer, 3TO He noBOA CAaeaTbC51 . Hy>t<HO TOrAa >Ka110BaTbC51 BbiWe: maBHOMY CYAe6HOMY np1.1craey cy6beKTa P<t>, e KoropoM npot.1CXOA!.1T 6e3o6pa3!.1e. Ec111.1 1.1 OH He ecraHeT Ha eawy cropoHy, HY>KHO o6pa~aTbC51 K maeHOMY CYAe6HOMy npt.1CTaey POCC!.-11.1. napa1111e11bHO MO>KHO Hant.1carb 311eKTpOHHoe o6pa~eH!.1e Ha ca~re, raM ecrb cnel\l.1a11bHa51 cpopMa . napa1111e11bHO MO>KHo no>Ka11oearbC51 e npoKyparypy 1.1111.1 Aa>Ke e CYA·

KaK COCTaBHTb >KaJ\06y

CaM reKCT >t<a11o6b1 A011>KeH 6b1Tb KOHKpeTHbiM 1.1 KpaTK!.1M (He 6011bwe 2 crp. , HO crapa~recb ece-TaK!.-1 Y110>Kt.1TbC51 Ha 1111.1cre). CyTb Ae11a nocrapa~recb !.13110>Kt.1Tb apryMeHT!.1poeaHHO 1.1 KOppeKTHO. He HaAO CMeW!.1BaTb B OAHOM nt.1CbMe cpa3y HeCK011bKO np0611eM (peMOHT Kpb!Wt.-1 C pa3MepoM neHC!.-11.1). noMH!.1Te: 4eM 6011bWe B nt.1CbMe 3MOL\!.1~ 1.1 06o6~eH!.1~ , reM MeHbwe waHcoe, 4TO ero paccMoTp51T no

cy~ecrey.

Crporo npt.1Aep>Kt.1Ba~recb cpaKToe, !.136era~Te 11!.14HbiX 1.1 no11!.1Tt.14ecK!.1X BbtnaAOB. V1 y>t< reM 6o11ee Ht.1KOrAa He npt.1 -

6era~re K OCKOp611eH!.151M 1.1 yrpo3aM B aApec A011>KHOCTHbiX 111.11.1. 8 3TOM c11y4ae o6pa~eH!.1e eoo6~e He paccMaTpt.1eaeTc51 . EC11!.1 >Ka1106a He K01111eKT!.1BHa51, He HaAO npt.1n11eTaTb npo611eMbl APYrt.1X rpa)I(AaH . nt.1Wt.1Te 0 ce6e 11!.14HO. EC11!.1 y sac CKeepHbl~ no4epK, nonpoc1.1re POAHbiX 1.1111.1 3HaKOMbiX Ha6paTb nt.1CbMO Ha KOMnbtOTepe. ne4aTHbl~ TeKCT BOCnpt.1Ht.1MaeTC51 11erYe.

no 3aKoHy o6pa~eH!.1e, He noAJle>Ka~ee

npo4TeH!.110, He paccMaTpt.1eaerc51 . 04eHb no11e3Ho yKa3aTb , KaK!.1e CTaTbt.-1 , KaK!.1X !.1MeHHO 3aKOHOB (nOCTaHOB11eH!.1~) . B OTHOWeH!.-11.1 sac HapyweHbl. TaK!.1e CCbi11Kt.1 CT!.1MY11!.1PYIOT 4!.1HOBH!.1KOB, n03TOMy Mbl npt.1BOA!.1M !.1X nOCT051HHO. 3ane4aTa~Te nt.1CbMO 1.1 OTnpaBbTe 3aKa3HbiM nt.1CbMOM C yBeAOM-

11eH!.1eM.

EcnM M3·3a AOnroa aaw c'leT apecToaanM 4T06bl nOH51Tb, 4TO K 4eMy, He06XOA!.1MO 03HaKOM!.1TbC51 1.1 CH51Tb KOnt.-11.1 C MaTept.1a110B Ae11a . ,Qn51 3Toro HY>KHO o6paT!.1TbC51 c 3a51B11eHt.1eM K npt.1CTaey, KOTOpbiM 6bl110 BbiHeCeHO nocraHOB11eH!.1e. HoMep 1.1 AaTy nocraHoBJleHt.-151 , a raK>Ke cpaM!.-1111.110 cyAe6Horo np1.1craea MO>KHO Y3HaTb e Bbtnt.1cKe no C4eTy 1.13 6aHKa. Aa11ee Ae~creyeM e 3aB!.1Ct.1MOCT!.1 or roro , 3aKOHHO Cnt.1CaH!.1e 1.1111.1 HeT. Hanpt.1Mep, ec111.1 Cnt.1CbiBaiOT AeTCKOe noco61.1e - 3TO MO>KHO 1.1 HY>KHO OCTaHOB!.1Tb. noc11e TOro KaK Mbl no11Y4!.111!.1 Ha pyK!.-1 nocraHOB11eH!.1e cyAe6Horo npt.1CTaBa - !.1Cn011Ht.1Te1151 0 B036y)I(AeH!.1!.1 !.1Cn011Ht.1Te11bHOro np0!.13BOACTBa , a TaK>Ke noCTaHOB11eH!.1e 0 6110K!.1pOBKe C4eTa B 6aHKe , HY>KHO 8351Tb B OpraHaX CnpaBKy, B KOTOpO~ 6yAeT Hant.1CaHo, 4TO Bbl (<t>V10), Ae~CTB!.1Te11bHO no11y4aere noco61.1e Ha AeTe~ (<t>V10 AeTe~) 1.1 ero nepe4!.1C115110T Ha OTKpb iTbl~ 11!.1l\eBO~ C4eT N2 .. .... , B TaKOM-TO 6aHKe , B TaKOM-TO pa3Mepe. Aa11bWe noAaeM >t<a11o6y Ha nocraHOB11eH!.1e cyAe6Horo np1.1craea , BbiHecwero nocraHOB11eH!.1e o6 apecre c4eTa . 8 >t<a11o6e yKa3bteaeM see o6CT051Te11bCTBa Ae11a e xpoH0110rt.14eCKO~ nOC11eAOBaTe11bHOCT!.1 , nt.1WeM , 4TO Ha AeTCK!.1e noco61.151 apecr HaK11aAb1BaTbc51 He MO>KeT, npt.1KllaAb1BaeM KOnt.-11.1 Bblnt.1COK co c4eTa , cnpaeKy 1.1 npoct.1M OTMeH!.1Tb nocraHoBJleH!.1e o6 apecre . Ec111.1 >Ke cn1.1caH1.1e 3aKOHHO 1.1 51BHO He 6yAeT nOC11eAH!.1M, B HeKOTOpbiX Ct.1Tyal\!.151X MO>KHO nonpOC!.1Tb CYA 06 OTCp04Ke, npeAOCTaB!.-18 AOKyMeHTbl, nOATBep)I(Aal0~!.1e yea>Kt.1Te11bHYIO npt.14!.1HY 3TO~ npOCb6bl (Hanpt.1Mep, MeAI.1l\!.1HCKYIO cnpaeKy 1.1111.1 AOKyMeHTbl 1.13 61.1p>t<1.1 TPYAa o nocraHoeKe Ha yYeT) .

Bee ARH neHCMOHepa

1001 COBeY MCeHpeT

Cl>opMaT A4, 40 nonoc

Cl>opMaT A4, 48 nonoc

noAnHCHO" HHAeKC

no"'Tbl

n9817

nO"'Tbl

POCCHH:

POCCHH: BbiXO.QMT

HOt; HHAeKC

pa3 a

He.QenM

PaaocrM Mcne3bl. nolieAbl MnopaJHeHMH Cl>opMaT A4, 36 nonoc

nA499 BbiXO.QMT

1 pa3 B

MeCJIL\

BbiXO.QMT

pa3 a

He.QenM

1001 coaer ARB Aa'IHMHa Cl>opMaT A4, 40 nonoc

'fTO rp03MT 3a Bpa'le6Hyl0 OWM6Ky? nocKOJlbt<y topMAM'feCKOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM 33 «Bpa'fe6HYIO owM6Ky)) a 3aKOHOAaTenbCTBe PCD HeT, K MeAM'-'MHCKMM pa60THMK3M npMMeHSIIOTCSI o6~Me BMAbl OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM. lAX MO>KHO p33AeJ1MTb Ha ABe rpynnbl:

• rpa>K,QaHCKO-npaBOBYIO OTBeTCTB9HHOCTb; yro110BHYIO OTB9TCTBeHHOCTb.

KyAa noMCanoaaTbCR Ha apa'la

CTpaxoBble MeAM'-'MHCKMe opraHM3a'-'MM M TCDOMC. 3a-

~··1Ta npaB 3aCTpaXOBaHHbiX na4~eHTOB - 06s:l3aHHOCTb CTpaxo-

80.;1 Me,Q~I..\~HCK0.;1 opraH~3al..\~~ . 2. PyKOBOAMTenb MeAyYpe>KAeHMSI (rnaBHbiM spay MnM 3aBeAYtoll.IMH). PyKoso,Q~Te11b o611a,QaeT s11aCTHbiM~ no11HOM04~s:lM~ no np~Hs:lT~IO Mep ,Q~CI..\~n11~HapHOro xapaKTepa B OTHOweH~~ Me.Q~I..\~HCK~x coTpy.QH~KOB.

3. PoC3ApaBH3A30p. Poc3,QpasHa,Q3op o6s:l3aH ocy~ecTB11s:lTb KOHTp011b KaYeCTBa ~ 6e3onaCHOCT~ Me,Q~I..\~HCK0.;1 ,Qes:lT911bHOCT~ , OKa3aH~s:l Me,Q~I..\~HCK0.;1 nOMO~~ ycTaHOB119HHbiM CTaH,QapTaM . Tepp~TOp~a11bHble opraHbl Poc3,QpasHa,Q30pa ~MetoTCS'l so scex cy6beKTax Pocc~.;1cKo.;1 ct>e,Qepal..\~~. 4. npot<ypaTypa M npaBOOXpaHMTeJlbHble opraHbl. npoKypaTypa ocy~ecTB11s:leT o6~~.;1 Ha,Q3op 3a Bbln011HeH~eM 3aKoHOB, co611to,QeH~eM npas ~ cso6o.Q rpa>t<AaH . rpa)KACIHCKO·npaBOBaJI OTB8TCTB8HHOCTb 3a Bpa'le6Hyl0 OWM6Ky B c11y4ae spaye6Ho.;1 ow~6K~ . BC11e,QCTB~e KOTopo.;1 nal..l~ eHTy 6bl11 np~Y~HeH spe,Q, noTepnesw~.;1 MO>KeT np~s11e'fb Me,Q~I..\~HCKOro pa60TH~Ka ~11~ Me,Q~I..\~HCKYIO opraH~3ai..\~IO K rpa>K,QaHcKo.;1 npasoso.;1 OTBeTCTBeHHOCT~. B aToM c11yYae spaYY rpo3~T : • WTpacp ; • OTCTpaHeH~e OT 3aH~MaeMo.;1 ,Q011>KHOCT~ ; • Bblrosop; • 3aMeYaH~e ; • nOH~>KeH~e B ,Q011>KHOCT~; • ~Has:l a,QM~H~CTpaT~BHas:l OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb . A na4~eHT snpase noTpe6osaTb MaTep~a11bHo.;1 KOMneHca1..\~~ 3a np~Y~HeHHbl.;1 spe,Q ~ KOMneHCal..\~~ Mopa11bHOro spe,Qa .

na.,...eHTa no,QaTb >t<a1106y Ha Ka'feCTBO Me,Q06C11Y>K~BaH~s:l B CTpaxosyto KOMnaH~IO MO>KHO KaK YCTHO , TaK ~ n~CbMe H HO . 3as:lBneH~e o6s:l3aHbl 3aper~cTp~posaTb . B 3as:ls11eH~~ ,Q011>KHbl 6b1Tb yKa3aHbl Bp9Ms:l , MeCTO, o6CTOs:lTe11bCTBa np~4~HeH~s:l MaTep~a11bHOrO spe,Qa (y~ep6a), 11~40 , B~HOBHoe s np~Y~ HeH~~ spe,Qa, 3as:lB11s:leMbl.;1 pa3Mep y~ep6a. Ec11~ Bbl nepe11eY~sa11~Cb n11aTHO , TO np~110>K~Te K 3as:ls11eH~to Kon~~ ,Qorosopos o6 oKa3aH~~ yc11yr ~ YeK~ . CTpaxosas:l KOMnaH~s:l ,Q011>t<Ha opraH~3osaTb ~ nposecT~ 3KCnepT~3Y KaYeCTBa OKa3aHH0.;1 BaM Me,QnoMO~~ .

Bawe 3as:ls11eH~e ~ see ,QOKyMeHTbl cTpaxosas:l KOMnaH~s:l HanpaB11s:leT s Me.Q~I..\~H CKoe

yype)f(AeH~e .

r,Qe saM

oKa3a11~

HeKaYe-

CTBeHHYto nOMO~b . Bbl MO>KeTe Hanps:lMYIO o6paT~TbCS'l K pyKoso,Q~Te11to Me.QyYpe>K,QeH~s:l C >Ka1106o.;1 . nops:l,QOK pa3peweH~s:l cnopa s TaKOM c11yyae - a H a11or~YHbl .;1 .

CpoK paccMoTpeH~s:l >t<a1106b1-

10 ,QHe.;1 . C

l..\e11bl0 6011ee 06beKT~BHOro paCCMOTpeH~s:l 3as:lB11eH~s:l o6e cTopoHbl snpase 3anpoc~Tb ~ ~Cn011b30BaTb 3aKJlto4eH~s:l 3KCnepTOB . IIIX BbiBO,Qbl MoryT 6b1Tb ocnopeHbl 11to6o.;1 ~3 cTopoH s cy,Qe . Ec11~ pyKoso,QcTso Kll~H~K~ cornacHo c npeTeH3~s:lM~ cTpaxoso.;1 KOMnaH~~ ~ na4~eHTa , KOMneHCal..\~~

BbiHOC~TCS'l peWeH~e

MaTep~a11bHoro

spe,Qa, pa3-

Mep Bbln11aTbl Ha3HaYaeTcs:l no o6oto,QHOMY cTopoH . PeweH~e o Bbm11aTe

cornac~to

nopRAOK A8MCTBMM Ec11~ BO BpeMS'l 11e4eH~s:l BaM He CTaHOB~TCS'l 11Y4We ~ (~11~) ec11~ eCTb COMHeH~s:l B npaB~11bHOCT~ nocTaB11eHHOrO ,Q~arH03a , TO o6paT~TeCb K CTOpOHHeMy cnel..\~a11~CTy. Ec11~ ero 3aKJlto4eH~e 6y,QeT OTJl~YaTbCS'l OT ,Q~arH03a 11e4a~ero spaYa , TO 3TO noso,Q .Q11s:l .Qa11bHe.;1wero pa36~paTe11bCTBa . 3a~~~aTb ceo~ npasa MO>KHO caMOCTOS'lTe11bHO, a MO>KHO o6paT~TbCS'l B CTpaXOBYIO KOMnaH~IO . np~ 3TOM MaTep~a11bHbl.;1 Bpe,Q MO>KHO B03MeCT~Tb 6e3 Cy,Qe6Horo pa36~paT811bCTBa , a BOT MOpa11bHbl.;1 - T011bKO Yepe3 cy,Q.

Ile'-ll-1MCR no 33KOHY

I ocpo~MnHeTcH

cne1..1111anbHbiM npii1Ka3oM pyKOSO,D,111TeJ1H Me,D,yYpe>K,D,eHII1H. 8 ,D,OKyMeHTe yKa3blsaeTcH ,o,aTa HaHeceHII1H yll.lep6a; <1>1110 nocTpa,o,aswero na1..1111eHTa , pa3Mepbl KOMneHC8L\111111 111 CpOKII1 SblnJ18Tbl. Kon111fl np111Ka3a Sblp,aeTcf! na1..1111eHTy. nonyYI!ITb ,o,eHbrll1 Hanii1YHbiMI!1 Henb3fl, KOMneHCal..\11110 nepese,o,YT Ha yKa3aHHbllil nal..ll!leHTOM cYeT s 6aHKe. np111 oTcyTcTs 111111 cornac 111 f! Me>K,D,y CTOpOH8Mii1 na1..11!1eHTY spyyaeTCfl MOTI!ISI!IposaHHbli/i OTK83. 8 T8KOM CJlyYae, 38 38Ll.lli1TOiil CSOI!IX npas HY>KHO o6pall.laTbCfl s cyp, 06Ll.leliiiOpii1C,D,Ii1KL\II11!1.

CyAe6HaR

3a~MTa npaa naL\MeHTa

na1..1111eHT MO>KeT nOJlyYII1Tb nOMOLl.lb S COCTaSJleHII1111 111CK8 111 no,o,aYe ero s cy,o, s cTpaxosolil KOMnaHII1111. AnH :noro H~Ho o6paTII1TbCfl Ty,o,a c 3af!sneHII1eM (ycTHO 111n111 nii1CbMeHHO). Ecn111 3KcnepT1113Y K8YeCTS8 OK838HII1H nOMOLl.lll1 na1..1111eHTY CTpaxosaf! KOMnaHII1H He nposo,o,111na, TO nepe,o, o6pall.leHII1eM s cy,o, OHa o6f!3aHa cp,enaTb 3TO. nocne Yero noMoraeT ocpopMI!ITb npeTeH31!110 111 111CK K Knli1Hii1Ke 111 HanpasmleT 3af!sneHII1e 3acTpaxosaHHoro na1..1111eHTa sMecTe c Heo6xop,li1MbiM111 ,o,oKyMeHTaM111 s cy,o,. K 3af!sneHII110 3acTpaxosaHHoro npli1Kn8,D,biS810TCfl pe3yllbT8Tbl 3KCnepT1!13bl CTpaxosoi/1 Me,D,II1L\111HCKOiil opraHI!138L\Ii11!1. ~8L\1!1eHT MO>KeT n.~lTpe60S8Tb S cyp,e KOMneHCII1pOS8Tb MOpallbHblli11!1 M8Tep1!18JlbHblli1 spep,. np111 onpep,eneHI!11!1 pa3Mepa MOp8llbHO-

r=================':L,I.:,r~ O ,!S:!;p::;e~ p,:a~c~yp, ~ pyKOSO,D,CTSyeTCfl ,o,syMfl Tpe6osaHII1fiMII1: pa3yMHOCTb '

YronoaHaR oTaeTcTaeHHOCTb 3a apa'le6Hyl0 OWM6Ky npMBile'lb Bpa'la K yrOJlOBHOH OTBeTCTBeHHOCTM MO>KHO,

ecnM:

• nal..ll!leHTY npi!IYI!IHeH TH>KKI!IIil spep, 3,D,Op0Sbl0 Jll!160 OH yMep ; • nal..llileHTa 3apa31!1Jlll1 81114-1!1HcpeKl..l111elil ; • nal..\l!leHTKe He3aKOHHO nposeJll!l a6opT; • 50JlbHOMY He OK83al11!1 nOMOLl.lb 111 3TO nosneKJlO np1!1YII1HeHII1e cpep,Hei/1 TH>KeCTII1 1!1Jlli1 TH>KKOrO spep,a 3,D,Op0Sbl0; • 8pa4 He3aKOHHO 3aHII1MancH YacTHOiil Me,D,111L\Ii1HCKOIII npaKTI!IKOi/1. Ecn111 spaYe6HaH ow1116Ka np111sena K CMepTII1 na1..1111eHTa 1!1Jlli1 eCTb OCHOSaHI!IH C4111TaTb, 4TO n8l..lli19HTY npii1YII1HeH TH>KKiili/1 spep, 3,D,Op0Sbl0 (YenoseK Jlli1WII1JlCH opraHa Ill!160 KOHeYHOCTI!I , CT8Jl 1!1HS8J1111,D,OM), TO nOJllill..\I!IH S 06H3aT9JlbHOM nopH,D,Ke npOSO,D,I!IT ,D,OCJ19,D,CTS9HHYIO nposepKy. 8 OCT8JlbHbiX CJ1Y48HX npii1,D,9TCH Hani!1C8Tb 38HSJleHII19 S nOJllill..\11110 CaMOCTOHT9JlbHO . 8 HeM yKa>KI!ITe see 06CTOHTellbCTSa , KOTOpbl9 SaM 1113S9CTHbl : YTO np01!130WJ10, cpaMII1Jlli110, I!IMH , OT4eCTSO spaya 111 yll.lep6, KOTOpbllil saM np111YII1HeH ero ,o,elilcTSI!IHMI!I . 8 xo,o,e nposepKI!I nonll1l..lelilcKII1e onpocHT spaYe i/1 , nOTepneSWI!IX, 1!13biMYT Me,D,I!1L\Ii1HCKII1e ,D,OKyMeHTbl 1!1 Ha3Ha4aT 3KCnepT1!13y. Cy,o,e6Hbllil 3KcnepT OL\9HII1T npasl!lnbHOCTb ,o,elilcTsl!llil ne4all.lero spa4a. no pe3ynbTaTaM nposepKiil s non1111..1111111 npi!IMYT peweHI!Ie n1116o o so36y>K,D,eHI!11!1 yronos Horo p,ena, n1116o o6 OTKa3e s so36y>K,D,eHI!1111 .

' 111 cnpase,o,n111socrb. Ecn111 spe,o, He3H8Yii1TellbHbllil, paCCYI!1TbiS8Tb Ha TO, YTO cyp, KOMneHC111pyeT Mli1JlJlii10Hbl, He CTOII1T. Pa3Mep spe,o,a, HaHeceHHoro 3,!J,Op0Sbl0, paCCMaTpl!lsaeTCH KaK COSOKynHOCTb YTPaYeHHoro 3apa6oTKa 111 pacxo,o,os Ha neYeHII1e. 8 cnyyae y,o,osneTBopeHI!IH Tpe6osaHII1H o so3Mell.leHII1111 spe,o,a (yll.lep6a) cy,o, s csoeM peweHI!1111 yKa3blsaeT pa3Mepbl 111 cpoKI!I KOMneHCal..\1!1111. AnH 38Ll.lli1Tbl CSOII1X npas Sbl T8K)!(9 MO>KeTe 06paTI!1TbCH s perll1oHanbHOe MliiHI!ICTepcTso 3,D,pasooxpaHeHII1H (111n111 ropo,o,cKolil ,o,enapTaMeHT 3,!J,pasooxpaHeH1!1H) c >Kano6olil Ha Me,D,II1L\111HCKOro spaya 1!1Jlll1 Me,o,yYpe>K,D,eHI!Ie. YnonHOMOYeHHble opraHbl MOfYT T8K)!(e npi!ISJleYb K ,D,Ii1CL\111nJ11!1H8pHOiil OTSeTCTSeHHOCTI!I spaYa 1!1Jlli1 Mep,yype>K,D,eHI!Ie 1!1 nOMOYb KOMneHC1!1pOS8Tb Yll.lep6.

rnaSHOMY spayy - - - - - - - <1>1110 _______________________ a,o,pec, TenecpoH

>KAfl06A

Ha AeHCTBMH spa'la

{( » 20_ ro,o,a H o6paTI!1JlCH K spa4y - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ <1>1110 spa4a _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ll13nO>KII1Te CYTb o6pall.leH1!1H K spaYy, nocne,o,crsi!IH 111 4TO no sa w eMy MHeHI!IIO Hapyw111n Me,D,Ii1L\Ii1HCKII1ill COTPYAHI!IK. 8s111,o,y SbiWei!13JlO>KeHHoro npowy: • o6ecne4111Tb MHe so3MO>KHOCTb peanli130saTb csoe npaso Ha nonyYeHI!Ie Me,D,Iill..\I!IHCKolil noMOLl.l111; • KOMneHCI!IpOSaTb MHe paCXO,D,bl, noHeCeHHbl9 S CSH31!1 C SbiHy>K,D,eHHbiM 06pall.leHII19M 38 nnaTHOiil Me,D,I!IL\I!IHCKO ;, nOMOLl.lbiO; • - p1!1 Hf!Tb Mepbl S OTHOWeHI!11!1 SI!IHOSHbiX Jllill..\. po.1no>KeH111e Ha _ Jlii1CTax. - - - - - - - - - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ <1>1110 no,o,nii1Cb

Jle'"IHMCH no 33KOHY

KyAa no*anoaaTbCR Ha wKonbHoro Y"'MTenR? nepBbiM BOnpoc, Ha KOTOpbiM He06Xo,QMMO OT· B9TMTb: KYA3 MO)f{HO nO)f{anOBaTbCSI Ha WKOflbHOrO

Y'~MTeM? Bapr.taHTOB MO>KeT 6btTb HecKonbKo: • ,o,111peKTopy yYe6Horo 3ase,o,eHII15~; • s ,o,enapTaMeHT o6pa3osaHII151 sawero per111oHa; • s npasooxpaHIIITenbHble opraHbl, npoeypaTypy, cy,o,. Bbl61!1paTb, KOMY 111MeHHO a,o,pecosaTb cso10 )f{M06y, Cile,D,yeT 111CXO,D,51 1113 cpaKTI!14eCKII1X 06cT051TerlbCTB, a TaK)f{e pyKoso,o,CTsy5~cb np111HI..lll1noM pal..llllOHailbHOCTIII. TaK, Hanp111Mep, eCillll, no saweMy MHeHIIIIO, yYIIITenb Heo6beKTII1BeH B Ol..leHKe 3HaHII1Lil sawero pe6eHKa, HeT HII1KaKII1X OcHOBaHIIIL/1 ,D,Il51 o6paU\eHII151 s cy,o,. AoCTaTOYHO npeTeH3111111, HanlllcaHHolil Ha 111M51 ,o,lllpeKTopa yYe6Horo 3ase,o,eHII151,

KaK HanMcaTb *ano6y Ha Y"'MTenR?

KOTOpbiL/1 HaBepH51Ka CMO)f{eT peWIIITb p,aHHYIO npo6neMy.

)f(a1106a Ha Y'H1Te.n51 COCTaB1151eTC51 B CB060,D,HOLII

To )f{e caMoe ,o,enaeTC51 111 s CilyYae, eCillll yYIIITenb nosen

¢opMe s m1CbMeHHOM Blll,D,e. B TeKCTe o65~3aTe11bHO

ce651 HeKoppeKTHO. To11bKO eCillll pyKoso,o,IIITenb yYpe>K,D,e-

Cile,D,yeT 0Tpa3111Tb cpaMII11111110, 111M51111 OTYeCTBO 111111..la,

HII151 He npe,o,npii1H5111 HII1KaKII1X Mep, 4T06bl ypery11111p0BaTb

KOTopoe o6paUiaeTC51 c )f{a11o6oll!, ero KOHTaKTHble

B03H111KW111L/I KOHcp11111KT, 111MeeT CMbiCil lll,D,TIIl ,D,ailbWe 111 06-

,D,aHHble (MeCTO )f{IIITe.nbCTBa, HOMep Te11ecpOHa).

paU\aTbC51 s ,o,enapTaMeHT o6pa3oBaHII1R B aToT opraH

KpoMe ~nora Heo6xo,o,II1MO oTpa3111Tb ,o,aHHble yYIIITe-

MO)f{HO o6paU\aTbC51 no 11106biM BOnpocaM, CB513aHHbiM C

1151, Ha KOTOporo Bbl nlllWeTe )f{a1106y, 111 KOHKpeTHble

HapyweHII151MII1 npas yYaU\IIIXCR KOH94HO, eCillll B OTHOW9-

06CT051-

HII1111 sawero pe6eHKa 6blfl0 np111MeHeHO nCII1X0110rii1YeCKOe

Te11bCTBa,

11111111 cp11131114eCKOe HaC11111111e, 06paU\eHII1eM K ,D,IIlpeKTopy

KOTOpble

He o6oliiTII1Cb. B TaKOM CilyYae Cile,o,yeT HanlllcaTb 3a5~s-

Bbl

11eHII1e s npasooxpaHIIITenbHble opraHbl, npoKypayypy, a

ocna-

plllsaeTe

TaK)f{e MO)f{HO o6paTII1TbC51 B Cy,D, ,D,Il51 B3biCKaHII151 C yYIIITe-

11111111

pac-

1151 MaTeplllailbHOL/1 KOMneHcal..lll1111 3a np1114111HeHHbllil Bpe,D,.

l..leHIIIBaeTe KaK

neHcal..lllliO IIIMYU\eCTBeHHOro 111 MOpailbHOrO spe,o,a, Bblpa-

Hapywe-

)f{eHHOro s ,o,eHe)f{HOM aKBIIIBaileHTe. To eCTb o6paU\aTbC51

Hille CBOIIIX

B cy,o, l..lerleC006pa3HO, KOr,D,a 111MeeT M9CTO Bpe,o,, KOTOpbiL/1

npas.

MO)f{HO Ol..leHIIITb C MaTep111a11bHOLil T04KII1 3peHII1R

Cy,o,e6Ha51 3aU\111Ta s ,o,aHHOM CilyYae npe,o,nonaraeT KOM-

06pa3e~

)l(ano6bl AlllpeKTopy WK011bl N2 _ r. _ _ __ 4>11'10

OT ___________ r. _ _ _ _ _ , y11 .

____,o,. _,

KB . _

>Kano6a

Moll! CbiH (AOYb), 4>11'10

ro,o,a po>K,D,eHII151, 51B1151eTc51 yYeHIIIKOM Bawelll WK011bl. (.O:aTa), np111,D,51 ,o,oMoL/1

1113 WK011bl, pe6eHoK no)f{a11oBa11C51 Ha TO, YTO yYII1Te11b __ npe,o,MeT, 4>11'10

nopsa11a ero pa6oYyiO

TeTpa,D,b, a TaK)f{e 111Cn011b30Ba11a OCKOp6111Te11bHble Bblpa)f{eHII151 np111 pa3rOBOpe C HIIIM 111 p,pyrii1MII1 yYeHII1KaMII1. noc11e yKa3aHHbiX ,o,elilcTBIIILil 4>11'10 YYII1Te1151 nocTas11111a Hey,o,os11eTBOp111Te11bHYIO Ol..leHKY 4>11'10 pe6eHKa 111 nonpoc11111a ero noKIIIHYTb yye6Hbllil Knacc. AaHHOe nose,o,eHIIle C4111Tal0 Henp111eM11eMbiM, s CB513111 c YeM npowy: nposecTIII nposepKy no ,o,aHHOMY cpaKTy, npii1H51Tb Mepbl B OTHOWeHII1111 yKa3aHHOrO ne,o,arora.

«_» ___ 2__

no,o,nii1Cb

Ba)f{HO HanoMHIIITb, YTO ec11111 no saweMy o6paU\eHII110 HII1KaKII1X Mep npe,o,np111H51TO He 6bi110, 3a 3aU\111TOLil cso111x npas MO)f{HO o6paTII1TbC51 s ,o,pyr111e opraHbl. Ec11111 rosop111Tb o cpoKax OTBeTa Ha )f{a11o6y, KOTopa51 no,o,aeTC51 Ha 111M51 PYKOBO,D,II1Te1151, TO TaKOBble 3aKOHOM np51MO He ycTaHOB11eHbl. nplll 3TOM npe,o,ycMaTp111BaeTC51, 4TO eCI1111 CpOK ,D,Il51 OTBeTa cnel..lll1a11bHO He ycTaHOB11eH )f{a11060L/I, TO OTBeT ,D,011)f{eH 6b1Tb HanpaB11eH B TeYeHIIle

,o,Helil c MOMeHTa no11yYeHII151 o6paU\eHII151. TaKIIIM o6pa30M, YT06bl He >K,D,aTb l..le11bllil MeC511..l, s csoelll )f{a11o6e 11Y4We cpa3y yKa3aTb CpOK. 06bi4HO OH ycTaHaB11111BaeTC51 OT Bbl yKa)f{eTe

10 pa604111X ,D,HeL/1,

10 ,0,0 14 ,D,HeL/1.

06paTII1Te BHII1MaHII1e, 4TO eC11111

TO BbiXO,D,Hble 111 npa3,D,HII14Hble ,D,HIIl C4111TaTbC51 He 6y,D,yT. ECI1111 )f{e nponlllWeTe

Ka11eH,o,apHbiX ,D,HeL/1, TO OTCYeT 6yp,eT np01113BO,D,II1TbC51 B COOTBeTCTBII1111 C Ka11eH,o,apHbiM 111C4111C11eHII1eM .

~P¥11T M . 36

nanoc

•

npoMrpGBWMX He 6yAeT! Bee, 'fTO BaM tteo6XOAMMO CAMCITb, - JTO Af*CJ'CITb

law

nOAnMCHOM KYnOH (MnM KOnMtO) HG 1-e nonyrOAM8 2020 rOAG HG mo6oe M3 HOWMX M3AOHMtl M 30AOAHMTb

<<AHK8TY 'fMTGT8nJI)).

Mbl Y'fT8M ace 8aWM COB8Tbt, A0)1(8AQHMA M KOMMeHTOf*M ANI TOto, 'fT06bt HGWM M3AOHMA CTQAM e""e

B cpoK AO

15.04.20 Mbl >t<.qeM BawM

C noMeTKOM ~

ut06MneMHbiM

AY'fi.Ue. H&Hf,QIJIH fllaCTH. •

nMCbMO

"":--- . Hlf nODYQHJ H8WH

p03blrpbiW!"

•• • HODDEHQHOHHIJIE • • • Ha 2-e nonyroAMe 2020 rOAa TOM noi1Y'fGT '4ettHwe npM3W! •· -- H3UHM8.

nepawelOO rtOAnMCGIWMXCR

HE VDVCTIITE CBOi UIAHCI DOADIIWIITECb HA HAWII t13AAHIIR! I - - :_: - - - - - _:- -

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ;: - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

((j)aMWIMll, MMA, ONeCTBO)

OonHblil a,QpeC

(HHAet<t)

~T------------------------------------------------------------

T~---------------------------------------------------Ha Kak11e JCPOMe Hawero BblllOAnMCaHbl? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ ~HMA

~arenbCTaa

~H~aHMRB8M~weH~AroA?

_________________________________________________

HAW A.QPEC : PoccltMcKaR cl>eAepai.4MR, 606007, HMlKtropoAcKaR o6n., r. AltP*MHCK, lhl13, e-mail: lzd@postpp.ru

noAa~~ta ac:ano61»1 Ha nocTaHoaneHMe

KyAa MO:HCHO noAaTb ac:ano6y? 3a~sneHV1e

o6 ocnapV1saHV1V1 peweHV1~ no CIAMV1HV1crpaTV1SHOMY Aeny rpa)f(,qaHe snpase noAaTb: s cyAe6Hble opraHbl; SbiWecro~ll.leMy AOll>KHOCTHOMY llV1l..IY opraHa, COTPYAHV1K Koroporo SbiHec He3aKOHHOe peweHV1e. ECllVl 38~SV1Tellb nOAaer >Kano6y OAHOSpeMeHHO SO see Sblwenepe<mcneHHble opraHbl snacrV1 , ro npaso Ha paccMorpeHV1e ero 3a~BlleHV1~ JaKpenn~erc~ 3a CYAOM.

06pa3e1.4 3aRaneHMR AnR o6ac:anoaaHMR nocTaHOBneHMR rM&AA Bee opraHbl, ynonHOM04eHHble npV1HV1MaTb or rpa)f(,qaH >Kano6bi Ha rV16,0JJ, pa3Mell.l810T S CS01!1X TeppV1TOpi118JlbHbiX nOApa3AeJleHI!1~X V1Hcj:>OpM8l..li110HHble CTeHAbl, rAe H8XOA~TC~ o6pa3l..lbl 3a~SJleHI!1Jii. TaM >Ke COTPYAHI!1Kil1 rocyAapcrseHHbiX opraHos pa3Mell.laiOT npi11Mepbl npasi!1JlbHoro 3anonHeHI!1~ >Kano6. K cocrasneHHOMy 3a~s neHV110 cneAyer npV1llO>Kii1Tb Kon11110 ocnap111saeMoro nocraHosneHI!1~ rV16AQ V1 AOKyMeHTbl, Ha Koropble asrop 3a~sneHV1~ ccblnaerc~ np111 onl!1caHI!11!1 o6cro~renbcrs Aena. nOCT8HOSJleHV1~

KorAa opraHbl anpaae He

oTae~~taTb

Ha ac:ano6y?

Orser He Aaerc~ no >Kano6aM, KOTOpble: He COAep>Kar cpaM1!1llil11!1 3a~s111ren~ 111 ero no4rosoro aApeca; He noMaiOTC~ np04TeHI!110. TaK>Ke opraHbl, npi11H~swl!1e 3a~sneHV1e or rpa)f(,qaHI!1Ha, coo6ll.laiOT eMy o HeS03MO>KHOCTV1 A8Tb OTSeT, eCJlVl OTSeT Ha 38~SJleHI!1e Tpe6yeT pa3rnaweHI!1~ CSeAeHV1ili, COCTaBJl~IOll.li11X rocyAapcrseHHYIO V1Jll!1 V1HYIO OXpaH~eMyiO 38KOHOM TailiHy.

nopRAOK o6ac:anoaaHMR nocTaHOBneHMR

rM&AA

nocraHOBJleHI!1e corpyAH111Ka AOPO>KHoili 1!1HcneKL.1111111 MO>KHo o6>Kanosarb s re4eHI!1e 10 AHeili . AaHHblili nep1!10A H841!1Haer 1!1C4V1Cll~Tbc~ : co cneAYIOll.lero AH~ nocne spy4eHI!1~ KOni111!1 nocraHosneHI!1~ (spy4eHV1e AOKyMeHTa np01!13SOAI!1TCH He n03AHee 3 AHeili C MOMeHTa ero Sb1HeceHi11~) ; CO CJleAYIOll.lero AH~ nocne nony4eHI!1H KOni111!1 (AOKyMeHT MO>KeT 6b1Tb SbiCJl8H no n04Te S 3-AHeSHbii/i CpOK C MOMeHTa erO SbiHeCeH1!1~).

PeweHMe no ac:ano6e Ha nocTaHOBneHMe

rM&AA

>Kano6a Ha nocraHoeneHMe C9TPYAHMKa r1115AA MO>KeT 6b1Tb noAaHa rpa>K.QaHaMM cneAytO~MMM cnoco6aMM: - OrnpasneHI!1eM no no4Te. - npeACT8SlleHI!1eM nyreM Jlii14HOro o6pall.leHI!1~ rpa)f(,qaHV1Ha . Ae>KypHble 48CTI!1 npi11Hii1M810T 38~BJleHI!1~ KpyrnoCYT04HO. - OrnpasneHI!1eM s 3lleKrpoHHoili cpopMe 4epe3 V1HcpopMal..II!10HHble Ci11CTeMbl 06ll.lero nOJlb30S8Hil1 ~ 1!1Jlil1 cnel..II!18JlbHble pa3Aellbl Ha cai/irax rV16AQ. KpoMe 3Toro y 3a~s111ren~ cyll.lecrsyer npaso Ha coo6ll.leHI!1e o HapyweHI!11!1 csoV1x npas 111 cso6oA nocpeAcrsoM cosepweHV1~ renecj:>OHHoro 3SOHKa S Ae>KypHyiO 48CTb nOAP83AelleHI!1~ rocaSTOI!1HCneKL.Iil11!1 . EcnM rpa>K.QaHMH no owM6Ke HanpaeMn CBOIO 3aSIBJleHMe B JlOApa3AeJleHMe, He ynonHOMoYeHHOe Ha ero paccMorpeHMe, TO AOKYMeHT nepeHanpaenSieTCSI AOll>KHOCTHbiMM JlM'-'aMM, npMHSIBWMMM 6yMary, B COOTBeTCTBYIO~MH OTAeJl B TeYeHMe 7 AHeH.

OTnpaaneHMe 3neKTpOHHoro 3aaaneHMR 06pall.leHI!1~ OT rpa)f(,qaH S Si11Ae 3JleKTpOHHbiX C006ll.leHI!1 Jii npi11Hii1MaIOTC~ Ha cai/ire rV16AQ, pacnOJlO>KeHHOM no C~Apecy http://www.gibdd.ru. 4ro6bi noAaTb >Kano6y, norpe6yerc~ 3anOllHV1Tb aHKeTy, npeAllO>KeHHYIO cepS1!1COM .

rM&AA

CpoK paccMorpeHI!1H >Kano6bi Ha nocraHosneHI!1e rV16AQ, noAaHHoili s AOCyAe6HOM nop~AKe , He AOll>KeH npeSblwarb 30 AHei/i C MOMeHTa ee perV1CTp8l..li111!1. 3aKOHOA8TellbCTSO AOnycKaeT npOAJleHI!1e CpOKa paCCMOTpe H V1~ AOKyMeHra Ha 30 AHeili c 06H38TellbHbiM yseAOMlleHI!1eM 38HSV1TeJl~ . no 38HSJleHV110, paCCMOTpeHHOMY s nopHAKe AOCyAe6Horo 06>KallOS8HV1H, MOryT 6biTb SbiHeCeHbl ClleAYIOll.l1!1e peweHV1H: - 06 ocrasneHV11!1 >Kano6bi 6e3 YAOsnersopeHI!1R - 0 sHeceHI!11!1 s nocraHosneHI!1e V13MeHeH1!1ili . - 06 orMeHe nocraHosneHV1H rV16AQ 111 npeKpall.leHI!1V1 npoi113SOACTsa no Aeny. - 06 orMeHe nocraHoBJleHV1H V1 so3spall.leHI!11!1 Aena Ha Hosoe paccMorpeHI!1e. AaHHoe peweHI!1e SbiHOCI!1TC~ np111 HapyweHI!1V1 npOL.IeCcyallbHbiX nopHAKOS, KOTOpbie He n03SOJlii1Jlil1 nOJlHO V1 06beKTI!1SHO paCCMOTpeTb AellO. - 06 OTMeHe nocTaHOBJleHV1~ rlt16AQ 1!1 HanpasneHI!1V1 Aella H8 paCCMOTpeHI!1e no nOASeAOMCTSeHHOCTI!1 .

* ~

Bee AJIH neHcMoHepa

1001 coaet MceKpeT

(J)opMaT A4, 40 nonoc

(J)opMaT A4, 48 nonoc

DOJIDIWITECb HI BTOPOE

DOJIYrOIIE~:~c

2020 '

roo!

CaMble aecenble pacKpacKM

1001 coaet JKeHIQMHaM

(J)opMaT A4, 20 nonoc

CIJopMaT A4, 40 nonoc

BbiXOAHT 1 pa3 a M&eJILI

PaAOCTM Mcne3bl. noGeAbl MnopaJKeHMR (J)opMaT A4, 36 nonoc

• BAM

no 6 H3A8HHM B Htone, aarycTe, HOJI6pe, A8Ka6pe

1001 coaet AJIH AaiiHMKa (J)opMaT A4, 40 nonoc

DTAbiXal c KaKJpO. MynbTCKaHBOPA

TpM 555 AJIH AJWM. OtraAaiiKa

... I

nc IAKO~T

nP041114TE MOJtO.QOCTb! COBEllol ,QJifi TEX, KOMY 45+ CCIIMBHr~.t

MU18YT C BAMM

(J)opMaT A4, 52 nonoCbl BbiXOAMT 1 pa3 a MeCJILI

BbiXOAHT 1 pa3 B 2 H8AenH

Cne4BbonyCKM c1001 coaer M ceKpen N2 17. >Kano6bo: KOMy, KYAB, KaK. Mapr 2020 r. Y"PeAMTenb: ropReB IOpM<i BanepbeBM". rn . peABKTOp: 6ynaTOa A. A. YCTBHOB~HbleAePB4MR, 606037, HMll<eropOACKBR o6n., r. Aaepli<MHCK, yn . nerpM~eaa , 35-12. AApec AflR nHceM: PoccM<iCKBR <l>eAePB4MR , 606007, HMli<BrDPOACKBR o6n ., r. aaepli<MHCK, a/R 13. AApec THnorpa¢HM : PoccH<icKaR <l>eAePB4MR, 606037, HMll<eropoACKBR o6n., r. Aaepli<MHCK, yn. nerpM~eaa, 35. OrAen npOABll<: ren. (831) 322-31-22 . 3n . n~ra: izd@postpp.ru. BMA n""BTM- o¢CBTHBR. i..1BHB CB060AHBR.

@V 16+

KoMnneKT BbiXOAHT 1 paa a 2 M&eJILia

~:JABHMe aaperHcTpMpoaaHo <l>eAepanbHOC7743618 or 18 RHBapR 2011 r. MHBHMB PBABK4MM MOll<eT He coanBABTb c MHeHMeM aaropoa ny6nHKB4M<i . Bee peKnaMHpyeMbiB TOBBpbl MycnyrM nOAneli<BT 06R3BTenbHO<i cepTM¢MKB4MM.