INSIDE: JON VAN GERPEN DISCUSSES SPONTANEOUS COMBUSTION November/December 2012
Plant Maintenance Essentials Important Advice for Large Facilities and Community-Scale Producers Page 26
Plus
Additives Help Improve Biodiesel Stability, Flow and Filterability
Page 20
AND
Biodiesel Industry: Regulated
Page 32
Workplace Safety: Are Extraordinary Steps Financially Justified? Page 06
WWW.BIODIESELMAGAZINE.COM
Don’t Let Biodiesel Problems Leave You
‹ 6FKURHGHU ,QGXVWULHV
Out in the Cold.
Contamination happens. 6WRUHG EXON ELRGLHVHO IXHO FDQ EHFRPH FRQWDPLQDWHG E\ DLUERUQH GXVW DQG GLUW RU DQ\ QXPEHU RI HQYLURQPHQWDO FRQGLWLRQV OLNH FROG ZHDWKHU
Cold Clear™ 0DLQWDLQ \RXU IXHO¶V LQWHJULW\ $YRLG MHOOLQJ DQG H[SHQVLYH UHSDLUV WR YLWDO IXHO DQG HQJLQH FRPSRQHQWV E\ SODFLQJ D Cold Clear™ XQLW EHWZHHQ \RXU VWRUDJH ORFDWLRQ DQG SRLQW RI GHOLYHU\
BCC 100 &ROG &OHDUâ„¢ Unit
GlyceRx™ 3XULI\ ELRGLHVHO ZLWK VXUIDFH PRGL¿HG PHGLD GlyceRx™ $ GLUHFW UHSODFHPHQW IRU UHVLQV WKDW LV VSHFL¿FDOO\ GHVLJQHG WR DEVRUE SRODU FRPSRXQGV GlyceRx™ LV OHVV FRVWO\ GRHV QRW UDLVH WKH ))$ OHYHO DQG FDQ EH GLVSRVHG RI YLD ODQG¿OO )RU PRUH LQIRUPDWLRQ RQ HLWKHU RI WKHVH SURGXFWV SOHDVH FRQWDFW IXHO¿OWUDWLRQPDQDJHU#VFKURHGHULQGXVWULHV FRP *O\FH5[™ 0HGLD
$Q ,62 &HUWL¿HG &RPSDQ\ _ :HVW 3DUN 5RDG _ /HHWVGDOH 3$ _ S _ I _ ZZZ VFKURHGHULQGXVWULHV FRP
CONTENTS
NOVEMBER/DECEMBER 2012 VOLUME 9 ISSUE 6
26
20 ADDITIVES
MAINTENANCE MAINT
Keep Biodiesel Stable, Flowing & Growing
Advice to Operate By
BY RON KOTRBA
BY RON KOTRBA
An overview of biodiesel antioxidants and cold flow improvers
Advertiser Index 40 2012 National Advanced Biofuels Conference & Expo 38 2013 Algae Biomass Summit 11 2013 International Biomass Conference & Expo 9 & 30 2013 National Biodiesel Conference 39 BBI Consulting Services 7 Biodiesel Industry Directory 18 California Biodiesel Alliance 33 Centre for Research and Innovation in the Bio-Economy 19 Chempump 34 Crown Iron Works Company 31 EcoEngineers 22 23 29 5 24 25 10 13 2 28 35
First Environment Inc. Frazier, Barnes & Associates, LLC French Oil Mill Machinery Company INTL FCStone Inc. Iowa Central Fuel Testing Lab. Jatrodiesel, Inc. Louis Dreyfus Methes Energies Schroeder Industries Velcon Filters Wilks Enterprise, Inc.
Sound help to maintain operations in plants large and small
CONTRIBUTION 32 SAFETY
Biodiesel Industry: Regulated
Process Safety Management and regulations under OSHA, EPA
BY NATHAN VANDER GRIEND
DEPARTMENTS 4 Editor’s Note Close the Books
BY RON KOTRBA 6 Legal Perspectives
Workplace Safety: Are Extraordinary Steps Financially Justified?
BY KURTIS A. GREENLEY 8 Talking Point
Spontaneous Combustion: An Overlooked Fire Source
BY JON VAN GERPEN 10 Biodiesel Events 12 FrontEnd
Biodiesel News & Trends
14 Inside NBB 18 Business Briefs
Companies, Organizations & People in the News
Biodiesel Magazine: (USPS No. 023-975) November/December 2012, Vol. 9, Issue 6. Biodiesel Magazine is published bi-monthly by BBI International. Principal Office: 308 Second Ave. N., Suite 304, Grand Forks, ND 58203. Periodicals Postage Paid at Grand Forks, North Dakota and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Biodiesel Magazine/Subscriptions, 308 Second Ave. N., Suite 304, Grand Forks, North Dakota 58203.
36 Marketplace
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
3
EDITOR'S NOTE
CLOSE THE BOOKS Ron Kotrba
Editor Biodiesel Magazine rkotrba@bbiinternational.com
www.BiodieselMagazine.com
E D I T O R I A L
While 2011 was a monumental year for U.S. biodiesel as the industry came back from near collapse the year before, 2012 is probably best forgotten, all things considered. Overall, domestic
Tom Bryan President & Editor in Chief tbryan@bbiinternational.com Tim Portz Vice President of Content & Executive Editor tportz@bbiinternational.com Ron Kotrba Editor rkotrba@bbiinternational.com Jan Tellmann Copy Editor jtellmann@bbiinternational.com P U B L I S H I N G Mike Bryan Joe Bryan Matthew Spoor Howard Brockhouse
&
S A L E S
Chairman mbryan@bbiinternational.com CEO jbryan@bbiinternational.com Vice President, Sales & Marketing mspoor@bbiinternational.com Executive Account Manager hbrockhouse@bbiinternational.com
Marty Steen
Account Manager msteen@bbiinternational.com
Bob Brown
Account Manager bbrown@bbiinternational.com
Andrea Anderson Jessica Beaudry
Account Manager aanderson@bbiinternational.com Circulation Manager jbeaudry@bbiinternational.com
Marla DeFoe
Advertising Coordinator mdefoe@bbiinternational.com
John Nelson
Senior Marketing Manager jnelson@bbiinternational.com
Jaci Satterlund Elizabeth Burslie
A R T Art Director jsatterlund@bbiinternational.com Graphic Designer bburslie@bbiinternational.com
Subscriptions Subscriptions to Biodiesel Magazine are free of charge to everyone with the exception of a shipping and handling charge of $49.95 for any country outside the United States, Canada and Mexico. To subscribe, visit www.biodieselmagazine. com or you can send your mailing address and payment (checks made out to BBI International) to: Biodiesel Magazine Subscriptions, 308 Second Ave. N., Suite 304, Grand Forks, ND 58203. You can also fax a subscription form to 701-7465367. Reprints and Back Issues Select back issues are available for $3.95 each, plus shipping. Article reprints are also available for a fee. For more information, contact us at 701-746-8385 or service@bbiinternational.com. Advertising Biodiesel Magazine provides a specific topic delivered to a highly targeted audience. We are committed to editorial excellence and high-quality print production. To find out more about Biodiesel Magazine advertising opportunities, please contact us at 701-7468385 or service@bbiinternational.com. Letters to the Editor We welcome letters to the editor. If you write us, please include your name, address and phone number. Letters may be edited for clarity and/or space. Send to Biodiesel Magazine Letters, 308 Second Ave. N., Suite 304, Grand Forks, ND 58203 or email to rkotrba@ bbiinternational.com.
production remained strong despite the fact that RIN fraud essentially defined the industry to some—to those who only know of biodiesel because of the scandal. For a different lot, perhaps catastrophic fires at production sites from Germany to Canada to Louisiana now characterize this industry. To others, maybe the word “limited” now portrays biodiesel’s future, given Europe’s very recent proposal to include the unsound science of indirect land use change in its Renewable Energy Directive. And who could forget the prolonged biodiesel trade war between Spain and Argentina? If the petroleum industry can bounce back from rock bottom after the Deepwater Horizon offshore oil rig exploded in the Gulf—killing 11 workers and injuring 17—so strongly that just two years later it got nary a mention as presidential candidates debated who was the bigger champion of oil, then these unfortunate events suffered by the biodiesel industry in 2012 are petroleum-free water under the bridge. For me and everyone I know in this integrity-filled, safety-conscious, resilient, unlimited, green industry of biodiesel, 2013 is sure to be a remarkable year. The fact that, despite these misfortunes endured all year, the U.S. EPA saw past those anomalies and increased the biomass-based diesel carve-out in the renewable fuel standard by 280 million gallons (from 1 billion to 1.28 billion gallons) speaks volumes. Provided Congress does not intervene while EPA and private industry are correcting deficiencies in the RIN program, the new year promises to bring with it a sounder, fairer regulation of the RIN market for everyone.
Please recycle this magazine and remove inserts or samples before recycling TM
4
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
COPYRIGHT © 2012 by BBI International
A GLOBAL UNDERSTANDING Biodiesel is a global industry, and it takes a company with a worldwide reach to understand it. That’s INTL FCStone Inc. and its subsidiaries. Whether your operations are centered in Brazil, Europe, Australia, China or the United States, we can make your world a little easier to manage and understand. With deep roots in agribusiness, we have a wealth of resources to help you cope with uncertainty and price volatility in grain, energy, ethanol, and other renewable fuels. With customers in more than 100 countries around the world and wide-ranging expertise in interest rate and currency risk management, we’ve got you covered no matter where you are or what you need.
FCStone, LLC
Renewable Fuels Group West Des Moines, Iowa 2829 Westown Parkway, Ste. 100 renewablefuels@intlfcstone.com 800.422.3087, ext. 7419 www.intlfcstone.com Commodity trading involves risks, and you should fully understand those risks before trading.
LEGAL PERSPECTIVE
Workplace Safety: Are Extraordinary Steps Financially Justified? BY KURTIS A. GREENLEY
Biodiesel companies face substantial financial exposure if they fail to provide a safe working environment.
Personal injuries to employees result in expensive and time-consuming workers compensation claims. Additionally, several states allow an injured employee to also bring a lawsuit against a third party who contributed to the injury, and that third party may be able to seek financial contribution from the employer if it was also negligent. Another area of exposure arises when nonemployees visit the biodiesel plant for business or personal reasons and are injured as a result of an unsafe or hazardous condition at the plant. The financial impact of such injuries is substantial, especially if the biodiesel company is self-insured, if it is insured but has a large self-retention on its policy, or if the liability limits are inadequate. Even if fully insured, a history of claims affects experience ratings and leads to increased premiums. Injury claims also place demands on the company, requiring substantial time from management and other personnel to defend the claims. A biodiesel company can also face large workplace penalties not covered by insurance. The federal Occupational Safety and Health Act requires employers to comply with numerous safety and health standards. OSHA plant inspections invariably follow a serious injury, and OSHA has statutory authority to perform unannounced or surprise inspections. Penalties for violations of health or safety regulations anywhere in the plant can be assessed even though there has never been an injury. These penalties are based on the categories of violations as follows: Other-than-serious: This violation is one where death or serious physical harm cannot be expected; the penalty is up to $7,000 for each violation. Serious: A serious violation is one that could result in death or serious physical harm; the penalty is up to $7,000 for each violation. Willful: A willful violation is one in which the employer knew that a hazardous condition existed, the condition violated a standard or regulation, and the employer made no reasonable effort to eliminate the hazard. The penalty is up to $70,000 for each violation.
6
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
Repeated: A repeated violation is imposed if the employer has been cited for a “substantially similar” violation anywhere in the nation within the past five years, even if the person in charge of plant safety is unaware of the earlier violation. A repeated violation carries a penalty of up to $70,000 for each violation. Other penalties include a $7,000 per day penalty for failure to timely abate a violation, and a $7,000 penalty per violation for failing to post information required by OSHA. Experienced companies recognize that once there has been a serious accident or injury involving its operations, it is too late to avoid the adverse affects. The same may be said of OSHA violations. Prevention is the only real way to avoid this loss. And being proactive need not be overly expensive, nor require extensive administrative time by the company. It has been estimated by OSHA that an effective safety and health program can save $4 to $6 for every $1 invested. Not only is it the right thing to do, but it pays off in lower costs, increased productivity and higher employee morale. Reducing work place losses is a goal the biodiesel company shares with OSHA. In this respect, OSHA offers numerous programs and areas of assistance. The OSHA Consultation Service helps employers identify potential hazards and improve their occupational safety and health management. The consultation is a free service largely funded by OSHA and operated by state agencies using trained safety and health staff. The OSHA training institute also provides basic and advanced training and education in safety and health. Compliance assistance specialists are available in each OSHA area office to provide general information about OSHA standards and compliance assistance resources. Other employer assistance programs are available through the OSHA area office. OSHA also has an extensive publications program. For a list of items, visit OSHA’s website at www.osha.gov or contact OSHA’s publications office, U.S. Department of Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue, NW, N-3101, Washington D.C., 20210. Author: Kurtis A. Greenley Attorney, Linquist & Vennum PLLP kgreenley@lindquist.com
Biodiesel Magazine’s
Biodiesel Industry Directory 2013 GET LISTED TODAY Print & Online
Hurry, deadline for print insertion: November 19, 2012
Biodiesel Magazine is proud to present the 2013 Biodiesel Industry Directory, the most comprehensive list of industry suppliers, producers, researchers and government agencies available in the world. The directory is an invaluable resource to help find the contact information you are looking for and help others find you, both in our print and online editions.
Visit: www.biodiesel-directory.com
It’s published annually One FREE listing per business Sent to all Biodiesel Magazine subscribers and major related conferences
Add logo and utilize display advertising for a low rate Join the most comprehensive list of biodiesel industry pros in the world
Questions? CONTACT US: 866-746-8385 service@bbiinternational.com www.biodiesel-directory.com
TALKING POINT
Spontaneous Combustion: An Overlooked Fire Source BY JON VAN GERPEN
Fires and accidents at biodiesel plants have heightened everyone’s awareness of the need to emphasize safety in plant operations. One chronic problem is fires that start mysteriously, with no apparent cause. Adding to the mystery is that many of these facility fires occur at night, when very few, if any, workers are present to point a finger at the source. Spontaneous combustion is a likely source of many of these fires. Researchers in the USDA-sponsored Biodiesel Education Program at the University of Idaho are studying the nature of spontaneous combustion of materials used to clean up biodiesel spills. We intend to isolate the ignition point of certain biodiesel fuels, the mechanisms leading to self-ignition, and recommend procedures to reduce the risk of spontaneous combustion in biodiesel production facilities. Spontaneous combustion is a bit of a nebulous phenomenon in the biodiesel industry, although it is a well-known problem with petrol fuel. Materials soaked in natural oils with a high number of double-bonded carbon atoms—such as many feedstocks used to make biodiesel— oxidize quickly. The oxidation process releases heat that causes an increase in core temperature. The materials begin to smolder and eventually self-ignite. Biodiesel researchers think they know the recipe for this reaction in theory, but there is very little research available that has studied its detailed cause or provided industry safety practices. In comparison, biodiesel producers are well aware of the risks of methanol use. They work with it every day and have a lot of respect for its volatile nature. Most safety information available for biodiesel production concentrates on reducing fire exposure to methanol, and rightly so. It is important to note that methanol is often just the fuel for the fire, and not the cause. The problem with analyzing the cause of fires that result in explosion or intense heat is finding the cause of the blaze. Could the fire have started with a spark or a flame? An often overlooked possibility is spontaneous combustion from improper disposal of material used to clean up biodiesel oil spills. A relatively recent fire where the cause has been attributed to spontaneous combustion took place in Nagoya, Japan, in August 2005. A facility worker simply placed a work rag in a cardboard box. The rag and box were consumed in the fire, but enough of the rag was left to determine that 8
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
trace amounts of fatty acid methyl esters were present in the rag. Since the rag was found within the point of origin of the fire, officials speculated that the source of the fire was the spontaneous ignition of the rag. Researchers at the University of Idaho have demonstrated that spontaneous combustion may pose a serious threat to biodiesel production facilities. We replicated a scenario of spontaneous combustion in our facility, using sawdust soaked in a mixture of biodiesel and boiled linseed oil for the initial experiments. This mixture is susceptible to quick oxidation due to a high degree of unsaturation. The core temperature of the mix increased steadily over time. Within two hours, the material began to visibly smolder; within eight hours, the material ignited and was consumed by fire. At the time when a visible flame appeared, the material had reached a core temperature of more than 400 degrees Celsius. Our observations lead us to believe that the probability of spontaneous combustion is associated with the level of rancidity of the biodiesel, the characteristics of the absorbent materials, the ease with which air could move through the material, and the ambient conditions in the storage environment. We are investigating what combination of these variables must be present to lead to spontaneous combustion, and what changes in the combination of these variables can prevent it. Production facility workers must be diligent in the disposal of materials used to clean up equipment and biodiesel spills. Rags used to clean up biodiesel should be disposed of in a separate, fire-safe, enclosed container, or laid out individually to dry. Biodiesel-soaked absorbent materials such as sawdust, Magnesol or Oil-Dri should not be composted. A recent incident of a compost fire caused by spontaneous combustion of oil-soaked Magnesol smoldered for weeks. In fact, some landfills refuse to accept these materials. As we conduct more research into the causes of spontaneous combustion of biodiesel-soaked materials, we will post our findings, photographs and video on our Biodiesel Education Program website, www.BiodieselEducation.org. Author: Jon Van Gerpen Biological and Agricultural Engineering Department Head, University of Idaho 208-885-7891 jonvg@uidaho.edu
20 years. 1.1 billion gallons. 1 industry with momentum. NBB IS CELEBRATING OUR 20TH ANNIVERSARY IN LAS VEGAS. FEBRUARY 4-7 THE MIRAGE HOTEL AND CONVENTION CENTER
2013 marks a momentous occasion for us: the 20th anniversary of the National Biodiesel Board — and of the U.S. biodiesel industry. What better way for you to celebrate this important milestone than by attending the upcoming 2013 National Biodiesel Conference & Expo? With 20 years and annual production topping 1.1 billion gallons of biodiesel, NBB has become a true force in our nation’s fuel supply. So the theme of this year’s conference — MOMENTUM — is aptly chosen. This conference is the only event all year that gathers biodiesel decisions makers from every part of the globe. All the important players who are having an impact in the industry will be there. Will you?
Hosted by
For details on the conference, visit www.biodieselconference.org
EVENTS CALENDAR LDCommodities.com
National Advanced Biofuels Conference & Expo NOVEMBER 27-29, 2012
Creating Opportunity Since 1851.
Hilton Americas - Houston Houston, Texas Next Generation Fuels and Chemicals Make plans to attend the 2012 National Advanced Biofuels Conference & Expo in Houston. With three comprehensive program tracks, titled Pathways & Partnerships, Inputs & Supply Chains and Money & Markets, this year’s event will feature advanced biofuels and biobased chemicals—technology scale-up, project finance, policy, national markets and more—with a core focus on the industrial, petroleum and agribusiness alliances defining the national advanced biofuels industry. 866-746-8385 | www.advancedbiofuelsconference.com
Canadian Renewable Fuels Summit DECEMBER 3-5, 2012
Partnership Connecting Your Supply to the Domestic and Global Marketplace.
Westin Ottawa Hotel Ottawa, Ontario Canada is now a frontrunner in the worldwide effort to create clean, renewable sources of transportation fuel. Learn from industry experts, engage in valuable peer-to-peer collaboration, find solutions for your business challenges, and discover new products and services. The CRFS is a great opportunity to exchange ideas and gain a global perspective on the renewable fuels industry. We offer insightful plenaries and are now offering concurrent industry breakout sessions. 613-594-5528, ext. 223 | www.greenfuels.org
International Biomass Conference & Expo
Community
APRIL 8-10, 2013
Active Participation in the Communities Where We Live and Work.
Commitment Supported by the Reliability and Financial Security of Louis Dreyfus Commodities.
Minneapolis Convention Center Minneapolis, Minnesota Building on Innovation Organized by BBI International and coproduced by Biomass Magazine, the International Biomass Conference & Expo program will include 30-plus panels and more than 100 speakers, including 90 technical presentations on topics ranging from anaerobic digestion and gasification to pyrolysis and combined heat and power. This dynamic event unites industry professionals from all sectors of the world’s interconnected biomass utilization industries—biobased power, thermal energy, fuels and chemicals. 866-746-8385 | www.biomassconference.com
International Fuel Ethanol Workshop & Expo JUNE 10-13, 2013
America’s Center St. Louis, Missouri Where Producers Meet Now in its 29th year, the FEW provides the global ethanol industry with cuttingedge content and unparalleled networking opportunities in a dynamic business-to-business environment. The FEW is the largest, longest running ethanol conference in the world—and the only event powered by Ethanol Producer Magazine. Visit our website to reserve premium booth space now. 866-746-8385 | www.fuelethanolworkshop.com
10
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
Make Plans to Attend REGISTER NOW Interested in Speaking? Presentation ideas and poster abstracts will be accepted through December 14, 2012. Submit in one of five tracks: Track 1: Pellets & Densified Biomass Track 2: Industrial & Commercial Thermal Energy Track 3: Biomass Power Track 4: Biogas & Landfill Gas Track 5: Advanced Biofuels & Biobased Chemicals
APRIL 8-10, 2013 Minneapolis, MN www.biomassconference.com
"The quality of business relationships built here are second to none." - Stephen S. Reidell, Eagle Innovations
866-746-8385 | service@bbiinternational.com |
#IBCE13 Follow Us: twitter.com/biomassmagazine
FrontEnd
Biodiesel News & Trends
The largest U.S. biodiesel producer, Renewable Energy Group Inc., with 210 million gallons of owned/operated biodiesel production capacity, originally anticipated its third quarter adjusted earnings before the deduction of interest, tax and amortization expenses (EBITDA) at a gain of $10 million to $15 million. It later issued guidance stating its third quarter EBITDA would result in a loss of $2 million to $7 million. While its final figures were due out at press time, this represents a significant financial swing, one largely blamed on movements in commodity prices and “a steep depreciation in the price of RINs” and, as a result, tighter margins than expected. Earlier this year, biodiesel RINs were close to $1.50. Just recently, biodiesel RINs dipped down to near 40 cents. “Despite these fluctuations in our markets, we remain optimistic about the longterm prospects for REG and the biodiesel industry,” says Daniel Oh, president and CEO of REG. “The recent finalization of the 2013 [renewable volume obligation] provides growing demand for the next year. Our flexible feedstock technology gives us a long-term advantage as a low-cost producer, since we can adjust to fluctuations in feedstock prices. Furthermore, REG continues to have a strong balance sheet with cash to sustain our growth strategy. Our risk management positions serve the economic purpose of reducing the effect of changing commodity prices and protecting the margin and profitability of contracted biodiesel sales. Volatile commodity fuel prices late in the quarter affected the market value of financial contracts, causing most of the reduction in adjusted EBITDA; however, the cash margin earned from biodiesel sales is protected by utilizing these financial contracts. From an accounting perspective, we must recognize such risk management losses in the third quarter, although the biodiesel sale that a position is protecting may occur in the fourth quarter. A secondary driver of our results was the decline in biodiesel RIN prices of approximately 35 percent during the quarter, which negatively impacted our revenue and resulted in tighter margin per gallon sold than expected. RINs can and do trade separately from energy and fluctuate in value based on supply and demand.”
Projected Adjusted EBITDA (in millions of dollars)
Major financial swings
One-step algae harvesting, dewatering, FAME production Researchers from the University of Texas at Austin have developed a proof-ofconcept design to harvest, dewater and convert algae to biodiesel in a one-step process using resins. In a paper titled, “Use of Anion Exchange Resins for One-Step Processing of Algae from Harvest to Biofuel,” University of Texas at Austin scientists Jessica Jones, Cheng-Han Lee, James Wang and Martin Poenie note that to circumvent the costprohibitive obtainment of algae oil due to the pumping and processing of large volumes of dilute algal suspensions, they used Amberlite anion exchange resins to simplify the process, which has potential to greatly reduce costs. Researchers packed a column with the beaded, fixed-charge Amberlite anion exchange resins and poured dilute algae water through. The algae bind with the resins and, at the point of saturation, the water coming out of the bottom of the column changed from clear to green-colored. They eluted algae off the resins with a 5 percent mix of methanol and sulfuric acid, essentially regenerating the resins for reuse. “The eluted algae appear to dissolve in the sulfuric acid reagent and esterified fatty acids are converted to FAMEs (biodiesel),” the researchers note. Poenie tells Biodiesel Magazine the researchers are working to develop resins with higher binding capacities.
12
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
FRONTEND
EPA boosts biodiesel mandate by 28 percent
More than a year passed since U.S. EPA first proposed boosting the biomass-based diesel mandate from 1 billion gallons in 2012 to 1.28 billion gallons in 2013. During that time, the $1 per gallon federal tax credit disappeared; high-profile biodiesel RIN fraud cases were exposed and discussed in major news outlets and in congressional hearings, causing a freezing of markets and hesitancy of obligated parties to buy biodiesel RINs; RFS waiver requested mounted; and reports leaked out of Europe that indicated what is now public information—the Continent was going to limit crop-based biofuels moving forward. Despite those challenges, the biodiesel industry perseveres, thanks in large part to efforts from biodiesel advocates, producers and the National Biodiesel Board. Here’s to 1.28 billion gallons of RIN-fraud-free production in the new year.
‘Biodiesel High’ seeks expansion In Fenton, Mo., Rockwood Summit High School students and chemistry teacher Darrin Peters have taken hands-on learning to a new level with biodiesel production. The journey began five years ago when a student learned from Peters that fuel could be produced from waste grease. Since then, select Rockwood Summit High School advanced classes have expanded laboratory work to regularly produce biodiesel fuel from waste oil collected from the cafeteria. After using a small, dedicated space in a school storage shed to produce biodiesel, they’re ready to expand. Peters is heading up financing for the new Falcon Renewable Fuel Educational Center. The proposed center would be 20 feet by 25 feet and would cost $100,000. The school’s initial equipment was crude but the new processor and design is markedly more sophisticated. It recently won a grant to help pay for solenoid valves to facilitate automation. “We are two months away from having a biodiesel processor that can be operated and monitored from my classroom computer,” Peters says. “These kids are phenomenal. We want room to say, ‘Yes, we can try that,’ when a student says, ‘What if we tried this?’” “I’ve learned that perseverance in biodiesel can go a long way— and having passion also,” says Rockwood Summit senior A.J. Park. “It helps you learn so much more than if you gave up on the first try.” Senior Austin Martin is helping set up automation programming. When Park tells people what kind of work she is doing, they’re shocked. “I think the main reaction we get is, ‘Are you high school students?’” she says. “They’re just surprised high school students would be doing this— it’s not like it’s complicated, but it’s not like high school work.”
Industry Momentum Paves Way for Future Growth Throughout our industry’s 20-year history, we’ve faced numerous challenges as we’ve grown our biodiesel businesses. I often think back to the group of soybean farmer leaders who met in 1992 to form a small development group to research a new biofuel. They had a vision for developing and commercializing biodiesel and in the process launch a new industry that created jobs, diversified our energy supply and benefited their fellow farmers. Fast-forward to 2012: The first domestically produced, nationwide advanced biofuel, biodiesel, today has a bright future. The renewable fuel standard has proven very effective as the leading demand driver for the biodiesel industry. Our No. 1 priority is to maintain our position as an advanced biofuel and grow the renewable volume obligation (RVO). In order to continue providing benefits to our country under the RFS, we must have RIN integrity throughout the biodiesel supply chain by focusing on administrative discipline and continuous improvement in the RINs system. Biodiesel offers a gallon of RIN compliance with every gallon of fuel and we must continue to work as a united industry to demonstrate our industry’s diligence as a reliable source of both biodiesel and RINs. I believe biodiesel producers large and small across the country would all agree that we cannot let our industry be tarnished by the unlawful actions of a few who made headlines for their 2010 and 2011 action. NBB worked feverishly to address this with the work of the RIN Integrity Task Force, development of the Genscape program and continuous collaboration with the EPA and the petroleum industry. While this problem continues to be a very difficult issue to address, our industry’s conscientious work will continue on this effort into FY 2013. With NBB members from nearly every state in the country, I encourage you to utilize our NBB Washington, D.C., team as a coordination point in your company’s lobbying efforts. Grassroots advocacy will continue to play a major role in accomplishing our RFS and RIN integrity goals and a coordinated team is needed for a highly effective effort. We received some most welcome news in mid-September when, after numerous delays, EPA announced the 2013 1.28 billion gallon RVO for biomass-based diesel. This precedent-setting achievement required an extraordinary amount of effort given the enormously challenging po-
14
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
litical dynamics. Thousands of letters were sent to administration officials and members of Congress. To help make our message widely heard and seen, NBB activated additional paid advertising tactics and enlisted public relations coalitions in key political states. Members aggressively campaigned in Washington, securing more than 60 signatures from members of Congress calling for the vol- Gary Haer, ume increase. To be sure, the 2013 RVO victory Chairman, National could not have happened without the grassroots Biodiesel Board efforts of your work; and the 2014 RVO recommendation will need just as much support, if not more. The renewable fuel standard remains the focal point for all NBB program activities. Truly successful implementation of the RFS program includes the Advanced Biofuel Initiative, enhanced fuel quality programs, OEM outreach, sustainability research, feedstock research and development as well as technical, marketing and communications programs. Today, our industry directly supports the livelihood of nearly 10,000 green-collar Americans. Another 25,000 people work in jobs that support, or are supported by, biodiesel produced across the country. With the growth of the RFS, we project the production of biodiesel will support more than 74,000 jobs in all sectors of the economy by 2015. I congratulate our industry’s earliest visionaries who sat around the table in 1992 and had the courage to begin the biodiesel endeavor. Over the past two decades, our industry has seen production levels expand and contract with new market opportunities or market uncertainty. Through it all, our members have driven forward with passion for energy security, cleaner air and economic development. I am energized by our industry’s recent momentum and hope you’ll join me in continuing to promote America’s advanced biofuel as an engaged and enthusiastic member of the National Biodiesel Board. Gary Haer, Chairman, National Biodiesel Board
inside
NBB Grassroots, advocacy efforts secure 2013 RFS volume increase The EPA’s recent decision to raise next year's biodiesel volume requirement under the RFS to 1.28 billion gallons was a pivotal and well-deserved victory for our industry. It also was a case study in grassroots advocacy that illustrates the impact we can have when we unite around a cause and make our voice heard. Over the past year, biodiesel supporters sent several thousand letters to the Obama administration and to Congress pushing for a positive decision. We made hundreds of phone calls, and dozens of us personally visited our elected officials in Congress or held meetings with the EPA to demonstrate why growing the biodiesel industry is good for America. The National Biodiesel Board’s Washington office reinforced this outreach with more than 200 meetings with lawmakers and administration officials. Sixty U.S. senators and representatives weighed in with letters of their own showing the positive economic, environmental and national
security benefits of U.S. biodiesel production. As your trade association, NBB understands that your daily work can be overwhelming and that it often seems impossible to find time in the day to get involved with policy and politics. After all, that’s why NBB has such a large presence in Washington—to represent your interests. But even with the best professional advocates in the business, our ability to get things done is directly related to our grassroots advocacy. Unless our political leaders know that their decisions directly affect constituents like you, we won’t be heard. Without letters, visits and phone calls from communities across the country, our policy victories will get fewer and fewer between. So please pat yourself on the back for a job well done on the 2013 volume. And then think about how important federal policies such as the RFS and the biodiesel tax incentive are to the success of our industry, and get ready for another round of advocacy in the near future.
How to join NBB The National Biodiesel Board is organized exclusively to promote the common business interests of those parties seeking to advance the use of biodiesel as a fuel or fuel additive that meets ASTM standards.To advance these common interests, the NBB will admit to membership, on a nondiscriminatory basis, any industry member or supporter who meets the member requirements. Whether you want to be a producer of biodiesel or are a company that supports the biodiesel industry through provision of
goods and/or services or simply an individual who supports biodiesel, the NBB has a lot to offer. To find out more visit http://nbb. org/join-us. For membership information, please contact Doug Whitehead, director of operations and member services, at 800-841-5849 dwhitehead@biodiesel.org.
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
15
insideNBB
Registrations picking up for 2013 biodiesel conference Discounted rates continue for the 2013 National Biodiesel Conference & Expo, but hurry because the rates climb steadily until the event, which takes place Feb. 4-7 at the Mirage Resort & Casino in Las Vegas. You can read the full session descriptions on the Schedule-ata-Glance, www.biodieselconference.org. You won’t want to miss a single day of the conference. The lineup of speakers relevant to growing the business of biodiesel continues to expand, with top scientists, original equipment manufacturer representatives, petroleum industry leaders and policy experts. National Biodiesel Board members receive low rates as a benefit of membership. The organization also has other programs designed to bring in valued stakeholders, including discounted rates for Clean Cities Coordinators, a U.S. DOE program; and Biodiesel Ambassadors, an NBB program. Also this year, thanks to the United Soybean Board and state soybean boards, a select few of tomorrow’s biofuel scientists will again be able to attend the conference. About a dozen scholarships are available to Next Generation Scientists for Biodiesel members to attend the conference. We’re also inviting
Scholarships and a student poster session will give college students an opportunity to participate in the 2013 Biodiesel Conference & Expo.
college students to submit abstracts for a poster session, which will take place in the exhibit hall for the second year. In 2013, we celebrate the 20th anniversary of the NBB, and the 10th National Biodiesel Conference & Expo. This conference has grown from a small gathering at our first event in Palm Springs, Calif., in 2004, to a powerful platform that drives biodiesel business all year long. See you in Las Vegas!
Who’s benefiting from the National Biodiesel Foundation—is it you? The short answer is all of us. The National Biodiesel Foundation manages or contributes to multiple projects directly benefiting the entire biodiesel industry. For starters, the foundation is funding critical land use modeling research at Purdue University. The results of this work will better position biodiesel to compete in California’s low carbon fuels market. Findings are expected to be published this fall. Earlier this year, the foundation supported the Sustainability Symposium held at the 2012 National Biodiesel Conference and the 4th Annual Biofuels: Science and Sustainability Congressional Tour. While the Sustainability Symposium provided academics and experts an opportunity to exchange information with each other and attendees, the congressional tour helped spread the word about the positive attributes of biodiesel to congressional members and their staff, the Congressional Research Service and other key individuals. With a grant from the U.S. DOE, the foundation continued to fund fuel distributors to install biodiesel terminals. These terminals are expanding distribution nationwide making this advanced biofuel more readily available.
NBB welcomes new members Green Energy Products LLC—Sedgwick, Kan. Viesel Fuel LLC—Stuart, Fla. 16
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
Foundation efforts in education, research and infrastructure development are drawing the attention of private businesses. Last spring, US Coachways, a charter bus company, began making regular contributions. According to NBF Executive Director Tom Verry, “Coachways’ monthly contributions are mutually beneficial. Their support of the foundation helps Coachways meet their desire to go green, while we enjoy the needed flexible revenue for critical biodiesel research and education.” Verry added, “We want to encourage more companies to do the same—to get involved with the NBF to support the advancement of the biodiesel industry.” US Coachways and other corporate donors have been featured on NBF’s website leader boards, in press articles and in other announcements. This year, the foundation plans to fund a large multifuel study necessary to help defend the RFS. Without additional funding, this work cannot move forward. To contribute to the NBF or learn more about its activities, visit them at www.biodieselfoundation.org.
Southern Energy Company Inc.—Shelbyville, Tenn. Fusion Renewables LLC—Milwaukee, Wis.
insideNBB
NBB gets to work on 2013
Securing the RFS volume increase for 2013 was one of the major industry successes this year.
Though most will wait until January to ring in the new year, the National Biodiesel Board is already hard at work on FY 2013 priorities. The new fiscal year began Oct. 1, closing out a significant and productive 2012. Despite continued challenges, it is impresThe BQ-9000 program saw a 20 sive what NBB accomplishes to percent growth in accredited companies during NBB’s FY support member priorities. 2012. With support from the soybean checkoff and federal grants, NBB leverages member dues to contributions 4-to-1. So for every dues dollar we can invest in policy issues, there is outside money available to support key programs like engine testing, communications and sustainability research. Securing 1.28 million gallons for 2013 was a big win and an uphill battle, but it’s just one of the many things to be proud of when looking back on the year. For example, NBB wrapped up its second year of a national ad campaign. The effort featured two 30-second television spots, print, online and radio ads and has already worked to advance biodiesel’s image as America’s advanced biofuel. Bioheat also gained new ground with it’s “the Evolution of Oilheat” campaign. The regional effort included ads as well as direct outreach and promotions to dealers. NBB’s RIN Integrity Task Force set to work and advised Genscape on their launch of a real-time audit system to help shore up RIN integrity. Overall, the BQ-9000 program saw a 20 percent growth in accredited companies in FY 2012, bringing the volume of biodiesel produced by BQ-9000 companies to 85 percent, marking continued expansion of quality fuel in the marketplace. This year, six states were added to the list of those that proactively enforce the ASTM specification for biodiesel. This means that 23 of
The second year of the Advanced Biofuel Initiative used TV, print, online, and radio ads to showcase biodiesel as America’s advanced biofuel.
Bioheat’s “the Evolution of Oilheat” campaign helped move the needle for biodiesel in heating oil country with a comprehensive media campaign that included fuel delivery truck wraps.
the 50 U.S. states now enforce D6751, up from only seven five years ago. NBB continues to invest in research that proves our environmental benefit, such as continued work to improve the quantification of indirect land-use change. In early FY 2012, the NBB’s Biodiesel for Diesel Technicians training curriculum received accreditation under the National Institute for Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) Continuing Automotive Service Excellence (CASE) program. Also in the technical umbrella, 2012 saw the development of a biodiesel durability protocol for the railroad sector. 2012 saw the final passage of the No. 1-B grade of biodiesel into ASTM D6751, with tighter controls on monoglycerides (0.4 percent by mass maximum) and a year-round cold soak value of 200 seconds maximum. While this list is not even close to exhaustive, it gives a glimpse into the power of a unified trade association working to further members’ priorities.
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
17
BusinessBriefs While petroleum-based methyl tertiarybutyl ether (MTBE) has largely been replaced with ethanol as a gasoline additive in the U.S. due to environmental concerns of groundwater contamination, Evonik recently announced it has been producing commercial volumes of a biobased version of the antiknock agent using an ingredient refined from crude glycerin, a coproduct of the biodiesel production process. Evonik produces its bioMTBE from isobutene and biobased methanol. Horst-Oliver Buchholz told Biodiesel Magazine that Evonik does not produce the biomethanol itself, but rather the chemical firm buys the glycerin-derived product from the market to manufacture bioMTBE alongside conventional MTBE at its factory in Marl, Germany. The company said because the biomethanol is made from raw glycerin, it is classified as a waste product according to the EU Renewable Energy Directive, thereby doubling its value for determining bioenergy content. Portugal-based biodiesel technology provider Incbio is marketing its latest development to the global biodiesel industry:
Companies, Organizations & People in the News
a multifeedstock platform based on heterogeneous, solid catalysis. Incbio says the technology has been commercially proven already in biodiesel plants with production capacity up to 30 MMgy and feedstock up to 90 percent free fatty acids. The catalyst lasts one to three years without replacement, provided appropriate feedstock pretreatment is performed to remove reactive contaminants, polymers and phospholipids that can foul the conversion beds. Incbio contends advantages of its system include ability to use lower-grade feedstock; “instantaneous” reaction and consistent quality from ultrasonic reactors; continuous production; skid-mounted modular design; variable flow rates from 500 kilograms an hour to commercial-scale flow rates; an energy-efficient design; methanol recovery; low capital and operating expenses; and the possibility of integrating (with automation) the process technology with existing commercial facilities. The firm says it can also “future proof ” plants with distillation and glycerin purification modules. Biodico Inc. and LamdaGen Corp. have entered a collaboration whereby LamdaGen's nanobased Meta-Catalytic Surface technology will be integrated into Biodico’s research and development programs for biomass-based diesel, combined
heat and power and biochemicals. Additional LamdaGen technologies will be incorporated into Biodico’s ongoing R&D programs, one of which developed the game-changing ARIES (Automated Real-time, Remote, Integrated Energy System) technology under the auspices of a Cooperative Research and Development Agreement with the U.S. Navy in 2002. Biodico is located at the National Environment Technology Test Site on Naval Base Ventura County, Calif.
Investors in Paseo Biofuels LLC, the Missouri Soybean Association and Cargill announced an expansion to the Paseo biodiesel plant in Kansas City, Mo., that will increase biodiesel production capacity by 40 percent. Using soybean oil as its primary feedstock, the facility, which opened in 2008, produces 40 million gallons of biodiesel and 30 million pounds of food-grade glycerin annually. The expansion is expected to be complete by March 2013. Paseo was started out of an equity drive in 2006, in which more than 650 agricultural producers in the state
Co-located with the th
10 ANNUAL NATIONAL BIODIESEL CONFERENCE & EXPO
REGISTER TODAY! www.BiodieselConference.org/2013/CBA DISCOUNT TO CBA MEMBERS: Call 916-583-8015 | www.CaliforniaBiodieselAlliance.org 18
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
BUSINESSBRIEFS Sponsored by purchased shares. The company then formed a joint venture with Cargill to help make the facility a reality. It is located near the Paseo Bridge in Kansas City, Mo. Algae.Tec Ltd. and Lufthansa have signed a collaboration agreement for the construction of a large-scale algae-to-aviation biofuels production facility. The site will be in Europe, adjacent to an industrial CO2 source. Lufthansa will arrange 100 percent funding for the project. Algae.Tec will receive license fees and profits from the project, which will be managed by Algae.Tec. As part of the agreement, Lufthansa commits to a long-term offtake agreement of at least 50 percent of the crude oil produced at an agreed price. The agreement forms the base for a long-term cooperation between Algae. Tec and Lufthansa for the industrial production of crude algae suitable for conversion into aviation kerosene and conventional diesel fuels. A final feasibility report will be completed once the first site has been selected. A new hub of biodiesel distribution is up and running in Des Moines, Iowa, leading to greater consumer access to biodiesel. On Sept. 14, the Iowa Biodiesel Board congratulated the Magellan Pipeline Co. for completing a new biodiesel distribution facil-
ity at its largest petroleum distribution terminal in the state. The company announced the opening of the terminal facility at the IBB annual meeting Sept. 7. The installation of new equipment will allow for the unloading, storage and blending of biodiesel at the terminal. Magellan received partial funding for the project from the Iowa Renewable Fuel Infrastructure Board, the Iowa Soybean Association and soybean checkoff program, and the Iowa Economic Development Authority funded by the U.S. DOE. The infrastructure upgrade will enhance distribution of biodiesel by making it simple for petroleum distributors to access preblended fuel. Biodiesel is now available via truckload from Renewable Energy Group’s new biodiesel location in Rancho Dominguez outside of Long Beach, Calif. The first truckload of biodiesel was picked up by Whole Energy, a regional distributor and retailer with locations in Washington, Oregon and California. REG also recently registered its REG Seneca (Ill.) plant with CARB in accordance with the low carbon fuel standard, and REG-9000 biodiesel from that location has a carbon intensity as low as 4.0 gCO2e/MJ, according to CARB.
BDI-BioEnergy International AG has concluded a contract with Portuguese company Assunto Importante S.A. to upgrade the existing biodiesel plant in Sines. The local petroleum industry will be the end-user of the biodiesel produced. The order volume is in the single-digit million range. The objectives of the project are to not only increase the raw material flexibility of the existing plant, but also, and in particular, to improve the quality of the biodiesel so it satisfies the requirements of the stricter quality standard EN14214/2013, which will have to be observed in the future. This is being done in the context of the BDI RetroFit program. The company in Sines is opting to use such waste materials as animal fat or used cooking oil to manufacture biodiesel, and as a result, 25,000 metric tons (approximately 7.5 MMgy) of “second-generation” biodiesel (i.e., biodiesel from waste streams rather than first-use materials) will be produced for the local petroleum industry per year as a result. SHARE YOUR BUSINESS BRIEFS To be included in Business Briefs, send information (including photos, illustrations or logos, if available) to: Business Briefs, Biodiesel Magazine, 308 Second Ave. N., Suite 304, Grand Forks, ND 58203. You may also fax information to 701-746-5367, or email it to rkotrba@ bbiinternational.com. Please include your name and telephone number in each correspondence.
ADDITIVES
STABILITY TESTING: Eastman Chemical Co.’s Andy Singleton tests the company’s BioExtend 30 line of biodiesel stabilizers with fuel samples sent through its one-click submission process at eastmanbioextend.com. PHOTO: EASTMAN CHEMICAL CO.
20
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
ADDITIVES
Keep Biodiesel Stable, Flowing & Growing An overview of antioxidants and cold flow improvers for B100 and blends BY RON KOTRBA
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
21
ADDITIVES For B100 and biodiesel blends, two main fuel additive categories dominate the sector: stabilizers and cold flow improvers. Biodiesel can be produced from many fats, oils and greases, each possessing unique chemical make-ups that affect stability and cold temperature performance differently. Saturated feedstocks like palm oil are more stable but have worse cold flow properties. Conversely, unsaturated feedstocks such as canola oil carry more desirable cold flow properties but will oxidize and go rancid quicker. Oxidation is a three-step process consisting of initiation, propagation and termination, says Andy Singleton with Eastman Chemical Co., which offers BioExtend 30 (U.S.) and BioExtend 30 HP (EU) stabilizers. BioExtend 30 HP is certified by the biodiesel quality management board AGQM as a “no-harm” additive tested to ensure that chemical and physical properties aren’t affected by the use of oxidation stabilizers in biodiesel; that no inadmissible reciprocal effects occur with other stabilizers used in a B7 blend; and that security datasheets are available for the additive. The “noharm” list includes 36 positively tested products from 22 manufacturers, including Eastman, Innospec, Infineum, Evonik, Kemin, Albemarle, International Fuel Technology, Lanxess, BASF and more. The U.S. has no such additives oversight, says Gary Pipenger, owner of Amalgamated Inc. He says while U.S. EPA polices chemical ingredients in additives, there’s no regulation on performance. “The biggest thing I’ve wanted for 40 years,” he says, “is some way of holding additive companies accountable for what they’re selling.” Eastman’s BioExtend 30 and 30 HP products both contain a metal chelator that works in the initiation phase to sequester metal ions from residual processing catalyst or adsorbents, and from mild steel or yellow metals in transport or storage vessels. “No antioxidant will stop oxidation,” Singleton says, “but they’re used to inhibit oxidation. The antioxidant we use interrupts the propagation cycle where free radicals that are formed in the initiation cycle react with
oxygen and form peroxides. Stable, oxidized products such as aldehydes and alcohols are formed in the termination cycle.” Time, temperature, moisture, air and contaminants all contribute to accelerated oxidation. A rule of thumb for hot, humid regions like the Gulf Coast is that biodiesel shelf life is six months; in colder, dryer regions, it can be longer. But if you leave biodiesel in a tank, the oxidative stability score will go down. Additives raise the starting value on the oxidation stability test, part of U.S. and European quality specifications (three-hour Rancimat minimum in U.S., six-hour minimum for Europe), and they change the oxidation curve’s slope. Biodiesel is treated with antioxidant at the plant by the producer, unless perhaps the fuel stays local for immediate use. Treated biodiesel can be retreated after oxidation begins, but if 200 ppm is the recommended treat rate for fresh fuel, adding that same dose to oxidized fuel will not achieve the same results. Some fuels are just unable to meet spec no matter how much additive is used. “I’ve tested samples from waste grease where the original oxidative stability index is less than five minutes,” Singleton says. “So we work with customers and they go back and maybe make process improvements.” Frank Moran with International Fuel Technology says IFT offers nine different biodiesel stabilizers in its DiesoLIFT BD-series, each with slightly different chemistries depending on feedstock. “We try to customize our formulations to the feedstock,” Moran says. “We send samples so they can test finished product,” but, he notes, some multifeedstock producers switch inputs at the drop of a dime—literally. A 10-cent swing in price, plus availability, is incentive to move from one to another. Innospec also has a line of antioxidants. “We’ve got a few products in the BioStable line,” says Jim Vrzak, a sales director for Innospec Fuel Specialties. BioStable inhibits peroxide formation, protects against metal-catalyzed oxidation, minimizes effects of
Ensure the integrity, validity, and marketability of your RINs Get your Renewable Identification Numbers verified by First Environment, a trusted Validation/ Verification Body. Call us at (312) 629-5099 for more information or to request a proposal. RIN Verification • RFS Reporting • Third Party Engineering Reviews First Environment was voted best verifier for North American Mandatory Markets for the past 4 years, and best verifier for Voluntary Markets for the past 2 years. (Environmental Finance Magazine Annual Survey)
www.firstenvironment.com • contactus@firstenvironment.com • (800) 486-5869 22
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
ADDITIVES gum formation from peroxide decomposition, and defends against acid-induced degradation. Kemin Industries’ biodiesel stabilizer is BF320. Kevin Custer, business director, says as biodiesel clients switch feedstocks, he encourages them to send samples so Kemin can test and inform the client of the best treat rate. BF320, like Eastman’s BioExtend 30, contains a metal chelator to sequester metals. Custer also says Kemin offers consultation on application equipment, dosage rates, application sites, antioxidant storage and execution of product into biodiesel. Kemin can also design and install application equipment. Magellan Midstream Partners LP requires a six-hour Rancimat performance at the point of fuel origin. “To a great extent, this specification is established by our customers who are the companies that own the biodiesel in our storage tanks,” says Bruce Heine with Magellan. “Generally, our customers have asked us to administer a Rancimat specification of six hours from origins. We target a delivery value of five hours, but have the latitude to release product down to three hours. This increased stability provides added protection for the ultimate consumer. This is especially important in markets where biodiesel is stored for extended periods of time.” Magellan approves a handful of stabilizers. “We receive requests for approval of all performance additives from our position holders,” Heine says. “If a customer would like to add a specific additive, we request data that supports the claims from the additive manufacturer. At our option, we may request a sample of the additive be sent to our laboratory in Kansas City for analysis.” Once a biodiesel producer is on Magellan’s approved list, companies that hold positions in its tanks can purchase biodiesel from the plant and the biodiesel can be stored at a Magellan terminal. Samples are taken from all B100 deliveries, and random testing is conducted. For performance and cost comparisons of four commercial antioxidant additives, the University of Idaho’s Department of
Biological and Agricultural Engineering, led by Jon Van Gerpen, department chair, conducted tests and published results in Biodiesel Tech Notes that can be found at biodieseleducation.org. Using the appropriate stabilizer isn’t just about meeting a spec for purposes of selling product though. Today’s modern, highpressure common rail fuel systems recycle fuel under high pressure and temperature, and an unstable fuel will form deposits that can foul fuel injector inlets and nozzles. Badly degraded fuel can even exhibit cold-flow-like problems. Moran says IFT is working with a bus fleet in Europe that uses B30 and the buses were breaking down due to filter clogging. After experimenting with a blend of its DiesoLIFT10 and antioxidant, the buses’ fuel mileage increased by 7 percent. “More encouragingly, they stopped breaking down in the middle of their route,” Moran says. IFT Global Business Development Manager Axel Farhi says, “What we did was improve the physical stability and oxidation stability of the B30 blend, thus avoiding formation of residues collected in the filters, and thus improving combustion and fuel economy.” Infineum, a 50/50 joint venture between Shell and ExxonMobil, recently unveiled its R536 filterability additive, says Joanne LaBarge, a global advisor with Infineum USA LP. R536 was developed to improve biodiesel filterability in the three tests used to gauge whether precipitate formation above the cloud point will occur: D6751’s Cold Soak Filtration Test, the Canadian General Standards Board’s Cold Soak Filter Blocking Tendency Test, and Europe’s Cold Soak IP 387 Test. Infineum says R536 also significantly reduces vehicle filter pressure.
Cold Flow Improvers No. 1 diesel fuel (kerosene) is used in colder region winter diesel fuel blends at various percentages depending on temperature extremities. It works well at driving down cloud and cold filter plugging point (CFPP), but it is costly and reduces fuel mileage due to
Frazier, Barnes & Associates, LLC Technical & Marketing Services
For more than a decade, FBA has provided value-added services to the biodiesel industry.
Feasibility Studies / Business Plans RFS2 Registration and Pathways *RIN Verification* Feedstock Procurement Margin Management Business Valuations/Appraisals Product Marketing
Process Safety Management Pre-Treatment Solutions Product Quality Optimization Plant Expansion Justification
Commissioning Services When issues such as RIN Validity, Operator Training Margin Management and Process Process Troubleshooting Safety Management arise, trust the Independent Engineering Plant Sales team that knows. Trust the team with experience. Introducing RIN Verification Services Visit www.RINtrust.com Phone: 901-725-7258 for more information! Frazier, Barnes & Associates, LLC www.FrazierBarnes.com NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
23
ADDITIVES lower Btu content. Because of its high cut rate, kerosene is not a cold flow improver but rather a winter blend agent to diesel fuel. The right cold flow improver—meaning effective in both performance and price— should reduce costs and improve mileage by reducing the percent of No. 1 needed. Biodiesel producers generally don’t treat with cold flow improvers unless on rare occasion they need to bump the CFPP down a degree or two in order to meet a purchaser’s spec. There are very few, if any, cold flow improvers on the market that are effective on B100 at a reasonable treat rate. Instead, most biodiesel cold flow additization is performed downstream at the rack when blended, and in some cases only work on the petroleum side of the blend equation. “There’s no chemistry out there that will materially affect B100,” Pipenger says. “My company (Amalgamated Inc.) and a few others out there can drop the cold flow properties about eight to 10 degrees, but that’s really not that great for a B100 since you’re starting at plus 25 for pour point, 30 for CFPP and 32 for cloud on a soy product. Animal fats and palm are higher than that, so if you drop those eight or 10 degrees, that’s not that big a deal. No one has anything that is going to materially affect the B100.” Amalgamated Inc.’s wax dispersing additives (trademarked WDA) work like other cold flow improvers, by changing the size and shape of the diesel paraffin wax crystals, allowing them to flow through fuel filters. While this concept works on diesel and some biodiesel blend concentrations, for B100, even modest dips in CFPP temperatures might be an “embellishment,” Vrzak says. “It’s very minimal at best.” The difficulty is so great that some who have tried quickly gave up. Farhi tells Biodiesel Magazine that IFT began looking at B100 cold flow technologies on the market and “was not particularly impressed with their performance,” he says. “All were working better on the more unsaturated feedstocks, but the more saturated feedstocks could not be significantly improved. A major problem we found in unsaturated feedstocks was the poor repeatability. The other critical aspect was the very high 24
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
dosages necessary, up to 3,000 ppm or more, to obtain significant cold flow improvement in B100. We were extremely concerned by these high dosages, the impact on the biodiesel price, and certain reluctance from fuel distributors and OEMs to accept such high additive levels due to the risks of potential instability and compatibility issues.” He says IFT concluded that these problems were related to the type of polymer chemistries used in these materials, which are very similar to the CFPP additive technology used in diesel. “We assumed that was the reason it wasn’t performing particularly well in biodiesel, as wax crystallization processes differ in diesel and biodiesel (paraffin vs. fatty acid) and would therefore require different types of polymer chemistries,” he says. “We finally decided to drop this biodiesel cold flow improver project.” He also adds that current standard methods—CFPP, pour point, LTFT, etc.—might not apply to biodiesel feedstocks. “Last winter was particularly harsh in Europe,” Farhi says. “Problems were observed even with B7 blends meeting the latest EN590 low-temp specs, and made from biodiesel meeting the latest EN14214 low-temp specs.” Instead of treating the biodiesel portion of the blend, some say what many blenders selling fuel in cold climates do is a little rough math by considering the blend ratio, the bio and diesel cloud points or operational parameters like CFPP or pour point, and drive the diesel portion well below the desired target and then add bio, which raises the final blend to the desired point. Vrzak says petroleum cold flow improvers can be effective in biodiesel blends up to B20 by either increasing the treat rate or adding in more and greater dispersanttype technology. Most biodiesel is consumed in low-level blends. “If you are using a blend up to B7, chances are the [diesel] additive you were using before would work,” says LaBarge with Infineum, “but it’s a question of, is it optimized? Can someone say you can use the same system for biodiesel blends? Yes, but it definitely wouldn’t be an optimized solution, which means the fuel source and the biodiesel you’re using, unless you go through the full testing and really pick the right additive
ADDITIVES for it, you may meet spec, but not necessarily in the most cost-optimized fashion.” Vrzak says Innospec has cold flow additives that suppress CFPP tailored for B10 and B20, primarily, but he, like most additive suppliers, says the only way to optimize cold flow performance is to send samples of the diesel, biodiesel and the intended blend ratio to your current or prospective supplier so the best-performing, most cost-effective solution can be sought. “If you are trying to effectively treat a biodiesel blend, then obviously you want to treat both phases and you need two different ingredients,” says Erik Bjornstad, technical director with Bell Performance. “The chemistry we use in our cold flow formulations, specifically with respect to the ingredient that actually targets the esters, is more of a viscosity modifier for those esters—they don’t flow the same way diesel does.” Bell Performance offers Bio Dee-Zol, an antioxidant and water eliminator, and Bio DeeZol Plus, a cold flow improver, primarily to downstream markets. Vrzak says while the refining industry business is huge for additive suppliers, the end-user market, especially with EPArequired ultra-low sulfur fuel and low-level biodiesel blends incentivized or mandated in various states, is growing as refiners and obligated parties take economic advantage of blending B5. “The downstream opportunity for additization has definitely increased,” Vrzak says. Bjornstad says as low-level biodiesel blends become more widely implemented by fuel distributors and jobbers, it’s “a bit of a game changer,” mainly because biodiesel displaces the need for Bell Performance’s lubricity additives. Conversely, it opens new additive opportunities. Heine says Magellan’s stance is that cold flow properties of the finished fuel should be determined by the blender. “The blender can select an array of cold flow improvers available at our terminals, and adjust treat rates based on anticipated climatic conditions with consideration of the level of biodiesel that will be in the finished fuel.”
What’s Next? Vrzak says cold flow improver work is always high on the list of Innospec’s R&D
program, including biodiesel CFPP additives. “And we continue to keep in queue a cloud point depressant for B100,” he says. “We always have ongoing work related to that. We’re always hopeful to find that B100 silver bullet additive.” Jeff Thompson, a North American fuels group manager with Infineum, says Infineum will continue improving its cold flow additives “to treat traditional FAME better than we do today.” LaBarge adds that Infineum is developing additives for renewable, hydrogenated diesels made from nonfood sources, citing Europe’s recent biofuel policy alterations to limit traditional oilseed biodiesel. Bjornstad says he doesn’t foresee any new problems with biodiesel that people aren’t aware of today, so Bell Performance’s focus is trying to combine most effective treatment for those major problems and create the best value for end-users and bulk purchasers. Moran of IFT says, like what it did with those buses, “there is technology out there
that we’re trying to create or shape to adapt to new [biodiesel] requirements and regulations.” Eastman says it’s not ready to share ongoing developmental work. And Pipenger … well, he says trust no additive company’s claims, not even his own. Send samples to independent labs and verify their, and his, assertions. Biodiesel producers should also test stabilizers themselves in their labs. And for blenders or end-users who want to test their cold flow improvers, do a simple, free test by placing an additized sample in the freezer for a day. If particles develop, make a new sample with more additive and repeat. If more than 1 ounce of additive per 3 gallons of fuel is required to stop particle formation, then maybe it’s time to shop around. Author: Ron Kotrba Editor, Biodiesel Magazine 218-745-8347 rkotrba@bbiinternational.com
GET 55% HIGHER VALUE FOR CORN OIL BY CONVERTING TO → BIODIESEL LEADER
Biodiesel Technology, Turnkey implementations
EXPERIENCE
Multi-feedstock including Corn Oil, 15 Operating Plants
ECONOMICAL
Industry’s lowest CAPEX and OPEX
TECHNOLOGY
Continuous Process, Maximum Yield, Complete Solution, Advance Technology
JatroDiesel, Inc. 845 North Main St., Miamisburg, OH 45342 Phone: (937) 847-8050 ext. 201 | www.jatrodiesel.com | sales@jatrodiesel.com NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
25
MAINTENANCE
PLANT ESSENTIALS: Good operator and maintenance team training, an established maintenance plan, availability of spare parts, good housekeeping and respect for operators who work in a complex installation are important to keep biodiesel facilities operating optimally, according to BDI-BioEnergy International, which offers its plants 24/7 hotline support for operations and maintenance. PHOTO: BDI-BIOENERGY INTERNATIONAL AG
26
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
MAINTENANCE
Advice to Operate By From sophisticated, large plants to self-designed community production, Biodiesel Magazine shares practical, expert advice on plant maintenance BY RON KOTRBA
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
27
MAINTENANCE For biodiesel refineries, a good maintenance plan starts with good training. Austria-based BDI-BioEnergy International AG, which has built more than 30 plants worldwide, starts its plant personnel training routine during construction of the facility. “Operator training is essential for stable, effective biodiesel production,” says Christine Riedl, senior engineer with BDI process engineering. Laboratory training is first, followed by classroom operator training during cold commissioning consisting of familiarity with feedstock parameters, chemicals used, safety regulations, reactions, production units, operation modus, safety material data sheets, the process control system (PCS) and troubleshooting. During this phase, operators are also involved in the cold commissioning and are familiarized with operating the equipment,
valves, instruments, process control system and the entire installation. “BDI will also provide special training for pumps, instruments and process control system,” she says. Also the subsuppliers or vendors of special equipment such as centrifuges and steam boilers are onsite for equipment training. Besides technical documentation for equipment, troubleshooting and maintenance lists are available during commissioning. She says best results are achieved when operators are involved in commissioning and maintenance works as early as possible. The third phase of training starts during hot commissioning, where operators should be responsible not only for biodiesel production but also equipment maintenance itself such as oil changes, pump sealings and new calibration of instruments. “One of BDI’s responsibilities is to also train operators in preventive maintenance,” Riedl says. “Listening to cavitation of pumps, or unusual noises in the plant, allowing
New Velcon Poster
Velcon Filters, LLC Diesel and Biodiesel filtration solutions for fuel quality and cleanliness, crucial factors to guarantee engine performance.
Recommended Filtration for Diesel and Biodiesel Transfer Points
Velcon Filters, LLC Colorado Springs, CO USA www.velcon.com/diesel.html 888.224.0716 719.531.5855 Fax 719.531.5690 vfsales@velcon.com ™
MEMBER
Fuel Filtration and Separation Specialists for over 50 years 28
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
Top 11 Maintenance Guide 1. Rotating Equipment 2. Vessels and Piping 3. Pressure Safety Devices 4. Risk of Fouling a. Heat Exchangers b. Cooling Towers c. Distillation Columns 5. Lab Equipment 6. Truck/Rail Scales 7. Spare Parts Inventory 8. Automated Control Valves (ACVs) 9. Boilers 10. Chillers 11. Process Instrumentation Source: Frazier, Barnes & Associates
the operator to react before the equipment will have greater damage, which can lead to a high production loss.” During the commissioning, BDI organizes an operator plant tour as to “get a feel” for the process equipment. “A walk around ensures that operators are able to react as soon as possible on unexpected interruptions or equipment failures,” she says. While training operators is essential, Riedl says a plant maintenance director ultimately responsible for upkeep duties must develop a maintenance plan that includes operation hours, oil changes and the like; listing of necessary maintenance items that can be done during an unscheduled stop; planned, or scheduled maintenance stops (involving all necessary subsuppliers); spare parts logistics including statistics, most needed parts, delivery times and availability; and cleaning procedures including clean-in-place systems, intervals for cleaning and so forth. “Prevention is always better than reaction,” says Warren Barnes, vice president of Frazier, Barnes & Associates. “It creates havoc for an organization when you have unscheduled downtime versus planned downtime. Customers don’t like it. Feedstock suppliers don’t
like it. And owners don’t like it. It implies that you’re not in control of your business.” The biodiesel supply chain has such a small amount of product in it that “process hiccups,” as Barnes says, “can literally run your customer out of product.” Therefore, Barnes says regularly scheduled maintenance, particularly on rotating pieces of equipment, is extremely important. Planned downtime should be scheduled with some regularity, whether it’s one day a month and two to three days every quarter, or even a shift a month and a few shifts a quarter, Barnes says, with a well-thought-out list of things to be checked. “It’s unrealistic to expect any plant large or small to run for months without some scheduled maintenance,” he says. “We’re not talking two or three weeks of downtime—maybe a shift, maybe two shifts on a holiday, schedule it around what the demand for your product is.” Riedl agrees. “The maintenance plan has to be in place and stops must be planned,” she says, adding that several maintenance items can be done during an unexpected or expected stop of the plant. Some producers only consider costs for spare parts and the maintenance team during unscheduled stoppages. “They don’t think about the time and the costs for an unexpected stop of production,” Riedl says. “There’s not only the time for the equipment repair, but also the time to stop and start the plant.” Stocking spare parts must also not be overlooked. While holding inventory costs money, it’s usually less costly than a failure after which a part must be ordered and delivered. “Equipment vendors know parts have limited life,” Barnes says. “They will provide required spare parts for their equipment if asked, and most will without asking. To them it’s just a normal course of business, when they get a proposal, they automatically get spare parts. Regardless of plant size or sophistication, it is fundamental for every plant, for every piece of equipment, to have them in inventory.” Riedl says there are different equipment parts that can cause hangups and downtime. “First, there is all rotating equipment like pumps or centrifuges, causing long shutdowns if there is no preventive maintenance in place and no spare parts on stock,”
PHOTO: MIDLANDS BIOFUELS
MAINTENANCE
NOT COMPATIBLE: “Bio” Joe Renwick with Midlands Biofuels says Lasco-brand light gray PVC fittings all failed one by one, even though they are Schedule 80 PVC.
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
29
MAINTENANCE she says. “Second, fouling of the equipment is always an issue—that appears not suddenly but lingering. Slowly the quality of the products decreases and the quantities are going down.” This can be avoided by using purified feedstock according to input specifications and by having an established maintenance plan. “Basically,” she says, “a bad organization of even the smallest parts can have an impact on the production in several parameters.” There’s only 365 days in a year, so when developing a maintenance routine, back off from there with a number of days for sched-
uled maintenance. Then, Barnes says, “things will break,” so add a number of days in a routine for unscheduled maintenance. Once a routine is established, at least there is something to hold people accountable to and improve upon. “If you don’t establish one, you don’t have anything to measure against,” he says. “It’s all about capacity utilization. The best return is the one you get on that extra gallon you produced yesterday.” As it relates to maintenance activities with flammable materials, Barnes says lockout/tagout and confined space entry procedures are
REGISTER TODAY! The only place where the entire biodiesel community gathers to conduct business…and more.
February 4-7, 2013 The Mirage Resort & Casino Las Vegas www.biodieselconference.org
Hosted by
30
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
critical. “You can go into a vessel that has been purged with 100 percent nitrogen and the first three breaths seem normal, but then you will rapidly lose vision, fall down, lose consciousness, and you will die,” he says. “In maintenance, everyone wants to do it quickly because you’re not making money when the airplane’s not flying, and that’s when personnel safety is at the greatest risk.” Often overlooked are items like pressure relief valves, which could go unneeded and unchecked for five or 10 years and, as Barnes says, people assume they’ll work. “But the way you find out it didn’t work is you blow a weld out and have a catastrophic failure of a vessel,” he says. Barnes advises plant owners to use insurance carriers to help identify areas of risk. “He is your helper, if you do what he says, you have an argument for lower insurance costs,” or, at least avoidance of insurance increases. Owners can assess the industry’s experience modifier and determine how their plant compares. “That’ll tell the management how they’re doing,” Barnes says. Midlands Biofuels is a small, community-scaled producer in Winnsboro, N.C. Like many similar-sized plants, Midlands was built not by a large design/engineering firm, but by a few ingenious, resourceful individuals with a vision. Midlands co-founder “Bio” Joe Renwick speaks with Biodiesel Magazine about his maintenance experiences over the years. The first words of advice Renwick shares are, “Just because something says it is biodieselcompliant does not mean it will withstand the biodiesel production environment.” Renwick and partner Brandon Spence built Midlands with whatever they had available as far as parts, valves and pumps go. They designed everything themselves, including its methanol recovery system. Renwick says Midlands uses hose instead of piping in many areas where piping was either too complicated or expensive, and where flexibility was desirable. “We replaced every single hose inside this facility, and in the tank farm,” he says. So-called “biodiesel-compliant” hoses were anything but, he says. Four years ago, Midlands switched out all hoses with Thermoid Vapor-loc hose. “It’s amazing,” he says. “We’re very pleased with it.” It’s made of multiple layers and eliminates
MAINTENANCE permeation and other things that cause biodiesel hoses to fail. “It’s thick and heavy-duty, but still pliable,” he says. “It’s not only better, but cheaper. When we first started, we had Mustang hose, they said it was great but biodiesel would permeate and leak like no body’s business. Our Thermoid Vapor-loc hoses trap in all those gases that could permeate, so it’s good not only because it alleviates replacement costs, but it makes the work environment safer.” Midlands uses Schedule 80 PVC instead of steel in a number of piping applications. “It turns out not all manufacturer’s Schedule 80 PVC can withstand biodiesel,” he says. We had a lot of pipe fail and then spent a lot of time reprocessing. It was a hell of a nightmare.” Renwick says Lasco-brand light gray fittings were the source of the pipe problems. “They all failed,” he says. “They swelled and deteriorated. At first we started seeing bits of gray pieces of gray shavings in the biodiesel that became soft and rubbery to where you can squeeze it, it was really weird. They were in the bottoms of our tanks and filters. We had tanks with that Lasco fitting at the bottom and it broke loose at the threads. Biodiesel just began leaking out on the floor, not a gush but a trickle. We quickly evacuated the tank and broke it all down. We had three tanks fail, and then we had to gut the entire system and replace all the PVC fittings and all piping. Specifically what was failing was the fittings, the pipe was holding up. It’s not all Schedule 80 PVC fittings either, it’s just this certain brand, and it’s a light-colored gray.” He says regular white Schedule 40 PVC fittings held up better than this brand of light-gray Schedule 80. Other advice Renwick shares includes pipe threading techniques. “When threading pipe, don’t do to the standard one or two inches,” he says. “Do it a little bit bigger, it makes fitting tighter, it seals a hundred times better. Also, a lot of companies say they have pipe dope that works for biodiesel. We now use Slic-tite, it actually works. We’ve used a number of other brands and they leak.” Renwick says Midlands uses Wilden diaphragm pumps. “They’ve been amazing,” he says. Midlands designed its own methanol re-
covery system and after a series of trials and errors, mostly in cooling the vapors enough to condense, he said they found a $20,000 commercial chiller from government surplus and paid only $750. It uses a lot of electricity and requires a lot of space, but chills extremely well. Methanol recovery not only requires heating and cooling, but also vacuum pumping. “We tried a number of styles of vacuum pumps,” Renwick says, “and found the only safe and reliable option is a liquid ring vacuum pump.” Why has Renwick shared this information Midlands learned along the way? “The way I feel
about the biodiesel industry right now is, if we don’t become more of an open-source industry where we’re helping each other, we’re all going to be screwed,” he says. “The biodiesel industry is not a real pretty industry to be in right now, it’s pretty tough. If I can give information right now that will help someone else do it better and keeps this industry alive, I’m glad to do it.” Author: Ron Kotrba Editor, Biodiesel Magazine 218-745-8347 rkotrba@bbiinternational.com
CHOOSE THE INDUSTRY LEADER FOR YOUR RIN QUALITY ASSURANCE EcoEngineers Design
Verification Compliance
Join the industry leader and implement a RIN QAP at your plant! EcoEngineers is the industry leader for process and quality standards. Our comprehensive program monitors biofuel production in accordance with EPA requirements without disrupting daily production cycles with intrusive equipment or procedures. We send a clear message to RIN markets that your operations meet RFS2 RIN quality standards.
That means: • 2,000,000+ RINS transacted daily on our RIN management platform; • 330,000,000 gallons of biodiesel annual production capacity under management; • 250,000,000 gallons of ethanol annual production capacity under management; • 30 biofuel plants and growing; • Volume-based pricing at a fraction of a penny per RIN!
Features: • • • • •
Batch level review and reports available to downstream parties; Daily RIN price index; Access to RIN insurance to further indemnify downstream RIN holders; Quarterly reports, engineers reviews, registration, annual attests; Available for advanced biofuel and foreign production.
The results: • Producers have more access to RIN markets and fair market pricing; • Blenders can trust the RINs they are separating; • Obligated Parties can trust the RINs they are buying.
Contact: Jim Baker, Sales and Marketing Director | Phone: 515-309-1279 (o) / 515-556-1936 (c) Email: jbaker@ecoengineers.us | Website: www.ecoengineers.us
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
31
SAFETY CONTRIBUTION
Biodiesel Industry regulated Ignorance of OSHA, EPA regulations no longer flies for biodiesel producers BY NATHAN VANDER GRIEND
Safety training, work permits, standard operating procedures and what seems to be an almost endless amount of documentation can be a burden to an operating facility. It hasn’t always been that way, but today in the life of a biodiesel producer, there are a great deal of regulatory requirements in place to reduce workplace injuries and fatalities. With the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, Congress created the Occupational Safety and Health Adminis-
tration to assure safe and healthful working conditions for working men and women by setting and enforcing standards and by providing training, outreach, education and assistance. OSHA tends to be the driving force in getting movement on pertinent issues across all industries. For example, management personnel oftentimes just accepts and agrees that a certain amount of noncompliance or minor worker compensation claims are a part of doing business, and are risks they are willing to take. These, today more
than ever, are futile assumptions largely because of the OSHA enforcement efforts. On average in the U.S. biofuels industry, there are at least two workers compensation claims annually. The insurable cost of those claims average approximately $12,000, or $6,000 per claim, but that is why people buy worker compensation insurance, so why should you care? Because of the downstream effects of those claims, such as OSHA citations, increased insurance costs, replacing time of the injured employee, administrative time to deal with
The claims and statements made in this article belong exclusively to the author(s) and do not necessarily refl ect the views of Biodiesel Magazine or its advertisers. All questions pertaining to this article should be directed to the author(s).
32
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
SAFETY
claims, and the most invaluable of them all, management responsibility. As management of a company, the buck stops with you, not only emotionally, but legally as well. According to the National Safety Council, the uninsurable cost of claims are, on average, four times the insurable or direct cost, giving biofuels producers $48,000 net loss to the bottom line. When the numbers are laid out, it is easy to see that there is a real, tangible value to care about this topic and to spend time and resources on safety. When looking at safety and compliance risks specifically within the biodiesel industry, and more specifically within an individual company, it is important to use a systematic approach to determine the importance of each. Categorizing each potential risk into a risk matrix will provide a pathway for continuous improvement. A great place to start is to identify risks through a comprehensive facility audit. This should outline all of the risks, both safety and compliance related, for your staff to prioritize and address. Lately, it seems the enforcement group of OSHA is the most active in the biodiesel industry, due to a handful of fires and explosions. Just like large chemical and refining operations, biodiesel production poses a significant risk of catastrophic events occurring if comprehensive Process Safety Management programs and training are not in place and followed religiously. Process Safety Management (29 CFR 1910.119), as defined by OSHA, is in place to set forth requirements for preventing or minimizing the consequences of catastrophic releases of toxic, reactive, flammable or explosive chemicals, as these releases may result in toxic, fire or explosion hazards. To make it simple, a PSM program in biodiesel is a very systematic approach to manage and ensure that you operate your
HIGH cost
HIGH cost
LOW frequency
HIGH frequency
LOW cost
LOW cost
LOW frequency
HIGH frequency
QUANTIFYING RISK: Categorizing each potential risk into a risk matrix provides a path forward for continuous improvement.
Biorefineries allow our local forest industry to extract value from every part of every piece of wood that is harvested and are the future for a sustainable forest-based economy in northern Ontario. By pairing traditional materials with sustainability, we can create a brighter future. CRIBE is proud to support the commercialization of new uses for wood in Ontario, including biorefinery research.
Have an idea you’re looking to grow? Find out more at www.cribe.ca NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
33
SAFETY
processes containing hazardous materials such as methanol, sodium methylate and biodiesel in a safe manner. This is done by limiting potential for unintended mixing, equipment failures, and unplanned maintenance while ensuring employees understand the process through involvement and training. Beyond the current “hot issue� of PSM compliance, there are several compliance topics that all biodiesel producers should be
in tune with to ensure citations are avoided. Below is a brief snapshot of three of the most looked at and easily definable regulatory requirements per OSHA. Written Safety Policy: A written safety plan, or policy, is required for all workplaces. This policy should be accessible to all employees. The safety plan states the purpose of the company to protect workers, details who is responsible for implementing safety
DISTILLED TO BE THE BEST FIRE WATCH: The biodiesel industry's safety record is less than stellar, but plants implementing and adhering to a strong PSM program could improve that.
THE CLEAR ANSWER FOR BIODIESEL DISTILLATION Stay ahead of tighter biodiesel specifications Improve cold weather performance
CROWN BIODIESEL DISTILLATION FATTY ACID STRIPPING | EXTRACTION | OIL PROCESSING | BIODIESEL | GLYCERIN REFINING | ESTERIFICATION CROWN IRON WORKS COMPANY Call us today 1-651-639-8900 or Visit us at www.crowniron.com Additional offices in Argentina, Brazil, China, England, Honduras, India, Mexico, Russia and Ukraine
34
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
programs, and provides contact information for reporting unsafe work conditions. The main portion of the safety policy should also address the hazards a worker may encounter on the job, as well as how management, supervisors, and workers, can avoid being injured around those hazards. Safety checklists and any needed permits for specific types of work need to be included in the proper section of the safety policy. Safety Training: OSHA also requires all workers to complete a 10- or 30-hour safety training course, given by an OSHAcertified trainer, such as the company's safety director or a consultant from a professional safety training company. Training must be completed before beginning work at a particular company. Some companies allow previously trained new-hires to provide proof of training from a former job, if the training is relevant. All workers
SAFETY
have the right and the responsibility to be trained in all areas of safety that will affect his or her safety on the job. Other training as needed should be provided, such as when new equipment is presented on the job, new safety policies are added or an unfamiliar work situation arises. Record Keeping: Record keeping for the workplace includes documentation of employee training, records of illness and injuries on the job, and proof of licensing for workers who operate certain equipment or vehicles. OSHA and state authorities require periodic records concerning injuries and illnesses. Hazardous materials in the workplace, even substances such as dishwashing soap or floor cleaning materials, must have a Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS, now referred to as SDS) on file. In the world of OSHA and EPA regulation, if it isn’t documented, it will be treated as if it never happened. While on the subject of regulatory scrutiny, there are several regulations that apply to the biodiesel industry that fall under the U.S. EPA’s authority. All facilities that have the potential to emit an air contaminate are regulated under the Clean Air Act, requiring some form of air permit. All biodiesel facilities have the potential to come in contact with storm water, requiring the need for storm water pollution prevention plans and spill plans as industrial sources. Additionally, since biodiesel facilities have explosive and potentially harmful materials onsite, they trigger additional requirements for plans/approvals under Sara Title 313, and RCRA (additional EPA regulations). It is recommended that every facility know what environmental regulations they are also applicable to, as to not have noncompliance exposure related to EPA requirements. A lot has been learned through working hand-in-hand with biofuels producers, agribusiness companies and chemical production facilities over the past decade. One key thing to understand going forward is excuses, such as “we didn’t know” or “we
planned to do that,” simply aren’t going to fly any longer. As the federal government continues to look for ways to balance the budget, it seems as if tightened OSHA and EPA regulations will not waiver. It is much easier to hear in the news that XYZ Biodiesel was fined $75,000 for failure to comply with a certain safety regulation than it is to hear that their income tax rate is going up.
OSHA regulation might be a nuisance, but it is there for good reason, and they are no longer sitting around. Author: Nathan Vander Griend Vice President of Client Services, ERI Solutions Inc. 316-927-4294 Nathan.Vandergriend@erisolutions.com
Low-Cost Ethanol and Biodiesel Blend Analyzers Ethanol in Gasoline • Biodiesel in Diesel Fuel • Portable, Easy to Use • Used by Fuel Distributors, Petroleum Terminals, and Regulatory Agencies •
On-site analysis with InfraCal® Analyzers offers a quick way to verify that fuel blends are on spec. Incorrect blends can lead to regulatory fines, loss of customer confidence, and damage to equipment using the fuel. InfraCal Ethanol and Biodiesel Blend Analyzers give you: ➢ Results in under 30 seconds ➢ 0.2% - 98% ethanol ➢ 0.2% - 100% biodiesel ➢ Same technology as EN 14078 and ASTM D7371 ➢ Easy, dependable operation ➢ Ideal for non-technical users ➢ Assurance your blend quality always meets specifications
Watch our videos www.WilksIR.com/videos Visit our website www.WilksIR.com Scan the QR code to watch our videos on your mobile device.
®
simple analytical solutions
Wilks Enterprise, Inc. East Norwalk, CT 06855 USA TEL: 203-855-9136 FAX: 203-838-9868 EMAIL: info@WilksIR.com
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
35
BIODIESEL MARKETPLACE Filtration Equipment
Associations/Organizations
Laboratory-Testing Services
California Biodiesel Alliance 415-380-1410 www.californiabiodieselalliance.org
Construction Plant Construction AP Fabrications 870-673-8504
www.apfabrications.com
Consulting Business Plans BBI Consulting Services 866-746-8385 www.bbiinternational.com
Met-Chem ¿lter presses are ideal stock pre-¿lters. They have been sucessfully used in process ¿ltration of Magnesol™ and in various other applications for processing biodiesel. Call: 216-881-7900 info@metchem.com Fax: 216-881-8950
Greasemasters, LLC 321-202-6688 www.greaserecycling.com
Feasibility Studies BBI Consulting Services 866-746-8385 www.bbiinternational.com
Quality Assurance
Pelcal, LLC 805-602-1088
SGS Group 41-0-22-739-91-11
www.sgs.com
Employment
www.pelcal.com
Filtration Media Met-Chem, Inc. 216-881-7900
www.metchem.com
Recruiting SearchPath of Chicago 815-261-4403, x100 www.searchpathofchicago.com
Engineering
French Oil Mill Machinery Company 937-773-3420 www.frenchoil.com/biodieselmag.shtml
Grease Handling Equipment
Process Design BBI Consulting Services 866-746-8385 www.bbiinternational.com PreProcess, Inc. 949-201-6041
Flaking Equipment
Moeller Plastics 931-738-809
www.moellerplastics.com
Heaters-Tank www.preprocessinc.com
Equipment & Services
Dragon Wagon 251-223-7997http://dragonwagon.allenterprises360.biz
Conditioning Systems
Laboratory Outsourcing
AXI Fuel Conditioning 239-690-9589 www.axifuelconditioning.com
Bently Tribology Services 775-783-4688 www.bentlytribology.com
Laboratory-Equipment Cole-Parmer 800-323-4340
www.coleparmer.com/biofuels
French Oil Mill Machinery Company 937-773-3420 www.frenchoil.com/biodieselmag.shtml
36
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
BIODIESEL MARKETPLACE Iowa Central Fuel Testing Lab 515-574-1253 www.iowafueltestinglab.com
Loading Equipment-Liquid PFT-Alexander, Inc. 1-800-696-1331
www.pft-alexander.com
Savage Associates 908-822-8735 www.savageassociatesinc.com
Maintenance Services PFT-Alexander, Inc. 1-800-696-1331
Media
Transportation
Publications
Vehicles
Platts 1-800-PLATTS-8
Process Technology
Meters
PICK-UP & DELIVERY.
Biorefining AE Resources, Inc. 412-996-2002
www.pft-alexander.com
www.platts.com/biofuels
www.aeresource-inc.com
Modular Systems GreeNebraska Renewable Diesel Refineries 402-640-8925 www.greenebraska.com
PFT-Alexander, Inc. 1-800-696-1331
www.pft-alexander.com
Pressure & Temperature Davis Instruments 800-358-5525
Turnkey Systems
Tank Sizes from 300 to 7000 Gallons
BDI – BioEnergy International AG 623-570-8186 www.bdi-bioenergy.com
Slide-In Units Size & Pump Options In STOCK Selection
www.davis.com
Separation Equipment GEA Westfalia Separator 201-767-3900
Grease Collection Service Aluminum Vacuum Tank Trucks
Ask about our dual tank & pumping systems. www.wsus.com
• •
Separators Hydrasep, Inc. 662-429-4088
•
Industries Inc.
www.hydrasep.com
866-789-9440 www.keevac.com
Tanks-Reactor
Denver, CO • Bellefonte, PA • Kansas City, MO
Ultrasonic Power Corporation 815-235-6020, x126 www.upcorp.com
BIODIESEL MARKETPLACE
Finance Insurance IMA of Kansas, Inc. 316-266-6290
www.imacorp.com
Lender Representatives BBI Consulting Services 866-746-8385 www.bbiinternational.com
JatroDiesel Inc. 937-847-8050
Reach Your Customers
www.jatrodiesel.com
Legal Services
Your Solution. Advertise Today.
Attorneys Greenwich Blackhawk Prof. Corp. 310-393-2200 www.greenwichblackhawk.com
Marketing Auctions Maas Companies 507-285-1444
www.maascompanies.com
FREE ADVERTISING Call (701) 746-8385 for more information on a free listing in Biodiesel Marketplace
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
z
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
37
save the date Learn more at algaebiomasssummit.org
The Largest Algae Biomass Conference in the World
September 30 - October 3, 2013 Hilton Orlando | Orlando, Florida
Advancing Technologies and Markets Derived from Algae “One of the best biomass conferences I attended all year. The contacts and exposure have proven to be invaluable to our biomass program.” Richard Wilson - Applied Chemical Technology
“The Summit provided the right mix of industry, academia, and interested investors, committed to building and expanding the role of algae in biofuels, feeds, and products. Collaborations and partnerships developed at ABO will influence the field and industry for decades to come.” Ryan Dorland, Ph.D., Cellana LLC
38
BIODIESEL MAGAZINE
z
NOVEMBER | DECEMBER 2012
November 27-29, 2012 | Houston, TX VISIT: www.AdvancedBiofuelsConference.com
Meet Hundreds of Biofuel Industry Leaders, Educational Expo Hall Three Comprehensive Biofuels Tracks, 57 Speakers Conference includes: t › %BZT PG 1SFTFOUBUJPOT t 1SPHSBN 5SBDLT 1BUIXBZT 1BSUOFSTIJQT *OQVUT 4VQQMZ $IBJOT .POFZ .BSLFUT t .PSF 5IBO 5FDIOJDBM 4FTTJPOT t $PNQSFIFOTJWF *OEVTUSZ 6QEBUF t &EVDBUJPOBM &YQP )BMM t /FUXPSLJOH 0QQPSUVOJUJFT
Contact us today at TFSWJDF!CCJJOUFSOBUJPOBM DPN PS DBMM
0SHBOJ[FE 1SPEVDFE CZ
“We’ve made 10 contacts with companies we’d have to chase independently. For the dollars spent, this event has been worth it.� VISIT OUR WEBSITE TO LEARN MORE
- Gene Carter, Matrix Service Company