CLEANROOM MAGAZINE MAGAZIN
02 02
spring Frühjahr 2016 2016
Life & Science Life & Science Information Cleanroom Technology Informationen fürfor die Reinraumtechnologie
High Voltage in Hochspannung the Cleanroom im Reinraum Throw sparks and Damit out keinthe Funke überspringt protect sensitive products sensible Produkte schützen
In-Vitro-Fertilisation Künstliche Befruchtung
How doesder theKinderwunsch desire to have children Was hat mit correlate with cleanrooms? Reinräumen zu tun?
Never Never stop stop thinking thinking
Cleanroom Creative Prize 20162016 Cleanroom Award Award & und Creative Prize
Register now!
3
Dear Readers! You can remember from past issues that we reported on the Internet of Things and the 3D Printer, on the Operation Theater of the future and on
EDITORIAL
Driverless Driving. All these innovations have induced significant changes although they are based on tiny component parts. Micro-controllers, miniature batteries, communication chips and micro-systems are the foundation on which the digital world of tomorrow will arise. In order for this foundation to be sustainable, the components have to be produced to the exclusion of contamination. That’s why we have cleanrooms. However there lurks still another danger, which cannot be kept away from products with air locks, ventilation systems and isopropyl alcohol: Electrostatic discharge. Everyone is familiar with this for example when touching a door handle. These tiny sparks can be disastrous for production. For a micro-electronic Frank Duvernell: „I have been convinced for
component, the energy of electrostatic discharge is comparable to lightning
some time that cleanroom technology is a
striking a tree. Respectively, the results are also enormously devastating
vastly interesting topic. This enthusiasm I would like to bring out into the minds of the general public in order to make professionals and talented students more aware of the relatively unknown but exciting professional
for integrated switches, instrumentation or small-structured components. Learn about how lightning strikes can be prevented inside a cleanroom in our cover story.
opportunities in the field of cleanroom technology. There is only one place where any
Electrostatic Charges
kind of potential has to be avoided, namely, the
generate High Voltages
cleanroom. Why? Please see right.“ (a)
(b)
Picking up a plastic bag from a table: 1.200 bis 20.000 Volt (a) Walking on untreated vinyl floors: 250 bis 12.000 Volt (b) Source: DGUV
Change of subject: The ReinraumAkademie is looking for the best ideas in respect to innovation, sustainability and energy efficiency in cleanrooms for the Cleanroom Award 2016. Join in! You can submit your projects until August 31th, 2016. The winner will be announced at Cleanzone. Read about how to participate in our Service section. I wish you pleasant reading in our new issue.
Frank Duvernell Editor
Editorial | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
4
CONTENTS 02/2016
08
08 Title Story: Lightning Strike in the Cleanroom
CONTENTS
Electrostatic discharges are able to destroy electronic and micro-structured component parts. How to prevent eclectrostatic sparks when producing in a cleanroom.
................................................
LIFE & BUSINESS Latest News from the World of Cleanrooms
06 The Market in Brief • Cannabis used more frequently for medical purposes • India is on the Way to becoming the World’s Pharmacy • 3D-Televisions are on the Way Out • Experts expect Approvals for New Medications in 2016 • A Fish could save People with Eye Disease from becoming Blind • Replace Body Parts and improve the Treatment of Diseases • Hospital Group does away with Doctor’s White Coat
................................................ Coverstory: throw out the sparks and protect sensitive products. Photo: Cleanroom Media
16
16 The next big thing?
Virtual reality devices are expected to replace computers and Smartphones. The business models are still vague and the contens meager but the new possibilities are fantastic.
................................................ 20 Portrait: Joachim Ludwig
On May 1st, 2016, Colandis GmbH will be celebrating its 20 year anniversary. How Managing Director Joachim Ludwig formed his one-man engineering office into a company operating worldwide.
................................................
Virtual Reality: VR goggles are considered the next big thing. Photo: Eugenio Marongiu/Fotolia
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Contents
5
24 When new Life
24
emerges from the Cleanroom
For involuntary childless couples, artif icial insemination is one of the ways to founding a family. This way often begins in a cleanroom.
................................................ 32 Controversy:
More Cleanroom Technology against Hospital Germs? If the use of more cleanroom technology is able to prevent hospital infections is discussed by Professor Arnold Brunner of the University Luzern Technology and Architecture and Dr. Uli Lösch of the University Hospital Basel.
Cleanroom technology can help couples to fertility. Photo: xolibu/Fotolia
................................................
54
36 Behind the Scenes:
On the road with René Hecker René Hecker, Account & Project Manager at the Dutch measurement instrumentation company Pedak.
................................................
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY Solutions for the World of Cleanrooms
38 Technology in Brief • The lightest Solar Cell in the World • Pharmaceutical Products dosed cleanly without any Filaments or Dripping • Pipe Fittings meeting GMP Requirements • The Production of Y-Connectors in Cleanroom Facilities • Granulate Production in High Containment • Microbiological Air Monitoring accomplished more easily • New Product Generation of Premium Pocket Filters
................................................ 40 Keep It Clean
Cleaning procedures critically inf luence product quality but also the costs. How procedures are able to be economically set up will be shown at the part2clean trade fair at the end of May in Stuttgart, Germany.
................................................
And the winner wil be? Read more about the cleanroom award 2016. Photo: Nils Bröer
44 New Surfaces for
54 Cleanroom Award 2016:
Cleanroom Technology
Send in your Applications now
Senomed is a chemically-resistant, scrub-resistant and anti-bacterial synthetic film for surfaces in cleanrooms and air locks. It has the potential to replace existing materials.
Until August 31th, 2016, the Reinraum Akademie (Cleanroom Academy) will be accepting the best ideas in innovation, sustainability and energy saving in the cleanroom. The award will be presented at the beginning of November at Cleanzone 2016.
............................................. 50 What do you do there, …?
Birgit Kriegesmann, responsible for the micro-biological quality controlat Bremer Pharma GmbH in Wartburg, Germany.
................................................
SERVICE
................................................
57 Professional Literature: References for the Cleanroom Industry
• EU Guide to Good Manufacturing Practice for Medicinal Products for Human and Veterinary Use
................................................
Events, Awards, Columns
58 Trade Fairs and Events
52 Laws and Regulations: What it comes down to
60 Imprint
................................................
When everything is already written down in the regulations, why don’t we have the perfect cleanroom?
................................................ Contents | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
6
Life&Business
LIFE & BUSINESS
The Market in Brief
Cannabis used more frequently for Medical Purposes
India is on the Way to becoming the World’s Pharmacy
Approval Debate | Cannabis anti-in-
Generics Market | The market research
flammatory, relieves pain and is far
company Global Data forecasts for
better tolerated thatn morphine and
the Indian pharmaceutical market a
opiates. For pharmaceutical com-
tremendous surge in growth. Market
panies it is nevertheless difficult to
volumes are expected to more than
get approvals for cannabis-based
double from 20 to 55 billion dollars
Samsung will not produce any new
medications. In Germany for
in the next five years. The driver of
products with 3D functions. The
example, it is neither allowed to
this development is the tremendous
reasons for this is the low demand
plant cannabis, to possess nor to be
growth in the generics industry. Ac-
caused by the need to wear 3D glasses
sold. This situation could soon be
cording to Global Data India covers
and the lack of standards for the
changed. The Federal Public Health
20 percent of the worldwide generics
glasses. Another reason is the com-
Ministry is considering putting in
market and is therefore the world’s
petition from the new technologies
the hands of a federal “Cannabis
largest exporter of imitations drugs.
such as ultra HD and virtual reality.
Agency”, the cultivation and sale of
The success of the Indian generics
Industry observers forecast that 3D
cannabis. The plant’s ingredients
televisions will make a comeback as
suit themselves for a wide range of
soon as it becomes possible to build a
medical applications. The spectrum
3D panel which can be used without
ranges from wound medications,
glasses.
the treatment of Multiple Sclerosis to the treatment of neurological illnesses such as the Tourette-Syndrome and ADHS.
The worldwide demand for generics is causing a boom for
Experts expect Approvals for new Medications in 2016
India’s pharmaceutical manufacturers. Photo: arsdigital/ Fotolia
Pharmaceuticals | The Association of
industry is a result of the low produc-
Pharmaceutical Companies doing
tion costs and a worldwide increase
Research in Germany (VfA) believes
in the demand for cheaper medicinal
that in this year several new medi-
products.
cations will be receiving approvals. Included are two-digit numbers of
3D Television on the Way Out
new pharmaceuticals which aid in the treatment of leukemia, lung cancer and bone marrow cancer.
For medical purposes it is expected the cultivation and sale of cannabis will be allowed. Photo: stokkete/Fotolilo
VR and HD dominate | The Korean
Several of these pharmaceuticals
manufacturers Samsung and LG are
are based on newly developed prin-
pulling out on the much-praised 3D
ciples of operation, for example, the
technology for televisions. LG wants
use of oncolytical viruses which
to halve its production of 3D devices,
attack cancer cells and activate the
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | The Market in Brief
7 3D-Televisions will see their breakthrough when they can be used without glasses. And maybe when this kid is big.
journal “Der Ophthalmologe” (The
In another project, a new material
Ophthalmologist), an artificial
was developed which replaces
cornea made out of Tilapia scales
human cartilage. Enriched with a
is currently being tested. The back-
patient’s own cells, the material is
ground of this research is the large
able to support the development of
need for donated corneas which
natural tissue.
until now have been supplied by deceased doners. On the search for alternatives, researchers at the University Hospital for Eye Care Cologne
Hospital Group does away with Doctors’ White Coats
and the University Hospital Leiden
Photo: Sunny studio/Fotolia
are examining a substance which
WHO-Recommendation | The Askle-
comes from the fish’s scales. These
pios Group is the first hospital oper-
are cultured in aquacultures, the
ator which has done away with the
fish’s scales consequently providing a
traditional long sleeved white coat in
base material whose Type 1 collagen
all of its 100 medical facilities. A short
is similar to a human cornea. With
sleeved garment for doctors, the
an experiment on rats, the artificial
so-called tunic, has taken its place,
cornea grew as well as the natural
which in many medical centers is
cornea on other rats.
already the rule. The occasion for
immune system to act against these cells. Additionally, other antibiotics against problem germs (MRSA and others) as well as medications for
Replace Body Parts and improve Treatment of Disease
the treatment of hepatitis C, the treatment of hemophilia A and B,
Stem Cell Research | In Switzerland,
and new vaccines against anthrax
the five-year national research pro-
are expected to reach the market.
gram “Stem Cells and Regenerative
Moreover, more than ten new med-
Medicine” has come to its close. The
ications for the treatment of patients
results which have been recently
with rare diseases are expected to be
presented are very promising. The
approved in 2016.
A Fish could save Those with Eye Disease from becoming Blind
Long sleeved doctor’s coats are often permeated with germs and should be replaced with short sleeved tunics. Photo: Syda Productions/Fotolia
Corneal Transplantation | The much-eaten fish Tilapia from the family cichild could save thousands of people from becoming blind. As researchers have reported in the
The scales of the Tilapia supply the base material for artificial human corneas. Photo: KonArt/Fotolia
this change is the recommendation The Swiss stem cell research focuses on regenerative
from the Robert Koch Institute and
medicine. Photo: kwanchaift/Fotolia
the World Health Organization
researchers have found out that the
studies that pathogens are more
risk of tumors don’t only come from
frequently found on long sleeved
stem cells but also from immature
coats. Asklepios is the first hospital
intermediate forms. They also dis-
operator which has implemented
covered that the pancreas following
the recommendation. Related to this
the destruction of all insulin pro-
issue, according to a recent survey
ducing cells is able to reproduce new
conducted by Asklepios, 65 percent
cells from closely related cell types.
of the people surveyed are concerned
This discovery could make insulin
about being infected with multi-re-
injections for diabetics unnecessary.
sistant germs in a hospital.
WHO. They have shown in several
The Market in Brief | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
LIFE & BUSINESS
8
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
Mini Sparks with Maxi Damage
9
Product loss threatens those who take no precautions against electrostatic discharging. Photo: Cleanroom Media
Electrostatic discharges are able to damage integrated switches, instrumentation and small-structured component parts. It is nearly impossible to prevent these static discharges but it is possible to render them harmless. Materials suitable for use in a cleanroom, anti-static measures and grounding protect against spark discharges.
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
10 PMT Partikel-Messtechnik GmbH.
Amber as a Clothing Brush
LIFE & BUSINESS
The company located in Heimsheim, Germany is specialized in the mon-
The term electrostatic means latent
itoring of clean and sterile rooms as
electricity and comes from the Greek
well as the management of electro-
natural philosopher Thales von Milet
static charges. As Scheibel reports,
(625-546 BC). During his lifetime,
the defective components find their
people in well-to-do homes made use
way to customers and later cause
of the amber phenomenon, which
Indispensable in electronics: tool with ESD symbol.
losses in production which causes
was described by Thales. It is based
Photo: Cleanroom Media
considerable costs in downtime and
on the discovery that an amber stone
replacements. Intact components
which is rubbed on animal fur or on
“A lack of gap will certainly mean
are also vulnerable. “An electrostatic
a piece of cloth is able to attract pieces
that some of the sparks will jump the
discharge at any position along a
of straw or feathers. Larger amber
seam.” With these words the poet Er-
robot-controlled assembly line is
stones were used as clothing brushes
ich Limpach (1899-1965) described in
enough to interfere with the process
because they attracted dust particles
a lyrical form what manufacturers of
regulation in the micro-controllers
when glided along the clothing. The
sensitive components describe with
and to stop the entire assembly line.”
old Greek word for amber is “electron”,
a balled fist: electrostatic discharges. The mini sparks which are known when combing hair or grabbing a
the origin of the word electricity.
Cleanroom Air no longer offsets Electrostatic Charges
door handle come across as being
Terms such as Anti-Static don’t belong to the Study of Architecture
harmless but in the production of
That mini sparks are able to cause
small and sensitive products they
such maximal damage has diverse
often result in fatal consequences.
reasons. Besides the flooring, table
Electrostatically charged surfaces
For a micro-electronic component
mats, gloves, overalls, brushes and
in cleanrooms are in two respects
for example, the energy of an elec-
tools being used, the air condition-
critical. Firstly, a spark-like discharge
trostatic discharge is comparable to
ing above all is the reason for two
threatens to damage or destroy
lightning striking a tree.
boosting effects: With one effect, the
products. Secondly, charged surfaces
Proportionately the results are disastrous. They range from the damage or destruction of electronic components, instrumentation errors, breakdowns and faults in electronically controlled production processes on up to the danger of explosion in areas with flammable gases, vapors and dust.
“The nasty thing about electrostatic discharges is that for every one defective product detected, two to five defects will be detected after the delivery.” Ricco Scheibel, Sales Manager PMT Partikel-Messtechnik GmbH
Out of every defect which is detected, there are two to five which remain undetected.
air conditioning systems reduce the
attract particles. Studies show that a
ion content in the air entering the
heavy load of particles on charged
“The nasty thing about electrostatic
cleanroom and the other effect is
surfaces is able to reduce locally the
discharges is that according to
that this air is no longer able to offset
cleanroom classification up to two
industrial estimates, out of every
the electrostatic charges due to the
steps lower than the ISO classifica-
defect which is detected in produc-
reduced air humidity. Therefore the
tion of the cleanroom.
tion, there are two to five which
materials, products and machines
Moreover particle deposition is not
are detected after delivery” says
in the cleanroom are able to take on
easy to remove from charged sur-
Ricco Scheibel, Sales Manager of
electrostatic charges.
faces. The electrostatic suspension
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Electrostatic Discharge
11 of contamination is able to cause in sensitive areas for example in semiconductor cleanrooms or in pharmaceutical labs, critical quality issues which are imperative to prevent. It’s no wonder then that the demand for consultation in respect to the issue of electrostatic and ESD protection (ESD = electrostatic discharge) is increasingly growing. “The demand is large” observes Christian Fleuren, Market Segment Manager Industry at Nora Systems GmbH. The company located in Weinheim, Germany produces flooring and shoe components. Fleuren emphasizes: “Terminology such as electrostatic dissipation, conductivity or anti-static are not an integral part of an Architectural study.” Building contractors however expect pertinent knowledge in the construction of production sites and laboratories.
ESD-Network provides Know-how and Equipment In order to make this knowledge
Impressions of the Cleanzone 2015: Between footwear and flooring arise charging voltages when walking. Thus there will be no uncontrolled
available to the market, the German
discharges have clothing, footwear
ESD Network was founded one year
and flooring - as demonstrated here
ago. Four large companies have joined their ESP lines of business
- have static dissipative properties. Photo: Cleanroom Media
whereby each company has its own focus and core topic. Andreas Karl GmbH & Co. KG is specialized in ESDsafe work places. Keinath Electronic GmbH offers seminars, workshops, consulting and equipment for the entire ESD sector. Nora Systems
“Terminology such as discharge capability, conductivity or antistatic are not an integral part of an architectural study.” Christian Fleuren, Market Segment Manager Industry, Nora Systems GmbH
GmbH is a specialist for flooring in ESD protected areas. Wanzl Metallwarenfabrik GmbH produces access controls for Electrostatic Protected Areas (EPA). “In this combination we are able to provide in respect to ESD protection a comprehensive portfolio in know-how and equipment” says Andreas F. Karl Managing Director of Andreas Karl GmbH & Co. KG.
Electrostatic Discharge | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
12 The German ESD Network presented
over a floor between the shoe and
expert Ricco Scheibel. “Firstly all
itself for the first time in May, 2015
flooring material. People are not ex-
electrically condutive components
in Nürnberg, Germany at the SMT,
posed to any danger in this instance
are to be equipped with ground-
Europe’s leading trade fair for system
but electronic components and
ing. Concretely this means: All
integration in micro-electronics. Fur-
devices are. Sitting on ungrounded
personnel are to be grounded with
thermore the newly produced ESD
chairs with rollers as well as wearing
antistatic clothing, this measure
guidebook was presented. “With this
clothing unsuitable in ESD areas can
s u p p o r t e d b y t h e w ea r i n g o f
guidebook, we would like to support
cause people to accumulate charges.
grounding straps on the wrists
companies and specialists in their
So that no uncontrolled discharging
and ankles. Additionally, work
daily work and to sensitize them
takes place, people, clothing, shoes
places are protected by grounding
to the relevance of this topic”, says
and floors have to have electrostatic
table tops, mats and conductive
Andreas F. Karl. The avoidance of
dissipating properties.
flooring.”
LIFE & BUSINESS
damage by electrostatic discharge not only prevents a company from accruing higher costs but also increases customer satisfaction and retention.
Devastating Killer-Events are preventable How is damage caused by elec-
For a micro-electronic component the energy of an electrostatic discharge is comparable to the energy of lightning striking a tree. Source: Wikipedia
trostatic discharge preventable? „Fundamentally in practice, it is impossible to completely keep static electricity out of production
“In order to suppress particle-at-
Producers of cleanroom needs offer
facilities” says Ricco Scheibel of PMT
traction and ESD-killer events,
a wide range of products. Modern
Partikel-Messtechnik GmbH. Charge
there is a range of pragmatic and
cleanroom clothing reinforced
voltages are generated while walking
effective approaches” says PMT
with conductive carbon fibers for dissipating electrical charges is available which should be worn in
Important ESD Norms and Policies EN 61340: Theses European norms deal with the protection of electronic components against electrical phenomena. The various norm sections support the user with the selection of suitable protection measures.
the production of sensitive technical devices. Cleanroom gloves for chip production and microprocessor processing are also furnished with anti-static accessory equipment. ESD protection also provides overboots, which thanks to anti-static
ANSI/ESD S 20.20: This industry-overlapping standard describes the administrative and technical demands of the ESD control program for the protection of sensitive electronic components, assembly groups, devices and facilities against ESD damage and downtimes. SEMI E78-0998: This guideline aims at minimizing the negative impacts on productivity by static charges and electrical fields in semiconductor production equipment. It is the guideline for the use of electrostatic tolerant operating supplies in the semiconductor industry. Source: PMT Partikel-Messtechnik GmbH
properties no longer electrically charge those who wear them. Other anti-static measures which are recommended are charge-dissipating ESD work places and ESD rubber flooring systems. It should be observed that charge dissipation by grounding only works with conductive materials. There are in every work environment socalled insulators that is materials on whose surfaces electrical charges are not able to move. In such cases,
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Electrostatic Discharge
13 grounding doesn’t work. In order to remove electrical charges from insulated surfaces other solutions are required.
Air Ionization is effective where Grounding fails As an effective method for neutralizing insulated materials, active air ionization has proven itself because it improves the electrical conductivity of the dry cleanroom air. The dryness of the air has a large influence on the electrostatic charging. The drier the air is, the stronger the electrostatic charging is. As the cleanroom air is itself a relatively good insulator, it
Measures against electrostatic Discharge Antistatic Mats protect people and products against electrostatic charging and discharging, and makes it possible to work safely in ESD endangered areas (ESD = electrostatic discharge). The mats have to be supplemented with further antistatic measures for example ESD approved clothing, work places and tools. Grounding directs electrostatic charges on products, facilities and people to the ground. Grounding straps are to be used for wrists and ankles as well as for table mats and tools with conductive grips. Grounding also prevents explosions due to electrostatic discharges. ESD-Work Place Systems consist of conductive worktops and table frames with grounding for the dissipation of electrostatic charges. Such conductive work place systems are necessary everywhere component parts are processed or handled which could be damaged or destroyed by electrostatic discharge.
is actually very easy to raise air conductivity by increasing air humidity. However upon closer examination, this is not an option for cleanroom operators. The method is not only expensive and not very effective, but also could favor the growth of micro-organisms.
Packaging play an important role in the protection of sensitive components. The common packaging chips and bubble wrap are good electrical charge carriers and therefore are ruled out. Against undesired discharges during transport and storage, special antistatic or electrostatic dissipating materials provide protection. Source: www.arbeitsschutz-portal.de
As an alternative to air humidification, air ionization has proven itself.
too few. If these ionized air molecules
practically neutralize itself. Several
Ionizers via air flows intensively
come into contact with an electrically
technical ionization processes have
provide the cleanroom with air mol-
charged surface, the ions will change
been established. Depending on the
ecules which have an ion too many or
their polarities and the surface will
process environment, cleanroom operators are able to choose from among various possibilities available the most optimal ion distribution system for their environments. Those who choose to protect their production in respect to the ways described with an all-encompassing “lightning rod”, they will not have to heed to the poet’s warning „ A lack of gap will certainly mean that some of the sparks will jump the seam”. The mini sparks with maxi damage will thereby be passé. Author: Frank Baecke
The moment at which the spark might be dangerous - if no precautions were taken. Photo: gammaburst/Fotolia
Electrostatic Discharge | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
14
“Neutralization by ionization is the method of choice”
LIFE & BUSINESS
Ralf Keinath, the Executive Managing Partner of Keinath Electronic GmbH, comments on the risks to products by electrostatic discharges.
Cleanroom Magazin: In cleanrooms
a spark with our own eyes. Semicon-
as well as possible. The second: To
the constant issue it the ellimination
ductor components are sensitive to
controllably dissipate charges,
of particles and germs. However
even just a few volts!
whereby a gentle discharging is
there isn’t much said or written
meant which is best done with the
about the risks to products by elec-
Cleanroom Magazin: How large are
appropriate room and personnel
trostatic discharges. Why is this?
the damages and product losses due
equipment in the grey rooms. In
to ESD?
cleanrooms, this is conditionally
Ralf Keinath: Well as the name
possible as such equipment present
itself indicates, the demands on
Ralf Keinath: It can be assumed that
contamination issues. Moreover
cleanrooms deal primarily with
15 to 20 percent of all electrical fail-
the metal surface areas which are
cleanliness, either in the sense
ures of semiconductor components
preferred in cleanrooms cannot
of particles and/or in the sense
can be traced back to an ESD event.
be gently discharged as they are
of germs. However, there is also
These values were confirmed by
low-impedance objects. This leads
present the natural phenomenon
different and independent analyses
to the undesired hard discharge
of electrostatic discharge. It is im-
over a period of many years and at
which can cause ESD damage. And
portant to always be aware of this.
several different semiconductor
now for the third method: The
manufacturers.
neutralization of the charges with
Cleanroom Magazin: Is the awareness
neutralization devices. This is in a
of ESD risk lower because it presents a
Cleanroom Magazin: How can
cleanroom as a rule the method of
lower risk than contamination?
cleanroom operators neutralize or
choice!
prevent electrostatic discharges? Ralf Keinath: The question concern-
Cleanroom Magazin: Is it possible
ing risks has to be differentiated
to build cleanrooms ESD neutral or
from case to case. At first, it must
is this condition only seen after the
be clarified to what extent the prod-
cleanroom is put into operation, if
ucts handled in the cleanroom are
and where it sparks?
electrostatically sensitive. Ralf Keinath: The latter should be Cleanroom Magazin: Back to my
in any case avoided. If the products
question: Is the awareness of ESD
handled are electrostatically sensi-
risk lower?
tive, than the ESD protection has to be and should be considered in the
Ralf Keinath: I would say: Yes. Everybo-
Ralf Keinath is the Executive Managing Partner of Kein-
dy knows about electrical discharges
ath Electronic GmbH. The company counts as one of the
from everyday life, like the electrical
founding members of the German ESD Network (Deutschen
shock when touching a door handle or
ESD-Netzwerkes). Grafik: kutukupret/Fotolia
the crackling sound when pulling on a sweater. People perceive a discharge
Ralf Keinath: ESD can effectively be
from 3000 volts under this we don’t feel
controlled with three methods. The
anything. From 10,000 volts we can see
first: To avoid electrostatic charging
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Electrostatic Discharge
initial planning of a cleanroom. *ESD = electrostatic discharge
CLEANROOM EXPERIENCE The license for knowledge surrounding everyday cleanroom use!
Makes work easier For all cleanroom supervisors Contents More than 500 topical articles including: · Best Practice · Presentations · Checklists · Key Standards · Training Materials · Operating Instructions Download A wide range of materials in PDF format Like us on Facebook!
Register It’s this easy: go to www.cl-ex.com Click on Register, and start using the knowledge.* For Cleanroom Users Cleanroom Suppliers Cleanroom Supervisors Cleanroom Trainees Instructors Students
* The license fee for one year constitutes a single payment of € 98.–
www.cl-ex.com The knowledge portal for the cleanroom industry. 3D-DruckCLEANROOM | MAGAZINE 2/2016
15
16
The next big thing? Virtual Reality-Devices are expected to replace Smartphones.
Virtual-Reality-Glasses: 20% of Germans are interested in imaginary 3D worlds 14-29 years: 28% 30-49 years 25%
28%
34%
13%
Over 50 years: 13% Other: 34%
25% Source: Bitkom
Virtual-Reality-Glasses: 20% of Germans are interested in imaginary 3D worlds
LIFE & BUSINESS
14-29 years: 28%
Facebook, Google and Microsoft are putting millions of dollars into the development of VR-technologies, and together with device manufacturers such as Samsung, LG and Co. are creating fascinating worlds of illusion. The devices are still rather vague and the contents meager, but one thing is sure: The market prognosis looks splendid.
30-49 years 25%
“With modern cleanroom technolOver 50 years: 13% 34%
28%
Other: 34% ogy, modular and flexible solutions
are increasingly in demand. There25%
fore13% the transparent and individual Source: Bitkom planning of cleanrooms for oper-
ators is becoming more and more important”, says Harald Wodtke, To set up a cleanroom today which
in the planning, construction and
Project Manager at bc-technology.
will be built tomorrow? Virtual
qualification of cleanrooms. With
“With the help of VR technology, we
Reality (VR) makes this possible. The
stereo-visualization using CAD
have found a medium which makes
technology generates an artificial
data, the specialists provide for their
it possible for a customer to step into
world on a computer in which the
customers virtual tours through the
his cleanroom also when the project
observer is able to virtually move
planned cleanrooms. Customers are
is only in its conception phase.”
through as if he is actually on site.
able to view machines, devices and equipment from every perspective
Bc-technology GmbH already offers
and – also with ergonomic consid-
for its customers the use of such
erations – play through, reality-true,
virtual 3D worlds for the design of
their individual solutions. Produc-
cleanrooms. The company located in
tion processes are also able to be
Dettingen, Germany is specialized
simulated in real-time.
The Risks are decreasing, The Planning Dependability is increasing These possibilities are providing cleanroom operators major advantages: They are able to determine in virtual reality the optimal utilization of their rooms, to resolve any critical issues before beginning construction and to estimate more realistically the expenditures. Potentials for reducing costs become visible, risks decrease and planning dependability increases. Virtual reality holds to be “the next big thing”. The global IT and electronics industries see in this technology their future markets, they are expected to become the platform which will replace PC’s and Smartphones. This was the message from the big market players at the
...and ready to go into the 3-D-Future. Photo: Monika Wisniewska/Fotolia
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Virtual Reality
recent Mobile World Congress in
17 Barcelona, Spain, Europe’s largest Mobile Communication Trade Fair. From the end of February to the beginning of March, 2016, manufacturers presented their latest solutions and devices for working and playing virtually. The technological approaches are really quite different. That company which will be leading the pack is still open. Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg announced during his presentation at the Mobile World Congress: “Virtual reality will be the next major platform.
Put the smartphone with the relevant content in the glasses.... Photo: Monika Wisniewska/Fotolia
It will change every facet of life.” Together with Samsung, Facebook wants
on in life he didn’t want to only look
charging ahead with its VR glasses
to become the market leader in this
at photos and films of her but fully
which are far lighter and therefore
anticipated billion-dollar market. The
immerse himself into these earlier
more comfortable. The trick is: The
New York investment banking and
scenes. Together with Samsung his
Smartphone is not connected to the
securities trading company Goldman
company has developed the Virtu-
glasses but only a connection cable.
Sachs forecasts that turnovers with virtual reality will reach 110 billion dollars in 2025.
Instead of looking at old Photos, immerse yourself once again in the Scene
“Virtual reality will be the next major platform. It will change every facet of life.” Mark Zuckerberg, CEO Facebook Inc.
Facebook boss Zuckerberg believed early on in the new technology. He has already invested since March,
al-Reality-Glasses Gear VR, which
HTC wants to seize the market from
2014, two billion dollars in the pur-
uses the Smartphone as its display.
the top end and bring to the market
chase of the company Oculus VR
Facebook has piloted its software
in April a highly-praised high-tech
which with its Head-Mounted-Dis-
know-how into the partnership
headset. Apple is also hoping for
play with the name of Oculus Rift is
which has raised eyebrows among
new growth outside of the saturated
considered the forerunner among
market observers. Forrester analyst
Smartphone market and therefore
providers of VR entertainment. The
Juli Ask said when interviewed on
has called into life a top secret di-
glasses give the user the feeling that
n-tv: “The combination of social
vision for Virtual and Augmented
he is really able to move around in
media and communication is the
Reality.
the virtual world.
Killer-App.” According to forecasts from IHS,
The Oculus glasses were developed for especially realistic game enactments however Zuckerberg has long been thinking of further
2016 is expected to bring the Breakthrough for VR Technologies
applications. These range from
by the end of 2016 seven million VR headsets are expected to be flaunted by their enraptured new owners. The market researchers at CCS expect a jump in sales of VR glasses to 20
education to the marketing of real
Facebook and Samsung are however,
million in 2018. By 2020, IHS forecasts
estate and tourism on up to a per-
not the only ones which will make
that 37 million headsets will be sold.
son’s private life. After the birth of
2016 the year for Breakthroughs
The euphoria over the new tech-
his daughter, he realized that later
for the new technologies. LG is
nology does not however include
Virtual Reality | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
LIFE & BUSINESS
18
Ready to go into a cleanroom before it is build? VR technology makes it possible. Photo: bc-technology GmbH
all management boards. Sony for
the small gamer niche, good content
Doctors would have the possibility
example is keeping to its Playstation
material for the mass market is
to digitally simulate risky proce-
VR glasses and is staying out of the
still scarce. Oculus founder Palmer
dures. Architects and city planners
mobile communication market. For
Luckey doesn’t see in the sales of
could create walk-in designs. The
Sony Mobile boss Hiroki Totoki it is
VR glasses a long term sustainable
logistician could be assisted in the
not about putting still another VR
business model. At the first “VR/AR
optimization of goods-storage with
glasses device on the market. He is
Summit” presented by the software
the help of VR glasses. Applications
more concerned with the question
company Unity at the beginning of
have also been devoted to business
where enough good content ma-
February in Los Angeles. California,
communications. The Canadian
terial for the virtual world will be
Luckey stated that money can only be
company Summit Tech for example,
coming from.
made with material content: “It only
has developed a solution with which
counts how often the buyer returns
globally scattered colleagues are
to experience something new.”
able to sit themselves in their host’s
Sales alone of Glasses is not enough, There has to be Content
conference room during a video The drawing card for the new
conference by using VR glasses and
technology should be in the busi-
are able to look around and see all of
ness applications. For example
the participants.
Thereby the Sony manager has put
pilots could train how to control
a finger in the wound. Apart from
an airplane in a virtual world.
“With the help of VR technology we have found the medium which will make it possible for a customer to step into his cleanroom also when the project is only in its conception phase.” Harald Wodtke, Project Manager bc-technology GmbH
Augmented Reality Highly Interesting for Industry For many industries, it is more interesting the linking of real environments with virtual components which can be merged into the user’s field of vision. This augmented reality is able to facilitate the work from production to logistics facilities on up to the OP in that technicians, assemblers or surgeons are shown instructions for the necessary procedural steps on the data glasses. The
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Virtual Reality
19 Sales of Virtual-Reality glasses 2,2 Million
Sales of Virtual-Reality glasses
2015 2018
20 Million
2,2 Million
2015
20 Million
37 Million
37 Million
2020
2018 2020
Sources: IHS, CCS Insight
Sources: IHS, CCS Insight
Mercedes Benz factory in Bremen
have direct access to information
this world of illusion provides not
has implemented Google Glasses
or need both hands for their tasks.
only the optimization of facilities.
in the construction of automobiles
Cleanroom operators can generate
whereby the tools necessary for
It is imaginable to use such applica-
training environments in which they
the assembly of external parts are
tions in the cleanroom. The textile
are able to prepare new employees
displayed. With these augmented
service and lavatory hygiene provider
for their work in a cleanroom.
reality glasses the tools can be mod-
CWS-boco offers its customers an App
If this is the way it is going, then the
ified and the data immediately sent
for Android and Apple Smartphones
situation has come full circle. Elec-
to the factory in Peking where the
which makes it possible to virtually
tronic systems are able to virtually
tool implementation is just taking
equip a real room with CWS dispens-
resurrect cleanroom worlds from
place. Augmented reality or the
ers. Therefore customers or potential
which they themselves have just
merging of immediate information
customers can see in advance which
emerged.
in real time, is for industry useful
solutions optically and functionally
above all where employees don’t
at best suit their premises. However
Author: Frank Baecke
vali.sys gmbh hofstrasse 94 ch-8620 wetzikon +41 43 495 92 50 info@valisys.ch www.valisys.ch
innovative – competent – customized
Your partner for validated systems!
Visit us at LOUNGES in Stuttgart
With us, you see your monitoring from April 5-7, 2016 an entirely new perspective. We transform your cleanroom into the Hall 1, Booth F2.3 «next big thing».
Virtual Reality | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
20
Two Desks, a Drawing Board and a lot of Courage From these ingredients, Joachim Ludwig created the nucleus of today’s Colandis GmbH.
Colandis CEO Joachim Ludwig.
LIFE & BUSINESS
Photo: Cleanroom Media
It is really amazing. The man earns his money with products and process solutions for cleanroom technology and at the same time says: “The best cleanroom is that which is not needed.” This is like saying: Let me have my cake and eat it too. However for Joachim Ludwig the founder and Managing Director of Colandis GmbH in Kahla, Germany, this is no contradiction: “The cleanroom can be a solution but doesn’t have to be.” The question is, though, does the customer always need a complete cleanroom? Sometimes a simpler solution is better, whereby employees are kept out of the production processes. “I always think in broad terms and discuss with my customers technological alternatives” explains Ludwig and refers to Henry Ford. Ford said: “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said: faster horses.” Colandis’ boss ticks in the same way: “For me, it’s always about new ideas, about how to do it differently.” Obviously it is exactly this way of
On May 1st, 2016, Colandis GmbH will celebrate its 20 year anniversary. In an interview with “Cleanroom Magazin” Managing Director Joachim Ludwig reports on how he out of a one-man engineering office built up his Clean Air Company which is active worldwide and which role his daughter’s Latin book played.
thinking which one day brought a member of staff to become an entrepreneur. This day was for Joachim Ludwig July 1st, 1995. On this Saturday, seven years after graduating from the university, he became his own boss in an engineering office. At that point in time,
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Portrait
21 he couldn’t imagine that out of this one-man office, the company Colandis GmbH would one day arise.
Only Five One-Thousandth Kelvin Tolerance This native of Jena, Germany, started his career after finishing his Engineering Diploma at Carl Zeiss Jena. At Zeiss, he had three possible choices. “The one was too involved with optics, the other too much mechanics but nevertheless
Company Portrait COLANDIS GmbH COLANDIS GmbH located in Kahla, Germany is specialized in the construction of customer-specified cleanroom solutions. Besides consultation, development and construction, the production of proprietary products in cleanroom conditions belongs to its spectrum of services. Furthermore, the company possesses a high degree of know-how in the carrying out of inspections for suitable cleanliness-conditions according to VDI 2083-9.1. Additional services include assembly and machine cleaning under cleanroom conditions, consultation in all issues concerning cleanroom technology as well as process-specific employee training.
better, and the third was cleanroom technology – this I didn’t know so I took up this one” recounts Ludwig. The business sector in which he worked built large machines for the
In Jena, they were already two steps ahead of the Fraunhofer-IPA
However his efforts paid off. With Ludwig’s support, the company developed new product ranges among them one of the first circuit board
semiconductor industry and was to some extent a competitor for the
The German re-unification came
direct exposure machines. “We could
Dutch lithograph systems manufac-
two years later and the Kombinat
directly go to the circuit board with
turer ASML, at that time known as
Carl Zeiss Jena was divided into
the laser which omitted the round-
ASM. “It was always gripping when
several independent companies.
about film exposure procedure”
we brought our own assemblies into
Joachim Ludwig landed at the
says Ludwig. A further important
operation. For example, we ensured
new Jenoptik Infab GmbH. At this
development was the automation of
constant temperatures of precision
company he took up the initiative
wafer handling and transport into
optics in wafer steppers. There was
to collect information from various
the cleanroom. The terms SMIF and
only a five one-thousandth Kelvin
and diverse sectors of industry. “I vis-
FOUP are well known in the semi-
tolerance and this had to be strictly
ited many congresses and meetings
conductor industry.
maintained” portrays this former as-
and often paid for these trips out of
“At that time, we were in respect to
sembly group/component developer.
my own pocket” recounts Ludwig.
the state of knowledge comparable
CLEANROOM TRAINING
www.reinraum-akademie.de
Portrait | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
22 Two Desks and a Drawing Board
“For me, it’s always about new ideas, about how to do it differently.” Joachim Ludwig, Managing Director Colandis GmbH
At first, the projects were sporadic. Then came the search for a colleague and finally the founding of a GbR with the name Cleanroom Technology Jena. This was on May 1st, 1996, the day on which today’s
LIFE & BUSINESS
Colandis GmbH will be celebrating to the Fraunhofer IPA in Stuttgart”
technical ventilation components
its 20th anniversary. “We started
remembers the Colandis owner. At
in sterile environments). Joachim
in Kahla which is nearby Jena in a
the time he was visiting a presenta-
Ludwig is still working today in
40 square meter office. Below the
tion on the optimization of wafer
this and in many other commit-
office was an equally-large garage
steppers at the IPA, he advised the
tees: “I’m the dinosaur there.”
which we could use as a work shop.
referent: “Come on over to Jena,
Two desks and a drawing board
we’re already a step further.” As
were all we had” depicts Joachim
the referent did indeed come to Jena, he was astonished: “You are already two steps ahead!” Prompt-
The Jump to Self-Employment begins with a packed-full Cardboard Box
ly, he invited Joachim Ludwig to
Ludwig about his start. In the garage, which was soon equipped with used work benches
be part of the VDI Guidelines 2083
Then came the hammer. At the end
and surface plates, emerged the
Work Group, in which he was sig-
of 1994, the company management
first company product, a joint de-
nificantly contributing to on page
announced: “We have to dismiss
velopment with Mannesmann-Re-
8, today’s page 9.1 (Suitability of
further employees, but you are
inraumtechnik. The small GbR
operation supplies and equipment
allowed to bring any running
grew quickly. After two years, the
in respect to cleanliness as well as
projects to their finish.” Ludwig
80 square meters in Kahla had be-
sought a dialogue with his boss:
come too cramped. There followed
“We had made the appointment
a move to Jena into an area of 300
for 4.00 p.m. The kids were in the
square meters, which after a half
car. At 5.00 p.m., I still hadn’t been
year also became too small. For the
called in. I called my wife and she
necessary size for his company,
said to me: You have known for a
Joachim Ludwig had already had
long time what you really want to
“a super piece of property in sight”,
do. So, after the conversation with
however the city of Jena put a stone
my boss, I cleaned out my desk and
in his way. They wanted to pass on
as it is known from news reports
the costs for a retaining wall on the
about the USA, marched out of the
property to Cleanroom Technology
company with a full cardboard box
GbR. “I called the mayor of Jena
under my arm.”
about this who immediately offered me an alternative piece of property.
Joachim Ludwig talks about this
A week later, I was able to sign the
setback in his life with crossed
deed of sale” says Ludwig.
arms, but a smile on his face. The crossed arms give the impression as if he retrospectively would like
The Daughter’s Latin Book
to protect himself from the intervention on his professional life.
The new construction in Kahla
However his smile shows: Looking
made it necessary to found a
back, leaving the company was
GmbH. However this had a catch
the right thing to do. A short time
to it. According to a new court deci-
In the days of beginning 1990 / 1991.
later, he was the boss of his own
sion, the GbR could not name itself
Photo: Colandis GmbH
engineering office.
Cleanroom Technology Jena GmbH,
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Portrait
23 as the company resided in Kahla.
don’t usually enjoy crime stories
“At this time, my middle daughter
but these I do” raves the 54-year old.
discovered in her Latin book that ‘colandi instumentum’ means approximately filter instrument
Colandis Production Highlights
or filter element.” Thus the idea for the new company name was
Today the company employs 23 peo-
born. Indeed in September, 2001,
ple and has a turnover of around three million Euros. When asked about the major highlights from the last 20 years, the Colandis boss crosses his arms once again and leans back in his chair. It seems that something is running by his inner eye as the answer has to wait a moment. “Let’s take our Ventilation-Filter-Module” he eventually says. “Instead of a standard disposable product, we offer customer-specific solutions which achieve higher prices in Asia because we provide better performance.” Further highlights of Colandis’ production are x-ray safe mini-environments , a nine-meter high cleanroom with an integrated cable-crane system for an aerospace
QUALIFIZIERUNG WARTUNG STRÖMUNGSVISUALISIERUNG MONITORING
company and above all the com-
MESSTECHNIK
pany’s proprietary portable rent-
KALIBRIERUNG
Colandis CEO Joachim Ludwig celebrates the 20th anni-
al-cleanroom. “We build a 20 square
versary of his company. Photo: Colandis GmbH
meter portable rental-cleanroom
SERVICE
with an ISO Class 5 specification,
BERATUNG
without using any tools in less than Cleanroom Technology Jena GbR
15 minutes, plus two minutes for
became Colandis GmbH.
laying out the flooring” emphasiz-
Joachim Ludwig freely admits that
es Joachim Ludwig. This kind of
he has experienced times in the last
modular installation of a sterile
20 years which he “would rather
environment is unparalleled in the
have done without”. However to
world. Joachim Ludwig glances at
give up was never a question: “The
the clock, the next appointment is
company is my baby!” This admirer
calling. “Oh, one more thing”, he
of Manfred von Ardenne is today
adds while standing up, “Colandis
the possessor of several patents, the
was among the finalists for the
author of numerous publications
Small and Medium-Sized Compa-
as well as a speaker in all corners
nies Award in 2014…”
SCHULUNG
BSR Ingenieur-Büro BSR Meßtechnik GmbH Beratung und Service im Reinraum Marienstraße 156 68794 Oberhausen-Rheinhausen eMail: blattner@reinraum.info Tel. 07254-959 590 Fax 07254-959 5929
of the world. “To enjoy what I do is always first priority” says the
So many highlights, so many rea-
father of two daughters and one
sons to celebrate. Happy Birthday,
son. He also enjoys good hard-rock
Colandis!
music and the crime stories by the Islander Arnaldur Indridason. “I
Author: Frank Baecke
Portrait | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
When New Life emerges from the Cleanroom Couples want to have children. Is not the natural way possible, artificial insemination may be a solution.
Photo: g-stockstudio/shutterstock.com
LIFE & BUSINESS
24
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Artificial fertilization
25 The wish to have children belongs to one of the most intensive longings of couples who remain involuntarily childless. Artificial insemination promises help. The use of cleanroom technology ensures that contamination and other negative influences are to the greatest possible extent kept away from the sensitive cells.
How can new life arise in a cleanroom when these environmental conditions should be preventing the growth of cells capable of reproduction? How can human life thrive, of all things, under such hostile environments? To answer these questions, the Practice for Fertility Dr. Peet and Dr. Wilkening in Berlin, Germany
In in-vitro fertilization, the fertilization of the eggs takes place in a test tube. Then the embryos are implanted into the mother. Photo: Dan Race/Fotolia
commissioned the experts at the Avantalion Consulting Group an
The latter comes across as self-
international expert consulting
evident but in fact, it isn’t. The
service in the areas of Pharmaceu-
Av a n t a l i o n P r o j e c t M a n a g e r
ticals, mechanical engineering and
Claudia Pachl reports that various
The First In-Vitro Procreated Baby was born in 1978 No other medical procedure was able to cause such a furor in past times than artificial insemination. Louise Joy Brown, born on July 25th,
“If a wafer is dropped, money is lost. If a Petri dish is dropped, life is destroyed.”
1978 in Oldham near Manchester, England, was the first in-vitro procreated human in the world. The egg cell was fertilized outside of the womb in a test tube (in-vitro
Claudia Pachl, Avantalion Consulting Group
fertilization) and the embryo afterwards placed back into the womb. The method rapidly spread itself around the world. In Germany, the
automotive financing, The goal of
regulations have to be considered
first test-tube baby was born in 1981,
the project was to obtain the per-
whose diverse work group and ex-
in Erlangen, Germany.
mission in regards to the Medicinal
pert’s interpretations oppose and
Products Act for the Operation of
conflict with each other, which
Practices to fulfill childless couples’
contradict statutory requirements.
desire to have a family. The devel-
These contradictory challenges
opment of a concept was necessary
have to be overcome in order to
which enabled the safe execution of
lead the practice toward obtaining
the demanding processes of han-
an operating license.
dling the germ cells and in addition complying to all regulatory and technical requirements.
Artificial fertilization | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
26 Artificial insemination is always
federal regulations, which require
Wilening, the new Practice for
applied in medicine when a diag-
the use of cleanroom technology,
Fertility in Berlin in March, 2015.
nosis has been submitted which
and the particular needs of working
The doctor looks back on over 20
indicates, for example, a defect in
with human cells in connection
years of experience in artificial
the oviduct, serious limitations in
with the procedures in a doctor’s
insemination. In order to operate
sperm quality, or when only very few eggs are available. “In every case, because of ethical reasons,
“There are more and more invitro-fertilization practices and clinics opening which with the implementation of cleanroom technology are obtaining better results.”
the best-suited environment for the artificial insemination to take place has to be provided.” Says the Avantalion Managing Director and
LIFE & BUSINESS
Partner Claudia Pachl.
Between the Conflicting Priorities of Life and Technology
Claudia Pachl, Avantalion Consulting Group
With the so-called Assisted Reproduction Technique, better known as In-Vitro-Fertilization or artificial
office or clinic have to be dealt with.
the new practice in the Friedrich-
insemination, the practice-opera-
Just how complex these challeng-
straße, he needed a new license
tors face major challenges: In order
es are, the owners of the Berlin
meeting the requirements of the
to properly carry out the procedure
Practice for Fertility Dr. Peet and
Medicinal Products Act which
within the regulatory framework of
Dr. Wilkening could sing out
was applied for at the relevant
artificial insemination, the balanc-
loud. David Peet founded togeth-
State Office for Public Health and
ing act between the fulfillment of
er with his colleague, Dr. Wibke
Social Affairs (LaGeSo).
Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection: In this method, a sperm with a very fine needle is injected directly into the egg cell (see image page 25 bottom right). Photo: VILevi/Fotolia
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Artificial fertilization
27
View into the new cleanroom of the practice for fertility Dr. Peet and Dr. Wilkening in Berlin-Mitte. Photo: Praxis Dr. Peet and Dr. Wilkening
Laws, Laws and still more Laws
EU-GMP-Guidelines, in other words, Class A. In order for a Class A working
Experts in Disagreement over the Use of Cleanroom Technology
However, there is more. Those who
environment, equipped with special
want to provide Assisted Reproduction
air treatment and air flow regulation
Techniques have to also deal with not
systems, to reduce particulate and
In addition to all this, there are nu-
only the Medicinal Products Act, but
microbial contamination risks to a
merous guidelines and publications
also the Transplantation Law, The
minimum, the adjoining areas have
from associations and scientists
Pharmaceutical and Active Agent
to be constructed to support the ster-
whose recommendations are over-
Production Ordinance, the Industrial
ile conditions inside the cleanroom.
whelmingly contradictory with the
Code as well as the Directives for the
For the treatment and processing of
requirements written down in the
Implementation of Tissues and Cells.
tissues, cleanroom not less than Class
Pharmaceutical and Active Agent
The last two deal with donating, pro-
D is required.
Production Ordinance and reject
curing, testing, processing, conserving,
the use of applicable measures.
storing and distributing human tissues
Moreover the qualification of critical
and cells. Furthermore, the Infections
equipment and devices is required,
“This is principally plausible� ex-
Protection Law and the Embryo Protec-
the validation of critical treatment
plains Claudia Pachl. The built-in
tion Law have to be considered.
and processing procedures is required,
air flows in the Class A areas could
appropriate hygiene measures are
cause changes in the pH values and
The Pharmaceutical and Active Agent
required, traceability procedures are
in the worst case make the germ
Production Ordinance requires for
required, training is required, internal
cells unusable due to cooling effects.
the treatment and processing of
inspections are required, procedural
In addition, the transfer of the
the germ cells the highest degree of
instructions showing standards are
fertilized cells back into the womb,
cleanroom air quality according to
required and much more.
which in nature takes place over a
Artificial fertilization | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
28 authorities in Berlin represent a clear standpoint: The have not
A Small Glossary:
recognized the often-quoted ex-
IVF stands for In-Vitro-Fertilization. With this procedure, egg cells and sperm cells are brought together in a glass (in-vitro). In the nutrient fluid, egg fertilization should take place. When the fusion of one or several egg cells with sperm cells is successful, the embryo is transferred to the womb after a few days.
LIFE & BUSINESS
ICSI stands for Intra-Cyto-Plasma Sperm Injection. With this method the sperm cells are directly injected into the egg cells with a very fine needle. In Germany, ICSI is much more often done as in-vitro-fertilization. In 2011, over 75 percent of artificial inseminations were done using the ICSI method.
ceptions coming from experts and associations. Although Dr. Peet has been successfully operating three in-vitro-fertilization practices in Berlin for many years, the LaGeSo (State Office for Public Health and Social Affairs) is demanding for the new practice, measurements for the qualification of treatment rooms as well as verification of a Clean-up-Phase. In addition, a verified and controlled pressure
germ-charged body opening which
technology are obtaining better
cascade which includes monitor-
mustn’t be disinfected, namely the
results although some experts dis-
ing is being required as well as
female vagina, contradicts the
agree with this” observes Claudia
the qualification of the critical
sterility requirements of Class A.
Pachl. “Often it is argued that the
equipment and devices.
Moreover the necessary micro-
Assisted Reproduction Technique
scope, heated table and incubators
has been carried out for many
These environmental conditions
which have to be utilized in the
years under poor environmental
requirements could only be im-
Class A area seem to make the
conditions.” There are, however,
plemented by using cleanroom
situation senseless as the warmth
experts in the world who have the
technology. In this respect, the
emitted, the movement of the
opinion that the use of cleanroom
Ava n t a l i o n Co n s u l t a n t s h av e
microscope and the intervention
technology contribute substantially
been able to support and help and
of the reproduction biologists make
to the increase in pregnancy rates.
have drawn up a concept which
the required air flow relationships impossible to maintain. „Nevertheless, there are more and
fulfills all regulatory demands
The Key to Success is the Safe Handling of the Germ Cells
more in-vitro fertilization prac-
and ensures safe processes when working with germ cells. A particular focus was put on the safe handling of germ cells. “If a
tices and clinics opening which
Independent of the various opin-
wafer is dropped, money is lost.
with the installation of cleanroom
ions and recommendations, the
If a Petri dish with germ cells is
CLEANROOM CLEANING
www.profi-con.com
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Artificial fertilization
29 dropped, life is destroyed” emphasizes Claudia Pachl. Therefore the cleanroom equipment is installed in such a way that the germ cells are optimally protected. Likewise the consultants have perfected all the procedures and walk ways so
Successful Artificial Insemination Statistics Up to 2014, approximately 225,625 children were born in Germany using the methods of IVF and ICSI (see box, „A Small Glossary). Worldwide, this number was more than five million.
that the reproduction biologists are able to safely work without limitation among all the technical
Every sixth to seventh couple has difficulties to become pregnant without medical support.
devices and installations. This concept was presented before the authorities and it was accepted. Within a very short time, the cleanroom-technical and organizational measures were carried out and implemented so that in November, 2015, the LaGeSo (State Office for Public Health and Social Affairs), following an inspection
Over 2.5 percent of all children born alive in 2013 were the result of fertilization outside of the body. Statistically, in every class of school children, one of 30 children was born due to artificial insemination. Due to conventional IVF, in 2014, 36.2 percent of all embryo transfers resulted in pregnancy. With the ICSI method, the probability of pregnancy came to 34.5 percent. Source: Deutsches IVF-Register e.V.
of practice rooms and procedures, pregnancy rates have been nega-
been done to protect germ cells and
tively influenced by the cleanroom
patients with the support and im-
equipment. In order to have signif-
plementation of cleanroom-tech-
icant statistics over the possible
nical possibilities” says Claudia
positive influences on pregnancy
Pachl. New life can also emerge
rates due to the implementation of
from cleanrooms. For childless
The first practice results point
cleanroom technology, the data will
couples who long for offspring, this
towards hope: Pregnancy rates
have to be collected over a longer
is indeed good news.
averaged over all age groups from
period of time.
issued the pertinent license.
New Hope for Childless Couples
Author: Frank Baecke. Professional
November, 2015 to February, 2016, come to 41.9 percent. The numbers
“Inherently, the positive feeling re-
and Expert Consultation: Avantalion
show that the germ cells and
mains that everything possible has
Consulting Group, Claudia Pachl
Reinraumbekleidung Dekontamination Sterilisation Am Beckerwald 31 66583 Spiesen-Elversberg Telefon 06821 7930 Telefax 06821 793150 E-Mail: wzb@wzb.de
www.wzb-reinraum.de
Artificial fertilization | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
30
“Cleanroom technology must prevent damage to the germ cells”
LIFE & BUSINESS
Claudia Pachl, managing director and consultant at Avantalion Consulting Group, explains the challenges of building an IVF Laboratory. Cleanroom Magazine: You have
IVF treatment there. Our task was
think about how we could get elec-
advised a Berlin IVF clinic during
thus to integrate the required clean-
tricity and water in the cleanroom,
the installation of a cleanroom
room technology in such a way that
how to deal with ventilation, install
and accompanied by the grant of
not only fit all legal requirements
the air conditioning and how to in-
permission to Medicines Act. What
but also fit into the daily processes
stall the equipment and appliances.
was the initial situation?
of the clinic.
The cleanroom is about 60 square
Claudia Pachl: The building in which
Cleanroom Magazine: What were the
classes A and D. The main hurdle
the clinic was located had no con-
difficulties?
was to fit in all appliances so that
meters, divided into cleanroom
trolled environment in accordance
the clinic workflow wasn’t impeded.
with GMP standards. Therefore at
Claudia Pachl: Since the cleanroom
If an employee carries open petri
the moment, the authority refused
was to be implemented into an
dishes from one table to another, we
permission, to carry out artificial
already existing structure, we had to
can’t have any edges or raised floors,
Reinraumtextilien im Mietsystem Profitieren Sie gleich mehrfach: • Maßgeschneiderte Bekleidungskonzepte und Reinigungssysteme • Transparente Einzelteilbewegungen • Lückenlose Dokumentation • Abschätzbare Kosten • Professionelle und kompetente Beratung Sprechen Sie uns an, fordern Sie uns heraus! Tel: 09841 – 40140850 E-Mail: info@decontam.de Internet: www.decontam.de
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Artificial fertilization
31 no vibrations or circulating air cur-
increased risk for the cells. We were
rents that damage the germ cells or
then able to determine whether we
cause a shift in Ph of the germ cell
needed a class A and class D range
solution. The latter is incidentally
and how much space and equip-
one of the reasons why some experts
ment was required. The derived
say, one must not expose germ cells
cleanroom concept was discussed
to the conditions of class A.
with the government agency to ensure that we had taken into account
Cleanroom Magazine: Why was
their ideas. This was especially im-
a cleanroom in the Berlin clinic
portant because we could not build
necessary?
a typical A class cleanroom to Annex
Claudia Pachl is a partner of the international Avantalion Consulting Group and managing director for the location Lucerne. She has over 15 years of experience in the pharmaceutical industry, especially in the areas
1 of the EU GMP Guidelines. Rather,
of quality management, qualification, validation and
Claudia Pachl: Because the govern-
we designed our own concept in
cleanroom technology. Photo: Avantalion
ment agency has a different point of
reference to the Annex 1.
view than the experts. For example,
class A cannot be met during an op-
they didn’t allow the exception
Cleanroom Magazine: ‘In reference’,
erative state. We faced several such
clause described in the regulations
What does that mean exactly?
balancing acts between regulations
that experts rely on.
and daily workflow practicality. All Claudia Pachl: For example, we had
in all, a mammoth task. Thankfully,
Cleanroom Magazine: How did you
to change the prescribed airflow
all went well in the end. The gov-
implement these requirements?
speed slightly to find a variation
ernment agency has granted an
that did not damage the germ cells
operation permission for the clinic
Claudia Pachl: We looked closely
when exposed to air, but also main-
after a second walkthrough.
at the workflows in the clinic and
tained the needed preservation.
identified all steps that carry an
Furthermore, the particle limits of a
Author: Frank Baecke
Ihr Vollversorger für den Reinraum •
Vollversorgungslösungen für Reinräume und kontrollierte Produktionsumgebungen
•
Erfahrene Spezialisten entwickeln maßgeschneiderte Produkt- und Versorgungskonzepte
•
Supply chain excellence: 100%ige Liefersicherheit und Just-in-Time Lieferungen
•
Umfassendes Qualitätsprodukt- und Dienstleistungsportfolio
•
Globales Netzwerk aus Lieferanten und Partnern
VWR International GmbH · basan – the cleanroom division of VWR | Tel. +49 6107 9008-500 | info.basan@eu.vwr.com | vwr.com/cleanroom
Artificial fertilization | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
32
Cleanroom Technology versus Hospital Germs Can more cleanroom technology prevent the much feared hospital germs?
LIFE & BUSINESS
The discovery of MRSA germs in a premature baby unit in the middle of February in Wiesbaden re-fired up the fear of hospital germ outbreaks. “Cleanroom Magazin” interviewed Dr. Uli Lösch of the University Hospital Basel as to which possibilities cleanroom technology could offer in the prevention of germs in hospitals.
From my point of view, cleanroom
Dr. Uli Lösch: As every person
technology would be an important
carries around with him or herself
addition to other measures of
a flora of germs and pathogens are
ensuring hygiene. Together with
transferred via diverse ways such
Doctor of Science (DSc) Uli Lösch
thorough room disinfection, staff
as hand contact, sneezing, etc., a
completed a pharmaceutical study
hand disinfection, appropriate
solitary application of cleanroom
by dissertation at the University
hygiene-clothing, sterile materials
technology is not able to disrupt
Heidelberg. Afterwards he worked for
and an antibiotic patient covering
the infection-chain.
15 years as an Industrial Pharmacist
, all available technical measures
The high velocity of a sneeze, for
in the areas of production and quality
have been taken to effectively
example, is not able to be captured
assurance. Since 2010, Uli Lösch has
prevent infections.
by the installed air flow system.
been employed as the Director of Production in the Hospital Pharmacy of the University Hospital Basel.
PRO PRO: Dr. Uli Lösch, Director of Hospital Pharmaceutical Production, Hospital Pharmacy, University Hospital, Basel, Switzerland
“Cleanroom technology is to my mind indispensable as an additional measure of protection for patients against microbiological contamination.” Dr. Uli Lösch
Cleanroom Magazin: Would the application of more cleanroom
Cleanroom Magazin: Hospital germs
Furthermore, the many people
technology help prevent most
are in most cases, as was recently
present in a hospital and the speed
cases of hospital germ infections?
shown in Wiesbaden, carried in
of their movements disrupt air
from the outside. Wouldn’t it make
flows and considerably reduce
Dr. Uli Lösch: ABecause of the
more sense to approach the issue
protection measures. Therefore
abundance of germs which people
of pathogen prevention by using
the hospital-wide application of
and thereby patients bring into a
cleanroom technology in the entire
cleanroom technology would not
hospital, cleanroom technology is
hospital and not only in individual
have any great effect. Cleanroom
not able to induce an effect by itself.
departments or in the OP?
technology is able to help in local
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Controversy
33 applications, for example in the OP
resistance against antibiotic
Prof. Arnold Brunner: No, because
to safeguard a patient undergoing
therapy and the increasing spread
the probability that an individual
open surgery against additional
of multi-resistant pathogens,
passing on his/her own flora of
germ infections. Cleanroom
it is expedient to install this
bacteria through the air is rela-
technology is in any case standard
technology in an OP. However,
tively small. The focus has to be
equipment in a hospital pharmacy
these costs have to be considered
put more on the transmission of
for the protection of the manufac-
by medical institutions as well as
germs by direct contact, that is,
tured pharmaceutical products.
when calculating package-priced
on measures which prevent the
treatments.
transfer of germs by direct contact
Cleanroom Magazin: What role do
from person to person. In this re-
room ventilation systems play?
spect, a hospital-wide installation
Are they a main source of patient infection or is it more the patient’s
CONTRA: Professor Arnold
own flora of pathogenic organisms
Brunner, university lecturer for
or is the source the OP personnel
building and cleanroom technology
themselves?
at the University Luzern and consultant at Brunner Haustechnik AG
Dr. Uli Lösch: I don’t see the HVAC
in Wallisellen-Zürich, Switzerland.
technology and equipment as being the main source of patient
Cleanroom Magazin: Can the use
infection. If anything, the entry of
of more cleanroom technology
germs into an OP is effectively in-
prevent the majority of hospital
hibited by a regularly maintained
infections?
system equipped with modern filter and air flow technology.
Prof. Arnold Brunner: No. Clean-
Prof. Arnold Brunner is the founder of
Furthermore, the installation of a
room technology is only able to re-
Brunner Haustechnik AG in Wallisellen-
pressure gradient system ensures
duce the risk of hospital infections.
Zürich, Switzerland and is still active as a
that no microbiological organisms
The difference between sterile
consultant. This graduate HLK engineer
contained in outside air are able to
pharmaceutical production and a
is a full-time lecturer for Building and
flow into an OP.
hospital is that the products of the
Cleanroom Technology at the University
pharmaceutical industry emit no
Luzern Department of Technology and
A patient’s own germ flora can
germs. In contrast, the patient is
Architecture as well as the Chairman
be viewed as the main source
not sterile and arguably the major
of the Work Group for Guidelines
of contamination which even
source of germs in a hospital.
SWKI VA 105-01 “Ventilation and Air
disinfection cannot completely
He brings along his own flora of
Conditioning Technology in Rooms
eliminate. For this same reason,
pathogens into the hospital, not
used for Medical Purposes” (Hospital
the hygiene of OP staff is of course
to mention the doctors, nurses
Guidelines) and Swiss Delegate in the
absolutely essential.
and visitors doing the same. From
CEN Norms Work Group TC156 WG18
everywhere bacteria strains are
“Ventilation in Hospitals”. Furthermore
Cleanroom Magazin: Going
imported into the hospital. In
he is a Board Member of the Swiss
back to the main issue here: Is
Germany, this risk has long been
Association of Cleanroom Technology
the application of cleanroom
neglected. The result: There are
SwissCCS/SRRT and on the VDI Specialist
technology in hospitals necessary
more MRSA related deaths in a
Committee for Cleanroom Technology.
and meaningful or is it completely
hospital than traffic deaths.
overstated and unaffordable? Cleanroom Magazin: If hospital
CONTRA
Dr. Uli Lösch: Cleanroom technol-
germs are imported from the
ogy is to my mind indispensable
outside, doesn’t this mean that
of cleanroom technology would
as an additional measure of
cleanroom technology has to be in-
contribute little.
protection for patients against
stalled in the entire hospital against
In order to prohibit the transfer-
microbiological contamination.
pathogens and not just in individual
ence of germs, hand disinfection,
In view of patients’ growing
departments such as the OP?
the cleaning of contact surfaces,
Controversy | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
34 the changing of clothes and so
observe all hygienic measures
Prof. Arnold Brunner: Cleanroom
on would be far more effective.
and to avoid germ transfer by
technology selectively plays
Cleanliness is a chain of measures
direct contact in order to avoid
an important role, perhaps in
which comes down to every single
hospital infections.
sterile treatments, in isolation
link. If hand disinfection is already
wards or in the OP. In a normal
poor, than all the technical meas-
The ventilation and air condi-
hospital room, normal building
ures taken also become ineffective.
tioning systems function more
technology is enough. Hospitals
to dissipate warm air and odors
are also not qualified under GMP
out of the OP. The same is for
guidelines because the major
Cleanroom Magazin: Which roles do room ventilation and air conditioning systems play? Are they a main source of infections
“In order to prohibit the transference of germs, hand disinfection, the cleaning of contact surfaces, the changing of clothes and so on would be far more effective.”
LIFE & BUSINESS
for patients or is this more the patient’s own bacterial flora or that of the OP personnel? Prof. Arnold Brunner: DRoom ventilation and air conditioning systems are able to filter out airborne spores and bacteria,
Prof. Arnold Brunner
but if the patient carries in these pathogens in his hair or on his skin, then cleanroom technology can do nothing against this. A patient doesn’t allow himself to
surgical fumes which are formed
source of germs is namely the
be so disinfected that all of the
by cutting with laser beams.
patient, only partially the system
germs are eliminated. Therefore
These fumes are really unhealthy
itself.
when a scalpel makes a cut,
for personnel.
germs are able to enter the body
via the wound. These germs are
Cleanroom Magazin: Let’s get back
then rendered harmless with
to the original point: Is the use
antibiotics. However, the problem
of cleanroom technology in a
is that many germs become re-
hospital necessary and sensible
sistant to antibiotics. Therefore it
or fully over-exaggerated and
is far more important to strictly
unaffordable?
*HVAC: heating, ventilation, air conditioning
Author: Frank Baecke
RIBE® Technische Federn
RIBE® – IHR ENTWICKLUNGSPARTNER FÜR TECHNISCHE FEDERN Wir sind langjähriger und renommierter Lösungsspezialist in der Medizintechnik und Entwicklungspartner von namhaften Pharmaunternehmen und deren Zulieferern.
Seit der Gründung im Jahr 1911 hat RIBE® die mittelständische Ausprägung und den Charakter eines familiengeführten Unternehmens beibehalten. Wir bieten Ihnen Zuverlässigkeit in der Serienproduktion und gleichzeitig immer wieder neue Akzente im Bereich neuer Technologien.
• Wir sind gelisteter Lieferant der FDA • Produktion im Sauber- oder Reinraum (ISO Klasse 8) • Prozessdesign incl. Logistik- und Verpackungskonzepten • Bauteilereinigung mit Lösemitteln oder auf wässriger Basis
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Controversy
w w w.r ibe.de
35
PROGRESS
© Kovalenko Inna | Fotolia
THROUGH WISDOM.
Know-how and News – for R&D and Industry. ◾ ◾ ◾ ◾
The leading trade publication in German speaking Europe for Operators and Users Volume 18, 2016 – 5 issues per annum 14,000 qualified readers (IVW)
Cleanroom technology
–
Sterile technology –
Hygiene
–
Production
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
36
On the road with René Hecker René Hecker, Account & Project Manager at Pedak
LIFE & BUSINESS
Photos: Cleanroom Media.
René Hecker is at Pedak, a measurement instrumentation specialist in Heythuysen in the Netherlands and is responsible for the sales of measurement equipment solutions for room climate control systems and the monitoring of cleanroom conditions. Pedak, together with the Swiss company Novasina, has been active in this business for more than 40 years.
How often are you on the road on
What is important for you when
What kind of music do you enjoy
business? On the average, I am on the
travelling? Of the highest priority for
listening to when travelling? My
road three days a week in Germany
me is to strictly keep appointments
taste in music is diverse. The
where I visit customers and business
with customers, as an appointment
kind of music I enjoy listening to
partners who are looking for meas-
is just that, an appointment. I try to
depends on my mood at the time.
urement equipment solutions for their
plan trips so that I am the least time
I enjoy listening to classical music
cleanrooms. Besides Germany, I reg-
stuck in traffic jams. When I am on
for example Rachmaninow, but
ularly visit the company Novasina in
the road, my car is at the same time
the group Queen also belongs to
Switzerland for meetings and training
my office. A comfortable car with a
repertoire of music.
workshops.
mobile access to the internet enables me to take care of my work. When I
Which countries and regions are
What is your favorite mode of trans-
have to stay somewhere overnight, I
on the list of those you most often
portation? When I visit customers,
am mindful of a comfortable bed in
visit? Our office is located in the
I take with me the sensors from
order to be fit for work the next day.
south of the Netherlands and I am
Novasina and our own cleanroom
This is important if a person wants to
able to reach the German border
displays so that my customers are
get the best out of him or herself.
in only 15 minutes by car. This is
able to experience this equipment
absolutely ideal as I travel quite
“live”. Therefore I prefer to travel by
What should never be forgotten when
a lot and I like to travel through
car. This way I am flexible, quickly at a
travelling? My mobile telephone, my
Germany for my work. Additionally,
customer’s location and have enough
laptop and my products. It is impor-
I am regularly in Switzerland at the
room in the car to pack everything I
tant for my customers that I always be
company Novasina, the producer
need. If no other means of transport
available in order to be able to quickly
of our sensors. As I am the contact
is possible, then I fly.
answer their questions.
person for all our international
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | On the road with…
37
customers, it often happens that I
How do you unwind at best? Music is
What would be the first thing you
have to travel outside of Germany.
also here my miracle drug. Together
would do if you had the unlimited
Are you able to relax after a day’s
with a good book, this is absolutely
opportunity to do so? II would
the best way to come down.
provide for the political stability
work when travelling on business?
of the entire world as I hold as my
The days are hectic and often long
Which travel destinations do you
life’s motto: The common folk, the
but luckily I am able to come down
favor and why? Germany naturally!
servant and the conqueror alike,
quickly by listening to music. When
Germany is so much larger than the
confess and affirm at all times: The
the weather is nice, mostly in the sum-
Netherlands and offers an incredible
supreme fortune of Earth’s great
mer, I really enjoy riding a motorcycle.
number of possibilities for me and my
populace is solely a person’s caliber
This gives me a wonderful feeling of
company. I am faced again and again
and character.
freedom and an unbelievable amount
with the challenges of offering the best
of energy which makes it so much
solutions to my customers and meeting
easier to cope with stress.
these challenges is for me very fulfilling.
Author: Frank Baecke
EasyMop GMP
®
Reliable cleaning and disinfecting of pharmaceutical cleanrooms
Pfennig Reinigungstechnik GmbH · Heubachstr. 1 · 87471 Durach · ✆ +49 (0) 8 31 / 5 61 22 - 0 · www.pps-pfennig.de
On the road with… | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
38
Science & Technology
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Technology News in brief
The lightest Solar Cell in the World
Pharmaceutical Products cleanly dosed without Filaments and Dripping
Organic Semiconductor | Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Tech-
Filling | For the highly precise filling
nology have developed the lightest
in the pharmaceutical industry Visco
solar cell in the world. This flexible
Tec, a specialist for the production,
photovoltaic module is 50 times thin-
dosing, application and extracting
ner than a human hair and generates
of viscous mediums, has developed
six watts per gram. This is in terms of
a solution. The prerequisite for
Pharma-Dispenser from ViscoTec doses viscous products
weight, 400 times more performance
precise dosing is that the filaments
without filaments and dripping. Photo: Visco Tec
than with conventional glass solar
are accurately and cleanly pulled
modules. Additionally, the substrate,
off. This is often not the case with
which plant manufacturers are
semiconductor and top coat no longer
viscous products such as creams,
able to hold to the specifications
have to individually be applied as with
salves or gels. These products pull
of Good Manufacturing Practice
conventional modules, but rather all
long filaments from the dosage
(GMP). These pipe connections suit
three layers ‘grow’ simultaneously by
needle into the packaging or even
themselves for stationary cleaning
vapor deposition. This happens in a
drip. The pharma- dispenser from
(also named Cleaning in Place) by
vacuum chamber at room tempera-
Visco Tec prevents dripping in that
their hygiene-minded construction.
ture. This way the otherwise required
after dosage-injection, the way to the
The flange connections are nearly
next step through the chambers in
gap-free, ruling out to the greatest
the Rotor-Stator-System is blocked
possible extent medium contact
off. Furthermore, the medium is ac-
in the area of the flange gasket.
curately pulled back into the dosage
Belonging to the product program
needle after dosing has been com-
are gaskets and stainless steel parts
pleted. An absolute, clean tear-off
which are able to withstand the high
of the filament is achieved by using
cleaning demands such as the use of
this procedure. The dispenser is also
acids, high temperatures and high
suitable for use in cleanrooms.
medium pressures. The products
The ultra-light solar cell floats even on the surface of a soap bubble. Photo: Joel Jean and Anna Oshero
intermediate treatments and cleanings can be omitted as well as the
Pipe Connections for GMP Requirements
use of solvents and harsh chemicals which with other organic solar cells
Plant Manufacturing | Machine
are needed. As the new solar cells can
and plant manufacturers which
be fixed onto any desired substrate,
work according to GMP guidelines
they could be the basis for the next
need cleanroom-suitable com-
generation of portable, wearable
ponents. Linnemann GmbH has
electronic devices.
developed pipe connections with
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Technology News in brief
Small flange connection with stainless steel centering ring and O-ring gasket. Photo: Linnemann GmbH
39 are pre-destined for the chemical, food product and pharmaceutical industries.
Production of Y-Fittings in Cleanroom Construction
Granulate Production in High ContainmentGranulate fertigen im High Containment Powder Mixture | Three-Tec GmbH has reacted to the increasing demand for a granulate production process in
Injection Molding | At the Medtec Eu-
isolated environments and together
rope Trade Fair from April 12th to the
with ART Reinraumtechnik (Clean-
14th in Stuttgart, Germany, Arburg
room Technology) has manufactured
will show in an electrical injection
an isolator with an integrated dosage
molding machine the production of
system, an extruder, a conveyor belt
Y fittings in cleanroom construction
and a granulator. The processes of
for the infusion therapy industry. A
powder-mixing on up to the finished
highlight is the lateral injection via a
granulate takes place in a protected and
beverage and cosmetics industries
needle shut off nozzle which results
controlled environment which saves
as well as in related industries.
in a higher surface quality of com-
the setting up of a complete cleanroom.
ponent parts. “The manufacturing
The built-in machines are laid out especially for working with gloves and can be easily disassembled and
Airborne Germ Collector for efficient air monitoring. Photo: MBV AG
New Product Generation of Premium Pocket Filters
cleaned by operators. The negative pressure guarantees the compliance
Fine Particle Filter | Camfil has
with GMP Cleanliness Class C speci-
brought a new generation of Premi-
fications. Even the tearing of a glove
um Pocket Filters to the market. They
prevents products from reaching
are called Hi-Flo II XL and provide
outside environments.
besides higher stability a minimum efficiency of a remarkable 54 percent
cell allows itself to be easily docked to a cleanroom. This saves time and
Micro-Biological Air Monitoring easily accomplished
at low energy consumption levels. This is according to company statements unparalleled in the industry. In the new pocket filters, the prior filter
space in comparison to manufacturing solely in a cleanroom� says
Airborne Germ Collector | MBV AG
medium has been replaced by a mate-
Sven Kitzlinger, Medical Technology
has brought to the market a new
rial which in the filter class F7 reaches
Application Consultant at Arburg.
airborne germ collector with the
the highest energy class A+ according
MAS-100 VF. What the abbreviation
to the new Eurovent Guidelines 2015.
VF indicates is that the device is controlled by volume flow (Volume
The new HI-Flo II XL filters are
Flow). The determination of col-
usable in very diverse applications.
lection volumes, the calibration
The spectrum ranges from standard
as well as the readout of collec-
building ventilation to specific in-
tion and error records is done
dustrial applications on up to pre-fil-
directly via a PC-browser without
tering systems meeting cleanroom
Europe 2016 Y-fittings for the infusion therapy industry.
prior software installation. The
standards.
Photo: Arburg
new device is predestined for
An electrical all-rounder 470 A produces at the Medtec
micro-biological air monitoring The exhibit operates via a covered
in aseptic zones, clean-rooms as
conveyor belt which docks onto the
well as for environmental meas-
cleanroom. Via the conveyor belt,
urements. The MAS-100 VF has
the clean, produced parts are trans-
been validated for ISO 14698 and
ported into the cleanroom while the
guarantees efficient monitoring of
machines and peripheral equipment
micro-biological contamination in
remain outside.
the pharmaceutical, food product,
The new filter series encompasses four models with conical-formed filter pockets of various lengths. Photo: Camfil KG
Technology News in brief | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
40
Keep It Clean
Foto: Fotolia.
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
How component part cleanliness is maintained from Production to Shipping.
Cleaning procedures decisively influence production quality but also expenditures. This is why production and shipping processes should be not just as clean as possible but as clean as necessary and as most economically designed as possible. How this can be accomplished will be shown at the trade fair ‘part2clean’ at the end of May, 2016 in Stuttgart, Germany.
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
41
Above: cleaning a satellite component. Left side: ultrasonic cleaning. Photos: Fraunhofer IPA
While walking with his dog, Klaus
Component Part Cleanliness is as Important as Dimensional Stability
automobile and supplier industries,
friendly component part cleaning
Industrial component part cleaning
practically every business and indus-
technology. As his dog was shaking
has gained increasing importance in
trial sector, companies are having
itself dry after a swim in the lake,
the last years. More and more compa-
to fulfill ever stricter demands on
Döhrer saw the solution right in
nies have taken on the opinion that
component part cleanliness” says
Döhrer came up with the idea. He had received the order to look for an energy-saving and environmentally
the medical technology industry, the aeronautics industry, precision engineering, optics or electronics – in
front of him: Vibration-Cleaning. This engineer and Managing Director of Vibro-Tec GmbH in Unna, Germany, has developed a process in which the parts to be cleaned are vibrated in such a way that oils, cooling lubricant substances and chips are slung away and vacuumed up. Innovative cleaning solutions of this kind will be standing in focus
“Even the smallest particles are able to lead to failures and defects or a fingerprint on a circuit board can cause an electrical short.” Christian Siegert, General Manager of CEC Cleaning Excellence Center Leonberg
at the international trade fair for industrial parts and surface cleaning, parts2clean. The trade fair takes
the cleanliness of component parts
Olaf Daebler, General Manager of
place from May 31st to June 2nd, 2016
and surface areas plays an equally
parts2clean at Deutschen Messe AG.
in Stuttgart, Germany.
decisive role in issues such as qual-
This is increasing expenditures for
ity, dimensional stability and the
cleaning substantially. To be on the
absence of defects. “Whether it be the
safe side, things are often dealt with
Technical Cleanliness | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
42 according to the motto: as clean as
Center Leonberg, Germany’s leading
in production processes. Robots are
possible. However, this affects profit-
competence network for industrial
able to feed the component parts into
ability and thereby competitiveness.
component parts and surface area
the cleaning and drying stations.
cleaning. “However, one approach Relief is made possible by a suitable
works mostly only for the processing
A further trend is the targeted clean-
requirements-specified, well-de-
of one, individual component group.
ing of functional surfaces. Instead of
signed cleaning solution which
The one, single solution which al-
cleaning parts completely, only the
allows the cleaning results to be
ways works unfortunately doesn’t
critical sealing or gluing surfaces are
optimized and the expenditures to
exist”.
cleaned. This saves time and money.
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
be reduced. The motto should then
Furthermore, the functional surfac-
read: as clean as possible, as econom-
When choosing an optimally suited
es can be cleaned using just-in-time
ical as possible. Which processes and
cleaning technology, materials,
concepts, whereby the costs for
procedures clean economically will
component geometry, throughput
keeping parts clean after cleaning
be shown at part2clean, as well as
and the kind of soiling (films or par-
or during transport can be omitted.
other solutions in the “Theme Park
ticulate matter) are to be considered.
Precision & Cleanrooms – Cleaning
For mass-produced parts, wet-chem-
under Cleanroom Conditions”.
ical cleaning is recommended. The
Diverse cleaning and analysis pro-
advantages are the high degree of
cesses will be presented which fulfill
throughput and the low percentage
the most demanding cleanliness
of cleaning costs in comparison to
If soiling is to be dependably and
requirements.
overall production costs. More com-
economically removed, the entire
plex parts are cleaned individually
periphery as well as the contaminant
in order to effectively reach drilled
material itself has to be considered,
holes, indentations and channels.
beginning with the cleaning chemi-
Individual part cleaning provides
cals, the manufacturing equipment,
logistical advantages when subse-
the parts-transport system and trans-
“Evolution and innovation take
quent processes require a particular
port bins, the supplied materials and
place continuously in industry”
position of the work piece. Generally,
products on up to the packaging.
observes Christian Siegert, General
the trend toward individual cleaning
Manager of CEC Cleaning Excellence
is preferred because of automation
The one Solution which always works doesn’t exist
The Periphery also influences Component Part Cleanliness
The following criteria play roles in the optimal sequencing oft he cleaning process: Which materials are to be processed? At which step in production are the parts dirtied? Does this contamination have to be immediately removed in order to rule out any adverse affects in the next processing step? Does the processing involve any auxiliary materials whose intermixture could lead to cleaning complications? Does the risk exist of parts made of differing materials causing cross-contamination? A cleaning solution can be developed coming from the answers to the above questions, which is optimized both in regards to results and costs.
The sterilization and aseptic packaging of parts often requires clean rooms and personnel. But many companies can not have the entire process chain for logistical and economic reasons. A new method of Fraunhofer IFAM can now arise molded parts sterile in the package. Photo: Fraunhofer IFAM
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Technical Cleanliness
The range of cleaning possibilities stretches from solvent cleaning in sterile rooms directly following parts
43 production to CO2-Snow-Jet Cleaning and Plasma Activation on up to Multi-bath Ultrasound Precision
Important Component Part Cleaning Processes
Cleaning in cleanrooms. In order to find the most suitable cleaning procedure, realistic tests should be carried out in the equipment manufacturer’s laboratory. Looking forward, it can be recommended to carry out cleaning after every mechanical process step in order to remove chips and cutting oils. Therefore a mixing of the differing cutting oils is prevented which can lead to more difficult cleaning issues. Especially important is the reliable elimination of films and residues from medical-technical products which are used on or inside people as particles, burrs or oil films on implants and instruments present health hazards. Cleaning costs can be reduced when component parts and component groups are designed to be easily cleaned.
When the Cleaning Facility becomes a Material Lock A time-saving possibility to bring parts which have been milled or lathed or parts produced by injection
Wet Chemical Cleaning | The most often used technology in the industry is the cleaning with liquid mediums and solvents. The latter is roughly differentiated into halogenated hydrocarbons (CHC) and polarized solvents. The cleaning results are determined by the choice taken by the person doing the cleaning. In order to obtain the desired result in a short time, the effects of the cleaning medium, in all cleaning procedures, are supported by diverse strongly-acting physical processing technology. Typical processes are injection, immersion, pressure flooding and ultrasound. Plasma Cleaning | The plasma procedure provides with the use of various reaction gases a wide spectrum of applications with piece and bulk goods of every kind made of synthetic materials, metals, glass and ceramic. This procedure improves the adhesion of glues and coatings. Moreover it makes possible the generation of the so-called Easy-to-Clean surfaces such as the surfaces which protect the parts from contamination during production. Plasma procedures are relevant prior to coil coating in the medical technology sector, the electronics, optics and the micro-systems technology sectors. CO2-Snow Blasting | With this technology, fluid CO2 together with pressurized air is accelerated through jet nozzles at supersonic velocity. The CO2 snow removes oil and particle contamination, dry and without leaving behind any residues from practically all materials. This procedure suits itself also for the targeted treatment of function-surfaces such as seal, coating, glue and laser-welding surfaces. With dry-ice blasting, small ice pellets are used instead of fluid CO2. This procedure suits itself for the cleaning of forms, tools and machines. Super critical carbon dioxide uses the physical properties between the fluid and gas-forming phases. In this condition, CO2 has very small viscosity. Therefore, oils and fats can be removed even from the tiniest gaps and cracks.
molding into a cleanroom sterile and particle-free, is to implement a grey-room. The cleaning facility then
Cleaning Excellence Center Leonberg
orders. Included here is the contin-
acts as a material lock. Parts can be
says, “In the automobile industry the
ued education and training. What do
brought into the grey-room from the
development in motor technology
employees need? Is it enough to have
production facility and after clean-
has in recent years led to higher
only a sterile room? Which cleaning
ing be taken out on the cleanroom
and higher demands in technical
procedures suit the product? In this
side to be checked and processed.
cleanliness. Even the tiniest particles
respect, the trade fair Cleanzone
Afterwards, the parts can be packed
can lead to failures and defects or a
(November 8-9, 2016, Frankfurt am
under cleanroom conditions and
fingerprint on a circuit board can
Main, Germany) is an ideal place for
now protected from contamination
cause an electrical short.”
industry players to meet. “Visitors
be stored and shipped.
are able to comprehensively inform This is why it is so important to
themselves about new developments
Beyond all the technical solutions,
anchor into the minds of employees
and come into direct contact with
there lies yet another factor which
the awareness of the importance of
manufacturers“, says Siegert.
influences component part cleanli-
technical cleanliness for the entire
ness: employee awareness. Christian
process from purchasing to produc-
Siegert, General Manager of CEC
tion on up to the receipt of customer
Author: Frank Baecke
Technical Cleanliness | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
44
New Surfaces for Cleanroom Technology An innovative synthetic film makes it possible to design totally new cleanroom work places. CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
Photo: Senoplast Klepsch & Co GmbH
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Among the finalists for the Clean足 room Award 2015 was Senoplast Klepsch & Co. GmbH in Austria. The company develops using Senomed a chemically resistant, scrub resistant and anti-bacterial film for surfaces in cleanrooms and air locks. The film has the potential to replace existing materials.
45
Doubly protected in cleanrooms as well as with entrance-safety and visually-dense facades: Senoplast synthetic film production in Piesendorf, Austria. Photo: Senoplast Klepsch & Co. GmbH
The high barbed-wire fence around
expand with its innovative prod-
In Piesendorf synthetic films from
the factory premises gave it away:
ucts into diverse market niches.
then on were to be produced on an
Something unique is being pro-
Operations are running at full
assembly line in a cleanroom.
duced here. With the military-like
capacity in the factory round the
border, Senoplast Klepsch & Co.
clock which produces in four shifts.
GmbH in Piesendorf, Austria is
Two cleanroom production lines
protecting its most innovative
are already in operation and a third
product from the curiousity of its
is in the planning.
Thanks to Cleanroom Production the Percentage of Rejects fell by Two Percent
with an extremely scratch resistant
Senoplast did without cleanrooms
The clean production environ-
and chemically resistant systhetic
for decades. As a producer of plas-
ment was expected to solve
film which disinfects itself. There
tics in the distribution segment,
two problems. The first
is nothing comparable to it in the
the company offered customers
concerned the rate of
world.
a standard range of products for
rejects which was
industry, supplied Thermoplast
in some years over
mass-made products for various
20 percent due to
industry segments in film and
the uncontrolled
panel formats. However as the
environmental influ-
financial and economical crisis in
ences. “The high rate
2008 involved important customer
of rejects raised the risk
industries, the time had come in
of customer claims” says
which to re-orient away from mass
Marco Grugger, responsible for
production to more demanding,
the process equipment in the Seno-
Auswirkung Auswirkung unkontrollierter unkontrollierter Umgebungseinflüsse Umgebungseinflüsse
10 10 5 0
15 15
10 10
20 20 5
25 25
5
30 30
0 Ausschussrate Ausschussrate ohneohne Reinraumproduktion: Reinraumproduktion: mehrmehr als als
20 % 20 %
0
15 15
5
20 20 25 25 30 30
0
Ausschussrate Ausschussrate nachnach Beginn Beginn der Reinraumproduktion: der Reinraumproduktion: unterunter
2 %2 %
Quelle: Quelle: Senoplast Senoplast Klepsch Klepsch & Co.&GmbH Co. GmbH
specialized products. To realize this
plast Group. “The profitability just
Senoplast produces – unusual for
change in strategy, a cleanroom
wasn’t happening.” With the start
a plastics manufacturer – in clean-
was to be installed in production.
of production in a cleanroom, the
rooms. As the market segment for
When the first experiment began
percentage of rejects fell rapidly to
synthetic films and panels is not
in 2006 during the crisis, it was de-
under two percent.
standard, the company is able to
clared as a strategic company goal:
Surfaces of the Future | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
Photo: Fotolia
competitors. The product deals
46 The second concerned the rise in product quality. Step by step the developers succeeded in improving product properties. “The production environment and the process had to be completely re-designed” says Operations Manager Ernst Rattensperger. Although the cleanroom had been custom made, the process didn’t run smoothly at the beginning. The base material which
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
is transported into the extruder is indeed a mixture of standard plastics however the catch didn’t reside with the raw materials but with the processing.
The molecular Manipulation of the Surfaces hardens the Synthetic Material
Hospitals and Laboratories can easily use the new film. Foto: sudok1/Fotolia
Senoplast is now fulfilling the
molecular chemistry, medical tech-
The 200 degree base material glides
quality demands of many former
nology, IT, optics and mechanics.
along a 1.40 meter wide and 20 meter
customers and even surpasses these
Special surfaces play here an im-
long machine. At a particular posi-
demands. The company produces
portant role, not only because they
tion the surface is molecularly ma-
in such a high quality that it is able
are essential for the aesthetics of
nipulated and as a result becomes
to open and extremely demanding
the facility but also because they
harder and more stabile. How this
markets.
take over a variety of tasks acting
works and which material is applied
as a covering for installations, wall
is a company secret.
systems and process surfaces.
It is no secret however that the process demands extremely strict
Suitable for all Particlefree and Micro-biological Clean Environments
control of the environmental con-
For example, hospitals use the material for extensions and interior furnishings and equipment such
ditions. Heat and air flow have to
Since Senomed-Film 2014/2015 en-
as doors, cupboards, wall systems
be controlled and regulated. If the
tered the market, the Austrian fam-
and beds. Research institutes use
temperature changes only a half of
ily company has captured the notice
it for lab furniture, lab cupboards
a degree, no high-gloss, high-tech
of all those industries which need
and walls. Even food product man-
base material will emerge but a
particle-free and micro-biologically
ufacturers are considered as users
material which hurls bubbles.
clean environmental conditions:
for the unique material.
After years of collecting experience
Phamaceutical industry, biology,
“The film is scrub-resistant, even steel wool leaves behind no scratches. Where no scratches are found, fewer germs are able to settle in.”
Easy to clean, to disinfect and to sterilize That the synthetic material suits itself to be used in aseptic, that is in germ-free environments is due to its properties above all on one: The material’s surface possesses a very high degree of hardness. This makes it scrub-resistant in fact
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Surfaces of the Future
47 steel wool leaves behind no scratches. Where no scratches are formed, fewer germs (colony forming units – CFU) are able to settle in. Additionally: Thanks to its extremely smooth surface, the product is easily cleaned, disinfected and even sterilized with standard materials
These are the Advantages of Senomed Synthetic Film Cleanroom Suitability: The film has passed all relevant tests and is approved for cleanrooms classified with ISO Classes 1 to 9 as well as for cleanrooms with GMP classification A to D.
and when absolutely necessary with acids or alkaline solutions. The latter have no effect on the material. Such radical cleaning is
Diverse Properties: The films are scratch and scrub-resistant, chemically resistant, anti-bacterial effective, color-stable and emissions-free. The chemical tolerance refers to acetic acid, hydrogen peroxide, sulfuric acid, hydrochloric acid, acetonitrile, methanol, isopropanol, and many more.
not often necessary as the surface neutralizes itself as tests with the most prevalent germs have shown. Testers took contact samples from contaminated surfaces in certified labs at defined time periods. The samples confirmed the microbiological properties: After less than 180 minutes, microbiological activity was no longer detectable.
Easy to work with: The film can be applied to any stable and smooth sub-surface. The synthetic substrate combination can easily be drilled, screwed and re-worked. After installation, polishing is seldom necessary as is the use of solvents. Color Diversity: The synthetic is currently available from the factory in 50 colors and diverse metallic versions. New colors are always technically conceivable, which in contrast to other base materials, is not expensive. Thanks to its high quality color optic, the synthetic film will find a market even in aesthetically demanding home environments.
The Film gives off neither Vapors nor Particles
Problem-free Integration: High-tech components with specialized functions can easily be integrated with the synthetic surfaces.
The material is also emissions-neu-
Interesting Cost Advantages: The wall systems compared with hitherto existing cleanroom materials are very cost-efficient including investment expenditures and operation/maintenance costs.
tral: It neither gives off vapors nor particles. On top of that the synthetic material is so stable that only heat and extreme physical impact
is able to destroy it. In a nutshell, the new material offers the positive characteristics of glass, ceramic or metal without giving up any of its synthetic advantages. With this many-sided product the Austrian company has unlocked a niche which is unique in the world. The innovative synthetic surfaces suit themselves above all for the use in aseptic areas. They are also suitable for making work places more pleasant thanks to their diverse properties for color design and configuration. When Previously in a Blue Man (Boiler suit), today in overalls: Factory employees keep to strict hygiene and work behavior requirements. Photo: Senoplast Klepsch & Co. GmbH
correctly configured, colors increase employee concentration,
Surfaces of the Future | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
48 prevent accidents, improve safety and reduce the number of sick days (Cleanroom Magazine reported on the effects of color and design in cleanrooms in the issue 03/2015).
Even Less Comples Films are gaining in Quality in Cleanrooms
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Even today, Senoplast is preparing a major budget for research and development, is cooperating with universities and has a particularly distinctive product range. Its pro-
Process control in the clean room: The film running in the endless process from tape. Photo: Senoplast Klepsch & Co. GmbH
prietary manufacturing systems engineering was responsible for
inter-disciplinary know-how of
without it, especially since random
the construction of the clean-
systems engineering, chemistry,
tests have shown that many less
room-technical processing facility,
physics and process technology.
complex synthetic films gain in
even the palettes for transport to
Therefore Senoplast has succeeded
quality when they are produced in
the interim storage are of its own
to make the cleanroom the com-
a cleanroom.
design and construction. The
pany’s focal point. The company’s
development team possesses an
bosses never again want to do
PT16_175x125_CLEANROOM_MAGAZIN_C4_PHARMA.indd 1
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Surfaces of the Future
Author: Professor Gernod Dittel
14.12.15 13:40
49
CLEANROOM AWARD 2016 INNOVATION, SUSTAINABILITY & EFFICIENCY IN THE CLEANROOM
APPLY NOW! DEADLINE 31st AUGUST 2016 winners presentation at the cleanzone
9 th NOVEMBER 2016
CREATIVE PRIZE 2016 CREATIVITY & BEAUTY IN THE CLEANROOM
APPLY NOW! DEADLINE 31st AUGUST 2016 winners presentation at the cleanzone
9 th NOVEMBER 2016 more informations:
more impressions: CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
50
What do you do there, Birgit Kriegesmann?
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Brief profiles of the cleanroom industry
Birgit Kriegesmann works as a Biological-Technical Assistent at Bremer Pharma GmbH in Warburg, Germany and conducts in the context of microbiological monitoring, airborne germ measurements in sterile-filling cleanrooms. Photo: Bremer Pharma GmbH.
My name is Birgit Kriegesmann.
cleanroom conditions. My tasks in-
in production materials and WFI,
Regarding my profession, I am a
volve monitoring the microbiological
the production and testing of
Biological-Technical Assistent.
issues in the production processes.
growth media, the administration
Since 1999, I have been working
I conduct airborne germ measure-
of culture collections as well as
at Bremer Pharma GmbH in War-
ments in the framework of environ-
the measurement instrument
burg, Germany, in the department
mental monitoring with air samplers
qualification and calibration in
responsible for the microbiological
and sedimentation plates. I also
the microbiological laboratory and
quality control. Bremer Pharma
check surface areas and cleanroom
the validation of microbiological
GmbH is a middle-size company
personnel with direct contact tests
methods.
in the pharmaceutical industry
and afterwards evaluate the growing
and specializes in the production
medium results. Furthermore I am
In 2003, I became qualified as the
of pharmaceutical products both
responsible for the sampling and the
Hygiene Officer and conduct in
in fluid and powder form. These
testing of the water used for injection
this context training courses and
products are for the export and
purposes and for the Aqua purificata
workshops for company employees
domestic markets.
(PW) of the company.
regarding this topic of hygiene.
Sterile and aseptic parenterals have
Additionally, I am responsible for
* sterile preparations which are designated for injection,
to be produced under strictly defined
the testing of bacterial endotoxins
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | What do you do there, ‌ ?
infusion or implantation in humans or animals. ** Water for Injection
51
! k r a t s t h c a m n le ie p S Jedes Kind hat das Recht auf Spiel. Spielen und Sport treiben sind für eine gesunde Entwicklung von Kindern unerlässlich. Doch für Millionen Jungen und Mädchen, die in Armenvierteln oder auf der Straße leben, ist dies nicht selbstverständlich. terre des hommes schafft für diese Kinder Gelegenheiten zu Spiel und Sport. So lernen sie, Konflikte gewaltfrei zu lösen und entwickeln Stärken, die ihnen für ihr ganzes Leben nützen. Bitte unterstützen Sie unsere Arbeit – mit Ihrer Spende! Weitere Informationen unter Telefon 0541/7101-128
terre des hommes Hilfe für Kinder in Not Ruppenkampstraße 11a 49084 Osnabrück spenden@tdh.de
Spendenkonto 700 800 700 Volksbank Osnabrück eG BLZ 265 900 25 IBAN DE20 2659 0025 0700 8007 00 BIC GENODEF1OSV
www.tdh.de/spielen
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
52
What it’s about.
SERVICE
ISO, VDI, GMP – it’s all written down. Why don’t we then have the perfect cleanroom?
The regulations for cleanroom technology neither contain planning details for a turn-key cleanroom concept nor exact requirements for practical operations. They more describe the requirements of safe cleanroom operation and are to be taken as a code of practice for correct implementation.
applies only for the air” emphasizes Frank Duvernell. “When you measure the particle concentration of your cleanroom, than you still don’t know what is lying on your surface areas.” Therefore clean-
“Rules guide the wise man. The
the appropriate materials.” Such
room operators should not rely on
idiot obeys them” said Oscar Wilde.
statements leave a lot of room for
air quality measurements.
This Irish writer’s aphorism could be flatly coined for the cleanroom industry, even though Wilde – who
“The regulations are only recommendations. You will never find anything concrete for your situation – it always depends.”
passed away in 1900 – didn’t knew about cleanrooms. Nevertheless his quote is applicable because the regulations for cleanroom technology often only have contents which guide instead of convenient, easy to follow instruc-
Frank Duvernell, Managing Director profi-con GmbH Contamination Control
tions. Those who read the rules and regulations quickly notices that a lot of content is not specified to the smallest detail but requires the
interpretation. It could also be said
In order to determine surface
wisdom of the cleanroom-practicing
in another way: The regulations
contamination, contact tests are a
man.
contain too many standards. It is not
tried and tested method. With this
specified for example, how often a
method, flat plastic dishes with a
Frank Duvernell, Managing Di-
cleanroom is to be cleaned or how
nutrient medium are pressed onto
rector of the cleanroom cleaning
often employees should be trained.
objects and surfaces to collect any
specialist profi-con GmbH Con-
“When I ask professionals about
micro-organisms possibly present.
tamination Control in Leipzig,
this, they always say: It depends.”
Afterwards the dishes are incubat-
Germany, can shout out loud in this
ed. “After two days I know then if
respect. “What actually stands in
something is growing. After five
the ISO and GMP regulations?” he asks. “For example,: The cleanroom
The Weaknesses of the Measuring Methods
days, I know what it is and how much” says Frank Duvernell. The long incubation time is not the
should be regularly cleaned with But what does it depend on? - Above
only disadvantage with this meth-
all on a risk analysis. The basis for
od. The method is only a random
this analysis is given in the ISO
measurement and cannot be com-
tables with air cleanliness class-
prehensively applied.
es from 9 to 1. “This Regularium
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Laws and Regulations
53 The VDI contains a lot, but not everything
of ceilings, walls and floors with
Managing Director. Frequently, the
mops can be done. “Something like
purchasing department decides
this isn’t found in the regulations”
which devices are to be used.
Written down are the particular
explains Duvernell. “It only states
requirements for the cleanliness of
which cleanliness standard has to
Even trickier are the cleaning
the air, work places, surfaces and
be achieved.”
towels. There is a tremendous se-
the personnel in the VDI Guidelines
lection but worldwide, not a single
Series 2083 “Cleanroom Equipment”.
The same applies for cleaning ma-
binding testing procedure. “Every
These guidelines contain a broad
terials. “Where does is state in the
manufacturer can write on his
spectrum of things which are
regulations which cleaning mate-
towel ISO 8/ lint-free” says Frank
allowed in cleanrooms and which
rials are to be used” asks Duvernell.
Duvernell. But what does lint-free
are not allowed, but even though,
“There isn’t anything, worldwide
mean? How much is allowed to
not everything explains Duvernell.
nothing.” In the regulations, it
come out of the towel, in which
“It is fully understandable for ex-
is not specified if isopropanol or
time period, on which surfaces?
ample that cardboard has no place
ethanol should be used. This is
There are no clear statements
in a cleanroom – but where is this
purely a question of the cleanroom
written in the regulations. “It isn’t
written?”
operator’s or cleaning company’s
even written down which towel
experience.
you should choose. This namely
The profi-con Managing Director further points out that with the
depends on…” A further example is disinfection with hydrogen peroxide. For its use,
Even when choosing cleanroom
according to the regulations, no face
personnel, there are no detailed
mask is necessary up to a six percent
guidelines in the regulations. “The
concentration. “But in practice, a
guideline VDI 2083 Page 15 indeed
cleaning operator gets red eyes after
encompasses cleanroom related
20 minutes with this concentration”
requirements for personnel and
indicates Frank Duvernell. “In other
their clothing, however if jewelry
words: What works and what doesn’t
is allowed in the cleanroom, this
work, you have to try it out – it
isn’t stated” says Frank Duvernell.
depends.”
He gives this advice: “Determine for yourself the criteria which are
profi-con CEO Frank Duvernell. Photo: Cleanroom Media
most appropriate for your clean-
Trying out comes before studying the regulations
room and for your personnel and which bring the best results. The regulations are only recommenda-
This is also the case with cleaning
tions. You will never find anything
thorough cleaning of a cleanroom, it
materials. Nowhere is it written
concrete for your situation – it
is sensible that all fire alarms, sprin-
which device should be used. This
always depends.”
klers, ventilators and so on, have
means only that the devices have to
to be cleaned before the cleaning
be appropriate reports the profi-con
Author: Frank Baecke
Seit 12 Jahren Kompetenz für generative Technologien
14. – 16. Juni 2016, Messe Erfurt • Fachmesse und Kongress
Rapid.Tech
• Anwendertagung „Neue Technologien“
International Trade Show & Conference for Additive Manufacturing
• Fachforen Wissenschaft, Medizintechnik, Luftfahrt und Werkzeuge
www.rapidtech.de
Titelmotiv: Bremspedal, EOS/Materialise Foto: Andreas Stedtler
Laws and Regulations | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
54
What Cleanroom Technology is revolutionizing
Photo: Nils Brรถer
SERVICE
Until August 31th, 2016, innovation highlights for the Cleanroom Award and the Creative Prize can be submitted.
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Cleanroom Award and Creative Prize
55 “These robots will revolutionize cleanroom technology” was the opinion of Cleanzone’s audience and went on to choose the air filter monitoring system RobotScan from the company Infrasolution AG as the winner. However: Following the award an award is waiting! The ReinraumAkademie immediately started accepting applications for the Cleanroom Award and the Creative Prize 2016.
in Frankfurt am Main, Germany. It
the Creative Prize was awarded
was a very good idea to have applied
for the first time in 2015. “In many
for the Award and at the same
companies the tea kitchen is better
time be an exhibitor at Cleanzone.
equipped than the cleanroom”, says
“We will once again be here next
Duvernell. Researchers have long
year – with still a better product”
since proven that colored work
exclaimed Itter to the fair’s visitors
environments help to increase
in the Cleanzone Plaza.
the well-being of employees and therefore also product quality. The
Following tradition, the winner
Creative Prize honors companies
from the previous year presented
which are already taking these
the Award. Yvonne Weis Marketing
factors into consideration.
“We are extremely delighted to
Manager and Representative for
have received this award” said
Initial said during the Award pres-
Infrasolutions Managing Director
entation to Mathias Itter: “It was
Mathias Itter at the Cleanroom
really great for us to have won the
Award ceremony 2015 at Cleanzone
Cleanroom Award. Afterwards we received so many customer inquiries for our Cleanvision Cleanroom Suit that we had to turn down some inquiries because we were just getting too many.” MED-EL from Austria won the Creative Prize 2015.
Frank Duvernell Managing Di-
Photo: Cleanroom Media
rector of the ReinraumAkademie and founder of the Cleanroom
Applications for the Creative Prize
Awards emphasizes: “With this
and the Cleanroom Award can be
award, we want to bring out new
submitted to the ReinraumAkade-
ideas which are important for the
mie until August 31, 2016.
Infra Solution won the Cleanroom Award 2015, presented
industry to the general public.” To
by Frank Duvernell (right). Photo: Cleanroom Media
additionally serve this purpose,
Author: Frank Baecke
Applications for the Cleanroom Award and the Creative Prize 2016 What ideas are being looked for? All interesting ideas regarding the topics of innovation, sustainability and energy efficiency in cleanrooms can be submitted. They should differ from conventional ideas and processes and present more than just a marginal improvement to existing products or services. The concepts have to be thoroughly worked out and cannot be fragmentally submitted.
Until when can applications be submitted? Submission deadline for applications is August 31, 2016. Valid for participation are companies, institutions, scientific facilities and individual persons. Where can applications be sent? Please send applications for the Cleanroom Award 2016 and the Creative Prize 2016 to the following address:
ReinraumAkademie GmbH Kennwort (Code word) “Cleanroom Award”/ or “Creative Prize” Rosa-Luxemburg-Str. 12-14 04103 Leipzig Tel.: +49 341 98989 302 E-Mail: info@reinraum-akademie.de Web: www.reinraum-akademie.de
Cleanroom Award and Creative Prize | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
56 The Cleanroom Award
The Creative Prize
Awarded will be ideas related to
Awarded will be the most optically
the innovation, sustainability or
and ergonomically creatively de-
energy efficiency in cleanrooms.
signed cleanroom.
Wanted are concepts, products, or
Wanted are concepts and ideas
Also in 2016 the most creative designed cleanroom will
services which distinguish them-
which eliminate the “white noise”
get an award. The Creative Prize will be every year fresh
selves as trailblazing solutions or
in cleanrooms by using colors, by
are influential in changing the
implementing processes and by
industry.
using colored edges.
created by an artist. Photo: Daniel Read, Cleanroom Media
Creative cleanroom planning not
SERVICE
only relates to the walls but also An expert jury chooses five finalists
Additionally, applications are
the overalls worn by employees
from the total number of applica-
welcome showing concepts which
could be color-coded according to
tions. These five finalists then pres-
use colors to indicate orientation
department or function.
ent their projects at Cleanzone on
and information for example to
November 8 – 9, 2016, in Frankfurt
optically separate adjoining areas.
Author: Frank Baecke
am Main, Germany. Which of the five finalists wins the ReinraumAkademie’s 3000 Euro Cleanroom Award prize is determined by Cleanzone’s visitors by ballot.
The Creative Prize was awarded in 2015 for the first time and designed by the Swiss artist Beat Toniolo. Photo: Messe Frankfurt Exhibition GmbH, Sandra Gätke
All Previous Winners of the Cleanroom Award 2012: APMON The Dutch company Technology of Sense won in 2012 with APMON the very first Cleanroom Award. This measurement instrument monitors all particles in a room which could fall onto products and sounds an alarm when safety limits have been exceeded. 2013: BLAUTOUCH The Portuguese company Laborial S.A. developed with Blautouch a
laboratory table with an interactive surface for GMP cleanrooms. The Touchsystem has been installed under a glass surface and makes possible the use of computers which have been placed outside of the room. 2014: CleanVision Cleanroom-Suit The CleanVision Cleanroom-Suit from the company Textil Service GmbH is a one-piece suit with an integrated hood and an integrated visor. The
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Cleanroom Award and Creative Prize
closed design predestines itself for the use in sterile environments. 2015: RobotScan Flex The German company InfraSolutions AG developed with RobotScan Flex a solution for robot-supported air filter monitoring. The measurements are able to be done with fewer personnel and with much more precision and speed than by hand.
Cleanroom Knowledge to glean The editorial office of Cleanroom Magazin regularly scans new publications which are relevant to the cleanroom. These books – newly published – we would like to present.
EU Guide to Good Manufacturing Practice for Medicinal Products for Human and Veterinary Use Concerning the development, manufacture and monitoring of pharmaceutical products, not only the high quality standards are presented, but also the numerous legal guidelines and requirements to be fulfilled. The expanded new edition of the English edition of the EU Guide offers the latest legislative text up to October, 2015. The book contains the three main parts, Part 1 Basic Requirements for Medicinal Products for Human and Veterinary Use, Part II Basic Requirements for Active Substances used as Starting Materials, and Part III GMP Related Documents as well as the Annex 1 to 19. “EU Guide to Good Manufacturing Practice for Medicinal Products for Human and Veterinary Use”, G. Auterhoff and S. Throm, ECV Editio Cantor Publisher, 8, updated and expanded edition 2016, 325 pages, Brochure. ISBN 13:978-3-87193-431-5. Price: 72.76 Euros.
Project Management Cleanroom Technology
Master every challenge by using our services.
Process Management Qualification
Benefit from our 360° Pharma Consulting to gain more efficiency, safety and quality. independent · transparent · sustainable Visit us at LOUNGES 2016 · booth K3.8
Quality Management
Validation Computer System Validation
www.avantalion.de
New reference books on the market | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
57
58
14.–17.11.2016 Medica/Compamed Düsseldorf Germany
Graphic: Fotolia
SERVICE
Trade Fairs and Congresses
08.–09.11.2016 Cleanzone Frankfurt Germany
Berlin
Germany Leipzig Düsseldorf Frankfurt a. Main
12.–14.04.2016 MedTec Europe Stuttgart Germany
Nürnberg
Stuttgart München
20.-23.09.2016 ILMAC Basel Switzerland
Basel Wangen an der Aare
Switzerland Lausanne
13.-14.04.2016 LabInnovations Lausanne Switzerland
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Trade Fairs and Congresses
19.–21.04.2016 Powtech mit Partec Nürnberg Germany 10.-13.05.2016 analytica 2016 München Germany 31.05.–02.06.2016 parts 2 clean Stuttgart Germany 21.-23.04.2016 Cleanroom Exhibition & Biotech Euroasia Istanbul Turkey
59
Events at the ReinraumAkademie, Germany and the CleanroomAcademy, Switzerland Reinraum-Expertentage | Cleanroom Experts Days 11.-12.05.2016 | Flexible Cleanroom Design | Leipzig, Germany 07.-08.06.2016 | Cleanroom: Layout, Planning and Construction | Wangen an der Aare, Switzerland 28.-29.09.2016 | Flexible Cleanroom Design and Integration of Production Facilities, Equipment and Furnishings in Cleanrooms | Wangen an der Aare, Switzerland 05.-06.10.2016 | Fundamentals and Optimization in Cleanroom Operations, Cleanroom and Qualification | Leipzig, Germany 23.-24.11.2016 | Optimal Cleanroom Personnel | Leipzig, German 07.-08.12.2016 | Optimization and Qualification of Cleanroom Operations | Wangen an der Aare, Switzerland
BEHAVIOR IN A CLEANROOM 11.04.2016 | One-Day Training Plus | Penzberg, Germany 27.09.2016 | One-Day Training Plus | Wangen an der Aare, Switzerland 02.11.2016 | One-Day Training Plus | Leipzig, Germany
BASICS OF PROFESSIONAL CLEANROOM CLEANING 17.-18.10.2016 | Two-Day-Seminar | Leipzig, Germany
ADDITIONAL EVENTS 28.09.2016 | Swiss Cleanroom Industry’s Autumnal Reception | Wangen an der Aare, Switzerland 05.10.2016 | Cleanroom Industry’s Autumnal Reception | Leipzig, Germany The events are at: Cleanroom Experience Competence Center Rosa-Luxemburg-Str. 12-14, D-04103 Leipzig Tel.: +49 341 98989-0, Fax: +49 341 98989-200 info@reinraum-akademie.de, www.reinraum-akademie.de
Cleanroom Experience Competence Center Vorstadt 4, CH-3380 Wangen an der Aare Tel.: +41 326316050, Fax: +41 326316059 info@reinraum-akademie.de, www.cleanroom-academy.ch
SwissCCS SYMPOSIUM & General Assembly (GA) 2016 20. April 2016 08:30 - 09:00 | registration / coffee & cake 09:00 - 10:00 | General Assembly SwissCCS (SRRT) 10:00 - 17:00 | Symposium NEWS: ISO, VDI, CEN NEWS: SwissCCS Experts groups: Engineering, microbiology / qualification and operation / behavior in the cleanroom.
After that Symposium with: "Requirements for purest high-tech packaging" 17:00 - 20:00 | Net-working with Apéro ( r.s.v.p.) Cleanroom Experience Competence Centre Schweiz c/o CleanroomAcademy GmbH Vorstadt 4, 3380 Wangen an der Aare
Events | CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016
60
Order your free subscription
www.cleanroom-media.com
A DV ER TIS ING R ATE S / 2 016
Next issue | Juli, 2016 1/2013
2/2013
2/2014
Cleanroom Award
SERVICE
Monitoring fallender Partikel Monitoring Particle Deposition
Cleanzone
Paris
Attraktives Reiseziel für Technologen Popular destination for technologists
Die Reinraumwelt trifft sich in Frankfurt / The World of cleanroom meets in Frankfurt
Barbara Kanegsberg
Sieglinde Sellemond
Genuss, Kunst und Kultur Indulgence, art and culture
Das Produkt steht im Mittelpunkt / The focus on the product
Dresden
Attraktives Reiseziel für Technologen Popular destination for technologists
Jan Gerbrands Motivation und Leidenschaft Motivation and Passion
Cleanroom Award – Herausforderung an die Branche
Cleanroom Award – Fortschritt für den Reinraum Cleanroom Award – Advancement for the Cleanroom
Cleanroom Award – Challenging the branch
EDITION 1/2014
Keime im Essen Wie die Reinraumtechnik gefährlichen Lebensmittelkeimen den Garaus macht Wenn Milliarden von Geräten dank winzigster Bauteile aus dem Reinraum miteinander kommunizieren
So schätzen Experten die Aussichten der Reinraumbranche ein
Recht und Regularien
Wie Mitarbeiter zu Reinraummitarbeitern werden
Hochspannung im Reinraum
Talententwicklung Ausblick 2016
Der 3D-Druck eröffnet dem Reinraum neue Perspektiven
Internet der Dinge
Vorstoß in die dritte Dimension Approaching the Dimension 3D printing is opening new perspectives for cleanrooms
Experts estimate future prospects in the cleanroom industry How employees become cleanroom operatives
Life & Science Informationen für die Reinraumtechnologie
Life & Science Informationen für die Reinraumtechnologie
CLEANROOM
MAGAZIN
CLEANROOM
2016
Winter
01
2015
Herbst
04
So sieht der Chirurgen-Arbeitsplatz der nächsten Generation aus
Operationssaal der Zukunft
Mitdenkende Stoffe verändern Medizin, Architektur, Mode und Autoindustrie
Smarte Textilien
Wie die Vision vom autonomen Fahren mit Produkten aus dem Reinraum Wirklichkeit wird
Freude am Gefahrenwerden
ISSN 2364-0405
Regularien Lästige Pflicht OLEDs Die Lichtrevol Krankenhaus Wie Raumtec So nehmen Pol Einfluss auf Ih
Blüh Gefä Kont Life & Science Informationen für die Reinraumt
Sommer 2015
03
Manager Cleanroom Media und Conception Magazine Maja Franke Tel. +49 341 98989 404 maja.franke@cleanroom-media.com Chief Editor Frank Baecke Tel. +49 341 98989 405 frank.baecke@cleanroom-media.com
02
Managing director Frank Duvernell, V.i.S.d.P.
Never stop thinking
How does the desire to have children correlate with cleanrooms?
Newest revisions of ISO 14644-1 and ISO 14644-2
2016
EDITION 4/2015
In-Vitro-Fertilisation
Laws & Regulations
Frühjahr
This is what the surgery workstation of the future looks like
Cleanzone 2015 This international cleanroom trade fair gives momentum and impulse to the cleanroom industry
Throw out the sparks and protect sensitive products
Talent Development
MAGAZIN
Operating Theatre
High Voltage in the Cleanroom
Outlook 2016
Life & Science Informationen für die Reinraumtechnologie
Smart Textiles
CLEANROOM
0 3 | S O M M E R 2 015
02
spring 2016
Life & Science Information for Cleanroom Technology
Life & Science Information for Cleanroom Technology
Germs in Food Products How cleanroom technology aids in killing off dangerous food product germs
Intelligent fabric changes medicine, architecture, fashion and the car industry
CLEANROOM MAGAZINE 2/2016 | Imprint
MAGAZINE
Damit kein Funke überspringt sensible Produkte schützen
C LE AN R O O M M AG AZ I N
Das bringt die Neufassung der Norm ISO 14644-1 und 14644-2
How the vision of autonomous driving is gradually becoming a reality
Internet www.cleanroom-media.com
more informations
CLEANROOM
01
winter 2016
MAGAZINE
Thanks to the tiny components produced in cleanrooms, billions of devices are able to communicate with each other
Imprint CLEANROM MAGAZINE Is issued and published by Cleanroom Media GmbH Rosa-Luxemburg-Straße 12-14 04103 Leipzig Germany
free subscription
CLEANROOM
The Internet of Things
Joy of Being Driven
EDITION 3/2015
04
autumn 2015
Künstliche Befruchtung
09.07.15 12:53
Cleanzone 2015 Die internationale Reinraummesse wird zum Impulsgeber der Branche
EDITION 2/2015
MAGAZINE
Was hat der Kinderwunsch mit Reinräumen zu tun?
Umschlag_2015-03_5mmRuecken_005.indd 1
Rules & regulations Annoying agree or a tip for money values? OLEDs The lighting revolution out of the cleanroom Hospital germs How cleanroom technologies prevent infections
summer 2015
Life & Science Information for Cleanroom Technology
C LE AN R O O M M AG AZ I N
The influence of pollen and air humidity on your production
0 3 | S O M M E R 2 015
Blossoming Nature Dangerous Contamination
CLEANROOM
03
02
spring 2015
Life & Science Information for Cleanroom Technology
07.12.15 16:38
MAGAZINE
15.03.16 14:05
CLEANROOM
EDITION 1/2015
EDITION 2/2014
Never stop thinking
EDITION 2/2013
Cleanroom Award und Creative Prize 2016
EDITION 1/2013
2015-12-07_Ducklayout_Cover_mit_Schutzlack_CMYK.indd 1
Tirol – High tech in mountain paradise
2016-03-15_Ducklayout_Cover_mit_Schutzlack_CMYK.indd 1
Tirol – Hightech im Bergparadies
EDITION 1/2016
Cleanroom Award & Creative Prize 2016
EDITION 2/2016
Translation Bill Hillman
Circulation 10,000 copies
Authors Frank Baecke Prof. Gernod Dittel Frank Duvernell Claudia Pachl
Printer Löhnert-Druck, Leipzig
Advertisements/Notifications Maja Franke Tel. +49 341 98989 404 maja.franke@cleanroom-media.com Infographics Daniel Read, Cleanroom Media Implementation Wohlfahrt GmbH www.wohlfahrt.net Publication Quarterly
ISSN 2364-0405 Reprints Reproduction and digital use of articles from this magazine, even partially, are only allowed subject to prior approval by the editorial staff. No liability is assumed for unsolicited manuscripts of photographs.
MAG
CLEANRO