85644981

Page 1

PEDIATRIC DENTISTRY

llinic al Article

V 3 5 ; NO 1

JAN :' EEB 13

RETROSPECTIVE RECORD REVIEW

Reinforced Zinc Oxide-Eugenol Pulpotomy: A Retrospective Study E.K. Hui-Derksen, DDS, MS' • Chiung-Fen Chen, DDS, MS^ • Robert Majewski, DDS, MS^ • Ruwaida G.H. Tootia, BChD, PhD" • James R. Boynton, DDS,

Abstract: Purpose: The purpose of this retrospective study was to evaiuate puipotomies eompieted without the use of a fixative, preservative, or astringent agent prior to piaeement of a reinforeed zinc oxide-eugenol (ZOF) sub-base in the puip chamber and subsequent restoration. Methods: Ciinicai and radiographie data were collected from a private pédiatrie dentai offiee in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The pulpotomy teehnique used invoived: amputation of coronal pulp: radicuiar hemostasis via pressure with dry cotton peiiet: piaeement of ZOE into the puip ehamber: and restoration with stainless steel erown or amalgam. Results: One-hundred-ninety primary moiars in 116 chiidren (foiiow-up=6-94 months: mean=35.8 months) met the inclusion eriteria. The radiographie, dinicai, and overaii sueeess rates were approximately 95%, 97%, and 94%, respeetiveiy. The most frequentiy observed pathoiogie puipai response was fureation radioiueency (N=7, ~4%). The patient's age at time of puipotomy, restoration type, tooth type, arch, and ioeation of treatment (in-offiee vs gênerai anesthesia) were not statistieaiiy significant factors influendng the success of the reinforced ZOF puipotomy technigue. Conclusion: The success rates indicate that the reinforced zinc oxide-eugenoi puipotomy technique may be an aeeeptabie treatment modaiity for primary moiars requiring vitai puip therapy (Pediatr Dent 2013:35:43-6) ReeeivedJune 20, 2011 / Last Revision November 13, 2011 i Aeeepted November 23, 2011

KEYWORDS: PULPOTOMY, ZINC OXIDE, EUGENOL, DENTITION, PRIMARY

When caries removal results in a carious or mechanical pulp exposure, a pulpotomy is performed in a primary tooth with extensive decay but without evidence of radicular pathology.' The coronal pulp is amputated, and the remaining vital radicular pulp tissue is treated with a medicament such as formocresol. After the pulp chamber is filled with zinc oxide-eugenol (ZOE) or another suitable base, the tooth is given a restoration that seals it from leakage. Formocresol is considered the "gold standard" of all pulpotomy agents.' Due to concerns over mutagencity, potential carcinogenicity, and immune sensitization of formocresol,'•'' however, alternative medicaments have been proposed, including: calcium hydroxide^; glutaraldehyde*"; ferric sulfate'; electrocautery"; lasers'*; collagen solutions; bone morphogenic proteins'"; and mineral trioxide aggregate.- In the search for alternatives to formocresol, some practitioners have simply eliminated the initial medicament step and placed the ZOE base into the pulp chamber after achieving radicular pulpal hemostasis with pressure. ZOE was the first agent to be used for preservation (minimal devitalization, noninductive)" and is currently used as a base material in pulpotomy. Some studies have shown that teeth treated with a pulpotomy with a ZOE base demonstrated internal résorption and inflammation at the pulpotomy's amputation site.'^'^ It has been assumed that internal résorption is associated with eugenol and, when ZOE is used as a sub-base following pulpotomy, eugenol directly contacts with the vital tissue and causes moderate to severe inflammatory response.

Products such as IRM and ZOE B&T (both Dentsply Caulk, Milford, Del., USA) are reinforced ZOE materials with improved mechanical properties. Reinforced ZOE contains polymethyl methacrylate, zinc oxide, acetic acid, and eugenol. Euks et al. found that 73% of pulpotomized primary teeth of baboons treated with IRM (group 1) only presented with mild or no inflammation vs teeth treated with ferric sulfate (58%; group 2) and formocresol (48%; group 3) prior to placement of an IRM base within 8 weeks."" No statistically significant differences were noted among the 3 groups for degree of inflammation, abscess, or inflammatory root résorption. A pédiatrie dentist in private practice in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, has been employing a pulpotomy technique using pressure hemostasis followed by placement of ZOE B&T in the pulp chamber for a number of years. This private practitioner has reported anecdotal success, but no study could he found in the literature that analyzed this technique. Therefore, the purpose of this retrospective study was to evaluate puipotomies completed without the use of a fixative, preservative, or astringent agent prior to placement of a reinforced zinc oxide-eugenol (ZOE) sub-base in the pulp chamber and subsequent restoration.

Methods A private pédiatrie dental office in Toronto has exclusively used ZOE B&T after achieving radicular pulpal hemostasis within 60 seconds with pressure from a dry cotton pellet. Permission to conduct this study was obtained from the private practitioner. This study was approved by the Health Sciences Institutional Review Board of the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Mich. ^Dr. Hui-Derksen is in private practice in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada. ^Dr Clinical and radiographie data were collected from record Ghen is a clinical lecturer, and ^Dr. Boynton is a elinical assistant professor and direc- review. Patients who presented between 1997 and 2001 were tor, pédiatrie dentistry, both at Department of Orthodontics and Pédiatrie Dentistry. considered to be potential candidates, the records of whom were Sehool of Dentistry. University of Michigan; 'Dr. Majewski is a elinical director, pédiatrie dentistry. Mott Children's Health Center, and adjunct associate professor. Department reviewed and recruited for this study if the following criteria of Orthodontics and Pédiatrie Dentistiy. School of Dentistry. University of Miehigan; and were met. The patient had to have: *Dr. Tootia is a pédiatrie dentist, allin Ann Arbor, Mich.. USA. 1. at least 1 primary molar which had undergone pulpoCorrespond with Dr. Boynton at jboynton@umich. edu tomy; THE REINEORCED ZINC OXIDE-EUGENOL PULPOTOMY

43


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.