the essex
November 8, 2018 • The Essex Reporter • 1
RepoRteR
Prsrt Std ECRWSS U.S. Postage Paid Permit No. 266 Burlington, VT 05401 Postal Patron-Residential
FREE Vol. 17, No. 45 essexreporter.com
{ Thursday, November 8, 2018 }
COURTESY PHOTO
Kirstie Paschall slides in her vote at Essex High School on Tuesday morning accompanied by her 3-month-old daughter, Nora, who was attending her second-ever election after also hitting the polls for the August primary.
Giambatista and Houghton cruise to re-election Redmond breaks through, Myers retains seat Local voters choose Scott, Zuckerman
A
ELECTION DAY By COLIN FLANDERS
sizable midterm turnout saw incumbents sweep the board in
ing people what was on their minds – a lesson she planned to carry on
state and federal races Tuesday while voters handed down clear
to Montpelier. “I’m just really humbled,” she said when reached Tues-
advantages in both Essex house districts.
day night. “I’m excited to represent Essex and really understand what
Democrat Marybeth Redmond led all vote-getters in the two-seat
people’s concerns are and bring all of those voices to the statehouse.”
Chittenden 8-1 district with 2,458, while Republican incumbent Linda
In Chittenden 8-2, incumbent Democrats Lori Houghton and Dylan
Myers retained her seat with 1,974 votes, about 400 more than Progres-
Giambatista earned re-election, receiving 3,013 and 2,895 votes, respec-
sive/Democrat Tanya Vyhovsky, unofficial results show.
tively. Challenger John Brennan, a Republican, finished a distant third
Redmond credited her success to simply knocking on doors and ask-
with 1,448.
See ELECTION, page 2
Alleged courthouse rape victim sues state By COLIN FLANDERS A woman who said she was sexually assaulted at Burlington’s Edward J. Costello Courthouse is suing the state of Vermont for negligence nearly a year after a jury acquitted her alleged rapist. Filed in Washington County Superior Court last month, the lawsuit accuses Burlington criminal courthouse security of failing to protect the woman from sexual assault despite several reports of her alleged attacker’s aggressive behavior toward female attorneys on the morning of Oct. 16, 2015. The suit names the state of Vermont as its lone defendant and references the ac-
cused – Robert Rosario, 35, of New York – throughout the complaint. “[The] state of Vermont and its security officers knew of the foreseeable risk of harm of violent assault on courthouse visitors and knew or had reason to know that Robert Rosario, in particular, posed a threat,” the lawsuit says. The state will argue court officers couldn't have forseen that Rosario would commit the alleged crime and therefore the state shouldn't be held liable for his actions, according to Kate Gallagher, chief of civil division at the Attorney General’s Office, which is representing the state. “There is no duty here that was breached,” she said.
The woman lived in Essex during Rosario’s trial last December, and the lawsuit says she still lives in the county. The Reporter does not identify victims of alleged sexual assault without their consent. Reached Monday, her attorney, David Lynch, declined to comment on the case. The assault has left the woman with ongoing medical expenses to address mental and physical harm rising to the level of some “permanent disability,” according to the lawsuit. She asks for compensatory damages and any relief the court deems just. Rosario’s trial focused heavily on interactions between Rosario and the woman
leading up to the incident. Court records show she was there for a meeting with a counselor while Rosario attending a hearing for a drug trafficking charge. The alleged victim testified that Rosario approached her several times and insisted she knew him. Later, she said, he went into the women’s bathroom, shoved her into one of the stalls, told her to “shut up” and raped her. Prosecutors from the Attorney General’s Office told the jury the woman was homeless and working to overcome a drug addiction at the time of the incident. They called her the “perfect victim.” See LAWSUIT, page 2