CLASS OF 2021_Chisvo, T

Page 37

access to the statue because of the student card identification and explanation that he was researching for academic purposes. The critics of the statue say that Kruger is a relic and artefact from the oppressive, racist colonial and apartheid era and should be removed for the city truly to belong to the original inhabitants. On the other hand, defenders argue that Kruger is a pivotal part of the Afrikaner cultural heritage and should be respected and honoured as such. For many people, the statue represents values associated with Afrikanerdom, while for others and represents the inherent and institutionalised racism of the South African society before 1994. The anti-Kruger activists argue that the statue is a painful reminder of centuries of oppression and there is no place in modern South Africa to celebrate a figure central to that history. Historians have also written extensively about his involvement in government corruption and manipulation of the Transvaal1 elections (Du Toit, 2020). Kruger was also the Afrikaans peoples’ spiritual leader during their bitter war of resistance against British rule, the consequences of which have become a point of reference in Afrikaans peoples’ collective consciousness. In the same war, black South Africans lost any claim to their country. Kruger inevitably became the embodiment and representation of black dispossession, oppression, and racism. As a result, when the Afrikaans peoples’ view the artefact, they may venerate their hero and icon. In contrast, black South Africans are often reminded of the torturous past and their loss of national identity.

3.3.5 Proposals in terms of statue or plinth position This section presents two proposals that may change the narrative in terms of the historical meaning of the site by relocating the statue or removing the statue.

Consideration A In light of the numerous sentiments around and perspectives on Paul Kruger (the person and the statue), it is evident that statues tell not so much what the people on the plinths did, as that which the people who put them there want society to believe

1

The Transvaal province in the north of South Africa between 1910 and 1994 (Wikipedia).

26


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

LIST OF REFERENCES

5min
pages 88-91

legacies in the SADC

1min
page 81

4.4 Recommendations

2min
pages 85-87

Figure 3.46: One walkway with trees on both sides

0
page 78

4.2.3 Review of policies of architectural decolonisation

1min
page 82

Figure 3.44: Main walkway with trees and grass

0
page 76

Figure 3.45: Elevation with trees and grass

0
page 77

Figure 3.43: Square with meandering pathways

0
page 75

Figure 3.42: Square with a water garden

0
page 74

Figure 3.41: Bridge crossing

0
page 73

Figure 3.37: Africa Unity Square layout plan

0
page 70

Figure 3.38: Walkways north of the square removed

0
page 71

Figure 3.34: Broken tiles

0
page 66

Figure 3.28: Closing the opening between the Hall of Heroes and Hall of the Altar

2min
pages 59-60

Figure 3.33: Rainbow floor option

0
page 65

Figure 3.32: Rainbow patterned floor

0
page 64

Figure 3.29: Upper dome opening closed

0
page 61

Figure 3.27: Beam splitter for light on both Cenotaphs

0
page 58

Figure 3.26: Adding another Cenotaph next to the existing

0
page 57

Figure 3.25: Cenotaph inscribed in 11 languages

1min
pages 55-56

Figure 3.21: City development around the Voortrekker Monument

0
page 51

Figure 3.23: Sunlight shining on the cenotaph

0
page 53

Figure 3.15: Empty plinth at Church Square

1min
page 44

Figure 3.16: Voortrekker Monument

0
page 47

3.3.5 Proposals in terms of statue or plinth position

2min
pages 37-38

3.3.7 Conclusion

1min
page 45

Figure 3.12: Another statue next to Paul Kruger

0
page 42

Figure 3.10: Plinth and statue removed from the central point

0
pages 39-40

Figure 1.0: Video QR Code

2min
page 13

2.5 SADC

1min
page 22

3.2.3 Conclusion

1min
page 27

Figure 3.3: Church Square and surroundings

1min
pages 30-31

Figure 3.9: Paul Kruger statue and plinth

0
page 36

3.2.2 Height and scale

2min
page 26

2.3 Conflicting memories

1min
page 20

2.4 spirit of heritage

1min
page 21
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.