Journal of Learning and Teaching
Do Undergraduate Students Still Value Seminar Learning? Assessing and Responding to Changing attitudes. Tim Brindes, History Abstract In recent years, UK universities have been required to accommodate increasing student populations. Contemporary scholarship implies that due to a cultural shift, a proliferating proportion of this student body perceive themselves as ‘customers’ of higher education; as a result of these factors, many students potentially feel disinclined to contribute to discussion and activities in crowded seminar classes. To assess student attitudes towards seminar teaching and learning, a case study has been carried out in a West Sussex University. This has revealed that that it is not only imperative for tutors to facilitate learning in small groups but also to provide early guidance for students, highlighting the benefits of group work, and to use developing information sharing technology to consolidate their professional relationship with students.
Introduction
into a new social and academic culture (Christie et al., 2008), yet
Contemporary literature concerning learning and teaching at university level places increased emphasis on the perceived commodification of education in the UK, United States, Canada, Australia and other European nations, and the associated changes in student expectations of the university experience (James, 2002; White, 2007). Students have been likened to ‘customers who are aware of their...rights’ (Sander et al., 2000) with higher education establishments compelled to meet ‘consumer’ demands in an increasingly competitive ‘market’.
Student expectations
of higher education are frequently related to the rising financial encumbrance of degree level study, and it is suggested that students understandably demand ‘value for money’ (Coaldrake, 2002), wishing to ensure that their enrolment at university is time and money well spent. Financial motivation is not the sole contributory factor behind student expectations however. Increased marketing from higher education establishments competing for student applications influences the initial expectations that prospective students will formulate (James, 2002), while technological developments alter their preferred ways of transmitting and receiving information in both a social and academic environment. Desire for integration into ‘university life’, both educationally and socially, is a manifest component of student expectations. Undergraduate students have been described by authors in the field as ‘strangers in a strange land’ who are exposed to unfamiliar people, surroundings, practices and responsibilities in their initial experiences of higher education (Mann, 2001; McIlroy, 2003). The sense of displacement and anxiety that new students might experience is tempered by the optimistic anticipation of integration 2012 Series: Paper 5
for many this represents a challenging emotional and intellectual transition. Younger students are expected to enter a world of ‘adult’ learning where they must adopt levels of responsibility for their own education unfamiliar from school or further education; indeed university staff are often dispirited by the perceived desire for academic ‘spoon-feeding’ among new university intake (James, 2002). Ultimately, a failure to integrate oneself into the new academic or social environment represents an evident disparity in the expectations and actualities of university life, and is identified as one of the principal causes for undergraduate non-completion in the UK (Yorke, 1999). Furthermore, integration into life at university appears to be intrinsically related to the expectations that new students harbour towards tutors. Empirical research reveals that students expect a learning environment that places them in close contact with university staff, from whom they desire a personal academic relationship (Hovdhaugen & Aamodt, 2009).
Such
personal attention is recognised as being of crucial importance in facilitating a beneficial learning experience for students (White, 2007), while the failure to generate such a relationship can result in alienation from, and disinterest in, studies (Mann, 2001). In light of the factors surrounding student attitudes and expectations described above, it is logical to examine whether or not universities are sufficiently accommodating the needs and desires of the student body by investigating tangible examples of student experience. The following study was therefore designed to investigate - by means of a limited case study - student attitudes towards seminars, an environment that should ideally offer undergraduate students the chance to integrate and interact with both tutors and peers at a personal and academic level,