an urban village in mumbai worli koliwada Summer school 2017 cept university
in association with g5a foundation for contemporary culture
kamalika bose | anuradha parikh
CONTENTS 01/ LOCATING WORLI KOLIWADA: The Current Context
1
02/ MAPPING WORLI KOLIWADA Illustrated Built Environment Impressionistic sections People and place diary
7 9 11 15
03/ CULTURE CURRENTS: Impressioning a Community in Flux Faith & Place FELT PLACE: Emotions & Behavior CULTURE-NATURE: An Integrated Life Cycle Framing Culture: (multi)Place Readings
19 20 21 23 27
COURSE TITLE An Urban Village In Mumbai: Culture and Community in the Maximum City.
COURSE INSTRUCTORS Kamalika Bose Anuradha Parikh
COURSE DURATION May 8 - 22, 2017
Hosted by:
PARTICIPANTS Aarati Binayak Aayushi Joshi Anjali Katare Anupama Warrier Arkadipta Banerjee Jacob Baby Jane Thomas Kamna Vyas Manushi Sheth Namrata Toraskar Nilesh Prajapati Rhujuta Jadhav Shemal Pandya Shriya Balakrishnan
In assosiation with
SWS
Summer Winter School
04/ REWRITING THE LIVELIHOODS ECOSYSTEM Worli Koliwada Urban Livelihoods Mapping the Minutes: The Daily Cycle The Fishing Ecosystem The Non-fishing Ecosystem
31 33 35 37 39 41
05/ WHO’S WASTE IS IT ANYWAY?: Towards a Cleaner Koliwada Existing Waste Cycle Proposed Integrated Cycle Travelogue
45 49
INTRODUCTION AND COURSE OBJECTIVES Vibrant communities lie at the heart of dynamic and resilient neighborhoods and cities. Their history, stories, dreams and aspirations fuel the engines of urban transformation for a future that is sustainable – economically, environmentally, culturally and socially. Mumbai’s urban villages, or gaothans, are historically endowed with this rich social and cultural capital leading quiet yet disconcerted existences. Struggling to fit into the mosaic of the city’s contemporary urban culture, Worli Koliwada, one of the earliest fishing villages in Mumbai, is representative of this phenomenon. This study is a culmination of a collaborative effort between G5A Foundation’s CityLAB initiative and participating students from CEPT University’s Summer School 2017. Working in groups, the students interacted closely with the local community to enable qualitative research and impressionistic mapping. Dove-tailing into G5A CityLAB’s ongoing work on developing a participative and inclusive model for neighborhood governance, with a current focus on Solid Waste Management in the Worli Koliwada, the students additionally looked into aspects of the physical neighborhood, livelihoods, heritage, culture and memories - and their changing patterns with time.
locating worli koliwada The current context
The work attains a broader relevance in wake of Mumbai’s towering aspirations and swift transformation into a global megapolis. However, such priorities dexterously implant global images of urbanity into the local landscape, while often casting aside any concern of context, culture and livability.
Much has been eulogized about Mumbai’s original fishing villages and the undisputed significance of the Kolis in carving an indigenous narrative within the Maximum City’s multicultural mosaic. Akin to traditional communities whose lives and histories are often over-documented and romanticized, thereby heightening a sense of nostalgia, the contemporary canvas of Worli Koliwada is vastly different from its idealized past. Identifying the current context is paramount while charting a course for re-signification – both for its community and the city at large.
That the Worli Koliwada, by its strategic location, foregrounds this emergent skyline, is both ironic and opportune. This study is thus also an attempt and opportunity to refocus on the local – by minutely observing embedded histories, acknowledging the ordinary, and enabling an inclusive, bottom-up approach of working with community and culture.
With an estimated population of 30,000 residents, where only approx. 20% families of Koli descent remain, Worli Koliwada today has a mixed, lower-middle income demographic carrying a towering cultural legacy and inheritance with a fading significance. On the periphery of civic and infrastructural priorities, its urban landscape and amenities
Locating Worli Koliwada
are fast degrading. Unchecked building activity, over land demarcated for fishdrying yards and open spaces, has pressured existing infrastructure. Long-standing habits of open defecation and improper waste disposal pose health and other environmental hazards. Forgotten in these urban challenges is the 18th century Worli Fort, a former British military outpost, that harks back to the days of maritime trade and warfare. Yet at the heart of the settlement are its enterprising and resilient people – who have tided over decades of threat, to their land and seas, by various vested interests and continue to remain a force to reckon with. By Locating Worli Koliwada the attempt is to place this forgotten yet strategic geography and its dynamic people back onto the map of contemporary discourse and urban future.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
1
Worli Tip Jetty
Worli Fort
a
Bandr a Wor li S
ea-lin k
New Jetty
Cleaveland Jetty
b
c
a. The view from Worli fort with Koliwada in the foreground and city’s rising skyline in the background b. G-South ward in Mumbai c. Koliwada in the G-South Ward
Locating Worli Koliwada
Satellite imagery of Worli Koliwada, Google Earth Pro.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
3
Mapping worli koliwada To map is an act of layering information that creates a more holistic understanding of an environment. Worli Koliwada, as described earlier, is an important urban precinct in a Mumbai in flux. The contradictions of its indigenous heritage when confronted by the globalizing city that surrounds it, makes it a potent site for creating positive change in the mainstream urban discourse. The idea of mapping Worli Koliwada is not embedded in morphological approaches that emphasize settlement and architectural form. It is, in fact, about excavating qualitative information mined from a saturated history and timeline - saturated with the culture, the landmarks, the transitions, the spirit of the settlement. This approach emphasized the gathering of empirical data by engaging with the direct stakeholders - the residents themselves - as agents of change within their own community. Information collected is a culmination of an intuitive understanding of the space through ethnography, primary data collection via individual and group interviews on site, and supported by secondary data from theoretical research and inputs. The impressionistic map portrays the memory centers that make Worli Koliwada, and the various layers that are embedded in making something a landmark. The visual narrative
of the map seeks to position the reader at its heart and create an immediacy in the placement of Worli Koliwada in the readers’ mind. The sections that accompany it are indicative of the urban environment that the residents are in, and the change in usage across the land and activities. It further reinforces that in spite of a visible transformation across the settlement, both laterally and longitudinally, in the end it is the composite whole which makes the place. It seeks to provoke and instigate the readers with questions that lead to conversations and an opening of a dialogue within the community. The sections display the variety and organic development of Worli Koliwada, over time, through tangibles and variables. It becomes important to observe the evolution of the settlement over the years, through the continuity and change lens, and identify patterns that govern change today. This approach provides clues to then identify, and potentially preserve, the unique typologies, clusters and zones, which continue to retain the values and ethos of the urban village character.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
5
Mapping Worli Koliwada
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
7
Mapping Worli Koliwada
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
9
Mapping Worli Koliwada
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
11
PEOPLE PLACE DIARY
Mapping Worli Koliwada
Clockwise from far top: Panaroma of the church and jetty with the Sealink in background Street Character Paapmochan temple entrance courtyard Mumbai skyline and Mahim bay from Worli Fort with settlement in the foreground
Clockwise from far top: Locals worshiping at roadside grottoes Walking through the lanes of Koliwada The children playing at Achanak Krida Mandal The Cleaveland jetty A game of volleyball being played by the shoreline
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
13
This illustration employs ghost stories that surround the facts and fables of the historic Worli Fort to highlight its forgotten history and significance today. Dwarfed by a rising skyline, altered use and encroachments, the changing lifestyles and aspirations of the Worli Koliwada is in stark contrast to the static, unchanging monument. The Fort ghost then becomes a metaphor for lost identities and alludes to the fading significance of the Worli Koliwada today, as Mumbai surges ahead on a path of massive urban transformation and global aspirations. Will the Koli spirit live on only as memories and stories??
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
15
Culture currents Impressioning a Community in Flux Indigenous societies have traditionally imbibed a deep understanding and respect for nature and its diverse cycles. This respect informs the community’s knowledge systems and has given rise to cultural practices that are organically and intrinsically synchronized with natural cycles. CultureNature integration was what made life, livelihoods, celebrations, faith and beliefs a tight-knit and sustainable whole. In today’s world of fast-paced change and shifting value systems, this finely-tuned tie is slowly severing, which then threatens to corrode collective, community practices. Kolis, as an indigenous sea-faring community, exemplify this culture-nature connect and its integration with their worldview. The sea is both a source of sustenance and a critical element of their physical environment. Both Hindu and Christian Kolis exude a Respect for nature - not merely for economic gains, but through a strong cultural alignment between the lunar and seasonal cycles and communal practices is strongly visible. The high-spirited Koli festivals – famed for their celebratory fervor, along with ritualistic practices are based on the Hindu Calendar which is in turn linked to the seasonal and geographic specificities. Activating diverse spaces and physical landmarks across the settlement, the culture-nature connect further reinforced multifunctionality through periodic spatial
transformations. Livelihood cycles, derived from the lunar cycles, have also been adapted to respect marine biodiversity and human safety. This sensitivity towards natural and manmade worlds had resulted in an ecological and cultural equilibrium that positively enhanced the physical surrounds as well. In recent times, forces of migration and economic externalities have altered the demographic character of the Worli Koliwada. Cultural osmosis has resulted in an expansion of worldview, diversified celebrations and enriched the Koli cultural inheritance. And yet the undercurrents of change and disonance are palpable. In spite of a harmoniuos coexistence with other ethnicities who now reside in the Koliwada, operating within alternate cultural frameworks, a slow delink from the natural cycles is evident. The elderly residents of Koliwada take immense pride in their cultural practices and safeguard them zeal, however, the younger generation is drifting away. This section is an attempt to join the missing dots and encapsulate these forgotten links to an integrated living through the culture-nature cycle. It also maps the resultant change in physical environment owing to this disconnect – linking place to emotion and behavioral pattern.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
17
Faith and place
Felt Place: Emotions and behavior FELT PLACE: EMOTIONS & BEHAVIOUR
FAITH & PLACE
E 11
1 2 3 4 -
A 1
5
5
1
5 -
a
4
10 b
2
6 -
B
7 8 9 10 -
3 c
2
4
6
1,2: The street transforms from being a mere movement corridor into a celebration ground for festival processions and street fairs during the Golfadevi Jatra which links to Achanak Krida Mandir.
C
5,6: How two adjacent spaces are being treated differently owing to use and association evoking contrasting emotions
c
5
d
6
e
D
7 8 f
3: Chededev Temple bedecked for the annual celebration during Pausch Purnima
6
9
a - Sri Sai Temple b - Space near Velankanni Matha grotto c - Sri Paap Vimochan Temple - Velankanni Matha Cross d - Ek Veera Mata Photo - Open space for boat Pooja e - Temple of Golfadevi - Sai Baba Mandal - Statue of Shirdi Sai Baba f - Sri Mahadeva Temple g - Vetal Temple - Chapel of Jesus Christ
7
3 3
Sri Sai Temple Siddhi Vinayak Krida Mandal Jnaneshwar Seva Mandal Bal Gopal Krida Mandal Statue of Velankanni Matha Open space near Santoshi Mata Temple Amir Prem Vyayam Mandal Open space near Dattatray Temple Open space opposite Ganga Wine & Beer Parlour Cross of Velankanni Matha Open space near Paap Vimochan Temple Nakhwa Admin Office Vijay Mitra Mandal Informal chowk near fish market Velankanni Matha Grotto Gazebo near Chededev Temple Cross near Waras Lane Chowk Mahadeva Temple Chowk near Mahadeva Temple Velankanni Matha grotto Open space in front of Vetal Temple
7: The place beside New Jetty remains an area of neglect in spite of having an idol-making workshop in the vicinity
7
25
50
A - Path toward Worli Fort B - Open defecation spot near Jnaneshwar Seva Mandal C - Playground near Achanak Krida Mandal D - Open space near idol maKING workshop E - Area beyond built edge of gathering space near Vetal Temple
100m
2 8
9 4 4: Narali Purnima processions that culminate at the Worli Tip Jetty with worshipping of the fishing boats and the sea
1
25
50
100m
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
Chededev Temple Hanuman Temple Sri Paap Vimochan Temple Church Vetal Temple Santoshi Mata Temple Achanak Krida Mandal Sai Baba Mandal & Temple Golfadevi Temple
Processions and festivals activate the major streets, chowks, mandals and open areas surrounding the religious spaces. 3: goo.gl/zwoIg6
Culture Currents : Impressioning a community in flux
8
8 8: The chowk near the fish market acts as a place for people to sit and relax, a gathering space where men and children often play games
9 9: Transitional spaces, that buffer sacred(temple) and utilitarian (fish drying) areas, have emerged as areas of neglect
How the people of Koliwada use and maintain spaces reflect their emotions associated with them. Places of worship are often linked with respect and calm. Spaces with less visual and physical access have been observed to be linked with neglect. There are cases where respect appears to end at imaginary boundaries beyond which neglect creeps in.
4: goo.gl/66E7bt 8
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
19
FRAMING CULTURE : (MULTI)PLACE CULTURE-NATURE: An Integrated Life Cycle
10
11
13
14
12
15
17
19
READINGS
16
18
20
21
10,11,12: Personalised symbols of faith outside houses, 13: Grotto across the entrance of Worli Fort which is also a community otla, 14: Typical scene of puja of a new boat in Koli culture before it fares into the sea, 15: A shrine to Velankanni Matha, commonly worshipped by Christians in fishermen communities, 16: Velankanni Matha grotto where men are often seen relaxing, 17: A streetside Lord Ganesha shrine, 18: Daily evening mass at the Church at Worli Tip, 19: A community hall and a multifunctional chowk used for weddings and celebrations; 20,21: Siddhivinayak Seva Mandal transforms from a household extension of daily activities to a filming location, 21: Coldplay’s ‘Hymn for the Weekend’
Culture and traditions are a community’s window of expression to the world. They help people mark significant occasions in life transitions; strengthening a community’s sense of belonging. They stem not only due to personal or communal beliefs, practices and habits but also geographical and climatic conditions. The culture-nature relationship is best depicted when understood with the Hindu Lunar calendar. These concentric rings are a graphical representation of the festival and fishing cycles in the Worli Koliwada - which are the warp and weft of the Koli lifecycle. These cycles are mapped along the Hindu calendar and corresponds to the seasonal cycle, as well as the familiar Gregorian calendar - to understand occurences, overlays and the community’s integrated culturenature worldview.
21:`www.youtube.com/watch?v=YykjpeuMNEk 8 Culture Currents : Impressioning a community in flux
8
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
21
FRAMING CULTURE : (MULTI)PLACE READINGS Framing culture: (Multi)place readings
A
B
A
B
C
D
C
D
E
F
E
F
H
H
G
G
The diverse celebrations of Koliwada has been captured through frames, each representing the major activity or festival at a particular time of the year. H having chosen eight important spaces, how they transform through the lens of time through the year has been depicted.
1A: Chededev Temple- Pausch Purnima, B: Hanuman Temple-community lunch, C: Paap Vimochan Temple- Pausch Purnima, D: Church and surrounding area near Worli tip jetty- Daily activity of fish drying, E: Worli tip jetty-Holi, F: Sai Baba Seva Mandal- Dahi Handi, G: Golfadevi Temple- Golfadevi Jatra, H: Achanak Krida Mandal-Golfadevi Jatra 2A: Daily aarti, B: Havan, C: Yoga class, D: Daily evening prayer, E: Boat repair, F: Medical camp, G: Drying chillis & paapad, H: Jahir Sabha SET 1 : January- May
SET 2 : June- July
8
Culture Currents : Impressioning a community in flux
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
23
Framing culture: (Multi)place readings FRAMING CULTURE : (MULTI)PLACE READINGS
A
B
A
B
C
D
C
D
E
F
E
F
H
H
G
G
3A: Narali Purnima procession commences, B: Ganesh Chaturthi, C: Daily evening aarti, D: Narali Purnima procession, E: Culmination of Narali Purnima, F: Daily activity of children playing, G: Local belief associated with Golfadevi who answers worshippers’ questions through chanderi supari, H: Daily activities
4A: Wedding procession, B: Resting space for elderly, C: Local belief that praying here will cure diseases, D: Christmas, E: Film shooting, F: Dussehra, G: Dussehra, H: Garbage dump in neglected playground & car parking at Krida Mandal
SET 3 : August- September
SET 4 : October- December
8
Culture Currents : Impressioning a community in flux
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
25
The narrow streets of Worli Koliwada makes the entire settlement like a labyrinth with interconnections and informal open spaces. These spatial diversity - chowks, osari, benches - along the streets become areas of interactions, nostalgic memories and associations amongst the Koliwada residents. The illustration tries to bring out such intimate conversations that emanate from these spaces which are declining in the new compact housing typology that is emerging in Worli Koliwada. An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
27
rewriting livelihoodS ecosystem ‘Livelihoods’ can be defined as a person’s means of securing the basic necessities of life such as food, shelter, clothing etc. It can be viewed objectively as the several strategies people adopt to survive and to make the best use of the resources they have acquired over time or currently available to them. Understanding the livelihood ecosystem in Worli Koliwada, lends key insights into how the community have undergone stages of transition keeping up with trends of Urbanization the city has undergone. This exercise focused on understanding the nature of key livelihoods, their cycles and patterns, along with continuity and change within the livelihoods ecosystem. What kinds of capital does the community possess in order to achieve their livelihood goals? The nature of spatial shifts, externalities associated with livelihoods under pressure and their overall sustainability in the face of changing times and aspirations informed the line of inquiry. The study was categorized into two strands – a) The traditional fishing trade: This study entailed a thorough grasp over the fishing cycle and activities, places within the settlement actively related to the trade and the key processes. b) Diversifications and shifts over time towards newer livelihoods: Non-fishing activities were mapped on their evolution,
occurrence and proliferation across the settlement along with their impact on the physical and social fabric of Worli Koliwada.
A key learning point was people’s aspirations and notions as propelled by their primary or allied livelihoods. Being hidden in this fast-paced city was an advantage till recently, with growth opportunities and abundant resources from the sea – creating a massive natural capital in sustaining fishing livelihoods. The advent of technology has challenged several rudimentary practices and set the fisherfolk back due to the lack of affordable access and incentives. The infiltration of external players into the arena, pollution from the sea resulting in low catch, and low economic returns is dampening the spirit to continue fishing activity in Koliwada. An amalgamation of these factors is discouraging the continuation of this multigenerational trade. A shift towards pursuing higher education and alternate livelihoods – both outside and within the Koliwada – for social and economic mobility is emerging slowly but strongly. The idea of livelihoods is interconnected with multiple factors and it serves as a starting point in understanding dynamics of communities. Though often invisible to the rest of the city, they form an integral patch in the fabric of the Maximum City Mumbai. An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
29
Worli koliwada urban livelihoods
Worli Koliwada Urban Livelihoods Worli Koliwada Urban Livelihoods
devi Golfa
Road SK Golfa
devi
Road
e Bhay
Road SK
e Bhay
Road
Scrap mart shop Spice shop
Tuition classes Vegetable and Fruit vendor
Fishing Boat
Rewriting Livelihoods Ecosystem
Brick / Stone shop
Lottery ticket shop
General store
Medical store
Lottery ticket shop
Health centre
Medical store
Jewellery shop
Tailoring / Laundry Gymnasium
Florist Chaas / Lemon juice vendor
Health centre
Beauty parlour
Jewellery shop
Electronic shop
Food Tiffin Service
Gymnasium
Chaas / Lemon juice vendor
Beauty parlour
Driving school
Electronic shop
Garment shop
Statue making
Cable Net service
Street Food
Driving school
Garment making
Electronics repair
Sprout stall
Notary and legal works
Wine shop
Automobile workshop
Share Taxi Service
Bakery Items vendor
Orchestra / Musician
Meat vendor
Statue making
Fish Market
Automobile workshop
Fishing Activity Fishing Activity
General store
Photo studio
Garment making
Fish Market
Spice shop
Florist Vegetable and Fruit vendor
Fish drying
Fish drying
Photo studio
Brick / Stone shop
Tailoring / Laundry New French Restaurant Food Tiffin Service Fishing Boat
Tuition classes
Scrap mart shop
SmallSmall scale industry scale industry
Cable Net service Electronics repair Share Taxi Service Services Services
Street Food
Sprout stall Bakery Items vendor
Street Vending Street Vending
Profession
Garment shop
Notary and legal works
Wine shop
Orchestra / Musician
Meat vendor
Profession
Trading
Trading
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
31
Mapping the minutes: The daily cycle
Worli Tip Jetty
Worli Tip Jetty
N
New Jetty
New Jetty
4AM-8AM
Fishing Activity
Rewriting Livelihoods Ecosystem
Street Activity
Fish Market
Cleveland Jetty
Cleveland Jetty
8AM-12PM
Early mornings at Worli Koliwada begin with fishing activities. Worli Tip Jetty, New Jetty, Cleveland Jetty are the most active spots in this time period.Flowersellers, chaiwallahs and vegetable vendors also set up their stalls at specific spots such as near temples, informal bazars etc.
12PM-4PM
The settlement cores become very active during this period. The streets are bustling with energy, shop-keepers unlock their day’s trades,and the fish market’s periphery becomes a hub for variety of non-fishing activities. Fish Drying Area
New Jetty
Fish Market
Cleveland Jetty
Cleveland Jetty
Worli Tip Jetty
New Jetty
Fish Market
Fish Market
N
Worli Tip Jetty
Service
4PM-8PM
As noon sets in, so does siesta time. Most trade and commerce wraps up for lunch. Service sector comprising workshops and repair units remain open while street activities thin down considerably.
Street Activity
General stores and some street vendoes restart activities around 4PM, while most professional activities wrap up around 6PM.Service activities extend to 8PM after which all commercialactivity comes to a close.
Profession based Activity
Small scale Industries
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
33
Boats set sail, nets are laid. Dinghys head out first.
8
First batch of fresh sea catch brought in.
Cleaning of nets and detangling, collecting fish
Catch sorted and sent off to market or to drying yards
10
Bigger boats go next to span a wider, expansive net.These are motorized and employ different net types for catch diversity.
Fish market opens. Fish from the Jetty, Docks sold here by Koli womenfolk. Active days Monday, Wednesday, Friday and weekends.
12
2
A visual storytelling of the fishing activity in Worli Koliwada, the heart and soul of Koli community lies in fishing. It brings out their entreprenuerial spirit and binds them much closer to their biggest resource : The Sea.
Rewriting Livelihoods Ecosystem
8
OVER REGULARIZATION
Boats return from sea with more fish. Jetty forms first disembarking and sale point.
The fish market is dominated by Koli women and have spaces allocated for sale by the Market Committee on rental basis.
ILLEGAL TRAWLERS
Some fishermen procure catch from the Mumbai docks. Sell the variety available in Koliwada markets
NO GOVERNMENT INCENTIVES
4
URBANIZATION
DOCKS
LOW RETURNS POLLUTED WATERS
THE FISHING ECOSYSTEM
Fish taken for drying, storing and selling in other markets. Boats and allied equipment parked by Jetty.
Vans The impact of fast paced development and urbanization has led the people of Koliwada to adopt Fish markets closes transport majority stock different livelihood strategies and make a transition from fishing.The above picture for the day. Cleaning andtell a to market and homes. story of how the streets have become vibrant places of trade and commerce adding tomarket the maintenance of the Fishing wrapped up for fervour of entreprenuerism of the community. takes place after. the day.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
35
The impact of fast paced development and urbanization has led the people of Koliwada to adopt different livelihood strategies and make a transition from fishing.The above picture tell a story of how the streets have become vibrant places of trade and commerce adding to the fervour of entreprenuerism of the community.
Rewriting Livelihoods Ecosystem
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
37
Koli women Illustrtn Distinctive attire, love for gold jewelry and outspoken attitude are the hallmark of Koli women who enjoy a dominant position in domestic and business matters alike. An equal partner in sharing roles in the fishing trade, their economic independence and hence empowerment is a fascinating social
model. Single-handedly running the fish markets in the Worli Koliwada, their jovial and mischievous interactions keep the spirits high even in difficult times. Conversations that begin in banter can often turn aggressive to the point of being quarrelsome! This illustration highlights the position of these hardworking women, their freedom of speech and action, stemming from a high social status in all spheres of life.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
39
Vijays spot illustratn The illustration presents a satirical outlook at the problem of solid waste disposal and open defecation that is rampant in the Worli Koliwada. It highilights the humorous accounts of specific associations, especially of children, with respect to the defecation spots of their family and friends – almost making it a fun group activity! Garbage disposal spots that have conveniently cropped up along the Koliwada’s shoreline leading to environmental pollution and degragation is further reinforced. An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
41
Whose waste is it anyway? Towards a cleaner koliwada In a contemporary culture of conspicuous consumption and urban densification, solid waste management (SWM) plays a key position. This section seeks to explore and understand SWM practices in an extremely dense and diverse urban village - the Worli Koliwada. Representative of a long historical development and indigenous culture, livelihoods and traditional practices, the settlement today grapples with issues of migration and ownership, changing aspirations and value systems.
Mapping and analysis are used in two ways: one to understand the existing waste cycle, and the other that proposes an integrated approach - using spatial networks and community action as key tools to germinate positive change. The methodology used qualitative analysis based on ethnographic data, personal and group interviews in situ. These impressionist maps aim to convey a basic sense of the urban environment, and are indicative of the possible directions the community could together move towards.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
43
50
Dumping sites Shoreline Chuha-gadi waste route MCGM route
ACRES OF LAND
metric
7 tonne OF WASTE GENERATED EVERYDAY
31
1
2
WORKERS CLEAN THE AREA EVERYDAY WITH
Mapping of the existing solid waste management at Worli Koliwada.
Whose Waste is it Anyway? Towards a cleaner Koliwada
x
1
x
2
x
3
x
4
Beach
x
5
SMPA
x
11
MCGM
x
15
3
4
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
3
5
The beach cleaning unit working at a dumping site. A female worker hand-carting waste to the collection site through SK Bhai Road. SMPA workers at the MGCM collection unit. The indigenous waste-carts through the widest section of the Golfadevi road. Activity at the common collection point outside the Cleaveland pumping station.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
45
6
16
7
8
9
17
10
12
11
13
14
15
6,7,8,9 : The western shore. Burning of the waste is a common practice. Rag pickers are also largely prevalent along this coast. The shoreline is used as an open defecation spot. 10 - 15 : The inner core of the Koliwada. The roads are extremely clean despite being quite narrow. Even areas under construction are maintained as seen by pic.12. The roads are almost an extension of the house.
Whose Waste is it Anyway? Towards a cleaner Koliwada
18
16, 17, 18 : The inactive eastern shoreline becomes a natural dumping ground for the residents along the coast. The community is largely inward looking, making the shoreline neglected. Plastics and construction debris along with organic waste is prevalently seen.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
47
GENERATION + SEGREGATION
Proposed waste collection at shoreline
INORGANIC WASTE
Bound by the sea on three sides, Worli Koliwada is blessed with an expansive s horeline , which is under high duress and daily degradation, owing to rampant w aste disposal onto the coastline. As an urban village with a high percentage of daily generated organic wastethis is symptomatic of a broken system and insensitivity at multiple levels.
Government agency
COLLECTION + TRANSPORTATION
< cooperation >
Incubation and insemination by knowledge partners.
Special vehicle formed of by and with the community for internal waste mobilization, processing(organic only) and organization.
common collection point
In order to m anage this situation,this study proposes a Special Purpose Committee(SPC) be formed which c omprises community members,with the leadership and drive to raise awareness on the issue .
Revenue feedback for the vehicle
2 . Set up composting pits within the Koliwada where the bins carrying organic waste are offloaded 3. Organize SWM related Capacity building& Skill Development facilitiesfor local personnel
Capacity building
Women empowerment
Community development
Recycled manure
4 . Facilitate a revenue generation model based on byproducts and incubate allied processes yielded from the SWM model ACHANAK KRIDA MANDAL
Mapping of the proposed solid waste management situation at Worli Koliwada.
Carnival, Farmers market, events
Market
Drying grounds on the west of the Worli Fort Achanak Krida Mandal
Revenue generation
PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT
Organic Waste Composter
SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
1. Locating community bins a t identified spots along the Shoreline
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Achanak Krida Mandal Neglected playgrounds Around 10 tonne
coastline.
Area of installation Quantitative analysis Density based distribution
Change in the urban fabric through green inserts and breathing spaces post clean up and development of the
Potential for segregation setup
his Committee T would work on the following mandates:
Whose Waste is it Anyway? Towards a cleaner Koliwada
ORGANIC WASTE
Organize members Create awareness Implementation
Waste collection route
To create awareness regarding community-driven solid waste management (SWM)processes and segregation at source within the W orli Koliwadathrough a participatory process.
uch an integrated system will S be a value addition to the physical environs, economic strength& s ocial cohesion of the community.
Segregate at source Community activity
Lane wise action areas
DISPOSAL + PROCESSING
My Waste, My Responsibility
Conceptual model of the proposed solid waste management situation at Koliwada, Worli.
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
49
a
d
b
e
c
e
Travelogue
a. Briefing and course orientation in Mumbai b. Introduction to the site and interaction with the locals c. Discussions and dialogue at G5A Foundation
d. On site interactions and daily discussions e. Final presentation and review at G5A Foundation
An Urban Village in Mumbai: Worli Koliwada
51
Hosted by:
In assosiation with
SWS
Summer Winter School