C M Y K
www.morungexpress.com
The Morung Express
Dimapur VOL. VIII ISSUE 304
Modi is seen only on TV and in Gujarat, says Mulayam Singh [ PAGE 08]
reflections
By Sandemo Ngullie
“
www.morungexpress.com
”
Fear not for the future, weep not for the past
Taylor Swift leads winners with three CMA Awards
Friday, November 8, 2013 12 pages Rs. 4 –Percy Bysshe Shelley
‘MISSION POSSIBLE’
Rohit’s debut ton puts India in control
[ PAGE 02]
‘Festivals of Nagaland celebrated to bind unity’
[ PAGE 11]
C M Y K
[ PAGE 12 ]
[ PAGE 09]
Rupees 937,82,67,500/Amount spent in buying votes during Election 2013 in Nagaland: YouthNet Morung Express News Dimapur | November 7
You need Science, Maths, English teachers. Mmm.. mm. Have you any reason for this demand?
‘Repeal AFSPA’ new Delhi, november 7 (ianS): The Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act must be immediately repealed, Amnesty International India said Thursday. This follows a recent spate of domestic and international criticism of the act and continuing human rights violations enabled by the controversial legislation, the rights group said. The demand was made in a briefing, “The Armed Forces Special Powers Act: Time For A Renewed Debate in India on Human Rights and National Security.” “Several expert bodies have now pointed out that the AFSPA enables serious human rights abuses wherever it is in force,” said Shashikumar Velath of Amnesty International India. “The AFSPA has not made these areas safer but has instead led to gross abuse of fundamental human rights of ordinary people. Authorities cannot simply continue to trot out arguments about national security any longer to defend the AFSPA.” The AFSPA provides sweeping powers to members of security forces, including the power to shoot to kill in situations where they are not at imminent risk, and to arrest people without warrants, and even detain them illegally, often leading to cases of extrajudicial executions and enforced disappearances. Amnesty International India recognizes the duty of nations to protect people from rights abuses and crimes, including those committed by armed groups. However, the AFSPA has been ineffective in meeting these goals, and has instead contributed to the creation of a ‘culture of impunity’ for gross human rights violations in areas where it is operational, it said.
Superstitions and scientists
C M Y K
Chennai, november 7 (ianS): Space scientists the world over may be working on advanced scientific fields. But they are not free of superstitions and beliefs, said an Indian space scientist. While Indian space scientists pray to Lord Balaji at Tirupati in Andhra Pradesh prior to every space mission for its success, their American counterparts eat peanuts. “More interesting is the tradition of Russian cosmonauts who urinate on the right back wheel of their transfer bus on their way to the launch centre,” a space scientist at the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) told IANS. “It is all individual beliefs. One cannot take chance with God and poison,” a former ISRO chief told IANS. According to a retired ISRO rocket scientist, a project director used to wear a new shirt on the day a rocket was launched.
In February this year, Nagaland went into election. For a State that has hit financial starvation, this might not be the best news. But here it is: the election saw a staggering expenditure of Rs. 937,82,67,500/- (Rupees nine hundred and thirty seven crore, eighty two lakh, sixty seven thousand and five hundred); “the highest ever researched in the history of elections in the State of Nagaland.” The Nagaland election story is known. The YouthNet has now established it. In a report made available to the media today, titled ‘Post Election Watch Report 2013 Nagaland,’ the YouthNet has claimed that the amount spent to “buy votes” and “muscle man power” by candidates in the 2013 election is twice that of 2008. In 2008, candidates spent a total sum of Rs. 569, 96,00,000/- (Rupees five hundred and sixty nine crore and ninety six lakh). Unfortunately, YouthNet reveals, “from all the 60 constituencies, most of the candidates who overwhelmingly spent the highest amount in their constituencies won the elections.” And the highest amount in any district was
spent by the 29 candidates of Mokokchung vying for 10 constituencies, pitted at an approximate of Rs. 230,60,00,000/- (Rupees two hundred and thirty crore and sixty lakh). The least, Rs. 14,52,50,000/(Rupees fourteen crore, fifty two lakh and fifty thousand), was spent by the six candidates of Kiphire district on two constituencies. The 2013 election was contested by seven political parties (recognised and unrecognised), i.e. the Naga People’s Front, Indian National Congress, Bharatya Janata Party, Nationalist Congress Party, Rashtriya Janata Dal, Janata Dal (United) and UNDP. 37 Independent candidates also joined the fray. The Post Election Watch, a study conducted by YouthNet, is a continuation of its research on the Election System in Nagaland. The report does not reveal the names of any candidate but is intended to “educate the masses to shift from the vicious circle which would bring checks and balances in the system for overall development of our State.” The report is based on data gathered from 11 districts of Nagaland on the record of 184 candidates through information collected by Youth-
Party-Wise Break UP Of exPenditUre Abbreviation
Party
NPF
Naga People’s Front
INC
Indian National Congress
NCP
Nationalist Congress Party
RJD
Rashtriya Janata Dal
BJP
Bharatya Janata Party
JDU
Janata Dal (United)
UNDP
United Naga Democratic Party
Independent --Total
Amount spent Number of (Approx) candidates Rs.486,08,97,500/- (Rupees four hundred and eighty six crores, eight 60 lakhs, ninety seven thousand and five hundred) Rs.217,26,15,000/- (Rupees two hundred and seventeen crores, twenty 55 six lakhs and fifteen thousand) Rs.40,83,00,000/- (Rupees forty 15 crores and eighty three lakhs) Rs.3,87,00,000/- (Rupees three 2 crores and eighty seven lakhs) Rs.11,91,50,000/-(Rupees eleven crores, ninety one lakhs and fifty 11 thousand) Rs.8,07,00,000/-(Rupees eight crores 3 and seven lakhs) Rs.4,20,00,000/- (Rupees four crores 1 and twenty lakhs) Rs.180,59,05,000/- (Rupees one hundred and eighty crores, fifty nine 37 lakhs and five thousand) Rs./- 937,82,67,500/184
GENERAL TRENd • From all the 60 constituencies, most of the candidates who overwhelmingly spent the highest amount in their constituencies won the elections. • 33 candidates spent less than 1 crore. Only one won. • 85 candidates spent more than 1 crore and less than 5 crores. 24 won. • 42 candidates spent more than 5 crores and less than 10 crores. 22 won. • 12 candidates spent more than 10 crores and less than 20 crores. 3 won. • 11 candidates spent 20 crores or more. 8 won. Source: YouthNet
Net representatives. Of all the parties in the fray, the NPF spent the highest, a boggling amount of Rs. 486,08,97,500/- (Rupees four hundred and eighty six crore, eight lakh, ninety seven thousand and
five hundred) on the 60 constituencies it contested in, notes the YouthNet study. The second position in the hall of shame was taken by the INC, which spent Rs. 217,26,15,000/(Rupees two hundred and
seventeen crore, twenty six lakh and fifteen thousand) in the 55 constituencies it contested in. Both parties have spent nearly double what they spent in 2008. That noted, however, “every political party has
failed miserably to uphold the elections code of conduct,” stated the report, given the corresponding amounts spent by them. If the figures are to be averaged out, candidates in Dimapur district spent Rs. 30 crore for each seat in 5 constituencies. This is the highest average among all the districts. On the other hand, the lowest average expenditure was incurred in the 7 constituencies of Tuensang district, where each seat cost the candidates Rs.6 crore on an average. These averages need to be taken with a pinch of salt, however, as while the highest expenditure by any candidate was recorded at Rs. 40,00,00,000/- (Rupees forty crore), the lowest was Rs. 15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand), both from Zunheboto. Neither of them won but the average expenditure on each seat of the 7 constituencies of Zunheboto has been calculated at Rs. 23 crore. But based on the statistics, one cannot blame politicians and their parties alone. People have also used the election time to fill up their pockets unscrupulously. The average amount spent on households by these candidates, for instance, has been pitted at Rs. 10,000-20,000.
In Mokokchung, some households are reported to have received Rs. 10 lakh or more. Similarly, the average amount spent per vote all over the State is between Rs. 2,000 to Rs. 5,000, with a voter in Mokokchung receiving as much as Rs. 1 lakh! No doubt, given that average expenditure for each seat in the 10 constituencies of Mokokchung District comes to Rs. 23 crore. How these figures managed to escape the notice of the Election Commission of India is inexplicable. The only silver lining to be seen in the report is the ironic statistic that both in 2008 and 2013, candidates recorded to have spent the highest have lost. Nonetheless, the figures quoted here amply substantiate how the disruptive election cycle brings about the even more damaging habit of corrupt practices to fuel each election. As YouthNet puts it, the vicious circle can only continue in this way: wealth drainage during election --- rampant corruption of cut/share system from funds meant for development --- no development/no productivity --- stagnation of job both in the public and private sector --- unemployment and poverty--- same system of election.
corruption is a cancer; it must Government not taking be destroyed: Governor Kumar demands seriously: ensf Chief Minister Neiphiu Rio is scheduled to grace the valedictory function at 2:00 PM on November 8.
“Political will important for anti-corruption”
Governor Dr. Ashwani Kumar along with participants of the 1st North East Conference of Heads’ of Vigilance & Anti–Corruption Bureau in Kohima on Thursday. (Morung Photo)
Chizokho Vero Kohima | November 7
“Corruption is an evil. It is a cancer. It must be destroyed completely,” asserted Dr Ashwani Kumar while addressing the 1st North East Conference of Heads’ of Vigilance & Anti –Corruption Bureau on ‘Anti-corruption- difficulties & challenges’ at the Capital Convention Centre, Kohima on November 7. He asserted that the best and the easiest way to fight corruption is through science and technology. He pointed out that the cancer of corruption must be destroyed scientifically and morally. Dr. Kumar said corruption is not only a crime, as per PC Act, IPC or other laws but “is a morale offence, it is an ethical crime.” “Unless you have the support of public, you will be left alone in the fight against corruption,” he said and stressed on the need to concentrate on youth, civil society and religious organization for obtaining public support. “Today money has been allowed to assume so much importance that it has adversely impacted our morals. In elections, money has become the main driving and deciding force. That is why it is said we have the government we deserve,” he said. Dr. Kumar also challenged the gathering to start a campaign from January 1 2014 in all schools, colleges, civil society organizations and churches/temples in the north east to resolve, “I shall not pay bribe.” For the last 50/60 years, he stated that “vigilance has concen-
trated on the demand side, the bribe takers. Let us now concentrate on the bribe givers. I think we will have greater success with them.” “If every morning, in school assembly and before every gathering or congregation, a pledge is taken that we shall not pay bribe and expose all bribe takers, then only corruption can be contained,” he said. He maintained that Parliament is the “most transparent and most accountable and may be the most honest or the least corrupt.” He said it is parliament which has been in the forefront to fight corruption. The Governor said the Parliament has thrown out its MPs for taking cash for questions, has passed the anti-defection laws, RTI, Money Laundering Acts and the 91st Amendment to restrict the size of cabinets/ ministries to 15% only. He urged that heads of vigilance and anti- corruption bureau at the conference to probe, investigate, gather evidence, have full information and put it on record. Encouraging them to state the truth, the Governor said “Don’t shout from the house top. To punish someone, or hold someone guilty is not your job. To tell the truth and nothing but the truth, is your job.” He called for absolute transparency in their conduct and methods. Earlier, Besesayo Kezo, DGP and vigilance commissioner Nagaland delivered the welcome address while a speech was delivered by R. Sri Kumar, vigilance commissioner, Central Vigilance Commission, Delhi. The inaugural function was chaired by Chief Secretary, Alemtemshi Jamir.
R. Sri Kumar, Vigilance Commissioner, Central Vigilance Commission, Delhi, at the 1st North East Conference of Heads’ of Vigilance & Anti–Corruption Bureau which began today in Kohima has stated that the most important part of any anti-corruption strategy is political will. He added that unless political will is explicitly started and acted upon, without fear or favour, no anti corruption strategy can succeed. He also stressed on the need to seek compulsory inclusion of anti-corruption strategy in all election manifestoes of political parties. “We also need to spell out an evaluation and monitoring mechanism for this purpose,” he said. Kumar informed that strategies to contain corruption would involve leveraging technology and crowd sourcing and citizen empowerment, and informed that legislating a whistleblower law to encourage people to report corruption cases without fear of a backlash is on the way. He said it is essential to rethink current practices, revise anti corruption strategies and come up with concrete plans of action. Nagaland DGP and Vigilance Commissioner, Besesayo Kezo said that in spite of positive impacts of flagship programmes such as MGNREGA, RTE Act, NRHM and the Food Security Bill, “it is our experience that such programmes are fraught with misutilization or mismanagement.” Kezo revealed that the number of complaints against corruption has come down but the amount of embezzlement has increased from few thousands to several crores of rupees. He said the fight against corruption, fraud, misdemeanor and misconduct should be a joint and coordinated effort of the vigilance and anti corruption bureau, the state police, treasury, audit, banks and all concerned government departments.
ENSF Pamphlets demanding the fulfillment of the four-point ultimatum to the Nagaland Government are seen pasted at a vegetable market at Chare, Tuensang. The four-point ultimatum concerns the Niathu Resort Agreement, TET-SCERT, Mid-Day Meal and Conversion of NAPs to DEFs.
Our Correspondent Tuensang | November 7
Along with the other three eastern districts, Tuensang on November 7 observed the third day of the Phase-1 ENSF agitation peacefully. Talking to The Morung Express, Shasha L Menhahu, President of ENSF said that the organization disagrees with the reasons provided by the Government to the ultimatum submitted by ENSF on October 10. The Government in its reply to the 4th Ultimatum had stated that “although the Government had taken decision to convert one Coy each of NAP Bns to DEF, the decision have been kept in abeyance as decided by the cabinet”. Contradictorily, the letter continues to state that “however, the Government is working out a redeployment plan so that all the outposts and police stations are manned adequately”. Shasha slammed the Government for not taking its demands seriously and said they do not want any more letters from the Government but implementation of its demands. “It’s like playing with a child,” he added. In this regard, he remarked that the Government has made many backdoor and random appointments and are trying to redeploy them in the DEFs. ENSF reminded the government that a total of “7 new police stations; 7 police outposts upgraded to police stations and 7 new police out-posts was established during the year 2012-13.” The government however did not create any posts for manning the new establishments
but instead redeployed 1176 NAP to the DEF. ENSF in its ultimatum no. 4 demanded the Government cancel the Government order for conversion and transfer of eight Coys of NAP Battalion from 1st NAP to 8th NAP Personnel into DEF Staffs. It demanded that new posts be created for manning the establishment of the new police station, police out posts and upgraded outposts against the existing PSs and outposts which have shortage of police personnel. It called for fresh recruitment against the establishment of the new police station, police out posts and upgraded outposts against the existing PSs and OPs which have shortage of police personnel. The ENSF team submitted memorandums to Tuensang DC, T. Mhabemo Yanthan regarding the conversion of NAPs to DEFs, Niathu Resort Agreement, TET-SCERT and Mid-Day Meal to be further forwarded. Confederation of Chang Students Union (CCSU) also submitted representations and memorandum supporting the same. Meanwhile, CCSU submitted two representations to the Deputy Commissioner. It stated that GHS Thangjam had been upgraded to higher secondary level some years back but was non-functional. It reminded that the representation submitted by the frontal organizations of Eastern Nagaland to the Chief Minister on March 3 demanded that NH-155 (202) be handed over from the Nagaland Public Work Department to Boarder Road Organization. These matters need to be dealt with at the earliest, it urged.
C M Y K