Wp u 201601

Page 1

Š5

34567

% & ˚ % H

6 > 5:

34567 Vol. 137, No. 1

S`*3 V*3/\-\ ,m]daV* , `*4Zmf e\`Y*b*fB 9< =<; >>> Ë™\abd]1Z Z* 698 )Ë›%

No. 1 2016

RUSSIAN

% Ë™ Ëš ËšH Ë? w b\`\31,*q +*jZqx ]`\aW*,Wq1b \-* 1-\,d P `*,Sb1Wq a1W1ZZ\yD 'b\b 3d`Z*W db1j*1b Wp/1y +W*-\y ,1abnp \ b\YE hb\ \3n1 Z1+1aZ\1 *`ab,\ ,aV\`1 ]\V\ZhSb a\ ,a1Y 4W\Y S ,aq 41YWq ab*Z1b `*1YD Z dV`1]Wq1b ,1`d , Sada* `Sab*E V\b\`my dY1`E hb\+m Ym Y\-WS \+`1abS ,1hZdp 3S4ZnE S V\b\`my a1yh*a ]`*,Sb V*V *`n \3n1-\ *`ab,*D 'b\b 3d`Z*W S4/*1baq Z1]`1`m,Z\ a 5<;= -\/*D Z ]\WSbSh1aVS Z1yb`*W1Z S ]\WZ\abnp \aZ\,*Z Z* S+WSS

Ë?1W*1b1 WS ,m ]\WdhSbn +\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS SWS f\bSb1E hb\+m a ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\an +1a]W*bZ\1 /\Y*jZ11 S4dh1ZS1 S+WSSH \a1bSb1 a*yb www.jw.org/ru SWS Z*]SjSb1 ]\ \/Z\Yd S4 dV*4*ZZmf ZS31 */`1a\, Ëš &B 1WS-S\4Z\1 \+l1/SZ1ZS1 ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , 1a]d+WSV1 1W*`danE 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq = )B ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,mE */q 5<6E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E 5=>>>> B ;=8=5E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE *Na =99 \WZmy a]Sa\V */`1a\, aY\b`Sb1 Z* a*yb1 www.jw.org/ru/a,q4*bnaq

b*W +m YS` Wdhj1E 1aWS +m ,a1 aW1/\O ,*WS ob\Yd +S+W1yaV\Yd ]`SZgS]dH w mDDD ,\ ,a1Y f\bSY ,1abS a1+q h1abZ\x LËš,`1qY 57B5<MD ob\Y ,m]daV1 w b\`\31,\y +*jZSx \+ad3/*1baqE V*V h1abZ\abn ,WSq1b Z* ,a1 ab\`\Zm Z*j1y 3S4ZSD

b\Sb WS +mbn h1abZmYH

1abZ\abn +\Wnj1 Z1 , Y\/1H 7 *V Z1h1abZ\abn ,WSq1b Z* ,*a 8 \h1Yd ab\Sb +mbn h1abZmY :

• Ëš Ë?Ëš S+WSq Y1Zq1b 3S4Zn

˙*y YZ1 f\bq +m \/SZ -\/ a]\V\yZ\y 3S4ZS < ˛Z*1b1 WS ,mH 5> *V +\`\bnaq a hd,ab,\Y Z14*kSk1ZZ\abS 55 ˙`1,Zqq Yd/`\abn /Wq a\,`1Y1ZZ\y 3S4ZS

1 +1a]\V\yb1an 59

b\ -\,\`Sb S+WSqH 5:

˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙˙

1a]W*bZ\D 'b\ S4/*ZS1 P h*abn ,a1YS`Z\y +S+W1yaV\y ]`\a,1bSO b1WnZ\y /1qb1WnZ\abSE V\b\`*q ]`\,\/Sbaq f`SabS*ZaVSYS ,S/1O b1WqYS 1-\,m S ]\//1`3S,*1baq /\+`\,\WnZmYS ]\31`b,\,*ZSqYS ËšaWS Z1 dV*4*Z\ SZ*h1E +S+W1yaVS1 gSb*bm ,4qbm S4 w ,qk1ZZ\-\ Sa*ZSq P 1`1,\/* Z\,\-\ YS`*x

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) Issue 1 January 2016 is published monthly with an additional issue published in January, March, May, July, September, and November by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; L. Weaver, Jr., President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 1000 Red Mills Road, Wallkill, NY 12589-3299. 5 Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft, Selters/Ts., V. i. S. d. P. Ramon Templeton, Selters/Ts. 5 2016 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. Printed in Germany

s

• ˚ •

˚ % ˙ ˚ ˚• ˚ %

\31b WS YZ1 ]\Y\hn S+WSqE 1aWS d Y1Zq /1]`1aaSqH

r

L Y\b`Sb1 ,VW*/Vd ˚• ˚ ˚ ) ˛ ˚ % ˚• ˚ %M

˚ ˝

1abZ\abn +\Wnj1 Z1 , Y\/1H

Sb\aS `*+\b*W +df-*Wb1`\Y , *-1Zbab,1 ]\ b`d/\dab`\yab,d , )]\ZSSD \-/* \Z ]`\,1`qW eSZ*Za\,my \bh1bE Z*h*WnZSV ]\]`\aSW 1-\ ]\//1W*bn /*ZZm1D

Sb\aS \+lqaZSWE hb\ a\,1abn Z1 ]\4,\Wq1b 1Yd ]\abd]Sbn Z1h1abZ\D ˚Yd ]`S-`\4SWS d,\WnZ1ZS1YE S , Sb\-1 \Z /1yab,Sb1WnZ\ ]\b1`qW `*+\bdD

W1/dpkS1 Z1aV\WnV\ Y1aqg1, Sb\aS aSWnZ\ ]1O `13S,*W S4O4* b\-\E hb\ ZSVd/* Z1 Y\- dab`\SbnaqD /Z*3/m ,\ ,`1Yq a\+1a1/\,*ZSq \Z d]\YqZdWE hb\ Z1 Y\31b ,m]\WZqbn Z1h1abZdp `*+\bdD * ob\ a\b`d/ZSV V\Y]*ZSS aV*4*WB w *V\yOb\ ,m ab`*ZO ZmyIx ˙`d4nq S `\/ab,1ZZSVS ]\+d3/*WS Sb\aS Z1 aZS3*bn ]W*ZVdE Z\ d Z1-\ ]\q,SWSan Z1V\b\O `m1 a\YZ1ZSqD *]`SY1`E \Z V*VOb\ aV*4*WB w) d31 Z1 4Z*pE /1yab,Sb1WnZ\ WS ab\Sb -\,\`Sbn \ b\YE hb\ q ]`S/1`3S,*pan b*VSf ab`\-Sf ]`SZgS]\,xD Wdh*y a Sb\aS a,S/1b1Wnab,d1b \ b`1,\3Z\y b1Z/1ZgSS P /Wq YZ\-Sf h1abZ\abn b1`q1b a,\p ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abnD *]`SY1`E Z1V\b\`m1 /*31 ,\a]`SZSY*pb 11 V*V ]\Y1fdE \a\+1ZZ\ , /1W\O ,\y ae1`1D w) ]\ab\qZZ\ ab*WVS,*pan a Z1h1abO ZmYS Wp/nYSEP -\,\`Sb \/Z* `*+\b*pk*q 31ZO kSZ* S4 ( EP S SZ\-/* \h1Zn b`d/Z\ ]`\bS,\O ab\qbn /*,W1ZSp ]\abd]*bn V*V ,a1xD

/Z* S4 e\`Y Z1h1abZ\abS a1-\/Zq \a\+1ZZ\ `*a]`\ab`*Z1Z*D 'b\ W\3nD 1aV\WnV\ W1b Z*4*/ , f\/1 SaaW1/\,*ZSqE ]`\,1/1ZZ\-\ ]aSf\W\-\Y \+1`b\Y 1Wn/Y*Z\Y S4 *aa*hda1baV\-\ dZSO ,1`aSb1b* , Yf1`ab1E ,mqaZSW\anE hb\ :> ]`\O g1Zb\, ,4`\aWmf ,\ ,`1Yq `*4-\,\`* W-db ]\ Y1Znj1y Y1`1 `*4 , /1aqbn YSZdbD w 14dWnb*O bm Z*a \h1Zn d/S,SWSEP -\,\`Sb 1Wn/Y*ZDP m Z1 \3S/*WSE hb\ W\3n d31 ab*W* Z1\bl1YW1O Y\y h*abnp Z*j1y 3S4ZSxD 1 V*31baq WS ,*Y ]*O `*/\Va*WnZmYE hb\ +\WnjSZab,\ Wp/1y Z1Z*,SO /qbE V\-/* SY W-dbE Z\ ]`S ob\Y a*YS \+Y*Zm,*pb /`d-SfH \h1Yd W\3nE ,\`\,ab,\ S /`d-S1 e\`Ym Z1O h1abZ\abS b*V `*a]`\ab`*Z1Zm a1-\/ZqH *V Z1O h1abZ\abn ,WSq1b Z* \+k1ab,\ , g1W\YH hb\ +\O W11 ,*3Z\E V*V Z1 ]\//*bnaq ob\y Z*+S`*pk1y \+\`\bm b1Z/1ZgSSH Š 5 6>5:

7

*V Z1h1abZ\abn ,WSq1b Z* ,*a w 3S4ZS ,a1-/* +d/db Z1]`\abm1 aSbd*gSSE S4 V\b\`mf Y\3Z\ ,mybSE Z1YZ\-\ ]`S,`*,x L *Y*Zb*E ( MD \-W*aZm WS ,m a obSY ,maV*4m,*ZS1YH \/\+Z\ *Y*Zb1E ,a1 Ym ,`1Yq \b ,`1Y1ZS ab*WVS,*1Yaq a b`d/ZmYS aSbd*gSqYSD b\E V*V Ym ,1/1Y a1+qE V\-/* ,\4ZSV*1b SaVdj1ZS1 ]\abd]Sbn Z1h1abZ\E ]\V*4m,*1bE V*VS1 d Z*a 3S4Z1ZZm1 ]`S\`Sb1bmD *]`SY1`E 1aWS Ym ,a1YS aSW*YS ab`1YSYaq a\O f`*ZSbn a,\p `1]db*gSpE Ym Y\31Y \bZ\aSbnaq V Z1h1abZ\abS V*V V 1k1 \/Z\Yd a`1/ab,d /Wq /\O abS31ZSq ob\y g1WSD \ V\-/* W\3n ,aV`\1baqE ob\ Y\31b Z*Y /\`\-\ ab\SbnD

˚ ˚ & ˛ " ˚ ˙ ˚ ˚ bZ\j1ZSq \+mhZ\ ab`\qbaq Z* /\,1`SSD \-O /* /,* h1W\,1V* /\,1`qpb /`d- /`d-dE d ZSf ]\q,O Wq1baq hd,ab,\ 4*kSk1ZZ\abS S Z*/13Z\abSD \ /\,1`S1 Z1 Y\31b ,\4ZSVZdbn , \/Z\h*an1D p/S `*4,S,*pb /\,1`S1E V\-/* ,Y1ab1 ]`\,\/qb ,`1YqE -\,\`qb /`d- /`d-d ]`*,/d S ]`\q,Wqpb +1aV\`mO abS1D \ \/SZ Z1h1abZmy ]\abd]\V Y\31b a,1abS Z* Z1b ,a1 daSWSqD V\-/* /\,1`S1 `*4`dj1Z\E ,\aab*Z\,Sbn 1-\ V`*yZ1 aW\3Z\D 8

˝˚ ) " )

+Y*Zm,*W WS ,*a V\-/*OZS+d/n b\bE V\-\ ,m ahSb*WS +WS4VSY /`d-\YH ˚aWS /*E hb\ ,m b\-/* hd,ab,\,*WSH V\`11 ,a1-\E +mW\ +\WnZ\E +mW\ \kdk1ZS1E hb\ ,*a ]`1/*WSD ,*jS hd,ab,* Y\3O Z\ ]\ZqbnD 1h1abZ\abn /1yab,Sb1WnZ\ Y\31b ]\O /\`,*bn /\,1`S1 P \aZ\,d /\+`mf \bZ\j1ZSyD

˚ ˚ & ˝˙ ˚ ˚ ˚ &

aaW1/\,*ZSqE ]`\,1/1ZZm1 \+1`b\Y ZZ1O a\YE ]`\e1aa\`\Y oV\Z\YSVS *WSe\`ZSyaV\-\ dZS,1`aSb1b*E ]\V*4*WSE hb\ wZ1h1abZ\abn P ,1kn 4*`*4Z*qxD ˚1 Y\3Z\ a`*,ZSbn a ,S`da\Y P h1Y h*k1 h1W\,1V \+k*1baq a Z1h1abZmYS Wp/nYSE b1Y ,mj1 `SaV w4*`*4SbnaqxD *V Z1 ]\/f,*bSbn ,S`da Z1h1abZ\abSH ob\Y Z*Y Y\31b ]\Y\hn S+WSqD ˙*,*yb1 `*aaY\b`SY Z1aV\WnV\ +S+W1yaVSf ]`SZgS]\,D

\`Ym Z1h1abZ\abS \3n ' ËšH \\+k1ZS1 Z1,1`Zmf a,1/1ZSy b\YdE Vb\ SY11b ]`*,\ 4Z*bn ]`*,/dD \3n Y\31b ,VWph*bn , a1+q SaV*31ZS1 e*Vb\, a g1Wnp ,,1abS V\-\Ob\ , 4*+Wd3/1ZS1C a\V`mbS1 ,*3Z\y SZe\`Y*gSSE hb\+m \+Y*Zdbn /`d-SfE * b*V31 ]`SdV`*jS,*ZS1 /1yab,Sb1WnZ\abS a Z*Y1`1ZS1Y ]`\S4,1abS f\`\j11 ,]1h*bW1O ZS1D )D w \,*`Zmy h1W\,1V \b,`*bSb1W1Z /Wq 1-\,mE * a h1abZmYS d Z1-\ /\,1`Sb1WnZm1 \bZ\j1ZSqx L `SbhS 7B76MD w 1]1`nE V\-/* ,m \bW\3SWS W\3nE -\,\`Sb1 SabSZd V*3/my a,\1Yd +WS3Z1Ydx L'e1aqZ*Y 8B69MD

W1,1b* ' ËšH *a]`\ab`*Z1ZS1 4*,1/\Y\ W\3Zmf a,1/1ZSyE ]\/`m,*pkSf hnpOWS+\ `1]db*gSpD )D w Zb`S-*Z a11b `*4/\`mE S VW1,1bZSV `*4Wdh*1b +WS4VSf /`d41yx L `SbhS 5:B6<MD w /1 Z1b /`\,E \-\Zn -*aZ1bE S -/1 Z1b VW1,1bZSV*E aa\`* dbSf*1bx L `SbhS 6:B6>MD

\j1ZZSh1ab,\ ' ËšH Ë›*,W*/1ZS1 hd3SYS /1Zn-*YS SWS SYdk1ab,\Y \+Y*ZZmY ]db1YD )D w 1 \+Y*Zm,*y Z*1YZ\-\ `*+\bZSV*E V\b\`my Z*f\/Sbaq , b`d/Zmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*f S +1/1Zx L b\`\O 4*V\ZS1 68B58E 59MD w b\ \+Y*Zm,*1b ZSk1-\E b\b ]\`\hSb 1-\ \4/*b1WqE * Vb\ +W*-\aVW\Z1Z V +1/Z\YdE b\b ]`\aW*,Wq1b Ëš-\x L `SbhS 58B75MD

\`\,ab,\ ' ËšH `Sa,\1ZS1 hd3\-\ SYdk1ab,* +14 `*4`1j1ZSqD )D w b\ V`*WE ]dabn +\Wnj1 Z1 V`*/1bE * Wdhj1 da1`/Z\ b`d/SbaqE /1W*q a,\SYS `dV*YS ]\W14Z\1E hb\O +m 1Yd +mW\ h1Y ]\/1WSbnaq a Zd3/*pkSYaqx L'e1aqZ*Y 8B6<MD w 1 4*+Wd3/*yb1anD DDD S ,\`mE ZS 3*/Zm1E ZS ]nqZSgmE ZS 4W\O aW\,qkS1 /`d-SfE ZS ,mY\-*b1WS Z1 Z*aW1/dpb g*`ab,* \-*x L5 \`SZeqZ*Y :B=E 5>MD

Å 5 6>5:

9

\h1Yd ab\Sb +mbn h1abZmY w m d,1`1ZmE hb\ SY11Y hSabdp a\,1abnE b*V V*V ,\ ,a1Y f\bSY ,1abS a1+q h1abZ\x LËš,`1qY 57B5<MD

ab`1h*pk11aq , S+WSS /`1,Z1-`1h1aV\1 aW\O ,\E V\b\`\1 SZ\-/* ]1`1,\/Sbaq V*V wh1abZ\abnxE +dV,*WnZ\ \4Z*h*1b wb\E hb\ ]\SabSZ1 f\`\j\xD Z\ b*V31 Y\31b \4Z*h*bn hb\Ob\ \h1Zn V`*aSO ,\1 , Z`*,ab,1ZZ\Y \bZ\j1ZSSD `SabS*Z1 a1`n14Z\ \bZ\aqbaq V +\-\,/\fZ\O ,1ZZmY aW\,*Y *]\ab\W* *,W*B w mDDD ,\ ,a1Y f\bSY ,1abS a1+q h1abZ\xD b\ , ob\ ,VWph*1baqH Ëš )) &

*3/\1 db`\E ]1`1/ b1Y V*V ,mybS Z* dWSgdE +\WnjSZab,\ Wp/1y aY\b`Sbaq , 41`V*W\D ˙Wq h1-\H ZS f\bqb ,m-Wq/1bn V*V Y\3Z\ Wdhj1D \ 1abn hb\Ob\ +\W11 ,*3Z\1E h1Y abSWnZ*q ]`Sh1O aV* SWS Y\/Z*q \/13/*D \E V*VS1 Ym ,Zdb`SE Y\O 31b WS+\ /\+*,Sbn Z*Y ]`S,W1V*b1WnZ\abSE WSO +\ WSjSbn Z*a 11D W\,1 \-* \bV`mb\ -\,\`SbaqE hb\ d Wp/1y 1abn aVW\ZZ\abn ]\abd]*bn ]W\f\D w 1`/g1 h1W\O ,1V* a a*Y\y pZ\abS aVW\ZZ\ V 4WdxEP aV*4*Z\ , mbSS <B65D \ob\YdE hb\+m \ab*,*bnaq h1abZmO YSE Ym /\W3Zm +\`\bnaq a ,`\3/1ZZmYS -`1jO ZmYS ]\+d3/1ZSqYSD \b V*V *]\ab\W *,1W \]SO a*W a\+ab,1ZZdp +\`n+d a -`1f\YB w \ ,Zdb`1ZO Z1Yd h1W\,1Vd q Z*f\3d d/\,\Wnab,S1 , 4*V\Z1 \-*E Z\ , a,\Sf hW1Z*f ,S3d /`d-\y 4*V\ZE ]`\O bS,\+\`ab,dpkSy 4*V\Zd Y\1-\ dY* S /1W*pkSy Y1Zq ]W1ZZSV\Y 4*V\Z* -`1f*E V\b\`my Z*f\/SbO aq , Y\Sf hW1Z*fx L SYWqZ*Y ;B66E 67MD \-/* Z*j1 a1`/g1 ]\/b*WVS,*1b Z*a V ]W\f\O Yd S d Z*a ]\q,Wq1baq aSWnZ\1 SaVdj1ZS1 ]\O abd]Sbn Z1h1abZ\E Ym Z1 \+q4*Zm `*+aVS ]\/hSO Zqbnaq 31W*ZSqY a1`/g*D Z*a ,a1-/* 1abn ,mO +\`D b,1`-*q Z1]`*,SWnZm1 YmaWSE Ym Y\31Y \ab*,*bnaq h1abZmYSE Z1aY\b`q Z* g*`qkdp ,\O V`d- Z1h1abZ\abnD

:

Ë?Ëš ) " )

%• ˚˙ ˚ ˚

b\+m +mbn h1abZmYSE Z*Y Zd31Z h1bVSy Y\O `*WnZmy V\/1VaD \ V a\3*W1ZSpE YZ\-S1 Wp/S +\Wnj1 `*+\b*pb Z*/ a,\SY SYS/31YE h1Y Z*/ Z`*,ab,1ZZmY \+WSV\YD \ob\YdE V*V b\WnV\ 4*O f\/Sb `1hn \ ,m-\/1E \ZS -\b\,m \]`*,/*bn Z1O +\Wnjdp Z1h1abZ\abnD \b hb\ \+ ob\Y -\,\`SbO aq , VZS-1 w 1abZ*q ]`*,/* \ Z1h1abZ\abSxB w \ adbSE Ym ]`S+1-*1Y V \+Y*Zd `\,Z\ , b\y Y1`1E , V*V\y ob\ ]\4,\Wq1b Z*Y \ab*,*bnaq , a,\Sf -W*O 4*f +\W11 SWS Y1Z11 h1abZmYS Wp/nYSx LThe Honest Truth About DishonestyMD \ adk1ab,dO 1b WS Z*/13Zmy ab*Z/*`bE ]\Y\-*pkSy \]`1O /1WSbn /\]dabSYmy ]`1/1W Z1h1abZ\abSE 1aWS \ b*V\Y ]`1/1W1 ,\\+k1 Y\3Z\ -\,\`SbnH ah*O abnpE b*V\y ab*Z/*`b 1abnD

SWWS\Zm Wp/1y ]\ ,a1Yd YS`d ahSb*pbE hb\ /Wq ob\y `\WS ]`1V`*aZ\ ]\/f\/Sb S+WSqD Z1y a\/1`3Sbaq Z1]`1,4\y/1ZZmy Y\`*WnZmy V\/1Va L a*W\Y 5=B;MD Z* /*1b Z*/13Z\1 `dV\O ,\/ab,\ , \bZ\j1ZSS a1Y1yZ\y 3S4ZSE `*+\bmE

Z`*,ab,1ZZ\abS S /df\,Z\abSD S+WSq ,m/1`3*O W* ]`\,1`Vd ,`1Y1Z1YD Ëš1 4*V\Zm S ]`SZgS]m ]`SY1ZSYm /Wq Wp/1y ,a1f Z*gS\Z*WnZ\ab1y S `*aD 4dh1ZS1 S+WSSE `*4YmjW1ZS1 Z*/ 11 aW\O ,*YS S ]`SY1Z1ZS1 11 a\,1b\, ]\Y\31b Z*Y ]`SO dhSbn a,\1 a1`/g1 V h1abZ\abSD

,a1 31E hb\+m \/1`3*bn ]\+1/d , +\`n+1 a Z1h1abZ\abnpE \/ZSf 4Z*ZSy S4 S+WSS Z1/\ab*O b\hZ\D 1/n Ym 3S,1Y , `*4,`*k1ZZ\Y YS`1E V\O b\`my ]mb*1baq ,bSaZdbn Z*a , a,\S `*YVSD \oO b\Yd Z*Y Zd3Z\ Y\WSbnaq \-d \ ]\Y\kS S ]\/O /1`3V1 L SWS]]Syg*Y 8B:E ;E 57MD \-/* d Z*a +d/1b aY1W\abnE hb\+m ]\abd]*bn ]`*,SWnZ\ S ,\ ,a1Y ,1abS a1+q h1abZ\D Ë™ Ë› Ëš &

Sb\aSE \ V\b\`\Y -\,\`SW\an , ]1`,\y ab*O bn1E +mW ,\4Z*-`*3/1Z 4* a,\p ]\`q/\hZ\abnD 1yh*a \Z `*+\b*1b b*YE -/1 Z*h*Wnab,\ g1ZSb 1-\ h1abZ\abnD Sb\aS -\,\`SbB w) b*V `*/E hb\ aY\- Z*ybS `*+\bdE V\b\`*q ]\4,\Wq1b YZ1 a\O f`*Zqbn hSabdp a\,1abnIx Ë™`d-S1 b\31 Sa]mbm,*pb b*VS1 hd,ab,*D *aO aY\b`SY ]`SY1`m b1fE V\Yd ]`SY1Z1ZS1 +S+W1yO aVSf ]`SZgS]\, ]`SZ1aW\ `1*WnZdp ]\Wn4dD

Sab*q a\,1abn w 57 W1b q +`\aSW* jV\Wd S a,q4*W*an a ,\`*YSD `*VbSh1O aVS ,a1E hb\ q SY1W*E +mW\ /\+mb\ Z1h1abZmY ]db1YD \4O /Z11 q ,mjW* 4*Yd3E S Ym a Yd31Y ab*WS S4dO h*bn S+WSp a\ ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,mD m d4Z*O WSE hb\ \- 1-\,*1 Z1Z*,S/Sb Z1h1abZ\abnE S ]\ob\Yd `1jSWS ]\`,*bn a ]`\jWmYD 5==> -\O /d Ym ]\a,qbSWS a,\p 3S4Zn 1-\,1 S V`1abSO WSan V*V 1-\ ,S/1b1WS L `SbhS :B5:P5=MD *Znj1 Y\y /\Y +mW +dV,*WnZ\ Z*+Sb V`*/1O ZmYS ,1k*YSE Z\ a1yh*a , Y\1y 3S4ZS ,a1 ]\O /`d-\YdE S b1]1`n d Y1Zq hSab*q a\,1abnD a]\O YSZ*q a,\1 V`SYSZ*WnZ\1 ]`\jW\1E q \h1Zn +W*-\/*`Z*E hb\ 1-\,* ]`\q,SW V\ YZ1 \-`\YO 1 \-W*aZ\ S+WSSE 1-\,* P ob\ SYq \-*D

Z\1 YSW\a1`/S1D *V ]`SqbZ\ 4*am]*bn V*3/dp Z\hnE 4Z*qE hb\ 1-\,* YZ\y /\,\W1Zx L"1`SWE

`W*Z/SqMD w \-/* /S`1Vb\` d4Z*WE hb\ q \bV*4*Waq +`*bn ,4qbVd d ]\b1ZO gS*WnZ\-\ 4*V*4hSV*E \Z aV*O 4*WB t S/Z\E hb\ bm b*V\y h1abO Zmy +W*-\/*`q a,\1Yd \-dD

m ah*abWS,mE hb\ bm `*+\b*O 1jn , Z*j1y V\Y]*ZSSIr ) ,\ ,a1Y ab*`*pan ]\O abd]*bn h1abZ\E S ob\ ]\Y\-*1b YZ1 a\f`*Zqbn hSabdp a\,1abn ]1`1/ 1-\,\yD `\Y1 b\-\E q Y\-d a\ a,\+\/\y aW\,* ]\+d3/*bn V h1abZ\O Yd \+`*4d 3S4ZS a,\p a1Ynp S /`d-Sfx L \ZZSE \ZV\Z-MD

˙dj1,Zmy ]\V\y w) `*+\b*p , Y13/dZ*`\/Z\Y +*ZV1D ob\y ae1`1 ]`S+mWn h*ab\ ,*3Z11 h1abZ\abSD Z\O -S1 /dY*pbB t 1+\Wnj*q Z1O h1abZ\abn ZSV\Yd Z1 ]\,`1/SbE 1aWS \Z* ]`SZ\O aSb ]`S+mWn S ]\Y\-*1b aoV\Z\YSbnrD \ h1abO Z\abn ]\4,\Wq1b a\f`*ZSbn /dj1,Zmy ]\V\yD ) f\hd \ab*,*bnaq h1abZmYE Z1,4S`*q Z* ]\aW1/O ab,SqD *h*Wnab,\ 4Z*1bE hb\ q ZSV\-/* Z1 +d/d W-*bn SY SWS /Wq ZSfx L \YE " MD

*Y\d,*31ZS1 w dV\,\/Sb1Wn \b/1W* ]\]`\O aSW Y1Zq aV`mbn ]`*,/d \ ]`\O ]*31 Z1V\b\`mf b\,*`\,E Z\ q \bV*4*W*anD \-/* ,\`\, Z*jWSE Z*h*Wnab,\ ]\+W*-\/*`SW\ Y1Zq 4* h1abZ\abnD `1+d1baq aY1W\abnE hb\+m \ab*,*bnaq h1abZmY , Z1h1abZ\Y YS`1D \ , V\Z1hZ\Y ah1b1 h1abO Z\abn ]\Y\-*1b 4*aWd3Sbn /\,1`S1 S d,*31ZS1 /`d-Sfx L *\`SE )]\ZSqMD Sab*q a\,1abnE /dj1,Zmy ]\V\y S a*Y\d,*O 31ZS1 P ob\ /\ab\yZ*q Z*-`*/*E V\b\`*q ]\V*O 4m,*1bE hb\ d Z*a 1abn ,a1 ]`ShSZm +mbn h1abZmO YSD a obSY b`d/Z\ Z1 a\-W*aSbnaqE Z1 ]`*,/* WSH ˇ Š5 6>5:

;

) ˚ )˚ ˝ ˛ &

˙*y YZ1 f\bq +m \/SZ -\/ a]\V\yZ\y 3S4ZS

˛ ˚ ˙˝

˙ ˝˙˚ ) 5=;5 ˝˙˚ ) ) " % ˚

E ˚˙ ˚ O

˚˙% )D *j* a1Ynq 3SW* , 1WW*ZVd`1E /1`1,djV1 Z* a1,1`\O,\ab\V1 `*ZgSSD \y \b1g e`*Zgd4E * Y*bn Sb*WnqZO V*D \-/* YZ1 +mW\ ,\a1Yn W1bE Ym ]1`11f*WS , +1/Zmy `*y\Z Z* \V`*SZ1 SY* L b*WSqME -/1 3SWS ]`\abm1 `*+\hS1D +ab*O Z\,V* , a1Yn1 ab*W* \h1Zn Z*]`q31ZZ\yD \/Sb1WS ]\ab\qZZ\ aV*Z/*WSWS S4O4* ]`\+W1Y a /1Zn-*YSD

*Y* a\,1b\,*W* YZ1 ]\h*k1 ,mf\/Sbn S4 /\Y*E hb\+m Z*yO bS a1+1 /`d41yE ]\ob\Yd q ab*W ]\/\W-d ]`\]*/*bn Z* dWSg1D aV\`1 q a,q4*Waq a ]W\f\y V\Y]*ZS1yD \-/* YZ1 +mW\ 59 W1bE V\ YZ1 ]\/\j1W Yd3hSZ*E V\b\`my ,m-Wq/1W \h1Zn /`d31O Wp+ZmYE S ]`1/W\3SW ]\]`\+\,*bn Z*`V\bSVSD ) a\-W*aSWaqE b*V V*V f\b1W V*4*bnaq ,4`\aWmYD aV\`1 Y1ZqE V*V , 4m+dhS1 ]1aVSE 4*bqZdW\ , YS` Z*`V\bSV\, S +14Z`*,ab,1ZZ\abSD 1O aV\WnV\ `*4 Y1Zq Z*aSW\,*WSD ˝S4Zn ]\b1`qW* /Wq Y1Zq ,aqO VSy aYmaWD Z1 +mW\ ,a1 `*,Z\E hb\ a\ YZ\y +d/1bD ) +mW \h1Zn \/SZ\VD 5: W1b q ]\]mb*Waq ]\V\ZhSbn a a\+\y P ,mO ]SW +dbmWVd ,SaVS S ]`m-ZdW , \41`\D Sb\-1 q b`S /Zq ]`\O W13*W , V\Y1D \aW1 ob\-\ q Z*h*W g1ZSbn 3S4ZnE Z\ ]`S ob\Y ab*W 31ab\O VSY S W3S,mYD ) ]`1/W*-*W Wp/qY a1VaOdaWd-SD \-/* \ZS ]`S-W*j*WS Y1Zq /\Y\yE q ]\/am]*W SY Z*`V\bSVS S 4*+S`*W ,a1 g1ZZm1 ,1kSD `d]Zm1 ]`1abd]Zm1 -`d]]S`\,VS ]\`dh*O WS YZ1 b\`-\,*bn Z*`V\bSV*YS ]\ ,a1y b*WSSD Y1Zq h*ab\ +mWS ]`\+W1Ym a ]\WSgS1yD \q 3S4Zn V*4*W*an YZ1 +1aO aYmaW1ZZ\y S Z1d]`*,Wq1Y\yD \ ,a1 31 q ,1`SWE hb\ Z1 ]`\O ab\ b*V ]`Sj1W , ob\b YS`D ) Y\WSWaq \-d S ]`\aSW 1-\ /*bn YZ1 f\bq +m \/SZ -\/ a]\V\yZ\y S ah*abWS,\y 3S4ZSD ) ˛ ˚ ( ˝ ˛ &D 68 -\/* q `1jSW ]1O `1+`*bnaq , Z-WSpD \aV\WnVd q +mW a,q4*Z a Z*`V\b\`-\,O g*YSE Y\q 3S4Zn +mW* , \]*aZ\abSD 1`1/ \bl14/\Y q Z*,1O ‹ abSW Y*bn S \h1Zn d/S,SWaqE d,S/1, d Z11 ZdZaS*b\ d-*`*1D Z `*aaV*4m,*W Y\1y Y*b1`S \ S+WSSD ˛Z*q \ 1-\ V`SYSZ*WnO Z\Y ]`\jW\YE q Sa]d-*Waq S a]`\aSWE 4*h1Y \Z ]`Sj1WD Z aV*4*WE hb\ V\`1ZZmY \+`*4\Y S4Y1ZSW a,\p 3S4ZnE hb\+m ab*bn ,S/1b1W1Y 1-\,mD ZdZaS*b\ ,4qW a Y1Zq \+1k*ZS1 1 Y\b`Sb1 Sab\`Sp ZdZaS*b\ d-*`*‹ , ab*bn1 w S+WSq Y1Zq1b 3S4ZnD `S YZ1 ,a1-/* +mW ]Sab\W1bx , w b\`\31,\y +*jZ1x \b 5 SpWq 6>58 -\/*E ab`*ZSgm <P=D

<

˝˚ ) " )

*V 31 q `*/E hb\ \+`1W Z\`Y*WnZdp a1YnpE V\b\`\y b*V 3*3/*W\ Y\1 a1`/g1E S Wp+qk1-\ bg*E \ V\b\`\Y ,a1-/* Y1hb*WI

\+q4*b1WnZ\ ]\-\,\`Sbn a\ ,S/1b1WqYSE V\-/* q ]`S1/d , Z-WSpD \E \V*4*,jSan , Z-WSSE q bdb 31 ,1`ZdWaq V ]`13Z1Yd \+`*4d 3S4ZSD /Z*3/m Z* \/Z\y S4 \3S,W1ZZmf dWSg \ZO /\Z* q ,ab`1bSW ,S/1b1WqE V\b\`my ]`1/W*-*W 3d`Z*Wm w b\`\31,*q +*jZqx S w `\+d/Sb1anIxD a]\YZS, a,\1 \+1k*ZS1E q ]\]`\aSW b\-\ ,S/1O b1Wq S4dh*bn a\ YZ\y S+WSpD \E hb\ q d4Z*W S4 S+WSSE ]\`*4SW\ Y1Zq /\ -Wd+SZm /djSD *]`SY1`E Y1Zq \h1Zn 4*b`\ZdWS aW\,* S4 5 \*ZZ* 5B=E -/1 \ \-1 aV*4*Z\B w˚aWS Ym ]`S4Z*1Yaq , a,\Sf -`1f*fE \Z ]`\abSb Z*Y -`1fS S \hSabSb Z*axD 'b\b abSf ]`\S4,1W Z* Y1Zq Z1S4-W*/SY\1 ,]1h*bW1ZS1E ]\b\Yd hb\ q hd,ab,\O ,*W a1+q \h1Zn -`q4ZmY S4O4* a,\1-\ \+`*4* 3S4O ZSD ) a`*4d 31 ab*W ]\a1k*bn f`SabS*ZaVS1 ,ab`1O hS , ˛*W1 *`ab,* ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mD ,S/1b1O WS b1]W\ Y1Zq ]`SZqWSD \-/* q d,S/1WE V*V*q V`1]V*q Y13/d ZSYS /`d3+*EP b\E h1-\ q ,a1-/* b*V 3*3/*WEP YZ1 4*f\b1W\an ab*bn h*abnp Sf a\O +`*ZSqE ]\f\31-\ Z* a1YnpD

Z1 +mW\ Z1b`d/Z\ +`\aSbn Z*`V\bSVS S \ab*,Sbn +14Z`*,ab,1ZZmy \+`*4 3S4ZSD \`*4/\ aW\3Z11 +mW\ S4Y1ZSbn a,\p WShZ\abnD ) ]\ZqWE hb\ Zd3Z\ \bZ\aSbnaq V Wp/qY a d,*31ZS1Y S ,ZSY*ZS1YD 1abZ\ -\,\`qE YZ1 /\ aSf ]\` ]`Sf\O /Sbaq +\`\bnaq a Z1V\b\`mYS h1`b*YS a,\1y WShO Z\abSD \ a ]\Y\knp 1-\,m YZ1 d31 YZ\-\1 d/*O W\anD 1`14 j1abn Y1aqg1, ]\aW1 Z*h*W* S4dh1ZSq S+WSS q V`1abSWaq S ab*W ,S/1b1W1Y 1-\,mD 'b\ +mW\ , 5==; -\/dD

˛*b1Y S+WS1y 4*SZb1`1a\,*W*an a1ab`* Y\1y +*O +djVSE V\b\`\y +mW\ d31 4* <>D Z* da]1W* V`1O abSbnaq /\ a,\1y aY1`bSD 1yh*a q aWd3d ab*`1yjSZ\y , Y1abZ\Y f`SabSO *ZaV\Y a\+`*ZSS , \Z/\Z1D m a 31Z\y ]\a,qO k*1Y YZ\-\ ,`1Y1ZS ]`\]\,1/ZSh1aV\y /1qb1WnO Z\abSE S4dh*q S+WSp a Wp/nYSE V\b\`m1 -\,\`qb ]\OSb*WnqZaVSD \-/* Y1Zq Ydh*pb ,\a]\YSZ*O ZSq \ ]`\jW\YE *`+*`* ]\/+*/`S,*1b S db1j*1b Y1ZqD *V 31 q `*/E hb\ \+`1W Z\`Y*WnZdp a1YnpE V\b\`\y b*V 3*3/*W\ Y\1 a1`/g1E S Wp+qk1-\ bO g*E \ V\b\`\Y ,a1-/* Y1hb*WI ) ]`\aSW \-* /*bn YZ1 f\bq +m \/SZ -\/ a]\V\yZ\y S ah*abWS,\y 3S4ZSE * ]\WdhSW -\`*4/\ +\Wnj1I ˇ

" & ) ˝ ˛ &D \aW1 V`1O k1ZSq q 31ZSWaq Z* /1,djV1 ]\ SY1ZS *`+*`*E V\b\`*q b\31 Z1/*,Z\ ab*W* ,S/1b1W1Y 1-\,mD \-/* \/SZ S4 Y\Sf ab*`mf /`d41y d,S/1WE V*V aSWnZ\ q S4Y1ZSWaqE \Z Z*h*W S4dh*bn S+WSpD \ ,`1Y1Z1Y \Z S 1-\ a1ab`* ab*WS ,S/1b1WqYSD Š 5 6>5:

=

˛ ˚ ˚ %H

*V /1W*WS a,SbVS , +S+W1yaVS1 ,`1Y1Z* S V*V SYS ]\Wn4\,*WSanH

˛ ˝ ˚ ˚ ) ˚ ˚• • ' & LXVIII ˚ D 'DM 5 The Trustees of the Chester Beatty Library, Dublin

˚,*Z-1WSS \b dVS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ Sada \bV`mW a,Sb\V a*SSE ]`\hSb*W S4 Z1-\ S 4*b1Y a,1`ZdWD ]\ab\W \*ZZ , V\Zg1 a,\1-\ ˚,*Z-1WSq b\31 d]\YqZdW \ a,SbV1E aV*4*,E hb\ Z1 aY\- ,VWphSbn , Z1-\ ,a1 hd/1a*E V\b\`m1 a\,1`jSW Sada L dVS 8B5:P6>C \*ZZ* 6>B7>C 65B69MD *V S4-\b*,WS,*WS a,SbVSH daVS V\3SE ]1`-*Y1Zb* SWS ]*O ]S`da* aVW1S,*WS , /WSZZdp ]\W\adE V\b\`dp 4*b1Y a,\`*hSO ,*WS , `dW\ZD ,Sb\V Z*Y*bm,*WS Z* ]*WVd P Sa]Sa*ZZ\y ab\O `\Z\y ,Zdb`nD 1Vab `*a]\W*-*Waq ab\W+g*YSD /WSZZmf a,SbO V\, SY1WSan ]*WVS a \+\Sf V\Zg\,E S hSb*pkSy ]\ab1]1ZZ\ ]1`1Y*bm,*W a,Sb\V a \/Z\y ]*WVS Z* /`d-dpE ]\V* Z1 Z*f\/SW Zd3Z\1 Y1ab\D w `1SYdk1ab,\ a,SbV* a\ab\qW\ , b\YE hb\ \Z +mW /\ab*O b\hZ\ /WSZZmY L/\ 5> Y1b`\,ME hb\+m , Z1Y Y\3Z\ +mW\ dY1O abSbn g1Wdp VZS-dE S , b\ 31 ,`1Yq V\Y]*VbZmYE +W*-\/*`q b\O Yd hb\ 1-\ Y\3Z\ +mW\ a,1`ZdbnxEP -\,\`Sbaq , \/Z\Y +S+W1yO aV\Y a]`*,\hZSV1 LThe Anchor Bible DictionaryMD *]`SY1`E /Wq ˚,*Z-1WSq \b dVS ]\b`1+\,*Waq +m a,Sb\V /WSZ\y ]`SY1`Z\ /1,qbn a ]\W\,SZ\y Y1b`\,D Z\-/* ,1`fZSy S ZS3ZSy V`*y a,SbV* \+`14*WSE jWSe\,*WS ]1Y4\y S \V`*jS,*WSD ˇ

b\ b*VS1 wab*`jS1 a,qk1ZZSVSxE d]\YSZ*1Ym1 , `SabS*ZaVSf `1h1aVSf Sa*ZSqfH 4Z*h*WnZ\ /\W3Z\abn ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSV* , 4`*SW1 Y\- 4*ZSO Y*bn b\WnV\ \/SZ h1W\,1V S \Z* +mW* ]\3S4Z1ZZ\y L SaW* 79B69MD *YmY ]1`,mY ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSV\Y +mW *`\ZD 'b* ]\O h1bZ*q /\W3Z\abn \+mhZ\ ]1`1/*,*W*an \b \bg* V ab*`j1Yd amZd L af\/ 6=B=MD ,qk1ZZSV*YS aWd3SWS YZ\-S1 Yd3hSZm S4 ]\b\YV\, *`\Z*E , b\ ,`1Yq V*V ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSV\, 4* ,ap SaO b\`Sp +mW\ Z1 b*V YZ\-\D \-/* 4`*SWn Z*f\/SWaq ]\/ -\a]\/ab,\Y q4mh1aVSf ]`*O ,Sb1W1yE b1 Z*4Z*h*WS S aY1k*WS Sd/1yaVSf ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSO V\, ]\ a,\1Yd ]`\S4,\WdD \ ad/q ]\ ,a1YdE Z* obd /\W3Z\abn ]\hbS ,a1-/* S4+S`*WSan Wp/S S4 d4V\-\ V`d-* ]`S,SW1-S`\O ,*ZZmf a1Y1yE , \aZ\,Z\Y S4 `\/* *`\Z*D \/ ,m`*31ZS1Y wab*`jS1 a,qk1ZZSVSxE ]\O,S/SY\YdE ]\/`*4dY1,*pbaq \a\O +m1 ]`1/ab*,Sb1WS a,qk1Zab,*D ZSYE \h1,S/Z\E \bZ\aSWSan -W*,m 68 a,qk1ZZSh1aVSf -`d]]C 4Z*bZm1 hW1Zm a1Y1y ]1`,\O a,qk1ZZSV\, S +m,jS1 ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSVSE V\b\`mf \bab`*ZSWS \b aWd31ZSqE b*VS1 V*V ZZ* L5 1b\]San 68B5P5=C *be1q 6B8C *`V* <B75C ˙1qZSq 8B:MD ˇ

5>

˝˚ ) " )

*V +\`\bnaq a hd,ab,\Y Z14*kSk1ZZ\abS ˛˚ ˚E ]\3*WdyE Z1b +\W11 +144*kSbZ\-\

adk1ab,*E h1Y Z\,\`\3/1ZZmy YW*/1Z1gD \-O /* Ym ]`Sf\/SY , ob\b YS`E Ym ,a1g1W\ 4*,SaSY \b Z*jSf `\/Sb1W1yD \-/* Ym dhSWSan f\/SbnE /`dO -S1 Wp/S V*4*WSan Z*Y Z*ab\qkSYS ,1WSV*Z*YSD 'b\ ]d-*W\ Z*aE 1aWS `q/\Y Z1 +mW\ `\/Sb1W1yD \ ab\SW\ ]*]1 SWS Y*Y1 ,4qbn Z*a 4* `dVdE V*V Ym daO ]\V*S,*WSanD /1bab,1 Z*j1 +W*-\]\WdhS1 4*,Sa1W\ \b Wp+O ,S S \/\+`1ZSq `\/Sb1W1yD ,1`1ZZ\abn , `\/SO b1WnaV\y Wp+,S ]\4,\WqW* Z*Y hd,ab,\,*bn a1+q +\W11 4*kSk1ZZmYSD \-/* \ZS Z*a f,*WSWSE Ym hd,ab,\,*WS a1+q d,1`1ZZ11 S ab*`*WSan ab*bn 1k1 Wdhj1D \ Y1`1 Z*j1-\ ,4`\aW1ZSq /\]\WZSb1WnZ\1 hd,O ab,\ 4*kSk1ZZ\abS Z*Y ]`S/*,*WS +WS4VS1 /`d4nqD *Y +mW\ V\Ye\`bZ\ `q/\Y a ZSYSE S *bY\ae1`* , jV\W1 d31 Z1 V*4*W*an b*V\y dab`*j*pk1yD \Z1hZ\E 4/1an \]Sa*Z\ S/1*WnZ\1 /1bab,\D ˙*O W1V\ Z1 d ,a1f +mWS +WS4VS1 /`d4nqE S \h1Zn YZ\O -S1 Z1 ]\Wdh*WS \b `\/Sb1W1y Z1\+f\/SYdp ]\/O /1`3VdD w \-/* q ,S3d ah*abWS,m1 a1YnSE V\b\`m1 hb\Ob\ /1W*pb ,Y1ab1E q ,a1-/* /dY*pB t *V +m YZ1 f\b1W\anE hb\+m d Y1Zq +mW\ b*V\1 /1bab,\IrxEP

]`S4Z*1baq 1WSaa*1D \4ZSV*pb WS d ,*a ]\/\+O Zm1 hd,ab,*H

˚ ˙˚ ˚ ˚ % ˛ # #˚

\4Y\3Z\E , /1bab,1E , -\/m e\`YS`\,*ZSq WShO Z\abSE ,*Y Z1/\ab*,*W\ d,1`1ZZ\abS , a1+1D \31b +mbnE ,m ]\Wdh*WS Y*W\ Wp+,S S ,ZSY*ZSqD \O 31bE ,m ]\YZSb1 ]\ab\qZZm1 aa\`m `\/Sb1W1yE 4*O V\ZhS,jS1aq `*4,\/\YE , h1Y ,mE ,\4Y\3Z\E ,SZSO b1 a1+qD WSE hb\ 1k1 fd31E \/SZ S4 `\/Sb1W1y Y\\aV\`+Wqbn ,*a aW\,1aZ\ SWS eS4Sh1aVSD *V ,1/1b a1+q `1+1Z\VE V\b\`my `*ab1b , *bO Y\ae1`1 Z14*kSk1ZZ\abSH 1V\b\`m1 ]\/`\abVS Z*hSZ*pb ]`SZSY*bn Z*`V\bSVS S 4W\d]\b`1+Wqbn *WV\-\W1YD ˙`d-S1 ,abd]*pb , +*Z/mE hb\+m \kdO bSbn hd,ab,\ W\VbqD ˝*3/* Wp+,S S ,ZSY*ZSq Y\O 31b ]\/b\WVZdbn Z1d,1`1ZZ\-\ , a1+1 ]\/`\abV* V `\Y*ZbSh1aVSY \bZ\j1ZSqYD \ b*VS1 \bZ\j1ZSq `1/V\ /Wqbaq /\W-\E S `*4`m, h*ab\ 1k1 +\Wnj1 daSWS,*1b hd,ab,\ Z14*kSk1ZZ\abSD 1E V\Yd d/*W\an S4+13*bn b*VSf a1`n14Zmf \jS+\VE ,a1 31 Y\-db ,m`*abS `*ZSYmYS Wp/nYSE 1 a1 SY1Z* S4Y1Z1ZmD

Š 5 6>5:

55

\-/* ,\4ZSV*1b hd,ab,\ Z14*kSk1ZZ\abSH w \-/* \b1g Z*]S,*Waq S ,mf\/SW S4 a1+qE 1-\ WSg\ Y1ZqW\an /\ Z1d4Z*,*1Y\abSD Z aV*WSW 4d+mE b\hZ\ fSkZmy ,\WVE -\b\,my `*4\`,*bn /\+mhdD q +mW* V*V Sa]d-*ZZ*q \,1hV* S ab*`*W*an Z1 ]\]*/*bnaq 1Yd Z* -W*4* , Z*/13/1E hb\ \Z Y1Zq Z1 4*Y1bSbD b*V\Y V\jY*`1 q 3SW* ]\hbS V*3/my /1Znx L/1baVS1 ,\a]\YSZ*ZSq *`\WSZmMD w) ZSV\Yd Z1 Y\-W* /\,1`qbnD Z1 V*4*W\anE +d/b\ q ab\p Z* V`*p ]`\]*abS S V`ShdE Z\ Y1Zq ZSVb\ Z1 aWmjSb S ZSVb\ Z1 ]`S/1b Z* ]\Y\knx L˚,*E V\b\`*q Z1/*,Z\ ]1`13SW* `*4,\/MD w b1g h*ab\ Z*+`*am,*Waq Z* Y1Zq a V`SO V*YSB t Shb\31ab,\E b1+q ZSVb\ ZSV\-/* Z1 ]\Wp+SbIr Z\-\ W1b q ]mb*Waq d+1/Sbn a1+q , \+`*bZ\YD ) hd,ab,\,*W a1+q /,\`Zq3V\y a ]\/3*bmY f,\ab\YE V\b\`*q V\ ,a1Y W*abSbO aqE Z\ b\WnV\ ]\Wdh*1b ]SZVSx L *`VE V\b\O `\-\ , /1bab,1 dZS3*W \b1gMD w \-/* q ,S3d aSY]*bShZdp /1,djVdE q /dY*pB \Z* P V*V ]`1V`*aZ*q \`fS/1qE V\b\`dp V*3O /my f\b1W +m SY1bn d a1+q /\Y*D q +\Wnj1 ]\f\3* Z* 4*]mW1ZZmy a\`ZqV d \+\hSZmE V\b\`my ZSVb\ Z1 4*Y1h*1bx L *`SqE V\b\O `*q +\`1baq a hd,ab,\Y Z1]\WZ\g1ZZ\abSMD w \-/* YZ1 +mW\ ,a1-\ 56 W1bE `\/Sb1WS d1f*O WS `*+\b*bn 4* -`*ZSgd S \ab*,SWS Z* Y\1Y ]\]1h1ZSS /,df YW*/jSf a1ab1`D Z1 +mW\ b*V \/SZ\V\I ) f\b1W*E hb\+m Vb\OZS+d/n +mW `q/\Y S ]\//1`3*W Y1Zq /\+`mY aW\,\YD \ +mW\ b*V\1 hd,ab,\E aW\,Z\ q 4*+Wd/SW*an , +\Wnj\YE b1YZ\Y W1adD \bq q Sa]`*,Z\ ,m]\WZqW* a,\S \+q4*ZZ\abSE YZ1 \h1Zn f\b1W\an ,m+`*bnaq S4 ob\-\ /`1Ydh1-\ W1O a*D \b1W\an ab*bn ah*abWS,\y S +144*+\bO Z\yx L 1yh1WE /\hn `*+\hSfOoYS-`*Zb\,MD

56

˝˚ ) " )

ab`*/*pkSYS \b 4*ZS31ZZ\y a*Y\\g1ZVSD w) ahSO b*W* a1+q ZSVh1YZ\y S ZS Z* hb\ Z1 -\/Z\yE ]\O aV\WnVd b*V ,a1-/* -\,\`SW* Y\q Y*bnEP `*aaV*4mO ,*1b ZZ*DP 1 ]\YZpE hb\+m \Z* V\-/*OZS+d/n f,*WSW* SWS \+ZSY*W* Y1ZqxD \ hd,ab,\ Z14*kSk1ZZ\abS Y\31b ,\4ZSVZdbn d Z*a Z1 b\WnV\ S4O4* Z*j1-\ /1bab,*D `ShSZ\y Y\31b ab*bn bq31Wmy `*4,\/E ab*`\abn SWS /*31 ]1`13S,*ZSq ]\ ]\,\/d a,\1y ,Z1jZ\abSD *V\y +m ZS +mW* ]`ShSZ*E ob\ Y\31b WSj*bn Z*a ah*O abnq S Y1j*bn Z*jSY \bZ\j1ZSqY a \V`d3*pkSO YSD *V +\`\bnaq a ]\/\+ZmYS hd,ab,*YSH

% ˝ % ˙ )

*3Z\ 4Z*bnE hb\ ]\Y\kn 1abnD ,a1f Z*a 1abn b\bE Vb\ Z1 b\WnV\ Y\31bE Z\ S f\h1b Z*Y ]\Y\hnEP ob\ Z*j \-D

Y1ZZ\ obd YmaWn \- ]\ab*`*Waq /\Z1abS /\ Z*a h1`14 ]`\`\V* a*SpB w 1 +\yaqE ]\b\Yd hb\ q a b\+\yD 1 \4S`*yaq ]\ ab\`\Z*YE ]\b\Yd hb\ q b,\y \-D ) dV`1]Wp b1+qE ]\Y\-d b1+1E +d/d V`1]V\ /1`3*bn b1+q ]`*,\y `dV\y ]`*,1/Z\abSx L a*Sq 85B5>E 57MD *V ]`SqbZ\ a\4Z*,*bnE hb\ \-E \+`*4Z\ -\,\`qE 31W*1b ,4qbn Z*a 4* `dVdI \ob\Yd Z*Y Z1 Zd3Z\ +1a]\V\SbnaqI S+WSS `*aaV*4m,*1baq \ Wp/qfE V\b\`m1E Z1O aY\b`q Z* a1`n14Zm1 ]1`13S,*ZSqE Z*dhSWSan V`1]O V\ /1`3*bn \-* 4* `dVdD ZZ1E Y*b1`S *YdSW*E V*O 4*W\anE hb\ 3S4Zn 11 ]`\f\/Sb 4`qE ,1/n d Z11 Z1 +mO W\ /1b1yD ˙`d-S1 Z1`1/V\ aY1qWSan Z*/ Z1yE S4O4* b\-\ hb\ \Z* +mW* +1a]W\/Z*D Sb\-1 ZZ* ]\b1`qO W* *]]1bSb S h*ab\ ]W*V*W* L5 *YdSW* 5B:E <MD \E S4WS, a,\S ]1`13S,*ZSq , Y\WSb,1 V \-dE \Z* SaO ]mb*W* +\Wnj\1 \+W1-h1ZS1 L5 *YdSW* 5B5<MD a*WY\]1,1g ˙*,S/ b\31 ]\`\y hd,ab,\,*W a1+q dq4,SYmYD \/*YS g*`n *dW \f\bSWaq Z* Z1-\E V*V Z* /SV\-\ 4,1`qD 1aV\WnV\ `*4 ˙*,S/ +mW Z* ,\O W\a\V \b aY1`bSE S ]\`\y 1Yd V*4*W\anE hb\ \Z d,q4 , a,\Sf ]`\+W1Y*fE V*V , +\W\b1 L a*W\Y 99B7P9C :=B5MD 1aY\b`q Z* ob\E \Z ]Sa*WB w YS`1 q Wq-d S , YS`1 +d/d a]*bnE ]\b\Yd hb\ bm \/SZE \ 1-\,*E /*1jn YZ1 3Sbn +14\]*aZ\x L a*W\Y 8B<MD ZZ* S ˙*,S/ ,\4W\3SWS a,\1 +`1Yq P a,\S oY\O gS\Z*WnZm1 ]1`13S,*ZSq P Z* 1-\,d S ]\WdhSWS 1-\ ]\//1`3Vd L a*W\Y 99B66MD hb\ Y\31Y a/1O W*bn YmH

"

Ë› # #Ëš

5D *dhSb1an /\,1`qbn 1-\,1 V*V bgdD

Sada ]\+d/SW Z*a ]\4Z*V\YSbnaq a 1-\ bg\YE w1/SZab,1ZZmY SabSZZmY \-\Yx L \*ZZ* 5;B7MD w ZDDD Z1 /*W1V\ \b V*3/\-\ S4 Z*axEP 4*,1`q1b *]\O ab\W *,1W L˙1qZSq 5;B6;MD w `S+WS4nb1an V \-dE S \Z ]`S+WS4Sbaq V ,*YxEP Z*]Sa*W *V\, L *V\,* 8B<MD hb\ d Z*a 1abn Z1+1aZmy b1gE \-/* Ym d4Z*1YE V\b\`my Wp+Sb Z*a S 4*+\bSbaq \ Z*aE Ym /1W*1Y ,*3Zmy j*- , ]`1\/\W1ZSS b`1,\3Zmf hd,ab,D \O Z1hZ\E Y\31b ]\b`1+\,*bnaq ,`1YqE hb\+m `*4,Sbn /\,1`S1 V \-dE Z\ YZ\-S1 Z*jWS , ob\Y `1*WnZdp ]\Y\knD w \-/* 1-\,* ab*W /Wq Y1Zq bg\YE d Y1O Zq Z*V\Z1g ]\q,SWaq b\bE V\Yd q Y\-W* `*aaV*4*bn \ a,\Sf a\V`\,1ZZmf hd,ab,*fEP -\,\`Sb *`\WSO Z*DP 'b\ ]`SZ1aW\ YZ1 \-`\YZ\1 \+W1-h1ZS1Ix w 1-\,* ]\Y\- YZ1 Z1 +\qbnaqE V\-/* q \ab*W*an \/Z*E +14 `\/Sb1W1yEP ,a]\YSZ*1b 1yh1WDP ) Y\-O W* `*4-\,*`S,*bn a ZSY S ]`\aSbn 1-\ \ ]\Y\kS , `1j1ZSS ]`\+W1YD \Z ]`*,/* YZ1 ]\Y\-*Wx1D 1 ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m ]`1/W*-*pb +1a]W*bZ\1 S4dh1ZS1 S+WSS ,a1YE Vb\ f\h1b ]`S+WS4Sbnaq V \-dD

6D *y/Sb1 /df\,Zdp a1YnpD

Sada ]\+d3/*W a,\Sf dh1ZSV\, \bZ\aSbnaq V a\,1`dpkSY V*V V +`*bnqY S a1ab`*YD w m ,a1 P +`*bnqxEP aV*4*W \Z SY L *be1q 67B<MD Z f\O b1WE hb\+m 1-\ ]\aW1/\,*b1WS Wp+SWS /`d- /`d-* S ab*WS \/Z\y +\Wnj\y /df\,Z\y a1Yn1y L *be1q 56B8<P9>C \*ZZ* 57B79MD ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m SaV`1ZZ1 ab*`*pbaq a\4/*bn , a,\Sf a\+`*ZSqf b1]WdpE /`d31aVdp *bY\ae1`dE hb\+m ,a1 hd,ab,\,*WS a1+q h*abnp 1/SZ\y /df\,O Z\y a1YnS LËš,`1qY 5>B68E 69MD Z\-S1 Z* a\+ab,1ZO Z\Y \]mb1 d+1/SWSanE hb\ ,ab`1hS a\+`*ZSq Y\-dbE aW\,Z\ g1WSb1WnZmy +*Wn4*YE aYq-h*bn S 4*W1hSO ,*bn oY\gS\Z*WnZm1 `*ZmD w a\+`*ZSS d Y1Zq +mW* +WS4V*q ]\/`d-*E V\O b\`*q ]\ZSY*W*E V*Vdp +\Wn YZ1 ]`SjW\an ]1`1O 3SbnEP ,a]\YSZ*1b Ëš,*DP Z* ,maWdjS,*W* Y1ZqE hSb*W* YZ1 S Y\WSW*an ,Y1ab1 a\ YZ\yD Z* /1W*W* ,a1E hb\+m q Z1 hd,ab,\,*W* a1+q \/SZ\V\yD \/`dO -* /*,*W* YZ1 ,\4Y\3Z\abn ,m-\,\`SbnaqD W*-\O /*`q 11 ]\//1`3V1 q ab*W* +\W11 d,1`1ZZ\y , a1O +1xD w f`SabS*ZaV\Y a\+`*ZSS q Z*jW* \bg\, S Y*b1`1yEP /\+*,Wq1b 1yh1WDP ZS ]\Y\-WS YZ1 ]\hd,ab,\,*bn a1+q Wp+SY\y S Zd3Z\yxD Å 5 6>5:

57

7D `\q,Wqyb1 Wp+\,n S /\+`\bd V /`d-SYD \-/* Ym ]`\q,Wq1Y V /`d-SY Wp+\,n S /\+`\O bdE ob\ ]\Y\-*1b Z*Y Z*ybS Z*ab\qkSf /`d41yD SO ada aV*4*WB w \Wnj11 ah*abn1 P /*,*bnE h1Y ]\WdO h*bnx L˙1qZSq 6>B79MD \abd]*q b*VE Ym d+1/SYaqB h1Y +\Wnj1 Wp+,S ]`\q,Wq1jnE b1Y +\Wnj1 ]\WdO h*1jn ,4*Y1ZD w˙*,*yb1 P S /*/db ,*YxEP ]\\+1O k*W Sada L dVS :B7<MD \-/* Ym \b/*1Y a,\p Wp+\,n /`d-SY S ]\Wdh*O 1Y Wp+\,n , \b,1bE Ym hd,ab,d1Y a1+q Z*YZ\-\ +\O W11 4*kSk1ZZmYSD S+WSS -\,\`SbaqE hb\ wWpO +\,n ZSV\-/* Z1 ]`\f\/Sbx L5 \`SZeqZ*Y 57B<MD w) 4Z*pE hb\ YZ\-\1 S4 b\-\ Z1-*bS,Z\-\E hb\ q /dO Y*p \ a1+1E Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 Z1]`*,/*EP ]`S4Z*1baq

*`SqDP \-/* q ]\Y\-*p Wp/qY S 4*+m,*p \ a1O +1E YZ1 ab*Z\,Sbaq Wdhj1D ) ,a1-/* hd,ab,dp d/\,O W1b,\`1ZS1E V\-/* /1W*p hb\Ob\ /Wq /`d-SfxD

˛ # ˙ ) ˚ 'bS b`S j*-* Z1 ,\Wj1+Z*q e\`YdW*E V\b\O `*q Y\31b ,`*4 `1jSbn ,a1 Z*jS ]`\+W1YmD \ \ZS YZ\-\1 Y\-db S4Y1ZSbnD w \`\y q ,a1 1k1 hd,O ab,dp a1+q +144*kSbZ\yEP \bY1h*1b *`\WSZ*DP \ b1]1`n Y\q a*Y\\g1ZV* ]\,maSW*anD ) 4Z*pE hb\

58

˝˚ ) " )

\- 4*+\bSbaq \+\ YZ1E S d Y1Zq YZ\-\ +WS4VSf /`d41yE a V\b\`mYS YZ1 \h1Zn Z*/13Z\xD 1yh1W b*VS1 31 hd,ab,*D w `1Yq \b ,`1Y1ZS dZmZS1 ,\4O ,`*k*1baqEP /1WSbaq \Z*DP \ d Y1Zq 1abn /df\,O Zm1 +`*bnq S a1ab`mE V V\b\`mY q Y\-d \+`*bSbnaq 4* a\,1b\YD ZS ]\Y\-*pb YZ1 aY\b`1bn Z* ,1kS ]\W\3Sb1WnZ\D a*Y\1 -W*,Z\1E d Y1Zq 1abn Z1+1aO Zmy b1gE a V\b\`mY q -\,\`p V*3/my /1ZnD \q 3S4Zn , V\`Z1 S4Y1ZSW*anxD \YSY\ obSf b`1f j*-\, 1abn +\W11 V*`/SZ*WnO Z\1 `1j1ZS1D S+WSS -\,\`Sbaq \ -`q/dk1Y Z\O ,\Y YS`1E , V\b\`\Y V*3/my S4 Z*a +d/1b hd,ab,\O ,*bn a1+q , ]\WZ\y +14\]*aZ\abSD W\,1 \-* /*O 1baq b*V\1 \+1k*ZS1B w *3/my S4 ZSf +d/1b aS/1bn ]\/ a,\1y ,SZ\-`*/Z\y W\4\y S ]\/ a,\SY SZ3SO `\YE S ZSVb\ Z1 +d/1b Sf dab`*j*bnx L Sf1y 8B8MD \-/* Z*ab*Z1b ob\ ,`1YqE Ym d31 Z1 +d/1Y hd,O ab,\,*bn a1+q +144*kSbZmYS S ZSVb\ Z1 aY\31b ]`ShSZSbn Z*Y ,`1/D p/S w+\Wnj1 Z1 +d/db ,a]\O YSZ*bnx \ ]W\f\YE /*31 \ -Wd+\VSf /dj1,Zmf b`*,O Y*fE ]1`13Sbmf , ]`\jW\Y L a*Sq :9B5;E 69MD \- S 1-\ mZE `Sab\a SadaE dab*Z\,qb wSabSZZdp ]`*O ,1/Z\abnxD `14dWnb*b1 Z* ,a1y 41YW1 w+d/1b a]\O V\yab,S1 S +14\]*aZ\abn Z* ,1V*x L a*Sq 76B5;MD ˇ

Ë™ Ëš )) Ë™ & Ë™ ) Ëš Ëš • Ë? Ë›

1 +1a]\V\yb1an ˚• • B w 1`1ab*Znb1 +1a]\V\Sbnaq \ ,*jSf /dj*fx L *be1q :B69MD

b\ ob\ 4Z*hSbH Sada `Sab\a ]`\S4Z1a obS aW\,* , a,\1y *-\`Z\y ]`\]\,1/SD \-W*aZ\ \/Z\Yd +S+W1yaV\Yd aW\,*`pE -`1h1aVSy -W*-\WE ]1`1,1/1ZZmy V*V w+1a]\V\SbnaqxE Y\31b \bO Z\aSbnaq V w1ab1ab,1ZZ\y `1*VgSS h1W\,1V* Z* +1/Z\abnE -\W\/ S /`d-S1 +1/mE a V\b\`mYS \Z ab*WVS,*1baq , ]\,a1/Z1,Z\y 3S4ZSxD 1a]\V\yab,* h*ab\ ,VWph*pb , a1+q ]1`13S,*ZSq \ b\YE hb\ Y\31b aWdhSbnaq , +d/dk1YD ˙Wq Z*a 1ab1ab,1ZZ\ 4*+\O bSbnaq \ a,\Sf Y*b1`S*WnZmf ]\b`1+Z\abqf S +W*-\]\WdhSS Z*O jSf +WS4VSf L SWS]]Syg*Y 6B6>MD \E -\,\`qB w SV\-/* Z1 +1a]\V\yb1anxE Sada ]\+d3/*W a,\Sf ]\aW1/\,*b1W1y S4+1O -*bn Z1Zd3Zmf +1a]\V\yab, P h`14Y1`Z\-\ ab`*f* ]1`1/ 4*O ,b`*jZSY /Z1YE V\b\`my Y\31b WSjSbn `*/\abS , Z*ab\qk1Y L *be1q :B75E 78MD `SY1ZSY\ WS ob\ a1-\/ZqH mW\ +m Yd/`\ ]`SaWdj*bnaq V aW\,*Y Sada*D \h1YdH *V ]\V*4m,*pb Z1V\b\`m1 Z*dhZm1 SaaW1/\,*ZSqE V\-/* Wp/S aSWnZ\ +1a]\V\qbaqE Sf aSY]*bSh1O aV*q Z1`,Z*q aSab1Y* Z*f\/Sbaq , ]\ab\qZZ\y *VbS,Z\abSE S4O 4* h1-\ ,\4ZSV*pb w]`\+W1Ym a\ 4/\`\,n1YE b*VS1 V*V q4,*E a1`O /1hZmy ]`Sabd] S *abY*xD

Sada ]`S,1W d+1/Sb1WnZdp ]`ShSZdE ]\h1Yd ab\Sb S4+1-*bn h`14Y1`Zmf +1a]\V\yab,B ob\ +1a]\W14Z\D Z a]`\aSWB w b\ S4 ,*aE +1a]\V\qanE Y\31b ]`\/WSbn a,\p 3S4Zn f\bq +m Z* W\O V\bnHx L *be1q :B6;MD V\WnV\ +m Ym ZS ]1`13S,*WSE ob\ Z1 ]\O Y\31b Z*Y ]`\/WSbn a,\p 3S4Zn /*31 Z* /\Wp a1VdZ/mE b1Y +\O W11 dWdhjSbn 11D `\Y1 b\-\E Z*jS Z*Sfd/jS1 \3S/*ZSq ]\hbS ZSV\-/* Z1 \]`*,/m,*pbaqD \b V*V ob\ ,m`*4SW \/SZ +S+W1SabB w 1`13S,*bn \ +d/dk1Y P Z*]`*aZ*q b`*b* ,`1Y1ZSD d/dk11 `1/V\ +m,*1b b*VSY Y`*hZmYE V*VSY Ym 1-\ a1+1 ]`1/ab*,Wq1YxD *V ]1`1ab*bn +1a]\V\SbnaqH \O]1`,mfE /\,1`qyb1 \-dD ˚aWS \Z /*1b ]Skd ]bSg*Y S \/1,*1b g,1bm , ,1WSV\W1]Zm1 w\/13/mxE `*4,1 \Z Z1 aY\31b ]\4*+\bSbnaq \ ]\b`1+Z\abqf Wp/1yE /Wq V\b\`mf aWd31ZS1 1Yd q,Wq1baq -W*,ZmY , 3S4ZSH L *be1q :B69E 6:E 6<P7>MD \O,b\`mfE 3S,Sb1 Z*ab\qkSYD w SO V\-/* Z1 +1a]\V\yb1an \ 4*,b`*jZ1Y /Z1EP aV*4*W SadaEP b*V V*V 4*,b`* +d/db a,\S +1a]\V\yab,*xD \-W*aSb1anE hb\ w/\,\WnO Z\ /Wq V*3/\-\ /Zq a,\1-\ 4W*x L *be1q :B78MD `SaWdj*,jSan V Yd/`\Yd a\,1bd Sada*E Ym aY\31Y a\f`*O ZSbn a,\1 4/\`\,n1D \W11 b\-\E Ym \+`1b1Y /dj1,Zmy ]\V\y P b\E hb\ , S+WSS Z*4m,*1baq wYS`\Y \3nSYx L SWS]]Syg*Y 8B:E ;MD ˇ Š5 6>5:

59

)H

b\ ]`\Saf\/Sb ]\aW1 aY1`bSH

d/db WS dY1`jS1 3Sbn aZ\,*H

˚ %˚ (˙ ˚ ) E hb\ ]\aW1 aY1`bS h1W\,1V ]`\/\W3*1b 3SbnE Z\ d31 , SZ\Y ,S/1D ˙`d-S1 ahSb*pbE hb\ a\ aY1`bnp ,a1 4*V*ZhS,*1baqD ,\ hb\ ,1`Sb1 ,mH

% % ˚ H

˙ ˙*

˙ 1b

˙ \31b +mbn

)

)

w d/1b ,\aV`1a1ZS1 Y1`b,mfx L˙1qZSq 68B59MD

w 1`b,m1 ZSh1-\ Z1 4Z*pbx L'VVW14S*ab =B9MD \-/* h1W\,1V dYS`*1bE \Z ]1`1ab*1b adk1ab,\,*bnD

˚#˚ ˝ ˛ & ˛

˙ S+WSS aY1`bn h*ab\ a`*,ZS,*1baq a\ aZ\Y L \*ZZ* 55B55P58MD \- Y\31b ]`\+d/Sbn Y1`b,mf \b aY1`bZ\-\ aZ*C /Wq Z1-\ ob\ b*V 31 ]`\ab\E V*V /Wq Z*a `*4+d/Sbn a]qk1-\ L \, 58B57P59MD ˙ S+WSS \]Sa*Z\ Z1aV\WnV\ aWdh*1, ,\aV`1O a1ZSqE S ob\ 4*,1`q1b Z*a , b\YE hb\ dY1`jS1 \+q4*b1WnZ\ ,\aV`1aZdb L5 *`1y 5;B5;P68C dVS ;B55P5;C \*ZZ* 55B7=P88MD

˚#˚ ˝ ˛ & ˛

˙ 1`,my h1W\,1VE /*YE ]\aW1 aY1`bS ,1`ZdWaq , 41YZdp ]mWn L mbS1 6B;C 7B5=MD \/\+ZmY \+`*4\Y ,a1 Wp/SE dYS`*qE ,\4,`*k*pbaq , ]mWn L'VVW14S*ab 7B5=E 6>MD ˙ Y1`jS1 \a,\+\3/*pbaq \b -`1f\, P ,a1 Sf -`1fS ]`\k*pbaq L SYWqZ*Y :B;MD \aW1 aY1`bS h1W\,1V Z1 Z1a1b Z*V*4*ZSq 4* -`1fSE a\,1`O j1ZZm1 ]`S 3S4ZSD

1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqH

\3*Wdyab*E ]`SjWSb1 YZ1 VZS-d w 1Yd Z* a*Y\Y /1W1 dhSb S+WSqHx

)˛%

\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , :Oy -W*,1 ob\y VZS-SE S4/*ZZ\y ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,m

˙ ˚

*V31 /\abd]Z* Z* a*yb1 jwDorg

s

n o

1a]W*bZ\ aV*h*yb1 ob\b S ]`1/m/dkS1 ,m]daVS

p

Sb*yb1 S+WSp \ZW*yZ ]`SY1`Z\ Z* 57> q4mV*f

˛*y/Sb1 Z* a*yb wwwDjwDorg/ru SWS \baV*ZS`dyb1 V\/

wp16.1-U 151006

]Sa\V */`1a\, aY\b`Sb1 Z* ab`*ZSg1 6

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.