cover jan14_Benchmark_nov13 10/12/2013 14:17 Page 2
January 2014
Technology: Edge Recording Recommended: Best of 2013 Buyer’s Guide: Access Door Controllers Under the Skin: Latest Technologies Examined
BENCHMARK
Vehicular Control Iluminar’s ANPR camera tested
TESTED: IC Realtime ICIP-D2000VIR
CASE STUDY: Multi-megapixel Image Capture
Project1_Layout 1 02/12/2013 16:28 Page 1
AXIS P72 Video Encoder Series
Full-featured, cost-effective video encoders with H.264. > > > > > > >
Network redundancy Full frame rate Simultaneous H.264 and Motion JPEG streams Edge storage High resolution quad-view Two-way audio Power over Ethernet
For more information, visit www.axis.com/products/p72_series
www.axis.com
about_jul13_000_Benchmark_may10 12/06/2013 11:02 Page 1
About Benchmark
BENCHMARK The leading source of independent performance-based technical information for those specifying, designing and purchasing advanced security solutions t Benchmark, we passionately believe that the future growth and development of the security sector depends upon the creation of flexible, scalable and effective solutions. As technology delivers ever increasing levels of functionality, so the ability to integrate elements such as business intelligence and smart management create a more valued proposition for all concerned. This brings together enhanced security with truly beneficial solutions.
A
BENCHMARK INDEPENDENT TESTING THE STATUS AWARDS Benchmark Recommended Status is awarded to products that undergo the independent testing process and receive an overall rating of 80% or higher. Products which receive this status are then permitted to use the Recommended logo, which illustrates they have passed application-specific testing and have reached a very high standard. Benchmark Outstanding Status is awarded to products that undergo the independent testing process and receive an overall rating of 90% or higher. Products which receive this status are then permitted to use the Outstanding logo, which illustrates they have passed application-specific testing and have reached the very highest standards. Because products and systems in the electronic security industry are varied, there are inevitable price differences between products designed to do the same job. It may be that one device offers a credible level of performance equivalent to its peers, but has more competitive price. Alternatively, the device may have a similar price to its peers, but delivers additional features and functions. In such cases, these products are recognised by the award of Benchmark Best Buy status.
We believe that by embracing the new and emerging technologies, and by adopting a more holistic approach to encompass the inherent flexibility they offer, credible solutions that deliver enhanced protection, security and business benefits can be realised. Any solution which includes a degree of compromise, no matter how small, will always be flawed. Given the depth of options now available, the use of limited or outdated technologies, or formulaic design which does not specifically address the needs of a customer, is unacceptable. Through independent testing, system and technology assessments, field-based analysis, educational articles and informed debate, Benchmark provides vital information to those seeking to create best-in-class solutions. The editorial materials included in the magazine and its on-line initiatives ensure that those who offer bespoke advanced solutions have access to honest, independent and relevant reporting that aids and supports them in their work. Benchmark delivers its content via a monthly print-based publication, as well as a number of interactive electronic initiatives. By realising the potential that new technologies offer, enhanced solutions that deliver security and business benefits can be realised. IF YOU ARE INVOLVED IN THE SPECIFICATION AND/OR PURCHASE OF SECURITY SOLUTIONS, BENCHMARK INCLUDES VITAL INFORMATION THAT CANNOT BE SOURCED ELSEWHERE!
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
3
Project3_Layout 1 06/12/2013 17:24 Page 1
The Premier Elite Series represents the most advanced electronic security solutions Texecom has to offer. These products are designed to protect high value installations where design flexibility, product performance and integrated solutions are a priority.
Premier Elite Mobile Apps
Maintex Software
Premier Elite control panels can now be remotely controlled by smartphone and tablet. The 3 apps offer end-user, master user and system engineer functionality.
With Texecom’s Maintex software you can remotely diagnose and monitor any Premier Elite security system with remote signaling capabilities.
• SmartKey App
Fully compliant with PD6662, Maintex reduces unnecessary site visits and prevents problems before they occur; saving you time, money and above all, providing peace of mind.
• Keypad App
Available to download now!
• Engineer App
Designed & made in the UK by Texecom
Visit: www.texe.com Sales: +44 (0)1706 220460
cont jan14_000_Benchmark_dec13 10/12/2013 16:45 Page 1
January 2014
Contents 7 Editorial There can be no excuses for manufacturers who fail to provide stable and reliable utilities or drivers, no matter how good the hardware might be!
8 Under the Skin – 2013 Benchmark gets under the skin of some of the more interesting product releases from the past year.
18 Praising Innovation Benchmark announces its awards scheme to recognise innovation in the security sector.
20 Professional Test: IC Realtime – ICIP-D2000VIR
Editor Pete Conway Tel: 020 8295 8303 E-mail: pete.conway@benchmarkmagazine.com Advertisement Manager Wendy Thomas Tel: 020 8295 8305 E-mail: wendy.thomas@proactivpubs.co.uk Production Matt Jarvis Tel: 020 8295 8300 E-mail: matt.jarvis@proactivpubs.co.uk Administration Tracey Beale Tel: 020 8295 8306 E-mail: tracey.beale@proactivpubs.co.uk
Benchmark considers the performance of the networked dome camera from IC Realtime to see if it offers a complete package.
22 Best of 2013 Benchmark looks back at the products which were tested and achieved Recommended Status during 2013.
36
30 Case Study: Higher Resolutions There are arguments both for against multimegapixel resolutions. Benchmark considers these, and looks at an application where they offered a better level of security.
34 Softly Softly Here we go again! Benchmark’s Dave casts a jaundiced eye over marketing claims for established products and technologies.
ISSN: 1750-1040
36 Professional Test: Iluminar – LPRS-60-24
Editorial and Advertisement Office PO Box 332 Dartford DA1 9FF
Benchmark considers the performance of Iluminar’s LPRS-60-24 to see what degree of performance it offers for ANPR image capture.
© Pro-Activ Publications Ltd 2014
40 Buyers Guide: Door Controllers
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Benchmark reserves the right to alter, abridge or edit any submissions prior to publication. The views published in Benchmark are not necessarily those of the publisher. While every care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of material included in Benchmark, the publishers cannot be held responsible for the accuracy of the information contained herein, or any consequence arising from it. In the case of all product reviews, tests and assessments, judgements have been made in the context of the equipment supplied at the time of the review. Any judgements are based upon situations relevant at the time of writing, and comments relating to cost are based upon published prices available from major distributors. Comments are based upon products and systems currently available in the UK market-place.
22
40
Benchmark looks at the important specifications when selecting door controllers for access control applications.
45 Distributor News The latest news for installers and integrators from the distribution market.
46 Technology Assessment: Edge Recording Benchmark considers the use of an edge-recording model to enhance system performance.
51 Bulletin The latest product releases of interest to installers and integrators.
58 Next Issue A look ahead to the February 2014 issue of Benchmark. www.benchmarkmagazine.com
5
Project1_Layout 1 12/11/2013 17:35 Page 1
FUTURE PROOF YOUR BUSINESS
...AND SAVE MONEY WITH OUR WISENETIII IP SOLUTION At Samsung we understand that the decision for when and how you migrate to an IP security solution is a complex one, influenced by many factors. Our new range of WiseNetIII network cameras have both an analogue and IP output, as well as onboard SD card recording. This gives you complete control and flexibility to make the right decision to suit your business. Integrate WiseNetIII onto an existing analogue system, whilst recording Full HD onto the SD card, or take advantage of the dual output and record locally to your analogue recorder whilst simultaneously viewing remotely utilising the IP output. You don’t have to throw away the investment you made in your existing equipment – helping to improve Total Cost of Ownership!
Contact us for further information
E stesecurity@samsung.com
W www.samsungsecurity.co.uk/WiseNetIII
BM_comment_jan14_000_Benchmark_nov10 10/12/2013 16:17 Page 1
Editorial Comment
Editorial Comment... Pete Conway, Editor, Benchmark he team at Benchmark handles a high number of networked and softwarebased products every year. Whilst many of the hardware characteristics are similar (and often retain a familiarity with the configurations which have been commonplace in security devices for many years), what is often different is the installation process and the drivers used. The latter allows the device to communicate with a PC, VMS, or another device, either from the same manufacturer of a third party. With regard to installation procedures, the IP Utility is common, alongside the Installation Wizard. These are generally specific to each manufacturer, and offer a swift way to search, identify and address devices on the network. Whilst they’re not always necessary, where they work well is when multiple devices are being added. The best utilities will swiftly identify any of the manufacturer’s devices on the network, even if they’re on a different segment! They then allow network configurations – IP address, log-in details, etc. – to be altered. Some will run from the CD without installation. Unfortunately, not all utilities are as straightforward. Some will give errors while loading, others won’t find all the devices, and some simply will not find any devices at all. When they do they’ll adapt the settings with mixed success, leaving you to double-check what has and hasn’t happened. There are even some utilities which generate Windows-based warnings. These inform you that the use of the program isn’t recommended. A few will automatically block the utility unless all system protection is disabled. Neither scenario is good if the end user or an IT manager sees them. Some manufacturers will even publish details of
T
Few have an issue with manufacturers doing things their own way. However, when there is a gulf of difference in complexity and reliability, installers and integrators should vote with their feet! which warnings to ignore. Surely it would be better to write software – as many of the better manufacturers do – that doesn’t trigger such issues? The same is true of drivers and codecs. The better products often have drivers that selfinstall. They work, first time, every time. Others require a degree of tinkering to get them running, whilst a few require significant changes to system security and set-up in order to function. A few manufacturers will use open source freeware video codecs or drivers. This is a strange thing to do, as these are often written, rewritten and adapted by unknown individuals. That’s the nature of open source projects. If there’s an issue with the codec, it’s often difficult for the installer or integrator to fix unless they happen to be a software coder with full knowledge of how the scripting has been adapted. Drivers and utilities which fail waste time, and that eats into the profits of installers and integrators. Some don’t like to complain in case it’s the system they’re working on which is causing the issues. However, manufacturers need to accept that if their codecs and utilities are flaky, they will lose business to those who don’t have such problems. There can be no excuses. If some manufacturers are getting it right, then those who don’t have failed their customers, and don’t deserve the business you give them!
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
7
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:53 Page 2
Under the Skin
Under the Skin - 2013 Review
Riva – RC6602HD
Fermax – iLoft Collection
What is it?
What is it?
The RC6602HD from Riva is an integrated camera featuring integral infrared illumination for true day/night functionality. The RC6602HD is designed for external use, and also features an onboard heater and fan for operation in extreme conditions. To further simplify set-up, it includes a ‘one click’ auto-focus function. As indicated by the final part of the product designation, the camera delivers HD1080p resolution at 30 frames per second. So, what makes the Riva offering stand out from the crowd? Well, the camera features on-board intelligent video analytics.
Video door entry systems often represent the first point of contact when a visitor arrives at a premises. Whether the protected building is a commercial or residential site, many end users will have made an investment in the aesthetics of the property, and as such door entry solutions have to be sympathetic with the demands of modern decor. Whilst for many in the security sector, performance is always the major consideration, end users simply will not select any device which is an eyesore. However, it is also important that desigsn don’t move too far from the norm, as visitors must understand how to interact with the device. These considerations have been addressed by Fermax with its iLoft collection of door entry solutions. Available in surface- and flush-mount variants, the range is available in a range of colours. Options include black, white, silver and gold. A crystal edged frame is also available, as is a matt finish variant. Also, the unit has a low profile of just 13mm for the flush-mount unit.
What level of analytics? Riva makes use of video content analysis based upon the VCA Technology engine. This particular camera offers the standard package as a free-ofcharge base licence. This allows the use of up to 40 detection zones or lines; the zones can be made up of multi-segment polygons. The analytics themselves include a tracking algorithm and tamper detection. There are also a number of other analytics algorithms which can be added, albeit with the need for an additional licence fee. These include VCA-detectIP (perimeter intrusion, appear/disappear, enter/exit detection, stopping and dwell filters), VCA-countIP (people counting), VCA-accessIP (people counting and anti-tailgating) or VCA-surveillanceIP (perimeter intrusion, appear/disappear, enter/exit detection, stopping and dwell detection, people counting, object abandoned/removed, anti-tailgating, speed discriminations and perspective correction).
A few more numbers! The RC6602HD utilises a 1/2.7 inch CMOS sensor, and employs H.264 and M-JPEG compression. Dual streams are supported, but if analytics are utilised then only a single stream is configurable, with a restriction of 15fps. For some users who are seeking a combination of true HD performance and analytics, it is important to note that you can’t have both simultaneously. Other features include video motion detection, two-way audio, a digital alarm input and output, unicast and multicast transmission, and support for a MicroSD card for local storage. The range for IR illumination is quoted as 15 metres for external use. Power is 12V DC or PoE. 8
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Is it all about looks? Fortunately not; the range also delivers the expected performance for a video door entry system. The monitor unit is hands-free, and features a 3.5 inch TFT monitor that delivers a 480 x 234 resolution image. The flush fit monitor measures 131 x 197mm. The surfacemount monitor measures 131 x 197mm, with a profile of just over 34mm. The unit is fairly clean with regard to controls. There is a door release button, an auto-on button for main and secondary camera activation, and two buttons to start and end communications with a visitor. There are also two buttons to allow switching of auxiliary devices. Adjustments include volume control, and video adjustments include colour, brightness and contrast control. Call tones can also be selected by the user. Other functionality includes an integral doorbell, privacy mode and full duplex communication in hands-free mode. The control layout of the unit is the same across all variants. Power supply is 18V DC. Power consumption is 15mA in standby mode, and 400mA when active. The iLoft range of panels can be used with the Halo external panels. These interactive digital video entry panels utilise a 128 x 128 pixel LCD interface with icons, menus and graphic animations, making them simple and user friendly. An integral proximity reader is included, and supports up to 350 users. With a built-in colour camera, thermometer and clock, it offers more than traditional external panels.
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:54 Page 3
Under the Skin - 2013 Review Assa Abloy – Aperio
Honeywell – HDZ Dome
What is it?
What is it?
The benefits of electronic access control require no explanation. As the demand for 125kHz RFID-based solutions rises, so the potential for fully interoperable systems makes increasing sense. However, on sites where mechanical locksets are the order of the day, upgrading to an intelligent solution can cause problems. A solution exists, in the form of Aperio from Assa Abloy. Aperio allows doors with mechanical locksets to be upgraded. Making use of RFID-enabled lock cylinders and fittings in standard lock sizes, the electronic elements can simply replace existing mechanical locks. The RFID elements then connect to the access system utilising wireless links.
In the past the general consensus was that PTZ cameras would be on the decline as an increasing number of users moved to HD and megapixel technology. Talk of dreaded latency led to claims that operators simply would not be able to track activity. With enhanced bandwidth control, so the issue of latency has been minimised, and fully functioned network-connected cameras, and especially HD cameras, are the order of the day! The HDZ range includes an internal and external (IP66) unit. Optical zoom ratio is 20x, and the cameras offer true day/night operation. Resolution is HD1080p
How does it work? Aperio is based around a wireless link between the lock and a communications hub, which is then connected to the access control system using standardised cabling. The communications hub links wirelessly with the doorside devices. The RFID-enabled cylinders or escutcheons then transfer data to and from the communications hub using 2.4GHz encrypted wireless connectivity. Aperio communications hubs can support up to eight doors, within a range of up to 25 metres. The RFID elements are available as Euro Profile and Scandinavian Profile cylinders, along with and Euro Profile, Swiss Profile and Scandinavian Profile escutcheons. All are battery-powered.
Why do I want this? If you have isolated mechanical-locking doors, and adding them to the site’s access control solution is not costeffective, then the burden of key management will be obvious. Also, mechanical locks mean that many doors on a site will be outside of any established audit trails. By introducing Aperio, doors can be added, simply and easily, to the system. Fitting the RFID elements is as straightforward as changing a lock cylinder or escutcheon. Advanced access control technology at a minimal cost, with ease of installation and little disruption, is why you want it!
A few more specs! The HDZ cameras utilise a 1/2.8 inch CMOS progressive scan sensor, to deliver HD1080p streams in real-time. As well as true day/night operation, the cameras feature wide dynamic range for use in applications with contrasting lighting. Dual streaming is supported, and each stream is independently configurable. Compression is via H.264 and Motion-JPEG. Sensitivity is quoted as 0.05 lux at F1.6 for a 30IRE image. Other video features include motion detection, noise reduction, privacy making, digital slow shutter and backlight compensation. The unit also features alarm inputs and outputs, two-way audio and support for a MicroSD-HC card allowing up to 32gB of on-board storage. Mechanically the unit offers 360 degree continuous rotation, and 180 degree tilt with auto-flip. Manual speeds are 0.5 to 200 degrees per second for pan, and 0.5 to 84 degrees per second for tilt. Preset speeds are up to 400 degrees per second. Proportional pan/tilt speeds automatically control maximum speed dependent upon the zoom ratio Up to 256 presets are supported, along with 8 preset tours, 8 mimic tours and 4 auto tours. Power is 24V AC, and PoE is also supported.
Mounting? The HDZ domes are supplied as pendant mount, but other options are available. These include ceiling and wall mountings, corner mounting, swan-neck, parapet and roof mounting. There are choices for indoor and outdoor versions of some of the fittings. Another option is for a vandal-resitant smoked polycarbonate dome cover.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
9
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:54 Page 4
Under the Skin
Under the Skin - 2013 Review VDT – DV Cop Cell
Raytec – Vario IP
What is it?
What is it?
For many, CCTV is at its very best when used as an eventbased tool. Rather than recording hour upon hour of footage, it just captures and transmits video of incidents. The DV Cop Cell is pretty much focused on one thing; capturing footage of incidents. It’s never going to be selected as a mainstream recording choice, because it isn’t one – and it makes no apologies for that fact! It supports a single channel of composite video. Maximum resolution is VGA (640 x 480), and record rate is 10fps. Compression is JPEG, and has four quality settings, with a maximum image size of 10KB. It is supplied with a 2GB Mini SD card, but can be expanded to support 4GB. To aid remote connectivity, the unit features GSM/ GPRS Class 12 cellular connectivity, as well as alarm handling capabilities. Additionally, the unit is fully compatible with the Webeye cloud service.
Raytec is best known for its range of video surveillance illuminators, and it will come as little surprise to many that the Vario IP is an illuminator! Available in infrared and white light variants, the model adds IP connectivity. The Vario allows the angle of illumination to be changed in the field by physically changing the lens. It also offers a range of adjustable functionality, which can be controlled using an optional remote control device. This allows power adjustment from 20 to 100 per cent, remote switching and dimming, adjustable photocell sensitivity, setting of a timer and status LED disable. Maximum range is 220 metres for the infrared unit, and 150 metres for the white light model.
What are the benefits? So what’s this Webeye thing? Webeye CMS is cloud-based video alarm handling software, integrated with RSI Videofied as well as the Cop Cell unit. It allows users to receive and handle alarms from anywhere that has an internet connection, even on the move via a mobile device. For the latter, users can use the WebEye Alert app. It delivers a self-monitored option, enabling users to manage their own systems. Figures from 2012 claim that the service handles 8 alarms, 15 videos and 29 non-video events every hour.
Is it really mobile? Well, the manufacturer states that the unit is used by many of the UK’s police forces for asset protection and gathering evidence of flytipping. It’s suited to rapid deployment and can be run from a battery or low power source. It also includes a 12V output to power a standard video camera. Weighing in at 690 grammes, and measuring 153 x 140 x 43mm, it certainly is mobile. It also delivers connectivity without any need for permanent infrastructure. When an event occurs, triggered either by VMD or an external input, a series of still images are captured. These are recorded onto removable media, and can also be transmitted across the cellular network. Alternatively, the unit can send an email including time and date stamped JPEGs. The images can be optimised to suit cellular networks. WebEye then routes any alerts to other compatible devices such as smartphones or tablets.
10
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
The networked Vario units enable remote access for set-up and maintenance. The illuminators feature an integrated web server which enables users to configure, manage and control illuminators – individually or in groups – from anywhere on the network. Discovery software is included with each unit. The interface delivers the ability to adjust the unit in response to conditions. It can be powered on or off, and light intensity can be boosted or reduced. Configurations include timer functions, deterrent function, photocell sensitivity adjustment and soft start. Diagnostics give feedback on the status of each illuminator. Control can be password protected. Optional software can be used to deliver greater control of the lighting, including scheduling for all illuminators. An optional API is also available, allowing for integration of the illuminator control into a video management system.
What about PoE? If your way of thinking is anything like ours, your first reaction to the news of an IP-enabled illuminator will be an assumption that the units will allow PoE connectivity. Sadly, they are not equipped for this. One of the benefits that most enjoy about the use of networked solutions is the freedom (and cost savings) afforded by the use of PoE. Once you’re using it on a regular basis, you do start to question why anyone bothers with traditional low power. The Vario IP illuminators have a power requirement of 48W, and require a 24V AC input.
Project1_Layout 1 25/06/2013 17:43 Page 1
Lights out? No problem for the starlight cameras!
It’s time to switch to the most light-sensitive HD cameras on the market. The new DINION starlight HD 720P and FLEXIDOME starlight HD 720p RD/VR are the next real breakthrough in HD security. In poor light these amazing HD cameras deliver a clear color image where others show only black and white. And in extreme low-light they deliver a black and white image where others show no image at all! Add the Bosch Video Security app and overcome the bandwidth barrier so you can view HD images from anywhere. See video security in a new light at uk.boschsecurity.com/hdsecurity
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:55 Page 5
Under the Skin
Under the Skin - 2013 Review Comnet – NetWave What is it? ComNet Europe offers a line of wireless Ethernet transmission products. The NetWave line will include both point-to-point and point-to-multipoint models. It has to be accepted that in the past, those involved in security were a little bit sceptical about what wireless connectivity could offer. Some still are. However, by ignoring the potential offered by this approach, integrators and installers could find that their systems are flying in the face of demand from customers who are increasingly comfortable with the technology. In a security-centric world, some might feel that wireless connectivity isn’t the most secure option. The truth is that properly configured, wireless is as secure – and some will argue more secure – than hardwired alternatives. Also, the fact that these devices come from a security-based company, rather than an IT business, is reassuring.
What do I get? The NetWave range includes the NWK-2, available as a kit. This package contains all the components required to transmit a single Ethernet stream between a remote device and an access point, with a throughput of up to 95Mbps. The access point and client units are preconfigured. The kit also includes basic mounting hardware. Power to the units is via PoE, and PSUs and injectors are included. The NW-2 module can be configured as a client or as an access point. This allows up to 15 clients to be connected to one access point.
Muxlab – 50047X What is it? Currently, the video surveillance sector has more options when it comes to connectivity than ever before. Composite video is transported over coax with BNC connections or UTP with screw-fit connections. HD-SDI offers digital video transmitted over certain types of coax, using BNC connections, but using a different format to composite video. Digital video uses a range of connections, most typically RJ45, but this is not exclusive. Then there’s audio to consider too! Bringing all of these options together into one system can be something of a headache. Muxlab claims that its multimedia 16 x 16 matrix switch – the 50047x – can help.
What does it do? The matrix switch system is a modular audio-visual switching platform that converts and switches a variety of digital and analogue video and audio inputs to HDMI via HDBaseT over Cat5e/6 cable. It features an 8-slot chassis which enables up to four 4-port input modules to switch connections for up to four 4-port output modules. This means the unit can deliver a maximum switching capacity of 16 x 16 input/outputs. The matrix switch features dual-redundant hot-swappable power supplies. It can be controlled via the front panel, or remote connectivity via RS232, USB or a web server interface delivers a high degree of flexibility for distributed sites or multi-location applications. Once configured, the matrix switch is effectively invisible to the system and to operators, simply delivering all streams into one uniform output format.
And the set-up?
Is it totally flexible?
ComNet claims that its NetWave products are easy to install, and state that due to pre-configuration, the process is ‘point, power, play’. The units can either use DCHP, or a static IP address can be set. All of the products in the series feature LED arrays that assist with regard to alignment of the antennas for optimal performance. Other configurations allow for adjustment of range to suit short or long distance coverage. The units are industrially hardened, and are claimed to have an operating range of -40 to +75 degrees C. The units are rated to IP67, making them ideal for external use.
It is, within reason. The input cards each contain four inputs, and up to four cards can be supported. The cards include HDMI, HD-SDI, DVI and VGA inputs. Therefore, any specified input can be implemented in multiples of four. Output options are HDBaseT or HDMI. Again, these can be mixed, but again this must be done in multiples of four. For many in the surveillance sector, the main issue will be that analogue devices using standard BNC connections will need to have the inputs converted to one of the four supported formats prior to being connected to the matrix switch.
12
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Project1_Layout 1 12/08/2013 11:38 Page 1
Now it’s easy to keep an eye on your business 24/7…
…JustConnect™ with D-Link D-Link's DNR-2060-08P is a comprehensive yet easy to set up all-in-one network video display, storage and management solution.
Download your free JustConnect+ app now
It includes a complete surveillance software package that enables you to view, manage, store, record and search through footage from up to eight cameras without the need of a computer. It has eight built-in 802.3at compliant PoE+ ports that simplify camera installation by providing both power and network connectivity.
Visit www.dlink.com/uk or e-mail uki-surveillance@dlink.com for an information pack. IP SURVEILLANCE t STORAGE t SWITCHING t WIRELESS
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:56 Page 6
Under the Skin
Under the Skin - 2013 Review Mobotix – MxActivitySensor Concept Smoke Screen – Predator What is it?
What is it?
Whilst many manufacturers will tag any advanced processing trigger as analytics, MxActivitySensor from Mobotix is billed as intelligent video motion detection, and it adds the degree of discriminations that make motion detection reliable. These discriminations allowed the elimination of false alarms caused by wind-blown debris, global scene changes, swaying motion such as bushes and trees, flashing or switching or lights, etc..
The concept of security ‘smoke screens’ has been around for a few years now, and they work on the principle of preventing crime by ensuring that perpetrators cannot see, thereby preventing them from locating assets or moving through the premises. The systems are fast-acting, filling a space with a nontoxic cloud within seconds. The ‘smoke’ is a vapour cloud, which does not damage materials or leave any odours or residues. It can effectively ‘push’ intruders out of a building, and often the speed with which the systems deploy makes the effect disorientating for any intruder. Concept Smoke Screen has been adding developments to its product range, and offers the Predator, which links smoke screen performance with ‘DNA’ secure identification.
Is it complex? It goes without saying that any motion detection algorithm – well, any algorithm that is both reliable and effective – will be complex. That said, the complexity is in the processing engine. For those delivering the solution, the set-up is claimed to be minimal. The manufacturer even states that if used straight from the box, the functionality will be an improvement over many VMD options. Any discrimination-based video motion detection will require some degree of configuration, although Mobotix claims a minimal amount will eradicate 90 per cent of false alarms. Processing is carried out in the camera, and the MxActivitySensor engine is directly integrated. Only triggered events are then transmitted over the network. Alarm actions can include recording, initiating a telephone call, email or SMS transmission, etc..
Is it going to be expensive? We thought you’d ask that! The S15, D15 and V15 camera models are equipped with the MxActivitySensor functionality as standard. If you have an existing Q24M, M24M, D24M, T24M, D14Di, S14 or V14 (secure models), then MxActivitySensor is included within the camera software updates from 4.1.6 onwards. These are available as a free download. So, no; it’s not going to be expensive!
14
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Adding DNA Commonly referred to as DNA tagging, these systems use a registered liquid material containing unique encoding, typically in the form of microdots. Each cylinder of material is allocated to specific users, and when an incident occurs, the liquid is released, spraying the perpetrator. Following an arrest, the material can be collected by the police, and the registration of the unique encoding allows them to categorically link an individual with a premises, along with the date and time of the system activation. Predator combines smoke generation with DNA tagging. This reduces losses whilst also ensuring that criminals are tagged. The dispersing system can be used with almost all of the DNA markers currently on the market. The DNA/dye material is independently released to ensure that the encoded material is not damaged or destroyed by passing through the smoke machine’s heat exchanger system. The system is triggered in response to a verified intruder alarm activation. This reduces any risks associated with false alarms, and ensures that incidents are not missed. It also delivers a degree of flexibility with regard to the total system operation.
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 11:13 Page 1
or visit www.icrealtime.co.uk
uts_jan14_000_Benchmark_oct12 06/12/2013 11:56 Page 7
Under the Skin
Under the Skin - 2013 Review Dallmeier – Picodome
ACT – ACTpro eLock
What is it?
What is it?
The trend for miniaturisation has always been around in the video surveillance sector, and as optical manufacturing has advanced, so the move towards ever smaller cameras is one that a few companies have pursued. Those with good memories will remember the Picodome from Dallmeier. When it was launched the WDR-enabled unit was the manufacturer’s entry into the world of miniaturised cameras. Despite being 93mm in diameter, the unit delivered quality images. It used 17 bit digital processing and boasted Dallmeier’s Cam_inPix technology. Its basic specifications were what was called high resolution back then – 540 TVL – and sensitivity was 1 lux. Well, the Picodome is back, and its performance has moved on to exploit the additional functionality available from today’s technology.
In recent years, electronic locking systems have been greatly simplified by basic advances in technology. Door locks which include a proximity reader and opening mechanism, powered by batteries, offera cost-effective solution. These devices communicate with a central access control system wirelessly, via hubs supporting multiple doors, and eradicate issues concerning the wiring of individual doors. In recent times, the locking system has come of age. ACT now offers such a solution, in the form of its recently launched eLock.
So it’s not composite? No. Well yes. It’s hybrid, actually. The camera can be used in legacy analogue systems or networked applications. In truth, most people will use the composite output for setup. The new version of the camera – the Picodome DDF4220HDV – delivers HD720p video in real-time, as well as a range of resolutions up to 1.3 megapixel. The camera can stream H.264 or M-JPEG video, and dual or triple streams are supported. The composite output allows for video of up to 4CIF resolution. Other features include wide dynamic range (up to 115dB) and low-light performance is quoted as 0.3 lux. It supports video motion detection with remote notification, privacy masking, plus configurable settings for AES, AGC, DNR, etc.. The lens is a fixed focal 2.8mm item. Power can be traditional 12V DC or PoE.
Is it all about looks? Sometimes, when manufacturers opt for an aesthetically pleasing design, there can be a worry that the device has been built to a style, rather than with the practicalities of everyday performance in mind. However, the Picodome has been designed to stand up to the rigours of the real world. The housing is vandal resistant, and is rated to IK10. The dome is sealed to IP66. It is available as both a flush-mount and surface-mount item. Ease of installation has been supplemented by the inclusion of a push, point, lock ball-joint type bracket. It uses push, point and lock operation to make the final set-up simple. That said, for many the real attraction of the Picodome will be for aesthetical reasons! 16
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
How does it work? The lock unit can be added to any door with a thickness of 36-60mm, and can be fitted to doors which use an 8mm spindle, or to new doors. The lock ifeatures an integral reader, and is battery powered. Battery life is claimed to be 210,000 operations for a single CR123A cell, and battery voltage is monitored. The lock is available with an optional Euro-profile cylinder to provide key override. Also, should the battery become exhausted, a USB connection can be used to provide an external power source. The lock communicates with an ACTpro hub. Wireless connectivity is up to 150 metres (line of sight), and the link uses 128bit AES encryption. Each hub can support up to 32 locks. The hub is powered by 12V DC or PoE, and links directly to the workstation running the access control software over a network connection. Installation is simplified as it features auto-discovery.
Operational specs? The eLock can support up to 60,000 users. Versions are available to support either 125Khz RFID or Mifare (both Classic and Desfire EV1). The unit monitors for battery voltage, tampering and door status (with an additional contact). For ease of use, the lock unit features a tri-colour status LED. The electronics and door clutch are located on the secure side of the door. Also, the handle on the secure side is set to allow free egress. The hub can be supplemented with a memory card should additional credential support be needed. The event log is limited by the capacity of the PC running the software. Other features include signal strength monitoring, toggle and latch mode, timed actions to allow scheduling, supply voltage monitoring and fire alarm override.
Project1_Layout 1 09/07/2013 17:24 Page 1
awards jan14_000_Benchmark_aug13 06/12/2013 12:01 Page 1
Rewarding Innovation he security industry has never before enjoyed the sheer breadth of technological options that it does today. Gone are the times when manufacturers waited for older technologies to reach a low price point before they became commercially worth implementing. We are no longer reliant upon older technologies from other sectors. Today’s security systems market is advancing on a daily basis, and we can enjoy developments from the IT, communications, AV and consumer sectors, as and when they happen. In short, innovation has become our watchword. As advances in technology deliver ever greater levels of functionality, so the ability to integrate security elements increases. This is further added to by interoperability with other functions such as business intelligence and smart management. The result is that security systems can offer a more valued proposition for all concerned, bringing together enhanced security with truly beneficial solutions. Through on-going innovation, and by embracing the new and emerging technologies, manufacturers can assist installers and integrators who wish to adopt a more holistic approach to system design. This allows the subsequent solutions to encompass the inherent flexibility that new technologies offer, ensuring that credible solutions which deliver enhanced protection, security and business benefits can be realised.
T
At Benchmark, we passionately believe that the future of the electronic security sector lies in the creation of innovative and flexible solutions which deliver real benefits to end users. In order to allow installers and integrators to create such solutions, it is vital that manufacturers deliver innovation that both enhances the technological capabilities of their products, and allows those developments to be implemented in a realistic fashion. In order to highlight such advances, Benchmark is launching its Innovation Awards scheme. 18 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Defining innovation The Benchmark Innovation Awards scheme has been devised to recognise and reward innovations which solve problems faced when designing and implementing a security solution, which add to the degree of security offered, or which increase the range of realworld benefits on offer. Innovations must bring true value; it is not enough to add features for the sake of expanding a list of functions, nor to claim a ‘first’. If there is no real benefit for installers and integrators, or for their customers, then the developments will not be considered!
awards jan14_000_Benchmark_aug13 06/12/2013 12:02 Page 2
Benchmark Innovation Awards
NOMINATIONS CLOSE: 31 DECEMBER 2013
To be worthy of nomination, devices or systems must include a specific feature or function which ranks as innovative. Totally new concepts are, of course, also valid, but we all must accept that they don’t come along too often! Also, devices or software which add functionality and bring together other established systems will be considered. Benchmark will not consider commercial success as a factor when judging entries. Innovation cannot be assessed by the number of units sold! That said, if a solution is not realistic due to price, complexity or suitability for use in security applications, then it is not truly innovative. Innovations which cannot be used are not going to benefit the industry or the end user!
Making nominations Nominations can be made for any products, software, systems or services that are currently available to installers and integrators in the UK. Nominations can be made via the Benchmark website at: www.benchmarkmagazine.com Once the nomination period closes, all of the entries will be considered, and a shortlist will be created for each sector. Remember; innovation is the lifeblood of the security systems sector, and it is vital for a credible and profitable future. Ensure that those who strive to deliver advanced developments and better solutions are recognised for their efforts!
Innovation Awards Categories The Benchmark Innovation Awards are judged across five technology areas, with two categories covering each sector. These differentiate between hardware devices and software or service offerings. The five technology areas are Video Surveillance, Access Control, Intruder Detection, Perimeter Protection and Infrastructure. Video Surveillance covers video capture, management, archiving, transmission and processing (including analytics, ANPR, business intelligence and other technology-based automated video handling tools). The use of IVA specifically for perimeter protection is not included. Access Control includes devices or systems designed to manage the flow of people, vehicles or assets into or out of specified areas. It also includes any devices or software products designed to supplement or enhance the performance of such systems, including (but not limited to) credentials, data storage and management, communications, monitoring, etc.. Intruder Detection covers devices and systems designed to detect, and/or signal intrusion attempts into protected areas, as well as the management, transmission and monitoring of alarm data. Both internal and external devices are included, as are services involved with monitoring, signalling, etc.. Devices aimed at the detection of perimeter breaches are not included. Perimeter Protection includes devices, software or systems designed specifically to detect perimeter breaches, or to prevent and deter such acts. Along with a variety of sensors (long range, fence-mounted, buried, etc.) this category also covers video analytics when used specifically for perimeter protection, thermal imaging, radar-based systems, etc.. Infrastructure is made up of the physical and organisational devices and software used for the operation of a security solution, or the services and facilities necessary for its day-to-day management. This includes cabling and transmission devices, routing and switching hardware, servers, data handling devices, and total management software used to integrate and interoperate distinct security elements of a complete solution.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
19
icrealtime test jan14_000_Benchmark_DEC13 10/12/2013 16:24 Page 1
79%
A Complete Package?
BENCHMARK RATINGS
IC Realtime – ICIP-D2000VIR
IC Realtime – ICIP-D2000VIR
Product Design: Ease of Installation: Features & Functions: Image Quality: Overall Performance:
78% 78% 80% 80% 78%
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
In recent years, the video surveillance sector has seen something of a proliferation of HD day/night ruggedised static dome cameras with integral illumination. Often billed as the complete all-in-one package, these units obviously attract much interest from installers and integrators. IC Realtime has released the ICIP-D2000VIR into this sector. Benchmark took a closer look to see if it ticked all the right boxes. s demand for HD video increases, many installers and integrators are looking towards integrated cameras. Much as with composite video, integrated models are a popular choice because they can deliver an all-in-one complete image capture solution straight from the box. Supplied with a lens, housing, integral power management and often integral infrared illumination, these cameras typically are fast to install and can be fully operational with minimal set-up. When it comes to IP-enabled HD models, such cameras often additionally incorporate support for edge recording media and PoE. The market has a number of such devices, ranging from very low cost, basic units which creak a bit in terms of performance, to high end devices with excellent image quality and high functionality. IC Realtime’s offering in this sector is the ICIP-D2000VIR, an integrated vandal resistant HD static dome camera.
A
Specification The ICIP-D2000VIR is a day/night static dome camera, which utilises a 1/3 inch Sony 20 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
progressive scan Exmor CMOS chipset and makes use of the Texas Instruments Da Vinci processing engine. The camera can deliver dual streams, with resolutions of HD1080p, HD720p, 1280 x 1024, 1280 x 960 and D1 on the main stream. Compression can be H.264 (baseline or high profile are also offered) or M-JPEG. Frame rate is up to 25fps. The substream offers resolutions of D1 or CIF, again at rates of up to 25fps. Bit rate for the main stream can be variable or constant, with a maximum throughput of 8Mbps; this is enough for full HD video, but a tad more would be appreciated in some applications. The secondary sub-stream is capped at 1Mbps. The camera includes on-board infrared illuminators, and has a quoted range of 10-20 metres, which is a little ambiguous. We did note that with our test unit, of the 15 LEDs, 6 did not have the lenses fitted. We checked the packaging and they hadn’t fallen out, so we can only assume this is a manufacturing flaw. Sensitivity is quoted as 0.2 lux (F1.2). The lens is a 3-9mm motorised varifocal item. Control is via a small joystick on the camera interior. It can also be set and adjusted via the camera’s GUI. The camera includes a slot for a MicroSD card, and features an alarm input and output. Two way audio is also supported. Other features include exposure mode, backlight compensation and WDR, video motion detection, privacy masking, etc.. Power input can be via PoE; 12V DC or 24V AC are also supported. The unit is supplied with a very brief quick start guide; a full manual is on a CD, but ours
icrealtime test jan14_000_Benchmark_DEC13 10/12/2013 16:24 Page 2
Professional Test
wasn’t for this specific camera. There was also a manual for software, but no software is included!
Performance The installation process does give the impression that the product isn’t 100 per cent finished. The quick start guide refers you to an installation utility, which isn’t supplied. Whilst many manufacturers at the budget end rely on static IP addresses, if you promise a utility, you should include it. Connection could not be achieved with the static IP address, so this necessitated a camera reset. It’s not a big problem, but wasted time is never good. As mentioned, the manual isn’t for this specific camera, but there many similarities with the model it is for so you will get by! Once connected, the next stage was to download and run the driver. This is an executable program on the camera, and loading it had varied results. These weren’t consistent and did seem to indicate that the firmware wasn’t totally smooth. The first attempts informed us the file was not present. Then it did download but wouldn’t run. In the end we had to download and save the file, restart the PC, run the executable file and restart again to get it to work. Even if such a procedure is normal, there’s little mention of the process is the documentation we received. A point of note is that whilst the camera seemed stable with Internet Explorer, it gave regular errors (stream overtime) with other browsers. Once up and running, the menus are fairly straightforward. The GUI is relatively clean, and set-up is as you would expect from a basic camera. Viewing an HD1080p stream using H.264 and 8Mbps bitrate results in a sharp and detailed image. Colour fidelity is high, and there’s no real noticeable bias towards warm or cool tones. Even at the highest settings the camera doesn’t seem to drop frames. There is a slight blur on very fast motion, but this can be reduced by manually setting the shutter speed. Latency is low, at around a quarter of one second, and it is consistent so there’s no jumpiness when viewing streams. Dropping the bitrate has an increasing impact of the detail and quality of the image, and when you hit 4Mbps the compression is
still working well, although there are signs of artefacting in bland areas of the image. As light levels fall, you see degradation at a fairly early point, around 20 lux, especially if you’ve increased the shutter speed to dial out motion blur. Setting this back to 1/25th second does see a slight improvement, and things improve slightly as gain increases between 10 and 5 lux. It’s somewhere in this range that the camera should switch, to our thinking. Sadly it doesn’t and hangs on to a deteriorating colour image until 1 lux, when noise is obvious. Not only does the camera switch too late, but when the infrared illumination does take over there is an inconsistent level of light across the whole scene. This might be due to some of the LEDs not having lenses fitted. Motion detection is basic, but it is on a par with the degree of performance expected from an entry level product.
Verdict The ICIP-D2000VIR is a relatively new model, and our feeling was that it needs a few software tweaks and a decent manual to get it up to speed with the competition. Whilst you can achieve what you need (with a little patience and perseverance), there are other options available in the market which deliver a smoother installation process. The general video quality is well implemented, and aside from some minor barreling on the lens at the widest angles, there’s little to fault until light levels drop. There’s very little that you can do to alter the switching point aside from messing with the gain levels, but that impacts on other performance. The camera either needs to give the installer the chance to set the switching point, or automated switching should be earlier. The camera isn’t a disaster; it’s close to being right, but given the breadth of other options out there it cannot be Recommended unless IC Realtime address the minor issues. We’ll let you know if they do. 21 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
FINAL best of 2013_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 17:36 Page 2
Best of 2013
In this round-up, Benchmark looks back at products which have received Recommended status in 2013. Grundig GCI-F0505B The GCI-F0505B from Grundig is a megapixel day/night camera which employs a 1/2.8 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor to deliver resolutions of up to 3 megapixels (2048 x 1536). There is an option for 1280 x 1024 at 25fps. HD1080p and HD720p streaming are supported. The camera offers multiple encoding, with either H.264 or M-JPEG streams. Sensitivity is quoted as 0.5 lux for a 50IRE image with an F1.2 lens. Maximum bit rate is 8Mbps on the main stream; others are lower. Features and functions include the usual suspects: backlight compensation, exposure, white balance, wide dynamic range and noise reduction. The camera also offers motion detection, and set-up is aided via an activity histogram.
Tamron M13VG288IR The M13VG288IR is a three megapixel 1/3 inch 2.8–8mm varifocal lens. It is a DC auto-iris model with an aperture of F1.2. The lens is an aspherical model, and includes IR coating to prevent focus-shift when used with infrared illumination. The CS-mount lens is supplied with a pre-fitted four pin connector for auto-iris functionality. The lead is around 210mm in length.
Idis Direct IP The concept of Direct IP is a simple one. The company offers a selection of NVRs with different performance characteristics, PoE enabled switches, a range of accessories such as codecs and keyboards, a variety of cameras and a range of software. Auto-detection of devices and simple configurations underpin the Direct IP platform. The system uses the FEN network configurator, which allows simplified ‘one click’ configuration to deliver remote connectivity and system control.
DV Tel CM-3211-11 The CM-3211-11 is a dome-type megapixel day/night camera from DV-Tel. The model, which is part of the Quasar range, utilises a 1/3 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor to deliver resolutions of up to 1.3 megapixels (1280 x 1024). The camera can also deliver HD720p streams. Compression is H.264 and M-JPEG. Dual streaming is supported (either two H.264 streams, or one H.264 and one M-JPEG), and these can be delivered as 25fps and 13fps where two 1.3 megapixel streams are configured. Sensitivity is claimed as 0.2 lux. The lens is varifocal, with a motorised focus functionality. The dome itself is rated to IP66, making it ideal for external use. Features and functions include wide dynamic range, multi-zone motion detection, two-way audio, alarm input/output and tamper protection. Edge storage is supported via an SD card. Power is PoE, or 12V DC/24V AC.
22
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
IQinVision IQ863NE IQinVision’s IQ863NE is a megapixel day/night camera which includes a housing, cable-managed bracket and backbox. The camera utilises a 1/3 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor and delivers resolutions of up to 3 megapixels (2048 x 1536) at 20fps; real-time video can be achieved with a resolution of 1600 x 1200. It also supports HD1080p and HD720p streams. Multiple encoding is supported, with H.264 (Main) and M-JPEG options. Sensitivity is quoted as 0.3 lux. Maximum bit rate is 11Mbps. Features and functions include selectable gain style, auto-focus, motion detection, noise reduction, support for DTS and alarm handling.
Iluminar IR312-A100-24 The IR312-A100-24 is a semi-covert 850 nanometre model. It has a specified range of up to 24 metres and coverage of 100 degrees. The unit has an integral photocell (adjustable from 30 to 70 lux), and output power is adjustable too. It also includes a telemetry input and photocell following connection. An additional connector is required for this. The unit has a 3m power flylead (12-32V DC or 24V AC).
Axis P3384-V Axis Communications’ P3384-V is a vandalresistant megapixel day/night camera which employs a 1/3 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor to deliver resolutions of up to 1.3 megapixels (1280 x 960) in realtime. The camera can deliver multiple streams using H.264 and M-JPEG compression. Sensitivity is claimed as 0.5 lux, or lower using the camera’s Lightfinder function. The camera is a static dome unit, and is specified for internal use only. The lens is a 3-9mm varifocal F1.2 device, and offers P-Iris functionality. Features are diverse and include wide dynamic range, backlight compensation, gain control, exposure control, image rotation and privacy masking. This model also includes intelligent motion detection, audio detection and tamper protection. Edge storage is supported, as is video buffering. Other features include two-way audio, automatic focus and alarm input/output. Power is PoE.
FINAL best of 2013_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 17:37 Page 3
Best of 2013
Everfocus EDH5240 Leeds Electronics – CI-12-ASP-DAASS The CI-12-ASP-DAASS from Leeds Electronics is the latest addition to the company’s 2Y-Link range. The range comprises a number of solutions which enable the transmission of video, audio and alarm data, along with low power, over a single two-wire link. The system comprises two main elements; a signal processor and mixers. The signal processor is the main unit, which is housed at the control room. The mixers are located at the remote devices, such as the cameras. The signal processors link to the mixers using Cat 5 cable, with one pair required for each link. This allows a single cable to be run for up to four cameras. Leeds can supply a break-out box to allow a star or ring configuration connection at the location of multiple devices.
Axis Q1922-E The Axis Q1922-E is a thermal imager. The device is available with a wide range of lens options and uses an uncooled microbolometer with a resolution of 640 x 480 pixels. The thermal image stream is compressed using the H.264 algorithm; there is also an option to support M-JPEG. Customised stream profiles can be created, with variable bandwidth and refresh rates. Refresh rate is up to 30Hz.
Abus SC TVIP40000 The TVIP40000 video server from Abus SC is a single channel unit. Supported resolutions are D1 (720 x 576), 4CIF, CIF and QCIF. The video stream is handled as 25fps, and compression can be configured as H.264, M-JPEG or MPEG4. Up to four streams are supported, with a maximum of 10 simultaneous users. Features include video motion detection, with three zones configurable, and the unit can be programmed for preand post-alarm handling. It also features an alarm input and relay output. Alarm actions include email, file transfer via FTP, HTTP notification or recording to attached media such as a NAS unit. An on-board SD/SDHC card can be fitted, delivering up to 32GB of temporary storage.
The Everfocus EDH5240 is an HD-SDI enabled indoor static dome camera. It makes use of a 1/2.7 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor to deliver resolutions of HD1080p, HD1080i and HD720p. Frame rate is 25fps for the progressive scan resolutions, and 50 fields for the interlaced option. Signal to noise ratio is claimed to be 39dB. Sensitivity is quoted as 0.5 lux at F1.3. The camera is fitted with an integral varifocal lens; specification is a focal length of 3.3-10mm. Aperture is F1.3. To aid low light performance, the day/night camera is fitted with integral infrared LEDs. These are 850 nanometre items. Range is quoted as 20 metres.
Axis Communications Q7424-R The Q7424-R video server from Axis Communications is a ruggedized four channel unit. Supported resolutions range from 176 x 120 up to D1 (720 x 576). There is also an option for a full resolution quad view (1536 x 1152). The video transmission rate is 25fps per channel, although if a quad view at full resolution is delivered, this limits frame rate to 15fps. Compression can be configured as H.264 (baseline or main profile) or M-JPEG, and one stream of each can be set for each video channel. Features include intelligent video, which is made up of video motion detection, audio detection and camera tamper detection. There is provision for four alarm inputs and outputs. The server can be programmed for pre- and post-alarm buffering. An on-board SD/SDHC/SDXC card can be fitted, delivering up to 128GB of temporary storage.
Panasonic WJ-NV200 The WJ-NV200 NVR from Panasonic supports up to 16 video inputs. These can be i-Pro range cameras from the manufacturer; ONVIF conformant models are also supported. The WJ-NV200 handles input video streams using H.264, MPEG-4 and MJPEG compression, and can record at both 16:9 and 4:3 aspect ratios. Resolutions for the former include 1920 x 1080 and 1280 x 720. Recording is up to real-time. Recording can be triggered or scheduled, and up to 15 seconds of pre-alarm footage can be supported. Frame rate, video quality and resolution can be set for each individual camera. Up to two internal HDDs are supported.
Ingersoll Rand MT15 The MT15 is a reader from the Aptiq range of multitechnology readers. The unit can read both 125kHz and 13.56MHz credentials. It is compatible with Aptiq Mifare DESfire EV1 and Mifare Classic, along with most other manufacturers’ smart credentials and proximity offerings. The reader can also be used for NFC reading. The readers has a standard Wiegand output; an RS485 output is available as an option. For user status feedback, the unit supports red/green LEDs and an integral buzzer.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
23
FINAL best of 2013_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 17:33 Page 4
Best of 2013
Hikvision DS-6704HFI The DS-6704HFI video server from Hikvision is a four channel unit. Supported resolutions are 4CIF (704 x 576), 2CIF, CIF and QCIF. Compression can be configured as H.264, M-JPEG, MPEG4 or MPEG2. The video streams are transmitted at 25fps, aside from M-JPEG streams which are limited to 15fps. Dual streams are supported, and bit rate is adjustable per channel, up to a maximum of 8Mbps. Features include video motion detection, four alarm inputs and two alarm outputs, as well as exception alarms such as video loss, network disconnection, etc.. Alarm actions include file transfer via FTP or recording to an attached unit such as a NAS unit. An on-board MicroSD card can be fitted, delivering up to 32GB of temporary storage.
D-Link – DNR-326 The DNR-326 network video recorder is a simple two-bay HDD management device, which is supplied bundled with VMS software. The recorder supports up to 9 video inputs. These can be D-Link cameras; models from Acti, Arecont Vision, Sony, Panasonic, Axis, Cisco, IQinVision and Mobotix are also supported. The NVR supports input video streams using H.264, MPEG-4 and MJPEG compression, and can record at a variety of resolutions including HD1080p and HD720p. The cameras’ configurations, such as frame rate, resolution and quality, can all be adjusted for recording. Recording can be event-based or scheduled. Recording capacity is quoted as 90Mbps for H.264 at both HD resolutions.
Riva RE4000 The Riva RE4000 video server from Vidicore is a four channel unit. Supported resolutions are D1, 4CIF, 2CIF, VGA, CIF, QVGA and QCIF. The video streams are up to 25fps, and compression can be configured as H.264, M-JPEG or MPEG4. Dual streaming is supported, and deinterlacing can be switched on or off. The unit also features a composite video output. Features include video motion detection, along with four alarm inputs and four outputs, and video analytics. Included as standard are multi-window tracking and tamper detection. Advanced options include behaviour detection with filters for direction, stopping, loitering, entering, exiting, appear, disappear, abandoned and removed objects, tailgating, 3D behaviour and counting. However, these require an additional licence.
Everfocus EHH5200 The EHH5200 is an HD-SDI static dome HD1080p camera. The camera is a true day/night variant, and makes use of a 1/2.7 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor. The headline resolution is HD1080p, but the camera also offers HD1080i and HD720p resolutions. The camera features the typical basic surveillance settings such as electronic shutter, backlight compensation, AGC, white balance, etc.. Day/night witching is included. Sensitivity is stated as 0.5 lux.
24
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Bosch Security VJT-X40XF-E The VJT-X40XF-E video server from Bosch Security is a four channel unit. Supported resolutions are 4CIF (704 x 576), 2CIF, CIF and QCIF. The video stream is handled as 25fps, and compression can be configured as H.264 baseline or main profile. Data transfer can be capped, with rates of up to 6Mbps per channel. Two independent streams per channel can be established; a third M-JPEG stream can be used for third party integrations. Features include video motion detection, which can be configured for sensitivity and object size. The server also features four alarm inputs, with one relay output. Alarm actions include dual recording, whereby image resolution and frame rate can be increased when an event occurs. Internal archiving is achieved via a CompactFlash card slot; a maximum of 2TB can be supported by this.
Texecom Prestige Compact PW The Prestige Compact PW has a coverage pattern of 90 degrees, and a range of 12 x 12 metres. With regard to pet immunity, the detector is specified as being tolerant with pets of up to 35kg. The units use a proprietary technology referred to as HOTLens. This uses diffraction, which occurs when a wave encounters an obstacle. The effect creates the bending of waves around small objects. The Compact series detectors include a number of features including digital signal processing, digital temperature compensation, floating point thresholds, white light rejection, elimination of false alarms due to jarring and sealed optics to prevent foreign bodies from affecting stability. The detector features selectable pulse count (1 or 2), and includes on-board EOL resistors for ease of installation.
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 18:04 Page 1
FINAL best of 2013_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 17:32 Page 6
Best of 2013
Vicon V922D-N39-IP-P
Bosch Security NDN932V03-IP
The V922D-N39-IP-P is a network-connected static dome HD1080p ruggedised camera. The camera is a true day/night variant, and makes use of a 1/2.8 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor. The camera offers multiple streaming, with a choice of H.264, MPEG4 or M-JPEG compression. Resolutions can be HD1080p, HD720p or a range of standard definition resolutions are also available.
The NDN932V03-IP from Bosch is a ruggedised networkconnected static dome HD1080p camera. The camera is a true day/night variant, and makes use of a 1/3 inch progressive scan CMOS sensor. Multiple streaming is supported, with a choice of H.264 or M-JPEG streams. These can deliver HD1080p or HD720p streams in real-time. Video quality is set by bit-rate. This is adjustable on a per stream basis, as is frame rate. The camera features all the typical surveillance settings plus a few others. These include wide dynamic range, motion detection and video analytics, two-way audio, alarm input/output, intelligent noise reduction, BLC, etc.. Content-based imaging technology (CBIT) uses information from the analytics engine to adjust processing to optimise the image based upon conditions.
Samsung SNB6004P Samsung’s SNB6004P is a networked-enabled day/night HD box camera. The unit utilises the new Wisenet III processing engine. The 1/2.8 inch sensor delivers streams at HD1080p and HD720p resolution, along with other megapixel and standard definition resolutions. Multiple streaming is supported, and compression is via H.264 or M-JPEG. Video quality is controlled via bit rate. Frame rate is 60fps at all resolutions when using H.264 streams; M-JPEG is 15fps at HD and megapixel resolutions, or 30fps for standard definition footage. Features include focus control, wide dynamic range, backlight compensation, contrast adjustment, noise reduction, image stabilisation, AGC, motion detection, privacy masking and de-fogging. The camera also offers video analytics.
DVTel SC1DN-A The SC1DN-A is a part of the Ioimage range of cameras from DVTel. The camera is a box-type unit with on-board video analytics. It uses a 1/4 inch CMOS sensor to deliver both composite and digital video. Composite video resolution is 540 TVL, whilst networked streamed video is VGA with a frame rate of up to 18fps when H.264 compression is used. At the heart of the SC1DN-A lies its video content analysis (VCA) engine. This is self-contained, and requires no additional hardware or software.
Vigilant Vision DS23.6SDI The DS23.6SDI is a 23.6 inch LED display. The 16:9 unit delivers 1920 x 1080 pixel resolution. Contrast ratio is 1000:1, and brightness is 300cd/m2. The display has a response time of 1.5-3.5ms. Connections are HD-SDI, an HDMI input, a VGA input, an S-Video input, two BNC composite inputs and outputs, and audio input either from a stereo jack or via two phono connections.
Videcon CBP6324DN-HD Videcon’s CBP6324DN-HD is an indoor static dome HD1080p camera which uses HD-SDI connectivity. The day/night camera uses a 1/3 inch CMOS sensor to deliver an HD1080p or HD720p stream. Features include wide dynamic range, backlight compensation, highlight compensation, digital slow shutter, AGC, digital noise reduction, de-fogging and a range of other standard functions. Motion detection and privacy masking are also supported. Sensitivity is quoted as 1 lux.
26
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Siemens CCMS2025 The CCMS2025 from Siemens is a networkenabled HD1080p box-type day/night camera. It uses a 1/3 inch CMOS sensor to deliver HD720p streams. Triple encoding is supported, and compression options are H.264, MPEG4 and M-JPEG. Features include automatic gain control, backlight compensation, bi-directional audio, motion detection, privacy masking and digital noise reduction, alongside the other standard configurations. Power is PoE, or 12V DC/24V AC standard power supplies can be used. Edge recording is available via an SD card slot.
027_Layout 1 09/12/2013 13:47 Page 1
ACTIVE IR BEAMS TAKEX infrared beams offer the ultimate in trouble-free perimeter detection up to 200m outdoor / 400m indoor.
NEW
OUTDOOR PIR High performance mirror optic external PIR. 30m x 30m wide angle or 50m x 3m long range narrow angle models available.
SPEAKER SENSORS Record any voice or sound message for warning/security, health & safety, advisory or greeting applications.
OMS-12FE PET TOLERANT OUTDOOR PIR
MINI BEAMS Miniature beams for discreet detection across doorways and windows, for prestige or covert applications.
The OMS-12FE uses our reliable dual-zone detection system to create 180 degrees of volumetric protection with a range of 3 to 12m. Equipped with 4 pyros, the detection field is divided into left and right zones which can be enabled/disabled as required for precise area control. The slim-profile housing features a back-tamper, and the clearly labelled option switches
REFLECTOR BEAMS A convenient way to monitor entrances, driveways etc. where cabling to both ends is impractical.
make installation a breeze.
tel: +44 (0)1256 475555
|
fax: +44 (0)1256 466268
|
email: sales@takex.com
w w w.iluminar in c.co m
|
web: www.takex.com/uk
WE LIGHT UP THE WORLD
Sometimes, It’s What You Don’t See…
Don’t Waste Your Security Camera Investment with Poor Lighting. Even the best low-light cameras in the industry will perform better with proper lighting, especially megapixel cameras. Transform a mediocre picture into a great picture with Iluminar’s LED based infrared and white light illuminators for use with all IP, megapixel, and analog cameras. Remember, without light there is no quality video. Old Bank House, 59 High Street, Odiham, Hampshire, RG29 1LF
Tel: +44 (0) 1256 703340 email:sales@iluminarinc.com
FINAL best of 2013_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 17:30 Page 7
Best of 2013
Bosch Security VOT-320V013L The VOT-320V013L is an external thermal imager. Bosch can supply the unit with a wide range of lens options. The imager uses an uncooled microbolometer with a 320 x 240 resolution. The thermal imager supports three streams: the two main streams utilise the H.264 algorithm, while the third is an M- JPEG stream. There is the ability to create customised profiles, with variable bandwidth and refresh rates. Refresh rate is up to 8.33Hz. Additional features include video motion detection and IVA. The imager offers an edge recording capability via an integral SD card slot.
Vicon HDXPRES-4 Vicon’s HDXPRES-4 supports up to 4 video inputs. These must be compatible Vicon cameras, as well as other brands and ONVIF devices. The NVR features an integral four-way switch with PoE. All you need to do is connect a camera to each of the RJ45 ports, and this powers the cameras and handles the data. The NVR supports input video streams using H.264, and records HD1080p video as standard. Recording can be event-based or scheduled. Differing parameters can be set for continuous recording and event-based recording.
GJD Clarius IL-8100 The IL-8100 is a semi-covert 850 nanometre model, and so emits a faint red glow when in use. It has a specified range of up to 48 metres and coverage of 100 degrees. The unit has an integral photocell (adjustable from 30 to 70 lux) and power output is also adjustable. One nice touch is that connections for the telemetry input and photocell following are included in the 3m flylead which also handles power (12-32V DC or 24V AC).
Raytec Vario I8-1 Raytec’s Vario range is so-called because it features interchangeable lenses which allow the installer to set the coverage of the illuminator. Many of the Vario’s settings are configured via a common remote control. It’s an option and needs to be purchased. The unit has an integral photocell (adjustable with three levels of sensitivity) and power output can be adjusted. Connections for the telemetry input and photocell following are included in the flylead which also handles power (12V DC or 24V AC).
Optex AX100TF The AX1000TF detectors from Optex are active infrared twin beam sensors. The detectors have four selectable frequencies and are pulsed to ensure that extraneous sources of infrared light cannot be introduced. The beam interruption time required for an alarm event can be configured, with 4 selectable options: 50, 100, 250 and 500 milliseconds. Alarm period is 2 seconds. The unit requires both beams to be interrupted to trigger an alarm condition, reducing nuisance activations created by animals, birds or windborne objects.
Takex PB20TE The PB-20TE detectors from Takex are active infrared twin beam sensors and have a range of 20 metres in external applications. The detectors feature four selectable frequencies, are double modulated to enhance performance, and pulsed to reject infrared light from other sources. The beam interruption time can be adjusted to suit conditions at an application. The range of adjustment is 50 to 700 milliseconds. This is made via a potentiometer. Alarm time is 1.5 seconds. The detectors are rated to IP54. The covers include integral anti-frost and antidew protection.
Aver – IWH5416 Touch II Samsung SRN1670DP The SRN-1670DP network video recorder supports up to 16 video inputs. These can be Samsung cameras; ONVIF and RSTP conformant models are also supported. The NVR supports input video streams using H.264, MPEG-4 and MJPEG compression, and can record at a variety of resolutions including 2048 x 1536, 1920 x 1080, 1280 x 1024, 4CIF and VGA. Other settings, such as frame rate, also need to be configured at the camera. Recording can be event-based or scheduled, and up to 15 seconds of prealarm footage can be supported, along with six hours of post-alarm footage. Video quality can be set for every camera stream that is recorded.
28
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
The IWH5416 Touch II network video recorder from Aver supports up to 16 video inputs. These can be Aver cameras; ONVIF conformant models are also supported. The NVR supports input video streams using H.264, MPEG-4 and MJPEG compression, and can record at a variety of resolutions up to 5 megapixels per channel, with an overall capacity for streams of up to 80 megapixels across all inputs. Recording can be event-based or scheduled. There are a number of event options including motion and object detection, face detection, scene change, etc.. These can be associated with various actions initiated via an alarm
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 11:16 Page 1
casejan14_000_Benchmark_dec12 06/12/2013 13:39 Page 1
Higher Resolutions
Sometimes decried as unnecessary, ever-increasing megapixel resolutions are questioned by a few in the video surveillance industry. Some argue that there is no need to go beyond HD1080p, and in many applications such a view can be accepted. However, in a number of higher risk applications, significantly higher resolutions do make an increased amount of sense. Benchmark considers the potential role of multi-megapixel surveillance systems. ver since megapixel video first arrived in the security surveillance sector, the race has been on to deliver ever higher resolutions. Just as the consumer sector has battled to increase megapixel counts, so the surveillance manufacturers have pushed video resolutions. Whilst there arguably was an element of ‘ego’ in some of the earliest attempts to climb
E
30 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
to the top of the resolution heap, the reality is that certain multi-megapixel products do add benefits for many applications. The concept of digital pan, tilt and zoom within an image is not new. The function is also not the sole preserve of cameras with high megapixel counts. Indeed, some manufacturers cite this function as a reason to move to HD. This is not something that Benchmark agrees with. Most customers want HD because of enhanced image quality, not because they might be able to utilise a 4x digital zoom function! However, when you consider higher resolutions, such as 5-, 10- or 20megapixels – then the potential benefits of digital pan, tilt and zoom do offer added value. With multi-megapixel cameras, the possible digital zoom ratios achievable before image degradation becomes obvious are significant. This allows the creation of a wide area surveillance overview which can be
casejan14_000_Benchmark_dec12 06/12/2013 13:40 Page 2
Case Study
investigated, both as a live and a recorded video stream. Such an option is both credible and cost-effective.
The right balance High megapixel cameras do typically incorporate a degree of balance with regard to performance. The reason for this is basically an economic one. In order to remain realistically priced, it is important that the processing requirements do not become excessive. In order to manage processing needs, it becomes necessary to reduce the sheer amount of data that the camera handles. As the goal is to capture very high resolution images, it is pointless to try and throttle the picture quality. Instead, it is inevitably the frame rate which is restricted. Some – typically those with other devices to sell – highlight this as a downside for high megapixel cameras. However, when considered in context, this is clearly not the case. The reason for the installation of such cameras – a wider area view that can be examined in detail during and after incidents, without losing other general scene footage – underlines why real-time streams are not necessary. Few applications will require real-time very high resolution images, and it’s not realistic to expect a user to invest in the level of storage and/or management infrastructure needed for the amount of data that would be generated. It is the ability to manipulate the data which is more important. By way of an example, consider a VGA image. It is 640 x 480 pixels, made up of just over 300,000 pixels. It is arguably the lowest resolution image at which useful details of a scene can be guaranteed (obviously, this is very much dependent upon the optics used and the viewed scene). Now compare this to an HD1080p image, which equates to a 2-megapixel image. It is possible to digitally zoom to a small degree before the HD image degrades to a point where it is inferior to the VGA image. This is because the HD image contains nearly 7 times the amount of data of the VGA image. Whilst many will seek HD footage for enhanced real-time video streams, this isn’t generally the case with higher resolutions. The reason is because the price/performance trade-off isn’t worthwhile. There’s no point in paying for the capabilities to stream, record
A Supplementary Option One of the benefits of modern video surveillance solutions is the ability to mix and match video sources, and handle a variety of individually configured streams. As such, there should not be any need to compromise when it comes to overall delivery. This flexibility allows a combination of devices to be used, exploiting the available strengths of certain system elements without any exposure to their weaknesses. It is interesting that some manufacturers (typically those without higher megapixel offerings) like to highlight the weaknesses of such products without considering that any solution which uses only one type of camera (or any device for that matter) will always face a degree of compromise. Modern solutions allow a number of differing approaches to be taken, thereby exploiting the potential on offer. An often quoted ‘short-coming’ of higher megapixel devices is the reduced frame rate which is often necessary due to a need for higher processing power. However, few if any sites would be prepared to make the financial investment required to store and manage real-time footage from 5, 10 or higher megapixel streams. That said, in many applications, such devices can provide a highly detailed overview of a protected area, simplifying operator interaction. If there are areas where real-time coverage is a necessity, then this can be delivered by the use of other lower resolution cameras. Often, these can be HD cameras. However, in many cases D1 or even VGA units may be suitable. If, for example, higher resolution units are capturing images that can be used for the identification of individuals, vehicles or other objects, then a lower quality video stream can perform the secondary role of providing evidence of continuity. Whether SD and HD video supplements the multi-megapixel footage or vice versa will be very much dependent upon the needs of any individual site. However, one thing which is certain is that any solution that does not utilise a variety of image capture options to address all requirements will inevitably deliver a degree of compromise.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
31
casejan14_000_Benchmark_dec12 06/12/2013 13:40 Page 3
Case Study
and display 5-, 10- or 20-megapixel footage if you’re not going to see the full benefits. However, if you capture footage of a wide area to deliver situational awareness, and then zoom in on specific incidents and events for a better understanding of what is – or has – happened, it is a different proposition. With multi-megapixel footage, this can easily be achieved using a single camera. To put this in context, a camera capturing a 4000 x 2672 pixel image will be delivering Video which contains nearly 36 times the amount of information of a VGA image. This allows a significant degree of digital zoom to be implemented before image degradation occurs. Some will argue that a PTZ camera can deliver superior optical zoom performance. However, it will not record the full scene if zoomed in on an incident. Equally, if capturing a wide angle scene, an operator cannot then zoom in on detail after the event.
A case in point Associated British Ports (ABP) is the UK’s largest port operator, with 21 sites. As with all such sites, it must comply with regulations such as the International Ship and Port Facility Security Code, and has implemented advanced security systems across its locations. In order to enhance security and to add operational benefits, it was decided to maximise performance by exploiting an existing optical fibre network. This allowed the introduction of a network-based solution, and opened up possibilities for very high resolution image capture. ABP opted for the installation of a solution from Avigilon. This was designed to not only 32
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
offer high quality video surveillance – something which is integral to ABP’s security policies – but also to ensure health and safety compliance. Michael Howarth, Humber IT Infrastructure Manager at ABP, stated, ‘With the highdefinition surveillance system in place, we can monitor the entire port operations – from loading ships to crane operations – from a centralised location to ensure port security, employee safety and productivity. As a result, we can strengthen security, improve operational flow, and reduce costs.’ Prior to the upgrade, ABP suffered with a lack of required image quality, unfavourable degrees of system reliability, and an interface that wasn’t intuitive. The new surveillance system incorporates 11-megapixel cameras to deliver a detailed overview, along with HD cameras for other surveillance needs. It also brings together digital and analogue system elements, helping to preserve legacy investment. The nature of the port’s geography caused challenges with the infrastructure, as it combines the fibre network, existing coaxial cable segments and wireless connectivity too. At the core of the system is the Avigilon Control Center network video management software. This allows access to the system from two ports situated seven miles apart, and operators can view live and recorded footage, and control all elements. The 11-megapixel cameras are used to monitor vehicle entry and exit and to provide driver identification and numberplate information. A 3-megapixel camera provides additional coverage. ABP also utilise a number of 5-megapixel cameras to monitor and control lock gates, which manage the access and egress of ships. The footage allows staff to ensure that there are no obstructions to prevent the lockgates from opening. Additional cameras, including existing analogue units, provide a site overview and monitor the entrance and exit to the cargo weighbridges.
In summary By leveraging the high resolutions of the Avigilon 11-megapixel cameras, and by combining a mix of cameras, ABP has proved that the best results are gained by exploiting the various strengths of different video options in one integrated solution!
Project1_benchmark_March13 08/02/2013 14:57 Page 1
Double Vari-Focal The Simple Choice 2.8mm
8mm
8mm
M13VG288IR 3 MP 1/2.7“ 2.8-8mm with IR-correction (DC-Iris)
The Double Vari-Focal solution. Cover all focal lengths from wide to tele with 3-Mega-Pixel resolution using just 2 lenses. The new IR-corrected Mega-Pixel lens series from Tamron features a focal length range of 2.8 to 50mm in just two lenses covering 126.1° to 6.8° horizontal field of view with use of a 1/2.7“ camera. A new optical design uses glass mold aspherical lens elements and a special optical coating that ensures 3MP high resolution even under IR light and a clear image. The simple choice for better security imaging. Tamron‘s Double Vari-Focal solution.
www.tamron.eu
50mm
M13VG850IR 3 MP 1/2.7“ 8-50mm with IR-correction (DC-Iris)
dave_jan14_000_Benchmark_nov10 10/12/2013 16:25 Page 2
Softly Softly
Softly softly... Okay, there are times when marketing products leads to the invention of an alleged problem that we didn’t know we had! That’s fine for a bit, but the day has to come when the pretence stops ... unless they really think we’re too stupid to spot it! he basics of marketing are fundamentally simple. Find out what people want, and give it to them. For example, take our Kylie. If I get home from work and she’s stomping around the house, I just take her to Kentucky Fried Something-or-other, order a family bucket of greasy fried stuff, and let her get on with it. If Mrs Dave is tutting and rolling her eyes, I shut up and prepare to flex the credit card. Such thinking works well when it’s obvious what people want, but what if they don’t yet know they want it? When Henry Ford was creating the automobile, he famously stated that if he had asked people what they wanted it would have been faster horses. This isn’t unique to the invention of the car. The vast majority of new technologies are not created because of public demand, but because an innovator finds a method of doing something in a better way. The history of innovation is littered with brilliant ideas that took a long time to be adopted, because people didn’t realise the benefits that were on offer. Often they had to experience the innovation before realising that the established ways weren’t the best. Often, during the early point of innovation, those tasked with selling it will try to come up with reasons why the customer should be happy to invest. Those who sell well highlight the positives of the innovation. Those who don’t sell as well will often take a negative approach, trying to highlight problems that exist with the established technology. The risk is that if the customer doesn’t see the highlighted problems as real problems, they might take a negative view of the innovation.
T
34
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
After all, no one likes a snake oil approach when they’re being sold something. It is also important to realise that once an innovation becomes mainstream, any negative selling fails, because the old technologies have been defeated! Despite this, some will continue to wheel them out, especially when a product doesn’t add anything above and beyond what the competition offers! Whenever I see that, I smell a bunch of something, and it ain’t bananas! Here’s the thing: not every product launched is going to break new ground. Because something is run of the mill, it doesn’t mean it’s bad. It offers more choices, more competition, and that’s a good thing. However, I’m not going to automatically switch to any new product just because I’m told I can log in from anywhere, even the other side of the world, or because I don’t need two cameras to capture colour video by day and monochrome video at night! In the past few months I’ve seen three marketing claims of this type; the two mentioned above promoted a DVR with network connectivity and a day/night camera. The third was a DVR with the promise that it would remove the headache of tape jams and rewinding duties! I dismissed all three as pointless, more so because they spent so long selling the allegedly revolutionary features that they forget to reveal the basics, like the core specifications! Whilst marketing innovations can present challenges, marketing existing technologies doesn’t. Maybe they just want people to laugh at them, or maybe they really do think that we’re all too stupid to understand!
Project3_Layout 1 06/12/2013 17:23 Page 1
Have you tried Integriti yet?
Sophistication is not about size The Integriti Security Management System is an IP connected access control and intruder security system that offers sophisticated centralised management for both small systems on a single site, or large systems distributed across the country or across the globe.
With a growing list of new installations take a moment to think of what you’re missing! The Integriti system offers an advanced suite of software, hardware and integrated solutions to deliver complete management of your entire integrated system.
Inner Range Europe Limited Units 10-11 Theale Lakes Business Park Moulden Way, Sulhampstead Reading, Berkshire RG74GB UNITED KINGDOM
integriti@innerrange.co.uk
a4 integriti 0ne page UK.indd 1
+44 (0) 845 470 5000 www.innerrange.com 4/12/2013 8:40 am
iluminar test jan14_000_Benchmark_DEC13 10/12/2013 16:31 Page 1
Accurate Reading?
84%
Iluminar – LPRS-60-24
BENCHMARK RATINGS Iluminar – LPRS-60-24
Product Design: Ease of Installation: Features & Functions: Image Quality: Overall Performance:
84% 90% 80% 82% 84%
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Given the advances made with regards to video analytics in mainstream applications, it seems strange that ANPR – automatic numberplate recognition – hasn’t been embraced with the same gusto. Ideal for a wide range of vehicle management tasks, ANPR delivers real benefits. For some, issues with image capture have made reliability hard to guarantee. Iluminar claims to have the answer with its LPRS-60-24, a dedicated ANPR image capture camera. n recent years, the use of IVA (intelligent video analytics) has become increasingly common in mainstream applications. Often used as a trigger for alarm events, the move has seen IVA functionality built in to an increasing number of devices and software packages. This reflects how higher resolution digital video can enhance typical system performance through the use of analytics. The capabilities of such solutions range from basic line-crossing detection through sabotage protection, basic counting and facial detection. However, one form of analytics that hasn’t seen a
I
widespread take-up in the mainstream is ANPR. There are two main reasons for this. The first has much to do with the way in which ANPR providers positioned themselves. In the past, ANPR was aimed at law enforcement agencies and the larger campusstyle sites. The market for smaller scale sites, and tasks such as vehicular access control and traffic management, often weren’t considered as lucrative. With regard to such thinking, things gave started to change. The second stumbling block was the use of standard cameras for ANPR purposes. Whilst this is possible with careful specification and configuration of devices, results can be erratic, and many installers and integrators consider the technology to be more trouble than it is worth. Iluminar offers the LPRS-60-24, a dedicated ANPR camera which enhances image capture for numberplate recognition solutions.
Specification The LPRS-60-24 is a high resolution monochrome composite camera featuring on-board infrared illuminators. The camera utilises a 1/3 inch Sony Exview CCD chipset to deliver a claimed resolution of 580 TV lines. Much of the camera’s configurations are fixed. This may seem restrictive, but it does ensure optimum performance with regard to ANPR-related image capture. As such, the camera is not suitable for secondary use for general surveillance. It should be used solely for numberplate capture. 36 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
iluminar test jan14_000_Benchmark_DEC13 10/12/2013 16:31 Page 2
Professional Test
The unit features integral infrared 850 nanometre LED illuminators, and the power of these is adjustable via a potentiometer. The specified range for the camera is from 4 to 18 metres; another variant offers ranges of 2 to 10 metres. Numberplates can be read at speeds of up to 30mph, which is ideal for site entrances, approach roads, etc., where the user has the opportunity to regulate speeds. The facia of the camera includes an optical filter which reduces visible light falling on the CCD. This helps to eliminate glare from sunlight, headlights, etc., and maximises contrast for numberplates. The camera features a fixed omni-focus 16mm lens. Shutter speed is fixed at 1/1,000th of a second. Functionality such as Gain is automatic, as are all image manipulation features. The LPRS-60-24 is supplied in a black coated aluminium housing, which features a cable-managed bracket with three-axis alignment. This makes positioning a simple task. The housing is rated to IP67 making it ideal for outdoor use. Operating temperature range is -10 to 50 degrees C. Power input is 24V AC. The power connector and BNC output are fitted to a pre-attached flylead. Fixings are included, as is a brief but adequate installation guide.
Performance Installation of the LPRS-60-24 is very straightforward. It is, however, vital that whoever fits the unit has an understanding of design considerations when siting ANPR capture devices. The connection for power is a via a screw terminal block, and the BNC connection is simple. Both are on a flylead. Once mounted, you’re nearly finished. The one installer adjustment is for infrared intensity. This is adjusted via a potentiometer. The very first thing you’ll notice is that during daylight hours, the image has a high degree of detail, although in shaded areas it might be a little darker and duller than you’d expect. As light levels fall, so does the degree of detail. Fear not; this is how it should be! The optical filter reduces the incidence of visible light falling onto the CCD, and the fast shutter speed also has an impact. However, the filter does not affect the transmission of infrared light, and this makes any reflective surface – such as a numberplate – appear with a high degree of contrast.
The impact isn’t as great during the day, although numberplates can be clearly defined within an image. In lower light, gloom and at night, the performance is increased, because the numberplate has a much higher level of contrast. Fixed lenses can sometimes be a concern if there isn’t an opportunity to adjust focus, but the F2.0 optics on the LPRS-60-24 are very well set-up and, and there’s no sign of softness in the image. The camera housing is obviously ‘borrowed’ from a different model, because the rear of the includes two potentiometers for zoom and focus. However, these are simply pot covers and there is no functionality to be accessed. The infrared illuminators are permanently lit. This does eliminate any need for switching or other management of the camera. Finally, with regard to robustness, the camera doesn’t give any reason for concern. It is well built, sturdy and shouldn’t give any problems even in a typically British winter.
Verdict The LPRS-60-24 is a product with a very singular focus. It is optimised for ANPR, and should not be used for anything else. Indeed, this is made very clear by Iluminar. To the Benchmark way of thinking, ANPR solutions should use dedicated cameras which are optimised for the purpose. Otherwise, there are simply too many potential issues. Whilst you may initially think that taking away nearly all control over performance from the installer is a negative, it’s not. The unit is well optimised for its task, and if installed correctly it delivers the type of performance required. As such, the LPRS-60-24 has to be Recommended for ANPR applications.
37 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
FINAL bm web house_001_Benchmark_jul11 08/08/2011 16:20 Page 1
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
BENCHMARK
Benchmark – dedicated to independent tests, assessments and reviews of security products and solutions
The Benchmark website is a PRODUCT TESTS All tests are fully independent, and manufacturers supplement to the monthly have no involvement in the process. Additionally, Benchmark makes no charge, financially or of any magazine, and includes a variety other kind, for inclusion in tests. All products are selected by an independent team. In short, it’s the of tests and assessments of the only way you can ascertain the truth about product latest products, as well as guides performance! to product selection, technology Tests are carried out by an independent team of experts, telling you the truth about the performance challenges and information about of a wide range of security equipment, warts and all. influential technologies in the CHECK PREVIOUS ISSUES Benchmark back issues are available on-line, in a security sector. All content fully interactive format, and can be accessed free of is taken from the published charge. If Benchmark has tested the product, then you can establish the level of performance expected editions of Benchmark, so you in the field! will not find drafts by GUIDES AND CHALLENGES The Benchmark website includes product guides, manufacturers marketing their highlighting products that have been tested, or that wares or marketing hype that is have been recommended by security installers, system integrators, specifiers and security regurgitated via so many other consultants. There are also Technology Challenges, debunking the hype by reporting real-world channels. The content is written experiences of the various technologies. in plain English, free from technobabble, and reflects STAY UP TO DATE genuine experiences with the Benchmark is always testing and assessing products and technologies. Keep up to date equipment, whether that be with the latest reports by following Benchmark on Twitter. good, bad or indifferent. The www.twitter.com/benchmarkmag website is free to view.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
spot 39_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 16:48 Page 1
ADVERTISING FEATURE
A Different Option? Dahua – HDCVI Technology
ahua Technology has launched its High Definition Composite Video Interface (HDCVI) technology. HDCVI is an overcoax analogue HD video transmission standard, allowing long-distances. There are approximately 400 million analogue cameras in use in the world. The demand for high definition from end-users is increasing. However, changing the entire cabling creates higher operational costs. HDCVI is designed to allow existing systems to upgrade from standard definition to high definition without a need for new cabling or IP configurations. HDCVI is a solution for megapixel and high definition applications, featuring non-latent long-distance transmission. The modulation technology uses base-band and quadrature amplitudes, modulating the video signal before transmission. This avoids cross talk and completely separates the brightness and hue signals. HDCVI solutions incorporates both cameras and DVRs, and the system uses a star topology structure. The DVR is served as a node with an over-coax P2P (Point-toPoint) transmission to the camera. The technology offers two specifications — 1080p (1920 x 1080) and 720p (1280 x 720). In addition, the technology features Auto Signal Compensation (ASC) which delivers an extremely low signal distortion with long-distance transmissions.
D
Maximum transmission distance is claimed to be in excess of 500 metres, dependent upon the cable selected. HDCVI composites video, audio and control signals together for transmission over one coaxial cable. Audio signals and data communications are embedded in a blanking zone, which enhances synchronisation and supports 44.1kHz sampling rates. The data channels support control commands such as camera focus, PTZ control, real-time alarms, etc.. The forward data supports high transmission baud rates, while the reverse data supports lower baud rates. The HDCVI chipset comprises transmitting (TX) and receiving (RX) elements, which are designed for cameras and DVRs respectively. Chips could also be applied in fibre optic transceivers, distributors and matrices. Regarding analogue output, the TX chip is also compatible with CVBS and supports 720p at 25, 30, 50 and 60fps, and 1080p at 25 and 30fps. The RX chip supports HDCVI HD inputs and digital video outputs. It also supports flexible mapping of the HDCVI video input channel and digital output channel. HDCVI is claimed to be an industrial breakthrough that offers megapixel image quality over long distances, while enjoying a simple installation.
Tel: 0086 571 87688883 E-mail: overseas@dahuatech.com www.dahuasecurity.com www.benchmarkmagazine.com
39
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 11:18 Page 1
Advanced External Detection & Security Systems
D-TECT R Commercial Intruder
Residential
The Ricochet enabled range of external wireless detectors
Wireless CCTV
For more information... www.gjd.co.uk
+44 (0)1706 363 998
info@gjd.co.uk
BT Redcare Surveillance Helping to detect and protect
As a leading provider of CCTV transmission in the UK, you can be confident we can meet your needs and add value to your operations. Our range of transmission services includes analogue, IP and wireless CCTV, as well as cameras and video management platforms. We also provide a reliable helpdesk service that’s open 24/7 365 days a year to give you further peace of mind.
To find out more call 0800 011 3119* and quote B1
*calls are free from a BT landline and payphone. Costs from mobiles vary between service providers.
buyersguide_jan14_000_Benchmark_aug13 09/12/2013 20:36 Page 2
Buyer’s Guide
Buyer’s Guide: Door Controllers n recent years, access control has moved from being a basic security solution to becoming the core of modern integrated solutions. By its very nature, access control has always had the potential to offer far more than the control of access and egress through protected doors. As systems have become increasingly software-based, so the functionality on offer has continued to expand. It is fair to say that today, few marketing brochures for access control systems concentrate on the core function. Instead, the additional benefits have become the highlights, the differentiators when it comes to performance and flexibility. Because access control systems have the ability to manage and process real-time transactional data, the information gathered can be used to enhance a wide range of tasks. If occupancy, time and attendance, payroll, health and safety, asset management or even energy management functions need to be carried out, then access control systems can provide data that makes the operational basis of any processing more effective. The benefits have further been supplemented by smart credentials. These have allowed access control to move beyond the simple door-related security role, and now systems can deliver true multi-functional use with an intelligent token at the core. Advanced solutions are now better able to offer costeffective processing, and the added value delivers a real degree of return on investment to the customer. This is – in reality – a real bonus for those who design and install access control solutions. The technology is sought after rather than being a grudge purchase to prevent crime. However, despite all of the additional features and functions, it is vital for the success of any system that it retains its core ability to manage doors, and does so effectively and with cost-efficiency.
I
Increasingly, access control has come to the fore in integrated solutions, and for good reason. An access control solution has at its heart a real-time database of transactional information which can be used for a variety of purposes. However, despite the benefits on offer, the system cannot be deemed a success unless it successfully manages the doors at the site. Benchmark considers the options for selecting door controllers. The spotlight might not be on door control, but if this single element fails, then the entire investment will be questioned!
The basics Often the first consideration with a door controller is how many doors it supports. There are varied schools of thought about this. In the past, controllers were generally grouped for 4, 8 or 16 doors. Some manufacturers opted to try and simplify things by working with controllers for 10 doors. In more recent times, thinking has oriented towards single door controllers, allowing capacity to be added as it is needed. Typically door counts will depend on the way those designing the system work, and the www.benchmarkmagazine.com
41
buyersguide_jan14_000_Benchmark_aug13 09/12/2013 20:37 Page 3
Buyer’s Guide
DOOR CONTROLLER OPTIONS Paxton Access - Net2 PoE Net2 is a PC-based system for access control. Because the system is networked, all administration can be done from a central point. Net2 now incorporates Power over Ethernet (PoE), allowing both power and data to be passed along Ethernet cabling. By combining Net2 plus with PoE, Paxton’s Net2 access control system becomes faster, easier and more cost-effective to install. For example, there is no need to include a separate mains power supply, saving on extra cabling and installation time. Net2 Plus with PoE simply plugs straight into the existing LAN using a standard RJ45 connection powered from either a PoE switch or a PoE injector. It is then detected and configured from the Net2 software in the same way as any other Net2 access control unit. Net2 Plus with PoE is designed to continue operations in the event of a communications failure, meaning the control unit will continue to permit or deny access to users as appropriate. Once communications are re-established the activity is reported back to the server. ACT - ACTpro 1500 The ACTpro 1500 is a single door IP controller which is expandable up to 32 doors via door stations. The system supports 15,000 users, and can be configured and managed using the built in web server or ACT software running on a workstation. The may be connected over IP or directly connected via a built-in USB port and operated using its built-in web server. It supports entry and exit reading to allow two-way and occupancy control as standard. Up to 15,000 users with two credentials per user can be supported, with 250 user groups. Other features include anti-passback, break glass monitoring, voltage monitoring and interlocking. Continuity is supported via tamper and mainspresent monitoring
needs (both future and current) of the protected site. For many, another issue which may affect the capacity of the controller will be the cabling infrastructure and type of data communications being used. It is important to ascertain how flexible the door controllers are with regard to supported readers. Some are brand agnostic, and will work with any device using certain standardised formats. As network-based technology becomes more prevalent in access control, so a better attitude is emerging to third party interfacing. It is worth remembering that whilst a controller manufacturer might offer compatibility with the reader of your choice today, unless they have ensured integrations with a number of providers, that might not be the case in the future. If a controller only 42
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
supports limited readers, find out why, and consider whether the thinking behind the move will serve you – and your customer – in the future as technologies develop and needs change. There are a vast number of everyday ‘housekeeping’ specifications that need to be assessed – number of users, access levels, time zones, user groups, etc.. As systems become more intelligent, some of the processing is passed out to the controllers to enhance performance. It also adds a degree of redundancy. Where data communications are mixed, such as with TCP/IP and RS485 in one system, it is worth checking in the controllers can handle any conversions, or will additional modules be required? Another important consideration is whether the controller has the ability to retain and manage data should communications links be lost. Power continuity should also be investigated before a specification is made, as should the power requirements of the controller itself. Another important consideration is the support for additional inputs and outputs from the door controller. As technologies advance and intelligence becomes an increasing part of the access control package, so it becomes essential to be certain that the controller can interact with other elements of the system. This could expand beyond monitoring door status, door force attempts, etc.. Switching courtesy lighting, triggering a video surveillance element, or even sending an SMS message to a manager of concierge are all possible. If these benefits can help you deliver a credible and effective solution, ensure that the controller has the capacity to support them!
Security first Just as the software used in access control systems has advanced, and the credentials have become smarter, so the controllers have moved far beyond the boxes of relays that represented these products in the past. Todays controllers are networked intelligent devices that can operate as a part of a total solution or, where necessary, as a standalone point of control. Security must always come first, and modern controllers can offer better protection than ever before.
Project3_Layout 1 09/10/2013 10:02 Page 1
SECURE, WIRELESS ACCESS CONTROL LONG R ANGE ocks per hub. Long-range wireless technology, with up to 32 locks LONG BATTERY LIFE ations of the lock. Up to 3 years battery life or up to 200,000 operations SAFE EGRESS de of the door. Always allows free-egress from the protected side KEY OVERRIDE Available with or without key override for doors of 35mm-60mm in width. CARD TECHNOLOGY ies. Compatible with a wide range of card technologies.
CONTACT US TODAY TO FIND YOUR NEAREST ACT CERTIFIED INSTALLER
Unit C1, South City Business Centre, Tallaght, Dublin 24, Ireland Tel: +353 (0)1 466 2570
UK Lo call: 0845 300 5204 Email: ail: info@accesscontrol.ie www.accesscontrol.ie
Project3_Layout 1 06/12/2013 17:47 Page 1
“The Specialist Access Control Distributor� UK Distributor for
Security Management System CARDS | CARD READERS | ACCESS CONTROL SYSTEMS | AUDIO ENTRY | VIDEO ENTRY | LOCKING HARDWARE | POWER SUPPLIES | IPTV | BIOMETRICS |
“Access Control... Call the Specialists!� Smart R House | 2 Hazel Stub Depot | Camps Road
01440 704387
Haverhill | Suffolk | CB9 9AF
www.smartrdistribution.com
Tel : 01440 704387 | Email : sales@smartrdistribution.com
! "#$ %&'
dist news jan14_000_Benchmark_nov13 06/12/2013 17:45 Page 2
Distributor News
Mayflex expands support staff Mayflex has strengthened its support offering with the recruitment of three new internal security sales executives. Roy Jones, Claire Palgrave and Emma-Jean Ferguson have joined the team in the last two months to ensure that Mayflex can continue to provide customer sales support and handle all requests from customers. The staff at Mayflex undergo an in-depth induction program in conjunction with vendors to ensure that product knowledge and support offerings can be clearly conveyed to customers. Mayflex states that its business model is not based upon being a ‘what part number do you want?’ type of distributor. Instead it aims to provide support through pre-sales, product selection, commercial flexibility and technical know-how, to enable the delivery of converged solutions. Its focus is the provision of advanced, scalable and reliable IP-based electronic security solutions from leading manufacturers in all disciplines.
Distributor News The latest news for integrators and installers from the security system suppliers Smart R adds hardware Smart R Distribution has announced it has increased its range of door locking hardware. Whilst Maglocks remain popular, there is often a need for a lock to suit a specific door or application. The distributor offers a comprehensive portfolio of hardware devices ranging from electric strikes to motorised electric door handle locks. Smart R carriesstock of popular brands for immediate despatch from its warehouse, and has recently introduced same-day pick-up for installers working to tight deadlines.
edge jan14_000_Benchmark_nov13 06/12/2013 18:04 Page 1
TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT Recording at the Edge When edge-based storage was first discussed in the security industry, many saw it as a flawed approach designed to tackle issues with bandwidth. However, it actually offers a significant benefit in surveillance system design, and delivers a better level of security too. Benchmark assesses the potential of edge recording for surveillance needs.
devices should be secure, which then allows devices inside the network to be less secure, prioritising speed. In security – and predominantly in video surveillance – the term is used differently. For security purposes ‘edge devices’ are any field device – a device which has a network location away from a centralised control point. Therefore, when surveillance devices are described as offering a function ‘at the edge’, this indicates that processes (which may typically be centralised) are carried out at other locations on the network. There’s nothing revolutionary about distributed processing; actually, it is why networking has become so prevalent in other sectors. Whilst the IT sector embraced this to share resources, the surveillance sector can realise a host of benefits from such a topological design. However, it must be said that whilst there are processes which are beneficial when carried out at the edge, this does not mean that all edge processes are positive. There are some processes which are better carried out centrally, or with copied data to ensure redundancy. These are outside of the scope of this article. In many applications, the case for recording at the edge is very strong. If a system is well designed, then it can add benefits, save costs and deliver a higher degree of resilience.
The basics hen considering the potential available from network-based solutions, one of the often-quoted benefits is processing at ‘the edge’. This phrase has its roots in IT and networking, where it means something slightly different. In IT terminology, edge devices are entry and exit points to a network. They are generally routers, switches and other access devices, and are designed to offer smart security. Network thinking (in the IT sector) is that edge
W
46 www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Centralised recording has, historically, been the cornerstone on which surveillance systems were based. This was not because it offered better functionality, was more secure or aided overall performance. It wasn’t because the customer demanded it, nor did experts confirm it as ‘best practice’. The reality was that the technology available limited the choice to central recording, if a system was to be cost-effective! The truth is that manufacturers could not find a better way that was affordable. Many tried, but all attempts resulted in duplicated
edge jan14_000_Benchmark_nov13 06/12/2013 18:04 Page 2
Technology Assessment
equipment and a lack of communication between the devices. It is fair to say that few end users wanted to dedicate large areas of their business site to control rooms or equipment stores. However, if they wanted credible surveillance, and if operators were to have easy access to footage, it was a necessity. When networked solutions started to appear in the surveillance sector, centralised recording remained the dominant method. Again, this was for a simple reason – well, for two simple reasons! The first was that many manufacturers simply replicated existing analogue devices, but with network connectivity. The second was force of habit! Installers, integrators, specifiers, consultants and even end users were so used to thinking of a centralised recording model that it was difficult to change. Network-based solutions are better suited to a distributed archiving model. When properly designed and implemented, there is no need to opt for a centralised model. Indeed, a centralised approach can actually detrimental to many aspects of the system. The overall design becomes unnecessarily cumbersome, with many of the benefits of network infrastructure being ignored. Additional management elements are required to address vulnerabilities which the centralised model introduces. This adds to the overall cost of ownership.These vulnerabilities can also impact on system performance. Installation time is increased, and potential cost-saving and economies are eliminated. In short, a centralised approach can overcomplicate the system, introduce unnecessary duplication, deliver less performance and cost more. Such an approach is not always best practice! There are many who will argue against a distributed edge recording model, typically because of their own agenda. See the panel entitled ‘A Flawed Argument?’ for more details. Despite this, any examination of the realities of system design will not only underline the benefits of edge recording, but will make a very good case for the implementation of such an approach.
Multiple options Some people have a limited understanding of edge recording options. Probably the most common perception is that the technology solely revolves around the use of memory
A Flawed Argument? It is not unusual for those who are opposed to edge recording to argue the point that the approach is an alternative way working which has been created solely to address a shortcoming of networked video – limited bandwidth! They will imply that edge recording is a ‘workaround’ and not an appropriate way of recording security video. It is important to understand the weaknesses in this argument. Historically, in the vast majority of applications, centralised recording was never a choice; it was the only option. There was no alternative, despite many leading manufacturers trying to develop one. This was because centralised archiving wasn’t the best way to design systems. Sadly, the limitations of the technology of the day resulted in no other choices. That investment of R&D resources simply wouldn’t have happened if centralised recording was the best approach. At that time, the arguments put forward to support centralised recording had more to do with justification of the approach. After all, you don’t need to argue for a model if its the only one available! Therefore, it makes little sense to use the same arguments against a distributed model, now that one is available! There is no benefit in making an additional investment – both in terms of time and money – in duplicated infrastructure to move data around a site when it’s not necessary to do so. Equally, there is no need to deplete real estate to facilitate a dedicated space for the control and management of a system when such a space isn’t needed. Distribution of control, viewing and storage is a superior and more effective solution. Some point out that other technologies don’t need to preserve bandwidth so therefore don’t need a distributed storage model. This ignores the fact that such systems are limited in what they can deliver. Network solutions can deliver so much more, so where’s the point in limiting that to carry out a task which doesn’t need to be carried out? Many of the arguments against edge recording are based on things that the archiving model doesn’t do. However, they ignore the fact that the things it doesn’t do simply do not need to be done! There is no benefit in taking an advanced technology and limiting its potential in order to replicate a restricted model. cards. These can be inserted in cameras or encoders, and allow the local storage of footage. However, to consider these devices as the only edge technologies is to miss out on many of the alternatives. It is important to realise that edge recording is more about system design and operation than the media used to archive the footage. The model involves retaining the high quality footage captured near to its source rather than transporting it to a central location. This enables devices to be deployed where suitable locations exist. It also ensures that infrastructure can be used as required, rather than having resources tied up with unnecessary tasks. The video can be archived on devices which are network connected. These might be NVRs with lower camera counts, NAS or SAN www.benchmarkmagazine.com
47
edge jan14_000_Benchmark_nov13 06/12/2013 18:05 Page 3
Technology Assessment
storage devices, servers or memory cards. Low resolution video streams can be used for other purposes; indeed, high resolution streams can also be deployed. In many cases, the lack of a need for a centralised control room frees up personnel to manage the video system in a more effective way. Handheld devices such as smartphones or tablets can be used, along with general desktop PCs. Push notifications can inform authorised users of events. The entire system can be flexible and fit in with the way the customer’s business works. If and when high quality video is required, it can be pulled over the network. This might be for the creation of copies on WORM media for evidential purposes, or to allow a detailed examination of high quality video. The nature of the network means that it doesn’t matter where the video recording is, as the operator can access it immediately. With a centralised system, the actual topology can also create certain issues. Typically, systems tend to have one set of permissions controlling access to the entire system. Whilst permission levels can restrict what users can do, the system is generally accessed as a singly entity. Distributed solutions can be accessed as a single entire system, or as individual subsystems. Management is flexible; you and the customer decide how to manage it. Also, a centralised system will, by its very nature, have a single point of failure when it comes to the recording system. With a distributed system, unaffected parts of the system can continue to operate. Where a customer wants one centralised archive of recordings, these can be scheduled to be transferred to a central server during periods when site activity is low. With correct design, there is nothing that a central archiving solution can do that a distributed alternative cannot. However, the same is not true the other way around!
The right capacity? There are many options when it comes to edge recording. Often these include very cost48
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
effective units. This is driven by economies within the consumer market, and the growth in devices which store and manage data of different types. In recent years, aside from the small blip that followed a shortage of supply resulting from the mass flooding in Thailand, storage costs have fallen. One manufacturer recently commented that the surveillance sector was the last place where you could charge decent prices for hard drives. As awareness about the costs of storage grows, even that is no longer the case. It is not only the low cost of storage, but also the variety of ways in which it is packaged, that makes edge recording an attractive proposition. Currently, SDXC cards offer capacities of 128GB. If such a card is used in a camera, the storage on offer equates to the same capacity as each channel receives on a 16 channel 2TB NVR or DVR! Other memory cards have equivalent capacities. Many NAS and SAN devices are customisable, and can either be used to offer multi-disk archiving or RAID configurations. Capacities are customisable, allowing installers and integrators to specify the correct level of storage for any application. Adding extra capacity is simple. Importantly, edge recording isn’t about eliminating the NVR! These devices can play an important role in edge recording. The recorders are networkable, and are therefore easy to add to a surveillance system. Units with appropriate camera counts can be deployed near a group of cameras. Overall control can then be taken via management software. Many manufacturers offer such software without charge.
Verdict Edge recording should not be viewed as a ‘make do’ version of centralised archiving. It actually enhances the capabilities and performance of systems, and delivers genuine cost savings. Just because centralised recording was the only approach for many years doesn’t mean it is the best approach. There will always be cases where centralised recording makes sense, and when it is the best solution it should be adhered to. However, this will not always be the case, and by ignoring the possibilities of recording at the edge, you could lose out on valuable contracts.
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 11:11 Page 1
Project1_Layout 1 10/12/2013 17:17 Page 1
Electronic Locks
Electronic Cylinders
IP Door Controllers
Locker Locks
Everybody can do cameras -
We can do MORE. www.rivatech.de SALTO Systems 8QLW 7KH &RXUW +RO\ZHOO %XVLQHVV 3DUN 6RXWKDP :DUZLFNVKLUH &9 )* 7HO Lnfo.uk@saltosystems.com www.saltosystems.co.uk
bulletin jan14_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 16:46 Page 3
Bulletin
Bulletin:
Benchmark looks at product releases of interest to those involved in the design, specification and installation of security solutions
Input/Output addition Exacq has launched the ExacqVision USB I/O module. The module adds configurable trigger inputs, outputs and serial connections to surveillance systems using the VMS. Up to 8 modules can be connected per server for a maximum of 64 additional inputs and 40 outputs. The USB I/O module is compatible with all ExacqVision hybrid and IP servers running version 5.8 or later, and software versions on third-party servers running either Windows or Linux. The module installs in minutes, and is supplied with a two metre USB cable, screwdriver, mounting brackets and software driver. No external power is required. The I/O module can be configured in the client software and comes with a one year hardware warranty.
High resolution TeleEye has added new cameras to its range which use a Sony CCD image sensor claimed to deliver 700 TV lines. The new cameras feature the Sony Super HAD II CAD sensor. The new additions include fixed dome cameras, with models that include IR illumination. Optical options include 3.6mm fixed lenses and 2.8-12mm varifocal units. There is also a vandal resistant unit, as well as models with IP66 protection for outdoor use. Teleeye has also added a number of wallmount bullet IR cameras, with models featuring IR illumination with ranges of up to 80 metres. Lens options are as the fixed domes, but with the addition of a 5-50mm varifocal unit.z
20 megapixels in real time Stemmer Imaging offers the Spark SP-20000MPMCL and SP-20000C-PMCL industrial cameras. The monochrome and colour 20 megapixel cameras from JAI operate at 30fps, and their combination of speed and resolution makes them ideal for surveillance, border security and other high risk applications. The Spark cameras offer full frame resolution of 5120 x 3840 pixels with a dual CameraLink interface capable of supporting multiple data rates in either medium or full configurations. Power can be supplied through the CameraLink connectors using a dual-channel-powered frame grabber, or can be provided via a separate 12-pin connector. The cameras utilise CMOSIS 8-transistor (8T) pixel architecture, and a 1:50000 light rejection ratio gives clean images with sharp contrast. Processing has been enhanced to provide significant reductions in pattern noise. Features include automatic level control linking shutter and gain, and a built-in dualslope high dynamic range mode for high contrast imaging. The SP-20000 has user-defined single and multiple region-of-interest (ROI) capabilities, providing image capture flexibility with higher frame rates.
Outdoor ready zoom unit Axis has introduced a bullet-style outdoor-ready network camera. The Q1765-LE offers full HD image quality, 18x optical zoom and built-in IR illumination. The automatically adaptive infrared LEDs have a claimed range of 15 metres at wide angle, and 40 metres in tele view. The camera is IP66 rated for resistance to water and dust. An ‘Arctic Temperature Control’ feature allows reliable operation in temperatures from -40 °C to 50 °C. The camera supports Power over Ethernet and conventional AC/DC power. Resolution is up to HD1080p, and day/night operation is standard. An on-board memory card slot facilitates edge recording, and two-way audio is also catered for.
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
51
bulletin jan14_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 16:46 Page 4
Bulletin
Ethernet extension ComNet Europe has introduced an SFP (Small Form Factor Pluggable) device that can be connected to any Ethernet device, and can extends distances over Coax or UTP cables to just over 900 metres. The SFP-CL can be used in any Ethernet device that uses MSAcompliant SFPs for connectivity. Two models are available: a 10Mbps and 100Mbps model. These SFP modules can be connected any CopperLine device. The devices are ideal for applications where existing coax or UTP is being used for IP video transmission. The CL-SFP simplifies installation by eliminating the need for additional convertors by allowing direct connection to an ethernet switch. SFPs are widely accepted for fibre optic connectivity, giving flexibility in the choice of fibre and connector types.
Active approach Luminite Electronics offers BoundaryShield, a battery-powered wireless active IR beam range. The beams are triggered by interruption. The units have a modular design to simplify configuration and installation. Each beam head unit transmits alarm data to a masthead receiver across distances of up to 1km, according to the manufacturer. The beam heads are supplied in pairs, and feature 60 or 100 metre detection ranges. Single-direction and double-sided towers are available, with heights of 1.75 metres for single beams, or 3 metres for two pairs. Up to 64 beam heads can communicate with a masthead transceiver. The units feature front access for on-site adjustment. The housing is IP65 rated and made from ABS. Battery life is up to 2 years, using standard Alkaline cells. Lithium cells can also be supported, as can 12V DC power.
More at the edge Verint has announced enhancements to its Nextiva EdgeVR solution. The latest version delivers the benefits of an embedded NVR, including bandwidth optimisation, remote access and surveillance analytics. It can scale to support up to 64 cameras. The enhancements include advanced investigation tools, such as face detection, ANPR and a variety of analytics. Designed to enhance the efficiency of security operations in command, control and communications environments, the system offers video wall and mobile support. Analytics include loitering detection, directional movement, line crossing, objects left and missing items. Face detection makes captured facial details available for investigations.
Suitable for extremes Samsung Techwin’s WiseNet III HD network vandal-resistant dome camera, the SNV-6084, is designed to work effectively in extreme weather conditions as well as being resistant to physical attack, according to the manufacturer. The camera is rated to IK10 for vandal resistance and is weatherproof to IP66. It is claimed to withstand temperature variations of -50°C to +55°C. Both the camera and its integral heater can be powered by standard PoE (Power over Ethernet), negating the need for the installation of separate cables for power. The day/night model features an infrared cut filter, and utilises a 38.5mm motorised varifocal lens. Frame rate is up 60fps at HD1080p resolution. Other features include enhanced Wide Dynamic Range with claimed performance greater than 120dB, Digital Image Stabilization (DIS) and Defog which can be used to improve the clarity of images captured in poor weather conditions such as rain, smoke or fog. The camera also features an integral SDXC memory slot. Intelligent Video Analytics (IVA) is also included; this does not require an additional licence. Rules include tripwire, enter/exit direction, object appear/disappear and tamper.
52
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Project1_Layout 1 10/09/2013 15:00 Page 1
What Do You Require From Your Fire & Security Products?
High Quality
Reliable
Energy (I¿FLHQW
Switch Mode Design
Cost Effective
Compliant
High quality, reliable products OEM and bespoke customer products on request Free screen printing ISO14001 approved company RoHS & WEEE compliant products Unrivaled customer service 50 years in the industry
Why go anywhere else? Enquiries: sales@elmdene.co.uk Web: www.elmdene.co.uk
Intruder
Access Control
CCTV
Fire
bulletin jan14_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 16:47 Page 6
Bulletin
Fully functioned Grundig’s GCI-K2505B true day/night camera is the latest addition to its IP range. The camera is claimed to have a sensitivity of 0.03 lux. It utilises a 2 megapixel CMOS sensor with dual shutter and progressive scan technology, and delivers quad video streams. Options include a single, HD1080p stream at 50fps, dual streams of HD1080p and HD720p at 50fps and quad streams made up of one at HD1080p, two at HD720p and one at CIF resolution, simultaneously at 25fps. The streams can be optimized to suit applications, such as HD1080p for recording and lower resolution HD720p, D1 or CIF streams for display or viewing on mobile devices. The GCI-K2505B is ONVIF S compatible, and includes a microSD/SDHC memory card slot for alarm and scheduled image recording. Power over Ethernet (PoE IEEE 802.3af ) is supported. The standard video format is 16:9, but can be rotated through 90° to provide portrait views. Motion detection and privacy zones are supported, along with ATW, WDR and DNR functionality.
Retail solution Geovision offers a retail solution with POS data and video surveillance integrated to allow an efficient tool for security and fraud protection. The GPOS-DVR/NVR surveillance system uses video text overlays to provide visual awareness of transactional information to help reduce shrinkage and protect asset against business losses. The GV Series systems, in conjunction with GV Data Capture and GV POS Text Sender, associate POS transactional data with corresponding video from relevant cameras. It provides advanced search options, full video documentation, remote monitoring of cashier areas, outputs for alarms and pre-defined performance indicators. The system can use transaction criteria to search in a field filter, displaying the results in a newly created System Log. Search criteria can include a keyword in the receipt, transaction event (start/stop/void) or start time. When pre-defined abnormal transactions occur (such as high or low values) the system can trigger an alarm device or send an alert message via email, phone, or SMS. A configuration can be made to ensure that video is captured when the cash drawer is opened. As an additional benefit, the system also allows customer flow counting, with discriminations for incoming and outgoing customers.
Display coding TKH Security offers the Siqura S620D decoder, which streams video to two separate monitors complete with stereo audio. H.264, MPEG-2 or MPEG-4 video streams from IP cameras or encoders can be displayed in any resolution including HD720p and HD1080p. Designed for retail spot monitor, public monitor and control room video wall applications, it produces two video streams, each capable of driving widescreen, HDMI monitors and displaying images from up to 10 cameras simultaneously. The unit is compact, measuring just 101 x 101 x 51 mm. The decoder will produce two HD1080p30 or four HD720p30 H.264 video streams, in addition to multiple lower resolution streams such as D1 and CIF. Multi-codec support - including MPEG-2, MPEG-4 and H.264 compression formats - makes the decoder suitable for most applications. Both video outputs include lip-synchronised stereo audio. Specifically engineered for security applications, it includes TKH Security’s own embedded software. The hardware platform is based on an i3 central processor unit. In addition to the ONVIF NVD implementation, the decoder offers a REST API interface for remote control and quick integration.
54
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Remote telemetry Vista has launched an HD internal IPenabled dome that allows remote set up and control of the lens zoom and focus from any PC or mobile device. The VK21080VFD3V9F offers triple streaming of HD1080p video. The streams can be individually configured. A ‘Boost’ feature enables the camera to automatically increase the number of images per second streamed and recorded when an event occurs. This means the unit can stream continuously at a low frame rate, but when an event occurs the rate automatically increases to 25fps. Other features include alarm input/output functionality, ONVIF compliance, support for PoE and a supplied VK2-Client, allowing up to 128 cameras to be viewed simultaneously, while recording up to 32 cameras to a local PC.
Project1_Layout 1 12/08/2013 11:39 Page 1
bulletin jan14_000_Benchmark_jan14 10/12/2013 16:47 Page 7
Bulletin
PTZ capabilities JVC Professional has launched an HD1080p network PTZ dome camera: the VN-H557U. The camera features 10x optical zoom and 350 degree pan/tilt operation. Incorporating JVC’s Super LoLux technology, sensitivity for the camera is claimed to be 0.45 lux. The camera features dual stream operation (H.264 High Profile at 30fps), along with SD card recording; an alarm record function and direct MPEG 4 export allows event-based operation. Other features include dynamic noise reduction, support for ONVIF Profile S, audio and alarm functionality. The manufacturer states that latency is 50ms when using a USB joystick.
VMS integration Ambar Systems, a Salto certificated partner, has developed a plug-in integration that combines Salto Systems access control with XProtect software. The plug-in integrates the access system directly into XProtect Smart Client and allows the user to control access and monitor video surveillance from one unified interface, eliminating the need to run two separate applications. The plug-in integration enables the user to open doors while simultaneously viewing video footage of the area. It also captures critical events from the access control software and registers them as alarms. These alarms are automatically linked to relevant video footage from corresponding cameras. Users can control cameras in their surveillance system, such as starting/stopping recording, changing video frame rate and moving cameras to focus on a door. Monitoring events are issued by the access control system and automatically registered as alerts within the alarm manager in the VMS client. Details of the event, card holder, location and time are captured, along with the video footage, to provide a complete package of surveillance information. Additionally, users can open doors remotely from the VMS client. 56
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
Printing and encoding HID Global has announced a major update to its Fargo Direct-to-Card (DTC) printer line that expands the secure issuance capabilities for organisations producing ID, access control, payment and loyalty cards. The printers now feature an embedded multi-technology iCLASS SE Encoder to simplify card technology migration and personalise large ID card batches, all from within the printer. The DTC portfolio also includes enhanced personalisation features that offer faster speeds and increased flexibility with an optional wireless accessory module. The multi-technology iCLASS SE encoder enables all credential creation, encoding, personalisation and management for ID card batches to be performed at the printer. This reduces administrative and hardware costs. The units simplify migration from other credential technologies, such as magstripe cards, to smart cards and future technologies. Cards can be encoded with company or employee information, and programmed to work with a variety of access control systems dependent on the permissions written onto the card. Users can streamline all card ordering, inventory management and issuance processes while maintaining flexibility, security and end-to-end operational control.
Thermal option Riva offers the RTC1130-320, a thermal imager designed for security applications. The unit includes integral intelligent video analytics. VCA Presence and VCA Detect are included as standard, and deliver filters for direction detection, retention period, speed dependent detection and object classification (persons, animals, vehicles). Other VCA-filters for more specific applications can be purchased separately. Five different lenses between 7.5 and 50mm, with angles of view between 6.2 and 42 degrees, are available. Features include dual streaming, an integral micro-SD slot, and PoE. A refresh rate of up to 30fps with a resolution of 320 x 240 pixels can be achieved. The weatherproof housing allows outdoor use.
dycon ad risk nov13_Layout 1 07/11/2013 23:04 Page 1
D15xx & D24xx SERIES DIN-rail Mounted 1-3A Power Supplies
• No fixing screws required, clips directly onto an NS32 (‘G-Section’) or an N35/7.5 ‘Top Hat-section’ DIN-rail • Efficiency higher than 90% at full rated output • 230vAC -12vDC, 230vAC–24vDC, 1–3 A output versions • 110vAC–12vDC version for construction sites • With or without battery backup
Dycon POWER SOLUTIONS
FINAL next issue jan14_000_Benchmark_nov10 10/12/2013 16:27 Page 2
Next Month
Next Month in Benchmark... PSIM Examined Is it a fad, or does PSIM really offer something that adds to the features and functions already on offer from modern security solutions? Benchmark considers the claims to see if they have any validity for installers and integrators looking to deliver advanced systems.
Video Door Entry Video door entry has been established for many years now. However, as technologies in other parts of the video and access sectors advance, Benchmark looks to see whether these visitor management systems have also developed.
Event Handling Software-based VMS (video management systems) are growing in popularity, due to their open platform approach. Whilst interoperability and ease of video management are often cited as reasons to select such solutions, there is another reason why those who make the transition are glad they have. Often VMS packages can offer advanced alarm and event handling options, delivering increased levels of flexibility when it comes to system design. Benchmark looks at some of the options.
DOOR ENTRY elegant, modern and efficient This is TAB Clean lines, fully representing the best in modern design trends, the new TAB video door entry monitor blends perfectly into any residential setting with its ultra-thin profile and touch functionality.
The 3.5” LCD colour display ensures excellent clear image quality and simplifies programming for both users and installers. The capacitive keypad provides user-friendly operation - simply touch the keys to enable the main video door entry functions including: door opening with tside status display, stair lighting, automatic outside cameras and an intercom function with TAB VV other indoor stations. e The TAB handsets also have a special s. internal coil to assist hearing aid wearers.
ic Open Vo ble availa version 2014 January
Raytel Security Systems Limited mite te ed helping to keep communities safer
58
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
TAB - available in “glass effect” black or white and audio only versions
Sou Southern S South ou Office: 01268 749310 Northern Office: 0141 582 1275 Northe email: info@raytelsecurity.co.uk Internet: www.raytelsecurity.co.uk
Project1_Layout 1 01/08/2013 12:11 Page 1
Bringing together the entire security buying chain In 2014 IFSEC International, the largest and longest running security event moves to a truly international venue. With more than 40 years at the heart of the security industry, reČľecting innoYatiYe industry trends and SroYiding insight into the Oatest technoOogy to NeeS Eusinesses and goYernments secure Put the date in your diary now! www.ifsec.co.uk/add2014
IFSEC International is Sart of
PROTECTION & MANAGEMENT Week
WWW.IFSEC.CO.UK
17-19 JUNE 2014 ExCeL LONDON
Project1_Layout 1 11/11/2013 15:58 Page 1
Memories. iFly Singapore, the world’s largest indoor skydiving simulator,
uses Milestone XProtect® Enterprise surveillance software to monitor park grounds and give visitors a lasting memory. Flying at speeds of up to 186 miles per hour, the software records each skydiver’s Ų¿½¾Ê ·Äº ¿Ä¼ÅÈ÷ʿÅÄ ËɿĽ ·º¿Å È»ÇË»Ä¹Ï º»ÄÊ¿Ű¹·Ê¿ÅÄ ƺ ƻƔ ¼Ê»È ʾ»¿È Ų¿½¾ÊƑ · Ì¿º»Å ÉÅËÌ»Ä¿È ¾»ÂÆÉ visitors relive all of the adrenaline-fueled moments. Proving again that XProtect is more than security.
Milestone XProtect® is the world’s leading IP video surveillance management software and ¿É Ȼ¿·¸Â»Ƒ ¼ËÊËÈ» ÆÈÅż ·Äº »·ÉÏ ÊÅ ËÉ»Ɣ Ê ÉËÆÆÅÈÊÉ Ê¾» Í¿º»ÉÊ ¹¾Å¿¹» in cameras and seamlessly integrates with business and security solutions such as Ɣ ¾¿¹¾ û·ÄÉ ÏÅËÈ ÆÅÉÉ¿¸¿Â¿Ê¿»É ·È» ËÄ¿ÿʻº ·Äº ÏÅË ¹·Ä Á»»Æ ÏÅËÈ É»¹ËÈ¿ÊÏ options open. See our new products and the new ways to use XProtect at: www.milestonesys.com
Milestone Systems UK ȧɎÂƓ ̊ ʻʻ ƺʷƻ ʸʺʺʹ ʿʽˀʺʿʷ