July 24, 2009

Page 1

Opposition forms to abortion funding in proposed health care reform bills

Catholic san Francisco

By Angela Cave

(CNS PHOTO/LARRY DOWNING, REUTERS)

Newspaper of the Archdiocese of San Francisco

President Barack Obama waves after speaking about health care reform in the White House Rose Garden in Washington last week. Many people fear that proposed health care legislation could mandate abortion coverage for most insurance plans.

WASHINGTON (CNS) – President Barack Obama’s push for health care reform could be the worst thing for the pro-life cause since Roe v. Wade, the 1973 decision legalizing abortion nationwide, said individuals and groups that oppose abortion. The three health care reform bills currently in Congress do not specifically mention abortion. But legal precedent proves abortions could be covered by federal tax money unless excluded in legislation, pro-life members of Congress said. Legislation also could mandate abortion coverage for most insurance plans. The Obama administration has not ruled out the possibility of publicly funded abortions, said Peter Orszag, White House budget director, on “Fox News Sunday” July 19. “We would be very naive and foolish in the extreme if we didn’t notice the game that’s being played here,” said Rep. Chris Smith, R-N.J., chairman of the Congressional Pro-Life Caucus for 27 years. “It’s Orwellian.” Obama would be misleading Americans and Pope Benedict XVI in promising to reduce the number of abortions if language excluding abortions is not added to the legislation, said Smith, a Catholic. Thousands of abortion facilities could

spring up as a result of the legislation, and funding could cause an increase in abortions because lack of money would be one less barrier in a woman’s decision, Smith told Catholic News Service July 20. “It makes a quicker abortion that much more possible because she’s at a moment of vulnerability,” he said. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops also weighed in on the issue. “No health care reform plan should compel us or others to pay for the destruction of human life, whether through government funding or mandatory coverage of abortion,” wrote Bishop William F. Murphy of Rockville Centre, N.Y., chairman of the bishops’ Committee on Domestic Justice and Human Development, in a July 17 letter to Congress. A copy of the letter was released by the USCCB July 21. “Any such action would be morally wrong. It also would be politically unwise. No health care legislation that compels Americans to pay for or participate in abortion will find sufficient votes to pass,” the bishop said. A May Gallup Poll found that a majority of Americans are calling themselves pro-life for the first time since Gallup began asking the question in 1995. San Francisco-based Catholics for the Common Good highlighted a webcast seminar that was scheduled for July 23. OPPOSITION FORMS, page 11

By Rick DelVecchio Architecture students at the University of San Francisco are applying the language of architecture and design to spiritually sensitive projects in several economically struggling places around the world. In India, they are helping to realize a community center in an urban settlement known as a bubble of Muslim-Hindu harmony. In South Dakota, they are contributing ideas for an Oglala Lakota Native American cultural arts center dedicated to the spirit of the visionary Black Elk, who participated in the Battle of the Little Big Horn in 1876, was hurt at the Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890 and later converted to Catholicism. The location is the Pine Ridge Reservation, richly spiritual but one of the most economically desperate spots in the nation. Unemployment tops 80 percent and life expectancy is the nation’s worst. “When the children come of age they begin to lose their dream,” Black Elk’s great-granddaughter Georgine Looks Twice, who leads the project, said in an e-mail to Catholic San Francisco. The students are helping a second Oglala Lakota group design a meeting hall for 200 people. Their idea: a circular structure that combines a traditional roundhouse with modern framing that keeps the floor of the structure open.

The students are working under Assistant Professor Seth Wachtel, who directs the Architecture and Community Design Program in the Department of Art and Architecture and is co-director of the Garden Project Living-Learning Community at Jesuit-run USF. Wachtel focuses on low-income housing and the development of innovative construction techniques that produce sustainable and aesthetically and culturally appropriate buildings for human environments. He runs the Community Design Outreach and International Projects courses, which provide students the opportunity to work on real world design/build projects for underserved communities both locally and internationally. In addition to the projects in India and on the Lakota reservation, the students have local projects in underserved communities in Brazil, Mexico, Nicaragua, Liberia and China. In the Brazil project, for example, they are working with an American Jesuit priest, Father Harold Rahm, who has an outreach with the community and sees the need for a place where unwed mothers and their children can go for help. The India project is in Gujurat state, in the Jamalpur area of Ahmedabad. Within Jamalpur is the settlement of Ram Rahim no Teckro, with its Muslim-Hindu population mix that has remained harmonious through

(PHOTO BY RICK DELVECCHIO/CATHOLIC SAN FRANCISCO)

USF students help design buildings in underserved communities in seven countries

USF Assistant Professor Seth Wachtel with (left to right) architecture and design students Samuel North, Irene Kim, Tricia Smith and Kaci Taylor.

generations of inter-religious strife in the region. The students are challenged with the problem of working in a cramped urban spot to design a tiny gathering space that adjoins a Hindu temple and a Muslim gravesite. The design must reflect the special character of

the place without using overt religious references. Student Alex Kieve said the students decided to design the structure so that it is open to cooling breezes from a nearby river. They hit on an idea based on a popular form of recreation in the USF STUDENTS, page 10

INSIDE THIS WEEK’S EDITION News in brief. . . . . . . . . . . 4-5 Was Shakespeare Catholic? . 6 Women religious jubilees . 12-13 Editorial and letters . . . . . . 14 Scripture and reflection . . . 16

Walking in steps of Mother Teresa ~ Page 3 ~ July 24, 2009

Penance called ‘oil change for soul’ ~ Page 9 ~

San Francisco Opera – Verdi’s ‘la Traviata’ ~ Page 20 ~

ONE DOLLAR

Obituaries . . . . . . . . . . . 17-19 Datebook of events . . . . . . . 21

NEXT ISSUE AUGUST 7 VOLUME 11

No. 23


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.