Praxis: Emergent Urbanism Abstract Machines Leeds Metropolitan University February/May 2014
1 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
1
Contents
Emergence[y] Rules for Post Traumatic Urban Landscapes
Paul Bedson Nick Hart-Woods
Emergent Urbanism River Valley Settlements
Chris Foster
Ben Lillywhite
Emergent Urbanism Hills Dominic Kennedy
Hillside Urban Landscapes Richard A F Arthur
Oasis Theory and Research
Sam Hayes
Jan Harmens
4 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Emergence[y] Rules for Post Traumatic Urban Landscapes Nick Hart-Woods Paul Bedson
Contents Part 01 Introduction Part 02 Case Study Part 03 Approach Part 04 Relational Simulation Part 05 Quantitative Mapping Part 06 Connecting Part 07 Nodal Clustering Part 08 Praxis Part 09 Bibliography
Foreword
The following research is aimed at investigating the phenomena of architectural morphogenesis in small-scale urban developments situated in extreme environments. The extreme environment of study for this project is slum settlements, and it will aim to abstract out principles, rules and parameters as a series of metric, interlinked relationships operable on and guiding manifestation of form. This defined ‘performative model’ will be created as a digital simulation from which it will be possible to demonstrate various instances of digital morphogenesis subject to varying preference of defined parameters.
“When the avant-garde group Archigram introduced the term ‘instant city’ into architectural discourse nearly a half-century ago, they were inspired by the mobility of contemporary society and its dependence on high technology to enable urban migration and make it creative and exciting—a dynamic, uniquely contemporary way of living. Their model was the circus, which they admired for its élan as much as the excitement of its continuous performances. In their drawings and models they were projecting a future of adventurous hedonism, a liberation of the sort projected by Constant, though emphasizing human creativity less than leisurely consumption. Their visions fulfilled the idea that the city was not to be a monumental artefact of civilization, but a tumultuous, ever-changing process. “Each generation must build its own city,” Antonio Sant’Elia had proclaimed, and Archigram and Constant, in their own very different ways, fulfilled his demand at the same that they speeded-up the process. They never realized— or acknowledged—that the modern age could create utterly different kinds of ‘instant cities,’ the hastily constructed communities of urban dwellers displaced by catastrophes of both human and natural origin— war, economic disaster, hurricane, earthquake. After all, where was the role for architects in them? What could architects do to turn these instant cities into affirmations of the human spirit? Architecture is about planning. How can architects plan for the unplanned, for the unpredictable? Exactly….” Lebius Woods
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
7
Introduction
01 01
Slums
Historically the term ‘Slum’ was used to describe housing areas that were once desirable, but which deteriorated as the original occupants moved on to new and better parts of the city. The condition of these properties declined as they were progressively subdivided and occupied by lower income citizens. Slums develop and are perpetuated by a number of different forces. Among the main causes cited for slum settlements are rapid ruralto-urban migration, increasing urban poverty and inequality, insecure tenure and natural disasters.
0-10% 10-20% 20-30% 30-40% 40-50% 50-60% 60-70% 70-80% 80-90% 90-100% No data available
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
9
Overcrowding
Poor access to infrastructure
Poor access to clean water
Insecure tenure
10 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Lack of durable, permanent housing
Slum settlements
Today, ‘Slum’ has come to include a large variety of informal settlements, and as such a UN expert group recommended that policy makers consider a more “operational definition” of a slum. According to these experts, a slum is an area that combines, to various extents, the following characteristics:
• • • • •
Inadequate access to safe water Inadequate access to sanitation and other infrastructure Poor structural quality of housing Overcrowding Insecure residential status
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
11
Development Models
Globally the biggest cause of exacerbated slum conditions is not increasing rural-to-urban migration, not people squatting on disused land, not even poverty itself. The biggest factor is incorrect policy responses and ill informed- out dated administration all underpinned by a hostile and aggressive attitude to the urban and urbanizing poorer demographic. Most urban growth takes place in existing cities, not new ones, this means that planning responses to slums must take into account existing infrastructure. The current methodologies for planning these cities is based on colour coded zones on a master-plan, a top down approach. This approach is problematic because most city growth (especially in relation to slum settlements) is informal. By forcing development in these areas it is necessary to evict the existing population, demolish and rebuild. This fails to address the problem and simply moves it. Alternatively, a bottom up approach allows the development to occur incrementally and naturally as people improve their living conditions over time, as and when they can afford. The downside being there is no overriding control over the system and undesirable conditions can arise. To overcome this, the aim of this study is to begin to understand and simulate the complex relationships that govern slum development. By simulating the rules that govern slum dynamics, the designer can manipulate the outcomes for the benefit and improvement of the area. Slums will disappear not through demolition, but by transformation. Over time the shack becomes a house, the slum becomes a suburb. This is how citizenship and cities are built.
12 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Bottom up vs Top down
Statistics
Demolition
The study of informal settlement processes, with their direct generation based on locality, network relationships and open ended growth, appears to be promising terrain for exploration with computational tools. The development of bottom-up algorithms generating emergent behaviours from local interactions has the possibility to allow planners and architects to understand, foresee and drive urban growth. In this study computational tools will be employed as relational tools, attempting to move away from a paradigm of pure shape generation and embrace the complexity of network relationships and social structures.
Planner
Masterplan
Planning Rules
Imposed Order
Available Land
No infrastructure
The hopeful outcome of the study will be to illustrate some possible strategies of intervention in informal settlements, emphasising the need of avoiding large scale evictions and demolitions and instead trying to interact with the existing network processes to implement nodal changes that can influence the entire urban network.
Top down planning
Citizens
Self Build
The computational tools play a significant role as simulation and modelling tools, allowing the exploration of the complex interaction between social, economical and environmental parameters and to test and predict possible outcomes before implementation. The final outcome, far from having resolved the complex and often contradictory dynamics in informal settlements, will nevertheless try to propose a study and intervention method, and outline possible lines for further exploration into the topic.
Rescources
Undesired attributes
Bottom up planning
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
13
Case study
14 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
02
Case study: Petionville golf course, Haiti
Carribean
Petionville
Haiti
Port-au-Prince
Golf course
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
15
Development
t=0 The 2010 Haiti earthquake was a catastrophic magnitude 7.0Mw earthquake, with an epicentre just west of the capital Port-au-Prince. The earthquake occurred on January 12th 2010. The earthquake caused major damage in port-au-prince, Jacmel and other settlements in the region. Many notable landmark buildings were significantly damaged or destroyed.
t=1
t=2
16 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Figure ground analysis
26.08.2009
18.08.2010
13.01.2010
16.09.2012
15.01.2010
13.01.2013
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
17
Approach
18 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
03
Urban Strategies
Fundamentally, the city exists as a network of systems. In the past, this perception of the city was not useful when attempting to create an urban intervention due to the extreme complexity, offers designers the potential to tap into these systems and to alter them. â€œâ€ŚIt is not individualistic but relational; instead of treating them as independent, a network approach recognises that people and places influence one another through their relationships.â€?
Reductionism Reductionism Historically the approach to urban design employed reductionist methodologies. This is exemplified by the modernist movement, and ultimately failed due to the assumption that the designers will could override the underlying forces at play. Complexity The complexity approach attempts to apply complex systems science to urban design problems such as chaos theory. While this has potential, it required vast computing power and an extremely accurate and detailed model of existing conditions that are often infeasible to obtain. Relational Complexity
The relational approach aims to analyse the relationships between the various elements at play. By setting design objectives the results of various relational elements can be tested against desired outcomes and the system can be altered accordingly. The complex element of this method can be dealt with using computation while the objectives are set by the designer. This study will aim to explore the relational qualities of slum settlements.
Relational
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
19
Urban Growth Simulation
In order to simulate testing and evaluating these theories we implemented a simulation following Michael Batty’s formula for urban growth :
Pi(t) = f{εi(t) ,hi(t) ,ci(t), ai(t), νi(t)}
P- population l- location t- time
εi(t)-Randomness The variable used to blur explicit decision, the consideration of human decision making, this the case of this simulation, the random variable by which each dwelling is orientated on the plot.
hi(t) - Historical Accident The way in which mechanisms of change are enabled, be it the choice of a business or settlement based on human factors such as family, or in this case the position of the main track through the golf course determined by the previous usage.
20 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
ci(t) - Physical Determinism Geometric or geographic containers that affect an area or development, can have a varied impact on the development dependent on the level of the technology available. In this simulation the geometric container in action is existing site boundary of the golf course.
ai(t) - Natural Advantage Access and proximity to resources, growth will vary dependant on the economic and environmental gain of accessibility to a variety of resources. In simulation 1 the resource considered is the position of the main water point on the site.
νi(t) - Comparative Advantage Weighted measures and decisions based on benefit potential and distance, considering both benefit to cost ratio and non spatial impacts such as social and economic weighting. In this simulation this element is represented by the computational test of proximity to resources, the water point, or infrastructure. Allowing for settlement position to achieve the minimal distance to one of these factors.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
21
Sphere Project minimum standards for emergency settlements
Public Active recreation creates spatial voids with well maintained boundaries.
Maximise existing environment Shelter solutions should be planned to retain existing trees and other vegetation to maintain the soil stabilisation such growth provides and to maximise the opportunities for shade and protection from climate. Roads, pathways and drainage networks should be planned to make use of natural contours in order to minimise erosion and flooding.
Amenities Where possible, households can access land, markets or services for the continuation of development of livelihood support activities.
22 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Personal Privacy The plot layout in temporary planned camps should maintain the privacy and dignity of separate households by offsetting door openings and ensuring that each household shelter opens onto common space.
Family Privacy In mass shelters, the grouping of related families, well-planned access routes through the building or structure, and materials to screen personal and house-hold space can aid the provision of adequate personal privacy and safety.
vav Where possible, [...] routes should avoid creating isolated or screened areas that could pose a threat to the personal safety of users.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
23
Relational Simulation
04
Urban Network
In order to begin to attempt to simulate the complex relationship of forces at play it was necessary to attempt to recognise and establish patterns of how the settlement developed. In the days after the earthquake people began to congregate on the golf course from the surrounding city to escape falling debris caused by after shocks. At this early stage many people had lost all belongings so their primary concerns were based on basic survival needs. The needs we derived based on the Sphere Project minimal standards are as food, water and shelter.
The road is a settlement attractor due to the potential access to surviving infrastructure, the ability for the population to move across the site and the access to aid supplies. Water sources on the site are an obvious attractor as people would attempt to set up dwellings as close to water sources. The limited supplies available would encourage people to make use of the existing environment for shelter as much as possible. As such existing trees on the site act as attractors.
Obviously all of these initial nodal connections do not act independently and it is the interplay between them, as well as the weighting in terms of importance that effect the overall field of development.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
25
Proximity Simulations
Closest position to line
Once threshold reached develop around water source
Once threshold reached choose position closest to either attractor
26 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
3D visual of attractor rules
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
27
Quantitative Mapping
Terrain
Resources
Tree cover
Water
Distance to centres
Distance to centres
Choose closest
Choose closest
Topography
Road
Contours
Subdivide
Minimum exposure
Region
05
Region
Maximum slope
Region
Value map
+
-
Community Centres
28 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes Add Dwellings
Potential sites
Region
Access to city
Land Value Generator
Road
Height To begin to simulate the urban growth of the Petionville tent city five rules, defined from the starting conditions of the site were established. The main driving factors for settlement of the golf course are established by the relationship between terrain elements. This created diagrams of the most valuable land in relation to the attractor nodes.
Water sources
Tree cover
Terrain
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
29
+ 30 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
-
Development over time
Reality
Simulation
t=1
t=1
t=2
t=2
t=3
t=3
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
31
+ 32 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
-
Value Weighting
The simulation of the urban growth on the site is driven by a land value map. This map takes into account a number of set attractors across the site . Each of these attractor nodes is given a weighting based on their importance.
Road
The resulting value map is then generated based on the result of the average of these weightings. It is assumed that the most valuable land will be occupied first.# As this land increases in density its value will fall making other areas across the site more desirable.
Water Sources
The diagrams below show how the shifting value of the weightings over time alter the value of the available land and thus dictate the probable locations for the growth of the slum.
Trees
City connection
Contours
Heights
Weighting variations
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
33
Road
Water Sources
Trees
City Connection
Contours
+ Heights
34 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
-
Analysis
Road
Water sources
Road weighting decreases over time based on the initial need for a connection for resources and food aid. As the population grows the density of the land around the road increases. Shops and markets are also established which removes the importance of aid and the overall need for a road connection. As the population increases the settlement is unable to sustain itself with the shops and so aid is once again required. Water is given high importance as the slum is established for obvious survival reasons. As density increases this land becomes less desirable
Trees across the site are valuable for the cover they offer, reducing the amount of building materials necessary to be salvaged for house construction. Given that there are a limited number of trees across the site the value of these increase exponentially.
Trees
The connection point represents the access to the site from the destroyed city. The value for this is given exponential importance as this is where building materials can be salvaged. Given the weight and size of these materials the less distance these have to be carried the better, meaning clustering occurs around this area. Value is given to the site contours to represent the comparative ease of traversing along a hillside as opposed to climbing across it.
City connection
The height values across the site are calculated based on the need to avoid the weather exposed hill crest and instead favour the sheltered hillside.
Contours
Heights
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
35
Connecting
36 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
06
Frei Otto
Frei Otto proposed that settlements are a series of interconnected networks. These networks exist on multiple scales, from territory path networks (the connections between settlements), to settlement path networks (the connections within villages, towns and cities). These networks can be of the following types with many variations: The direct path system Masses and energies are transported in this system without making detours. In its ideal form, it only contains straight paths and path crossings. Path forks and concentrations do not occur. The direct path network is very simple to construct, as a plan on paper and also in any terrain that can easily be surveyed using simple plotting instruments, such as the Egyptians and Romans used. The minimal path system In a direct path system, every point is connected with every other point by the shortest route. This still applies if impassable obstacles deform some individual stretches. A minimal path system constructed between the same points has a significantly shorter total length. Minimal paths are created when paths have a low level of use and/or too expensive to construct, for example when three sites are situated in impassible terrain. The generative path system In many cases the occupation of a surface takes place sequentially. In addition to this, it is often random. Generative systems ‘search out’ the next nearest useful connection point. In generative path systems, users, when close to paths connecting at a right angle of the second generation usually take a short cut as soon as possible.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
37
Emergent Circulation Routes
Once these rules were established we were able to visualise the force relationship between the attractor nodes within the settlement and their effect on potential population movements. These diagrams proved to be especially useful at displaying ‘conflicted’ zones where the distance between one node and the next is equidistant. Essentially these diagrams are showing the shortest paths between the average of the nodes, marking the path of least resistance through the settlement as it is assumed that housing density would be less in these areas as people attempt to gather around useful resources. These paths of least resistance would become new pathways and road networks allowing people to move around the camp. In turn these pathways would become attractors in themselves. Water
This emergent system is displayed in the formation of rivers and streams, where water flowing under a force (gravity) attempts to find the path of least resistance downhill.
Road
Trees
38 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Fractal pattern created by water
Distance to centres
Topography
Distance to centres Distance to centres Choose closest Choose closest
Choose closest
Region
Choose closest Minimum exposure
Region Region
Road Access to city Subdivide
Subdivide Contours
Contours Distance to centres
Maximum slope Minimum exposure
Path Network Maximum slope
Region Region Region Region Region Another method of generating circulation routes is to create a definition that begins from a predetermined start point (in this case the road) Valueand mapsearches for valuable features (water sources.) Value map The next step for development in this simulation is to combine it with an optimisation routine such as the one simulated below. Finally it would be desirable to have the circulation ‘growth’ self reference the development of housing and other environmental factors.
Community Centres Community Centres
Potential sites
Add Dwellings
Potential sites
Add Dwellings
t=0
Access to rescources
> Critical < Threshold Critical Threshold Join Node New Node Add Dwellings Add Dwellings
< Critical Threshold New Node Add Dwellings
> Critical Threshold
Need for community Access to rescources
Attracting force
Join Node Add Dwellings
Need for privacy Need for community Power Law
Ne
Distancing force Attracting force Resultant density
Di
Orientatio Resultant density
t=1
Attractor node
Start node Attractor node
Start n
Distance to next node Distance to next node If ≈ Find nest nearest
Random possible paths
If > or < If ≈
If > or <
Unsuitable Find nest nearest
Unsuitable
Make connection
Target node Random possible paths
Test for nearest point Test for nearest point Average direction of attractor Average direction of attractor Make connection
Make connection
Make connection
t=2
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
39
Nodal Clustering
40 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
07
Social Dynamic
t=1
Centralized
Decentralised
Distributed
t=2
Following on from the circulation route investigations, we began to investigate how the various nodes across the site could be clustered into neighbourhoods. By studying the relationship of the connection to the nodes we are effectively establishing neighbourhood relationships. This will aid in the investigation of maximum densities that can be achieved. It is also hoped that this information it is hoped that social/cultural aspects of the slum can be added to the simulation.
t=3
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
41
42 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Neighbourhood grouping
In this simulation we attempted to simulate on a basic level the social groups that would form throughout the slum. The initial starting nodes are set to represent water points (i.e. community centres where people from nearby houses would meet.) From here we added further dwellings to these groups based on their proximity to neighbours. It is assumed that people living in close proximity would have regular contact as well as people who use the same water source.
t=1
At a certain point in the growth of a neighbourhood, the distance of the outlying houses reaches a critical distance from the central node (and contact with the central occupants) Where the outer region is isolated to the point where it becomes a sub neighbourhood.
t=2
t=3
Community centres with neighbourhoods
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
43
44 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Neighbourhood Growth
t=1
t=4
t=2
t=5
Small (Stable)
Large (Ready to divide)
t=3
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
45
46 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
K-Means Clustering
Resources
t=1
Tree cover
Water
Distance to centres
Distance to centres
Choose closest
Choose closest
Topograp
Contou
Minimum exposure
Region
Region
Region
Value map t=2
Neighbourhood simulation plotted over entire site
Community Centres
Potential site
Add Dwellings
t=3
< Critical Threshold
> Critical Threshold
New Node
Join Node
Add Dwellings
Add Dwellings
Access to rescources
Attracting for
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
47
Potential sites
Access to rescources
Need for community
Need for privacy Power Law
Attracting force
Distancing force
Resultant density
Orientation
48 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
Occupation With Distancing And Attracting Forces
Frei Otto distancing occupation
Distancing occupation Node
Frei Otto undertook a number of studies to simulate the occupying and distancing forces at play in urban environments. We undertook a computational simulation to recreate this experiment and to simulate how the slum dwellings would group at a neighbourhood level. To this we introduced forced separators such as roads and then applied an algorithmic solver to calculate the orientation of the buildings based on the requirement for privacy.
Attracting occupation Node
Algorithmic orientation
Frei Otto attracting occupation
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
49
Praxis
08 Terrain
Resources
Urban conditions Existing density Tree cover
Water
Distance to centres
Distance to centres
Choose closest
Choose closest
Topography
Road
Contours
Subdivide
Minimum exposure
Region
Region
Access to city
Maximum slope
Region
Region
Value map Community Centres
Start node
Add Dwellings
Distance to next node
< Critical Threshold
> Critical Threshold
New Node
Join Node
Add Dwellings
Add Dwellings
If â&#x2030;&#x2C6; Find nest nearest Random possible paths Test for nearest point
Potential sites
Access to rescources
Average direction of attractor
Need for community
Make connection
Need for privacy Power Law
Attracting force
Distancing force
Resultant density Depletion
Orientation
Density levels
Existing Proposed
50 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
If > or < Unsuitable
Combined Simulation
t=1
t=2
t=3
t=4
Initial experiments attempting to integrate feedback between levels of simulation for example as above showing relationship between neighbourhood clustering and road development The logic diagram on the left shows a model for future development of the simulation. By adding iterative feedback the various forces at play across the urban network would be able to self reference and produce a more accurate recreation of the true settlement conditions.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
51
Conclusions
52 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
08
Simulation Conclusion
01
01. The simulation seems to accurately predict in terms of land value the way that the settlement will develop in terms of responding to the site conditions 02. Land value anomaly; the area of high value land shown here remains unoccupied. There are a number of possible explanations for this, firstly the trees that are given an attractive value are plotted from a plan view. This makes it impossible to establish their height, and so areas of low bushes are plotted as tall trees. Obviously these would be difficult to build around due to their density and lack of strength. Similarly the area could have unfavourable ground conditions, to solve these issues a more detailed site survey would need to be undertaken.
02 03
04
03. Here it is possible to notice a direct correlation between the offshoot of the settlement and the land value map. From the satellite images it was possible to derive that these areas built up once the most valuable land was occupied. Given that they occur on medium value land this is an encouraging result, however the simulation does not currently have an iterative factor, and is unable to set limits on density for self referenced growth. 04.Land Value anomaly; this area shows that it is of low value which is significant due to the proximity of the road (an attractor) and the fact that people are settling in this area in the satellite images of the site. Upon further scrutiny it was discovered that the US military established this area in order to supply aid to the settlement. The camp is situated on the highest point on the site, away from water sources and tree cover. This is significant, as it highlights that the military area is governed by different settlement rules. In turn it is likely that this would become an attractor in and of itself, so this area will require further analysis.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
53
Conclusions
The phrase ‘city planning’ conjures images of quite traditional architectural working methods. Things like sketch perspectives and charts and graphs about how we use urban space. The problem with this way of working, is that as soon as you print out one of these graphs, sketch or photograph a feature of this city you’ve captured a snapshot of a dynamic system. The built form of a city is perceived as a result of its history, a snapshot of the human activity it represents and facilitates. The built environment is also only the tip of the iceberg in terms of what defines and drives a city’s development. Fundamentally then, the city exists as a network of systems as argued by Zachary Neal in ‘the connected city: how networks are shaping the modern metropolises when he says: It is not individualistic but relational; instead of treating them as independent, a network approach recognises that people and places influence one another through their relationships.” In the past this way of looking at the city was not useful in the design process because of the extremely complex relationship of the forces at play. Parametric tools, and the computers innate ability to handle complexity, are offering designers the potential to tap into these systems and to manipulate them. Currently the main problem with this approach is that architects and planners are still approaching the use of these tools with methodology that pre-dates them. This is echoed by Dr Micheal McAdams in a paper called ‘Complexity theory and urban planning.’ “Within the last few decades, urban planners, urban geographers and others have noted the inadequacy of using existing scientific methods and organizational structures based on concepts tied to logical-positivism such as rationalism, reductionism and comprehensive long-range planning to address the problems and challenges of the urban environment.” The way that modernist schemes approach the problem is to handle complexity with reductionism. For example in Le Corbusier’s radiant city plan; the city is treated as a machine with the function of addressing four identified problems: inhabitation, work, recreation and circulation. The problem here is that while it might sound valid on a theoretical level it is completely inadequate in practice. The assumption that the will of the designer can override the extensive underlying forces at play in the city is clearly a flawed methodology.
54 Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
So how else can we approach the problem? One approach it to utilise complex-systems science, things like complexity theory and chaos theory. There are problems with this method as well though, because besides the difficulty in formally modelling complexity if you take the simplest urban relationship, in isolation it can be easy to predict its outcomes. Add it back into the urban network and it becomes extremely complex through its interactions. As more and more of these relationships are combined they become intertwined like tangled string, as we found with the simulation as the scale was reduced. While you can analyse the relationship between these strings as either tangled or untangled it is extremely difficult to predict the effects of pulling one end of the string on the system as a whole. Once these systems are intertwined to the extent of a modern city they can only be addressed with chaotic system theories. At which point it could be argued that planning becomes infeasible and the system should just be allowed to develop naturally. This approach though, can lead to undesirable manifestations of the settlement, whether this be in a physical sense (the form) or on a social, economic or environmental level. So if reductionism is too simple, and complexity is beyond our ability to comprehend, how can we address the problems of designing in an urban context effectively? The way to manage the outcome of this method is to design the desirable city. We can set objectives to achieve with our designs. Objectives come from the desire to realise our imaginations. Imagination has the power to conceive a city not yet in existence, before all simulations and computer programs. It is a feat best performed by the human brain, not by computers. Parametric tools seek to augment our ability to simulate complex urban relationships, human creativity and the designer’s intuition create the goals of this process. While this sounds obvious, the way the majority of architects are practicing is not endeavouring to achieve this. It is essential that favourable social conditions are a primary objective and not the hopeful outcome of a deeply related set of purely geometric principles. By taking advantage of parametric tools architects can integrate digital computation with analytical design processes at a much more fundamental level than has previously been possible to achieve. What are objectives? Objectives are basically rules and rules are what makes computers work. So, it seems obvious that digital techniques could be useful in designing our cities.
Conclusions
The study aimed to simulate the way that emergent slum settlements grow and develop. At every step it was necessary to interrogate, in detail how we were achieving these outcomes. Primarily this was due to the fact that there are countless ways to generate the perceived patterns. It was however, vital to attempt to simulate the relationships that existed on the site, not merely recreate patterns that are visible from aerial views. Primarily, this was because it would have created incorrect results which would have compounded their inaccuracies through interactions with other aspects of the system. For future study it would therefore, be vital to test the simulation on other slum settlements, and observe whether the results are accurate. Similarly, when using this kind of methodology in practice it would be important to include an anomaly checking framework. Within our simulation there are areas that do not behave as predicted, it is necessary that these areas are scrutinised in order to either address inaccuracies in the simulation, or to extract the rules behind these anomalies for feedback into the system. Unfortunately, the simulation is limited by its inability to feedback between scales. Primarily this was due to the difficulty in achieving this computationally. There is also extensive research necessary to address and comprehend how these different scales interact.
In summary, the simulation provides a good foundation for the simulation and study of slum settlements. It is by no means a comprehensive, entirely accurate model, it is a tool for facilitating a more in depth study of the complicated set of networked relationships that drive a settlement. While there are levels of complexity to this simulation, there are also gross simplifications that have had to be made in order to reduce processing time. Given more computational power, it would be possible to increase the level of complexity and create a more organic, real time simulation of growth. The authors strongly believe, that approaching urban design with this methodology, is drastically more comprehensive than the current approach. Primarily, because it allows the computer to handle the multiple relational aspect, and does not rely on the designer to remember, or to calculate the effect of one chance on the entire system. Which would take a huge amount of time, and is therefore, largely overlooked in current practice. Using these tools it also facilitates the designer to simulate interventions and asses them against the desired objective. In the past the â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;simulationâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; occurred in the physical world, the intervention would be built and if it failed it had real world consequences. By rigorously testing such schemes computationally, more effective, site specific and sustainable solutions can be achieved.
It seems logical that, given settlements are essentially driven by human movement which is proven by observing the similarities between the patterns of individuals coming together to form groups and those of settlements. That there is an interaction between scales, i.e. the individual citizen has an effect on the system as a whole. For example if you place a large group of people in a landscape and left them there, with no way of constructing buildings, it is likely that the places they occupied and the pathways they used would be remarkably similar to the locations of the various buildings they would construct. Similarly, the simulation does not currently self-reference its own growth, In reality, as areas became overcrowded, or new amenities were added to the site this would alter the value map. Adding in this iterative self referencing, as opposed to a predefined change over time, would be necessary if the study was taken further. The next point of interest for further study would be to apply this simulation as a tool for design. By adding in additional services and nodes to settlement, it would be possible to predict areas where they would be most effective. It would also be possible to observe the possible detrimental effects these services could have.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
55
ban landscapes
Bibliography
Frei Otto, Occupying and Connecting: Thoughts on Territories and Spheres of Influence with Particular Reference to Human Settlement. Edition Axel Menges (1 Oct 2008) ISBN 978-3-932565-11-3 Edna Shaur ‘Non-planned Settlements; Characteristic features, Path system, Surface subdivision IL39 (1991) Michael Weinstock, The Architecture of Emergence: The Evolution of Form in Nature and Civilisation, John Wiley & Sons 2010, IBSN 978-0470066331 Michael Batty, Cities & Complexity: Understanding Cities with Cellular Automata, Agent Based Models and Fractals The MIT Press (August 24, 2007) Daniel Shiftman,The Nature of Code: Simulating Natural Systems with Processing (http:// natureofcode.com) Alex Lehnerer, Grand Urban Rules, nai101 (Sept 2009) ISBN 978-90-6450-666-6 Jak Drinnan. (2012). Urban growth networks. Available: http://www.jd-d.co.uk/2012/06/urban-growth-networks.html. Last accessed 17th April 2014. Davis, Mike, ’Planet of Slums’ London ; New York : Verso, 2006. 01/01/2006 eTorrens, Paul M.; Kevrekidis, Ioannis; Ghanem, Roger; Yu Zou. Entropy. Jul20123, Vol. 15 Issue 7, p2606-2634. 29p. 2 Color Photographs, 4 Diagrams, 3 Graphs. DOI: 10.3390/ e15072606 Zachary P. Neal, the connected city: how networks are shaping the modern metropolis McAdams, Dr M. A, 2008. Complexity Theory and Urban Planning. PHD. Istanbul, Turkey: Fatih University Urbanism for Expanding Cities: Designing the Conjugal Interface of Contrasting Systems”, with Jason King, in Landscape Architecture (China), Issue #2, pp.62-66.
Emergence[y] urban rules for post traumatic urban landscapes
57
Emergent Urbanism River Valley Settlements Chris Foster Ben Lillywhite
Contents 1. Defining Settlements Researching the basic understanding of what a settler and settlement are, without being defined by itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s context, to develop a knowledge of the key principles to define a settlement 2. Rivers Refining our research to its context and learning about the key features and factors of a river valley 3. Settlement Expansion Using our knowledge learnt so far to look at how the early settlements would have arrived at a river valley and then how the settlement would have expanded 4. Case Studies Using real life examples, we aim to test our theories to see if they run true and analyse the case studies for further rules and parameters 5. Digital Simulation Testing the rules we have found in a digitally created environment attempting to predict the initial starting point of a settlement within a river valley and analysing how they would expand 6. Conclusion Evaluating our work and script
59
Defining Settlements
01
To help us gain a greater understanding of how to fulfil the brief, we have gone back to the routes and learnt the basics of settlers and settlements
A settler is defined as:
â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;A person who permenantly resides in one locationâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
Humans settle in various locations, looking for areas which offer qualities that support the growth of a community and can assist in survival
Settlements expand to accomodate increasing populations due to developing their knowledge, but the emerging urbanism is affected by its environment.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
61
Settlement Criteria When deciding upon a location in which to settle, a set of criteria are established. The primary criteria for locating a settlement are related to its proximity to valuable resources such as:
“Where can we grow crops?”
“Does the topography of the land ensure safety?”
“Are materials for building nearby?”
“Are there methods of easy travel?”
62 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Benefits of Settling in the River Valley As every human needs water to survive the majority of settlements are close to a source of fresh water. Rivers are the most common source of fresh water, and their valleys often meet all the criteria for settlement location.
Fertile land for crop cultivation
Higher ground is safer for building
Forests offer timber for shelter construction
The river itself is used for travel
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
63
Rivers
River Features The locations of certain river features can be approximated based on the topography of any landscape. Rivers are often broken into three different courses; Upper, Middle and Lower.
Source - Upper Course
Meanders - Middle Course
66 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
The source of a river originates from areas of higher ground, where groundwater emerges from the substrate and flows downhill. The valley is usually v-shaped here and waterfalls and gorges are often found close to the source of a river.
Meanders are found in the middle course of a river where the surrounding land is open and gentley sloping. Faster flowing water erodes the the outside of a river bend whilst sediment is deposited on the inside, forming curved meanders.
River Features It is possible to approximate hypothetical locations of certain river features, as the locations of features below and subsequent pages are defined by the shape, gradient and geological make-up of the valley itself.
Confluence - Middle Course
Delta - Lower Course
Also known as a conflux, a confluence is where two or more bodies of water meet. Rivers meet in areas where two valleys run downhill and open out in the same location, these areas often flood creating vast expanses of fertile land.
A delta is formed where a river valley opens out to meet the sea, or other large body of water such as a lake. The river deposits its sediment where the gradient of the surrounding land becomes almost flat and the river loses its momentum.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
67
Features of the River valley that effect settlement emergence It is important to identify key features found in river valleys, as humans will look for these when deciding on a location to settle. We believe these will be the initial major factors.
Shallow points
River meander
68 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Often found in the upper course of a river, where the surrounding land is steeper and the water moves slower. Shallow, and or narrows points of a river are often sought out by nearby settlers as this makes crossing by foot easier; Thus allowing the possibilty of exploring the other side of the river valley and its inherint amenities.
Meanders primarily occur in the middle course of a river, where the surrounding landscape is less steep. Settlers will travel to the outside of a river meander to find the deeper, faster flowing water. Fish swimming in the river are pushed, by the current, to the outside of meander bends making them easier to catch.
Features of the River valley that effect settlement emergence The relationships and distances between these key features will affect the ways in which settlements emerge to accomodate a growing population.
Regularly flooded areas
Shallower gradients
Flood plains are usually found in the lower-lying middle course of rivers. River can burst their banks following heavy rainfalls, spilling the water into the surrouding landscape. The flatter the land to either side of the river, the further the water will spill and larger the floodplain will be. Humans often utilise the flat land that floods regularly to cultivate crops as this land is made much more fertile by flood waters. Ancient calendars were often defined by this regular flooding season and the subsequent harvests.
Areas of land with shallow gradients are sought by settlers to erect their shelters. It requires significantly less energy to form settlements on flat land, areas that are elevated above the flood level and have shallow gradients are often the most suitable locations to initiate settlements.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
69
Settlement expansion
Settlement Expansion Investigating the effects of an expanding settlement as resources and knowledge increase to fulfil its potential
Settlements are initiated at locations that meet the criteria.
Settlements expand to cater for growing communities, this increase in population is supported by the rivers eco-system and available resources
Communities continue to expand, in one location, until the resources in the immediate area are depleted and/or the land becomes too difficult to build upon.
72 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Settlement Path Emergence By learning how a settlement will look to expand when it reaches its maximum potential, we can then start to apply this in our digital simulation
When the growth of a settlement exceeds that of the available resources, a new location for settling is sought.
Paths develop linking communities from the existing site with those in new orv nearby settlements.
A network of paths linking settlements along the river is formed, allowing continued growth without depleting local resources.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
73
Urban Emergence How will the urban arrangement develop as the town increases in both size and population
From the initial settlement, the primary direction of urban emergence runs parallel to the river, in order to maintain each inhabitants proximty to the fresh water source.
It is possible that a settlement may expand and grow away from the river, this only occurs when the surrounding environment dictates it is better to do so.
Eventually the settlement will reach the boundaries constraining its growth, it is at this point that urbanism begins to emerge down pathways leading to nearby settlements.
74 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Urban Path Emergence By learning how a settlement will look to expand when it reaches its maximum potential, we can then start to apply this in our digital simulation
Building density increases alongside the growing population. Secondary path networks are formed connecting new inhabitants with others in the settlement.
Path networks evolve over time within the emerging settlement allowing easier access to amenities, whilst determing the locations of future properties.
Public buildings are often situated at the heart of existing settlements, as path networks linking settlers are already in place.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
75
Case Studies
Case Study: Sheffield, UK Don Valley
River Length - 110 km
Multi Scale Analysis of Sheffield
40km
• • • •
8km
Sheffield
Rivers / Tributary
Surrounding Cities
Soft Substrate - Fertile Land
Road Networks
Hard Substrate - Higher / Steep Land
Sheffield resides in the centre of multiple major towns such as Leeds, Manchester and Doncaster. Located within valleys to all sides, Sheffield sits within the confluence of 5 rivers: Don, Sheaf, Rivelin, Loxley and Porter. Path networks have developed as these cities grew defining the routes in which the settlements would evolve Using the local minerals and resources found within the ground, Sheffield quickly expanded it’s industrial prowess thanks to accessible transport links from the river. As well as using the river as a source of power
80 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
• • • •
Sheffield has developed alongside the River Don and has been inhabited for around 12,800 years Surrounded by hilltops, Sheffield is protected from the south westerly prevailing wind The fertile land drawn above represents the flood plain of the river. Sheffield has developed to lie just outside of this region, whilst close enough to take advantage of the opportunity to grow crops Whilst this fertile land helped the early settlements, Sheffield truely expanded during the industrial age, when the city took advantage of lieing on the fasterflowing outside of a meander, and using the river to power turbines
Multi Scale Analysis of Sheffield
2km
1km
Pre 1830’s Settlement
River Don
1830 - 1900
Initial Settlement
1900 - 1940
Urban Emergence
Post 1940’ss
• • •
The city quickly developed and expanded during the 1800’s as the industrial age took hold within Britain Developing along the path networks to Manchester, Leeds and the other major towns, people sought to come to the area due to the large number of opportunities and jobs Over the past 100 years, expansion has slowed, with ronovation being seen as key to the region
• •
To utilise the space as best as possible, properties were developed to sit back to back to allow for an increase in population Open space within the city centre was seen as room to expand for the early governments
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
81
Abstracting Rules of Emergence
Primary settlement in relation to nearby settlements
1km
River Don Initial Settlement Urban Emergence
• • •
Transport to nearby towns was key in Sheffield evolving as the products manufactured within the city could be easily taken to other area; either by the river, or more commonly, road. These early path networks helped to define the areas upon which buildings could be constructed and helped to shape the city plan The images to the right help to explain the way the city expanded defined by the path networks, whilst the image on the opposite page shows the paths on a larger scale
Road / path networks link settlements
Urbanism emerges along the road / path networks
82 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Diagramming Rules of Emergence
Elevated Land
Fertile Land
Crossing Points
Fast Flowing Water
Based on the river features we identified in the previous chapter, we wanted to test these theories against Sheffields development. The city expanded primarily due to the fast flowing water on the outside of the meander used to power machinery. There was also a significant use of fertile land in the early history of the area to provide resources, whilst the development was little based on crossing points and elevated land. The urban development appeared to be defined by the road network and there were clear signs that the city grew along these paths, as we had previously predicted, a result we can take forward into our own digital simulation.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
83
Case Study: Owensboro, USA Owensboro, USA Ohio River
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
85
Multi Scale Analysis of Owensboro
40km
•
• • •
8km
Owensborough
Rivers / Tributary
Surrounding Cities
Soft Substrate - Fertile Land
Road Networks
Hard Substrate - Higher / Steep Land
Owensboro is the 4th largest otwn by population in the Kentucky state, with neighboring nearby towns being Louisville, Evansville and Princeton, as well as being within 200 miles of Cininnati and Indianapolis Lies on a meander of the Ohio River The first European people settled here because their boats were puished to the shore due to the strong current. With evidence suggesting that the first settlers in the area occured 12,000 years ago. The city is famous for producing whiskey, as well as the Owensboro Wagon Company, utilising the central location and path network
• •
•
Owensboro developed on the outside of a meander of the Ohio River and lies on the opposite side of the fertile land. Despite the fact that Owensboro grew on the south side of the river, away from the fertile land, this has its advantages in the fact that the area is less likely to flood, and so the city could grow a lot closer to the river and utilise the power of the current a lot more efficiently Due to its location, the climate is hot and humid, whilst moderately cold in winter. Therefore, as well as being on the opposite side of the river to the fertile land, the area may not have grown many crops due to the environment.
Multi Scale Analysis of Owensboro
1km
2km
Initial Settlement
River Ohio
Initial Expansion 1797
Initial Settlement
Secondary Expansion 1900’s
Urban Emergence
Post 1940’s Developments
• • •
From the initial settlelemt, Owensboro has increased in stages in a radial fashion, with the first expansion primarily towards Evansville A secondary expansion occured early in the 20th century, again in a radial motion. During this period, a ring road was established signifying the extents of the city After the Second World War, the city again expanded, however this expansion occured along the road network, adhering to our previous hypothesis
• •
With limited extrnal parameters, and in a similar fashion to other American towns, Owensboro city centre has developed on a grid system Whilst the city centre does not comply with our previous thoughts regarding settlement expansion along path networks, the development in the 1940’s, outside of the city ring road, does mirror our initial thoughts
Abstracting Rules of Emergence
Primary settlement and transport link
1km
Ohio River Initial Settlement Urban Emergence
• • • •
All roads within the city centre run along a North/ South, East/ West axis, with clearly defined areas of the city The images opposite help to diagram the grid expansion Any future expansion is already clearly defined on where it is likely to take place, with any future buildings being restricted by the road networks The residents in Owensboro could build as close to the Ohio River as possible due to the fact they did not lie within the flood plain
Roads are the only growth constraint
Urbanism emerges in grid form, bounded by roads
88 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Diagramming Rules of Emergence
Elevated Land
Fertile Land
Crossing Points
Fast Flowing Water
Similar to Sheffield, elevated and fertile land carry little significance in the evolution of Owensboro. A key factor was the faster flowing water, allowing industry to thrive and use the river as a power source. The quicker current also brings with it an influx in fish, an alternative food source to the naturally grown crops. These crops could have been grown on the opposite side of the river, therefore crossing points also played a large part.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
89
Rules for emergence
Rules - Shallow Gradients
Safe to build
Safe to build
Safe to build
It is an inherent building rule, that the flatter the land, the easier it is to construct. Within a river valley, these areas are highly sought after due to the nature in which a valley is produced. In the case studies we have researched, the area has developed thanks to a shallow gradient and we believe this will be one of the key factors in our simulations and any future predictions.
92
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Topographical analysis of gradient
Z Axis Angle from verticle
To analyse the gradient in our digital simulations, we will analyse the surface normal, against the Z-Axis. The surface normal is the perpendicular angle created from the face of the surface. The lower that this angle is when compared to the Z-Axis, then the lower the gradient and the higher chance that settlements will begin to develop there. The larger the angle, then the steeper the gradient is and the ability to construct increases significantly.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
93
Rules - Fertile Land Proximity to river crossing points
Having the ability to find a food source is a neccesity to any settlement. In areas that flooded, when the flooded river drained away, it left behind highly fertile land which was then utilised by settlements to produce crops. These floods often became seasonal, allowing the settlements to predict when they would occur and so could harvest in time. As time went on, settlements began to realise the level to which the river would flood. Armed with this information, the settlement then new the lower boundary that they could build to, to avoid being flooded.
94
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Topographical analysis of fertile land
Flooded Water Level
Normal Water Level
In our digital simulation, we are going to set two river levels, a normal and flooded. Doing this will allow us to create a region of fertile points and find a desirable location for the settlelments. Depending on the surface that is created, it will be possible to see where the gradient is flatter, which will allow the river to flow over more land and create a larger fertile land region, as is depicted in the diagram above, to the left of the river. In this larger fertile land region, it will then be possible to cultivate and grow crops. Where the river bank is steeper, a smaller fertile land region will be created, meaning that it will be harder to grow.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
95
Rules - River Crossing Points Proximity to river crossing points
Often found near the source, in the upper course of the river, are shallow, narrow crossing points. Looking for these narrow points further down the river is another key finding of our research. These narrow points meant that less time and resources were needed to produce a bridge type construction, therefore less energy wasted. The crossing points also allowed towns such as Owensboro and Budapest, to develop or use the land on the opposite side of the river.
96
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Topographical analysis of potential crossing points
Depth
Width
Determining the shallow and narrow points of our digital simulation will allow us to find the natural crossing points. We plan to analyse the width of the rivers created and use this in the urban emergence. By finding the crossing points, it will enable us to attempt to find possible paths that would be taken, to allow further settlements to develop along the river.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
97
Rules - Fishing Locations Proximity to river crossing points
Crops is not the only food source that a river can provide, with fishing being another key consideration. Where little fertile land is available, fishing becomes the main food supply and is highly sought after, especially in the higher mountainous regions where the land is steeper and the temperature colder, meaning cultivation is extremely difficult.
98
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Topographical analysis of potential crossing points
Shallow / slow current
Deep / fast current
As the river meanders, the current flows faster around the outside, cutting and eroding a larger proportion of the river bed, compared to the slower moving inside bend. With this faster current around the outside, comes an increased population of fish as they are pushed around, meaning a greater chance of catching food. In our digitial simulation, we will analyse the curvature of the curve, in an attempt to predict the best fishing places.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
99
Initial river valley simulation
Elevation Analysis Visualisation
Gradient Analysis Visualisation
Areas Satisfying Parameters
Digital Simulations
Three-dimensional topography formation Describing the process of how we have created a flexible surface, in order to allow us to predict the Urban Emergence final arrangement in the future, based on numerous iterations of weighted rules
To give ourselves greater flexibility, we created ourselves a NURBS surface.
We were then able to manipulate it in the Z-Axis to create a surface
With this surface, we can then analyse the effects of one river source
Or multiple river sources and witness the results
102 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Plotting rivers on three-dimensional topography
From the single river source, we can see the path that the river will take.
Increasing the river level due to heavy rains we can find the flood plain
We are also able to see the results of adding a second river
And again the results of the flooded rivers
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
103
Digital Simulation - Creating the Valley Creating the river valley that we will use to test our rules and devise a conclusion
Creating a random surface from which we can examine the results of our theories
The river valley was defined by the path of the river
104 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Creating the Valley
The river flows down the valley from pre-determined sources
Overlaying a grid of points, enables analysis of the surface at any given point to ascertian areas the best comply with our rules
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
105
Digital Simulation - Our Rules By using the surface we have created, we are able to examine the various points that meet the needs of the individual rules
Finding flatter land upon which to build made it easier for settlers. Based on our inital points, the points highlighted offer initial settlement points based ona gradeint of below 10 degrees
Settlers often looked for fertile land from which they could grow crops. The points shown lie within the flooding region, meaning they will be most fertile through the growing season
106 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Our Rules
Crossing points allowed settlements to grow and so settlers often looked for the narrowest part of the river when determining their initial location. Highlighted are the best crossing points
On the outside of a meander the river flows slower and so fish can be more readily caught. Shown on this diagram are areas on which the river will be flowing at its slowest
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
107
Digital Simulation - Testing Our Rules Testing the surface against a number of rules with differing weights to examine the final outcome
To test our theories, we decided to weight our rules and try and predict where the initial starting point would be.
Starting from our initial points, we then deleted points that we found were on too steep a gradient.
108 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Testing Our Rules
From these points, we then found the closest points to the fertile land, whilst not lying within the flood plain
Finally, we found the areas that could be expanded easily. Therefore, we narrowed down our inital points to the ones closest to the crossing points
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
109
Digital Simulation - Finding the Initial Settlement Narrowingdown the inital settlement to one location
We managed to narrow down our starting points to several initial locations. We are now going to attempt to narrow this down even further. We start by finding how many points are within the immediate vicinity.
To find the closest points, we drew circles around all of our points. We then grouped these circles together, in order to find the ones with the largest area. This means that the region has the best chance in which to expand.
110 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Finding the Initial Settlement
After analysing the areas, we then cull the regions which we believe to be too small
Finally, we again search for the region which are closest to the fertile land and the crossing points, and are left with the one intial settlement.
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
111
Digital Simulation - Urban Emergence Focusing in on our surface, we can begin to analyse how the city would begin to develop based on our rules
From an initital starting point, the village will begin to expand, looking for its closest neighbour point
In the early stages, the settlement grows in a linear fashion
112 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Urban Emergence
Based on the points we found the settlement begins to grow along these points, having to curve around with the gradient, before diverting back towards fertile land.
Eventual settlement layout, based on pre-determined parameters
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
113
Digital Simulation - Urban Emergence Using the knowledge we learnt by analysing path networks, we can begin to predict how the settlement will look to expand outside of its territory
As the settlement expands, eventually it will reach maximum capacity. The settlers will then look to find a new territory. Based on our theories, we have found these new location points.
Analysing the direct paths, the settlers will have had to have crossed extreme terrain in this scenario. The river was often used for transport, allowing settlements to develop along the river banks
114 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Urban Emergence
Highlighted are the previously culled initial settlement regions, which were culled due to being too small. These areas could eventually develop being passing points to the larger settlements
Shown in green are the predicted smaller settlements that would develop as the 4 larger settlements grow
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
115
Digital Simulation - Path Outcomes On a smaller scale, investigating the effect the path networks will have on the smaller, satellite villages
As the settlements begin to expand and searching for new areas, small satellite villages will start to develop, as discussed on the previous page
Looking on a smaller scale, these satellite villages will begin to expand in the directions of the larger towns
116 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Path Outcomes
The larger towns will develop and expand towards the satellite villages and the other larger towns. These settlements will then start to trade between themselves
Final iteration including the smaller towns of how we believe the region would develop based on our rules
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
117
Digital Simulation - Various Iterations Testing the surface based on a variety of iterations to deem wether the script has been succesful and allowed us to predict a final scenario
This final iteration is based on the gradient being weighted heaviest, before fertile land.
In this iteration, the most important parameter was the fishing points, before culling the too steep gradient points
118 Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
Digital Simulation - Various Iterations
Here we have examined what would happen if the crossing points were weighted the heaviest, before culling the fertile points
Finally, we looked into the fertile land points, and fishing points
Emerging Urbanism of River Valleys
119
â&#x20AC;&#x153;We have always believed that River valleys offer the best option available for a settlement to emerge and allow urban growth. Through our initial research, we found the key criteria required when searching for an initial starting point based on any environment, then focused this criteria to river valley specific parameters. We were able to analyse path networks, how they formed the basis of new settlements and informed the evolutionary direction of the given settlements. Through our case studies, we were able to see that settlements did not need to fulfil all of the criteria, meeting just a few was enough to allow major urban development. Weighting the criteriaâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s a food source, be that crops or fish, was a necessity; alongside the flatter gradients to allow easier construction given the limited construction techniques. After thorough research we were able to devise 4 key criteria needed to enable urban growth. These being: shallow gradient to allow construction, fertile land to allow the cultivation of crops, narrow/ shallow points permitting easier crossing and further exploration and fast flowing meanders meaning a greater source of fish.â&#x20AC;?
â&#x20AC;&#x153;Using this knowledge, we could digitally create a surface and test our hypotheses, varying the weightings of the parameters in a similar fashion to the case studies, in order to predict the initial starting point, the expansion routes and the final outcome of our modelled terrain. We believe that the results found are in the areas that we would have imagined settlements to develop given the environment and that the urban evolvement to the nearby settlements would have been true. However, we based our initial starting settlement based on area and the potential to increase the settlement size. This may not have necessarily being true, with a settlement emerging at the earliest opportunity available given the direction that the travellers came from. Therefore, this may have meant that different satellite villages would have developed and the final scenario would have been different. Furthermore, every travelling community may have weighted their needs differently to the ones we have predicted, had a variety of construction methods, required another key principle such as elevated land for security, consequently another final outcome would have emerged. We believe that given the information and the surface topography, using our script we would be able to find an initial starting point and the final outcome of a scenario, based on a given set of rules. There are options to incorporate a variety of parameters within our script, where additional data can be collated such as; Wind velocity, Material / Energy use per person, Geological surveys, or Tidal influences.â&#x20AC;?
Conclusion
EMERGENT URBANISM HILLS
By Dominic Kennedy
123 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 123
TYPES OF HILL AND WAYS TO INHABIT
MOUNTAIN Formed by tectonic forces and volcanism Generally uninhabitable Highest points viewed as a connection to the Gods
HILL Formed by erosion and weathering Strategic devices for fortification, authority, storage of resources Inhabitable and suitable for agriculture
CLIFF FACE Formed by erosion and weathering Inhabitable spaces to protect civilisations from the harsh elements or climates across the world
124 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 124
HILLS AND HIERARCHIES IN URBAN ARRANGEMENTS
LOCATION FOR MONARCHY / DYNASTIC INFLUENCE
RELIGIOUS PRESENCE ANCIENT ROME, CHRIST THE REDEEMER, TIBETAN MONASTERIES
FORTIFICATION - SITES FOR GOOD VANTAGE POINTS AND ATTACK ADVANTAGES
LOCATION FOR HOUSING HIGH VALUE / IMPORTANCE RESOURCES TO DISTRIBUTE TO OTHER SETTLEMENTS
HILL TOP / SUMMIT
AUTHORITY
HILL BASE / VALLEY
PROVIDERS
HIERARCHIES Hills have traditionally been used for hierarchical delegation of authority or importance of amenity. The higher regions of hills are where the decision making, high value persons/goods would be located making it a key node to inhabit or take over. The ‘providers’ to the ‘authority’ settlements would be located in the lower altitudes. They would be subservient to the king or dynastic region and provide resources. Both parties however would have a strong mutual reliance upon each other. For example, a high defensive settlement would sacrifice amenities such as arable land, water sources lower down and the providers would require protection of resources, families, etc from rival tribes.
MUTUAL RELIANCE
125 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 125
FLOOD AVERSION
SEASONAL FLOODING DETERRED ENEMY ATTACKS
HIGH ALTITUDE LOCATIONS AVOID OR CURB FLOOD RISKS IN RAINY SEASONS
Uses today Today, hills are also used for sustainable measures. Higher terrains can be utilised for the wind energy generated by wind turbines. Recent climate change has resulted in increased rates of flooding around the world. Measures have been taken therefore to utilise sustainable urban drainage (SUDS) to reduce these catastrophic effects in valley regions. Tourism is a large industry today and hilly topographies have taken advantage of this. Chamonix resort on Mont Blanc, for example held the first Winter Olympics in 1924 and has attracted extreme sports enthusiasts and winter holiday makers ever since.
126 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 126
SUSTAINABLE ENERGY WIND FARMS
SUSTAINABLE URBAN DRAINAGE (SUDS) FOR EXAMPLE TREE PLANTATIONS TO REDUCE FLOOD RISK IN VALLEYS
LEISURE / TOURISM INDUSTRIES
TACTICAL ADVANTAGES OF HILL TOPOGRAPHY
ANTICIPATED FLOOD ZONES, TYPICALLY IN VALLEYS OR THE BASE OF STEEP TOPOGRAPHY
DEFENSIBLE AREAS ADVANTAGEOUS TO ENEMY ATTACKS
HIGHER ALTITUDES PROVIDE BETTER VANTAGE POINTS
FLOODING
CLIFFS
VANTAGE POINTS AND VISIBILITY
The potential risk areas have been mapped here to demonstrate where flood zones occur at high point in the rainy season.
Whilst the steeper gradients of cliffs show where cultivation, construction and access to and from the summit are more difficult to achieve, they are tactically essential for defense.
High points have been traditionally used on topographies around the world for awareness of contextual surroundings. Being higher than everyone else would provide a tactical advantage when spotting enemy troops from a distance.
Hills can be used tactically to avoid areas which are susceptible to flooding, but also locating near to water traditionally enabled a defensive barrier between rival tribes making it more difficult to penetrate a settlement.
Ascending up the areas highlighted below would significantly deplete energy resources over flatter terrain. Therefore, traditionally the more successful hill settlements embraced these conditions to make it more difficult to find and also attack.
Locating settlements or icons equally means that these locations can be seen more visibly by settlements lower down. Landmarks or beacons would be situated here to signal a high importance monument or party.
127 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 127
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES
+ DEFINE TOPOGRAPHY
DEFINE THE RULES
EVALUATE STRENGTHS / WEAKNESSES
AIMS AND OBJECTIVES The aim of this exercise will be to discover the rules that different topographies employ, when inhabiting a hilly or steep terrain. Some examples may employ a set of rules to address an intended purpose. This may include factors such as tactical attack and defense, climate considerations or simply finding the most suitable location to house the most amenities to prosper for the long term. These notions will then be cross examined to ascertain where these rules may be strong or weak in a different extreme environment.
128 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 128
CROSS EXAMINE RULES WITH OTHER TOPOGRAPHIES
ANCIENT PERGAMON URBAN RULES
MORE FUNCTIONS INCORPORATED Desirable site incorporates more uses. Key uses clearly ordered into differentiated districts - for example the barracks, palaces, cultural quarter, shops.
LANDMARKS AND ICONS Key diplomatic, religious and societal monuments were designed to be presented in the most desirable wy possible from the lower regions of the city.
ANCIENT PERGAMON Pergamum was an ancient Greek city in Aeolis, on the north side of the river Caicus (modern-day Bak覺r癟ay). The ancient city housed its cultural and religious landmarks at the highest, flattest peak of the city. It used its altitude to exhibit its exquisite monuments to bee seen from afar and justify its title as a cultural hub in Ancient Greece.
129 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 129
PERGAMON - SCRIPTING THE FLATNESS RULE
METHODOLOGY
X Y Z CREATE TOPOGRAPHY
DIVIDE SURFACE TO ACCURATELY EVALUATE ALL REGIONS
DECOMPOSE DATA TO EVALUATE FLATNESS
DEFINE DESIRED FLATNESS
DISTINGUISH FLAT ZONES
DEFINE SUITABLE HABITABLE REGIONS
PROCESS
DEFINED SURFACE Defined geometry mapped for specific topographical location.
DIVISION OF SURFACE Division of topographical surface to more accurately evaluate parameters
130 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 130
MAP TO SURFACE Find closest point on surface to evaluate
DECOMPOSE DATA Decomposing the surface into 3 dimensions enables critical evaluation of the Z-axis.
DEFINING FLATNESS Parametric controls enable a degree of flatness to be defined on the terrain.
CULL By cross-referencing the points higher than an inferred height with the total points gives the results at the higher altitudes.
PERGAMON - SCRIPTING THE FLATNESS RULE
1] TOPOGRAPHY DEFINED
2] ALL FLAT AREAS MAPPED
4] DESIRABLE SETTLEMENT AREAS MAPPED
DETERMINING AREAS
DEFINING FLATTEST TOPOGRAPHY FOR SETTLEMENT
FLAT AREAS DISTINGUISHED
FLATTEST
TOPOGRAPHICAL
The flattest topographical areas have been mapped here to determine suitable areas for overall vantage points, crop growth and village clustering. The blue demarcated zone shows potential flood risk parameters which, whilst this area may be flat, may be less desirable than locations in higher altitudes. The water zone (blue) was advantageous to the settlement of Pergamon due to its defensive strengths. This would have acted as a barrier to the site from rival tribes. The resource would have provided sustainable resources to make this settlement prosper for the long term.
3] FLAT AREAS DIFFERENTIATED
131 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 131
ANCIENT PERGAMON URBAN RULES
METHODOLOGY
X Y Z DECOMPOSE DATA TO EVALUATE STEEPNESS
DEFINE DESIRED FLATNESS
CULL INVALID REGIONS
PROCESS
Referencing FLATNESS rule Referencing the flatness rule shown previously enables more in depth analysis of habitable regions to determine more suitable flatter high points.
132 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 132
HEIGHT PARAMETER Parametrically decipher the correct location using the referenced data.
Sort data into ascending order Sorting the data found in the Z-axis allows for ease of selecting correct points. Used this as reference to define flatness.
DEFINE SUITABLE HABITABLE REGIONS
PERGAMON - DETERMINING HIGHEST AREA RULE
SUITABLE HIGH POINTS FOR LANDMARKS AND ICONS
PERGAMON LANDMARKS AND ICONS
OPTIMAL LOCATION FOR FLATTEST, SAFEST LOCATION FOR MULTIPLE USES
HIGHEST POINTS
MOST DESIRED HIGHEST POINTS
The highest points of the topographical surface have been mapped to show where the most effective vantage points and most noticeable points may be located when considering the contextual surroundings.
The flattest, highest points remain, making this area the most desired topographical area for settlement. FLATTEST, HIGHEST, SAFEST LOCATION
133 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 133
PETRA FIGURE GROUND PLAN
PETRA Petra is a unique city, carved into the arid, rocky mountainous region of Maâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;an in Jordan. Unlike the Norman settlers who exposed themselves to the hot elements just 170km away in Kerak, the settlers took the climate into close consideration. The trade routes were channeled by the steep cliffs that formed this dramatic topography. The settlers used the cliffs for inhabiting and for amenities such as the treasury.
134 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 134
Cliff inhabitation
Protection from climate
SETTLEMENTS FORMED ALONG Channeled trade routes
Religious usage
PETRA - SCRIPTING THE STEEPNESS RULE
METHODOLOGY
X Y Z CREATE TOPOGRAPHY
DIVIDE SURFACE TO ACCURATELY EVALUATE ALL REGIONS
DECOMPOSE DATA TO EVALUATE STEEPNESS
DEFINE DESIRED STEEPNESS
CULL INVALID REGIONS
DEFINE SUITABLE HABITABLE REGIONS
PROCESS
DEFINED SURFACE Defined geometry mapped for specific topographical location.
DIVISION OF SURFACE Division of topographical surface to more accurately evaluate parameters
DECOMPOSE SURFACE Decomposing the surface into 3 dimensions enables critical evaluation of the Z-axis.
EXAMINE DATA Check data points to establish points needed to cull / maintain. Used this as reference to define steepness.
CULL By cross-referencing the points higher than an inferred height with the total points gives the results at the higher altitudes.
135 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 135
PETRA CLIFF RULE
PETRAâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S TACTICAL CLIFF INHABITATION The mapped nodes depict cliff inhabitation forming. There are multiple reasons for utilising this type of topography that is often avoided. Firstly, the hot and dry climate would have made inhabiting open high areas difficult to live sustainably in this desert region of Jordan. Inhabiting the shaded cliffs would have therefore curbed this difficult condition. Tactically, this rock cut, man made route through such a steep vast terrain made it necessary for traders, invaders and religious parties to make use of. The route carved through the basin has inevitably been inhabited along it, to either attract sales for trade, maximize religious gathering numbers and provide key vantage and defensive points for attacking unwanted guests.
136 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 136
DEFENSIVE STRATEGY Carved route channeled unwanted parties into areas where they would be easy to ambush
VANTAGE POINTS High cliff regions enabled ease of attack below. Easy to predict opponents movements
ROUTE FORMED IN BASIN SETTLEMENTS FORMED ALONG PATH for commerce, religion and tactical reasons
KERAK CASTLE
VANTAGE POINTS Open location allows for maximized sight lines from all directions
URBAN ENVELOPE Settlement enclosed in perimeter wall to maximize security and defense from outside world.
CLIMATE ISSUES The hot climate was not as well considered as the defensive strategies
KERAK CASTLE Kerak Castle is a large crusader spur castle located in Kerak in Jordan. A spur castle is a type of medieval fortification that uses its location as a defensive feature. The crusaders who inhabited the castle of Kerak were motivated by the preservation of their influence and defense against rival parties; the high vantage points and urban envelope addressed these aims and intentions quite successfully. However, Jordan maintained a hot climate which would have made long term inhabitation for the Normans difficult.
137 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 137
KERAK CASTLE - SCRIPTING HIGH POINT RULE
HIGH POINT AND STEEPNESS RULE
METHODOLOGY
The intention here was to map the highest points to depict the most strategical advantageous vantage point in the settlement; in this case the rule was the ‘highest point’. The cluster in the first image below shows the highest points set by a small threshold domain. This is indeed the location of the Kerak Castle container settlement. This location would provide panoramic vistas from the most directions making the settlement secure, tactically. The steepness rule is then applied in conjunction to depict the topography which would be deemed difficult to climb. Set by a gradient parameter, the areas highlighted in green show steep banking features locally. This factor would exert more energy for the intruder as opposed to inhabiting the flatter ridge lines higher above. These would have been avoided by the enemy due to being quickly spotted from the castle. Defensively, the inclines surrounding Kerak Castle provide excellent defensive attributes for the inhabitants as a result.
DEFINE HIGH FLAT REGION
EVALUATE AND DEFINE STEEP ZONES
PROCESS
RULES DEFINED Height and steepness rules defined and culled
HIGHEST POINTS RULE
138 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 138
STEEP TOPOGRAPHY REGIONS ENABLES MORE PROTECTION FOR CONTAINER SETTLEMENT
KERAK - MAPPING ACCURATE CO ORDINATES FOR DATA METHODOLOGY
N째E째 GATHER OS COORDINATES
OS CORDINATES Data collected from OS coordinates
TREE DATA Data collected from OS coordinates extracted into different path networks
MAP CO ORDINATES
TOPOGRAPHY OS Data and VRML space data gathered to accurately plot world location
EXTRACT DATA TREES INTO ROAD TYPES
TOPOGRAPHY MESH Surface created using accurate OS and topographical satellite coordinates
MAP TO TOPOGRAPHY
ROUTES MAPPED Direct path networks mapped to topography to create accurate analysis of hill settlement
139 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 139
KERAK PATH NETWORKS
TOPOGRAPHY
WATER AMENITIES NEARBY
MAIN PATH NETWORKS FORMED FROM CASTLE / HIERARCHY
TERRITORY PATH NETWORKS FORMED FROM CASTLE EPICENTRE
PATH NETWORKS The diagram depicts how the primary and secondary path networks are notionally formed from the hierarchical epicentre of Kerak Castle. Here, generative path networks have spanned across the flat ridge line topographies to create the most direct path systems to other settlements. This method of generating path networks would conserve energy otherwise exerted from ascending steep topography, which has largely been categorically avoided. Tactically, inhabiting the high open roads would preserve vantage points from the castle from all directions and at an increased distance. The steeper topographies are largely uninhabited by settlements. Whilst the hot climate is a factor which can make inhabiting Jordan in the higher exposed altitudes difficult, the flatter terrain evidently becomes a more favourable attribute as opposed to building into hilly terrain. It has been utilised positively here to create a network which is closely arranged and conserves minimal energy.
140 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 140
KERAK CASTLE AT THE CENTRE OF ROUTES TO ALL DIRECTIONS
FLAT TERRAIN RULE FOR INHABITATION
SWAPPING THE RULES
EXTREME CLIMATE Exposure
INCREASED / DIFFICULT ROUTES
VANTAGE POINTS KERAK ‘HIGH FLAT POINTS’ RULE MAPPED TO PETRA
SWAPPING THE RULES AND TOPOGRAPHIES - ‘HIGH FLAT POINTS’ AND ‘LANDMARKS AND ICONS’ RULE IN PETRA As discussed earlier, the hilly settlements which adopt the rules have been chosen with a focused intention. Whether this is to be the highest settlement for defensive reasons, the flattest location to accompany most districts or functions in the most dense area or to adapt to an extreme climate by sheltering, all the case studies have shown effective use of the notional hill. However, the results become even more interesting when these acutely defined principles unique to a site are swapped with a contrasting topography. In the first instance, Petra has been mapped with the ‘highest points’ rule seen in Kerak and Pergamon. As seen before, the rule becomes successful on first glance at locating the potential threats from below. On the other hand, being located at the highest points is perhaps not as successful as the native origins of this rule. Firstly, Petra is a steeper, vertical gradient than Pergamon and Kerak. This could work for or against the settlement, depending on the intent. If the intent is to be spotted, such as in the case for the cultural buildings in Pergamon, the rule would not be as successful due to the extreme variation in height over area. If the intent were to be of a defensive nature such as the case would be in Kerak, adopting the highest point in Petra would have been advantageous to spotting the channeled tribes below or spotting the threat on the adjacent higher altitudes. This luxury would come at a cost however, due to increased energy consumed from ascending or descending the high altitudes, although this again would be a strength defensively.
141 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 141
SWAPPING THE RULES
Diversification of districts
Vulnerable from all directions TO ENEMY ATTACK
? PERGAMON FLAT POINTS RULE MAPPED TO PETRA
SWAPPING THE RULES AND TOPOGRAPHIES - ‘LOW FLAT POINTS’ RULE IN PETRA The ‘defined low flat points’ rule is then applied to Petra, a notion taken from Pergamon which considers maximum cumulative flat area to accommodate multiple districts. The results show inhabitation of the carved route as before, suggesting successful inhabitation of the route to channel trade, religion and enemy attack from one concentrated direction. However, the open meander previously left vastly open by previous descendants of Petra would be perhaps an unsuccessful location defensively. This is because the direction of enemy attack now becomes more unclear, where before the cliff inhabitation of the man made rock-cut route clearly channeled enemy combatants in a linear notion. Being located lower down at a crossroads would also leave the inhabitants incredibly vulnerable, with the advantage of being located at a higher altitude than their adversaries is gone. This would be due to the vantage points lost. Neither scenarios discussed here successfully consider the hot climatic implications in Jordan. The original steepness rule applied to Petra is the most triumphant at addressing this factor which was implementable to the development of this urban area long term. Therefore, this rule which was otherwise successful elsewhere would fail the civilisation would undertake these principles in this urban extreme environment.
142 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 142
DIFFICULT TO TRACK ENEMY MOVEMENTS
SUMMARY
SUMMARY From the case studies discussed, the motives behind all these settlements that inhabit the topographies have clearly defined rules to address a requirement to ultimately survive or sustain a long term establishment in an area. The ‘high point’ and ‘landmarks and icons’ rules for Pergamon showed successful results contextually. Utilising these notions at the high altitudes would enable the acropolis to exhibit its cultural status through portrayal of its landmarks. This would have been difficult to achieve if these beacons were less visible in a lower down region. Some settlements studied are more rounded than others. In Kerak for example the settlement is incredibly secure from enemy attack due to its raised elevation, steep topography surrounding it and contained fortification. However, Kerak is a hot climate which would have been difficult for the Norman settlers there who would have not been indigenous to this location. Left isolated, this hill fort settlement would have struggled to sustain itself long term without the path networks which subsequently formed to provide for this centre of hierarchy and decision making. Steep cliff topography is usually a solely defensive aspect instrumental to topographies. Hill settlements usually favour inhabitation of flat high points. However, Petra has exercised the steepness rule to meet hot climatic drawbacks in the desert region of Jordan. By carving out the rock to create linear route, the settlements forming along this would have benefited in terms of trade, religion and defensively to create a robust cliff settlement that could establish itself long term. When swapping these rules shown to be successful with each other, the results have shown to be quite drastic and surprisingly unsuccessful in places. The results demonstrate that the rules applied have been more carefully considered than by simple randomness or trial and error. The native regions of the rules have been applied to make the best use of an extreme aspect of a topography and these rules cannot be necessarily universally applied to another topography to achieve a similarly successful urban arrangement.
143 EMERGENT URBANISM_HILLS 143
Hillside Urban Landscapes Richard A F Arthur
Contents Introduction - Hillside, Urban Landscape Hillside Attractors
Traditional Hillside Attractors
Evolutionary Hillside Attractors Case Studies
Lincoln, Lincolnshire, England
Longsheng, Guangxi, China
Derinkuyu, Cappadocia, Turkey
Paro Taktsang, Paro District, Bhutan Hillside Urbanisation Rules Traversing the Landscape
To Move Across the Landscape
15o Path Gradient
30o Path Gradient Bibliography List of Illustrations
Introduction
Definition of ‘Hillside’ - The sloping side of a hill. Further to this definition Hillside Urbanism encompasses Hills, Mountains and Cliffs. A Hill is a naturally raised area of land, not as high or craggy as a mountain. Mountains are large natural elevations of the earth’s surface rising abruptly from the surrounding level. Cliff, steep rock face, especially at the edge of the sea or on mountain sides. This chapter will describe how it is possible for these regions of the earth’s landscape are able to urbanise. All urban growth has reasons to why the location was suitable, these reasons generally are in the form of a primary attractor and these can either be traditional or more recently evolutionary. Once an attractor has laid the foundations for growth to start clear rules and understanding mould the way each urban landscape will form. Through the use of case studies taken from different regions in the world each with different attractors, the rules and understanding can be extracted. These rules can then be further studied to aid new growth. Rules can be implemented through the entire lifespan of an urban landscape from the very beginning with the first structures emerging to the continuing growth, or eventual infilling and transformations of landscapes for other purposes. The end of this chapter begins to use some of these rules in a simulation for terrain traversing which is a fundamental aspect of a Hillside Urban Landscape.
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
147
Traditional Hillside Attractors
Monarchy Monarchs and people of importance tended to favour hill tops for residences. Primary reasons for this were, Defence and an Influence over the surroundings. With a structure of this importance came eventual and gradual urbanisation. left: Edinburgh Castle
Religion Historically it was believed that the higher you stood in a landscape the closer you were to heaven. For this reason hill tops were seen as the perfect locations for religious houses. In these cases the wealthier tended to settle around the point of interest and class spread out from this point. left: Lincoln Cathedral
Fortress In a hostile environment it was fundamental to have a raised position to be able to effectively see the surroundings and repel any potential attacks. Urban growth would be found near to such fortresses so that citizens my take shelter in times of need. left: Krak des Chevaliers
148 Hillside, Urban Landscapes
Evolutionary Hillside Attractors
Produce As populations continue to increase the need for produce (food / materials) also increases. This need generates a requirement for more cultivated land. With the creation of new produce landscapes there becomes a need for urban interventions. Right: Longsheng Rice Terraces
Energy With the growing energy requirement especially in the renewables sector a new attractor has be produced. These large installations are generally found on hillsides. The installation process requires heavy machinery and therefore there is a requirement for new infrastructure in an area that has been previously untouched allowing a new urban landscape to develop. Right: Scottish onshore wind farm
Leisure The leisure industry has played a large part in the development of newly emerging landscape. This development can primarily be seen within the ski industry where people require an unban landscape to survive while using the hillsides. Development can be found on the upper and lower slopes. Right: Ski Run in France
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
149
150
LINCOLN, Lincolnshire, England Lincoln is a Cathedral City and County Town of Lincolnshire, England. Lincoln developed from the Roman town of Lindum Colonia, which developed from an Iron Age settlement. Lincolnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s major attractors are Lincoln Cathedral and Lincoln Castle. The city is also has modern attractors in the form of the University of Lincoln and Bishop Grosseteste University.
Attractors on the topography
Path angle & width
Urban development
Growth from attractor
Avoiding topography
Growth along pathway
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
151
152
LONGSHENG, Guangxi, China The Longsheng Terraced Rice Fields are built along the Longsheng slopes from the riverside up to the mountain top, between 600m to 800m. The terraces divide the mountain into layers of water in spring, layers of green rice shoots in summer, layers of rice in fall, and layers of frost in winter. The terraced fields were mostly built about 650 years ago.
Attractors on the topography
Slope transformation
Urban development
Growth along pathway
Path of least resistance
Lines of sight
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
153
154
DERINKUYU, Cappadocia, Turkey Derinkuyu is notable for its large multi-level underground city (Derinkuyu Underground City), which is a major tourist attraction. The historical region of Cappadocia, where Derinkuyu is situated, contains several historical underground cities, carved out of a unique geological formations. The underground cities are not generally occupied but there has been urban development due to this attractor.
Attractors on the topography
Using natural landforms
Urban development
Growth from attractor
Growth along pathway
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
155
156
PARO TAKTSANG, Paro District, Bhutan Paro Taktsang Monastery is a prominent Himalayan Buddhist sacred site and temple complex, located in the cliff-side of the upper Paro valley, in Bhutan. The access to this site is by a winding mountain path which is slowly developing as the popularity of the temple grows as a tourist destination.
Attractors on the topography
Path of least resistance
Urban development
Growth along pathway
Using natural landforms
Path angle & width
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
157
Hillside Urbanisation Rules
Growth from Attractor As described earlier in this chapter there are different forms of attractor. These urban attractors generally become the epicentre of urban growth.
Growth Along Pathway Before or after an attractor has formed in an area a communication route will lead to and from the attraction. This route may begin as a pilgrims pathway which becomes a cart track for supplies or trade. Once the route is established it may progress to become a road so that a larger volume of traffic may flow along it. As a route becomes more of a resource it too becomes an attractor and reason for urban increase.
158 Hillside, Urban Landscapes
Using Natural Landforms In multiple regions of the world existing landforms are used as urbanisers. Through either natural means or human intervention a landscape can provide a suitable base for constructing. As described above the region of Cappadocia is famous for structures of this form, soft rock erodes and the hard volcanic rock remains. The settlers of the region used these formations as starting points for their urbanisation, which then spread deep underground. These settlements became attractors for future growth once the underground cities were no longer required.
Path of Least Resistance The shortest and most direct path route may not always be the most economical or viable in terms of cost, energy, time and intended use. Routes for different uses will have an optimal path. Linked to Path Angle and Width.
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
159
Path Angle & Width There is a direct correlation between the gradient of a path or route and its width. A pathway intended for pedestrian use can be wide enough for a single user and the gradient can be greater due to the size of the user, this pathway can be cheaper to construct / maintain and requires a low energy output. A route intended for large vehicles (horse & cart to cars & lorries) will require a route adapted to their needs. Width will be wider and the gradient angle will be less. This route way will have high construction / maintenance costs and a large energy requirement.
Avoiding Topography In most cases of hillside urbanisation there will be gradients that are not built on. The predominant reason for the is the excessive gradient of the slope. These areas if built on will usually be the last area of urban growth with the landscape requiring amendments to be made to create a suitable site for building on. One amendment would be slope transformation in the form of terracing.
160 Hillside, Urban Landscapes
Slope Transformation There are many ways of urbanising a slope and transforming a slope can allow greater diversity. This transformation could be used for both construction and industry. The most common form of slope transformation is Terracing. This transformation creates flat areas of land but retains the slope outline. Terracing is widely used for agriculture especially used in rice and grape growing. The flat steps also provide suitable building landscape without the need for expensive columns and deep foundations. Terracing a landscape helps to slow natural processes like erosion.
Lines of Sight Building on a hillside will generally come with a view. When constructing this view from a single location is not the only view point that needs to be taken in to consideration as others will have a similar view which should not be obstructed. This is where slope transformation can be implemented along with growth along pathways and avoiding topography.
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
161
Traversing the Landscape
To Move Across the Landscape From A to B
Start Location Point A Look ahead for shallowest path
Viewing Distance
Shallowest point becomes Point C
Chosen Multiplication
Look at Point C
Define Path Gradient
Define Move Distance
Movement boundary
Move to Point D
Positive points on boundary
Is Point D Point B?
Find closest point to C
Yes
Closest point becomes Point D
Move to Point B
No
Destination Point B
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
163
15o Path Gradient
164 Hillside, Urban Landscapes
30o Path Gradient
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
165
Conclusion
Chapter Conclusion This chapter has looked at primary reasoning as to why a â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Hillsideâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; can urbanise. From these primary reasons and through the use of case studies I have been able to extract some rules which are implemented and many are unique of a hillside environment. These rule can be simulated in any hillside environment to be able to produce the best urban development possible.
Personal Conclusion I have enjoyed undertaking this project. Through reading and studying I feel that I have furthered my understanding of urban development and processes. I have been able to formulate some urban rules and understand these rules in a logical fashion. The progression I was looking to take has been hindered by my personal understanding of computer programs to effectively simulate the extracted rules. If I was to undertake this project again I would do so once I had built a higher program knowledge to develop the rules and simulations.
166 Hillside, Urban Landscapes
Hillside, Urban Landscapes
167
168 Oasis Theory and Research
Oasis Theory and Research Sam Hayes Jan Harmens
Contents Analysis of Case studies - Dunhuang Oasis Location Context History - Huacachina Oasis Location Context History - Kabr Aun Oasis Location Context History - Bahariya Oasis Location Context History Dynamic Flow Exploration Application Analysis Conclusion Cellular Automata Exploration Application Analysis Conclusion Application to Huacachina Oasis Theory Development in Co-ordination with Case Studies Conclusion to Oasis Research with Calculated Spacial and Carrying Capacity Formulas Appendix
Oasis Theory and Research
169
What Is An Oasis?
‘A fertile spot in a desert, where water is found’ - Oxford Dictioinary An Oasis is an island of life in an ocean of temperature extremes.
170 Oasis Theory and Research
The Difference Between An Oasis And A Lake
An oasis typically has a small water source, fed from underground and rain but never from streams, tributaries or rivers. It can also ‘go dry’. Oasis areas are typically NOT man made.
Most lakes remain filled with water, except after/during a drought. Depending on environmental conditions, lakes can “go dry”. Lakes can be fed from underground or from streams, tributaries, and rivers. Some lakes came into being as a result of human planning.
Oasis Theory and Research
171
World Deserts Sahara Peruvian
Turkestan
Atacama Gobi
Australia Great Indian
Great Basin Patagonian
Arabian Kalahari & Namib
172 Oasis Theory and Research
Most World Renowned Oases Oasis of Maranhao (Brazil) Crescent Oasis (ะกhina) Oasis Herรฐubreiรฐarlindir (Iceland) Ubari Oasis (Libya) Oasis Gaberoun (Libya)
Oasis Turpan (China) Oasis Timi, Sahara Desert (Niger)
Oasis Huacachina (Peru)
Oasis Chebika (Tunisia)
Oasis Theory and Research
173
Global Landmass Overview
Oases are usually found in areas such as Deserts
2/3 of the earths surface is covered by water. Of the remaing 1/3, 1/3 of this is covered by Desert.
174 Oasis Theory and Research
What Is A Desert ?
< 250mm
A desert is defined as an area of less than 250mm of annual precipitation.
Oasis Theory and Research
175
How A Natural Oasis Forms ?
Aquifers supply most oases. These are created by water getting trapped above the bedrock and so being unable to drain away. In some cases, a natural spring brings the underground water to the surface.
The water rises until just below the surface before evaporating in the extremely hot desert conditions.
Strong winds / sand storms shift sand across the desert revealing these bodies of trapped water. 176 Oasis Theory and Research
Birds drink from these pools and excrete around the edge creating fertile ground full of undigested seeds.
The seeds grow creating vegetated space within the barren desert
The space becomes an epicentre of life with desert
Oasis Theory and Research
177
Oasis Civilisation Evolution If the area is big enough an oasis can support human life. This may begin as a marker or rest point on a trade route and gradually evolves into an inhabited area of human life.
Travellers Routes Though The Desert
Camel Herders
Trade routes open up and the flow of travellers increases 178 Oasis Theory and Research
Travellers begin to setup camps along routes
The Camps become more permanent settlements
The settlements develop into villages and later grow into towns Oasis Theory and Research
179
180 Oasis Theory and Research
Dunhuang Case Study Location Maps
Dunhuang
China
Dunhuang district Dunhuang
Dunhuang
Dunhuang Dunhuang Oasis
Dunhuang Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
181
Dunhuang Context
The Oasis has an area of approximately 0.0066 sq km and the surrounding inhabited area covers approximately 0.0677 sq km.
Early Buddhist monks arrived at Dunhuang via the ancient Northern Silk Road. A small population of monks still populate the space. However it is now a tourist destination for 1000â&#x20AC;&#x2122;s of sightseers a year.
182 Oasis Theory and Research
Fortification And Trade Of Dunhuang
Dunhuang became one of the Four Frontier garrison towns established by the Emperor Wu. Dunhuang played an important part in the Silk Road trade route.
Silk, lacquer-ware and porcelain were abundant in the east and much valued by the West. In turn, the Mongols and Chinese received large amounts of luxury goods from Europe.
Oasis Theory and Research
183
The Great Wall Of China Extended To Dunhuang
Dunhuang
China
The Great Wall Of China Line of fortified beacon towers stretched westwards into the desert
By the second century AD Dunhuang had a population of more than 76,000 and was a key supply base for caravans that passed through the city: those setting out for the arduous trek across the desert loaded up with water and food supplies, and others arriving from the west gratefully looked upon the mirage-like sight of Dunhuangâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s walls, which signified safety and comfort. 184 Oasis Theory and Research
Silk Road Trade Route Dunhuang Changâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;an
Russia Europe
China
Kashgar
The Great Wall Of China
Pamirs Merv Damascus
Roman Empire 13th Century, trading along the Silk Road peaked in the Mongol Empire allowing trade in the region to flourish. Oasis Theory and Research
185
Water Depths 1960’s
Maximum 7.5 m
Average 4-5 m
1990’s
Maximum 1.3 m Average 0.9 m
186 Oasis Theory and Research
2006
The local government intervened and began artificially filling the oasis to support the surrounding environment.
Fixed 1.5 m
Alternative 2015
Oasis Theory and Research
187
188 Oasis Theory and Research
Huacachina case study Location Maps
South America Peru Peru
Ica
Ica
Huacachina Oasis
Huacachina
Huacachina Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
189
Huacachina Context
The Oasis has an area of approximately 0.025 sq km and the surrounding inhabited area covers approximately 0.125 sq km.
The area has a permanent population of approximately 95 people.
190 Oasis Theory and Research
The Oasis became famous during the 1920-50â&#x20AC;&#x2122;s. Wealthy people from all over Peru came to soak in the waters of the oasis, which were considered to have medicinal properties.
200,000 tourists per year come to see the sights, soak in the oasis, sandboard, drive dune buggys and visit the wineries.
Oasis Theory and Research
191
Water Depth 1940’s-50’s
Maximum 11 m
Average 7-8 m
1990’s
Maximum 2.5 m Average 1.7 m
192 Oasis Theory and Research
2008
The local government intervened and began artificially filling the oasis to support the surrounding environment.
Fixed 2 m
Alternative 2015
Oasis Theory and Research
193
194 Oasis Theory and Research
Kabr Aun Oasis Case Study Location Maps
Libya
Awarbi Africa
Libya
Kabr Aun Settlement Kabr Aun Awarbi Awarbi Region
Kabr Aun Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
195
Kabr Aun Oasis Context
The Oasis has an area of approximately 0.90 sq km and the surrounding inhabited area covers approximately 0.09 sq km. 196 Oasis Theory and Research
The area had a permanent population of approximately 6000 people.
The Bedouin people lived off the land and the oasis for hundreds of years.
Oasis Theory and Research
197
They were moved in the 1980s to a settlement of concrete apartments outside the sand dunes in the Wadi Bashir. This was a government intervention to protect the oasis from the increasing Bedouin population.
198 Oasis Theory and Research
Land Use And Water Depth
Prior to resettlement the land surrounding the oasis had been used for agriculture to support the Bedouin population
Average 2.5 m
The average depth of the Kabr Aun Oasis has remained relatively constant
Oasis Theory and Research
199
200 Oasis Theory and Research
Bahariya Case Study Location Maps
The Nile Egypt Bawiti
Africa Egypt
Bawiti City
Bahariya
Bahariya Oasis Bawiti
Bahariya Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
201
Bahariya Context
The Oasis has an area of approximately 65.0 sq km and the surrounding inhabited area covers approximately 2.40 sq km.
The area had a permanent population of approximately 27000 people.
202 Oasis Theory and Research
A Greco-Roman necropolis known as the â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Valley of the Golden Mummiesâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; was discovered in 1995
In the last 100 years Carcharodontosaurus and Bahariasaurus dinosaurs have been found in Bahariya, which date to about 95 million years ago.
Oasis Theory and Research
203
Bahariya has always been predominantly an agricultural area however during its history the surrounding area was found to be rich in iron ore which has attracted many new settlers. The area is now know for its agriculture but also as a tourist destination due to the discovery of tombs and dinosaurs remains.
In the early 70â&#x20AC;&#x2122;s the asphalt road connecting Bahariya to Cairo was finished. With the new road came phone lines, electricity, cars, and a more accessible route to Cairo which has resulted in an increase in trade.
204 Oasis Theory and Research
Water Depth
Average 5 m
Average 11.5 m Average 22.5 m
The average depth of the Bahariya Oasis has remained relativly constant within its three troughs
Oasis Theory and Research
205
Civilisation Theories
That Apply to oasis civilizations
Oasis Theory Raphael Pumpelly
Proposed in 1908. Due to drought, both humans and animals converged close to oases. It was there that animals were first domesticated and seeds were planted.
206 Oasis Theory and Research
Demographic Theory
Carl Sauer
Proposed between 1889-1975. The increase in human population is hampered by the carrying capacity of the natural environment in supplying food.
Oasis Theory and Research
207
The immediate obvious starting place when trying to decipher spatial and carrying capacity rules was the water any specific oasis held. Priorities included the ability to break down and analysis hydrological cycles within extreme desert terrains. We investigated how limited amounts of water could be more effectively utilised and how pressure, water flow and underground strata affected the locations of oases. 208 Oasis Theory and Research
Oasis Theory and Research
209
Fluid Dynamics Fluid flow Initial precipitation source
Initial precipitation source
Resultant flow 210 Oasis Theory and Research
Initial precipitation source(s)
Resultant flow
Fluid Dynamics Fluid vector analysis
Zero precipitation source
Few precipitation source(s)
Several precipitation source(s)
Many precipitation source(s)
Oasis Theory and Research
211
Fluid Dynamics Terrain and Strata
Lofted terrain generation
Multiple layered strata
Setting levels of opacity to the strata layers
2 finished layers creating a unconformity within the terrain
212 Oasis Theory and Research
Fluid Dynamics Impermeable surfaces and hydrolgolical pressure
Identify surface for flow to originate
Produce a series of source points for flow to begin
Each line plots a water course based on terrain and pressure
When enough water is collected it forces its way upwards and when it reaches the desert surfaces forms a oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
213
Fluid Dynamics Oasis generation
Flow begins from source points with lowest pressure
The flow begins to react to the terrain
The flow had completely changed direction
The flow has saturated the space between layers
214 Oasis Theory and Research
The collection of water is forced upwards
The source has finally stopped and the oasis has begun to form
The water is continued to be forced upwards towards the desert surface
The flow has generated an Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
215
Fluid Dynamics Oasis force analysis
Identification of contours
Generation of reactive surface based on the contours
Random generation of source points each with an up thrust vector based on hydrological pressure
The water is forced to change course to eventually reach the surface
216 Oasis Theory and Research
The water is forced to a confluence point underground
The flow meets at a confluence where the pressure is at it highest
The water is continued to be forced upwards towards the desert surface
The flow has generated an Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
217
Fluid Dynamics Dunhuang case study Flow analysis
218 Oasis Theory and Research
Identification of contours
Generation of reactive surface based on the contours
Generation of interactive surface for flow dynamic study
The flow reacts to the terrain to highlight pressure areas and ultimately shows where the Oasis is formed
Oasis Theory and Research
219
Fluid Dynamics Huacachina case study Flow analysis
220 Oasis Theory and Research
Identification of contours
Generation of reactive surface based on the contours
Generation of interactive surface for flow dynamic study
The flow reacts to the terrain to highlight pressure areas and ultimately shows where the Oasis is formed
Oasis Theory and Research
221
Fluid Dynamics Kabr Aun Oasis case study Flow analysis
222 Oasis Theory and Research
Identification of contours
Generation of reactive surface based on the contours
Generation of interactive surface for flow dynamic study
The flow reacts to the terrain to highlight pressure areas and ultimately shows where the Oasis is formed
Oasis Theory and Research
223
Fluid Dynamics Bahariya case study Flow analysis
224 Oasis Theory and Research
Identification of contours
Generation of reactive surface based on the contours
Generation of interactive surface for flow dynamic study
The flow reacts to the terrain to highlight pressure areas and ultimately shows where the Oasis is formed
These case studies prove that the computational study we have performed correctly approximates the location and scale of any given Oasis. Oasis Theory and Research
225
After defining relationships between energy cycles and oasis formations. The micro-ecosystem that develops became the next investigated strategy. We developed and applied a cellular based digital system that approximates a biological agent to obtain behaviour, growth and development characteristics. This enabled us to progress onto the final strategy after resources and time. Space. We plotted and identified trends to generate a digital tool to produce a more efficiently and holistically sustainable Oasis environment.
226 Oasis Theory and Research
Oasis Theory and Research
227
Cellular Automata Cellular based system
Stage 1 Object: To progress from A to B
Stage 2 the automata has influenced each neighbours cell.
Stage 3 the cellular pattern progresses one step closer to B
Stage 4 the cellular pattern has reached B in 4 stages. It has effected 24 cells.
228 Oasis Theory and Research
Inactive cell
Dead cell
Alive cell
Active cell
Cellular Automata Agent based system
Stage 1 Object: To progress from A to B
Stage 2 the agent based system can react to any cell and calculates a minimum pathway
Stage 3 the agent based system progresses towards B with the option to influence any cell, not just its neighbouring cells
Stage 4 the agent based system has reached B in 4 stages. It has only effected 4 cells
Inactive cell
Dead cell
Alive cell
Active cell
Oasis Theory and Research
229
Cellular Automata Grid definition
230 Oasis Theory and Research
Square grid (1 node has 4 neighbours)
Triangular grid (1 node has 3 neighbours)
Rectilinear grid (1 node has 4 neighbours)
Hexagonal grid (1 node has 6 neighbours)
Cellular Automata Neighbour interaction
Square grid (1 node has 4 neighbours)
Triangular grid (1 node has 3 neighbours)
Rectilinear grid (1 node has 4 neighbours)
Hexagonal grid (1 node has 6 neighbours)
Oasis Theory and Research
231
Cellular Automata Iterative patterns
Square grid (Completed coloured iterative pattern)
Triangular grid (Completed coloured iterative pattern)
Rectilinear grid (Completed coloured iterative pattern)
Hexagonal grid (Completed coloured iterative pattern)
232 Oasis Theory and Research
Cellular Automata Random true/false sampling
Hexagonal grid (10% true ratio for random seed 1)
Hexagonal grid (10% true ratio for random seed 2)
Hexagonal grid (10% true ratio for random seed 3)
Hexagonal grid (10% true ratio for random seed 4)
Oasis Theory and Research
233
Cellular Automata Generation rules Generation rule 1 - 8
Resultant generation patterns
234 Oasis Theory and Research
Cellular Automata Live/Die rules and generation patterns
Version 1 (Born if false, Die if true)
Version 3 (Born if false, Die if you have more than 1 neighbour)
Version 2 (Never born, Die if you do not have a neighbour)
Version 4 (Born if you have neighbours, Die if you have 2 neighbours)
Oasis Theory and Research
235
Cellular Automata Generative predefined patterns
Orange pattern (Serpinskies triangles)
236 Oasis Theory and Research
Grey pattern (Accumulative pattern)
Cellular Automata Infinite oscillating patterns
Square pattern (Infinite block)
Triangular pattern (Infinite flower)
Rectilinear pattern (Stretched infinite block)
Hexagonal pattern (Infinite beehive)
Oasis Theory and Research
237
Cellular Automata Multiple rules combinations
Vegetation (Born if you have neighbours Cannot die)
238 Oasis Theory and Research
Generic insect experiment (Born if you have 0, equal or more oasis neighbours than competition. neighbours must die in you have neighbours)
Combined experiment (Both values of vegetation and insects are given a value of 2 if both true. If only one is true they receive a value of 1. If none are true the value is 0)
Cellular Automata Function vs analysis
Pattern 1 Multiple random source points. Purely additive process
Pattern 2 Similar to pattern 1 just with an added death mechanic
Pattern 3 Deliberately positioned source points based around a resource. Has both life and death mechanics
Oasis Theory and Research
239
Cellular Automata Huacachina case study analysis
240 Oasis Theory and Research
T1 shows a series of sporadic source points
T2 shows some growth completely encompassing the perimeter of the Oasis Oasis Theory and Research
241
Cellular Automata Huarcachina case study analysis
T3 shows a large body of cells active clustered around the source
T4 shows how a large percentage of the cells active from the previous stage have since died. The input equation applies the effect to assimilate competition between biological agents 242 Oasis Theory and Research
T5 shows a large number of newly living cells due to the significant cull that occurred during the previous timeframe.
T6 shows a large â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;swarmâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; like body of active cells. They show distinct approximation to the water source and are influenced by maximum number (carrying capacity), competition (quantity of neighbours), terrain (distance to the water source) and age (chance of survival) Oasis Theory and Research
243
Cellular Automata Limiting factors within the computational process of the Cellular Automata
1
3
2
244 Oasis Theory and Research
5 4
Irrespective External factors 1. Once the input parameters have been computationally derived and the Cellular process has begun. No external factors can react to active or inactive cells and impact the resultant cellular definition. Like like cell definitions 2. Each inactive cell that has yet not been reached but could be activated may have external influences from external source that are treated as irrelevant. These as the cellular geometry progresses could and should influence the pattern but don’t. Predefining boundaries 3. Before the computational process is allowed to begin there are forced limits on the maximum gird size and the maximum boundary. These eventually provide/manipulate the eventual outcome as they limit its tendency to spread ‘organically’. Variable inputs 4. Once the computational process has begun, the input resource factors cannot be changed without completed restarting/ altering the cellular outcome. For example. An Oasis in summer will have a lower volume due to increased evaporation rates. The cellular automata works by defining a relationship over time, and yet the inputs cannot change across the span. Grid attenuation 5. Regardless of the shape or size of the input resource, the grid that provides the framework for the ‘organic’ growth is limited to orthogonal grids patterns. This leads to a Significant inaccuracy based on the orthogonal attenuation for space when meeting a curve. The inaccuracy is further extrapolated by using multiple scales.
Oasis Theory and Research
245
Why The Collected Data Can Be Compared
Desert is a title for the environmental conditions of an area thus stating that the environmental conditions these oases exist in are all similar.
41 oC
< 250 mm -18 oC Extreme temperature changes
Precipitation is Less Than Evaporation
Less Than 250 mm Precipitation per annum
The Researched case studies all exist within deserts.
This allows us to cross reference the data and form an average of life supported per body of water.
246 Oasis Theory and Research
Basin Area Of The Oases
= 77 000 m2
Bahariya Oasis
Kabr Aun Oasis
Huacachina Oasis
Dunhuang Oasis
Oasis Theory and Research
247
Use Of Space
2 400 000 m2 4%
Bahariya Oasis
28 000 000 m2 43 %
Population of 27000 people 2 800 000 m2 4% Kabr Aun Oasis
88 000 m2 10 %
425 000 m2 47 %
34 000 m2 4% 248 Oasis Theory and Research
Population of 6000 people
17 500 m2 16 %
Huacachina Oasis
36 000 m2 32 % 41 000 m2 37 % Population of 95 people 6100 m2 8% Dunhuang Oasis
8900 m2 12 %
2800 m2 4%
Population of 10 monks
Oasis Theory and Research
249
Life Supported By 1m3 Of Water Per Case Study
0.003 People
2.7 m2 of Vegetation
0.080 People
5.8 m2 of Vegetation
0.008 People
1.6 m2 of Vegetation
0.030 People
2.9 m2 of Vegetation
1 m3
250 Oasis Theory and Research
Average Oasis Life Supported By 1 m3 Of Water Huacachina and Duhuang Oases information has been removed from further calculations due to anthropogenic tourism factors
0.042 People
4.25 m2 of Vegetation
This formula can be applied to any body of water in a desert environment to estimate the quantity of life that it can support (in terms of vegetation and people). The aim of this is to assess its carrying capacity allowing for oases to be used more efficiently and so reduce the effect of the demographic theory. Oasis Theory and Research
251
Life supported by finite quantities of water
Area x Depth / 3 = Volume of water
/2
Water = Population + Population in terms of Vegetation
From our research we have deduced an equation that with an input of ‘w’ volume of water (the volume of water in an oasis) an oasis can support ‘p’ number of people which need ‘b’ amount of area to live and ‘v’ amount of vegetation to live off. 252 Oasis Theory and Research
Generic Oasis A case study
165m2
Plan
123.75m2 Total water volume = 240m3 Average water depth = 2m Area = 160m2
165m2 123.75m2
Isometric
Total water volume = 240m3 Average water depth = 2m Area = 160m2 Built Up Area Vegetation Area Water Area Oasis Theory and Research
253
Appendix
254 Oasis Theory and Research
Oasis Theory and Research
255
Urbanism Conclusion
Sam Hayes and Jan Harmens
We thoroughly enjoyed the Urbanism project. It challenged us to look at a site in a very informative way. The brief was to analysis and evaluate a micro ecosystems for human requirements without a human perspective. Gathering initial information and following a logical process to determine an in-depth logistical and characteristic build up of site specific constraints. The micro ecosystem we were given was Oasis. We previously knew very little about these climates but were extremely keen to delve into their location generation, lifespan, uses and extremely niche site specific situations. We split the workload up and created a plan to analysis the research. There was a steep learning curve as we each presented and taught each other the relevant information we had learnt on a weekly basis. This was an extremely productive method as it allowed us to digest small sections of information with ease. This process passively questioned the progression of information. This investigation into the thought process that led from stage to stage allowed us to cover a huge range of information with relative ease. This process to segment the work allowed for those not covering that specific topic to critique each other without bias. This self editing system worked well and created a sophisticated and more holistic piece of group work that we had equally contributed too.
256 Oasis Theory and Research
Each individual withdrew a set of rules from the initial research then investigated a computational process to impliment and define these rules in a urban strategy that could be analysed. In order to consolidate the accuracy of the systems we had developed we chose a series of case studies. We then referenced the systems against the real case studies to determine the validity. Pros and cons of systems could be easily determined and as we had used parametric software that could easily redefine the rules. These rules underwent a series if developments which allowed for a more accurate urban strategy to be formed. The result of our research concluding in a mathematical formula that can help analyse and more sustainably use a finite amount of resources. Although it provides some level of accuracy there are inevitable inaccuracies within the informational process itself.
Sam’s Reflection
Jan’s Reflection
The project was split into several small group, pairs, which I feel worked really well. The smaller the group the easier it was to distribute workloads and create comprehensive pieces of concise well informed work. Each smaller group was then asked to contribute thier work to an overall book and there was a significant number of problems ranging from; conversion of works from multiple operating systems, multiple layouts, file compatibility hardware issues with different versions of similar software. There was a plan to collectively create a base format but as such a diverse range of formats where generated a final issue was never produced. This resulted in multiple groups reformatting and or adapting work. If this process was to be repeated I would like to see enforced deadlines with repercussions at interim stages to regiment the completed output.
Following on from Sam’s I agree with his points though feel that the quantity and quality of work should have been better regulated as the number of pages each group submitted differed significantly initially. Compatibility issues affected all groups. For example; different versions of InDesign changed text and also working between Mac and PC contributed further complications when compiling different groups chapters. Decisions upon the final output I believe should have been more demographic and once one part was decided upon should have been fixed. Considering these issues I am still very pleased with the final output and believe the output, book, successfully represents our portfolio for this project.
Oasis Theory and Research
257