GOVERNMENT/POLITICS A4 | OUR COLUMNISTS A6-7 | BUSINESS A13
A great community newspaper.
powell
VOL. 50, NO. 14
APRIL 4, 2011
INSIDE www.ShopperNewsNow.com
|
www.facebook.com/ShopperNewsNow
|
twitter.com/shoppernewsnow
Lights, camera, read! By Ruth White The kindergarten classes at Brickey-McCloud Elementary presented “Alphabet Rescue” adapted from the book by Audrey and Bruce Wood. Students sang snappy tunes and used props to tell a tale of the biggest rescue in town. The show is an opportunity for the kindergarten parents to see the progress of their children and for the students to apply skills learned in the classroom.
Big mama Sitting on eggs at the Collier place See Dr. Bob Collier’s column on page A-7
A bargain at twice the price Bean says outsourcing school custodians is a really bad idea. See column on page A-4
FEATURED COLUMNIST LARRY VAN GUILDER
Emma Franklin, Alex Cristelous and Weston Wright portray real life heroes during the opening song, “Hero” by Mariah Carey. Other musical numbers performed by the students included “Bye, Bye, Bye,” “Celebrate,” “Ring of Fire” and “Another One Bites the Dust.”
Brickey McCloud kindergarten students Regan Rhyne and Ayden Adams clean the old fire engine at the car wash during the performance of Alphabet Rescue.
Camryn Nichols gets a big sponge ready to wash cars during the song “Car Wash” at Brickey-McCloud. The kindergarten students performed “Alphabet Rescue” as principal Robbie Norman read the children’s book by Audrey and Bruce Wood.
Photos by Ruth White
Calling 1-900WHO-KNEW The Shopper’s own ‘Mr. Hotline’ answers some pesky questions about your county government. See page A-4
ONLINE
Old school trumps ‘new urbanism’ Southwest elementary recycles Gibbs By Larry Van Guilder Northshore Town Center was conceived as a compact urban neighborhood combining residential and retail establishments that featured innovative architecture.
Analysis
DO YOU
LIKE? TELL US! The Shopper-News is now on Facebook! Check us out for updates, photos and more! www.facebook.com/ ShopperNewsNow
4509 Doris Circle 37918 (865) 922-4136 news@ShopperNewsNow.com ads@ShopperNewsNow.com EDITOR Larry Van Guilder lvgknox@mindspring.com ADVERTISING SALES Patty Fecco fecco@ShopperNewsNow.com Darlene Hutchison hutchisond@ ShopperNewsNow.com Shopper-News is a member of KNS Media Group, published weekly at 4509 Doris Circle, Knoxville, TN, and distributed to 8,314 homes in Powell.
But the design for a new elementary school, which will become a prominent feature of the development when the school is completed in August 2013, reflects old ideas based on cheap land and outdated acceptance of urban sprawl. The new school’s footprint mimics Gibbs Elementary School. With the exception of its capacity for 200 more students, “It’s exactly like Gibbs,” said Knox County Purchasing Director Hugh Holt. Gibbs Elementary, completed in mid-2000, is a fine facility. But its onestory footprint, suitable where land is plentiful, is out of place in Northshore Town Center. How this “old school” school came to be slated for a neighborhood conceived as a step toward “new urbanism” is a story in itself. Before Cope Associates was selected as the architect for the project and awarded the $542,000 fee, the Knox County Schools system had never used a design competition to select an architect. And although Lanis Cope recently told the Shopper-News that the county wanted to “re-use … (something)
401(k) Rollovers Made Easy Toby Strickland Financial Advisor
7047 Maynardville Hwy. Knoxville, TN 37918
www.edwardjones.com Member SIPC
Gibbs Elementary School served to furnish the design template for the new southwest elementary school. Photo by Ruth White already designed,” the solicitation for proposals issued by county purchasing disagrees. In an addendum to the solicitation, Deputy Director of Purchasing Matt Myers wrote: “All designs will be considered. The intent of the competition is to allow consideration of all facilities, including those that have been previously designed and constructed, not to establish a prototypical design.” Cope’s firm designed Gibbs Elementary School, granting Cope a clear advantage over competitors starting from scratch with the costly design phase. Although there is no indication that the evaluation and selection process was biased (the designs were evaluated “blind,” with nothing to identify the submitter), some bidders were not satisfied. One local architect, who asked to remain anonymous, was scathingly critical of the process: “Knox County public schools,
RIGGS Drug can now meet your compounding needs!
MAKING SENSE OF INVESTING
Party
Enjoy swimming, rock climbing, basketball and more!
602 E. Emory Road next to Mayo’s 9 am-7 pm, Mon.-Fri., 9 am-2 pm Sat.
handbook adds that “a well-organized design competition, with selection based on ideas rather than past portfolio,” gives the designer an opportunity to “acquire expertise in a new market or building type.” The original ideas in the winning design are notable only for their absence. The usual suspect, money, is driving the school system’s bus. Replicating Gibbs is the economyminded choice, and a school system already faced with deteriorating buildings around the county can hardly be blamed for its decision. The school as designed is a poor choice architecturally and conceptually for the “new urbanite” Northshore Town Center. For a 2 cent property tax hike, the county could generate more than enough for the school system to pay for a building whose design would reflect something other than “the more things change, the more they stay the same.”
the night away with us!
We are pleased to announce Vance Griffin R.Ph, a nationally certified compounding specialist, has joined our staff! Please stop by and see how we can help you today!
947-5235
865-922-5575
meaning the buildings themselves, are remarkable for their mediocrity. I challenge you to find more than one or two built since 1950 which embody architectural merit. The recent ‘competition’ was simply lip service, the anonymous-submission drawings comprising but two ledger-size sheets, in conjunction with the usual non-anonymous boiler plate. A design competition normally involves original work, which then informs the project design developed by the winner.” The American Institute of Architects (AIA) publishes a handbook, “Architectural Design Competitions,” which is comprehensive in scope, beginning with “appropriate conditions” for a competition and ending with “post-competition activities.” According to the AIA, one of the advantages of design competition is to “generate a wide range of new ideas in the approach to a design.” Ironically, the design competition
An Independent Family-Owned Pharmacy
Reserve your lock-in now!
859-7900
mercy.com