Introduction
Ilaria Regondi Deputy Trade Commissioner – Europe and Director of France - Trade
OFFICIAL SENSITIVE OFFICIAL SENSITIVE
Opening Remarks
Dame Menna Rawlings
His Majesty’s Ambassador to France Laurent Germain Egis CEO
Energy and Climate Policies
McDonough, Director General Net Zero and International, Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS)
Michel, Director General for Energy and Climate, Ministry for Energy Transition (MTE)
Moderator: Dame Menna Rawlings, His Majesty’s Ambassador to France
Lee
Laurent
Hubert Kieken Group Climate Director, EGIS
New Build
Tilly Spencer, Director Edvance UK, EDF
Marc Duret, Director Sales & Business Development, Framatome
Francesco Granieri, Director of Operations Nuclear – EPR, Egis
Sarah Williamson, Sizewell C Civil Programme Director, Laing O’Rourke
Julien Malezieux, Commercial Director – Energy, Assystem
Moderator: Anne Falchi, Head of Strategy, Nuclear New Build, EDF
Paris
UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum
Tilly Spencer Director, Edvance UK
7 November 2022
HPC’s two units represent Units 5 and 6 in the EPR series;
SZC will be Units 7 and 8 and an exact replica
– a true Second of a Kind
Final design of UK EPR
• The design work to comply with the UK’s own, unique, regulatory requirements has been completed
Qualified supply chain
• Equipment and technology has been designed and qualified
Construction replication benefit
• HPC has learned from experience of constructing Unit 1, and is driving improvements for Unit 2
• SZC will benefit through further replication into Units 3 and Unit 4
Systems, data and processes
• HPC is developing systems and data – a “Digital Twin”, to be reused by SZC
• HPC learning is embedded in its processes
Skills and capabilities
• Technical client – construction and operation
• Design, construction and commissioning
8
→
HPC has made significant progress, despite a challenging external environment
Key highlights:
• Significant progress has been made on Civils, with the project now moving into the MEH phase to install equipment and miles of pipes and cables.
• Unit 1 is now 17m taller, following the lift of Liner Ring 2 in March
• The Unit 1 Dome is complete
• All marine tunnelling is complete
• Equipment is arriving now, certified and ready to be installed, including the world’s largest turbine
• Good progress has been made manufacturing NSSS Equipment; with the RPV on track to be delivered by the end of the year
• The Simulator Building is now open, and is training future Reactor operators
→Mar-22: Unit 1 Liner Ring 2 lifted into place
Apr-22: Simulator building handed over to Pre operations
• The final and most detailed version of the design (Consistent State 2) is almost complete
• Unit 2 is benefitting from the learnings of Unit 1 construction, experiencing 20-30% efficiencies
• Installation of all 6 marine heads complete, with the heaviest tandem lift in a marine environment
Mar-22: The final tunnel (Intake Tunnel 2) completed Aug-22: Marine Installation of all 6 heads
9
→
Sarah Williamson, SizewellC Civil Program Director
10
Bringing construction costs down
Marc Duret, Director Sales & Business Development
UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum, British Embassy, Paris, 7 November 2022
Framatome at a glance
Bringing construction costs down - UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum 7 November 2022 © Framatome All rights reserved
over 60 years, Framatome's teams have been involved in developing safe, competitive, clean, low-carbon nuclear energy worldwide by:
designing nuclear power plants,
supplying nuclear steam supply systems,
designing and manufacturing components and fuel assemblies,
integrating automation systems,
and servicing all types of nuclear reactors. Framatome is the original equipment manufacturer of: 92 nuclear power plants 10,000 components for 100 plants in 11 countries 230,000 fuel assemblies in more than 125 reactors 380 reactors served worldwide €3.4 billion revenue in 2021 12
For
•
•
•
•
•
Reactor construction and new power plant commissioning
Management of large projects
• Design, procurement, supply, and commissioning for new-build nuclear reactors
• Edvance: a joint EDF and Framatome engineering subsidiary dedicated to new-build reactor projects
New build projects 3
Olkiluoto 3 in Finland, Flamanville 3 in France, and Hinkley Point C in the United Kingdom.
-
7 November 2022 © Framatome All rights reserved
Bringing construction costs down
UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum
13
Framatome current contributions to the UK nuclear sector
Bringing construction costs down - UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum 7 November 2022 © Framatome All rights reserved
activities
Support EDF Energy for development of Sizewell C project : primary loop,
fuel, services
EDF Energy
Partner
Edvance
liquid waste mixing studies and solution engineering
Berkley waste canister depressurisation by water jets
Point C : Pool Liner project MCR Project HXA Tanks project 14 6 Framatome locations in the UK
Long term partnership with EDF Energy for maintenance
for Sizewell B and LTO Long term partnership with EDF Energy for fuel supply for Sizewell B
I&C,
Engineering Services to
Nuclear Generation in Barnwood EPR JDO Engineering
to
UK in Bristol, AZW Sellafield
Magnox
Hinkley
delivery
units
Hinkley Point C :
of primary loop and safety I&C for two EPR
Hinkley Point C : supply of fuel first cores for the two EPR units and long term fuel reloads
Long term service agreement with NNB HPC for maintenance activities
Thank You
→Julien Malezieux, Commercial Director, Energy, Assystem
16
Our 13% Energy 10% Industries & Complex Buildings
business. 10% Transportation
Assystem in an engineering company specialized in energy transition area and nuclear energy for all the lifecycle management.
9% Defence (including 7% of Nuclear Defense)
Turnover from the 2020 financial report and restated without the Life Sciences business (6%) which was sold on 1 January 2022
€500m revenue More than 600 Employees in Assystem UK 17
More than 6,000 employees
Assystem is an enabler of energy and digital revolutions. Turnover by sector 59% Nuclear
Assystem in UK Key figures.
Over the last 50 years, Assystem UK has built an impressive track record of successful projects for major operators within the Nuclear industry such as Sellafield Ltd, Rolls-Royce and EDF, gaining comprehensive knowledge and appreciation of all nuclear facilities in the UK.
HVAC,
CLIENT PROXIMITY
Westlakes: Sellafield
Derby: Rolls Royce Sunderland: ITER, O&G Bristol: EDF, HMNB Devonport & ANI Blackburn: Assystem HQ, EDF Energy, Sellafield
Glasgow: MOD Faslane Birchwood: Sellafield
Gloucester: EDF Barnwood, UKAEA, AWE London: CRA HQ
56% of
5 years’ service, • 43% have more than 10 years’ nuclear experience • Expertise in remote handling, stress engineering, non-contact surface metrology and industry 4.0 expertise (BIM, digital asset engineering, etc.) £65m* Revenues 600+ Multi-skilled energy and infrastructure specialists 10 sites Based in the UK whilst serving clients around the world *Figures as of 2020 inclusive of CRA 9 UK OFFICES WITH CLOSE
• More than 50 years of expertise • 500+ experts including civil, design, mechanical, EC&I,
Safety engineers, R&D and digital specialists •
our staff have more than
18
Nuclear New Build
Our main customers around the world.
Our 4,000 nuclear experts are actively involved nuclear energy projects around the world, supporting projects in France, the UK, Turkey, Finland, Saudi Arabia and India.
The wide range of locations and clients around the world enables us to handle all types of new programmes, regardless of their nuclear technology:
19
VVER FUSION
EPR / EPR 2
SMR/AMR Generation 4 PWR all power
Nuclear New Build Our ongoing projects 20 FA3 (FLAMANVILLE 3) EPR HPC (HINKLEY POINT C) EPR OL3 (OLKILUOTO 3) EPR AKKUYU VVE R JNPP (JAITAPUR) EPR BARAKAH APR 1400 ITER Fusion EPR 2 EPR 2 SZC (SIZEWELL C) EPR NUWARD SMR SAUDI ARABIA To be defined SMR UK SMR NAAREA SMR EL DABAA VVE R HANHIKIVI VVR
→Francesco Granieri, Director of Operation,
EGIS
Turnover Engineering breakdown Transport Sustainable cities Water and Energy 44 % 26 % 9 % €1.16 bn 16,200 EMPLOYEES IN THE WORLD TURNOVER 79% Consulting & engineering 21% Operation & mobility services 62% Consulting & engineering 38% Operation & mobility services 43 URBAN PARKING LOTS IN FRANCE 17 AIRPORTS 28 ROAD OPERATING COMPANIES 62% international 1st IN FRANCE 10th IN EUROPE ENR 22nd ENGINEERING NEWS RECORD GLOBAL RANKING EGIS AT A GLANCE
EGIS UK France Civil Nuclear Forum | 7 November 2022 OUR COMMITMENT TO THE UNITED KINGDOM 2021 €64M 2026 €140M 2nd Egis country, after France Our growth ambition both organic and external +645 employees 13 Legal entities 7 offices 3 new bolt-on acquisitions in 2021 & 2022 – rail, energy, buildings Transportation 60% 2021 turnover Energy 36% 2021 turnover Buildings 4% 2021 turnover including 49% road O&M
70+ YEARS EXPERIENCE
NUCLEAR NEW-BUILD
1945 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2020 2010 ZOE 1st French atomic reactor THIANGE (Belgium) 1st Belgian pressurized water reactor FESSENHEIM (France) 1st French pressurized water reactor KOEBERG (South Africa) DAYA BAY (China) 1st Chinese nuclear power plant ULJIN (South Korea) LA HAGUE (France) recycling and reprocessing plant CADARACHE France) research and test reactors Réacteur d’essais Jules Horowitz 3rd generation reactors EPR Olkiluoto
EPR Flamanville
EPR Taishan
ITER fusion experimental reactor (France) EPR Hinkley
C
ASTRID 4th generation test reactor EPR NM / EPR2
SMR Nuward (France) EPR Sizewell C
Taishan – China –2007 ITER – France2010 Hinkley Point –UK - 2014 EPR 2 – France2020 Fessenheim – France –1971 58 french reactors – 70’s-90’s Koeberg – South Africa –1978 Uljin – South Korea –1982 Daya Bay - China – 1986 Flamanville – France - 2006 Olkiluoto – Finland2005 La Hague – France – 90’s NUWARD– France - 2020
EGIS,
IN
ENGINEERING
(Finland)
(France)
(China)
Point
(UK)
(France)
(UK)
EGIS UK France Civil Nuclear Forum | 7 November 2022 Growing EGIS NNB activities A MULTIDISCIPLINARY APPROACH Nuclear safety, Licensing Multicriteria analysis Digital services Environmental impact Reduction of carbon footprint Stakeholder engagement Local integration and acceptability Oceanography Flood risk Maritime works Dykes and hydraulic works Soil remediation Decommissioning Dismantling Tunneling Underground works Instrumentation Geotechnics Seismology Lightning protection Nuclear security Industrial security PROJECT MANAGEMENT Civil and structural design Electrical, mechanical, HVAC Waste management Construction supervision and commissioning Health Security Environment Quality
Egis Footprint on Nuclear Markets
EGIS NUCLEAR IN FRANCE AND UK
EGIS UK France Civil Nuclear Forum | 7 November 2022
EGIS UK France Civil Nuclear Forum | 7 November 2022 NNB Performance boosters
INNOVATION PROJECT INNO NUCLEAR -SPECIFIC GROUP INNO APPLIED TO NUCLEAR TRAINING - eLEARNING INNOVATION
→Appendix
28
Hinkley Point C in context
• Twin 1650 MWe EPR.
• Numbers 5 and 6 in EPR series:
• #1 Olkiluoto 3 (Finland)
• #2 Flamanville 3 (France)
• # 3 & 4 Taishan 1 & 2 (China)
• # 5 & 6 Hinkley Point C (United Kingdom)
• # 7 & 8 Sizewell C (tbc) (United Kingdom)
• Located in Somerset.
• Fully funded by shareholders.
• Fully backed by the UK Government CfD (contract for difference) at £92.50 MWh for 35 years.
• Construction risk is held by the owners.
• HPC is a single purpose company responsible for construction, commissioning and operation.
A decade in development, a decade in construction and 6 decades of operation, followed by a decade of decommissioning … … in total spanning near to a century
The UK EPRTM Hinkley Point C
years (+ extensions)
→
29
Type 4 Loop PWR Thermal Power 4500 MW Electrical Power 1650 MW (37% efficiency) Fuel Uranium oxide (up to 5% enrichment) Operating temperature 297°C Tcold 312°C Tav 327°C Thot Operating pressure 155 bar (primary) 78 bar
Coolant pumps 4x 10kV, 8.7MW, 28,500m³/hr Availability
(SG)
91% 14 days refuelling outage Service life 60
→ HPC’s supply chain 30 Tier type: 1 2
UK-France Collaborative Engagement and Skills
Tom Greatrex, Chief Executive, Nuclear IndustryAssociation (NIA)
Nathalie Allimann, Chair GIFEN International and Export Commission
Corhyn Parr, CEO of Nuclear Waste Services / Chair of Nuclear Skills Strategy Group (NSSG)
Laure Prevot, Project Manager, Radioactive Waste Management Product Line Manager, EGIS
Moderator: Pierre-Yves Cordier, Nuclear advisor, French Embassy in London
French Nuclear Industry Association
The french nuclear industry
a dynamic, sustainable and low-carbon industry
• 3200 companies, 85% of which are SMEs and VSEs, localized on the whole territory
• 20% of their turnover on average in the nuclear sector
• 220,000 jobs and 22,500 new hires between 2020 and 2023
• Sector turnover : 47.5 Md euros
• 53% of companies have an export activity
• 2,500 reactor years of experience in the French sector
• Services provided for nearly 250 reactors worldwide
o France’s expertise builds on an integrated nuclear sector supported by a coherent energy policy
o It encompasses sale of technologies, services, nuclear safety cooperation and offers tailored solutions designed in collaboration with partners
Nuclear power requires a high level of technology and significant financing capacity, is now mainly developed in industrialized countries
Nuclear power requires a high level of competencies and a broad supply chain with extensive capacities and capabilities
●
●
Skills and Training
vision Communication Innovation and R&D Quality and Nuclear Safety European Affairs International & Export Digital
France
Support and accelerate developments ; increase international activity among member companies
Bring high-level support to the French sector on export projects piloted by either French or foreign major contractors
Club UK
industry alliances and export developments
collaborative partnership’ shared ambition to support UK-France Supply-chains to meet the markets needs
program French Nuclear Workforce Assesment
● Encourage cooperation with commercial industries among partner countries to continue their leading roles in nuclear GIFEN’
: support
GIFEN/NIA
MATCH
PARIS, FRANCE
35
November 28-30, 2023 Connect to the global nuclear community and meet the +17,000 international highly-qualified professionals
Nuclear Skills – A National Perspective
Corhyn Parr Nuclear Skills Strategy Group
At a time of an aging nuclear workforce with the challenge of transferability to the next generation… The Skills Challenges – Within the Next Decade • AGR extensions and Closure Programme • Decommissioning • Waste repositories and reprocessing to direct disposal • Further nuclear expansion and digital developments – eg • Defence Programme • SMR development and deployment • ANTs • Fusion • Digital Upskilling • Also need for greater diversity, productivity and cost savings
The Scale of the Skills Challenge
A 24 GWE model Today
Need to increase recruitment by 300% to meet 24GW by 2050 Tight global labour market annual shortfall of engineering talent at all levels Competing national Infrastructure projects drawing from same skills pool Aging workforce –increased attrition Skills immigration challenges Jobs in remote parts of the UK Un diverse workforce Reduced labour market supply Nuclear Sector not seen as attractive Time to competence lengthy need to recruit and train ahead of contract award
Cabinet Office (Kingman Review) and Great British Nuclear 1. HMG to provide certainty to industry by optimising the scheduling/ sequencing nuclear projects (civil & defence) 2. Develop workforce Market Intelligence & Analysis 3. Scale up and de-risk apprentices, in public sector, government sponsored pool of apprentices 4. Further development of T-level vocational courses 5. Scale up the existing NDA designed nuclear-graduates programme to support UK mission 6. Develop nuclear modules that can be delivered within existing undergraduate programmes 7. Utilise international solutions – Offshoring 8. Review security requirements and fund process improvement 9. Safeguard specialist nuclear skills/develop Subject Matter Experts 10. Improve collaboration in the sector 11. Improve wider knowledge and understanding of nuclear sector 12. Increase Diversity by setting funded targets 39
UK-FR Collaborative engagement and Skills
07 November 2022
Stronger together, developing our nuclear capabilities 30YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IN RADIOACTIVE WASTE MANAGEMENT WORLDWIDE 700 STAFF IN THE UK 18,000 STAFF IN THE WORLD STRONGER TOGETHER Joining forces with GSL BRINGING LESSONS LEARNED, NUCLEAR AND NON NUCLEAR EXPERTISE, AND CAPACITY RESEARCHING TOGETHER EURAD AND PREDIS ITER 70YEARS OF EXPERIENCE IN NUCLEAR ENGINEERING WORLDWIDE INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIVE R&D PROGRAMMES M&A & BILATERAL RECRUITMENTS TO FOSTER SYNERGIES TEAMING UP ON MAJOR NUCLEAR PROGRAMMES
Decommissioning and Waste Management
Tony Godley, International Relations Manager, Nuclear DecommissioningAuthority (NDA)
Vincent Gorgues, Senior Advisor to CEA's general administrator and Director for Dismantling and Decommissioning, CEA
Jean-Michel Romary, Decommissioning & Waste Project Director, ORANO
Daniel Delort, Head of International Affairs Department, ANDRA
Dan Galson, Managing Director, Galson Sciences, EGIS
Myriam Colacicco, Director Graphite Reactors Projects, EDF
Moderator: Tim Gilroy, Civil Nuclear Specialist, Department for International Trade (DIT)
TITRE COOPERATION ANDRA/NDA
Daniel DELORT Paola VILARINO-SALINAS
at Andra
It
This document is the sole property of Andra.
cannot be reproduced or communicated without its prior permission.
International Affairs Department
UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum 2022
Cooperation agreement between Andra/NDA
o Cooperation agreement in the field of radioactive waste management signed in 2019 for 5 years
o Objective : Share and exchange strategic, scientific, technical and operational information and knowledge within a clear and reassuring legal framework
o Organisation: steering committee, coordinators.
o Areas of cooperation:
• Strategies for radioactive waste management: radionuclide inventory, monitoring of sites, development of waste acceptance criteria…
• Governance of radioactive waste management: political and strategic approach to siting, engagement with stakeholders and the public, communication…
• Project development and management: decision process plan, reversibility/retrievability, knowledge management…
• Operation on-site: technical and scientific seminars, dialogique with the local community…
• Design and licensing file: safety case studies, cost, schedule…
• Human ressources : education, training…
o Forms for cooperation : exchange of information, seminars, workshops, technical meetings, visits, studies, specific agreements
o Confidentiality
This document is the sole property of Andra. It cannot be reproduced or communicated without its prior permission.
This document is the sole property of Andra. It cannot be reproduced or communicated without its prior permission. o Visit of french elected representatives to LLWR repository and discussions about Andra/NDA/NWS activities and projects (September 2022) Where are we today ? o First steering committee (11th October 2022 at Bure) • More than 25 people involved, including CEOs Pierre-Marie Abadie et Karen Wheeler • Objectif : to establish an action plan for 2023/2024 • Cooperation subjects : L and ILW-SL operational disposal site Waste management Strategy for LLW-LL waste and Integrated waste management plan Communication with non-nuclear sites Staff skills development GDF/DGR system engineering R&D and Site characterization • Visit of Andra’s URL and the Exhibition technological center the day after
46 COMMISSARIAT À L’ÉNERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ÉNERGIES ALTERNATIVES SPECIFICITIES OF D&D AT CEA ► Wide variety of complex facilities Reactors, pools, fast-neutron etc. Accelerators and irradiators Labs, workshops and plants Waste treatment and storage facilities ► Little to no scale effect ► Various sizes Reactors: Ulysse INSTN -> Phénix LAMA -> bat 18 FAR -> APM -> UP1 ► R&D facilities Traceability of changes, history Wide variety of waste ► Chemical treatment of irradiated fuel Level of contamination (and irradiation) can be important (FAR, Marcoule APM and UP1, ...) ► Legacy sites and installations
47 COMMISSARIAT À L’ÉNERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ÉNERGIES ALTERNATIVES INB 72 INB 166 Saclay Fontenay-auxRoses Grenoble Cadarache Marcoule UP1 : RCD bitumes et hors bitumes PHENIX PEGASE Combustibles usés Déchets solides anciens WASTE OR FUEL RETRIEVAL – THE MAIN PRIORITY INB 35 RCD 56 Effluents liquides (dont organiques)
DIVERSITY
48 COMMISSARIAT À L’ÉNERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ÉNERGIES ALTERNATIVES Entrée de Cellule APM Procédés ATUE Fond de cuvelage SILOE Broyeur rotor du Cryotraitement Tranchées Cadarache
OF SITUATIONS
Orano D&D Challenges
UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum
ROMARY
Jean-Michel
Decommissioning and Waste Project Management 7th November 2022
©
Photo credit to be completed
2022/11/07 - UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum - Oran D&D challenges
Other dismantling operations - SNF transport casks - Labo shielded lines - R7 evaporator ANNECY & VEUREY SICN PLANTS Decommissioning of sites and completion of reindustrialization
PLANT - Dismantling of small facilities (roasting, magnesio-thermal units) - Preparation of CX1 conversion facility dismantling - ECRIN waste on site disposal A wide experience on our own nuclear sites 30+ dismantling projects ongoing LA HAGUE PLANT UP2-400 reprocessing facility : - Legacy waste retrieval - Dismantling
Mercury contaminated soil remediation
PLANT - Dismantling of TU2-TU3, TE, laboratory, waste facility - Preparation of dismantling projects • GB1 enrichment facility • CX1 conversion facility - Waste on site disposal (hills) - Dismantling of UF6 cylinders Mine sites rehabilitation
LA HAGUE PLANT
MALVESI
MIRAMAS PLANT
TRICASTIN
Focus : La Hague UP2-400
waste retrieval
the 1st
waste management routes were
implemented
vitrification with cold crucible
waste
been stored temporarily until the waste route are implemented
implement the new waste routes, new facilities have
be designed and built UMo FP vitrification with cold Crucible Melter completed (2020) >> An incremental approach depending on maturity of waste retrieval and disposal solution (WAC) Fine-grained waste cementing facility: construction to be started in 2022 Used fuel structures retrieval facility: starting tests
GCR structures retrieval facility: started (> sept. 2020) GCR structures retrieval facility: basic design in progress Sludge retrieval facility: basic design in progress 2022/11/07 - UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum - Oran D&D challenges
Legacy
is
priority • At the time of the former operations, some ultimate
not
(hulls compaction,
melter) • These
have
• To
to
in progress
52
An
to
Focus : Tricastin George Besse
exceptional project due
its size >> Georges Besse U enrichment plant • Facility in operation from 1979 to 2012
• During operation phase, up to 3,000 tons of UF6 in the enrichment cascade, for a power consumption of 3,000 MW
• The process has treated only natural uranium
diffusion
>>
key facts • €1.6 Bn of planned expenditures for a project set to last over 25 years • Basic Design of the new workshop project in progress • D&D Project completion : 2045 160,000 tons of metallic components to be dismantled and recycled 28,000 tons of diffusion barriers to be dismantled and conditioned Cutting and conditioning workshop to be built • Qualification on-going • Start of operation in 2032 Melting of metallic parts under study (Orano / EDF VAL’M Project) 2022/11/07 - UK-France Civil Nuclear Forum - Oran D&D challenges
• Maximum enrichment : 5% • 4 buildings, 1,400 steps of
organized in 70 groups of 20 diffusers
The
The NDA Group
Accomplishing this important work requires the best efforts of the entire NDA group.
Cleaning up and decommissioning the UK’s nuclear legacy is a complex undertaking and relies on the full range of expertise and skills within the NDA group.
Over the last few years, important decisions have been taken on the way in which the organisations that deliver the NDA mission are managed, to create a stronger and more simply structured NDA group.
Tendering for NDA
We use 3 systems to advertise and to manage our contracts:
• Framework Contracts awarded by Crown Commercial Services or other procurement hubs for utilisation by the wider public sector Government Procurement Service website
NB new govt procurement website https://www.crowncommercial.gov.uk/
• New procurement opportunities with a cumulative value of over £10,000 Contracts Finder website
• New higher-value procurement opportunities with a cumulative total over the current EU threshold Tender Electronic Daily website
NDA will publish all contract awards over £20,000 on Contracts Finder website
Optimising the decommissioning end state for nuclear sites
UK France Civil Nuclear Forum 07/11/2022
56 Context The ‘GRR’ • The UK Nuclear Decommissioning Authority owns 17 nuclear sites including their assets and liabilities • The GRR also applies to non-NDA nuclear sites • Galson Sciences Ltd is supporting the NDA Estate in addressing new regulatory guidance relevant to End States of decommissioning & release from regulatory control • UK is leading the way in Europe
Options
57
for disposal of high-volume
decommissioning waste
waste unless dug up) Radioactive waste disposal for filling an existing structure Radioactive waste disposal for screening bund Radioactive waste disposed of in situ with engineered closure
low-activity
(Not
58 Schematic configurations Current configuration Spent fuel Reactor cooling ponds Possible End State configuration (many 10,000s m3 material at typical site) Non-radioactive structure or infill Radioactive structure Radioactive contaminated ground Radioactive infill KEY FSC = final site clearance
•
Detriments associated with off-site transport & disposal:
• Safety: conventional & radiological risks to workers removing subsurface contaminated structures & ground that could otherwise be left in situ, and then processing the resulting waste
Environment: risks & nuisance to members of the public from transport of waste to the off-site disposal facility & CO2 emissions
• Strategic: using up limited capacity in national facilities for radioactive waste disposal
decommissioning
optimisation methodology
approaches
tools
inventory understanding
strategic
…
• Cost: (1) removing subsurface contaminated structures & ground that could otherwise be left in situ… and (2) off-site waste disposal Transferability to French
sites: •
• assessment
&
•
•
issues
An optimised End State
Current situation with decommissioning Graphite Moderated Reactors
St Laurent
Bugey 1
Chinon
2020: Validation by French safety Authority of EDF progressive strategy to secure decommissioning of 6 reactors
2020-2021: Construction of an industrial demonstrator to test and qualify remoted tools for the FOAK CHINON A2
2022: Commissioning of the industrial demonstrator and first physical tests on full scale models
to secure FOAK graphite reactor
2 Elementary mock-up tests 2022 2024 2025 2027 Integral model tests Industrial demonstrator near Chinon CHINON A2 3D model conducted by a Joint Venture EDF – VNS to connect skills in nuclear decommissioning and robotics and remote handling solutions Developments & tests
Test programme
dismantling
International collaborations around graphite reactor decommissioning 3 Similar decommissioning challenges for UNGG, Magnox, RBMK reactors: concrete opening and removal, metallic structures cutting, brick extraction with remote handling tools Real interest to build synergies to develop common technologies and methodologies European Project Inno4graph Innovative Tools FOR dismantling of GRAPHite moderated nuclear reactors with 12 industrial and academic partners including EDF, CEA, University of Manchester o Share knowledge on common topics o Develop common technologies that can be used on the different types of reactors November 2021: IAEA designated EDF Industrial demonstrator New collaborating Centre for strategy and programme definition for Graphite Reactor Decommissioning (2021-2025)
Fusion
Gilles Schartle Project Director ITER, EGIS
Paul Methven CB Director
of STEP, UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA)
Egis committed to nuclear fusion ITER Project
7 November
UK - France Civil Nuclear Forum –
2022
agenda
1. Project presentation
2. Scope of contract
65
Project presentation
66 01.
67 ITER - a long term commitment 1988-2001 : Design 2006: Agreement on Cost and location of the project ITER Members included 50% of World population and 85% of world GDP. 2010-2013: Excavation & start of construction 2018-2025: Assembly 2025: Commissioning & 1st plasma (H-H) 2035: Start of Nuclear Plasma (D-T) ITER is First of A Kind
68
are ITER objectives? Goals: Maintain a plasma for 400s with a Q>10 (50MW 500MW) and Maintain a plasma for 3000s with a Q >5 Demonstrate the technical feasibility of a fusion power plant Achieve a self-sustaining DT plasma Set-up safety standards for a fusion power plant Fusion Avantages: Fusion fuels are available in abundance The amount of energy produced / fuel needed Decarbonized energy No Risk of « Run-away Nuclear Reaction »
What
69 B6 1 PF COIL B1 5 B1 3 B1 7 B11 B5 6 B52 B51 B3 3 B3 2 B6 9 HQ CA 2 B1 4 48 Progress
Tokamak Complex Progress Status
70 Civil Works Transferred to IO Works Ongoing Completed M&E Works Works Ongoing
Tokamak assembly progress
Platform progress
72
Scope of the contract
02.
4 stakeholders at 25% each
April 13th, 2010 : Signature by Fusion for Energy (F4E) of the biggest engineering contracts ever in Europe: the Architect Engineer contract for ITER Buildings and Civil Infrastructures was awarded to the Engage consortium (design and construction of ITER buildings).
A project team based in Cadarache, co-located with our Client F4E
The integrated team approach that advocates a “best person for the job” principle, and provides optimal task resourcing and high flexibility in order to meet changing demands
The defined project organization provides, a strong engineering support organization to back-up the design team and ensure consistent application of engineering principles across the project
Strong Project Management
74
Joint Venture ENGAGE
75 Buildings Engineering Team in Cadarache Detailed Design Procurement Schedule and cost Construction supervision and deliver to ITER IO A 8 year contract in lump sum with high level of commitment extended to 15 years (2010 2025) Around 1,700,000 hours of work extended to 3,600,000 hours of work Internal & External Experts Tender Batch 01, Tender Batch 02…. OWNER IMPLEMENTATION
Egis in the project
76 Technical scope Civil works / Steel structures CD/ED Architecture 3D integration HVAC, electrical, piping, I&C CD/ED Equipment (cranes, doors, lifts) Supports Infrastructure Power distribution SSI coordination Project management Configuration/Change Management Documentation Nuclear Safety & Quality Costs Control Planning/Program Risks management Purchasing Construction/Supervision Control Supervision Procurement/Expediting Qualification Test & Commissioning Site Coordination Common site logistics works Main activities ENGAGE consortium
77 Tore Supra (2003) Q=0 JET (1997) Q=0.65 ITER (2035) Q=10 STEP (2040) Fusion is a long journey which haS gone Through ITER and will go on witH STEP Q fusion energy gain factor Fusion Energy - a long journey
www.egis-group.com
Photos © | Egis, Unsplash, Benjamin Cazanova, Studio Cabrelli, Canva
STEP Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production
Paul Methven November 2022
The need
The opportunity - Economic value
Goals of the fusion strategy
1. “For the UK to demonstrate the commercial viability of fusion by building a prototype fusion power plant in the UK that puts energy on the grid
2. For the UK to build a world-leading fusion industry which can export fusion technology around the world in subsequent decades”
|
81
Deliver a UK prototype fusion energy plant, targeting 2040, and a path to commercial viability of fusion.
STEP mission
|
|
“ ”
| Commercially driven design basis: • Predictable net electricity production • Fuel self-sufficiency • Credible maintenance solution Spherical tokamak design – potentially lower capital cost Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production 83
Beyond ITER
Becoming a major programme
|
85
86
STEP site – From fossil to fusion
A collaborative approach (subject to approvals)
|
88
UK Fusion regulation
|
Creating a new pro-innovation regulatory environment for fusion
Green Paper: “We want to trailblaze a proportionate and pro-innovation approach and collaborate internationally to maximise fusion’s long-term global potential. With this plan, the UK hopes to lead the world on fusion regulation and enable the safe and rapid development of [fusion]” Energy Security Bill: “
energy”
89
What is fusion?
91
4 October 2022
Thank you