School of Built Environment Faculty of Arts, Design and Architecture
LAND7313 Capstone Studio 2 Assessment 3: Final Design Report
Landform Garden Lusty Street Reserve
Rutwik Deepak Gadgil z5289479
2
3
Vision and Design Statement
A Communal Landform Garden to promote mental and physical well-being by experiencing equipment-free play and nature engagement. Lusty Street Reserve is an existing public resreation space, but is currently devoid of any human activity. My vision to recognise the full potential of the site is to develop the vacant space into an engaging community space that connects directly to Wolli Creek Station by an underground passageway and to Cooks River Walk across Wolli Creek utilising the existing sewage aquaduct infrastructure. Public and semi-public spaces, artistic sculptures, architectural follies will be incorporated in the design of this community park to create a heirarchy of experiences to take back home. This landform garden will mark the entrance to the Bardwell Parklands and Wolli Creek Green Grid Corridor. Wavefield by Maya Lin University of Michigan North Campus
Native Planting, use of Local Materials, Landforms that generate and break Visual and Physical Connections, Dog-Friendly Park, Clear Wayfinding, Lowlit but Safe Spaces during night-time.
Teardrop Park by Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates Battery Park City, New York
4
CHAPTER I
5
Context
Lusty Street Reserve
Key Locations Site - Lusty Street Reserve
Train Tracks
Parks and Public Recreation
Train Stations
Mixed Use
422 Bus Route
Neighbourhood Centre
473 Bus Route
Turrella Train Station Wolli Creek Train Station
Bardwell Park Train Station
Local Centre Light Industrial Bexley North Train Station
Arncliffe Train Station
Banksia Train Station
N Not to Scale
6
Context
NSW Government Historic Imagery Viewer and NEARMaps
Site Boundary Subsequent changes in built environment Subsequent changes in vegetation communities and canopy cover
1943 Farmlands along Wolli Creek produce food and sell fresh product at a farmer’s market across Wolli Creek. However, street network is also established for existing houses and for future growth.
1943
1971
2005
2021
1971 60% of site area was converted to industrial use, 15% consists of the sewage aqueduct, and remaining 25% is green open space. Mangrove growth is observed along Wolli Creek.
2005 Industrial area to the SE of the site was converted to high-rise residential, freeing up space for green infrastructure.
2021 Current condition of site and surroundings.
7
Context
Site Area Analysis and Flora and Fauna
Recorded Fauna species
Rockdale Biodiversity Strategy Volume 1 and 2.
N
Golden Whistlers
Silver Eye
Pipits
Noisy Miner
Superb Fairy Wrens
Australian Thornbills
Green & Golden Bell Frog
Australian Microbat
Grey Headed Flying Fox
Not to Scale
Recorded Flora species Site Visit conducted by Author
Open Area
Abandoned Plinths
Sewage Aquaduct
Impermeable to Permeable Surface Ratio
Existing Built Mass
Vegetation Cover
Roads
Shaded Area to Open Area Ratio
Selected Site Area
Grey Mangroves
Eucalyptus species
Casuarina equisetifolia
8
Context
Site Flood Analysis
Recorded Historical Flooding
Bayside Council 2019. Bardwell Creek 2D Flood Study Review - Vol. 2 FIGURE F7
Q_Embankme
900m
m
HOTSPOT 6 SWSOOS, TURRELLA STREET PEAK FLOOD DEPTHS AND LEVELS 1% AEP EVENT
Line
750 mm
Airport & South Railway
! (
5m
m
R TU
RE
A LL
RE ST
Q_
450mm
! ( 37
ET
SW
! (
SO
OS
m
! (
45
0m
! (
! (
´
5m m
R
RE ST
STRE ET
30
KE AL W
PSON
! (
Pipes Major Contour (1 m Interval) Minor Contour (0.5 m Interval)
0m m
Depth (m) 0.15 - 0.25
! ( 0m
! ( Pits
0 - 0.15
! ( 45
Reporting Location
THOM
! ( ET
0.25 - 0.5
m
0.5 - 1 1-2 >2
ST RE
0
ET
J:\Jobs\118004\Arc\Maps\AppendixF\FigureF07_Hotspot06_SWSOOS.mxd
37
m
ON
! (
5m
LS NE
! (
52
! (
Street Flooding
25
50
100 Meters
Flood water flows into the site from under the archway of the aqueduct’s built mass
Water flows in from under the sewage aquaduct, and is retained due to topography
FIGURE F8
HOTSPOT 7 LUSTY STREET PEAK FLOOD DEPTHS AND LEVELS 1% AEP EVENT
900m
m
Airport & South Railway Line
N
! (
600m
Not to Scale
LUST Y STRE ET
m
utflo w
ET
Pipes Major Contour (1 m Interval) Minor Contour (0.5 m Interval)
0m
e
Depth (m)
m
Lin
60
0 - 0.15
ay
RE ST
0m
m
>2 0
25
50
Illa wa rr &
0.5 - 1 1-2
E
45
a
0.25 - 0.5
bu rb s
! (! (
Su
450mm
Ra ilw
0.15 - 0.25
! (
! (
NU
Area to address while designing site
AR
E AV
1 in 100 Year Event - 90cm
N BO
! ( Pits
! (
SS
1 in 100 Year Event - 40cm
´ Reporting Location
! ( Q_O
Ea ste rn
1 in 100 Year Event
J:\Jobs\118004\Arc\Maps\AppendixF\FigureF08_Hotspot07_Lusty_St.mxd
! (
E GU
• Flood water enters the site from under the railway tracks and from before the railway mound starts, which is as shown in the image. • Intervention like flood wall and/or a well designed stormwater system is required to cater to this large quantity of water.
Q_ Inf
low
! (
100 Meters
! (
Street Flooding
Needs more impervious surfaces and well designed stormwater drainage
Flood water retention
Retention only due to impervious surface, which can be avoided by design interventions
9
Context
Site Topography Analysis LEGEND: 10% Slope 20% Slope 40% Slope 50% Slope 60% Slope 75% Slope Slope exceeding 75%
Wolli Cre ek
Surface Water Area to address while designing
W ol li
Cr ee
k
Tr a
in
Li
ne
Turrella Train Line
• 80% of the site is gently sloping with a slope of 10% or less. • Balance 20% is where the mound is located which is an extension to the sewage aqueduct. • The mound seamlessly merges with the surrounding terrain but has a slope of 75% to some areas with a more than 100% slope. • This creates a barrier on the eastern side of the site, similar to how the mound on which the train line runs in the north. • Slope across the train line is in northern direction towards Wolli Creek, where excess surface water merges with Wolli Creek.
10
Context
Edge Conditions LEGEND: Site Boundary Street Residential (Passive) Mounds Sewage Aquaduct
• Edges with residences need to be carefully resolved to avoid peeping. • Street edges need to be carefully resolved to avoid accidents.
N
0
20
40
80M
11
Context Master Plan
Legend: Wolli Creek The sewage aquaduct has served as an integrated system for Sydney and its suburbs since 1895 and is still in use. It is the only direct connection to biodiversity rich mangroves along Wolli Creek across the train tracks.
Mangrove Vegetation On-site Canopy Cover Single Dwelling Residential
C
High-rise Residential Roadways Selected Site
Waterworth Park
Contours Train Tracks
Wolli Creek
Mangrove Vegetation
Wolli Creek Station
Train Tracks to Wolli Creek, Arncliffe and south.
B N A 0
20
40
(1:2000) High-density low-rise residential units
Integricare Turrella Long Day Care Centre for children
High-density high-rise residential complex
Protected Mangrove Forest demarcated for conservation strategies
Train Tracks to Turrella North, Bardwell Park and south.
80M
12
Context
Schematic Site Sections
Section A
Section B
Section C
High-rise residential
Day Care Centre
Sewage Aqueduct Mound
Industrial Block
Eucalyptus in Lusty Street Reserve
Train Line
Lusty Street Reserve
High-rise residential
Sewage Aqueduct Mound
Protected Mangrove Area
Lusty Street Reserve
Wolli Creek
13
Context
Existing Site Condition Images
1. Graffiti on the eastern side due to low surveillance of the space. 2. Brick structure with segmental arch supports that can be a design highlight. 3. Narrow connection for people across train tracks through this tunnel. 4. Brick structure as support for sewage pipes with a conneciton to the site. 5. Mature Eucalyptus trees in one line create shade as well as a feature. 6. G+5 apartment blocks that overlook the site and Wolli Creek. 7. Well-designed street infrastructure leading to the site. 8. Day Care Centre that provides play equipment, but not nature play. 9. Public play equipment just outside Day Care Centre boundaries.
Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
Image 4
Image 5
Image 6
Image 7
Image 8
Image 9
Context
Wolli Creek and Bonar Street Precincts Urban Renewal Area Contributions Plan 2019
14
15
CHAPTER II
16
Precedents Wavefield by Maya Lin
Guadalupe River Park by George Hargreaves
University of Michigan North Campus, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA
San Jose, California, USA
17
Precedents Garden of Cosmic Speculation by Charles Jencks
Orpheus by Kim Wilkie
Portrack House, in Dumfriesshire, Scotland
Boughton House, Northamptonshire, London
18
CHAPTER III
19
Design
Key Principles and Strategies
Provide recreational opportunities that connect to Wolli Creek
Provide a sequence of enhanced visual experiences throughout the site
Flood Mitigation and Stormwater Drainage Infrastructure
Strategies
Strategies
Strategies
1. Connect people to the mangroves and across Wolli Creek via a tunnel from under the train infrastructure. 2. Provide education and recreational opportunities, sustainability and ecology related lessons, nature-based activities for all. 3. Utilise renewable energy sources to create a safe environment for the local community and visitors during nights. 4. Utilise abstract sculptural landform to stimulate a variety of recreational responses.
1. Create a plant palette that stimulates a positive visual experience. 2. Plant species that enhance your visual experience (e.g., flowering and coloured leaf shrubs.) 3. Planting species that enhance your auditory experience. (e.g., creaking bamboo, whistling tree)
1. Provide flood protection by utilising landform design and flood retention walls. 2. Implementation of underground drainage, bioswale, rainwater harvesting trap and other strategies to prevent property damage.
20
Design Strategies
LEGEND: Site Boundary Protection Intervention Constraints Future Development Pedestrian Shared pedestrian, vehicular road
Train Tracks Underground connection to Wolli Creek Station
N
0
20
40
80M
21
Design Site Zoning
LEGEND: Site Boundary Train Tracks Future Development Movement Pause-Points
Landformed Area Landform Concept Day Care Area
N
0
20
40
80M
22
Design Master Plan
LEGEND: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
12
Landform Garden Shaded recreation Entrance 1 Entrance 2 Public equipment for recreation 6. Spillout space 7. Heritage structure 8. Flood Walls 9. Day Care Centre 10. Wolli Creek 11. Protected Mangrove Area 12. Bridge across Wolli Creek 13. Widened tunnel 14. Future Expansion 15. WOONERF inspired new street infrastructure
10
11 13 8
7
1
6 15
3 5
14 N
2
9 8
4 0
15
30
60M
e
,
e ot d
23
Illustration of traditional landowners of Wolli Creek
Pemulwuy – the leader
Pedestrian and Vehicular shared road in Green Square
Pedestrian and Vehicular shared road in Green Square
The Bidjigal clan is inseparable from its leader Pemulwuy (a name derived from ‘bimul’ meaning ‘earth’) who, in December 1790, ambushed and fatally speared Governor Phillip’s game hunter, John McEntire. Samuel John Neeles’ engraving of ‘Pimbloy’ is the only known image of Pemulwuy. ‘The resemblance is thought to be striking by those who have seen him,’ wrote James Grant, captain of the sloop Lady Nelson. Pemulwuy became a formidable resistance leader. In 1797, following a battle in Parramatta, Pedestrian and Vehicular shared road in Zetland he escaped after having been filled with buckshot and was described as one that ‘No gun or pistol can kill’. Governor King outlawed Pemulwuy in 1801, offering spirits and other rewards for his capture ‘dead or alive’. Pemulwuy was shot dead on 2 June 1802.
Pedestrian and Vehicular shared road in Zetland
24
Design
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
Detail Plan - Landform
N
0
4
8
16M
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
25
Design
Detail Plan - Access Points
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
N
0
2
4
8M
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK S
Design Sketches
26
27
Design
Planting Proposal
Planting for site is proposed with 80% Australian Native Species and balance ornamental non-native species for varied visual experiences, planted according to their solar requirements.
Callistemon salignus ‘Great Balls of Fire’
Lomandra labill.’LM600′ PBR Evergreen Baby
Agave attenuata (Fox Tail Agave)
Philodendron xanadu
28
Eucalyptus robusta
Eucalyptus grandis
Pianchoneila australis (black apple)
Cassurina sp.
Spathoglottis sp. (purple orchid)
Capparis arborea
Ficus macrophylla f. columnaris
Lagerstroemia subcostata var. orientalis
Bambusa oldhamii (creeking bamboo)
Dendrocalamus latiflorus
Fuchsia magellanica
Limonium perezii
Aglaonema commutatum (philippines evergreen)
Hydrangea macrophylla
Abelia x grandiflora
Maranta leuconeura
Alternanthera brasiliana
Portea petropolitana var. extensa
29
Design
Lighting Proposal
Lighting for site is proposed with both solar-powered as well as regular lighting fittings but with LED IP65 rating. Site access points will be installed with maximum fittings for visibility. The inner sections will be installed with area-lights spaced out and with a low-light feature for local habitat consideration and energy-saving.
Bollards
Area-Lights
Pole Lights
Wall Lights
30
Design Time Frame
Landforms generated as a response to flooding and for recreational purposes. Perennial and seasonal flowering species planted around the mound. Regular maintenance, once every fortnight in summers and once every month in winters.
Maintenance of the designed landscape by pruning shrubs, irrigation, and trimming the grass over gently sloping landforms, to avoid overgrowth.
A possibility of overgrowth due to lack of maintenance of mound. In this case, the landforms will be planted over with flowering and/ or coloured leafy species to evolve the landscapes’ visual factors. A drastic reduction in social and physical recreational engagement.
A possibility of completely flattening the landform to create space for a standard equipment-based playground area for children, young and the elderly. Why? Ease in maintenance of the designed landscape.
31
Design
Landscape Performance
Economic Performance Benefit
Description
Method
Property Value
Change in assessed value of nearby properties. This change might occur in phases when the park is under development Can be assessed by accessing property tax collected and completed. by government.
Economic Development
Establishment of new businesses nearby and the existing businesses observe an expansion in sales.
Can be assessed by accessing sales data from each business.
Environmental Performance Benefit
Description
Method
Water Conservation
Reduction in water use associated with plant selection.
Can be assessed by checking and comparing existing water flow data with improved water flow data.
Stormwater Management
Reduction in annual volume and percent of total runoff retained on-site. Annual volume of water redirected through stormwater drainage system during flooding.
Compare annual rainfall data with stormwater drainage system data including groundwater recharge.
Energy Use
Reduction in annual energy use due to renewable sources.
Compare existing and improved energy data.
Reused and Recycled Materials
Cost-saving for reusing on-site materials. Improving environmental impact by using recycled materials for construction.
Compare labour, transport cost and carbon footprint to get an estimate.
Social Performance Benefit
Description
Method
Health and Well-Being
Improvement in mood, workplace satisfaction and quality of life.
Can be assessed by conducting a user survey of the surrounding community and visitors.
Noise Mitigation
Percent reduction in perception of undesirable noise.
Can be assessed by conducting a user survey of the surrounding community and visitors.
Recreational and Social Value
Design of landsacped space to engage visitors in recreational and social activities.
Utilisation of policies, site observations and user surveys to determine the type of activities.
Safety
Increase in perception of safety, both during the day and during night time, from people as well as wildlife.
Can be assessed by conducting a user survey of the surrounding community and visitors.
Transportation
Convenient connection to public transportation services and expansion of pedestrian and cyclist lanes to connect to the rest of the city.
Identify key linkages that were generated as a part of the project.
32
Thank you
33
References 1. Rockdale City Council 2014. Rockdale Biodiversity Strategy Volume 1. Prepared by Eco Logical Australia 2. Rockdale City Council 2014. Rockdale Biodiversity Strategy Volume 2. Prepared by Eco Logical Australia 3. WILSON, G. C. 2015. Uncovering the Hidden History of the Wolli Creek Valley. Sydney. 4. KIRKWOOD, N. & KENNEN, K. 2015. Phyto: Principles and Resources for Site Remediation and Landscape Design, Taylor and Francis. 5. Bayside Council 2019. Bardwell Creek 2D Flood Study Review Volume 1. 6. Bayside Council 2019. Bardwell Creek 2D Flood Study Review Volume 2. 7. Local Strategic Planning Statement 2020. A land-use vision to 2036. Prepared by Bayside Council. 8. NSW Government Historic Imagery Viewer. < https:// portal.spatial.nsw.gov.au/portal/apps/webappviewer/index. html?id=f7c215b873864d44bccddda8075238cb > 9. Bureau of Meteorology Australia. Station Number: 066037. Station Name: Sydney Airport NSW 10. Andreasens Green Wholesale Nurseries. <https://andreasensgreen. com.au> 11. ROSSI, P. D. 2021. Can Active Play Encourage Physical Literacy in Children and Young People? In: KHAN, M., BELL, S. & WOOD, J. (eds.) Place, Pedagogy and Play : Participation, Design and Research with Children (Edition 1). Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge. 12. KOCHETKOVA, E. S. 2020. Horizon as a Symbolic Category in Contemporary Site-Specific Art. International Art in the 20th and 21st Centuries, 10, 576–585. 13. HERRINGTON, S. 2017. Landscape theory in design, Abindton, Oxon, Routledge. 14. M’CLOSKEY, K. 2013. Unearthed : the landscapes of Hargreaves Associates, Philadelphia, Philadelphia : University of Pennsylvania Press. 15. PETICAN, L. 2012. The arte povera experience: Nature represented. In: CROWTHER, P. & WÜNSCHE, I. (eds.) Meanings of Abstract Art; Between Nature and Theory. 1st Edition ed. New
York: Routledge. 16. Stuart Brown: Play is more than just fun, 2008. Directed by TEDTALKS. 17. BEARDSLEY, J. 2006. Earthworks and beyond : Contemporary Art in the Landscape, New York, Abbeville Press Publishers. 18. HERRINGTON, S. & STUDTMANN, K. 1998. Landscape interventions: new directions for the design of children’s outdoor play environments. Landscape and Urban Planning, 42, 191-205. 19. arts.umich.edu. 2021. Wave Field | Arts & Culture. [online] Available at: <https://arts.umich.edu/museums-cultural-attractions/wavefield/> [Accessed 1 April 2021]. 20. Smithsonian American Art Museum. 2007. The Wave Field. [online] Available at: <https://americanart.si.edu/blog/eyelevel/2007/06/1191/wave-field> [Accessed 1 April 2021]. 21. en.wikipedia.org. 2021. Stokes Wave. [online] Available at: <https:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stokes_wave> [Accessed 1 April 2021]. 22. sites.google.com. n.d. Maya Lin - Eco-Friendly Art. [online] Available at: <https://sites.google.com/site/ecofriendlyart/artists/ maya-lin> [Accessed 1 April 2021]. 23. Kochetkova, Ekaterina S. (2020). Horizon as a Symbolic Category in Contemporary Site-Specific Art. Actual Problems of Theory and History of Art: Collection of articles. Vol. 10. Ed: A. V. Zakharova, S. V. Maltseva, E. Iu. Staniukovich-Denisova. — Lomonosov Moscow State University / St. Petersburg: NP-Print, 2020, pp. 576–585. ISSN 2312-2129. http://dx.doi.org/10.18688/aa200-3-51 24. Key plants used by Australian birds - Eucalyptus. <https:// mdahlem.net/birds/plant/eucalypt.php> 25. GADGIL, R. 2021. (z5289479) Being at Leisure; A study of form and space in designed landscapes that create opportunities for recreational play. LAND7311_2021 Faculty of Built Environment, UNSW, Sydney, Australia. 26. GADGIL, R. 2021. (z5289479) Poster_7311 _Gadgil R. Sculptural Landscape through Constructed Landforms. LAND7311_2021 Faculty of Built Environment, UNSW, Sydney, Australia 27. GADGIL, R. 2021. (z5289479) Precis_7311 _Gadgil R. Sculptural Landscape through Constructed Landforms. LAND7311_2021 Faculty of Built Environment, UNSW, Sydney, Australia.
28. https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/384354149450444616/ 29. https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/10907224087743776/ 30. https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/36239971987533257/ 31. https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/504403227016723823/ 32. https://www.pinterest.com.au/pin/57420963985457459/ 33. https://www.suncalc.org/#/33.9292,151.1487,16/2021.01.21/13:19/1/3 34. http://www.michaelmercil.com/teardrop-park 35. http://thoughtsfromasketchbook.blogspot.com/2011/08/orpheusat-boughton-house-gardens.html 36. Andreasens Green Wholesale Nurseries 37. Wolli Creek Preservation Society 38. https://www.bega.com/en/