PROCESS LOG
INFLUX IN FLUX The time is now to sea change at ‘The Bays’.
SARA CURUKOVSKA z5205137
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF COUNTRY INFLUX acknowledges the Traditional Owners and Custodians of the land that this project is situated on. This includes the D’harawal, Dharug, Eora, Gaimaragal, Gundangara and Guringai peoples, among others. INFLUX pays its respect to Elders past and present and thanks them for sharing their knowledge and enduring connection to this landscape – the same landscape that is a central focus to our profession. INFLUX would also like to acknowledge that Aboriginal Sovereignty has never been ceded, and that this land always was and always will be, Aboriginal land.
Images sourced from Caleb Wright (2021), Eliza Graaf (2021) and SMC (2015).
TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION
4
2.0 PROJECT SCOPE
6
3.0 CASE STUDIES
12
4.0 SITE INTRODUCTION
16
5.0 DESIGN PROCESS
29
6.0 DETAILED DESIGN
41
7.0 CONCLUSION
80
8.0 REFERENCES
84
1.0
INTRODUCTION Chapter 1.0 provides a brief overview of INFLUX and the ‘Process Log’ at hand.
INTRODUCTION Climate Change is the defining issue of our time.
“the biggest threat to security that modern humans have ever faced”. - David Attenborough, 2021. Of its many impacts, Sea Level Rise is imminent. Global sea levels are rising at an unprecedented rate. This will have a devastating impact on cities and how they typically function, as it will threaten “to impact millions of people, destroy infrastructure, and damage the ecosystems in coastal communities” (Tang & Lukenda 2019). In the case of ‘The Bays West Precinct’ in Sydney Harbour, the impact of Sea Level Rise is profound. At this site, extensive land reclamation serves as an anthropogenic barrier to Sea Level Rise - only exacerbating its impacts. Therefore, there is a great need for bold new solutions and ways for our Harbour to adapt. INFLUX aims to embed a new public realm that responds to Sea Level Rise at ‘The Bays’. It seeks to confront the schism between land and water by addressing the question; How can a waterfront greenway embrace the conditions that Sea Level Rise will bring to ‘The Bays’ to, in turn, create thriving working waterfronts, resilient public spaces and foster emerging ecologies? This process log will detail the extensive journey and process that had been undertaken for INFLUX to achieve this.
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
Figure 1. Aerial image of ‘The Bays Precinct’ and the location of INFLUX.
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
5
2.0
PROJECT SCOPE Chapter 2.0 aims to ‘set the scene’ and outline the intent and purpose for INFLUX at ‘The Bays’.
AUSTRALIA AND THE COAST AUSTRALIA Australia’s coast is vast, diverse and unique. The identity of most Australians is shaped by the relationship that we have with our coastal environment. To such an extent that more than 80 per cent of Australians live within 50 kilometres of the coast (Cechet et al. 2011). It is also estimated that approximately 6 per cent of Australian addresses are within three kilometres of the coast (Cechet et al. 2011). Therefore, the coast has become one of Australia’s greatest assets - the location of most of Australia’s major cities, as well as being centres of trade, industry, arts, social activities, ecologies and cultural identity.
SYDNEY HARBOUR Sydney Harbour is universally acknowledged as a place of extraordinary natural beauty. Historically, Sydney was the setting for a globally competitive city, located on the harbour “for ease of trade, access, transportation, and connectivity” (Martin 2016). ‘The Bays’ is a prime example of this. Since European Settlement, ‘The Bays’ has been subject to rapid industrialisation. Throughout the 19th and 20th Centuries, ‘The Bays’ acted as Sydney’s centre for heavy industry, with this continuing to a lesser extent today (NSW Department of Planning, Industry and Environment 2021). However, this setting has now become vulnerable to the chronic issue of Sea Level Rise, and its related acute shocks.
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
Figure 2. Sydney Harbour from 16,000 feet (David Moore 1966)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
7
SEA LEVEL RISE /sea· level·rise/
uncertainty as to what extent sea levels will rise, it must be considered.
noun “sea level rise is an increase in the level of the world’s oceans due to the effects of global warming.” (National Geographic n.d.)
HISTORIC SEA LEVEL RISE
Figures vary, but the CSIRO (Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation) estimate in a ‘worst case scenario’ sea levels may rise to a global average of 1 metre by 2100 and up to 5 metres by 2300 (O’Dea 2021). At an even larger time scale, if we stay on our current
Despite the urgency to respond to Sea Level Rise in today’s age, it is a phenomenon that our planet has dealt with before. Sydney Harbour is a drowned river valley that formed as a result of the interglacial melting that started approximately 21,000 thousand years ago. Throughout this time period, sea levels rose 120 metres - melting two-thirds of all the ice on earth (O’Dea 2021).
emissions track, the earth would be on schedule to melt the remaining 30% of the ice on earth which would result in 60 to 70 metres of Sea Level Rise over the next 3 to 6000 years (O’Dea 2021). With these staggering projections, it is clear that the time is now to act to lessen the impact of Sea Level Rise. This is especially the case for our cities, such as Sydney Harbour, which would be significantly affected by such a rise.
CSIRO SEA LEVEL RISE PROJECTIONS 2300
*if we stay on our current emissions track
(5 metres)
CURRENT AND FUTURE PROJECTIONS Global sea levels are rising at an unprecedented rate as a direct result of climate change. We are currently living in a critical window of time where we can act to lessen the impact of Sea Level Rise. The most recent COP26 (26th United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties) is evidence of this, with the conference highlighting the importance of responding to Sea Level Rise with representatives of nations across the world pledging to lessen the impacts of climate change. However, Sea Level Rise is imminent. Although there is
8
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
2200 (3 metres)
2100 (1 metre) 2050 (0.4 metres)
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
THE ROLE OF THE LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT In wake of these global challenges, Landscape Architects play an essential role in curating and designing landscapes that can respond to the impacts of climate change, such as Sea Level Rise. This quote from Nina-Marie Lister highlights this idea perfectly, drawing attention to the fact that Landscape Architects must come to embrace our necessary role as stewards of the Earth.
“
we can no longer follow McHarg’s ecological imperative, certain that ‘nature will show the way,’ there must be a new role for humans as creative agents in the process of unfolding, as interpreters of change, as designers once again.
”
- Nina-Marie Lister 2007, p. 48
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
9
THE WATERFRONT GREENWAY THE GREENWAY
existing greenway networks, such as the GreenWay at neighbouring Iron Cove.
Greenways are a seamless landscape planning tool used to re-integrate natural systems back into the urban fabric of cities.
WATERFRONT GREENWAYS AS A SPATIAL
The ‘greenway’ concept is widely defined as “linear open space corridors in the built or natural environment, which preserve biodiversity... and generally engage the community in recreational use” (Crawshaw 2009).
Furthermore, academics and scholars alike have praised the ‘Greenway’ model as a critical tool that may improve the resilience of cities in wake of challenges such as Sea Level Rise.
They typically follow existing urban corridors, such as canals, streets, and abandoned rail beds, and are very successful in balancing the needs of the natural environment with the built environment - providing opportunities for physical activity, recreation, habitat, and transportation (Akpinar 2016). More importantly, greenways play a critical role in ensuring “places for nature in the city” (Luymes & Tamminga 1995) - allowing all city dwellers, both human and non-human, to “achieve solitude and retreat without leaving the public realm” (Luymes & Tamminga 1995).
Its praise mainly stems from the idea that the “linear characteristics of the greenway present an opportunity to develop a continuous line of defence against both coastal and inland flood” (Tang & Lukenda 2019). These ‘soft’ coastal defence strategies best protect coastal communities as they absorb wave energy and respond best to their surrounding conditions. This is seen to be advantageous as many local ‘resilience strategies’ used by coastal communities today place focus on ‘hard’ coastal defences - such as flood walls, sea walls, and groynes, which are limited in their effectiveness to provide long-term protection of the coast.
Even though the concept is still in its infancy in Australia, its popularity and success across Europe and North America make it exciting to see whether a concept like this could manifest at ‘The Bays’. This is especially since The Bays is currently devoid of any nature and would benefit tremendously from such an intervention. Not only this, but the addition of a greenway network at The Bays also presents the opportunity for a greater, interconnected network of greenways to extend across Sydney, linking with other
STRATEGY TO RESPOND TO SEA LEVEL RISE
This idea can apply to ‘The Bays’ - acting as the backbone to a larger, sustainable network of climate mitigation strategies across the Harbour.
Figure 3. Hunter’s Point South Waterfront Park (Landezine 2013).
10
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
THE GLOBAL RESPONSE With regards to the impact which waterfront greenways have on reducing the impact of Sea Level Rise on coastal landscapes, this line of thinking is also able to be aligned with the strategic objectives and principles set out in many important government and international documents - such as ‘The Bays West Place Strategy (2021)’ and the UN’s ‘Sustainable Development Goals (2015)’. The Bays West Place Strategy (2021) » Direction 7 “Deliver a world class sustainable precinct which is carbon neutral and delivers efficient management of energy and water, and the elimination of waste” » Direction 8 “Improve the precinct’s connectivity and integration into its locality and surrounding areas” UN’s ‘Sustainable Development Goals (2015)’ » Goal 11 “Make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable” » Goal 13 “Take urgent action to combat climate change and its impacts” » Goal 14 “Conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development” » Goal 15 “Protect, restore and promote sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems, sustainably manage forests, combat desertification, and halt and reverse land degradation and halt biodiversity loss”
Figure 4. The Bays West Place Strategy and the UN Sustainable Development Goals (NSW Department of Planning 2021 and the United Nations 2015)
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
11
3.0 CASE STUDIES
Chapter 3.0 details a variety of projects and waterfront greenways that have been successful in responding to water and the impacts associated with Sea Level Rise.
BROOKLYN BRIDGE PARK, NEW YORK Designed by Landscape Architecture firm ‘Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates’, Brooklyn Bridge Park is an award-winning waterfront greenway located on the Brooklyn side of the East River in New York City. A former port, the site has since been transformed into 34 hectares of open space, playgrounds, multipurpose courts, open plazas and more. In addition to this, the design also considers the role which Sea Level Rise may have on the site, as well as its associated impacts (i.e. storm surge, hurricanes, flood). It does this through the introduction of sea walls, marshes and trees along the waterfront.
Figure 5. Brooklyn Bridge Park (Lore Croghan 2018).
Figure 6. Salt Marsh at Brooklyn Bridge Park (Rudy Bruner Award Staff 2016).
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
Figure 7. The Granite Prospect at Brooklyn Bridge Park (Architectural Record 2011).
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
13
PIRRAMA PARK, SYDNEY Centrally located in the inner-city suburb of Pyrmont, Pirrama Park is a dynamic park that responds to its local conditions. A former industrial site, Pirrama Park provides a variety of spaces for harbourside enjoyment - taking people right down to the water’s edge. Its various terraced and stormwater interventions create a dynamic park that responds to the site and its daily conditions, such as the tide.
Figure 8. Pirrama Park (Adrian Boddy 2011).
Figure 9. Pirrama Park (Florian Groehn 2011).
Figure 10. Pirrama Park (Alex Rink 2010).
TIDAL ENCOUNTERS, GOSFORD ‘Tidal Encounters’ at Gosford Leagues Club in New South Wales is an immersive project and experience that responds to its surrounding landscape. Designed by landscape architectural firm ‘Turf Design’,’Tidal Encounters’is a nature-inspired play space that includes an innovative ‘tidal terrace’ that transforms the play space into a water play zone when tides rise. This innovative intervention showcases the transformative and ephemerality which water and tides can provide a landscape and space.
Figure 11. Hunter’s Point South Waterfront Park (Guy Wilkinson 2021).
Figure 12. Hunter’s Point South Waterfront Park (Turf 2021).
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
Figure 13. Hunter’s Point South Waterfront Park (Guy Wilkinson 2021).
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
15
4.0
SITE INTRODUCTION Chapter 4.0 introduces ‘The Bays’ as the perfect candidate for INFLUX - detailing nuances of the site, its context and many opportunities.
‘THE BAYS’ IN CONTEXT SYDNEY HARBOUR Waterfront locations across Sydney Harbour are highly sought-after. However, as economies and priorities shift, Sydney’s Harbour Foreshore has undergone a dramatic transformation. Habitats, industrial sites, and wastelands, which once lined the harbour foreshore have now been camouflaged over into new parklands, residences, and the like. ‘The Bays’ is the last flat surface yet to be built on in
05
Residential Settlements
04
Sydney’s CBD
03
Working Waterfront
02
Residential Settlements
01
Post Industrial Settlements
Sydney’s Harbour.
N
1:82,000@A3
‘THE BAYS’ THROUGHOUT TIME 1911
1922
1946
2021
N The copyright in this information is owned by the Port Authority of New South Wales, and must not be reproduced without the written permission of the Port Authority of New South Wales
18
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
Not to Scale.
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
‘THE BAYS’ TODAY
NSW Government 2017, The Bays Precinct | South-West of Central Sydney, Digital Image, ArchitectureAU, Accessed 21 November 2021, <https://architectureau.com/articles/fjmt-appointed-to-masterplan-district-of-new-sydney-fish-market/>.
ECOLOGY AT ‘THE BAYS’ Today, ‘The Bays’ is characterised by its reinforced concrete, built edges, steel, and grandeur scale. However, when looking at ‘The Bays’ at a smaller scale, there are evident signs of life and ecology ‘within the cracks’ of the old cement.
Bottom row of images sourced from: <https://powerplantsphytoremediation.com/performance_nl >.
20
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
‘THE BAYS’ AND ITS CATCHMENT ‘The Bays’ Precinct lies within the Port Jackson subcatchment of Sydney Harbour.
Sydney Harbour and Its Sub-Catchments
N
1:50,000 @ A3
OVERLAND FLOW ‘The Bays’ flat topography makes the site highly susceptible to flooding, with water draining into the site from higher areas, such as Balmain, Rozelle and Glebe. Overland Flow Paths (Direction of Flow)
1:100 Year Flood Depths Flood Depth (m) <0.1 Flood Depth (m) 0.1 - 0.2 Flood Depth (m) 0.2 - 0.5 Flood Depth (m) 0.5 - 1.0 Flood Depth (m) 1.0 - 2.0
Flood Depth (m) > 2.0
N
1:9000 @ A3
STORM SURGE AND TSUNAMI MAPPING Since ‘The Bays’ is highly susceptible to flooding, the site is also a major risk of storm surge. The map detailed on this page highlight the areas suggested being evacuated in the event of a land-threat tsunami. Evacuation areas in the event of a land-threat tsunami.
N
1:9000 @ A3 *Note. Information on this map is sourced from <https://www.ses.nsw.gov.au/resources-folder/tsunami-evacuation-map/>.
‘THE BAYS’ AND SEA LEVEL RISE 2050
2100
2300
If we follow a pathway with high emissions...by 2050, it is projected that sea levels will rise by 0.5 metres.
If we follow a pathway with high emissions...by 2100, it is projected that sea levels will rise by 1 metre.
If we follow a pathway with high emissions...by 2300, it is projected that sea levels will rise by 3 metres.
That is approximately 5 hectares of ‘The Bays’ to be affected by Sea Level Rise.
That is approximately 17 hectares of ‘The Bays’ to be affected by Sea Level Rise.
That is approximately 51 hectares of ‘The Bays’ to be affected by Sea Level Rise.
Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
24
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
A CLIMATE EMERGENCY Following the analysis completed on the previous pages, it is clear that ‘The Bays’ is on the cusp of major change. With the threat of sea level rise ever so prevalent, the time is now to act and respond to Sea Level Rise.
3m Sea Level Rise on a path of high emissions.
1.6m 1.2m 0.7m
2300
Sydney Harbour becomes a drowned river valley.
TODAY
8000 years ago.
1800
A critical window of action to respond to Sea Level Rise.
THE RESEARCH (HYBRID) QUESTION In response to the research and analysis that I have conducted thus far, I decided that INFLUX will aim to address the question below; Water is constantly in motion. It changes states, crosses borders, nourishes life, destroys life.
How can a waterfront greenway embrace the conditions that Sea Level Rise will bring to ‘The Bays’ to, in turn, create thriving working waterfronts, resilient public spaces and foster emerging ecologies?
26
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
BREAKING THE QUESTION DOWN In essence, the research (hybrid) question ensures that INFLUX will respond to and achieve the following.
at ‘The Bays’... create new tidal
sea levels will rise
opportunities
=
INFLUX will project ways humans and nonhumans will interact with this new ‘tidal zone’
1. Resilient Public Spaces
3. Working Waterfronts
2. Emerging Ecologies 1 metre Sea Level Rise
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
2 metres Sea Level Rise
3 metres Sea Level Rise
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
27
SITE SELECTION Length of Corridor: 4.5km Width of Corridor: 60m ‘The Bays’ foreshore commands one of the most spectacular and unique views of Sydney - with it being one of the few remaining areas of working waterfront in Sydney’s Harbour. However, despite its setting, ‘The Bays’ foreshore feels like an odd piece in an otherwise impressive Sydney Harbour foreshore. Its high level of development largely consisting of waterside industry has removed itself from its surrounding context - being the missing link and next chapter to be explored in the Harbour story. At its core, the primary purpose of a greenway is ‘to connect’, connecting people, ecological communities, or lost systems back together. Therefore, the overall proposal for INFLUX is to provide a continuous waterfront greenway that links Jubilee Park to the south with Ewenton Park to the north, that also aims to address the challenges associated with Sea Level Rise.
N
Not to Scale
28
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
5.0
DESIGN PROCESS
Chapter 5.0 recounts the design process and thinking that I had undergone to create INFLUX.
PRELIMINARY DESIGN TESTING
30
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
PRELIMINARY DESIGN TESTING
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
31
PRELIMINARY DESIGN TESTING
32
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
PRELIMINARY DESIGN TESTING
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
33
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
34
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
35
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
36
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
37
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
38
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
39
ADVANCED DESIGN TESTING
40
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
6.0
DETAILED DESIGN Chapter 6.0 details the specific design moves and interventions that INFLUX will entail.
INFLUX Set out overleaf is INFLUX! More specifically, the following pages will showcase the design details and interventions that INFLUX proposes for ‘The Bays’ Precinct. This chapter of the process log provides a summary of INFLUX, looking at its; » » » » »
42
The 3 Staged Timeline The 3 Staged Masterplans Edge Conditions 6 Anchors An Overview of Each 6 Anchors
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
STAGE 1
STAGE 2
STAGE 3
ABIDING EVENT #1: PHYTOREMEDIATION BEGINS (5-50 YEARS) Sydney’s Metro will present a significant opportunity for people to visit, work, and play at ‘The Bays’. For this to be safe, there is a need to treat the highly toxic landscape. ABIDING EVENT #2: THE NEXT GENERATION (2025-2039) The birth of ‘Generation Beta’ presents the opportunity to introduce interventions at ‘The Bays’ that can allow this next generation to learn through experience the changing behaviour of our environment from an early age. ABIDING EVENT #3: OPENING OF SYDNEY METRO WEST ‘THE BAYS STATION’ (2030) After the opening of Sydney’s Metro West line, people can be introduced to the site as toxicity levels at ‘The Bays’ should be reduced significantly from processes of Phytoremediation. ABIDING EVENT #4: SEA LEVEL RISE 0.4 METRES (2050) Sea levels rising by 0.4 metres presents the opportunity to create intertidal ecologies around edges that will be most affected by Sea Level Rise. ABIDING EVENT #5: SEA LEVEL RISE 1 METRE (2100) Sea levels rising by 1 metre highlights the need for strategies and interventions that are climate adaptive and resilient for both humans (incoming visitors and residential communities) and non-humans (habitats). ABIDING EVENT #6: THE BAYS METRO STATION WILL FLOOD (2200) Sea level rise will claim and flood the ‘The Bays’ Metro Station. ABIDING EVENT #7: SEA LEVEL RISE 5 METRES (2300) Sea levels rising by 5 metres will draw attention to the wide impact which humans have had on the environment and the need to adapt to the new ‘normal’.
2021
2025
2030
2050
2100
2300
REVIVE stage 1 /re·v ive/ verb
“to give or assume new vitality; flourish again or cause to flourish again” (Collins Dictionary 2021)
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
ACCOMMODATE stage 2 /a·c comm·o ·d ate/ verb
“to adapt oneself; to take into consideration or make adjustments for; allow for:” (The Free Dictionary 2021)
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
EMBRACE stage 3 /em·b race/ verb
“to accept; to take up; to adopt” (Collins Dictionary 2021)
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
IPCC RESPONSE OPTIONS TO SEA LEVEL RISE Throughout all three of its stages, INFLUX has been designed according to the following 5 different responses which the IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change) has outlined when responding to Sea Level Rise.
protection
ecosystem based adaptation
advance
accommodation
retreat
blocking extreme sea level hazards through hard coastal protection measures
the conservation and restoration of ecosystems
creation of new land by building into the sea
a diverse set of biophysical and institutional responses to reduce vulnerability of coastal areas
reduces exposure to coastal hazards by moving people, assets and human activities
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
47
THE EDGE The diagram on this page displays how INFLUX will spatially apply the IPCC’s 5 different responses when dealing with Sea Level Rise.
Protection Ecosystem Based Adaption Advance Accommodation Retreat
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
A CONTINUOUS FORESHORE at a systems scale...
Anchor 2 Anchor 1
INFLUX is a journey that primarily consists of six unique anchors along ‘The Bays’ foreshore. Anchor Anchor Anchor Anchor Anchor Anchor
1. That Ship Has Sailed 2. Just Add Water 3. Testing The Waters 4. All Hands on Deck 5. To Flood or Not To Flood 6. Smooth Sailing
Anchor 3
Anchor 4
Anchor 5
Anchor 6 N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
X
N
Not to Scale.
THAT SHIP HAS SAILED Anchor 1
THAT SHIP HAS SAILED anchor #1
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
‘That Ship has Sailed’ focusses on the opportunities presented at the White Bay Cruise Terminal to be a place for the visitors and residents of ‘The Bays’ to view the incoming cruise ships, and when not in cruise season, be a spectacular place to view the city skyline. The following precedent images provide a snap shot as to how this would look like.
The Yearly Cruise Season at White Bay SEPTEMBER
APRIL
The Daily Cruise Activities at White Bay 5am Cruise Ship Docks
52
6am-10am Guests Disembark the Cruise Ship
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
11am-6pm Guests Embark the Cruise Ship
8pm Cruise Ship Departs
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
X
N
Not to Scale.
JUST ADD WATER Anchor 2
JUST ADD WATER anchor #2
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
STAGE 1
N
Not to Scale.
Existing Landform Existing Water Level
Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH JUST ADD WATER 1:150@A3
STAGE 2
Terraced Filtration Swales
1m Sea Level Rise
Existing Landform
Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH JUST ADD WATER 1:150@A3
STAGE 3
Terraced Filtration Swales
Carex Appressa
Myriophyllum papillosum
Ficinia nodosa
3m Sea Level Rise Existing Landform Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH JUST ADD WATER 1:150@A3
X N
Not to Scale.
TESTING THE WATERS Anchor 3
TESTING THE WATERS anchor #3
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
STAGE 1
N
Existing Water Level
Not to Scale.
Existing Landform
Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH TESTING THE WATERS 1:150@A3
STAGE 2
2m Sea Level Rise
Existing Landform
Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH TESTING THE WATERS 1:150@A3
STAGE 3
3m Sea Level Rise
Existing Landform
Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH TESTING THE WATERS 1:150@A3
X N
Not to Scale.
ALL HANDS ON DECK Anchor 4
ALL HANDS ON DECK anchor #4
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
The anchor ‘All Hands on Deck’ is similar to that of ‘That Ship has Sailed’. ‘All Hands on Deck’ is centred around the White Bay Silos and allows visitors and residents of ‘The Bays’ to come up ‘close’ to the working waterfront - with a large viewing platform overlooking all the industrial activities and ship movements taking place. The following precedent images provide a snap shot as to how this would look like.
Figure 1. Auckalnd Waterfront (TCL 2011).
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
Figure 2. Bethlehem SteelStacks Arts + Cultural Campus (Landezine 2017).
Figure 3. Auckalnd Waterfront (TCL 2011).
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
65
X N
Not to Scale.
TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD Anchor 5
TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD anchor #5
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
STAGE 1
A PLAN THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
N
Not to Scale.
Existing Landform
Existing Water Level
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
Groundwater
STAGE 2
A PLAN THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
Existing Landform
1m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
Groundwater
STAGE 3
A PLAN THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
Existing Landform
3m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:100@A3
Groundwater
STAGE 1 | AT A BIGGER SCALE
N
Not to Scale.
Existing Landform
Existing Water Level
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:300@A3
Groundwater
STAGE 2 | AT A BIGGER SCALE
1m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:300@A3
STAGE 3 | AT A BIGGER SCALE
3m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH ‘TO FLOOD OR NOT TO FLOOD’ 1:300@A3
X
N
Not to Scale.
SMOOTH SAILING Anchor 6
SMOOTH SAILING anchor #6
N Base image sourced from Nearmaps <https://www.nearmap.com/au/en>.
1:5000@A3
STAGE 1
N
Not to Scale.
Existing Landform Existing Water Level Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH SMOOTH SAILING 1:300@A3
STAGE 1 Mostly Shelled Organisms
SPRAY ZONE
Soft-Bodied Organisms and Algae
HIGH TIDE ZONE
MID ZONE
LOW TIDE ZONE
SUB TIDAL ZONE
Existing Landform Existing Water Level Groundwater
A CUT THROUGH SMOOTH SAILING 1:300@A3
STAGE 2 Mostly Shelled Organisms
SPRAY ZONE
HIGH TIDE ZONE
Soft-Bodied Organisms and Algae
MID ZONE
LOW TIDE ZONE
SUBMERGED ZONE
1m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH SMOOTH SAILING 1:300@A3
STAGE 3 Mostly Shelled Organisms
SPRAY ZONE
HIGH TIDE ZONE
MID ZONE
LOW TIDE ZONE
Soft-Bodied Organisms and Algae
SUBMERGED ZONE
3m Sea Level Rise
A CUT THROUGH SMOOTH SAILING 1:300@A3
7.0 CONCLUSION
Chapter 7.0 concludes INFLUX and discusses the potential future impact that INFLUX may have on ‘The Bays’ and the Sydney Harbour story.
“
”
in the end we cannot fight water, we have to learn how to live with it - Koen Olthius // Architect and Founder of Dutch Firm ‘Water Studio’
CONCLUSION As we live in an age of rapid Sea Level Rise, the need to prioritise and design resilient waterfronts is everpresent. The impact which Sea Level Rise will cause on our natural and built environments will be enormous if not addressed. By synthesising literature from a range of disciplines and drawing on examples from cities across the world, INFLUX highlights the ‘waterfront greenway’ as a highly effective spatial strategy that can be used to address and manage Sea Level Rise at ‘The Bays’. It demonstrates how urban life does not need to be compromised to accommodate the influx of sea level at ‘The Bays’ or anywhere else in the world. INFLUX also underlines the growing responsibility which landscape architects have in creating resilient waterfronts - optimising land to be used by both humans and non-humans in wake of different influxes of sea levels. So much so, that INFLUX will result in a 76.5% decrease in land inundated with water at ‘The Bays’. As shown in the drawings set out overleaf, a ‘do nothing’ approach will result in 51 hectares of ‘The Bays’ site being inundated with water - rendering the site impractical for any human activity. However, through adaptation strategies implemented at INFLUX, this can be reduced to 12 hectares (at a scenario of high tide for 3 metres of Sea Level Rise). Although the design of INFLUX is site-specific to ‘The Bays’, its design interventions are usable, workable and successful examples of how to deal with Sea Level Rise in urban areas and opens up the opportunity for the design to be a precedent for future projects across Sydney Harbour and the world.
82
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
if we do nothing...
if we apply INFLUX
If we follow a pathway with high emissions...by 2300, it is projected that sea levels will rise by 3 metres.
If we apply INFLUX at ‘The Bays’ when sea level rise is projected to rise by 3 metres in 2300.
That is approximately 51 hectares of ‘The Bays’ to be inundated by Sea Level Rise.
That is approximately 12 hectares of ‘The Bays’ to be inundated at high tide by Sea Level Rise.
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
83
8.0 REFERENCES All references are according to the UNSW Harvard Referencing Style.
REFERENCES Akpinar, A. (2016). ‘Factors influencing the use of urban greenways: A case study of Aydın, Turkey’, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, Volume 16, Pages 123-131, Accessed 25 June 2021, <https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ufug.2016.02.004>. ASPECT Studios n.d., PIRRAMA PARK, ASPECT Studios, Acccessed 24 November 2021, <https://www.aspect-studios.com/project/pirrama-park/c>. Cechet et al. 2011, Australia’s coastline: adapting to climate change, Geoscience Australia, Acccessed 24 November 2021, <https://www.ga.gov.au/ ausgeonews/ausgeonews201103/climate.jsp>. Crawshaw, P. (2009). ‘The Future of Greenways in Sydney’, University of New South Wales, Accessed 25 June 2021, <https://www.be.unsw.edu.au/ sites/default/files/upload/pdf/schools_and_engagement/resources/_notes/5A2_41.pdf>. Department of Economic and Social Affairs 2015, THE 17 GOALS, The United Nations, Accessed 28 July 2021, <https://sdgs.un.org/goals>. Luymes, D.T. & Tamminga, K. (1995). ‘Integrating public safety and use into planning urban greenways’, Landscape and urban planning, Volume 33, Pages 391-400. Accessed 25 June 2021, <https://doi.org/10.1016/0169-2046(94)02030-J>. NSW Department of Planning, Industry and Environment 2021, DRAFT Bays West Place Strategy, NSW Government, Accessed 28 July 2021, <https://shared-drupal-s3fs.s3-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/master-test/fapub_pdf/00+-+Planning+Portal+Exhibitions/ Bays+westDraft+Bays+West+Place+Strategy_low+resolution+version.pdf>. nyc.gov 2021, Brooklyn Bridge Park, nyc.gov, Acccessed 24 November 2021, <https://www.aspect-studios.com/project/pirrama-park/>. Tang, H & Lukenda, J. (2019). ‘Rising Seas: Adaptable Planning Strategies for Coastal Urban Greenways - Case Studies in the US and China’, Proceedings of the Fábos Conference on Landscape and Greenway Planning, Volume 6, Accessed 12 July 2021, <https://scholarworks.umass.edu/cgi/ viewcontent.cgi?article=1056&context=fabos>. Turf Design 2021, GOSFORD LEAGUES CLUB FIELD, Turf Design, Acccessed 24 November 2021, <https://turfdesign.com/2020/12/01/gosford-leaguesclub-field/>. United Nations Security Council 2021, Climate Change ‘Biggest Threat Modern Humans Have Ever Faced’, World-Renowned Naturalist Tells Security Council, Calls for Greater Global Cooperation, The United Nations, Acccessed 24 November 2021, <https://www.un.org/press/en/2021/sc14445.doc. htm>.
INFLUX • Sara Curukovska (z5205137)
28/11/2021 • LAND 2413 PROCESS LOG
85