Edition 7: 2008

Page 1

The role of Student Media

SEXPO exploits

page 12

page 9

Alcohol in Res page 10

UCT open day - Despite the abysmal weather, prospective students turned out in hordes to tour campus

UCT Senate stalls on religious initiative Philippa Levenberg

UCT has temporarily resolved not to support a proposal requesting that university policy be amended to accommodate religious minority groups on campus. This was on the grounds that UCT is a secular institution and that the acceptance of this submission would cause disruption to the scheduling of academic activities. The proposal made two main appeals: That Muslim, Jewish, Hindu and Seventh Day Adventist religious practices in particular be recognised by not scheduling examinations between noon and 2 pm or after sunset on Fridays, as well as during five specified religious holidays in the year; Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, Diwali, Eid-ul-Fitr, and Eid-ul-Adha. These occasions are considered by these faiths to be the most significant on their respective religious calendars. An appeal was made for condoned absences from other academic activities, including tests and exams, scheduled for the holy days mentioned that did not fall within either the June or November examination periods. It was also requested that provisions be made for a permanent prayer venue for Muslim students during Meridian

on Fridays. The submission was made by the South African Students’ Congress (SASCO) UCT, the Muslim Students Association (MSA), the South African Union of Jewish Students (SAUJS), the Hindu Students’ Society (HSS), and the Seventh Day Adventist Student Movement. It was referred to the Senate Executive Committee (SEC), comprising of UCT Faculty Deans, Deputy ViceChancellors, Vice-Chancellors and some Executive Directors, as well as the University Student Affairs Committee (USAC), the SRC and Student Assembly, for consideration. USAC unanimously accepted the proposal. The SEC argued that UCT was a secularist university, and while it recognises various religions, it is stipulated in the University’s statute that ‘no preference may be given to or advantage withheld from any person on the grounds of that person’s religion, culture, belief or opinion.’ SRC Treasurer and member of SASCO UCT, Yusuf Mowlana, pointed out that the status quo allows certain students to practise their faith, as the most significant Christian observances are public holidays. Continued on page 3...

DASO-SASCO tension laid bare staff writer ON Wednesday 30 April, DASO held a press conference to contest the removal of DASO chairperson, Pierre Jansen, from a Student Assembly sitting. Jansen was acting as the official proxy for Chris Ryall, head of DASO UCT. He was escorted out of the sitting by a CPS officer following a comment he made towards Tende Makofane, the chairperson of Student Assembly: ‘With all due respect Chairperson, we know that you are all for Communism, but now is not the time for Stalinist tactics.’ Jansen said the statement was ‘meant to be a humorous aside, not to cause offence.’ DASO believes Makofane’s ‘integrity to deal with his responsibility as Chair of SAMC as a person was deeply flawed’. Ryall also stated that there were ‘numerous inconsistencies in the SAMC ruling’ with regards to Jansen’s removal from the sitting. DASO has proposed a motion of censure against Makofane for two main reasons: Student Assembly should remain as apolitical as possible and the fact that Makofane is serving as chairperson of both SASCO and the Student Assembly Management Committee (SAMC) represents a conflict of interest. According to DASO, this was demonstrated by the fact that Makofane failed to justify his ruling and did not offer Jansen the opportunity to retract or apologise. Makofane said, ‘... they can still bring their case forward to the next Student Assembly sitting, where it will be tested whether Student Assembly members agree with them on this one, or whether they are just making me their political target, due to the fact that I happen to be affiliated with SASCO, which they consider as their arch political rival.’

DASO argued that Jansen was not forewarned before being removed from the sitting. Makofane countered this accusation by saying: ‘At the beginning of the last Student Assembly sitting, I made it clear that I will not be tolerating disorder during the sitting. Pierre Jansen and other DASO members’ behaviour during the last Student Assembly sitting was generally disorderly. This includes some of them heckling other Student Assembly members, Geordin HillLewis standing up and instructing me (the Chairperson of Student Assembly) to recognise them, and the last incident was when the DASO Chairperson called me names when he was addressing the Student Assembly sitting.’ Student Assembly standing rule 8 says: ‘If the Chairperson is of the opinion that a member is deliberately contravening a provision of these Rules, or that a member is in contempt of or is disregarding the authority of the Chairperson, or that a member’s conduct is grossly disorderly, either due to insobriety or dissatisfaction with proceeding, and such a member has been forewarned; the Chairperson may order the member to withdraw from the proceedings for the remainder of the sitting.’ Makofane went on to say, ‘I want to make it clear that it was Student Assembly members themselves who took offence from his words and called him out of order, requesting that he be kicked out of Student Assembly.’ Ryall mentioned that Makofane had been offered the opportunity to defend his position on the matter at the press conference. He declined the invitation. Deputy Chair of SASCO, Mashao Moshabela, caused a stir at the press conference, when he claimed that labelling a person a communist was an insult akin to

Varsity, the official student newspaper since 1942, is committed to the principles of equality and democracy

Photo by Justin Andrews

Photo by Justin Andrews

13 May 2008 · Volume 67, Number 7 · 021 650 3543 · varsitynewspaper@gmail.com

Making Waves - Mashao Moshabela at the DASO press conference calling someone a kaffir. Moshabela arrived more than 30 minutes late for the conference and was given the opportunity to address the attendees. Makofane defended Moshabela’s outburst in saying, ‘The use of the word kaffir should be considered according to the context in which it was used, and not merely by reacting to the fact that it was mentioned in an example. The Deputy Chairperson of SASCO was trying to make a comparison that, in his opinion, what the DASO Chairperson called me at Student Assembly is as offensive as someone using the ‘K’ word on someone else. It is not like he used the word to refer to someone else...hence there is no merit to regard his mention of that word as offensive or disturbing.’ Moshabela added that ‘DASO is just seeking public attention and publicity.’


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Edition 7: 2008 by VARSITY - Issuu