MANCHESTER SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE | 2022
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
STAIRWAY TO HAVEN REVITALISE GRIMSBY GASTRONOMIC INDUSTRY
INTRODUCTORY RESEARCH Initial Thought 01 Stairway To Haven 02 Brexit Affect to the Seafood Industry 03 Symbiosis Industry 04 End Users Studies 05 Farm to Table Movement 06 Artisanal Food Industry 07 Regional Site Analysis 08 Introduction to the Building 09
DESIGN STRATEGIES Historical Analysis (Building) 10 Building Heritage & Fabric Study 11 Adaptive Reuse Methodology 12 Precedent Studies 13 Macro & Micro Site Analysis 14 Design Strategies & Iterations 16 Massing Iterations 17
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT
Atelier Ethos 1
2
3
Infraspace is a sub-discipline of infrastructure architecture that aims to link systems in a constructed form to improve efficiency. We created a housing idea based on historical contexts concerning networks and flows, with the goal of being informed by the infrastructure already in place at Grimsby and the North Sea, as well as how these networks and flows have impacted the area. We examined the area not only in terms of its physical appearance, but also in terms of its increasingly virtual and digital nature. With this in mind, our study examines the connection between temporary inhabitants and the scheme, with the goal of providing them with socially productive space that is beneficial to both parties. This would be beneficial to the entire community.
ARUP 2030 Masterplan 1
Grimsby was the first town in the UK to secure a government-sponsored ‘Town Deal.’ The Town Deal is a new paradigm of collaboration between central government and local governments. Government, local government, and business and industry are all involved.
2
Other stakeholders, all of whom are focused on achieving excellent results Grimsby will transform as a result of investment and support. Having a distinct vision for Grimsby’s future. Lays out how the city’s investment will pay off. Benefits for Grimsby people now and in the future
3
The foreseeable future will strengthen the existing support in the right place This concept gives the town core of Grimsby a long-term vision.
We will study what becomes of the areas surrounding this lovely historic city through this design project, which will be linked to our readings on the North Sea Policy and the ARUP Masterplanning for Grimsby.
Site Plan/ Masterplan 18 Key Space Hierarchy & Programming 19 Sectional Perspective (Programs) 20 Axonometric Building Diagram 22 Floor Plans (Demolition & Proposed Drawings) 23 Elevations (Existing & Proposed Drawings) 24 Sections (Existing & Proposed Drawings) 25
BUILDING COMPLIANCE Technical Sectional Detailings 26 Exploded Construction Axonometric 27 Regulations & Legislation (Approved Documents) 28 Structural Strategy (Technical Details) 29 Construction Isometric Construction Sequence 30 Plan of Work RIBA 31 Preservation & Restoration 32 Environmental Strategies 33
ATELIER SPECIFIC OUTPUT Killer Sectional Perspective 20-21 Physical Model (Structural Strategies) 34 Exterior & Interior Perspectives 35 Project Conclusion 41 Self Reflection 41 Bibliography & References 42
BUTTON SAMPLE This PDF document has several interactive pages that allow the viewer to engage with multiple levels of information on a single page. The cursor icon may be found on each clickable blue/black box to activate the layers of information. If it still doesn’t work, try refreshing the PDF viewer or reopening the document. Regards, Arif & Aiman.
The North Sea Policy
1
To reduce carbon emissions, the government and the oil and gas sector have agreed to invest up to £16 billion by 2030. This includes up to £3 billion for renewable energy to displace fossil fuel-based power on oil and gas platforms, up to £3 billion for carbon capture and sequestration, and up to £10 billion for hydrogen production.
In keeping with the atelier’s overarching questions of: Can an infrastructural architecture be productive in the service of both humans and the environment at the same time? Can infrastructural architecture spaces be socially productive? - We would like you to consider how this piece of industrial, former port infrastructure could be reimagined for a community use that is economically, socially, and environmentally sustainable.
2
By 2030, the industry will voluntarily commit to ensure that local enterprises contribute 50% of offshore decommissioning and new energy technology projects, helping to keep jobs in the UK.
This is a professional studies project that is being managed through studio. The project is designed to allow you to explore timely and topical themes, but the emphasis is on demonstrating your professional capability to:
3
- to propose innovative and creative solutions to design questions;
The North Sea Transition Deal includes the following key commitments:
1 2
3 4
The Project Brief
Early objectives have been established for the sector to reduce emissions by 10% by 2025 and 25% by 2027, with a commitment to cut emissions by 50% by 2030.
The appointment of an Industry Supply Chain Champion who will help coordinate local growth and job possibilities with other industries like carbon capture, storage, and storage, as well as offshore wind.
- resolve and communicate appropriate architectonic approaches through visual and verbal means; - explain suitable sequences for construction, project management and practice workloads; - produce outputs at a professional level and in ways that are appropriate for the subject and design..
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT VISUALISATION This collage represents our early notions after receiving the PS2 brief. We were both interested in looking at the seafood or fishing sector in the setting of Grimsby. The industry is significant and was historically glorious in the past, but it is no longer so. We can observe how the Cod War affected UK fisheries over time.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
INITIAL THOUGHTS AND IDEA
From there, we considered ways to make food sources that are more sustainable and responsible for all of the carbon footprints made by the food sector. We conducted research on the food sector in the United Kingdom particularly and globally in general, and discovered a sustainable political movement in the United States called “Farm to Table,” which has four key principles; 1. How to produce a sustainable food source while minimising social and environmental effect. 2. How to process the food produced in a sustainable manner, as well as how to transport or deliver it to the end customer with a low carbon footprint. 3. How to consume food ethically and responsibly, how to proportion the amount, how to preserve food, and so forth. 4. Finally, how to handle food waste and prevent it from decomposing without benefiting the environment.
01
DESIGN INTENT
MEANING JOURNEY, FLOW AND MOVEMENT
Architecture that pulls people into a journey. Architectural elements built into ones built forms can flow from one to the next, creating a journey for our building’s occupants. Ones occupants will move through ones building from beginning to end, and this journey will be marked by memorable and sensorial experiences.
INJECTING PROGRAMS
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
STAIRWAY TO HAVEN
MEANING GRIMSBY’S FOOD INDUSTRY
The establishment of a community learning centre with the primary goal of teaching local fishermen, residents, tourists, and students about the sustainable processing of seafood. It will also serve as a new landmark for public gatherings, where people will come not only to learn, but also to participate in other activities to create an informal learning and fun experience based on the space designs and programme combinations.
02
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
BREXIT TAKE HOLD OF SEAFOOD IN THE UK FISHERIES INDUSTRY IN THE NORTH SEA
25% The EU will transfer fishing quotas to the United Kingdom. Between now and June 2026, the UK will receive 25% of the EU’s fishing rights in UK seas (in terms of value). By the end of this time, the United Kingdom will have fishing rights to almost two-thirds of the stocks in UK seas. The five-and-ahalf-year interval between now and then is known as the “adjustment phase.”
£145m By the end of the adjustment period, this equates to around £145 million in additional quota for UK vessels.
15% of the EU’s fishing rights will be transferred in 2021.
0 0 6 , 13n6nes to
D RHEA E T E P
TRANSFER OF FISHING RIGHTS The EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement has been finalised and is now in operation. The agreement has far-reaching repercussions for the fishing industry, particularly in terms of fishing rights, access, and commerce. Most significantly, it ensures regulatory autonomy of management decisions in each party’s individual waters (as outlined in the UK’s 2020 Fisheries Act). Quota increases will be especially significant for vessels targeting species such as hake and sole in the North Sea, sprat in the English Channel, haddock in the Celtic Sea, and horse mackerel in the southern North Sea and Eastern channel. The most significant increases in volume are for Atlantic mackerel, North Sea herring, and Norway pout.
0 0 0 , 1to0nnes
SBY GRIM
03
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
SYMBIOSIS OF GRIMSBY’S SEAFOOD INDUSTRY KALUNDBORG SYMBIOSIS INDUSTRIAL Kalundborg is home to the world’s leading industrial symbiosis, which generates profits through a circular approach to production. Locally beneficial and encouraging the rest of the world. Kalundborg Symbiosis is a collaboration of thirteen Kalundborg public and private companies. In addition, we collaborate closely with the Biopro initiative. Since 1972, we have worked together to create the world’s first industrial symbiosis based on a circular production model. The basic idea is that a waste product from one organisation becomes a resource for another, helping both the environment and the economy. Having a local cooperation allows us to share and reuse resources, which saves money and reduces waste. The symbiotic relationship fosters growth in the local community and promotes the green transition.
k Docer Tow
h t r o N Sea
l a y RDoock al SeD e c x E LT food
SBY GRIM
FDoischk
N
04
rce l Soum Loca fro ms Far
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
END USERS STUDIES SEEMLESS SYMBIOSIS OF INDUSTRIES
SUBSET 01
ARTISANAL FOOD INDUSTRY The rise of this category has been exponential – artisan, or craft, food and beverages have grown increasingly popular in the past few years.
SUBSET 01
SUBSET 01
GRIMSBY’S SEAFOOD INDUSTRY
END USERS (LOCALS/VISITORS) CONSUMERISM
Grimsby seafood executives have welcomed the government’s £75 million investment in the industry. Westmister is following through on vows made during Brexit by investing in infrastructure, supply chains, employment, and skills.
According to consumerists, the food sector is solely governed by consumer demand. Choose more items. People are reported to buy food for a variety of reasons. Their eating preferences are influenced by a complex interplay of biology, economy, geography, and social relationships.
05
tahse 4 Ph 2Phnadse
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
Processed Seafood Raw Seafood Cooked Seafood Waste Produced
TRADITIONAL INDUSTRY
ACTIVISM/POLITICAL MOVEMENT
FARM TO TABLE
FARM TO TABLE MOVEMENT
3Phradse
1Pshatse
06
DEFINITION OF ARTISANAL FOOD
SUSTAINABLE FOOD PRODUCTION
£28bn
1
The participation of locals and visitors minimises the number of workers in the building while increasing social and public engagement in the region.
Food and beverage, the UK’s largest manufacturing sector, has remained robust through economic downturns and contributed.
96% SMEs represent 96% of the sector, within which sits artisan food production, typically small, often family, businesses whose products are inspired by local traditions. Artisanal food fuelled economic growth after the previous recession and continues to grow.
3.3b tonnes of packaging, single use plastics, plastic waste and food waste, globally estimated and the Zero waste campaigns will focusing on.
In the scheme, all food ingredients were produced in a sustainable manner, with as little carbon footprint as feasible.
Essentially locally produced food made with non-industrial processes. The term “artisan” is similar to the word craft. What we call craft beer could just as well be known as artisan beer.
SUSTAINABLE FOOD PROCESSING AND DISTRIBUTION
2
SUSTAINABLE FOOD CONSUMPTION
3
Our programme will also educate the public on how to manage food sources and consume it in a sustainable and ethical manner. How to balance the food supply so that it does not expire or spoil.
FOOD LOST AND WASTE PREVENTION
4
Finally, we would educate people on how to manage their food waste, such as whether to throw it away or use it as substrate or fertiliser to re-produce more food supply, and so on.
The rise of this category has been exponential – artisan, or craft, food and beverages have grown increasingly popular in the past few years. Just a quick search online or browse through social media platforms and you’re bound to see several homegrown food and drink producers, ranging from tempeh to whiskey. All proudly stamped with the “made locally” – or variations of that – tagline. The growth of this industry reaps several benefits. The advantage of artisan foods is that it comes with the added bonus of being sustainably produced. - unreservedmedia.com
Following manufacture, the goods must be processed and delivered to consumers. The programme might lead to efficient distribution systems that provide sustainable ways and local support for both the environment and the economy.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
The involvement of locals and visitors creates a strong community that is interested in living a sustainable life using food as a source of sustenance. The primary programmes would be education ARTISANAL FOOD INDUSTRY KEY PRINCIPLE OF PROGRAMMING and participation.
HUMAN/SOCIALLY
?
The involvement of locals and visitors creates a strong community that is interested in living a sustainable life using food as a source of sustenance. The primary programmes would be education and participation.
ATELIER QUESTION?
INFRASTRUCTURE
Can an Infrastructure architecture be productive in service of humans and the enviroment simultaneously?; Can the spaces of infrastructural architecture be socially productive?
In the proposed market, creating a space/building that can supply a sustainable food source (vegetables, fish, poultry, etc.) and serving artisanal foods and fresh ingredients.
As a result, there is a minimal balance of waste remaining, and all of the ingredients are used up until the scrap.
MANIFESTO 1
2
3
ENVIROMENTAL The structure and programmes would have a significant impact on the environment, lowering the carbon footprint, reducing food waste, and requiring less land for agriculture and aquaculture.
Artists in the food business, such as local fishers, fishmongers, farmers, and chefs, should be promoted.
Encourage sustainability in the food business through educating consumers and developing locally sourced foods.
Increase the economic and social effect of the Grimsby food sector by introducing new career opportunities.
07
EXISTING BUILDING ANALYSIS TRANSIT/ TRANSPORT FISH MARKETS
FARMS/ POULTRY RESTAURANTS/CAFES
DEVELOPMENTS
lk /wa s n i 15 m 10
alk w / s min lk /wa s n i 5m
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
SITE ANALYSIS/ REGIONAL
N
08
THEN No. 2 Fish Dock is a result of the rapid expansion of Grimsby docks in the 19th Century. The dock walls and supporting original infrastructure was completed c. 1877. These particular buildings were part of the inter-war expansion of the DOck and completed a continuous line of buildings that ran all the way to the mouth of No. 1 Fish Dock.
NOW
1940’s Most of people in Grimsby were working at the Grimsby Docks between 1940s to 1960s.
No. 2 Fish Dock is a result of the rapid expansion of Grimsby docks in the 19th Century. The dock walls and supporting original infrastructure was completed c. 1877. These particular buildings were part of the inter-war expansion of the DOck and completed a continuous line of buildings that ran all the way to the mouth of No. 1 Fish Dock.
According to our findings, the structure is a massive block of concrete with a fabric facade.
£13m worth of fish was brought in from Grimsby Docks in mid-60s.
£40m
was UK total worth of fish in mid-60s.
It was once the largest fishing port in the world with several thousand workers. Despite it’s workers dropping in numbers through the years, fishing is still in the blood of many locals. In the early 1950s, Grimsby landed approximately 20 per cent of the UK’s fish.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
INTRODUCTION TO THE BUILDING
With all of the shattered glass and metal sheets covering the openings, the building appears to be very old and somewhat dystopian. We are excited to analyze various spaces and programmes that could be incorporated into the new scheme in the future. From a human standpoint, the building is one-of-akind, with numerous projection elements or cantilevers. The majority of the building’s facade is open and breathable in a positive way. Because the building is not a listed structure, we are free to be more experimental because there are no constraints or regulations preventing us from creating unorthodox yet meaningful architecture.
Then, in the mid-70s, it reportedly employed 17 per cent of all active Grimsby workers. This dropped to about 8.5 per cent in the mid-80s, which still reflected a significant percentage on a national scale. To celebrate the rich history of Grimsby Docks, we have collated 23 pictures taken in circa 1940 to 1960.
09
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
HISTORICAL ANALYSIS EXISTING FABRIC STUDY Identifying which building components (fish market) were deemed historically valuable enough to encourage even if the structure is not classified, so that these characteristics are not significantly altered during re-use.
MATERIALITY PALLETE
BUILDING COMPONENTS CONVEYOR BELT
The original conveyor belt that connected the next ice factory and the fish market in the 1960s is now deconstructed, disassembled, and placed immediately next to the building.
ROOF STRUCTURE
The original roof structure is a RC flat roof slab , RC arc structure and also
COLUMNS AND BEAMS
The majority of the structure is made up of typical RC columns and beams that span 4m to 6m in length. There are numerous RC floor joists.
SLABS AND WALLS
BLOCK 03
The original roof structure is a RC flat roof slab , RC arc structure and also
Main ture umns
OPENINGS AND DOORS
BLOCK 02
The original roof structure is a RC flat roof slab , RC arc structure and also
STAIRCASE
The original roof structure is a RC flat roof slab , RC arc structure and also
building RC struc(slabs, wall, coland beams.
RC open structure (columns & beams) with pitched roof (with asbestos roof finishing)
BLOCK 01
RC structure that originally supporting the conveyor belt.
N 10
alal & n i g i Orructur s Stogram Pr
g agin Pack
ingural & t s i x E ruct s Stogram Pr
g agin Pack
Asbestos Roof Finishing RC Arch Roof Beam RC Flat Roof Ice Conveyor Belt
hing Weig
ning Can g agin Pack
RC Structure (Columns & Beams) Internal Brickwall Grilled Windows with Glass Glazing 1200mm Steel Railing
g Dryin
y ing Dra Lo d
Metal Sheet Coverings
ning Clea
e Offic
hing Weig
Asbestos Roof Finishing
ned ndo Aba
ning Clea
Timber Roof Trusses RC Structure
ned ndo Aba
g Saltin
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
EXISTING BUILDING ANALYSIS
PROGRAM & FABRIC STUDY
DAYLIGHTING ANALYSIS
HERITAGE & FABRIC STUDY
or Indroting o S
k Dec ing d a Lo
ing Cutt
Hanging Sliding Door
ing Sort r o do Orueta A
g adin Unlo
eck gD in d Loa
N 11
APPROACHES TO HISTORIC BUILDING TREATMENT
PRECEDENT STUDY OF ADAPTIVE REUSE
Identifying which building components (fish market) were deemed historically valuable enough to encourage even if the structure is not classified, so that these characteristics are not significantly altered during re-use.
1
PRESERVATION
2
COAL DROPS YARD / HEATHERWICK STUDIO RESTORATION
“Preservation means to maintain a place with a little change as possible” -ICOMOS New Zealand, 2010
3
ADAPTIVE REUSE
“The return of something to a former, original, normal or unimpaired condition” Stubbs, 2009
“The reuse of pre-existing structures for new purposes” -Wong, 2016
THE ROOF AND FORM EXPLORATION WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF REFURBISHMENT
The design extends the interior gabled roofs of the warehouses to connect the two viaducts and define the yard while also providing flowing circulation patterns. The flowing roofs climb up and stretch towards one other until they touch, supported by an entirely new and highly technical freestanding structure interlaced within the heritage framework. This creates a totally new floating upper floor, a vast covered outdoor space, and the site’s focal point.
WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THE BRIEF 1
3
2
The building specified in the brief is not a Listed Building in the United Kingdom, so we are not limited in exploring the possibility of creating a contrasting architecture silhoutte in the Grimsby context. However, we continue to consider the adjacent Ice Factory building, which is a Grade 2 Listed Building and will be converted into a Theater in the future.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
ADAPTIVE REUSE METHODOLOGY
We persist to restore nearly 50-60% of the building components and elements as part of our structures. For instance, the large percentage of the columns, beams, and slabs. While the building fabric, walls, and roof are being removed to allow for the construction of a new extension and facade.
This project is said to incorporate an element of adaptive reuse for the building as a method of heritage treatment. During the 1940s, the structure was used as a fishing dock, fish market, and jetty for the fishing industry.
HERITAGE APPROACH The intervention aims to repurpose the fishing dock as a place of industry and food production (specifically artisanal food production)
Contrast Elements
Dynamic & Rythm
Connection to the Historical
ADAPTIVE RE-USE METHOD : WRAP/UMBRELLA 1
2
The existing original building is made up of three different types of structures, and because it is not a listed building, we are attempting to explore more towards radical adaptive reuse in order to create a dynamic and contrasted architecture within the site to attract visitors.
3
We dismantle two sub-buildings and a portion of the main building’s roof covering to allow for intervention and the addition of a new structural system integrated within the original structures.
We introduce a new structural grid extension that mirrors the original grid and uses CLT to reduce the embodied carbon in construction. We also began to sketch the roof’s cascading silhoutte.
4
Finally, to avoid cold bridges in the building, we use the terms umbrella and parasite of adaptive reuse to clad the existing and extension structures with new facades.
12
ANALYSIS OF PROJECTS MICHIGAN FISH LADDER PARK, UNITED STATES
SYDNEY FISH MARKET, AUSTRALIA
OSLO OPERA HOUSE, NORWAY
CONCEPT OF JOURNEY, MOVEMENT, FLOW
ADAPTATION OF PROGRAMS AND SPACES
BUILDING MASSING AND PUBLIC REALM
The artist, Joseph Kinnebrew, created this functional piece of artwork that serves both a practical purpose and an aesthetic pleasure. This popular site, designed to give migrating fish a way to avoid the powerful water flow at the Grand River’s man-made rapids, allows visitors to watch fish jump up the “ladder” in a seasonal migration in the spring and late summer.
Sydney Fish Market, which will allow the public to observe the workings of what will be the world’s largest wholesale fish market. will separate tourists from the industrial activities, but keep the seafood market visible. The public will be able to access the first floor level from auditorium-style steps leading from a new plaza. Above this on the first floor a market-style arrangement of restaurants, cafes and retailers will be arranged around viewing galleries overlooking the fish market
The artist, Joseph Kinnebrew, created this functional piece of artwork that serves both a practical purpose and an aesthetic pleasure. This popular site, designed to give migrating fish a way to avoid the powerful water flow at the Grand River’s man-made rapids, allows visitors to watch fish jump up the “ladder” in a seasonal migration in the spring and late summer.
JOURNEY OF PEOPLE AND FISH INTO THE BUILDING (INSIDE OUTSIDE)
INFORMAL EXHIBITION & EDUCATIONAL
SEAMLESS TRANSITION BETWEEN URBAN AND ARCHITECTURE
The central atrium would be the conjunction of people and fish making their way inside the building.
Visitors can look at the seafood process from the first floor as part of exhibition.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
PRECEDENT STUDIES
Cascading form allowing public to acces the roof as part of their journey into the building.
13
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
MACRO SITE ANALYSIS & SYNTHESIS ENVIRONMENTAL STRATEGIES SOLAR PATH
CIRCULATION/ACCESS
ED ) OSR ORY P O E T PRHEAFTAC T E (IC
P-ING AD D L A I D BU SESE T) O E OP EURK PRIVE-RMA T ISH (F
POSSIBLE LANDSCAPE
VISTAS/VIEW
A
ED ) OSR ORY P E O T PRHEAFTAC T E (IC
G
TIN
ISI EXY BA
RIN MA
A) RE A IAL AHERC S B M KAOM (C
N
N 14
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
MICRO SITE ANALYSIS & SYNTHESIS ZONING AND PROGRAMMING
IC
BL
PU EDDE S O A OP EN PRROM P
H
E
UR
ED OSR P E O PRHEAT T
T FU
ED ZA OSPLA P O PRREEN G
RM FA D N EE IO AW AT SLEANT P
IES EC R P S OO A D ) I N S EC (I IE SPRMIVIT FAAPT C
FIS
A
IP RIN TR MA G G HIRNDIN SA FIO B
ED OSG P O IN PRASS M
H
FIS SR E I EC O SPTDO E U ) TIV (O IES NARMIVIT FAAPT C
N 15
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
DESIGN STRATEGIES & ITERATIONS ENVIRONMENTAL & SOCIAL APPROACHES
CONNECTION TO SURROUNDING CONTEXT
RESPONSIVE FACADE TREATMENT
POSSIBLE ENTRANCE
PUBLIC REALM ENTRANCE
NOISE BUFFER ZONE
POSSIBLE VISTAS/ VIEWS
To create a seamless public realm, the building will interact with the surrounding existing/ proposed buildings and green space.
The south side of the building will be furnished with a facade that will reduce glare entering the interior.
The entrance would be possible from the main road, bringing people and fish together in the same space.
To create an integrated transition between the public and the building, a portion of the entrance’s massing would be chamfered.
The majority of noise pollution comes from vehicles and ports; however, planting trees can minimise the sound towards the building.
The main view would be of the water body as well as the planned green promenade between the proposed theatre.
ZONNING & PROGRAMMING
UTILISE NATURAL DAYLIGHT
STAIRWAYS TO HAVEN ATRIUM
RESPONSIVE FORM EXPERIMENTATION
ELEVATED ROOFTOP GREEN SPACE
SEEMLESS TRANSITION OF LEVELS
The industrial spaces were located on half of the ground floor for loading, while the public spaces were located on the first floor overlooking the bay for a better view.
The south side of the building will be furnished with a facade that will reduce glare entering the interior.
The entrance would be possible from the main road, bringing people and fish together in the same space.
To create an integrated transition between the public and the building, a portion of the entrance’s massing would be chamfered.
The majority of noise pollution comes from vehicles and ports; however, planting trees can minimise the sound towards the building.
The main view would be of the water body as well as the planned green promenade between the proposed theatre.
N 16
EXPERIMENTATION OF PARAMETRIC FABRIC
EXISTING BUILDING
CENTRAL CIRCULATION
CASCADING FACADE
ZONING & PROGRAMS
DETAILED PROGRAMS
EXTERNAL CIRCULATION
N
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
MASSING ITERATIONS
17
12
CIRCULATION & ACCESS
11
10
14
3
4
2 6
8 15
1
7
LEGENDS 1. The Grand Stairway 2. The Promenade 3. Proposed Theater 4. Public Square 5. Outdoor Herbs Garden 6. Outdoor Fish Farm 8. Outdoor Shellfish Farm 9. Outdoor Seaweed Farm 10. Service Road (Access) 11. Connection to Kasbah 12. Indoor Fish Farming 13. The Marina 14. Hydroponic Farm 15. The Viewing Deck
09 18
N
5
9
PROPOSED MASTERPLAN EXISTING SITE CONDITION
SCALE 1:1000
SITE PLAN (MASTERPLAN)
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
13
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
KEY SPACE HIERARCHY & PROGRAMMING CIRCULATION & MOVEMENTS AS CONCEPT The spaces are arranged to follow the flow of the food processing industry, and the building is divided into three sections: educational, harvest, and output, but there is a seamless transition within the programme, assimilating. The journey concept for end users established a path for them to move from outside the building into the building.
Pro Lea pu Lea ce rn rp rn ss Ho int ose H Su Seaw o o w Pro Lea SomFood to stainfootdo ab e W Re ce rn ly ss Ho thing as t e Su Seaw sta fo to Else ina od bly
Int Ceera ntrctiv e e
od Fo ble n inaptio a st m Suonsu C
od Fo ble n inaptio a t s m Suonsu C
Inf or
ma
y rg
tio
le
n
g
n cti ne n Conts e um m i r Atll Ele A
Lo Baadi y ng
ab ewsis n Resmo O
&
e En
Se Inf afo ra od str cu Pro tur ce e ss ing &
Re ce iv
ing
Human Circulation Fish Circulation Seafood/ Service Circulation Water Circulation Biomass Energy Circulation
19
Human Circulation Veggies Circulation Seafood/ Service Circulation Water Circulation Biomass Energy Circulation
ACTIVITIES AND SPACES
ZONES AND AREA
HUMAN CIRCULATION
Visitors from the main road can really peek components of the programmes and flows of “making foods” within the building via the designated staircase leading to the roof, creating a seemless transition from the landscape to the building in a delicate way.
SEAFOOD CIRCULATION
This section of the building is intended to provide visitors with exposure to the seafood sector as well as the food industry in Grimsby in particular. Interacting with the exhibits allows visitors to learn more about the industry as well as how to make meals.
VEGGIES CIRCULATION
One of the key features is the source of seafood, which is fish that are naturally delivered into the facility by their migration route. The fish are transferred from outdoor fish farming to indoor captivities via the fish ladder before being processed into food products.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
SECTIONAL PERSPECTIVE
The main stairs also serves as a platform for consumers and employees to plant greenery for food. There are two kinds: hydroponic for tropical plants on the upper floor and cold climate plants on the actual steps.
20
Human Circulation Veggies Circulation Seafood/ Service Circulation Water Circulation Biomass Energy Circulation
ACTIVITIES AND SPACES
ZONES AND FLOW
HUMAN CIRCULATION
Because of its proximity to food sources, the kitchen is located beneath the stairwell to maximise space usage. The majority of the restaurant’s meals are prepared in the kitchen by a trained professional chef.
SEAFOOD CIRCULATION
The main stairs also serve as a learning platform for guests interested in learning about plants and herbs. They can also relax because there are seating areas throughout the indoor garden. Tranquility and serenity for the older generation, and interaction for the younger.
ENERGY CIRCULATION
There is a designated market where people can buy fresh, artisanal, and sustainable food ingredients produced in the building itself. This can generate revenue while also educating people about the importance of consuming sustainable food sources.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
SECTIONAL PERSPECTIVE
All food waste is being transferred to biomass facilities to be converted into electrical energy for building use. On top, there is also a photovoltaic glass panel to supplement the biomass energy.
21
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
AXONOMETRIC PROGRAMS ACTIVITIES AND SPACES The areas are organised to mimic the flow of the food processing business, and the structure is divided into three sections: instructional, harvest, and output, but there is a fluid transition inside the programme, absorbing. The end-user journey concept established a path for them to move from outside the building into the building.
nic o p o r Hyd kinhgop o o C orks W
lary i c n alion Apace c i t r S Verculat i C n& o i t i Exahlib ry G e
asteent W Foaondagem Mb La arm F n ee Grrera c Te
ssing e c Proace Sp nt a r u stafe ReC a &
alion c i t r Verculat Ci h Freasrket M
ing d a Lo y Ba es c i v r Se
k Dec
N 22
PROPOSED GF
EXISTING GROUND FLOOR
2
1
6
3 5
PROPOSED FF
EXISTING FIRST FLOOR
2
7
4
8
9
18
6 12
10
14 15
16
1 17
11
11
1
2 20
19
23
FF DEMOLITION
21
GF DEMOLITION
SCALE 1:500
FLOOR PLANS
1
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
13
22 LEGENDS 1. Outdoor Stairway Garden 2. Entrance 3. Exhibition Space 4. Indoor Stairway Garden 5. Fish Ladder/ Pond 6. Vertical Circulation Core 7. Toilets 8. Pump Room/Filter Tank 9. Restaurant Kitchen 10. Indoor Fish Tank 11. Restaurant Eating Area 12. Artisanal Market 13. Outdoor Promenade 14. Solar Energy Tank 15. Biomass Energy Tank
16. Biomass Facility 17. Storage Room 18. Dry Loading Bay 19. Waterfront 20. Waterfront Decking 21. Outdoor Fish Farm 22. Viewing Deck 23. Outdoor Seaweed Farm 24. Pontoon Deck
24
N 23
SCALE 1:500
NORTH ELEVATION
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
ELEVATIONS (FACADE TREATMENTS)
SOUTH ELEVATION
EAST ELEVATION
WEST ELEVATION 24
EXISTING SECTION
PROPOSED SECTION
SCALE 1:400
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
EXISTING SECTION
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
CROSS SECTION
PROPOSED SECTION
SCALE 1:400
25
NTS
1. Curtain Wall Glazing 2. Curtain Wall Steel Frame 3. PPC Coated Insulation 4. Lightweight Concrete Panel 5. CLT Trusses 6. CLT Floor Joist 7. Metal C Chanel 8. Height Adjustment Beads 9. Bolt and Nut 10. Steel Bracing 11. Damp Proof Membrane (DPM) 12. Timber Joist 13. Original RC Floor Slab 14. Wool Insulation 15. Rebars 16. Underfloor Heating System 17. New RC Floor Slab 18. Sealant Applied Between PPC Panel
1
2
5 7
9
17
3
4 6
GLASS ROOF DETAIL
1
11
16 14
18
12
DETAILED ROOF GLAZING
LEGENDS
DETAILED FIRST FLOOR
KEY SECTION
DETAILED GROUND FLOOR
CURTAIN WALL DETAIL
TECHNICAL DETAILINGS
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
DETAIL SECTIONS
15
13
2
8
10
DETALED TECHNICAL SECTION SCALE 1:10
ROOF TO FOUNDATION SECTION
SCALE 1:50
26
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
DETAIL SECTIONS TECHNICAL DETAILINGS DETAILED OUTDOOR STEPS
DETAILED FISH LADDER
KEY SECTION NTS
2 3 10
1 5
4
11
6
7 9
16
1
8
17
12
13
LEGENDS 1. Timber Floor Joist 2. Glazing Panel 3. Glazing Steel Frame 4. PPC Coated Insulation 5. Damp Proof Membrane (DPM) 6. Metal Bracing 7. Wool Insulation 8. I beam 9. Damp Proof Membrane (DPM) 10. Lightweight Concrete Floor Panel 11. Timber Batten 12. Glass Fibre RC Planter Box 13. Bolted to CLT Beam 14. CLT Beam 15. Wool Roof Insulation 16. Soil Substrate
2 14
15
DETALED TECHNICAL SECTION
SCALE 1:10
ROOF TO FOUNDATION SECTION
SCALE 1:50
27
APPROVED DOCUMENTS
DOCUMENT B
DOCUMENT K
DOCUMENT C & F
DOCUMENT M
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
REGULATIONS AND LEGISLATION FIRE REGULATIONS Table B4 All of the labbelled fire compartments with vertical escape will be constructed with concrete block internal walls, and faced with two layers of fire retardant plasterboard for 90 minutes of fire resistance. The internal walls will not have cavity to prevent smoke circulation. Table 9.1 The building will be fitted with a fire alarm and automatic sprinkler system to allow for 14,000m2 compartments. 3.6 Every compartment on every floor contains 1 or 2 wheelchair refuges of more than 900mm x 400mm. Clear Radius on Landing
bly m e s Asint B Po
Fire Compartment Wall
Refugee Shelter for Wheelchair
2.18 The building expected to hold between 60 to 220 people regularly, so the fire doors have a 1200mm clear width.
bly m e s Asint A Po
bly m e Assint C Po
28
CONSTRUCTION STAGES EXISTING BUILDING
Construction Phase 01 / Site & Building Preparation
PHASE 01 PHASE 02
PHASE 03
Preparing the site - Site Hoarding Construction - Site Clearance - Site Investigation - Survey Work - Site Utilities Setup - On-Site Facilities Construction
Demolition - Existing paladin fence removal - Shrub Removal - Additional Site Clearance - Removing Center RC Columns and Beams
Groundworks - Soil Investigation - Site Contimination Investigation
PHASE 04 PHASE 05
tureed c u r t s olish Sub em AD re ucltisuhed r t s b mo SuD B e
Existing Building Restoration - Concrete Core Testing - Concrete Column Steel Plate Bonding - Anti-Carbonation Coating - Additional Concrete Surveys
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE AND PLAN OF WORK
d adle ishe Facm o De
29
SUSTAINABLE AND TECHNOLOGIES MONTH 1 LEAD CONSULTANT
INTERDEPENDENCIES
KASBAH CLIENT
PROJECT TEAM
ARCHITECT
PROJECT TEAM
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36
MEETINGS 1
PROGRESS MEETINGS
2
PROPOSED DESIGN TEAM MEETINGS
3
CLIENT SIGN OFF
KASBAH CLIENT
4
APPOINTMENTS
KASBAH CLIENT
5
COST CHECKS
COST CONSULTANT
6
PRE-PLANNING CONSULTATION - ACCELERATED PRE-APP
7
PREP OF PRE-APP DOCUMENT
8
SUBMIT PRE-APP DOC
PLANNING CONSULTANT
9
PRE-APPLICATION MEETING
PLANNING CONSULTANT
10
PREP PUBLIC CONSULTATION
11
PUBLIC CONSULTATION
12
RIBA STAGE 0 - STRATEGIC DEFINITION
13
SITE VISIT & MEETINGS
14
RIBA STAGE 1 - PREPARATION & BRIEF
15 16
RIBA STAGE 2 - CONCEPT DESIGN RIBA STAGE 3 - DEVELOPED
17
TRANSITION SPACE + HOUSING (DETAILED DESIGN)
18
DEVELOP GROUND LEVELS STRATEGY
19
DEVELOP LANDSCAPE DESIGN CONCEPT
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT
ARCHITECT
20
DEVELOPED LANDSCAPE DESIGN
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT
ARCHITECT
21
FIRE STRATEGY
FIRE ENGINEER
ARCHITECT
22
REVIEW OF RTL, DAYLIGHT/ SUNLIGHT
SURVEYORS
ARCHITECT
23
DEVELOPED CIVIL DESIGN
24
TRANSPORT MODELLING
25
NOISE AND AIR QUALITY MODELLING
26
CIRCULATION STRATEGY, NUMBERS & SIZE
27
DEFINE SERVICING & PLANT STRATEGY
28
DEVELOPED MEP DESIGN
29
DEFINE STRUCTURAL STRATEGY
30
INITIAL LAYOUTS
31
DETAILED LAYOUT & CORE DEVELOPMENT
ARCHITECT
32
FACADE CONCEPT DEVELOPMENT
ARCHITECT
33
FINALISE FACADE DESIGN
ARCHITECT
34
PLANNING APPLICATION PREPARATION
35
APPLICATION FORMS & CERTIFICATES
36
DESIGN & ACCESS STATEMENT INCLUDING TVIA
37
PLANNING DRAWINGS INCLUDING PARAMETER PLANS
38
PLANNING STATEMENT
39
DEVELOPMENT SPEC & FRAMEWORK
PLANNING CONSULTANT
40
LANDSCAPE REPORT
LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT
41
ENERGY STATEMENT
ENERGY CONSULTANT
42
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT
43
TRANSPORT ASSESMENT & DRAFT TRAVEL PLANS
44
STATEMENT OF COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
45
ARBORICULTURAL ASSESMENT
46
AIR QUALITY ASSESMENT
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
47
NOISE & VIBRATION ASSESMENT
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
48
WIND & MICROCLIMATE
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
49
DAYLIGHT, SUNLIGHT & OVERSHADOWING ASSESMENT
50
FLOOD RISK ASSESMENT & DRAINAGE STRATEGY
51
FINAL SIGN OFF
52
SUBMIT APPLICATION
PLANNING CONSULTANT
53
DETERMINATION
PLANNING CONSULTANT
54
RIBA STAGE 4 - TECHNICAL DESIGN
55
RIBA STAGE 5 - CONSTRUCTION
56
PRELIMINARY WORK
57
SOIL INVESTIGATION, EARTHWORKS & EXCAVATION
58
DEMOLITION AND RESTORATION EXSITING BUILDING
59
ARCHITECT
ARCHITECT
PLANNING CONSULTANT
PR CONSULTANT
ARCHITECT
PLANNING CONSULTANT
ARCHITECT
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
PLAN OF WORK RIBA SCHEDULE
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER TRANSPORT CONSULTANT ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT
M&E ENGINEER
M&E ENGINEER M&E ENGINEER
ARCHITECT
M&E ENGINEER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL ENGINEER AGRICULTURAL CONSULTANT
ARCHITECT ARCHITECT STRUCTURAL ENGINEER ENERGY CONSULTANT
ARCHITECT
STRUC + LAND + PLANNING
ARCHITECT
STRUC + LAND + PLANNING
PLANNING CONSULTANT
GRIMSBY CLIENT
REVIEW
PLANNING CONSULTANT
REVIEW
ARCHITECT
REVIEW
SUSTAINABILITY CONSULTANT TRANSPORT CONSULTANT PR CONSULTANT
REVIEW
REVIEW
SURVEYORS
SURVEYORS STRUCTURAL ENGINEER GRIMSBY CLIENT
REVIEW
GRIMSBY CLIENT
EXTENSION FOUNDATION FISH DOCK
60
INSTALLING CLT COLUMN
61
REINFORCEMENT OF RC COLUMN
62
RC CORE (ELEVATORS & FIRE STAIRCASE)
63
INSTALL NEW FLOORING SYSTEM
64
INSTALLATION OF UNDERFLOOR HEATING SYSTEM
65
INSTALLATION OF DOORS, WINDOWS, OPENINGS, RAILINGS ETC
66
INSTALLING PRE-CASTED STAIRCASE
67
LANDSCAPE AND GREENERIES
68
WATERFALL UNIT FOR FISH LADDER
69
SERVICES (ELECTRIC, HEATING SYSTEM, WATER SUPPLY ETC)
70
RIBA STAGE 6 - HAND OVER
71
RIBA STAGE 7 - IN USE PLANNING SUBMISSION
30
EXISTING CONCRETE STRUCTURE DEMOLITION
In order to create a void in the center of the building, we decided to demolish the existing concrete structure (columns and part of beams). To create a public space that connecting the industrial part and commercial while receiving well-exposure natural daylighting into the ground floor, where previously not exposed to much sun exposure.
1
The grid of the existing RC column has 5 rows, as shown in the cross section, to support the roof arch structure on top.
PHYSICAL MODEL STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS ITERATIONS
1
3
We propose removing the middle row of columns and expanding the existing void to create a dramatic atrium space in the centre as the main space.
By removing the columns, you are adding instability to the grid as a whole.
There are two methods for strengthening the side columns that support the arc roof structure. The first is to cast concrete on the existing column surface to increase the structural grid’s strength and stiffness (lateral load and wind load). Cladding the existing columns with RC makes the structure look bulkier and heavier, while also increasing the embodied carbon.
FIBRE PLATE BOND
The second method is to simply drill metal plates into the original concrete columns to increase their strength and prevent them from swaying. This can also aid in the distribution of lateral loads across existing and new additional structures.
VOID
2
The load, particularly from the main RC arch roof structure, as well as wind load from the sides, reduces lateral load distribution throughout the grid system.
4
JACKETING
As we can see, the space in the centre has a lot of potential to become a focal point with a skylight on top.
The grid is too congested and close to one another, limiting the possibility of creating interesting spaces.
2
Creating a physical model allows us to see how the spaces would work in depth and from different perspectives if the structural grid system was changed.
1 CONCRETE COLUMN 2 STEEL AND CARBON
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
PRESERVATION AND RESTORATION
After removing the middle row of columns, we can see that the space has cultivated into this massive and well-lit area in the centre. The middle space would become a public and socially active space, as well as the link between the left and right wings, which would have different types of programming.
Aaron, one of our Structural Engineer panel members, suggested that we introduce a method of stiffening the existing columns and some kind of supportive trusses to support the arch structure.
3
Following the creation of this atrium space, occupants will have clearer and more direct views and vistas of each programme from various points of view. The structure of the building is more breathable, which was not the case in the original building arrangement of structures.
31
STRUCTURAL RESTORATION The continuation of research and analysis on column stiffening methods in order to integrate new and existing structures. For the columns and beams restorations, we consider sizing, aesthetics, impact on the spaces, and overall design. This is becoming an interesting aspect of the project where we can delve deeper into structural instability and the adaptive reuse approach in some ways.
EXISTING RC COLUMN
BEFORE y
x Existing column grids cannot bear the loads imposed by structures and wind alone; they must be stiffened and reinforced in order to maintain structural stiffness.
AFTER
1 CONCRETE COLUMN
JACKETING y
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
STRUCTURAL STRATEGIES
2 STEEL AND CARBON
FIBRE PLATE BOND y
x+1/3x
The disadvantage of this strategy is that the column’s size increases dramatically, taking up space in the grid and making the column appear huge.
x
So we finally decided to use a metal plate to reinforce the column while keeping the column’s size relatively constant because the metal plate is thin and sleek and will be covered by plants later.
32
SUSTAINABLE AND TECHNOLOGIES The material used for the roof steps is recycled concrete panel, which was reused from the building’s demolished RC columns. Constructing a lightweight panel to be installed on top of CLT structures.
Solar energy is collected from the greenhouse’s glass panel and used to heat the water inside the tube, which then circulates through the underfloor heating system.
Stack effect during the summer to assist the building in ventilating all of the humidity and warmth and circulating fresh air for the occupants by the openable skylight. Plants produce oxygen, which is beneficial to the environment.
Filtering the water from the docks and releasing it back into the environment.
The has bines erate lamps
waterfall small turthat genenergy for and exhibits.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
ENVIRONMENTAL STRATEGIES ACTIVE
Ra i nwa te r harvesting is used to water plants and flush the toilet.
All the food waste being proccess into biomass facility to generate electricity to power up the water filter and pump.
33
ISOMETRIC SECTIONAL
iling a R s Glas
ht g i e twled Ligchy c Re ncrete Conel Pa
al W aine t r u C cad Fa
The axonometric sectional graphic depicts the general building methods used in the project. How the new structure is linked to the old structures, the considerations, and how it generates unique spatial organisation within the study of the building fabric and structure
RC g n i f t Exicsh Roeo Arructur St ltaic o v o Phlaozting G
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
CONSTRUCTION AXONOMENTRIC
sh e M al Meotring Flo
oof R T CLusses Tr
s lab S RC Existing on bs Sla 34
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View From the Waterfront. 35
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View From the Main Road towards the Building. 36
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View of the Promenade between the Building & the Proposed Theater. 37
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View of the Central Atrium Space. 38
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View of the Exhibition Space. 39
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
3D PERSPECTIVES DESIGN PROPOSAL
View of the Restaurant and Eating Pods. 40
PROJECT CONCLUSION In the context of Grimsby, PS2 posed the problem of creating a space within existing fabric and considering the social and environmental aspect in term of infrastructure with a local context. The site’s location was quite unique, limited and contraint and there were not a lot of interesting relationships between the many types of people who moved around and lived in the neighbourhood so close to the ports, especially the Kasbah area. The reading list is extremely effective in bringing the data and research together to form a compelling narrative and plot for the project. The North Sea Policy aids us in developing a solid conceptual foundation for our use of the original Fish Dock and the incorporation of a existing Kasbah revitilisation program od Artisanal Food industry into the existing structure. The planning project was an excellent approach to bring together a large amount of research to support the site’s core issues and how each pair could potentially address them. The enormous amount of waste produced by both the docks and the material scooped out to develop them was one of our primary findings from the planning studies. The adaptive reuse project truly exposed us to this limitation yet critical thinking in order to achieve that unique and interesting environment with engaging programmes. By creating within the structures and refurbishing, we can celebrate the existing and original fabric of the building.
ARIF IZZUDDIN
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
CONCLUSION & SELF REFLECTION
Overall, I am delighted with the outcome of the project. I believe the design meets the brief effectively. The existing fish dock building framework has a massive quality to it, and I appreciate how the structures offer intrigue and continuity throughout the building. The building’s narrative was well-thought out; the idea of sustainability, community engagement, and environmetal consideration informed every architectural decision and gave the structure meaning. If time had permitted, I would have liked to explore three main aspects further: 1. Exploration of space; I would have experimented with various type of space form and complex design. 2.
Learn
more
about
the
Artisanal
Food
Industry;
Rather than providing a market area, I would have planned more detail on the mechanism of the production system more delicately and created more fun and experimentation on the space. 3.
Facade
Treatment
Experimentation;
If I explored a bit more by incorporating digital design such as Rhino or Grasshopper script to create a interesting facade yet environmental responsive.
AIMAN HAKIM As a partner, our approach to PS2 was to utilise our varied skills to create a unique and bold design for the adaptive re-use of the Fish Dock of Grimsby. This project has allowed me to gain a lot more experience working on a re-use project, instead of a new build, which I found very interesting as there were many constraints that we had to work around as a group which eventually lead us to produce our final design. Working with my partner, Ariff was an amazing experience and has proven to be very beneficial as we were able to allow more time to focus more closely on specific tasks, such as analysing the existing building and building regulations. The project presented us with many challenges along the way which tested us however we worked very efficiently as a team to overcome any problems we came across. Our project strategy was to create a building where visitors can interact and learn the history and glory of Grimsby. Our approach to this was to create light, and enhance the unique part of the building which is the Arch. As part of Infraspace we wanted to include quite a few elements of computational design which we learnt together and used at various steps in our design process from testing floor plan iterations, for these open spaces, to analysing the environmental aspects of our building
41
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We would like to express our gratitude to all of the teachers in Infrastructure Space year 05, Lisa, Samuel, and Dragana, for guiding us through our first overwhelming year in the UK. During our weekly tutorials in the InfraSpace studio, they have shown us a lot of kindness, assistance, and even love. The ing
studio taught and building great
us a lot, concepts with such
especially a broad
about link to
researchthe site.
PS2 INFRASPACE | ARIF IZZUDDIN X AIMAN HAKIM
APPRECIATION & BIBLIOGRAPHY
WEBSITES (Offshore renewable energy industry outlook - 2030 and beyond, Interreg VB North Sea Region Programme, 2022) (NORD Wins Competition to Design Marine Education Center in Malmö, 2022) (Marine Education Center / NORD Architects, 2022) https://www.archdaily.com/422608/fish-market-in-bergen-eder-biesel-arkitekter https://www.dezeen.com/2018/11/28/3xn-sydney-fish-market-blackwattle-bay/ https://issuu.com/cdrexel/docs/thesis_book https://www.dezeen.com/2022/01/14/kengo-kuma-hisao-hiroko-taki-plaza-tokyo-institute-technology/ https://www.google.com/search?q=glass+roof+truss+detail+drawing&tbm=isch&ved=2ahUKEwjStbvlxOr2AhWCyyoKHXA3BVUQ2-cCegQIABAA&oq=glass+roof+truss+detail+drawing&gs_lcp=CgNpbWcQAzoGCAAQCBAeOggIABAIEAcQHjoFCAAQgAQ6BAgAEB5QlgtYxEBgtUJoAnAAeAGAAeoBiAHoFJIBBjE0LjkuMpgBAKABAaoBC2d3cy13aXotaW1nwAEB&sclient=img&ei=SZJCYpLtMYKXqwHw7pSoBQ&bih=939&biw=1880&client=opera&hs=ZTv https://www.google.com/search?q=i+beam+to+glass+detail&client=opera&hs=68s&sxsrf=APq-WBugLufQ6nK0fvz_JUK29P4jKbiSbw:1648076271108&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwivyc7Fqt32AhUPUcAKHeX6BkQQ_AUoAXoECAEQAw&biw=1880&bih=939&dpr=1 https://www.google.com/search?q=planter%20box%20on%20timber%20column%20detail&tbm=isch&hl=en-GB&tbs=rimg:CSx4i14vucOoYewVvvwY8yG1sgIMCgIIABAAOgQIABAB&client=opera&hs=BcV&sa=X&ved=0CBsQuIIBahcKEwjQpImZ2tr2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQDw&biw=1865&bih=939#imgrc=PufTq56UQAMy2M
42