Record section price for Ashburton
Sandra Keith dumped from Black Jacks
P3
ASHBURTON
P28
www.guardianonline.co.nz
Tuesday, Jan 21, 2014
Since Sept 27, 1879
THE INDEPENDENT VOICE OF MID CANTERBURY
Retail $1.40 Home delivered from 95c
Big dairy stand-off Leferink, Morgan toe-to-toe over farming practice BY MICHELLE NELSON MICHELLE.N@THEGUARDIAN.CO.NZ
A stoush is brewing between dairy industry leaders and economist Gareth Morgan. Last week the Guardian published an opinion piece by Dr Morgan and Geoff Simmons, which took a swipe at the dairy industry for its impact on the environment. In today’s paper Federated Farmers dairy chairman, and Mid Canterbury corporate dairy farmer, Willy Leferink and DairyNZ CEO Tim Mackle hit back. Mr Leferink points to Dr Morgan’s dairy interests in Brazil, where he runs 3500 cows on five 56-hectare centre pivot irrigated units, which
the amount of land required to be locked in ecological estate. Currently 45 per cent of land is locked up. “In New Zealand of course there is no requirement and also the intensity of dairying per water catchment is markedly higher. “That’s the difference and local authorities have allowed dairying to expand past its sustainable size.” He said pricing water and charging polluters would help solve the problem, and suggested a tax on each cow, according to the catchment and type of dairy farming. “We could move to Brazil’s model but that might be too difficult an adjustment for farmers,” Dr Morgan said.
equates to 12 cows per hectare compared with 3.49 cows per hectare in Mid Canterbury. In terms of nitrate leaching, Mr Leferink queries whether the urine produced by Brazilian cows is less concentrated, and assumes that country’s environmental regulations are less stringent. Not so, according to Dr Morgan. He says the valid comparison is cows per hectare, over the relevant water catchment. “The area we farm in Brazil is roughly 100th of what it is in Canterbury – the reason being that in Brazil the environmental code requires you to lock up much of the land you own in environmental estate and also because for that catchment the amount of dairying is so small compared to the size of the area,” he said. “If dairying were to expand to anywhere near the extent we have allowed it to here, they would face similar issues.” However, before that happened, Dr Morgan said he expected the government would raise
P10-11
LEFERINK OPINION PIECE
Invest in Heartland to invest in New Zealand. Call 0800 227 227 Or visit your local branch.
With roots stretching back to 1875, Heartland has a proud history of supporting small-to-medium sized businesses, farms and families in Canterbury. It’s great to offer the people of Ashburton a local banking option that is 100% for New Zealand.
Ph 03 307 7900 to subscribe! 6 Months
12 Months
Interest paid quarterly.
Interest paid quarterly.
4.00 4.25
*IMPORTANT INFORMATION: Minimum term deposit investment $1,000. Interest rates subject to change. The current Heartland Bank Limited Disclosure Statement, Term Deposits Investment Statement and Account and Service General Terms and Conditions are available at any Heartland branch, at www.heartland.co.nz or by calling 0800 227 227.
BUFFALO/4308-HB
Weather: High 19˚ - Overnight 11˚ Page 26
Puzzles: Page 25
Television: Page 27
Family Notices: Page 26
www.guardianonline.co.nz