Q1
ADVOCACY UPDATE
Q1
ADVOCACY UPDATE
Dear BATC Members, Our work on behalf of the housing industry has been swift and intense in the first quarter of 2017. As we’ve heard from you and your industry colleagues consistently, the regulatory impacts and workforce challenges are the most pressing issues facing our industry. We continue to build out and execute our industry and advocacy strategies to address these issues head on. We left 2016 riding a historically successful election for Housing First and our industry. Almost immediately, our efforts pivoted towards elevating the housing industry in a new and powerful way. It begins with a powerful alliance with the Minnesota REALTORS®. Consistent with our strategic plan to leverage collaboration with like-minded organizations, our partnership with the MN REALTORS has positioned housing as a top-shelf issue. As you’ll see in this update, our Housing Day at the Capitol, legislative and regulatory progress are beginning to reflect this new energy. Of course none of this happens without you, the foundation of a strong association. BATC leaders on the Board of Directors and in committees have provided the vision and energy to drive our agenda to increase first-time homeownership opportunities and to increase housing affordability for all Minnesotans. On the ground, BATC’s professional staff and network of consultants are executing our strategic plan and finding success in big and small ways. The BATC team takes great pride in serving this industry. We hope you find this update to be informative, and we look forward to continuing our work elevating the housing industry. Onward,
David Siegel Executive Director
PA G E 2 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
James Vagle Director of Advocacy
1 PA G E 3 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY BATC seeks to convey the impact of current and proposed legislation with elected officials at the state and local levels, and to influence the process to ensure that our builders and remodelers operate in a healthy and low-barrier environment.
Q1 • 2017
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY
600
Attendees Registered
Housing Day Shines in Opener Nearly 600 housing industry members attended the first-ever Housing Day at the Capitol on Thursday February 23rd. The monumental event marked the start of an exciting partnership for BATC with the Minnesota REALTORS, and featured the Minnesota Homeownership Initiative. The Initiative is a package of commonsense legislative proposals that aim to protect the dream of homeownership for all Minnesotans by creating opportunities for first-time homebuyers and addressing the cost-drivers that are negatively impacting housing affordability. During this year’s Housing Day at the Capitol members of the housing industry were able to discuss the importance of the Minnesota Homeownership Initiative with 171 out of 201 legislators.
PA G E 4 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
The monumental event marked the start of an exciting partnership for BATC with the Minnesota REALTORS®, and featured the Minnesota Homeownership
Initiative.
Q1 • 2017
BATC and the Minnesota REALTORS® drew an impressive crowd that overtook the State Capitol
85%
of all MN Legislators met with Housing Day attendees
171
Legislator Meetings
took place throughout the afternoon
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY
Homeownership Initiative Moving Through Process We’ve officially reached the half-way point of the legislative session. March marks the deadlines in which committees must act favorably on bills. We’re pleased to report that all pieces of the Minnesota Homeownership Initiative have met the appropriate deadlines. It’s clear BATC’s modern advocacy program is playing a central role in the elevation of housing affordability and homeownership at the Capitol.
31 8
19
Committee Meetings
Initiatives
1
87-44
Bills
Press Conference
Affirmative Floor Vote for Homeownership Initiative Bill
BATC Initiatives First-Time Homebuyer Savings Account SF 888 (Housley, R-St. Mary’s Point) has been heard in multiple committees and is now in the omnibus tax bill. HF 1234 (Davids, R-Preston) has also been heard in multiple committees and is a part of multiple omnibus bills.
PA G E 5 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Rulemaking Review Oversight David Siegel, Executive Director, and Tom Wiener, Builder Vice Presidents, Cardinal Builders, have testified numerous times on behalf of HF 1001 (Vogel, R-Elko New Market) and SF 745 (Kiffmeyer, R-Big Lake), a bill that would require legislative oversight for any proposed rule that would impact a homeowner by $1,000 or more. In the House, the bill has made the appropriate committee stops and has been referred to the House General Register. In addition to the stand-alone bill, it is also a part of the House Jobs and Economic Growth omnibus bill and is in the Senate State Government Finance bill. The companion bill, SF 745, has been heard in multiple Senate committees and awaits further discussion in the Finance Committee.
Q1 • 2017
Removing Barriers to Condo/Townhome Development SF 1455 (Dziedzic, D-Minneapolis) has been heard in the Senate Judiciary and Public Safety Finance and Policy Committee. With broad support from a variety of groups, SF 1455 advanced to the Senate floor. The companion bill, HF 1538 (Smith, R-Maple Grove), also passed out of committee and has been referred to the House General Register.
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY
BATC Initiatives (continued)
Public Notice for Housing Moratorium HF 330 (Nash, R-Waconia) passed through the House of Representatives with bipartisan support, 87-44, on March 2. It has been introduced to the Senate General Register for discussion by the full body in the coming weeks. Senator Dan Hall (R-Burnsville), is leading the discussion in the Senate. In addition to the stand-alone bill it is also a part of an omnibus bill.
Job Opportunities in Construction The lack of workers trained in the construction trades is one of the biggest obstacles faced by our industry. Two bills, HF 1944 and HF 631 were introduced to address this issue. HF 1944 (Nash, R-Waconia) has been discussed in multiple committees and has most recently been referred to the Committee on Taxes. SF 1790 (Jensen, R-Chaska), the Senate companion, has been referred to the E-12 Policy Committee. In addition, BATC is working on a request for Workforce Development Fund dollars toward Project Build Minnesota, our collaborative effort to make the construction industry a career of choice.
Manufactured Homes Title Transfer HF 347 (Koznick, R-Lakeville) and SF 187 (Rudd, R-Breezy Point), bills that would modify manufactured homes titling process, have both worked through committees and been referred to their respective registers.
BATC v. DLI Townhome Definition Technical Fix
Homes Tax Conformity
For the past four years BATC has been fighting against mandated sprinklers in any single-family or twin home construction. Following our landmark victory in BATC v. DLI where the sprinkler mandate was struck down in one and two-family homes, the industry faced a new challenge- the court decision and code definition aren’t aligned. The 2017 legislature is addressing this technical issue with the House voting unanimously for HF 792 (Theis, R-St. Cloud). HF 792 now moves to the Senate where Senator Rich Draheim (R-Washington) will lead the discussion. In addition to the stand-alone bill, it is also a part of an omnibus bill.
An initiative that would make mortgage debt cancellation tax relief and mortgage insurance premium deductibility permanent features of Minnesota’s tax code. SF 824 (Draheim, R-Washington) and HF 1086 (Anderson, S., R-Plymouth) have both been introduced to their respective Tax Committees.
Additional BATC Supported Initiatives Uniform Standards A bill that would ensure fair and consistent labor standards across the state has passed the House and has been referred to the Senate General Register.
PA G E 6 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
VISIT
MNHomeownership.com to view the complete Minnesota Homeownership Initiative and watch the BATC Twitter and Blog for updates.
Q1 • 2017
Pat Hegseth, Chair of BATC’s Education and Workforce Developement Committee (Scherer Bros.), speaks at a press conference March 7 where BATC’s 2016 Legislator of the Year, Representative Jim Nash, introduced a bill that would encourage trades and vocational careers. BATC’s Executive Director David Siegel and BATC Members Tony Wiener, Cardinal Homes; and Missy Redman, T. Scherber Excavating, joined the conference in support.
LEGISLATIVE ADVOCACY
Homeownership Initiative in the Media
Minnesota Lawyer, March 27
Public Policy Committee Roster Bill Burgess (Chair) Lennar
Kent Brander
Civil Methods, Inc.
Bill Gschwind
Minnesota Construction Law Services
Ryan Hatton
Peter Coyle
Halleland Habicht PA
Bob Cumbow
Pulte Homes of Minnesota, LLC
Larkin Hoffman
Country Joe Homes
Robert Engstrom
Robert Engstrom Companies
Tamara Erickson Country Joe Homes
Paul Heuer
Roger Humphrey Stantec
Kendra Lindahl Landform Professional Services
PA G E 7 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
Andy Michels
Shawn Nelson
Nathan Jones
Greg Olson
Greg Livermont
Alden Pearson
Bob Michels
Ian Peterson
Shamrock Builders, Inc
Frank Kottschade
Matt Plec
Pioneer Engineering
Jason Mccarty
John Rask
Cardinal Homebuilders, Inc.
Michels Construction Tollberg Homes, LLC Andersen Windows
Michels Construction North American Realty, Inc. Westwood Professional Services
New Spaces ProEd
Alden Pearson, P.A.
David Weekly Homes Great Southern Bank M/I Homes
Paul Robinson
The Bancor Group, Inc
Joe Slavec
Minneapolis Garage Builders
Jim Stanton
Jenni Thompson Tom Wiener
ne igh
b
s supp
or
r
or
fri e n ds
&
t • Yo u
Vote F e b . 1 4 Anne Neu
for State Representative
2 PA G E 8 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
ELECTORAL ADVOCACY Electoral Advocacy is critical to the success of our comprehensive advocacy program. It is essential to participate in the electoral process to get individuals who are friendly to our cause elected to public office. BATC uses its Housing First Fund and Housing First PAC to engage in the electoral process at the state and local government levels.
Q1 • 2017
ELECTORAL ADVOCACY
Special Election Victory Following a very successful 2016 Election in which all 16 of our endorsees were victorious, the Housing First PAC and Fund also became involved in the February 14th Special Election to fill the Minnesota House District 32B (Chisago County). The Housing First PAC identified another Housing Champion by endorsing Anne Neu and the Housing First Fund ran independent expenditures in support. Neu won the seat in a close race, earning 53.22% of the vote. Neu now joins the growing caucus of Housing Advocates at the State Capitol.
17/17
Vote F e b . 1 4
Anne Neu
for State Representative
PAID FOR BY THE HOUSING FIRST FUND, NOT COORDINATED WITH ANY CANDIDATE OR CANDIDATE COMMITTEE
Endorsed Housing Advocates Elected 2016/2017 Elections
vot e
Feb. 14
yo ur friends & ne ighbors s upport
Anne Neu
Nue joins a growing caucus of Housing Advocates at the State Capitol
for State Representative
PAID FOR BY THE HOUSING FIRST FUND, NOT COORDINATED WITH ANY CANDIDATE OR CANDIDATE COMMITTEE
ne igh
b
s supp
or
r
or
fri e n ds
&
Anne Neu
for State Representative
t • Yo u
PA G E 9 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
Vote F e b . 1 4 PAID FOR BY THE HOUSING FIRST FUND, NOT COORDINATED WITH ANY CANDIDATE OR CANDIDATE COMMITTEE
3
LEGAL ADVOCACY
PA G E 1 0 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
When an unfavorable or abusive law or rule must be challenged in court via a lawsuit, BATC steps up via its BATC Legal Defense Fund (BLD Fund). Association legal advocacy is the last line of defense for the industry.
Q1 • 2017
LEGAL ADVOCACY
Minnesota Supreme Court Hears City of Rochester v. Kottschade The Minnesota Supreme Court heard arguments in City of Rochester v. Kottschade on Wednesday, March 1. At issue in this case is whether Rochester can appeal an order for arbitration from a previous case before any arbitration takes place. In 2010, the City of Rochester and Frank Kottschade, a BATC member and a Rochesterarea builder and developer, were ordered into arbitration by a district court in a separate court case. Kottschade’s legal battle with Rochester is one of several cases BATC is engaged in that could have significant impact to the industry in Minnesota. A decision is expected in the coming weeks. David Siegel, executive director, Nick Erickson, regulatory affairs manager, and Mark Foster, political engagement manager, attended the hearing in support of Kottschade.
Kottschade’s legal battle with Rochester is one of several cases BATC is engaged in that could have significant impact to the industry in Minnesota.
(L to R) David Siegel, BATC, Plaintiff Frank Kottschade, and Gary Van Cleve, Larkin Hoffman.
BATC Joins Appellate Court Battle Over Transportation Impact Fee in Harstad v. Woodbury BATC, in partnership with developer member Frank Kottschade and the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), has joined as an Amici Curiae party (friends of the court) in the Harstad v. Woodbury legal action at the Minnesota Court of Appeals. Amicus briefs are approved by the court and serve the purpose of bringing attention to relevant matter not already brought to the case. At issue is Woodbury’s appeal of the District Court’s finding that their Major
Roadway Assessment (MRA) fee is unlawful. Our brief argues that the District Court’s decision was the correct one, and that the Court of Appeals must affirm that decision.
tax that mirrors the road unit charge imposed by Eagan and struck down by the Minnesota Supreme Court in the landmark Country Joe, Inc. v. City of Eagan, which was decided 20 years ago.
Our core argument is that Woodbury’s Major Roadway Assessment (MRA) fee is unlawful because there is no statutory authority granted by the Legislature for any city to impose such a fee on development applications. Additionally, we argue the unauthorized impact fee is an unlawful
BATC has been the leader of the arguments against local governments using development agreements to raise general revenues for their respective cities. The Harstad case is extremely important as it affirms that cities possess only the authority granted by the legislature, and that any
PA G E 1 1 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
fees required of housing developments must be connected to the underlying development and must be fair, reasonable, and
proportionate. This case will be argued in the spring, with a ruling expected this summer.
Woodbury’s Major Roadway Assessment (MRA) fee is unlawful because there is no statutory authority granted by the Legislature for any city to impose such a fee on development applications.
4
REGULATORY ADVOCACY
PA G E 1 2 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
BATC strives to illustrate the cumulative effect of multiple regulatory impacts on home building and remodeling. This involves working with government agencies to ensure that regulations applied to our industry are common sense, necessary, and based in sound science.
Q1 • 2017
REGULATORY ADVOCACY EXAMPLES
BATC Surges Into Regulatory Space BATC’s Advocacy Team has been working hard to share industry comments and concerns with regulatory and rulemaking agencies. In January, BATC hired Nick Erickson to lead the organization’s regulatory affairs efforts. Erickson, who has more than 10 years of public affairs experience, serves as BATC’s contact with the Department of Labor & Industry, Metropolitan Council, Department of Health, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Board of Soil and Water Resources and the Department of Natural Resources. BATC has been busy reaching out to the industry’s regulators this quarter. BATC members and staff have met with the Metropolitan Council on land planning and land supply issues, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency on the 2018 Construction Stormwater Permit, the Department of Health on the Renovation, Repair and Painting
(lead paint) rule and has had several meetings and conversations with the Department of Labor & Industry on a variety of topics. BATC has attended additional meetings with the Department of Labor & Industry’s Construction Codes Advisory Council, Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s Water Reuse Workgroup and the Board of Soil & Water Resources. Earlier this month, BATC held the first meeting of its Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee. This meeting was the organization’s first-ever gathering of a formal group of industry regulation experts. The Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee is comprised of BATC members with deep government, legal and housing industry experience. During its quarterly meetings, the subcommittee will examine the effect regulatory rulemaking has on home safety and affordability in Minnesota. Bill Gschwind, an attorney with Minnesota
Construction Law Services, is the Chair of the Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee and Nick Erickson is serving as the BATC staff lead. Members of the subcommittee experienced in Minnesota’s Construction Stormwater Permit have already begun working with BATC staff on preparing recommended improvements for the MPCA to consider before the agency completes its draft of the 2018 Construction Stormwater Permit. BATC will be submitting these recommended changes in early April. Subcommittee members familiar with lead paint rules and staff are currently reviewing the Minnesota Department of Health’s draft rule allowing the department to take over local enforcement from the EPA. BATC will continue to engage regulators on both issues as the agencies work through the rulemaking process.
of BATC’s Regulatory Efforts Include:
Working with agency staff to
improve permitting processes
Assessing the
impact of water regulations
Helping to craft
reasonable regulations on water reuse & deep engagement in the state’s
building and energy codes
The Regulatory Affairs Subcommittee will examine regulatory rulemaking and other policy initiatives from regulatory agencies affecting members and the Minnesota industry as a whole.
Regulatory Affairs Committee Roster Bill Gschwind (Chair) Minnesota Construction Law Services
Ross Anderson The Energy Network
Steve Behnke
Brian Cook
Matt Plec
Mike Swanson
Kent Brander
Paul Heuer
Kris Ronning
David Weetman
Bob Cumbow
Andy Michels
Jake Steen
Traditions by Donnay Civil Methods
Country Joe Homes
PA G E 1 3 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
DR Horton
Pulte Homes
Michels Homes
Great Southern Bank Lennar
Larkin Hoffman
JMS Custom Homes
Westwood Professional Services
5
ISSUE ADVOCACY The advent of social media, technology, and the internet have substantially elevated the opportunities for issue advocacy. Issue advocacy refers to social media, digital and traditional advertising focused on broad political issues. The goal is to engage and persuade the public positively in support of our advocacy agenda. BATC achieves its issue advocacy through its growing Housing First Network (a 501c(4) organization).
PA G E 1 4 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
ISSUE ADVOCACY
Spreading the Industry Message Year-round, the Housing First Network is promoting the message of housing affordability, smart regulations and protection of the American Dream of homeownership for all. The network is actively engaging and persuading the public to think positively about our advocacy agenda, including the Minnesota Homeownership Initiative. The Network has been and will continue to actively engage influencers throughout the state and the public at large via a series of issue ads. Examples of our messaging include: Every new home built adds four new jobs to our local economy; 84% of Twin Cities residents believe that owning a home is central to the American Dream; For every $1,000 increase in the price of a home, 4,000 Minnesota families are priced out of the market.
VISIT
HousingFirstNetwork.com
New homes build strong communities.
Rising regulatory costs in Minnesota make home ownership harder for middle-class families.
New homes build strong communities.
LEARN MORE
PAID FOR BY THE HOUSING FIRST NETWORK
PA G E 1 5 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Q1 • 2017
LEARN MORE PAID FOR BY THE HOUSING FIRST NETWORK
Q2?
WHAT’S NEXT FOR Coming Up Homeownership Initiative
Harstad v. Woodbury
The numerous pieces of the Homeownership Initiative will continue through the legislative process as stand-alone bills or as pieces of multi-prong omnibus bills.
The Harstad v.Woodbury case will be heard at the Minnesota Court of Appeals. A ruling can be expected sometime this summer.
RRP, CSW Public Comment
Elections The 2017 local elections are just months away and the 2018 elections will be here before we know it. Housing First will be evaluating potential involvement in municipal races and will begin discussions with announced 2018 gubernatorial candidates.
Regulatory rulemaking processes are underway. BATC will be engaged with key agencies, drawing upon industry expertise from the regulatory sub-committee.
We’d like to thank our
2017 Board of Directors Bob Michels
Charlie Bradburn
Tom Wiener
Dennis Galligan
President Michels Homes
Associate Vice President ABC Millwork
Builder Vice President Cardinal Homebuilders, Inc.
John Rask Treasurer M/I Homes
Meg Jaeger
Immediate Past President New Spaces
Secretary In-Focus Systems
Jason McCarty
Past Associate Vice President Westwood Professional Services
Scott Busyn
Tim Fohr
James Julkowski
Gary Aulik
Art Pratt
Bill Burgess
Shawn Nelson
Artisan Home Tour Representative Great Neighborhood Homes, Inc.
Parade of Homes Representative Lennar
James Slaikeu
Past Presidents’ Representative Aulik & Associates, Inc.
Large Volume Representative D.R. Horton, Inc.
Jill Murphy
Membership Representative True North Consulting, LLC
Public Policy Representative Lennar
BATC Remodelers Representative Julkowski, Inc. Small Volume Representative Pratt Homes
At- Large Member New Spaces
Carla Warner
At-Large Member Warners’ Stellian Co., Inc.
BATC Advocacy Team
David Siegel Executive Director
James Vagle Director of Advocacy
PA G E 1 6 | B AT C A D V O C A C Y U P D AT E
Mark Foster Political Engagement Manager
Q1 • 2017
Katie Elfstrom
Press Secretary
Nick Erickson
Regulatory Affairs Manager
Mary Schweich
Assistant to Public Policy
Peter Coyle Attorney & Lobbyist Larkin Hoffman